Forgotten True Crime
Trevor Shelby
Join proud Host, Trevor Shelby, as he digs into the most interesting stories that show the darker side of True Crime. Every episode we will feature a true crime story that has been forgotten through time. We will cover Cold Cases, Missing Persons, Serial Killers, and Horrible Crimes that happened in the 19th, 20th, and 21st centuries.
Podcasts Similar to Forgotten True Crime
The Great Unsolved (94.42%)
The Oracl3 Network
Witches, Magic, Murder, & Mystery (94.32%)
Megan and Kara
Small Town Mysteries (93.62%)
Kate, Christine, and Rachael
Riddle Me That! True Crime (93.37%)
Jules Ph.D.
Uncovered: The Lovers' Lane Murders (93.2%)
OU Daily
Uncovered (93.2%)
Uncovered
True Crime All The Time Unsolved (93.0%)
PodcastOne
Crime Chats (92.98%)
CrimeChats
Puzzling: A True Crime Podcast (92.97%)
Tiffany Epp
Murder Most Foul (92.94%)
James Sulanowski
Crime, Coffee & Convo (92.88%)
Crystal Gray
The Prosecutors (92.73%)
PodcastOne
Redrum Blonde (92.72%)
Erin Fleming
Black Girl Gone: A True Crime Podcast (92.47%)
Cloud10 and iHeartPodcasts
Cousins on Crime (92.46%)
Cousins on Crime
Crime Bistro (92.41%)
Anna DiNino
Last Seen Alive (92.4%)
Last Seen Alive
Unsolved Murders: True Crime Stories (92.36%)
Parcast Network
Killin Missin Hidden (92.34%)
Brad. Just Brad.
Trace Evidence (92.32%)
Steven Pacheco
Not Your Normal Murder (92.29%)
notyournormalmurder
CASEWATCH True Crime Podcast (92.09%)
Flat Face Media
Sideline Sleuths (92.08%)
Sideline Sleuths
Beagle’s Butchery & Muncher’s Murder (92.05%)
Lauren Beagle
Murder With My Mother - A True Crime Podcast (92.04%)
Denika and Christie
Altitude Crime (92.04%)
Amelia Allan
Crime Vision (92.03%)
Breona James
True Crimecast (92.02%)
Stove Leg Media
Crimes & Closets (92.0%)
Cristy & Beth
Crime Over Coffee (91.93%)
Crime Over Coffee
Murder In America (91.85%)
Blood In The Sink Productions
Texas Chicks Who Talk Murder (91.75%)
Texas Chicks
Mysterious and Unsolved (91.75%)
Katie Duffield
The Great Detectives Present Nick Carter (Old Time Radio) (91.71%)
Adam Graham Radio Detective Podcasts
This Story is Nuts (91.69%)
Melissa Reece
Homicidal Impulse (91.67%)
ididitforjodie
Twisted Podcast (91.66%)
John W. Taylor
Crimeology (91.63%)
Crimeology Podcast
Going West: True Crime (91.6%)
Dark West Productions
Anatomy of Murder (91.59%)
audiochuck
The Felon File (91.58%)
Scott Lunsford
True Crime Recaps (91.58%)
Amy Townsend
Crime Talk with T & Z Podcast (91.55%)
Crime Talk with T and Z
Solved Or Unsolved (91.54%)
Solved Or Unsolved
Something Sick (91.53%)
Katy and Sydney
Crime Confidential (91.52%)
Mandy Haerr
Our Black Girls (91.52%)
Erika Marie
SC Currant News (91.49%)
Ava
Crack House Chronicles (91.48%)
Crack House Chronicles
Late Night Crimecast (91.46%)
Robyn Stephens
Crawlspace - True Crime & Mysteries (91.44%)
Crawlspace Media & Glassbox Media
Mysteries with The Bermuda’s (91.42%)
Reagan, Pj’s Studio, Indy, Phoenix
Beyond Bizarre True Crime (91.39%)
AbJack Entertainment
Absent Unknown Friend: The Rahway Murder (91.39%)
Absent Unknown Friend
True Crime Creepers (91.34%)
Kristin & Mogab
California True Crime (91.33%)
California True Crime
Vile Virginia: A True Crime Podcast (91.32%)
Vile Virginia
Syndicated – The Great Detectives of Old Time Radio (91.31%)
Adam Graham
Murder Sisters (91.3%)
Justine and Alyssa
Shaken and Disturbed (91.26%)
John Thrasher and Daryn Carp
True Murder: The Most Shocking Killers (91.18%)
Dan Zupansky -
Cold State: Exploring America's Cold Cases (91.17%)
Podmany
Project Sunlight (91.13%)
Project Sunlight
Secrets and Lies- A True Crime Podcast (91.12%)
Secrets and Lies
Forensic Myles (91.12%)
Forensic Myles LLC
Case Closed(?) (91.12%)
Sean McDonald
MMIW (91.11%)
Anthony Mellendorf
A Date With Murder: True Crime Podcast (91.09%)
Kelli Floyd And Ashley Day
Crime x Cassie & All Things Creepy (91.06%)
crimexcassie
Holmes, Borden and the Watson Papers (91.06%)
Chris
Detective Society (91.04%)
Part Time Podcasts
Murder, Mayhem, And The Military (91.03%)
Jessica Lynch
Coffee and Cases Podcast (91.01%)
Allison Williams, Maggie Damron
Was She Murdered? (91.01%)
Digging Up Roots
John Doe - Unsolved Mysteries (90.99%)
Dharma
Criminal Mind (90.99%)
Hope Vista
Central Crazies (90.99%)
Central crazies
Murder In The Hudson Valley (90.98%)
Hudson River Radio .com
Porch Sittin’: A True Crime Podcast (90.95%)
Ashley Brewer
Mind Over Murder (90.94%)
Bill Thomas and Kristin Dilley
Talking Murder (90.91%)
Freddy Ponce
OTR Detective - The Great Detectives of Old Time Radio (90.91%)
Adam Graham
Mystery On Our Minds (90.87%)
Kennedy and Nora
Solve'em When You Get'em (90.86%)
David Walker
Weeknight Mysteries (90.85%)
Weeknight Mysteries
TGICrimeday (90.84%)
TGICRIMEDAY
House of Murder (90.83%)
Cook and Co.
Lena Nozizwe Reporting: Tupac's Murder Was His Case (90.8%)
Lena Nozizwe
The Fletcher Files: A Murder, She Wrote Podcast (90.77%)
Monty
Moms and Murder (90.73%)
Not Your Mom Media
Truth or Death (90.73%)
VCM
Into the Bullpen (90.71%)
Kaycee Gray
Murder Burrito (90.71%)
Josie & Chelsea
Morbidology (90.69%)
Morbidology
Somebody Knows More (90.68%)
Rhiannon Doe
Case By Case (90.68%)
Ezzah Rafique
Citizen Detective (90.67%)
AbJack Entertainment
Campfire Stories with Amy Scott (90.66%)
Amy Scott
Middle School Mysteries: The Series (90.65%)
Ms. Grant
KillerKast (90.65%)
KillerKast