You’ll Never Guess What…

Kristiyan Reads Reddit Stories (88.93%)

Bob the Builder 999

Different But Wired With A Smile (88.62%)

Rori Smith

Welcome to GachaDarren podcast (88.36%)

Gacha Darren

Different-ish (88.2%)

Different-ish

Spilling the Tea (88.1%)

kelstea

The Stinky Slinkys (88.08%)

The Stinky Slinky’s

The Unbelievably True Podcast (88.06%)

Amber McConnehey

The Spooked Podcast (87.66%)

The Spooked Podcast

A1 Since 01 (87.63%)

Richard Rose & Tweety Griffith

idk I'm Bored Lmao (Random Crap) (87.51%)

Spoxy

Soulfits Podcast (87.43%)

Cameron White & Mario Marshall

The Odd Talk (87.41%)

Zaida Tolentino

The popkill (86.86%)

Gianni Deleon

S.T.I.F.O.L (86.67%)

ZB. mochi

The Monkeys With Mic's Show (86.64%)

Josiah, Davis, Connor, Nora

We the Women Can (86.58%)

Sneha Malhotra

justsisters (86.48%)

Theresa Habsburg

assley's podcast (86.37%)

assley

Two Fucking Tards (86.32%)

Bubblegum-Bitch

A Scary Place (86.28%)

JonWesley Barnhill

Readit Aloud (86.28%)

brian grabowski

Eighteenager (86.26%)

Emilie Burns

Spooky Dooky (86.18%)

Spooky Dooky

Buddie News (86.01%)

Milo Spark

Bosom Bloodies: A How-to Halloween Podcast (86.0%)

Queen City Podcast Network

plumpeach (85.98%)

plumpeach

Tea Time With Kaleb🚨‼️ (85.97%)

Kaleb Holmes

The Pretty People Show (85.89%)

Pretty People Show

Keepin it real (85.87%)

themccreepz (85.79%)

TheMcCreepz

The Taylor Experience (85.68%)

Taylor Elizabeth

Scary Story Sisters (85.53%)

Kelsey Wahl

Reddit Digital (85.52%)

Abby

Becoming A Better You (85.44%)

Coretta

The GKG Podcast (85.36%)

GKG

Literacy Optional (85.28%)

Literacy Optional

Daily shiz (85.21%)

daily shiz

Lonewolves (85.15%)

lonewolf adventure

The Casual Podcast (85.13%)

The Casual Podcast

That Wasn't Bad (85.05%)

That Wasn't Bad

Stories I Found on Reddit (84.91%)

Ner Gerasol

Dorkie (84.88%)

Twizzy Studioz

Paranoia chills (84.78%)

paranoia Chills

Terrifying Thoughts (84.75%)

Jack P Saddler

Scary Stories for You (84.68%)

Scary Stories

Faith Talks (84.68%)

Faith

Mummy Masterpiece (84.65%)

Laney McGahey

Rodney Podcast (84.64%)

Rodney Golar

The After Nightmare Podcast (84.56%)

After Nightmare

Lotsa Pasta (84.53%)

None

TERRIFYING REDDIT CONFESSIONS | EP 1 (84.45%)

TTS Anon

Terrifying Dark Nights (84.42%)

mysteriousgamebro

Scary.stories.live (84.41%)

jaden arens

The Girls Next Door (84.4%)

Gizelle&Mariaysela

What in the world with Ang (84.39%)

Angie Dawn

Awkwardly Intense (84.39%)

Jack & Xane

Anonomous (84.37%)

sky micheal

The Toby show (84.37%)

Toby

Cursed Tape (84.26%)

Astoria

A world with a purple sky (84.25%)

Brice Johnson

A world with a purple sky (84.25%)

Brice Johnson

yeah, i reddit (84.25%)

james

NJ&N Podcast (84.14%)

NJ&N

Two WOMEN One MIC (84.09%)

Terry Susan Pod

Lucia’s Crying Cave (84.04%)

lucia

Airyana's podcast (84.02%)

Airyana

Rejected (83.99%)

CreepyStoreBoy

BehindthestoriesWL (83.97%)

Hi Hi

Jinx (83.96%)

ella & caroline

Bathroom Talks (83.93%)

Keaton Thomas

The Squeaky Chair Podcast (83.92%)

Jack, Ryan and Emma

Porchcast (83.87%)

Porchcast

Based On Untrue Events (83.85%)

Lexi

Don’t Worry, This Doesn’t Matter (83.83%)

Jules Haze

Vic Talks (83.83%)

Victor Ruiz

The Devil'sGaze Podcast (83.8%)

Devil'sGaze

Fright Night Fridays (83.73%)

Fright Night Fridays

Spook Central (83.72%)

Spook Central

Officially unofficial (83.71%)

Offically_Unoffical

Trident News (83.68%)

Ahaan and Nathan

Smoking sesh with ruckus and Jonny (83.67%)

Smokin sesh with ruckus and Jonny

Something Crepyy (83.65%)

Tikscared Scary

The Agony Uncles (83.65%)

Freshair Radio

by Shishi (83.58%)

Sharon Habeck

CHILLIN’ WITH THE MEXICANS (83.55%)

Hilary Ortega

Scp tape to tape (83.51%)

Dr spider

Hold on, I’m learning (83.5%)

Hannah Landry

payton’s sick podcast (83.48%)

payton wheeler

My weird adventure (83.47%)

Ella W

Abusement Park (83.42%)

Simp

Scary Stories (83.4%)

James Chris Davis

Wearing Suspense (83.38%)

shriya singh

We’re Friends (83.33%)

Cristine Rosales

Vee's Scary Story's 👻 (83.27%)

vee pink tea

Melancholy crisis (83.17%)

Melancholy crisis

MichaelReadsReddit (83.16%)

Michael Ross

what the wtf with braeden dipps (83.09%)

Braeden Dipps

Tom’s Short Scary Stories (83.07%)

Tom

Movie Reviews (83.06%)

cookie swirl art

Partytime Podcast (83.06%)

Valerie Guadalupe vega