It's broken because Progressives, who are really Communists and anti-American/anti-Enlightenment/anti-Christian, are deliberately breaking it. The fact that people who think of themselves as "Republicans" cannot no longer agree on the solutions and can only agree that something is broken is simply a sign that they've been deliberately misled about what "Republican" means by people who claim to be "Republican" but are really Progressives pretending to be "Republican". Trump showed us basic Republican Values in a very simple package. In reality, it's not very difficult to understand. Get Government out of the way domestically and let the people use their ingenuity to solve problems for themselves. When dealing with Foreign Powers put America's Interests First. The Solutions write themselves then.