Catholic Studies Academy Podcast: Recent Episodes
Jason Gale
A great discussion on the need to recover classical education and the true liberal arts with Dr. Benjamin Smith and Mr. Joseph Grossheim.
Dr. Bulzacchelli speaks with canonist Tyler Ross about ecumenical dialogue and how to do it well. Mr. Ross shares his recent experiences with public discussions with a Protestant pastor on topics of dispute between Protestants and Catholics.
In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Dr. Smith and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss the meaning and history of the various political alignments, including "left" "right", "center right," etc. Once this terminology is defined the various alignmentsare evaluated in the light of Catholic theology. This episode is helpful for those Catholics (and others) confused by contemporary political labels. Topics:The French RevolutionLiberalismConservatismRevolutionary politicsSubsidiarityAnti-clericalismThe Enlightenment For more political philosophy from a Thomist, solidarism, and corporatist perspective visit: https://logosletter2022.substack.com/
In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Dr. Bulzacchelli and Dr. Smith discuss current political events from a Catholic perspective. The discussion focuses especially on presidential politics, the rule of law, the administrative state, and the politics of abortion. The conversation bypasses the usual shallow polemics and engages the deeper trends and underlying ideas of current events. Topics include:Abortion and gradualismThe Well-formed Catholic conscience, The managerial revolutionThe deep stateBiden's mental declineCover ups and the rule of law#managerial_revolution, #abortion, #election_2024Explore the intersection of politics and philosophy with Dr. Smith here: https://logosletter2022.substack.com/For an in-depth Thomistic critique of modern politics consider purchasing Dr. Smith's book: https://www.amazon.com/Understanding-Modern-Political-Ideas-Christians/dp/B08M2BKBR1/ref=sr_1_1?crid=MHO38G2CLHZ0&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.jkvuF_6ZCTrArsAOtdDPtY5KVZZH_EVaHSGtmtxiJ6FluO6Ho2gftfXQTf-_uhu8ODua7IwTbGSX8LNBlUec5nAN36Whisbjsnt37PoO2zSqXNxpI_Ti2DauhVg4rHXR5yzYVhU4lKDbmCMvclXNfBLeuUjphzqoWnR2oHU1BVvn86f808u31ereJmDdbIwbGSv_VCVs2NDeBihOzrDTbiEtkuzLJvB4j5-uJegkO70.852QKpSE3UCU2FANZWZa7CQo2lhJt8eHItOED6o6WZk&dib_tag=se&keywords=understanding+modern+political+ideas&qid=1723905217&sprefix=understanding+modern+political+ideas%2Caps%2C139&sr=8-1
Dr. Bulzacchelli and Dr. Smith discuss "pastoral theology".Can pastoral theology be intellectually rigorous?What distinguishes "pastoral theology" from speculative theology and other subdisciplines in theology?Is there a danger of too sharply dichotomizing between these two theological projects?How does pastoral theology overlap with non-theological disciplines, like sociology, psychology, economics, cultural studies, and so on?What does the landscape of pastoral theology look like today? What are the biggest issues for effectively ministering to the Church, and spreading the Gospel, in our time and culture?Support us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/user?u=496536...Purchase courses: https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/#pastoral_theology, #liturgy, #holy_mass
In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Dr. Smith and Dr. Bulzacchelli explore the unique character and ethos of medieval philosophy. The discussion focuses on distinguishing characteristics, the decline of the Roman empire, the intersection of faith and reason, and especially the enduring value of medieval philosophical thought. Join in, subscribe, and share with others! Topics:The Fall of the Roman EmpireThe Carolingian Renaissance The Catholic ChurchMetaphysicsFaith and ReasonCivilization theoryThis discussion is based on a forthcoming essay over at logosletter2022.substack.com.
The Liberal Arts and the Renewal of Western CivilizationDescription:#liberalarts, #Western_civilization, #Classical_EducationHave you ever heard of the liberal arts? Maybe when you were applying for college? But you probably don't know that the liberal arts are at the heart of western civilization? In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Dr. Smith explores the history, meaning, and value of the liberal arts. This is a great opportunity to reflect on the role of education in shaping the world around us. Listen. Learn theology. Explore philosophy. Topics include:The decline of educationCitizenshipThe liberal artsPostmodernism and deconstructionThe spirit of Western CivilizationFor more great philosophical content check out Dr. Smith's Logos Letter: https://logosletter2022.substack.com/. For a Thomistic critique of modern political ideas, see Dr. Smith' book, Understanding Modern Political Ideas: https://www.amazon.com/Understanding-...
Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger was a leading churchman and one of the greatest Catholic theologians of the 20th century. In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Dr. Bulzacchelli leads us on a guided tour of Ratzinger's classic text, Introduction to Christianity. In this discussion, we explore the problems of presenting Christian faith in the contemporary world, Ratzinger's dialectical engagement with existentialism, freedom, Vatican II, theology and culture, and much more. You will not want to miss this episode. Topics include:ExistentialismPostmodernismJean Paul SartreMartin Heidegger FreedomGod and Modern IndifferenceTheological Enculturation For more great philosophical content check out Dr. Smith's Logos Letter: https://logosletter2022.substack.com/. For a Thomistic critique of modern political ideas, see Dr. Smith' book, Understanding Modern Political Ideas: https://www.amazon.com/Understanding-Modern-Political-Ideas-Christians/dp/B08M2BKBR1
We live in interesting times --- for better or worse. Confusion and anxiety are the hallmarks of the age. In this episode, our contributors discuss and critique the key cultural, political, and philosophical developments of 2023. The discussion covers divergent views on natalism, the sexula revolution, political power, the decline of liberalism, and so much more. Join us as we continue to explore the Catholic intellectual tradition, classical philosophy, and the world around us. Topics Include:Natalism, the culture of death, the culture of lifeAbortion and politicsPolitical powerHigher educationThe common goodThe failure of liberalism#sexual_revolution, #2023, #Abortion
Dr. Bulzacchelli speaks with canonist Tyler Ross about the matrimony in the Catholic Church today from the perspective of canon law. Topics include:AnnulmentMixed marriagesImpediments and Defects in attempted marriages
Are you confused and frustrated by current cultural trends? You are in good company. America and Europe are experiencing an unprecedented period of self-destruction. What is going on!? This episode is wide-ranging romp through the philosophical flotsam of our current cultural crisis. And we are featuring a new guest: Mr. Whit Smith --- entrepreneur, music producer, and Catholic provocateur. If you want to understand what is going on, this is the podcast for you. Listen, subscribe, and share. Topics include: PostmodernismThe EnlightenmentUtilitarianismScientismCovid-19 https://www.patreon.com/user?u=49653668#postmodernism, #zeitgeist, #hedonism
Famously Aristotle claims that being ("reality") is primarily said of substance and claims that substance is the basic, foundational, unity of reality. In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Dr. Smith and Mr. Grossheim (Ph.D. student in Philosophy) explain how substance is discovered through a methodical analysis of change, which culminates in the insight that real composites are always composed of form and matter, that is, that substance cannot be reduced to a more basic kind of reality. Listen, enjoy, share, and subscribe!
Topics include: Substance and accidents Matter, form, and privation Reductionism and ancient atomism Plato and the separate forms Form-matter composition Design in nature
In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Dr. Smith explores the connection between God and politics in the thought of Thomas Aquinas. Specifically, Smith explains the hierarchical connect of God to natural law and law to God. This connection lays the basis for a naturalistic, theistic politics that is also consistent with divine law. If you are interested in the debates about politics and religion this is the episode for you. Please listen, like, and subscribe.
Topics include: Law, Authority, and the Common Good Eternal law Natural law Divine law Integralism and the Confessional State
Catholics rightly hold out their own Catholic Intellectual Tradition as an alternative to contemporary errors and aberrations. But just what is the Catholic Intellectual Tradition? What distinguishes it as a specific way of thinking about the world and man? Does it consistent primarily in learning a particular content, or is it a method? Dr. Bulzacchelli and Dr. Smith take up these question in the newest episode of Take Every Thought Captive. Enjoy, subscribe, and like. Topics include: · Defining questions of Catholic thought · The relationship between thought, tradition, and community · The historical character of Catholic thought · Change and Catholicism · Engaging with other traditions · Balancing the past and the present For more great theology and philosophy, purchase CSA courses and become a regular reader and subscriber to Logos Letter.
Many Catholics feel like they are constantly under siege from a hostile culture. We seem to lurch from one crisis or controversy to another. Even worse, local churches seem to be in permanent decline. What are the intellectual, cultural, and spiritual reasons for the current state of the church? How should we respond? Dr. Bulzacchelli and Dr. Smith address these questions in this episode of Take Every Thought Captive. A thoughtful and sober discussion. Listen, share, and subscribe. Topics include: Pope FrancisNeo-PelagianismEarly ChristianityAncient PhilosophyDionysian hedonism Christian realismSin, Grace, and HopeCheck out philosophy and theology courses available from Catholic Studies Academy: https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/shop-courses/ For more great philosophical content from Dr. Smith subscribe for free to Logosletter2022: https://logosletter2022.substack.com/
In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Dr. Bulzacchelli leads a discussion on the intersection of globalism, nationalism, and Catholic faith. This conversation was occasioned by Pope Francis's recent remarks on the subject. His Holiness suggested that Catholics should affirm both roots and bridges. What should Catholics do to affirm national and religious roots? And how should "rootedness" be balanced with building bridges to others. This is an in depth conversation that touches on the foundations of political community, natural law, and international relations. Topics include:National populismGlobalismIdeological ColonizationPope Francis and International RelationsThe Common GoodDiverse structures of international organizationInternational law and immigrationFor more in depth content on political philosophy visit: https://logosletter2022.substack.com/
In modern political discourse, authoritarianism is often denounced but rarely defined or understood. In this exploratory discussion, Dr. Smith and Dr. Bulzacchelli consider the meaning and possible legitimacy of authoritarianism. The discussion focuses on ideas taken from Plato, including the paradoxical claim that doing whatever you feel like is not really freedom. This exploration pushes the limits of political legitimacy and raises important questions about the limits and meaning freedom, the individual, obedience, and corruptio. Other topics include: Authentic freedom The real goodPlato and the rule of wisdomThe common goodCurfew and Sabbath restGod and the natural lawAmerican decline
A recent study published by the Wall Street Journal and the University of Chicago found that traditional American values are in steep decline. Specifically, Americans were found to value patriotism, children, and religion to a far lesser degree than previous generations. In fact, the only value that has increased is the putative importance of money. In this episode of Take Every Thought captive Dr. Smith and Dr. Bulzaccelli are joined by special guests Bob Gorman ( a scholar of international relations) and Joseph Grossheim (graduate student at the Center for Thomistic Studies). Topics discussed include: the causes of decline, hedonism and technology, abuses of elite power, distorted views of happiness, diversity, and possible solutions. This is a rich discussion that touches on many important points of political philosophy, geopolitics, and theological anthropology.
In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Dr. Bulzacchelli interviews Dr. Smith about his recent edition of Logosletter entitled, "Should we Desire Riches: The Forgotten Vice of Greed." This is a wide-ranging and detailed discussion that covers the meaning of ownership, the foundations of private property, and the spiritual effects of a disordered desire for riches. The discussion concludes with ideas about avoiding greed. Following the view of Thomas Aquinas, Dr. Smith argues that an unqualified and limitless is in fact vicious and undermines both the virtue and just community.Topics include:CommunismThe foundations of private propertyComparison of John Locke and Thomas Aquinas Errors regarding property, distribution, and povertyThe connection of greed to the other vicesStewardshipFor more great philosophical content from Dr. Smith check out catholicstudiesacdemy.com and subscribe to Logoletter2022 (it's free).
This week, Dr. Smith interviews special guest, Joan Watson, about the Chosen. In recent years, Joan has become a well known speaker and writer and much of her work directly interacts with the smash tv series The Chosen. If you want to engage the Chosen from a Catholic and Biblical perspective, you are going to love this episode. We discuss criticisms of the Chosen, major themes, discernment, and so much more. We hope you enjoy!Topics:Theological objections to imagesThe uses and dangers of imagesChristian artBiblical interpretationChristian discernmentThe scandal of the Incarnation
Why do conservatives revile higher education? Is there any way for conservatives and higher education to reconcile? In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Dr. Smith addresses the open hostility between conservatives and higher education. He discusses conservative anti-intellectual attitudes, the "woke left," and the nature of higher education. Along the way Dr. Smith develops an Aristotelian-Thomist argument for the abiding significance of higher education for conservatives. Topics include:The nature of educationThe importance of higher educationHuman natureThe meaning of conservatismThe classical virtue of pietyFor more great content from Dr. Smith, check out logoletter2022.substack.com.#highereducation, #conservatism, #thewokeleft
In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Dr. Smith interviews special guest Mr. Phillip Berns, ABD graduate student at the Center for Thomistic Studies. Mr. Berns' research focuses on the intersection of economics and Aristotelian philosophy. This is a serious exploration of the nature of economics, the scientific character of economic theory, and the morality of economic action. Frequent contributor, Mr. Joseph Grossheim (MA philosophy, ABD) also joins in the discussion. Topics include:The meaning of economicsThe place of economics in Aristotelian philosophyThe relative autonomy or subordination of economicsThe connection of economics to the political common goodJust economyEconomics and the philosophy of the human person
In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Dr. Bulzacchelli explores the historical origins and major theological themes of Advent and Christmas. The discussion centers on the development of the liturgy and the ways in which these liturgical seasons help us to encounter Christ. The discussion concludes with suggestions for better ways to celebrate these important seasons. Historical originsLiturgical developmentThe intersection of personal devotion and liturgyThe eschatological themes of AdventThe historical-redemptive significance of ChristmasHow to get the most out of Advent and Christmas
In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Dr. Smith explores the modes of thought that have led us to our contemporary crisis in culture and elucidates five Thomistic principles for recovering an authentic sense of reality. Dr. Smith discusses the reliability of human reason, the errors of postmodernism, and the proper understanding of nature. This is a crucial and important episode that you do not want to miss!Topics include:Postmodernism, scientism, and existentialismThe reliability of human cognitionThe meaning of truthThe reality of natureNature acts for end
In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Dr. Smith and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss the recent US elections using the political categories developed by Aristotle, including aristocracy, oligarchy, democracy, republicanism, etc. Dr. Smith defends the view that American politics features a broad middle-class, focused on the household defending itself from domination by oligarchs and revolution and redistribution by the "dispossessed." Topics:What is democracy?How do democracy and oligarchy differ?Why is the middle-class the predominant class in a republic?The distinguishing values of oligarchy, democracy, and republicanismImmigrationThe future of American politicsFor more great content from Dr. Smith visit: https://logosletter2022.substack.com/
Perhaps the most notorious statement in the history of philosophy is Friedrich Nietzsche's claim that "God is Dead." In this episode of "Take Every Thought Captive," Dr. Smith and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss the death of God, the rise of unbelief, and the sources of unbelief identified by Nietzsche. Ironically, Nietzsche turns out to be a useful resource for Christians, because of his keen understanding of the causes of unbelief. The conversation wraps up with a brief discussion of Dr. Smith's newest project, Logos Letter. In this new publication, Dr. Smith explores the history of philosophy, culture, politics, faith, and everything else. Subscribe for free here: https://logosletter2022.substack.com/. Topics include:The meaning of the death of GodThe four causes of unbeliefChristian responses to the death of GodThe parable of the madmanFinally, follow Dr. Smith on Twitter: @logosletter2022.
In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive Dr. Smith and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss the sixtieth anniversary of the Second Vatican Council. The conversation focuses on the continuity of the Council with the prior Catholic tradition. Through this interpretive lense, a taxonomy of approaches to Catholic faith is developed. It is hoped that this discussion will contribute to a better understanding of the Second Vatican Council and the current state of the church. Topics include:Hermeneutic of Rupture vs. the Hermeneutic of ContinuityTraditionalism, Conservatism, and ProgressivismCollegiality and Papal InfallibilityThe Universal Call to HolinessThe Limitations of Vatican IThe Catholic Faith in the Modern WorldFor more great content from Dr. Smith on philosophy, faith, politics, and culture, check out Logos Letter: https://logosletter2022.substack.com/
In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Dr. Bulzacchelli and Dr. Smith explore the idea of Christian monarchy. Smith and Bulzacchelli critique false misconceptions of Christian monarchy, and discuss some features that have made this form of government attractive to Christiians over the centuries. This discussion is an excellent opportunity for rethinking our assumptions about democracy and the best form (for forms) of government. Topics include: - The divine right of kings - Absolutism and constitutional monarchy - Tradition, custom, and inheritance - The familial roots of monarchy - Piety, politics, and regime structures And much, much more
In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss Hegel's view of freedom. We cover: - Kantian freedom: freedom of rational (universal and consistent) decision making - Kantian freedom + mutual recognition - Our self-recognition is only verified by the mutual recognition of someone else - But the "other" is a problem - Freedom and the end of history is a social and cultural achievement - Freedom is found in the ethical and the ethical is obedience to the rational state Watch our previous episode on the influence of Hegel and his philosophy of history - https://youtu.be/cdslgvTLFqY
In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Dr. Bulzacchelli and Dr. Smith explore the metaphysical structure of transubstantiation. The launch point for this discussion is the treatment developed by Saint Thomas Aquinas in the Summa Theologiae. If you have ever wanted to gain more insight into the meaning and ontology of the Eucharist this is a great opportunity for you.
ST III.75 Natural place and time vs. sacramental place and time The reality of the accidents The relation of the Eucharist to Christ's risen and glorified body The connection of the Eucharist to redemptive history
In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Jason and Dr. Benjamin Smith discuss the topic of freedom. We cover: - William of Ockham and historical context - Servias Pinckaers on rivaling views of freedom - Freedom for Excellence vs Freedom of Indifference/License - Freedom and the Good - The Nature of the will - Reason and will - The role of virtue - The role of the law - Authentic Freedom and the cultural crisis today
In this episode, Dr. Bulzacchelli and canonist, Tyler Ross discuss the theological and canonical issues surrounding the ban of Nancy Pelosi from Holy Communion. We cover: - The issue - Is this excommunication? - Types of excommunications - Mortal Sin and Excommunication - Canon 915 and 916 - The relationship of ethics and politics - Conditions – obstinate, manifest, and gravity (serious) - Scandal - Bad Commentary out there - Clarity on the issue and the implications - Difficult practicalities
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss the current debate over abortion, the Dobbs case, and the elements of the culture war. We cover: - The Dobbs Case - The reaction to the Dobbs case - The culture behind abortion - Elements of the Abortion Worldview - History and the Narrative - Lifestyle - Eschatology
In this episode, Dr. Smith and Jason discuss the influence of Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel. We cover: - Hegel's place in history - Hegel's idea of history history: human experience changes - Progress: achievement, inadequacy, new stage of consciousness - Trajectory of history and Geist - Omega point of history: the fully adequate realization of consciousness
In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Dr. Smith and Mr. Joe Grossheim discuss the Thomist theory of human dignity, including Thomas Aquinas's controversial claim that human dignity can be lost. We also explore whether human dignity can serve as the foundation of ethics. This discussion is inspired by the recent debates surrounding Alisdair MacIntyre's critical comments regarding human dignity last year. Topics include:
- Personalism, JP2, and Human dignity
- The meaning of human dignity
- The loss of human dignity
- The true foundational principles of ethics
- The Primacy of the common good
- The psychology of human action
Related episode on the common good: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tT5V-wkrAKs For more political and ethical analysis purchase Dr. Smith's book Understanding Modern Political Ideas: https://www.amazon.com/Understanding-Modern-Political-Ideas-Christians/dp/B08M2BKBR1/ref=tmm_pap_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&qid=&sr=
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss 4 modern objections to Christianity and how to combat them. We cover: - Relativism - Pluralism - Scientism - Neo-Marxism
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss his upcoming course in philosophy covering 20th century philosophy. We cover: - The end of Idealism - Husserl and Phenomenology - Neo-Marxism - Heidegger - Existentialism - Logical Positivism - Post-modernism and more
In this episode, Dr. Bulzacchelli, Dr. Smith, and Jason discuss the current crises we are experiencing in the world, the Church, and seemingly everywhere we turn. We take a 30,000 foot view of the current culture underlying the crises. We cover: - Diagnosing the problem - We cannot think rationally - Reactionary thinking - Public reasoning for public reasoning - Decline of public reasoning - Truncation of reason to scientism - Atheism – the view of the person - Human suffering - A New Dogmatism and a new magisterium
In episode 116, Jason and Dr. Smith welcome special guest, Joe Grossheim to discuss a classical saying, "Nature Acts for an End." We cover: - Why this is an important question - Aristotle and the Physics Book II - What is Nature? - Art and Nature - Necessity and Chance - Intelligence and chance - Nature, ends, and ethics
https://www.newadvent.org/summa/2001.htm#article2
Go to: https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/shop-courses/ and use code: csasoundcloud to get any course for $25! shhhhhhh...don't tell anyone!
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith welcome special guest, Joe Grossheim to discuss a classical saying, "Nature Acts for an End." We cover: - Why this is an important question - Aristotle and the Physics Book II - What is Nature? - Art and Nature - Necessity and Chance - Intelligence and chance - Nature, ends, and ethics
In this episode, Dr. Smith and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss Aquinas' 4th Way to understand the existence of God. We cover: - Reading the 4th Way - The uniqueness of this argument - Gradation and degree - The metaphysical foundation
The 4th Way - "The fourth way is taken from the gradation to be found in things. Among beings there are some more and some less good, true, noble and the like. But "more" and "less" are predicated of different things, according as they resemble in their different ways something which is the maximum, as a thing is said to be hotter according as it more nearly resembles that which is hottest; so that there is something which is truest, something best, something noblest and, consequently, something which is uttermost being; for those things that are greatest in truth are greatest in being, as it is written in Metaph. ii. Now the maximum in any genus is the cause of all in that genus; as fire, which is the maximum heat, is the cause of all hot things. Therefore there must also be something which is to all beings the cause of their being, goodness, and every other perfection; and this we call God." - https://www.newadvent.org/summa/1002.htm
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the topic of predestination in the writings of St. Thomas Aquinas. We cover:
Principles of Predestination - God is the cause of every perfection, including the good of order to an end (means and end) - Providence is God’s plan for the good of order - Providence presupposes the intention/ will of God - Everything subject to God’s infallible providence - The gravity of sin and the necessity of grace
Providence rightly attributed to God - Argument from universal and infallible providence – order to supernatural end - Argument from grace and supernatural order - God reprobates some
Two Objections 23.5 ad3. Seems unjust 23.5 ad3. Why not everyone? Two answers
Humility and dependence on God
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the difficult but important topic of Divine Providence from the writings of St. Thomas Aquinas. We cover: - Principle of Causality - First and Second Causes - Important Corollaries - What is subject to God's Providence - Providence and Evil - Does God cause Evil? - Does Providence negate Free Will?
Read Summa I, ques. 22 - https://www.newadvent.org/summa/1022.htm
In this episode of Take Every Thought Captive, Dr. Smith and Dr. Bulzaccelli discuss the role that Christians should play in the political sphere. What kinds of policies should Chrsitians support? What are the obligations of the Christian to the state? How is the political community related to the kingdom of God? These and other questions are addressed in this deep dive discussion. We cover: - Eschatology, Christian faith, and politics - The dangers of utopianism - The Bible, moral law, and political community - Religious liberty, abortion, and private property - The value of limited government etc.
For more political commentary from Dr. Smith purchase his book, Understanding Modern Political Ideas. In this book, Smith examines modern political ideas in the light of classical political philosophy and Christian anthology. It can be purchase here: https://www.amazon.com/Understanding-Modern-Political-Ideas-Christians/dp/B08M2BKBR1/ref=sr_1_2?dchild=1&keywords=understanding+modern+political+ideas&qid=1630792561&s=books&sr=1-2
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss lessons to be learned from the trial and death of Socrates. We cover: - Historical background - Transition to democracy from Aristocracy - The Sophists, rhetoric, and relativism - The Socratic method. - The importance of asking questions - The Trial - Philosophy helps the city - Is there a tension between politics and philosophy?
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the necessity of philosophy. We cover: - Socrates "The unexamined life is not worth living." - What does philosophy do for the human person? - Ultimate questions - The big three categories - Place of Science - Where do I begin? - Do I love wisdom or do i want to be foolish?
In this episode, Dr. Richard Bulzacchelli and Canonist, Tyler Ross discuss the liturgy as was envisioned by the documents of the Second Vatican Council. We cover: - Traditiones Custodes - Preservation of Latin and Use of Vernacular - Girl Altar boys - The placement of the altar - ad orientum and versus populum - and much more
In this episode, Dr. Smith and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss many different aspects of death. We cover: - The ancient view of death - Life after death in ancient philosophy? - The Stoics - Greeks, Romans, and Manicheans - Energies and Pseudo-science - Christianity - Worship a God who is not part of the cosmos - Heidegger and Christianity
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss serious issues around the youth and belief. We cover: - relation-based youth ministry and the problem that people already don't believe - is relation based ministry still possible? - Trust someone or the message? - Secular view of reality – objective and subjective approaches - Ways forward for adolescents
In this episode, Dr. Bulzacchelli and Dr. Smith discuss freedom as the founder's intended. We cover: - The Declaration of Independence - Influence of the English Philosophers - The Monarchy - Progressives’ concept of freedom - If we are going to defend American freedom, we need to get it right! - Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of happiness - Private property - Scottish Commonsense Realism and Thomas Reed - Self-Evidence under attack
Buy Dr. Smith's Book on Political Philosophy - https://www.amazon.com/Understanding-Modern-Political-Ideas-Christians/dp/B08M2BKBR1/ref=sr_1_6?dchild=1&keywords=benjamin+smith+political&qid=1624971760&sr=8-6
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss rival points of view of happiness. We cover: - Aristotle's idea of happiness - The Stoic's view of happiness - Christianity's view of happiness - Eternal life - Happiness in Sacred Scripture - John 17:3, Proverbs 3:13-18, Col 3:1-17, Phil 3:8-11
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss Steve Skojec's article, Rod Dreher's response, and the issue of clericalism. We cover: - Steve Skojec's article - https://skojecfile.steveskojec.com/p/against-crippled-religion - Rod Dreher's response - https://www.theamericanconservative.com/dreher/catholicism-steve-skojec-has-had-enough/ - Marginalization and persecution of orthodox Catholics - "Mere Catholics" - Clericalism - Ecclesiological issues
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith talk about happiness from a philosophical perspective. We cover: - Trying to define happiness - Happiness, Actions, Ends, and Goods - An end desired for its own sake - Imperfect vs perfect ends - External goods and virtue - A desirable life
ThomasAquinas
AristotleEthics
Happiness
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the importance of natural theology. We cover: - Natural Theology hesitancy among Christians - Defining our terms - From Effects to Causes - Common objections - "Ontotheology" - Causal relation transcends genus of effects
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss a pertinent topic for Holy Week. Why did Christ have to Die? We cover: - St. Thomas and the Summa - Was it "necessary"? - What are the effects of Christ's Passion and Death? - The exaltation of Christ
Summa Tertia Pars, Question 46 - https://www.newadvent.org/summa/4046.htm Summa Tertia Pars, Question 49 -https://www.newadvent.org/summa/4049.htm#article3
In our 100th episode, Jason, Dr. Smith and Dr. Bulzacchelli talk about the importance of faith and how they deepen their own faith. - What is faith and why it is important - The importance of deepening your faith - Good guides - Who have been our guides in our faith.
In this episode, Dr. Bulzacchelli and Tyler Ross finish their discussion on Pope Francis’ Moto Propio allowing women into the ministries of acolyte and lector. We cover: - Ministry vs Orders - “Deaconesses” in the Bible - “Venerable Tradition” - Pope Francis’ Moto Propio – Spiritus Domini - http://www.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/motu_proprio/documents/papa-francesco-motu-proprio-20210110_spiritus-domini.html - The Ministry of Acolytes and Lectors
In this episode, Dr. Bulzacchelli and special guest, Tyler Ross, canon lawyer for the diocese of Knoxville continue their discussion on the minor orders. We cover: - Pope Paul VI Moto Propio of 1973 disbanding the minor orders - Clerical and lay state - Ministries and Minor Orders - Are the minor orders of acolyte and lector different from the ministries of acolyte and lector - Sacramentals
Pope Paul VI’s Moto Propio – Ministeria quaedam, August 15,1972 - http://www.vatican.va/content/paul-vi/la/motu_proprio/documents/hf_p-vi_motu-proprio_19720815_ministeria-quaedam.html
In this episode, Dr. Bulzacchelli is joined by special guest, Tyler Ross, canon lawyer for the Diocese of Knoxville to discuss issues around the minor orders and Pope Francis' decision to allow women to be installed as acolytes and lectors. We cover: - the importance of canon law - minor and major orders - Canonical changes - "ordered" toward what - Men and Orders
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss how find your identity according to St. Thomas Aquinas. We cover: - Why we need to understand ourselves - The problem with modern self-help - The Myth of Self and Introspection - Classical Realism - St. Thomas Aquinas on the Intellect - Knowing and loving external objects - The Paradox of Christianity
Question 87 of Summa Prima Pars - https://www.newadvent.org/summa/1087.htm
Join Dr. Smith for a 3-Part Seminar on Modern Political Ideas. If you cannot make the times, do not worry. We will send you the video and audio links.
https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/product/modern-political-ideas-a-3-part-seminar/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss the issue of communion in the Catholic Church. We cover: - The origins of division - The need for communion - 3 Aspects of Communion - "Extra Ecclesiam nulla salus" - Outside the Church with valid faith and Sacraments - Reduction to the juridical - Importance of all three
From: Robert Bellarmine, De Contraversiis I.3.ii.
Full citation: https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/episode-95-robert-bellarmine-communion/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss some dispositions we should have going into 2021 and what Catholic wisdom and classical philosophy can offer us. We cover: - State of Affairs - Clarity - Ultimate End - Well Ordered Soul - Allegory of the Caves - Healthy Skepticism - Healthy Stoicism - Avoiding Anxiety
catholicstudiesacademy.com
In this episode, Dr. Bulzacchelli and Dr. Smith are joined by our special guest, Joseph Grossheim, a doctoral student in philosophy at the University of St. Thomas’ Thomistic Institute to discuss Conservatism in political philosophy. We cover: - A reaction to what? - Defining conservatism - Custom, Natural Law, Tradition - Liberalism and Tradition - Epistemological considerations - Have conservatives been successful? - Conservative problems with Progressives - Decentralization - Unity, Political Order, and the Common Good
Get a Copy of Dr. Smith's Book - https://www.amazon.com/Understanding-Modern-Political-Ideas-Christians-ebook/dp/B08M99QP5B/ref=sr_1_2?dchild=1&keywords=benjamin+smith+book&qid=1609152062&sr=8-2
In this episode, Dr. Bulzacchelli and Dr. Smith are joined by our special guest, Joseph Grossheim, a doctoral student in philosophy at the University of St. Thomas’ Thomistic Institute to discuss Progressivism in political philosophy. We cover: - The need for the study of political philosophy - Defining Progressivism - Progress toward what? - Maximize aggregate satisfaction vs common good - Progressivism vs Libertarian - Utilitarianism and Progressivism - “As equal as possible” Get a copy of Dr. Smith's book - https://www.amazon.com/Understanding-Modern-Political-Ideas-Christians-ebook/dp/B08M99QP5B/ref=sr_1_2?dchild=1&keywords=benjamin+smith+book&qid=1609152062&sr=8-2
Jason and Dr. Smith continue their discussion on the false idea of "true self". We cover: - Undefined consciousness - The "true self" vs the "false self" - Writings of Richard Rohr - Centering Prayer - Buddhist and Hindu influences - Correct way of understanding of the self
Richard Rohr's Article - https://cac.org/themes/true-self-separate-self/ https://cac.org/true-self-separate-self-weekly-summary-2020-09-05/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the erroneous and modern idea of "self." We cover: - The pervasiveness of "self" - Philosophical foundations - Descartes and Kant - Undefined consciousness - Arguments against the idea of "self"
Read a sample of Dr. Smith's new book - https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/books/
The Myth of Self articles - https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/the-myth-of-self-3/
Podcast on Kant - https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/episode-69-understand-the-modern-mind/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the topic of divine providence in relation to difficult and uncertain times. We cover: - God as First Cause - Summa Prima Pars, Question 22 - God in history - The Patience of the Martyrs - Eschatological Reality - Providence gives us duties
Read Summa Prima Pars, Question 22 - https://www.newadvent.org/summa/1022.htm
Purchase Dr. Smith's NEW book on Political Philosophy - https://www.amazon.com/Understanding-Modern-Political-Ideas-Christians/dp/B08M2BKBR1/ref=sr_1_3?crid=233LODR81XH90&dchild=1&keywords=benjamin+smith+book&qid=1605709015&sprefix=benjamin+smith+%2Caps%2C656&sr=8-3
In this episode, Dr. Bulzacchelli, Dr. Smith and special guest, Dcn. Bob Gorman, Emeritus Professor of Political Science, discuss Dr. Smith's new book, Understanding Modern Political Ideas: A Guidebook for Christians and Other Patriots. In this episode we cover: - Post Modernism and Nature - Reason and Tradition - The Common Good and the Individual Good - Flourishing, Happiness, and Perfection - "The political community perfects man." - Temporal Goods - "Incommensurability of ideas"
Buy Dr. Smith's Book - https://www.amazon.com/Understanding-Modern-Political-Ideas-Christians/dp/B08M2BKBR1/ref=sr_1_1?dchild=1&keywords=benjamin+smith+political&qid=1604948572&sr=8-1
We discuss Dr. Benjamin Smiths new book!
In Understanding Modern Political Ideas, Dr. Benjamin Smith defines and critically evaluates the major political ideologies of the modern period in the light of classical political thought. Drawing on the insights of Thomas Aquinas, Aristotle, Plato, and others, Smith highlights the failures and shortcomings of modern political thought, including the pretensions and fallacies of progressivism, Marxism, and neo-Marxism. In contrast to these ideologies, Smith develops an alternative approach that emphasizes the common good, local community, and personal virtue. Understanding Modern Political Ideas presents a vision of politics rooted in a classical and Christian understanding of the human person.
Get your copy today! - https://www.amazon.com/Understanding-Modern-Political-Ideas-Christians/dp/B08M2BKBR1/ref=sr_1_7?dchild=1&keywords=benjamin+smith+understanding+political+ideas&qid=1603908929&sr=8-7
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith finish their series on Marxism. We cover: - Marx's view of the fulfillment of history - The evolution of conscience - Three critiques of Marxism - Flawed Anthropology - Reduction of the Human Person to Social Relationship - The role of work - Subordination of everything to politics - Political Correctness
In this episode, Jason an Dr. Smith continue their discussion on Marxism. We cover: - Review of Hegel's view history - Marx and culture - The dialectic - Capitalism as a necessary stage - Marx's critique of capitalism - Revolt of the Proletariat
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss Marxism. We cover: - The resurgence of Marxism - The historical context of Karl Marx - Kant and Idealism - Hegelian view of history - The "Geist" - The materialism of Marxism - Freedom in the thought of Marx
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith continue their discussion of the natural law. We cover: - Natural Law known in degrees - Must be cultivated - Do Good, Avoid Evil - Responsibilities derived from Natural Law - Private Property - Eternal Law, Divine Law, Human Law in relation to Natural Moral Law
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss natural law. We cover: - Christianity and Natural law - Legacy of natural law - Basic position - Known by all but to different degree - Two Hypothesis and evidence - Bonum honestum - Three ways to find bonum honestum - Natural end and supernatural end
"When Gentiles, who do not possess the law, do instinctively what the law requires, these, though not having the law, are a law to themselves. They show that what the law requires is written on their hearts, to which their own conscience also bears witness; and their conflicting thoughts will accuse or perhaps excuse them." - Romans 2:14-16
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss how Pope St, John Paul II stood in the breach in many different ways. We cover: - The historical context - The breach in philosophical approaches - Personalism and Phenomenology - The breach of Vatican II - The breach of secular regimes - The world is different
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the ideas ad influence of David Hume. We cover: - The period of Modern Philosophy - Who was David Hume - The influence of Hume on other philosophers - Newton and Hume - Hume's Epistemology - Impressions and Ideas - The Copy Principle - The Problem of Causation
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss his new course on Modern Philosophy. We cover: - Time period - What led to 'modern' philosophy - Historical context - Effects of Scientific Revolution - Man's ability to Reason - Autonomy and Freedom - Decline of religious authority - Overconfidence in Man's abilities
Click here to support the work of Catholic Studies Academy -https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/donate-to-csa/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the intricacies of the Principle of Double Effect. We cover:
- Review of the sources of morality
- The 4 rules of the Principle of Double Effect
- Independent consequences and actions
- Foreseeable bad consequences
- Proportionality
- Several Examples of applying PDE
- Seriousness of judging human actions
Support the work of CSA - https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/donate-to-csa/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the judgment of human actions according to St. Thomas. We cover: - Human actions vs Acts of man - The contribution of St.Thomas - Proximate end - The sources of morality - Everything contained in the object - Foreseeable, unintended consequences
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss some distortions of hope or misrepresentations of hope. We cover:
- The rival of Christian Hope according to Pope Benedict XVI
- "Exiles in the desert"
- Progress and Enlightenment philosophy
- Bacon and Marx
- The Object and Means of Hope
- Modern Hope vs Christian Hope
In this episode, we use these two books: 1. Cardinal Ratzinger, Christianity and the Crisis of Culture -https://www.amazon.com/Christianity-Crisis-Cultures-Pope-Benedict/dp/1586171429/ref=sr_1_6?dchild=1&keywords=crisis+of+culture&qid=1586909575&sr=8-6 2. Spe Salvi - http://www.vatican.va/content/benedict-xvi/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_ben-xvi_enc_20071130_spe-salvi.html
Donate to the work of Catholic Studies Academy - catholicstudiesacademy.com/donate-to-csa/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss different aspects of hope. We cover: - The idea of hope - The passion of hope according to St. Thomas - The object of kinds of hope - Natural hope - The Virtue of Hope vs Passion of Hope - What hope does for the Christian - Ordering life according to hope
Donate to the work of Catholic Studies Academy - https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/donate-to-csa/
In this episode, Drs. Smith and Bulzacchelli wrap up their series on the capital sins. We cover: - Propensity to wrath and justified anger - Proportionality - Modern Entitlement and wrath - Forgiveness, pain, and wrath - Forms of sloth - The importance of fortitude in all of life - Why sloth is deadly - Priorities and sloth - Pride and morality - Pride and the ultimate end
Click here to donate to the work of Catholic Studies Academy - https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/donate-to-csa/
In this episode, Drs. Smith and Bulzacchelli discuss envy and vanity. They cover: 1. The place of envy in the list 2. Envy in the Parables 3. St Thomas and envy – habit of grieving over the good of another 4. Being Conscious of sins 5. Detraction 6. Vanity and praise 7. Whose opinion matters? 8. Vanity and Modernity
Mentioned in this podcast - Max Scheler’s Book “Ressentiment” https://www.amazon.com/Ressentiment-Marquette-Studies-Philosophy-Scheler/dp/0874626021/ref=sr_1_2?keywords=max+scheler&qid=1584980701&sr=8-2
In this episode, Dr. Smith and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss three of the seven capital sins: greed, gluttony, and lust. They cover:
- The origins of the list of capital sins
- Capital sins as natural vices
- Sins against the proper desire of the good
- Greed: Possession
- What really is enough?
- Gluttony: Consumption
- Habitual excess and the good
- Lust: a sense of possession and a sense of consumption
- The contrary virtue of lust
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss Lent and lenten practices and most importantly, the legitimacy of the Impossible Burger during Lent. We cover: - The meaning of "lentare" - Doing more or doing less? - The example of the monks - Book recommendations for Lent - The Impossible Burger
Dr. Bulzacchelli's article on Lent - https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/what-should-i-do-for-lent/
Click here to support the work of CSA – catholicstudiesacademy.com/donate-to-csa/
In this solocast, Dr. Smith discusses 5 philosophical and practical principles to guide life. He covers: 5 Principles for Practical Living - Philosophy is a way of life - Augustine, Christianity, and Philosophy - The Interior Life - 1. Do not react - 2. Do not judge - 3. Attend to yourself - 4. Attend to the present - 5. Accept all from God
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss what is called Post Post-Modernism or "Po-Po-Mo". We cover: - Kant and Modernism - Post Modernism - Social Constructs and Objectivity - Privileged Discourse - Post Post Modernism - Critiques of Po-Po-Mo Click Here to view the diagram used in the podcast - https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/episode-69-understand-the-modern-mind/
Click here to support the work of CSA - https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/donate-to-csa/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss Sir Roger Scruton (1944-2020), a conservative political Philosopher and author of the book, "The Uses of Pessimism". We cover: - Legacy of Roger Scruton - Three Principles of Pessimism - Pessimism and Optimism - The "Best Case Fallacy" - The "Born Free Fallacy" - The "Utopian Fallacy"
Roger Scruton "The Uses of Pessimism" - https://www.amazon.com/Uses-Pessimism-Danger-False-Hope-ebook/dp/B0048EKUFY/ref=sr_1_5?keywords=pessimism&qid=1579719169&sr=8-5
Click here to support the work of CSA - https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/donate-to-csa/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss the topic of his upcoming course on the Trinity. We cover: - The difficulty of the task - The term 'Father' and other male language - The difference between 'that' and 'how' - The Foundation of the Trinity - Three-Personal Relationship with God - The difference between solving the mystery and pondering a mystery - The vital importance of a good understanding for the rest of theology - The Trinity, Salvation, and Communion - The Trinity and Baptism
Support the work of Catholic Studies Academy - https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/donate-to-csa/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss the feast days of Epiphany and Baptism of the Lord. We cover: - Christmas, Epiphany, Baptism of the Lord - The Magi - The Star - God uses the Star - Eschatological considerations to these feast days
Mentioned in this podcast: CCC 528 - The Epiphany is the manifestation of Jesus as Messiah of Israel, Son of God and Savior of the world. The great feast of Epiphany celebrates the adoration of Jesus by the wise men (magi) from the East, together with his baptism in the Jordan and the wedding feast at Cana in Galilee.
Click here to support CSA - catholicstudiesacademy.com/donate-to-csa/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith wrap up their conversation on 'The Great Divorce'.
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith continue their discussion on C.S. Lewis' masterpiece 'The Great Divorce'.
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss C.S. Lewis' classic work, The Great Divorce.
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the idea of virtue and the soldier. We cover: - An application of the primacy of the common good - What is a soldier - Is it good to be a soldier - Combat and lethal force - The virtues of a soldier - Patriotism - The defense of the common good as a act of justice - Soft Christians - The spiritual analogy of a soldier
Click here to support CSA - https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/donate-to-csa/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the third principle or the primacy of the common good. We cover: - Review of first two principles - Man is naturally political - The political community is the 'perfect' community - The common good is a higher good than individual goods - The common good is not the multitude of individual goods - Common good is unique kind of good. - Primacy of the common good
Click Here to Support CSA - https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/donate-to-csa/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss what the classics have to offer us with regards to political wisdom. We cover: - Political wisdom is not political science - Man is naturally political - Politics has a natural end, therefore it cannot change - Political community is "perfect" - Some errors in political thought
Support the work of Catholic Studies Academy by donating - https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/donate-to-csa/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss St. Thomas' 2nd way of demonstrating God's existence. We cover: - We live in a changing world - Secondary or intermediary causes - The Efficient Cause - Absurd positions against this way - Sequential order vs outside of order - Wholly other Cause
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith continue their discussion on the Problem of Knowledge and discuss the topic of Classical Realism. We cover: - Overcoming errors to truth - Epistemology - Defining Classical Realism - Dialectic Refutation vs Proof - Truth exists - We can know the truth - We can trust our senses - First Principles
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss issues surrounding the attainment of knowledge. We cover: - What is knowledge? - What is epistemology? - "How do you know that?" - Questions regarding "justification" of belief - Skepticism - Whether truth should be defined in terms of coherence rather than correspondence? - Whether knowledge should be defined by utility rather than truth?
Donate to CSA and help us continue our work - https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/donate-to-csa/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the classical distinction between nature and grace. We cover: - Modern challenges to the classical distinction - What is nature/natural - Isn't everything from God? - The interaction of grace with nature - Real distinction - To Heal and Elevate - Potency and Act
Click Here to support CSA - https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/donate-to-csa/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the reality of human evil and the cultural disregard for it. We cover: - The denial or diminishing of the reality or gravity of human evil - Erroneous Arguments - Catholic Responses - Flatly against scripture - Original sin - Concupiscence - The reality of bad men, sinners
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss Modernism and Anthropocentrism in Catechesis throughout the 20th century. We cover: - The philosophical underpinnings of Modernism - The influence of Kant - What is Modernism? - Condemnation of certain positions in catechesis - Divine Revelation in Catechesis - The Theology of Revelation of Gabriel Moran - Moran's further influence on catechetical methodolgy - Experiential Catechesis - A Faithful Catechesis
Help us create more content like this by donating to CSA - https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/donate-to-csa/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the idea of Universals and trace its development in Medieval thought. We cover: - Plato and the Idea of Universals - Universals and Particulars - Christians and universals - How do we access universals? - St. Thomas and knowledge - The Franciscan development - Ockham and Nominalism - "Social Constructs" - The Importance of Medieval Philosophy
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss salvation and the idea that all men might be saved. We cover: - Hans Urs Von Balthasar and Bishop Barron - Strict Universalism - Scriptural Passages pointing to universalism and damnation - "Reasonable" Hope - Constant teaching of the Church - What should be our disposition as Catholics?
Dr. Smith and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss the legacy of John Paul II and in particular his moral theology. In this episode we cover:
- The philosophical project of JP II
- The gift of self in married love
- The unique value of moral theology
- The role of moral theology in understanding Christian marriage
- The legacy of JP II in the arena of moral theology
- Contemporary errors undermining Catholic moral theology within and outside of church
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss knowledge and God. Sometimes people speak of heart knowledge and head knowledge, but what is this really? We discuss: - Knowledge and relationship - Knowledge and emotions - Love and knowledge - Doctrine as God revealing himself to us - Simplicity and doctrine - The will and the intellect - The intellect is ordered to truth and relationship
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss the issues of celibacy and married priests, We discuss: - Celibacy in Sacred Scripture - Permanent diaconate and Sacred Scripture - Paul to Timothy about bishops - "One woman man" - Church as bride - Understanding celibacy and marriage - Marriage is about the Eschaton - Josephite Marriages - The Holy Family as the Exemplar Family - How we imitate the Holy Family
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith continue their discussion on Metaphysics talking about the aspect of purpose and how it is found in being. We discuss: - Reality, being, and meaning - "Adulting" - Parts and arrangement of reality - Design in nature - Why deny natural purposes - Nature acts toward an end - Overwhelming evidence - reductio ad absurdum - Ordering of reason toward truth - Truth, pride, money and sex
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the importance of metaphysics and the connection of being to truth, beauty, and goodness. We discuss: - What is metaphysics - First Causes and the question of 'Why?' - What is being - Meaning and purpose - "Think for yourself" - A philosophy forged in hell - Science and power - Essence and Existence - Loneliness and Meaning - The existential burden of defining yourself
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss the Jewish Festival of Shavuot and the Christian feast of Pentecost. We discuss: - What is the Festival of Shavuot? - The idea of gift - The Torah as gift - Gift and Reception - Waiting and replacing Judas - Stone and Flesh - Tongues of Fire - Shavuot and the Church - Tower of Babel - The Holy Spirit and the Torah - The constitution of a people - The refusal of Pentecost
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith continue their discussion on authenticity, this time addressing Goodness. We discuss: - Authentic Goodness and Ethics - "Shared Ethical Discourse" - Lost Vocabulary - Emotivism - Goodness tied to Reality - Goodness is a form of Being - Goodness and Desire - Nature of Man and Goodness - Pleasure and the Good
Mentioned in this episode: - "After Virtue" By Alastair McIntyre - https://www.amazon.com/After-Virtue-Study-Moral-Theory/dp/0268035040/ref=sr_1_1?keywords=after+virtue&qid=1559744168&s=gateway&sr=8-1
In this episode, we discuss authentic truth and the philosophical implications of truth lying in reality. We talk about: - The dictatorship of relativism - Feelings and Reality - Like beauty, truth lies in reality - Relativism's view of truth - Unicorns, Badgers, and the Mind - The world is organized and knowable - The alternative to truth is illusion
Take Every Thought Captive - 2 Cor 10:4-5 "The weapons we fight with are not the weapons of the world. On the contrary, they have divine power to demolish strongholds. We demolish arguments and every pretension that sets itself up against the knowledge of God, and we take captive every thought to make it obedient to Christ."
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith talk about what makes up authentic beauty. We discuss: - Is beauty in the eye of the beholder? - St. Thomas on Beauty - Beauty and Goodness - Beauty, Form, and Reality - St. Thomas' 3 characteristics of beauty - Beauty and Truth - Beauty without Truth and Goodness - The intellect and beauty
In this episode, Jason, Dr. Bulzacchelli, and Dr. Smith talk about the meaning of Easter Joy. We discuss: - Is Easter joy sentimentalism? - The Eschataological Lens of the Christian - The Kingdom of God and wrong ways to think about it - Easter brings order - Metaphysical considerations - Matter and spirit - How to live this practically
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss technology and several different aspects of how it affects us. we discuss: - “We become what we behold. We shape our tools, and thereafter our tools shape us.” ― Marshall McLuhan, Author of "The Medium is the Message" - The issue of immediacy - Constant stimulation - Communication and Technology - Vanity and Envy - Duplicity of Persons - Disembodied character of technology - St. Joseph the Worker
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the topics of the cross and the Resurrection within the Catholic intellectual tradition. We discuss: - Why the cross? - St. Thomas on Satisfaction - St. Anselm's Theory of Satisfaction - Mercy and Justice - Penal Substitution Theory - The Resurrection - The importance of the Ascension - Keeping up your prayer and study habits during Easter Season
In this episode, Dr. Benjamin Smith and Jason discuss a paper presented by Jason at the 8th Annual Symposium on Advancing the New Evangelization at Benedictine College in Kansas. We discuss: - Cardinal Ratzinger's "eclipse of the sense of God" - Technology and the Human Person - Social Media - The subjectification of reality - The need for Metaphysical Realism - Realism and the nature of things - Realism and Contemplation - The Primacy of the Creed - On the Creed, "the faith which it professes is reality, not merely the content of Christian consciousness." (Schonborn and Ratzinger, Christoph and Joseph. Introduction to the Catechism of the Catholic Church. San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1994, 30.)
-Dr. Jean Twenge's book iGen - https://www.amazon.com/iGen-Trends-Shaping-Todays-People/dp/B073XS9RXH/ref=sr_1_2?keywords=igen&qid=1555597937&s=gateway&sr=8-2
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss a paper recently presented by Dr. Smith at the American Maritain Association on the topic of the common good. We discuss: - St. Thomas Aquinas and the Common Good - Acquired Actual Happiness - Utilitarian Error - Statist Error - Egalitarian Error - Theological Error
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Bulzacchelli talk about Christology and its primacy within the other disciplines of theology. We discuss: - The early Church and the Christological Controversies - Christology and the Sacraments - Christology and Salvation - Christology and Ecclesiology - Christ and John 6 - Christology and the Eucharist - Christology and Eschatology
Check out Dr. Bulzacchelli's new course - https://catholicstudiesacademy.com/courses/christology/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss Lent and some historical considerations. We discuss: - Early origins of Lent - Fasting and Abstinence - What the word Lent actually means - The idea of "doing something extra" for Lent - The importance of sacrifice during Lent - Simplicity in our Lenten offerings
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss our society's confusion of different kinds of love. In order to evangelize people and the culture, we need to restore a proper understanding of love. We discuss: - Passionate Love - Human Love - Love is not primarily a feeling (passion) - Love is an act of the will - Discussion of the good in relation to the love - Discipline and Love - Brief discussion of the friendship and love
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the problem of confusion and understanding and how Aristotle's 4 Causes can help us avoid confusion. we discuss: - understanding has to judgments - judgments have to to do with reality - Plato asking 'what?' and 'why?' - Aristotle's 4 causes with examples - 4 Causes lead to 4 questions - how asking theses questions dispels confusion and leads to understanding
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss St. Thomas' treatment of the passions. We discuss: - what are the passions - where do the passions lie - how the passions motivate - desire and the passions - love and desire - "Emotional Intelligence" - being intelligent about our emotions - Estimations and choices
In this episode, Jason talks with Dr. Allison Low about her embrace of the Catholic faith and her work in evangelization. We discuss: - Dr. Low's full embrace of her Catholic Faith - The relationship of studying the faith and loving God - Her experience with St. Paul's Street Evangelization - She gives 4 tips for every evangelist - The importance of writing, evangelizing, and teaching - Baptismal call to be holy and hand on the faith
Dr. Low's work can be found at: www.catholicstand.com http://www.pillarandfoundation.com/ and we also discuss http://streetevangelization.com/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Bulzacchelli talk with Lyle about Courage International. Lyle is the chapter leader for Courage in Nashville, TN. We discuss: - What is Courage - What are the 5 principles of Courage - What is shame and what do we do with it - What is Encourage - What separates Courage from other "ministries" - What is "acceptance" mean - Chastity and Freedom - What are some resources offered by Courage - What is the difference between celibacy and chastity
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the claim that is made even by some Christians that they do not need philosophy or that philosophy is useless if you have the Word of God. We discuss: - the role of philosophy in theology - what is faith - the elements of faith - what philosophy has to offer us - the limitations of philosophy with regard to faith - the usefulness of philosophy - faith seeking understanding
In this episode, Jason, Dr. Bulzacchelli, and Dr. Smith discuss the sin of detraction and the 10 Commandments. We discuss: - What is detraction? - Why it is important today - Detraction and Truth - Downplaying the 10 Commandments - Distinction of 10 Commandments and Levitical laws - Misconceptions about the old law and the new law - Detraction and some "what if" scenarios
We mention the following article - https://relevantmagazine.com/god/why-do-christians-want-to-post-the-10-commandments-and-not-the-sermon-on-the-mount/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the importance of intellectual development and fitting this into your New Year's resolutions. We discuss: - Physical Health and Intellectual Health - Practical Suggestions on setting up a development plan - The need for philosophy and theology - Intellectual Dieting - Philosophical reading suggestions - The need for silence
In this episode, Jason interviews Fr. George Elliott, a priest of the Diocese of Tyler who recently published a book entitled, Discernment Dos and Don'ts: A Practical Guide to Vocational Discernment. We discuss: - What is a vocation - The importance to discern properly - Holiness as a a vocation for all - God's Timing vs our timing - Objectively vs Subjectively Better Vocations - A Tour of Fr. Elliott's book
Find at TAN Books: https://www.tanbooks.com/index.php/discernment-do-s-and-don-ts-a-practical-guide-to-vocational-discernment.html
Find on Amazon: http://a.co/d/i2zStQN
Connect with Fr. George Elliott: http://catholiccastmedia.com/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the relevance of ancient philosophy, one of the new courses available at catholicstudiesacademy.com. We discuss:
- What is ancient philosophy
- The context of the rise of philosophy
- Ancient relativism
- Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle
- The Sophists and the importance of reality
- The Stoics
- Plato's Theory of the Forms
- Philosophy as a way of life
- The modern relevance of ancient philosophy
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss some principles of Catholic economics. In particular, we look at communism and capitalism from an American perspective. We cover:
- Communism
- Right to Private Property and its limitations
- Capitalism
- Pope Leo XIII's Rerum Novarum
- Rights of workers
- Rights of employers
- Just wage
- The need for virtue in economics
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the crisis in education while reexamining the classical approach to education. We discuss: - Aristotle's view and goal of education - Habits and Virtues - Order - The importance of intellectual virtues - The Quadrivium - The Trivium and logic - The importance of logic in thinking clearly - The virtuous logician - Examining modern approaches to education
In this second episode on justice, Jason and Dr. Smith finish discussing the distinctions of justice as laid out by St. Thomas and the topic of capital punishment. We discuss: - Brief definition and overview of previous episode on the first two distinctions in justice - What is commutative justice (part-part) - Equal Exchange - Natural and Acquired rights - Acts opposed to commutative justice - Just punishment - Restoration of justice and retribution - A just punishment is a good act - Capital punishment - Are there crimes that could justify capital punishment?
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss justice primarily in terms of politics and ethics. We cover: - Defining justice - The division of relationships within justice - Political justice (part-whole) - Service to the common good - Obedience to legitimate authority - Distributive justice (whole-part) - Genuine need and merit
In this episode, Jason talks to Joan Watson, Director of Adult Faith Formation (AFF) for the Diocese of Nashville, on the topic of Adult Faith Formation. In this episode, we discuss: - The primacy of adult faith formation in the Church's understanding of ministry - The goal of AFF - Formation for mission - The principle of subsidiarity in faith formation - How parishes can get started - Gradualness in formation - Primacy of the study of Sacred Scripture - Need for systematic formation
Check out Joan's work at: joanmwatson.com and 3minutetheology.com
In this episode, Dr. Smith and John Carswell discuss the philosophical and theological themes of J. R. R. Tolkien's Lord of the Rings and related writings. Mr. Carswell is the creator and host of The Tolkien Road, a weekly podcast on the writings of Tolkien. The podcasts and John's other writings can be found at truemyths.org. John is an expert on the writings of Tolkien and graduated from Belmont University with a Master of Arts degree in Literature. In this episode we discuss:
- The nature of evil
- The void, possibility, the soul, autonomy
- Pride, domination, and the temptation of power
- Pre-Christian insights and values
- Hope, despair, and humility
- Creativity, artistic creation, and beauty
- Art as "sub-creation"
- Christian art
http://tolkienroad.com/
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss the idea and defining characteristics of post-modern man. We discuss: - historical placement of modern and post-modern man - the idea that society structures everything - social constructions - reality as interpretation - metanarratives - how post-modern man views the human person - how post modern man views the world - points of contact for the Christian and post-modern man
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss a topic covered in Dr. Smith's course on the Philosophy of the Human Person, namely, the will and human freedom. In Thomistic philosophy freedom must always be attached to what is good. Freedom is not the ability to choose whatever we want. We discuss: - how sense perception informs the person - freedom involves both the intellect and the will - how the intellect works - how the will works - we give multiple examples of how freedom must be attached to the good - how choosing the good leads to more freedom - the erroneous idea of shear possibilities is authentic freedom
Jason and Dr. Smith continue their discussion about God's Providence and the Problem of Evil. We discuss: - Bearing the Cross as part of being Christian - Passive purification/mortification - The false prosperity gospel - The compatibility of secular idea of autonomy and Christianity - The fact and implications of living in a fallen world - Suffering as punishment
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss one of the most difficult topics of not just Christianity but human life as a whole. How can an all good God exist and there be senseless suffering. We cover: - Fundamental questions concerning the topic - Does God Cause evil? - Why does God allow evil? - The Aggregate Explanation - The Free Will Defense - The Soul Making Explanation - The role of evil in God's Providence - The example of Job
In this episode, Dr. Smith and Jason explore Plato's classical text, The Republic. We cover: - Is it better to live justly or unjustly? - Glacoun's argument for an unjust society - Plato's definition of justice and why justice is good - The guardians of a just society - The Philosopher-King and the modern politician - The Allegory of the Cave and Modern Society
In this episode, Dr. Smith, Dr. Bulzacchelli, and Jason Gale discuss the issues regarding problematic catechesis particularly in the late 20th century. We cover: - A century of movements - Anthropocentric turn in catechesis - A problematic view of revelation - Problematic methodology
Christian faith has been declining for decades, but its influence and appeal has fallen remarkably in recent years. Indeed, it appears that the faithful are simply disappearing.
The central, undeniable truth about modern Christianity is that it has turned decisively from away from a Biblical, God-centered worldview, and in its place has constructed an anthropocentric form of Christian humanism that prioritizes human suffering, human satisfaction, and human dignity. In this worldview man is given the first place in reality. In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith discuss this anthropocentric turn in Christianity and specifically how the creator/creature relationship can serve as fundamental to a Catholic worldview.
- Anthropocentricism
- Creator-creature relationship
- The image of God as distinct from God
- Divine justice
- The reality of 'Man as a sinner' in relationship to the perfection of God
- Humility and the virtue of religion
- Creator/creature relationship in evangelization
In this episode, Jason and Dr. Smith talk about the importance of natural theology and what it has to offer sacred theology. We discuss:
-How does natural theology operate? What is its function? -Demonstrating the existence of God -Rational certainty or at least reasonable/ probable affirmation -Principle of causality and secondary causes -the natural world does not explain itself sufficiently -Implications - Immutable, Incorporeal, Eternal - God is omnicausal, omnipotent, omniscient -Benefits: (a) supports Christian worldview; (b) aids our learning about God; (c) resources for contemplation
Either human sexuality is left "to the arbitrary will of man" or God has given it a design and it must be respected. In this episode Jason and Dr. Bulzacchelli discuss the document itself. We cover: -The competency of the Magisterium to make such a declaration -The "principle of totality" -Fidelity to God's design -The decision to abstain from the marital act -The moral difference between a contraceptive mentality used with licit means of avoiding birth compared to using artificial contraception for grave/serious reasons -An appropriate use of science -The family apostolate and witness of married couples
In episode 4 of Take Every Thought Captive, we discuss the greatness of St. Thomas Aquinas and why he is especially relevant today. In his clarity and rigorous logic, St. Thomas gives the Church and the world reasons for belief in God and natural law. We talk about: Why St. Thomas is a good guide to intellectual formation Dr. Smith, as a student of St. Thomas Why St. Thomas is one of the most sound and reliable guides for Catholics Natural Theology The Existence of God Natural Moral Law St. Thomas as a teacher Healing power of teaching How to begin to study St. Thomas
In this episode, Dr. Benjamin Smith and Jason Gale discuss Joseph Pieper's Book, "Leisure: The Basis of Culture". They discuss the importance of this little book in our current cultural setting. Authentic leisure cannot be reduced to entertainment or those things we "do for fun", but as Pieper points out, is something that involves the soul and leads to contemplation. Leisure is higher than work because it has no use. It is for its own sake and helps build the culture because leisure opens the soul to reality. Examples of leisure are learning, worship, and building friendships. Our current culture tries to redefine or self-define reality which actually closes them off to the truth of the way things are, but authentic leisure has a humble openness to reality as it is and thus builds up the person to be more human as he is made in the image and likeness of God.
Join Jason Gale, L.Div. and Dr. Benjamin L. Smith as we introduce the Catholic Studies Academy. We also dive into why it is important for Catholics to study theology and philosophy in a systematic way.