13.3 Makkos Daf 09 A (8 lines Dn)_Suggestion: Before listening to the recording take a minute and review yesterday’s gemara. It will help to lock it in in your mind, and today’s gemara will flow better!_SummaryAnother version of the foregoing discussion: One _possuk_ states “These [sanctuary] cities will be for you _(the bnei Yisroel)_ and for the _ger (toshav)_ amongst you”. Another possuk states “The sanctuary cities will be for you” . And we understand “But not for the _ger toshav_ ”. So it’s a contradiction.Rav Kahana: The second _possuk_ refers to a _ger toshav_ who killed a Yisroel _(galus is not enough for him; he’s put to death),_ and the first _possuk_ refers to a _ger toshav_ who killed another _ger toshav_ .Challenge: Beraisa: A _ger toshav_ or a gentile who murdered, is put to death.We don’t distinguish between the victims of a gentile, and even if he murdered a gentile, not a Yisroel, he is put to death. So it seems that we don’t distinguish between the victims of the _ger toshav_ either.Rav Chisda: The ger toshav goes into _galus_ when he killed with a downward blow, just like a Yisroel (10.1-10.5). But the beraisa refers to when he killed with an upward blow . Since even a Yisroel does not go into _galus_ for upward killing, the _ger toshav_ cannot go into _galus_ and is executed. See acast.com/privacy for privacy and opt-out information.