Scary But True
Tyler Saylor
Podcasts Similar to Scary But True
Creeped Out (97.92%)
Iam Chambers
The One With Darkness (97.85%)
Phillip Shaw
Samantha Scary (97.75%)
Samantha Scary
From Beyond The Crypt Podcast (97.56%)
From Beyond The Crypt Podcast
Creepy Sensei (97.28%)
Creepy Sensei
Freaky Attractions (97.08%)
freakyattractions
Marsh Lights (97.08%)
Richard Morgan
I Scream, You Meme (97.08%)
Ben and JD
5KULL F4CE Horror Stories (96.94%)
5KULL F4CE
HorrorWhispers PodCast (96.87%)
Horror Whispers
Good Nightmares (96.84%)
Horrocane
Donny Giles' Scared Sh!tless (96.8%)
Donny Giles
Creepypasta Storytelling (96.7%)
Ethan Wyche
MNL MND FCK (96.7%)
MNL MND FCK
CREEPYPASTA - True scary horror stories & paranormal podcast - Thread horror (96.53%)
Alexandre Lougnon
Scary Bad Writing (96.47%)
Liam Thistlethwaite
The Horror Planet (96.22%)
Em
Deadly Discussion (95.85%)
Deadly Discussion
Lucid Dreaming (95.83%)
Taiga
No Name-The Dark Web Serial Killer (95.68%)
Chris Sherron
Campfire Stories (95.63%)
Zurik
The Arcane Horrors Of TheFearlessOmniest (95.51%)
Jonathan Bogdan
Miss Hex - The Home of Horror Stories (95.42%)
Miss Hex - The Home of Horror Stories
Dark Aura (95.39%)
KB
We're figuring it out (95.33%)
wifo
waffles yea (95.13%)
Anna Coussons
Rivers Horror Stuff & More! (95.03%)
Orxchid
Dr. [REDACTED] (95.01%)
Child Of The Night
Mrs. Nightmare’s Creepypastas (94.98%)
Mrs. Nightmare
CreepCode Storytime (94.98%)
Code D
Preschool Teacher Reads (94.7%)
Preschool Teacher Reads... This is not for children.
Lets Talk Horror (94.59%)
Jason Bald
Room Sixty6 (94.4%)
Room Sixty6
Scary noodles (94.36%)
Jonas
Alter Umbra - ENG (94.24%)
Little Ms. Death
The Campfire podcast (94.2%)
Buddy
Metus Mortis - ENG (94.19%)
1Lilith
Unsettling Events With Akira (94.18%)
Unsettling Events with Akira
The Witches Of The Shadow World - ENG (94.18%)
Some Witch
Pointless Podcast (94.17%)
Toast
Night Frequency Whisper (93.92%)
Lost Silver
Pointless podcast (93.73%)
Pointless podcast
MuseEmHorror (93.72%)
MuseEmHorror
The Spooky Half-Hour (93.72%)
Tyler M
The Shadowcast (93.43%)
THESHADOWCASTER
Mistress Creepypasta (93.25%)
Tay Bae
Heckstechsupport LLC (93.25%)
Heckstechsupport LLC
HorrorLover - Mr NoSleep (93.21%)
Mr NoSleep
Raise The Dead Radio (93.1%)
Ian Leary Champion
Oh Macabre! (93.06%)
Shayla McGee
CreepyPasta (93.03%)
BoxedIn
Creepypasta (92.9%)
JD
Spooky Noodles (92.82%)
Xdude Gamer
Scary Stories With An Illiterate (92.79%)
Jack Quesenberry
Nightmare Fuel (92.77%)
James
Suffer The People . A Horror Podcast By Jaehylinn (92.66%)
Marilynn Jordynn Camrynn Evert
Scripter (92.54%)
Enchanted Scriptz
THE ONE WITH JUST... (92.43%)
Armando Garcia Jr
Weird Stories to Tell in The Dark (92.34%)
Dylan
CreepyPasgetti (92.2%)
CreepyPasgetti
Creepypasteen (92.16%)
Xeezin
Ghastly Girls (92.13%)
The Ghastly Girls
MoreSins (92.01%)
Morsine
Horror Pickup Podcast (91.99%)
Anthony Sheehan
creepypastareadings's podcast (91.79%)
creepypastareadings
Al Dente Rigamortis (91.7%)
Review Cultist, Mik.E and the Gamer in Yellow
Sicko Story Time (91.63%)
Sicko Story Time
Small Talk (91.6%)
The 10 Minute Podcast
Chucky's show (91.58%)
Chucky Ray
The Nightmare Manifesto (91.48%)
Nate Johnson
Horror Files (91.42%)
Vincent Sobocinski
What's The Tea? With Gabriel (91.29%)
gabriel esparza
Nonna Roy’s NIGHTMARINARA (91.23%)
Roy
Think Thank Thunk (91.15%)
Allison Hiser
Freaky Friday (91.05%)
AmbitGambino
Crazed Insanity (91.0%)
CrazedInsanity
Al Dente Rigamortis (90.97%)
Review Cultist, Mik.E and the Gamer in Yellow
TalesOfDarkness (90.93%)
DOCTOR HEINOUS
Queerpypasta - The LGBTQ+ Creepypasta Podcast (90.88%)
Queerpypasta - The LGBTQ Creepypasta Podcast
MY CrEePy PODCAST (90.75%)
Beloved Thorns
Day Dreams and Nightmares with To_42 (90.69%)
To_42
DC. Sykes (90.52%)
dc sykes
This Unnamed Podcast (90.5%)
Flores
The scary stories podcast (90.42%)
The scary stories podcast
The scary stories podcast (90.42%)
Scary Stories
Story Glory (90.41%)
N/A
TURN IT OFF- A CREEPYPASTA (90.38%)
ThatOneFurry
We're Not Sisters (90.37%)
Eleanor and Greta
Storytime with Erin (90.34%)
Erin
Creepy Chats (90.14%)
Bouncy Q
Talesfromtheabyss87 (90.11%)
Talesfromtheabyss87
Beyond The Bizarre (90.1%)
Beyond The Bizarre
Bruh Podcast (90.08%)
Evan
ReadingRedditer (89.99%)
ReadingRedditer
Kylo_Ragnar (89.96%)
Michael Woods
AAAAAAAAA (89.95%)
Mckenzie Sayles
Short Creepypasta Readings (89.91%)
WindowsStartup27
Cryptids and Creepypastas (89.86%)
Conner Dye
Once upon a fort fright (89.81%)
Larry Cross