13.2 Makkos Daf 08 B (3 lines Up)_Suggestion: Before listening to the recording take a minute and review yesterday’s gemara. It will help to lock it in in your mind, and today’s gemara will flow better!_SummaryWe learned in the Beraisa that a Yisroel receives malkos because of what he did to a slave or a samaritan. But what could that be?Rav Acha bar Yaakov: If the Yisroel falsely testified against the slave and was _huzam,_ he would be punished with whatever he intended to punish the slave; that’s how he would receive _malkos_ because of a slave.Challenge: The first half of the _beraisa_ mentions that a slave receives _malkos_ because of what he did to a Yisroel, but a slave cannot testify!Rav Acha son of Rav Ika: The slave hit the Yisroel and he caused less than a _perutah’s-worth_ of damage. Since there is no payment here, he receives _malkos.__(The Torah says that when administering malkos “He should not add” if one gave one more blow than necessary, he has transgressed a lav. However whenever a payment is involved, there is no malkos [5.2].)_As Rabbi Ami quoted from Rabbi Yochanan: If one hit his fellow and caused less than a _perutah’s-worth_ of damage, he receives _malkos._We do not equate hitting with cursing. [While we are not punished for cursing a samaritan (13.1), we are punished for hitting him]._[The Kusim (Samaritans) accepted the entire Torah, only that they didn’t keep all of it! A ger toshav never accepted all the mitzvos, only to refrain from idolatry]._We learned in the mishna: A Yisroel does not go into galus for killing a _ger toshav_ . A _ger toshav_ goes into _galus_ for killing another _ger toshav._Question: From the beginning of the _mishna_ it seems that a _ger toshav_ is treated as a gentile (because his murder is not cause for _galus_ ), but then we see that a _ger toshav does_ have to go to _galus_ , but there’s no _galus_ for a gentile?!Rav Kahana: The beginning of our mishna refers to a _ger toshav_ who killed a Yisroel _(galus is not enough for him; he’s put to death),_ and the end of the mishna refers to a _ger toshav_ who killed another _ger toshav_.Attached is daf 6 make sure to print it.* See acast.com/privacy for privacy and opt-out information.