Underrated: Recent Episodes
Underrated Podcast
Caleigh and Tina advocate for things they find to be underrated! Some material may include blunt observations, cosmic energy, and sparkling dialogue from two of the most underrated girls on the scene.
This week, Caleigh and Tina dive into the underrated worlds revolving around their new favorite Elphaba, nearly changing majors in college, being kind in the holding room, people getting their day of reckoning and OF COURSE they briefly discuss the men that raised them, their fathers. Enjoy!!!
This week, Caleigh and Tina are discussing seeing Seth Meyers, adult acne, half marathon training, how close we are to Handmaid’s Tale, getting snappy in PetSmart, Wicked Trailer, if the Wicked book is pervy, Octomom, Kate Gosselin, the Senior Chop, Going Off the Grid, and MENTORS!!!
Caleigh and Tina talk: Impractical Jokers, celeb sightings, Dance Moms reunion, the JoJo Siwa of it all, Maria from the Bachelor, school projects, and more!
The girls are talking Allison William’s as Peter Pan in Peter Pan Live, Breaking Bad, Vanessa Hudgens, Bryan Cranston and Aaron Paul’s tequila biz, Tony Soprano’s Birth chart, Scorpio full moon, having a bitch attack, Team Edward or Team Jacob, Justin Bieber, being a brat, and MORE!
Mary Oliver said it first and we agree! The girls talk about having one wild and precious life, delicious weather and delicious drinks, older siblings vs. younger siblings, tax season, IS IT STUPID TO GET A BURGER SOMEWHERE, responding to everyone's Instagram stories after having one drink, and WHAT ARE YOUR MID TWENTIES AND WHAT IS THE CUT OFF??? Tina makes several embarrassing confessions...
Caleigh and Tina get INTO it! There are new segments even...Topics include: New York's two natural phenomena this week, kids telling it like it is (or not), movie ideas (DO NOT STEAL THEM), The Sopranos, what Caleigh's hairdresser thinks, Tina's sudden adult acne, the girls beating (or trying to beat) toxic thought patterns, and MORE!
This week, the girlinas visited queen Girlina herself, Drew Barrymore! They were in the live studio audience of her talk show and have many thoughts to share about the show and Drew in general!
We are a week out from the "real" Academy Awards; however, Caleigh and Tina are here today to bestow many honors upon many movies that are not being considered for the "real" Academy Awards. The UNDERRATED girlinas are always here to lift up the underdog, and awards season is no exception. Categories include: "Picture that made me want to run as fast as I could in a parking lot after I saw it", "Movie that made me wish my parents forced me to continue dance and sent me to a bunch of open calls when I was younger even though I would have refused", and so many more!
Caleigh and Tina dive into the new affirmation/ manifestation method that is sweeping TikTok: Lucky Girl Syndrome. They unpack the origin, meaning, and what they think about the trend. Tangents include Emily Webb, first periods, the Daytona 500, Orange Theory, and being bold in interviews.
Caleigh and Tina are here with a 2022 recap; highlighting personal and pop-culture moments (or the intersection in which pop-culture and personal merge, which is RHONJ because those girls are FAMILY to us)!
If you are a lukewarm fan, this is not the episode for you because Caleigh and Tina are serving up some PIPING HOT TAKES! The girls haven't been on the pod in a while, and have many grievances to get off their chest up top. Topics include: Tina's Instagram feud, the girls being scared they are haunted by a particular spirit haunting both of them, the girls inability to accept criticism unless it's from a teacher, and how the girls are making it through all these retrogrades going on. At the 30-minute mark the girls begin discussing being starstruck...they are giving juicy, never before heard information about, yes, CELEBRITIES.
After a 6 month hiatus the most UNDERRATED girlies on the scene are back and better than ever! Catch up with the girls as they grapple with 6 months worth of hypochondria, new job opportunities and dissect the family that is, The Real Housewives of New Jersey.
This week the girl's dive into the topic that is...Mark Ruffalo! AKA Hollywood's #15 leading man, AKA, The hulk, AKA She Hulk's boyfriend (?).... we cannot guarantee any accuracy for the information that we provide during this episode but nonetheless, enjoy!
This week Caleigh and Tina take it back to the early 2000’s and the songs that they find to be the most underrated. Other topics include, forgiving Vanessa Hudgens, The Blue Man Group and Jackass pranks! ENJOY!
Hello sweet listeners! Caleigh and Tina are here to tell you that it is ALRIGHT TO ALLOW YOURSELF A FLOP ERA. We all have em! This week Caleigh and Tina dive into the details of their flop era pasts and give helpful insights that may inform you that you are or currently have been in a flop era. Check it out!
With the start of 2022, Caleigh and Tina take a look back at the most UNDERRATED moments of 2021 ranging from their personal lives to pop culture today! There are so many things that happened this year that were SO wild and yet you still may have forgotten about them, so these girls are here to remind you. ENJOY!
HAPPY NEW YEAR! We are back and better than ever, which is saying a lot considering one of these girlies caught COVID. Like most people, Caleigh and Tina have been taken back into the world of Sex and the City and are loving it. This week the girls gab about the iconic series and give you their hot takes on each of the ladies at hand. ENJOY!
Joshua Bassett dropped 3 new songs this week and YOU KNOW we had to let you know what we thought! This week's episode feels like a dream (considering Caleigh and Tina woke up at the ass crack of dawn to record). Listen to us tackling the big issues on this ep and please ENJOY!
This week Caleigh and Tina pay tribute to the queen of the underrated aspect of NEVER GETTING OVER ANYTHING, Taylor Swift! Caleigh and Tina dive into how never getting over anything is the only way to live life and give you the inside scoop of circumstances that they’ve never forgotten.
This week Caleigh and Tina discuss the UNDERRATED universe of life’s everyday small victories. Sometimes it’s so easy to take the little wins in life for granted, luckily Caleigh and Tina take the time to highlight the simple things that leave them smiling! Take a listen and ENJOY!
This week Caleigh and Tina take on spooky season by diving into the most underrated Halloween movies! As usual, the girls stray from topic and give you the blunt observations and cosmic energy that you crave. Enjoy!
This week Caleigh and Tina highlight the most underrated inventions of all time, while also finding it absolutely impossible to picture these inventions coming to fruition during any period other than the 1800’s. Please take a listen as these modern pioneer women give the content that you CRAAAAAVE!
This week the girls are back and finally having a long overdue catch up as life has been absolutely CRAZY in the best of ways! Catching up with a friend can be highly underrated, so be sure to tune in and listen while the girls do exactly that!
The girls are back this week with guest Stephen Glickman! Take a listen to hear iconic stories from Stephen’s time on Big Time Rush and tune in to Caleigh as she lets the world finally know that she is…..a rusher! Enjoy!
Caleigh and Tina are on their VERY best behavior today as they welcome to the pod…STEPHEN KRAMER GLICKMAN! Stephen Kramer Glickman is an actor, comedian, musician, and podcast host who iconically played Gustavo Roque in the series Big Time Rush. He is here to discuss acting school, decorating your bathroom like a McDonald’s, being a ballsy bastard, advice Snoop Dogg bestowed upon him, and showbiz in general! We learn all about his audition for Big Time Rush and how he won over the room despite initially thinking he was completely wrong for the role of Gustavo! Part 2 coming soon!!!
This week the pod welcomes actress and singer Juliette Goglia!! Juliette is a Virgo queen who has been seen on Fired Up, That’s So Raven, The Michael J. Fox Show, Good Luck Charlie, 3 Lbs, and most notably, Garfield. Caleigh and Tina are so at home with this girlie because she is a confirmed HYPOCHONDRIAC! The girls have so much fun discussing Juliette’s lifelong acting career. Some stories include how Juliette: ultimately reminded Stanley Tucci what acting is, was CGI’d Marvel Style to play young Emma Stone, and convincingly saw God at 11 years old. We discuss this crazy business we call show business, and how to stay balanced and happy in the midst of the chaos.
This week, NYC based comedian Katie Boyle is on the pod to discuss being a woman in comedy! Katie dives into all of the underrated aspects of her work and shares MANY insightful observations from her time on the comedy scene.
This week Caleigh and Tina bring back an iconic topic….the UNDERRATED highs of life! These girls love the simple joys in the life and advocate for some of life’s most pure yet special moments. Other topics include, two topping pizzas, the devil’s grass and the art of haggling. Enjoy!
This week Caleigh and Tina discuss their favorite world, that being, the world of REALITY TV! The girls reminisce on reality tv’s most underrated moments and of course have laughs along the way. Other topics include, the rat population, name dropping and the Hell that is I84.
This week Caleigh and Tina celebrate their favorite time of year, Cancer Season, by taking a walk down memory lane and discussing their most underrated birthdays. Other topics including, having a UTI while performing Chekhov, self diagnosing on long car rides, mixing friend groups and so much more! Enjoy!
This week Caleigh and Tina discuss three people that take up a large amount of space in their brains, memories, and hearts. These 3 defined an ERA and a CULTURE! Take a listen and join us in reminiscing on some of the most underrated moments of pop icons Miley Cyrus, Demi Lovato and Selena Gomez.
This week Caleigh and Tina can’t keep their mouthes shut! The girls spend the first 40 minutes catching up and then absolutely DIVE INTO THE TOPIC AT HAND! Please take a good listen to this week’s ep as it is not only filled with laughs on laughs but also an honest discussion about growing and educating yourself while supporting your fellow girlies.
This week Caleigh and Tina dive into how UNDERRATED being basic is!!! Basic girls gays and theys, PLEASE UNITE and listen as we tackle topics such as, our iconically poor sound quality of weeks past, high school bullies staying lame and so much more!
This week Caleigh and Tina give you what you’ve been CRAVING....their thoughts on the most underrated tracks and lyrics on Olivia Rodrigo’s iconic debut album, Sour! Other topics include, the weather, splat points and the intoxication that is lavender/butterfly merch. Enjoy!
EMERGENCY MEETING We just couldn’t follow through with our break considering that the LEAST UNDERRATED girly on the scene has been absolutely blessing our ears lately. For this week’s quick little ep the girls just catch up and have absolute laughs all the while advocating for what makes Olivia Rodrigo underrated (even while being the next IT girl) and so much more. Enjoy!
Caleigh and Tina are BACK for part 2 with Quincy and Kevin! This week the quad takes a deep dive into the underrated Elphabas and Glindas that we know (or in Caleigh and Tina's case, may not know) and LOVE! Quincy and Kevin give a thorough and very necessary education to the girls and of course there are laughs on laughs had along the way! Enjoy!
This week Caleigh and Tina are on their absolute BEST behavior, because they have not one, but TWO guests on the pod this week! Quincy Brown and Kevin Bianchi of the podcast SENTIMENTAL MEN, join the girlies this week as they take a deep dive into the universe that is, UNDERRATED Elphabas and Glindas from the iconic musical WICKED. The boys advocate for their top underrated leading ladies, all the while educating Caleigh and Tina on any and all of the most talented women in this business that we call show! Enjoy!
This week Caleigh and Tina discuss the underrated performance of Jennifer Garner in 13 Going on 30! The girls dive into Jennifer’s unmatched artistry all the while tackling topics such as where all of your lymph nodes are located, “bad movies” that are honestly actually really GOOD and more!
This week, Caleigh and Tina are in the silliest little mood! The girls have an abundance of laughs in the beginning and then switch gears to talk about times Life Has Not Gone As They Planned it but that, weirdly, it does work out for the best! Other topics include: struggling with British dialect, Teresa Giudice, if the girls will be strict professors one day, and taking scissors to your own hair.
This week, Caleigh and Tina awoke at the crack of dawn to deliver what you all crave: the Glee covers the girls find to be Underrated!!! As former/ regrettable current Gleeks, the girls have a lot to say about which covers they find to be underrated, as well as the plots the songs revolved around. Other topics include: Tina's vaccination side effects, spelling your name like "V as in Victor" like how moms do, and being disrespectful toward the Royal Family.
This week, Caleigh and Tina dive deep into a juicy little subject: Celebrity Couples. The girls dish on who they find to be underrated celebrity couples and WHY. Other topics include: how it's annoying that Stanley Tucci isn't in Mamma Mia, the girls getting VACCINATED, and randomly waking up from surgery to a world full of music.
The girls are on the VERY best behavior as they welcome guest Molly Hagerty, known as @throughlymodernmolly on TikTok, known as a friend in our hearts! They all discuss the most underrated roles in musicals, getting extremely specific, but of course, have laughs along the way! Other topics include: the college audition process over ZOOM, sneaky benefits to insomnia, and making bold choices in audition attire!
This week, Caleigh and Tina discuss their own experiences with therapy, what they individually have gotten out of it, as well as mental health vibes in general. The girls also discuss men who think women can only be funny on accident, awkward reunions with feline friends, and Boston tea-partying a salad shop.
This week, Caleigh and Tina bring absolutely silly energy into the studio (their respective bedrooms where they record) as they recount pre-pandemic simple joys/ simple joys they are looking forward to returning to post-pandemic. The girls also discuss being left out in your neighborhood, Eskimo sisters, and a huge hypochondria reveal that makes the girls more similar than ever!!
This week, Caleigh and Tina discuss LEAVING AT THE RIGHT TIME! While discussing the topic, the girls discuss warning signs for a night out going astray, the value in going to bed at the right time, and the difference 10 minutes can make on an exit time. Other topics include sweaty kneecaps, perfectionism, and being in a good mood in March (weirdly)!
This week, Caleigh and Tina discuss the cultural phenomenon that is DISNEY CHANNEL ORIGINAL MOVIES! They delve into masterpieces such as Cheetah Girls, Cow Belles, Jump In, Princess Diaries, ICE PRINCESS, and more!!! While the girls have an absolute blast discussing these movies, they are not unaware of some plot holes in the movies and discuss those as well. Caleigh and Tina also discuss toxic positivity, understanding doctors, and secretaries being either really nice or really mean.
We had so many laughs with Chris that we had to split it into two episodes! In this part, we discuss how sometimes the right person shows you what you deserve, being unapologetic (while also hoping, HOPING that those we discuss do not listen to the pod), and FREEING BRITNEY!
The girls are on their VERY best behavior as they welcome CHRIS OLSEN to the pod! These three chat away about anything and everything, but specifically knowing their worth as individuals and in a relationship! Other topics include Tiktok algorithms, authenticity in what we do, theatre school, and we raise a very important question...can you be too little of a hypochondriac?
This week Caleigh and Tina take turns listing off the underrated highs of life. The girls draw you in, guided mediation style, as they describe some of their favorite feelings in the world. Join for the guided mediation vibes and stay for the laughs!! Other topics include: wanting to go to a CONCERT again, being present in your life, and powerful air conditioners.
Caleigh and Tina are on their best behavior because they have a GUEST! The girls have invited their dear friend Sam Rogers onto the pod to discuss TEAM JESS from Gilmore Girls. The debate about Team Jess is full of twists and turns, aggressive statements that do cross lines, and acknowledgements of each sides shortcomings. Other topics include having RBF (resting bitch face, of course), what do headaches MEAN, and the delicacy that is sleeping with your mouth open.
Caleigh and Tina bravely break their "one episode a week" structure to bring you a special report about an event that shook our world: "Skin" by Sabrina Carpenter. The girls knew they had to give everyone their take on this matter, which is why they came into the office on the weekend to bring you this powerful, albeit brief, episode.
This week Caleigh and Tina have tons of fun highlighting the female-owned small businesses that have participated in our giveaway (there's still time to enter)! We celebrate these wonderful women and their incredible businesses!! Other topics include: wondering if we would have been feminists in the Bridgerton era and inauguration reflections!
This week, the girls FINALLY have the opportunity to publicly discuss what they have been privately discussing for a week: DRIVERS LICENSE BY OLIVIA RODRIGO! Caleigh and Tina are simply smitten with this girl and her star power and songwriting ability. They delve into the crazy fact that they are much OLDER than Olivia Rodrigo, the backstory surrounding her song, and the future they see for Miss. Rodrigo. Other topics include: not taking a side in drama, lazy eyes, and shampoo that could ruin your life.
This week on Underrated, mum's the word...if you're British. If you're American (like these two girls) MOM'S THE WORD!! Caleigh and Tina delve into their favorite moms featured in TV and film. As two girls who love a maternal moment, this topic was near and dear to our hearts. Other topics include: the rapid decline of the American empire, how cool Caleigh's cat is, and ingrown toenails.
Hello sweet listeners! Tina and Caleigh are back after a little holiday break and they're here to offer their take on something truly underrated: the lost days between Christmas and New Year's. Of course, the girls stray from the topic and get a little existential and talk about lots of other things! Topics include cartoons that weirdly help the girls understand life, webcam selfies from 2013, and whether or not thermometers can be trusted.
Caleigh and Tina are on their best behavior today because they have a GUEST! Caroline Cianci, writer and comedian, joins the pod and, you guys, this is not one to miss. Caroline talks about her experience in comedy and has simply the most delightful, refreshing, and honest takes. In addition to her valuable advice, Caroline also shares a barrel of laughs with the girls, as she has embarrassing high school anecdotes about Caleigh!
These girls are back at it again! The episode begins with Tina saying the word " plateau" when she means "tableau" three different times, and it just gets crazier from there! Caleigh and Tina discuss Pauly D from the Jersey Shore franchise and why he is underrated compared to his co-stars! Other topics include: what reality show the girls would thrive on, a possible internship opportunity working for Caleigh, if Tina is destined to be a jester, misogyny in 2010, and our friend Sam's tonsils!
We know what you're thinking, guys...how could breakfast be underrated when it is ranked by Government Officials as the most important meal of the day? Caleigh and Tina feel that breakfast has been tragically underrated, and give you the scoop on their various breakfast philosophies. The girls discuss the ritual of breakfast, differing opinions on butter, and Bagelman (shoutout to the Greater Danbury area)! More topics include: Sarah Paulson, being bad at sewing, and why the girls are canceling Tina's sister.
Caleigh and Tina know that Thanksgiving looks a little different for a lot of people this year (they are nothing if not ASTUTE) so this week, they delve into their favorite Thanksgiving episodes of some cherished TV shows! If you are looking to boost your holiday spirit in these weird times, hopefully, these episodes can do the trick for you. Other highlights include Tina's perpetual paranoia that she has pink eye, Caleigh's defensiveness over Ross Geller, and the girls actually DISAGREE on a plotline of This Is Us!
This week Caleigh and Tina discuss HIGH SCHOOL SUMMER JOBS, which actually ends up being a conversation about summer jobs in general. The girls discuss the highlights of their money-making days, and emphasize how a paycheck of $200 at the age of 17 leaves you ultimately feeling nothing short of on top of the world!
This week, Caleigh and Tina talk about something near and dear to their hearts: the iconic minor role! The girls discuss instances in which actors have randomly gone 200% for a small role, as well as instances in which the girls themselves have done the same! Other topics include: buttered popcorn, Reba, and Caleigh's run-in with the full moon!
This week, Caleigh and Tina discuss a super difficult topic and that is LOVING YOUR BODY! The girls discuss insecurities (because we all have them) and ways of showing our body a little bit of love because no matter what shape, color or size you are, YOU ARE BEAUTIFUL.
This week, Caleigh and Tina take a trip down memory lane to the most UNDERRATED year of high school...JUNIOR YEAR! The girls discuss their experiences at high school football games, the iconic HALO awards, and how each of their graduating classes contained approximately 5 people! Please listen, subscribe, and enjoy lil friends!
This week, The Big Three (Caleigh, Tina, and Rocky) discuss how UNDERRATED Improv Comedy is! All you little actors better take a listen because this could help YOU, yes YOU, with your craft! Rocky explains to us how she got her start on the comedy scene and how she loves to be a WOMAN in COMEDY and of course the gals share laughs all along the way!
This week, Caleigh and Tina woke up at the actual ass crack of dawn to discuss what's UNDERRATED about being the oldest (Caleigh) and youngest (Tina) cousins in their families while also trying to figure out the perks (if any) of being the middle cousin! Because if you aren't the oldest and you're not the youngest, ultimately, that makes you middle! AND THAT'S OKAY! We don't judge!!!!! Enjoy!!!
Caleigh and Tina have the absolute time of their lives unpacking The Mamma Mia! universe. They disagree about Mamma Mia! creative choices exactly two times, which is the ideal amount of times to disagree on a podcast! The girls tackle the real questions (who is really the dad??) and have laughs on laughs on laughs!
Caleigh and Tina welcome their first BEAUTIFUL guest, Miss. Jillian Caillouette! Jill talks about mediation and its benefits, as well as how you can get started on your meditation journey. She speaks about mediation in such a gorgeous and non-intimidating way that Caleigh and Tina feel inspired to try. The three girls also chat about Jill's debut album, Phases, streaming everywhere now!
Caleigh and Tina discuss Frankie Grande, the uncertainty of the universe, taking pictures of their tonsils, and ASTROLOGY! As two proud Cancers, this subject is near and dear to their hearts. Do they get off-topic a bunch? Oh, for sure. But isn't that why you're here??
Caleigh and Tina have fun laughs and good times as they create a perfect first episode. Chili's Bar and Grill is the queen of our heart and the king of our tummies! We celebrate them every day, but especially today because they are UNDERRATED!!!