Mike's On with Francesa: Recent Episodes
Audacy
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open Monday's show by discussing the New York Yankees' offensive struggles -- and whether or not the strength of their pitching is enough to overcome their slump without Aaron Judge.
George Lombard Jr. has given the Yankees something they desperately needed: energy, confidence and a reason to believe their offense can finally look different. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber, and Shaun argues Lombard’s impact goes far beyond the box score. His defense, speed, poise and ability to create runs have made him look ready for an even bigger role.
Tiki remains cautious because the Yankees still struggle badly to score, but their dominant starting pitching has created a legitimate path to winning in October. The biggest question is whether Aaron Boone should stop treating Lombard like a typical rookie and move him straight to the top of the lineup.
Friday Nights extra inning victory over the Braves may go down as the biggest win of the season. Mets win 4th in a row.
Carton believes that Yankee fans and the entire organization should be worried about the Red Sox who are on a never ending heater
The Red Sox have erased a 15.5-game Yankees advantage with a staggering 31-5 run, forcing Evan Roberts to reconsider just how real Boston has become. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan, and Shaun remains defiant, insisting the Yankees will still finish ahead of the Red Sox despite Boston’s stunning surge.
The timing is impossible to ignore. Boston’s run began the same night Michael Kay mocked Red Sox fans for chanting “Yankees suck,” giving Evan a perfect new jinx candidate. Meanwhile, Aaron Judge remains out, the Yankees have played .500 baseball without him, and Evan questions whether that changes anytime soon. Shaun sees the opposite, predicting the Yankees are about to heat up before a huge late-August showdown with Boston.
Willie fills us in about what training camp is really like in the NFL based on his first hand experience.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open Thursday's show by tearing apart the Yankees' offense, which George Lombard Jr. might not be able to save...
Evan Roberts has reached his breaking point with the Yankees and officially declares their American League East chase over. Their lifeless offense, mounting injuries and growing deficit behind the Rays have convinced him there is not enough time to recover, even with Aaron Judge and Cody Bellinger potentially returning in September.
Darius Slayton thinks he got the “Tom Coughlin-esque” coach he was looking for in John Harbaugh. Willie speaks to the importance of leadership and how players can sense a difference when it’s real and strong vs weak. On a fun note, Willie is a fan of Disney Cruises and recently shot a commercial for them after they heard about his experiences. Disney made Willie a cruise guy.
Ryan Ruocco of YES Networks joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle to discuss his call of George Lombard Jr.'s first home run as a Major League Baseball player for the New York Yankees!
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open Wednesday's show by reacting to George Lombard Jr.'s Major League debut for the Yankees, and questioning just how much the Giants plan to depend on a 33-year-old Odell Beckham Jr. this season. Is Jaxson Dart in trouble?
George Lombard Jr. delivered the Yankees debut fans had been waiting for, crushing a home run and immediately flashing the smooth defense and athleticism that made him such a highly anticipated prospect. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe Lombard can become a real difference-maker in the division race.
Gio got a laugh out of C-Mac interviewing Brian Cashman on The Carton Show yesterday. Gio felt good about most of Cashman’s answers except for the one about not acquiring a catcher.
New York Yankees GM Brian Cashman joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on WFAN's Carton Show to explain the Yankees' controversial trade deadline decisions.
Cashman discusses why the Yankees couldn't land Orioles star catcher Adley Rutschman, the challenges of finding bullpen help, and why the organization decided the asking prices were too high. He also gives updates on Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton's injuries, explains the decision to call up George Lombard Jr. and send Anthony Volpe to Triple-A, and responds to criticism that the Yankees lacked urgency at the deadline.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether Brian Cashman completely failed at the deadline or if Yankees fans are overreacting. Did Cashman miss a golden opportunity to add a catcher and bullpen help, or are fans acting like the season is already over?
Shaun Morash blasts Brian Cashman for an “insulting” Yankees trade deadline, arguing that failing to add a major-league catcher or reliever showed zero urgency while the Red Sox and Rays improved. Evan Roberts agrees that leaving the deadline without a catcher was unacceptable, though he still believes the Yankees can contend. Tiki Barber pushes back on the harshest conclusions while questioning where the team’s momentum is headed.
The frustration peaks with George Lombard Jr.’s promotion. Shaun believes the Yankees deliberately waited until after the deadline to call up their top prospect as a way to distract fans from Cashman’s failures, turning an exciting debut into another example of organizational dysfunction.
Craig and Big Mac react to breaking news of the Mets trading Clay Holmes and Tyrone Taylor to the Chicago Cubs for prospect Jefferson Rojas. They also evaluate the Yankees' urgent need for an impact catcher and the potential timeline for Aaron Judge's return to the lineup.
01:00 - Yankee Catcher Search
03:35 - Judge Return Timeline
07:58 - Mets Roster Discussion
12:36 - Clay Holmes Trade
16:13 - Trade Deadline Stress
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react LIVE as the Yankees watch catcher after catcher come off the trade market while division rivals make big moves. Are Brian Cashman and the Yankees running out of options? Is Tyler Stephenson now the last realistic answer behind the plate?
Howards Johnson joins Hoff to take a look back at the 1986 Mets for their 40 year anniversary
Emmanuel Berbari Tells Hoff why the Yankees are still live in the American League and how the Bombers can with the deadline
Trades, trades and more trades. Yanks get Garcia, Jr. Mets hand Peralta to Rays. Dodgers keep dodgering.
Hoff and Jon Morosi discuss how Mets can lay the foundation for the future with a successful MLB trade deadline approach
Shaun and Tiki also react to Tony Romo being placed on leave by CBS and J.J. Watt stepping into the booth with Jim Nantz. Plus, they examine the Rams’ mysterious Ty Simpson selection, revisit the Lamar Jackson versus Josh Allen MVP debate, and explain why improved coaching has created legitimate optimism for both New York football teams.
Malik Nabers is recovering faster than expected, and Connor Hughes believes the Giants’ optimism about a Week 1 return is justified barring a setback. But his progress also exposes the team’s biggest concern: a wide receiver room that has failed to produce a clear No. 2 option.
Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as Hughes explains why Odell Beckham Jr. still has to earn his roster spot, how John Harbaugh has immediately made Giants camp feel more professional, and why Abdul Carter is already taking over practices against Andrew Thomas. The Giants may have raised their floor, but their passing game still depends heavily on Nabers getting healthy.
Baker Mayfield says he feels disrespected by Tampa Bay, and Tiki Barber sees a major opportunity for the Jets. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as they argue that New York should aggressively explore a trade before another quarterback-needy team beats them to it.
Tiki believes Mayfield’s toughness, leadership and proven ability would instantly upgrade a shaky Jets quarterback room and help stop the franchise from falling deeper into its losing cycle. Shaun pushes the idea even further, wondering whether Tampa Bay’s contract standoff could eventually lead to a trade and whether the Jets should be willing to use one of their three first-round picks to make it happen.
If the Dodgers get Tarik Skubal and win another World Series, this is going to help the chances of there being a lockout.
Ali Sanchez’s disastrous throw helped turn a four-run Yankees lead into their most frustrating loss of the season. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber rip Aaron Boone’s postgame defense, questioning whether the manager’s refusal to demand accountability will allow the same mistakes to haunt the Yankees in October.
Yanks fans were furious for him taking Cam Schlittler out yesterday when he was pitching well. Gio said you can’t blame Aaron Boone if you also blame analytics.
Forty years later, Mookie Wilson takes Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle behind the scenes of one of the greatest moments in baseball history. From his unforgettable Game 6 at-bat against the Red Sox to his emotional friendship with Bill Buckner, Mookie shares stories Mets fans have never heard. He also reflects on the chemistry that made the 1986 Mets champions, why today's Mets are falling short, and what this year's 40th anniversary celebration means.
Don't miss one of the best baseball interviews you'll hear all year.
🔹 Mookie Wilson relives Game 6 pitch-by-pitch
🔹 The truth about Bill Buckner and their friendship
🔹 Why the 1986 Mets' chemistry was so special
🔹 Thoughts on the current Mets' disappointing season
🔹 Behind-the-scenes stories from the legendary championship team
After setting Giants fans on fire, Carton doubles down on his claim that John Harbaugh is the most overrated coach in the NFL. Chris McMonigle pushes back, callers defend Harbaugh's résumé, and the debate quickly turns into one of the hottest Giants conversations of training camp.
The Jets finally appear to have enough offensive talent to escape years of misery, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber agree everything depends on Geno Smith. Evan sees a potential playoff formula built around Breece Hall, Garrett Wilson, an improved offensive line and Frank Reich, while Tiki fears Geno’s recent turnovers and offseason distractions could wreck the entire plan.
Their biggest disagreement centers on rookie Cade Klubnik. Tiki believes the fourth-round pick should get a legitimate chance if he outplays Geno, but Evan argues the Jets’ most realistic path to surprising the league requires Smith to rediscover his Seattle form. With the franchise chasing its first top-half offense since 2015, the quarterback decision could determine whether the Jets finally escape the abyss.
We start the day looking at Geno Smith and the Jets QB situation and the future of Aaron Glenn. Boomer thinks GM Darren Mougey has done a good job so far.
Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the New York Giants' path to the playoffs and the evolution of Jaxson Dart. They also react to Plaxico Burress's viral comparison between his time with the New York Jets and his prison sentence. Additionally, the conversation turns to a heated debate over Jets rookie David Bailey and local geography.
01:00 - Giants Playoff Potential
09:48 - Plaxico Burress Viral Comments
18:10 - Jets David Bailey Debate
23:23 - Long Island Geography Banter
The Giants enter training camp with playoff expectations, at least in Evan Roberts’ eyes. Evan believes John Harbaugh’s demanding approach, better late-game coaching and a more experienced Jaxson Dart can transform last year’s four-win team into a nine or ten-win contender. Anything short of the postseason would leave him disappointed.
Tiki Barber is not ready to set the bar that high. He points to major questions in the secondary, run defense and receiving corps, arguing the Giants still need to prove they can crawl before anyone expects them to run. The debate also centers on Dart’s physical playing style, his repeated trips to the medical tent and whether better coaching can help him stay available while still making winning plays.
Cody Bellinger is on the IL, joining Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton -- he will be out 4-6 weeks. Gio thinks Aaron Boone should be a favorite for manager of the year.
The Yankees' offense continues to struggle, Cody Bellinger lands on the IL, and the trade deadline is just days away. But Chris McMonigle says Brian Cashman shouldn't panic and overpay for average hitters.
The Yankees won two of three against Philadelphia, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber are alarmed by an offense that has become nearly unrecognizable. With Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton and Cody Bellinger sidelined, Evan calls the current lineup one of the worst the franchise has fielded in decades and argues that elite pitching is the only thing keeping the season afloat.
The weakness of the American League only increases the pressure on Brian Cashman to be aggressive before the trade deadline. Evan and Tiki debate which bats the Yankees need, whether Spencer Jones and George Lombard Jr. should be part of the solution and why multiple moves may be necessary. Plus, they defend Jose Caballero after an umpire ruled that he intentionally dropped a line drive.
We kind of aren't. Gio thinks it's going to be a disaster with the Sixers not overtaking the Knicks at all.
Yanks need to be aggressive and trade for a big bat as the Red Sox are getting closer in the division.
On The Carton Show with Chris McMonigle, Craig unloads on LeBron's decision to join the 76ers, arguing the Knicks remain the undisputed kings of the Eastern Conference. Carton claims New York turned LeBron away, calls Philadelphia "MSG South," predicts Sixers fans will eventually turn on him, and debates whether the Sixers are even a legitimate threat to the defending NBA Champion Knicks.
Will LeBron and the Sixers create the NBA's next great rivalry, or is Philadelphia destined for another playoff disappointment?
LeBron James is signing with the Philadelphia 76ers, and the stunning breaking news instantly transforms the Eastern Conference. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as they react to LeBron joining Joel Embiid, Jaylen Brown and Tyrese Maxey, praise him for putting his legacy on the line, and declare Philadelphia the Knicks’ biggest threat.
The move carries an enormous boom-or-bust consequence. LeBron could deliver Philadelphia its long-awaited championship and become a permanent city icon, or watch the experiment collapse and leave as one of its most hated athletes. Evan and Shaun also debate whether this will truly be LeBron’s final season, how his decision changes the NBA schedule and why Knicks-Sixers now belongs on opening night.
Malik Nabers avoiding the PUP list gives the Giants a massive boost before training camp and strongly suggests he will play September football. Shaun Morash is in for Tiki Barber alongside Evan Roberts as they explain why Nabers’ progress raises the ceiling for Jaxson Dart and an offense that already showed promise without its number one receiver.
Evan and Shaun also rank the players the Giants and Jets cannot afford to lose. Jaxson Dart, Andrew Thomas and Nabers headline the Giants’ list, while Geno Smith’s importance exposes the Jets’ shaky backup quarterback situation. They also debate whether the Giants can become a playoff team even if Dart does not develop into an elite quarterback.
Gio thinks the Giants have elements of a team that can be special. Jerry sees the Giants as a 10-win team.
Craig Carton sounds off on LeBron James and the NBA after the league delays releasing the 2026-27 schedule while waiting for LeBron's decision. Carton argues the defending NBA Champion New York Knicks deserve to be the center of attention—not a 43-year-old superstar deciding his next team.
The Yankees’ offense needs an immediate jolt, and Evan Roberts is demanding that Brian Cashman call up George Lombard Jr. now. Evan argues that Jose Caballero and Anthony Volpe have already shown they are not the long-term answer at shortstop, while Lombard’s hot bat and major league-ready defense make him the most exciting option available.
Tiki Barber agrees with the idea but warns that a rookie could struggle under postseason pressure, while Shaun Morash believes Lombard could also solve the Yankees’ problems at third base. They debate whether Volpe should be sent down, whether Lombard is being protected as a trade chip, and why waiting until September could waste the prospect’s chance to transform the season.
The Yankees' offense has become painful to watch, and Craig Carton isn't holding back. Craig and Chris McMonigle break down another frustrating loss, rip Cody Bellinger's struggles, discuss Giancarlo Stanton's possible return, and debate whether Brian Cashman can save the lineup before the trade deadline. They also react to John Harbaugh's first speech to the New York Giants and Craig absolutely unloads, calling it one of the most embarrassing coach speeches he's ever heard. Do Giants fans have reason to worry already?
John Harbaugh’s first speech to the Giants has Evan Roberts ready to run through a wall and openly jealous that Big Blue finally hired a proven head coach. Tiki Barber explains why Harbaugh’s résumé, authenticity and football obsession make his message land differently than the empty optimism surrounding past Giants coaches.
The excitement quickly turns into a warning about expectations. Evan believes Harbaugh’s competence should prevent another embarrassing, inept season, while Tiki admits the runaway hype scares him after a decade of disappointment. They debate how long Harbaugh’s honeymoon will last, compare his arrival to Bill Parcells taking over the Jets and explain why elite coaching could change everything for the Giants.
Gio started watching the new season of “Quarterback” yesterday. Boomer wonders how good the Ravens will be without John Harbaugh. Gio says it’s important to have the head coach and QB combination to win and that’s what has us excited about the Giants having momentum and heading in the right direction.
Craig Carton and Zach Gelb- filling in for Chris McMonigle- are joined by former New York Mets manager Bobby Valentine for an insightful conversation on the state of the Mets and the growing role of artificial intelligence in baseball. Valentine shares his perspective on AI calling pitches, the importance of the human element in managing a team, and the challenges facing today's Mets. He also reflects on the unforgettable emotions surrounding Mike Piazza's iconic post-9/11 home run, discusses leadership in the clubhouse, and shares stories from his legendary career in baseball.
Craig Carton is joined by Yankees legend Jim Leyritz for an unfiltered conversation about the Bronx Bombers' season. Leyritz shares his thoughts on Jazz Chisholm's impact, Anthony Volpe's future, Aaron Boone's leadership, and what the Yankees need to do at the trade deadline to make a World Series run.
Craig Carton is joined by Zach Gelb, filling in for Chris McMonigle, for a packed show covering the biggest stories in New York sports. The guys debate whether the Yankees are still legitimate World Series contenders despite injuries, discuss Jazz Chisholm's impact, react to the Yankees' latest win, and argue over the Jets' outlook after the release of their new white uniforms. Plus, they dive into a spirited Jets vs. Patriots debate, preview the MLB trade deadline, and touch on the latest ESPN drama surrounding Ryan Clark.
WFAN’s upcoming arrival on SiriusXM sends Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber down memory lane, including Evan’s remarkable decision to quit his Sirius job so he would not miss the Mets’ 2006 playoff run. Evan explains why he took the financial gamble, how the season ended in heartbreak and why the risk ultimately helped launch his full-time career at WFAN.
Evan and Tiki also react to John Harbaugh making light of Jaxson Dart’s backflip, debate whether the Giants coach should address it privately and examine whether different offseason moves could have pushed the Mets into a pennant race.
Freddy Peralta’s miserable return to Milwaukee leaves Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash stunned by his postgame admission that he does not know what is wrong. After another rough outing, the hosts argue that David Stearns cannot be protected by the idea that nobody could have predicted the deal failing. He gets credit when moves work, and he deserves the blame when they become disasters.
The conversation also shifts to the Cowboys, where Evan makes an early declaration that Dallas will win the NFC East if its rebuilt defense can become merely respectable. Plus, the return of the offseason game “New Team, Who Dis” produces an immediate miss, and Aaron Boone’s vague update on Giancarlo Stanton creates even more uncertainty for the Yankees.
Jazz Chisholm’s explosive night against the Pirates proves why the Yankees cannot afford to trade him before the deadline. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash acknowledge Jazz’s frustrating inconsistency, but his power, energy and production in high-leverage moments make him essential to any potential October run.
The pursuit of Luis Arraez creates a major lineup dilemma, potentially forcing Jazz back to third base or the outfield after years of complaints about playing Yankees out of position. With Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton facing uncertain returns, the Yankees may need to ignore defensive comfort and build the strongest possible offense. After months of low-scoring baseball, the eight-run outburst felt like a much-needed night at an open bar.
Drew Brees joins us in studio to begin the hour. He discusses what it was like playing in New Orleans in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina. Brees recalls the end of his time with the Chargers and how he ended up with the Saints instead of the Dolphins.
Boomer thinks Francisco Lindor is not happy and the Mets should consider trading him. Gio believes this is shaping up to be the worst year in Mets history.
Craig Carton and Willie Colon break down a packed Monday on The Carton Show! Craig sounds off on Giants rookie Cam Skattebo after his viral backflip at Fanatics Fest nearly ended in disaster. Is the young star being reckless before playing a single NFL game? The guys also debate whether Yankees fans are overreacting after losing 2-of-3 to the Dodgers. Despite the series loss, did New York prove it can hang with baseball's best even without Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton, and Max Fried?
The Yankees offense is drowning, Aaron Judge cannot be counted on to return soon, and Evan Roberts says Brian Cashman now has two weeks to save the season. Evan points to Cashman’s aggressive 2017 trade deadline as the blueprint, arguing that New York needs impact bats instead of waiting for Anthony Volpe, Austin Wells and others to suddenly turn things around.
Tiki Barber agrees the Yankees can no longer assume struggling players will figure it out, but warns there is no obvious answer on the trade market. With the lineup averaging just over three runs per game for a month, Evan and Tiki debate catcher and infield upgrades, a possible George Lombard Jr. call-up and why every mistake becomes devastating when the Yankees cannot score.
Craig and Big Mac are joined by Jason from AA Mint Cards to take a look at some of the latest collectibles.
Entrepreneur Gary Vee joins Craig and Cmac live from Fanatics Fest to talk sports, his career path, and much more.
Craig and Cmac are joined by Rossi Takes, a content creator and Philly superfan, live from Fanatics Fest.
Frank the Tank from Barstool Sports joins the show to lament on the Mets horrible, terrible, no good, very bad season.
Craig and Big Mac talk with Robert Wuhl of Arliss, Batman, Bull Durham, and many others, about baseball and much more.
Shaun and Tiki are joined by Yankee Great, Alex Rodriguez, to break down possible Yankee deadline moves, and much more.
We start the day with baseball talk. Mets beat the Phillies (ho-hum), the looming lockout for next season and moves that might need to made now.
Craig and Cmac are joined by rapper Lil Dee to get his thoughts on the Knicks playoff run, a little freestyle, and more.
Craig and Big Mac speak with Mike from Heritage Auctions about some of the most valuable items in their possession.
WWE Superstar Charlotte Flair joins Craig and Cmac to talk about her experience in Wrestling and much, much more.
Andrew Giuliani joins Craig and Cmac to get their thoughts on the logistics surrounding the World Cup Final and much more.
The Yankees are going back to the World Series, the Giants could make the playoffs and Jaxson Dart might emerge as one of the NFC East’s best quarterbacks. Shaun Morash is in for Evan Roberts alongside Tiki Barber as the crew puts its boldest New York sports predictions on the table.
The optimism comes with serious fear. Tiki worries injuries could destroy the Giants’ season before it gets going, while Morash admits a major Dart regression would crush the franchise’s momentum. Aaron Judge’s uncertain recovery also raises the possibility of the Yankees making a title run without their captain, creating a complicated legacy debate even if they finally win it all.
The wildfires in Canada are making the air quality here terrible. Could the dangerous air quality affect the World Cup final at MetLife Stadium?
Craig Carton has had enough! After watching the 2026 MLB All-Star Game, Craig goes OFF on American sports fans for constantly complaining about everything — too much pitching, not enough offense, boring games, bad entertainment and more.
Chris McMonigle pushes back as the guys debate whether the All-Star Game exposed a bigger problem with modern baseball — or with the fans watching it. Plus, Craig and C-Mac react to Boyz II Men’s rough performance and discuss encouraging comments from Giants coach John Harbaugh about letting Jaxson Dart use his legs.
Football is already taking over New York, and Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber turn their attention to the biggest questions facing the Giants as training camp approaches. At the center of the conversation is Malik Nabers and whether his recovery will allow him to rejoin the offense without being rushed.
They also react to a dull MLB All Star Game, the Yankees winning with small ball, and a National League lineup that looked far too much like the struggling Mets. With baseball failing to deliver much excitement, the anticipation for Giants and Jets camp is only getting stronger.
We talked about last night’s All-Star game which ended 4-0 and had a ton of strikeouts. It was simply boring.
Craig Carton has noticed a major change in Jaxson Dart and he believes New York Giants fans should be thrilled.
After an offseason filled with celebrity appearances, big events and life in the spotlight, Dart has seemingly disappeared from the public eye as training camp approaches. Craig believes that means the young quarterback is locked in on football and preparing to prove he can become the Giants’ franchise quarterback.
Chris McMonigle explains why he never doubted Dart’s commitment and why proving he is the long-term answer at quarterback is the biggest question facing the Giants this season.
Jordan Walker emerged as a breakout star in a Home Run Derby that finally felt fun again. Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber explain why the new format worked, how Philadelphia fans added energy to the event and why Major League Baseball delivered a much needed win.
The conversation then shifts to Geno Smith and the repeated speeding stories surrounding the Jets quarterback. Shaun and Tiki debate whether the incidents reveal poor decision making and why Smith must become a stabilizing leader instead of another offseason distraction.
Craig Carton is back alongside Chris McMonigle on The Carton Show, and he wastes no time unloading on the Mets after they were swept by the Red Sox and stumbled into the All-Star break at 17 games under .500.
The Mets enter the break buried in frustration after another costly mistake from Francisco Lindor and another late collapse from Devin Williams. Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber debate whether Luke Weaver should immediately become the closer, whether he should be traded, and which young players offer any real hope for the future.
The Yankees provide a more encouraging story after four straight wins and a weekend filled with late comebacks. Shaun and Tiki discuss whether the lineup is learning to survive without Aaron Judge, why the offense still feels incomplete, and how the tightening race with the Rays and Red Sox could shape the second half.
With Aaron Judge sidelined, Chris McMonigle says the Yankees can't afford to think small at the trade deadline. While Judge's injury is impossible to replace, Chris argues the bigger long-term concern is Giancarlo Stanton's latest setback—and makes the case for Brian Cashman to swing BIG for Rafael Devers.
Plus, Chris breaks down why the Yankees' win over the Rays was so important, why the AL is still there for the taking, and why standing pat at the deadline would be a massive mistake.
Aaron Judge’s uncertain recovery has changed the outlook for the Yankees. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber examine why Brian Cashman’s latest comments are so concerning, whether Judge can return as the same dominant hitter, and how Giancarlo Stanton’s injury adds even more pressure to a struggling offense.
They debate how the Yankees should approach the trade deadline when no single player can replace Judge’s production. The conversation also explores which current hitters must improve, how Judge could still provide lineup protection if he returns at less than full strength, and why Ryan McMahon’s long at bat may have sparked a much needed offensive breakout.
Jerry & Gordon are in for Boomer & Gio and start the show talking about the Yanks win and Brian Cashman's presser the status of Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton.
Big Mac reacts to the Yankees' much-needed series finale victory over the Rays and explains why this wasn't just another win. From Ryan McMahon's game-changing 12-pitch at-bat to Ben Rice's monster series, Chris breaks down the biggest positives and why Yankees fans shouldn't dismiss them. He also clashes with callers who insist the Yankees still aren't contenders, discusses the bullpen, Aaron Judge's injury update from Brian Cashman, and why the upcoming series in Washington is now critical.
The Yankees offense has reached a new low, with strikeouts piling up, scoring opportunities disappearing, and no obvious solution available. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the problem is strategy, mentality, fatigue, or simply a lineup full of players who need to perform better.
Cody Bellinger takes center stage as his dramatic slump raises questions about Aaron Judge’s impact on the entire lineup. With trades unlikely to provide an instant cure, Evan embraces an unconventional idea and pulls a completely new Yankees batting order out of a hat.
We opened with the Yankees shutout loss to the Rays and all the bad things about that game. Paul Goldschmidt is now 0 for his last 34. Aaron Boone got tossed last night and Boomer thinks he’s trying to wake up his listless team.
Chris McMonigle is flying solo on The Carton Show and unloads on the Yankees after another frustrating loss. While everyone is focused on the team's record-setting strikeout totals, Chris says they're missing the real problems. He also dives into the latest Anthony Volpe controversy after reports surfaced that Volpe allegedly refused to play second base before Michael Kay walked back the story. Has the Yankees-Volpe relationship reached the point of no return?
The Yankees struck out at an alarming rate, but Evan argues that their problems go far beyond missed swings. Will Warren struggled against the bottom of Tampa Bay’s lineup, Cody Bellinger made another costly mistake, and the uncertainty surrounding Aaron Judge has left the offense without an obvious solution.
Instead of trying to patch every weakness, Evan believes the Yankees should make one aggressive move and trade for Tarik Skubal. Pairing him with Gerrit Cole and Max Fried could give New York the dominant rotation it needs to survive a flawed American League and make a serious championship run.
Boomer said there had to be something else going on in the locker room for the Mets to get rid of Alonso, Nimmo and McNeil. The Yankees lost to the Rays and struck out 17 times again.
The Yankees striking out 17 times for the second straight game, The Mets, specifically their pitching situation, a disaster. What's even going on with baseball in this city anymore?
Chris McMonigle reacts to the New York Yankees' recent performance and the growing debate over the starting shortstop position. He critiques Aaron Boone's 'day-to-day' approach with Jose Caballero and Anthony Volpe, while also highlighting a dominant outing from the pitching staff. The discussion on The Carton Show explores the tension between team analytics and on-field results during a pivotal stretch of the season.
01:00 - McMonigle Breaks Down Yankees Victory
03:43 - Jose Caballero Shortstop Debate
07:31 - Aaron Boone's Management Critique
12:53 - Analyzing Anthony Volpe's Struggles
17:31 - Previewing Upcoming Sports News
Team USA failed to rise to the moment against Belgium, leaving Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber frustrated by the lack of aggression, defensive mistakes, and inability to match the intensity of a superior opponent. They also question whether American fans truly feel the same emotional investment in international soccer that they do with their favorite local teams.
The conversation then shifts to renewed optimism around the Yankees after a crucial win over Tampa Bay. Cam Schlittler looked like an emerging ace, Jose Caballero strengthened his case to become the everyday shortstop, and the Rays lineup gave Evan even more confidence that the American League East remains within reach.
Former soccer player Jimmy Conrad from CBS joins us to talk about the U.S. getting eliminated from the World Cup in their loss to Belgium.
It wasn't the outcome we wanted for Team USA but it is what it is. We also talked about Juan Soto who continues to be the brightest spot on the Mets roster.
Chris McMonigle analyzes the New York Yankees' recent series loss to the Minnesota Twins and the team's overall lack of focus on The Carton Show. He argues that the roster issues fall on Brian Cashman rather than Aaron Boone and highlights the necessity of a division title to ensure a deep postseason run.
01:00 - Yankees Struggle Against Twins
06:39 - Crucial Rays Series Preview
09:10 - Evaluating Boone and Cashman
15:29 - Shortstop Depth Chart Debate
20:06 - Cam Schlittler's Key Start
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down the controversy surrounding FIFA’s decision to suspend Flo Balogun’s red card ban, clearing him to play for Team USA against Belgium. The debate centers on whether this was a rare case of justice being served, or a strange example of political influence entering the sports world. The conversation dives into the VAR process, why the original red card was so disputed, and how American fans may view due process differently than the global soccer community.
Boomer went to the Norway match and had a great time of it. We also talked about Donald Trump calling President of FIFA and having him reverse a US players red card suspension.
On this episode of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether Aaron Boone deserves to be fired or if fans are overreacting to one brutal week of baseball. They discuss the Yankees' offensive collapse, defensive mistakes, injuries piling up, and why Boone has historically been able to pull the team out of these midseason swoons.
Yankees temperature check after a historically ugly stretch of baseball. With the team sliding and frustration building, the focus turns to Aaron Boone, the decisions that helped cost them another game, and whether Yankee fans are justified in talking seriously about a managerial change.
Evan and Shaun break down the bunt call, the failure to use Paul Goldschmidt, the bullpen issues with Camilo Doval, and Brian Cashman’s role in keeping the wrong arms around. They also call out Cody Bellinger and Ben Rice for struggling without Aaron Judge, making it clear that the Yankees’ problems go far beyond one bad night.
With start the show with USA's win over Bosnia-Herzegovina and a controversial red card penalty given to the US.
On WFAN, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the Mets owner's podcast appearance where he confirmed there was tension between Francisco Lindor and Juan Soto during the 2025 season. Cohen also made it clear that David Stearns will remain the Mets' President of Baseball Operations through his full five-year plan, even as the team spirals.
The New York Yankees have officially entered a full-blown June swoon after dropping their 7th straight game, and Chris McMonigle has had enough. From blown opportunities to Aaron Boone's decisions, Cody Bellinger's struggles, and another frustrating extra-inning loss, Craig Carton and Big Mac break down everything that's gone wrong in the Bronx.
Plus, Mitchell Robinson leaves the Knicks to sign with the Boston Celtics, ending his championship run in New York. Was letting Mitch walk the right move? Can Leon Rose replace his rebounding and defense, or will Knicks fans regret this decision?
The Yankees lineup, concern over Jazz Chisholm returning so quickly, and a strange food poisoning situation involving Spencer Jones and Ryan McMahon. With the Yankees trying to stop the bleeding, Shaun questions whether the team is being cautious enough and what this latest mess could mean as they look to get back on track.
The bigger fireworks come from Steve Cohen’s comments about David Stearns, Juan Soto, and Francisco Lindor. Shaun breaks down why Cohen’s words raise real questions about the Mets’ front office, last year’s clubhouse issues, and whether the team’s offseason moves were more about keeping its biggest stars comfortable than actually building the best roster.
Shaun Morash reacts in real time as Mitchell Robinson leaves the Knicks for the Boston Celtics, turning a beloved championship piece into a rival overnight. The move is painful for Knicks fans, especially because Robinson was a homegrown favorite who stuck around through the franchise’s lowest points before helping deliver a title.
The conversation also digs into whether the Knicks can survive without Robinson, why his free throw struggles and injury history made his future complicated, and how Boston adds another emotional layer to the loss. Shaun also continues the Yankees debate with callers questioning Brian Cashman, the lineup’s lack of contact, and whether the front office has the urgency to fix a struggling roster at the deadline.
The Yankees are suddenly spiraling, and Shaun Morash is no longer trying to talk himself out of panic. After a historically bad offensive stretch, fresh injury concerns, and a brutal showing against Detroit, the frustration around this team has reached a new level.
Shaun digs into the warning signs that make this feel bigger than a typical slump, from Cam Schlittler looking human to the uncertainty around Aaron Judge’s return. With the trade deadline approaching, he questions whether the Yankees can afford to wait for injured stars or if the front office needs to act before the season slips away.
We started the morning with a little World Cup excitement, LeBron leaving the Lakers news, and talked about the future of Mitchell Robinson.
As Craig and Big Mac rip into the New York Mets 2026 season, Darryl Strawberry calls in to defend the entire team and organization.
Are the Yankees officially in a June swoon? Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debate whether New York's five-game skid is just a rough stretch or the beginning of something much worse. With Aaron Judge still out, Ben Rice and Cody Bellinger struggling, and the offense completely disappearing, Craig says the Yankees "stink right now" while Big Mac isn't ready to panic just yet.
Shaun and Tiki react to Jazz Chisholm’s scary collision and turn it into a bigger conversation about trust, urgency, and the Yankees’ handling of injuries. What starts as a debate over dugout habits and a lollipop scare quickly becomes a serious question about whether the team should play it safe with one of its most important players.
The conversation expands into Aaron Boone’s future, Brian Cashman’s deadline pressure, and whether the Yankees are built well enough to dominate a weak American League. Shaun and Tiki also dig into the roster holes, Ben Rice’s recent slump, the need for real additions, and why this Yankees season may ultimately be judged by whether they finally get back to the World Series.
The Yankees are stumbling through another June swoon, and Shaun Morash and Tiki Barber are asking whether this is just a rough patch or a sign of a much bigger problem. With the offense disappearing, mistakes piling up, and Tampa Bay moving back in front, the pressure around the Yankees is starting to feel impossible to ignore.
Shaun and Tiki dig into the injuries, fatigue, poor fundamentals, and leadership questions surrounding Aaron Boone as the same concerns keep resurfacing year after year. The conversation turns to whether Boone’s messaging is enough, why Giancarlo Stanton’s presence feels missed, and what another season without a championship could mean for the Yankees manager.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the Yankees getting swept by the Red Sox, falling out of first place, and the growing concerns surrounding their postseason hopes. But according to Craig, the Mets somehow managed to have an even WORSE weekend.
From Steve Cohen's controversial comments and fan backlash to the firing of Carlos Mendoza, Juan Soto clubhouse drama, and why Craig believes Cohen should take advice from James Dolan, nothing is off limits in this fiery opening segment of The Carton Show.
Shaun and Tiki talk about the Yankees getting swept against the Red Sox and why Boone sounded so positive at the end of the game.
Sad news that Chris Johnson, a former running back for the Tennessee Titans, contracts ALS at the age of 39.
We talk some Mets disaster including when Steve Gelbs was talking seriously to Gary, Keith & Ron in the pre-game about the Mendoza firing, Mr. Met was dancing right behind him.
Cookie and Pete Hoffman break down the New York Knicks re-signing Jose Alvarado and the financial logistics of keeping Mitchell Robinson on the roster. They examine the fallout from the New York Mets firing Carlos Mendoza and brainstorm ways to keep fans engaged at Citi Field on WFAN. The duo also reacts to a caller's huge gambling win and critiques staff attendance during major news days.
01:54 - Alvarado Re-Signs With Knicks
07:53 - Historic Knicks Betting Win
13:18 - Mendoza Firing and Mets Woes
19:45 - Anthony Gallo’s Pink Eye
22:51 - Advice For Chris McMonigle
Former Mets manager Terry Collins joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on WFAN to react to Carlos Mendoza's firing and doesn't hold back. Collins explains why managers have to demand accountability, why today's Mets need to get back to baseball fundamentals, and why he still believes this team has enough talent to turn things around.
Carlos Mendoza is OUT as Mets manager, but was he really the problem? Todd Zeile joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on WFAN to deliver a powerful defense of Mendoza, saying he was sent into battle with "no weapons" and that the front office deserves far more blame. Zeile also questions David Stearns' roster construction, discusses Steve Cohen's role in the firing, and reveals what really happens inside a clubhouse after a manager gets fired.
Friend of the Carton Show comedian Paul Virzi joins Craig to catch up on life including how the Knicks changed the way he viewed the world and how he views the Mets firing of Carlos Mendoza through a Yankees fans lens.
Carton explains why Steve Cohen actually did Mendoza a favor, shifts the blame squarely onto David Stearns, questions the future of the Mets organization, and breaks down what happens next with Andy Green taking over as interim manager.
Evan, Tiki, and Shaun react to the news of Carlos Mendoza's firing and discuss the Mets' mess.
We react to the news that the New York Mets have fired manager Carlos Mendoza. Plus, your calls.
Hold on to your hats, we actually talked about the World Cup in this segment and are excited about Team USA.
After surrendering 20 runs in a disastrous doubleheader and committing SIX infield errors, Mets fans are fed up. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the growing outrage at Citi Field, the chants for Pete Alonso, the backlash against David Stearns, and whether Steve Cohen's biggest gamble has completely blown up in his face.
Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash open Thursday's show by breaking down the Mets' meltdown in Queens and wondering just how Steve Cohen, David Stearns, & Carlos Mendoza got themselves into this mess.
On WFAN's The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into a stunning rumor circulating around baseball: Did Juan Soto sit out on the exact day Francisco Lindor returned because the two stars don't want to play together?
Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash open Wednesday's show by reacting to the Mets' loss last night, Kodai Senga's performance, and putting the final touches on what they said is a "dead" season from the guys in Queens.
Another bad pitching performance by Kodai Senga. Boomer said his confidence is in the toilet. Gio said there’s no sadder video on the internet than the one of Evan Roberts at the Mets game.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle welcome former NFL reporter Chrissy Froyd to The Carton Show on WFAN for a stunning interview about the controversy surrounding Dianna Russini and Mike Vrabel. Freud claims the issue goes far beyond one person and says she knows of other alleged relationships between reporters and NFL sources.
On WFAN's Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the bizarre controversy surrounding Jazz Chisholm playing second base with a lollipop in his mouth during the Yankees' loss to the Tigers. Aaron Boone reportedly wasn't happy, fans exploded online, and Craig can't understand why THIS is the issue everyone is focused on while the Yankees have bigger problems.
The Eastern Conference landscape has completely flipped with the ultimate irony: the Nets have acquired Julius Randle seven years after mocking the Knicks for signing him. The trade, though, makes the Nets a better basketball team. Plus, we dive into the massive ramifications of Giannis Antetokounmpo heading to the Miami Heat and how it impacts the defending champion Knicks.
It's NBA Draft day and big trades happened including Julius Randle to the Nets and Giannis to the Heat.
Fresh off an NBA Championship, Craig Carton throws out a bombshell idea on WFAN: should the Knicks trade Karl-Anthony Towns and Mikal Bridges for Giannis Antetokounmpo?
Evan and Tiki open Monday's show by discussing whether or not the Yankees have made it to the same spot as the Knicks: where nothing matters until the playoffs.
Boomer and Gio break down a wild weekend at Shinnecock Hills after Wyndham Clark flips the script to capture the U.S. Open! The guys recap the course conditions, Clark’s legendary escape out of the fescue on 16, and the "embarrassing" Tri-State gallery fans who were aggressively heckling him down the stretch.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open Friday's show by refusing to let go of the 2025-26 CHAMPION New York Knicks, debating just how worried fans should be about James Dolan's proclamation on The Carton Show about the salary cap's second apron, and wondering if Aaron Boone might just be the best manager in MLB.
The Knicks are champions, the parade glow is still fresh, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber begin the conversation every fan knew was coming: what happens next? James Dolan’s comments about the NBA’s second apron turn the celebration into a debate over money, flexibility, and how far an owner should go to protect a championship window.
Evan pushes back on the idea that any New York owner should say a check is too big, while Tiki weighs the business reality of keeping a contender together. The conversation also touches on Leon Rose’s role, the possibility of running it back with key pieces like Mitchell Robinson and Landry Shamet, fan reaction to the parade, and a caller’s throwback frustration over “Who Let the Dogs Out.”
Craig and Big Mac recap their experience walking through the "controlled zoo" of downtown Manhattan during the New York Knicks championship parade on The Carton Show. They reflect on the emotional weight of the victory, Jalen Brunson’s speech to the doubters, and the "now what" feeling facing fans after ending a 53-year drought.
01:00 - Knicks Parade Atmosphere
06:14 - Security And Logistics
11:32 - Brunson And Parade Speeches
13:51 - Post-Championship Reality
16:46 - Travel And Station Appreciation
The Knicks are NBA champions, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber take listeners inside the celebration as New York honors Jalen Brunson, the roster, coaches, and front office after a historic title run.
From Brunson thanking the fans and reflecting on the journey to the team receiving keys to the city, the scene is filled with emotion, humor, big crowd reactions, and plenty of classic New York energy as the franchise celebrates its first championship since 1973.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber take listeners through the championship ceremony at City Hall as the Knicks are introduced, the crowd erupts, and Mike Breen gives voice to a moment New York fans waited 53 years to experience. From the national anthem to the team’s arrival with the trophy, the celebration becomes a powerful mix of nostalgia, pride, and pure citywide joy.
The speeches bring the day to life, with Mayor Mamdani honoring generations of Knicks heartbreak, memorable franchise moments, and the resilience that carried this team to a title. Evan and Tiki react as city officials, James Dolan, Leon Rose, and Mike Brown address the crowd, celebrating the fans, the players, the organization, and a championship run that finally gave New York its long awaited parade.
Live from City Hall, Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber set the scene as the Knicks championship parade begins and New York erupts into a celebration decades in the making. With Jalen Brunson, Karl Anthony Towns, Josh Hart, and the rest of the champs moving through packed streets, the long imagined parade finally becomes real.
The conversation captures the emotion, chaos, and disbelief of the day while also breaking down how this Knicks team was built. Evan and Tiki focus on the chip on the shoulder shared by Brunson, Hart, OG Anunoby, Mikal Bridges, and Towns, all players whose former teams were willing to move on before Leon Rose brought them together and turned them into NBA champions.
Evan & Tiki are doing their show live from there and Evan has been there since 4am this morning.
In a rare and must-see interview, New York Knicks owner James Dolan joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on WFAN following the franchise's first championship since 1973!
Dolan opens up about the emotional title run, his now-viral speech to the team, the culture change that transformed the Knicks, and what this championship means to generations of fans.
The voice of the New York Knicks, Mike Breen, joined Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on WFAN and delivered an unforgettable interview following the Knicks' historic championship.
Breen shares the incredible story of sleeping on a couch in an Atlanta Marriott after Game 5, reveals the origin of his iconic "BANG!" call, explains why Jalen Brunson belongs in the same mental toughness conversation as Kobe Bryant, and admits fans almost got the legendary TRIPLE BANG!
The New York Knicks are NBA Champions, and Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle are counting down the hours until the first Knicks championship parade in franchise history! 🏆🗽
On WFAN, Carton explains why he believes the celebration will be one of the greatest moments New York City has ever seen, while Big Mac can't wait to see Jalen Brunson, Josh Hart, and the champions partying through the Canyon of Heroes.
With Shaun in for Evan, Tiki Barber helps set the stage for a huge Knicks parade eve in New York City. The excitement around the Knicks championship opens the door to a bigger citywide question: are the Knicks most likely to win again, or is another New York team ready to break through next?
Shaun makes the case that the Yankees could be the next local team to deliver a title, pointing to their young talent, dominant pitching, and the possible championship energy spreading through town. Tiki pushes back by focusing on what made the Knicks special, from resilience to killer instinct, and asks whether the Yankees truly have that same edge.
Excitement builds for a massive New York Knicks ticker tape parade as merchandise sales soar to record-breaking levels. Comparisons are drawn between this historic moment and the 1994 Rangers championship, highlighting the deep passion of New York sports fans across the tri-state area.
01:26 - Knicks Ticker Tape Parade
04:50 - Historic Knicks Merch Sales
07:54 - 1994 Rangers Championship Gear
The Knicks are NBA Champions, and Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle reveal a stunning piece of New York history: the 2026 celebration will be the FIRST ticker-tape parade in franchise history!
Craig and Big Mac debate whether former coach Tom Thibodeau deserves an invitation after helping rebuild the franchise before Mike Brown delivered the championship.
The Knicks are NBA champions, and Jalen Brunson’s place in New York sports history is suddenly the debate of the city. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to Brunson delivering the kind of moment Knicks fans waited generations to see, then ask how far one championship can carry him among New York’s most beloved sports figures.
The conversation turns into a passionate climb up the New York icon ladder, with Brunson compared to Tiki, Curtis Martin, Alex Rodriguez, Henrik Lundqvist, Patrick Ewing, Mike Piazza, Mark Messier, Eli Manning and Derek Jeter. Evan argues that leading the Knicks to a title carries a rare weight in this city, while Tiki and the crew push back with points about longevity, legacy, playoff greatness and what it really means to become a New York legend.
We started the show with Boomer wondering how things will go when James Dolan tells the team they are going to the White House.
The Carton Show reacts to Dolan's speech which was released by Josh Hart & Jalen Brunson's Roommate's Podcast
On WFAN's Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle hilariously discuss the upcoming Knicks championship parade, open containers, and how fans can "blend in" with the millions expected to flood the streets of Manhattan.
At long last, the streak is over. For the first time since 1973, the New York Knicks are champions! Craig Carton and C-Mac hopped on YouTube the second the horn sounded on the Knicks' 94-90 win over the Spurs in Game 5 to give their instant reaction and bask in the glory.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber are joined by New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani to capture the emotion of the Knicks finally delivering a championship moment New York has waited decades to celebrate. Mamdani shares how he watched the comeback unfold, what the streets felt like after the win, and why he had no hesitation declaring Jalen Brunson the new king of New York.
The interview also dives into plans for Thursday’s Canyon of Heroes parade, the city’s efforts to keep celebrations safe, and the way this Knicks title has united fans across neighborhoods and political divides. From Brunson’s legendary closeout performance to parade logistics and a citywide release of joy, this segment is all about New York basketball history becoming real.
We talked about all the moves the Knicks made to get here. We also discussed the importance of MVP Jalen Brunson. Boomer called Victor Wembanyama the dirtiest player in the NBA.
Heavyweight Ciryl Gane is set to take on Alex Pereira for the interim UFC Heavyweight belt. The humble Ciryl discusses his biggest challenges with Hoff as he goes up against the former two division champion.
Hoff gets a chance to speak with Steve Garcia as he is set for his biggest fight of his career against Diego Lopes in his featherweight bout this Sunday, June 14th at UFC Freedom 250 on the White House Lawn.
Heavyweight Josh Hokit joins Hoff in a brief conversation about his upcoming fight with Derek Lewis. The Interview may go just as long as his fight this Sunday, June 14th on the White House Lawn for UFC Freedom 250.
Chaos and comedy hit the Carton Show on WFAN as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle welcomed Knicks anthem singer Avery Wilson into the studio!
Things got WILD on WFAN as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle welcomed Knicks legend Gerald Wilkins to the studio! Gerald reflected on his Knicks career, Patrick Ewing, Pat Riley, Michael Jordan, and the current Knicks' championship run before the conversation exploded into an all-time GOAT debate.
Wilkins passionately argued for LeBron James, while Carton defended Michael Jordan, leading to a hilarious and heated back-and-forth that every basketball fan needs to hear. Plus, Gerald shares incredible stories about MJ's aura, putting Jordan's picture on his bathroom mirror, and why today's Knicks have destiny on their side.
The New York Knicks are one victory away from ending a 53-year championship drought, but Chris McMonigle still isn't ready to celebrate. On WFAN's Carton Show, Craig Carton and C-Mac debate whether Knicks fans should continue celebrating OG Anunoby's unforgettable Game 4 tip-in or start worrying about finishing off Victor Wembanyama and the Spurs in Game 5.
The Knicks are on the verge of a championship, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why closing out the Spurs may come down to one simple fix: starting faster. After repeatedly falling behind early and relying on historic comebacks, New York has a chance to take control from the opening tip and turn a tense series into a statement win.
Evan and Tiki break down the Spurs’ fatigue, the Knicks’ dominance in recent closeout games, and the growing scrutiny around Victor Wembanyama’s physical play. They also spotlight Miles McBride as a forgotten X factor whose shooting could shift the game and give the Knicks another weapon off the bench.
We started with all of the additional videos posted to social media regarding the Knicks/Spurs game that we didn’t see while we were on the air yesterday. Among them was a video of Wemby going after OG’s knee.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the New York Knicks pulling off a miraculous 107-106 victory over the San Antonio Spurs in Game 4 of the NBA Finals. After trailing by an astonishing 29 points, the Knicks willed their way back into the game with clutch shots from Jalen Brunson and OG Anunoby. Hear why the guys believe this is the greatest comeback in professional sports history and what it means as they look ahead to Game 5.
The Knicks are one win away from an NBA championship after erasing a 29 point deficit in a Finals comeback that felt impossible even after it happened. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to the shock, the emotion, and the surreal feeling of watching a Knicks team refuse to quit on the biggest stage.
They break down why this comeback was not a fluke, how the Spurs lost control, and why OG Anunoby’s late game heroics may have created one of the defining moments in franchise history. From Jalen Brunson’s stamina to Victor Wembanyama’s missed free throws, the conversation captures the disbelief and excitement of a night Knicks fans will never forget.
The Knicks come from 29 points behind to take Game 4 behind the legendary tip-in by OG Anunoby.
New York Knicks Owner James Dolan joined the Carton Show in studio to discuss everything from Watch parties, Donald Trump, and the Knicks title hopes!
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the NBA refusing to issue a retroactive flagrant foul against Victor Wembanyama after his controversial play involving Jalen Brunson. Carton blasts the league, calls Wembanyama a dirty player, and says the Knicks should treat Game 4 like a war.
Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash open with the chaos around Madison Square Garden and the latest security advisory for fans, commuters, and anyone near Penn Station before turning to the biggest Knicks story of the day: Victor Wembanyama avoiding a retroactive flagrant foul after his altercation with Jalen Brunson.
Evan argues that while the missed call was wrong, the NBA’s decision may actually benefit the Knicks because Wemby is not one flagrant away from an automatic suspension. The conversation then shifts to Game 4, the hostile MSG crowd waiting for Wemby, and the challenge facing the Knicks as they try to respond to San Antonio’s physical style.
We started with the Knicks/Spurs as game 4 is tonight at MSG. Jose Alvarado said Wemby got away with one, but it will be his last. We talked about how refs can really affect a game in the NBA.
The Knicks lost for the first time in 46 days, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why Game 3 was less about one bad call or one bad performance and more about how hard it is to win an NBA Finals game. The Spurs brought a tougher, more physical approach, disrupted New York’s offense, and gave Knicks fans their first real dose of pressure in weeks.
Evan and Tiki break down the sloppiness, the turnovers, Jalen Brunson’s rough stretches, Karl Anthony Towns’ quiet night, Mikal Bridges’ disappearing act, and OG Anunoby’s standout performance. They also weigh the officiating complaints, the atmosphere at Madison Square Garden, and why the mood around Knicks fans still felt more confident than panicked.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the Knicks' first loss in over a month after Game 3 of the NBA Finals. Despite the defeat, Carton says Knicks fans are overreacting and reminds everyone New York still leads the series 2-1. The guys break down Jalen Brunson's struggles, turnovers, questionable officiating, Victor Wembanyama's controversial play, and why Game 4 at Madison Square Garden could define the series.
We started with the Knicks loss in game 3, the first game at the Garden. The Knicks had won 13 straight games before the loss. The Knicks couldn’t come back this time in the fourth quarter after having a lead at the half.
The Knicks are up 2-0 in the NBA Finals and New York City is buzzing! On WFAN's Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle discuss the electric atmosphere surrounding Game 3 at Madison Square Garden, why this could be the biggest sporting event New York has seen in decades, and how Jalen Brunson, Karl-Anthony Towns, Mikal Bridges and the Knicks have everyone believing a championship is within reach.
They also debate Victor Wembanyama's struggles, the Spurs' mistakes, the Knicks' championship mindset, and whether President Trump's attendance at Game 3 is being overblown.
The Knicks are two wins away from a championship, and the feeling around New York has shifted from hope to something much bigger. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dig into the nerves, excitement, and disbelief surrounding a team that suddenly looks capable of finishing the job.
They discuss why Knicks fans are both confident and terrified, the dangers of talking parade too early, and the basketball reasons this team should believe. From Mikal Bridges’ locked in mentality to Karl Anthony Towns delivering when it matters, Jalen Brunson’s clutch moments, and the Spurs trying to convince themselves they are fine, the conversation captures a city on the edge of basketball history.
Knicks took a 2-0 series lead Friday night with KAT dominating Victor Wembanyama. We also talked about the officiating and wondering how tonight’s game will be called.
Craig Carton stunned Chris McMonigle with a jaw-dropping claim that Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce are planning to get married at Madison Square Garden during Fourth of July weekend. The guys discuss the security, celebrity guest list, cost, catering, possible performances, and whether the idea is iconic or completely over-the-top.
Marv shares incredible stories from the Knicks' championship teams of 1970 and 1973, relives the iconic Willis Reed Game 7 entrance, discusses why Walt Frazier deserved Finals MVP, and recalls the unforgettable O.J. Simpson chase during the 1994 NBA Finals.
Plus, Marv gives his thoughts on Jalen Brunson, compares today's Knicks to the championship teams of the past, reveals the player who impressed him most in his broadcasting career, and settles the Michael Jordan vs. LeBron James debate.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the shocking news that Aaron Judge will miss at least two months with a stress fracture in his first rib. Is the Yankees' season still alive, or is this worse than they're saying?
Aaron Judge’s rib injury has created real uncertainty for the Yankees, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down why this setback may not be the season ending blow fans feared. With Judge shut down and a reevaluation still weeks away, the conversation turns to how long he could be out, what the best case timeline looks like, and why this roster is better built to withstand his absence than past Yankees teams.
A rib injury that'll take 4-6 weeks to heal. A caller wonders if a bone stimulator would be helpful.
We started with a preview of tonight’s game 2 between the Knicks and Spurs. The Knicks are actually underdogs tonight. Dylan Harper reposted a video of De’Aaron Fox playing poorly in the fourth quarter when Harper was on the bench.
Breaking Yankees news had Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle stunned on WFAN. With Aaron Judge undergoing further imaging and consulting a specialist in thoracic outlet syndrome, Carton shared his own experience with the condition and explained why a diagnosis could mean season-ending surgery.
On WFAN's Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to another unbelievable Knicks comeback, Jalen Brunson's fourth-quarter magic, Karl-Anthony Towns' huge performance, and why this team simply refuses to lose. Carton even goes as far as declaring the series over and calling the Knicks the 2026 NBA Champions.
CP The Fanchise joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber to break down the Knicks’ Game 1 Finals win and the growing belief that this team has a real championship identity.
The conversation centers on Jalen Brunson’s toughness after another injury scare, Karl Anthony Towns’ aggressive impact on both ends, Mike Brown’s coaching advantage, San Antonio’s likely adjustments, the electric Knicks watch party scene, and why CP thinks the Knicks can head back to the Garden up 2 to 0.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to a dramatic Knicks Game 1 win over the Spurs, where Jalen Brunson briefly gave fans a season flashing before their eyes before returning to lead another unforgettable victory. Brunson’s toughness, late shot making, and ability to answer every scare became the defining story of the night.
The guys break down how the Knicks handled adversity, from Brunson’s injury moments to a 14 point deficit and a late Spurs push that briefly put New York behind. They also highlight the bench stretch that gave the Knicks control, OG Anunoby’s fourth quarter impact, Karl Anthony Towns’ physical play, Josh Hart’s all around production, and the coaching edge that helped New York close on a dominant run.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle welcomed rising Brooklyn rapper Lil Dee (Danny James) to WFAN to perform his Knicks anthem ahead of Game 1 of the NBA Finals. But what started as a freestyle session turned into an unforgettable moment when Craig surprised Lil Dee with a phone call from none other than hip-hop legend Lil Wayne!
The Carton Show captures the electric atmosphere in New York as the Knicks prepare for their first NBA Finals appearance in decades. Craig and Big Mac break down the matchup against Victor Wembanyama, San Antonio's controversial ticket policies, and James Dolan's narrative about the team gelling at the perfect time.
01:07 - NBA Finals Preview
06:18 - Knicks Team Likability
08:14 - MSG Watch Party
09:53 - Spurs Ticket Controversy
11:01 - Series Prediction Rules
As the Knicks reach the NBA Finals, Evan Roberts wrestles with the one thing he still cannot see: orange and blue filling the Canyon of Heroes. He explains why, even after believing in this team all season, his experience rooting for losing franchises makes it impossible for him to confidently predict a championship.
Tiki Barber pushes back, arguing this Knicks team has earned a different kind of belief after building its way to this moment. The debate moves from fan trauma to the actual matchup, including Victor Wembanyama’s defensive presence, Josh Hart’s importance from three, Jalen Brunson’s reliability, and the role players who could decide whether the Knicks finally break through.
NYC hasn't had a champ since 2011. The Knicks remind Boomer of the late-blooming New York Giants in 2007.
Craig Carton and Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle react live to the Judge news, debate how serious the injury could be, discuss Yankees prospect Carlos Lagrange's bullpen transition, and compare Judge's injury situation to Mitchell Robinson's expected return for the Knicks. Plus, the guys go completely off the rails with stories about Craig being the THIRD-BEST Centipede player in the world as a kid, arcade games, old-school tournaments, and some classic Carton Show chaos.
NBA and New York City basketball legend Kenny Anderson joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on WFAN to talk about the Knicks' Finals matchup against the Spurs, why Victor Wembanyama is such a unique challenge, Mitchell Robinson's injury impact, and why European basketball is producing so many stars. Plus, Kenny shares stories from his unforgettable NBA Draft night, walking to Madison Square Garden before being selected by the New Jersey Nets, his years in the NBA, coaching young players, and why developing the next generation matters most to him.
Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the rumored rift within the Philadelphia Eagles locker room involving A.J. Brown and Jalen Hurts. They break down video evidence suggesting Mitchell Robinson will be ready for Game 1 of the NBA Finals despite his recent hand surgery. The conversation takes a turn into pop culture, debating the merits of the Sister Act films and Lauryn Hill’s breakout role.
01:00 - Eagles Locker Room Rift
06:58 - Mitchell Robinson Injury Update
18:45 - Sister Act Movie Discussion
22:20 - Final Knicks Injury Forecast
Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the mystery surrounding Mitchell Robinson’s injury and his absence from media availability before Game 1 against the Spurs. Craig argues that the New York Knicks are deep enough to win the championship series even if Robinson is limited or sidelined. They also touch on the Mets' recent struggles and reports of locker room dysfunction involving A.J. Brown and the Eagles.
01:03 - Mitchell Robinson Injury Mystery
03:47 - Knicks Depth Without Robinson
12:51 - San Antonio Fan Base
17:59 - Mets Struggles & Eagles Drama
Odell Beckham Jr. is back with the Giants, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber say the signing is less about nostalgia and more about concern over Malik Nabers. With Nabers recovering from major knee issues and not looking close to full speed, the Giants’ sudden wave of veteran wide receiver additions feels like a clear sign that they are preparing for uncertainty.
Evan and Tiki break down what Beckham can realistically be at this stage of his career, why Juju Smith Schuster and Braxton Berrios change the conversation, and how the wide receiver room has become a true roster battle. They also debate when Nabers might actually return and why missing significant time would be a major blow to the Giants’ 2026 season.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the blockbuster news that A.J. Brown is officially heading to the New England Patriots—and it sparks a passionate debate about NFL insiders, breaking news, and Dianna Russini's controversial reporting.
Craig argues that Russini deserves full credit for the story after being the first reporter to connect Brown to New England months ago, while questioning why other insiders are rushing to claim the scoop now that the deal is official.
The New York Giants made headlines by bringing back Odell Beckham Jr. while also signing JuJu Smith-Schuster and Braxton Berrios. But are these moves actually helping the Giants, or are they creating more distractions?
On The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to OBJ's return to Big Blue, discuss Malik Nabers' injury concerns after appearing in a charity softball game, debate whether Jaxson Dart has enough weapons around him, and question if the Giants' offseason has become a complete circus.
Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash react to the Knicks landing a Finals matchup with the San Antonio Spurs and explain why, even as Knicks haters, they see it as great news for New York. The Spurs have earned respect after taking down Oklahoma City, but their lack of postseason scars raises real questions about whether they are ready to finish the job.
The guys compare San Antonio’s emotional win to teams that celebrated too soon, debate whether Victor Wembanyama and the Spurs are playing with house money, and contrast that with a Knicks team that has treated every playoff step like business. They also revisit the NBA Cup matchup and why this Finals rematch may give that tournament new meaning.
Hoff talks about Game 7 of the Western Conference Finals and says how he doesn't care who wins.
Carton and Big Mac critique the New York Giants for prolonging a controversy involving Abdul Carter and Jaxson Dart by holding an unnecessary press conference. They also discuss the mystery of Mitchell Robinson’s broken pinky, questioning why the Knicks are hiding the cause of the injury. Finally, they contrast this secrecy with Aaron Boone’s historical honesty regarding off-field accidents.
01:16 - Giants Press Conference News
02:46 - Giants PR Strategy Questioned
10:42 - Mitchell Robinson Injury Mystery
17:40 - Aaron Boone Injury Honesty
Mitchell Robinson’s broken right pinky has Knicks fans anxious, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dig into what the injury could mean with the NBA Finals looming. With Robinson expected to play after surgery while wearing a brace, the big question is how much the injury will affect his pain tolerance, rebounding, lob catching, rim protection, and overall confidence.
The conversation also turns to Robinson’s brutal free throw struggles and whether this is the moment to try something drastic, including the underhanded “granny shot.” Evan and Tiki debate Rick Barry, Wilt Chamberlain, Ronnie Lott, and the difference between football and basketball toughness while weighing whether Robinson can remain a true X factor for the Knicks.
We started with the news that came out yesterday that Mitchell Robinson is dealing with a broken pinky - will it affect him? The Spurs & Thunder are heading to a game 7 tomorrow night. Watching these games, Boomer wonders how the Knicks aren’t favored over both of these teams.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to one of the wildest viral police stop videos ever, a cop accuses a woman of holding her phone in her “right hand”… except she doesn’t HAVE a right hand. Craig can’t stop laughing as the guys break down the unbelievable bodycam footage and the officer still giving her a ticket. Plus, the guys dive into the Knicks waiting for the NBA Finals, why every Knicks fan should root for a Spurs-Thunder Game 7, and why Gerrit Cole’s dominant outing has Yankees fans dreaming big.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to the Giants locker room conversation surrounding Jaxson Dart, Abdul Carter and the political noise that suddenly resurfaced around the team. What first seemed like a small controversy has become a bigger question about leadership, leaks and whether the Giants can keep outside distractions from taking attention away from football.
Evan and Tiki discuss why the issue may have been addressed internally, how John Harbaugh could handle questions about it, and why a modern locker room has to navigate different personalities, politics and public comments. They also debate whether this is truly a problem for the Giants or just noise that will only matter if the team fails to win.
We started with President Trump saying he’s going to attend a Knicks finals game at the Garden and we wondered what type of reaction he would get from the crowd. Umm...
Kurt Thomas joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle to reflect on his 1999 Knicks run and analyze the team’s current dominant postseason performance. They are joined by Tim Hardaway Sr. to discuss roster moves by Leon Rose and share legendary stories about Manute Bol and high-stakes card games on the team plane.
01:26 - Kurt Thomas Joins the Show
04:15 - Rivalry with Reggie Miller
10:13 - Mike Brown’s Coaching Success
13:45 - Leon Rose and Jim Dolan
17:45 - Comparing Brunson and Ewing
23:43 - Jalen Brunson’s Dallas Departure
30:25 - Tim Hardaway Sr. Interview
37:25 - The Manute Bol Story
39:50 - NBA Team Plane Gambling
On The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle unload on the disastrous state of the New York Mets after another embarrassing loss to the Reds. Craig says the Mets season is officially OVER, questions Steve Cohen’s leadership, rips David Stearns’ expensive rebuild, and explains why New York is now a “one baseball town” with the Yankees rolling and the Mets collapsing.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dig into the one matchup issue that could drive Knicks fans crazy in a potential NBA Finals showdown with Oklahoma City: Shai Gilgeous-Alexander’s ability to draw fouls. SGA’s free throw hunting becomes the center of the debate as they compare his whistle to Jalen Brunson’s and ask why one star gets to the line so much more than the other.
The conversation turns into a larger look at how officiating could shape the series, why foul trouble may be just as dangerous as the points SGA scores at the line, and whether Knicks fans should actually want the Thunder because beating the defending champs would silence every critic. Evan and Tiki also weigh the appeal of facing Victor Wembanyama and the Spurs, while making the case that any championship path is valid if the Knicks finish the job.
If the Knicks win it all, every player on that team will be immortalized. Boomer compared Brunson to Aaron Judge on how he goes about his business.
Craig reacts to the Knicks’ dominant playoff run, calls out all the doubters who trashed Mike Brown, Mikal Bridges, and Leon Rose earlier this season, and explains why this Knicks team is unlike ANYTHING the NBA has ever seen.
From Jalen Brunson’s leadership to the Knicks destroying teams in closeout games, Carton says this run has officially become historic. Plus, Craig gives credit to James Dolan and Leon Rose for letting the PLAYERS have the spotlight after winning the Eastern Conference.
The Knicks are headed to the NBA Finals, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber capture the surreal feeling of a franchise long defined by frustration suddenly looking like the most dominant team in basketball. What once felt impossible now feels real, as New York has turned playoff closeout games into statements and forced even skeptical fans to believe.
Evan and Tiki break down how the Knicks overwhelmed Cleveland, why their defensive transformation has changed everything, and how contributions from Jalen Brunson, Karl Anthony Towns, Josh Hart, Mikal Bridges, Landry Shamet, Deuce McBride, and Jose Alvarado have made this team so dangerous. They also push back on criticism of the Knicks’ path, arguing that New York can only beat the teams in front of them and has done it with historic force.
We started the show with the Knicks completing the sweep of the Cavaliers. They are not just winning, they are dominating their opponents.
The New York Knicks are now TWO wins away from the NBA Finals and Craig Carton is officially all in. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the Knicks dominating the Cavaliers again, Josh Hart’s huge night, Jalen Brunson’s leadership, Mikal Bridges’ defense, and why this team might be the best Knicks squad ever assembled.
Plus, the mood changes quickly when Craig turns his attention to the New York Giants after Joe Schoen receives a multi-year extension, Malik Nabers’ injury concerns grow, and the Giants’ defensive line takes another hit. Craig even suggests the Jets may finish with a better record than the Giants this season.
Evan & Tiki react to another massive Knicks playoff win and discuss the real possibility of them winning it all.
Boomer believes that this current Knicks team has the potential to be the greatest ever. Also, there's controversy after the guys go to dinner.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle are joined by John Fanta to break down the Knicks’ shocking comeback win over Cleveland in Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals. Fanta explains why he picked the Knicks in six, why the Cavs “lost their souls” in the fourth quarter, and why Cleveland fans saw the collapse coming. The guys also dive into Donovan Mitchell, Kenny Atkinson’s coaching decisions, Jalen Brunson’s dominance, Karl-Anthony Towns needing to step up, and whether this is finally the Knicks’ year to win a championship.
Big Mac and a physically ill Craig Carton discuss the Knicks' chances to sweep the Cavaliers after a dominant Game 1 performance. They analyze Jalen Brunson's impact and the return of meaningful Knicks playoff talk to local radio. The discussion takes a nostalgic turn toward classic sitcoms before concluding with updates on the Yankees and Mets.
01:00 - Carton Battles Stomach Issues
04:48 - Knicks Seek Game 2 Stamp
09:19 - WFAN Knicks History Talk
14:03 - Different Strokes Cast Nostalgia
17:46 - Local Baseball Slump Analysis
The Knicks are one win away from putting real pressure on Cleveland, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explain why Game 2 could shape far more than this series. With injuries piling up out West, the guys look at how the Knicks can turn urgency, health, and rest into a potential Finals advantage.
Evan and Tiki break down why the playoffs often become a war of attrition, why closing out Cleveland quickly matters, and how Mike Brown may need to adjust against the Cavaliers’ size. They also examine Karl-Anthony Towns’ role as a point center, the value of shooters like Landry Shamet and Deuce McBride, and how the Knicks can avoid falling flat while chasing a commanding 2-0 lead.
John Minko has come into the studio for Eddie’s last day and he was getting a little emotional. Minko talked about all the things Eddie has done with the station over the years.
Craig and Chris give a heart felt tribute to Boomer Esiason after it was announced he would be inducted into the Radio Hall of Fame
Big Mac breaks down the New York Knicks' improbable 22-point comeback victory over the Cleveland Cavaliers at Madison Square Garden. He praises Jalen Brunson's superstar performance and the crucial coaching adjustments made down the stretch. They also criticize fans who left the game early and address the New York Mets' blunder regarding Gary Carter's jersey number.
01:08 - Knicks Historic Comeback
08:01 - Early Exit Fan Critique
11:51 - Mets Gary Carter Blunder
17:25 - Brunson Performance Analysis
21:31 - Madison Square Garden Chaos
The Knicks stunned Madison Square Garden with a comeback that instantly entered franchise history, rallying from 22 points down in the fourth quarter to steal Game 1 from Cleveland. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to the chaos, the energy inside the building, and the brilliance of Jalen Brunson leading a comeback that had even loyal fans believing the game was already over.
The guys relive the defining moments from the final minutes, including Landry Shamet’s improbable three, Mikal Bridges’ clutch shooting, and the Cavaliers’ collapse under pressure. They also discuss fans admitting they shut the game off too early, the emotional swing inside the Garden, and why this Knicks team feels different from past playoff runs.
Jalen Brunson turned it on in the fourth quarter as the Knicks came back down 22 to win in OT. Kenny Atkinson sat on his timeouts for some reason as the Knicks came roaring back.
Craig Carton and Big Mac discuss the Yankees' critical win over Toronto and Anthony Volpe’s improved plate discipline. They pivot to a detailed preview of the Knicks-Cavaliers series, with Craig predicting a dominant New York victory. The conversation also covers the Mets' recent surge and Craig's chaotic travel experience returning from Iowa.
01:03 - MLB Recap and Highlights
06:04 - Yankees Defeat Blue Jays
12:30 - Knicks vs Cavaliers Preview
17:42 - NBA Playoff Coaching Analysis
24:08 - Garden Baseball Scorekeeping Debate
Carmelo Anthony joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber for a wide ranging conversation on the Knicks’ playoff run, what has changed under Mike Brown, and why this team may be finding its identity at the perfect time. Melo breaks down the defensive shift, Karl Anthony Towns’ evolution, and the kind of role players who can swing a postseason series.
The conversation also dives into Melo’s own New York story, including why he never became a Net, why he has no regrets about choosing the Knicks, and how personal stability shaped his career decisions. He also addresses the long running Jeremy Lin rumors and explains why he wants to reconnect publicly to celebrate Linsanity as a special moment in Knicks and NBA history.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to a loaded night for New York sports, with the Mets pulling out a chaotic extra innings win, the Yankees surviving a tense finish against Toronto, and Knicks fans counting down to a massive Eastern Conference finals game.
The conversation centers on whether the Mets’ recent surge is something real or simply a fun hot streak, why their young players have made the team more watchable, and how much trust Yankee fans should place in David Bednar after another high wire ninth inning.
We are getting ready for our Kickoff to Summer live from D’Jais in Belmar, NJ this Friday. It will be the last time we see Eddie, as he is retiring after that. We talked to Eddie about if he thinks he will cry on his last day. When does Eddie think it will hit him that he’s actually retired?
While Craig is away Chris & the Crew explore Ben Simmons' transition into professional competitive fishing and his ownership in the South Florida Sails. A caller recounts a chance dinner meeting with Paul McCartney, describing the rock legend's surprising humility and kindness. The discussion also highlights the high-stakes world of elite sport fishing, including Michael Jordan's involvement.
01:00 - Knicks Banners and Fishing
05:51 - Ben Simmons Pro Fishing
10:40 - Meeting Paul McCartney
13:16 - Pro Fishing Tournament Scene
Chris McMonigle is riding solo today, discussing the Mets' resilient performance in the Subway Series following a rotation injury. He evaluates the Yankees' bullpen struggles and roster gaps while looking ahead to the Knicks' playoff series against the Cavaliers.
01:03 - Big Mac Flying Solo
01:53 - Mets Subway Series Mojo
10:29 - Yankees Bullpen Meltdown
18:01 - Yankees Offensive Struggles
20:06 - Knicks Vs Cavs Preview
The Subway Series ended with a shocker, as the Mets pulled off the kind of ninth inning comeback their fans had been conditioned not to expect. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to Tyrone Taylor’s stunning homer, the empty seats at Citi Field, and the rare feeling of the Mets actually delivering a magical late game moment.
The guys also break down why the loss should worry Yankees fans beyond just one ugly afternoon. David Bednar’s latest collapse, Austin Wells’ growing struggles, Aaron Judge’s quiet series, and a rough road trip all become part of a bigger conversation about a Yankees team that is still in good shape but suddenly has real problems to solve.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle are joined by Daryl Strawberry at the MLB Store in NYC ahead of this weekend's Subway Series between the Yankees and Mets!
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open Friday's show from the MLB Store in NYC by discussing... how Craig has convinced himself that the Jets are going to win more football games than the Giants.
MLB Network's Al Leiter, an Emmy-nominated and snubbed sports broadcaster and former Yankee pitcher, joins Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash to discuss growing up a Mets fan, being drafted by the Yankees, playing with legends, and where the Mets and Yankees are today.
Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash discuss the Yankees' situation with Max Fried's elbow - and Tiki has breaking news on what's going on with the star's arm.
Mariano Rivera joins us live at the MLB store in midtown Manhattan. He also has a hot sauce called ‘Mo’s Heat’. He talked about playing for the Yankees and not wanting to go to another team, even though he had offers.
We are live today from the MLB store in midtown Manhattan to kick off the subway series. The Mets are coming in after sweeping the Tigers and the Yankees come in at 1-5 in their last 6 games.
Walt 'Clyde' Frazier joins Craig and Big Mac to discuss his legendary performance in the 1970 NBA Finals and his profound respect for idol Willis Reed. He shares his perspective on the current Knicks roster, praising Jalen Brunson's leadership and the team's impressive depth under Mike Brown. Frazier also reflects on his iconic fashion sense, his childhood in Atlanta, and his long-standing broadcasting career.
02:49 - Willis Reed’s Heroic Impact
09:22 - Story Behind Puma Suede
12:08 - Modern Knicks Roster Analysis
14:18 - Mike Brown’s Coaching Style
17:22 - Ringside at Ali-Frazier
25:08 - Trading for Earl Monroe
30:48 - Rucker Park’s Streetball Legends
38:00 - Jersey Retirement Honor
44:35 - Lessons From Atlanta Roots
50:30 - Broadcasting Under Marty Glickman
Craig and Big Mac break down the New York Giants' upcoming schedule following leaks that place the team in several high-profile primetime slots. They debate Peter Schrager's prediction of an 11-12 win season while analyzing the difficulty of the Giants' closing stretch. Additionally, they address inaccurate reports regarding the New York Jets' opening matchup and share the history behind Walt "Clyde" Frazier's iconic nickname.
01:00 - Walt Frazier Nickname Origin
05:03 - NFL Schedule Release Leaks
08:31 - Giants Season Win Predictions
15:31 - Giants Primetime Schedule Debate
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber focus on the Mets finding a rare spark in a difficult season, as Carson Benge and A.J. Ewing bring energy, athleticism, and a little hope to a team that has badly needed it. The walk off win over Detroit gives fans something to feel good about, even if the Mets remain well under .500 and far from proving they are truly back.
The conversation also centers on the concern surrounding Juan Soto’s foot, another frustrating injury scare in a season already filled with them. Evan and Tiki weigh the excitement of the youth movement against the reality of the Mets’ offensive struggles, the need for cleaner baseball, and the importance of Soto avoiding a longer absence.
OG Anunoby is back practicing with the Knicks - we talk a little preview for the next series. Max Fried left yesterday’s game with elbow soreness. Fried said he doesn’t expect to be out long.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the Yankees going 1-5 on the road trip, the offense completely disappearing, Anthony Volpe struggling again, and the huge concern surrounding Max Fried’s elbow injury scare. Plus, Subway Series hype, Mets chaos, Malik Nabers injury concerns, and Craig predicts the Jets are starting 2-0!
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to a fascinating split in New York baseball, with Yankees fans uneasy about Anthony Volpe’s return while Mets fans rally around the arrival of A.J. Ewing. The Yankees’ shortstop situation becomes a test of whether Aaron Boone and Brian Cashman are truly operating differently this season.
The discussion centers on why Jose Caballero should keep the job when healthy, what Volpe’s role should be moving forward, and how Ewing’s debut instantly injected energy into a struggling Mets season. From patient at bats to a fan base desperate for hope, Ewing gave the Mets something worth watching.
AJ Ewing had 3 walks, a stolen base and an RBI triple. Plus, David Stearns refuses to address Mendoza's future with the Mets.
Carton considers a potential studio visit from Rich Robinson before examining the tragic career of Otis Redding and the "deal with the devil" music theory. They analyze the Mets' trajectory toward a 100-loss season and debate Jazz Chisholm Jr.'s maturity following a rough performance for the Yankees. The conversation also explores humorous personal habits like whistling on the toilet to avoid family stress and a lunch review of sandwiches from Faicco's.
01:04 - Rich Robinson Studio Visit
04:13 - Otis Redding History
08:14 - Mets Relevance Crisis
11:41 - Bathroom Hiding Habits
18:24 - Jazz Chisholm Maturity Debate
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to the Yankees’ four game losing streak and explain why the concern is not panic, but the offense suddenly going quiet. After another frustrating one run loss, they look at how a team with strong overall numbers can still feel vulnerable when key bats stop producing.
The conversation focuses on Jazz Chisholm’s rough start, his 50 50 comments, and whether he is pressing in a lineup where he does not need to be the hero. Evan and Tiki also debate whether skipping the media after a bad night matters, why Austin Wells needs to wake up, and the strange handling of Jose Caballero’s finger injury.
Craig Carton and Big Mac analyze the New York Yankees' recent four-game skid and the offensive disappearing act of Jazz Chisholm Jr. They also discuss the lack of leaks surrounding the New York Jets' schedule compared to other NFL teams. The conversation shifts to the New York Mets' struggles under David Stearns before concluding with personal banter and a featured segment on grilling with Premio sausage.
01:05 - Carton Show Intro
02:47 - NFL Schedule Leaks
06:40 - Yankees Slump Analysis
09:06 - Jazz Chisholm Jr. Struggles
20:23 - Mets Opening Struggles
Craig Carton walked into the studio to talk about all the condiments in his office. He also talked about C-Mac taking a 2-week Disney cruise.
We started with the Cavaliers beating the Pistons to even the series 2-2 as the Knicks are resting at home. Gio is feeling extra confident as a Knicks fan and it’s a weird feeling.
Light Heavyweight Khalil Rountree sits down with Hoff to talk about his rise to the top of the division.
Follow @HoffWFAN
Craig Carton and Big Mac celebrate the New York Knicks' historic dominance and the embarrassing takeover of Philadelphia's home court by Knicks fans. They heavily criticize Joel Embiid's comments regarding the Sixers' season being a success following their elimination. The discussion also touches on the current struggles of the Yankees and Mets, alongside Craig's upcoming travel plans to Iowa.
01:11 - Knicks Dominance Over Philly
04:36 - Joel Embiid Success Comments
09:58 - Philadelphia City Disdain
18:16 - New York Baseball Update
21:21 - Craig's Iowa Trip
The Knicks are headed back to the Eastern Conference Finals, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to a blowout that felt like more than just a series clincher. New York overwhelmed Philadelphia on the court and in the stands, turning a road playoff game into what sounded and looked like a Knicks home game.
Evan and Tiki break down the Knicks’ scorching shooting, the Sixers’ visible surrender, and the stunning fan takeover that left Philly embarrassed. They also debate whether this seven game Knicks surge is starting to look unstoppable, how injuries have not slowed them down, and why Josh Hart’s postgame jab at Philadelphia landed so hard.
Today's show begins with the Knicks dominant performance yesterday against the Sixers and how they dominated the entire series. Boomer called the level of play from the Knicks, ‘breathtaking’.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to massive New York Jets news as Breece Hall signs a new 3-year extension, discuss the potential of the Jets offense with Geno Smith, and preview Knicks vs Sixers Game 3 in Philadelphia. Plus, Spencer Jones makes his Yankees debut, Dana White jokes about Big Mac missing the studio, and the show takes an emotional turn when Craig personally reaches out to help a caller battling gambling addiction.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to another frustrating Mets loss, even as the team finally strings together back to back series wins. The conversation centers on why moral victories are not enough for a club still buried under .500 and why every missed opportunity feels magnified.
They also dig into the renewed Pete Alonso drama, David Stearns’ roster building, Juan Soto’s quiet big moments, and the frustration around a Mets lineup that still does not look good enough. What should have been a step forward instead becomes another reminder of how much work this team still has to do.
The Knicks dodged a bullet with the OG Anunoby injury. He likely won’t play tonight and may not play in the rest of this series because of how much better the Knicks are than the Sixers.
Yankees legend & Timberwolves Owner Alex Rodriguez calls into the Carton show to catch up with Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle.
The Knicks are up 2 to 0 after doing exactly what they needed to do against the 76ers, but the biggest story is the health of OG Anunoby. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to a gritty playoff win that was not pretty, not dominant, and not comfortable, while sorting through why OG’s injury scare immediately changes the mood around the series.
Evan and Tiki compare this moment to OG’s previous postseason injury against Indiana, debate whether the Knicks can still finish off Philadelphia without him, and explain why his defense, shooting, and clutch impact have become so essential to New York’s championship hopes. They also break down the Sixers’ late-game fatigue without Joel Embiid, the Knicks’ defensive stand, and the Josh Hart three set up by OG that helped turn the game.
OG Anunoby left with a hamstring injury and Gio said they are not a championship team without him. He is very concerned for the Knicks if he is going to be out for the next round.
Knicks legend John Starks stop by the studio to preview Game 2 of the Knicks vs Sixers series. The trio talk a wide range of Knicks and hoops topics, as well as the growth of James Dolan as an owner.
Dana White discusses the logistics of the upcoming Freedom 250 event at the White House and his vision for revitalizing boxing over the next five years. He shares stories from the early days of the UFC, including hiring Joe Rogan and the impact of Ronda Rousey on women's MMA. He also delves into his personal gambling habits and his approach to raising his children.
02:08 - White House Event Logistics
05:08 - Future Business Strategy
06:13 - Baccarat And Gambling Habits
10:30 - Handling The COVID Era
13:04 - Revitalizing Professional Boxing
16:30 - Spike TV Partnership History
20:20 - UFC 328 Fight Breakdown
21:57 - Power Slap Viral Success
27:14 - Joe Rogan Commentary Impact
30:54 - Ronda Rousey's UFC Legacy
The Yankees are rolling, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber are split on just how special this team really is. After another impressive win, the conversation turns from admiration to argument as the guys debate whether this roster’s depth, resilience and nightly confidence are starting to echo the legendary 1998 Yankees.
Evan wants no part of comparing any early season team to the greatest Yankees club of all time, while Tiki and others see familiar signs in the way this group wins, responds and survives injuries. From Ryan McMahon grinding out a huge home run off Jacob deGrom to the bullpen escaping trouble again, the first twenty minutes become a spirited debate over whether this team is simply excellent or already entering sacred territory.
Boomer is working from home today and we started talking about B&G playing golf at Shinnecock yesterday. We also talked about Sixers head coach Nick Nurse as his brother passed away last week unexpectedly and was at the funeral yesterday, but he will coach tonight. Boomer said the Knicks can’t take their foot off the gas and need to dominate again.
They discuss the Mets' weather-delayed series in Colorado and the general lack of excitement surrounding the team's poor play. A debate ensues over SNY's Gary Cohen using the word "pulchritudinous" during a broadcast, leading to a broader conversation about language, historical beauty standards, and the existence of William Shakespeare.
01:00 - Mets Colorado Series Postponed
04:04 - Gary Cohen's Word Choice
07:54 - David Cone's On-Air Comment
14:04 - Spelling Pulchritudinous
18:07 - Shakespeare And Beauty Standards
Craig and Big Mac analyze the New York Knicks' historic dominance in the playoffs, labeling their recent play as some of the most impressive in NBA history. They criticize Joel Embiid for his foul-baiting tactics while also celebrating the New York Yankees' recent winning streak.
01:00 - NY Sports Success
02:14 - Big Mac Fandom Investigation
03:12 - Knicks Historic Dominance
14:45 - Yankees Recent Performance
18:27 - Upcoming Guest Lineup
The Knicks opened their playoff series against Philadelphia with a statement and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down exactly why New York looks so dangerous right now. From Jalen Brunson’s unstoppable scoring to Karl Anthony Towns forcing impossible defensive matchups, the guys explain how the Knicks completely overwhelmed the Sixers in Game 1. They also dive into the team’s growing chemistry, elite ball movement, and why this version of the Knicks finally looks fully connected heading into a deep playoff run.
The conversation also centers around Joel Embiid accusing Mikal Bridges of dirty play after a hard screen sequence and whether the Sixers are already mentally cracking under the pressure. Evan and Tiki debate Embiid’s comments, discuss the adjustments Nick Nurse has to make, and explain why the Knicks’ playoff experience together could be the biggest difference in the series.
Kim Jones joins Craig and Chris to share intimate memories and reflect on the life of legendary Yankees broadcaster John Sterling. She discusses their long-standing friendship, his genuine personality, and the unique legacy he leaves behind in the sports world.
01:00 - Kim Jones Joins
04:22 - Dinner Conversations and Baseball
07:56 - Sterling as an Original
12:06 - Voice of the Yankees
15:23 - Relationship with the Players
Aaron Boone joins to reflect on the legendary career and impact of late Yankees broadcaster John Sterling. He also clarifies the team's decision to option Anthony Volpe to the minor leagues in favor of Jose Caballero's recent performance. They conclude by discussing Gerrit Cole's physical condition and the grueling nature of travel for aging broadcasters.
01:00 - Remembering John Sterling
09:59 - Anthony Volpe Demoted
14:20 - Gerrit Cole Update
16:54 - Challenges Of Travel
Craig and Big Mac reflect on the legendary career of New York Yankees radio voice John Sterling following his passing at 87. They also preview the Knicks' upcoming series against the 76ers, calling Joel Embiid a clown and criticizing Philadelphia's ticket sales strategy. The discussion highlights Sterling's unique home run calls and his impact on generations of baseball fans.
01:11 - Knicks Sixers Preview
03:44 - John Sterling's Legacy
15:55 - Philly Ticket Issues
20:51 - Listener Tributes
23:31 - Yankee Broadcast History
Sweeny Murti joins Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash for an emotional and entertaining conversation about legendary Yankees broadcaster John Sterling. Murti shares what it was really like working alongside Sterling for years, from his larger than life personality to the preparation and passion he brought to every single game. The guys also discuss how Sterling turned Yankees broadcasts into theater and why his energy connected with generations of fans.
The interview dives into Sterling’s unforgettable home run calls, his resistance to modern technology, and the joy he found in creating moments on the air. Murti also explains why Sterling became one of the most imitated voices in sports and how his signature style became part of the fabric of New York baseball. It is a celebration of a broadcasting icon whose voice defined Yankees baseball for decades.
Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash are joined by Suzyn Waldman for an emotional conversation about the life and legacy of John Sterling. Suzyn reflects on their decades together in the booth, sharing personal stories about Sterling’s kindness, humor, passion for baseball, and the unique personality that made him beloved across New York sports.
The interview revisits Sterling’s iconic home run calls, his emotional call of Derek Jeter’s 3,000th hit, his old school lifestyle, and the way he connected with both players and fans. Evan and Shaun also discuss why Sterling’s broadcasting career deserves Hall of Fame recognition and why his voice will always be tied to Yankees history.
Evan Roberts and Shaun Morash celebrate the life and legacy of John Sterling, remembering the legendary Yankees broadcaster whose voice became part of baseball history. They reflect on Sterling’s passion for the game, his larger than life personality, and the unique style that made every Yankees moment feel bigger.
The Yankees Spanish broadcaster calls in with his anecdotes and remembrances of John Sterling.
News of the passing of John Sterling was given to us during the show and we discussed his legacy.
Hoff is fed up with the Mets, especially after the latest news from Jon Heyman saying the Mets are on the prowl for a big bat with power, one that may even play first base. Add that to Juan Soto having fun while playing injured, pitching being miserable and the rest of the team being lifeless, minds are exploding.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber react to the Knicks delivering their most dominant performance of the season with a convincing playoff win over the Hawks. The guys explain why Jalen Brunson and Karl Anthony Towns looked unstoppable, how the team finally played with the urgency fans have been waiting for, and why this game has Knicks fans starting to dream bigger than just winning the series.The discussion also focuses on Mike Brown’s adjustments, including the double big lineup with Towns and Mitchell Robinson, and why the head coach is finally earning back confidence after a shaky start to the playoffs. Evan and Tiki also push back on Charles Barkley’s criticism of Knicks fans, debate the pressure surrounding championship expectations in New York, and touch on another strong night for the Yankees behind Aaron Judge and rising ace Cam.
Gary Bettman joins Craig Carton to discuss the NHL's record-breaking viewership numbers and the success of the Stadium Series outdoor games. They explore the league's stance on expansion into markets like Houston and Atlanta, while Bettman reflects on his career legacy and the influence of David Stern.01:00 - NHL Viewership Growth07:08 - International Tournament Success14:17 - Sports Betting Integrity19:04 - Future Expansion Markets25:06 - Bettman's Career Legacy
John Fanta joins Craig to analyze the New York Knicks' playoff series against the Atlanta Hawks, focusing on the dominance of Karl-Anthony Towns and OG Anunoby. He also previews his upcoming assignment at the Kentucky Derby and discusses potential NBA coaching changes.01:00 - Towns Dominates The Hawks03:30 - OG Anunoby Playoff Impact07:17 - Mikal Bridges Villanova Pedigree11:40 - Coaching Carousel Rumors13:21 - Kentucky Derby Reporting Debut
Cooper and Carter, the 11-year-old sensations known as the Twin Stripe Reporters, share their viral journey and insights on the New York Yankees. They discuss their interactions with stars like Gerrit Cole, their thoughts on the Savannah Bananas, and the playful sibling rivalry stemming from their opposing NFL fandoms.01:16 - Twin Stripe Reporters Join05:32 - Savannah Bananas Experience10:07 - Yankees World Series Prediction15:10 - Basketball Versus Baseball Debate17:16 - Cowboys Versus 49ers Rivalry
Chris McMonigle shares his realization that the Yankees are better off with the emergence of Ben Rice and the presence of Max Fried than they would be with Juan Soto. He and Craig Carton also review the success of their NFL Draft coverage as reported by the Sports Business Journal. The two react to the news of Kodai Senga heading to the injured list and debate the timing of Giancarlo Stanton's injury status.
The Yankees are off to another strong start, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether this version of the team has the potential to be something greater than the usual 94 to 95 win formula fans have come to expect. With Max Fried dominating, the rotation looking deeper than ever, and Ben Rice exploding into a major contributor alongside Aaron Judge, the conversation shifts toward whether this team could truly separate itself from recent Yankee seasons.Evan and Tiki break down why the pitching staff may be the biggest difference maker, what concerns still exist in the bullpen, and whether the Yankees finally have the kind of edge needed for a deep October run. The discussion also turns to the Mets’ ongoing collapse, Carlos Mendoza surviving another day as manager, and why the organization suddenly looks directionless during a brutal stretch of baseball.
Yanks beat the Rangers last night and we got a bet going. Who'll hit more home runs this year: Ben Rice or Aaron Judge?
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down a WILD segment on WFAN as they react to the New York Mets’ struggles, debate whether Trevor Bauer could actually help the team, and even bring Bauer himself onto the show after his Long Island Ducks no-hitter.Plus, the guys pivot to one of the craziest sports stories of the day, two runners breaking the sub-2 hour marathon barrier wearing the same $500 Adidas super shoe that instantly sold out and is now reselling for THOUSANDS.
The New York Mets have officially hit rock bottom and Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle are NOT holding back.After an embarrassing sweep by the Colorado Rockies and a lifeless offense that scored just ONE run in a doubleheader, Mets fans are furious and calling for manager Carlos Mendoza to be fired immediately.
The Mets’ struggles hit a boiling point after a brutal showing against the Rockies, sparking serious questions about just how bad things have become. What was supposed to be an easy series instead turns into a defining moment of the season, forcing a hard look at leadership, effort, and whether this team is already beyond fixing.Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate the growing calls to fire Carlos Mendoza and explore the fantasy versus reality of replacing him with a top-tier manager like Alex Cora. They break down the team’s offensive failures, the lack of accountability, and why even a major shakeup might not be enough to turn things around as frustration reaches an all-time high.
We started the show talking about the Knicks game 4 win and the adjustments Mike Brown made. We also talked about Josh Hart’s outstanding defense. Plus, the Mets plain old stink.
Craig and Big Mac analyze the emerging photos of Mike Vrabel and Dianna Russini and the fallout regarding Vrabel's draft attendance. They reflect on their favorite parts of the NFL draft before diving into the New York Mets' first win in two weeks and the injury to Francisco Lindor.
01:41 - Vrabel And Russini Scandal
06:49 - NFL Draft Traditions
10:33 - Mets Snap Losing Streak
With the NFL Draft just hours away, the focus is on the New York Jets holding the No. 2 pick and the New York Giants navigating a rare opportunity with two top 10 selections. The conversation centers on how much certainty really exists when evaluating rookies, and whether teams should prioritize immediate impact or long term upside in a draft filled with unknowns.
The discussion explores the Jets’ decision between safer, plug and play talent and higher risk prospects, along with the importance of drafting players who truly want to be great. On the Giants side, the focus shifts to building a defensive identity and finding a leader who can anchor the unit for years to come, while also weighing how the two picks could work together to shape the roster.
What are the Jets going to do at number two? That'll pretty much get the rest of the round going. How about the Giants with their two picks?
Craig and Big Mac react to the New York Mets' disastrous 12-game losing streak and the team's decision to debut a home run celebration amidst the slump. They criticize manager Carlos Mendoza for a lack of leadership and discuss the escalating tension between the organization and its frustrated fan base.
01:25 - Mets 12-Game Losing Streak
02:57 - Lindor's Hard Hat Celebration
09:02 - Carlos Mendoza's Management Struggles
13:09 - Social Media Dunks On Mets
21:00 - Fanatics Fest Summer Preview
The Mets’ losing streak reaches a breaking point, and the frustration is impossible to ignore. What should have been a winnable game turns into another collapse, highlighting a team that looks disconnected, unprepared, and lacking any real identity. From empty at bats to late game meltdowns, the sense is growing that this is more than just a rough stretch.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dive into the issues piling up, including questionable in game decisions, a roster that is not delivering, and a clubhouse that feels like it has no glue. They debate whether a managerial change is inevitable, question the roster construction from the top down, and examine the harsh historical reality facing teams in this kind of spiral. The tone is blunt and emotional as they ask whether anything can realistically save this season.
Mets have lost 12 in a row and they are pretty much lost. Fans are mad and want answers.
Big Mac and Craig analyze the New York Knicks' recent loss to the Atlanta Hawks, specifically pointing fingers at coaching and star player performance. They eventually turn their frustration toward Mets owner Steve Cohen for his presence at the game. The discussion transitions to MLB news regarding death threats sent to Cam Schlittler and the fallout of rumors involving Mike Vrabel and Dianna Russini.
01:11 - Knicks Basketball Debacle
09:52 - Blaming Steve Cohen
17:58 - Yankees Pitcher Threats
19:58 - Mike Vrabel Rumors
A controversial ending sparks major debate as the Knicks’ Game 2 loss raises one big question: who’s really to blame? Confusion over a phantom timeout dominates the conversation, but once the dust settles, the focus shifts to execution, decision making, and accountability in a brutal playoff collapse.
The discussion dives into the NBC graphics error, why Mike Brown can’t be blamed for a timeout he didn’t have, and where criticism actually belongs. From questionable late game choices to missed opportunities in the final seconds, the guys break down how the Knicks let control slip away and why the real issues run deeper than one confusing moment.
Here's the whole first segment as we break down what went wrong, who screwed up and what needs to change.
Craig and Big Mac react to the New York Giants trading star defensive tackle Dexter Lawrence to the Bengals in exchange for the tenth overall pick. They debate the long-term impact on the defense and discuss reports regarding internal friction with Joe Schoen and Dawn Aponte. Pat Leonard joins the conversation to provide insider details on the culture issues that led to Lawrence's exit.
01:53 - Knicks Hawks Preview
02:24 - Lawrence Trade Analysis
14:24 - Giants Trade Credit
23:13 - Lawrence Exit Reasons
27:06 - Pat Leonard Interview
40:18 - Skyline Chili Debate
46:11 - Yankees Red Sox Preview
Randy Livingston joins the program to break down the chemistry between Jalen Brunson and Karl-Anthony Towns during the Knicks' playoff push. He reflects on his career playing alongside Hakeem Olajuwon and Charles Barkley while sharing personal insights into his recovery from gambling addiction. They also discuss the NBA GOAT debate and his wild recruiting experience with Rick Pitino.
01:50 - Knicks Hawks Recap
05:25 - Brunson Superstar Rise
08:45 - Coaching Staff Changes
12:15 - NBA GOAT Debate
17:40 - Recruiting Story Secrets
21:10 - Knicks Title Chances
24:50 - Rockets Legend Memories
28:15 - Gambling Recovery Story
36:05 - Living In Australia
Craig Carton and Big Mac dissect the New York Mets' agonizing 11-game losing streak and the questionable bullpen management by Carlos Mendoza. They compare the team's last-place standing to the success of the Yankees and Knicks while discussing the massive payroll disparity in Major League Baseball. The duo also considers the future of the front office under David Stearns and the potential for a mid-season managerial change.
02:10 - Mets 11-Game Losing Streak
07:47 - Carlos Mendoza's Hot Seat
13:30 - David Stearns' Offseason Failures
14:45 - Yankees And Knicks Updates
The Mets’ losing streak reaches 11 games, and frustration boils over as the focus turns to Carlos Mendoza’s future. With the team spiraling and no immediate fixes in sight, the debate intensifies over whether a managerial firing is the only move left to spark change or just a reaction to a much deeper problem.
A disastrous extra inning decision involving Nico Hoerner becomes the flashpoint, highlighting questionable strategy under pressure. Combined with a lifeless offense and blown opportunities, the discussion explores accountability across the roster and front office, and whether anything short of a major shakeup can stop the collapse.
Craig and Big Mac analyze the New York Yankees' recent struggles, focusing on a bullpen they describe as a "disaster" following a loss to the Los Angeles Angels. They discuss Mike Trout’s dominant series and the irony of former prospects finding success against their old team. The conversation also touches on the New York Mets' losing streak.
01:06 - Mike Trout Punishes Yankees
04:55 - Yankees Bullpen Defensive Issues
09:18 - Comparing Yankees And Mets
13:53 - Austin Wells Winning Run
The New York Mets are off to a brutal start, and the frustration is already reaching a boiling point. After another lifeless loss to the Los Angeles Dodgers, the conversation turns to a shocking reality: two teams with similar payrolls that look like they belong in completely different leagues. The big question looms large, who if anyone can actually save this team?
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dig into how the Mets’ massive payroll is being wasted on underperforming players, questionable decisions, and millions tied up in guys no longer contributing. They break down the lack of offense, inconsistent stars like Francisco Lindor, and a roster that feels both too old and too young at the same time. The result is a team with no identity, no production, and growing concern that this season could unravel fast.
Craig Carton criticizes New York Mets owner Steve Cohen for being out of touch with his fans following a series of listless losses. He argues that Cohen’s use of financial terminology like "green shoots" and excuses about weather conditions fail to address the core issues of a struggling roster shaped by David Stearns.
01:00 - Mets Listless Offensive Struggles
02:34 - Cohen's Tone-Deaf Social Media
09:21 - Stearns Roster Vision Debate
The Mets are spiraling, and a late-night tweet from owner Steve Cohen only poured gasoline on the fire. Evan and Tiki react to the now-infamous “green shoots” message and why it completely missed the moment for a frustrated fanbase watching a team that looks lifeless early in the season. When expectations are high, messaging matters, and this one struck a nerve.
The guys break it down from both sides, with Tiki offering a player’s perspective on why public excuses can backfire, while Evan lays out what fans actually want to hear during a losing streak. They also touch on accountability inside the clubhouse, leadership questions, and how quickly optimism has turned into real concern about what this Mets team actually is.
On this segment of The Carton Show on WFAN, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle are joined by NFL insider Nikki Gist as she drops a major update on the New York Giants’ front office situation ahead of the NFL Draft.
The discussion centers around reports that Giants GM Joe Schoen may be uncertain about his role under a new regime led by head coach John Harbaugh, with speculation that multiple personnel changes could follow immediately after the draft. The crew breaks down what this means for draft-day decision making, trade scenarios, and whether Schoen even has full authority in the war room.
On the April 14, 2026 episode of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle are joined by Front Office Sports reporter Ryan Glasspiegel to break down the shocking resignation of Dianna Russini from The Athletic.
The New York Yankees may have won… but the lineup drama is just getting started. On this segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into the growing debate around Ben Rice, should he be playing EVERY day, no matter what?
The Yankees snap their losing streak in unforgettable fashion, storming back in a chaotic, high-scoring battle fueled by Aaron Judge and a headline-worthy showdown with Mike Trout. It’s the kind of game that electrifies the stadium and reminds fans just how explosive this lineup can be when everything clicks at once.
But beneath the excitement, real concerns remain. The bullpen struggles, roster decisions, and late-game management all raise questions about sustainability moving forward. Evan and Tiki break down whether this was a turning point or just a temporary fix, and what it reveals about the true identity of this Yankees team.
Mets shut out again, this time by the Dodgers. Lindor questions. Mendoza in the bullseye.
The Yankees have an instant classic with the Los Angeles Angels as Trent Grisham, Aaron Judge and Mike Trout all have multiple home run games. The biggest coming in the bottom of the 9th by Grisham to tie it at 10 a piece. Meanwhile, the Mets were lucky enough to get 3 hits against the Dodgers!
A brutal start to the week in New York baseball. New York Yankees and New York Mets fans are fed up after a winless weekend, and Craig Carton with Chris McMonigle break it all down on WFAN.
The Mets’ slow start is one thing, but what’s happening with Francisco Lindor is something else entirely. Evan and Tiki focus on the first wave of concern coming out of Queens, zeroing in on Lindor’s uncharacteristic mistakes that go beyond a typical early-season slump. From base running blunders to defensive lapses, they try to make sense of why one of the game’s smartest players suddenly looks out of sync.
They explore multiple theories, including whether increased aggression, lack of familiarity with new teammates, or even a possible lingering injury could be impacting his instincts. The conversation also touches on the Mets’ offensive struggles, lineup inconsistencies, and the growing pressure surrounding Carlos Mendoza as questions begin to mount just weeks into the season.
Boomer & Gio disagree on if Soto and Lindor actually care about playing baseball for the New York Mets.
Of all the dramatic things. Who would have thought the Mets and Yankees would both be swept this weekend and head into Monday on a 5 game losing streak. What is going on??? Plus, the most unbelievable win in sports this weekend!Follow @HoffWFAN on TikTok, X, and Instagram
Things got REAL on The Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle bring on rising NFL insider Nikki to break down the controversial Mike Vrabel–Dianna Russini situation and she does NOT hold back.
Nikki sounds off on the impact this scandal could have on women in sports media, the double standards in the industry, and the challenges of being taken seriously as an insider. Plus, she pushes back on Russini’s reporting and shares her own experience navigating the business.
Craig Carton and Big Mac critique the defensive struggles and offensive drought plaguing both the Mets and the Yankees. They celebrate the New York Knicks' victory over the Celtics and discuss the team's playoff positioning before introducing a new game called Carton Show Connections.
01:00 - Mets Defensive Woes
07:19 - Baseball Power Outage
11:40 - Analytics Statistics Debate
15:33 - Knicks Playoff Seeding
21:00 - Connections Game Preview
The New York Knicks are closing out a regular season that, by every measurable standard, is better than last year—more wins, improved efficiency, and stronger results against top competition. Yet for many fans, confidence hasn’t followed the numbers. Instead, there’s a growing sense that the regular season no longer matters, and that belief has shifted the way this team is judged heading into the playoffs.
Evan and Shaun dig into why the vibe around this team feels so different, from questions about how sustainable the stats really are to the evolving expectations that now mirror those of New York Yankees fans. They explore whether the Knicks’ inconsistencies, coaching decisions, and overall feel outweigh the hard data, and what it says about a fanbase that has officially moved from hopeful to demanding as the postseason approaches.
The Yankees may be 8-4, but don’t let the record fool you, something is OFF.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down a frustrating series loss to the A’s where the Yankees’ offense completely disappeared, 17 scoreless innings, no clutch hitting, and major concerns in the lineup.
Strawweight Tatiana Suarez joins Hoff to discuss her upcoming fight with Loopy Godinez at UFC 327.
With the NFL Draft approaching fast, the conversation kicks off with a focused debate on what the Giants should do with the fifth overall pick. The hosts lay out their official endorsements, emphasizing strategy over prediction and diving into what would truly set the franchise up for long term success.
The discussion centers on two primary paths, building a dominant defense with Sonny Styles or adding offensive firepower with Jeremiyah Love. The clash highlights differing draft philosophies, from positional need to best player available, while also touching on roster construction and the rare opportunity that comes with picking this high.
Boomer’s comments yesterday about Dianna Russini and Mike Vrabel made it to a lot of articles. A bunch of videos of Russini on talk shows and podcasts talking about her marriage also emerged.
Boomer doesn’t like players wearing ski masks in the field when it’s cold. Plus, Evan Roberts was very upset that Steve Cohen gave away free Mets tickets and 58% of the people that took them didn’t use them.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle kick off the show with a MASSIVE day in sports, from a wild Yankees comeback win to the Mets staying hot without Juan Soto. But the real fireworks come off the field.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber start with rare praise for both Aaron Boone and Carlos Mendoza after a night where managerial decisions actually delivered wins. From bold lineup choices to trusting the right hitters in clutch spots, it is a refreshing shift from the usual criticism as both New York teams benefit from smart, decisive managing.
But the real fire comes when the conversation turns to Mets fans and a shocking stat: more than half of the free ticket holders didn’t show up. Evan unloads on what he sees as selfish behavior, arguing fans took opportunities away from others who would have gone, while Tiki pushes back with a more laid back perspective on human nature and free stuff. The debate turns into a bigger discussion about responsibility, fan culture, and whether anyone actually “owes” anything when the ticket costs nothing.
We started with the Yankees win last night and how Amed Rosario hit two home runs as he started in place of Ryan McMahon.
Things take a hilarious and completely unexpected turn on the Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle get sidetracked by a very questionable headline. What starts as a simple discussion about a school “mentoring day” quickly spirals into chaos when the phrase “first hand job experience” gets, interpreted a little differently depending on how you say it.
With Gallo and the crew jumping in, the segment turns into pure radio gold filled with awkward reads, double entendres, and nonstop laughs. Plus, the guys circle back to Mets vs Yankees fan debates and react to callers dealing with the Citi Field time change.
Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle kick off the show diving into a heated debate: did the New York Mets just disrespect their own fans? After moving their game time due to cold weather, the Mets offered fans replacement tickets but is it really generosity or just the law? Meanwhile, the New York Yankees stand firm, trusting their fans to tough it out in classic April baseball conditions.
The Giants are facing a defining moment as tension builds around Dexter Lawrence and his very public trade request. What started as a contract dispute has quickly turned into a franchise-shaping storyline, raising questions about leadership, culture, and the team’s long-term direction. At the same time, concerns about Juan Soto’s calf injury add another layer of intrigue to the New York sports landscape.
Evan and Tiki and Connor break down why Lawrence’s situation escalated, what his true market value could be, and how the Giants might resolve it before things spiral. They also dive into potential draft strategies at number five, including the growing buzz around key prospects and whether the team should prioritize defense, offense, or long-term upside. The conversation explores how this offseason could redefine expectations for both the Giants and Jets moving forward.
The Giants are suddenly dealing with real tension as Dexter Lawrence’s trade request sends shockwaves through the fanbase. What should be a moment of optimism with a new coach and fresh direction is now clouded by questions about effort, leadership, and whether Lawrence’s frustrations are truly justified or just about money.
Evan and Tiki break down the reported reasons behind the demand and why some of them are not landing with fans or former players. They explore how last season’s performance, locker room dynamics, and shifting expectations have changed the way Lawrence is viewed, while also debating whether the Giants should pay him, trade him, or stand firm as this situation escalates.
Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle are joined by Pat Leonard to break down the shocking report that Giants star DT Dexter Lawrence could be seeking a trade.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into a jam-packed segment on WFAN as the New York Mets make a fan-friendly move, pushing game times earlier due to weather, while the New York Yankees face pressure to follow suit.
Big-time drama in New York sports. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to shocking news involving the New York Giants, as Dexter Lawrence reportedly tells the team he wants OUT.
A major shakeup hits the Giants as Dexter Lawrence requests a trade, sending shockwaves through the fanbase and raising serious questions about the team’s direction. What led to this point, and how did a cornerstone player become this dissatisfied? The crew reacts in real time to the breaking news and what it says about the organization.
They dive into the contract dispute at the center of it all, Lawrence’s recent performance, and whether the Giants should pay up or consider moving him for a massive return. It sparks a larger conversation about player leverage, locker room dynamics, and how a team trying to build a contender handles a situation like this.
A miserable, rain-soaked Sunday at Yankee Stadium turns into a marathon experience for fans who waited hours just to see first pitch. The guys dive into the chaos of a 3.5 hour delay, the decisions fans had to make, and the reality of sitting through brutal weather with little clarity from the team.
They also explore how some fans managed to game the situation, the challenges for families stuck at the stadium, and the broader frustration with how these delays are handled. Plus, a look at the Mets’ surprising offensive surge and why early season results might not tell the full story of what this team can become.
We start the day discussing the New York Islanders firing of coach Patrick Roy, as well as discuss the fact that Juan Soto is missing games due to a calf injury.
Hoff proclaims the need to have Mark Vientos to play, especially with the potential of Juan Soto being out with an injury,
Juan Soto has exited after the first inning of the Mets game. Good news, the Mets bats woke up!
The New York Yankees are off to a scorching start in 2026 and their pitching staff might already be the BEST in baseball. Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle break down the Yankees' early dominance, including a stellar outing from Max Fried and surprising contributions across the rotation and bullpen.
The Knicks continue to send up red flags as their lack of chemistry becomes impossible to ignore. After another sluggish start and uninspired performance, the focus shifts from individual talent to a bigger question about whether this roster actually works together as a unit with the playoffs quickly approaching.
Evan and Tiki break down the growing disconnect between Jalen Brunson and Karl-Anthony Towns, the struggles of the starting five, and why the offense and defense both look out of sync. They also question coaching decisions, lineup adjustments, and whether this team can realistically fix its issues in time or if these problems are deeper than just a late season slump.
Gio knows what teams are trying to do against the Knicks, and it’s working, and that’s concerning for the playoffs.
Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle kick off the show reacting to stunning comments from Jets head coach Aaron Glenn, who doubled down on his belief that Geno Smith can lead the team to the “Promised Land.”
The first full night of New York baseball sparks instant reactions as the Mets find a way to win behind their bullpen while the Yankees fall late in a game filled with second guessing. Early season decisions from both managers take center stage, raising questions about urgency versus long term strategy.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dive into the Yankees’ aggressive use of the ABS challenge system, Aaron Boone’s bullpen choices, and why fan frustration hits harder during late night losses. On the Mets side, the focus shifts to bullpen execution, clutch concerns carrying over from last year, and whether early results should already shape expectations.
Yanks were 5 for 5 in ABS challenges last night and umpires are increasingly ending up with egg on their faces.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to a WILD weekend in sports! Duke blows a 19-point lead to UConn in a shocking collapse, Carton unloads on the Blue Devils and explains why he LOVES seeing Duke lose, Debate over whether UConn deserves the hype or if fans are overreacting, St. John’s expectations vs reality, Mets take the series… but fans are already BOOING?!, Early-season frustrations with Bo Bichette, Juan Soto & the offense
Opening Weekend is in the books, and the reactions are already getting loud. After just three games, the Yankees are being talked about like a dominant force with elite pitching and a lineup firing early, while the Mets are already facing questions despite a winning series. It is the perfect mix of excitement and overreaction that only baseball’s return can bring.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber lean into the early storylines, breaking down why the Yankees’ hot start feels both real and exaggerated, and why Mets fans are already uneasy about certain performances. They explore standout pitching, early offensive trends, and the natural urge to draw big conclusions from a tiny sample size as the season gets underway.
The Final Four is set and we talk about it, in particular St. John’s loss to Duke and UConn beating Duke.
Middleweight Joe Pyfer discusses his upcoming fight versus 2x former champion Israel Adesanya this Saturday night at UFC Fight Night 271.
The story comes full circle. After a shocking medical emergency during Mets Opening Day at Citi Field, the fan at the center of it all joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle live on WFAN.
Martin shares what he remembers from the moment he collapsed, reveals it was NOT a heart attack, and delivers an emotional thank you to the Good Samaritans, ER doctor, and first responders who rushed to save him.
From chaos in the stands to walking out of the hospital the same night — this is an incredible, feel-good New York story you don’t want to miss.
An unbelievable and emotional story out of Opening Day at Citi Field. During the Mets’ home opener, a fan suffered a medical emergency in the stands — but thanks to quick action from a Good Samaritan, an ER doctor, NYPD, and stadium staff, his life was saved.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the incredible chain of events, including firsthand accounts from the doctor and the fan who performed CPR. From chaos to celebration, this is one of the most powerful sports stories you’ll hear all year.
Plus, reactions to the Mets’ win, the Yankees staying undefeated, and more from a packed Friday show.
The NCAA Tournament intensity is reaching another level as St. John’s resurgence collides with Duke’s high expectations. With a Final Four feel in the air, the conversation dives into whether this red-hot St. John’s team is truly destined for a breakthrough or if Duke will reassert its dominance when it matters most.
From Rick Pitino’s remarkable redemption arc to questions about Duke’s vulnerability, the discussion explores key matchups, coaching contrasts, and the rise of standout talent like Cameron Boozer. The episode also zooms out to examine a stacked region featuring powerhouse programs, breaking down why this stretch of March Madness feels as wide open—and as compelling—as ever.
Opening Day delivered exactly what Mets fans were craving a win, a fresh identity, and plenty of reasons for optimism. The guys break down how the Mets manufactured runs, battled through tough at-bats, and showed off a new offensive approach that could define their season.
They also dive into the full ballpark experience, from traffic headaches and quirky fan challenges to a bizarre on-field moment involving a dead bird. Plus, Evan shares a wild personal story involving a lost wallet that somehow finds its way back, adding another unforgettable layer to an already eventful day at the ballpark.
We started with the Mets win over the Pirates on Opening Day. Oneil Cruz had a rough day in the field and at the plate. Gio loved the Mets offensive performance as well.
It’s a chaotic Opening Day edition of The Carton Show on WFAN! Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to a HUGE start to the baseball season, the Yankees dominate, the Mets survive late drama, and things get hilariously off the rails.
Opening Day is HERE and the New York Yankees wasted no time making a statement with a dominant 7-0 win but somehow the biggest story might be the Netflix broadcast disaster
The Yankees kicked off their season with a convincing win, but that wasn’t what had fans talking. Evan and Tiki break down the overwhelming reaction to Netflix’s Opening Day broadcast, where production choices, missed moments, and constant distractions left viewers frustrated. Instead of celebrating a strong performance, the focus shifted to how the game was presented—and why it didn’t sit well with diehard fans.
They dig into what actually happened on the field, including Max Fried’s dominant outing and the lineup’s aggressive approach, while debating whether fans were nitpicking or justified in their complaints. The conversation also touches on modern sports viewing habits, the balance between entertainment and gameplay, and how a clean win can still spark controversy when the broadcast gets in the way.
Keith Hernandez joins us to talk about Mets Opening Day and what we can expect this season with all the new guys.
Yanks win in SF despite Judge going 0-5. However, is the MLB turning off fans with what comes across as a money-grab?
Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle are joined by legendary Yankees radio voice Suzyn Waldman
Breaking news from The Carton Show on WFAN—and it’s not good for Mets fans. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react LIVE to the so-called “999 Challenge” coming to Citi Field… but when the details come out, things get heated FAST.
Baseball is BACK and the energy is off the charts on the Carton Show! Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle kick off Opening Day with pure excitement as the New York Yankees begin their 2026 season. From the magic and nostalgia of Opening Day to why fans should STILL believe in this Yankees team, the guys bring the passion early.
Opening Day brings excitement, but also a familiar debate just how good are the Yankees really? With a roster that looks dominant on paper, expectations are sky-high as the season begins. The conversation centers on whether this team is clearly the class of the American League or if lingering doubts from last year still cast a shadow over the hype.
Evan and Tiki dig into why the Yankees’ lineup and rotation stand out, where they may have improved, and why some concerns—especially around the bullpen and long-term trust—haven’t gone away. They also explore how fans balance early-season optimism with the reality that everything will ultimately be judged by what happens in October.
Ron Darling calls in and we discuss the new baseball season focusing on the Mets future.
Legendary New York Yankees Spanish play-by-play voice Ricky Ricardo joins the Carton Show to break down everything from the World Baseball Classic to the start of the 2026 Yankees season. Ricky shares his wild stories from the Miami nightlife at Club Eleven , explains why Latin American baseball fans just do it better , and gives us the ultimate insider scoop on Aaron Judge’s mindset after a tough postseason.
The legendary Steve Schirripa (Bobby Bacala from The Sopranos and Blue Bloods) stops by The Carton Show on WFAN to hang out with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle! Steve dives deep into the archives to share incredible, never-before-heard stories about James Gandolfini’s legendary generosity, the "unspoken rules" real-life wiseguys expected the cast to follow, and why he actually took a pay cut to leave Las Vegas for the role of a lifetime.
The hosts of WFAN react to the Red Storm punching its ticket to the Round of 16 for the first time since 1999, setting up a showdown against the tournament's No. 1 overall seed, Duke.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber dive into a spirited Yankees debate over how much analytics should shape a lineup and whether the numbers are pointing toward changes fans may not want to hear. At the center of it all is a bold idea Roberts has pushed for years: Aaron Judge leading off to get more plate appearances and create more scoring opportunities.
From a data-built lineup that puts Trent Grisham in a premium spot to a larger argument about Aaron Boone, Brian Cashman, and the balance between information and feel, the conversation touches every nerve Yankees fans have. They also get into growing doubts about Jason Dominguez, what the team really believes about its young talent, and how long the Yankees should stick with struggling veterans before making a change.
We started the hour joined by Nick Swisher on the phone to talk about opening day and specifically what he expects for the Yankees season.
On this wild Monday edition of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle go OFF on the sudden surge of St John’s fans after their Sweet 16 run. Are New Yorkers truly back on board, or is this just a city full of bandwagon jumpers? And the guys dive into the Cam Scott controversy, asking the big question: are we taking athletes too seriously or not seriously enough?
St. John’s delivers a signature moment, knocking off Kansas in a game that had everything momentum swings, controversy, and a fearless finish. What looked like a potential collapse turned into one of the program’s biggest wins in decades, fueled by confidence, composure, and a head coach who never blinked in the biggest moments.
Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber break down the sequence that changed everything, from Bryce Hopkins’ crucial three to Dylan Darling demanding the ball and delivering the game-winner despite struggling all night. They also dive into Rick Pitino’s influence on the team’s mentality, Kansas’ late-game mistakes, and what this gutsy win means as St. John’s prepares for a heavyweight showdown with Duke.
Is NOTHING sacred anymore?! On this wild segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go head-to-head over one shocking decision: Netflix putting Jameis Winston on the Opening Day broadcast for Yankees vs. Giants. Carton calls it a DISRESPECTFUL gimmick ruining one of baseball’s most sacred traditions… while Big Mac says: RELAX, it’s supposed to be FUN!
Sienna almost takes out Duke. High Point snuffs Wisconsin. Some St. John's preview for tonight.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle kick off the show in absolute chaos as Carton declares it “Father’s Day”… in March?! That quickly spirals into a hilarious debate about tournament time, office bracket warriors, and why nobody cares about your picks.
Howie Rose sits down with Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber for a thoughtful conversation about why the 2026 season will be his last in the Mets booth. He explains the personal and professional factors behind the decision, from family sacrifices to the importance of stepping away before the job changes, while also sharing what still makes the biggest moments in sports so addictive for a play-by-play broadcaster.
Along the way, Rose looks back on the unforgettable calls and career turns that shaped his legacy, including his love for radio, his transition across hockey and baseball, and the thrill of capturing iconic New York sports moments. He also opens up about mentoring the next generation, the lessons he learned from great broadcasters around him, and the one dream that still burns brightest: getting the chance to call a Mets championship before it’s all over.
The Mets announce that legendary broadcaster Howie Rose will retire after the 2026 season, marking the end of a voice that has defined generations of baseball fans. The news sparks a wave of emotion, as the impact of Rose’s storytelling, passion, and connection to the team comes into focus for fans who grew up with his calls.
Evan and Tiki reflect on Rose’s remarkable career, revisiting iconic moments like Johan Santana’s no-hitter and the unforgettable calls that captured the spirit of Mets history. They discuss what made Rose unique behind the mic, the bond he built with listeners, and why his final season now carries added weight for both the team and its fanbase.
We start the show talking about St. John's in the tourney and it ends up with Gio accusing Boomer of talking a bit much during a golf outing.
The fallout from Team USA’s loss in the World Baseball Classic is getting HEATED… and now New York Mets fans are piling on?!
The fallout from Team USA’s loss in the World Baseball Classic is getting HEATED… and now New York Mets fans are piling on?!
Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber, and Shaun Morash open the show by diving straight into the familiar and heated debate surrounding Aaron Judge after Team USA’s loss. A rough night at the plate quickly reignites the question Yankees fans can’t seem to escape: can Judge deliver in the biggest moments, or is the narrative about his postseason struggles here to stay?
Using caller reactions and their own perspectives, the hosts explore the gap between Judge’s undeniable greatness and his inconsistent results in high-pressure games. They debate whether one WBC performance should matter at all, how much perception shapes his legacy, and why, fair or not, October remains the only thing that can ultimately change the conversation.
MVP joins Pete Hoffman to talk about his upcoming out with Sam Patterson at the O2 Arena this Saturday, March 21st for UFC Fight Night 270 Evloev vs Murphy.Follow @HoffWFAN on Instagram, X & TikTok
Is tonight a LEGACY moment for Aaron Judge or does it mean absolutely nothing? On The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle get into a heated debate over whether a huge moment in the World Baseball Classic could finally change the narrative around the Yankees’ superstar.
The show dives headfirst into a fiery Giants draft debate: should New York seriously consider taking a running back at No. 5, or is that still a roster-building mistake in today’s NFL? The conversation centers on whether the usual anti-running back logic is too simplistic, especially for a Giants team that may be closer to contention than critics think.
From Saquon Barkley comparisons to examples like Bijan Robinson, Christian McCaffrey, Ezekiel Elliott, and Jahmyr Gibbs, the episode examines how context matters when judging top-10 running back picks. The hosts argue over Jaxson Dart’s development, the state of the Giants’ offensive line, the team’s limited draft capital, and whether adding another weapon would be smart strategy or a repeat of past mistakes, with side mentions of Mikal Bridges, Mike Brown, and the World Baseball Classic final.
The guys are both back and Gio said the WBC is not as good as the Olympics because MLB pitchers are on pitch counts.
Did Aaron Judge just say the World Baseball Classic atmosphere was BETTER than the World Series?
On The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to Judge’s postgame comments after Team USA’s dramatic win over the Dominican Republic. Judge said the energy and atmosphere of the WBC might have been better than his World Series experience and that set off a massive debate.
Dominican baseball fans furious over late strike calls in Team USA’s win, and St. John’s fans upset over what feels like a punishing NCAA tournament seed and draw. It is a fast, opinionated start that taps into the emotional fallout from a dramatic sports weekend and makes room for both outrage and analysis.
The conversation centers on whether the World Baseball Classic should have used the ABS system after multiple pitches that appeared to be called incorrectly in key moments, while also debating Juan Soto, Aaron Judge, and the difficulty of deciding the “best team” in a one-game setting. The segment then shifts to college basketball, where the hosts argue that St. John’s strong recent play and Big East title run were not properly rewarded, leaving fans to wonder what more the team could have done to earn a better path.
Boomer & Jerry today and they start the show with the WBC and Team USA past the Dominican Republic and into the final game. Then it's on to the Red Storm stomping on the Huskies.
Is the Geno Smith hype completely out of control?
On The Carton Show, Craig Carton absolutely unloads on Geno Smith and the excitement surrounding the New York Jets signing him. Carton calls the reaction from fans and media a total “scam,” comparing the situation to getting fooled in a strip club or falling for a phone scam.
The show opens with a deep dive into Geno Smith’s return to the New York Jets and the big question fans are asking: is there any chance this could actually work long term? After Geno says he still has “a lot of football left,” the hosts debate whether that’s just standard quarterback optimism or a hint that he believes he can resurrect his career again the way he did in Seattle.
They break down Geno’s age, the surprisingly low mileage on his career, and what a realistic best-case scenario would look like if he replicated his strong 2022 season. The discussion quickly turns into a bigger Jets debate—if Geno plays well and the offense clicks, would the team actually consider keeping him beyond this year, or should they still prioritize drafting the quarterback of the future no matter what happens this season?
Geno said the right things and seems like he's got a mature attitude. What can the Jets do next season?
The New York Giants are bringing back Evan Neal and Craig Carton cannot believe it.
On The Carton Show, Craig and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle react to the shocking decision to re-sign the former 7th overall pick to a one-year veteran minimum deal. Carton rips the move, calling Neal one of the biggest draft busts in franchise history and questioning why a new regime would keep a player who represents years of failure for Big Blue.
The New York Giants made a surprising move that immediately sparked debate across the fanbase: bringing back former first-round pick Evan Neal. Once drafted seventh overall with expectations of becoming a cornerstone offensive lineman, Neal’s career has instead been defined by inconsistency, injuries, and mounting criticism. Now, on a low-risk veteran minimum deal, the question isn’t just why the Giants brought him back it’s whether a fresh coaching approach could finally unlock the player many believed he was supposed to be.
In this episode, the hosts break down Neal’s rookie tape, how his development appeared to derail after year one, and the complicated perception surrounding his career so far. They debate whether coaching, motivation, or the team’s offensive line situation could explain the decision, while also revisiting the controversy that fueled fan frustration. With a new coaching era beginning, the conversation turns to trust: should Giants fans believe this staff sees something everyone else has missed—or is this simply another chapter in a disappointing draft story?
Could the Giants compete for the NFC East title? The Jets have had a good offseason, but what is their ceiling this year?
Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle break down the CHAOS after Team USA’s shocking loss in the World Baseball Classic. Aaron Judge had the tying run at the plate and struck out. Now fans are asking the brutal question: can you trust Judge in the clutch?
Evan and Tiki react to the stunning news that Geno Smith is returning to the New York Jets. Is this the right move for a franchise desperate to stabilize the quarterback position, or are the Jets settling for a short-term solution with no real future? The guys debate whether Geno is simply a bridge to the next quarterback, why some fans hate the move, and what the Jets’ long-term plan might actually be. Plus, the emotional side of a full-circle reunion in New York and whether fans can separate Geno’s past with the team from the player he is today.
Gio & Willie Colon (sitting in for Boomer) discuss the news that Geno Smith is rejoining the Jets. Here's the whole first segment because there's tons of Jets talk going on here with someone who knows.
The Carton Show kicks off with chaos! Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle debate whether the New York Giants actually closed the gap with the Philadelphia Eagles after the first wave of NFL free agency. Are Giants fans getting ahead of themselves… or is the NFC East suddenly wide open?
Evan shares one of the strangest encounters he has ever had at Mets spring training. While sitting along the left field line in Port St. Lucie, Evan suddenly finds himself face to face with former Mets owner Fred Wilpon… and the interaction takes a bizarre turn involving a half-eaten sandwich.
Evan and Tiki break down the awkward moment, debate whether Wilpon actually knew who Evan was, and try to figure out if the whole thing was a joke, a prank, or just an old-school rich guy sense of humor.
Plus, more Mets spring training observations, the return of ballpark staples like Mr. Softee, and why nothing beats the first ice cream of the baseball season at Citi Field.
Jets fans got tough news when Alijah Vera-Tucker left for the New England Patriots, and Evan explains why this one hurts. After years of injuries and frustration, Vera-Tucker finally moves on from the New York Jets, but seeing him land with a division rival makes it even worse.
Evan and Tiki break down why the breakup may have been inevitable, whether the Jets did enough to try to keep him, and why the fear now is that Vera-Tucker finally stays healthy and thrives somewhere else.
Plus, the conversation expands to the Jets’ offensive line outlook, the shrinking quarterback market, and why Jets fans are bracing themselves for whatever comes next in free agency.
Evan and Tiki react to a flurry of Giants moves in NFL free agency and why the roster already looks dramatically different. From Isaiah Likely and Tremaine Edmunds to Jordan Stout and Greg Newsome, the guys break down how the Giants are starting to reshape the team and why the early returns have fans feeling optimistic.
They also discuss the biggest remaining questions on the roster including cornerback, guard, and wide receiver, and whether more aggressive moves could still be coming. Plus, the conversation shifts to the Jets’ busy defensive overhaul and the growing tension around when their quarterback decision will finally drop.
Yesterday it looked like Carson Wentz, today not so much. Also, unhappy Breece Hall is unhappy.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the shocking NBA decision to CANCEL the legendary Magic City promotion at the Atlanta Hawks game, all over one player's complaint! Fans are furious, and Carton doesn’t hold back on Luke Kornet or even Adam Silver. Plus, chaos ensues as the hosts debate PB&J vs. grilled cheese, reveal diner secrets, and throw in pop culture trivia you won’t expect.
Rock star meets sports talk! On The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle welcome Train frontman Pat Monahan into the WFAN studio for an awesome conversation about music, sports, and one of the biggest songs of the last 25 years.
On WFAN’s Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle are joined by Connor Hughes to break down shocking developments involving the New York Giants and New York Jets.
The NFL legal tampering window is OPEN and the madness has begun!
On The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to a wild day of deals across the league including major moves involving the New York Jets and New York Giants.
The Jets kick off NFL free agency with a strong move, landing Minkah Fitzpatrick in a deal that feels like an instant win for a defense that badly needed help in the secondary. Evan and Tiki break down why Fitzpatrick is such a smart addition, what he brings to the Jets right away, and why this move shows New York is trying to win now.
But even after the Minkah trade, the biggest issue remains the same: quarterback. With legal tampering underway, the conversation turns to the Jets’ most important decision of the offseason. Is there any real path that makes sense? Why do names like Carson Wentz and Geno Smith feel like a disaster waiting to happen? Could a riskier swing like Kyler Murray, Malik Willis, or even Tua Tagovailoa give the Jets at least some hope?
The Jets are trading for Minkah Fitzpatrick. We heard from Maxx Crosby on going from the Raiders to the Ravens. Luka talked about the Lakers beating the Knicks yesterday. In the WBC tonight, USA takes on Mexico. Evan Roberts talked to Aaron Boone and asked if it still bothers him that Juan Soto chose the Mets over the Yankees. Moment of The Day: C-Mac tricked into reading a fake ED commercial.
The Carton Show on WFAN kicked off with Craig Carton going absolutely nuclear over rumors the New York Jets could bring in Carson Wentz.
Evan and Tiki break down WFAN’s craziest takes of the week in “Are You Kidding Me?” featuring Big Mac’s Roger Clemens defense, Craig Carton’s Joe Montana claim, Tommy Lugauer’s Saquon Barkley argument, and Shaun Morash’s Giants draft take. Plus, the guys react to Alex Rodriguez’s White House appearance and Donald Trump’s past comments about A-Rod.
Boomer kept bringing up sports influencers. Not only did this confuse Gio, it kicked off a heated exchange.
The Carton Show on WFAN kicks off with a huge sports debate as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the New York Knicks’ tough loss to the Oklahoma City Thunder and what it actually says about their championship chances.
Did the New York Giants almost land Trent McDuffie before he was dealt to the Los Angeles Rams?!
The Yankees tried to post a wholesome throwback… and may have accidentally created a rivalry controversy.
Evan and Tiki react to a Yankees social media post showing childhood photos of players like Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton. The problem? Internet sleuths quickly noticed something strange about Stanton’s Little League photo. His hat looked edited and fans soon discovered why: the original image appears to show Stanton wearing a Mets hat, which the Yankees seemingly removed before posting.
So why edit it at all? The guys debate whether the Yankees were trying to avoid trolling from Mets fans, protect their brand, or if this was just unnecessary “little brother” behavior from baseball’s most powerful franchise.
The conversation spirals into classic Yankees-Mets rivalry stories, including a legendary George Steinbrenner urban legend involving Andy Pettitte, Little League hats, and the Mets that may or may not have actually happened.
Plus, they break down why something as small as a childhood photo can turn into a full-blown New York sports debate.
A simple throwback post… or the pettiest Yankees move ever?
Bantamweight Raul Rosas Jr. who is set to take on Rob Font this Saturday Night at UFC 326 joins Pete Hoffman to discuss his upcoming fight and more.Follow Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram & TikTok
He comes cheap but might be a touch short in stature for the Jets needs. There are other good options.
Craig Carton goes OFF on Aaron Judge after his underwhelming Team USA speech ahead of the World Baseball Classic calling it the worst captain’s speech in sports history! Is Judge a great player but a bad leader? And does this explain the New York Yankees October struggles?
The Jets are at a crossroads with Breece Hall and Evan and Tiki lay out the three paths: contract extension, transition tag, or franchise tag. Which move keeps him happy? Which move guarantees he stays? And which move opens the door to unnecessary drama?
The guys explain why the franchise tag might be the safest option, why the transition tag could backfire, and why letting Hall test the market would be playing with fire. Is he the best running back available right now, even compared to draft names like Jeremiah Love? And how much does his age and production matter when projecting the next four years?
Then the conversation shifts to the quarterback room. The Jets are almost certainly adding multiple QBs. So who will they be?
The Atlanta Hawks are having a Magic City night and Luke Kornet of the Spurs is not happy about it.
All hell breaks loose on The Carton Show after actor Shia LaBeouf calls out Mike Piazza over a childhood autograph snub and it somehow turns into one of the most heated debates in WFAN history.
The Carton Show opens with one of the wildest discussions you’ll ever hear — millions of dollars wagered on global events through predictive gambling markets… and when the outcome happens, bettors STILL don’t get paid!
What was supposed to be a quiet Giants offseason is suddenly anything but. Evan & Tiki dive into shocking chatter that Big Blue could take a running back at No. 5, explore the surprising Kenneth Walker rumors, and debate whether John Harbaugh is preparing to take a full wrecking ball to the roster. Is this strategic misdirection… or a true franchise reset after a four-win season?
The guys also discuss injury concerns in the current backfield, how free agency could shape draft decisions, and why this team might look completely different in a matter of weeks. If the Giants really are about to reshape everything, what would actually count as “shocking” for fans?
We start with what the Jets need to look for in the draft for their needs and move on to who they could possible bring in as a QB.
UFC Bantamweight Marlon "Chito" Vera discusses his upcoming fight with David Martinez this Saturday night in Mexico CIty.Follow @HoffWFAN
A touching check-in with legendary Yankees announcer John Sterling after his recent heart scare, and nostalgia-packed stories about New York’s iconic broadcasters. Don’t miss the laughs, insights, and behind-the-scenes commentary from WFAN’s Carton Show!
Two time UFC Flyweight Champion Brandon Moreno discusses his upcoming fight with Lone'er Kavanagh this Saturday night in Mexico CIty.Follow @HoffWFAN
The drama is heating up at the NFL Combine and the takes are getting WILD. On this explosive segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to shocking comments from Aaron Glenn, who says his “superpower” is calling defensive plays for the New York Jets. But does that actually translate to WINS or more chaos?
With Evan Roberts out, the spotlight turns to the NFL Combine and the massive quarterback questions facing the Jets and Giants. As GMs, coaches, and prospects descend on Indianapolis, the real action isn’t the 40-yard dash, it’s the behind-the-scenes conversations that could reshape franchises.
The discussion zeroes in on why this week is make-or-break for the Jets’ new regime, the pressure to secure a long-term quarterback, and whether prospects like Ty Simpson are worth a bold first-round gamble. Is drafting a QB about building the franchise… or saving jobs? And how much can a strong combine performance actually change a team’s future?
Plus, a look at how the event itself has evolved into a TV spectacle, why top prospects increasingly skip drills, and what truly matters when evaluating quarterbacks in today’s NFL. For a team desperate for upside, standing still may not be an option.
The US Hockey team is catching some heat regarding their phone conversation with Donald Trump after their win.
The Olympic gold medal hockey game between Team USA and Canada had EVERYONE buzzing but on WFAN, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down why this epic moment might NOT change anything long-term. From emotional tributes and overtime drama to the reality of hockey’s place in American sports the guys ask the big question: was this just a one-day sports high?
On a snow-buried Monday in New York, Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber open the show fed up with the blizzard, only to get swept up reliving one of the most dramatic moments in USA hockey history. Team USA takes down Canada in a heart-stopping overtime thriller, Jack Hughes delivers the golden goal, and suddenly a Devils star is the face of American triumph.
But how much did it really move the needle for fans? Is an Olympic gold comparable to a championship run with your favorite team, or does the emotion fade fast when you only invest a few days into the journey? Evan, Tiki, and Shaun debate national pride vs team loyalty, casual fans vs diehards, and why hockey’s biggest stage hits differently than baseball, basketball, or football.
An exciting game and an exciting finish. You couldn't have written the script any better.
Are New York Giants fans completely overhyping this team… or is Vegas way off?! 👀
On this fiery opening segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton puts Chris McMonigle on the spot over the Giants’ shocking over/under win total — and whether fans are living in fantasy land.
With the NBA back, the conversation turns into a “what counts as success?” checklist for every team in town, and the answers get blunt fast. For the Knicks, it’s simple: anything short of the NBA Finals is a massive disappointment, and the window is not staying open forever. For the Yankees, the standard is even harsher: win the World Series, period, no matter who’s on the other side. The Mets are trickier, with the floor rising from “make the playoffs” to “get to the Division Series,” because the quick exit versions of October do not count as progress anymore.
Then the focus shifts to football, and the Giants get put under the microscope. With the offseason still unfolding, the expectations are more complicated, but the baseline is clear: competence, a winning season, and being in the mix late. The division suddenly feels more open than it did a year ago, which raises the pressure even more. And looming in the background is the Jets wild card, because one aggressive move at quarterback could instantly change the entire expectation game.
A full-state-of-the-union debate on New York sports standards, pressure points, and what “successful” really means for 2026.
We started with the Olympic hockey games yesterday. After a short detour about Sam Darnold's taxes, we got on the MLB work stoppage that’s coming next year, a salary cap and a salary floor.
Is Jalen Brunson really worth over $400 MILLION… and should NBA stars get paid if they sit out games?! On this heated segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go OFF on the future of the New York Knicks superstar and the massive contract numbers coming his way.
A stunning off-field scandal rocks baseball as MLBPA chief Tony Clark resigns amid revelations of an inappropriate relationship, sending shockwaves through the sport at the worst possible time. What does this mean for the balance of power between players and owners? Could this leadership vacuum hand Rob Manfred and the owners the leverage they’ve been waiting for?
The discussion dives into the looming labor battle, the growing push for a salary cap, and why the appointment of a hardline interim leader could push both sides toward a damaging showdown. Would either side actually sacrifice games to win the war? And after the lessons of past strikes, is baseball heading toward another lost season with nothing to show for it?
Plus, the guys debate competitive balance, small-market frustrations, deferred mega-contracts, and the uncomfortable question every fan must answer: Would you give up a season to “fix” the sport?
If you care about the future of baseball, this is a conversation you can’t ignore. ⚾
Tony Clark resigned from the MLBPA after having an inappropriate relationship with his sister-in-law who also works there. This is real bad timing with a work stoppage looming next year.
BIG interview on the Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle welcome Carlos Mendoza to talk EVERYTHING about the New York Mets heading into the season.
Major League Baseball rocked today as MLBPA executive director Tony Clark steps down amidst explosive allegations! From alleged misappropriation of union funds to a jaw-dropping personal scandal involving his sister-in-law, the drama has it all.
Did Aaron Judge really blast the Yankees’ offseason, or did everyone hear what they wanted to hear?
After one viral quote from spring training set social media on fire, we break down the FULL context of Judge’s comments, including the positive answer most people ignored. Was his frustration about the team’s direction, or simply the long wait to re-sign Cody Bellinger and key pieces?
The debate gets heated as opinions clash over leadership, loyalty, expectations of “Yankees baseball,” and whether fans are projecting their own frustrations onto the captain. Does Judge actually support “running it back,” or was he subtly calling for more moves? And how much freedom has a three-time MVP earned to speak his mind?
Chaos kicks off the show as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle go OFF on fans already panicking about a potential MLB shutdown… years before it happens. Why worry about tomorrow when baseball is about to start NOW? Meanwhile, the guys break down the stunning ruling involving Woody Johnson, the New York Jets, and the battle between players and owners over public report cards. Why did the National Football League side with ownership and what does it mean for players across the league?
The NBA tried something completely different… and it might have saved All-Star Weekend. From the early start time designed for a global audience to the fast, tournament-style format that turned every possession into crunch time, this year’s game delivered something fans haven’t felt in years: real competition.
But not everything landed. Why did the championship game fall flat? Did splitting Team USA into “young” and “old” backfire? And why did some stars seem way more invested than others?
The conversation then shifts to the bigger picture. Commissioner Adam Silver is openly searching for ways to eliminate tanking, and the proposed solutions range from intriguing to absolutely insane. A postseason tournament for lottery teams? Guaranteeing playoff spots AND top picks? Or blowing up the entire system by abolishing the draft altogether?
Plus, the crew reacts to LeBron’s comments on the USA vs. World format, debates whether All-Star Games are really just for kids now, and explores why fans crave entertainment in the moment but quickly forget the results.
If you care about where the NBA is heading, this one’s packed with ideas, arguments, and a few takes that could reshape the future of pro sports.
There's a rumor going around that Kevin Durant has a burner account that he uses to badmouth teammates.
Note: People still use X?
A scary Friday the 13th story kicks things off before the conversation turns into full Jets chaos. The guys break down how whispers about Derek Carr coming out of retirement to play for the New York Jets went from sounding obvious to suddenly feeling unrealistic. After revisiting Carr’s December comments and his latest clarification, the debate shifts to what he really wants, which teams actually make sense, and why the Jets keep finding themselves stuck in quarterback limbo. Plus, concern over Yankees injuries, early thoughts on a new weekly “worst take” segment, and the exhausting reality of chasing veteran QB solutions with no clear answer in sight.
Dan Le Batard's show producer was angry at Boomer for his take on Olympians not being proud to be American. The guy called Boomer all sorts of names.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open the show with a MASSIVE controversy surrounding Giants owner Steve Tisch and Craig says there’s only ONE solution he’s gotta go. As more emails surface, Carton explains why this is a full-blown crisis for the franchise and why the Giants can’t stay silent any longer.
Then the mood shifts and the Knicks absolutely EMBARRASS the 76ers in Philadelphia, with Knicks fans taking over the arena in a blowout statement win heading into the All-Star break. Are they becoming a championship team?
Even a Knicks hater had to admit it: watching New York go into Philadelphia and smack the Sixers around was flat out fun. And save the “Embiid didn’t play” talk, because that is the story of the Sixers. If your whole plan hinges on a guy who never seems available, you are not a real postseason threat.
The Knicks deserved credit for showing up tough in the final game before the All Star break, with Jose Alvarado bringing edge and the whole team playing more physical, more direct, and way less whiny. But the bigger question is the one Knicks fans have been living with all season: this team looks capable of being great, and also capable of the most annoying letdown losses imaginable.
So with the break here, the guys make a one day only exception and do the Mike Brown vs Tom Thibodeau temperature check. Do you feel better, worse, or the same about the Knicks right now, and what do you make of the inconsistency heading into the stretch run?
We're a lot happier today after the Knicks simply ruined the Philadelphia 76ers. We also touched on some college ball as Kansas' superstar Darren Peterson and others are missing some big games.
What started as a mystery caller turned into an AWESOME surprise on The Carton Show! Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle take a random call from Chicago… only to realize it’s ACTUALLY former Mets All-Star catcher Todd Hundley calling in LIVE! Todd breaks down Francisco Lindor’s hamate bone surgery, what recovery REALLY looks like, and whether Mets fans should expect him ready for Opening Day. Plus, incredible insight into hitting, the steroid era, rule changes, and life after baseball.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle kick off the show with MASSIVE sports drama Francisco Lindor heads into surgery just weeks before Opening Day, Mets fans are already sweating… and Craig absolutely GOES OFF on LeBron James for skipping another showdown with the Spurs.
Three major stories broke after the show ended, but the conversation quickly zeroes in on the most polarizing one. Evan and Tiki debate Juan Soto’s move from right field to left field, why it actually makes sense at Citi Field, and why the timing and explanation from the Mets still feels strange.
The discussion digs into Soto’s defensive history, his split time between left and right field throughout his career, and whether the World Baseball Classic played a bigger role than the team wants to admit. Plus, questions about roster construction, fan reaction, and why this move was obvious to some long before it became official, even if it still feels awkward the way it rolled out.
Knicks somehow lost to the worst team in the NBA - one that is probably tanking the season.
One of the funniest moments of the Carton Show. Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle completely set up WFAN producer Pete with a fake call from “former Met Todd Hundley” complete with Abu Dhabi stories, family trivia, and a flawless sell. The reveal sends the studio into chaos as Pete realizes he’s been had, live on air.
The New York Mets offseason takes a brutal turn. On the Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to shocking news that Francisco Lindor may need hamate surgery and could miss Opening Day plus the Mets announcing Juan Soto will be their starting LEFT FIELDER. Was this even the plan? Carton unloads on the Mets’ front office, questions the timing, and wonders if the season is already spiraling before spring training even starts. Mets fans are NOT going to like this.
The next big football story in New York might be the Jets, not the Giants. While the Giants feel “done” after locking in their coach and QB plan, the Jets are staring at a total quarterback reset with Aaron Glenn back, Frank Reich running the offense, and zero easy answers on the market.
Then a weekend report lights the fuse: Derek Carr is seriously considering a return, his shoulder is reportedly fully healthy, and the Saints still hold his rights. Is Carr the smart “bridge” the Jets actually need, or is this just another offseason mirage? Plus, why Carr vs Kirk Cousins is a real debate, how the Raiders could complicate everything, and the moment the conversation flips into “wait… does Carr actually want to be a Jet?”
Craig Carton unloads on the New England Patriots after their ugly Super Bowl loss, calling Drake Maye one of the most overrated quarterbacks in NFL history. As a proud Jets fan, Craig celebrates the Patriots’ downfall, debates Chris McMonigle on whether New England has a real franchise QB, and explains why this was a total fraud run.
While most fans called it boring, this was a perfect night for anyone who enjoys watching the New England Patriots fall flat on the biggest stage. We break down why Super Bowl 60 was far more entertaining than people want to admit, especially if you are a Jets fan or anyone tired of Patriots success.
From Seattle Seahawks controlling the game with defense and the run, to New England Patriots looking overwhelmed offensively, this episode dives into why the outcome felt inevitable early. We talk about Drake Maye struggling under playoff pressure, why the Patriots’ easy path finally caught up to them, and how Seattle won without needing a heroic performance from Sam Darnold.
Was the game ugly? Absolutely. Was it satisfying? For at least one bitter Jets fan, it was four hours of joy. We also look ahead to what this loss means for the Patriots, why getting close does not guarantee you will ever get back, and whether Seattle can realistically repeat this formula next season.
A defensive game that was honestly a bit of a dud. You have to be happy for Seattle and Sam Darnold regardless.
Craig Carton opens Super Bowl Friday by absolutely unloading on New York Giants fans. Eli Manning misses the Hall of Fame cut, Abdul Carter gets ZERO Defensive Rookie of the Year votes, and Jaxson Dart manages just ONE vote while Giants fans argue Greg Roman is a “great hire.” Chris McMonigle pushes back, Carton gloats, and Giants Twitter takes another beating. Classic Carton Show chaos on WFAN.
As Super Bowl 60 approaches, Evan tries to “squint” and find hope for New York football, and Tiki actually sees a real blueprint. The Giants, led by John Harbaugh and rookie QB Jaxson Dart, look eerily similar to the Patriots’ recent turnaround: solid run game, defense ready to modernize under Denard Wilson, and a rookie season stat line that mirrors Drake Maye. The big swing factor: can Matt Nagy be the Josh McDaniels type who accelerates Dart into stardom?
Gavin McKenna is the best junior hockey player in the world, but he’s now facing first-degree felony aggravated assault charges after a massive brawl at a Penn State bar. Craig Carton and Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle break down the shocking details.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle declare the New York Knicks are a LEGIT championship contender after an electric double-OT win over Denver. Giannis staying in Milwaukee? Carton says it’s actually GOOD news for the Knicks. Karl-Anthony Towns gets praised for finally “growing up,” Mitchell Robinson dominates Jokic, and Jalen Brunson proves he’s THAT guy.
Everything snaps into focus once The Athletic report drops: Deuce McBride is getting surgery for a core muscle injury and might be out until the playoffs. Five minutes ago, the Alvarado trade felt like smart “just in case” depth. Now the “just in case” has a name and it’s a scalpel.
The guys immediately pounce on what feels “off” about the situation. McBride had been listed as left ankle injury management, then it morphed into an ankle issue, and now it’s suddenly a core muscle surgery that never showed up on the injury report in any obvious way. That whiplash becomes the story, not just the injury itself. They compare it to how different leagues handle transparency, with the NFL forcing specifics while other sports can play games with wording, competitive advantage, and vague reporting.
Breaking news hits mid-show and the Knicks make a classic contender move, grabbing Jose Alvarado from the Pelicans. The guys immediately lean into the New York angle, Alvarado is a local kid, and the “homecoming” vibe matters because this is a player built for Madison Square Garden energy. They run through the scouting report fast: high motor, pest defender, full-court pressure, and the nickname says it all. “Grand Theft Alvarado” is about taking the ball, not the video game jokes, even if they still squeeze those in.
Then the return drops and everyone starts laughing because it’s one of those deals where you almost assume there has to be more. The Knicks give up newly acquired Dalen Terry and two second round picks. That’s it. It also sets up a mini victory lap at the reporters who said the Knicks were nowhere close to Alvarado.
From there, the basketball case gets loud. This is a playoff-rotation pickup, not a headline grab. They frame Alvarado as a weapon for a series where you need someone to harass a primary ball handler, with Cade Cunningham being the example that keeps coming up. He also becomes insurance for Deuce McBride with the injury situation still weird and vague. The point is simple: you just added a guy who will actually play when it matters, without touching the core.
The Knicks beat the Nuggets last night and it seemed like an NBA Finals preview. Also, what about Giannis?
Craig Carton opens the Carton Show with a take Jets fans aren’t used to hearing — optimism. Craig and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle break down why hiring Frank Reich as offensive coordinator might finally signal competence inside Florham Park, and what it REALLY says about the Jets’ quarterback plan.
Trade deadline eve gets spicy fast after a new report out of The Athletic delivers the money quote from Giannis: “I want to be here, but I want to win.” Evan and Tiki translate what that really means for Milwaukee, why the Giannis uncertainty froze the market, and why so many teams made their moves early.
Then Ian Begley joins the show to lay out the hard truth for Knicks fans: New York is on the outside looking in on Giannis right now, not because they “love their roster,” but because they simply do not have the assets to win that bidding war. Begley explains what the Knicks could still do before 3:00 PM, including potential targets like Jose Alvarado and a backup big, plus how Deuce McBride’s status factors in.
Finally, the conversation widens to the East shifting under everyone’s feet, from Cleveland’s aggressive swing to Boston’s moves, and why the real Giannis sweepstakes might be headed for the offseason.
Yankees manager Aaron Boone joins Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle on The Carton Show on WFAN for a wide-ranging, no-nonsense interview that hits every topic Yankees fans obsess over. Boone addresses long-standing rumors about Brian Cashman and analytics controlling in-game decisions, responds to criticism about accountability, and explains why he won’t rewatch painful losses. Plus, Boone opens up on Aaron Judge’s leadership, Giancarlo Stanton’s health, Gerrit Cole’s rehab, Anthony Volpe’s future, bullpen struggles, running it back in 2026, and the pressure of managing the New York Yankees without a championship. A must-watch conversation during Super Bowl week as Boone heads to Tampa for spring training.
Bantamweights Mario Bautista & Vinicious Oliveira clash at UFC Fight Night 266 for a chance to try and crack the top 5 in the division. Pete Hoffman gets a chance to speak with Mario Bautista during fight week to talk about the huge matchup!
Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram, TikTok
Shaun Morash claimed he had inside info that Mougey was telling people not to come to the Jets because they are a disaster. Boomer answers that.
Super Bowl week turns into full-blown New York football chaos on the Carton Show. Craig Carton and Chris “Big Mac” McMonigle react to the Giants hiring Matt Nagy as offensive coordinator for Jaxson Dart, breaking down why fans are split on the move. Then Craig goes OFF defending the Jets after a wild report sparks another round of Jets dysfunction talk. Is this a competent Giants hire? Are the Jets being unfairly dragged again? Plus classic Carton rants, media drama, and peak WFAN energy you don’t want to miss.
Breaking news hits early as the New York Giants officially hire Matt Nagy as offensive coordinator under John Harbaugh. The crew digs into Nagy’s winding path from Chicago to Kansas City, his fit with Jaxson Dart, and why Theo Johnson could quietly thrive in this offense. It is not a splashy hire, but it feels deliberate, competent, and very Giants.
Then the conversation takes a sharp turn to the New York Jets, where exclusive reporting paints a bleak picture of an organization unraveling from the top down. Woody Johnson is accused of stripping authority from head coach Aaron Glenn, blocking key hires including Wink Martindale, and creating a culture so toxic that league insiders are warning others to stay away. As the Giants project stability and direction, the Jets appear stuck in a familiar cycle of dysfunction with no clear exit in sight.
They're still looking but there's more of a consensus that it might just be Frank Reich. We ask Boomer.
Craig Carton unloads on fake Super Bowl outrage during a fiery rant on The Carton Show with Chris McMonigle. From people claiming they’ll boycott the halftime show, to debates over whether this Super Bowl matchup is “sexy,” Carton says everyone needs to stop lying because we’re all watching anyway. Plus, takes on Bad Bunny, halftime politics, boring matchups, NFL hypocrisy, and why the Super Bowl is still king no matter who’s playing. Classic Carton unfiltered radio at its finest on WFAN.
The release of thousands of Jeffrey Epstein related emails puts uncomfortable attention on the NFL, including the naming of New York Giants minority owner Steve Tisch. The discussion breaks down why some mentions are meaningless, why others can seriously damage reputations, and why this one sits in a very different category.
The guys question why national NFL media largely ignored the story, what responsibility Roger Goodell has when it comes to ownership optics, and whether the league actually has the will to act when no crime is alleged but the association itself is troubling. They also examine how this impacts the Giants brand, the Mara family, and why protecting the shield has mattered in past ownership cases.
Ultimately, it becomes a larger conversation about power, accountability, and whether the NFL will confront uncomfortable realities or quietly move on once the headlines fade.
We open with the shocking revelation that Steve Tisch, co-owner of the New York Giants, shows up in emails to and from Jeffrey Epstein. What does it mean and what is the NFL going to do.
Lightweight Dan Hooker joins Pete Hoffman to talk about his co-main event this Saturday at UFC 325.
Follow @HoffWFAN on Instagram, TikTok & X
Wink was supposed to be here as DC. Hey, wha'happen? We also ponder Frank Reich's decision to come to this mess.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle kick off the show breaking down a wild New York sports day. The Giants lose Todd Monken to the Browns, sparking a heated debate about embarrassment, John Harbaugh, and Jaxson Dart’s future. The Jets get dragged into the Jon Gruden chaos, Barstool jokes fly, and the Knicks enter the Giannis Antetokounmpo trade conversation. Pure Carton energy, real New York sports drama, and zero filters.
Evan lays out every major report from the last 48 hours and asks the big question Knicks fans cannot avoid anymore: is a Giannis Antetokounmpo trade actually happening? From Milwaukee’s growing acceptance that a split may be coming, to Rich Paul circling, Portland lurking in a multi team deal, and the Knicks quietly testing the Karl Anthony Towns market, the smoke is everywhere. The guys debate whether the Knicks should pull the trigger before the deadline, what it would cost, how it impacts chemistry and health, and whether this move raises the ceiling or slams the championship window shut.
Who did? Glenn? Mougey? Woody? Here's the whole first part of the show as we try to figure out what's going on.
Live from the Giants fieldhouse, the scene is set with hundreds in attendance, current players in the building, and the room going silent as the organization prepares to introduce its next head coach. The guys play a quick prediction game on what Harbaugh will cite first for taking the job, then the moment arrives as Joe Schoen steps to the podium and officially introduces John Harbaugh as the new head coach of the New York Football Giants.
Harbaugh’s opening remarks hit hard. He makes it clear he wanted the job, embraces the expectations of New York, and lays out a foundation built on toughness, physical football, discipline, and finishing. He emphasizes “team” repeatedly, thanks ownership, and brings the room into his mindset with a message about attacking every day with “enthusiasm unknown to mankind.”
In the Q&A, Harbaugh addresses why he didn’t take time off, what he likes about the roster, and why he’s excited to work with Jaxson Dart. He talks staff building starting immediately, explains what “culture” means in football terms, and even nods to Andy Reid’s advice that “change can be good.” The press conference closes with Harbaugh reinforcing that success starts with how the Giants work every day and how they choose to play on tape.
New Giants head coach John Harbaugh sits down with Evan and Tiki right after his introduction and gets into what made this job feel inevitable, why the Giants are an iconic fit, and what he believes the team can become. Harbaugh talks about leaving Baltimore, his relationship with ownership, and the role his family and faith play in how he approaches the grind of coaching.
On the football side, he dives into what he saw on tape, why the run game starts up front, and what excites him about the Giants’ backfield and offensive line. He discusses Abdul Carter’s rookie finish, the importance of physicality, and how he wants the Giants to win in the margins. Harbaugh also explains how he views Jaxson Dart as a modern quarterback who gives an offense options, from RPOs to quarterback driven concepts that stress defenses.
Harbaugh updates where he is in the coordinator search, confirms he is meeting with the current staff, and even entertains the idea of reaching out to familiar names from his past. He also shares what he wants Giants fans to feel watching this team, pride, identity, and effort that shows up on tape every week. The interview closes with a few lighter moments, including the early morning workout routine and the competitive edge that comes with a fresh start in New York.
Giants general manager Joe Schoen joins the show fresh off the hiring of John Harbaugh and walks through how the process came together so quickly. Schoen details why the Giants were prepared for unexpected coaching movement, how early research mattered, and why they moved decisively once Harbaugh became available.
Schoen also opens up about roster construction, the importance of Jaxson Dart’s development, and why the Giants believe their young core made the job attractive. He addresses his own performance as GM, the Daniel Jones decision, resisting short term fixes, and the plan to keep building through free agency and the draft. The conversation closes with roster priorities, staff building, and why Schoen believes the Giants are positioned for a real turnaround under Harbaugh.
Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle kick off this edition of "The Carton Show" with a heated debate over the future of New York Football. Giants & Jets could be the next Patriots? Who actually has a bright future if either? Also the guys get into it when discussing John Harbaugh's motivations for coming to Big Blue.
Connor Hughes of SNY has been on it and Boomer said the reporting seems accurate. We break down what it might mean for the team and their future.
Craig Carton comes out FIRING on The Carton Show as he unloads on the New England Patriots’ “gift-wrapped” road to the Super Bowl. From Sam Darnold debates to Sean Payton’s coaching blunders, Carton and Chris McMonigle clash over bad football, bad offenses, and fans crying about snow games. Plus, Craig says there’s BLOOM OFF the Bill Belichick rose and predicts a shocking coaching return.
The AFC Championship turned into a full-on weather event, and Evan and Tiki debate whether that chaos made the game unforgettable or completely unwatchable. They break down how the Patriots benefitted once they had the lead, why the second half felt like 1960s football, and whether weather should ever decide a championship. Plus, the poll that perfectly split the audience, the contrast with a beautifully played NFC title game, and the bigger question looming over the NFL. Did the snow make this game legendary, or did it ruin real football?
Drafted third overall by the NY Jets who (of course) could do nothing with him. Bounced around. Disrespected by the Vikings. Now he's going to the Super Bowl. Ha!
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the wild report that former NFL QB Philip Rivers is the frontrunner to become the Buffalo Bills head coach. Can a quarterback with zero NFL coaching experience really lead Josh Allen and a Super Bowl contender? The guys debate recycled coaches vs thinking outside the box, break down the Sam Darnold narrative and why it’s NOT a Jets story, dive into Giants organizational changes under John Harbaugh, and look ahead to Championship Weekend. Classic Carton Show chaos, arguments, laughs, and strong takes from WFAN.
A Jets fan dilemma: Sam Darnold is one win from the Super Bowl, and the fan base is split between rooting for a guy they still like and bracing for the avalanche of “LOL Jets” takes that would follow.
The guys revisit how the Jets handled Darnold, how the “seeing ghosts” moment became a career-defining label, and why moving on for Zach Wilson still feels like the franchise’s biggest sliding doors decision. They also debate how much credit Darnold deserves for Seattle’s success, why Jets fans fear two weeks of nonstop relitigating, and whether this would be more embarrassing than Giants fans watching Saquon win it all in Philly. Plus, the poll question that could start an all-out NY fan war.
But what did the Mets have to give up? Some say too much. Jett Williams and Brandon Sproat have been sent packing. David Stearns gets his guy. Is the off-season complete?Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram & TikTok
Pat Leonard joins Craig Carton and Big Mac to break down the real impact of John Harbaugh taking over the New York Giants. From cleaning up leaks inside the building to reshaping the front office, Harbaugh is already wielding serious power. The guys dive into whether Joe Schoen is officially on borrowed time, what scared ownership into making massive changes, and how broken the Giants organization truly was behind the scenes. Plus: Jaxson Dart’s future, staff shakeups, and why this finally feels different for Giants fans.
Craig Carton goes full Mr. Positive as the Mets finally make a splash, landing Freddy Peralta — and somehow fans are STILL complaining. Craig unloads on miserable Mets fans, fires shots at Evan Roberts’ negativity, defends trading prospects to win NOW, and declares the Mets a better team today than yesterday. Plus, a classic Carton rant on why fans can’t have it both ways. Passion, arguments, and laughs to kick off the Carton Show.
- Evan makes one thing clear right away: he does not hate the move, but he is not celebrating either. The Mets are undeniably better after adding Freddy Peralta, and the rotation finally looks respectable. The problem is the price. Two top-100 prospects for a pitcher Evan believes is a one-year rental based on the track record of David Stearns.
- That sparks a deeper conversation about what the Mets are actually building under Stearns and Steve Cohen. Is this a smart year-to-year strategy, or a risky way to live as a fan? Evan lays out why a rental only works if it leads to a World Series run, compares the move to past Mets rentals, and asks fans the real question: what result makes this trade worth it?
- Plus, a hilarious and painfully real dad moment from Madison Square Garden, where Evan has to explain to his kids both Nets misery and why Jet Williams is suddenly no longer a Mets prospect.
The best play by play man in all sports, Jon Anik, stops by the WFAN studios and talks all things UFC, Boston Sports, New York Sports and a whole lot more with Pete Hoffman.Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram & TikTok
With Freddy Peralta now coming to Citi Field, we're pretty up on the moves the Mets have made this off-season. We also toss some Yankees talk to mix it up a bit.
Craig Carton and Big Mac react to a huge day in New York sports as the Yankees officially bring back Cody Bellinger, shutting the door on the Mets, Blue Jays, and Dodgers. Craig explains why patience paid off for Brian Cashman and why this move was a must to avoid a disastrous offseason in the Bronx. The conversation turns fiery as the guys debate the Mets’ pivot from Kyle Tucker and Bellinger to Luis Robert Jr., questioning whether Mets fans should really be “crowing” over a defense-first, low-power lineup.
The Mets finally make the move everyone assumed would never happen, acquiring Luis Robert Jr. and forcing a hard look at what this roster is really becoming. Evan, Tiki, and Shaun debate why the trade makes sense defensively, why the upside is real despite two rough seasons, and why the only true risk might be financial.
The conversation turns into a deeper breakdown of David Stearns’ long term vision, the famous “painting” analogy, and whether this lineup is better, worse, or just wildly different after losing Pete Alonso and reshaping the middle of the field. They dive into Robert’s change of scenery potential, the Mets’ desperate need for a real center fielder, and how bad last year’s production truly was at that spot.
Plus, the ripple effect on the Cody Bellinger sweepstakes, why the Mets likely have a short term offer out, and why Yankees fans may feel more confident as the staredown with Scott Boras continues. The big question remains: when you squint at this roster, is the picture starting to come together or does it still feel unfinished?
From a breathless intro by Joe Schoen, who sent Mara to Harbaugh, and whether Rex Ryan might join the staff, everything from yesterday.
Craig Carton and Chris “C-Mac” McMonigle react to the introduction of John Harbaugh as the new head coach of the New York Giants. Is this the long-awaited rebirth of Big Blue, or are Giants fans and media getting carried away with a feel-good pep rally? The guys debate what Harbaugh actually guarantees, the meaning of “competency,” Joe Schoen’s role, tough questions the media didn’t ask, and whether this hire truly changes the Giants’ future or just the vibes.
The Jets are in a rare spot, there are plenty of head coaching jobs available and they aren't one of them. However, maybe they should be.
Follow @HoffWFAN on Instagram, TikTok & X
The day starts with the Hoosiers win over the Hurricanes and how good Fernando Mendoza played. We also get into all coaching changes that are happening in the NFL.
Craig Carton and Big Mac react to a wild NFL Divisional Round weekend and dive headfirst into the biggest storylines shaking up New York sports. The guys break down the New York Giants landing John Harbaugh, why Vegas still isn’t buying the hype, and whether Giants fans should be satisfied with an 8-win expectation. Plus, Craig unloads on Josh Allen after another Bills playoff disappointment, questions Sean McDermott’s firing, and debates the controversial interception that changed everything. Is Josh Allen really in the Mahomes/Burrow tier? And what is John Harbaugh truly worth to the Giants? All that and more from The Carton Show on WFAN.
Evan opens with a brutal but honest take: he hates the Bills, celebrated their loss, and still believes Buffalo got completely screwed. The guys break down the interception that never should have stood, why the lack of a real review in overtime is indefensible, and how nearly the same play was officiated the opposite way just one day later.
The discussion turns to the pass interference calls that suddenly appeared after flags were swallowed all game, and whether Sean McDermott truly lost his job because of the officiating or if Buffalo was already looking for an exit. Josh Allen’s turnovers, Denver’s credit, and the league’s obsession with “consistency” all collide in a segment that explains why this loss felt bigger than just one bad night.
It happened. The Buffalo Bills got rid of Sean McDermott after their loss to Denver. This opens the door for a familiar face. Peter's got the highlights of the weekend and a Moment of the Day that is maybe a bit too revealing.
A wild opening segment on The Carton Show as Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the most chaotic 24 hours of the MLB offseason. The Mets thought they had Kyle Tucker locked up before the Dodgers swooped in during the dead of night, sparking outrage across New York. Craig unloads on Mets and Yankees fans for whining about money, calls the Dodgers the new Evil Empire, and debates whether the Mets truly “panicked” or smartly pivoted to Bo Bichette. Plus, why Bichette was a better fit for the Yankees, why Yankee fans should actually be angrier than Mets fans, and a fiery argument over whether the Dodgers have an unfair advantage or are just smarter than everyone else.
The news Mets fans feared becomes reality as Kyle Tucker chooses the Los Angeles Dodgers over the New York Mets. Evan reacts with raw frustration, breaking down why this one hurts even though the Mets made a massive and legitimate offer. Tiki Barber explains why the Dodgers always win these battles, how their financial edge changes everything, and why no one should be surprised.
The conversation turns from Tucker to the bigger picture as Evan questions the Mets’ offseason direction, the failure to replace Pete Alonso, and what the real pivot is with spring training approaching. Is this anger really about Tucker, or about the position the Mets have put themselves in? Plus a Winston Churchill inspired rally cry, and a brewing conspiracy involving MLB and Rob Manfred.
A must listen for Mets fans trying to figure out where this team goes next and whether there is still a path to contention.
The Mets made a crazy offer. The Dodgers made a crazier offer and Tucker said thanks. Boomer explains why it's the owners and not the players that are going to cause a lockout in 2027.
4 years and $240 million dollars. The Los Angeles Dodgers have done it again.Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram, TikTok
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open the show reacting to the Giants officially landing John Harbaugh as head coach, calling it the biggest and best move the franchise has made in over a decade. Craig gives credit where it’s due — the Giants got their dream coach and instantly stabilized the organization — but quickly pumps the brakes, arguing Big Blue still has the worst quarterback and wide receiver group in the NFC East. Big Mac fires back with optimism, playoff dreams, and belief in Jaxson Dart, while Craig plays the role of honest reality check.
The New York Giants finally land the coach everyone wanted. The guys break down why John Harbaugh choosing the Giants over every other opening is such a massive statement for the franchise, and why this cycle feels different from the last decade of misses. They also explain how Joe Schoen deserves real credit for building a roster and drafting Jaxson Dart in a way that made the job irresistible for a Super Bowl winning head coach. From coaching failures of the past to why this move feels like a true turning point, this is why Giants fans have every reason to believe again.
Lots of reports coming in that the ink is almost dry for the Giants to get their head coach. So let's talk who his coordinators might be.
Hoff explains his issues with David Stearns and how he's playing too many games during this off-season.
Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram & TikTok
Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle are interrupted by breaking news that Oregon QB Dante Moore has decided to stay in school another year. Craig Carton discusses why this may be a great thing for the Jets & their fans.
Veteran New York reporter Ian O'Connor joins Tiki and Evan to break down the most pivotal day in the New York Giants coaching search. O’Connor explains why the Giants are firmly out in front in the pursuit of John Harbaugh, why New York’s quarterback situation gives them an edge over Atlanta and Tennessee, and how today’s meeting could determine whether this saga ends quickly or drags on. Plus, why there is effectively no true Plan B, what could cause hesitation, and why this hire would be the biggest the Giants have made in decades.
Mets fans are running out of patience, and it all comes down to one name. Evan and Tiki break down why signing Kyle Tucker would not make this a perfect offseason, but could absolutely save it. They dig into the bidding war with the Dodgers and Blue Jays, Steve Cohen’s willingness to flex financially, and David Stearns’ short term contract philosophy. Plus, why missing out on Tucker would leave the Mets banking on too many maybes, reopen the Pete Alonso wound, and make this offseason feel just as bleak as it did a month ago. Everything is on the line in the next 24 hours.
Mike Tomlin stepped down yesterday. Will he go to TV next year? How will the Steelers follow his success and that of his predecessor, Bill Cowher?
Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle kick off the show debating the Giants strategy to wooing John Harbaugh when news of Mike Tomlin stepping down as Steeler head coach starts to circulate.
Another January, another familiar ending in Pittsburgh. The Steelers bow out early, the offense goes silent, and Steeler fans immediately turn their frustration toward Mike Tomlin. But the conversation shifts to a more uncomfortable question: what if Tomlin is the one who’s ready to move on?
The guys break down the post Ben Roethlisberger quarterback void, the never-ending coordinator carousel, and why the Steelers’ constant playoff appearances may actually be trapping them in mediocrity. They explore the Sean Payton comparison, the idea of Tomlin stepping away to reset, and why that scenario could quietly benefit the Jets while complicating things for the Giants. Plus, Aaron Rodgers’ latest playoff exit raises real questions about his future and whether this version of Rodgers can still lift a team when it matters most.
The Texans defense just stifled the Steelers. Is Tomlin's time with the team done? Plus, we look ahead to the Divisional Round.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle open the show with Craig unloading on what he calls a brutal weekend for Jets fans, despite an incredible slate of playoff football. The Bills advance, the Patriots win again, and Dante Moore’s national stage performance only fuels Craig’s fear of the Jets getting it wrong—again.
The Packers melt down in an all time ugly loss to the Bears, and for a minute it feels like Matt LaFleur could actually be in trouble. Then Adam Schefter drops the update: Green Bay expects a new deal, and the conversation flips from “fire him” to “what if the contract talks get weird?”
From there, Evan and Tiki zoom out to the Giants’ view of Wild Card Weekend and why it didn’t create any scary new openings. The real issue is the same one it’s been: the entire coaching market is basically stuck until John Harbaugh makes his move, with teams like the Giants and Browns convinced they have a shot.
They debate the reported Harbaugh price tag, why the top coach available is going to push for top dollar, and how LaFleur’s postseason résumé has taken hits despite regular season success. Plus: Schefter’s “Packers connection” to Harbaugh, why it’s interesting but not needle moving, and what would actually make Green Bay a real threat if a vacancy somehow opened up.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into a wide-ranging NFL discussion on The Carton Show and if Craig will be coming out to a Group outing with the guys at WFAN
The Giants coaching search has reached the point where it feels like one name is towering over everyone else: John Harbaugh. Evan explains why this has become a “massive disappointment” situation if the Giants don’t land him, even if the replacement is a proven coach like Kevin Stefanski or Mike McCarthy. Tiki pushes back with a reality check: Harbaugh could want a break, he might not want a rebuild, and nothing is guaranteed. The big question becomes simple: are Giants fans being reasonable… or is this officially turning into Harbaugh or heartbreak?
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle sit down in studio with MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred for a wide-ranging, candid conversation on the state of baseball. Manfred addresses free agency deadlines, the Dodgers’ spending power, competitive balance concerns, and whether baseball needs spending incentives or a salary cap. He also discusses looming CBA fears, the integrity of the game amid gambling expansion, automated balls and strikes, the World Baseball Classic, MLB expansion and realignment, regional sports network instability, and his legacy as commissioner.
Tiki Barber doubles down on his surprising stance in the Giants coaching debate, explaining why Kevin Stefanski edges out John Harbaugh for him. The discussion centers on QB development, staff building, and long term upside versus the comfort of a proven track record. The guys dig into Stefanski’s “boost factor,” Harbaugh’s elite résumé, concerns about burnout, and why the Giants may need hunger and fire as much as experience in their next head coach.
Gio drops a bombshell thought - could Harbaugh end up with the Bills or even...the Eagles?
Craig Carton plays the role of the “Grinch” as he pumps the brakes on Giants fans celebrating the idea of John Harbaugh coming to New York. In a fiery chess-vs-checkers debate with Chris McMonigle, Carton explains why Harbaugh holds all the leverage, why the Giants can’t rush this process, and how other NFL jobs (Bills, Eagles, Packers) could derail Big Blue’s plans. Is this the greatest coaching carousel ever—or a potential disaster waiting to happen for the Giants?
The Giants are caught between temptation and patience as the coaching market heats up. Evan and Shaun debate whether chasing John Harbaugh is worth the risk of losing Kevin Stefanski, and why this search could turn historic fast. Desire, panic, and power plays collide as the New York Giants try not to blow the biggest hire of the decade.
The NFL coaching carousel just hit warp speed. With John Harbaugh officially out in Baltimore, the New York giants are suddenly staring at a franchise-altering opportunity.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the news that the Ravens have fired John Harbaugh. Safe to say Chris McMonigle is very happy.
Evan and Shaun dig into James Dolan’s appearance with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle. They break down the short-term bet on Big Mac’s first question, Dolan’s comments on the Knicks, trade deadline expectations, and what it really means when Dolan says Leon Rose can overrule him.
Then the conversation turns to the Rangers, Chris Drury, and Dolan preaching patience, which sparks frustration and skepticism. The Knicks slump comes back into focus with more reaction to their lack of effort and whether this rough stretch actually matters long term. Plus, more Giants coaching search calls, Kafka criticism, defensive coach debates, and a live report from Detroit after another ugly Knicks performance.
What if the Giants could get Kevin Stefanski as head coach and Jonathan Gannon as defensive coordinator?
New York Knicks and Rangers owner James Dolan joins The Carton Show with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle for a rare, wide-ranging, and candid interview—his first public sit-down in years. Dolan opens up about the controversial decision to move on from Tom Thibodeau, why collaboration and player development drove the coaching change, and why this Knicks roster is built to win an NBA championship now, not just compete. On the Rangers side, Dolan explains his patience with Chris Drury and Mike Sullivan, the culture reset in progress, and why fans shouldn’t give up despite early struggles.
The Carton Show officially begins on WFAN as Craig Carton makes his long-awaited return to afternoon drive alongside Chris McMonigle. The debut show open gets off to a chaotic, hilarious start as Carton and C-Mac joke about the rocky launch, producer mishaps, and the pressure of Day 1. From there, they dive straight into Jets vs. Giants dysfunction, coaching decisions, quarterback futures, and Craig’s bold vision for fixing New York football. A must-listen opening that sets the tone for a brand-new era on WFAN.
Joe B joins Evan and Tiki for a must-hear, no-filter interview as Black Monday fallout hits full force. Joe unloads on the Jets keeping Aaron Glenn after a historically brutal finish, calling it one of the most embarrassing stretches of football he’s ever seen. The conversation dives into why this coaching staff can’t be trusted to develop a young quarterback, what the Jets should do with the No. 2 pick, and whether drafting a franchise QB into this situation is setting him up to fail.
Joe also lays out his blueprint for fixing the roster, from adding a real veteran quarterback to overhauling a broken defense, plus his thoughts on Rex Ryan, Mike McCarthy, Kliff Kingsbury, and why this job still isn’t attractive to top coaches. The interview wraps with Super Bowl predictions, Mets frustration, and classic Joe B rants that hit like a fastball.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle join us in the studio to promote their new afternoon show which starts today on WFAN. Craig said there will be an SNY simulcast for two hours of the show. Jim Dolan will be a guest in the studio today at 5:30pm with Carton and C-Mac.
A horrible season finally comes to an end. Were they worse than the Kotite Jets? Um...yeah.
With a combined record of 7-27 the Jets and Giants end another bad season of football in New York. Was there a silver lining anywhere?Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Instagram & TikTok
Jeff McNeil is the last part of the Mets "core" that has finally found a new home. With Nimmo, Diaz, Alonso and now McNeil moving on to new teams, how does Stearns go about building his new core?Follow @HoffWFAN on X, Insta & TikTok
The Mets and Yankees continue to recycle one another's players? Why is that the case? Plus week 16 in the NFL.Follow @HOFFWFAN on X Insta and TikTok
In a deeply personal and raw final hour, Brandon Tierney delivers his ultimate sign-off from the legendary WFAN. The segment kicks off with a surprise call from BT’s biggest fan and toughest critic—his father—who takes listeners on a 25-year trip through BT’s career: from packing up for Allentown to the drive-time battles in San Francisco, and finally, his "dream fulfilled" return to New York.
BT reflects on the "unrelenting drive" that defined his run, acknowledging that while his time in the midday slot is ending due to station shifts (the return of Craig Carton), he leaves with his head high and his competitive fire unquenched. He shares his pride in sharing studios with titans like Stephen A. Smith, calling Knicks games at the Garden, and building the "Unkillable" brand with co-host Sal Licata. It’s a tear-filled, high-energy goodbye to the city he loves, ending not with a whimper, but with a promise that the next chapter will be his biggest yet.
In a wide-ranging, high-octane interview, Hall of Famer Rick Pitino joins Brandon Tierney to discuss the state of St. John's basketball and his storied career. Pitino gets brutally honest about his current squad, admitting they lack the veteran dominance of last year's team and issuing a public challenge to Bryce Hopkins to become an "alpha dog" or risk his NBA dreams.
The conversation turns fiery and nostalgic as Pitino recounts a "hysterical" story from the birth of WFAN, remembering how "clinical moron" callers wanted him fired while his Knicks were in first place. The Coach also settles New York's greatest debates, naming Pearl Washington and Kenny Anderson as the ultimate handles and Chris Mullin as the city’s premier marksman. To wrap it up, BT shares a legendary personal story of an all-night bar session with Pitino that felt like a scene straight out of The Godfather.
In a massive, wide-ranging interview, Alex Rodriguez joins Brandon Tierney to deliver a masterclass on the current state of the game. A-Rod doesn't pull any punches, declaring the Yankees' organizational hitting philosophy "absolutely broken" and critiquing the development of Anthony Volpe, arguing the team is forcing a "little guy" to play a "big boy game" that neuters his best assets.
The two discuss the ticking clock on Aaron Judge’s prime, the criteria for signing free agents like Cody Bellinger, and the "sad" takeover of data-driven analytics that has sidelined traditional baseball people. A-Rod also shares intimate reflections on his HBO documentary, the healing process of turning 50, and hilarious behind-the-scenes stories about David Ortiz and his relationship with the "2009 Homeboys." From Pete Alonso's exit from the Mets to his own refusal to manage in today's patient-less league, this is A-Rod at his most transparent and passionate.
It’s the end of the road for a New York radio stalwart. In this emotional and high-energy final broadcast, Brandon Tierney officially signs off as a full-time host on WFAN. Refusing to go out with a whimper, BT brings in the big guns with A-list guests Alex Rodriguez and Rick Pitino to celebrate a career built on "emptying the tank" every single day.
BT doesn't hold back on his final sports takes either, ripping into the "inexcusable" coaching decisions of Tom Thibodeau and standing firm as an Aaron Glenn supporter despite the Jets' defensive "train wreck." He reflects on his journey from Brooklyn Little League to the Division 1 mound and finally to the pinnacle of New York sports talk. While the day is bittersweet, BT leaves with his head high, delivering a masterclass in authenticity and connection, proving that while this chapter is closing, the "Unkillable" brand is only just beginning.
Did the Rams get robbed, or did the Seahawks just play to the whistle? We break down that bizarre 2-point conversion where the defense stood still while Seattle found the end zone.
Filling in for BT & Sal, Marc "Moose" Malusis delivers a blistering critique of the Yankees' 2025-2026 offseason, starting with Hal Steinbrenner’s bizarre media appearance where he lamented the cost of owning the team. Moose takes particular aim at the Yankees' passive approach to the bullpen, highlighting their failure to land elite closer Edwin Diaz, who instead signed a record-setting $69 million deal with the Los Angeles Dodgers.
Moose argues that the Dodgers have officially replaced the Yankees as the "Evil Empire," operating with a "slice your head off" mentality while the Yankees settle for regular-season stability and "hope for the best" in October. From slamming the team's failed player development (citing names like Volpe, Greg Bird, and Andujar) to mocking Hal’s complaints about paying the City of New York every February, Moose demands to know: "How much does it really bother the Yankees that they haven't won since 2009?"
Looks like the Knicks might not play up to four of their star players for the Pacers game. The Cup must've wore 'em out.
Is Aaron Glenn’s time with the Jets already ticking away? Mike Florio of Pro Football Talk reports there is a real chance especially after the mid-season firing of defensive coordinator Steve Wilks—a move Florio views as a major red flag for the head coach's stability.
Chris talks about how the NBA Cup doesn't mean anything and that is the reason why the Knicks didn't hang the banner, not because the Knicks are better than that.
We’re breaking down that wild Josh Hart and Jalen Brunson celebration and why these locker room antics matter.
With the Steelers dominance on Monday Night Football, it appears things have stabilized for Mike Tomlin in Pittsburgh. That being the case CMac says the Giants need to continue to tank the rest of the way and use the first overall pick to overhaul this roster.
BT unleashes a fiery critique of the Yankees' slow-moving offseason, warning that the assumed return of Cody Bellinger is a false assumption and a major threat to the team's success. With a long list of young, unproven position players like Jazz Chisholm, Ben Rice, and a potential "strikeout machine" in Ryan McMahon, Tierney argues the lineup is riddled with holes.
The more pressing concern, according to BT, is a disaster start: with Cole, Rodón, and Schmidt all recovering, the rotation is dangerously thin. Tierney urges the Yankees to forget big-bat spending and execute a "radical reset" by loading up on pitching depth (like signing Michael King or trading for Peralta) to ensure they don't "drown in April or May" against a rapidly improving, aggressive AL East (Jays, O's, Red Sox). The ultimate message: the path to winning is no longer through hitting, but through a surplus of elite arms.
The Jets fired DC Steve Wilks—one of four coaches already canned by the 5-win Giants/Jets—as we look ahead to their top draft picks.
Hoff talks about the end of the BT & Sal Show and then somehow goes on a rant about the Yankees and Mets awful offseasons.
CMac breaks down yet another loss for the Giants and why losing is currency right now for Big Blue
BT reacts to the news that the Jets have fired defensive coordinator Steve Wilks following a string of "embarrassingly inept" performances, including a 48-20 blowout loss to the Jaguars where the defense looked like they "didn't even want to tackle." While not celebrating the firing, BT calls it the "right move" and criticizes Head Coach Aaron Glenn for his "awful" personnel decisions, specifically highlighting the hiring of Wilks and the catastrophic Justin Fields QB trade—both significant "Xs" on Glenn's resume.
Tierney also offers a small dose of optimism, analyzing three distinct, radically different quarterback paths for the Jets next year, and offers some hope that undrafted rookie Brady Cook has shown enough moxie for the team to consider developing him.
Recapping a wild NFL Sunday that saw a huge Bills comeback, Philip Rivers' return, a Bengals shutout, and two shocking ACL tears. Also, not a lot for Giants and Jets fans to be excited about.
Chris talks about how good Joe Burrow would make the Jets if he is willing to leave the Bengals but talks about Burrow's presser and how he might retire sooner rather than later.
Chris says that with the amount of talent leaving the Mets, they shouldn't trade for Tarik Skubal when he can become available as a free agent next offseason.
BT and Sal deliver a raw and intensely emotional final segment, reflecting on their journey together. The discussion centers on a shared, fiery motivation stemming from their fathers—the principle that "life is going to keep hitting you," and the only response is to keep fighting forward. Sal talks about playing a motivational clip for his late father, while BT recounts the life-changing moment his dad showed him support after his first firing.
They discuss their turbulent start, specifically the unplanned Carl Banks firestorm, and assert that they have "no regrets" because they "gave everything they had" to the show, proud it was not a "failed experiment." With grateful thanks to the listeners and the station for the opportunity to have a proper farewell, the "Dynamic Duo" promises their partnership is far from over, signing off with a heartfelt affirmation of their bond.
On their final show, BT & Sal dive into the hot rumor surrounding the Mets and Tigers ace Tarik Skubal, who is available with only one year of control left. Sal argues the Mets and Yankees must knock down the door for Skubal, but BT fires back, arguing the Mets should absolutely NOT include top pitching prospect Nolan McClain—calling a potential trade "idiotic" given Skubal's short-term control and impending $400M contract. They debate the Tigers' leverage and the risks of waiting to sign Skubal in free agency versus trading top farm pieces now. The hosts also discuss whether Mets owner Steve Cohen will react to the current "state of desperation" among the fanbase and overrule David Stearns' measured plan. The show wraps up with emotional fan calls and appreciation for the "juice" the New York Knicks brought to their time slot.
Joe Burrow hinted at either wanting to leave the Bengals or not play at all. Is that a sign he could end up with the Jets? We have our serious doubts.
BT and Sal discuss the volatile fallout of the Mets letting both Pete Alonso and Edwin Diaz walk, labeling it a "wreckage." Sal wants David Stearns to explain publicly why the Mets, with all their resources, wouldn't meet Alonso's market price, especially after a great offensive year. Tierney argues that keeping players who delivered "subpar results" makes no sense, stating that fans must choose between loving the players or demanding a winner.
The conversation pivots to skepticism, addressing the caller theory that Steve Cohen's focus is now purely on the casino deal at Metropolitan Park. They also debate the future of the Mets' offense: is trading for Kyle Tucker the necessary "sexy, splashy move," or will Stearns prioritize young talent and make the team less competitive in the short term? Tierney is insistent that letting Alonso go only makes Stearns' job of building a playoff contender "more difficult."
Pete Alonso is out, and Boomer is declaring "the great Met reset!" Gio still has faith in Steve Cohen's World Series promise, arguing the team is tearing down to truly build a winner.
BT & Sal react instantly to the explosive news that Pete Alonso is officially gone, signing a five-year, $155 million deal with the Orioles. Sal defends the move, arguing that the Mets needed a "wrecking ball" to change a core that "wasn't working," even though he acknowledges the raw emotional pain for Mets fans who loved the "Polar Bear." Tierney pushes back, declaring David Stearns the most hated man in New York sports right now, demanding he "start cooking fast" to replace the massive power loss. They discuss the potential pivot, noting the money saved from Nimmo, Diaz, and Alonso could target players like Cody Bellinger or Kyle Tucker, but warn that Stearns has zero latitude left and must deliver major moves to avoid becoming a failure. The hosts agree that the team needs at least two big bats and two significant pitchers to prevent the 2026 roster from looking "disgracefully bad."
BT and Sal react to the seismic breaking news that Pete Alonso has officially left the New York Mets, signing a five-year, $155 million contract with the Baltimore Orioles. Hof's fiery reaction sums up the fan base's outrage, calling the decision by President of Baseball Operations David Stearns "inexcusable."
The hosts debate whether this move is a necessary "ripping of the band-aid" for a flawed team or a colossal mistake, especially after the recent departure of Edwin Diaz and the trade of Brandon Nimmo. Tierney points to Stearns's focus on defense and high-OBP players like Marcus Semien as the new direction, arguing the Mets can be a better team even with fewer home runs. The key question now becomes: Did Alonso's anger over his treatment by the organization lead him to leave without giving the Mets a final chance to match the offer?
BT & Sal blast the Yankees for their glacial pace this offseason, with Tierney describing the Yankees Hot Stove show as a cure for insomnia. The hosts mock GM Brian Cashman's vague Winter Meetings update that deals have been "tough so far," contrasting his comments about the "aggressive" Dodgers to the Yankees' own timid approach.
The discussion quickly turns to the Yankees' glaring roster needs: a leadoff hitter and a reliable right-handed thumper to balance the lineup. They zero in on the problematic infield, with Sal calling for changes at two spots due to the mess of Volpe, Chisholm, and McMahon. Tierney floats the idea of trading Jazz Chisholm for Bo Bichette to upgrade the offense, while Sal flatly rejects the possibility of pursuing Pete Alonso, declaring, "He's just not my kind of ballplayer." The segment concludes with a spirited debate on the entitled nature of former Yankee Edwin Diaz being "upset" with the team for not consulting him before signing Devin Williams.
BT & Sal launch into a fiery debate over David Stearns' leadership, with mounting fan panic following the loss of Edwin Diaz and the looming free agency of Pete Alonso. Sal maintains that the Mets will be better, but argues that losing their top power bat without a clear replacement (Tucker? Bellinger?) makes improving on 83 wins exceedingly difficult.
Tierney fires back, cautioning that if Stearns deviates from his "hard line" of three years for Alonso—simply to avoid "public backlash"—it would prove he is "flimsy" and unable to run a healthy organization, drawing a parallel to the foolishness of breaking a budget when buying a home. The discussion is punctuated by a Mets fan caller, Joe, who reads an old "Sal Was Right" tweet about never trusting Edwin Diaz.
The Mets fanbase is melting down over Edwin Díaz signing with the Dodgers, a move Boomer paradoxically believes guarantees they'll sign Pete Alonso, while the industry fears the Dodgers' spending power is so dominant it will force an MLB lockout in 2027. Díaz ultimately "didn't want to be here," giving the Mets a small shield from the chaos.
The Mets needed to do whatever it takes to bring back Edwin Diaz, and they let him "test the Dodgers market"?? They should have never et it get to that!
A passionate and dare we say unhinges Evan Roberts responds to Edwin Diaz leaving for the Dodgers?
BT & Sal bring in the legendary Bruce Prichard (aka Brother Love) to discuss the WWE landscape, including the highly anticipated final match of John Cena this Saturday. Prichard shares a touching, sad moment from Cena's last bout and definitively ranks him as a Top 5 wrestler, calling him "the prototype" for success.
The conversation gets fiery as they discuss the evolution of the business: what makes a wrestler "lose it" physically, the lack of script writers in the golden age, and the constant challenge of producing creative content in the age of remakes. Prichard also names Brock Lesnar (and others) as a legitimate tough guy in the current locker room, opens up about the reality TV series 'Unreal,' and recounts a surprise punch from Roddy Piper that he "never saw coming." The segment wraps with Sal demanding Brother Love determine who the true "heel" is between him and BT.
BT & Sal react to the breaking news that closer Edwin Diaz has signed a three-year, $69 million deal with the Los Angeles Dodgers, a figure far below the initial $100 million rumors. The hosts are stunned that the Mets, who just signed Devin Williams for three years, $51 million, couldn't bridge the mere $18 million gap to keep the elite closer. Sal argues it's an absurd holdup, especially considering Cohen's spending power and the team's costly mistakes elsewhere.
Tierney wonders if Diaz simply took less money for the chance to win a championship with the Dodgers, a move Diaz's agent reportedly didn't even allow the Mets to match. A fiery Mets fan calls in, accusing Stearns of destroying the team's "culture" and leading a "wrecking ball" demolition that could push out even Pete Alonso. The segment ends with the question of whether the Mets' focus on Devin Williams (who had a rocky year and personality issues) over the consistent Diaz will haunt them.
BT & Sal dive into shocking breaking news on the MLB hot stove, reacting in real-time to two major deals: Edwin Diaz signing with the Dodgers and Kyle Schwarber returning to the Phillies for 5 years, $150 million.
Sal argues that the Mets made the right long-term move by refusing to invest over $100 million in a closer, calling the move an "unreliable" luxury the team can't afford given their other holes. BT agrees, but they both acknowledge the sting for Mets fans. The Schwarber deal immediately pivots the conversation to Pete Alonso's impending contract, with the hosts questioning if $150 million sets a new floor for the Polar Bear—and where the Mets will now find replacement power if Pete walks.
BT & Sal ignite the hot stove discussion, questioning the Mets' fixation on former Yankees, specifically reporting Michael King as their "top rotation target." Sal fears GM David Stearns is setting a dangerous precedent by avoiding long-term deals for top pitchers like Tatsuya Imai. They tackle the Pete Alonso saga, wondering if his personal attendance at the Winter Meetings is a sign of a weak market, and if the Red Sox's pursuit of Alex Bregman (for defense) further complicates Pete's quest for a long-term deal. The conversation heats up around Kyle Schwarber, with BT arguing for him as a priority DH target to add consistent power, and they debate if the Mets' focus on Peralta and McGill trades signals an acceptance of losing Edwin Diaz.
The MLB offseason is a snoozer compared to last year's Mets splash, and Yankee fans are getting antsy. Is Cody Bellinger the only hope? We'll dive into the Tatis Jr. rumors, plus, why Boomer wants the other Fernando (Mendoza) on the Jets!
BT & Sal go off on the Veterans Committee's shocking decision to once again deny Don Mattingly election to the Hall of Fame, especially after he received an embarrassing six total votes.
Tierney, Mattingly's all-time favorite player, is perplexed and enraged, questioning how his former peers on the panel (like Ozzie Smith and Robin Yount) could overlook a player who was undeniably the best in baseball for several seasons, was a "steward of the game," and has an "incredible level of character."
The debate quickly shifts to the hypocrisy of the selection process, contrasting Mattingly's brief but brilliant career and clean record with the enshrinement of players like Jeff Kent, who lacked the same accolades, raising the central question: Why are players with "legitimate holes" in their resumes getting in while Mattingly gets disrespect? The hosts lament that Mattingly's prime is now so distant, it's becoming a reference point "40 years" in the past.
BT & Sal go off on Giants linebacker and third overall pick Abdul Carter, discussing off-the-field issues that sources say stem from excessive drug use, which has reportedly led to him falling asleep in meetings and showing a clear lack of professional commitment.
Tierney and Licata debate the new prevalence of THC use in the NFL and argue that while the drug itself is less harmful than alcohol, Carter's problem is the "trifecta of failure": poor production (just 1.5 sacks in his rookie season), repeated disciplinary issues (benched twice for missing team obligations), and a failure to prioritize his career. They question why the Giants organization, from the previous regime to interim head coach Mike Kafka, allowed these character flaws to fester and whether this now looks like a "disastrous pick." The segment ends with a sharp comparison: Lawrence Taylor had his issues, but he was the greatest defensive player ever—Carter has zero production to lean on.
BT and Sal dive headfirst into the heated topic of going bald. BT launches a blistering attack on men who are completely bald on top but insist on keeping the hair grown out on the sides, calling it one of the "worst looks any man can have."
Sal, who fully shaves his head, admits he is currently a "neurotic" fanatic testing three different electric shavers in his quest to find a tool that can get as close as a wet shave—a method BT champions. BT details his strict routine of being a "shower shaver" at least three to four times a week to keep his "dome" perfectly tight. The conversation concludes with a hilarious, yet brief, detour into the viral photo of "Hoff's Package," which Tierney claims he barely even noticed.
BT and Sal are furious that the main takeaway from the Yankees' Winter Meetings is Brian Cashman's old Sonny Gray drama, where Cashman claimed Gray lied about wanting to play in New York. The hosts argue this is a self-made distraction to divert attention from the real issues: the team's inaction on critical offseason needs.
They demand to know if the Yankees are pursuing Kyle Tucker or Cody Bellinger and are frustrated by the vague plan for left field and the ongoing leadoff hitter void. The hosts warn that simply relying on a strong rotation (which will be vulnerable early due to injuries) and the return of Judge is not enough to win a World Series, criticizing the focus on a former player instead of fixing the lineup.
BT & Sal dissect the Jets' "brutal" and "unwatchable" loss, condemning Brady Cook's erratic quarterback play and the receiver corps' lackluster performance. The upside? The guys pivot to the Jets' improving draft capital, discussing how Daniel Jones's Achilles injury has dramatically boosted the value of the Colts' first-round pick (now projected around #18). Sal argues the Jets must prioritize losing to secure a high-value pick to land their coveted franchise QB, Mendoza (an obvious college football comparison). They debate the scenarios of trading up and the conviction needed to go "all-in" for the right quarterback, even if it means risking massive draft capital.
BT and Sal dive headfirst into the Mets' offseason dilemma, sparked by a report that David Stearns is "reluctant" to give long-term deals to free-agent starting pitchers like Framber Valdez.
Sal argues this philosophy is smart money, insisting the Mets should avoid overpaying for a non-ace like Valdez and instead aggressively target trade-and-extend options like Tarik Skubal. BT agrees Valdez isn't a true ace, but asks if the Mets can afford to be choosy after last year's rotation collapse. The debate heats up on the question of value: is a three-year deal for Michael King smarter than seven years for Valdez?
The discussion expands to the future of the core, with Sal advocating for the emotional release of Pete Alonso and Edwin Diaz if they demand reckless contracts, believing the Mets haven't won with them anyway. The hosts analyze Stearns' strategy and ask whether his dedication to player development will clash with the need to win now.
It's the one-year anniversary of the Juan Soto signing, but the current baseball offseason has been anything but exciting! We dive into the quiet winter and take a call from listener Paul, who returns to voice his strong opinion: He does not like Steve Cohen!
You have to see the photo Pete Hoffman posted of him and his wife in matching Christmas shirts—but the real story is what his sweatpants revealed!
Boomer is head over heels for Indiana QB Fernando Mendoza, and Gio thinks this energetic, outspoken signal-caller has the personality to make it in New York.
The Jets were destroyed quickly in a 21-0 first-quarter rout, while the resting Giants lucked into the #1 draft pick after a Titans win. Does Daniel Jones' latest injury confirm Joe Schoen's long-held fears. The Bears plummeted from the #1 seed to #7, a meaningless late-game Raiders field goal, and a controversial rule robbed the Ravens of a crucial touchdown.
Chris talks Yankees Hot Stove and feels like outside of trying to re-sign Cody Bellinger, he is not confident in the Yankees front office and ownership to build a championship winning roster.
Chris talks about how the Jets played terrible defense against the Dolphins and that their draft pick won't be as high as they would hope it would be to draft a QB.
BT & Sal kick off the show addressing the elephant in the room—the breaking news about Craig Carton's inevitable return to the station—and commit to delivering the same "damn good show" regardless of the downstream effects.
They then dive into a fiery post-mortem of Joe Shane's press conference, dismissing it as irrelevant compared to the bigger picture. Sal is definitive: the Giants' underperformance proves Shane must go, and he should not be allowed to pick the next head coach. Tierney argues that the Giants' job is actually highly appealing due to the lack of an Eli Manning transition roadblock, and the presence of a promising young QB in Jaxson Dart. Sal counters that the uncertainty and instability at the top of the organization make it an "unstable mess," and that the team's regression under Shane's roster influence is undeniable proof that a total clean sweep is necessary. The hosts and callers agree that there is "no support for Joe Shane" left among the fans.
The Mets appear to have chemistry issues again, is Francisco Lindor the problem? There seems to be evidence indicating he is.
The Jets win has the fanbase split -- root for wins, or the better draft choice? BT says he wanted the Tank, but with the number of times the team has messed up the QB in the draft, he says just win games and build the culture.
Jaxson Dart gets the start tonight in New England, prompting the question: will the defense look any different now that Shane Bowen is gone? We then look at the teams we wrote off too soon and dive into the baffling AFC North race—can the 6-6 Ravens really take the division crown?
The Jets finally got a win, sparking debate on whether a culture of winning is taking hold, but the real fireworks started with shocking speculation: could "Fire Tomlin" chants in Pittsburgh open the door for Mike Tomlin to coach the Giants?
Chris opens the show talking about the Jets and says that a Week 13 win when you are out of playoff contention hurts the Jets for the NFL Draft next year.
Giants may be 2-10, but in our hearts they're undefeated!!! This is the best Giants season we've watched in over a decade. So do you really want more changes next year to the staff? Plus, Aaron Glenn still has a lot to prove in year one and more fall out from David Stearns trading Brandon Nimmo.
Follow Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN
Carl Banks is livid and calling out the coaches for being unprepared. Plus, the sounds of the Niners winning despite Purdy's meltdown, and Stearns explains the Brandon Nimmo trade. Rangers snap skid and win at MSG.
BT & Sal dissect Mets President David Stearns' decisive, high-stakes trade of fan-favorite Brandon Nimmo for veteran infielder Marcus Semien, praising Stearns for making a "necessary, difficult" move to fundamentally change the clubhouse and improve the team's defensive core. Stearns confirms the trade was driven by the realization that "running back the exact same group wasn't the right thing to do" and to create space for "very young outfielders" (like Jett Williams and Carson Benge) to play.
The hosts debate the emotional aspect of trading a beloved player, then clash over the wisdom of the outfield youth movement: Sal is okay with leaving a spot open for a prospect, but BT argues the Mets cannot rely on unproven young players for a winning club and must acquire two top-tier outfielders to secure the spot Nimmo vacated. They conclude by looking ahead to hear from Yankees owner Hal Steinbrenner.
BT & Sal dissect Hal Steinbrenner's year-end press conference, focusing on his comments regarding the Yankees' massive payroll and his reluctance to promise another $300M+ spending spree to keep pace with the Dodgers. The hosts vent their frustration over Hal's lack of "irrational behavior" and his deflections on the team's failures, including blaming players for the summer swoons and playoffs.
The discussion centers on Hal's claim that it's "not fair to assume" the Yankees make a profit, which the hosts quickly call out as a convenient gloss-over of their $8 billion valuation. Finally, they debate the necessary "radical" roster changes needed, like trading Giancarlo Stanton, to rebuild a winning club, arguing that simply running it back with a healthy rotation and Cody Bellinger isn't enough to secure a World Series.
BT & Sal dissect the shocking, confirmed trade of Brandon Nimmo to the Texas Rangers for Marcus Semien. Sal hails the trade as an "awesome move," proving the Mets are finally ready to build the right way and focus on run prevention, given Nimmo's declining defense, poor arm, and lower-extremity injuries. BT argues that the move was necessary to upgrade the defense and frees up the DH spot, making it mandatory for the Mets to now re-sign Pete Alonso to replace the lost offensive power.
They debate the trade's immediate impact (Nimmo for Semien is a defensive upgrade at second base, setting up Jeff McNeil to be traded) and what the next move must be: acquiring a top outfielder (Bellinger or Tucker) to fill Nimmo's spot. The hosts praise David Stearns' "gutsy, bold" decision to move past the core's sentimental value.
BT and Sal dive into the firing of Giants Defensive Coordinator Shane Bowen, with Tierney arguing the move was "long overdue" and just "throwing a bone to the fans." Sal agrees Bowen "needed to be fired" but questions why it took so long, calling his tenure an "awful chapter" defined by the "inability to hold leads."
The hosts debate the impact, with Sal suggesting it's primarily a move to "placate distraught, miserable, angry fans," as Bowen was never coming back next year anyway. Tierney counters that it may be Mike Kafka attempting to "clean things up" to bolster his own head coaching potential. The core of the conversation shifts to the evaluation of Joe Shane, questioning if the talent is better than the embarrassing 2-and-10 record suggests, and whether the GM deserves to stay beyond this season.
David Stearns is doing his best to turn the New York Mets into a David Stearns team. Sunday night he traded away fan favorite Brandon Nimmo to the Texas Rangers for second baseman Marcus Semien. Hoff explains why this is a good move!
Follow @HoffWFAN
The Giants just fired their Defensive Coordinator! With Mike Kafka auditioning to be the next head coach and doing everything the fans want, who will he pick as the interim DC? The New York shake-up is officially underway!
We discussed the Mets trading Brandon Nimmo and what other moves might be on the horizon. A caller checks in to thank us for putting on AJ & Big Justice last Friday as his kids are big fans.
The 2-10 Giants are the most fun trainwreck in the NFL, thanks to Jameis Winston! Should they have kicked the field goal? Boomer vs. Gio duke it out over the crucial play!
The Mets are worse after trading Brandon Nimmo but could be set up to improve the team with their following moves.
BT & Sal ignite a fiery debate over the hypothetical trade for Texas Rangers shortstop Corey Seager. Sal, prioritizing a World Series push, argues that even 100 games from a two-time World Series MVP is worth the risk, advocating for a potential move to third base to manage his recurring hamstring issues. However, Tierney is vehemently "not interested," likening the trade to acquiring a physically unreliable Giancarlo Stanton and expressing concern over Seager's significant contract and extensive injury history. They discuss whether sending prospects like Wells, Rice, and Volpe is too steep, and debate if the Yankees' biggest issue is relying on their underperforming young players or Brian Cashman's "risk-averse" philosophy.
BT and Sal dive into Jaxson Dart's return to play following his concussion, focusing on how new play-caller Mike Kafka will manage the young quarterback differently than Brian Daboll. The hosts argue that the remainder of the season is solely about Dart's development and availability, not wins or losses, and that Kafka must prove he can protect the franchise QB by limiting designed runs. They vehemently criticize the "insane" mindset of fans who want to "bubble wrap" Dart for the rest of the season, asserting he needs to play to evolve. The discussion expands to the Giants' overall two-and-nine record, debating whether the team is "devoid of talent" or just poorly coached, with the hosts agreeing that the current record is worse than the roster's actual potential.
Rumors are swirling of Corey Seager being put on the trade market. Can the Yankees swoop in to get one of the bets hitting shortstops in the league? If so, they will put themselves back into the "Evil Empire" tier!
Follow @HoffWFAN
The Costco Guys, AJ & Big Justice, are in the studio, and they bring the Boom. They talked about their rise to fame on social media and joining up with AEW Wrestling.
Jerry brings us the crushing sound of Josh Allen getting picked off to end the Bills' game. Meanwhile, Cam Skattebo predicts a 12-win, playoff year for the Giants! Plus, the Mets' Adam Ottavino trashes Carlos Mendoza’s bullpen handling on his own podcast. The Rangers also lost to the Avalanche.
The Bills are the NFL's biggest disappointment. After losing to the Texans, they're stuck with a Wild Card spot and a roster that's not championship-caliber. Gio says it's another wasted year, but Boomer argues Allen can win in any stadium. Who's right?
Evan has gotten the memo from Mets fans, the drum has to be banged more for Pete Alonso to return
BT & Sal kick off the segment with a mix of disgust and fascination over football player Cam Skattebo's latest viral stunt: chugging an energy drink from his cleat (a "Shoey"). Then, they dive into a fiery hypothetical: an Athletic-proposed trade for Tigers ace Tarik Skubal involving a Yankees package of Spencer Jones, Will Warren, and two pitching prospects. The hosts debate whether this offer is deliberately undervaluing Skubal compared to the Mets' reported trade pieces, reigniting the argument over the true quality of the Yankees' farm system.
The conversation shifts to the upcoming Japanese posting window, with Sal confidently predicting the Mets and Yankees will each land a star, while Tierney is skeptical, fearing the Dodgers will collect everyone. They discuss the worrying scouting report on star hitter Munetaka Murakami and his inability to hit fastballs over 93 MPH. The segment wraps up by venting about high NBA ticket prices and the outrage fans feel when high-priced stars like Giannis sit out.
BT & Sal ignite a heated argument with Hoff over a hypothetical Mets trade proposal by Jim Bowden, which sends four top prospects (Tong, Sproat, Williams, Mauricio) to Detroit for one year of Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal. BT is "in a heartbeat" for the trade, arguing they must be aggressive to land a frontline ace. Hoff slams it as "irresponsible", insisting they absolutely cannot trade that "butt load of prospects" without a guaranteed contract extension, comparing the high cost to the Yankees' "bunch of nothing" price for Juan Soto. The debate centers on risk: the Mets' willingness to gamble on an extension versus the risk of being "stupid" and losing their best young talent for a one-year rental.
BT & Sal dive into a hypothetical (but fiery!) discussion about Pete Alonso wearing a Yankees uniform. While acknowledging reports that the Yankees have no interest in the Polar Bear, Sal argues that a move for Alonso would be a smart piece of a necessary "restructuring" for the Yankees—specifically, by trading Giancarlo Stanton and replacing his power and DH slot with an everyday first baseman and DH option in Pete.
The conversation gets personal as they debate the emotional fallout for Mets fans if their franchise slugger jumped to the hated Yankees. Sal asserts that his hatred for the Yankees would "usurp" any affection for Pete, but Hoff and Sal debate where Mets fans would draw the line. The segment also touches on the frustrating lack of development and hype surrounding Yankees prospects like Jasson Dominguez and Mets prospect Carson Benge.
BT & Sal dive into a fiery debate over the Yankees and Mets' intertwined offseason, focusing on a direct clash for Cody Bellinger and the closer market (Edwin Diaz vs. Devin Williams). Sal argues the Mets must pursue Bellinger and go "pedal to the metal," while BT has more faith in Brian Cashman's urgency than David Stearns' willingness to spend like a big-market GM.
The Mets' need for a "shake up" dominates the conversation, with discussion of trading Senga (despite the desperate need for pitching) and moving core players like McNeil, Nimmo, Baty, and Vientos—the guys Sal is "tired of waiting on." The segment concludes with BT teasing his "Grand Slam Mets Offseason" plan, a four-component blueprint he believes would make the Mets World Series contenders.
Everyone is upset at the Yankees, Brian Cashman and Trent Grisham for signing the qualifying offer to return for the 2026 season. Hoff explains why this is not a Trent Grisham issue!
Follow @HoffWFAN
The show begins with Boomer having back spasms so he’s in rough shape this morning, plus kids sports on Long Island can be a rough game of rivalries.
Giants legend and Super Bowl MVP Phil Simms joins BT & Sal for a fiery, in-depth NFL discussion. Simms slams the Giants' "biggest disappointment"—the defensive failure—and calls out the coaching for not being "aggressive" enough. He weighs in on the extensive head coach search, arguing that analytics have made NFL game management "stupid," and reveals what former coach Bill Parcells taught him about chasing points.
Simms also tackles the Giants' "leaderless" atmosphere, the controversy surrounding Jaxson Dart's running and Cam Scott's wrestling appearance, and the "sad" state of the Giants' home-field advantage. Finally, he breaks down the top college quarterback prospects the Jets might target, including Fernando Mendoza and Ty Simpson, offering a strong take on why Mac Jones was the 49ers' true target over Trey Lance.
BT and Sal unleash a fiery discussion about Trent Grisham's decision to accept the qualifying offer ($22 million), with BT calling it a "colossal mistake" by the Yankees' front office, who seemingly misread his willingness to take the one-year deal. BT views the move as the "first potential domino to a horrendous offseason," arguing the allure of a compensatory pick blindsided them. Sal, however, believes Grisham is still a valuable commodity who can be used as a high-end fourth outfielder or trade bait (after the June 15 deadline), and that the $22 million shouldn't stop the Yankees from landing Cody Bellinger or trading for Steven Kwan.
The hosts debate the impact on the roster, specifically how Grisham's presence complicates the paths for young prospects Jason Dominguez and Spencer Jones and exacerbates the Yankees' already dangerous left-handed hitting compromise. BT's main fear remains that this move encourages the Yankees to "run it back" with a team that failed to win, banking too heavily on a different outcome.
Aaron Glenn meets the media, but will he finally admit Tyrod Taylor is the starter? I mean, we all know it is.
Trent Grisham accepts the Yankees' qualifying offer—a move Cashman never saw coming. Also some Yankees makeover talk, a potential MLB lockout, and the latest on Pete Alonso...and the Red Sox!
Gio slams the 2-9 Giants organization, calling for a 'full douching' as the team repeats the exact mistakes that previously fueled firing rumors around Brian Daboll.
The Knicks are dealing with injuries of their own, but going into a shorthanded Dallas team they have to find a way to get their first road win.
BT & Sal sit down with wrestling royalty Natalya Neidhart to discuss her powerful new book, The Last Heart Beating. Nattie drops truth bombs on her complicated life, revealing the volatility of growing up with her father, Jim "The Anvil" Neidhart, who suffered from an undiagnosed traumatic brain injury (CTE), and the experience of her family being homeless despite his stardom.
Nattie explains the "scratch and claw" fight to enter the WWE without family help, including the demand to lose 30 pounds just to get hired, and how she used her rough upbringing to fuel her drive. The conversation covers her journey to unconditional forgiveness for her father, the therapeutic experience of writing the book, and the incredible support she's received from legends like John Cena (who "bawled his eyes out" reading it) and Bret Hart. Finally, she hints at a fiery new character she's developing and throws down a challenge to current champion Rhea Ripley!
NFL Insider Brian Baldinger joins BT & Sal for a fiery Week 12 breakdown, immediately ripping Giants rookie Cam Skattebo for his bizarre WWE appearance while nursing a fractured ankle, calling the optics "bizarre" and "unprofessional." The conversation shifts to the Giants' deeper issues, with Baldy agreeing that the team has "no internal veteran leadership" to guide young players like Abdul Carter, whose repeated tardiness to meetings was "unacceptable" and made Coach Daboll look worse.
Baldy breaks down the tape, exonerating Jameis Winston on the game-ending interception and slams Jalen Hyatt's execution. He offers a shocking take on the Giants' much-maligned offensive line, calling them "middle of the pack" and "playoff worthy." On the AFC, Baldy weighs in on the contenders, calling the Baltimore Ravens a "problem" and the Buffalo Bills "a mess" defensively. Finally, he supports the Jets' move to Tyrod Taylor to gather crucial information on their young, unproven receivers like Adonai Mitchell and Mason Taylor.
BT & Sal torch Giants players Cam Skattebo (injured) and Abdul Carter (amid team controversy) for their physical involvement in a scripted altercation at WWE's Monday Night Raw. The hosts argue the optics are terrible for a 2-9 team, with fans already feeling an "embarrassment."
They slam Skattebo for taking an unnecessary risk by getting pushed, given his severe ankle injury, with Sal calling it "dangerous" and questioning the running back's judgment. Carter, fresh off controversy for sleeping through a team walkthrough, is also criticized for his lack of awareness and showing up for the spectacle. The segment highlights the incident as another sign of the Giants' "sloppiness" and their deteriorating team culture.
Benched by the Giants for missing meetings, Abdul Carter claims he was "recovering, not sleeping," after reports surfaced alleging he chose rest over preparation. The team confirms the missed meetings; Carter denies the reason.
BT & Sal erupt over another predictable Giants loss, arguing that the team's continued struggles after firing Brian Daboll definitively proves the problem lies with the "undermanned, under-talented" roster built by General Manager Joe Schoen.
Tierney argues that more losses are a good thing as they should force Mr. Mara's hand to end Schoen's "colossal fail" of a tenure and allow for a clean-slate fresh start. Sal doubles down, asserting that a "lame duck GM" cannot be trusted to hire the next head coach, which would only lead to a perpetual "cycle of sloppiness" in the front office. They discuss the defensive coordinator's job security and call for a total organizational teardown to prevent a fifth consecutive losing season.
We're calling for Jaxson Dart to play, arguing experience is all that matters for a future franchise QB. We discuss Sam Darnold's four-interception nightmare. Meanwhile, a caller suggests Brian Daboll might be secretly happy about the Giants' loss—was it a sneaky relief?
Chris doesn't believe this is good news for Pete Alonso after Josh Naylor signs a 5 year deal and returns to Seattle.
BT & Sal dive into the aftermath of the Jets' loss to the Patriots, arguing it was a "good loss" that reveals a well-coached football team under Aaron Glenn. Sal defends the mindset of being "proud" of the effort, emphasizing that this is what a "real rebuild" looks like—a complete, albeit painful, resetting of the foundation and expectations.
They praise Glenn's unconventional opening decision to receive the ball and execute a perfect, scripted touchdown drive, contrasting it with the "avoid getting embarrassed" style of past regimes. However, the hosts intensely critique Justin Fields' "woeful" passing and lack of big-play support, debating whether Glenn's loyalty to the quarterback is justifiable and if it's time to play Tyrod Taylor for a true evaluation of the young receivers.
The discussion concludes with the consensus that the talent disparity is massive, but the team is building the right culture for the long-term, following a model similar to the first year of a successful coach like Tom Thibodeau.
Boomer and Gio debate the Giants’ next move on the sideline as the search begins in earnest. Do they lean on experience and stability with a proven veteran, or roll the dice again on an up-and-coming coordinator? The guys break down what ownership wants, how the locker room factors in, and why the right personality matters as much as the résumé.
The Jets lost again last night, and Boomer & Gio break down why they simply cannot keep putting Justin Fields on the field. After a sharp opening touchdown drive, Fields unraveled and so did the offense and the guys explain how that kills any hope of winning games or building a real culture.
Boomer details what he’s seeing on tape, Gio vents about the mixed messages coming from inside the building, and the guys try to answer the big question: What exactly are the Jets trying to accomplish the rest of this season?
Keith is joined by Bobby Skinner of the Giants Nation Podcast to get his thoughts on the state of the Giants, the Daboll firing, and more.
Keith is joined by CP The Fanchise from Knicks Fan TV to get the latest on Jalen Brunson's injury and more.
BT and Sal dive into an explosive report from Joel Sherman suggesting the Mets are "spit-balling" scenarios to trade veteran outfielder Brandon Nimmo. With five years and over $100 million left on his contract, the Mets' motivation is to upgrade a poor defense and gain roster flexibility, even if it means eating some salary. Sal supports moving on from a contract that David Stearns wouldn't have signed, while BT sees it as an "out-of-the-box" move that could define a transformative offseason. The conversation also touches on other potential trade targets, like Ketel Marte, as the guys conclude that no one is untouchable this winter for the new front office.
BT and Sal get a hilariously fiery interview with comedy legend Marlon Wayans, who unleashes a scorching take on "cancel culture." Wayans argues it's a fear-based illusion fueled by foreign bots and "scared executives," not what real audiences want, and declares his intent to bring back the "equal opportunity offender" laughter of In Living Color with the upcoming 'Scary Movie 6.'
Marlon also opens up about the friendly jealousy among the famous Wayans brothers (and why he was their mother's favorite), reveals his "F these people" pre-show ritual for comedic fearlessness, and debates whether an Archie Bunker-style show could ever survive in today's hypersensitive world.
BT & Sal kick off the segment by immediately addressing the viral news surrounding Sydney Sweeney—specifically the disappointing box office flop of her latest movie, with Sal jokingly suggesting their recent interview "helped" the movie sink. They dive into the ensuing drama, including the Ruby Rose feud over the casting and a bizarre segue into the Eddie Murphy GOAT debate.
The conversation pivots sharply back to sports with a fiery Yankees trade suggestion: dumping Carlos Rodón and his hefty contract to free up money for a major free agent acquisition like Shohei Ohtani or Kwang Hyun Kim (a bit of classic Sal hyperbole). The hosts criticize the Yankees' recent lack of "creative" trades, arguing they need to be more aggressive this offseason. The segment concludes with Tierney reluctantly admitting his unique, and incorrect, definition of "swordsman" after a caller brought up an old rumor about a certain sports radio host.
BT & Sal unleash a fiery debate on the Yankees' offseason, arguing the entire success of their winter hinges on re-signing free agent Cody Bellinger. Sal insists the team has "no excuse" to lose Bellinger after already whiffing on Juan Soto last year, demanding the Yankees get aggressive now and exceed the market if necessary. Tierney agrees, noting that losing Bellinger would make their already unclear roster situation "very worrisome."
The hosts also pivot to a bigger picture, asking: "Is Bellinger enough?" They propose bold moves like trading for a true leadoff hitter like Steven Kwan and questioning the Yankees' self-imposed limitation at third base with Ryan McMahon when a proven winner like Alex Bregman is available. They conclude that without Bellinger and further aggressive action, the Yankees risk simply starting the next season with the same flawed team.
Boomer & Gio react to the Knicks dropping their first home game of the season to the Magic, raising early concerns about consistency at MSG. Jerry Recco shares Scott Boras’ latest round of Alonso-themed alliteration as he ramps up the Pete Alonso free-agency campaign. The guys also touch on Michael Penix Jr.’s surprising admission that he doesn’t have many teammates to lean on during tough days, and they close the hour by looking ahead to Packers/Giants with Drew Brees on the call.
Boomer & Gio open the show with a heartfelt tribute to legendary hockey writer Larry Brooks, reflecting on his impact, legacy, and the mark he left on New York sports. Then the guys pivot to a fiery conversation about Aaron Glenn’s bizarre and hostile treatment of the media this week. Why is he acting like this? What’s behind the sudden attitude?
Keith opens up his Wednesday show by thanking the Schmooze, Steve Somers for all he has done for him as he follows his 2 1/2 hour schmooze. Keith then gets into the sports, including Mike Kafka talking to the media and a busy day for Scott Boras at the MLB GM Meetings.
The schmoozer returns to the WFAN airwaves to give an update on his book, "Me Here, You There" as well as give you his thoughts on the happenings with the Giants, Jets and more!
Legendary comedian Jay Leno joins BT & Sal for a fiery, in-depth conversation on his career and the changing landscape of late-night television. Leno critiques the current state of late night—too many commercials, too much political fighting—and reveals the never-before-heard truth about the Conan O'Brien/NBC debacle, stating the network's incompetence and infighting drove the wedge.
Leno shares priceless stories from his career, including his years-long prank war with David Letterman involving a meatball sandwich, and the unforgettable difference between President Obama arriving to the show in a rental car versus a satellite-proof tent. Finally, he discusses the need for humility and why working on his massive car collection helps him avoid the "Beverly Hills Bubble."
BT & Sal step into the studio with UFC Middleweight star Bo Nickal ahead of his main prelim event at UFC 322 at Madison Square Garden. Nickal, an elite wrestling champion, talks about navigating the nerve-wracking emotions of fight night and how he's using his first-ever career loss as "massive motivation" for his upcoming bout.
The conversation ignites when they discuss the low-key feeling of being a fighter who could "disable" anyone on the street, the debate over UFC vs. Boxing (Bo calls MMA a "complete sport"), and his thoughts on the constant temptation to fix a fight in the sport. Plus, Nickal opens up about his relationships with Kyler Murray and the late Hulk Hogan, and a surprising reveal about a potential UFC event at the White House after speaking with President Trump. Sal is so sold, he declares he's "hammering" a bet on Nickal's comeback!
BT & Sal dissect David Stearns' recent comments on the Mets' offseason, debating whether the GM has the appetite—or the checkbook—to execute the massive overhaul the team needs.
Sal outlines a fiery, aggressive ultimatum for Pete Alonso's agent, Scott Boras, proposing a "$180 million, take-it-or-leave-it" deal to prevent the slugger from holding up the entire offseason. The hosts agree that simply bringing back Alonso and Diaz and adding a single pitcher is "not enough," arguing that the team's core DNA must change. Tierney demands a minimum of two high-end starters plus a major position player acquisition (like Bellinger or Bregman) to make the offseason a success. They also clash over Alonso's value, with Sal focusing on his lack of production when the power isn't there, and Tierney arguing his home run numbers are irreplaceable in a lineup already lacking offensive threats.
Boomer and Gio react to reports that Jameis Winston will start Sunday against the Packers, and debate what kind of spark or chaos he could bring to the offense. Then they check out the Patriots’ new “nor’easter” uniforms debuting on Thursday night, with Gio wondering if New England is trying a little too hard to stay relevant. The hour wraps with a passionate caller making his case for Antonio Pierce as the next Giants head coach and Boomer and Gio weigh whether the fiery former linebacker could be the right fit for Big Blue’s rebuild.
Boomer and Gio dive into Aaron Glenn’s latest clash with reporters, calling out the Jets defensive coordinator for being combative and defensive despite his team’s struggles. Gio says you can’t bark at the media when you’re not winning, and warns that reporters will start rooting against you. The guys talk about how Glenn’s behavior has crossed the line from confident to confrontational, and how the tension between coaches and beat writers is boiling over in New York.
Boomer and Gio react to Ian O’Connor’s report that Joe Schoen’s job as Giants GM isn’t safe beyond this season, raising questions about ownership’s trust and the team’s direction after firing Brian Daboll. The guys debate how Schoen could go from “rebuilding hero” to “on the hot seat” so quickly. Then they pivot to the NBA, where the Mavericks fired GM Nico Harrison after his handling of Luka Doncic backfired. Boomer and Gio wonder if this could be a cautionary tale for the Giants — when star players and front offices clash, someone always pays the price.
Keith opens up his Tuesday evening show by talking about the Knicks impressive victory over the Grizzlies on Tuesday evening at Madison Square Garden.
Can Aaron Glenn last longer than the media? Their seems to be a bigger battle off the field than on the field.
What type of coach is going to want to take the Giants HC job with Joe Schoen behind the reigns?
BT & Sal are joined by NFL Insider Brian Baldinger, who immediately sets the Giants debate on fire by placing the blame for Jaxson Dart's injuries squarely on recently fired head coach Brian Daboll. Baldinger argues that Daboll's play-calling, specifically the reckless use of read-option plays and poor blocking assignments, physically endangered Dart—a pattern he believes also "ruined" Daniel Jones.
The conversation pivots to the Giants' future, with Baldinger critiquing the organization's current structure compared to winning franchises like the Rams and Eagles. He offers a list of fiery coaching candidates, including Lane Kiffin (who he believes would maximize Dart's potential) and Bill Belichick (but NOT as GM), while questioning the merit of another failed coach.
BT, Sal, and Hoff unleash "Bald-Faced Lie, Bald-Faced Truth," testing the hottest takes in New York sports and beyond! The trio goes head-to-head on the Mets' looming free agency: Will Edwin Diaz be back in 2026, or will the Dodgers steal him? They clash over baseball insider Jeff Passan's predictions, debating if Kyle Tucker and Cody Bellinger could be teammates and if the Yankees can afford to lose Bellinger. Finally, a fiery NFL/NHL crossover question: will the Rangers' home win total in November surpass the combined home wins of the Jets and Giants? The segment closes with a serious discussion about the influence of John Mara's health and family loyalty on the Giants' front office decisions.
BT & Sal are infuriated by the Giants' "ass-backwards" decision to fire head coach Brian Daboll while retaining GM Joe Schoen and allowing him to lead the search for a new coach. Sal argues that the Giants' failure to clean house is a continuation of decades of "ineptitude." Tierney is "genuinely stunned," questioning why any "battle-tested adult" coach with a winning resume would hitch their wagon to a GM "hanging by a thread" and pointing out that Schoen's roster depth is "pathetic." The hosts dissect the stunning quote in the press release that they feel Schoen "assembled a good young nucleus," given his track record of major busts like Evan Neal. They conclude that by splitting the ticket, the Giants chose the absolute "worst option," dooming the franchise to more losing.
Boomer & Gio wonder how Daniel Jones really feels about Brian Daboll’s firing. Gio thinks Jones might be quietly celebrating after a rocky relationship with his now-former head coach. Boomer weighs in on what this means for Jones’ future with Jaxson Dart taking over. Plus, Jerry Recco’s update features Daboll reaction, Eagles-Packers highlights, and the Rangers finally winning at home.
Boomer & Gio react to the stunning move by the Giants to fire Brian Daboll while keeping GM Joe Schoen. Gio calls it strange to split up the duo that came in together, while Boomer wonders what this means for Jaxson Dart’s future. Is this the right reset for the franchise or another sign of front-office confusion at MetLife?
BT & Sal react to the breaking news that Brian Daboll has been fired as the New York Giants head coach, effective immediately, with Mike Kafka named the interim. The hosts agree it was the "humane thing to do" after another fourth-quarter collapse and a disastrous season, arguing that his record—not bad luck—is the reason.
The fiery discussion quickly pivots to the next logical steps, demanding that defensive coordinator Shane Bowen be fired immediately, calling his continued employment "patently offensive." They also debate General Manager Joe Schoen's future, with Sal stating "He'll be next" but expressing concern over ownership's commitment to a full clean-house approach. The segment covers the immediate optics of the firing and what the Giants need to do for a true, long-term rebuild.
BT & Sal tackle the "predictable" concussion suffered by Giants QB Jaxson Dart, arguing that his physically punishing style and the team's over-reliance on designed runs (RPOs) is an "abuse" that is "not sustainable" in the NFL. They debate whether the Giants can or should "reel in" his play, acknowledging his dual-threat ability makes him a future star, but also his long-term health is "hanging by a thread."
The discussion heats up as they slam the inexcusable breakdown in concussion protocol, questioning how Dart was allowed back on the field after a vicious hit where his head smashed the turf. They demand accountability, arguing that "somebody messed something up, seriously."
BT & Sal emphatically declare that it is "painfully obvious" the Brian Daboll era is over and that the Giants must fire him today for the good of the franchise. The hosts slam the team for repeatedly blowing big fourth-quarter leads (like the latest loss in Chicago) and accuse Daboll of having a "losing mentality." They highlight his conservative, "scared" decision-making, specifically critiquing the choice to kick a field goal from the 1-yard line while up 20-10, arguing that it's a "loser move" in the modern NFL. Sal insists Daboll's presence is now doing "more harm than good," creating a toxic environment where players are focused on "not collapsing" rather than winning. The discussion also touches on the significant injury suffered by QB Jaxson Dart and its impact on the team.
Boomer and Gio react to the bizarre story of Steve Cohen auctioning off his $10 million gold toilet and how it perfectly sums up the Mets’ season before diving into Major League Baseball’s growing gambling scandal. From Guardians pitchers caught fixing prop bets to questions about how deep it goes, the guys debate whether fans, players, or commissioners are taking it seriously enough.
The Jets somehow pull out a win despite Justin Fields throwing for just 54 yards thanks to special teams heroics and a dominant defensive effort. Boomer and Gio react to one of the strangest victories of the season, as Aaron Glenn’s crew finds a way to win ugly while the Giants sink further into chaos.
Boomer & Gio react to another brutal Giants collapse Jaxson Dart goes down with a concussion, Brian Daboll looks defeated, and fans are demanding change. The guys debate whether this was the final nail in Daboll’s coffin and if it’s time to turn to Jameis Winston.
BT & Sal are joined by former New York Rangers legend Henrik Lundqvist and Dr. Jonathan Salik to raise urgent awareness about Recurrent Pericarditis (RP), a chronic and often misdiagnosed heart disease. Lundqvist details how RP forced his retirement following open-heart surgery, calling the condition a major "life disrupted."
The King also weighs in on the current Rangers squad, addressing their embarrassing zero-goal start at home and reflecting on the frustration of his own career, where he often carried deficient offensive teams. The hosts conclude by placing Lundqvist on New York's "Mount Rushmore of Heartbreak," alongside greats like Patrick Ewing and Don Mattingly—legends revered for their greatness but lacking a championship ring.
BT & Sal dive into the "DH or Done" dilemma surrounding Pete Alonso's free agency, arguing that the Mets cannot let the star first baseman hold their crucial offseason hostage. Sal insists the Mets must offer Alonso a "perfect" deal—a long-term contract (he suggests 5 years, $150M) only if he agrees to transition immediately to a Designated Hitter role to improve the team's defense. Tierney agrees he needs to be an affordable DH, but suspects Alonso's pride in playing first base will lead him to walk away for less money elsewhere. They both conclude that if Alonso and his agent, Scott Boras, drag the process out or refuse the DH mandate, the Mets must move on immediately to aggressively build a World Series-caliber roster
Who would have predicted that in the beginning of November, neither the Jets or Rangers would have a single win at home AND that Sauce Gardner and Quinnen Williams would no longer be on the Jets?Follow @HoffWFAN
The reaction to breaking news of the Jets trading their star defensive tackle to the Dallas Cowboys.
BT & Sal are stunned as breaking news hits the air: The New York Jets have traded star cornerback Sauce Gardner to the Indianapolis Colts for a massive haul, including two first-round draft picks! The hosts are immediately joined by NFL Insider Brian Baldinger to break down the blockbuster deal. BT views it as a "bold" and needed move that shows the new front office has a "clue" and direction, while Baldi discusses Gardner's perceived overrated play and lack of recent turnovers. The trio debates the implications for the Jets' full rebuild, questioning if players like Breece Hall are now on the trade block and if the move will finally "expedite the process" of changing the franchise's losing culture. They also briefly touch on the Giants' "embarrassing" defensive performance against the 49ers.
BT and Sal unleash a fiery critique of the Giants' leadership, reacting to reports that ownership might split the ticket and keep either Brian Daboll or Joe Schoen. The hosts vehemently argue that both have failed and deserve to be fired, calling a split decision an "epic disaster." Sal makes the case that if he had to keep one, it would be Daboll due to his work in developing quarterback Jaxson Dart, but questions why Schoen is reportedly favored by ownership despite the team's disastrous record, especially against NFC East rivals. The debate escalates as they discuss the danger of letting Schoen make trade deadline moves and demand that ownership make a decisive move now to start a true culture reset.
The clock’s ticking to 4 PM. No buzz, no moves — yet. Will the Jets shock the league and move Breece Hall? The Giants found their guy in Jaxson Dart. Can the Jets do the same?
BT & Sal declare the Schoen and Daboll era is unequivocally over after the Giants' latest pathetic loss at home to the depleted 49ers. Despite Jaxson Dart's strong performance, the team is now 2-7 for the third straight year, proving the regime's failure goes far beyond the quarterback position. The hosts blast the horrific play calling, abysmal defensive effort (especially stopping the run), and the disengaged players who are reportedly quitting on plays—a sign of a broken culture. They argue that the marriage of Dart and Daboll is not worth saving, demanding the firing of both Shane and Daboll immediately before they "run Dart into the ground" out of desperation. The conversation concludes with a list of the franchise's failings: they don't draft well, don't develop well, and don't coach well.
The Giants fall again — and this time, their own stadium sounded like a Niners home game. Boomer says the winds of change are blowing in Big Blue, and Brian Daboll’s future might be caught in the storm. The rookie QB’s playing reckless, Jayden Daniels is likely done for the season, and Boomer’s throwing out Lane Kiffin for the Giants — while Gio wants him in Gang Green.
THE MONSTERS WE MAKE: Murder, Obsession, and the Rise of Criminal Profiling[W. W. Norton and Company; October 14, 2025] where Rachel Corbett takes a fresh look at criminal profiling -- the effort to analyze criminal behavior to identify criminals as a predictable, and controllable human type. Corbett walks readers through its history, examines its modern uses, and takes clear-eyed stock of its profound limitations.
Follow Rachel Corbett on Instagram & X @RachelNCorbett
Follow Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN
After 165 days and more than 8,000 miles at sea, British adventurers Jess Rowe (28) and Miriam Payne (26) — known as the "Seas the Day" ocean-rowing duo — have officially completed their record-breaking, non-stop crossing of the Pacific Ocean from Peru to Australia, becoming the first female team ever to row the Pacific mainland-to-mainland unsupported.Follow Jess Rowe on Instagram @Wild_RoweFollow Miriam Payne on Instagram @MimsinthewildFollow Pete Hoffman on X Insta & TikTok @HoffWFAN
BT & Sal launch a blistering attack on the Mets and Yankees, arguing that despite their immense wealth, neither team is truly committed to going "all-in" like the Los Angeles Dodgers. They dissect how New York has consistently lost out on premier superstars, from Freddie Freeman to Ohtani and Yamamoto, and how they often settle for a "nice plan B" instead of adding talent on top of talent. The hosts demand both teams flex their financial muscle this offseason for names like Skubal and Kyle Tucker, declaring that competing with the Dodgers requires a mentality of zero restrictions. Sal and BT debate the risk of trading top pitching prospects like McClain and Schlittler to achieve immediate World Series contention, emphasizing that anything less than total commitment is unacceptable for New York.
BT & Sal interview global star Sydney Sweeney about her intense new film, "Christy," based on the life of professional boxer Christy Martin. Sweeney dishes on the extreme physical transformation, revealing she gained 35 pounds of muscle through rigorous training and consuming excessive calories—a process she found tougher than losing the weight! She shocks the hosts by admitting the fight scenes involved real contact, leading to bloody noses and even a concussion. Sweeney also talks about her surprisingly grounded life in Idaho (living in her great-grandma's house!) and her background as a combat sports athlete before Euphoria blocked her path to a black belt. Plus, she gives an update on the end of Euphoria and teases her next big horror project.
BT & Sal lay into the Giants after their latest loss to the Eagles, leaving them at a disastrous 2-6 record for the third straight year under Brian Daboll. Despite the excitement around rookie QB Jaxson Dart, the hosts argue the same pattern of losing, poor defense, and inexcusable game management (like coughing up the Cowboys and Broncos games) proves the regime is failing. They call out the top-ten payroll and high-priced defensive stars for their inability to stop the run (giving up 276 yards!), slam Defensive Coordinator Shane Bowen, and debate whether Daboll's job is safe even with Dart's promise, asking: "Why is their record the same that it's been for the last nine seasons?"
We started the show talking about the passing of Nick Mangold. Aaron Glenn and the Jets got their first win of the season with a great comeback win in Cincinnati. This was the Justin Fields we watched in week 1.
BT & Sal welcome legendary WFAN host Steve Somers to the studio to discuss his new book, Me Here, You There, available for pre-order on November 18th. The interview is fiery and deeply personal, covering his incredible career journey, from boxing three rounds with Muhammad Ali and watching the Immaculate Reception with John Madden, to his decades at WFAN. Somers reveals sensitive, never-before-heard stories about overcoming prostate cancer and his struggle with alcoholism (which led to a 30-day rehab stint) while working the overnight shift. He also offers honest, behind-the-scenes takes on his difficult midday pairing with Russ Salzberg and details his unlikely friendship and correspondence with Jerry Seinfeld, who wrote the book's foreword.
The Jets finally got their first win of the season but it doesn't change the fact that they don't have a long-term solution at QB or head coach.
BT & Sal dive into the highly-charged Giants vs. Eagles Part Two, arguing over whether this crucial divisional showdown is the last chance for the Giants to have a "relevant" 2025 season. Sal believes a win sets the Giants on a realistic 9-win path, while BT focuses on the big-picture evaluation of Jaxson Dart and Brian Daboll.
The hosts debate:
Whether sweeping the Eagles is plausible given the Giants' decade-long losing streak in Philly.
The impact of the brutal Broncos loss, and if the team can respond against a tough opponent.
The pressure on Brian Daboll to stop finding ways to lose, with the implication that his job is on the line.
They agree the game will be "definitive," either igniting "Giants Pride" and a playoff push, or forcing the conversation to shift entirely to "who's coaching the Giants next year?" and the future surrounding their young quarterback.
We kicked off with the NBA gambling scandal. Kash Patel blasted Stephen A. Smith for claiming Trump was behind the arrests, while Gio said Smith was just protecting ESPN’s NBA ties. Brian Windhorst revealed a sportsbook tipped off the NBA about Terry Rozier, leading to a fake “injury” cover-up. Chris Russo shrugged it off.
The Rangers find a way to light the lamp 5 times against the worst team in the NHL... and still wind up losing 6-5 in OT! How is that possible?Follow @HoffWFAN
BT & Sal react live to the explosive breaking news: NBA figures Terry Rozier and coach Chauncey Billups were arrested as part of a massive, multi-year FBI probe into illegal gambling and sports rigging involving La Cosa Nostra. The hosts slam the shocking details—tens of millions in fraud, prop bets fixed by faked injuries, and high-tech rigged poker games using X-ray tables and hidden cameras. They passionately argue that the scandal shatters the integrity of sports, proving that immense player salaries won't stop cheating driven by addiction or the "rush." This is every fan's worst fear confirmed.
Sports world shaken as FBI arrests Heat’s Terry Rozier and Trail Blazers Head Coach Chauncey Billups in a sports gambling probe. A federal prosecutor joined the discussion, shedding light on what could be behind these high-profile arrests and the growing crackdown on gambling in professional sports.
We kicked off the show with a bang — the Knicks snagged their first win of the season under Mike Brown, taking down the Cavs at the Garden!
Knicks kick off the season at home against the Cleveland Cavaliers. Will this be the year of the NYK? Anthony Gallo joins Hoff to talk about game one.Follow @HoffWFAN and @PicoDe_Gallo
BT and Sal clash over the New York Knicks' opening night and season expectations, arguing whether it's "championship or bust" after major offseason moves. BT admits he doesn't believe in new coach Mike Brown to get them over the hump, while Sal worries the team lacks a second superstar and highlights Karl-Anthony Towns' defensive deficiencies and "soft" demeanor as a major postseason liability. They also debate whether the players, specifically Towns and Bridges, were the driving force behind the decision to move on from Tom Thibodeau, and question if the team's core—including Mitchell Robinson and Jalen Brunson—has too many "major liabilities" (defense, shooting, free throws) to actually win an NBA title.
The Knicks season gets underway tonight and hopefully new coach Mike Brown is not going to be buddy buddy with the players. We previewed what we expect from the Knicks season.
Woody Johnson made it sound like Jets fans should accept losing because they are used to it
Before their collapse, the Giants were DOMINATING in Denver, can you spin that into a positive sign for the rest of the Giants season?
We broke down which teams are struggling — including the Jets — and all the trade chatter surrounding them. The Giants were likely exploring a deal for a wide receiver before their tough loss in Denver. We also looked ahead at what could be next for the Jets, especially when it comes to their head coaching situation.
We should be celebrating Jaxson Dart's coming out party that stamped the Giants as a good team but a 4th quarter collapse ruined all of that.
The New York Giants have one of the worst collapses in NFL history. What went wrong? BT and Sal take you through one of the toughest losses in a lifetime.
Gio’s seeing a silver lining — says the Giants have energy and a bright future. Boomer’s not buying it, ripping the coaching staff for mismanaging the game and blasting their late defensive calls. He sticks by his “only go for 2 when you need 2” rule. Brian Burns blew up over dropped coverage, and Jaxson Dart looked crushed — which Gio oddly loves. Now the question: how will Big Blue respond heading to Philly?
Brian Cashman hit the mic with Evan and Morash, firing back at Jeter and A-Rod’s digs at the Yankees and Boone. He slammed the notion that the Bronx Bombers are the only team running on analytics—looks like the clubhouse drama isn’t slowing down!
The Bengals stunned the Steelers on a last-second field goal in a wild Thursday night thriller. Both Flacco and Rodgers lit it up, but the real headline? Gio says defenses are trash across the league — and right now, anyone can beat anyone!
Aaron Rodgers and Joe Flacco combined for 7 passing touchdowns and 591 yards in the air. Who turned back the clocks? And why couldn't either of these QB's play like this for the Jets?Follow @HoffWFAN
Yankees GM Brian Cashman finally addresses the media, opening up about the rash of late-season injuries and their impact on 2026. He makes a stunning reversal on Anthony Volpe's struggles, admitting the shortstop's shoulder surgery showed the injury was "more severe" than previously claimed, and confirms Volpe will start the season on the Injured List (IL). Cashman also reveals Carlos Rodón will undergo surgery for a bone spur/loose objects and will also miss the start of 2026, creating immediate, serious holes in the roster. While defending manager Aaron Boone and expressing a strong desire to re-sign Cody Bellinger, Cashman's comments shift the focus from the team's postseason failure to a daunting injury crisis that already threatens next year's campaign.
Yankees manager Aaron Boone delivers his fiery end-of-season press conference, admitting the team was "out-executed" and "got beat" by the Blue Jays in a disappointing 2025 season. He addresses the key injuries, confirming Carlos Rodón had elbow surgery and will be delayed, while Aaron Judge avoided surgery and will remain in right field. Boone defends his decision to play Anthony Volpe through a shoulder injury, arguing it wasn't impacting his defense, and doubles down on Volpe being in the mix for the starting shortstop job next year, despite the offensive struggles. Finally, Boone discusses the difficult staff changes—including the departures of Harkey and Chapman—and acknowledges the ultimate frustration of not bringing home "Number 28."
BT and Sal tear into Aaron Glenn for his "terrifying" and "ridiculous" comments suggesting he's worried about media reaction if the Jets throw deep and get intercepted. The hosts debate whether the new head coach is "insecure" or just "sensitive" and defensive because he's 0-6 and "getting bludgeoned."
They argue that his transparency, a former appealing trait, has become a massive liability, proving he's overwhelmed and learning on the fly how to handle New York's pressure. The core problem: Glenn lacks the winning pedigree to back up his aggressive, Parcells/Belichick-style rhetoric, making his failure to "handle the heat" a serious warning flare for his future with the worst franchise in North American sports.
We kicked off the show with the Jets’ QB mess — Justin Fields is scared to throw picks and keeps getting sacked. Gio says Aaron Glenn looks in way over his head and more worried about the media than coaching.
Hoff dives into what has been a record breaking 3 game losing streak to start the season at home with ZERO goals scored. Plus, should the Jets inquire about a new QB for the rest of the season.Follow @HoffWFAN
Pat Ragazzo, covering the Mets for Sports Illustrated, joins the show to give his thoughts on the Mets offseason and more.
Keith is joined by Bob Papa, the radio voice of the Giants, to talk about the excitement around the team following last week's win over the Eagles.
Antwan V. Staley of the Daily News joins Keith to give his thoughts on the Jets 0-6 start.
BT & Sal link up with Andy Martino to tackle the Mets' chaotic new coaching structure. The discussion focuses on the Kai Correa bench coach hire and the confusing appointment of Jeff Albert as "Director of Major League Hitting." Martino offers crucial insight, revealing that the new coaches haven't been forced on Carlos Mendoza, giving the manager more autonomy than feared. The hosts also rip into the potential folly of having multiple, confusing hitting titles, echoing Eric Chavez's past concerns that "too many cooks" overcomplicate the game for major league hitters. The segment probes the organizational philosophy behind the new titles and how they're seen in the clubhouse.
BT and Sal engage in a fiery debate over the New York Mets' recent hiring of a new bench coach, Chi Correa, and what it signals for manager Carlos Mendoza. Sal argues that Correa's hire—a move driven by analytics and the front office—is a direct, ominous message from President of Baseball Operations David Stearns and sets up Correa as a manager-in-waiting if Mendoza stumbles early in the season. BT disagrees with the structure, arguing that forcing a new coach on a manager they've never worked with is setting Mendoza up to fail, but ultimately waves the white flag on the debate over old-school feel versus analytical front-office control in modern baseball. The hosts agree that the move signifies a very short leash for Mendoza following a disappointing prior season and the total overhaul of the rest of the coaching staff.
If the Dodgers and Mariners clash this October, it’s Hollywood cash versus Northwest grit — a classic David vs. Goliath showdown. The Dodgers’ megabucks roster meets Seattle’s scrappy heart, and fans are wondering: can hustle beat the money machine? With talk of a salary cap heating up, this series could be about more than a trophy — it could define baseball’s future.
After being accused by Evan Roberts, audio shows Tiki did not want Aaron Boone fired after the World Series
BT and Sal bring the heat with NFL insider Brian Baldinger for an electric breakdown of the Giants and Jets. They dissect the Giants' surge behind rookie Jaxson Dart, questioning if they've truly closed the gap in the NFC East, and if Denver's ferocious defense can contain his unique running ability. On the flip side, the trio unloads on the Jets' offensive struggles, debating whether Justin Fields' late-game hesitancy is fixable and if coach Aaron Glenn's late-game decision-making cost them a win. Baldinger gives a scorching film-based critique on everything from the Giants' Andrew Thomas' impact to the Jets' collapsing offensive line and why a QB switch to Tyrod Taylor was warranted. This is a must-listen reality check for every NY football fan
BT & Sal invite Hoff into the fire for "Bald face lie, Bald face truth" to tackle the biggest, most volatile New York sports debates! They lay down the law on whether Jaxson Dart will lead the Giants in rushing touchdowns in Week 7, if the Rangers can finally score a goal at Madison Square Garden against the Oilers, and if the struggling Jets will trade one of their young stars: Garrett Wilson, Sauce Gardner, or Breece Hall before the deadline!
BT and Sal dive into the red-hot possibility of the New York Giants (2-4) making a surprising run for the NFC East crown after a stunning blowout win against the Eagles. Fueled by the "real" talent of new quarterback Jaxson Dart, the hosts argue that the gap between the Giants and the rest of the seemingly vulnerable division (Eagles are "just okay," the Commanders are "vulnerable," and the Cowboys are "not any good") has been definitively closed. While acknowledging the difficult upcoming schedule (Denver, Philly), they lean into the optimistic view, suggesting the team's new energy and the shifting landscape of the NFL mean the Giants are "live" and a legitimate threat this year, and certainly in the near future. They agree that for the first time in a long time, the Giants are must-watch football.
The NFC East is up for grabs as the Giants roll into Denver. Boomer blasted Aaron Glenn for not yanking Justin Fields for Tyrod Taylor, and now Jaxson Dart faces a true trial by fire against that Broncos D.
Yet another weekly segment with Joe B following the latest of a long line of Jets losses
BT and Sal tear into the New York Jets organization following an "all-time low" performance marked by questionable coaching decisions and a palpable sense of organizational dysfunction. The discussion centers on the growing crisis surrounding Head Coach Aaron Glenn, with Sal questioning if Glenn is the right person to lead the team, especially with a potential top draft pick looming. They dissect Glenn's management of the game—particularly the baffling end to the first half and the final down-and-distance decision—and his defensive, overwhelmed interactions with the media. While Sal argues the team looks lost and lacks "a clue" under Glenn, BT counters that a first-time coach needs more than six games, arguing the Jets' toxic culture is the true culprit, not just the head coach. They ultimately debate the catastrophic implications for the franchise's future if upper management makes another ill-fated coaching change.
The Jets have played some horrible football through 6 games. The London game takes the cake! Plus, the New York Rangers can't find the back of the net at home.Follow @HoffWFAN
The Jets hit rock bottom! The defense showed up, but the offense was a no-show. Boomer blasted the team for giving Justin Fields a huge deal only to bench his arm, calling his play “embarrassing” and the worst QB performance in Jets history. A fake punt to run out the clock? Total disaster. Even Garrett Wilson’s frustration says it all—the Jets are a mess.
Michael Fliegelman joins Pete Hoffman to discuss the upcoming 25-26 New York Islanders season!Follow @HoffWFAN & @MFliegelman
New York Giants completely punk the Philadelphia Eagles in prime time. Cam Skattebo led the way with 98 yards on the ground and 3 rushing touchdowns. Key turnovers on defense and Brian Burns sacks made this game a dominant victory over the defending champs.Follow @HoffWFAN
BT and Sal dive into the New York Yankees' disappointing season post-mortem with legendary Yankees radio voice Suzyn Waldman. Following a Division Series loss at home to the rival Toronto Blue Jays, Waldman offers a fiery breakdown, arguing that the Yankees' early exit wasn't a surprise for those who were paying attention, citing a fundamentally flawed and unbalanced roster construction that the front office failed to address. She challenges the organization's adherence to its analytical philosophy, defending manager Aaron Boone while pointing to the front office's continued resistance to real change, leaving the franchise with its longest World Series drought in history and raising questions about the legacy of a superstar like Aaron Judge.
BT and Sal tear into the New York Yankees' all-too-familiar playoff exit, this time at the hands of the Toronto Blue Jays. They argue that the team's reliance on "mash or whiff" power hitters and a flawed organizational philosophy is consistently exposed in the postseason. Speaker 1 (BT) finds the annual failure "exhausting" and "predictable," noting that the Yankees look like the "grossly inferior team" because they lack the ability to grind out at-bats and put the ball in play, unlike better-constructed teams like Toronto. Speaker 2 (Sal) agrees that the core issue is the roster construction and the front office's failure to adapt, emphasizing that the $300 million-plus payroll and star players like Judge (who, they agree, can no longer be blamed) are masking a deeper organizational flaw. They dissect specific failures, including poor starting pitching, an anemic offense against the Blue Jays' bullpen, and critical defensive errors, concluding that the team is "built for stats, not the Series," leading to the longest championship drought in Yankees history since before they became the Yankees.
The Yankees are done, and Boomer’s pointing fingers at the starters—everyone but Cam Schlittler. The bats went silent when it mattered most, and even A-Rod piled on, calling this one of the worst-built rosters he’s ever seen. Jazz Chisholm talked big, then booted a key play, and while Judge shined, Vlad stole the show.
It's do or die for Cam Schlittler and the New York Yankees. Does Cam have another shut down performance in front of him? And can this Yankees offense unleash some runs in a Blue Jays bullpen game? Is there a Friday in Toronto? We'll find out here once the game is over!Follow @HoffWFAN
Ryan Chichester joins Pete Hoffman to discuss the upcoming 25-26 New Jersey Devils season!Follow @HoffWFAN & @RyanChichester1
BT and Sal dive into the Aaron Judge home run that tied the game, focusing on the fiery debate surrounding his stare into the camera as he walked toward first base. While one caller rips the move as "no class" and yearns for the old school "head down" approach, BT and Sal fiercely defend Judge, calling it the perfect alpha-male flex that baseball needs in 2025, especially after the Blue Jays were "talking smack." The conversation quickly escalates into a larger discussion about baseball's unwritten rules, theatrics, and Mets-Yankees postseason rivalry.
Aaron Judge who has been batting over .400 during the post season finally puts one into the seats to tie game three up at 6-6. Was that all the Yankees needed to get energized? It certainly woke up Jazz Chisholm. Unfortunately at MSG the New York Rangers were dropping the puck for the first team this season. Picking up from last year, they forgot how to put the puck in the net.Follow @HofWFAN
Chris Lopresti joins Pete Hoffman to discuss the upcoming 25-26 New York Rangers season!Follow @HoffWFAN & @CLoprestiWFAN
The guys debate where or not there is reason to believe that the Yankees can still comeback to beat the Blue Jays.
BT and Sal tear into the New York Yankees after a humiliating ALDS Game 3 loss to the Blue Jays, debating the fate of Aaron Boone's job and Aaron Judge's legacy. They agree the team has profoundly underachieved, citing the pitching woes, bullpen mess, and a "meek" offense that's striking out at a historic rate. It's a team failure, but the hosts furiously ask: how high up the hierarchy will the blame go for this "bloody" debacle?
The Jags and Colts are rolling at 4-1, while the Jets and Giants are a brutal 1-9 combined. Boomer’s not feeling any “Championship Winds” in New York—hockey’s cold, the Yankees on the verge of being swept, and Gio’s worried Schlittler’s mouth might jinx their only shot at a win.
Keith talks with Charlotte Carrol of The Athletic about the Giants loss to the Saints and their upcoming Thursday night football against the Eagles.
Keith is joined by MLB Insider and Blue Jays Reporter Shi Davidi of Sportsnet to discuss the ALDS from the Blue Jays point of view.
Keith opens up his Monday evening show by talking about the fight the Yankees must show down 2-0 to the Blue Jays in the ALDS.
Yankees legend Alex Rodriguez joins BT and Sal for a fiery, in-depth breakdown of the Yankees' struggles against the Blue Jays. A-Rod doesn't hold back, criticizing the team's "all out of whack" hitting approach, lack of roster continuity, and the front office's reliance on analytics over instinct. He defends Aaron Boone while ripping into the team's inability to hit elite pitching and offers a passionate perspective on what it takes for a collection of "great players" to finally become a "great team" in October. It's a candid, no-holds-barred conversation on the Yankees' perennial playoff problems.
BT and Sal tear into the latest New York Giants disaster—a sackless defensive showing and an overall team struggle—but fiercely argue against the knee-jerk call to fire Brian Daboll. The co-hosts contend that with rookie quarterback Jaxson Dart finally under center, this season should be viewed as "Year One." They stress that firing Daboll now would perpetuate the Giants' destructive cycle of instability, urging the organization to prioritize continuity and allow the Daboll-Dart marriage a chance to grow before blowing up the regime.
Boomer wasn’t holding back after the Yankees’ latest playoff flop, calling out their “give-up at-bats” and lack of fight. Once again, a better team sent them packing — this time it’s the Blue Jays — though if they somehow reach Game 4, at least they’ll have Schlittler on the mound.
On a special edition of WFAN Daily, Pete Hoffman is joined by Jeremy Stephens and Mike Perry before they fight Saturday night at Prudential Center for BKFC 82 Saturday, October 4th.Follow @HoffWFAN on all social media.
Cam Schlittler put on a performance for the ages! 8 innings 2 strikeouts and no walks. Talk about one of the best postseason outings of all time! And, the Yankees win a ticket to Canada to take on the Toronto Blue Jays!Follow @HoffWFAN
Yankees find themselves in another close game with Boston Red Sox. This time however, the Yankees have the final say and push the Wild Card Series to a 3rd and final game on Thursday night at Yankee Stadium.Follow @HoffWFAN
The Red Sox have a 2-1 lead in the bottom of the 8th. Do the Yankees have more than an Anthony Volpe solo home run up their sleeve?Follow @HoffWFAN
Emmanuel Berbari joins Pete Hoffman to recap the New York Yankees 2025 season and preview the Yankees Red Sox Wild Card Series!
Follow @HoffWFAN & @BerbariOnAir
Sal and BT furiously dismantled the 2025 Mets season, declaring their failure to make the expanded postseason with 83 wins and a massive payroll the most embarrassing season in franchise history. Sal insisted that the collapse—which included the inability to beat the Reds for the final Wild Card spot—was due to a lack of clutchness and character from the core players, not just pitching woes. Both hosts agreed that the team needs a wrecking ball to smash the current foundation and that the team's entire existence was an "absolute mess," making their non-playoff finish an unacceptable disgrace given the talent and spending.
The Mets went silent when it mattered most, shut out and shut down without a playoff berth. Fans packed the seats all year, but the players never showed — leaving those fans embarrassed and furious.
The Mets get eliminated on game 162. Yankees win but can't take the division. The Giants have their QB1, but lose their WR1 in the same day.Follow @HoffWFAN
Sal and BT expressed a complete lack of faith in the Mets' ability to secure a playoff spot over their final four games, despite holding a one-game lead. They attribute this implosion not just to poor starting pitching—forced to use young, unready arms like Jonah Tong and rely on veterans like Peterson, Manaea, and Senga who have been disastrous—but also to basic fundamental failures like poor defense, bad baserunning, and mental errors. BT differentiated the team's struggles as an "implosion," not a "collapse," due to the disintegration of the team's core and a pervasive feeling that they simply "don't have enough" quality and depth to finish the marathon, especially with no reliable pitching options beyond Nolan McLean for the final stretch.
Sunday is set to explode with the Mets’ do-or-die, Yankees-Blue Jays title clash, Jaxson Dart’s Giants debut, and Ryder Cup’s nail-biting finish.
Keith talks about the Yankees being tied for first in the division and kept his receipts on the Toronto Blue Jays.
Anthony Gallo is joined by MLS Season Pass on Apple TV Analyst and Former MLS Player Dax McCarty to preview NYCFC's big matchups against Inter Miami and Messi. As well as getting us ready for the Hudson River Derby this Saturday. He also discusses the New York Red Bulls' desperation as the season winds down.
BT and Sal celebrated the Yankees' routine return to the postseason, acknowledging it's an accomplishment that's often taken for granted in New York. Despite losing Gerrit Cole and Juan Soto, and overcoming early-season struggles like Devin Williams' high ERA, the team pivoted successfully with players like Trent Grisham, Ben Rice, and a stellar bullpen rebuilt at the deadline. The hosts agreed that while the Yankees are held to an impossibly high standard and have flaws, their consistent ability to be in the hunt—and potentially win the division—is something all fans should appreciate, especially compared to the struggles of other local teams. The focus now shifts to whether this flawed, yet dangerous, team can finally cap off a season with a World Series title.
We started with a great night of baseball for the locals, with the Yankees clinching a playoff spot and the Mets coming back to beat the Cubs. It felt like a special night for the Mets. And where is Keith Hernandez? Is he sick?
The Yankees walk off the White Sox to punch their way back into the playoffs, Mets fight back after another near collapse, and Giants have made their decision on QB1.Follow @HoffWFAN
Keith talks about the Yankees clinching their spot in the postseason for the 8th time in 9 years and the Mets win puts them back into the last Wild Card spot in the NL.
We look back at our day after the draft projections of when we thought Dart would start his first game.
BT and Sal are fired up over the possibility of the Giants rushing rookie quarterback Jaxson Dart into the starting lineup as early as Week 4. They argue that starting Dart too soon—driven by fan frustration and organizational embarrassment over the team's abysmal start—would be a disastrous, emotional decision that repeats the team's mistakes with Daniel Jones. Sal insists the Giants must remain disciplined and prioritize the young quarterback's long-term development over temporary fan gratification, warning that an emotional, short-sighted move could jeopardize the future of the franchise's most promising asset.
We started with the Giants quarterback situation and Boomer thinks they are going to announce Jaxson Dart will start this week against the Chargers. Boomer said it seems that Dart has a little ‘red ass in him’. I am going to google that to see what that means. The only way things get worse for the Giants is if they play Dart and he stinks.
Brian Daboll met the media during the 1st hour of our show and may have let the world know Russell Wilson's days are numbered
After another demoralizing loss, BT and Sal dissected the Giants' abysmal performance and the seemingly hopeless state of the franchise. They argued that the team's struggles go far beyond just quarterback play, pointing to a long history of poor drafting, bad coaching hires, and a fundamental lack of organizational direction. The conversation quickly turned to the debate over playing rookie quarterback Jaxson Dart, with BT and Sal both agreeing that while he might make the offense more exciting, throwing him into the current chaotic situation could be an "irreparable" mistake that ruins his career. They conclude that the Giants' leadership has put the team in a no-win scenario, with their jobs on the line and no easy path to a turnaround.
The Giants lost again last night, as they are now 2-19 in their last 21 prime time games. When do you go to Jaxson Dart? The Chargers come to town next week and then they go to New Orleans. You can’t throw him to the wolves against the Chargers. The Giants kicker was hurt again before the game even started. The Giants had first and goal and couldn’t score and had the worst plays called. They never got Malik Nabers involved in that game.
The Yankees started the day off with a huge extra inning output to give them a win in Baltimore. The rest of the day however was downright frustrating and ugly!Follow @HoffWFAN
Sal and BT discussed the early struggles of the New York Jets under new head coach Aaron Glenn. Despite his initial praise and the team's promising talent, they're worried about the Jets' history of failure and how it could derail Glenn's tenure. After an encouraging Week 1 followed by a disappointing Week 2 blowout, the hosts expressed concern that the "dark cloud" of the franchise is already starting to form around the new coach. They argued that while it's too early to judge Glenn's long-term success, he needs to start getting wins and showing tangible results soon to prevent the negativity from spiraling out of control and interfering with his coaching staff.
We started with the local baseball teams and who they will likely play when the playoffs come (assuming the Mets make it).
After Wednesday night's loss, Sal confessed for the first time that his "gut" tells him the Mets will miss the playoffs. He attributes his grim new outlook not just to the loss itself, but to the team's overall struggle to win consistently since June. Sal pointed to a lack of trustworthy starting pitching, citing David Peterson's continued struggles and the team's reliance on a rookie like Jonah Tong in a crucial game. This combination of an untrustworthy rotation, a looming threat from the Arizona Diamondbacks, and a general feeling of desperation has led Sal to believe the Mets are playing with fire and are bound to get burned before they can clinch a wild card spot.
The Mets set an MLB record for number of different pitchers used in one season: 46. That number will tell you how bad the pitching has been.
Good news, the Mets are still sitting in that final playoff spot. 10 games to go they have a 1.5 game lead over the Diamondbacks. Bad news, the Dbacks have the tie breaker if it gets to that point. Follow Hoff @HoffWFAN
Sal Rants about the maddening inconsistency of both the Yankees and Mets, expressing his frustration with their inability to play solid, consistent baseball. He highlights the Yankees' near-collapse after a 10-1 lead and the Mets' win streak after an embarrassing losing streak, arguing that these wild swings make it impossible to know how to feel about either team. Sal explains that while both teams have the potential to make a deep playoff run, their unpredictable nature and unreliability make it difficult to be confident in their success. He concludes that despite the emotional toll, the only thing that matters now is for both teams to make the postseason, where their regular season performance becomes irrelevant.
We started the show with the Mets, who had a big first inning and beat the Padres. We have 11 more games to go and the Diamondbacks are right on their heels. Gio is encouraged by last night. Boomer thought he gave up on the Mets. Gio thinks the Yankees should want to play the Astros so they can pay them back.
The Mets put up a 5 spot in the first inning against Michael King and the San Diego Padres. The Yankees up 10-1 allow the Twins to score 7 unanswered runs. Can Bednar stop a potential collapse? Follow Hoff @HoffWFAN
BT and Sal's discussion rages over the Yankees' recent loss, which has all but ended their chances of winning the AL East. Sal is furious, believing the Yankees underachieved and let a weaker Toronto Blue Jays team run away with the division, making their postseason path much more difficult. He argues that with the Yankees' standard, winning the division is a must, and their failure to do so is a "disappointing regular season." BT, however, takes a more nuanced view, pointing to injuries to key players like Gerrit Cole and Louis Hill as reasons for the team's struggles, and maintains that just making the playoffs is a significant accomplishment given the circumstances. He believes the "get in and anything can happen" mentality of the modern MLB postseason makes winning the division less important. The two hosts clash on whether the Yankees' performance is a disappointment or a resilient effort.
Boomer loves him some Tom Brady, but him sitting up in the Raider’s coach’s booth with headsets on is ‘B.S.’
Losing games is bad enough but Brian Daboll and Aaron Glenn must be careful not to lose their teams as well.
Keith opens up his show by talking about the Yankees disappointing 7-0 loss at the hands of Simeon Woods-Richardson and the Minnesota Twins.
The first number of Jets lottery hit last week, the 2nd number this week wasn't even close with Justin Fields.
BT and Sal break down the Giants' heartbreaking loss to the Cowboys, placing the blame squarely on the shoulders of the entire organization, with a specific focus on head coach Brian Daboll. BT initially targeted the defense, citing their failure to make crucial stops despite a roster built for disruption. However, Sal argued the blame was "all encompassing," pointing to a multitude of issues including stupid penalties, offensive miscues, and poor coaching decisions. They agreed that the loss was a microcosm of a much larger, systemic problem within the Giants organization—a lack of accountability and a "disgraceful" culture that has plagued the franchise for years.
Here we are again, 2 weeks into the NFL season and the Giants and Jets are both 0-2. The Giants played prevent defense which didn’t make any sense with the Cowboys having one of the best kickers in the league. Cowboys fans should be concerned that they gave up all that offense to a Giants team that normally can’t seem to score.
Jets get crushed, Giants get dealt a heartbreaker, Yankees lose series finale in Boston, but Pete Alonso and the Mets walk it off in 10!Follow @HoffWFAN
Sal and BT opened their show with a fiery takedown of the Mets, who are in the midst of an epic late-season collapse that threatens their playoff hopes. After the team's promising run last year, Sal expressed disappointment in this year's Mets for playing with a lack of fight and seemingly "crumbling to the pressure." BT pushed back, arguing that the team has no character and doesn't even care about losing, citing a pitiful ninth inning where the team went down meekly. Both agreed that the team's performance has been "unacceptable" and that, regardless of whether they back their way into the playoffs, massive changes are needed.
Mike Tyson joins us in the studio and Boomer immediately has Gio do an impression of him to his face. We talked to him about his upcoming live shows at Hard Rock venues around the country and his upcoming fight against Floyd Mayweather.
The Mets lost again, getting swept by the Phillies. The Mets have a 1 ½ game Wild Card lead with 15 games to play. Even if they get in, are you confident they can do anything? They don’t have the same chemistry and confidence that they had last year. They finish up the season against the Marlins, just like in 2007.
The Mets have now lost 6 in a row after getting swept in a 4 game series in Philly. What will change the way the Mets are currently performing. Hoff has a crazy idea!Follow @HoffWFAN
We started the show with reaction to the assassination of talk show host Charlie Kirk and the 24th anniversary of the attacks on 9/11.
Tigers and Phillies both put up double digits while the Yankee and Mets combined for a total of 4 runs between the two of them on Wednesday Night. This is a bad time to be bad!Follow @HoffWFAN
Todd Zeile joins the guys LIVE in studio to discuss the current state of the Mets and the upcoming Alumni Day.
Todd Zeile joins the guys live in studio to discuss the Mets 9/11 Anniversary memorial and what it was like playing in New York at the time.
The Mets are in a full tailspin, Sal still sees enough good to propel them to the playoffs, BT says as long as Sean Manaea is in the rotation, the Mets will miss the playoffs.
It feels like we are in the middle of a complete collapse by the Mets. The Mets are on the verge of not making the playoffs, and if they do make it, it will be short lived. To not get as far as last year after adding Juan Soto would be insane. They cannot let Sean Manaea pitch another game this season. Gio said they stink and have stunk for months.
Harrison Bader continues to put a hurt on the New York Mets and Gleyber Torres makes his return to Yankee Stadium. Follow @HoffWFAN
Brian Baldinger joins BT & Sal to give a raw and unfiltered breakdown of the Giants' brutal Week 1 loss, calling their performance "terrible" and "the walking dead." Baldy rips into the team's play-calling, offensive line, and especially their goal-line struggles, arguing that the Giants should have just "shoved it down their throat." He contrasts the Giants' struggles with the Jets' impressive start, praising Justin Fields' play and the creative offense. The conversation culminates with Baldy's emphatic call for the Giants to bench Russell Wilson and start rookie quarterback Jaxson Dart immediately.
In a fiery segment, Hoff declares the Mets' season is over, predicting they'll miss the playoffs despite currently holding a spot. He argues their recent struggles, a brutal remaining schedule, and a history of collapses make it an inevitable outcome. BT and Sal push back, but Hoff's "eureka moment" is based on the team's "unfathomably bad" fundamentals, foolish front-office moves, and their stunning inability to win when trailing late in games.
BT and Sal get into a heated debate about the Mets' recent struggles and whether manager Carlos Mendoza is to blame. While Sal argues the team's bigger problems lie with inconsistent hitting and a flawed roster, BT insists that Mendoza's "sloppy" in-game decisions, particularly a confounding pinch-hitting choice, are a recurring detriment that could ultimately cost the Mets a playoff spot. They dissect Mendoza's tactical missteps from the recent loss and question if he has what it takes to guide a team through a high-stakes pennant race.
Nolan McLean pitched well last night but the Mets offense has been horrible and couldn’t score a single run. They are not winning the division now, we can only hope that they hang on and get into the Wild Card.
Mets lose the the Phillies, but what's worse is what the teams chasing the Mets for the final wild card spot did.Follow @HoffWFAN
In a predictably frustrating press conference, Brian Daboll confirmed that Russell Wilson will remain the Giants' starting quarterback for Week 2, despite an anemic six-point performance in the season opener. Daboll's defiant stance and refusal to hold the offense accountable, especially after the unit's third straight season opener without a touchdown, sparked a fiery response from BT and Sal. They criticized Daboll's excuses and his "moral victory" attitude, arguing that his decision to stick with Wilson over promising rookie Jaxson Dart is a sign of a deeper, systemic problem within the Giants organization.
Sal and BT ripped into the New York Giants' season-opening loss, calling it a "disgrace" and a mirror image of the team's struggles over the past three seasons. They argued that despite new personnel, including a new quarterback in Russell Wilson, the same fundamental issues—a terrible offensive line and an inability to run the ball—remain. BT and Sal blamed head coach Brian Daboll and general manager Joe Schoen, pointing out that after four years, the offense looks just as broken as ever, proving that the coaching is the true constant behind the team's failures.
The Jets offense looked surprisingly good but the defense gave up 4 TDs to Aaron Rodgers. The Jets also had a fumble on a kickoff return that really hurt them. Justin Fields made a lot of good throws.
Sunday's in New York are not as fun as they used to be. Jets lose a nail biter, Giants lose a head scratcher, Mets lose final game in Cincy, but at least the Yankees won!Follow Hoff @HoffWFAN
Evan and Tiki are joined by Giants Running Back Tyrone Tracy to talk about the upcoming season and expectations for Big Blue.
Evan and Tiki are joined by Giants radio analyst Carl Banks to talk about the upcoming season for Big Blue.
Sal and BT had Ian Eagle on the show, and the veteran broadcaster immediately turned the tables on his former WFAN colleagues. Eagle dropped a number of bombshells, including his thoughts on a new broadcasting partner, how he avoids getting caught up in the drama of fan topics, and even a funny story about J.J. Watt and his brother. Throughout the segment, he kept the hosts on their toes, playfully jabbing at them and proving why he's one of the best in the business.
In a spirited and insightful discussion, former Jets tight end Anthony Becht joined BT & Sal to preview the 2025 New York Jets season. Becht addressed key issues, from the season-ending injury to Tucker to the impact of new head coach Aaron Glenn's "all-in" culture and the team's reliance on Justin Fields' unique skill set. He offered a "coach's perspective" on the team's potential, emphasizing that discipline and winning are the only true measures of success. Becht's passion and directness set the tone for a must-listen preview of the Jets' highly anticipated campaign.
Sal and BT dissect a painful Yankees loss to the Houston Astros, a game they believe exposed the team's core flaws despite their strong regular-season record. Sal expressed frustration with the inconsistent and sloppy play, particularly with Devin Williams and the bullpen, while BT focused on the larger pattern of the Yankees struggling against quality teams. Both agreed that the umpire's poor calls were a factor but not the ultimate reason for the loss, highlighting instead the team's shaky defense, bullpen issues, and mental lapses. They concluded that while the Yankees' potent offense can win games, their underlying problems make them an "imperfect" team with an uncertain path to a World Series.
Is Andrew Thomas going to play for the Giants this Sunday against the Commanders? We also talked about the season ending injury to Alijah Vera-Tucker of the Jets. Both teams tried to build up their offensive lines.
We get NFL football tonight as the Cowboys play the Eagles. The Giants open with Washington and then play the Cowboys and Gio said they have to win one of those games as they can’t start the season 0-2 with two losses in the division. The NFC East could be a top division if the Giants figure out how to get some wins. We wondered how soon Brian Daboll would try to get Jaxson Dart into games.
Devin Williams did it again and don't blame the umpire. The Yankees can erase an ugly loss with a game and series win on Thursday.
Evan doesn't want anyone calling the show saying the Jets should tank for a quarterback this season
BT and Sal spoke with Brian Baldinger about the state of the Jets and Giants heading into the season, with Baldy offering a blunt and critical take on both teams. He immediately addressed the Jets' offensive line woes and Justin Fields' continued struggles, tempering expectations for a team that many believe to be a playoff contender. He also gave a very cautious endorsement of the Giants, acknowledging their improved roster but questioning whether their quarterback situation would be good enough to make a difference. Overall, Baldinger's analysis was a stark reality check for both New York teams and their fan bases, highlighting the significant obstacles they face this season.
BT and Sal reacted with predictable anguish to the news that Alijah Vera-Tucker will miss significant time with a serious arm injury, a bombshell dropped just before the start of the season. The hosts discussed how this injury, to a key player on what was supposed to be the team's strength—the offensive line—takes all the "juice" and excitement out of the season. While BT noted it's not as catastrophic as the Aaron Rodgers injury, he lamented the Jets' perpetual "same old Jets" luck and the razor-thin margin for error they now face. The hosts expressed frustration that a team with aspirations of running the ball and being a physical force is now hobbled before they even play a single down.
The Mets beat the Tigers again and Nolan McLean pitched great again after having a rough start to the game. Boomer would start him first in a playoff series.
Trent Grisham hit his 3rd Grand Slam of the season this year for the New York Yankees. In what looked like a throw in piece, Grisham has seen regular at bats and now has 29 home runs on the season. Do the Yankees need to bring the outfielder back in 2026? Plus, Mets put on another offensive explosion in Detroit.Follow @HoffWFAN
Sal and BT, with the help of a text from their partner, reignited their early-season debate about Juan Soto. While Sal wanted to celebrate Soto's recent surge and shut down the "haters" who criticized him, BT insisted that the initial criticism was warranted and that Soto's first two months of subpar play couldn't simply be ignored. The conversation pivoted to a heated argument about what statistics truly matter, as Sal pointed to Soto's impressive RBI and stolen base numbers, while BT highlighted his lower-than-career-average on-base percentage and lack of doubles.
In a fiery segment, Sal and BT tackled the immense optimism surrounding the upcoming NFL season for both the Jets and Giants. While BT expressed a cautious optimism, praising the "buttoned-up" nature of the teams' offseasons and new leadership, Sal remained skeptical. He warned fans to temper their expectations, questioning where the winning projections are coming from for two teams that have underperformed for years. He argued that a "fresh start" or a new regime doesn't automatically translate to victories and that fans are getting ahead of themselves by predicting playoff success.
Gio watched the Netflix documentary, ‘Unknown Number: High School Catfish’. There’s a big spoiler alert in this segment of the show, just a heads up y’all.
We started the hour with the start of the Giants schedule. Gio said they have to go 2-2 to start the season at the very least. They have to score points and Russell Wilson has to throw TDs. They have to beat either Dallas or Washington to start the season. Boomer thinks both their defense and offensive lines will be better and Russ doesn’t turn the ball over very often.
We talked about Arch Manning’s performance this past weekend and Boomer doesn’t want people to overreact. And Bill Belichick’s debut with North Carolina did not go as planned.
Juan Soto keeps on hitting and driving in runs and the Mets pitching keeps throwing it away, Monday afternoon alone, Soto drove in 6 runs. One a grandslam to give the Mets a 6-3 lead, and finally a 2 run triple to retake the lead and make it 8-6 after the pen coughed it up.For more follow @HoffWFAN
Marc Malusis and Jon Morosi delve into the storied career of Wade Boggs, sharing behind-the-scenes stories from his journey from the Red Sox to the Yankees and his eventual enshrinement in Cooperstown. The conversation then shifts to the current state of New York baseball, with Morosi praising the Mets' recent performance and expressing his belief that they are a "dangerous" team heading into the postseason. He contrasts their potential with the Yankees' inconsistent play, noting the wide-open nature of the current MLB landscape and the unpredictability of this year's playoff race for both teams.
Marc Malusis was absolutely floored by the Dallas Cowboys' decision to trade Micah Parsons to the Green Bay Packers. Calling it a "moronic" and "befuddling" move, he argued that Jerry Jones has actively made the Cowboys a worse team for the sake of future draft picks. Malusis believes this self-inflicted wound is a prime example of the Cowboys' repeated blunders, and it gives a massive advantage to the rest of the NFC, especially the Giants, who no longer have to game plan for a generational talent in their own division.
We begin the final hour of the show talking to former Giants offensive lineman and current FOX Sports broadcaster Geoff Schwartz. He chats with the guys about Micah Parsons and expectations for a few contenders before sharing his thoughts on the Giants and Jets. He previews the college football season as well.
Jerry and Willie Colon debated the Micah Parsons trade. Jerry, open to the trade, questioned Parsons' on-field impact, while Willie felt the Cowboys didn't get enough in return, especially since he was traded to the playoff-contending Packers.
In his fiery monologue, Marc Malusis contrasted the New York Mets and Yankees, arguing that the Mets have developed a "fear factor" with the emergence of young star pitcher Nolan McLean and a resurgent lineup. Meanwhile, he claimed the Yankees are merely "bully teams," padding their stats against inferior opponents. Malusis expressed his frustration that despite a recent winning streak, the Yankees have shown nothing to suggest they can compete with elite teams, while the Mets are becoming a genuine threat to contend in the National League.
Compass Media Networks and former NFL linebacker Chad Brown calls in to preview both the upcoming college football and NFL seasons. They discuss what to expect from Bill Belichick’s first season at UNC and Aaron Rodgers in Pittsburgh. Chad does not have a lot of confidence in Russell Wilson’s ability to have a strong season for the Giants. He says Wilson “no longer has it as an NFL QB”.
Jerry says the Mets could have something real in Nolan McLean. Jerry and Willie both rave about how good and exciting McLean was in his start last night as he shutout the Phillies for 8 innings in the Mets win. They swept the Phillies. It feels like the Mets are starting to click.
First there was Seaver, then there was Doc, followed by Harvey and DeGrom... Now... Now it's McLean!Follow Hoff @HoffWFAN
Clem Pappas of our sponsors at Surfside joins the show to talk Mets vs. Phillies, how the Phillies might just be cursed at CitiField, and keep tabs on the wager he made with BT & Sal.
Sal Licata opens Wednesday's show with an honest discussion about the Mets' standing in the NL East amidst their series with the Philadelphia Phillies.
We begin the final hour of the show with Jets radio voice, Bob Wischusen. Bob tells Jerry and WIllie what it will take for the Jets to surprise people and have a good season. He is optimistic about the team’s chances of at least playing meaningful games in December.
The Mets beat the Phillies in a great game last night. Juan Soto was granted a timeout by a young home plate umpire and the Phillies weren’t happy about it. Willie is more impressed by Francisco Lindor every time he watches him. Maybe the parabolic mics will be this season’s rallying cry and this series will be what turned the Mets around.
It's about time Yankees fans recognize how valuable Giancarlo Stanton is to this 2025 team!For more from Hoff follow him @HoffWFAN
Evan and Shaun react to the breaking news that the Mets promoted top pitching prospect Jonah Tong to the major leagues.
Brendan Tierney is joined by actor and die-hard Yankees fan Nick Turturro, who vents his frustration over the team's ongoing struggles. Turturro, a lifelong fan who remembers the team's lean years, feels the current organization has lost its winning mentality and has become a "Disneyland" where on-field performance is secondary to business and fan consumption. He and BT agree that the team lacks "dogs" and a sense of accountability, and he wishes players and coaches would show more rage and frustration over their poor play.
BT believes that Mark Vientos is the missing spark the Mets have needed all season. He notes that while other stars like Juan Soto and Pete Alonso are consistent performers, Vientos brings a different, more infectious energy to the dugout. BT argues that Vientos's fiery play and undeniable swagger are what the team feeds off of, and his recent hot streak is no coincidence. This emotional and energetic jolt, coupled with his clutch hitting in last year's postseason, gives the Mets a real chance to turn a corner and make some noise this season.
The Mets bounced back despite another poor Kodai Senga start. He is the new human rain delay. The Mets scored a lot of runs with two outs last night. Mark Vientos is red hot and looking like the player he was last season. Willie says it’s time for the Mets to start stacking wins and the guys agree that Sean Manaea needs to get going beginning with his start tonight.
Cam Schlittler looks great again as he shuts down the Nationals, the offense does what they do against bad pitching and put up 10. Meanwhile, Kodai Senga gives up 3 runs in 4+ innings, the Mets offense then went on to score 13 unanswered runs to crush the Phillies. All in all, that's a lot of runs in New York!For more follow Hoff @HoffWFAN
Evan and Shaun kick off the show by debating if the Yankees handling of Anthony Volpe is enough to wake up the young shortstop.
BT and former Jets great Nick Mangold agreed on the major issue plaguing the team: a fundamental lack of leadership and accountability. Mangold explained that the constant player turnover and absence of long-tenured veterans has prevented the team from building a winning culture. He praised new coach Aaron Glenn for emphasizing that the players themselves must drive the team's success, a stark contrast to previous regimes. BT echoed the sentiment, highlighting the team's chronic penalty problem as a clear symptom of their lack of attention to detail and discipline.
BT ripped into the Yankees for their abysmal series against the Boston Red Sox, arguing that the team has no heart, grit, or toughness. He proclaimed that the days of opponents fearing the Yankees are long gone, replaced by a "Bronx Country Club" mentality. BT expressed his frustration with the team's reliance on home runs and their overall lack of competitive spirit, pointing out that players show no outward emotion or frustration after losses. He concluded by saying the Yankees have become a predictable, uninspired, and lifeless team that has drained him of his passion.
Jerry Recco and Willie Colon fill in for Boomer and Gio. The Yankees salvaged their last game against the Red Sox but need more from Aaron Judge and better performance against strong pitchers. The Red Sox excel at manufacturing runs, unlike the Yankees' reliance on home runs. They agreed Anthony Volpe's break is a good decision, despite his terrible throw in Saturday's ugly game, which Willie felt was a "tap out."
Aaron Boone joined BT and Sal last week. Boone challenged Sal to make a lineup and also discloses that Stanton is an unspoken leader in the clubhouse.
Yankees stop the bleeding against the Red Sox as Carlos Rodon shuts down the Boston offense. Mets, however, had a real chance to win three games in a row, and decided to blow it, again!Follow Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN
Tommy and Tiki are in this week, and the guys say there will be no magic carpet to come save the Mets this season, but the team is good enough to get the season back on track without the bells and whistles.
Things get heated yet again between Sal and BT when comparing Kyle Tucker and Juan Soto.
The guys open a monday morning show with the Mets as they seem like a team who has turned a corner. Do you trust Nolan Mclean now? Helsey does not seem to be holding up since arriving in Queens
Boomer & Gio are back together and we started with Jaxson Dart’s performance this weekend against the Jets. Boomer is impressed so far, but he’s not calling for him to start for the Giants.
A Funeral for the Mets
It's a funeral, my friends. That's what it is. A complete and utter disgrace. This franchise, from the owner to the players, is rotten to its core. This team is a pathetic excuse for a baseball team, a dumpster fire that's burning bright for all of New York to see. After losing 14 out of 16 games, there is no sugarcoating it anymore. The Mets are an embarrassment, and the worst team money can buy.
Joe Benigno's scorching takedown of the Mets wasn't just a critique; it was a furious, caffeine-fueled sermon delivered to the masses. With the passion of a true New York fan, he lit into every aspect of the team's woes, from a disgraceful bullpen filled with "stiffs" to the "delirious" managerial decisions. He saved his most venomous barbs for "Boy Genius" David Stearns, blaming the front office for the team's abysmal state and an inability to acquire a competent starting pitcher at the trade deadline. Benigno’s rant was a raw, unfiltered cry of disgust, perfectly capturing the agony of a fan watching his team self-destruct.
BT put the blame squarely on Mets manager Carlos Mendoza for the team's latest loss, calling out his "scared" and "gutless" managing. The critical error, according to BT, was pulling a well-pitching Kodai Senga with 93 pitches, a move that BT believes was a clear sign of a manager lacking trust and conviction. This decision, combined with Mendoza's repetitive and uninspiring postgame interviews, is symptomatic of a larger issue within the team's coaching staff, which is failing to properly lead a talented but underperforming roster.
If the Mets miss the playoffs it will be one of the most disappointing seasons, and maybe the most disappointing, in their history. Losing is contagious and the Mets feel like they have some sort of loser virus infecting the team. The season is turning into a nightmare.
Back to back games where they have the lead against the lowly Braves and they LOSE! How's the bullpen looking? How's the starting pitching looking? How's the offense looking? ALL LIKE A PILE OF POOP!Follow Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN
In a conversation about Pete Alonso breaking his all-time Mets home run record, Darryl Strawberry showed his championship pedigree, focusing not on the individual accomplishment but on the importance of winning. Strawberry insisted that while records are nice, they are ultimately hollow without championships. He passionately recalled the "hate to lose" mentality of the 1986 Mets and urged the current team to adopt that same fierce, competitive spirit to deliver a winner for the long-suffering fan base. While classy and appreciative of Alonso, Strawberry's message was clear: individual accolades are secondary to team success and bringing a championship back to Queens.
BT and Sal tore into the Mets for what they deemed an "unacceptable" and "disgraceful" loss, a stunning collapse that saw the team blow a six-run lead to the Atlanta Braves. The hosts expressed outrage that the Mets' pitching staff, led by All-Star David Peterson, could not hold a significant lead, a recurring issue that has plagued the team for months. They criticized the organization for its inability to fix the pitching problem and questioned whether the Mets have what it takes to be a serious contender, arguing that the constant breakdowns are a sign of a team with a low ceiling and a frighteningly low floor.
Gio and Jerry are back from California and they want to discuss the trip but have to start with last night’s Mets debacle. They both woke up and couldn’t believe the Mets blew a 6-0 lead. They are surprised and disappointed that David Peterson fell apart in the 4th inning. The Mets are drawing big crowds and playing poorly. The pitching staff has been among the worst in baseball lately. Neither of them can believe how far the Mets have fallen the last two months. Gio doesn’t believe they will go on a run and wonders where it ends with the pitching staff. The Mets need a good start from Kodai Senga tonight but Jerry isn’t counting on it.
BT and Sal, still hot after ripping into a recent Mets' broadcast call for being "corny" and "pre-meditated," brought on the legendary John Sterling to discuss his most historic home run calls. The fiery duo celebrated Sterling's ability to capture the moment with unscripted passion and unique flair, a stark contrast to the broadcast calls they had just criticized. Sterling's appearance turned into a masterclass on the art of broadcasting, with the iconic voice of the Yankees sharing the stories behind his most memorable and spontaneous home run calls.
After Pete Alonso officially became the Mets' all-time home run leader, BT and Sal got into a fiery debate about his future with the team. Sal believes that this historic moment, combined with Alonso's strong performance, makes it impossible for Steve Cohen to let him walk in free agency. BT, however, argued that it's a sentimental take that ignores the business side of baseball, citing Alonso's age and the team's past hesitation to sign him long-term. Both hosts agreed that the fans would revolt if the Mets let their homegrown home run king leave, but they couldn't agree on whether the team's front office will prioritize this emotional connection over cold, hard business logic.
Pete Alonso is the Mets new home run king and last night was a get right night for the Mets and Yankees. C-Mac is still unsure if David Stearns will want to sign Pete Alonso after the season but he’s coming around to believe Steve Cohen will make sure that Pete is a Met for life.
Yankees hit 3 home runs, Mets hit 6, two of which were by now home run king of the New York Mets Pete Alonso!Follow Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN
Is the wrong New York team being criticized after the Sheduer Sanders performance last weekend?
BT and Sal are refusing to get excited about the Yankees' latest win, arguing it's just another instance of "bully ball" that gives a false sense of hope. They dismiss the victory against a struggling Twins pitcher as a meaningless, temporary fix that doesn't address the team's fundamental problems. The co-hosts insist that this win, built on home runs and against weak competition, is a distraction from the larger issues of a flawed roster, poor baserunning, inconsistent pitching, and a broken organizational culture that has persisted for years.
The Yankees got back on track last night. C-Mac says it’s nice to win but other than Will Warren, there’s nothing to really make anyone feel more confident in the Yankees. C-Mac is annoyed that every team has to be compared to teams of the past that have no connection other than wearing the same uniform. C-Mac says there’s too much focus on comparing teams to past champions when the focus should instead be on current competition.
It didn't hurt that the Yankees also had 4 solo homeruns, but Will Warren was on a different level Monday night!Follow Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN
Evan and Shaun talk about whether or not the Yankees and Mets seasons are over and both believe that they can bounce back and sneak into the postseason.
Boomer & Gio are in Pebble Beach and so is Jerry so today we have Chris McMonigle and Willie Colon. It was a miserable baseball weekend with the Mets getting swept and the Yankees losing 2 of 3 to the Astros. Both teams are falling apart and barely holding on to playoff spots. C-Mac says the stars of both teams are failing them right now.
Mets look terrible, Yankees look terrible, Giants and Jets on the other hand.... JUST GET ME TO WEEK ONE OF THE NFL SEASON!Follow Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN
In a highly-anticipated segment, Sal was joined by the legendary Mike Francesa, marking a significant reunion on the airwaves of WFAN. The two sports talk hosts discussed a wide range of topics, from Francesa's viral Giants' podcast with Eli Manning to the current state of the Yankees and Mets. Francesa, never one to mince words, offered his characteristically fiery takes on New York sports, including his blunt assessment of the Yankees' roster and the Jets' new coaching staff, while also giving a rare glimpse into his personal life and a good-natured jab at Sal's on-air style.
If you thought being swept at home by the Guardians was bad enough, the Mets were a Juan Soto home run away from being NO HIT! But at least the bullpen looks good. New York Yankees decided to show a little fight and beat the Rangers on the road to end a losing streak.Follow Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN
In a revealing conversation, former Mets GM Zack Scott was pressed about the infamous 2021 trade that sent a young Pete Crow-Armstrong to the Cubs for Javier Báez. Scott candidly explained the front office's thought process at the time, admitting that while they valued Crow-Armstrong's defense and makeup, they fundamentally missed on his offensive potential, specifically his power. He detailed how the team, in a "win-now" mode under new ownership, prioritized a veteran bat for a playoff push, and how the industry as a whole underestimated Crow-Armstrong's future stardom. This discussion offers a rare glimpse into the complex and often unforgiving world of baseball front office decision-making.
Sal Licata sits down with former Mets acting general manager Zack Scott to discuss the true story behind his highly publicized 2021 arrest and subsequent termination. Scott, who was recently exonerated of all charges, shares his account of the event, explaining that he was tired, not intoxicated, and that video evidence presented in court confirmed his innocence. He reveals that despite being cleared and even being asked to return to his role, the Mets still fired him without a clear explanation, a decision he believes was influenced by the team's "zero tolerance" climate at the time.
Sal held a direct and fiery conversation with Mets manager Carlos Mendoza about the team's recent struggles, which have seen them lose seven of their last eight games. Sal pressed Mendoza on the team's frustrating inconsistency, particularly with their star-studded offense. While Mendoza acknowledged the team's struggles and the need for more complete games, he maintained confidence in his roster, emphasizing that the players are working hard and will eventually turn things around. Sal ended the interview by reminding Mendoza that King Cohen had done his part by providing the talent, and now it's up to the manager and players to "get the job done."
The New York Mets & Yankees have won a combined 1 game since the trade deadline on Thursday. They've played 5 games each. That's not good.Follow Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN
Keith talks about how the Yankees and Mets struggles continue with their losing streaks and how both teams need to be criticized heavily.
Evan and Shaun discuss Evan's opinion that the Yankees need to fire manager Aaron Boone.
Sal lit into the Yankees for their latest loss, blaming the team's culture of prioritizing a player's feelings over winning. He was especially incensed by the decision to let Devin Williams close out the game, a move that he believes was made to avoid hurting Williams' feelings after he had already proven to be unreliable. Sal argued that this "soft" approach and lack of accountability are at the heart of the team's ongoing struggles, leading to a frustrating and predictable loss. He insisted that the Yankees' management and coaching staff are afraid to make tough, performance-based decisions, and it's costing them games they should be winning.
The Mets' frustrating loss prompted Gio to liken them to the Knicks: good but inconsistent in the regular season. Boomer noted the constant "gut punches" for both the Mets and Yankees. Aaron Judge returns tonight as DH, keeping Giancarlo Stanton out.
Monday's blown save in Texas has to be the last time the Yankees ask Devin Williams to close a game.
The Yankees' biggest problem isn't their recent losing streak or a few bad plays, but a deep-seated culture of complacency and a lack of accountability that has been festering for years. Sal argues that this is by design, stemming from the front office's decision to move on from a disciplinarian manager like Joe Girardi in favor of a more "player-friendly" approach with Aaron Boone. He points to repeated on-field blunders, from Austin Wells walking off a base to Jazz Chisholm getting doubled off, as evidence of a team that doesn't face repercussions for its mistakes. Sal believes this systemic issue, where players are coddled and managers are protected, is a direct result of a front office that doesn't feel pressure to win it all, creating a chain reaction of low expectations and sloppy play that permeates the entire organization.
It was a beautiful weekend in the area except for where the baseball teams are concerned. The Yankees were swept by the Marlins and Gio says this is the most pressure Aaron Boone has faced as the manager.
The Yankees have underachieved, Aaron Boone's message is falling flat, and it appears he's lost the team. Chris says it's not the lack of accountability he has a problem with, it's the lack of urgency that's costing them. For the first time, C-Mac admits, it's time for the Yankees to part ways with Aaron Boone.
It was another wasted weekend for the both the Mets and ESPECIALLY the Yankees... but at least their was a great distraction at Metlife as WWE Summer Slam took over!For More follow @HoffWFAN
In a lively studio discussion, WWE's Michael Cole joined BT & Sal to share his passionate New York Mets fandom and offer insights into the upcoming two-night SummerSlam event at MetLife Stadium. Cole, a self-proclaimed "massive Mets fan," expressed mixed feelings about the team's trade deadline moves, praising the bullpen acquisitions but lamenting the lack of offensive help. The conversation also delved into Cole's extensive career as a WWE commentator, highlighting the unique challenges and joys of his role, including surprising moments like Brock Lesnar ending The Undertaker's WrestleMania streak and John Cena's heel turn. He shared his personal take on wrestling legends, naming Hulk Hogan and John Cena as his top two, and revealed how he prepares for major WWE events like SummerSlam, emphasizing the storytelling and character development aspects of his job.
In their post-deadline analysis, BT and Sal gave the New York Mets and Yankees a "solid" grade for their trade deadline moves, though neither felt the teams truly "crushed it." While acknowledging both clubs addressed critical bullpen needs and secured important position players (Mullins for the Mets, McMahon for the Yankees), they expressed a slight disappointment that neither team made the "over the top" blockbuster moves that would have earned them an A+ in their eyes, particularly the Yankees not landing a top-tier starter or Kwan, and the Mets settling for Mullins instead of a "splashier" center field option like Robert. Both hosts agreed that while improved, neither team went "all in" at the expense of top prospects.
Boomer gives Brian Cashman credit for a great trade deadline. The Yankees got 3 back-end relievers. Gio says it was fun to watch both the Yankees and Mets be aggressive without giving up top prospects. Boomer takes a look at the schedule and says the Yankees are about to take off. Boomer is mad at Gio for a bet he made on whether or not Boomer would eat a fried cannoli. The guys agree that both teams did what they needed to at the deadline.
Mets and Yankees made their fair share of trades. How did they do compared to other playoff contenders?Follow @HoffWFAN
Giants rookie running back, Cam Skattebo, joins the show live from Giants Training Camp.
Giants rookie pass rusher, Abdul Carter, joins the show live from Giants Training Camp.
Hour 1: The guys start the show by saying the Yankees have been too quiet during today's trade deadline, followed by the initial reaction to the Yankees acquisition of relief pitcher David Bednar.
In this engaging interview, Cody Rhodes joins BT & Sal to discuss the historic two-night SummerSlam at MetLife Stadium, his highly anticipated street fight with mentor John Cena, and the indelible legacy of his father, Dusty Rhodes. Cody opens up about his journey from a slow start in WWE to becoming a main event staple, the unique dynamics of the wrestling world, and his surprising affinity for getting "beat up" in the ring. He also shares candid insights into his relationship with his father's legacy, the evolution of the locker room culture, and the challenges and triumphs of being a top-tier WWE superstar.
The New York Mets made significant waves at the trade deadline on Wednesday, acquiring Tyler Rogers and Ryan Helsley to bolster their bullpen without giving up any top prospects. This strategic move addresses a major weakness, transforming the Mets' bullpen into a formidable force for a deep postseason run, complementing their already strong offensive lineup, and positioning them as serious World Series contenders.
Stu Feiner and Frank the Tank join Boomer and Gio. Boomer asks Frank about the Mets trade deadline moves so far. Stu feels good about the Mets. Frank is a Dolphins fan but appreciates the Giants for defeating the undefeated Patriots in Super Bowl XLII. He is not optimistic about his own team. Stu is optimistic about the New York teams exceeding expectations this year. They are at Giants camp to run a play with Eli Manning today. Eli will throw a button hook to Frank as Stu tries to cover him.
Jevon Holland was one of the prized free agent signings in March and he joins Boomer & Gio. Gio asks Boomer what comes to mind first when he hears “Jevon Holland” and Boomer says it’s that Holland is Canadian. For Gio, it’s that Holland returned Tim Boyle’s “Fail Mary” 100 yards for a TD in that infamous Jets Black Friday game. Holland thinks the Giants have the bones to be a great defense.
Giants head coach Brian Daboll joins us next to discuss leading his QB room and preparing for the season. Daboll says he has a great relationship with John Mara and does not feel any added pressure this season beyond his usual drive to win games. Daboll tells the guys what he likes about Jaxson Dart. Daboll is also excited about coaching Abdul Carter. Daboll wants an update on whether or not the guys are going to Streamsong in September.
Dexter Lawrence joins the show to discuss his excitement for the season. Lawrence says the D-line leads the team and speaks about adding a player as talented as Abdul Carter.
Russell Wilson joins us to talk about being the new Giants starting QB. Russ talks about coming into a new locker room and establishing himself as a leader as well as how important it is to him to get involved in the local community. He does not regret the “Mr. Unlimited” video and does it for Gio in person.
Jameis Winston is our first guest at Giants camp. He is loving the New Jersey/New York culture and how people are straight to the point here. He also loves Italian culture. All he knew about New Jersey before joining the Giants was the TV show “Jersey Shore”. Gio was the sideline reporter for Pitt during Winston’s first start for Florida State. Winston preaches to be aggressive, not reckless. Winston adds that Malik Nabers is capable of being the best receiver in the NFL.
Yankees and Mets had very different days. Mets lose the game, but set themselves up for the battle as they and two top tier relievers. Yankees grab a right handed bat and walk off in the 11th with a W.Follow Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN
In a revealing interview, WWE executive and legendary superstar Triple H joined BT & Sal to discuss a range of topics, from the passing and enduring legacy of Hulk Hogan to the groundbreaking two-night SummerSlam event. Triple H offered insights into the challenges and evolution of the wrestling business in the digital age, highlighting the increased fan interest in behind-the-scenes content like the "Unreal" series. He also touched on the creative process within WWE and the balance between honoring tradition and embracing modern entertainment demands.
In a heated exchange, BT and Sal fiercely debated the New York Yankees' perplexing situation with struggling shortstop Anthony Volpe. Sal, exasperated by Volpe's continued defensive miscues and mental struggles, vehemently argued that the only solution is to send him down to the minors for a complete reset, asserting that the current "noise" and pressure are insurmountable in the majors. BT, while acknowledging Volpe's woes, pushed back on an immediate demotion, suggesting that a prolonged benching to clear his head, rather than a full-blown demotion, should be attempted first, emphasizing that Volpe's offensive flashes indicate he's not entirely overwhelmed. The core of their disagreement revolved around the severity of Volpe's mental state and the most effective path to salvage his potential for a Yankees team desperately chasing a division title.
Will they go to Aly’s wedding this weekend? Jerry keeps getting lopped off but Boomer says it isn’t intentional. Boomer is angry at what he calls the misconception that Jerry is always getting left out. Jerry is not being left out of the show trip to Pebble Beach. Jerry maintains that he is not upset about any of this.
Despite a recent grand slam and flashes of his offensive potential, the debate rages on for the Mets regarding Mark Vientos at the trade deadline. BT and Sal dissect the difficult decision, weighing his impressive power against defensive liabilities and a crowded infield. The question isn't if a move will be made, but whether Vientos's boom-or-bust profile and inconsistent play will finally lead to his departure, despite emotional fan ties to his past October heroics.
Boomer and Gio are back today and open the show discussing yesterday’s tragic shooting in Manhattan. The shooter had a note on his person expressing grievances against the NFL related to CTE. An off-duty NYPD officer was among the four people the shooter killed. One NFL employee was seriously injured. Boomer and Gio agree that modern athletes know the risks of playing football.
The Yankees got good news, all things considered, over the weekend for their star player
BT and Sal tear into the Yankees' egregious mishandling of Aaron Judge's injury, revealing a pattern of organizational blunders and a roster construction that sabotages their star player. They argue that the team's desperation and unwillingness to make tough decisions have led to a "grotesque and unacceptable" period in Yankee history, prioritizing other players over Judge's health and the team's overall success.
Jerry and Dani Wexelman are here today and they are questioning what the 2025 Yankees are. Aaron Judge avoided a serious injury but will miss at least 10 days. Jerry and Dani agree that the Yankees will still be a playoff team. Dani preaches patience.
The Yankees lose two of three and Aaron Judge. The Mets stay hot with 7 straight wins. The MLB trade deadline is days away. Are the Yankees AND Mets buyers?For more follow Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN
Brandon Tierney unleashes a passionate tirade on the New York Yankees, demanding they shed underperforming veterans and embrace their promising young talent. He argues that the team's lack of accountability and unwillingness to reward minor league success is a fundamental flaw, urging the Yankees to make radical moves at the trade deadline to infuse the roster with fresh, capable youth, even if it means trading established names. Tierney believes the current Yankee squad is not a World Series contender and needs a complete philosophical overhaul to become one.
We talked about the Justin Fields injury, which is a dislocated toe, but he should be good to go for the start of the season. But, he will likely not play in preseason. Phil loves Tyrod Taylor as a backup.
The tag team of Pete Hoffman & Anthony Gallo (A.K.A. Gore Buddies) are joined by Jason Leavy of "Fuzz On The Lens". They talk about the 2025 upcoming NFL season, New York Mets, and of course the "Terrifier" series which Jason has been a producer for.
Make sure you follow Jason Leavy on X @JLeavy83, Instagram @Jaybirdd83, Anthony Gallo on X @PicoDe_Gallo, Instagram @PicoDeGallo24, and Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN on X & Insta
Evan, Tiki, and Tommy give their thoughts on the passing of legendary wrestler Hulk Hogan.
Brandon Tierney announces the shocking news that wrestling legend Hulk Hogan has passed away at the age of 71. Tierney emphasizes the immense impact Hogan had on professional wrestling, transforming it into a global phenomenon and highlighting his iconic status alongside other transformative figures in sports like Michael Jordan and Tiger Woods. He recounts Hogan's rise to fame, including his pivotal victory over the Iron Sheik, and reflects on the emotional investment fans had in "Hulkamania," which transcended the sport itself.
Brandon Tierney reacts to the breaking news of Justin Fields being carted off the field, initially fearing a season-ending injury for the Jets' quarterback. However, as reports clarify it's a toe injury, Tierney expresses cautious optimism, debating the severity and potential long-term impact on Fields' running game.
Brandon Tierney goes off on the New York Yankees, emphatically declaring that their recent performance, riddled with errors and poor roster construction, signifies they have officially hit "rock bottom." He argues that despite the immediate frustration, this unprecedented low might be a much-needed wake-up call for the organization, from Hal Steinbrenner and Brian Cashman down to the players, forcing them to confront their deep-seated issues before the trade deadline. Tierney highlights the defensive woes, questionable player deployment, and overall lack of urgency as key indicators of their current disastrous state.
We talked about Justin Fields being carted off the field at practice this morning. It was a non-contact injury.
The Mets swept the Angels and Francisco Lindor snapped out of his 0-for-31 slump. The Yankees lost in Toronto and committed four more errors. We talked about the trade deadline in regards to the local teams. Boomer said the Mets need an offensive outfielder.
Russell Wilson is the starting QB of the New York Giants! Plus... Mets sweep the Angels, and the Yankees get a taste of Toronto!Follow Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN for more.
The Mets win again, they are hot, the Yankees are not as the same errors keep costing them.
Evan and Tiki open the show breaking down Brian Daboll announcing that Russell Wilson is the Giants starting QB entering camp.
Brandon Tierney dissects the New York Yankees' latest thrilling victory, a much-needed win that saw Ben Rice hit a crucial home run. While celebrating the excitement of the comeback, Tierney can't ignore the glaring defensive liabilities, particularly the ongoing struggles of shortstop Anthony Volpe, who reportedly leads the league with 13 errors this season. Tierney expresses a mix of elation for the win and frustration over the team's inconsistencies, questioning how long they can afford to overlook critical errors from key players like Volpe, especially as the trade deadline approaches and they aim to contend.
We started the show remembering Ozzy Osbourne, who passed away yesterday. We talked about his career in music and reality television. Ozzy was mysterious before the reality show. Now with social media, we will probably not have another mysterious person like that.
That's right, on the day that Ozzy Osbourne passes away, both the Mets and Yankees find ways to come back and win!Follow Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN
Evan and Tiki open up the Tuesday show by discussing the defensive issues surrounding last night's loss and if Eugenio Suarez is a good fit for the team.
Brandon Tierney unleashes a fiery rant on the New York Yankees' persistent struggles, pinpointing a dire lack of accountability from management down to the players. He sharply criticizes manager Aaron Boone for his post-game "everything's fine" rhetoric, especially in the face of glaring on-field issues like Anthony Volpe's defensive woes and overall team complacency. Tierney argues that the Yankees have become a "circus" with no repercussions for poor performance, urging for a drastic shift in approach to reignite the team's competitive fire and address their alarming slide as the trade deadline approaches.
The Yankees lost in Toronto and the left side of the infield continued to have problems, committing 2 errors last night.
Keith talks about the defense being an issue for the Yankees in their loss against the Blue Jays and their need to upgrade at 3rd base.
Evan is back from vacation on this Monday afternoon! The boys talk about the weekend that was for the Mets and Yankees, including a Yankees signature win on Saturday afternoon.
Brandon Tierney dives headfirst into the high-stakes world of the MLB trade deadline, focusing on the New York Yankees and New York Mets. With both teams showing flashes of brilliance but also significant flaws, Tierney argues that the 2025 season hinges entirely on the moves made by GMs Brian Cashman and David Stearns. He'll break down the critical needs for each squad, the pressure cooker these GMs face in the demanding New York market, and whether either team has the guts to make the necessary, game-changing trades to become true World Series contenders. It's a fiery debate on the future of New York baseball, where inaction could mean utter disaster.
Everyone is back today with Boomer, Gio, Jerry, Al & Eddie all in place. They started with Scottie Scheffler winning The Open Championship. He is the most dominating player in his sport and has the most boring personality.
The second half got off to an ugly start for both teams but the Yankees had a big comeback victory on Saturday and then the Mets found a way to win and salvage a game on Sunday.
Yankees and Mets are back for the final half of the season. Yankees take down the Braves in Atlanta while the Mets salvage their series against the Reds.Follow Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN on all social media
In a candid and revealing interview, Sal Licata is joined by Mets legend David Wright on the eve of his number five retirement ceremony. Wright opens up about the emotional weight of the occasion, reflecting on his unparalleled connection with the Mets fanbase, his "once a Met, always a Met" philosophy, and the surreal feeling of joining iconic numbers in the rafters. From his earliest days in the majors to the 2015 World Series run and the challenging road back from injury, Wright shares heartfelt anecdotes and behind-the-scenes insights into a career defined by unwavering dedication and a profound bond with New York.
Sal Licata sits down with former Mets infielder Daniel Murphy for a no-holds-barred discussion about the indelible legacy of David Wright as his number five is retired. Murphy shares candid insights into Wright's evolution as a player and leader, reminiscing about key moments, his quiet competitive fire, and the sheer athleticism that often went unnoticed, all while playfully jabbing at Sal and Josh Satin about fantasy football and golf rivalries.
The TJ Watt extension led Gio to ponder how teams can really know which players are worth investing in. Salaries are skyrocketing and players can make more money off the field than ever before. A lot of players only care about the money these days.
Shaun, Tiki, and Loogy discuss Russell Wilson and the Giants this upcoming season and if he can revive his career with Big Blue.
Sal talks with former Mets President Sandy Alderson talking about his time with the Mets, 2015 season, and David Wright number retirement
Sal talks with former Knicks shooting guard John Straks talking Knicks new Head Coach hire Jalen Brunson, and expectations heading into next season.
Sal talks with Willie Randolph about Managing with Mets and playing and coaching with the Yankees, David Wrights number retirement.
Sal interviews former Yankees Manager Joe Torre discussing the Yankees free agency moves, life managing the Yankees and World Series success.
KAT has a lot to prove and the ability to do it all on the court. Boomer wonders if KAT wants to be great and put in the work to get there or if he’s happy with where he already is. Gio hopes KAT uses this as fuel to fire him up moving forward.
Shaun, Tiki, and Loogy break down the merits of the swing-off and why it might find its way to regular season play.
Sal talks with former Mets Manager Terry Collins about his career with the Mets, and David Wrights number retirement and his impact to the impact he made to the team
Boomer says now that the All-Star game is over we are moving into trade season for Brian Cashman and David Stearns. Boomer says both teams are close enough to a championship that they have to be aggressive and go for it. Gio says it depends on who is available. They discuss it all with details.
One of the more entertaining All-Star games took an unexpected turn after the 9th inning. Plus, the Jets don't sleep on Sauce.Follow Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN
Coming off the Garrett Wilson extension news, Shaun and Tiki talk about the most important Jets and Giants player heading into the season.
Sal is absolutely fuming over Juan Soto's All-Star Game snub, calling out Major League Baseball for what he perceives as a blatant disregard for the fans and a nonsensical decision, perhaps fueled by jealousy over Soto's contract. He argues that despite any minor statistical nitpicks, Soto's overall performance and star power demand his inclusion, especially given the All-Star Game's purpose to showcase the sport's best. Sal goes as far as to declare a personal boycott, emphasizing the absurdity of an All-Star Game without a player of Soto's caliber.
Boomer & Gio begin the morning talking about Garrett Wilson’s contract extension with the Jets. The Jets did not have to make this deal now but they could be glad down the road that they acted early. Gio says extending Wilson before Sauce Gardner was the right move. Wilson had a strong third season with the Jets and he earned an extension while Gardner did not.
The derby was a dud for the one local participant, but there was one New York Athlete who cashed in big on Monday!!!Follow Pete Hoffman for more at @HoffWFAN
Shaun, Tiki and Tommy give their thoughts on what the Mets and Yankees biggest concerns are at the All-Star Break.
Sal Licata delivered his fiery first-half grades for New York's baseball teams, giving the Mets a resounding 'A' for exceeding expectations and overcoming significant injuries, despite Juan Soto's struggles with runners in scoring position. In contrast, he handed the Yankees a 'B', citing maddening inconsistencies, questionable managerial decisions, defensive blunders (particularly from Anthony Volpe), and a general underperformance against pre-season expectations, even with Aaron Judge's stellar play. Licata emphasized that while both teams are in good spots heading into the All-Star break, the Yankees have more room for improvement, and he isn't shy about calling out their flaws.
Both the Yankees and Mets are in a good spot at the break. Gio considered buying tickets for the second half of the season. When the guys went to a Mets game last summer it was a “catalyst spot”. How many trades will Brian Cashman make before the deadline?
C-Mac tackles the looming MLB trade deadline. Do the Yankees have more urgent needs than the Mets, and will they actually trade top prospects like Spencer Jones? Plus, can the Mets justify moving young pitching for a rental, given their aversion to big spending on arms?
The All-Star Break is finally here and both the Yankees and the Mets end the final Sunday before the break with a big fat L. Did the Yankees send a message with their draft picks?For more follow Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN
BT and Sal delve into the recently released SNY documentary about former Mets captain David Wright, titled "The Right Way." Sal, having watched the nearly two-hour film, praises it as SNY's best documentary yet, highlighting the intimate look at Wright's humble beginnings, his blue-collar family, and his journey through the minor leagues to becoming a Mets icon. They discuss Wright's career highs, like the 2015 World Series appearance, and the heartbreaking lows, particularly the injuries that shortened his career, including a pivotal play that led to his back issues. Sal passionately argues that, excluding Tom Seaver, David Wright is undeniably the greatest Met of all time due to his character, leadership, and overall impact, despite some personal reservations during Wright's playing career due to unmet expectations.
BT and Sal engage in a spirited, sarcastic, and often fiery debate about two recent slides to home plate: Anthony Volpe's game-winning "swim move" for the Yankees, and Pete Alonso's less-heralded, but still effective, slide for the Mets. Sal, ever the contrarian, dismisses the excessive praise for Volpe's slide, arguing it's overblown due to his otherwise poor season and that his speed alone should have gotten him there. BT, however, defends Volpe's athleticism and the brilliance of his maneuver, sparking a heated back-and-forth as they dissect the mechanics and context of both slides, ultimately agreeing to disagree on which was truly superior and how much credit each player deserves.
BT and Sal dive into the Yankees' most improbable win of the season, a comeback where they were no-hit through seven innings and trailed by five runs before roaring back for a dramatic victory. They analyze how this gritty, old-school win, featuring clutch at-bats from unexpected heroes, felt different from their usual "bully ball" home run barrages, hinting at a potential shift in the team's character and a glimpse of the "Yankees of old" that fans have desperately missed. Despite acknowledging the flaws of being shut down for so long, they can't help but be excited about the offensive potential and renewed belief this monumental win has ignited.
C-Mac is pumped after last night’s Yankees comeback win. He called it the best win of the season. They didn’t have a hit until the 8th inning and they were down 5-0.
Keith talks about how the walk-off win against the Mariners was the best win of the season and gives credit where credit is due.
Tiki and Morash open the show breaking down the great start from Cam Schlittler last night and the way that start has inspired fans.
BT and Sal are abuzz with the New York Yankees' recent turnaround, shifting from frustration over a losing streak to renewed optimism. They highlight key changes like the long-awaited decision to move on from DJ LeMahieu, the return of Jazz Chisholm Jr. to second base, and the consistent lineup featuring Jasson Dominguez leading off. This philosophical tweak and personnel shake-up, particularly after being swept by the Blue Jays and losing to the Mets, has instilled a new energy in the team, making them a "better ballclub" with a refreshed approach.
We started with C-Mac’s favorite team, the Yankees, who are having no problem with the Mariners. Jazz Chisholm hit 2 home runs last night and Jerry said he’s fun to watch. Yankees pitcher Cam Schlittler made his debut last night and his parents were there to see it.
Wednesday, fans got what they wanted when news broke that DJ LeMahieu had been DFA'd. The next thing you know, the Yankees are on a three game winning streak.Follow @HoffWFAN on social media.
Keith talks about the Yankees 3rd straight win but also likes what he heard from Aaron Boone and Brian Cashman pre-game and their decision to DFA DJ Lemahieu.
Mets get a big win against Baltimore and the boys discuss what the moves should be as the deadline approaches.
BT and Sal open their show celebrating the New York Mets' recent offensive surge, particularly from their "Big Three" of Lindor, Soto, and Alonso, which is finally reflecting the formidable lineup they were designed to be at the season's start. They highlight the team's stabilized pitching rotation with the return of Senga and Manaea, fostering a new sense of hope and positivity around the club after a period of struggles. While acknowledging the need for potential further additions, especially a bullpen arm or a center fielder, the hosts emphasize that the top of the Mets' order is now clicking, making them a dangerous team built to contend for a World Series.
We have comedian Jeff Ross in the studio. He has a new one man show called, ‘Take a Banana For The Ride’. We also talked about all the roasts including the Roast of Tom Brady. In the final segment of the hour, we had Jeff Ross back and he talked about his journey with colon cancer.
We started with the Mets and Yankees both getting wins. Lindor, Alonso & Soto all were key players in the win.
Keith talks about the Yankees and Mets winning today and despite being a positive day, Clay Holmes could potentially be moved back into the bullpen after another disappointing start.
Shaun and Tiki open up the show on Tuesday by discussing their expectations leading into the Mike Brown introductory presser.
BT and Sal are fired up discussing the latest Knicks news, with Rick Brunson's role reportedly being cut back under new head coach Mike Brown. While the organization claims this move grants Brown more control and addresses "distractions" or perceived conflicts of interest, Sal argues it's a dangerous demotion that could create an untenable situation for Rick, ultimately jeopardizing the relationship with star player Jalen Brunson. Given Jalen's close bond and loyalty to his father and his support for former coach Tom Thibodeau, the demotion is seen by some as a potential misstep that could upset the Knicks' franchise player and lead to further instability, despite Rick reportedly being "on board" with the change for now.
BT and Sal kick off the show with a fiery debate on the current state of Major League Baseball, particularly focusing on the New York Yankees' recent struggles and the broader trend of baseball's expanded postseason. Sal advocates for the Yankees to "sell" off current players to make room for promising prospects, arguing that the team's fundamental issues—poor situational hitting, defense, and protecting leads—are dealbreakers regardless of the new playoff format. BT, while acknowledging the Yankees' deficiencies, urges listeners not to overreact to short-term slumps, emphasizing the evolving, inconsistent nature of modern baseball and the ability of teams, even flawed ones, to make deep playoff runs as seen with past Mets and Diamondbacks squads.
We started with NFL Training Camps being only days away. Jerry says for the first time in a while there is a new positive outlook for the Giants and Jets. Al strongly disagrees, he’s not falling for the hype again. Both agree they’d love to see Jameis play. Al is not buying Aaron Glenn’s tough guy act. Al is amazed at how time passes.
The talk has been around the New York Yankees and the need for change. But is new blood going to automatically equal success?Follow @HoffWFAN
Keith recaps the Subway Series weekend, as he expected the Yankees to struggle but gives credit to the Mets for taking care of business at home when they needed it badly.
Tiki & Shaun talk about part two of the Subway Series, as the Mets took 2 out of 3 games at Citi Field.
BT and Sal clash over the struggling New York Yankees, with BT advocating for a complete "blow it up" approach, urging the team to sell off key assets and rebuild, frustrated by what he sees as a wasted season and squandered talent. In stark contrast, Sal remains a staunch believer in the Yankees' playoff chances, arguing that despite their current woes, the team still possesses enough talent and time to turn things around and secure a postseason berth.
Evan Roberts recorded a Rico Brogna podcast, live from Paris. Evan was scoring the game while in line at the airport.
We started with the Subway Series and how the Mets threw out a bunch of no name pitchers to face Max Fried, and it almost worked. If Cody Bellinger doesn’t make that amazing catch and then doubles up Lindor at first. It saved the game for sure. Carlos Mendoza was tossed in the ninth yesterday because of the horrendous strike calls. Pete Alonso will not be doing the HR derby as he wants to enjoy the all star festivities. Juan Soto was not voted to the all star game and some see it as a snub
Yankees salvage the three game series with the Mets winning 6-4. After losing six in a row, was Sunday's win enough to get them back to winning ways?Follow Pete Hoffman @HoffWFAN
In a captivating Fourth of July interview, legendary pitcher Doc Gooden sits down with Sal Licata for a candid discussion spanning his illustrious career and personal journey. Gooden reflects on the highs of his Mets days, including the unmatched thrill of his retired number at Citi Field, while also opening up about the profound impact of his father's passing and the enduring regret of missing the 1986 Mets parade. He offers sharp insights into today's Mets and Yankees, dissecting lineups and pitching strategies with the wisdom of a true baseball icon, all while maintaining his unwavering loyalty to the orange and blue.
Mets are coming off a series win over the Brewers and the Yankees are coming off getting swept by the Blue Jays in a 4 game series. These two teams have been at the breaking point for 3 weeks now. Will the season be decided in the next installment of the Subway Series?Follow @HoffWFAN
Sal Licata unleashed a fiery tirade against the New York Yankees, not just for another painful loss to the Blue Jays, but for their systemic failures in playing "the game the right way." He lambasted the organization for continually fielding players out of position, highlighting the egregious example of Ben Rice catching despite not being a catcher, and questioning the continued presence of underperforming veterans like DJ LeMahieu and the team's overall reliance on analytics over common sense. Licata's frustration boiled over as he dissected the Yankees' inability to correct long-standing issues, asserting that their consistent postseason appearances mask a deep-seated problem of sloppy baseball and a lack of accountability from management, ultimately calling for a fundamental shift in how the team is constructed and coached.
The Knicks finally have their next head coach, Mike Brown. This feels like a lateral move from Thibs. Gio does love the experience he brings. There were also rumors going around that the Knicks were interested in bringing Ben Simmons in. The press conference is going to be interesting because nobody from the Knicks addressed why they got rid of Thibs, so all of the questions are going to be about that now. Mike Brown is inheriting the best Knicks team a coach was ever handed.
Yankees comeback... and then they give it right back. What a waste of time! Mets split doubleheader! Knicks hire a new coach.@HoffWFAN for more
Keith breaks down the Mets win in game two of the doubleheader and discusses another Yankees implosion against the Blue Jays.
Boomer about a month ago promised Mike Brown would not be the Knicks Head Coach and we relive it.
BT and Sal are fed up with the New York Yankees' recent performance, particularly after what they deemed the "worst loss of the season" due to across-the-board poor play, including shoddy baserunning, defensive errors from the left side of the infield, and a bullpen that acts like a "gas can and matches." They pinpoint Anthony Volpe's struggles at shortstop and Mark Leiter Jr.'s frequent ineffective pitching as prime examples of the lack of accountability within the organization, pushing for bold moves like benching Volpe and cutting Leiter to send a clear message that the current "unacceptable" status quo must change, especially given the team's ongoing issues at third base and the need for another bat to protect Aaron Judge.
3 Overall in the 2025 PWHL Draft, Casey O'Brien, joins Pete Hoffman to talk about the New York Sirens trading up to take her, her love for New York sports, favorite players, and her goals in her rookie season of the PWHL.
Jerry has the sounds of Pete Hoffman, the host of WFAN daily’s podcast, interviewing a professional women’s hockey player. He thinks it comes across as flirtatious. The Yankees lost in Toronto and had another catcher’s interference. Springer hit 2 home runs, including a grand slam. So we have more from that including post game explanations.
NBA free agency is buzzing, with the Bucks making moves and the Knicks signing Guerschon Yabusele. The NHL's free agency has been quieter, though the Rangers did pick up Vladislav Gavrikov.
BT is are fired up discussing the alarming trend of opposing teams intentionally walking Aaron Judge, signaling a critical lack of protection in the Yankees' lineup. With Judge being walked 20 times already this season – matching his total from all of last year – the guys debate whether the Yankees can truly contend for a championship if they can't force opponents to pitch to their best player. They dissect potential solutions, from shifting Judge in the order to trusting young bats like Dominguez or relying on Bellinger, emphasizing that if the Yankees don't make teams "pay with blood" for walking Judge, their World Series hopes are in serious jeopardy.
We started with NBA free agency and the moves that were made yesterday, and also LeBron’s situation with the Lakers and whether he wants to be traded. And if he is traded, will he land with the Knicks? His former coach Mike Brown came in for a second interview in New York. The NBA is actually in free agency right now and the Knicks don’t have a coach, which has never happened before.
Yankees lose a game that was in their hands to division rivals, the Blue Jays. The Knicks land Jordan Clarkson for Veteran minimum.Follow @HoffWFAN
BT is absolutely disgusted and furious with the New York Mets' performance against the Pittsburgh Pirates, calling their series sweep "completely unacceptable" and a "disgrace." He highlights the stark contrast between the Mets' staggering $325 million payroll and the Pirates' meager $90 million, emphasizing that a team with such high-priced stars should never be outscored 30-4 by a low-budget opponent. BT also expresses frustration with the team's lifeless play, the ineffective pitching, the anemic offense, and the repeated failures of team meetings and managerial ejections to spark any change, concluding that the Mets have hit a new low despite their high expectations.
The Mets got swept by the Pirates and were outscored 30-4. Boomer said you know the team is bad when Ron Darling is talking about ice cream sandwiches. They had a players only meeting on Saturday night that did not work. We talked about the Mets payroll and how that payroll only scored 4 runs. Carlos Mendoza got tossed from a game hoping that would help. It didn’t. Because of the payroll, ‘Somebody’s ass has got to be held accountable’, according to Boomer.
Chris talks about the 3-13 stretch in the last 16 games the Mets are having after being swept by the Pirates, and believes that David Stearns should deserve more scrutiny.
The Mets get outscored by the lowly Pirates 30-4 in a three game series. We have officially hit rock bottom with the New York Mets!Follow @HoffWFAN for more content
Mets manager Carlos Mendoza joins Evan Roberts on The Rico Brogna podcast LIVE from Fanatics Fest to talk about the Mets’ recent collapse, lineup decisions, clubhouse chemistry, and what it will take to turn things around. Evan asks the tough questions Mets fans want answered—nothing is off the table.🔶 Hosted by Evan Roberts | Rico Brogna Podcast🎧 Listen on the Audacy App or wherever you get your podcasts!Chapters00:00 – Carlos Mendoza Joins Rico Brogna01:06 – What Went Wrong During the Losing Streak05:50 – Clubhouse Leadership & Comparing to 202310:15 – Missed Challenge, Lineup Talk & Lindor’s Struggles
Buy "The Rico" T-Shirts follow this link: https://breakingt.com/products/the-ricoPlease like, rate, follow, favorite or subscribe to Rico Brogna here: https://link.chtbl.com/RicoBrognaEmail TheRicoB@gmail.com
BT and Sal acknowledge the grim reality of Griffin Canning's Achilles injury, which is a significant blow to the Mets' rotation. However, they express a strong belief that the team is well-equipped to overcome it, citing the impending returns of key pitchers like Minaya and Senga, along with the recent promising performance of Montas. While the injury necessitates some temporary adjustments, they argue that the Mets' organizational depth, built with such setbacks in mind, means this unfortunate event won't derail their season or their pursuit of a World Series.
Griffin Canning leaves with a nasty injury. Mets win, but at what costs?Follow @HoffWFAN
The Mets won last night to split their series with the Braves. Griffin Canning became the latest athlete to suffer an achilles injury and everyone is trying to figure out what’s going on.
The Yankees continue to make the same trying mistakes. Thursday is a much needed break from the Yankees and the way the organization operates these days.
Ron Darling, commentator for the New York Mets on SNY, talks about all things Mets with Evan and Tiki.
Howie Rose joins the show to talk to the guys all things Mets and his legacy as a Mets announcer.
Pete Alonso joins the show to talk all things Mets, how the season is going, the losing streak and becoming a father.
BT and Sal delve into the swirling rumors of Jason Kidd potentially becoming the next Knicks head coach, with Sal asserting that Kidd views it as a "dream job" and the only move that aligns with a coherent plan for the team, given the "smoke" around his name. While Sal believes Kidd is a good coach and a familiar face to Jalen Brunson, he expresses significant reservations about Kidd's past character and loyalty, acknowledging his "slippery" nature. BT questions if Kidd is a definitive upgrade over Tom Thibodeau, but concedes Kidd's differences might benefit the current Knicks core, especially concerning Jalen Brunson. The conversation also touches upon the intense scrutiny a Knicks coach faces and whether Kidd possesses the alpha personality to handle New York's demanding media and fanbase, ultimately concluding that a Kidd hiring would, at least, signify the Knicks finally have a "plan."
We started the show with the NBA draft which was last night and how the Knicks still don’t have a head coach. They better have one soon as we head into free agency.
The Mets and Yankees both have good days, finally. Is it time to breath again?
Follow @HoffWFAN
BT and Sal launch into a fiery discussion about the alarming downward spiral of both the New York Yankees and Mets. They dissect the fundamental flaws plaguing each team, with the Yankees struggling to hit consistently and exhibiting late-game ineptitude, while the Mets are experiencing a complete offensive collapse and a bullpen that's become a "massive problem." Both hosts express frustration and concern that these issues are deeper than just a "funk," with Sal particularly astonished by the Mets' sudden and dramatic fall from grace, and both questioning whether the front offices will make the necessary "difference-making" moves to pull their respective teams out of this alarming freefall.
The Mets are finding new ways to lose every night. The Yankees can’t seem to win a game when it gets to extra innings. Frankie Montas pitched really well, the Mets got off to a lead, and still lost. Sean Manaea has loose bodies in his elbow which does not sound good.
The Mets actually get a great start from Frankie Montas, but the bullpen blows it. The Yankees take a lead in the 4th, and then get two singles he rest of the game including extra innings!!!For more follow @HoffWFAN
Keith shares his frustrations with the Yankees continued struggles by losing in extra innings to the Reds on Tuesday night.
BT and Sal delve into the New York Mets' recent struggles, arguing that Pete Alonso's severe slump is directly tied to the team's abysmal 1-9 record over their last ten games. While acknowledging Alonso's hot start to the season, Sal emphasizes his current lack of production, including 16 strikeouts, two extra-base hits, and one RBI in that stretch, as a major reason for the Mets' collapsing offense and their plummeting playoff aspirations, leading them to question the team's overall construction and urgent need for significant trades
Boomer is out today so it’s Gio and Nicky Cass today. The Mets lost again, making it 9-of-10 games. Gio doesn’t want to hit the panic button because last year at this time we had them completely counted out. When Juan Soto was not hitting, the Mets were winning. Now that he is hitting, they’re not.
Another day, another loss for the Mets AND the Yankees. Who will get out of the funk first? For more follow @HoffWFAN on all social media.
Keith voices his displeasure about the Yankees 6-1 loss to the Reds and the Mets 3-2 loss to the Braves at CitiField.
Keith voices his displeasure about the Yankees 6-1 loss to the Reds and the Mets 3-2 loss to the Braves at CitiField.
BT and Sal open the show with a fiery dissection of the Mets' recent struggles, with BT ready to hit the panic button, declaring everything from pitching to defense and offense to be "less than championship worthy." Sal, ever the optimist (or maybe just in denial), tries to calm the nerves, pointing to the Mets' record and potential for a late-season surge, but even he admits they need to "prove themselves." The pair hilariously disagree on whether a "transformative trade" or simply a healthy rotation is the Mets' salvation, leaving fans to wonder if their beloved team is just in a rough patch or if it's indeed time to call the season a dumpster fire.
Two things Boomer was talking about last week came true. Francisco Alvarez was sent down to Syracuse, and Tyrese Haliburton’s calf injury turned into an achilles injury. He is likely going to miss all of next season. Kevin Durant was traded to the Rockets and he found out about it on stage at FanaticsFest.
Yankees don't play great baseball, but they do enough to win the three game series against the Orioles. Meanwhile, in Philadelphia, it seems like the message was sent to the team Saturday to go out and score runs!For more follow @HoffWFAN
Evan says the Mets will not collapse, the pitching was bound to come back down to earth, but the offense will be much better and the Mets will still be competing for the NL East title come September. Plus, will Carlos Mendoza back out of his Rico Brogna podcast appearance on Saturday? And, has Tommy stopped the "No Biggie" charade?
BT and Sal open a Friday show live from fanatics fest and discuss the Mets after getting swept by the Braves
Do the Mets need a ‘slump buster’ like Mark Grace used to talk about back in the day. Which single Mets player can ‘jump on a grenade’ for the team?
It may not have been pretty, but the Yankees find a way to edge out the Angels. On the other hand, Mets get swept for the second straight series.For more follow @HoffWFAN
Keith talks about the Yankees losing their sixth game in a row and how this is affecting the whole team. SHOW OPEN.
In an abbreviated show following a Yankees win vs the Angels the guys react to the game and look ahead to a huge night for the Mets in Atlanta.
BT and Sal kick off their show with an exasperated and fiery discussion about the ongoing, abysmal losing streaks of both the New York Yankees and Mets. They lament the "circus" of errors, baserunning blunders, and inability to get clutch hits that have plagued both teams, with Sal pointing out the Mets' continued struggles against the Braves and BT dissecting the Yankees' inexplicable offensive drought without Judge. The hosts express a morbid curiosity about how much worse the situation can get, questioning managerial accountability, player performance, and the sheer sloppiness that has gripped both New York baseball franchises.
The Yankees and Mets continue to lose and are 0-11 combined since last Friday. The Yankees finally scored but not enough to win and the Mets are breathing life into the Braves. Gio says the “I told you so” fans are getting louder but his message to everyone is to calm down. He’s staying positive. Has Boomer sat through a full week like this with both teams losing every game in his 18 years of hosting this show? The Mets had a chance to bury the Braves but instead are breathing life into them. Anthony Volpe’s crucial error cost the Yankees and Gio says it’s tough for any Yankee to play in the shadow of former franchise legends. Volpe and Francisco Alvarez were both two top prospects who have disappointed early in their careers. The Lakers sale has Boomer wondering about the value of the Yankees and Gio thinks the Steinbrenner’s group chat must have been going off yesterday because of the news.
Chris talks about how the bad the Yankees have been playing in the past few weeks including the six-game losing streak and how the team has been ending games, with Anthony Volpe, Aaron Judge, and Aaron Boone at the forefront of that.
With the MLB season beginning tomorrow Mike discusses the outlook for both the Mets and Yankees.
Mike closes out the week by giving his thoughts & taking your calls on a variety of topics including sports returning during the coronavirus pandemic, the surge of popularity for golf & horse racing during the past few months and the importance of legalizing gambling in New York.
Mike discusses what the season may look like for Notre Dame as NCAA Football Conferences announce no Non-Conference for 2020 season. Also, Ed Coleman checks in to give an update on where the Mets are and preview what they may look like at the start of the season.
Mike takes a look at the restart of sports and discusses the PGA Tour's ongoing season.
Mike gives his thoughts on the potential sale of the New York Mets and who he thinks might have the upper hand to buy the team. He also talks about the Yankees "Summer Camp" game last night, what he thinks of the Patrick Mahomes contract & takes calls.
Mike opens up the week by talking about the idea of sports continuing during the coronavirus pandemic. Brian Geltzeiler joins the show to talk about the NBA restart in Orlando. Other topics include the record setting contract Patrick Mahomes signed with the Chiefs, Bryson DeChambeau's win this weekend & the professional future for Colin Kaepernick.
Mike talks about the challenges the major sports face as they try and to return in July.
Mike talks about the 2nd round of the Traveler's Championship & the round that Phil Mickelson played.Ron Darling also calls in to talk about what he thinks of the 2020 MLB Regular Season and different strategies that managers will have to implement.
Mike discusses the PGA Tours ongoing season and what the future may hold for not only the MLB restart but all sports.
With the MLB finally set to return Mike discusses the MLB's plan and what the season may look like when it does with WFAN's own Ed Coleman.
Mike talks about the latest with the Mets ownership story, sports during the Coronavirus pandemic and more.
Mike talks about the MLBPA turning down the offer put forth by Major League Baseball, the reality of sports coming back with the pandemic & gives his thoughts on the Mets ownership situation.
Mike discusses the PGA Tour as they enter their second weekend of action and the breaking news of Jamal Adams requesting a trade from the NY Jets.
Mike talks about the return of golf and Albert Breer of NFL Network checked in to chat about some football.
With the PGA back in action Mike discusses the play and what the absence of fans did to the broadcast.
Mike talks about the Mets worth to whomever owns them and potential plans for next year's NBA schedule.
Mike talks about Sixers and Devils co-owners Josh Harris and David Blitzer showing interest in owning the Mets and he also discusses the newest proposal MLB has for the player's union.
Mike is joined by Hoops Critic, Brian Geltzeiler to discuss the return of the NBA. Also, Mike gets into Roger Goodell's most recent comments.
On today's show, Mike talks more MLB struggles, Zion Williamson's legal trouble, and a little horse racing.....
Mike continues to talk about the current civil unrest in the country regarding the killing of George Floyd. For a sports perspective, he talks about the life of Wes Unseld, Major League Baseball continuing to flounder & takes calls.
Mike opens the show talking about the current civil unrest in the country right now. He also gives his opinion on the reported MLB counter offer to the MLBPA to try & reach an agreement for a baseball season in 2020, his thoughts on the life of former Auburn football head coach Pat Dye and takes calls.
Mike continues the discussion regarding the negotiations between the MLB and MLBPA to get a season in 2020.
Mike talks about the positive days we have had recently given the circumstances & the impending returns of the NHL & NBA. He also talks about how MLB continues to have trouble coming to an agreement between the players and owners. Mike takes your calls & gives his thoughts on the big golf match this past weekend.
NFL Network and WFAN's Kim Jones joins Mike to talk about football in the fall, DeAndre Baker and much more.
Mike Francesa goes through the days leading up to the Mike Piazza trade to the New York Mets.
Mike is joined by the great Ed Coleman to discuss where we are with the MLB season and what we could be looking at when sports do return.
Mike gives his thoughts on the new set up for the Belmont Stakes in June & how vital it is that the MLB owners and players come to an agreement to bring baseball back. He closes out the show by giving his thoughts on "The Last Dance" Documentary and the 1990s Chicago Bulls.
Mike talks about the importance of sports coming back during the coronavirus pandemic, an update on the DeAndre Baker situation & the possible legalization of sports betting in New York.
Former NFL Exec Scott Pioli joins Mike on his Sunday show to talk the latest in the NFL.
Mike gets into the ongoing discussion on the return of baseball and the difficult road it may be to get there.
Mike talks about the ongoing negotiations between the players and owners to get baseball back on the field.
Former NFL Exec Scott Pioli joins Mike Francesa on his weekly Sunday Morning show to talk NFL Schedule and more.
Mike talks about being able to golf again along with when we can see the return of professional sports.
Mike discusses the difficulties professional sports face as they continue to plan their returns.
Mike talks about the recent Jets roster moves (signing Frank Gore & placing Quincy Enunwa on the PUP list), the Rick Pitino situation & when sports might return following the coronavirus pandemic.
Mike reflects on the early 90s Bulls off the heels of episodes 5 & 6 of "The Last Dance" Documentary. Mike also gives his tribute to the late Don Shula.
Former NFL Exec Scott Pioli joins Mike on his Sunday show to talk what to expect from the 2020 NFL Football season.
Mike discusses the continued effects of the Coronavirus on the sporting world reacting to the impact it will have on Summer racing in Saratoga.
Mike talks about the Homeland series finale, Dennis Rodman, a mistake baseball could be making and whether or not there will be racing in Saratoga this summer.
Former NFL Exec Scott Pioli joins Mike Francesa to recap 1st round and preview the 2nd and 3rd rounds of the NFL Draft.
NFL Insider Kim Jones joins Mike to preview the NFL Draft and some surprises we may not see coming.
Former NFL Exec Scott Pioli joins Mike to preview the first round of tonight's NFL Draft.
Mike give his thoughts on the potential of former Alabama QB Tua Tagovailoa & where he might be go in the upcoming NFL Draft. Mike also shares his thoughts on Rob Gronkowski reuniting with Tom Brady in Tampa Bay. Mike closes out the show by talking about how the Coronavirus pandemic compares to previous events in America's history.
Mike continues to give his thoughts on the country's response to the Coronavirus pandemic and how that meshes with sports coming back.
Mike talks about the New York Mets winning the World Series verse the Boston Red Sox in 1986 before WFAN replays game 7.
Mike reacts to the comments made by Dr. Fauci on the country not being ready to reopen its economy.
Mike continues to share his thoughts on the Coronavirus epidemic & what routes the country should take before "re-opening".
Mike opens a Thursday show with trying to find signs of optimism with the coronavirus about to reach its apex.
Mike opens a Wednesday show with the notion of getting back to normalcy, amid the CODVID-19 crisis.
Yankees Broadcasting legend Suzyn Waldman joins Mike to discuss the ongoing suspension of the MLB season and what the league may look like when we get back to baseball.
Former NFL exec Scott Piolo joins Mike Francesa to talk about the NFL, the upcoming draft and more.
Dr. Richard A. Shlofmitz, MD of St. Francis hospital in Long Island joins Mike Francesa to talk about the COVID-19 pandemic that has taken over Long Island.
Mike reflects on the legendary career of update anchor John Minko as he retired today after 30+ years at WFAN. Mike also talks about the role government should play during the current Coronavirus pandemic.
Mike continues to talk about the lasting impact of the Corona Virus and what we should expect going forward.
Mike continues to share his thoughts on the Coronavirus pandemic and how it is affecting every day life.
Mike Francesa had some sterns words Sunday morning for people who celebrated James Dolan's coronavirus diagnosis.
Mike talks with NFL executive Scott Pioli about the state of NFL teams going into the NFL draft which will still be held in April.
Mike discusses Noah Syndergaard's Tommy John surgery, changes to the WFAN weekend lineup and more.
Mike opens the lines to hear more from the tri-state area in regards to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Mike Francesa talks about the COVID-19 affect and takes calls from listeners to find out how it's changing our society.
Mike continues to talk about the effect of the coronavirus in life and in sports. He also talks about all the NFL Free Agency deals from today and the relationship between Tom Brady & Bill Belichick.
Mike talks about how the Covid-19 virus is effecting the world and it's impact on sports.
Mike Francesa hit's the airwaves for the first time since the suspension and cancellation of pro and college sports due to the COVID-19 virus.
Mike gives his thoughts on Edwin Diaz going into the season as the Mets closer, taking calls on the Mets, and previewing Seton Hall men's basketball taking on Villanove tonight.
Mike gives his thoughts on the James Dolan-Spike Lee situation as well as what he thinks the Knicks have done wrong in recent years. Mike also briefly talks about the Arnold Palmer Golf Tournament at Bay Hill this weekend & Tiger Woods not participating in it.
Mike talks about Leon Rose taking over as president of the Knicks and St John's win over Creighton.