8.6 Makkos Daf 06 B (8 lines Up)SummaryIn the mishna (8.3) Rabbi Yosi said that the witnesses must give the _hasra’ah._Rav Papa commented to Abayye: Isn’t Rabbi Yosi of the opinion that we’re not particular about the _hasra’ah;_ as we learn in a _mishna_ that “Rabbi Yosi says an ‘enemy’ does not need a _hasra’ah_ because his act is clearly premeditated and he is aware of the consequences.“?Abayye: Rabbi Yosi bar Yehuda (one of the later _tanna’im,_ in the generation of Rebbi) is the one who holds we are not particular about _hasra’ah._ We learn this in a beraisa: “Rabbi Yosi bar Yehuda says that a chaver (a _lamdan_ ) does not require _hasra’ah_ because he is considered forewarned “. See acast.com/privacy for privacy and opt-out information.