The Learn/Perform Mixtape is a podcast of my study notes as I prepare for the Certified Professional in Learning and Performance (CPLP). More at: https://techknowtools.com/learnperform-mixtape/
2.13. Legal and Ethical Issues: Copyright and Fair Use in Learning Design
Learning Objective for Section 2.13.: Explain the importance of legal and ethical issues related to instructional design
Using any copyrighted work for learning and training purposes required permission from the copyright owner, i.e. the publisher of the work or the employer of the work’s author, or the author/creator of the work. As stated and shared in the AOE #3 episode on the topic 3.10. Copyright and Fair Use Laws.
Here is the recap of what US laws state about the use of materials for a class, training, or learning:
Copyright Law: protects the expression of ideas but not the ideas themselves in some tangible form e.g. book, magazine, video, film, etc. Although the exact words in a book may be copyrighted the ideas in the book are not.
READ: Copyright, eLearning, and Creativity via eLearning Industry
Fair Use: is a legal doctrine that promotes freedom of expression by permitting the unlicensed use of copyright-protected works in certain circumstances. Section 107 of the US Copyright Act provides the statutory framework for determining whether something is a fair use and identifies certain types of uses—such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research—as examples of activities that may qualify as fair use.” When considering if objects or materials are under fair use, you should examine the four requirements:
Title 17, US Code of Federal Regulations, Section 201 There are also “Works Made for Hire” where the employer or the other person for who was hired for the work was authoring training instruments for an employer or organization as training materials to be designated their copyright.
RESOURCE: US Code: Title 17. Copyright via Cornell Law School
RESOURCE: Writing Copyright Statements for eLearning
Legal and Ethical Issues Related to Copyright and Fair Use
Things that cannot be protected by copyright include: ideas, processes, procedures, methods of operation, concepts, principles, or discoveries; however, a tangible description, explanation or illustration of these may be copyrighted.
In the United States, registering the work with the US Copyright Office provides legal protection and redress in state and federal courts; a copyright holder has the exclusive right to:
Exclusive rights are qualified by the fair use privilege, which allows others to use copyrighted material in a reasonable manner without the copyright owner’s consent. Although legal guidelines exist, fair use is difficult legal concept to understand.
Bottom line: obtain written consent from the copyright holder to use the materials that are copyrighted, even for an educational program OR find training materials that allow for fair use or attribution for your learning/training materials. When in doubt ASK SOMEONE!
Open Up: Creative Comments and Open Education Resources
2.12. Individual & Organizational Influences on Learning and Change
Learning Objective for Section 2.12.: Identify individual and social factors that influence an adult’s motivation to learn and change.
Change might be a business decision; however transitions at work often have emotional and political effects on any organization and their employees. Motivating factors is one of the most critical elements to consider while implementing change related to learning. If designing learning is part of a change initiative, organizational transition, or method for managing change in a company, talent development practitioners should be aware of how any change could create challenges to learning solutions, i.e. resistance, turnover, and failure to institutionalize the change.
READ: 3 Instructional Design Strategies for SMART Change
It is critical to involve the change agents during during the learning planning stage to minimize potential issues and consider issues that might occur at all levels. Empowering employees to make choices can help them accept change and ensure this transition is smooth. Some incentives might come from management rewards for acceptance or additional support to help move others along in the transition.
Influences on Learning: How Instructional Design Can Impact Change
Motivation is one of the main influences on people’s willingness to learn. When change comes, sometimes a learning initiative to understand this transition is needed. Two ways to influence this willingness to learn is to:
Training success happens when the new skills and knowledge are applied on the job.To encourage a change in behavior or performance, learners need to realize the learning outcomes.This could be through other learner testimonials, sharing the implications of not gaining this skill, what's in it for me (WIIFM), and identify the knowledge gap might do for their career trajectory. You might also be able to introduce employees to informal learning and technologies (e.g. wikis, blogs, communities of practice, etc.). Other ways to motivate learners by:
More information about support organization and individual influences on learning, more will be discussed in AOE #10 Change Management, Section 10.11. Motivation Theory.
Are you a learning designer or talent development professional who has developed training/learning solutions for change? How'd it go?
2.11. Learning Technologies
Learning Objective for Section 2.11.: List at least three strategies for keeping up-to-date regarding learning technologies
Similar to the previous episode 2.10. about Selecting Delivery Options and Media, it will be critical to make the most appropriate and effective choices for technologies for learning. There are a number of options for methods, media, and ways to deliver training/learning solutions; however, not all technologies will be suitable for your employees/professionals. Not all training settings or organizational set ups will require high-tech solutions for learning, and it will be context and learning participant dependent as well.
Knowledge of Learning Technologies and Support Systems
It is critical to get to know a few things, with regards to technology, which include:
Here are a few suggestions of where and how to stay connected to learning technologies within talent development from the CPLP training system:
And beyond these organizations, there are a number of professional associations, organizations, and networked communities to access, share, and find learning technologies for training and instructional design in K-12, higher ed, etc. -- here are my “go to” to get you started:
Ahead, we’ll talk more about learning technologies in AOE #6 Managing Learning Programs, Section 6.2. Learning Technologies and Support Systems -- stay tuned!
How do you stay connected to learning technologies for training and instructional design? Let me know! Share your suggestions on what to read, watch, follow, or connect to online to continue my knowledge on the topic.
2.10. Delivery Options and Media
Learning Objective for Section 2.10.: List at least three delivery options or media available for delivering learning solutions
Delivery Option Considerations
To design effective learning talent development professionals must understand what is possible, the variety of mediums, and the current technologies or media that can support training/learning solutions. To determine the most effective delivery option and types of media, it will be critical to understand the advantages and disadvantages of each medium has for learning.
Selection of learning delivery method and media also will be aligned to the given scope constraints, time to design and deliver learning, cost, geographic location of learners, baseline knowledge of learners, technical skills to be taught, and so on. Here are a few things to consider for learning delivery options:
THROWBACK: #TBT You may recall that selecting training/learning delivery options and media can also be found in AOE #3 Training Delivery; Section 3.5. Various Delivery Options(link to this podcast episode and resources)
What Exactly is Flipped Learning?
Flipping the learning experiences is also known as “inverting” learning or taking a “pedagogy-first” approach to instruction. This is where the learning materials (for a course, training session, or workshop) are introduced outside of the designated class meeting session. The time spent either in-person or during an asynchronous online meeting is re-purposed for inquiry, application, and assessment in order to better meet the needs of individual learners.
The Four Pillars of F-L-I-P from the Flipped Learning Network
F: Flexible Environment
L: Learning Culture
I: Intentional Content
P: Professional Educator
Read more at: https://flippedlearning.org/definition-of-flipped-learning/
BONUS RESOURCES:
How do you make your decisions about media, mediums, and delivery options for instructional design?
2.3. Individual Learning Preferences
Learning Objectives for Section 2.3.:
Learning Modalities
Learning modalities refers to how information is received from the environment into our brains through our five senses: hearing, seeing, smelling, tasting, and touching.
The Learning Style Concept is a Neuromyth: learnings styles that try to measure differences in individuals' learning have been debunked and are a myth. You might know a few of these assessments or instruments to classify learning styles: Kolb’s Learning Styles Inventory or VAK (visual, auditory, kinesthetic). Researchers have indicated that there is no evidence for the validity of learning styles or that it leads to optimal learning if identified. Additionally, investing in these learning style assessments/inventories could lead learners to develop self-limiting beliefs about themselves that could be a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Models that Incorporate Learning Preference: some evidence-based theories and models that focus on individual learning preferences include (which a few were mentioned on the previous episode in the AOE #2 Instructional Design; Section 2.2. Learning Theories):
The Design Value of Learning Modalities
Although we don’t use learning style preferences, there is something for offering training and learning solutions for a variety of learning modalities and techniques to resonate with all learners. Here are a few helpful reminders of why multiple modes for learning are critical from Design for How People Learn (Dirkesen, 2012):
Senses & Design Considerations
Seeing
Hearing
Touching
We need to design learning beyond our own expectations or personal preferences for learning design solutions -- it needs to be relevant for on-the-job outcomes and performance.
REVIEW: Designing Multimodal Approaches for Learning
How are you designing with multiple modes and learners in mind?
AOE 2. Instructional Design; 2.2. Learning Theories
Learning Objectives for Section 2.2.:
The Role of Adult Learning Theories in Instructional Design
Learning theories explain why some training techniques may work better than others; and this helps talent development professionals design effective learning solutions. Trainers help improve performance by facilitating learning in a traditional or virtual classroom, one-on-one, or on-the-job in an organization. Knowledge of adult learning theories help talent development professionals to:
Theories of Learning and Memory:
This is the HOW learners internalize information and identifies ways to increase the successful transfer of learning for retention. Essentially it will be to understand how humans access, treat, and retrieve information with these three classic learning theories:
READ MORE: Epistemology and theories of learning; Objectivism and behaviorism; Cognitivism and Constructivism from Chapter 2: The nature of knowledge and implications for teaching by Tony Bates
Maslow’s HIerarchy of Needs: explains the foundations of motivation and offer a logical leveling from physiological to psychological needs:
READ: Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs Explained
Malcom Knowles’s Adult Learning, or Andragogy: the way adults learn are different from children; often more self-directed, internally motivated, and ready to learn; unlike pedagogy (traditional style of teaching based on lecturing or a didactic model), this is learner-centered rather than content-centred or instructor-led.
READ: Andragogy - Adult Learning Theory (Knowles)
Andragogy (Knowles, 1984): contends that five key principles affect the ways adults learn:
Individual Characteristics of Learning: adults learn only when they need or want to learn, no matter how good the talent development professional or training experience is -- here are the four key characteristics of learning:
Approaches to Motivating Learners: 4 foundational principles to motivate adult learners are:
How Culture May Influence Learning: this might impact the training experience and ability for participants to learn, specifically related to these differences:
Questions the learning designer should ask before developing training:
Adult Development and Age: Does our learning change or capacity to learn change as we age? Not necessarily. Neuroplasticity, the ability of our brains to change and adapt, does not decline with age. We are able to continually learn, adapt, and grow -- this includes building new neural connections to receive, process, and transmit information. Confronting ideas that are contrary to one’s own helps to stimulate the development of new neural pathways -- keep adult learning programs going!
The Whole Brain Thinking Model: we use the whole brain (both sides/hemispheres) to process information. These are complementary, not competitive to make a decision, analyze a problem, compare solutions, and support long-term learning. The left side of the brain is associated with time orientation; sequential processing of events; language; logic; mathematics; analysis; and awareness of cause and effect. The right side of the brain specializing in the following functions: emotion; intuition; visual-spatial orientation; music; art, imagery, and pattern awareness; synthesis of information; simultaneous processing of events; timelessness; and divergent thinking.
This model of whole brain thinking was analyzed by the Herrmann Brain Dominance Instrument (HBDI) developed by Herrmann (1988) to study how individuals' thinking preferences, or brain dominance, affect the way we work, learn, and communicate. The HBDI classifies learners in terms of thinking in four modes or quadrants of the brain:
A. Rational/Intellectual: logical, quantitative, analytical, technical factual
B. Lower-Left Limbic = Practical/Instinctive: sequential, controlled, detailed, organized, conservative
C. Upper-Right Cerebral = Experimental/Intellectual: metaphoric, integrative, visual, synthesizing, conceptual
D. Lower-Right Limbic = Relational/Instinctive: emotional, musical, humanistic, expressive, sensory
LEARN MORE: Understanding the Herrmann Whole Brain® model
External and Environmental Influences: these factors can impact or influence how professionals/employees learn, like in more informal training environments or a relaxed atmosphere. Different aspects can impact motivation to learn and the transfer of training specifically these external or environmental factors: stress, time pressures, job status, learning environment, peers, supervisor, family, and/or company conditions.
Multiple Intelligences: Howard Gardner (1983) has suggested that there are multiple ways to measure and account for intelligence; he developed the Multiple Intelligence Theory which states that there's no single way in which everyone thinks and learns. Gardner created a list of intelligences that includes:
All of these intelligences will impact how people process information when learning. Gardner believes that most people are comfortable in three to four of these intelligences and avoid the others. He also defines intelligence as a measurable aptitude that people use to create and solve problems and valued by the culture; however, intelligence is not fixed.
BONUS READ: Multiple Intelligences Theory: Widely Used, Yet Misunderstood via Edutopia
Difference Between Teaching and Facilitating Learning: teaching is the “teller” of information whereas facilitating is the “guide” of bringing learning to participants to they understand concepts, skills, and information. Teaching is pedagogical vs. facilitating is more andragogical. Teaching methods might be more lectures, presentations, webinars, etc. vs. facilitating might involve brainstorming, small-group discussion, role play, case studies, debates, teach backs and other interactive ways to learn.
A couple of books I mentioned for learning theories
The Area of Expertise (AOE) #2: Instructional Designrefers to the “designing, creating, and developing informal and formal learning solutions to meet organizational needs; analyzing and selecting the most appropriate strategy, methodologies, and technologies to maximize the learning experience and impact.” This section is weighted 13-14% of the exam; 20-21 questions
A skilled workforce is one that has a competitive advantage that enables the organization to adapt, change, grow, and innovate. Talent development professionals who are savvy instructional designers (IDs) contribute directly to the business strategy and organizational goals. In AOE #2, we will focus on the following key knowledge areas:
Crossover in this chapter will be with AOE #3 Training Delivery and AOE #6: Managing Learning Programs, specifically the section on Legal, Regulatory, and Ethical Requirements. Roles in this area might be called: instructional designer, course designers, program designer, designer, instructional developer, eLearning specialist, or curriculum development specialist. There are so many more names--see my presentation “Who Designs Learning Today?” https://www.slideshare.net/LauraPasquini/who-is-designing-learning-today
A few books I might refer to or mention in this area of expertise:
2.1. Business Strategy and Drivers
Learning Objective: Describe the value and purpose of understanding the business drivers that identify a need prior to designing the learning.
Like other areas of your organization, talent development requires investment for your employees to encourage more production, sales, output, customer satisfaction, and more! If your professionals are being developed and engaged, it will increase the bottom line. Aligning goals and objectives of the company to instructional design, will allow you to justify the need for talent development professionals within your organization.
READ: Instructional Design Strategy: What Is Its Role in eLearning Design
Link Talent Development and Instructional Design to Business Drivers
Business drivers are internal and external forces that direct and influence the organization’s strategy, goals, business needs , and performance goals. Business drivers are often resources, processes, or conditions that are essential for growth and success of a company. The learning design and goals should be linked to these business drivers and strategies that might include:
Design to Meet Business Requirements
Similar to the AOE #1 Performance Improvement (specifically Section 1.3. Business, Performance, and Gap Analysis and Section 1.4. Root Cause Analysis), you want the instructional designer (ID) to focus on designing learning that develops objectives, materials, instructional methods, timing, and participation that is related to focused business needs and requirements. This would include assessing the session length, cost of development, media needs, learning activities, the environment to learn, how to have participants practice skills, and more. To meet these business requirements, you will need to ensure that participants are prepared to learn and the ID meet the goal expectations by:
Design to Achieve Strategy
IDs and talent development professionals needs to understand the business to align learning with organizational goals. Practitioners developing learning and training can upgrade skills and knowledge for strategy by:
Note: More will be discussed in AOE #6 Managing Learning Programs; Section 6.1: Business Model Drivers, and Competitive Positionin an upcoming episode
AOE 7. Integrated Talent Management; 7.4. Individual and Organizational Assessment Tools
Learning Objectives:
Human Resource Audits: is one component of succession planning system, which build s on the identification of successors and addresses employee mobility with regards to various positions; this audit would identify is employees should stay at their current position or move to other positions and it offers strategies to help designate pools of qualified employees based on their skills and abilities. Managers often conduct an HR audit by reviewing their direct reports to determine:
Plans for succession and movement within an organization allow pathways into leadership and identify other opportunities where professionals might also move into new functional roles or to grow in a particular new occupational area.You want to work with and involve employees in the process of succession planning based on their performance appraisals or other means of providing viable, dependable, employee skill information. This might also happen with reporting in progress on projects; 1:1 meetings; quarterly reviews;snapshot of work with clients or billable hours.
READ: A Beginner’s Guide to Succession Planning
Human Resource Assessment and AuditsMulti-Rater Feedback: Multiple reviewers offer feedback as a process with at least two levels of management to review employees and agree on their candidacy for specific positions. This type of evaluation might occur or be warranted under these conditions:
360-Degree Feedback Evaluation: is based on opinions and recommendations from superiors, direct reports, peers, and internal and external customers on how a person performs in any number of behavioral areas; offers a more well-rounded view of performance/work
Assessment Centers: might include oral exercises, counseling simulations, problem-analysis exercises, interview simulations, role-play exercises, written report, or analysis exercises for individuals or groups of employees; may be used for selection or development purposes
Personality Inventory Instruments: offers a picture of a person’s personality type and indicates personality preferences. Examples (of many):
DiSC Personality Profile: is a behavior assessment tool based on the work on William Marston that provides four dimensional model and four profiles: dominance (direct and decisive), influence (optimistic and outgoing), steadiness (sympathetic and cooperative), and conscientiousness (concerned and correct). Learn more at: https://www.discprofile.com/what-is-disc/overview/ Free DiSC Assessment: https://www.onlinepersonalitytests.org/disc/
Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI): is an instrument that helps determine personality type based on preferences for extraversion or introversion, intuiting or sensing, thinking or feeling, and judging or perceiving; used in career development and team building. Learn more at: https://www.myersbriggs.org/my-mbti-personality-type/mbti-basics/ Free MBTI or Jungian Personality Test:https://psychcentral.com/quizzes/personality/start.php
Strong Interest Inventory: E.K. Strong self assessment tool to look at people's interests (likes and dislikes) at work; Also in the ONET Online: https://www.onetonline.org/ Learn more at: https://www.thebalancecareers.com/the-strong-interest-inventory-526173
Holland Code (RIASEC) Test - Interest Inventory: https://openpsychometrics.org/tests/RIASEC/
My Next Move https://www.mynextmove.org/ “Tell us what you like to do” section to self-assess
Career Profiles: include a resume, summary statement, personal work history, skills, and competencies; a tool to map current professional progress in a position and plan for career changes.
Leadership Assessments: help organizations assess developmental needs of current and future leaders at all levels; This might help with career planning, professional development, and understanding baseline needs with role-playing, simulations, etc. to identify needs for improving leadership skills like decision-making, delegating, coaching, etc.
Administrative Considerations
It is important to consider the following issues when you are administering any of these inventories, assessments or using these instruments as a talent development professional:
AOE 7. Integrated Talent Management; 7.8. Ethical Standards and Legal Issues
How are your employment practices (e.g. hiring, promotion, demotion, etc.) fair, legal, and just? FYI: This episode is US-centric and refers to talent management practices in the United States.
Learning Objective: Identify and explain the implications of hiring or promotion decisions when using psychological and personality tests
Understanding the legal ramifications of all aspects of the talent management cycle ensures compliance with applicable local, regional, national, etc. regulations and laws. In the US, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) is the governing body that dispenses regulations to govern the hiring, promotion, and discharge of employees, as well as training guidance. The EEOC guidelines apply to tests and other selection process for hiring, promoting, or demoting employees, and also decisions for training, transfer, or any other impacts for employees.
READ: Equal Employment Opportunity https://www.dol.gov/general/topic/discrimination via US Department of Labor
READ: What is the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC)?
Hiring Practices and Testing
If you have ever applied for a job, it often requires a number of application sections and online processes to submit your application and complete the job application process. In the United States, there are a number of layers as you enter into the job or candidate portal to complete a single job application. Beyond uploading your resume, CV, cover letter, etc. detailing your work experience, you might also be required to enter your work eligibility, age (above 18), accessibility needs or accommodations, non-compete disclosures, previous employment at the organization, and other related qualifications or certifications for a particular role. In the United states, the EEOC will also ask candidates questions about their gender, sexual orientation, military service, disability, and ethnic/racial backgrounds.
Use of any testing in hiring , promotion or retention is an established practice. Tests must confirm that employer’s test criteria are directly related to job performance and not a protected group. These are guided by the EEOC regulations to ensure there is not discrimination in hiring. Other practical examples of this equal opportunity considerations look at the lawful selection of individuals to complete talent development programs, such as :
It is up to the organization, the employer, to bear the burden of proof to demonstrate specific requirements are based on job performance. US federal court will evaluate any job requirements for job relatedness through the human resource management and development cycle. More in AOE 6. Managing Learning Programs, Section 6.8.
Are you studying for the CPLP now? Let me know and let's connect:
Podcast web space: https://techknowtools.com/learnperform-mixtape/
Twitter: @laurapasquini
LInkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/laurapasquini/
AOE 7. Integrated Talent Management; 7.7. Maximizing Workplace Diversity
Diversity is more that "good for the bottom line" -- it improves our organizations functions, creativity, productivity, and awareness to new ideas and innovative approaches for how we work and learn.
Learning Objectives:
READ: Workplace Diversity Through Recruitment: A Step-By-Step Guide via Ideal
Cultural Awareness: Training material sand software for global use need to be designed from the start with multilingual and multicultural participants in mind. Culture arises from shared behaviors, values, and beliefs shaped by such factors as language, religion, cuisine, music, etc. Culture influences the value society puts on individualism versus group action, tolerance for uncertainty, a willingness to take risks, and ways of interacting with a trainer and peers for professional learning, which impacts other factors such as communication and interaction for talent development.
BOOK: Developing Localization Friendly ELearning by Kieran McBrien (2015)
Power Distance Differences: high-power cultures emphasize more traditional teach-student relations -- here are the differences:
High Power Distance | Low Power Distance
Formal relationships | Informal relationships
High dependence | Low dependence
Teacher oriented | Learner oriented
Impersonal | Highly personal
Status emphasis | Equality emphasis
Fixed approach | Variable approach
Conformity | Experimentation
Some features of culture, such as language and dress, are immediately apparent. Other features, such as attitudes about age, personal space, work, time, and reactions to authority, may be subtle.
Gender Equality: In the US, after the Civil Rights Active of 1964, American corporations still did not not deal with gender discrimination in the workplace -- many claims were made each year revealing that women in particular still experience discrimination in pay and advancement. This is SLOWLY being worked on to deal with gender discrimination and pay inequity issues -- but we’re still not there. The importance of gender varies by country, nationality, culture, and more.
BONUS LISTENS: The #InVinoFab Podcast https://invinofab.transistor.fm/ these specific episodes:
Race Awareness: Implementing diversity and awareness can only help the bottom line. The CPLP guide on this is out of date -- those organizations who do not embrace or consider any diversity, equity, and inclusion efforts for any aspect of talent management will not contribute to enhance individual or organizational missions, visions, or goals. Identifying racial or ethical differences are key to understanding how individuals interact, communicate, and engage in work. That’s my “off script” insights to what I read -- bringing awareness to racial issues and viewpoints allows the organization to benefit by:
Generational Differences: There are 4-5 generations at work together, depending on where you are working in the world (see 7.3. Career Development Theories & Approaches); that being said talent development professionals want to strive to raise workplace awareness of the diversity and differences for how these different generations approach and perceive work. This can prevent conflict and encourage cooperation in an organization.
Personal Space: This is a cultural item -- space between individuals varies depending on the cultural context. This matters for training, mentoring, coaching, and other interactions for talent management/development. Mentioned before in an earlier podcast episode, Proxemics, is the relationship of people’s positions in space. Hall (1969) defined four spatial relationships:
Disability Awareness: In the United States, the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) of 1990 has a number of implications for training and learning design for people who need access. The ADA prohibits discrimination in employment, public services, transportation, public accommodations, and telecommunication services. This includes aspects of employment such as job applications, selection processes, on-the-job-training, wage increases, benefits, and employer-sponsored social activities. Employers must provide reasonable accommodations for professionals to access and perform the essential functions for the designated job.
Implications for Multiple Languages: For difference learning experiences, it might be helpful to offer training and learning materials in multiple languages depending on the workplace setting, geographic location, or needs within the professional group. These will help to add to learning and talent development:
Facilitation of Inclusion: it is important to include new cultural ideas or identities for various groups who are part of your talent management plan. In looking at your training analysis and planning processes for employee development programs, HR functions and top management may develop a strategy to interview and hire for differences to broaden diversity in the organization. Additionally, it is important to facilitate inclusion of employees by building awareness and celebrating difference cultures and groups. Differences across cultures and groups offer the opportunity to look at new approaches, create awareness, model new ways, target solutions, and offer training opportunities for other employees.
READ: Workplace Diversity and Inclusion Gets Innovative via SHRM
Are you studying for the CPLP now? Let me know and let's connect:
Podcast web space: https://techknowtools.com/learnperform-mixtape/
Twitter: @laurapasquini
LInkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/laurapasquini/
AOE 7. Integrated Talent Management; 7.6. Talent Management Software Solutions
Where and how do you organize and manage all of the data around talent development? Technology solutions, of course!
Learning Objectives:
The opportunities and affordances for talent management systems (TMS) encourage data collection for career development, coaching, feedback, and professional learning related to employee competencies, training effectiveness, onboarding practices, employees’ interests, performance management, and succession planning.
EXAMPLE: Talent Management Platforms for 2019 via Solutions Review
LEARN MORE: Find Out More about Talent Management Software
This data and information can identify learning and/or performance gaps to outline what is needed in the workforce or organization. TMS can also help identify if/when training is needed, and keep track for training/learning records for employees related to industry reports, books, research, and evidence from the talent development field.
If you are preparing to invest in or upgrade a TMS or software, consider the following four steps when you evaluate a product/system:
READ: Why Talent Management Is an Important Business Strategy to Develop via The Balance Careers
What are your "must have" requirements for a talent management system? What features are requirements for your TMS technology solution?
Are you studying for the CPLP now? Let me know and let's connect:
Podcast web space: https://techknowtools.com/learnperform-mixtape/
Twitter: @laurapasquini
LInkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/laurapasquini/
AOE 7. Integrated Talent Management; 7.5. Talent Management Analytics
If you are not collecting and analyzing your talent development data -- your missing out on key performance indicators and understanding how they meet individual and organizational goals.
Learning Objectives:
Talent Management Analytics describes the use of talent data and information to improve business performance, predict turnover, measure the impact of leadership development programs, and determine the effectiveness of onboarding programs or just-in-time training solutions. The data available will be based on the tools being used and could include basic statistics, such as the number of learners attending training, or correlations between course content and performance. If collected and measured well, talent analytics can inform and offer direction to employees to support their career development paths and offer insights for the business goals. The impact of learning and other talent development offerings may impact to the organization’s bottom line -- but how can you know if you are not measuring this.
“Only 21% of HR leaders believe their organizations are effective at using talent data to inform business decisions.” ~Gartner (2019)
READ: Talent Analytics: How HR can leverage analytics to inform talent and business decisions via Gartner
Learner data can be captured in a variety of ways to measure and assess talent development. Whether its an end of workshop survey, online course questionnaire, focus group, or 1:1 follow up with a manager, here are a few common methods for analyzing learner data:
BONUS LISTEN/READ: Competing on Talent Analytics via Harvard Business Review
REPORT: 2019 Top 125 training and development organizations via T&D Magazine
Book referenced in this episode: Employee Training & Development, 7th Ed. by Raymond Noe (2017)
Are you studying for the CPLP now? Let me know and let's connect:
Podcast web space: https://techknowtools.com/learnperform-mixtape/
Twitter: @laurapasquini
LInkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/laurapasquini/
AOE 7. Integrated Talent Management; 7.3. Career Development Theories and Approaches
Learning Objectives:
Balance Between Personal Assessment and the Market: To determine the ideal future at work, in terms of our own career plan, is a process of considering different concepts and theories -- this is known as career development. Zandy B. Leibowitz (1986) sees career as a “vision must be realistic and provide a strong link between the present situation and future possibilities… real needs, structures, and cultures.” The goal is to offer a sense of direction and rationale for these career approaches and theories to measure actual results in your career journey.
Trait-Factor Counseling: is a cognitive career counseling approach based on the theory of individual differences. Known as the talent-matching approach, it assumes that each person has a unique pattern of relatively stable traits, interests, abilities, and characteristics that can be identified as an occupational profile. This approach originated in the early 1900’s and is associated strongly with vocational theorists Frank Parsons and E.G. WIlliamson.
BONUS LISTEN: Satya Nadella: Don’t Be Brilliant, Be Curious episode from the Hello Monday podcast
Super’s Developmental Framework: D.E. Super’s career development theory includes the idea that our careers move through five distinct phases from childhood through adulthood; the choice of an occupation is highly influenced by each person’s self-image and how this self-image maps to people already in a particular occupation. 5 stages/phases:
READ/LEARN MORE: Super's Theory via the Government of NZ Careers Site
Personality or Typology Theory: some career theories match individuals to occupations based on their personality, strengths, interests, values, characteristics, and more. For example:
Roe’s Theory of Occupation: divides occupations into eight groups of service and six decision levels; can be used to assess individuals to determine best career choice based on interests.
READ MORE: Anne Roe’s Theory on Occupational Choice
This is similar to Holland’s Occupational Congruency Model that seeks to match individual sto the best career choice through interviews that deal with six types of work environments known as RIASEC:
READ MORE: Holland’s Theory of Career Choice and You
Assess: Holland Code (RIASEC) Test: https://openpsychometrics.org/tests/RIASEC/
Behavioral Theory: suggests that career-related behavior can be broken down into parts to better understand our own behavior at work. Here are a couple of theorists and their examples/models:
Behavior Career Counseling: is a scientifically precise approach to career decision making that leverages concepts from psychology; this approach notes that career-related behavior (e.g. a job interview) results from events from our past; the goal is to understand that behavior to move forward in your career decisions)
Krumboltz’s Model: is about planned happenstance, which makes it okay to not always plan because unplanned events could lead to good careers. He uses the DECIDES model as a decision-making process with seven steps:
READ: Krumboltz’s Theory
Career Anchors Theory (Edgar Schein, 1961): A career anchor is one’s self-concept about one’s talents and abilities, basic values, motives, and needs as they relate to your own career; this theory was developed to determine how careers in management advanced and how well individuals fared with their employers (12 year study; n=200); self-awareness and personal insight contributes to your career choices; The basic drivers of these career decisions are we related to these tenants: talents, motives, values -- into these eight career anchors:
READ MORE: What are the Career Anchors?
Issues Associated with Career Planning Theories
There are a few common issues that challenge career planning for talent development in organizations to ensure companies their financial return-on-investment (ROI) -- this includes balancing the needs of the organization goals and professional objectives, such as:
I. Organizational Need & Human Capital: describes the collective knowledge, skills, competencies, and values of the people in an organization; investment in employee development hopefully contributes to the company’s bottom-line/goals; More of this is discussed in AOE #5: Evaluating Learning Impact; Section 5.1.7. The Phillips ROI Methodology
II. Approaches to Work & Different Generations: In the US and Canada we have five generations working side by side these days in our organizations. Globally, there are currently 4 working generations:
For career development in the generations their might be different approaches, For example, the value of mentoring programs will be critical to support learning.This can be traditional mentoring (senior professional mentoring a junior professional) or peer mentoring on learning a new skill, adjusting to new technologies, institutional knowledge, applied experience, etc.
READ: Generations-Demographic Trends in Population & Workforce: Quick Take
BONUS READ: Which generation speaks to you?
III. Multicultural Influences: most organizations bring a rich diversity of multicultural and cultural issues that cannot be ignored when it comes to career development. There may be differences in customs, practices, or expectations depending on where and who you are working with.
BONUS READ: Multicultural Career Assessment Models e.g. Healy’s Career Appraisal Model
Development Approaches for Key Roles and Jobs (Actions: Values)
Are you studying for the CPLP now? Let me know and let's connect:
Podcast web space: https://techknowtools.com/learnperform-mixtape/
Twitter: @laurapasquini
LInkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/laurapasquini/
AOE 7: Integrated Talent Management: 7.2. Workforce Planning & Talent Acquisition Approaches
Learning Objectives:
Current Capability Assessment: How do talent professionals match current skills to the organizations needs now and in the future? A capability assessment can help organizations and HR establish a baseline of understanding for comparing against future personnel requirements by looking at performance from these three perspectives:
How Do You Estimate Future Demand? Talent development professionals need to determine the potential gaps and be cognizant of workforce supply and demand projections; this can be done by conducting an environmental scan, looking at workforce projections for the business (products or services in the organization), and being creative with how this workforce plan is developed, e.g. hiring temporary or P/T appointments, targeted recruitment planning, ways to reduce a surplus of talent or relocate professionals, etc.
BONUS READ: Workforce Planning via NIH Office of Human Resources
Internal vs. External Acquisition: These are the questions talent development professionals ask for their work in an organization to determine this choice/decision due to their participation in employee development programs. Factors considered when choosing to develop talent internally, includes:
On the other hand, you can consider outside talent options if:
Relationship Between Workforce Planning & Strategic Planning: Strategic planning is a process of systematically organizing the future, where HR will rely on past experiences to inform talent hires ahead. This helps all employees focus their attention on an organization's desired outcomes using four separate steps:
WATCH: Trends in Workforce Planning: Aubrey Wiete via ATD
Workforce plan: is a design that identifies the skill and knowledge gaps between today’s talent and the needs of the future as well as the actions required to meet the needs; it emanates from the organization's strategic plan and offers managers a framework for making staffing decisions based on an organization's mission, strategic plan, budget, and desired competencies
RESOURCE: Workforce Planning Job Aid [DOWNLOAD] via ATD
Job Analysis & Competency Modeling: A job analysis can be completed in a few different ways depending on the time available, access to subject matter experts, and the level of detail needed. Here are a few job analysis methods:*
Survey or Questionnaire
More instruments might be found in AOE #2: Instructional Design; 2.5.2. Types of Data-Collection Methods* -- check out that episode, if you have not already heard it.
From a job analysis you identify the requirements of work, create a thorough and complete job description. Competencies will focus more on the skills, knowledge, and attitudes (KSAs) of those employees who are performing the jobs at a high level proficiency, specials apply to pintoin unique characteristics of successful employees that are typically mapped to a competency model. Ideally, talent development professionals will want to develop training that targets those competencies to create a sustainable workforce. Often these competencies guide the needed learning by the organization and often competency models include these 3 areas:
Role of TD in Workforce Planning: from education, training, employee/management development, executive leadership programs, organizational learning/development, and human performance technology -- the purpose is to improve performance by developing human expertise. This might be part of the succession planning process -- to identify and develop internal employees who will likely fill key business leadership positions in the organization -- and proactively planning for personnel demands/needs/shifts. This could include employ ability of current talent, preparing professionals for the future, etc.
Other roles for Workforce Planning in TD: To support some of this workforce planning there are a few prominent roles that TD professionals play as HR partners, including:
Are you studying for the CPLP now? Let me know and let's connect:
Podcast web space: https://techknowtools.com/learnperform-mixtape/
Twitter: @laurapasquini
LInkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/laurapasquini/
Areas of expertise (AOE) 7: Integrated Talent Management“Builds an organization’s culture, engagement, capability, and capacity through the implementation and integration of talent acquisition, employee development, retention, and deployment processes, and ensures that these processes are aligned to organizational goals” (ASTD, 2013) -- in short, integrated talent management ensures organizations have the right people, with the right skills, in the right jobs, at the right time -- this means thinking about human resources, organizational development, talent development, more to bring a company's goals and missions forward to enhance their products, services, and output. Key knowledge areas or AOEs for section 7 include:
READ: 10 Ways to Build a Culture of Continuous Learning by Joanne Wells via ATD
Books read and referenced for AOE #7:
7.1. Key Components of Talent Management Systems
Talent Management Systems: What systems and processes organize how talent is managed within your organization? What are some critical factors and components that should be part of the talent management system? How can talent development professionals help to overcome some of the “mystery” in managing employees/talent? (AOE 7. Integrated Talent Management; 7.1. Key Components of Talent Management Systems)
Talent Management (Noe, 2017, p. 26): defines it as “the systematic, planned, and strategic effort by a company to use bundles of human resource management practices, including acquiring and assessing employees, learning and development, performance management, and compensation to attract, retain, develop, and motivate highly skilled employees and managers”; due to changes and evolution of our working roles, occupational trends, and needs within our jobs, there are needs for developing skills, obtaining knowledge, and apply concepts within our career journeys - shifts in emerging technologies, generational differences, leadership development, etc.
READ: Building a Talent Development Structure via ATD Research (November, 2015)
This report organizes talent development into 15 primary functions and 24 secondary functions
ARCHIVED: Building a Talent Development Structure Without Borders Webcast via ATD (2015)
Learning Objectives:
Workforce Planning & Talent Acquisition Approaches: to ensure organizations have the human capability and capacity to meet strategic challenges you need to plan for and acquire the right talent. Here are the two approaches:
Performance Management: through strategy and process you will establish integrated expectations, developing capabilities, and ways to improve performance (e.g. retirements, new hires, emerging technologies, or new strategic directions) will have TD professionals management performance by:
Employee Development: leverages formal and informal learning opportunities to ensure that professionals have the right skills for their current jobs and are developing skills and knowledge for future career opportunities and industry needs; 70-75% of work-related learning happens informally outside a classroom or a course, including coaching, reading, mentoring, self-study, social media or internet surfing.
Other ways you can think about training and education programs:
Leader and Manager Programs: this is often part of succession planning for managerial and supervisory training; part of an integrated talent management program; this may include mentoring programs (or sponsorship); action learning (potential leaders study their own actions and experience to improve performance); and coaching programs. The most effective development program support these three key tenets:
Succession Planning: Two key questions regarding talent management:
Succession planning is how you identify and develop potential talent for key positions in an organization through systematic evaluation process to fill these critical roles, and helping to:
Compensation and Rewards: this can be a key component for any job candidate and important factor for retaining talent; this might include medical, vacation, retirement, stock options and more; work-life balance or flexible working schedules, access to technology, ability to work remotely, childcare, or other benefits.
Engagement and Retention: is a desire to create an environment where employees have the tools, resources, and professional opportunities to develop skills and fulfill their career goals; long-term career growth and opportunity strategies, employees are empowered to reach their full potential and add value to the organization. Seven key drivers of engagement:
Interrelationships Among Talent Management Components: Through effective talent management, employees develop skills to work more efficiently and effectively, produce sustainable growth, grow professionally, and help the organization attain its goals. Success is all about planning for and acquiring talent, ensuring that people are performing to meet and exceed expectations, developing skills to move the organization forward, and ensuring a people of talent for the future.
Why bother getting the CPLP credential? What exactly are you studying for? Why is it important?
Are you studying for the CPLP now? Let me know and let's connect:
Podcast web space: https://techknowtools.com/learnperform-mixtape/
Twitter: @laurapasquini
LInkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/laurapasquini/
Chapter 3: Importance of Certification (Kippen, Son Lee, & Toister, 2014)
Reference: Biech, E. (2014). ASTD handbook: The definitive reference for training & development, 2nd Edition. Alexandra, VA: American Society for Training and Development.
What is CPLP certification?: involves the comprehensive evaluation of skills that are measured against industry standards, professional associations, and other industry-wide credentials for T&D -- with the following requirements for CPLP certification eligibility:
More about the CPLP from this past episode: https://share.transistor.fm/s/debbd68e
Why is the CPLP certification so important?
READ: Joining Community, Gaining Respect Through a Credential by Patty Gaul via ATD
ATD RESOURCES: Why Should I get Certified?
Countdown to the CPLP Calendar: Here are a few steps to developing your own study plan for the Knowledge and Skills Application exams as you prepare for certification:
3.8. Organizational or Cultural Differences in Learning Preferences and Communication
Cultural differences can impact the training delivery and how the learner receives the information. Around the globe, organizations and their employees think, work, act, learn, and lead in different ways -- these vary based on national, ethnic, and corporate cultures.
Learning Objectives:
Barriers to Communication: to prepare for intercultural communication talent development professionals are recommended to know that there are differences when providing training. If left unattended to, cultural differences can cause misunderstandings, conflict, and poor learner interactions or involvement of participants in a training session. Culture as an “individual’s patterned ways of thinking, feeling, and reacting” -- how do people interact with one another? What are some attributes and characteristics of teams, groups, or organizations you work with?
READ: Understanding and Developing Organizational Culture via SHRM
Language and Speech: we might all speak the same language, but there are so many nuances, differences, and misunderstandings that can occur. From accents to how we pronounce words.There might also be differences with pace or linguistics for how language is used. Other challenges might come from gross translation errors or nuance errors.
Environment: relates to a culture’s existing technological level and physical environment; this is primarily based on knowledge rather than culturally intrinsic values. Examples of this include:
Psychology: the way thoughts and ideas are process may also vary from different points of view globally, here are four ways cultures think and express themselves:
Nonverbal Behavior: Did you know that 65% of a message's meaning is conveyed through nonverbal behavior? It’s true This could be from eye contact to a laugh. Nonverbal behaviors include both your appearance (first impressions, artifacts, and physical traits) and body language (posture and how we talk, stand, walk, sit, etc. Types of body language include:
Patterns of eye contact include -- eye movements and their meaning:
READ: Nonverbal Communication in the Workplace via The Balance Careers
Proxemic Zones and Difference Between Cultures: a term coined by anthropologist Edward T. Hall in 1977 defining the study of the cultural, behavioral and sociological aspects of spatial distances between individuals; this might vary by country and culture. For example, the four types of distance between adults in the US are:
Some people feel threatened when others are too close to them -- but they also find people standoffish if the are too far apart. Fun fact: friend co-workers tend to sit beside each other at a table, where mere acquaintances or enemies in a work setting might sit opposite one another. (More to come on this topic AOE 11. Global Mindset)
READ: How to Create an Effective Cross-Cultural Training Program via SHRM
Basic Communication: information theory came from scientists’ interested in electronic communication systems (you're very welcome), it’s also called communication theory, computer mediated communication, human information processing, etc. just to name a few. Listening is one activity in a relational process -- speaking is the other. Together they make a dyadic (two-part) system -- so here are some common concepts and terms talent development professionals and researchers use in this area:
Barriers to Listening: Listening -- it’s a challenge. Sure you can hear, but are you actually listening and understanding what is being communicated? An average person talks at about 140 words/minute and a listener can understand about 280-560 words/minute. That being said, most of us can think three times faster than the person sending the message. However, 15% of the spoken word is lost in a training situation where the speaker talks fast, is rushed with delivery or speeds up because they are anxious to get the presentation over with. Other communication problems may include:
That being said this listener issues may include:
Preferences to Formal Vs. Informal Approaches
Individual Differences in Learning Preferences
There are many theories that distinguish or have set learning preferences and styles -- most have been debunked by now. You know this from what I already shared in episode 3.2. Individual Learning Preferences.
That being said, there are different modalities to learn and some people prefer a mix to fully understand -- I know I do. Here are some ways to offer individual choice and options for learning preferences -- consider these formats:
How do you prefer to learn? Are you more of an informal or formal learner?
3.10. Copyright and Fair Use LawsLearning Objective: Summarize how copyright and fair use laws relate to the production of materials for training delivery
It is important to get permission and give credit where it is due, so as talent development professionals creating materials for training delivery it is important to use copyright and fair use guidelines to do so. Whether it’s print or digital materials for training, it will be important to understand how laws and regulations impact the design, delivery, and measurement of learning or a performance initiative.
Fair Use: air Use is a legal doctrine that promotes freedom of expression by permitting the unlicensed use of copyright-protected works in certain circumstances. Section 107 of the Copyright Act provides the statutory framework for determining whether something is a fair use and identifies certain types of uses—such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research—as examples of activities that may qualify as fair use.” When considering if objects or materials are under fair use, you should examine the four requirements:
There are also “Works Made for Hire” where the employer or the other person for who was hired for the work was authoring training instruments for an employer or organization as training materials to be designated their copyright.
Copyright Law: protects the expression of ideas but not the ideas themselves in some tangible form e.g. book, magazine, video, film, etc. Although the exact words in a book may be copyrighted the ideas in the book are not. Things that cannot be copyrighted: ideas, processes, procedures, methods of operation, concepts, principles, or discoveries; however, a tangible description, explanation, or illustration of these may not be copyrighted.
In the United States, registering the work with the US Copyright Office provides legal protection and redress in state and federal courts; a copyright holder has the exclusive right to:
To avoid plagiarism, that is passing others works off as your own, give credit and recognition for knowledge and information you use for your training materials. It is important to obtain consent and permission for those items with copyright, and be prudent to include all citations or other attributions to copyrighted work. See more in AOE #6: Managing the Learning Programs; 6.8. Legal, Regulatory, and Ethical Requirements.Here are my thoughts and contributions to the topic, as I think copyright is really important and giving credit to creators -- artists, authors, and content makers.
BONUS: Public Domain: The public domain refers to creative materials or works that are not protected by intellectual property laws, including copyright, trademark, or patent laws. These materials are owned by the public, not an individual author, artist, or creator. Public domain materials and work may be used without obtaining any permission; however, no one is permitted to claim ownership for it. E.g. Pexels has Public Domain Images
READ MORE: Getting Started with Copyright, Fair Use, The Public Domain, and Creative Commons via @laurapasquini
As I think we ought to share and share alike, I thought I would offer some advice and guidance for how to license your work with a Creative Commons (https://creativecommons.org/) open license on it. E.g. Flickr Creative Commons
RESOURCE: To Share Your Work, You Gotta Put a @CreativeCommons License On It! By @laurapasquini
How do you share and license your training materials? Where might you find Fair Use other materials (e.g. images, audio or video clips, etc.) for your learning and training development? Tell me about it. I am always looking for a new resource.
3.9. Preparing for DeliveryLearning Objective: Discuss the importance of adequate preparation to ensure effective communication during training delivery
Preparing for training for adult learners is key. You need to focus on the topic for the training and ensure you have the focus and interest for the professionals you are training. Getting this learning material ready and organized in advance will ensure effective communication and preparation for interactive training environment. To prepare training content, a talent development professionals should be aware of who is attending the training, know their backgrounds, work experience/industry, and motivations for the session so you know your key objectives in advance, by learning more about this information:
Presentation notes for training should think about what you will say and how you will deliver the knowledge and skills information by:
Rehearsals: it is important to practice and practice for the training sessions. Trainers should consider these suggestions for rehearsing:
Personality: For trainers it is critical to think about training delivery as a project to share confidence, enthusiasm, and competence to promote the mindset of the presentation focus and delivery:
READ: 6 Tips for Leading a Training (That They'll Actually Enjoy) via The Muse
RESOURCE: Training Preparation Checklist from Toolbox IT/Tech
How do you prepare to perform? What are your pre-training delivery techniques that help you facilitate learning? For my veteran speakers, presenters, and trainers, what tips and strategies do you prepare before you are going to deliver a training or information session?
3.7. Facilitation and Presentation Tools & Techniques
Learning Objectives:
Creating a Learning Climate: defined as “the andragogical approach to learning climate as being relaxed, trusting, mutually respectful, informal, warm, collaborative, and supportive with openness, authenticity, and humility as key contributing factors” (Biech, 2015). You want to think about having combined strategies, relevant course materials, suitable facilities, and reliable instructional instruments to contribute to a successful learning experience.
Andragogy: the method and practice of teaching adults and is based on five key principles of adult learning from Malcolm Knowles theory based on five key principles of adult learning: self-concept, prior experience, readiness to learn, orientation to learning, and motivation to learn. (See 3.1. Learning Theories for more info)
Here are practical tips from Training and Development for Dummies (Biech, 2015), to make sure your participants learn in either virtual or physical training environments:
Preparing to Delivery Training: Preparing for the presentation and training session provides trainers with guidance and preparation for learning and development, to include:
READ: 10 Tips for Better Presentations & Facilitation via ATD
Classroom Management for Training: For working with participants you want to hold their attention, create a safe space for learning, and build in some introductions or icebreakers so others get to know one another and interact with one another. To hold participants attention, it is recommended to:
Managing Difficult Participants: Sometimes you can have challenging participants in your training session that might disrupt the learning, so it’s important to know how to deal with it. Here are some potential disruptions you might encounter with participants who:
Keeping Energy Levels High -- The Strategies: when a trainer uses active training techniques, learners will get involved in the training experience and be active learners to construct personal meaning. Here are some examples of active training techniques to include:
Energetic presentation + high energy:
Presentation Style & Behavior: for any presentation, what is said is as important as what is shown, for training delivery. There are a number of tips on delivering interactive presentations and keeping the energy level high and understanding these standards for success:
Facilitating Learning Activities: for the training field, facilitation refers to guiding or making learning easier, specifically the materials, learning content, and application for training on the job. Solid trainers are facilitators first, and presenters or “sage on the stage” last. It’s not about you, but the information you are trying to deliver to the adult learner. Being intuitive about your audience and their understanding of what you are sharing cannot be taught, but you can learn the basics about how to be a more effective facilitator -- here are some tips:
Facilitation Techniques
READ: The Role of the Facilitator via MindTools
Facilitator’s Self-Check, always asks “Am I…”:
Most good facilitators:
READ: Top 11 Skills of an Effective Facilitator by The Design Gym
Icebreakers, Openers, and Closing Activities
Questioning Techniques:
Engagement Strategies for Online Training
Other Considerations for Online Facilitation include:
Presentation and Training Tools: flipcharts, slide decks, and other training aids...oh my! Here are the 5 MYTHS about use of visual aids for training:
Options for visual aids and training tools:
Books referenced and read in this episode:
3.6. Learning Technologies
Learning Objective: Explain why it is important for talent development professionals to know the current and emerging learning technologies
Importance of Being Aware of New Learning Technologies & Leveraging Technologies to Train:
Virtual Training Basic, 2nd Edition “Rules” by Cindy Huggett:
READ: HOW TO: Virtually Team and Facilitate Meetings by @laurapasquini
REVIEW: Checklist: Selecting Technology for Learning via @laurapasquini
RESOURCE: Choosing and using media in education: the SECTIONS model by Tony Bates
Modified questions for training delivery:
Be sure to check out AOE 6. Managing Learning Programs; 6.2. Learning Technologies and Support Systems to learn more about other options.
Books mentioned in this episode:
3.5. Delivery Options and Media [For Training Delivery]Learning Objectives:
Blended Learning: “the practice of using several mediums in one curriculum. Typically refers to a combination of classroom and self-paced computer training” and it offers the best of both online and face-to-face experiences of learning environments (Biech, 2015, p. 49, 77)
Online Learning: describes how technology is leveraged via computers, mobile devices, Intranets or the Internet, etc. is used to apply learning concepts and delivery training. Other technologies that have been used: CD-ROM, DVDs, learning portals, learning management systems (LMS), email, collaborative tools, smartphones, wearable technology, electronic job aids, help systems, TV, etc. Here are a few things to help you determine if online learning is the best training delivery method before investing resources to develop it:
Asynchronous learning: learning/training where the trainer and learner do not participate simultaneously e.g. discussion board, email.
Classroom Training: a learning space set up like a traditional classroom environment led by an instructor/trainer/facilitator.
READ: Why Can’t Learning in the Analog and Digital Just Get Along? By @laurapasquini
Selecting the Facility & Preparing the Environment
The facility for training will require a process, a trainer, facilitator or program coordinator to identify what this space should look like to enhance learning goals and plan for the physical setting to enhance reaching those objectives, activities, etc. This space might be set up for reception, a meal, theater seating, conference seating, classroom set up, or U-shaped seating arrangements.
You will want to consider the following factors for the room, set up, and space:
READ: Preparing Your Training Environment by Elaine Biech
Distance Learning: educational delivery in which the instructor and students are separated by time, location, or both; can be synchronous or asynchronous; characterized by interaction between the learner and the trainer, among learners, or between learners and learning resources by using one or more learning technologies
READ: What is Distance Education? Via MSU Office of Instructional Technology
Ways to train with electronic presentation and distribution methods:
READ: 6 Tips To Design Interactive Virtual Classroom Training
Benefits of Technology-Based Training include:
Technology-Based Terms and Definitions for Training:
This is what's listed in the ATD guide -- what needs to be added? Removed? Revised?
Talent Development Performance Support Systems
Job Aid: is like a cheat sheet or stage place for information that employees will want to refer to when performing a task. This could be a reference or check list of things to remember for steps or a process for functions of their job. Typically it offers step-by-step guidance for performing a task within their job e.g. pilots use a pre-flight checklist before take off
Electronic Performance Support Systems (EPSS): is a computer application that’s linked directly to another application to train or guide employees through completing a task in the target application; a comprehensive computer-based job aid. Often the EPSS is used for training or as a job aid itself (just electronic format). The training and job aids are complementary solutions. Keep in mind that EPSS or a job aid is often less expensive than other training, and this is only when the employee needs this support. Also employees will not retain this knowledge or skills, but use the job aid or EPSS when they need it as reference.
Games and Simulations: are a way to model and represent real situations; they can introduce new skills, challenge current thinking, and guide new ideas for the future. This allows employees to practice, experiment, and apply learning in certain situations before encountering them at work. It is critical to debrief after the game or simulation with this training method.
READ: 10 Secrets of Successful Simulations
Experiential Learning: or discovery learning -- where learners encounter a problem in an activity, respond to the problem, identify useful knowledge or skills gained, debrief what was learned, and plan for transferring what they learned.
Self-Directed Approaches: self-directed learning or SDL refers to self-paced training programs that use a wide variety of media digital, print, etc. less formal types of learning e.g. team learning, knowledge management systems, and self-development programs
On-the-Job Training (OJT): happens in normal work situations using the tools, equipment, documents, or materials that employees will use during their regular work day. It often takes place with employees and using structured solutions like coaching and mentoring
Support of Personal Learning Networks: Check out episode 3.4. For more on PLNs and how you can use these communities to learn.
Books and articles referenced in this episode:
3.4. Ways to Facilitate Informal Learning & Build Learning Communities
90% of learning occurs outside of formal training settings and environments, so talent development professionals needs to foster these activities and encourage informal learning experience for training and learning.
Learning Objectives:
Informal Learning: describes anything that’s not learned in a formal program or class; on the job through talking, observing others, trial and error, discovery, collaboration, studying or reading books, MOOCs, and seeking knowledge or information through social media. E.g. conversation, communities of practice or virtual communities, and the web (blogs, videos, social networks, podcasts, videos, discussion forums, search engines, etc.)
Formal Learning: defines learning as a behavior change and rooted in a philosophy of behaviorism
Constructivism: suggest that knowledge is built (or constructed) through experience and influenced by interactions with people; ways of knowing and learning from others
Learning Platforms/Applications: on the Internet there are a number of growing digital spaces that allow people to exchange information, develop ideas together, post questions, share advice, and disseminate things. e.g. blogs, tags, wikis, screencasts, communities of practice, instant messaging, podcasts, videos, etc.
Techniques for Encouraging the use of Informal Learning: WHY? It leverages existing materials and relationships without requiring a classroom, a learning designer, or training facilitator. To support informal learning, you will need to set clear expectations among stakeholders in the organization about what informal learning is and the potential for supporting employees in their work. Here are a few group activities that promote informal learning at work:
READ: Thinking About Promoting Informal Learning in Groups by Juana Llorens
It’s important that talent development professionals coach employees and managers to accept and leverage informal learning by:
Developing Personal Learning Network (PLN): a PLN is an informal learning network that consists of the people a learner interacts with and derives knowledge from in a personal learning environment; From the theory of connectivism (Siemens & Downes, 2007), it purports that learners create connections and develop a network to contribute to their professional development and knowledge.
BONUS READ: Thoughts my My PLN by @laurapasquini
Types of Learning Communities: Groups of people who share a professional interests or background and discuss opportunities, challenges, and feelings related to it. These can meet in person or online or a combination of the two on a regular basis (weekly, monthly, annually, etc.) to share a common interest and share resources.
MORE ABOUT: Introduction to Communities of Practice
REVIEW: Networked Communities of Practice - Research Project
EXAMPLE: Connect and share with people in your industry: https://www.fishbowlapp.com/
BONUS COMMUNITY: Higher Ed Podcast Project
Ways to Grow and Foster Learning Communities in an Organization: informal learning is a journey and to grow or foster your learning communities within your own organization, here are a few suggestions:
A PLN you should join if you are studying for the CPLP Exam:
ATD Certificied Professional Learning & Performance (CPLP) Candidate Preparation LinkedIn Group: https://www.linkedin.com/groups/8664160/
Books mentioned in this episode and to read more:
3.3. Instructional Methods
Learning Objective: Explain what is meant by instructional methods, and list five factors that talent development professionals should consider when selecting an appropriate method
Choosing an Instructional Method: science + art + feeling = decision; After you write the learning objectives to define the knowledge, skills, and attitudes, that professional learners should acquire as a result of training, the selective method or activity should relate to the LO and other factors, including:
READ: Choosing and Using The Right Instructional Methods and Training Activities
READ: Selecting the Instructional Setting
Refer to more about choice for instructional methods for training, teaching, and learning in AOE 2. Instructional Design; 2.9. Instructional Methods.
Books mentioned in this episode:
3.2. Individual Learning Preferences
Learning objectives:
The Learning Style Neuromyth: A neuromyth describes fallacies scientists discover about how the brain functions (Biech, 2017). There are a number of misconceptions about your brain and how you learn -- specifically being there is no measurable proof that learning styles exist, all learners learn differently and have their own preferences -- even though we know that all of us learn well through all modalities.If you provide learning that encompasses many different modalities:
Herrmann’s Whole Brain Approach is related to the Herrmann Brain Dominance Instrument: a method of personality testing developed by Ned Hermann that classifies learners in terms of preferences for thinking in four modes based on brain function. This is a personality testing related to brain dominance to understand how people learn in terms of preferences for thinking in 4 modes based on brain function:
Multiple Intelligence: how people prefer to receive information, intelligence reflects how they process information. Gardner (1983) suggests that intelligence is multifaceted and the traditional measures such as IQ tests do not accurately measure all its facets and defines intelligence as:
Multiple Intelligence Theory: (Frames of Mind, 1985) Gardner describes how intelligences reflect how people prefer to process information; believes that most people are comfortable in three to four of these intelligences and avoid the others. READ: Multiple Intelligences: What Does the Research Say? Via Edutopia
Perceptual Modalities: a learner’s primary perceptual modality and the preferred mode of learning may be one of these:
Cross’s Adult Learning: the barriers to adult learning, such as participation and development stages and conceptual frameworks to describe aspects of adult learning and stimulate related research:
Accelerated Learning (AL)Techniques and Principles: a method for speeding and enhancing both the design and learning processes. AL uses the techniques that maximize learners’ long-term retention by honoring the different learning preferences of each learner and using experiential learning exercises e.g. role plays, mnemonics, etc.
Myers-Briggs Type Indicator: an instrument to help determine personality type based on preferences for extraversion (E) or introversion (I), intuiting (N) or sensing (S), thinking (T) or feeling (F), and judging (J) or perceiving (P); used in career development and team building; the MBTI was not designed to assess the level of maturity, degree of motivation, state of mental health or intelligence. This is a jool based on the work of Carl Jung to ask people to self-report on preferences. READ: An Overview of the Myber-Briggs Types Indicator 16 Personality Types
Silver and Hanson’s Learning Style Inventory: MBTI was used to adopted as a spectrum of four distinct styles that help students learn:
Adult’s Learning Rates: a variety of factors can influence the speed at which adults learn; factors that influence the time it takes for employees to learn includes: psychological, environmental, emotional, sociological, physical, intellectual, experiential, and age.
WATCH: The first 20 hours -- how to learn anything | Josh Kaufman | TEDxCSU
BONUS READ: Make Your eLearning Stick: 8 Tips & Techniques for Learning Retention
Identifying Training & Presenting Styles: this can impact the delivery of the learning and impact the training process; the key is to be a flexible presenter and consider how you facilitate learning to adapt the content in a manner that appeals to all learners.
READ: Don’t have 10,000 hours to learn something new? That’s fine - all you need is 20 hours
Books mentioned in this episode:
AOE 3: Training Delivery
Delivering learning solutions in a manner that both engages the learner and produces desired outcomes; managing and responding to learner needs; ensuring that learning is made available in effective platforms and delivered in a timely and effective manner (ASTD, 2013). This section is weighted 13-14% of the exam; 20-21 questions)
This AOE for Training Delivery we are going to emphasize all about learning. To train effectively you need to build a culture of learning (ATD, 2016) -- as this results in a high-performing organizations that is:
Training Delivery: Deliver informal and formal learning solutions in a manner that is both engaging and effective (ASTD Handbook, 2nd Edition)
The Value of Training (IBM, 2014) report says that 84% of employees in the best performing organizations are receiving the training they need, compared with 16% in the poorest performing companies. Key knowledge areas for talent development related to training delivery includes (also related to AOE: 2 - Instructional Design):
Books read and referenced for AOE #3 on Training Delivery:
3.1. Learning Theories
Learning Theory: What cognition and learning theories form the foundation for the talent development profession to improve skills, knowledge and performance deficits that support business strategy? (AOE 3. Training Delivery; 3.1. Learning Theories)
Learning objective: Discuss the importance of adult learning theories and techniques for delivering training.
Key goals for learning theories in talent development:
Adult learning theories: attempt to explain how adults learn. Some look at what is observable -- stimulus and response; and other look at memory and propose environmental factors
READ: 3 Adult Learning Theories Every E-Learning Designer Must Know via ATD
Stay tuned and/or check out Learning Theories in Section 2. Instructional Design -- there will be more of a deep dive there. This was just a teaser or follow up -- depending on the order you are listening to and reviewing my study notes.
READ: Applying Adult Learning Theory to Training by Elaine Biech
Books mentioned in this episode:
AOE 8. Coaching; Sub-section 8.2. Ethical Guidelines and Standards of Conduct Related to Coaching
Learning objectives:
Ethical Guidelines: talent development professionals must be conscious of the effects of their products, services, and actions on an organization’s employees they include the follow code of ethics for coaching conduct:
Standards and practices related to ethical behavior include:
Privacy and Confidentiality Expectations: this includes offering objectivity and confidentiality; typically outsider coaches are welcome as they are unbiased and can focus on the client’s success without any hidden or personal agendas. Trust expectations allow developments and coaching to take place.
Conflicts of Interest: this might occur if a coach has an interest that impedes or interferes with the ability to act in the best interest of a client. To avoid any personal gain or interests, coaches need to engage in a coaching agreement that avoids a conflict of interest. The International Coach Federation (ICF) code of conduct and ethics guidelines offer coaches suggestions, such as:
Relationship Limitations: coach-client relationship it is important to establish an agreement about expectations and boundaries. It is important to manage and set up the boundaries for the coaching relationship to determine if/when the coaching relationship will be terminated.
Pitfalls of coaching:
Tips for Successful Coaching:
Why ICF? https://coachfederation.org/why-icf
BONUS RESOURCES:
Coaching Training - Dr. Katie Linder https://www.drkatielinder.com/training/
An Introduction to the Coaching Training (episode) https://www.drkatielinder.com/ygt161/
Podcast: Coach to Coach https://www.drkatielinder.com/coach/
Welcome to the CPLP Area of Expertise (AOE) 8: Coaching
Using an interactive process to help individuals develop rapidly and produce results; improving others’ ability to set goals, take action, make better decisions, and make full use of their natural strengths. This section is weighted 8-9% of the exam; 12-14 questions.
AOE 8. Coaching; Sub-section 8.1. Core Coaching Competencies
The learning objectives for Core Coaching Competencies:
Coaching: is not counseling or mentoring; it is a conversation focused on helped others (clients) move forward relative to their goals, hopes, and curiosities -- things they want to accomplish or achieve. The coaching practice believes that the clients have the answers within and the coach uses tools and techniques to draw it out
READ: The Difference Between Coaches, Mentors, Advisors, and Consultants by Mike Krupit
Role of a Coach: for talent development, coaches are designated to improve employee performance to impact the organization. A successful coaching client will be highly motivated and generally have some combination of the following characteristics:
READ: Boundaries in Coaching by Skh Mishraa, PCC via ICF
The Purpose of the Coach: typically it’s part of a larger strategy for helping individuals, units, systems and organization to improve performance; it gives 1:1 personal attention to focus on the client/employee for just-in-time needs for issues beyond a training/learning solution.
Setting the Foundation for Coaching - the most important skills for a productive coaching relationship includes these skills for any coach:
BONUS READ: Minimal Skills Requirements for what ICF assessors evaluate when reviewing recorded coaching sessions for ACC level certified coaches.
Co-Creating the Relationship & Building Trust: coaching requires a safe and comfortable environment that encourages open, two-way conversation. This includes verbal and nonverbal cues, when/where/how you meet, and creating a space to form this new coaching relationship. Elements of Great Dialogue shared by Lisa Haneberg from Coaching Basics, 2nd Ed, includes:
READ: From the Toolbox: Trust and Intimacy Explained by David Ander via ICF
Effective Communication: helps to clarify clients goals and thoughtful communication can help move these goals to be meaningful and actionable.
Asking Questions: Two most common types of questions often asked:
The Socratic Method: probing and open-ended questions; expose contradictions for thoughts and ideas to guide your clients toward solutions and their own actions. E.g. Can you give me an example? What does that mean? How does this relate to what you said before?
Setting Expectations: a coach should reach an agreement with the client that identifies the following aspects about coaching and the coaching sessions:
Providing Feedback: for coaching feedback is a valuable tool to help the client improve performance, motivate, etc. If done poorly it can lead to demotivation or impact to their self-esteem. Two types of feedback for coaching:
Some guidelines around feedback:
Creating Talent Development Opportunities
Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs: a motivation theory from Abraham Maslow (1954) from his book Motivation and Personality that said people have complex needs, which they strive to fulfill and which change and evolve over time.
Theory X and Theory oY (McGregor): Theory X explains the importance of heightened supervision, external rewards, and penalties, while Theory Y highlights the motivating role of job satisfaction and encourages workers to approach tasks without direct supervision.
Career Building Options and Descriptions: There are a number of reasons why employees seek out 1:1 coaching to improve their learning and performance at work and beyond, here are a few ways clients seek to build their career:
Call to Action [Together]: an action plan* is written to acknowledge the current situation and outline specific goals with the steps to reach this outcome. Things to co-create in an action plan:
Debriefing, Reflecting, and Measuring Results: coaching requires specific goals and linking these objectives to measurable results for evaluation. For this you will want to consider using Kirpatrick’s Model of Evaluation Level 2 (Learning) and Level 3 (Behavior) measure with how it addresses Level 4: Results.
AOE 1. Performance Improvement; Sub-section 1.10. Group Dynamics Process
Learning objectives for Group Dynamics Processes:
Group dynamics: the interaction of individuals working or learning together & includes things like setting goals, communicating, making decisions, providing leadership,& resolving conflict; facilitation strategies can affect and impact these dynamics, as shared in Ep. 1.7.
Personal identity issues: Will I belong? Will I be listened to? Will I have a chance to contribute?
Relationship issues: Will everyone get along? How will people from different departments and levels interact? Will the working atmosphere be friendly or businesslike? Will communication be open?
Inclusion Practices
Groupthink “occurs when a group of well-intentioned people make irrational or non-optimal decisions that are spurred by the urge to conform or the discouragement of dissent. This problematic or premature consensus may be fueled by a particular agenda or simply because group members value harmony and coherence above rational thinking.”
Conditions that allow for groupthink: isolation of the group, high group cohesion, directive leadership, lack of norms related to methodical decision-making procedures, homogeneity of members, and high stress from external threats.
Ways to avoid groupthink:
Decision-Making Processes — see Ep. 1.7.; allow others to contribute their ideas and perspectives and allow the group to avoid narrow thinking. E.g. brainstorming, nominal group technique, affinity & interrelationship diagramming
Social Psychology Dynamics: behavioral styles categorize personality differences, information-processing styles, and social interaction differences. One common way to identify behavioral style model is the DiSC Personality Profile (Marston, 1928) refers to the four basic behavioral styles:
What’s your DiSC Personality? Find out: https://www.123test.com/disc-personality-test/
Tuckman Model of Group/Team Development
Cogg’s Ladder: Model of Team Development
What sort of models do you use for team development? Are there assessments that you prefer for assessing individual and group dynamics? Let me know!
AOE 1. Performance Improvement; Sub-section 1.9. Communication Techniques & Tools
Learning Objective Communication: Describe the importance of planning communication for a performance improvement initiative.
For performance improvement and solution implementation, you need to know the audience to communicate these initiatives and the appropriate communication style that will be the most helpful. This might be a verbal presentation or even clear and concise written communication. Consider the following communication items for performance solutions:
READS:
AOE 1. Performance Improvement; Sub-section 1.8. Project Management Tools & Techniques
Learning Objectives for Project Management:
The ideal way to support performance improvement is to have a pragmatic schedule of activities and steps to help with successful solution implementation. The last episode 1.7 discussed how to facilitate this process improvement methods; whereas this part of the performance solution will focus on seeing this process improvement through to project success.
These project management tools consists of planning, organizing and controlling work to attend to the needs of the project, tasks, phases, work, and resources. A project manager knows what happened from the past (learn from past mistakes) and plan for the future as you stay in the present (react to surprises).
A few project planning tools are:
Certification in Project Management
RESOURCES:
Follow these stellar project managers I have learned from in higher ed:
My Recommended Project Management Tools & Tech:
More about this in AOE 6. Managing Learning Programs; 6.11. Project Planning Tools and Processes (future podcast episode).
AOE 1. Performance Improvement; Sub section 1.7. Facilitation Methods
Learning Objectives for Facilitation Methods:
Facile: translated from French: (adjective) easy,simple, quick, effortless, light
A facilitator is a guide for a group; and facilitation has many meanings we’ll get into for AOE 1.7 on this episode.
Training vs. Process Facilitation — what are the differences between these 2 ways to facilitate?
Training Facilitation
Process Facilitation
Facilitators are responsible for the team/group they are working with and the organization they are supporting by:
Three skills needed to successfully manage a team:
BONUS: Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Mode Instrument (TKI)
The TKI, outlines the basic dimensions of behavior as how others in the group want to respond to conflict situation, here are a few of the dysfunctional team members you might encounter:
Tools for Facilitation
Storytelling is an effective way to communicate and present information as it helps to capture others attention, establish a rapport, build credibility, bring a team closer together, and deliver a message others will remember.
Questioning Techniques help to stimulate discussion, check for understanding, keep participants of the meeting involved, gain consensus for ideas, and allows for open thinking to brainstorm or offer potential solutions. More about this to come in AOE 3. Training Delivery.
Meeting Management
Process Improvement Methodologies - often is from a result of a gap analysis identifying the components of the process that needs attention (as shared in Ep. 1.3.). To conduct a process-level gap analysis, you will need to design and recommend process improvement solutions with these four basic components:
Suggested ways to get process improvement going when facilitating include:
Plan, Do, Check, Act (PDCA) Model is a standard process improvement model; READ: How to Apply the Plan-Do-Check-Act (PDCA) Model to Improve Your Business by Lucidchart
Also known as the Deming Cycle or PDSA Cycle
Decision-Making Methods & Processes — you need an organized process to solve problems so a good facilitator will ensure the team is following a specific & agreed-upon process for making a decision, like this problem solving model:
In Search of Solutions (Quinlivan-Hall & Renner, 1990), offers the following guidelines for creating the appropriate question to clearly define a problem:
BONUS READ: 7 steps of the Decision Making Process
Group Dynamics, Observations, and Interventions
Group dynamics focuses on the nature of groups, specifically urges to belong or to identify may impact attitudes and influence the group to become bonded. To observe a group, it will be critical for the facilitator to use all three types* of listening:
*There seem to be many more types of listening — these are just not identified in this section of the ATD Learning System for the CPLP exam.
Nominal Group Technique — helps with decision-making, like I shared in Episode 1.5, this exercise generates many ideas and lets the group evaluate each of these in a round robin approach to classify, rank, and identify critical suggestions of importance.
Books mentioned in episode 1.7.:
Passive listening music clip song was The Vendetta featuring Apoxode by Stefan Kartenberg from http://dig.ccmixter.org/files/JeffSpeed68/58628 with a Creative Commons license.
AOE 1. Performance Improvement; Sub section 1.6. Change Management Theory Learning objective: Describe why change management is important to plan for and manage as it relates to performance improvement initiatives
Connect with the podcast post on Twitter: @laurapasquini
Or LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/laurapasquini/
Are you studying for the CPLP? Want more learning & performance ideas?
Subscribe to the pod for the next study session: https://learnperform.transistor.fm/subscribe
Change Management Considerations:
Three other roles that should be used as you plan/manage change initiatives:
READ: Change Management by MindTools to learn about the objectives and activities for managing change in your organization:
*Stay tuned and subscribe to the Learn/Perform Mixtape podcast for when I talk more about AOE 10 - Change Management … coming soon!
AOE 1. Performance Improvement; Sub section 1.5. Approaches for Selecting Improvement Solutions
This could be called a performance improvement solution, improvement solution, or solution —the terminology depends on what your client and what their organization uses.
The learning objectives for the Approaches for Selecting Improvement Solutions are:
Performance Improvement Selection Overview
When conducting a resource analysis as mentioned on 1.3. Business, Performance, & Gap Analysis episode — you can return to if you want to learn more — looking for:
Behavior Engineering Model (Gilbert, 1996) from Ep. 1.2, looks at the systematic approach to identify barriers and difficulties that might occur in the workplace to block reaching the desired outcomes of the organization related to performance:
Potential Solutions — There’s always room for improvement on the following:
Partnership Creation and Support — to reach solutions are critical. Clients you work with can either enhance or block these solutions. Find expertise and specialists in the organization who have good listening skills, can build trust, and respect one another to reach the goals of the organization.
Decision-Making Matrices and Methods — the tools to help you aid in selecting a solution:
BONUS READ: Facilitator’s Guide to Participatory Decision-Making by Sam Kaner
AOE 1. Performance Improvement; Sub section 1.4. Root Cause Analysis
This learning objectives for Root Cause Analysis for this episode:
To do this Root Cause Analysis you need both objective (a target or purpose that leads to a goal) and subjective (personal opinions, points of view, emotions, judgements, etc.)data to get a full picture of what is going on. Learning & performance professionals might use a process improvement tool, like a cause-and-effect (fishbone or Ishikawa) diagram to help identify all the likely causes of an issue or problem. Another technique you might try is the Pareto Analysis to prioritize problem solving work based on the 80/20 rule, where 80% of the problem may be the results in as few as 20% of the causes. And of course, you will be collecting data to identify the root cause of a performance gap, just as we discussed in the previous episode no. 6 about Business, Performance, and Gap Analysis (AOE 1.3.).
For performance improvement, we often consider asking the following issues:
BONUS VIDEO: Introduction to Root Cause Analysis via MindToolsVideos offers a nice guide to the steps for conducting this type of analysis:
Examples of Root Causes found in performance gaps include (but are not limited to):
Root Cause Analysis Tools:
Importance of Gathering Data
To make an objective and informed recommendation for a learning/performance solution, you need to ensure the data is measurable and the items identified in analysis have the largest impact on performance in the organization. To ensure the root cause analysis is complete, be sure the following questions have been answered:
Books mentioned in this episode:
Facilitating with Ease!, 4th Edition by Ingrid Bens
AOE 1. Performance Improvement; Sub section 1.3. Business, Performance, and Gap Analysis
This episodes learning objectives for Performance Analysis:
Business Analysis consists of 3 main tasks:
During the business analysis phase, talent development professionals gather information related on a series of issues. E.g. external/internal factors impacting business goals; rationale for these goals; trends and forces in the industry; and relevant strategies to reach their goals. The business analysis has these three phases:
Performance Analysis: “the goal of performance analysis is to measure the gap between the desired and actual performance” (Rossett, 1992); for talent development professionals conducting this analysis, your job is to determine what initiatives or combination of initiatives will close that gap to have the actual performance level reach the desired performance level. These performance improvement initiatives are more effective as you work in partnership and collaborate with stakeholders across the organization — this helps break down barriers and fully understand the issues and potential outcomes e.g. front line workers responsibilities and executive leadership suggestion/thoughts all matter; BONUS READ: Performance Analysis in Instructional Design
Project Scope should include answers to these three questions:
Measurement Criteria & Desired Performance Outcomes
ATD Human Performance Improvement (HPI) model uses two types of evaluation: formative and summative. Both use quantitative analysis (measurable data or the quantities of particular items present in a situation or event) and qualitative analysis (non-measurable data like individual opinions, behaviors, and attributes of the org, reputation, etc.) to support measurement and results.
The formative evaluation purpose (Brinkerhoff, 1998) are to:
The summative evaluation measures:
Constraints Analysis: identifies what factors might limit the potential project; barriers to consider, e.g. budget, time, scheduling, space, resources availability, competing priorities in the organization
Cultural Analysis: you can complete a culture audit — an assessment to examine current practices, programs, and processes and identify how culturally appropriate they may be for multicultural or global audiences; you can look at corporate histories, documents, data, internal/external studies, sources of information on finances, etc. Find the beliefs and values through research methods, e.g. interviews, surveys, focus groups, direct observation, etc.; READ: Basics of Culture Audits via TD.org
High-performing cultures in organizations typically encourage intrinsic motivation; flexible work environments; results-oriented; inclusive; collaborations and partnerships; values talent; encourages creativity/play; promotes trustworthiness; enables transitions; build knowledge; reinforces participation and engagement.
Performance gap analysis: is a profess that measures, describes, and compares what employees currently accomplish and what is required in the future; it should define these 3 factors:
BONUS READS: Performance Gap Analysis; Choosing Strategies for Change via HBR
BONUS TOOL: Gap Analysis SWOT Template; 5 Change Management Tools & Techniques
Workflow Analysis: is a process for how people, materials, methods, machines, and the environment combine to add value to a produce or service; workflow or process analysis looks at how the work is completed, individual roles and responsibilities in this process; and all resources and systems used.
Analysis tools:
External Analysis: to take inventory of the economic, social, political/legislative, workforce, technological, and competitive factors that might influence the way an organization functions and forces them to evaluate or even realign their goals and priorities.
Resources Analysis: to identify the available resources in the organization that can be used to determine a performance gap or to help with designing a potential performance improvement solution.
AOE 1. Performance Improvement; Sub section 1.2. Systems thinking and theory
This episodes Learning Objectives for Systems Thinking and Theory:
Systems thinking looks at problems in a holistic way and puts them into context of the whole to find objective performance solutions. When taking a systems approach to projects, you need to look at the entire organization with regards to the ramifications of all decisions and strategies. For example, you might question the types of behaviors that are being rewarded or incentivized — and how this might look if people were rewarded for long-term systematic changes. More on what systems thinking involves: what, why, when, where, and how?
The goal is to determine the underlying and fundamental relationships causing the problem. It’s a proactive way to avoid the continual reaction and need to manage issues. General principles of systems thinking includes:
Characteristics of systems thinking:
Principles of Systems Thinking (Kauffman, 1980; Senge, 1994):
READ: The Six Systems Thinking Steps to Solve Complex Problems
Levels of Systems Thinking Problems — involve the understanding how how you view the problems in terms of events, patterns, and structures. Ways to unlock systems level change you need to unpack the systems mindset, identify the right tools or process for the job, and understand the impacts of human dynamics. How does systems thinking impact a collective mindset? What are the ways we can solve issues with these considerations?
Cultural and global factors that can affect the organizational system include:
Systems thinking helps to identify and respond to a series of changes before those changes lead to failure — especially as organizations experience transitions (e.g. mergers and acquisitions). People experience these transitions in four stages — here are their reactions to change:
Other factors to benchmark during a business analysis include:
Industry Knowledge-the organization’s rationale for a goal and why it is a priority
-other organizational goals, that may be competing or contradictory
-other strategies that have been identified or tried previously to meet the goal
Industry factors to understand:
--the competitive environment
--compliance issues
Broad Company Knowledge:
-the industry segment
-the organizational structure
-the formal and informal power structures
-knowledge transfer
Business awareness: key factors impacting the organizations current situation, influences in the market/industry, and factors affecting health.
System Archetype: is a pattern of behavior of a system which can be used to identify the type of system one is working with. Here are eight system archetypes and their storylines as mentioned in this episode. Examples discussed include: Fixes that fall; Shifting the burden; Limits to success; Drifting goals; Growth and underinvestment; Success to the successful; Escalation; and Tragedy of the commons
Books mentioned in this episode:
Area of Expertise (AOE) 1: Performance Improvement; Subsection 1.1.: Performance Improvement Process
Learning Objectives for Performance Improvement Process:
The purpose of performance improvement is to strengthen the organizational processes, systems, products, or services, specifically aims to:
A few things mentioned on this Learn/Perform “track”:
Models Mentioned
Shared Principles of Performance Improvement
Key areas of focus for performance improvement: organizational goals and initiatives + changement skills (impetus skills, communication channels/information networks, group dynamics, process, facilitation skills, etc.)
Books mentioned in this episode:
Now that we're past eligibility, it's time to review what is in the Knowledge Exam for the CPLP. On this episode I give an overview of the Content Outline of the Knowledge Exam (also found on pp. 40-44 of the 2019 CPLP Certification Handbook). You can download your copy directly from the bottom of this web page: https://www.td.org/certification/cplp/eligibility
Have you just stumbled upon this podcast? Here's the trailer to give you an ideas about what the Learn/Perform Mixtape is all about.
Are you studying for the CPLP now? Let me know and let's connect:
Podcast web space: https://techknowtools.com/learnperform-mixtape/
Twitter: @laurapasquini
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/laurapasquini/
Areas of Expertise (AOE)
AOE 1: Performance Improvement (Weighted 13 - 14% of the exam)
Applying a systematic process of discovering and analyzing human performance gaps; planning for future improvements in human performance; designing and developing solutions to close performance gaps; partnering with the customer when identifying the opportunity and the solution; implementing the solution; monitoring the change; evaluating the results.
AOE 2: Instructional Design (Weighted 13 – 14% of the exam)
Designing, creating, and developing informal and formal learning solutions to meet organizational needs; analyzing and selecting the most appropriate strategy, methodologies, and technologies to maximize the learning experience and impact.
AOE 3: Training Delivery (Weighted 13 - 14% of the exam)
Delivering learning solutions in a manner that both engages the learner and produces desired outcomes; managing and responding to learner needs; ensuring that learning is made available in effective platforms and delivered in a timely and effective manner.
AOE 4: Learning Technologies (Weighted 11 - 12% of the exam)
Identifying, selecting, implementing, and leveraging a variety of learning technologies; adapting learning technologies; applying appropriate technologies to a learning opportunity or challenge.
AOE 5: Evaluating Learning Impact (Weighted 11 - 12% of the exam)
Gathering, organizing, and analyzing information regarding the impact of learning solutions against key business drivers; presenting the information in a way that is meaningful to the organization; using learning metrics and analytics to inform organizational decision making.
AOE 6: Managing Learning Programs (Weighted 8 - 9% of the exam)
Providing leadership to execute the organization’s strategy; planning, monitoring, and adjusting learning and development projects or activities. Strategic and Tactical areas of knowledge
AOE 7: Integrated Talent Management (Weighted 8 - 9% of the exam)
Building an organization’s culture, engagement, capability, and capacity through the implementation and integration of talent acquisition, employee development, retention, and deployment processes; ensuring that these processes are aligned to organizational goals.
AOE 8: Coaching (Weighted 8 - 9% of the exam)
Using an interactive process to help individuals develop rapidly and produce results; improving others’ ability to set goals, take action, make better decisions, and make full use of their natural strengths.
AOE 9: Knowledge Management (Weighted 5 - 6% of the exam)
Capturing, distributing, and archiving intellectual capital in a way that encourages knowledge sharing and collaboration in the organization.
AOE 10: Change Management (Weighted 8 - 9% of the exam)
Applying structured approaches to shift individuals, teams, and organizations from a current state to a desired state.
Foundational Competency (FC) 11: Global Mindset
Having an openness and awareness of cultural differences; working effectively across borders and cultures. Cultural, global theories & issues -- self-awareness and looking at different dimensions of learning, communication and dynamics.
My Study Notes for this Learn/Perform Mixtape episode:
Here's a message I received ATD after being "accepted" as being eligible to sit for my exam --
There is no prerequisite study/preparation requirement for the CPLP program; however, most candidates find it necessary to do so. Depending on your learning style and preference, there are a variety of additional study/preparation options available. Here are just a few suggestions:
The CPLP registration fee covers the cost of all testing and test related materials for a one time sitting. Fees do not cover the cost of study or preparation materials, study group support, travel expenses to and from the testing center, transfers, or retesting fees.
I've decided to become a member to get a discount on the ATD Learning System: CPLP Edition. Get ready to put aside 80+ hours of study just to prepare for the first exam -- the Knowledge Exam. Here are a few other prep resources from ATD: https://www.td.org/certification/preparation
Here are a few helpful resources I found to prepare before I signed up for the first exam (January 24, 2020) that are open or accessible for free, specifically two previous webcasts from this year from ATD on the CPLP and SAE exams:
p.s. The ATD Competency Model is changing mid-2020 -- as they are reviewing this now. This podcast series is relevant for the current model and prep for the CPLP exams scheduled for early 2020.
Are you studying for the CPLP now? Let me know and let's connect:
Podcast web space: https://techknowtools.com/learnperform-mixtape/
Twitter: @laurapasquini
LInkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/laurapasquini/
Study notes from this episode:
More blogged about this at: Getting Certified in Learning & Performance with the CPLP
More about Learn/Perform Mixtape and host at: https://techknowtools.com/learnperform-mixtape/
The Learn/Perform Mixtape are a series of podcast episodes I'm recording as I prepare for the Certified Professional in Learning and Performance (CPLP) by reviewing the Association for Talent Development (ATD) Competency Model. Welcome to my podcast study playlist for the CPLP exams.
More about Learn/Perform Mixtape and host at: https://techknowtools.com/learnperform-mixtape/
This podcast features the song "I dunno" by grapes featuring J Lang, Morusque (c): http://dig.ccmixter.org/files/grapes/16626 under a Creative Commons license. The music has been modified to fit the length of this podcast.