I'm on Fire!
Chloe and Arissa
Podcasts Similar to I'm on Fire!
Not Another Horror Podcast (82.52%)
Anthony Rossetti
Interstate Odyssey (82.4%)
Sophie Peterson
Lonely Fans Podcast (81.1%)
TigerHussle
Just A Story: Urban Legend Podcast (80.19%)
Just A Story Urban Legend Podcast
Razzmatazz Audio Theater (79.51%)
Jack West
CARPE DM (79.45%)
None
Real Crime with Danny Lopez (79.06%)
Danny Lopez
The Wicked Weird Podcast (79.0%)
The Wicked Weird Podcast
Far Side Chats (78.48%)
Far Side Chats
The Great Detectives Present Ellery Queen (78.47%)
Adam Graham
Horrifying History (77.82%)
Horrifying History
Fuckin' Jersey (77.42%)
Jen Ponton
Bulldog Drummond (77.41%)
Entertainment Radio
Some Kind of Moment (77.05%)
Athoug, Adwa and Shahla
Jace Beleren Must Die (76.84%)
Roll20Network
Eternal Return Podcast (76.46%)
Eternal Return
VENGEFUL VEGAS: True Crime in Sin City (76.34%)
Vengeful Vegas Podcast
NightValeRadio (76.01%)
NightValeRadio
Casebook of Gregory Hood – The Great Detectives of Old Time Radio (75.4%)
Adam Graham
SunflowerRadio's Specials and Holidays (75.4%)
SunflowerRadio.com
The Binging Librarian (75.17%)
Christina Jo
Shared Pages (75.13%)
sharedpagespodcast
Fandible: Unhallowed Metropolis Actual Play (75.01%)
Fandible Podcast Network
News From Slothville (74.85%)
Sloan Love
When It's Convenient (74.84%)
Benjamin Graham
Mister Olsen Podcast (74.79%)
Mister Olsen
Creepy Life (74.69%)
Thomas And Sparkie
The Strange and Unusual Podcast (74.68%)
Alyson Horrocks | Morbid Network
GSMC Classics: The Adventures of Ellery Queen (74.68%)
GSMC Podcast Network
The Edge of Sanity (74.33%)
James Barraford
Feelings First Podcast (74.3%)
Feelings First
Realm46 (74.25%)
Realm46
Charnel.FM (74.23%)
Charnel.FM
Bizarre Tales (74.19%)
Bizarre Tales
P.W.C.A.: The Podcast Without a Cool Acronym (74.09%)
Chance Ellison
Turn Up The Volume (74.02%)
Chantia Murphy
Mystery Magnet (73.98%)
Joe Edwin
Gloom & Bloom (73.97%)
Christine Allen & Tayler Palfreyman
TubeFlash - Flash Fiction Inspired by London Underground (73.91%)
Joanna Sterling
Unsolved Mysteries (73.84%)
PubMe
Killer Country Podcast (73.83%)
Killer Country Podcast
Assorted Candies (73.83%)
Josh
It's a Strange World After All (73.71%)
Brit & Dee
Wannabe Heroes (73.67%)
Ally, Connor, Delaney, Jake, Jacques, Justin
Couples Skate (73.67%)
Emma Arnold and Pidge Robertson
Behind The Red Nose (73.62%)
Two Clowns
Blister and Muck (73.6%)
Jenny Mason
Drunken Gumshoes (73.55%)
PANELISM Network
Dick Tracy (73.51%)
Entertainment Radio
Mage the Awakening: Wards and Witchcraft (73.48%)
Wards and Witchcraft
Fictional Hangover (73.41%)
Fictional Hangover
Myths, Magic and Murder (73.24%)
Abbie & Katherine
Wisconsin Legends Podcast (73.2%)
Mike Huberty and Jeff Finup
Ding Dong Darkness Time (73.17%)
Allison Dickson
The Darker Side of Life Podcast (73.17%)
Kristen & Dana
Into the Night: A FNaF Podcast (73.11%)
Nick Black
Straight-Up Enigmas (73.09%)
Jaden McKell
Mile13 (73.09%)
Casper Van Oss
Evil and Eerie Podcast (73.04%)
Evil and Eerie Podcast
The Adventures of Elizabeth Crowne (73.04%)
The Adventures of Elizabeth Crowne
Castles & Cryptids (72.88%)
Alanna and Kelsey
Bitchcraft Podcast (72.83%)
None
White Girl Haunted (72.8%)
White Girl Haunted
Scary Mysteries (72.78%)
Scary Mysteries
GSMC Classics: The Lives of Harry Lime (72.75%)
GSMC Podcast Network
Horror Slumber Party (72.63%)
Horror Slumber Party
This One's A Doozy (72.58%)
Funner House Publishing
Deviant Little Darlings (72.54%)
Kate & O
BooZing Podcast (72.5%)
BoozingPodcast
The Gray Phantom by Herman Landon (72.48%)
Loyal Books
ClownTown (72.39%)
Aditya, Sidhant and Chris!!
It Happened to a Friend of a Friend (72.35%)
Megan and Sarah
Macabre London Podcast (72.32%)
Nikki Druce
IAMERICANIZED (72.3%)
Shafi Hossain
The Bison Crest Weekly Broadcast (72.3%)
A Rusty Hay Wagon Circus Films Production, Hank Kellerman, Pete Kellerman
Unexplained Realms (72.3%)
Unexplained Realms
Storytime with sammie (72.29%)
Sammie
Attention Horrors (72.29%)
Ring Rust Studios
Weird Distractions (72.22%)
Weird Distractions Podcast
Weird Distractions Podcast (72.21%)
Weird Distractions Podcast
Cryptids Across the Atlas (72.17%)
Cryptids Across the Atlas
Two Scared Siblings (72.09%)
twoscaredsiblings
Going To Bed Now (72.07%)
going to bed now
The Pretty Weird Podcast (72.04%)
Tatum Peggy Harris
Let's Talk with Joe Meyer (72.02%)
josephrmeyerwritings
Creepify (72.02%)
Creepify
The Other Side (71.99%)
Doug Fraser
Isn't It Past Your Bedtime? (71.8%)
Isn't It Past Your Bedtime?
That's Strange (71.73%)
Alex, Chad, and Ryan
Shoes Boos and Tattoos (71.71%)
Shoes Boos and Tattoos Podcast
Two Weirdos One Podcast (71.7%)
Megan Taylor / Ashley Kovacic
Frightful (71.69%)
Peter Laws
Silver Eye Society (71.66%)
Silver Eye Society
Reading Materials (71.66%)
Corrie and Lucia
One Weird Chick (71.66%)
Jessica Fernando
Culture Circus (71.63%)
Anne Donahue, Crystal Gibson and Jared Sales
N of Y (71.61%)
Trtales
Morbid Academy: A Podcast (71.6%)
Taylor Golub
The Metaphysician’s Electronic Journal (71.56%)
The Metaphysician
The Spooky Line (71.52%)
Kiara Precious