Catholic Answers Live: Recent Episodes
Catholic Answers
Catholic Answers LIVE is a daily, call-in radio program of Catholic apologetics and evangelization airing live from 6-8 pm ET.
“Why Does It Take So Long to Become Catholic?” This question opens a discussion on the intricacies of the Catholic initiation process. Other topics include the concerns of a Jewish individual raised atheist who loves Jesus but hesitates to join the Church, and how Catholics can defend their faith without being apologists.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:29 – Why is the process to become Catholic so long?
- 14:13 – I’m Jewish but I was raised atheist. I love Jesus but I’m afraid to go to the Church.
- 29:14 – I struggle with defending the faith. How should a Catholic defend the faith without needing to be an apologist?
- 42:01 – Regarding Papal Infallibility in Vatican 1. What historical documents affirm this doctrine?
- 47:45 – I’m joining OCIA because of the Church fathers and apostolic succession. Do Episcopalian have apostolic succession?
- 49:58 – I’m reading the Early Church Father and I’m not Catholic because I’m trying to figure what my next step is.
“What keeps young people from going to Mass?” This question opens a discussion on the challenges faced by the younger generation in engaging with their faith. Other topics include the need for Vatican II, concerns about social dynamics in church communities, and the experiences of recent converts starting young adult groups.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:09 – What keeps young people from going to Mass?
- 17:14 – What was the need for Vatican 2?
- 29:05 – I’ve been trying to go to Mass but the people are weird and lack social awareness. Will I have friends if I join?
- 40:02 – I’m non-Denom. How can I be sure the Catholic faith didn’t make a change that led it off track?
- 49:23 – Recent convert. I started a YA group at my parish.
“Is Raphael lying to Tobias?” This question delves into the intriguing moment in Tobit where Raphael identifies himself in a way that raises doubts about honesty. Additionally, the discussion touches on the unique role of Peter in relation to the keys of the kingdom, the Ethiopian Bible, and the biblical foundations for Vatican II, showcasing a rich exploration of faith and scripture.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:13 – I was reading Tobit 5 where Raphael appears to Tobias and Tobias doesn’t recognize him as an angel. In v11 he asks what tribe he’s from, and Raphael replies saying he’s one of Tobias’ relatives. What’s going on here? It sounds like an angel is lying to Tobias.
- 16:14 – I’m a catechumen and kind of between Orthodoxy and Catholicism right now. When Jesus gives the keys to Peter, later in that chapter he gave the rest of the apostles to ability to bind and loose. Catholics say that they keys give the pope the ability to bind and loose, but if the rest of the apostles have that, what makes Peter unique?
- 28:43 – What do you know about the Ethiopian bible and the books of Enoch?
- 33:08 – What recommendations do you have to get a Catholic typological understanding of the bible?
- 42:23 – Is the scripture materially sufficient for salvation?
- 52:45 – What are the biblical bases for Vatican II and becoming modern?
“Why date John’s Gospel earlier than the modern consensus?” This question opens a discussion on the dating of biblical texts, alongside intriguing inquiries about the identity of Melchizedek and the implications of Genesis 1 regarding the Trinity. Other topics include the reality of dinosaurs in relation to the creation story and the reliability of different biblical texts.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:40 – Why do you date John’s Gospel earlier than the modern consensus?
- 17:27 – Gen 1 the Spirit is named and the Father is named but Jesus isn’t. Could the face of the waters be a reference to him?
- 32:07 – Who was Melchizedek and there an actual order based on him?
- 40:10 – Are dinosaurs real? Scientists say they lived like 70 million years ago. But that doesn’t seem to work with the creation story in Genesis, where the animals were created after Adam and Eve.
- 44:57 – In your video on the Ark of the Covenant, you said you believed the Ark was destroyed by the Babylonians. How could they have done that given the story of Uzzah, who just touched it and died?
- 50:00 – A Protestant told me that the Alexandrian texts of the Bible were not reliable because they were so far away geographically from the origin point that they would have been corrupted. I believe his conclusion was that therefore the King James Version is the only reliable version of the Bible. What do you make of this?
“How do Catholics handle the Eucharist?” This question leads to a discussion on the accommodations for those with gluten allergies. The conversation also touches on the conditions for papal infallibility, including the implications of Pope Benedict XVI’s resignation, and offers insights on evangelizing those who feel the Church distorts the Gospel.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:50 – How do Catholics handle the eucharist who has a gluten allergy?
- 18:00 – When is the pope infallible? When Pope Benedict XVI resigned did he still have infallibility? How does it all work?
- 24:10 – How can Catholics better evangelize those who think we distort the gospel?
- 40:00 – How do I become a better Catholic? I just returned to Church about 4 months ago.
“Are some saints better than others?” This question opens a discussion on the unique virtues of saints, while also addressing the journey of conversion for those considering joining the Catholic faith. Additional topics include the importance of knowledge in conversion and the complexities of reunifying with the Orthodox Church regarding apostolic succession.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:11 – Are some saints better than others at certain things?
- 30:47 – My husband and I are looking into converting. Should I wait till I know everything about Catholicism before entering?
- 43:47 – How would it work if we were to reunify with the Orthodox especially regarding apostolic succession since they do not have it through St. Peter?
“When should you receive the Anointing of the Sick?” This question is addressed alongside practical insights for recent converts grappling with Marian dogmas and a discussion on the implications of 2 John 1:1-2 regarding infallibility and sensus fidelium. The episode covers a range of topics relevant to faith and practice.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:18 – When is it appropriate to receive the anointing of the sick? Can one get it before surgery?
- 17:30 – What advice would you give to someone who just converted 4 months ago and is really struggling with the Marian dogmas?
- 41:40 – 2 John 1:1-2 Is this a good argument for infallibility and sensus fidelium?
“How can we trust early Christians?” This question opens a discussion on the reliability of early Christian teachings, alongside inquiries about the Catholic Church’s agreements with the Oriental Orthodox and the practice of seeking intercession from deceased loved ones. These topics highlight the complexities of faith and tradition in Catholicism.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:14 – How do we know which early Christians to trust?
- 20:20 – Do you think the Catholic Church’s agreement with the Oriental Orthodox on many doctrines is a good argument against Protestantism?
- 43:03 – Can you ask deceased family or friends for intercession even though they haven’t been canonized?
“Should new converts evangelize?” This question opens a discussion on the role of new believers in sharing their faith, addressing whether they can represent their parish right away. Other topics include the antiquity of Miriam’s song in Exodus, the timeline of the Torah’s final form during King David’s reign, and the interpretation of light patterns as signs from God.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:45 – I’m a new convert. Can new converts evangelize on behalf of a parish or are they required to wait till they’re not as new to the faith?
- 12:41 – Is Miriam’s song of the sea in Exodus 15:21 more ancient than what Exodus claims?
- 35:03 – What evidence led you to conclude that the Torah, in its final form, was concluded in the time of the reign of King David?
- 48:09 – Can you take things like light refracting on a wall that looks like a religious symbol as a sign from God or can it just be dismissed as one’s imagination?
“Why did Jesus tell Mary not to touch him?” This question opens a discussion on the significance of Jesus’ words to Mary Magdalene, alongside other topics such as the biblical basis for the timing of baptism in relation to faith and advice for someone navigating family dynamics during a conversion.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 08:16 – Why did Jesus tell Mary Magdalene to not touch him but told Thomas to touch him?
- 17:15 – The book of Acts shows that baptism happened immediately after display of faith but the Church makes people wait. Where does this idea of making people wait come from? Is it biblical?
- 41:00 – What advice would you give to my girlfriend who wants to convert but doesn’t know how to talk to her family who will likely not approve?
“What’s the evidence for Mary’s Assumption and its importance?” This question opens a discussion on the early Church’s beliefs about Mary’s Assumption, highlighting its significance in Catholic theology. Additional topics include the necessity of Mary’s Assumption for her role as Queen of Heaven and the intriguing concept of fetal microchimerism related to her life.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:44 – What’s the Evidence for the Assumption of Mary in the early Church?
- 13:03 – Why did Mary have to be assumed into heaven in order to be Queen of Heaven? Why is it essential for us to believe it?
- 17:09 – Regarding the Assumption, can you elaborate more on fetal micro chimerism ( the mother obtaining the child’s DNA throughout her life)?
- 22:14 – If Mary’s Assumption was a historical event, then why is there no physical evidence for this?
- 29:20 – My 7-year-old daughter is claiming to see Mary to the point where she says things that are naturally outside of knowledge. We are converts. Is this something that’s common and what should we do?
- 38:18 – How can I accept Mary as the Queen of Heaven?
- 46:59 – I’m no longer Catholic and have studied the bible. Where is Mary’s burial cloth? Why is Mary appointed queen of heaven and placed on a pedestal? No where in the bible does it say to pray to Mary.
“What’s the difference between celibacy and chastity?” This question opens a discussion on the distinct yet related concepts of celibacy and chastity, followed by inquiries about the challenges priests face in maintaining celibacy, the implications of priestly blessings, and the reasons behind the current shortage of priests.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:00 – What’s the difference between celibacy and chastity?
- 12:38 – I’m Lutheran. Why doesn’t the sacramental priesthood always produce good and holy priests?
- 21:23 – How do priests deal with celibacy? What do they do to distract themselves?
- 28:40 – What does it mean when something has been blessed by a priest? What does that do? What changes?
- 35:01 – Why do you think there is such a shortage of priests?
- 47:38 – How possible is it for an ordained baptist minister to become a Catholic priest?
“Can modern biblical criticism be accepted?” This question opens a discussion on the complexities of faith and interpretation, addressing concerns about how Catholics reconcile personal beliefs with Church teachings. Other topics include the significance of the Book of Enoch, the concept of Jesus having the odor of sanctity, and guidance for a teenager struggling with belief in God.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:32 – I sense that you didn’t answer Richard’s questions properly but instead framed it in a way where it was dismissed. I have the same questions, and it seems like dismissing scripture almost makes it seem as though it’s preaching a different gospel.
- 15:00 – I’m confused about the acceptance of modern biblical criticism. How much do Catholics have to believe personally and externally about the teachings of the Church?
- 28:50 – My friend who is Missouri Synod and asked me about the Bible of Enoch. I’ve never heard of this. What is it? What can I send her to read?
- 38:18 – Did Jesus have the odor of sanctity?
- 44:23 – My 16-year-old nephew is saying he doesn’t believe in God anymore. What advice do you have to help with showing God’s existence?
- 50:12 – Why was Mary able to marry Joseph but didn’t need to be open to life/ have relations with him for it to be considered valid?
“Why should secular people consider Catholicism?” This question opens a discussion on the relevance of faith in modern life, alongside inquiries about the different levels of heaven and how one might improve their standing. The conversation also addresses concerns about the role of repetitive prayers in Mass and the Church’s teachings on saints versus direct access to Jesus.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:10 – Why should secular people consider the Catholic faith?
- 17:28 – Are there different levels in heaven? If there is, how can you upgrade your position?
- 33:54 – The repetition prayers at mass bored me. Why don’t they teach the bible at mass? The bible says to go to Jesus not the saints. Why does the Church teach people to go to the saints instead of Jesus?
- 49:01 – I’m not Catholic because of the teaching on mortal sin and the inconsistencies. I don’t see how committing a sin like murder would necessarily cut off our relationship from God. His love is greater than that.
“Why Aren’t You Catholic?” addresses common concerns about the Catholic faith, including the feeling of not being forgiven in confession and the potential consequences in purgatory. The discussion also touches on the nature of the papacy and its divine intention, as well as misconceptions about a works-based gospel. Additionally, practical advice is offered for introducing friends to Catholicism.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:13 – I don’t go to Mass consistently. I don’t feel forgiven from confession. Are there purgatory consequences?
- 20:52 – How do we know Papacy in its current form is what God intended. It seems like Peter was supposed to be first among equals. Polycarp and Anicetus were equals.
- 28:46 – I’m Not Catholic Cause I think Catholics preach a different works-based gospel.
- 43:55 – My best friend is a bartender. What’s the best way to introduce my friend to catholic faith?
“Is there evidence for the papacy in early Church history?” This question addresses claims about the absence of papal evidence in the first 300 years of the Church, while also considering the authority of both Peter and Paul in Rome and the role of Ignatius in the early Church. Additionally, the discussion touches on the potential censorship of records by Constantine and the parallels between the Seat of Peter and the Davidic throne.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:56 – There’s a claim that there is no evidence for the papacy in the first 300 years of the Church. Is that true, and if there is, where do we find it?
- 11:32 – What about the claim that BOTH Peter and Paul were the authority in Rome?
- 15:15 – Protestants using Ignatius as evidence from the early church that there was no bishop in Rome.
- 22:49 – Did Constantine and the roman empire censor records to help spread the Christian faith?
- 31:17 – How does the Seat of Peter parallel the Davidic throne? Does this explain how the papacy can be valid with bad popes?
- 47:28 – How do we know that the apostles were bishops? Did they make the position of Bishop?
“What do you mean by ‘The Church’?” This episode addresses the Catholic understanding of the Church’s nature, while also tackling questions about gluttony, the complexities surrounding the SSPX, and the implications of mortal sin on salvation. Each topic sheds light on key aspects of Catholic faith and practice.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:45 – How do you define “The Church”? What is the Catholic understanding of what exactly the Church is?
- 08:19 – If I get “fourths” is that gluttony?
- 14:30 – I’m a Catholic struggling to resolve the viewed contradictions regarding the SSPX.
- 30:48 – You gave me some tips a few weeks ago for visiting a Mormon church and told me to call back and tell you how it went.
- 44:00 – How is the gospel good news if you can commit a mortal sin and lose salvation? What even is a mortal sin?
“Should Christians drink alcohol?” This question opens a discussion on the balance between moderation and faith, while also addressing related topics such as the implications of truth-telling and scandal, and the Vatican’s recent doctrinal notes on Marian titles. Other questions include the role of hope in salvation and the significance of confession for Protestants.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:28 – Should Christians drink alcohol?
- 15:07 – Can telling the truth be considered the spreading of scandal?
- 22:25 – Given the doctrinal notes given by the Vatican recently on the titles Mediatrix and Co-Redemptrix, does it affect our understanding of Marian consecration?
- 29:08 – I heard Karlo and Brayden recently talk about faith and charity and their role in salvation. What is the role of hope in relation to salvation?
- 35:03 – Should I attend a men’s event or my 35th anniversary?
- 40:31 – Why can’t a Protestant just decide to go to confession and get absolution?
- 46:46 – When making the sign of the cross, is it better to say Holy Spirit or Holy Ghost?
- 51:05 – Why wasn’t the sacrifice of Jesus done earlier? Why did God wait so many years to redeem us?
“How does the Bible view divorce?” This question opens a discussion on the complexities of marriage in light of Catholic teaching, including perspectives on divorce for non-Catholics and the interpretation of terms like porneia. Other topics include the permanence of marriage bonds and the implications of Vatican II on contemporary views of marriage.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:00 – Secrets from heaven
- 14:23 – I’m not Catholic. How does the bible and Catholicism view a person who has been divorced?
- 22:15 – Regarding the psalms. Why can’t they be updated? They just seem like random prayers.
- 30:14 – Does the term porneia refer to fornication and not just unlawful marriages?
- 39:45 – Jesus said let no man tear apart a marriage so how can a tribunal decide whether a bond actually occurred?
- 45:31 – Why does the defense of Vatican 2 seem like gas-lighting?
- 52:48 – Can seniors get married in the church even though they can’t produce children?
“What divided us from the Orthodox Church?” This question opens a discussion on the historical and theological rifts between Catholicism and Orthodoxy. The episode also addresses which non-Roman rite churches maintain apostolic succession, the validity of Orthodox sacraments despite schism, and how to respond to Eastern Orthodox interpretations of early Church Fathers regarding papal authority.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:26 – What originally divided us and the Orthodox Church?
- 11:00 – Which Churches outside of the Roman rite have apostolic succession and how are they traced? How are orthodox sacraments valid even though they are in schism?
- 18:23 – How do we respond to EO who use early church fathers on Matthew 16 and Isaiah 22 and claim it’s not about the papacy?
- 22:54 – What’s the difference between Orthodox Church and orthodox teaching?
- 28:51 – My brother married a Greek Orthodox woman. Does one have to be baptized in order to remarry there? I’m worried that he might have committed apostasy.
- 31:47 – Eph. 4 says to walk in unity. This episode is causing disunity by dissing the orthodox.
- 41:29 – The gates of hell will not prevail. If the Church were to proclaim error, what should the faithful do, go underground, go orthodox or what options would there be?
- 47:50 – I’m a southern Baptist. John 15 seems to support that the Holy Spirit proceeds only from the Father. Can you clarify?
- 51:35 – I recommend William and all his listeners to read the Alexandria document and the Chieti Document.
“Why are moral values and curiosity key to marriage?” These qualities significantly enhance long-term relationships by fostering deeper connections and understanding. The discussion also touches on the importance of morality in marriage, the Catholic Church’s stance on same-sex unions, and the role of religion in marital dynamics.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:00 – The new study found that general compatibility mattered a lot less than compatibility with regard to “moral values” and “curiosity.” Why are those two qualities so helpful for long term marriages?
- 17:35 – Can you expand on the morality part of the two qualities?
- 30:39 – Where does that Catholic Church stand on same sex unions?
- 36:42 – How does religion play into marriage?
“Is transhumanism a sin?” This question opens a discussion on the ethical implications of modern technology, including insights from the AI encyclical. The conversation also addresses whether IVF remains problematic, the Church’s stance on genetic engineering, and the complexities of recognizing AI as a unique life.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:30 – What is the main takeaway about transhumanism/ posthumanism from the AI encyclical.
- 16:00 – Is IVF still bad?
- 23:10 – Anthropology proves we come from apes. I don’t believe in Adam and Eve. How do you explain that?
- 34:28 – What does the Church say about genetic engineering and implants?
- 41:38 – At what level of advancement would the Church recognize AI as an individual unique life and baptize it?
- 45:28 – If a woman is able to undergo a procedure where she has her eggs frozen and later reimplanted without any damage to them or her, would this be ethical?
- 51:59 – Should we throw out the idea of humans coming from apes since we haven’t found any intermediate step between us and them?
“Do Catholics believe in the rapture?” This question opens a discussion on Catholic eschatology, addressing where the idea of the rapture originated and its connection to dispensationalism. The conversation also touches on the Illumination of Conscience, the concept of the Antichrist, and the significance of the mark of the beast, providing a comprehensive look at these intriguing topics.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:30 – Do Catholics believe in the rapture?
- 15:07 – Where did the idea of the Rapture come from?
- 16:26 – What is dispensationalism, and is it ancient or a modern invention?
- 21:10 – What is the Illumination of Conscience (or “the Warning”)? What is it, and when might it happen?
- 29:10 – The Three Days of Darkness—what is it, and does the Church require belief in it?
- 34:29 – What—or who—is the Antichrist?
- 44:50 – What does “666,” the mark of the beast, actually mean?
- 51:25 – As Catholics, what are we supposed to do with all this? Should we be afraid?
“Are we living in the end times right now—the ‘last days’?” This question opens a discussion on the signs that may precede Jesus’ return, alongside insights into Catholic beliefs about the Book of Revelation and whether Jesus got the end-of-the-world prophecies wrong. The conversation covers a range of perspectives on these significant topics.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:59 – Are we living in the end times right now—the “last days”?
- 14:40 – What are the signs that will precede the return of Jesus?
- 34:58 – What do Catholics believe about the Book of Revelation? Is it a coded timeline of the future?
- 48:00 – Did Jesus Get the End-of-the-World Prophecies Wrong?
“Why is it necessary to follow the Church’s sexual ethics?” This question opens a discussion on the Church’s role in personal morality, addressing concerns about authority and its relevance in private life. Other topics include the differing views on birth control among Protestants and the canonical processes for those engaged in SSPX chapels.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:44 – Why is it necessary to follow the Church Sexual ethics? Why is the Church in my bedroom?
- 13:47 – Why don’t protestants think birth control is immoral?
- 29:16 – I got engaged in February and I am a parishioner of an SSPX chapel. I do not have schismatic intent and wondering if there is a canonical process for a situation like mine?
- 36:40 – To get conversation going I play trivia with people. I ask them about the last supper, then proceed to ask about the last breakfast and last lunch. Do you think this is a good approach to evangelize?
- 43:50 – How do we know the apostles gave their authority to their successors?
“Why trust God when He doesn’t answer prayers?” This question opens a discussion on faith and hope amidst silence. Other topics include guidance for those entering Catholicism and the challenges of parenting after separation, as well as navigating personal barriers in pursuing God’s work. Each question reflects the complexities of faith in everyday life.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:00 – Why should we have faith in God’s promises when he often doesn’t answer our prayers?
- 16:12 – I’m on my way to becoming Catholic. I have a desire to get into apologetics. Not sure how I listen to God through this. Advice?
- 30:03 – My wife has left me and 3 kids. Am I leading astray by guiding them to pray and hope that mom will return?
- 36:23 – I want to continue the work God started in me but every time I start working towards it, barriers always come up. What do you recommend I do?
- 39:54 – What do you think of Phil. 1:6 in light of our journey from start to finish?
Despite declining fertility rates, many young individuals still hold onto these aspirations of parenthood. Some find this shocking. Additionally, the discussion touches on what Pope Leo might consider for his next encyclical, highlighting the evolving nature of family and faith in contemporary society.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:45 – Even as Fertility Rates Drop, Young Still Aspire to Partnership and Parenthood, UN Report Shows
- 28:35 – What Should Pope Leo Do for His Next Encyclical?
“Does the world really need more silence?” This question opens a discussion on the importance of quiet in our lives, alongside insights on navigating rudeness in an increasingly digital age. The conversation also touches on the surprising stance of Catholic Answers regarding piano and the implications of Norway’s near ban on AI in elementary schools.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:15 – Does the world really need more silence?
- 16:00 – How Not to Be Rude in 2026
- 34:55 – Catholic Answers Comes Out Against Piano
- 49:00 – Norway Imposes Near Ban on AI in Elementary School
“What did the early church believe about the Eucharist?” This question opens a discussion on foundational beliefs, while also addressing the serious implications of Church teaching on moral responsibilities, such as the obligation to care for those in need, and the perceived disparities in how the Church treats traditional versus liberal interpretations of faith.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:45 – What did the early church believe about the Eucharist?
- 16:23 – The Catechism says it’s a mortal sin to let a child die of starvation if you have the financial means to feed them. I don’t know anyone who does this. Is this really Church teaching?
- 32:40 – Why does it seem that the Church is coming down unfairly on those who hold a more orthodox/traditional stance of church teaching and allows those who take a more liberal take on the faith run freely?
“Why can’t women be priests?” This question opens a discussion on the role of women in the Church, alongside inquiries about how transgender individuals can feel welcomed in Catholicism and the negative perceptions of the Church within the LGBTQ community. Additional topics include defending the Immaculate Conception and addressing marriage preparation with unmarried priests.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:13 – Why can’t women be priests?
- 12:25 – How does a transgender person feel welcomed in the Catholic Church?
- 20:35 – Why is there such a negative view of Catholicism among the LGBTQ community?
- 30:20 – What advice do you recommend to defend the Immaculate Conception?
- 41:12 – How do I explain to someone why we have to go to a priest, who will never be married, to take marriage preparation classes?
- 45:54 – How do I respond to fellow practicing Catholics who agree on all teaching except for the teachings on homosexuality because they have family with same-sex attractions?
“Where is apostolic succession in the Bible?” This question opens a discussion on the biblical foundations of church leadership, alongside inquiries about the celibacy of bishops and priests, the distinctions between ordination and consecration, and the roles of different levels of clergy. Each topic sheds light on the structure and traditions of the Catholic Church.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:09 – Where is apostolic Succession in the bible?
- 17:39 – Why did the Catholic Church decide to have bishops and priests be celibate, especially when that wasn’t the case with the first pope?
- 28:45 – What is the difference between ordination and consecration? I hear about priests being ordained and bishops being consecrated. Is there a difference?
- 36:30 – The Levels of clergy and what each of them do
- 43:25 – If any Catholic male can be a pope, but they first must be made a bishop, does that mean they skip being a priest?
“Can we lose our salvation?” This question opens a discussion on the Catholic understanding of faith and grace, addressing concerns about the nature of salvation. Other topics include the idea of being saved and lost repeatedly, responses to claims about prophecy and salvation, and the implications of Matthew 7:21-23 for believers.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:00 – Can we lose our salvation?
- 06:15 – Are we just saved and lost over and over again? How do Catholics view this? How does it work in the day to day?
- 16:00 – My brother is talking to his protestant friend who claimed you lose your salvation if you don’t accept the prophecy from a current pastor. How does one respond to that?
- 22:00 – I’m a convert, what does salvation mean from the Catholic position?
- 31:22 – I’m protestant and believe you can not lose your salvation. Missing sunday service doesn’t cause you to lose salvation.
- 50:45 – Regarding Matthew 7:21-23 Not everyone who says Lord, Lord… What does this quote mean for salvation?
“Why do Catholics believe in no divorce when Jesus says that there is an exception for sexual immorality?” This question opens a discussion on the Church’s teachings about marriage, alongside inquiries about the idea of the gift of tears experienced during Mass, the implications of Bishop Gasser’s relatio on doctrinal decisions, and the validity of baptisms in diverse church contexts.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 00:01 – Why do Catholics believe in no divorce when Jesus says that there is an exception for sexual immorality?
- 14:48 – Is the gift of tears real? I had an experience of crying for no reason at Pentecost Mass this year?
- 28:40 – Does Bishop Gasser’s relatio necessitate many ex cathedra doctrinal decisions in the past?
- 40:58 – I grew up in a oneness church, where some believed in the Trinity; others did not. For baptism, if the two people in the church involved in the baptism believed in the Trinity and baptized in the trinitarian formula, would that baptism be valid?
- 45:25 – If we hold Mary to be the most exalted creature, how do we handle Matthew 11:11 that says no one born of woman is greater than John the Baptist?
“What is schism and heresy?” These concepts are explored alongside questions about the nature of sin and forgiveness, including how a priest forgives sins. The discussion also touches on the implications of making a slasher movie, the fate of souls after death, and the role of guardian angels, providing a comprehensive look at these important topics.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:15 – What is Schism and Heresy?
- 18:23 – Is it objective grave matter to make a slasher movie?
- 30:30 – How does it work for a priest to forgive sins?
- 32:35 – My atheist friend is asking where are people who have died? If Christ hasn’t come to judge yet then they couldn’t be in heaven or hell.
- 38:30 – Would it be a stretch to say that Saint Paul might have wrote the first few chapters of Hebrews, with one of his followers finishing it after he was executed?
- 46:15 – What happens to your guardian angel when you die?
- 49:13 – Why do Catholics believe in no divorce when Jesus says that there is an exception for sexual immorality?
“Are we transported to the Cross at every Mass?” This question opens a discussion about the profound connection between the Eucharist and Christ’s sacrifice. The conversation also addresses whether the SSPX can consecrate bishops without approval, the meaning of the word “Mass,” and a simple explanation of consecration for those seeking clarity.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:40 – Are we literally transported at the foot of the cross at mass?
- 14:20 – Is it true that the SSPX should be able to consecrate bishops without approval because that’s how it was done before Vatican II?
- 25:00 – What does the word Mass mean?
- 36:18 – I struggle with understanding what the word consecration means? I need it explained to me in a very elementary way.
“Can I attend an SSPX Mass?” This question opens a discussion on the complexities of attending Mass at an SSPX chapel, alongside inquiries about the significance of the altar’s elevation, the implications of not attending Sunday Mass, and the historical context of Latin Mass celebrations. The episode addresses various aspects of Catholic worship and practice.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:40 – Can I go to Mass at an SSPX chapel?
- 11:29 – Why is the altar elevated and the people in the pews tend to sit lower? Does that mean the people are lower than the priest?
- 16:32 – What can be done where all churches would have the option to celebrate the Latin Mass? Was Summorum Pontificum retracted?
- 21:07 – Can you explain why it’s a mortal sin not to attend Sunday Mass?
- 29:04 – Are we supposed to make the sign of the cross after praying the confiteor?
- 32:24 – During Covid, Masses were shut down. Was this something historical where the mass was shut down?
- 35:05 – I’m a new Catholic. Should we be raising our hands during the Our Father?
- 38:55 – How is it called a Traditional Latin Mass if it started in Aramaic and Greek?
- 44:14 – Can you receive communion with venial sin on your soul? What if you receive communion without realizing you had committed a mortal sin?
- 47:55 – What if one can’t find a Latin mass outside of SSPX? Where should they go?
- 51:30 – I believe the hand holding during Our Father did not start as imitating the priest but became natural after a retreat.
Questions Covered:
- 04:15 – What is the theology of the body and why do I always here about it?
- 13:54 – Is it a sin to avoid news or social media because it disturbs my peace?
- 20:15 – Is something wrong if i don’t feel anything during mass or prayer?
- 29:23 – Is it okay to pray while distracted?
- 33:29 – What do I do when I keep falling into the same sin and feel numb about it?
- 39:30 – Can I fantasize about my own spouse?
- 44:40 – Could an AI ever be culpable for sin?
- 49:30 – If God already knows what I’m going to do, what is the point of prayer?
Questions Covered:
- 01:37 – How can I tell the difference between mental illness and genuine spiritual attack?
- 06:15 – What’s wrong with the Oiji board
- 12:40 – Can non-catholics come to the Catholic Church for help combat demonic activity?
- 14:40 – Tarot cards, crystals
- 21:33 – What do demons do? Temptation, infestation, …
- 23:35 – Infestation
- 33:33 – Obsession
- 36:00 – Posession
- 39:40 – Top 3 things you can do to avoid posession
- 43:25 – Generational curses
- 47:00 – Are ghosts real?
- 51:45 – What’s the difference between superstition and faith?
“How Is Mary the Mother of God?” This question opens a discussion on the significance of Mary in Catholic theology, including her role in Revelation 12 and the implications of Matthew 1:25 regarding her relationship with Joseph. Other topics include the biblical foundations for the Immaculate Conception and the Assumption, as well as addressing concerns about Marian apparitions.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:50 – I’m a former non-denom. Mary is why I became Catholic. Does the Church see a connection between Rev 12. And Mary giving birth to God on earth?
- 11:40 – Can you elaborate on Matthew 1:25 and why it doesn’t mean that Mary and Joseph eventually had relations?
- 18:20 – What biblical evidence is there for Immaculate Conception and the Assumption?
- 29:30 – Can you help me understand the recent document that backed off the idea of Mary as Mediatrix?
- 35:49 – My aunt says Marian apparitions are demonic. We tell her Mary always points to her son, but she doesn’t listen. How can we reach her?
- 43:00 – Where is the Immaculate Conception rooted in the Bible?
- 48:30 – Why do Catholics say the prayer, “Jesus, Mary, and Joseph, we love you. Save souls.” Mary and Joseph don’t save souls. Jesus does.
“Should we pray to Mary?” This question opens a discussion on the role of Mary in Catholicism, addressing biblical support for praying to her and the concept of mediatorship. Other topics include the significance of Mary’s titles, the Immaculate Conception, and the belief in her perpetual virginity, providing a comprehensive look at Marian devotion.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:25 – Where does the Bible say we should pray to Mary?
- 05:30 – Isn’t Jesus the one mediator between God and man?
- 10:20 – If Mary was sinless, why did she need a savior?
- 14:35 – Where is the Immaculate Conception in the Bible?
- 18:55 – Why do Catholics give Mary titles that seem to belong only to Jesus?
- 21:25 – Doesn’t calling Mary “Mother of God” make her sound like a goddess?
- 30:00 – Didn’t Mary have other children after Jesus? Why do Catholics say Mary remained a virgin if the Bible mentions Jesus’ brothers and sisters?
- 44:32 – Why do Catholics kneel before statues of Mary?
- 48:25 – Isn’t the rosary vain repetition?
- 51:00 – Why ask Mary to pray for us when we can go directly to God?
“Why did Jesus have to die for our sins?” This question opens a discussion on the necessity of Christ’s sacrifice, addressing whether God could have chosen another path for forgiveness. The conversation also touches on Calvin’s view of predestination and resources for understanding salvation from a Catholic perspective, along with a variety of other intriguing questions.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:46 – Why did Jesus have to die for our sins? Couldn’t God have forgiven us another way?
- 10:44 – Can you explain Calvin’s understanding of predestination and if we still disagree with what he taught?
- 16:21 – Is there a resource that gives a clear total overall understanding of salvation from the Catholic perspective?
- 23:30 – Lightning round questions
- 48:08 – I think everything you are saying aligns with the protestant view of absolute corruption. Am I wrong on this?
“Can we be saved by faith alone?” This question opens a discussion on the nature of salvation, touching on key concepts such as what salvation truly means. The conversation also addresses the relationship between Scripture and tradition, and explores the idea of “once saved, always saved,” providing a comprehensive look at these important theological topics.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:40 – What is Salvation?
- 15:55 – Can we be saved by faith alone?
- 35:15 – I’m reformed presbyterian and looking into Catholic. Regarding. CCC 74-82. Does one need to view scripture and tradition on equal footing in order to have salvation?
- 44:05 – Once Saved Always Saved
“Does the Bible teach the invocation of saints?” This question opens a discussion on the role of saints in Catholic belief, alongside inquiries about the end of animal sacrifice in Scripture, the presence of archangels, and the interpretation of 2 Corinthians 5:8 regarding Purgatory. The conversation also touches on the differences in Gospel accounts of Judas’s betrayal.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:05 – Does the Bible teach the invocation of saints?
- 13:30 – Where in the Bible is the end of animal sacrifice? And why was it ended?
- 20:15 – Where are the archangels in the Bible?
- 23:58 – Matthew, Mark, and Luke all have Judas kissing Jesus. John does not. Which one is true?
- 32:55 – 2 Cor.5:8 says to be absent with the body is to be present with Christ. Do protestants think that they all go to heaven? What about Purgatory?
- 41:35 – Is the Deuterocanon read in the same way the rest of the Old Testament is?
- 48:32 – Regarding Isaiah 37:36 records the siege of Jesusalem by the Assyrians. Was the Angel that was sent to save Jerusalem actually a pharaoh from Egypt? Is it possible that the bible recorded the pharaoh and his army as an angel from God?
“What book had the most controversy?” This question leads to a discussion about the canon’s acceptance, alongside inquiries about the historical evidence for the papacy beyond key scripture, the appropriateness of having a menorah in a Catholic home, and the reasons behind variations in biblical translations.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:35 – What book in the canon had the most controversy about its acceptance?
- 16:21 – I’m considering Catholicism but am not convinced by the historical and scriptural evidence for the papacy. Beyond Matthew 16 and Luke 22, what is the strongest evidence that the early church recognized the papacy?
- 20:45 – The book of Exodus mentions a menorah. It’s not necessarily a Catholic symbol, but since it’s in the Bible is it okay to have a menorah in your house?
- 29:20 – Why is Matthew 17:20 (“But this kind is not cast out but by prayer and fasting”) excluded from certain translations? The Douay Rheims has it and the RSV-CE does not. And how might that affect the nihil obstat?
- 36:33 – Why do people think Catholics worship Mary?
- 43:25 – Is there any truth to the claim that ancient Jews thought there were two powers in heaven? They cite Genesis referring to “us.”
- 51:00 – How do I answer when people say that Jesus didn’t judge, especially in regard to immoral behavior?
“What makes music sacred?” This question opens a discussion on the role of music in worship, touching on the significance of chant sheets for altar servers at the Traditional Latin Mass and the relationship between sacred music and faith. Additional topics include recommendations for finding chant resources and the belief that sacred music must stem from a genuine faith.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:00 – What makes music sacred?
- 30:15 – I altar serve at the TLM and have a hard time chant sheets. Where do you recommend I find them?
- 36:35 – Would you agree that sacred music has to be a product of faith?
“Why only the Eucharist?” addresses the Church’s practice of offering the Eucharist without the precious blood, providing clarity for those exploring Catholicism. The discussion also touches on why God allows conception outside of marriage and the implications of mortal sin on salvation, offering a range of perspectives on these important topics.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:20 – I was raised southern baptist and looking into Catholicism. Why does the Church only give the people only the eucharist but not the precious blood?
- 20:10 – I’m a fallen-away-Catholic. Why does God allow people to be conceived outside of marriage?
- 28:40 – If a Catholic commits a mortal sin and dies instantly, can they go to heaven. What are your thoughts on why?
“Why did God choose the Jews?” This question opens a discussion on divine selection and purpose, while also addressing intriguing topics such as the nature of our eternal souls and the implications of finding Masonic symbols in a Catholic cemetery. Additionally, the conversation touches on the value of remaining Catholic amidst insights from Orthodoxy and the role of reproduction in Catholic natural law.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:00 – If our souls are eternal, were our souls in a waiting tank waiting for us to be born?
- 11:25 – Why did God choose the Jews out of all people and places in the world?
- 21:18 – I recently found a gravestone at a Catholic cemetery with the logo on the freemasons. I have been communicating with the people in charge and they refused to do anything about it because it’s considered private property. I don’t know what to do because I was looking into a plot there myself. What should my next step be?
- 28:32 – I feel like I’m getting more insights from Orthodoxy. Why should I remain Catholic?
- 35:35 – Someone argued that successful reproduction is the highest intrinsic good because it is humanity’s natural purpose. What does Catholic natural law think about this?
“How do I respond to anti-Catholic claims?” This question opens a discussion on the necessity of physical church participation, addressing concerns raised by non-Catholic family members. Additional topics include the next steps for a young believer not ready for OCIA, and the qualifications for being in a state of grace, providing a well-rounded exploration of faith and doctrine.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:35 – My mom is not Catholic and said the Church is merely spiritual so being a part of a physical church is not needed. How do I respond to this?
- 15:32 – I’m 17 and have come to believe in the Catholic faith. I’m not in a position to join OCIA right now. What is my next step?
- 29:00 – Who qualifies us as being in the state of Grace? Who decides that?
- 40:50 – Why did God choose Jacob over Esau?
- 49:00 – Is the Mass a perpetual sacrifice? I see 2 teachings on this in the Church that contradict. When did the wrong teaching creep into the Church?
“What do you tell someone who says my faith is faltering?” This question opens a discussion on the importance of prayer and support during challenging times. Additional topics include how to help a family member who has left the Catholic faith, advice for someone drifting away from their practice, and addressing concerns about the Bible’s portrayal of women.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:37 – What do you tell someone who says my faith is faltering?
- 15:42 – Someone in my family lost their Catholic faith and went to a non-denominational church. What can I do to help bring them back?
- 19:13 – I recommend people keep praying even though they might not feel like it.
- 23:45 – I’ve drifted away from practicing my faith. How did you come back? Do you have any advice for me?
- 31:20 – My 16 year old daughter is leaving the faith because she sees the Bible as not respecting women.
- 43:45 – I’m starting to explore Catholicism, but I feel like I’m getting stuck on the intellectual aspect. How do I make room for the faith side of things?
- 48:58 – What would you say to someone sympathetic to the SSPX in their current situation?
“Why do we lose people raised pro-life to the pro-choice side?” This question opens a discussion on the complexities of belief and autonomy in the abortion debate. Other topics include the argument that bodily autonomy supersedes the right to life and the moral implications of abortion in cases of rape or incest.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:25 – Why do we lose people raised pro-life to the prochoice side?
- 11:10 – I think that bodily autonomy supersedes the right to life.
- 17:38 – I am pro-choice because we should be able to allow women to abort in the case of rape or incest.
- 29:15 – Obviously you think abortion is murder. Do you think women who have had abortions should be charged with the same crimes as murderers?
- 44:25 – This issue is what drove me away from the Catholic faith. Until the zygote is viable as a human being, it is not a human being.
Who was Venerable Fulton Sheen, and why does his life continue to inspire Catholics around the world? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Msgr. Jason Gray explores the remarkable life and legacy of one of America’s most influential Catholic evangelists. Discover how Sheen became a radio and television pioneer, earned the respect of Protestant audiences, championed the missions, and approached politics through the lens of the Gospel. The conversation also explains the Church’s beatification process, the meaning of titles like Servant of God, Venerable, and Blessed, how miracles are investigated, and the evidence behind the miracle attributed to Sheen’s intercession. Finally, the episode reflects on what Sheen’s beatification means for the Church in America and where listeners can continue learning about his life and teachings.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:25 – Who was Fulton Sheen?
- 04:15 – How did Sheen become a radio and tv star?
- 09:30 – How did Sheen’s protestant audience view and think of him?
- 13:20 – The beautification process for Sheen
- 15:27 – Sheen and the Missions
- 17:25 – Sheen’s view of politics
- 21:50 – What would Sheen think of Catholic media today?
- 24:58 – How did Sheen get into media?
- 31:57 – What was Sheen’s process of creating episodes of “Life is Worth Living.”
- 33:49 – How does the Pope figure out who can be beautified?
- 36:50 – What is the difference between Servant of God, venerable, and Blessed
- 37:50 – How decide if something is a miracle or not?
- 43:40 – What was the particular miracle performed by Sheen and what is the evidence for it?
- 49:50 – What does Sheen’s beautification mean to the United States and the world?
- 52:25 – Where can I go to know more about Fulton Sheen?
This Flannel Panel was recorded during the Catholic Answers Cruise on the Rhine River earlier this year.
What is the Catholic sense of America, and how should Catholics understand the nation’s history, heritage, and future? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, the conversation explores American identity through a Catholic lens, including the experience of encountering American heritage for the first time, whether God is finished with America, and how Catholics should evaluate classical liberalism. The episode also reflects on the American perspective of the world and what faith can contribute to a more truthful and hopeful vision of the country.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:00 – The Catholic Sense of America.
- 11:00 – Experiencing American heritage for the first time.
- 20:38 – Is God finished with America?
- 29:00 – Classical liberalism is a good
- 47:55 – American perspective of the world
How has America done after 250 years, and what role has Christianity—especially Catholicism—played in shaping the nation’s ideals? In this special episode of Catholic Answers Live, Dr. Chad Pecknold reflects on the 250th anniversary of the United States, examining the country’s founding principles through a Catholic lens. The discussion explores whether July 4 is truly America’s birthday, how Catholic thought influenced the concept of inalienable rights, and whether America could reach its fullest potential by embracing the Catholic faith. The episode concludes with an intriguing look at the theory that the Cold War helped preserve American unity and what that might mean for the nation’s future.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:00 – How are we doing as a country after 250 years?
- 14:50 – Is the 4th of July the actual birth date of the U.S.?
- 23:00 – How has Catholicism influenced the idea of inalienable rights?
- 30:00 – Does America becoming a Catholic country mean she has reached her fullest potential?
- 47:50 – The theory that the Cold War actually kept America together.
“How do you make a good confession?” This question opens a discussion on the essential elements of confession and the role of grace in overcoming sin. Additionally, the conversation addresses the challenges faced by Protestants regarding sin and the struggles of Catholics dealing with habitual sin, providing a comprehensive view of these important topics.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 21:20 – How do you make a good confession?
- 29:50 – If you’re Catholic you have confession but where does that leave protestants who struggle with sin? What happens with Catholics who can’t get over habitual sin?
“Why be courteous if Jesus wasn’t?” This question opens a discussion on the importance of courtesy in faith and dialogue, addressing how to approach sensitive topics, such as when a child chooses a different faith. Other questions include whether Jesus ever invited rather than commanded and the appropriateness of lending a rosary to someone of a different faith at a vigil.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:30 – Why do we always have to be courteous when Jesus wasn’t always courteous?
- 37:00 – My son was raised Catholic and now wants to become Muslim. How do I approach him with courtesy?
- 46:43 – Did Jesus ever invite someone to do something instead of commanding them?
- 50:42 – I’m attending a vigil. Would It be a courtesy to lend a rosary to a jewish woman for the vigil?
“Are guardian angels real?” This question opens a discussion on their biblical mentions and the belief that every person, including non-Christians, may have one. Other topics include the fate of a guardian angel after their charge dies, the nature of angels and time, and the appropriateness of praying to saints or angels.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:15 – So on the topic of angels who can actually help us — are guardian angels real? Are they ever mentioned in the Bible?
- 07:50 – Does every single person have a guardian angel? Or only the baptized, or only children, or only the holy?
- 10:55 – What about non-Christians — an atheist, a Hindu, someone who’s never heard the name of Christ? Do they have a guardian angel too?
- 13:15 – When the person they’re guarding dies, what happens to a guardian angel? Do they get reassigned — ‘recycled,’ so to speak — onto a new baby?
- 17:50 – Why do you think angels haven’t fallen again?
- 24:15 – Do angels experience time as in having a before, now and later?
- 32:25 – I know angels have gender. Does the gender of our guardian angels correspond to our gender?
- 35:48 – When God told Moses to build the ark with Seraphim on it, how did Moses know what a Seraphim looked like?
- 41:19 – What is appropriate or not appropriate when praying to saints or angels? Are we asking them to actually do something for us, or just asking them to pass on our request to God?
- 45:00 – Can we name our guardian angels? Plenty of well-meaning Catholics do exactly that.
- 50:01 – If everything you’ve said is true — that every one of us is surrounded, right now, by powerful, personal, tireless servants of God who love us and want to get us safely home — how should knowing the angels are real change the way a Catholic prays, faces temptation, and meets death?
“Are angels real?” This question opens a discussion about their nature and purpose, addressing whether they are merely symbolic representations of God’s presence. The conversation also touches on the relevance of angels in our lives today and explores the distinction between angels and humans, including the popular belief that deceased loved ones become angels.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:35 – Let’s start at the bottom of the ladder. Are angels real, or are they symbolic ways of talking about God’s presence?
- 06:10 – So okay — if angels are real, can we just ignore them and get on with our lives? If they don’t do much nowadays, why should I care?
- 11:35 – Let’s define our terms cleanly. What exactly is an angel — and how much of what we believe comes from Scripture, versus theological speculation?
- 14:55 – Here’s one everyone has heard at a funeral: that grandma is an angel now, watching over us — that we get our wings when we die. Do human beings become angels when they die?
- 19:00 – Have angels always existed alongside God, or were they created like everything else?
- 23:00 – If angels are bodiless spirits, then how do we get all these accounts of angels appearing, speaking, even sharing a meal? How does a spirit with no body show up and get
- 29:25 – Roughly how many angels are there? Are we talking about a handful of major players, or something vaster — are there more angels or more humans?
- 34:45 – Most people have heard there are nine choirs of angels — seraphim, cherubim, archangels, and so on. Where does that come from, and what are these nine choirs of angels?
- 49:20 – We’ve talked a lot about praying to saints on this show — but why should we specifically pray to angels? Isn’t that more dangerous? Let’s steelman it. Twice in Revelation, John falls down to worship an angel, and both times the angel stops him cold and says, ‘Worship God.’ Paul warns the Colossians against the worship of angels. In light of all that, why would we ever pray to an angel?
- 53:10 – How do we even know angels can hear us?
“Are Christians just Protestants?” This question opens a discussion on the diverse identities within Christianity, addressing misconceptions about faith. The conversation also touches on whether Jesus had blood-relative brothers and the Catholic understanding of Mary’s perpetual virginity, alongside the differences between Catholic and Orthodox beliefs regarding the Immaculate Conception.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:15 – Are people who call themselves Christian just protestants?
- 05:35 – My Protestant friend said Jesus had blood-relative brothers. I said if that were true, Jesus would not have entrusted Mary to John’s care at the foot of the cross. Was that a good defense?
- 16:10 – I’m protestant. The bible says Jesus had brothers so how do Catholics come to the conclusion that Mary was a virgin all her life?
- 35:00 – I’m Eastern Orthodox. What is the Catholic argument for the Immaculate conception rather than the Orthodox believe in the Dispassionate Conception, and the Catholic belief in original sin versus the Orthodox idea of ancestral sin.
- 51:43 – What covenant did Jesus fulfill?
“Why does it matter if Mary is sinless?” This question opens a discussion on the significance of Marian doctrines in Catholic faith. The conversation also touches on early church beliefs regarding Mary’s perpetual virginity, responses to biblical passages that challenge her sinlessness, and how to cultivate a personal relationship with Mary and the saints.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:05 – Why does it matter for a catholic to believe Mary is sinless
- 13:05 – Did the early church believe in the perpetual virginity of Mary or is that a doctrine that developed over time.
- 17:07 – My Protestant friend cites Luke 2:48 (where Mary asks Jesus how he could do that to them at the finding in the Temple) to show she is not sinless.
- 23:40 – How can I have a more personal relationship with Mary, or other saints? Is that even possible in the same way it is with Jesus?
- 32:55 – My evangelical friends object to papal statements that say people who deny certain Marian doctrines are outside the faith. They say this is adding additional criteria for salvation. How do I respond?
- 42:50 – In John 20 Christ tells Mary Magdalen not to touch him because he hasn’t risen to his Father yet. But later he tells Thomas to touch him. Why the different answers?
- 46:30 – I’m about to start OCIA. I want to lean more into a relationship with Mary. But I grew up in an Evangelical background, and it feels strange. I keep on thinking about how I need to make sure I’ve giving more reverence to Jesus.
- 52:38 – How is it that Jesus and Mary could experience the effects of original sin when they didn’t have original sin?
“Can you explain the Assumption?” This question opens a discussion on the Marian dogmas, addressing common struggles with understanding them. The episode also touches on discerning the differences between Orthodox and Catholic beliefs regarding Peter’s role, as well as the Catholic teaching on the death penalty and its evolution under Pope Francis.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:25 – I have been looking into the Catholic Faith for a while. I have struggled with the Marian dogmas, especially the Assumption.
- 17:34 – How do you discern whether or not the Orthodox or Catholics are correct, specifically whether or not Peter is first among equals or infallible?
- 29:55 – Why is it that Catholics say you can’t spread ashes, but when it comes to saints you divide up their body parts?
- 35:37 – Can you explain the Catholic teaching on the death penalty? Did it change with Pope Francis?
- 41:35 – I am sympathetic to Catholic traditions and have tried to go through OCIA. But my husband has decided that our family is not going to be Catholic. I want to be a respectful spouse.
- 50:58 – I’m trying to love my wife back into the faith. She was raised Catholic but stopped practicing. She goes to a Protestant church where the sermons are peppered with anti-Catholic remarks. I think this creates a major barrier for a lot of people to become Catholic.
“What obstacles keep us from healthy relationships?” This question opens a discussion on the challenges individuals face in becoming marriage-ready, alongside insights on how media representations can influence perceptions of relationships. Other topics include the moral considerations of premarital intimacy for older couples and the implications of annulment on family planning.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:40 – What obstacles keep people from being marriage ready?
- 31:38 – I’ve noticed in a lot of media relationships are not portrayed in a healthy way. What would be good to see in stories and shows to model healthy relationships?
- 36:55 – My friend is a widower and is now dating a widow. He asked if it is a sin to have premarital sex in old age and in their circumstance?
- 49:21 – I’ve been married for 8 years and am going through the annulment process for my previous marriage. Should we wait until that annulment is complete before we try to conceive a child?
“What makes Isaiah’s prophecies unique?” Isaiah’s writings from the 700s B.C. present some of the first clear and explicit predictions of the Messiah, including titles like “Wonderful Counselor” and “Prince of Peace.” Additionally, the discussion touches on how Daniel 7 influenced Jewish expectations of the Messiah and addresses objections regarding Jesus’ fulfillment of these prophecies.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 00:30 – You point to Isaiah, writing in the 700s B.C., as providing the first clear and explicit prophecies of the Messiah: “Wonderful Counselor, Mighty God, Everlasting Father, Prince of Peace.” What makes these passages different from what came before?
- 20:15 – Some Jews read Daniel 7 and concluded that the Messiah would be a heavenly “Son of Man,” hidden with God before creation. That later became Jesus’ favorite title for himself. What would that title have communicated to his original audience?
- 34:00 – One major Jewish objection is that Jesus did not establish universal peace, restore the Davidic throne in Jerusalem, or complete everything associated with the messianic age. How can Christians say he fulfilled the prophecies?
- 42:45 – A skeptic might respond that Jesus intentionally acted out certain prophecies or that the Gospel writers shaped their narratives to make him appear to fulfill them. How much of the evidence can those explanations account for?
“Can historical evidence prove Jesus as Messiah?” This question opens a discussion on the differing claims of Christianity, Judaism, and Islam regarding Jesus. The conversation also touches on the expectations of the Messiah in Judaism at the time of Christ and the significance of the Davidic covenant in shaping messianic hope. Additionally, the role of Isaiah’s prophecies in this context is examined.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:00 – Jimmy, Christianity, Judaism, and Islam all make different claims about Jesus. Christians say he is the divine Messiah. Judaism does not accept him as the Messiah. Islam calls him the Messiah but denies central Christian beliefs about him. Can historical and biblical evidence help us determine which view is correct?
- 06:20 – In the introduction, you lay out the book’s argument in four steps . . . Give us the thirty-thousand-foot view of that case.
- 07:20 – Before we examine Jesus, what did Judaism at the time of Christ actually expect the Messiah to be and accomplish?
- 19:30 – Everything in the messianic hope seems to hinge on King David and the promise God made him in 2 Samuel 7—that his throne would be established forever. Tell us about the Davidic covenant and why it matters so much.
- 36:15 – Then came the Babylonian exile, and suddenly there was no son of David on the throne. How did the Jewish people get from that apparently failed promise to the expectation of a future Messiah?
- 49:25 – You point to Isaiah, writing in the 700s B.C., as providing the first clear and explicit prophecies of the Messiah: “Wonderful Counselor, Mighty God, Everlasting Father, Prince of Peace.” What makes these passages different from what came before?
“Do miracles still happen today?” This question opens a discussion on the nature of miracles in the context of Lourdes and Catholicism. Other topics include the thorough investigations the Church conducts on reported miracles and the significance of the miraculous events at Lourdes, as well as the awareness of our loved ones in heaven regarding our lives.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:00 – Do Miracles Still happen today?
- 39:48 – I’m a new Catholic and have a Pentecostal background like Tim. It has been very reassuring to me that the Catholic Church does do so much investigation of these miracles.
- 42:29 – I’m considering Catholicism. But the Lourdes thing confuses me. Lourdes has millions of visitors per year. Why is 72 out of millions significant?
- 47:35 – Are our loved ones in heaven aware of the details in our lives?
“How much can a priest change in the Mass?” This question opens a discussion on the boundaries of liturgical modifications, alongside inquiries about the sacrilege of receiving communion in the hand, the optional nature of certain prayers during the Communion rite, and the significance of the priest’s gestures before the Gospel reading.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:40 – How much is the priest allowed to change things in the mass?
- 10:40 – How do we answer sedevacantist who say that prior popes made it a sacrilege to receive communion in the hand?
- 13:00 – In the Communion rite, in the preparation, sometimes there is a prayer the priest says and sometimes there is not — is it optional?
- 21:35 – i finally have made the decision to come to the Catholic church. Getting to talk to Tom last week about hyperdulia really helped. I was hoping for a book suggestion for Catholic basics.
- 23:20 – At what point during the Mass does the bread and wine become Jesus?
- 31:05 – what is the difference between infallibility & indefectability? The English translation for indefectability seems to indicate the Church is without error, but how if Clergy are sinners?
- 33:00 – When the priest is about to read the gospel, he makes the sign of the cross on his forehead, lips, and heart. What is the significance of that? Are there words that accompany that?
- 34:38 – I’m in the Reformed tradition. I was taught that Catholic Mass was like sacrificing Jesus over and over again, but I’ve never actually asked a Catholic their view of that. What is the Catholic view of that?
- 46:54 – If you go to a SSPX Mass after the upcoming illicit consecrations is it a mortal sin?
- 50:55 – What should an extraordinary minister of holy communion do when people come up with hands crossed for a blessing?
“Is Catholicism a false church?” This question opens a discussion on the validity of Catholicism compared to Eastern Orthodoxy, particularly regarding changes in liturgy and fasting rules. The conversation also addresses whether first-century Christians prayed to saints and explores what Catholics believe about salvation in contrast to the “once saved, always saved” perspective.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:35 – Considering Catholicism or Eastern Orthodoxy. If the majority of bishops left the RCC, is that a sign they are a false church? Also, if Catholics changed liturgy/fasting rules while EO have been consistent, is that a sign they are a false church?
- 20:30 – How to Respond to the claim. Did first-century Christians pray to the saints? My protestant friend says it started in the third century.
- 31:05 – What do Catholics believe they have to do to be saved, and how do I respond to the once saved always saved belief? What are simple verses to refute that?
- 42:22 – Agnostic Brother Asked thinks Christianity is too Anthropocentric. He has a hard time believing that the universe was made for human beings primarily.
- 47:20 – Best Friend and brother want to convert to EO because of the filioque. How can I respond?
“Why Do Catholics Believe Peter is the Rock? Is Jesus the Rock?” This question opens a discussion on the interpretation of Matthew and the role of popes. Other topics include addressing misconceptions about Jesus’s sacrifice and the necessity of works for salvation, as well as arguments for the papacy and responses to claims about Catholic traditions resembling those of the Pharisees.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:30 – Catholics say Peter is the Rock in Matthew. But certain popes say Jesus is the rock?
- 10:35 – My friend says that Catholics Don’t Believe Jesus’s Sacrifice was Perfect. And that Catholics must do extra things to be saved. How do I respond?
- 17:45 – Not Catholic Cause no arguments for the Papacy are convincing. He believes in contingency argument to believe in God. But he needs a good argument like that for the papacy.
- 37:48 – If the Tree gave Adam and eve the knowledge of good and evil. How would they even know eating the apple was bad?
- 46:10 – How can I respond to the claim that Catholics are modern Pharisees? How are Catholic traditions any different than what the Pharisees did?
“Is God good if a boy feels like a girl?” This question opens a discussion on the nature of identity and divine creation. Other topics include navigating friendships after expressing disagreement with same-sex marriage, the Church’s training for priests to support same-sex attracted individuals, and the impact of hormones on mental health.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 10:00 – Is a boy who says he “feels like a girl” or vice-versa basically saying God is not good at creating?
- 18:33 – I had a friend who I learned who was going to marry another man. I told him I couldn’t go to the wedding. Because of this I learned a bunch of my friends are gay and they are now mad at me. How can I make amends with them?
- 33:15 – What kind of training is the Church giving priests to minister to same-sex attracted people? When I was in high school (60+ years ago) the priest wouldn’t even talk to me.
- 36:50 – Does the use of hormones in contraception and in our food have an effect on mental health?
- 48:25 – I’m all about inclusion and acceptance. What has helped me is that when I notice the haters, I ask them “imagine if a woman’s brain went into your body and your brain went into her body. And then the doctor asks you what gender are you.” That makes people think.
“Where are sacraments in the Bible?” This question opens a discussion on the biblical foundations of Catholicism, including the presence of sacraments. Other topics include the meaning behind the phrase “take it to the foot of the cross,” the role of Cardinals in Scripture, and how logic can support the papacy.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:35 – If Catholicism is in the Bible, where do you see the sacraments in the bible?
- 10:15 – I hear a lot of Protestants use say “take it to the foot of the cross and lay it down.” What exactly does that mean and does it square with Catholicism?
- 12:45 – I’m a recent convert. I have not been successful in convincing my friends and family about the Catholic Church. How do I convince them that it matters to belong to the Catholic Church as opposed to another church.
- 19:40 – Where do we find Cardinals in the Bible?
- 31:30 – Can we prove Catholicism and the papacy just by using logic and reason? How can people condemn the Church with the bible if the Church canonized the bible?
- 40:25 – Sin clouds our mind and makes it harder for us to express our true free will. Mary was protected from sin so always had the clearest use of her free will. If God desired all of us to go to Heaven, why didn’t he give us the same grace he gave to Mary?
- 44:53 – Former Catholic, looking into Orthodoxy… What is some proof for the papacy?
“Is Baptism Necessary for Salvation?” This question opens a discussion on the essential role of baptism in the Catholic faith, addressing concerns such as whether a Catholic father can baptize his children without the mother’s consent and what God is doing during the baptismal rite. Other topics include the Church’s acceptance of baptisms from some Protestant denominations and the differences between sprinkling and immersion.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:29 – Is Baptism Necessary for Salvation?
- 06:40 – Can a father who is Catholic get his children baptized without the consent of the mother?
- 08:05 – Since baptism is not just a symbol, what exactly is God doing at baptism?
- 15:20 – Why does the Church accept baptisms in some protestant churches
- 18:10 – What is the Catholic view on sprinkling vs immersion, and also on the formula (in Jesus’ name vs the trinitarian formula)?
- 41:30 – I grew up Catholic and have been Catholic my whole life, but I don’t have any proof that I am baptized. Should I get baptized? I’m kind of worried that maybe I was never baptized.
- 47:20 – Was John the Baptist’s baptism from God or from man?
- 52:00 – My granddaughter is being raised in a non-denom church. They are going to let her choose to be baptized when she turns seven. Should I be worried about the state of her soul before she is baptized?
“Why are we guilty of the sin of Adam and Eve?” This question opens a discussion on original sin and its implications for humanity. The episode also addresses the introduction of the “Once Saved Always Saved” concept, clarifies the authority of papal documents regarding salvation, and explores the challenges faced by a divorced Catholic seeking to return to the faith.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:25 – Why Are We Guilty of the Sin of Adam and Eve?
- 12:13 – How did the idea of Once Saved Always Saved get introduced into the world?
- 19:02 – Regarding Papal documents that say shedding blood for Christ won’t get you into heaven unless one submits to the pontiff. I’ve heard it argued that protestants are, loosely, under his authority but that feels more like a technicality rather than a development of doctrine. Can you help clarify?
- 29:05 – How is a fallen away Catholic who is divorced but wants to begin practicing the faith again supposed to live?
- 34:45 – Revelation 19:9 talks about the true things of God. Does that imply there are also bad things of God?
- 41:30 – I’m a Baptist. How is dogma viewed in Catholicism? Why are they required for salvation and why not treat them like some Marian apparitions where the Church allows the belief but doesn’t require it?
“How do I defend the Trinity?” This question leads to a discussion on the eternal subordination of the Son and how to address claims of heresy. Additionally, the episode touches on where the Church Fathers sourced their Hebrew scriptures, the need for ecclesiastical permission in fictional scenarios, and the Catholic perspective on lying.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:50 – Where did the Church Fathers get their copies of the Hebrew scriptures?
- 12:00 – How do I best defend the Trinity against someone who calls it heresy specifically in regards to eternal subordination of the son?
- 21:00 – Would the ghostbusters need ecclesiastical permission to do what they did in the movies?
- 28:58 – Is it ever ok to lie from the Catholic perspective?
- 35:40 – When did it become a custom for religious people to change their names?
- 42:15 – Does Romans 4 (particularly Romans 4:5) conflict with Catholicism’s doctrines faith, works, and a love?
- 52:45 – What is the church’s position on simulation theory?
“What did Jesus mean by losing your life?” This question opens a discussion on the profound implications of self-sacrifice in faith. The episode also addresses interpretations of the commandment regarding other gods, the Vatican’s stance on supernatural phenomena, and the availability of grace for salvation, showcasing a rich variety of theological insights.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:55 – What did Jesus mean when he said, “if you lose your life, you will find it” in Mt 16:25?
- 13:30 – Can we interpret having “no other gods before me” as not having any angels and saints before God’s presence?
- 24:20 – Do the new norms of the Vatican exploring supernatural phenomena abrogate the belief in Medjugorje?
- 32:10 – Does Catholic teaching allow us to tell anyone at any time that grace is sufficient for salvation as always available or is it more limited to certain times?
- 43:15 – What are your thoughts on the three days of darkness?
- 47:42 – Is the idea that life begins as conception an idea based on Greek philosophy and not an original Christian principle?
“What was the best argument against Catholicism?” This question leads to a discussion on the challenges faced by Catholics, including how to reconcile difficult moments in Church history, such as the Inquisition, and the role of priests in absolution. Additionally, the conversation touches on maintaining faith during tough times, providing a well-rounded exploration of these important topics.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 17:10 – What did you think was the best argument against Catholicism when you were protestant?
- 22:45 – How do we justify bad things in Church history like the inquisition and bad things that popes did?
- 33:55 – Why can’t priests absolve themselves?
- 36:25 – In light of Mark 11:24, how can I maintain faith when things are hard?
“How should Catholics respond to aliens?” This intriguing question opens a discussion on faith and the unknown, while also touching on the significance of the Eucharist as both a meal and a sacrifice. Other topics include the historical basis for apostolic succession and the distinction between hyperdulia and a worship of Mary, showcasing a diverse range of theological inquiries.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:40 – If you found yourself face-to-face with what appeared to be an intelligent being from another planet, how should you respond as a Catholic?
- 13:38 – Why is the Eucharist not only a meal but also a sacrifice?
- 20:30 – I’m LDS but am starting to question the Great Apostacy. There doesn’t seem to be a strong historical basis for it. What is the historical evidence for the Catholic claim of apostolic succession?
- 33:35 – My friend is an evangelical Protestant but he won’t consider Catholicism unless we give him answers about eschatology. He is a dispensationalist.
- 41:55 – I don’t understand this distinction between hyperdulia and worship of Mary.
- 46:32 – I saw this video “New Evidence for Early Popes” that talked about how in the early church history would be dated according to who was pope at the time. Is this a good argument for the papacy?
- 52:05 – I grew up in the Southern Baptist church believing that baptism is just a symbol. I’m starting OCIA soon. It sounds like the Catholic Church is going to accept my baptism as valid. This doesn’t make sense to me because I believed it was just a symbol.
“Why dialogue with non-Christians?” This question opens a discussion on the importance of engaging with those outside the faith, including how to approach Mormons regarding the Trinity despite their unique beliefs. Additional topics include insights on Daniel 2 and its implications for apostasy, as well as the complexities of Mormon theology concerning Jesus on other planets.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:20 – Why should we dialogue with people who are not Christians as we see them?
- 09:40 – How do you talk to Mormons about the Trinity if they reject the philosophy of the apostolic fathers or anything outside the bible?
- 23:25 – What are your thoughts on Daniel 2 and how it can prove or disprove the apostasy?
- 46:50 – I cant get mormons to answer if there is a Jesus on every planet. Do you know how this works into their understanding and theology?
“What are three things Mormons get wrong?” This episode addresses key misconceptions about Mormon beliefs, including insights on theosis and how it differs from Catholic teachings. Additional questions cover thoughts on the musical “The Book of Mormon,” advice for visiting a Mormon church, and how to respond to common Mormon perspectives on Jesus.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:15 – What are Three Things Mormons Get Wrong?
- 15:45 – Regarding the musical, The Book of Mormon” What are your thoughts on a musical mocking Mormonism?
- 20:38 – I’m Catholic and a former Mormon. I’m confused about theosis. Where do the beliefs of Mormonism and Catholicism on this topic differ?
- 35:02 – I’m visiting a Mormon church with a Mormon friend. What should I be prepared with before I go?
- 45:40 – If the Christian Church was reestablished with the Mormons within the last couple of hundred years, what would have happened with the souls of the Christians during that gap?
- 49:20 – How do I answer the response from a mormon when they say, we disagree but we all love Jesus so lets just do that?
“How can I explain Purgatory and the Eucharist to my son?” This question opens a discussion on the nature of suffering in Purgatory and the significance of the Eucharist, while also addressing concerns about interpretations of Scripture, such as the differing translations of 1 Timothy 3:15 and the implications of miracles related to the Eucharist.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:18 – How can I explain to my 18-year-old son Purgatory and why there is suffering there?
- 10:10 – I think it to be expected that the crowd in John 6 wouldn’t take Jesus literally about the Eucharist, because they would have thought of that as cannibalism.
- 22:40 – Can you explain why 1 Tim 3:15 is translated differently? The RSV says the Church is pillar and bulwark, and the NIV says pillar and foundation.
- 28:55 – I’m Christian. Does the Church know what the most important wedding is mentioned in Rev. 19:9?
- 33:55 – In the miracles of the eucharist, science comes back with results of a specific part of the heart of a living man. How do we clarify this with your understanding of the real presence of the Eucharist?
- 43:07 – I’m a returning Catholic and bringing my protestant husband along. Is there a “basics” book you recommend because it’s overwhelming for him?
- 46:40 – I’m Protestant because of Act 2:42-47. I think the protestant vision of it is closer to that then modern-day Catholicism.
- 50:20 – Is part of the problem for Catholics evangelizing all the requisites to enter the Church?
“Can we pray for lost babies?” This question opens a heartfelt discussion about the Church’s teachings on salvation and the hope for lost infants. Additionally, the episode addresses the historical invocation of saints, the apparent contradictions in salvation teachings from different Church councils, and the complexities of praying to saints in light of biblical texts.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:15 – We don’t have any indication that Christians invoked the saints until the fourth century. That’s too late for it to be part of the apostolic faith.
- 13:28 – My husband and I just lost a baby through miscarriage. We understand the Church has hope for lost babies’ salvation. But is there anything in Church teaching that would prohibit us from praying for our child’s soul?
- 18:45 – At the first Vatican Council they said outside of the Catholic Church there is no salvation. The Second Vatican Council said that salvation could be found in Protestant liturgy. Isn’t that a contradiction?
- 29:28 – I’m former New Age, and when I became Protestant I realized a lot of those practices were not right. I’m wondering how praying to the saints is okay, given that the Bible says not to speak to the dead.
- 41:55 – In the finding in the temple when Jesus says did you not know I would be in my Father’s house, is that a prefigurement the Eucharistic Jesus in the tabernacle?
- 51:17 – I consider myself Christian, but not Protestant or Catholic. When Jesus says if you don’t leave your father and mother you’re not worthy to call yourself his disciple, does that apply just to Catholics or to Christians as well?
“Why do Eastern Orthodox apologists reject doctrinal change?” This question opens a discussion on the objections many Eastern Orthodox apologists have regarding doctrinal development. The conversation also touches on the appeal of Orthodoxy’s power structure, strategies for guiding friends toward Catholicism, and the complexities surrounding the filioque controversy.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:20 – Why Do Many Eastern Orthodox Apologists Object to Doctrinal Development?
- 18:28 – We are Catholic but are considering Orthodoxy. One argument is that in Orthodoxy there is less emphasis on power structure so less chance of corruption.
- 23:40 – My non-denom friends are looking into Orthodoxy. How can I steer them towards Catholicism instead of Orthodoxy?
- 37:15 – There are two Patriarchs of Jerusalem, the Greek Orthodox and the Latin. The Latin one goes back to the Crusades, and the Greek Orthodox one goes back to the New Testament. I think it was schismatic act for the Latins to set up a separate one.
- 50:44 – The Eastern Orthodox argument against the filioque makes it seem like the Father and the Son have abilities that the holy spirit doesn’t have, which would seem to put him in a subservient position. Would you agree with that?
“Why is the Apostolic Age not a well-known part of Church history?” This question opens a discussion on the significance of early Church writings, including the role of the Church Fathers and the authenticity of the Apostolic Fathers’ texts. Other topics include the importance of listening to the Church Fathers and the historical context of early Christian martyrdom.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:45 – “Why is the Apostolic Age not a well known part of Church history?
- 20:00 – Why listen to the Church Fathers?
- 23:00 – How do we know the writings of the Apostolic Fathers are real?
- 38:00 – What is the spelling of the names of the writings you mention?
- 43:40 – Did Paul write things down in the Bible that Jesus didn’t tell him?
- 45:55 – Has Steve been on an archaeological dig? If so, what did he see?
- 47:15 – What did these Apostolic Fathers believe?
- 52:03 – How did it go from the apostolic fathers being martyred to Catholics killing Protestants at the Reformation?
“Why do some priests teach differently?” This question opens a discussion on the diversity of teachings within the Church, addressing concerns about consistency in doctrine. Other topics include the Church’s stance on charging for weddings and the significance of the Eucharist as a propitiatory sacrifice, along with the standards Catholics are held to regarding mortal sin.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:19 – I don’t understand why different priests have different teachings — if it’s one Church shouldn’t there be one teaching? Also I don’t understand why the Church charges for weddings — shouldn’t it be free?
- 17:32 – How do we know that the Early Church Fathers’ writings are correct?
- 24:25 – How is the Eucharist truly propitiatory as stated in CCC 1367?
- 48:15 – Why are Catholics held to a different standard? For example, for us it is a mortal sin if we miss Mass on a holy day.
“Which Church Did Jesus Start?” This question opens a discussion on the distinctions between Catholic and Orthodox beliefs, including what defines the Catholic Church as the one established by Christ. Additional topics include addressing the term “Roman” Catholic Church, the nature of the Eucharist, and the reasons behind the Orthodox separation from Catholicism.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:00 – Which Church Did Jesus Start
- 17:09 – What makes the Catholic Church the one that Jesus started and not the Syrians, the Orthodox, or the Coptics?
- 22:26 – How do you go about correcting Protestants who use the term “Roman” Catholic Church in a pejorative sense?
- 36:40 – When the bread and wine is turned in to Jesus’ body and blood, why does it still taste like bread and wine?
- 42:56 – Why is there no list of infallible Church teachings?
- 46:50 – Why did the Orthodox pull away from the Catholic Church?
- 51:30 – I have some SDA friends who believe in the long sleep instead of heaven or purgatory. What is the best refutation of the long sleep?
“Can I become Catholic without believing all dogmas?” This question opens a discussion on the complexities of faith and belief, addressing concerns about papal infallibility and the necessity of dogmas for conversion. Other topics include the Catholic view of predestination and the Church’s role in compiling the Bible, as well as challenges posed by Protestant interpretations of scripture.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:00 – I’m in the episcopal church and am curious about Catholicism. I have some reservations about papal infallibility. I’m wondering if I’d be able to become Catholic without holding to some dogmas.
- 17:30 – What is the Catholic view of predestination? Also, I know the Catholic Church put together the bible, but how did it do it?
- 30:00 – Protestants use 1 Cor 13:8 to say the age of miracles is over and it ended with the death of the last apostle. Some Protestant also say that this was the end of apostolic authority, specifically when it comes to forgiveness of sins via a priest. What are your thoughts on these?
- 40:25 – I’m not Catholic because the organization of Catholicism is openly homophobic and an official hate group. Also because of its crimes against humanity.
“Why do you reject the papacy?” This question opens a discussion on authority within the Church, touching on the necessity of a papal figure and the implications of such leadership. Other topics include the role of Mary and the Eucharist, as well as concerns about the treatment of statues and experiences with controlling religious groups.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:00 – Pope Leo on Nations
- 07:15 – The original precepts of Catholicism are fine by me, but I don’t agree with the “fine print.” For example, I agree with the idea of a need for authority and headship, but I don’t see the need for a papacy and all the things that go along with that.
- 20:57 – I don’t agree with the idea of Mary being protected from being able to commit sin. I also feel like the filioque rejects the Trinity. Also my problem with the Eucharist is how could it be him if he instituted it when he was still alive?
- 29:05 – I feel like Catholic treatment of statues is kind of like worshipping the golden calf.
- 40:19 – It doesn’t seem right for people to be bound by a particular opinion of the pope. That prevents people from thinking and coming up with an answer that makes sense.
- 47:32 – I got involved with this group and felt like I was being fed spiritually. They claimed to be baptist. But it got more and more controlling. Once they told me I am no longer myself and I was someone else. Once they laid me down and there was some kind of thing sucking out of my mouth and a electric feeling on my forehead. It got more controlling. They told me where to work. Have you ever heard of this? Is it a cult?
“What Church did Jesus found?” This question opens a discussion on the foundational beliefs of Christianity, touching on the Church’s teachings about Original Sin and the differing perspectives held by Jews and Muslims. Additionally, the conversation addresses the Orthodox view of apostolic succession and the implications of Jesus’ return for the Earth.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:09 – What Church did Jesus found?
- 12:14 – What does the Church teach about Original Sin, and why Jews and Muslims view it differently?
- 19:42 – The Orthodox believe that any validly consecrated bishop is the successor of Peter. And that Peter was called rock because he was the first to recognize the divinity of Christ. And Peter consecrated other bishops, so he cannot be the only foundation stone.
- 29:14 – What will happen to the Earth when Jesus returns?
- 32:07 – Is loving your neighbor and loving God more important than sacrifice. Because Jesus said we live by every word that comes from God, and he said love God and love your neighbor. So is that more important than the Eucharist?
- 35:20 – In the early Church is there more evidence for divine simplicity over the essence/energy distinction of the Eastern Orthodox?
- 41:35 – Who were the Apostolic Fathers? How many were there?
“How did you become a prophet?” This question opens a discussion on the nature of prophecy in the Bible, alongside topics such as the differences in prayer practices between Catholics and Protestants, and the historical context of the deuterocanon in the Protestant Bible. Other questions touch on the biblical understanding of marriage and the nuances of salvation from different theological perspectives.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:35 – How did you become an Old Testament Prophet?
- 08:35 – Can Catholics and Protestants pray together, and where do we see this in scripture?
- 15:40 – Who took the deuterocanon out of the Protestant Bible and when did they do it?
- 20:38 – I predicted something that happened. Does that mean I’m a prophet?
- 24:35 – I think it’s Judith that says Nebuchadnezzar is king of Syria, but the rest of the bible says he’s king of something else. So how can Judith be scripture if it contradicts the rest?
- 32:54 – I’ve heard that Protestants have more of a courtroom view of salvation, and for Catholics it’s more about Jesus reversing what Adam did. Is that accurate?
- 38:50 – What does the bible say about marriage?
- 42:18 – Jesus said we’d be accountable for our mistakes, and he also said he came for sinners. It seems like these contradict each other. Can you explain?
- 52:45 – Jesus says to be saved follow the 2 greatest commandments. But elsewhere he says you have to receive the Eucharist. So is it both?
“How Does Islam and Christianity Differ on Jesus?” This question opens a discussion on the distinct perspectives each faith holds about Christ. Additionally, the conversation touches on whether God could have forgiven humanity without the cross, the concept of Messianic Muslims, and the implications of the Koran’s teachings regarding Jesus and messengers.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:45 – How Does Islam and Christianity Differ on Jesus?
- 10:45 – If God could have forgiven humanity without the cross, what makes the cross a more fitting means of salvation than simply forgiving sinners?
- 21:00 – What do you think of the idea that Muhummad had the strength of 30 men?
- 29:02 – Are there Messianic Muslims — Muslims who believe in Jesus?
- 35:35 – It is in the Koran that Jesus said he was going to send a messenger.
- 41:35 – Does Islam teach that Christians must be destroyed?
- 45:15 – Isn’t it disingenuous to dismiss all of Islam culturally? It seems like people try to trash the whole religion when we could build bridges instead.
- 52:35 – How do you explain the Catechism’s teaching that Muslims and Christians worship the same God, when Islam is so different than Christianity? Also, early church fathers used the quick spread of the faith around the world as an argument for its truth. But Islam spread even more quickly. How would you respond to that?
“Should Sacrificial Love Be Exhausting?” Many believe that constant giving and never saying no is the essence of love, but this perspective can lead to burnout. The discussion also touches on balancing obligations to God and family, the moral implications of defending one’s family, and how these principles apply to single individuals.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:17 – Many Christians think constantly giving, never saying no, and exhausting themselves is a form of sacrificial love. Where does that idea go wrong?
- 14:57 – How I balance my obligations to God and to my family?
- 24:18 – Is there ever a time that a Catholic is morally obligated or allowed to defend one’s family by physical means? Or is it ever sinful?
- 33:24 – Many of your examples are for married people with families. How would the principles here be applied to a single person?
- 41:00 – I’m 18, and there is a girl I’d like to ask out. How do I deal with the fear of rejection?
- 45:52 – I think I’m having a trauma response to my family. My family and I are moving onto the same property as my parents. Our family farm is falling apart and I’m worried how it is going to affect relationships.
“Why are Esther’s chapters not sequential?” This question leads to a discussion about the structure of the Book of Esther, addressing why it begins with chapter 10 and revisits earlier events. Other topics include the meaning of Romans 5:7, the implications of modern technology as a new Tower of Babel, and advice for those new to reading scripture.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:47 – I’m reading the RSV of the Book of Esther. Why are the chapters not sequential? It starts with chapter 10 (or so) and then later goes back to chapter 1.
- 12:50 – What does Romans 5:7 mean? “Very rarely will anyone die for a righteous man, though for a good man someone might possibly dare to die.”
- 20:26 – Could modern technology be a new Tower of Babel?
- 33:28 – What is the best scholarly work that refutes Bart Ehrman’s view that the gospels are not reliable?
- 42:05 – I am grew up, but I have not actually read much scripture before. I would like to start. What is the best way to start? I get bored easily, and I don’t want to start and then lose momentum.
- 50:20 – On the road to Emmaus, one of the disciples is named and the other is not. I’ve heard speculation that is because the other was his wife. What do you make of this speculation?
“Are any parts of the Bible taken from other cultures?” This question opens a discussion on the influences surrounding biblical texts, while also addressing intriguing topics such as the possibility of ensouled humans mating with un-ensouled humans and the role of Nicodemus in the burial of Jesus. Additionally, the dating of 2 Peter is examined, providing a rich exploration of scriptural context.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:00 – Are any parts of the Bible taken from other cultures?
- 16:16 – In the beginning of humanity, could ensouled humans have mated with un-ensouled humans? If so, would it have been sinful for them to do so?
- 34:28 – When I was a kid I was told that Nicodemus helped take Jesus’ body off the cross. But it doesn’t mention him specifically in John 19:39. Is there any truth to this?
- 45:00 – When do you think 2 Peter was written? A lot of scholars place it after 70 AD and I am wondering if you would place it earlier.
“How do we deal with suffering?” This question opens a discussion on the Catholic perspective of suffering, contrasting it with Protestant views. The conversation also addresses practical advice for supporting a friend who has lost a loved one and offers insights on how to cope with suffering while experiencing it.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:34 – Protestant theology deals with suffering very differently. How do we deal with suffering?
- 14:50 – What are we supposed to deal with suffering while we are in it?
- 29:57 – My friend lost her husband recently. Do you have any advice on what I can say to her?
“What does active participation at Mass mean?” This question opens a discussion on the significance of engagement during the liturgy, including the practices of kneeling and standing at key moments. Other topics addressed include the meaning behind the priest’s prayer for “servants” during Mass and the implications of Eucharistic adoration as a spiritual weapon.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:20 – Eucharistic adoration is a neglected spiritual weapon.
- 11:08 – What does active participation at Mass mean?
- 15:53 – At the Agnus Dei is see a lot of people kneel and a lot of people stand. Which are we supposed to be doing? Also toward the end of Communion, when do we stop kneeling and start sitting — after the cleaning of the vessels, or when the tabernacle is closed?
- 23:06 – During the Mass the priest says “we pray for your servants” and then he pauses. Who are the servants referred to here?
- 29:23 – The Bible talks about a “mystery gospel” and a “secret doctrine”. I don’t have the chapter and verse but believe me it’s there. Do you have any insights into what these are?
- 36:05 – Is there ever a scenario where a non-Catholic who is aware of the Church can be saved?
- 42:40 – I kneel at the Agnus Dei because I think we should kneel when the tabernacle is open. The Bible says that we kneel before God.
- 45:45 – My non-Catholic friend comes to Mass with me sometimes. He wants to receive communion but I tell him he can’t, that he needs to approach with his arms crossed. But he receives communion anyway. Should I stop inviting him? Have I sinned by not being forceful enough?
- 51:09 – I saw on YouTube that when Jesus was a child he fell from a roof, and he turned mud into birds, and other miracles. Are these true?
“How can the Catholic Church be infallible?” This question addresses concerns about the Church’s historical positions, including its past endorsement of burning heretics. Other topics include the nature of worship as sacrifice and the confusion some feel about identifying as a Christian amidst various denominations. Additionally, there are discussions about the papacy and its perception within the context of modern issues.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:55 – My non-Catholic friend asks how can the Catholic Church be infallible when it has flip-flopped on issues. The issue he cites is the Church endorsement of burning heretics, and then later saying we shouldn’t.
- 14:45 – I’ve heard you say that worship is sacrifice. But my Protestant friend says they do sacrifice — sacrifice of praise.
- 24:25 – I’m not Catholic or Protestant or Orthodox because it is so confusing. So I just identify as a Christian.
- 42:25 – I’m considering Catholicism but I have some concerns. My SDA friend sent me a document saying the papacy was the beast of Revelation. Also I feel like the Catholic Church is not as welcoming to the LGBT community.
“Why Aren’t You Catholic?” addresses the reasons some individuals hesitate to embrace Catholicism, including concerns about unanswered prayers and the role of saints. The discussion also touches on the perception of praying to saints as idolatry and the scriptural basis for understanding prayer as worship.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:26 – I’m Not Catholic because after years of prayer, research, and personal conversations, God Has not allowed me to become Catholic
- 32:58 – I’m Not Catholic Because Prayer to Saints seems to be a type of Idolatry. I believe scripture makes it clear that prayer is a form of worship.
“How can we achieve perfection?” This question leads to a discussion on the steps we can take to avoid Purgatory, alongside insights on responding to Protestant challenges about Catholic doctrine. Other topics include the relationship between science and belief in God, the purpose of praying the Rosary, and the complexities of Church teachings on birth control.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:50 – What can we do to reach a level of perfection where we won’t have to go to Purgatory?
- 13:45 – How do we respond to Protestants when they challenge our Catholic doctrine?
- 22:10 – Is there a good book that addresses the scientific basis for God? My intelligent 22 year old grandson says science prohibits him from believing in God.
- 30:19 – I’ll be starting OCIA soon. Why pray the Rosary when we can go directly to God? And when would I pray the Rosary? It seems like if I just pray the Rosary I’d be giving up the fruitful prayer routine I already have. I wouldn’t want to give that up.
- 41:45 – The verbiage of CCC 2370 regarding birth control, “rendering procreation impossible” puzzles me. I’m not sure how it would apply because both artificial contraception and NFP have similar success rates.
- 48:29 – What are some of the sins that a regular priest can’t absolve? And what should a priest do if someone confesses something illegal?
“How is the Mass Christ’s sacrifice?” This question leads to a discussion on how Catholics view the Mass as the re-presentation of Christ’s single sacrifice, despite the experience of imperfection after attending. Other topics include the validity of saying “My Lord and My God” during consecration, and how to address challenges to the authenticity of Scripture.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:35 – Catholics believe that the Mass is the re-presentation of the single sacrifice of Christ, which Hebrews 10:14 says makes us perfect. But Catholics attend Mass and leave not perfected. Therefore, the Mass must not be the single sacrifice of Christ.
- 16:02 – A couple weeks ago I heard someone on CA say that you shouldn’t say “My Lord and My God” at the consecration. But my priest told me there is actually a partial indulgence for doing this. What’s true?
- 23:52 – How do you navigate the constant bombardment of people who deny the authenticity of scripture?
- 33:52 – Was Jesus always there from the beginning with God?
- 43:46 – The Hail Mary and the Hail Holy Queen seem like idolatry to me.
- 50:20 – What do Catholics believe about predestination? Is every event meant to be?
“How do I deal with being the only Catholic?” This question resonates with many, especially those navigating family dynamics. The discussion also touches on finding a Catholic community as a young adult, managing heated debates with family members, and approaching the sensitive topic of conversion without causing conflict.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:28 – How do you deal with being the only Catholic in the family?
- 20:50 – I’m 21 and the only Catholic in my family. How do I find a Catholic community?
- 29:56 – I’m the only Catholic in my family. How do I keep cool when having a heated debate with my brother?
- 34:24 – I’m converting and will be the only Catholic in my family. How do I break this news to my family without burning bridges?
“Is addictive personality real?” This question opens a discussion on the complexities of addiction, including insights on how to recognize an addictive personality. Other topics include strategies for helping a son struggling with nicotine and vaping, the intersection of faith and recovery in programs like Al Anon, and the role of sacraments in overcoming addiction.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:10 – Is there Such a thing as an addictive personality and how do i know i have one?
- 13:46 – I think my son struggles with nicotine and vaping, possibly some ADD. I think he is self-medicating. Any suggestions on how to help him?
- 18:50 – I was part of Al Anon and I feel like it brought me back to my Catholic faith. Ultimately I stopped going because they seemed to shun my Catholicism. Yet, it is interesting that they say they are a God-centered program.
- 29:16 – I have been in a 12 step program for food addiction for almost 20 years. I have recently had the epiphany that I can continue those meetings, but also go to Catholic in Recovery meetings where I can feel more relaxed about being open about my faith.
- 35:01 – I think the sacraments were the force that pulled me out of addiction.
- 41:09 – I sobered up in AA. I found that most people there who were against talking about Catholic faith were people who grew up Catholic but were hurt in some way. I found after a meeting was a great time to do apologetics.
- 47:59 – My dad is elderly and an alcoholic. Now he is sick. If he stopped his drinking his medication would work better. I don’t know how to approach it. Sometimes I feel like I’m giving up on him.
- 52:38 – I was addicted to pornography and I’m wondering if I’m doing the right thing by staying away from it.
“Can you help me understand the Catholic focus on Mary?” This question opens a discussion on the role of Mary in Catholicism, addressing why Catholics pray to her rather than solely to God. The conversation also touches on the Catholic version of salvation compared to the Protestant Romans Road and explores the nuances of the Catholic view of heaven.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 00:59 – Can you help me understand the Catholic focus on Mary? Why not just pray to God in Jesus’ name?
- 23:03 – The Protestants have Romans Road. Is there a Catholic version of that — a list of quick bullet points on how to get saved?
- 29:15 – It seems like many Protestants have a kind of flat view of heaven — you are either in or you are out. Is the Catholic view more nuanced than that?
- 39:58 – I’m a new Catholic. Can you give me advice on how to hear God’s voice when we pray?
“How do I get to heaven?” This question opens a discussion on the Catholic understanding of salvation, alongside intriguing inquiries about recognizing loved ones in heaven, including those we’ve never met, and the importance of guarding against presumption regarding our eternal destiny.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:20 – How do Catholics get to heaven?
- 20:35 – In heaven how will we know the people in our lives that we never met (like a miscarried child or an ancestor)?
- 40:17 – How do we guard against being presumptuous about going to heaven?
“What has Tim learned after 25 years of apologetics?” In this episode, Tim reflects on his extensive experience in Catholic apologetics, addressing questions such as the obligation of Catholics to follow Ember Days and the trustworthiness of the Catholic Church’s authority. He also tackles challenges faced by parents with children who have left the faith and discusses the complexities of interfaith dialogue regarding the nature of God.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:00 – What has Tim Staples Learned after a quarter -century of doing Catholic Apologetics?
- 14:55 – Are Catholics still obliged to follow Ember Day?
- 18:20 – Why should we trust the Catholic Church and its authority? My friend is a non-Catholic and is concerned he will be deceived. He is trying to trust the Catholic Church but doesn’t know how.
- 41:34 – My adult son has left the faith and challenges me about it. He sent me a video of someone saying if Adam and Eve are the parents of humanity, how did we end up with so many races and genetic backgrounds. How would we answer this?
- 49:15 – Why does the Catechism teach Muslims worship the same God, when the God of the Koran is so vastly different from the God of the Bible? Is there a way to tell if another monotheistic religion worships the same God or not?
“Why did the Church end weekly fasting?” This question opens a discussion on the evolution of Church practices, alongside inquiries about the Church’s stance on jousting, the concept of limbo for infants, and the pastoral duties of priests. These topics reflect the diverse concerns and curiosities within the Catholic faith today.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:50 – Why Did the church kill off weekly fasting?
- 08:00 – I have heard the Church banned jousting. Does that mean we can’t do that at Medieval Times?
- 13:27 – Is it acceptable for Catholics to believe in the limbo of the infants?
- 19:13 – How do I articulate the Catholic position that it is not faith alone that saves, without sounding like our works save us?
- 28:00 – Modeling Jesus in Dating Before Marriage
- 34:36 – I’ve been going through some ongoing stalking, hacking, and financial fraud. I thought I could go to the Church for help but they don’t seem to be able to offer me support. What are the pastoral duties of a priest? I’ve been thinking of leaving the Catholic Church because of this.
- 43:54 – Why is it the norm in the US to receive communion in the hand and standing? Why did it change from what seems to be a more reverent posture?
- 48:09 – How can the Church hold up Mary and Joseph as an ideal marriage, when they did not consummate and therefore it would not have had a sacramental marriage?
- 51:23 – When should you leave your parish for another parish based on your priest teaching false things? My priest is very loving and kind, but is not on board with some doctrines and some sexual teaching of the Church?
“Why don’t we see more of the charismatic gifts in the Catholic Church?” This question opens a discussion that also touches on the nature of original sin and God’s relationship with evil, as well as addressing concerns about Pope Vigilius and responses to objections regarding God’s presence. The conversation provides clarity on these diverse theological topics.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:18 – Why don’t I see more of the charismatic gifts in the Catholic Church?
- 11:09 – Discussion with Non-denom Sister. Thinks Jesus was not free from original sin and God created evil. Looking for Bible focused responses for the idea that God is completely incompatible with sin.
- 19:00 – Did Pope Vigilius go against earlier popes in the 3 chapter controversy.
- 29:25 – An orthodox objection. What’s a good response to the idea that we only see God in his energies.
- 34:00 – How do I speak about the Catholic Faith to my friends and family who say Catholicism is too complicated?
- 46:14 – If I become Catholic, do I need a new name?
“How do I explain that Jesus is God?” This question leads to a discussion on the nature of Christ and the Trinity, while also addressing related topics such as the historical disagreements between Catholics and Orthodox on the canon of scriptures and the evolving emphasis on Mary in the Church. Additional questions touch on interfaith relationships and early church governance.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:35 – When did Catholics and Orthodox begin to disagree on the canon of scriptures?
- 15:00 – Why don’t we hear anything about Mary? It seems like the Church has much more emphasis on her now than in early church?
- 24:28 – How do I explain to my family members that Jesus is God?
- 35:20 – My son is dating a Ukrainian Orthodox girl. Are they in line with the Roman catholic church? Can you give me 3 similarities and differences between the two?
- 42:46 – I’m Not Trinitarian because Jesus has a proper name, the Father has a proper name. But the Holy Spirit does not have a proper name.
- 47:47 – Was there more of a democracy of bishops in the early church? I don’t want to jump into a system similar to Mormonism again.
“Can salvation happen outside the Church?” This question opens a discussion on the Catholic understanding of salvation, addressing concerns from Protestants about Church teachings. Other topics include navigating a past as a Protestant while exploring Catholicism and the reasoning behind Paul’s letter to the Romans despite Peter’s presence in the city.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:23 – I have many protestants tell me that they would never become Catholic because the Church teaches salvation outside the Church.
- 11:38 – I became Protestant in 2021 and am now looking into Catholicism. How do I process my past life?
- 22:10 – If Peter was in Rome then why did Paul write the letter to the Romans?
- 34:57 – Do Christian who are hostile to the Catholic Church still have invincible ignorance?
“How Could Mary ascend to heaven?” This question leads to a discussion about the implications of Jesus’ words in John 3:13 regarding who has ascended to heaven. The conversation also touches on the scriptural basis for the communion of saints, the Church’s stance on marriage for the infertile, and the complexities of indulgences.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:00 – Mary’s bodily assumption doesn’t make sense because Jesus says in John 3:13, “No one has ascended up to heaven, but he who descended from heaven, the Son of Man.” If no man has ascended into heaven, wouldn’t that include the Blessed Virgin Mary?
- 07:23 – Where do we find the communion of saints in scripture?
- 14:22 – Is it true that a person who is infertile cannot get married in the Catholic Church?
- 19:09 – I cannot wrap my mind around indulgences.
- 31:17 – How do I defend Jesus and the accusations that he was a fraud?
- 46:11 – Why do we profess in the Nicene Creed that the power of the Holy Spirit made Jesus incarnate not the power of the Son?
- 51:36 – Are we called to suffer or do we ask the saints to relieve our suffering?
Questions Covered:
- 05:13 – Sexual Sins
- 08:56 – Fornication
- 16:20 – Adultery
- 18:30 – Pornography
- 21:54 – Masturbation
- 29:52 – Homosexual Acts and Contraception
- 33:00 – Sins of the Heart
Questions Covered:
- 06:05 – What is a mortal sin?
- 07:08 – The three components of mortal sins
- 20:33 – Sins Against God
- 21:00 – Idolatry
- 23:42 – Blasphemy
- 29:32 – Missing Mass
- 32:51 – Occult practices
- 37:42 – Sins Against Others
- 39:19 – Murder/War
- 42:00 – Gossip
- 50:41 – Lying/Slander
Questions Covered:
- 02:20 – How culpable are people of other religions when it comes to not following Jesus?
- 09:42 – How did the Church select the popes before conclaves? When did it fall on the shoulders of the college of cardinals?
- 13:50 – Why do we have the books in the bible that we do? Why did they remove those books in the reformation?
- 21:57 – Which Church Father writings about Mary would you recommend for a Protestant?
- 23:47 – Why do Catholics believe that both species contain the body, blood, soul and divinity if the consecration separates them?
- 29:00 – If the Jews couldn’t kill Jesus, forcing them to send Jesus to be crucified, then why did they stone people?
- 41:07 – How is it that the Orthodox Church is considered in schism, but the Anglican Church is not? Seems like they have similar issues with unity with the Catholic Church.
- 48:42 – Do we know when St. Joseph died? Is there anything in the bible?
- 49:23 – On what level of reality does the eucharist change?
- 50:32 – What do you think are the weirdest things that Jesus taught?
Questions Covered:
- 4:00 – If the early church was Catholic, then why doesn’t it look anything like the Catholic Church of today?
- 11:32 – Can Catholics use the title Christotokos alongside theotokos?
- 17:31 – Question from Non Catholic Family-Member: How does Mary intercede for us if she’s not alive?
- 23:43 – If the Eucharist is truly Jesus, body and soul, why isn’t it open to everyone, and why are priests allowed to determine who receives it? How do I answer?
- 31:03 – What is the best argument for Catholicism to a Protestant who accepts the Nicene creed?
- 36:59 – If someone who received the gospel of Jesus and believed, should the Church immediately baptize him since we have a similar example in the Ethiopian eunuch?
- 44:11 – What are the theological differences between the Catholics and the Orthodox?
- 49:33 – Is there a list of infallible teachings that has been published?
“What is the Catholic Church?” This question opens a discussion about the Church’s identity and mission, while also addressing how to navigate family dynamics when dealing with issues like homosexuality. Additional topics include the challenges of engaging with an evangelical perspective on the Catholic Church and fostering relationships with family members who hold anti-Catholic views.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:45 – What is the Catholic Church?
- 13:48 – How do I deal with family who is fully immersed in homosexuality?
- 28:57 – I’m evangelical. The premise that the Church that Jesus founded was the Roman Catholic Church is false.
- 49:07 – My mom is a evangelical, former Catholic and anti-Cathoic. How do I bridge that gap and have a relationship with her?
“What makes music sacred?” This question opens a discussion on the essence of sacred music, touching on its spiritual significance. The conversation also addresses practical concerns like where to find chant sheets for traditional Latin Mass altar serving and whether sacred music must stem from a place of faith.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:00 – What makes music sacred?
- 30:15 – I altar serve at the TLM and have a hard time chant sheets. Where do you recommend I find them?
- 36:35 – Would you agree that sacred music has to be a product of faith?
“How do I explain Mary’s sinlessness to my Protestant wife?” This question opens a discussion on the role of Mary in Catholic theology, addressing concerns from recent converts and their families. Other topics include offering comfort after a loved one’s passing, navigating doubts about Sola Scriptura, and understanding the Church’s teachings on end times and marital relations.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:21 – I’m a recent convert. How do I address the sinlessness of Mary to my Protestant wife?
- 17:41 – My non-Catholic father-in-law died suddenly. What words of comfort can I offer to my Catholic family?
- 24:33 – If I become convinced of certain Church teachings but still have major questions about things regarding Sola Scriptura, would it be a good thing to move towards Catholicism?
- 34:05 – Regarding the end time, it appears Irenaeus is premillennial and claims he gets it from St. John, but the Church teaches against it. How binding is this?
- 42:35 – I’m a recent convert. My wife had a procedure to save her life that required the removal of parts of her reproductive system. Is it a sin to have relations since we cannot be open to life?
- 47:31 – Where does Mary fit in because she’s always popping up everywhere? Why is she so prominently seen?
“Did the Early Church teach that Mary sinned?” This question opens a discussion on Marian doctrine, while also addressing the moral implications of investing in Christian-friendly funds versus secular ones. Other topics include reconciling John 6:35 with the Eucharist and the ethical concerns surrounding IVF, providing a comprehensive look at contemporary Catholic issues.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:50 – Did the Early Church teach that Mary sinned?
- 14:00 – Regarding the principles of cooperating with evil. Do I have a moral obligation to invest in Christian friendly funds over secular ones?
- 21:38 – How do I reconcile John 6:35 with the literal understanding of his body and blood?
- 30:37 – What makes IVF fundamentally wrong? Where does the right to be conceived through natural means come from?
- 50:35 – How do we respond to the Protestant claim that they also offer a sacrifice, but it’s a sacrifice of praise?
Can suffering or illness in our family be a punishment from God for our sins? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Catholic Answers apologists address this difficult and deeply personal question before exploring a wide range of theological and pastoral topics. The discussion covers whether Catholics may hold the Genesis Gap Theory, how the Church can better evangelize people with disabilities, and why Catholic teaching on the death penalty has developed over time. Additional questions examine the extraordinary endurance of St. Paul, the purpose of offering prayer intentions with the Rosary, why Catholicism claims to be more than just another denomination, and why sacramental confession is necessary before receiving Holy Communion in certain situations. A thoughtful conversation on suffering, grace, Church authority, and the sacraments.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:12 – Is it possible that God punishes my continuous sin through my son’s disease?
- 04:19 – Can a Catholic hold to the Genesis Gap Theory? Or is it heretical?
- 12:41 – How can the Church evangelize to those with disabilities? What are good resources that can help me get started?
- 19:28 – Can we in good conscience support the death penalty? I can’t seem to understand why the church changed this. In theory can’t the church’s teaching on this revert?
- 28:37 – Is there a miraculous quality to St. Paul recovering from the stoning at Lystra or from all of the other beatings he suffered? It seems any number of the rods, stonings, etc. could have disabled him and made his long-distance travel impossible.
- 32:49 – How does setting a prayer intention before praying a rosary differ from just praying for that intention directly without praying a rosary, does it have something to do with the merit involved with praying a rosary? Thank you!
- 36:40 – Why can’t Catholicism be just another denomination among the denominations? I think Protestants see Catholicism as a Christian denomination, thus no need to make the move if they are already happy where they are.
- 43:02 – If priests have the sacramental power to ordain, why has this actually happened so rarely in Church history?
- 46:50 – Why is it mandatory to go to a priest for confession before one can go for Holy Communion. Why isn’t going to God directly sufficient for this? If someone sits on his seat because he hasn’t gone for confession, everyone would see that he hasn’t gone to confession, it would elicit some kind of shame on this person.
“What’s the best argument for Catholicism?” This episode addresses the top argument to convince an unbeliever, while also tackling questions about submitting to the Church amid concerns of sin, the differences between original sin and ancestral sin, and the significance of Marian prayers.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:55 – What’s the top argument to convince an unbeliever?
- 10:40 – Am I supposed to submit to the Church even though it might be sinning?
- 18:20 – How is the Catholic doctrine of original sin better than the Eastern doctrine of ancestral sin?
- 29:10 – In the earliest known Marian prayer its written, “…do not despise our petitions in time of trouble, but rescue us from danger. Only pure one, only blessed one.“ As a former Protestant, the “rescue us“ Part troubles me a bit to pray.
- 32:54 – How can I explain to a non-Catholic the difference between a blessed item and a “good luck” charm?
- 40:03 – What is the explanation for the Celibate priesthood?
- 46:42 – My friend is not Catholic because other denominations have sacraments and clergy, how do I as a Catholic respond to that argument?
- 52:03 – Can you clarify the teaching of paragraph 1377 in the Catechism which states that…” Consecration endures as long as the Eucharistic species exists…?
“Where do we see the Marian doctrines in Scripture?” This question opens a discussion on the biblical foundations of Marian beliefs, alongside inquiries about why Catholics refer to Mary as “holy” and “our life, our sweetness, and our hope,” and the differences in veneration of Mary among various Christian traditions. The episode also addresses the Catholic and Orthodox views on the Immaculate Conception and the significance of Mary as the Queen of Heaven.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:00 – Where do we see the Marian Doctrines in scripture?
- 23:43 – Why do Catholics call Mary “holy” and “our life, our sweetness, and our hope” in the Salve Regina?
- 28:59 – Is there a difference in veneration of Mary in EO, Assyrian Church Of The East, OO and Catholicism?
- 32:49 – How does the Catholic view of the Immaculate Conception differ from the Orthodox view (as it relates to Original Sin)? And what is the evidence for the Catholic view?
- 45:45 – How can we be sure Mary is the Queen of Heaven?
- 50:40 – Why are there so many apparitions of Mary but not of Jesus?
“What are Near Death Experiences?” This question opens a discussion on near-death experiences and the nature of the soul. The conversation also addresses critiques of NDE content, the concept of purification in the afterlife as described by Father Nathan Castle, and intriguing thoughts on the relationship between soul and brain in hypothetical scenarios.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 00:55 – What do you say to critics of your content on NDEs, who say that it understates the skeptical research in the academic NDE literature?
- 18:50 – What do you think of the way purification seems to occur in Father Nathan Castle’s afterlife accounts? It would seem that rather than experiencing a “painful” and “fiery” purification as often depicted in pious stories and prayers about purgatory over the centuries, the souls essentially just learn new things and gradually correct their misunderstandings and errors, including needing to come to grips with their past sins and their effects on others. The idea that angels, saints and deceased relatives all get involved at different points along the journey of purification of souls and to help them move to a new level really appeals to me.
- 36:17 – If two individuals had their brains swapped, would their soul remain in their original bodies? Or if it stayed, how would the mismatched soul/brain experience consciousness?
- 46:01 – My wife is utterly convinced that all lizards including and especially the dinosaurs used to be dragons and wings were the limbs mentioned in Genesis when God punished the serpent. Note that most modern-day lizards although they do have legs still scurry around on their bellies because of their wide stance.
“Can humans possess one another?” This question opens a discussion on the nature of influence and control, including the implications of brainwashing techniques. Additionally, the episode addresses what happens to souls in purgatory at the end of the world and whether it’s morally acceptable to seek the identity of a ghost that may be trying to communicate. Other intriguing topics include the concept of fallen guardian angels and their replacements.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:40 – can human beings possess one another? For example: would brainwashing techniques done by the CIA and other government agencies with the use of LSD and other mind-altering drugs count as possession? My understanding is that the subject’s personality is changed, and they become very influenceable. Is this a form of possession by humans?
- 20:07 – My 9-year-old son loves listening to your show. He is wondering if you could shed any light on what might happen to the souls in purgatory when the end of the world comes. Do they get forcibly zapped through the rest of their purification process?
- 33:21 – If you have good reason to believe a ghost in purgatory is trying to get your attention, is it morally okay to ask them to reveal their identity? Context: a few years ago I was home alone with my newborn daughter on All Souls Day and heard repeated loud rattling sounds coming from the kitchen. The baby began screaming. I calmly walked out and said, “Whoever is bothering my baby, go away.” The rattling stopped and I have never heard it since. I have had Mass said for the soul, and also for one person I suspect it might have been, but I am not sure. Is it forbidden to ask for such knowledge or should I be content to wait?
- 44:37 – Are there fallen guardian angels, if so do we get a replacement if our intended guardian angel fell?
Does John 6 really teach the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist, or are Catholics reading too much into the passage? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Catholic Answers apologists continue responding to major Protestant objections to the Catholic interpretation of Jesus’ Bread of Life discourse. The discussion examines whether Jesus’ failure to clarify misunderstandings proves literal intent, how Catholics answer the Old Testament prohibition against drinking blood, and whether John 6 is truly connected to the Eucharist despite John not including the Last Supper narrative. Additional questions address figurative language about never hungering or thirsting, what Jesus meant by promising eternal life, and where the Gospel of John fits among the four Gospels. A detailed biblical defense of the Eucharist and the Catholic understanding of John 6.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 10:01 – Catholics argue that since Jesus didn’t clarify the literal thoughts of his listeners then he must have intended his words to be taken literally. But Jesus’ lack of clarification for misunderstandings is nothing new under the sun. He did it in John 2:15-17 concerning his teaching about destroying the temple of his body.
- 16:37 – Jesus can’t intend us to literally drink his blood because the Bible prohibits the partaking of blood in Leviticus 17:10-12.”
- 21:22 – Catholics appeal to John 6 to prove Christ’s Real Presence in the Eucharist. But John 6 has nothing to do with the Eucharist at the Last Supper.
- 30:15 – Where does John Fall among the gospels since John does not contain the last supper?
- 35:04 – If Catholics take Jesus’ words to eat his flesh literally, then would also have to take his words literally in verse 35 when he speaks of never hungering when we come to him and never thirsting when we believe in him.
- 45:57 – If Jesus meant his words literally—and intended us to engage in a physical act to eat his flesh, then we’d have to take him literally when he says that we will never die.
Do Catholics interpret John 6 consistently, or are Jesus’ words about eating His flesh just symbolic like calling Himself the “gate” or the “vine”? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Catholic Answers apologists respond to some of the strongest Protestant objections to the Catholic understanding of the Eucharist. The discussion examines whether John 6 should be interpreted metaphorically, how the surrounding context affects Jesus’ teaching, and what Christ meant when He said “the flesh is of no avail.” The episode also explores why many disciples walked away from Jesus in John 6 and whether their reaction supports or undermines the Catholic doctrine of the Real Presence. A deep and biblical defense of the Eucharist rooted in Scripture, theology, and the words of Christ Himself.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:23 – Catholics aren’t consistent in their interpretation of John 6. They interpret Jesus’ words about eating his flesh and drinking his blood literally in John 6, but they don’t do that when it comes to his words about being the “gate” in John 10:9 or the “vine” in John 15.
- 15:52 – Catholics ignore the preceding context in verse 35 where 3. Jesus uses the metaphors of eating and drinking for coming to and believing in him. If Jesus used those images as metaphors there, then he must have used them as metaphors when he speaks of eating his flesh and drinking his blood.
- 30:05 – Catholics ignore verse 27 where Jesus moves away from a physical mentality and takes things in a spiritual direction. Here’s what he says, “Do not labor for the food which perishes, but for the food which endures to eternal life, which the Son of Man will give to you.” This distinction between spiritual and physical food serves as the basis for interpreting Jesus’s words about eating his flesh figuratively rather than literally.
- 35:50 – Catholics argue that Jesus never clarified his audience’s literal thoughts. But that’s not true. He does it in John 6:63, where he says, “It is the Spirit that gives life; the flesh is of no avail. The words that I have spoken to you are spirit and life.”
- 50:20 – Catholics argue that because Jesus let his disciples leave based on their literal interpretation of his command to eat his flesh and drink his blood that meant Jesus meant the words literally. But the disciples didn’t leave because of Jesus’ teaching. Rather, they left because of Jesus’ teaching in verse 65 that no one comes to him unless the Father draw him.
Can human reason alone lead us to the conclusion that God is personal, even without divine revelation? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Catholic Answers apologists tackle deep philosophical and theological questions about God, authority, and the Church. The discussion explores whether Eastern Orthodoxy has a singular teaching authority comparable to the papacy, why Catholics often receive only the host and not the chalice at Communion, and whether extraordinary ministers of Holy Communion are sometimes overused. Additional topics include whether Adam was a single historical person or a group, how to evangelize someone immersed in New Age spirituality, and whether the early Church taught any doctrines no longer held today. A thoughtful conversation on Catholic theology, Church practice, and apologetics.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 12:36 – Is there a way to arrive at the conclusion of the personhood of God without resorting to revelation?
- 21:46 – Does Eastern Orthodoxy have a singular authority like we do?
- 29:07 – How come everyone takes the host for communion but not everyone gets the chalice?
- 32:07 – Are extraordinary ministers of holy communion only to be used in emergency situations? My priest doesn’t always give communion at mass. He lets the EMs do it. Is that an abuse?
- 39:35 – Was Adam one man or a group of men?
- 43:00 – How do you start a conversation with someone who’s kind of a “new age junkie?” Like they’re always looking for a spiritual high or buying the next big self-help book, but can’t be bothered to open the Gospels?
- 48:54 – Is there something that the early church believed in terms of doctrine that isn’t taught today?
Why did the Pharisees and Sadducees fiercely disagree about the resurrection, and why is the resurrection so central to Catholic belief? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Catholic Answers apologists explain the theological importance of bodily resurrection before tackling questions about the Protestant and Jewish biblical canons, including why Maccabees is missing despite its connection to Hanukkah. The discussion also explores common misunderstandings about Catholic teaching on salvation, including accusations of “works-based salvation,” how justification can grow even while Christians still commit venial sins, and the connection between the Bread of Life discourse and Christ’s Passion. The episode concludes with pastoral advice for someone in OCIA facing family conflict about becoming Catholic and attending Mass.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:22 – Why was there a dispute between the Pharisees and Sadducees on resurrection, and why is it so central to Catholic teaching?
- 11:14 – Is the protestant bible based off of the Jewish translation of the bible? Why doesn’t the Jewish bible have Maccabees, since those books contain the origin of Hanukkah?
- 20:10 – How would we respond to someone who pushes back when we say don’t believe in a works-based salvation? They say that we would claim someone loses their salvation if they miss Mass.
- 30:20 – How do we reconcile a justification that progresses and still commit venial sin?
- 37:01 – How close in time was the bread of life discourse to the Passion of Christ?
- 51:30 – I’m in OCIA and my husband doesn’t agree with my decision. If I were to become Catholic and I can’t make it to mass because of issues at home, will I be in mortal sin?
“How is the Eucharist not cannibalism?” This question opens a discussion on the nature of the Eucharist, addressing misconceptions while also touching on the movement of the Holy Spirit in communities, the need for an infallible interpreter of scripture, and the concept of mortal sin in Catholic teaching.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:24 – How is the Eucharist not cannibalism?
- 15:30 – I think the Pentecostal belief in the real movement of the Holy Spirit within the community was pretty convincing. What is the best response to this?
- 22:31 – How do I answer the following: The Catholic argument that we need an infallible interpreter for scripture would not work because then you would need an infallible interpreter of the infallible interpreter and so on.
- 37:08 – For Catholics almost anything can be a mortal sin but for Jesus there is one mortal sin.
- 43:00 – What was lacking in Jesus that made the Jews reject Jesus as the Messiah in the early church?
- 52:15 – How do we interpret the magisterium? How do we know when we are interpreting the magisterium correctly?
“How do we know Mary is a perpetual virgin?” This question leads to a discussion on the implications of Luke 1:34 and the differing views between Catholics and Protestants. Other topics include whether Jesus fulfilled all Mosaic sacrificial offerings and the nature of baptism, specifically if it refers to the baptism of the Holy Spirit rather than water.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:40 – In support of the belief that Mary was a Perpetual virgin, Catholics appeal to Luke 1:34 where Mary asks Gabriel how she’s going to conceive a child since she doesn’t “know man,” the implication being she hasn’t had sexual relations with Joseph. But some Protestants counter that Mary asked this because she wasn’t yet married to Joseph. How do we respond?
- 13:29 – Regarding Jesus’ sacrifice, did he fulfill all Mosaic sacrificial offerings? Or just specific offerings?
- 21:19 – Is baptism actually the baptism of the holy spirit, not that of water, and is the evidence speaking in tongues?
- 29:49 – Were Mary and Joseph actually married but just hadn’t consummated it?
- 41:35 – Mark 9:38-41 is the best argument for Protestantism.
- 51:15 – What is the connection between the coronation and the bodily assumption?
Did Vatican II introduce harmful changes to the Catholic Church, and does Catholic theology go too far in defining mysteries like the Eucharist? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Catholic Answers apologists respond to major Orthodox objections to Catholicism, covering theology, Church history, and doctrine. The discussion examines Catholic teaching on remarriage and original sin, the necessity of the Immaculate Conception, and the Christological differences between the Catholic Church and the Oriental Orthodox Churches. Additional topics include whether transubstantiation “overdefines” the Eucharist, why Orthodox and Catholic biblical canons differ, and whether Catholic theology lacks the Orthodox essence–energies distinction. A thoughtful and charitable look at some of the deepest divisions between East and West.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Objections Covered:
- 02:12 – Vatican II introduced harmful theological and liturgical changes.
- 05:51 – Catholic teaching on remarriage is too rigid.
- 13:36 – Catholic original sin wrongly teaches inherited guilt.
- 17:14 – The Immaculate Conception is unnecessary and unfounded.
- 28:52 – What does one say about the Christological differences between the Oriental Orthodox Churches and the Catholic. They claim they hold to the early definitions of Ephesus that we have abandoned.
- 36:14 – Transubstantiation overdefines the Eucharistic mystery.
- 39:57 – Why do Orthodox Churches differ with us on the canon of Scriptura?
- 47:57 – Catholicism lacks the essence–energies distinction.
Are papal supremacy and papal infallibility later inventions unknown to the early Church? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Catholic Answers apologists respond to some of the most common Orthodox objections to Catholicism. Topics include whether the papacy is biblical, if the Filioque was an illegitimate change to the Nicene Creed, and whether mandatory clerical celibacy reflects apostolic Christianity. The discussion also examines claims that purgatory and indulgences are Western corruptions, whether doctrinal development preserves or distorts the faith, and if Rome’s actions caused the East–West Schism. Finally, the episode addresses whether Vatican I contradicts the structure and authority of the early Church. A deep and charitable exploration of the major theological divisions between Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Objections Covered:
- 02:34 – Papal supremacy is unbiblical and unknown in the early Church.
- 12:00 – Papal infallibility is a late doctrinal invention. Papal authority undermines conciliar Church governance.
- 18:45 – The Filioque is both unauthorized and theologically incorrect. Rome illegitimately altered the Nicene Creed.
- 24:20 – Mandatory clerical celibacy is non-apostolic.
- 30:33 – Purgatory is a Western innovation without early consensus.
- 36:37 – Doctrinal development is corruption, not preservation.
- 42:07 – Indulgences distort repentance and were historically abused.
- 45:40 – The East–West Schism was caused by Rome’s overreach.
- 49:42 – Vatican I contradicts the structure of the early Church.
Could Jesus have been an alien using advanced technology—and how can Christians know that’s not true? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Jimmy Akin tackles some of the strangest and most fascinating questions listeners have ever asked. He explains whether receiving Communion affects Ash Wednesday fasting rules, what kinds of abilities resurrected bodies may have, and why theories about Jesus as an extraterrestrial don’t hold up historically or theologically. The discussion also explores why Rome is called the Church founded by Christ despite Jerusalem coming first chronologically, whether dinosaur cancer challenges traditional understandings of the Fall, and what Christians should think about pets and the end times. A fun and thoughtful episode blending theology, science, apologetics, and the unusual questions Jimmy Akin is famous for addressing.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:04 – In the case of Ash Wednesday, when fasting and abstinence are required, would receiving communion break one’s fast or count as a smaller meal? In other words, can one receive communion in addition to eating one full meal and two smaller meals? Thanks, Jimmy!
- 12:24 – Hi Jimmy. You’ve previously mentioned Aquinas and the possibility that humans have low-level psychic ability.. Will our resurrected body have other abilities, such as telekinesis or telepathy? Will I be able to fly like Superman? Jesus ascended, and there are stories about Saints “levitating”, so will the body get any potential flying or levitating abilities, or what other abilities might we get?
- 23:48 – How can we be sure that Jesus wasn’t actually an alien talking about his “father in heaven” who is actually in outer space and his spaceship is actually his kingdom? And the eternal life that we get from following Jesus to his kingdom is from advanced alien technology that keeps you alive forever? And the immaculate conception was by an alien that performed IVF on Mary, and the “angels” in the Bible are actually all just aliens too? This question has really been the only thing challenging my faith, even though it seems preposterous.
- 40:59 – How is the Church of Rome considered “the first church” or “the church that Christ founded”, when (chronologically) the first church was in Jerusalem?
- 44:38 – I watched a video with a young earth creationist who claimed that there are dinosaur fossils that show evidence of cancer, which was, in his opinion, proof that dinosaurs existed after the fall because cancer wouldn’t have existed until after the fall. The question has kind of bothered me ever since. If dinosaurs went extinct before humans existed, why would they have had cancer?
- 50:22 – What will happen to our pets after the Rapture?
What is the mysterious “Devil’s Bible,” also known as the Codex Gigas, and should Catholics be concerned about it? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Jimmy Akin explores the strange history and legends surrounding one of the world’s most famous medieval manuscripts. He also examines the mysterious naked young man in Mark’s Gospel, whether Genesis surprisingly parallels aspects of evolution, and why meteorology is considered scientific while astrology is rejected by the Church. The episode concludes with fascinating questions about purgatory, including whether souls in purgatory can pray for others and whether the Church has ever recognized authentic communication from them. A wide-ranging discussion blending Scripture, history, theology, and the strange corners of Catholic thought.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:54 – Hey Jimmy. I really enjoy your show. Not many Catholic podcasts I’ve found address the weirder aspects of our world. My question is in regards to the Codex Gigas, or the devil’s bible. I’ve heard a lot of secular sources talk about it but not really any Catholic ones. What is your opinion on its mysterious origin story?
- 11:09 – What’s the deal with the naked young man in Mark 14:51-52?
- 19:26 – Here’s a question for you Jimmy: in Genesis 1:20-23, it discusses how God created life. It started with water animals, then birds, then land animals. Does that not in fact mirror how we acknowledge the evolution of life on earth exactly, from life beginning in water, then dinosaurs (birds) and then mammals?
- 29:48 – I sometimes wonder why it is permissible to use meteorology but not astrology. Why can I observe the movements of air parcels and high and low pressure fronts to decide I shouldn’t plan a picnic for this weekend because it will likely rain, but I cannot turn my eyes a little higher and observe the movements of the heavenly bodies to know that I shouldn’t plan my clarinet recital for August when Mercury will be in retrograde?
- 44:42 – If the souls in purgatory cannot pray for themselves. Can they pray for the other souls in purgatory or for us. Has there ever been a communication or action from a soul in purgatory that is recognized by the church as authentic?
What does the Catholic Church do when someone claims the Virgin Mary is appearing to them? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Catholic Answers apologists explain how the Church investigates reported apparitions and discerns whether they are authentic. The conversation also explores why Jewish Bibles do not include Maccabees despite the importance of Hanukkah, why Catholics believe Jesus has two natures, and how to better understand St. John Henry Newman’s famous quote about history and Catholicism. Additional questions cover biblical support for confession and Communion obligations, who Jesus was referring to when He said “Father, forgive them,” how Catholics recognize ex cathedra teachings, and when the Eucharist becomes the Body and Blood of Christ. The episode concludes with advice for non-Catholics discerning whether the Catholic Church is true.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:58 – If a person claims that Mary is appearing to them, how is that dealt with in the Church?
- 12:50 – Since Hanukkah is big in the Jewish tradition, why don’t they have Maccabees in their bible?
- 20:50 – Why do Catholics believe that Jesus has two natures vs. one nature?
- 22:56 – How do I better understand Newman’s quote, “to be rooted in history is to be Catholic?” I’ve been looking into history, and I’m not convinced.
- 28:54 – What bible verse could I use to back up the claim that we should go to confession and communion at least once a
- 33:59 – When Jesus said, “Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do,” who was guilty?
- 37:44 – How do I know when something is declared ex cathedra? How can I brush up more on papal infallibility?
- 42:30 – When exactly does the Eucharist become Jesus?
- 48:35 – I’m not Catholic. How do I know if Catholicism is the right way to go?
How can Catholics begin studying apologetics and get better at debating Protestants? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Catholic Answers apologists offer practical advice for learning Scripture, Church history, and core Catholic doctrines in a charitable and effective way. The discussion also addresses whether a pope at Vatican I really said “I am tradition,” whether watching Mass online fulfills a Catholic’s obligation after COVID-era habits, and why some Protestants strongly oppose devotion to the Blessed Virgin Mary. The episode concludes with a look at whether any of the apostles were married or had families before following Jesus. A helpful conversation on apologetics, Church teaching, and Christian history.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 15:16 – How do I begin studying to get good at debating protestants?
- 23:43 – Did the pope at Vatican 1 actually say “I am tradition”?
- 29:19 – Since COVID-19, my wife has been watching the Mass every Saturday. Is that okay?
- 40:26 – Why are some Protestants opposed to the Blessed Mother?
- 47:07 – Were any of the 12 apostles married or have children that they had to leave in order to follow Jesus?
“Is leaving the Church a mortal sin?” This question opens a discussion on the implications of faith and scandal, particularly regarding a friend’s conversion to Protestantism. Other topics include the distinction between Jesus being Catholic or Christian, the reasons for embracing Catholicism, and concerns about praying to Mary.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:36 – My friend left the Catholic church and became protestant because of scandal. Is he in Jeopardy of mortal sin?
- 16:35 – Was Jesus Catholic or Christian. What’s the difference?
- 24:45 – Explain in one minute why someone should be Catholic.
- 29:17 – I have PTSD, Anxiety, depression, how can I go to OCIA?
- 37:13 – I don’t think it’s right to pray Mary
- 47:21 – What in Vatican 2 is infallible? Does a certain word need to be included for a statement to be infallible?
“What do modern people not get about Jesus?” This question opens a discussion on contemporary misunderstandings of Christ’s nature and mission. The conversation also touches on whether Jesus always knew he was divine, the Church’s stance on penances, and the significance of Mary’s betrothal despite her virginity.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:59 – What do modern people not get about Jesus?
- 16:54 – Did Jesus always know he was divine, or did he only know this after his baptism?
- 31:39 – Has the Catholic Church Changed its views on the severity of penances?
- 42:20 – Why was Mary betrothed if she was dedicated as a virgin?
- 49:23 – I talk to Jesus, God the father, and the Holy Spirit separately. How should I address them as three persons or do I even need to? What do you call on them for?
“Why do Catholics believe in baptism?” This question opens a discussion on the significance of baptism in Catholic faith, addressing how Catholics understand being born again through this sacrament. Other topics include navigating relationships with family in the SSPX, the role of evangelism for new converts, and the interpretation of 1 Peter 3:21 regarding baptismal regeneration.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:45 – Why do Catholics believe we are born again at baptism, and how do we answer Protestants who deny it?
- 06:50 – I’m a convert and I have family who are SSPX and they say that its wrong for me to go to my church. How do I navigate this and why do they believe this?
- 13:51 – What do Catholics believe about evangelism? I’m about to be confirmed and am wondering what God will expect of me.
- 20:53 – 1 Peter 3:21 says baptism now saves you. But it seems like the later part of that verse would contradict the Catholic view of baptismal regeneration.
- 29:25 – I’m married and considering becoming a permanent deacon. I am too young for the program now, but what can I do to form myself now before I am eligible for the program at age 35?
- 33:47 – Why is artificial insemination a sin?
- 41:15 – John 3:5 says nobody can enter the kingdom of heaven unless they are born of water and the spirit. How does this square with Genesis 2:4-7, which seems to describe a baptism of Adam. Adam was already in the kingdom, so why would he need baptism?
- 46:20 – Why does the Catholic Church practice infant baptism? Shouldn’t it be later like with confirmation?
“Why do Catholics believe in Mary’s virginity?” This question opens a discussion on the biblical basis for Mary’s perpetual virginity, particularly referencing Luke 1:34. The conversation also touches on the complexities of believing in Eucharistic miracles and Marian apparitions, as well as the challenges of understanding papal comments amidst political perceptions.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:25 – Why do Catholics believe Luke 1:34 supports Mary’s perpetual virginity?
- 13:02 – Why believe in Eucharistic miracles and Marian apparitions when some of them can be proven to be false?
- 20:50 – Why do people constantly refer to our pope as liberal or conservative instead of just a faithful Catholic? Why do popes make comments that cause controversy or cause confusion?
- 32:08 – I was wondering if I need an annulment since I’m getting divorced? Why would I need it?
- 35:28 – Why do we pray to the saints and how can I help my wife see this using the bible?
- 45:15 – Why should we find comfort in the Church being right if it appears to be conforming to political correctness?
“What does it mean to say that marriage is sacred?” This question opens a discussion on the profound nature of marriage within the Catholic faith. Additional topics include how to support adult children during a parent’s annulment and navigating challenges in a marriage with an irreligious spouse. The conversation also touches on fostering virtue and healing after divorce.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:35 – What does it mean to say that marriage is sacred?
- 14:40 – I’m new to the Catholic faith. I have adult children, have received an annulment, and am getting married. How can I help my non-Catholic adult children deal with the fact that the Church is saying their mom and dad were not really married.
- 20:25 – I’m struggling with my husband who is mostly irreligious (nominally Lutheran) and very controlling. He doesn’t seem to be very interested in being part of the family. People tell me I shouldn’t stay in the marriage.
- 33:49 – As a friend of someone who recently went through a divorce, how can I bring my friend into a closer relationship with God, and help in healing from the divorce. He practices the faith but does not have a very close relationship with God.
- 41:29 – How can a wife approach her husband about growing in virtue. She is nervous about asking him to do something that would require him to sacrifice.
- 48:42 – I’ve been separated from my husband for 20 years. He is finally going to counseling, but won’t do marriage counseling because he says he needs to work on his own trauma first. Any advice?
- 53:10 – How does one learn to prepare for marriage? I’ve been married almost 40 years and wondering how to teach this to my kids.
“What is the most beautiful aspect of Catholic faith?” This question opens a discussion on the profound elements of faith that often go uncommunicated in apologetics. The conversation also touches on how to rekindle a personal relationship with God after conversion, finding beauty in the Mass despite familiarity, and responding to evangelical critiques.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:20 – What is the most beautiful aspect of the Catholic faith that you didn’t think you were communicating while doing apologetics?
- 18:50 – I’m in a similar situation. I converted due to a relationship but now I’m all head knowledge. How do I get back to the relationship part?
- 42:38 – How do you find beauty in the mass when you’ve gone all your life and have almost become desensitized to it?
- 49:00 – How would you respond to evangelical counters to what you’re saying?
“How can couples decide when they disagree?” This question addresses the complexities of decision-making in marriage, especially when spouses hold opposing views that could lead to sin. Additionally, the discussion touches on whether a Catholic can pray in a Bahai temple, how to counter Jehovah’s Witnesses’ views on the Church, and the connections between ancient Hebrew weddings and the Mass.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:45 – In a marriage, if the consciences of the husband and wife are formed to have an opposite opinion on something, such that if option A is chosen then the wife is sinning, and if option B is chosen the husband is sinning — how can they make a decision?
- 17:20 – I was invited by a friend to say a prayer in a Bahai temple. Is it okay for a Catholic to do that?
- 21:47 – I asked some Jehovah’s Witnesses how they justified their restorationist view of the Church. What scripture might they cite for their explanation, and how might I counter that?
- 29:18 – I have been studying ancient Hebrew weddings. And there are so many connections between that and the Mass. I’m wondering why we don’t see more catechesis based on this — is there some kind of danger in it?
- 42:25 – What language do you think Adam and Eve spoke?
“If Jesus was Jewish, why are we Christian?” This question opens a discussion on the roots of Christianity and its relationship to Judaism. The episode also addresses the necessity of seeking truth in a diverse worldview, the implications of practicing yoga or transcendental meditation for Catholics, and the annulment process for converts.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:20 – If Jesus was Jewish, why are we Christian?
- 12:50 – What is a succinct way to argue for the necessity of finding the truest thing? I see some non-Catholic friends happy that I’ve found a cohesive worldview, but they don’t see any reason why they should investigate such a thing.
- 20:30 – Is it objective grave matter for Catholics to practice yoga or transcendental meditation?
- 33:30 – Why do converts seeking annulments from marriages before their conversion have to go through that process? It seems like a barrier to evangelization — “Hey, you should be Catholic. But you might never be able to receive communion if you aren’t granted an annulment from a marriage you had before you were even Catholic.”
- 44:55 – Do you think the story about the woman with seven husbands that the Sadducees questioned Jesus about is the story of Tobit?
- 50:12 – I am theologically not committed. I see that Christianity seems evidence based, but I don’t feel drawn to it. Any thoughts?
“What would it take for Catholics and Orthodox to reunite?” This question opens a discussion on the complexities of Christian unity, while also addressing varied topics such as the validity of a non-Catholic marriage without civil ceremony, the necessity of confession after salvation, and the differences in gospel accounts of the women at the tomb.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:35 – What would it take for the Catholics and Orthodox to reunite?
- 14:48 – Is my mom’s marriage valid? She and he are non-Catholic but baptized. She didn’t get civilly married, but it was a public ceremony with witnesses. Both were married before, but those previous spouses have died.
- 18:30 – I was told that once you are saved there is no need for confession. How does a Catholic respond to that?
- 29:29 – I heard a Protestant say we have the same spirit that raised Lazarus from the dead. Is that true?
- 35:00 – Why do the four gospels list different women at the tomb?
- 40:16 – My wife and I are converts. We were non-Catholics when we married. It was a non-Church ceremony at an embassy. There were not vows. But it was a legal marriage. Are we married in the Church? Do we need to have it convalidated?
- 47:27 – Does the Church infallibly teach that Mary had no actual sin?
- 51:05 – Could you comment on how the prodigal son narrative relates to the act of confession? Is this parable an example of confession?
“Did Mary and Joseph doubt Jesus?” This question leads to a discussion about their understanding of His identity, especially during the incident at the temple. Other topics include the appropriateness of repeating prayers for healing, navigating faith in the context of divorce, and clarifying the status of the Ethiopian Bible.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:10 – Did Mary and Joseph not trust or know who Jesus was by the time they lost him at the temple?
- 14:15 – Is it wrong to repeat prayers? For example, to ask many times for a sick friend to be healed?
- 28:40 – I’m a godparent to a child in a family where the husband and wife are divorcing.
- 36:50 – What is the status of the Ethiopian Bible? Is it considered inspired?
- 44:30 – I was born and raised Catholic and am starting to get back into it. My wife was raised non-Catholic and just converted. In OCIA we got a lot of answers that contradicted Church teaching. Different people are giving different answers that contradict. How do I know what is right?
“Who was the first Catholic?” This question opens a discussion that also touches on the nature of souls in animals, St. Paul’s views on the second coming, and the meaning behind Jesus’ words about His yoke. The conversation further explores the differences between the King James Version and other biblical texts, as well as Catholic beliefs regarding the Eucharist.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:55 – Who was the first Catholic?
- 07:16 – How do you explain to people that animals don’t have souls?
- 16:32 – I think St. Paul argued that many generations will pass before the second coming. What are your thoughts on that?
- 24:42 – What does it mean when Jesus says my yoke and burden are light?
- 31:45 – What do we know about the KJV? How does it compare to the Ethiopian bible and the original bible?
- 41:33 – Do we as Catholics believe that we’re eating the resurrected body of Christ or are we eating the crucified body of Christ?
- 47:40 – How hard is it to leave Mormonism?
- 53:15 – Do Mormons have a concept of a god as a first principle?
“Do Catholics and Mormons worship the same God?” This question opens a discussion on the fundamental differences in how each faith views God. Additional topics include the reasons behind God’s silence for two millennia, the challenges faced by former satanists in addressing Mormon beliefs, and the complexities of LDS doctrines and their changes over time.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:15 – What’s the difference in how Catholics and Mormons view God?
- 12:51 – My father is not baptized but is open to dialogue. His best friend is Mormon so he is always listening to these perspectives. He asked, Why hasn’t God spoken to his people directly for two-thousand years?
- 18:17 – I’m a former satanist and a new Catholic. How do I help persuade people from not going down the path of Mormonism?
- 30:17 – According to the LDS who arranges who gets what planet? How do they justify changing doctrines?
- 37:06 – I’ve heard that Joseph Smith had performed miracles. Is there any evidence of this?
- 48:21 – I was born and raised Catholic. I was Mormon for 45 years and am now attending a Catholic church. How can you know that the early church had it right?
“What can angels do for us?” This question opens a discussion on the role of angels in our daily lives, including how they might help us feel more connected to our guardian angels. Other topics include the nature of angelic communication with the deceased, the reasons behind God’s creation of angels, and the intriguing portrayal of angels in art versus scripture.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:10 – What Can Angels Do in our Daily Lives?
- 12:55 – My grandparents died in 2006. Can my grandparents communicate with me through angels? SENDS Secrets from heaven.
- 17:59 – How can you feel more connected to your guardian angel?
- 22:05 – Do we know why God created angels?
- 29:39 – Do angels give grace, or help in distributing graces?
- 33:32 – Can you comment on why angels are portrayed in art as little babies with wings, but in the Bible they seem like they would actually be frightening?
- 36:14 – Can you comment on the angels’ reaction in the book of Job?
- 44:35 – When we say the prayer to our guardian angel, ever this day be “at my side,” what does that really mean since angels are in heaven?
- 48:20 – How do our guardian angels protect us? The way the Bible describes them it seems like they would be too big.
- 50:04 – What do I call my guardian angel?
- 51:52 – Aquinas says angels don’t know your thoughts. If that is true then how do guardian angels know what you are thinking?
“Can we have absolute assurance of salvation?” This question opens a discussion on the nature of faith and security in salvation. Other topics include responding to Southern Baptist views on the parable of Lazarus, the concerns of a Protestant considering OCIA, and strategies for evangelizing Muslims.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:50 – Can We Have Absolute Assurance of Salvation?
- 12:38 – How do you respond to a Southern Baptist that denies the story of the Lazarus and rich man establishes the immediate judgement?
- 20:13 – I’m protestant and considering OCIA but I hesitate on the rules that change in Catholics. How do we know rules won’t change in the future like attending Sunday mass, women veiling, etc.?
- 32:37 – Is it correct to say the Sadducees and Pharisees had a similar relationship as Catholics and Protestants. Is this true?
- 43:16 – How do we effectively evangelize Muslims especially when they come across as arrogant and even resort to using foul language?
- 50:30 – How do I better explain apologetics to a crowd that is not religious at work?
“How is the Mass a sacrifice if nothing seems to be sacrificed?” This question opens a discussion on the nature of the Mass, alongside inquiries about the practice of intinction in the U.S. and the reasons behind the removal of kneelers in some churches. Additional topics include the relationship between the Mass and Hebrews 10:14, and proper etiquette before Mass.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:40 – How is the Mass a Sacrifice if nothing seems to be sacrificed?
- 12:37 – How common is intinction practiced in the US?
- 15:11 – I’m not Catholic. Why did the Church take out kneelers?
- 23:26 – How does the Mass not contradict Hebrews 10:14?
- 33:03 – Is it licit to say, “my Lord and God” during the consecration?
- 41:19 – Is there proper etiquette for silence prior to mass?
- 44:58 – I am a protestant and I would like to understand the order of the mass. Could you help me make it understandable?
- 50:25 – When did priests start wearing vestments?
- 52:03 – Why do the priests stay away from telling people what they need to do at home during the homily?
“How do you reach young people online and teach faith?” This question opens a discussion on effective strategies for engaging youth in their faith journey. Additional topics include addressing concerns about pre-marital sex with college students and the challenges faced by religious educators in reaching teens. The conversation also touches on teaching methods for confirmation classes and engaging late teens exploring Catholicism.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:22 – How do you reach young people online to help them encounter Christ offline?
- 07:56 – How do I explain to my niece who is in college who only sees the problem with pre-marital sex the potential of getting pregnant even though she was raised Catholic?
- 15:21 – I’m a religious educator for teens and I feel like I don’t have enough resources to reach them. What are your thoughts?
- 29:11 – I’m a catechist. Is it unrealistic to only teach in a classroom setting for 11–17-year-olds?
- 39:53 – I’m a confirmation teacher. How do I get them to talk?
- 47:48 – I’m a catechist and am getting a lot of late teens and early 20’s who want to explore Catholicism but have no background in faith. Where do you recommend I begin with them?
“Are aborted babies doomed to hell?” This question leads to a discussion on the Church’s teachings regarding the fate of aborted infants. Additionally, the conversation touches on whether the magisterium can override scripture and how to engage with a Protestant partner about differing interpretations of faith.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:38 – Does the Church teach that aborted babies are doomed to hell?
- 19:02 – Can the magisterium override scripture?
- 30:55 – What are your thoughts on when conversing with a protestant who adheres to sola scriptura about pointing out how they should accept one’s interpretation of scripture since they don’t accept any other authority?
- 42:13 – I’m protestant dating a Catholic. I found out that her understanding of Catholicism is lacking. How do I talk to her and correct her without sounding condescending?
- 50:00 – If we were meant for the afterlife, how come we all fight death?
“How can I help my friend consider Catholicism?” This question opens a discussion on various approaches to sharing faith, including how to engage with family members who oppose conversion. Other topics include the Church’s evolving stance on women and birth control, the moral implications of supporting war, and addressing doubts about salvation among non-Catholic friends.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:11 – How do you talk to a parent or sibling who is strongly opposed to one’s desires to become Catholic?
- 20:28 – There’s evidence that the Church position on women has changed over the years. Doesn’t allow birth control because of natural law, vs the subjugation of women being a part of natural law? The Church’s denial of birth control contradicts the church’s rejection of the subjugation of women.
- 28:42 – I’m a veteran. Is it a mortal sin to support a war?
- 32:29 – I’m a convert. My wife has no interest. How can I gently nudge her?
- 43:14 – My non-Catholic friend said she says a lot of division among Catholic influencers online especially about salvation. This has caused her to doubt and would like clarification on exactly what the Church teaches on salvation? How can I help her consider Catholicism?
- 50:11 – My friend is considering Catholicism but his big hang up is female altar servers. He says it’s a rupture from tradition. How can I help guide him?
“How Do I Witness to Others?” This question leads to a discussion about the importance of faith in the family when considering baptism. Other topics include effective ways for new Catholics to witness to non-Catholics and a hopeful interpretation of Jesus’ teaching on marriage in heaven.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:05 – I always believed baptizing a baby should be immediate. I’ve recently heard that if the family isn’t practicing the faith, they maybe shouldn’t. Is this true?
- 18:10 – I’m a new Catholic. What is the best way to witness others, especially non-Catholic?
- 40:00 – We know Jesus said there is no marriage in heaven. How do we look at this passage with optimism?
“Is infant baptism necessary?” This question leads to a concise defense of the practice, addressing its theological significance. Additionally, the discussion covers the morality of eating meat and examines whether Judas’s actions challenge the concept of eternal security. The episode also delves into the fate of souls grappling with the distinction between venial and mortal sins.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:55 – What’s the one minute defense for infant baptism?
- 09:18 – Why is it morally okay to eat meat?
- 17:46 – Does Judas disprove once saved always saved?
- 36:50 – What happens to the soul of a person who thinks they commit a venial sin but is actually a mortal sin?
“What is the gift of tongues?” This question opens a discussion on the Catholic understanding of this spiritual phenomenon. Additionally, the conversation touches on why polygamy may not serve as a strong apologetical argument for Mormons, and clarifies the mention of two Zechariahs in the Old Testament during a debate.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:00 – What is the Catholic understanding of the gift of tongues?
- 19:28 – Why wouldn’t polygamy be a good apologetical argument towards mormons if Jesus himself restored marriage towards its original intention?
- 36:33 – You mentioned 2 Zechariahs in the OT. Can you explain what you meant in your debate?
- 48:22 – Who is Jesus referring to when he tells Peter, do you love me more than these?
“What’s the one-minute defense for the papacy?” This question sets the stage for a discussion that also addresses the strongest arguments for infant baptism, the reasons behind the anti-Catholic stance of Seventh Day Adventists, and how to discern the presence of the Holy Spirit in someone’s life.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:44 – What’s the one-minute defense for the papacy?
- 10:30 – What are the strongest arguments to convince someone to baptize their baby?
- 18:05 – Why are Seventh Day Adventist so Anti-Catholic?
- 36:20 – How do we know when someone has the Holy Spirit?
“Are there doctrinal differences on the Septuagint?” This question leads to a discussion on the major distinctions between Protestant and Catholic views, particularly regarding the seven additional books. The conversation also touches on the moral implications of generative AI, the Church’s response to potential ex-cathedra proclamations, and the interpretation of visions experienced during psychedelic ceremonies.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:40 – Are there any major doctrinal differences between Protestants and Catholics in regards to the Septuagint apart from the 7 books?
- 14:44 – What are the moral implications of using generative AI? Where is the line on when it’s sinful?
- 36:50 – My protestant friend asked me this: what would happen if the pope tried to proclaim ex-cathedra something contrary to Church teaching? Does the Church have a contingency plan?
- 47:24 – What do we make of people who have visions on psychedelics who use them as a spiritual ceremony?
“Do dinosaurs create a problem for Catholic beliefs?” This question opens a discussion on the intersection of faith and science, while also addressing the Catholic position on Revelation and the end times. Additionally, the conversation touches on how to respond to those who dismiss the importance of detailed faith discussions and the claims of personal apostolic authority.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 08:40 – Do dinosaurs create a problem for Catholic beliefs?
- 21:34 – What is the Catholic position on Revelation and the end times?
- 39:49 – How do I respond to people who think it’s not important to go into the details of the faith? They think it’s irrelevant.
- 50:33 – How do I respond to my dad who believes he has apostolic authority because he says he follows the bible?
“What verses prove Peter was the Pope?” This question opens a discussion on the biblical foundations of papal authority, including key verses that support this claim. Other topics addressed include the significance of Jesus changing Peter’s name, the perpetual nature of the Petrine office, and how to approach conversations about Catholicism.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:26 – What Bible Verses Best Support that Peter was the Pope?
- 24:45 – Why did Jesus Change Peter’s name?
- 29:15 – How do we know the Petrine office is perpetual?
- 36:27 – Are the apostles also bishops and how does the petrine ministry affect this?
- 42:46 – I’ve been Christian for a year. How do I tell my protestant girlfriend that I live with that I’m interested in Catholicism and Orthodoxy?
- 49:45 – Do we see anywhere in the bible where Peter exercises his authority?
“Does anxiety mean I’m a bad Christian?” This question opens a discussion on the true causes of anxiety, challenging common misconceptions. Other topics include the struggle of trusting God amidst worry, the appropriateness of seeking help for anxiety, and effective therapeutic approaches for childhood wounds.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:55 – Most people think that anxiety comes from worrying about problems, but you say that isn’t the case. What IS the real cause of anxiety?
- 06:14 – Does having anxiety mean that I don’t trust God enough (or am a bad Christian)?
- 08:30 – I keep giving a particular situation to God, but I still keep thinking/worrying about it. What am I doing wrong?
- 10:35 – Am I somehow letting God down by seeking help for anxiety? What kind of help works best (counseling? medication?)
- 15:25 – When it comes to childhood wounds and overcoming them. What do you recommend in terms of therapy that would be effective?
- 19:17 – I have a lot of anxiety due to issues with my marriage and need guidance on how to overcome it.
- 21:32 – My husband has cancer and has caused so much anxiety. I went on a Catholic mindfulness retreat and helped so much. And communicating and praying with loved ones has helped.
- 29:25 – My 10-year-old has anxiety. How can I help him?
- 34:50 – My adult children are starting to take on leadership in our family business and are basically cutting me out. How do I overcome this anxiety and tension that’s building?
- 41:05 – I’m dealing with brain damage and anxiety. How do I deal with anxiety about going to confession?
- 45:41 – What’s the difference between secular counseling and Catholic counseling?
- 50:06 – How do people learn to deal with anxiety if there is no counselor?
“Did God harden Pharaoh’s heart?” This question opens a discussion on divine sovereignty and free will, alongside inquiries about the ownership of cattle by Israelites during the plagues, the significance of myrrh given to Jesus, and the meaning behind God’s rest on the Sabbath. Each topic invites a deeper understanding of faith and scripture.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:32 – Ex 9. Regarding the 5th plague and the cattle dying. It says that the Israelites had cattle. Were slaves allowed to own cattle?
- 07:21 – Regarding the Myrrh given to Jesus by the Magi. Do we have any evidence that this was more than just embalming material for death but rather something tied to the priesthood?
- 15:08 – Regarding the sabbath. Why did God need to rest on the last day if he doesn’t get tired?
- 22:59 – Did God take away the pharaoh’s free will when he hardened his heart in Exodus 21?
- 29:44 – Who did God marry at the wedding at Cana? Why are there 14 stations of the cross?
- 44:25 – The first will be last and last will be first. Does that mean everyone will go to heaven?
- 49:10 – Jesus told his disciples his Father’s house has many rooms. What does that mean?
- 51:45 – What was the relationship God had with the Israelites and how did Jesus dying for our sins change that? What exactly changed for humans?
“Why did God call the Hebrews to slaughter the Canaanites?” This question opens a discussion on divine judgment and love, addressing complex themes in Scripture. Other topics include God’s love for all people, the Israelites’ understanding of judgment and purgatory, and the significance of wave offerings in Exodus and Leviticus.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:45 – Why did God call the Hebrews to slaughter the Canaanites?
- 18:11 – Is there anywhere in the bible that can lead us to believe that God loves all people in hell?
- 29:21 – Since the Israelites did not have a clear sense of what the afterlife was like, Do they have any written documentation of their understanding of the particular judgement, final judgement and purgatory?
- 40:51 – In Exodus and Leviticus they talk about doing a wave offering but don’t explain what that is. What is it?
- 48:16 – How do we show in the OT that the 3 days of Jesus were meant to be figurative not literal 3 days apart from the story of Jonah?
- 51:24 – Jesus Said I am the way, truth and life. Why do we have to believe that?
“Do Catholics treat Mary like a God?” This question opens a discussion on the role of Mary in Catholicism, addressing misconceptions about worship. The conversation also touches on whether Mary guided the writing of the Gospel of John and clarifies how Catholics view her as the New Eve, alongside the significance of Marian apparitions and the practice of praying to her.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:00 – Do Catholics treat Mary like a God?
- 10:35 – Was Mary the guide for the writing of the Gospel of John?
- 14:00 – How do I get across that Catholics don’t worship Mary, and that this is not a threat?
- 18:47 – Can you explain Mary as the new Eve?
- 36:19 – Why does William believe there has been so many Marian apparitions and not others?
- 43:13 – There is not one example in the Bible to pray to Mary, so why do we pray to Mary? Abraham is called the father of faith and not even he has an example of people praying to him.
“What convinced Tim to leave Evangelicalism?” Tim shares his personal journey and the theological insights that shaped his faith transition. The discussion also touches on the significance of penance in Catholic practice and addresses the nature of the Eucharist, including how it retains its breadlike form while being the body and blood of Christ.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:30 – What Convinced Tim to Leave Evangelicalism?
- 12:54 – Why do Catholics practice of penance?
- 28:50 – How can we call the Eucharist the body and blood when it keeps the breadlike form?
- 32:42 – How do you approach the question, “what is the church” with scripture?
- 39:28 – How can I respond to Hebrew 4 verse 16, “We can boldly approach the throne of God” as a refute against intercessory prayers?
“Is being unmarried a call to priesthood?” This question opens a discussion on the relationship between personal vocation and divine calling, while also addressing how to explain the Rosary to Protestants and the nature of purgatory. Other topics include principles for giving to the poor and the implications of Vatican II’s teachings on interfaith worship.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:27 – I’m 32 and unmarried. Is this a sign I’m called to priesthood? Married life is still preferable, but I believe whether I’m a priest or married is up to God, not me.
- 08:35 – How do I explain and defend the Rosary to Protestants?
- 18:50 – Why isn’t purgatory instant? Why does it need to exist in general?
- 23:35 – Should we give money to people living on the streets? What’s a good general principle for giving to the poor?
- 37:32 – Can you explain Vatican II’s teaching that we worship the same God as Jews and Muslims? It seems anti-trinitarian to me.
- 49:15 – How do you balance calling out heresy with being kind to your opponent in debate? When are you more direct vs. more charitable?
- 53:30 – Responding to an atheist dilemma. Is Jesus’ sacrifice really a “Sacrifice” at all if he knew he was coming back? How do I respond to this?
“Are Catholics modern-day Pharisees?” This question opens a discussion on the role of tradition and faith in Catholicism. The conversation also touches on reasonable expectations for children at Mass, responses to LDS beliefs about marriage in heaven, and the significance of the Eucharist in receiving grace.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:55 – Are Catholics modern-day pharisees?
- 18:13 – What are reasonable expectations for children at Mass?
- 23:51 – How to respond to LDS members who believe they are still married in heaven?
- 29:30 – Do Protestants worship God even though they do not have the Eucharist?
- 34:45 – How exactly does the Eucharist give us Grace?
- 47:21 – Can Catholics and Mormons pray together? And how do I explain the intercession of Mary and the Saints?
“What are the Parameters for Papal Infallibility?” This question opens a discussion on the true nature of the Eucharist, while also addressing Mary’s age at the Annunciation, the parameters of Papal Infallibility, and the role of saints in intercession. These topics highlight the rich tapestry of Catholic belief and practice.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:56 – What if the Eucharist is just a symbol?
- 14:12 – What age was Mary at the Annunciation?
- 18:01 – What are the parameters for Papal Infallibility?
- 29:08 – How do I navigate the relationship with my daughter to teach my granddaughter the Faith?
- 37:48 – Why would I have a saint or Mary intercede for me when I can go directly to God with my prayers?
- 47:42 – Why does the church not label Jews, Muslims, and Protestants heretics?
“Is the Assumption of Mary in Scripture?” This question leads to a discussion on the biblical basis for Mary’s Assumption, alongside other topics such as the differing beliefs about the Eucharist between Catholics and Protestants, and the role of priests in forgiving sins. The conversation also touches on the implications of being baptized Catholic and raised in a different faith.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 20:15 – Is the Assumption of Mary discussed in scripture?
- 29:13 – If the Eucharist is the body and blood of Christ for Catholics why is it not the same for protestants?
- 41:04 – I was baptized Catholic as an infant but raised in the Baptist church, am I Catholic?
- 46:14 – Why do Catholics believe that priests can forgive sins?
- 51:11 – What is the Dogma of the Assumption?
“Do Catholics really eat God?” This question delves into the belief in the Eucharist and its significance in Catholic faith. The discussion also touches on the changes brought by Vatican II, the appropriateness of addressing minor issues with a visiting priest, and the role of personal expressions during Mass for those from different backgrounds.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 17:31 – Do Catholics really believe that they are eating God literally?
- 31:33 – Why did we have the change of Vatican II?
- 44:04 – Should I bring up something minor about a visiting priest that isn’t in the rubric of the Mass?
- 49:29 – I am coming from a protestant background that included raising our hands often. Would some be inappropriate for the Mass?
- 53:54 – Why do we say Mary “merited to bear” Jesus in Regina Caeli when it was God’s doing?
“How can I heal a strained relationship?” This episode addresses practical steps for mending relationships, including four tips for healing and insights on reconciling childhood trauma. Additionally, the discussion touches on honoring parents as a Catholic and navigating complex family dynamics after forgiveness.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:18 – What are four tips for healing a strained relationship?
- 12:03 – How do you reconcile childhood trauma?
- 15:42 – Listen, Lead, Love, Let go.
- 18:01 – Resentment
- 20:42 – How can I honor my parents now that I am a Catholic?
- 33:59 – I have forgiven my family for various things, but my wife hasn’t. I have let it go, but it is causing strain.
- 43:18 – I have had a hurt relationship; I was married outside the church in an abusive relationship. I am now married in the church, but I still feel like I need healing. (Guidance)
- 46:19 – My father passed away, my mom is giving the family house to my brother when it was promised to me. How can I respond to this best?
- 52:31 – To what degree to talk about something controversial or let it go if we know that it will cause someone to be upset?
Questions Covered:
- 05:35 – Why are the 10 Commandments different for Catholics and Protestants?
- 14:46 – Why does the Church take the transubstantiation view over the consubstantiation view?
- 20:52 – How does the Church balance orthodoxy and heterodoxy with everything going on?
- 25:26 – Is it possible for a laicized priest to ever be reinstated?
- 29:00 – Under what circumstances does a priest allow a non-Catholic to participate in the Eucharist?
- 36:03 – Is there any room in Catholicism for being a millenialist?
- 42:10 – Who took over after Peter?
- 51:37 – Do I really need to seek out indulgences?
Questions Covered:
- 03:18 – What is Ecumenism?
- 06:38 – Why did Mary have to be immaculately conceived?
- 14:45 – Does Galatians 1:8 talk about the apostles failing to pass on the gospel?
- 17:45 – Why is there a separation of church and state?
- 25:06 – Is sacramental marriage possible without a civil marriage?
- 29:07 – How do I discern the papacy claims on both the Catholic and Orthodox sides?
- 44:33 – What are the last two declared infallible doctrines of the Catholic Church?
- 46:06 – Would Christotokos be more correct than Theotokos?
- 50:26 – Why do people think the Church was started in the 300s?
“Is the Road to Emmaus the First Mass?” This question opens a discussion on the significance of the Emmaus encounter, while also addressing when the first Mass after the resurrection occurred and the Catholic understanding of the order of Melchizedek. Additional topics include the appropriateness of receiving communion in the hand and the history of the doxology.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:50 – When was the first mass after the resurrection?
- 07:21 – I know there is one sacrifice but is it one or many offerings?
- 11:50 – What is the catholic view, if there is a view, on the order of melchizedek? Is there an accepted catholic teaching?
- 14:50 – Is it appropriate to receive communion on the hand?
- 17:30 – What’s the history or background of the doxology?
- 20:10 – What do the Hanc Igitur and communicantes mean in the roman canon and what do they mean during easter?
- 23:45 – Was the Road to Emmaus the First mass or was the last supper the first mass?
- 28:49 – How do I approach someone who receives communion who you know shouldn’t? Where in the bible can I show people to encourage them to go to mass every Sunday?
- 37:40 – My friend loudly says ‘my Lord and my God’ during the consecration. Is this appropriate?
- 42:10 – Did Cy blow it by saying the sorrowful mysteries during the Easter octave?
- 46:10 – Is it true to say everything in the Church builds towards the Mass?
- 49:15 – Does Divine Mercy Sunday count as to fulfill the obligation since it’s later in the day?
“Can God force you to be a priest?” This question opens a discussion on vocation and discernment, addressing the complexities of divine calling. Other topics include how individuals can establish their own religious orders, the challenges of pursuing a diaconate while managing military commitments, and the implications of missing one’s vocation.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:20 – Can God force me to be a priest?
- 10:48 – If someone has a call to religious life, how do people go about creating their own convents and religious orders?
- 16:20 – I feel a call to the diaconate. I’m military and the classes conflict with my time. How much effort should I put into doing this? Should I talk to my bishop about it?
- 20:42 – What if you miss your vocation?
- 25:12 – What is a vocation?
- 29:19 – I feel a call to disciple others but am having a hard time figuring out what that looks like. What advice do you have?
- 35:30 – I’m a revert and am 37. Is it too late for me to discern a vocation?
- 40:10 – If a person who never marries or becomes a priest can have an equally fulfilling life, aren’t they missing something?
- 43:35 – Why do seminaries require so much education for people to just be priests and not bishops?
- 46:40 – What is the ministry of acolyte? Is it just an adult altar boy or is it deeper than that?
- 49:23 – I am a dedicated single man and find my life very fulfilling.
- 51:35 – I’m Protestant. Why is celibacy a requisite for the priesthood?
“Iceland Priest Faces Jail Threat for saying LGBT Identifying People Can Be Chaste” This episode presents a discussion on the ongoing celebration of Easter and the implications of a priest in Iceland facing jail for his views on chastity. The episode also touches on the legacy of Paul Ehrlich, author of “The Population Bomb,” and the concept of just war, showcasing a range of important topics.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:15 – Keeping up celebration of Easter
- 08:11 – Iceland Priest faces jail threat for saying LGBT people can be chaste
- 29:05 – Death of Paul Ehrlich, author of The Population Bomb
- 47:00 – Just war
The conversation touches on Peter Thiel’s views regarding the Antichrist and examines recent New York Times reports on adult Catholic converts, highlighting the diverse experiences within the Church today.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:22 – Peter Thiel and the anti-Christ
- 40:48 – New York Times reports on adult Catholic converts
“Were the authors of the Gospels the apostles, specifically Matthew?” This question opens a discussion on the authorship of the Gospels, while also addressing varied topics such as overcoming objections to confession from family, the Church’s stance on the death penalty, and advice for presenting the case for the Eucharist to friends.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:00 – Were the Authors of the gospels the apostles, specifically Matthew?
- 05:20 – I’m a convert. How do I overcome my parents’ objection to confession?
- 18:51 – The CCC 2267 goes against the death penalty but the bible says it’s permitted. Why is the Church trying to get rid of it?
- 23:45 – What advice would you have for my son who is presenting the case for the eucharist to his friends, some of whom are protestant?
- 33:54 – excluding papal infallibility, what’s the possibility for a pope to lead his people into theological error?
- 41:20 – How does it work for the accidents of the eucharist still being of bread?
- 46:03 – Is the use of contraception allowed in certain circumstances?
“What if Paul said no to God?” This question opens a discussion on the implications of free will in faith, while also addressing the respect the laity owes to Church hierarchy and the Church’s stance on private revelations after Jesus. Other topics include the teachings on the road to Emmaus and the sin of presumption, showcasing a variety of theological inquiries.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:50 – What if Paul said no to God?
- 12:10 – How much respect and reverence does the laity owe to the hierarchy? Do we have to kiss their ring etc.?
- 20:52 – If the Catechism says there is no further revelation after Jesus, why does the Church still accept private revelation that came later?
- 32:22 – On the road to Emmaus, was Jesus teaching something new that they didn’t know?
- 40:11 – What is the sin of presumption?
- 46:15 – What does the Church say about the medical treatment of ectopic pregnancies?
- 52:00 – Were the Authors of the gospels the apostles, specifically Matthew?
How many messianic prophecies are found in Scripture, and how do they point to Jesus? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Catholic Answers apologists explore the Old Testament foundations of the Messiah and how Jesus fulfills them. They discuss the most important messianic texts and passages, address whether people in Jesus’ time were sincerely seeking the Messiah, and examine common objections—such as why Jesus didn’t immediately bring universal peace. The conversation also explains why the apostles expected a conquering king, the difference between “Messiah” and “Lord,” and whether Jesus’ miracles would have been recognized as messianic signs. A clear and compelling look at how Scripture reveals Jesus as the promised Messiah.Join the Catholic Answers Live Club NewsletterInvite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.comQuestions Covered:04:29 – How many messianic prophecies are in scripture? 10:20 – Are the people questioning Jesus sincerely trying to figure out if Jesus is the Messiah? 15:30 – What are the main messianic texts? 18:45 – What are some of the main messianic passages? 24:20 – What do you find to be the most compelling messianic prophecy? 31:46 – Objection: Jesus wasn’t the Messiah because he didn’t usher in eternal peace. 37:11 – Why did the apostles keep expecting Jesus to be the conquering king messiah? 46:10 – What’s the difference between messiah and lord? 53:08 – Would people have recognized something messianic about Jesus’ healings?
How many times did Jesus appear after His Resurrection—and where did these appearances take place? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Catholic Answers apologists walk through the key post-Resurrection appearances of Christ, from the Upper Room to the road to Emmaus and beyond. They explain what happened during the 40 days leading up to the Ascension, the significance of Jesus appearing to the apostles, and how these encounters strengthen the case for the Resurrection. The discussion also covers the Ascension from the Mount of Olives and Christ’s later appearance to St. Paul on the road to Damascus. A clear and compelling look at one of the most important periods in Christian history.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:45 – In the Bible, how many times did Jesus appear between the Resurrection and the Ascension?
- 16:55 – Where did he physically appear during the 40 days?
- 29:00 – What happened when he appeared in the Upper Room?
- 36:12 – Mount of Olives and the Ascension.
- 44:20 – Appearing to Paul on the Road to Damascus.
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live Classics, Fr. Hugh Barbour breaks down the sacrifice of Jesus on the cross with a focus on the Precious Blood of Jesus.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live Classics, Fr. Paul Check breaks down the sacrifice of Jesus on the cross.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
“How can I believe in the Trinity?” This question opens a discussion on the complexities of faith, including concerns about conversion from Protestantism and the potential conflict with family beliefs. Other topics include the challenges of Catholic practices versus dogma and the significance of adoration in the conversion process.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:28 – I need help believing in the Trinity.
- 18:44 – I was raised Protestant and my parents are anti-Catholic. Would it be dishonoring my parents to convert?
- 29:02 – I’m not Catholic because of how Catholicism is practiced and not necessarily about dogma.
- 35:07 – My one hang up to convert is adoration.
- 50:07 – Is there any connection between Matthew 7:24-27 and Matthew 16:18?
“Can prayer to saints be justified?” This question opens a discussion on the role of saints in Catholicism, addressing concerns about mediation and the nature of prayer. Other topics include skepticism about the credibility of the Gospels and the application of indulgences, highlighting the diverse perspectives on these theological issues.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 2:00 – I’m not Catholic because I think Joe changes the gospels for his own gain and reduces the credibility of the real gospel.
- 20:29 – I think prayer to saints violates the idea that Jesus is the one mediator.
- 42:12 – I don’t believe in indulgences specifically how they can be applied to others.
“How can I respond to Protestant objections about Scripture?” This episode addresses this question while also tackling varied topics such as how to engage with a friend’s doubts about the resurrection, responding to claims about dietary restrictions from non-Catholic Bible studies, and discussing the significance of the Deuterocanonical books.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:50 – I feel like Catholics come across as first century historians about a God that wants nothing to do with you.
- 12:20 – My friend’s dad doesn’t believe Jesus really rose from the dead. How can I object to his premise?
- 21:35 – I have a relative who is going to a non-Catholic bible study. They were told that they are not supposed to eat pork or else they will be condemned. How do I respond?
- 28:49 – What is your response to protestants who reject the seven extra books we have?
- 39:40 – Do Catholics believe that there is no more procreation in the afterlife?
- 45:41 – Why are Holy Thursday and Good Friday not considered holy days of obligation?
- 47:51 – My protestant friend said that they reject the Deuterocanon because they came in at a time where no new prophecies would come. How do I respond to that?
“Why does God call sinners to grace and not the damned?” This question raises important theological discussions about divine mercy and justice. Other topics addressed include how Catholics believe they can attain heaven, the procession of the Holy Spirit, and the significance of choosing a saint’s name for baptism.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:20 – Catholicism doesn’t make sense to me because it says God moves a sinner to repentance by grace and yet he doesn’t do that for the damned. If God were all-loving, then wouldn’t he move the damned to repentance and forgive them?
- 13:28 – How do Catholics make it to heaven?
- 16:50 – Why do we say the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father and Son and why do the Orthodox disagree?
- 22:44 – If this is the Church Jesus founded, how is it that the Church has done so much evil in Canada, the crusades?
- 45:33 – I’m getting baptized this Saturday. What is the meaning of picking a saint’s name for baptism?
- 52:30 – Why go to general confession and why repeatedly confess the same sins over and over again?
“What is our authority structure?” This question leads to a discussion on the implications of Sola Scriptura and how Catholics understand authority through both Tradition and Scripture. Other topics include how Catholics respond to 2 Timothy’s assertion about Scripture’s profitability and the significance of 1 Timothy 3:15 regarding the Church as the pillar and foundation of truth.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:33 – If Sola Scriptura is Wrong, Then what does our authority structure look like?
- 13:54 – How do Catholics refute protestant understanding of 2 Tim, All scripture is profitable.
- 21:00 – 1 Tim 3:15 says the Church is the pillar and foundation. How do protestants get around that scripture?
- 29:33 – I think another evidence for being against sola scriptura is Satan using scripture to tempt Jesus. What are your thoughts on that?
- 32:35 – What exactly is Tradition?
- 42:14 – How do you deal with the objection from protestants about wisdom and not being in their canon but only accept Sola Scriptura?
“How do you talk about chastity to an indifferent generation?” This question opens a discussion on the challenges of conveying the importance of chastity today. Other topics include seeking intimacy without lust in relationships, addressing concerns about the Church’s stance on sexism, and offering guidance to a daughter navigating attraction in dating.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:40 – How do you talk about chastity to an indifferent generation?
- 13:13 – I have been intimate with my girlfriend in an inappropriate way. How do I seek intimacy with her without lusting over her body?
- 16:30 – In light of the scriptures of the OT. How would you respond that the Church is not sexist?
- 29:24 – What words of wisdom could I offer to my 26-year-old daughter who is dating someone she is not physically attracted to because she is afraid, she can’t find any nice guys?
- 34:15 – At what point is pornography use habitual, making it a venial sin and not a mortal sin?
- 41:21 – Why doesn’t the Church attack the American sexual revolution? If they are the enemy why not attack them to destroy it?
“Is it a sin to marry outside your faith?” This question opens a discussion on the nuances of faith and relationships, including interpretations of 2 Corinthians and the concept of being unequally yoked. Other topics addressed include the implications of Matthew 7:6 on sharing scripture, the nature of particular judgment, and the meaning of being poor in spirit.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:45 – When discussing 2 Corinthians where Paul mentions not being unequally yoked, my protestant friend argued is it a sin to marry outside your own faith. I argue that Paul was giving his own opinion and not giving a commandment from God. Is this a proper response?
- 13:33 – Matthew 7:6 says don’t throw pearls to swine. Would giving bibles to the homeless be throwing pearls to swine?
- 18:30 – How would I prove biblically that there is a particular judgement and not a resting in Christ until the final judgement? Do people go to Hades now or do they go to Gehenna?
- 37:05 – How do Catholics combat free grace theology using scripture?
- 45:38 – In John 21:15 Jesus says to Peter, “do you love me more than these?” Who are “these”?
- 48:30 – At the end of Acts, Paul was told he didn’t do anything wrong. Why then was Paul beheaded?
- 53:01 – What does it mean to be poor in spirit?
“Did Jesus use a racial slur against the woman in Mt. 15:26?” This question opens a discussion on the complexities of scripture interpretation. Other topics include the Catholic understanding of faith and works as discussed by Paul, and how to reconcile 2 Corinthians 5:8 with the doctrine of purgatory, showcasing a range of theological inquiries.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:44 – Did Jesus use a racial slur against the woman in Mt. 15:26?
- 15:23 – How do Catholics understand when Paul says faith apart from works of the law?
- 29:30 – Jesus tells when we fast and pray we are to do things a certain way. Do we follow exactly what he says or do we follow how the Church tells us to? If the fasting is in quiet, how do we witness to people?
- 41:15 – How do we reconcile 2 Cor 5:8, to “be away from the body and at home with the Lord” with the doctrine of purgatory?
- 47:23 – Did St. Jerome change his mind on the Deuterocanon?
- 51:59 – I want to study more formally bible studies. What do you recommend one do or which programs to follow?
“Can a bishop ordain married men to the priesthood without the pope’s approval?” This question opens a discussion that also touches on whether Catholics and Muslims worship the same God, the appropriateness of performing marriages outside of church buildings, and the implications of changes in Mass prayers.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:00 – Does a bishop have the authority to ordain married men to the priesthood without the popes approval?
- 11:20 – What do Catholics say about Muslims and Catholics worshipping the same God?
- 16:35 – Is a priest allowed to perform a marriage outside of a church building?
- 20:05 – Why did they drop the word “One” from the closing prayer at Mass?
- 24:05 – Our parish is adding an extra song after the consecration, and another one during the cleaning of the vessels. Is this proper?
- 33:15 – I’m an evangelical Protestant and I’m getting curious about Catholicism. How do I go about this without falling into error?
- 48:20 – What is the difference between the Anglican and Catholic views of the Eucharist? Is it efficacious to receive communion at a non-Catholic Church?
“Is Catholicism a works-based salvation?” This question leads to a discussion on the nature of salvation in Catholicism, addressing concerns about the apostolic Church’s teachings. Other topics include the journey of someone in OCIA seeking clarity on salvation and guidance for those raised as Jehovah’s Witnesses looking to convert to Catholicism.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 08:15 – I believe in the apostolic Church and don’t think Catholicism holds to the original form.
- 28:45 – I’m in OCIA. How is Catholicism not a works-based salvation?
- 45:42 – I was raised JW. How and where do I start if I want to become Catholic?
“How do I introduce Jesus to Muslim and Jewish friends?” This question opens a discussion on effective ways to share faith across different beliefs. Additional topics include techniques for engaging with Muslims, addressing the question of God’s death, and explaining the rejection of the Quran. Each question offers valuable insights into interfaith dialogue and evangelization.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:40 – I’ve felt called to share my faith to non-Christians. How do I introduce Jesus to my Muslims and Jewish friends?
- 07:58 – What techniques do you employ when sharing the faith with Muslims?
- 14:25 – How do I answer the question, did God die?
- 19:41 – How can one lovingly explain why we reject the Quran and don’t accept Mohammed as a prophet?
- 29:15 – What’s the difference between the deity of Christ and Divinity of Christ?
- 33:16 – I have a Muslim best friend that I shared a lot with when I converted to Catholicism. What else can I do to evangelize her?
- 40:13 – Can Muslims who convert to Catholicism become priests, like when Anglican converts become priests? If so, what would you do with their wives?
- 44:37 – Why doesn’t Islam allow women to answer the call to prayer? Where do women get their religious training?
- 46:46 – I was told there was no evidence that Mohammed ever existed. Is this true?
- 47:56 – Why are the bishops quick to come to the defense of Muslims but Muslims are quick to be violent towards Christians?
“Do Catholics Worship the Same God as Muslims?” This question opens a discussion on the relationship between Catholicism and Islam, addressing key points such as the three essential things Catholics should know about Islam and how Muslims perceive salvation. The conversation also touches on whether Catholics and Muslims worship the same God and how interfaith marriages can work, particularly regarding baptism for children.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:00 – Three things Catholics should know about Islam.
- 12:23 – How does someone know they are saved in Islam? Why does Islam reject the Trinity if they claim to worship the same God as Christians?
- 16:24 – How do we answer the question from Muslims, if we actually believe Jesus rose from the dead?
- 21:06 – Do Catholics worship the same God as Muslims?
- 29:00 – If a Muslim man can marry a Catholic woman, how do they support each other? Can their kids be baptized Catholic?
- 34:48 – How do we argue for the Trinity to our Muslim son-in-law? He says the Quran is more true to the original than the bible because there are so many versions of the bible. How do I respond?
- 43:52 – What are your thoughts on Zealot by Reza Aslen? What’s a contrary book that would debunk it?
- 47:04 – How do we respond when Muslims dismiss Mohammed consummating his marriage with a 9 year old by claiming Mary was only 14 when she was pregnant?
“How do I respond to once saved always saved?” This question opens a discussion on the nuances of salvation, including the belief that being born again and receiving the Holy Spirit occurs only once. Other topics include the appropriateness of receiving the anointing of the sick before baptism, the interpretation of 2 Timothy 3:16, and the implications of Lent practices for recent converts.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:50 – My Baptist friend believes in once saved always saved. He said being born again only happens once, and you only receive the Holy Spirit once. How do I respond?
- 17:32 – I am going to be baptized in a couple weeks. My parish gives out anointing of the sick once a month, and I was told I could receive that before being baptized. But that seems off to me.
- 19:59 – 2 Tim 3:16 says all scriptures are Godly. Which scriptures are they talking about? The NIV?
- 24:00 – On the lying question, was it wrong for Catholic priests to issue baptismal certificates to Jews in WWII?
- 41:52 – Is it sinful to marry a Catholic man who has not been circumcised?
- 44:45 – My friend is a recent convert, but still questions a lot of things. He says he’s going to eat meat on Fridays of Lent. How can I help him understand this practice?
“How do we respond to sola scriptura?” This question opens a discussion on the challenges of infallible testimony in the context of biblical canon, particularly in light of Protestant perspectives. Other topics include the sacrament of anointing of the sick in Eastern and Roman Rite practices, the morality of lying, and the doctrine of eternal conscious torment.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 3:00 – Catholics often critique sola scriptura by saying it blocks a Protestant from having an infallible testimony upon which they can base their belief that the Bible consists of 66 books, nothing more and nothing less. But Protestants counter that Jesus often held the Jews accountable to their scriptures even though they didn’t have infallible declarations of their canon. How do we respond to that?
- 12:46 – I’m an Eastern Rite Catholic. Every year in Holy Week we receive the sacrament of the anointing of the sick. My Roman Rite friends have said if you can only receive it if you are seriously ill. They’ve also said it can wipe away mortal sin. But that is not my understanding. Which is true?
- 22:00 – How can there never be instances where lying is okay?
- 34:55 – I’m having trouble with the doctrine of eternal conscious torment.
- 45:53 – Why do we have to accept the teaching of the magisterium even when it’s not infallible?
- 52:23 – what do you think of equivocation?
“How can I heal my relationship with my son and forgive?” This episode addresses the complexities of forgiveness in parent-child dynamics, including what true forgiveness looks like and how to navigate growing apart in faith within a marriage. Other questions tackle concerns about rekindling friendships after returning to the Church and the challenges of maintaining relationships with family.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 13:50 – I grew up Catholic and went away from the Church for over a decade and am now coming back. My friend is a devout Catholic and I’m worried I’ll sabotage our relationship by putting him on a pedestal.
- 18:27 – What exactly is forgiveness, and what does that look like in a parent-child relationship?
- 31:35 – What if my wife and I are growing apart because I am growing in my faith and she is not? Is that repairable?
- 40:00 – I call to wish my grandchildren a happy birthday but my son just hangs up on me. How can I heal the relationship with my son?
- 43:14 – How do I know if I have really forgiven someone?
“Can Catholics Believe in Young Earth Creationism?” This question opens a discussion on the relationship between faith and science, addressing topics such as the role of God in holding atoms together, the balance between atomism and Aristotelianism, and the implications of biblical statements on creation. Other questions touch on the nature of infinity and eternity, as well as the age of the earth from a Catholic perspective.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 12:05 – It seems to me that modern science substituted mathematics for formal cause. Do you have thoughts on that?
- 21:02 – I was taught that with atoms, it is somewhat inexplicable how they are held together since the protons naturally repel. In bible study I was taught that the only explanation is that God holds it together. Is this correct?
- 30:05 – If atomism is too bottom-up, is aristotelianism too top down?
- 36:28 – How do infinity and eternity go together?
- 40:35 – Have you read Ed Feser’s The Last Superstition and what do you think of it?
- 42:30 – Who came up with that time could somehow be subject to gravity? Is that for real? That seems so off to me.
- 45:00 – The bible says “let there be light” and that was the beginning. I think that proves that there was a beginning.
- 48:33 – I’m a convert and had been taught creationism my whole life. How do Catholics view the age of the earth?
“Where Is Purgatory in the Bible?” This question opens a discussion about the biblical basis for purgatory, addressing concerns from those who struggle with its concept. Other topics include the role of confession and the fulfillment of Old Testament prophecies, as well as guidance for those considering a return to the Catholic faith.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:00 – I’m not Catholic because I don’t understand purgatory.
- 29:04 – I left Catholicism, I’m Baptist and don’t really go to church anymore but still follow Jesus. I think we should confess directly to God and not have to go through a priest.
- 43:09 – I work with a dispensationalist. I want to talk to her about the Old Testament prophecies but before I do, I would like to know, were all the prophecies fulfilled?
- 49:17 – My children are no longer practicing Catholics. They were never confirmed. If they were to return, what would they have to do?
- 53:08 – I’m on my way to becoming Catholic. How do I answer the Protestant objection that Catholics have no infallible list of infallible dogmas?
“Why aren’t you Catholic?” This episode addresses a range of concerns, including the reasons some converts cite for their Protestant faith, such as dreams and personal experiences. Other topics include the belief that there is no marriage in heaven and questions surrounding Marian devotion and the significance of the Council of Nicaea.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:00 – I’m a recent convert and never had this question answered. I’ve heard of Muslims who convert due to dreams but when they convert, they become protestant. Is there a theory as to why?
- 16:50 – I’m not Catholic because there is no marriage in heaven and I would feel incomplete without femininity
- 29:01 – I’m not Catholic because of Marian devotion and the holy days of obligation.
- 46:37 – I’m an ex-Catholic because of Nicaea and how Catholics break from the Jesus described in the council and your understanding of his divinity.
“Why aren’t you Catholic?” This question opens a discussion on the complexities of faith, including the roles of purgatory and indulgences in salvation. Other topics include the significance of the feast of Saint Joseph and the challenges faced by those considering the SSPX. The conversation also touches on perspectives from Anglo-Catholics regarding papal infallibility.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:00 – The feast of Saint Joseph
- 11:39 – I’m not Catholic because I don’t understand purgatory and indulgences and how they relate to salvation.
- 29:03 – My father was one of 13 and all the boy’s middle name was Joseph.
- 33:37 – I am Catholic but 3 women in my life are SSPX and are very convincing. Why should I not join?
- 45:44 – I’m an Anglo-Catholic. I’m not convinced of Papal Infallibility.
“Why don’t we have Mass on Good Friday?” This question opens a discussion on the significance of this solemn day in the Catholic tradition. Other topics include the obligations of Jewish converts to Christianity, the participation of Protestant converts in Communion, and the appropriateness of saying Hallelujah during Lent.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:00 – Why don’t we have mass on Good Friday?
- 10:12 – If a Jew converts to Christianity he has to believe Jesus is God but does he also have to follow the commandments of the Torah?
- 21:46 – If Protestant Converts have already been baptized and believe in Transubstantiation, why aren’t they allowed to fully participate in the fullness by receiving communion?
- 30:55 – If My husband and I are done having kids, how do we proceed without violating Catholic teaching?
- 43:58 – Can we say Hallelujah during Lent outside of Mass?
- 47:36 – I notice my Catholic friends’ religious views become political. What’s with the trend? What’s with things like the Latin Mass?
- 52:25 – Is it mandatory to say “One God, forever and ever” at the end of the Collect?
- 54:25 – If major transformations are rooted in God, why would we need to become Catholic?
- 01:00 – The feast of Saint Joseph
- 11:39 – I’m not Catholic because I don’t understand purgatory and indulgences and how they relate to salvation.
- 29:03 – My father was one of 13 and all the boy’s middle name was Joseph.
- 33:37 – I am Catholic but 3 women in my life are SSPX and are very convincing. Why should I not join?
- 45:44 – I’m an Anglo-Catholic. I’m not convinced of Papal Infallibility.
“How Does Baptism save us?” This question opens a discussion on the Biblical evidence supporting baptism’s role in salvation. Other topics include the Catholic Church’s stance on full immersion baptisms, the significance of being marked with a seal in Ephesians 1:13, and the validity of baptisms performed in Protestant churches.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:30 – What’s the Biblical Evidence That Baptism Saves Us?
- 11:42 – Why does the Catholic Church not employ full immersion Baptisms?
- 15:14 – I’m a recent convert. Ephesians 1:13 having belief in him you were marked with a Seal, how is that different from being baptized?
- 20:41 – Would the Church accept a baptism that was administered in Protestant Church, if the protestant minister preached that baptism was just a symbol?
- 29:45 – Orthodox teach full immersion baptism, why doesn’t Roman rite do full immersion?
- 35:54 – How does baptism assist us in avoiding sin?
- 47:20 – In an emergency baptism how would the church validate it?
- 50:00 – People who return want to be re-baptized. Is it a misplaced desire?
“Did Catholics remove the Gospel of Thomas?” This question opens a discussion about the origins and decisions surrounding the biblical canon. The conversation also touches on why the letter of Clement was excluded, the identity of James in the New Testament, and the Catholic perspective on the Jewish scriptures.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 00:40 – Senator Talarico claims that Christian removed the Gospel of Thomas from the Bible. Can you tell us what the Gospel of Thomas is, and did Catholics remove this book, or any book from the Bible?
- 16:47 – Why was the letter of Clement not included in Canon?
- 19:49 – Is the Book of James the James who is the bigshot in Acts?
- 20:58 – Does the presbyterian church that Tarlrico belongs to believe that women must become men to enter Heaven as stated in the Gospel of Thomas?
- 29:16 – How does the Catholic faith view the books of scripture that Jews adhere hear to and which books of scripture are part of Catholic canon and not protestant?
- 36:55 – If Hannukah (a high holy day) which is only mentioned in Maccabees, but protestants leave Maccabees out of their canon, how can this be if they base their canon on Jewish canon?
- 46:04 – Are any of the letters attributed to Paul actually written by anyone else?
- 53:00 – What do you make of the stories of Jesus as a young boy?
“How should we approach modesty?” This question opens a discussion on the cultural sensitivities surrounding dress and respect. The conversation also touches on how the Church can promote proper attire at Mass and the responsibilities men have regarding custody of the eyes, highlighting the importance of respectful presentation in a faith community.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 33:33 – How do we consider the different geographic and culture sensitivities to dress when it comes to modesty?
- 40:27 – How can the Church restore a renewed sense of proper and respectful dress at Mass?
- 44:29 – What responsibility do men have when it comes to custody of the eyes?
- 51:45 – At her parish the pastor has instilled a presentable dress code for volunteers during Mass which is setting and example for the congregation.
“Why oppose assisted suicide?” This question opens a discussion on the complexities of suffering and the value of life, touching on personal experiences of trauma and the lack of resources for healing. The conversation also addresses the role of legislation in protecting the unborn and the implications for fathers in abortion decisions, highlighting the multifaceted nature of these ethical issues.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 12:54 – Why would we be against wanting to end their own life if they are suffering?
- 21:00 – I was abused growing up and considered assisted suicide and didn’t have the resources necessary to deal with the trauma.
- 32:22 – Is legislation the most grace filled way to protect the unborn?
- 41:18 – What is the Church’s stance on passing legislation that would punish abortion providers and people who procure abortions; should they be punished as murderers?
- 48:32 – What about Father’s who are completely left out of the decision if the child is aborted or not?
“How do we respond to the claim Jesus was just a wise teacher?” This question opens a discussion on the true nature of Christ, while also addressing concerns from new converts about finding a parish in communion with Rome, the historical use of priestly vestments, and the implications of Jesus’ words in John 20:17 regarding the hypostatic union.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:45 – How do we respond to the Claim Jesus was Just a Wise Teacher?
- 10:56 – I’m new to the faith, getting baptized soon, and I’m going back into the Army. I’ve seen a lot of heretical things in parishes. As I move to a new station, how do I navigate making sure I’m in a parish and diocese that is in communion with Rome?
- 18:56 – When did Catholic priests start using vestments?
- 22:07 – I am dogsitting for a family member who is out of town, and they have tarot cards in the house. What should I do with them?
- 30:49 – In John 20:17 Jesus calls God “my God and your God.” Is Jesus worshipping the Father because of the hypostatic union? Would that have also been the case before the Incarnation? Does the Holy Spirit worship the Father?
- 36:49 – If Jesus would be born today, would he still have died for our sins, considering how bad things are?
- 43:58 – When Moses wrote the creation story, what were his sources — where did he get it from?
- 48:40 – I am in OCIA. I am feeling spiritual attacks and temptation to backslide. Are these attacks to be expected as I enter the final weeks before entering the Church?
- 50:57 – What are good books to read or something to listen to learn about the faith? I watch you guys and Joe Heschmeyer. I want to dive into some more source material, like the stuff you guys draw from.
- 53:20 – Why is Joseph not mentioned much in the Bible?
“Did Jesus fulfill the prophecy of the Messiah?” This question opens a discussion that also touches on why Pilate didn’t gather evidence during Jesus’ trial, the nature of Jesus’ last name, and the Church’s infallibility. The conversation navigates through various theological inquiries, providing clarity on these important topics.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:00 – Did Jesus Fulfill the Prophecy of the Messiah?
- 10:43 – When Jesus came before Pilate, why didn’t Pilate try to gather any kind of evidence?
- 14:27 – What is Jesus’ last name?
- 18:59 – How would you convince a Buddhist to become Catholic?
- 22:06 – Was Nestorius wrongly condemned at the counsel of Ephesus? Why were Chalcedonians accused of sounding Nestorian?
- 29:07 – When is the Church infallible and when is she not?
- 32:33 – If Jesus was a Jew, why are we not all Jewish?
- 36:34 – What is the Gospel of Thomas, who wrote it, and why is it considered an apocryphal book?
- 41:26 – Who was the human author of Genesis? Was it first an oral tradition that was written down later?
- 45:09 – Last week I thought I heard on this show that when Christ was crucified he set aside his divinity so he could fully experience the pain and suffering of sin. That sounds off to me, is that right?
- 53:14 – I am converting from a Jewish background. I’d like to share resources to the previous caller about being a Jewish Catholic.
What Made Jews Expect a Messiah?
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:17 – What factors had the Jews expecting the messiah in the 1st century?
- 07:03 – Where is a good start when reading the Deuterocanonical books? Books Protestant bible doesn’t?
- 12:29 – Should Isaiah 65:20 be taken literally or symbolically?
- 19:30 – How do you decide what content to consume when reading or listening to videos?
- 28:42 – Why do people rip or tear garments so often in the Old Testament?
- 34:48 – What is the historical tradition behind male altar servers?
- 46:22 – What does the church know or teach about the life of St. Joseph?
- 50:51 – Could blasphemy of the Holy Spirit prevent Jeffrey Dahmer Baptism from being valid?
Were the Gospels Written Earlier?
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:27 – Were the Gospels Written Earlier then We Were Taught?
- 14:44 – Why are pregnant women allowed to receive the Eucharist?
- 22:18 – When did the terms low, high and solemn high Mass develop for the Latin Mass?
- 28:45 – At what point should we take the bible stories more literally?
- 41:00 – Did Jesus descend into the Hell of the just? Is this different from Hell and why did Jesus need to do this?
- 45:36 – Why isn’t the book of Enoch in the Bible?
“Where do we see the Mass in Acts of the Apostles?” This question opens a discussion on the early Church’s practices, alongside topics like defending infant baptism against claims of its necessity, and the significance of Jesus’ addition of “mind” in Mark 12:30. Other questions touch on the nature of confession and the papacy’s ties to Rome, showcasing a rich variety of theological inquiries.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:20 – Where do we see the Mass in Acts of the Apostles?
- 09:38 – How do we defend the baptism of infants? My co-worker says you just need faith and it’s not necessary to baptize babies.
- 17:52 – In Mark 12:30ff Jesus quotes the great shema. In Deuteronomy it says to love God with your whole heart, soul, and strength. Why does Mark add the word “mind” to that?
- 22:15 – Why do some people feel reluctant to go to confession?
- 28:39 – Is the papacy so tied to Rome that it could never be somewhere else? If Islam took over Europe could the pope be based somewhere else?
- 31:58 – Why isn’t the book of Maccabees in the King James Bible? I’m trying to talk about the faith with my Seventh Day Adventist family members.
- 41:00 – Mt 10:3 calls James son of Alpheus, and Mk 2:14-17 calls Levi the son of Alpheus. Could they be brothers?
- 44:17 – My grown children think we are living in a simulation. How can I counter this?
- 50:13 – You said the King James did not translate the deuterocan books. But I have two KJV Bibles that include the deuterocanonical books.
- 52:01 – I’ve been getting along with my new coworkers because they are Christian. But today Mary came up and they really attacked Catholic teaching on Mary. What can I say to them?
“How do you make a great confession if you haven’t been in a long time?” This question opens a discussion on the sacrament of reconciliation, addressing the steps to prepare for confession. Other topics include the morality of working for a divorced employer and the concept of priests acting in persona Christi, providing a rich exploration of faith and practice.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:10 – How do you make a great confession if you haven’t been in a long time?
- 14:45 – Is it okay to work for an employer who is divorced? I told her not to get divorced because it’s against God but it’s a good job.
- 31:52 – Where do we get the idea of priests acting in persona christi?
- 43:30 – Until recently I’ve never never heard of the Synagogue of Satan. But I see it twice in the book of Revelation. What is it all about?
“What does the Bible say about Confession?” This episode addresses the significance of confession in the Catholic faith, alongside questions about whether one should confess venial sins, how priests maintain confidentiality, and the necessity of confession before receiving communion. The discussion also touches on the nature of mortal sins and the concept of perfect contrition.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 08:53 – Should I go to confession if I don’t have any mortal sins, since my venial sins are forgiven at Mass?
- 11:49 – How can priests keep all these confessions confidential? They see their parishioners all the time, how do they not slip?
- 17:11 – Do you need to go to confession every time before taking communion?
- 19:35 – When I confess my sins I don’t say how many times. But I heard I should be saying the number of times.
- 31:16 – What are the mortal sins?
- 39:24 – Regarding priests keeping the seal of confession — how would it even benefit a priest to talk about a confession, even if they don’t reveal who the person is?
- 41:42 – I’m in OCIA and my wife isn’t. I’m trying to help her understand why we don’t just confess to our hearts directly to God.
- 45:25 – I was baptized presbyterian and became Catholic last year. Sometimes I remember a sin from my pre-Catholic life that I didn’t mention in my first confession. Do I need to confess those?
- 48:26 – If you have committed a mortal sin and die before going to confession, I understand you’re good if you have perfect confession. But what exactly is perfect contrition?
- 50:40 – Is the withdrawal method a mortal sin?
“Where does the Church stand on the ethics of Neuralink?” This question opens a discussion on the intersection of technology and morality, while also addressing the ethical considerations surrounding frozen embryos and the implications of pharmaceutical birth control methods. Additionally, the conversation touches on the responsibilities of attorneys in providing ethical healthcare advice in line with Catholic teaching.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:30 – Where does the Church stand on the ethics of Neuralink?
- 18:32 – We have frozen embryos from before we became Catholic. What is the ethical way to handle them?
- 33:50 – Do all pharmaceutical birth control methods prevent implantation of the embryo?
- 42:14 – I’m an attorney. What do I need to know to give good ethical advice about healthcare directives? I have clients that want things that might contradict Catholic teaching. Can I not draft the document for them?
“Who received the first Eucharist?” This question opens a discussion on the significance of the Eucharist and the scriptural evidence for the real presence of Christ. Other topics include how to address Catholics who feel more fulfilled in Protestant services, the morality of the death penalty, and the rationale behind the Hail Mary prayer in the rosary.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:34 – Who received the first eucharist? Which scripture is the best to show as evidence for the real presence?
- 12:23 – How do we respond when a Catholic says they are getting more out of going to a Protestant church? How do we bring them back?
- 22:49 – How is the death penalty an immoral thing, and why is it changed for the first time in history?
- 37:30 – What is the response to the justification that the reformation is valid because the reformers followed the example of the apostles being kicked out of the temple?
- 42:05 – I see a lot of inconsistencies in the Catholic Church. I have an issue because if Doctrine can change how can I agree with what will change in the future?
- 51:24 – Why do Catholics pray the hail mary so much during the rosary? Isn’t it against scripture?
“How do I explain James 2 to Protestants?” This question opens a discussion on the Catholic understanding of faith and works, while also addressing how we determine the canon of Scripture and the role of tradition in the Church. Other topics include the significance of traditions like kissing the bishop’s ring and the implications of 2 Timothy 3:16-17 for interpreting Scripture.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 13:13 – How do we figure out the canon? Are the books self attesting. Why does the Holy Spirit give infallibility to the Church but the Holy Spirit does not give infallibility to individuals?
- 20:31 – I’m entering into the Church and recently met my bishop. Are traditions like kissing the bishop’s ring still necessary? Why or why not?
- 31:50 – How do I explain the Catholic approach to James 2 to Protestants?
- 42:11 – What are our areas of disagreement apart from Sola Scriptura?
- 49:11 – What does it mean when it says all scripture in 2 Timothy 3:16-17?
“How can Catholics hold councils without Orthodox bishops?” This question opens a discussion on the complexities of ecclesiastical authority and governance. Additionally, the episode addresses whether one must be Catholic to be saved, the Orthodox perspective on the Immaculate Conception, and the differing views on the Filioque in the Creed.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:45 – How can Catholics still hold councils without the Orthodox bishops?
- 12:12 – Do you have to be Catholic in order to be saved?
- 15:15 – What’s the Orthodox view of Immaculate Conception? Is the Orthodox canon different from ours?
- 20:25 – Leo III wouldn’t add the Filioque to the Creed and gave his reasons?. Did the pope who added it ever give an explanation as to why?
- 28:43 – Is it ok for Catholics to accept the Ethiopian canon description of Jesus?
- 30:18 – I’ve heard some Orthodox say they don’t adore Jesus in the Eucharist because they view it as food. Is this uniform thought?
- 33:33 – How can a non-Christian evaluate the competing claim of the Eastern Orthodox who also claims apostolic authority?
- 39:21 – Why does the Eastern Orthodox allow contraception and Catholics don’t?
- 43:55 – Can a person who became Eastern Orthodox from Catholicism just jump back and forth? How can Eastern Orthodox justify 3 sacramental marriages?
- 48:12 – Do you think the Catholics and all other churches will ever fully reunite?
“What are the top reasons for Gospel reliability?” This question opens a discussion on the foundational aspects that affirm the Gospels’ trustworthiness, including the significance of eyewitness accounts. Other topics include the challenges posed by Bart Ehrman regarding Jesus’ words, the role of St. Luke among the apostles, and the criteria used to determine authentic Gospels versus apocryphal texts.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:10 – What are the top 3 reasons for the reliability of the gospels?
- 29:07 – Have you considered the work of Bart Ehrman and his problems with what Jesus really said?
- 35:56 – Is it safe to assume that St. Luke was one of the 72 that was originally sent out?
- 42:27 – How did they figure out which gospels were the actual eye witnesses and others weren’t like the gospel of Thomas?
- 46:49 – How would you go about balancing knowing the bible is the word of God and knowing humans had some influence on it?
- 50:44 – How would you compare the reliability of transmission of the NT compared to the Quran and the Hadiths?
Why does the Catholic Church have both the Traditional Latin Mass and the modern form of the Mass—and how should you explain the difference without getting pulled into “liturgy wars”? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Catholic Answers apologists address this common question before diving into a wide range of topics. They explore whether charging interest is still considered usury, how just war theory applies to rebellions, and how historical cases like the Knights Templar fit with Church law. The episode also explains the role of baptism in justification, offers arguments against naturalism, and gives practical advice for strengthening Catholic marriages. Additional questions include how to understand Peter’s denial of Jesus and what it means for salvation. A rich discussion covering liturgy, moral theology, and everyday Catholic life.Questions Covered:05:32 – I attend the Tridentine Mass Almost exclusively at my ‘local’ FSSP parish. I have a friend seeking the Catholic Church who asked me ‘why do you have two different masses in the Western Rite? Why don’t you just attend the regular English one?’ I often say that I am drawn to the beauty and simplicity of it. How do we respond to this simply without dragging them into the so-called ‘liturgy wars’? How do we respond given the restrictions placed on the older masses? Basically, how do we address this difference to those outside the church? Do I just keep a response about ‘preferences of the faithful’? 11:46 – The Church has been quite vocal against usury over the centuries. Is it still defined as any lending of money at interest? How does this notion square with the idea of a variable money supply? Would things like bank accounts, bonds, cds or stocks still be considered illicit? Has there been any recent guidance from the magisterium? 19:02 – Does just war theory apply to rebellions? Historically, I’m thinking of Irish wars against the British Empire and slave revolts of African-descended peoples in the Americas, including during the U.S. Civil War. What would be the conditions of jus ad bellum in cases like these or any other group dealing with an oppressor? 28:46 – Canon 7 of Chalcedon forbids clergy and monks from war and holding secular office. How then did the Knights Templar, and bishops such as the bishop of Andorra, who also holds title of Co-Prince of Andorra, not violate this? 34:03 – How does baptism fit with “faith alone working through love?” Can someone with “faith alone working through love” be initially justified apart from baptism? 19:44 – What do you think is the most convincing argument/thought exercise against naturalism/empricism (or at least what the average indifferent secular person thinks they believe). 46:29 – What is your best advice for a married Catholic couple to strengthen their bond in marriage? Your stories about you and Renee are always so beautiful (the blue birds especially). Also thanks for being a Catholic cowboy. I grew up Southern Baptist, and seeing a southern Catholic gentleman do apologetics is really cool. 50:51 – Peter denied Jesus 3 times. After the cock crows three times he ran away in shame. What if he falls, hits his head and dies after this? Would his soul be in danger of damnation?
What if Christians today are misunderstanding what God really meant in Scripture? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Catholic Answers apologists address a thoughtful concern about biblical translation and interpretation, explaining how the Church safeguards authentic teaching across centuries. The discussion also covers how to discern and use your God-given talents responsibly, why there isn’t a simple official Vatican list of all dogmas, and whether belief in Marian dogmas is required for justification. Additional questions explore the nature of election and free will, whether artificial intelligence could ever possess consciousness, and whether uncertainty around ex cathedra statements challenges papal infallibility. A wide-ranging and intellectually engaging conversation on faith, reason, and modern questions.
Questions Covered:
- 01:47 – Knowing that the Bible and other texts have been translated over the centuries… what if how they’re understood now, by any faith, is wrong? What if God is sitting in heaven, looking down and thinking, “that’s not what I meant at all”? If it matters, I’m a convert to Catholicism from the Baptist church (and it’s been the best decision I’ve ever made by the way), I just think about weird stuff like this from time to time watching the debates about who’s right and who’s wrong or the meaning of things we now read in translated texts.
- 12:00 – When you have more than 1 talent and competing basic life priorities, what’s the most prudent way to act in a pleasing manner to God so as to not be at fault for neglecting a gift from God.
- 17:33 – Why is there no official Vatican list of Catholic Dogmas? Google has its own searchable list of 255 dogmas. But, you would think….
- 30:27 – Is justification predicated upon belief on your four Marian dogmas.
- 35:46 – Would it be fair to say there are two steps to being considered elect? That is to say God elects everyone (calls them to salvation and has a plan for them in place) but that our cooperation with his grace makes that initial unconditional election conditional on our acceptance and continued faithfulness?
- 43:18 – Can something like AI ever gain consciousness and what should we make of it if it does or doesn’t and on what grounds?
- 51:20 – Isn’t the fact that we can’t precisely define how many Papal statements have been made “ex cathedra” a problem for Papal Infallibility?
Why didn’t the Jewish people of Jesus’ time—and many today—accept Him as the Messiah? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Catholic Answers apologists explore this foundational question before diving into others on the core of Christian belief. They explain the evidence for the resurrection, whether Pascal’s Wager could justify belief in the Eucharist, and if our prayers can override God’s will. The episode also unpacks St. Augustine’s famous reflection on the Trinity, clarifies what indulgences really are, and examines difficult biblical passages like 1 Corinthians 15:29. Finally, they address why the Catholic Church accepts Protestant baptisms but not confirmations, and how to respond to claims that infant baptism isn’t found in Scripture.
Questions Covered:
- 04:21 – What is it about Jesus that the Jews of his time and today still don’t accept him as messiah and considered him sacrilegious?
- 12:14 – What are the reasons to believe in the resurrection? What convinced you?
- 17:40 – If we did pascals wager with the eucharist, If we’re wrong, is it idolatry?
- 21:10 – Do our prayers override God’s will?
- 28:40 – Could you expound on the story of Augustine trying to understand the Trinity? (The story of Augustine seeing a boy trying to fill a hole with the ocean.)
- 36:15 – I don’t understand indulgences. Can you help clarify what they mean?
- 43:55 – What is the Catholic position on 1 Cor. 15:29?
- 49:49 – Why is baptism in a Christian denomination accepted to join the Catholic Faith, but confirmation is not?
- 51:16 – We have friends that say they can’t find infant Baptism in the bible. How do I respond?
Is IVF ever morally acceptable for Catholics facing infertility? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Catholic Answers apologists tackle challenging questions about Catholic teaching on human life, Scripture, and Mary. The discussion begins with how to respond when someone believes IVF is their only option, followed by questions about consent and pregnancy, whether Ezekiel 18 contradicts original sin, and how the Church responds to the claim of total depravity. The episode also explains what the Magisterium is, whether Revelation 12 refers to Mary or Israel, the evidence for Mary’s sinlessness, why Catholics honor Mary above John the Baptist, and how spiritual beings like angels can engage in battle. A thoughtful exploration of Catholic doctrine and biblical interpretation.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:55 – How can I answer someone who isn’t Catholic and the only solution is IVF?
- 08:15 – Do Catholics minimize consent? The example: Just because a person consents to sex does not mean they consent to impregnation.
- 15:14 – What’s the Catholic response to the claim that Ezekiel 18:20-21 argues against original sin?
- 20:31 – Since the bible describes original sin as impacting the whole person, it seems like it teaches the doctrine of total depravity, which the Catholic Church rejects.
- 28:51 – Could you explain what the magisterium is?
- 33:36 – Is Rev 12:1-18 about Mary or Israel
- 40:40 – I struggle with Mary being perfect? What proof do we have that she led a sinless life?
- 47:25 – Why do we believe that Mary was greater than John the Baptist when Jesus says he is the greatest?
- 50:30 – How can spirit creatures do battle, regarding the battle of angels?
“Did Constantine rig the Council of Nicea?” This question opens a discussion on early Church issues, including the specifics of the canon established at the Council of Florence and the complexities surrounding the organization of the early Church. Other topics include the role of Protestant pastors in critiquing Catholicism and the scriptural basis for attending Mass and confession.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:30 – Did Constantine rig the Council of Nicea?
- 07:51 – What is the specific canon of the council of Florence (1422) whereby the Catholics, Eastern Orthodox, and Coptics all agreed on the 73 book canon of scripture?
- 12:40 – How can we help stop this war in the Middle East? What can I do?
- 16:51 – How do I respond to a Protestant claim citing Eamon Duffy’s book, Saints and Sinners, that Clement never makes the claim to be a bishop, that his letter from the whole Roman community (not just him), and that the church at that time was organized under a group of bishops, not a single bishop.
- 21:32 – Why do Protestant pastors feel compelled to put down the Catholic faith? If they don’t believe it, why don’t they just leave us alone?
- 29:12 – Where is it in scripture that we need to attend Mass once a week and go to confession once a year? And are there any exceptions for people who can’t get there (like if they can’t drive).
- 34:09 – Why do all of the apostolic Churches like the Oriental Orthodox have different canons on scripture and different christologies?
- 41:08 – If my mother and father are in Purgatory, do they know each other in Purgatory? Can souls in Purgatory pray for each other?
- 46:28 – In the early church, how did they know how to consecrate the bread and wine at Mass?
- 49:10 – How does the Catholic Church view the development of the election of a pope changing from Roman clergy to the College of Cardinals?
- 51:48 – I’ve heard people say that Peter and Paul had different gospel messages, and that since I’m American, I’m a gentile, therefore I should follow Paul instead of Peter.
“Is it appropriate to pray the Rosary during Mass?” This question opens a discussion on the integration of personal devotion within communal worship. Other topics include why many Catholic parishes serve only bread during Communion, the historical context of the Holy Family’s journey to Egypt, and the process of seeking annulments while preparing for the sacraments.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:30 – Is it appropriate to pray the Rosary during Mass?
- 17:03 – I’m not Catholic. Why do many Catholic churches only give the bread and not the wine? It seems like if we’re following scripture it should be both.
- 29:15 – I heard that when the Holy Family went to Egypt they were robbed by two thieves, and these same thieves were crucified with Jesus. Is this true?
- 33:33 – My wife and I are going through OCIA. Both of us are seeking annulments for our previous marriages. The annulments will likely not be done by Easter. Can we still receive the sacrament of reconciliation?
- 43:11 – Could the new Mass of Paul VI be considered a new rite? Especially considering the new Eucharistic prayers, and the fact that the Roman Canon is not required?
- 45:21 – What are your thoughts on making noise in the church before Mass begins? Should it be silent preparation, or should we greet and talk to people? Or somewhere in between?
- 50:07 – Is Aquinas’ belief that Jesus did not have the theological virtue of Faith a doctrine of the Church? Or is it just Aquinas’ opinion?
“Is feminism compatible with Christianity?” This question opens a discussion on the intersection of faith and feminist ideals, addressing concerns about objectification and the complexities of modern feminism. Other topics include how to engage charitably with feminist viewpoints and the misconceptions surrounding women’s equality and the patriarchy.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:30 – Is Feminism compatible with Christianity?
- 23:28 – My sister claims to be a feminist and says she is in support of legal prostitution. At the same time she says she is against the objectification of women. Any advice on how to talk to her about this stuff?
- 32:46 – What’s your advice on how to best debate with a feminist in a charitable way?
- 43:50 – I think people are confused about what feminism is. People think women being equal is women being like men, and that’s wrong. I think the patriarchy still has a hold on us in some ways — women need education so they can escape abusive relationships if needed.
“Should we remove holy water and cover statues in Lent?” This question opens a discussion on the practices of the season, while also addressing the nature of the Mass as a true sacrifice, the challenges of explaining its mystical elements to Protestants, and the historical changes from the Latin Mass to the new order.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:27 – Should We Remove Holy Water and Cover Statues Doing Lent?
- 12:25 – Is the sacrifice of the Mass symbolic or is it actually Christ continually being sacrificed through time and space in the Eucharist?
- 17:14 – How do you deal with a Protestant who struggles with the mystical or supernatural aspects of the Mass. I mean, consuming flesh and blood is pretty out there.
- 37:10 – After the collect, does the congregation need to wait until the priest sits down before we sit down? We did it that way when I was a kid, but not anymore.
- 42:25 – Why did the Mass change from the Latin Mass to the new order?
- 47:43 – I’m in OCIA. I wanted to attend a Church that has a Latin Mass. What do I need to know beforehand? I saw on a parish website times for high mass and low mass. What is this all about?
“How Can I Avoid Gossip?” This question opens a discussion on the implications of cursing and the use of God’s name in vain. Other topics include strategies for overcoming cussing, the moral responsibilities of viewers regarding language in films, and whether little lies can be considered sinful.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 15:16 – My worst habit is cussing. Can you recommend how I can stop?
- 19:31 – Is it ever acceptable for an actor to take the Lord’s name in vain for a movie? And as viewers do we bear any culpability for viewing it?
- 31:32 – Are little lies sinful?
- 42:07 – Is it wrong to say “G.D.”? My dad said it all the time.
- 45:59 – Rahab lied, but she’s this biblical hero. What’s the deal with that?
- 47:30 – How would you approach someone in your life who regularly uses the Lord’s name in vain?
- 51:43 – My students just say the most outrageous and nonsensical things. How can I cut this off without completely shutting down the classroom?
“Is there a scriptural basis for St. Joseph’s Assumption?” This question opens a discussion on the biblical foundations of St. Joseph’s bodily assumption into Heaven. Other topics include the differences between the Douay–Rheims versions, the appropriateness of praying for intercession from souls in purgatory, and the practice of clergy praying with covered heads during Mass.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 18:29 – What is the difference between the Douay–Rheims reims and the traditional Douay–Rheims?
- 21:45 – Is it okay to not just pray for the souls in purgatory, but to ask for their intercession?
- 29:07 – 1 Cor 11 says to not pray with your head covered. So how do we reconcile that with clergy praying with heads covered (mitres, cardinals hats, berettas, etc) during Mass?
- 32:49 – Should we offer Masses for the recently deceased leader of Iran and his party?
- 42:39 – How does one pray to saints? Also, The Bible records Jesus’ words of prayer in the agony in the garden, but how do we know what he said if nobody was there to witness and report it?
- 45:23 – How often can one make a general confession?
- 48:22 – Can you help me understand this controversy of interpreting the bible as saying we are either “declared” righteous or “made” righteous?
- 52:04 – I feel like God’s love and mercy has already washed my sins away even though I haven’t been to confession yet. What’s the deal with that?
When exactly can Catholics fulfill their Easter duty, and why does the Church require it? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Jimmy Akin answers thoughtful questions from listeners on a wide range of topics. He explains how we know the Scriptures are divinely inspired without falling into circular reasoning, discusses theories about the causes of same-sex attraction, and examines whether monastic life conflicts with the Church’s mission to evangelize. Jimmy also explores the relationship between the Eucharist and the resurrection of the body, moral responsibility for actions done in ignorance, whether swallowing something stuck in your teeth breaks the Eucharistic fast, and how Catholic moral theology evaluates difficult scenarios like stopping a hijacked plane. A wide-ranging discussion covering Scripture, moral theology, and practical questions about living the Catholic faith.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:00 – When can you fulfill your Easter duty?
- 11:07 – How can we know that the Scriptures are divinely inspired?
- The idea that “the Church says the Scriptures are divinely inspired because the Church has the authority to say so, but the Church has the authority to say so because the Scriptures give them the authority to” feels like a circular argument. I know there’s more to it, but I can’t quite articulate it, so any help would be appreciated!
- 19:33 – Have you in your learnings come to understand what causes Same-Sex Attraction? Is there a theory you find convincing? Do you have a theory of your own?
- 29:11 – Is monasticism selfish? For example, how could have the apostles fulfilled the Great Commission if they were cloistered? And how would that apply today? Can evangelization be accomplished from inside a monastic cell?
- 39:54 – It seems to me that God’s ultimate goal is to get us back bodily in heaven with him. Would that be like the garden of Eden again and how does us eating the eucharist help with that? Or does it? It seems we need to eat our savior to be bodily with God like he is. Is this correct or am I going somewhere I shouldn’t with this line of reasoning?
- 44:17 – If somebody does something evil out of stupidity, how responsible is he for said action? Can he be at least partly excused?
- 47:58 – This might sound silly, but I’ve wondered it a lot: If you are in mass and you’ve fasted the hour but find something in your teeth, does it break the fast to swallow it?
- 50:00 – Would it be moral to shoot down a hijacked plane full of civilians over an unpopulated area, if it is believed the hijackers intend to crash it in a populated area? Would this be considered doing evil that good may come of it or double effect?
Are generational curses real, and does the Bible support the idea that sins can pass down through families? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Jimmy Akin tackles a wide range of fascinating questions from listeners. He explains the Church’s teaching on generational curses, whether Christians can eat food offered to other gods, and when it may be morally permissible to disobey unjust laws. Jimmy also explores deeper philosophical and theological questions, including how we can experience happiness in Heaven before the resurrection of the body, whether a pope emeritus remains a cardinal, and whether delaying confession can itself become sinful. A thoughtful and wide-ranging discussion covering moral theology, Church authority, and practical Catholic living.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 00:55 – Is there such a thing as generational curses?
- 13:21 – Could you please summarize the church’s teaching on food offered to other gods? Is it a sin to eat it if it’s offered to me or is it fine if I just think of it as something to eat?
- 20:09 – When does illegally acquired power become legal? For example, when can a Chinese person stop obeying the authorities in Taiwan, and henceforth honor the ruling Communists?
- 23:27 – Yes, can you please explain when, if ever, it is okay to disobey laws and rules? Also, while vigilantism is against Catholic teaching, when, if ever, is it appropriate to try to restore justice as an ordinary citizen if corruption has gone so far? Sorry, I know this is very broad but I appreciate any thoughts. Thank you so much. God bless you always, Jimmy.
- 34:13 – How can we be happy in Heaven before the general resurrection if happiness is dependent on chemicals in our brains?
- 44:34 – Is a pope emeritus still a cardinal, or would the next pope need to create his predecessor as a cardinal again so that he could vote in a conclave again?
- 49:00 – Is it an additional sin to delay confession if you know you need to go? Someone on X argued Aquinas says delaying confession is not a sin. I argued that he says it’s impractical to go “immediately,” but it can still be a sin depending on your access to a priest and why you delay.
“Is ecumenism compromising doctrine?” This question leads to a discussion on the goals of ecumenism and whether it involves compromising with Protestant beliefs. Other topics include the Church’s relationship with modern culture, the historical and biblical basis for apostolic authority, and the theological implications of God’s actions in the stories of David and Bathsheba.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:41 – What is the goal of Ecumenism? Is it us compromising on doctrine with Protestants?
- 11:00 – Do you think the Church should change with modern culture or stand apart from it?
- 17:40 – How can we demonstrate historically and biblically that the apostles passed on their authority to bishops?
- 29:04 – Why did God create man alone when he knew he would create woman after?
- 40:53 – Why did God take out his anger on David and Bathsheba’s first baby?
- 49:15 – Why does freemasonry have an appeal that Catholicism doesn’t have, and why is Catholicism better?
“How can couples avoid bitterness?” Respect and patience are essential in nurturing relationships. In this episode, Rose Sweet shares her personal journey and offers insights on seeking understanding, addressing disrespect, and maintaining perspective. She also discusses coping strategies through art and the challenges of navigating annulment processes within marriage.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 29:01 – Through my marital difficulties I coped with it through doing art.
- 33:03 – After going through all of that, how did you pick up the pieces and move on after your husband passed?
- 35:21 – I’m civilly married to my wife. We’re both Catholic. She and her first husband have tried to go through the annulment process but one of the witnesses died. Another time another witness would not cooperate. We’d like to try again but a little reluctant given the previous difficulties. Do you have any advice? We do not receive Communion because my wife’s first marriage is not annulled.
- 43:24 – I can relate to your story and had a similar experience. I had to learn to detach with love when he went from alcohol to crack.
- 48:02 – I’m having a problem with patience with my spouse. I’m married to a schismatic. I don’t think I’d call myself bitter, but I’m getting tired of it. I’m a former schismatic myself.
- 50:49 – To get through our difficulties I increased my adoration time.
“Can the Pope become an antipope?” This question opens a discussion on the complexities of papal authority and the implications of heretical statements. Additionally, the episode addresses why Pope Leo can’t grant permission regarding a new bishop, the historical context of how bishops became popes, and the origins of conclaves.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:58 – Why can’t Pope Leo grant permission about the new Bishop?
- 17:07 – I have heard that if the Pope made a heretical statement, he would become an anti-pope. Is this true and could it happen?
- 21:35 – Do you have an opinion on Pope Leo visiting the US?
- 29:30 – How did the Bishops of Peter’s time become Pope? Give him the Peter and the Eucharist books
- 40:50 – How did conclaves come to be?
- 45:06 – When do you think the Didache was likely written? Any one of Joe’s books…
- 49:47 – What is the difference between the Papacy and the Orthodox Patriarch?
- 51:53 – When do we know the Pope is speaking Ex Cathedra and how many times has he?
- 54:00 – What is the tradition behind the headgear of pope and cardinals?
“How can I help a Protestant friend?” This question opens a discussion on addressing concerns about the papacy and its history, including the boundaries on questioning the Pope’s comments and the implications of Jesus’ statement about the gates of Hades. Other topics include the workings of assent with the Magisterium and the nature of infallible teachings.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 12:45 – Where are the boundaries on questioning the comments of the Pope?
- 22:26 – What does Jesus mean when he says “the gate of Hades” won’t prevail. Can these be lies?
- 33:22 – How can I help a Protestant friend whose greatest hurdle is papacy history and scandals?
- 40:42 – How does assent work with the Magisterium?
- 49:16 – Is there a list of the Infallible teachings?
“What are the limits of Church authority?” This question opens a discussion on the role and boundaries of ecclesiastical power, while also addressing related topics such as the authority of the Bible versus Church tradition and the implications of using AI in homilies. Other questions touch on the origins of purgatory and the complexities of religious freedom in a diverse society.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:59 – What would be a good response to a Protestant asking why the Bible isn’t the final authority?
- 12:27 – Pope Leo said priests should not use AI to prepare homilies. Would the pope have authority to limit or govern the Church’s use of AI in the future?
- 19:17 – A Protestant might say that when the early church first started calling itself Catholic, that was really a “small c” kind of Catholic. It wasn’t really the Church united under a bishop of Rome. How do we respond to that?
- 23:25 – Where do we get the idea of purgatory?
- 30:36 – I am autistic. Are we able to use AI to study the scriptures?
- 36:39 – Why do we believe in religious freedom? It seems like that gives other religions a kind of tactical advantage? Why not just have the government say that everyone should be Christian?
- 42:01 – A priest told me questioning the authority of the Church is blasphemy. Is that really true? If that’s the case then how would you guys be able to have this discussion right now without blaspheming?
- 47:51 – Can you explain what’s going on with the SSPX right now? If the pope is the authority I don’t see why these bishops are disobeying him.
“What did daily life look like for the Holy Family?” This question opens a discussion about the domestic life of Jesus, Mary, and Joseph, touching on their cultural practices, including cleanliness in Jewish tradition. Other topics include the identity of the “brothers of Jesus,” and insights into St. Joseph’s life and burial.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:00 – What Did Daily Life Look Like for the Holy Family?
- 22:50 – Were the “brothers of Jesus” children from Joseph but not Mary?
- 29:37 – I think I might disagree with you statement that the Holy Family would have been dirty. That Jewish culture was very concerned with being clean.
- 33:20 – How does the Bible describe St. Joseph?
- 37:33 – Where is St. Joseph buried?
- 41:49 – Was Joseph old or young when He married Mary?
- 47:43 – What is the earliest attestation of the assumption of St. Joseph ?
“How can we cooperate with the grace of Lent to work on healing our relationships?” This question opens a discussion on the importance of reconciliation during this sacred season. Additional topics include navigating family dynamics with a 22-year-old son who struggles with respect and addressing the challenges of processing grief amid loss.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:30 – How can we cooperate with the grace of Lent to work on healing our relationships?
- 18:15 – My 22-yr old son lives with us but does not respect the family dynamic?
- 30:33 – I’ve asked my 22-yr old son who is dealing with alcohol issues to leave our home and he refuses to?
- 43:21 – How can I process grief; I’m in a season experiencing a lot of death of friends?
“Why Aren’t You Catholic?” addresses the question of infallible authority in the Church, particularly in light of claims from some Christians. The discussion also touches on whether confession is necessary if baptism forgives sins, the marital status of Peter, and the implications of Mary’s immaculate conception.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:48 – “Some Christians say they’re not Catholic because they don’t see any evidence for any sort of infallible authority continuing after the apostles.”
- 13:10 – In the Nicene Creed when we pray “One Baptism for the forgiveness of sins…” does this mean we do not need confession?
- 23:34 – Was Peter married?
- 32:48 – If Mary was immaculately conceived, why did she have to die?
- 41:32 – The Church does not seem divinely inspired, so how can it claim to teach infallibility?
- 48:09 – Will sins confessed an absolved by a priest be read in our final judgement?
Who are the “sheep and the goats” in Matthew 25, and are we judged by works or saved by grace? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Catholic Answers apologists unpack this key passage before addressing other challenging questions from Scripture. They explain what Revelation means about reigning with Christ, how Jesus could offer Himself at the Last Supper before the crucifixion, and what the Church teaches about the mysterious Nephilim in Genesis 6. Additional topics include why Jesus allowed Himself to be tempted, what happened to the cross after the crucifixion, and why Catholics are cautious about numerology in biblical interpretation. A thoughtful discussion on salvation, Scripture, and Catholic theology.
Questions Covered:
- 04:00 – What does Revelation mean when it says that those who overcome will be the ones to rule in the new heaven and earth with Christ?
- 10:06 – How is it possible for Jesus to offer himself up if he offered himself up first at the last supper but did not die till the next day?
- 16:30 – Mat. 25 talking about the sheep and the goats. How are they saved by grace if it feels like they were separated and judged based on works?
- 23:40 – Gen.6:1-2 What are the nephilim? What interpretation does the Catholic Church take?
- 33:38 – Why would Jesus so pure be tempted by the devil?
- 37:42 – Who are the sheep and the goats?
- 43:00 – Do we know what happened to the cross immediately after the crucifixion and where it is today?
- 46:59 – It feels like the Church has moved away from numerology in the bible? Why should Catholics avoid it?
Did Jonah really get swallowed by a whale, or is the story symbolic? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Catholic Answers apologists tackle this question along with several others about Scripture and theology. They discuss how to prepare for conversations with Muslims using the Bible, why giants appear after the flood, and whether Catholics can accept the Orthodox canon as inspired. The conversation also explores what St. Paul means by being “slaves to sin” and what Christ truly accomplished through redemption. Additional questions address modern concerns about alcohol in light of the wedding at Cana and clarify how the Bible uses terms like mind, heart, soul, and spirit. A wide-ranging discussion on biblical interpretation and Catholic teaching.
Questions Covered:
- 01:22 – Did Jonah actually get swallowed by a whale?
- 11:27 – Is there some part of the bible I should study to prepare to speak to Muslims?
- 17:16 – When the Israelites entered the holy land they fought giants. Why are there giants after the flood?
- 21:03 – Can we as Catholics personally hold the belief that the Orthodox canon is divinely inspired?
- 23:54 – Romans talk about being a slave to sin. What did Jesus actually accomplish if we are slaves to sin?
- 34:39 – New research suggests that no human should consume alcohol because of how bad it is for humans. How could God create and make water into wine at the wedding of Cana knowing how harmful it is for humans?
- 45:50 – Does the bible mean the same thing when it refers to the mind, heart, soul and spirit?
“Why isn’t fish considered meat?” This question opens a discussion on dietary laws and traditions within the Church. Other topics include the role of extraordinary ministers of holy communion, the appropriateness of taking a female saint’s name for confirmation, and the Church’s stance on organ donation, showcasing a variety of inquiries related to faith and practice.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:55 – There are things I cannot accept about Catholicism. Marriage equality and women priests are the two things that I just cannot get past.
- 16:25 – Mark 7:31-37 Where did Jesus spit?
- 20:03 – In the US we see a lot of extraordinary ministers of holy communion being used ordinarily. Is that an abuse?
- 31:44 – Why isn’t fish considered meat?
- 41:22 – Is there any issue for a man taking a female saint name for confirmation?
- 42:45 – In what state in the body of the damned?
- 44:32 – What is the Church position on organ donation?
- 48:35 – Could you clarify when it meant when God said he regretted the creation of Man when speaking to Noah?
“Is Lent biblical?” This question opens a discussion on the origins and significance of Lent, addressing whether it is a divine command or a human tradition. Additional topics include the nature of God’s sacrifice, the fate of Protestants, and the practice of refraining from saying Hallelujah during Lent, providing a rich exploration of faith and tradition.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:46 – Is Lent biblical or is it a man made tradition?
- 12:30 – Did God want to die for us? Why did he put the tree of the knowledge of God and evil in the Garden in the first place?
- 20:15 – Do all protestants go to hell?
- 28:30 – Are there any recognized Catholic saints from Scotland?
- 36:12 – Why do we not say Hallelujah during lent and when did that practice start?
- 41:00 – Am I sinning by how I think about other people? I’m not judging others but I can’t help but see their sin. How can we be witnesses to others without being forceful?
- 43:45 – Am I sinning by how I think about other people? I’m not judging others but I can’t help but see their sin. How can we be witnesses to others without being forceful?
“Can you explain papal authority?” This question opens a discussion on the complexities of Church leadership, including the reconciliation of Vatican I and the Council of Constance. Other topics include the practice of praying for the dead and the perspectives of Orthodox believers on Roman primacy, highlighting the diverse theological inquiries that arise in Catholic apologetics.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:07 – I am no longer Catholic but I don’t really know why it’s taking me long to desire to come back.
- 20:15 – Even if I were to accept 2 Macc. We could not accept the practice of praying for the dead because it was descriptive, not prescriptive.
- 23:59 – I’m Orthodox. In the 7th Ecumenical Council it talks about the agreement with the patriarchs. I do see a Roman primacy but it feels like there’s something missing where Rome didn’t do things with the agreement of the other patriarchs.
- 43:05 – How do you reconcile the contradiction on papal authority in Vatican 1 and Council of Constance?
- 50:25 – A couple was struck down in Acts of the Apostles after holding back. That feels like it contradicts the message of Jesus and the gospel. Can you explain?
“Is Receiving Ashes Against Scripture? This question opens a discussion on the intersection of faith and politics, addressing concerns about the implications of such support. Other topics include the challenge of serving both God and money, and the complexities of identity in faith, such as navigating historical claims about the papacy and exploring the differences between Catholicism and Orthodoxy.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:12 – Reading not doing public penance, but then we get big ashes on our heads.
- 09:23 – Jesus said you can’t serve God and money. Is it contrary to being a christian for a Church to support a political party or movement?
- 18:38 – Isn’t it condescending to ask the question, why aren’t you Catholic? You’re asking, why aren’t you one of us? Wouldn’t it be better to ask who raised you to be the faith you are?
- 40:56 – 1689 London Baptist confession of faith claims the pope is the Anti-Christ, how do I navigate that as a non-Catholic?
- 51:52 – I’m looking into Catholicism and Orthodoxy. What’s the Catholic response to the claim that Rome used to be orthodox before the great schism?
“Can non-Catholics receive ashes?” This question opens a discussion on the significance of rituals in the Catholic faith. Other topics include the differences between Catholic Mass and Protestant services, the removal of certain feast days from the calendar, and the meaning behind the priest adding a drop of water to the wine.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:30 – Can Non-Catholics receive ashes?
- 06:09 – I’m in OCIA. How do I sum up the differences between a Catholic mass and a protestant service and why it’s important?
- 12:44 – In the new calendar we removed feast days of saints. Why did that happen and did it undermine papal authority?
- 16:58 – How can the bread turn into the body and the wine turn into the blood?
- 21:50 – Iowa Catholic Radio. Why does the priest add a drop of water into the wine?
- 28:47 – Are the SSPX in communion with Rome? What do you say to someone who goes to those masses?
- 34:28 – Can you emphasize why our Catholic rituals have meaning?
- 43:49 – Why does the eucharist have to be celebrated at every mass if it’s only required once a year?
- 51:14 – My priest changes words during the mass. What are your thoughts on that?
“Why is Mary our Mother?” This question opens a discussion on the significance of Mary in Catholicism, touching on her role as a mediator and the importance of the rosary. Other topics include the justification of the saints in Scripture and the nature of Marian apparitions, providing a comprehensive look at these essential aspects of faith.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:30 – What Bible passage do you like as far as justifying the Catholic view of the saints?
- 09:08 – I want to pray the rosary but I struggle with the amount of prayers meditating on Mary rather than Jesus. Can you help me get over this hurdle?
- 24:08 – Why is the rosary so repetitive?
- 34:31 – How does the Church determine whether a Marian apparition is authentic?
- 40:35 – The Orthodox reject the immaculate conception but believes that Mary had her sin removed at some point in her life. Why isn’t that the Catholic position?
- 46:13 – Why is it imperative for Mary to have remained a virgin? Does it have anything to do with Mary being the Ark of the covenant?
- 49:42 – The decades of the rosary meditate on the life of Jesus. What are your thoughts on that?
“Did God will Adam and Eve to sin?” This question opens a discussion that touches on the necessity of the cross and whether God could have chosen another means for salvation. Other topics include the validity of baptism when the recipient lacks full desire, and the Church’s stance on karma, providing a rich exploration of faith and doctrine.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:06 – Did God will Adam and Eve to sin?
- 14:06 – Regarding the necessity of the cross. I’m bothered by the Catholic idea that God could have used something else other than the cross.
- 20:18 – For doctrine to change, what mechanically needs to change as a prerequisite?
- 28:59 – What is the validity of the baptism of a person who does not fully desire it or desires it for the wrong reasons?
- 34:16 – How does the Church view karma and why does she reject it?
- 44:40 – I accept the real presence, but I have a hard time adoring the host in adoration?
- 51:41 – I attended a sede-vacantist church and I admired their unity. Our Catholic churches seem so divided. Will we admit that the experiment of Vatican II failed?
“Does the Church make Scripture pointless?” This question addresses concerns some Protestants have regarding the Church’s role as the infallible interpreter of Scripture and its implications for the authority of the Bible. Other topics include the mechanics of transubstantiation, the Catholic understanding of being born again, and the relationship between faith and works.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:49 – Some Protestants have a problem with the belief that the Church (identified in the magisterium) is the infallible interpreter of Scripture. They argue that if the Church is infallible in this task, then Scripture has no inherent authority.
- 20:00 – How does transubstantiation work?
- 29:01 – How do Catholics understand the born-again discourse?
- 32:50 – Can you clarify why you believe in Faith plus works?
- 43:50 – Why has the Church changed so much in the last 80 years?
- 49:16 – Why does the Church exclusively associate the Petrine office with Rome?
“Could the Pope Crown a New Holy Roman Emperor Today?” While the papal authority in this regard has evolved, the discussion touches on the historical significance of such ceremonies. Other intriguing questions include whether zombies could get married and what argument one might use to convince a medieval king of time travel. Additionally, the conversation explores the limits of a priest’s ability to bless water.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:20 – Could zombies get married?
- 12:04 – What person does Jimmy consider a healer
- 21:45 – Does the Pope still hypothetically have the power to crown a Holy Roman Emperor?
- 28:47 – If you were cast back in time, let’s say to medieval Europe. You are captured upon the moment that you materialized in the past and were brought before the King immediately. You have one argument that you can present to the King to prove that you are a time traveler (and not say a witch). What argument could you use to convince the king that you time travelled? If you fail at the argument you’re burned at the stake. Those are high stakes!!
- 37:12 – Is there any evidence that ancient humans may have reached a level of technological advancement similar to, or even higher than, ours, and that this knowledge was somehow lost after the fall or after the great flood?
- 51:20 – How much water can a Priest bless in one time? Presumably they cannot bless the whole ocean so how far is their reach in this regard?
“Could vampires be creatures of God?” This question opens a fascinating discussion about the nature of evil and creation, particularly in light of the belief that vampires, as blood-consuming beings, oppose Christ. Other intriguing topics include the theological implications of aliens being viewed as demons and whether fictional narratives can align with real-life moral principles.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:52 – How do we grapple with the Eastern Orthodox theology that aliens would be considered demons? I think the idea is largely from Fr Seraphim Rose (although he’s quite contentious in orthodox circles as I have many friends who dislike him a lot, and others who consider him better than basically every saint)
- 13:37 – Hello, thank you for taking the time to read my email. I watched your video “Could You Marry An Alien,” and I found it to be quite comprehensive in answering that question. But, now I have a question on whether the exact same principles for real life need to be followed in a fictional story. I have been reading a serialized science fiction story by an Anglican author. In the story, a relationship starts to develop between a human male and a humanoid female alien. I have talked with the author about his plans for the story, and while most of the criteria have been met (being with a rational soul, will be baptized later in the story) the author decided to treat the ability to have children the same as an infertile human couple. Is this an okay approach for a fictional story, or should real-life principles be applied? He has also discussed another potential solution, potentially objectionable idea. Having sci-fi technology be capable of allowing inter-species couples to reproduce. Is this a viable solution, provided that it works like acceptable fertility treatments (instead of IVF, cloning, or any other unnatural intrusion) or is this also bad? Can the same principles be applied to humanoid fantasy creatures as to aliens?
- 22:54 – I understand vampires to be the antithesis of Christ, consuming blood to give themselves life whereas Christ shed His blood to give us life, and this makes vampires evil. If they were real, how could they be evil since they would be creations of God? It seems a paradox to me that they would be naturally evil (the evil act of consuming blood is in their nature) while being a creature of God.
- 35:18 – I enjoy listening to much of your content! I am wondering: Does Jesus genetically resemble God in genotype and/or phenotype? How about Mary? Thank you for considering answering my question!
- 42:51 – Is it ok for one to hold the view that the Tree of Life from Kabbalah is a valid conception of God without straying from the doctrinal belief in the Trinity? Like, if God is so beyond the realm of human comprehension (in the sense of the story of the blind men and the elephant, where we as mortals don’t possess the capacity to conceptualize God in His totality), is it valid to explore other conceptions of the role God plays in the world without straying into heretical territory so long as you still hold onto the traditional categorization of the Trinity as well?
- 50:58 – If there were no Fall, would philosophy exist?
“Can I pray to my family members who have died” The conversation touches on whether it’s appropriate to pray to deceased family members and explores the order of Marian Dogmas, providing a well-rounded look at these important topics.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 20:20 – Can I pray to my family members who have died?
- 34:01 – Is there an order among Marian Dogmas?
“Did the Exodus really happen?” This question invites a closer look at the historical and theological implications of the Exodus narrative. Additionally, the discussion touches on why Matthew 24:36 states that not even the Son knows the time of God’s return, and how the Rosary played a role in defeating the Cathars, highlighting the rich tapestry of faith and history in Catholicism.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 08:24 – Did the Exodus really happen, or is it symbolic?
- 37:08 – How exactly did the Rosary defeat the Cathars?
- 48:35 – Why do the Gospels share the same story with different details?
“How should I sort through everything the Church teaches?” This question opens a discussion on navigating the complexities of Church doctrine. Additionally, the episode addresses intriguing topics such as why St. Michael is recognized as a saint despite being an angel, and whether a Protestant can participate in Confession, providing a well-rounded exploration of faith.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:58 – How should I sort through everything the Church teaches?
- 13:20 – How come St. Michael is a saint if he is an angel?
- 20:28 – What’s the response to the claim that Mary and Joseph did not have very much faith because they were afraid and didn’t know where to look when they lost Jesus?
- 33:10 – Can a Protestant go to Confession?
- 42:50 – How is the Eucharist a propitiatory sacrifice and how is it applied?
“What’s the best argument against Mormonism?” This question opens a discussion on the key points of contention between Catholicism and Mormon beliefs. Additionally, the conversation touches on the evidence of divine protection for the magisterium and offers guidance for an ex-Mormon navigating discussions about biblical reinterpretations, such as baptism for the dead.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:20 – What’s the best argument against Mormonism?
- 18:15 – What is evidence of divine protection for the magisterium and the Catholic Church as a whole?
- 35:41 – I’m an ex-Mormon in OCIA. How do I talk to my family about the bible verses that Joseph Smith and reinterpreted such as baptism for the dead.
“Does prevenient grace give some form of imperfect faith, hope, or love in order to move us to baptism?” This question opens a discussion on the nature of grace and its role in our spiritual journey. Other topics include the unique benefits of Eucharistic adoration compared to communal prayer, the lesser-known significance of St. Joseph, and the reasons why the symbolic view of baptism is not accurate.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:36 – Does prevenient grace give some form of imperfect faith, hope or love in order to move us to baptism?
- 16:21 – What do I get out of adoring the Eucharist that I wouldn’t get from gathering 2 or 3 in Jesus name?
- 31:54 – Why don’t we hear much about St. Joseph?
- 43:50 – Why is the view of baptism being symbolic not correct?
“Is Sola Scriptura self-refuting?” This question opens a discussion on the foundations of Scripture’s authority, while also addressing why Catholics believe the Eucharist is essential for salvation. Additional topics include the salvation of Gentiles in Romans 2 and the theological implications of drinking the blood of Jesus despite biblical prohibitions.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 08:03 – Is Sola Scriptura Self Refuting?
- 14:40 – Why do Catholics believe they need the eucharist to be saved?
- 35:12 – How are the gentiles in Romans 2 saved?
- 50:35 – If the bible says drinking blood is a sin, then why is drinking the blood of Jesus not a sin?
“How Can Non-Catholics Be Saved If Jesus is the Only Mediator?” This question opens a discussion on the relationship between faith, works, and salvation, addressing concerns about Ephesians 2:8-9 and its compatibility with Catholic teaching. Other topics include the nature of Marian devotion and its perceived paganism, as well as the implications of Vatican II on salvation for non-Catholics.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 09:41 – Seems to me that Marian devotion is paganism, like it’s worship. It’s one of the reasons why I left the Church. How would you respond to that objection?
- 21:42 – It always bothered me that God gave Bathsheba an abortion — why would God do that?
- 29:32 – According to Vatican II a non-Catholic can be saved. That seems to contradict Jesus’ teaching that nobody comes to the Father except through him.
- 37:02 – Why do we have Holy Days of Obligation?
- 46:46 – After Peter died, would the new bishop or Rome have authority over the still living apostles, such as John?
- 50:52 – Is it better to think of works in terms of losing our salvation through mortal sins of omission?
“How do you make a good examination of conscience?” This essential practice is explored alongside questions about the significance of Jesus’ second coming, the role of the Trinity in marriage counseling, and the implications of annulments for remarriage. Each topic sheds light on the complexities of faith and relationships within the Catholic tradition.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:50 – How do you make a good examination of conscience?
- 19:25 – What does it mean that Jesus will come again in glory? Was the first time at creation, the incarnation, or the Eucharist?
- 22:00 – How might one use the image of the Trinity when counseling couples for marriage?
- 24:33 – What happened to the gold, frankincense, and myrrh that the wise men gave to Mary and Joseph?
- 29:57 – If my husband divorced and I have an annulment, does he have to die before I can marry someone else?
- 36:00 – My wife and I are going through OCIA and our annulments are not complete. If the annulments are not finalized by Holy Week would we still be able to enter the Church provided that we intend to remain celibate until the annulments are resolved?
- 41:00 – Could a widow enter into a marriage that was just through the Catholic Church and not a civil, legal marriage? I’m getting mixed answers about whether or not this should be done.
- 43:26 – My son is getting married to a muslim woman. He was raised Catholic. Now he says he believes in God but not in Jesus’ divinity. She is Muslim but not very practicing. They told her father a lie, that my son converted to Islam, to appease him. How do I handle this upcoming wedding?
“Will there be a Rapture?” This episode dives into the Catholic perspective on popular rapture theology and explores key topics such as the concept of a literal thousand-year reign, the Catholic understanding of the Three Days of Darkness, and the nature of the Antichrist. Join us for an examination of these important eschatological questions.
[Encore episode, original air date July 25, 2025]
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:30 – Will there be a Rapture, and how should Catholics respond to popular “rapture” theology?
- 20:00 – Will there be a literal thousand-year reign (the “millennium”)?
- 31:00 – What is the Catholic understanding of the Three Days of Darkness?
- 33:00 – What is the Illumination of Conscience or Warning, and when might it occur?
- 43:00 – What is “Antichrist”?
“Are we currently in the End Times?” This episode explores the signs of Jesus’ return, delving into questions like what dispensationalism is and whether Jesus got end-of-the-world prophecies wrong. Join us as we navigate these important topics and more in this thought-provoking discussion.
[Encore episode, original air date July 25, 2025]
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:30 – What is dispensationalism?
- 05:59 – Are we currently in the End Times?
- 14:30 – What are the signs that will precede the return of Jesus?
- 30:33 – Did Jesus get end-of-the-world prophecies wrong?
- 49:58 – Will Jesus really return—like “a thief in the night”?
“Can saints intercede for us?” This episode explores the biblical basis for intercession, addressing questions like the reconciliation of Revelation 22:9 with the practice of honoring saints and the significance of the Eucharist in relation to salvation. Tune in as we also delve into the complexities of annulments and the nature of Mary’s sinlessness.
[Encore episode, original air date July 22, 2025]
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:55 – The saints’ attempt to intercede for us in Rev. 6:9 seems to have failed. What other biblical evidence is there for intercession?
- 14:16 – How can you reconcile Rev. 22:9 with the practice of offering dulia to the saints?
- 23:28 – If the Eucharist is required for salvation, then why did Jesus tell the good thief he would be in paradise that day. Why was it good enough for him but not the rest of us?
- 31:13 – It doesn’t make sense because we don’t know which saints are in heaven and if we pray to one that isn’t there, does that mean we are praying to a demon? The saints pray for you.
- 36:56 – Religions are man made and are all imperfect in particular the Catholic Church?
- 46:33 – I don’t understand where annulments fit into scripture?
- 51:31 – What sin did Mary not have? What is a dark intellect?
“Is eternal security promised in John 5:24?” This episode explores the implications of Jesus’ words on eternal life and judgment. Additionally, we delve into questions about the Church’s changes in the Mass, the nature of angels and their vulnerabilities, and the role of priests in forgiving sins.
[Encore episode, original air date July 22, 2025]
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:30 – “Jesus says in John 5:24 whoever believes in him has ‘eternal life.’ He states, “24 Truly, truly, I say to you, he who hears my word and believes him who sent me, has eternal life; he does not come into judgment, but has passed from death to life. Isn’t that a promise of eternal security?”
- 16:55 – Mt. 12:38 seems to contradict what Catholicism teaches on how much time Jesus spent in hell.
- 20:16 – Why did the Church change so much in mass?
- 28:50 – Can angels get hurt?
- 32:27 – I think there is a contradiction between priests forgiving in persona Christi since they contribute nothing vs forgiving mortal sin.
- 46:04 – It seems as though we worship an arrogant God.
“Why is the Catholic Church the One True Church?” This episode dives into the unique claims of the Catholic faith, while also addressing pressing questions like the existence of Hell and the fate of souls, the significance of John 6, and effective ways to share faith with nonbelievers.
[Encore from August 8, 2025]
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:17 – Oneness Pentecostal: Is the Catholic Church the One True Church?
- 11:11 – Is There a Hell, and Do Most People Go There?
- 20:54 – Recommended Videos on John 6
- 24:38 – Why “Bind and Loose” Doesn’t Apply to Everyone
- 35:41 – Best Way to Bring Faith to Nonbelievers
- 43:00 – Why Jesus Didn’t Let Mary Magdalene Touch Him
- 51:20 – Who Was in Heaven When Enoch & Elijah Arrived?
“Which Marian apparition has the best evidence?” In this episode, we explore this intriguing question alongside a variety of topics, including whether Pope Leo might change Church teaching and the implications of obeying dogmas given from the future. We also discuss the nature of sedevacantism and how God protects the Church from error.
[Encore from August 8, 2025]
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:00 – Best-Evidence Marian Apparition
- 15:25 – Will Pope Leo Change Church Teaching?
- 22:48 – Must I Obey “Future” Dogmas?
- 29:55 – Is Sedevacantism Heresy?
- 36:30 – Accepting Jesus Without the Sacraments? (Rev 3:20)
- 41:15 – How Does God Protect the Church From Error?
- 47:47 – Protestant Mom Received Eucharist—What Should I Do?
“What are Anglican sacraments?” This question opens a discussion on the validity of Anglican sacraments, alongside inquiries about communicating the nature of devotionals to non-Catholics and the historical role of laity in the early Church. The conversation also touches on the impact of politics on the split between Orthodox and Roman rites, providing a rich exploration of faith and history.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:28 – What is “Norming the norm that cannot be normed?”
- 13:45 – What are some ways to communicate to non-Catholics and fallen away Catholics that devotionals are not obligatory?
- 21:08 – Why are Anglican sacraments not valid?
- 28:55 – Why does the New Testament not talk about the fulfillment of the prophecies of the destruction of the Temple?
- 31:48 – Are there any historical records of the laity in the early church being able to celebrate the Mass?
- 35:35 – What is Joe’s preferred Bible?
- 37:41 – If it weren’t for human politics between East and West, would there not have been a split between Orthodox and Roman rites?
- 46:30 – Does Catholicism have a good answer to modern Biblical scholarship?
“Why do Catholics make religion so complicated?” This question opens a discussion on the intricacies of Catholic beliefs and practices. The episode also addresses the significance of the number 37 in scripture, the relationship between the Gospels of Mark and John, and whether one can wear a scapular without being baptized.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:05 – Why do Catholics Make Religion so Complicated?
- 09:58 – The number 37 seems to show up a number of times in scripture is there some significance to this?
- 13:35 – If Mark was written before John, why doesn’t Mark’s Gospel include the “I AM” statements?
- 22:31 – Can I wear a Scapular if I am not Baptized?
- 23:16 – If I attended Sunday evening Mass but they did different readings than the Sunday morning Mass, does it still fulfill the Sunday obligation?
- 29:30 – What is the SSPX and sedevacantist relationship to the Church?
- 40:12 – How can I defend the Faith when I am not sophisticated in my arguments at the moment?
- 50:15 – If the Kingdom of David ended when God said it wouldn’t why does God not apply the same standard to the Great Apostasy?
Are practices like the blessing of throats or cars just superstition, or do they have a deeper meaning in the Catholic faith? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Jimmy Akin addresses this question before tackling several others about Scripture and theology. He explains how to understand God’s role in events like the plagues of Egypt, whether the Garden of Eden can be seen as the first tabernacle, and when Satan’s fall occurred in relation to Adam and Eve. The episode also explores the apparent tension between faith and works in the Bible and offers guidance on how to approach questions about the “extra” books in the Catholic canon, including resources for understanding their historical and theological basis. A thoughtful discussion on Scripture, tradition, and Catholic practice.
Questions Covered:
- 01:02 – Opener: Is the blessing of throats and blessing of cars superstitious?
- 11:25 – How did God allow the plague in Egypt to happen?
- 17:22 – Was the Garden of Eden the first tabernacle?
- 20:02 – Did Satan fall before Adam and Eve?
- 29:23 – It seems like there is a contradiction in the Bible between Faith, and Faith + works. What resources can you offer about the 7 extra books in the bible? Something not from the Vatican to not be biased in favor of Catholics.
“Is the Angel of the Lord Jesus?” This question opens a discussion on the identity of this figure in Scripture, alongside inquiries about the biblical basis for purgatory and the role of Mary. Other topics include the appropriateness of clapping in church and the actions of a priest during the Agnus Dei, providing a rich exploration of Catholic beliefs and practices.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:37 – Is it appropriate to clap in church?
- 11:54 – Gen 3:15 says he will crush the head of the serpent but the vulgate translates it to she. This is keeping me from converting.
- 23:29 – I’m blind. What does the priest do while the congregation sings the agnus dei?
- 34:53 – Where do we find purgatory in the bible?
- 37:20 – Is this angel of the Lord in the Old Testament believed to be Jesus?
- 46:29 – Psalm 51:2 Catholic version is different. The bible version is different from the mass part read. Why is that. The USCCB version moves it down to verse 4.
- 49:22 – Does scripture teach the sinlessness of Mary?
“Can you interpret the Sower parable?” This question opens a discussion on the meaning of Mark 4’s parable, touching on themes of public teaching and predestination. Other topics include the claim by Islam regarding the corruption of the Bible, the church’s interpretation of Genesis, and whether Mary knew of Jesus’ resurrection after the Crucifixion.
Join the Catholic Answers Live Club Newsletter
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:11 – I’ve heard that a small group of Jews are the real church based on the Acts of the Apostle and the Jews who were called “the way”?
- 13:07 – Can you explain the Sower parable of Mark 4? Why can I interpret the idea of public teaching and predestination?
- 13:07 – Can you explain the Sower parable of Mark 4? Why can I interpret the idea of public teaching and predestination? – IF you Like the question
- 18:35 – Can you explain why Islam claims that our bible is corrupt, but they also use certain books?
- 29:01 – Can you explain the church’s doctrinal literal interpretation of Genesis? Is there any consideration of young Earth creationism?
- 38:58 – Can someone interpret Genesis trees as literal trees and places? It seems it could be based on Mose’s miracles? Varied
- 48:00 – Is there a reliable bible commentary for an average reader not scholar?
- 52:51 – After Jesus is Crucified did Mary know He was going to rise in 3 days?
“Why Aren’t You Christian?” In this episode we ask callers why they are not Christian, and we answer any questions they have about the Catholic faith.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 16:00 – Am I doing the wrong thing by not becoming a Catholic?
- 24:55 – My non-Christian brother says he’s not Christian because the God of the Old Testament is not a loving God.
- 42:12 – I have studied religions my entire life. I don’t think faith in any religious faith is worth doing.
“Is annulment just Catholic divorce?” This episode explores the nuances of annulment in the Catholic Church, addressing common misconceptions. Additionally, we tackle questions about the implications of not becoming Catholic, the significance of burying a St. Joseph statue, and the challenges of faith in the context of differing beliefs.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:30 – Is annulment just Catholic divorce?
- 17:25 – My Catholic friend buried a statue of St. Joseph upside down
- 35:27 – Can two non-practicing baptized Catholics get married outside of the Catholic Church?
- 45:39 – Can a Catholic watch K Pop Demon Hunters?
- 52:44 – I recently saw in a church dia de los muerte images displayed next to Mary images.
In this episode, we feature Jeff Cavins, author of the Bible in a Year. He answers all your major biblical questions!
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 12:44 – Where do we see Eucharistic adoration in the bible?
- 18:15 – Could you elaborate on who king james was? Were there ways of reading the bible before King James and the printing press?
- 22:19 – What do we know about Cane’s wife and the city that he built?
- 32:37 – I read the bible twice, what can I do to make my next read more meaningful?
- 40:30 – How do you get through the Old Testament? I always lose steam at Numbers?
“How do we engage teens in faith and Eucharistic adoration?” This episode explores effective strategies for connecting with young people, addressing common misconceptions about reaching teens, and discussing the biblical foundations of Eucharistic adoration. Additionally, we delve into resources for catechists and ways to foster meaningful conversations about prayer with teens.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:00 – What do we get wrong about reaching teens?
- 18:25 – I teach catechism. What resources do you recommend implementing those principles?
- 24:18 – I’m a catechist. The teens don’t even want to talk. How do you even start to engage them?
- 31:55 – How do you capture the kids younger since in their teen years, we’ve already lost them?
- 42:13 – I made my students feel like this was their program, their opportunity. What are your thoughts on that approach?
- 45:14 – How do you talk about prayer to teens?
- 49:17 – What things can you do to keep your young adult kids engaged when they come home from Catholic university?
“Can non-Catholics be saved?” This episode explores the nuances of salvation beyond Catholicism, while also addressing why Catholics confess to a priest instead of going directly to God, and the significance of feast days in the Church.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:12 – Why do protestants not make the sign of the cross before praying like Catholics?
- 10:54 – Why do we confess our sins to a priest and not just go directly to God?
- 14:55 – Why do Catholics believe that they are the one true church if people from other denominations can make it to heaven without becoming Catholic?
- 20:57 – How do I answer the following protestant arguments: Transcendental argument for God and rejecting the Thomist view? The fallible list of infallible books argument?
- 48:58 – Why do Catholics have feast days where they carry statues of Mary?
“Why do Catholics believe in Sacred Tradition?” In this episode, we explore the significance of Sacred Tradition, along with questions about the meaning behind the peace greeting during Mass, the role of the Catechism of the Catholic Church, and the origins of holy days of obligation. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these essential aspects of Catholic faith.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:42 – Why do Catholics believe in Sacred Tradition?
- 05:51 – But those traditions aren’t some unwritten teachings that Christians are bound to believe. They’re simply the same stuff that Paul wrote down.
- 13:57 – Why do Catholics say the peace be with you during the mass?
- 19:39 – What is the Catechism of the Catholic Church and why do we follow it?
- 29:48 – why do we have holy days of obligation and when did they start?
- 37:20 – Why would God institute animal sacrifice in the old testament if it ultimately wouldn’t suffice?
- 46:59 – Is there an exhaustive list of infallible teaching? Why isn’t it written into a creed?
“Is confession Catholic therapy?” This episode explores the role of confession in spiritual healing, alongside discussions on the Catholic understanding of salvation, the challenges of prayer devoted to Mary, and navigating marriage in the Church when one partner is hesitant. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:00 – Is confession Catholic therapy?
- 09:45 – What is the Catholic view of Salvation as it relates to faith?
- 14:22 – I struggle with the time prayer devoted to Mary?
- 20:13 – Can you explain the foundation of the Catholic church?
- 29:05 – How can I get married in the Church, but my spouse doesn’t want to?
- 34:24 – I am struggling with accepting and understanding Confession. After a general confession, I find myself thinking of new sins or doubt of making a good confession
- 42:45 – Are sins committed in dreams sinful, and how can one deal with minimizing “sins” in dreams?
- 46:50 – Going through OCIA, what tips and pointers can Fr. offer as he goes through the process?
- 52:28 – What to do when she attends Mass and witnesses folks doing odd things…I.e. Drinking coffee, brings dog etc….?
“Can Catholics be saved by works?” This episode explores the relationship between faith and works in Catholicism, addressing concerns about the New Testament’s reliability and the emphasis on works over faith. Additionally, we delve into questions about the Catholic view on Mary and the reasons behind the Church’s baptism practices. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:25 – I am not Catholic or Christian because there is too much fiction in the New Testament for it to be reliable.
- 11:59 – I am religious, but I am not Catholic because of the issues with organized religion.
- 18:00 – Catholics seem to put too much emphasis on works not faith. Why do Catholics put emphasis on Works?
- 30:07 – I am struggling with the Catholic view on Mary?
- 46:30 – Where in scripture does it layout the current financial hierarchy of the Catholic Church? Second: Why do Catholic not do full immersion Baptisms?
“Who Was Peter’s Wife?” This episode explores the complexities of salvation and morality, alongside intriguing questions like whether psychic healing undermines miracles as proof for God and what happened to the saints who rose at Christ’s resurrection. Tune in for a thought-provoking discussion on faith and understanding.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:20 – Does psychic healing undermine miracles as proof for God?
- 14:56 – Does Genesis 1:26 show the Father speaking to the Son?
- 21:40 – Can psychopaths who feel no remorse be saved?
- 28:48 – What happened to the saints who rose at Christ’s resurrection?
- 34:00 – Why does the Bible describe parents eating their own children?
- 37:58 – Who was Peter’s wife, and did he get along with his mother-in-law?
- 43:14 – If aliens needed saving, would Jesus have two mothers?
- 48:16 – Can someone be a Buddhist Catholic?
“Can damned souls ever repent?” This episode explores the complexities of salvation and the afterlife, addressing questions such as the nature of excommunication and whether a parent’s desire can lead to the baptism of an unbaptized child. Tune in as we also consider the implications of Luther’s potential reforms and the intriguing topic of spirit possession.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:07 – How many souls did my twins have before the egg split?
- 13:27 – If I’m born at 7 a.m. on Ash Wednesday, does fasting start then?
- 17:50 – What if Luther had reformed from within the Church?
- 20:36 – Can a living person’s spirit possess someone else?
- 30:49 – Can a parent’s desire baptize a child who dies unbaptized?
- 34:17 – If someone was excommunicated unfairly, can they still go to heaven?
- 41:32 – Can damned souls or demons ever repent?
- 46:40 – If science shows we’re small and ordinary, how are humans still special?
“Can non-Catholics be saved?” This episode explores the complexities of salvation outside the Catholic Church, addressing questions like the origins of apostolic Churches and the resurgence of Gnosticism in some Protestant denominations. Tune in as we also discuss the nature of God’s invisibility and the role of patron saints in our lives.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:00 – Can you explain why non-Catholics who reject Catholicism will not have salvation?
- 14:00 – How can I find a list of all the apostolic Churches and where the Apostles ended up?
- 23:03 – Do you see Gnosticism creeping back into some Protestant denominations?
- 35:30 – How is God invisible?
- 42:27 – How does one establish a relationship with our patron saints and what do they do for us?
- 50:55 – Have you heard of people experiencing a being presenting itself in their room at night?
“Where did we get the Rosary?” This episode explores the origins of this beloved prayer tool, while also addressing intriguing questions such as the absence of records of Jesus’ life between birth and age thirty, the proper way to venerate Catholic statues, and the role of guardian angels after death. Tune in for a rich discussion on these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:00 – Where did we get the Rosary?
- 17:45 – Why is there no record of Jesus’ life between birth and thirty?
- 28:45 – Do you clean Catholic statues with holy water? What’s the proper way to venerate St. Jude and Our Lady of Guadalupe statues?
- 42:36 – What happens to your guardian angel when you die? Do they mediate during your judgement?
- 48:47 – What insights can you offer on how to respond to Pentecostals?
“Can the Hierarchy Change Itself?” This episode delves into the complexities of Church authority and reform, addressing questions such as whether the Church still uses canon priests and how to trust the hierarchy. We also explore intriguing topics like Pope Leo’s blessing of ice and the implications of a heretical pope according to Bellarmine.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:55 – Does that Church still set up canon priests to assist and convey messages for bishops?
- 06:57 – Does the Church hierarchy have the authority to change the Church hierarchy?
- 15:05 – I’m returning to the Church but I’m having a hard time trusting the hierarchy.
- 24:09 – Why should we conform to a magisterium who has abandoned Christ?
- 37:55 – Are you familiar with Pope Leo blessing the block of ice and the whole significance behind that?
- 48:30 – When Robert Bellarmine said that there can be a heretical pope, what did he mean by that?
“Does God Want Organized Religion?” In this episode, we explore the role of organized faith and its significance, along with questions like why Protestants should respect the Pope and how a priest can absolve sin. We also delve into the historical presence of bishops and the continuity of apostolic authority, providing a comprehensive look at these vital topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:01 – Does God Want An Organized Religion?
- 13:37 – How do I explain to protestants why they should at least respect the pope?
- 17:38 – How can a priest absolve a person from sin if he is also only a man?
- 29:05 – What are biblical or historical proofs that bishops were present from the beginning and not an addition in the 4th century?
- 42:00 – How would we address someone who agrees that Jesus gave authority to his apostles but disagrees that it was passed on?
- 47:49 – I’m distressed with the pope. How can I have any confidence in the Church? I need guidance.
“Choosing Anglican or Catholic ” This episode explores the complexities of Marian dogmas and their biblical foundations, addressing concerns about the Assumption of Mary and the concept of sinlessness. Additionally, we delve into the journey from Orthodoxy to Catholicism and the implications of mortal sin on the Holy Spirit, along with the topic of idolatry in worship practices.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:11 – I have trouble with Marian dogmas because I believe they contradict the bible. The Assumption of Mary is never mentioned in scripture. How can Mary be sinless if the bible says that all have sinned and have fallen short.
- 18:15 – I’m going to leave Orthodoxy for either High Church Anglican or Catholicism. What advice do you have for me?
- 28:40 – I’ve studied Catholicism as a Protestant for years now. Does the Holy Spirit leave you when you commit a mortal sin and get the Holy Spirit back when you repent?
- 40:32 – I grew up protestant and was taught that worshipping idols is wrong. Praying to the dead seems wrong.
“Can Mary be sinless if all have sinned?” This question opens a discussion on Marian dogmas and their biblical foundations, alongside inquiries about the Catholic Church’s stance on divorce and communion, and the journey from Orthodoxy to Catholicism.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 5:40 – The Catholic Church teaches that the reason why we stand in a right relationship with God—that’s to say, the reason we’re justified—is because of the interior righteousness that is brought about within us when we’re initially justified. But if that’s the case, then the focus would move away from the perfection of the work of Christ to the believer who has to maintain the state or condition, thereby dividing the glory between the savior and the saved.
- 7:11 – I have trouble with Marian dogmas because I believe they contradict the bible. The Assumption of Mary is never mentioned in scripture. How can Mary be sinless if the bible says that all have sinned and have fallen short.
- 18:04 – I’m Protestant interested in Catholicism. My Methodist church has fallen away from biblical teachings. Why aren’t divorced people allowed in the Church but people who advocate for abortion allowed to receive communion?
- 18:15 – I’m going to leave Orthodoxy for either High Church Anglican or Catholicism. What advice do you have for me?
- 28:40 – I’ve studied Catholicism as a Protestant for years now. Does the Holy Spirit leave you when you commit a mortal sin and get the Holy Spirit back when you repent?
- 30:54 – What’s the true faith and how can you know it’s true?
- 40:32 – I grew up protestant and was taught that worshipping idols is wrong. Praying to the dead seems wrong.
- 40:35 – I wasn’t raised with religion forced upon me. What is Protestantism?
“How To Talk About Jesus to Anyone” explores effective ways to share your faith with others. This episode also addresses questions about the importance of evangelization in today’s world and practical tips for faith sharing in everyday conversations. Tune in for a thoughtful discussion on these vital topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:00 – How To Talk About Jesus to Anyone
“What Saints Battled Addiction?” This episode delves into healing and devotion, offering practical advice for those struggling with addiction. Additionally, we explore the role of devotion in the healing process and address concerns about judgment when returning to the Church during recovery. Tune in for a thoughtful discussion on these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 0:00 – What Saints Battled Addiction?
- 15:35 – What is your advice on how to overcome sexual addiction?
- 33:35 – What are your thoughts on having a devotion to help with healing?
- 36:15 – I’m on the road to recovery. I have a fear of being judged while trying to return to Church. How is recovery and the church intertwined?
“Is Faith a Gift or a Choice?” This episode explores the intersection of faith and popular culture, while also addressing questions about the power of relics in 2 Kings 13:21, the implications of AI-generated art, and the complexities of faith as a gift. Tune in for a thought-provoking discussion on these diverse topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:20 – Is Billy Batson sinning by using the powers of Hercules, Atlas, Zeus, Achilles, and Mercury?
- 06:43 – Do you think 2 Kings 13:21 could be used as proof for the power of relics?
- 10:00 – In a past AMA, you said that if someone were assimilated by the Borg, the state of their soul adjacent to confession would remain unchanged. If someone were assimilated, could they conceivably receive the anointing of the sick?
- 15:57 – Can AI generated images be considered art?
- 21:44 – If faith is a gift, how can someone be culpable for not having faith?
- 29:06 – As it pertains to the dating of the Gospel of John, I think there’s good internal evidence that it’s written before 70 AD, but I’ve heard people say that Irenaeus teaches that it’s dated in the 90-95 AD range. Is there any perspective out there that can hold that both Irenaeus is correct, and a pre-70 AD Gospel of John is correct? (For example, are people just misreading Irenaeus to make it seem like he’s saying it’s in the 90s but in reality he might not even be saying that?)
- 37:53 – Why is Catholicism a better option than Oriental Orthodoxy?
- 45:55 – As a Protestant converting to Catholicism, what duty does one have to inform family, friends, and former pastors/church members of one’s conversion to Catholicism? How should conversation be done? Any advice? Thanks!
- 52:42 – Has Catholic Answers thought of making a list of the De Fide statement found in Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma? I know this is a resource used by Catholic Answers and it would be great to have a bullet point list
“Can souls in purgatory know their fate?” This episode explores the awareness of souls at their particular judgment and whether those in purgatory know they are not in hell. Additionally, we delve into the authenticity of the Greek New Testament, the implications of Catholic marriage law, and the evidence for Mary’s immaculate conception.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:19 – Is the Greek the New Testament is written in of poor style? Is the style it is written in a testament to its authenticity?
- 19:02 – At the point of my death, at my particular judgment, will my soul necessarily be aware of its ultimate fate as either Heaven or Hell bound? Do souls in purgatory know they are not in hell? What does the magisterium lend to address these questions?
- 31:18 – What “exactly” makes someone subject to Catholic marriage law? Catholics recognize baptisms in other ecclesial communities, and baptism makes you Catholic at least in some sense, but it doesn’t subject you to Catholic marriage law.
- 41:37 – What other “evidence” is out there that Catholics may be able to point to in order to defend Mary’s immaculate conception to non-Catholic Christians, since the dogma was declared by Pope Pius IX as opposed to being derived from Scripture or another source Protestants/Evangelicals revere.
- 48:46 – If certain demons are in fact the spirits of Nephilim/giants as most Second Temple Jews and some early Christians held, were they able to be saved? If they were indeed biological offspring from angels and humans, they would still be partly human (having original sin). All writings concerning them from that period treat them like Orcs, and never show them having the possibility of redemption. Thanks.
Questions Covered:
- 02:02 – Is time itself a created substance? Can there be change or motion before there ever was time?
- 05:30 – what is redemptive suffering?
- 13:23 – Why did Christ allow himself to be baptized if he was without sin?
- 17:55 – What’s a biblical defense of souls living in heaven?
- 21:53 – How do know the difference between Gods voice and your own?
- 24:45 – John 20:32 Are there sins that were retained by the disciples?
- 33:42 – If someone is diagnosed with terminal cancer, is it morally ok to deny treatment?
- 41:20 – Jewish boys at the age of 12 have bar mitzvah. Is there a connection between this and Jesus being found in the temple at 12?
- 43:47 – What doesn’t God only make the people who will choose heaven?
- 50:11 – How would you recommend I bring up the permanence of marriage to a large protestant group?
Questions Covered:
- 04:08 – What’s the connection between protestants view of John 3:16 and the sin of presumption
- 07:57 – What do you think the source of interest of the Catholic faith among young people is?
- 13:10 – Is it true that when we pray the Hail Mary, Mary Queen of Angels is present with all angels to assist in our prayers?
- 15:52 – So many Atheist claim God doesn’t exist by saying that matter is eternal how do I debunk it?
- 18:22 – Has the Church ever canonized a non-Catholic. Is this possible
- 21:29 – How do you get closer to God?
- 29:46 – The Holy Spirit proceeding from the Father and Son implies motion and change. If they are in eternity, how can there be movement and change?
- 34:43 – How does “begets” not mean “cause” when we say that the Father begets the son?
- 40:40 – What is the latest book you’ve written?
- 45:02 – Explain the difference between grace and mercy?
- 47:42 – How do we talk to our protestant brothers and sister about the topics where we disagree?
- 50:14 – Why do we pray the Apostles Creed when we pray rosary? What’s the difference between the Nicene and Apostles creed?
“How Does the Pope Choose Cardinals?” This episode explores the complexities of papal authority, including how the pope selects bishops and cardinals, and whether it’s reasonable to question his role amid current Church confusion. We also delve into the pope’s influence on Vatican appointments and the implications of Canon 285 for clergy in public office.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:35 – How does the pope choose who will be elevated to a bishop or cardinal?
- 15:12 – Can we disagree with the pope’s statements?
- 18:42 – Why hasn’t any pope successfully consecrated Russia?
- 21:26 – Isn’t it reasonable to ask whether the pope is the real pope with so much confusion within the Church right now?
- 37:45 – Canon 285 permits clergy to hold public office. Can the pope hypothetically serve in public in the U.S?
- 46:54 – How much input does the pope have on appointing people in the Vatican? Especially people who have a scandal background?
- 51:33 – What is the pope’s recourse with a disobedient cardinal?
“What should you do if you disagree with the pope?” This episode tackles this important question while also exploring whether ex-cathedra statements are a recent development in the Church, the purpose behind papal interviews, and the implications of the pope’s humanity on his infallibility. Tune in for a thoughtful discussion on these pressing topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:45 – What should you do if you disagree with the pope?
- 15:29 – The ex-cathedra statements from the papacy seem to be a new addition and weren’t in the early Church. Are they a new addition?
- 23:11 – Why is the pope doing papal interviews if he has a seat where he can make announcements?
- 30:47 – If the pope is human, how can he not commit error?
- 36:30 – I’m in OCIA and I want to attend the latin mass but how do I know whether the latin mass church accepts or rejects the pope and Vatican II?
- 43:32 – To what extent does the pope have to make changes and reform the liturgy?
“How can I help a friend return to faith?” This episode explores effective ways to engage with those who have drifted from belief, including a discussion on the significance of the Eucharist and its real presence. Additionally, we delve into early Christian practices and the role of a priest in consecration, offering a comprehensive look at faith and conversion.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:00 – He also has a friend that grew up in the Catholic church but has fallen away and does not believe in God any longer, how can he talk to her to try and encourage her that there is a God?
- 14:01 – What does the real presence in the Eucharist mean and why is it important, does God not exist elsewhere in the world?
- 22:05 – Did the early Christians offer sacrifices at the Jewish temple?
- 29:11 – In OCIA, would like some advice on properly processing the mixed emotions he is experiencing through his conversion?
- 40:55 – If a protestant believes in the real presence how do I explain that it needs to be consecrated from a valid priest?
- 46:16 – Why does the Eucharist have to be consumed repeatedly in order to receive eternal life, “like our fathers who ate the manna in the desert?”
- 52:08 – Why does it have to be a priest to consecrate the Eucharist?
“Is the Eucharist a sign of a Deceptive God?” This episode delves into the complexities of the Eucharist, addressing questions about its significance and the real presence of Christ. Tune in as we explore concerns about salvation, the nature of communion in different denominations, and the implications of consuming the Eucharist for eternal life.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 1:00 – Is the Eucharist the sign of a Deceptive God?
- 16:10 – His friend says she is afraid of going to hell, she is not sure if she believes in God or is just afraid of Eternal Damnation. How can he minister to her?
- 21:31 – What is the Catholic response regarding the possibility of the true presence in Lutheran communion?
- 29:54 – If the wine is transformed into the blood of Christ how does that square with the God’s command not to drink blood ?
- 35:32 – Epiouis meaning higher bread. Why do we not call “our daily bread” in the Our Father the Epiouis bread?
- 45:45 – Can we make anything out of the direction of the identity statements: I am the vine, I am the door, vs the bread is me, the wine is me?
- 52:32 – If one receives communion in a non-Catholic church is that a sin?
- 04:58 – He also has a friend that grew up in the Catholic church but has fallen away and does not believe in God any longer, how can he talk to her to try and encourage her that there is a God?
- 14:01 – What does the real presence in the Eucharist mean and why is it important, does God not exist elsewhere in the world?
- 22:05 – Did the early Christians offer sacrifices at the Jewish temple?
- 29:11 – In OCIA, would like some advice on properly processing the mixed emotions he is experiencing through his conversion?
- 40:55 – If a protestant believes in the real presence how do I explain that it needs to be consecrated from a valid priest?
- 46:16 – Why does the Eucharist have to be consumed repeatedly in order to receive eternal life, “like our fathers who ate the manna in the desert?”
- 52:08 – Why does it have to be a priest to consecrate the Eucharist?
“What Identity Were You Born With?” In this episode, we explore the profound connection between our identity and the Eucharist, alongside questions about the nature of identity itself and the role of sacraments in leading a fulfilling life. We also delve into how to engage in meaningful dialogue with those of different faith backgrounds and the intriguing topic of angels in spiritual warfare.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:40 – People are obsessed with identity
- 06:25 – We have to deal with the fact that we are creatures.
- 08:00 – Where does identity come from?
- 18:04 – What does it mean that our identity is Eucharistic?
- 23:35 – His Father is non-denominational and believes that the Catholic church is just a middle ground and not necessary. That he can just go directly to Christ and have a relationship with him. What advice can Father offer for him to better dialogue with his dad?
- 31:13 – So are the sacraments “the key” to a full life?
- 35:55 – How do angels do battle?
- 43:35 – Can I classify “relation” as a transcendental of being given how Ratzinger writes about it?
- 46:44 – Why has Jesus been portrayed as a white man throughout time and what implications has that had on the Church over time?
“How to keep young people in the faith?” This episode explores essential tips for nurturing faith in youth, along with strategies for catechizing high schoolers beyond traditional Bible studies. We also address challenges like maintaining faith in split households and navigating relationships when commitment seems scarce. Tune in for a thoughtful discussion on these pressing topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:59 – What are the key tips to keeping a young person in the faith?
- 17:19 – What would be the best strategy to catechize high schoolers without resorting to it being a bible study?
- 22:28 – How do I navigate keeping my youth in the faith in a split faith household?
- 33:30 – Struggling with dating when few commit to marriage
- 42:19 – I’m protestant and my fiance grew up Catholic. He’s wanting to go back to Catholicism. I want to follow him into the Church because I’m being persuaded. How do I know Catholicism is the way?
- 52:02 – I am a professor teaching nursing students. How do I keep them Catholic?
“Can you avoid purgatory after last rites?” This episode explores the nuances of last rites and their implications for salvation, alongside intriguing questions about the meaning of the Holy Spirit overshadowing Mary and the Church’s teachings on the Nephilim. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important topics in Catholic faith.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:53 – My father received last rites and went to confession. The priest said that if he were to die, he wouldn’t have to go to purgatory. Is this true?
- 14:46 – What did it mean when the Holy Spirit overshadowed Mary?
- 21:38 – What are legitimate reasons to not have kids?
- 40:28 – What’s the Church’s official teaching on the Nephilim?
- 48:47 – Do you have to believe in all doctrines of the Catholic Church in order to be appointed a priest or bishop?
- 53:13 – 1 Corinthians 4:6 says to “not go beyond what is written.” Is this evidence for sola scriptura?
“How Does the Vatican Approve Miracles?” This episode explores the significance of Mary in Catholicism, addressing questions about her unique role and the nature of her sinlessness. Additionally, we delve into how the Vatican approves miracles, the reality of the holy fire at the holy sepulcher, and the implications of marriage convalidation for those entering the Church.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:29 – How Does the Vatican Approve Miracles?
- 14:30 – I have a lot of Protestant friends who ask me a lot about Mary. I am curious now, why do we venerate Mary at all? If she was born without original sin, how can she be good? She didn’t have the option to be sinful, because she was born without sin. So shouldn’t we venerate saints to a higher degree than her because they had the choice to be sinful and they didn’t, which seems like that makes them even better than her? Also, I also was told by a Catholic that God loves Mary more than any other human he created. Is this true?
- 24:15 – Do you think the miracle of the holy fire that the Orthodox claim at the holy sepulcher is real?
- 32:48 – My wife and I are Protestants, and I am in OCIA. She is not interested. Do we have to get marriage convalidated in order for me to be received into the Church?
- 35:03 – Would it be un-Catholic of me to be superstitious about attending an event where I was hospitalized after I’ve gone? This has happened multiple times.
- 44:20 – How did the name lucifer become a catchall name for the devil since it’s not in scripture?
- 50:40 – Does practicing craniosacral therapy go against Church teaching?
“Can you avoid purgatory after last rites?” This episode explores the nuances of last rites and their implications for purgatory, alongside intriguing questions about the meaning of the Holy Spirit overshadowing Mary, the Church’s teachings on the Nephilim, and the reasons for not having children. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:53 – My father received last rites and went to confession. The priest said that if he were to die, he wouldn’t have to go to purgatory. Is this true?
- 14:46 – What did it mean when the Holy Spirit overshadowed Mary?
- 21:38 – What are legitimate reasons to not have kids?
- 40:28 – What’s the Church’s official teaching on the Nephilim?
- 48:47 – Do you have to believe in all doctrines of the Catholic Church in order to be appointed a priest or bishop?
- 53:13 – 1 Corinthians 4:6 says to “not go beyond what is written.” Is this evidence for sola scriptura?
“How Does the Vatican Approve Miracles?” This episode explores the significance of Mary in Catholic faith, addressing questions about her unique role and the nature of her sinlessness. Additionally, we delve into how the Vatican approves miracles, the reality of the holy fire at the holy sepulcher, and the implications of marriage convalidation for those entering the Church.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:29 – How Does the Vatican Approve Miracles?
- 14:30 – I have a lot of Protestant friends who ask me a lot about Mary. I am curious now, why do we venerate Mary at all? If she was born without original sin, how can she be good? She didn’t have the option to be sinful, because she was born without sin. So shouldn’t we venerate saints to a higher degree than her because they had the choice to be sinful and they didn’t, which seems like that makes them even better than her? Also, I also was told by a Catholic that God loves Mary more than any other human he created. Is this true?
- 24:15 – Do you think the miracle of the holy fire that the Orthodox claim at the holy sepulcher is real?
- 32:48 – My wife and I are Protestants, and I am in OCIA. She is not interested. Do we have to get marriage convalidated in order for me to be received into the Church?
- 35:03 – Would it be un-Catholic of me to be superstitious about attending an event where I was hospitalized after I’ve gone? This has happened multiple times.
- 44:20 – How did the name lucifer become a catchall name for the devil since it’s not in scripture?
- 50:40 – Does practicing craniosacral therapy go against Church teaching?
“What’s the Church’s stance on unapproved Marian apparitions?” In this episode, we explore the Church’s position on various mystical experiences, along with discussions on the challenges faced by those considering Catholicism, including recent controversies like the LGBT Mass in Rome, and the biblical roots of the Eucharist as a re-presentation of sacrifice.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:00 – What’s the Church’s stance on unapproved Apparitions?
- 10:43 – My Protestant friends were looking into Catholicism, but stepped back because they are finding leaders in the Catholic Church to back up non-Catholic ideas like the recent LGBT Mass in Rome
- 31:05 – My Protestant Objection: Jeremiah 7 mentions idolatry worshipping the queen of heaven in the Temple of God. That seems like how Catholics treat Mary.
- 44:11 – Where did the idea of re-presenting a sacrifice come from in Scripture with the Eucharist?
“Can Protestants understand infant baptism and purgatory?” This episode explores the nuances of these topics, including what the Protestant view on infant baptism reveals about their understanding of sin, and how Catholics interpret purgatory in light of scripture. Additionally, we delve into the significance of saints’ relics and the complexities of baptismal regeneration.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:45 – Some Protestants don’t believe in infant baptism, what does that tell us about their understanding of sin and how does that compare to the Catholic view?
- 12:16 – I understand the Catholic teaching on cremated remains is to not separate them. But if that’s the case, why do we have cases where certain saints’ body parts are in different locations? It seems like that contradicts the policy on cremated remains.
- 20:20 – How do Catholics understand Purgatory in light of Hebrews 9:27?
- 24:44 – How do you determine what a saint is a patron of? Like how does someone become patron saint if pilots when airplanes weren’t even invented yet when they lived?
- 34:45 – Can you comment on the different translations of Luke 1:28, why Protestant Bibles say “greetings o favored one” and why Catholic bibles say “hail full of grace”?
- 44:45 – What is the Catholic interpretation of 1 John 5:1 with regard to baptismal regeneration? I’m struggling to square “if you believe you’ve been born of God” with having to be baptized.
- 51:50 – I practice no meat on Fridays. How do I keep up this practice during times when there are lots of feast days or solemnities on Fridays?
“Why do Catholics call priests Father when the Bible clearly says, ‘call no man father’?” This episode delves into this common question while also addressing the Great Apostasy claim by Latter Day Saints, the real presence in Communion for those exploring Catholicism, and the interpretation of Catechism 841 regarding salvation.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 12:10 – How would a Catholic respond to the Latter Day Saints claim of the Great Apostasy?
- 19:12 – I’m Protestant and exploring Catholicism. I’m starting to believe in the real presence. Should I stop receiving Communion in my Protestant church?
- 32:01 – How would you respond to a claim of once saved always saved?
- 41:30 – Are there some principles to applying scripture to our lives? It seems like I’m getting signs from God in these verses that come to me and I read.
- 50:15 – CCC 841 seems to imply that Muslims are included in the plan of salvation. I don’t believe they worship the same God. How do we interpret that Catechism paragraph?
“Who were the Desert Fathers and their impact on Catholicism?” This episode explores the lives and teachings of these early Christian ascetics, while also addressing questions like why Mother Angelica has not been beatified and how to interpret the recent LGBT pilgrimage to Rome. Tune in for a rich discussion on the early church and its relevance today.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 12:35 – why has Mother Angelica not been beatified?
- 14:45 – How should we interpret the recent LGBT pilgrimage to Rome?
- 18:15 – If the early church had martyrs, are those martyrs saints. Also, if Charlie Kirk is considered a martyr, could one day he be considered a saint?
- 22:40 – Did the early church interpret Genesis literally, and then after we realized it doesn’t really correspond to our scientific knowledge, we just started saying it’s not literal? (this is what her son is claiming)
- 31:12 – I was raised in an independent fundamentalist Baptist church. I’m looking at Catholicism. I want to read writers of the early church. Where do I find that and how do I know if it’s a good translation?
- 34:30 – How do we know if the early church fathers were Catholic? Because Protestants quote them too. How do we know St. Augustine wasn’t Protestant?
- 41:15 – I understand for a sin to be mortal we need have knowledge that the act is sinful. But do we have to know the act is specifically a grave offence, or do we just need to know that it is sinful. For example, if one commits a grave offense, but things that act is only venially sinful, would it still be a mortal sin?
- 46:28 – The Bible says that Mary visited Elizabeth in her sixth month. I saw a video that says that means the sixth month of the year, not Elizabeth’s sixth month of pregnancy. Which way does the Church teach?
- 50:40 – Were some of the early church fathers Eastern Orthodox? I know the Eastern Orthodox have their church fathers, so whose are right?
“How should Catholics approach Muslims?” In this episode, we explore effective evangelization strategies and discuss the complexities of interfaith dialogue, including the implications of Muslims worshipping in churches and the beliefs of Ahmadi Muslims in India. We also tackle the historical context of the Crusades and the differing perspectives on their necessity.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:30 – How do we approach a Muslim when evangelizing?
- 12:14 – How do you feel about Muslims worshipping in churches?
- 15:26 – Ahmadi Muslims in India, they believe that their messiah lives on earth today, and that Jesus went to India and died in India and is buried there. What does William think of this?
- 19:40 – Muslims believe that Allah is all loving, but their faith teaches against Christianity and Judaism so how can their followers believe in an all loving God.
- 29:05 – How can he respond to his Muslim friends who use John 20:17, as an argument to him as a contradiction of the Catholic Faith. How can Jesus be a God if he has a God (his Father)?
- 34:46 – How should Catholics view the Crusades, there seems to be two extremes of thoughts, secular thought is that they were a terrible thing perpetuated by the Church, His Catholic friends take a hard line that they were absolutely necessary and there was no issue with them
- 40:45 – Why doesn’t the Catholic Church publish a document detailing the evils and false truths of Islam?
- 46:36 – 20 yr Son told him last week that he wants to convert from Christianity to Islam
- 52:40 – What is the mindset of folks who would convert from Christianity to Islam?
In this interview, Catholic Answers Producer Edgar Lujano talks about Islma with Muslim to Catholic convert Ismail Youseff.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:00 – You don’t hear of a lot of Muslim Convert
- 04:00 – What would It take to Evangelize a Muslim Effectively?
- 05:40 – What are the most effective arguments for a Muslim?
- 07:35 – What does the saying “without reason” mean?
- 10:45 – How is the person of Jesus himself an argument against Islam?
- 15:30 – What is meant by “The Muslim Dilemma”?
- 17:45 – Is Islam pretty unified or divided?
- 19:45 – Has the Koran been changed?
- 21:46 – How does the Muslim view of heaven compare with the Christian view?
- 29:10 – Why did you decide to start sharing your testimony?
- 30:35 – Growing up as a Muslim in Canada
- 32:40 – Watching the livestream of the killing of the Coptic martyrs.
- 34:02 – Slavery in the Koran
- 37:05 – I asked Jesus if Christianity is true.
- 40:15 – How did your family react to you leaving Islam?
- 45:17 – How did the Christian missionaries introduce you to Jesus?
- 47:55 – How would you invite a Muslim to consider Christianity?
- 51:00 – Every religion has to deal with Jesus.
“How should I talk with my non-Catholic friends?” This episode explores effective communication strategies for those considering conversion, while also addressing intriguing questions like the nature of the Eucharist, the existence of Satan, and the challenges of Sola Fide arguments. Tune in for a thoughtful exploration of these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:37 – How should I talk with my non-Catholic friends and family as I think about converting myself?
- 14:28 – The Eucharist seems like magic to me.
- 21:05 – Some people I know are not Catholic because of the very existence of Satan and the fact that God allowed man to fall.
- 35:40 – I am a Protestant becoming Catholic, but I do not know how to rebut Sola Fide arguments.
- 45:02 – I get hung up on intercessory prayers and praying to the saints in general
- 51:20 – I am Catholic, but I disagree with a lot of orthodox teachings.
“How Do I Learn About Catholicism?” This episode explores the significance of Mary in Catholic teaching and the papacy, addressing questions like why some reject Catholicism due to the papacy, how non-Catholics can begin their journey of faith, and where to find biblical support for Mary’s perpetual virginity.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 08:17 – My friend is not Catholic because popes have been wicked or corrupt.
- 14:16 – I am not a Catholic but want to learn more. How do I go about doing this?
- 19:34 – Where can I find Mary’s perpetual virginity in the Bible? I am a lapsed Catholic.
- 34:50 – Does Joseph have a body and soul in Heaven?
- 37:40 – I’m not sure if I’m Catholic; if I have a godfather, does that mean that I am?
- 43:04 – To play Devil’s advocate, could all the secular accounts of Jesus be mentions of Christian texts and not Christ himself?
“Does God Punish Us By Afflicting Family? ” This episode explores the complex relationship between divine justice and human suffering, addressing questions like whether continuous sin can lead to a loved one’s illness and how the Church can effectively evangelize to those with disabilities. Additionally, we delve into the implications of the death penalty and the miraculous nature of St. Paul’s recoveries.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:12 – Is it possible that God punishes my continuous sin through my son’s disease?
- 04:19 – Can a Catholic hold to the Genesis Gap Theory? Or is it heretical?
- 12:41 – How can the Church evangelize to those with disabilities? What are good resources that can help me get started?
- 19:28 – Can we in good conscience support the death penalty? I can’t seem to understand why the church changed this. In theory can’t the church’s teaching on this revert?
- 28:37 – Is there a miraculous quality to St. Paul recovering from the stoning at Lystra or from all of the other beatings he suffered? It seems any number of the rods, stonings, etc. could have disabled him and made his long-distance travel impossible.
- 32:49 – How does setting a prayer intention before praying a rosary differ from just praying for that intention directly without praying a rosary, does it have something to do with the merit involved with praying a rosary? Thank you!
- 36:40 – Why can’t Catholicism be just another denomination among the denominations? I think Protestants see Catholicism as a Christian denomination, thus no need to make the move if they are already happy where they are.
- 43:02 – If priests have the sacramental power to ordain, why has this actually happened so rarely in Church history?
- 46:50 – Why is it mandatory to go to a priest for confession before one can go for Holy Communion. Why isn’t going to God directly sufficient for this? If someone sits on his seat because he hasn’t gone for confession, everyone would see that he hasn’t gone to confession, it would elicit some kind of shame on this person.
“Can excommunicated Catholics be saved?” This episode explores the complexities of salvation and excommunication, while also addressing the morality of IVF and the Church’s perspective on good deeds in different faiths. Additionally, we delve into the workings of the Holy Spirit in our lives and clarify the role of sacramentals versus talismans. Tune in for a thoughtful discussion on these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:30 – I understand IVF is immoral even if there is only one child created and implanted, but should it also be illegal? Where is that line?
- 13:41 – How would the church differentiate between a work a saved person does versus a non-saved one. (context: good deeds in Islam vs works in Catholicism.)
- 28:40 – How does the Holy Spirit work in our daily lives? After confirmation, why do so many youths lose the guidance of the Holy Spirit?
- 33:25 – Can a baptismal candle be used for everyday purposes (like when the power goes out)?
- 36:28 – James IV of Scotland was excommunicated by Pope Julius II for breaking the Treaty of Perpetual Peace with England in favor of the much older “Auld Alliance” with France when Henry VIII of England participated in the “Holy League” against France via a military invasion. James IV of Scotland later perished in the Battle of Flodden field against England and his excommunication had never been rescinded. Did James (or any excommunicate for that matter) have any hope for salvation after dying while formally excommunicated? Are there distinctions between spiritual vs. politically motivated excommunications? I understand this requires context provided by James’ private conscience, which we can only speculate on.
- 45:00 – How do we think about the Trinity when directing our prayers? Should I be developing a prayer rapport with each person of the Trinity or am I overthinking this?
- 51:31 – How do you explain sacramentals to someone when they say it’s basically like having a magic talisman? I’ve understood it as God’s grace working through the sacramental, but how can we make a better distinction between sacramentals and talismans?
“Is NFP just Catholic Birth Control?” In this episode, we explore the nuances of Natural Family Planning and its distinction from contraception. Additionally, we tackle questions about the salvation of non-Catholics who have committed mortal sins and the criteria for canonizing laypeople like Carlo Acutis. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 10:05 – Is NFP ‘Catholic Contraception?
- 22:23 – Can someone who is not Catholic and committed mortal sin at some point in their life still be saved?
- 45:07 – What would be the grounds for canonizing a person who is not a priest, bishop, religious or martyr like Carlo Acutis?
“How did people travel in the time of Jesus?” This episode explores the transportation methods of the era, including the quality of Roman roads around Jerusalem. Additionally, we delve into intriguing topics such as the existence of two tombs of Jesus and the significance of Mount Tabor, offering a rich perspective on life in biblical times.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 2:00 – How did people travel in the time of Jesus?
- 10:38 – Were there high quality Roman roads around Jerusalem?
- 14:50 – Jesus followed Mary twice a day for 1/4 mile to get water every day — imagine little Jesus “Wait up for me, Mom!”
- 19:30 – Are there 2 tombs of Jesus? Which one is the real one?
- 29:19 – Have you done the full walk of Mount Tabor?
- 32:43 – What are your thoughts on the flight to Egypt?
- 40:20 – What place in the Holy Land inspires you the most?
- 46:42 – I’ve heard there is a lot of demonic activity there. The holier the place the more demonic activity. Is this true? And what can one do to protect themselves when visiting?
- 48:42 – Is the Eye of the Needle a real gate into the city of Jerusalem?
- 50:00 – What’s the Sea of Galilee like? What would fishermen’s life be like?
- 52:26 – How large was the temple where Jesus was lost?
“What are the earliest writings about the Mass?” Discover the historical roots of this central Catholic practice, along with discussions on the early Church’s interpretation of 1 John 5:13 and the significance of healing in the Bible. Join us as we explore these foundational topics and more in this enlightening episode.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:00 – What are the earliest writings about the mass that we have?
- 04:30 – Would you consider writing a book on justification?
- 12:26 – What are the earliest Catholic Church buildings and where was the altar located in those churches?
- 16:25 – Jesus promises to heal in the bible but people deflect and say that healing happens in the next life. What are your thoughts on that? Does God want you to suffer here to get more reward in heaven?
- 22:34 – What was the early Church’s interpretation of 1 John 5:13?
- 28:30 – Continued – Jesus promises to heal in the bible but people deflect and say that healing happens in the next life. What are your thoughts on that? Does God want you to suffer here to get more reward in heaven?
- 44:26 – What are the earliest writings about the mass that we have?
- 50:38 – Did the writing of the same Shepard Hermas hold the same weight as the Didiache, writing of St. Clemente of Rome and others?
“Do Non-Catholics Go to Heaven?” This episode explores the complexities of salvation and the teachings of the Early Church. Tune in as we address questions about the necessity of listening to the Early Church Fathers, the implications of a nun’s claim regarding non-Catholics and heaven, and the early Church’s views on the Immaculate Conception and Assumption.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:00 – Charlie Kirk
- 15:00 – Do we have to listen to the Early Church Fathers? Are their statements doctrine because they tell us what the early Church believed?
- 28:30 – My son was told in school by a nun that non-Catholics don’t go to heaven. I’m shocked, is this true?
- 37:43 – How did the early Church view the immaculate Conception and Assumption?
- 48:00 – What resources can you point to to help put the Didache in its appropriate cultural context?
- 04:30 – Would you consider writing a book on justification?
- 12:26 – What are the earliest Catholic Church buildings and where was the altar located in those churches?
- 16:25 – Jesus promises to heal in the bible but people deflect and say that healing happens in the next life. What are your thoughts on that? Does God want you to suffer here to get more reward in heaven?
- 22:34 – What was the early Church’s interpretation of 1 John 5:13?
- 28:30 – Continued – Jesus promises to heal in the bible but people deflect and say that healing happens in the next life. What are your thoughts on that? Does God want you to suffer here to get more reward in heaven?
- 44:26 – What are the earliest writings about the mass that we have?
- 50:38 – Did the writing of the same Shepard Hermas hold the same weight as the Didiache, writing of St. Clemente of Rome and others?
“Are catechumens who died before receiving baptism saved?” This episode explores the nuances of baptism and salvation, addressing questions such as the implications of a parent’s desire for their children’s baptism, the validity of baptisms outside traditional norms, and the differences between baptism and christening.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:27 – Are catechumens who died before receiving baptism saved? If my wife doesn’t want our children baptized but I do, does my desire for their baptism save them?
- 12:00 – How do you answer Baptism and protestants pointing to Acts 10:47 as evidence for receiving the Holy Spirit before baptism?
- 19:00 – How would you determine whether a baptism is valid outside form, matter and intention? Would the priest contact that particular protestant church?
- 24:45 – What’s the difference between baptism and christening?
- 30:00 – If baptism is valid even if it’s illicit, why would that not apply to marriage?
- 41:07 – Is immersion baptism the correct way of doing it and not sprinkling?
- 45:55 – Council of Florence Session 11 did pronounce that the only remedy for the salvation of children is baptism.
- 50:20 – What’s the difference in receiving the gifts of the Holy Spirit in baptism and confirmation?
“Is infant baptism necessary and what does the Bible say?” This episode explores the significance of baptism, addressing questions like where infant baptism is found in Scripture and what it means for babies in terms of salvation. Additionally, we delve into the Protestant perspective on baptism as a saving sacrament and the role of emergency baptisms.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:50 – What made you think we needed a book on baptism?
- 06:30 – Where is infant baptism in the bible?
- 18:02 – If babies need to be baptized, what are they being saved from?
- 24:26 – Do Protestants agree baptism is a saving sacrament?
- 32:10 – Can any person baptize in an emergency situation?
- 36:42 – Can you clarify the presbyterian position on baptismal regeneration?
- 44:40 – Does the book of Revelation say anything about baptism?
- 50:45 – My wife and I are fostering a child. Can we baptize this child in the Church? The biological father is Catholic, and we are not sure if we are going to adopt them or if reunification will happen.
“Did Vatican II ruin the Church?” This episode tackles this pivotal question while also addressing the concerns of non-practicing Catholics about salvation, the implications of using Latin in worship, and the rules surrounding cremation and the scattering of ashes. Join us for a thoughtful exploration of these important topics in Catholicism.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:25 – Did Vatican II ruin the Church?
- 12:02 – I’m a non-practicing Catholic. Am I saved?
- 31:11 – Why isn’t it a good thing to continue using Latin in the Church?
- 41:49 – What are the rules on cremation and scattering ashes? How do you tell someone to not spread ashes?
- 46:03 – Were the prayers changed when they translated to the vernacular? If so, how?
- 52:24 – Is it okay to donate blood to an organization that would use the blood for stem cell research?
“What Biblical Texts Support the Mass and Transubstantiation?” In this episode, we explore key scriptural references that underpin the Mass, while also addressing questions about the differences between transubstantiation and consubstantiation, the changes made during Vatican II, and how the early Christians might perceive today’s Catholic Mass. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:00 – What biblical texts support the practice of the Mass?
- 18:02 – What’s the difference between transubstantiation and consubstantiation?
- 30:53 – Why during Vatican 2 did they decide to take out so much to form this new liturgy?
- 36:50 – How do you respond to the claim that if the Early Christians were to see the Catholic mass, they wouldn’t recognize it as their form of worship?
- 44:45 – Where do you even see the Mass in the Bible?
“Can demons present themselves as ghosts?” This episode explores the intriguing connections between demons, exorcism, and the Nephilim. Join us as we delve into questions about the exorcist qualities of the medal of St. Benedict, the nature of pagan gods, and the impact of past involvement in satanic cults.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:30 – Are you familiar with Dr. Michael S Heiser’s work on the Nephilim and their demonic nature and how that connects to Mount Hermon and the Transfiguration?
- 09:16 – How does the medal of St. Benedict have exorcist qualities?
- 13:22 – What would be a good way to determine whether the pagan gods of a foreign country are demons or are simply not real?
- 20:50 – Can the devil use the world and the flesh to tempt us or are they separate with no overlap?
- 23:15 – My son’s father got involved in a satanic cult when he was in high school. Could he still be affected by the demonic to this day?
- 37:00 – Why was Padre Pio oppressed by demons if he had such closeness to God?
- 41:19 – Does the evidence that Timothy Alberino provides for the literal existence of the Nephilim hold any ground?
- 46:15 – Elon Musk is currently working on uploading human consciousness onto a computer, if this were to be successful could this person still be subjected to demonic activity even without a body?
- 50:19 – Does the Church have a position on the existence of ghosts? Can demons present themselves as ghosts?
“What can demons do in our daily lives?” This episode explores the influence of demons, addressing questions like whether they can be seen as mere metaphors for human evil and what powers they truly possess. We also delve into the nature of demons and angels, their fall from grace, and practical advice on avoiding their negative impact.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:13 – Is it permitted to think of demons merely as metaphors for human evil?
- 08:38 – What is a demon?
- 19:42 – What do they actually have the power to do in our daily lives?
- 28:45 – Are demons and angels equal in power?
- 40:35 – Why did the demons fall? Meaning, what could possibly have tempted an angel away from God?
- 47:55 – How do I avoid demons and stay out of their evil clutches?
- 51:25 – What’s the difference between demonic possession, oppression, and obsession?
“How can we prove the Holy Trinity?” In this episode, we tackle common objections, including whether the Trinity is mentioned in the New Testament and how God can be both one and three persons. We also explore the relationship between the Trinity and the Christian understanding of God as Love, addressing logical concerns along the way.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:47 – The Trinity isn’t in the New Testament
- 28:45 – If God is one, how can He be three persons?
- 19:30 – Doesn’t the Trinity contradict basic logic (3 ≠ 1)?
- 44:47 – Is there a connection with the Trinity and the fact that only Christians say “God is Love”?
“How do you evangelize to non-Catholics and Protestants?” In this episode, we explore effective strategies for sharing the faith, including the top tips for evangelization and the reasons behind focusing on Protestants. We also discuss how to communicate without appearing superior and the challenges of evangelizing to culturally diverse family members.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 32:40 – Why do we evangelize more to Protestants over atheists?
- 36:54 – How do you communicate with someone without coming across with a superiority complex?
- 43:21 – How do you balance having Catholic and non-Catholic friends?
- 48:10 – My family is culturally Oriental Orthodox Christian and I’m a recent convert. How do I evangelize them?
“What is the significance of the 24 elders in Revelation?” In this episode, we explore this intriguing question along with discussions on why the Protestant perspective often downplays Revelation, the authorship of the book, and the Catholic understanding of being lukewarm in faith. Join us for a deep dive into these essential topics of Catholic apologetics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 13:34 – What is the significance of the 24 elders in Rev. 4?
- 16:30 – Why does the protestant perspective downplay Revelation?
- 24:05 – Warren Cage said that the book of Revelation is a copy and paste version of the fall of Jericho, is this true?
- 30:37 – Who exactly wrote Revelation, who is John the Evangelist in relation to John the apostle?
- 35:10 – Regarding Rev 3:16, what is the Catholic understanding of being lukewarm?
- 45:07 – What do we make of the woman in Rev. 12 and the crown of 12 stars?
- 50:44 – I’ve heard it said that the second coming isn’t going to happen until the gospel is preached to the ends of the world. Is that from Revelation?
“What is the Book of Revelation really about?” In this episode, Fr. Sebastian Carnazzo tackles this question and explores the significance of the Seven Churches, the identity of the author, and the meaning behind the number 666. Tune in for a deep dive into these intriguing topics and more!
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:25 – If you had to explain the Book of Revelation in just one sentence, what would you say it’s really about?
- 13:10 – What is the significance of the Seven Churches mentioned in Revelation?
- 29:45 – Who was the author
- 36:47 – What is the significance of the number 666 in Revelation?
- 50:56 – What is the meaning of the term “the Mark of the Beast”?
“Can Mary perform miracles?” This episode explores this question alongside a variety of topics, including the morality of adult content, the validity of apostolic succession amidst multiple patriarchs, and the reasons behind the Assumption of Mary.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:28 – Why is adult content immoral?
- 17:48 – Why don’t Catholics believe that Mary can do miracles on her own power since she probably had more faith than the rest of us; more than a mustard seed?
- 22:03 – How do we know that apostolic succession is valid considering there are places where there are multiple patriarchs and others where governments have to approve of successors?
- 28:45 – Why is the Assumption of Mary held to be if I think the evidence leads to an opposing conclusion?
- 40:49 – Why were there innovations of papal supremacy at the First Vatican Council?
“Do Catholics change their beliefs over time?” This episode explores the evolution of Catholic doctrine, addressing why the Church accepts changes and how these shifts have occurred. Additionally, we delve into why not everyone embraces the truth of God’s covenant, the significance of transubstantiation, and the celibacy requirements for priests.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:18 – Why does the Church accept that doctrine changes over time? How has the Catholic Church’s doctrine changed over time?
- 20:39 – Why isn’t everybody assenting to the truth especially since there is one God who has been public about his covenant?
- 28:45 – Why does it matter that we believe in transubstantiation rather than consubstantiation?
- 36:59 – Why are Catholic priests required to be celibate but Anglican priests who convert and are married don’t have to be?
- 49:55 – Where did the Catholic Church arrive at the idea of a soul?
“How do we defend papal primacy and infant baptism?” In this episode, we explore the scriptural basis for papal authority and the early Church’s connection to Rome, while also addressing concerns about infant baptism and the implications of belief for salvation. Joe Heschmeyer explores this question and more from the audience at SEEK 2025, including Sheol’s transformation after Christ, infant baptism, and the Real Presence in Anglican and Orthodox churches.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:46 – What did it actually mean to go to Sheol and how did that change with Christ?
- 07:42 – How do I defend papal primacy using scripture? How do we defend how the early Church was based out of Rome?
- 17:08 – I’m Protestant and struggle with infant baptism. How can A child be saved if they have no belief?
- 23:44 – Hypothetical from an atheist? If I tell my wife: love me or i will set you on fire?” Does she have a choice, and do I actually love my wife?
- 29:29 – What’s wrong with the following argument: Protestants are more catholic than Catholics because they have fewer factors that need to unify them?
- 32:30 – How does one discern who has the fullness of the faith between Catholics and Orthodox?
- 37:50 – Is it ok to refer to Scripture as Jesus since he is he is the word of God?
- 41:30 – How do we encounter the world, take criticism, and spread the gospel without being obnoxious?
- 42:12 – If Mary is the Mother of God and she is not the source of his divinity, why does she need to be sinless?
- 51:13 – Do the Anglican Church and Orthodox have the Real presence? Am I supposed to bow if they do?
Join Catholic Answers Live as Cy Kellett interviews Fr. David Michael Moses on reaching young people through social media and evangelization in today’s digital age!
“How can bodily resurrection exist if the universe itself will end?” This question opens a fascinating exploration of faith and theology, alongside discussions on why invoking Jesus’ name is believed to stop abductions, and whether psychotropic drugs impact our free will.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:55 – How can bodily resurrection exist if the universe itself will end?
- 16:05 – Why does invoking Jesus’ name stop abductions?
- 28:39 – Do psychotropic drugs affect our free will?
- 42:00 – Why did early Church Fathers appeal to Scripture instead of papal authority?
- 47:52 – If God is perfect and needs nothing, why create humans and angels who could fall?
- 51:12 – Why must children be raised by biological parents, but adoption is allowed?
“Why can saints’ bodies and relics be displayed if we’re supposed to bury the dead?” This episode explores the significance of relics in Catholic tradition, alongside questions about evangelizing Indigenous peoples, the requirements for altars, and the meaning of taking the Lord’s name in vain. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:53 – Why can saints’ bodies and relics be displayed if we’re supposed to bury the dead?
- 07:16 – How can we evangelize Indigenous peoples who see Christianity as a “white man’s religion”?
- 16:16 – Do all altars need relics, and does distance matter when praying with relics?
- 19:47 – What does it mean to take the Lord’s name in vain?
- 23:13 – How can we know if a loved one is in heaven?
- 29:01 – When Jesus says “believe in the Gospel,” what does He mean?
- 36:05 – Is it selfish or wrong to grieve someone before they die?
- 42:03 – What will we be doing in Heaven?
- 47:00 – How is Christianity different from pagan myths and miracles?
“Does wealth endanger our salvation?” This episode explores the relationship between material wealth and spiritual well-being, along with intriguing questions like whether the Olivet discourse refers to 70 AD or the end of the world, and what occurs at the atomic level during transubstantiation. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 00:01:06 – Does the Olivet discourse describe 70 AD or the end of the world?
- 00:10:45 – What happens at the atomic level in transubstantiation?
- 00:16:30 – Must agoraphobics attend Mass in person?
- 00:20:37 – If God is unchanging, does creation exist forever?
- 00:22:24 – Does wealth endanger our salvation?
- 00:24:41 – Did Jesus die on April 3, AD 33? How exact is the dating?
- 00:28:51 – What is the “Promise of the Father” in Acts?
- 00:42:18 – Why did the angel in Revelation forbid worship?
- 00:49:49 – Why were only four gospels chosen?
- 00:53:02 – Do good works prevent loss of salvation?
“Did Jesus really appear to 500 people at once?” This episode explores this intriguing question while also addressing topics such as the relationship between good works and grace in mortal sin, and how Catholics can affirm the Filioque without compromising the Trinity. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these essential aspects of faith.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:38 – Did Jesus really appear to 500 people at once?
- 04:31 – Do good works earn grace if I’m in mortal sin?
- 06:31 – How can Catholics affirm the Filioque without compromising the Trinity?
- 10:51 – Why does the Angelus say “conceived by the Spirit” before “be it done”?
- 15:09 – Can someone avoid sin without grace?
- 17:16 – If Jesus finished His sacrifice, why do we still suffer?
- 20:24 – What’s the significance of confirmation?
- 28:38 – Where are Jesus’ and Mary’s bodies now? What is Heaven?
- 35:58 – How can Jesus be both divine and human?
- 38:09 – When did the liturgy of the word begin?
- 45:35 – Why do even trained exorcists risk being deceived by demons?
- 51:41 – Must a Doctor of the Church be a canonized saint?
“Can indulgences help souls in Purgatory?” This episode explores the significance of indulgences in the context of Purgatory, while also addressing questions about the Mystery of Faith during Mass, the church’s teaching on Israel’s role in the end times, and what makes a Baptism valid.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:39 – During the Mass, why does one option for the Mystery of Faith not mention the resurrection?
- 12:19 – What is the church’s teaching on Israel’s role in the end times?
- 15:43 – What is necessary for a Baptism to be valid?
- 29:00 – How can I defend the charismatic faith?
- 36:45 – I heard that Jesus quoted the book of Tobit. Where is this?
- 41:09 – Where did we get the word “Church”?
- 44:39 – Can explain the indulgences given during this year of Hope as they relate to souls in Purgatory?
- 50:26 – What is the biblical support for particular judgement?
“How Can Jesus be both God and Son?” This episode explores the complex doctrine of the Hypostatic Union, while also addressing varied questions such as the identity of the Black Hebrew Israelites, the significance of Godparents, and the role of the two witnesses in Revelation.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:20 – Are the Black Hebrew Israelites the Real Jews?
- 13:59 – Who are the two witnesses at the end time in Revelation 11?
- 19:11 – What are some tips on selecting God Parents?
- 29:10 – If Jesus is the most high God, how can He have a Father?
- 39:07 – Can you clarify the Hypostatic union?
- 49:11 – Can a Roman Catholic appreciate St. Gregory Palamas’s energy essence distinction?
- 52:31 – How are Catholics to understand Ephesians 2 considering the contradiction in James ?
“Is Mary pre-saved according to Scripture?” This episode explores the biblical basis for Mary’s unique role, addressing questions like whether the term “Adelphoi” always indicates a biological sibling and why the Blessed Mother doesn’t mention abortion in her apparitions. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of Mary’s Immaculate Conception and her sinlessness.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:07 – Is thinking of Mary as being “pre-saved” biblical?
- 08:02 – Is it true that the Greek word Adelphoi always refers to a sibling born of the mother or father unless there is a qualifier?
- 15:30 – Why doesn’t the Blessed Mother ever talk about abortion in her apparitions since she always appears pregnant?
- 18:50 – Is there any mention of Mary being baptized?
- 23:20 – Regarding Lourdes, how does Mary’s declaration of being the Immaculate Conception relate to being protected from original sin?
- 29:29 – Is it true that if Mary had any sin on her soul she would not be capable of saying yes to the Angel Gabriel due to the pain she would endure during the passion?
- 34:04 – Can you provide a list of Early Church fathers that supports the view that Mary was purified and sanctified at Jesus’ conception in her womb?
- 38:03 – Could you expound on the term handmaid and what it means, especially in the context of Mary’s response to Gabriel?
- 44:44 – How could Mary be sinless and perfect? Since only God could be perfect, wouldn’t that be contradictory?
- 51:20 – Is there any reason to think that Mary lived a consecrated life in the temple?
“Did Christ have to die for Mary?” Tune in as we also tackle whether Mary’s parents knew about her pregnancy before visiting Elizabeth and discuss the necessity of Marian dogmas in relation to the gospel message. Join us for a thought-provoking hour of apologetics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:20 – A few weeks ago, Allie Beth Stuckey released a video entitled “The Mary Debate” where she gave a series of rebuttals to Catholic beliefs about Mary. One rebuttal was directed toward the Catholic’s appeal to Luke 1:28, where Mary is said to be ‘full of grace.’ She argued that Stephen is also said to be ‘full of grace’ in Acts 6:8 and yet we don’t say Stephen was conceived without original sin.”
- 19:51 – I’m a Southern Baptist and my son is a recent convert to Catholicism. Did Christ have to die for Mary?
- 23:36 – Do we have any insight on Mary’s parents’ knowledge for her pregnancy before visiting Elizabeth or did they find out when she returned?
- 33:55 – Are we preaching a different gospel message since the Marian dogmas are now required for salvation?
- 45:38 – Did Mary know that her son was God or Messiah?
- 51:33 – Don’t Protestants have to accept Mary as sinless due to Jesus getting his flesh from Mary?
“Who Thought the Eucharist Was Just Symbolic? ” This episode delves into the early Church’s beliefs about the Eucharist, exploring questions like the origins of the symbolic view and whether early Church Fathers spoke symbolically. We also tackle the significance of “breaking bread” in the early Church and the implications of transubstantiation.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:30 – Where did the symbolic view of the Eucharist come from?
- 05:13 – Didn’t some early Church Fathers speak symbolically about the Eucharist? Doesn’t that challenge the idea of unanimous early belief?
- 07:30 – Didn’t the disciples fail to object during the Last Supper because they understood Jesus metaphorically?
- 09:00 – If “breaking bread” was common in the early Church, doesn’t that just suggest a fellowship meal, not a literal body and blood?
- 15:25 – The Eucharist doesn’t seem to do anything to believers?
- 20:30 – How Do I Properly Receive the Eucharist?
- 21:50 – How does transubstantiation actually work—and why does it rely on medieval Aristotelian philosophy rather than Scripture?
- 29:05 – How do we know that the early Church actually believed in transubstantiation and not just a spiritual or symbolic presence? Why does the Catholic View win out?
- 35:22 – The priesthood is against going directly to God. We don’t need Earthly priests.
- 42:20 – Does the Eucharist cause more division than Unity?
- 48:08 – Is the Eucharist just an adaptation of pagan rituals?
“Is the Eucharist a Literal Sacrifice or a Symbolic Act?” This episode delves into the nature of the Eucharist, addressing questions like whether Jesus spoke symbolically when He said, “This is my body,” and how His command to ‘eat my flesh and drink my blood’ aligns with Jewish law. We also explore the implications of Jesus’ words, “Do this in remembrance of me,” and the teachings of the Book of Hebrews.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:36 – Wasn’t Jesus speaking symbolically when He said, “This is my body”?
- 15:15 – Wouldn’t Jesus’ command to ‘eat my flesh and drink my blood’ violate Jewish law against consuming blood?
- 37:25 – Didn’t Jesus say, “Do this in remembrance of me”? Doesn’t that clearly indicate the Eucharist is a memorial, not a literal sacrifice?
- 40:20 – Doesn’t the Book of Hebrews teach that Christ’s sacrifice was ‘once for all’? How can the Catholic Mass be a true sacrifice without re-sacrificing Christ?
- 49:00 – Wouldn’t Jesus’ command to ‘eat my flesh’ be cannibalism
“Was the Holy Spirit on Earth before Jesus?” This episode explores the role of the Holy Spirit in the context of the Gospel order and apologetics. Additionally, we tackle intriguing questions such as whether Christians can be labeled as “psychopaths on a leash,” the nature of Christ’s cross, and the implications of critical scholarship on Church teaching.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:36 – Was the Holy Spirit on earth before Jesus?
- 05:20 – Are Christians “psychopaths on a leash”?
- 15:22 – Did Christ carry the whole cross or just the beam?
- 16:59 – What happened between Jesus’ death and Resurrection?
- 28:34 – Can critical scholarship undermine Church teaching?
- 34:45 – Is Luke 9:49–50 About Protestants Casting Out Demons?
- 41:47 – Why are the Gospels in this order?
- 47:24 – Dating/authorship of Job?
- 49:50 – What’s the deal with Malachi Martin?
- 52:40 – Do animals show rationality/personhood?
“When was the Church born: At the Cross or at Pentecost?” This episode dives into this question while also exploring diverse topics such as whether Jesus knew the day and hour in Matthew 24:36, the evolution of the term “Christianity” since the Reformation, and the meaning of divine simplicity. Tune in for a rich discussion on these aspects of faith.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:33 – When was the Church born: Cross or Pentecost?
- 12:00 – Do you like fish tacos?
- 16:10 – Did Jesus know the day/hour in Matt 24:36?
- 21:51 – Has “Christianity” changed meaning post-Reformation?
- 31:15 – What does divine simplicity mean?
- 36:45 – Has the Roman Canon always been the same?
- 43:33 – Thoughts on Futurama?
- 48:24 – How can I return to the Church?
- 51:08 – Can ashes be mixed with a pet’s?
“What is the role of the Holy Spirit in the sacraments?” This episode explores the vital connection between the Holy Spirit and the sacraments, while also addressing how to explain their significance to non-Catholics, the necessity of certain sacraments for salvation, and the relationship between sacraments and the Church’s authority.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:00 – What is the role of the Holy Spirit in the sacraments?
- 12:15 – How can we explain the importance of the sacraments to someone who is not Catholic?
- 22:45 – Are there any sacraments that are not necessary for salvation?
- 35:30 – How do the sacraments relate to the concept of faith and works?
- 47:00 – Can you discuss the relationship between the sacraments and the Church’s authority?
“Are Sacraments Biblical?” This episode tackles the claim that the Catholic Church’s seven sacraments lack biblical support, addressing foundational questions about God’s grace through outward signs. Discover the scriptural basis for baptism’s saving power, the distinct nature of Confirmation, and the authority behind Confession, all rooted in Scripture.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:00 – Some Christians claim the Catholic Church’s seven sacraments aren’t in the Bible at all. How do you respond to that broad objection?
- 17:00 – Let’s start at the foundation — where in Scripture do we see the idea that God communicates grace through outward signs?
- 23:40 – Baptism is accepted by most Christians, but Catholics see it as more than a symbol. What’s the biblical evidence for baptism actually saving us?
- 42:28 – Many people say Confirmation is just a Catholic “add-on.” What are the scriptural roots for a sacrament distinct from baptism?
- 06:23 – When it comes to the Eucharist, the biblical debate can get intense. How do you show from Scripture that Jesus meant His words—“This is my body”—literally?
- 16:50 – But what about when Jesus says, “Do this in remembrance of me”? Doesn’t that prove that the Eucharist merely a meal in which we recollect on the tings that Jesus did?
- 29:20 – Confession to a priest is one of the hardest for non-Catholics to accept. Where does the Bible show that God gave men the authority to forgive sins?
- 32:50 – Anointing of the Sick is sometimes seen as “Last Rites” only. How do the Scriptures present this sacrament, and does it match Catholic practice?
- 41:42 – Marriage as a sacrament—some say the Bible just sees it as a natural institution. How do you show from Scripture that it’s a channel of grace?
- 48:10 – Holy Orders—where in the Bible do we see a distinct, ordained priesthood in the New Covenant?
Canadian Death Culture and “Is This Rude?” Quiz
It’s another Flannel Panel, join Cy, Chris, and Joe as they talk about what’s going on in the world today!
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:00 – Is It Rude Quiz
- 19:02 – Canadian Death Culture
- 46:20 – Flannel Panel Recommends
Over 1 Million Young Catholics Gather for Pope Leo!
It’s another Flannel Panel, join Cy, Chris, and Joe as they talk about what’s going on in the world today!
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:45 – One Million Youths Gathered with The Pope
- 28:40 – Are we getting Ruder?
“Are Muslims Forgiven by God?” This episode explores the complexities of salvation in relation to Islam, addressing questions such as the impact of education levels on conversion and whether the Catholic Church played a role in the creation of Islam. Tune in as we also discuss the adoption of Jesus in Islamic belief and the challenges faced by Muslims considering conversion.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 12:45 – Is it realistic to convert Muslims since most Muslim countries tend to have a lower education level?
- 17:18 – Did the Catholic Church create Islam in order to take control of the trade routes in Arabia?
- 20:37 – Why did Islam adopt Jesus into their religion?
- 24:41 – Did Muhammed call himself a false prophet as he was dying?
- 30:18 – How do they justify killing infidels?
- 35:26 – Aren’t the ramifications for Muslims to convert radically more complicated than any other convert?
- 41:42 – Vatican 2 declared they are a Christian heresy. Is there any previous info that backed this declaration?
- 44:55 – Do Muslims have a mechanism for forgiveness?
In this episode, we explore this provocative questions about Islam along with discussions on how the Quran is confirmed in the gospels and whether Islam can be considered a Christian heresy. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 15:23 – Why is the Catholic Church focusing on our similarities with Islam in Nostra Aetate instead of talking about the age of Ayisha?
- 29:00 – The Quran is confirmed in the gospels. How can we demonstrate that?
- 33:00 – Is Islam a Christian Heresy?
- 39:19 – How can we use the Mariology in Islam as a bridge to evangelization?
- 44:41 – Who do we think spoke to Muhammed?
- 49:44 – Where did the Quran come from?
In this episode, we tackle the question, “How to respond to charges of bigotry?” as we explore the complexities of faith and perception. Additionally, we delve into the issues surrounding contraception and discuss the reasons for not sharing a bed before marriage.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 30:20 – How to respond to charges of bigotry?
- 34:19 – What’s wrong with contraception?
- 47:40 – Why not sleep in the same bed before marriage?
“What’s the point of confession?” This episode delves into the significance of this sacrament with Tom Nash. Additionally, we explore whether you can confess to a different priest and the nuances of confessing in a Greek Orthodox church.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:22 – What’s the point of confession?
- 16:58 – Can I confess to a different priest than usual?
- 20:04 – How to explain confession to Calvinists?
- 29:31 – Protestant youth minister converting—how to leave well?
- 45:49 – Can a Roman Catholic confess in a Greek Orthodox church?
- 51:14 – Why do some go to confession weekly?
“What does ‘faith that moves mountains’ mean?” This episode explores the depth of faith and its implications, while also addressing intriguing questions such as the nature of early heresies and their relation to Protestantism, and how Catholics can reconcile Church teachings with historical canon law penalties. Tune in for a thought-provoking discussion on these diverse topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:01 – What does “faith that moves mountains” vs. “conviction of things not seen” mean?
- 11:43 – Were early heresies forms of Protestantism, and why date it only from 1525?
- 14:55 – How can Catholics reconcile Church teaching with canon law penalties of enslavement?
- 20:52 – If I live in one diocese but attend Mass in another, which is my official diocese?
- 28:25 – Do vampires exist? Any plans for Mysterious World episode on them?
- 37:04 – Is it ethical to host a symbiote (like Venom) to save a life or for benefits?
- 45:25 – How to answer atheists who ask if God might demand child sacrifice like Abraham?
“Can the Pope receive new revelations?” This episode explores the implications of potential papal revelations, including whether such insights could become dogma. Additionally, we tackle questions about responding to Protestant views on exorcism, the moral dilemmas faced by Catholics in corporate settings, and discerning spiritual guidance. Tune in for a thought-provoking discussion!
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 15:45 – Could the Pope or Magisterium receive a revelation (e.g., about aliens having souls) and would that become dogma?
- 20:50 – How to respond when Protestants cite the exorcist Jesus told the disciples not to stop?
- 28:15 – Is it material cooperation with evil for a Catholic executive to enforce company abortion policies?
- 34:13 – Does God know all possible futures (Many Worlds idea)?
- 36:55 – How to tell if guidance is from the Holy Spirit vs. a Guardian Angel?
- 42:56 – Is experimenting with manifestation sinful?
- 52:17 – Do Daleks have souls?
In this episode, we Tim Staples and Cy Kellett tackle every major objection to the assumption of Mary. In this discussion, they also address objections regarding the early Church’s mention of Mary’s Assumption, providing a comprehensive look at this significant topic.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:20 – Is the Assumption of Mary a dogma?
- 07:55 – Why do we believe in the Assumption?
- 21:00 – Scriptural evidence for the Assumption
- 45:25 – Objection: the early Church does not mention Mary’s Assumption.
Join Cy Kellett and Director Anthony D’Ambrosio as they discuss the upcoming St. Maximilian Kolbe movie, Triumph of the Heart.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
“How can lay people support vocations, prayer, and service?” This episode explores the vital role of the laity in fostering vocations, alongside Fr. Marc Gandolfo’s personal journey to the priesthood. Tune in as we discuss the meaning of “pray without ceasing,” the experience of a life dedicated to service, and practical steps for laypeople to assist in promoting vocations.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:24 – How did you end up being a Catholic priest?
- 16:30 – On “Pray without ceasing.”
- 17:30 – What is it like to live a life dedicated to serving others?
- 29:18 – Could you give examples of listening to God and listening outside structured prayer?
- 22:24 – What can a lay person do to help vocations?
- 29:18 – Could you give examples of listening to God and listening outside structured prayer?
- 41:48 – What degree of certainty does a young man need in order to apply to seminary?
- 46:04 – Do you normally work with local Catholic high schools to promote vocations?
“How does the Catholic Mass compare to other Christian worship services?” In this episode, we explore the unique aspects of the Catholic Mass, including the significance of language in worship and the origins of the term “Mass.” We also discuss the varying practices among parishes and the spiritual benefits of attending Mass, whether in person or via television.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:20 – How does the Catholic Mass compare to other Christian worship services?
- 15:54 – Why do some people think it matters which language the Mass is in?
- 21:35 – Where does the word Mass come from? Why don’t we call it something else?
- 23:40 – Why is there no uniformity amongst parishes on how they celebrate the mass?
- 30:15 – How does the Mass relate to the real presence in adoration? What is the mode of presence in the host during adoration?
- 44:17 – I have a friend who travels 3 hours to the Latin mass and says they wont go to mass if they don’t go there. How do I respond to this?
- 50:42 – What is the spiritual benefit of mass on TV compared to a protestant service down the street? What are additional benefits other than the Eucharist when attending mass?
In this episode, we explore “How did the Church councils get their names?” along with a variety of other intriguing topics, including recommendations for studying Early Church Fathers and the concept of monophysitism. We also delve into whether Purgatory was discussed in the Early Church and the criteria used by the Council of Rome to determine the Canon.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 00:55 – How did the Church councils get their names?
- 06:02 – If I only had one Early Church Father to study what would be your recommendation and why?
- 10:50 – What in the world is monophysitism?
- 29:16 – Was Purgatory mentioned in the Early church or discussed at council?
- 34:02 – What criteria did the Council of Rome use to determine the Canon?
- 48:04 – Is there a similarity and difference the Catholic Churches and the Eastern Orthodox councils?
“Did the Early Church Have Deaconesses?” This episode explores the role of women in the early Church, including discussions on the Council of Constantinople and whether the Council of Jerusalem should be counted among the ecumenical councils. We also delve into Arianism’s connections to modern groups and the significance of the Council of Ephesus.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 18:30 – The Council of Constantinople
- 24:40 – Do we count the Council of Jerusalem among the first councils?
- 29:07 – Pope Leo announced reintroducing Deaconess based on Church History? Were there Deaconess in the Early Church?
- 31:59 – What the basic stuff to know about the Council of Nicea?
- 33:19 – Arianism sounds like Jehovah’s Witnesses?
- 35:20 – Why did the council of Ephesus do?
- 40:10 – I feel like there is a popular opinion that the church was united up until 1054. But at the Council of Ephesus and Council of Calcedon there was a split by assyrian church of the East and oriental orthodox Church. Is this an argument that the church wasn’t always Catholic?
- 45:00 – What is Nestorianism?
- 47:35 – Who are the heroes of the Council of Ephesus?
“Why Are There Honest Atheists if God Exists?” In this episode, we explore the complexities of faith and doubt, addressing questions like the nature of honest atheism and the implications of God’s love for humanity. We also delve into challenging topics such as the reasons behind the existence of hell and the nature of divine justice.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:35 – Why Are There Honest Atheists if God Exists?
- 42:11 – Why Would a Loving God Send People to Hell?
“If God Is All-Good, Why Does Evil Exist?” This episode delves into the complexities of evil and suffering, addressing questions such as whether “pointless evil” disproves God’s existence and if the problem of evil could justify the presence of the devil. Join us as we explore these challenging topics with clarity and depth.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 28:45 – If God Is All-Good, Why Does Evil Exist?
- 38:32 – Does “Pointless Evil” Disprove God?
- 48:12 – Problem of Evil: Could It Justify the Devil?
“Why is the Catholic Church the One True Church?” This episode dives into the unique claims of the Catholic faith, while also addressing pressing questions like the existence of Hell and the fate of souls, the significance of John 6, and effective ways to share faith with nonbelievers.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:17 – Oneness Pentecostal: Is the Catholic Church the One True Church?
- 11:11 – Is There a Hell, and Do Most People Go There?
- 20:54 – Recommended Videos on John 6
- 24:38 – Why “Bind and Loose” Doesn’t Apply to Everyone
- 35:41 – Best Way to Bring Faith to Nonbelievers
- 43:00 – Why Jesus Didn’t Let Mary Magdalene Touch Him
- 51:20 – Who Was in Heaven When Enoch & Elijah Arrived?
“Which Marian apparition has the best evidence?” In this episode, we explore this intriguing question alongside a variety of topics, including whether Pope Leo might change Church teaching and the implications of obeying dogmas given from the future. We also discuss the nature of sedevacantism and how God protects the Church from error.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:00 – Best-Evidence Marian Apparition
- 15:25 – Will Pope Leo Change Church Teaching?
- 22:48 – Must I Obey “Future” Dogmas?
- 29:55 – Is Sedevacantism Heresy?
- 36:30 – Accepting Jesus Without the Sacraments? (Rev 3:20)
- 41:15 – How Does God Protect the Church From Error?
- 47:47 – Protestant Mom Received Eucharist—What Should I Do?
“How has Catholic Answers changed lives?” Join us as we explore powerful stories of transformation and faith, highlighting the impact of Catholic Answers Live. We’ll also touch on the significance of community in faith journeys and the role of apologetics in personal growth.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:00 – Join us for an hour of testimonies on how Catholic Answers Live has changed lives.
“Can love for family compromise salvation?” In this episode, we explore the delicate balance between familial love and personal faith, addressing whether devotion to a spouse or child can lead to neglecting one’s own salvation. We also delve into the suitability of the Passion translation for Catholics and examine the relationship between para-psychological phenomena and consciousness.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:34 – Can love for one’s spouse or child compel them to deprioritize their own salvation?
- 21:00 – Is the Passion translation of the bible ok for Catholics to read?
- 37:30 – Is para-psychological phenomenon are they conscience related or unconscious?
“What is the Church’s teaching on predestination?” In this episode, we explore the nuances of predestination, examining the perspectives of St. Augustine and St. Thomas Aquinas in relation to Calvinism. Additionally, we address whether practicing “chair yoga” is acceptable for those with disabilities and delve into the question of why Jesus descended into hell as stated in the Creed.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:00 – What is the Church’s teaching on predestination? It seems like St. Augustine and St. Thomas Aquinas seems to be in agreement with Calvinism?
- 34:47 – I’m disabled. Is it ok for me to practice “chair yoga”?
- 50:20 – Why did Jesus go to hell as stated in the Creed?
“How do we know Jesus’ authority endures today?” This episode explores the transmission of authority from the apostles to future generations, while also addressing intriguing questions about Eucharistic miracles and whether they imply cannibalism, the nature of demons, and the Church’s teaching on predestination. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:20 – How do we know that authority Jesus gave to his apostles passes on to the next generation?
- 18:30 – When a Eucharistic miracle occurs and the accidents change to flesh and blood, would it be cannibalism at that point?
- 34:16 – Is David in the book of Samuel a bad guy?
- 46:21 – Why are demons so legalistic?
“Is Mary the Mediatrix of All Graces?” This episode explores the scriptural basis for Mary’s role in grace, addressing questions like the biblical foundation for confession and the scriptural evidence of Mary’s sinlessness. Join us as we delve into these important topics and more in this enlightening Q&A session.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 09:31 – Where does the Church in scripture get the idea of Mary as Mediatrix of All Graces?
- 29:32 – I’m not Catholic. Where do you see confession in the bible?
- 52:19 – Where in the bible that Mary was without sin?
“Can God really regret His decisions?” This episode explores the intriguing question of divine regret as we examine 1 Samuel 15:11, where God expresses regret over Saul’s kingship. Additionally, we delve into the parallels between Eve and Mary, the reasons behind God’s decree on human lifespan, and the relationship between praying to saints and the Body of Christ.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 09:07 – 1 Sam 15:11 God says he regrets making Saul king. How can God have regret?
- 20:17 – What are the similarities and differences between Eve before the fall and Mary before the Assumption?
- 33:55 – Why did God decide that man can only live to 120 but some in the bible live longer than that?
- 48:48 – Someone told me that the Body of Christ is separate. When I pray to the saints, is it separate from Christ?
“Are Annulments Too Legalistic?” This episode delves into the complexities of marriage and divorce within the Catholic Church, addressing concerns about the perceived bureaucratic nature of annulments. Tune in as we explore questions about the validity of annulments granted under specific circumstances, the implications for non-Catholics, and the Church’s teachings on relationships during the annulment process.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:25 – Aren’t annulments legalistic, bureaucratic, and all about control?
- 07:08 – Why was an annulment granted if it doesn’t seem like it should be granted?
- 13:36 – My boyfriend is Protestant, married in the protestant church and is divorced. Why does he have to get an annulment if he’s not Catholic? He’s not interested in joining the Catholic church at this point. He’s doing this for me because I want to be married in the Catholic Church.
- 16:24 – Why don’t they call in the priest who gave the couple the pre marriage instruction to a couple seeking an annulment?
- 18:46 – I got an annulment 20 years ago. Is there a way for me to see what my ex husband submitted on his side of the annulment report?
- 22:33 – What does the Church teach on pursuing romantic relationships while waiting for an annulment? Is there anything that is offered to help prevent future annulments?
- 31:05 – You keep talking about the Marriage bond. Does that also include the covenant?
- 34:14 – If my nephew decided to return to the Church one day, could he have an annulment and remarry one day?
- 41:48 – Once the annulment is granted the marriage is not valid. Does that mean the kids and their sacraments are also invalid?
- 44:49 – Can an annulment decision be appealed?
- 47:55 – Is there any hope to get an annulment if the witnesses are no longer able to be located?
- 50:51 – My marriage was annulled 50 years ago and all I got was a letter in the mail and I never participated with it. It felt like a slap in the face to be told that my 9.5 year marriage never existed. I left the Catholic Church after that. Should there be a limit to when you can seek an annulment?
In this episode, we explore the complexities of annulments and divorce, addressing questions like whether annulments are simply a form of Catholic divorce and concerns about the potential abuse of the annulment process.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 11:30 – Is Jesus’ teaching on marriage beautiful or terrifying?
- 19:00 – Aren’t annulments just Catholic divorce?
- 29:03 – So many people get annulments – isn’t the annulment process abused?
- 40:40 – Are psychological grounds for annulment too subjective?
- 45:30 – When did annulments start in the Catholic Church?
- 50:40 – Objection: annulments cost too much money and they take too long.
“Can time-traveling Catholics fulfill Sunday obligation?” This intriguing question opens a discussion that spans various theological topics, including how baptism would apply to a Trill and symbiote from Star Trek, and whether a baptized person with intellectual disabilities can be considered a saint. Join us as we explore these fascinating ideas and more.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:00 – How would baptism work for a Trill and symbiote (from Star Trek)?
- 12:30 – Would a time-traveling Catholic before Christ still have a Sunday obligation?
- 16:39 – Why hasn’t God revealed stories of earlier creations before our time?
- 28:48 – Can a baptized person with intellectual disabilities be considered a saint?
- 38:05 – Should the Church explore the 4th dimension to better understand Scripture?
- 47:34 – Any strange movies with rich theological themes to recommend?
“Could a marriage involving conjoined twins be valid in the Church?” This intriguing question opens a discussion that also explores the origins of rock and roll, the phrases “up north” and “down south,” and the nature of baptismal water in relation to transubstantiation.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 00:50 – What are the origins of rock and roll?
- 03:53 – Could a marriage involving conjoined twins be valid in the Church?
- 16:37 – Where did the phrases “up north” and “down south” originate?
- 30:34 – If we believe in transubstantiation, why don’t we believe baptismal water becomes the Holy Spirit?
- 34:06 – Could God create a duplicate soul in Heaven for companionship?
- 46:04 – Why would God create earthquakes if they cause destruction?
- 52:35 – What would have happened to the papacy if the pope never returned from Avignon?
“What can we do to comfort the suffering?” In this episode, we explore this vital question alongside topics such as the selection of the apostles and the reasons behind God’s allowance of suffering and evil.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:00 – How to discern between Catholic and Protestant apologetics?
- 21:24 – How were the apostles chosen?
- 23:47 – How can we comfort the suffering (2 Cor 1:3–5)?
- 28:41 – Why does God allow suffering and evil?
- 45:50 – Do we receive the full Eucharist with just the host?
“Can the Church claim to be the one true Church?” This episode explores this fundamental question while also addressing whether false information on an annulment application invalidates it, how to respond to Protestant objections regarding the veneration of saints, and the obligation to correct someone misusing the Lord’s name.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:32 – Does false information on an annulment application invalidate it?
- 14:55 – How to respond to Protestant objections to veneration of saints?
- 20:00 – What’s the obligation to correct someone using the Lord’s name in vain?
- 30:53 – Why does the Catholic Church claim to be the one true Church?
- 37:53 – Did the First Lateran Council mandate divorce for married priests?
- 44:12 – Best way to argue for God’s existence to a secular thinker?
- 50:30 – If all can be saved through Christ, why become Catholic?
“Is the Church drifting from the Truth?” This episode explores the implications of Vatican I on Church teachings, alongside discussions on the papacy, the rationale behind infant baptism, and how to approach friendships with those who are same-sex attracted.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:25 – Is the Church drifting from the Truth?
- 29:02 – What does Vatican I say about the papacy?
- 43:28 – Why baptize infants if they can’t consent?
- 48:42 – How to treat same-sex attracted friends?
“What if bishops’ conferences teach error?” In this episode, we explore the implications of erroneous teachings and several other topics, including the differences between Matthew 3:7 and Luke 3:7, the Catholic perspective on Israel and Jews, and the process of annulments. Join us for a thoughtful examination of these important questions.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:30 – What if bishops’ conferences teach error?
- 07:17 – Why do Matthew 3:7 and Luke 3:7 differ?
- 13:42 – What’s the Catholic view on Israel and Jews?
- 22:25 – What if annulments aren’t done by Easter?
- 35:03 – What is the magisterium and how to access it?
- 48:00 – Can I convert if my spouse objects?
“Why isn’t everyone Christian?” This episode explores the complexities of faith and belief, addressing questions such as why baptism in the spirit isn’t more prominent in Mass, the appropriateness of a Catholic music award show, and how to approach confession after a long absence. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:02 – Why don’t we hear more about baptism in the spirit in Mass?
- 15:46 – Is it appropriate to have a Catholic music award show?
- 22:11 – Did God create everything we see now at the moment he created the heavens and the earth?
- 28:46 – How do I approach confession after many years of not going?
- 32:27 – Is there a summary of laws from the Old Testament that no longer apply to Christians?
- 38:43 – What is clothing etiquette for mass?
- 45:47 – A family member fell away from the faith into the Orthodox Church? Why do the Orthodox re-baptize Catholics?
- 50:37 – Mt. 16:19, if the Church is infallible then how do you explain selling indulgence and other corruptions? I’m not repeating myself
“Can blessed items be sold?” This episode explores the nuances of blessed items and their significance, along with questions about the validity of immersion baptism and the timing of forgiveness in relation to baptism. We also delve into the impact of prayer on God’s will, offering a comprehensive look at these important topics in Catholic faith.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 10:59 – Could blessed items be sold?
- 16:00 – Does the bible say that immersion baptism is the only valid baptism?
- 29:53 – Is it only at the moment you are baptized that you are forgiven?
- 43:42 – Does our prayer do anything to move the Will of God?
“Did the woke agenda destroy Superman?” This episode dives into the impact of contemporary cultural shifts on iconic characters and narratives, exploring themes of masculinity and femininity in film. Additionally, we touch on the 50th anniversary of Jaws, the evolution of summer blockbusters, and a discussion about the Fantastic Four.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 00:45 – Jaws 50th Anniversary, Spielberg, Summer blockbusters
- 08:45 – Did the woke agenda destroy Superman?
- 38:00 – Masculinity and femininity in film
- 45:34 – Fantastic Four
In this yearly episode Cy Kellett sits down with Andrew Petiprin to discuss The Phoenician Scheme and Mission Impossible.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 00:45 – Cy’s friend ChatGPT
- 20:27 – The Phoenician Scheme
- 46:00 – Mission Impossible: Final Reckoning
“Will there be a Rapture?” This episode dives into the Catholic perspective on popular rapture theology and explores key topics such as the concept of a literal thousand-year reign, the Catholic understanding of the Three Days of Darkness, and the nature of the Antichrist. Join us for an examination of these important eschatological questions.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:30 – Will there be a Rapture, and how should Catholics respond to popular “rapture” theology?
- 20:00 – Will there be a literal thousand-year reign (the “millennium”)?
- 31:00 – What is the Catholic understanding of the Three Days of Darkness?
- 33:00 – What is the Illumination of Conscience or Warning, and when might it occur?
- 43:00 – What is “Antichrist”?
“Are we currently in the End Times?” This episode explores the signs of Jesus’ return, delving into questions like what dispensationalism is and whether Jesus got end-of-the-world prophecies wrong. Join us as we navigate these important topics and more in this thought-provoking discussion.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:30 – What is dispensationalism?
- 05:59 – Are we currently in the End Times?
- 14:30 – What are the signs that will precede the return of Jesus?
- 30:33 – Did Jesus get end-of-the-world prophecies wrong?
- 49:58 – Will Jesus really return—like “a thief in the night”?
“Why create us if we can choose Hell?” This question opens a thought-provoking discussion on free will, evil, and salvation. The episode also explores how Jesus has written natural law on our hearts, the implications of the rebellion of Korah, and why God allows senseless evil in the world. Tune in for a deep dive into these critical topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:29 – Angels and humans were given free will. God doesn’t want us to go to Hell. Since he knows everything, why bother creating us if we were to choose Hell?
- 13:00 – If natural law has existed since the beginning of time, how has Jesus written the law on our hearts?
- 23:08 – Is the rebellion of Korah a foreshadowing of the Protestant rebellion?
- 33:10 – Why does God allow senseless evil, such as car accidents, natural disasters, etc. to kill his people, which seems to be something that would happen in a Deistic universe?
- 38:05 – What is a good answer to someone who says the church is not needed but only a relationship with Jesus?
- 42:30 – Protestant constantly say that there is one mediator. How would you respond to that claim?
- 46:54 – Lutherans say baptism forgives the sin from before and after your baptism. Why would that be incorrect?
- 51:16 – Aren’t we supposed to pray to God in Jesus name? We are not supposed to be praying to Jesus?
Explore the complex interplay of free will, evil, and salvation in this insightful discussion on why God allows choices that lead to Hell.
What is the Melkite Catholic Church? Catholic Answers Live Host Cy Kellet interviews Bishop François Beyrouti to learn about the American Melkite Church.
“Why doesn’t St. Ignatius mention belief in Mary as essential for salvation?” This episode explores this intriguing question while also addressing the distinctions between latria and dulia, the Catholic Church’s stance on supporting the modern state of Israel, and the differences between Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:42 – Why doesn’t St. Ignatius of Antioch mention belief in Mary as essential salvation?
- 17:41 – What is the difference between latria and dulia?
- 25:05 – Are Catholics required to support the modern state of Israel?
- 30:11 – Why does the Catholic church typically only have communion with the bread and not wine?
- 40:52 – What is the main difference between the Catholic church and Eastern Orthodox?
- 44:30 – I don’t believe in God or the supernatural? What might help me believe in a God?
“Am I Catholic Without Catechesis?” This episode explores the nuances of faith and practice, addressing questions like the implications of baptism and confirmation without catechesis, responses to Seventh Day Adventist beliefs about death, and the role of Catholic schools in adhering to Church teachings. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 11:54 – Am I catholic if I was Baptized and confirmed, but I wasn’t Catechized or practice?
- 20:59 – What is a good response to the Seventh Day Adventist idea of a sleep death?
- 29:04 – At the time of Judgement, do we bypass heaven if we receive the apostolic pardon?
- 33:49 – Do Catholic schools need to abide by the Catholic church for curriculum?
- 45:05 – Why did you discount the Second Judgement in your answers for Seventh Day Adventist?
- 49:55 – How can I navigate converting to Catholicism when family isn’t supportive?
“Can saints intercede for us?” This episode explores the biblical basis for intercession, addressing questions like the reconciliation of Revelation 22:9 with the practice of honoring saints and the significance of the Eucharist in relation to salvation. Tune in as we also delve into the complexities of annulments and the nature of Mary’s sinlessness.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:55 – The saints’ attempt to intercede for us in Rev. 6:9 seems to have failed. What other biblical evidence is there for intercession?
- 14:16 – How can you reconcile Rev. 22:9 with the practice of offering dulia to the saints?
- 23:28 – If the Eucharist is required for salvation, then why did Jesus tell the good thief he would be in paradise that day. Why was it good enough for him but not the rest of us?
- 31:13 – It doesn’t make sense because we don’t know which saints are in heaven and if we pray to one that isn’t there, does that mean we are praying to a demon? The saints pray for you.
- 36:56 – Religions are man made and are all imperfect in particular the Catholic Church?
- 46:33 – I don’t understand where annulments fit into scripture?
- 51:31 – What sin did Mary not have? What is a dark intellect?
“Is eternal security promised in John 5:24?” This episode explores the implications of Jesus’ words on eternal life and judgment. Additionally, we delve into questions about the Church’s changes in the Mass, the nature of angels and their vulnerabilities, and the role of priests in forgiving sins.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:30 – “Jesus says in John 5:24 whoever believes in him has ‘eternal life.’ He states, “24 Truly, truly, I say to you, he who hears my word and believes him who sent me, has eternal life; he does not come into judgment, but has passed from death to life. Isn’t that a promise of eternal security?”
- 16:55 – Mt. 12:38 seems to contradict what Catholicism teaches on how much time Jesus spent in hell.
- 20:16 – Why did the Church change so much in mass?
- 28:50 – Can angels get hurt?
- 32:27 – I think there is a contradiction between priests forgiving in persona Christi since they contribute nothing vs forgiving mortal sin.
- 46:04 – It seems as though we worship an arrogant God.
“How does mental illness connect to spirituality and healing?” In this episode, we explore the intricate relationship between mental health and faith, addressing questions like the role of inherited genes in mental illness and spirituality, the Church’s stance on electric shock treatment for depression, and the spiritual aspects of OCD. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 20:25 – How do we look at inherited genes when it comes to mental illness and spirituality?
- 31:38 – How does the Church feel about electric shock treatment? Is it helpful for people with depression?
- 35:40 – I have a son with schizophrenia, and I’ve been looking for someone to help connect the spiritual and physical.
- 42:25 – Is there a spiritual component to OCD, if so can someone heal from it?
- 47:03 – I’ve had mental problems that the doctors have said there is no solution for. What do you recommend?
- 50:58 – How does generational trauma end?
“What happens if someone confesses to murder?” This episode explores the complexities of confession and forgiveness, alongside questions about processing unconfessed sins and the requirements for receiving a plenary indulgence during a visit to Rome. Join us as we delve into these important topics and more in this thought-provoking discussion.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:41 – What happens if someone confesses to murder?
- 15:36 – How do I process unconfessed sins that I haven’t thought of?
- 20:42 – What do I have to do to receive a plenary indulgence for my visit to Rome?
- 23:35 – Was Jesus ordaining the disciples at the washing of the feet?
- 30:22 – If God doesn’t weigh our deeds, what’s the point of Jesus weighing our deeds at the last judgement?
- 35:46 – Is it ok to publicly use a rite or celebrate a mass of a defunct rite?
- 38:04 – If a person has dementia, would that person still remember the people they met after dying while in purgatory?
- 43:02 – Regarding last Sunday’s readings? Who were the 3 men Abraham met outside his tent?
- 47:01 – Why do we not read about gentiles believing in God until Jesus? Did the Jews not allow them to follow God?
- 50:18 – What happens at death? Do we sleep until the resurrection or do our souls move to either heaven or purgatory?
- 53:25 – Can people in purgatory pray for us?
“Can Latin Mass bring Catholics back?” In this episode we are joined by Catholic Speaker John Sablan to talk about re-engaging fallen away Catholics. We discuss the potential of the Latin Mass in revitalizing faith, alongside discussions on using personal businesses for evangelization, reaching those curious about sacramental life, and effective ways to engage with fallen-away Catholics. Tune in for a thoughtful exploration of these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 21:46 – Is it a good idea to use my new woodworking business as a way to have a good Catholic influence for evangelization?
- 32:09 – How do you reach out to the people who can seem to figure out the mystery of sacramental life?
- 37:16 – How can the Latin Mass play a role in bringing Catholics back?
- 45:21 – What’s a good approach to converse with a fallen away older Catholic man to bring him back?
- 50:04 – My friends told me the reason they can’t become Catholic is because they don’t have the time for all the classes. Wouldn’t it be better to go back the older way that was a shorter process?
In this episode Dr. Marcus Peter answers questions about the covenants of God. He discusses how covenants tie into our modern Sacrements and how covenantal theology is key to understanding the Catholic faith!
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 44:24 – Is there a relationship between the term sacramentum and oath. Would calling a sacrament an oath detract from its proper meaning?
- 51:08 – Should you keep engaging with a person who is having a sin conversation and wont correct it?
“Why doesn’t the pope make more infallible statements and settle more issues?” This episode explores the complexities of papal authority and decision-making, while also addressing what factors are considered in electing a new pope, the reasons behind Pius XII’s suppression of liturgical octaves, and the intriguing question of why there has never been a Pope Peter II.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 21:47 – Why doesn’t the pope make more infallibile statements and settle more issues?
- 31:23 – What do they consider when electing a new pope?
- 35:40 – What was the reason for Pius XII to suppress so many liturgical octaves?
- 43:34 – Can you comment on Pope Pius XII’s position during WWII and why he wasn’t more vocal?
- 51:30 – Why has there never been a Pope Peter II?
“Can saints intercede for us?” This episode delves into the role of saints in prayer and tradition, addressing common concerns such as explaining intercession to Protestant family members and understanding why only the priest consumes from the chalice. We also explore the line between intercessory prayer and superstition, along with tips for inviting fallen-away Catholics back to the Church.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 12:26 – I come from a protestant family and am about to start OCIA. The obstacle I find is explaining the intercession of saints to my family.
- 19:56 – I struggle with not being able to consume from the chalice. Why does only the priest consume from the chalice?
- 24:36 – When does Intercessory prayer become a superstitious tradition?
- 39:48 – How do I approach my fallen away Catholic friend about returning to the Church?
“Can non-Catholics be saved?” This episode explores the complexities of salvation and the Catholic faith, addressing questions like the role of Mariology, the fear of the Lord, and the implications of Vatican II. Tune in as we also discuss concerns about worship practices and the challenges of unity among different Christian denominations.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:08 – I’m not Catholic because I don’t believe in Mariology and I don’t worship her.
- 18:33 – Are you supposed to be afraid of the Lord?
- 22:23 – I want to convert but my wife won’t. Would I be able to receive communion if she doesn’t convert?
- 30:01 – I’m not Catholic because the bible tells us to worship Saturday not Sunday.
- 33:34 – I’m Orthodox. I have issues with the changes of Vatican 2 and the claim that Muslims are saved.
- 48:29 – I’m not Catholic because of the divisions I see. It’s difficult to figure out which Church is true.
“Why doesn’t the Church embrace the Spirit like Pentecostals?” This episode explores the differences in spiritual expression between traditions, while also addressing questions about the necessity of dogmas in Catholicism, the misconceptions surrounding the Roman curia, and the significance of icons in the faith. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:36 – Why doesn’t the Church field the Spirit the way Pentecostals do?
- 12:17 – I’m not Catholic because the Church requires you to believe in all its dogmas.
- 23:00 – How do I debunk the claim that the Roman curia is run like the mafia?
- 37:30 – Could you explain Icons to me and the history of their veneration?
- 47:26 – My family’s obstacle to the faith is that God preserved the true Church as a remnant and not a big visible church.
“How is original sin passed down through evolution?” This episode explores the intersection of faith and science, addressing questions like how to respond to claims about Mary and Jesus in Revelation 12, and whether enjoying earthly pleasures contradicts the call to be a saint. Tune in for a thoughtful discussion on these important topics and more.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:54 – How is the original sin passed down within the framework of evolution?
- 11:12 – My husband is not Catholic. He took issue with Rev. 12 and claimed that it cannot be Mary and Jesus. He said that it was all false. How can I respond?
- 14:35 – Is there any contradiction in enjoying earthly pleasures like watching football and playing cards and fulfilling the call of being a saint?
- 24:28 – Can the devil have power over people after death? Is there any benefit for having masses said for people we can assume are already in heaven?
- 31:50 – Siying’s conversion story
- 35:51 – I just joined the Church. I know there is a 1 hour fast before communion. Can we drink coffee?
- 37:40 – If my friends don’t know Church teaching or misconceptions, but love God, what are they responsible for?
- 45:01 – Why did Mary have to be sinless and why do we have to follow that line of thinking?
- 52:06 – What’s the historical doctrinal development of transubstantiation and what does substance actually mean?
“What did the Early Church say about Mary?” In this episode, we explore the significance of Mary in early Christianity, addressing questions about her extraordinary nature, the evidence for her Assumption beyond Revelation, and the historical context of groups like the Pelagianists who downplayed her role. Tune in for a rich discussion on these pivotal topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:00 – What did the Early Church say about Mary?
- 13:01 – Was Mary ordinary and made extraordinary because of her actions or was she extraordinary from the beginning? Does Simeon’s prophecy that the hearts of many would be revealed mean she would hear all of our prayers?
- 18:30 – Besides the book of Revelation, what other evidence for the Assumption of Mary?
- 22:30 – I’m reading St. Louis de Monforte, and he mentions a group who didn’t care to talk about Mary. I think it was the Pelagianists. What happened to them and their denial of her?
- 29:51 – I was taught that ever since the flood there was no evil seed. And that sin was passed on through man seed in conception. How can the Catholic Church claim she was preserved from sin if she was conceived through ordinary means?
- 41:38 – To what extent did Mary know about the sufferings that Jesus would endure at the passion?
- 45:55 – Can we accept the apparition of Our Lady of La Salette or did the later issues with the children taint the whole message?
- 50:19 – How do we refute the Protestant claim that the title Queen of Heaven is not of a pagan goddess from the Old Testament?
“Can non-Catholics receive Communion?” This episode explores the nuances of this question while also addressing topics such as the inclusion of the apocrypha in the canon, the Church’s approach to blending faith with different cultures, and the authorship of the Acts of the Apostles. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important issues.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:05 – I’m LDS. How do you justify including the apocrypha in the canon?
- 05:45 – How does the Church justify mixing the faith with foreign cultures?
- 11:40 – What is your view on the authorship of Acts of the Apostles? Act 2:1-11 What was the atmosphere in the room on Pentecost?
- 17:43 – How do I explain to a Protestant why they can’t receive communion in a Catholic Church?
- 23:33 – How do you really know God is real?
- 32:47 – how do protestants ignore the obvious verse in the New Testament where Jesus says Peter is the rock?
- 37:10 – When a non-Catholic attends mass, can the person receive a blessing?
- 44:25 – What exactly happens at a consecration? When the priest consecrates the host, what do believe is the range for consecration? Can the host be across the room for it to be validly consecrated?
- 50:02 – How do I learn to properly read the Bible?
“How do we know indulgences are valid?” This episode explores the authority behind indulgences and the merits of saints, while also addressing questions about responding to critiques of Church scandals, the meaning of Christ’s words on the cross, and the practice of bowing to statues. Tune in for a thoughtful examination of these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 17:06 – How do we know we have the authority to apply the merits of the saint in indulgences?
- 22:47 – I have a lot of protestant family. How do I respond to the valid critiques when it comes to Church scandals?
- 29:07 – What did our Lord mean when he said It is finished on the cross?
- 37:10 – Why do Catholics bow to statues since Exodus condemns it?
- 46:35 – If God gave Mary a special grace in which she still has free will but will always choose Him, why doesn’t God give us that same grace?
“Can we take Jesus literally as the Bread of Life?” This episode explores the nuances of interpreting Jesus’ words, addressing the Protestant claim about literalism and metaphor. Additionally, we delve into the nature of hell and God’s mercy, and discuss how to approach conversations with Protestants regarding the intercession of saints. Tune in for a thoughtful exploration of these important topics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:29 – Protestant claim we shouldn’t take Jesus literally when he says that he is the bread of life because he also says he is a door. What is the best response to this?
- 15:37 – How do we know that hell is forever and how do we justify God being merciful with that reality being taken into consideration?
- 23:26 – What angle can we use when talking to protestants when discussing the intercession of the saints. It seems like they get hung up on the ‘praying to’ wording.
- 35:21 – Since Jesus is omniscient and omnipotent, did that take away from his suffering?
- 43:46 – Why is it uncommon to pray to Old Testament saints?
- 47:16 – I’ve heard it said that the reason Satan fell was because he knew God would become man. Wouldn’t this imply that Satan has some kind of foreknowledge?
“Can animals go to heaven?” This episode explores the intriguing question of animal salvation, alongside discussions on the material sufficiency of Scripture and the Church’s tracing of papal succession back to Peter. Tune in as we delve into these thought-provoking topics and more, providing clarity on faith, works, and biblical interpretations.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:45 – Why is the material sufficiency view of scripture not self-refuting?
- 15:37 – How does the Church trace the special status and succession of popes back to Peter? How is it pass on?
- 23:12 – I always taught my kids that animals don’t go to heaven, though I’ve heard you say that they possibly do. Can you explain your view?
- 37:21 – I’ve heard you say the Church has never claimed that faith and works lead unto salvation. If so, then what is James talking about?
- 46:52 – Today’s gospel says “Amen, I say to you, you will not finish the towns of Israel before the Son of Man comes.” What does that mean if he is the Son of Man who is presently there?
- 52:08 – Was Cornelius justified prior to being baptized in Acts 10?
“What Is the Role of Popes in Approving Ecumenical Councils?” In this episode, guest apologist Alex Jurado from Voice of Reason addresses the necessity of papal approval for early councils, explores how Jesus grew in knowledge, and discusses the connection between Mary’s Assumption and 1 Cor. 15:55.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 08:59 – How did Jesus grow in knowledge? And did he have knowledge of his passion from a young age?
- 14:30 – What’s the necessity for popes to convene and approve ecumenical councils particularly the earliest councils of the Church?
- 17:46 – Is there a connection between Mary’s Assumption and 1 Cor. 15:55?
- 21:52 – Why did the person who touched the ark dropped dead but people who stole it didn’t. Why is that?
- 24:24 – Is it ok for a priest to consecrate a large amount of hosts and give them to a homebound person?
- 30:31 – Has Pope Leo expressed any opinion on Same sex unions?
- 32:10 – How would you explain to children deep theological questions?
- 43:40 – How many of the 10 commandments would exist today if there weren’t any religions?
- 48:48 – Why do Protestants have a different canon of scripture?
- 52:09 – If Jesus descended into hell to retrieve souls to enter heaven, does that mean those souls were suffering?
“What Is the Origin of the Hail Mary Prayer in Catholicism?” Join Colin Donavan as he explores the roots of this beloved prayer, along with intriguing questions about the letter from Jesus King to Abgar and the nature of free will in relation to Eve and Mary.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:19 – What do we make of the letter from Jesus to King Abgar as recorded in Eusebius’ Church History?
- 07:02 – There was a supposedly leaked document from the Vatican about the TLM and it claims that the reasons why it was banned were fabricated. What do we know about that?
- 16:12 – Where did the prayer of the Hail Mary come from since it’s not in the bible?
- 24:37 – Did Eve have free will? If she did and didn’t fall, would we have had Mary?
- 41:52 – Did Pope Francis change church doctrine on capital punishment?
A caller shares that his coworker refuses to take direction from a female supervisor, citing Scripture as justification. In this episode, Catholic apologists respond with clarity on what the Church teaches about gender roles, authority, and human dignity. Discover how Catholic teaching affirms the equal dignity of men and women while refuting misuse of Scripture to justify sexism.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:35 – The Church recently rolled out the final document on the Synod on Synodality and I cannot intellectually accept it. Am I essentially no longer Catholic?
- 12:16 – Why is marriage between a man and a woman?
- 18:08 – At what point did Jesus declare that all animals are clean to eat?
- 24:49 – What is the Catholic stance on eugenics?
- 32:45 – My supervisor said he would refuse to submit to his supervisor because she is a woman. He used scripture to justify this. How do we approach this as Catholics?
- 42:41 – Regarding the year of Jubilee, when you visit 7 churches, do you receive 1 indulgence or an indulgence for every church you visit?
A listener asks whether it’s morally permissible to attend the wedding reception of a Catholic getting married outside the Church. In this episode, Catholic apologist Joe Heschmeyer explains the difference between supporting the person versus appearing to support an invalid union, and how to navigate these situations with charity, clarity, and fidelity to Church teaching.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 15:43 – Is there a small document that describes the latest eucharistic miracles from a scientific perspective?
- 21:38 – Is it ok to attend the reception of an invalid marriage of a confirmed Catholic who is not getting married in the Church?
- 28:38 – Melchizedek in Genesis. Where did he come from and what happened to him?
- 37:11 – If a laicized priest becomes an Anglican priest, is the host consecrated the body of Christ?
- 45:44 – What is your view on AI and what is the intersection between the Church and AI?
A caller asks whether Muslims truly worship the same God as Christians. In this episode, Catholic apologist, Dr. Karlo Broussard, explains the Church’s teaching from Lumen Gentium and the Catechism, clarifying how Islam’s incomplete understanding of God still refers to the one true Creator. The conversation also touches on key differences between the faiths and what authentic interreligious respect looks like.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:04 – If we can’t control how people see us, how is it then that we can be culpable for the sin of scandal?
- 11:50 – Does the lack of understanding of a mortal sin mitigate something being a mortal sin? For example, if a person views pornography but doesn’t believe it’s a mortal sin, is it still a mortal sin?
- 21:02 – How does the pope calling the crusades and saying going on a crusade forgives sins, fall into the doctrine of the papacy?
- 29:23 – Can you explain how Muslims worship the same God even with an incomplete understanding of him?
- 37:04 – I’m not Catholic. I was shocked to hear that Catholics believe that the biblical story of the flood is allegorical. Is this true?
- 45:48 – Are we obligated to forgive those who have not repented of sinning against us?
- 50:34 – Why does a person who wants to be baptized have to wait until going through class up until Easter?
Many Catholics struggle with understanding what truly makes a sin mortal. In this episode, the hosts offer a clear explanation of the three conditions: grave matter, full knowledge, and deliberate consent. They explore common misconceptions, offer real-life examples, and help listeners better examine their consciences with clarity and confidence rooted in Church teaching.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 16:42 – I’m Orthodox and don’t believe that purgatory is a belief of the first century. What evidence do Catholics provide for it?
- 28:15 – Can I come up with my own mysteries of the rosary to meditate on?
- 34:44 – I feel the current criteria for mortal sin is not properly fleshed out to what they actually mean. How can one actually know what these 3 criteria actually constitute?
- 48:22 – The Filioque troubles me. How is it that a previous pope saw it problematic, yet a later pope included it?
- 52:47 – Can you clarify how there is salvation outside the Church?
What does Scripture mean when it says Christ was “made sin for us”? In this episode, Catholic apologists address a Protestant caller’s concern about Psalm 51 and the Catholic rejection of penal substitution. Learn how the Church understands Christ’s sacrifice—not as punishment in our place, but as a redemptive offering rooted in love and union with humanity.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 08:01 – I’m Protestant. I’ve listened to a lot of Catholic radio. I’ve had no change. Is this lack of movement of desire to change from Satan?
- 18:38 – How do we catechize older boomers who prioritize politics and social views over religion?
- 23:32 – What evidence do we have that the Catholic Church is the true Church?
- 34:09 – in Friday morning’s psalm prayer it says, “He who knew no sin was made sin for us to save us and restore us to your friendship” Psalm 51. We don’t believe in Calvinism substitutionary atonement. So, in what way was Christ made sin for us?
- 40:45 – Is there any point in saying “If God wills it, it will happen?” Especially if he has two wills?
- 48:22 – Is it possible for a person to sin in purgatory or if they have not died?
In this episode, Catholic bioethicist Fr. Tad Pacholczyk tackles tough moral questions about teenage medical consent, frozen embryo implantation in older women, and the ethics of sustaining life through new technologies. Hear a thoughtful Catholic perspective on where moral lines are drawn in modern medicine and why intention, consent, and dignity matter in every case.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 20:24 – What are the reasonable limits to sustaining a pregnancy, such as the case you were discussing vs embryos conceived in IVF?
- 30:03 – Regarding the Georgia situation, since keeping dead person vitals going a new technology, would this be done only at the consent of the mother? Would that solve the dilemma?
- 34:59 – I have a 13-year-old son. We were told that at 14 we would be asked to leave the room for our son to decide if he wanted to make his own medical decisions alone with the doctor. Are you familiar with this situation and would this be ethical?
- 44:19 – Would it be ethical to implant a frozen embryo in a woman who is 60 years of age knowing that the pregnancy would probably not be viable?
Can someone with a water allergy be baptized? Why do priests receive both species of the Eucharist while the laity often don’t? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we take on some of the most thought-provoking questions about Catholic doctrine and tradition. Topics include evangelizing Jewish people, the theological necessity of Marian dogmas, recognizing divine inspiration in Scripture, and reconciling the joy of heaven with the loss of loved ones. We also address questions about God’s providence versus coincidence, and near-death experiences involving deceased relatives. Whether you’re exploring Catholic teachings or deepening your faith, this Q&A offers clear, faithful answers rooted in Church teaching. Ideal for those curious about baptism, Eucharistic theology, salvation, and how Catholics understand prophecy and the afterlife.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:10 – How would the Church baptize someone with a topical allergy to water, where contact with water causes hives but drinking it is fine?
- 08:15 – Did the Old Testament prophets know they were prophets? Did the New Testament writers know they were divinely inspired when writing?
- 18:22 – How can heaven be a place of perfect joy if a loved one, such as a child, does not attain eternal life? Wouldn’t we notice their absence and grieve?
- 22:15 – What is the Church’s current teaching on evangelizing Jewish people?
Does God’s promise of the land to the Jewish people still apply under the New Covenant? - 29:45 – Why is the Eucharistic cup often withheld from the laity? Jesus instructed us to eat His body and drink His blood. If the host contains both, why does the priest still consume both species separately?
- 34:58 – Why are the dogmas of the Immaculate Conception, Bodily Assumption, and Perpetual Virginity necessary for salvation from a theological standpoint? What core gospel truths are denied if these are rejected?
- 43:43 – If someone nearing death sees and speaks to deceased family members, does that mean those individuals are in Heaven or could they still be in Purgatory? What if certain people don’t appear—does that imply anything about their final destination?
- 50:01 – Is everything part of God’s plan, or do coincidences exist?
What’s really in a hot dog? Why does the letter “s” look like “f” in the Declaration of Independence? Are bald eagles actually bald? On this unique Fourth of July edition of Catholic Answers Live, we dive into five fun mysteries of Independence Day. Plus, callers ask deep theological questions: Did Christ always have a human nature? Can Genesis reflect ancient myths while remaining divinely inspired? Did the apostles expect the Second Coming in their lifetimes? Is it possible that angels are saints from a previous universe? And what happens to grace when a baptized person commits mortal sin?
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:30 – Top 5 Mysteries of the 4th of July
- 14:25 – Why do some oppose the Traditional Latin Mass?
- 15:43 – Did Christ always possess a human nature, or did God gain a human nature at the moment of the Incarnation? What is the best language to describe this mystery?
- 18:28 – Could Genesis incorporate contemporary myths like the Mesopotamian flood stories to explain God’s actions, such as the Flood, using familiar cultural narratives?
- 31:47 – Why did the Church transition from severe fasting to weekly abstinence and now allows other penances in the US? Is this spiritual progression good or bad?
- 42:08 – Did the apostles believe the Parousia (Second Coming) was imminent during their lifetimes?
- 48:32 – Is it conceivable that angels are saints from a previous iteration of the universe?
- 52:22 – Does a baptized person who commits a mortal sin lose all grace until Confession, despite the indelible mark of baptism?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, listeners ask thought-provoking questions on topics ranging from liturgy and Church history to spiritual warfare and vocational discernment. Questions include how to begin a career in Catholic apologetics, whether the Novus Ordo Mass assumes an ad orientem posture, and how exorcism practices differ between Catholics and non-Catholic Christians. Also discussed is the historical development of the priesthood and the formal distribution of Communion, tracing its evolution from house churches to today’s liturgical structure.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:50 – What are some practical suggestions and advice for someone considering a career in Catholic apologetics? How should one begin to pursue the “soul” of apologetics?
- 15:19 – Does the Novus Ordo rubric originally assume that the Mass is celebrated ad orientem, and has it changed over time to be commonly celebrated facing the congregation?
- 29:15 – How is it that non-Catholic Christians are able to cast out demons, while in the Catholic Church exorcism is ecclesiastically regulated and reserved for authorized exorcists?
- 49:00 – When and how did the Church transition from early Christian gatherings in homes to a more formal institution of the priesthood and structured distribution of Communion?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, listeners gain clear and insightful answers on key Catholic teachings and questions. Topics include whether St. Paul would recognize the doctrine of transubstantiation, reliable resources on liturgical changes since Vatican II, and the historical context of the Inquisition. The episode also clarifies misconceptions about the Bible and addresses claims of suppressed books. Discussion covers patristic sources on the Immaculate Conception, the nature of the Transfiguration, and why the NAB Bible is used in U.S. liturgy. Additionally, listeners learn about the Catholic view of justification versus Protestant faith alone, the acceptability of prostration in Latin Rite prayer, and the theological implications of worshipping a deceiving spirit.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:59 – Would St. Paul recognize the doctrine of transubstantiation?
- 08:26 – Where can reliable resources be found regarding changes to the liturgy post-Vatican II?
- 14:05 – What is the historical context and Church justification regarding the Inquisition?
- 18:40 – Is there any truth to the claim that the Catholic Church is hiding or suppressing 14 books of the Bible? Clarification needed on the Bible as a Catholic book.
- 21:56 – During the Transfiguration, when Moses talks with Jesus, is that an example of necromancy?
- 28:55 – Where can more patristic information about the Immaculate Conception be found?
- 35:05 – Why is the NAB Bible used as the basis for liturgy in the U.S.? What would be required to change to a different translation?
- 41:22 – If Satan or a demon tricks a group into worshipping him, is that group worshipping the same God as Christians?
- 48:53 – Is it acceptable in the Latin/Roman Rite to pray in a prostration style similar to Eastern Orthodox practice?
- 50:55 – What is the Catholic understanding of Justification compared to the Protestant doctrine of Faith alone?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, listeners ask insightful questions on a variety of Catholic topics. Discussion includes the history and value of the Liturgy of the Hours for laypeople, Church teaching on keeping cremated ashes at home, and how miracles are evaluated in the canonization process when multiple saints are invoked. Other questions address the origin of John the Baptist’s baptism, the theological distinction between infant baptism and Old Covenant circumcision, and whether someone who doesn’t attend Mass may receive Communion during a hospice visit. Also covered are explanations of patron saints for Protestant audiences and concerns about receiving a Shinto omamori charm. A wide-ranging episode filled with clarity on Catholic doctrine, sacramental theology, and respectful interfaith dialogue.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:17 – What is the history of the Liturgy of the Hours and how can it benefit a layperson?
- 14:24 – What is the significance of receiving an omamori charm (Japanese Shinto) for marriage, and why is it advised not to hang it in a car?
- 19:09 – What is the origin of the baptism practiced and preached by John the Baptist?
- 22:51 – What is the Church’s teaching regarding keeping ashes at home? Additionally, is it permissible for a non-practicing Catholic to receive communion during a hospice visit?
- 34:10 – In the canonization process, how is a miracle attributed specifically to one saint when people praying may also ask for the intercession of other saints?
- 44:04 – How can patron saints be explained to Protestants? How is the practice of having a Mass said for someone communicated to those unfamiliar with Catholic traditions?
- 52:22 – If infant circumcision was used to bring people into the Old Covenant and infant baptism brings people into the New Covenant, why is infant baptism not condemned as a “work of the law” while circumcision is?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we tackle a wide range of thoughtful questions from callers of various faith backgrounds. Topics include the similarities and differences between Catholicism and Latter-day Saint beliefs, a clear explanation of purgatory, and why only the priest consumes the Precious Blood during Mass. We also discuss whether purgatory is purification or punishment, the role of baptism in Christian unity, and the theological significance of the 1,000 years after Armageddon. Additional questions explore the Catholic view on salvation versus universalism, the Greek wording in Scripture regarding Jesus’ “brothers,” and how to make sense of the brokenness in the world today—especially in children.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:47 – Are there any similarities between Latter-day Saint (LDS) and Catholic beliefs?
- 08:20 – What is a simple explanation of purgatory for someone unfamiliar with Catholic teaching?
- 16:36 – Why is it only the priest who consumes the wine during Mass?
- 22:20 – Is purgatory meant to be purification or punishment?
- 25:13 – If baptism is the great unifying sacrament among Christians, why doesn’t it allow all baptized Christians to receive Communion?
- 31:41 – What is the meaning and significance of the 1,000 years after Armageddon, and how does it compare with the concept of purgatory?
- 35:29 – How does the Catholic view of salvation differ from Christian universalism?
- 43:37 – What does the Greek in Scripture indicate about Jesus’ brothers and whether Mary was their mother?
- 50:43 – Why does so much brokenness exist in the world, especially as seen in children?
In This episode of Catholic Answers Live we cover questions on: Catholic-Muslim views on God, early Church writings, Arian heresies, salvation through the Church, Marian apparitions, explaining the Eucharist to Protestants, creation timeline in Genesis, Jesus’ agony in the Garden, and proper handling of cremated ashes.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:05 – What is a succinct apologetics response to the claim that Catholics worship the same God as Muslims? How can this be explained clearly to Protestants?
- 12:35 – Is there a book or collection of theological documents from the first to third centuries?
- 21:29 – How can one refute an Arian-type heresy when discussing with others?
- 29:15 – What does it mean that salvation comes through the Catholic Church, especially in light of the alleged Marian apparition above a Coptic church in Zeitoun, Egypt?
- 36:03 – How can the Catholic teaching on the Eucharist be explained to Protestants who claim it resembles cannibalism?
- 46:37 – Why did God wait until the fourth day to create the sun, moon, and stars when He said “let there be light” on the first day?
- Follow-up – Why did Jesus agonize in the Garden of Gethsemane if He knew His Passion was necessary?
- 51:15 – If a family cannot afford cemetery entombment, is it permissible to spread a loved one’s ashes on cemetery grounds?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we tackle some of the most thought-provoking and commonly asked questions about the Catholic faith. Topics include the biblical basis for Mary’s sinlessness and the Assumption, as well as how to explain the word “Catholic” despite it not appearing in Scripture. We also explore the Church’s teaching on the respectful handling of cremated ashes versus the veneration of saints’ relics. Listeners ask how to understand Acts 2:38–39 in relation to infant baptism and seek guidance on restoring hope during spiritual dryness and doubt in the power of prayer.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 19:15 – Where in the Bible is the idea of Mary’s sinlessness found?
- 24:20 – What is the distinction between the Church’s prohibition on scattering cremated ashes and the distribution of saints’ relics?
- 33:20 – Why do Catholics believe in the Assumption of Mary?
- 44:41 – How can one restore hope and faith when doubting the efficacy of prayer?
- 51:22 – How can Catholics explain the term “Catholic” being Biblical when the word itself is not in the Bible?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, listeners ask thoughtful and wide-ranging questions on Catholic doctrine and spirituality. Topics include whether a cantor’s lifestyle affects the Mass, how to discern mystical experiences from coincidences, and the potential impact of Ecumenical Councils on doctrine and liturgy. Other questions touch on miracles in non-Catholic churches, the meaning of Matthew 11:27, the history of the Sacrament of Confession, and how to address disruptive chatter before Mass. The show also delves into more unusual inquiries, such as whether the Church has any stance on fairies, and how to understand the eternal consequences of dying in mortal sin.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:27 – Does a cantor living a homosexual lifestyle diminish the value of the Mass?
- 09:59 – Will there be more Catholic-Orthodox apologetics content in the future?
- 18:00 – How can one discern whether an experience is mystical or merely coincidence?
- 23:21 – Can an Ecumenical Council change doctrine in a way that leads to liturgical abuse, or is this an application of Matthew 18?
- 28:44 – Why do miracles occur in Orthodox and Protestant churches if they are outside the Catholic Church?
- 34:44 – What is the proper understanding of Matthew 11:27?
- 40:00 – What is the historical development of the Sacrament of Confession?
- 47:32 – How should pre-Mass chatter in church be addressed?
- 50:52 – Does the Church have any official teaching or view on fairies?
- 53:22 – If someone dies in mortal sin, why isn’t it appropriate to conclude they are in Hell?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we tackle some of the most thought-provoking and practical questions about the Catholic faith. Topics include tips for bringing toddlers to Mass, a deep dive into Exodus 21:7-11, and the moral implications of marrying for an inheritance. We also explore why so much of world history has unfolded outside the visible boundaries of the Catholic Church, whether Catholics and Muslims worship the same God, and how to reconcile evolution with the Genesis account. This episode is packed with Catholic apologetics, biblical insight, and guidance for living out your faith in everyday situations. Whether you’re a parent, a student of Scripture, or just seeking clarity, this episode offers something for every Catholic thinker and believer.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 15:34 – Do you have tips for bringing toddlers to Mass?
- 24:13 – What is the explanation behind Exodus 21:7-11?
- 29:10 – What are the moral implications of marrying someone for an inheritance?
- 32:44 – Why has so much history and civilization occurred outside the universal church?
- 46:19 – Does the Catholic church consider Allah from Islam the same as our God?
- 50:29 – How do I navigate evolution when referencing Genesis?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we dive into one of the most debated topics in the modern Church: Why was the Novus Ordo Mass introduced after Vatican II, and how should Catholics view it alongside the Traditional Latin Mass? We explore the historical context, theological intent, and the call for reverence and unity across both forms. Whether you’re attached to the TLM or attend the Novus Ordo, this episode emphasizes mutual respect and liturgical richness.
Help support the work we do by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 13:22 – If Mary was born without original sin, why can’t everyone else?
- 16:33 – Is there any strong case (theological, biblical and/or historical) for women deacons? It seems there isn’t any case, but as it gets brought up so often, what could be a strong man case for it?
- 35:02 – Hello from the UK, Jimmy. What exactly is a Doctor of the Church, and why are their views held in higher esteem compared to any other theologian or apologist? Thanks.
- 40:54 – What’s a good way to explain why the Novus Ordo was introduced? How would you address critics of either the Novus Ordo or the Traditional Latin Mass that both forms should be respected?
- 49:10 – If after the resurrection we will be more like the angels, does this imply we will be genderless as well?
- 52:33 – Recently in one livestream, someone was saying Christianity spread with Bible in one hand and bullet in other. What should be my response as a Christian?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we explore a fascinating question about Gospel authorship: When St. John wrote his Gospel, was he aware of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and the Acts of the Apostles? We examine historical evidence, early Church tradition, and scholarly insight into how the Gospel of John fits into the broader New Testament timeline.
Help support the work we do by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:12 – What does it mean in 1 Peter 2:24 from a Catholic perspective that Jesus “bore our sins in His body?”
- 10:21 – Where did the boy Jesus sleep when he was missing for three days?
- 19:33 – If an entity is currently traveling forward through time (ie progressing from the present to the future) then does it follow that it must have begun traveling through time?
- 29:02 – How would you reply to someone who says it was the Holy Spirit only who led the church in the first 4 centuries and not the Catholic Church, etc.
- 37:52 – I’m in a Catholic parish choir and the hymnal has a lot of songs of Protestant origin with lines like this: Till on that cross as Jesus died. The wrath of God was satisfied. Am I right to find this a distorted view of Jesus’s sacrifice of himself? It seems to show God the Father as a vengeance-hungry idiot happy to hurt the most innocent Victim possible.
- 45:25 – When John wrote his Gospel, was he aware of the three synoptic Gospels Matthew, Mark, and Luke plus the book of Acts? Is there any Church tradition or research that confirms he was aware of their existence?
Join Cy Kellett on Catholic Answers Live as he welcomes Eucharistic pilgrims Leslie Reyes Hernandez and Jonathan Hernandez, two vibrant young Catholics journeying across the country to share Christ’s love through the National Eucharistic Pilgrimage. From Indianapolis to Los Angeles, they’re visiting churches, hospitals, and schools—bringing the Eucharist and a powerful message of faith, healing, and joy. Hear Jonathan’s incredible testimony of transformation from anger to peace through Eucharistic Adoration and how both he and Leslie are witnessing to the Real Presence with every step. Their passion, humility, and surrender to God’s will are deeply moving. Get inspired by their faith, their stories, and their call to evangelization on the road—an uplifting reminder of the power of Christ in the Eucharist.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
In this inspiring episode of Catholic Answers Live, Bishop Earl Fernandes of Columbus, Ohio, shares his powerful family story of immigration, perseverance, and vocation—from the son of Indian immigrants to Catholic bishop. Hear how Catholic education, hard work, and faith helped his family rise from poverty, and why he believes Catholic schools remain a vital force for evangelization and community renewal. Bishop Fernandes discusses universal school vouchers in Ohio, how Catholic schools transform lives, and the Church’s role in serving the common good—through education, healthcare, housing, and workforce development. He also reflects on the lasting impact of Catholic formation and why authentically Catholic education must form the whole person.
Is it a sin to change your surname? Can Mary hear our silent prayers? In this episode, we explore unique and thought-provoking questions about Catholic belief and morality. Learn the difference between the minimal and maximal facts approaches to defending the Resurrection of Jesus, and discover the Church’s perspective on “reality shifting”—a concept involving altered states of consciousness. We also address whether it’s morally acceptable to own and use firearms, especially in cases of self-defense. Finally, we examine Genesis 1:30 and whether it truly suggests that all animals were originally vegetarian.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 11:42 – Which is more effective in defending the Resurrection of Jesus: the minimal facts approach or the maximal facts approach?
- 19:14 – What is the Catholic perspective on the morality of “reality shifting,” or shifting consciousness to an alternate version of reality?
- 29:00 – How should someone discern whether changing their surname dishonors their father, and whether they should change it back out of respect?
- 40:35 – Is it morally acceptable to own and use guns, particularly for self-defense and situations involving lethal force?
- 46:12 – Can Mary hear our silent prayers and thoughts, such as when praying the Rosary silently rather than aloud?
- 50:20 – Does Genesis 1:30 support the claim that all animals were originally vegetarian, as some fundamentalists suggest?
Can Catholics name their Guardian Angels? Will receiving both the Body and Blood of Christ return as a regular practice? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we dive into intriguing theological and scriptural questions. Learn the difference between hermeneutics and exegesis, the Church’s view on the gift of tongues, and whether drone technology could ever be used to deliver the Eucharist. We also explore Jesus’ question to Peter—“Do you love me more than these?”—and what it reveals about love and leadership among the apostles. Finally, we address the idea that the elect are always a remnant and what that means for salvation.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
04:30 – Can the faithful receive both the Body and Blood of Christ at Communion? Will this practice return universally?
06:03 – How should Catholics respond to the idea that the elect are always a remnant, implying only a small portion of humanity—including Christians—are saved?
14:51 – What is the difference between the terms hermeneutics and exegesis in biblical interpretation?
17:40 – Could drone technology ever be used to deliver the Eucharist to those unable to attend Mass?
31:55 – What is the Catholic position on the gift of tongues? Must it involve unintelligible sounds, real languages, or can there be differing views?
43:42 – Are Catholics permitted to name their Guardian Angels?
49:15 – Why did Jesus ask Peter if he loved Him more than the others? What is the meaning behind that specific comparison?
Can a pope change infallible doctrine? What does the Church teach about receiving the entire Trinity in Holy Communion? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we explore key theological topics and respond to common questions about the Catholic faith. Learn how to respond to Calvinist interpretations of key Scripture passages, understand why the Eucharist is more than just Christ’s flesh and blood, and dive into the origins of the doctrine of receiving Christ’s body, blood, soul, and divinity. We also examine why the Catholic Church typically uses pouring rather than full immersion for Baptism.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:52 – How can Catholic theology respond to Calvinist interpretations of Matthew 1:21, Philippians 1:6, or 1 Peter 3:18?
- 09:00 – Does receiving Holy Communion also mean receiving the Holy Spirit and God the Father, based on the doctrine of the Trinity?
- 30:04 – What prevents a pope from changing infallible Catholic doctrine?
- 42:51 – What is the origin of the teaching that the Eucharist is the reception of Christ’s body, blood, soul, and divinity—not just His flesh and blood?
- 50:12 – Why doesn’t the Catholic Church practice full immersion Baptism as the normative form?
Is the Eucharist cannibalism? Why is the Precious Blood sometimes withheld from the laity? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we respond to common misunderstandings and explore the deep theology behind Catholic beliefs. Learn how to explain the Eucharist to skeptics, understand the Church’s teaching on the Sacrifice of the Mass despite Christ’s once-for-all death, and explore the scriptural, theological, and historical support for the Assumption of Mary. We also tackle the question of whether God calls all Christians to become Catholic.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 20:50 – How can the Catholic teaching on the Eucharist be explained to clarify that it is not cannibalism?
- 29:33 – What are the theological and historical arguments for the bodily Assumption of Mary?
- 36:17 – If Jesus died once for all sin, why does the Church continue to offer the Sacrifice of the Mass?
- 45:03 – Is God calling all Christians to enter into full communion with the Catholic Church?
- 49:05 – Why is the Precious Blood of Christ sometimes withheld from the laity during Communion?
How can Catholics respond to Sedevacantist claims and Jehovah’s Witness interpretations of Scripture? Why does the Bishop of Rome hold primacy over the Bishop of Antioch? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we tackle these challenging apologetics questions, explore how to clearly defend the Catholic doctrine of the Trinity, and offer strategies for helping LGBT youth remain connected to the Church. We also discuss the spiritual significance of choosing a saint’s name at Confirmation and how to distinguish authentic Magisterial teaching from personal theological opinion.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:21 – How should one approach an apologetic conversation with someone who holds a Sedevacantist position?
- 08:24 – Why doesn’t the Bishop of Antioch hold the same authority as the Bishop of Rome?
- 15:39 – How can the Catholic interpretation of Ecclesiastes 9:5 be explained in response to Jehovah’s Witnesses?
- 24:19 – How can the Catholic doctrine of the Trinity be clearly defended?
- 42:53 – What can be done to help prevent LGBT youth from leaving the Catholic Church?
- 48:37 – What is the significance of taking a saint’s name at Confirmation, and how does it relate to the saint?
- 51:26 – How can Catholics distinguish between teachings of the Magisterium and personal theological opinions?
What does Scripture say about Mary’s perpetual virginity and sinlessness? Is an annulment needed if a spouse dies after a civil divorce? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we explore these and other challenging questions about Catholic teaching and Scripture. Discover the meaning behind Jesus’ command to “take up your cross,” learn how to recognize mortal sin before receiving Communion, and understand the Church’s view on praying for those who die by suicide. We also discuss key Church Fathers to reference in conversations with Calvinists and explore the importance of forgiveness in light of Matthew 5:21–26.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:05 – Where in Scripture can the doctrines of Mary’s perpetual virginity and sinlessness be found or supported?
- 20:26 – If a person’s spouse dies after a civil divorce, is an annulment still required for the surviving party?
- 22:24 – When Jesus says, “Take up your cross and follow me,” was this a known expression at the time, or only understood after the Crucifixion?
- 29:20 – Which Church Fathers are most effective to reference in discussions with Calvinists?
- 42:24 – Is it worthwhile to pray for someone who died by suicide?
- 47:11 – How can someone know they are free of mortal sin before receiving Holy Communion?
- 50:16 – What does the Catholic Church teach about the need to forgive as emphasized in Matthew 5:21–26?
What do the sermons in Acts reveal about the early Church’s belief in the Resurrection? Where was Tabitha before her resurrection in Acts 9:40? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we explore deep theological questions about Christ’s human nature during His death, how to explain Original Sin to students, and what good—if any—can come from eternal suffering in Hell. We also address how to explain the mystery of the Trinity to someone from a Latter-day Saints background.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:06 – Do the sermons in the Book of Acts offer early references to the Resurrection similar to the creedal formulations in Corinthians?
- 12:26 – In Acts 9:40, where was Tabitha before her resurrection? Could it have been Limbo, Purgatory, or another state?
- 17:12 – During the time Christ was dead, was His human nature still united to the Second Person of the Trinity? If so, how is that explained?
- 22:59 – What are effective ways to explain Original Sin to students who struggle to understand the concept?
- 37:12 – If God allows suffering to bring about some good, what possible good can come from the eternal suffering of souls in Hell?
- 45:55 – How can the doctrine of the Trinity be explained to someone from the Latter-day Saints tradition who wants to understand it?
Can Catholics attend 12-step recovery programs? Are we less spiritually zealous today than the early Church? What’s the proper posture for laity during the Our Father at Mass? And how do ancient texts like the Book of Jubilees align with Catholic tradition on Adam’s burial? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we dive into these thoughtful questions from listeners across the country. Discover what the Church teaches about appropriate behavior during Mass, explore how Catholic spirituality has changed over time, and examine intriguing connections between biblical traditions and apocryphal writings.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:08 – Is it appropriate for a Catholic to attend 12-step recovery programs?
- 20:57 – Compared to the early Church and the saints, have modern Catholics lost some of their spiritual fervor?
- 29:07 – Are laypeople supposed to raise their hands during the Our Father at Mass? Is there a resource that explains what’s appropriate for the laity?
- 46:30 – The Book of Jubilees says Adam was buried next to his son and had a proper funeral. How does this relate to the tradition that Adam’s skull is buried under Calvary?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, listeners ask deep and thought-provoking questions about Scripture, the sacraments, and God’s love. Why is exact language so essential when administering the sacraments? How can we dispose ourselves to receive God’s love rather than trying to earn it? We also explore the powerful Old Testament moment when Jacob wrestles with the angel—what does it mean, and why is it significant? Join us for a rich conversation that blends theology, spiritual insight, and biblical understanding, helping Catholics and seekers alike grow in knowledge and faith.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 17:21 – Why is precise language necessary in the valid and effective administration of the sacraments?
- 29:39 – How can a person open themselves to receiving God’s love rather than trying to earn it?
- 50:20 – What is the theological and spiritual significance of Jacob wrestling with the angel in Scripture?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, guest Alex Jurado from “Voice of Reason” tackles thoughtful and challenging questions from callers exploring Catholic teaching and doctrine. Topics include the true meaning of the word anathema, biblical support for confession to a priest, and how to explain the seal of confession in difficult moral situations. Alex also addresses concerns about biblical contradictions, the authority of the Magisterium, and how to interpret Matthew 16:18 in Protestant-Catholic dialogue. Listeners ask about papal authority in light of the Pope Vigilius controversy, proper church etiquette for seekers, and what the Church means by salvation through “faith working through love.”
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:41 – What is the correct meaning of the term anathema, and how can misunderstandings about it be addressed in conversation?
- 11:55 – Where does the Bible support the practice of confessing sins to a priest?
- 17:10 – How can the Catholic teaching on the seal of confession be explained to those who find it troubling, especially in serious moral cases?
- 23:39 – In John 7:8–10, does Jesus contradict Himself? How should this passage be understood?
- 28:50 – How can someone considering Catholicism come to trust the authority of the Magisterium?
- 31:51 – How can Catholics respond when Protestants interpret Matthew 16:18 as referring only to the invisible Church?
- 35:54 – How does the controversy surrounding Pope Vigilius and the Three Chapters not contradict the doctrine of Papal Supremacy?
- 44:40 – For someone exploring Christianity, what is appropriate attire for attending Church, and when is it acceptable to enter a church to pray?
- 49:42 – What does the Catholic Church mean by salvation through “faith working through love,” especially for someone transitioning from Islam to Christianity?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Cy Kellett is joined by Catholic apologist Joe Heschmeyer and Catholic Answers President Chris Check to unpack what’s fueling a renewed interest in Catholicism today. From cultural instability and gender confusion to the peace and stability found in the sacramental life, they explore why more people—especially young men—are finding their way to the Catholic Church. They discuss the popular Shameless Popery podcast, a surprising CNN episode titled “Catholicism Is So Hot Right Now,” and how truth, tradition, and meaning are attracting a new generation of seekers.
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, join Cy Kellett, Chris Check, and Joe Heschmeyer for the always-entertaining “Flannel Panel,” where they dive into world events and moral issues through a Catholic lens. Topics include the ethics of war, the phrase “unconditional surrender,” nuclear weapons, and how Catholic just war teaching applies to modern conflicts. They also discuss the sonic boom from a recent SpaceX rocket launch, the moral challenges of technology, and reflections on recent Supreme Court decisions.
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Karlo Broussard answers a range of insightful questions about Scripture, Church teaching, and Catholic doctrine. He explains how Matthew 25 supports the Catholic view that good works are essential for salvation, addresses why the Church typically welcomes converts at the Easter Vigil, and points to biblical evidence for purgatory. Karlo also clarifies how annulments work, discusses the value of formal theological study versus self-education, and offers guidance on teaching the origins of Adam and Eve alongside Church teaching on evolution. Finally, he shares the Catholic perspective on the teachings of John MacArthur.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
01:49 – How does Matthew 25 support the Catholic view that good works play a role in salvation, in contrast to the Protestant view of faith alone?
12:30 – Why does the Catholic Church typically receive converts during one specific time of the year, such as at the Easter Vigil?
17:54 – Where can the doctrine of purgatory be found in Scripture?
31:02 – When an annulment is granted by the Church, is it effective immediately or does it apply retroactively to the original marriage date?
37:03 – For someone deepening their faith later in life, is it better to pursue formal theological education or engage in structured self-study?
44:10 – What is the Church’s teaching on the origins of Adam and Eve and how can it be effectively taught alongside the theory of evolution?
52:07 – What is the Catholic Church’s perspective on the teachings of Protestant pastor John MacArthur?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Karlo Broussard answers questions on Catholic doctrine, Church history, and theological distinctions. Why does the Church teach the difference between mortal and venial sin? What is the Catholic response to the idea of ordaining women in the Eastern Orthodox Church? Karlo also clarifies the requirements for conditional baptism and confirmation, explores the similarities and differences between Catholic and Lutheran views on justification, and discusses the traditional order of the sacraments in the Latin Rite. Plus, learn how the early Church understood purgatory and when belief in it began to fade.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 00:59 – Why does the Catholic Church teach the distinction between mortal and venial sin?
- 16:43 – If the Eastern Orthodox Church were to ordain women, would such ordinations be considered sacramentally valid?
- 21:49 – What are the conditions under which conditional baptism or confirmation may be granted, and why might one be approved while the other is not?
- 31:56 – What are the key differences and similarities between the Catholic and Lutheran views on justification? Are they closer than commonly believed?
- 46:45 – Is there any movement within the Latin Rite to restore the traditional sacramental order—Baptism, Confirmation, then Eucharist—especially for infants?
- 51:43 – When and why did belief in purgatory begin to decline, and how was it understood in the early Church?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Dr. Matthew Bunson of EWTN joins us to discuss the historic election of Pope Leo XIV—the first American Pope. Dr. Bunson shares behind-the-scenes insights from his front-row seat at the Vatican during the conclave, including the dramatic moment white smoke signaled a new pontiff. Learn how the voting process unfolded, why the election moved faster than expected, and how the Church and media reacted. Dr. Bunson also discusses his new book, Pope Leo XIV: Portrait of the First American Pope, published by EWTN Publishing. From spiritual significance to journalistic intensity, this episode captures a powerful moment in Church history as experienced by a leading Catholic voice.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Fr. Paul Keller joins us to tackle a wide range of questions from Catholics seeking clarity and guidance. Can saints in Heaven and souls in purgatory communicate with us on earth? What can someone do to help a loved one return to the Catholic faith? For those new to the Church, Fr. Keller explains what to expect during Eucharistic adoration and how to participate with reverence. We also explore whether assurance of salvation is possible, especially during life’s trials. What does it mean that the Holy Spirit “proceeds from the Father and the Son”? How can one support a vocation to the priesthood?
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
09:19 – What are the spiritual capabilities of the saints in Heaven and the souls in purgatory when it comes to communicating with people on earth?
20:31 – What guidance can be given to someone who wants to support a loved one in returning to active participation in the Catholic faith?
28:55 – What should someone new to the Church know about Eucharistic adoration—what to do during it, and any particular postures or gestures to observe?
34:13 – Can a person have any assurance of salvation, especially when facing life’s hardships and uncertainties?
42:49 – What does the phrase “proceeds from the Father and the Son” mean in the context of the Holy Spirit as stated in the Nicene Creed?
48:55 – How can someone support and encourage a family member who is discerning a vocation to the priesthood?
52:19 – What is meant by the term “Catholic guilt,” and how should it be understood within the context of the faith?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we explore key questions about Catholic doctrine and Scripture. Topics include the Church’s teaching on Purgatory, the meaning of “under the earth” in Scripture, and Pope St. John Paul II’s quote on free will and the greater good. Jimmy discusses who the Church Fathers are and how to read them, how doctrinal development fits with the end of public revelation, and biblical support for the resurrection of the dead and Christ’s second coming. He also addresses whether a priest can deny communion to someone kneeling and whether baptism removes both sin and attachment to sin.Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click HereInvite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.comQuestions Covered:03:00 – What is the Catholic teaching on Purgatory, and is there a “middle space” between Heaven and Hell for souls?12:52 – In the verse “every knee shall bend… under the earth,” what does “under the earth” refer to—could it mean Hell?20:49 – How should one understand Pope St. John Paul II’s quote: “The greater good is maintained when someone uses his freedom wrongly than when he is forced to do what is good”?28:45 – Who are the Church Fathers, and how can someone begin reading them alongside Scripture for deeper understanding?32:30 – How can the Church’s claim that public revelation has ceased be reconciled with the idea that doctrine continues to develop?41:58 – What Bible verses support the Catholic teachings on the resurrection of the dead and the second coming of Christ?49:26 – Is it within a priest’s authority to deny communion to someone who chooses to receive kneeling?52:51 – Does the sacrament of baptism remove not only sin but also attachment to sin?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Jimmy Akin and Cy discuss what someone in the annulment process must do before entering the Church through OCIA, and examine how Sola Scriptura and a priori syllogisms relate to Anglican apologetics. They explore how to discern messages from angels, and whether Spock’s sacrifice in Star Trek reflects John 15:13. Other questions include whether Martin Luther sought self-justification, and how to respond to criticisms of Catholic parish events like gambling nights.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
05:15 – What must someone do regarding their current marriage if they are in the annulment process, remarried, and preparing to enter the Church through OCIA?
15:25 – How does Sola Scriptura relate to a priori syllogisms in the context of Anglican apologetics?
23:07 – What is the proper way to discern signs and messages from angels according to Catholic teaching?
35:10 – In Star Trek, Spock sacrifices his life for Captain Pike. Is this an example of John 15:13 in action?
40:38 – Was Martin Luther ultimately motivated by a desire for self-justification?
47:49 – How should Catholics respond to criticism about past parish events like gambling or casino nights being seen as hypocritical?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Tim Staples answers questions about Catholic teaching and practice. Topics include the Church’s position on dividing ashes, relics, and organ donation, and the meaning of a line from the “Golden Arrow” prayer. A caller asks why some OCIA participants still struggle with Marian dogmas. We also explore whether Jesus had a middle or last name, what to do during Eucharistic adoration if the fire alarm goes off, and whether downloading copyrighted material is morally acceptable. Finally, he explains the Church’s view of The Mystical City of God by Mary of Ágreda.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
3:29 – What is the Church’s teaching on the dividing up and spreading of ashes as to the distribution of relics or organ donation?
19:44 – The “Golden Arrow” prayer has a line spoken from the Lord, which states, “Be careful to utilize this grace because I demand an account of it from you.” What is meant by this?
29:40 – My friend completed OCIA and still will not accept Marian dogmas.
40:35 – Did Jesus have a middle and last name?
43:44 – What to do during adoration if the fire alarm sounds?
45:29 – Is copyright morally binding. If I find a pdf / video / music online but cannot find it anywhere else, can I download it?
51:20 – Is the book Mystical City of God by Mary Jesus of Agreda Catholic?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Adrian Lawson from the YouTube channel Sips with Serra, joins CY to discuss the growing appeal of the Catholic Church among young people—has the Church changed, or has the culture shifted? A caller enrolled in OCIA asks why we receive the Eucharist by eating it, and how that connects us to Christ’s sacrifice. They also address the Eucharistic Congress and recent protests surrounding it, offering a Catholic perspective on public witness and reverence for the Blessed Sacrament.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
30:19 – What has changed to make the Catholic Church more appealing to young people? Has the church changed or American culture?
34:23 – I’m signed up for OCIA, and I am curious to why we eat the Eucharist as the mode of receiving and participating in Christ’s sacrifice?
47:10 – What are your thoughts on the Eucharistic congress and the disruptive protesters following it?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we explore faith-based approaches to addiction and healing with Scott Weeman, founder of, Catholics in Recovery. Listeners ask how to find Catholic support groups, whether addiction to spending money can destroy relationships, and if those with mental health diagnoses like schizoaffective disorder can benefit from Catholic recovery programs. We also discuss the role of the sacraments in healing, how to balance recovery with public speaking, and how to reach a college-age son struggling with marijuana use. Discover real-life stories of healing and how Catholics in Recovery supports those battling addiction through Catholic teaching and community.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
09:06 – I’ve been battling many addictions for decades. I’ve been desperate to find a Catholic support group. I’m in a group that is celebrating pride month so it’s not really for me. How can I get plugged in to Catholic in Recovery?
15:51 – Do you see a problem in addiction to spending money? In my opinion an addiction to money ruined my first marriage.
21:20 – I had traumas in relationships at age 17. Now I’m 64 and I’ve been diagnosed with schizoaffective disorder. I’m being treated but not sure it’s enough. Could Catholic in Recovery have something for me?
29:04 – I came back to the Church last December and I’ve been in AA for years. This is the first time I’ve heard of Catholic in Recovery. Can you tell me more about it?
37:02 – How does someone get involved in Catholic in Recovery? I’ve been sober for a year and God has healed me so much through the sacraments.
43:26 – How do you manage your recovery and public speaking? I know that one of the AA principles is not speaking on behalf of AA. I’ve done public speaking and I’ve also crashed horribly in addiction.
51:29 – My son is into smoking marijuana. He gets very angry and will not listen. Any advice on how we try to reach him? He is a junior in college and lives with us.
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Joe Heschmeyer discusses a wide range of questions on Catholic doctrine and apologetics. Topics include: when salvation occurs in the case of baptism of desire, the difference between sacrifices due to God and those made for others, and how to respond to Protestants who claim unity isn’t needed if we all share the fruits of the Spirit. Joe also addresses how to explain the word “Catholic” in the Apostles’ Creed to non-Catholics, whether Muslims worship the same God as Christians, biblical evidence for Mary’s perpetual virginity, and how to counter gnostic-sounding claims about sin being “in the body.”
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
08:58 – In the case of baptism of desire, when is the person saved?
17:57 – What type of sacrifice is due to God alone? As opposed to the type of sacrifices we make for others.
29:02 – If Protestants have fruits of the Spirit, some see that as a deterrent to unity (why seek unity when we all have fruits of the Spirit). How do we respond to that?
34:21 – My parents are Presbyterian. They see the word “Catholic” in the apostles’ creed and say that since Catholic means universal it’s simply referring to all the churches. How do we respond to that?
38:25 – The CCC says Muslims worship the same God as Abraham. How do we understand that since Muslims don’t think they worship the same God as us?
44:12 – Where in the Bible can we find Mary’s perpetual virginity?
51:25 – My friend thinks that sin is “in” the body. So when we die we don’t have sin because we don’t have our body. To me that sounds like gnosticism, but he doesn’t think it is. How can I respond to him?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Karlo Broussard answers the questions: Why must Mary have been Immaculately Conceived—couldn’t Jesus have been born of a sinner? How does addiction affect the conditions for mortal sin? Karlo discusses the Church’s teaching on free will, grave matter, and culpability. He also addresses the claim of annihilationism—does the Bible really support eternal punishment in hell? Plus, is it accurate to call non-Catholics “Christians,” or should we still use the term “heretics”?
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
12:08 – Why do we say that Mary “must have” been Immaculately conceived? It seems like Jesus could have been born from someone even if they had original sin.
17:00 – How do the three conditions for mortal sin relate to the area of addiction? Can the consent of the will be lessened by an addiction?
29:47 – What is real factual evidence that annihilationism is false, and wrong to believe?
39:23 – I struggle with calling non-Catholics Christians. It doesn’t seem to fit with the old style of calling them heretics.
47:12 – My protestant friend has trouble with the idea of praying to the dead. When did the practice begin? And is it in the New Testament?
51:37 – Where in the Bible does it teach against contraception?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Karlo Broussard tackles tough questions from converts and curious Protestants. Can Protestants receive the gifts of the Holy Spirit if they haven’t received the sacrament of Confirmation? What does the Church teach about Mary as Queen of Heaven—and is it essential to salvation? Karlo also responds to the common claim that the intercession of saints was borrowed from Greco-Roman paganism. Finally, are indulgences still a part of Catholic practice today, or are they just a relic of the past?
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
15:40 – In my OCIA class they told me that the gifts of the Holy Spirit are received at Confirmation. If that is true, then it would follow that no Protestants receive gifts of the Holy Spirit. But that doesn’t seem right.
34:00 – I’m a recent convert and I struggle with Mary being queen of heaven. It just doesn’t seem relevant to my salvation.
37:12 – My Protestant friend says the idea of intercession of saints was influenced by Greco-roman pagan ideas. How can I answer him?
45:48 – Are indulgences still a Catholic practice?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, guest Jason Evert discusses healing after past relationships, struggling with chastity, lust in marriage, and talking to family about same-sex issues.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
14:23 – Any advice for someone who is living a chaste life but still has attachments from previous relationships before conversion?
22:48 – At what point do you tell your significant other that you struggle with chastity?
33:44 – Can a married couple lust for each other?
41:50 – I have four granddaughters that are now young women. One of them has a girlfriend. I think I’m the only person in her life telling her this is wrong. She is open to talking to me about it. What can I tell her, or what information can I send her?
50:36 – How does one clear one’s mind from impure images seen in the past?
Can your temperament shape your spiritual life? In this episode we explore how natural disposition, trauma, and personality types affect prayer, change over time, and whether they’re at odds with providence. Also—can you be a composite temperament?
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
16:56 – Would my temperament have effect on my trouble with keeping focus on prayer life
30:34 – Can we have a composite of our temperaments?
42:33 – Can your temperament change during the course of your life?
49:40 – How do we square the idea of a temperament being “happy-go-lucky” with providence, when as Catholics we do not believe in luck?
52:37 – Is it possible to have early childhood trauma that shapes and forms your temperament?
In this episode of Weird Questions with Jimmy Akin, we start with a surprisingly common theological puzzle: Why didn’t Jesus Himself write anything down—like a Gospel? We explore what this reveals about Jesus’ mission, oral tradition, and how the Church transmits truth.
Help support the work we do by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:15 – Why is there no gospel according to Jesus, or, why is there nothing written attributed to Jesus?
- 13:47 – Could there be aliens (intelligent species from a distant planet) enjoying eternal life in heaven?
- If there are intelligent aliens living on other planets, do they have guardian angels?
- 17:18 – Do dogs remember their previous experiences? I have a foster dog that was rescued from a hoarding situation. Now he is safe and well cared for, but I worry that he remembers being hungry and lost.
- 23:32 – Could there be an alternate universe/dimension where 2 + 2 =5? Is that a mathematical truth that only applies to our universe?
- 28:41 – I suspect I know the answer, but: in some fantasy-genre systems of magic (in particular, I’m thinking of the works of Tamora Pierce, which are aimed at young girls), magic is described as natural-born talent which involves being able to engage your personal energy to achieve desired results like healing, transfiguration, etc… It is specifically mentioned that only some humans can do this, and the ability is from birth, so no involvement of demons or other supernatural figures. Of course this talent can be used for evil, like anything else. If, however, magic like this was a God-given talent, would it be licit to use this talent for things like healing on recognition that this is God working through you?
- 40:44 – Did Moses eat mushrooms and hallucinated the burning bush?
- 45:14 – Would it be a formal apostasy, heresy, or schism to profess belief in a multiverse and/or simulation hypothesis where an alternate reality exists in which the substance of our Divine Revelation either never happened or happened in an opposite way or where our dogmatic facts & moral laws do not apply or apply in the reverse?
- 52:18 – If we are living in a simulation with our physical bodies suspended in a hibernation capsule in the base reality, would our sacraments be valid? What if some of us are A.I. characters within the simulation and just don’t know it, do we still have a soul
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we explore a fascinating Gospel mystery: When Jesus began His public ministry, did anyone recognize Him as the same child who once astonished the elders in the Temple? We dig into Scripture and tradition to consider whether that moment left a lasting impression—and why the Gospels remain silent on this point.
Help support the work we do by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:45 – I hope this email finds you well. I’m a longtime admirer of your work in Catholic apologetics and your thoughtful approach to complex questions. I have a hypothetical theological question inspired by the movie Groundhog Day that I’d love to hear your perspective on. In the film, Phil Connors is trapped in a time loop, reliving February 2nd repeatedly, with only his memory carrying over each day. From a Catholic perspective, if someone in a real-life time loop committed sins during earlier iterations of the loop, but then they broke the cycle, waking up on February 3rd, would they need to confess the sins from the previous loops? Since the loop resets the world and only the person remembers their actions, do those sins carry moral or sacramental weight after the loop ends?
- 12:18 – Hi, I am a mega fan of Jimmy Akin’s Mysterious World, I am fourteen and I have a weird question for you. First, in Lord of the Rings, how culpable are people for mortal sin when they wear the One Ring? I am asking because it is possible to ignore the temptation of the Ring.
- 20:20 – My second question is does the Holy Spirit guide other sects of the Catholic church such as Greek Orthodox or the Coptic? Keep the great work up, and it would make my day if you answer my questions on weird questions with Jimmy Akin.
- 22:28 – Is the website created by soon to be canonized Bl. Carlos Acutis a relic? For that matter, are the writings of Saints, whether in written or digital form, relics?
- 28:45 – Studies show that everyone likely has at least one doppelgänger. Could it be when we make life altering decisions, that a doppelgänger is actually split from us and onto a separate timeline? Like, for example, what if a doppelgänger of me actually stayed with that guy I dated and is now living the life I would have led had I not dumped him?
- 35:15 – Everyone seems to believe aliens, if they exist, must be strange and non-human like. But, isn’t it possible that life on another earth like planet could mirror ours? And, if so, what if the mysterious Man from Taured was actually an alien human from another earth like planet?
- 46:30 – Could Melchizedek have been a Zoroastrian?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we explore a fascinating Gospel mystery: When Jesus began His public ministry, did anyone recognize Him as the same child who once astonished the elders in the Temple? We dig into Scripture and tradition to consider whether that moment left a lasting impression—and why the Gospels remain silent on this point.
Help support the work we do by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:06 – Did Jesus change when he was incarnated?
- 18:54 – I married a convert but was married under the conduction that he would receive the rest of his sacraments after marriage. He hasn’t done it. Am I sinning by going to communion since he hasn’t fulfilled that?
- 24:13 – Can you expound on Mary being the new Eve?
- 36:53 – Is there any indication that anybody recognizes the adult Jesus as the child who impressed the elders at the temple when his parents lost him?
- 45:18 – Why isn’t it required that the Church give you the option to receive under both species?
In this intellectually rich episode of Catholic Answers Live, we explore a key theological difference between East and West: How can man be united with God if God’s energies are uncreated and eternal? We examine the Catholic understanding of divinization (theosis), grace, and the beatific vision—and how these differ from the Orthodox view of God’s “energies.”
Help support the work we do by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:42 – Did priestly celibacy start because the Church did not want the families to inherit money and property? How do I refute that claim from a protestant?
- 11:07 – How can I help convince parents to allow their children to attend youth groups? They are hesitant because there are students who attend who have same-sex attraction.
- 17:33 – I had a Catholic family member who recently passed away. I’m not Catholic. How do I properly ask the intercession of saints for this person’s soul?
- 23:55 – According to the western view, how can man be united with God if God’s energies are uncreated and eternal?
- 34:24 – I’m a Protestant chaplain. What is the Church’s opinion of me offering the lourdes supper to Catholics?
- 44:51 – Weren’t Peter and the other apostles married? Would this nullify your claim on priestly celibacy?
- 49:22 – Would a confession be acceptable for a plenary indulgence if I go a week before fulfilling the rest of the criteria?
- 51:37 – Do the Orthodox believe that the laity can invalidate councils? How can I use that information apologetically?
Orthodox vs. Anglican communion, pro-life ethics, voting dilemmas, spiritual encounters, and New Testament objections—Catholic answers to tough questions.
Help support the work we do by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 00:15 – Content creator highlight: The Religious Hippie
- 19:54 – Why would we be able to receive communion in some circumstances at an Orthodox church but not at an Anglican Church?
- 28:50 – If we are not allowed to choose between the life of the mother vs the baby in the pro-life debate, why do some Catholic circles say when you do have to decide, the life of the mother supersedes the life of the baby?
- 33:41 – Hypothetical: If you were voting between 2 candidates, one was causing physical harm and the other spiritual harm, how should one vote?
- 39:42 – How do we respond to the secular arguments against the New Testament?
- 45:32 – What does the Church have to say if we sense a family member who has passed away is trying to reach out to us?
- 49:24 – How do I help guide my Catholic aunt who goes to a Lutheran church and believes she’s receiving the real presence?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we tackle one of the most intriguing questions about the Bible’s development: If the disciples and early Christians referenced the Book of Enoch, why isn’t it part of the biblical canon? We explore the Church’s criteria for canonization, Enoch’s influence, and why it ultimately didn’t make the cut.
Help support the work we do by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:51 – Why was Enoch not considered canon if the disciples referenced it?
- 14:25 – Why is confession to a priest necessary?
- 21:17 – Who is St. Mary Salome? Was she the Blessed Mother’s sister?
- 25:07 – Why is the penalty of sin, death? It seems so harsh.
- 33:55 – Rather than having a Catholic funeral Is having a mortuary service burial, okay?
- 35:32 – Is there any truth to the rumor that the baptism formula was in Jesus name early on?
- 40:30 – What would be the implications of a person without a soul?
- 44:45 – Could a Catholic accept Jesus as the new Isaac and Peter as the new Abraham as an explanation of Mt. 16:18-19?
- 49:17 – My husband is interested in Catholicism. He asked: 1 Peter 2:25 Why is the word bishop replaced to overseer in some versions?
In this heartfelt episode of Catholic Answers Live, we address one of the most difficult situations a Catholic can face: What if your spouse is resistant—or even hostile—to the idea of conversion? We offer practical and pastoral advice on how to approach this conversation with patience, love, and truth, without pushing them away.
Help support the work we do by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:17 – How does the soul know whether it’s in heaven, hell or purgatory?
- 12:49 – How do I bring up the conversation about converting to a spouse who is not friendly to Catholicism?
- 20:01 – Why don’t we hear about the intercession of the Old Testament saints?
- 23:34 – Can a person be in good standing with the Church and be an annihilationist?
- 33:41 – How can I have a more genuine relationship with Jesus?
- 37:20 – Why are the eastern right patriarchs not named cardinals?
- 41:34 – Why do Catholics do Eucharistic adoration but other churches like the Orthodox don’t?
- 45:29 – What was the purpose of the dream of Pilot’s wife, Claudia?
- 51:05 – I don’t think belief in annihilationism jeopardizes being in good standing with the Church. JRR Tolkien would agree with me. Can you clarify your thoughts?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we tackle one of the most persistent Protestant arguments against the Catholic canon: Did St. Jerome actually reject the Deuterocanonical books? Some claim he supported a 66-book Bible—so what’s the truth? We unpack what Jerome really believed, what he said about the Septuagint, and how his writings have been misused.
Help support the work we do by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 14:05 – How do we respond to protestants that will use St. Jerome to support their 66 book canon?
- 24:37 – What are the differences between the Greek, and Russian Orthodox churches and why do they disagree so much?
- 31:13 – Who was the author that helped write Hebrews?
- 34:22 – How does the Church judge when one is really inspired?
- 43:34 – Was Mark plagiarized from Luke and Matthew?
In one of the most compassionate and powerful episodes of Catholic Answers Live, we take on difficult but crucial questions about mental health, suicide, guilt, and healing from a Catholic perspective.
Help us reach our goal by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 20:16 – What can I do for my son who has Autism and recently tried to take his own life? How can I support him?
- 24:46 – What will it take for mental health to catch up to actually treating people, especially those considering suicide?
- 40:57 – I’m new to the faith and my friend who helped me come to the faith has been struggling mentally so much lately. How can I be a support for him?
- 45:19 – We tend to feel guilt after we sin, but do we get out of the constant dwelling of that guilt?
- 47:48 – Where do you feel the Eucharist fits into mental health and healing?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we tackle a wide range of thought-provoking questions from callers seeking clarity on Catholic teaching and practice. The highlight question: Can a Catholic date a non-denominational Christian—and make it work spiritually and relationally? Steve Ray offers pastoral wisdom and theological insight into navigating interdenominational dating with truth and charity.
Help us reach our goal by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 14:02 – How do I defend our claim that the woman in Revelation 12 is Mary?
- 18:21 – Can the saints return to earth in spirit, and can they audibly communicate with us?
- 29:51 – How do I get over past hurts and addictions?
- 33:27 – What advice can you offer me? I’m Catholic dating a non-denominational girl.
- 36:20 – Why are we not supposed to wear hats when praying? When did that tradition start?
- 41:21 – My grandmother has bought into the prosperity gospel. What advice do you have for approaching her?
- 48:16 – How do I help my Protestant friend trust in the Church’s authority to interpret scripture?
- 53:48 – You mentioned a great book on the geography of the holy land. What is the name of it?
Did the Catholic Church ever teach reincarnation? Some claim early Christians believed in it, but what does history actually say? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we examine the origins of this myth, what the Church Fathers believed, and how Catholic doctrine on the soul and resurrection firmly rejects reincarnation. Karlo Broussard sets the record straight with clarity and charity.
Help us reach our goal by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:32 – If Joseph had a home in Bethlehem, why would he need to find a place to stay?
- 11:17 – Is it true that at one point the Church taught reincarnation?
- 14:58 – What is the new Jerusalem and the new heaven in Rev. 21?
- 20:20 – What are your thoughts about pursuing a career in the Church? What jobs with a theology degree do you think are out there where one could raise a family?
- 23:34 – Was Mark 16:9-20 originally part of the canon?
- 35:57 – Since DNA is all different, will there be a point when DNA sequences will start repeating, if this happens will it be the end time?
- 39:15 – How does one self-verify visions that one experiences?
- 45:30 – What is the bottom line on demons?
Can a Catholic be personally opposed to abortion but still believe it shouldn’t be criminalized? In this segment of Catholic Answers Live, we tackle the tough intersection of morality, law, and Church teaching. Karlo Broussard explores what it means to be a Catholic in good standing, how the Church views the legal protection of human life, and where the line is drawn when it comes to public policy. A must-watch for anyone navigating pro-life convictions in a political world.
Help us reach our goal by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:50 – Dr. Bergsma proposed that the events of Holy Week were originally different than we thought. He says the last supper might have been on Tuesday. What are your thoughts on this?
- 07:55 – Why is the conclave kept in secrecy?
- 15:40 – 1 Chronicles references other books like Chronicles of Nathan and Chronicles Gad the Seer. What do we know about them, and can we read them?
- 16:00 – Where do we get the idea of purgatory other than Maccabees?
- 29:15 – What constitutes grave matter?
- 33:35 – Is it possible for a protestant to bring communion to a person who is homebound?
- 40:56 – My mom is Protestant. What is the best way to evangelize Protestants?
- 45:33 – Where is the line between invincible ignorance and universalism?
- 50:39 – Can I be a Catholic in good standing if I personally oppose abortion but also don’t think the government should criminalize it?
In this special Catholic Answers Live episode, Cy Kellett interviews Dr. Jacob Imam—convert from Islam, founder of New Polity and the College of St. Joseph the Worker. They discuss Catholic education, political renewal, and building institutions rooted in Catholic social teaching.
To watch the entire episode visit the Cy Kellett Show YouTube Channel
Please support our mission by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
In this inaugural episode of the Cy Kellett show, Cy sits down with Nick Madden of Sent Ventures and Red Door Escape Rooms to discuss how to direct ethical, Catholic companies in our world today.
To watch the entire episode visit the Cy Kellett Show YouTube Channel
Please support our mission by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Topics Covered:
00:00 Intro
01:50 Red Door Escape Rooms
07:43 Thinking Creatively About Business
11:00 Harvard Almost Broke My Faith
23:50 Encountering the Person of Jesus
29:50 Temptations in Running a Business
38:40 The Workplace is The New Evangelization
43:50 Connecting Catholic Businesses with Sent Ventures
52:50 Being a Witness to the Faith in Your Workplace
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Karlo Broussard goes beyond proving that the saints in heaven are aware of our prayers—he tackles the deeper question: Should we actually invoke them? Karlo answers key Protestant objections such as the absence of early Christian practices, claims of necromancy or idolatry, and the charge that saints would need to be omniscient to hear so many prayers. With Scripture, Church history, and careful reasoning, Karlo shows why invoking the saints is not only legitimate but spiritually powerful—and not a substitute for going directly to Jesus, but a biblical expression of the communion of saints.Help us reach our goal by donating! Catholicanswersradio.comJoin The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click HereInvite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.comQuestions Covered:03:48 – Even if I concede that Revelation 5:8 proves the Christians in heaven are aware of our specific requests and intercede for us on account of those requests, it doesn’t give us any sort of instruction to invoke them. Therefore, we shouldn’t do it. 17:40 – Maybe we don’t need an explicit instruction to invoke the saints. But you’d think that if it were appropriate to ask the saints to pray for us, then at least we’d have some examples of the first century Christians doing this. Since we don’t, we shouldn’t invoke the saints. 22:16 – But Karlo, we don’t have any evidence of Christians invoking the saints’ intercession for the first two hundred years plus of Christianity. The earliest evidence we have is the mid third century. Since this belief and practice is a historical accretion, we shouldn’t engage in it. 28:30 – Perhaps the lack of evidence for Christians invoking the saints in the New Testament and the first two hundred years is because Christians believed it was wrong to communicate with the dead, given that Deuteronomy 18:12 forbids necromancy and calls it an “abomination to the Lord. 35:40 – Let’s say I agree that the invocation of the saints isn’t necromancy. But we still ought not to do it because it’s idolatrous. Don’t Catholics say, “we pray to the saints”? Prayer is something that we offer to God alone. 42:00 – It still seems that Catholics make “gods” out of the saints because by invoking them you’re implying that they can do only what God can do—namely, know the hearts of men. 2 Chronicles 6:30 says, “God alone knows the hearts of men. 44:58 – Okay, maybe God can give some knowledge to the saints. But the amount of knowledge involved with the Catholic belief and practice would require omniscience. How could Mary hear 8 billion prayer requests, say, at the same time? She’d have to be God to do that. 48:50 – Maybe there’s nothing wrong with invoking the saints in principle. But because it has led to so many abuses and violations of the Gospel that we should not do it. 52:45 – Practically speaking. Why would I invoke the saints when I can just go straight to Jesus?
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Karlo Broussard tackles one of the most common objections to Catholic teaching: If Jesus is the “one mediator” between God and man, why ask Mary and the saints to intercede for us? Drawing from 1 Timothy 2:5, Ecclesiastes 9:5, and Revelation 5:8, Karlo addresses Protestant concerns about the awareness and intercessory role of the saints in heaven. He explains what the Bible really says about heavenly mediation, the beatific vision, and whether the saints are aware of and respond to our prayers. Along the way, he refutes key counterarguments and clarifies Catholic teaching with clarity and Scripture.Please support our mission by donating! Catholicanswersradio.comJoin The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click HereInvite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.comQuestions Covered:13:50 – You ask Mary and the saints to intercede for you. But doesn’t Paul say in 1 Timothy 2:5 that Jesus is our one mediator? 19:20 – If Paul isn’t denying mutual Christian intercession (whether that’s between us here on earth or the saints in heaven and us), then what does he mean by “one mediator”? 21:57 – It’s true that the Bible says we can pray for each other. But the Christians in heaven have died. They aren’t aware of what’s going on here on earth. Ecclesiastes 9:5 says, ‘the dead know nothing.’ So, your requests are futile. 33:23 – Okay, you say that it’s at least possible the saints in heaven could know what’s going on here on earth in virtue of the beatific vision, which the saints in the afterlife before Christ’s ascension didn’t have. But is there any biblical evidence that the saints in heaven in fact are aware of what’s going on here on earth? 36:00 – Okay, so you’ve shown that the saints in heaven can at least be aware of the affairs of men here one earth. But what about their intercessory prayer? Is there any biblical evidence that the saints in heaven in fact pray for us? “But Karlo, you’re assuming that the 24 elders are human souls. You’re also assuming that the “prayers of the saints” refers to petitions made by Christians on earth. How do you know these assumptions are true? 46:07 – I’ll concede that Revelation 5:8 shows the 24 elders interceding for Christians on earth in a general way. But I don’t think this text gives the Catholic what he’s after—namely, intercessory prayers for specific requests.
Is the sacrament of Confirmation really found in Scripture? In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, we tackle one of the most common questions about Catholic sacramental theology. Karlo Broussard explains the biblical roots of Confirmation, where it shows up in the New Testament, and how early Christians understood the laying on of hands and the gift of the Holy Spirit. If you’ve ever wondered how to explain Confirmation to your Protestant friends—or just want to understand it better yourself—don’t miss this segment!
Help us reach our goal by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:15 – If it was revealed to John the Baptist that Jesus was the Messiah, then why did he later send one of his disciples to ask Jesus?
- 07:33 – Why do Catholics primarily receive the Body of Christ (the bread) vs. the Body and Blood (bread and wine)?
- 11:45 – If a married protestant pastor converts, can he seek the priesthood?
- 13:03 – What does Jesus mean by the Kingdom of God?
- 17:21 – How biblical is Confirmation?
- 21:07 – What authority does the magisterium have over changing the TLM and what’s the current rule?
- 23:05 – Was Jesus in the Garden of Eden? When Genesis refers to “Our image”, is this referring to the Trinity?
- 31:22 – Based on Genesis, is the world flat? Is there firmament in the sky keeping us from falling off?
- 33:59 – Why do some people still blame the Jews for the death of Christ?
- 37:45 – Why would God ask Moses to build a bronze serpent if the serpent is the symbol of Satan?
- 42:12 – My coworker got arrested and I went around asking to know what happened. Did doing this cause me to commit the sin of detraction?
- 49:53 – Why are baptisms outside the faith valid even though they don’t share the same beliefs?
- 52:13 – I was raised non-denominational and I want to know what the difference is between the Jesus I know and what Catholics believe.
In this episode of Catholic Answers Live, Cy Kellett is joined by theologian Tom Nash for a deep dive into Catholic social teaching through the lens of Rerum Novarum, the 1891 encyclical by Pope Leo XIII. Prompted by Pope Leo XIV’s decision to connect his papacy with his namesake, the discussion explores why Rerum Novarum remains foundational for the Church’s response to modern social and economic upheavals. From labor rights and the dignity of work to AI, solidarity, subsidiarity, and the proper role of the state, this hour unpacks timeless Catholic principles for navigating new challenges. Whether you’re new to Catholic social teaching or looking to revisit its core insights, this episode offers a clear, passionate, and relevant exploration of how faith meets public life.
Please support our mission by donating!Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Topics Covered:
- 00:00 – Intro: Why Pope Leo XIV chose the name Leo
- 03:30 – Overview of Rerum Novarum and Pope Leo XIII
- 07:00 – Origins of Catholic Social Teaching
- 10:30 – Response to Industrial Revolution
- 14:00 – Gregory XVI and Marari Vos
- 17:30 – Theocracy vs. Catholic moral leadership
- 21:00 – Definition of Catholic Social Teaching
- 24:30 – Human flourishing and property ownership
- 28:00 – Dignity of workers and work conditions
- 31:30 – Modern implications: AI as a moral issue
- 35:00 – Market economy vs. socialism
- 38:30 – Greed, envy, and class warfare
- 42:00 – Role of unions and political integrity
- 45:30 – How AI might affect human dignity
- 49:00 – Solidarity and Subsidiarity explained
- 52:30 – Common Good and the role of the family
With Pope Leo XIV hailing from the United States of America, what global and internal shifts might follow? We explore how his nationality could impact the Church’s perception, diplomacy, and direction.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Please help support our mission by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Topics Covered:
- 0:00 – The Consequences of Pope Leo Being From the US
- 8:50 – Developing a Christ-like Voice online
- 17:05 – The Anti-Life California Bomber
- 34:10 – The Negative Impacts of Social Media regarding Extremism
- 42:00 – San Diego Ranked 3rd Happiest City in the US
As artificial intelligence reshapes society, what role should the Catholic Church—and the new pope—play? We explore potential responses Pope Leo XIV might take to address AI’s moral and spiritual implications.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Please help support our mission by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Topics Covered:
- 0:00 – More Thoughts on Pope Leo
- 13:22 – What Can Pope Leo Do About AI?
- 40:10 – The Renewed Interest In Catholic Pilgrimages
You’ve invited God into your heart, prayed sincerely, and still feel silence. What does that mean? We explore how to respond when God seems distant—even when you’re doing everything right.Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click HereInvite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.comPlease help support our mission by donating! Catholicanswersradio.comQuestions Covered:01:01 – I kind of want to convert but Eucharistic ministers’ hands touching hands and tongues and sharing the chalice are so yucky! What can I do about this hang-up? 12:49 – Do you have a response to Dr Mark Miravalle’s response about Medjugorje? 18:22 – I heard you state on a recent podcast that you have a particular interest in linguistics, so I’m hoping you can comment on the following issue. Why are some Old Testament names so familiar in modern English and others so foreign to us? Is it a matter of translation, the importance of the person, or something else? 24:45 – What’s the best evidence that psi phenomenon exist? 39:50 – If Angels have been around since creation, but they don’t reproduce, does that mean that it’s the same number of angels since the beginning? No more and no less? 44:52 – How do those who desperately want a relationship with God, including prayers inviting all three persons of God to come into their heart, deal properly with an apparent lack of response from God. 48:21 – How can ‘days off purgatory’ be understood in the hereafter since we live in a different ‘time zone’ AND isn’t the timeframe of the purging a discretionary matter ONLY God can determine? 50:52 – The Copenhagen experiment where they shot photons through slits (I think I have that right?) and the particles behaved differently when they were observed vs unobserved – does this offer any proof for God? Also how does this work with Weeping Angels?
If Marian apparitions are considered private revelations, why are events like Our Lady of Guadalupe on the Church calendar? We explain the Church’s distinction between public and private revelation—and why some apparitions are recognized liturgically.Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click HereInvite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.comPlease help support our mission by donating! Catholicanswersradio.comQuestions Covered:01:52 – Do Protestants receive the Holy Spirit in (valid) baptism? If so, then why would they need to be Catholic? 04:06 – Protestants are claiming that the book of James was written before the Council of Jerusalem and together with Acts 15 shows that James doesn’t understand the Gospel because he emphasizes works. How would you respond? 12:21 – Is our time set in stone? 14:47 – If Marian apparitions are private revelation, why does the church recognize apparitions such as our lady of Guadalupe on the church calendar? 17:10 – What are your thoughts on the studies done that aim to determine if prayer is an effective medical tool. I’m referring specifically to prayer groups praying for the patients and not the patients themselves. Also if a non-Christian group prayed for the patients and it was shown to be effective… what would this mean? 28:30 – If the catholic church doesn’t accept a Mormon baptism because of their understanding of God… why does the catholic church accept a marriage when the people involved have a misunderstanding about the nature of the marriage [it doesn’t line up with our beliefs about marriage]? 32:34 – Jesus sent his disciples to heal the sick, expel demons, purify the lepers and resurrect the dead (Matt 10). Why do we not hear much about the resurrection of dead people, but only of exorcism and healing of sickness? 36:45 – Thanks for your important work! Could you explain how the Old Testament practice of sacrificing an animal then eating it is really a sacrifice? 43:03 – Could you explain what Christian non-exclusivism entails. And more importantly, what the biblical and patristic evidence is that this is an acceptable/non-heretical position. I watched the Theology Unleashed videos you were in, and feel like this position would change entirely how I see everyone, Christians and non-Christians. Also, are there not things like the in-filling of the Holy Spirit and gifts of the Holy Spirit, that devotees of other religious traditions cannot experience or share in, outside of explicit faith in Jesus.
Can we be sure that God—and not multiple gods or cosmic forces—is the one true Creator? We explore biblical, philosophical, and theological reasons why Catholics affirm one all-powerful God as the source of all being.
Help us reach our goal by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 11:38 – I had a vasectomy. If I were to convert to Catholicism, would I still be able to engage in the conjugal act with my wife?
- 21:30 – Why was the Holy Spirit given in a different way in the New Testament than in the Old Testament?
- 35:22 – How do we know that God is the one and only almighty creator?
- 45:32 – How many variations of the rosary are there?
- 49:45 – What does it mean to defend your faith but avoid quarreling? Who is your confirmation saint?
Many hear the phrase “imputed righteousness” and think it’s a Catholic belief—but is it? We explain how Catholicism differs from Protestant views on righteousness, justification, and purgatory.
Help us reach our goal by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:54 – Is 2 Tim 1:12-14 linked to sensus fidelium?
- 19:20 – Is the Archangel Gabriel, Mary’s guardian angel?
- 31:50 – How should we understand doing works of mercy and how it relates to the final judgment?
- 38:49 – I’m reading a book on purgatory and saw the phrase imputed righteousness of Christ. What does that mean?
- 46:04 – What are your thoughts on the claim that Jesus was a master hypnotist and trained his apostles?
- 51:58 – Am I allowed to genuflect after communion?
When Jesus said “I Am,” was He just making a poetic statement—or clearly claiming divinity? We explore how His listeners would’ve understood those words and why they reacted the way they did.
Help us reach our goal by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:23 – I used to be Mormon and on my way to converting. My mother had a profound emotional experience inside a church. She took it as a negative experience. What advice can you give on how to approach her?
- 19:58 – Why do we say Christians with valid baptisms are converts? What was the process by which we said which laws of the Old Testament were fulfilled and no longer applied to us?
- 32:52 – I’m a new Catholic. Can you help me better understand indulgences? Can you offer it up for someone else?
- 40:33 – Jesus says I Am a lot. Would his listeners have understood that he was claiming divinity?
- 47:47 – My dad is a huge Joe fan. What book does Joe recommend I get for my dad for Father’s day?
- 52:36 – My family is Protestant. How do you talk to someone who only believes in Sola Scriptura about the Eucharist?
After leaving Mormonism, many seekers ask: What makes Catholicism unique? We explore the Church’s claims to apostolic authority, the sacraments, and how it fulfills the promises of Christianity in ways no other faith does.
Help us reach our goal by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 12:28 – When was the sacrament of baptism instituted? When were the apostles baptized?
- 21:00 – When John the Baptist says I baptize with water he will baptize with the Holy Spirit. Would his audience know what that means?
- 31:40 – I grew up Mormon but have since fallen away. What does Catholicism claim that sets itself apart from the rest of the Abrahamic faiths?
- 43:54 – What is the meaning of Exodus 16:16-18? It seems like a contradiction.
- 48:51 – What is the Catholic response to the claim that once saved, always saved is biblical?
If God is called “the Rock” in Deuteronomy, how can Catholics say Peter is the rock in Matthew 16:18? We explore how Scripture uses the term and why identifying Peter as the rock of the Church doesn’t take anything away from God’s ultimate authority.
Help us reach our goal by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 29:47 – If a person confesses their sins to a person who is portraying themself as a priest, is that confession valid?
- 40:07 – Is the following a proper analogy: We are like the apostles who were lost in the quantity of fish they caught and didn’t recognize Jesus along the shore? We get caught up in our daily distractions and don’t recognize Jesus.
- 48:47 – How does the Church resolve God being the rock such as in Deuteronomy?
Many wonder whether the Mass is a true sacrifice or just a memorial. We explain what the Church teaches about the Eucharist, how it’s tied to Calvary, and why it’s not a re-crucifixion.
Help us reach our goal by donating! Catholicanswersradio.com
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:45 – Is the sacrifice of the mass the sacrifice of Jesus being perpetuated or is it just symbolic?
- 30:14 – What’s the difference between actual grace and sanctifying grace?
- 40:52 – How do you defend the claim that the Catholic Church is the oldest governance body in history?
- 47:55 – How does 1 Tim 2:5 relate to the pope?
If you suspect your child has a drinking problem, you’re not alone. We share Catholic resources, signs to look for, and how parents can respond with both love and accountability—while staying rooted in faith.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 14:23 – Do you have resources available in Spanish? Is CIR a supplement or replacement for other 12 step programs?
- 19:45 – I’m in recovery and just want to encourage others. I went to Mass, gym and meetings everyday.
- 24:15 – What resources do you have that we can use? My wife and I think my son has a drinking problem?
- 34:04 – The last 7 years of my marriage I discovered my husband had a sex addiction. I eventually filed for divorce. What is known about this kind of addiction and its correlation to abuse?
- 42:33 – I’m recovering but being exposed to new age theology through recovery programs. How do we address this?
- 48:18 – I’m on methadone and having a hard time quitting. I’m having a hard time convincing myself this is a sin.
Many Catholics struggle with how to oppose IVF while still loving children conceived through it. We explain how the Church separates the dignity of the child from the morality of the method—and how to navigate this with clarity and compassion.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 15:33 – Why would God allow creatures to come into existence if they are not the right way? Why would God ensoul then?
- 20:59 – Could you explain philosophically, why is IVF dominating, not cooperating?
- 29:28 – Could you educate me more, at what stage is the human being frozen?
- 30:50 – I have 2 nieces who were IVF children. Where do I fit in as a Catholic who loves them but disagrees with IVF?
- 42:54 – How do people get a baby naturally if they have been told that they have bad egg quality and they feel that IVF is the only hope?
- 48:28 – How do you approach when someone you know tells you they are going to use IVF and have family who have been successful in using it?
- 52:23 – Do a lot of people have a hard time bringing the children to term through IVF?
Sedevacantists often cite St. Robert Bellarmine’s De Romano Pontifice to claim the papal seat is vacant. We explain what Bellarmine really taught, how his work is often misunderstood, and why the Catholic Church affirms the legitimacy of post-Vatican II pop
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 02:17 – What books do you recommend I read if I want to learn world history?
- 05:57 – When did Jesus come to realize that Judas would betray him?
- 10:52 – I went to confession for a grave sin I committed but the thought of it still weighs heavy on me. Do I need to go to confession again?
- 19:16 – Can a pope take the name of a female saint like Joan of Arc?
- 21:40 – How do you protect yourself from people who do astro-travel or those who are witches/Satanists etc.?
- 28:41 – My wife is a convert and asks me questions I can’t answer. Are the relics in Church altars saints or just important people?
- 31:24 – What’s a good response to the question why we should be Catholic
- 36:06 – The Church got the calendar wrong. Since we have a pope who has studied math, will the Church correct the calendar?
- 44:06 – If I had children out of wedlock, could I still get married inside the Church?
- 47:02 – How do we refute Sedevacantists who use the works of St. John Bellarmine, specifically in De Romano Pontifice, to support their case for Sedevacantism?
- 52:34 – Are Catholics allowed to get civilly married before sacramentally married?
Is it possible for a pope to change or override the declarations of an ecumenical council? We explore the limits of papal authority, how councils and popes interact, and what Catholic tradition teaches about continuity and development in Church doctrine.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:37 – If the pope wanted to, could he modify the declaration of an ecumenical council?
- 11:23 – Did any early Jewish denomination accept the Deuterocanon?
- 15:06 – Why did God make us how he did? Why did he give us eyes, arms, etc.?
- 19:13 – Does the Church consider mortal sin to be objective or does it depend on the perspective of the individual?
- 28:46 – Where do popes get their names from?
- 38:14 – Why did God create hell?
- 44:33 – Why is it important to learn Church History?
- 47:13 – Is it sinful to lack a relationship with God and to lack knowledge of God?
- 50:49 – My friends found out that the priest who baptized them killed someone and they were informed by the diocese that their baptism was invalid. How is this possible?
Both Thomism and Calvinism talk about predestination—but they mean very different things. We break down the Catholic (Thomistic) view vs. the Calvinist model, focusing on grace, free will, and God’s sovereignty in salvation.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:17 – How can I rectify the evil caused by free will and the love of God?
- 22:42 – How did Protestants come up with the concept of the Rapture? How can I combat this?
- 32:52 – Can you explain the difference between Thomistic predestination and the Calvinist view?
- 50:07 – Why does the Bible use the translation “the Jews” instead of “Jewish Authority”?
Many ask where the Bible clearly teaches Jesus’ divinity. We walk through the strongest scriptural arguments that show Christ isn’t just a prophet or teacher—but truly God incarnate.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:17 – Can the new pope make changes to Dignitatis Humanae?
- 13:09 – Why do we put value on the Pope Leo XIII instead of the original Pope Leo?
- 18:27 – What are some arguments to prove Jesus is God?
- 28:45 -Can I still experience the effects of a sin even after confession?
- 34:52 – Why don’t Catholics put more attention to Divine Mercy Sunday?
- 39:41 – CCC 1371 states those who die in Christ are not yet wholly purified. Does this conflict with the Bible?
- 43:17 – Do you need to confess that you are divorced even if you don’t get remarried?
- 46:33 – To what degree must we listen to the pope if the conclave can be corrupt?
- 52:11 – If I witness someone who I know is in Mortal Sin receive communion, am I complicit?
If God isn’t bound to any denomination, why should anyone be Catholic? We unpack the meaning behind this popular objection and explain how the Catholic Church sees itself as the fullness of the faith Christ established—not a limit on God’s grace.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions covered:
- 05:56 – What was Jesus doing when he descended into hell?
- 15:11 – Why are you Catholic if God is not Catholic?
- 47:01 – I don’t believe that Catholicism is biblical? CCC 1321 says the opposite of 1 Jn 1:9, 5:13, And Hebrews 10:14
With the election of Pope Leo XIV, many are asking where he stands. Is he liberal, conservative, or something else entirely? We explore his early actions, public tone, and what that might mean for the future of the Church.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions covered:
- 07:54 – Is Pope Leo XIV liberal or conservative?
- 13:58 – I don’t find joining organized religion. I find that it corrupts morality.
- 19:48 – I’m Protestant. Who do you worship? The Pope or Jesus? My daughter left religion because she was told that she was not allowed to receive communion in the Catholic Church after they discovered we were Anglican.
- 36:06 – What’s the basis for purgatory?
- 46:50 – What is the apostleship argument and why is it used against the doctrine of Apostolic Succession?
Many Protestants argue the pope was never meant to lead the Church long-term. We examine biblical and historical evidence for the papacy, Peter’s unique role, and how the Church has understood this office from the beginning.Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click HereInvite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.comQuestions Covered:0:03:00 – Is the papacy unbiblical or a temporary office?0:07:30 – Does the Bible ever say Peter went to Rome?0:11:30 – How does 1 Peter 5:13 support Peter’s presence in Rome?0:14:30 – Did Peter and Paul really found the church in Rome together?0:16:30 – Does Paul rebuking Peter disprove papal authority?0:19:30 – Can a pope be fallible or rebuked for his actions?0:23:00 – Is the real Protestant objection that we don’t need structure, sacraments, or hierarchy?0:25:30 – What does the temple veil really mean for Christian worship?0:29:00 – If Jesus is the only mediator, why do we have priests or popes?0:32:30 – Does the Eucharist show that Christian priesthood is still valid?0:36:00 – What’s the real difference between Catholicism and Orthodoxy on the papacy?0:39:30 – Is the Pope really just “first among equals”?0:42:00 – What does Irenaeus say about Rome’s authority and apostolic succession?0:45:00 – Did Pope John Paul II suggest the papacy could look different in the future?0:47:30 – Is the complexity of the modern papacy a sign of corruption or growth?0:50:00 – Does celibacy contradict Peter’s example?0:53:00 – Was Peter actually married during his apostleship?0:55:00 – Is the Pope the Antichrist and the Church the Whore of Babylon?
In Galatians, Paul publicly rebukes Peter—but does that disprove papal authority? We unpack what really happened in Antioch and why the Church still holds Peter as the first pope, even amid correction and scandal.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:22 – Why do people object to the Pope’s role in the Church?
- 06:40 – Isn’t the papacy unbiblical and not meant to persist beyond Peter?
- 10:35 – Does the Bible ever say Peter was in Rome?
- 14:20 – What does “Babylon” mean in 1 Peter 5:13, and how is that connected to Rome?
- 17:15 – Didn’t Paul co-found the Church in Rome with Peter?
- 20:05 – Paul rebuked Peter—doesn’t that undermine papal authority?
- 25:18 – Was Peter’s behavior in Antioch heretical or just scandalous?
- 30:40 – Doesn’t Galatians 2 show Peter as just another apostle, not a leader?
- 34:25 – Why do Protestants say we don’t need a Pope if Jesus tore the temple veil?
- 39:12 – Does Jesus as sole mediator mean there’s no place for the Pope or priests?
- 43:50 – Why is Hebrews 10 crucial to properly understanding the torn temple veil?
- 47:00 – Is priesthood abolished in the New Testament?
- 50:10 – What does 1 Corinthians 10 tell us about sacrifice, the Eucharist, and priests?
- 54:45 – Why is there a structural Protestant objection to the papacy?
If someone wants to become Catholic, why not just let them in? We explain the purpose of OCIA, its roots in Church tradition, and how it helps prepare hearts and minds for full communion with the Catholic Church.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions covered:
- 04:54 – Why do non-Catholics who want to join the Church need to go through OCIA instead of just joining immediately?
- 14:33 – How is the Catholic Church’s apostolic succession compare to what other churches believe?
- 21:43 – How does the intercession of the saints work when the Bible says that men are appointed to die once, and then face judgement?
- 28:53 – I go to church every once in a while with my family and I take communion, but I heard that I’m not supposed to do that. What are the rules?
- 40:30 – Is Jesus’ renaming of Simon the reason why the pope takes a different name?
- 44:09 – I have a hard time accepting the perpetual virginity of Mary. I don’t think she’d want to refuse giving Joseph as many sons as possible, and John’s Gospel clearly mentions brothers of Jesus.
If a non-Catholic knowingly rejects Catholic teaching and commits a grave sin, are they just as culpable as a Catholic? We explore moral responsibility, Church teaching on invincible ignorance, and how conscience and knowledge affect culpability.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions covered:
- 06:53 – I read in the Catechism that you need to be in the state of grace to receive the sacrament of confirmation. What happens if you’re not?
- 18:24 – If a Catholic and a non-Catholic both do something that’s a mortal sin, and they both know what the Catholic Church teaches, is the non-Catholic also culpable for mortal sin?
- 28:45 – Was there anything Pope Francis actually did to change any teachings in the Catholic Church?
- 35:04 – Why did the Catholic Church need to dogmatize the Assumption of Mary?
- 43:31 – What is the practical effect that the pope has on the world when he makes a pronouncement or encourages the world, considering most of the world isn’t Catholic and doesn’t have reason to listen to him?
- 50:12 – How does the Pope’s authority compare to the Bible’s?
Did the teachings of Vatican I—like papal primacy and infallibility—suddenly appear in the 19th century, or do they have roots in the early Church? In this episode, Karlo Broussard explores whether first-century Christianity shows signs of the very authority Vatican I defined. From Peter’s leadership to early documents like First Clement, we trace the continuity between apostolic Christianity and conciliar declarations, helping you respond to historical objections with clarity and confidence.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:59 – How can we avoid begging the question against the Catholic faith when talking to Orthodox?
- 12:34 – Does sitting in adoration impart grace?
- 18:46 – If sacrifice is the only actual worship, how is it that the offering of the Eucharist, worship of Jesus if we’re offering his own body?
- 18:46 – If sacrifice is the only actual worship, how is it that the offering of the Eucharist, worship of Jesus if we’re offering his own body?
- 21:26 – Why was Jesus’ death so horrific but the sacrifice of Isaac didn’t seem like it was as brutal?
- 31:44 – If all the angels were created in a perfect state, what inclined them to their first sin?
- 36:23 – I believe that being elevated as one of the greatest like Mary and John was because of their humility. What are your thoughts?
- 42:14 – Are the teachings of Vatican 1 apparent in the first century?
- 47:35 – I know that communion on the hand was allowed recently but was the intended form palm to mouth? When did picking it up with our fingers and placing it into our mouth specifically allowed?
- 50:52 – I’m a new convert. How does the Church view the imparting of the Holy Spirit and Pentecost?
When pregnancy complications threaten the life of the mother, what does the Catholic Church actually teach? In this episode, Karlo Broussard clarifies the Church’s position on morally complex medical cases. He explains the principle of double effect, what treatments are permissible, and why direct abortion is never considered a moral solution—even in rare or tragic circumstances. If you’ve heard myths about what the Church requires in these cases, this episode brings clarity and compassion.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 19:17 – What does the church teach on rare pregnancy complications and abortion?
- 34:20 – Is hocus pocus taken from the Latin of the words of consecration? Is it similar to book bell and candle?
- 43:03 – What does attachment to sin mean?
- 48:09 – At what point does a cardinal who is elected pope pick their new name?
- 51:03 – Is Mary considered the highest creature? If so, how does that relate to how Jesus says John the Baptist is the greatest?
Curious about Catholic Social Teaching but don’t know where to start? In this episode, Karlo Broussard points you to essential resources—from magisterial documents to accessible books—that will help you understand the Church’s teaching on human dignity, the common good, subsidiarity, and solidarity. Whether you’re a beginner or looking to go deeper, this episode lays the groundwork for learning how Catholicism speaks to politics, economics, and justice.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 28:50 – I went to a communion service where the female minister was standing in the sanctuary behind the altar. Is this allowed?
- 31:47 – Are there any resources you can offer to me where I can learn more about Catholic Social Teaching?
- 40:59 – How much can we read into Pope Leo’s Augustinian background?
- 49:34 – Does the indulgences the pope gave today at his blessing affect those who are in mortal sin?
Why did the new pope choose the name Leo XIV? In this episode, we explore the possible historical, theological, and symbolic significance of the name “Leo”—from Leo the Great to Leo XIII—and what it might reveal about the new pope’s priorities, vision, and identity. Karlo Broussard also discusses whether this signals a moderate papacy and how the choice reflects on the Church’s current moment.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 18:28 – What are your thoughts on why he chose the name Leo XIV? Do you think he will be a moderate?
- 22:06 – Can we receive communion at a Orthodox church?
- 24:19 – What are some general guidelines in discerning satanic resistance vs God closing the door?
- 30:13 – Do you think the resurgence of traditional Catholicism in the US gave the idea that we were ready to have an American pope? That we are no longer looked upon as a wild card?
- 30:13 – Do you think the resurgence of traditional Catholicism in the US gave the idea that we were ready to have an American pope? That we are no longer looked upon as a wild card?
- 34:15 – The new Pope has a degree in Math. Could his papal blessing also impart more math knowledge?
- 37:41 – I think Cy’s book Ad Limina was a great parallel to what we have now. What are your thoughts on those parallels?
- 44:18 – What are your thoughts on the general name Leo and the historical significance of Leo III?
- 49:00 – What’s the difference between Catholicism and Episcopalians?
What happens if someone grows up Catholic but was never properly taught the faith? In this episode, we explore the Church’s teaching on invincible ignorance, personal responsibility, and how culpability is assessed when someone lacks formation. Does ignorance excuse sin? What if that ignorance is the result of others’ failure? Karlo Broussard breaks it all down.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:51 – I got a tattoo at 16 of the number 666. I got it covered up and have confessed. Are there any implications for still having it on my body?
- 09:46 – When you were protestant, how did you handle church shopping with Jesus saying he is the way, the truth and the life?
- 19:25 – What do the 153 fish mean when Jesus met with his apostles after the resurrection?
- 22:55 – How can the Trinity have one divine mind of the persons are each other?
- 29:32 – If a person receives the anointing of the sick before they die are they absolved of all of their sins?
- 32:17 – What is or is not allowed in adoration? Can I do my homework in his presence?
- 39:40 – CCC 2156 discusses receiving a Christian name. Did my parents mess up by not naming me after a saint?
- 43:54 – What is the Church’s view on suicide?
- 49:08 – If a person goes to Catholic school and is poorly catechized would he be culpable or would he have invincible ignorance?
Many Christians find it hard to see the papacy in the first-century Church. In this episode, Erick Ybarra addresses the historical and biblical foundations for the papal office. Was Peter truly the first pope? How did early Christians view his authority? And what evidence do we have from Scripture and tradition that connects the leadership of Peter to the role of today’s pope?
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 12:33 – I struggle with not seeing the papacy in the first century. Can you help clarify where we see it?
- 18:30 – How close have we ever gotten to the pope who was the minimal requirement, a male baptized Catholic?
- 22:32 – Regarding his debate with Ubi Petrus. Do you have clarification from one of your questions from the debate?
- 35:29 – How is it ok that we added the filioque to the Nicene creed? Didn’t the Nicene Creed have a clause that not one word could be changed?
- 42:09 – How do you think the Church balances separating itself from being too political and how it’s done that historically?
- 48:24 – How closely do we tie our belief in Christ to our belief in the Church? If the pope were to dogmatically declare heresy, would it invalidate the magisterium?
- 52:06 – What do you think about the passages in First Clement where he says the Holy Spirit is writing/speaking through him? Is this evidence of papal infallibility?
How long do souls stay in purgatory? Can they meet their guardian angel? Is it okay to ask them to pray for you? We explore Catholic teaching on purgatory—its duration, biblical references, and the mystery of hope beyond purification.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:52 – Length of time in purgatory. How do we know how long we’ll be in purgatory?
- 08:46 – When you’re in purgatory do you get to meet your guardian angel?
- 29:29 – What does Philippians 2:10 mean? Is ‘under the earth’ a reference to purgatory?
- 34:06 – My father died 10 years ago. What happens to the indulgences I offer for him if no longer in purgatory and in heaven?
- 36:40 – I’ve heard of Purgatory as described as hell but with the hope of heaven. Is this accurate?
- 42:27 – I praise God, thank God and give my intentions for those in purgatory. I make a deal with those souls to pray for me when they get to heaven. Is this okay to do?
- 51:42 – If God can save infants who are not baptized, then why does he extend this grace to everyone through purgatory?
If Christ’s death paid the full price for our sins, why do Catholics still teach purgatory? In this episode, we break down common objections using Scripture and tradition—explaining why purgatory isn’t a rejection of Christ’s sacrifice, but a deepening of its transformative power.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:42 – Where is “purgatory” in the Bible?
- 12:50 – Catholics appeal to 1 Corinthians 3:11-15 for purgatory. But Paul doesn’t say the person is tested by fire. Rather, he teaches “works” are tested by fire.
- 16:52 – Catholics appeal to Jesus’ teaching about the unforgivable sin not being forgiven in this age or in the age to come in Matthew 12:32. But all Jesus meant by this is that the unpardonable sin is never forgiven, as Mark’s version makes clear in 3:29.
- 22:10 – Does the doctrine of purgatory contradict the Bible’s teaching on the immediacy of heaven after death (“to be absent from the body is to be present with the Lord”)?
- 29:30 – Didn’t Jesus tell the thief on the cross, “Today you will be with me in paradise”? Doesn’t that disprove purgatory?
- 35:40 – Doesn’t the Bible teach that there are only two eternal destinies: heaven or hell?
- 39:55 – Didn’t Jesus’ death on the cross fully pay for all our sins? Why would additional purification be needed?
- 48:34 – Isn’t the idea of purgatory a denial of justification by faith alone?
- 49:55 – Why would a loving God punish believers after death if they’re already saved?
Many Catholics read the Vatican II documents and wonder: where are the reforms we see today? We explore what the Council actually said, how those ideas were implemented, and also dive into Marian theology and questions about spiritual warfare.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 15:36 – Who were Mary’s parents? Did she have a natural birth? Did she have original sin?
- 29:36 – I’m new to the Church. Is studying spiritual warfare making me a target for demonic attacks?
- 41:54 – I read the documents of Vatican 2. I don’t see a lot of the liturgical reforms. Where did they come from?
A new law in Washington state requires priests to report abuse heard in confession—can civil law override the sacred seal? We explore Church teaching, legal precedent, and why this issue matters for Catholics everywhere, along with insights on forgiveness, tradition, and spiritual healing.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 13:16 – If God said all creation is good, were there predators and prey from the beginning?
- 16:44 – How do I get over being hurt from my local Catholic Church? Sorry i put up the wrong fader at first.
- 20:54 – How do I better explain why can’t women be priests?
- 28:49 – I’ve been forgiven in confession for hurting others. My heart still yearns to be forgiven from them. Some are living and some are deceased. Is it ok to feel this way?
- 33:27 – I’m a new Catholic. What do you recommend I read more about traditions of the Church that I didn’t cover in OCIA?
- 43:44 – On Friday the governor of Washington signed a law that priests will be required to report child abuse revealed during confession. Isn’t this already settled law?
- 51:34 – What is your best argument against the essence/energies distinction as proposed by Gregory Palamas?
From Scripture to early Church doctrine, we examine the foundation of Christ’s divinity and humanity. This episode also covers the biblical use of YHWH vs. Elohim, proper burial attire, and how the Bible was compiled.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 01:49 – When do they go from using the name YHWH to Elohim?
- 21:58 – How do we know that Jesus is eternal and fully God and fully human?
- 32:18 – What is appropriate for dressing a deceased person?
- 36:50 – How do we understand Ephesians 2:8-9 in light James 2:24?
- 47:58 – How were all the books of the bible compiled?
From apostolic succession to secret ballots, the history of papal elections is rich and fascinating. We explore how popes have been chosen across the centuries, and also tackle questions on sanctuary use, offensive Talmudic texts, and disposing of a damaged rosary.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 07:43 – I am a Catholic school teacher and they use the sanctuary for plays immediately after mass. What are the rules for use of the sanctuary?
- 14:44 – I see a lot of bumper stickers at church of an M with a line through it. Does that have any significance? How does one dispose of a damaged rosary?
- 18: 58 -Can you give a brief history of how popes were elected?
- 29:14 – In the Talmud it says that Jesus is burning in hell. What do I make of this?
- 40:41 – Jn 11 and Jn 12 there’s a plot to kill Lazarus after being raised from the dead. Did they ever succeed in their plot?
- 43:13 – Can you bless non-Catholic items like a buddha?
- 48:14 – Are you familiar with the documentary, Hypothesis? When do they go from using the name YHWH to Elohim?
What happens when a papal constitution seems to contradict a past ecumenical council? We explore Church authority, plus questions on circumcision, plenary indulgences, the Holy Spirit, and why Jesus wept for Lazarus even knowing the resurrection was near.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:02 – Is it possible for an ecumenical council’s constitution to be overridden by a subsequent papal constitution or declaration?
- 11:45 – I have a son on the way. Is it still licit for Catholics to be circumcised?
- 17:31 – How didn’t God save Adam and Eve’s first children from the wound of original sin?
- 20:24 – I’ve always heard that the Holy Spirit is the love between the Father and Son. Most recently I’ve heard that it’s a person. What’s correct?
- 29:30 – Is a faithful Catholic committing a grave act when seeking a divorce when domestic abuse is involved?
- 33:51 – Does our modern dual definitions of ‘prodigal’ come from the parable?
- 38:52 – After the resurrection of the dead and we are living here on earth, what will happen to us when our sun explodes?
- 41:39 – If we apply a Plenary indulgence to a soul in purgatory, do we need to continue to pray for them?
- 47:09 – Why did Easter happen to land after two full moons?
- 49:13 – Is it okay for me to attend a non-Catholic wedding that won’t even be at a church?
- 50:25 – In 2020 I died in the hospital 3 times. Who can I talk to about what I saw to help explain and understand it?
- 52:07 – Why did Jesus weep when Lazarus died when he knew he was going to resurrect him?
While Catholicism and Orthodoxy share deep roots, key differences remain—especially on authority. We explore one of the most compelling arguments against Orthodoxy and also touch on Catholic miracles, lost apostolic letters, and starting fruitful Bible studies with Protestants.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 03:13 – Why should we read the apocryphal books?
- 06:53 – Why does Genesis specify the building material in the building of the tower of babel?
- 11:49 – Suppose the letter of Paul to the Athenians is found, would it be considered scripture?
- 18:57 – Why does it seem like there’s not a lot of evidence for Catholic miracles?
- 28:56 – What is the best argument against Orthodoxy?
- 35:08 – I’m starting a bible study with protestants. What can I do for them to be open to it?
- 42:47 – I’m reverting to Catholicism. My in-laws are very anti-Catholic. How should I approach them?
- Could you expand on your comments on Matt Fradd’s show about intelligent life on other planets and how Christ’ sacrifice would apply to them?
- 52:31 – What are your thoughts on the AI Confessional in Europe?
Some claim a woman secretly reigned as pope—but is there any truth to the legend of Pope Joan? We explore the origins and historical credibility of the story, plus discuss Orthodox biblical canons, Christ’s fulfillment of prophecy, and the Church’s understanding of Islam.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 12:13 – Is the fact that the Orthodox have a variety of biblical canons, an argument against them?
- 16:46 – I’m a convert. Is the story of Pope Joan true?
- 20:03 – How can I make a defense for supposed contradictions in the ecumenical councils?
- 29:41 – How did Christ fulfill the prophecy of world peace?
- 34:35 – What was the aftermath of the Jews after the resurrection?
- 40:16 – Has anyone compiled a list of the early Church writings that were recently discovered that were not available during the reformation?
- 44:31 – Why did Jesus not tell the Pharisees that he was born in Bethlehem when they said he was born in Nazareth?
- 46:21 – I agree with the premise of your video on Muslims. What would one believe about their God in order for it to be a different god?
- 52:02 – How much information did the Church actually have on Islam before making an official statement?
When talking to Muslim friends or curious skeptics, it’s crucial to know where Scripture reveals Christ’s divinity. We walk through key verses that affirm Jesus is truly God, and also explore topics like Communion for Protestants, the identity of angels, and baptism for foster children.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 05:04 – What are your thoughts on the growing trend that converts are not even real Catholics?
- 13:18 – I’m newly married and my wife is pregnant. I’m feeling very uneasy. What advice do you have to look forward to it?
- 23:02 – How did you first learn about Abraham’s faith?
- 28:30 – My Muslim friend wants to know where in the bible does it say that Jesus is God?
- 34:44 – Nowhere in scripture to hear angels referred to as females. They are always male. Do we hear anywhere where a female angel appears?
- 37:15 – I’m a new convert. Why can’t my protestant mom receive communion if she truly believes in the real presence?
- 43:12 – Was John the Baptist Elijah?
- 46:03 – What book do you recommend for homeschooling my son? What can I do to strengthen my marriage?
- 50:30 – I have a 2-year-old foster son. Is there any reason why I should not baptize him?
Catholics believe Mary was conceived without sin—so why does she still call God her Savior? We explain how the Immaculate Conception and God’s saving grace work together, along with insights on hell, Scripture interpretation, and loving family members with same-sex attractions.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 04:10 – How could an all-loving God send people to Hell?
- 16:25 – How do I explain that we should seek more than just feeling good?
- 30:00 – How could Peter be the Pope of Edomites and not the Israelites?
- 34:50 – How can I deal with family members with same-sex orientations?
- 43:38 – If Mother Mary was saved from Original Sin, why would she need a Savior?
- 48:20 – How can I navigate the varied scripture interpretations?
Where did the practice of confessing sins to a priest come from? We explore the biblical and historical roots of the sacrament of reconciliation, along with clarifying Catholic teaching on statues, baptism, the papacy, and prayer to the saints.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com
Questions Covered:
- 06:49 – How is kneeling before a statue not worship?
- 14:04 – I don’t understand the origin of Confession.
- 18:25 – Can you clarify about the super substantial bread in Matthew 6:11?
- 22:30 – Why would a Protestant not need to be Baptized again in the Catholic faith?
- 32:58 – If the logic of the Papacy was consistent, why don’t the other apostles have their own apostolic sees?
- 44:13 – I struggle with the Catholic church annulment process.
- 52:25 – How do Catholics justify praying to Saints?
Join Cy Kellett on Catholic Answers Live as he interviews Emily Torres from the popular Catholic Converts Instagram page. They discuss how social media can be a powerful tool for evangelization, the challenges and rewards of sharing the Catholic faith online, and practical tips for reaching hearts in the digital world. Whether you’re a seasoned apologist or new to Catholic outreach, this inspiring conversation offers insights into living and witnessing the faith today.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Catholic history includes dark moments—how do we honestly and faithfully explain them? We tackle common challenges like the Middle Ages, Old Testament violence, the St. Bartholomew’s Day Massacre, and how Catholics approach people influenced by LGBT ideology.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 10:41 – How do I explain the atrocities in the Middle Ages to my protestant friend?
- 19:19 – Can we ask Pope Francis to pray for us even though he hasn’t been canonized?
- 28:58 – How do we rectify the pro-life position with the Old Testament passages where God called his people to kill babies?
- 41:35 – How do we respond to certain accusations of the reformation like the St. Bartholomew massacre?
- 47:00 – Where were the souls before paradise?
- 50:44 – How should we approach people who fall under LGBT ideology?
What’s the meaning behind the twelve stars on the Miraculous Medal? We explore the biblical symbolism connected to Mary, Revelation, and the Church, along with insights into papal elections, Christ in the Old Testament, and explaining Catholic beliefs to Mormons.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 04:19 – Why are there twelve stars on the Miraculous Medal?
- 10:26 – Why would the teaching that the dead donor rule not apply to the unborn?
- 18:11 – Who would elect the Pope if all the Cardinals died?
- 28:54 – How can I explain Psalm 82:6 in a Trinitarian way to a Mormon friend who believes it relates to them becoming gods?
- 44:33 – Can Revelation 21:12 be applied to the miraculous medal crown since it describes the image?
- 51:10 – Can the God that walked with Adam and Eve or came to visit Abraham be considered the pre-incarnate Jesus based on Colossians 1:15?
Can Catholics believe in both a historical Adam and Eve and modern evolutionary theory? We explore how Church teaching reconciles faith and science, along with insights on Jesus’ divinity in the Gospels, the death of a pope, and Catholic relations with Protestants and Orthodox Christians.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 04:24 – Why in the debate with Bart Ehrmann, he had a disagreement about Jesus saying He was divine in the synoptic gospels? Why?
- 18:11 – I heard a claim that the Church wanted Luther dead, is this true?
- 24:11 – How should we treat the death of the Pope? Can we say he is already in heaven?
- 31:13 – How can the historical Adam and Eve fit in with modern evolutionary science?
- 44:24 – Was Jesus born in a cave or a house?
- 47:03 – Can I go to a Protestant service, if I still go to Mass?
- 49:18 – I heard there is a reentering of communion between Rome and Anglicans. Will this be on hold with the passing of Pope Francis?
- 52:16 – Can you explain the Orthodox claim that the church was originally beyond just Rome because Peter founded a church in Antioch?
The Original airdate for this episode was Easter Monday but with the passing of Pope Francis, we pushed the episode back to Easter Wednesday
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
We also explore the challenges of living the faith in the modern world, including a call for more intentional discipleship, authentic masculinity, and a deeper commitment to both evangelization and the corporal works of mercy. The panel also weighs in on the alarming religious persecution in Nicaragua, highlighting how faithful Catholics can advocate for the oppressed through prayer and action.
Whether you’re a convert, cradle Catholic, or someone exploring the faith, this lively episode offers encouragement, challenge, and practical takeaways for living the Resurrection all year long.
The Original airdate for this episode was Easter Monday but with the passing of Pope Francis, we pushed the episode back to Easter Wednesday
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Celebrate Easter Wednesday with the Flannel Panel on this special episode of Catholic Answers Live! Join host Cy Kellett, apologist Joe Heschmeyer, and Catholic Answers president Chris Check as they reflect on the joy of the Resurrection, the meaning of the Easter Octave, and the profound relevance of Jesus’ triumph over death.
From theological insights on the empty tomb and the significance of liturgical traditions to real-world news of a remarkable resurgence in Catholicism—especially among young men in Great Britain—this conversation dives deep into the signs of hope across the global Church.
Whether you’re a convert, cradle Catholic, or someone exploring the faith, this lively episode offers encouragement, challenge, and practical takeaways for living the Resurrection all year long.
Can we trust Scripture as divinely inspired? We look at the historical and theological reasons Catholics believe the Bible is the Word of God, plus tackle topics like the early Church’s view of the afterlife, confirmation saints, and what really happened in the Roman Inquisition.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 03:20 – How does one properly incorporate my new confirmation saint into my prayer life?
- 13:43 – There’s a lot of pictures online of people in Spain with what look like KKK hoods. They are the Nazarene Brothers of the Holy Week of Seville. Are they Catholic?
- 19:31 – What is the early Church evidence for the state of the dead? Soul sleep vs entering heaven or hell?
- 30:45 – How do we make sense of 2 Maccabees 15 and it stating that taking one’s own life is an honorable thing?
- 34:27 – With the pope passing, what would happen if the east and west were to be united? Would we have to choose from the patriarchs to be the next pope?
- 37:28 – How do we know that the bible truly is the Word of God?
- 43:14 – I watched a video online that said Pope Francis is in hell. Is this true?
- 49:02 – I’m writing a series of articles debunking Chick Tracts. What actually happened during the Roman Inquisition?
If God’s will is inevitable, why pray at all? We explore how prayer fits into God’s providence, and also tackle questions on prudential judgment, understanding papal encyclicals, and the emotional hurdles people face when approaching full conversion.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 06:56 – We just got confirmed this past weekend and I just want to say thank you!
- 15:16 – I’ve been praying the 7 Sorrows. One-line states something about suffering in silence. Should I not tell my husband when I’m having a bad day?
- 23:59 – What is the relationship between a prudential judgement and the justification for it? Can a bad reason undermine the judgment itself?
- 36:46 – If God’s Will will always be done, then what is the purpose of praying for things?
- 44:20 – What resources do you recommend to properly understand Papal encyclicals?
- 51:01 – How do I deal with the final hurdles to conversion?
More than just a symbol, baptism is a sacrament with real spiritual power. We dive into what it accomplishes, who can receive it, and how early Christians—like the Church Fathers—understood it. Plus, we explore topics like baptism of desire, evangelical outreach, and infant baptism.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 13:43 – Is it possible to apply baptism of desire to the good thief on the cross?
- 17:20 – I’m Protestant. Do Catholics have evangelical events where they give people an opportunity to respond to God and be saved?
- 20:30 – What is baptism and what does it do for us?
- 30:02 – I see salvific baptism in the Church Father but not a lot of infant baptism. Where do we hear about that in the Church Fathers?
- 38:17 – Does water have to touch the skin in order for the baptism to be valid?
- 42:48 – If baptism has a purifying effect, then why aren’t we being baptized on a regular basis?
- 51:19 – What if a person is baptized in a Baptist church in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit but doesn’t believe that it’s regenerative. Is it still valid?
Does Ephesians 2:8–9 contradict Catholic teaching on the role of works in salvation? We unpack this key verse and how Catholics interpret it, along with insights on baptism’s power, Mary and Adam, and resistance to Church reforms like those from the SSPX.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 16:33 – What is the difference between Adam before the fall and a current person who needs to be baptized?
- 24:25 – How is baptism actually efficacious? How do I explain it to my Protestant friends?
- 38:22 – Was Mary the same as Adam in being full of grace?
- 44:31 – What are your thoughts on Baptism being used as an acronym? Best Actions Persons Take In Saving Mankind
- 47:09 – What are your thoughts on the people coming to the Church who don’t want to embrace the changes just like the SSPX?
- 51:01 – How are we to understand Eph. 2:8-9?
The Flannel Panel discusses the recent passing of Pope Francis and how the media has reacted to the news.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Trent Horn shares the story of meeting Pope Francis and reflects on what it meant for Francis to “lead with his heart.” JD Flynn explores Francis’ reforms—what was completed, what remains unfinished, and the role of mercy at the heart of his papacy. What’s next for the conclave? Could Africa rise? Jimmy Akin weighs in on the papal name and even touches on the Malachi prophecy.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Topic Covered:
- 03:10 – Trent shares a story of him and Laura meeting Pope Francis.
- 17:10 – JD Flynn talks about the conclave, what is likely to happen next
- 31:25 – What name the future pope may choose and the Malachi prophesy
- 43:50 – The Heart of Pope Francis’ papacy was that of mercy
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Why did Jesus have to suffer and die on the cross? On this Good Friday episode of Catholic Answers Live, Cy Kellett speaks with Joe Heschmeyer, author of The Early Church Was the Catholic Church, to unpack the meaning behind Christ’s crucifixion.
Joe explains how the cross is not divine punishment but the ultimate act of love—God offering Himself for our salvation. Drawing from Scripture, the Church Fathers, and the theology of St. Thomas Aquinas, this episode explores:
- Why there’s no Mass on Good Friday
- The meaning of Christ’s sacrifice
- How the cross heals our relationship with God
- The spiritual power of praying before the crucifix
- Why Good Friday is both history’s darkest and brightest day
On this encore special Holy Thursday episode of Catholic Answers Live, Cy Kellett sits down with apologist Joe Heschmeyer to explore the profound meaning of the Last Supper. Why did Jesus institute the Eucharist and the priesthood on this night? How does the Gospel of John’s account—focused on the washing of the feet—fit with the synoptic Gospels’ focus on the bread and wine?
Joe connects the dots between the Passover sacrifice, Christ’s role as the Paschal Lamb, and the liturgical richness of the early Church. You’ll also learn why Holy Thursday marks the beginning of the Church’s most sacred three-day liturgy—and how Catholics today are called to enter into this mystery.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Many exploring Orthodoxy question whether the pope’s authority was recognized in the early centuries. We look at the history behind papal infallibility, plus Catholic answers on the devil, 1 Timothy 2:12, and the Bread of Life discourse.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
00:20 – Content Creator Spotlight: Desirea Sifuentes, the Uncatechized Catholic
15:98 – Why does God let the devil run around to cause problems?
28:45 – I’m Catholic, considering Orthodoxy. Was papal infallibility practiced in the early Church?
38:30 – What’s the context 1 Tim 2:12 and what was going on for him to write it?
44:28 – What supporting verses do you have for your understanding of the Bread of Life discourse?
The apostolic pardon offers a powerful grace at the moment of death—but what exactly is it? We explain its purpose, how it works, and also discuss the Church’s authority in science, the reality of hell, and why confession is an underrated tool in apologetics.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 05:16 – What authority does the Church have on scientific matters when it comes to faith and morals?
- 12:32 – What is an apostolic pardon and how does it work?
- 20:08 – How can people go to hell if God knows what would be good for them?
- 37:59 – Why don’t we use the availability of confession as an apologetics selling point?
If sin is forgiven, why does temporal punishment still exist? We explore scriptural and early Church support for this Catholic teaching and also touch on the rapture, eternal punishment, and how Protestants can begin attending a faithful Catholic parish.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 04:55 – What’s the basis for temporal punishment for sin? Where is it in the New Testament or Church Fathers?
- 14:04 – I’m getting confirmed this Saturday. Is the rapture a protestant invention?
- 19:15 – Why on the 2nd day of creation does God not say, “it was good”?
- 29:16 – I’m Protestant and I’m ready to start going to a Catholic Church. How do I go about finding a good faithful church?
- 41:44 – How can we have such confidence in faith as the Church defines it?
- 49:42 – Eternal punishment troubles me. How do we harmonize God being all good and loving when he created people knowing they will suffer forever?
The Apostles’ Creed says Jesus “descended into hell,” but where is that in Scripture? We explore the biblical foundation for this teaching and also cover Marian dogmas, priestly celibacy, and how to explain Catholic beliefs to Protestant friends.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 11:11 – My protestant friend is going through OCIA and has been struggling with the concept of praying to the dead. How can I help?
- 17:44 – Where in the bible does it say that Jesus descended into hell?
- 22:25 – I have an issue with Marian dogmas and the idea of her co-redemptrix.
- 29:21 – I would like to get a better understanding of Mary’s place. Perpetual virginity and the assumption.
- 40:36 – Why did Jesus say that nothing can be revealed to Peter in Matthew 16 but Nathaniel does know who Jesus is Jn 1:49?
- 46:10 – What’s the teaching on priestly celibacy?
- 51:37 – Can you clarify Vatican 2’s statement that the Old Testament is not defunct. What does that mean?
Many Muslims argue that the Bible can’t be trusted because it was corrupted. We explore effective Catholic responses to this common objection, along with tips for respectful dialogue, Islam’s historical roots, and Muslim views on divine inspiration.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 22:34 – Muslims tend to be aggressive when debating or discussing faith. Should we match their approach?
- 24:05 – How does the general Muslim take it when you start to question Mohammed or Allah?
- 35:07 – Is Islam basically an amalgamation of Arianism, selective Jewish theology and Arab pagan religion?
- 44:39 – What religion did Arabs believe before Islam?
- 46:35 – How do you refute Muslims when they claim that our bible can’t be trusted because it was corrupted?
- 52:22 – How do we respond when they claim that Mohammed was inspired to write the Quran by the Angel Gabriel?
Jesus performed countless miracles and changed lives—but where were those people when He was suffering? We explore this thought-provoking question and what it reveals about human nature, gratitude, and the loneliness of the Cross.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 42:42 – Where were the followers, especially those who received the miracles?
- 44:37 – If Jesus knew he was God and was going to heaven, why was he so distressed in the Garden of Gethsemane?
Protestants often point to Matthew 6:7-11 to argue against repeated prayers—so how can Catholics reconcile this with prayers like the Rosary or the Our Father? Jimmy Akin explores this concern along with Catholic teaching on saints, Mary’s spiritual motherhood, and mixed-faith marriages.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 02:18 – How can we reconcile Jesus saying that the Sabbath was made for man and the punishment of death for not recognizing the sabbath in the Old Testament?
- 10:21 – How can I defend the Church that was Instituted by Jesus Christ, especially on the topic of saints and Mary?
- 13:47 – Is St. Boniface VIII Unam Sanctam Papal bull statement infallible? If not, is there any dispute?
- 18:05 – How do we know that Mary’s motherhood expands to the rest of us in the wake of Mary being given over to John at the foot of the cross?
- 28:45 – I’m Protestant. How do Catholics reconcile Mt 6:7-11 and the repetitious prayers specifically the Our Father?
- 35:01 – How do we respond to Orthodox rejection of the Filioque?
- 39:45 – Would it be scandalous for me to attend the ordination of a married couple as priests in the Episcopalian church?
- 49:35 – What advice would you offer me as someone who is in a mixed faith marriage?
The Church teaches that baptism is a once-in-a-lifetime sacrament—but what are the consequences of being re-baptized? We break down the theological and spiritual implications, and also explore topics like Peter’s crucifixion, the authority of the Church Fathers, and what makes a sin truly mortal.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 04:25 – How is Onan responsible for a sin that wasn’t given until Deuteronomy?
- 11:53 – How could have Mary said no if God had the plan since the beginning of time?
- 16:23 – Which Gospel passages on John are indicative of him filling in the gaps on Luke?
- 20:50 – Where does the Church get the belief that Peter was crucified upside down?
- 23:16 – How do you get Protestants to stop dismissing the Church Fathers?
- 28:45 – How do we know that Ignatius of Antioch and Polycarp were disciples of John the Apostle?
- 32:50 – Why are Ed and Lorraine Warren problematic since they were Catholic?
- 39:44 – What are the consequences of being re-baptized?
- 43:40 – If Jews get a new temple they would begin animal sacrifices, but Christ was the final sacrifice. Is this why God has allowed enemies to control the temple mount?
- 48:05 – What exactly constitutes full consent of the will in regard to mortal sin?
Does changing the words during the consecration make the Eucharist invalid? We dive into what the Church teaches about the essential form of the sacrament and also address confession practices, Orthodox weddings in Catholic churches, and bridging the gap with Protestants on faith and works.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 08:00 – Adams providential testimony.
- 28:47 – I go to confession every month and I was told that I shouldn’t give a number of times I commit a sin. Is this ok to omit?
- 32:48 – Can an Orthodox wedding ceremony happen inside of a Catholic Church? Can My husband attend the wedding?
- 35:32 – If using the wrong words during baptism, it makes it invalid. Would the same logic apply to the Eucharist and the words of consecration?
- 40:18 – How do I bridge the gap with my Protestant friends? Why are Protestants so hung up on salvation by faith alone? What is the downside of works?
If the Old Testament was accepted without an infallible Church, why is that needed for the New Testament? We explore this key apologetics question, along with topics like apostolic succession, Catholic-Orthodox unity, and defending the faith online.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 05:25 – If the Old Testament can be known without an infallible authority, then how come we can’t have that for the New Testament?
- 16:23 – How do you defend the faith against Protestants on social media? Is it better to find common ground or go on striking on what they oppose?
- 21:29 – If God is immaterial and he created the material world how do you explain the interaction between the material and immaterial substances?
- 29:00 – What efforts are being done by the Catholic Church to facilitate the union between them and the Orthodox?
- 35:54 – Regarding the crusades, how do we rationalize and defend the idea that the pope offered forgiveness of sins for those going on a military expedition?
- 48:32 – How do you defend protestant questions on apostolic succession?
Does free will really exist, and how does Catholicism explain it? We explore the Church’s teaching on human freedom, how to defend it in conversations, and also tackle questions about burial and cremation, suffering, Jesus’ childhood, and even pseudoarchaeology.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 01:21 – Supposing a cannibal eats a Christian, and then the cannibal gets converted, who gets which bits in the resurrection?
- 12:37 – Is the requirement to receive communion to not be conscious of mortal sin or grave sin? I ask because the official canon law says grave sin, but grave sins can be venial in the case of addiction
- 14:13 – Could you clarify the Catholic teachings on burial, specifically concerning what is/isn’t permitted, and what is preferred. I’ve been told that cremation isn’t forbidden, but scattering ashes is, due to our desire to respect the body.
- 20:49 – Can you explain the problem with Islam: Is the word of Allah separate from Allah?
- 22:41 – What was Jesus’ life like in childhood and adolescence?
- 24:41 – What is the catholic understanding of free will, and how can we argue for it?
- 37:00 – What are cardinals and how did that position become established?
- 41:45 – I know that God brings a greater good from evil He allows and that He helps save our brothers and sisters through OUR efforts but are those the only answers to why God would allow tens of millions of people to starve under Mao and Stalin? Or why so many people, including children, are trafficked, and satanically ritually abused? I mean the scale of human pain is mind-blowing. Is the realization of our impotence in the face of evil and our need to surrender to God for help the point?
- 48:13 – Recently a real Archaeologist Flint Dibble debated Graham Hancock a pseudo archaeologist. Are you still planning on doing an episode on pseudo archaeology? Would you consider interviewing someone like him for it? There seems to be a war brewing between mainstream archaeology and a few camps of pseudo archaeology online. I have to admit, I was in one of these camps until I watched a good volume of your material.
- 50:21 – I would like to know if it is true that Our Lady of Fatima told Lucia, that Francesco would pass and his soul would be in purgatory until the end of time. It is hard to believe that a child would have such horrible sins that would keep him there for so long.
What happens if someone receives a sacrament while pretending to be someone else? We explore a wild baptism scenario involving identical twins and what it means for the validity and liceity of the sacrament. Plus, we tackle guardian angels, Mass in space, miracles, and the mystery of God’s plan.Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click HereQuestions Covered:02:52 – Considering most of your show is about theology I was wondering if you experience anything more on the personal side. 13:25 – Would it be permissible for a Catholic to believe that God knows all possible multiverses and chose to create the one we are in where we have freewill and God reveals himself and incarnates as Jesus to help us know God, but that the universe basically runs on its own and our choices are our own. Would that be a way to reconcile that God has a plan, but that we also have free will? 18:20 – Why does God allow miracles in some cases but not others, especially in reference to Matthew 18:19 which states, “Again I say to you, if two of you agree on earth about anything they ask, it will be done for them by my Father in heaven”? For example, why does this not apply when groups of people are praying for someone to be healed and they are not. 23:25 – Jesus said, “I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except by me.” Did he mean that he, Jesus Christ is the door, or did he mean “the way, the truth, and the life” is the door? Or both? 28:42 – Does Mary have the same kind of guardian angel as we do? Could it possibly be Gabriel? Is there any value in contemplating the guardian angels of others? 34:49 – You mentioned something about shared death experiences (where someone else will be in the room when someone is dying and someone will be in the room who is not dying and they both experience the visions) in one of your videos. Have you come across any contemporary accounts of these that are credible? Asking for my friend who is a grad student in philosophy. 37:46 – I was wondering about Holy Mass and space travel. if you were traveling near lightspeed, let’s say 99% , You start to experience some heavy time dilation. Specifically at 99% light speed you’re you are experiencing 14% of the time that passes on Earth relative to an observer on Earth. Would your Sunday obligation depend on Earth time or ship time assuming there’s a priest on the ship? I figured it out that there will be about one day for a week so you could do mass everyday, but I was also wondering about calculating the date of Easter while you’re on a relativistic speed journey. Would the priest need to start Mass at the short time that it’s still Easter on Earth? 43:30 – Is it a correct understanding of the teaching of the Catechism of the Council of Trent to say that the expression “God died” is not to be understood literally but rather figuratively (i.e., anthropomorphism and/or synecdoche)? 46:25 – Let’s say there are two identical twin sisters, Kait and Leia. Neither are baptized, but Kait wishes to become baptized. For reasons, Leia does not want her sister to be baptized, and so has her sister kidnapped. Leia pretends to be her sister Kait and receives the sacrament. Question: When the priest says, “I baptize you *Kait in the name….”, how does this affect the validity and liceity of the sacrament? Is Leia actually baptized? What about Kait?
Protestants often ask how Catholics can believe in sacraments, purgatory, and the Mass while affirming that Jesus’ sacrifice was once and for all. We explain how Catholic theology upholds this truth, along with insights into purgatory, salvation, and the unity of the Church.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 00:45 – The Bottom Line on The Natural Law
- 10:02 – What passages can I use as evidence for purgatory that a protestant will accept, especially 1 Corinthians?
- 14:32 – Why do Catholics believe there could only be one Church?
- 30:11 – I’m Protestant moving closer to Catholicism. How does Catholicism view the once and for all Sacrifice of Jesus considering all the things Catholics believe in like sacraments and purgatory?
- 36:50 – How do I refute the Protestant view that we are all one church?
- 45:59 – How do Catholics respond to the question: Are you saved?
- 49:40 – Regarding Baptist baptism. Would their intent to baptize confer grace even if they don’t believe it is salvific?
Many Protestants see relics as idolatrous—but are they? We explore the biblical and historical support for relics in Catholicism, and also answer questions on praying to saints, Marian apparitions, and what makes Good Friday “good.”
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 04:54 – How do we support the use of relics when Protestants see it as idolatry?
- 14:01 – I’m in OCIA. How are Catholics different from Gnostics and Protestants?
- 21:29 – The bible tells us not to seek mediums or speak to the deceased. How is it then you can speak to the saints?
- 34:53 – My protestant sister asked me, why do they call it Good Friday if that was the day Jesus suffered and died? Who gave it that name?
- 42:03 – Why do Catholics take John 6 literally but John 6:58 sounds more metaphorical?
- 48:39 – How do we know that Marian apparitions are not taking away attention from Jesus? How do we get the title of Queen of Heaven for her?
What sets the Catholic Church apart from other faiths? We explore the historical, theological, and spiritual reasons to choose Catholicism, along with questions about evolution and the conditions for a valid Eucharistic consecration.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 17:00 – I’m a convert. If a priest walked into a bakery and said the words of consecration, would the bread become Jesus?
- 21:54 – Why Catholicism over any other religion?
- 46:01 – How do Catholics approach evolution?
What does the Church say about receiving the Eucharist if your annulment hasn’t been finalized? We explore this important question and also discuss healing after divorce, reuniting with a former spouse, and how to approach annulments with non-Catholic partners.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 18:42 – I’m in a civil marriage that needs an annulment on behalf of my wife. How do you get a non-Catholic to support the annulment process?
- 22:42 – I went through an annulment. I found it easiest to focus on writing out a draft and presenting it
- 32:10 – My annulment was the best thing that has happened to me. It allowed me to fully recognize my now Catholic Marriage.
- 37:34 – What do you think about the idea that more attention needs to be placed on the person who is not seeking out the annulment?
- 40:42 – I’m a good practicing Catholic and I don’t want a divorce, but I can’t handle the abuse, he’s a narcissist. What should I do?
- 44:21 – I’m 59 and my ex-husband remarried civilly. Should I seek out an annulment to help him out?
- 50:28 – Is it ok for me to receive communion even though I left the annulment process incomplete?
- 53:29 – I married my husband, we got a divorce and then got back together. Do I need an annulment?
With evidence of burial rituals and culture, were Neanderthals spiritual beings like us? We explore their place in theology, along with topics like praying in dreams, moral behavior in animals, the nature of heaven, and whether we could ever learn like computers.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 01:13 – What physical explanation can parapsychology offer? Because one thing is describing phenomena, another one is explaining it in a physical framework.
- 11:15 – How are we to consider our Neanderthal cousins? They were hominids, close enough to us that we interbred (I have more than the average Neanderthal DNA), they had a culture, and there is evidence that they not only buried their dead, but buried flowers and grave goods with them, hinting at a belief in the afterlife. Yet, they were different from us, and they went extinct millennia before the Incarnation. Theologically, how are they considered? semi-Neanderthal minds want to know!
- 16:31 – Can animals act in ways that are morally good or evil? i.e. the dog that saves the child vs the dog that bites the child. What implications, if any, would that have on the prospect of an animal afterlife?
- 22:44 – If I am asleep and I dream that I am praying, is it possible that God and the saints I ask for intercession hear those prayers? And if I receive a blessing in the context of my dream, is it possible that some minor intercession has occurred?
- 29:15 – If a sincere penitent in the confessional confesses that he has set a bear trap outside the priest’s confessional, set to go off the moment the priest exits the confessional, could the priest require the penitent to remove the bear trap as a part of his penance? Or can the priest not make requirements like that in order to give absolution? (One that I’ve actually gotten from my students!)
- 34:34 – Tell us about your Arkansas accent. It’s coming on pretty thick these days. I assume you lost it when you moved to CA and now that your back you just naturally fell back into it?
- 41:30 – I’ve never heard anyone address this: after the resurrection, we will be reunited with our physical bodies. So is heaven a physical place?
- 44:15 – Growing up I was told that our souls wander about while we sleep as an explanation for Deja vu. I know in the past you’ve attributed Deja vu to remote viewing, how similar are these 2 ideas?
- 52:45 – The mystery of learning and memory. Why can’t humans learn, store, and recall information in the same way a computer does (i.e. massive storage, data compressibility/extractability, can download and upload information, etc.)? It would seem extremely beneficial if humans could learn via download and share via upload like computers. Just to qualify I mean the speed of data transfer as well. For example, instead of spending years learning a new language, just download it and have perfect fluency (similar to the Matrix and how Neo could learn things).
Can a kamikaze-style sacrifice ever be morally justified? We explore the ethics of self-sacrifice in sci-fi scenarios and real life, along with deep (and wild) questions about vampires, psychiatric visions, Jesus’ second coming, and even the Rick Astley paradox.Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click HereQuestions Covered:02:23 – If someone were to kill everyone on earth to force Jesus’s second coming, would Jesus come? If the person did it to save everyone so they can all go to heaven, would this make them a good or bad person? 05:00 – Are heaven and hell customized for you and how you lived? 06:55 – If you sacrifice your life for God, do you go to hell for committing suicide? 14:45 – Could a killer whale get a taste for human flesh? 17:55 – I worked as a firefighter/EMT for a while and people prided themselves about having a stiff upper lip and a tough cynical personality. I got to thinking, some people are more docile, and some seem to pride themselves in having a rough edge. When we are perfected in heaven, will we all have the same disposition/temperament and just different talents and interests, or will our different dispositions remain? 22:01 – How will a body not be destroyed when living on earth forever? For example—If you fall off a cliff or get crushed? 28:57 – Can you please comment on the moral implications of the following? In Return of the Jedi, an A wing pilot gets shot down and plows his ship into the bridge of the Executor. Can a space pilot do this if death is a near certainty become a kamikaze? Or, in 2009’s Star Trek movie, Captain Kirk’s father stays behind and navigates the Kelvin on a collision course with the Romulan vessel to protect escaping shuttles. He sacrifices himself and the ship to save his son. Can the captain of a ship stay behind to again be a kamikaze to inflict heavy damage on somebody else and/or save other people if it means certain death? 32:59 – My Mom and sister are both nurses in a psych ward. They have had hundreds of patients who claim to see Angel’s and Demons. Some patients who claim they have seen them also knew personal information they shouldn’t have about Mom and Sister. Do you think these people are actually connected to the spiritual realm in a way we aren’t or is it just a mental illness? 38:08 – If a priest were to become a vampire, would he have to retire? 41:30 – If Santa Claus (not St Nicholas) were to die would he go to heaven? 44:01 – Will we see Wooly Mammoths in our lifetime? Will they really be Wooly Mammoths or something else that looks like them? 48:46 – How does the Rick Astley paradox work? Here’s how it goes: If you ask Rick Astley for a copy of the movie Up he can’t give it to you because he can’t give you Up but if he doesn’t give you Up he lets you down. This has been my hardest question since I heard it. What do you think? 50:54 – Sorry this is kind of a gross one. A few years back, there was a news story about a man who had his leg amputated and then had his friends over for a party where they ate tacos made from his amputated leg. While this is definitely strange, is it necessarily immoral?
Some claim Catholics trust the Church more than Christ—but is that true? We explore this common misunderstanding along with questions on Jesus’ “brothers,” historical temple virgins, and how to reach out to loved ones who feel unwelcome in the Church.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 01:55 – I’ve heard that Catholics put more of their faith in the Church over Jesus. What is your response to that?
- 16:37 – How do we know that the brothers of Jesus were actually cousins?
- 24:47 – Are there historical sources for Jew temple virgins?
- 40:52 – Is there anything I can say or do other than pray, to help a loved one soften their hearts on their belief that the Church is unwelcoming?
A common misconception is that Mary’s perpetual virginity is optional to believe. We clarify Church teaching and how to explain it respectfully, along with insights on binding and loosing, the birth control pill, and how to talk about pornography and marriage.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 06:30 – Does binding and loosing represent the Sensus Fidelium?
- 13:35 – Why is the pill considered abortifacient?
- 19:22 – Does God operate based on condition? I can’t wrap my head around the principle of double effect.
- 30:46 – How do I explain to my daughter in law who’s going to OCIA the perpetual virginity? She learned in class that the Church has never clarified and that her perpetual virginity is optional to believe?
- 42:54 – We tend to hear in TOB circles that men who are addicted to pornography should be avoided when considering marriage? Would you say the same start can be used for women?
- 51:27 – How do you avoid making circular arguments for the papacy and magisterium?
Romans 8–9 is often cited in support of Calvinist theology—but is that the only way to read it? We explore a Catholic interpretation of these powerful chapters, along with questions about the priesthood, interfaith prayer, and the role of bishops in setting fasting rules.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 1:00 – Why does the office of the priesthood deserve reverence and respect and how is it beautiful?
- 08:23 – What kind of authority does a bishop have over fasting rules?
- 14:40 – Will there be a new temple built in Jerusalem?
- 18:52 – How do I read Romans 8-9 without reading Calvinism into it?
- 29:28 – Pope Francis inaugurated the Abrahamic house. Is it smart to be praying with Muslims?
- 36:40 – How do I respond when I don’t know the answers?
- 47:31 – Where do you see the papacy in the Council of Nicaea?
Is it really possible for spiritual harm to be passed down through families? We explore the Church’s view on generational curses and demonic influence, along with insights on martyrdom, the Eucharist, and the connection between Revelation and the Gospel of John.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 03:58 – Is Jesus’ view of election the same as the parable as the wedding feast?
- 10:20 – I’ve never been able to understand, how is the incarnation not a change?
- 17:45 – Is there a connection between Revelation and the gospel of John in regard to the relationship between Jesus and Mary?
- 23:32 – What are the rules and guidelines for picking a confirmation saint?
- 33:02 – Do you think it real or possible for people to experience demonic activity due to family curses?
- 42:28 – What does it take to be considered a martyr in the Church?
- 47:01 – Why do some people not see a change in their lives after they receive communion for many years?
- 50:22 – If we consider Baptist Christians, would they go to heaven, purgatory or hell?
Some Catholics are concerned about recent changes to synod structures and future decisions. We take a closer look at Pope Paul VI’s vision for synods, the Church’s stance on women’s ordination and same-sex unions, and answer more on valid marriage, frozen embryos, and Mary’s sinlessness.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 14:40 – Why does the pope not follow Pope Paul VI’s understanding of synods only being made up of Cardinals? Will he allow women priests and homosexual weddings?
- 20:50 – What does the Church require for a marriage to be valid?
- 24:36 – Why doesn’t the Church have an articulated position on frozen embryos?
- 33:14 – Why does the Catholic moral belief prioritize the individual and neighbor over family and kin?
- 41:34 – Why does the Church believe in patron saints?
- 46:43 – If Mary was human, how was she sinless?
- 48:09 – Why aren’t the remains of a cremated loved one allowed to be kept in a home?
- 51:06 – Why do we believe in the God of the Old Testament?
Many Protestants ask why Catholics follow papal authority when it’s not explicitly stated in Scripture. We explore the biblical and historical roots of the papacy and also explain why Catholics reject sola scriptura, differences in baptism, and the rules around receiving Communion.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 07:16 – Why do Catholics follow the doctrines and orders of the pope even if it’s not written in the bible?
- 19:00 – Why don’t Catholics follow Sola Scriptura?
- 37:24 – Why is baptism different among Catholics vs Baptists?
- 47:20 – Why can’t non-Catholics receive communion at a Catholic Church? How would one explain it to them?
Navigating Mass with an estranged spouse can be difficult, especially when co-parenting. Dr. Ray offers guidance on maintaining peace and setting a good example for children, along with insights on family boundaries, self-compassion, and recognizing spiritual experiences in prayer.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 21:06 – Navigating Mass with an estranged spouse: How can he foster peace while co-parenting post-divorce?
- 30:20 – Is it ethical to challenge therapists who advise cutting off family members? A listener questions Dr. Ray’s stance.
- 36:04 – How can he manage negative self-talk and stop assuming the worst about others’ intentions?
- 41:21 – She struggles with being her own worst critic—what are some practical tools for self-compassion?
- 44:25 – She and her father are estranged from her younger sister—how can she start the path to reconciliation?
- 49:02 – Therapy vs. self-help: Can Dr. Ray expand on why seeing a therapist is different from following social media advice?
- 51:25 – Is a peaceful, tingling feeling during prayer a sign of the Holy Spirit? How can he discern spiritual experiences?
Opus Dei often sparks curiosity—and controversy. But what is it really, and how does it function within the wider Catholic Church? We explore this question and also discuss papal resignation and the balance of free will and institutional pressure.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 33:36 – Does a papal resignation raise concerns about free will vs. pressure within the Vatican?
- 37:31 – What is Opus Dei, and how does it fit into the larger Catholic faith?
If intelligent alien or fictional species like Vulcans or Hobbits existed, could they be ordained as priests? We dive into this speculative theology question and also explore Marian devotion, dowsing, near-death experiences, and papal infallibility.
Questions Covered:
- 02:59 – Would other intelligent creatures (like hobbits or vulcans) become priests?
- 08:29 – Could a Catholic holding all that the Church teaches on Mary believe that she’s overemphasized?
- 12:03 – What are the “living waters” discussed in John 4?
- 15:32 – I’ve seen your videos on dowsing. Is dowsing for future events permissible, or is it considered divination?
- 24:55 – Can a consecration be valid if one item is defective?
- 30:58 – Why do most people who have Near-Death Experiences that are not religious or mention Jesus?
- 36:01 – How do you meditate on the rosary while saying the vocal prayers?
- 40:21 – When Jesus talks about “a divided kingdom” and the demons, what is he talking about?
- 46:20 – If the pope were to make a definitive statement, could half of it be infallible and the other half be fallible?
- 51:44 – What are the limitations of a bishop over the liturgical functions of a diocese?
If a gorilla could understand the Gospel through sign language, could it be saved? We explore this unusual but fascinating question, plus why St. Philomena’s feast was removed, the Church’s view on devotionals, and how to approach celibacy in unexpected life situations.
Questions Covered:
- 03:38 – How can I invite my college Newman Center to a seder dinner as part of an interfaith event?
- 08:32 – Why was St. Philomena’s feast day removed from the Roman Calendar?
- 12:38 – If a person could evangelize via sign language to a gorilla, could the gorilla be saved?
- 24:33 – Does the Church have a stance on devotionals that seem to put words in God’s mouth?
- 32:05 – How do I respond to the claim that situations like David and the bread of the temple or Jesus’ disciples eating on the sabbath should be applied to same-sex relationships?
- 42:46 – Catechism 1658 talks about single persons — not by choice, but by life circumstance–; is God calling them to celibacy? If God is all-knowing, why would He call people to a vocation they can’t fulfill?
- 49:00 – What is the threshold for the Church to make a public excommunication of an individual(s) spreading hatred explicitly or implicitly and claiming the Catholic faith informs their hateful worldview?
- 52:21 – Where does St. Veronica come from? Why are there three times Christ falls in the Stations when the Bible says he fell once?
Are Marian doctrines like the Immaculate Conception and the Assumption late inventions, or do they have earlier roots? We explore pre-Augustinian thought, why some doctrines develop differently, and how Marian beliefs compare to teachings like eternal security and sola fide.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 12:41 – I know the Eucharist is the Body, Blood, Soul & Divinity of Jesus. Is it his Resurrected body?
- 16:30 – Do we have any prior to Augustine who taught the concept of the Immaculate Conception and the Assumption? Why is the argument of time work for eternal security and sola fide, but not Marian doctrines?
- 47:30 – Have you read “Jesus Wept”?
Are all Catholics bound by the same beliefs, regardless of rite? We explore the unity and diversity within the Catholic Church, plus discuss attending Byzantine parishes, Marian theology in the East, and inter-rite confessions.
Questions Covered:
- 10:17 – Can a priest of a certain rite celebrate the Eucharist in a different rite?
- 15:21 – Do the Eastern Catholic Churches believe in Mary the same way the Orthodox?
- 19:15 – Have any of the Eastern Catholic Churches undergo sweeping liturgical changes like the Latin Rite?
- 19:15 – Have any of the Eastern Catholic Churches undergone sweeping liturgical changes like the Latin Rite?
- 25:15 – How do you answer the objection that the early Church was Orthodox, not Catholic?
- 29:59 – As a Roman Catholic, can I attend a Byzantine Parish to fulfill my Sunday obligation?
- 34:30 – You helped me in my conversion. Is there anything in the Bible to help me point my wife towards Catholicism?
- 45:29 – What was the biggest adjustment when you started attending the Byzantine Rite?
- 46:43 – Why do we use “the Roman Catholic Church” to refer to all the rites? Can’t we just use “The Catholic Church” and use “Roman Catholic” for the specific rite?
- 48:40 – Did you take it easy on George Janko?
- 51:08 – Can I get Confession from an Eastern Rite priest?
- 53:00 – Are Eastern Catholics required to believe everything that other Catholics are required to believe?
In this episode, the Flannel Panel goes through the biased takes of NPR and offers commentary from a Catholic perspective.
Topics Covered:
- 03:30 – Understanding the context of NPR
- 05:15 – What are religious people divided on according to NPR
With so many voices on social media and YouTube, is Catholicism gaining ground in the digital world? We explore the Church’s online presence and also look at trends in adult conversions to the faith.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Topics Covered:
- 09:00 – Are more adults converting to Catholicism?
- 33:00 – Are Catholics winning online?
Is it required belief that St. Joseph remained celibate his whole life? We explore Church teaching on this tradition and also dive into Mary’s sorrowful apparitions, obedience to the pope, and infant baptism debates with Protestants.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 12:03 – Why does Mary sometimes appear sad, like at appearance la Salette and in the seven sorrows of Mary?
- 19:20 – Is it necessary for Catholics to believe that St. Joseph was a perpetual virgin?
- 34:36 – My OBGYN is recommending that I do not have any more pregnancies after having an ectopic pregnancy. What should I do?
- 38:35 – When scripture speaks of Jesus having Brothers and Sisters, are those cousins?
- 43:14 – How do I respond to Protestants that say infant baptism is not correct because scripture says “repent and be baptized” but infants cannot repent? Is it sinful to have incorrect understanding of Catholic doctrines and teachings.
- 46:01 – How far does obedience to the pope go? What are the parameters in which we can disagree with the Pope?
What happens if the priest or pastor doesn’t say the exact words during a baptism? Does it still count? We explore the Church’s teaching on valid baptism, plus questions on receiving Communion before convalidation, judgment after death, and depictions of Jesus in iconography.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 06:19 – I’m having my marriage convalidated in a couple of weeks. I will go to confession the day before. The next day I will go to Mass at 9am and the convalidation ceremony is at 1pm. Can I receive Eucharist at Mass or do I have to wait until after the convalidation?
- 09:08 – Is my baptism valid? The pastor changed the words.
- 17:33 – When do the general judgment (Mt. 25-31) and individual judgment (Hebrews 9:27) take place?
- 22:21 – If Mary had said no, would that have been her exercising her free will and not committing sin?
- 32:01 – As Catholics how should we practically approach suffering and should we pray to have it removed?
- 38:12 – Why do Catholics believe they can get messages from guardian angels, specifically regarding Archangel Gabriel on this solemnity of the Annunciation?
- 48:43 – Where to start with learning to sing the Psalter? What radio?
- 52:23 – In iconography, why is Jesus usually painted white when he was probably darker skinned?
If the writings of the Church Fathers aren’t part of the Bible, why do they matter? We explore their authority and role in understanding the faith, plus tackle questions about God’s omniscience, Eucharistic miracles, and why Mary doesn’t appear more often in Scripture.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 04:15 – I constantly hear that God knows everything that’s going to happen, but in the Old Testament He changed His mind. It sounds like a contradiction.
- 10:02 – How seriously should I take the ancient church fathers given that they are not sacred scripture?
- 13:50 – How do I get atheists/agnostics to recognize the bible as a legitimate source?
- 16:00 – On the assumption that God is all-powerful, merciful, etc. Then why would he make us if he knew we were going to go through all this suffering and anguish?
- 22:52 – Is heaven empty until Jesus returns? If not, then how can Catholics believe that we all go to sleep and enter heaven until the second coming?
- 30:59 – In the Our Father, what is the true meaning of” thy kingdom come, thy will be done, on earth as it is in heaven?”
- 35:14 – How is it possible for Satan to stand in the presence of God in Job if evil can’t withstand the presence of God?
- 41:00 – Why doesn’t Mary appear more in the Bible for all the reverence we give her?
- 46:01 – Debating with a Christian who claims Eucharistic miracles are demonic; how do I respond to them?
- 51:46 – Why should I care if there is a God?
Many Marian prayers mention having “recourse” to her—but where does that phrase come from, and is it something Catholics are required to believe? We explore its origin and meaning, plus questions on Mary’s titles, Christ’s conception, and the early practice of the sign of the cross.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 04:44 – Many prayers to Mary say we have recourse to her. What is the origin of that? Is it required to believe that?
- 08:12 – In the liturgy it says that Christ was conceived through the overshadowing of the Holy Spirit. Doesn’t the bible say “the most high” overshadowed her?
- 12:30 – How can Mary be both the spouse of Joseph and the spouse of the Holy Spirit? It’s kind of uncomfortable to hear that.
- 17:14 – When CCC 674 says Jesus won’t come back until he is recognized by “all of Israel,” who are they talking about?
- 23:21 – How early on did the practice of making the sign of the cross happen?
- 28:39 – Why do we withhold the Eucharist from adults up until confirmation?
- 33:33 – If you forget to confess sins during confession are they absolved or is it a valid confession?
- 37:50 – When we are in heaven do we reflect on our lives on earth?
- 42:55 – What are your thoughts on children marrying someone who’s not Catholic?
- 46:31 – I’m Catholic but this is a question that I get from atheists: Why did God create us in the first place?
- 50:02 – How do I talk to a very combative protestant who demonizes everything the Church teaches?
Are we responsible for staying silent when others sin? We explore what Scripture says, plus why some parishes don’t offer the chalice, how to pray for a seriously ill loved one, and the meaning of “action follows being” in Thomistic philosophy.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 02:44 – Where does it say in the bible that we would be culpable if we don’t speak up against someone else’s sin?
- 10:57 – Do you think the people present at the Tower of Babel were different races?
- 24:18 – Why do some parishes not offer the chalice during communion?
- 35:00 – What type of novena or sacrifice should I be doing for my very ill 27-year-old daughter?
- 50:58 – What evidence do we have for the Thomistic principle of action following being?
What exactly is a Pride Mass, and does it meet the requirements of a valid Catholic Mass? We break it down and also tackle topics like abstaining from meat, Mary’s need for a Savior, and the authority of Scripture in Catholic teaching.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 05:16 – Do arguments for the resurrection work?
- 12:59 – Is there a difference in worshipping Jesus and God the Father?
- 17:20 – I’m a convert from Orthodoxy. Were my confessions as an Orthodox considered valid now that I’m Catholic?
- 21:34 – I went to confession and got my sins absolved. What happened to my soul?
- 29:30 – Are children required to abstain from meat during lent? Are we adults supposed to abstain from meat on non-lent Fridays?
- 35:07 – Why did Mary need a savior?
- 43:20 – What is a pride mass? Is it a valid mass? If not, why is it allowed?
- 47:09 – Do we believe in scripture as being the final authority since we always refer to it as evidence?
Some claim Jesus was Muslim, but what does history—and Jesus’ own words—actually show? We break down how to respond to this argument and also explore topics like Halloween costumes, the woman in Revelation 12, sacred art, and purgatory.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 13:36 – Toddler wants to dress up as a witch for Halloween, is it ok, would like more clarification on what the church teaches?
- 20:16 – Sheol is hell not Purgatory, could clarify this statement?
- 24:10 – I run into folks who argue that Jesus was Muslim, I attempt to tell them he was not, that Jesus was of Jewish descent. How can I more adequately speak to them?
- 30:18 – Revelation 12, who is the woman, and passage regarding birth pangs and representing Mary? And is it ok to interpret the woman as representing the Church and not Mary?
- 36:45 – Why in sacred images is God the Father sometimes depicted with a body when scripture says he has no body
- 42:05 – Travels for work, attends Latin Mass and sees a lot of young people at Mass, would like Joe’s thoughts on why that is
- 49:16 – How does purgatory relate to plenary indulgences?
- 50:48 – My daughter passed away 3 years ago. She professed being a Christian on her deathbed. Was this enough?
Is it valid or even permissible to attend a Mass led by an excommunicated priest or bishop? We explore this complex issue and also dive into questions on Mary’s perpetual virginity, altar calls at Pentecostal services, and the meaning behind “baptism for the dead.”
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 04:55 – My wife is Pentecostal and I attend early morning Mass and then Pentecostal service with wife and children I want to know if it is ok to go up to altar call with my wife and children?
- 14:53 – How to refute quantum mechanics disproving the Aristotelian proof of God and Causality
- 18:22 – Perpetual Vigirnity of Mary. Is it reasonable to think that St. Joseph did not know that Mary had taken a vow of Virginity?
- 24:30 – St. Paul, scripture, baptism for the dead, he has a theory of what it means, wants to get Joe’s take…He thinks baptism for those who are dead in their sin
- 32:50 – Why does St. Paul go against the Council of Jerusalem when he says some Christians can eat meat sacrificed to idols?
- 36:25 – Can I attend a Mass that is being celebrated by an excommunicated priest or bishop?
- 42:41 – Mary’s role as intercessor in light of Lukes passages on sword piercing her soul, and the Magnificat.
- 47:04 – Girlfriend died 3 years ago, he led her to Christ, wants to know if he can still pray to her, even though she may be in Purgatory, and can he ask her to pray for him
- 52:04 – Calling back with follow-up question, his wife does not want the kids baptized in the Catholic Church. Should he still passively participate?
Some claim Catholic practices resemble idol worship—but is that true? Joe Heschmeyer explores the distinction, along with the role of Marian dogmas, the qualifications to be an altar server, and advice for those returning to the Catholic faith.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 04:51 – I’m in OCIA. What are the qualifications to be a server at the altar?
- 13:28 – I’m returning to the Catholic Faith. Do I still proceed to return or wait until I clear up my lack of understanding?
- 24:09 – I’m a convert. How is what we do, not considered idol worship?
- 37:14 – What is the relevance of Marian dogmas for Christians?
Struggling with scrupulosity and unsure how it fits within the Catholic faith? Joe Heschmeyer explores how to navigate this challenge, along with preparing for OCIA, understanding the Eucharist in John 6, and the biblical basis for praying to saints.
Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here
Questions Covered:
- 10:51 – I’m looking into Catholicism. What should I be doing in preparation for starting OCIA classes?
- 29:33 – I’ve been told that I have really bad scrupulosity, and I don’t see how that is compatible with Catholicism.
- 38:30 – Are Catholics wrong about the Eucharist because of John 6:60-63?
- 41:51 – I’m in OCIA. What do candidates do if they sin since they can’t go to confession?
- 46:35 – Why do Catholics pray to the saints? Is there a scriptural basis for it?
If Christ is our sole mediator, why does the Church encourage prayer to saints? We explore the biblical foundation for intercession, along with Catholic teaching on mediums, Purgatory, and receiving glorified bodies in Heaven.
Questions Covered:
- 07:21 – What is the Catholic stand about mediums?
- 15:29 – Can we speak to people in the past in any other way apart from pagan means?
- 18:57 – Why do we pray to Saints when Jesus says there is only one intercessor?
- 37:27 – Did Pope John Paul II originate the idea of receiving our glorified bodies in Heaven?
- 47:00 – Can you explain what Purgatory is like for people? Can you pray for yourself in Purgatory
Many employers struggle to find skilled and confident young workers—Jacob Imama, Founder of the College of St. Joseph the Worker explores why this is happening. We explore the challenges in hiring today’s workforce, along with advice for carpenters on pricing their work, words of encouragement for tradesmen, and biblical insights on land surveying.
Questions Covered:
- 20:11 – 45-year machinist wants to give Jacob words of encouragement and is thrilled about the College of St. Joseph the Worker.
- 28:20 – I am a carpenter who just started my own business. How do I appropriately price my work for clients, so it is fair but also takes care of my family?
- 32:24 – I find it hard to find and hire capable young men. Boys and young men just don’t seem confident to learn or try.
- 41:41 – What are your thoughts on the practice of land surveying as it appears in the bible?
Some Protestants argue that Catholicism is a cult—how should you answer? Andrew Petiprin tackles this common objection and discusses misconceptions about the Church, early Christian history, and the differences between Catholicism and other denominations.
Questions Covered:
- 12:25 – I’m Protestant. How would you respond to the claim that the Catholic Church is a cult?
- 23:04 – Why do people have misconceptions about Catholicism, especially to other Christians faiths?
- 35:45 – What do you recommend doing to dispel someone from the idea that Catholicism is just another denomination?
- 44:35 – How would I respond to the claim that the Church for the first 700 years was trying to limit its ideas?
- 52:05 – I’m Protestant but my son is Catholic. My daughter’s father-in-law told me that he was going to go to hell for not converting me. How do I respond?
When should you rely on faith alone, and when is it time to seek professional help? Gary Zimak tackles questions on giving up worrying for Lent and more, including Scripture recommendations, and accepting life’s crosses.
Questions Covered:
- 15:00 – How do we give up worry in a case where one has clinical depression?
- 18:44 – What good scripture and writing from the Church Fathers do you recommend I read?
- 23:12 – I’ve used therapy, and it never helped. Now that I follow faith it’s been a huge change. Should I still continue traditional therapy?
- 34:45 – I want to improve my faith life before seeking professional help for anxiety. How do I know whether or not I need to seek professional help, or I’m simply just not trying enough with my faith life? I feel like getting professional help would be “failing” or giving up on trying to solve my anxiety with Jesus. How do I know when I’ve tried hard enough that I need outside help?
- 42:17 – I worry about a friend who has basically given up in life. How do I help or stop worrying?
- 46:57 – How does one accept that life will have crosses, and that life is not always happy?
- 49:11 – I personally went through a period of terrible anxiety due to a traumatic event. I was given medication, and it helped so much! Both prayer and medication can be from God.
Could a dream about purgatory have spiritual significance, or is it just the mind at work? Jimmy Akin explores how to approach such dreams and answers more on the Eucharist, spiritual warfare, and hyper-charismatic movements.
Questions Covered:
- 01:08 – I’ve had a frightening dream about purgatory. How should I approach or interpret it?
- 12:43 – Is water witching a form of divination?
- 22:00 – How would you introduce the truth of the Eucharist to a layperson who doesn’t believe or objects?
- 29:00 – Could you explain lesser Yahweh and how it relates to the figure Yahoel and the angel Metatron?
- 34:36 – My son joined a hyper-charismatic group. What can I do to help besides praying for him? Is there a book that would help me defend the faith?
- 44:01 – How could I as a Non-Denominational Christian seek help with spiritual warfare?
- 52:56 – My estranged son is trying to get married by a friend who is “ordained” by the internet. Should I attend this?
If God created human life on other planets, would original sin apply to them? Jimmy Akin explores this fascinating question and more, including papal authority, Friday fasting rules, and Confession in non-church marriages.
Questions Covered:
- 03:56 – How do I approach my non-ecclesiastical marriage in terms of the martial embrace and Confession?
- 11:23 – Can you explain why Christians should be subject to the pope?
- 13:40 – I had collagen mixed with my coffee today. Is that against the Friday fast and abstinence?
- 17:13 – Did priests celebrating the Mass at the time of RFK Sr.’s funeral celebrate in English and Latin?
- 19:20 – Was concelebration allowed before Vatican II?
- 20:46 – What do you think about the claim “God tortures people in hell for eternity”?
- 29:22 – My estranged daughter was diagnosed with borderline personality disorder; how should I react to this? Should I go to Confession?
- 37:34 – If God created human beings on other planets, would the sin of Adam and Eve affect those humans?
- 42:46 – Can priests forgive excommunications centered around abortion?
- 46:30 – A pastor I know said that in Hebrews, it proves we no longer need priests; how do I respond to this?
- 50:44 – How do I remain consistent with my faith while having ADHD and commitment issues?
How Do You Defend Papal Primacy Using Scripture? And More
What biblical evidence supports the Pope’s authority and the early Church’s foundation in Rome? Joe Heschmeyer explores this question and more from the audience at SEEK 2025, including Sheol’s transformation after Christ, infant baptism, and the Real Presence in Anglican and Orthodox churches.
Questions Covered:
- 05:46 – What did it actually mean to go to Sheol and how did that change with Christ?
- 07:42 – How do I defend papal primacy using scripture? How do we defend how the early Church was based out of Rome?
- 17:08 – I’m Protestant and struggle with infant baptism. How can A child be saved if they have no belief?
- 23:44 – Hypothetical from an atheist? If I tell my wife: love me or i will set you on fire?” Does she have a choice, and do I actually love my wife?
- 29:29 – What’s wrong with the following argument: Protestants are more catholic than Catholics because they have fewer factors that need to unify them?
- 32:30 – How does one discern who has the fullness of the faith between Catholics and Orthodox?
- 37:50 – Is it ok to refer to Scripture as Jesus since he is he is the word of God?
- 41:30 – How do we encounter the world, take criticism, and spread the gospel without being obnoxious?
- 42:12 – If Mary is the Mother of God and she is not the source of his divinity, why does she need to be sinless?
- 51:13 – Do the Anglican Church and Orthodox have the Real presence? Am I supposed to bow if they do?
Join Catholic Answers Live as Cy Kellett interviews Fr. David Michael Moses on reaching young people through social media and evangelization in today’s digital age!
Tradition says Jesus was 33 when He died, but did early Church Fathers like St. Irenaeus suggest otherwise? Tim Staples explores this question and more, including Mary’s virginity, swearing as a sin, and historical accounts of Jesus’ miracles.
Questions Covered:
- 08:39 – Can you explain Jesus’ age when he died? St. Irenaeus seems to say Jesus died around the age of 50?
- 17:08 – Is there a list of spiritual faculties?
- 29:45 – Did Jesus know Mary was a virgin? Did he introduce her to people as “my virgin mother”?
- 42:28 – If I swear or use vulgar language, is that a mortal sin?
- 46:26 – Since Josephus was Jewish, did he include Jesus’ raising of the dead in his histories?
- 51:09 – Should I house my sister who lives with her female partner if she loses her job?
Sharing and defending Catholicism can be overwhelming—how can we do it with confidence and peace? Tim Staples offers practical advice and answers more on the Wailing Wall prophecy, Eucharistic Adoration, and the role of the Trinity in Baptism.
Questions Covered:
- 08:15 – Why is a Wailing Wall leftover from the temple (Mt 24, there will not be a stone leftover)?
- 19:31 – What is Joseph referring to in Gen 50:19?
- 23:58 – How can we defend the faith and not be anxious?
- 42:00 – How do you explain Adoration to a Protestant?
- 50:55 – Do we have to believe in the Trinity for the Baptismal regeneration to occur?
What’s the difference between change and development in Catholic teaching? Karlo Broussard explains how the Church maintains continuity and answers more on First Confession, receiving Communion, and the first miracle of creation.
Want more free exclusive content? JOIN THE CA LIVE CLUB NEWSLETTER
Questions Covered:
- 03:08 – What are we supposed to confess at First Confession?
- 05:30 – What is the standard to know if Catholic Doctrine has changed versus developed?
- 14:51 – Why can’t I receive Communion unless I’m in a state of grace?
- 32:17 – Why is it okay for Catholics to only receive the bread versus both species?
- 37:12 – Could the Creation of Eve be considered the first miracle?
- 43:19 – Why do we cling to certain Biblical teachings and stray from others?
Why do sins have consequences even after the forgiveness of sins? Karlo Broussard breaks down the concept of temporal punishment and provides more answers on OCIA preparation, early Christian persecution, and proving the Resurrection to skeptics.
Want more free exclusive content? JOIN THE CA LIVE CLUB NEWSLETTER
Questions Covered:
- 06:31 – I find more people coming to OCIA with no knowledge of Jesus Christ? How would you approach this?
- 22:08 – How do I explain to others the temporal punishment for sin? My example was drinking and the effects on your liver.
- 31:02 – Can you tell me about early Christian persecutions before its legalization?
- 35:51 – Based on 2 Tim 3:8, would it be appropriate that as Catholics we believe in an oral tradition exclusively from the Jewish tradition?
- 41:05 – In relation to my personal experience, how should I honor my father and mother?
- 47:57 – If you were to talk to an atheist, what evidence would you provide to prove the Resurrection? How would we explain other religions getting prayers answered or getting some private revelation?
Did the Declaration of Independence reference the Biblical Creator, or was it a more general idea of God? In this episode, we discuss The Church Against the State with Dr. Andrew Willard Jones, exploring the historical tension between secular and religious authority.
Questions Covered:
- 37:48 – What do you think about the reference to a Biblical creator in the Declaration of Independence?
What does the Church say about evolution? Dr. Stacy Trasancos explores the compatibility of Darwin’s theory with Catholic teaching and answers more on faith in science, IVF, and ethical fertility treatments.
Questions Covered:
- 13:32 – Do you support the theory of evolution as proposed by Charles Darwin?
- 17:11 – How has faith related to your work in science? Can you talk about your conversion? How do you talk couples away from IVF?
- 24:00 – Do you think the acceptance of IVF by Catholics is due to the lack of guidance we have?
- 28:49 – What alternative treatments do Catholics have for infertility?
- 35:00 – How do you reconcile survival of the fittest theory with Jesus’ teaching on taking care of the poor and the weak?
- 38:20 – Because we have probably consumed the atoms that Jesus once consumed, does that make humanity second class relics?
- 45:25 – How can we be assured of when is a good time to donate organs?
- 50:29 – Why are we not considering fathers in these conversations about IVF?
- 51:33 – How can we see things in nature and see how it reflects God?
If God is omniscient, how can He “forget” sins forgiven in Confession? Jimmy Akin explains this theological mystery and answers more questions on Genesis, Catholic complexity, and divine judgment.
Questions Covered:
- 01:02 – How does the Jubilee Year and forgiveness apply to my divorce and financial situation?
- 07:39 – How can Catholics believe Genesis is an allegory and a genealogy at the same time?
- 16:46 – How can I better defend against the claim “Catholicism is too complex”?
- 21:01 – The Vatican suppressed the Miles Christi order recently. What does that mean for the order and the faithful associated with them?
- 23:57 – Could pursuit of knowledge of the faith ever be an idol?
- 29:07 – What is the difference between the particular judgment and general judgment?
- 33:25 – How can God forget sins forgiven in Confession if He is All-Knowing?
- 36:01 – I’m cradle Orthodox; what is the best, concise argument against Eastern Orthodoxy? Why should I become Catholic?
- 46:40 – I’m in OCIA, my spouse is attending a Protestant Church. Am I allowed to continue attending Protestant services with him?
- 47:59 – I heard that God allows us to go to Hell because we would not be able to stand the beatific vision if we had mortal sin on our soul. Is this true?
- 51:14 – How did the Lord atone for our sins?
How do substance and accidents help us understand the Eucharist? Jimmy Akin unpacks Aristotle’s influence on Catholic theology and answers more questions on NFP, venial sin, and returning to the faith.
Questions Covered:
- 05:09 – If someone venially sins in a category that is grave by nature, has one committed a grave offense that he’s only venially culpable for? If so, does one have a similar responsibility to avoid such sins like mortal sins?
- 08:16 – What is the meaning of Genesis 49:14-15?
- 13:43 – What is considered a grave reason to use NFP to avoid pregnancy? Would it be a sin to avoid pregnancy for a less than grave reason?
- 15:10 – Was Yahweh tempted in the desert when Jesus was tempted in the desert?
- 18:32 – Does the Prime Directive in Star Trek go against Catholic theology?
- 23:27 – Having been baptized in a different faith, I’m getting ready for my First Reconciliation; could I bring in a list of my sins, or should I confess what’s on my heart?
- 29:40 – Can you help me understand how recent immigration changes will affect priests from other countries?
- 34:34 – Is there a good book a Lapsed Catholic could read to relearn all the traditions? Should I go back to confession?
- 43:23 – I’m an Extraordinary Eucharistic Minister. Can non-Catholics Christians receive ashes on Ash Wednesday?
- 45:16 – How does Aristotle’s distinction between substance and accidents help explain the concept of transubstantiation?
- 48:13 – Why is there a response to “The Mystery of the Faith/Mysterium fidei” that doesn’t mention the Resurrection?
- 51:48 – The Catechism says temporal punishment doesn’t remain after Confession, but my Catechist says otherwise. Who is right?
Protestants often receive both bread and wine, so why don’t all Catholics? Tim Staples explains this and more, including annulment cases, attending Lutheran Confirmations, and whether Jesus referred to all the apostles as the “rock” of the Church.
Questions Covered:
- 05:10 – To defend our position, is it possible to say that Jesus could have looked at ALL the apostles when he says “upon this rock I will build my church”?
- 16:03 – Why can’t Catholics receive both species of the Eucharist? It seems Protestants receive both.
- 24:56 – How legitimate is it for me to attend a Lutheran Confirmation for family members?
- 34:59 – Is a spouse dealing with alcohol, drug abuse, or adultery a case for an annulment?
- 45:09 – Kent Hovind says there’s a flood story in every culture; why do we only hear of the story of Noah?
- 54:00 – Why aren’t Ash Wednesday and Good Friday Holy Days of Obligation?
Can we know for certain that souls exist? Trent Horn explores this fundamental question and more, including the meaning of the filioque, the fate of aborted babies, and how the Council of Trent would respond to Protestant objections.
Questions Covered:
- 04:41 – What does the filioque really mean?
- 14:21 – Regarding your video on Evangelicals and Trump, could you clarify the argument you used?
- 19:10 – How do we know or is there any proof that we have a soul?
- 29:20 – How would Trent respond to the Protestant claim “He died once and for all” in Hebrews?
- 41:30 – Where do aborted babies go after death?
If you were baptized in a Protestant church, do you need to be re-baptized after becoming Catholic? Jimmy Akin explains Church teaching and answers more questions on the Great Apostasy, Torah observance, and whether being late to Mass is a sin.
Questions Covered:
- 01:55 – A Jewish friend said that everything went wrong after the Apostles. Was that the Great Apostasy? How should I respond?
- 07:21 – How is sedevacantism, the SSPX, and the Fatima Secret related to Malachi Martin?
- 14:22 – I heard once that the unforgivable sin is becoming an atheist. What is the Catholic stance on this?
- 20:42 – What is the relationship between the Knights of Columbus and the Catholic Church? Is it okay to celebrate deceased parents and loved ones and say they are together in heaven?
- 28:50 – If I was baptized in a Protestant church and then converted to Catholicism, is my baptism valid?
- 31:19 – How do I reach my brother who has recently converted to Torah observance?
- 38:23 – My LDS friends would say “know them by their fruits” as a reason to convert to Mormonism; how do I respond to that?
- 46:45 – Is it a sin to be late to Mass?
- 49:58 – How do I respond to the claim “Jesus’ crucifixion paid all debts, including temporal ones”?
Engaging in debates can be challenging, especially when opponents use unfair tactics. Joe Heschmeyer shares his approach to ethical debate and answers more questions on Purgatory, Catholic traditions, and even motorcycle club members joining the Church.
Questions Covered:
- 14:00 – Where can I find the original source of the phrase “Source and summit of the Christian life”? It seems that Catechism is quoting something.
- 16:39 – What can be said of the Baby Boomer Catholics that is good? It seems there’s a lot of dislike of them due to circumstances.
- 22:25 – Considering your recent debate, how do you prepare to engage with someone who may use “unethical debate tactics”?
- 29:42 – I have ashes of a loved one (Catholic, family non-practicing) given to me. Is it okay to have these ashes?
- 41:59 – Are people in Purgatory conscious of the fact that they are in Purgatory?
- 44:20 – Were the Apostles saved at Pentecost? If not, is there a Catholic position on when the Apostles were saved?
- 49:22 – Can a member of a 1% Motorcycle Club join the Catholic Church?
- 51:48 – In response to a previous caller, I want to note that the Baby Boomers are the ones who show up to Mass and are offering Masses up for the younger generation.
Does Matthew 1:25 contradict the belief in Mary’s perpetual virginity? Karlo Broussard unpacks this theological question and answers more “why” questions on penance, fasting, and why the New Testament wasn’t written like the Ten Commandments.
Questions Covered:
- 03:58 – Why do we do penance to satisfy the temporal debt of our venial and mortal sins rather than indulgences?
- 10:28 – Why is Catechism vague about what “an act of charity” is that works towards sanctification? Why don’t they have a concrete list?
- 15:02 – Why are there so many rules or regulations in Catholicism when in the New Testament, Paul discourages making it hard to be a believer?
- 31:18 – What am I to do if I am not given penance?
- 35:14 – Why do we only fast during Lent and not all the time?
- 44:13 – Why did God not write out the New Testament in the same way the Commandments were?
- 48:43 – It seems that Mary and Joseph didn’t have relations until AFTER they had Jesus. Why do we call Mary ever-virgin?
Why does the Church take fasting so seriously, and how do we know if something is a grave matter? Dr. Karlo Broussard answers this and more, including First Communion rules, missing Mass, and salvation outside the Church.
Questions Covered:
- 03:55 – Why is breaking the fast on a Friday considered a grave matter? How do we know if something is a grave matter?
- 12:42 – Why do I have to be in second grade to receive my First Communion (I’m currently in first grade)?
- 17:30 – Why does the Church dogmatize beliefs that are not pertinent to salvation (Immaculate Conception)?
- 32:24 – Why is missing Church (Sundays and Holy Days of Obligation) considered a mortal sin?
- 40:52 – Why do we believe that Jesus had one criminal crucified on his right and one on his left versus more criminals?
- 45:15 – Why is Catholicism the true faith (quick response to someone who doesn’t know anything about Catholicism)?
- 49:59 – Why does the Church say people outside the church can be saved?
With Jesus being perfect, did His guardian angel have an easy assignment, or was there more to it? Jimmy Akin explores this curious question and tackles more topics, including the nature of Hell, the resurrection of the body, and what would happen if Rome became uninhabitable.
Questions Covered:
- 01:08 – I’ve heard some folks claim that Hell is where God isn’t present, but isn’t that impossible if God is omnipresent?
- 10:42 – Did Jesus’s guardian angel have the easiest job?
- 16:03 – I have a question on resurrection and whether resurrection requires our bodies to be the same as our earthly bodies. I recently finished a fictional story (Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure: Steel Ball Run) where the characters receive powers from having some interaction with the Body of Christ. The story takes place on an alternate earth though the story of Christ is mostly the same save for the fact that He resurrected but that His corpse remains. This is very likely that because the author is Japanese he does not know the specifics of Christian theology. This made me wonder if the resurrection of the body requires the same earthly body that died. Or could God possibly create a new body for us our heavenly bodies?
- 22:08 – My daughter wants to know: what would happen if you dropped a skyscraper-size piece of tungsten onto a nuclear armory (where they are stored), would all the bombs go off? How big a fallout would it be? And would it be a deterrent for nuclear weapons?
- 36:30 – Assuming that Nephilim is literally the result of human women somehow mating with fallen angels, what sort of nature would they have? Could they be baptized?
- 42:27 – Is there a scientific reason behind automatic writing? What might be happening outside of supernatural causes and assuming no mental health issues as well?
- 52:34 – Where would the Pope go if Rome was nuked with a nuclear bomb designed for maximal radiation damage over an area? The Vatican is largely intact but is rendered unlivable for millennia due to fallout. Would the church make a new St. Peter’s Basilica? Would the bones of the martyrs in the city of Rome be relocated if the area around the reliquaries is too radioactive to enter?
If Christ took on flesh in multiple alien worlds, would He have more than one glorified body? Would He sit on multiple thrones? Jimmy Akin explores this fascinating theological question and answers more on baptism, the death penalty, and even the mystery behind his own accent change!Questions Covered:02:34 – I have a weird question for Jimmy. What happened to Jimmy between episode 314 and 315? The YouTube video on “The Soul of Frankenstein’s Monster” is an audio only version with no camera; Ominous to say the least. In episode 316, we once again see Jimmy, but now he dawns a white cowboy hat. There was mention of a move back to the Ozarks and this is where my questions emerge. There is a distinct change in Jimmy’s pronunciation of words, especially with words ending in “ing”. Jimmy now pronounces words with “ing” with a more redacted “in”. Was Jimmy abducted? Are the Borg involved? Has there been an assimilation? Has Jimmy employed A.I. in his likeness and asked the program to represent him in a more western fashion? Does the hat have influence over Jimmy’s dictation? Is there somethin’ in the water in Arkansas? Does Jimmy have an identical twin who has taken over? I mean no offense by my question Jimmy. The change in dictation was very noticeable and weighs on my mind when I listen to episodes now. Settle the matter and remove the perplexation! God bless and thank you for the entertainment and enlightenment. 06:44 – If the Son incarnated on multiple alien worlds and ascended to the right hand of the Father from each, would he have more than one body in Heaven? If so, would He have multiple thrones? 13:30 – Hello Mr. Akin + Cy Cellet My question is… How would you go about Baptizing “The White Witch” from the book “The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe” by C.S Lewis set in Narnia? Big fan of the work you do! Also, how would you go about Baptizing “The Wicked Witch” In “the wizard of Oz ” given her “allergic” reaction to water. Big fan of you guys; keep up the great work. 16:13 – I understand the church teaches that the death penalty is inadmissible. My understanding is that this is because modern society has the means and resources to process dangerous criminals without the death penalty (correct me if I’m wrong). My question: let’s say that a group of humans were surviving on an island cut off from the world and they established a primitive society with their laws to help them survive. In this situation, they wouldn’t have the means and resources that modern society has to deal with dangerous criminals. Could they morally administer the death penalty in certain circumstances, or would they have to follow the current teachings of the magisterium? What ethical considerations would they have to take into account if they were to administer the death penalty? 21:35 – Do criminals with psychopathic disorders have free will? If their free will is compromised by their psychopathy, does that mean that they are not fully accountable, even if their crimes are heinous? Also, what’s up with the Holy House of Loreto? Is it legit? 30:21 – If Adam did not eat the fruit, what would it mean for the fall and original sin if only one parent ate the fruit? 33:51 – Genetic enhancements on human embryos are clearly immoral because it kills them, but would it be permissible to modify your own germinal tissue (which produces gametes) to not transmit flawed genes to your offspring? 38:33 – Do ghosts watch zombies walk around and scream at their bodies for doing dumb things like fall in a manhole or walk into a glass door? 44:57 – If a priest goes to a bakery and consecrates all the bread, would those bread now become the body and blood of Jesus? 47:00 – Will our resurrected bodies wear clothes? 51:00 – If two people were
Why does God let us go through pain, like breakups, when it feels pointless? Jimmy Akin explores this tough question and answers more on Sunday obligations, Church hierarchy, and Catholic history.
Questions Covered:
- 02:52 – What would obligations for Sunday Mass be if you were in a Ground Hog’s Day scenario?
- 08:38 – Do we jump around with the readings at Mass?
- 14:13 – How do I know the difference between a bishop, an archbishop, and a cardinal?
- 20:39 – When did Jesus mean by “taking up your cross” when he wasn’t crucified yet? Also, I’m writing a Catholic history book in Spanish; do I need an imprimatur?
- 36:10 – Why does God give us suffering when it feels like there’s no purpose? For example, a break-up.
- 45:50 – Why does St. Irenaeus say that the Church was founded and organized in Rome by Peter and Paul?
- 49:15 – What are the rules for working on Sunday?
Jimmy Akin explores the surprising etymology of “meek” and answers more intriguing questions on faith, morality, and Church authority.
Questions Covered:
- 05:01 – If we had technology that could let us live forever, would it be immoral to use?
- 08:28 – How should I interpret Romans 10:13?
- 12:18 – How do the nihil obstat and the imprimatur work in terms of Church authority and infallibility?
- 17:44 – What is the etymology of the word meek? Someone claimed it to mean “equipped for battle”.
- 23:40 – Our cardinal retired and they’re going to install a new bishop. What do cardinals/bishops do after they retire? Are they excluded from the College of Cardinals?
- 28:49 – Are there any examples of Jesus asking someone would please, or did he command people to things?
- 37:14 – Why is extending life not immoral? I have some objections.
- 46:36 – It looks like Joseph Biden has been appointed an Honorary Mason. What’s the difference between the Knights of Columbus and the Freemasons? See also our related article on President Biden, which illustrates the problematic religious aspects of Freemasonry.
Fr. Tad Pacholozcyk dives into complex ethical and moral questions surrounding IVF, infertility, and bioethics. He discusses how to approach conversations about IVF with struggling couples, the Church’s stance on embryo adoption, and the moral implications of CRISPR technology. Tim also examines the influence of Catholic politicians on these issues and guides those who have undergone IVF and are seeking healing. Plus, discover resources to help infertile couples understand the Church’s teachings. Tune in for a thought-provoking discussion!
Questions Covered:
- 19:44 – How do I approach discussing IVF with couples who are infertile?
- 24:21 – How much weight does a Catholic politician like J.D. Vance have on topics like IVF?
- 29:59 – Are we aware of CRISPR technology? What does the Church say about this?
- 36:00 – Is it morally permissible for couples to adopt abandoned embryos?
- 44:28 – How do we as individuals who’ve been through IVF deal with the damage and advise others?
- 50:18 – Are there resources that help infertile couples understand the Church’s position on IVF?
The Flannel Panel takes on the news from the Catholic perspective including NPR’s take on previous popes and their accomplishments.
Topics Covered:
- 01:30 – Movies
- 06:00 – National Geographic
- 14:10 – NPR
- 30:00 – What did Pope John XXIII do?
- 42:20 – What did Pope Paul VI do?
- 47:03 – What did Pope John Paul II & Benedict XVI do?
The Flannel Panel takes on the news from the Catholic perspective, including the current state of Pope Francis, The upcoming Academy Awards and the process of sainthood.
Topics Covered:
- 02:00 – Pope Francis
- 09:10 – Academy Award Best Picture Nominations
- 18:15 – Indigenous Man
- 28:30 – How to Pull off Sainthood
- 34:00 – Mailbag
- 43:45 – Jesus Christ Superstar
Why don’t we witness miracles like burning bushes or pillars of fire today? Jim Blackburn of Catholic Questions explains the Catholic perspective on divine manifestations and why they seem less frequent. He also answers questions on living a celibate life when a spouse has Alzheimer’s, why bishops prefer standing over kneeling for Communion, and when to stop debating with Protestants.
Questions Covered:
- 04:02 – Why do we not see or hear of burning bushes, rocks being split in two or pillars of fire anymore?
- 09:29 – My wife has Alzheimer. Should I live out a celibate life due to the circumstances?
- 11:52 – I’m a fairly new Catholic. Why do bishops prefer people to stand instead of kneel for communion?
- 15:54 – When should we stop conversing with Protestants in light of Jn 3:18?
- 24:26 – I’ve been dating a Lutheran and plan to have a Catholic wedding. What advice do you have for me or what should we expect in marriage prep?
- 42:58 – Why go to a priest for confession when we can go directly to God?
- 49:22 – My boss is Amish and said purgatory is not in the bible. How do I respond to him?
Is killing always intrinsically evil? Fr. Paul Keller, OP, explores the Catholic Church’s teaching on the morality of killing and when, if ever, it can be justified. He also answers pressing faith questions, including whether Catholics can date a divorced non-Catholic and many more.
Questions Covered:
- 05:50 – Is killing an intrinsically evil act?
- 16:43 – Can a Catholic date a divorced person that was not married in the Catholic Church?
- 20:54 – I’m Catholic and was just married in a non-denominational church. Is my marriage valid? If not, how do I make it valid?
- 23:48 – If a person discovered that their partner was homosexual, would it be an impediment to receiving an annulment?
- 30:35 – How can the Church claim that there is no salvation outside the Catholic Church?
- 36:09 – I was asked by my pastor to no longer kneel for communion. What advice do you have for me?
- 45:43 – Why did God appear so cruel, angry and petty in the Old Testament?
- 50:51 – I had candles blessed during Candlemas. If the holy water didn’t touch my candle, is it still blessed?
- 52:16 – How can I learn to love God when my fear for him is much bigger?
Dr. Karlo Broussard takes calls about Catholicism from Non-Catholics, including how to explain conversion to Protestant friends, why some people reject God despite knowing the proofs, and whether Judas was forgiven. He also discusses the restoration of souls for politicians who promote sinful laws, the reliability of saint stories, and whether purgatory acts as a second chance for salvation. Tune in for deep insights into Catholic faith and theology!
Questions Covered:
- 04:01 – I’m a Protestant considering to convert, but I need help explaining this to friends and talking about the Catholic Faith?
- 15:01 – Why would God allow for some people to know all the proofs of the existence of God and yet still not believe?
- 29:25 – Was Judas forgiven? Could he theoretically be saved and in Heaven?
- 35:46 – How does restoration of a soul work if certain politicians keep sinning/promoting sinful legislation?
- 43:06 – Why are so many Saint stories uncritically accepted?
- 52:32 – Is Purgatory a “second chance’?
This episode tackles common Protestant objections, including John 6, the nature of the Eucharistic meal, and how non-Catholics can be saved.
Questions Covered:
- 05:40 – Where can I learn more about St. Stephen, the proto-martyr?
- 19:37 – How does devotion to Mary’s Immaculate Heart not take away from Jesus?
- 29:26 – Does John 6:37 contradict the Catholic view of Salvation?
- 40:53 – Why are Catholics allowed to marry non-Catholics including non-Christians with a dispensation?
- 46:42 – How can others outside the Catholic faith be saved if they have never had the chance to hear about Christ?
- 52:51 – A Protestant friend says the Bible dictates that Eucharist was a full meal, and not just a bit of bread and wine, so how does the Catholic Church respond to this?
Questions Covered:04:57 – How do I get my OCIA students more interested in the topics we discuss?13:55 – What do we make of Jesus, Mary and Joseph getting expensive gifts from the magi but still only making the poor persons’ offering at the temple? Wouldn’t they have been rich?22:16 – How do Catholics respond to people who are interested in Wesley Huff and what he teaches about the canon of scripture?36:33 – What does the Catechism mean when it says that together with us Muslims adore the one true God?45:05 – What’s our response to a non-Catholic who asks us about the ordo amoris?51:00 – How can I practice humility?…
Live from the Los Angeles Religious Education Congress. Fr. Agustino Torres, CFR, joins us to talk about evangelization and Gen Z.Questions Covered:12:50 – How can I expand the youth group I lead? I am a youth coordinator, how can I get kids to live what they learn out in the world?18:30 – How do we evangelize to someone who is at peace with their life in their own religion?46:54 – How do we use social media to move young people to person-to-person communication and the Eucharist?…
Questions Covered:06:05 – Catholicism seems to be rules obsessed.17:52 – How do I explain to protestants that they have tradition also?23:45 – It seems like Catholics are inconsistent with their interpretation of the use of the word “until” in Scripture.35:40 – How do Catholics reconcile the idea of a Catholic view of Jesus and Protestant view of Jesus?44:21 – What exactly is tradition?…
Questions Covered:05:54 – Help me respond to Protestants who say that Jesus had brothers.13:23 – Our marriage to Christ can be dissolved and we can lose our salvation. But the marriage sacrament cannot be dissolved. Why the inconsistency?19:57 – What are the Catholic mysteries?29:29 – Protestants use the word “altar” a lot during their services or when they preach. He thinks they are incorrect to use it like they do, because an altar means sacrifice, and everything they do at “the altar” is misrepresenting?40:57 – What is the culpability of Protestants with regards to mortal sin? They may not be aware that something is a mortal sin.47:41 – I attended a protestant funeral and at the end the pastor went on an anti-Catholic rant.52:26 – My co-worker says the modern church is part of the syllabus of errors. What’s that all about?…
Joe Heschmeyer answers key Catholic questions, including why Catholics don’t baptize by full submersion. He also refutes accusations of cannibalism,…
Joe Heschmeyer tackles questions from non-Catholics about key Catholic teachings including if we know how long does purgatory last, and much more.…
In this episode, Jimmy Akin answers a variety of thought-provoking questions about Catholicism like if first-century Jews expect the Messiah to be divine.…
In this episode, Jimmy Akin tackles a wide range of thought-provoking questions on Catholicism including his explains whether the power of binding and loosing was meant to continue indefinitely,…
In this episode, Fr. Matthew Spencer tackles deep theological and moral questions, including God’s will vs. free will if and missing Mass as a mortal sin…
Steve Ray answers questions about Jesus, from His meeting with John the Baptist and being called Rabbi to His time in the Temple and the differences in the Nativity accounts.…
Jimmy Akin dives into big questions on Cain’s fear of others in Genesis, Catholic tradition vs. Sola Scriptura and many more questions!…
Jimmy Akin tackles fascinating Catholic questions, from Sunday obligation at Eastern liturgies to Eucharistic reverence, and the best Bible translation.…
Tim Staples tackles tough questions from non-Catholics, covering topics like bad popes, and why non-Catholics can't receive Communion.…
Tim Staples answers questions from non-Catholics, tackling key topics like why Catholics confess to a priest instead of going straight to God, and much more…
Scott Weeman discusses Catholic in Recovery, the 12-step model, and support for those battling addiction, include marijuana’s impact and family struggles…
William Albrecht tackles key canon debates—John 8, Nicaea, apocryphal books, and translation changes. Can we trust the Church’s authority on Scripture?…
Questions Covered: 01:21 – How do the Jews have their sins forgiven if there’s no Temple or sacrifices being offered? 05:47 – Did King Solomon from the Book of Kings lose his soul? 10:50 – In Mark 5, when the possessed man recognizes Jesus as the Christ, is this example of a bestowed grace? 14:07 – Why in Gen 32:27-28 does Jacob’s name change to Israel, but then not used in full force until Gen 35? 19:17 – How does the Book of Revelation relate to cosmology? 23:17 – In today’s First Reading (Gen 1:26), God uses “we” and “us” in the creation of man. Who is this referring to? 33:16 – Why do we say that Jesus was Jewish? 40:28 – If demons could potentially know Jesus as the Christ, why didn’t the demons attack him as a child? 47:42 – Is it okay to read the Apocrypha? If so, which ones? Is there a particular order to read them? 50:19 – In John 14:6, when Jesus says “he’s the way, the truth, and the light”, is he being literal about being the truth? …
Questions Covered: 02:37 – How do which parts of Esther are original Hebrew if we don’t have all the original Hebrew texts?12:00 – Why did God pick St. Michael the Archangel to defeat Satan?15:17 – From the Churches mentioned in the Bible, are any still remaining?20:05 – Is the battle 2 Maccabees 10:29-38 (5 magical men leading the Jews) to be taken literally?24:45 – How do you explain sanctification and justification in light of the book of James?30:59 – What are the differences between the Catholic and Greek Orthodox canons of scripture?33:28 – In the Bible, you hear of apparitions of Jesus or Mary. Have there been apparitions of other people from the Bible?35:27 – If someone who received the gospel of Jesus and believed, should the Church immediately baptize him since we have a similar example in the Ethiopian eunuch?42:45 – Why do we say “the Hebrew texts” when Hebrew is a more modern language?…
Dr Karlo Broussard tackles key Catholic questions on Sola Scriptura, the papacy in Isaiah, how saints hear prayers, and on how reliable the Church Fathers are.…
John Martignoni takes questions on scriptural apologetics defending prophecy with Scripture and the authority of the deuterocanonical books.…
Jimmy Akin tackles questions on mysterious warnings, biblical oaths, the deuterocanonical books, forgiveness, all paths leading to God , and navigating faith with anti-Catholic family…
Jimmy Akin answers key Catholic questions on Jesus' promise of paradise, the Church’s stance on creation, sainthood, Marian apparitions, marriage, and more.…
In This Episode Tim Staples discusses the evidence for Jesus' birth on December 25, Why Jesus casted the demons into pigs and much more.…
This discussion explores key theological and historical questions within Catholicism and the Church’s stance on mystical visions…
Questions Covered:08:34 – Is it ok to raise your hands or hold hands during the Our Father?13:20 – What does the Church have to say on environmentalism? I joined a club at school so I want advice on how I should approach it.37:40 – Why do some Catholics refrain from using the word pray when discussing Mary when Church documents says Catholics pray to her?48:50 – Would it be sinful for a Catholic to claim to be the Caliph of all of Islam?…
Questions Covered:10:00 – Why are there time gaps in the bible when God speaks to us? 24:05 – What is your response to protestants who claim that an infallible canon is not necessary because the Jews didn’t have one during the time of Jesus? 37:11 – I was going to repeat my gift from last years but I have a challenge for you Cy and Tim. Repeat Johann Tetzels phrase in German and explain it and its misunderstanding from protestants. If you do I will double my donation! 47:21 – How does 1 Tim 4:3 not contradict Catholic teaching on priestly celibacy and abstaining from meat? …
Questions Covered:08:31 – Does the Catholic Church ever say that Moses and Elijiah were already in heaven at the time of the Transfiguration? 18:23 – What is the church’s stance on listening to non-Catholic gospel music? 37:13 – Do we have an idea on who the apostle who is not named on the road to Emmaus, is? 47:47 – Is the struggle against sin, even if one can never overcome it, still efficacious? …
Questions Covered:09:48 – Are mosaic law sacrifices valid?22:34 – Since we place urgency on baptizing babies, why isn’t that also applied to adults who need baptism?33:59 – You mentioned that the Catholic Church has the fullness of truth, but do the other churches like the Assyrian church also contain the fullness of truth?46:32 – Why did early Christians celebrate and practice Marian doctrines?…
Questions Covered:05:58 – Why do some Catholics believe in the 3 days of darkness and others don’t?15:20 – Where is a good place for a fallen away Catholic to start in the bible?20:05 – Why does the Catholic Church ignore what the bible teaches?41:25 – What did Jesus mean when he called Peter the rock? Could Jesus have been referring to the original cornerstone of the second temple, which now sits in the golden dome Mosque?44:11 – Where in the bible does it talk about fornication being a sin?47:44 – Can we have masses offered for family that are still alive?49:40 – What does it take for a law to be officially promulgated in the Church?51:26 – Why is Isaiah 7:14 translated to young woman instead of virgin?…
Questions Covered:07:28 – Why does the Church believe babies can go to hell?20:05 – Does a priest have to wear a stole when he blesses items like holy water?23:44 – Why is it that protestants no longer have genuine consecration of the eucharist if Martin Luther was a priest and was able to consecrate?29:45 – What is the difference between meat and fish, especially in the context of meatless Fridays?34:15 – Why do Catholics use Aristotelian logic especially when not a lot of others do?45:35 – How can I best explain the infallibility of the Papacy?51:44 – Why do Catholics pray to saints and Mary when Jesus said only pray to God?…
Questions Covered: 3:46 – How do I convince a hardened atheist that God exists? Or even the historical figure of Jesus? 05:58 – How do we properly understand typology as pointing towards the New Testament? 14:10 – What does Jimmy think of the new document Antiqua et nova? Does he have any advice for the everyday person? 18:08 – I have a friend who doesn’t believe God loves sinners and uses Ps 5:5 as evidence. Are there other verses to combat this? 22:15 – What exactly are charisms from the Holy Spirit and how does one discern them? 32:25 – Our visiting priest doesn’t say “do this in memory of me” when consecrating the bread but does it for the wine. Is this valid? 36:15 – Can you assure me and help me further understand how God exists? 43:00 – If the pope were to time travel, would the seat be vacant? 49:06 – Would it be okay to ask a priest to bless my new firearm? 52:49 – I’m teaching my kids the Glory Be, and it says “world without end” at the end of the prayer? Why does it say that? …
In this episode, we tackle an intriguing question: If God created Satan and loves all His creation, does God love Satan? Jimmy Akin answers this and more!…
Questions Covered: 03:17 – I’m about to turn 82; how can old people deal with technology and progress?12:08 – Is God displeased with quiet / subtle presentations of faith vs. publicly declaring the faith?19:03 – Am I being prideful because I find it hard to accept help?28:45 – Jesus said forgive your brother 77 times 7, how do I forgive people who’ve hurt me while I’m still in relation to them?35:44 – Is it immoral to celebrate the death of those we view as enemies?47:18 – Is it okay to make my own icon(s) (Sacred Heart and Immaculate Heart) for my mother?51:52 – It doesn’t make sense to a Protestant friend of mine of how infants can be baptized, especially if the parents are just doing the motions?…
Questions Covered: 30:17 – In light of the new Vatican document, is it sinful to hold an anti-AI position? I don’t think we can practically use AI well.34:10 – In another country (Switzerland), are they doing A.I. confession? Is this possible? What are the repercussions of this if true?36:41 – Is the Vatican / Catholic Church open to inputting the Archives into A.I.?46:50 – I think A.I. is great for making my life a bit easier (opinion/comment, not question).49:29 – I was praying with the rosary with Archbishop Fulton Sheen on YT, but something didn’t feel right (I remember him live); it turned out to be an A.I. generated voice. Is it okay to pray with A.I. generated resources?51:54 – I heard that God created man and Satan created A.I. because Satan can only copy God’s power; is this logical?…
Topics Covered:14:15 – Child Tax Credit24:55 – Subsidiarity & Solidarity | CST37:15 – China47:00 – MAILBAG…
Topics Covered: 03:40 – News05:33 – Audience favorite topics12:31 – Open AI46:12 – Taylor Swift…
Questions Covered: 13:52 – It doesn’t make sense to me why some people hear God in their prayers and others don’t?19:38 – How is it that Protestants seem to experience the fruits of the faith, but without the sacrifices that Catholics do?30:01 – As Catholics, we agree that we’ll probably be in Purgatory before going to Heaven. The Bible says that Jesus at the Second Coming will take everyone with him. Does that mean they’ll skip out on Purgatory?35:33 – A Protestant friend wonders if we’re defecating or disgracing the Eucharist when we receive it?43:00 – I want to know how does Dr. Broussard decides when his interpretation of scripture is a maybe/what if and how does he know when God’s Will is definitive?…
Questions Covered: 05:53 – Catholic, married Methodist. He has a divorce; they have a civil marriage. I’m told I need to get an annulment. Why is this?12:20 – I’m not Catholic; why does the Catholic church believe/profess the doctrine of Transubstantiation?20:11 – I come across a lot of Protestants who have trouble with perpetual virginity of Mary. Who is James (“brother of Jesus”) in Gal 1:19; is he one of the 12 apostles?29:40 – Is the celebration of the Eucharist/the Real Presence greater than the miracle of the Last Supper?33:58 – It doesn’t make sense to me that John the Baptist is described as “the spirit of Elijah’, whereas the prophecy makes it seem as if Elijah was to come back?41:19 – I’m Catholic, but I’m interested in Orthodoxy. Some of their claims seem to have weight. How can the Church change its position on topics?47:37 – Where do we get the idea/doctrine of indulgences?…
Questions Covered: 03:09 – How do you compare Ephesians 2:8-9 to James 2:17? 06:43 – What is the church’s social teaching on immigration and treatment of immigrants? 17:00 – Why do we presume a valid Baptism for Protestants coming into the Catholic church? 21:37 – What is Opus Dei? 29:20 – It seems Mary’s condition of the Immaculate Conception helped her be sinless. Does this mean that children conceived sinfully are more prone to sin? 33:02 – What is the difference between presence and substance? 42:58 – How should we discern God’s wants you to use words, action, or prayer?47: 52 – Where did the practice of folding hands or interlocking fingers come from?51:30 – Why at Mass do we say “until you come again” right after the consecration? …
Questions covered:6:21 – Why did you become Catholic instead of some other denomination? 29:46 – How did you arrive at your beliefs pre-conversion? 35:47 – How did you change your mind about Christianity not working for society? 42:36 – What came first for you: believing in the teachings of the Bible and the Church, or the sense of a personal relationship with Jesus? 46:05 – I experienced the same thing as Christine did with dreams coming true. What is that? 48:20 – Were there any Catholic dogmas that were particularly hard for you to accept? …
Questions Covered:11:44 – Is there a difference when you pray for specifics like for a job vs when praying in general like the Our Father?23:26 – How can you tell the difference between a demonic manifestation and a soul in purgatory who needs prayers?23: 33 – Is it true that the first bible came from Ethiopia?28:47 – If God is all knowing, do we really have free will?37:24 – How do I respond to the objection that Mary had a painless childbirth but yet still experienced death meaning that she was not sinless.45:50 – Is it necessary to have sacramentals be blessed by a priest?48:17 – What is the official language of the Church? What was the process of marriage in the 1st century Holy Land?52:45 – What era did the Church rule that priests could not be married?…
Questions Covered:07:35 – Does 2 Jn 1:1-3. prove Sensus Fidelium?12:42 – How are the different theological opinions in the east and west that would be needed to be reconciled for union?19:38 – Why did God place the tree of knowledge of good and evil in the garden of Eden in the first place?24:58 – Is it true that in biblical days women who gave birth to boys had to be secluded for 30 days and if they had girls it would be 60 days?31:46 – Sola scriptura is very defendable from scripture. It was Jesus’s primary gripe with the Pharisees. Almost every conversation He had with them was directly condemning any source other than scripture.34:05 – What are the differences in biblical canons for the Catholics and Orthodox?36:37 – I go to an evangelical school. My teacher said that Jesus couldn’t have instituted the eucharist at the last supper because it would go against the Deutero laws and Levitical laws. How do I respond to that?45:28 – What was the process to enter the Catholic Church in the early 1900’s?…
Questions Covered: 05:49 – I’ve heard there’s 7 Sacraments. Two are mutually exclusive (Matrimony & Holy Orders). If a Catholic Man is unmarried/not ordained religious and receives the other 5 Sacraments, is he missing something/less than others who are married/ordained? 15:21 – When talking to Tom earlier, you left on a cliffhanger. Where in the Bible does it say you should be Catholic? 37:41 – As a non-Catholic, can I go to Confession? 44:02 – Is there a connection between Classical Liberalism / democracy (differing ideas in society) and Protestantism (having differences in faith in the “Church”)? 50:37 – Could you give me a Biblical/Traditional defense on Marian Doctrine in general? …
Questions Covered:05:42 – Can you become Catholic on your deathbed? 15:01 – My wife and I are Protestant, but I’m leaning towards Catholicism. What becomes of our marriage? Do I have to divorce her to become Catholic? 28:51 – My daughter and I listened to (Lutheran). If God is all-knowing, why did He create Satan, and why did He create people who would go/choose Hell? 43:10 – I’m converting this Easter, but my family is anti-Catholic. How can I better explain Catholic beliefs to my family and make them sound reasonable? 48:20 – I left the Protestant Church and I’m learning about Catholicism, but my wife has a hard time with faith vs. works. Can you provide some insight on how to help her understand the difference between faith and works? …
Questions Covered:01:59 – My sister and I grew up Catholic. She married a protestant and started going to Protestant services. Today she invited us to her baptism, even though she has already been baptized. Should I attend?06:08 – What is the Church teaching on reporting illegal activity of someone who is in a vulnerable position? For example, reporting a poor person for stealing food.17:05 – What is the Catholic view of the Elect and predestination?22:56 – My Pentecostal friend is asking why we don’t say “In the name of the Father, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit.” He’s wondering why we don’t use his name instead of his title “The Son.” How would you answer?29:00 – How can we get stronger in spiritual warfare?33:02 – What is the Catholic response to someone saying we are cannibalistic because we eat the Eucharist?…
Questions Covered:07:00 – What is the Catholic perspective on cynicism and anger?15:38 – Why do y’all have so many titles for Mary?21:45 – In Leviticus 10 two dudes are killed for doing something liturgically wrong, but later two other dudes did something liturgically wrong but were not killed. What’s the deal with that?31:58 – How do I deal with spiritual attack without being superstitious?41:37 – I want to go to a Protestant Bible study to promote the Catholic faith? Is it a problem for me to pray with them? I heard something like if I pray with them I might be excommunicated.47:10 – Do I need to go to confession for rooting for Ohio State over Notre Dame?50:12 – We have a Christian understanding of baptism, but what was the understanding of baptism by the Jews at the time of Jesus’ baptism?…
Questions Covered:02:00 – I’m in a Monday night Ignatius Bible study. We’re talking about the giving of the keys to the kingdom. I’ve looked at Scripture and the Catechism; what is the limit of the pope’s authority? 10:28 – I’m Catholic and have numerous hidden tattoos that are religious in nature. What is the Church’s opinion/teaching on this? 13:07 – There seem to be some conflicting verses; death of Judas in Matt vs. in Acts. Joseph’s father being Jacob vs. Hele. Are these misprints or contradictions, or is there an explanation for this? 23:56 – In terms of purgatory, there’s a lot of differing opinions. Popular position / Cardinal Ratzinger said that they’re so engulfed in love with Christ and encountering Him that they’re burning and being purified. Since they’re encountering Christ, our prayers don’t do anything? 38:01 – Are canonizations of the Saints considered infallible? 44:14 – Can we only assign moral values to actions? What can we call bad? 50:29 – Some people use MT 10:28 to teach the idea of annihilation. How do I counter this? Would Rev 14 be a good rebuttal? …
Questions Covered: 05:53 – What advice would you give to help me from falling into the sin of envy? 13:39 – Angels have free will; since Satan is an angel and he rejected God, can he return to God and be redeemed? 18:19 – I have a Catholic friend and we go to daily mass together. My friend is taking classes at protestant global outreach on prayer for healing; what is your opinion about this? Is this okay? 23:21 – How do I handle with leaving the church I’m from and joining the Catholic Church? 29:02 – I have a sister going through an estrangement with daughter, doing everything, asking me for advice. I don’t know how to counsel her. I’m Catholic, what advice do you give to her? 37:34 – One of my daughter’s friends (a fallen away Catholic) has bad self-esteem, wants a nose job; her dad thinks she’ll go to hell. How can my daughter help her friend navigate this? Will she go to hell? Also, what does the phrase “minister to God” mean? 46:36 – I have a Pentecostal friend and he got excited when I told him Catholics pray in tongues; he prayed over me, I responded with the Lord’s prayer in Hebrew. Did I mislead him, and is it bad that I took Communion after this event? …
Questions Covered:01:20 – How does the issue of free will square with papal infallibility?06:13 – I like how some protestants treat Jesus’ words of righting wrongs before approaching the altar. Has the Catholic Church fallen off following this?14:33 – One thing I frequently hear is Acts 10:41 as evidence for rejecting regenerative baptism. How do I respond?21:46 – I’m orthodox. What’s the premise of the papacy?29:00 – Do the letters to the Corinthians give leeway to divorce and remarriage?32:14 – How do I present to my non-denominational friend that the Catholic Church is non-denominational and pre denominational?36:50 – Is holding hands during the Our Father permitted?…
Questions Covered:06:46 – What is the purpose of holy water?14:46 – Why would John’s account of what Jesus do after his baptism differ from the other gospel accounts?20:03 – My question would be about Jesus’ sisters regarding the immaculate conception. The claim I’ve seen is that sister doesn’t have the same range of meaning as brother. This means they must be Jesus’ biological sisters.22:46 – I’m Lutheran. I believe the saints pray for us, but I don’t see where it says that we are supposed to ask them to pray for us. Can you clarify?37:05 – Can someone tell me what verses say about saints in heaven interceding for us?46:28 – I’m Catholic and absolutely hate it. What should I do?…
Questions Covered:00:59 – Did Mary and Mary Magdalene also receive the gift to forgive sins since they were present when Jesus breathed on his disciples and commissioned them?05:22 – If I’ve fallen away from the Church what do I need to do to return?07:22 – Did Catholics chain up the bible and limit access to it? Is this true?12:07 – How does one fully trust God for everything?18:28 – What are your thoughts on the fracturing and divisions in the Catholic Church?23:11 – Can one fulfill their Sunday obligation at an SSPX church? Are they in schism?36:36 – I’m dating a girl who is staunchly protestant, and her mother is anti-Catholic. What’s the best way to share my faith with her?45:40 – What happened in Europe that made it very atheistic but the faith was fairly preserved in the US?49:34 – Is it ok to read books about the Nazi’s and the history of their rise without it leading me to sin?52:24 – What is the Catholic interpretation of Jesus healing the paralytic in Mt 9:5-6 and forgiving his sins?…
Questions Covered:04:09 – In the scenario that a person is changed into an object or an animal since the rational soul is the form of the body and the body changes, does that mean the person dies?11:10 – 2 Tim 1:12-14 Does the Greek version indicate that the deposit will be preserved?17:55 – I was baptized in the Mormon church. How do I go about being a part of the Catholic Church?20:58 – How is prayer efficacious? I know God’s not a genie in a bottle.29:48 – Didn’t the church prosecute Galileo for contradicting the churches flat-earth biblical models?32:30 – How does the Catholic Church understand 2.Thess 2:15 specifically the oral tradition part? Is this the tradition of the Church?37:19 – How do you reconcile middle knowledge and prophecy?43:50 – What is your opinion on Louisa Piccerta and the Divine Will movement?48:51 – Can someone know whether they have perfect or imperfect contrition?…
Questions Covered:06:01 – Jerome made a comment on Titus 1:7 that the presbyters were basically the same as bishops, then there was a development that made the distinction between them, and also the papacy. How would you respond to that?16:40 – Why do we have to learn God’s love language but he doesn’t have to learn ours? It seems like it’s a one-way relationship.29:42 – I’ve been inquiring about Catholicism for a long time, and I agree with a lot of Catholic points. But I worry about a lot of liturgical abuse happening in the Church and that the Vatican doesn’t do anything about it. Any thoughts?48:28 – If you are in friendship with God, but then commit a mortal sin and get hit by a train on the way to confession, do you go to Hell because you didn’t confess? Also, I have been told that Catholics are not required to confess to a priest, they can confess directly to God. How do you respond to that?…
Questions Covered: 01:30 – Cy and Tim discuss the Jubilee year.29:00 – I have a Calvinist background, and realized I don’t believe in once saved always saved. Can you explain to me the Catholic view of losing salvation?…
Questions Covered: 01:21 – What are your thoughts on infallibility and keeping the tradition preserved from corruption? Do 1 Tim 1:12-14, 2 Jn 1:1-3 and 1 Pt 1:25 support the teaching of infallibility?11:39 – Is Pope Gregory I the reason why we say, ‘God bless you’?14:50 – Is Mary the mediatrix of all grace? Is she the shortest road to Christ? Is she even necessary?23:04 – Is God’s love conditional? Does He love us more when we are in the state of grace?29:09 – What dogmas have been declared on Adam and Eve?39:45 – What does the Church think about non-sexual physical abuse by the parents?47:02 – I was raised Muslim and am now in RCIA. Can you help clarify purgatory? It’s such a foreign concept to me.…
Questions Covered:04:36 – Why isn’t there an infallible translation of the bible?13:00 – How does consecration to saint’s work?19:32 – Gen 35:16 says Benjamin was born in Canaan, but Gen 35:26 says he was born in Paddan-aram. Is this contradictory?24:45 – What occurred during the Great Schism?39:11 – You do know this celebration of the dead [veneration of the saints] has pagan Roman origins like all the other pagan infiltrations camouflaged as church traditions?46:43 – I’m talking to an evolutionist bible scholar. How do I convince him of monotheism?…
Questions Covered: 00:45 – How can Catholics ask Protestants to be in communion with the Pope, when there have been so many schisms? 06:15 – I don’t understand the teaching of no salvation outside the Catholic Church? 15:00 – How do I explain Papal Authority? When should we listen to the Pope? 23:20 – What do Catholics believe are necessary beliefs to be Christian? 29:56 – I struggle with the teaching of Mary’s Virginity based on Matthew 1:24-25? 37:26 – Is Catholic doctrine found in the Bible? 45:33 – I’m confused by the belief in Sacrament of the anointing of the sick? I’ve heard different perspectives on going to Heaven with last rites? …
Questions Covered:05:23 – Why do Catholics put so much emphasis on Mary? 12:36 – I struggle with the doctrine of The Real Presence. 20:06 – I don’t understand Mary’s perpetual Virginity after giving birth? Why is this important? 28:45 – Why doesn’t God just annihilate evil? 42:38 – How can the Creed change in the Western church from the original Eastern Church? 45:28 – Can you explain apostolic infallibility?52:28 – Is there a doctrine on the Afterlife? …
Questions Covered:01:52 – Question: What exactly is Paul referring to in Galatians 3:1 when he says Christ was “publicly exhibited/portrayed as crucified”? Is it possible Paul knew of the Shroud of Turin? Or maybe he’s referring to very early iconography of the Crucifixion?05:30 – In the story of Ananias and Sapphira in Acts 5, could it be logically deduced that Peter was exercising the ability to retain sins?10:28 – If Jesus was born in 3 or 4 BC, and lived to be 33, would it be more accurate to say the crucifixion, resurrection, and ascension took place in AD 29 or 30, as opposed to the commonly cited AD 33?16:25 – Since Mary was preserved from original sin, did she experience sickness?19:59 – If St. Joseph had children other than Jesus (as some traditions hold) why wouldn’t they be the legal heirs to David’s throne?23:36 – What is your take on Revelation 6:10?33:16 – How authoritative are the Pontifical Biblical Commission’s early decrees on traditional authorship (for example in 1914 the PBC declared Paul wrote Hebrews)? Now the PBC is not part of the magisterium, but at the time of these declarations it was. It seems like almost no Catholic scholar nowadays thinks Paul wrote Hebrews, but I don’t understand why the PBC’s earlier declarations are no longer authoritative. (Including supporting Mosaic authorship of the Pentateuch, supporting Matthean priority, etc)37:31 – I was talking to a fallen away Catholic. How do you respond when they say Adam had a first wife named Lilith and Eve was his second wife?40:20 – I understand if a couple divorces legally they’re still married in the eyes of the church. If one wanted to get remarried, they would have to get an annulment from the church, but suppose that marriage produced children. What does the annulment mean for the children of that marriage as far as the church is concerned?? Or another way of putting it: if my parents got annulment from the church, does the church still recognize me as a baptized Catholic? or do I suddenly become a bastard child (for lack of a better term)??45:08 – How should we understand Jesus “fulfilling the law”, specifically considering the abandonment of many of the laws of the old covenant?49:16 – Prior to the fall — Did “Adam and Eve” have Preternatural Gifts if they existed under the Federal Headship Model or the Polygenism Model? If they did what would have been the morality of Human Beings, with Preternatural Gifts, mating with human like beings without preternatural gifts.…
Questions Covered:02:01 – At what point do you think pursuing the rights in the second amendment becomes sinful?08:10 – Are there dinosaurs in the Bible?12:41 – How does the incarnation not defy divine simplicity?16:09 – If faith is a grace from God, why does not everyone be given all the grace they need? In the parable of the sower, why isn’t everyone made into good soil, is it simply due to free will that even given all the grace in the world some people for whatever reason would still say no? Thank you for your time, Mr. Akin.20:05 – With what level of certainty can we say where someone is in the afterlife apart from extraordinary means like canonization. Secondly what are good ways to communicate this appropriate level of certainty to those grieving the loss of someone they love.29:05 – I travel quite a bit. Missing mass and days of obligation happen unfortunately. Should I seek a dispensation from my pastor? What should my approach be?34:17 – I understand that the “Law of the Conservation of Mass,” applies to chemical reactions. However, when considering the bodily assumption of our Blessed Mother, and the ascension of Jesus into heaven, how is the Law of the Conservation of Mass applied? I understand that heaven isn’t “somewhere else,” but “somehow else.” Then how is Mass conserved between our physical realm to the spiritual realm where our Lord and Lady exist?40:25 – How does one justify or condemn the use of nuclear weapons? More specifically how do you weigh the deaths of Japanese children against the potential deaths of American soldiers? (From a Catholic perspective)48:30 – Would Jesus’ family be considered poor compared to the average family in Nazareth? If so, would that have something to do with not being able to find room at the inn in Bethlehem?53:03 – I don’t know if this counts as normal or weird, but I’ve started to get into linguistics and I was wondering how we should think of the Tower of Babel story? Thanks!…
Questions Covered: 02:15 – How can I respond to my Orthodox friends who struggle with depicting God the Father in Catholic artwork? 12:00 – How can I respond to questions that Mary Magdalene was an apostle and even wrote a book of the Bible? 19:50 – How does your Catholic faith help during holidays or moments of loneliness during the year? 28:45 – Can you explain why Jesus in the New Testament said things directly when teaching to fulfill the scripture of the Old Testament? 43:06 – I live with a brother who claims to be Pro-life, but doesn’t fully agree with teachings on contraceptives. How can I best explain this to him? 48:51 – Is it okay for a non-Catholic to use Holy Water or have a bottle at home? 50:04 – Is it true that the Pope is infallible when canonizing Saints? …
Questions Covered: 06:31 – How should Daniel’s final vision be interpreted in the book of Daniel? 13:24 – Is it okay to wait for someone to ask for forgiveness before giving it? 18:06 – What is grace? 28:53 – I read from St. Bernard that Christ has three natures instead of two. Does this align with Catholic teaching? 33:37 – Can horror books and movies be considered demonic? 51:30 – How can I respond to my Orthodox friends who struggle with depicting God the Father in Catholic artwork? …
Questions Covered:03:30 – How do I respond to the claim that 1 John 2:18-21 proves that if the faithful leave Christianity, they were never a part of the faith in the first place?17:10 – Why is there not a list of dogmas?29:23 – I’ve committed the same mortal sin so much that my confessor questioned my sincerity. Now I just received a blessing. What should I do?42:40 – Tertullian mentions the word ‘symbol’ when discussing the Eucharist. What would be the Catholic response to this?51:25 – Regarding your Mary book. Mary and Joseph couldn’t have been religiously married because it would have had to be consummate. What are your thoughts on this?…
Questions Covered: 08:20 – Why can’t a non-Catholic receive communion in a Catholic church?16:21 – My husband is Muslim but can get around the idea of Jesus as God. How do I explain it to him?24:55 – I’m on my way to becoming Catholic. How can I better defend a faith that I’m not yet a part of?31:39 – How can I bring up the topic of Religion/ Catholicism to my friends?33:57 – How does a Catholic respond to antisemitism?48:18 – Can you give a general defense of the faith against Mormonism?…
Questions covered:04:37 – How should I talk with my non-Catholic friends and family as I think about converting myself?14:28 – The Eucharist seems like magic to me.21:05 – Some people I know are not Catholic because of the very existence of Satan and the fact that God allowed man to fall.35:40 – I am a Protestant becoming Catholic, but I do not know how to rebut Sola Fide arguments.45:02 – I get hung up on intercessory prayers and praying to the saints in general51:20 – I am Catholic, but I disagree with a lot of orthodox teachings.…
Questions Covered:08:17 – My friend is not Catholic because popes have been wicked or corrupt.14:16 – I am not a Catholic but want to learn more. How do I go about doing this?19:34 – Where can I find Mary’s perpetual virginity in the Bible? I am a lapsed Catholic.34:50 – Does Joseph have a body and soul in Heaven?37:40 – I’m not sure if I’m Catholic; if I have a godfather, does that mean that I am?43:04 – To play Devil’s advocate, could all the secular accounts of Jesus be mentions of Christian texts and not Christ himself?…
Questions Covered:02:53 – Why can anybody baptize but only priests can consecrate the Eucharist?07:57 – What is a good answer to: why is there a physical dimension to the catholic faith, like blessing ourselves and kneeling?13:30 – Why do we refer to Christ as the Son of Man?19:07 – What does it mean to love God if he neither gains or loses anything?22:22 – Did Jesus have brothers and sisters?30:26 – What do you say to the claim that God is not all powerful because he can make a rock so big that he can’t lift it?36:14 – Why do we venerate the relics of the saints when we have the eucharist?46:35 – Why can’t we take the eucharist home with us?51:47 – Why didn’t Jesus want the demons to reveal who he was when he was exorcizing them?…
Questions Covered:11:51 – Why do Catholics pray for the intercession of Saints? When did that start?18:45 – Why do Catholics hold tradition equal to the bible?23:42 – Why does the Church not have greater clarity on the language of devotion that might be stumbling blocks for Protestants?34:28 – Why do Catholics believe in transubstantiation instead of consubstantiation?42:12 – Could baptism of desire be effective for someone who had an invalid baptism?45:05 – How do we prove that Once Saved Always Saved isn’t biblical?52:09 – What can humans do that angels can’t do?…
Questions covered:33:00 – How do I keep myself from burning out from Exodus90?37:48 – How are the Exodus readings and reflections similar or different from previous years? I have the book; will it be the same as the app’s readings and reflections?46:13 Is there a version of Exodus90 for women?…
Questions covered:21:23 – What other Christians besides Catholics, if any, profess the Nicene Creed and why?35:10 – Where does the Catholic teaching of the Assumption come from?42:00 – Please explain the differences and history of the Nicene Creed, the Apostles’ Creed, and Athanasian Creed.49:15 – Is there any debate on the translation from the original Greek text of the Nicene Creed?51:20 – Is it okay for me to add words to the Nicene Creed in private?…
Topics Covered:02:44 – Persecution of the Church in Nicaragua17:45 – Presidential election19:55 – Inflation21:15 – Ukraine War25:23 – Israel/Hamas/Hezbollah/Iran War32:00 – Catholic news stories of the year44:50 – Story of the year47:58 – Catholic word of the year48:54 – Catholic podcast of the year52:04 – Catholic person of the year…
Topics Covered:02:00 – What is LinkedIn for?14:20 – Dogs in restaurants16:50 – Luce20:41 – Evidence of Christianity in Germany as early as 270 AD23:30 – Meatless Friday obligation35:39 – Altar rails41:39 – Dogs in strollers42:38 – The Eras Tour46:47 – School vouchers47:39 – Australia ban on social media under age 1648:42 – Dogs in airports49:51 – Traditional Latin Mass50:35 – NPR…
Questions Covered:05:24 – Isn’t it correct to say that some good works are necessary to retain our salvation? Isn’t Jesus listing grave sins of omission that imperil salvation at the end of Mt 25? Isn’t a grave sin of omission a failure to do an obligatory good work? 12:35 – What is the basis between mortal and venial sin in scripture and tradition. Is 1 John 5’s talk of sin that leads to death about mortal sin or the unforgivable sin? If it is about mortal sin, are we not to pray for the forgiveness of someone’s mortal sin (i.e., that they go to confession? 19:40 – In your book The Early Church was the Catholic Church, you cite how strong belief in baptismal regeneration was, to the point of people delaying baptism until the end of life to avoid sinning after baptism. This doesn’t seem like behavior we would expect if the sacrament of confession was passed down from the apostles. What early evidence do we have of the sacrament of confession? 24:56 – I hope it is not too late! Who are the Apostolic Fathers? Who are the Church Fathers? What’s the difference among them? 29:18 – I know the usual line for “sin” committed in dreams is that they cannot be mortal sins since in a dream you do not have full consent of the will, but would that also apply to Lucid Dreams? Lucid Dreams are ones that you can control, and there are methods to get this to happen intentionally. Would this increase of conscious control over the dream allow it to become a Mortal Sin? 33:35 – Was Jesus Christ Himself actually the first pope? Didn’t He actually established the Church through His ministry and the selection of His Apostles? Or is this a really meaningless distinction? 37:19 – How can we understand when the words (direct speech) of God are quoted in the Old Testament? Was it, for example, some kind of inner hearing of God? Or a direct revelation of God? How did the characters know that this was what God was saying to them? 45:09 – Are Sacramentals (such as holy water in Anglican churches) blessed by either Priests not in communion with Rome or Non Apostolic priests Valid? 49:30 – Can you help me answer people who think that the pope arose in the early church because of politics? For example, I know someone who thinks that when Clement was telling the (Corinthians, I think?) to not dismiss their leaders in direct contradiction with Scripture in order to gain power. 52:36 – My question is…are you ready for Jesus?! …
Questions Covered:13:30 – In the parable of the servants who were left with talents, what is the meaning (if any) behind the servant with only 1 talent failing to multiply his goods but rather burying them? It can’t follow that having less (skill or what have you) means you’re more likely to fail God? Usually we find great reversals in the parables so this has me a bit puzzled if I’m missing something? Thanks 20:49 – 1 Kings 2 is often cited as evidence for the powerful intercession of the Queen Mother in David’s kingdom. In this scene, although Solomon rises and bows before his mother, Bathsheba–and even brings out a throne for her to sit as his right!–he doesn’t actually grant her request. In fact, he even puts Adonijah to death! Should this passage be considered evidence for Mary’s intercession before her Son (as the fulfillment of the Davidic Kingdom), or are we who use this passage reading too much into it? 31:23 – Thank you! Can you help me formulate the best argument that the Bible is inspired by God to an unbeliever? Thanks. 37:19 – Why do other rites (besides the Roman) have their own canon law codes? 44:07 – What makes a sacrament a sacrament? I messaged a Lutheran content creator recently (because he called Purgatory a “Catholic Lie” and the conversation widened), and the Lutheran fellow very condescendingly spoke to Catholics (as well as Eastern Orthodox) ‘finding God where He is not present’, stating that Baptism and the Eucharist are the only sacraments, with anything else from Holy Matrimony/Orders to Annointing of the Sick being meaningless gestures that distract us from God’s grace, instead of imparting it. I was mortified, and disengaged at some bad faith arguments on his part, but it still made me wonder what is it about those seven things that make them sacraments, but not other things? 50:55 – Can you explain what inerrancy means and doesn’t mean? For example, in I Chronicles it says David prepared materials for the temple and in Samuel it only says it was Solomon. It also says David prepared 100,000 talents of gold for the temple, along with a million talents of silver, bronze, iron, timber, and stone. Do these numbers have to be literally correct for inerrancy? …
In this encore episode, we recall our conversation with our then-chaplain, Fr. Hugh Barbour, O. Praem, on the baby Jesus.…
EWTN has preempted us for special Christmas programming today, so instead of a live show, we are playing an episode of the Catholic Answers Focus podcast from December 29, 2021. …
Questions covered:02:53 – Why is there no uniformity in the Church. Some of the differing practices of parishes seem to contradict each other?14:20 – I don’t understand why the Church split up.20:52 – I don’t understand the biblical basis for the Immaculate Conception.30:12 – Why do Catholics use repetitive prayer? I don’t understand why you should say more than one at a time.41:58 – Why should I believe in Catholicism? I am an atheist.…
Questions covered:04:24 -Why does Catholic Answers urge Catholics to “invoke” the saints rather than “pray to” them?13:23 – What does it mean for the church to be the Body of Christ?18:14 – My Protestant friends don’t seem to understand that the early Church taught the existence of Purgatory.22:25 – Can you explain the nuances in the relationship between scripture and tradition?29:00 – How come there isn’t any evangelization within the flock itself? Catholicism seems so divided.36:23 – The Catholic Church seems to guilt trip its flock.43:53 – Catholicism seems to be based off a religious leader whose legitimacy of claim is questionable.…
Questions covered:01:46 – What is the latest work of the Church regarding extraterrestrial life, and would such life be demonic?07:05 – How do I keep the guilt from the past from interfering with relationships prior to my conversion?16:57 – Are prayers valid for those not in the state of grace?23:03 – Some of my extended family has still not baptized their 5-year-old daughter. How can I charitably approach this?33:26 – In Joseph’s dream, how did he know the angel was real and not a figment of a dream?37:22 – Should we pray for an ecumenical effort inspired by Romans 11?44:43 – Why doesn’t the priest say the blessing that Christ said at the Last Supper?48:30 – My Protestant friend argues that St. Augustine believed submission to the Papacy was optional. How can I respond to this?…
Questions covered:05:07 – How do we define life and consciousness such that we can apply these terms to God but not inanimate objects?13:38 – Why did Mary and Zechariah give similar responses to Gabriel?15:47 – In Genesis 25:23, why didn’t Rebecca share with Isaac so that he could bless Jacob over Esau?19:00 – Why did Jesus need to be baptized? Wasn’t he sinless?23:03 – Why is the Protestant service not a valid mass?25:02 – Can you offer previously said prayers for current intentions?31:58 – Are hastily said prayers valid?34:27 – I woke up to a shadowy figure shaking my bed. What could be an explanation for this?40:35 – Being that Genesis 2:24 talks of one man and one woman, why would God allow polygamy in the Old Testament?44:18 – Can you explain the story of Ananias and Sapphira?47:09 – My now Catholic friend claims John 6:66 was pivotal to his conversion. Could you help me make sense of this?52:00 – Was the Witch of Endor’s summoning the prophets evil?…
Topics Covered:02:51 Is It’s a Wonderful Life communist (continued from first hour)16:00 – Heretic22:00 – Perfect Day31:46 – The Beast43:10 – Mission Impossible…
Topics Covered:02:00 – Overview of movies in 202412:22 – Wicked29:50 – Netflix’s Mary49:15 – Is It’s a Wonderful Life communist?…
Questions covered:13:25 – Can I use the apparition at Lourdes as support for the Catholic Church and the Immaculate Conception?21:05 – Is Transubstantiation a logical contradiction?34:38 – What is humans’ relationship with archangels?38:28 – As a Catholic, what is my responsibility as a grandparent?48:40 – How can someone with autism evangelize to my peers; how can I emulate the life of St. Francis?…
Questions Covered:06:08 – Was Jesus’ claim to be Messiah considered blasphemous by the Jews?14:20 – How do I get my Protestant friend to accept the authority of the Church?23:05 – What does the “work of mercy” entail for the fulfillment of the plenary indulgence for the Jubilee?37:00 – Jesus was historically born in the summer, not the winter. So, Christmas cannot be about his birth!39:27 – My Protestant friend claims that Catholics have changed the Our Father.46:33 – Is there anywhere in the U.S. that has holy doors open for the Jubilee?50:47 – In a hypothetical scenario regarding a committed crime, would a priest hinting that he knows the culprit be an offense against the seal of confession?…
Questions Covered:03:33 – How do you answer when protestants say that the stone is Christ not Peter?07:45 – How do I convincingly argue to my protestant friends why we Catholics confess our sins to priests?15:05 – I always said that the Church has too much money and is too rich but always asks for money. How should I respond?24:11 – How do I respond a protestant who says “my Jesus is no longer on the cross” in response to my crucifix?32:54 – I’m a protestant considering Catholicism. What is the sin of presumption?42:08 – How do I respond to my southern Baptist friends who teasingly say that Catholics go to confession just to go sin again?48:37 – How do the saints hear our prayers?51:36 – I want to share my response when I get asked about my crucifix.…
Questions Covered:06:38 – How do we know that the saints can hear us from a scriptural perspective?18:00 – I struggle with all the forms that look like worship given to the saints. Things such as incense. What’s the distinction?30:21 – I’m Orthodox. If the Papacy is so important to salvation, then why didn’t St. Paul wrote about it in Romans?30:21 – I’m Orthodox. If the Papacy is so important to salvation, then why didn’t St. Paul wrote about it in Romans?43:13 – I’m in RCIA and have a Dilemma on whether I should join Catholicism or Orthodoxy. Did the Papacy really change in a radical way?52:08 – Does the Church lean on the prima gracia, prima scriptura aspect instead of the sola aspect in regard to Luther and the protestant reformation?…
Questions Covered:12:33 – What are we protestants missing out on by having different scripture from you Catholics?16:55 – Do you happen to know why Act 2:42 is constantly used by nondenominational Christians to claim their denomination is right and Catholicism is wrong?29:27 – It seems like sola scriptura is a cause for protestants to miss out on purgatory.32:00 – We protestants in our mind see that only the word of God is important, and Catholics muddy the waters.36:38 – Iowa Catholic Radio… Is it an official view that tradition always wins when scripture and tradition are pitted against each other?44:45 – There must have been more that Jesus did that was not recorded in scripture. Is that where tradition comes in?47:40 – Is it right to say that protestants miss out on the understanding of the coming of Christ since they miss the entire story of the Maccabees?51:20 – Does 1 Jn 2:27 teach against tradition?…
Questions Covered:11:41 – My biggest struggle was discovering that certain vices that I struggled with were sins that people don’t seem to pay a lot of attention to.16:53 – Is there a lack of attention on the kingdom of heaven during a healing journey?22:05 – Station of the Cross… My daughter is dating a man who looks like is in the beginning stages of alcoholism. What can we do to help him?30:38 – How do you beat addiction?37:27 – I’ve been sober since March of 2020. I’m homebound and unhappy. I feel stuck.47:20 – My brother is a recovering alcoholic and has never formally received any help. I don’t know what to do if I catch him drinking again.52:20 – I work in the field and commend you for your work!…
Questions Covered:01:30 – One of my family members is now a Sedevacantist and doesn’t recognize JP2. How can I help guide him back?08:32 – Why does the placement of Maccabees in the bible vary depending on the bible?15:12 – In Genesis it says God’s presence dwelled in the presence of the garden of Eden and since marriage/sex is the manifestation of our desire to be in union with God, then why did Adam yearn for a partner/Eve?18:12 – Does the bible mention miscarriages in Numbers?20:59 – Does a bankruptcy also forgive the moral obligation to pay off the debt?29:12 – What are the reasons that orthodox Jews don’t believe that Jesus is the Messiah?35:09 – In my psych class we were told that you can detect violent behavior in young children that could manifest itself if it goes unchecked. What would be the ethical stance on hospitalizing them for life?42:47 – Does the bible say anything about how to approach relationships with the in-laws?46:34 -Did Fatima want us to be enrolled in the scapular? Do you need to get a scapular blessed?49:10 – Is it possible for the devil to steal souls from purgatory?50:30 – I see that the Anglican Church is going to have a female archbishop, should we end dialogue with them?51:49 – Why do Catholics honor the Sabbath day on Sundays?…
Question Covered:05:11 – Why do we address the pope as holy father?07:38 – Is it ok for us to not wear shoes at Church?14:30 – What does the Catholic faith mean to you?17:30 – What explains Skinwalker Ranch? Have we ever been visited by extratempestrials?23:29 – Is listening to music with profanity cooperating with evil?35:28 – What are your thoughts on wearing veils at mass?37:03 – My brother is using abortifacient birth control, how can I approach this situation?43:43 – What’s a good amount of prayers to pray a day?45:38 – What would happen if the pope declared something ex cathedra that was clearly heretical?50:28 – Why do some masses not give the precious blood historically? …
Questions Covered:00:58 – How does one keep from worshiping Mary?08:13 – I don’t believe Juan Diego was a historical person. I see it as problematic that the Church canonized a person who possibly wasn’t real.17:05 – How can you tell that Guadalupe is not a man-made image?21:35 – What are your thoughts on evangelical Catholic churches?29:00 – How does one come back to communion after one loses salvation after being baptized?46:18 – What obligations does an adult child have to a dying parent who does want to receive the final sacrament?…
Questions Covered:11:39 – James 2:18-19. What is the Catholic position on where the quote ends?20:40 – Could you help me explain the Assumption of Mary to a Protestant?50:00 – If God ever forgot about you, would you disappear?…
Questions Covered:06:50 – If Numbers 36 applies to Mary since she’s a perpetual virgin, does this imply she is closely related to her husband?09:10 – How does one become consecrated to Mary? How does the Church approve of Marian apparition or vision?16:25 – How do I develop a stronger love and devotion to Mary?19:50 – If Mary was consecrated, how was she not in the temple and getting married?24:00 – If Mary was here to glorify her son, how do we make sense of her requesting Juan Diego to build a chapel in her honor in the Guadalupe apparition?33:26 – How much autonomy does Mary have?37:28 – Is it true that if you pray the rosary using a certain devotion you gain generational blessings?41:55 – What was the cost that Mary endured to say yes to God?47:35 – What does it mean to be consecrated to Mary as a child?51:30 – Is there any teaching on the love between Jesus and Mary?53:15 – Was Mary always the intended holy mother?…
Questions Covered:15:50 – How does a man separate worry from his duty as a husband and father?19:40 – What scripture can I meditate on to ease my guilt of leaving a job that is in desperate need?30:00 – What are your thoughts on Phil. 4:6 saying not to worry. What do you think of false guilt?36:13 – How can we find peace when our children and grandchildren don’t practice the faith anymore?42:50 – Had a moment where a work situation stole my joy and peace. Offered it up through Mass but still had to deal with it afterwards. Besides trying to trust and continuing to “offer it up”, what can I do to not worry and trust Jesus more?47:57 – I was diagnosed with chronic anxiety. I need help and answers.50:50 – I am currently working to be a certified spiritual director. What piece of advice for someone who suffers from severe panic attacks?…
Questions Covered: 09:17 – How did Protestant lose the Doctrine of the Immaculate Conception?16:17 – What is the status of the devotion of Jesus King of all nations?20:16 – How would you word the Divine Simplicity of God not having a body without it becoming a heretic?29:38 – What proof do we have that the Catholic church was founded by Christ?36:30 – Having a hard time understanding why Mary is immaculately conceived but no else?46:17 – The Pope and Trump have differing views on building a wall, who am I supposed to believe?50:11 – how did protestants go from the catholic belief that faith without works is dead to faith alone?52:00 – in a protestant bible study who is going to argue with her about confession… why do we have to confess to a priest?…
Questions Covered: 04:54 – Why did the Jews of Jesus’s day believe in the power of Satan to drive out demons? 15:20 – How do we evangelize people who are uncomfortable hearing about God? 22:14 – On Christmas Eve, the 50th Jubilee begins. If I can’t get to Rome, how can I observe the Jubilee? 48:40 – Did Jesus or the Apostle kneel before statues or pray to Saints?…
Questions Covered:01:15 – Hi Jimmy! What does a real Paranormal investigator do and what methods do they use compared to all “ghost hunter” sensationalist types out there? I’ve had a couple of genuine experiences myself and I don’t fall for the bogus methods (spirit boxes. SLS cameras) out there. I’m Catholic (and certainly don’t think “everything is demons”) and I don’t believe nonsense like tarot or go looking for these encounters. Just curious if there’s any real scientific research in this area. Thanks!13:45 – In light of recent studies on psychedelics such as psilocybin or DMT being an effective treatment for depression, PTSD, and smoking cessation, how can Catholics understand this and how does it apply to paragraph CCC 2291?20:40 – What are your thoughts on reverse speech?30:30 – What is the church’s teaching on usury? On economic injustice?33:43 – I’m pregnant with my first child. When I receive the Eucharist, does my baby also receive?35:27 – What I get from the online discourse is that the only mood for mass is reverence. I get that this is because of the sacrifice of Christ at the cross. But then, why can’t I feel joy or excitement? Or if I can, when is it appropriate to show it and how? Also, some resources for learning about liturgy would be nice.42:45 – If God picks your time of death, wouldn’t this mean he could choose if you go to heaven or hell? Because your will might be at point A towards God and at point B against God48:58 – If a person is prayed for that may already be in heaven, can those prayers help other family members or someone else who might be in need of those prayers?…
Questions Covered:03:33 – What are your thoughts on determinism and free will, can they be combined?7:20 – How does God know he’s not a brain in a vat?08:14 – My 5-year-old asked “Did Jesus’ death on the cross make God the Father sad?”12:44 – Where does the idea of “the rapture” come from? I’ve heard that it isn’t actually biblical, but pop culture and many Protestants would claim otherwise.19:30 – I am a later in life convert and I did not baptize my two now young adult children as infants. Is it possible to conditionally baptize them due to their other parent preventing their baptisms? The situation they are in is not typical I gave birth to them within a same sex marriage prior to conversion and then I was radically converted. The same sex marriage ended 10 years ago I am now married to a man in the Catholic Church. Neither of the children desire to attend Catechism classes and my son is 17 and my daughter is 20. I pray a Novena daily for Baptism for them to occur. It’s the Saint Therese of Lisieux Novena asking for her prayers for my children. Thank you Jimmy and God bless you.21:47 – Hello Jimmy, i am Catholic from Africa how can I help people around me who refuse to be Christian or Catholic saying it is because it is an invention to keep Africa poor calling it « the white man’s religion »28:40 – Hi Jimmy, someone had asked if there would be bacteria in Heaven and you said it’s possible if God allows us to eat and Heaven is like a big banquet with the saints. So if we eat in Heaven does that mean there’s death in Heaven since things would have to die for us to eat it?36:44 – What would the Church do to celebrate the Eucharist in the event of a blight that killed all wheat on the planet?42:41 – How should Christians understand these words of Jesus: “For truly I say to you, until heaven and earth pass away, not the smallest letter or stroke of a letter shall pass from the Law, until all is accomplished! Therefore, whoever nullifies one of the least of these commandments, and teaches others to do the same, shall be called least in the kingdom of heaven; but whoever keeps and teaches them, he shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven.” Doesn’t this mean the Law of Moses still applies to Christians?46:30 – In a previous AMA, you said in response to someone’s question that if a person were assimilated by the Borg, the state of their soul adjacent to confession would remain unchanged. If someone were assimilated, could they conceivably receive anointing of the sick?47:55 – To what extent can a priest alter the words of the mass? For example, a priest at a chapel I go to says “This is Jesus, the Lamb of God” instead of “Behold the Lamb of God”, which I think is quite beautiful, but I am unsure if it’s correct.49:17 – Doesn’t the act of naming someone a pope fit the definition of a sacrament? It’s 1-a rite 2-Instituted by Jesus (Matthew 16) 3-to convey grace (infallibility)52:59 – Are orthodox bishops and old catholic bishops and sedevacantist bishops real bishops?…
Questions Covered:01:50 – Mr. Akin ….I had my future told to me after I had a staring contest with a guy who had the ability to view my future life like watching a video in fast forward….pausing when he saw things he thought important….this is how he explained it to me…He was able to see all the way to my last day….something he said he hadn’t been able to do with others…. not only could he see my life through my eyes …but could also see what was going on all around me….. I met him at work …. Mr. Akin have you ever heard of this type of ability before…..can you help me understand what happened and why please….12:47 – What if the priest doing Mass is really old and suddenly dies during the service? How’s that handled?15:50 – Which Church Sui Iuris would extraterrestrial join if they accepted the Faith?16:56 – Has Protestant exorcism ever been validated??? Is Protestant exorcism only the goofy stuff like Bob Larsen and Benny Hinn yelling and throwing invisible spiritual inner chi fireballs at their subjects? Or does it have any credulity like the most severe case I’ve seen with the Warren family helping MAURICE “Frenchy” THERIAULT on camera footage?21:58 – Did Jesus have a body before he was born as a man?24:54 – How does Odo not turn into a pile of goo when he uses a transporter?32:52 – Most people get half of their DNA from their mother and half from their father. I assume Jesus got at least half of his DNA from Mary, but what about the other half? Was he 100% Mary? Did God just “invent” 50%? Do you think God made him resemble St. Joseph?35:24 – Could someone be a Catholic atheist?39:36 – If we discovered the Creature from the Black Lagoon, would it be permissible to eat it on Lent?45:07 – If a ship of volunteers is collected to go to Mars, should the Church insist on sending a Bishop?50:05 – I work with a non-Christian lady who used to be a Hindu and claims to believe in the Christian God. She was not a very nice person from what I saw how she treated other people. One day, she told me a story that when she went to a Church to pray because she was having a problem at that time, she saw blood on her palm. The light in the Catholic church was dim so she looked at the palm intensely and didn’t know what it was. After few seconds the blood disappeared. She got spooked and thought that was a spooky Church so she went to the Anglican Church nearby. Before she told me the story, I was listening to the life of St Padre Pio who had stigmata. My question is does stigmata happen to anybody?…
Questions Covered:02:22 – I heard this as an argument against the body and soul being distinct and advocating strict materialism, i.e. it’s all in the brain: If we consider that memories, emotions, reasoning, consciousness, personality, etc. are distinct from the body in the senses of sight, sound, smell, touch, taste then what accounts for the changes that occur when drinking alcohol or taking drugs for a temporary effect, or the habitual use of psychedelic drugs which cause a permanent effect? A spiritual soul should be unaffected by the chemical changes in the brain, but since behavior is changed passively from ingestion in this and not by an active decision, doesn’t that prove materialism and disprove a spiritual soul?13:26 – I have asked multiple priest and exorcists about “perfect possession “and have yet to have anyone give me an answer. I have read about this characterization of complete possession of a person by Fr. Malachi, Martin, as well as a few other exorcists, but no thorough definition or had any current exorcist or priest confirm that perfect possession is true and possible. Could you please expand on this? It seems in these crazy times perfect possession would explain a lot of what we see in the church at large and the world. Example, people openly and flagrantly in the state of mortal sin able to go to mass, receive the sacraments, come into contact with holy objects, receive communion etc., without any adverse reaction or manifestations towards these holy things. I am hopeful and humbly asking that you will answer with clarity about perfect possession22:25 – If aliens made of anti-matter showed up and wanted to become Catholic, how would we accomplish this when the sacraments like baptism, ordination, and the Eucharist involve contact with matter?31:30 – Which, if any, pagan gods are real?34:46 – Did Neanderthals have immortal souls?44:02 – Why does time seem to go by faster as we get older?47:26 – How tiny can the Blessed Sacrament be? Many years ago I once asked a priest to clean the paten better because I noticed some particles of the consecrated bread remained on it. He answered that my problem was that I believe that Jesus is present on each of those tiny crumbs. I was very indignant. I like a verse in a Corpus Christi hymn that mentions that Jesus is really present on each of the small pieces of the consecrated bread broken. Now, recently I was reflecting on that indignant moment, saying to myself well, Jesus is present as tiny as a molecule, atoms, fundamental particles or strings, if they exists… until I said wait a minute… at some point on those levels one cannot distinguish bread. There is even a theory that says that all the electrons of the universe are the same thing. So I think the limit is not scientific but philosophical: Jesus is present up to the point when one can still perceive the attributes of bread. But then… maybe that priest was not that wrong at all… Mr. Akin, is Jesus present in the crumbs and if so to which level of smallness?…
Questions Covered:02:30 – Why was the early church so divided on things like the dating of Easter?12:29 – Did Mary have a choice to say no since God had already made her without sin?17:45 – Did the events of Joshua actually happen? If not, what consequences would that have?30:20 – How do I defend the Marian Assumption to protestants?36:17 – How do I remember and internalize epiphanies that I have during prayer?43:37 – How do last rites and apostolic pardon tie into redemptive suffering?50:07 – When are teachings infallible? How do we figure when something is open for discussion, like female priests?…
Questions Covered:06:08 – How do I defend infant baptism?13:28 – I’ve heard the Church has banned and burned books. Is this true? What is the Lesser Key of Solomon?18:49 – What are your thoughts on options for fathers getting to veto abortions of their own children?28:30 – According to science, a fetus is not alive till it gets the heartbeat. Which means comparing it to an alive grown human is wrong.30:48 – Why does God tolerate our free will if he knows we pick things that are not good for us?36:18 – Is it Simony to purchase a blessed item?41:40 – Can Catholics be universalists?47:34 – My friend asked, how could Mary hear our prayers if she is in heaven?51:32 – How do I defend the faith against the Orthodox who claim we are inconsistent especially the filioque but yet doesn’t require eastern Catholics to say it?…
Questions Covered:00:30 – What spiritual advice do you have for someone who is discerning Catholicism?12:49 – Is it disobedient or sinful for us to receive communion kneeling if we’ve been requested to receive standing?18:06 – If I’m given a heavy penance and can’t complete it before the next mass, can I receive communion?23:26 – Is my marriage valid since I wasn’t married in the Catholic Church?29:33 – How do I work in a family who is not Catholic? How do I celebrate advent with them?36:17 – Was Jesus’ body always present before coming to earth?46:01 – If our desire to sin evaporates when we are in the presence of God, then why does purgatory exist?53:14 – What is the chronological order of, the presentation of Jesus, visit of the Magi, flight to Egypt and the massacre of the innocent?…
Questions Covered:05:17 – How could Adam and Eve choose to sin if their nature did not include concupiscence?15:26 – How do we determine whether the early Church was Catholic or Orthodox?21:49 – How do you know when you are in a Calvinistic church?32:49 – Can you go to heaven without the sacraments? Or if you die in the process of becoming Catholic.35:30 – How do we properly deal with not feeling that our prayers have been heard?47:35 – If good Mariology leads to good Christology where does the bodily assumption fit in?52:53 – What spiritual advice do you have for someone who is discerning Catholicism? …
Questions Covered:1:00 – Why are the people attending the Latin Mass starting to lean towards denying the pope and those in the Novus Ordo leaning towards affirming him?22:27 – Who writes the footnotes in the bible? Is it the Magisterium?32:28 – In John 3:16 the Protestant translation says, ‘should not perish’ but in the Catholic version it says, ‘might not perish.’ Which is more correct?37:05 – My best friend and I both left the Church and now I’m making my way back. How do I approach her especially on topics like salvation when she doesn’t seem to care?48:09 – I work for a company that sells Plan B and occult items. I have no say in the selling of these items. Should I look for another job?…
Questions Covered:03:23 – Why is Orthodox communion valid?11:59 – I’m Protestant. How do you process that God calls people to practice as ministers in protestant church?34:02 – Why isn’t Mt 27:52-53 more attested in history?46:12 – where do you think, presumably, are we in the eschatology timeline?52:24 – Psalm 72 seems to reference that it was the last Psalm of David. Is it a Psalm written by Solomon to David or from David to Jesus?…
Questions Covered:20:45 – My husband is a revert to the Catholic faith. His family has not reverted, they’re non-denominational. How can I as the in-law discuss with them why we need to have time to go to Mass? 36:14 – How do works play into our salvation? 47:00 – My high-school-aged son is “Catholic” but he says there’s no God. 53:20 – I have two sisters and a brother-in-law who have left the Church because of their spouses. What are some strategies to get our siblings to at least think about investigating that as a reason? …
Questions covered:16:25 – How do you answer a trans or gay person who tries to justify their lifestyle by saying “God made me this way”? 37:46 – I want to thank Jason for tweeting about St. Bernadette’s church in Scottsdale years ago. It’s what got me to go back to Mass. 41:44 – Do you think we as Catholics need to separate boys and girls at school more? 44:25 – I became promiscuous because I was Mad at God. How does someone deal with the pain and anger? 49:45 – I’d like to share how I overcame my desires when a priest in the confessional gave me the chastity prayer of St. Augustine. 52:31 – As a father of young girls, how can I tell them that not liking stereotypically feminine things isn’t a sign that they’re actually boys? …
Questions Covered:01:55 – How could one know what statements are infallible? Why does it not matter that there isn’t a definitive record or list of infallible statements/teachings 06:27 – Is a hot dog a sandwich? 12:48 – Do the eastern churches that used to be eastern orthodox still use the eastern canon, or did they switch to the Catholic list of books. And if it did change their canon, how has that changed their liturgy or practice/their sacraments? 15:46 – One question that I’ve always pondered was, what would it have been like when the Blessed Mother first received the Eucharist? I can’t imagine what it would have been like for her and perhaps I may never be able to understand or imagine that. 17:35 – Dear Jimmy, I have one: Can Catholics believe in an atemporal fall? (Or a pre big-bang fall)? Thank you very much! 21:38 – Hi Jimmy, new Catholic here. Could you help me to understand in The Apostles Creed where it states that Jesus “descended into hell.” Still a little confused as to what that means. I’ve read several interpretations and can’t seem to find a consensus. Thanks! You’ve been a great help in my journey. 24:31 – What makes baptism in tongues different from baptism in water? 29:12 – How should we treat the angels named in ancient extra biblical sources like Enoch and Jubilees? I have been wary of and avoided interest in them after seeing their use in occult and esoteric connections? Is there any standing Catholic teaching on this topic? I have come across references to a 745 synod in Rome? 37:08 – Do atheists who willfully reject the existence of God and Christianity on strict philosophical/evidential grounds have a chance to be saved? If so, on what basis? 41:18 – We know that angels, both holy and fallen can materialize in a form on earth. Jacob, Lot, etc….If fallen angels do materialize as UAPs, why do they choose the form of a flying craft?…a craft can carry multiple individuals. Why materialize as a flying craft? 48:48 – Does reciting the Confiteor during Mass absolve us of venial sins, and if so, is it necessary to say the entire Confiteor for the absolution to be valid? One of our parish priests will sometimes skip over it, jumping straight into “May Almighty God have mercy on us, forgive us our sins …” Thank you for all that you do, Jimmy! 51:37 – Bible Question: How does one reconcile 1 John saying “If we say we have no sin, the truth is not in us” and also saying, “Those who are born of God do not sin.” 53:51 – I came across a claim recently that suggests Lazarus could actually be the Beloved Disciple from John’s gospel and the eyewitness source for the gospel. I wonder if you have heard this claim before and if so what are your thoughts on it. …
Questions Covered:03:19 – How do we understand what Mary is doing for us, and how should this reflect in the language of our prayers? E.g. do we ask Mary directly for graces on the interpretation that God has given her authority to dispense these graces (& if so, how can we be confident this is accurate/appropriate), or do we ask Mary just to pray on our behalf for God to give us those graces? I guess the same question can apply to other saints too, like St. Anthony when we’re searching for lost things. Whether or not we ‘need’ to add extra words to make clear that we’re just asking them to pray for us, should we be mentally holding that concept? Or are there ways in which any saints (particularly Mary) can be known to actually dispense graces so we can just ask that saint for that grace directly without adding qualifiers about how what we’re requesting is for them to pray to God about this? 06:24 – Is bruschetta a valid appetizer? 10:24 – The possible prophet who predicted Trump being shot in the ear 4 months ago. Is this for real? 14:04 – How would you rebut the belief that the early church fell into idolatry immediately, e.g the Eucharist, and is heretical, and because Israel fell into idolatry immediately in the desert there’s a biblical pattern/ example for this 16:05 – I wish to have a more convincing answer for this question ¿What prevents us from believing that Catholicism is but a development of Christianity as understood by St. Paul, thus lacking validation since he was not a direct witness of Christ’s teachings? So far my faith-based answer is that 1) the 12 disciples were around and they would stop Paul if he was teaching false doctrine; 2) Peter acknowledges Paul’s wisdom even if he’s “hard to understand” (2 Pt 3,15-16); and 3) Jesus allowed the development of doctrine guided by the promised Holy Spirit. However, these reasons may not be enough for a non-believer: 1) the 12 might not be always auditing all of Paul’s letters; 2) being hard to understand in fact includes the risk of passing as true something that is not; and 3) teachings that do not contradict those of the Founder do not mean that were meant by the Founder. Thank you Jimmy. I like your apostolate a lot. Greetings from Panama. God bless you. 22:17 – I’m sure you’ve heard this one before, but I don’t know a good answer. If we assume (hopefully) that someone with invincible ignorance of the faith may receive God’s mercy and avoid Hell, is it possible we’re sending people to Hell by trying to evangelize them, knowing that they may in fact reject our attempt? Or, even worse, we are bad witnesses and we actually push them away from the faith? (The example I have heard applied to an Eskimo, but it could apply to anyone who is far removed from any church or believers.) Thanks again Jimmy. Peace be with you. 29:31 – I would love to know where the Tradition of the Assumption comes from. I was just baptized this last Easter, and though I am familiar with the teaching itself, I’m very fuzzy on why Christians believe this. If there is a scriptural basis we can turn to as well, I’d love to know it! Thanks for everything you do, Jimmy! 34:36 – To what degree should we take saints’ teachings and beliefs as Catholic doctrine? Both for topics involving our faith & for non-religious ones (e.g. thoughts on raising children). Thank you! 37:43 – Thanks Jimmy. I know this is a basic tenet of the faith, so I know I’m missing something: How did Jesus ‘save’ us? If he had not been incarnate, how would our lives be different? Or, say he was scheduled to arrive 100 years from now, instead of 2000 years ago? Would we not be able to be ‘saved’? 49:10 – Many religions and religious sects arise from a type of prophet or chosen one who begins to claim that the …
Questions Covered:05:21 – How does the Church establish the dogma of the Immaculate Conception with so much of the Early Church not clearly defining it and even St. Thomas Aquinas being contrary to it? 14:35 – If a person dies and is cremated, can the remains be held in a sacred space or altar in a home? 18:16 – If the Jews are the chosen people, why not convert to Judaism? 22:44 – Is scripture a higher authority than tradition? 28:54 – I heard that fulfilling the conditions for an indulgence results in someone’s soul going to heaven. Is that true? Do I still need to pray for them? 32:12 – Is it true that once you confess your sins, they won’t be revealed on judgment day 36:00 – Vatican 2 states that anyone baptized validly is Christian and called brothers to those in the Catholic Church. Is this objective or subjective especially when compared to previous documents of the Church? 43:30 – Would a woman have to get a tubal ligation reversed to be in line with the Church? 44:12 – Why does Mary need to be without original sin to be able to say yes or no to God? 46:05 – My question is regarding latria/dulia and the distinction. Specifically the claim that in a religious context they are never separated or approved of for anyone other than God. the claim I heard also mentioned that this is because they come from the same root word in Hebrew. 50:04 – To what extent does the Church say that intrusive thoughts can be sinful? 51:44 – Are they referring to chattel slavery in Deut. 20:10-14? …
Questions Covered:06:26 – Is belief in the Assumption and Immaculate Conception necessary for salvation?14:03 – If saints are confirmed to be in heaven, is there any barrier to the Church canonizing non-Catholics who live good holy lives?17:12 – Was John the Baptist born without original sin?19:40 – If someone wants to join the Church it seems like they have to do so much unnecessary waiting to go through the RCIA process. Any thoughts on that?24:21 – How is there room in heaven for us and the angels if God is infinite?30:02 – Considering how the Orthodox don’t believe in the Immaculate Conception, does that mean they’re not saved???:?? – How do we reconcile Purgatory with the last judgment? It seems unfair for people who live till the last judgment and still have sins on their soul to be treated differently than those who died earlier and were purified.42:25 – Is it hard for us to understand that we can go to hell for things like missing mass because we are not looking at it from God’s perspective?47:40 – Do I have to believe something that a saint, like St. Thomas Aquinas, said?…
Topics Covered:01:00 – Bible in Texas Schools30:30 – Meatless Fridays46:34 – Conclave Movie49:00 – Martin Scorsese’s TV series on the Saints…
Topics Covered:00:00 – Introduction and Chris knows about Spongebob05:57 – Australia bans social media for kids32:41 – No dating, no spouse, no……
Questions Covered: 02:45 – What’s the difference between a plenary and partial indulgence and are in the bible? 08:15 – Why do Catholics worship statues? 18:27 – Is there evidence that Jesus ever existed? 24:05 – Why do Catholics call priests Father? 35:59 – I struggle with the Protestant interpretation of Hebrews 6:2? 42:54 – I struggle with eating the Blood and Body of Christ? 48:08 – I heard a priest share there are no more miracles after Peter. What do Catholics believe and how can there be a contradiction? 50:26 – Do Catholics believe Jesus didn’t finish the work of redemption? …
Questions Covered: 09:56 – Why do apparitions only happen for Catholics and not other religions? 17:51 – Can you make the argument for indulgences? 24:11 – Why can’t priests be married? 34:48 – Why are the Saints depicted with halos? 43:50 – Why do we need to confess to a priest? 50:51 – How can I believe Catholicism when it seems to leave many things open to interpretation? …
Questions Covered: 01:29 – Is there a parallel between Jeroboam breaking off the Northern Tribe and Protestantism? 12:33 – In 1 Timothy, Paul talks about qualification to become a Bishop you must have one wife. Can you explain what is meant by one wife? 17:52 – Traditionally Pilate is seen in a negative light, is it okay to see him in a more positive light? 23:41 – Can the Old Testament relationship between David and Johnathan be used to support same-sex relationship? 28:53 – The Greek word barjonah is used in Matthew 16:17. Is this evidence against Matthew being a Jewish author? 34:50 – How can I explain priest celibacy and how it changed? 43:36 – Can you share what is the Catholic interpretation of Ephesian 5? 51:11 -What is the correct translation of Genesis 3:15? …
Questions Covered: 04:35 – When Christ comes back will he reinstitute animal sacrifices? 07:00 – How can I speak on the rapture since it is not in the Bible? 15:17 – Where in the New Testament does Jesus establish the priesthood? 16:17 – In Roman 13, what authority is meant when it states to submit to the government?22:24 – Why does the Our Father prayer differ from the biblical line “deliver us for the evil one”? 29:24 – I heard God does not do evil, so he doesn’t harden people hearts. Does this conflict with the Old Testament when it say God will harden Pharaoh’s heart? 35:13 – What does the Bible say about civil litigation concerning priest abuse? 42:35 – How can you explain the teaching “turn the other cheek”? 49:49 – Why was the devil able to tempt Adam and Eve, but not Mary? …
Questions covered:03:35 – In John 17, when Jesus prays “that they may be one,” I can’t help but wonder if the way he phrases it there implies that the Church wouldn’t be one. Is that the case? 07:08 – What is the logical path from deism to Catholicism? 15:17 – Why was the death penalty allowed in some circumstances in the Old Testament when the person wasn’t a threat to the society? 28:55 – Why isn’t Thomas à Kempis a saint? 31:34 – What are Jimmy’s thoughts about how advanced ancient civilizations fit into the history of the Bible? 38:15 – Could a Catholic read Jesus’ teachings in terms of a midrasch? 42:40 – Were there two different creations of humans, since Genesis records two accounts? 45:52 – If there are ghosts haunting churches, what are their souls doing here on earth instead of being with the father? 51:27 – In a state of mortal sin, what helps are there for overcoming that sin? …
Questions covered:14:15 – I don’t know how to approach my son. He fell away and now he doesn’t want to hear anything about Jesus.32:46 – Is there a difference in the way a Protestant would evangelize versus how a Catholic would?43:59 – My Catholic sister-in-law is pro-choice and believes there’s “two different Catholics.” Whenever I try to talk to her she says “God tells us not to judge.” I’m stuck and don’t know how to move on from there.…
Questions Covered: 03:08 – In cases of annulment are the children from that marriage illegitimate? 07:16 – What is an interlinear Bible in the original to Spanish? 13:05 – What are the seven spirits of God in Revelation 5:6? 15:47 – Who would the people in 2 Maccabees 12:46 been praying for, since there weren’t Christians?33:01 – How do I re-evangelize my aunt and Godmother who is Pentacostal? …
Questions Covered: 07:00 – How do priests have the authority to Transubstantiate? 15:02 – Did the apostles receive the Sacrament of Holy Orders at the last supper? 21:17 – Why does Jesus refer to himself as the Son of Man in Mark 10:32 instead of saying I? 28:48 – How should I view Pope Francis’s revision to the Catechism on the death penalty with Pope Leo X? 41:00 – Can someone who doesn’t know Christ receive Salvation? 47:44 – I heard a Rabi say that the only unintentional sins were forgiven in the Old Testament. How was this fulfilled in the new covenant?51:55 – I have heard that the Husband is the priest of the house. Who is the priest of the house when their isn’t a husband? …
Questions Covered: 04:00 – Would the promise of the Brown Scapular apply to the second coming? 09:44 – How can I argue well against IVF? 17:42 – Why didn’t Eve and Adam have any children in the garden prior to the fall? 29:50 – Can I attend the wedding of my Mother-in-law to a man who hasn’t gone through the annulment process? 33:28 – Should I not receive the Eucharist if my marriage is not valid? 39:48 – I’ve heard people say there were English translations prior to William Tindale, what were those Bibles? 46:20 – Why do Eastern Rites receive Confirmation and Baptism as kids?50:24 – What are the key differences between Catholic and Protestant beliefs on the end times theology? …
Questions Covered: 08:17 – How can we navigate the idea of conversion for those who live in evangelical families? 17:45 – What is your favorite Advent tradition and why? 23:00 – Is it okay to listen to lonely themed music? 29:44 – Why didn’t Jesus explain exactly how things should be instead of speaking in parables? 32:24 – Do people in a state of sin face more negative thoughts or habitual patterns? 41:46 – Do we know what it means when Gabriel says the Spirit of God will overshadow Mary? 45:04 – Why don’t protestants recognize the early church fathers or apostolic succession? 50:07 – How should I interpret Mark 13 on the temple being destroyed in comparison to other passages? …
Questions Covered:02:59 – I attend a protestant church. What questions should I be asking the pastor?12:46 – Am I going to heaven when I die? I was baptized in protestant church.19:57 – I’m a recent convert. Why is mortal sin such a big deal if we can just go to confession?29:36 – I’m in OCIA. I would like you to critique my reasoning on purgatory as I’m beginning to understand it.34:32 – How do Catholics view salvation?44:27 – What’s the difference between the elect of the Old Testament and the elect as Paul talks about in Romans 8?52:05 – How do I respond to my protestant who brings up Mark 7:7-8 when I mention Thes. 2:15 during our discussion on tradition.…
Questions Covered:08:45 – I got to church with my baptist husband. Is it hypocritical for them to use the Church Fathers to defend their faith? They quote Eusebius.16:59 – As a protestant I’ve been looking into the Eucharist. Why are priests necessary for consecration? Is communion outside of the Catholic Church valid?32:26 – Why do Catholics believe in purgatory?44:21 – Why can babies be baptized if they can’t have faith?…
Questions Covered:04:44 – Can my girlfriend and I get married sacramentally without having to get married civilly?09:13 – I’m worried about my husband’s soul who passed away. What can I do to help him?21:55 – Do Catholics believe that other denominations can go to heaven?30:16 – How do I explain to my ex wife why I want to get our marriage annulled?38:22 – Was Paul married?46:46 – What is the best way to figure out which translation of early church writings to read?53:50 – Do you have to request a mass to be said for you while you’re still alive?…
Questions Covered:16:14 – My friend divorced over 40 years ago and never remarried. How would one find out if the spouse is still alive? Does the Church have a process of finding them?18:44 – The Church Tribunal says I have to have witnesses of my husband’s unfaithfulness to get an annulment granted. Since there are no witnesses, am I stuck with this?20:53 – My daughter married a divorced man in the Greek Orthodox Church. Does he have to go through the Orthodox Church for the annulment?22:26 – Do marriages that don’t take place in a church need an annulment? Does the Church make it clear how serious marriage is during marriage prep?30:55 – I watched your Coming Home Interview. I just wanted to thank you and show appreciation for all you do.35:23 – My grandparents married outside of the Church but are now divorced. I worry about their salvation. How do I approach them about this?38:46 – How confidential is the annulment process?43:07 – I want to marry in the Church who is currently married and estranged from her husband so can’t file for annulment. What can the Church do to help?47:37 – I’m a convert. What’s the basis for all the grounds for annulment? Is it from the bible or from Tradition?51:16 – Do I have any interjection or right in a current annulment underway where the respondent will not respond due to being afraid or hurt? This man I question was also my husband?…
Questions Covered:02:20 – in the sacrament of Holy Orders, clergy progress through ranks—deacon, priest, and bishop—implying they receive the sacrament multiple times, each with additional spiritual authority. Does this mean they receive the full sacrament once, with additional authority “unlocked” at each level, or is each stage more akin to receiving a fuller portion of the sacrament over time? If they receive the same sacrament with varying levels of authority, wouldn’t that mean Holy Orders is actually three different types of sacraments that are slight variations of each other?08:25 – Mt 7:13-14. Is it wrong for me to read this as a motivational passage instead of a somber one?13:17 – Will you do an episode of Mysterious World on our Lady of Champion?15:47 – What are your thoughts on the mystic Luisa Piccarreta?20:38 – How do we find a happy balance between taking responsibility for actions that lead to bad thing happening to us vs bad things just happening?29:03 – What are your thoughts on Exodus 4:24?35:38 – What is the best way to dispose of Catholic literature?43:27 – Why is it that Catholicism removes consent and stewardship from its moral philosophy?52:04 – How do I respectfully approach my pastor to bring back passing around the basket for the offertory? It was discontinued during COVID and never brought back.…
Question Covered:10:41 – Could you expound on the idea of spiritual communion?24:46 – Nicodemus misunderstood born from about, but St Paul discussed being born again as well. Can you expound on this?32:44 – Can I work at a place that sells alcohol or vapes? Is me selling this making me guilty of causing others to sin?44:23 – How do I reconcile the teachings of St Paul on enduring love and the reality of heartbreak in breakups and being told that a young person can’t know love?…
Questions Covered:09:45 – Does the Church allow for reception of the Eucharist outside of Mass? How has the Eucharist affected you personally?21:15 – I got into a conversation with Baptists and after some back and forth they asked, from a Catholic perspective if it’s okay to be Baptist. How should I answer?34:30 – What methodology do you use to know what parts of the bible to take literally?43:24 – How would you respond to the question, who or what created God?…
Questions Covered:07:16 – Why should we follow the natural law?22:01 – Is it considered idolatry when protestants use grape juice for their communion?32:12 – In John 17:12 it makes it sound like Judas is destined to be condemned. How is this not evidence for predestination?37:57 – Why did the devil exist in the first place?44:10 – How does my exploring Catholicism fit in with invincible ignorance?…
Question Covered:06:07 – How can Catholics affirm evolution if we believe that Adam and Eve could not have experienced death and decay before they fell into sin?11:25 – How does Prevenient grace work if the concept of total depravity is heretical? They seem like the same thing?19:00 – Why is it necessary for Jesus to continually offer his body through priests?23:30 – How can I discuss uniquely Catholics doctrines to my evangelical friends and family?38:34 – I’m Catholic looking into Orthodoxy. Am I wrong to assume that papal primacy wasn’t as apparent as we claim because if it was, they wouldn’t have split?47:52 – Is it true that souls in purgatory can’t pray for themselves but can pray for us?…
Questions Covered:06:58 – When do thoughts become mortal sin?15:57 – If you die wearing a brown scapular, do your loved ones have to pray for you? Do you have to go to purgatory?20:42 – I’m just now returning to the Catholic faith. I’m meeting with my priest tomorrow. How do I properly prepare? What should I expect? Send words of eternal life and secrets from heaven32:13 – I was in line for confession and the priest stopped right before I got to go. What do I do at that point? Can I receive communion since my intention was there?42:02 – Will parents be culpable for their children’s sin before they reached the age of reason?47:01 – What are the miracles attributed to the Miraculous Medal? Is it Just superstition?51:50 – What is the Church position on immigration law?…
Cy and Matthew discuss the Synod on Synodality, recognition of saints among Catholics and Orthodox and the results of the 2024 U.S. election.…
Questions Covered:01:48 – What do you mean that it is ok to believe Adam and Eve are symbolic?06:20 – What are the restrictions on Fridays? Does that include all animal products or just animal flesh?10:22 – Why did God mandate Hosea to have relations with the prostitutes?15:08 – Can we truly know if we are saved?19:10 – I found a ring with the initials SMOTJ. I discovered it was the Sovereign Military Order of the Temple of Jerusalem. What is it and is it Catholic?22:30 – How do I respond to the claim that there is no evidence that the Deuterocanon was not included in the original canon of the Old Testament?29:04 – Once you discover the talents that God has given you, how do you use them to the best of your abilities?30:52 – Is polygamy acceptable in an apocalyptic situation?37:12 – Why don’t Catholics baptize by immersion and in the name of Jesus?43:40 – Do you have any speculation as to why the book Esther wasn’t found in the dead sea scrolls?46:45 – When did the bread that Jesus had at the last supper turn into his body and blood?50:17 – What are your thoughts on Dr Scott Hahn’s theory and book on the Fourth Cup?52:36 – Is the Church’s definition of death, the separation of body and soul? Would Elijah resurrect a child in 1 Kings 17:17-24 back up this definition?…
Questions Covered:06:01 – John 14 Jesus says He is the way the truth and the life. How would this affect people who haven’t heard the message of Jesus?08:35 – Why do some Catholics justify doing bad things in a civil marriage and later dismiss that former behavior saying it was not an issue because it wasn’t a valid marriage?15:09 – Is it necessary to believe in historic Adam and Eve?21:09 – Why does one need to be baptized to merit anything? How do you answer the atheist object of why would God send an unbaptized but otherwise good person to hell?32:08 – Can you help me better understand Matthew 24?45:29 – Why did God allow certain things in the old law like capital punishment?52:50 – How is it not blasphemy to pray to the saints?…
Questions Covered: 03:05 – I have an Eastern Orthodox friend – How can you prove Mary’s sinlessness through scripture and history? 12:10 – Can you explain your article that said Miracles happen? If they do, why do we rarely ever see them? 19:05 – How do I go by the code of canon 988 in confession, which says I must confess all past mortal sins? 34:25 – If somebody has a phobia is that something they will need to detach from in Purgatory? 38:08 – I struggle with the idea that rituals would mean something to God. Is there a scriptural reference for their importance? 43:06 – Why did St. John the Baptist send his disciple to ask Jesus who he was, if he recognized Jesus in the womb? 47:28 – My church does a communal Rosary during the time I can go to Adoration. How can I respond well to this since it prevents me from doing private prayer? 52:14 – Why do bad things happen to good people? …
Questions Covered:03:08 – How do atheists handle the question “How do you know what is essential to the category of God”? 07:45 – I met an atheist who believes in the idea that the universe is circularly caused. How can I respond to this? 13:40 – How can I interpret paragraph 9 of Inter mirifica as it relates to media? 19:14 – What did St. Paul think of his previous faith and Judaism? 29:23 – How do I respond to people who say you shouldn’t judge? 34:40 – Is Tradition infallible? 41:31 – Can a Catholic consider corporal punishment in general inadmissible? …
Questions Covered:03:10 – What happens if someone commits a mortal sin under baptism of desire?05:28 – When Pope Pius XII issued liturgical forms to include vernacular, what was the purpose of that?08:04 – Can Latin Mass societies begin the Easter Vigil Mass at a different time than is standard today?12:49 – Is it okay for me to use the New Oxford Bible translation for a Catholic Bible study?16:12 – How can we be so sure that Jesus wasn’t just using symbolic language during the last supper?29:16 – What is your advice on what I can do since I can’t participate in the sacraments as a non-Catholic?33:59 – Would a person that has to go to RCIA classes have to pay for the classes?46:17 – The World Health Organization says that no amount of alcohol is good for a person. How does this square with the Catholic religion and their use of alcohol?…
Questions Covered:05:13 – What is the matter in the sacrament of confession?12:33 – What do you recommend to read for someone who wants an intro to the Church Fathers?18:10 – How do we make the argument that Enoch is not inspired scripture?23:56 – If we are not supposed to judge people, how do we judge anything in our lives?31:20 – Why should Catholics consider Mary perfect?38:32 – What evidence in the Early Church apart from Paul do you have to justify calling priests father?48:08 – My husband is not Catholic. How do I convince him of the authority of the magisterium?…
Questions Covered:07:26 – I’m new to Catholicism. What next steps can I take to learn more?13:49 – What reliable methods do Catholics have to detect the supernatural?22:16 – I’m Protestant. Why does RCIA/OCIA take so long?30:03 – Why did they get rid of the communion rail?33:39 – Why should a non-denominational Christian become Catholic?38:22 – Are there levels of Purgatory?47:20 – What are the 3 most common misconceptions that keep Protestants away from Catholicism?…
Questions Covered:04:53 – Why does the Catholic Church claim to teach salvation by faith?17:53 – Why do Catholics believe in purgatory and what does that mean?31:44 – What is the Catholic interpretation of Romans 4:5?35:28 – Why don’t we see Catholics street preaching? If they do, what does that evangelization look like?46:05 – Why do we as Catholics believe in some of the laws of the Old Testament such as priestly laws? Why do we follow those and not others like the Mosaic laws?…
Questions Covered:08:38 – Is there empirical evidence in biochemistry for your God?17:28 – If AI had free will, could it be blamed?22:16 – How does the Church deal with how Fr. Georges Lemaître’s work was used to calculate the big bang?34:22 – Could science prove the existence of God? Have you read Peter Kreeft? Are spirit and matter distinct and disconnected?45:37 – I’m a Catholic AI engineer. I disagree with the claim that AI sentience cannot exist. I think it’s something we should be concerned with.52:36 – I have thoughts on AI not being able to have sentience. Its closer to robots.…
Questions Covered:17:33 – Should we take every word that Jesus said literally? Ex. Pluck your eye out if it causes you to sin.30:26 – What are your thoughts on a priest who claimed that feeding the 5 thousand was not literal?35:46 – What are your thoughts on Jonah?38:38 – I heard that the sponge they used to give Jesus wine on the cross was a sponge the Romans used to clean up after using the restroom. Is that true?45:40 – You guys are wrong about the eye of the needle was a gate.49:58 – Is the miracle of Jesus raising a man from the dead a prefigurement of his death?52:30 – Saul/Paul was given a new name at his conversion.53:12 – They used to swaddle lambs so it wouldn’t get blemished.…
Questions Covered:02:58 – Do you think God speaks to you?07:22 – I’m actively reading and studying my Bible and one of my top concerns is if the Jewish people were given adequate chance to believe that Jesus was God and that his teachings were true? Obviously the Jewish people have continued on and is that not what God wanted? Any discussion on the topic would be appreciated, thank you to Jimmy and his team!15:13 – Good evening Jimmy from the UK! I have a question about the Sacrament of Confession. In the Old Testament, people brought animal sacrifices to the priest to atone for their sins, with the size of the sacrifice corresponding to the severity of the sin (If I remember rightly). This is mirrored in the early Church, as confession was a public act, where individuals admitted their sins before the entire congregation. However, this practice evolved into the private, one-on-one confessions we know today, largely due to the influence of Irish monks, who introduced this method in the early medieval period.Some have argued that because the form of confession has changed over time, the Seal of Confession could also be altered. How can I explain this development to non-Catholics (and some Catholics too)? Thank you Jimmy, may God continue to Bless and Guide you all!20:18 -I’ve watched your Mysterious Worlds episodes on young earth/old earth and the flood, but would it be permissible for a Catholic to interpret Genesis as a poetic narrative describing God’s creation of man and culling of the most evil men in our distant past by 1) reading Adam and Eve being earlier hominids when our ancestors became able to reason instead of being driven by instinct and in turn after sinning against God by eating from a possibly metaphorical tree of knowledge, our brain capacity started to expand causing more difficult births? And 2) reading the flood as being a story about God destroying more sinful versions of our ancestors, causing a population bottleneck as far back as 900,000 years ago?Converting to Catholicism from a secular background, reading the Old Testament as divinely inspired truths seen and expressed through a lens of the contemporary culture when each part of the OT was written removes all the stumbling blocks to finding my faith, but I don’t know if my interpretation stretches what is written too far.34:56 – How is a narcissist saved if he’s in complete denial about being a narcissist?37:10 – Is there a philosophical possibility that God exists without omnipotence?I heard an argument from a liberal Christian, Dr. Goff, which posits that a semi-powerful God would solve many theological quandaries, such as the problem of evil.42:08 – Hello Mr Akin! What do you think of religious orders?45:20 – Is it a correct understanding of the Catholic Faith to say that when Jesus suffered and died that only his human nature suffered and died and not the divine person?’48:06 – How to find the truth in the world of excess information?49:55 – I would love to know a breakdown of the evidence for and against global warming and in particular the degree to which human activity plays a role in this. I ask this of Jimmy because he may be one of the only people I would trust to give an unbiased assessment.…
Questions Covered:10:38 – Why was the Ascension “necessary”?13:05 – Some saints were said to have levitated. Will our resurrected bodies have abilities like levitation, telekinesis, etc.?17:12 – What if the pope breaks the seal of confession? Is he excommunicated? Who would he be excommunicated from?21:00 – Is the war in Israel/Hamas prophesied in the Bible?24:06 – I’d like to know the church’s view on the union dock worker strike? Is it ok to stop working in this situation/what roles does the union play in society?32:22 – After the bodily resurrection, do we live in Heaven, the new Earth, or some combination of the two?33:14 – Hi Jimmy. Why were there guards stationed at the tomb of Jesus if Jews only believed in Resurrection at the end the world? Doesn’t this imply that the Jewish authorities at least thought Jesus’s followers believed Jesus could rise from the dead? Do you think His disciples believed he would rise after 3 days?37:35 – Jimmy Akin. Do you think that Jesus received any grace when he ate the Eucharist? I know He is the source of grace, but He was strengthened by an angel in the Agony in the garden. Curious to hear your thoughts on what is happening in both of these instances, on a metaphysical or ontological level.42:40 – Are there instructions or limits to cursing? My intuition is that it is bad… but Jesus did curse a fig tree and said woe to whom betrayed Him. Was it OK because He’s God? Furthermore, would it be bad to curse a war and what would be the effect?51:09 – When death occurs suddenly and the incident is faster than the brain can comprehend (as in the case of a submarine implosion) does God give a grace of awareness to the victim, or is it possible for the soul to be confused at the judgment seat of Christ?…
Questions Covered: 01:30 – Do we need to fast on Holy Days of Obligation? 08:01 – Is it okay for Catholics to read the Left Behind series if viewed as Fiction? 15:11 – Why haven’t problematic catholic influencers been excommunicated? 28:55 – Is my confession valid if I am not given a penance or asked for the Act of Contrition? 35:09 – Can you explain the existence of the Serpent before the fall in Genesis 3:12? 50:00 – I’ve heard that only people who bear the mark of the Antichrist will be able to buy things in the end times. Is this true? …
Questions Covered: 11:46 – What does the Catholic church view as the main problems with to Martin Luther’s Ninety-five theses? 18:01 – Why do Catholics Baptize infants? 29:18 – Is it a permissible view Genesis 18 as a manifestation of the Trinity? 34:25 – I found $600 today, what should I do? 42:00 – What is the Catholic view of organ donation specifically when it comes to brain death? 48:30 – Why is it assumed that Mary died before she was assumed? …
Questions Covered:03:27 – How can I get across to my confirmation students the importance of going to confession? 11:53 – How did the Magi know that the star of Bethlehem was leading them to the king of the Jews? 16:21 – Does Joe still hate cheesecake or have you repented of that sin? And is Cy going to release a full version of St. Irenaeus and the Goblet of Fire? 22:26 – I heard Catholics say that Scripture has a kind of primacy over Tradition. But that seems to contradict what I’ve read in the Catechism and Dei Verbum. Can you explain? 31:19 – The shroud of turin is one cloth, but one of the Gospels clearly says there’s a separate cloth for his head. Is that a problem? 34:33 – What is the Catholic position on embryos? Are they alive or just tissue? 43:44 – Can you help me explain the role of Mary in salvation history? 48:39 – How can we know God, and in what way is a person able to know God? 52:05 – How can be there different levels of approach to God in heaven? I’m uncomfortable with that idea. …
Questions covered:05:28 – How do we reconcile parts of both scripture and tradition that seem pessimistic about many being saved with other parts that are more optimistic?14:48 – Does infallibility produce an infinite regress?20:48 – How would Joe’s argument against the Protestant view of scripture handle views of perspicuity that are more limited?29:01 – How do we know that Matthew wrote Matthew and John wrote John and Revelation? We don’t have any other writings to prove that from.36:01 – What does CCC 841 mean when it says we and Muslims together adore the one God?47:38 – How do Isaiah 53 and Galatians 3:13 fit into the Catholic view of atonement as opposed to penal substitutionary atonement?…
Questions Covered: 04:13 – Can you share your interpretation of Matthew 5 as it relates to purgatory? 07:38 – If God is all good and loving, it seems unjust to send an unbaptized baby to Hell? 15:14 – How do I share with my mother that the Saints are praying for her, she just needs to ask? 21:41 – Are canonizations infallible? What confidence can I have in this process? 29:40 – Where did we get the idea that Saints can pray for us but not themselves? 33:39 – What is Purgatory? Can we know if we are going to purgatory? 41:31 – Is the suffering in Purgatory close to the level of Hell? Can the souls in purgatory talk to us? 49:10 – Can you explain the Saint prayer to release 1000 souls in purgatory? 52:05 – Is purgatory different from Paradise? How does this impact the thief on the cross? …
Questions Covered: 05:03 – Does the church teach that Purgatory is a process or a place? 13:13 – How can I reconcile purgatory and the final judgment? 19:23 – What is the difference between OCI and RCIA? 24:27 – What is the treasure referenced in Luke 18:25? 32:57 – How do I defend purgatory with a Baptist who don’t have the book a Maccabees? 39:23 – How many Saints pray for us? 45:39 – How do you find out the name of your guardian angel? 50:08 – Can you explain Hallowtide as we prepare for All Saints solemnity? …
Questions covered:18:35 – I want to know what Father thinks about the long lines for communion and the short lines for confession. 22:20 – How should I engage my siblings who are lukewarm? 36:04 – My husband goes to communion but not to confession. I’m worried about what to tell him. 43:18 -What is the difference between discipleship and a relationship with Jesus? 50:10 – I go to Mass a few times a week and help at the parish. But some people go to Mass every day. Should I be doing that too? 52:30 – How important is it to have somebody else with you when evangelizing? Jesus sent the disciples out two by two but it’s hard for me to find a good partner. …
Questions covered15:35 – How can I introduce the faith to people who have no previous experience or reference to it? 21:08 – What’s the best way that I can continue to catechize my children? I’m taking them to church but they don’t really participate and they’re bored. 29:28 – A logical exercise for parents who feel guilty about their children leaving the faith. 33:44 – My daughter married a man with two kids and they’ve had two more. I want to tell her she should focus on the two kids she’s had and let the father discipline the older ones. Is that the right thing to say? 36:47 – In the business world “systems thinking” is when we go beyond the “what” and try to look at the “why.” It ties in beautifully with what Dr. Ray is saying. 52:12 – I was kicked out of my parents’ house because they didn’t want to talk to me about the faith. How can I reconcile with them? …
Questions Covered: 01:28 – Was St. Thomas Aquinas excommunicated? Why? 14:37 – What is your opinion on the ethical framework of God asking Abraham to sacrifice his son? 24:21 – I heard Jimmy say it is better to exist even if you end up in Hell. How can I compare this to Jesus saying, “The one who betrays me it was better for him not to be born”? 34:42 – What is your opinion on Dousing? 44:35 – Who did Jacob wrestle within the Old Testament? 51:47 – How do blessings work with lay people versus priest? …
Questions Covered: 03:35 – What advice would you give for starting a college apologetics club? 09:22 – Is there Mass in Heaven? 15:03 – What is your defense on John Henry Newman’s idea of doctrinal development? 24:45 – How can I refute once saved always saved and perseverance of the saints with scripture? 34:16 – How did Thomas receive the gift of the Holy Spirit since he was absent in John 20? 41:08 – In the 3rd letter of John, I have read different translations with Church or church. Would the lower-case c translation indicate John talking about a local church not the universal? 46:30 – Is snowflake adoption ethical? 51:59 – Does the long history of sexual abuse in the church make the church an apostate? …
Questions Covered:03:02 – Why do Catholics have Jesus on the cross instead of just a cross. Also, are tattoos immoral?16:01 – My wife and I were married in a Lutheran church. She is Catholic. She was told by her priest that she is not allowed to take the sacraments. Is this true?28:45 – Often I hear complicated ideas when explaining Catholic doctrines. I find it hard to follow, and imagine others do as well. Do you have to understand these things to be Catholic?44:15 – I’m considering Catholicism. I’m struggling with some Marian doctrines. Is it enough for me to become Catholic to assent to the Church’s doctrines, while not really being sure if I believe in them?47:40 – What is the Catholic view on dispensationalism?…
Questions Covered:03:48 – Could we employ some of your arguments against the Evil God Challenge against atheistic naturalism?08:37 – I like the argument against sola scriptura that scripture doesn’t say everything has to be in scripture. But Protestants respond that Old Testament Jews didn’t have a magisterium, yet they still knew, more or less, what books were canon. If Old Testament Jews were fine with that, shouldn’t we be too? How do we respond to that.17:17 – Are those who go to Hell likely to eventually go mad from all their suffering?21:08 – In light of the recent story of the man declared brain dead from whom they were harvesting organs, but then the man showed signs of life: how should Catholics consider organ donation?29:33 – Convince us that abortions are evil without using religion.32:20 – Why is the purpose of the uterus disanalogy in the violinist argument successful in refuting it?43:24 – Is 1 Cor 15:29 a good proof for purgatory?50:18 – How do we answer the ethical dilemma: a robber comes to your house and makes you choose a family member for him to kill, or else he will kill your whole family.…
Questions covered:14:42 – Some Protestants are telling me there was no centralized authority in the early church and the bishops of Rome weren’t popes. How would you answer that? 22:32 – What are the other possible interpretations of Isaiah 53? 25:14 – Is it licit to practice cranialsacral therapy? 32:21 – How does the Catholic Church justify what it did in the Inquisition? 44:23 – I think what goes on in my neighborhood during Halloween is demonic. They’re glorifying death. 50:49 – Can you tell me more about the Black Mass happening in Atlanta on Friday? What’s going on there and what should we do? …
Questions covered:06:05 – Is the story of the rich young man the same story in Matthew, Mark, and Luke, or is it something that happened frequently enough that they all reported similar but distinct interactions? 15:29 – Exodus says half of the ten plagues didn’t impact Israel, but doesn’t say that about the others. Did they impact Israel, and if so, why? 21:15 – The physical human body is sexed male and female. Is the human soul also sexed masculine and feminine? 34:38 – Can you help me understand the Church’s new teaching on the death penalty? …
Questions Covered: 03:48 – How to respond to Catholics recent teaching on infallibility? 15:00 – I question the validity of annulments? 20:04 – How do we reconcile a dogma taught by Pope Pius XI being counter only a few decades later by Vatican II? 29:25 – I struggle with the teaching on life when it comes to cases of rape or incest? 36:46 – What is the point if only 144,000 will be saved? 44:49 – I struggle with the line “I go and prepare a place for you in Heaven” in John 14:3? …
Questions Covered: 05:39 – Why does the Church teach that there in no salvation outside the Church? 13:29 – I struggle with the statistical proof for faith? 19:57 – My friend has a hard time with the Pope. Why are there disagreements? 30:16 – My friend can’t get over the Queen of Heaven in Jeremiah and Pope Gregory’s teachings on it? 34:06 – I struggle with the lack of clarity in RCIA classes. Should RCIA members participate in the sign of the cross and other parts of the Mass? 43:56 – My obstacle to practicing is my personal challenge with improving past behaviors and my friend group? 51:28 – My friend struggles with what makes monotheism true? …
Questions covered:08:11 – If you got permission from the Pope to access the secret vatican archives, what’s the one thing you’d want to see?19:20 – Why does it seem like so many Catholic priests are hard to interact with on a personal level?24:10 – My granddaughter is being taught that Adam and Eve aren’t real people and that bothers me. What are Tim’s thoughts on that?35:28 – How did the rosary come to be? And how did it become associated with Mary?46:05 – Why does the stigmata occur in the hands when most historical data suggests Jesus was crucified through his wrists?51:14 – Who is the man of lawlessness referenced in 2 Thessalonians?…
Questions covered:23:30 – What would be a short, succinct response to the Protestant claim that indulgences aren’t found in the Bible? 32:20 – How can I develop my online outreach and persuasiveness in order to reach peoples’ hearts? 42:20 – How do I evangelize online? 48:07 – How should I go about starting a YouTube channel for Christian apologetics to boost my profile as a DJ? …
Questions Covered: 01:31 – Is Zachary King’s testimony a legitimate conversion? 05:39 – Why is it not good to receive the Eucharist in your hands? 13:06 – My first wife had abortions; do I still need to confess this? 15:17 – What is the will of the Church regarding Baptism? 19:13 – How do you discern if the traditions you believe are from God? 23:25 – What is the origin of relics in Catholic Altars? 33:34 – Was the Gospel of Luke written as a Classical Greek comedy? 44:22 – How should I view the unapproved Our Lady of the Tear of Joy apparitions? 48:47 – What is the difference between First Baptist and Catholics? 51:39 – If there is no time in Heaven, how was Moses in a waiting place?…
Questions Covered: 06:21 – If we know that angelic beings can assume physical bodies, why don’t we just say they have physical bodies? 14:48 – Why didn’t Jesus acknowledge a scenario where He and the demon were putting on a play verses saying Satan doesn’t allow conflict? 17:49 – Why should we have trust in the Papacy based on the historic aspect of having good and bad Popes? 23:21 – To what degree are we expected to defend the Eucharist physically? 33:09 – When we say there is no salvation outside the Catholic church, do we mean the institution or the body of Christ? 35:55 – Is the Immaculate conception a Holy day of Obligation on this year’s Calendar? 41:44 – How do we pray for the repose of the souls of still born babies? 44:23 – Can you explain buying blessed items? 48:48 – Is it okay to have relations with an ex-spouse prior to being remarried? Does this second marriage need to be in a church? 52:17 – Why are Holy days of Obligation different in the United States and Canada? …
Questions Covered: 13:30 – I’ve found the people within the church to be roadblocks to others. 23:00 – What commonalities can I build on with my Protestant friends? 30:19 – I feel called to be a Deacon; can you give any input on next steps? 35:03 – I have had problematic experiences with a priest. How can I trust a priest again? 43:44 – How can I humbly help in the conversions of friends? …
Questions Covered: 03:20 – In Genesis, when God says, “let us make Man in our image”, is He speaking to himself or to the holy angels? 07:47 – Is it okay to wait to convert and what can I do in the waiting? 13:19 – Judaism never had a concept of a “Diunity” of God and Holy Spirit, so how did we get to the doctrine of the Trinity? 20:06 – In Matthew Jesus says to pray in private, so is communal prayer blasphemy? 24:30 – If the Real Presence is the source and summit of our faith, why is it not in the Apostle or Nicene Creed? 31:52 – How can I go about bad or toxic friendships? 37:39 – What is the Catholic perspective on the first or second great awakening? 46:25 – I was shown Mason hand gestures and symbols from a coworker. Would this be considered sinful? 50:30 – Can you clarify the parable of the wheat and weeds? …
Questions Covered: 01:49 – Is a Lutheran Baptism valid in the Catholic church? 09:36 – Why do you believe in the Bible when the Bible makes claims disproved by modern science? 20:22 – Catholic views on the end times, do Catholic prescribe to postmillennialism or has the church changed? 23:40 – Can you explain works and faith based on Canon 24 in Council of Trent and 2010 CCC? 50:16 – How can we differentiate between God and Spirit talking to us or own personal thoughts? …
Questions Covered: 05:18 – When did the Bible go from Full of Grace to Highly favored one? Why do we believe Mary was sinless? 29:28 – Can you explain the Stations of the Cross? 42:03 – How can I trust the church when the Pope makes statements undercutting the Catholic positions? …
Cy is joined by two John Paul the Great Catholic University students to face off in this game show episode!…
Questions Covered:04:25 – What does it mean when the book of Samuel says that God’s evil came down?07:50 – What should be the relationship between faith and politics? 14:48 – There have been a lot of apparitions where few people go to heaven. It feels very discouraging. Is this accurate?20:10 – Are the dead that will be lifted up in 1 Thess. 4:17 saved? If not, who are they?23:50 – If you went to confession do you still have to go to purgatory?31:18 – Are all religions different paths to the same God? 44:24 – What is the significance of the water that they put into the wine during mass?46:24 – Charles Morris’ book, in his book American Catholic, he says that the vast majority reject the teaching on contraception. Is this true?48:20 – I’m a convert. How do I better understand the words of consecration? It sounds like the words are only meant for that piece of bread and not other pieces moving forward.50:28 – Since we as Catholics believe that Jesus sat on the throne of David, how do we respond to Christian Zionists who believe it needs to physically happen?…
Questions Covered:01:53 – Why was Judas necessary?10:21 – Is abortion wrong just because a uterus is for the purpose of fostering children?16:30 – Nondenominational people in my area have begun believing the idea that the pope is going to make a one world religion that will usher in the end times. Are you familiar with this idea and where it stems from?23:11 – You mentioned earlier that you didn’t think very highly of the author Dan Brown. I’m genuinely curious why.28:59 – I’m engaged to a man in the military and started having visions of his friends who have died in battle. What should I make of this?37:03 – What bible translation do you think is the most accurate? Coming from a protestant background, what translation would you recommend for me?41:58 – Are our deceased loved ones able to recall the pain they endured?47:10 – Why does God let children suffer?51:47 – With the Church constantly under attack, why aren’t we praying for victory but peace instead?…
Questions Covered:03:34 – What are the necessary contrition, motivations and resolutions needed for a valid confession? 07:59 – My protestant friend claims that St. Augustine’s said that being born of water and spirit means a physical birth, not baptism. Is this true? 14:16 – Is it socially acceptable in Catholic circles to make up Marian apparitions for writing science fiction? 19:00 – Can you clarify the meaning of Luke 11:15-26? 23:32 – Are coincidences negative or positive and how should one navigate them as a Christian? 33:40 – Why did the Church make Sunday mass obligatory? 37:35 – Is it morally just for a government to outlaw labor unions? 42:50 – Why should one become Catholic considering how shaky the foundations can sometimes feel? 49:48 – What would be a good response to the Calvinistic claim that the story of Jonah is evidence for there being no free will? 53:31 – Can someone disagree with what the church teaches if they have a well-formed conscience? …
Questions Covered:07:41 – What should Catholics take into consideration when voting?19:45 – The Council of Carthage claims that babies don’t go to heaven. Was that rejected or was that authoritative and how does that relate to the line in the Creed we believe in one baptism in the remission of sins24:42 – Is Nestorian considered Christianity in the sense that Lutheranism and Calvinism is?32:29 – Can an Orthodox person receive communion in the Catholic Church?36:48 – What is the Catholic view on freedom and determinism? Is it hard determinism, libertarianism, or compatibilist?45:43 – Jesus says render unto Caesar, but does that mean we are giving a pass to leaders since they are so evil?51:17 – Could you explain what the current synod is and what it means for the Church?53:09 – Does Mary have any authority other than intercession?…
Questions Covered:02:54 – What are your thoughts on Matthias being appointed to replace Judas?13:48 – If I could learn a language to read the bible, which should it be, Ecclesiastical Latin or Biblical Greek?17:17 – Why doesn’t the Church gather frequently to infallibly define everything?28:45 – How would I explain that there is only one God to a Mormon?41:14 – What is your best argument for the Assumption of Mary?…
Questions Covered:03:30 – Gal.3:13 mentions Jesus became a curse on the cross. How do we properly understand the term curse in that context?15:05 – Is there a difference between the Septuagint and the current translation of the Old Testament?19:58 – My friend is a traditional Catholic and has a 1st class relic. She said she got it after the Church cleared out the churches after Vatican 2. Is this true?29:35 – I’m Catholic but how do I know that Catholicism is the one true religion?44:10 – Was witchcraft mixed into Catholicism when African slaves were brought over to Haiti?47:27 – I’m 69 years old and I get strange experiences where I have knowledge of things I shouldn’t know. What should I do with this information?51:53 – I’m in RCIA coming from a reformed background. How do I understand the difference between penal substitution vs Anselm’s satisfaction…
Questions Covered:03:25 – What’s the actual effect of Grace? What does receiving the Eucharist do practically?13:50 – How does the Catholic community define and practice worship and prayer?21:03 – In Anglican. If the claim that Peter’s successors retain the same power and status, why don’t the successors of the other apostles hold the same?29:33 – I’m almost finished reading the book of Numbers. How am I supposed to read the story of Balaam and Balak?34:31 – What is the Sabbatine privilege and what are the requirements to obtain it?40:52 – What scriptures do Jewish converts to Catholicism have to abide by?51:50 – What are the requirements for a plenary indulgence?…
Question Covered:06:49 – Can you explain the concept of a new Heaven and a new Earth? 15:19 – How can I help my Christian Grandmother’s salvation without hurting her feelings? 21:19 – Can you explain what Paul meant by handing a sinner’s flesh to Satan so his soul can be saved in 1 Cor 5:5? 30:50 – Can you explain why temporal sinfulness can merit eternal punishment? 43:47 – How does Purgatory work and how can we get out? 47:19 – My priest wrote that the worst pain you can have is in purgatory, where in the bible might this be? 51:17 – Does Mark 14:7 excuse us from giving to the poor? …
Questions Covered: 06:29 – Can a believer who is not Baptized in the Catholic church go to Heaven?13:51 – What was the first recorded miracle with a relic?16:09 – When did people stop believing in Purgatory?22:28 – What is the scriptural basis for purgatory?32:46 – How can we explain ghosts or spirits on Earth if there are only three paths after death?36:30 – My son died as a teen, but I didn’t Baptize him. Can he be saved since it was my choice?43:48 – Why might a courtroom scenario be used to describe our final judgment?50:16 – Is it true that only Jesus and Mary are in heaven?…
Questions Covered: 02:10 – How can I respond to claims that Matthew 4 and Jesus’s temptations prove Sola Scriptura?06:31 – Can you explain the new and the old wine skin parable? 12:53 – When is the completion of the Eucharist on the Cross? 16:17 – What is a good response for any problematic study notes in the New American Bible? 22:25 – Was there any time in the Bible where the Eucharist looked like the Mass today or was it a communal dinner? 30:37 – Does Act 8:14-17 disapprove baptism by Jesus’s name only? 39:48 – When Matthais became an apostle there were 13 now, how does this impact the 12 seats? 44:36 – Is the italicized text in the Bible the word of God? 48:17 – Why don’t Catholics go by the Bible exactly? …
Questions Covered: 06:56 – Did the apostles receive the same Baptism of Jesus based on Act 19: 3-4 and Matthew 28:19? 15:15 – Does scripture rule out God being incarnated previously in another world? 16:58 – Based on the different descriptions in Isaiah, Daniel, and John are there quantifiable things in heaven? 22:22 – Was John 6 taken literally by those following Jesus? 31:56 – Why does Jesus take Peter, James, and John specifically in Mark 5, 6, and 14? 35:09 – Are there any recorded instances of people failing to receive communion properly as described in1 Corinthians 11:30? 38:51 – In Isaiah 11:2, why is piety missing from the gifts of the Holy Spirit? 41:59 – Did the New Testament authors realize their writing was divinely inspired? 51:14 – How do we know Peter was given greater authority than the other apostle? …
Questions Covered:01:20 – Why did they stop writing books into the bible?15:45 – Doctrinally how do the differences work in the east and west regarding infant communion?30:51 – How would a protestant align intercession of the saints and a belief in soul sleep?45:39 – Why doesn’t the 9th commandment state coveting thy neighbor’s husband only thy neighbor’s wife?50:06 – In cases where one has discerned that certain media doesn’t impact one poorly, but it will affect others. Can one still listen to it?…
Questions Covered:02:23 – How do we make sense of how we are not crucifying Christ during the mass?18:38 – I’ve noticed that some Catholics and Protestants are acting as though we are in the end times. How do I go about talking with them?35:19 – I need help responding to some saying that Mary disproves the Eucharist?47:41 – Why does a bishop have to give permission to perform an exorcism?…
Questions Covered:02:34 – When we choose our investments for retirement, can a Catholic invest in companies who we know are contributing money to Planned Parenthood?11:26 – Since James was writing before the events of Acts 15, did he fully understand the gospel?17:14 – How would you talk to someone for the World Mission Society, Church of God?22:34 – How do I evangelize my agnostic brother?29:19 – Can you recommend a source on the history of communion?34:18 – Is it permissible to bless my home with blessed oil?36:22 – Why do Catholics keep using the word pray when it comes to communicating with the saints? If they change the wording it may not cause as much confusion?43:06 – Do you think an individual blessing given during communion is in violation of Fiducia Supplicans?…
Questions covered:02:17 – It seems like a lot of non-Catholic religions in which people speak in tongues. Why don’t Catholics do that? And what is the Catholic position on speaking in tongues? 11:49 – What must one do to be saved? 16:49 – What are the rewards that we can obtain in heaven? 19:29 – Why are we still split with the Orthodox over the filioque when Greek is no longer the dominant language in the Church? 24:53 – Can you help me understand the Church’s current teaching on the death penalty in relation to its older teachings? It seems like it’s done a complete 180, not a development. 44:32 – If someone knowingly votes for a person who supports abortion and then dies before confessing, does he go to hell? 49:59 – Why is an infertile person allowed to be married but an impotent person is not?…
Questions Covered:01:36 – I’m a Baptist. If I attend a Catholic service why can’t I receive communion?17:16 – How do we harmonize intercession of the saints and purgatory?41:10 – It’s hard for me to get over the idea of the Eucharist being the body and blood of Jesus as a nondenominational Christian, because I feel like I would deify the wafer. How can I get over this hurdle?51:41 – I was told that some of the saints may be pagan gods and goddesses like St. Brigid. Is this true?…
Questions Covered:08:03 – My wife and I aren’t confirmed yet. Does practicing do anything yet since we’re not fully initiated into the Church?25:25 – I’m Jewish. What is the Catholic interpretation of Psalm 110?36:47 – Why can’t we have premarital intercourse?50:29 – Why does the show prompt there’s a non-optional requirement to be Catholic? Why does the Church think that it bears any weight in an individual’s relationship with God?…
Questions Covered:01:42 – What does a day-in-the-life of Jimmy Akin look like? I know so many of us are in awe of your depth and breadth of knowledge. It would be interesting to see how you structure your day with learning etc.06:40 – I have a few questions that I have had on my mind for some time now. It is said that Latin is especially efficacious for prayer and exorcisms because it is the official language of the church. My question is this, for an Eastern Rite Catholic, who would be under the authority of their church’s head (although the Pope’s authority is, of course, universal and preeminent) and have their own Codes of Canon Law, would the native language of that church be more efficacious or similar in efficacy to prayers in Latin? Or would this only apply to the ancient languages? E.g. Latin, Greek, Aramaic, Coptic, Hebrew, and possibly Church Slavonic and Arabic.14:22 – What’s your thoughts about whether animals and our pets can be in heaven with us or not?18:55 – Does the church condone organ donation?20:28 – Also should we vote for a candidate who is for abortion, when there is no one who is prolife. Should we vote for the lesser of two evils?21:51 – I have full confidence that you are knowledgeable about the “identity” issue. What would you offer in scripture and the catechism to someone who identified as a furry?28:38 – Given the tragic shortage of priests, what would you recommend to someone seeking a spiritual director who is having a hard time finding one?32:08 – I’d like your advice on what to tell my 9-year-old about Blessed Imelda Lambertini (the young girl who reportedly died of joy upon receiving the Eucharist). After hearing about Blessed Imelda my 9-year-old is scared that the Eucharist will kill her too. And for my own curiosity, do you know if this is a documented account or more of a pious legend? Thanks!37:39 – The strongest challenge I ever heard from a Protestant about the Assumption is, “How can the Catholic Church dogmatically declare that the Assumption was ‘believed at all times by the Church’, when there is literally no evidence anywhere in the Bible, Church Father writings or, apocryphal writings of the first Century?”43:05 – What separates the “New Atheists” from the old Atheists?45:26 – If there are many other planets with life, then how would they be saved? Did Christ death and resurrection count for them also and if so, how would they know. Or did God save each planet with aliens differently?48:14 – What are some of the best ways to practice becoming as humble as possible, like Our Lady?50:13 – Is it possible for your guardian angel to not like you or something about you? For example, maybe your guardian angel doesn’t like the same kind of music you listen to. I wonder if a guardian angel ever feels like they preferred getting someone else to guide.52:38 – Who would win in a fight, the Incredible Hulk or felony tax evasion? Asking for a friend ️53:43 – Why was it necessary for the Church to make the immaculate conception and assumption into dogmas (vs leaving them as non-mandatory for belief teachings)?…
Questions Covered:09:42 – I have an adult family member who is developing mental health issues and I’m noticing a lot of overlap with addiction and compulsion. How would CIR be able to help?14:43 – I have an addiction to hoarding and still struggle. What advice do you have for me?19:06 – How do I find a good Catholic sponsor?24:17 – I’ve been addicted to heroin for many years and have been praying for Jesus to take this addiction away. Have you heard of any stories where people are healed from it?32:27 – Through God, Mass and prayer I am 11 months sober from pornography.41:45 – How does mental health and recovery relate to mortal sin? How much is in and out of our control?46:09 – Do you have resources for families of adult children who struggle from addiction?51:05 – Can someone have a drink and still say that they have been sober for 5 years?…
Questions Covered:04:45 – How could one in the Church still believe in the claim of authority in light of all the controversy?15:13 – My co-worker says he is spiritual and believes in the pineal gland and its supernatural effect. Do you know anything about this?18:29 – How should Catholics navigate modern dating?25:12 – Would you be willing to do a dialogue with Gavin Ortlund especially after all your videos?36:55 – Was Paul an apostle?43:12 – How do we reconcile No Salvation outside the Church and those ignorant of Christ possibly having salvation?49:52 – My protestant admits the Early Church was Catholic but how do I convince her of apostolic succession and why it still matters today?…
Questions Covered:01:48 – How can I trust that the whole of tradition is divine revelation rather than a false doctrine of human beings?12:00 – What about people who feel so close to God, what about their authority?18:51 – What’s the relationship between James and Peter and the authority of the two?24:20 – If I didn’t go to Church on Sunday and wanted to watch football, then if I die, would I go to hell?33:57 – I’m a catechist. What are the dogmas of the Church? Is there a definitive list?40:07 – I don’t know what kind of Christian I am. Can you help me to clarify where I stand?47:15 – In Matthew Jesus rebukes the Pharisees and tells his people to listen to them. Why did you use that story as evidence to follow authority?52:42 – What would be the main way to bring a friend to Catholicism who is interested in Orthodoxy?…
Questions Covered:05:08 – Is it accurate to put scripture and tradition in the same level of authority?08:49 – Why should we believe the magisterium over a Protestant pastor?20:11 – What gives priests and bishops authority to consecrate the Eucharist?29:31 – How does a Catholic reconcile 1 John 2:27 and the authority of the magisterium?36:40 – What’s the difference between big “T” traditions and small “t” traditions?43:52 – How do we show that from authority that apostasy is not the only mortal sin but also includes the breaking of the 10 commandments?51:28 – Why does the Church give authority to the Protoevangelium of James?…
Questions Covered:02:56 – If a person goes missing and is presumed dead. What would happen if the spouse remarried?10:10 – I need direction on presidential candidates on the issues of abortion and immigration. What’s your advice?10:10 – I need direction on presidential candidates on the issues of abortion and immigration. What’s your advice?19:30 – Could you explain the canonical delict of heresy and notoriety in fact?28:39 – I bought a rosary at the Vatican gift shop but the center metal had a skull and crossbones instead of a Marian medal. What should I make of this?32:26 – Can you clarify on Mary remaining a virgin and the meaning of until in the phrase, she remained a virgin until…37:36 – Can you explain how Pope Benedict can potentially agree with Sola Fide?44:06 – At mass, a priest encouraged everyone to receive communion and to approach confession afterwards if they needed. Is this okay to do?46:30 – I was denied absolution, but then another priest gave it to me. Am I absolved?48:47 – Can we still hold to traditional understanding purgatory?51:39 – Jesus mentions he is one with the father and mentions all he knows is through the father but claims to not know the end times. Why is that?…
Questions Covered:25:15 – Is the song, Mary Did You Know, biblically accurate?35:25 – What does it mean to be consecrated to Mary? How do you do it and why is it important?43:44 – what are the Greek words when talking about Mary having other children?48:52 – Are we human race a type of Mary that’s looking for Jesus? …
Questions Covered: 00:52 – The recent ruling regarding Medjugorje 05:09 – Why isn’t the Bible written in such a way that there isn’t wiggle room on moral topics? 13:07 – Can you explain the difference of the Greek and Aramaic word for “my Church” in Matthew 16:18? 19:42 – How can I respond to the Pope’s comments in Singapore that all religions lead to God? 23:49 – How can I effectively Catechize my daughters without over complicating the faith? 30:26 – How late can you be to a Sunday Mass for it to be considered valid attendance? 33:55 – Do we get to meet our Guardian Angels in heaven? 35:42 – Why does a marriage need to be consummate in the Catholic church? 40:13 – How do we reconcile our free will with God’s omniscience? 43:14 – If Jesus and Mary’s bodies are in heaven, would other symbiotic organisms be with them? 49:40 – Can divorced Catholics be allowed to receive Holy Communion? …
Questions Covered: 05:11 – Is it possible to do a group Reconciliation or is the individual way the best practice? 13:36 – Was the early Eucharist psychedelic? 18:25 – How can we verify the claims of the Papacy without falling on a dogmatic assertion? 29:03 – The Catholic Church killed William Tyndale for translating the Bible into English because they didn’t want anyone to have it. 31:39 – What is the difference between social and classical Trinitarianism? 34:03 – What can laity do for wayward souls? 45:58 – Can girls be altar servers? 49:41 – Can Saul pursuing David be viewed as a prefiguration to Saul, in the New Testament, persecuting Christians? 51:20 – Do you think action figures can be considered the modern-day idols referenced in Revelations 9:20? …
Questions Covered:02:37 – If God doesn’t hold people accountable for their ignorance, why should we evangelize? 08:19 – My husband had his first marriage annulled before marrying me. His father has told me that I’m “Carrying his [my husband’s] cross [first marriage].” Is he right? 17:25 – What is the message of Our Lady of La Salette? 20:24 – What is the standing of the gospel of the birth of Mary in the Catholic Church? Can it be read devotionally? 23:46 – Is grace better defined as “an empowering of our free will to do that which we think is good” rather than “obliging us to do good?” 32:00 – How is the next pope going to be chosen? 41:33 – Would my wife and I occupy the same place in heaven since we were so close in this life? 48:23 – How do you reconcile Jesus’ commands to love our enemies and turn the other cheek with him saying he came not to bring peace but division? 52:30 – What’s the difference Roman and Palmerian Catholics? …
Questions Covered:03:17 – Did the council of Jamnia exist? And if so, what came out of it? 07:45 – A Protestant told me we break the sabbath commandment in Exodus because we worship on Sunday instead of Saturday. How do I respond to that? 28:36 – Since Padre Pio’s stigmata allegedly disappeared as he died, could someone use that to argue that the saints’ intercessory abilities are diminished after they die? 34:47 – If someone commits a mortal sin, repents, but hasn’t gone to confession yet, what is the current state of their soul? 44:38 – What did Jesus mean by “Let the dead bury their dead”? 51:57 – Why are relics of the saints allowed to be distributed?…
Questions Covered:19:33 – I grew up Lutheran and just converted. I want to share why Mary was important to us. Also, how does one go about consecrating?25:17 – How do I cultivate a relationship with Mary if it seems one sided only?37:42 – I bought 33 days for morning glory and never went through with it. Is it best to do a consecration on specific dates?47:04 – People ask why get consecrated and I ask why not get consecrated!53:08 – How do I approach Marian Consecration with my grown children who are no longer Catholic?…
Questions Covered:06:15 – Do animals go to heaven?22:00 – What are the rules on mixed marriages in Catholicism?31:41 – Why is it wrong for parishioners to wear hats in Church even for medical reasons?28:45 – What’s the Church’s response to the excessive self-flagellation especially in Latin America?36:40 – How do we justify Mary being the Queen of all Christians?41:55 – are there any spiritual ramifications to seeking medical attention from a Shriners hospital?44:27 – Christ heals a man with mud he made with spit. And he had to do it twice for the person to be fully healed. Why was that detail included?47:43 – My Baptist parents want me to be on birth control. Do I disobey them or go against the Church?49:22 – Why aren’t the other 4 archangels in our canon anymore? Why aren’t they named?…
Questions Covered:04:32 – What does the Church say about married who are on the way to converting and should they abstain from relations?15:23 – My protestant friend believes that sexual relations make 2 people one flesh and equal spiritual ties. What is the Church’s role in annulment and divorces?22:15 – I’m a convert. How do I address the lady on Rev 12 and my protestant friend who claim she is Israel?31:48 – Does the Church teach we can be perfectly sinless on this side of heaven?37:44 – How do we reconcile God being all good if he created the devil knowing he would end up evil or Adam and Eve falling?45:08 – How does the Church know which saints have bodies in Revelation?…
Questions Covered:05:48 – How does one rightly critique Marian devotion?24:41 – Does the account of the Ethiopian eunuch disprove apostolic succession?33:31 – Does Mary need a savior?40:31 – How am I supposed to properly understand the title of Queen of Heaven in light of Jer. 7:17-18?47:12 – Has anyone ever looked into what heaven is and the details?…
Questions Covered:01:12 – Did fetal microchimerism have a part to play in Mary’s assumption?06:10 – There is a practice where people fast during lent from one thing (food, vice.) Some people say that when you pray Sunday evening prayer 1 on Saturday, it is now Sunday where you feast and you don’t have to fast from your Lenten fast anymore. Is this a sound practice or should one only stop their Lenten fast on Sunday?09:55 – Is it true that the ends never justify the means? It seems that this belief would prohibit things like war. A popular moral question is; If the nazis asked you where a Jewish family is hiding, isn’t it best to lie? How else can you respond? I haven’t heard you speak on this and I’m interested in your perspective13:22 – Why do priests not get to marry? Doesn’t this lead some into sexual sin anyways when they harm children in the worst cases? God gave us a holy marriage between men and women for this purpose. Why?19:14 – If the West believes in original sin, and the Eastern Orthodox believe in ancestral sin, where does that put Eastern Catholics? I spoke with one Eastern Catholic priest who said they affirm ancestral sin, but I thought in order to be Catholic you had to believe in original sin?21:08 – Both are good, but is it better to know history or philosophy? Concerning Catholicism or life in general (your opinion).23:15 – I have a question concerning canon 285.2 of the 1983 Code of Canon Law.It states: “Clerics are to avoid those things which, although not unbecoming, are nevertheless foreign to the clerical state.”Is the law thinking of any special area here? Could you give an example of something that is totally fine to do for a layperson but not for a priest?31:09 – Do you like tooled leather?32:12 – Can you explain Vicarious Satisfaction as taught by Aquinas vs. Penal Substitutionary Atonement and is Penal Substitution the foundation for salvation by Faith Alone?36:52 – Kinda a silly question, but when Moses, Elijah, and other old testament characters “saw God,” did they see Jesus before He was sent from heaven and born unto the world through the Blessed Virgin Mary? Or did they actually see “God the Father?”40:41 – You have previously critiqued the philosophical version of the Kalam argument because you believe God is capable of actualizing a universe with an infinite past. Let’s take that for granted. It seems to me that an atheist cannot make such an appeal to support the possibility of an infinitely old universe. Therefore, could someone use the philosophical version of the Kalam as a sort of “internal critique” of the atheist worldview. One can say, “What you describe is impossible without divine omnipotence making it happen.”44:39 – To what extent is the Catholic dogma of the Assumption of Mary a potential stumbling block to reunion with Eastern Orthodox churches? I have heard that they believe something similar, called the Dormition of Mary, but I don’t know if the belief is uniform among all Eastern Orthodox churches, or if it’s exactly the same as the Assumption.47:59 – Why did God not give us a mortal sin (or Grace) detector so we can know with certitude what we did was deadly or venial or simply a vice?51:00 – What if a person had no faith all its life, just refused to believe and then gets dementia or alzheimers is there still hope for them to get to heaven52:32 – Can you please contrast the passage from Luke 1:28 where the Angel Gabriel addresses Mary with the greeting “Hail, full of grace,” with the passage from Acts 6:8 (also authored by Luke) where Stephen is described as “full of grace.”…
Questions Covered:02:59 – What are the implications of praying to a saint that may or may not have ever existed? Couldn’t this be dangerous/dubious in some way? I’m referring to saints that were probably local myths/legends. I take it you know some examples better than me since I’m a new Catholic. 06:23 – Are there other Marian beliefs beyond her Assumption and immaculate conception which the church could realistically issue as doctrines in the near future? Maybe even dogmas? 12:53 – Can Catholics play D&D?14:27 – Will there be different happiness levels in heaven? For example if ones family didn’t make would they be less happy then if someone’s family did make it?16:37 – What is “hyper papalism?”18:09 – Does the Church currently teach that coeducation (especially of adolescents) is evil and are people dissenters for preferring it?21:47 – The “lost” years of Jesus. Please.28:49 – While Jesus was incarnate, how was he the creator of his contemporaries? (I’m cath., just looking to understand better).31:21 – What does Mary’s assumption mean in context of resurrection? Why are some biblical figures resurrected and others are assumed to heaven (like the prophet Elijah), and what can we expect? I know that’s more than one question, but I also know you’ll come up with a succinct answer33:53 – The topic of bulimia, anorexia, if eating disorders are sinful or not, are they signs of demonic oppression? How can one overcome them with the means of which the Church provides? Daily Mass isn’t possible unfortunately36:37 – In Matthew 12, 1-8 Jesus is referring to a story from 1 Sam 21, 2-7. My question is, why is He talking about David and his companions (verse 3) eating the bread, when David was alone there talking with Achimelek? The young men David is talking about are not there with him, so they did not eat the bread with David. It seems that Jesus is wrong about the story He is referring to. I’d appreciate an answer to this, thanks for your work Jimmy41:52 – How do I respond to a seventh day Adventist asking, If the soul survives beyond death, then why do you need Mary to be bodily assumed? I don’t know if I should approach this the same way I would approach this with any protestant or if I should deal with soul sleep and then use the same argument. Thank you God bless.50:50 – I’ve been thinking about patron saints and would like to identify some for those suffering with schizophrenia and/or bipolar disorder. St. Dymphna is a good start, but are there any others?52:14 – Doctrinal development in general… This is a core issue with my family members not accepting the Church. They will admit the Marian dogmas may be true, and don’t in principle reject them. They just can’t see why we should be compelled to accept them as “De Fide”.…
Questions Covered:03:31 – How would you respond to Dr. James Madden’s objections to near death experiences?12:15 – If I get to heaven, is Andrew the name he will call me by or will he have another name for me?16:11 – How many pipes does Jimmy have?17:25 – I’m a revert. How would I feel in heaven if a loved one wasn’t there?20:42 – Do some textual variants within the New Testament be due to variants from different manuscripts?23:41 – When will you go on a speaking tour and will you come to Mississippi?28:54 – How do I respond to someone who says the keys in Mt 16 cannot be the singular key of authority mentioned in Rev 3 and Is 22?33:55 – Do we have free will in heaven?41:29 – Does the Church have a definitive teaching on what the sensory experience of purgatory will be like?48:55 – I was baptized in a non-denominational church and am in OCIA. Where would I be salvation-wise right now if I were to die since I haven’t received any confession?53:20 – Were all the 95 Theses of Martin Luther wrong?…
Questions Covered:16:27 – How can I help a friend get out of a bad situation where a child is involved?19:13 – I’m contemplating divorce and need advice.22:50 – What bothers me about the church is that when someone is in a relationship with a narcissist, the Church doesn’t take into consideration the pain caused by that person. What are your thoughts on this?28:45 – My son is going through a separation due to his wife coming out as bisexual. Please pray for us. No one ever talks about the devastation that’s left behind.34:05 – Ive been married for 30 years and my wife no longer wants to be close to me and wants to separate. What’s your advice?41:51 – Is it better to stay in a marriage than to divorce? How do you deal with all the conflict and misery?46:03 – I want to share what helped my husband and I save our marriage.49:35 – I’m new to Catholicism and have been divorced 3 times. Will this preclude me from becoming Catholic or being married ever again?…
Questions Covered:03:10 – Why isn’t there an instance in the bible where a child is adopted into faith?07:52 – What is the Catholic view of Matthew 16:28? Is it an unfulfilled prophecy?14:33 – Is it sinful to work on Sunday?20:28 – Today in class they were talking about schizophrenia and my teacher asked if anyone was religious, to make a comparison between the two. I didn’t raise my hand. Did I do something wrong by not speaking up?28:52 – I just found out that one of my friends is a Freemason. Am I still allowed to associate with him?37:48 – Would a land value tax be better than an income tax in light of Catholic Social teaching on just taxation?51:00 – What does the mark of the beast mean? Are we all born with it? What was Jesus doing after the Resurrection but before the Ascension?…
Questions Covered:03:36 – Why was it necessary for Jesus to Send the Holy Spirit if it seems as though we got everything we need with Jesus and the sacraments?13:08 – How do I explain to 3rd, 4th, and 5th grader boys why they don’t wear head coverings in Church in light of 1 Cor. 11:6-7 and Act 18 where Paul shaves his head?29:22 – If the constitution is more of a Protestant document, does it conflict with anything in our Catholic faith?37:08 – What are your thoughts on the authorship and dating of Genesis?44:26 – What is the mechanism of action for the devil’s temptations on the world?…
Questions Covered:04:02 – How do we reconcile God the father being a singular entity in the Old Testament to God prior being seen as a polytheistic idea?16:37 – How long did it take to replace Judas among the twelve and how did it happen?20:54 – Could you explain some of the contents of the Gospel of Thomas and why it’s not in the canon?28:52 – Why doesn’t the office of apostle exist anymore? Why did Jesus have to be crucified?41:54 – I dread being asked the following question: How can we defend the teaching of the Church when there are some situations where our own leadership refuse to defend it and sometimes even want to change the truth? How would you respond?46:31 – When I picked my confirmation name, I chose it after a secular person. Can I pick a specific saint now with that same name?49:24 – How do you explain Pope Francis’ comments with a sort of communion with Muslims and worshiping the same God?…
Questions Covered:04:37 – If Adam and Eve did not possess the beatific vision but the saints now do, was it better for humans to fall?07:34 – I’m ethnically Jewish and looking to convert. What’s the history of antisemitism within the Church and how prevalent is it within the Church today?18:15 – How would you answer the objection: Jn 8 has been shown to be a later addition using historical critical methods, but the Council of Trent claims they are true and infallible. This would make the claim untrue.24:08 – Was Jesus joyful?34:03 – Is it possible, theologically, for there to be a fourth person in God?37:54 – I’m Protestant. Is the bible a living translation that the holy spirit guides you when you read it? If so, why do we need the Church?46:28 – Did some of Jesus’ apostles doubt his resurrection?…
Questions Covered:03:41 – What happens to tribes that are not exposed to Christianity?18:36 – I’m a sponsor for a friend in RCIA. He has been donating to a Shriners hospital in honor of his friend. Is this a problem for him as he discerns the faith?28:46 – What mechanism do you have to rationalize today being right compared to the Church being wrong in the past on topics like Geocentrism?36:39 – Why does Mark’s gospel not mention Mary’s presence at the crucifixion?45:04 – Why does Jesus have to announce our sins in the final judgment? Does purgatory exist after the final judgment?…
Questions Covered:06:15 – Is it a good idea to use Acts 9:40 as proof for intercession with the saints?13:40 – What’s the difference between, Redemption, salvation and justification?25:14 – What is the state of a person commits a mortal sin, repents, dies but never had a chance to make it to confession?32:11 – How do respond to the claim that since the Rothchilds family donated to the Vatican they have control over it?35:59 – Why did they put baptism ahead of the wedding feast in the luminous mysteries?51:15 – What does it mean to be out of God’s grace and that we can’t merit anything for ourselves?…
Questions Covered:01:58 – Did Job commit blasphemy?05:09 – How much do the errors of people copying the bible affect the inerrancy of scripture?11:55 – John 6 What’s the proof that what he is saying is not just symbolic?21:07 – Rev refers to the mark of the beast. Is there a correlation to the mark of the beast and the upcoming digital dollar? Are we living in the age described in Revelation?36:54 – What is the Church’s position on God writing the law on the hearts of man? Was that just exclusive to the Old Testament?42:51 – Was creation a literal 6 days?46:41 – When did God reveal his name to mankind?53:31 – How did Mary know he could perform a miracle at the wedding at Cana if this was his first miracle?…
Questions Covered:04:01 – Did Jesus write five books that were not included in the canon?08:50 – How do we make sense of 2 Sam 21? David avenging the Gibeonites.15:53 – How do we interpret Matthew 5:20?24:12 – In 1 Thessalonians 5:23 Paul mentions body, soul and spirit. What’s the difference between body, soul and spirit? Is one more important than the others?30:55 – The bible says believe and be baptized. Is the intention of baptism important to the validity of the baptism? Does the pastor baptizing have to intend salvation?35:35 – Is Judas betraying Christ correlated to receiving Jesus in grave sin?41:12 – Is the story of the Witch of Endor in 1 Sam evidence that those in the afterlife can hear us, leading to evidence for the intercession of the saints?49:37 – It’s really weird that Mary Magdalene washed Jesus’ feet with hair. Would it have been considered weird back then too?…
Questions Covered: 02:04 – Does priestly celibacy fall into the category of binding traditions that are not necessary? 08:24 – Where in the bible does it say we can pray to the saints in heaven? 15:40 – Did God create us to be sinful in light of Paul’s struggle with “the flesh”? 20:11 – I wasn’t raised religious and am looking into Catholicism. How do I reconcile my differences with the teachings of the pope if I want to become Catholic? 28:36 – What will be the outcome of the Synod on Synodality? 30:53 – How do I respond to my friends who believe 1 Peter 3:21 refers to Baptism of the spirit and not Baptism by water? 34:45 – Why can’t people break the law of physics when demons can? 41:20 – Why do some Catholic Universities have same-sex student unions or groups? 45:10 – Can you clarify the reference to Mary’s other children? 48:06 – Is the Sacrament of Baptism impacted if the parents are not Catholic, but influenced by extended Catholic family? 51:08 – Does Romans 4 teach that we are guaranteed Salvation? …
Questions Covered:03:52 – Is it acceptable to consume media from artists involved in the occult and artists who impact people in a negative way? 11:02 – 1 Cor 3:10-15 referencing purgatory or the final judgment? 15:32 – Is watching football wrong? 21:08 – What is your opinion on the connection between Colossians 2 and Ephesians 2? What does faith mean? 29:28 – Richard Dawkins makes a comparison between transgenderism and transubstantiation. What’s your rebuttal? 37:47 – How can I start a bible study? 44:09 – What Catholic traditions are not in the bible? 50:17 – When a Jehovah’s Witness asks why we pray to dead people, should I say? …
Questions Covered:12:55 – How is it that we can call Mary, our life, our sweetness and our hope in the Hail Holy Queen?18:38 – As a Latin rite Catholic attending a Byzantine church. Should I follow the customs of the west or of the east when it comes to my children receiving the sacraments?20:05 – Could there be other creation aside from angelic beings that have knowledge and reason?32:32 – When the teaching on infallibility was declared during Vatican 1, they sighted hundreds of instances of infallibility being used. Now we hear that infallibility has only been used twice. Why is there a discrepancy?40:30 – What platform should you vote for if one supports the death penalty and the other supports abortion?51:18 – Is it a sin of omission if someone passed away and I never offered masses for them if I knew they did something wrong?…
Questions Covered:02:47 – Is it licit for the laity to assume the orans posture during the Our Father in Mass?12:40 – I’m a catechumen. Why does the Church sprinkle instead of submerge for baptism?22:52 – My Baptist friend taunts me saying ‘nailed it’ referring to Luther and the 95 Thesis. What would be a good reply to this snarky remark?31:51 – How do I communicate to people my age (college age) that euthanasia is wrong?44:07 – Would it be out of line to say that Protestantism is meant to be a direct insult to God?…
Questions Covered:02:20 – What is the Catholic stance of Miaphysitism?07:49 – If Mary is the new Ark of the Covenant, could we correlate the story of someone touching the old ark and dying to Joseph potentially touching Mary to him potentially dying?16:46 – Would it be correct to say that the second person of the Trinity had a human nature since the beginning since God is outside of time?22:08 – My brother is into Krishna and reading a lot about it. Where can I start on engaging him?29:52 – Can you recommend a good Catholic audio bible?32:07 – Who authorized the removal of books in the bible?35:33 – Are dating show marriages grounds for annulment?42:36 – What is being baptized in the Holy Spirit?45:19 – How can Satan be in God’s presence in the story of Job if no unclean thing can be in God’s presence?…
Questions Covered:08:35 – How do I start a conversation with a member of the satanic temple? Their biggest hang up is the problem of evil16:20 – Are American Catholics deserting Israel?24:05 – Why is the Catholic God ok with ritualistic cannibalism? How did the miracle of Lanciano go from bread to flesh?36:10 – Wasn’t Papal infallibility a 19th century invention? If so, can you really backdate it 2,000 years?42:58 – How do I get off a double minded mindset? I’m tired of church hopping.47:01 – How available is contemplation for lay people?…
Questions Covered:04:04 – Is masturbation a mortal sin that would at least allow you to go to purgatory?14:37 – What are the rules for non-Catholics to get to heaven?19:52 – Why does the Church normally issue communion in one kind?24:21 – I’m Catholic and married. If I feel called to be a priest, would it be morally wrong to become an Anglican priest in order to try to become a Catholic priest?29:06 – How is NFP not contraception?35:29 – I don’t think first class relics should be distributed. The body of saints should be kept together.42:25 – In the Divine Mercy it says we offer the body of Jesus. How is it we can offer the body of Jesus to God?49:38 – Can you help me better understand the Catholic teaching on justification and how it differs from the protestant understanding?…
Questions Covered:05:30 – Why are marriages a Catholic sacrament?14:32 – Do you have any empirical evidence that Catholicism is true?29:44 – How can there no longer be public revelation but we still accept private revelation?36:02 – How come the Church can reject their own baptism if they were done wrong but can accept protestant baptisms on a whim?47:53 – Why should we call priests father if the bible specifically says not to call a man father?51:31 – I’m a catechist. Why does the Church not follow Lev. 19:28 and when it comes to tattoos?…
Questions Covered:03:35 – Is there a restricted number of religious orders that can be formed? What do the initials mean after the names of religious? 13:03 – In the book of Acts Paul confronts Peter regarding Peter’s refusal to eat with gentile believers. If the Pope makes a similar error today, who confronts him and how is it done? 31:42 – What kind of initiatives do we need a bishop’s permission for? 41:19 – Mark 9:29 says these kind are driven out by prayer and fasting. I have heard that the “and fasting” part is a scribal entry. How can we know that Jesus actually said this? 47:19 – What prayer do you say, or any prayer when you see crosses on the side of the highway 48:53 – Are there spiritual dangers of apologetics? If so, what are they? 50:44 – Hi this is Jeff from Huntingdon, TN. We know that God does not judge a person that is mentally unstable the same as others. What about people that have personalities, environmental situations and inclinations that could be considered almost impossible to overcome, even with a lifetime of praying for those traits to end? Will they be judged the same at the end of their life? …
Questions Covered:08:02 – How come Peter never wrote any gospels? Were the 4 who did write the gospels considered superior over the others? 13:42 – Did the power that Pharoah have in the story of the Exodus come from demons? 17:22 – I have recently had long-time, life-long, cradle Catholics tell me that there is not much of a difference between being a Catholic and being Lutheran. One of them, in particular, is actively exploring his options to leave the Catholic Church to join the Lutheran Church. What are the most compelling things that you would share with Catholics like this to encourage them to stay in the Catholic Church? 24:38 – What is the Catholic Church’s belief about whether the Blessed Mother physically “delivered” Jesus as in “labor and delivery?” Is it the Church’s belief that since she is ever-virgin that she did not go through birth in the same way as all women? How does this relate to Revelations Chapter 12 verse 2? 31:30 – How does the idea of God being “pure act” square with the fact that God chose to do certain things and not other things? 37:27 – When I go to Confession and I say “”I am sorry for these and all the sins of my past life””, and I am absolved by the priest, why would I need to go to Purgatory. Aren’t all my sins forgiven? 44:03 – The Apostles’ Creed has a line saying that Jesus “descended into hell.” Please explain this, since that is the last place he should be! 49:37 – Did the Old Testament period realize God was a trinity? …
Questions Covered:13:24 – How does the Church see its role in the current situation in Israel?…
Questions Covered:15:33 – Is Kekulé’s dream that led to the discovery of the benzene molecule just scientific apocrypha?22:48 – Do you see intelligent design as an actual theory to supplement Darwinian evolution?32:28 – What do you think of the comments of Max Plank saying that everything postulates consciousness?32:28 – What do you think of the comments of Max Plank saying that everything postulates consciousness?42:27- What knowledge do you have on the timing of conception?46:48 – Particle collider in Switzerland. What are your thoughts on the research that is taking place there?…
Questions Covered:02:07 – Can you clarify why Christians from other denominations can’t receive communion with each other?08:30 – Are all angels boys or girls like humans?13:31 – If Mark was Peter’s interpreter, why did Peter need an interpreter?19:58 – Is it possible for a husband to lust after his wife and it becomes a sin?28:46 – Could you expound on Psalm 34:18 and Psalm 23 in light of personal sufferings?32:25 – What am I allowed to do in prayer with non-Catholics?36:22 – You have said that magisterial teaching can fall into disuse. Can you back up your claim and explain?43:34 – I have seven children and my wife almost died during the last pregnancy. NFP is a way of life now. Is this wrong and would this require us to abstain from intimacy?49:53 – I’m a Byzantine Catholic. Why isn’t there much diversity in the western rite compared to the eastern rites? …
Questions Covered:02:16 – Weird Q: Regarding the show Eureka, Can synthetic water be made and can it be blessed?12:41 – How do I deal with my parents not believing in certain teachings of the Church and can they receive communion?22:20 – What’s the Catholic alternative to penal substitution?33:20 – Who asked you to worship on Sunday? It’s not the Sabbath, it’s the day of the sun god worshipped by Rome.34:49 – How did the Dominican, Ambrosian etc. rites of the liturgy come to be?38:01 – Is it bad to drink holy water or to wash your face with it?42:47 – How do we act as a child of God without falling into scrupulosity?47:55 – Is a priest allowed to restrict you from communion as a penance even if he gave you absolution?52:06 – Is it true that anyone you become conscious of a sin you must repent immediately or else you commit an additional sin?…
Questions Covered:06:50 – How does chastity apply to older people leading up to marriage?33:59 – With all the talk on abortion, we never get to the root cause, which is a lack of chastity. Why don’t we hear more about this?42:26 – Is there any way to reintroduce chastity to this generation of kids?44:50 – I practiced chastity after a failed marriage and love it now.48:36 – What kind hope can there be for chastity in the world with phones in the hands of every child?51:16 – What can we do to stop big tech censoring emergency pregnancy centers?…
Questions Covered:15:41 – How do I distinguish the theological virtue of hope and my hope to acquire a virtue I lack and my hope to get married after a recent annulment?30:57 – I think Chris is on his way to his goal of hope by his actions.37:57 – The hope of our faith and that of the world are so contradictory because our Christian hope is in heaven.45:47 – I always change the term hope to reliance and trust in God.48:24 – Some people fuse hope and faith. What is the difference between those?52:41 – What is your advice for teens to cultivate hope in a hopeless world?…
Questions Covered:00:30 – Do the members of the trinity share will and intellect and do they share a consciousness?08:55 – Is there one center of consciousness for the Trinity?13:58 – Why do people bow their heads during the mass when the name of Jesus is said?22:47 – Did Jesus withhold divine attributes when he walked the earth?41:18 – Where can we point to in the bible that that is evidence that is evidence for Mary being our mother apart from the moment of Jesus on the cross?49:10 – Scenario: A tornado is ripping through the neighborhood and there is only room for one person. You and your neighbor do rock paper scissors for the spot. What’s the morality of this?…
Questions Covered:05:49 – Should Catholics circumcise their children? Do godparents need to be confirmed to be godparents?12:01 – What do you know about the latest miraculous attributes of the image of Our Lady of Guadalupe?17:35 – When did you start putting your Christmas lights up?21:09 – What does the process of convalidating a marriage look like?28:53 – Are modern Jews no longer in a covenant with God?47:52 – What’s the best way to pray the rosary reverently?51:09 – Do the members of the trinity share will and intellect and do they share a consciousness?…
Questions Covered:12:55 – My 3 adult children are nowhere close to marriage. What can I as a parent do to help them?20:10 – If a potential spouse wants to use artificial contraception, how should one proceed?38:44 – How does one navigate local traditions and the traditions of the Church leading up to marriage. In my culture the parents blessing is important, and my parents do not believe I’m ready yet?49:20 – I think it’s more complicated for kids now especially due to dating post pandemic.53:19 – I disagree with your comment on older individuals’ difficulty entering a vocation due to being set in their ways.…
Questions Covered:13:31 – Regarding Rev 12. How do I respond to a JW that the woman in Rev 12 is not Mary but the Kingdom God? How do we properly interpret it?19:56 – Can we view the papal authority the same as we would see a person who wrote a book of the bible? A sinner but with authority?30:35 – If a protestant asks us how we know that we are interpreting the teaching of our infallible Church, how do we respond?37:41 – How do we explain that Jesus gave authority to his apostles to forgive sins in John 20:22-23?44:10 – Is the teaching on Mary’s perpetual virginity based on the bible or is it just a tradition?50:35 – Is there any strategy we could use to implement the scripture when talking to atheists?…
Questions Covered:05:30 – I’m protestant. What did the Church Fathers believe about Mary’s assumption?11:31 – Why is the Church not receptive to canton marriages?15:53 – How would you respond with my reason for not returning to the Church? I won’t return because of how the priest sex scandal was handled.21:18 – Why do we have to go right up to the borderline of worshiping the saints?33:08 – What’s the logic on assigning day to indulgences?38:35 – Is there salvation outside the visible Church?47:57 – Is the Protestant bible missing any book from the canon?52:54 – I heard your story on the Journey Home. Could you repeat the story of your mother.…
Questions Covered:06:41 – Why did only Mary need to be conceived without sin?12:34 – Why are people hating on Mary and the Medjugorje apparitions, especially with so many conversions?17:05 – Why does the woman in Revelation 12 have a dual interpretation as being Mary and Israel?20:46 – What is your opinion of Our Lady of Lourdes and what is the Church’s official teaching?24:09 – Did Mary live out her natural life before her Assumption?32:42 – How is it that some protestants deny Mary’s assumption but accept a pre-tribulation rapture?35:47 – How does one reject the Immaculate Conception if God dispense grace according to his will and purpose before time eternal as said in 2 Tim 1:9?38:12 – My wife is considering Catholicism. She wants to know where in the bible it says to pray to Mary?43:31 How do you respond to the claim that the bodily assumption and that Mary is mother of the Church were inventions by the Catholic Church?47:12 – Regarding the Song Mary Did You Know. How much did Mary know and how did she know?51:05 – My Protestant husband can’t understand how Mary can be the mother of God?…
Questions Covered:01:16 – It sounds like they are worshiping Judith in Judith 15:9-10. How do I understand this verse?05:04 – Regarding Daily Defense Day 70. I disagree that abortion is not a religious issue. Abortion violates the commandments.11:28 – Is there a teaching on what our age would be in the next life?16:18 – Are you familiar with the criticism that the bible doesn’t have a basis for the immortality of the soul? If the soul is not immortal would this erase the need for hell?29:04 – How do we explain animal death before the fall?35:20 – Does the Church have an official stance on Medjugorje?42:07 – Since the Church expanded the understanding of salvation outside of the boundaries of the physical Church, would a person in those times who believed our current interpretation, be in good standing?49:36 – When the pope does an action, is he saying ‘this is good, do this.’ For example, Pope John Paul II kissing the Quran.52:53 – Why are masons not allowed to be Catholic but other organization members like Alcoholics Anonymous can?…
Questions Covered:03:50 – Why do we believe that we have free will if God already knows what we’re destined for?09:23 – If listening to music that’s offensive to God is sitting on your heart, you should listen to that and stop.13:45 – Revelation says the Lord will rule with an iron rod. What does this mean? Will this be a ‘dictatorial peace?’17:12 – Regarding divorce and Jesus’ comments in Mt. 5:31-32. What would justify divorce?29:40 – Is it licit for Catholics to receive donated body parts and materials from deceased people?33:29 – Are we supposed to bury an urn with ashes after a certain period of time? Can we keep the remains on a shelf?37:51 – Why do Catholics believe in guardian angels? What do you think they do?41:56 – How do you respond when a Protestant uses the Church Fathers to defend their position?47:27 – Is there distinction between venial and mortal sins in the bible?52:09 – Why does the Church teach that there are no more prophets after the apostolic age?…
Questions Covered:05:50 – Are indulgences real?17:35 – Why wasn’t Moses allowed to go into the promised land?22:07 – Could you explain plenary indulgences and the history of people paying for them?29:12 – If someone goes to confession and does their penance, they still have to go through a purgation. Is this true?33:43 – Can one listen to music where the singer uses the Lord’s name in vain?41:05 – How does the Church reconcile the preferential option for the poor when poverty arises due to one of the 7 deadly sins?49:04 – In the Creed it mentions the resurrection of the body. Why is this important and why can’t we just leave the body behind?…
Questions Covered:01:22 – My neighbor keeps pushing onto my property. How do I approach the situation in light of Mt. 5:39?08:11 – My father says that Acts 2. Is evidence that the apostles were saved devoid of water baptism. How do I respond?17:00 – How do I explain the papacy to my protestant friend?23:40 – Follow up on baptism. In the OT Noah was saved through water. Do you believe that from the beginning water was used for salvation?29:01 – Is it permissible to think that purgatory will begin when we see Jesus on the judgment throne?34:59 – How do we know whether a Pentecostal’s beliefs are biblical?43:25 – Why don’t we allude to Luke 12:42 in regard to Peter being the leader of the Church?51:19 – Regarding No Salvation Outside the Catholic Church. Does this mean that all protestants are going to hell?…
Questions Covered:04:08 – Is Mary the virgin daughter of Zion since Jeremiah speaks negatively about the virgin daughter of Zion?12:00 – In Exodus it says that God hardened the pharaoh’s heart. What does that mean?17:13 – Did Jesus have a sense of humor?21:34 – If Jesus and Mary are the new Adam and Eve, why are the mother and son and not husband and wife?29:40 – How were disagreements in the Early Church settled?36:38 – How does it all fit together that the bread and wine are now Jesus but the last supper was with lamb? How do we logically all make this fit together? Where’s the lamb?42:50 – Where does the Church get the knowledge of who the parents of Mary are?46:08 – How do I respond to a protestant that says we shouldn’t consider the wine as blood because the Old Testament says we shouldn’t drink blood?49:07 – Why is it that the gift of peace is located in the middle of mass?53:18 – My protestant girlfriend says 1 Cor. 4:6 proved Sola Scriptura. How do I respond?…
Questions Covered:05:07 – What proof do we have that the Catholic Church was founded by Christ?11:01 – What is the historical evidence for the assumption of Mary?15:08 – If God is the Trinity and has no gender, can we pray to God in a genderless way?19:14 – If you can steal food to survive, then why can you lie to survive?29:04 – How are Mary and Elizabeth related?33:00 – Are the strict words of absolution necessary for a confession to be valid?36:12 – What intentions from the priest would make the Eucharist validly consecrated?41:35 – Where do you draw the line between discipline and mercy?46:15 – I’m in high school looking into Catholic colleges. How do I find a faithful Catholic school?…
Questions Covered:17:50 – What can I do to keep my focus off of being spiritually attacked while I continue to learn more about the Catholic faith?21:09 – What is recommended for a lay person to pray for spiritual warfare? Which prayers are forbidden?31:19 – Have you seen cases of spiritual warfare where the situation was resolved due to baptism?36:31 – I tend to experience panic attacks and irrational anger when I leave adoration. Is this spiritual warfare?45:26 – Can the devil reach you in your dream?46:17 – Are we allowed to keep relics?47:32 – I was baptized three times. Is it possible that a demon entered into my life due to being baptized so many times? Can disease be a result of being attacked spiritually?…
Questions Covered:02:35 – Why can’t adults who are unconscious be baptized due to not being able to give consent but babies can be baptized? 09:04 – Can you clarify if God is limited on performing miracles based on the person’s belief? 15:06 – My protestant father says baptism isn’t important because Acts 1 says that John baptized with water but baptism with the spirit is what’s important. How do I respond? 18:58 – How do you respond to the claim that baptism is a work? 23:12 – What do we experience if we are in heaven and we see a family member on earth suffering? 25:15 – What does it mean to have “full knowledge” of a mortal sin? 35:23 – Why do we ask people to pray for us or for saints’ intercession when the Bible tells us that we’ll receive whatever we ask for in faith? 42:20 – If Catholics are permitted to believe in evolution, is it a weaker version of evolution? How does it work with salvation? 47:44 – Is it possible to receive one person of the Trinity in baptism and not receive the others? 50:13 – My 7th Day Adventist neighbor brought up soul sleep and annihilationism. How do I respond to those topics? …
Questions Covered:04:10 – What’s the best way for me to talk to my Protestant family members?15:00 – At the general judgment, will those who are already in hell be present?29:05 – At Mass, why does the priest bless one host, but then the people receive ones from the tabernacle?35:42 – Why do we need the presence of Jesus in the Eucharist when he said he would send us the Holy Spirit?45:04 – Is there a connection between Karlo’s book The New Relativism and C.S. Lewis’ The Abolition of Man?47:27 – Am I understanding this correctly about the final judgment? I think one reason we won’t be embarrassed about all of our sins being known is because we’ll know that everyone else is perfected in love and has forgiven us.51:03 – Can you clarify to me whether the sacraments are works?…
Questions Covered:02:39 – What exactly is the power of binding and loosing?19:35 – Since the Church runs like a monarchy, what is the Church’s stance on monarchies?29:25 – Can a parent bless their child’s dorm room?36:29 – How often does one need to take communion?44:58 – I’m not Catholic. I’m a part of a new Church and my pastor said he received a sign to start a church. How does a Catholic explain this?…
Questions Covered:03:30 – What would make someone a heretic?06:56 – How can we defend the claim that we are not worshiping icons?15:02 – Could you explain What is means not to judge intent and motivation?20:09 – Is it a sin to have suicidal thoughts?30:11 – Regarding the woman caught in sin, how would I anticipate a response from a protestant who argues faith alone?36:05 – Luke 12:1-8 I don’t understand why they use the example of buying sparrows. What did they use sparrows for?41:40 – What is the meaning of Acts 2:38 and how does it align with the Church’s teaching on baptism?45:49 – What’s the legitimacy for using intellectual arguments to come back to the faith?50:44 – How can I better explain the need for confession before communion? Did Judas receive communion?…
Questions Covered:02:39 – Do you think pointing out human’s infinite value is a good response to the problem of animal suffering?07:53 – Doesn’t everyone already have reproductive rights? How do you make clear to people that those words are just a euphemism for killing?12:27 – How do indulgences play into our time in purgatory?18:45 – How does the teaching of elective suffering benefit us and our participation in Christ’ suffering?25:10 – Were some events in the book of Joshua meant to be taken literally?34:30 – How do I re-confess my sins that I possibly overestimated?37:07 – My 3-year-old is confused when we say Jesus is present at mass, but he doesn’t see a person. How do I explain it to him?42:24 – There’s so much confusion on how to receive communion and I don’t want to be culpable when I meet Jesus face to face.49:23 – My parents were born pre-Vatican 2 and told me that Luther was one of the most evil men to ever exist. What are your thoughts on that?52:17 – What are the daily responsibilities of the camerlengo? How does their role change when the pope dies?…
Questions Covered:04:47 – What’s the best way to argue against assisted suicide?17:36 – I have a friend who believes in God but doesn’t think he is a good God. How do I go about changing my friend’s mind?29:30 – Mass is the biggest waste of time. Repent and believe the gospel.32:26 – I work in fast food and my coworkers say that they don’t think everything has to have a reason to exist. How do I respond?43:36 – How can I defend baptism being a necessity for salvation?51:07 – How did the Lutheran Church get started? Luther doesn’t seem to be connected to the Lutheran Church.…
Questions Covered:01:21 – Will the antichrist be from the tribe of Dan and Jewish as some theologians think? 02:33 – Suppose the pope called you and said: “Mr Akin! As a reward for all your good work, I’ll let you ask me a question and I’ll consult bishops, theologians, and other academics, and I’ll issue the answer we find to the highest level of authority my conscience will allow me to”, what do you ask? 04:28 – What is the oldest ghost or haunt that we know of? Any really ancient or even prehistoric ghosts? Is it in theory possible for someone to encounter the ghost of, say, a Neanderthal or ancient Sumerian? 10:34 – Would it be possible for apes today to evolve into humans in the future? If so, what would the ramifications be theologically? 16:37 – Do we take up the spiritual battle against evil after we die when we become soul/spirits? 17:44 – What would Catholic ethics have to say about the vigilante efforts of someone like Batman? OR one who has fewer rules, like Punisher. 21:05 – One is simply: what exactly is an aura headache? 23:26 – Let’s say aliens exist and they also believe in a supreme being, how can we reconcile our differences if we know that Jesus is the true God incarnate and became incarnate as a human rather than that alien? 24:35 – I always thought the Monita Secreta would be interesting to address. Love your work! 31:14 – Is the concept of a mentally dependent yet (objectively) real entity (as opposed to a hallucination or imagination) an actual logical possibility? 34:12 – Would it be moral to use a lightsaber in self-defense because it cauterizes all wounds even if it results in a limb being severed? 40:14 – What is the catholic churches stance on deja vu and/or schizophrenia? 43:58 – Can a bald man wear a (normal looking) wig in church or does that count as a hat? 46:44 – What do you think of the idea that death, rather than being a punishment, was a sort of mechanism to give man a way out of becoming eternally evil like the demons? 47:55 – You may have done a mysterious world episode about this I haven’t seen. But I’ve always wanted to know your opinions on the existence of fairies, elves, and similar beings. 49:46 – I had a weird question about NDEs. In the paper, A Systematic Survey of NDEs in South India by Satwant Pasricha, some Hindus who experience NDEs see the god Yama. Some of these are veridical in which for example a person is branded by Yama and then a mark appears in the same place that they were branded. How can we explain these reports in terms of Catholic theology? Also do these reports show that NDEs are hallucinations since these people saw what culturally they believed? Thank you, Jimmy. …
Questions Covered:03:21 – Hey Jimmy. What is your opinion about the Shrine of the Three Kings, a reliquary traditionally believed to contain the bones of the Biblical Magi. Is it possible that the first Christians knew exactly who were those three men and somehow obtained their remains.06:11 – Does quantum superposition undercut the principle of non-contradiction?12:41 – Why doesn’t the Bible talk about Mary Magdalene after the Gospels? What actually happened to her? Was she still part of the Church?16:52 – Hey Jimmy. In the world of online video games, sometimes people like to play together, but since players like to play mean and rude, there was once a funeral held for a player within World of Warcraft that was interrupted by other players that decided to attack the players attending the in-game funeral. Are we morally culpable for actions taken in virtual worlds?19:40 – This is a threefold question regarding angels: When were the angels created by God? What motivated Lucifer and other angels to rebel against God? Were they all cast down upon the earth, or do they exist in another spiritual dimension separated from God and pass back and forth between that spiritual dimension and the earth?28:36 – In the OT, it seems evident that those in Israel (and maybe in the surrounding cultures) cared more about what happened in this life than in the next. This even to the point, generally speaking, that they didn’t care what bad things happened in the world they left behind after they died, as long as they weren’t around to see it happen. An example of this is Hezekiah’s odd reaction to Isaiah’s dooming prophecy at the end of Isaiah 39. I’m also thinking of the episode when Nebuchadnezzar gouges out the eyes of Zedekiah after he kills his sons right before him, ensuring that Zedekiah does not die before he sees his progeny destroyed. It also states in the OT (in the Psalms, I believe) that “in death there is no remembrance.” Was that indicative of what they believed about the afterlife in Sheol?33:52 – Has your paranormal research led you to change your views/answers on phenomena such as Qi (“Chi”) and practices such as Qigong regarding their compatibility with Catholicism?39:47 – Is there any evidence to support the claim that Emperor Guangwu of China saw a prophecy of Jesus’s death before it happened?42:12 – If an electric-powered boat is sinking and a shark is ten feet away, should you choose electrocution or risk the shark? Also, why is nobody talking about all the shark attacks? And is it true that sharks bite women’s legs off because they are misunderstood?44:42 – What’s with all this Nephilim talk lately in the media/culture?48:20 – By time traveling to the past, what are ramifications if 1) a person prevents the crucifixion51:57 – What are ramifications of (2) talking to Jesus and informing him about his divinity and certain mysterious of the Trinity. OR alternate version, if the multiverse exist, would there be different Jesus in each timeline since there is only one God…
Questions Covered:06:58 – Why does Jesus call Mary Magdalene women, just like his mother, Mary?17:07 – I pray the St Bridget 12-year prayer. It includes prayers for sins of youth, the heart, flesh, spirit, tongue and prayers for holy arrangements. What does all that mean?35:50 – What is the clearest way to explain to Protestants that we are not saved by faith alone but also don’t believe that we work our way to heaven?47:04 – How does an election process work for a bishop? What does the pope look for?…
Questions Covered:11:23 – How do we handle Jehovah’s Witnesses at our door?20:26 – How does Tim memorize all the bible verses?32:09 – How should I perform my confession?40:35 – Did Mary have any birth pains?51:42 – What’s the Catholic perspective on the Nicholas Cage Ghost Rider movies?…
Questions Covered:05:12 – Is sloth grave matter?16:37 – Is breaking a promise to God a sin?29:47 – How can we determine a level of infallibility a particular teaching is?42:35 – What’s the strongest argument against your claim of Sola Scriptura not passing its own test?49:07 – Why does God let bad things happen to good people?…
Questions Covered:06:15 – How would Christ be able to atone for the sins of aliens if he is not able to incarnate as an alien?16:18 – Is it necessary for salvation to receive the Eucharist?23:08 – How would I respond to a protestant who claims the deuterocanonical books should not be in the bible?32:12 – Since all Catholics are of a royal priesthood, can a lay person in an extreme situation consecrate the Eucharist?37:11 – I’m an ex-Mormon. How do I discern divine revelation among Catholicism compared to Mormonism?46:17 – What do you know about the Jewish legend of the Golem?50:00 – What does CCC 677 mean?…
Questions Covered:04:51 – What would be the best approach to talk to Mormon missionaries? 13:40 – How do I argue against predestination especially when considering the fate of Judas and the Pharaoh? 22:43 – Is concupiscence a sin of desire? 31:51 – Would relocating tabernacles to the center of the sanctuary assist to re-instilling the belief in the true presence? 42:15 – Using the context of 2 Kings 13:20-21, why does God use relics? 49:48 – How do I respond to the Protestant claim that the KJV is the only authorized translation? …
Questions Covered:01:57 – Did King Saul In 1 Sam 28 speak to a demon when he sought to conjure Samuel’s spirit when he approached the witch of Endor?15:15 – Didn’t the Church require 3 miracles for a saint’s cause in the past? Can someone be called a saint if someone lived a heroic and holy life if they didn’t commit any miracles?20:03 – Are we allowed to say God bless and Mary keep you? Is that something we can trust in Mary and not God?32:18 – I showed scriptural evidence for Mary and the protestant responded by saying that I proved sola scriptura. How do I respond to that?36:07 – Does Mt.1 prove that Mary wasn’t a virgin because of the word ‘until?’43:56 – Is singing to a statue of Mary, Marian worship?48:46 – I’m not Catholic, It seems like Catholics don’t treat Marian dogmas as salvific issues. Why are they treated differently?…
Questions Covered:07:56 – Do I have to worship Mary if I become Catholic?17:45 – I’m Protestant and am engaged to a Catholic. Where do I start on Mary?30:46 – Why do some Protestants fail to see Mary as the Mother of God? Why is intercession seen as satanic?45:25 – Why is the Protoevangelium of James accepted as source for the Mariology even though it’s rejected by earlier Church sources?48:51 – My Lutheran wife can’t get on board praying to Mary and the saints. How do I help her open up to better understand this teaching?…
Questions Covered:01:00 – What evidence do we truly have for a human soul?06:36 – Can you point to evidence or the deuterocanonical books in the New Testament or the early church?14:32 – Why didn’t Psalm 151, Maccabees 3 & 4, Book of Susana make the cut?18:12 – What do the different colors of the scapular mean?22:08 – Can you disagree with the Church if you don’t promulgate it?29:10 – When did the Church start baptizing by sprinkling?42:23 – What is grace? How is it imparted?46:32 – How do we justify killing non-combatant innocent civilians in a war? How does that fit into Just War Theory?52:10 – Has everything before Rev. 20:7 have already taken place?…
Questions Covered:05:34 – Catholics believe one is divinized and protestants believe you are imputed for righteousness. However, when Pentecostals talk about sanctification, aren’t they talking more about divinization?20:52 – Why do they say Jesus is God? How do I explain it to my 30-year-old unbaptized son?30:09 – What would be a Catholic response to the protestant question, are you a good person?36:27 – Were the apostles originally considered bishops? Was Peter also considered a bishop?43:59 – If you sin now does that continually add to the suffering of Jesus on the cross?48:18 – I have a funeral mass to go to tomorrow, would that satisfy the first Friday devotion?…
Questions Covered:02:35 – Is James Sterba’s moral evil principle sound?05:31 – While Jesus was alive was he aware of his destiny and did he orchestrate the events of the New Testament?07:09 – Is it possible for demons to manipulate algorithms?14:07 – Could you explain the teaching on the couple giving each other the sacrament of marriage and not the priest. How does that compare to the Orthodox teaching?19:12 – Can you talk about Pseudo-scientific theory of ancient civilizations like Atlantis? How do we square that with Adam and Eve?23:21 – In Mark Where Jesus talks about the second coming he mentions that “this generation will not pass away before these events take place.” But that didn’t happen. Can you explain?28:45 – Is the Holy Spirit only with us when we’re persecuted?35:19 – If there is such a lack of information about Joseph in the bible, where do we get our information about him?40:44 – I know the Church is against assisted suicide. I need clarification. I’ve hard physical and mental conditions and I’m exhausted. How do I work with God in these final years?49:05 – What’s the correct defense for the existence of the priesthood? Is it a good defense to use the argument that the term comes from the word Presbiteros?…
Questions Covered:05:11 – I’ve heard that we are to reverence the altar in the Church rather than genuflect to Jesus in the tabernacle. Is that true?12:48 – How can Mary be sinless in light of Romans 3:23-24 which says all men have sinned?18:14 – Is Mary an angel of light?22:24 – My mom suggested I set a reminder to get to bed on time. I forgot and didn’t do it, and stayed up too late. Was that a violation of the 5th commandment?32:30 – It seems like we Catholics focus on just getting to Heaven rather than preaching the kingdom of God. What are some practical things we can do to build God’s kingdom?42:50 – Can you set me straight on all the James’ in the New Testament? There’s so many I can’t keep them straight. And which one wrote the book of James?48:07 – When we receive Communion, do we receive Jesus’ presence and do we become living tabernacles?50:03 – What does the Church say about the status of Medjugorje?…
Questions Covered:06:12 – CCC 841 says we worship the same God as Islam. Does that contradict Christian teaching?13:58 – If we are all part of the universal priesthood, why are there no priestesses?20:16 – In the old testament when they had the manna, they were told not to gather it, that it would be given day to day. I have concerns that we’re doing that with the Eucharist, that maybe we shouldn’t be saving it after Mass. Also, when the host is in the monstrance, when does it become the body and blood of Christ?29:48 – How can I explain the saints to my Protestant friend who doesn’t believe in saints?36:07 – My husband and I are in the process of adoption. What is the Church’s stance on embryo adoption?43:35 – It says clearly in scripture when Jesus consecrates the wine that they should receive it. So isn’t it contrary to scripture that my diocese doesn’t offer the cup during Mass?49:01 – I struggle with the granularity of the terms surrounding indulgences. I embrace wholeheartedly the concept of indulgences, but when things say “do x amount and you’ll get y days off purgatory” it just seems so transactional and rings untrue to me.…
Questions Covered:08:25 – Why was Christ’ sacrifice necessary for salvation in light of the Old Testament and the law?18:57 – Why is baptism the only sacrament that can be given by a non-clergy, or non-believer?33:09 – How do I make sense of Pope Paul VI’s change of indulgences? Are all partial indulgences equal in value?49:04 – I’m talking to a protestant and having a hard time arguing penal substitutionary atonement. Can you help clarify?…
Questions Covered:05:26 – How often should I go to confession when I’m in the state of mortal sin as an underage person who doesn’t have a license?23:00 – Why do Catholics believe in the seven sacraments for salvation, when us Christian believe in faith alone?39:47 – How can Mary exercise power of God as St. Louis de Montfort claims?…
Questions Covered:04:50 – Can you explain why Christ wasn’t baptized until he was 30?08:44 – Psalm 110 and other places mention Melchizedek. Who is he?15:32 – Can you talk about the Anglican notion of Two Swords Theology?22:14 – Can you receive other sacraments apart from baptism, by desire?31:46 – Are the saints in heaven now or are they in paradise awaiting heaven?36:18 – The Oracle Balam in Numbers refuses to curse Israel and is eventually killed but he is condemned by Israel. What do we make of him seemingly being a friend of God but being condemned for practicing witchcraft?43:46 – How do I explain to my non-Catholic friends the real presence?48:23 – In John 16:8-11 Jesus is going to the father. How do we receive righteousness from that?…
Questions Covered:05:25 – What is a Eucharistic procession? Who would I need to talk to to organize one in my town?14:00 – How does the Church look upon Aquamation as an option for burial?18:41 – What is the appropriate pronunciation of Elisha?22:20 – Why do we not believe in reincarnation? Where in the bible would we find evidence for this lack of belief?35:15 – How do I talk to an ex-Catholic Protestant about Mary?43:10 – My priest denied the necessity of baptism for salvation. How do I deal with this?48:45 – 2 Tim 3:16 I’ve heard it argued that when Catholics are confirmed they receive the HS and are “God breathed.” Is this true?…
Questions Covered:32:43 – Here in Colorado a Church is suing a town because they are told they can’t house a person in a van in the parking lot. I want Matthew’s thoughts on this.…
Questions Covered:01:01 – The bible says that if you evangelize the Holy Spirit will give you the words but why wont the Holy Spirit give you the words when talking to your children?04:16 – Romans 8:28 How does it work for the physical world today?06:58 – Should we consume the Eucharist when there is a miracle?14:48 – There seems to be a divide between the Church teaching on marriage vs what Jesus and Paul taught. Can you explain where they come together?20:34 – Where is the lineage of apostolic succession?24:20 – What ranking is St. Michael in? Do demons also have rankings?35:13 – Is the mark of the beast a future financial payment system?45:19 – Did Constantine found the Catholic Church?50:47 – Was there infallibility during the Old Testament period?…
Questions Covered:17:50 – Is it necessary to dive into childhood or is it more about exposure?22:00 – Can a moms feeling of just being overwhelmed actually be anxiety?34:26 – I’m a middle school teacher. What tips do you have for helping my students through anxiety?36:45 – I’m so filled with anxiety that I have torn up my skin and have ulcers. I need help in mitigating this experience?43:00 – How do you deal with anxiety knowing that you’ll always fall to sin?48:10 – Thought my anxiety would go away after being sober for 4.5 years. How do I deal with it now that it hasn’t gone away?51:49 – How do you deal with anxieties when you don’t realize you have anxiety until it boils over?…
Questions Covered:08:25 – How can I approach my wife about her codependency on our daughter and how unhealthy it is?15:28 – I’m an alcoholic. I just want to share my light bulb moment.18:12 – What does addiction to lust include?22:30 – I have an attachment to food. I’m nervous about attending a meeting due to confidentiality.29:45 – I am a workaholic. Does your organization offer help for that?33:10 – I want to recommend the book! Will there be another one in the future?37:05 – I think the 12-step program is for everyone.44:04 – I lost my 21 one year old son to addiction. Thank you for doing this! I wish I had known about you before.50:48 – I’ve been in 12 steps since January. I just want to share how much there is to offer.…
Questions Covered:3:45 – In the Creed it says that Jesus will judge the living and the dead. Who are the dead?08:00 – How do I talk about Jesus to people who have questions but don’t actually seem to care?13:04 – What’s the relationship between mortal sins of omission, and good works? Could you lose your salvation through a sin of omission?17:29 – Is there a process of choosing a patron saint?21:22 – Does a couple have to be married in the Church to bring up the gifts during mass?24:07 – What exactly must one say when confessing sins, how specific must one be?33:55 – What does it mean for a teaching to be essential? What considerations did the Church take to declare the Immaculate Conception and the Assumption?38:04 – Why if Joseph had a house in Bethlehem, was Jesus born in a manger?42:38 – Can you talk about the purpose of marriage? Is it strictly to procreate?47:29 – Am I able to confess a mortal sin if I was intoxicated?52:14 – Are guardian angels capable of being fallen angels? Could we have been assigned a fallen guardian angel?…
Questions Covered:08:32 – What does a vocational call mean?15:43 – How did people in the OT worship God and how is it similar to how we worship in the Catholic Mass?23:59 – What is the proper understanding of Rev 19:15?29:15 – In what way is the mass a propitiatory sacrifice?35:20 – Why isn’t there adoration for the blood of Jesus?40:42 – Why isn’t the Catholic Church against interest-based economics?46:04 – My in-laws are not Catholic and were just introduced to the stations of the cross. What’s the history of them?50:44 – I want to read the fathers of the Church. Where can I start with being led astray?…
Questions Covered:03:37 – How important is consolation during prayer in Mass?11:19 – How do you respond to the claim that If the devil can portray himself as an angel of light, then the devil can potentially be present himself as Mary in apparitions?16:49 – Does the bible support sprinkling of water in baptism?23:32 – Why don’t we quickly baptize people like protestants instead of making people go through a whole class and dragging it out?32:47 – Why does Catholic worship re-present the cross as a sacrifice when the passover wasn’t a sin offering?42:46 – Is Jesus’ prayer for unity in Jn 17 meant to be now or unity when he returns?51:05 – Critique my argument for the Immaculate Conception: If Joseph was worried about Mary committing adultery he would not have to quietly divorce her. He was protecting her because he knew the truth.…
Questions Covered:04:15 – How can I elaborate on the bread of Life discourse?19:14 – In the Hail Holy Queen, Mary is called the ‘most gracious advocate’’ How can Catholics call her that since that’s who Jesus is the gracious advocate.29:54 – I’m protestant considering Catholicism. What should I do if I believe something is morally wrong but the Church compels us to believe?41:48 – How do I respond to the claim that Baptism doesn’t save you?47:46 – How do we better understand the different I Am statements?51:59 – Can you talk about why the center for worship is different for Catholics and Protestants? One is prayer and sermon, and the other is the Eucharist.…
Questions covered:04:26 – How can God be infinite if he became man in the Incarnation?18:10 – How do you respond to someone who says the Catholic Church got its traditions from the Roman Empire?28:28 – Is my understanding of faith and works correct?36:12 – The Catholic church teaches that in ongoing justification, works justify us and are not merely a sign. How is this different from a works-based salvation?47:12 – When James 3 says teachers will be judged more harshly, does he mean judged by God or by men?51:11 – Would it be sinful to read things formerly banned by the Church, like Machiavelli?…
Questions Covered:22:27 – A relative of mine just had his spouse leave him out of nowhere. How should we guide him towards hopeful reconciliation? 30:31 – If a couple is living in a sinful divorce, goes to confession, but then goes right back to that same lifestyle, do they have to confess again before receiving communion and keep doing that over and over? 33:58 – If your spouse had a previous marriage that was never annulled, and then they go through the annulment process, do you now need to get your marriage convalidated? 35:44 – My brother married outside the Church and got a divorce. Now he’s dating a Catholic, cohabitating with her, and receiving the Eucharist. Should I say anything? 42:01 – I was civilly married, then we had our marriage convalidated in the Church. My husband was a non-Christian. Now during our divorce he’s saying he never intended to become Catholic or raise our children Catholic. Is this grounds for annulment? 45:43 – If someone’s spouse dies, does she still need to get an annulment before marrying someone else? 49:12 – I’ve had two priests say it’s okay for me to date before I’ve had an annulment. Are they correct? …
Questions Covered:01:55 – The Church Fathers have different interpretations of the unforgivable sin. How can we know the true meaning of that passage?10:50 – How do we reconcile the consecration to the Immaculate Heart with the accusations from Protestants that Catholics worship Mary?14:11 – Is it possible there were non-human civilizations on Earth before Adam and Eve?19:46 – I was surprised that Catechism 1856 names immoderate laughter and idle chatter as sins. Are they really sins?29:02 – It seems like near death experiences confirm that the soul is eternal and this life is just a passing form. Why doesn’t the Catholic Church deal with this instead of persisting with the idea of Hell to scare people into being good?40:54 – My family believes in Oneness theology. How might I convince them of the Trinity?47:24 – Can you obtain an indulgence now for someone who is not dead yet? And for getting an indulgence for 30 minutes of Eucharistic adoration, does it have to be the exposed Eucharist, or can it be in a closed tabernacle?53:17 -Are we obligated to fraternally correct others? …
Questions Covered:06:45 – Are sins you forget in confession still forgiven? 13:07 – Why are there so many Eucharistic prayers and how does a priest pick the one to use? 20:20 – We all came from Adam and Eve, why do we have so many races? 31:40 – What is the proper order of Sacraments when received as an adult? 36:00 – How can we know what the unforgivable sin is? 41:54 – How can I discuss Catholic Baptism and rebaptism with my non-Catholic Wife? 47:51 – Why do Catholics say Christ is present “body, blood, soul and divinity”? 52:14 – Is it always a Mortal Sin to miss Mass, or can you be excused based on age? …
Questions Covered:02:47 – I have a declaration of nullity but I still feel married. I feel like my husband is living with his girlfriend. Is there a prayer or something I can do to help me release this?16:11 – The Catechism of JPII states that the covenant of the Jews has not been revoked. How does that relate to the Council of Florence which declares that the matters of the old law have been revoked?41:14 – Would it have been possible for the Church to flourish without the Bible, and what do you think the Church would have looked like without the Bible? 48:41 – Is it wrong for my fiancé and I to purchase a home together before we are married?52:23 – Why does Jesus affirm the authority of the Pharisees (as in Matthew 23)?…
Questions Covered:14:38 – My partner says she can’t become Catholic because of sexism in passages such as Ephesians 5, 1 Timothy 2, and 1 Pet 3. How can I respond?29:45 – There are photos online of Adam and Eve’s grave sites — is that legit? And what do we know about what happened to Adam and Eve?41:13 – Why don’t Protestants accept the Septuagint? And when did they take it out of their Bible?…
Questions Covered: 01:36 – Why is the book of Enoch not in the Bible? 12:15 – Was Judas one of the twenty-four apostles seen by John when on the island? 18:46 – How can I approach the pursuit of knowledge in the defense of faith? 24:47 – Since Jesus knew of his Crucifixion, why did he agonize in the garden? 36:00 – How can I help a friend understand the history of the Catholic Church? 43:03 – Is it a good practice to hand out Bibles? 44:44 – There are many passages in the Bible that say miraculous thing are from the devil. How can we trust source of miracles?53:18 – In Genesis, when God condemns Cain, he is worried of being killed. How can this be since there were only 3 people? …
Questions Covered:04:27 – When were the books of Maccabee and Wisdom added to the Bible? 07:39 – In the Gospel of Mark, who does the naked man in the garden represent? 16:56 – How do I explain why Catholic pious practices differ from what is described in Baruch 6:8? 29:35 – Where would you go for verses on Trust in the Lord from the bible? 33:08 – How can I put the Old Testament in good light, specifically Leviticus, to Jewish people? 42:26 – Who is Melchizedek in the Bible? 49:34 – What is the possibility that the evidence John saw at the empty tomb was the Shroud of Turin? …
Questions covered:05:47 – How do you respond to the claim that Baptism is a work?15:44 – Can those outside communion with the church be heard by the Saints?18:58 – In 1 Cor. 15 what would Paul mean when he mentions scriptures?28:47 – My friend said the Papacy is wrong because Jesus left evangelizing the rest of the world to Paul (Gal. 2:7), not to Peter. He says the apostles were only supposed to evangelize to the Jews (Mt. 10:5).41:49 – Is it going too far to make movies or TV shows about Jesus?52:20 – Why do the patriarchs not always observe the rights of primogeniture with their firstborns?…
Questions covered:04:55 – What is your theory of atonement?12:11 – How can I evangelize to a Jehovah Witness?17:42 – What do Catholics believe about justification in relation to James 1:5?20:33 – Can you explain the Catholic perspective on faith alone for salvation?28:59 – How do we define Catholic?33:55 – Why didn’t Jesus solve the problems of his time?42:18 – Does the distinction between Jews and Gentiles still exist?47:07 – Can you explain Biblical inerrancy of the resurrection accounts?50:17 – How do you define the difference between Catholic values and virtues?…
Questions Covered:06:15 – Why is the Filioque such a big deal?11:24 – Was Mohammeds spiritual encounter authentic, and if it was, was it angelic or some other nefarious being?14:10 – I was raised Pentecostal. I think I understand the Marian dogmas, but it feels weird, and it feels like worship. How can I make it feel less like worship?19:19 – If your name is in the book of life then how could it ever be removed?31:55 – What is the response to the claim that speaking in tongues is necessary?35:55 – How and when did the Catholic faith start?43:03 – If a priest is in mortal sin, how can he absolve me of my sins?48:37 – How can we challenge the claim that only the apostles had the ability to forgive sins and not the successors?52:39 – I want to go back to church, will it cost me money? What are the requirements?…
Questions Covered:04:38 – Was the material universe always supposed to be temporary?16:28 – What does the verse that says Jesus is first born of all creation mean?19:35 – What qualities do women lack that disqualifies them from being priests?22:54 – Why in some places do they stand after the consecration before the great amen. What do bishops have to do to get those changes approved?39:57 – Does God still chastise people for their sins on this earth like He did in the old Testament?45:47 – What’s the difference between a Plenary indulgence earned during the day and one which is earned at the moment of death?49:51 – What is a general confession?…
Questions Covered:03:30 – Why can only a priest consecrate the Eucharist if anyone can baptize with the right intention?06:38 – How much of saintly intercession would apply to old testament figures?13:41 – Is there a connection between Jesus entering into hades to retrieve the souls and the Catholic understanding of Purgatory?17:13 – Regarding Isaiah 53:4, the story of a suffering servant. It says that the servant smitten is by God. How do we as Catholics understand this?22:19 – Is there some way to determine if someone is in a state of grace?30:01 – Was Judas ever given the grace to be saved or was he doomed to fail?35:12 – I just became Catholic. My biggest issue was infant baptism. What am I supposed to say to my children if they grow up and question me why i didn’t give them a choice?37:24 – Does God love some more than others?41:43 – The Eucharist liturgy doesn’t make sense, especially transubstantiation.45:34 – The Church claims infallibility but why should we believe the rest of the teachings that aren’t declared infallibly?…
Questions Covered:03:11 – How do I make sense of 1 Corinth 11:5 on the topic of head coverings?16:01 – How do I respond to someone who says they don’t adhere to the biblical interpretation of condemning homosexuality because times have changed?20:55 – With Mary being called woman and the woman at the well being called woman, what’s the distinction in Jesus calling them both by the same title?28:50 – Can you clarify and navigate the stern and loose interpretations of Extra Ecclesiam Nulla Salus? What’s the clear correct understanding?36:45 – If Catholics take John 6 literally, how can we call Protestants our separated brothers and sisters since they “have no life in them?”43:47 – What’s the role of Mary in the Church? Is she being worshiped?48:00 – I’m a convert. Is Mary the dispenser of all graces? How can all the saints hear all of our prayers?…
Questions Covered:02:22 – I have discussed the doctrine of whether or not the pope had supremacy, and whilst I quote church fathers, he states other who are against papal supremacy. Why don’t the church fathers agree?08:08 – for a new convert from southern Baptist domination, should I be concerned my baptism is invalid because my pastor likely did not have the intent needed as stated in the catechism14:23 – How can I put Leviticus in the most positive light for believing Christians that aren’t particularly sophisticated in their theology?20:10 – How to convince Protestants of Marian doctrine?28:57 – Why do we call Mary, Jesus, Moses, ect. just by their names, instead of St. Mary, St. Jesus, ect. ?32:45 I just need help understanding the trinity. The more I learn, the more I think I don’t know.35:50 – I’m trying to understand the Church’s Treasury of Merits? what exactly is it and how does it work with Purgatory?42:10 – why are only the successors of Peter important and not the other apostles? When Peter died was the apostle John subject to his successor or did John hold more authority? Peace47:21 – Is the SSPX in full communion with the Church?49:45 – Is belief that elves exist compatible with catholicism? What is the strongest point against the idea of sola scriptura, or that every teaching must be found in the Bible?…
Questions Covered:05:11 – Would it be accurate to say the Nicene Creed is part of the deposit of faith?08:23 – What is palmarian church14:19 – Can there be a pope from one of the Eastern Catholic Churches?17:41 – How can one be a liberal Catholic and still believe in the teachings of Christ31:16 – Is it wrong to love God because you fear Hell?36:40 – Do we need to confess venial sins that were taken away by our last communion? Or does that show doubt in the efficacy of communion?41:22 – I see people often wondering if a life decision is God’s will. But as long as one is loving God fully, and loving their neighbor, isn’t everything that falls under that God’s will?47:52 – IS the Sabbatine privilege for wearing brown scapular endorsed by Catholic Church ?49:44 – is it true that God loves some people more than others?, hence why certain people have more graces, are chosen to be priests or even have a better fulfilled purposes in life. thank you.52:46 – What is your commitment when it comes to honoring/respecting parents or grandparents when they refuse to communicate to you and tell blatant lies about you regarding serious sins?…
Questions Covered:02:22 – I was at a gun show in Idaho not long ago and one of the vendors was a born again Christian group handing out Jack Chick tracts. I walked past them fairly quickly, not because I didn’t want to engage but because I was trying to catch up to my son-in-law. As I was walking back up the aisle they were on I was distracted by a vendor selling antique rifles, some going back as far as the Revolutionary War, when someone said to me “thank you for your service!” I turned to my left to see a guy, about my age, and he repeated himself. I thanked him but explained I hadn’t been in the military. He looked surprised then said something about the color of my eyes (hazel/green) and when I realized who I was talking to I knew I was stuck. It was the Pastor of the group handing out the JC Tracts. Long story short he asked me if I knew I was saved. I said yes. He asked if I knew I was going to heaven I said it’s my hope, but that ultimately was up to me. Then he commences to break out a green, hand held, KJV military Bible (one that I have), reads me some scripture, and asks if I will pray with him. I said of course! We commence the praying and I realize this was my altar call…I was being made born again. After the prayer he congratulated me…and I started to feel uneasy. It’s bothered me since. I know I hadn’t renounced my Catholic faith because the prayer was pretty generic, but there’s a part of me that thinks I made a mistake. Did I, or am I being overly scrupulous? 05:47 – How did authorship work in the ancient and medieval periods? For example, I heavily doubt that Homer made a fortune selling copies of The Iliad and The Odyssey or that Plato sold copies of The Republic. How were ancient writings circulated? I imagine having to hand copy every word from every scroll would put a damper on how accessible they would be in markets. Did every individual who copies the Odyssey have to copy down “Written by Homer” with it? What if someone wanted to take the same Odyssey and pass it off as their original work? Also, how would the average man living in these periods know which authors (who are trying to pass information down) are genuine and which authors are hacks? 16:26 – I just learned about Hilazon blue. Is there a checklist of all the things needed for rebuilding the Third Temple, and what’s left? 18:36 – You have mentioned before that God could have created a universe that appeared to be eternal, that is, without a beginning (I hope I have that right…). I do not understand this, as being “created” would seem to require a beginning (otherwise, God would not need to create it). Or are you saying that it merely has the “appearance” of always existing, but was created? In which case, does that mean that God is deliberately deceiving? 22:01 – Why do we restrict Protestants from receiving the Eucharist except in certain limited circumstances (grave necessity)? Children baptized into the Catholic faith are able to receive the Eucharist before being confirmed. There is no difference (as far as I am aware) between a valid Catholic baptism and a valid Protestant baptism, so there is no ontological difference between a baptized-but-unconfirmed Catholic and a baptized-but-unconfirmed Protestant. Belief cannot be the answer, since many Protestants (while in RCIA and before their confirmation) have the same faith as Catholics. Is it prudential? 28:34 – Why is the Protestant account for the canon of scripture untenable? 34:05 – How will we be able to interact in heaven with our loved ones without a body? (That is, until they are resurrected.) 35:44 – John 20:22, our Lord breathed on the apostles and gave them the Holy Spirit. Thomas was not with them. When did Thomas receive the Holy Spirit? 40:47 – What is a good source to use to get authentic news from what th…
Questions Covered:03:21 – 1 Sam 18:10 says “an evil spirit from God rushed upon Saul.” How are we supposed to interpret that when nothing evil can come from God?10:06 – Can you help me understand in what sense Jesus is God? How can a thing have two natures? Is it the same way the Burning Bush, or the Eucharist, is God?19:39 – What are the reasons a person might hear voices?28:55 – My spiritual director has been cautioning me against treating novenas and relics like magic. But in last Sunday’s gospel we hear of the woman who was healed because she believed if she touched Jesus’ clothes she would be healed. How can one have that kind of faith without treating it like magic?38:05 – Does Matthew quote the Septuagint?45:50 – What’s the difference between black magic and white magic?48:42 – I had an experience in early youth that led to my conversion later in life. Have you heard anything like that before? What kind of experience is this?…
Questions Covered:10:52 – Does the Council of Jerusalem in Acts 15 relate back to a council 1 Chronicles 28? I’m thinking that if it does, it could be more proof for the papacy.17:14 – Does Matthew quote the Septuagint?21:53 – I heard an interpretation of the story of Abraham’s sacrifice of Isaac that Abraham failed because he should have offered himself in place of Isaac. Is there any truth to that interpretation?31:46 – I find it’s hard to use 2 Macc 12:46 to defend Purgatory to Protestants because they don’t believe in that book. How do you deal with that?40:20 – How do we answer someone who says that God is Jehovah?45:22 – How do we answer free-gracers that bring up Rom 3:20 as proof that works of the law are all works?49:50 – What is the biblical evidence for inclusivism, meaning that God has mercy for those who through no fault of their own have not heard the gospel? And if there’s time… Why does Acts 1:5 talk about a water baptism and a holy spirit baptism, but Eph 4:5 says “one baptism.”…
Questions Covered:05:35 – My youngest daughter decided to leave the Church and became Lutheran. She will be getting married with a Lutheran pastor officiating. Can I attend?17:58 – Why don’t we point to images of angels of death and say that it’s St. Michael the Archangel? Doesn’t he do God’s work of bringing death to the earth?20:25 – How does NFP fit into a Catholic life and being open to life?34:35 – Is pirating games online immoral?40:54 – I’m not Catholic. What is the Catholic view of the rapture?46:37 – I pray the Divine Mercy novena for family who has left the Church. Will this help them when they pass away to avoid hell?50:36 – Why didn’t the Church make exorcism into a sacrament?53:03 – Does the Church uphold the validity of a marriage outside of the Catholic Church in the situation of the previous caller’s daughter? …
Questions Covered:07:03 – I’m close to coming to faith but hell doesn’t seem to fit with an all-loving God. Can you explain?40:34 – Can you give a summary on the Catholic Moral life?50:07 – If you start worshiping Buddha, Is that a big sin?…
Questions Covered:01:02 – Can someone tell me what verses talk about saints in heaven interceding for us?09:55 – How can we be sure that the Catholic Church is the one true Church when the early church seems more conciliar like the Orthodox?28:26 – My Eastern Orthodox friend argues that there’s 3 Petrine sees, and Rome does not have a right to override the others. How do I respond to that?43:47 – I was raised Catholic and can’t get past the bible verse saying call no man father. What’s the answer?…
Questions Covered:06:29 – Can I attend a wedding of protestant family members?16:33 – Does a priest have to touch the host during the consecration for the mass to be valid?30:14 – Why does Jesus say that divorce is allowed only during infidelity in Matthew 19?44:15 – Mt. 27:9. Is it true that there are ancient rabbinical documents that quote one prophet but attribute it to another prophet?50:56 – When I talk to my protestant friends about a sacrifice at the mass they say that they have a sacrifice of praise. How do I respond to that?…
Questions Covered:06:42 – Is it possible to reconcile Young-Earth Creationism with findings of science that appear to say the earth is much older? 13:55 – During the apostolic age, was a mustard seed considered a weed or a harvestable crop? 19:11 – Did Jesus have an elemental soul like humans do? 22:43 – I’m having a lot of problems with two dioceses. They’re restricting my ministry and not telling me what’s wrong. What’s the next level I can go to to try and sort this out? 33:36 – How do the Catholic observances of holidays and seasons and feasts reconcile with Mathetes’ Epistle to Diogenetus, which seems to say that holidays and seasons are not Christian? 41:07 – With all the suffering in the world today, has anyone proposed that purgatory might be this world? 47:31 – Is it okay for Catholics to use supplements for your mood like adaptogens? 49:49 – What are some good sources I can read concerning typology of St. Peter in the Old Testament? …
Questions Covered:01:27 – What is the history of the use of the tetragrammaton/divine name in worship, particularly as it relates to Jehovah’s Witnesses? 07:44 – I heard your show where you mentioned a study in India on near death experiences where the people in India would see some spirits that were either good or evil spirits. Christians see angels, good or bad. So non-believers could argue that the fact that people don’t see the same thing is proof that these visions are due only to chemical reactions of a dying brain. How would you respond? 13:52 – What would be the best way for us as Catholics to answer some Protestants who claim what’s happening in Israel right now has to do with the 2nd coming of Jesus that in there minds is gonna happen soon or at any moment? 17:49 – Which allegedly evidential NDE do you think is the strongest? 23:57 – If the Pope has the keys to heaven and hell, could the Pope/Church canonize someone that God would not have allowed into heaven by ordinary means, but since the church/pope utilized the authority of those keys they now get in? what about the reverse a just person going to hell because the church invoked the keys of authority to condemn them? 28:25 – From what I understand, the Jesuits are not allowed to hold positions of Authority or power. Is this true? And if so, did it change to permit Pope Francis to be Pope? 29:55 – Maybe better for a weird questions episode but I recently had several blessed, holy objects go missing around the house and it occurred to me, if it WAS demons, is there 34:53 – From my 15 year old : Is God alive both scientifically as well as theologically? 39:30 – From my 13 year old: In the Skinwalker Ranch episode of Mysterious World there were three wolf- like activities and one of them was a wolf-like creature running around in the horse pen. One thing that I realized was that the description for the wolf was almost the same as the beast of Gevaudan. Do you think the beast could have been a skin walker? They were both red, had poofy tails, head like a wolf, heyena like bodies and boar like legs. I’d like to hear your thoughts. 43:51 – I remember a very helpful episode where you discussed the career of Dr. Steven Greer. I have been very curious about what you know about the legitimacy of the UAP claims by Bob Lazar and David Grusch? 48:56 – How can we better understand the word “Belief” with regards to God and our faith, and do Catholics and Protestants (specifically Lutherans, understand this idea of belief in God differently). Is it just about saying you know of God’s existence and profess to others that you know and understand of his existence; or, is there a deeper understanding of “belief in God” which also calls us to act or respond to this understanding of “belief” in Him. If there is a deeper understanding (or action) of belief, where do we find this ( in history, in scripture, or in the actual definition in or meaning of the word)? …
Questions Covered:05:42 – How is it that we can’t keep cremated remains on the mantle but we can keep relics of saints?13:10 – Do most Catholics believe that most people go to hell or most people go to purgatory?19:00 – After purification in purgatory, do you think we’d even have the ability to think the same kind of thoughts we have here on Earth?22:18 – In the story of the rich man and Lazarus, is the Rich man in purgatory or hell?37:02 – Can the souls in purgatory pray for themselves?41:54 – What do people do in Heaven? Also, what is this whole new heaven and new earth thing all about?46:45 – Did Vatican II change the Catholic understanding of baptismal ecclesiology? My pre-conciliar catechism says we are born as soldiers of Christ, and priests are the officers. I like that. But now it feels like priests and laity are more like colleagues.…
Questions Covered:12:46 – In Purgatory, are human memories saved in the soul or in the body? 19:16 – I’m Protestant and it seems to me that scripture indicates that upon death one immediately either goes to Heaven or Hell. Is that not the Catholic view? 30:32 – How did people come up with the idea of Universalism when it seems clear in scripture that people will be lost? 39:52 – I want to pray for people in purgatory, but there’s so many people I know who have died, some from long ago. How do I know who I should be praying for, or if that person is even still in purgatory? 43:53 – My Protestant friend thinks purgatory is very legalistic or transactional, in that mortal sins send you to hell but venial sins only to purgatory. How can I answer him? …
Questions Covered:00:45 – Is in Persona Christi limited to the priest celebrating the mass or does it extend to the magisterium?10:04 – Is there a possible connection between “calling no man father” and people in the New Testament being baptized and assigning their spirituality on those who baptized them?17:04 – At what point is a marriage considered sacramental outside the Catholic Church?22:33 – Why should I become Catholic if my western rite Orthodoxy is so similar without the baggage?46:12 – My father is not a Catholic and is battling cancer. I’ve been offering holy communion for him. Is that allowed? What does the Church say about cremation?49:59 – Should we respond with ‘because God said so’ when approaching social issues in apologetic debates?…
Questions Covered:05:41 – Is there any problem for a Catholic to believe in Mary as Co-Redemptrix?21:50 – Why was Jesus baptized?34:22 – My Baptist cousin is in seminary. What good resources could I use to challenge him without being confrontational?42:22 – You’ve mentioned that you are a fan of the synodal process. Can you express why and what the process is?…
Questions Covered:07:30 – Does non resistant, non belief have any bearing for protestant exploring Catholicism?19:50 – If you’re praying the rosary while doing everyday things like mowing the lawn, do those things become good works?31:02 – I’m converting to Catholicism. I’m convinced but what if God is a fundamentalist?41:12 – Is Quo Primum by Pope Pius V ex cathedra? Can later popes get rid of the latin mass?50:08 – If you’ve already been consecrated to Mary, can you be consecrated to other saints or Jesus?52:00 – If angels are morally infallible, are they also inerrant? Can they make a mistake?…
Questions Covered:01:00 – Catholics like to try and validate the serpents claim that when you die you don’t really die. That’s how they end up teaching Mary and all the saints are not dead but in heaven.05:46 – How should I love God and have a firm resolve especially after confession?12:28 – When was the last time the pope spoke ex cathedra?17:07 – Do you think it’s ok to use philosophy and theology to evaluate human evolution?27:53 – I’m a recent revert. Why does the bible seem to suggest that Jesus is subordinate to the father?36:39 – How are we sure the saints are in heaven if there’s a chance they went to purgatory?46:23 – Are priests also counselors?…
Questions Covered:21:47 – How do you know when God answers your prayer vs when he doesn’t?30:06 – Am I over-spiritualizing my situation? I’ve been diagnosed with a disease that’s completely changed my life. What should I do?47:33 – Most of my life I’ve felt alone. I’m married and now have a tendency to want to be alone, lazy, and unhappy. What am I battling?…
Questions Covered:02:00 – What is the necessity of purification after death but before heaven?15:30 – What is the textual criticism of John 8 and the woman caught in adultery?22:53 – Why is the pope pushing heresy by allowing people to receive communion after a divorce?35:26 – How does one know if they believe in their heart?41:20 – How does Jesus fulfill the prophecy of reuniting all the tribes of Israel?46:18 – What are the requirements for being an apologist?49:39 – My friend asked us to take their children if anything ever happened to them but told us to not baptize them. Would I have to honor that or are we morally obligated to baptize them?…
Questions Covered:41:07 – What are your thoughts on the governor of Louisiana mandating every school to have the 10 commandments?49:15 – What’s the purpose of the Synod on Synodality?…
Questions Covered:04:15 – Is it ok for me to attend a Bar Mitzvah?06:10 – How do we know for sure that it was Samuel that the witch of Endor contacted?12:19 – You can lose your salvation but what must happen for that to occur?19:45 – Is the entire mass a sacrifice or just the Eucharist? Is the profession of faith essential?24:20 – Do we as Catholics fall under any of the following categories; provisionist, open theists, Arminian? I know Calvinists use these categories.34:41 – If God knows the future, then why does he regret making humans Gen 6:6?44:17 – In the bible it says things like ‘ I chose you and you’re a chosen race. Why are some people chosen?48:41 – Could you explain how we know that the saints can hear us, and why having statues doesn’t mean we worship them?52:52 – What is the Beatific Vision?…
Questions Covered:43:22 – If schism is a mortal sin, does that mean that when those schismatic churches receive communion, they are receiving it in mortal sin?50:40 – What are your thoughts on Pope Benedict XVI’s view of Purgatory in Saved in Hope, Spe Salvi, encyclical?…
Questions Covered:08:30 – What happens to Pontius Pilate’s wife Claudia? Did she ever convert?12:48 – How can the Church say that there is no salvation outside the Church yet declare people saints like St. Gregory of Narek?16:13 – How did you come to believe in the intercession of saints and confessing sins to a priest? I’m protestant and having a hard time with it28:54 – What do you think of Catholics who say that Catholics have to support labor unions?36:24 – What are the benefits of being Catholic as opposed to being an atheist? And Why Catholicism instead of another denomination?43:45 – Since venial sin doesn’t send one to hell, would one still need Jesus if they’ve never committed a mortal sin?49:38 – As a Catholic how do we respond to the Black Hebrew Israelites who assert salvation due to race or culture?…
Questions Covered:03:44 – In the Transformers, there are a team of Constructicons where 5 robots can combine to make one giant robot. According to the official character bio, the giant robot, Devastator, has a unique consciousness that is also a composite of all 5 unique, individual robot personalities. Do you think this is a good illustration of how God works, albeit being a Quintessence as opposed to a Trinity? 08:40 – Chiropractic. Religion? New Age wooow? Scam? 13:15 – Most Christians I know would say “light as a feather, stiff as a board” is demons. Because, you know… If it’s not demons, is there a natural explanation for why it works? 16:50 – What do you think the likelihood is that we will meet beings from other realities that God created when we get to heaven? Or should we expect that this is the only reality, and the sole occupants of heaven will be from this space-time continuum? 18:23 – Why did Jesus ascend into the sky and what happened to His body? Did it disappear or do he go to other planets or outer space? 21:14 – Was it not a good idea for Johnny to take the bet with the devil in the song “Devil went down to Georgia”, given that the Church strongly encourages not conversing with the devil or demons, even though he won the bet? 24:03 – If humans evolved from different humanoid species in the past, at what point did we gain a soul? 29:07 – Why did Peter put on his clothes before jumping in the water? 31:05 – In Tobit, Archangel Raphael states that it only seemed to Tobias that he was eating, but really did not. So did Raphael atomize the food he touched when having meals with Tobias or is there another explanation? How would someone be able to explain that Jesus really ate with his Apostles when Archangel Raphael only made it seem like it? 36:35 – I wonder is it a sin to be psychic? My grandmother was a very gifted psychic and a devout Catholic. This created some issues when she was criticized by the priest at church.…
Questions Covered:02:30 – I mean no disrespect with this question…. I noticed a few weeks ago that Jimmy was leaving the “g” off of words like “teachin” or “reasonin” and others. I can only assume that this is the normal dialect in Arkansas? Question. Is this change due to a conscious effort to return to his “roots” or is this an outcome of being immersed back into the Arkansas dialect through local conversations? Love Mysterious World and Cy’s awkward Dad joke sense of humor.08:17 – In the very first Weird Questions I listened to, Jimmy answered a question asking if a man was teleported back in time to 5 BC, what obligations he would have to do in order to worship God properly. Now, let me ask the reverse of that. Suppose a man from 500BC was in stasis for thousands of years and wakes up when a group of archaeologists discover him. I imagine the option to be baptized and confirmed would be just as open to him as to any other man (provided he knows what the sacraments and the Gospel mean), but if the man were to die after his waking up in the 21st century without having done these things, what would be the state of his soul?11:31 – We have a ghost where I work….and I wouldn’t have believed it if I hadn’t seen and heard it with my own eyes. A coworker recently got a spirit box and it has picked up some interesting things but I wasn’t there when they were using it. Do those things (spirit boxes} have any legitimacy to them?16:40 – Just wondering if you can address something that kept coming to my mind while listening to Mysterious World (AA 1025) If so thanks. My question is not directly related but it made me think about Bella Dodd and her impact related to infiltration in the church along with her conversation. I just want to hear your thoughts on this. On a side note I really enjoy your work but I particularly enjoy Mysterious World!!!19:31 – Are there any conditions that must be met for the devil to possess someone? In Other words, are there any characteristics of a person that would need to be present in order for that person to be possessed by a demon?28:57 – Did Jesus ever get bitten by mosquitos, ticks! Lice or other blood-feeding pests? And if so what would the implications be of these creatures potentially being the first among creation to receive the precious blood of Christ? I tend to think about this when hiking in deep quiet woods and swarmed by a fog of billions of mosquitos with nothing apparently to eat but me. Perhaps they cannot starve to death and are in a sense immortal?33:25 – So I read a book about a guy that whenever he dies he is reborn but with all the memories of his previous lives.My question is that if he became a priest in one of his lives would that end at his death, or would he technically still be a priest in every life after that?35:16 – Who invented smoking? More importantly, how did people discover that inhaling burning fumes from various herbs feels good?39:27 – Can the belief in djinn be incorporated into the Catholic worldview? And if so, how would this affect the categories of alien and demon by adding a third possible explanation of unexplained phenomenon?44:35 – What is Baphomet?48:45 – My son, Jonathan would like like a deep dive on Angelic swords (Genesis 3:24) Did the angels forge them? Are they still around? Did God invent swords?51:42 – Would it be a stretch or not from a Catholic perspective to say that both Multiple Personality Disorder and Rabies are different ways in which demonic activity can manifest? I.e. The Personalities of those with MPD actually being demons in disguise waiting for the right moment to strike or rabies being a disease that could evolve into a form of demonic possession that can manifest in various animals…
Questions Covered:04:03 – Does the trial of Pope Formosus disprove Papal Infallibility?10:50 – Does time exist in the Church triumphant and the Church suffering as it does for the Church militant?17:56 – How can we explain to an animal rights activist that humans have greater value and dignity?24:36 – What’s the morality of interacting with algorithms that can influence others to encounter questionable material?31:09 – I want to start defending the faith. How do I defend the words “Praying to” when referring to Mary?36:42 – What is the Catholic perspective of the orthogonality thesis within general purpose intelligence research?42:29 – In your recent debate with James White on Sola Scriptura you argued the different ways “Word of God’ was used. What resource did you use to build that argument?46:33 – My wife and I both grew up Catholic but never got married in the Church. Do we have to get our marriage blessed by the Church? We now live like brother and sister.51:05 – My son is in college and questioning whether God is real. How do I start a conversation with him without scaring him away?…
Questions Covered:05:25 – How would you explain to a protestant that the reformation did more harm than good?11:52 – How would I reply to a friend who says that a Catholic shouldn’t judge a gay relationship?18:45 – Can I receive communion more than once a day?20:07 – Our priest seems to rush the Mass. Is it appropriate to approach him and ask him to slow down?29:52 – Is it good to assume that the people being addressed in Romans 10 were already baptized with great faith? Thus, faith being what was needed for salvation for them?34:52 – My friend favors the spiritual presence view of the eucharist? How do I explain to him that this view is insufficient?40:58 – I’m thinking of leaving the Catholic church because they won’t give the precious blood? Why am I being denied a sacrament?43:56 – I agree with the limiting of microplastics. We need to do what we can to save God’s planet?49:05 – Are the different Churches in the new testaments akin to what today are modern dioceses?51:49 – In light of 2 Cor 5:20, what is a good way to evangelize senior citizens whose memory isn’t good?…
Questions Covered: 09:32 – Can you explain why all Judeo-Christian revelations come from the Middle East? 32:58 – How can Catholics believe the Saints are in heaven based on the day of judgment? 50:32 – Can you give advice on how to dialogue when they don’t accept the Sacrament? …
Questions Covered: 04:53 – How can a Catholic prophecy be wrong about the end of the world? 15:18 – Why does the Divine Mercy chaplet say, “I give you the body and blood”? 30:05 – Why do Catholics need Confession when Jesus paid the price for our sins? 40:56 – Is it possible to affect someone’s ultimate salvation? 51:58 – In what sense is Jesus God? …
Questions Covered:01:02 – What do you think about the supposed references to Jesus in the Talmud?08:10 – Please explain how does the process work when a priest earns the title of Monsignor I’d like to understand how that whole process works.13:?42 – Can you make a distinction between God’s miracles and what demons are capable of?18:39 – Who is the “destroyer” / angel of death in Exodus? An actual angel?20:24 – Do you think the Jewish faith was reinterpreted after Jesus’s death and resurrection 25:10 – Why is the word Holy Ghost said instead of Holy Spirit?28:25 – Why are there so many people who say that the Catholic Church is evil? The red shoes are evil. The room that looks like a serpent, at the Vatican. And other claims…?32:43 – I was recently challenged on the papal bulls allowing conquest and enslavement, followed by the bull Sublimis Deus forbidding enslavement, which I take as an abrogation of the prior. The interlocutor asked 1) how can one infallible bull overrule another one; and 2) how was anyone supposed to know when Sublimus Deus doesn’t mention the prior bulls or say they were abrogated? What do you say?35:24 – Can you explain how the Godhead and the Trinity are not conflicting ideas or doctrines. I get SO MANY people who challenge the Trinity and say that Catholics try to replace the Godhead with the “false doctrine” of the Trinity.44:50 – Let’s say a person was properly baptized as a child but didn’t remember. They grow up and live a secular life until finding the faith later. They go through RCIA and, not remembering that they had been already baptized, are baptized and confirmed into the church.This person thinks that their recent baptism washes away the sins to that point and so does not go to confession for those sins. Is this person in trouble spiritually? Can they, since they are ignorant of the situation, receive the Eucharist?48:08 – Jimmy Akin, what’s your most recent and thorough reflection on Numbers 12?51:57 – Do we have one guardian angel for our whole life?53:11 – What are your thoughts on the “manna machine”?…
Questions Covered:02:17 -If there are conjoined twins who are saints and they have the power of bilocation, would they be able to bilocate separately or should they bilocate together?07:06 – Will conjoined twins still be joined in their resurrected bodies?11:11 – In marriage, is the “good of the spouses” supplied by nature, or grace?13:10 – What is the Church’s stance on the history of St Veronica?17:52 – Can God “forgive” you your sins or could it be more accurate to say He is the immutable embodiment of forgiveness itself- thus really only we can change by atoning and reorienting ourselves to Him?19:35 – My son, Joshua wants to ask you if you think the Superman movies could have a Christian allegory to them?28:42 – How/why did the Jews become monotheists?32:41 – Where did the prayer come from that w e say at Mass after the Our Father… “For Thine is the Kingdom,,,”35:35 – Why do you suppose the account of Peter walking on the water only in Matthew?39:42 – My daughter has a turtle. One day, she was laying on the floor with the turtle. The turtle looks at her, then at a piece of fence about a foot or two tall, and back at her a few times. The turtle then runs to the fence, pushes it over to create a ramp (inclined plane) onto my daughter, then climbs the fence onto my daughter’s back. That would appear to be a lot of thought going on in the turtle’s brain to figure that out. What evidence do we have for the extent of intelligence in animals? Does she just have a really smart turtle?45:41 – What’s your take on original monotheism?49:28 – Will we continue learning in heaven? Or will we just instantaneously know everything we can know?51:14 – Did Jesus drink wine, or was it just grape juice?53:12 – If Jesus submitted his DNA to 23&Me would it prove that Joseph was his Father?…
Questions Covered: 04:00 – Did the people who were resurrected after Jesus’ resurrection in Matthew 27:53 go to heaven? 11:12 – How do I respond to the claim that Jesus was crucified on a Wednesday? See: https://www.catholic.com/magazine/print-edition/crucifixion-wednesday See my article: https://www.catholic.com/magazine/online-edition/the-timing-of-jesus-death 15:38 – It sounds like Catholics disagree with Christ’s teaching of eternal security in John 5:24. Can we still perish even if we believe in Christ? See article: https://www.catholic.com/magazine/online-edition/dont-take-eternal-life-for-granted 19:48 – Why is the Catholic Church always in the defensive position when it comes to apologetics? 24:23 – Why do we have to explain anything out of our faith? Why do we concentrate so much on defending the faith? 30:20 – Can the terms priest and pastor be used interchangeably? 34:28 – I heard a protestant say that Mt 12:32 has nothing to do with purgatory because there’s no forgiveness after we’re dead. How do I respond? 42:24 – Why did Mary say “My God and My Savior” in Luke? 46:49 – Is a crucifix a graven image that the bible condemns? …
Questions Covered:04:51 – Why is there only one incarnation? Why not the Father and Holy Spirit too?15:30 – If Satan had not fallen, would humans have fallen?17:18 – How do I respond to a 2nd grader who doesn’t understand why women can’t be priests? I gave the typical answer about the apostles but got pushback. What do I do now?20:41 – Where in the bible does it say that women can’t be priests?32:27 – In the martyrdom of Perpetua, it says that she had a vision of her brother suffering and then another where he no longer was. Is this an early account for purgatory? Are there other documented accounts of purgatory in the first 300 years of the Church?42:39 – How do you reconcile papal primacy and the necessity to submit to the Roman pontiff and salvation only coming from the Lord?46:03 – How do we know Jesus isn’t using a metaphor when he says that He is the Bread in John 6 since Jesus later says in John 10:9 and 15:5 that He is the door and a gate?…
Topics Covered:00:00 – Why flannel?02:32 – Plastic straws13:46 – The Dumbing Down of Society33:14 – Zach’s Killing it!33:40 – Polyamory…
Questions Covered: 01:10 – Are Martyrs automatically Saints? 02:47 – Is the role of the Diaconate expandable? 06:56 – What is the difference between Eucharistic Adoration with Exposition and in the tabernacle? 12:09 – Was the date of Friday, April 3 of the Crucifixion calculated on the Julian calendar or Gregorian? 14:59 – What is the legitimacy to the story of the Nephilim? 22:23 – Where can I find information on how to get an exorcism in my area, is this reserved for only Catholics? 24:22 – What was the mood of the apologist when Pope Benedict retired? 32:56 – Can you explain Paul’s teachings on women wearing coverings for angels not other interpretations? 32:56 – Can you explain Paul’s teachings on women wearing coverings for angels not other interpretations? 42:48 – How can we have peace with God when we are able to fall into mortal sin on any day? 46:26 – Why is this divorce seen as a big deal? 52:46 – Is lying against the Holy Spirit different from blasphemy of the Holy Spirit? …
Questions Covered:13:20 – One of my family members revealed they have alcohol addiction. We usually have gatherings with alcohol. How should we handle this? 20:18 – Do you have services for the family of someone who is struggling through alcohol addiction? 29:28 – My family member went to a CIR Retreat. How are other addictions addressed at those retreats? 35:35 – I’ve been sober for 6 years. In your experience, does the feeling of dependency ever go away? 42:03 – Have you ever used the John Bradshaw theory and Erick Ericksons family therapy series? 46:02 – Does CIR have a form of it for someone who is not Catholic? 47:45 – What is your take on alternative recovery options? 49:53 – I’m 30 years clean. My first step was admitting my fault and praying the rosary. 51:33 – How is recovery different from a Catholic perspective compared to Baptist or Protestant perspective? …
Questions Covered: 02:10 – Would it be illicit to call Protestants heretics? 10:42 – What is the difference in significance to Jesus calling Mary “woman” and the woman at the well “woman”? 17:25 – How can I respond to someone who brings up the Serpent church in the Vatican? 23:08 – Can you claim to be Catholic and only attend Protestant services? 30:28 – Is there a difference between God in the Old Testament compared to the New Testament? 40:05 – What is the Catholic position on the moral righteousness of God ordering the Israelites to kill women and animals? 47:34 – How can I compromise with my ex-wife on the Baptism of my daughter? …
Questions Covered:06:00 – How do we reconcile Jn 17:9 and God wills all to be saved?13:04 – How should I make the distinction between transubstantiation and consubstantiation?20:00 – What are good resources for the Spanish Inquisition and the Crusades?25:14 – Why does Jesus teach us to pray “lead us not into temptation?31:52 – What is the Church’s stance on war? Are we allowed to use violence?44:45 – With the pope’s recent comments on gay men in seminary, what are the rules of who is allowed in seminaries? Does the same apply for women religious?49:08 – What’s the clear answer to if there is salvation outside the Church?52:31 – How do I evangelize my family who doesn’t care about the historical component?…
Questions Covered:06:13 – When did baptism become effective and when did the Trinitarian formula begin?14:36 – How do I navigate anti-Catholics online? It’s extremely disheartening.23:37 – The Youtuber Cliffe, said that Jesus allowing others preaching in his name who were not known to the disciples is an example of multi-denominations? What’s the response?40:48 – What’s the best way for a Catholic to navigate Pride month?48:21 – Do you think that young men need to be accepted as they are, or to be challenged in order to bring about more vocations?…
Questions Covered:03:22 – Why was limbo taught in the past but not now?16:14 – I’ve heard that Catholics put the authority of the Church over the bible?30:18 – How did the switch to celebrating on Sunday happen?35:25 – Why is it that Catholics say a person was ‘molded after God or Mary’s own heart?”38:38 – If you need to believe to have salvation, then how does this apply to infant baptism?49:24 – What are the logistics of the spiritual world? How can an angel be with a person and be in the presence of God?…
Questions Covered:05:11 – Is Mary being the new Eve and Jesus the New Adam a strictly Catholic belief?13:48 – Is it ok to read Protestant theologians?22:22 – What is the Catholic answer to how do I get to heaven?39:08 – Christians should love abortion since it guarantees heaven45:44 – My non-Catholic friend asked: If Christ finished the sacrifice but the mass is ongoing, how is it actually finished?…
Questions Covered:02:09 – How can I better interact with Protestants when they insult and slander the Catholic Church?07:17 – Is Elohim in Hebrew a plural word?16:43 – Exodus says Moses begged God to not destroy Israel. How would it have been possible for God to destroy Israel if Jesus was supposed to come through the tribe of Judah?21:38 – How do we reconcile Mary being a perpetual virgin and Matthew 1:25?28:31 – Did the pope send a representative to the 1st Council of Constantinople? How Does the fact of the pope not being in attendance fit with the Catholic claim of Papal authority and infallibility?34:48 – Could you explain how anger is not a sin?41:49 – Regarding the James White Debate and James’ comments on indulgences. What is defined dogma?49:48 – Can you be a Catholic and believe in the real presence at Mass but not during adoration?51:34 – Are you familiar with the story of Lilith, Adam’s first wife? What are your thoughts?53:16 – Who are the Nephilim?…
Questions Covered:03:05 – Is it necessary to not act on a doubting conscience if something is avoidable?07:29 – Does God violate the Pauline principle?14:13 – What does it look like when demons and angels fight each other?17:59 – How do we clearly differentiate between mortal and venial sin?22:10 – My Spanish teacher claimed that we are all God. He mentioned Jn 10:34, Psalm 82 as evidence. What’s the response?28:33 – How do we know when marriage becomes an idol?33:08 – Was Moses assumed into heaven?40:55 – My husband and I were married in a Lutheran Church. We’re baptized in the Catholic Church. Do we have to abstain from intercourse while we wait to get our marriage blessed?44:34 – If God is outside of time and space, could Abraham have received the eucharist by Melchizedek?47:01 – Would it be moral for the scientific community to pursue artificial wombs in order to protect life?49:37 – The idea that angels fell at the moment of creation contradicts the book of Enoch. How do we understand this seeming contradiction?…
Questions Covered:05:22 – Is there light or ‘a light source’ in purgatory?12:51 – If a leader is not following the bible’s teaching, how is that going to affect the next generation?16:42 – Can you clarify the Catholic view on the Holy Spirit?23:26 – What did Jesus mean when he says ‘The flesh is of no vail’ in John 6?28:48 – Are we supposed to have a second baptism to receive our gifts from the Holy Spirit?39:39 – If IVF is a sin, then why would God provide a soul?44:48 – I’m having a hard time reconciling the God of the OT and the God of the NT. Can you explain?52:39 – How do I bring up Purgatory to my Southern Baptism friends?…
Questions Covered:06:44 – I’m an Orthodox convert from Protestantism. Why is cremation ok and how do you square it with the second coming?17:32 – Do we even need the Old Testament anymore? Should we do away with it?28:58 – How should I go about being better at debating with Protestants? How can I improve?33:40 – How is contraception different from NFP?44:52 – How do we respond to the claim of Eternal Security when they quote Jn 10:28 and 1 Tim 1:12?…
Questions Covered:02:18 – How is Jesus involved in the sacrament of marriage?18:00 – What are good tips to evangelize fallen away and lukewarm family?29:28 – Jn 5:24, Act 10:44, Gal 3:2 point to Justification by faith alone. How are works involved?45:12 – Is Lev 19:22 to show as evidence as to why we go to priests for confession?50:03 – When did they change the words ‘cup’ to ‘chalice’ in the mass?…
Questions Covered:14:02 – Will our heavenly Father still hold us to account for the sins we’ve confessed?19:35 – If someone was raised Catholic but no longer practicing, does that mean that they’re doomed?29:07 – What are the earliest documented records of the Immaculate Conception?37:33 – What’s the best argument against atheism?49:01 – What does the Church teach about speaking in tongues?…
Questions Covered:03:50 – The Passion of Joan of Arc05:18 – The Flowers of St. Francis07:24 – Apocalypto15:06 – Stand By Me17:24 – Before Sunrise24:10 – Casablanca33:15 – Lawrence of Arabia37:05 – Alfred Hitchcock46:45 – Eric Rohmer48:48 – Lightning Round: Summer movie recommendations52:20 – Tolkien…
Questions Covered:17:23 – Wildcat34:15 – Mad Max45:46 – Baseball movies50:05 – Chariots of Fire…
Questions Covered:19:05 – What would you say to someone who says they can’t get married because they can’t trust anyone?32:19 – Should I try and talk to a family member who is cohabitating to seek a sacramental marriage?35:58 – how do you maintain chastity in marriage? I’m going to get married soon and I as a female have recovered from a pornography addiction and he’s struggled as well but we’re both now recovered.45:00 – What does making love look like after pornography addiction?47:35 – A lot of people think chastity is just for women.51:32 – My husband left me. How do I proceed with my life?…
Questions Covered:17:19 – If the Holy Spirit gives the gift of tongues, how is babbling building up the body of Christ?23:16 – Why is there a need for confirmation if a baptized child has already received the Holy Spirit?33:12 – Is Acts 2:1-11 and Jn 20:19-23 the same event of the descent of the Holy Spirit?36:03 – When did it go from Holy Ghost to Holy Spirit?41:45 – My priest friend said the charismatic movement is a bad idea. What are your thoughts?47:41 – How does the Church regard speaking in tongues? And also speaking in tongues in protestant churches?…
Questions Covered:06:14 – Did Mary ever die? Wouldn’t there be a record of that?10:07 – Why does the Church promote the use of hospice care? It feels like mercy killing.19:04 – How can a Catholic best explain Pentecost and the birth of the Church to a Protestant?24:10 – I’m taking a college course and there’s a group of people who are taking the course in not a good direction. How can I as a Catholic be charitable to them while trying to keep us on track?30:20 – When is typology the legitimate exercise in pattern recognition?34:47 – What is the great war in heaven mentioned in Rev. 12, going to look like?40:38 – In relation to the earlier call on hospice. How does Terri Shaivo innocent look from the Catholic perspective?46:00 – Pope Francis allegedly made a comment saying that homosexuals live the gift of love. Is this true?49:06 – Do we have to pray aloud to Mary?50:40 – Does faith/believe or repentance need to be present for baptism to be valid? If it does, how is infant baptism valid?…
Questions Covered: 03:08 – Regarding Mary’s bodily death, is it a valid theology opinion or position to take that she did not die but was assumed without dying first, given its not part of the dogma itself? 05:46 – I heard a priest say that even an atheist can get to heaven, is this true? 16:52 – Why does the rosary have ten Hail Marys in a row? Is there a significance to this? 22:28 – Do rights exist or are rights just something that came out of the enlightenment period? 35:13 – Can the verse Act 8:16 and Acts 19:1-6 be used in an argument for the efficacy of Baptism? 44:35 – Is there any connection of “That which dwells” from the Old Testament to the Holy Spirit? 52:47 – Why are the Gospels written in third person? …
Questions Covered: 04:24 – Is evangelizing through content creation of video games good?11:52 – I read in a Lutheran book that “the reason the church used to only provide the bread not the blood is because the congregation is not holy enough” can Joe speak to this?18:38 – What intercessory power do old testament figures hold? Are they the same as saints? (ie: is Moses/Elijah the same as St. Thomas Aquinas?)20:31 – If purgatory is meant to purify us of our disordered desires, how do indulgences play into that?30:15 – How do I explain to my friend that the Catholic church does have the fullness of the faith?34:15 – How are things different for people with autism in the church? Do they have different expectations from the church?45:45 – What is your take on the widespread phenomenon of Pentecostal miracles driving people away from the Catholic Church?…
Questions Covered:24:59 – How do I find peace when things like the Latin Mass I prefer going to is being restricted?34:36 – I have peace by only listening to Catholic radio and not the news of the world.39:00 – I’ve taught confirmation for a long time now, but now I’m being told that I don’t teach enough love. How do I find peace while I’m being told I’m not teaching the faith right?47:50 – I agree with you, Pray, don’t worry and serve other people.51:19 – How do we maintain peace when fellow Christians are suffering persecution all across the world?…
Questions Covered:28:55 – Could you comment on how human dignity is affected by NFP and barrier methods of pregnancy avoidance especially for those who don’t want to take artificial contraception?40:27 – I want to know more about the upcoming alliance in the World Health Organization.…
Questions Covered:16:05 – How do I grow my trust in God’s goodness and love?36:50 – I’m not Catholic, what are some resources you recommend to learn more about Catholicism?49:00 – What does the Church teach about monastic life and the mandate to be fruitful and multiply?…
Questions Covered:08:40 – Can I be a conscientious objector if I join the military and don’t want to partake in an unjust war?21:55 – Why was Mary not baptized?28:30 – Does the validity of baptism depend on the acceptance of the recipient?52:12 – Would you still need to go to purgatory if you went to confession 10 minutes prior to death?…
Questions Covered:18:06 – How guilty am I supposed to feel for Jesus dying for our sins?31:47 – I’m a new Christian and my girlfriend is Catholic. We have been debating the Trinity. My church teaches that The Father, Son and Holy Spirit are all the same. What does the Catholic Church teach and why is mine wrong?…
Questions Covered:10:28 – Since St. John was exiled at the end of his life, how did he deliver his last books?18:11 – How can I sincerely pray the act of contrition and the Our Father if I have a hard time with what the prayer says?34:98 – Do you need to be specific when asking for a prayer intention?…
Questions Covered:05:27 – How can we explain the view of predestination according to Augustine and Aquinas?17:45 – What tips would you give to someone who was raised Christian but now doesn’t even believe Jesus existed?31:57 – If my husband were to go through RCIA would he have to do anything else to make our marriage sacramental?33:58 – Is it plausible to say that St. Ignatius of Antioch’s famous quote on ‘the is the Catholic Church’ a reference to Peter being bishop of Antioch?45:26 – Why are the letters of St. Paul so confusing regarding grace and law?…
Questions Covered: 14:32 – Is it okay to use a protestant kids comic book Bible for my Catholic kids? 18:30 – can Mark talk more about his program for middle schoolers and how Fr. Peter could adapt it for his family catechesis program? 21:50 – how to teach kids reverence in the church? 36:28 – My nephew is in public middle school, how can I help his parents teach him about sexuality and what the bible says about it when the school is teaching things opposed to Catholicism. …
Questions Covered: 06:08 – I heard the Pope is allowing the blessings of same sex marriages, what does this mean?12:15 – What does the term “son of man” mean?17:52 – Do you have your family in heaven?22:30 – How does the Catholic Church feel about abortion if a severely mentally/intellectually disabled person were to become?28:40 – If God is all-powerful AND all loving hell shouldn’t exist in the first place.32:00 – How do you know if the Bible is true or not?34:26 – I was sent a website called “OurLadyisGod.com” — have you heard of this website? How do i rebuttal this?37:40 – I have heard that some Catholics don’t believe St. Juan Diego was a real person, based on historical evidence, what is the Catholic perspective of this?48:59 – If Jesus is on the right hand of God, what is on the left side?50:21 – Can Joe talk more about the doctrine about no salvation outside of the church? …
Questions Covered: 37:07 What’s the difference from myself as a Baptized Catholic to someone who isn’t Catholic, but living a similar type of life?…
Questions Covered:06:09 – Why should we care about the Filioque? 15:38 – What is the Kingdom of God mentioned in the bible? 20:43 – How do we make sense of freewill when we die? 29:24 – Where does Limbo and purgatory fall especially when looking at the time before Jesus? 43:05 – How authentic is the Letter of Pilate to Tiberius? 51:06 – . Julie… Rochester, MN… I’m a cradle Catholic and I have a two-part question about baptism: I’ve had relatives who wished to have their children baptized by a priest, but the priest denied them because of their living situations and lack of practicing their faith themselves. I understand that any Christian baptism is valid as long as proper form is used, so these relatives likely could have gone to another Christian church and had their children baptized and it would have been seen as valid by the Catholic Church. So what is the reasoning for just not baptizing the children in the Catholic Church as requested, when other baptisms would be considered equally valid? It seems that the other Christian churches are more willing to offer the grace to the innocent child. Also, in the Catholic Church, holy water is used for baptism. This is not available in other Christian churches, and often not available in emergency situations either, so I’m having difficulty seeing those baptisms as equally valid. …
Questions Covered:07:13 – Which pope introduced the Assumption of Mary?13:12 – How should we read Genesis? Should we take it literally?24:40 – Does a confessor have to confess the number and kind of sin?34:41 – Does calling the Holy Spirit a demon make one commit the sin against the Holy Spirit?43:12 – Do children lost due to miscarriage, end up in Limbo?…
Questions Covered:01:38 – If we receive the Holy Spirit and He’s supposed to guide us, then why don’t all Christians arrive at the same conclusions?16:40 – Question from a Muslim friend, If God is unchanging in his nature how can Christians claim that their God is unchanging when the second person became man?22:05 – How did infants have original sin forgiven before the covenant with Jesus?30:13 – Can you help me understand purgatory and where we see it in the bible?47:55 – What does the Catholic Church do to a bishop after they are let go from they’re duty? Do the Just gland pick up any job?50:55 – Is the baptism of John different from Catholic baptism?…
Questions Covered:16:55 – How come it seems like any sin is forgivable but no accountability for repeat offenders?40:30 – The few infallible teachings were about Mary. Why did the Church decide to declare those teachings at that time?52:45 – I’m on fire for learning more about Catholicism and I need some guidance. I can’t get enough…
Questions Covered:03:32 – I’m protestant looking into the Church. Does a protestant have to redo salvation?13:22 – Some people use scripture to denigrate Jews. What does the Church say about this?24:48 – Rev 19:16 says Jesus will return on a horse with a name inscribed on him. Does this mean that animals are in heaven and that tattoos are acceptable?31:45 – What does the Church teach about illegitimate children?34:38 – Does it make the pope a heretic for praising Martin Luther?37:31 – Do we believe in the antichrist as a person?41:43 – Why don’t you talk about the Palestinian people?49:55 – I always thought that animals were in heaven. Can you clarify?…
Questions Covered:11:55 – Should I be reading the bible from cover to cover?16:59 – I’m protestant looking into Catholicism. What is 1 Tim 3? How come priests can’t be married?21:01 – Why does Elijah and Moses appear in the Transfiguration?29:31 – A Protestant told me that Catholics worship the same God as Islam. How do I respond?34:36 – Is there anything that supports the idea of cultural Catholicism? Saying if the culture doesn’t accept it, then the Church shouldn’t enforce it. Does the bible accept or reject it?41:28 – The Gospel of Matthew says that Jesus condemns divorce except for the case of unchastity. What is that?44:06 – I’ve been grappling with the issue of women’s silence in the church, as mentioned in 1 Corinthians 14:34-35. Could you help me understand why it states that women should remain silent in the church and ask their questions to their husbands? I have read so many articles and watched videos but didn’t satisfy.47:19 – You said a person cannot divorce, remarry and receive communion. Is this true? Did I hear you correctly?49:39 – Was St. Dismas the first saint in heaven? Where were the other souls of the Old Testament?…
Questions Covered:18:54 – Why didn’t Jesus keep the wounds from his scourging?23:05 – Since Jesus has a body in heaven and so does Mary, are we going to have the same bodies purified and cleansed in heaven?43:12 – It makes sense to me that Jesus changed his physical appearance, and they didn’t recognize him. I’m a recovering alcoholic and people didn’t recognize when I became sober.50:50 – 1. Cor 15:28 What does this mean? And how do I respond to people who claim this disproved Jesus divinity?…
09:04 – How can I reconcile Adam, Eve and Evolution?17:05 – What are your thoughts on magnetism, gravity and light? It almost seems like there’s a spiritual element to them that we can’t explain. Good22:27 – Is it plausible to conclude that there must be a God, seeing how inanimate matter cannot create on its own? Good33:36 – Is there an agreed upon definition of science?37:27 – When Jesus said, you will have life more abundantly, do you think he was referring to the future and scientific discovery in the temporal world?44:27 – The Church teaches all humans are persons but there seems to be circumstances where persons don’t exist in humans like, braindead people and zygotes. What are your thoughts on this?52:35 – I’m a homeschooling mom and feel unprepared for the scientific subjects. How can I prepare?…
Questions Covered:02:55 – I disagree with your statement that the apostles did not gain from spreading the gospel.08:22 – How can I defend my new Catholic faith to my Jewish family?16:39 – How do I defend the position that abortion should be illegal?23:56 – Why does our modern biblical text use the Masoretic text instead of the Septuagint which is more apologetic friendly?31:17 – I’m a revert living in the bible belt. How do I share my faith with my non-denominational Christians?37:42 – Why is baptism a prerequisite to confession?48:04 – How would you respond to the claim that euthanasia decreases suffering so it should be allowed…
Questions Covered:05:50 – If a person leaves the Church because they sincerely believe it’s not true, are they still in danger of going to hell?19:53 – Does the fact that the Church grants the title of Doctor of the Church to women contradict 1 Timothy 2:11-12 that talks about women being submissive not being teachers?28:48 – After arguing with ChatGPT trying to make it conclude in belief in Jesus, I came to realize that it was hardwired to oppose it. What are your thoughts on this?41:17 – I’m in college and need to debate if humans are good or bad in class. How do I argue this from free will?49:31 – If a Catholic person doesn’t believe in the real presence would they still be able to receive communion?…
Questions Covered:05:10 – Did the Old Testament permit chattel slavery?11:05 – Regarding your recent Sola Scriptura Debate. Why did it matter that the Jews didn’t know that Isaiah was a part of the canon?13:17 – I’m a little confused about purgatory. What exactly is it for?17:15 – How can we be sure that the Divine Mercy revelation is true?20:41 – If NFP is just as successful as other contraception, how does the Church differentiate the morality of one or the other?24:46 – Was it wrong for Rahab to have lied to the guards?31:44 – How are we supposed to interpret 1 John 5:16-17 in the context of venial and mortal sin?41:30 – Where does motor sport fall into CCC 2290 which states, “Those incur grave guilt who, by drunkenness or a love of speed, endanger their own and others’ safety on the road.”44:19 – If God knew us from the beginning, does this mean that time is not linear but just is?49:38 – What do Catholics believe about Protestants who speak in tongues?52:39 – How would one respond to a non-Catholic who claims we do more than just pray to saints like ask St. Anthony to find lost items or bury a statue of St. Joseph to buy a house?…
Questions Covered:08:16 – In order to become a sacristan, does one also have to be an extraordinary minister on holy communion?12:30 – After the final judgment, will there be procreation?17:56 – How can I gain enough knowledge to defend the Filioque and the papacy from the Orthodox?20:49 – Can you elaborate on the differences between praying to Mary and the saints and contacting the dead?37:08 – How can we not conclude that Genesis 3:18-19 would you support human composting?44:03 – How do you know when you are truly repented of a sin rather than just being afraid of hell?…
Questions Covered:02:02 – The Catholic Church says that no evil thing can enter into heaven. Then how can Satan enter heaven accuse the brethren before God?07:31 – Who can bless people? Can we only bless our children? If someone baptizes their child in a non-emergency situation, would it be valid and would it be a sin?15:27 – My parents are Pentecostal and have recently been asking why we don’t celebrate Easter on Passover or any other Jewish feasts? How should I respond?22:16 – I’ve been meeting with Jehovah’s Witnesses. They claim that the bible says that the name of God (Jehovah) must be used. How do I respond?29:04 – I was arguing with a protestant who said Jesus can’t be sacramentally present in the Eucharist because of Hebrew 9:28. What is the35:28 – Does the Church teach that all truths that are necessary for salvation are found in the bible?43:01 – Are the 3 persons of the Trinity co-equal?47:54 – What if a person baptized a child without the knowledge that they weren’t supposed to? Is that sinful?51:16 – I disagree with your comment that God did away with the law…
Questions Covered:03:41 – This YouTube user’s main stumbling block to Catholicism was Divine Hiddenness. Why doesn’t God show himself to us?15:36 – My son is scrupulous. If my son is in a state of mortal sin but desires to go to confession and suddenly dies, what is the disposition of his soul?20:12 – Hypothetical Question: Would lay people be able to offer the sacraments if there were no more clergy?25:09 – CCC 83 says sacred tradition needs to be of apostolic origin. Why isn’t there a consensus on the number of sacraments?44:30 – Is the essence of the Trinity the first person of the trinity, the Father?50:22 – My husband says he doesn’t believe in the Catholic Church anymore. Is he committing a mortal sin if he continues to receive communion?…
Questions Covered:20:17 – Is there a correlation between couples not using birth control and the success in raising catholic children?21:55 – I am Catholic, but my husband is Protestant. I find it hard to bring the Faith, especially the Rosary, in our household in ways that are non-threatening to my spouse. Any advice for parents in this situation?33:11 – What can we do for the the 85% of kids who are raised Catholic who don’t practice?46:00 – What advice do you have for grandparents for their children’s children?50:19 – My wife is Catholic but has a superficial faith. How can I approach her about this without pushing her away?…
Questions Covered: 04:57 – Can you explain the speaking of tongue references in Acts 2? 14:17 – Why don’t Catholics need to receive the body and blood at the same time? 20:13 – When someone receive absolution at confession, is there ever a need to do additional penance above what the priest asks? 31:13 – When God said he is a jealous God what does He mean? 34:45 – Why would we need our body after second resurrection references in CCC 1059? 39:49 – Can you explain the option of internal forum for a Catholic who was denied annulment? 43:08 – Is there anything we are encouraged to do for St. Catherine of Siena’s feast day? 45:13 – When Catholics discuss things with Muslim, should we mention the personal life of Mohamed? 47:06 – Hypothetically, if a Catholic priest was elected in the next election, would he have to be laicized to take office? 50:00 – Is there any place in the bible that mentions the existence of Dinosaurs? 51:05 – What is the maximum age for a man to become a priest? …
Questions Covered:11:43 – Does it matter what the image we pray to is since we don’t pray to the actual image?16:42 – What’s the point of Marian Consecration?20:05 – What’s the point of the repetitive nature of the rosary and the hail holy queen prayer?31:23 – How would you clear up a misconception that Mary is competing with our natural mothers?34:54 – If the bible is not scientific then can’t we say that Mary’s virginity is not scientific? Wouldn’t Marian consecration be a validation of that?…
Questions Covered:22:27 – Do you focus on how liberalism affects sexual ethics only or economics etc in your new book?28:55 – What is your opinion on how much social media and the availability of information has played into this confusion?32:14 – Was there a meeting at the Kennedy compound where pro-abortion politicians were given a roadmap to set their agenda?45:09 – Why doesn’t the USCCB have an official position on Methotrexate, the chemical used in abortion?49:50 – How do you address questions in regard to the opposite of progressive Catholicism?…
Questions Covered:02:49 – Does the death of Joseph elevate Jesus as the king and Mary as the queen mother? 11:18 – Regarding the story of the woman caught in adultery. Why is it included in the gospel of John in bibles but not others? 19:35 – If Adam and Eve did not disobey, would Jesus have ever come? 28:46 – I was asked: Were the 3 wisemen following the star of the devil? And Michael the Archangel isn’t what Catholics think he is. I didn’t know how to respond. How can I reply? 41:20 – How can we avoid heresy especially if you’re not familiar with heresies and Church history? 46:25 – I bought a crystal that might have been used in Chakra. I wanted to gift it to my dad since he’s a rock collector. Is it spiritually dangerous to possess this? 49:40 – Did Adam know of the fruit he was eating? How did the world come to be populated if there were only 2 people?…
Questions Covered:03:52 – What does true humility look like and what does one have to do to attain it?06:35 – If a bishop is removed from a diocese as the bishop, why do they retain the title of bishop?11:24 – Why was Mary’s title changed from lowly handmaid to lowly servant?14:21 – I wrote a syllogism on God that led me to the logical conclusion of pantheism. Can you tell me where I went wrong?20:42 – Do you have advice for someone who wants a spiritual director but will be moving soon?24:09 – As a Catholic, can I just pray to Jesus?29:33 – When did the Church start to implement annulments?34:56 – Does Jesus in heaven still have the wounds from the crucifixion?39:58 – What do you think of the Independent Catholic Movement?41:38 – I’m in RCIA and have been struggling with early term abortion. Why is it bad and why do we believe that a soul is infused to an embryo?47:56 – Fr. Paul led my RCIA class 32 years ago. I just want to say hello.49:57 – What is the Church’s belief on who the whore of Babylon is?52:09 – Is a livestream of Eucharistic adoration a valid form of adoration?…
Questions Covered:03:28 – If Joseph was the heir to the throne of David, then why did he marry a virgin?13:36 – Follow up on the Rev. 12 Question: I was always told that the Church was born when the side of Jesus was pierced. What are your thoughts on this and Mary’s participation in that?18:00 – Did Mary have other children?24:41 – St. Alphonsus Liguori’s prayers on Mary are a stumbling block for me. I’m a protestant.40:10 – How do we respond to the question: “Why don’t we pray directly to God?47:00 – I’m a recent convert. Regarding Saint relics. Who decides who gets what relic?50:15 – Can the Saint and Mary read our minds?…
Questions Covered:16:33 – Why is it that many Catholics nowadays idolize her through statues or images?34:39 – Rev. 12 refers to Mary’s assumption how then do we reconcile her being sinless and this account claims she had birth pains?43:33 – Catholics worship Mary in Mexico. What are your thoughts on that?…
Questions Covered:12:44 – I’ve been feeling a pull to the TLM. Why do they have animosity toward the Divine Mercy?23:09 – How can you figure out what you need to believe as a Catholic?29:22 – Regarding Tims article on unconditional election. Can you clarify what you meant with your “If God calls first” line?44:31 – I go to a Baptist university. What is my role in correcting professors?51:40 – What did Mary do to deserve to be the Mother of God?…
Questions Covered:18:14 – The Jewish nation ruled under Maccabees were friends with the Romans. What happened that led the Romans to conquer the Jews?22:31 – How do I approach my teenage kids about the Eucharist?32:48 – Regarding Plenary Indulgences, what is attachment to sin?37:20 – Can we show from the bible that baptism apart from confirmation imparts the Holy Spirit? Are Act 2:38, Acts 6:18 evidence of this?43:32 – Why do so many bishops believe that Fiducia Supplicans allow blessings of irregular unions when it clearly doesn’t?52:20 – During the Council of Ephesus, Philip made claims about Peter. Where do we find statements like that in the Early Church?…
Questions Covered:14:29 – Why do Catholics have a conversion to believing in the teachings while people who convert to Protestant faiths convert it through no longer drinking, doing drugs, etc.? 29:41 – Should I be sharing my testimony? 37:47 – I want to learn how to be an incredible evangelist like you. How do I do that? 47:48 – How do I find ways to engage more black people in the Church and bringing them to the faith? …
Questions Covered:17:25 – I feel like I don’t have enough time with 6 kids.46:57 – I bought your book and helped me.…
Questions Covered:03:06 – How do you rebut James Sterba’s new logical argument from evil?07:49 – Do you have any resources I could use when returning to the Catholic faith? I feel like I have a heart of stone?14:19 – How would we prove apostolic succession?21:22 – What is a good approach to Catholic dating? Could there ever be a Catholic version of shows like the Bachelor?28:51 – Was Jesus’s death really a sacrifice if he knew he was going to come back from the dead?31:01 – Mt 27: around 51-52 says that people came out of their tombs and were walking around. How do we make sense of this?33:35 – If we minimize the risk, would it be morally good to bring back dinosaurs?39:50 – Do you ever smoke your pipe during prayer. If so, would this make your pipe a sacramental?44:35 – Jn 19:25-27 refers to Mary and her sisters. Who were these sisters of Mary?49:16 – What’s the status of the adoption of lay ministry of acolytes and lectors in the US?52:15 – If Jesus and the Holy Spirit gave authority to the apostles to heal. Who else had this gift?…
Questions Covered:24:44 – I’m a doctor and want to give some insight as well.32:12 – Could you explain more what you mean by sadness if the soul?47:30 – Could you offer more resources?…
Topics Covered:3:00 – Mar Mari Emmanuel attacked19:30 – Dignitas Infinita document released by the Vatican written by Cardinal Fernandez. Plus, CNN’s comments.…
Topics Covered:4:45 – Bill Maher’s accepting that abortion is murder34:40 – National Public Radio (NPR) is biased…
Questions Covered:03:42 – How would I respond to my children if they grow up and ask why I never gave them the choice to be Catholic when I baptized them as babies?16:12 – I believe life existed before Adam and Eve. Did those animals experience pain and fear? If so, how is that possible before the fall?28:30 – As a Catholic I’m curious why we are allowed to have statues and painting when it says not to make any idol or icon.35:05 – Is confession valid if you don’t receive a penance?40:05 – If you can’t fast to the point of harming your body, what do we make of Catherine of Siena? How do we balance these extreme examples?46:23 – Is using cannabis medicinally a sin?…
Questions Covered:03:56 – I’m considering Catholicism from a protestant background. How do I defend against sola scriptura when their objection is that the declarations of the Church mean nothing?16:08 – What did Jesus really mean when we said that no one knows the day and the hour?23:49 – How can redemptive suffering be necessary for God’s plan?43:45 – What is the role of Catholics individually interpreting Church history?50:32 – How do I explain what the mass is to my non-Catholic friends?…
Questions Covered:22:13 – Because theology develops over time and is impacted by culture, how does this affect morality since morality can’t change?47:55 – Doesn’t Isaiah claim that the earth was a globe? When was this discovered?…
Questions Covered:03:45 – Given the Church doesn’t have a set view on Zionism, how far can go in saying that the entire region belongs to Israel?06:50 – Would it be morally wrong to avoid paying tax when you can?14:45 – My fiancé went through RCIA but didn’t convert because he can’t get past the belief in the real presence of the eucharist. What advice Can you give?17:18 – I was told that I received communion incorrectly by smiling. Is this true?21:25 – When Jesus was tempted in the desert, was he actually tempted to fall into sin?31:14 – When you take the Eucharist to the homebound, does it have to go directly to them, or can you wait overnight?37:36 – I’m trying to figure out where I belong in religion, but I don’t know the difference between being Christian and Catholic.45:29 – How does a priest deal with loneliness?50:23 – Is it ethical for me to work at a non-Catholic dental office?52:55 – Is there an indulgence gained using holy water? Is it ok to do work around the house on Sundays?…
Questions Covered:07:21 – Does your guardian angel leave you when you die12:21 – What are some good research tools and/or websites for researching paranormal experiences?17:01 – If the priest has an accident (e.g. spills the host and/ or wine such that it’s not salvageable), before, mid, or after consecration, how would this affect the rest of the mass? If the priest would simply consecrate again, would the procedure change if there’s no more host and/ or wine to consecrate?20:28 – Let us make man in our own image? Who is US and OUR? Is this an early indication of the Blessed Trinity?24:39 – Why didn’t the Pharaoh at the time of Moses, being a first born, die during the 10th plague?28:54 – During his trial, why didn’t Jesus try to stand up for himself? Pilate seemed like he would listen.30:52 – 1. What does it mean when the church says that Mary’s virginity remained intact during childbirth? Is this belief Dogma?33:59 – 2. Is it appropriate to worship God in Mary due to Theosis? If in heaven the saints are united to the divine nature in a similar way to Christ’s hypostatic union wouldn’t it be appropriate to worship God in the glorified saints? (I know it’s not appropriate but I just need help understanding the distinctions)36:42 – Is there a definitive teaching (or even different schools of speculation) on whether or not your guardian angel is specifically assigned only to you (that is, the GA only ever served as a guardian for you) or do they get different assignments when their guardees die? (Asked another way, are there the same number of guardians as there have been/will be human beings; or do the guardians guard different folks throughout their “careers”?)41:56 – At what point in attending an illicit or invalid Mass should the laity speak up or choose not to receive communion?46:26 – If God doesn’t change (the “God is simple argument”), how does that square with Jesus gaining a human nature?47:54 – I have heard people say that the hats that Bishop’s wear symbolize their authority. Can you please expand on this?48:45 – What does it mean that the disciples didn’t know Jesus till the breaking of the bread51:32 – Can any parameter of creation be infinite?52:26 – In what sense do unicorns “exist” ? (or any other fantasy idea like orcs or dragons)53:36 – I have a hard time learning languages. I get the principles, but the memorization of endings gets me. I am better at reading and working it out than listening and translating by hearing. I desperately want to learn Greek for purposes of studying the Bible. What program, book, software, class, etc. would you recommend someone like me look at to learn Biblical Greek?…
Questions Covered:03:32 – Do we know anything about the families of Apostles other than Peter, who had a mother-in-law? Which ones were married, who had children, etc.? 07:19 – I’m curious about John 10:18 where Jesus talks about having the power to lay down his life and take it up again. Does this mean he could have chosen to die right then, or could it suggest that he had the option to remain on the cross longer before choosing to die? 11:36 – What sacraments can angels administer? I’ve heard stories of angels administering holy communion and even heard once of an angel hearing confession. And it made me wonder if there has been any other sacraments they’ve been known to administer? 15:30 – Is experiencing deja vu the intersection of your current timeline with another? 20:52 – What’s the best answer that I can give my dad about why people who are members Opus Dei scourge themselves as a form of penance? He seems to think it’s not biblical. 29:19 – Was it when Judas received the sacrament of the Eucharist that the devil entered into his soul due to the state it was in? 33:46 – Would conjoined twins be able to be married in the Church? 40:24 – Someone told me that if you add regular water to a small bit of holy water the blessing is transferred and the holy water bottle can be filled in this way as long as you don’t let it run out. Is this true? 43:41 – How would you respond to someone who says that they’re doing just fine without God and they see no reason to acknowledge Him or follow Him? 47:12 – Could you go over the meaning of “Transubstantiation” and what to say and not say in the Sacrament of Reconciliation? If you like I can explain further. 52:41 – Wouldn’t these verses from Mark 7 demonstrate that if Mary had other children, Jesus would not have given her to John to care for? …
Questions Covered:07:40 – Were the books written in the Catholic bible with women’s names, were they written by women?11:56 – Can the unforgivable sin be committed in thought and can a person lose the Holy Spirit?14:36 – When praying the Divine Mercy I have a hard time praying for really bad sinners. What’s your advice?20:39 – What is the difference between a holy day of obligation and a solemnity?22:41 – What are the different levels of hell and why? Thank you.30:21 – The Council of Jerusalem of 1672 was accepted by the Eastern Orthodox. The common Catholic claim against Orthodoxy is that they haven’t had an ecumenical council. How do we reconcile these two facts?33:27 – What’s the official teaching regarding organ transplants? Will i have a connection in heaven to my organ donor?40:42 -How do you respond to the claim that you don’t need a Church for Salvation?47:01 – Was William Tindale killed by Catholics for translating the bible into English?51:40 – Is it okay for Catholics to go up during communion to receive a blessing? Fiducia Supplicans seems to indicate that it is not the proper time for it.…
Questions Covered:46:09 – Were any of these women in the 19th/20th century worried about the word man used in scripture and their role as religious?…
Questions Covered:06:21 – I’m a United Methodist minister. What more resources do you recommend in my exploration of Catholicism?20:01 – Surely God hears the prayers and offers signs to people outside of Christianity. How do we make sense of these signs that might offer people in their faith outside of Christ?31:01 – What do Catholics believe in what’s going to get them into heaven? I’m Catholic, but some say it’s good works; but I keep saying it’s through Jesus Christ37:11 – My Catholic cousin is not going to get married in a church. Can I attend?45:37 – I’m reading a book that claims that the Catholic doctrine of atonement has changed since Trent to Vatican II. Is this true?51:43 – You mention a lot the appeal to natural law. Why should we live according to our nature?…
Questions Covered:16:57 – Is Pope Damasus decree on the canon a forgery?19:14 – What is the Catholic opinion on protestant ministers being called to ministry?34:34 – CCC 2372 says the government has a right to intervene in marriage. What does this mean?47:51 – Did any of the doctors of the Church talk about the rapture?…
Questions Covered:02:25 – What’s the order of the hierarchy, pope, cardinal, bishop etc.?08:35 – How would oral or mechanical stimulation be morally ethical in leading up to the conjugal act?17:55 – In what circumstance does suicide become a venial sin and not a mortal sin?22:49 – What does it take to be an apologist?31:12 – When did cremation become okay in the Church?40:30 – When is superstition wrong?46:04 – What’s the difference between modern Roman Catholicism and early Roman Catholicism?52:27 – How can we defend the idea that the Early Church fathers were Catholic bishops? Resources Mentioned:Fr. Hugh Barbour, “Sex After Marriage,” CAL episode from 4/23/2018…
Questions Covered:14:15 – Beside the ones mentioned in the bible, how much evidence do we find of the apostles preaching the resurrection?21:43 – What’s the meaning of John 20:4; John outran Peter?28:30 – All of Catholic traditions contradict the Bible34:03 – What’s the best argument against Islam?44:14 – How does the Catholic make sense of the First and Second Great Awakening?51:55 – What’s the order of the hierarchy, pope, cardinal, bishop etc.?…
In this episode of the game show, Chet, from Houston Texas and Chuck from Illinois go head-to-head and test their apologetical knowledge! …
Questions Covered:03:24 – Did God ordain that women cannot be priests?07:22 – Is there other meaning of “baptism” other than immersion?15:04 – When God created the first humans, were they already fallen?19:10 – Is it essential to affirm people by their biological identity especially to our youth in Catholic schools?29:15 – Why don’t we baptize children in the womb especially if they are at risk of being miscarried?36:04 – How can I defend the Church’s teaching against Sola Fide?41:48 – Were there more people around when Adam and Eve were around? Resources: Kenneth W. Kemp, “The Science of Adam” first things, Kenneth W. Kemp, “Science, Theology, and Monogenesis,” 2011, American Catholic Philosophical Quarterly, Vol. 85, No. 2, Fr. Nicanor Austriaco, “The Historicity of Adam” and “Defending Adam After Darwin.”49:24 – What does Hebrew 6:4-7 mean in light of going to confession?52:46 – Why is there only one incarnation? Why not the Father and Holy Spirit too?…
Questions Covered:02:59 – In the Old Testament God comes across as angry and jealous but in the New Testament he seems kinder and more merciful. Does he grow or what’s the explanation?10:20 – Regarding the promises of the rosary and being delivered from purgatory. Does this mean that you will skip purgatory if you pray the rosary devoutly?14:15 – How can I spread faith at my high school?23:02 – I’m in Costa Rica and when I went to Mass the priest didn’t know what to do when I went up for a blessing and shoved the host into my mouth. I don’t know how to react to this.29:10 – I’m protestant. How can I make sense of redemptive suffering?…
Questions Covered:03:39 – If confirmation is supposed to be like Pentecost then how come we don’t go out like the apostles?08:10 – Rom 5:12 said death entered because of sin but if evolution is how God created everything which included death, how do we square that?14:46 – My 7th grade students wanted to know if the children of Adam and Eve had to have children with their siblings?20:55 – Does the Cyclical Universe Model disprove God?34:59 – What is the Church’s teaching on miscarriage in regard to family planning?41:50 – Is there a distinction in Catholic theology between spirit and soul?45:05 – Why does the word Hosanna translate differently in different bibles?? What’s the proper translation?49:52: I’m a convert. My mother has recently become pagan and has been more combative. Most recently she has become confrontational regarding St. Patrick driving out snakes from Ireland. How should I handle the situation?…
Questions Covered:2:40 – I can appreciate the God works through Catholicism, but I don’t understand when people elevate this one denomination? Organizational and leadership definition instead of spiritually defined.22:57 – I don’t understand the Catholic concept of a “good God.”36:28 – I don’t understand and believe that Original Sin is in the bible and how is Mary not a sinner?42:38 – I don’t understand the distinction between venial and mortal sin. How do we distinguish them in the context of 1 John 5:16?49:58 – Regarding a previous call on abortion. Can you clarify the limited circumstance on abortion?…
Questions Covered:06:16 – I don’t understand the Doctrine of eternal hell?15:26 – I don’t understand how items like holy water and other blessed items work and their effect?20:52 – All scriptural evidence seems to show that our only priest is Jesus. There is no need for other priests.37:18 – Christianity general. How can the murder of the 1st born in Egypt by God be justified?50:09 – Do Catholics need to believe in the doctrine of eternal conscious torment? I believe the Catechism of Trent teaches eternal conscious torment?…
Questions Covered:4:32- How can I explain Marian doctrine to my non- denominational family who believe this is communion with the dead? 12:02 – Why do people get attacked by demons? 18:12 – How can I interpret someone who has passed away appearing or speaking to me in a dream? 21:03 – What is a response to someone who claims I worship a human being in Jesus Christ? 28:30 – How can I share the need to confess to a Priest since it is not in the bible? 34:24 – Can you interpret Jesus’s words to Judas of “Woe to the man…”? 42:32 – Is polygamy the same as adultery? How does this impact the Old Testament? 48:13 – How can I explain to a Protestant why they need the Sacraments? 51:40 – How can I interpret Jeus’s response in Luke 11:27-28 to Mary being called blessed? …
Questions Covered: 04:28 – Did St. Matthew write the Gospel or was it someone who knew him? 11:35 – How should I treat my bulletin that contains the Sunday reading? 14:16 – Can a Baptism be valid if a priest says the prayers mentally or to a deaf audience? 18:28 – How can I respond to a Protestant friend who shared that the trial of the Catholic church is from the devil since God only does good? 31:02 – Where are Christ’s wounds? 36:58 – 1 Corinthians 14:34 says women should remain silent in churches. What does Paul mean by this and has this teaching changed? 45:00 – Can you explain redemptive suffering as stated by St. Faustina’s diary? …
Questions Covered:18:37 – I’ve been a Christian all my life and was just brought into full communion with the Catholic Church last year. I’ve always loved the story of the Prodigal Son but I’ve always been curious of what his brother represents. Is it simply jealousy and pride? Or does he signify something deeper. 29:00 – My spouse is protestant. He doesn’t want the sacrament of confirmation since he thinks it is against scripture, since scripture tells us not to make vows / oaths. He’s hung up on submitting to a Church and all it teaches. Can you help address his concern? 37:17 – Thanks for offering this again! I’m always cooking dinner when the show is live and never have free hands to call in. I have a question about the myth that most Catholic Holidays are based on Pagan holidays. I know from listening to Shameless Popery that Christmas is not on December 25 because of other pagan holidays, but it’s hard to convince other Catholics this, because many reputable Catholic sources feed this myth. For example, the St. Joseph’s Sunday Missal has a blurb in the Liturgy section stating that the date was chosen in part because of pagan winter solstice festivals. If the early Christians were so adamant at separating themselves from the pagans, why is there so much disagreement among reputable Catholic sources? 46:45 – When praying the Luminous mysteries, I have difficulty on what to meditate on with the Kingdom of God decade. 50:44 – Will all our sins be revealed to the whole world at the general judgement, including those that have been forgiven ? We’re trying to reconcile Luke 8: (For there is nothing hidden that will not be disclosed, and nothing concealed that will not be known or brought out into the open) and Hebrews 8:12 (For I will forgive their wickedness and will remember their sins no more) 52:06 – Can some early Christian writings that did not make the canon, such as the Shepherd of Hermas, be regarded as approved private revelations, similar to those of Fatima or St. Faustina? 53:12 – “I enjoy listening to Catholic Answers as often as I can and have learned a lot! My Question: In Galatians 2:11-21, Paul confronts/rebukes Peter for refusing to eat with gentiles: “”11 But when Peter came to Antioch, I had to oppose him to his face, for what he did was very wrong.”” If the successor of Peter says, thinks or does something “”very wrong,”” who, when and how is the successor confronted/rebuked or corrected?” …
Questions Covered:14:25 – How did the Vatican end up in Rome, Italy along with the body of 19:19 – How many popes sat on the chair of Peter during the life of St. John the apostle? Are any of their writings to the Church available anywhere?22:42 – I’ve been discussing the sacrifice of the mass with my wife who is protestant, and I told her that we, the regular attendee, are part of the sacrifice – partakers – and how we participate frequently in Christ’s perpetual sacrifice… Could you elaborate for me? It would be great if you could take us all the way from leviticus to the images of the lamb (as sacrificed) in revelation. How are our offerings involved too?37:10 – Does the fact that that Didache does not appear to refer specifically to the Real Presence (only mentions the “Eucharist”) pose a problem for the assertion that the Early Church did actually believe in the Real Presence, since the Didache was one of the earliest surviving documents that we have from the Early Church?46:00 – Where does the Bible say that a book CAN’T be a valid part of the Old Testament unless it’s quoted from in the New Testament? (this Protestant line of reasoning seems like a “Tradition of Men” to me.)51:40 – I know we have the lineage of the Popes documented but the succession of bishops isn’t as well recorded – how can we know that certain branches of bishops are within succession? And if a bishop went off the rails went about those he ordained?…
Fr. Paul Check joins Cy Kellett to discuss the mental sufferings of our Lord on this encore episode of Catholic Answers Live.…
Questions Covered:03:05 – Given Jesus is timeless, did Jesus have a body before his birth?10:21 – What is the Catholic view on how to remain saved after initial justification?15:08 – What can I expect from my first Latin mass? How different will it be?18:36 – With the red heifers and altars being constructed, what details do we look for to know we are in the end times?23:24 – If someone disagrees with infallible teaching, what do they need to do to return? Just change their mind or go to confession?31:54 – Has your study of the paranormal strengthened your faith? What’s the best way to pursue the paranormal?37:46 – Can a Catholic receive a valid absolution if they reject the teaching on contraception? Do I have a duty to stop my close family from sinning even if they tell me to let them be?46:40 – How do I respond when someone says that the pope is the antichrist?50:31 – Has the Church had anything to say or teach on the jinn in Islam?…
Questions Covered:04:38 – How do you rebut the soteriological argument from evil?10:00 – Why did God choose the category of God to reveal himself to the nation of Israel given that all the other gods are different in nature than him?15:48 – Should the characters in Tobit be seen as fictional?17:44 – How can we respond to a Mormon or unitarian that claims that John’s gospel says Jesus has the same power and authority as the Father but not one in essence?20:47 – How could I respond to Orthodox people who justify their allowing of remarriage?24:33 – There are people in the OT who weren’t Jewish such as Job, what was their religion?30:02 – Jesus speaks about the way to salvation being narrow and damnation being wide. How do we make sense of this?36:08 – If you went back in time, could you pray for yourself so you won’t commit a sin?40:24 – Why did the Church change the terminology for the Good Friday Service from “Veneration” to “Adoration” of the holy cross? Isn’t adoration reserved from God alone?43:28 – I’m in RCIA. I had my first confession but I think I committed another sin. I’m having a hard time finding another confession time. Should I move forward in receiving the sacraments?48:20 – Is there any evidence where Judas went or if he met up with Jesus after his death?…
Questions Covered:03:11 – Why is there a personal judgment and a general judgment? Doesn’t that seem redundant? 13:29 – Have any credible remote viewers ever tried to remote view heaven? 23:15 – How does our doctrine of inspiration interact with 1 Cor 7:29-31? In that passage, Paul seems to assert to his original audience that the end of history was near upon them, and gives them advice which only makes sense in that context. Paul seems to change his mind later on (in other letters). But in that spot, it really seems like an assertion which is untrue. But I say this, brothers: the time is shortened, that from now on even those who have wives should be as if they do not have wives, 30 and those who weep as if they do not weep, and those who rejoice as if they do not rejoice, and those who buy as if they do not possess 31 and those who make use of the world as if they do not make full use of it. For the present form of this world is passing away. 36:57 – How can parishes do better at helping those who don’t drive attend Mass? Or help those would are considering joining the church and don’t drive. 40:38 – What is the reason behind why the Gospel of Mark has both a short ending and a long ending? 46:30 – Which Bible translation is the most faithful to the original languages? 51:40 – Loving and liking are different. We know that in heaven we will love everyone the same. Does this mean that we are still going to have people that are closer to us, people that have a special bond? Or will those relationships become the same in the sense that there are no persons that have a closer friendship? …
Questions Covered:05:15 – I have a photo of an object with an inscription and was wondering what it means ( a client had it on the shelf and I’d never seen it, I take it it is Protestant: Along the top of the block of wood from left to right are painted the names: Paul, Irenaeus, Martin, Columba, Luther, Wesley and Branham. In the center is painted “The Seven Church Ages” and at the bottom is the person’s birthdate. Thank you! 13:20 – how are we to respond to Pope Francis saying that Priests can bless same-sex unions? Is it reconcilable with our Catholic faith being we were taught it goes against God’s teachings? 17:38 – What does the Church say regarding the things people find funny? There are some things that we find funny that may be dark, edgy, and slightly irreverent but we have little control over our reflex to laugh or chuckle at such things. If we do find something funny that’s seen as “offensive” from a moral point of view, are we to confess it and try harder in the future to process the bit or joke until we no longer find it amusing? 24:05 – How does a revert get involved in parish life? 28:32 – Can you explain kenosis? I keep hearing a certain strain of Christians abuse Philippians 2:7 to suggest Jesus gave up his divinity. Their reasoning is that Jesus had to sacrifice himself as a man in order to atone for humanity. Can you please debunk this? 2 Therefore, if there is any encouragement in Christ, if any consolation of love, if any fellowship of the Spirit, if any affection and compassion, 2 complete my joy, so that ⌊you are in agreement⌋, having the same love, united in spirit, ⌊having one purpose⌋. 3 Do nothing according to selfish ambition or according to empty conceit, but in humility considering one another better than yourselves, 4 each of you not looking out for your own interests⌋, but also each of you for ⌊the interests of others. 39:06 – I’ve wanted to hear your treatment of the souls of unbaptized children who die before the age of reason. I’ve researched it a fair bit from the 2008 document approved by Pope Benedict, to Servant of God Marcel Van, to alleged quotes by St Bernard of Clairvaux, to other reasons that suggest they go to heaven rather than limbo, but your research & insights would be of interest too. 47:31 – Why was there a bowl of wine/vinegar at the cross? It wouldn’t have been for antiseptic or pain-numbing reasons. What was the reason for it? 49:22 – Have you ever considered doing any Jimmy Akin’s Mysterious World episode on neurodivergence? 52:15 – What are the three secrets of Fatima? Why was one of them never revealed to us? …
Questions Covered: 06:17 – calling on behalf on a friend who is discerning Catholicism– his friend has a question about people in the past paying for indulgences and for people to get out of purgatory?29:14 – discerning Catholicism, he feels open to Catholicism, but his wife is not comfortable with it. What are some basic things he can share with his wife to positively share more about Catholicism with her?49:10 – I have a family member who is not catholic. Is he allowed to receive last rights?…
Questions Covered:04:08 – What do Roman Catholic believe going to heaven is dependent upon?16:14 – What archeological Study Bible should I use if I am trying to become Catholic?19:07 – how does one become a Catholic but avoid a triumphant attitude?29:44 – Non Catholic, parents were Catholic, in her 3rd marriage, wants to become Catholic but doesn’t have anyone to sponsor her in RCIA… how does she navigate this?42:08 – Why is God not held accountable to the same moral standards in relationships as we are?49:39 – Can you explain more about purgatory and how someone can pray for someone else in purgatory?…
Questions Covered:15:07 – If you’re divorced and remarried but your first marriage wasn’t in the Church, can you receive communion?18:46 – While you wait for an annulment, what does it mean to live like brother and sister23:19 – I was married to a non-Catholic and having trouble finding proof of this prior marriage. Only divorced. What can I do to prove it was not a marriage in the Church?30:07 – What does it take to get an annulment?34:13 – I just wanted to say that the advice to give, to go to a priest should also include the deacons. I feel like the deacons were made for this.35:07 – Why don’t they treat casual sex with the same degree as being in a non-Catholic valid marriage?43:34 – What’s the Church’s guidance for those who don’t have a valid marriage and are separated but don’t seek divorce?45:28 – What is the reason for annulments being valid if the couple are married outside of the Church building?…
Questions Covered:08:44 – When dialoguing with a protestant and using the common ground of the bible, where should I go in terms of moving the conversation after a “this is just how i interpret it’ point 5. causes it to stagnate?15:30 – How do you respond to the claim that in order to be Christian one needs to be born again?20:20 – Is there salvation outside the Catholic Church?28:46 – A protestant asked me if using bacon grease breaks the Friday Lenten abstaining from meat?34:40 – How do we defend against claims that the papacy has changed over history? How do we defend doctrines that were introduced later in history?44:56 – How do I respond to people who say that the Catholic Church is the whore of Babylon?52:55 – What’s the difference between abstinence and fasting during lent?…
Questions Covered:02:42 – Some Protestant minister who converts to Catholic church can become priests and stay married. Why isn’t this extended to Deacons? 09:09 – How can I reconcile Holy Days of Obligation and fasting during lent with Mark Chapter 7? 17:05 – I’ve heard the Word became the Son at the incarnation only based on Psalm 2. How can I respond to this? 23:50 – Where is St. Gabriel mentioned in the Bible, what makes him an Archangel? 28:50 – Why is there no video evidence of a miracle? 34:02 – How did the Septuagint get its name? 36:05 – How can I talk to someone who says you don’t need Confession? 40:32 – Why did St. Padre Pio have the stigmata, and did it hurt? 42:13 – Why in the US does we seem to ignore a 1997 Vatican Instruction when it comes to the use of extraordinary minister? 48:17 – What denomination is the Hillsong church and can we attend as Catholics? 50:54 – Is there firm teaching of using they/them pronouns? …
Questions:04:55 – Why shouldn’t we use the pronouns of transpeople, if the Pope consistently does? 14:47 – Why do Protestants use Ephesians 4:11 to say that we don’t need priest? 22:22 – Is going to Confession for the same thing repeatedly pointless? 31:54 – What are your thoughts on increasing reverence by receiving on the tongue and kneeling? 42:55 – How did David become a priest based on the order of Melchizedek? 47:54 – Was the Son of God in biological form or spiritual form prior to the birth of Jesus? 51:56 – Understanding more on the What separates the deuterocanonicals from the rest of the books from the apocrypha? …
Questions Covered:01:43 – What exactly are Catholics bound to follow? letters, encyclicals, ex-cathedra declarations, etc.06:02 – What exactly is the authority carried by the nihil obstat?11:57 – If I believe in everything the Church teaches but I also believe in reincarnation and continual revelation. Can I become Catholic?22:45 – If you have to be in the state of grace to enter heaven, does that mean your last confession is the only one that matters?31:17 – I’m a convert. How can I go about receiving the spiritual benefits of the eucharist if I have a hard time believing in the real presence?37:36 – Are there any writings of papal authority being passed on in the early Church?46:02 – Can you explain the difference between venial and mortal sin?52:11 – Why can’t you go to confession over the phone?…
Questions Covered:02:42 – Why do we have to attend mass on Sunday and who mandated it?10:54 – What is the Church’s teaching regarding Mary as co-redemptrix?15:23 – What is the importance of the woman’s submissive role as laid out in the bible? How can we go about it to make women more comfortable?22:16 – If Jesus is the Prince of Peace, how then can it be moral to carry a firearm? Can we defend ourselves? 28:40 – If the Gospel of John focuses on the body and blood of Jesus, why doesn’t the gospel have the story of the last supper?33:37 – Regarding the statement “there is no salvation outside the Church,” how does the idea of some Protestants and Jews being able to be saved correlate to that phrase? 43:59 – How do I respond to my mother and brother who left the Church due to there being too many ‘man-made traditions’? 48:49 – How do you respond to the claim that Jesus being the bread is just metaphorical like him being a branch or a door?…
Questions Covered:05:01 – How is time experienced in heaven?09:20 – Where do we get the documentation of the fall of the angels since it’s not in the bible?15:00 – How can we say Extra Ecclesiam nulla salus but still say the Orthodox are saved?19:20 – Gal 5:2 says circumcision will be of no value. Will a baby that is circumcised today be of no/less value to Christ?24:28 – Why are we not born with full grace and still affected by original sin?35:14 – Why does God test his people if he knows what the outcome will be?43:37 – Is YHWH the Trinity? Did Christophany happen in the Old Testament; meaning did Jesus appear to people in the Old Testament?49:59 – My granddaughter is not going to be baptized because my son fell away from the Church? Can the baptism of desire be applied to others apart from the parents?…
Questions Covered:02:28 – Yesterday’s Reading regarding Susana. Did Daniel end up marrying her? How were the two elderly men trying to harm Susana proved to be lying based on a tree?06:00 – Is birth control acceptable to prevent a pregnancy if the pregnancy is life threatening for the mother?20:00 – I heard that after Vatican II men were no longer required to be heterosexual to join the priesthood. Is this true?29:29 – In 1 Jn 5:16-17, why are there different versions that describe sins as mortal vs deadly?35:40 – If a person is baptized but not confirmed can they receive confession? How do you harmonize baptism of desire and the declaration from the Ecumenical Council of Florence that no one can be saved outside the church even if they shed blood for Christ?45:55 – Do you consider John Main’s form of meditation compatible with Church teaching?52:16 – You said that men cannot be entered into seminary if they have carnal sins. Homosexuality is not a carnal sin; it is a condition. Can you expound on this?…
Questions Covered:04:05 – Why are Mt 17:21, Mk 9:29 missing from our current bibles? They were in the Douay–Rheims bible.15:47 – What does it mean for all graces to flow through Mary?29:15 – I’m a lapsed Catholic and looking to return. I’m divorced, remarried, and want to receive the sacraments. Am I living in sin?38:03 – How can I help bring a Sedevacantist to the Church?50:15 – Is Melchizedek a Christophany? Is there a difference between “the angel of the Lord” and “An angel of the Lord?”…
Questions Covered:07:08 – What is the significance of St. Clement’s letter being written in the 60s rather than the 90s AD?15:00 – Why would God allow Protestants to have the wrong canon of scripture?23:32 – Were the gospels written to make the roman empire look good and make the Jews look bad?34:25 – Did Jesus descend to hell (hellfire) after he died? If demons are tormented in hell, who is tormenting them?34:25 – How do you reconcile evolution with the creation account?52:46 – I’m becoming Catholic this Easter. Where can I go to better understand the Reformation?…
Questions Covered:13:31 – Where do we see this apostolic and papal succession in the bible?20:02 – When is the pope infallible?28:30 – The Papacy was invented in the Middle Ages. Peter was not the pope. I will not go along with the papacy.36:35 – When Jesus says that he’s praying for Peter, Is this giving him some authority?43:46 – Regarding unbroken succession. How do we make sense of the Avignon papacy?49:29 – How should I reconcile the current pope’s opinions and involvement on the environment issue and the science that opposes his view? Should I just keep my mouth shut? What’s the code of conduct?…
Questions Covered:02:23 – Would the best possible world contain actual concrete infinince?06:22 – Can the human soul possess and animate an object like the video game Five Nights at Freddy?15:56 – Why do protestants say we re-crucify Jesus at the Mass?20:59 – If the devil knew that God was all powerful, why did he rebel against him?24:09 – I offend my brother no matter what I do. I don’t love him. When will I come to love him?29:37 – You don’t need baptism to go to Heaven. If you believe Jesus is the Son of God who died and rose again and you repent…that is your salvation.31:51 – Why do we need priests if Jesus was the final mediator?35:57 – Why do you call yourselves apologists? It sounds like you’re apologizing for the faith.41:20 – How did they come up with the numbering chapter and verse in the bible?48:35 – How does the Jewish view of heaven compare to the Catholic view?53:07 – How will time be experienced after we die?…
Questions Covered:01:31 – Is there anything in the Didache that protestants or Catholics would have a problem with?04:51 – I’m Southern Baptist. What was the reason for Martin Luther removing the seven books from the Old Testament?16:01 – My parish doesn’t do the washing of the feet on Holy Thursday. Are we missing out on an important part of the liturgy?19:14 – What book would you recommend for a new convert to help explain to a protestant family?21:52 – Can you explain the history behind the teaching on usury?28:51 – If Jesus, the Father and Holy Spirit are equal then why does Jesus have to sit at the right hand and have to intercede for us?31:46 – If someone becomes Catholic then becomes Orthodox, can they still be saved, or did they just commit heresy?36:19 – Is it wrong to work for a company that is making something morally compromised? Would I be morally obliged to resign?44:08 – Regarding Simeon’s predictions to Mary, why do we take some of those as metaphorical and others not?50:40 – Are Catholics allowed to attend civil weddings that involve two Catholics?53:04 – Did any of the apostles have any wives or children before following Jesus?…
Questions Covered:03:43 – Does the Church allow the faithful to believe polygenesis?11:51 – How do you respond to the boring hell objection?14:56 – My new pastor uses a lot of incense and I have a severe sensitivity, to the point of getting physically sick. It’s been going on for months and I’m growing in resentment since he is not willing to change. What can I do?22:23 – If time is different in heaven, and I go to heaven, can I intercede for myself?28:30 – If the early Christians came up with a fixed date for Christmas, why does Easter’s date change? Shouldn’t it be fixed too?33:15 – Humane Generis Paragraph 5-6. What does it mean by continual evolution?44:37 – According to Church teaching, when is a revolution necessary or just?51:40 – My grandmother was a Jew woman who became a Messianic Jew. Given our Jewish background am I supposed to continue following the Jewish feasts?…
Questions Covered:06:15 – Where are the Assumption and the Coronation of Mary in the Bible?16:18 – What is an inspired work in the Catholic Church?22:10 – What are the first steps to converting?32:24 – Where do indulgences come from? Am I required to believe in them?45:21 – Why do we pray to Mary?49:46 – I’m a ‘prodigal son’ Catholic. What research do you have on the 18 years that are missing about Jesus in the bible?…
Questions Covered:09:55 – Why is it ok to cut up the bodies of saints and distribute them throughout the world?19:35 – My husband is an example of different ways of coming into the Church.28:42 – The Easter vigil masses look different depending on where you go, diocesan, Dominican etc. Do their Mass services reflect their theology?34:10 – Comment: I wanted to express just how beautiful it is for people to come into the Church during this time.36:03 – Why should someone become Catholic and not Orthodox with so much confusion coming from the Vatican?43:30 – My friend’s daughter is going to RCIA and wants me to be her daughter’s godmother. How best can I explain Catholicism to the Baha’i family?48:05 – I’m being baptized on Easter with a Mormon background. So, are my wife and I no longer going to be married in heaven?…
Questions Covered:02:19 – Do we understand the 2 natures of Jesus the same as the Oriental Orthodox?15:38 – Considering that suicide is a mortal sin, how come we can’t say that they automatically go to hell?23:50 – Were dinosaurs alive when Adam and Eve were created?28:25 – How are things outside of ecumenical councils infallible such as canon law?42:47 – How do you keep your mind from wanting to leave the Church, especially for those who are on the spectrum?49:45 – How do I defend the Immaculate conception if a protestant says that Luke 1:28 doesn’t translate to “hail full of grace?”…
Questions Covered:04:11 – If you apply CS Lewis’ Lord, Lunatic, or Liar options to Mohammed, what would you choose? Prophet, Lunatic or Liar?07:02 – Do near death experiences detract from the reality of purgatory?15:06 – What is the earliest record of the Eucharist celebrated after the last supper?19:41 – Where in the bible do we see purgatory? Do Jesus’ words to the good thief disprove purgatory?28:23 – I’ve heard it said that the road to Emmaus account is the first Eucharist. What are your thoughts on this?32:06 – Why is liberation theology a problem?35:19 – Did Judas go to heaven or hell?40:14 – Why does John never name the mother of Jesus?44:53 – Why do we call Mary the blessed Mother if that’s what we call people in the process of being saints?47:32 – Why doesn’t God speak to all of us clearly like he did to David? How do we discern what God is telling us?51:52 – How can we help people in purgatory?…
Questions Covered:02:21 – How do you know when you’re being forgiven if you don’t feel peace after confession?10:10 – Why do we not use the name Jehovah?12:34 – My friend said that during the early Church there were other Christians apart from Catholics? Is this true?15:44 – If a tabernacle is God’s dwelling place and Jesus is no longer in Mary’s tabernacle, can we still call her God Tabernacle? How can Mary hear everyone’s prayers and not be equal to God?22:53 – I’m Protestant. If you miss Mass to go to a Cowboy game and die on the way to the game, is your soul damned just because you were going to the game?36:36 – Can you give a good answer to the accusation that we worship Mary and statues?42:55 – I visited a Pentecostal church and was told that I need to be rebaptized in the name of Jesus. How do I respond?…
Questions Covered:05:59 – How do we refute double predestination?14:42 – What’s the response to the objections that consecrate virgins would make Christ a polygamist since they are his brides?23:06 – My protestant friend claimed that the Catholic Church was founded in the 5th century by Pope Gregory the Great. What’s the response?31:00 – Is the antichrist going to claim that he is the rightful Messiah?35:55 – My brother says that the Eucharist is not the real presence. Can you clarify this teaching?44:41 – I’m protestant. Can purgatory be lessened with words being spoken during last rites?…
Questions Covered:02:02 – How do I defend the deuterocanonical books?05:42 – I’m a convert and my husband is atheist. His main question: If God is good then how did he create suffering?16:19 – If a man has a vasectomy and later repents and goes to confession. Are he and his wife required to abstain from relations indefinitely?20:26 – If a priest blesses a cloud, will it rain holy water?22:04 – Regarding the prophecy of Illumination of conscience at Garabandal. If it comes to pass, will the sins we confessed be washed away from our knowledge?29:22 – What’s the difference between the deuterocanonical and the apocrypha, and how do we defend it?32:20 – Was the Creed the only document that came out of the Nicene council?36:12 – Is it immoral to eat more intelligent animals like dolphins and octopus?37:57 – Is there a reason other than a mortal sin to go to confession?41:36 – I’m a fertility care practitioner. I always advise couples who had vasectomies to not have relations during the woman’s fertile days. Is this morally acceptable to do?47:59 – How does one receive communion in the Church if one is divorced but was never married in the Church?51:48 – Could you help clarify CCC 1650?…
Questions Covered:04:23 – Is it fair to use Hannibal crossing the Alps as a comparison to not being skeptical of the gospels?15:58 – How do we respond to someone who says they are better without God?30:35 – A god that floods an entire planet to kill his creation is not about love. Abrahamic religions are nonsensical.33:55 – Can the canon of scripture be added to?43:52 – How do I tow the line in staying true to the faith without jeopardizing my job in a secular society?50:26 – What are your thoughts on grandparents promoting abortion?…
Questions Covered:08:53 – How do I defend the Catholic position on the Bipartite, tripartite nature of man? I’m in a bible study with a group of protestants and this has been a debate.16:20 – Is it considered living in sin to be a Catholic in name only?20:01 – Where can I find indulgences in the Church?24:31 – If we are forgiven in this life but there is a final judgment where we are judged, how do we square those too?35:00 – Why do Catholics have to go to a priest to have a relationship with God? Especially since the bible says we can go straight to Jesus?43:40 – Where does Our Lady of America stand in the Church?46:09 – What does one do with a physical copy of the liturgy of the hours? Do they have to be discarded or can they be reused?47:54 – I just wanted clarification: Is the only way to God through a priest? Why do Catholics still pay homage to saints?…
Questions Covered:04:20 – How does one do paranormal investigations as a faithful Catholic without getting into the occult?06:14 – Does Gal 5:2 teach that Catholics aren’t saved?12:16 – Why is the canon of scripture closed?16:55 – My daughter is into witchcraft and asked me how transubstantiation is not magic or witchcraft?24:30 – Mat 5:22 What did Jesus mean when he said don’t call anyone Raca?35:55 – If God loves this world & does not want to destroy it, then why is he promising heaven instead of doing something to fix the mess here in this world?37:22 – Are you invoking demons when you debate Satanists?43:30 – My Episcopalian son says he’s Catholic but not Roman Catholic. What does that mean?50:35 – What is the actual name that people used for Jesus? Why don’t we use it?…
Topics Covered:1:00 – Alabama Supreme Court says embryos are humans.19:05 – Manners and generational social norms.41:54 – China’s demographic collapse.…
Topics Covered:03:47 – Romans going back to paganism29:05 – Christian self- immolation46:00 – Alabama Supreme Court says embryos are humans…
Questions Covered:06:22 – I am low income and receive charity from the Church. What is my obligation to give back as an offering to the Church?17:48 – Can Protestant pastors cast out demons?28:44 – How is it possible for a Catholic who has same sex attraction to become a saint given that they are prohibited from having a vocation according to the Church?40:41 – what resources can i give to an 18-year-old to stay Catholic?45:37 – As an obedient Catholic must I fire a freemason who I hired as a contractor? Do I have to limit my interaction with them?49:35 – What does the Church think of books like 3-4 Maccabees and others? Are they Inspired scripture?…
Questions Covered:05:15 – Do we have true contrition of sins if we know we will commit them again?07:35 – How do we share in the divinity of Christ if we don’t become gods ourselves?13:09 – Can I reject some element of the Catholic view of purgatory and still call myself Catholic?17:54 – I’m debating between leaving the Novus Ordo Church and going to a sedevacantist church. What resource can you offer to get me out of this thought?23:05 – How do we know when we are being obedient in the context of Deut. 13:7-12 and Acts 733:16 – How do you know when you are truly connected to God?36:09 – I’ve been trying to get out of debt. Is it advisable to stop giving my donations to the Church? If I take a side job to speed up my debt pay off, can I work on Sundays?44:31 – I’m not Catholic. What are these groups like Jesuits, Benedictines, etc. and how do they all fit under the umbrella of Catholicism?48:10 – My mom is Protestant. What are good scriptural defenses for the papacy?…
Questions Covered:18:07 – How do you encourage schools to share the hard teachings of Catholicism?23:56 – Where does a sense of purpose fit into education?45:06 – How do you handle students who don’t take reverence and church seriously?47:43 – I’m studying to be liberal arts Catholic teacher. How can we balance being away from technology and acting as an Amish versus understanding the need for it?…
Questions Covered:23:28 – Is the goal of the 9-month novena to pray the traditional rosary? Or what order did you have in mind? 34:41 – I just want to thank Cardinal Burke, your leadership and witness make me want to get closer to the Church. 36:14 – I and my entire bible study signed up for the novena. Please keep your friend Paul Nelson in your prayers. 47:31 – I wanted to compliment Cardinal Burke on his great work at the Shrine. 50:00 – Should Our Lady of Fatima’s Miracle of the Sun have a greater impact due to the miracle being a historical moment? …
Questions Covered:04:39 – Does Romans 11:6 nullify the idea of faith and works?08:24 – Why do we genuflect or bow during the Apostles Creed quote “conceived by the Holy Spirit, born of the Virgin Mary?”13:03 – A friend is a recent convert who wants to be a monk. He doesn’t want to get his previous marriage annulled. Would this affect him?18:47 – How does salvation come?20:46 – How do I discern what God wants me to do?28:47 – Is there any truth to the claim of ‘serpent seed? The claim that Satan had children with other humans during the time of Adam and Eve.32:07 – Is it ok for me to go to an Assembly of God church or Pentecostal church if I can’t find a Catholic church?39:55 – Can generational sins be passed on?43:30 – How are protestants saved if they know of the Church and reject it?46:10 – My sister left the Church for Islam. How can I evangelize?49:10 – I’m Anglican. My ex husband became Catholic. If he chose to remarry, what would that look like?…
Questions Covered:13:07 – How do Catholics approach images of Jesus in the Eucharist since it doesn’t actually resemble him?15:50 – How do you answer the claim that Jesus was a proponent of Sola Scriptura because he always quoted the Old Testament?21:54 – What forgives us our sins?34:18 – Given the crusades, indulgences etc. Why should a person join the Catholic Church? I’m protestant and I don’t believe the Catholic Church is good.42:01 – How would you respond to the claim that the Catholics broke away from the Orthodox Church, not the other way around?45:46 – How would you reply to an evangelical who claims that all Catholics should leave the Catholic Church because of the pope’s comments on blessing same sex couples?49:59 – Is it true that a pope can go to hell?…
Questions Covered:01:27 – What does the Church say on the morality and development of AI?6:21 – How can a cemetery be respectfully moved in a situation where they need to move it?16:28 – What’s the difference between an apologist and a theologian?22:07 – Was Jesus going to become man even without the fall?32:36 – Is it permissible to cremate remains after the body has been buried?34:54 – Why do people refer to the Catholic Church as she?41:35 – In the Apostles Creed it says that Jesus descended into hell but it is omitted in the Nicene Creed. Why is that?46:27 – I’m about to start Lutheran confirmation. Why should I stop that and instead enter RCIA?50:10 – I’ve had demonic activity for the last 3 months. I’ve had it blessed. What more can I do since it hasn’t stopped?…
Questions Covered:07:37 – Are annulments valid in the bible?12:42 – Do you know of any saints who teach that prayer and sacraments are the only treatment for depression?16:15 – Why is Caiaphas offended in Mt 25:31?20:29 – How can we present the gospel in a compelling way especially to young men who increasingly lack direction and meaning in the world today?32:12 – How many intentions can you attach to one rosary?39:28 – What do you think is the most important stage of schooling for a Catholic and when should it take place?46:12 – What is required for a Catholic to believe publicly vs privately. Ex. Can a person be pro-life publicly but pro-abortion privately?51:54 – How do you argue against people who say daily communion is bad?…
Questions Covered:11:24 – If you leave the Church due to lack of knowledge, is that sinful?18:45 – After returning to the Church after 5 decades, was it ok for a priest to forgive me from past sins even those that I might not have been aware of?25:06 – Is it licit for the congregation to sing an amen after the gospel?31:30 – How did we get from receiving communion reverently at the altar rail to receive communion in the hand and in line?37:25 – Were Mary and Joseph validly married since they were betrothed? Did Mary die?41:33 – Is it allowed for there to be no music during the preparation of gifts at mass so the congregations can hear the prayers the priest is saying?45:48 – What’s the Catholic perspective on Jn 14:2 regarding eternal security?49:19 – How much historical evidence for the crucifixion is there?53:45 – Is there an obligation to go to your closest parish?…
Questions Covered:17:15 – My daughter has been heavily drinking after her twin brother committed suicide.31:34 – I’ve been in AA for 12 years. How did you move forward with recovery and mix Catholicism with the 12 steps?28:45 – I’m a Catholic and 43 years in recovery. Where can I find your group and help?37:13 – How do I deal with spiritual desolation through addiction?44:42 – I’m in CIR and celebrating 1 year of sobriety today!47:50 – Do you have codependent meetings?49:46 – Do you have meetings for people with food addictions?51:50 – I’ve been in AA for 16 years and have a lust addiction and have not been successful in the latter. How is desperation to quit a grace?…
Questions Covered:05:22 – Why do Christian Zionists evangelicals believe in Israel the way that they do?14:07 – Why didn’t Jesus write the New Testament himself?16:30 – I comes from a materialist background. I struggle with the concept of the soul. What’s the best way to understand it with my background?22:05 – I pray the rosary daily. How do we justify including Mar in the last two glorious mysteries without it feeling like we’re worshiping her?31:19 – When we pray to saints in heaven, they know of the pain and sorrows of earth, how can that be heaven?34:54 – Can the identity of the pope be infallibly known?47:40 – Are angels male and female or just male?49:55 – What is the Church teaching on Mary as Co-Redemptrix?52:10 – What are sins of the heart and of the spirit as said in the 12 year prayer to St. Bridget?…
Questions Covered:06:47 – Are there any independent sources of the murder of the Holy Innocence?12:23 – Should the Saturday vigil mass only be for those who can’t go to mass on Sundays in a strict sense such as paramedics etc.?18:17 – What does it mean to retain sins?31:10 – Regarding the Church’s stance on abortion. What does the Church stand when it comes to rape, incest and the life of the mother?45:35 – How do I respond to my protestant friend who claims the early Church quickly fell into error? His evidence is that in the New Testament Paul was already correcting errors, and that the Old Testament says God’s people are continually falling away.52:30 – Mt.16:24, What did Jesus mean when he said that everyone needed to pick up their cross and follow him if he had not yet been crucified when he said it?…
Questions Covered:03:55 – My cousin is considering leaving Catholicism. What is going on regarding the 7 churches in Revelations? Why do Protestants use this to justify different Churches?14:58 – I’ve lived 52 years as a Lutheran. Why did Luther “water down” the Eucharist and make it less of a pure miracle than it is?29:10 – In the book of John during the trial of Barabas, the Jewish mob says, “His blood be upon us and all our generations.” Is that a legally binding statement?49:32 – How is it that the Church of the Jews suddenly became the Roman Catholic Church of Esau? If the Jews come from Jacob, then how did Catholics come to be of Esau?…
Questions Covered:03:10 – Was the Ethiopian Eunuch responsible for starting a Church in Africa. How would this be possible if he wasn’t a bishop?05:29 – Why don’t angels preach the gospel to humans?08:14 – How would you approach someone who says that Christianity sounds great but sounds unbelievable?17:23 – Could you explain why the Old Testament is reasonable to believe in?40:35 – What’s the best way to explain purgatory to protestants without invoking anger?47:03 – What do you say to the question, if one holds to the old earth creationist view, how could there be death and disease prior to the fall?…
Questions Covered:18:26 – If you get married civilly then divorced, are you married in the eyes of the Church?20:45 – I have a family member who married in the Church and her husband was abusive. She divorced him and now she feels pushed out of the Church. What are her options?24:14 – Is addiction a valid reason for divorce and annulment?31:12 – Is divorce illegal in the Church? Is it punishable by sin?35:12 – My husband divorced me when I became Catholic. I know I can’t remarry but I know some others have. This feels like the Church is inconsistent.42:21 – Under the circumstances where divorce is allowed, would one still need to confess their divorce?45:33 – How do I explain to my stepdaughter that an annulment would not affect the legitimacy of her children?48:55 – I’m on my second marriage. My priest just told me that it’s not valid. What are your thoughts?52:09 – My sibling received an annulment. She hasn’t gone to confession. Do you think it’s important for her to go?…
Questions Covered:02:56 – Hebrew 10 says the blood of bulls and goats can’t take away sin. Why then does Leviticus say that it does?06:00 – I heard that a red heifer was going to be sacrificed in Israel this year for Passover. Is this significant and what is the Church’s opinion of this?14:44 – I’m in RCIA. I’m getting conflicting information. Who wrote the gospels?23:17 – I had a seizure and was placed on meds. I started to hear a voice in my head saying I was going straight to hell. Once I started to pray the rosary, the voice immediately went away. What do you make of this?29:10 – The bible has a lot of reference to demons. Were there a lot more demons during Christ time than ours?32:34 – How do I understand images and apparitions of pain and suffering? I thought there was no more pain and suffering in heaven?35:38 – Is there sometimes when more than one rosary is needed in our possession?40:11 – Why is it that you can EM in one diocese but not another? In the Fatima apparitions it was said that one girl would be in purgatory until the end of time. If we pray for her, can we change that?44:45 – Regarding Daniel 9:24; is Jesus the new temple?49:58 – Why doesn’t CA produce books in mass like Matthew Kelly does? I feel like we are missing out.…
Questions Covered:04:04 – What backs up the claim that revelation ended with the last apostles?9:47 – How do you respond to the problem of angelic hiddenness?12:57 – When God says in Genesis, let us make man in our image, is it a reference to the Trinity?18:40 – Is the Council of Chalcedon an illegitimate council as the Oriental Orthodox claims? If not, what’s the defense?22:49 – Is it okay for Catholics to practice martial arts?28:47 – St. Thomas Aquinas says the fires of purgatory are the same as the fires. How would the soul know whether they are in purgatory or hell?35:34 – What is the oldest manuscript of the bible we have? Is our current translation the most accurate one?40:59 – What are your thoughts on Israel only preterism?47:09 – My college age child is attending a charismatic retreat this weekend. Should we be concerned especially with the tendency to encourage the gifts?52:28 – Was the marriage between Mary and Joseph only a legal marriage and not a sacramental one?…
Questions Covered:04:10 – Is it ok to study religions outside of the Catholic Church?09:49 – Are babies capable of faith even without understanding?14:35 – What happens to people who have never heard of Jesus?19:01 – Is it permissible to take communion at a Protestant church?24:16 – When the Eucharist is broken, a lot of priests elevate the host spreading crumbs everywhere. Is this valid to do?30:00 – I was invited to a neighbor’s second wedding. Could I attend? She’s a divorced baptized Catholic and this ceremony is at a winery.40:41 – What advice would you give to a person who said that they prayed to God, and they didn’t answer so they concluded that he didn’t exist?45:23 – Is there going to be a formal response from the Church now that the former president is calling for a 16-week abortion ban?53:05 – Is receiving communion at another church a mortal sin and should it be confessed?…
Questions Covered:13:05 – What’s the most effective way to fight back against the abortion pills being delivered via mail?17:55 – I’m a college student. It feels like I’m the only pro-lifer in my classes. What do you think I can do without endangering my grade in class?23:35 – I was tricked into taking an abortion pill. Are you familiar with them tricking women into taking a pill for ‘menstrual extraction’?28:30 – What about abortion in the case of ectopic pregnancy? Is that okay?35:05 – How do we know that conception is when the soul gets created? I don’t think it’s from scripture, right? Is it Aquinas? I hear there’s often miscarriages in early pregnancy that don’t even get noticed. So, are all those lost souls?40:14 – Lots of abolition laws have been introduced that include punishing women who had abortions. Where does the Church stand on this?43:40 – Do you think the prolife movement needs to rebrand after the overturning of Roe V Wade?…
Questions Covered:02:43 – When my wife comes to Mass, she goes up to receive a blessing from the priest, but when I go to protestant service with her and do not go up for a blessing, she gets mad– how do I reconcile this? 10:59 – If you go to confession and confess 2/3 mortal sins in the confessional but then die, can those 2 confessed sins be used against you in your judgment? 19:44 – If a married priest becomes a widower, can he then become a Bishop? 21:44 – Which Protestant denominations are Calvinist? 29:28 – Why might a church not have a relic in the Altar? 40:58 – Why do Orthodox believe that we believe the Pope is infallible? 45:41 – If Adam and Eve hadn’t sinned, but a descendant sinned, everyone still have original sin? 48:08 – What is the Catholic evidence for Apostolic succession? …
Questions Covered:03:14 – How many levels of hell are there? 04:57 – Can you help me reconcile these two verses? Sirach 12: 4-7 “give to the devout but do not give to the sinner” and Proverbs 25: 21 11:55 – How does the baptism of infants work when the infant is not capable of understanding? 16:35 – If someone with a mental illness (such as schizophrenia) is struggling with sins of impurity, are they still morally culpable? 20:00 – I converted to Catholicism, if I go to protestant service with my family can I receive the “communion” at their service? 23:27 – Hypothetical question– If a priest were to die during the consecration and only consecrated the body, not the blood, is the transformation still complete? 29:12 – If you are new to the Catholic faith should you wait to start studying apologetics or dive right in? 38:58 – is it okay to support the scouts? 44:32 – How explicit should you get with your sins in confession? 47:40 – How do I explain Christ’s humanity to people who don’t understand Christ was both man and God. 51:33 – if you don’t know you’re committing a sin are you still accountable for that sin? …
Questions Covered:02:18 – How can I stay Catholic with all the changes from Rome?10:21 – Does the appointment of only men imply that women are not called to spread the gospel in the same way men do?14:53 – I heard that whatever you offer up for fasting on Fridays can also be given up.16:16 – I’m concerned about the fewness of the saved. Is it an infallible teaching?21:16 – Would God being perfect be necessary for him to be God?28:57 – Can a Catholic convert to Judaism to be more like Jesus?32:57 – Is there a list of infallible teachings?40:16 – My daughter thinks that creation surprised God and that means that he isn’t all knowing. What is the Church response?44:38 – Why does the Latin Church not use the host and chalice for mass anymore?48:30 – When we talk to someone who isn’t Catholic and they question us, what should we do?52:34 – How do we know what’s divine tradition vs man-made tradition?…
Questions Covered:05:09 – Papal Infallibility bothers me.14:30 – Can you explain Transubstantiation?20:34 – I’m a convert and a former pastor. Can the Church change teaching via ex cathedra?34:12 – If you believe in a God that would send unbaptized babies to hell then I guess we don’t worship the same God.38:28 – I’m a protestant and I want to convert. Why are we asked to give up meat for lent? Why does fish not count as meat?48:40 – Are mortal sins infallibly defined?…
Questions Covered: 06:30 – How can I respond to a protestant friend’s interpretation of Matthew 8:22as it relates to Purgatory? 16:40 – Can the church change the status of a Saint? 20:53 – How does the devil help people in this world? 29:31 – Did Jesus mean that He would see the good thief in Heaven that day or did the thief need to go through Purgatory? 34:26 – What is the teaching about being married in Heaven? 42:33 – Is anyone in Hell? 49:40 – If Heaven is completely good, would Hell need to be completely evil? If so, How could Hell even exist? …
Questions Covered: 10:59 – Is it church teaching that some people will experience heaven to a lesser degree than others? 18:00 – What are some of the last signs before Christ’s second coming? 29:30 – What is the traditional Catholic teaching on the rapture? 42:13 – Can the Antichrist come from within the church? 47:15 – Did the devil know that Jesus was divine when tempting Him? 51:40 – How do I talk to Protestant friend who believe an end time prophecy has been fulfilled? …
Questions Covered:10:50 – If the Eucharist is so important in John, then why isn’t the Last Supper story in the gospel?19:13 – If Jesus can’t commit sin, then why did agree to go with the devil to be tempted?29:20 – How do bishops get their jurisdiction?43:25 – Can you expound on Lumen Gentium and what it teaches on invincible ignorance?54:10 – Is there a 13th chapter to Daniel?…
Questions Covered:04:40 – Does infallibility entail denial of freedom of opinion?18:35 – Since Jesus God, Did Mary worship Jesus as a baby?21:55 – I’m Protestant. How does Mary be “our life, our sweetness and our hope” not conflict with Jesus being our only hope?32:38 – I found a weird rosary that I think could potentially be a satanic rosary. What should I do when I encounter one?44:30 – Does my mental disability affect my Sunday obligation?51:16 – How do priests consecrate the bread n and wine into the body and blood of Christ?…
Questions Covered:04:50 – Was Jesus sacrificed because God got tired of all the animal sacrifices?11:09 – Why do we believe that non-Catholics cannot achieve heaven? Where does it say this in the Catechism?16:13 – Are the groups like Christian Scientists, Salvation Army, Quakers etc. Christians since they don’t baptize?19:02 – Under what circumstances does a non-Catholic have access to the sacraments?22:06 – What does it mean that Mary is the mediatrix of all graces?29:37 – What’s a quick easy response to the question of why we pray the rosary?31:57 – Can you explain the difference between venial and mortal sin?42:07 – What does John mean in 1 John 5:17 when he says to pray for people who have not committed a sin that leads to death but doesn’t say to pray for those who commit a sin that leads to death?52:50 – I didn’t receive proper absolution after confession. He didn’t say the proper words. What do you suggest I do?…
Questions Covered:14:35 – How can I focus and remember not to worry and focus on God?16:51 – My husband was diagnosed with cancer, after reading the book, I decided not to worry and give it up to God?22:49 – How do you tell the difference between worry and natural problem solving as things come up?31:56 – How do you know what God wants you to do when you worry about something?34:16 – I worry about my adult children and their faith. How do I handle that?47:50 – I worry about when the priest changes words during mass.…
Questions Covered:06:34 – Is it permissible for Catholics to attend a gay wedding reception?20:08 – How do you reconcile contradictions in the Old Testaments?28:57 – What forgiveness for abortion is needed? No harm has come to a soul. Souls inhabit at first breath, at inspiration.31:41 – 2. Cor 5:21. How would you explain, “he who had no sin, became sin?”37:43 – How do I answer the question, “How can God exist with all the evil in the world?43:43 – Can a Catholic include the Easter Orthodox Church ever be recognized as another valid denomination?52:02 – Were 4 of the 7 sacraments instituted by the Church and not by Christ?…
Questions Covered:05:41 – How do I explain infant baptism to a Protestant?16:31 – When I go to confession what does it do to my spiritual life when you put it into the context of my mental disability?33:42 – What does imprimatur mean in the Church? Should mystics who have one be taken seriously?42:37 – I work in an environment where swearing is common. How do I go about it especially when they constantly say the Lord’s name in vain?48:40 – What do the different colors of the scapulars mean, particularly the blue one?…
Questions Covered:05:20 – Is it sinful to reuse a train ticket if the conductor did not tag the ticket?16:55 – Is it important to view the New Testament as a liturgical aid?36:47 – How do you respond to the claim that the woman in revelation is the Church not Mary?47:01 – What do you say to someone who says the Catholic Church works on an economic system?…
Questions Covered:08:56 – How can I properly articulate free will to a Calvinist?19:20 – What is the difference between theonomy and theocracy?34:17 – Since Vulcans are logical, what would be the best arguments you would give to convert them to Catholicism?44:43 – What are the jobs of the different types of angels?…
Questions Covered:06:07 – How and when did Jesus know he was God?15:28 – Is James White’s version of how the bible canon came into existence the same as the Catholic view?28:40 – I had an atheist friend use Mt 24:34 to claim that Jesus is a false prophet. How do I respond?41:27 – I’m a convert from Judaism. I was told that even if I didn’t accept Jesus, I would still be good through the old covenants. Is this true? RESOURCE: Salvations is From the Jews48:58 – I’m a convert. Do you have information on popular devotions? I’m new to all of it.…
Questions Covered:09:15 – In the Gospels, at the Last Supper, why do they focus so much on the feet washing?18:19 – How do we NOT evangelize? Resource Mentioned: Seven Deadly Sins of Apologetics34:26 – Did Ananias die because God didn’t want him to sin and be in heaven?43:59 – How can we find out about apparitions?51:02 – Why is apologetics important in the Church?…
Questions Covered:06:47 – How often should I go to confession? I go back and forth between being agnostic and Catholic.17:11 – Can we as Catholics deny the existence of resistant non-believers?23:42 – How many times has papal infallibility been invoked?33:31 – Is it ok for me to just keep the eucharist in my mouth until it dissolves. I’m having jaw surgery and I place it in my mouth and pray for healing till it dissolves.41:10 – Will Protestants be saved?48:05 – Why are we not bound to worship on Saturday like the 10 Commandments?…
Questions Covered:01:04 – Can you clarify why Jesus could not have sinned if he could act as both God and man?05:49 – Will we miss people when we’re in heaven? Would it be irresponsible to have children even if there is a slight chance they’ll go to hell?12:49 – Did Mary have other children?16:00 – Do donations to your parish only count as tithing or does donating to other charitable organizations count too?18:44 – What’s Joe’s favorite mystery of the rosary?21:46 – Do you think we are in the end times? I’m Catholic but I feel like I’ve been born again. All the rules of the Church seem like they are not something Jesus created.38:53 – Dual nature of Jesus. What would Jesus have known about his death?46:15 – Are man and woman acting as priests in the sacrament of marriage? If a priest’s holiness doesn’t matter when acting in his ministry, would something similar apply to a married couple?52:07 – Is there a contradiction between CCC 751 and 779?53:46 – Were head coverings for women common in the early Church? If so, when did it end?…
Questions Covered:04:24 – My protestant friend claims that priestly forgiveness of sins doesn’t have its roots in the apostles. What’s the response?11:31 – Why can’t we eat meat on Fridays during lent?13:46 – Where did the Church come up with the teaching on the Eucharist?19:15 – How would you respond to a critique of the Eucharist? And how he says he is a door, branch and bread all figuratively?31:13 – Why can’t we eat food in Mass?34:33 – How were the sacrifices in the temple not sufficient?40:18 – On Natural law theory. How do you respond to objections to it as an ethical basis for moral logic?48:28 – To what degree am I obligated to defend the Church’s teaching to friends?…
Questions Covered:06:55 – What is the difference between the Melkite and Roman Catholic Church?11:06 – If Jesus did have blood brothers and sisters, how would that be inconsistent with the rest of the Bible?19:45 – What obligation do the rich have to the poor? To what extent are people allowed to have things beyond what they need?28:39 – Does the Catholic Church believe in apparitions? Can apparitions and ghosts be visible to all people? Can they be a human spirit?35:42 – Can a person be married in the Catholic Church without a marriage license?37:33 – Are angels made in the image of God? If so, how can I then answer why God made humans?43:41 – What are the origins of annulments in the Catholic Church? Why are they valid?49:44 – Is it the actual blood of Christ or the act of the passion that was redeemed?52:32 – What’s the teaching on Catholics owning a Jewish Tallit? Are Catholics allowed to wear them?…
Questions Covered:6:30 – What is the Catholic view of the rapture and how can I respond to a Protestant who says it’s the only correct view of the end times? 13:34 – How can I defend Catholicism against Orthodoxy? Specifically, I thought they couldn’t hold councils, but I heard they have. 18:29 – Why does the Church excommunicate people for abortion but not for killing a born person? 24:19 – How would you respond to a person who says that Catholics are equally as divided as Protestants, citing groups like the SSPX? 35:29 – I’ve been told that Catholics shouldn’t play role-playing games like Dungeons & Dragons. Is that true? If not, how should I answer? 46:22 – How can I better explain the Trinity to a Muslim? Specifically, how did all the persons exist before creation and the incarnation? …
Questions Covered:05:15 – Are there impediments to betrothal?06:32 – What is the Church’s stance on technology like Neuro-Link?15:52 – What do you recommend I read for lent along with a St. Louis de Montfort book?19:10 – What is the history of the celebration of the birth of Christ?28:55 – My roommate is a Baptist and told me that he, his mother and aunt have the gift of tongues. What is the Catholic understanding of this?34:43 – My wife and I are not married in the Church. She’s protestant. If she doesn’t want to get our marriage convalidated, would this mean that we would have to continue to live as brother and sister?42:30 – Jacob has his name changed to Israel but the bible continues to refer to him as Jacob. Why is that?44:33 – Is it okay to wear a rosary?48:04 – If you can lose Grace, can you get it back?50:38 – What are your thoughts on transformation and sharing our gifts?…
Questions Covered:03:25 – How do you respond to someone who claims that Mt 6:30-34 offers a false promise?12:15 – I will be invested into the Order of the Holy Sepulchre. There is a possibility that I might be ordered to take action that might cause the deaths of Christians in the Middle East. How do I reconcile these actions?18:12 – To what extent does submission of intellect must we abide to non-infallible teachings such as the death penalty?29:38 – What do you measure oral traditions against to know whether it’s from God or man-made?33:14 – Domestic Church Media… When and how did Jesus become aware of his divinity?40:54 – Are we relieved of our human emotions when we pass to heaven?44:39 – I’m protestant. Do Catholics use the Septuagint or a Hebrew translation with the Deutro-canon?49:26 – How do I approach a loved one who is divorced and remarried without an annulment without pushing her away from the Church? …
Questions Covered:03:38 – What do you think of miraculous testimonies of protestants? Do you think they are saved?11:52 – Is it possible to offer a mass for a deceased Catholic who lived a lukewarm life?14:22 – There have been many private revelations that promise salvation. What’s a prudent way to approach this?18:00 – How do you respond to someone who claims Sola Fide?23:54 – What is the protestant understanding of salvation and how does it compare to Catholicism?34:58 – How does Confirmation fit in with salvation? Do I need to be confirmed?41:09 – Where did baptism come from?45:52 – I’m a Protestant. How does the fact that Catholic leaders are straying away from the Word affect how the Church sees salvation?…
Questions Covered:03:40 – Since Jesus is both God and human, is his human nature also eternal?07:00 – In our baptism we participate in the priesthood of Christ. How is that?15:05 – What’s the Church’s teaching authority on what it takes to be saved?21:16 – If you’re baptized as a baby, then fall away and then want to return, do you have to be rebaptized?31:02 – Where in the New Testament does Paul talk about baptism?35:08 – Is the Mosaic covenant eternal?46:02 – Regarding John’s purpose statement in John 20:31, How does the Church include baptism and repentance into salvation when John doesn’t?…
Questions Covered:03:29 – Did Mary show signs of aging? How is Mary our life, our sweetness and our hope?07:53 – My friend who just converted to Catholicism has become very curious about the SSPX. How do I explain to him what this is?15:50 – What criteria was needed for the canon of scripture. Why Catholic Bibles Are Mas Grande.22:40 – Regarding Romans 9:11, what are the implications for predestination and election?34:10 – Is Mary the reason why we have the Apostles’ Creed? Did She ask the apostles to contribute two lines each or is this just legend?36:49 – What are the ethics of recommending Orthodoxy to my protestant friends who still struggle with Catholicism?42:15 – How do I respond to a protestant who asks if you know you’re saved?48:13 – Could you explain what blessed items are?50:21 – My ex-husband and I don’t have an annulment and he remarried. Can I receive communion?52:50 – How often do you have to go to confession before going up to communion?…
Questions Covered:07:10 – Is it okay as a Catholic to read an Orthodox bible?13:33 – How do we know the relic of the true cross and crown of thrones are authentic?21:13 – How does one start an apologetics conversation?28:38 – Does a priest have to be in a state of grace to administer the sacraments?37:01 – How do I respond to Protestants who claim that it’s more Christian to live like a Jew?48:15 – What does Matthew 10:34 mean when it says that Jesus will be the cause of division. And can you clarify what John means in Mt 11:11 when he says there are others greater than him in the kingdom of heaven?…
Questions Covered:01:31 – Mt 17 when Peter catches the fish with the coin in its mouth, Is there significance to Jesus only paying the temple tax?08:06 – I received a prayer from a priest that seems like it’s saying that we’re justified by works. Can you clarify?15:36 Does hell have infinite suffering?22:12 – My daughter was baptized along with another girl. During the baptism the priest switched the names. Should I be worried?28:29 – Why did Vatican 1 prematurely end? Did any pope ever officially close it?32:22 – How can 1 Cor 11:29 be used to show that the Eucharist is efficacious?40:15 – Are we supposed to understand the resurrection of the dead?43:30 – How do I respond to the people who make a big deal about female lectors and servers?48:26 – In what sense is John the prophet Elijah?50:30 – When Pope John Paul 2 gave the Luminous mystery the structure of the rosary novena changed. What’s the official change on the rosary novena?52:24 – What is the significance of the Assumption of Mary?…
Questions Covered:03:59 – What role does infallibility play in understanding the biblical canon?14:38 – Have there been any kind of clothing that people can wear as married people apart from the wedding ring? Something equivalent to a monk wearing a habit?16:54 – Is it good to learn Latin for God?19:53 – Does cleansing of a passion in purgatory need a body for purification to happen?24:43 – If both Mary and Jesus are present physically in heaven, does that mean that heaven is material?32:34 – What is the Church’s view of 3-4 Maccabees?35:57 – Did the Corinthians believe Paul about the 500 witnesses?46:23 – What book do you recommend about the Eucharist? When was the first Mass celebrated?49:44 – Why is praying to angels not idolatry?52:54 – What prompted the idea that animals don’t have immortal souls?…
Questions Covered:06:46 – When the Divine Worship Missal was revised, why wasn’t the Rite to Mass Options included?14:06 – Could a confession not be forgiven even if a priest absolves you, if you are not repentant?28:48 – How does the Ordinariate handle annulments, evangelization, etc.?32:15 – How are eastern Catholics in communion with Rome if they still honor certain saints who opposed Catholicism?41:55 – Why don’t Catholics need an altar call?46:03 – Would you agree with the statement that the reason many protestant ministers who convert don’t become priests is because bishops are still suspicious of them?…
Questions Covered:40:57 – Do you think the American press does not report about the persecution because they’re happy about it?45:47 – What if our US bishops said we should pray and fast for the African Church?50:14 – I want to thank Matt, he was what got me started on thinking about the Church.…
Questions Covered:02:55 – If you feel spirits in you and feel teleportation, is this obsession, oppression, or possession?17:34 – What’s a clear way to explain form and substance as it relates to the Eucharist?28:55 – Why does the Church hold to the view that the last moment of being in the state of grace is more important if God is outside of time?42:08 – Is it true that we cannot truly love God unless we have the ability to reject him?49:08 – What is the Church response to the epicurean paradox?…
Questions Covered:30:18 – My daughter is going to college. Why should I send her to a Catholic university instead of a state school?32:19 – How are students changing due to woke culture especially in Catholic universities?36:49 – Can you speak to UD’s success in terms of alumni gaining employment after graduating?43:12 – What is your own spiritual tradition?51:12 – I want to get closer to God and I’m interested in studying theology. The university that I’m looking into doesn’t have a program. What do you recommend?…
Questions Covered:03:30 – I divorced after 24 years. He passed away a few years ago. Can I discern marriage?12:00 – How do I discern offering tough love to my children?20:13 – Is it proper to say that Justification is through grace, and obedience to Christ?28:35 – Why is Selah denoted in a few of the psalms? What does it mean?32:15 – Were there any patristic witnesses to the claim that Christ only had knowledge that was pertinent to his mission?40:42 – Does the revelation in Fatima debunk the claim that hell is empty?48:42 – Can you clarify why we believe in free will? This is in the context of talking to a Calvinist.…
Questions Covered:16:33 – What does it mean to discern God’s will?33:05 – I’m 62 with an annulment. I’m dating someone and am considering marriage. How do I discern whether it’s love or lust?40:22 – My 30-year-old son has lost his way. We opened our doors to him, but he is going back down a dark path. How do I discern God’s will in this situation?46:44 – I ‘ve been training to be a “perpetual pilgrim” for the National Eucharistic Revival in the summer. I wasn’t accepted but still have it in my heart to do it. How do I know whether God is calling me to this?…
Questions Covered:03:05 – How are the priest’s hands consecrated? What is done to the hands of an extraordinary minister of holy communion for them to be able to give out communion?14:55 – How do I navigate the situation with my son and his girlfriend who are cohabiting and plan on having a wedding outside the Catholic Church?23:30 – What is the Catholic view of the Tribulation and the Rapture?35:17 – Why do some people think the pope is evil?41:54 – What are your thoughts on praying the Divine Mercy as a personal devotion?48:16 – What made you go from Southern Baptist to Catholic? What resources could you point me to? …
Questions Covered:05:10 – Are the Psalms mandatory like the commandments?08:05 – Today’s reading. How do I reconcile Mary’s authority over Jesus compared to the wedding of Cana?19:34 – My wife and I are converts. Even if convalidation of our marriage isn’t necessary could we still do it as a renewal of vows?29:11 – Could God design the earth with a pre-implemented age into it?32:53 – Does the covenant with Noah disprove the possibility of an apocalyptic event unless the world is ending?36:25 – Is there an official definition of anathema? How do we relate it to ecumenical dialogue?43:59 – My Baptist friend believes that all the early Christian were apostates. How do I respond to this?49:02 – If the Church is meant to evangelize to the end of the earth how, then do I approach my sibling who is transgender? They’ve influenced my nephew to be transgender and I don’t want my child to be influenced?52:35 – Why is the Mass so repetitive and robotic?…
Questions Covered:05:15 – Why did the Church approve the books of the bible that are in it now and reject others?09:10 – If sin brought death into the world, why did dinosaurs and plants die before humans existed?20:02 – Why do Catholics have a relationship with saints?28:50 – Why didn’t God give us a second chance after Adam and Eve?33:25 – Why do Catholics believe Mary was sinless but not Joseph?42:20 – How do we know about the 9 choirs of angels?45:28 – Why do we believe that Mary’s giving birth miraculously? Was her virginity preserved?50:58 – Why do we say “May we merit eternal life” in Mass? How do we understand this?…
Questions Covered:12:52 – Why does the Church believe it can declare canonized saints but not condemn those in hell?20:40 – Why does the Church tell us that we won’t be in heaven body and soul until the last day?29:40 – Why did the Church change the teaching of tithing from 10% to something more general?35:50 – Why do we Catholics pray to Mary and not to Jesus or God?44:20 – Why is a Catholic able to believe that purgatory is either instantaneous or a long process? Is there any evidence for either?50:42 – Why do Catholics not eat meat on Fridays during lent?…
Questions Covered:24:16 – What’s the best way to defend the Church Fathers when they’re accused of being anti-Semetic?30:00 – There is no reason to believe in the Marian dogmas.34:27 – St. Anselm’s writings on universal salvation brought me back to the Church. Are those writings in line with the Church?46:29 – What are your thoughts on challenges to the authenticity of the letters of St. Ignatius of Antioch?…
Questions Covered:05:19 – I want to become Catholic but still live at home and my parents are opposed to this decision. What tips do you have for me?17:14 – What do you say to people who use Church history for not believing in God? Ex. Saying Nazis and Fascists were Catholics?28:28 – I’m a sidewalk counselor. Whenever I mention Mary people begin attacking me. How do I approach this subject?34:44 – How would you respond to the claim of Eternal Security while using 1 Jn 5:13 and Mt 7:23 as evidence for it?42:55 – How is purgatory good news?48:20 – How do I address the sex scandal to a friend who constantly brings it up as a dig towards the faith?…
Questions Covered:03:34 – What’s the scriptural proof for purgatory?08:39 – Can you bless God?12:23 – What does it mean to be made in the image and likeness of God? Are aliens also made in his image?18:39 – My friend who survived the Bosnian war in the 90’s said she will never become Catholic because the Catholic and Orthodox Churches influenced the war. How do I respond to this?24:30 – Is wearing Nikes a sin because the name comes from a pagan goddess?30:43 – What is the difference between the gift of prophecy and words of knowledge? Does bone broth break a Friday meat fast?41:00 – Luke described the baby Jesus swaddled and hands and feet tied. Is this imagery of the crucifixion?45:03 – My husband is a convert and just joined the Knights of Columbus. I don’t know anything about them. Can you explain?49:39 – What do we know about the state of the soul of a person entering dementia, and losing mental faculties etc.? What can they do to go to heaven?…
Questions Covered:04:17 – Why would God allow sexual slavery as mentioned in Deut. 21:10-14?13:14 – How do I respond to protestants who ask about the brothers and sisters in Christ?23:58 – What is the Catholic teaching on cremation?34:40 – Can you do a video on the 7 apocryphal books and talk about if there are connections to the New Testament? And if they were accepted by Jews?38:16 – Can you create your own novena for a saint?41:32 – During the petitions at mass they mentioned “equity for all people.” Am I overreacting in saying this is inappropriate for Mass?51:07 – Do you think we are at the beginning of the tribulation considering all the civil unrest happening today?…
Questions Covered:01:24 – Why does the Catholic Church downplay the deaths caused by Thomas More?12:40 – Can the pope’s authority ever be invalidated?21:50 – What exactly do Catholics believe about the assumption of Mary?41:33 – If the Jewish faith accepts reincarnation, does the Catholic faith also accept the teaching of reincarnation?50:36 – when you go to confession, is your absolution not valid until you complete your penance?…
Questions Covered:15:35 – I left the Church because of religious OCD/scrupulosity. How can I overcome that? 29:39 – How did you understand the Gospel when you were a Protestant? How did you understand it before you converted? And how do you understand it now? 34:45 – What is the gospel according to the Catholic Church, and how does it teach we can be saved?52:23 – I want to make sure that I’m making the right decision in converting to Catholicism.…
Questions Covered: 04:29 – What is the best way to read the Bible? 13:58 – How is God’s justice being fully carried out in Jesus taking our sins? 28:30 – Where does the Bible say anything about purgatory? 33:38 – What words of encouragement can be offered to me about the anger and divisiveness in regard to the Pope among Catholics? 42:57 – Can you explain how the document on blessing of same sex couples is or is not feeding into wokeism and relativism? …
Questions Covered: 06:08 – What is the Catholic take on Jews regaining control of Israel? 16:55 – I heard that Jesus is not the correct name for Jesus, is this true? 19:16 – My son, who is pro communism, says that Heaven is going to be communist. Can you speak on this? 35:30 – Can you help me reconcile science and what is stated in the Bible? 49:17 – Matthew 16, Jesus tells Peter that he has the keys of the kingdom… in Greek this translation seems different. Can you help me understand? …
Questions Covered:01:32 – I’m trying to be clever. Can I pray and offer up my suffering for the souls in purgatory so that they will pray for me?04:48 – Matthew says Repent and believe in the Gospel. What would he have thought of when he said gospel if the books weren’t around?06:33 – It seems like James in Acts 15 is in charge, not Peter. How do you rebut the claim that this proves that Peter was not the leader?15:12 – Why are we following a lot of the Old Testament readings in mass? The readings on the Israelites destroying their enemies are not very Catholic.23:19 – In the story of finding Jesus in the Temple, why were Mary and Joseph scratching their heads on Jesus’ words: Don’t you know I’ll be in my father’s house.”32:31 – Can you explain and quantify the Treasury of Merit?43:04 – Mark 2:26 Is there an error on the explanation of who was allowed to eat on the sabbath?46:24 – How does one read the term “word of God” In the bible? Does it mean, bible, logos, etc.?50:07 – What’s the Church’s view on Prenuptial agreements?52:34 – If Mary is Queen of Heaven, where in the bible does it say that she has a throne in heaven?…
Question Covered:05:19 – If we get a false pope, are we required to follow him?10:49 – Does competition fall under the sins of the flesh? What are the sins of the flesh?16:06 – What’s the history of baptism? Are there references to it in the Old Testament?20:13 – What does it mean to bless the Lord?21:54 – Sermon on the mount. Why would Jesus say to allow a person to steal your cloak? Can you break down the meaning of it?28:50 – Can you go to a vigil mass for a holy day of obligation even if they say the evening vigil mass isn’t for that day.33:39 – How do I respond to the protestant claim that Hebrews says Jesus is the high priest and we need priests anymore?38:44 – What would be a good way to introduce the Eucharist to a Protestant?47:25 – I don’t mind veneration of saints, but Mary is not queen of Heaven.50:33 – How exactly is marriage a sacrament? What makes it a sacrament?…
Questions Covered:3:53 – Moral argument objection: He either has some reason for commanding what he does, or he doesn’t. What is God adding to this scenario?14:25 – What are your thoughts on Pope Francis’ Spanish tv interview, that Homosexuality is a sin but not a crime. But it’s a crime in African countries, would that mean that the Church should be exempt from this issue in those countries?20:40 – Does the Eucharist become the body and blood of Jesus in all Churches?23:50 – Regarding the Mass, the priest usually gives an intention before the mass. Are the merits for that intention the same as the merits for our intentions that we bring?29:30 – When will we receive from the chalice at mass again?33:53 – Why does the Annulment process for Catholics who marry outside the Church consider their marriage lack of form?39:20 – Why are prayers to Mary efficacious?46:04 – What makes a Catholic mass have a real presence while others don’t?48:22 – Why were Jesus’ healings more physical and not so much emotional healings?50:40 – Does the Church teach anything about the morality of dancing?52:35 – What would my brother in his marriage have to do to have it blessed by the Church?…
Questions Covered:15:42 – Why doesn’t the Church try to mend a marriage instead of immediately going forward with the annulment process?18:34 – I’m in an irregular relationship and am working on it. Do I have to confess it every time?22:53 – You’re focusing on the irregular part but can you discuss the union part? Is it really a union?31:35 – How does one explain the current issues on irregular union blessing to a protestant?40:40 – If a lesbian marries a man, is that grounds for annulment?43:00 – Why are priests not bringing more clarity on this topic?47:15 – Can you give us the 6 A’s again. I couldn’t write them down?49:22 – My husband’s annulment has been suspended and has not received any guidance from my parish. What should I do?…
Questions Covered:05:32 – Would giving money to the poor fulfill the need for “the works necessary for salvation?”10:17 – Were Adam and Eve kept from eating of the tree of life in Genesis?14:49 – Are there any examples of Early Church Fathers who were not premillennialists?19:38 – I’m doing a bible study with protestants. How do I explain infant baptism to them?28:44 – I’m making a statue of Mary Magdalene, so do I have to have her head covered?32:25 – I’m protestant and work with a Jehovah’s Witness. What’s the historical evidence for Jesus being crucified on a cross and not on a pole?36:48 – Acts 15:28 Paul forbids the Gentiles from consuming blood. Does this mean we have to reinterpret John 6?45:04 – Why is Tertullian not a saint?49:53 – My family and I are recent converts. My 13 year old daughter said she doesn’t want to go through confirmation and feels like she was forced to become Catholic. How do I handle this?…
Questions Covered:04:28 – Are the merits gained through acts of charity lost if a person commits mortal sin?06:16 – Where did disease and death come from?14:49 – What’s the proper response when I’m invited to a protestant church service?17:50 – Why were the Church Fathers not able to agree on the number of sacraments?22:22 – Why are we as Catholics allowed to embalm our deceased loved ones?41:43 – In what tense do you read the book of Revelation, past present and future? Regarding Rev 12, how is it possible that Mary experienced birth pains if she was sinless?51:46 – Which prayers can I accept from other people? For example, prayers from St. JP2 to someone satanic?…
Questions Covered:05:29 – Is there ever a circumstance where a person can perform a baptism without water?10:50 – How is it just to create eternal souls without their consent and then punish them when they don’t do right?18:40 – How do we square the seeming contradiction in Luke 23:43 where the thief will be with Jesus in paradise on that day but Jesus didn’t ascend to heaven for another 40 days?29:17 – What’s the difference between Anglican and Catholic?31:39 – With the transgender issue becoming more common, what things are being done in seminaries to ensure the candidates joining are truly men?34:26 – Who started the teaching that priests had to be celibate?42:24 – What is the distinction between blessing a marriage and blessing a same sex couple?46:18 – How long has the Church approved annulments? Are the children of these marriages illegitimate?48:23 – What does the Church say about asexuality?…
Questions Covered:15:41 – Are there people at St. Paul Street Evangelization who could give talks at parishes and maybe start a chapter in my local area? adam@stpaulse.com22:39 – What would be a good way of starting a conversation about faith with an agnostic?38:43 – I’m a revert and I’m struggling to figure out how to share it with friends who are not believers. How do I engage with my friends who are part of the LGBT community?47:49 – I’m a Protestant. I do exactly what you do and the way I would word it is that the Holy Spirit is in charge of the outcome, we are just required to share the message.52:09 – I ran into a St. Paul Street Evangelization in the street and it changed my life.…
Questions Covered:02:43 – Is there a point of no return in this life when it comes to salvation?14:34 – If God wasn’t letting out his wrath on Jesus on the cross, then why was there an earthquake and why did it go dark?18:08 – How can I prove the Immaculate Conception using only the bible?29:44 – Is it a sin to take communion if you are divorced and remarried?43:01 – If same sex marriage is sin, why does the Catholic Church bless same sex marriages?…
Questions Covered:04:20 – Did the Church ever teach that purgatory entailed retributive punishment?13:17 – If the Apocrypha is scripture, why is it called the Deuterocanon?19:45 – How concerned should I be for the salvation of our protestant brothers and sisters who don’t baptize their kids?25:02 – My granddaughter says she’s engaged to a woman. How should I approach this?39:45 – Did Mary get additional confirmation that Jesus was God when she visited Elizabeth?46:33 – If the Last Supper was the Passover meal, where does Jesus’ saying to consume his blood come in?50:13 – How close is the idea of Prima Scriptura to Church teaching?…
Questions Covered:04:10 – I get a lot of slack for being a Freemason. What’s the problem with it and being Catholic?12:56 – What are the classifications of relics and what happens when you touch a prayer card up to a relic?18:16 – What’s the difference in the way Catholics and Orthodox view baptism and original sin?24:28 – I’m Catholic but I have a lot of questions about the faith. Can I still receive communion if I have doubts?33:27 – Catholics often appeal to Mary being “full of grace” and being “blessed among women” as reasons to believe in the Immaculate Conception. With that in mind, is it also logical to conclude that John the Baptist is also conceived without sin?44:33 – Mt.1:25. Joseph did not know his wife until she had Jesus. Does this mean that Joseph and Mary had relations after the birth of Jesus?48:45 – What’s your advice on how to talk to my Pentecostal family members who are just starting to warm up to Catholicism but can’t let go of that style of worship?…
Questions Covered:05:58 – I visited Vatican City last summer and was shocked at the amount of treasure, art, and also general booty from extinct civilizations that was there. How did the Papacy obtain all of this and why do they still possess it?13:30 – What semester-long classes/programs would you recommend for Catholic high schoolers that are similar to RCIA that recap their faith, strengthen it, reinforce it, and so on? In other words, anything that recaps their faith that is online that will also help them grow in their love for God.16:19 – I was asked by my atheist son, “If God, beyond a shadow of a doubt, asked you to kill me, would you?” I confirmed that it was “beyond a shadow of a doubt” and then responded “Yes.” I place God’s will above all else. My atheist husband then turned on me and insisted that that was unacceptable. I feel as though I was just duped by a straw man argument. I’m so upset I don’t want to even be around them and just feel like grieving that they both so badly misunderstand. Help? 29:21 – I’m currently a Baptist Christian but I’m having a hard time choosing between Baptist (Protestant) Christian and Catholic Christian. The reason I’m Baptist is because I believe that we are all guilty sinners who deserve hell and only Jesus Christ paying for our sins is what saves us and I don’t think you can ever lose your salvation. …. after learning some church history and getting a good amount of my questions answered I’m starting to lean more towards Catholicism. But I will always believe that Jesus Christ is the only way to heaven and his sacrifice is enough and we can’t work for our salvation. I believe we will be rewarded in heaven for our good works but I don’t think the good works are what save us. Does the Catholic Church believe we Christians are saved by grace through faith in Jesus Christ paying for our sins?37:25 – Our 30-year-old son has left the faith and is living with his girlfriend. Is it a sin to allow them to stay in the same room in our home? My spiritual director has told me that it would be a serious sin for me, as the spiritual leader of my family, to allow this to happen. I have lovingly discussed this with my son and told him that he and his girlfriend are always welcome in our home but must sleep in separate rooms. This did not go well and our son has refused to come to our home in the future. I made it clear how much I love and care about him. We still communicate, but he claims that he and his girlfriend are upset and hurt over this. Even though my wife agreed to my following my conscious regarding this issue, she doesn’t see things in the same way as me and this has created tension between me and my wife. She feels that this decision has negatively impacted our relationship with him. Most of our other 5 adult children also disagree with my actions. I pray and sacrifice daily for my son’s conversion as well as that of his girlfriend, who is unbaptized and was raised without any faith. I also pray for my wife, marriage, and family. I don’t know what else I can do. It is just a terrible place to be in. I think that it might be helpful for my wife if you could provide me with some specific references to the Catholic faith referring to this type of situation. Thanks for your assistance. God Bless you and your ministry.46:14 – If you get the Last Rites from a Catholic priest, do you automatically go to Heaven? Also, is it true you can get the Last Rites from anyone?50:48 – I am concerned about my parents. They were raised Catholic but chose to go with non-denominational Christianity. I do not know their reasons for leaving the Catholic faith. My inquiry is if my parents, both of them or one of them, desired to return to the Catholic faith then what would they have to do?…
Questions Covered: 06:25 – Can the Sacrament of matrimony be valid from other Christian denominations? 12:23 – Does the Church have a moral obligation to talk against Communism? 17:07 – Is Baptism after death possible? 20:28 – If two Catholics are married in Church and get a divorce, are they still spiritually married? 30:06 – Can you explain more about the current plenary indulgence from the Franciscan and Pope Francis? Is there a reason that communion wine has not come back in some churches? 36:33 – When was the church established? 43:18 – In Hebrew 5:8 it says Jesus had to learn obedience, why would He need to learn anything? 48:14 – Where can you go to get a Christian fiction book published? 51:38 – What is the appropriate way to evangelize an elderly atheist? …
Questions Covered: 06:10 – Can any member of the Trinity assume a nature that isn’t rational? 09:15 – Can I go to a protestant church for apologetic research? 17:08 – I struggle silence. Do you have any recommendations to help my prayer life? 22:44 – Are there exceptions to RCIA? 28:52 – Is there a way for Catholics to discern if something is divine or demonic? 35:31 – What is our understanding of animal suffering prior to the fall? 42:47 – What can we do to discern if the news we hear is accurate or not?47:32 – How would I respond to Eastern Orthodox friends who share the Papacy wasn’t established till 8th Ecumenical council. 51:32 – Why is St. Dismas not considered the first Martyr? 52:53 – What is the reason for the Paul VI Audience Hall looking like a serpent’s head? …
Question Covered:15:15 – Why do Christian denominations practice the holy eucharist differently? Would it “count” for say a Mormon or Baptist?19:00 – I believe the John 6 dispute among the disciples was Christ’s statement that he came from heaven to earth. The conversation with the disciples seems to confirm this in verses 61 and 62. Thoughts?30:00 – There is such a different view between Catholics and Protestants on this topic. How/when did they determine the Eucharist wasn’t actually the body of Jesus? How can we prove it is to non-Catholics? If I have been receiving “communion” from a Protestant church, am I committing mortal sin?!36:07 – Did Jesus offer His literal Body on the cross or was His Body a symbol?37:18 – How can we as Catechists correct a former student who went back to Protestantism, especially after leaving the Holy Eucharist?46:09 – Would you tell us about the Eucharistic miracles of Lanciano Italy and Bueno Aires regarding their laboratory test results?50:21 – if a “mortal sin” is an addiction and I feel like eating the Eucharist helps fight the addiction can I eat it even though I’m still struggling?…
Questions Covered:11:03 – Should we take it literally that a star led the Wisemen? Was it possibly an angel? 19:11 – The Wisemen didn’t come for like 2 years right? 24:00 – Was Jesus’ family wealthy because the Wise Men brought gold, etc. in their treasure chests? 29:35 – Do they think Jesus was born at midnight? Or sometime during the night. 33:12 – why have they made up names for the three kings since those names are not in the Bible ( like Balthasar etc..)? 35:38 – Are we supposed to bless our homes with chalk on the Epiphany? Why and how? How did the writing with blessed chalk above one’s household door come about, and why is it okay (i.e., not some kind of spell casting)? 37:38 – Why do they say we are celebrating Jesus’ baptism when it was really a circumcision since they are not the same? – In the Byzantine liturgical tradition, the Magi are always depicted as gentiles. But in contemporary biblical studies, they are generally considered as Jewish. What do you think? 47:37 – Hello my brothers! I’m from Mexico and when I was a kid my grandma and other family members used to tell us that the three stars aligned in the sky were the three magi and I used to be so excited looking up during these special days of the epiphany and in Mexico we receive our Christmas gifts January 6th and you write a letter to the magi not Santa jaja have you heard of these traditions? Especially the one about the stars? …
Questions Covered:07:22 – What to say to a Protestant who insists that a relationship with Jesus is more important than denominational squabbles. 18:11 – I would love to hear an explanation of Adam and Eve being the first two people created by God. I’ve had a couple of people (including a newly ordained priest) say that this story is not historical, but that there were two “progenitors” through which we inherited original sin, and that they were “more or less” the first two people. Also, the other person said there was no way that all of the population came from just two people, that they “evolved” from other creatures around the world and “original sin is really just the downfall of man during that time.” 28:23 – Please explain why Joseph was an older man and how a young Joseph was a latter theological novum 33:55 – Do we actually know that Yahweh is how the divine name was said or are we just guessing? I know about the tetragrammaton and how the a stood for Adonai and the e stood for Elohim so doesn’t this mean the divine name was something else? I grew up a Jehovah’s Witness, so this is something close to my mind often. Thanks for all you do Joe! You and all the crew at Catholic Answers helped bring me to the Catholic Church! 37:51 – Was St. Patrick a Baptist? 44:03 – What would you say to an Orthodox who would make the claim that because the Catholic Church says they have valid sacraments or priesthood that they don’t need the Pope. 48:55 – Were there any church fathers, say, in the first 150 years, who did not believe in baptismal regeneration? 51:29 – Does John 10: 22-23 (Jesus being in the Temple during Hanukkah) disprove the Protestant Canon being that Hannukah is only found in 1 & 2 Maccabees? …
Questions Covered:04:31 – What’s an obscure teaching that more people should know about? I saw something in Denzinger which condemned eating for pleasure. That was odd and not sure what to make of it. 12:50 – Hey Joe, according to 1 Corinthians 15:51-52 the last generation don’t sleep (die) and are changed instantaneously, in the twinkling of an eye. If the last generation don’t go to purgatory and God can change them instantly then why can’t God change the dead instantaneously without the need for purgatory? Thanks, God Bless 19:47 – Why did the Church declare an anathema and tie salvation to the belief in the Marian dogmas (in particular the immaculate conception and the assumption)? On the surface, these dogmas don’t seem to have anything to do with the Gospel message that Jesus died for our sins as we can imagine a world where Jesus still defeats death with a Mother who had original sin or was not assumed into heaven. 29:42 – I would like Joe to answer the “no salvation outside the catholic church” you hear the rad trads say this then on the other side you hear the universalist “everybody goes to heaven” perspective. In my limited study it appears the answer lies in the middle but it’s very complex. 37:25 – What is wrong with the patriarchal ratification theory of what makes a council ecumenical? 43:03 – Something I’ve always wondered: What do priests do if they don’t have access to valid matter for the Eucharist? I’m thinking, for example, of explorers like Father Jacques Marquette, traveling for a long time in a strange (to them) country without wheat or wine. Are they just excused from the obligation to celebrate Mass frequently? 45:21 – How can we find holiness in our ordinary lives? 50:54 – Hi Joe, where did your awesome blog name come from? …
Questions Covered:02:02 – Can I be a Catholic in good standing if I don’t believe the doctrines to be literally true?10:08 – What is the distinction between Hell, Sheol, Gahena, and Abraham’s bosom?13:59 – Why is the spreading of Ashes in air, land, and sea is wrong in layman terms?18:17 – What are the types of temporal punishments on earth that can be removed by a plenary indulgence?20:24 – How would I respond to the claim from a Protestant that it doesn’t matter what the early councils declared as being canon of scripture because they are Catholic?29:20 – Can you explain Jesus on the cross saying “why have you forsaken me” and him being divine?34:56 – If us Catholics are not saved by works, how can we lose our salvation by not completing works?43:06 – I’ve heard, once a Catholic always a Catholic. My brother is now protestant, Can he still enter into heaven because he believes in Jesus?47:04 – A protestant used Hebrews 9:24-8 as an argument against the eucharist. How do I respond?…
Questions Covered:1:45 – If we can pray and interact directly with God, why can’t we confess our sins directly to him?06:46 – I’m considering becoming Catholic. Can we go directly to God for prayer or do we have to go through Mary?13:35 – Did God ordain that women cannot be priests?17:48 – Where in the bible does it say that humans will go to heaven when they die?21:05 – If our penance is the Our Father, can we just use the one in mass as it?25:09 – What constitutes mortal sin? I’m familiar with the 3 criteria but what is grave matter?35:56 – I’m an atheist. Why don’t pray to heal amputees?48:41 – How does a Catholic feel with disagreement among the Church Fathers?…
Cy sits down with Fr. Hugh Barbour, O. Pream. for this encore episode to discuss devotion to the baby Jesus.…
In this Special Christmas episode, Cy sits down with Catholic Answers president, Christopher Check, to wish you a Merry Christmas!…
Questions Covered:03:49 – How can the Church have different rites and different forms of liturgy if the Mass is so important?14:35 – How can I answer someone who says we’re idolaters for having statues?21:21 – I don’t understand why Catholicsm makes more sense over Orthodoxy when they both have apostolic succession.30:10 – Should somebody drop out of Catholicism because of the declaration of same-sex unions?36:00 – Why do people have to do seven months of RCIA, and why do we have to go to church every Sunday?49:51 – Is it true that the Catholic Church believes only Catholics go to heaven?…
Questions Covered:09:25 – Sirius XM I don’t find any of the stories of miracles and the supernatural to be convincing.17:44 – What does worship mean from a Catholic perspective?23:14 – If I can pray directly to God and Jesus, why pray to anybody else?33:03 – Wasn’t Catholicism responsible for the Inquisitions?35:08 – Didn’t Jesus condemn repetitive prayer?44:06 – How would Catholics define graven images?51:24 – It doesn’t make sense why we don’t worship Mary.…
Questions Covered:03:40 – Are martial arts a sin?07:25 – When were the angels created? Also, what did the angels fight with in the battle of angels?14:12 – What sources could be useful to prepare a discussion with a protestant?16:22 – I’m trying to become Catholic but I’m having problems understanding why Mary is a perpetual virgin. Is there any scriptural evidence?24:25 – I am a registered nurse and in the process of converting to Catholicism. As an RN, I practice in the correctional system and some of these inmates are dealing with gender dysphoria. I am required to administer medications to patients, including medications that support transitions. Am I doing wrong? What does the Church teach about this?38:37 – What do you do if even if you know you’ve been forgiven through confession, you can’t forgive yourself?44:20 – Is there evidence that Satan really exists? Or is it just symbolism?…
Questions Covered:03:16 – Does the original sin of Adam work in a similar way as the infused righteousness of Christ? 11:29 – What kind of magisterial document does “Fiducia Supplicans” fall into? What kind of sin of intellect and will must Catholics make with documents like that? 16:57 – When it comes to praying to the saints, how do they come to conclusion of what saints represent which things? 21:00 – I have been both Methodist and Catholic and am now non-practicing. I miss things from both. Is it possible to make the two come together? 29:40 – The man on the cross beside Jesus didn’t have time to jump down and become baptized. But Jesus told him TODAY you’ll be with me in paradise. 32:33 – I’ve heard both Jimmy and Trent talk about the use of nuclear weapons as being not licit. If this is a church standing, does that mean Catholic military members cannot be involved in the operations of nuclear weapons? 41:35 – Is there any archeological evidence to whether Sodom and Gomorrah was real? 47:25 – Do two married people have a united nature? Is it a matter of being one nature but two persons? 51:00 – Is there any info on the human side of Jesus and his disciples? For example, favorite color, how he celebrated birthdays, etc.…
Questions Covered:03:20 – If Jesus is the only one who has conquered death, then how do we get these people rising from the dead at the end of Matthew?05:22 – Is the story of Sodom and Gamorrah historical?10:58 – When God speaks it’s not in quotes but when humans do it is. Why is that?17:52 – Why does the devil tempt Jesus after he starts his ministry and not before? Also, why are none of the temptations sexual in nature?22:25 – I’m not Catholic. Jesus told the good thief that he would be with Jesus in paradise that day? Wouldn’t that negate purgatory?37:00 – In Proverbs the fear of the Lord is the beginning of knowledge. What does it mean?43:56 – I just want to thank Jeff, His book saved me from leaving the Church.48:05 – Did Jesus have brothers?51:41 – Could you explain Mt 16:28 in the context of verse 27? Is it referring to the second coming? Who is that Jew that has not tasted death?…
Questions Covered:4:51 – Do any New Testament manuscripts exist that have the gospels in a different order? Follow up: If the orthodox were united with us, would we have to accept the extra books of the Bible that they accept?9:26 – Do you have any advice for Christians battling mental illness?16:29 – What pastoral advice would you give to a committed Catholic couple who are cohabiting?21:44 – I’m coming back to the church after 40 years. I’m concerned about not remembering how to go to confession. What do I say? Should I bring a list of my sins?30:57 – What ways can we help out our community that is not part of our local parish, but still do it for Jesus?34:52 – How do we handle near death experiences where someone said they were going to end up in Hell?41:41- My son is dating someone who is not religious. Any advice for when I see her this New Year’s Eve?45:47- Our priest used to allow us to receive at the altar rail. But it seems he was told to no longer have the altar rail. Is that something he can be told to do?49:44 – Our priest sings songs when he’s preparing the gifts. Does that invalidate the Mass? Also what if a priest only washed one hand instead of both — would that cause the Mass to be invalid?…
Questions Covered:02:21 – Why don’t the Church Fathers use the same passages when defending Church Doctrine?07:16 – How do you know when the pope is making a statement ex cathedra?14:33 – Are Catholics allowed to consume or watch combat sports?19:05 – Why was Zechariah punished and Mary wasn’t for asking a similar question?23:22 – When did the practice of praying the rosary as call and response begin?29:43 – My protestant friend is close to becoming Catholic. He doesn’t understand penance. What would penance look like for people Hitler etc?40:45 – What conditions could I give to a protestant for either of us to convert if those conditions are met?44:49 – When does the bread become the body of Christ during Mass?52:26 – If God knows what we’re going to do, do we really have free will?…
Questions Covered:20:14 – I wanted to ask Trent specifically, are combat sports moral?35:48 – I agree God allows us to pray for others & to ask others to pray for us. But my question is: how does Mary hear all those prayers? Is she omnipotent?41:47 – What are your thoughts on Gavin Ortlund? Do you think he is a good faith actor?46:33 – Is the stain of original exclusive to one individual, Adam?52:28 – My agnostic friend is engaging with a married woman who is in an open marriage. Should I stop being friends with him?…
Questions Covered:18:11 – I need advice on how to practice leisure and balance as a Catholic.23:10 – I think the basis of our work ethic in the US and lack of leisure is because of its Puritan roots.32:45 – What tips do you have to work less and embrace leisure?36:42 – Leisure is savoring the moment and acedia is not.44:08 – What’s the connection between work and leisure?…
Questions Covered:15:45 – Why do we refer to Mary as ‘our life’ in the Hail Holy Queen?19:03 – Have you done research on the books about Mary by Sister Mary of Agreda?22:44 – I’m Protestants. What do we make of the response that Jesus gives that almost sounds like he’s degrading his mother in Lk.11:27?29:58 – Did Mary have other children?37:43 – Heart of Jesus Radio… Can you clarify the interpretation of ‘Our Life’ in the Salve Regina? I thought it was a reference to Jesus.42:08 – My Baptist friend claimed that Mary was a sinner. What’s the response to this?45:07 – Isn’t it logical that there would be a large emphasis on Mary since half the population is women?46:53 – Is it possible for Mary to have said no since she was already sinless?48:34 – Do Genesis 3:15 and Isaiah 7:14 refer to Mary51:38 – I’m protestant and am making my way to the Church. Father, your way of talking about Mary is contributing to me getting closer.…
Questions Covered:02:50 – A person wants to be baptized but has a family member who insists they were baptized as children, together (at the same time as they are twins). They do not have anyone living who would know and cannot locate records in places they guess it may have occurred. Do they take the steps toward baptism or assume they are?04:50 – Is the Protestant Canon of Scripture materially sufficient for salvation? If yes, is the Deuterocanon unnecessary? If not, is there information in the Deuterocanon that is needed for salvation?11:16 – Jimmy I think the biggest crisis in the Church today is the lack of belief in the Eucharist. I’d like to see you speak on the prefigurement of the Eucharist in the Old Testament and the fulfillment in the new. Also, I’d like to see a discussion on the real existence of hell and what many of the saints have said about it plus the testimonies of modern-day exorcists. Thanks.18:38 – Why does St. Paul refer to levels of Heaven and what might that mean for Christians? Are the levels multiple steps to God?22:58 – In Matthew 4 and Luke 4:8, why did Jesus tell Peter to “Get behind me Satan”? Why did he call him Satan? Or did he? Thanks, Jimmy!28:35 – In your podcast episode where you went through the different possibilities of aliens, I didn’t hear you mention the possibility of an alien race that is ahead of humanity in their salvation journey. What are your thoughts on an alien race that is on their New Earth equivalent? I would assume that alien abduction would be immoral and therefore such a race wouldn’t abduct anyone. Would such a race be able to or even want to interact with humans?33:18 – It would seem that Judas was the first to receive and leave communion in a state of mortal sin at the Last Supper. What might be the implications of Jesus knowing ahead of time that Judas would receive the morsel with murder in his heart?42:00 – Why can’t I baptize people with Beer since it’s mostly water? Also, can I baptize with tears?45:20 – My 15-year-old would like to know why God would choose a 13-year-old girl to be the mother of Jesus instead of a fully grown woman.51:20 – Is it okay to lie in certain situations like if you were hiding Jews, in Germany during World War II?53:23 – If I suffer Martyrdom with unconfessed sins, even a Mortal one, do I really go straight to heaven or will I still need to spend time in Purgatory?…
Questions Covered:03:17 – Are there any insights as to when Christ was using His Divine intellect vs. His human intellect or is this a complete mystery or is it incorrect to say Christ was not always using both?06:38 – I would love to hear you comment on the theology of numbers.18:58 – If God is the God of all, how can he have a “chosen people”?21:41 – God gave us the gift of free will. By my understanding, it is the only gift he cannot take back or overrule, otherwise our will would not be truly free. With this in mind, how are we to understand his words in Exodus where he seems to make pharaoh obdurate, as though overriding the free exercise of his will? For example, Exodus 7:3-4: “Yet I will make Pharaoh so headstrong that, despite the many signs and wonders that I work in the land of Egypt, Pharaoh will not listen to you. Therefore, I will lay my hand on Egypt, and with mighty acts of judgment I will bring my armies, my people the Israelites, out of the land of Egypt.”30:17 – It seems like miracles are less known than they should be. Example- Fatima, St Pio, Beauraing, and others. Do you think the evil one obfuscates the message?32:51 – Questions from a fellow pipe smoker. What’s your favorite pipe and tobacco?40:26 – Which is the best government: the United Federation of Planets (from Star Trek) or the United Planets (from Legion of Super-Heroes)?44:04 – Is there any chance Our Lady of America is coming back from the disapproval of the diocesan bishops?48:55 – Please discuss the metaphor and actuality of new heavens/new earth. Who (will) live there? The need for a new earth and whether it’s metaphorical has been discussed more than a new heavens. What is wrong with the old heavens?…
Questions Covered:04:00 – Are the results of our free will predestined if God doesn’t change his mind?12:22 – My co-worker is Wiccan and and her granddaughter wants to know about God. My co-worker gave me permission to talk to her but I don’t know where to start. What’s your advice?18:35 – My father is saying that there would have been no census during the birth of Christ, therefore no flight to Bethlehem. What’s the response to this?23:49 – Where does the Church stand on plastic surgery?29:39 – Should we receive communion unless we are certain of having committed a mortal sin?34:58 – I’m interested in the Church Fathers. What book do you recommend to read to get started?39:53 – What has Pope Francis done that’s so objectionable that people slander him instead of defend him?47:44 – Is Doxastic Damage Theory of lying applicable Jn 7:8-9?…
Questions Covered:04:01 – How can we as Catholics demonstrate to Protestants that our bible is accurate?10:25 – Since the Trinity are different persons but all one God, did everyone come down earth when Jesus did?16:01 – Is it acceptable to listen to music written by Protestants that are theologically acceptable?20:15 – Was Jesus actually tempted or did the devil just try?24:09 – How prevalent was the Holy Spirit in the Old Testament?24:09 – If Adam and Eve had not sinned, would we be here?32:02 – Can we trust the International Association of Exorcists?39:58 – How do I respond to the question that if Jesus is perfect, then why is his Church so sinful?46:08 – How did Joseph truly marry Mary if it was never consummated?50:00 – I thought that if Adam and Eve didn’t sin, each of us would have been individually tested. What are your thoughts?52:34 – How do we know that the intercession of saints has helped in prayer?…
Questions Covered:02:10 – Why should we not believe in Sola Fide and once saved always saved?13:48 – Is it possible for the Magisterium to suppress truths for the sake of order?20:18 – How do you reconcile your fear of God and God’s love?30:05 – Are boxing, MMA and Muay Thai immoral?42:06 – I’m struggling with the St. Michael prayer. How is it intercessory if we are directly asking St. Michael to protect us?48:12 – Why are bishops like Strickland and Burke being kicked out of the Church while others that are blessing gay marriages safe?…
Questions Covered:03:36 – I confessed to a priest that I don’t believe Catholicism to be literal. Can I still consider myself Catholic?07:15 – I’m entering the Church during Easter. My wife is divorced and said that the best case scenario is if she converts and will become a Poll case. What is that?13:56 – Revelation says the living and the dead will be judged. How will the dead be judged?28:18 – If the language of the Jews was Hebrew, then why did Jew start speaking Aramaic? Where did it come from?31:32 – Who was Jan Hus and why was he put to death?45:15 – How old was Rebecca when Isaac married her?50:35 – How does the Church view the authenticity of the relics of the true cross?…
Questions Covered:02:34 – If silent prayer is heard by saints, does this mean that the devil can also hear them?15:30 – What are your thoughts on near death experiences?29:15 – I saw a video saying that the Israelite God was just a copy of a Canaanite god. What are your thoughts on this?35:28 – I have an eating disorder. Do I need to continually confess the sin of gluttony?41:42 – What’s the best way to explain Jesus as fully human and fully divine to 5th graders?47:05 – Is God against people acquiring wealth?50:44 – Is competition a sin?…
Questions Covered:06:40 – Does the concept of time travel prayer create a paradox for why we don’t see future saint don’t come into the past?12:27 – I’m Christian. How do we reconcile reincarnation and people remembering past lives with Christianity?029:21 – Is the body of Christ in the Eucharist, glorified or suffering?32:18 – Why did Elisha call two bears to eat kids in 2 Kings?36:00 – What does Paul mean when he says that women must be subordinate to their husbands?46:35 – If the Apocrypha was in the bible up until the reformation, then why wasn’t it officially in the canon until Trent? What is the difference between the Apocrypha and Deuterocanonical?52:51 – Could you explain what a feast day is, and what you are supposed to do on a feast day?…
Questions Covered:37:31 – Could we say that the story of the Christmas Carol could be considered a parable?46:00 – I wanted to share what we do for advent.50:33 – We opened our gifts on Dec. 6, feast of St. Nick, and emphasized Christ during Christmas. It worked out well for our 7 kids.…
Questions Covered:16:26 – Does psychology clash with Catholicism or is there a continuity like Catholicism and the other sciences?21:17 – What single scientific fact is most persuasive to you that God exists?31:33 – I read your book. Could you review the foundational points on the elegant creation of earth?36:21 – I’m protestant and have always been taught young earth. Why does young earth seem to be dismissed in the Catholic world?44:04 – What is the Catholic view of evolution by natural selection?…
Questions Covered:06:51 – What’s a simple response to “Christmas is pagan?”16:43 – St. Faustina said that if angels could envy, they would envy the Eucharist and suffering. Are angels capable of envy?32:50 – What does Matthew 16:19 mean when it says whatever you loose, its loosed in heaven?43:58 – How do I delicately explain to in-laws why you need a priest for the Eucharist?49:15 – Why is Jesus returning to judge the living and the dead when we’re already going to be in heaven?…
Questions Covered:07:18 – I used to be Catholic and now I’m considering returning. Why should I come back and not go to an Episcopal church since they have more progressive values?15:23 – Are you afraid of death? If Christ gives us hope for the afterlife, should we be nervous about death?24:40 – When did the Church begin allowing secular kings using violence in the name of the Church?35:24 – Does God hate people as he mentions in Romans 9:13?42:51 – Could you explain how we know the Eucharist is really the body and blood of Jesus and not just a symbol?47:44 – Where did God come from? Who created him?52:03 – How many prayers in the mass come from Judaism?…
Questions Covered: 01:54 – Are there two different types of salvation referenced in the Bible? 12:19 – Is anxiety a sin? 16:22 – When did marriage become a religious ceremony? 19:26 – At what point do the sins of converted Protestants impact their Purgatory? 21:30 – Did Jesus eat himself at the Last Supper? 29:53 – Is there scripture that states Jesus asked us to pray to his mother? 33:37 – What is the Catholic Church’s understanding of Hell and the devil? 40:47 – Do Jesus and Mary experience pain now even though they are in Heaven? 43:55 – What is the difference between Married life and religious life? 48:40 – When we talk about Jesus’s age of 33, did we use the Gregorian calendar? 49:44 – Is it a mortal sin to not to believe in Jesus? How would this impact people in remote parts of the world? …
Questions Covered: 06:20 – Is there ever a possibility for a Catholic to practice the faith at home due to a personal situation? 16:00 – What is the role of Purgatory at the end of the world? 19:55 – Are there prophets in today’s age? 31:15 – I don’t feel like getting baptized as a baby makes much sense because you didn’t choose to accept Jesus yet. 33:13 – What is the symbolic comparison between the Christian and Islamic versions of Abraham’s sacrifice? 40:56 – How do I appropriately celebrate feast days within fasting periods? 48:43 – If the Pope is chosen by the Holy Spirit, why do we end with corrupt Popes or one who can retire? 51:20 – Am I under obligation to say something about unbaptized grandchildren? …
Questions Covered:04:34 – I read an article saying that elements of the liturgy can harm someone (and actually make grace less efficacious) because of his past traumas. Is that true?17:00 – My daughter has requested that I only make one reference to my faith when we talk. Is it sinful for me to consent to that request?20:32 – Fr. Elias Mary claimed that the Pope is going to be the antichrist. Is that possible?30:09 – What does the Apostles’ Creed mean when it says Jesus “descended into hell?”35:48 – What happens between the particular and general judgments? How are they different?42:16 – Can I receive sacraments from SSPX priests?44:36 – Where does the origin of Christmas as Jesus’ birthday come from? Is it in the Bible?50:33 – I heard someone say “it is no longer I who lives but Mary who lives in me” is this a theologically correct statement?53:05 – Can you explain Acts 5? How do you relate to Acts 5 now versus in the 1st century?…
Questions Covered:05:23 – Does the Church having canonized saints diminish the value of non-canonized saints?12:23 – Were the three wise men practicing astrology when they looked at a star to find Jesus?19:45 – I know that the answer to the problem of suffering is that God allows suffering for a greater good. But where does that idea come from? The Bible?30:42 – When Gabriel says “Hail” to Mary, is that a greeting or is it something more?37:30 – My best friend’s sister died recently, and my friend is wondering if she’s in hell. I didn’t know what to say to her.46:18 – Do the cases of Pope Honorius and Pope Vigilius disprove papal infallibility?…
Questions Covered:08:37 – My child was exposed to pornography in 3rd grade at school without the school’s knowledge. He is now in high school. How can I support him to break this addiction?36:06 – What do you attribute the huge increase in sexual issues especially in the trans issue?47:41 – What is the response to the claim that regret is rare in the transgender movement?51:59 – How do I get over an overwhelming sense of lust?…
Questions Covered:12:05 – Is it okay for a Catholic to go to a Byzantine church? Did the office of St. Andrew survive like St. Peter’s line?18:46 – Would you communion at a Roman Catholic rite? If the Orthodox acknowledge the papacy why are they under another authority?23:44 – I became Orthodox. What went wrong for the division to happen?35:03 – How does confession differ in the Catholic Church vs the Eastern Orthodox?42:50 – Churching of women after birth is a tradition in the Orthodoxy that fell off in Catholicism. Are there other traditions like this that also fell off?45:32 – How do we keep the conversation positive when conversing with Orthodox friends?52:13 – Is the Eucharist in the east actually the body and blood of Jesus?…
Questions Covered:01:09 – What are your thoughts on the UFO/ET sightings being demons?17:01 – In The Shining Dick Halloran the chef tells young Danny Torrance that the Shining gives people the ability to see the things from long ago and things that have not yet happened. With that being said is the ability to Shine in the movie & book the same thing as prophecy, extrasensory perception, intuition, empathy, precognition, and retrocognition?12:10 – What are the historical ramifications if Abraham had never left Ur?13:43 – Is it true that the Vatican has one of the best science labs in the world, and if so why and what is it used for? Thank you.16:41 – Suppose an couple is engaged and is approaching the Church to be married. However, they are an unfortunate genetic match and have certainty that 100% of their children will perish in the womb. Would it be immoral for them to live as husband and wife? And does the Church have any legislation that would prevent them being married in the Church?18:46 – Can a priest celebrate Mass if he has no arms?22:42 – On May 31, 1985 I was baptized by the fire of the Holy Spirit from the crown of my head, through every cell in my body. See Luke 3:16 Do you think the fire of Purgatory is the same purifying fire I experienced? Meaning, do you think it’s the Holy Spirit that does the purging?29:00 – How many times in one’s life can one vow “till death do us part?”34:00 – If throughout the Bible angels (who are spiritual, non-corporeal beings) appear with enfleshed bodies as apparitions, could that be true for the Holy Spirit as well? Is it possible that those puzzling times in Scripture when people didn’t recognize Jesus it was because the Third Person of the Trinity was making an appearance? When Jesus appeared to Mary Magdalene in the tomb (John 20:14-18), and to the two followers on the way to Emmaus (Luke 24:13-35) and to the seven disciples fishing (John 21:1-14), is it possible that they didn’t recognize Him because they were not seeing God the Son at first, but God the Holy Spirit for a brief time? The One who they didn’t recognize consoled, comforted them, revealed truth to them, testified to them, convicted them, taught them, walked along side of them (parakletos), witnessed to them, brought things to their remembrance, and revealed and glorified the Lord to them…all the things Jesus promised the Advocate would do when He came (John 14:15-31, John 15:26-27 and John 16:5-16).40:05 – If angel are non-corporeal beings, why do we gender them?46:42 – How does one mistake a reconnaissance balloon as an alien space craft?48:30 – Where was Jesus between the ages of 12 and 30?50:54 – Let’s say that macro-PK is real. Where does the energy to move the objects come from? If there is a violation of the laws of thermodynamics, could the heat death of the universe be defeated by a sufficiently large, trained force of PKers?…
Questions Covered:02:05 – Suppose a modern lay Catholic (baptized, confirmed, etc.) were transported through time and space to the year 5 BC, Jerusalem. Assuming he/she retains his/her knowledge and beliefs from the 21st century AD and is aware that he/she has arrived in a time before the Incarnation has taken place, in what way would this Catholic be obligated to worship God? Would he/she need to live as a Jew under the Mosaic law, given that the New Covenant has not yet been established in their “present” timeline, or would he/she be required to live according to Catholic practices to the best of their ability? Would he/she be morally obligated to be a sort of prophet, proclaiming the coming Lord; or perhaps be obligated not to, lest they affect salvation history? 06:11 – I’m curious whether Satan can “bless” people and/or things? By “bless” I mean supernaturally enhance in the manner requested by those seeking the “blessing”. 12:05 – If someone is trapped in a time loop like in Groundhog Day or Edge of tomorrow, is it still a sin to commit suicide in order to reset the time loop? If you already have been trapped for several weeks then it would probably feel annoying to wait out the entire loop if you mess something up. 14:53 – I write Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles fanfiction, mostly action/adventure stories. I am currently outlining a story where the TMNT meet a Catholic Apologist. I have modeled her after Mr. Akin in both personality and intellect. In my story, the apologist is explaining the Catholic idea of the soul to the TMNT. One of the things that has hung me up a little is that I believe all sensitive and rational souls are created immediately upon conception. The TMNT started out as ordinary turtles, so they were given sensitive souls the moment they were created, before they were even born. However, now that they have mutated, they have rational souls. One of the characters questions whether the turtles’ sensitive, animal souls died and a new, rational soul was installed in them when they mutated, or if their souls were changed when they mutated? Initially I had the idea that God “upgraded” their sensitive souls to rational souls upon their mutation, but a friend of mine suggested that maybe they were conceived with rational souls, but as it took 15 years for them to develop from babies to teenagers, they simply didn’t express their rational souls until they were old enough/mutated enough to talk. I’m curious as to what Mr. Akin would say and would be grateful for his perspective. 21:45 – I have a few questions for you: 1. If angels are spiritual, eternal beings existing outside of time, how can they be created in time if eternity is outside of it? 2. When we die, our souls survive our mortal bodies. If our souls are eternal, how can we be created in time if eternity is outside of it? 3. How did God create something out of nothing if it is against the nature of nothing to be something? 31:50 – What is “Burning Man” really about? It seems to get a lot of media attention each year. My stepdaughter and her husband have both apostatized from the church, and went a few years back. They have regional “burns” as well that they attend. The stories they seem happy to tell people seem very disturbing. Almost satanic. Certainly evil. Nothing at all like what I get from Mr. Google or the media. Who is “The Burning Man? Do you have any insights on any of this? 34:02 – I have a weird question (I think). I know in the early 20th century or late 19th century catholic theologians mentioned the desirability to baptize not-yet-born babies in the womb as long as it was safe and possible. My question is, why isn’t this done right now even without medical intervention? It seems to me that the form (I now baptize…) the matter (water, after all the baby is…
Questions Covered: 04:02 – What evidence is there for Hell?11:02 – Is it immoral to play audio or watch a video of someone saying the Lord’s name in vain?14:23 – Do you think there are more than two James? Is James the less different than Jame the brother?21:34 – Question about predestination. Did God know who I was going to date before I dated them?28:42 – Why does the Catholic Church have a pope? Is the Pope biblical?35:27 – Is receiving the Eucharist in the hand wrong?41:58 – Is consuming artificial sweeteners immoral? Because artificial sweeteners are intentionally not nutritional.50:41 – Can the multiverse be real?…
Questions Covered:02:30 – Would there be a licit way to do something like the Bachelor to find a spouse?06:03 – How do Catholics avoid picking between the beliefs of the Church Fathers?16:58 – What causes someone to lose their salvation?18:10 – Is there a relationship between modern Israel and 1st century Israel?21:47 – I’ve heard Skinwalker ranch is based on a curse in folklore. Could this be a case of diabolic infestation?28:30 – Why does the Catholic church claim to have changed the sabbath day because it had the ecclesiastical power to do so?31:20 – Can you clarify any of the lies related to the Jewish Talmud?37:01 – Did the early Church Fathers believe in the doctrine of atonement?46:38 – Why isn’t the Ascension mentioned much in the Bible?52:18 – Is there a good book to give to someone who is interested in faith but has no religious background.…
Questions Covered:04:50 – How do I respond when someone asks if I denounce other gods? It feels like a “gotcha” question.28:29 – What can my friend who is a new Catholic do who just found out his grandfather was a Freemason?35:08 – Regarding Lev. 23, on what days did the appointed festivals fall on. Were they all on Sunday?41:25 – Will the generation that sees the end of time have to pass through death? If not, then how will the souls be purified if they don’t go to purgatory?44:55 – If Jesus promised to return at the end of time, how do we square that with Jesus coming back constantly in the Eucharist?47:52 – What’s a generational curse?50:45 – If Ex. 15 says we have to keep the sabbath, why then Sunday?…
Questions Covered:16:21 – Should you give a general state in life when in confession?19:19 – Am I doing something wrong if I don’t feel anything after confession?23:26 – I haven’t been to confession in over 20 years. What’s your advice on how to approach confession after so long?31:20 – I’m a new Catholic coming from a Protestant background. I approach confession for venial sin but the priest is almost dismissive when mentioning those sins. What’s your advice on how to handle it?36:37 – I’m not Catholic. Is it true that you have to be sorry to go to confession or can you go and pray for the grace of repentance after going to confession?43:05 – Do venial sins need to be confessed?46:30 – How do you get over going to confession confessing the same sin over and over again?…
Questions Covered:05:32 – Can you help me better understand purgatory? I still can’t wrap my mind around it?13:43 – What’s the difference between the assumption of Mary vs the saints in heaven. Do saints have their bodies?18:53 – What’s the Church’s teaching on vasectomies?29:30 – Acts 5 Why were the couple struck down because they didn’t donate all they have? How do we understand that in the context of today? Can we be struck down too?41:06 – Do spouses continue to have a special relationship in heaven?44:15 – Regarding the Papal Bull Unum Sanctum, do we still teach that all those who are saved must be subject to the Roman Pontiff?50:39 – I had a dream multiple times about my uncle after he died. In the dream he was suffering and asking for help. Does this mean he was in purgatory?…
Questions Covered:05:45 – How can we show that annihilationism is false using the bible? 13:59 – I’m confused about the Catholic position on the death penalty. Can you help clarify? 24:17 – Regarding the last 2 glorious mysteries (assumption and coronation). How do I relate to her and not feel like we are supposed to worship her? 33:27 – St. Irenaeus’ letter says that the Church was founded on Peter and Paul. Can you clarify? Also when Paul first arrived in Rome, Acts says that there was already a community and there was no evidence that Peter had been there. Can you clarify? 43:36 – Mt 19:11-12 If there were physical handicaps acknowledged in the bible, Is it possible to say that gender dysphoria is also a valid thing for us to acknowledge? …
Questions Covered:12:06 – What’s your advice on how to handle my 20 year old son who is in the process of transitioning using female hormones. How can I cope? Do you have any resources?23:30 – Is Medi-Share Christian Health faithful to Catholic ethics?29:43 – What are your thoughts on Assisted reproductive technology?36:47 – What is the Church’s teaching on embryo adoption?44:15 – If a pregnant mom has surgery on her baby in the womb where the baby is lifted out for the procedure, can the baby be baptized before being placed back into the uterus?46:30 – How does one determine if a vaccine is ethically produced? I’m specifically thinking about the HPV vaccine.51:53 – What ethically am I morally responsible for in administering drugs as a healthcare administrator?…
Questions Covered:14:59 – I had an eating disorder for over 40 years and now healed from it.22:18 – How do you go about starting a local CIR group?28:56 – Is there a better avenue in which the Church can reach out to those in addiction?46:55 – Recovery is fragile. And I’ve been in recovery for 14 years now.…
Questions Covered:20:56 – I found it better to share my experience over my knowledge.33:52 – Maybe a captive audience is not the best time to evangelize.46:08 – How do we present the gospel to younger people? Do you have resources?50:50 – I want to challenge the idea that we don’t want to make people feel uncomfortable.…
Questions Covered:06:47 – I struggle with the Immaculate Conception and the Latin Vulgate.14:00 – The claim that Jesus started the Catholic Church and that you have to be a part of it to fully be united with him.20:03 – I don’t like the structure of the rosary and how it has changed.30:59 – Why do Catholics call priests father, and why can’t priests get married? Also, Mary was a sinner and needed saving.39:58 – Offering suffering for others troubles me.48:00 – How do Catholics know Mary is in heaven?…
Questions Covered:08:54 – In the profession of faith, why do we confess one baptism? How can the Spirit proceed from the Father and Son if they are all equal?16:21 – How do I respond to protestants who say we anathematize them for something that was said in a Church council?22:52 – What does the Church teach about the gifts of the spirit in 1 Corinthians?29:31 – Why did the Pope 21 Coptic Orthodox Christians martyrs as saints? Aren’t they heretics?41:30 – I’m going to be confirmed soon. How far back do I have to go for my first confession?47:32 – What’s the balance perspective of Psalm 37:4. Mark 11:24 pertaining to the Word of Faith movement.…
Questions Covered:07:43 – Would it be a stretch to say that the Lazarus and the rich man in Lk 16:19 embody what the Jews believed about the afterlife?16:42 – Does the 1st century evidence support a 3 tier Church governance structure?24:19 – Jesus says to not leave a tribute till we clear up any offense with our brother. Would this mean the tributes we left are meaningless if we haven’t sought forgiveness?34:52 – Is it ok for Catholics to celebrate Christmas during advent?41:31 – My son is getting ready for first confession, but I’m doing all the catechesis at home. The parish told me I needed to go through the parish. Is this right?52:23 – What makes the salvific sufficiency of Christ’ sacrifice?…
Questions Covered:06:07 – What’s the Church’s view on marriage when one person is abandoned by their spouse? Can they remarry?18:02 – Can Catholics believe in predestination?29:49 – Why did Jesus die if it wasn’t to satisfy the wrath of God?43:04 – Can non-Catholics still gain the benefits of the Eucharist even if they don’t believe what Catholics believe?49:16 – Mt 23:9 says call no man father so why do Catholics call priests father?…
Questions Covered:06:31 – Would Mormons be considered Protestants according to Catholics?14:55 – How can the Catholic Church claim to have the fullness of the faith if the resurrection must be taken by faith?22:15 – I’m not Catholic because I don’t always trust the arguments of the apologists.29:01 – Is Jesus eternally subordinate to the Father or are they coequal?34:12 – How can I differentiate devotion to Mary?46:19 – What’s the Church’s position on Genesis 1 and evolution?53:05 – Do you have to go through RCIA if one is baptized in the Lutheran church?…
Questions Covered:02:28 – What was the thorn in Paul’s side?06:48 – When I cited John 20: 21-23 as clear evidence for sacramental confession, a protestant made a claim that the power granted by Christ in those passages died with the apostles.13:10 – At Pentecost, tongues of fire rested on those present, and they spoke in foreign languages (foreign tongues). Is this a play on words? In other languages, especially in Greek, is the word for an anatomical tongue, the same as the word for a slice of fire? Even without a play on words, the coming (from unknown source) of fire often signified the presence of God, so the point of the phenomenon doesn’t rely on the (at least in English) play on words. Does it?16:07 – My husband died in June of brain cancer 5 months after diagnosis. So many good people keep telling me that “he’s in a better place.” Why do they say that when it should be obvious that he should be with me? I understand that we can’t know for certain where a soul goes after death. How do I respond to this? It makes me angry at how easily people toss that cliché out to a woman who is grieving the death of her husband.22:04 – Does the Church have a preferred stance on Darwinism vs Lamarckism?33:36 – The Bible IS a Catholic book. Right. Besides dropping the Deuterocanonical Books, have Protestants in the English-speaking world “mistranslated” words? Like the word Tradition which, in Spanish versions is translated as tradition when is in a negative sense (tradition of men) and teaching when it’s favorable. Is there any in English?40:25 – Jimmy Buffett’s song Coastal Confessions has a line “Bless me father for I have sinned, given the chance I’ll probably do it again.” Would this make the confession null since it seems Jimmy hasn’t fully repented or is it just honestly/humility?46:00 – Where did your Mexican serape blanket that you drape over your chair come from?50:44 – What do you think about the Gospel of the Hebrews? Later patchwork of reworked quotes from the Synoptics? Something contemporary with the Synoptics? A Hebrew version of Matthew? Could it ever be rediscovered?…
Questions Covered:04:35 – My 9yr old daughter, Kateri, would like to ask: “Does God get angry at us? Sometimes He seems angry, especially when we read stories from the Old Testament.”07:37 – I am wondering why Whitey Bulger had a funeral Mass? Are there examples of people the church will not give a funeral Mass for? Also, are there any situations when the church excludes people from being buried in Catholic cemeteries? Does the church provide funeral Masses for non-Catholics?17:50 – After becoming a revert… 30 years ago now…I’m miserable… I thought I could pray a few rosaries and my life would come together…I loved Scott Hahn, and Mother Angelica…but here I sit…waiting…am I just faithless?24:39 – If aliens show up in a major way and submit to testing n such…what would be necessary or possible to prove to the people who think they would have to be demons that they are not? If that made any sense. Like how could you prove conclusively they are not demons? Or would that not be possible?35:55 – In the traditional Anaphora of Mar Addai and Mar Mari, the Eucharist is consecrated without the words of institution. How do we explain it with Catholic sacramental theology?43:30 – There is speculation that the negative response that humans have to the “uncanny valley” is due to some evolutionary development where our ancestors were preyed upon something that looked like humans but wasn’t quite human. What do you think?…
Questions Covered:02:35 – If every soul is guaranteed to go to heaven, why does it matter if you pray for the souls in purgatory?10:28 – Does morality change over time?19:48 – What is meant when Jesus says “I am the son of man”28:46 – How do you minister to people who are suffering and explain that faith can help their suffering?34:18 – Have the verses in Isaiah 63:1-7 come to pass? What do those verses mean?41:36 – Could a pope contradict a previous non infallible papal teaching?48:31 – What does Jimmy think about theistic evolution?51:41 – Once a deacon is ordained to the permanent diaconate, does he have to remain celibate?53:35 – Is there scientific study that shows that people who get prayed for are better off than people who do not get prayed for?…
Questions Covered05:52 – Should someone refrain from becoming Catholic if it would cause division in their marriage?13:28 – What does the word relations mean in Matthew 1:25?17:51 – Do angels have genders?29:04 – the sacrament of extreme unction. Can it take away the need for purgatory?34:45 – Does a high mass have more spiritual value than a low mass?42:14 – Why do you have to be baptized before you can get your marriage annulled?46:42 – Why didn’t the Holy Spirit stop the protestant reformation?51:04 – Was St. Paul ordained by any of the apostles as a bishop? Was he even a bishop at all?…
Questions Covered: 02:24 – How can the Saints handle the quantity of prayers based on Daniel 10:10-14? 10:35 – Is it proper to go to confession for not being able to kneel at the appropriate times at Mass? 13:00 – Is scattering of ashes after cremation allowable? 15:32 – Has Vatican II been interpreted in a strict neo-scholastic way? 19:49 – If there is no wine at Mass can there be a Consecration? 22:25 – Did Paul ordain Linus instead of Peter? 28:59 – Why do Catholic people confess their sins to priests? 32:54 – How can a person who has never heard of Jesus get to heaven? 40:20 – How is it okay for Saint relics to be scattered all over the world? 45:05 – Can you clarify why we have one chalice that we share instead of individual cups? 50:58 – How do we call out our brothers and sisters at Mass for inappropriate behavior?…
Questions Covered:06:47 – Who is the man of lawlessness in the book of 2 Thessalonian? 11:46 – How does purgatory relate to Abraham’s bosom? 20:10 – Is gossiping a mortal sin? 28:58 – Can we receive the Sacrament of Confession over the phone or online? 33:10 – Why is the character Julius in the Bible not a canonized Saint? 36:55 – Is there typology for the Eucharist? 46:34 – How can I know this church holds the truth when others also claim the truth? Resources Mentioned:https://canonlawmadeeasy.com/2020/04/30/confession-over-phone/…
Questions Covered:01:36 – Is there any inherent logic for St. Paul putting so much emphasis on the cross?05:48 – Why is Paul in the bible if he never met Jesus?09:52 – If a person is abused (physically or mentally) in the church and decides to leave, have they committed heresy?15:05 – If I eat and then go to mass, can I still receive communion even If I didn’t plan on going to mass originally?20:55 – Was the story of Jesus just co-opted from the story of Romulus?24:11 – Why would my college professor claim that purgatory was invented in the 11th century? How do I respond to that argument?28:29 – Why don’t Messianic Jews align with the Catholic faith?35:45 – What is the Holy Spirit?41:41 – How did you come to the conclusion that the Catholic Church compiled the bible?45:12 – Are we required to believe in indulgences?47:49 – My fundamentalist friend says that infant baptism is invalid because it does not have apparent fruits. What’s the rebuttal?49:49 – How do we talk to protestants about deification of Mary?51:41 – What is the infinite nature of God?…
Questions Covered:07:38 – What is the Catholic Church’s stance on the current conflict in the Holy Land?15:44 – Have you heard of the Egg Theory story? What are your thoughts on it?28:56 – I’m in RCIA. I’m struggling with the Immaculate Conception. Where did this idea come from and does it have roots in scripture?37:53 – How would you respond to a protestant who asks why they can’t receive communion?42:48 – Do the Jews have writings or records about Jesus?49:17 – How do I confront the ideas like purgatory from a reformed background?…
Cy and Karlo are joined by two guests to test their knowledge on the Catholic Answers Game Show.…
Questions Covered:03:19 – How do Catholics reconcile no salvation outside the Church and Jesus saying if you’re not against us, you’re for us?10:32 – What’s the Church’s view on the Assumption of Elijah as compared to the Assumption of Mary?18:12 – What is the difference between our Church and an ecclesiastical community?20:44 – Protestant friends want to know why we pray to saints, especially the rosary? And how can I understand the rosary better?34:46 – My friend fell away from the Catholic faith. Now I feel uncomfortable sharing my faith with her because she always has something to say about it. How can I continue this friendship?40:50 – What exactly are indulgences and how does the Catholic Church choose what they are?46:28 – Can a Catholic in the Roman rite of the Church understand the teaching of the Eucharist in a way different than how the institution teaches?50:42 – If you have to desire confirmation to get confirmed, shouldn’t you have to desire baptism to get baptized?…
Questions Covered:07:04 – I’ve been reading a lot of Orthodox material. What’s the Catholic explanation as to why they changed the creed to include the filioque?34:29 – What did Jesus mean when he said “do not pray in vain repetition?”43:52 – What’s your advice to me, who has a child with my protestant wife? I want to raise my child Catholic.…
Questions Covered:09:38 – What time does the prohibition to work on Sunday begin?17:06 – What’s the difference between a prophet, a fortune teller and a mystic?34:11 – What are generational demons?40:55 – Are there any books that are hidden gems that you would recommend for someone returning to the faith?49:02 – If we are unable to change our mind after death, then what’s the point of purgatory?…
Questions Covered:09:01 – How do we know that the gospel writers were Matthew, Mark, Luke and John?21:22 – Can you explain what Opus Dei is and what it isn’t?35:18 – What is modernism?44:11 – My house was blessed, but I was living in mortal sin then. I’m no longer living in sin. Do I have to get my house blessed again?49:35 – Were there other gospel writers apart from the four that we know of?…
Questions Covered:06:48 – Will time and space end?15:15 – How do we know what modesty is if it revolves around the culture?31:41 – Why would God command Abraham to sacrifice his son Isaac? Isn’t killing intrinsically evil?41:52 – If a person is conditionally baptized, what happens to the mortal sin on their soul if they were already actually baptized in the original ceremony?49:27 – If God wants to know each of us why doesn’t God reveal himself to everyone?…
Questions Covered:06:02 – How do I respond to the claim that one has to receive communion in both species in order for it to be valid12:30 – I’m a convert. How can I help my father overcome his challenges with Marian devotion?29:21 – I heard that there were 300 texts that were being considered when compiling the bible. Is this true?37:06 – What if you get drunk from communion wine?43:22 – Why doesn’t the Church use eschatological language in its responses anymore?51:22 – What are your thoughts about Lucifer Marian typology?…
Questions Covered:05:24 – What’s the difference between, last right, unction, and extreme unction?10:35 – Can a member of a different rite become pope?17:14 – Did Constantine legalizing Christianity do more harm than good?31:26 – Why was it necessary for Jesus to be baptized? Didn’t he already have the Holy Spirit?38:57 – Did St Jerome replace the word repentance with do penance in the Vulgate to collect alms from people?48:18 – What’s the limit when it comes to Marian devotion?…
Questions Covered:17:41 – What do you do when your husband has never been romantic? The marriage is strong but there’s no romance.29:22 – After you say I’m sorry, and the person says I don’t believe you. What can you do?32:43 – My husband has been verbally abusive after he got sick after 23 years of marriage. Is it wrong for me to want to leave to be happy?47:10 – How do you deal with your spouse if you differ with child rearing?50:41 – How do I do a better job as a husband if I’m constantly being hurt after sharing?…
Questions Covered:17:13 – What am I sacrificing while I’m at mass?23:21 – Do we keep Jesus on the cross because he’s sacrificed for the sin of the past, present and future?32:09 – When exactly does the sacrifice occur during the Mass?35:12 – Does the Todah suggest that he had to institute the eucharist in order to fulfill the scripture?42:13 – Three of my protestant friends converted to Catholicism thanks to Steve’s visit to Salem, OR.44:04 – Why is it so important to determine that the mass is a sacrifice? Are we witnessing a miracle at every mass?48:16 – I truly believe that it is a sacrifice. My husband is a deacon and a mystic and has encountered this sacrifice in a real way.51:48 – Is the physical presence of Jesus actually present in the eucharist?…
Questions Covered:18:12 – What’s your perspective on how to respond to people in the prolife movement who say that the adoption system is broken?23:40 – I’m in my 60’s, what can I do at my age?33:20 – My daughter is adopted and has a wound of rejection. Do you have advice on how to help her?41:10 – I’m an adoptee and have worked in the Juvenile justice system. The courts have a program called Court Appointed Special Advocates that helps as well.44:56 – Are there foster care opportunities for medically fragile infants?49:05 – How can adoption be made more of a first choice instead of second choice?…
Questions Covered:04:45 – The scandals of the Church keep me away. Why did they reinstate Fr. Rupnik?12:08 – I was raised protestant and am now Anglican. Sacraments and works are my stumbling blocks.20:38 – All my social and business life is wrapped around Protestantism. It would take a lot to untangle myself.30:39 – I’m having a hard time figuring out what teachings are infallible while going through the Catechism. This isn’t very clear in the Church.42:31 – I’m impressed with the claim of apostolic succession. According to the Orthodox, apostolic succession was interrupted under Charlemagne in Catholicism.47:16 – The Catholic Church says I have to prove that my divorce was legal? I don’t think that’s right but I am convinced that Catholicism is right.…
Questions Covered:06:58 – Does Jesus have a soul? What’s the difference between a soul and a spirit?16:12 – How would I respond to the argument that the Eucharist is symbolic while the person is using John 6 as evidence for this claim?24:12 – I heard 1 Cor. 11:27-29 is no longer read at mass. Why is that?32:20 – How can I get my infant baptized? There seems to be a lot of red tape.37:15 – How does the Church know when a relic is authentic?42:49 – Is there a need for us in heaven? If so, would that make heaven incomplete without us?46:56 – Before mass begins at my parish, we are instructed to greet each other in the name of Jesus. Are we supposed to call each other Jesus?49:17 – Why can’t the Church just baptize a teen now and have to wait till Easter?52:21 – How would you debate sola scriptura using the bible?…
Questions Covered:03:20 – Is everything stated at a council infallible?11:13 – How can I be a faithful Catholic at a Catholic university where it’s not encouraged?18:57 – Both the Parable of the talents in Matthew and parable of the pounds in Luke 19 read the same. Can you compare and contrast the meaning between those two?24:40 – Why does the Catechism describe purgatory as a place of punishment instead of a place of healing?38:00 – When Jesus sent the apostles out two by two, do we know where they went?43:50 – How long does a plenary indulgence last after you receive it?49:45 – How would we explain relics to a non-Catholic?…
Questions Covered:02:50 – Could you explain why the virgin birth is not a logical contradiction? 07:02 – If you reject the idea of bilocation, what about Padre Pio? 14:30 – I’m an Atheist because of slavery in the bible. How can people of faith rationalize it? 18:06 – Rev. 20 What is the Church’s position on the Millennial reign referred to in Revelation 20? 22:51 – If you evangelize someone with invincible ignorance, are you putting them at risk of going to hell? 31:18 – Are former Catholics who left the Church for Protestantism condemned to hell? 35:04 – If worship is offering sacrifice, then do we not worship Jesus because we don’t offer a sacrifice to him? 37:26 – Did Jesus breathe on the apostles or were the tongues of fire at Pentecost? Comparing the accounts of John and Acts? 43:32 – Does God have accidents in the Aristotelian sense? 47:50 – Wouldn’t Jn 19:25 prove that the brothers of Jesus were actually extended relatives? 51:12 – Can you share some philosophically based resources for talking to Protestant friends and family on the difference between venerating saints rather than worshiping them? …
Topic Covered:Cy and Karlo discuss the communion of saints in honor of the Solemnity of All Saints. …
Questions Covered:02:40 – Why do Orthodox have valid sacraments but the Anglicans don’t?07:47 – How many prophets have been recognized by the Jewish people since Christ?15:04 – If I was married in the Church but I said vows in a language that I didn’t know, would this be grounds for an annulment?18:38 – Could you talk about the Moratorium fragment and how protestants use it to defend sola scriptura?39:26 – Could you explain what Opus Dei is?45:54 – What’s Mary’s birthday and where was she born?49:57 – If Jesus was actually born on March 2 would it still be valid to celebrate his birthday?…
Questions Covered:08:40 – Was Mary free from venial sin as well?16:08 – I’m a convert and my mother is really into crystals. How do I address this since she’s putting them up around the house?22:10 – If a priest is in mortal sin, does it invalidate his sacraments?33:31 – How is it that Mary remained a virgin if Matthew says, “she remained a virgin until the birth of Jesus?”37:06 – Were Adam and Eve real or were they just symbolic?47:44 – If you’ve been baptized once, does getting baptized again do anything?50:56 – What is the biblical evidence for purgatory?…
Questions Covered:14:49 – A Greek Orthodox priest said to me that they didn’t break from us but we broke from them. What’s the response to this?17:38 – Is there patristic evidence for adoration?23:06 – Can you talk about created Grace?32:05 – I’m considering converting to Orthodoxy because Mariology is excessive in the west.36:22 – What’s the difference in the date of Easter between the east and the west?43:02 – Could you address the difference in theology on Theosis?46:17 – I had an Orthodox monk tell me that praying the rosary is not a good thing. How do I reply?…
Questions Covered:06:02 – How do we know that relics are real?11:58 – What book do you recommend giving to my atheist friend?17:59 – Are demons going to enjoy being separated from God for all of eternity?21:48 – How would you respond to the claim that the Church Fathers didn’t believe in transubstantiation?36:50 – Is inflation immoral?45:22 – Why do we no longer number bishops like we do popes?47:25 – Is it worth debating Christians who claim that the church is really for abortion?51:51 – What is my obligation to my adult children? Should I let them remain in ignorance in order to not ruin their chance of salvation?…
Questions Covered:31:28 – What is Augustine’s main obstacle to conversion?35:06 – Why doesn’t Augustine mention anything about his concubine after his conversion? How did he deal with it?…
Questions Covered:05:47 – I don’t believe that life begins at conception.17:20 – I’m pro-choice because I believe in donor rights.37:02 – Assuming Christian theology is based on natural law, nature carries out abortion frequently.45:09 – I think women have a right to their own bodies.47:21 – I want everyone to make the right choice. That’s why I’m pro-choice.50:15 – I go back and forth in the case the case of rape.…
Questions Covered:01:06 – Have you thought about exploring the assassination of the president of Ecuador in 1875 on Mysterious World? It’s said that he was killed by Freemasons.04:35 – What is necessary for salvation?14:42 – Are you familiar with Serapis Christus? Could you talk a little about him?23:59 – What’s the difference between the authority of the catechism vs the code of canon law?32:55 – What’s the proper definition of Sola Scriptura and what’s the best way to defend the faith against it?43:42 – There seems to be a conflict with the two statements: World without end and on the last day. Can you help clarify?47:14 – How do we properly understand predestination and free will?…
Questions Covered:04:30 – When did priests start wearing clerics? 08:10 – Why is there a difference in presentation between fornication and adultery in the Old and New Testaments? 12:30 – Why do they consider Mary as the Immaculate Conception? Is it mainly because of the apparition in Lourdes and Mary identifying herself as so? 14:53 – Where does the long list of mortal sins come from? 22:45 – Why is there such animosity between the Freemasons and the Knights of Columbus? 30:02 – What is the reason Catholics are not taught to heal the sick, make blind men see or raise the dead? 32:37 – Why do eastern and western Catholics have different canon laws? Is canon law infallible? 37:08 – How do I approach my priest who doesn’t properly offer the words of absolution? 42:12 – Is it appropriate for me to use an old, damaged bible for crafts? 46:03 – Why would Mary have to be sinless? …
Questions Covered:03:25 – I want to be Catholic but I’m waiting on an annulment. It’s been 2 years and I feel like it’s never going to end. I feel left out. 19:00 – I have a hard time being a Catholic all the way because people in the Church don’t read the bible? 29:09 – Why does the Catholic Moral tradition exclude consent and stewardship? 41:20 – Is excommunication not applicable to pro-choice Catholic politicians? …
Questions Covered:09:20 – What is the extra biblical tradition that’s part of the deposit of faith?32:15 – Does James 5 mean a mutual confession or a one-way confession?42:56 – When did the pope become infallible?49:09 – Is Judith canonical?…
Questions Covered:03:39 – I’m protestant. What does the language of prayer intention mean?04:55 – How do you as a former protestant, speaking in tongues?15:12 – If angels can appear in dreams, can demons also appear to us in dreams?21:52 – Do we Catholics believe that the eucharist is the physical flesh of Jesus?36:21 – Did Mary’s Immaculate Conception give Mary a pre fall human nature or post fall human?45:48 – How can I explain to a protestant that Jn.19:26-27 is Jesus give Mary to us and not just to John?52:00 – How would you explain that the current Jews are the descendants of the original Israelites for the bible?…
Questions Covered:08:34 – What should I know before going to my first mass?13:34 – What’s the most difficult thing for you today as being a Catholic?18:05 – I’m having a hard time figuring out what I’m supposed to do at a Catholic mass?23:00 – What am I missing as a former protestant and as a Catholic of 1.5 years.?29:38 – Could you give me advice on how to communicate conversion to a spouse?33:22 – My non-Catholic wife joins me to mass often. Usually in the beginning of those books in the pew you have the order of the mass.35:23 – My daughter in college has been invited to a non-denominational church. What resources can I give her to help her rediscover her Catholic faith?42:55 – My 2 sons have left the church. Where can I get that book?49:58 – As a recent convert, how do you deal with possible regret?51:10 – I’m discouraged in my journey to the Catholic faith. I just need advice.…
Questions Covered:01:29 – What evidence is there for Papal Supremacy?10:53 – What is the difference between doctrine, dogma, and discipline?18:01 – How do we as Catholics handle salvation by faith and works?23:32 – If a priest is stripped of his faculties, would that invalidate any of the sacraments he performed?30:48 – I’m not Catholic. I disagree with priestly celibacy.39:48 – The Church seems to deny that Mary had a normal childbirth. Is there a reason for that?46:28 – How do we properly defend the saints?51:36 – How do I deal with someone who subscribes to the historical critical method of reading scripture?…
Questions Covered:06:15 – How do we know that the early Church didn’t arrange the NT in order to establish an organization for self-interests?16:35 – Is forgiveness from sins only through a priest?23:40 – How do you respond to this logic: Jesus says all who receive in body have eternal life, not everyone who receives communion has eternal life, therefore not everyone who receives the host is receiving Jesus body?34:37 – What does it mean to make a general confession? How does one go about doing one?41:25 – I think the title of Co-Redemptrix can lead people away. What are our thoughts on this title?47:00 – How can I have people take me seriously and be heard in the Church?…
Questions Covered:34:28 – It sounds like you guys are doing damage control for the Synod. …
Questions Covered:20:27 – Where do annulments come into play when children are involved?23:39 – My diocese requires a civil divorce before obtaining an annulment. What are your thoughts on this?30:01 – Isn’t it true that if a person wasn’t married in a Church to a non-Catholic without a dispensation, it would make the marriage invalid?34:02 – You’re right in saying that therapists will tell a couple to abstain to get in touch with the emotional component.40:09 – How do I get my intimacy back with my husband now that we entered the brother and sister phase?43:39 – I want to share my reason why I remained celibate.46:29 – Wouldn’t it be more prudent to file for an annulment before a divorce in case the annulment is rejected?50:59 – Some dioceses may reject an annulment while another will. Keep on trying!…
Questions Covered:04:25 – What did Jesus mean when he called himself the Son of Man?12:11 – What’s the best way to evangelize an 18-year-old?16:33 – I tend to see recurring numbers that sometimes bother me. Should I as a Catholic not read into this?28:41 – Can we assume that a person is in heaven if they receive an emergency baptism and die immediately afterwards?35:00 – I’m considering getting a job at a coffee shop. Could I take the job if they don’t specify what charities they support?40:47 – Is it okay to replace fasting with something else if you’re recovering from an eating disorder?44:49 – How do I know when to take a sign from God seriously and how to discern what is and is not a sign?49:34 – Did Christ’ deity die on the cross?…
Questions Covered:05:14 – Where did all the sects of Judaism come from in the time of Jesus and where did they get their authority?10:37 – Intercessory pray and redemptive suffering How was St. Therese of Lisieux able to intercede for a person who was put to death and sway him if God cannot affect his free will?16:51 – When did praying to Mary become a thing in Catholicism?23:27 – How do I respond to the claim that if 2 popes contradict each other in ex cathedra statements, we are challenging divinely inspired teaching? In other words, do we do what we accuse protestants of doing?31:40 – Why is it that the apocrypha aren’t accepted by the Jews, and why then do we accept them?36:48 – I’m Methodist and my church just split because of female clergy. What does the Catholic Church say about female clergy?44:12 – How should we treat the LGBT community?50:03 – Is it better to pray in a church or in a chapel with the eucharist exposed?…
Questions Covered:28:46 – Can God make the devil not exist?33:01 – Does Joe think the pope in his magisterium can teach heresy?43:12 – If God’s will is going to be done, why do we have to pray for one another?50:04 – Is evolution compatible with Genesis?53:17 – Why don’t Catholics believe in the rapture?…
Topic Covered:Cy and Joe interview Raymond Cardinal Burke on the Dubia and the Synod on Synodality …
Questions Covered:22:00 – How does apostolic succession in Anglicanism and Orthodoxy affect the validity of their sacraments, especially the eucharist?32:57 – I’m protestant and have been looking into Catholicism. What’s your advice for someone who is getting overwhelmed with so much information?43:04 – Does a Church have a view on Christians being persecuted in Europe for not going along with the transgender movement?50:38 – I don’t think only Catholics are going to heaven. All we need is to believe in Jesus and the Bible.…
13:27 – Is locker room talk and locker room behavior considered a mortal sin?20:24 – When V2 allowed communion under 2 species and concelebration, were there other times before V2 when that was allowed?28:23 – I’m in RCIA. Do you have advice for someone who is very concerned about the end time?32:54 – As a lay Catholic I try to be witness to my faith. How can I best witness to my eastern orthodox friend?38:59 – What does it mean to get consecrated? I’ve been reading St. Louis de Montfort’s consecration to Mary book? Is it possible to be consecrated to 2 or more saints?43:21 – With all the chaos and war happening in the world, can we assume that we are in the tribulation?46:47 – What is the pain like in Purgatory?…
Cy and Karlo welcome on contestants Amy and Jim to battle it out on the Catholic Answers Game Show …
Questions Covered:04:31 – In light of Romans 3, how could anyone outside of the Church be justified?10:04 – Based on Matthew 24. can the faithful really be inadvertently lost?14:15 – As a new convert who had poor RCIA, how should I move forward if I still don’t accept some teachings like the Immaculate Conception?20:08 – Jn 6:55-66. Have you encountered arguments against this verse from protestants?28:22 – Some Catholics argue that NFP should rarely be used. Do things that can be mitigated by prudence like financial stability count as grave reasons in justifying the use of NFP?32:33 – Why do animals have to suffer?40:00 – How do I talk to an atheist friend who doesn’t believe in souls?44:35 – Are wearing crystals because they ‘give off good energy’ be considered the occult?48:38 – What is the scriptural basis for baptism by desire? Could Jesus do something similar for those who can’t receive the Eucharist?51:41 – The CCC says we come to know Jesus through the Holy Spirit. But how can we say that if the bible says we come to know him through the breaking of the break and the real presence of the Eucharist?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:01:05 – Is there any validity to the claim that the veil torn in the temple during the death of Christ was made by the Virgin Mary?07:20 – My Orthodox friends consider ecumenism to be heresy. Why don’t we consider it so?16:42 – Where can I find in the bible that the Catholic Church is the church that Jesus founded?28:37 – Am I opening myself to the demonic world if I go to a haunted house?34:06 – How does the Church explain death before the fall especially if Catholicism isn’t in tension with evolution?42:08 – I’m not Catholic. My Catholic family always pushes Fatima. It doesn’t seem spectacular as they make it. Am I missing something?50:53 – My religion teacher told us that Jesus wasn’t actually born on December 25th. Is this true?53:18 – Why doesn’t the pope approve of Medjugorje?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:04:22 – I’ve heard of numerous protestant eucharistic miracles. Is this a possibility? 11:30 – How do I refute the claim that Rev 3:10 supports the rapture theory? 19:58 – How do we know that the writings of St. Ignatius of Antioch are reliable? 28:35 – Is there anyone I can work with to start getting Catholic content in audio format since I’m visually impaired? 37:23 – Is it immoral to check the box to say that you’ve read the terms and service of an agreement? 43:08 – You mentioned at the conference something about animals having souls. If they do, would it be wrong to euthanize my horse? …
Questions Covered:Joe – 06:03 – You were a huge impact on me and my journey from Calvinism to Catholicism. So thank you and never stop! Since converting, I’ve noticed when “Protestants argue like Atheists”, but I’ve also recently come to notice when “Protestants argue like Agnostics”. This usually happens when I bring up something in Scripture that denominations disagree on. The result is something like “Well, we can’t know for sure, so it’s best not to take a stance on it”, or “That’s not a main issue so I’m not going to judge anyone else for taking that stance, what’s important is that they have faith in Jesus.” Have you come across this, and how do you suggest furthing a conversation once it reaches that point? 16:28 – Trent, I hope you are doing well today! I had a question. I was going over your “Arguing Against Abortion” course at the School of Apologetics, and I was kind of confused about something and wanted to get some clarity! In Section VI. of the course: Answering Arguments from “Hard Cases”, when rape is mentioned here there is a part where the Ethical and Religious Directives for Catholic Health Care Services speaks of being able to “Defend herself against potential conception from the sexual assault.” Is this saying that a sort of “contraception” can be used to help prevent conception or the fertilization of the egg, and if so, is this an exception and not a rule? Also, Have you found it harder to defend the Catholic church’s view on contraception after arguing this point? 23:08 – What is a good, well rounded “elevator speech” for why be Catholic vs other Christian denominations? I’ve been trying to convert my non denominational brother and sister in law and every time I give them biblical proof or historical proof of their position being different than the early Christian’s – they don’t seem to care. 28:18 – Hello Trent, please strictly consider the text of Mark’s Gospel Chapter 9, verse 1. If Jesus really said the words attributed to him, does that mean Jesus’ second coming is a failed prophesy? In other words, that it’s safe to say the second coming is a prediction that never came true. Thank you! 32:08 – Hello Trent! Do you have any advice for a beginner apologist? Any advice on how to bring people to Christ through the intellectual side of Christianity, and do so with gentleness and respect? I know you do this very well, so I thought it would be worth asking. Thank you for all you do. 35:47 – How can we get a secular person to agree that using sex for something other than “babies and bonding” is a bad thing without appealing to religion? Most secular people I talk to about sexually disordered acts believe that using sex for something other than it’s natural purposes is morally irrelevant, and I’m not sure how to convince them otherwise without bringing in theology. 40:57 – Are nuclear weapons inherently evil? Do we as Catholics have a moral obligation to avoid working with or in companies that produce or manufacture nuclear weapons, or nuclear weapon support systems? Would you consider the proliferation of nuclear weapons a pro life topic like abortion? 45:47 – In a psychology course, we had an online discussion board assignment where we were given this dilemma: A man’s wife is terminally ill, but there is one drug that will cure her. However, this drug is extremely expensive and they can’t afford it. Would it be morally wrong for the man to steal the drug? How would you apply Catholic moral teaching to this situation? Personally, I would not want to risk the state of my soul by doing something even potentially wrong – stealing the drug – to cure a loved one. I was surprised that almost all the students said that it would NOT be wro…
Questions Covered:04:25 – What is the first thing you look for when you hear an argument for the opposing side?07:20 – What’s the best way to explain why we need the Marian dogmas, and why Mary plays an important role for Catholics?13:41 – What is the catholic stance on ghost apparitions? Can you be a faithful catholic and believe in ghosts?David – 20:55 – Why is the term ‘Christ’ frequently used in place of the name ‘Jesus’? Is not ‘Christ’ a title or a role (i.e., Messiah) rather than a name? Using the term ‘Christ’ seems to diminish Jesus’s full identity as fully man and fully God.33:39 – Can you (Trent) please comment on what I think is a very underutilized apologetic argument against Protestantism: You can have sola scriptura and the perspicuity of scripture, you can have the epistle of James, you can have sola fide, BUT YOU CAN’T HAVE ALL THREE! And when one falls, they all fall. That’s the protestant three-legged stool.41:58 – Could you answer why you believe reasonable people disagree? It’s hard to imagine why so many smart people debate topics like the ones you address and seemingly few of them budge. This question can easily be asked in other areas like politics, and science.48:19 – Can you respond to the atheist “unintelligent design” argument?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:06:55 – What are your thoughts on the apparent contradiction in the policy of the Vatican that says women have to be dressed modestly but it’s filled with naked statues?14:20 – How should I love someone who has a different viewpoint than I do?17:59 – How does suffering of living family members affect family members that have passed?22:50 – Why did Jesus stay at the temple when Mary and Joseph lost him?31:14 – My daughter in college took a history course that said Hitler was Catholic in order to associate Catholicism with evil. Was he Catholic?37:11 – What is the role of new miracles if public revelation is closed?42:42 – How can I counter protestants who say that you need to believe in order to be baptized?50:30 – If I get my child baptized through the Baptist church, would the Catholic Church be required to accept it?53:01 – I’m a new Christian. Luke 9:50 and Luke 11:23 seem to contradict on those who are not with us. Can you clarify this for me?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:06:20 – What is the Catholic understanding of imputed righteousness vs infused righteousness?17:06 – Is it wrong to say praying with the saints instead of praying to the saints?23:40 – How can I support my nephew who is changing genders from a Catholic perspective?37:23 – Why do Catholics keep making idols/statues/icons/graven images, when God specifically asked you not to make graven images?42:37 – How do we know that God hasn’t moved on from the Catholic Church like he did with the Jewish faith?48:10 – How do we have faith in the current situation in the Holy Land?52:26 – How come Jesus is from the tribe of Judah and his cousin John was from the tribe of Levi?…
Questions Covered:02:28 – Does the Holy Spirit have chromosomes since the Holy Spirit came over Mary and she became pregnant with Jesus? 03:26 – Did Zoroaster Fulfill all of the prophecies for a savior hundreds of years before Jesus did? 10:55 – Does time always move forward, and is there time in heaven? 18:44 – I’ve been listening to a lot of stories on Bigfoot and aliens lately. What are The Church’s teachings in regard to these types of creatures/sightings? 21:56 – We are not supposed to spread ashes of the deceased, but relics of saints are spread far and wide. Is there a reason for these seemingly illogical practices? 28:17 – What sacraments can Angels administer? And can they confect the sacraments? We know the Angel at Fatima gave the children communion. I’ve also heard of an angel that had heard confession for someone and was disguised as a priest. (Not sure how true that one is though.) 35:57 – Why do Muslim woman cover their heads, and Mary and Elizabeth covered their heads, but CHRISTIAN women these days do not. (I’m certainly not campaigning for Christian women to wear hijabs. I was just wondering.) 51:53 – What are we to make of the “sword of St. Michael” — the straight line of seven monasteries, all of them built on a mountain or tall hill, and stretching from Ireland to Israel? Each monastery was built in a different time by different people, and yet they all appear to line up perfectly, as if by design. Was it by design? And if so, whose, and to what end? …
Questions Covered:02:47 – In John 10:16, is it possible that Jesus was referring to extraterrestrial life when He said “And I have sheep that are not of this fold. I must bring them also, and they will listen to my voice.”? 07:37 – Hypothetically, if there was a global religious catastrophe and all clergy members were killed except one priest, would that priest automatically become the pope? And follow up: if all the clergy were killed, how would the faithful go about rebuilding the church given that there are no priests/bishops left to ordain new members? 16:00 – Is it possible that my dog is actually my guardian angel who is temporarily in the form of a dog? 17:51 – I think about the doctrine of Divine simplicity and the afterlife. If God is not made of any parts, what are we going to see when in heaven? Or what is he going to reveal to us if he is so simple. 19:37 – I heard that Lucifer’s rebellion was that God revealed the Incarnation of the Son, for which he refused to serve a man. Does that mean it wasn’t revealed that God is Trinitarian? I’m assuming that because God is omnipresent, the Son is God and is man. 21:33 – What are your thoughts on spontaneous human combustion? Is there evidence it’s happened, and what would be a possible explanation for it? 28:35 – What evidence is there that humans matured earlier in life in Christ’s time? 33:48 – What would the moral implications be of joining an expedition to colonize Mars or other planet, knowing that there would not be access to any sacraments indefinitely? 38:44 – If Christ made a visit to all continents together with Joseph, Mary, and the apostles (just like a Papal visit) before He was crucified, would the world have become Christians? 42:52 – Did Jesus have opinions? Such as having a favorite food or favorite color? Would these be the results of random biology and environment as He grew up? 48:00 – If an animal (let’s say a dolphin) were artificially made more intelligent, like to a human level, would that dolphin be able to be baptized? Would it be basically a human with regards to the afterlife? If not, what change would be required to make an animal into a person? How would this be the same or different from a scenario where we discover intelligent space aliens? 52:50 – What happened to the Holy prepuce? …
Questions Covered:14:23 – How am I supposed to get answers from God or my guardian angel?20:37 – When I pray sometimes I feel like I’m talking to myself. How do I approach prayer while feeling like God is listening?33:21 – How do we do mental prayer correctly?38:06 – Why does the Our Father say “lead us not into temptation?” It makes it sound like God is the cause of our temptation. The Spanish version doesn’t translate the same?48:17 – Could you elaborate more on Pope Benedict’s prayer that you just quoted? Where can we find it?49:46 – Could you talk about how important it is to just “show up” when it comes to prayer life?…
Questions Covered:18:51 – Jn. 10:16 If there are other sheep, where else would they have heard of Jesus?21:46 – Since Matthew 1:25 says that Joseph did not have relations with Mary until the birth of Jesus, does this mean Mary wasn’t a perpetual virgin?26:45 – Where is purgatory in the bible? How do you respond to the claim once saved always saved?34:21 – If the bible has contradictions, can I still believe it is the inspired word of God?38:55 – Wisdom 14:17 says they weren’t supposed to make images of the king to honor. Does this mean we Catholics aren’t supposed to make images of saints to honor?45:16 – I know there are a lot of different views on when the actual day Jesus was born. With that in mind, when is Jesus’ birthday?47:23 – Will your book be available in audiobook format?50:27 – Does the bible say that salvation only comes through the Catholic Church, or can it be attained through other denominations?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:07:44 – What’s the morality of espionage? Resource mentioned: https://stpaulcenter.com/06-nv-10-2-petri-wahl/15:55 – If the Church is pro-life then what does the Church make of politicians who contradict her teachings?23:29 – I teach RCIA and received this question: How was the second pope elected?28:57 – What book can I give my Southern Baptist friend who has been asking about Catholicism?34:50 – By what authority can people of other religions perform exorcisms according to the Church?44:20 – Does the bible ever say to pray to anyone other than God?52:56 – My daughter transitioned, and I’m really worried about her soul. What can I do to help undo the spiritual damage caused by this sin?…
Questions Covered:
05:10 – “Catholics, could you give me an example of taking veneration too far, improperly worshiping a saint?” 09:52 – Paul says that a bishop should be “husband of one wife.” Does this argue against priestly celibacy? 14:52 – Do you think that a near-perfect image of the Trinity is found in human beings as mind-body-soul composites? 18:03 – Could you expound on Proverbs 3:5-6 and Psalm 119:5? 37:30 – Is it wrong to go to confession if you are not a Catholic? 47:46 – My friend is Catholic but married a Muslim and converted to Islam, will she still go to heaven? 51:29 – Is there a good commentary on the Nicene creed? 52:48 – What are Joe’s thoughts on the visions/prophecies of Fatima?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
04:23 – When Jesus sent out the 72 disciples in pairs of two, what was the gospel they preached? Jesus hadn’t yet suffered, died, risen, or ascended, and he hadn’t even proclaimed the fullness of his teachings yet, nor had he instituted the Eucharist or sent the Holy Spirit – so what was their “good news?” 07:53 – Why does God permit the damnation of souls He created? 10:47 – Did the Donner party commit unrepentant mortal sin? 18:55 – Is there a word in English that rhymes with Orange? 20:03 – Who is Joseph in this prayer? “Lord God, who left us the signs of your Passion on the Holy Shroud in which your most holy body was wrapped when you were lowered from the cross by Joseph, grant us, most loving Lord, that by your holy death and burial and by the sorrows and sufferings of your holy Mother Mary, our Lady, that the souls in Purgatory may be brought to the glory of the resurrection where you live and reign with God the Father, in the unity of the Holy Spirit, God for ever and ever. Amen.” 23:08 – But how do you tell if something is the will of God versus the will of another human being imposed upon you? 28:36 – Is there a definitive theology concerning wealth, and if not, why not? 33:02 – Help me out with the elusive “hold hands/orans posture” vs. no change in posture during the Our Father for the laity. If both are allowed now, what would be the reason in favor of doing the hand hold/orans posture? 44:49 – I would be interested in your thoughts on the late paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren (husband-and-wife demonologist/clairvoyant trance medium, allegedly employed by the Catholic church on occasion). They remain part of popular culture thanks to the “Annabelle” and “The Conjuring” films. 49:01 – How can we counter Protestants who name the same tired insults regarding the Blessed Virgin Mary as Mother of God as well as the false claims that we worship her? 51:55 – Why do Catholics all shake hands at the reenactment of the Crucifixion of Jesus?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
6:14 – What do you make of the statement in 1 Maccabee 12:21 and it’s accuracy? Could the Greek demonym Danaans be for members of the tribe of Dan, so that some Greeks were once Jews? 14:49 – I understand a common answer on Catholic Answers is that the era of “public revelation” ended with the death of the Apostle John. Any further revelation is considered “private” and not binding to the faithful. My question is, “Why?” Wouldn’t the era public revelation have ended with the Ascension of Christ? If not – and original apostles could add to public revelation, then why not their disciples, and the disciples of their disciples, etc.? 20:06 – I have several follow-up questions to Michael’s question: In Lamentabili Sane, Pope Pius X condemned the following proposition (#21): “Revelation, constituting the object of the Catholic faith, was not complete with the Apostles.” Was there any magisterial precedence for this condemnation? After the publication of Lamentabili Sane, many theologians restated the condemned proposition as a positive statement: “Revelation was completed with the death of the last apostle.” But in more recent years, some theologians are stepping back from that positive statement. If Public Revelation did not end with the death of the last apostle, is there a definite time, event, or condition which closed the era of Revelation? Could you walk us through the steps to show how “Revelation was completed with the death of the last apostle” is not infallible teaching, if that is the case? Thanks in advance! 28:56 – Could the intro to the gospel of John be discussing the pre-incarnate Christ? I’ve heard this as an opinion held by some. Note that the verses talk about Jesus coming into his own before in verses 10 through 13, before announcing he became flesh in Verse 14. Is this a plausible interpretation? Did any of the fathers hold it? 36:37 – The book of Jonah: history or parable? 42:30 – When Jesus performed various miracles in the gospels, why did He tell the recipients not to tell anyone what He had done? Why did He want His miraculous deeds to be kept secret? 47:23 – Could God create a rock too heavy for him to lift? 50:15 – When the stone was rolled back from the tomb, what became of the cord and seal?
…
Questions Covered:
15:26 – Would these synthetic embryos be soulless when they become full grown adults? 23:53 – Do the scientists who work on the embryos consider them humans or just scientific objects? 31:10 – Doesn’t anyone believe in the healing power of God instead of just depending on science? 37:25 – How are we supposed to think about it philosophically if humans create other humans and whether they have souls? 42:35 – If life begins at conception, then how does one enforce laws around miscarriages? 46:26 – Could plan B be ethical if you take the approach of self-defense in a situation of rape? 50:17 – Why would it be unethical to end a life if the quality of life is low?
…
Questions Covered:
11:28 – My cousins don’t go to church anymore. What’s the best way to share the gospel with them? 16:36 – Would you consider making the appeal to get the tabernacle to be placed at the center of the Church to help restore faith? 29:35 – I’m a new Catholic. What are the best practices to start evangelizing? 35:20 – How can we best evangelize in a difficult situation at a funeral? 42:30 – What’s a good starting point when talking about Catholicism? 45:52 – Thank you for sharing the beautiful message to the caller at the funeral. 52:47 – Why do some churches say the Nicene Creed, and some say the Apostles Creed?
…
Questions Covered:
2:04 – Does the bible imply Judas is damned based on Mt. 26:24, Mt. 19:28 and others? 8:34 – I’m reading The Lost Page by Joe Morris. How true is it that we’re missing the last part of the Gospel of Mark? 21:28 – If the bible does not allow divorce, then why does the Church approve annulments? 36:09 – Does the bible condemn yoga? 43:00 – Could you talk about the unforgivable sin against the Holy Spirit? 45:48 – What does Jesus mean when he said he came to not bring peace but a sword? 51:00 – Why are there unnecessary connections between Isaiah and St. Peter?
…
Open Forum:
06:58 – Was it accepted by the Church that the writings of the NT were written by the people they were named after? 15:54 – Who are the Edomites? Are they white people? Have they been destroyed yet? 21:41 – Who went to Rome first, Peter or Paul? 28:48 – Are there any female angels? Are Lilith and the Succubus real? 34:02 – How do I dispose of a bible in a respectful way? 37:08 – What’s the point of seeing the bread and wine as sacrificial offerings? Wasn’t Jesus supposed to be the sacrificial offering? 46:26 – If something is permitted in the Torah, does that mean it can’t be intrinsically evil?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:07:17 – What would be the effect on the human soul if it would not be born with original sin?15:36 – If Adam and Eve didn’t sin would animals and plants still be dangerous?18:15 – Is watching Mass on TV considered fulfilling one’s obligation?20:04 – Why does the Latin rite have extraordinary ministers of holy communion since the other rites don’t? It doesn’t seem like a very Catholic practice.31:20 – What is a Catholic free to believe regarding the dropping of the atom bombs?40:10 – Is it unethical to secretly put holy water in my atheist friend’s drink?44:32 – If one has committed a mortal sin one should go to confession as soon as possible. How soon does the ‘soon’ need to be?49:05 – When we receive communion in the host we receive the body and blood. When was that declared?…
Topics Covered:00:45 – The Mongolian empire and the lost Christians of the east.4:00 – Pope Francis’ comments in Russia23:30 – Pope Francis’ comments regarding the Church in the United States…
Topics Covered:19:29 – The Burning Man Situation48:55 – Pope Francis’ Visit to Mongolia…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:1:00 – Fr. Mitch Pacwa says if we collect all the relics of the true cross, we would have about ⅓ of a cross.06:53 – Psalm 37:4 and Mark 11:24. What would be a balanced perspective on understanding these verses?12:37 – How would one explain the need for purification after death to a Protestant?18:19 – How does being a Christian and living with depression and anxiety coexist with joyfulness?31:32 – What happens to your body when you die?34:05 – Can a pope change tradition? How do we distinguish small t and capital T tradition especially when considering capital punishment?45:20 – What is the likelihood that the Orthodox will reunite with Rome in our lifetime?47:08 – Why does Jesus tell his followers to buy a sword in Luke 22?…
Questions Covered:03:57 – Whose opinion takes precedence when choosing music for liturgies?14:03 – What does one do with cremated remains?18:53 – Where did the mysteries of the rosary come from?23:40 – How can grandparents respond to grandchildren who have divorced parents, one of which is not Catholic and telling them that the Eucharist is just a symbol? Our daughter takes them to Mass when she has them but half the time they are with their father who is Baptist. We want them to respect both parents and do not want to say or do anything to impact their relationship negatively with either of them. Still, we want them to know and understand Church teaching. What should we do?28:55 – How do I explain the word flesh mentioned in John 6?34:04 – Where should one start when wanting to read scripture? 42:37 – What are the Biblical and Church teachings about having sexual relations before marriage?45:52 – If you ask for the intercession of two people and receive a miracle, which person gets the credit?48:58 – Was there a concept of a Passover before Moses?51:18 – Why do the Orthodox who do not follow the Pope still continue to have apostolic succession with valid sacraments? I was always told that Catholic splinter groups like the SSPX would lose their apostolic succession after the last validly ordained priest in their group died. Is this not true?53:01 – I hope this point’s not obscure. it’s a point about clarifying the actual name of the Father, Trinity’s First Person. some insist that the spelling should be either YHVH, or YHWH, or Yahweh. i know almost no Hebrew & i nevertheless want to call God the Father Jehovah. Even during internal prayer, i sometimes salute The Father as Father Jehovah. Am i blaspheming when i say “Jehovah”? Do I need to play it safe; & just say: “Our Father”? …
Questions Covered:11:59 – Why did God create lice? 15:54 – Is it a sin to participate in Protestant communities? 19:45 – Why does Jesus tell people to not say anything after he performs a miracle? What is limbo? 30:04 – During the Mass, why do we “dare” to say the Our Father? I’m curious about the use of the word “dare” since the Our Father is one of our most common prayers. 34:30 – How do you counter the argument that we are small and insignificant in the wide scope of the universe, so why would God care about us? 44:43 – My question is, what is some biblical support for offering up our suffering for others? 50:40 – How old was Mary when she conceived and what would be the significance of her being so young? …
Questions Covered:
06:29 – What’s the teaching on the Kabbalah tradition in Judaism? 11:33 – I’m protestant. What’s the rebuttal to the 7th day Adventist claim of the Sabbath still being on Saturday? 18:41 – What important teachings are in the 7 books that Catholic bibles have that protestants don’t have? 22:35 – What’s the best argument for Jesus being the Messiah and that the Church was founded by Jesus? 35:39 – I’m protestant and my husband is Catholic. This is a second marriage for both of us. We believe that we both divorced due to biblical reasons. Why wouldn’t the Church recognize our marriage? 41:24 – What’s the history of the Roman part of the Roman Catholic Church? 46:13 – What’s your advice to a lifelong anti-Catholic Baptist who is now feeling drawn to the Church?
…
Questions Covered:
12:10 – What is your take on Hollywood and the theory that they are Satan worshippers? 14:09 – Why do Catholics pray to saints? 19:36 – How is it possible for God to create light but not make the sun till the fourth day? 31:57 – I’m having a hard time understanding Jesus as a sacrifice on an emotional level. 34:10 – Could you explain the selling of indulgences? 40:36 – Could you explain what the Church means when they say that drunkenness is a sin? 46:38 – Who has authority to define doctrine? 49:53 – Could you explain Mary’s sinlessness and perpetual virginity?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:5:40 – Why do you want us to support the Vatican church that supported Fascist Italy in World War 2? Where was the Vatican’s stance on the ethnic cleansing of Jews?12:30 – Are there others apart from Catholics, Orthodox and Muslims that honor Mary? What does that honor look like in Islam?18:10 – When does death occur? Is it morally permissible to be an organ donor?23:57 – Why did God have no beginning?28:40 – Are haunted dolls real? If so, how are they possessed?34:12 – Before I became Catholic, was I culpable for knowing that salvation came from the Church?42:10 – Where did John the Baptist get the rite of baptism?50:15 – Acts 22 says Paul was a Roman citizen. How would authentication work?52:41 – How do you respond to the atheist claim that you don’t have to be Christian to be moral?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:06:15 – My daughter is a lapsed Catholic and her issue is the problem of evil. What’s the best way to explain this?16:00 – My husband and I were lukewarm Catholics when we got married. I’ve gotten closer to faith while he’s gotten further away. What does obedience to him look like in our situation?24:39 – Does canon 1404 mean that no one can judge the pope except for God?32:21 – Do we know what Jesus and the temple teachers were discussing in Luke 2?34:12 – Why doesn’t the Church just admit that Joseph and Mary had other children?43:38 – How is a rite of passage like a Quinceanera intermingled with the mass? Are there official guidelines for it?47:39 – If Jesus and Mary are in their physical bodies in heaven, would this also mean that the saints are too?51:12 – How do I explain the title of Mary, Mother of God to my protestant friends? Shouldn’t it be, Mother of Jesus?…
Questions Covered:
04:15 – I don’t understand the Synod. I’m not Catholic but what are your thoughts on it? 11:40 – How is praying the rosary and praying to statues not idolatry? 20:29 – Why are protestant baptisms accepted in the Catholic Church? 29:00 – Can you explain patron saints? 35:04 – Why do some people get exposed to the full teachings and others don’t? 41:25 – In John 6, could it be possible that the disciples left due to his claim that he came from heaven and not due to cannibalism? 48:22 – Do all Catholics who die go to purgatory? 49:24 – Where does the Church come up with all the different choirs of angels? 52:18 – Why is it assumed that Catholics don’t read or know the bible?
…
Questions Covered:
08:57 – If someone has obstacles entering the church formally, can they just start going to Mass and start receiving Communion on their own? 17:18 – I don’t think praying to the saints makes sense. Wouldn’t this undermine God? 29:10 – What are the qualifications to fit under papal infallibility? 35:15 – Purgatory doesn’t make sense to me. Also, why isn’t it good enough to just pray to God? 45:12 – Why did the church stop giving us the precious blood? 50:04 – I think the Church interprets Mt. 16:18-19 correctly?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
05:55 – Why do we need to make payment for temporal consequences of sin? 17:40 – Is the Church required to have a daily mass? Can a parish remove a Saturday mass? 22:40 – How can the trinity be eternal if we use words like generate, or beget to describe Him? 32:27 – What is the foundation of Catholicism’s claim of marriage being elevated to a sacrament? 36:09 – I’m Evangelical and am looking into Catholicism. Could you explain the communion of saints? How do you justify bad behavior in the hierarchy in the past? 44:54 – What happens to the souls of children who were miscarried? 50:00 – My niece is getting married outside of a church building with a Catholic priest. I thought this wasn’t allowed. Can you clarify? 52:46 – Did John the Baptist baptize with the Trinitarian formula?
…
Questions Covered:
14:50 – What are your thoughts on the Synod’s upcoming conversations on the LGBT movement? 18:36 – I have 2 young daughters. What advice would you give on how to affirm them in being children of God? 34:01 – I work with a woman who is transitioning her child. I don’t know if I can socialize with this person in my home. Any thoughts? 41:07 – I’m in college and am in a lot of classes where these issues come up. How do I approach these topics as a Catholic where I might be condemned for my views? 45:20 – How can we discuss these issues as Catechists?
…
Questions Covered:
05:23 – Where did the other people in Genesis in the story of Cain’s exile come from? 12:08 – How would you explain different nationalities if we all came from Adam and Eve? 15:19 – What does the Catholic Church teach and represent? 19:17 – If Peter was married what is the reason for the Catholic Church to have priestly celibacy? 30:38 – should the argument of priestly celibacy even include the conversion about Peter being married since he was married before he started following Jesus? 33:45 – Why should anyone believe in the Catholic Church instead of any other Protestant church? 40:54 – How come we don’t walk barefoot in Church since Moses was ordered to take off his sandals in the presence of God? 44:21 – How old is the bible? What’s the oldest print we have? 47:02 – How do you refute the claim that Luke 11:51 implies the inclusion of the canon of Old Testament? 49:22 – How would you look at a protestant and know if they’re a Christian?
…
Question Covered:
04:53 – How do I respond to someone who asks why we pray to Mary? 10:05 – How do we move forward from infidelity and regain the trust that was lost? 14:56 – The bible says to give to Cesar what is Cesars. Who decides what belongs to Cesar? 18:59 – I grew up a reformed Baptist and looking into Catholicism. Where do I start? 30:36 – My daughter has been missing for 10 months. How do I keep my faith during this hard time? 34:33 – I had a dream about being reprimanded by a priest for not holding the patent correctly during mass. What should I make of this? What are your thoughts on a general confession? 40:54 – How do I reconcile the two bible verses: picking up your cross daily and taking up Jesus’ yoke because it’s light? 45:38 – I want to encourage Carson, I was on a similar path and now I’m Catholic. 50:10 – Parable of the talents had 100% success rate how would this apply for those who aren’t always successful?
…
Questions Covered:
01:38 – When I was in seminary, I was taught that rabbis thought the name of God revealed in Exodus wasn’t the whole name of God. Rather, to say the whole name of God you’d have to effectively speak the whole Torah at once. Was this a real belief they had? 09:53 – Why might the gospel writers be considered more like editors than authors? 20:35 – What does “anathema” mean? Can someone be reconciled after it? 28:50 – When is the soul united to the person? Is it created by God at the moment of conception or does it exist prior? 41:35 – Who is responsible for compiling the Bible as we know it today? 48:00 – Could a Christian be involved in something like the Manhattan Project?
…
Questions Covered:
02:40 – How can we hold to unconditional election without falling into double predestination? 12:08 – Why did God allow men to have multiple wives in the Old Testament? 18:55 – If good is convertible with being, and evil is a privation of good, then how can we talk about evil being a thing at all? And if evil is a privation, what purpose does it have? 28:53 – I have an elderly friend in a terrible state and I have no idea what to pray for because I don’t think they’re going to be healed. 32:23 – What support does the Church offer for people who are spiritually gifted (i.e. see visions of deceased people). 40:13 – If the Carmelite nuns in Fort Worth continue to refuse to recognize their bishop’s authority, is it possible for him to excommunicate them? 49:25 – What’s your best defense for the existence of purgatory?
…
Questions Covered:
03:05 – Can I go to Mass or receive Communion if you are dating someone in an invalid marriage? If not, what steps do we need to take? 05:35 – Is there a concern about people worshiping Mary? Can people go too far? 14:06 – Are the Marian doctrines of her being sinless or a perpetual virgin against scripture? 28:25 – Who was the first member of the human race to die in a state of grace? (Baltimore catechism question from Daughter who is with her) 33:26 – Do you have a consistent interpretive framework for Catholicism? 42:20 – Is the SSPX in schism? 45:19 – Can you explain the history of the change in not eating pork, shrimp, and shellfish? 48:05 – What does it mean to consecrate yourself or family to Mary or Joseph? 49:49 – The famous philosopher, Blaise Pascal, said that God doesn’t exist, but we should believe in Him anyways. Is justified belief in God possible?
…
Questions Covered:
02:55 – As a Catholic I became the Godfather to my nephew in the Lutheran Missouri Synod. Is this okay and if not what can I do to correct this? 04:57 – What is my moral obligation or duties as a husband if we disagree on contraceptives with my wife? 11:50 – I’ve been told some people’s prayer is more effective than others, is this true? 18:00 – Why didn’t God just forgive Adam and Eve if He is merciful? How can we not be resentful? 29:20 – How many Saints are in the world? 32:15 – Can you make a video about papal supremacy in the early church? 36:55 – Do Mormons think Christianity died out until Joseph Smith or were they underground? 42:39 I watched your video on what makes Christianity unique, which is Jesus’s union to mankind. Other religions seem to have similar examples of this like Buddha. 48:35 – How do I defend the church’s infallibility in light of the letter to the 7 churches in the book of Revelations? 51:24 – Peter had a mother-in-law, does this mean our first Pope was married?
…
Questions Covered:
03:05 – If you are Catholic, can you baptize a friend’s child in a Protestant church? 06:13 – How do you repair the damage you unknowingly did to your children when they were younger? 11:00 – Is it okay for a Catholic to marry a Baptist in a ceremony officiated by a Baptist minister in a community hall? What if the bishop gives his permission? 16:08 – Could Jesus ever be wrong about something? 20:11 – How can Mary hear all our prayers if she’s not omniscient? 28:52 – Is there anybody in the Bible that performed a non-religious miracle (i.e. not an apostle, not a priest, etc.)? 34:08 – Is it okay to use a service dog as a rosary? 37:00 – What is the interface between the spiritual and material worlds? 43:03 – Is it possible for a person who hasn’t had a near-death experience to have access, while dreaming, to the upgraded knowledge the saints enjoy? 51:04 – Was it unjust to canonize St. Maria Goretti for defending her chastity but not canonize other women who were raped and murdered too?
…
Questions Covered:
04:33 – Is it immoral or suicidal for my neighbor to refuse to pursue medical treatment that would cause her hardship? 14:33 – How can I reconcile the veneration of saints with the Catechism’s teaching that we shouldn’t put anything before God? 28:47 – Is there any theological significance to Jesus having his disciples eat his body before he consecrated his blood? 38:17 – Why does Jesus seem to insult the Canaanite woman in Mt. 15:21-28? 45:39 – My Catholic friend is saying that it’s “a Protestant thing” to memorize the Bible.
…
Questions Covered:
02:20 – Is there a way to get an English translation on Pope Pius II’s encyclical on aliens? 05:53 – How to ponder the fact that our sins put Jesus on the cross? And why did Jesus go through so much suffering for us? 13:26 – How do we debunk the statement that the Catholic church is a cult? 16:32 – If sin causes death, why do animals die? If animals don’t sin? 21:09 – Can Fr. talk about the particular judgment versus the final judgment? 29:28 – What happens if a minor wants to join the church but the parents are against it? What do they do? 34:31 – What would hinder any baptized Christian (even non catholic) from going to confession and receiving God’s grace? 43:19 – can Fr. Paul explain why we have gluten free hosts? 52:00 – What is the difference between a sacramental marriage and valid marriage in the church?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
3:13 – How did the apostles have the fullness of revelation? How does that relate to private revelation? 9:32 – my 7-year-old asked me, how do you know that our religion is the right one? How do I answer her? 16:33 – My parish priest, who I was good friends with, apostatized. What can I do to get him back? 20:45 – My protestant co-worker used Mt. 12:50 as evidence for saying that Catholicism is the wrong denomination. How do I respond? 28:57 – How does the Church decide who is a martyr? 39:27 – I’m protestant considering conversion. I’m legally married but legally separated. How would this be seen if I joined the Church? 47:54 – I’ve been a Baptist for 21 years and have a desire to become Catholic. Can you give me resources on St Thomas Aquinas and Marian theology?
…
Questions Covered:
16:24 – Jesus says in the bible if the husband divorces her and remarries that she is committing adultery. How does that make sense? 21:42 -What kind of example does a pastor who was divorced set for his congregation? 24:10 – I’m a revert after being away for most of my life. I was only baptized. During that time I was married and divorced. Do I have to get that marriage annulled? 32:26 – It sounds like people feel entitled to sex and love and don’t like that the Church has something to say about it. 36:19 – Is seeing the other party a necessity when going through an annulment? 37:17 – I’m going through an annulment now. What are the roots of annulments? Where did it come from? 44:18 – Are there any marriages that would not be granted an annulment? 47:22 – My partner left the Church, and doesn’t want to return to Catholicism. Can we get married in the Church? 51:01 – Is my marriage valid since the priest that married us left the Church afterwards?
…
Questions Covered:
01:44 – Can and should the Filioque be removed now? Or is it still important to keep it? 06:25 – Is it okay to attend a non-Catholic wedding of a fallen-away Catholic? Does being a godparent or confirmation sponsor have any bearing on that? 14:18 – Does the Church’s teaching on self-defense include the right to bear arms? If it does, how does this fit with bishops and the pope calling for more gun control? 20:56 – Is it acceptable to smoke medical marijuana? 28:51 – In Luke 17:22-37, was Jesus talking about the destruction of Jerusalem in AD 70 or about his second coming? 39:39 – Why was Fr. Frank Pavone laicized? 46:49 – I’ve heard that Pope Gregory Great did not accept the book Maccabees in a debate on the Canon of scripture. Is this a misrepresentation or a valid argument? 50:30 – If only God can hear our thoughts, does it make sense to pray interiorly to the Saints or Our Lady?
…
Questions Covered:
01:40 – Can you talk more about the Protestant work ethic? What kind of work ethic should a Catholic have? 08:21 – What direct ties does Catholic Answers have to the Church/Vatican? Do you answer to any bishops or hierarchy? 29:15 – Do I have an obligation to leave my job at a company that is very pro-LGBTQ? 45:53 – At what point is it good to simply stop paying attention to the news? It’s demoralizing and I don’t get much agency from it.
…
Questions Covered:
02:17 – God never said contraception was sinful, in fact the bible says the opposite. 10:15 – I’m confused. Isn’t it apostasy to go to the Greek Orthodox Church? 15:55 – If we say God is everywhere, can we say he is in hell? 20:05 – Why do we call Mary holy? 24:17 – Why do we call Mary THE woman when there are women in the bible who are also called woman? 33:29 – Where did the Church come up with the theology of everyone having a guardian angel? 38:14 – What prayer does the priest use to turn the host and the wine in the body and blood of Jesus? 42:43 – Why is the SSPX able to give the eucharist but not validly forgive sins before Pope Francis’ approval? 47:12 – Why do protestants say it’s blasphemous to pray the rosary?
…
Questions Covered:
04:18 – Why Catholicism over Greek Orthodoxy? 11:23 – Why doesn’t the Catholic understanding of ‘holding fast to the tradition’ assume that all the oral traditions of the Church were included into scripture? 20:13 Is moral relativism a new form of Gnosticism? 28:39 – Where did the idea of Satan falling come from? How did he conceive the thought of going against God? 37:30 – Why do we say that we bless the Lord? 44:59 – Is there a difference between Greek Orthodox and Greek Catholic Orthodox?
…
Questions Covered:
02:33 – Why is Ez.23:20 so graphic in its description? 14:00 – Is there anything in scripture that tells us whether Jesus was present at damning souls to Sheol? 20:04 – Where in the bible does Jesus say ‘I am God, worship me?’ 30:25 – Is there any use of the 7 day week before Genesis? 37:05 – How can you tell the difference in what has already happened and what will happen in the book of Revelation? 42:44 – Psalm 2 in the Douay-Rheims version uses the word Christ. Why is that? 48:12 – I’m Protestant. I’ve heard the argument that the OT does not apply to us because it wasn’t meant as instruction to us but only the Jews. What does the Catholic take on this?
…
Questions Covered:
05:14 – Why was the gospel of Thomas not included in the canon? 16:19 – Jesus quotes Isaiah in Matthew and says traditions get in the way, then why do Catholics emphasize tradition? 29:07 – Who gave us the bible? 34:22 – I’m a revert. What’s a good resource to properly understand the book of Daniel? 36:35 – I’m a protestant. How does a Catholic understand Romans 3:21-22? 45:41 – Why are there so many different versions of the bible? Which is the original and what’s a good Catholic good version? 52:35 – Has the Church ever recognized a Protestant interpretation of the bible?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
08:32 – My former Catholic friend keeps telling me that I’m going to hell for being Catholic. How do I refute the claim that the Church is the whore of Babylon? 18:38 – How can an indulgence be attached to a certain design of a crucifix like the Pardon Crucifix? 21:02 – Do Protestants believe that the work of saying the sinner’s prayer brings them salvation? 32:35 – I’m a protestant in RCIA and I work at my church. I know I’m going to be asked about the priest abuse scandal. How do I respond and what safeguards have been put in place to protect the innocent? 44:08 – Wouldn’t calling the Church the whore of Babylon be considered bearing false witness? 48:45 – If someone dies without baptism, do they immediately go to hell?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
03:15 – Regarding CCC 2267 on the death penalty. Why was there a change and does it change anything practically? 10:39 – How can the Pachamama incident be looked upon other than in a negative light? 17:41 – Why are there so many variations of Jesus’ and Mary’s name? What is the original and should we go back to it? 24:00 – Is it proper to pray at crosses on the side of the road where people have died? 28:45 – How do I respond to my protestant friend who says Mary didn’t give her consent until Jesus was older? 40:42 – What is the Catholic view of the Calvinistic view of total depravity? 44:16 – Is it okay to do yoga for just physical well being and not for spiritual purposes? 46:37 – Wasn’t it evident that Mary knew Jesus was God at the Annunciation? 49:10 – Do we have conclusive evidence that Jesus believed himself to be God? 51:55 – My husband was not baptized. Does this mean that our marriage is invalid?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
04:15 – I heard from a bishop that sexual immorality wasn’t considered grave matter until the 17th century. Is there any credence to this? 07:04 – If we believe that the Eucharist is the body of Christ, why do we do it every mass? 11:58 – How can the pope be infallible if humans are fallible? 15:00 – My protestant friend compares images of Jesus with his hand blessing and the image of Baphomet. How do I respond to this? 19:12 – When we die and go to heaven, what’s the point of the second judgment? 28:50 – If mortal sin requires full knowledge and grave matter, why was Adam’s sin considered grave if it sounds more like curiosity? 34:45 – How did the apostles know who Moses and Elijah were during the transfiguration? 40:38 – How do I explain purgatory to a protestant who doesn’t accept Maccabees? 45:56 – Why was Jesus allowed to teach in the synagogue without a formal educational upbringing? 48:04 – Why can’t we accept the eucharist as symbolic if all the other sacraments are symbolic gestures and yet still efficacious? 51:24 – How do you reconcile Isaiah’s prophecy of the woman not having birth pains and Revelation’s prophecy of the woman suffering birth pains?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
01:47 – Is it sinful or sacrilegious to receive communion on the hand? 05:28 – Where should I start when learning apologetics? 09:09 – Is it morally acceptable to kill a baby in the womb, if there is a risk of the baby killing the mother? 16:44 – Why do you need to receive communion when you’re in 2nd grade? 19:46 – Can I still receive the eucharist even if I don’t believe it’s the body and blood of Jesus? 24:25 – Does the prayer “Lord Im not worthy…” contradict St. Paul sayings on no one receiving the body and blood unworthily? 33:50 – Do souls in heaven still have free will? 38:05 – What’s the best way to dialogue with schismatic traditionalists? 43:45 – I’m new to RCIA and I’m struggling with the Trinity. Can you help clarify it? 51:00 – What’s the church’s stance on salvation outside the Church specifically in Judaism and Islam? 52:57 – Is there a difference between Catholic bibles and Protestant bibles?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
02:41 – How do statements by Pope Eugene fall in line with Vatican 2’s teachings on those outside the Church? 11:50 – I’m traveling outside the country and will be going somewhere where it’s not safe to leave the location. How do I handle going to mass on Sunday when safety is a concern? 13:53 – What is the most reverent to receive communion? 16:30 – Would a person need to be re-baptized if they were baptized in a protestant church with the trinitarian formula but they didn’t believe in regenerative baptism? 20:11 – There have been people starting to teach that certain saints were gay. How do I respond to these claims? 28:31 – Why do we say “we believe” instead of saying “we know?” 34:36 – In the RSV-CE and New RSV-CE translations of the wedding at Cana, one insinuates Mary as co-redemptrix. Which is the proper translation? 41:57 – Is there really a gay agenda in the Church or is this just a conspiracy? 49:44 – How do I bridge the gap with my protestant family when their church teaches that the Mass is blasphemous?
…
Questions Covered:
04:06 – I’ve recently turned to Sedevacantism. Are there any proofs in Church documents for baptism by blood and baptism by desire. 19:04 – Could someone experiencing a spiritual “rebirth” serve as a replacement for baptism? 23:32 – I grew up Catholic then was re-baptized as an adult as a protestant. How was I validly baptized as an infant if I didn’t choose it? 41:04 – Was Mary baptized? 43:43 – I adopted 3 children and they are just under or at the age of reason. My priest says that we can’t just baptize them. Why is that? 51:55 – Why does the Church consider Mormon baptism invalid?
…
Questions Covered:
09:26 – How do I explain to my friend that my baptism is valid even though I wasn’t submerged? 16:58 – When a clergy member performs a baptism do they have to use the Trinitarian formula? 22:15 – I was just asked to be a godmother for baptism at a nondenominational church. Is this ok for me to do? 33:30 – When you are baptized Catholic, are you always a Catholic even if you reject the Church? 41:22 – Why do we Catholics not recognize universal salvation? 47:28 – Were my children validly baptized if the priest was one involved in the priest sex scandal?
…
Questions Covered:
05:21 – I am a bit of a survivalist nut and I am always preparing for the collapse of civilization. I was just wondering, if there was a nuclear war or really any kind of catastrophe that would trigger a societal collapse, and the chaos was so widespread that most of the bishops and all of the cardinals were killed, how would the new pope be elected? Could the surviving bishops (who I would imagine would not be cardinals because most likely they’d all be remote rural bishops) elect the new Pope? Furthermore, what if all the bishops were killed? Could regular priests somehow advance one of their own to the bishopric? If not, could they at least lay their hands on laypeople and continue apostolic succession that way? 19:12 – When the Magi came, do you think it made the Holy Family wealthy? Enough to travel and stay in Egypt, provide for a 3-year ministry of 13 plus, and for the care of his beloved mother Mary until the Dormition? 22:43 – Are the laws of logic and thought — identity, non-contradiction, and excluded middle — true of all possible universes, or only of ours? Would multiverse theories or alternate dimensions modify these rules? And do the laws certainly apply even here, or could one argue that maybe an extreme form of Scotistic “haecceity” versus “quiddity” means that maybe they don’t? 28:19 – Why is most lunch meat round when bread is mostly square? 36:28 – Jimmy, huge fan of your work, your terminal intellect and towering beard. Or maybe I got that backwards. If we, in the eschaton are given our infallible bodies and the new Jerusalem in essence becomes our planet krypton… can you postulate on what we will do in the eschaton? Saints are generals in God’s army etc? But what will our missions be? Will we go and evangelize the universe of fallen creatures? If so, will Christ have to incarnate on that world to save them or will we as we have been “made Gods” or is that a blasphemous thing? If we do hypothetically have to incarnate for them, would our infallible bodies change to the alien form we incarnate for thus we become aliens only until we go to the next world? Or if only Christ can do the incarnating / saving would be or are there already millions of incarnations of Christ and his form in heaven adjusted to whatever creature he’s interacting with? 44:40 – Why did Humans take so long to be advanced just recently with agriculture, medicine, economy, infrastructure etc. What were they doing for 200,000 years!? 52:45 – With admission by the USA of ufos, what do we think about extraterrestrial beings—souls, evangelizing, origin, etc.?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
09:12 – Are the prophecies about the Jewish people being the new Jerusalem in the end times still in place in Catholic theology? 24:11 – What’s the origin of the belief of the immaculate conception? 37:29 – How does the New Jerusalem bible compare to new translations? 45:53 – What’s the difference when the Church uses the terms Universal Church vs Catholic Church?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
06:50 – I teach RCIA. I have a former student who, after converting, left the church. What do I say to her when I run into her? 19:17 – How do I explain to my protestant parents why we close our prayer with the Trinity instead of in the name of Jesus? 34:03 – Did Solomon go to heaven? 37:18 – I call myself an atheist because the only thing religion solves is the life after death issue. It doesn’t seem to solve the issues of this world. What are your thoughts on that? 46:20 – Were the illumination of conscience, the rapture and the dark night of the soul terms made up by the reformers? If not, where did they originate?
…
Questions Covered: 08:17 – My father is in hospice after a severe stroke. What do we mean when we say redemptive suffering? 19:20 – When and why did we change the fasting time before communion? 35:48 – Is oil an essential part of the sacrament of Confirmation? 43:20 – How legitimate is the claim that when one is saved, you are saved, past, present, and future? …
Questions Covered: 08:05 – What’s the earliest record of the Eucharist? 17:04 – When discussing the essential beliefs with a protestant. Is there a list that the Church has? 22:18 – Will there ever be an American or young pope? 31:24 – My priest told me some penance is to not eat all the food on my plate. What do I do with the food that’s leftover since it’s not good to throw it out? 41:22 – Can you clarify Jesus’ role as high priest and how that works with our atonement? …
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
09:06 – How do I refute people who claim that the pope is the antichrist? Especially coming from Catholics? 19:48 – Sometimes I go to a Christian church and they do the bread and the wine. What’s the Catholics stance on their version? 30:21 – The bible mentions that those who doubt do so because of lack of faith. How does one with scrupulosity interpret this? 45:48 – When does ownership end to avoid stealing? Such as when a restaurant throws out food.
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
04:28 – What is the proper interpretation in the Old Testament where God commanded the Israelites to kill women and children? 16:02 – Regarding the teaching that God’s existence can be known with certainty by human reason. What does this mean? 28:40 – Do curses relate to the sacraments? Do the sacraments negate curses? 40:36 – Do you know of any alien encounters where the aliens had any reaction to prayer or religious objects? 49:32 – Were people who were healed by Jesus also baptized by the Holy Spirit? 52:28 – Are Non-Catholic people who are married outside the Catholic Church validly married?
…
Questions Covered:
17:28 – What are the results that you’re seeing come from the Eucharistic Revival? 21:47 – Can you give me feedback on what to do on receiving communion while kneeling and what to do when one is denied? 29:31 – Why aren’t the essential things to bring back faithful Catholics being emphasized in the eucharistic revival? 33:46 – Is it alright to join the procession if it’s coming near my town? 39:30 – My Baptist sister claims she received Jesus at her church. How do I approach her in informing her of the truth without being abrasive? 43:00 – I’m Protestant. How does the eucharist help achieve unity in the Church? 46:45 – How do we get a unified message from priests? It doesn’t always seem like there is a uniform message. 49:52 – If the eucharist is Jesus, why would there be an issue with receiving communion on the tongue?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
04:48 – Col. 2:16-17. Is the sabbath mentioned, Saturday or Sunday? 12:47 – Are Catholic priests allowed to run for office? 28:25 – Are we currently in the years of the antichrist’s reign? 35:53 – I’m having health issues and am afraid I might have cancer. I need some guidance. 51:51 – What’s the Church’s teaching on attending non-Catholic gatherings and services?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
04:10 – I read a story about a witch and it said she had a statue of Our Lady of Guadalupe. Why would the witch have an image of Our Lady? 07:22 – How do you respond to the claim that Catholics aren’t Catholic because they believe in salvation by faith and works? 18:20 – I once heard that Lazarus might have been special needs. Is there any evidence to this? 28:29 – Is Zoroastrianism a monotheistic religion? 36:01 – Are you familiar with the theory that insects are a result of the fall. Is this true? 42:11 – Can a priest adopt a child? 46:31 – My mother has dementia. How can I help my mother get to heaven? 49:55 – How could I show my faith to my girlfriend?
…
Open Forum:
03:31 – Could you explain the apparent heresies that Sedevacantism accuses Pope John Paul II and Pope Francis? Could you debunk them? 14:58 – What’s the significance of Jesus’ facial burial cloth mentioned in Jn 20:7? 16:22 – I’m confused, why do we pray “world without end” but still talk about the end of the world. Isn’t this contradictory? 18:47 – Why is the Eucharist called the bread of angels if the angels can’t receive him? 23:46 – What’s the rationale behind having so many different kinds of devotions to Mary and Jesus? 33:26 – YouTube… Why do we not receive the precious blood during Mass? 37:01 – I’m going to air a Beatles special and will play the song Imagine by John Lenin. Is it appropriate for me to do so since it rejects the existence of God? 48:50 – How permissible is it for Latin Rite Catholics to pray to St. Uriel the Archangel?
…
Open Forum Questions Covered:
04:13 – How can I decipher if the Lord is speaking to me through the Church or if the enemy is trying to confuse me? 08:45 – What are your thoughts on the hollow earth theory and that aliens live there? 19:05 – What is the Catholic opinion on Zionism? 28:36 – Can you help clarify the story of Lot and the 3 visitors? I’ve always found it very confusing. 39:29 – What’s the best argument against the gospel of Thomas? 46:37 – How do you know if you’re following the Will of God in your life? 50:20 – Can you give examples of magisterial reversal on non-definitive teachings? Can the earth be under 20,000 years old?
…
Questions Covered:
29:24 – Given the distinction between self-help and surrender to Christ, are you aware that our culture is pushing just the self-help part? 32:31 – I have chronic fatigue syndrome and have a difficult time getting to mass. Is it appropriate for me to make this a spiritual challenge or just rest? 37:31 – Can you get into the details of how your program works? 43:06 – I’ve suffered 2 brain aneurysms. I’m a Christian and I need some guidance. 47:33 – What’s the cost of your 12-week program? 48:45 – I have a lot of health issues but I walk with God. I don’t go to doctors anymore. I fail a lot and am at a loss. Can you help?
…
Questions Covered:
15:47 – I’ve heard that the forgiveness doctrine was settled but recently I heard that you don’t have to forgive those who are seeking forgiveness. Can you clarify? 19:21 – What can we do about over the counter birth control? 23:20 – My granddaughter asked me what happens after death. How do I reply? 31:24 – Is there a proper order when doing mental prayer? 35:29 – Is it appropriate to have a rosary where the center metal is personalized like a picture of a loved one or a dog? 37:09 – I’m new to Catholicism. How far should tolerance go regarding social issues? 40:40 – Are the soul and spirit two different things? 46:45 – Any advice on how to prevent distraction while praying or at mass? 49:48 – How can the laity most effectively participate at mass? 52:52 – Where would be appropriate to place a home altar and what should we put on it?
…
Questions Covered:
18:42 – You mentioned the burning building scenario. For the sake of argument, shouldn’t we do the opposite of what the crowd does? 28:54 – I think we know what’s good because we are born with a subconscious and as we get older we can lose that? 37:20 – How does one defend the rationality of faith using analytical philosophy vs continental philosophy? 45:55 – How do we know what’s good within the Church?
…
Questions Covered:
01:01 – does the bible say that bishops are infallible? 07:50 – Do protestant pastors speak out against woke-ism? 12:13 – I just discovered your program. I’m protestant. If Billy Graham is Protestant and the Catholic Church is right, where did he go wrong? 20:10 – How can an indulgence help another soul? 24:11 – How early in Church history did devotion to Mary begin? 30:10 – What should I say when a Jehovah’s Witness comes to my house? 35:01 – Are going through a protestant chaplain program and going through RCIA inconsistent? 43:30 – I would like to know more about Mary’s perpetual virginity? 49:40 – Do indulgences mean that God’s grace is insufficient for salvation?
…
Questions Covered:
05:33 – If grace builds on nature, then how come in the eucharist the grace destroys the nature of bread? 20:06 – Why do people with gluten intolerance still have a reaction if the eucharist is no longer bread? 28:25 – What does the Church teach on the death penalty? 34:13 – My friend said he didn’t believe in the bible because he believed that Jesus was God. He said the reason was because the claim that Jesus was from the house of David was inaccurate due to the fact that Joseph wasn’t his biological father. Can you comment on this? 41:24 – How do I help my friend who left the Church for a non denominational church return? He claim is that she doesn’t need the Church because she already feels Christ in her life. 48:38 – Where is purgatory in the bible?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
04:46 – What is the dating of the Exodus? Were the Israelites in the desert during the bronze age collapse? 12:18 – Do bishops still have power and Apostolic succession if they broke away from the Church like during the protestant reformation? 15:26 – Can a medium contact the souls in the afterworld? 23:25 – Is the kingdom of heaven mentioned in scripture physically real? How is it related to St. Augustine’s City of God? 32:03 – Are there any moral concerns with working at the post office such as shipping immoral items? 34:22 – I have a sense of knowing when certain people are calling me. Is this a real thing? 41:52 – I’m not Catholic yet but I’m having trouble with Mary, specifically her lifelong sinlessness and Immaculate Conception. Can you point me to some resources? 48:35 – Was YHWH the Canaanite god of war that was adopted by the Israelites? 52:14 – Do using palm payments at grocery stores have anything to do with the mark of the beast?
…
Questions Covered:
19:22 – My wife had a brain injury that gave her body dysmorphia. What do I do as a husband? 24:52 – The way you’re describing it confirms that this is a spiritual warfare attack. 34:19 – How is the conversation including the exponential rise in everyone regarding body dysmorphia? 43:53 – I have de-transitioned and now follow my Catholic faith. Why would I now be viewed negatively and shunned? 50:06 – My 13 year old granddaughter says she’s bisexual. How can I talk to her from a Catholic perspective?
…
Questions Covered:
05:01 – What is your opinion on The Chosen? 13:29 – What is the Catholic Church’s opinion on the Orthodox Church? 18:07 – During an annulment why don’t they question the priest who did the marriage prep? 23:22 – Can you explain the process of Medjugorje being recognized by the church? 29:42 – Daughter is gay, and I have been told that because she is married to her partner she is going to hell, how do I respond to this? 42:50 – Considering converting but is hung up on confession. 1) when you are in confession can the priest see you? 2) when you confess your sins how specific do you have to be? 52:45 – How does the Holy Spirit move and work in the Catholic church compared to the protestant church
…
Questions Covered:
06:20 – How do you handle/address people’s differing opinions on Pope Francis 18:29 – The Council of Trent says “formal cause of justification is the justice of God” what does that mean? 28:58 – His dad wants to get baptized but does not want to join the Catholic church, how do I address this? 33:36 – What is the Church’s position on the Garabandal apparitions of Mary? 37:30 – How do I explain the passage in Acts 8 about “being baptized but the holy spirit has not fallen on them yet” 44:10 – Has a friend who described John 1 “the word became flesh” as “the Bible became flesh” can Joe help me describe this? 48:52 – Wants to ask Joe if can write a book on justification? And explain the Catholic view of justification versus Protestant view?
…
Questions Covered:
12:32 – What is the Catholic moral teaching on circumcision? 18:58 – Are health care clinicians and scientists formally cooperating with evil when they publish papers or give presentations in spaces that require gender neutral language on topics that are specific to women, such as ovarian cancer? 30:37 – Not listening but her husband is listening and told her to call and he listens on Spirit… Does the Church have a position on what to do with frozen embryos? 38:14 – Is it acceptable to preserve human eggs? 45:41 – I am a pharmacist and have recently taken a job where I am likely to be asked to dispense contraceptives. What do I do? Do I tell my employer I can’t do that? 50:20 – If God doesn’t make mistakes, how are we to think about children that are born intersex, and how are we to raise them?
…
Questions Covered:
06:32 – Why does the Roman Catholic Church not believe in the imputation of the righteousness of Christ? 17:43 – Can I altar serve and be an extraordinary minister of Holy Communion at the same Mass? 17:43 – Can I altar serve and be an extraordinary minister of Holy Communion at the same Mass? 21:43 – How are SSPX and the Society of Pope Pius XII “false Catholicism.” 30:57 – Do I have to believe in papal supremacy to be Catholic? I crave tradition and The Eucharist, but I cannot get behind the Pope being head of the church. 35:19 – What would you say to a believer who is discouraged and having doubts about the faith? 46:14 – John 15:15 Jesus says I have told you everything I have heard from the Father. Does that mean that Jesus has given all knowledge to mankind? And is that why our civilization has become so advanced technologically? 51:32 – Are animals cooperating with God’s grace when they act in kindness?
…
Questions Covered:
15:19 – What was the early church like and what did they call themselves? Did the early church fathers differ on anything other than the pope? 20:54 – comment on Dr. D’Ambrosio’s book and the comment (has cantored at Mass Dr. has been at) 31:47 – Who are the early Church fathers that are most closely related to the apostle John and what were their teachings on salvation? 37:23 – Why don’t Protestants recognize that the early church as Catholic? What do protestants think about the early church fathers? 46:41 – When Mary went to go visit Elizabeth, how did she get there? Does Dr. Ambrosio have any insight?
…
Questions Covered:
15:19 – How liberally can we interpret the first 6 chapters of Genesis? 19:42 – since Jesus was a Rabbi, did the Jews consider him to be celibate? 21:57 – Genesis 3:15, when man betrays God, God says a “punishment” is man having dominion over woman, why is this considered a punishment? 31:54 – Genesis 3:16, what does it mean when it says “God will strike enmity between her seed and the serpent” 47:48 – How does the Catholic Church view the rights of the first born son (according to Genesis) 51:58 – What is the story behind snakes (why does the Old Testament use snakes) and how do they relate to Jesus?
…
Questions Covered:
06:39 – I heard that it is good to pray in the Lord’s name to get responses. Why is this true? (Has seen this to be true in their life) 14:27 – Why do we need gluten-free hosts if we believe the substance changes? 21:34 – As a Catholic, should I assume that those who have not had the opportunity to know Jesus will go to heaven? 32:51 – In Ireland, are there any celtic rite Catholics left? 35:04 – Do you believe in predestination? Do you believe that St. Faustina’s writings about hell are legitimate? 44:43 – Why do we not see such great/beautiful art from Catholics/Christians anymore?
…
Questions Covered:
06:10 – In the bible it says Jesus went up into the sky, and will come back in the same way. Is this symbolic like Genesis description? 14:42 – Why is Mary placed in such a high position? Was this the apostolic father’s placement or God’s? What books should I be reading to start my journey into Catechism classes? 30:23 – Why do Catholic churches have Bingo when Jesus flipped tables in the temple? 42:11 – Scripture says that the apostles were given the ability to speak in tongues to better communicate with others. Why does it seem that the current use of this gift involves a language that isn’t understandable? 48:38 – Why can I not receive the Sacraments of communion or confession until I complete my RCIA program?
…
Questions Covered:
03:56 – Why do we or don’t we receive the Precious Blood? 08:57 – Why do we worship Mary? 18:14 – Why does the church have caveat to the teaching on salvation outside the Catholic church? 33:49 – Does God give private Revelations? 42:42 – Why is our Old Testament different than the Jewish Old Testament? 48:13 – The commandment to be fruitful and multiply was given when the population was small, why would this still be applicable with today’s large population?
…
Questions Covered:
07:44 – During Mass, the priest does the sign of the cross on his forehead, lip, and heart before reading the Gospel. Should everyone do this or only the priest? 12:00 – How can I better clarify with protestants that they are included when the Nicene Creed says catholic? 17:55 – How can I explain to a friend who missed Mass that they should go to confession before receiving communion? 32:58 – Why is Luke 10:16 a good source for submitting to Church authority? 42:58 – What level of certainty did the Vatican Council fathers have when they stated “The one true God’s existence could be known through human reason”? 48:18 – Jesus said we must drink his blood and eat his flesh, where does that leave Protestant? 52:26 – Can you explain praying to the different Marian titles like Our Lady of Fatima or Our Lady of Sorrow?
…
Question Covered:
20:05 – What are practical tips for linking Confirmation students with community? 39:59 – How can we as a community help people with addiction? 42:08 – Are the guilds an outcome of the monastic life? 45:56 – Why should I become Catholic?
…
Questions Covered:
03:44 – How can God be intelligence when it seems like intelligence only belongs to biological systems? 20:43 – 2 Peter 1:20 seems like the ultimate smackdown of sola scriptura. Am I wrong? 29:28 – How do you as an individual grapple with the problem of evil? 32:58 – How do I talk to my son who is an atheist and refuses to let my grandkids go to church? 44:48 – Why don’t apologists use personal revelations of saints when talking with non-Catholics? 49:50 – I don’t think the problem of evil is solved by free will.
…
Questions Covered:
17:51 – What’s the best way to convince people that Catholic monarchy is the best form of government for America? 29:55 – What should a Catholic know about the terms “integralism” and “Christian nationalism”? 33:51 – Am I wrong in thinking that in the ’20s-’60s, priests put a heavy emphasis on class difference and socialism? 37:15 – What is the value of bringing religious codes into government? Is it biblical? 44:09 – What would a Catholic foreign policy look like, in terms of when to go to war? 48:06 – I think today we don’t have clarity on what the proper jurisdictions are for the papal and imperial powers. 51:34 – How much trust should we place in the political process and in government, and how do we balance that with our faith and trust in God?
…
Questions Covered:
15:21 – What is schism? 25:10 – How would we classify someone who says that homosexual acts can be loving and the church’s teaching is wrong? (he’s calm but could rant) 36:39 – When is it appropriate for a layperson to call someone a heretic? 45:14 – Is it possible for a pope to be an apostate, heretic, schismatic, or dissenter? If so, what would be required for that to happen, and who could determine it? 49:49 – What should we think about some of the recent appointments the Pope has made to the synod and his crackdown on Bishop Strickland?
…
Questions Covered:
23:11 – It’s easy for me to give common courtesy when I remember that it’s one way to follow Jesus’ command to love one another. 29:26 – It’s more easy for common courtesy to flourish in a relaxed setting than in a more fast-paced or cutthroat one. 36:43 – I offered help to an elderly person today, and when people ask me how I am I reply “I’m blessed.” It often makes their day. 42:37 – Why did we have more courtesy in a print-dominated world than we do in a screen-dominated world, when we seem to be doing mostly the same thing with each? 47:28 – I work in sales and it’s hard to be courteous with my coworkers because it’s such a competitive environment. Is it right for me to behave that way when I have to support my family?
…
Questions Covered:
29:58 – What do we do about the web designer who wont make a site for a couple because he doesn’t believe in interracial marriage? 45:35 – How do we prevent abuses of religious liberty? 51:42 – When are we going to realize that the other side just wants to put us in jail? When Are we going to fight back?
…
Questions Covered:
17:17 – What is the role of godparents and confirmation sponsors when it comes to sharing the faith? 20:51 – Have you sold all of your belongings and followed Jesus like you quoted earlier? 38:11 – How do you share the good news while discussing the moral argument and not raising anger and emotion? 49:12 – How do you share the faith in a place where you are not supposed to talk about faith, like the workplace?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
04:28 – Given the degree of the accusations of heresy and apostasy today, how much of our salvation is at stake on knowing how to identify heresy? 15:58 – What would the implications on the Incarnation be if fallen intelligent alien life existed? 21:19 – Is there a policy on facial hair in the west? Roman Catholics tend to be clean cut while eastern Catholics tend to have beards. 28:51 – When people get to heaven do they still have the same personalities? 33:34 – Is Allah really a god or a devil? 37:25 – Would I be apostate if the Catholic Church accepted women’s ordination and I left? 42:30 – If ghost’s exist and we need to test them, how would we test them? 49:18 – If a person baptizes a grandchild without the parents knowledge and the parents later begin to practice their faith and want to baptize their child, would that baptism be necessary? 51:44 – When a priest does an exorcism, does the person who’s receiving the exorcism need to consent to it for it to take effect?
…
Questions Covered:
38:13 – I know a priest that keeps saying that the real miracle of the fish and the loaves was sharing and that Jesus didn’t actually multiply them. Is this true?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
05:07 – Is it okay to remain a Protestant? 08:35 – Why as Catholics do we not follow the kosher food laws of the Old Testament 15:56 – Is Catholicism an Ideology? 28:36 – Are we supposed to do the orans posture during Our Father at Mass? 40:51 – I’ve noticed various practices in the Catholic Church. Apart from the typical sit stand kneel, are there points where we are supposed to bow, raise hand etc.? 50:36 – Can you suggest what to write on a family member’s birthday card? She is a retired nun. 52:01 – I just returned to the Church. Can you simply explain what indulgences are?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
04:28 – Can we reconcile free will and the call to evangelize with the idea that everyone is ultimately responsible for their final destination? 11:30 – Why does the Church feel the need to have a distinction between priests and lay people? 20:23 – What did they do with the dead bodies during the time of Pharaoh? 28:39 – Many Protestants believe that salvation cannot be lost once attained. What does the church say about this? 31:51 – Do we have the authority as Christians to rebuke someone? 41:21 – Is God the Father the same God as the God of Judaism and Islam? 50:37 – Can I, as a layman, bless my own children?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
01:04 – Were the dogmas Immaculate Conception and the Assumption explicitly preached in the apostolic age? 16:52 – If my wife and I were to become Catholic would our marriage have to be convalidated? 21:42 – Can you explain the calling of single lay people? You didn’t mention that when explaining celibacy. 31:21 – How do you respond to the claim that Mary didn’t actually have a miraculous pregnancy because she was intersex and conceived Jesus herself? 38:38 – Can the laity use holy oil? 47:06 – I saw that a small percentage of Catholics actually accept the teaching against contraception. Can you shed some light on this?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
04:28 – St. Jerome claims that presbyters and bishops are the same thing. How do we take that? 11:04 – Where is the best place to start studying Catholicism? 14:17 – If no one greater than John the Baptist has been born, then what do we make of Mary and Jesus? 18:48 – I’m a former Calvinist now Catholic. What’s the difference between the perseverance of the saints vs the gift of perseverance? 22:41 – When did the Church implement priestly celibacy and what was the rationale behind it? 35:24 – Was there one specific event that led you to become Catholic? 43:02 – Could you explain how to pray? I don’t know what I’m supposed to be feeling.
…
Questions Covered:
03:06 – What is the most likely outcome of the German Synodal Way? 29:15 – What do you think will happen to the Church over the next 10 years? 42:05 – Rate the leadership of Pope Francis. 43:26 – Rate the leadership of the Catholic bishops. 48:32 – Rate the work of Catholic media.
…
Questions Covered:
06:28 – What was the top Catholic story? 22:30 – How is it that Francis can be pope when he’s spoken so many heresies? I am Sedevecantist, formerly Catholic. 33:06 – I’ve listened to the flannel panel regularly and this is not the first time someone has forgotten their flannel. Have you thought about having a box of emergency flannels? 34:42 – Which word represents your feelings on the Synod on Synodality? 45:00 – Which word represents your feelings on the Eucharist Revival? 51:14 – Is it true that the Synod is open to all people, not just Catholics?
…
Questions Covered:
15:36 – What makes NFP different from contraception? 24:44 – I teaching marriage prep. Where do you get your stats so I can use them in my classes? 31:54 – If someone with SSA finds a woman they’re attracted to, should they pursue her? 41:02 – Could you explain why marriage isn’t just a social construct? 43:45 – How do I deal with my son? I think he struggles with porn and lust.
…
Questions Covered:
04:01 – If a Catholic rejects the real presence in the eucharist, is it a mortal sin? 11:15 – Why do the priests say “Accept this sacrifice” Wasn’t the sacrifice only from Jesus? 20:25 – The prophet Daniel talks about the fullness of time. What does that mean? 23:37 – Can you help clarify what purgatory is? Also, did the children of Fatima see hell or purgatory? 38:39 – Is Jehovah and Yahweh in the New Testament? 42:16 – Can you clarify what Jesus meant when he said My God why have you forsaken me? 47:45 – What is the preferred diocesan approach to current traditional communities?
…
Questions Covered:
03:41 – When the pope and the bishops are in disagreement, who should I listen to? 11:27 – What are the compatibilities and the points of diversion between First Nations religions and Catholicism? 20:48 – If the priest at Mass somehow omits putting the water in the wine, what should we do? Does the consecration not happen? 28:49 – Did the angels fall when Jesus was born or before? 34:57 – If everyone followed the church teaching on being open to children without contraceptives, would the world become overpopulated? 39:26 Is it morally acceptable for government organizations to use psychics to receive information to help solve cases? 47:30 Is it true that the Divine Mercy chaplet was condemned by multiple Popes? 49:37 – What advice do you have for someone struggling with addiction?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
04:52 – Can Catholics reject same sex marriage and be okay with same sex civil unions? 08:00 – I’m protestant. How do you approach people who seemingly don’t care about the history of the Catholic faith, especially protestant receiving communion at Catholic Church? 15:12 – Can you explain praying to spirits? 22:19 – Are laicized priests allowed to do private masses? 30:16 – Who is the author of Genesis? 40:08 – Why doesn’t the Church encourage Catholics to read Catechism? 46:02 – Did Catholics add books to the bible or did Protestants remove books? 49:08 – Could there have been other women who had said no to the Annunciation? 51:52 – Would a good response to a protestant who wants to receive communion that it’s just rude?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
05:11 – Is it a sin to disobey someone from my diocese? 11:03 – How do I refute the claim that we worship Mary in a simple and clear way? 16:36 – Is it wrong for me to go to protestant services even though I still go to Mass? 23:35 – Why can we wear a crucifix but not a rosary as jewelry? 29:42 – I’ve been told that perfect contrition can allow me to partake in communion even if I haven’t gone to confession. Can you clarify? 33:40 – Can any of us truly have full knowledge of the sin we commit? How is full knowledge regarding mortal defined? 43:13 – I’m confused on how to pray. Can you help clarify what pray is and how to do it? 46:55 – Wouldn’t it be better to minister to those who have no faith rather than to those who have faith in Jesus? 52:05 – If indulgences for the dead are possible can the LDS doctrine of baptizing the dead be considered valid?
…
Questions Covered:
07:08 – My granddaughter has been an addict since she was 13 and is now 30. She has many children and was just arrested in front of her oldest children. How do I get her connected to you? 14:07 – I run CIR in Wichita and can help Elizabeth. Does Scott want me to get in touch with her. 18:01 – I have OCD with scrupulosity to a great degree. How much effort should I be putting into overcoming it instead of giving in? 21:52 – Is there any addiction group for adults for trans people? 33:58 – Would your program also be helpful for people who hoard? 47:09 – In your program, does God come across in a friendly sense towards those afflicted?
…
Questions Covered:
19:32 – Will the pope take action on the Church in Germany? 28:53 – What’s your take on Dr. Regis Martin, Cardinal Burke, Vigano, Fr. Altman’s collective concerns of Pope Francis’ handling of COVID ? 31:28 – What’s your take on the World Economic Forum on using AI to interpret? 43:58 – How come there hasn’t been any follow up on the McCarrick case? 49:09 – Can you give us the Catholic perspective on Trump and the documents he had?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
02:13 – Are smells that remind you of loved ones that have passed away significant and a sign from God? 13:38 – How do you know if God exists? 18:34 – Does the Immaculate Conception mean that Mary could not sin? 28:19 – Can you clarify the difference between the Marian and the papacy teachings that Catholics and Protestants teach? 46:34 – Has anyone written a religious text that says leaving the faith is dangerous and why Protestantism is wrong?
…
Questions Covered:
12:36 – Can you talk about the importance of seeing your spouse as a subject and not an object? 19:23 – We just found out that my husband has cancer. Can you give us advice? 21:55 – Should I get married if I’m nervous about being a father? 32:49 – What does it mean for the woman to love her husband? 36:32 – Can you give me advice on how to handle bickering with my spouse? 46:22 – How should a parent love their children?
…
Questions Covered:
17:10 – I’m Catholic and believe in the full presence but I don’t feel it. Am I supposed to want to feel it or feel his love through it? 29:55 – We should bring the Holy Spirit into helping us accept the real presence. Can you comment on that? 33:19 – The pope has isolated us by watering down the faith. How do we reconcile having water down faith and still having real faith? 40:13 – If you haven’t been to confession, the eucharist isn’t going to help you very much. 45:05 – Do you think it would be helpful for people to have more faith if the church offered communion in both species?
…
Questions Covered:
06:54 – I was received into the ordinariate in Toronto, should I adhere to the Canada bishops or the US bishops (in Texas)? 10:52 – What are the similarities with a lay father with children and a priest who is called a Father? Duties and vocation. 16:16 – During confession can you deny the penance the priest gives you and ask for a new one? 20:41 – When we receive the Eucharist do we need both the body and blood? Why do most churches only have the body? 30:58 – Are the words said during consecration actually Jesus speaking through the priest? 34:30 – Retired Lutheran Pastor who likes to occasionally go to Mass out of interest, does Father have any advice for me? 43:30 – How can I best prepare to become a Father? 49:23 – How do I avoid pride while I am fasting? 52:03 – Wants to say hello and welcome Father to St. john the Baptist in PA (he’s local to Fr.’s new parish)
…
Questions Covered:
16:15 – I have two struggling children from a previous marriage. How can I support them while also protecting my younger children? 19:34 – What can a wife and kids do about a man who struggles to bond with the family? 22:12 – What can I do if my children will not talk to me after a divorce? 29:58 – Are there any books or tips for father with kids who are being influences by the LGBTQ teachings in schools? 38:20 – Can a mother compensate for the lack of a relationship with a father? 45:23 – Is there a movement to give funding for parents who desire to homeschool? 50:43 – How do I deal with my 5-year-old son, who is difficult?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
07:28 – I’m a Baptist considering Catholicism. Can you help clarify how Aquinas is not just reasonable but biblical in his understanding? 17:19 – If God is infinitely greater than man, why do our works matter? 21:29 – How do respond to the claim Act 8:22 is evidence for confessing directly to God? 28:22 – How does irresistible grace differ from efficacious according to Aquinas? 32:52 – If God permits evil so that humans can choose love, can we say the same thing for animal suffering? Can we say they have free will, if not does God cause evil? 43:18 – We see God do a lot of miracles in the bible. Why don’t we see him perform miracles like he did then? 49:00 – How does Luke 20:37 prove that there is a resurrection? 53:06 – Why isn’t the sacrament of penance extended to Protestants?
…
Questions Covered:
17:16 – In America we struggle with Catholic hospitals doing things against the Church and the bishops. Is this something that Australia struggles with too? 24:21 – Are there any Catholic sites in Australia that Catholics should see while visiting? 31:04 – Is it true that the government can really just take a hospital? 41:07 – I wanted to highlight a growing community in Australia called Apostoli Viae. Are you familiar with them? 44:50 – How is the Australian Church fighting back against the wokeism that is attacking the Church? 49:55 – What’s the Catholic Church’s response to dealing with the lost generation of indigenous like what happened in Canada?
…
Questions Covered:
07:03 – Can you help me understand what’s happening with the Dodgers and the sisters on perpetual indulgence? How do Catholics reconcile 16:28 – Can I clean my house on Sundays? 20:12 – I had a conversation with a Jewish friend who asked me to prove where Jesus said he was God? Where can I find that? 24:57 – How do I let someone know that wearing a rosary is inappropriate? 32:00 – Act 8:37 Why does it appear in some bibles and not others? 41:57 – Can you help clarify the proper way of receiving communion? I’ve heard a lot discord lately 47:48 – Is it ok for me to remain a protestant? 50:54 – I was raised Catholic but became Mormon. I’m considering Catholicism again. How do I proceed? Resource Mentioned: https://ignatius.com/from-the-susquehanna-to-the-tiber-fstp/
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
04:17 – How do we qualify ourselves to receive holy communion? 18:18 – Who can serve as extraordinary ministers of holy communion? How often can one serve? 28:42 – How do you face the fear of going to confession especially if you know you’re going to commit the sin again? 41:35 – How do I talk to my family and catch up with them without gossiping? 49:54 – I had a very real dream that I went to confession. If I would have died at that moment would that confession have counted?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
12:03 – 1 Kings 15:5 says David followed the Lord all the days of life. But how can this be if he had multiple wives and committed adultery with Bathsheba? 18:05 – What is the Catholic root of confirmation? What does this have to do with the Holy Spirit? 21:51 – What’s the best explanation for the original ending of Mark? 29:27 – Can you go into detail about the Catholics’ connection to the pope and the point of one? 32:22 – When discussing transubstantiation. Can we hold to the dogma without accepting the notion of substance and accidents? 41:13 – Do we have any writings of the Church Fathers that explain what heaven might look like? 47:53 – How can Catholics reconcile Pope Boniface IX’s explanation that salvation can only be obtained by faithfulness to the holy pontiff and Vatican 2’s teaching that people can be saved outside of the Church due to ignorance?
…
Questions Covered:
11:42 – How do we alleviate suffering since we can’t totally get rid of it? 23:51 – I’m a widow. It’s important to call out to God during suffering. 32:39 – I’m in my 80’s and in constant pain. My wife constantly takes care of me daily and has embraced suffering daily. 42:46 – How does suffering connect to the souls in purgatory? How can suffering bring us closer to God? 51:18 – Can you expound on your comment that suffering is related to evil?
…
Questions Covered:
09:14 – Would It be ok for Catholics to believe extra books of the bible like 3rd and 4th Maccabees as inspired scripture? 15:23 – Where do we see in the bible passing on of the diaconate, priesthood and episcopacy? 22:15 – Could we use Mt.18 as evidence for confession? 29:22 – What’s the difference between Catholics and Protestants? 38:45 – Gal 1:17 used as evidence for not needing apostolic teaching but for individual interpretation. What’s the rebuttal? 42:56 – It seems that John 20 is sufficient for salvation. What is the Catholic Rebuttal? 47:00 – How do we understand sin based on the bible, and how does that correlate with Jesus giving authority to forgive those sins?] 50:24 – I’m a convert. The Methodists are the only exception with more authorities than scripture.
…
Questions Covered:
11:32 – Why would someone who is raised Catholic become transgender? 19:00 – As a Catholic school teacher, how do I help my students who identify as a different sex/attracted to same sex? 34:33 – Calling to give word of encouragement as someone who is Catholic and experiences same sex attraction. 37:46 – What is the best way to be a good Christian witness to my gay friends? 46:47 – Where is the balance between being loving and standing up for the truth in regard to all the propaganda that is thrown at us?
…
Questions Covered:
03:32 – How do we know that God is good and not evil? 14:40 – What is a venial sin? 21:52 – When is it okay to receive communion outside of the Mass? 30:07 – If God exists in the eternal realm, is our spirit with him now or only at the end of our life? 33:46 – How do I deal with end of world prophecies on YouTube? 37:35 – Should I keep going to confession for the same sin? 44:10 – How can I encourage a Protestant friend to kneel at Mass if she does believe in the real presence? 47:31 – Why were Mary and Joseph amazed by Simeon’s prophecy? 51:58 – Can I refuse to be a witness to an annulment request from my daughter’s ex-husband?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
04:00 – How accurate is the movie Nefarious on demonic possession? 16:11 – Can you help me better understand the devotion to the Sacred Heart? Why not just a devotion to all of Jesus? 21:39 – What’s the meaning of the opening of the tombs in Matthew 27:52? Is John 5 an allusion to that verse? 29:07 – The most crucial problem with the Roman Catholic Church is its belief that faith alone in Christ is not sufficient for salvation. 32:30 – Is baptism a requisite to be a Christian? 35:06 – Is AI now or in the future able to create images of our thoughts through scanning our brains? If so, how do we reconcile this with our thoughts being a spiritual thing? 43:35 – What does the Church teach about mediums like John Edward? 51:29 – I was told that there are 7 levels of heaven. Is this true?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
03:40 – I don’t understand how a sacrament can be valid and illicit at the same time. 07:55 – How did people prior to Jesus expect and understand eternal life? 14:51 – Is there any sign that there will be a revival of faith coming? 21:57 – Is there a reason why some Catholic art contains architecture and weaponry that is anachronistic to its time? 28:22 – Can you explain who has authority to do exorcisms? 32:34 – Is numerology real? 38:23 – What reasons should a Christian believe in just war theory? 49:49 – Can you help me understand better the ‘Oh Happy Fault’ that we sing on Easter? Why do we say we gained more than we lost?
…
Open Forum, Questions Covered:
05:50 – What your thoughts on Utah’s banning of the bible. I think the bible’s sexual content is far worse than the sexual content of other books that are banned. 15:04 – What’s the Church’s relation to the Greek Orthodox Church and what are the differences? 18:45 – How can we understand the NT when some miracles were only temporary for the first century? such as the disciple who lied to Peter and died instantly. 24:07 – I have trouble understanding penance. Why did some people have penance that lasted years? 37:43 – If you get a plenary indulgence, is it good for life? 43:49 – How did the Orthodox retain apostolic succession while the protestants didn’t? 48:44 – What are the best argument against Wicca Paganism?
…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:
10:25 – I’m atheist and am looking into Catholicism. My only religious friend began attacking Catholicism the moment I mentioned it. Why would Christians say that Catholicism is evil and Satan worshippers? 18:18 – What is the ordinary form of the liturgy and what are the other forms? 28:36 – If the priest does not say the words of absolution, is the confession still valid? 33:07 – When does Marian devotion become heresy? 43:10 – My birth mom has made me the person in charge of her will. She requested being cremated and having her remains scattered. Can I do this as a practicing Catholic? 49:14 – Josephus and others had different beliefs about Jesus. Because of their beliefs, did they just leave out the resurrection? 51:25 – How do the Catholic and Calvinistic view of the Eucharist differ?
…
Questions Covered:12:11 – Is there a list of dogmas that I have to believe that I have to believe to convert?16:44 – I want to challenge the Catholic view on and interpretation of the Old Testament?30:00 – What creates the foundational understanding of the Church’s teaching on contraception?41:00 – What is the responsibility of the Church if they have Catholics who don’t adhere to the teachings?46:26 – Why should I believe the magisterium is holy if they are caught up in scandal?50:09 – It’s hard to believe that God loves us. How can we know that he actually does?51:15 – What criteria would be needed for a person to morally take their own lives?…
Questions Covered:17:00 – When is the ideal age for a woman to conceive a child?19:42 – Should Christians see adoption of frozen embryos as a noble thing to do?24:44 – If someone is terminally ill and certain to die in a short amount of time, why is it morally wrong to terminate their own lives?33:10 – I’ll be entering the medical field soon. What do I do if a patient starts requesting physician assisted suicide?46:33 – What is the difference between embryonic adoption and children being adopted?…
Questions Covered:2:58 – Jimmy, huge fan of your work, your terminal intellect and towering beard. Or maybe I got that backwards. If we, in the eschaton are given our infallible bodies and the new Jerusalem in essence becomes our planet krypton… can you postulate on what we will do in the eschaton? Saints are generals in God’s army etc? But what will our missions be? Will we go and evangelize the universe of fallen creatures? If so, will Christ have to incarnate on that world to save them or will we as we have been “made Gods” or is that a blasphemous thing? If we do hypothetically have to incarnate for them, would our infallible bodies change to the alien form we incarnate for thus we become aliens only until we go to the next world? Or if only Christ can do the incarnating / saving would be or are there already millions of incarnations of Christ and his form in heaven adjusted to whatever creature he’s interacting with?13:45 – Why did Humans take so long to be advanced just recently with agriculture, medicine, economy, infrastructure etc. What were they doing for 200,000 years!?18:10 – With admission by the USA of ufos, what do we think about extraterrestrial beings—souls, evangelizing, origin, etc20:15 – I think about the doctrine of Divine simplicity and the afterlife. If God is not made of any parts, what are we going to see when in heaven? Or what is he going to reveal to us if he is so simple.23:30 – I heard that Lucifer’s rebellion was that God revealed the Incarnation of the Son, for which he refused to serve a man.Does that mean it wasn’t revealed that God is Trinitarian? I’m assuming that because God is omnipresent, the Son is God and is man.28:28 – What are your thoughts on spontaneous human combustion? Is there evidence it’s happened, and what would be a possible explanation for it?34:07 – What evidence is there that humans matured earlier in life in Christ’s time?38:45 – What would the moral implications be of joining an expedition to colonize Mars or other planet, knowing that there would not be access to any sacraments indefinitely.42:40 – If Christ made a visit to all continents together with Joseph, Mary, and the apostles (just like a Papal visit) before He was crucified, would the world have become Christians?46:31 – Did Jesus have opinions? Such as having a favorite food or favorite color? Would these be the results of random biology and environment as He grew up?…
Questions Covered:04:00 – Was it certain or contingent that Adam and Eve would fall or that the angels would fall? 14:42 – Suppose Middle-Earth really existed. Could God become incarnate as a man, an elf, a dwarf, and a hobbit all at the same time? If yes, could man, elf, dwarf, and hobbit Jesus interact with each other and maybe all go 17:03 – I am a bit of a survivalist nut and I am always preparing for the collapse of civilization. I was just wondering, if there was a nuclear war or really any kind of catastrophe that would trigger a societal collapse, and the chaos was so widespread that most of the bishops and all of the cardinals were killed, how would the new pope be elected? Could the surviving bishops (who I would imagine would not be cardinals because most likely they’d all be remote rural bishops) elect the new Pope? 23:34 – When the Magi came, do you think it made the Holy Family wealthy? Enough to travel and stay in Egypt, provide for a 3-year ministry of 13 plus, and for the care of his beloved mother Mary until the Dormition?28:43 – Where does the idea of toll booths come from, and why didn’t it make its way into the Western church?42:30 – Are the laws of logic and thought — identity, non-contradiction, and excluded middle — true of all possible universes, or only of ours? Would multiverse theories or alternate dimensions modify these rules? And do the laws certainly apply even here, or could one argue that maybe an extreme form of Scotistic “haecceity” versus “quiddity” means that maybe they don’t?49:23 – Why is most lunch meat round when bread is mostly square?…
Questions Covered:01:43 – What’s a good response to someone who insists that believers don’t need a hierarchy? 04:38 – When Jesus was baptized by JTB, did John hear God say that Jesus was his son? If so, why did John ask Jesus if he was the Messiah in Luke 7? 11:16 – Soul sleep. I’ve read everything on Catholic Answers including your own article Jimmy Akin. Recent rebuttal to Luke 15 was this refers to “angels but not saints as they are dead until raised” or in the Transfiguration, these were mere “visions.” 20:21 – Our Bishop interprets Paenitemini in such a way that we are required to abstain from gravies and soups made from meat in the Fridays of Lent. 28:40 – How does God answer our prayers? How do Mt 21:22 and Mk 11:24 come into play? 33:13 – What is hardness of heart? When it says God hardened pharaohs heart, what did it mean? How does it tie into Judas’s decision? How does it tie into our spiritual growth today? 40:48 – How can we have a better time converting Muslims? 46:25 – Hi Jimmy, I recently spoke with an atheist, and he asked me why the Christian God? …
Open Forum – Questions Covered:15:59 – Why do we say that we vote on the issues instead of the person? What if a person is morally corrupt?22:02 – NFP is causing a rift in my marriage. Is there any middle ground for Catholics?37:12 – How do you defend the privation view of evil?45:03 – I’m interested in Catholicism. I’ve been convinced that the sabbath is actually Saturday. What’s the argument for the Sunday Sabbath and would it be valid to celebrate the sabbath of Saturday?…
Questions Covered13:41 – Do you think Pontius Pilate went to heaven?20:42 – How do you recommend talking to someone who is Anti-Catholic?30:48 – What is the difference between someone’s mind and soul?35:56 – How can the Catholic church promote reading the Bible more?42:47 – If two popes have differing opinions/teachings on things, how do you approach that?47:18 – If God is all knowing, why does it matter what I do? Do you actually have free will?53:11 – Is the magic 8 ball part of the occult?…
Questions Covered06:16 – Does Paul teach works-based salvation in Romans?13:36 – How do we invite Non-Catholic’s to Mass?22:14 – Can the devil read your thoughts?29:38 – How do you explain Mary being the Queen of Heaven?42:17 – As someone who is new to Catholicism, how do you dive deeper into your faith? Why do you have to go to mass on Sunday?48:30 – Is St. Bridget of Ireland a pagan goddess? What is her history?…
Questions Covered13:47 – As people have their body parts replaced with mechanical parts (arms, heart, etc.) is there a point where they are no longer themselves?19:00 – Has there been any update on stem cell research? Is there any update on embryonic stem cell research?31:49 – Is it acceptable to donate your body to science? What is the Church’s stance on cremation?37:02 – Legally, do you have to test animal embryos before testing human embryos? Is it ethical to preserve embryos to display for educational purposes?45:07 – Are condoms illicit during pregnancy if they can help prevent bacterial infection when antibiotics can be harmful to the fetus?50:32 – What is Fr. Tad’s perspective/counsel on ectopic pregnancy procedures?…
Questions Covered07:23 – Is it heretical or orthodox to say that homosexual behavior is illegal?16:28 – What translation of the bible do you use? What makes a good/bad translation?20:55 – Does it matter if you get baptized in the name of the Father, Son, Holy Spirit versus just the name of Jesus?34:00 – Is it orthodox to throw red rose petals during mass to celebrate Pentecost?41:25 – How do you explain indulgences? And not make them seem like “tokens” to heaven?46:45 – Do you think the protestant reformation upset God or was it part of His plan?49:40 – What did Jesus mean when he said to the thief on the cross “you will be with me in paradise”?52:27 – Why did Jesus choose to resurrect privately without any witnesses?…
Questions Covered03:46 – Why do people still have an issue with the Divine Mercy devotion, and why is it actually okay?13:24 – Why is St. Gregory Palamis canonized as a saint if he was an Eastern Orthodox monk?20:55 – In the language that Jesus spoke, did he use the same word in Aramaic to refer to Peter and to the rock upon which he’d build his church?30:00 – What’s the theology behind popes blessing monarchs, and how does that bear on the relation between church and state?35:32 – When the Jewish people were given the Old Testament, were they given infallibility with interpreting the scripture?45:11 – After the battle of La Ponto, the pope instituted the feast of Our Lady of Victory then changed it to our lady of the rosary… can Catholics still ask for the intercession of Our Lady of Victory?48:39 – Why does the Roman Rite not practice infants receiving communion like the Byzantine Rite?…
Questions Covered:08:15 – Is there a theological basis for the pope to restrict the TLM?21:05 – Wouldn’t Mary’s parents need to be free from sin in order for them to have an Immaculate Conception. Behold Your Mother24:28 – Do you know anything about an official World War I metal rosary?31:16 – Mt 18:6 Does this mean that Jesus considers little children to believe in him?46:30 – How did Jesus’ humanity and divinity exhibit themselves in his everyday life?…
Questions Covered: 09:40 – CCC 2093. Does this mean we shouldn’t be pulling weeds and swatting flies since we aren’t loving God through those creations?20:03 – What’s the difference between a spiritual director, confessor and someone who hears your confession?31:09 – I am a Catholic and would like to know if I have to confess my sins to a priest, or can I confess my sins to God through prayer?35:15 – Is one considered a baptized Catholic if they are baptized by a schismatic?39:25 – If a priest charges admission to the mass is Jesus still present?41:10 – Why do we need purgatory when we’re quenched by the blood of Jesus?46:37 – If you’re in an opportunity of offering redemptive suffering but you forget, can you offer that up later?51:35 – Why are Anglican and Episcopalian priests allowed to become Catholic priests even though they hold different beliefs?…
Questions Covered:30:09 – I thought Mary visited Elizabeth to learn about childbirth. Is this true?32:58 – Why were Mary and Joseph surprised at Jesus’ comment about being in his Father’s house after they lost him?42:23 – I was taught that the visit to Elizabeth was typological to David dancing in front of the Arch of the Covenant. Can you expound on that?44:16 – Can you explain the timeline of Joseph and Mary’s betrothal? Was it before, during, after the Visitation?49:32 – Would Simeon at the Presentation have remembered that this was the Mary that was pregnant outside of marriage and Joseph almost divorced?…
Questions Covered:20:15 – It feels like Catholic Charities has been pushed out of the foster care services.32:39 – How do you prepare your home if you want to foster?35:51 – I was adopted as a baby. I want to encourage people to adopt and not abort.44:44 – Are there any grandparent programs to adopt children?48:16 – I work in a foster organization and everything you’re saying is correct.…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:04:33 – I’m a convert from Episcopalian church. Why can’t I receive communion at both churches when I go with my family?17:35 – I’m interested in Catholicism. What is the thought of using products that have been associated with immorality? For example, buying shoes from a company that has produced shoes with a pentagram?31:04 – I’m coming into the Church but am cohabiting. What should I do?37:25 – A Protestant was arguing that we shouldn’t have Marian intercession because it is based on the Old Testament. What’s the response?45:23 – Is once saved always saved the sin of presumption?48:29 – Is it okay to go to adoration and just sit in silence?50:55 – Do Anglican priests have to be re-ordained when they convert to Catholicism?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:05:27 – Does Is. 53:10 support penal substitution?17:42 – What is the best way to discuss the Marxist tendencies in the Grapes of Wrath from a Catholic perspective?20:30 – How does Hebrews 10:14 not teach eternal security?42:37 – Did God really forsake Christ on the cross?47:30 – Why aren’t the Church Fathers as popular among Protestants as they are with Catholics?51:34 – I’m returning to the faith. Is it appropriate for me to read the bible and try to discern the word of God?…
Questions Covered:03:06 – Is Michael Heiser a heretic? Why are so many Protestants intrigued by his teachings?11:04 – This question has always been on my mind. The Bible periodically speaks of God as being the One True God. Or mentions, as I paraphrase, “no other gods are like our God.” What’s the faith teach about “other gods?” Are the Hindu, Buddhist, Greek, Roman, Mayan, etc., gods real to an extent? I always wondered if they could have been demons or fallen angels manipulating things on earth. Would love to explore that topic of other gods and their legitimacy.18:28 – I learned from a Catholic trivia game that “as a result of the 1917 Code of Canon Law, the moon is considered part of the Diocese of Orlando, FL.” There was no citation, however. What is the law in question and how does it apply to the moon when it was promulgated before space exploration began?28:27 – I love my wife, my cats, my country, and cheesecake. Why then do I find it so hard to believe that I love the Lord? Considering all that the Lord has done, I feel I should be positively burning with love and gratitude and that I should actively live each moment of my life in His service. Yet, I get caught up in life, I sin, and that burning devotion never really materializes. I am left feeling selfish and ungrateful. I pray, I try to keep the commandments, and I avail myself of the sacraments, but if you ask “Do you love the Lord?” I will hesitate. If I really DID love Him, I’d be a better person, less of a sinner, and my love for Him would burn far greater than my fear of His judgement. Right? I certainly have FEAR of the Lord. My greatest longing is to be numbered among His sheep. My greatest terror is to be cast out with the goats, even though I deserve it. Is this just scrupulosity? Am I being too hard on myself? Can love and fear of the Lord be the same thing? Am I missing something important that I need to change?34:20 – If, as written, a wife needs to submit to her husband and a husband should love his wife like Christ loves the church. How does this make sense if the wife must in some relationships make a much better leader? Is it really the teaching that a family may suffer if absolutely the inadequate person is the leader? Is it church teaching that a woman cannot be a better head than any man? Resource: https://www.catholic.com/magazine/print-edition/spiritual-headship42:14 – Can saints (and demons for that matter) hear our thoughts? If not, is silent prayer to saints therefore useless?…
Questions Covered:02:55 – During the recitation of the Gloria at Mass, we say (speaking to and about our Lord Jesus), “For You alone are the Holy One. You alone are the Lord. You alone are the Most High…” My question deals with the use of the word “ALONE” in these statements. I accept that they are all true, but I also know that they apply equally to the Father and the Holy Spirit. Understanding that the prayer intends no contradiction or diminution of the other Members of the Trinity, is this grammatical “glitch” just an artifact of translation or is there a deeper meaning present that eludes me?07:18 – In the divine plan of things, why did Jesus come when he did? He could easily have showed up in 1930’s Louisiana and we would all be wearing electric chairs around our necks. My $0.02 take is that the year that we call “1” was the perfect time because (1) The Hebrew people have marinated long enough in the stew of Salvation History. They became mature enough to finally host the Messiah. (2) The Jews lived at the literal center of the world (the Americas and its peoples not coming into play in the divine plan for another 1500 years, of course). (3) What made the Roman Empire special was its vastness and its roads. The original information superhighway for which the early members of “The Way” can spread the messages given by The Savior. I would love to hear your take on this question.14:45 – Does the Catechism of the Catholic Church have more authoritative power than previous conciliar documents? Isn’t the CCC the primary authoritative text currently?17:07 – It seems like a lot of people see loved ones after they die. Can loved ones come back for a moment to comfort those they left?21:26 – I have some friends that are Traditionalist Catholics who seem to possess a “my world is coming to an end mentality” over the fact that Pope Francis issued his Traditiones Custodes document. Could you give me some advice on how to talk to Traditionalist Catholics about why the Pope issued that document?28:28 – During a recent program, you gave the requirements for a sin to be classified as mortal. Namely: grave matter, full knowledge, and free consent. You went on to illustrate “grave matter” with the example of stealing $1.00. If done against a millionaire it would probably not classify as “grave”, but if done against a poor person it very likely would. All of that makes perfect sense, BUT… I have a measure of OCD and the related scrupulosity. While they make me very good at my job, they also make me chafe at grey areas with high stakes, and what stakes are higher than salvation? My question is this: How can we best define the line between “grave” and “not grave” without foolishly or mistakenly convincing ourselves that what may actually be grave really isn’t? Clearly, the location of that line will vary depending upon the circumstances, but what guidance can you offer to help us draw it correctly, or at least safely, each time? To borrow a phrase from Douglas Adams, “We demand rigidly defined areas of doubt and uncertainty!”36:30 – Does God have perfect knowledge of the future?41:45 – Someone was married to someone who got caught up into Satanic worship after watching the original Rosemary’s Baby. Their house became infested with spirits who played tricks on the spouse, trying to get her to leave, mostly they hid keys or other things, so she was often late. An occult expert told her the spirits wanted her out and they would become dangerous, harm her, or even kill her. She told her husband and tearfully told him she had to leave. He had a big bonfire and burned the objects he had collected along with the books, he quit participating, and bit by bit the spirits stopped antagonizing the wife. The husband had a terminal illness, but he was never seriously ill as long as he participated but almost immediately…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:03:58 – If a marriage is declared annulled, how do you refer to the former marriage if it was declared invalid?08:44 – How do I talk to a Mormon about the Trinity? Resource mentioned: From the Susquehana to the Tiber22:37 – How is one qualified as a valid Catholic?28:37 – How do Catholics understand Mt 24:13 and Mt 24:22?40:18 – How do I balance liberal and conservative theology within the Catholic Church?47:46 – Do people become angels when they die?51:42 – Is Marian devotion a requirement for a Catholic?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:09:25 – Were the prophets in the New Testament Church prophesying about the future of the Church?15:40 – CCC states the canon of the bible has apostolic origin but does the early Church disprove that?31:00 – Why does a Catholic have to get married inside of the Church?40:12 – I was invited to a Christian baptism. Is it okay for me to go?47:18 – Who wrote Genesis?50:03 – How do we reconcile John the Baptist being the greatest of the prophets and Mary being the greatest creation?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:02:15 – Is it okay for Catholics to use contraception for irregular cycles?08:41 – If God is pure spirit then why does the bible suggest that he has a human body?18:04 – Can Catholics be a part of Elks Clubs and other societies?23:47 – How do you explain confession to non-Catholics?37:28 – Is using words like, darn or heck, sinful?45:44 – Did the early Church Fathers believe that the three angels who visited Abram were a physical manifestation of the Trinity? Are they right?48:37 – How do we balance separating the body of relics and not allowing the scattering of the remains of loved ones?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:07:24 – Who was the very first Christian?18:45 – This past Sunday’s reading Acts 8:14-17. Don’t we receive the Holy Spirit fully in baptism?22:34 – What choir of angels are depicted only having a head and wings?24:39 – How do you respond to the claim that St. Patrick was a Baptist minister and that the Catholics hijacked his story?34:16 – by saying the Orthodox priesthood is valid, are we saying they are right in saying the papacy is wrong?37:45 – Is it true that there are over millions of Satan clubs across the country?46:02 – Chris, Thank you for your article in the magazine. Have your read Dr. Kreeft’s, How the weakness of the cross makes us strong?49:03 – Why is there so much repetition in the bible, specifically in Exodus?…
Questions Covered:02:34 – Why do Catholics reject abortion but they are ok with taking vaccines with abortion fetal tissue?13:06 – Why would we want to preach the gospel to people if they have invincible ignorance?17:59 – Why do only 30% of professed Catholics actually believe in the real presence of the eucharist?21:52 – How can I defend my faith against a narcissist?31:20 – Why do we say deliver us from evil and lead us not into temptation? We are the cockroaches that create evil, not God.40:07 – What does it mean to be one under the pope?47:35 – Is it a sin to go shopping on Sunday?…
Questions Covered;04:02 – What does the Church believe in reincarnation and why?11:36 – Why do Catholics believe that salvation is faith and work when Jesus preaches works only salvation in Mt 25?17:00 – Why is the pope coming down so hard on the traditional Latin mass?20:57 – Why does the priest mention Melchizedek during the prayers of consecration?24:25 – Why would one want to evangelize a faithful methodist? Wouldn’t they already be considered part of the faithful?34:52 – Why are Catholics not united on the abortion issue?40:17 – Why would God allow things like Hurricane Sandy?46:42 – Why did the words of the mass change several years ago?…
Questions Covered:09:02 – What’s the Catholic view on a 3-person baby that was recently created?17:25 – If evolution is real, why don’t we have any transitional fossils?22:51 – If God is the concept of infinity, is he an ever-expanding infinity or is he the highest set of infinity?31:02 – With science expanding so quickly, I’m reminded of the of the Jurassic Park quote: we are doing things so fast we are not stopping to think if we should.35:07 – Is it okay for me to question certain components of science such as carbon dating?41:04 – What have you done to handle situations when you hit a wall when publishing studies?45:48 – Wouldn’t the argument that God is constantly changing support the theory that men and women can change and be transgender?…
Questions Covered:04:47 – Could you comment on arguments against legal abortion based on it allowing people to make lazy decisions? 12:08 – My son has a buddha statue in his home. My wife and I were invited over to dinner. I don’t feel comfortable going over because of how scandalous it is. What’s your advice? 20:21 – How do you respond to atheists who say you’re only Catholic because you grew up that way? 29:44 – How do you respond to a protestant who explains away Marian apparitions as demonic? 36:38 – Gavin Ortland claimed that the Church Fathers would not agree with what the Church became by the 1500’s. How would one debunk that? 45:58 – How do you reply to someone who says the Catholic version of baptism because of the sprinkling of water instead of submersion? 49:43 – We are studying centering prayer in our Catholic book club. The book by Fr. Thomas Keating says that we are God and my parish priest says St. Athanasius backs this up. Can you clarify? …
Open Forum – Questions Covered:04:01 – Is it moral for my Catholic boyfriend to make glass containers for cremated remains?14:00 – Does the Church take a position on what the genetic makeup of Jesus would look like?16:44 – If God is all knowing, then why would he allow atheists to be born?31:17 – What kind of society would you want to see America become? One that respects all religions or just the Catholic faith?46:41 – How did the concept of the immortal soul come to be in Christianity since the Jewish people didn’t believe in that?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:01:33 – does the initial stage of justification differ from the process that happens after?05:54 – What is the Catholic view on the 1000-year reign of Jesus in Revelation?08:45 – Could you write a book on what the Catholic teaching on justification actually is and why we reject penal substitutionary atonement?18:56 – Is it okay to pray the rosary in public?22:14 – On what basis did the Orthodox dissent during the Great Schism?29:25 – Why can’t our protestant brothers and sisters who are baptized receive communion?45:38 – Under what circumstances would a child or baby receive communion49:06 – How is it possible to say that the Church can claim to be consistent in its apostolic tradition and yet claim that 5 degrees of minor orders are no longer real?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:10:56 – I’ve been getting a lot of Mormon missionaries. Is it fruitful to talk to them?17:12 – Can you clarify Divine simplicity and the essence energies distinction?21:51 – What is the nature of the Church’s non infallible teachings? Could a theologian dissent from those opinions?32:31 – How does Sola Scriptura affirm Tradition as meaningful and authoritative but claims only Scripture as infallible?35:56 – Was it cruel for God to kill innocent babies during Noah’s flood?45:52 – Did Pope Leo the Great and Pope St. Gelasius I condemned communion under one form?50:21 – How do we defend transubstantiation and reject transgenderism since both have the appearance of something they’re not?…
Questions Covered:02:25 – How many languages was the bible translated into around the year 500 AD? I find polemical stuff all around the internet that is trying to put down the Catholic Church by saying it was translated into 500 languages by then.06:23 – What is the Church’s view on suffering well when the person doesn’t really know what that means? My 8 y.o. daughter has been diagnosed with cancer. We as her parents offer up her suffering but how does the Lord view hers?15:44 – Follow up question to Julian. Can you please give some clarification that we can go directly to Jesus rather than always through a mediator?30:57 – If a husband and wife become one flesh in marriage and both die and end up in purgatory, do they first both need to be purged of their sin in order to go to heaven?34:35 – I understand the concept of indulgences that if we do good works or pious actions it will reduce temporal punishment in purgatory. It seems like we’re just doing indulgences to check a box. Are the indulgences in these big books real and what is their full purpose?41:36 – Follow up to previous question – You said, “If you have a gun license, you’ve been deputized by the state to carry out capital punishment.” Can you give some more clarification on that statement?47:27 – How do we reconcile the different factions and the division they cause within the Catholic Church, especially in the US?52:09 – How do I explain the papacy to my Protestant friend?…
Questions Covered:04:04 – Does listening to an audio version meet the criteria of saying the rosary?05:55 – Is it a licit theological opinion to think that Mary did not die before her assumption? On catholic.com, Fr. Hugh Barbour says the magisterium does not teach that she died but Michael Lofton says she did.15:05 – What were the differences between presbyters and Bishops in the early Church?20:38 – In Hebrews 4:15-16, it says, “We have not a high priest that cannot be touched with the feeling of our infirmities…Let us therefore come boldly…” Why do Catholics have priests if this passage says we can go boldly ourselves?32:35 – I shared a video with a friend about how a monastery here in OC is going to be dedicating the month of May to the Blessed Mother. How can I respond to her when she says praying to the saints is demonic?41:50 – Do our works play into the initial stage of justification? If they do, how so?49:11 – If we were in an active shooter situation and have legal license to carry, would we be subject to the same rules regarding “Thou shalt not kill” as a soldier in war?…
Questions Covered:10:40 – What can we do to teach apologetics in our schools?20:48 – What ways can Catholics and other Christians work together to evangelize?29:18 – We should remember that Catholic schools are just the beginning of faith formation. It’s a lifelong learning process of learning faith.36:56 – How does one evangelize one’s own family?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:05:14 – If God gives us free will while he doesn’t give us the option to opt out of heaven and hell?16:42 – Mt 5:28 Does this apply to us thinking about any sin and not just lust?23:23 – How can a person know he is going to heaven?29:19 – Can you speak about numerology or angel numbers? Is it from God or from the devil?33:02 – What does presbyteros mean? Does it have a different meaning in the tanakh?45:18 – Does God not annihilate us because He makes us in His images?48:28 – If God loves everyone does this also mean He loves Satan and his followers?52:27 – Is it possible that we are actually living in hell right now?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:07:13 – What book does the following quote come from? “Let your yes be yes and your no be no. If you are lukewarm, I will spit, you out.” 16:02 – Do baptism and repentance save? How efficacious are they if you can still lose salvation and go to hell? 23:30 – I have a daughter with intellectual disabilities with limited understanding and she is nonverbal. What is the Church’s stance on her being able to receive the sacraments? 31:58 – What am I supposed to contemplate while on the transfiguration in the Luminous mysteries? 38:48 – Why do Catholics call priests father? Doesn’t the bible prohibit that? 46:21 – Will the chalice ever be restored for communion? 53:09 – I have family who don’t know anything about Catholicism and they’re looking for a book recommendation that lays out the very basics. What do you recommend? …
Open Forum – Questions Covered:06:07 – Why do non-Catholics often refer to the pope as the antichrist?13:12 – What resources should I read in order to find the real Church?22:16 – Are all lies mortal sin?39:56 – The wedding at Cana. Did the jars already have water? I asked my pastor and I disagreed with him. He told me I needed to believe exactly what he believed. Is this true?50:16 – How does one get saved in the Catholic Church?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:05:47 – I heard a claim that the Romans created the idea of Jesus. That the Flavian Dynasty created it to suppress rebellion. What’s the rebuttal?13:50 – I just discovered you 6 months ago and am now a donor! I just want to thank Cy for making the show great!20:27 – If the eucharistic miracles are true, would protestants go back to calling us cannibals?36:29 – How do I respond to “nothing but Jesus matters?”49:06 – How long was Jesus on the cross?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:08:39 – Does Pope Pius IX definition of the Immaculate Conception include Mary crushing the head of the serpent? And what does that mean?19:25 – What should one do with wedding rings after an annulment according to the Church?33:10 – Did God will Mary to be the Mediatrix of all grace?44:42 – If you make a vow to God can you make a request of him that the vow is contingent upon?52:04 – What is the bible and Church Fathers view of intercession of the saint?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:08:43 – What happens if you die wearing a scapular but are in mortal sin? Will you go to hell?16:44 – Is there additional grace needed for salvation apart from sufficient grace?34:18 – When you say “forgive these sins and all of my others” in confession, are the sins that you forgot forgiven?47:10 – How do you respond to someone who claims that the devil can intercept prayer and falsely answer it to mislead?52:55 – Jn 6:37 Is this evidence for not needing the Catholic? …
Open Forum – Questions Covered:06:03 – Why do other religions criticize Catholics, but we don’t criticize other religions? 13:52 – How do we help non-denominational Christians understand the truth of Catholicism? 31:19 – How do we reconcile Jesus’ promise to the good thief being with him in paradise that day and Jesus’ descent into hell for 3 days? 41:16 – Can Catholics donate their body to science? 46:22 – Is there a scriptural distinction between intercessor and mediator? 51:51 – Can a Catholic morally officiate a protestant wedding? …
Questions Covered:09:18 – During the period we’re suffering with Christ, he reveals beautiful things to us. He has revealed to me a small prayer.13:54 – Suffering is what drew me towards the Catholic faith and away from Protestantism.16:18 – My wife and I separated for about 3.5 years and there was a lot of suffering involved. I was the cause of it. I went to confession. I look at it as the 3.5 years was a sort of penance as I went through a lot of growth in that time. We got back together after that time.21:39 – I had an experience about 13 years ago where my finger was partially amputated. I decided to offer up my suffering for my husband who wasn’t Catholic. He came into the Church 2 years later. Is this an example of redemptive suffering?33:35 – How can I get a hold of Salvifici Doloris by JPII?36:17 – My wife and I went through a large disagreement on adopting. I was considering moving out when I came across St. Teresa of Calcutta’s teaching on suffering that changed my whole outlook.45:08 – In Psalms it says, “You are the potter, we are the clay.” I think that’s what our entire lives are and that sometimes he’s going to use suffering for that.51:10 – My family has shared some suffering and miracles have come out of it. Resources Mentioned:https://www.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/apost_letters/1984/documents/hf_jp-ii_apl_11021984_salvifici-doloris.html…
Questions Covered:14:38 – At the beginning of the mass, the priest says he’s offering up the holy sacrifice of the mass. I thought only Jesus offered up the mass so what does it mean when the priest says this?17:01 – Do I qualify for making a podcast? I am a practicing Catholic, but I’m not yet baptized.22:03 – Do you have any advice on prayer? I tend to get very distracted but want to listen and get answers.28:50 – I am a fan of combat sports like MMA. I saw a video of Fr. Mike Schmitz saying it’s a sin. I don’t see anything in the catechism about it so is it totally sinful or only parts of it?32:31 – We follow God before we follow men. Do you have any direct verses that point to this?37:23 – How old is the Latin Rite? I’ve seen some sources say it’s from the 13th century and some say it’s much older.41:47 – In the book of Tobit, Raphael says he’s the son of multiple people. What does it mean when he’s just an angel and not the son of anyone?44:31 – How can we reconcile 1 Thessalonians 4:13-18 with the immortality of the soul?48:38 – I am a convert to Catholicism. I’m disappointed in the way the Catholic Church is going along with things like transgenderism. What are your thoughts on it?51:10 – How can we speak about church hierarchy who may be offending Jesus and Church doctrine without offending Jesus and the priesthood itself? Resources Mentioned:https://www.catholic.com/magazine/print-edition/saving-judith-and-tobithttps://catholic.cafe/2020/01/21/angel-pretends-he-is-azariah/…
Questions Covered: 30:54 – Do you see any parallels between Mormonism and Islam? 35:18 – I found the Osmonds to be a strong family. As a Catholic, can I still admire this Mormon family. 42:36 – Do Mormons believe Jesus was an Angel? 45:00 – Did you ever hear of any miracles in the LDS church? 46:38 – Do I need to get Baptized again when entering the Catholic Church from Mormonism? 50:33 – Do you find Mormon women more stressed because of a requirement to server from the church? …
Questions Covered:01:30 – While I was praying my rosary, it broke. Does this mean anything? 05:07 – Could 1 John 5:7 be used as evidence for the Trinity in scripture? 14:16 – How can I become an apologist? 18:40 – Why are the angels fighting in Revelation 12? And is that describing something current? 22:33 – How would you prove to a protestant that the woman in Genesis 3:15 is Mary? 29:53 – Does the Church have any literature on the topic of why men are leaders in the Church and the home? 35:13 – Is there historical evidence of dragons? Is it possible that they are what we currently think of as the dinosaurs? 45:23 – Is it required to have your first reconciliation before your first Communion? Are we supposed to have a CCD program at our parish for this? 48:32 – Is it better for an atheist to come to believe in some kind of God even if they don’t get all the way to the Christian God? …
Questions Covered:04:24 – My Catholic son married a non-denominational Christian who’s trying to get him to raise their kids. What can we do? 15:08 – I went to the Ark Encounter in Kentucky recently, and they showed dinosaurs on the ark. How does that, and the extremely literal interpretation of Genesis they took, fit in with the Catholic view? 28:29 – What was the first Catechism officially accepted by the Church? 30:47 – Was it a sin for me to be the best man at a non-Catholic wedding? 34:18 – Did the war between the faithful angels and the fallen angels take place in heaven or on earth? 43:40 – What kind of fruit was on the tree of knowledge of good and evil? 47:58 – I’ve heard from some non-Catholic sources that the Council of Rome didn’t set the Canon of Scripture. Is that true? 51:32 – Could the Catholic Church end up revising its declaration that Anglican orders are null and void? …
Questions Covered:02:30 – I had a family member convert to fundamentalism. They typically tend to run away from their problems and look for the next new thing. How do I bring them back to the Catholic faith in which they were raised?12:32 – Taking into account evolution, at what point in time was our race “human enough” to engulf the soul and spirit so we could start partaking with God? Also, is there a point during fermentation of grape juice in which it is considered fit for consecration? Why aren’t we able to use grape juice like Protestants?22:33 – Are indulgences just shortcuts to heaven? How are they ok?40:26 – Why do we call on Mary as a particular apparition in certain prayers rather than just calling on her as a whole?48:51 – Is it wrong to refuse the blood of Jesus at Mass when offered due to germs on the cup?52:13 – What did God really mean by telling Adam and Eve to not eat from the tree of knowledge? What is the true meaning of the tree of knowledge? Did each of these things have deeper meaning?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:05:45 – Why do we say that Jesus was crucified under Pontius Pilot in the Creed?13:18 – If a gay couple can offer a good well balanced homelife why would the Church’s teaching be relevant anymore?23:01 – What are your thoughts on the bible claim that few go to heaven, and many go to hell?32:58 – Matthew 5:27, Dennis Prager said that this quote is mistranslated, and the term is not actually “lust” but instead “covet.” Is this true?40:30 – You wrote an article that said that not everything in the bible is historically accurate. Could you expound on that?46:04 – Have you ever run into an argument that would try to discredit the papacy and the name change of Peter?51:03 – How can we claim that Moses was a prophet since in Numbers he was so violent?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:03:14 – If my son is incapable of committing mortal sin, does he still have to go to confession?07:57 – Why wasn’t St. Peter arrested for cutting off the soldier’s ear?16:43 – What is the biblical evidence for Mary’s bodily assumption?30:35 – What are your issues with sola scriptura?33:47 – What was the purpose of bringing Lazarus back to life? Where was Lazarus while he was dead?42:16 – I’ve read Early Church was the Catholic Church and now I want to read the original documents. Which collection of writings do you recommend me reading?48:48 – How do I respond to my atheist friends that say the apostles experience mass hysteria after Jesus’ death?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:07:34 – I’m struggling with family members who are in a same sex relationship, especially with kids around. Now they are adopting a child. Should I be more welcoming?16:00 – I disagree with some of Joe’s points on the resurrection that he made on Shameless Popery. Could you clarify?23:20 – Wouldn’t it be better for the Church to relax the strictness on the seal of confession if it would help save people?31:05 – Is it proper for a lay person to start the Agnus Dei. Is there a rule that says you can start the mass not singing but can change it halfway through the mass and start singing?37:56 – I’ve been told I need an annulment. It’s causing me great anxiety. Why would I need one?45:11 – Why would God allow John the Baptist to be beheaded?48:59 – I’m curious about the contradiction of ecumenism. Can you clarify?…
Questions Covered:31:49 – How do you talk family who are a part of the LGBT community about coming back to the faith?36:17 – Thank you for having this topic. What you’re talking about has really struck a chord with me.48:26 – I’m falling into a lot of sexual sin and go to confession weekly but I feel like I’m abusing the sacrament. I don’t feel like I’m gaining traction. What can I do?52:25 – How can we support those entering the Catholic Church who are LGBT?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:11:29 – Are you familiar with the deification of Mary? Is this a Protestant teaching?14:03 – How do I overcome my fear of exorcist movies? I really want to watch Nefarious now.20:20 – Can I pray with a Jehovah Witness since we don’t know which God they’re praying to?22:44 – What’s the justification for the death penalty?31:15 – Why doesn’t the Church make the Feast of the Annunciation a Holy Day of Obligation?34:25 – what’s the argument against the claim that Jesus might have been the Messiah but wasn’t divine?40:35 – What are the differences between experiencing a conversion like Paul vs like Peter?44:18 – Genealogy of Jesus in Matthew. Why does it follow Joseph’s line if that’s not his blood?48:10 – Why would categorize nudity in the Pope Exorcist a near occasion of sin?52:18 – Are health problems a punishment from God?…
Questions Covered:40:25 – How do you work through being physically apart for long periods of time?46:35 – How should I encourage my parents to do a marriage wellness check since they see it as taboo?49:27 – What should a couple who is doing well spiritually do to take it to the next level?52:49 – My husband has a lot of spiritual issues and I feel as though he takes it out on me. What can I do? …
Questions Covered:42:19 – The IMF came out with news that they have a global currency called the “Unicoin”. Are Catholics supposed to be compliant with any totalitarian rules regarding central currency?49:14 – I read an article today that Pope Francis is giving a relic of the ‘True Cross’ to King Charles as a coronation present. What are your thoughts on this?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:05:24 – Canon 932 seems like it says that Mass needs to be in a sacred place unless out of necessity. With this in mind, would it be licit for a priest to celebrate mass on a hike?12:10 – What is the process of getting a spiritual director?16:45 – I’m going to start RCIA soon. How do you recommend me leaving my Lutheran community?21:29 – What are your thoughts on the claim that Paul and Peter didn’t write their letters?35:41 – What happens if someone that is connected to an evil spirit tries to enter a blessed building?41:04 – What’s the difference between spirit and soul?46:15 – What is the role of lay people as spiritual directors?51:07 – Does God have a sense of humor? Is there evidence of this in the bible?…
Questions Covered:21:45 – I work with a nurse’s association that has a sister group in Nigeria. I met some of them at a conference and were later kidnapped and no longer heard from again. 31:05 – 29 years ago was the Rwandan genocide. With that, what is the Nigerian government to prevent a repeat of that? 42:57 – What is the response from the Nigerian military when handling these kidnappings? …
Questions Covered:13:05 – Catholic Answers and St. Paul have changed my life so thank you both!16:35 – I always pray with people whenever they are in need and going through tough times.20:06 – I’m returning to the Catholic faith. Do you have any recommendations on where to start?23:55 – I share my faith by giving medals to people.33:08 – How do I explain the Trinity to kids?42:38 – Is there a course one can take in order to go out and evangelize?46:26 – What’s a good way to evangelize with the Divine Mercy?…
Questions Covered:04:13 – Why do Orthodox celebrate Easter one week late?05:33 – My friend is convinced that there is a class of spirits that aren’t demons. How do I refute this?11:44 – Without wanting to know the future, is it possible to have a conversation with God through the bible?17:25 – Can you clarify what adultery is? Especially since Jesus intensified the teaching.20:52 – Is it a sin to not immediately do your penance after confession?23:30 – I’m considering joining the third order Franciscans. Is it ok to not disclose cannabis use for medical purposes?30:23 – Carolina Catholic Radio App… How can Our Lady help us today?34:30 – How can I better trust that God is speaking to me with so many saints and devotions to Mary?38:10 – Why is the earth referred to as a she in the Exultet prayer?42:52 – The writer of Hebrews says the spirits of the just are made perfect. How are they made perfect?46:21 – Can a married Catholic couple be unequally yoked?49:23 – Is it allowed for the priest to elevate the ciborium during the consecration instead of a single host?51:18 – Was there ever a woman who became pope?51:48 – Would you say that the book by Fr. John Harvey is still a good book to read on homosexuality?53:01 – I had a friend argue that in Acts of the Apostles, the dividing up there belongs was an early evidence and support for socialism. How do I respond?…
Questions Covered:23:08 – Does the CCC talk about when you can resume consuming what you fasted from during advent and lent?30:44 – Is the bible timeline still available?42:00 – How does one square Jesus being the only way to heaven vs no salvation outside the Church?45:42 – I’m Protestant. What should a person who is baptized do to turn to God after they have turned away? Should they be re-baptized?49:42 – How can Jesus not know things temporally, like who touched him when healing power went out from him, but knows everything because he is outside of time?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:04:50 – How did the animals on Noah’s ark reproduce without deformities?10:07 – I am a new Catholic and am drawn to the Latin Mass but the community is not very welcoming. What can we do to be more relevant in our services and be welcoming to newcomers.21:04 – We get frustrated with our parishes for not doing things and sometimes we have to do them on our own.29:02 – I’m a revert. How do I become a better apologist? How do I respond to the claim that Catholics aren’t Christians?34:58 – A priest said that the teaching on homosexuality will evolve and in 50 years will be accepted. Is this true?44:15 – How do I talk to my protestant brother about sola scriptura without being confrontational?…
Questions Covered:1:00 – Update on the Catholic Answers magazine28:51 – Why isn’t there more media promotion for things that build our faith? Things like Bible in a Year, The Chosen, etc.36:37 – I think gestures speak volumes when it comes to Eucharistic Revival.45:04 – I find it disheartening that people don’t want to hear the truth and the constant bashing of formal religion.48:00 – Remembering Dr. Kevin Vost.…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:01:37 – Would everything have played out the way it did whether Mary had said yes or no?12:54 – Can 2 year olds be confirmed?17:01 – I’m protestant considering conversion but I’m having a lot of trouble with Mary being the Queen of heaven. Can you help clarify42:30 – What’s a good way to explain Transubstantiation to a Lutheran pastor?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:07:47 – How is the Catholic Church the first church if there was no Catholic Church till the Great Schism around 1050 AD?16:04 – J. Warner Wallace uses Origen and other early Church sources as evidence against the Perpetual Virginity of Mary. What’s the response to that?21:52 – Are we allowed to use the earth for our own benefit or only use it for God’s glory?30:10 – What are the exceptions to being able to go to weddings that are generally scandalous for a Catholic to attend?34:28 – How was it possible for one pope to override a previous one specifically in the event of the suppression of the Jesuit?36:26 – John 20:17, Why does Jesus Make a distinction between his God and Mary’s God? Why doesn’t Jesus let Mary touch him?41:10 – What is Soli Deo Gloria and how could I talk to Protestant about it?44:26 – How is Transubstantiation taken from scripture?48:12 – A priest said that Moses actually parted the Reed Sea, not the Red Sea. He also said that Marian intercession wasn’t invented until the black plague. Are these things true?53:05 – When is the need for universal acceptance of the Church properly applied?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:15:58 – Is the fact that Mary went to prepare Jesus’ body 3 days after his death evidence against the resurrection? 21:23 – In Paul’s letters to Timothy, what is the meaning of the laying of hands? 23:41 – Is it scandalous for me to attend a civil wedding if the people getting married haven’t finalized an annulment? 31:07 – A friend of mine visited Rome and said “it says a lot about a religion when the streets are made of gold” referring to the Vatican. How should I respond to that? 36:52 – Lev 27:29 Could you explain the harsh consequence if a person is rejected in their vote of offering? 40:57 – St. Alphonsus Liguori says all graces flow through Mary. Is that true? 47:40 – Why didn’t the rabbi’s take note and cause a stir when Jesus was circumcised if Simeon knew he was the Messiah? …
Open Forum – Questions Covered:04:22 – What can I tell my mom who makes comments about hypothetically wanting to be taken off life support instead of suffering?13:39 – Who really was Mary Magdalene? The woman who was delivered from demons or the woman caught in adultery?15:39 – Regarding Pope Francis’ recent statements on the TLM and German bishops. It seems imprudent with how he handles both situations? What can we lay people do in a situation like this?19:41 – Can a person change one’s confirmation name?22:05 – Mt 27:52-53. It seems like a singular event and why isn’t it recorded in the other gospels?24:37 – My friend recently converted to Christianity. How do I explain to my friend the need to confess our sins to a priest?32:11 – Sorry but Jesus didn’t create the Catholic Church. Show me in the Bible please. He told his disciples to go spread the Good News.39:13 – Is it possible for a demon to intercept a petition prayer?44:43 – Is the Easter Vigil Mass mandatory to attend?46:29 – How would one respond to the claim that you’re not supposed to baptize babies because Jesus was baptized at 30?50:02 – How specific does a person need to be in the confessional? If you remember a sin while the priest is giving absolution, what should you do?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:10:35 – Can you help me understand salvation history especially regarding substitutionary atonement?22:00 – My protestant friend claims that Catholics put Mary and the saints above God. I’m a convert and I just want some clarification.25:08 – Is the Aramaic word God Allah?35:35 – Why does the gospel of John not have the institution narrative?43:12 – How did Joseph and Mary deal with temptation if they didn’t have concupiscence?47:00 – How do we counter the claim that the parable of the wheat and the weeds is evidence for double predestination?51:18 – Could the church have made the change that they did at Vatican 2 without having an ecumenical council?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:06:14 – What is accidental glory?13:11 – St. Paul refers to people alive as saints. A protestant argued that this was evidence for once saved always saved. How do I refute this?19:50 – I’m protestant and am considering converting to Catholicism. I was married to 2 married Muslim men and now I’m married to a Jewish man. What would I have to do to convert?29:18 – I’ve seen the Latin mass in the news a lot and who has authority to celebrate it. Do priests who travel from diocese to diocese have authority to celebrate it?32:34 – I’m listening to the Bible and a Year podcast and have a question about Joshua. Why were the Israelites ordered to leave no Canaanite alive? How can we believe in a good God knowing this?37:48 – Why do we pray in the apostles’ creed that our bodies will be in heaven? Isn’t it clear that we know that there are only two bodies in heaven, Mary and Jesus?44:21 – How does one apply indulgences in real life?52:16 – What’s the rule for going to Mass this Friday since it’s both Good Friday and First Friday?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:04:53 – On Sunday the priest talked about Palm Sunday; that some people who welcomed Jesus were also the ones who condemned him. Why was there such a change in viewing Jesus?07:50 – In the Penguins Classic version of City of God, the author of the forward states “St. Augustine showed typical signs of someone on the verge of metanoia” What are those signs?12:58 – Why did God harden the heart of people in the bible?17:00 – Can Catholics attend protestant worship services?23:50 – We had a situation where the mass couldn’t be completed. I had a question about how they concluded it was appropriate.31:58 – Why does Jesus put his hands on the blind man twice in order to heal him? Why not just once?35:50 – I’m considering converting. Will I still be able to serve and play guitar at protestant services?45:01 – Why can’t God create another god?50:06 – Is it okay to take communion twice in one day?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:09:12 – Did anyone in the early church interprets Matthew 16:18-19 as referring to anything other than Peter?16:58 – There were African Martyrs who were a mix of Catholics and Anglicans. Would we Catholics consider those Anglicans as saints in heaven?20:02 – How does confession work?29:50 – Is it okay to receive communion if you have doubts about some teachings of the Church?35:42 – I’m Protestant. How does the Magisterium get the interpretation of scripture right as opposed to protestant pastors and churches?44:21 – I have some very anti-Catholic friends. They say that the Paul VI Hall in the Vatican is satanic because it has the shape of a snake. How do I debunk it?49:30 – Is it okay to wear a zodiac symbol necklace?…
Questions Covered: 03:46 – My son’s future sister-in-law is a nun, does she have to wear her habit to the wedding?10:52 – Did Mary need to be baptized and did she get baptized?15:28 – If annulment means a marriage is invalid, what does that mean for the time the couple spent together?18:34 – Hypothetically if there was a medicine created that allowed you to live forever, should you take it as a Catholic?30:00 – In the Baptist tradition they bring people to Jesus through the roman’s road. What do we do in the Catholic Church to bring someone to a relationship with Jesus before bringing them to RCIA?36:09 – Are there any places where Paul teaches eternal conscious torment as an understanding of hell?46:54 – how is it that the Jews could stone people if they were not allowed to do capital punishment?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:03:19 – What should I do if someone who I know hasn’t received the Sacrament of First Holy Communion receives communion at Mass?13:33 – How do I talk to friends who believe in the rapture?28:27 – Should I still wear a wedding ring for a marriage outside of the church?35:25 – In Genesis it says “let us make man in our image”, who is the “us”?46:47 – What is the blue, purple, scarlet stuff mentioned in Exodus? Specifically, what is “stuff”?…
Questions Covered:02:07 – getting my marriage blessed by the church, should i go through the premarital counseling process? 07:22 – is it always a mortal sin to smoke mamajuana? Resource: https://www.catholic.com/video/what-is-the-churchs-position-on-marijuana 11:26 – What is your advice for discerning marriage with someone who comes from a family with a history of divorce and how to talk to potential children about divorce? 15:29 – what is a sin against the Holy Spirit? Resource: https://www.catholic.com/audio/caf/what-is-the-sin-against-the-holy-spirit 19:28 – What do we do with used bibles and rosaries? 22:31 – how do you approach the question from non-Catholics about asking for the saints intercession? 29:55 – does Father find it difficult to live out his priestly vocation not living in community with fellow priests? 34:58 – Why is it a sin to smoke mamajuana but not drink alcohol? 39:58 – how can someone in heaven look down on a sinful person– does that taint the glory of heaven? 46:24 – commenting on the power of praying for Mary’s intercession 48:08 – if an adult is not baptized why should they wait for Easter versus getting baptized right away? Why can (but shouldn’t) a lay person baptize someone else? …
Open Forum – Questions Covered:02:29 – Regarding two people who have divorced and remarried and now live as brother and sister. What is the Church’s position on receiving communion? Is this a temporary arrangement that needs to be resolved by separation. What does scandal mean in this situation?12:14 – Do you think it’s important to consider false flag heresies in the secular world?20:27 – How does God exact his judgment, particularly in the Old Testament?32:17 – What is the relationship between salvation and good works?42:57 – What does it mean to carry your own cross?51:54 – Is it possible that God can appear to us by appearing as a random person?…
Questions Covered:19:55 – What are the stations after the resurrection? What are your thoughts on them?23:36 – What are the origins of the stations of the cross?32:25 – The stations helped me when my husband was diagnosed with cancer and passed away.37:02 – Was the scourging at the pillar common for all crucifixion or was it unique to Jesus?43:22 – What does it mean to lead the stations at one’s parish?…
Questions Covered:19:47 – Does the Catholic Church teach that Noah’s ark really happened and are we all descendants from those 6 humans?29:47 – Are we all descendants from a common ancestor?44:04 – I want to make a distinction between evolution and natural selection?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:07:07 – Why did Jesus pick John and James to witness the Transfiguration?12:47 – Jesus made a strong statement towards Judas “better not to have been born.” What is your interpretation of that verse?19:57 – We hear that all the angels and saints are always present at Mass. What does that look like on a practical level since Mass is happening across the world?28:46 – Constantine founded Catholicism, and he was a pagan sun god worshiper.32:45 – If a Catholic couple is civilly married but only one of them wants to get married in the Church, what are their options?37:19 – At my parish they are introducing a new model where there is no longer a pastor. They will put a lay person in charge. What is your view on this?43:09 – Why did the Transfiguration happen? Was it in any way related to Jesus’ Baptism since those are the only 2 places God speaks?46:29 – Without the act of betrayal of Jesus, would the passion have happened? Is his life an example of the consequences of free will?50:10 – Jesus’ greeting towards Nathaniel seemed light-hearted. Does this affect the Catholic Church and how they view Nathaniel?…
Questions Covered:13:26 – you give me advice on how to successfully discuss these matters with someone who is having a crisis of faith and trying to make Christianity fit with the gay lifestyle?20:32 – Could people living in a publicly known same-sex relationship serve in public ministry like lectoring?30:49 – It feels as though the bigotry of the Catholic faith is a cause for the high suicide rate in the gay community. Where is the compassion for these people?40:07 – What are your thoughts on Catholic ministries that support all aspects of the LGBT lifestyle?46:24 – How do I relate and love my son who lives out his SSA while holding my ground?52:34 – I have SSA and what made it difficult for me to return to the faith was by how mean Catholics were, especially online. What advice can you give so we can welcome people?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:04:48 – How would you respond to the claim that the Church has tried to keep the bible from people?15:21 – Is there a book that gives a summary of the major theological differences and mainline protestant denominations?19:33 – Should you genuflect every time to enter or exit a pew?22:43 – Judges in the bible sometimes punish others don’t. Which of those are the most just?30:40 – Good Friday and First Friday fall on the same day. Since there is no mass that day how does this affect our obligations?34:41 – What’s the purpose of the St. Michael medal?42:46 – Can you elaborate on your previous comment that the new Mass is just a translation of the old?46:48 – If a person is made in a lab, will that person have a soul?52:17 – Is purgatory the same as Sheol, Gahanna, and limbo?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:03:33 – Is it immoral to sell one’s blood plasma?6:57 – Is it ok for a woman to be a surrogate for her sister?13:55 – If God never says no to our prayers, and we pray for someone not to die but they do anyway. Does God fulfill those prayers by taking that person to heaven?19:44 – I’m trying to return to the Catholic Church. I’m struggling to understand praying to Mary and statues. Can you help me comprehend it?24:43 – Where in the bible does it say that one could drink poison and not be affected? Since we are not supposed to take it literally, What is the real meaning of the verse?35:26 – Could Romeo and Juliet’s marriage actually have taken place?41:14 – Is it necessary under the pain of sin, to call out blasphemy or people who use the Lord’s name in vain?44:06 – I’ve had someone bring me communion for 6 weeks now. Recently she has been coming during lunch time. What’s the rule on taking communion with food in this circumstance?47:01 – I have 3 protestant roommates that want a deeper connection with Christ. How do I best present the Catholic faith as the best option?49:16 – What do Catholics believe that they need in order to have eternal life?…
Questions Covered:05:19 – I’m struggling connecting and loving a God setting up things how he wants and having no input from us.18:55 – Slavery in the bible. Why isn’t it more clear in condemning it?29:12 – I want to ask about opulence in the Catholic Church.36:28 – the Western Schism is a big obstacle. How does the Church explain the multiple popes42:44 – I don’t think transubstantiation is possible because I don’t believe in substances.47:52 – Jesus says you are not supposed to give anything up until you make amends with others. Do Catholics ignore this teaching?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:01:59 – I think 1 Cor. 3:15 is not actually evidence for purgatory as Catholics claim. What’s your response?14:11 – I’m Protestant, I notice a lot of ads to respond to protestants but are there any initiatives by Catholics to call for reunification with us?29:55 – Why did God create predator animals that cause death and suffering?37:30 – I’m in the middle of getting an annulment. What do I do if we can’t prove that my former husband was baptized?44:06 – Do Catholics speak in tongues in their Church services?47:46 – St. Therese of Lisieux said that people go to purgatory for not believing enough in God’s mercy. What are your thoughts on this?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:06:30 – What does a scapular do?08:47 – For an ecumenical council to be ecumenical does it need the majority of the world’s bishops to be valid?15:37 – Is there a specific time in the gospel where the apostles received holy orders?18:22 – How do I explain to my non-Catholic wife why we pray for the dead even though we don’t know where they ended up?28:10 – Is it appropriate to have a baby shower on the Saturday before Easter?32:38 – Is it possible for someone to enter into a vocation that God didn’t intend for them? What would be the results of that?37:05 – When are Joe’s books going to be available in audio format?41:30 – I heard that St. Patrick was schizophrenic because he heard voices. Is this true?47:18 – When Christ quotes Psalm 22 on the cross, did those mocking him know he was quoting it?50:51 – The Catechism says God created all of creation to show his glory. Who was he showing it to if there was nothing there?…
Questions Covered:09:02 – Is the situation in Germany going to permeate into the Church in the US?18:54 – How do you get over being treated wrong in the Church?30:18 – I’m a huge fan of Dcn Harold and I wanted to know if you plan to visit New Jersey?33:25 – How do I talk to my daughter since I feel there is a divide happening between us due to our opposing views on abortion?51:22 – My wife and I teach marriage prep. I wanted to share some of the struggles that these young couples have with the Church’s teaching.…
Questions Covered:07:54 – Does the bible tell us if we can be certain that someone goes to heaven?11:47 – What is your favorite book of the bible? What is your favorite verse of the bible?15:19 – The bible says one receives a crown in heaven. Does one get a crown if one has to pass through purgatory first?18:54 – Are plenary indulgences in the bible and how do they relate to purgatory?22:35 – Does the bible tell us to confess our sins to a priest?35:48 – How do I respond to a protestant who makes a distinction between Petra and Petros when talking about Peter’s papal authority?43:19 – How do I reply to Jehovah Witnesses?47:24 – Does the Catholic bible have passages about the rich man in Luke 16? Was Lazarus in the bosom of Abraham?52:11 – Why do Catholics believe what they do about Mary?…
Questions Covered:06:14 – What is the Catholic response to the accusation that the church is a “revamped/updated” version of Judaism? 11:11 – How did the Apostles know what to say after the Last Supper? How do we know that their words do indeed consecrate the host? 18:22 – I had a mass said by my priest at Christmastime for a late term abortionist that just started a business last year. When the priest says the mass, it’s for their intentions but I don’t want their intentions honored. How does that work, and does it need to be changed? 22:30 – My mother-in-law is not Catholic, and my wife is a convert. My mother-in-law insists on her ashes being split when she passes away. Would going to her funeral knowing this be condoning the splitting of her ashes? 24:31 – In the Our Father we say “…and lead us not into temptation…” Jesus says in the bible “a kingdom divided against itself cannot stand.” Why do we ask Christ not to lead us into temptation if he wouldn’t do so in the first place? 29:44 – I’m a protestant and want to go to mass and start RCIA. Can you explain why there is so much disagreement in the church about the Latin Mass and the Novus Ordo Mass? 37:40 – Is there a connection between the skull cap and the Jewish yarmulke? Also, what’s the significance of the large cap the pope wears? 42:25 – Why do I feel like I’m demanding things from God when praying certain prayers? For example, “…lead all souls to heaven, especially those in most need of thy mercy.” 44:51 – I confessed that I had an “impure thought” and the priest asked me to tell him what exactly that impure thought was. If that ever happened again, am I obligated to tell him that? 48:13 – We have rules and regulations but are never encouraged to bring back fallen away Catholics. Why is that never addressed by the clergy and how can we approach this better? 51:38 – What’s the difference between Lourdes water and holy water? Is there a difference between blessing yourself and blessing a room with either?…
Questions Covered:17:40 – Sometimes people do things that they did not intend but had the same consequence. And It was something they should have known. How does that fit into this calculus? 25:06 – I tried to forgive my father but hung up on him. He then passed away. How do I forgive myself for that? 35:38 – Do you find it important to not detract from someone’s dignity when making light of something? 46:10 – I was in the same situation as Jan and I was able to forgive after speaking to my brother. 48:59 – My mother and father passed away and the siblings have been having a hard time. My brother won’t forgive me and now doesn’t want anything to do with the family. What can I do? …
Open Forum – Questions Covered:07:00 – As a practicing Catholic, can I get ordained as a minister to marry my non-Catholic niece and her fiance?12:00 – What is faith working through charity?17:31 – How can we explain to Jews that the New Covenant fulfills the Jewish law, especially concerning Jesus as the Messiah?22:07 – Are ghosts real?29:46 – Can you recommend any reading that make the case for Catholicism over Orthodoxy?34:45 – Is there an ancient Jewish pre-Christian equivalent to praying to the saints?45:18 – How can I combat relativism in conversations?51:35 – Calvin Robinson is an Anglican who claims that The Anglican Church is the ‘established’ Church. Are you familiar with him and what would that comment mean?…
Questions Covered:10:52 – I have visitation every other week. What’s the best thing I can do?14:13 – As a mother, should I be limiting the time my daughter is with my ex who mistreated me?30:01 – When my daughters were growing up, my husband had the idea of disciplining them by having them stand with their arms out like Jesus so they understood what he did for them. What are Dr. Ray’s thoughts on that?33:42 – As a widower, how do I find some balance in parenting when the kids just have me and no mother?41:43 – How important is it for a father to have a sense of humor? Do you think God has a sense of humor?45:17 – I grew up without a father, so what resources do you recommend for me to learn what I missed out on?49:00 – What’s the most difficult part of parenting?…
Topics Covered:04:22 – Daylight savings07:32 – With the recent vote by the German bishops and the pope’s comments, is homosexuality mainly wrong for the same reasons as adultery?29:50 – What is Pope Francis doing?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered01:25 – What role did Paul play in ordination? When he laid hands, was it Confirmation or ordination?11:38 – What does it mean for Jesus’ human will if he is incapable of sin?21:49 – Does having same sex attraction forbid one from working in ministries in the Church?34:47 – I struggle with hearing very little about Jesus from Catholics? Can you give advice to a person considering the Catholic faith?42:10 – Are thoughts considered sinful, if you don’t consent to the thought and it just pops into your head?46:48 – Should we pray more than once for a specific request?51:05 – When is it permissible to bless another person as a lay person?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:03:35 – When comparing John 3 and John 6, If infants are called to be in the faith, why don’t we allow infants to take communion in the west?12:30 – What reasons do we have to trust the proto-evangelium of James?19:05 – Why pray for those in purgatory if the point is for them to be there to be purged? Wouldn’t that defeat the purpose?28:00 – I recently heard that only 20% believe in the real presence. How do we talk to people about this and help them better understand?39:02 – If there’s multiple layers to heaven and people are on different layers, can they still interact?44:48 – On a college campus what is the most important thing to share about the Catholic faith to guide them towards God?50:45 – Can a Catholic receive ashes from a non-Catholic ash service? Can you receive ashes more than once? Can a female give ashes? …
Questions Covered:12:29 – Is it ethical to consume animals and animal products? Is this taking us away from the true call of Jesus?19:36 – Is it true that the shelf life of a frozen embryo is 5 years?22:11 – What would a couple do with the frozen embryos? Does the Church allow these embryos to go to women who cannot conceive?29:33 – What is gain-of-function research and is it ethical?39:54 – What are your thoughts on printing animal DNA for interplanetary colonization? Would it be ethical?44:55 – Would it be appropriate to have frozen embryos buried with the mother at her death?47:20 – Is Gamete Intrafallopian Transfer licit?…
Questions Covered:19:17 – Why did the death of John receive the distinction of being known as the Passion of John the Baptist?23:02 – Could the sign of the cross be traced back to John the Baptist?29:44 – Since Jesus and John were cousins, is it possible for both of them to be in the temple when they were 12 years old?35:43 – Can you tell us about John’s disciples becoming Jesus’ disciples?42:10 – Steve, you will be coming to my area and I just want you to thank you for talking about Jesus and the Eucharist.45:08 – Jesus refers to John as blessed among women. Since this line is also evidence for Mary being sinless, can we also say that John was conceived without sin?47:14 – Jesus said as high as John ranks, he still ranks as low as women. If that’s the case, where does that put me?50:18 – Would Mary have been baptized by John? Were women baptized in general?…
Questions Covered:12:10 – I have a problem with hospice use of morphine because it can cause respiratory failure. What are your thoughts on this? 17:56 – I’ve considered doing sidewalk counseling. Do you have advice on how to be successful in talking to people? 23:18 – I’m a physician. Has anyone who has prescribed the abortion reversal pill been successfully sued? I worry about prescribing it? 29:44 – Why are children born disabled? 32:27 – Are you aware of the drugs that are used in hospice that can put the patients into a medical coma? It seems like there is incentive to euthanize people. 42:26 – What other options are there for Catholics who don’t want any more kids? 48:45 – I’ve seen the abuse in hospice care and ended loved ones’ lives. I want to thank you for talking about it. …
Questions Covered:03:30 – I’m not Catholic yet because of the lack of evidence for the papacy in the 2nd century.15:28 – The conflicting accounts between Genesis and evolution.22:47 – I’m in RCIA, I’m having a hard time understanding the rosary.28:56 – I was raised Pentecostal and left because of hypocrisy. Now I’m non-denominational. I won’t be Catholic because I don’t get what I need or feel that closeness of Christ.42:35 – Everyone I know that has given up on faith was Catholic. There is no love or redemption. It’s all just rules and worshiping dead saints. Hard pass.46:08 – I became Catholic years ago. I got used to praying the rosary with my church community.49:46 – I don’t see praise and worship in Catholicism.…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:01:36 – When someone goes to hell and we pray for them, what happens to these prayers?04:01 – Why did John the Baptist send one of his disciples to find out if Jesus was the messiah if he already knew who Jesus was?07:39 – When Jacob wrestled with an angel, the bible says that God failed to win him over. How could God fail? Am I reading this properly?14:12 – Do the Jews today still believe in praying for the dead?16:37 – What makes a good confession during lent?20:23 – How do we reconcile the historical clues that Judaism and Christianity come from a polytheistic religion?24:06 – Who was Joseph’s first wife before he married Mary?28:51 – What is the significance of the centurion proclamation that Jesus is God at the crucifixion?30:19 – Phil 2:7-9 Why does Paul say that “because of this God greatly exalted him?” The ‘because’ is confusing me.34:31 – Why is it tradition for a woman to take a man’s last name after they get married?44:43 – How much of the 9 choirs of angels is speculation vs Church teaching?49:01 – Why is it a mortal sin to miss Mass on Sundays?52:30 – In Delaware they’re trying to make a priest record confessions and report illegal activity. What are your thoughts on this?…
Questions Covered:02:00 – I think there’s a difference between regret and repentance06:43 – I’m Catholic. How should I deepen my faith? Should I still go to RCIA?11:18 – What are the arguments against the question: why would I follow Christianity if Buddhism teaches similar things but are more accepting LGBT people?15:43 – Can you add or take away from the bible?19:35 – I’ve been dealing with shameful behavior and coming to the point of being embarrassed to go to confession. I’ll be receiving Confirmation soon and feel unworthy. Can you give me some advice?29:43 – I’m in RCIA and am trying to evangelize my 14-year-old daughter. Do you have advice on how to help?36:53 – What are your thoughts on RCIA directors who don’t have a good understanding of the faith? How would one approach this?43:20 – My husband and I are considering RCIA. We are a bit uneasy with the things the pastor and teacher say. They seem contrary to the faith. What should we do?51:04 – I was baptized as a baby but wasn’t raised Catholic. I want to fulfill all of my sacraments. How do I go about doing that?…
Questions Covered:06:57 – How do I respond to a protestant whose claim against images is saying that the Jews would never have had a statue of Moses in the Temple?16:49 – If we were baptized as babies, would we be able to go through the RCIA program?19:38 – I agree with everything the Church teaches except for papal authority. If the pope were to declare something ex cathedra against scripture. What would happen?24:48 – Do you have to pay to go through RCIA?30:01 – On the past Sunday readings on the Transfiguration. I’ve heard conflicting evidence on which mountain did this occurred. Can you help clarify?33:41 – As a single dad, 41 and having busy life, I’ve started RCIA 3 times in the last 10 years. I’ve never finished and am considering trying online. What are your thoughts?44:09 – If a couple comes into the Church, would their marriage need to be blessed by a priest?47:52 – I have a hard time believing the words in the Creed “for the forgiveness of sins.” How can I get over this?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:02:06 – Will all the people, including the people around the time of Adam and Eve, also be resurrected?07:44 – Regarding NFP, what is the nature of this practice directed to? Is it for getting pregnant or avoiding pregnancy?14:17 – I’m struggling with the teachings of Mary, her Assumption and the painlessness of her childbirth. Can you help bring me some peace?22:58 – Why do Catholics give up meat on Lent but other Christians don’t?29:33 – Can godparents bless their godchildren?31:26 – Is it okay to listen to Catholic mass online more than once a day? Can one receive spiritual communion more than once a day?33:40 – Why can you not give an indulgence to another living person?40:14 – Don’t Transubstantiation, Consubstantiation, Transfiguration, Consubstantial all basically mean the same thing?45:12 – When NFP is undertaken and conception occurs when it will not be implanted, is it justifiable under natural law?50:26 – My Protestant sister claims that the forgiveness of sins Jn 20:23 is past perfect in the Greek. She implied that this was a commission to all and not an apostolic mandate. Resources Mentioned: https://www.catholic.com/magazine/online-edition/finding-sacrament-confession-in-biblical-grammar…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:05:57 – Did Leonardo DaVinci have a vision of an angel in his life?13:30 – As a Catholic do I have to believe that Adam and Eve were real people?19:09 – When Jesus comes back, will he be in a special form?23:31 – On the Glory be prayer. Can you break it down and what it means?34:13 – I’m protestant and am converting. My pastor passed away. Would the Catholic Church teach that he was a heretic?39:38 – What is the Church teaching on what happened to Judas Iscariot?46:16 – How can we say that when the body passes away that we should keep it together, but at the same time we separate relics?52:31 – If Peter was the first pope, then why was he considered the bishop of Antioch?…
Questions Covered:09:46 – I’ve been an addict for over 5 years now. Am I missing anything in terms of my faith life? I pray the rosary and go to mass daily. 18:07 – I worked for a Christian non-profit where we helped addicts get on their feet. I would always make it a point to tell them not to look back. What do you think about saying that? 29:11 – When a person is dating or married to an addict, how do they discern who the real person they are is? Is it ok to break things off without giving them the chance first to get help? 35:50 – How can you combat food addiction? You can’t just cut food out completely so I think it’s a different process than being addicted to substances. 41:50 – Is all addiction sinful? Is an addiction to something that’s not “bad” still sinful? 46:55 – I’m noticing a lot of similarities between the step program and Ignatian spirituality. Are you aware of any Ignatian programs or retreats that incorporate the step program? 48:07 – I’m 68 and currently on a methadone program. Is it worth getting off methadone after being on it for 30 years? Is it ok to stay on it? 53:03 – Is Sr. Ignatia Gavin recognized as one of the starters of Alcoholics Anonymous?…
Questions Covered:17:01 – How can the Eucharist solve the problems we have with the division in culture today?30:08 – I don’t think the Eucharist can change the world. I think there’s more that goes into it. I think there’s too much money in everything, including the Church, for the Eucharist to change everything.35:29 – You say the Eucharist awakens our conscience. The bridge to receiving the Eucharist to someone not in the church, however, isn’t a short one. What can we do in the interim to make an argument against Transgenderism?49:22 – Sometimes when people criticize the Church we get a litany of this and that. I think your talking about the Eucharist in terms of changing the culture will really help.…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:10:54 – I left the Church because I feel like God was giving me a hard time. I’m Protestant now and I feel like the sin I was committing was that I didn’t have enough faith. I’m considering coming back to the Church. What are your thoughts on this?17:55 – What is the Catholic teaching on salvation? How does it differ from what our protestants believe?22:36 – Act 8:21 Peter rejecting Simon. Today we hear that we should not judge, then how could Peter have done this?36:52 – I couldn’t make a confession when I became Catholic and on the Easter vigil Mass the priest absolved me right in the middle of mass since I approached for a blessing. I received communion. Was this valid?42:53 – Since Ingo Swan was a Scientologist; does it affect the permissibility of remote viewing?50:41 – I wear a cross that someone told me was a Rosicrucian cross. Who are Rosicrucian’s, Is the cross affiliated with them and is it ok to wear them?…
Questions Covered:13:42 – What does salvation look like for people that have left the Church due to the sex abuse scandal? Good question20:31 – Jesus says he is the way, the truth and the life. Catholics say the Catholic Church is the way. Is this contradictory?24:20 – Paul says those who call in the name of the Lord will be saved. That which you are proclaiming is false.34:45 – Can you give me 3 of the best reasons to be Catholic and not Orthodox?38:18 – I’m Anglican and faithful. Is your Church saying that I can’t have salvation?45:47 – How do we practically communicate this teaching to ecumenical groups?48:40 – What are your thoughts on the movie Silence and the question on salvation in it?50:33 – Are there any documents prior to the 60’s that show the caveats regarding salvation that we hear about today?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:10:31 – Is a confession valid if a priest forgets to ask you for your act of contrition?13:12 – In the Mass, why do we pray for those who have passed away and those who have fallen asleep? Why separate them?14:36 – If we can pray directly to God why go to a priest for confession?20:34 – I’m a convert and now my son is going through RCIA. He was baptized in a protestant Church. Was it valid? Should he go to confession before receiving communion?32:00 – I’m a new Catholic and just went to adoration for the first time. Why is adoration ok? Should the eucharist be consumed?40:01 – How do we prove polygamy wrong using scripture?47:25 – I’m a non-practicing Catholic and looking to return. I got married and divorced and never had an annulment. I just discovered that my ex-wife filed and was granted an annulment without my knowledge. Would it be in my best interest to have the case reopened to have my testimony on file?52:18 – What is the sin against the Holy Spirit?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:04:19 – What do we Catholics believe about protestants receiving communion at their own churches?07:06 – Where do we get the traditions of Peter being crucified upside down and Veronica wiping the face of Jesus?11:50 – The bible says God is a trinity and also one. Which is it?16:04 – I’m failing to understand how the Eucharist is a sacrifice. Can you help clarify?21:43 – What do we know about the similarities and differences between the Pharisees and Sadducees. What role did they play in the Passion?28:37 – If Adam and Eve didn’t sin, would there still be a heaven?30:47 – I stopped practicing my faith because of the sex abuse many years ago. I’m beginning my return but now I see new abuses. Why were the priests shuffled around?34:31 – How can you tell if a message is coming from God or the devil?41:05 – What happened to Moses and Elijah after the Transfiguration of Jesus?42:59 – The GIRM 199 states that the priests cannot celebrate the Easter vigil mass alone but later 204 it contradicts that. Can you help clarify?44:31 – How do we read the age of people in the Old Testament, especially since some people lived for hundreds of years?51:36 – Why is Mt. 17:21 missing from some bibles?…
Questions Covered:01:47 – Why do Catholics believe you can pray to the dead when the bible says the opposite?12:22 – Why does the Church believe that Mary is sinless?18:08 – Were the Assumption of Mary and JP2’s declaration on the male only priesthood fall under ex cathedra?23:00 – Could you help explain why we use relics?32:32 – Why do we use the phrase “Mother of God” instead of “Mother of God Incarnate” in the Hail Mary prayer?43:23 – If you’re in a relationship with someone who is going through RCIA, why do you have to be married to them to be their sponsor?51:52 – Why do we Catholics find it easier to accept scientific discoveries over protestants if we have a lot of the same materials?…
Questions Covered:08:45 – How did the Church come up with the idea that Mary was conceived without sin?17:39 – Why does the pope only speak ex cathedra on morals? What exactly is ex cathedra?29:32 – My friend passed away and left her kids behind. Why would God allow that?37:29 – Why do we celebrate Easter when we do? Did we replace Passover with Easter to follow a pagan holiday?44:07 – How many times has ex cathedra been used? And why?47:48 – Is organ donation licit as a Catholic? Why or Why not?50:41 – What does the Church teach about creationism and evolution? What are the boundaries and why?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:01:33 – Why are there some Catholic churches that feel like they don’t want people with mental disabilities?11:13 – Can you explain the presumption of mercy?18:12 – A lot of non-religious and native Americans use sage for purification. Can we as Catholics use it if we get it blessed?21:31 – What’s a good response to once saved always saved?31:56 – Why was the fall of the angels irreparable? Why can’t they repent?36:15 – If Vatican 2 was successful then why are those who prefer the Latin Mass being attacked?45:58 – How does one know when you are going to heaven?51:00 – I’m divorced and have been banned from receiving communion. How am I supposed to be nourished?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:08:55 – Did God know the devil would become a fallen angel? Were there other fallen angels apart from the devil?14:41 – Is it Catholic to say that God is consistently pouring out his grace and by cooperation we come into a closer relationship with him?18:18 – What is the official position on eschatology?23:27 – I’m Lutheran. I see saints say contradictory things about Mary. Some say we should be slaves to her and others say don’t put Mary above God. Can you clarify?36:40 – What would be a good response to a protestant who rejects private revelation?42:05 – What is the mechanism by which we have the hope for salvation?…
Questions Covered:06:02 – How does one respond to an atheist who says every theist version of evolution puts sin before death, that death didn’t exist until sin. How does one respond? 15:04 – Is divorce a sin? Is it okay to date before an annulment has been given? 22:08 – If you kill 3 people do you have to name them in confession? Do you have to name each individual instance? 29:37 – How can the laity make sense of priests and bishops who speak out against the pope? 33:07 – My wife doesn’t feel loved by me, and I don’t know how to show her. How do I approach her and suggest we go to therapy? 40:36 – I’m a medical student and help with surgeries including tying tubes. What is my culpability in those surgeries? 46:08 – If you’re destined for heaven, why are souls tortured in purgatory? 50:22 – We hear a lot about the second coming, but what was the first coming? Who was that? …
Questions Covered:14:31 – Does atheism lead to nihilism?21:13 – Why do so many Christians fall into atheism?23:02 – Is the intelligent design argument against evolution helpful, unhelpful or irrelevant in the debate about God?33:41 – Why the Judeo-Christian God instead of any other God?40:58 – What are good resources for atheists who want to get into philosophy?48:38 – My belief in God stems from my illness.52:05 – I just discovered the idea that we are born seeking God. Can you comment on that? …
Questions Covered:04:08 – I have been struggling with a lot of anxiety. When I pray, sometimes I get peace and sometimes I don’t. I pray the rosary, I do devotions, etc. Can you help me know if maybe I’m missing something so I can be at peace? 12:54 – One version of Matthew 1:25 says Joseph did not have marital relations until Mary had the firstborn son. But does that mean Mary wasn’t a perpetual virgin? 21:52 – Why did the 12 Apostles end with the apostolic age? Why didn’t they keep reinstituting the 12? 35:00 – My wife is a nutritionist and doesn’t fully understand fasting and that it’s harmful for our hormone balance and metabolism. She wants to know how you could be doing something harmful to your body for the sake of spiritual gain. 42:13 – Tim said he used to be pro-death penalty but now that he’s a Catholic, does not because the Pope says it’s a development of doctrine and supersedes the bible. How can he do that? 50:25 – I’m a new Catholic. How can the Church maintain unity within the setting of having different “branches”, like the SSPX?…
Questions Covered:02:29 – I attend a protestant bible study often and in the coming weeks we’re getting to John 20. What are some common Protestant arguments for it and how can I respond to them?11:52 – Something Jimmy quotes in The Fathers Know Best on St Ignatius’ letter to the Smyrnaeans is that some people abstain from the Eucharist because they don’t believe it’s the flesh. Since this is in the short version and there is a longer version, how do we know which versions of these early Christian writings are reliable or if any of them are?21:04 – A fellow parishioner said the Devil must have been surprised at the resurrection. Of course, Satan knew Jesus was the son of God but how can I point him in the right direction?29:47 – Can you explain how you know Jesus and God exist without making any biblical references? I have adult children who were raised Catholic, left the faith, and nothing I say works to convince them of the existence of Jesus and God.36:16 – Can a Catholic who married in the Baptist church, and got divorced, then get married in the Catholic Church?41:56 – Is it possible to know the existence of angels through natural reasons alone?Resources Mentioned:https://jimmyakin.com/2013/08/did-jesus-exist-an-alternate-approach.html…
Questions Covered:05:25 – I’m just entering the Catholic Church. A lot of my friends see me as a spiritual father. These friends will follow me if I convert. That makes me very uncomfortable. Can you offer some advice?14:40 – What happens if you’re going through RCIA and you can’t find a Confirmation sponsor?16:41 – How is the presence of Christ in the Eucharist different from the way God is always present to us, as Scripture says?29:27 – I’m not Catholic. How can I better understand the real presence? Where in the Old Testament does God prophecy that he was going to reveal himself as bread and wine?38:00 – Does the bible lose its impact when it is translated?45:59 – I’m not Catholic but I would like to be. Why would being divorced preclude me from becoming Catholic?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:05:54 – Is Redemptionis Sacramentum, especially regarding the role of extraordinary ministers of holy communion?16:11 – Does the Church recognize the existence of ghosts, and can they cross over from the afterlife to earth?23:02 – Do Catholics have to believe in the historical existence of Adam and Eve?31:49 – I’m not Catholic. Can I participate in Ash Wednesday and receive the ashes?34:02 – What is the difference between being one of the elect and the doctrine of eternal security?44:16 – Can we have efficacious prayer if we are in the state of venial or mortal sin?48:55 – My protestant teacher said that Catholics were wrong and bad during the time of Martin Luther. How do I respond?…
Questions Covered:04:25 – What is satanic music? Is that even a thing? What are the characteristics?12:58 – Who are the two witnesses in Revelation 11?17:20 – If a Hindu friend offers to pray for you, should you ask them not to since they’re praying to demons?21:13 – In the Gospel of Mark, when the woman touches Jesus’ robe and he asks who touched it, that doesn’t make sense to me because he should know. What’s going on there?28:56 – Why are things related to the Pope called “papal” but he’s not called the Pape? Or why aren’t they called “popal?”34:35 – After the flood, how did the one family left multiply the human race again?43:43 – Why is it that if you go to hell, something bad will happen to you? Why would the devil torture me when I’m doing exactly what he wanted me to do?49:02 – When Jesus calls the apostles, they all seem to drop everything and follow him even though they don’t know him. Did God the Father actually draw them to him, as Jesus says must happen?51:27 – When Jesus tells Pilate that he wouldn’t have power over him unless it was given from above, was he referring to God?…
Questions Covered:05:00 – Where is the Garden of Eden?06:56 – Why, if Scripture seems to make it clear that some individuals are in hell, doesn’t the Church officially condemn them?17:11 – Have any of the popes ever had military jurisdiction, and if so, why?29:24 – Can a Catholic be a sponsor for a Lutheran going through Confirmation?33:07 – St. John Chrysostom said in a homily on Matthew 16 that Jesus said he’d build his Church on Peter’s confession of faith, which seems to agree with Protestants arguing against the papacy. What do you think of that?38:29 – Why did Jesus pick Judas if he knew what Judas was going to do?47:37 – What does the Bible mean when it says God hates certain people like Esau?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:04:11 – Were gospels written to try and make Romans, especially Pilot, look good? I watched a show that made this claim.10:33 – Does the grace of the Divine Mercy Chaplet that I pray for my relatives reduce if I include others?15:34 – I’ve heard that scientists that study the universe are finding evidence that the earth might be the center of the universe. What are your thoughts on this?19:46 – I know my faith pretty well and have been doing bible study with Jehovah’s Witness. I also go to Sabbath with my Jewish friends. Where is the line when it comes to praying with other faiths?29:31 – I’m Catholic and my wife is agnostic. My priest pressed me about her converting. He got upset with my response and denied me absolution. Can you give me some clarity with this situation? Am I going to hell for this? It felt very judgmental42:56 – Is there any theology on why Jesus came to earth in the time that he did?47:14 – What causes Jesus’ different reactions in 4th and 8th stations of the cross?51:10 – Psalm 110:7 What does this line mean?52:45 – Was Mary Magdalene the sister of Martha?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:04:47 – How do I explain to Protestants that when the bible says that Mary did not know Joseph until after Jesus’ birth, it doesn’t mean that they had relations after? 10:47 – I struggle with the theory that if you go to hell, it is because you chose to be there. Can you help clarify? 16:52 – I had a dream where I saw many upside-down crosses. How do I interpret this? Is this demonic? 22:50 – Is it moral for women to be in the military? 32:21 – Do you believe in the book “The Warning” by Christine Watkins? 35:50 – What’s the significance of Christians fasting on Wednesday and Friday? 42:15 – Has Jimmy ever investigated the theory using an engrailed cross to navigate the earth potentially used by the Knights Templar? 46:32 – If you are coming into the church do you need to go to confession if you are receiving a conditional baptism? 50:26 – If Christ could not sin, what was the point of the temptations? …
Questions Covered:17:11 – A Christian is someone who you connect with because you have the common foundation of Christ. 43:30 – How do I talk to people of other Christian faiths? 47:50 – Comment: Foundation of faith is trust, how to have a conversation with people that don’t believe what you do. …
Questions Covered:13:43 – I’m divorce, remarried, then widowed and now I’m getting remarried. If we get married, I know my husband will be excommunicated if we marry. Do you have any advice?21:31 – I fear inviting young women to Church and not knowing if they’ve had an abortion. Would they be able to come into the Church if they had?24:57 – When did Jesus rise again? Does that mean it was the first or second time that he rose?29:20 – I want to join the Roman Catholic Church but I’m divorced. I don’t ever plan on being remarried. Do I have to get my marriage annulled? Or can I skip that?32:30 – I’m Anglican. I struggle with the honor that we are supposed to give to Mary and the saints.45:13 – How do I discuss Pope Francis with my Evangelical friends who see him as vague and almost wanting to change Church teaching?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:10:16 – Is it ok to attend an SSPX mass? 15:20 – Why did it take so long for the Church to declare the Assumption and the Immaculate Conception as dogmas? 23:13 – How do I deal with people who won’t acknowledge that their actions are sin? 34:41 – Should babies be rebaptized when they get older? 36:28 – How do I contribute history and theology to a bible study when they focus on feelings? 43:36 – What is a good book that gives an overview of heresies in history? 44:32 – How can a good Catholic walk by a homeless person in the cold and feel like a righteous person? …
Open Forum – Questions Covered:10:52 – How do we respond to the objection that he is not eternal creator because he is not eternal creating?14:52 – At what point does a struggle with a Church teaching not allow us to receive communion?19:57 – How do I respond to the claim that we should be baptizing in the name of Jesus over the name of the trinity?32:34 – If God made everything, how did he come to earth?35:31 – What is the earliest evidence for the assumption of Mary?46:45 – I’m engaged and was planning to get married in November. People tell me that we should get married sooner. What is your advice?51:04 – Is it ok for me to feel uneasy for a non-Catholic to come and speak to our Catholic men’s group at the Church?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:08:45 – Is there any evidence that Cyprian of Carthage accepted the papacy and ended back into communion with Rome? 22:45 – What’s the true meaning of schism? 34:50 – When did the pre-communion fast change from the night before to only a few hours before communion? 37:37 – Is the pope just the first among equals? 40:25 – I’m getting mixed advice about Catholics being allowed to watch Harry Potter. Is it ok or not? How does one discern what is right? 49:25 – Why did God give a definitive law to Moses forbidding sexual sin but wasn’t as direct about slavery? 51:25 – Why isn’t there more contribution from Peter and James in the New Testament? …
In today’s episode, Cy and Joe discuss artificial Intelligence and what that means for the future.…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:05:55 – What was the timeline and details around the nativity of the Lord and their movement?09:51 – If the bible wasn’t put together until the 300’s how can the early church claim that a heresy, such as Marcionism (140 AD), was against scripture?15:54 – Is Mary the woman in Rev. 12 Mary? If so, she had child pains, so does that mean she was not sinless?23:54 – Does Vatican II’s decree on ecumenism contradict tradition?28:15 – How does one deliver the beauty of Catholicism?44:56 – If Jesus flipped tables in the temple because of the money changers. How then, can we justify raffles, bingo, and casino nights at our churches?49:43 – Can I receive communion at a Byzantine Catholic Church and is it licit for them to clean the spoons with just water?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:12:19 – What did Jesus mean when he said “let the dead bury the dead?33:22 – Did Jesus know he was going to be crucified when he started his ministry?42:57 – How is the Holy Spirit a person like the Father and the Son?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:10:24 – What is holy mortification? 18:10 – Why does the bible use the genealogy of Joseph for the lineage of Jesus if they’re not related by blood? 29:56 – My protestant friend is claiming that the KJV bible is superior to Catholic translations. How do I respond? 46:59 – Is the mosaic law prohibited like it said in the Council of Florence? …
Questions Covered:11:46 – I was told that the 12-step program is based on the beatitudes. Is this true? 13:58 – The beatitudes start with “happy are those” not “blessed” 18:07 – The beatitude regarding righteousness, How does this apply when wanting to help a parent who doesn’t want to be helped because they don’t see you as someone to correct them? 22:30 – Could you expound on the beatitude “blessed are the peacemakers?” 36:35 – Can you clarify the phrase poor in spirit? 39:16 – To what extent is the term blessed synonymous with happy? 44:19 – Are you familiar with how the beatitudes are depicted on the series The Chosen? If you have, what are your thoughts on it? 49:55 – How does one receive the awareness of being poor in spirit if one lives in a society of comfort and abundance? 53:08 – Is your new book in a good format for a bible study? Does it come with the study guide? …
Questions Covered:13:55 – I’ve been Catholic all my life but I’m still mystified. A part of me embraces his mercy and another part of me is afraid of him. Can you help give some insight?20:14 – What is a relationship with Christ? How does one relate that to protestants?31:53 – How does God use guardian angels to bring us closer to him?35:07 – Am I focusing too much on the Father rather than Jesus?40:18 – Has your knowledge of the Church Fathers helped you with your relationship?43:38 – You mentioned reading the bible to help with a relationship. I struggle with reading the bible because I fear that I’ll misinterpret it. Can you give me some advice?46:45 – Don’t have a relationship with Jesus and am no longer believing. I’m only remaining Catholic because I fear hell. Is this wrong?50:17 – How do I help my four children have a relationship with Jesus when I struggle with having one with him?52:37 – How do you make having a relationship with Jesus sound fun and exciting when talking about it?…
Questions Covered:00:58 – Does Time Travel exist?04:39 – Granting that I time travel back to the past to Jesus’ crucifixion, I take videos of Jesus to prove he exists, and I join Mary and John in approaching him. Is there a possibility that I will be recorded in the Bible? And will the videos and photos that I have taken will be erased if I come back from the past?09:35 – Did Adam and Eve have belly buttons?17:39 – Where are all the cryptid sightings coming from, especially in national parks?28:44 – Archeologists have discovered that there was a small Christian community in the city of Pompeii before the Vesuvius eruption. What if, by some miracle, a scroll somehow survived in the city, with the text of something that claimed to be a “Letter of Paul to the Pompeians”? It follows the format of the universally accepted Pauline epistles, it doesn’t contradict anything Paul wrote previously, and it ultimately seems to be genuinely from Paul. How do you think the Church would respond to the situation?41:48 – What are the top three (or any other arbitrary number) lost books you would love to have? Tell us about them, and tell us why you would love to have them. I’d like to read the Gospel of the Hebrews, for example, in its entirety (instead of the fragments left behind in writings by the early Church Fathers).50:43 – Does the Highlander have a soul since he is immortal? Would an immortal being need a soul? 52:13 – Does baptism apply to a person’s entire body? For example, if technology were such that my body died but one cell remained alive and I was regrown immediately from that cell, is my baptism still valid or does the regrown body need to be baptized? Similarly, if a baptized person’s heart (or other organ) is transplanted into another non-baptized person does the organ from the baptized body transmit its baptismal graces to the new body?…
Questions Covered:02:30 – In Genesis, the Lord told the serpent he would have to crawl on his belly and eat dirt. Did the serpent die, or is it still around? Did its descendants have to eat dust too? Are they still around? 06:48 – How would a Catholic time lord know when to go to mass to fulfill the Sunday obligation? Are all the incarnations of the Doctor married to River Song, or just the eleventh doctor? Given that they both time traveled separately and could conceivably encounter each other at any point in time and space, at what point would he be considered a widower? 12:59 – Jimmy Akin, how do you store information in your brain? Do you have a photographic memory? Have you been partially assimilated or turned into a cyber man, allowing you to call to mind detailed information at will? How exactly do you store the plethora of the facts and data that you keep in your head? 28:43 – A news story described a couple that discovered they were not legally married because—after the service was performed—the marriage license was not sent to the proper civil department, so they needed to have a new civil wedding. Question 1 If this happens with a Catholic Wedding would anything need to be done when fixing the civil side? Question 2 What if there is clerical error with a Catholic Wedding and the need notation is NOT made in the church (baptism) records how would it be fixed? 33:08 – If Jesus died once and for all and rose from the dead, if there are other planets that support life created in His image and likeness, how did we get so lucky that it all happened on our planet? Or do we need to spread the good news to all the ends of the universe too? 35:10 – What would have happened if just Eve had eaten the apple and not Adam or vice versa? 38:54 – A woman gets married then transported back in time 400-ish years. Thinking she’ll never make it back to her own time, and because she needs to be married for protection, she gets married, despite the fact she was married in her original time. Is the new marriage valid? 44:58 – Deja Vu. What is it? Why does it happen? …
Open Forum – Questions Covered:03:44 – What was in the holy of holies during the time of Jesus? 12:20 – Has the Church taught exactly what we can know about God based on human reason? 17:00 – Does God break his promises? 23:03 – What’s the best way to interact socially with clergy? 28:46 – I think there’s a ghost in my home and wanted to get your thoughts. 33:24 – In the Luminous Mysteries, it says that the wedding at Cana was where his disciples started believing in Jesus. Why didn’t they believe in him before? 40:40 – Could you explain what glory is? 47:10 – I’m confused by all the mentions of John in the bible. The Gospel, letters, and revelation and also those Johns mentioned in the bible. Are they all different people? …
Questions Covered:02:10 – Did God create the earth with oil as a necessity for it to function and rotate the way it does or did he only make oil to be a resource to man? 05:53 – I have my moms ashes and she wasn’t Catholic. Would I be able to get them blessed by a priest? 10:30 – As a Catholic, how can I explain to protestant girlfriend that going to her church doesn’t fulfill my Sunday obligation? 15:55 – I was married civilly in another country and then divorced. Could I remarry in the Church? 19:06 – I want to marry in the Church but my significant other is divorced. The priest did bless that marriage after being bribed. Can we get married and if not, how do we live in the good graces of the Church? 23:07 – What is the Church’s teaching on what happens after death? What does the Church teach about ghosts? 30:36 – If Mary has free will, how can she be kept from sinning? 37:30 – Is baptism necessary for salvation? 46:47 – A Baptist minister claimed that Catholics have the wrong bible translation. He claimed that the real manuscripts are sitting in a safety deposit box in Texas. Have you heard of this? How do I respond? 50:40 – What’s the process to join the Ordinariate? 52:35 – What happens to the souls in purgatory when Christ returns? …
Open Forum – Questions Covered:04:25 – What are the fasting obligations for the elderly and those in elderly homes? 13:07 – Why does it take so long to enter the Church? 18:50 – Did Mary experience labor pains? If she did, why if she didn’t have sin? 24:36 – What’s the science behind transubstantiation? 40:49 – 1 Tim. 2:11-12 What’s the Church’s stance on women in teaching ministry? 49:25 – I teach RCIA and I have a candidate struggling with Sunday Mass obligations. Can you help explain? …
Open Forum – Questions Covered:04:26 – Is it possible for babies in the womb to receive grace from their mother receiving communion?14:49 – The early Church seemed to be pacifist. After Constantine the tone changed, why is that?21:31 – Am I required to send my kids to religious education after confirmation?28:36 – Could we Catholics start implementing prayer mats into our services?30:26 – Why did God allow polygamy in the Old Testament?38:32 – Are all of the priest’s sins absolved when he washes his hands during mass?42:19 – Why do Catholics worship Mary and the saints through prayer?46:42 – How much weight should we give to dreams and try to interpret them?51:16 – Could you clarify whether Mary and Joseph were married or unmarried. Can you clarify why betrothal?…
Questions Covered:18:03 – Do you think this movement is driven by a lack of fathers and profiting off people’s feelings? 22:24 – Can You clarify your statement on God’s plan to put this confusion into our kids? 29:59 – My godson is transitioning and taking hormones. How do I approach this especially since his mom is approving? 36:05 – Can you help break down what non-binary means? 43:36 – What do you think about the argument that no matter the hormones and surgeries, one’s DNA will always be either male or female? 52:39 – How far will third wave feminism go in its radical ideology? …
Open Forum – Questions Covered:03:29 – Can purgatory be experienced on earth? 12:08 – When did Jesus realize he was God? 17:21 – My mother with dementia sometimes goes to mass with us. She’s protestant and sometimes gets confused on receiving communion. How should I approach this? 21:54 – I go to an Institute of Christ the King parish . I heard the pope was going to ban all Latin masses. Is this true? 29:03 – Are Adam and Eve symbolic or real people that existed? 32:12 – The bible says that Jesus could not do miracles in Nazareth. Why does it say that he could not instead choose not to? 35:57 – What is an indulgence? 42:24 – I was challenged by a Catholic that the pope can attempt to bind the faithful to heresy. Is this true? 47:11 – How do we know that Peter was in Rome? 52:11 – Can an absolving priest make a positive endorsement of the penitent saying that there is no impediment to allowing them to move forward? …
Questions Covered:02:30 – Why did God create Satan if God knew he would cause so much evil? 07:35 – Why would putting money in front of a statue not be considered idolatry? 14:12 – Why do we insist on saying that the body and blood is in the form of bread and wine? Why not say that it’s both? 19:15 – Why is it not emphasized that we should not receive communion if we are in mortal sin? 24:42 – Why do Catholics justify war theory when Jesus says to turn the other cheek? 36:09 – Why does the Holy Father have free will if it’s not possible to lead the Church into error? 42:55 – Why can’t converts be rebaptized? 47:53 – Why is the point that Romans in speaking to baptized Christians, never mentioned when discussing Romans 10:9? …
Open Forum – Questions Covered:01:54 – Why did Joseph receive the birthright, but the blessing went to Judah? Weren’t they usually given to the same person? Why were they separated?08:31 – Is it a sin to look at pictures of women in bikinis?13:28 – Is the rosary the high form of devotional prayer? Does praying rosary without focusing on the prayers fall under vain repetition?23:35 – Would asking saints to reveal the future count as necromancy?28:51 – Why are extraordinary ministers not allowed to do intinction?31:55 – What Church is the Church mentioned in the book of Revelation?36:25 – How do you explain grace to kids about to do their first communion?41:25 – What do the hand placements of the Infant of Prague statue mean? Does it have something to do with Tarot cards?47:00 – 2 Sam 6-7 mentions someone being struck down after reaching up to touch the Ark. Is it possible that this might have happened to St. Joseph when potentially reaching to touch Mary?51:12 – Regarding the second commandment, how should one take it into consideration in daily life? For example, in conversations and watching movies.…
Questions Covered:17:57 – We should be doing things with young couples to keep them in the Church? 29:24 – We need to be very careful when bringing in the new generation by not pushing out the old community. 40:36 – How do I help my 15-year-old grandson engage in the parish, and should he even be confirmed? 51:28 – My friend and I are trying to start a Catholic skateboarding men’s group. Can you give us some practical tips to get going? …
Questions Covered:11:51 – I believe science used to be a study in philosophy. 18:45 – I had a conversation on science and religion and realized that even the most complex equations are still less than God. 22:12 – If the universe operates on quantum mechanics and has no beginning or end, how do we reconcile this with the Christian understanding of creation? 28:41 – Are you familiar with Graham Hancock’s Ancient Apocalypse? What are your thoughts on that? 33:00 – Where do you stand on the idea of God implementing evolution to develop creation? 35:53 – How do we come to the understanding of the incarnation if there was no way he would have been provided with a Y chromosome? 41:08 – How could God be good if he can create us with dangerous things like gamma radiation everywhere that can kill us simply by being in its presence? 48:33 – Wouldn’t the story of the loaves and fishes suspend the laws of physics? …
Questions Covered:09:16 – Are Catholics finding it difficult to argue for certain moral issues since the issuance of Vatican II documents that emphasize the primacy of conscience?17:47 – I think if we followed what the Council said things would be a lot better, and fewer people would receive Communion unworthily.19:59 – Do you think we can get back to what the documents of the council truly say?24:15 – If we believe in the real presence of Jesus in the Eucharist, why did Vatican II change the way of receiving communion to the hand?32:16 – Why would anyone become Catholic if we teach ecumenism?35:06 – Why were Protestants involved in Vatican II?39:10 – How can Lumen Gentium 16 be true since the Muslims deny the Trinity?45:57 – The faithful never received what the bishops voted on at the Council. So it’s hard to discern the fruits of the council.49:04 – Why do all the Vatican II popes have all these ecumenical events with other world religions, like the Assisi events, that are explicit violations of the first commandment?…
Questions Covered:03:48 – What is your opinion on who built the megalithic structures in the Azore islands? 08:27 – Can I be a good Catholic and believe in Universalism? 18:46 – What constitutes being in a state of grace? Do you need to be in a state of grace to receive communion? 30:18 – Does the devil still have access to heaven? Also, does the devil have to take permission from God? 42:27 – I’ve been feeling the need recently to pray for a person I’ve never met. How can I be sure to stay away from anything occult and how can I best pray for them? Also, are there any stories of saints having feelings of souls needing prayer? 48:45 – I’m a Lutheran. Is there one thing you would recommend from Catholicism for Lutherans as an extension from the faith? 52:21 – Is it ok to have mass said for a departed loved one who was not Catholic? …
Questions Covered:04:55 – When I was young and attended the mass in Latin, I didn’t understand what was happening at the altar. It seemed nobody had any connection with each other or with God. Why can’t the mass today be a cooperation between Latin and English?17:19 – In Boston, priests that moved from the Anglican church to the Catholic church can’t advertise that they are using the Anglican rite. Why is that and if there are people that like it, why can’t it be used more?28:42 – I’ve been sick for 11 years and on bedrest. I’ve had so much joy and it’s been a happy time but recently my brain isn’t working as well so it’s hard to pray. Can I please have some pastoral advice for how to continue to be close to God?39:28 – It seems that there are more options for ministry in Protestantism than in Catholicism. It seems that if you’re not a priest, there’s not as much you can do in terms of higher study. Is that correct or is this a misconception and there’s more than just being a lay person?46:03 – What are your thoughts as to why people that are passionate about the Latin mass don’t put that same effort into the Novus Ordo mass? Is it really the guitars and English that are keeping them from the newer mass?50:05 – I used to be Protestant pastor and I’m now Catholic. I’m fully tattooed from the neck down and married. Is there any way I can become a deacon while being fully tattooed?…
Questions covered:02:59 – Before I pray the rosary, do I need to announce my prayer intentions out loud? 14:44 – How do you reconcile the doctrine of hell with Christianity being a religion of “good news”? Does that mean it’s only good news for some people? 22:04 – When I visited a Catholic church recently, I saw a statue of Mary that was higher than all the rest (including the ones of Jesus) with a label that said “Blessed Mary, Mother of God, above all things in heaven and on earth.” How is this not worshiping her? 33:14 – Was St. Athanasius ever excommunicated or anathematized? I was talking to a non-Catholic who claimed that disproved papal infallibility. 42:09 – How can someone evangelize to other Christians? 48:26 – In my Bible study the others were saying that when we get to heaven we’ll immediately have all knowledge. I thought we still grew in knowledge, not that it was immediate. Am I wrong? …
Questions Covered:14:55 -What do you think about the science of artificial womb technology? Do you think it might have any relation to the end of abortion? 19:43 – Ethically, how much as Catholics can we trust that scientists are doing the right thing? Is using stem cells for cancer treatment ethical? I’m asking as a parent that has a child dying from cancer. 29:24 – I work as a clinical research coordinator with humans. Is it ok for me as a faithful Catholic to present contraceptive options for women going into a trial? 37:30 – Is insulin a necessity at the end of life? 45:20 – My mother has recently been diagnosed with Alzheimer’s. She’s also on dialysis for kidney failure. How long, morally, should she continue dialysis as her dementia progresses? 50:17 – I’m 75 y.o. my adult children have all left the faith and don’t care about me anymore. What do I do if I’m hospitalized and have no advocate? Resources mentioned:https://vimeo.com/bioethicsvideos…
Questions Covered:10:04 – How would the church feel about a woman that was raped and must share custody with the rapist? Does that make it justified to kill the baby?17:22 – I’m pro-life but can you explain why IVF is not pro-life? My wife was conceived that way and now that she’s becoming a doctor, I feel that will influence how she deals with IVF and contraception.24:09 – I think it’s awful but I think women are going to have abortions whether we want them to or not and I want it done in a doctor’s office.35:20 – I was pro-choice for a long time throughout my 20s and 30s. I then studied Buddhism and they talk in detail about how the soul enters at the time of the union of the sperm and egg. I am now going back to the beginning when I was baptized Catholic and comparing things to find my way41:22 – I’m pro-life, for babies who survive late term abortions, aren’t they automatically American citizens?46:52 – When I was younger, I went through two abortions and came to really regret them.48:30 – I believe that there are times when pregnancies are dangerous for women.…
Questions Covered:12:41 – How do I get this program started in my parish? 18:39 – How do I get someone into rehab before they hit rock bottom, which would be death? 24:01 – If this program is anonymous, then why give out your name? 34:25 – If this is supplemental to the 12 steps, how come it follows the same format? 43:35 – What was your breakthrough moment? 51:45 – How do we find people to draw them to these groups? …
Open Forum – Questions Covered:04:49 – Are there any regulations on a priest cleaning off particles of a consecrated host from his fingers over an unconsecrated chalice? 09:15 – I’m considering doing a pilgrimage. Do you have any resources or advice? 15:10 – Have the Church fathers or theologians said anything about why the apostles didn’t recognize Jesus after the resurrection? 21:48 – Is it ok for me to attend a non-Catholic Christian bible study? 29:30 – I see a double standard in Catholics accepting saint miracles but rejecting other non-Catholic religious miracles. Can you help me sort it out? 35:22 – What is the best case for why the Catholic Church should have authority to insist on all of its doctrine? 46:50 – What is heresy? What is a heretic? Can you be a heretic without knowing it? 51:22 – What are two good reasons why my evangelical friend should be Catholic and not just Christian? …
Open Forum – Questions Covered:03:54 – Do you have any recommendations on evangelization of Muslims and atheists who give more credence to Norse mythology over Christianity?14:38 – Why do we have both the Nicene Creed and the Apostles Creed since they’re so similar?17:07 – Why are there missing books in the bible such as Enoch, Gospel of Thomas etc. Was it just to fit the agenda of the Church?25:06 – Are we obligated to forgive someone even if there isn’t repentance on the other end?36:40 – How do I defend Marian apparitions and the rosary when faced with the Gal. 1:9:9 – As we have said before, so now I say again, If anyone is preaching to you a gospel contrary to that which you received, let him be accursed.48:12 – This coming Sunday is the 2nd of Ordinary Time but last Sunday was the last Sunday of Christmas. What happened to the first Sunday of Ordinary Time?51:20 – From a Catholic perspective, is it immodest for trans people to use the same bathroom with men or women?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:13:57 – My family and I have started attending an Eastern Catholic parish. Can we be parishioners there even as Latin rite Catholics? What would that look like when seeking sacraments for my children? 20:18 – You mentioned that the deuterocanonical books are not in the modern Jewish bible, but were they in the ancient Jewish canon? 35:58 – How far along can a heretic offer valid sacraments? 46:29 – How do I defend the Second Vatican Council? …
Open Forum – Questions Covered:02:06 – Can practicing Catholics watch shows that contain some sexual content and explicit language?12:57 – What is the difference between humility and poverty of spirit?18:48 – Was papal infallibility ever used before it was defined in Vatican 1?28:03 – Should I go to a medical provider and pharmacy who provide the abortion pill?31:30 – My high school priests told us that we didn’t have to be specific about the sins we confessed. I feel like I’m not being honest when I go to confession. What’s your advice?38:50 – Should we bother with a general confession if Divine Mercy Sunday offers the same effect?44:30 – I was asked if non-Catholics can go to heaven and didn’t give the best answer. How would I answer this?48:45 – What are the roots of Latin being used in the Church?…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:07:37 – What does no salvation outside the Church mean and has it developed over time?19:43 – Is it ok for Catholics to play video games that were created based on ideas of false religions?23:48 – Why is it that priests can’t get married?35:28 – You’ve called sodomy an act of violence. I agree but what’s the reasoning?41:37 – Is Jesus in Mt 5:29-30 speaking in hyperbole?45:24 – If the cardinals were all to die at the same time along with the pope, how would we elect a new pope?51:34 – What is the Catholic understanding of 1 Jn 3:9? …
Questions Covered:12:13 – The bible has passages where God is bargaining with Satan. How do I understand these passages?16:44 – The teaching of purgatory bothers me. Where is it explicitly in the bible?20:52 – I want to push back on who was left behind. Maybe the protestant conclusion is right. Were those who were left behind actually left behind to experience destruction?24:01 – Mk. 10 says some will not taste death. Is that Jesus predicting his death in the 1st century and was he wrong?38:04 – How do I respond to the claim that Mary had more children?44:20 – How could one be baptized with fire and spirit? Could you elaborate?46:50 – Have you asked protestants to protect their positions from the historical perspective?52:03 – In Acts it was said that the gentiles should not eat meat of strangled animals. How does that tie to Jesus’ death on the cross?…
Questions Covered:04:42 – I’m not Catholic because I’m confused. I’m protestant but I have gone through RCIA. I’ve recently started exploring Orthodoxy. 13:30 – I’ve never been to Mass, but I keep hearing that Catholics pray to saints and Mary. 28:45 – I have not been to church in 2 years. When I did go last week, I was chastised by the warden in front of other parishioners for being late. Is it wrong? 34:50 – I don’t understand how the saints can hear us if they’re not God. If they’re not omniscient, how can they hear so many people at once? 43:38 – I’m not Catholic because of the Catholic view on predestination. 51:53 -What was Jesus’ real last name? …
On today’s show we celebrates 25 years of Catholic Answers Live on the air. Cy welcomes Catholic Answers President Chris Check, Chief Operations Officer Jon Sorensen, Senior Apologist Tim Staples, Production Manager Erik Gustafson and Director of Studios John Vercillo to recount the origins and memorable moments of the show.…
Open Forum – Questions Covered:05:28 – Can you clarify the theological status of natural marriage and Pauline privilege (1 Corn. 7:10-15)14:30 – If God is omniscient, doesn’t that mean that I last forever in the mind of God? If that’s true doesn’t that make me immortal?24:08 – I do respond to the question: Why pray for the dead after they die if they can no longer turn to God?30:45 – Does God have a soul?36:00 – What does the Church teach about exorcisms, and how to heal people from a spiritual affliction?41:11 – If people don’t have free will after they die, then how can saints in heaven pray and have miracles?44:58 – On praying for the dead: We don’t know if they went to heaven or hell, but we still should pray for them.49:36 – Does Jesus need the grace of faith?52:19 – Does God the Father have a body?…
Questions Covered: 01:04 – How can Protestants be part of the body of Christ, when the council of Florence says the body of Christ is the church? 12:44 – What happened to the families of the Apostles when they dropped everything to follow Jesus? 19:00 – What would the Catholic perspective be to an argument that Rome is not in union with orthodoxy? 30:05 – Would Deuteronomy 12: 32 make Jesus a false Prophet because he abolished the old law? 41:07 – When someone is born is a new Guardian Angel created? 48:49 – Why is it important to have a relationship with Mary? …
Cy sits down with Catholic Answer’s Director of Publishing, Todd Aglialoro, and Catholic Answers Magazine Editor, Tim Ryland, to review the top Church news stories of 2022.…
Cy sits down with Catholic Answer’s Director of Publishing, Todd Aglialoro, and Catholic Answers Magazine Editor, Tim Ryland, to review the top Church news stories of 2022.…
Questions Covered:03:01 – If we are “surrounded by a crowd of witnesses” is it reasonable to believe that our deceased loved ones and the saints are aware of what we are doing and thinking even if we cannot experience their presence? Is it reasonable to believe that my deceased loved ones are in communion with me momentarily through the body of Christ when receiving communion?16:12 – My brother argues that Jesus was supposed to be the last high priest. Why do Catholics believe that there could be more priests after Jesus?22:24 – What would it take for you to have a disbelief in a deity29:23 – Why is there a waiting period for the Church to baptize candidates?35:49 – We understand that before there was confession, people went to heaven. What changed that we now have to go to confession to get to heaven but people in the Old Testament did not?41:16 – What is the difference between the Thomistic view of predestination and Calvinistic view? Do you hold a Thomistic view or Molinistic view of free will?48:42 – How should I talk to a non-Catholic who tries to receive the Eucharist?…
Questions Covered:08: 24 – How do we know when the pope is speaking infallibly?21:42 – Why as Catholics do we have images? When did this start?31:44 – I’m not Catholic but my husband is. Why do I have to become Catholic if we are all children of God? When Christ returns, will there still be a need for Catholic, Presbyterian, Episcopalian churches?36:58 – What happened to St. Peter’s wife? Was she crucified with Peter? The Bible mentions Peter’s mother-in-law. Was he married, and if he did, did he leave his family?45:51 – What does Jesus mean when he says there will be no marriage, nor will they marry in Heaven? Why would He say this if we have bodies on the final day, won’t my husband still be my husband?…
Questions Covered:06:01 – I’ve heard a lot of Protestants complain about spiritual “dryness”. Do you think this is comparable to the dark night of the soul, a problem due to an impoverished Protestant spirituality, or something else?14:23 – how does one become a Protestant elder? Contrasted with how one becomes a catholic elder “aka bishop”17:51 – Are there any instances where something has been declared a dogmatic fact when later it was discovered to be historically or scientifically wrong? Say the theory of geocentrism or perhaps somebody declared to be a heretic at a church council who was later discovered not to be? How would we navigate a situation like this?23:42 – How did the Church determine who the true Pope was during the time that there were multiple claimants to the Papacy? Also, how do we know that the Church got it right?29:58 – Are the words of institution at Mass quoting the gospels, or do the gospels quote the Mass?33:41 – How does the Catholic view the Old Catholic Churches and the Polish National Catholic Church?35:02 – I was wondering if you could tell me about the Dubia submitted to Pope Francis (there were 5 Dubia I think), and why do you think he is waiting so long to answer- if he even intends on answering. hasn’t it been close to two years?38:54 – Also you have said the magisterium cannot allow anything harmful, nor can the magisterium not be present at all times so as to not have any point where the faithful are abandoned, and I of course agree, but how can that be reconciled with the fact that the Arian heresy seemingly dominated for the brief time until it was condemned in council? What if hypothetically someone was taught Arianism by one of the many bishops and subscribed to it but died before it was sorted out in council? Could someone level this as an argument against the magisterium always being present for Catholics to follow?47:40 – Is Palamism considered a heresy in the west? I’ve heard some Eastern Catholics practice it.50:38 – Why don’t we believe in the 4 other archangels that the Orthodox accept?51:19 – I have a friend who is the daughter of an orthodox mother and a Catholic father. She professes to be both. I’m concerned. Is this possible?52:50 – Are we moving towards a healing between the east and the west?…
Questions Covered:07:04 – How does Catholicism interpret the Tome of Leo when it says “For each form does what is proper to it with the co-operation of the other; that is the Word performing what appertains to the Word, and the flesh carrying out what appertains to the flesh. One of them sparkles with miracles, the other succumbs to injuries.”?14:48 – How has Catholicism defined hypostasis and nature throughout history?19:23 – Would the Orthodox have to accept Transubstantiation if the Catholics and Orthodox were to be reunited?24:12 – I often hear Orthodox claims about how the first millennium ecclesiology was Orthodox and not Catholic. Is this true?35:33 – Protestants often balk at Catholic apologists claiming “all of the fathers” on an issue. These same Protestants will justify their rejection of the fathers as an authority by stating that they are so varied in opinion on things that no one can really claim them. How do we respond to them in a nuanced way that doesn’t exaggerate the patristic agreement on a subject, but demonstrates the importance of listening to their witness?42:50 – The teaching of the magisterium on young earth creationism and evolution are difficult for me to reconcile. I am personally very convinced of an old earth, but my conversion to Catholicism was helped in large degree by the witness of the fathers. From what I understand, besides Augustine, who still believed in an Earth that is thousands and not billions of years old, there is a consensus of the fathers on this issue that the Bible teaches that the earth is young, not old. What exactly goes into the magisterium’s ruling that this is a matter outside of the scope of the fathers, and can that standard be applied consistently to other doctrines to show that we are reasonable and consistent to reject this patristic consensus while asking Protestants and Orthodox to be bound on other areas where there is patristic consensus?48:45 – Is it possible for there to be a papal situation where the previous Pope resigned, but the next pope for whatever reason wasn’t legitimately elected, and that Antipope hangs around for a long time but short enough that the Church still has sufficient valid cardinals to legitimately elect a new valid pope, resulting in the Church actually having a sede vacante for a decade or so with almost nobody knowing, and the situation quickly being resolved with a new valid pope being elected after some time?…
Questions Covered:05:05 – Why is it so wrong for a woman to be a priest? Continued from hour one12:30 – Is Santa real?17:40 – If Jesus is fully in the host, then there must be millions of him.23:50 – Why did they call Jesus’ birthday Christmas?30:15 – Why does God live in heaven?36:03 – Who made God?42:50 – Why did the wisemen decide to follow the star?49:24 – Why do we have Christmas trees during Christmas?…
Questions Covered:04:45 – Who’s the first person in the world to believe that Jesus is God?13:13 – “The 7 Joys of Mary,” why is the 6th joy of Mary, Jesus on the crucifix?18:56 – Do dogs go to heaven?24:00 – Why does Mama Mary pray for us?29:50 – Why did God make dinosaurs?32:30 – Why does God let bad people kill good people?42:45 – How can we prove God’s existence through science?49:27 – Why is it so wrong for a woman to be a priest?…
Topics Covered:04:00 – Gay “Marriage” Bill 42:05 – Nicaraguan Bishop persecuted and ideologies …
Questions Covered:08:30 – What are your suggestions of books on how to deal with loneliness especially during the holidays, from a Catholic perspective? 19:35 – I was told that it would be okay to be a godparent to a Lutheran and now I am. What do I do now if it is wrong? 29:05 – Were Mary, Martha, and Lazarus unmarried? And does this have any significance? 33:54 – I’m a new Catholic. How to respond to the protestant claim that the Eucharist is a symbol? 44:18 – If Mary is the mother of Jesus and Joseph is the stepfather, but the Davidic line is through Joseph, how can we claim that Jesus falls under the Davidic Line? 50:44 – Why use the word apologist? Why are we apologizing for being Catholic? …
Questions Covered:04:21 – How can I interpret Deuteronomy 21:10-14?19:30 – Who is your favorite Church father?23:10 – Why did God suspend natural law in order to impregnate Mary?30:24 – Can a Catholic be a godparent to a Lutheran in the Missouri Synod?33:00 – What are the Catholic teachings on Yoga as a physical activity?41:20 – Where is the balance in living one’s Catholic Faith and not coming off strong?47:10 – What were Pope John Paul II’s grounds for adding the Luminous mysteries to the rosary?…
Questions Covered:30:08 – Is family catechesis something you promote in your book?41:12 – How can we baptize some of the secular things in our lives such as sports?47:45 – What does hospitality in a Catholic family look like?…
Questions Covered:28:46 – My parents divorced when I was 11 and my dad ended up marrying his high school sweetheart. Even today, decades later, I’m still feeling the effects of it. Can you just comment on that?31:54 – I’m divorced, and my depression kicks up around this time of year. How do I get over it?34:59 – I’m annulled after a marriage that lasted 6 months. How do I discern marriage with this hanging over my head?40:55 – Can you clarify your point of inviting someone to a gathering but rejecting the significant other? It doesn’t seem very Christ-like.44:47 – Your advice is great for other situations, not just for the divorced! I just wanted to thank you for your advice!50:13 – If someone is not married in the Church can they still receive communion?…
Questions Covered:00:54 – I feel like I don’t have a path. How do I faith in God?11:54 – What’s the relation of James the lesser to Jesus?21:28 – Why did the Jewish people sacrifice animals? Was it a matter of having sins forgiven just to feel better since heaven wasn’t open?28:40 – What role did the Talmud help, if any, in establishing the canon of scripture in the Catholic Church?35:55 – The food chain seems a bit cruel for God to create. What are your thoughts on this?46:34 – How do you respond to protestants who say the rosary isn’t in the bible?51:30 – Who were the shepherds that the angels appeared to during the birth of Christ?…
Questions Covered:03:51 – Could you explain the apparent contradiction with the thieves crucified with Christ? One gospel says they both mocked Jesus and another gospel explains the good thief and bad thief story.07:57 – Did God order genocide in the Old Testament?13:48 – What’s the proper Catholic interpretations of Romans 9:19-23?28:53 – In the bible, the Our Father has a variation. Can I add a word to the prayer to help it make more sense to me?36:38 – How do you divorce someone quietly?44:08 – Can you explain the meaning of the term Son of Man? Why did it create so much controversy?51:18 – The St. Pius X Catechism says we should burn protestant bibles. I’m a convert, should I burn my old bibles?…
Questions Covered:01:28 – Is it heretical to believe that the reason God gives us life is to test our worthiness of heaven?11:10 – I was approached to be a sponsor for someone who’s going through RCIA but I’m also going to be a godparent to their child. Is it appropriate for me to take on both roles?14:15 – How do I respond to the claim that Constantine created the Catholic Church?21:20 – How does the Church deal with killing in general? War, first responders etc.36:15 – Why couldn’t Isaac give Esau a better blessing?41:27 – 1 Thes. 4 say Jesus will return and those alive will be taken up. Why do Catholics not believe in a rapture?49:00 – Jesus claims to be meek and humble of heart but was bold and brave. Is the translation for these terms wrong because he doesn’t act very meek?…
Questions Covered:05:25 – How can we reconcile with the prophets who said the Messiah was going to be named Emmanuel but ended up being named Jesus?09:09 – What’s your opinion on the charismatic movement in the Church?16:52 – How is it possible for Orthodox Christians to recognize some of our popes as saints and yet reject the papacy?24:14 – If Jesus is God, how could Jesus lead us to God?29:20 – Why don’t we see more books on apologetics defending Vatican 2?33:25 – In Matthew Jesus says to pick up your cross and follow him. He said this before his crucifixion. What did it mean to the people then?35:33 – In the Gospel it says that John the Baptist was the greatest man born of woman but the least in the kingdom of God. What is the proper interpretation of this? Is he greater than Mary?39:15 – I wanted to say thank you! Catholic Answers was what got me interested in Catholicism!45:01 – Is restitution necessary for forgiveness when going to confession?46:42 – My husband heard claims from Mother Teresa and her ministry made people sicker through lack of medicine and accusations of fraud. Did the Church make a mistake in canonizing her?53:15 – Is general absolution valid?…
Questions Covered:06:44 – How would you respond to the claim that some people cannot receive grace from liturgy due to the abuse done by some priests?17:29 – Do Catholics believe in irresistible grace? https://www.catholic.com/magazine/online-edition/gods-resistible-grace23:15 – Why do we have many translations of the Catholic bible?29:25 – How do we reconcile Gen. 49:5-7 and Judith 9?33:05 – Since the deposit of faith include liturgical traditions, can the pope infallibly declare things that are not written or oral traditions?42:30 – Why do Catholic bibles have more than protestant bibles?47:00 – Would you consider Taoism a religion searching for God?52:36 – How is it just for someone who dies old to have a lifetime for conversion but someone who dies young doesn’t?…
Questions Covered:05:25 – How did Judas die?12:03 – Paul recommends not being married but Genesis says that it’s not good for man to be alone. How do we reconcile this?18:43 – Why did Jesus come when he came?23:50 – Did the pope change Church teaching on the death penalty or did he just share his opinion?32:22 – I attend a monthly service with holy oil. The priest tells after those services that we don’t need to go to confession because of the service. What are your thoughts on that?36:48 – Are we supposed to raise our hands up during the Our Father?44:18 – If God wanted all things perfect, why did He create the tree of knowledge of good and evil?49:23 – Do You know where I could find homilies written by saints?52:50 – Is it true that women can be priests in the Church now?…
Questions Covered:07:08 – How do we respond to: If Mary was sinless why would she die? 13:15 – What are the Nephilim? 20:15 – Does prayer affect the will of God in our life? 28:41 – My protestant boss is going on a mission, and I want to write a bible verse on his card. What would be a good verse to write in as a Catholic? 33:47 – How do we know Jesus was here for all of us and not just Jews since He is the Jewish Messiah? 38:11 – What’s the earliest account that we have on the sacrament of reconciliation? 44:01 – How are we to understand the idea that schism is wrong, but Jesus and the apostles were in schism with Judaism? 50:37 – My Catholic friend has started talking to a medium and has been supposedly receiving messages from his father. I told him to talk to a priest and the priest told him it was ok. How do I respond? …
Questions Covered:01:53 – 2. Sam. 24:1 God said to David make a census but the 1st. Chronicles 21:1 Satan entices David to take a census. Who incited David to make the census. Is this a contradiction? 12:18 – If I am in a state of mortal sin and can only get a ride from a friend who only has a provisional license and legally can’t ride with him, am I morally okay to still get a ride with him? 15:23 – How would you refute the Orthodox claim that liturgical abuse in Catholicism is the biggest sign that the Catholic Church is not the one true Church? 21:19 – Is it wrong for me to go to clinic that has some involvement with abortion but seeking non abortion services? 23:57 – I’m an illustrator that has to do a lot of research for references. Some of the things I have to research dives into pagan deities. How do I find the line between my faith and these things that make me feel uncomfortable? 33:41 – Are we only going to see Jesus in heaven or are we also going to see God the Father? 39:00 – I struggle with the idea that fallen away Catholics getting married outside the Church don’t have a valid marriage. How should I approach those marriages? Can I celebrate them? 46:30 – I’m allergic to incense and my pastor just started using it heavily. Where does this leave me in attending mass? …
Questions Covered:05:35 – What are your thoughts on prima scriptura over sola scriptura? 12:36 – How should we approach submission to church authority when we have problems with her teachings? 21:58 – How do I level admonishment and prudence when considering approaching a friend who married outside of the Church? 33:28 – John the Baptist knew that Jesus was the Messiah in Mt.3 but sent to question whether He was the Messiah in Mt. 11. Was he doubting Jesus? 41:23 – How does the Catholic Church elect its new bishops? 45:38 – If God knows everything, why did he still create Satan and the third of the angels that fell? …
Questions Covered:22:01 – What’s the difference between stem cells and cell lines? 34:13 – How do we respond to people who ground human value in consciousness? 36:54 – Could you give an overview of transhumanism and if there is any link to the covid vaccine? 41:19 – What do you think is the reason why people become gay? Is it genetic or is it cultural? 46:51 – The drug Humera is made with human and animal cells. Do you know what those cells are specifically from? https://cogforlife.org/ 49:23 – If a trans person is considering joining the Catholic Church, would they have to detransition? 52:40 – Have we forgotten that there is a stage in human development where we have a nonsexual same sex attraction? …
Questions Covered:03:05 – How would one come to know the gender of one who is intersex? 11:21 – What’s the reasoning behind the teaching that Jesus is present in both species? 14:45 – Is it possible to live a contemplative life as a married man? 21:57 – If Adam and Eve were perfect before the fall how did they have imperfect judgment by choosing sin? 30:01 – How can we prove that Mary was always a virgin? 38:12 – How can I prove that we receive salvation through faith and works and not salvation through faith alone? 43:19 – Does God already know if we are going to heaven or hell? …
Questions Covered:04:01 – Imagine a technology developed that gives two people the ability to share feelings, emotions, physical sensations, etc., with each other as if they were truly experiencing the other person in the exact state that they are in at that moment in time. I’m thinking of a situation where John is trying to explain how he feels about something important, but he just can’t put it into words for Jane to understand. To solve the problem, they both connect their minds with the technology and for a brief moment, Jane knows exactly the how’s and why’s of John’s emotions, even his physical sensations or pain or pleasure. She is now able to understand him on a level that is too complex for words, resulting in greater intimacy and love between them. If we apply this to Church teaching on marriage, would a husband and wife be obligated to participate in this activity as a means of total giving of oneself to the other? If not, could you think of some variation of this technology or scenario that the Church would promote or even require? For the purpose of this thought experiment, assume that you wouldn’t be able to abuse this technology or generally use it in a negative way.15:30 – Is there competition in heaven? It seems to be part of human nature.18:54 – Assuming that there is life on other planets and that they have been given the same immortal souls as we have, and assuming that they are susceptible to death as we are, does that mean that Heaven, Hell, and Purgatory are currently comprised of human souls and the souls of what we would consider aliens, too?22:51 – Has a convert ever been Pope?24:32 – Are the proposed alien sightings aliens or angels and/or demons?34:25 – My understanding is that the soul is the life principle. When stem cells are removed from a body and cultured, do they receive a new sensitive soul but not rational soul?41:52 – Some writers through history have depicted multiple “levels” of hell and heaven (e.g. Dante). Is there any biblical support for distinct experiences of heaven and hell?48:06 – Could the other people mentioned in Genesis be the Neanderthals? (See Genesis 4 and the reference to the people who might kill Cain)52:03 – What happens to your soul if you get assimilated by the Borg?…
Questions Covered:03:54 – What’s the Catholic perspective on self-help books?7:45 – Did the fall of angels happen before or after Adam and Eve?13:24 – What is a well-formed conscience and how does one form one?20:08 – How can the NAB be an approved bible if there are some passages, mainly the story of the woman in adultery is included but states that it’s potentially not in the original?28:50 – How did evil come to be? The bible doesn’t really talk about it but it seems like other religious writings talk about it.35:48 – Did Jesus tell Peter to build the Church upon the rock before or after the crucifixion?42:07 – If you’re addicted to a sin and commit it habitually does that make it a mortal sin?47:06 – How do Catholics balance assenting to authority and knowing when to revolt against spiritual authority?53:55 – Is it permissible for a Catholic organist to play at an Episcopal church?…
Questions Covered:
13:59 – I have a history of attempts at recovery and have a traumatic brain injury, do you have any advice to get over these hurdles? 24:20 – I recently got out of a protestant recovery program and am excited to hear that there is a Catholic alternative! Could you share more about the ministry? 35:13 – How do I tell if my spouse is an alcoholic? 45:55 – Does your organization point families to programs that have good track records? 50:39 – I founded a CIR group and the clergy were very excited that this existed! I would like to share this story.
…
Questions Covered:
02:01 – did Mary have the beatific vision? Where is the line between making jokes and being blasphemous and sacrilegious? 08:18 – Did Zoroastrianism influence Judaism or Christianity? 21:20 – In the Nicene Creed it says that Jesus will come the living and the dead, does that mean that those who have died are in the state limbo waiting for Jesus to return? 28:53 – What’s the Church’s understanding of personhood? 41:06 – If a priest is in the state of mortal sin and celebrates mass, is it proper for him to receive communion? 45:39 – What do you know about the origins of priests celebrating mass 3 times a day on Christmas? 48:15 – If God forgives all sins during confession, what are judged for after we die? 52:58 – Jesus breathed on the apostles giving them the Holy Spirit and then the apostles received the Holy Spirit again on Pentecost. Did they get a double dose or was it a different spirit?
…
Questions Covered:
02:00 – If God is outside of time how does he know if someone didn’t keep holy the sabbath or perform delayed obedience? 09:55 – Was the 28th Canon of Chalcedon accepted in the east? 21:53 – How do we square the story of Adam and Eve and science? 39:56 – What do we know about God watching over us as individuals and situations in our lives? 48:37 – What is the Church’s stance on race and the specifically the biblical descendants?
…
Questions Covered:
03:00 – I know some very good people that have no affiliation with Christianity no belief in God. Some of them are more giving and patient than people I know that are Christian. Are they dismissed by God because they’re not baptized and don’t go to church? 13:08 – What makes a marriage valid? Does it need to be performed by an ambassador of Christ? If so, does that mean a Protestant minister cannot perform a valid marriage? 19:39 – How can one reconcile the faith when looking at history with indulgences and corruption in the church? 23:31 – Why is there such an emphasis on the Church as an organization? For example saying, “What does the Church say about it?” Why can’t we just go right to the bible? 33:20 – Every time I pray it feels like there’s an all-consuming feeling of fear activated that’s strong. How do I grow spiritually with this fear? Should I wait until it dies down and just not pray as frequently? 41:50 – I adopted my now 12 y.o. son and he has severe cognitive disabilities. I’m fairly certain he has never been baptized. Should he be? What’s the process for that? 44:28 – In Matthew 24:40 in last Sunday’s gospel it says “One is taken, one is left.” What does this mean? 46:44 – How did Jesus go up into heaven since he can’t fly there? 51:25 – My son and his fiancé are getting married in the spring. She would like her parish priest preside and we would also like to have a retired bishop. Can the bishop concelebrate?
…
Questions Covered:
04:20 – How do we defend Catholic position that Muslims and Catholics worship the same God, but Mormons aren’t Christian heretics? 16:59 – How is it that some Catholics can be anti-Semitic? 30:03 – I was told by a relative that I love the Church and my faith more than I love God. Is that possible? If so, is that bad? Also, can you help me understand the protestant funeral my grandmother was buried with today? 42:14 – I’m a recent convert and after I sin I repent and trust God forgives me when asking sincerely. It feels like a sin to go and ask a priest afterwards like I’m asking him again. Also, is saying the Our Father not asking God forgiveness for our sins? Is that not sufficient enough?
…
Questions Covered: 03:00 – Joan “Siobhan” of Arc 14:30 – NPR Selling out to transgender ideology 20:30 – The passing of pro-abortion legislation 28:15 – Moral idiocy 36:10 – Marriage rates in the U.S. …
Questions Covered:
08:00 – Gratitude 18:00 – The Eucharist is Thanksgiving 29:20 – Pausing the Synodal process 34:30 – Religiosity based off education demographics 48:00 – Diversity in Christian denominations
…
Questions Covered:
06:46 – Is the newest booster vaccine approved by the Catholic Church? 11:40 – Why are the gospels named Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John if they weren’t necessarily written by those men? 19:05 – In Tobias in the Douay–Rheims I find a story about a dog and the angels. I don’t find that story in any other translation. Why is that? 34:44 – Is Mt. 28:19 a directive for everyone or just priests? 41:16 – I know we are required to forgive whether they want forgiveness, but we must want to be forgiven for God to forgive us. Why is that? 47:48 – Why did Jesus tell Mary Magdalene not to touch him but told Thomas to touch his wounds? 51:28 – Can a priest perform their priestly duties without a stole? Where is the stole in the bible?
…
Questions Covered:
04:17 – In Gen 46-48, it says Abraham, Jacob, Isaac died in their hundreds. The calculate it by multiplying numbers. Example (5x5x7, 6x6x5, etc.). Is there a specific meaning behind that? 11:15 – Does the bible say which form of government is ideal? 19:20 – Why is it rare that passion narrative pieces are read throughout the year in Mass? 21:34 – Is there a bible passage that clarifies either the Nicene creed and apostles’ creed statement “conceived by the Holy Spirit” or “incarnate of the Holy Spirit?” 29:15 – Maccabees say that it’s good to pray for the dead. What good did it do at that time if Jesus hadn’t opened the gates of heaven yet? 35:04 – What was Luther’s theological foundation for breaking away from the Church? 44:50 – What is the legitimacy of the 3 vocations and is being single a vocation? 52:04 – Why would Abraham and Isaac go to other kingdoms and claim that their wives were their sisters?
…
Questions Covered:
05:12 – Why doesn’t the Catholic Church consider other Protestant denominations’ communion valid? 12:06 – If God is outside of time and in the eternal, how does God know if someone didn’t honor the sabbath or know of delayed obedience? 15:23 – Is there anything in the Catechism that says anything when the baby in the womb has a soul? 19:52 – My household is very lukewarm. I’ve become curious about learning more about the Theotokos. What is it? 29:51 – What does it mean to be in the state of Grace? 35:54 – An abortion doctor in Indiana performed an abortion on a 10-year-old. How do I defend life in that situation? 41:47 – Is there a program that I can order online about apologetics? Where can we go to get a good explanation about the Inquisition and the crusades? 46:04 – Is it a mortal sin for a Catholic married couple to use the withdrawal method?
…
Questions Covered:
06:46 – Why is it important to confess your sins to a priest instead of asking God directly? 24:17 – I’ve recently rediscovered my faith. How can I bring my family back to the Church without being overbearing? 20:39 – What is the Church’s stance on Marijuana? 23:59 – How do I simply respond to someone asking how I know I’m saved? 40:17 – Where do dinosaurs fit into the creation story? 45:30 – How do I get over the hurdle of feeling like we worship Mary? 51:20 – Why do we need the Eucharist if we have the Holy Spirit who is always with us?
…
Questions Covered:
4:40 – Is being Catholic the only way to reach salvation? 13:56 – Why do Catholics believe that they are the one true Church? 22:47 – Where does the requirement of needing 2 miracles for the canonization of a saint come from? What are your thoughts on praying to relatives who have passed if they were holy people? 29:38 – Is it okay for Catholics to read books that aren’t Catholic/Christian? 32:29 – How is it that the Church says Mary did not have any more kids when the bible says she does. 45:31 – Jesus said to the good thief that he would be in paradise with him that day. Does that mean that Jesus didn’t go to hell? 50:28 – I’m in RCIA. Am I declaring the saints omniscient by praying to them?
…
Questions Covered:
23:57 – How do you approach children who have gone away from the Faith? 39:47 – What would be the best way to handle your children having children and not baptizing them? Words of Eternal Life 45:06 – What can I do to help my brother return to God? 49:57 – My 17 years old daughter says she doesn’t believe anymore. What should I do? What are your thoughts about going back to basics?
…
Questions Covered:
12:13 – Can you explain where the sacrament of confession is in the bible? 17:56 – How can the prodigal son be simultaneously saved and not yet given his inheritance, which is salvation? 20:45 – How do I explain holy water to a protestant, specifically from the bible? 24:11 – Follow up on confession: My protestants respond that Jesus said to confess to one another not a priest. My response to this is Jesus’ intentionality. What are your thoughts on this? 32:30 – If God is immutable then how does that reconcile with the bible describing wrath and anger in God? 38:33 – How do you refute Sola Fide from a Catholic perspective? 46:24 – Does God stop the devil from confessing his sins? The Bible said he was created before Adam and Eve and was the smartest creation. Why spend all this time without confessing? 52:39 – In scripture Jesus says the thief would be in paradise on that day but the Creed says Jesus descended into hell for three days. How do we reconcile this?
…
Questions Covered:
08:00- What is the best concise support for the papacy? 17:12 – Have you heard of Zachary King, the former Satanist High Wizard turned pro-life advocate? If so, can you verify his story? 37:03 – How is the Old Testament God the same as the New Testament God, and how can I explain that to my Protestant friends? 46:04 – How do you answer the claim that anyone can consecrate the Eucharist since the Bible never says it has to be a priest?
…
Questions Covered:
07:37 – Where did the idea come from that ancient Israel worshiped many gods in addition to Yahweh, who was just one among many? 23:14 – My friend wants to know how praying to Mary is more efficient or effective than praying to Jesus alone, and whether there’s any official Church teaching on that. 36:57 – If one is out of a state of sanctifying grace, is he still part of the Body of Christ? 46:29 – The Mexican supreme court is currently debating whether to use public funds to buy nativity scenes for public display. How should I as a Catholic feel about this in terms of the relation between Church and state?
…
Questions Covered:
11:15 – How should Christians think about the different types of grace and how we move in and out of a state of grace? 22:42 – How does the Church view Protestants who are aware of and accept most Catholic doctrine but are reluctant to convert? Does imperfect communion extend to them? 35:36 – Where do we get the idea that God cannot do anything logically impossible? And if that’s true, how can Jesus be 100% God and 100% man? 49:03 – How should I talk to my husband, who’s a self-described materialist, about the soul? What are some basic principles I can appeal to?
…
Questions Covered:
07:40 – Did Jesus’s prophecy about the timing of the second coming go unfulfilled? 21:00 – As Catholics, what can we do to go outside of the Church and evangelize? 36:50 – Why does the Church approve certain private revelations without requiring the faithful to believe in them?
…
Questions Covered:
05:34 – How can I respond to objections to Mary’s perpetual virginity? 17:19 – Can new godparents be appointed? 34:44 – How did the Church conclude from the Bible that Mary is our spiritual mother and immaculately conceived? 49:00 – Is it okay to meditate on nothing or are we only supposed to meditate on the word?
…
Questions Covered:
03:04 – Why does the Church teach against masturbation? 14:32 – Why do we believe in the True presence in the Eucharist? 21:10 – What is the supporting evidence for the Coronation of Mary? 29:12 – Do we retain free will when we’re in heaven? 35:26 – How do I approach my Protestant friend on the topic of the Assumption of Mary? 47:24 – I have trouble with accepting the Trinity.
…
Questions Covered:
06:20 – I’m troubled by the doctrine of Hell and people who don’t accept Jesus going to Hell, and what constitutes invincible ignorance. 15:18 – I’ve never fully understood the doctrine of indulgences. 20:43 – I’m troubled by the Church’s teaching on contraception. I had a vasectomy when I was a Protestant and I want to know if that’s going to impede my entry into the Church. 29:21 – How can I believe the doctrines of Mary? 41:24 – I’m troubled by why hell would be eternal instead of the souls being annihilated. 52:09 – I’m trying to understand the role of the bishops’ authority. How could a bishop have the authority to punish a priest who didn’t do anything wrong?
…
Questions Covered:
02:48 – In Exodus there is talks about the buying and selling of slaves. Does this mean that the bible condones chattel slavery? 13:47 – How do I explain to my protestant friends that people don’t become angels after death? 17:32 – I see the Holy Spirit as wisdom personified. In the bible it refers to wisdom as feminine. Is it appropriate to conclude that the Holy Spirit is female? 29:06 – What are the requirements to obtain an indulgence for someone who has passed away during the month of November? Is the requirement of having no attachment to sin almost impossible to meet? 33:08 – Who does the pope confess to? Is it a person or directly to God? 34:66 – My daughter goes to a Catholic school, 41:21 – Do Daniel 9:27 and Malachi 1:11 contradict each other? What is the proper understanding? and I discovered inappropriate books in their library. I have a meeting with the principal. Am I overreacting? 48:05 – How is it possible for the Virgin Mary not to enter into original sin like Eve?
…
Questions Covered:
01:48 – What’s the difference between penal substitution and vicarious satisfaction in atonement theology? 13:18 – My son goes to Catholic school and was told by a teacher that Protestants reject that Mary is the Mother of God. Is this accurate? 15:11 – Is there any situation in which a pope can be removed from office? Specifically, if he is no longer of sound mind. 21:23 – Is there any record of the differences in light skin and dark skin people in the Bible? Why is there no mention of Africans in the Bible? 37:28 – Who coined the word saint? Is it a carryover from Judaism? 44:35 – Does the Church treat private revelation and near-death experiences the same? What are your thoughts on near death experiences?
…
Questions Covered:
04:08 – If St. Paul was incorrect about the timing of the second coming, was he incorrect about other things? 09:37 – I’m having an operation, is it appropriate to receive the anointing of the sick and an apostolic pardon? 16:57 – If the 1965 Mass in Latin with some vernacular was the true intention, what was their motivation with adding additional Eucharistic prayers? 23:28 – If ‘once saved always saved’ isn’t true, when does someone lose salvation? 38:15 – Which of the apostles were present at the crucifixion of Jesus? 46:32 – Is it definitive that we’ll have glorified bodies in heaven, but will those in hell also receive a form of glorified bodies? 50:50 – Why did God kill all the first born in Exodus and could He have gone about it in a different way that led to the freeing of the Israelites?
…
Questions Covered:
03:23 – Where is purgatory in the bible and how do you prove it to a Protestant? 13:46 – As a health worker am I morally able to work at a children’s hospital that offers hormone therapy and puberty blockers? 22:01 – What was the question? Am I in communion with bishops who are denying the faith in Europe? 34:26 – If Jesus did not forgive people on the cross, would he and all of humanity have been cursed? 40:02 – Why did you concretely assert that the gospels were written anonymously on page 155 in the Early Church book? 44:24 – Is God’s free will limited by his own omniscience?
…
Questions Covered:
05:23 – Do I need to specify the number of times I’ve sinned during confession? 07:44 – How do I talk to my friends in class about becoming Catholic? 15:27 – When we talk about receiving communion people say they feel closer to God, but If we are always in God’s present how can we say that we are closer? 20:46 – What would happen if a priest were to claim that they are a woman? How would the Church respond? 30:33 – I’m a divorced Catholic, could I join a monastery? 33:06 – One of my favorite bands has some borderline sacrilegious lyrics. Is it a mortal sin to listen to their music or go to a concert? 38:11 – Under what circumstances does a non-Catholic have access to the sacraments? 45:26 – What is the Church’s teaching for those who are not disposed to receive communion but instead go up, cross their arms and receive a blessing? 49:07 – What is your advice to a fallen away Catholic who wants to return?
…
Questions Covered:
06:34 – Is it appropriate to compare playing the lotto with the Apostles casting lot to replace Judas and the soldiers casting lots for Jesus’ robe? 15:46 – My wife and I just miscarried, what is the Catholic stance on cremation and also on scattering the ashes? Resource: heavensgain.org 21:59 – Gen 6 talks about how God was disappointed with the people and sent a flood. Weren’t the people that he killed innocent? 33:07 – Why do we only receive the host for communion instead of both species? 41:39 – I’m a 7th Day Adventist looking into Catholicism. How do I talk to people who feel that once you become a believer, that all your sins, past and future, are already forgiven? 51:04 – I believe in biological evolution. I have a hard time reconciling animals tearing each other apart with there being a just God.
…
Questions Covered:
04:03 – If a Catholic does not believe in the Eucharist, is he technically not saved? 13:00 – Referring to scripture, what’s the difference between showing shame and being guilty? 16:45 – How would you respond to people who are a part of the World Mission Society Word of God and their claim that there’s a Mother God? 31:55 – I’m Protestant. The Catholic Church looks different from the Church from the Patristic period. How does the development of doctrine work according to Catholics? 42:49 – A relative of mine who was raised Catholic but now questions everything. She asked why the Church doesn’t accept “gay” marriage and forces women to give birth in circumstances such as rape. How do I respond? 50:14 – Why should I be Catholic and not just Protestant?
…
Questions Covered:
05:03 – How would a Catholic respond to the population argument for reincarnation? 12:15 – Is the desire and being on the way to commit mortal sin, make one lose salvific grace? I’m comparing this to baptism by desire. 16:43 – If the Pope is infallible, what if he preaches something blatantly immoral? 20:30 – Can St Joseph’s intercession be good for finding a job? 23:35 – Why did David wear the priestly garment if he wasn’t a Levite? 29:37 – How could the Orthodox have a valid priesthood if they reject the authority of the priesthood? 32:54 – If you prefer going to confession with a certain priest but there’s a confession time earlier with other priests, should you wait or go to the earliest confession? 36:54 – My brother sends me inappropriate memes about the Church and the Eucharist? How should I handle this since he thinks it’s no big deal? 43:21 – My dad is a protestant missionary and is very anti-Catholic. He went to Iraq and said he found the original church and claims the Catholic Church is the original Protestant church that broke away from them. How do I respond? 48:32 – When did adoration become a practice? 51:27 – 1. Cor 5 says that people who are sexually immoral should be expelled from the Church. How do I reconcile this with people who have been accused of this but continue to retain their power and position in the Church?
…
Questions Covered:
17:19 – Is there any non-religious proof for the existence of a God? 23:35 – What is your favorite footnote in the appendix for your book? 30:12 – Granting everything you said about God being timeless, how does having free will make any sense? 41:36 – How do we reconcile God being love and the bible saying that God hates certain people? 50:25 – What does God mean when he says that there will be many mansions in heaven?
…
Questions Covered:
23:15 – I read that Jesus was only one of many messianic figures and Jesus’ religion was only spread because of Constantine. Is this True? 30:50 – How is it that we can believe in evolution and Catholicism? 35:37 – I’m 9 weeks pregnant. Does the baby in the womb have a soul? 44:04 – Can protestants be saved? 49:05 – Why did God not dissipate Satan? Why did God send him to earth?
…
Questions Covered:
02:23 – Why should I pursue converting my Lutheran friends if they are already really great Christians? 05:50 – My wife is Catholic and I’m a Methodist going through RCIA. How does the bible support the real presence in the Eucharist? 12:17 – Do I need to pay some sort of gratuity to a priest if I ask him to bless items for me? 14:28 – I pray the rosary frequently but am very distracted. Do they do anything even if I’m distracted? https://www.catholic.com/audio/caf/does-the-church-encourage-superstition 17:43 – What was Mary and Joseph’s betrothal? Was it a marriage since he was able to divorce her? 20:34 – How would a woman who had an abortion atone for her sin? SEND purgatory is fo reals 30:19 – Are there any plenary indulgences that someone who is a shut in can obtain through prayer alone? 33:38 – How do I talk to my Jewish fiancé about Catholicism? 40:23 – My fiancé and I are trying to find a good foundation for our marriage and are considering Catholicism. Is Catholicism a good foundation? 47:15 – How can God be omnipotent and desire something?
…
Questions Covered:
01:03 – I do martial arts and yoga. Are these things ok for me to do as a Catholic. How do I figure out if I know I can or can’t? 06:01 – Does Jn 2:10 make Jesus look irresponsible by giving my wine to drunk people? 18:32 – Why doesn’t the western rite allow infants to be confirmed but the eastern Catholic rites do? Can a western Catholic go to an eastern Catholic priest and get their child confirmed, as well as baptized in emergency situations? 28:31 – I grew up, was married, and divorced in the Mormon church. What do I need to do to be fully accepted into the Catholic Church since divorce is not acceptable? 34:16 – Can you clarify your comments on yoga? Isn’t a position a prayer posture? Also, you said TV is bad, what about the 2 Catholic channels? Are those bad? 42:23 – 1 Cor 3:15 and 2 Maccabees are used as proof for purgatory. They don’t seem to actually be referencing purgatory. What is your response to that?
…
Open Forum:
04:20 – Where do we find the word ‘priest’ in the New Testament? 14:11 – Can the laity perform a minor exorcism? 23:41 – What resources would you recommend giving my dying protestant mother? 29:38 – What is the Church’s view on ghosts? 34:19 – How do we refute the Calvinist view of free will? 41:18 – How far can the new understanding of capital punishment be taken either way? If I’m a juror and consider capital punishment, am I at risk of sin?
…
Questions Covered:
04:23 – I applied for a new job as a data analyst for a medical company. I found out they partner with fertility clinics and LGBT people adoption centers. Could I take this job or am I too close to cooperation with evil? 07:56 – Do you have to be Catholic to go to heaven? Is everyone in heaven Catholic? 14:20 – If I’m serving at a Saturday vigil mass, does it qualify as me participating? 19:21 – Did the Jews that died in the holocaust go to hell? 24:06 – What’s the correct response to the objection on John 6 that Jesus is just speaking spiritually? 31:27 – Does the host after consecration emit anything? 40:45 – Is Anglo-Catholicism a legitimate branch in the Catholic Church? 47:05 – What happens to a person spiritually when they are in a state of grace and then commit a mortal sin? 50:42 – How are we supposed to pray for our loved ones who, as far as we know, have denied Christ? 52:53 – What is the Church’s teaching on fertility drugs?
…
Questions Covered:
13:37 – In the early Church, as apostolic succession tied to the bishops of the presbyters? 18:13 – Is the Magisterium above Sacred Scripture? 23:32 – Is there a difference between a nun and a sister? 29:06 – I’m a recent convert. Is salvation lost for my ex-Catholic dad? 33:38 – Are there any connections today between Moloch and abortion? 35:40 – You once gave a great argument against Orthodoxy saying that historically they did take the popes say as authoritative. Could you expound on that? 43:27 – Are the Jewish people still saved by the old covenant? Does the old covenant still apply to converted Jews? 47:33 – Is the long form of the St. Michael prayer an exorcism prayer? 50:41 – What keeps an antipope from adding to Catholic tradition?
…
Questions Covered:
04:05 – Why is the Father the first person of the Trinity, the Son the Second, and the Holy Spirit the Third? Why that order? 13:34 – How are we saved? By grace alone or by baptism? 17:54 – Are you fully a Catholic if you have baptism by desire? 28:37 – Is it true that the Council of Trent taught that there’s no salvation outside of the Catholic Church? And if it is, is that still what the Church teaches today? 39:09 – How can we increase in the initial state of justification? 47:30 – Why do Catholics not believe in predestination?
…
Questions Covered:
04:37 – 1 John 5:13 says that we can know that we have eternal life. But Catholics say that we can’t know. It sounds like Catholics disagree with the Bible on this. Can we still perish even if we believe in Christ? 17:15 – Why do Christian churches try to scare everybody into believing in hell? 23:09 – Is it true that all Christians who are baptized technically have been exorcized? 29:39 – I have trouble with the teaching that God’s authority over his creations makes it okay for him to kill them. Wouldn’t that make him pro-choice? 42:38 – I see substitutionary atonement as very influential in pushing me towards atheism and I want to see if I’m understanding it correctly.
…
Questions Covered:
01:21 – My question involves a Frankenstein’ monster scenario. Let’s suppose that the monster’s body was created as provided in the original novel. Let’s also suppose that the body parts were all gathered from baptized persons. After coming to life, would the monster need to be baptized in order to have the stain of original sin removed? 06:11 – Why do things fly off the shelf by themselves? Why do we hear heavy footsteps on our ceiling when we only have a one-story house? Why do our cats avoid a certain spot in the living room and spend hours alertly watching it? 13:16 – I believe in ghosts, or whatever it is that we call ghosts, because my daughter has seen them when she was younger and scared us all. What did she see? If ghosts are real, what are they? Why would someone be able to see them? 23:53 – If you lean too close when blowing out your Jack-o’-lantern, can the pumpkin suck out your soul? 30:02 – I know someone who died, and he was very possibly in mortal sin. His wife died a few years earlier, she was a good faithful Catholic. He spoke to two different relatives probably within an hour after he had just passed and revealed to them that he was not in the same place as his wife, he said that he could not see her. Both relatives didn’t even know he had passed away, he spoke to them in their dreams with the same message. How does that happen? 34:05 – Is Father Amorth fake and/or just a product of the Satanic Panic? If he is fake, is he sincere in his beliefs or is he some type of Satanic Panic Grifter like Mike Warnke and Zachary King? In the case of Father Amorth I still believe in exorcism, but Father Amorth’s claims, and documentaries make me think that he is not a good exorcist. RESOURCE MENTIONED: http://www.canonlaw.info/a_amorth.htm 36:57 – Could a gateway to hell exist? Such as the legend of Stull, KS 40:42 – My daughter, Lauren, would like to know the history of the tradition of carving pumpkins and if it had any connection to the Catholic “All Hallows Eve” 43:16 – Is serving Candy Corn a mortal or venial sin? 44:11 – I hear demons are not able to reveal a person’s sins IF that person already went to Confession. And demons especially hate Latin. Are either true? 48:28 – Catholic Apologist Matt Fradd does a horror podcast called Sibling Horror… it can get pretty spooky. My question is, can someone listening or writing such stuff put them in any danger of even an occasion of sin since it could be entertaining thoughts and scenarios that could lead down a dark path? Or is that something that would change depending upon the inclination of the specific individual?
…
Questions Covered:
02:54 – In Wales many claim Halloween came about because of the Celtic festival of Samhain. Is this true? When did All Saints begin? Does it predate Samhain? If not are the dates coincidental? Is this a case of “if the church chooses a date, it’s always going to coincide with something somewhere in the world?” 09:05 – How would you address the deeply Catholic origins of the holiday and how those got twisted into what we have today? 13:16 – What was your favorite Halloween candy when you were a child? And what was your favorite costume? 19:45 – If I were to dress up as a Knight Templar for Halloween, putting on the habit of a knight of the order, would I be in violation of the Papal Bull Vox in Excelso, and thereby excommunicated? The bull suppressed the Order of the Temple, and specifically stated that anyone wearing the habit of the Order would be subject to laetae sentiae excommunication. 28:18 – Jimmy, I’ve got a story that happened to me that I’d love your thoughts on: I went to a Benedictine Catholic liberal arts college in the mid-west. One night, during the week of Halloween, I was up late at night, 1am, working on a Russian history paper. I was in my dorm room, working with just my lamp on, and my roommate was asleep behind me on the bottom bunk. Suddenly, I hear him sit up. So I turn and look at him, and he looks at me with a weird, distant look on his face and says “You have something dead in your school…” I assume I misheard him, so I just say, “What?” “You have something dead in your school…” he says again. “WHAT!?” “You have something dead in your school…” At this point I reason that he’s very actively sleep talking, and I say as much. “You’re talking in your sleep, man. Go back to sleep.” He looks at me with an odd half-smirk, nods, and just lays back down and falls back into sleep. I think nothing else of this and go to bed after printing off my paper. I come to find out that at that same time as this took place, around 1 am, one of the monks at the abbey had passed. So…just a coincidence? Some sort of heralding? I’d love your thoughts… 39:49 – Who’s the best Dracula? 44:50 – Which does Jimmy feel is the better TV show- Addams Family or Munsters, and why? 47:08 – Why do all the Star Wars force ghosts have to sit down when imparting lengthy advice to Luke? 47:45 – My daughter Fiona wants to know if Annabelle the doll is really possessed by a demon? 52:33 – What exactly are the differences between exorcisms and deliverances? How accurate are the depictions in movies overall; which movie/show is most accurate? Also, were any of the canonized saints ever possessed by a demon?
…
Questions Covered:
02:17 – A friend adopted two cocker spaniels that are Double Merles. These dogs are bred with the full knowledge that only one or two of the litter won’t be born blind or deaf, or both, and these will often be put down (which is why my friend adopted them). We agreed it was rather a cruel custom, but then I thought it was no different than how God created humanity in the full knowledge that many would need to be “put down” (to hell). Yes, we have free will, but He knew this would be the case and created us anyway, seems like there had to be a better way or at least no way at all. 16:05 – Do you know any good stories of persons leaving the SSPX or other schismatic organizations and returning to full communion? 17:01 – My question is: why have certain pockets of American Catholics lost their schismatic minds and Catholic Answers is silent about it. 20:12 – If or maybe when time travel becomes possible, would you want to travel back to the first Easter weekend or would you want to travel to any when in Jesus’ life apart from those last days? 22:28 – If Jesus was nailed through the wrists, why do some stigmatists have the wounds in the palms of their hands? And why do some artists put a nail in each hand and each foot, a total of 4. 32:21 – Are birthstones in the same vein as astrology? 37:27 – I’m a wishful skeptic regarding Big Foot. By “wishful skeptic” I mean, I don’t believe in Big Foot, but I wish it was real, that would be fun. What are your thoughts? Is it possible he’s real? It seems that by now we would have stumbled upon the remains of a dead Big Foot. 46:10 – What Star Trek (non-human) species are most likely to be what aliens would look like?
…
Questions Covered:
4:10 – I would like to hear a response to Professor Daniel O’Connor’s claim that aliens cannot exist according to Catholic teaching and that they must be the work of demons. 19:13 – I think a lot would like to know about whether Catholics can celebrate Halloween. 23:14 – In honor of Halloween, could you explain the common misconceptions by Protestants (and some Catholics) that Halloween is a “pagan” or “demonic” holiday? 28:41 – 1. If Halloween existed during the time of Christ, would He recommend it (trick or treat, wearing of costumes, family gatherings, etc…) to Joseph, Mary, and the apostles? 31:19 – 2. If the word “Purgatory” was explicitly mentioned by Christ in the Gospels, would all Protestants believe in it? 32:46 – I’d love to better understand “being outside of time”! 36:49 – If Adam did not take a bite of the apple Eve gave him, would there have been a fall? 41:01 – I have heard that a mass must be complete and not stop, even in an emergency. At what point must a priest not stop mass (is it during the liturgy of the Eucharist, or just specifically at the consecration, or another time)? 51:22 – What is your take on the Irresistible force paradox? What would happen if an unstoppable force encountered an unmovable object?
…
Questions Covered:
00:48 – Does the Church believe in a closed canon? 04:11 – I think you’re leaving out the important point that the Baptists claim of being able to trace their line back to Jesus is incorrect. 15:40 – Which denomination would the Catholic Church consider having valid apostolic succession? 22:33 – How can we Catholics defend the teaching of having images and them not being idols? 30:40 – In what ways could a priest help a Baptist in a situation where demonic forces could potentially be involved? 35:33 – What’s the best way to approach a protestant pastor with a large following who is spreading blatant lies about the Blessed Mother? 45:53 – My protestant brother is slowly making his way to the Catholic Church. How do I encourage him to be open to the Catholic Church? 52:06 – I’m a Protestant Freemason. Why would I not be allowed to be Catholic if I’m a Freemason?
…
Questions Covered:
05:33 – Was there an end date for Divine Revelation? 13:26 – Do you see a place for Anglicans to be in communion with Catholics without converting? 19:42 – Are saints benefiting from the beatific vision or are they waiting till the end for all of us to join in? 22:44 – What would you explain to a protestant the authority of scripture vs the authority of the Church? 35:33 – How do I explain to my sister-in-law that the Catholic Church was the first Church to be founded and not the Anabaptists? 47:06 – What is required of someone who wants to become Catholic? Why does one have to believe in everything the Church teaches and not just the essentials?
…
Questions Covered:
02:48 – Do you have to be a practicing Catholic to receive the Anointing of the Sick and the forgiveness that comes with it? 13:58 – What gave Pope John Paul II the right to add the luminous mysteries to the rosary? 19:19 – What does heaven look like? 22:59 – Can you talk about the discrepancy between the popes change on the death penalty vs the teaching of the historical Church and the Church fathers? 42:30 – I heard Tim mention the 12 sorrows of Mary on Al Kresta’s show. I missed the context of the 12 sorrows, could you expound more on this? 47:14 – How do I prove to a Jehovah’s Witness that Jesus is God using the Bible?
…
Questions Covered:
21:35 – I’m in a relationship with someone who has a daughter who thinks she’s a boy. What can I do to help? 29:54 – My daughter is struggling with gender dysphoria. She won’t talk to us anymore. Do you have any suggestions on how to help? 34:43 – My parish is rolling out the welcome mat to the transgender movement. Do you think this is a good or bad move on behalf of parishes? 43:06 – I’m a teacher and I’m corrected by my students regarding the language. When did the terminology change? What can we do about it? 49:00 – Do you think it’s more productive to argue the facts about the changes or is it better to expose the agenda? 52:24 – My brother is 50 and now lives as a woman. Being faithful to the truth, how can I better love him?
…
Questions Covered:
06:12 – Since God is above time, are we currently in heaven or hell outside time with him? 13:40 – Could you elaborate on St. Augustine’s comments and perspective on the account of Genesis? 21:03 – Can you give an explanation why a protestant who fully embraces doctrinal matters still cannot receive communion? 28:55 “Catholics leave out the real second commandment from the Old Testament” 37:20 – My protestant/anti-Catholic wife is requiring contraception in our marriage. If I don’t go along with it, there’s a possibility that she’ll seek divorce. What should I do? 45:53 – Were there 3 days that were dropped from the Gregorian calendar? Was it a correction or a miscalculation? 51:09 Before St. Paul died, he said wolves would arrive. How do we know that these wolves are not the Church Fathers?
…
Questions Covered:
02:50 – Is there salvation outside of the Church? 07:02 – When the priest says, “please accept my offering… yours and mine” What offering am I supposed to offer at that time? 14:36 – I’ve had priests tell me that interracial marriages aren’t valid. Is this true? 16:10 – I’m Hispanic and married a white woman. My grandmother is racist against white people. Would I commit a mortal sin if I choose not to associate with her? 18:14 – Could you give me advice on courtship and compatibility? How will I know when I’m called to marry a person? 22:38 – Are the Son and Holy Spirit subordinate to the Father? 29:11 – What is the best way to start a community in a Church? 35:50 – Did Jesus consume the bread and wine during the last supper? 42:34 – How do I respond to the question: Did God just create us to follow his rules and earn a reward at the end? 49:53 – Why is my Lutheran wife not able to receive communion in the Catholic Church? Can I share the host with her when I get back to my pew?
…
Questions Covered:
20:20 – I’ve learned that you’ll fall in love more with your spouse as the time goes on. Is there anything in scripture that speaks about this? 22:40 – My husband and I love each other but are not in love with each other and our marriage is deteriorating. What should I do? 33:38 – Do you have any insight on when the Church started to recognize marriage as a sacrament? 36:00 – My daughter’s husband just asked for divorce. How do I help her especially since they have a very young child? 48:04 – Is it proper to say, “you should always treat your spouse like before you were married” or is that too simplistic?
…
Questions Covered:
11:38 – When did “Divine Right” start? Why didn’t the pope say that Henry 8th did not have a divine right? 17:06 – What is responsible parenthood according to Catholics? How does a good Catholic decide when they should no longer have kids and how they should space kids? 22:48 – Did Vatican 2 really say that we should take all the relics out of the altars? 24:28 – Jimmy what are your general thoughts on Vatican 2? 32:15 – Is God the Father the boss of the Holy Trinity? 36:08 – How do I balance ministry with personal life and prayer life? 44:04 – Why do Catholics think Mary is the ark of the new covenant? 48:30 – Why were women not allowed in the temple when they were menstruating during Old Testament times?
…
Questions Covered:
11:39 – What are the signs of demonic possession? 15:50 – How Can I discern what is an appropriate tithe? I’m currently a college student and I don’t know if it’s enough? 21:26 – How does the church view special needs children especially when considering converting? How does mental disability play into having to properly understand the Church’s teachings? 28:43 – How was Vatican 2 taken so out of context that they ended up almost taking all of the Latin out of the mass? 35:25 – Why is the Vatican located in Rome? Is there a reason why it was in Rome especially since the Roman Empire was the ones who ordered the execution of Jesus? 46:57 – Is there any data on what fruits came out of Vatican 2?
…
Questions Covered:
20:30 – How can a Catholic be as effective in evangelizing as Protestant preachers, but in a more “down-to-earth” and less “in-your-face” manner? 29:22 – Did the Atheist you’re mentoring come to you looking for a discipleship relationship, or at what point did it turn into one and how did that happen? 34:16 – I had a gentleman approach me and hand me a pamphlet by Mike Gendron that’s aimed at disproving the Roman Catholic Church. How can I speak with this man about what he’s trying to disprove about Catholicism? 41:58 – I’m helping a guy out with discipleship and the way he encounters God is different to my way. I’m more intellectual and he’s more feeling based. How can I get to his level and help him in a way I’m not familiar with?
…
Questions Covered:
15:33 – I’ve heard people say that Abraham knew that he wouldn’t have to actually sacrifice his son because he said, “wait here, we’ll be back”. What do you think about this? 29:23 – What happened with Abraham’s other son? 41:20 – Did Abraham know God to be a trinity, or did he know God to just be one person, the Father? 45:48 – Follow up on the conversion earlier – Do you typically call the elder generation “brethren”? 50:54 – Did Abraham have/receive the Holy Spirit?
…
Questions Covered:
02:44 – Can St. Padre Pio still give absolution? 06:07 – If a faithful Catholic couple who are not yet married (but want to be) were able to find each other, or happened to already be spending time together, during a cyberattack or catastrophic natural disaster that ended modern society as we know it, how would they go about getting married? If they had no way to find a priest, would they just have to wander around the wasteland until they found one? Or could they make their vows in the presence of whatever witnesses they could find? 10:40 – In Psalm 139 in the New American Bible, it says ‘If I ascend to the heavens, you are there; if I lie down in Sheol, you are there too.’ [Psalms 139:8] So, what exactly is Sheol? 21:18 – I heard a priest created a machine allowing him to see the events of the Crucifixion as they happened. Then the Vatican excommunicated him. Is this a true-ish story? 22:43 – Speaking in tongues and resting in the spirit—are they always legit or are they sometimes psychological? 31:20 – Mystics who claim to live without food for years. There are a few in the Catholic tradition but there are also claims of Prahlad Jani, an Indian Hindu. Is it demonic or a hoax? 45:21 – If they were still around, which human relatives (homo neanderthalensis, homo erectus, homo floresiensis, homo denisova, etc) would we likely be able to baptize if they were so inclined to be received by Christ and His Church?
…
Questions Covered:
19:15 – What advice would you give to a couple if one person doesn’t want intimacy and the other is depressed/despaired? How does one stay faithful in that regard? 24:22 – If someone was baptized Catholic, fell away from the church, and then got married in a protestant ceremony, is that marriage valid? 31:05 – My wife of 2 years and I went through marriage prep and married in the Catholic church, but she is 18 years older and her tubes are tied. I know I can’t be fruitful in having children, but can I be so in a different way? 34:45 – My parents, in their will, indicated their money would go to their children, and if the child passed, it’d go to the spouse and grandchildren. It is now my husband and I’s will to go to the spouse and children. Is it wrong to split up the money rather than giving it all to the spouse? 38:59 – My wife, before deciding to get married, decided to come to the Catholic faith. We were not married in the Catholic Church. She has now decided not to become Catholic. Is our marriage valid and/or lawful? 43:01 – I was born into a Catholic family but never really practiced. When I was 40, I married a woman in a courthouse who was married 3 times before. We were together for 6 months and split up. I just returned to the Church in March of last year. What is my standing in the Catholic Church? 46:36 – I was born and raised Catholic, was married to my ex-husband and we share 3 kids. He had an affair and I’ve been with my fiancé now for 12 years. He’s Baptist and said I don’t need an annulment and we can just get married in the Baptist church. I don’t want to go against the Catholic church so what do I need to do? 52:25 – I am widowed for 2.5 years after 30+ year marriage. I’ve just started dipping my toes into the dating scene, however, I feel like I’m paralyzed. Can you please give me some advice?
…
Questions Covered:
10:50 – Do church authorities, the Popes and Bishops, synthesize the sources of our tradition or use tradition as guidelines when making authoritarian teachings? 22:38 – My priest only provides the host and not wine. Is that appropriate? 33:50 – I have heard that we can venerate statues of Saints, but not pray to them. Can I pray to a statue of Jesus? 40:29 – In the past I heard if you watch the Mass that you will not receive a blessing. Why wouldn’t I receive a blessing if I participated in the Mass? 45:13 – Jesus gives thanks to his Father for giving him disciples except Judas who he called a devil. How can Satan tempt a devil, Judas? 47:14 – I read information on a living icon in a Byzantine Church. Can you explain this description? 50:41 – I heard a response to school shootings is that God is no longer present in schools. Is this a reasonable response?
…
Questions Covered:
03:26 – When Jesus asked Peter, do you love me 3 times, the Greek translates each differently. Is this also true in Aramaic? 07:00 – What advise can you provide for having a conversation with an Eastern Orthodox Priest belonging to Antiochene tradition on the role of the Pope? 10:49 – Does God have any part in sending people to Hell? 20:26 – Does Catholic mysticism have anything to do with Pantheism? 29:10 – Do you have any tips on how to deal with scrupulosity? 34:33 – In the bible, I have heard that Paul didn’t confront Peter, but a man named Cephas. Does this idea have any merit? 40:24 – Is the Sedevacantism movement considered a cult? 46:30 – Why does God choose circumcision as a sign of the old covenant? 51:16 – Can you explain the different accounts of Jesus’s sharing of the two great commandments?
…
Questions Covered:
07:56 – Considering Jesus’ acceptance of prostitutes, thieves, tax-collectors, etc., why is someone’s “transgender status” an issue for Catholics? It doesn’t impact my Catholic faith or my following of Church teaching/Christ. Why can’t we just accept them? 37:30 – When I was younger, I dealt with gender dysphoria and I’m grateful the surgeries there are now weren’t available back then. It would have greatly changed my life for the worse. 44:30 – I have a son in law that has recently come out as “transgender feminine”. What would you suggest is the best way to deal with this situation with him? 49:15 – Some of this stuff with transgenderism seems totalitarian. People that agree with it seem to have the last word and are really harsh about voicing their views.
…
Questions Covered:
16:37 – When is the proper time to take kids at mass to the back and the right time to let it go and stay in the pews? Is there a right or wrong way to approach this? 29:50 – Are there any Catholic educational programs for children outside of school? My kids go to public school, but it seems like there’s so much for Protestants and not much for Catholics. 47:49 – How do I draw my adult children, who have all fallen away from the church, and my husband, who has always been protestant, to the Church? 49:00 – What activities and formation would you recommend for children under the age of 5 to teach them about the faith outside of daily prayer and mass?
…
Questions Covered:
18:03 – What should we say to young women who are forced to have an abortion? 24:03 – I’m not Catholic, my wife left me and returned pregnant. I raised the child as my own and became pro-life because of that. 29:10 – How do I talk to women who have had abortions who refuse to even consider any argument? 35:00 – How do I answer the following two objections: 1. The fetus is not a person. 2. You’re a hypocrite because you’re not adopting. 42:01 – Why do people refer to the unborn child as an it? 46:59 – I had an abortion and it left a scar on my soul, and I never want anyone to go through that.
…
Questions Covered:
08:13 – How do you respond to a pro-choicer that answers the question “what are the unborn?” correctly but persists in the pro-choice side? 14:43 – How do I talk to young girls about being pro-life? 18:30 – What are we to do about states that are now denying medication because lawmakers aren’t looking at the details of the law since Dobbs? 28:48 – What would you say to someone who says they’re “not pro-murdering babies, but pro-women in tough pregnancies who don’t have a choice?” 33:31 – How do we approach a situation if the priest at our parish doesn’t have the same intensity to tackle this issue? 36:09 – How do you respond to someone that says if they had been aborted the world would not have changed? 42:54 – Can a baby feel pain weeks after 20 weeks? Is this a typo in the book? 46:53 – Why do we never address the fathers of aborted children? 49:00 – Cardinal Arinze stated that the life in the womb belongs to someone else. We are meant to bring forward children in life.
…
Questions Covered:
03:36 – I’m a minister at a protestant denomination and have hang ups on the Marian dogmas. 19:04 – I’m not Catholic because I’ve never had someone give me a good response for the persecution of Jews and protestants during the inquisition. 33:50 – How do the saints listen to our prayers if they’re dead? 43:25 – I’m not Catholic yet, I don’t fully understand Mary’s role as co-redemptrix. 48:36 – I’m not Catholic because I wasn’t evangelized.
…
Questions Covered:
06:07 – I’m was raised Catholic and now I go to a non-denominational church. I still call myself Catholic but need some convincing to go back to a Catholic Church. I’m happy at my non-denominational church. 13:49 – I grew up Methodist and not Catholic because this is how I grew up. 22:57 – I’m not Catholic because praying to saints sounds like idolatry. Also, why are there so many religions? 33:52 – I’m not Catholic because there seems to be more requirements. At least as a Christian I know I’m saved. 41:47 – I’m Orthodox, I don’t see the Papacy as the Catholics do. The Christians of the first millennium were Orthodox.
…
Questions Covered:
5:00 – Is it possible to get Catholic politicians who are not faithful to be excommunicated? 15:11 – What happens to the soul of a baby who was miscarried? 19:15 – How does a potentially new Catholic make sense of the art that the synod official page just posted? 29:38 – What is your opinion of the current state of affairs in the leadership of the Church and the perceived suppression of the Latin mass and Latin language in general? 37:21 – I’ve noticed that Catholics have a very hard time on the communal aspect. Communal events don’t really happen anymore. What are your thoughts on this? 48:41 – How do we correct boys in public concerning manners and acting in a morally upright way without being too harsh?
…
Questions Covered:
01:23 – I’ve heard an argument from Protestants that Mary did have original sin because it was transferred through the male parent. This would solve the issue of Jesus being associated with sin. How do I respond? 06:19 -Where do near death experiences fall into the Church’s understanding of the afterlife? 13:49 – What empire treated the Israelites best in the Old Testament? 17:55 – How do I reconcile the violence in the Old Testament compared to what Jesus taught in the New Testament? 28:58 – Does the prophecy in Daniel 7 prove that the Catholic Church is going to mislead the world? 36:30 – How do you respond to someone who claims that scripture supports or condones slavery? 44:04 – Could a non-Christians receive absolution in a case of emergency? 49:55 – Where did the people that died before the coming of Jesus go? 52:13 – I’m interested in going to a bible school. Are there any Catholic bible schools or should I pursue a Christian bible school? 53:46 – Are Anglican prayer beads and prayer ropes permissible to be prayed as a Catholic? What are your general thoughts on them?
…
Questions Covered:
03:12 – How do the motives of credibility prove the cause of miracles are of an omnipotent being as opposed to a being with sufficient power to cause the miracles? 08:38 – When patients stop taking food orally, are we obligated to start IVs for nutrition? 16:55 – How do I respond to a friend who says we no longer need to use a crucifix since Jesus is no longer on the cross? 22:11 – How do you interpret 1 Cor. 15:50? How do you reconcile this with the resurrection of Jesus? 28:47 – Why did God allow war in heaven during the fall of the angels? 42:59 – How do you justify not believing in justification by faith alone specifically regarding Romans 6:1-7? 47:56 – Do college fraternities and sororities fall under the category of secret societies?
…
Questions Covered:
24:13 – Do you see that seeing scripture as sola scriptura made the pendulum swing in the opposite direction today saying that scripture is unreliable and biased? https://www.catholic.com/magazine/online-edition/slavery-homosexuality-and-sola-scriptura 31:46 – I disagree with the idea sola scriptura are what cause racism and slavery. The Spanish Catholics encouraged lack slaves in the Caribbean. What are your thoughts? 47:44 – What’s the Eastern Orthodox response to slavery?
…
Questions Covered:
12:34 – How can the Catholic Church claim to be united when Byzantines are allowed to venerate saints that are only recognized in Orthodoxy? 18:06 – What are your thoughts on the east and west finally being united? Is there a chance to reconcile with the Russian Orthodox Church? 23:29 – Shouldn’t the form of the Eucharist be important for unity? Shouldn’t Catholics use a loaf instead of an individual host to symbolize unity? 29:47 – Shouldn’t the emphasis be on unity instead of governance style and organization? 36:55 – It’s my opinion that if we unite on the date that we celebrate Easter we will usher in unity. What are your thoughts on that? 42:45 – If I decide to go to confession to an orthodox priest, would it be accepted as normal in the Catholic Church? 46:20 – Is there a particular reason why the Latin won’t use the three-bar crucifix? 48:02 – Why is there a large difference amongst the Orthodox churches on Purgatory? 50:41 – Our true unity doesn’t come for the loaf but unity of Christ. 51:58 – Did Catholics and Orthodox share saints after the schism?
…
Questions Covered:
05:29 – How do I explain Mary to my Baptist friends? 13:50 – What’s the rule for the laity on folding hands and placement of hands during Mass? 15:20 – Is it necessary to go to confession before going to communion? 20:30 – Are chastisements part of Church teaching or just folk Catholicism? 28:35 – I’m Protestant. What’s your interpretation of Gal. 1:8-9 especially in light of the Marian dogmas as a necessity to become Catholic? 42:00 – Does keeping holy the sabbath apply to both Jews and non-believers? 46:44 – Did the English take up a different accent after the American revolution to distinguish themselves apart from Americans? 50:41 – Could you expound on your comment on lying that you mentioned at the conference?
…
Questions Covered:
04:27 – What is the Catholic teaching on dispensationalism compared to covenant theology? 15:36 – How does the universe expand faster than the speed of light? 20:38 – What kind of kinship did St. Elizabeth have with Mary? Was she actually her cousin? 22:47 – When is a saint incorruptible? Are there different levels of incorruptibility? 25:07 – In order for evolution to be true, the genome size of all life forms needs to be increasing. Has this been observed? If so, what is this process called? 33:50 – My diocese is not offering the chalice for communion. Is this just a diocesan rule or is it a universal rule? When will this be lifted? 40:18 – There’s a couple at my parish that use contraception and are also extraordinary ministers of holy communion. When I approached the priest, he had no issue with it. What does the Church officially say about this? 42:17 – I’m a catechist. How do I explain clearly to the girls that women can’t be priests? 45:09 – How does the Church declare someone a venerable, especially considering that now we have so much information on people? 48:30 – What are your thoughts on a current priest who claims that he communicates with angels and the deceased?
…
Emmaus Road Press is the publishing arm of St. Paul Center for Biblical Theology Questions Covered:
28:59 – Should I join the Catholic Church or stay in a protestant church that has a good strong loving community? 35:12 – Why did Jesus have to die on the cross? 48:39 – Why did Jesus cry? How does this fit into our understanding of who he is?
…
Questions Covered:
06:34 – I’m a brand new Catholic but I’ve had sacraments in the Orthodox Church, how do I make them recognized in the west? 14:37 – Is it wrong to use the names of pagan gods in stories or to name your children? 20:38 – Where’s the line with passion kissing before marriage? 29:35 – I haven’t been going to Mass because of my disability. Should I not receive communion when I do go because I don’t go consistently? 34:48 – Does mortal sin affect a priest’s ordination? Would an unconfessed mortal sin invalidate their ordination? 42:27 – I’m in my 50’s and I want to get married. Do I have to be open to life at this age? 48:54 – Why is it ok for popes to worship with other religions? 52:45 – Did the pope have the authority to add the filioque to the creed much later after the council?
…
Questions Covered:
08:31 – When did the Early church start doing the sign of the cross and why do Eastern Christians do it backwards? 13:01 – How much participation can a Catholic have in civil unions? 15:02 – Do we portray the pope as more than the Vicar of Christ by calling him holy father? 16:46 – How do you explain to someone the purpose of Canon law? 19:53 – What is necessary to receive communion? 29:20 – I heard at the conference that it is not God who enters into us but we who enter into God . Can you help me understand this better 32:15 – The Church didn’t allow cremation for the longest time but allowed saint relics to be separated. Are these t2 circumstances different? 37:03 – How grave sin is it when a divorced and remarried catholic continues to receive communion? 45:27 – Since Covid, we now only receive the host and not from the chalice. Does it change anything now that we can only receive the host? 47:24 – What would be your guidance and advice to help a young boy to become a man? 51:25 – What are your thoughts on bringing communion rails back?
…
Questions Covered:
05:15 – If a man commits a murder and never repented or confessed it and became a priest. Would his ordination be valid 08:10 – How important is the sign of peace during the mass? I heard some say it’s a distraction. 13:14 – How do I encourage people to attend mass after people got used to watching it online? 18:39 – What does the Eucharist mean to Catholics? 29:23 – Is it an abuse of the mass when the priest Extraordinary ministers of holy communion for communion when they are not needed? 30:48 – Why doesn’t the Church advertise the Eucharistic miracles from around the world to highlight the true presence? 32:45 – Is Jesus fully present in the Eucharistic miracles such as Lanciano? 33:22 – I have Jewish friends who were considering converting to Catholicism, but they worry about comments from Catholics that Jews killed Jesus. How do I help them to overcome these hurdles? 39:30 – Is the sacrament of the Eucharist still valid if the host is not made with the correct recipe? 41:46 – What would be some ways to talk to protestant family members who have some understanding about the Eucharist who think they can receive communion at Catholic Churches? 43:51 – I showed a friend a painting of the battle of Lepanto and they noticed that Mary was in a more prominent place over Jesus. Why is there a bigger emphasis on Mary? 48:49 – Could the validity of a consecration be questioned if the priest proceeded to place the host in envelopes for the faithful to pick up? 50:35 – How do I explain to my non-Catholic family that non-Catholics can’t receive communion? 53:21 – Can you receive communion if you’re late to mass? If so, how late?
…
Questions Covered:
03:01 – The Synod claims the Church is unwelcoming because of rules and regulations. Do you see this as an issue? 23:11 – How do I respond to my friend who says she doesn’t believe in structured prayer? 34:13 – How do we address the continuation of the magisterium in light of previous schism and perhaps Germany? 43:14 – How does fasting and mortification enhance prayer? 51:14 – Is it incorrect to say that Jesus is physically present in the Eucharist?
…
Questions Covered:
03:08 – If God forgets our sins, what happens in the final judgment when our sins are revealed? 08:00 – My son entered in a same sex union, how do I deal with this in the family dynamic especially when some celebrate it and other reject it? 15:08 – How do we as the extended family deal with a same sex family member 19:09 – How do you discount the theory of the bible alone in a nice way? 23:10 – If God doesn’t change his mind, what’s the purpose of prayer? 34:41 – Is the holy eucharist a prerequisite for entrance to heaven? 36:45 – When God uses singular pronouns in the Old Testament, is it safe to assume that He’s referring to the Father alone? 42:55 – When does transubstantiation occur during the mass? 47:16 – How efficacious are the sacraments celebrated by bad clergy?
…
Questions Covered:
06:50 – Are you conscious of other people that are in purgatory with you? 12:14 – Am I supposed to take stories like Paradise Lost and Dante’s Divine Comedy literally? 17:30 – I know there are demons in hell and on earth. How do you overcome the temptations of demons? 28:50 – When people go to heaven, does it look like earth? 41:47 – Wouldn’t only using one scripture verse be shaky ground for explaining purgatory? 51:30 – Can you talk about visions of hell?
…
Questions Covered:
02:10 – Gavin Newsom and promoting abortion across state lines. https://www.catholic.com/prolife 21:05 – Does the bible teach that few people go to heaven? Referencing the road to hell is wide and the road to heaven is narrow. https://www.firstthings.com/article/2003/05/the-population-of-hell 28:49 – Why don’t we do away with euphemisms and water down hell? 34:42 – Will perpetual mortal sins like addictions get you into hell? 48:26 – What can I do for a person who was killed 100 years ago? Can I still pray for them?
…
Questions Covered:
06:29 – What happens after we die? What’s the Church’s teaching on a new earth? 13:40 – Does the SSPX have authority to bless items such as miraculous medals? 18:11 – Why don’t all Catholic churches have the tabernacle at the center of the sanctuary, or in the sanctuary at all? 23:45 – Is not being in the state of mortal sin the only qualification to go to heaven? What’s necessary for something to be considered a mortal sin? 35:45 – Why were only men circumcised in Old Testament times? What rite was there for women to be initiated into the chosen people? 43:24 – Will unbaptized babies who are in limbo be allowed into heaven after the resurrection? 48:00 – How did the words get written in scripture in the cases where Jesus was alone, and nothing was said 51:16 – Jn 14:12 How can Jesus be present in the Eucharist if he sent the Holy Spirit after he left? Would he have to be no longer around?
…
Questions Covered:
03:23 – When the church’s dicastery has approved all miracles and is ready to be declared a saint, how do they decide what they will be the patron saint of? 09:30 – Does one spouse receive grace from the other spouses’ works? 14:54 – Where is purgatory in the bible? How do I better explain purgatory to my protestant friend? 23:02 – Would there be a sacramental characteristic that will be visible to us in the next life? Would the 3 levels of holy orders be visible? 24:52 – When Paul was headed to trial before Caesar, would it really have been before CAESAR HIMSELF or just a magistrate, or appointee who heard cases? 33:46 – Why do Catholics collect pieces of the saint’s body? 37:06 – Was Joan of Arc schizophrenic? 47:58 – What was the purpose of the Transfiguration? 53:30 – What is a novena? Is it a specific type of prayer?
…
Questions Covered:
08:42 – How do we know that the Holy Spirit inspired the books of the bible? 13:52 – I grew up protestant and divorced because of abuse. I remarried and now want to know what step I would have to take to enter into the Catholic Church? 21:32 – Are godparents by proxy still a thing? 24:35 – Why have the German bishops who have been preaching heresy never been excommunicated? 32:29 – Can Abortion be forgiven by a priest? 34:50 – The visiting priest at my parish changed the wording during the consecration. Was it a valid consecration? 40:19 – What does it take to become a priest? I’ve been feeling a call. 44:05 – If you are a Catholic priest, how are you married? 48:00 – How should I handle my relationship with my cousin who’s living with a divorced woman? 51:52 – At my parish the priest has asked us to wait till he has processed down the aisle before we can pray the St. Michael prayer. Is this a common practice?
…
Questions Covered:
12:37 – What’s the difference between Catholics and Eastern Orthodoxy? 17:26 – Does the pope have the authority to order the bishops to celebrate the Tridentine Mass? 29:33 – How can you explain violent acts that the church used to get rid of people who opposed it? 34:23 – When did the Church start instituting daily mass? 37:47 – What does the Catholic Church think about the traditions of other religions? 43:50 – Could you give me your thoughts on my understanding of tradition based on the family and its basis and its importance to culture? 50:16 – Is the communion fast biblical?
…
Questions Covered:
03:30 – German Synod. 42:00 – Pray for Nicaragua and the Queen 47:35 – A really interesting article on the collapse of Catholic practice in 1965 https://www.catholicworldreport.com/2022/09/13/anatomist-of-the-catholic-collapse-in-france-and-beyond/
…
Questions Covered:
5:30 – Shia LaBeouf and New Catholics 22:10 – How to talk to your children about abortion from National Public Radio
…
Questions Covered:
04:15 – Is it moral to eat meat from factory farms 08:52 – Is there a logical inconsistency of NFP with other methods of contraception? 15:10 – Was the Church involved in killing of the reformers such as Jan Hus? 24:36 – My non-Catholic friend said that it’s wrong for the Church to deny communion to non-Catholics because not even Jesus denied communion to Judas. Is that a good argument? What’s a good response to this? 38:29 – What’s the reason we go to Mass? 47:26 – How can I be a good Catholic teacher in a secular school? 50:25 – Why did the Church treat Copernicus and Galileo differently?
…
Questions Covered:
22:14 – I found out a Catholic family member has an IUD. She said a priest told her it’s ok to use it to maintain her mental health. What can I do to guide her? 29:15 – Genesis explains that gender and day and night are binary. The opposition claims that since day and night are not actually binary because we have a sunrise and a sunset, this disproves that Genesis really doesn’t support a binary gender either. How do I respond to that argument? 34:22 – Do you have any thoughts on Stephen Fry’s debate on putting the Church on trial for being sex obsessed? 41:51 – Do people need to start focusing on preaching and education on sexual ethics in order to bring it to light. What are your thoughts? 47:42 – Is there hope for our culture to turn around?
…
Questions covered:
05:30 – Could you help to respond to the claim that the inquisition was just a form of secret police hunting people down 15:29 – Is there a gentile perspective and Jewish perspective of salvation? Do Catholics and protestant have different perspectives? 24:50 – The Catholics, Orthodox, and Protestants all have different church services. What makes the Catholic stand out from the others? 33:28 – Who or what is Gog and Magog mentioned in Rev. 20:8? 38:11 – Could you lay out the Catholic belief of the one sacrifice as mentioned in Hebrews 9-10? Why is the Catholic view right and not the protestant one? 49:15 – I’m a divorced and remarried protestant. I’m drawn to the Catholic Church but how can I come to the Church with my current situation?
…
Questions Covered:
04:13 – Why is the church very conservative when it comes to sexual teaching compared to protestant churches? 13:18 – How can Catholicism be true if the Church forbade Jewish Christians from keeping practices? 22:48 – How can you declare someone a saint? What do they have to do? Wouldn’t that imply that there’s a checklist they have to fulfill? 34:06 – If a Catholic were to adhere to the teachings of the Church but were to find out on the last day that the Church was wrong, do they get a “get out of jail free card” because we were just being obedient? 42:34 – What do I need to accept regarding Mary becoming Catholic? 43:59 – Why does everyone use a different translation of the bible? 47:28 – Why do Catholics claim to be the one true Church?
…
Questions Covered:
03:23 – How do we know when it is wrong to use medical drugs that affect brain chemistry? 09:07 – How do I respond to my Pentecostal friends’ challenge on what the Catholic church’s plan for salvation is? 10:44 – Do we Catholics believe in things like fairies and other things heard in fairy tales? 15:03 – Jesus says we do not have life in us if we do not consume the eucharist (Jn. 6). Would not Jesus’ words trump St. Paul’s words in 1 Corinth. 11? 22:00 – What’s the proper devotion to the scapular and what are its origins? 23:43 – Would God create people who He knows are going to hell only because that person would have offspring that would be saved? 32:20 – When venerating saints, is there a line that would cross us into necromancy? 39:52 – Is Zechariah 14:9 evidence for the validity of baptism in the name of Jesus instead of the Trinitarian formula? 41:54 – Are we supposed to baptize people in the name of Jehovah and Jesus since Jesus said we are supposed to baptize “In the name of?” 47:10 – How do we interpret St. Paul’s exhortation on obeying our rulers? 49:20 – It sounds like Mt. 13:20-21 and Mark 10:15 are at odds. Could you help clarify? 52:10 – Why does the Church accept Vatican 2 if it sounds like it contradicts Vatican 1 and other things the Church has taught?
…
Questions Covered:
02:42 – Does the Church consider the Greek language scripture and inspired scripture or only the original Aramaic? 12:33 – In Sacrosanctum Concilium 36 it says that Latin needs to be preserved in the mass. Why hasn’t it been preserved? 21:17 – Who made the decision to change the word during the distribution of holy communion? What is the proper way of disposing of fragments and crumbs of the Eucharist? 29:26 – How do I balance my faith life and my life living in the world? 39:54 – What does the Church base its teaching on no premarital relations? 45:52 – Why don’t we have a specific name for God? 50:11 – Why was the mass changed from Latin to the vernacular?
…
Questions Covered:
00:56 Is biblical Hebrew different from the Hebrew spoken today? If so, how different are they? 9:50 – How did God make Satan a snake in the garden of Eden? 10:42 – I’m not Catholic. Do Romans 8 and 1 Timothy 2:4 contradict about predestination? 19:02 – Is there a significance in the name changes in the bible and why they are sometimes used interchangeably? 27:57 – Matthew 24:29-31 Could you give me more information on the illumination of conscience? 43:30 – What was the first angel? 46:15 – Lev. 5. When in the bible did, they become aware that they stopped practicing the jubilee? 50:10 – What are the biblical teachings on tribulation, millennium and the final judgment? Does the Catechism say anything about these?
…
Questions Covered:
03:34 – If saving faith can happen by calling out to the name of the Lord prior to baptism, is baptism just a substitute? 11:27 – Revelation says that the Euphrates River would dry up at the end times. It’s drying up now. Is this a warning sign? 19:50 – There’s a verse in the Old Testament that supports putting to death false prophets, witches, etc. Was this the reason they did that in the Middle Ages and what’s the church’s official teaching? 24:54 – Why would the Lord regret something He did? 33:47 – Is it likely that Joseph would have sped up his engagement process? Was she under reproach after the birth of Jesus? 44:40 – Mark 11:22-24 If we really believe in something are we really going to have? 51:38 – How did David offer sacrifice if it says that only members of Aaron’s family were allowed to offer sacrifice?
…
Questions Covered:
03:14 – Could you give me a brief summary on how the mass came to be? 12:18 – What made you become Catholic instead of Orthodox? 18:46 – How do you properly consecrate yourself to Jesus and Mary? 23:54 – I sometimes have a hard time understanding because of the thick accent. I heard that you have to understand certain things he said that the priest said to receive communion. Is this true? 31:56 – Do priests have training to help people from other religions to figure out why they should convert to Catholicism over other religions? 42:37 – I’m Orthodox. What was your timeframe when you were considering Catholicism vs Orthodoxy? What has been your development of ideas since converting regarding the national ties to Orthodoxy compared to the historical national ties in Catholicism? 50:33 – Why are celibate gay men allowed into the priesthood?
…
Questions Covered:
20:59 – What gives the German bishops the authority to do what they’re doing? If they don’t have authority why doesn’t the pope reprimand them? 23:29 – What are your thoughts on establishing a Catholic monarchy? 30:06 – This disunity is what’s keeping me from being Catholic. How should I approach this? 34:16 – I know there’s a pope who, when he was elected, immediately got rid of the bishops and appointed new ones. Do you happen to know who this pope was? 45:35 – Is it fair to make a comparison of the surveys the protestant churches sent out to the survey the bishops sent out for this synod? 50:54 – Is there a similar disparity within the German bishops as to the US bishops?
…
Questions Covered:
01:55 – How much of a hand does God have in our suffering? 08:04 – Why does Jesus refer to himself as “son of man?” 15:12 – What did Jesus mean when He said “the end of the age” in Matthew 24:3? 23:58 – What criteria did the Church use to choose which book is canonical and which is not? 37:15 – Is it valid to think that souls of those who only had a baptism of desire can enter purgatory? 42:01 – When did the apostles begin believing in the Trinity? 48:50 – Why did some songs change from using the name Yahweh to God? 52:30 – Did the Jews believe that the soul is mortal?
…
Questions Covered:
06:15 – Why do Catholics pray to the saints and Mary? 15:10 – Was St. Ann cleansed of original sin because of her conceiving of Mary? 19:12 – Will we be able to teleport to other planets in our resurrected bodies? 24:07 – A Oneness Pentecostal argued that the saints praying for us places a burden on them and that’s why it’s impossible for them to pray for us. How do I respond? 33:52 – Is there any explanation on the sinless Mary that is biblically founded? I’d love to hear concretely why we can assume she’s free of sin. 39:42 – What power does Mary have as intercessor? 46:00 – What are your thoughts on astral spiders? Are they demons or of a demonic nature? 52:03 – I heard a prophecy that said that once Queen Elizabeth died, Jesus would return. Is this true? What are your thoughts on this prophecy?
…
Questions Covered:
03:46 – Is it appropriate for a Catholic to use the practice of accessing your inner child by using your non-dominant hand to write with? 10:37 – My dad is very close to converting to Catholicism. His wife is more hesitant, do you know any books in Chinese that I could give her? 14:00 – Why doesn’t the Church come out and say marijuana isn’t an intrinsic evil and actually has good potential for medical use? 21:42 – What would happen is a mega church pastor converted to Catholicism, would he be able to be ordained as a priest? 31:57 – What is the Catholic interpretation of Hebrews 6:4-6? 41:36 – My catechism book says that if you feel guilty for a sin that you have already been forgiven for, that you should still confess it. Is this true? 46:57 – Is it alright to ask Jesus to pray for you? 52:50 – What’s the proper term for a person who received all the sacraments but didn’t live it out until 20 years after being away from the Church?
…
Questions Covered:
03:40 – Would you like to continue our Socratic dialogue on the argument from cosmology? 18:03 – Why do we have and need godparents for sacraments? 20:58 – Why do some translations have “blessed are you among women” in the story of the Annunciation but not in others? 24:06 – Can you compare the Catholic and Protestant understanding of 1 Corinth. 11? Was there both a feast and a liturgy? 32:00 – How do we talk to Protestants about the Deuterocanon? 41:34 – Why doesn’t the Church include the Didache and Clement’s letter to the Corinthians into the canon of scripture? 44:43 – What is sanctifying Grace? How do we get it? Did Jesus need it and how did He get it? 48:35 – Why did the translation change from “forgive us our debts” to “forgive us our trespasses?” 51:39 – Is it proper to take pictures of the Eucharist in the monstrance?
…
Questions Covered:
04:55 – How does the annulment process work? If the process is approved, what does that imply? 14:30 – If I stand in line for confession but it ends, am I still able to receive communion even though I didn’t get to go to confession? 17:59 – Since Jesus is the only path to salvation, how is it possible to pray to Mary? Is it somewhere in the bible? 28:34 – Is there still purgatory after the final judgment? 33:09 – What is a lukewarm soul? 39:50 – Are you allowed to get married after your ex-wife dies? And if you remarry, can you receive communion? 43:33 – 1 Jn 3:6 My friends use this passage as evidence for once saved always saved. How do I respond? 48:50 – Is it likely that Joseph moved up the “engagement phase” with Mary? If Mary and Joseph had had marital relations during the betrothal, would it have been a stonable offense?
…
Questions Covered:
02:45 – Where’s the line for fraternal correction for a pope? 11:48 – Is increase in merit necessary to enter into heaven? 22:56 – One of my favorite saints is Padre Pio but I struggle with his severity in the confessional. How do we square his approach with our current approach of mercy? 35:19 – 1. Corinth 6:1-11 Why did the Church change the wording of Paul from condemning homosexuality to condemning boy prostitutes? 46:30 – Acts 2:41 Does it conflict with Peter’s promise that baptism will be for our children? 52:10 – Is it ok to attend a re-baptism of a friend or family member in a protestant church?
…
Questions Covered:
01:38 – A family member with dementia has me thinking a lot about this: Say you’re Catholic and maybe haven’t been the most charitable or loving, but you do your basic duty of Mass and Confession. Dementia creeps up–either slowly or quickly–and you get to the point where you don’t know what day it is, much less is able to make an examination of conscience for confession. I just wonder about the state of the soul that can’t improve or offer things up. I know you’re not responsible for your actions if you’re not in your right mind, but do you think they can gain any merit just for the trial of what they’re going through? 05:37 – Any thoughts/ideas about when the Great Pyramid was built? Some say 4000 BC, but others claim 10,000 BC is more like it, even pre-flood, where its air shaft would then point to a different Star. 16:36 – What’s the best way to talk to people who just don’t see anything good about what the church teaches? 18:17 – I have been in a few debates about “limbo.” Does it exist? And do un-baptized children go there? So many different thoughts on this from many different theologians 21:44 – Is the Latin Mass evil, good, or wonderful, and why does Francis hate it so much? 24:00 – How would you answer Atheist regard the problem of “unresistant unbelief”? If a fellow says he wants to believe in God and be a Christian (as one famous Atheist YouTuber said recently), but just needs some confirming sign to push him over the hump, what explanation can we give for why God refrains from doing so? Or is there some other reply? 28:26 – How is it possible that when a semi-trailer is carrying a bunch of honeybee hives, a honeybee can fly outside of the hive and just hover right there while the truck is moving 75 miles an hour and the honeybee doesn’t get left behind? This blows my mind lol I need Jimmy’s help 33:18 – I know it is illicit for someone like a grandparent to baptize a child in secret, against both parents’ wishes, and against their priest’s decision even though my understanding is valid. My question is, did the child ultimately benefit from this? If yes, why is it considered illicit? If not, how come? Was it just neutral? 36:23 – Do vampires have souls? Is it murder to slay a vampire (assuming the classical undead form)? 41:55 – What do you think of AI-created “art” (MidJourney, etc)? I used to think there could be a Turing test equivalent, i.e., that we’d always be able to tell the difference between computer-generated images and human-created art, but as I see what is being created by MidJourney and the like I’m having doubts 45:23 – Is there a distinction between Hell / Hades / Gehenna / Sheol (Shuh ull)/ Lake of Fire, or are they all the same thing? 50:08 – Why is sex outside of marriage sinful? This seems to be an overwhelming reality.
…
Questions Covered:
01:58 – If you were dying, could you relay your confession to another person and they tell it to a priest? Also, can you say a confession over the phone? 08:09 – Is there any evidence for or against St. Thomas evangelizing India? 12:48 – What would the Mass look like if the reforms of Vatican II were faithfully implemented? Resource Mentioned: https://www.catholicworldreport.com/2021/07/23/the-mass-of-vatican-ii/ 21:08 – How does remote cooperation with evil get defined and how does it apply to using the benefits of medical research? 24:46 – I would love to know how, exactly, the early Church knew that Mary had been assumed into heaven. Is there a gospel somewhere (small “g” because it’s not in the canon of Scripture) that attests to it? I believe it–I just would love to hear where it was written down what happened, and how everyone reacted, kind of like the Ascension narrative! 30:02 – After St. Peter died, what were the relative levels of authority between the subsequent popes and the remaining apostles? 34:17 – If through Adam’s sin we all inherit original sin, and if Jesus is the new Adam, why do all of us after Jesus’ time who are children of baptized people still inherit original sin? 36:22 – How do we know (and explain) that the catechism doesn’t contradict prior Church teaching about there being “No salvation outside of the Catholic Church”? 44:11 – In the book “Ten Popes who Shook the World,” Eamon Duffy wrote: “The most famous of all ‘papal’ bible texts, Mathew 16:18 – ‘You are Peter, and upon this rock I will build my Church…and I will give to you the keys of the kingdom of heaven’—is quoted in no Roman source before the time of the Decian persecution in the middle of the third century, and the very roots of what may be called the foundation myth of the papacy are uncomfortably complicated.” True or not, what makes a “Roman” source definitive and what is the earliest/best source for this passage. 50:11 – Why do we kneel for prayer during Mass and yet we stand for The Lords Prayer?? 51:32 – Was Moe Berg really a spy?
…
Questions Covered:
09:19 – My husband has expressed interest in becoming Catholic out of convenience for the family. How do I give him resources without being intrusive? 21:43 – When do we think Jesus knew he was divine? 36:06 – Why doesn’t the Catholic Church use the name Jehovah if that’s His name? 43:38 – Can anyone bind or loose? 49:25 – How did Lucifer fall if he was one of the highest of angels?
…
Questions Covered:
02:51 – Why are there people that reject the 3rd Secret of Fatima? 09:58 – Regarding Mk 9:14-29 and the story of the healing of the demoniac boy. What’s your take on the father’s unbelief? 15:25 – Are writings necessary for canonization of a saint? Is it necessary for them to have written documents? 18:57 – Would it be reasonable to believe that Mary knew that she was conceived without original sin? 20:50 – How would a Catholic immortal respond to the situation of being immortal? Would it be legitimate for them to fight another immortal? 24:59 – What are your thoughts on the prince of Persia in the book of Daniel? Was that a person or a demon? 33:23 – Did the flood in Genesis flood the whole world or just the known world? 38:11 – Who was the first pope? 41:17 – Is there a kind of annulment for the priesthood? 48:18 – Can 2 divorced Catholics who never annulled their marriages date each other? 51:26 – I’m converting, and I want to know the difference between praying in the name of Jesus versus praying in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit?
…
Questions Covered:
02:56 – What makes masturbation a mortal sin? 07:59 – If the protestants lost apostolic succession because of their errors, why did the Orthodox lose it? 12:45 – Act 5 and Joshua 7 because the stories are so similar, can we say that Peter is a new Joshua? 16:53 – What are the Catholic grounds for divorce? 20:18 – I watched a video that claimed Abraham, Isaac and Jacob were not related. Is this true? 24:28 – What’s the purpose of venerating saint relics? 31:05 – I found some Old Testament verses about illegitimate children and now I feel worthless. What does God say about us? 36:20 – When did the shift happen from calling priests by their last name to their first name? 42:13 – What drew you into the Catholic Church? 46:08 – Can you help clarify the difference between divorce and annulment? 49:42 – My parish depicted Adam and Eve as a parable. Was it a real story?
…
Questions Covered:
06:12 – How do I understand Mary from a Catholic perspective compared to an American Baptist? 13:20 – Why did God make poison ivy? 18:55 – What was Jesus’s vocation if he was high priest, carpenter ect? How does that compare to our understanding of our personal vocation? 29:09 – How do I respond to a protestant who holds Martin Luther in high regards in Christianity? 36:03 – When St. Paul was traveling around the world, did he do anything that today would be considered Catholic practices? 42:30 – Why are there so few canonized Latin American saints compared to European saints? 52:00 – Is there a difference between getting baptized in the name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit verses in the name of Jesus?
…
Questions Covered:
03:58 – How do we know that the early Church was the Catholic Church? 11:46 – How did God create everything out of nothing? 16:30 – What are your thoughts on God as a mother? Is this concept even possible? 22:55 – How can I guide my Lutheran friend to become Catholic? 29:15 – How does God pick the 144,000 to have the seal mentioned in Revelation? 35:35 – Catholics use Acts 2 as a proof for apostolic succession but never use the qualifiers mentioned in chapter 1. How do Catholics reconcile apostolic succession if those qualifiers are no longer possible? 40:29 – How can Catholics believe in purgatory? 45:30 – Is there biblical evidence that would support the idea that a marriage would be invalid because of a person’s past? 49:15 – Why is it important to point out that Mary was saved when discussing that Mary was sinless? 52:38 – Do dogs go to heaven according to Church teaching? 53:00 – Is Yoga against Church teaching?
…
Questions Covered:
03:25 – Could you help clarify the idea that Mary is the spouse of the Spirit? 17:15 – Is it possible to create a 3rd or 4th class relic using the host of a Eucharistic miracle? 21:30 – If Christ restored everything to pre-golden calf times, why isn’t the priesthood extended to everyone? 36:16 – Is God’s love for us unconditional or conditional? 44:06 – I’m a lapsed Catholic seeking to come back. Why are saints’ bodies dismembered after their death and spread throughout the world? And why do they do this before they are declared saints? 52:00 – My boyfriend and I want to get married but I’m Catholic and He’s Protestant. What do we have to do? What does the Church say about mixed marriages?
…
Questions Covered:
19:16 – How do the beatitudes relate to promises made to Abraham in Genesis? 24:02 – “Blessed are the poor in spirit…” I take this as someone who is not particularly spiritual. Is this a valid way to look at it? 29:07 – Could you give insight on the last part of the beatitudes, going from “blessed are those “to, “blessed are you?” 32:58 – What exactly does meek mean? 48:50 – Is the woe to those rich because it’s harder or more testing? Is it woe to those who rejoice in this world because he deserves all the glory?
…
Questions Covered:
12:25 – Why are there more verses that stress belief in Jesus for salvation rather than baptism for salvation? 17:49 – Does it matter if you were baptized in a hospital vs inside a Church? 24:54 – If baptism is necessary how could the good thief be saved if he wasn’t baptized? 33:06 – I’m protestant. We believe you reach salvation not by going underwater but by the spirit. Is Jesus’ conversation with Nicodemus a proof of separation of baptism by water and baptism by the Spirit? 45:38 – Does it say in the bible that you need the age reason for someone to be baptized? 52:23 – Why did Jesus get baptized if he didn’t need it?
…
Questions Covered:
20:57 – What can we learn from how the crusaders governed? 28:47 – What was the impact of the order to destroy the Holy Sepulchre? 37:48 – Can you elaborate on the idea that Christian, Muslims, and Jews civilians lived in harmony prior to the army and government influence? 43:58 – How did the nature of indulgences change throughout the crusades? 49:56 – What was the Northern Germanic perspective on the Crusades?
…
Questions Covered:
15:20 – How can I best respond with love to an atheist and non-binary sibling? 21:38 – Can a Catholic vote in favor of restrictions on abortions that do not outright ban it? 24:48 – How do we balance an absolutist view on morality with the Catechism’s teaching on following our own conscious? 32:00 – How are Christian supposed to react to the death penalty being used in the past verse today? 36:14 – What resources would you recommend for a high school moral theology teacher? 43:34 – Am I wrong for wanting people to stop using the words abortion and euthanasia because they are too ambiguous? 46:26 – How can I respond to relativists who say I am pushing religion by saying objective morality is from God?
…
Questions Covered:
01:25 – Are we able to pray the rosary while driving with the aid of audio, or would we have to do it again later for it to be valid? 03:33 – When St. Paul was Saul and was persecuting the Christians, what gave him the authority to do what he did? 06:19 – My friend was Atheist and now Protestant, but she’s very hostile towards Catholicism. What would be a way to help her not be so hostile towards it? 11:09 – Can you obtain forgiveness for something you don’t truly regret? 13:45 – Are there limits on plenary indulgences and do they generally fall under binding? 18:33 – I recently have been meeting with Mormon missionaries and they use Ezekiel 37 to defend the Book of Mormon. Could you elaborate on this passage and why it does or doesn’t defend Mormonism? 23:15 – Would the Roman Pontiff be able to reinstitute the Tridentine Mass? 28:59 – Why does actual grace need to be present for good works to happen or at least be meritorious? 34:35 – Is it true that Judas was condemned to hell because of his actions towards Jesus? 40:54 – People point to Matthew 16:19 being the point at which Peter was given the keys. However, it says, “I will give you the keys”. Wouldn’t that mean he was going to be given the keys later? 46:56 – During mass, the priest at my church sometimes asks the congregation to extend their right arm towards a particular person they want to bless. Is that a licit thing to do? If not, how can I approach the priest in a charitable way about it? 50:26 – Is it ok to receive Communion on the tongue if it’s not from a priest? 52:18 – Is farming the ideal way for Catholics to get their food? What does the Catholic Church teach about mass food production and factory-made food?
…
Questions Covered
03:05 – What makes the Pope so Infallible? 05:55 – For the Catechumen, what are they taught when eternal life begins? 13:20 – When the Catholic Church executed Protestants in the past, was it in their right to do that for spreading Protestantism? 15:56 – I’ve heard scholars say some of the Pauline Epistles were written in the 2nd century and not by Paul. What are your thoughts on that? 21:37 – Does the Catholic Church officially believe some Protestants can have the indwelling of the Holy Spirit, especially if they don’t speak against the Church or deny the prophecy? 36:44 – How do we as Catholics know that the Calvinist understanding of original sin as depravity is false? 43:22 – Is Hell total darkness? Also, is it complete isolation or partial isolation? 48:55 – What is the relationship between free will and predestination? For example, was Mary predestined to be the mother of God?
…
Questions Covered:
03:00 – As someone who is possibly discerning becoming Catholic, why should I be Catholic instead of Orthodox or another denomination that believes in the real presence? 07:45 – Going off a previous question on why slavery isn’t mentioned in the bible, I wanted to talk about the Exodus story and God’s willingness to intervene in cases of injustice. 15:48 – I would like to dispute the issue that marriage is for life. 29:01 – I feel that the idea of organized religion needing to be a mediary between you and your god is evidence that that god isn’t there. That’s why I don’t feel a need to be a part of any religion. 33:38 – What’s the validity of sacraments outside the Catholic Church? Also, do Catholics believe people other than Catholics go to heaven? 43:17 – I was in RCIA in 2019 and then COVID happened. One of the reasons I did not end up going into the church was the Church’s response to it. I was taught that the Eucharist was extremely important to receiving the grace of God and the Church denied people access to it. Why did the Church do that? 51:03 – Are Protestants allowed to go to confession and confess to a priest? 51:43 – What are the main differences between Catholics and Protestants?
…
Questions Covered:
14:56 – How does religious freedom account for the freedom of people that aren’t Catholic? 22:43 – I’m Catholic but my Protestant friend has a question. He doesn’t like the fact that there’s non parallelism in the Jewish roots of Mary. How could Eve be the new Mary since she is the wife of Adam? 34:23 – I’m 90 years old. I’ve been Catholic for 2 months, so I was a non-Catholic for 87 years. I am so happy being Catholic and being filled with the fullness of truth. If I can do it at my age, others can too! 41:55 – I have discovered through studying eschatology that everything that the Protestant church understands as our traditions actually came from early Catholicism. Do Catholics believe that they decided to create a new sabbath on their own, not understanding the scriptures, but out of a dislike for Jews because they killed Christ? 47:29 – I’m Catholic but my friend is Atheist. He says the bible doesn’t talk about the evil of slavery. Why is it not addressed? 52:22 – Why is being married in the church so complicated? I’m divorced and annulled but now married outside of the church. Why is it so legalistic?
…
Questions Covered:
09:57 – Do you think the Conjunction Fallacy is correct? What are your thoughts on it? 19:29 – Does the church have any teaching on taking photos of open caskets? 21:55 – I understand that Protestants have a valid sacrament of marriage. If a Catholic becomes a Protestant and marries another Protestant, is the marriage valid? If they were to be married in a Vegas chapel with no witnesses, would it still be a valid marriage? 28:50 – I was told baptized babies don’t receive the fullness of the Holy Spirit until confirmation. Could you elaborate on what this means? 33:19 – What is the meaning of the first resurrection in Revelation Ch 20? 37:18 – Would Adam and Eve have suffered a physical death had they not eaten the fruit? 41:51 – Can you clarify what the church means by “the dead know nothing”? 49:50 – How did the church construct how we’re supposed to fast?
…
Questions Covered:
03:20 – If a Roman Catholic doesn’t commit mortal sin, then is it still necessary to increase in merit to increase in justification? 11:53 – What is a doctor of the church is how does someone become one? 14:40 – On a show I watched there was a married man that became a monk. Can married people become monks? 19:05 – Science says there’s multiple dimensions and each choice we make is split up. Does the Church teach that there are multiple of us? If so, does it say that in some universes we are saved and others we aren’t? 23:43 – Why is the New Testament church that Paul talked about different from the way the church is set up today? I am technically Catholic but I am Protestant now. 45:31 – Are the fruits of the spirit the proof of our regeneration rather than baptism? 50:40 – Does the church have any teaching on whether the soul of a deceased person can linger as a ghost? For example, in the sense of a house being haunted.
…
Questions Covered:
01:35 – Why do we believe that a child confirmed under a different Christian religion would not be a valid sacrament in the Catholic Church? 07:18 – If God is love, does God’s love equal sanctifying grace? 15:15 – Why is there music in Church? 18:57 – Why do we believe in purgatory? 23:21 – Why could Jesus never be left alone during adoration? 29:30 – Why would a marriage not be valid if it wasn’t celebrated in a Church for a Catholic? 33:40 – Why does the Church reach out to the communion of saints and not to pray to the dead? 39:57 – I’m a Protestant, how is sin not totally paid for on the cross? 51:10 – Why does it take so long to be baptized as a Catholic?
…
Question Covered:
04:32 – Why can we say that creedal statements of the 4th Lateran Council can be infallible when we have to stretch it to sound Catholic? 17:27 – Why do we believe that it’s the Holy Spirit that enables us to speak in tongues, specifically the babbling? 25:05 – Why does divorce disqualify you in some cases from receiving communion? 33:22 – Why do we have the three criteria for something to be a mortal sin? Has it always been like this since the beginnings of the Church? 42:12 – Why are some promises from saints approved and others not? Examples of the St. Brigid of Sweden’s promises and her visions of Jesus.
…
Questions Covered:
01:05 – Is there any reference to Papal infallibility in the Old Testament? 11:10 – What is your favorite version of the Bible and why? 14:26 – Is there Biblical proof for the Eucharist? 18:27 – In Matthew 27, what is meant by the passage that says, “many saints who slept rose from the dead”? 21:49 – How many people in the Bible are referred to as the “Son of Man”? 33:00 – Why does the Catholic Bible have more books than the Protestant Bible? 36:19 – What is the Catholic understanding of Revelation 2:9? 42:15 – Were there any exorcists in the Old Testament? 46:40 – How do I answer my Protestant friend who claims that only in “66 books” is the truth of the Bible? 49:15 – The parable of the wedding feast this past week has me concerned about merit and salvation. Can you explain it further?
…
Questions Covered:
09:35 – Even though Christ’s blood is continuing, does Christ’s suffering continue? 13:30 – Are there passages that discourage women from being teachers? 18:06 – In Ezekiel 34:16, what is meant by “sleek”? 21:54 – What do you think of the Scofield Reference Bible? 29:03 – Does the phrase “let the dead bury the dead” imply that we should leave people in our lives who are spiritually dead, even spouses and family members? 33:25 – In the Book of Revelation, there is a reference to saints on earth. How can this be possible? 39:21 – What does the Gospel from this past Sunday mean? 41:53 – Were people baptized by John the Baptist validly Baptized? 46:28 – Is there Biblical evidence that Jesus did not have siblings?
…
Questions Covered:
01:06 – Why should I go to a Catholic Church when the non-denominational church that I like going to is also preaching the truth? 07:00 – Are there any Catholic alternative voices that support a minimalistic approach to natural law? 13:50 – How do we reconcile the discrepancy in Matthew and Luke regarding when the birth of Christ occurred? 21:08 – Where in the bible does it say that we are wounded by original sin and not totally depraved? 34:55 – If a person was baptized later in life and had committed terrible sins, would baptism remove the need for purgatory for those sins? 37:09 – What genre of literature in the book of Genesis? 42:46 – The Baltimore Catechism says that in order to enter heaven you have to get to know, love and serve God. Which of the three is most important? 46:13 – How do we reconcile Adam and Eve and the evolution of homo sapiens?
…
Questions Covered:
04:48 – How do I respond to Mormons whenever they go back to having good feelings about the Book of Mormon? How do I get past that roadblock? 12:14 – What is the official teaching on the eucharist and the sacrifice? 17:11 – Is it true that the Roman canon of the Mass can’t change? If this is true, how can St. Dominic and St. Ambrose be in it? 21:02 – Is it proper to say that Mary is the dwelling place of the Holy Trinity? 23:59 – I’m a lapsed Catholic, how to overlook current Church politics and scandals in order to come back to the Church? 37:53 – How do we explain children who have memories of a past life? 48:25 – Did God give a divinely inspired tradition to the Jews like he did to the Church? If not, why not? If He did, Why would He allow it to be corrupted enough for Jesus to criticize it?
…
Questions Covered:
08:57 – What were the differences between Pharisees and the Sadducees? Are they comparable to Catholics and Protestants? 15:15 – I’ve returned to the Church and I want a list of books you recommend. Which Catechism should I get? 17:50 – Does your guardian angel finish your prayers if you fall asleep? Are people only their specific religion because that’s how they were raised? 29:56 – What are your thoughts on the idea that the founding principles of America are anti-Catholic? 35:57 – I’m in a long conversation with my protestant friend. How do I help soften their position and bias against Catholicism? 42:05 – Can you critique my argument for the Immaculate Conception that I want to present to my parents? 47:53 – What would you say is the most compelling argument for God that is not a Thomistic argument? Can you provide an explanation of the moral argument? 53:00 – How do we prove Mary’s virginity?
…
Questions Covered:
08:51 – My friend told me that there’s a vision of Mary currently happening. She said that Mary is saying to stock up on nuts, honey and blessed grapes. Are you familiar with it? Is this a valid apparition? 16:30 – Did the Church have all 73 books of the bible after the council of Rome in c.398 AD? 21:30 – Why bother evangelizing to my protestant family if Christ is the center of their lives? 32:41 – How can you ask Mary to pray for you if she is a human being who has passed on? Do Catholics think you can talk to the dead? 35:20 – How can you ask Mary to pray for you if she is a human being who has passed on? Do Catholics think you can talk to the dead? 43:12 – Why are certain sexual acts not allowed in marriage, specifically sodomy? 49:38 – How do I explain to my protestant friends that Jesus gave Peter primacy in authority and not to the entire Church?
…
Questions Covered:
01:42 – How do I show my protestant friends that there are more than 2 sacraments? 10:10 – I don’t think God could have saved us in any other way. Is there evidence for that? 20:15 – Who were the sons of God in Genesis? 32:00 – How do I build up trust in people after many years of not trusting others? 43:03 – I’m reading a book on exorcisms and a demon claimed that Mary is powerful. If he is a liar, could he be lying about that? 48:20 – My little sister came out of the closet. How can I help her and bring her to the truth?
…
Questions Covered:
03:55 – Is it possible for sacramentals to have the same graces as sacraments? Can we make our own sacramentals? 13:45 – I’m protestant. What is the Catholic doctrine on the atonement? 19:10 – Why are some Catholics not supportive of the Catechism? 24:30 – How could we claim that the Church’s teaching were infallible if the early Christians believed that Christ would come back in their lifetime? 32:30 – How can Mary be a co-redemptrix if Jesus is the one who redeemed us? 42:05 – I’m a teacher and was tasked to teach on race and gender in a liberal school. How do I approach this as a Catholic? 49:37 – With a lack of catechesis in different parts of the world, is there an effort to bring materials in the native languages to remote parts of the world? 51:49 – How do we know whether a vision or visionary/prophet is really happening? How do we know if God is actually speaking to them?
…
Questions Covered:
01:14 – How do you answer a former Mormon regarding how the church has so much money and distributes it? Why don’t they give more of it to the needy? 07:30 – Could you share your thoughts on Sirach 42:14 “Better is the wickedness of a man than a woman who does good; and it is a woman who brings shame and disgrace”? A friend said it should not be in scripture because it is “anti-Christian”. 12:43 – I heard that when we read about Abraham, we don’t read it literally. But how do we fill the gaps specifically in regard to his age? 17:09 – I have protestant friends who ask me, how can you discern sacred tradition from the tradition of man? 22:18 – Did the early Church have anything to say about abortion and same-sex marriage? 29:16 – Could sports be a sanctifying act? 42:39 – Why do we not have the same belief on the Eucharist as with Protestants? And why do we have the body and blood and they don’t? 48:33 – Protestant objections to Mary
…
Questions Covered:
11:25 – What is the difference between the Father ‘begetting’ the Son and the Father ‘willing’ the Son? 22:18 – Which approved miracles could I use in conversation with an atheist when discussing evidence for God? 29:00 – Can you explain how the Sacraments work? Especially confession. 34:08 – In the bible there is a verse that says all you need is to believe in Jesus. But Catholics think baptism saves you. How do you reconcile these two things? 36:59 – In an emergency can a non-Catholic confess their sins to a priest? 43:24 – Who were the elders in the early Church and what is their equivalent today? 48:26 – Why is Lucifer’s name changed to Satan? What’s the meaning of the name?
…
Questions Covered:
13:07 – How do I as a non-Catholic understand the issues going on in Germany and the changes with the Synodal way? 16:06 – How do we distinguish the similarities and differences between the development of doctrine of Catholicism and the explication of doctrine as understood by the Orthodox? 19:56 – What do you think about the changes the Church made about slavery? It used to endorse it and now it doesn’t. 32:12 – How can the Church change to get rid of clericalism and embrace the Gospel? 35:50 – Is the role of the Church to preserve the traditions of the Church of the times of the apostles or can this also be applied to later traditions 43:13 – Is the teaching on contraception definitive? 48:45 – Did the Church change its teaching on limbo and where aborted babies go?
…
Questions Covered:
04:09 – How do I explain the sacraments to my Baptist girlfriend? 11:08 – What’s the relationship between religious truth and fact? 16:04 – Is the phrase extra Ecclesiam nulla salus still a usable phrase after the second Vatican council? 17:29 – Is it appropriate to own tarot cards if you don’t use them for spiritual purposes? 21:06 – Is binding and loosing a slippery slope that can lead the Church to loosening up morals? 28:56 – What is the reason behind Vatican 2 decision not to indict the Jews for Jesus’ death? 34:08 – Since we are obligated to help people in dire need and there’s always people in dire need, is it ok for us to enjoy luxuries for ourselves? 41:45 – How much of Church teaching do we actually have to believe? 46:13 – What did Jesus mean when he said about Judas “ It would be better if he were never born?” 47:57 – a 7th day Adventist claimed that Mt. 24:20 proves that the Sabbath remains on a Saturday. How do I respond? 52:12 – If you were married and the apocalypse happened and you were only left with one other woman, would it be adultery to repopulate the earth with that woman?
…
Questions Covered:
02:48 – What are your thoughts on a pre-tribulation rapture? 10:41 – What are your thoughts on if the mystical experiences of the New Testament were due to the use of psychedelic drugs? 16:06 – I was debating with a Muslim and he asked why God sent the Holy Spirit? Wouldn’t this make sending Jesus pointless? How do I respond? 21:18 – What is the history of the pentacle? Why does the Church frown upon it? 24:29 – Why do things in life grow? 33:19 – Is it proper to interpret Marian apparitions naturally or supernaturally? 37:05 – How can we as Catholics believe in evolution, the big bang, and the 7 days of creation all at once? Resources: https://www.catholic.com/audio/caf/is-the-big-bang-a-proof-of-god 44:33 – How do I incorporate fasting into my prayer life? 49:28 – Why is Easter celebrated on Sunday instead of Monday? Why call it Easter and not Resurrection Day?
…
Questions Covered:
11:32 – How can I help my girlfriend who’s trying to stop her marijuana addiction, but she still lives with friends who tempt her? We are also long distance. 17:26 – What are your thoughts on other paths that lead to sobriety that are not 12 steps? 21:21 – I feel what you are doing is a form of the New Evangelization! 32:17 – How do you help the partners of those going through the program for sexual healing? 36:07 – What is your take on the 11th step? 42:07 – How to persevere in being sober from pornography especially with thoughts? 46:10 – I’m concerned for my kids, especially since I suspect my ex-husband to be an alcoholic. How do I influence them? 51:26 – How do I start an alcoholic group for teens?
…
Questions Covered:
03:18 – Will we be able to fly in our resurrected body? Would I be able to fly to space? 11:35 – How do I implement an understanding of the development of doctrine to Vatican 2? 16:44 – What did Jesus mean that the only exception to leaving a marriage is due to immorality? 23:27 – Could you explain what Jn 1:1 means? 33:15 – How do you respond to the claim “Catholics think you can buy your way into heaven?” 37:15 – How do I explain to my friend that it’s important to go back to church since she feels betrayed by God due to her daughter’s illness? 45:17 – How culpable is a person who committed mortal sins due to trauma that he had? 52:22 – Is faith a work?
…
In this episode Trent sits down with Cy Kellett of the Catholic Answers Focus podcast to break down common slanderous accusations pro-choice advocates make against pro-lifers.
Welcome to The Counsel of Trent podcast, a production of Catholic Answers. Trent Horn: Hey, everyone. I’m still taking time off this week to spend time with family, to celebrate my wife’s birthday with her, but I thought it would still be nice to share with you an interview that I did, just in case you’re missing some time with me. Before the Dobbs v. Jackson decision came out in June, I sat down with Cy Kellett on the Catholic Answers Focus podcast to tear apart common pro-choice arguments and pro-choice stereotypes of pro-life people. The interview is still quite timely because you’re hearing all of these arguments now, just as I predicted you would be hearing all of this. I said even before… Trent Horn: It’s funny, when you go back and listen to the interview, I’m such a Debbie Downer. We’re talking about it, and I said, “Even if the Court doesn’t overturn Roe v. Wade, this is still a big deal.” You could tell I just had a hard time getting my hopes up, but now yippee! I’m happy that we’ve made this advance to protect the lives of unborn children. Trent Horn: We have not won the war by any means, but we have secured a major victory. That means we have to continue to push forward, and we have to do so in an assertive way and a gracious way. I hope this interview helps you to be able to do that, to give you some tips for engaging in these conversations. They’re going to be coming up more and more and more. Trent Horn: Hope that’s helpful for you guys, and don’t forget to subscribe to the Catholic Answers Focus podcast if you want to hear more interviews like this. Of course, continue to subscribe to The Counsel of Trent. Leave a review for us on Apple Podcasts, Google Play. That’s always helpful as well. Trent Horn: Without further ado, here is my interview with Cy Kellett about debunking pro-choice arguments and stereotypes about pro-life people. Cy Kellett: One thing that is clear, because the media has made this clear to me, is that the pro-life movement has overwhelmingly been a movement of violent people who attack pro-abortion people and abortion doctors and all of that. It really has been an extraordinarily violent movement. Trent Horn: Well, that’s what you’ll hear from the media, that, overall, the pro-life movement is violent; but when you compare the pro-life movement to other social movements throughout history, the pro-life movement is one of the most peaceful social movements of all time. This is a movement in the United States composed of tens of millions of people. Think about all the people who go to March for Life, who pray in front of abortion facilities. Trent Horn: While there are other movements around… If you think there are other movements around the country, such as animal rights movements, which are, I would say, they’re not as large as the pro-life movement. I’ve never seen an animal rights march that could compare to the March for Life. Yet animal rights, environmentalists, frequently engage in acts of violence. They’ll put steel spikes into trees when loggers try to cut them down. They will blow up laboratories, burn them down. In fact, there’s a whole branch of violence dedicated to that, called eco-terrorism. Trent Horn: Similar other movements throughout history have resorted to things like violence, but the pro-life movement… It’s really interesting, I was reading an article at Slate, which is an online publication, very liberal, so very in favor of the pro-choice worldview. One of the articles there, I remember the author saying, “It’s actually quite surprising how little violence there is in the pro-life movement given that pro-lifers believe thousands of human beings are being killed e…
Questions Covered:
05:55 – Where does one have a right to deny someone else communion? 19:22 – How to reconcile evangelization with invincible ignorance? 29:01 – How do we know when we cross from dulia to latria? 35:26 – If the Holy Spirit can talk to us, can the saints and Mary communicate with us too? 38:08 – Can we pray for ourselves before and during our time in purgatory? 43:50 – Why did God not want Adam and Eve to eat the fruit? Is Natalie an adult – Sounds like a child? 48:36 – Are we allowed to attend Orthodox vespers or liturgy of the hours? 51:14 – What is the Catholic response to the claim that 2 Tim 2:15 KJV supports two gospels, one for Jews and another for the gentiles?
…
Questions Covered:
04:14 – Since God isn’t limited to time and space can he see all the paths that we could have taken in life? 15:30 – Could you explain the Vatican’s Council for Inclusive Capitalism? 22:10 – What should we expect if Jesus comes back tomorrow? 29:45 – I’m not Catholic but I am so close. Can you give me advice on making the leap even though Pope Francis scandalizes me? 37:50 – Is it ok to marry with the intention to adopt and not procreate? 42:37 – Can demons materialize in human form? 48:39 – How does Jer. 31:29-30 relate to original sin?
…
Questions Covered:
14:10 – How would Rev.12:13-17 be applied to Mary? 19:40 – If Mary was born without sin, would that mean she’s separate from humanity? Wouldn’t Jesus need the consequence of sin in order to get rid of them? 29:50 – Do Catholics believe that Mary’s egg was used for the conception of Jesus? 35:24 – I view sin as a deformity, did Mary have this? 41:30 – Is there a difference between the bodily Assumption and the Dormition? 44:55 – What are your thoughts on the speculation that St. Ann was infertile, and St. Joachim was away during the time of the conception of Mary? 50:17 – Who was Mary and why was she important and had so many suitors? Why was Joseph worthy of marrying her?
…
Questions Covered:
12:20 – Do you think the miracle of the sun at Fatima is good evidence for God? 20:34 – Who has the burden of proof since the atheist can’t prove a negative? 31:10 – Is the complexity of life a good argument for God? 42:20 – The bible is just hearsay. The best we can do is say that we don’t know.
…
Questions Covered:
06:48 – Could dark energy be associated with angelic/ demonic energy / dark matter that God created at the beginning of the universe? As in, the reason we have missing/ dark matter and/ or energy is due to the spiritual world or dimension we can’t see but know is there? 13:33 – Is it possible to pray for the souls who have already gone to Hell? And if so, would it do any good? I would love to hear what you have to say, even if you can’t answer my question. 17:41 – Did toddler Jesus have meltdowns and temper tantrums, and can we guess if Mary ever lost her patience on him and yelled at him? 22:54 – How is original sin, inherited from Adam and Eve, different from the biologically discredited idea of inheritance of acquired characteristics (Lamarckian evolution). In other words it seems analogous to the story of how the bear lost its tail (easily googled). In the spirit of transparency, I’m a professor of biological anthropology but also a Christian. I know the scientific and religious truth in this matter can be reconciled, but I don’t know enough to be able to do it by myself. 39:57 – Is string theory (or implications drawn from string theory) incompatible with Theism and Christianity? 43:55 – In terms of the theory of infinite possible futures, are there an infinite numbers of past timelines? Or do all possibilities combine into one single “past” timeline? 47:34 – Could you speak a bit about Adam and Eve and the other hominids—many of which seemed to have used tools, bury the dead, and made cave art.
…
Questions Covered:
19:15 – During my current experiences with divorce, I am hesitant to tell my children not to cohabitate. 29:19 – Does cohabitation affect marriage in a bad way, or are the people who are inclined toward cohabitation already predisposed to divorce? 41:55 – How do I help my friend who is a lapsed Catholic and is cohabitating without an annulment from his marriage? 45:06 – How can I help my brother who is now getting married after cohabitation for a while? 48:48 – What do I make of people who get married civilly? 51:58 – I am bothered by thoughts I have of a friend who is cohabiting. How can I find peace?
…
Questions Covered: 06:42 – What is the most persuasive argument for the faith? 14:04 – What are blessings and curses? 31:49 – Did Mary disobey Jesus at the Wedding Feast at Cana? 33:36 – Why are the gospels not ordered “Mark, Matthew, Luke, and John” if Mark wrote his gospel first 49:00 – Why are women not allowed to be priests? 52:00 – What are your thoughts on contemporary art in churches? …
Questions Covered: 07:56 – Did Pope Francis engage in a Pagan ritual in Canada? 13:16 – What are the limits of invincible ignorance? 32:25 – Does our being a part of the “Mystical Body of Christ” make us biologically related to him and Mary? 37:46 – What happens when I die? 46:13 – What Biblical evidence is there for the sovereignty of God? …
Questions Covered: 07:10 – Can a priest ever be reinstated if he broke the seal of confession? 14:40 – How do I respond to the Mormon argument for the great apostasy? 33:01 – Are protestants living in sin since they are not in communion with the Church? 44:42 – Can an uncertain law impose a certain obligation? 51:58 – How do we respond to the Orthodox claim that the rosary is vain repetition because you focus on the mysteries and not the words? …
Questions Covered:
05:20 – How do respond to the argument that God isn’t pro-life because of what happened to King David’s first child? 15:16 – Can venial sins be deemed mortal sins? 22:14 – Why did the immaculate conception have to happen? 30:53 – Why does Genesis not mention the creation of dinosaurs? 37:10 – If sin didn’t exist how could have Satan fallen? 45:12- What is the standard of measurement that God uses to qualify us as a generous person? 50:38 – How does one unite one’s sufferings with Christ? What happens?
…
Questions Covered:
07:56 – My protestant friend is asking why the pope has authority. How do I answer? 17:56 – When our lady of Guadalupe appeared, was she really pregnant with Jesus? 38:08 – Did Jesus have brothers and if they exist, what happened to them? 50:04 – Do you think the letters from Pontius Pilot to Rome are authentic? 51:26 – How do I respond to my atheist friend who claims that the Church has only been pro-life in the last 200 years?
…
Questions Covered:
10:10 – Why do Catholics believe that our Faith is a gift from God instead of using the evidence that we have? 29:07 – If a priest who is hard of hearing doesn’t fully understand all your confession, is it still valid? 34:42 – Is our sexual desire still going to be present in our resurrected body? 42:43 – Is it reasonable to hope that many will endure purgatory and few in hell? 48:15 – How does the Church decide which sins are more grave than others?
…
Questions Covered:
03:15 – How can I explain confession to a non-denominational friend? 11:06 – Has the Church formally declared that the Fatima events were genuine? 13:50 – How was Jesus heard in the sermon on the mount if there were thousands of people? 20:00 – Will those who are still alive during the end time have to experience death? 21:40 – Where in the gospel does it address cohabitation? 24:27 – If we cannot see God face to face but we can see Jesus face, does that mean we can see his face? 28:49 – I’m in a debate with friends. Is our solar system geocentric or heliocentric? What are your thoughts? 36:17 – Was Peter’s profession of faith the real rock that Jesus built his Church upon? 44:10 – What is a synod? What is the synod on synodality? 47:20 – Is there any occasion where the creed can be omitted from Mass? 47:07 – In the Old Testament, two prophets were assumed into heaven, where did they go if the gates of heaven weren’t open? 52:00 – What do you think of the illumination of conscience that many saints have prophesied and foretold?
…
Questions Covered:
17:40 – What do you think the president and the speaker should do to keep the Church happy? 20:54 – Why is there talk of politicization of holy communion? 30:27 – How do we change minds on this issue? 35:20 – Why is it that banning people from receiving communion takes so long? 43:50 – I’m a registered nurse and the state board came out condemning the decision. How do I as a faithful Catholic handle this? 48:50 – Is it bad for me as a Catholic to blow off this topic and say, “It’s your body, your sin?” 52:00 – I think it’s important to emphasize the financial incentive for businesses to pay for abortion.
…
Questions Covered:
10:43 – What do you think about Catholic organizations promoting homosexuality? 13:28 – How do you handle a response from Catholics who prop up priests who promote that lifestyle? 18:07 – How do I share my Faith with people and show them that there are good people who also struggle with same sex attraction? 24:29 – Should I attend a gay wedding that I was invited to? 33:08 – If I send a baby shower gift to a nephew and his gay partner who adopted be taken as promoting gay adoption? 42:48 – I’m bisexual and my wife knows that. I was almost married to a man. How would my spiritual life have been different if I had taken that path? 47:44 – I’m not Catholic, do Catholics have the same reservations about attending gay weddings as they do with 2nd weddings, cohabitating couples’ weddings etc.? Resource: https://ruthinstitute.org/
…
Questions Covered:
16:04 – I’m very close to joining the Catholic Church but how do I make sense of Pope Francis and his actions, especially the restrictions on the Latin Mass and the pope praying with non-Catholics in non-Catholic ceremonies? 21:47 – Can a pope declare a private revelation to be necessary for salvation or for one to be considered Catholic? 30:59 – Pope St. John Paul II declared that he had no authority to ordain women, was that considered an infallible statement? 36:13 – If a pope says something that isn’t true, is that a danger to souls? 45:42 – Is it true that the pope can declare something about the Mass that a future pope could not undo? 49:29 – Because Jesus instituted the papacy, the pope cannot declare new things like ordaining women.
…
Questions Covered:
02:22 – Do you have any advice regarding forgiveness? 09:03 – What is the nature of man? Is Jesus’ soul separate from His divine nature? 14:47 – Was Moses circumcised? 18:55 – What is the formal definition of tradition? 22:30 – How do Catholics defend the practice of penance in light of the parable of the Prodigal son? 28:46 – Is capital punishment immoral? 34:13 – Why did Jesus go after the money changers in the temple? What was the source of the anger? 39:40 – Is the Flavian signature a valid argument? 43:05 – Is there any gray area to consider a marriage between a Catholic and a Jewish person in a synagogue without the bishop’s dispensation to be valid? 47:24 – Why does Christ sometimes appear in the form of a baby in private revelations? 48:58 – Why does God allow suffering and even asks us to bring more children into this world? 50:50 – Who were the sons of God mentioned in Deut. 32 and Psalm 82? Were they fallen angels worshiped as pagan gods?
…
Questions Covered:
03:02 – Does God’s omniscience make an infinite past impossible? 07:28 – Were there early church fathers that bought into Calvinism? 12:20 – Is there a distinction between fallen angels and demons? 16:29 – Why did they change the name from RCIA to OCIA? 20:31 – What are the requirements for becoming a deacon or apologist/religious leader? 29:29 – In Romans 2:25-26, what does Paul mean here? Doesn’t God stay faithful to His covenants with His people no matter what? 35:27 – How are our internal organs affected by the resurrected body? 40:50 – Considering the verse that calls Christ the cornerstone, could you explain the stability of the Catholic church? 46:38 – Were the places that the Israelites attacked in the book of Joshua military bases or civilian towns? 49:53 – What’s the difference between praying, desiring, and wishing?
…
Questions Covered:
01:46 – I grew up attending Spanish speaking mass and now I go to English Mass. I noticed that a lot more people receive communion in the English-speaking Mass. Is this a catechetical thing? Why is this? 10:12 – Why didn’t Jesus tell Mary that he was going to go to God’s house in Jerusalem? 14:11 – Luke 10:25 How is Jesus answering that question? It is vague. Why don’t we stress the deity of Christ instead of the divinity of Christ? 21:06 – What does the Church teach about deliverance prayer? 28:46 – St. Thomas More’s reflection asking for happiness. Should this be something we should be praying for? 34:00 – I was an OB/GYN for many years and was once asked to perform a baptism. Would using salt water and a syringe impact the validity of the baptism? 41:36 – How do I prove that infant baptisms are valid and being at the age of reason is not necessary? 47:08 – Is it ok as a Catholic to watch documentaries such as the Ed Warren cases on demons? 51:00 – How many physical bodies are in heaven according to the Church?
…
Questions Covered:
09:01 – What was the creation of Jesus like? Begotten not made? Was he created since he is the Son God not Father God? 14:32 – If a bishop claims he is afraid of death, should we also be afraid of death? 21:45 – Do we know if the pope listens to Catholic radio, EWTN or Catholic Answers? 29:18 – Is it wrong to wait a few days to go to confession after committing venial sin? What’s the gravity of venial sin vs mortal sin? 38:14 – I was baptized as a Baptist at 8. Then I was baptized by a Sedevacantist priest and now am in full communion with Rome. What sins would I have to confess because I don’t know when I was validly baptized? 46:51 – Is the Deut. 32:8 worldview in The Unseen Realm by Michael Heiser compatible with Catholicism? 51:17 – In the Exodus story, did God take away Pharaoh’s free will when he hardened his heart? How do we understand that phrase?
…
Questions Covered:
4:27 – What’s the Church’s teaching on cannibalism in extreme circumstances? Is it ever ethical? 11:50 – Regarding the teaching on following your conscience, how could one do so if you’re highly scrupulous? What is the Church’s approach when it comes to mental illness? 20:40 – Can you clarify why there are different perspectives on Old Testament covenants and why some say the signs are different? The Mosaic covenant is either the 10 commandments vs Passover. The Davidic: Throne vs Temple 29:20 – Is our concupiscence a result of our free will? If Adam and Eve had not sinned, would someone else have sinned? 36:50 Since Covid, we haven’t been able to consume communion from the chalice. Does this mean we aren’t receiving the blood of Jesus? 42:27 – Why don’t we as Catholics focus on baptism of the Holy Spirit? The Charismatic renewal has been focusing on this for 50 years now. 48:07 – Do Catholics follow the sabbath? How do you reconcile this with Isaiah 66:22-23? 52:30 – If someone is baptized with Trinitarian formula but doesn’t believe in the Trinity, is it a valid baptism?
…
Questions Covered:
05:56 – Why would the Holy Spirit not know when the second coming will happen according to Mt. 24:36. 15:33- Do you have assurance that people with mental disabilities have salvation? 31:40 – How do you balance reading “plucking out your eye” and “cutting off your hand” as metaphorically” and readings on hell as literally? 41:21 – I’m struggling, why do the popes, bishops and priests adorn themselves so much and treat themselves with a lot of luxuries if Jesus never walked that way?
…
Questions Covered:
13:09 – What is the biblical evidence for the different levels of heaven as compared to Mormon teaching? 23:21 – I’m not Catholic and I’m looking for resources on the big issues in Catholicism. 28:35 – How do you convince an atheist or agnostic that is real in simple terms? 33:38 – How do I defend the fact that Jesus was quoting Psalm 22 and not doubting? Was Psalm 22 written in its entirety prior to the birth of Jesus? 41:47 – How do you respond to the pro-choice argument: If abortion is treated as a crime, failing to treat a miscarriage should be a crime. 46:44 – How do I defend against Universalism? 51:26 – My college is having a priest come in and teach a course on queer theology. What should I do?
…
Questions Covered:
07:00 – I have a friend who is hesitant to convert to Catholicism because the idea of confessing her sins to a man seems shameful. 16:38 – How do I respond to the “forced birth” argument? 21:09 – I teach a catechism class at a local public school (Australia). I was inviting them to our parish confirmation program even though most never go to church. One question I couldn’t answer: How did Peter know what Jesus meant by “Church” in Matt 16? Was the term used before then? 24:46 – What is the best way to open conversation with family who are practically atheist? 36:46 – Is it wrong to gamble during a financial struggle? 42:22 – What, in your opinion, was Christ’s strangest teaching? 47:05 – What is the difference between Protestant and Catholic salvation? 50:25 – Why would Mary Magdalene go to the tomb if it was sealed and guarded?
…
Questions Covered:
03:58 – How do I respond to someone who says that bishops’ authority did not exist until after Constantine and that Protestant ministers serve the same role as these bishops prior? 12:25 – How do I respond to an apatheist? 19:25 – How do you speak out against certain sins when there is public knowledge that you have a history of struggle with this sin? 29:20 – How can we defend the divinity of Christ and the fact that Jesus is God? 32:38 – How do I defend the Church from the claim that she changed her teaching on the death penalty? 44:50 – How do I prove that the Sabbath is on Sunday instead of Saturday? 51:50 – Why does the Church need a pope?
…
Questions Covered:
04:31 – How do I respond to the Protestant claim that antipopes ruin the line of apostolic succession and that there are subliminal Satanic messages in the Vatican? 15:19 – If a priest uses your phone for a prayer, does the phone become blessed? And if you hear a prayer in a different language, are you still praying? 22:01 – What is the church’s position on popes and heresy? Can popes commit heresy? What happens if they do? 35:17 – Could you explain Marian apparitions for someone who struggles with them as a stumbling block? 49:10 – Does the Vatican have an observatory, and if so, why? Will we know when the end of the world is coming based on Revelation?
…
Questions Covered:
19:23 – Can you touch on the significance of Mary Magdalene finding Jesus first after the Resurrection? 35:10 – Is it possible that John made up verses to address heresy? It seems his gospel is frequently in discord with the other synoptics. 44:18 – Why do some Bibles not include John 8? 48:56 – Are we inspired in a way like the Synoptic Gospel writers?
…
Questions Covered:
03:38 – According to the bible, does the soul stay in the grave until judgment day, or does the soul go to heaven? 12:36 – Was Hebrews among the Dead Sea Scrolls, and if it was, was the author named? 17:44 – In 1 Cor. 1:17, is Paul separating the gospel and baptism? 22:33 – If Mary had said no to becoming the mother of God, would that have contracted sin/opened her up to sin? 29:08 – Can you explain Numbers 5:21? It appears contradictory with most modern Catholic views on abortion. 32:49 – In Acts 2, were the apostles actually speaking the other languages, or were the people hearing it in their own language? 35:56 – With reference to 2 Peter 1:10, what is the opinion on the Doctrine of Eternal Security? Can you abandon your faith? 44:24 – When and how did the Jewish religion stop sacrificing animals, and is there still sacrifice? 47:10 – In Matthew 12:40, why does it say three nights, when Christ was only in the tomb for two nights? 49:19 – In Numbers 9:11-14, can you clarify what it means for strangers and sojourners to participate in the Passover?
…
Questions Covered:
4:16 – What is the biblical evidence for guardian angels? 06:42 – Is the Trinity incestual because it implies that Mary is both mother and bride? 11:44 – Is it possible that St. Clement wrote Hebrews? 14:42 – What accounts for the difference in the treatment of the apostles between Herod and his son Herod? 20:25 – Do novenas have their origin in the preparation for the time of Pentecost? 28:53 – Before I formed you in the womb. I knew you Jer. 1:5. With that in mind, when was the soul created? 33:00 – Why do we say in the creed, “Jesus suffered under Pontius Pilot” when Pilot did everything he could not to harm Jesus? 36:34 – Why are the KJV and Catholic version of the Our Father different? Why did we add the ending into the Catholic Liturgy? 43:28 – What did Jesus mean when he said, “Easier for a camel to enter through the eye of the needle”?
…
Questions Covered:
06:59 – How necessary is baptism for salvation? Also, how would you explain the Sedevacantist view of invincible ignorance? 17:06 – Could you clear up some misconceptions protestants have about the nature of salvation? For example, faith + works = salvation or faith = works + salvation. 28:47 – Why do we refer to angels like St Michael as saints? I thought that was something simply for humanity. 34:17 – Is necromancy the act of summoning those that are dead? Does it include interacting with them when they come to you and you didn’t summon them? 43:00 – What is the Catholic viewpoint on Mormons baptizing the dead? Do Catholics do this? 52:12 – What would the earliest forms of the Eucharist have looked like? What is the earliest rite in which we know the order of the mass or the liturgical calendar?
…
Questions Covered:
03:20 – My sister’s Catholic and married a Muslim in a mosque but they’re now getting divorced. She went to confession, but the priest said he could not give her reconciliation until she was divorced. Is that correct? 07:09 – I went to daily mass this morning and an elderly guy didn’t go up to communion because he had a hard time getting around. I thought the priest should have gone to him and offered it to him. Could I have broken mine in half to make up for an oversight by the priest? 13:11 – I was talking to a protestant friend about the Eucharist and I brought up 1 Corinthians 11. He said that doesn’t mean it’s the true body and blood but it’s just affirming your unbelief and hardening your heart. What are your thoughts on this? 18:33 – What happens to unborn babies before they’re born? Do they go to “limbo”? If so, how long do they stay there? 25:00 – Why do we think the Catholic Church needs to control people’s free will in response to Roe v Wade when God doesn’t control our free will? 35:23 – What are the authoritative teachings on the Church’s stance on homosexual acts? 43:40 – I come from a Calvinist background. Could you explain St. Augustine’s view of predestination and perseverance of the saints? 50:50 – Yesterday in the show the guest left me with the impression that the Blessed Mother didn’t need to be Immaculate to be the mother of Jesus. Is this true?
…
Questions Covered:
03:30 – Could Adam and Eve have fallen into sin without being tempted by the serpent? 05:08 – My wife passed away 3 years ago and haven’t gotten over it. The teaching of not being married in the afterlife really bothers me. Can you help clarify? 12:07 – Does the Church teach anything about trading in the stock market or crypto currency? 13:51 – I’m protestant, how do works play into salvation compared to sola fide? 31:02 – What is the Church’s current teaching on usury? 37:19 – How literal do we take the verse: “Many are called, but few are chosen?” 43:53 – Why does Mary say “My God and My Savior” in Luke? How do we square her being perfect but needing a savior? 48:41 – How can we pray to saints and family members in light of bible verses about inquiring of spirits?
…
Questions Covered:
06:34 – What is the historical validity of the bible? 16:07 – When is it appropriate to say that a loved one is no longer in purgatory? 22:05 – When did the practice of intercessory prayer originate? Why is Calvin’s objection to intercession being a pagan practice false? 33:43 – How can we know that Mary did not fall into personal sin if she had free will? 39:38 – Are there any angels higher than the archangels? What do they do? 43:37 – Why did God decide to incarnate Jesus at that point in history? 49:18 – What is the response to the Buddhist claim that the Catholic God is a diluted being that thinks he created the world?
…
Questions Covered:
05:07 – How can we increase our justification in light of Gal. 3:15-18? 14:46 – Is it moral to play video games that call upon deities for power? 19:38 – Who was Melchizedek 28:37 – If the priest didn’t lay his hand on a person receiving confirmation, would the sacrament be valid? Is the validity through the chrism oil? 30:51 – Where is confession in the Bible? Also, isn’t it absurd to get your sins forgiven though someone who also sins? 34:01 – Does our guardian angel go into confession with us? How many beings are in the confessional at that moment? 39:19 – In the Catholic faith, what is the “ticket” to heaven? 40:29 – What should I do with a rosary that I no longer want? 45:11 – Are the 2 types of speaking in tongues?
…
Questions Covered:
06:35 – I’m starting the diaconate program. How do I navigate the formation process as an orthodox person while my bishop and diocese are not? 17:29 – Why do bad things happen to good people like the previous caller who lost his fiancé? 28:30 – A protestant asked me this: Would we be carrying/wearing electric chairs if Jesus was sacrificed on an electric chair today? 34:12 – How should I pray? Should I pray for a direct sign or pray for the ability to make a good decision? 41:15 – Is the phrase “God is slow to anger, and easy to please” biblical? 46:04 – I want to encourage Cy and know that we are praying for him. 51:17 – How do I find a spiritual director?
…
Questions Covered: 05:08 – Can we assume that St. Joseph was assumed into heaven like Mary? 08:35 – What are the parallels between Catholicism and classical theism? 17:15 – Is it possible for someone to live purgatory on earth? 21:35 – What options do I have as a Catholic if my child’s godparents are no longer Catholic? 29:20 – When do we take the bible literally and figuratively? 33:38 – How old do Catholics believe the earth is? How long do they believe it took God to create the cosmos? 36:44 – Do Psalm 32 and Deut. 32 point to a polytheistic understanding of heaven by the Israelites? 41:33 – How can Jesus judge the living and the dead as stated in the Creed? 44:02 – I’m considering conversion to Catholicism. The Marian dogmas are the main hang up. Where can I find more information on dogmas? 51:16 – Is it possible for the Church to add books to the bible? How could this happen? …
Questions Covered:
05:08 – When we commit mortal sin, besides confession, what else can we do to avoid purgatory? 14:32 – Why be Catholic and not just a Protestant Christian? 20:16 – I’m in a conversation with a Baptist and they asked: how do we know that tradition is divinely inspired? How do I respond? 31:14 – Acts 20:29-30 How do we know that the pope and priests aren’t the people that will lead people away from Christ? 37:30 – Why were other books like the Gospel of Thomas not included in the bible? Should they have been included since they mention more about the early life of Jesus? 46:12 – Is the Church able to teach heresy? Church indefectibility
…
Questions Covered:
04:46 – Can you explain the Eucharist specifically in terms of a sacrifice? 18:20 – In the Old Testament did the Levitical priest have the power to forgive sins or did they merely pronounce God’s Forgiveness? 31:15 – Regarding Judah’s death is Acts 1:18 or Mt 27:5 true? 35:38 – Is the blood of Christ on the cross the same substance as the blood in the Eucharist? 44:54 – Is speaking in tongues the babbling of the Holy Spirit? 51:16 – Does needing to go to confession after baptism lessen the efficaciousness of baptism itself?
…
Questions Covered:
22:00 – do they say that you can’t receive the Eucharist if you’ve committed a mortal sin? 33:37 – Is there a correlation between the Eucharist and how we are made in the image of the Holy Trinity? 45:12 – How often is the Eucharist supposed to be offered and why? 47:45 – I did RCIA under Dr. Feingold and am a recent convert. Can you talk about why God chooses to use physical things to be bridges to the eternal? 52:30 – I’m a Lutheran, why do Catholics have the sacrificial part? I don’t see it.
…
Questions Covered:
21:15 – My daughter has bipolar and is in and out of hospitals. How do I fight hopelessness if nothing changes? 30:50 – My 15-year-old daughter struggles with anxiety and depression. How can I help her as a mother? 38:05 – I’m training to be a childhood counselor. Can you give me preventative advice to avoid anxiety, depression and hopelessness? 38:03 – The thing that helped me was to draw a line in the sand. And not let the darkness in. 51:16 – Do you have recommendations on things I can do and say to help our society that is so politically divided? We no longer see each other as neighbors, and it causes lots of anxiety.
…
Questions Covered:
02:15 – I’m protestant, I grew up thinking Catholic symbolism was idol worship. Where did we go wrong in that thinking? 10:10 – Is God both merciful and just? How does this manifest itself on the cross? 17:00 – Is the idea that Anglicanism is not valid an indefinite teaching in the Catholic Church? 22:06 – Both cremation and communion in the hand became permissible in the 1960’s. A. What’s the most proper way of disposing of a body? B. When and why did communion in the hand become universal? 30:01 – Why isn’t the Church using extraordinary ministers of holy communion or deacons to go give communion at hospitals? 32:09 – If Jesus is all merciful and we should be like him, should we be imprisoning murderers and thieves? 37:52 – What is the Church’s stance on the Old Catholic Church? 44:15 – What is the significance of doing a pilgrimage? What is the best way to prepare for one? 47:56 – Is it ok for Catholics to cross-dress in situations like theater or cosplay? What’s the best way to respond to the pro-abortion reply that Catholics are pro-life because it was started in a time of misogyny? 52:43 – Jesus said, “Let the dead bury the dead.” Did he mean physically or spiritually?
…
Questions Covered:
15:40 – What should we expect to experience once we die? How will our nature change? 20:00 – we called to give to the poor even if we know there will be no change? 25:00 – What are your thoughts on women being inserted into the dicastery of bishops? 34:43 – Is there a scriptural basis for the two different judgments? 38:35 – I just got out of the hospital. An Anglican priest came to visit and give me communion. Is this valid for Catholics to receive? Is it common to have communion wrapped in plastic packaging? 46:52 – The catechism says that if you help someone that’s doing something wrong, you’re held accountable. How would this be applicable to the caller who asked about helping her family?
…
Questions Covered:
10:39 – How do we reconcile Vatican 2 teaching on Muslims with the rest of the Church’s historical teaching? 18:00 – If God can’t go contrary to his nature and he is good then how can he do evil as said in Isaiah 45:7? 22:10 – How is mental illness handled in Christianity specifically dealing with multiple personalities? 31:32 – How do we tell the difference between saintliness and mental stability? 44:52 – How do we reconcile the 4th Lateran Council and Vatican 2 on no salvation outside of the Church? 50:48 – Do Jews believe that God created evil?
…
Questions Covered:
03:55 – Is there any reason we should think that Adam was given a rational soul at the moment of his conception? 10:28 – What would be the best way to respond to protestants when they try to claim that St. Augustine believed protestant doctrine? 14:55 – Why does the Catechism say that we go to heaven, hell or purgatory right after death if scripture says differently? Why does the Catechism say there are 2 judgements? 21:00 – Has Christ provided everything for our salvation? 22:40 – Who are the people who Cain was afraid of after he was exiled? 28:38 – Do I lose salvation for not going to a Catholic Church? Is the Eucharist essential for salvation? 32:47 – When Jesus died, the curtain was torn into two. What’s the significance of that in our Christian life? 35:40 – In the Old Testament, how can people believe in false gods especially when they were tested, and nothing happened? When people that go through RCIA and go into the church turn away from the church, are they held accountable for their actions? 43:29 – Revelation 12:9-12 says that St. Michael will fight with the devil. What exactly does that mean? 48:43 – Follow up on torn veil question: Rending one’s garments was used as a form of mourning. This meaning can also be used to describe the veil being torn in two. 50:38 – What are your thoughts on us having unused DNA and us possibly using it in the next life?
…
Questions Covered:
01:12 – I’m not Catholic because of a long series of Socratic conversations with Catholics who don’t have a complete understanding. I don’t think they are intellectually honest. 15:53 – I’m contemplating leaving Catholicism. I have a problem with the idea that missing Sunday mass is a mortal sin. 28:30 – I’m not Catholic because of the Council of Nicaea and how they changed the Sabbath to Sunday. 44:20 – I’m not Catholic because of Daniel 7:25. 50:53 – I just converted to Catholicism because the Episcopal church changed when it came to sexual ethics.
…
Questions Covered:
06:19 – I was raised in the Pentecostal Church and taught that Catholics were beer drinking cursing heathens that pray to Mary. 17:45 – I used to be very Baptist but now believe that Catholics are the only ones that haven’t caved to the world. Though Amoris Laetitia now shows me a lack of consistency in the Church. 29:00 – What evidence is there for the papacy? What sources do you recommend I read? 35:05 – I’m not Catholic anymore because I went to a protestant pastor, and he prayed over me and the demonic spirits that were haunting me left. When I went to a priest nothing happened. 46:46 – I’m Catholic but my soon-to-be wife is not Catholic. She says everything makes sense but says she can’t be Catholic. Do you have any advice? 51:50 – Why does it take so long to be a Catholic? Why did Luther take the 7 books out of the bible?
…
Questions Covered:
06:17 – I’m a new Catholic, can you help me understand the devotion to the infant Jesus? 11:39 – How do I approach someone who is not Catholic to come to mass, but they have a history of receiving communion at Catholic churches? 21:03 – How do I respond to someone who claims Marian apparitions are demonic apparitions because demons can appear as creatures of light? 28:28 – What does the Church teach about dreams? Can they be sinful? 35:31 – Why do we not hear Act 19:18 when discussing the sacrament of reconciliation? Is the verse relevant? 44:02 – What is the sin that cannot be forgiven? What is the sin against the Holy Spirit? 48:11 – Does Corinth 6:3 prove that humans are above angels? 53:05 – What’s the relationship between mercy and justice?
…
Questions Covered:
11:50 – Does Judaism believe in hell, the devil or the antichrist? 18:42 – What does the scapular promise, and how does one obtain the promises? 23:38 – What’s the definition of apologetics? It doesn’t make sense since you’re not apologizing. 28:49 – Archbishop Cordileone refused communion to Pelosi but Pope Francis blessed her and gave her communion. Who’s right? 40:43 – What did Jesus mean when he told his followers, “let the dead bury the dead?” 46:48 – I’m going to take a program on massage therapy, and they will cover some eastern spiritual forms of therapy. How should I approach this? 49:56 – I’m a convert. Can a fallen away Catholic still go to heaven?
…
Questions Covered:
04:42 – Has the Catholic Church changed its understanding of time based on Purgatory? Is the purgation process meritorious for salvation? 15:49 – Is a sin truly forgiven completely after confession? Can you share an example of a priest not forgiving someone in confession? 23:34 – I’m not Catholic. How do I forgive the sin of my husband’s past who has Alzheimer’s? 32:30 – How can you tell the difference between personal thoughts and God’s calling? 40:39 – Not a listener, our number was recommended… How can I be true to my Catholic faith while also respecting the people around me with different views? 50:02 – How can someone like Adam or Angels choose something evil knowing that it’s evil?
…
Questions Covered:
02:40 – Why would the soldiers cast lots for Jesus’ clothing? They were dirty and bloody, why would they want them? 11:27 – Does 2 Tim 3:16 refer to the New Testament? How do non-Catholics know that scripture is inspired? 19:30 – Does the bible support a plant-based diet? 28:48 – Did all the people that were condemned to be killed by the Israelites deserve to be killed? 33:30 – Is the term mustard seed in the bible actually supposed to be mulberry seed? 36:54 – Regarding 1 Corinth 13:8-10, what is the Catholic interpretation and perspective on speaking in tongues? 47:50 – I heard that the devil attacks us 4 times at the moment of our death. Is this supported anywhere in the bible? 50:22 – How do we reconcile all the weird laws in the Old Testament?
…
Questions Covered:
09:15 – Do Exodus 21:22 and Numbers 5:28 support the pro-choice position? 20:21 – How was Mary conceived without original sin? 35:25 – Where is confirmation in the bible? 48:50 – What are the origins of Adam?
…
Questions Covered:
01:20 – I’m a protestant considering converting. Why was it wrong for protestants to take books out of the bible? What should I buy a Catholic bible? 11:53 – In Ender’s Game, the villains are a hive mind. If the protagonist kills the queen, resulting in the death of the entire population, is he culpable of the death of one or of many? 16:51 – 1 Corinth. 5 How do we know where to draw the line when it comes to expelling members of the Church? 21:12 – Who is the Harlot in Revelation? 28:31 – Can you explain the difference in translation in Ex 21:22 in the NKJV vs Douay Rheims. Is the woman fined or punished by death? 33:24 – Why are people concerned about the charismatic renewal in the Church? How ecumenical can we be towards other charismatic protestants? 44:13 – What is the Church doing for people who are willing to adopt? Are there funds or grants available? 47:24 – Were there any protestant beliefs within the early Church? 52:02 – Could you recommend a biography of G.K. Chesterton and a book by him? www.chesterton.org
…
Questions Covered:
03:53 – Is Mt. 24. about the destruction of the temple in 70 A.D.? 15:12 – What happens if someone receives their first communion in mortal sin? Do they have to re-do it? 16:52 – My company just announced that they will begin funding employees travel for abortion. What should I do? 19:04 – I hear people always describe the Church with “Truth, beauty, and goodness.” What exactly does that mean? 29:10 – Is it sinful to engage in traditions or practices belonging to another religion, as I have friends of other faiths and enjoy experiencing how they live? 31:27 – Jn 10:28, does Jesus teach eternal security with this passage? 35:53 – If an item can be touched to a 1st class relic and become a relic itself, why can’t we do the same with the Eucharist since it is God Himself? 35:53 – If an item can be touched to a 1st class relic and become a relic itself, why can’t we do the same with the Eucharist since it is God Himself? 42:50 – What would need to happen between confessional Lutherans and Catholics in order to promote unity? 46:48 – Is it ok to read books like Stephen King books, Game of Thrones, etc? 50:28 – Why do we have two judgments? How would the general judgment work for people who have passed away?
…
Questions Covered:
08:09 – Does the Dobbs decision outlaw procedure for ectopic pregnancies? 10:08 – Do you think they will try to overturn other laws like interracial marriages? 12:04 – Are there any laws that protect pregnancy centers especially with the danger that they face after Dobbs? 28:40 – Could we now force men to have vasectomies to avoid pregnancy?
…
Questions Covered:
23:44 – Would the football coach case also affect religions we don’t like? 29:35 – Did the justices address the rights of the child in the Dobbs decision? https://www.catholic.com/magazine/online-edition/what-is-the-deal-with-dobbs-v-jackson
…
Questions Covered:
06:47 – Could you unpack Mark 11:22-25? What is the proper interpretation of these verses? 14:38 – How do we respond to people who try to discredit Peter as the rock by saying that Jesus is the true rock? https://www.catholic.com/tract/peter-the-rock 21:34 – If baptism by desire is true and miscarried babies can also be saved, will they also receive their perfected bodies after the resurrection? 32:09 – Does Mt 6:7-9 contradict repetitively praying for a soul who I assume might be in purgatory? Can baptized Catholics be claimed by demons since they’ve already been claimed by Christ? 43:33 – Do people have to have miracles attributed to them in order to be canonized? 47:56 – Does anywhere in Church teaching allow for charging fees for the sacraments? Is charging fees for sacraments licit? 52:13 – I’m not a Catholic and am really interested in apostolic succession. Do you have any resources you can share?
…
Questions Covered:
06:10 – Can a baptized protestant receive grace when worshiping God? 16:15 – I hear Christians say that it’s not about religion it’s a relationship? How would you respond to that? 19:40 – Does everyone in heaven get to have the beatific vision? 30:10 – Why is sacramental confession required to receive the Eucharist? 37:55 – How does Genesis 3:15 refer to Mary if it states that the woman would have labor pains and Catholics claim that she didn’t experience them? 47:09 – Does the New Testament teach that Mary had other children? Were there other people more holy than Mary?
…
Questions Covered:
15:37 – What can parishes do to support women through pregnancy in general? What legislation can we support? 31:15 – My daughter is pro-life but is concerned about the Dobbs decision. She worries that this will be harmful to those sexually assaulted and pregnant. How do you respond to this claim? 34:25 – What strategies to we have to support those who are pregnant through rape or incest? 38:20 – Are there any biblical text that show that abortion is wrong? 42:44 – How can we address the concerns of the father in regard to abortion? 46:20 – We need more young passionate women like Molly! 49:39 – How can I start a conversation with pro-choice family members? How do I break the ice? Resource – Wewerebornready.com
…
Questions Covered:
13:31 – Concerning evolution, did the early world believe in a literal interpretation of Genesis? Was it a dogmatically approved belief until evolution was discovered? 20:33 – Was Jesus expecting his disciples to follow the sabbath on Saturday? When did it develop to Sunday? 32:47 – Did the Church develop from baptizing in the name of Jesus to a Trinitarian formula? 38:06 – Are there any doctrines that are developing right now in regard to governments legislating morality or moral laws? 45:15 – Has the Church tried to clarify the understanding of the Trinity? How do we justify this development with the early Church’s understanding of God? 50:18 – How do we square the death penalty not being intrinsically evil with the most recent change in the catechism?
…
Questions Covered:
05:07 – Why aren’t we thanking Donald Trump more for appointing 3 conservative justices? 21:02 – I’m noticing a lot of calls for violence against Catholic churches online. What do we do? 31:40 – Do you have any advice on how to start a conversation with friends who are ex-Catholic and very upset with the decision? 36:51 – In regard to how we can respond, how did the early Church respond to a culture of infanticide? 43:17 – How can anyone celebrate this decision? We condemned people who have been raped.
…
Questions Covered:
19:04 – Why isn’t abortion overturned for the whole nation since Roe allowed it for the whole nation? 32:05 – What should the punishment be for those involved with abortion where it’s illegal? 44:30 – How do I prove that life begins at conception? Resource: https://www.catholic.com/magazine/print-edition/how-to-prove-life-begins-at-conception 48:10 – How can we engage in discussion with people who don’t acknowledge human life in the womb?
…
Questions Covered:
02:51 – If a bishop proclaimed that we should all stand during the consecration, would we be obliged to abide by it? 06:07 – What should happen to the eucharist in the monstrance if the adoration chapel is closed overnight? 10:23 – My husband just bought the book of Enoch. Is it ok for him to read? 13:39 – Does doing good works out of mere responsibility merit anything good? 19:09 – In the Hail Holy Queen what does “After this exile” mean? What are your thoughts on RH- blood? Can you do a mysterious world episode? 22:50 – Protestants claim that its clear which books are in the bible so sola scriptura isn’t needed. What is your response? 32:36 – Aquinas says we should pay latria to the cross. Doesn’t this conflict with the teaching of latria to only God? 36:25 – How would you respond to a protestant who says that in the Old Testament they didn’t have a magisterium, so we don’t need one now? 41:03 – Does the church teach anything on circumcision and is it ethical in our current time? 43:43 – Do we have a responsibility to stay within our own liturgical rite? 48:24 – What’s the history of offering bread and wine as a sacrifice leading up to the time of Jesus? 51:29 – What should I do with the ashes of a cremated Catholic? 52:32 – Which is a better translation: the NAB or the Jerusalem bible?
…
Questions Covered:
04:34 – How can Catholics claim that there is no list of people in hell but invoke anathemas in the councils. How would I respond to this challenge from my Calvinist friend? 15:17 – How do we know that the universe did not happen because of a necessary process? Is a personal God necessary for creation? Could it just be an impersonal being that caused creation? 19:47 – How do we know that the first cause from Aquinas’ argument is God? 24:04 – What bible verses back the claim that we do not adore the Virgin Mary? Looks good 34:24 – Can saying the Lord’s prayer during mass act as a sort of act of contrition? Looks good 38:15 – Who are spiritual directors? Can they be laymen? When do you know if you need one? How do you find one? Looks good 44:02 – Is it possible for us to believe in the 7 days of creation, big bang, and evolution? 47:30 – How is it possible for the Catholic Church to have eastern saints post schism? 50:40 – Would it make sense to say that the Islamic forces interrupting communications between Christians caused the Great Schism?
…
Questions Covered: 01:00 – Weddings 22:47 – We rented out a restaurant and the mothers paid for it. It only costed $2500 29:48 – Move the wedding to earlier in the day for brunch to make it cheaper. The Prolife movement history 49:30 – Trauma post abortion 51:50 – Killing of abortion providers …
Topics Covered:
government funding private schools School losing the Catholic title due to flying the BLM and LGBT flags
…
Questions Covered:
04:57 – When Jesus was walking up to the cross and fell 3 times, did that signify the Father, Son and Holy Spirit? 10:10 – Could there be significance in correlating the number of words in a verse to stress the importance in scripture? Send Words of Eternal Life 17:27 – Would God allow suffering even if nothing good were to come from it? 23:24 – Why did women stop covering their heads in Church? 34:26 – St. Gertrude received a prayer to save souls in purgatory. Why don’t we promote this or is this a valid prayer? 41:34 – Does the Catholic Church have a teaching on what happens to us after we die? 45:55 – I’m a new Catholic. When is it appropriate to ask God for help rather than appeal to Mary? 51:02 – I’m starting a bible study with half non-Catholics; how do I market properly to all? 53:30 – I’m not Catholic but my husband is. Why do I have to become Catholic if we are all children of God?
…
Questions Covered:
04:51 – How does Molinism not confirm double predestination? 14:06 – How does St. Jude’s intercession come into play when asking for his help? 20:54 – Would it be abusing confession if you keep bringing up the same mortal sin repeatedly? 28:54 – If Mary was sinless, then how is it that she did not fulfill the law? 34:53 – Why do Christians still say Yahweh if the Vatican specifically wrote that we shouldn’t be using the word. 40:25 – Why did God pick Mary to be Jesus’ mother? 45:22 – The Council of Florence claimed that circumcision is mortally sinful. When did that thought change? 49:50 – Have there been any saints throughout history that have had demons exorcized out of them?
…
Questions Covered:
04:43 – Is it unchangeable teaching that women can’t priests, and same sex marriages can’t be blessed? 14:51 – Was the public school system created by the Catholic Church? Do you have resources on this topic? 19:04 – I’m in conversion with a missionary of the LDS Church. I’ll be sitting down with him soon. What questions and topics should I bring up to be a good representative of the Catholic Church? 24:13 – Mk 15 on Jesus’ death. What is the meaning of the tearing of the curtain in the temple in two? 33:35 – It’s important to have Juneteenth. We need to keep in mind that white people were not the only ones to own slavery. 44:13 – Is it a mortal sin to not believe that Mary is a perpetual virgin? Where does the Catholic Church get the importance of this teaching? 49:49 – Hebrew 8:6-8. How do I explain that God didn’t want us to fail but accounted for us failing?
…
Questions Covered:
07:58 – Is there a degree of reverence for digital images? Do they equate to printed versions? 15:33 – Why are we Catholics still not receiving communion from the chalice compared to the Episcopalians? Everyone else receives from the chalice except us. 20:14 – What does scripture mean when it says, “God gave to the hand of David the Philistines?” 23:32 – How do I respond to the question, “why are the majority of Catholic saints white?” Is this true? Does this mean that Catholicism is a white people’s religion? 37:13 – Is commemorating Juneteenth during mass appropriate since it is so political? 50:10 – Regarding the book of Revelation, In what sense is the Church the new Jerusalem? How is that contrasted to our understanding of the Church as the Body of Christ? 52:57 – Which translation of the bible is better to have, the RSV or the NAB?
…
Questions Covered:
01:29 – I am not Catholic because the relationship with the apologetic individuals being complicit with wrong. 07:39 – I am not Catholic because of the teaching on Papal infallibility. 14:09 – I am not Catholic because of the Assumption of Mary becoming a Dogma. 24:40 – I am on my way out of being Catholic because I can’t wrap my head around some rituals and the definition of the Eucharist. 36:25 – I am not Catholic because of inconsistency about priest not being able to be married based on 1 Timothy 4: 1-5. 45:54 – I am not Catholic because I am skeptical of most religions. 52:05 – I am not Catholic because I am not a believer in the event or the philosophy.
…
Questions Covered:
06:48 – I’m not Catholic because my Catholic coworkers tend to share an over importance on Mother Mary. 18:32 – I am not Catholic because I’m a member from the Episcopal Church. I believe the women in the Gospel were also Apostles. 30:29 – I am not Catholic because I was raised Catholic, but I was turned down when trying to get married in the Catholic Church. I also can’t support the Pope. 40:00 – I am not Catholic because Sola Scriptura. 46:27 – I am not Catholic because the foundational doctrine doesn’t make sense. 51:45 – I am not Catholic because the relationship with the apologetic individuals being complicit with wrong.
…
Questions Covered:
18:44 – What local events were used to prove the validity of this Marian apparition? 22:55 – What can I do in preparation for a visit? 32:02 – Is it possible that Mary appeared to Native American before Caucasian North Americans? 33:34 – My husband had an apparition of me while on military leave. What is the church’s teaching on this? 38:00 – What did Mary mean when she said her son will punish those who don’t believe in him? 48:28 – What type of catechesis is available for the public who might be skeptical? 50:45 – What leads to an apparition not being approved and one being approved?
…
Questions Covered:
12:42 – Does the valid election of someone as Pope imply divine endorsement of the wisdom of that choice? 21:42 – Why do Catholics pray to the Saints? 29:45 – Which Protestant challenge do you find the most compelling or difficult to answer? Which aspect of Catholicism is the most misunderstood? 39:42 – When the Apostles raised souls from the dead in Acts, where did the souls come from? 46:06 – Where did specific prayers come from for the different Saints?
…
Questions Covered:
22:01 – How can I understand a rejection from seminaries based on having a disability like blindness? 36:12 – Can you explain how marriage is a vocation? 51:18 – Should I discern the Secular Franciscans?
…
Questions covered:
02:00 – What can we affirm about asexuality? What does the virtue of chastity have to do with it? 16:58 – What are some ways to keep Catholic children Catholic in a fallen world? 22:56 – Does the Church teach anything about pre-Adam races of humans? If there was a mix between Adam and a pre-Adam human, would they have the same dignity? 35:40 – I heard someone claim that the tearing of the veil indicated the end of the priesthood. Where did they get that idea and how can I respond? 44:00 – I’d like to issue a correction to the question about converting from an Eastern rite from last hour. 49:04 – If I die before converting, is there any way I can get last rites?
…
Questions Covered: 05:27 – What does apostolic succession mean? Would the laity be able to choose the next pope in a crisis? 15:40 – How is Sedevacantism wrong? 19:53 – Can I celebrate a friend’s entry into the Eastern Orthodox Church? 22:27 – What is the criteria that we should use to discern which Messianic prophecies should be used for proof-oriented research and which should be used for process-oriented research? 30:02 – How do I respond to my aunt who has left the Catholic Church considering hierarchical corruption? 41:53 – What do I do to become Catholic considering my previous baptisms in other denominations? 46:49 – Would Jesus “separate the weak from the chaff” before his Second Coming by withholding his grace? 52:07 – What is Opus Dei and its mission? …
Questions Covered: 14:48 – How do I encourage young people to live productive, meaningful lives? 29:14 – Station of the Cross Radio…What is the difference between a spiritual advisor and a life coach? 36:40 – Does Stand Tall do couples’ counseling or just individual direction? …
Questions Covered:
06:35 – Why do we say “For us men and for our salvation” instead of just “For our salvation” in the Nicene Creed? 11:40 – What changed in the teachings of the death penalty when Pope Francis changed the Catechism? Does that mean we were wrong this whole time? 16:17 – Can demons reveal accurate knowledge of the future to people they communicate with? 22:20 – Is there a theologian or doctor of the Church that can speak on how prayer affects daily living? 31:39 – How do we Catholics reconcile the tension between God’s active will and His permissive will as it pertains to divine inspiration? 39:11 – Hebrews 10:14. What does it mean by “perfected for all time?” 46:01 – Did Luke and Mark personally know Jesus? 50:16 – What is the Church’s teaching on people who claim to be Catholic and communicate with the dead?
…
Questions Covered:
04:41 – Is the supper of the lamb in Revelation referencing the eucharist rather than the end times? 16:31 – When the Father and the HS manifest at the Baptist and the Transfiguration, did the witnesses witness heaven and the beatific vision as well? How did the witnesses know who Jesus was talking to at the Transfiguration? 20:40 – I found evidence in the early church fathers that the eucharist was symbolic and also the understanding of transubstantiation. What are your thoughts on the symbolic evidence? 28:46 – What is the benefit of the Mass if you don’t receive communion? 32:20 – Does the Catholic Church teach that men and women are equal? 34:11 – If the material sufficiency view of scripture is true can’t protestants raise the same objections that Catholics use against them? 42:32 – What was the temple meant to be used for during the time of Christ? 47:23 – How would you explain transubstantiation to a protestant? 49:42 – I’m Reformed Protestant and still struggle with the concept of sin. Can you help clarify?
…
Questions Covered:
15:05 – My protestant friends say that they have an advantage to forgive their sins. How do I answer them that it’s not an advantage? 24:05 – If you haven’t done a sorrowful examination of conscience and forget to confess something. Do I just forget it or do I still have to confess it? Would it invalidate my confession? 34:39 – I’m a new Catholic and I struggle with going to confession because I work myself up too much. How do I keep it together in the confessional? Resource: Catholic Answers Focus Episode “The Surprising thing that Brings Jesus Joy” (https://www.catholic.com/audio/caf/the-surprising-thing-that-brings-jesus-joy) 42:41 – I’m protestant hoping to become Catholic. I find it more trustworthy to confess to a priest rather than just confessing to “one another.” 46:41 – What part of our sins are not remitted during confession? 53:04 – Can a validly baptized Christian go to confession and be validly absolved?
…
Questions Covered:
21:06 – My Non-Catholic husband doesn’t want to raise our kids Catholic. How do I approach this if I want to get them baptized Catholic? 29:12 – Do you have any references to check out on your discoveries in the Holy Land? 32:20 – How do you deal with extended family who are very anti-Catholic? 42:36 – How do we deal with facing secular culture, especially what’s on tv?
…
Questions Covered:
03:28 – What does it mean for us to be made in the image and likeness of God? 13:40 – How do I discuss the Eucharist with Protestant family members? 28:35 – I’m currently contemplating transition surgery to help get rid of self-harming urges. I would really appreciate knowing and trusting in the solidity of church teaching on this in spite of the changes perceived in response to LGBTQ issues? 36:30 – Do we have biblical evidence for the members of the trinity being distinct? 45:19 – If you’re struggling with your Catholic faith, how do you go about finding your identity in it? 51:28 – How can I defend my faith against Christadelphians?
…
Questions covered:
04:13 – Does mortal sin undo our adoption by God? 14:40 – If forgiveness releases us from what we owe someone, why do we still need to do something to fix it up? 31:49 – If we all receive the same graces at baptism, what’s the difference between the baptized Catholic who goes to heaven and the baptized Catholic who goes to hell? 43:23 – How do you respond to the Orthodox argument against the papacy that appeals to an apostolic constitution (34?) stating that bishops cannot interfere with each other? 51:39 – How do you help someone defend the natural moral law, especially in the context of teleological definitions of men and women like Trent’s?
…
Questions covered:
15:19 – My friend is a drug addict and tends to lash out a lot. I no longer want to be his friend and I’m not sure how to break the news to him. 18:20 – Is there a time and a place for righteous anger? If so, how do we discern whether our anger is righteous or sinful? 20:15 – How do we control our anger towards someone we know is never going to change? 23:41 – I’m not angry at my family, but I am angry at the force that is dividing us. How can we identify what is dividing us, and what should I do next? 34:16 – How can I talk to my atheist husband who uses the name of Jesus in vain? 40:14 – How can I deal with my husband’s anger problem? 43:09 – I had a conversation with somebody who got mad at me for becoming Catholic and I’m not sure if I handled it well. 47:21 – I heard that a lot of times anger comes from hurt. I’d like to know Dr. Ray’s thoughts on that.
…
Questions covered:
07:34 – How can I defend the Catholic canon of scripture to Protestants who don’t accept the Church councils? 15:57 – How do you defend the pro-life position against someone who says you must also be vegan? 25:06 – How do you answer someone who doesn’t believe in God’s plan in the context of miscarriage? 31:35 – How can Catholics rationalize the belief of Adam and Eve with evolution? 42:22 – What female apologists do you recommend? 49:29 – How can I respond to anti-Catholics who use 1 Tim 2:14 to say Adam was not deceived? 53:50 – What’s the difference between the word “saint” as used in the Bible and as we use it today?
…
Question Covered:
03:51 – Would it have been morally just for Elrond to have thrown Isildur into the fires of Mt Doom when he refused to destroy the One Ring, as a way to ensure its destruction? 14:02 – I have one question about The Chaplet of the Divine Mercy. I do not understand the words Eternal Father, I offer you the Body and Blood, Soul and Divinity of Your Dearly Beloved Son, Our Lord, Jesus Christ, in atonement for our sins and those of the whole world. Father and Son are One Divinity, right? So… how can I offer God to God when there is One God? 17:18 – Have there been any documentaries, or at minimum, speculations of people who have claimed to come back in time from the distant future (with perhaps a story to tell —and what is heading our way)? 20:06 – If you were involved in a teleportation accident that created a duplicate of you, would that person have to confess your sins? 23:40 – If Christ died to Redeem all, would alien scriptures reference an alien Redeemer, or are all aliens Unfallen, thus not needing Revelation and Salvation? Related to this, if Satan knew that the Incarnation would occur on Earth, did he then ignore aliens, thus leaving them Unfallen? Therefore, if and when Humanity travels to the stars, might we be the cause of their Fall? Continuing on this theme, since working with tools was a punishment due to Original Sin, it could be argued that technology is a sign of a Fallen species. Since we haven’t seen any evidence of ETs, might that be proof that aliens are Unfallen? 32:49 – What are your thoughts on Gulf War Syndrome? 39:45 – If a family wanted their child baptized in Klingon or a pre-Christian Babylonian language. Assuming an accurate but not Vatican-approved translation, would it be valid? This is obviously theoretical but speaks to the point of whether a translation or interpretation is assumed to be valid or not before any Vatican intervention on the text. 45:00 – Would it have been possible to hold a spelling bee in ancient Egypt? 48:50 – Did Adam and Eve have belly buttons? 51:45 – Is it possible for a species (such as an alien, or an understudied cephalopod) to have a powerful brain comparable to or even greater than our own, but not an immortal soul?
…
Questions Covered:
31:13 – I’m divorced and have a child with my ex. She remarried but I still battle with wanting her. Am I committing the sin of lusting over another man’s wife? 36:10 – My daughter in law is abusive to my son. Is there anything I can do as an outsider? 42:32 – My ex-husband decided that our marriage was over because the Holy Spirit wasn’t with us. He also had a porn addiction. Does a porn addiction play a role in the annulment process? 45:25 – Forgiveness of a habitual sin is necessary only when they are willing to be forgiven. 48:18 – What happens when you have a husband who proposed because a medium said he would marry a woman that looks like me? 51:27 – Does the unwillingness to have children after we’ve already had kids fall within your broad definition of infidelity?
…
Questions Covered:
06:46 – Why do we as Catholics believe that we are sinful by nature when we were created in the image likeness of God? 13:57 – When a person dies does a guardian angel get reassigned? 17:51 – How can I balance my Faith during so called Pride month? 29:37 – Where did the Church decide the order of the Mass? 40:57 – Do souls in heaven have eyes and other sensory capabilities? 50:08 – My son had said that it is unreasonable to expect a person with SSA to be celibate for their entire life. How do I respond?
…
Questions Covered:
03:40 – Why doesn’t the Acts of the Apostles match our current experience? Why does God seem so hidden now? 12:33 – Is sheep stealing unbiblical? What’s your opinion? 17:44 – Why is Hebrews considered a part of the canon since it is anonymous? 21:24 – When I read the Old Testament I become more critical of faith. Why does God care if the temple was precise? 32:57 – Why did God allow Solomon to have many wives but now it’s not allowed? 35:00 – In your book Daily Defense, why are the pronouns for God not capitalized? 42:49 – I work for the US Forest Service and we sometimes work for 14 days straight and am unable to get to mass. Should I confess this? 46:00 – How do we distinguish between thinking that we’re chosen for a grand plan from grandiose thinking? 49:17 – How can I be more susceptible to hearing the voice of God?
…
Questions Covered:
02:58 – I’m trying to find encouragement. I find myself more Catholic than the Catholic Culture around. Any advice? 12:33 – My father started a new church in our home and a year ago I began exploring and discovered the Mass. I have a lot of questions. How do I proceed? How do I discern if Catholicism is true? 19:57 – I see that in the Shroud the nails go through the wrists but in stories of stigmata the wounds happen in the hands. Should I not believe in these stories? 29:53 – Why do we need repetitive prayer like the rosary? 34:53 – How do I explain to my child that my recent ex-wife is engaged? As a Catholic how do I approach this? 40:30 – When is it appropriate, after entering the Church, to start considering a religious vocation? 43:52 – My granddaughter has been diagnosed with a tumor. We will be going to a healing Mass, what should we expect? 53:55 – Is the process of working through the doctrines a barrier of evangelization?
…
Question Covered:
14:31 – What would you say to someone struggling with Marian doctrine? 19:20 – What is allowed for Catholics to do with their bodies after death? Is decomposition allowed? 32:55 – It appears the Church puts Mary in a higher position than Jesus. What’s the teaching? 44:10 – In the Hail Holy Queen prayer it says that Mary is our life, sweetness and hope. Wouldn’t this be Jesus?
…
Questions Covered:
03:22 – do I move forward in Faith from personal experience to a more rooted understanding? How can I know that Christianity is true? 11:43 – Why would God do miracles in a Pentecostal church if it would lead them away from the Catholic Church? 24:30 – In Mt 26 it says that the disciples were eating before the consecration. Was there a meal beforehand? 29:19 – I’m also having trouble having faith in the Eucharist. Can you give me some guidance? 36:19 – After Adam and Eve, how many people were there? 40:55 – How do I explain apostolic succession to a Calvinist if they claim that succession was only needed during those years? 48:28 – Does the Church cast out demons and should every believer cast them out? 52:06 – Does Lev 21:9 concern burning the living or cremation?
Resources Mentioned:
Ad resurgendum cum Christo
…
Questions Covered:
03:09 – How do you tell the difference between purgatory and hell? 05:13 – Why are Christianity and Buddhism not compatible? 14:25 – Would the son of a married Catholic priest be able to become a married Catholic priest? 18:58 – I lost my 18 Y.O son to suicide. How do I make sense of this and what’s the Church’s understanding? Resource: When a Loved One Dies by Suicide – Ave Maria Press 31:08 – Why doesn’t God just eliminate Satan? 34:56 – What’s the official Church teaching on centering prayer by Thomas Keating and Christian meditation according to John Main? What are the concerns? 44:40 – My friend claims that the bible’s context was changed in different periods of time. How do I refute this? 52:31 – I’m Nigerian and in my home country Christians are being killed. In Lk. 22:36 it says that Christians should fight. Should we take up arms to fight back?
…
Questions Covered:
00:43 – The Church has precepts that relate to minimum standards of behavior (receive communion once during the Easter season, etc.) Are there also minimum standards of belief to be considered in communion with the Church? (For example The Trinity, Bible, virgin birth etc.) 04:38 – What do priests do when you confess to a murder? I’m pretty sure they can’t make turning yourself in a requirement for absolution, but it strikes me that “five hail marys and three our fathers” isn’t exactly going to cut it either. 07:56 – Exegetical questions: What does the unjust steward parable mean? Why is it considered inspired in a Psalm that we should crush the heads of babies? 19:04 – Recently during a homily, I heard that a piece of a person’s soul literally goes into the food they prepare. So, if the food is made by religious nuns the food will taste better because of the love in the food. On the other hand, if it is prepared by someone evil, the opposite will occur. Furthermore, he said that the traditional blessing of food is an exorcism to keep evil spirits away from your food, so you don’t consume them. Is this a teaching of the Catholic Church? 28:33 – What is the story with Lilith? I have people tell me she was Adam’s ‘first wife’ but they are usually getting that from a Discovery Channel alien show or something that their friend posted on FB. What is the truth? Is she in the Old Testament? Does the Catholic Church say anything about her? 34:30 – What is the exact status of the Coptic Orthodox Church in regards of small “o” orthodoxy? 44:14 – Which part of the Trinity is responsible for life? 48:15 – What was the nature of Holy Communion on the original Holy Thursday? As Our Lord had not risen yet it couldn’t have been His resurrected Body, right? 49:15 – If part of the Host were reserved on Holy Thursday would It have died on Good Friday and resurrected? 50:30 – During Mass the bread and wine become the Body and Blood of Our Lord as His Sacrifice is made present on the altar. We receive the resurrected Body of Christ. Is the Resurrection made present on the altar as well? If so, when?
…
Questions Covered:
01:39 – Why did Jesus say it was better for Judas to never have been born if it was because of Judas’ act that Jesus’ Passion and subsequent Resurrection was set in motion? Was Judas’ betrayal not necessary for this? 05:23 – Are there any Pseudepigraphal writings in the New Testament? If not, and if any are discovered, would that alter the canon? 14:03 – Do you favor the material sufficiency, partim partim view, or something else about scripture? Why do you hold to this position? 28:21 – My teen son always asks me why do we have to go to mass every Sunday? What is so important about going to mass? Also, why should we dress our best for Sunday mass? 32:18 – Is it correct to assert that there’s an ongoing eternal liturgy in Heaven? If so, why is that the case and what does it consists of? 35:45 – Currently there are Catholics who prefer the Tridentine Latin Mass. Pope John Paul II & Pope Benedict encouraged celebration of the Tridentine Latin Mass. Pope Francis is trying to regulate it & put the decision about the TLM in the hands of the local bishops because he perceives that there is division in the Church. In prior Church history was there ever another time when the form of liturgy was changed but some Catholics preferred the prior form & were given permission to celebrate Mass in the prior form? 42:59 – Given the limited number of people at the time of Adam and Eve, can it be inferred that incest not only occurred, but was necessary and, as such, can it be stated that incest is a circumstantial evil? 50:22 – If we can use medical advancements to cure diseases and perform surgeries, then why can’t we use advances in medicine to cure or correct birth defects genetically in the womb.
…
Questions Covered:
01:03 – What is the Catholic take on the Rapture? 06:45 – The Manual of Indulgences says that a priest is not present at the point of death the Church grants it. So does that mean that any Catholic can receive it if the other requirements are fulfilled. Am I interpreting this correctly? 14:12 – What are St. Augustine’s view on fraternal correction and when its obligatory 31:10 – I’m going to be confirmed on Saturday. Can I receive communion because I’m still having doubts about the real presence? 35:44 – Could you explain to me what it means that Mary is co-redemptrix? 42:49 – Why did Jesus appear to the women after the resurrection? How can we trust their accuracy if all accounts are different? 47:41 – Why did Constantine think he had the authority to change the sabbath from Saturday to Sunday? 49:56 – I’m Protestant considering conversion. I can’t make sense of the Marian teachings. Why was it important for Mary to remain sinless?
…
Questions Covered:
03:20 – A few years ago, I started a small apologetics ministry in Guatemala, but very few people seem to be interested in learning about the Catholic faith and how to defend it. Even some of my evangelical friends don’t appear to be much interested in learning about their own faith origins. Do you have any advice? 11:20 – What is the difference between the 10 commandments in Exodus 20 and Deuteronomy 5? 13:23 – Why does Jesus do so many miracles in the protestant churches when they are not in communion with the Catholic Church? I was received into the Catholic Church last Monday 9/5. As a Pentecostal Christian, I saw God do so many healings, signs, and wonders. Why? It gets confusing when He somehow approves them when they are so wrong on doctrine. Please help me to understand this. 21:04 – How many Extraordinary Ministers of Holy Communion (EMHC) is too many for a single Mass? Is there a canon law that all available priests must be made available during Mass to help in the liturgy of the Eucharist before appointing EMHCs? 29:03 – What is the Church’s teaching on adultery when someone is drunk? 34:01 – What does the Church require for the end of life? I know you can’t deny water etc. 44:59 – I understand the theology behind Marian consecration but the language still bothers. Could a reasonable Catholic believe that Marian consecration is excessive? 48:45 – What’s the difference between Divination and Divinization?
…
Questions Covered:
01:15 – The Bible is called the word of God. Jesus is also called the Word of God. What is the difference between them? I have heard one person argue that because the Bible and Jesus are the Word of God and the Word of God is God, the Bible is also God. I know most people don’t believe this, but using the same word for each is kind of confusing. Why are both the Bible and Jesus each called the word of God, and what is the difference between them? 12:25 – Reading church history, one thing that is clear to me from the early fathers on up is that bishops were not allowed to move dioceses–a bishop was elected to one diocese and he stayed there till death. This was even inserted into the canons of Nicaea and observed throughout the Middle Ages. Sometime between the end of the Middle Ages and today this changed, because now Bishops are routinely transferred from one diocese to the next. I don’t know when this happened or why and I would like to know what made the Church change its thinking here. 18:25 – From a Catholic perspective, what is the proof the Bible is both inspired and inerrant? 22:30 – In the interest of a family member that wants their ashes spread in the mountains, I really need to know if Church teaching/Canon law would allow me to enter a portion of the ashes. I’d like firm information to go on, please! 30:30 – What will the new heaven and earth be like? 34:15 – How important is it for Catholics to obtain a plenary indulgence (corporal works of mercy) and offer to the poor souls in purgatory? I never hear apologists’ comment, condone, or approve of this practice. 40:12 – My 13-yo would like to know that if the Catholic Church is built on faith, and God was scientifically proven to exist, would we still need the Church? 48:55 – What might life have been like if not for the Fall? 51:10 – If the Holy Spirit is needed to believe in Jesus, How did the apostle believe in Jesus if the Holy Spirit hadn’t descended yet until Pentecost? 52:50 – If there were other fallen intelligent species on Earth (Sasquatches, whatnot), would Christ’s death have saved them too?
…
Questions Covered:
02:14 – Where are the Pope and the Church in this abortion debate? Why is Biden being supported? 07:41 – Does 2 Corinthians 5:21 teach Imputation as many Protestant scholars say? The Bible cross references and church fathers point to Rom8.3 to say, “made sin” means “sent in the likeness of sinful flesh”. 17:40 – What are the inherent problems with penal substitutionary atonement? 21:45 – Has the Church officially condemned the idea that it’s the community (not the priest) who consecrates the Eucharist? Or that consecration is not valid unless the community is present? 23:25 – Was God a corpse? If it is right to call Jesus God because of the hypostatic union, does that mean it is right to call Jesus’ corpse, while in the tomb, God?? 32:54 – Is it probable that cryptids exist? 40:12 – Are Catholics bound under pain of mortal sin to refuse to watch, or stop watching as soon as it happens once, movies where God’s name is taken in vain? 42:40 – Is Jesus our father in heaven? 44:45 – Is the conversion of the Jews prior to Jesus 2nd coming Catholic dogma? 46:46 – Historical comparison question: has the Church experienced its current level of schism and recovered without major splits? 48:40 – Why don’t we believe in Limbo anymore? 52:20 – In Acts 13, who was the guy who was friends with Herod and why is that such an important attribute to note in scripture? “Manaen who was a close friend of Herod the tetrarch”
…
Questions Covered:
02:23 – What I found important in helping convert atheists is prayer. What are your thoughts on this? 16:01 – What do I do if I have nobody in my life and I’m wanting to find guidance? I also want guidance to explore Catholicism. 24:16 – How do you respond to someone who says that you don’t need a priest to have your sins forgiven? 33:50 – I’m having surgery and will be under for 6 hours. Is it appropriate to ask for the anointing of the sick? 40:47 – Could you explain Mary as the Co-Redemptrix? 50:22 – What does it mean to be fully consecrated to Mary?
…
Questions Covered:
06:37 – Has the Church ever taught geo-centrism as a definitive teaching? 15:20 – I debated Patrick back in 1992 when I was an evangelical and I am Catholic now! I wanted to say hello! 19:09 – My problem with Catholicism is the teaching in Amoris Laetitia on divorced people being able to receive communion. What about the other spouse? 22:44 – How are we not going to sin in heaven? 30:47 – How do I go about converting my friend to Catholicism? 37:24 – Why is it that Jesus had to return to heaven as opposed to staying here on earth? 42:50 – Why would my current wife have to fill out paperwork if I want to file for an annulment from a previous marriage? 45:52 – Is it a sin to not stop someone from gossiping? 47:55 – If Jesus called Judas a devil, does that mean he condemned him? 50:44 – What are your thoughts on burying a statue of St. Joseph upside down to sell your house?
…
Questions Covered:
05:30 – Why do Catholics deny the idea of once saved always saved if in 1 Jn 3:6 it says, “Whoever keeps sinning has not known Jesus?” 15:11 – With the recent mass shooting in Texas, is it safe to infer that God does not intervene in these situations due to the respect he has for free will? 21:36 – What’s the Catholic perspective on the marriage of two protestants? Would the Church consider it a valid marriage? https://www.catholic.com/audio/caf/did-jesus-allow-some-divorce 28:42 – If Christ gave himself fully for our sins why did he pray “Let this cup pass from me?” I know Catholics reject penal substitution. 34:51 – Sirach 24:1-16 says that Jesus was created, and we proclaim in the Creed that he was “born of the Father before all ages.” So, is he created? 40:43 – Do you believe the phrase “God doesn’t give you more than you can handle” is incompatible with the Catholic faith? 48:02 – I’m watching The Chosen, and I saw before their meals they say the prayer “Blessed are you God…” but we as Catholics say “bless us oh Lord…” When did we start making this prayer centered on us instead of God? 52:04 – How do we Catholics understand the bible especially since we’re told that the bible has changed multiple times?
…
Questions Covered:
03:26 – If Mary was conceived without sin, how does it not detract from Christ’s divinity? 24:11 – Does God know if God knows if we are going to heaven or hell? If so, why would he create someone to go to hell? 42:03 – What’s the consensus on what’s going to happen after the general judgment? 49:50 – I’ve started feeling uncomfortable praying before meals in public. Is it ok for me to pray in the car so I won’t have to pray in public? 52:44 – Are the marriages in the Old Testament where the couple remained chaste different from the marriages today that require the marriage to be consummated?
…
Questions Covered:
06:04 – Where is hope in the phrase “Faith working through love?” 11:42 – What is the Catholic view on Luther’s 95 theses? Do you have any resources to continue my study on it? 17:49 – How does a person whose mute participate in the sacrament of reconciliation? 23:05 – How do I respond to a protestant who does not believe in regenerative baptism because they say it can be used as a get out of jail free card? 28:37 – Jesus told his disciples that he was going to resurrect and when he did, why were they stupefied? Why, if Jesus had prepared them? 34:53 – Do you know any stories of any impaired people who had near death experiences and remembered a conversation that was had near them that they normally wouldn’t because of their sensory impairment? 43:12 – Regarding the changes of the Mass after Vatican 2. I go to the new mass, and I’m constantly bombarded by traditionalists. Is it true that they changed the 7 sacraments?
…
Questions Covered:
11:43 – You’re using a lot of emotional language. Why should people object to their decision to choose their gender? 18:41 – I’ve never heard of consecrated virginity until recently. Until when do we start exploring that option? 23:30 Children in the womb are given hormones that make them more masculine or feminine, that is why we have so much confusion. 33:04 – What would you say to someone who struggles with pornography? 36:52 – Could you give me resources on what chastity looks like for a married couple? 42:49 – Wouldn’t the proper term for transgender more accurately be called “tran-neutured?” Is it actually possible to change genders? 46:15 – How does one remain chaste in today’s society when the world only focuses on physical satisfaction? 48:33 – Is it true that women like to fool around before marriage? 51:29 – Hopkins used to do gender reassignment surgeries and stopped because of the high depression rates. Now they are doing them again. Why do you think that is?
Resources Mentioned:
Catholic Answers Live from April 23, 2018: Fr. Hugh Barbour – “Sex After Marriage”
…
Questions Covered:
07:03 – I have non-Catholic friends who asked me to preside at their wedding. Is this acceptable? 22:01 – Why don’t Catholics ever bring up the Magnificat as evidence for Mary’s importance? 29:01 – How do I reconcile the differences between these two verses? Mk. 9:40 and Mt. 12:30. 35:27 – What makes the St. Michael Scapular different from a talisman? 39:37 – What’s your opinion on the Sworn Book of Honorius and Solomonic Magic? 44:24 – In John 17, Is that the prayer that Jesus prayed in the garden? Can you recommend books on the early Church? 48:50 – Do Plenary indulgences wipe away all consequences in one fell swoop? 51:17 – Why doesn’t the USCCB come out with a statement about the difference between Church teaching and opposing opinions by Catholic politicians?
…
Questions Covered:
17:15 – Is there a cessation of apostolic gifts? 23:14 – Is it morally acceptable for a supreme court nominee to lie in order to get on the court to strike down abortion? 35:32 – Who are the watchers mentioned in the book of Enoch? 41:10 – I grew up believing in the rapture. I was recently told that it’s wrong but was never told what is right. What do Catholics believe? 48:37 – How can you be absolutely sure that Christianity is the right religion? 52:25 – How does a physician tell a patient who is near the end that it’s going to be ok?
…
Questions Covered:
03:33 – I heard that historically confessions were in groups and out loud. I heard that they only confessed major mortal sins but not the more minor mortal sins. Is this true? 11:59 – How do I stay focused on God with secular friends? 14:48 – Micah 5:5-6 Prophecy of the messiah. Did this happen in history and how do we interpret this? 20:38 – Is it morally permissible to help fathers return to their families even though they are not married? Would I possibly be bringing people to cohabitation? 22:56 – Could you explain typology as a method for interpreting the bible? 35:06 – Let’s have a time machine and go back in time to the time of Moses. If I tried to touch the Ark of the Covenant, would I be ok since I’m fulfilled through the new covenant? 42:01 – My non-denominational sister claims that when scripture says “you need to be born of water and spirit” it means amniotic fluid and not baptism. How do I respond? 49:35 – Is it better to not have kids because of how bad the world is? 52:50 – Why is it that we are still left with the effects of the Fall after Christ’ redemption?
…
Questions Covered:
8:00 – With corporations now offering their employees funding to cross state lines to get abortions, how should a Catholic handle this? 22:45 – I’ve learned about alternative coffee shops that donate to pro-life causes. Is that something to consider doing? 29:02 – Could you explain how you are a married priest? 31:35 – How do you go about having a relationship without including sexual immorality in order to create a Catholic culture? 44:11 – I’m interested in writing novels. How can I include my faith in that kind of work?
…
Questions Covered:
02:58 – My biggest issue with the Church is language. You use similar words for different meanings. 19:22 – I’m not Catholic because I don’t know which religion to follow since there’s so many different churches out there. I just believe in Jesus. 30:06 – I was brought up protestant and have recently felt the call to be Catholic. Why did Jesus descend into hell? Where do I start to be Catholic? 36:42 – I’m not Catholic because I don’t believe in Jesus, who I believe is just a fictional character in a book. 48:29 – I’m not Catholic because it seems like a labor-intensive religion.
…
Questions Covered:
05:35 – My husband isn’t Catholic anymore because he doesn’t think God is good. How can I respond? The problem of evil is his big objection. 14:12 – I’m not Catholic because they don’t pray directly to God. Why is that? 20:35 – I’m not Catholic because I grew up as a southern Baptist and had all the preconceived notions that a Baptist has. I am feeling drawn to the Church. Where do I start? 24:31 – I’m not Catholic because I can’t fully comprehend the Eucharist. 35:13 – I was raised Catholic and fell away because I just didn’t care and was later baptized non-denominational. 42:25 – My girlfriend is not Catholics because we do strange things like the sign of the cross. 46:00 – The early Church was not the Catholic Church because they were a Sabbath keeping Church.
…
Questions Covered:
03:40 – I’ve noticed a non-Catholic friend go up to receive communion during Mass. What’s the Church’s official teaching on this? 13:42 – My Godson said he learned in Catholic school that your venial sins are forgiven during communion. I thought venial and mortal sins could only be forgiven during confession. Could you help clarify? 18:30 – Domestic Church Radio…Why did God throughout Salvation History demand a blood sacrifice? 23:40 – What’s a good book that shows that the Catholic Church is the one true Church? 28:50 – Why did Jesus not say “This is my body” at the feeding of 5,000? This would have been more convincing. 32:30 – Why do we only receive the host and not from the Chalice during communion? 38:50 – How do you properly dispose of a broken rosary? 40:55 – Why would abortion automatically excommunicate someone? Wouldn’t confession just solve it? 46:10 – Do I have a responsibility to talk to someone who has given up hope on salvation? How would I go about that? 51:16 – When the priest says that Jesus loves you more than your parents, what does that mean?
…
Questions Covered:
03:26 – In the gospels, Jesus says he will not take away anything from the law but later he lets his disciples take things away. Can you clarify? 14:03 – Do we sacrifice Christ over and over again? Can you help me understand that and respond? 24:13 – Did Galileo get in trouble with the Church because he didn’t have enough evidence and was claiming Copernicanism as fact or was it because he was interpreting scripture as a scientist? 33:33 – The Pope came out with scripture in defense to bring LGBT people into the Church while allowing them to continue to live the lifestyle. Isn’t this contrary to the Church’s teaching? 46:20 – What is the best course of action to address churches named after the controversial “Our Lady of All Nations?” 50:10 – Why can’t women be priests?
…
Questions Covered:
24:21 – Was the Aristotelian philosophy integrated with other philosophy in Chaldean for the translation? 29:14 – Has anyone gone back to the original Greek from the time Aristotle for a translation? 32:50 – Can you explain Aristotle’s concept of happiness and his influence on Thomas Jefferson? 43:20 – Did Aristotle have any spiritual mindset beyond philosophy?
…
Questions Covered:
05:04 – What’s the Catholic teaching on what to do when a fetus has been conceived in vitro but not implanted in the womb yet? 11:28 – How should we balance strong defense of the faith and the unborn with a charitable approach to those who are pro-choice? 19:29 – How should a Catholic talk to a family member with homosexual inclinations about what the Church teaches, while still having a caring approach? 28:35 – How can I explain anointing of the sick to a Seventh Day Adventist? 35:39 – How can I respond to Protestants who say statues and things like that are idols? 42:45 – How can the Son be begotten of the Father but also be consubstantial with him? 47:18 – How can we defend the idea that life begins at conception if not all fertilized eggs become implanted?
…
Questions Covered:
02:00 – I’ve been taught that you are required to believe in hell but not required to believe that anyone is in there. What are your thoughts? 13:21 – When Jesus says eat “my body and drink my blood”, does he truly mean eat or believe? 28:46 – Why does the Church teach against contraception but promote NFP? 41:27 – I am struggling with my Faith right now. How do we know that we have an immortal soul? 46:00 – Why do fundamentalist translate the 7 days of creation literally, but Catholics do not? And why do Catholics take the Eucharist literally but not fundamentalists? Who is right?
…
Questions Covered:
03:15 – I see that there’s some questionable quotes in Church History on the Immaculate Conception. Can you help clarify why they seem to contradict the official dogma? 12:17 – On Marian Consecration, why do they use the language of “giving ourselves to Mary” and worshiping her? 17:55 – Why has Judas been condemned since he seemed so remorseful? Why has the Church and even Jesus seem to condemn him? 28:31 – What is the Church’s stance on aliens? Resources: Would Aliens Debunk Christianity? | Dr. Karin Öberg | Catholic Answers Focus 28:31 – What is the Church’s stance on aliens? 36:54 – What is Transubstantiation and Consubstantiation? What did Luther believe? 44:38 – Are people in heaven aware of people who are not there? 51:24 – I heard a theory that Jesus asked Judas to make the biggest sacrifice and turn him in because Jesus loved him the most. What are your thoughts on this theory?
…
Questions Covered:
08:07 – Where can I find purgatory in the bible? 16:16 – What’s the moral stance on helping beggars? Are we obligated to help, or can it be considered enabling drug addicts? 21:46 – Did the Church condemn dissection in the Middle Ages? If they did, has that been reversed to allow for scientific discovery? 29:18 – I’m a theology student in college. I read in the Summa; Aquinas says the husband has a right to beat his wife as a punishment. I also heard that it was part of canon law. This is disturbing to me. Can you help clarify this? 40:42 – I’m involved with FOCUS; we are going over a passage in 2 Kings. In the story of Bathsheba taking a request to Solomon, Solomon rejects his mother’s request. How do I better explain the typology of Marian intercession since it seems like intercession is rejected? 46:57 – I’m currently attending a Catholic high school that is increasingly slipping away from Catholic ideals? What should I do? 52:03 – When should we offer fraternal correction according to St. Augustine? Does using the Lord’s name call for fraternal correction?
…
Questions Covered:
02:44 – What’s the culpability of Jazz? How culpable is a child and the parents when it comes to transitioning genders? 12:08 – Is the protestant doctrine of justification contrary to the Gospel? 19:02 – What’s the morality behind the use of marijuana? 24:10 – My ex-wife had an abortion before we were married, and I just found out. If the abortion excommunicated her, does that mean that she was no longer Catholic while we were married? Does this make the marriage invalid? 30:29 – Regarding Archbishop Gomez’s request to fast tomorrow, is the protocol for fasting the same as Ash Wed. and Good Friday? 35:57 – On the initiation of reconciliation, Jesus said “Whoever sins you retain are retained.” What does that mean? 43:04 – I’m currently a student at a protestant seminary and I’m convinced Catholicism is true. What can I do with my degree if I convert? How do I approach my marriage? 50:19 – Should I boycott buying from companies that support pro-abortion organizations? At what point is it ok to shop at certain stores?
…
Questions Covered:
08:06 – How much weight do regional councils hold, especially when looking back at history? 16:30 – If St Peter was martyred, how was he supposed to have laid hands on Pope Linus? 24:00 – How do we reconcile 1 John “Whoever denies Jesus denies the Father” with claims that Jews and Muslims worship the same God in Nostra Aetate? 37:03 – I recently had a lot of spiritual healings through Reiki done and I want to start developing my relationship with Jesus further. How do I deepen this relationship? 48:55 – In the Sacred Heart of Jesus Novena, there’s a line in the prayer that says that Mary is our Salvation. How do I explain this? 53:13 – What does the following phrase mean: God from God, light from light, True God from True God?
…
Questions Covered:
13:53 – I’ve noticed in my parish that they removed all images of a crucified Christ. Is this a common practice around this time of year? 17:19 – What is the difference between the particular judgment and the general judgment? 20:43 – Is being a homosexual a sin or is it just the action that is sin? 36:06 – Is it ok to say “bless you” back to a priest? Is that a quick prayer? 38:38 – What are your thoughts on the claim that Jesus started small churches and not a big universal church? I’m being told that all I need to do is believe in Jesus. 45:29 – What does the white collar mean? 49:08 – I’ve heard people say we should unite our sufferings to Christ for the redemption of others. What does that mean?
…
Questions Covered:
04:01 – What does it mean that Mary is the spouse of the Holy Spirit? 07:43 – Why would a Catholic use faith as a pathway to truth? 14:23 – Is it morally permissible for someone with anxiety to take prescribed Xanax? 18:32 – Are lay people worthy to handle and distribute communion? Are we worthy to receive communion on the hand and why did it historically change? 22:42 – I just saw a video of protesters at St. Patrick’s Cathedral in New York. The men defending the Church said “your body is mine” to the protesters. Have you seen this? What are your thoughts? 28:35 – Do you have advice on how to handle a 12-year-old girl who has become antagonistic towards God? 30:54 – Why are some African saints portrayed as white in icons and other sacred art? 35:31 – Rising from the dead is a scientific impossibility. Are we really supposed to believe that Jesus physically rose from the dead? 41:53 – I used to be an Extraordinary Minister of Holy Communion in the 80’s but I have not done it in years. What would I have to do to be certified again? 44:09 – Could you explain indulgences? How do they work? 49:23 – Who makes the call on excommunication? On what level does that responsibility lie on? Is it priests, bishops, the pope? 50:50 – How was time kept in Jesus’ time?
…
Questions Covered:
03:38 – Are the Jewish-Christian lead tablets forgeries? 06:38 – Can a trans-man marry a trans-woman in the Catholic faith? 11:27 – It seems like a lot of the popes in history have been mean and evil? How does the Church respond? Was Martin Luther correct in trying to go against those things? 18:28 – How does the Church respond to a politician who supports abortion and receives communion? 28:11 – Being that there’s bishops in Germany advocating for a change in the catechism regarding the LGBT community, what are the disciplinary measures that the other bishops can place on them? 32:46 – I was accused of being a cannibal because of the Eucharist. How do I respond? 40:58 – Is it accurate to say that God’s ordaining will is will in himself? Is this will unrelated to his creation while his permissive will is in relation to his creation? 43:27 – How can I bring up a conversation about faith with my boyfriend? 48:15 – If both parties in a marriage have to freely enter into it, then, historically, how were arranged marriages valid? 52:17 – I’ve heard that you’re not supposed to judge someone’s soul, but can you help find it in the Catechism?
…
Questions Covered:
03:45 – My priest tends to make jokes to families during Baptism, is this proper? 08:00 – Does the Spirit of Truth from John Chapter 16 apply to every believer or just the magisterium? 12:40 – Does a Catholic in a civil marriage who is married to a non-Catholic need to get an annulment? 17:45 – Did Jesus wash the feet of Judas on Holy Thursday? 22:20 – When praying the Divine Mercy Chaplet how can I say I offer the body, blood, soul, and divinity? 29:30 – When they divided Jesus’s clothing, they were also called priestly garments. Do we know the ancient name or today’s equivalent name of the garments? 32:15 – Where in the bible do we get the criteria for proper marriage or an annulment? 36:10 – Is it appropriate to ask a priest for the Sacrament of the Anointing of the Sick before an open-heart surgery? 44:05 – How can I tell my adult children about getting an annulment? 52:10 – What is the best way to offer Mass for souls in Purgatory?
…
Questions Covered:
09:30 – How do you respond to the argument that banning abortions will actually make them increase? 15:00 – Is forcing someone to continue a pregnancy conceived in rape a continuation of the original crime? 20:35 – When I change someone’s mind on abortion, how do I keep them from going back to being pro-choice? 23:30 – What should we say about women who are in tough pregnancies due to poverty or abusive partners? 28:45 – How do you respond to the claim that children born from unwanted pregnancies would become criminals? 32:15 – Is abortion ever medically necessary? Are cases like ectopic pregnancies real? 36:50 – When abortion rates started decreasing, did adoption rates start increasing? 43:00 – If one day we could fully grow a fetus outside of the womb, what would be the Catholic position on that? 50:15 – Is there a moral difference between a two-year-old and an unborn child? I don’t know if the Church teaches that.
…
Questions Covered:
48:21 – I’m so glad you guys finally said this out loud! We don’t need to poke the bear!
…
Questions Covered:
08:30 – Roe V. Wade document Leak 47:33 – I’ve been in the prolife movement since 1985. You’re right, most people in the movement are religious and those that are not, burn out quickly. Stigmatizing abortion helped to keep it in the spotlight. It showed what it really is.
…
Questions Covered:
09:48 – How do I explain to my Catholic friends that when we pray to Mary, we are not taking glory away from God? 15:35 – I’m not Catholic but I’m trying to find in the bible that you will be blessed more if you give more. Where can I find that? 20:45 – Would it be reasonable for the Church to assert a lawsuit for plagiarism against those who teach heresy? 32:24 – Why does Mary have her own power? Why does she ask for shrines in her name? 41:45 – Is it ok to receive communion on one knee? 48:17 – After I apply a plenary indulgence to a departed soul, do I no longer have to pray for them?
…
Questions Covered:
12:42 – How effective are prayers if you are not in the state of grace? How effective are non-Catholic prayers? 24:18 – If Christ’s death on the cross was enough, then why do we need purgatory? 35:35 – I used to go to mass daily as a kid. Where do we go from here with the massive cultural change? 46:05 – In John, Jesus says if you believe in my name, you will be saved. Is he talking about Sola Fide?
…
Questions Covered:
07:00 – How do I live an orderly life and control one’s appetites? 18:15 – Do people conceived through IVF and cloning have souls? 24:37 – What’s the distinction between the Hellenist and a Hebrew as mentioned in Acts 6? 35:24 – Could you explain Mary’s perpetual virginity and her assumption? 44:25 – Is communal confession permitted?
…
Questions Covered:
07:15 – The Church teaches that we need to avoid the near occasion of sin. How am I supposed to approach life if, due to my severe scrupulosity, I find myself always in the near occasion of sin? 22:33 – I heard that the Magi saw different instances of Jesus, but I cannot find any source on that. Are you familiar with this? 32:38 – The CCC (Catechism of the Catholic Church) says you’re morally obligated to help others if you can. If you are and are omnipotent, are you obligated to help everyone? 49:35 – How do we respond to the claim that ensoulment does not happen after 40 days?
…
Questions Covered:
09:33 – Have the Church fathers address the topic of transubstantiation and the reception of the resurrected Jesus? Did Jesus give his future body to the disciples at the last supper? 17:32 – If Jesus loves us, why does he let bad things happen to us? 30:27 – I’m just now returning to the Church. When making up for the sin of lying, do we have to go back to everyone we lied to and make amends? 42:02 – Can you recommend a good book for someone who is deeply opposed to the Church? 51:03 – How do I help my girlfriend understand the importance of worship instead of the emotional high of protestant services?
…
Questions Covered;
06:50 – How can some people claim to be Catholics and pro-choice? 15:30 – Where does the sign of the cross come from? Why do Catholics always do that gesture? 20:53 – 1 Kings 22:22 Why does God say that he sent forward a lying spirit? What is this spirit? 32:24 – My Baptist cousin is interested in being Catholic. How can I explain to her the Divine Mercy? 47:15 – What do Catholics believe about Revelation? I’m a fan of the Left Behind series. What are the teachings on the end times and the rapture?
…
Questions Covered:
17:49 – Why is it difficult to find liturgical books for people who are now in the ordinariate? 22:22 – Are there allowances for using liturgical Ordinariate texts outside of Ordinariate? 28:42 – Do you see the Anglican Church becoming closer to the Catholic Church? 31:51 – I’m interested in the Ordinariate, could you give me general information. What do I have to do to potentially join? 35:06 – Could you explain the differences between the Ordinariate and the Roman Rite? 43:09 – Is there an evangelization outreach effort for Anglicans?
…
Questions Covered:
02:37 – What is an apologist? What do they do? What’s a good solid study of apologetics that I can start with? 06:05 – What would you say to someone who says that Mary can’t be the bride of the HS and the Church can’t be Christ’ bride because there is no marriage in heaven? 14:50 – How do I process converting to Catholicism? How do I deal with family? 20:45 – What historical evidence for Jesus founding the Catholic Church outside of the bible? 28:56 – My grandson is being asked to officiate a wedding. How can I discuss this with him in a loving way? 34:00 – I’m in the military, we are not allowed to openly discuss the transgender issue. How do I defend the faith in a less than optimal circumstances? 41:44 – Why can’t Catholics be socialist? 47:47 – Can frozen embryos be saved? 52:42 – What resources do you recommend to those who want to prepare to defend the faith against friends and family?
…
Questions Covered:
21:03 – What’s the Church’s position on families adopting fertilized eggs that were frozen for IVF? 31:04 – I’m looking to donate my body to science for study. Is it ethical and how would you go about it? What would be the burial options after the donation since body part would be missing? 38:29 – I heard scientists are putting miniature human organs on microchips? Could you verify whether this is happening? 47:10 – What is being done to generate new stem cells for vaccines?
…
Questions Covered:
08:29 – Could you give me the scriptural basis for the papacy? 17:35 – does it say in the bible that you shouldn’t judge? 20:50 – How do you approach protestants to start evangelizing? Should we wait till they engage? 29:19 – When Jesus came down from heaven (resurrected), what happened to the people who hurt Jesus? 31:16 – What does the bible say about the resurrection of our loved ones? 39:30 – My husband is an evangelical and I’m a revert Catholic. I feel like I’m letting God down by not making the sign of the cross before meals. Is it a sin? 44:57 – Follow up on judging question: How far do we go with judging? We don’t want to push them away, do we? 47:44 – Regarding the thief that Jesus promised him he would see him in paradise. How does this relate to purgatory? 51:42 – is it safe to pray the rosary in Latin? I’ve been involved in the occult and trying to get out.
…
Questions Covered:
03:27 – I heard that a priest could deny someone forgiveness. Is that possible? 10:49 – Will a baptism be valid if I took the child to be baptized or performed the baptism myself without the parents’ consent? 17:54 – How would you reconcile evolution with original sin? 20:58 – What’s the difference between the magic in Harry Potter and Lord of the Rings because it seems like the magic in Harry Potter is bad? 28:44 – Why can’t we have separate chalices when receiving communion? 33:04 – Is it ok to add an Our Father for Uriel the archangel to the St. Michael Chaplet? 37:14 – I’m a lapsed Catholic. How would I begin my journey to return? 42:27 – I’m not Catholic. Am I understanding this next statement correctly: When Catholics receive the Eucharist, they are truly becoming one with Jesus.
…
Questions Covered:
03:40 – If something is taught by the magisterium but is not infallible, could a person disagree with it? 08:03 – How would I defend that the Catholic Faith is true to protestants? 18:44 – I have never been fully satisfied with the Catholic response to “call no man father.” Can You help clarify it for me? 28:40 – I’ve been practicing martial arts and I’m getting a new instructor, but it feels like it borders on eastern religion. Can I still practice this as a good Catholic? 32:48 – What are the positions that the Church relooked at that were once considered modernist ideas that are now approved? 36:45 – Can you help me better understand devotion to relics? 44:48 – In the TLM the consecration prayer for the chalice includes the words the mystery of faith. It was dropped in the new mass. How do I explain to someone that this doesn’t make the Mass invalid? 51:12 – I just became Catholic. I’ve heard some say that Mary didn’t have childbirth pains and others say she did. What’s correct?
…
Questions Covered:
02:40 – I reverted to the Church and I wanted to share the miracle God did to bring me back! 12:44 – I come from a southern Baptist background. How can I improve my prayer to the saints I have devotions to? 21:50 – Can a non-Catholic go to confession and receive absolution? 30:18 – What are we as Catholics doing to talk to the youth about sexuality? 40:59 – There’s a pastor in my town that claims the bible approved polygamy, can you help me answer this question? 43:48 – Could the pope be heretic? 51:53 – I wasn’t given the option to choose a saint when I was confirmed. How can I integrate that into my journey?
…
Questions Covered:
12:27 – What are the boundary lines for a Catholic regarding predestination? 21:48 – Is it necessary to be Catholic? 29:22 – I was never taught to deal with sin as a protestant. What’s the best way to approach a sin that I continually struggle with? 42:45 – In the OT when David killed Goliath, King Saul sounds like he didn’t know who David was. It seems like the story is not in chronological order. What are your thoughts on it? 48:03 – Why do we bless statues with incense?
…
Questions Covered:
08:58 – Why do we go to a priest to confess our sins? 15:10 – Splendor of Truth, JP2 includes deportation as inherently immoral. Can you help clarify why he says that? 19:50 – Lumen Gentium says Catholics and Muslims worship the same God. Could you elaborate? 33:35 – How was the Magnificat record in scripture? 36:23 – Is Jesus sitting at the right hand of the Father as a human being or a spiritual being? 45:27 – In the Bible it says that God is with us. How is this different from saying he is with us in the Eucharist? 49:01 – As a practicing Catholic I would like to learn more about responsible parenthood. When is it appropriate to practice NFP? 52:02 – Follow up comment on Muslim question: My son in law is Muslim and they do believe in Jesus and the one to come at the end to save us, but they just don’t believe that He’s God.
…
Questions Covered:
05:45 – Sedevacantist claim that St. Lucia’s letter confirming the consecration with JP2 was forged. Is this true? Was the 3rd secret of Fatima fully revealed? Did Padre Pio know the full 3rd secret of Fatima? 15:44 – What breaks Sunday rest? Does ordering pizza or going to Disney World break it? 28:39 – I’m converting to Catholicism but live in a rural area where RCIA is not available. I was allowed to have 1 on 1 sessions with an associate pastor. What can I do to make sure I get the most out of my situation? 33:48 – Gen 3:16 God says Eve’s pain will be intensified. How is this possible if pain was a result of the fall? Does this mean that they weren’t seeing the beatific vision before the fall? 40:31 – What did Jesus mean when he told his disciples to go buy swords but later condemned Peter when he used the sword? 46:50 – Was there really an imposter of Sister Lucia? The pictures look different at different times. 49:12 – Why are we so relaxed with the 4th commandment but strict on theology of the body?
…
Questions Covered:
14:45 – What are your thoughts on one parent sharing all the terrible things the other parent did to the child? Is this protecting the child or hurting them? 22:29 – I haven’t spoken to my mother for 15 years. Do I reconcile with my abusive mother? 31:33 – How do you recover from being the targeted parent? How do you reconcile with the children? 38:50 – I’m experiencing parental alienation. I feel like I’m still being targeted. How do I respond to his behavior? 43:19 – I’m the victim of parental alienation. I’ve run out of ideas. What do I do now? 49:27 – How can I get a relationship back with my kids? They won’t speak to me?
…
Questions Covered;
08:20 – What are your thoughts on Sola Scriptura? 14:13 – If you’re pressured to have an abortion and given no option, is it still a sin? What does scripture say? 22:14 – Can you give recommendations for biographies of people who have really lived out the Faith? I want to give it to a non-practicing Muslim friend. 29:15 – How would you respond to someone who denies an afterlife? 34:40 – I’m a born again Christian. How do I respond to someone who asks who created God? 41:30 – How can I defend the principle of having to go to confession to remove mortal sin? 48:59 – What are good responses who claim all things are just opinions?
…
Questions Covered:
01:57 – My son Peter who is 9 asked when your judged what age are You? It is Thomas Aquinas’ opinion that we will be 33 in the resurrection does that mean we will be judged at the age of 33. Thanks for Your shows! 05:55 – Bleeding tears?!? That’s aliens. 10:55 – What does the Easter bunny have to do with it, and why does he deliver eggs when bunnies don’t lay eggs? My granddaughter asked me that the other day. Is the Easter bunny perhaps an alien? 16:27 – How much DID that stone weigh, anyway? It was very large. 21:09 – What if time travelers went back and succeeded in preventing the Crucifixion? (Mind you, I think that time travelers would be unable to change the past even if time travel turns out to be possible.) Would all those prophecies go unfulfilled? Would God have a backup plan of redemption in place? 28:28 – Jimmy Akin, apparently smaller breeds of rabbits live longer than larger ones. Given the known average lifespans of different-sized known breeds of rabbits and the photographic evidence of Easter bunnies could you estimate the average lifespan of an Easter bunny? 32:25 – I heard a priest explain when Christ’s Body was in the Grave, He went and preached to the “spirits or souls in prison” mentioned I believe in 1st or 2d Peter…He preached to the Good dead…not to the bad dead…those in true Hell….and as I understand it…Mel Gibson’s upcoming Passion Of the Christ 2 movie, will be about this very subject…what say you, Jimmy, on this scripture in St. Peter’s Epistle? 44:15 – How does undigested food affect the properties of resurrected bodies? For example, it’s usually assumed resurrected bodies can walk through walls. But would a resurrected body that just ate be able to do so. When talking about the Eucharist, we often assume the real presence is there for about 15 minutes as it still has the accidental form of bread, would a resurrected body need to wait 15 minutes after eating before walking through a wall? 51:13 – What can we say in response to those History Channel types who might ask how we be sure that Christ wasn’t raised from the dead by a benevolent, sympathetic alien force that has been surreptitiously monitoring the human race?
…
Questions Covered:
08:20 – I heard a priest say that the Eucharist is not physically Christ but substantially Christ. Is that true and what does that mean? 17:25 – I’m a new Catholic and just had my first confession that was very long due to years and quantity of sin. The priest only gave me a small penance. Would this penance remove all temporal? 20:05 – Regarding your debate on Justification vs Jordan Cooper. I had a hard time seeing the differences. How would you summarize our position vs the Lutheran position? 31:13 – Jesus made a reference to Judas as a son of perdition. Would this be evidence of him being in hell? 40:43 – What happens if you are not fully repentant right before you die? 44:40 – What is the Church teaching on praying retroactively? 47:20 – Can I get your perspective on seeing the God the Father as a grandfather? 51:57 – How are we supposed to understand the passages of God instructing the Israelites to kill all living creatures of the enemy in the Old Testament?
…
Questions Covered:
02:08 – How far is too far with honoring a saint? 06:13 – I am divorced and haven’t had an annulment. Am I excommunicated? It lays very heavy on my heart. 13:40 – What’s the biblical rebuttal to predestination? 17:21 – Did Neanderthals have rational souls? 31:27 – Why did Jesus not allow Mary Magdalene to touch him but allowed Thomas to touch him. What’s the best defense for the shroud of Turin being legitimate? 39:57 – I’m Protestant. Do you have any resources on the Catholic and Protestant division? 20 answers 43:39 – Duet. 18.21-22 How do we tell the difference between a prophecy that didn’t come true because it was conditional or one that didn’t come true because it wasn’t from God? 49:39 – Regarding the Eucharist revealed on the road to Emmaus, what could possibly be the protestant interpretation of this story? 52:44 – Why do Orthodox celebrate Easter a week later?
…
Questions Covered:
22:47 – How do I find God through anxiety and feeling overwhelmed? 31:54 – What are your thoughts on the surrender prayer? 34:41 – Can you help clarify mental prayer and contemplative that St. Theresa of Avila talked about? 44:12 – Is taking medication for mental issues an admission that God’s presence doesn’t work? 46:28 – How did you accept God’s calling for you to be Carmelite sisters? 50:11 – What inspired you to take your vows? What was the experience like?
…
Questions Covered:
01:52 – Jer. 33:18 There will never fail to be a time where men will offer burnt offerings. How do we reconcile this with New Testament theology doing away with ritual sacrifices? 11:37 – As the first born of the resurrection, had Christ not ascended at the end of the gospels, would Jesus have been biologically immortal in his human nature? 15:49 – Could the Massacre of the Innocence be an allegorical story? 24:17 – 2 Kings 2:23-24 Why would God allow the children to be harmed because they made fun of someone? What is the meaning of that story? 31:35 – What are your thoughts on the theory that there was a mistranslation on the story of the crossing of the Red Sea and the actual translation was the Sea of Reeds? How do I refute this idea? 33:36 – Could you recommend a resource to read on the original understanding of Scripture? How would Jews have understood the bible? – Resource Mentioned: Ancient Israel by ROLAND DEVEAUX, Biblical Backgrounds by CRAIG KEENER 45:05 – Jesus said be perfect like your Father in heaven is perfect. How can a sinner become a saint? 49:12 – Jesus said we can only have eternal life by eating the bread and drinking his blood. Since Covid we stopped taking the chalice, does this hurt our chances of having eternal life? 51:15 – What’s the best way to refute the doctrine Total Depravity etc. How do we refute their use of Romans 9 as evidence?
…
Questions Covered:
03:47 – Rev. 13:15. What is the image of the beast? Is it a statue, painting etc.? Is it symbolic? 12:32 – What would the Jews think of Jesus’ name? Were there other Jesus’ walking around? 15:12 – Could the Holy Family have traveled to Wales? 19:08 – Does the verse “If you do not carry your cross you cannot be my disciple” mean that the purpose in life is to suffer? 21:10 – Why did Matthew make the distinction of Petros and Petra in Mt. 16? 28:49 – Who was Lillith in the apocrypha? 41:35 – Book of wisdom. Since they refer to wisdom as female, could they be alluding to the Virgin Mary? 47:15 – Where is purgatory in the bible? Where do you find praying to the saints, especially Mary, in the bible?
…
Questions Covered:
06:30 – Is it correct to say Jesus is a human being based on a 1 Cor 15: 21 reference? 13:00 – How does the Mormon view of salvation compare to the Catholic view? 19:19 – Is it wrong to say the incarnation is below God? 33:31 – Why do you have to be Baptized to go to Heaven? 37:30 – What is the difference between personal sin and original sin? 40:51 – Am I right in saying one reason for Pope Francis issuing his Latin Mass Document, was that he felt traditional Catholics were being too arrogant or legalistic? 49:45 – Why is there an altar call at the end of Mass? 51:40 – Does the RCIA duration delay people’s salvation?
…
Questions Covered:
03:03 – Which modernist positions are currently condemned? Has the Pope given input? 12:30 – Did Jesus establish a cult with Mary? 19:52 – How can I pray for Vladimir Putin with compassion while praying for Ukraine? 29:26 – What is the Catholic Answer to inconsistencies? For example, the comparison between Thomas seeing Jesus’s wounds in his palms and the information on where nails would have been traditionally placed in wrist? 36:40 – What happens to babies that die in the womb? Can they commit sins? 41:52 – Can you be the best man for someone who is currently living with their fiancé? 46:06 – Are there any other Popes, before Pope Clement, that are in a confirmed line after Peter?
…
In this episode, Cy Kellet and Trent Horn discuss the following questions:
Can the Resurrection be known through historical evidence? Why believe in the Resurrection and not other non-Christian miracles? What about the hallucination theory? Are there different ways to defend the Resurrection? How does the Resurrection affect our own lives?
Resources:
…
Questions Covered;
03:31 – Why doesn’t Jesus refer to God as Our Father? 06:58 – Since God made man and women, does that mean that God encompasses all genders or is it not important? 16:56 – I’m going to be confirmed on Saturday. I’m hesitant to receive communion because I sometimes have doubts about the real presence. What should I do? 22:20 – What would you say to material atheists who say morality comes from evolutionary development and not from God? 28:39 – What are the Eastern Orthodox objections to the Papacy and what are our responses? 35:22 – In John it says that Jesus said he refused to go up to the Feast of Booths and went in secret afterwards. Did he lie? 43:58 – What’s wrong with Sola Scriptura according to the Catholic perspective? 49:12 – In Jimmy’s debate with James White, James claimed that the early Church overwhelmingly disagreed with Peter being the rock. Can you expound on it?
…
Questions Covered:
24:37 – I applaud the signing of the letter but what is the point of signing a letter if we’re not a democratic Church? 32:12 – Wasn’t the Anglican Church based on a synodal way? Wouldn’t this make the synod a bad idea given the results of that? 35:41 – Every time there’s a council comes confusion. And John Paul II also saw this coming according to his writings. 42:05 – If a bishop has not signed the letter, would it be appropriate to ask him to sign it? What would be the best way to approach him? 44:46 – What obedience do the laity owe to the bishops? 51:25 – What are your thoughts on Pope Francis’ comments to reporters that sound like he’s promoting civil unions?
…
Questions Covered;
05:04 – My employer wants me to be a notary. One thing they do is to perform marriages, including gay marriages. Can I do this as a Catholic? 14:55 – Is God the Father our grandfather? 28:37 – I would see motorhomes parked outside Catholic churches and schools and I was wondering why they are no longer allowed. What were they used for? 30:20 – Are you exempt from the postures that the congregation are to do if you are an altar server? Will it be considered liturgical abuse? 34:55 – What is your favorite title for Mary? 37:00 – I was diagnosed with a condition that prevents me from taking the Eucharist. What are my options? 42:35 – Pope Pius XII encyclical Fulgens Corona P.33-34 He says that we worship Mary. How do I respond to someone who claims that we worship Mary and uses this as evidence? 48:58 – I have friends who are getting married outside of the Church and they asked us to participate. Is this allowed? 52:00 – Are the elements of the Trinity co-eternal and co-equal?
…
Questions Covered:
03:25 – I’m a biology student. What’s the effect of the soul on the body? If the soul is the animating factor, then why does it appear that bodies can function on their own through natural processes? 13:43 – In 1 Tim. 3 and Titus, Paul talks about bishops having 1 wife. How do you reconcile this with the Church’s current teaching on celibacy? 19:05 – My son doesn’t feel comfortable bringing his children to church because of the violence of the crucifix. How do you explain that to children? 29:08 – Is Luke 12:47- 48 a reference to purgatory? 35:34 – Why hasn’t the Church approved the Marian apparition of Garabandal? 39:00 – When Jesus is asked about a person not associated with the apostles, he responded by saying to leave him alone. How does this fit in with the understanding of schism? 44:10 – My father passed away on Friday and had a deathbed conversion. The priest gave him a conditional baptism, confirmation, anointing of the sick and the Eucharist. How is it possible for him to receive communion without receiving confession? 48:07 – Can demons perform miracles? How do we discern if miracles come from good angels or bad angels? 50:39 – What is the origin of universalism?
…
Questions Covered:
06:32 – Luke 22:15 Jesus is at the last supper, and he references a cup before he offers his body. What does that signify? 11:49 – Speaking to my non-Catholic family, how do I speak to them when they vocally speak out against the Church? 17:19 – Should I skip on confession since I am still working on being contrite? 29:58 – Does the Church teach infallibly that the soul who dies in mortal sin is condemned to hell? What is necessary for something to be considered mortal? 36:38 – If Jesus was crucified and raised after 3 days, then how come we only celebrate it after 2 days? Friday to Sunday are only 2 days. 40:22 – Is there salvation for people outside the church according to the Catholic Church? 46:02 – I’m not Catholic. Why are the 10 commandments of the Catholic bible different from the Protestant bible? 50:59 – Why is Biden not being excommunicated if he is not inclined to repent?
…
Questions Covered:
04:07 – How would you respond to those who shout people down when they don’t want to debate anymore? 07:21 – Mk. 2:1-5 the paralyzed lowered him through the roof to be healed. Was the paralyzed man forgiven because of his friend’s faith? 13:26 – What does a transgender person do that is inherently sinful since changing the way they dress and undergoing surgery isn’t necessarily sinful? 15:54 – I know someone who is afraid of going to confession because of the abuse they suffered in the past. How can I help her? 19:22 – Is it ok to think when Jesus sweated blood that that was because he knew what was coming and that’s why he said, “to let this cup pass from me.” 28:30 – What is the environment of purgatory like? 32:35 – Regarding Fatima: Mary told Francisco that he will be in purgatory till the end of time. Is this true and how is that possible? 36:00 – Was reading a book that was not approved by the bishop heretical? 38:59 – I’m struggling with liking people. Is that a sin? 41:49 – I have to go to jury duty. Could you recommend a prayer because I felt manipulated last time I was there? 44:34 – Did the Church adopt penances after the year 1000? Does the eucharist keep us out of sin or bring us closer to the Lord? 48:13 – If Jesus died for our sins, then why do we have to pay for them through penance? 51:34 – Could you explain when Jesus says you can’t serve God and Mammon?
…
Questions Covered:
18:50 – I’m an Atheist. How do you go from an argument for God to an argument for the God of the Jews? 28:52 – I grew up atheist and have been in a lifelong philosophical pursuit for God. Thank you for having this conversation. 41:04 – Can we know the existence of God by knowing the precise dates of Jesus and his passion? 47:51 – Could you comment on this statement: It’s not possible to prove the existence of God.
…
Questions Covered:
06:15 – Why did the Church change the Nicene creed? 15:12 – Why do Catholics make your priest be celibate? 21:54 – In Matthew, Jesus says to deny ourselves. What does that mean? Does that mean he doesn’t want us to have things? 35:42 – Did God create more people after he made Adam and Eve? He would have had to because Cain was afraid of other people after he killed Abel, right? 44:05 – There are many stories of Jesus being killed. Did God specifically establish Jesus to be killed during the Passover? 49:48 – What is the Catholic view on yoga and centering prayer?
…
Questions Covered:
04:57 – In Mt. 12:36 what exactly is meant by “idle word?” 12:10 – How can we best prepare for receiving the Eucharist? 15:16 – Is there a primary way of receiving grace and coming to know God’s love without having received the sacraments? 21:54 – Aside from prayer to God and Jesus, what exactly can Mary do? 28:30 – What does the Church teach about hypnosis and 3rd dimensions? 36:30 – In the Apostles Creed it says descended into hell. Did he actually go to hell? 42:08 – I listened to your debate with Dr. Bart Ehrman. In the end of the gospel of John, it uses the pronoun we when the author refers to himself. Could you help clarify? 48:37 – Will adding one word to our wedding vows make the sacrament invalid? 51:28 – In Rev. 17 how they map out the size of heaven with cubits. Why is there a size denomination applied to heaven?
…
Questions Covered:
02:15 – My son married a non-Catholic outside of the Church and is now divorced. What does he have to do to be in good standing with the Church? 08:30 – Regarding the Miraculous Medal. It’s starting to sound like a superstition to me. Can you help clarify? 13:48 – When we die, do we go to heaven now or in the final judgment? 19:11 – How does the idea of original sin affect our everyday lives? 29:32 – I’m a Baptist and had a change of heart on the Catholic Church. Is not becoming Catholic a grave matter? 36:33 – How does the Catholic view on justification differ from the protestant view? 44:22 – How do we know so much about angels? 47:00 – On the requirements for the first Saturday devotion: Should we be meditating on all 15 mysteries or is it just one? 50:15 – I’m coming into the Catholic Church. Where can I find the evidence for authority for private revelation in the Catholic Church?
…
Questions Covered:
07:24 – Is binding and loosing evidence for Papal infallibility? The early church writings claim an unblemished church of Rome, does that correlate to infallibility? 18:45 – Why does the decree Sict Dudum only seek to protect Christians? 22:28 – If you are in a gay marriage and repented and now living celibacy, do you have to get a divorce? 31:26 – What has to happen for the Catholic Church to let gay men and women to get married? 38:55 – If the Latin rite and the Eastern rites have different beliefs, how can they both be Catholics? 45:10 – Why do Catholics not eat meat on Fridays during Lent? 50:45 – Where are the elders in the Catholic Church? 53:00 – My son married a non-Catholic outside of the Church and is now divorced. What does he have to do in order to be in good standing with the Church?
…
Questions Covered:
07:54 – Can our guardian angel hear our thoughts? If they can, can fallen angels hear them? 17:04 – What’s the response to the argument that modern scholars claim that the gospels were not written until hundreds of years after Christ’ death? 24:05 – Is it possible for people to get married without the presence of the Church? 34:23 – How can Catholics believe in a standard view of evolution and accept the Church’s teaching on original sin? 44:53 – I want to work at a pregnancy center that is evangelical. I would have to sign an oath of agreement. I worry that it might not be ok for me to sign it as a Catholic. Can I get your thoughts? 47:44 – Is it valid to pray for people who died recently and a very long time ago? Purgatory is for real 51:59 – Why is the bishop of Rome not considered the Archbishop of Rome? 53:30 – What does the Catholic Church think of the Orthodox prayer the Hesychasm?
…
Questions Covered:
07:32 – Is indentured servitude immoral? 18:42 – Why were the eastern churches not affected by the liturgical reforms? When Vatican 2 changed the readings in the liturgical calendar, why was John not given its own year cycle? 24:19 – I see faith and faithfulness as synonymous. Can you share your thoughts on that? 33:39 – According to the Bible, how are we supposed to worship God? Is that similar to how we worship today? 36:50 – Can you give an in-depth definition of discipleship? 45:28 – If you don’t believe or understand everything in the Catholic Church but have faith can you receive communion? What if an error was introduced into the Catholic Church through a pope and I don’t accept it, can I still receive? 51:49 – Why did God create man? Was He lonely? Did He need us? 53:35 – Is it possible for a member of the Church to be condemned without being conscious of grave sin?
…
Questions Covered:
03:50 – Is a sacrament the source or the conduit? 05:44 – God in the Old Testament is so authoritarian and so merciful in the New Testament. Why the drastic shift? 14:35 – The bible says that the souls shall die. Since the soul dies along with the body, then we can’t pray to the people that died. What’s the Catholic response to this? 21:45 – Why doesn’t the Catholic Church follow the model that Christ set up? 31:58 – Is the laying on of hands the only way the charisms are transmitted. Do these continue into the lifestyle of the recipient? 44:58 – Is there a conflict between the real presence and the Holy Spirit’s presence on earth? 49:12 – Doesn’t it say in the bible that you have to ask for forgiveness to be baptized? Why do Catholics baptize babies if they haven’t sinned?
…
Questions Covered:
06:33 – I heard a Capuchin Franciscan say that in the story in Mt. 15:21, Jesus was prejudiced, and he had to learn not to be. Is this true? https://catholicconvert.com/is-jesus-being-harsh-calling-a-woman-a-dog-in-todays-gospel-reading/ 15:00 – How do you go about overcoming hurdles like calling the pope holy father? I feel more inclined to believe what the early Church believed and not what the Catholic Church teaches? 24:42 – The canonization of Juan Diego is my reason why the Church is not the real Church. I don’t think the Church speaks infallibly on canonizations. What’s your response? 36:05 – What are the roots of the Catholic view of baptism? How is that different from the protestant view? 44:34 – There’s a verse in the bible that says to not pray to the dead. Praying to Mary is different because she’s dead. Wouldn’t that be more like a séance? 52:20 – Why do Catholics make the church services so boring?
…
Questions Covered:
19:41 – In the context of Mt. 18:18, how does the language of the promise to Peter compare to the powers given to the apostles in Jn. 20:23? 23:18 – Who is really speaking when giving the authority to Peter? Is it Jesus or YAHWEH? 37:28 – Could you recommend a good reading list of apostolic fathers? 48:57 – What’s the difference between the Pharisees and Catholic priests?
…
Questions Covered:
03:56 – Why is there an order of angels if each angel is its own species? 07:58 – What is the significance of Moses not entering the promised land? 13:32 – Can there really be 2 legitimate popes at the same? 16:20 – Can you discuss the Triduum? 18:19 – I had a confessor tell me that when we sin, we make ourselves enemies of God. Is this true? Do you think there is an unhealthy understanding of mortal sin? 28:37 – Is it ever permissible for a Catholic to take birth control? Is it ever permissible for a Catholic to have an abortion? 37:48 – What exactly has the Church defined as eschatology or the end times? 47:07 – What is the difference between Christ being with us till the end of the earth and his presence in the Eucharist?
…
Questions Covered:
02:52 – What book do you recommend for a well-rounded treatment of the Trinity? How does the Church understand Jesus entering time and space in relation to the Trinity? 07:48 – How well did the apostles understand the Trinity? 14:42 – I read a story about a mass grave found in Ireland just like in Canada and they are blaming the Catholic Church. What is the best way to address this because it doesn’t look good? 20:21 – I just became Catholic but my wife is not. We got married civilly. Would my wedding be recognized? If not, what criteria are necessary? 24:33 – St. Thomas Aquinas talks about “the fires of purgatory.” Is that a proper way of referring to purgatory? 33:15 – Why do we refer to Jesus as a Palestinian if the term wasn’t created until after Jesus’ time? 40:02 – Do you affirm libertarian freedom or compatibilist freedom? If compatibilist, then what is the meaningful distinction between Thomism and Calvinism? 45:30 – Can I unite my sufferings to Christ’s suffering even though they happened many years ago? 48:36 – Is there any written evidence against the resurrection in the first century? I would expect there to be people who would try to disprove it.
…
Questions Covered:
06:11 – Is Heaven divided into different time periods? How will those people understand and get along with each other? 07:54 – What does the Church believe about modern Israel fulfilling biblical prophecies? 12:43 – Is one really lying if one is telling an automated phone system false information? 18:14 – Jimmy: What is the unforgivable sin against the Holy Spirit? 22:24 – How do corruptionist and survivalist theories work with the Catholic understanding of Purgatory and intercession? 29:06 – Can you give me a historical account of the Fraternal Lodge of the Eagles. Can Catholics join? Are they Masonic? 30:50 – Do you believe there to be a parallel between the Great Schism of 1054 and the supernova explosion of the same year? 35:46 – Where in the bible does it say anything about purgatory? 43:02 – I was told in RCIA that I shouldn’t be reading writings from the saints because they’re reliable. Is this true? How can we know if anything is reliable? 47:50 – I was told that the Catholic Church teaches that civil war is always wrong? Is this true? 49:57 – Do you believe there to be a parallel between the Great Schism of 1054 and the supernova explosion of the same year?
…
Questions Covered:
02:14 – How could God have 1 will and Jesus 2 wills without us saying that the Father and the Holy Spirit both have a human will? 06:57 – How do I get over the fear of Mary? 15:50 – How is veneration of relics not superstition? 20:08 – Is there a parallel between Jesus being fully God and being fully man and the Eucharist being fully bread and fully Jesus? 29:57 – When I went through RCIA they said purgatory wasn’t real. Can you clarify? 40:45 – What is the Consecration of Russia? What are we supposed to do? 46:40 – My future daughter in law wanted to get married soon but didn’t finish the RCIA process. Can she still get married in the Church? 50:04 – Can you clarify Revelation 5:8?
…
Questions Covered:
10:19 – I’m considering entering RCIA. Is it ok to pray for bad people like Hitler? 16:33 – Is it necessary to actually attend RCIA? Does it matter to God? 22:06 – There’s a lot of Catholic traditions that I haven’t encountered. Is there a book where I would be able to find these or research them? 29:27 – Why is there so much confusion with baptism of desire? 36:57 – Why did God allow Satan to enter the garden of Eden? 53:18 – Could you clarify from a previous call, are protestants also saved or just Catholics?
…
Questions Covered:
05:02 – Where is the earliest mention of the celebration of the Eucharist outside of the bible? 12:17 – I ran into a claim that Jesus was actually King Tut. I heard it said that the name Tut also means “I Am that I Am.” Can you help refute it? 14:38 – What would be the Catholic response to Dispensationalism? 21:55 – Could I be a moral car salesman? 24:13 – If God knew that I would be skeptical and that would lead to hell, does that mean that he created me just to suffer? 29:34 – Does the Church have a teaching on the fundamental option? 34:38 – I had a Protestant tell me that we don’t have a choice on which graces we receive from God. How do I respond to this? 42:52 – During the Collect at Mass the priest no longer says, “One God forever and ever,” and now just says “God, Forever and Ever.” Why was there a change? 45:46 – Where can I find in the bible that we are supposed to honor Mary and the saints? 50:31 – If most of Protestant concerns for the Church have been answered, why is there still Protestantism?
…
Questions Covered:
16:29 – Could you share more information about your work? 23:44 – How can I explain to people that men and women are different? Why is that a good thing? 29:26 – How do we charitably defend our womanhood in a society that says womanhood is malleable? 48:17 – I’m a 1950’s wife and it’s good to have some support and reassurance! 51:03 – Do you think women should be required to register for the draft?
…
Questions Covered:
04:30 – Are there any questions that Catholics can ask Protestants instead of always being on the defense? 04:30 – Are there any questions that Catholics can ask Protestants instead of always being on the defense? 12:30 – How do I respond to my friend who asked me why Catholics believe vasectomies are wrong? 20:52 – Does God have love for people who ultimately choose hell? 29:43 – How do I respond to a Protestant friend when he brings up the 7 Churches in Revelation in response to the Catholic Church is the one true Church? 35:28 – How does the Catholic Church prove that Jesus founded the Catholic Church? 45:13 – How do I respond a Protestant arguing for Sola Scriptura. I was stumped with 2 Peter 3:15. Can you help clarify? 52:54 – Follow up to your response that God does not grieve like us. I don’t think I can use that defense because it contradicts scripture. Can you expound on your argument?
…
Questions Covered:
34:05 – I met my wife when I was 50. None of us can have kids but both of us willed to be together. She now has dementia, but I visit her every day at the home she lives at now. 37:40 – I’m someone who’s trying to take the Faith seriously, but my partner is not. We are in the process of getting our civil marriage blessed by the Church. How can I present the faith to her in a sympathetic way? 45:00 – Can you speak on the Church’s official teaching on people who want to get married but can’t have kids because of age? 48:28 – How do we reconcile the Catholic view of marriage with other cultural views that exist?
…
Questions Covered:
01:45 – How is it remotely right that annulment due to canonical form means that a person who was baptized Catholic but left the church in their teens and was married in a protestant church isn’t really considered married by the Catholic Church and they could get it annulled if they came back? How does this actually work and what am I misunderstanding because I don’t see how that’s remotely justified 10:42 – What would you say to a protestant who doesn’t see the need to go to church on Sunday? 15:03 – Is it wrong to address the Angel Gabriel as “archangel”? I have learned from Wikipedia that he is an archangel 2nd in command. Is it a Catholic teaching to acknowledge Gabriel as archangel, what is the difference between the two? 18:48 – Since the LXX was the basis for our current Bible, why weren’t all of the LXX’s books included in the Bible? 21:15 – Question 1: When are Catholics required to give their full assent to the teachings of the Church? I heard an apologist mentioned that we do not have to follow Pope Francis’s teaching on the death penalty since he was making a prudential judgment. 23:15 – Question 2: Since the Latin Church is in communion with Byzantine Rite Catholic Churches. Does that mean that Rome has implicitly canonized the Saints in the Eastern Church that were Orthodox since these saints were after the Great Schism like Gregory of Palamas? 24:28 – Jimmy, how do you respond to non-Catholics who ask about the number of Catholics who publicly criticize the Pope – they question our claim of unity. 31:58 – Please shed light on what this is about. Matt 27: 52-53. the tombs also were opened, and many bodies of the saints who had fallen asleep were raised, and coming out of the tombs after his 35:00 – Can you explain purgatory in adult terms. 41:58 – What is transubstantiation? Is there a good example of change in substance in anything besides Eucharist that would help people understand Eucharistic transubstantiation? 47:43 – If (or when) we welcome the Eastern Orthodox Churches back into the fold – what could that mean for the Table of Contents for our Bibles? What books could plausibly make the cut, so to speak? 3 Maccabees but not 4 Maccabees? 51:55 – I know of holy water and blessed salt to protect my family from evil. What else should parents know to protect their families?
…
Questions Covered:
06:00 – Does the physical material (for example, bone or hair or tooth or whatever) of a given saint’s relic bear upon its Wonder-Working Providence? 11:56 – How can one better understand the trinity without falling into one of the many heresies there are? Why does it seem like there is a hierarchy when Christ says that the Father is greater than Him when all are equally God? 17:23 – Is God “complicated”? It has been bandied about that God has “His” time to call us home. Regardless… I’m not sure that I think this. 22:15 – When a new saint is canonized who identifies the attributes that one sees in depictions of that saint? This assumes that there is an actual selection, as opposed to a tradition arising that “sticks” by attrition as the years go by. Similarly, who identifies the patronages, if that’s a real word. Example: When St. Jimmy is canonized one day, who will decide that you’re always to be depicted wearing a cowboy hat, and that you’re the patron saint of philosophers from Arkansas? 28:48 – Protestants call certain parts of Scripture apocryphal and we call them deuterocanonical. I want to understand why. It seems to me there is one canon of scripture and when I looked up deuterocanonical, it means second canon. Why do we have a second cannon of scripture when there should be just one cannon? 31:50 – People advise people in difficult marriages to draw on the graces of the sacrament. For those with annulled marriages, were there any? 33:00 – I am having a discussion with a protestant who claims that power to forgive or retain sins was given to more than the apostles that night of Jesus’ resurrection. He bases this on Luke 24:33 (that says others were present) and John 20:19-23 being the same appearance. How do we know that these two appearances were not the same? Or were they? 41:45 – In Robert Hugh Benson’s book “Lord of the World” the Pope establishes the “Order of Christ Crucified” in which the goal of the members are to seek out martyrdom. Is there a sense in which seeking martyrdom can be contrary to the Faith? 47:27 – Why are Catholics seen as “haters” when we stick to our guns on items of faith, sacraments, and morals? I hate no one but I know there is a standard we are all held to 50:24 – Can a practicing Catholic go to a Protestant Mass with a friend who is of this particular denomination as a friendly gesture? I know that the Catholic Church would not recognize the Eucharist within a Protestant service as being properly consecrated and thus null. Also, I do believe it is against church teaching to say some Protestant prayers that go against Catholic teaching. Can I have some clarification and guidance in regards to wanting to be friendly and charitable but within the parameters of Catholic responsibilities?
…
Questions Covered:
02:00 – Why do we believe that Mary is in heaven with her glorified body and not Moses and the Old Testament prophets? 08:03 – Regarding the prayer for the faithful depart, why do we pray for the “faithful” departed and not the unfaithful? 13:28 – Our Lord died for our sins but why do we still have to pay for our sins in purgatory? 20:00 – Why do we not have the same belief of the Eucharist as with Protestants? And why do we have the body and blood and they don’t? 28:53 – How do we know that guardian angels don’t leave them when they become adults? Do adults have them too? 34:34 – How do you address a non-Catholic on Catholic issues who only believes what’s written in the bible? 43:00 – Follow up on communion question: Can you receive communion at different non-Catholic churches? 46:07 – Why do we believe that at the end of time the Jews will come to the Faith and Catholics will leave it? 50:19 – If the Catholic Church is the one true Church, why is there a distinction between Catholic and Christian?
…
Questions Covered:
04:32 – Why ask for forgiveness during prayer if absolution is only offered during confession? 15:35 – Why do we believe in the perpetual virginity of Mary? 20:07 – If God is all loving and merciful, why do we have to fear the punishment of sin? 23:33 – If you sin with the thought that you will just go to confession after, will you still be forgiven? 28:57 – Why Catholicism and not Greek Orthodoxy? 36:59 – Why do Catholics believe in guardian angels and is it obligatory for Catholics to believe in them? 44:06 – Why aren’t a wider range of Papal utterances protected by papal infallibility? 50:32 – Why is it necessary to be married in the Church, even for fallen away Catholics?
Resources: https://www.catholic.com/audio/caf/fed-up-catholics-shouldnt-turn-to-orthodoxy …
Questions Covered:
05:38 – In Deuteronomy 22:28-29 It talks about a man lying with a virgin. What does it mean from the Catholic perspective? 16:12 – I’m a 2nd grade catechist. They want to know why God judged Adam and Eve so harshly? Why couldn’t it be just a teaching moment? 22:22 – What if a person holds back a sin due to shame before their wedding? Will that person’s confession and marriage be valid? 24:30 – Why did God direct the Israelites to kill the other nations who were occupying the promised land if we’re all God’s children? 35:43 – I’m blind and I just wanted to tell Cy thank you and I love your audio book. 41:25 – My protestant friend called me and told me that he was convinced that hell doesn’t exist. Could you explain if it does exist and how you get there? How could it exist if Jesus died for everyone? 48:46 – If the sacraments are efficacious should we expect a temporal manifestation of that grace? 52:22 – I feel drawn to become Catholic. How can I approach this with parents who are deeply opposed?
…
Questions Covered:
02:15 – Should we avoid any forms of media that can be linked to the demonic? 12:18 – Why did the Church in the west retain the Latin language in the liturgy? Prior to the Reformation, were homilies delivered in Latin? How would you answer a protestant if they say that the Church kept everything in Latin to keep people from understanding? 23:10 – My sister is going to marry a non-Catholic outside of the Church. Will her marriage be a valid Christian marriage? 28:43 – Why do some bibles have different chapter numbers for the Psalms? 31:35 – What did the souls that went to heaven do differently from the souls that went to purgatory? 46:10 – Why do we believe that Jesus is not speaking in hyperbole in John 6?
…
Questions Covered:
10:05 – Did Adam and Eve benefit in any way from eating of the fruit before being expelled from the garden? 11:35 – James and John talked about sitting on Jesus left and right and Jesus rebuked them. On the cross Jesus told the good thief that he would be sitting by his side in heaven. Could you clarify this for me? 14:05 – We as Catholics are told to call priests father when in the bible it says call no man father? 19:12 – What’s the biblical basis of relics? 28:40 – What do you think of the Douay-Rheims in terms of it coming from older manuscripts that are now available? 38:55 – In the bible it says having faith the size of a mustard seed can move a tree. How can I know that I have faith? 43:50 – In Deuteronomy 23:12 and Wisdom starts at 3:16, it says that children born through illegitimate births will not inherit heaven. Can you clarify this for me? 51:11 – I’ve heard it said that one doesn’t have to believe in personal revelation, but Paul had personal revelation. Why do we put so much emphasis on Paul’s personal revelation?
…
Questions Covered:
06:05 – Could you expound upon the writer and history of the book of Sirach? 15:42 – How did all the races change after the flood? 31:21 – Mary Magdalene went to touch Jesus and was told not to touch him. Jesus then told Thomas to touch him. Why was Mary Magdalene not allowed to touch him, but Thomas was? 36:13 – Is there biblical support for intercession over praying to saints? 43:16 – Does the Catholic Church have an official translation of the Septuagint? 48:22 – Does Jesus actually mean that we are consuming his flesh and not bread?
…
Questions Covered:
12:36 – Was the Lazarus that received the drop of water on his tongue the same Lazarus that was Mary and Martha’s brother? I hear of a lot of Mary’s apart from the Virgin Mary, are they all the same woman? 17:31 – The pope said we have a moral obligation to take vaccines. Is this true? 20:08 – I’m protestant and I’m exploring Catholicism. Where does one start with a true clear picture of Catholicism? 29:33 – How can you be assured of your forgiveness of sins? In Purgatory you’re being purified from attachment, but I’ve read that people went to hell because of their attachment. Why wouldn’t they just go to purgatory? 40:24 – I was told the word homosexuality was never mentioned in the bible up until 1946. Is this true? 50:04 – I’ve heard it said that it was impossible for Jesus to sin. Could you explain?
…
Questions Covered:
08:11 – What are the consequences in the next life of not receiving indulgences while on earth? 17:06 – Is there a papal dispensation for eating meat while traveling on an airplane? 19:53 – I had friends ask about the Council of Trent. What were the main topics? Was there anything declared in that council that was retracted at Vatican 1 or Vatican 2? 23:37 – Responding to your article on Armageddon and translation. Could it be translated differently from Mount Meddido? 35:42 – Are sedevacantists in heresy as well as schism? Could you clarify the definition of heresy? 43:25 – Regarding Moses and the stories of how magicians could replicate his power. Could you clarify what they meant by magic? 52:31 – Why is bodily mortification not seen as wrong?
…
Questions Covered:
01:55 – I’m atheist, so all of the reason are why I’m not Catholic. Catholics like to rename everything that they took from Judaism. 13:26 – I grew up in a different religion and I see no reason to convert. 23:07 – The power of Church Tradition to declare things necessary for salvation. Specifically, the Immaculate Conception. 40:36 – I’m not Catholic because of the Church’s crimes against humanity. 50:35 – I’m 70 and the Church used to be legalistic and felt very toxic.
…
Questions Covered:
07:14 – I’ve been visiting lots of Catholic churches and was contemplating converting but what really turned me off was watching people sell lottery tickets after Mass. 20:15 – I was Catholic and left 30 years ago and started attending a Methodist church. My question is why do we need to belong to something? 28:56 – St. Paul said the antichrist was going to come after he died. I believe the Catholic Church is the antichrist. 42:27 – I don’t think the historical development of the papacy is biblical.
…
Questions Covered:
02:43 – Is it ok to copy and paste parts from your website and post them on forums when responding to protestants? In the context of 1 Peter 3:19 Does baptism save you? 16:24 – I’ve seen a lot of young people attracted to the Traditional Latin Mass, should we start having more Latin Masses? 18:42 – If you give something up for Lent and decide to enjoy it on Sundays, what time can I start? Can you start at the vigil? 22:55 – I’ve heard that cursed rosaries from Africa are being circulated. What should we do with them and what does a curse do? 28:48 – A devout Catholic asked me the following question: Is there a telepathic connection between mother and child? Can you help me answer it properly? 33:49 – What does the Church teach about guitars in mass and contemporary music? 41:25 – I have a lot of friends that work in the night life industry that I want to share the Faith with. How can I share the Faith and how does your work life affect your spiritual life? 46:27 – When does temptation become a sin? 51:03 – There are 3 differences between the Nicene and Apostles Creed. Why did the changes happen?
…
Questions Covered:
05:00 – Was the reading “love your enemies,” an image of how God responds to his enemies? 15:20 – Is there any theology for praying for the intercession of the souls of aborted children? 17:45 – I’ve heard it said that in Catholic theology the “means doesn’t justify the ends.” How do we reconcile this with solving the problem of evil? 20:28 – I don’t quite understand the joint declaration of justification between the Lutherans and the Catholics. Could you clarify it for me? 23:57 – On the invalid baptism: could you clarify, is it unsolvable unless someone goes back to check the documentation? 28:48 – Are you familiar with the Sermon of St. Leonard Port Mourice entitled “Few Are Saved.” What do you think about how the Church has shifted away from focusing on salvation, especially in homilies? 32:57 – Were Adam and Eve the people Cain was afraid of after he murdered his brother? Who else was there when Cain asked for the mark of protection? 39:38 – I read in the bible about silence being considered consent. I can’t seem to find it. Do you know where that would be? 43:08 – I’m a protestant but have decided to leave. Where would be a good place to start my research on why the Catholic Church is the one true Church? http://jimmyakin.com/why-be-catholic http://jimmyakin.com/why-i-am-not-eastern-orthodox 48:23 – I tend to read the bible as though God is speaking directly to me. What does the Church teach about this?
…
Questions Covered:
05:36 – Whenever a heterosexual couple calls, you say “God bless you, you have a heavy cross, we will pray for you” but when a homosexual person calls, you never say those things to them. How do you answer for this? 14:18 – I have a daughter with same sex attractions and her significant other is divorced while as the same time identifying as trans. How can I compassionately respond to this situation? 19:43 – Over 50% of Catholics in America are secularizing themselves and supporting LGBT beliefs while at the same time rejecting the official teachings on this issue. Why do you think that is? 23:42 – I feel like you guys have always been compassionate, and I thank you for that. 32:30 – I’ve heard it said that same sex attractions can be malleable, what is your understanding of this idea? Is there any group that serves that goal? 39:10 – I’m familiar with Encourage, there is a virtual audio conference call for parents, and I wanted to share that information. 43:40 – My daughter has same sex attractions and says that the reason is because dad is a jerk and not a good dad. Is that a thing? 48:52 – My brother lives in a polyamorous relationship and is married to a woman. How can I help him change his sense of direction and share the Catholic Faith with him?
…
Questions Covered:
3:00 – What is the difference between propitiation, atonement, satisfaction, and expiation? 7:46 – Regarding veiling in the Church, why was veiling not true for all time in the Church’s teaching? 14:56 – My Jewish friend said he doesn’t accept Jesus as the Jewish messiah because Elijah didn’t come and didn’t fulfill the prophecy. How do I respond? 21:39 – What does it mean when Jesus says that there are many rooms in his Father’s house? 23:25 – Seeing as beliefs are not a choice but a compulsion, where do you stand regarding Romans 2: “People know what God is, it is written on their hearts, and they suppress it.” 40:45 – How can there be a guard at Jesus’ tomb if it was the sabbath and they weren’t supposed to work on a sabbath? 45:25 – Regarding almsgiving. What type of emphasis does the Church place on private property?
…
Topics: 13:40 – “Don’t Say Gay” Bill 33:15 – Rising Housing Costs 47:17 – “No Fancy Fish on Fridays” Questions: 23:37 – I have comments on reasonable expectation of the success in just war. …
Topics: 16:00 – Just war: Ukraine and Russia 28:00 – Endurance Fining 36:30 – Texas Transgender Bill Questions: 52:45 – I have some comments on the war. …
Questions Covered: 04:19 – I’m Catholic and was talking to an Orthodox priest. He said that Jn. 15:26 rejects the Filioque. How can I respond? 16:01 – What is the Church’s teaching on corporate personhood? 19:04 – On the nature of angels, are they inside or outside of the material created world? 21:28 – Why does the communion wafer look the way it does and how it was standardized? 28:40 – What is the interpretation Romans 10:6-7? “But the righteousness that comes from faith says, “Do not say in your heart, ‘Who will ascend into heaven?’” (That is, to bring Christ down) “or ‘Who will descend into the abyss?’” (That is, to bring Christ up from the dead).” 32:17 – Were there extra-biblical sources used in the writing of the Pentateuch? What’s the process of the redactors of the oral traditions? 42:21 – are those that learned the Faith in Catholic school but now reject the faith, in mortal sin? 49:05 – Is impeding the proper use of the body immoral? …
Questions Covered: 01:28 – I was reading a book about the Reformation and it says that Luther was a heretic. I heard you call Protestants our brothers, but would they be considered heretics too? 07:02 – What would you say to someone who accepts that Jesus founded the Catholic Church but can’t accept that errors weren’t introduced at some point in time? 14:20 – Can you explain Substitutionary Atonement Theory? Why do Catholics reject it and Protestants accept it? 20:33 – Who are the beneficiaries of the promises of Abraham? Where are those people now? 24:29 – I’m Catholic and believe in purgatory but I have a hard time with the following question: How do our prayers help people in purgatory? 31:29 – I’ve heard it said that Faith Alone is sufficient for Salvation but in James I see Faith without work is dead. Also, Jesus killed the fig tree after seeing that it produced no fruit. What is the Catholic teaching on these? 40:59 – I go to an Episcopalian church and we pray the rosary. There are no Catholic churches here that offer a group rosary, so Catholics come to my church to pray it. Is it wrong for us to pray together and how is it different from receiving communion together? 46:21 – I’ve been talking to Mormons over the past 6 months. They keep bringing up emotions and feelings and that they get a deep sense of peace when asking whether the book of Mormon is sacred scripture. How do I respond to that? …
Questions Covered: 07:27 – Why are saints and their intercession necessary? Can’t I just go to Jesus? 15:30 – Jesus says that John the Baptist is the greatest man, so how do Catholics justify saying that Mary is above all others? 19:11 – I heard that some theologians doubt Job existed. They also question the 6 days of creation. How do Catholics understand this? Is there an official position? 28:33 – What do you think is the strongest objection that a protestant can have? 35:25 – A friend was explaining the 5 basic points of Calvinism (TULIP). How can we respond to the question of predestination? 43:48 – How do I talk to Protestants about the real presence in the Eucharist? 50:53 –What does the title Pontiff Maximus mean and why did the pope adopt? …
Questions Covered: 02:35 – When we go to heaven does our knowledge of God continue to grow or does it stay the same? 12:44 – Was there a creed written in the Council of Trent? 16:23 – How can we answer the sedevacantist objection that the pope is legally elected but doesn’t have the authority of the pope? 22:17 – I’m reading St Augustine and I wanted to know, how do we reconcile free will and concupiscence? 33:56 – Is there a religious implication to the conflict in Ukraine right now? 41:44 – Everyone describes heaven with no more tears, but we keep getting messages from Mary that she’s saddened for souls? How do we reconcile this? 47:50 – Tim, you mentioned the seat of Moses in your CASA course, how does that play out for Christians after the resurrection? 52:49 – What lineage is Mary from? Was she from the line of David? …
Questions Covered: 03:57 – Is it possible for us as men who are living chaste appreciate a woman’s body without falling into sin? 13:31 – Is 1 Corinth 3:11-15 a typological reference Wisdom 3:1-7? 16:23 – What is one’s personal responsibility when it comes to end of life issues? 24:46 – I’ve asked my husband to pray together during lent and it still hasn’t happened. How can I encourage him to pray with me? 31:17 – I’m a convert but I still struggle with the teaching purgatory. I feel as though the verse “To be absent from the body is to be present with the Lord” supports people going to heaven. Can you help clarify it for me? 43:27 – How can you show a protestant the truth of the Catholic faith when they don’t know the bible or doctrine? 49:44 – I try to pray without ceasing but when I’m praying, I feel my peace goes away for a bit and comes back. Can that be attributed to evil or dark entities? …
Questions Covered: 13:47 – Is there a cycle of readings in the Eastern Churches, and what are they? How do they differ from the west? Are they similar to the readings from Orthodoxy? 17:56 – I’m part of the Assyrian Church of the East, being in partial communion what should I do? Should I seek full communion? 22:09 – For any of the Orthodox churches to come into the Church, does it boil down to the primacy of Peter or are the other things that are in the way? 30:41 – Why do you think we don’t talk about the eastern rites among Catechism classes? 34:36 – I’m Eastern Orthodox. Why did you convert from Orthodoxy to Catholicism? Is there anything else we can do to promote unity apart from praying? 42:33 – I heard that as a Catholic you can go to an Orthodox divine liturgy and fulfill the Sunday obligation. Is this true? 44:51 – Can you explain the use of the prayer rope in the east? 47:27 – Does the Russian government have any role to play in the lack of unity amongst the eastern orthodox churches? 49:22 – Mickey Rorke played St. Francis of Assisi in a Biopic movie. 50:18 – Is there any belief that the Orthodox have that we don’t as a point of faith? 53:16 – What is your perspective on the Orthodox teaching on contraception? …
Questions Covered: 15:31 – Regarding the sacrament of penance, I know the Eastern Orthodox Churches deputize lay people to hear each other’s confessions. What is the Catholic view of this, and do we ever make allowances for this? 19:02 – I’ve been to confession where the priests asked me to choose my own penance or gave me a penance with no end date. Is this a normal thing to come across? What should I do in these situations? 29:22 – I have a big sin from my past that I’ve confessed and still feel guilty about. How can I get that guilt to go away? 34:44 – My parish priest visits me once a month and I take that time to go to confession. If I sin the day after he comes and I do a sincere act of contrition, am I forgiven then or do I have to wait till the next month to be forgiven? 44:20 – Is it sinful to question whether I’m actually forgiven? 48:14 – My elderly father has started to come to Mass again after a very long time. He hasn’t been to confession and has been receiving communion. What’s the best way to approach him? 51:14 – Is it possible to request from God and receive from God our penance to not get it in purgatory. 52:53 – Can one be forgiven for a sin that one is too embarrassed to confess but says “and forgive the rest of my sins”? …
Questions Covered: 03:39 – My girlfriend is not Catholic but is now open to converting. Does she have to go through RCIA to just get baptized or are there other options? 07:16 – I’m just getting started in RCIA but am in the class with children but getting mixed information of when I could join the Church. Should I just “parish shop?” 15:39 – My fiancé is non-denominational, and her parents are strong evangelicals. How can I guide and lead her to the Church because she’s expressed interest? 18:41 – I’m moving and am currently attending RCIA at a Novus Ordo (N.O.) parish, but I love attending the Traditional Latin Mass (TLM). Should I start attending RCIA at the TLM parish or continue at the N.O. parish? I plan on receiving the sacrament at the N.O. parish. 20:50 – I’m in RCIA and going with my wife but I’m not converting. If Mary and the saints are so important, why doesn’t Paul show that? 29:12 – I’m in RCIA, regarding the “I” “We” baptism story: How do I know whether my pastor said the right words and am validly baptized? 33:52 – I’m considering joining RCIA, there are currently no issues with me joining but if there is a problem within my family, is there a better way of going about joining the Church? 43:06 – I’m having my teenage daughter come live with me. She doesn’t have much faith formation. Does her entry to RCIA have to be on her behalf or can I put her in it? 47:07 – I just came back to the Church, when does a sexual thought become a sin? 51:40 – Do Catholic schools or RCIA do a better job at catechizing Catechumens? …
Questions Covered: 08:01 – My granddaughter is in RCIA, and we went to Ash Wednesday Mass together. She asked why we don’t have women priests. What’s a good way to explain this to a teen? 15:39 – I’m considering joining RCIA. Why can’t religion embrace evolution? If God infuses a soul, how do new souls come into existence? 21:12 – I’m a RCIA instructor, I want to ask you about the processes and if you think there’s a better way to instruct and improve now that you’re on the other side? 29:22 – I’m too shy to come into the Church but can I still receive the anointing of the sick? 35:42 – If a person was baptized into the Church do they have to go through RCIA to receive all the other sacraments? 40:30 – I’m very confident in converting but the one thing that hangs me up is not being married in heaven. Are we going to have a close relationship in heaven? 47:48 – Can a baptized 9-year-old go to RCIA and get formed in the sacraments? …
Questions Covered: 05:23 – 1. Cor. 15:29, Mormons justify baptism of the dead, what does this actually mean? 14:36 – If God were to contact humans and directly communicate the immediate details of their life, would a human be able to deviate from that? 21:00 – There’re several places in scripture where it says that David is a Man after God’s heart. Because of this you could argue that David was the first person to be devoted to the Sacred Heart, Is this a good argument? 31:10 – Is anyone familiar with the book Bible, the Quran and Science? Can you speak on that? It purports inaccuracies in the Bible. 35:18 – Canon 1251 says we should abstain from meat on every Friday. Why is that not practiced? 44:50 – Can God create Himself? Was Jesus created? 50:50 – What’s the most convincing argument to make to a non-believer that the culture that the Church created promoted the advancement of science? …
Questions Covered: 04:11 – 1 Tim. 2 it says that woman should not have authority over a man. What does this mean? 8:39 – Why is online confession not allowed yet? 15:40 – In the Old Testament how do we know what a measurement of years is equivalent to the years of today? 23:07 – What kind of soul does a single cell organism have? 34:23 – Why does the priest remove a small piece of the eucharist and place it into the chalice during mass? 41:46 – Why did paradise not seem to be enough to Adam and Eve? 48:08 – When Jesus is walking to Calvary and addresses the weeping women he says “If this is done to green wood what will be done to dry wood” What does that mean? …
Questions Covered: 04:44 – My 7-year-old daughter wants to know why do we abstain from meat on Ash Wednesday and on Fridays? 11:07 – What does “created” mean in Sirach 1:4. – “Wisdom was created before all other things, and prudent understanding from eternity” 14:56 – How is the bread consecrated without Jesus being sacrificed yet while he was in the upper room during the last supper? 17:41 – I was married outside the Church to a non-practicing Catholic. I was never Confirmed and we divorced 3 years ago. Are we technically still married? 21:55 – I was raised Pentecostal and I had a vasectomy, would this bar me from becoming Catholic? 29:16 – Is it a mortal sin to provide transportation for someone who doesn’t have a work visa to work? 32:43 – In Matthew 6 it says that Jesus goes back home and does not perform miracles because they don’t have faith. How does the people not having faith play into Jesus not doing miracles? 35:29 – I tend to be emotional over the grandkid and my mom who is elderly, why do I get emotional? I’ve talked to a priest in the past about this. 40:56 – I’m not able to attend Mass on Ash Wednesday because I’m a trucker. Am I going to hell? 45:25 – Follow up on Vasectomy: I got one and my wife had medical issues where it was risky for her to get pregnant. Can you help me sort through the logic and values associated with the vasectomy decision? 51:09 – How do I approach my 26-year-old son when he challenges me about the Church? He insinuates that religion is evil and brings up slavery, inquisition etc. …
Questions Covered: 09:42 – How can I start a local group? 14:38 – My mom is in recovery and doesn’t think she needs more than AA. What resources can you provide? My sister and I enjoy an occasional drink. What do you recommend for us as children of an alcoholic, so we don’t follow the same path? 23:50 – I have a high schooler who’s struggling with online gambling addiction, and I need advice on how to handle this. 40:43 – I’ve been in recovery for 13 years and am a convert. I find the Faith and AA compatible. 43:40 – You mentioned overeating and I have an addictive personality. 52:07 – My fiancé is struggling with porn addiction. He’s been resistant to getting outside help. What can I do? …
Questions Covered: 03:22 – I’m Catholic and married a Lutheran, but she divorced me. Is the marriage still valid? 10:48 – How many times a day can you go to mass? 12:32 – Is God all-knowing and all powerful? 18:07 – I’ve been married and divorced. Does my divorce nullify me being Catholic? 30:27 – Did the followers of Jesus that had originally followed John the Baptist have to be rebaptized? 36:42 – I’m going to be received as a Catholic this Easter, can I go to confession now? 41:57 – I heard in an RCIA class that being Catholic is just a liturgical form of worship, if this is true why should I become Catholic? 47:36 – Baptism in Jesus, I have a defense for why it’s valid. …
Question Covered: 02:35 – Do we have an idea of how old Mary was when she was assumed? 14:17 – I was watching the conversion story of the late Alex Jones, how can I apply his story to my own conversion? 19:50 – What does Pope Francis mean by rigidity and why is it so important for us to avoid it? 35:41 – Since our Lord says no one is greater than John the Baptist, how can we say that Mary is without sin and greater than John the Baptist? 40:38 – What’s the difference between the Catholic and Orthodox lent period? 43:17 – My dad is judgmental about Catholics “parading around” with ashes. What’s a good way to respond to this? 51:14 – CORRECTION: Byzantine Rite starts Lent the Monday before Ash Wednesday not the 7th of March. 51:54 – How do you go about telling family and friends that you are becoming Catholic? Resources Mentioned: https://timstaples.com/2019/are-the-ashes-of-ash-wednesday-contrary-to-scripture/ …
Questions Covered:
11:50 – Is it moral for a married couple to use IVF if that is the only option to conceive naturally? 19:05 – Does a woman have to go through the same process for surrogacy as she would with IVF 30:09 – How do I talk to a family member who has gone through IVF and is continuing to go through it? 37:07 – God is present when a child is conceived either in a tube or the body. You are implying that God’s hand is not involved. I want to challenge you on that claim. 48:06 – It seems like you’re splitting hairs between fertility clinics and IVF procedures. If God has determined that people can’t get pregnant, how is it different? 51:03 – What are the Repercussions if someone decides to do an embryo adoption? Does it pose a moral problem?
…
Questions Covered:
05:56 – How would Trent demonstrate that a fetus has the right to live in the mother’s womb? 15:15 – It seems that there is no legal responsibility for the man. It is his fault for not having safe sex and kicking off the natural course of the events. Why is he not held accountable? 22:02 – Jer. 1:5 “I had a plan for you, called you by name” If there’s a child that was made with a plan, but there’s no soulmates, how can you have both? If there’s a plan, then how can you explain rape and incest? 35:58 – More attention needs to be given to men who lost children through abortion. https://www.usccb.org/committees/pro-life-activities/hollow-men-male-grief-trauma-following-abortion 42:49 – I’m an ER physician and have read that its permissible for women who have been raped to take the morning after pill within 48 hours. Has the teaching changed? https://www.usccb.org/issues-and-action/human-life-and-dignity/health-care/upload/Ethical-Religious-Directives-Catholic-Health-Care-Services-fifth-edition-2009.pdf
…
Questions Covered: 15:50 – Is the Leviticus prohibition on drinking blood a form of preparation for the Eucharist? Specifically, the punishment. 20:05 – Why are you not allowed to receive the Eucharist when you’re divorced? 30:19 – I work with some Lutherans, they think that we have the same communion, how do I explain that we don’t? 34:21 – How long does the presence of the Eucharist last after you consume it? 40:55 – I started taking medication and it started making me scrupulous and questioning my beliefs. Is it still ok to receive the Eucharist? 44:42 – I talked to a Protestant about the mass and he said the verse says “do this in remembrance,” so that means it’s just a symbol. How can I respond? 49:15 – I’m Lutheran, You said we believe in consubstantiation. That term is offensive. Why do you keep using it? …
Questions Covered:
02:36 – Is there different terminology for a priest, bishop or pope acting in persona Christi? 04:30 – I come from a Pentecostal background and am converting. My family is fully preparing for the second coming. The event with Russia reinforced their belief. How could I respond to my family, and how should we Catholics respond to the end time? 12:00 – I’m on the verge of converting to Catholicism from Protestantism, why do we pray to the saints? 14:13 – A 7th Day Adventist left a tract on cars after Mass. Is there a resource to answer those questions? 18:16 – Are you familiar with the company Senomyx. I heard they were using aborted fetal tissue in flavoring. 20:44 – Follow Up to the annulment questions, how does your earlier comment reconcile with the pro-forma annulment? 22:59 – There were readings in Mass on Ep.4-5, but they skipped a portion about speaking foul language. Why would this section be left out? 28:37 – I don’t go to church because of guilt. I don’t go to confession because of mortal sin. How do I handle this? 34:42 – Is it ok for a practicing Catholic to attend an atheist wedding? 39:07 – My husband and I were raised Catholic. My husband is active-duty military and we decided to get married outside of the church due to him being deployed. Will the Church honor it at a later point in time? 44:03 – I’m a recent convert, how do I become better at evangelizing? 46:41 – Are you familiar with the idea of Mother God, I couldn’t find anything on the CA website? 49:23 – At the end of this world, will writers be able to write about problems? 52:30 – Why aren’t there any miracles regarding amputations?
…
Questions Covered:
03:49 – Can a person be held responsible for a sin he intended to commit but due to circumstances he was unable to commit? 05:13 – Who were the correct teachers of the law before Jesus? 12:32 – CA Live App… Do we have an idea of whose wedding Jesus and Mary went to in Cana? 14:32 – Will our knowledge keep growing infinitely after our resurrection? 17:19 – Rev. 17. – 7 heads and 10 horns, what is the Catholic perspective of what this means? 29:06 – What would happen to someone who is in mortal sin and has an appointment to go to confession, but then he dies? 33:09 – Is it inconsistent to ask for God to change someone’s mind while still acknowledging free will? 35:28 – When the second coming happens, will we still have free will? 41:29 – James 2:24, Eph. 2:8-11, Romans 3:22,27 – Regarding Faith and works, what is the work that Paul is referring to? 47:19 – My son is in RCIA and has been married a couple of times. Why does he have to have an annulment? 52:06 – Did the apostles teach the Marian dogmas?
…
Questions Covered:
18:40 – Since Papal infallibility wasn’t defined till Vatican 1, how was a Catholic supposed to know when he was speaking infallibly? 21:36 – How can we explain the infallibility of the pope in a context that avoids seeing the limits as an excuse to ignore that which is not infallible? 32:25 – My cousin and her husband have started attending an independent Catholic Church (Society of Christ the King). Can I attend church with them even though they don’t accept papal infallibility? 36:58 – What declarations can a pope overrule from a previous pope? 46:00 – Why not just believe everything the pope says if it’s not really going to affect my life? 50:20 – I know the teachings on contraception were clarified by Pope John Paul II, I was told that Pope Francis overturned that teaching. Can he do that and is that true?
…
Questions Covered: 13:52 – With everything going on with Russia, I worry a lot about my soul and my children. How can I compartmentalize and prioritize? How can I not bring those worries into my home? 18:41 – Does worrying negate your trust in God? Can you have peace and still have some worry? 22:58 – Worrying as a parent, how do I let go of always being in defense mode over my kids? 29:17 – I grew up as a protestant and always heard of Catholic guilt. Where did we get the idea that if you’re Catholic you are full of guilt? Do we need to feel guilt? 33:01 – What advice would you give to parents whose children struggle with anxiety? 40:43 – I worry over my health issues, I was just diagnosed with cancer. How do I cope with this daily? 45:38 – If I don’t worry about things I don’t get things done. How do I deal with that? 48:53 – Where’s the line between being too laid back and worrying? 51:23 – Sacred Heart Radio…How can we alleviate the stress of anxiety? How can we not be so angry when we worry? I shut down and fall into a toxic cycle. …
Questions Covered: 03:50 – What is the difference between papal supremacy and papal primacy? What does the Church teach on these two? 12:43 – What is the biblical basis for the sacraments being administered in persona Christi? 22:31 – If individual conscience is prime, how intrusive can the Church be when it runs against individual conscience. Specifically, in regard to the vaccine. 35:20 – God was and always will be and it’s hard to wrap our minds around that. Why would he make human beings at this precise time? 41:15 – How do Catholics reconcile 1 Tim 3:2 with celibacy? 51:20 – We know there are 7 sacraments, 2 being marriage and religious life. Why isn’t being single a sacrament of vocation as well? …
Questions Covered: 07:59 – If a person prays while in mortal sin, is meritorious and is God still hearing it? I’ve heard different things from different priests. 14:46 – Does Tom think the great Apostasy prophesied in Fatima is currently happening now? 21:04 – I’m thinking about converting from the Methodist church, with the current situation about invalid baptisms in mind, will my baptism be considered invalid? 23:38 – My friend and I were talking about Martin Luther and the Reformation. She brought up the selling of indulgences. What is the Church’s response? 35:00 – Is it true that St. Augustine had a mistress and he called her by a derogatory name? This was a reason a friend used to leave the Church since he’s a canonized saint. 40:37 – In Mt. 6. “If you have to cut off a hand to keep from sinning, do it. It sounds very serious, but other places seem to be very light on sin. What am I supposed to do if I’m struggling with sin? 48:30 – Speaking in tongues, Is there any explanation on what language it is? 52:40 – Why can’t a Catholic Priest get married after he becomes a priest, but an Anglican priest can get married? And if the Anglican priest converts to Catholicism, why can he remain a priest and be married? …
Questions Covered:
19:56 – I have a friend with SSA, how do I walk with her in love and not leave her without offending her? We are both Catholics. 29:12 – I have an adult daughter who has SSA and is in a relationship. How do I support my daughter without supporting her actions, especially since some Catholics support and encourage SSA? 38:04 – I’m a high school teacher and a member of the LGBT community, isn’t boiling someone down to having SSA not showing them respect or understanding the fullness of what that means? 48:34 – What are your thoughts on protestant churches that focus on being LGBT friendly instead of salvation?
…
Questions Covered: 05:58 – I discovered “No salvation outside the Church” when reverting to the Faith. How do we share this message in a gentle way? 13:18 – Do you see whether people object to the faith because of the moral or the scientific side more? 17:47 – My son asked me: Why does God let the devil exist and also to tempt Eve? 22:44 – Regarding the We vs I on baptism: I’m getting a lot of push back from friends, how do I respond? 41:46 – I’m an atheist, I don’t see a need to defend the faith. Could you discuss the demonization of atheists among churchgoers. …
Questions Covered: 07:58 – When Jesus came he said he didn’t come to change but to continue but why did he change the teaching on divorce? 18:08 – 1.How is it justified that Jacob deceived his brother for his birthright and the blessing worked. 2. Why did the Israelites pray for quail if they had livestock as well? Why didn’t they just eat the livestock? 38:07 – Follow-up on veils – My priest told us that we veil because women are sacred and the things that are sacred should be veiled like a tabernacle. I would like to know your thoughts on this. 46:12 – My wife is Methodist, and I’m considering leaving the Methodist church for the Catholic Church. How can I present an argument from the bible for using wine during communion? They claim it’s a sacrilege to use wine. …
Questions Covered: 03:38 – Is there a contradiction between Romans 8:15 and Galatians 4:6? 10:43 – Was the prayer of Hannah in 1 Sam. 1:10-13 the first prayer recorded in the bible? 15:04 – John 17:11 Hebrew 1:4, Is the name Jesus also the name of the father? 20:50 – 1 Corinthians 11, Paul requires women to veil, why has the Catholic Church made this optional? 31:53 – I’m a non-Catholic Christian, can we trust the canon of the bible without trusting the Catholic Church? 41:49 – Besides the bible and the 10 commandments, is there any evidence for the exodus? 50:09 – In Mt. 7:13 Jesus says that the way to salvation is narrow, does that mean that most people aren’t saved? …
Questions Covered: 12:34 – Where is a good place to meet people that follow what they actually believe? 16:19 – I teach confirmation and had a student ask this question: when God created light, is that also when He created heat? 21:23 – Regarding confession: is matter and form more important, or is intent, since some don’t say the same word during absolution? 24:09 – Where in our DNA are inclinations for our likes and dislikes and can this be analogous for same sex attractions? 40:00 – How do we reconcile old and new covenant theology on the Levitical priesthood being eternal? 47:30 – Where can I find more about St. Joseph in the bible? 50:01 – Would a baptism be valid if a deacon poured water only touching the hair and not the actual skin? 53:05 – Follow up on Henry’s question on absolution: If all your sins are forgiven during absolution would that include the sins that you didn’t confess? …
Questions Covered: 13:12 – Could you summarize the first debate between Amari and French on First Things? 20:48 – One of the biggest problems in society today is pop culture. How can I guide my children away from this modernist view? Can we evangelize in stories? 32:19 – There’s a lot of Catholics that are OF the world and receive communion. They want to be accepted how they are. What do we do about them? 41:08 – What is the role of protestants in evangelizing in the culture? 49:49 – What are your thoughts on the integralist/liberal debate going on today? …
Questions Covered: 01:37 – Since the penalty for original sin was death and Mary was conceived without original sin, why did she face death? I know in some teachings we hear that she died. 06:07 – My family and I are on our journey to the Church; this is one of the final obstacles. Did she have to be immaculately conceived? I don’t see it as necessary. 13:12 – Who is the pope accountable? I know God but when he errs what are the steps to hold him accountable 21:10 – If a person loves God with all his heart and soul and loves his neighbor as himself, does he have everything he needs to be saved? 28:36 – I’m Catholic and try to pray the rosary daily, is praying the rosary daily a necessity? 33:32 – What makes sacramentals special and writing 20+C+M+B+22 on your door? It sounds superstitious. 43:30 – Why choose the Catholic Church over other churches who have apostolic succession? 48:14 – Why is purgatory not mentioned in the bible? 52:47 – Can you respond to sexual abuse in the Church? …
Questions Covered: 06:46 – I’m an atheist, how can you be sure that the Nicene Creed is in accordance with Jesus’ teachings? 17:53 – I don’t think the Church makes sense when they invalidate baptisms based on the change of one word from “I” and “we” 31:29 – My son raised this objection: When lockdowns hit, we could watch Mass on TV and not be in mortal sin but now we must return to churches. Why can’t I just continue watching the Mass on TV since I can focus more and not be distracted by others? 42:48 – I’m flirting with Orthodoxy, what’s the difference between the Catholic teaching on papal infallibility and the Orthodox understanding? …
Questions Covered: 02:15 – I want to get a better understanding of past, future, present justifications? How is this possible? 17:12 – Is there a specific way the Church lets people know which devotions count towards an indulgence? Can Indulgence affect us now and not just purgatory? 29:19 – The two beasts in Rev. 13, what do they symbolize? 31:35 – Rev. 5:8. I was doing a bible study with protestant friends, and they said that the “prayers to saints” is talking about us on earth. How would you refute that? 41:40 – I had a Lutheran pastor say that we are born as saints. It sounds very Calvanist to me. How can I respond to this claim? 50:11 – I have a friend who claims to be Christian, she asked me if people who commit suicide go to hell. How do I respond to her? …
Questions Covered: 06:20 – What is the proper interpretation of Sirach 1:4, specifically the word “create?” – Sirach 1:4 – “Wisdom was created before all things, and prudent understanding from eternity.” 17:20 – How can I prove the existence of the Catholic Church using scripture and Christian history? 28:39 – What has your medical experience taught you in your faith life? 42:18 – Can a Catholic accept the phrase, “The bible contains all things necessary for salvation?” 50:45 – I’ve considered joining the Church and I’ve decided to come into the Church this Easter vigil! …
Questions Covered: 37:59 – I’ve had 60 years of a good marriage and I’ve seen a lot of marriages fail because the man was addicted to porn. 51:00 – Life on the Rock interviewed a woman who wrote a book about women struggling with porn too. …
Questions Covered 24:28 – How do we encourage young couples to engage in doing the stations? 32:48 – I’m a new Catholic, I didn’t know the stations were supposed to be done yearly, when was this established? 51:16 – People’s reservations with the Hail Mary, It occurred to me that the Hail Mary is biblical! …
Topics Covered: 38:37 – Pope Francis recently said that it’s dangerous to replace kids with pets. I think it is offensive to God to call pets children. 48:55 – Comment on the babysitter: It’s common practice! This is crazy …
Topics Covered: 1:00 A Discussion in response to Patrick Coffin’s recent video on Pope Francis being an Anti-Pope 24:21 – Should we look at the papacy in a different light? Mainly since Pope Francis is from Latin America and it’s changing the mindset of the papacy being Euro-centric. 42:55 – I feel like you’re dancing around the topic. The Pope appointed a pro-abortion person to a committee in the Church. You can’t deny that he’s been doing some questionable things. 49:29 – What is the definition of an antipope? How can we know who would qualify as an antipope? 52:52 – I don’t think the pope is perfect and I feel like you guys think he is. I love the Latin Mass and I feel like he’s trying to take it away from me. …
Questions Covered: 06:34 – My son said that John the evangelist, the gospel writer and the apostle were all the same person but I’ve also heard that they are different people? Which is it? 20:23 – Is it a sin to go shopping on Sunday? 29:00 – Does God allow our dead loved ones to come help us during our lives? 34:44 – One of my friends gave another friend a mean note. What do I and my friend do with the friend who wrote the mean note? 39:16 – How many wives and kids did Solomon have? And was he considered a good dad? 42:35 – Could you expand on how it is our Faith that allows us to believe in the real presence in the Eucharist? 47:41 – How thoroughly do you check books before approving them in at Ignatius Press? 52:10 – How does one know the difference between venial and mortal sin. How do you determine when something crosses the line into grave matter? …
Questions Covered: 03:47 – Did Jesus and John the Baptist know each other as children? 08:00 – Is there connection between ASMR and hypnosis and is it wrong to listen or follow this as a Catholic? 15:23 – I told my kids over Christmas that I’m becoming Catholic, and it didn’t go well. How do I proceed with telling other friends and my church? 18:35 – Does the Church have a preferred view of the individuating factor of the human person. Material or spirit? 22:08 – Should swearing on the bible in courtrooms be made optional for non-believers? 28:16 – I’m a protestant, in my philosophy class we are discussing the question of evil. If Good is all knowing, good, ect, and was able to remain Mary sinless, why didn’t He do that for the rest of us? 35:51 – I would like to hear your cosmic prayer. I want to write it down. 39:28 – You were discussing hypnosis, in line with that, is yoga a religion? 41:05 – What’s the difference between soul and spirit? 46:42 – Was the early Church the same Church as the one in the dark ages that sent people to the stake? 51:58 – I was told that one day we will be reunited with our bodies, will we still be able to do earthly activities? …
Questions Covered: 13:41 – What is your take on whether an obstacle is the different images of who Jesus is? Examples socialist Jesus etc. 17:51 – Communion has always been an obstacle for many. I heard a Jewish scholar say the Jewish marriage ceremony includes “this is my body.” Is there a connection between that ceremony and Jesus’ last supper? Why don’t we hear of this connection? Would this be helpful to overcome the obstacle? 23:55 – How can an attachment to things of this physical world, such as over involvement in sports, be turned into a good instead of an obstacle to Jesus? 34:08 – I have an atheist co-worker, how do you respond to someone who does not have belief? 45:22 – The Real Presence of Jesus, I can’t always wrap my head around it. How can I overcome that obstacle? 50:34 – I’m a cradle Catholic struggling with a crisis of accepting God’s way instead of my way. …
Questions Covered: 24:20 – Being a young adult fresh out of college, how do I maintain a consistent prayer life working a 9-5 job. How can lay people be held accountable? 36:14 – How do you gain wisdom? 48:22 – My fiancé and I are going through RCIA and using Dr. Sri’s video, I missed some lessons, where else can I watch? 50:41 – I recently returned to the Church and all of my sins were forgiven through attrition how do I get to contrition? …
Questions Covered: 01:13 – Is there a connection between the Tree of Life in Genesis and the Cross. I’ve never heard this connection. 07:02 – If a saint has bilocation, do they share thoughts and memories to both locations or do they have one mind in both locations? 12:14 – With regards to the following story, Jesus drove out a demon and the demon sought out another soul but did not find one; he then returned back to the same person, Why would this person be predisposed to receiving the demon again? 17:50 – What does Jesus mean when he says don’t pray in vain repetition? 23:16 – Sirach 42:14, What is the Catholic interpretation of that verse? 33:07 – In regards to translation, why are some words given so much weight in specific translations and sometimes not even seen in others? 42:08 – Why can’t I baptize my entire household if they’re all willing? 51:17 – Acts 8:37 – Can you clarify your comments about the baptismal formula and the protestant objection from your book The Early Church was the Catholic Church? …
Questions Covered: 05:20 – Why do Christians and Jew alike not offer animal sacrifice anymore? 11:10 – I help with Confirmation, What level of authority does the subcommittee of the Catechism actually have? They recommended a book, and I was wondering if I actually have to follow it. 15:00 – I watched a video promoting the rapture, Is there someone that has responded to things like this? How can I approach this without starting an argument? 19:17 – I read an article on NC Register on the priest baptizing using the wrong words. What happens to the people who went on to receive the other sacraments and specifically Holy Orders? 28:50 – Regarding Hysterectomy, my wife is not Catholic, and she wants to have the procedure. How do I approach it as a Catholic and will it be a sin to continue to live out my call as a husband? 34:40 – What is the Gospel according to Hebrews? St. Clemente mentions it. Is there a secret Gospel of Mark? 41:49 – What or Who determines what public vs private revelation? Who judges what should be followed? 47:05 – Is there any dogma that teaches whether Jesus had the virtue of Faith? 49:55 – Is torture always wrong or are there exceptions specifically interrogations to save lives? …
Questions Covered: 17:24 – It’s sad to see that people are replacing children with animals. 21:00 – Would the 2 greatest commandments be a good response to “live your best life?” 38:57 – How do you I talk to my friends about why marriage shouldn’t necessarily be about making you “happy” when happiness is pushed as the ultimate goal? 42:42 – Where can young couples find a resource for things like NFP and other Church teaching on marriage? 45:50 – How does the Catholic Faith respond to other faiths and their fruitfulness if the Church claims that they are the one way? 47:42 – You can learn from the negative and not just the positive especially in divorce. …
Questions Covered: 15:16 – None of the police forces have demilitarized since 2020. Since peace is important, what is your opinion on threat protocols? Can we do something in the culture to reduce that? 22:40 – Is it a sin to want your child to marry within your race? 36:23 – I had a black Catholic friend who wanted me to read White Fragility. How do I respond to her who wants me to focus the conversation from a secular perspective? 44:12 – I have a daughter who is involved with BLM and I feel resentful that they are teaching her that I am racist. What would be better, to address it more forcefully or wait and pray? 52:55 – Are division and racism ways of dividing our Church? …
Questions Covered: 02:54 – Whichever of the standard folklore approaches one takes to faeries, it seems like it would be unusual for a faery to be baptized. Which in turn opens up some interesting questions about what’s going on with Cinderella having a faery as a godmother. Maybe there’s an order of fair folk who returned to the faith, were baptized, and do good works on behalf of mortals. They’re probably also suspected and persecuted by the institutional church. But Cinderella’s family is part of the remnant which maintains a connection with them. Maybe this also has to do with why the stepmother treats Cinderella badly: the stepmother is an outsider and suspects what’s going on in the family history and she’s putting pressure on Cinderella to try to make her renounce her pietism. Which of course makes it extremely dodgy to have someone with a faery godmother marrying into the royal family. There’s going to be some resistance to that. Is there reconciliation? Is the country placed under interdict? Why don’t the stories address this stuff? I have a few questions regarding the Soul Gem, one of the six Infinity Gems of Marvel Comics. Here I am specifically referring to the comic version, versus the film version. I do not know how much you know about the Infinity Gems, so here is some important background info: — They were created as part of the Universe in the Big Bang — Each allows for complete universal control over a different aspect of the universe: power, space, reality, the mind, the soul, and time. 1) 11:23 – The Soul Gem can warp and unwarp the soul. This means it can forcefully make beings evil or good. Thanos says: “I can turn sinners into saints, and saints into monsters.” Question: What effect does this have on free will, the need for God’s forgiveness, and Purgatory? 2) 14:39 – The Soul Gem can resurrect the dead. Thanos says, “And the dead, — their souls are also within my control.” Question: If someone was in Heaven and was resurrected, could they theoretically end up in Hell after they die a second time? What about going from Hell to Heaven? 3) Question: 17:06 – Could the Soul Gem fix Original Sin? 18:25 – What would happen to your soul if you were assimilated by the Borg? Let’s assume that the cybernetic implants and the nanoprobes keep your body alive indefinitely, you are never killed, and you are never rescued. 20:16 – Before the fall, did Adam and Eve have to poop? And if so, would their poop have been stinky? Or would they have had perfect poop? Or would they not have pooped at all, and the digestion was perfect, with no need to poop. 22:41 – Is it possible to validly baptize an unborn baby? I’m thinking of an instance where maybe the mother is dying and the baby is not developed enough to survive outside the womb. If it is not possible, does the reasoning implicitly contradict the church’s teaching on life beginning at conception? If it is possible to validly baptize an unborn baby in emergency situations, then what about non-emergency situations? It seems like it would be a good idea just in case something happens before the baby is born. 29:30 – What criteria would the Catholic Church have to consider if someone wanted to marry an alien? Would the couple have to prove they can consummate the marriage? Would they have to come up with some way to prove that they are the equivalent of the opposite sex? What if any child they bear might have severe disabilities because of mixing species? To that end, the Church is against bestiality, so would they have to come up with some criteria to distinguish human from beast? 34:40 – Why do all representations of the cross depict the corpus with a wound on the right side when the heart and plural sac are on the left? Would blood and water gush forth from the right side when a spear pie…
What are the Dead Sea Scrolls? What is their relevance for Christianity? Find out these answers and more from this episode of Catholic Answers Live. Questions Covered: 16:00 – What would you say to people who would dismiss the Essenes as just a fringe cult? 25:00 – What do the Dead Sea Scrolls teach us about His childhood and early adulthood? 29:15 – What are the Dead Sea Scrolls? 35:20 – Was St. Paul an Essene? 44:38 – Considering the Dead Sea Scrolls, why did the apostles choose the Septuagint type instead of the others? 48:44 – In Mark 4 Jesus says some will not be converted. I once heard that that verse was a reference to Isaiah, is this true and if so, what does that mean? …
Questions Covered 8:56 – If Martin Luther was a Catholic priest, then why doesn’t the Lutheran church have apostolic succession? 12:19 – Why did the popes stop wearing the crowns and what is the importance of the crowns? 22:00 – If the Eucharist is the full body, blood, soul and divinity of Jesus, does it have a consciousness? 35:06 – I’m confused about the sequence of becoming a saint, what is the order? What happened to the physical bodies of Mary and Jesus when they entered heaven? 41:50 – 1 Pt 3:21 on baptism. I’m a protestant looking into Catholicism. Can you clarify the verse? How do you reconcile it with the Church’s teaching on Baptism? 49:32 – If God is present everywhere, does that mean he’s present in hell? …
Questions Covered 10:00 – I’ve seen images of the Holy Spirit with a red cross over it, what symbolism does that have? And why did the Holy Spirit conceive Jesus instead of Jesus doing it himself? 18:49 – If the Orthodox Church is reunited with the Catholic Church, would it pose a problem if we recognized the book of Enoch and others? 39:04 – What is the role of ecumenism in Faith and practice in the Catholic Church? …
Questions Covered 8:05 – The Church Fathers say the body is the same before and after the fall and the resurrection. What does that mean? 14:39 – I was talking to my sister who is an atheist and believes in the spirit realm. How would you plead that the spirit world and God can coexist? 20:02 – With the Catholic understanding of baptism being salvific, what role does the person’s faith play? 31:51 – How did the early Church work through different people who taught different teachings on Christ like heretics? 37:36 – Is calling people hateful and racial names a sin against charity and if not, what is it a sin against? 49:14 – Can a non-Catholic adult receive the anointing of the sick? …
Questions Answered 7:04 – I am a non-Catholic. What do Catholics believe with what happened to Jesus on the cross compared to a Calvinistic understanding? 17:39 – What is your favorite church father? 39:48 – Rev. 9:6 “medicine being witchcraft” How do we interpret the verse? 45:12 Are their other Scriptures that are not in the Bible that are valid, such as the Gospel of Thomas? …
Questions Covered 6:40 – Why do bad things happen to good people and not always to bad people? 15:55 – How did John the Baptist and his disciples get separated from Jesus? 34:27 – Why did the way we receive communion change from on the tongue to in the hand? 43:19 – My niece is Catholic and engaged to a Catholic. My father is questioning whether it’s a sin to attend the wedding since they are getting married outside of the Church. …
Questions Covered 09:18 – Is the trinity only conceptually or universally revealed to mankind as three persons in one substance? 34:03 – If a priest is celebrating Mass and he’s not in the state of grace, is he exempted from consuming the host during consecration? 44:47 – As someone in RCIA, how can I better develop into a Catholic and into a Catholic who’s soon to be married? 51:08 – Is heaven on earth? …
Questions Covered:
17:22 – Can a Grandparent take any steps to get their grandchildren baptized even though parents don’t want to put in the work? 23:10 – Why are we as Catholics allowing our country to destroy itself through drugs etc.? 9:15 – What authority do atheists appeal to? 41:45 – I’m Atheist. I’m not sure why people should turn back to the Church if the Church isn’t addressing relevant issues. How is the Church making itself relevant in contemporary society? 46:38 – Was Peter the Pope and do we have evidence for that? 49:46 – Why does the Catholic Church put so much emphasis on the law when St. Paul says our salvation comes from Grace?
…
Questions Covered 09:18 – How do you respond when an Atheist says we claim that “special pleading” for the existence of God? 16:05 – I teach Catechists who went to college and have left the Church. What would be the best way to respond? 19:48 – Recently I was confronted with a person who experienced tragedy and asked, how can God exist if bad things happen? How do you respond when it comes from an emotional place? 28:33 – How do you know that the universe can’t be a necessary being? 33:55 – I’m an Atheist, you are stating that the problem of evil is a problem for Atheists. Why are you linking a moral assessment of the supernatural if atheists don’t believe that the supernatural exists? 47:23 – How do you address the claim that if the miracles in the bible were true then how come they were not recorded in other sources? …
Questions Covered: 28:53 – How do we deal with the popular scandal in the news regarding sexual immorality in the Church? How do I support a Church that seems to cover it up? 40:56 – I’m not Catholic yet, but it scares me to join because of the scandals and the effect they could have on my family in the future. Can you give some advice on how to get past it? 48:35 – Everyone points out how the Church has scandals, but priests are held to a higher standard than teachers who have a lot of scandals too. How do we explain to people that it’s not a Catholic Church problem but a human problem? …
Questions Covered:
01:15 – Are there any written or audio recorded angelic languages? 10:50 – Could you share your thoughts on some biblical and early church father quotations regarding the real presence of God in the Eucharist? 15:50 – I read a book about the witnesses of the miracle of the sun. Could you elaborate for me what happened in Fatima? 20:25 – Regarding the Roman rite and the Byzantine rite of receiving communion, how do their theologies not clash with each other? 28:40 – Are Sacraments required for salvation? 35:35 – I’m Presbyterian, I’m battling with predestination. What is the Catholic view of predestination and the elect? Send the drama of salvation 42:50 – In regards to Fatima, I know we are not required to believe in private revelation. Is there a more recent revelation that applies to today?
…
Questions Covered:
04:20 – Would it be inappropriate or against God to consider the holy spirit the female portion of God? 17:50 – Is there any biblical doctrine or dogma about the Immaculate conception that doesn’t rely on typology? 33:00 – I have some questions on some changes that took place after Vatican II. Like the implementation of Eucharistic ministers, receiving the Eucharist in the hand, women no longer veiling at mass, etc. Why were some things put in and some taken out? 40:00 – What is the significance of the story in Matthew 8:28-32 when the demons ask Jesus to send them into pigs and they go into the water and drown, what does that mean? 45:40 – How should I respond to people that justify contraception? 50:00 – How does stigmata happen? Have there been any recent cases since Padre Pio?
…
Questions Covered:
01:51 – With the translation of the Nicene Creed, what’s the difference between “confession” and “profession”? Like when we say, “I confess one baptism”. 04:48 – Thomas Aquinas had two arguments for the Filioque controversy. One of these is that the eternal origin is reflective of temporal mission. The other was that without it, we wouldn’t be able to distinguish between the son and the spirit. What are your thoughts on these arguments? 09:39 – How can I answer people that say the early church wasn’t the Catholic church? They believe Constantine put the Catholic church together. 16:09 – Why hasn’t the Catechism of the Catholic church been put in audio format if it’s such an important book? 20:30 – I recently went back to school for psychology and the topic of intersex people came up. It was argued that there should be more genders because having just two leaves out intersex people. Can you tell me how to approach this in a loving and non-judgmental way? 36:34 – Could you recommend some resources to refute Eastern Orthodoxy? I know someone that is drifting away from Catholicism and considering becoming Eastern Orthodox. How can I stop them from doing so? 42:56 – I have a Baptist friend whose mother donated her body to science. How does the Catholic church view doing that? 46:24 – I’ve heard the Catholic belief that Jesus’ flesh and blood is in heaven. Is that true? 54:00 – Since blood related sexual relationships are genetically problematic, how did they do that before in the bible? Did it not used to create problems?
…
Questions Covered:
16:53 – When did priests start wearing vestments? 19:17 – I’m a Catholic convert from 7th day Adventism. I wonder what the early church fathers were taught about the soul after death. Is the soul with God or is the soul asleep in what we call “soul sleep”? 23:10 – I was listening to a podcast called The History of the Early Church and the speaker kept saying that James was Jesus’ brother. Is this a known thing or is that not true? Did He have any brothers or sisters? 32:09 – When I talk to more educated Protestants, they will bring up the church fathers quite frequently but ignore questions about the papacy. How are they able to get away with that? Is that something they do on purpose? 35:50 – When did the early church become known as the “Catholic” church? 36:59 – If there are all these letters written by the apostles in jail, how come none of them survived? The Romans were known for how horrible they were, so were they letting enemies of the state in jail write letters? 42:55 – I heard that in the early church you were obligated to receive the eucharist once a year on Easter. When did that change and why did they do that? 46:48 – In the history of the church, has the church ever locked down like we did in 2020? Do the bishops or the pope have the authority to say it’s not an obligation to go to Sunday mass? 50:17 – In the apostles’ creed when it says Jesus descended into hell, when he came back, did he bring any souls with him? 52:15 – I’m an Anglican. If the Catholic church was the early church, then why doesn’t it look like the book of Acts?
…
Questions Covered:
05:27 – I have the cremations of my relative. What are the Church’s teachings on keeping these? When did receiving the Eucharist on the hand start being permitted? Where can I find the Catholic church’s writings on this? 15:05 – In Mark 3:28-30, what does it mean to blaspheme against the holy spirit? Why is it unforgivable? 23:23 – Why are our Churches not teaching that if you are complicit in voting for something that supports abortion, you are an accomplice to an intrinsic evil? Why did 50% of Catholics vote for a candidate that supports abortion? 31:30 – My girlfriend died a few months ago. How do I know if she is in purgatory or heaven? 34:52 – In Genesis Ch 1, it often says that God “saw that it was good”. Is there a chance that God created without knowing if something was good? 37:20 – If someone has a near death experience, where does their soul go? 40:50 – Why does the Catholic church require a divorce before you can get an annulment? 48:18 – Are Mormons able to go to heaven? 50:58 – My protestant friend said that when we say Jesus’ name, there’s not as much power in it as saying “Yeshua” or “Yahweh”. When we say “Jesus”, is there as much power in it? If we were all to be saying his real name, would he listen to us more?
…
Questions Covered:
05:04 – Were there any other people alive around Adam and Eve other than them and their children? 11:58 – How do we best understand the reality of Christ’s suffering and death on the cross? 18:15 – When someone says they’re baptized Catholic, how is that different from a Protestant baptism? 20:53 – Is it possible that God made other people before Adam and Eve and there are other descendants from them? In Genesis 4:14 Cain says “whoever finds me will slay me.” in 17 it says Cain met his wife. 23:17 – My wife and I are expecting our first child. What is expected of us in choosing the godparents and what is expected of the godparents we choose? 30:49 – Can demonic spirits from people that are praying over you come into you? 35:53 – Do you go to heaven if you’ve been cremated? 41:40 – I know that Jesus came to save us. If he’s half man and half divine, when he passes away as a man, is he still divine? 46:24 – I’m a protestant looking into Catholicism. As of right now, I believe in conditionalism. If I were to become Catholic, would I have to drop that belief? 52:40 – In the four gospels, is there any way to know if they were written in chronological order?
…
Questions Covered:
17:15 – Deuteronomy 22:5 talks about how men that dress in women’s clothes are condemned and looked at in a negative manner. Is that talking about transgenderism, and can that be applied today? 21:26 – With the young adult peer group I have, how do I speak the truth to my friends about chastity and gender without being insensitive and hurting their feelings? 31:30 – How do you know if your child is going through a transition without you knowing about it? 37:11 – We are grandparents of a 15-year-old girl that we’ve heard is thinking about transitioning. She’s threatening to commit suicide if everyone doesn’t support her. How can we deal with and help this situation? 45:10 – How can we as Catholics provide outreach to people that are dealing with this gender situation and do so in a way that is non-judgmental? 52:26 – I saw a study that said transgender identity can be linked to brain activity. Is this true?
…
Questions Covered:
15:12 – My 27-year-old daughter has come out. If God makes you who you are and being gay is a sin, then how can a child be born gay? How am I supposed to as a mom accept her lifestyle if it’s a sin to be gay? 24:37 – In the bible, God says marriage is between a man and woman and to cut off people that aren’t doing what’s right. In that context, how do we deal with the difficult relationships in which we know people that are same sex attracted? 33:34 – If the bible says it’s not right to be a homosexual, like in Sodom and Gomorrah, then why do some religions not take this into account? 46:32 – I’m 42 and grown up Catholic my entire life. I’m a gay man. We were always told that homosexuality is wrong but because I was being told that, I found myself hating myself. When I went to a private Methodist college, I branched out and spoke to many different priests. Isn’t it worse to lie to yourself?
…
Questions Covered:
18:25 – I have a 2 year old now but my husband and I have always wanted to adopt. If I’m already overwhelmed, how do I know if we’re ready to adopt? 24:34 – Could you give some information on how to get started in the adoption process? 32:31 – What is the oldest age of a couple/individual that you would recommend to adopt a child? 43:18 – I’m 45 years old, single, and with no kids. What are your thoughts on single people adopting? 46:04 – I think it’s wonderful the way you are about your adoptive kids. How could I start a resource to find more people like you? There’s so many kids taken away by CPS so I wish more could be placed with people like you. 51:02 – How does it work if you were in a situation where you opted to adopt a child from a woman that was looking to give away her child? Do you have to go through an agency?
…
Questions Covered:
39:18 – You talking about kicking your son to the curb brought up some old wounds about my parents. It didn’t strike me quite right. Can you talk through why you ultimately did it? 42:26 – Can I spiritually adopt my daughter and granddaughter who are atheists? 45:57 – As an older single adult, I’ve found it difficult to be alone. I just wanted to comment that there is a whole group of people that I feel people should remember. 49:18 – Could you go into more detail about the exorcism prayers you were talking about? Do you have to be in a state of grace to say them? 51:10 – Can you talk about adopting/praying for your own siblings? How do you reach out to them and help them get back to faith when they don’t want to listen to you?
…
Questions Covered:
03:30 – How can an infinite God be three persons if three is a limit? 06:30 – Does Canon 1248 of the 1984 Code of Canon Law prohibit attending an SSPX Mass to fulfill your Sunday obligation? 18:10 – Is drunkenness a venial or mortal sin? If it depends on the context, when does it move from venial to mortal? 24:05 – I’ve heard people talk about “the four things that call down the wrath of God.” What are those and where are they written? 24:50 – Is it possible that the six other sacraments besides the Eucharist are aspects of what Christ does, such as the water of baptism being the water from Christ’s side? 32:50 – Was Joseph young or old when he married Mary? 35:20 – How do we properly dispose of devotional materials in a respectful way? 39:20 – I heard that our prayers for our loved ones are only efficacious if we’re in a state of grace. I think that might cause despair since so few people are in a state of grace. 43:15 – How do I get past misinformation about what the Church Fathers said? Whenever I hear anyone quote them it’s always in favor of his own view, and they wrote too much for me to read it all. 45:30 – My friend told me that I have to be perfect to get to heaven, and I’m confused because I thought only Jesus and Mary were perfect. 48:30 – If Jesus saved the world, why is it still so messed up and why does he have to come again? 52:20 – How do we as Christians approach interfaith relationships in a healthy way?
…
Questions Covered:
17:35 – I’m in the Navy. What can I be doing now to prepare for fatherhood when I get out? 29:45 – My wife and I just bought our first home but we don’t feel at home there. What small things can we begin to do to make it? 31:50 – What would Noelle say to young college women who are more focused on a career than being a homemaker? 34:30 – How do I create a home if I’m living by myself? 46:10 – (Does the book suggest that you need to be a parent instead of having a career? I want to get it for my kids but I don’t want them to think I’m telling them that.
…
Questions Covered:
04:07 – Did Adam and Eve have belly buttons? 10:41 – I’m a new Catholic convert. The argument I get from others that say they don’t need to be Catholic is that according to Luke 9:50, Jesus authorizes people that aren’t Catholic to be followers. Why do we believe that you should be a part of the Catholic church as a follower of Him? 18:20 – Why is it important that Mary remains a perpetual virgin? 29:07 – My 6 year old son asks, “Why do we believe that the bible is true?” 35:44 – Why do Catholics believe that people are supposed to be baptized as infants? 44:50 – How can Peter have a teaching authority guided by the holy spirit when St Paul had to correct him because he gave a bad example? 48:54 – Why don’t we do what Peter commanded?
…
Questions Covered:
04:53 – Why do Catholics believe they can pray to saints? 14:31 – Are there any sources other than in scripture that explains why Christians believe in God? 24:49 – I’m a non-Catholic. Why do Catholics believe in the perpetual virginity of Mary? 36:53 – Why do we believe that the early church was the Catholic church? How can we then prove it to protestants? 44:41 – Why do we believe in the real presence of Jesus in the Eucharist? How can I explain it to my husband who doesn’t believe?
…
Questions Covered:
02:28 – Why didn’t the pope and the Catholics take more of a hard stance against Germany in WWII? 08:00 – Where is the Trinity in the Bible? 14:20 – One of my friends has a hard time with confession. He wants to know if he’s still forgiven if he doesn’t feel sorry for his sins, but he wants to feel sorry. 21:20 – How do we distinguish between sinners and righteous people, like the Bible talks about in the story of Sodom? Isn’t there a lot of gray area? 29:40 – Why isn’t there an official Church teaching on the existence of aliens, or at least a clarification on whether they might be angels or demons? 41:58 – Why would God create the dinosaurs if he knew they would be killed? 48:20 – Whenever I talk to my friend about Catholic teaching, he says “I’ll pray about it and God will tell me if it’s right.” Is there anything fallacious about this thinking?
…
Questions Covered
06:58 – Is the legal doctrine of adverse possession immoral? 14:03 – Do we have proof that Jesus walked on earth? 18:42 – Is Elijah the same person as John the Baptist? If so, how is that different from reincarnation? 21:02 – We were talking about baptism in RCIA, and one of the candidates says he thinks that original sin is a stain on the soul, but concupiscence is more psychological. Is he on the right track? 29:41 – What’s the difference between the extraordinary and ordinary magisterium? 32:30 – Can you respect the position of the papacy and still disagree in some aspects with the pope? 37:10 – Why didn’t the Apostles eat Jesus’s body after he died, since he called himself the bread of life? 45:05 – What does Jesus mean in the anointing at Bethany when he says “For the poor you have with you always; but you do not always have Me” (Mt. 26:11)? 51:08 – What’s moral and not moral when it comes to investing?
…
Questions Covered:
12:00 – I don’t feel a very good connection to our Lord. How can I make that connection deeper? 17:03 – Does the devil or anything evil make miracles like Jesus? 22:12 – I teach CCD and my student asked, “If God is all knowing and knew that Judas was going to betray him, why did he choose him as a disciple?” 29:03 – What are your book recommendations on building our relationship with God? 13:47 – I had a priest tell me that the particles of the Eucharist don’t contain the real presence of Jesus. Is this true? He was referring to the video of the priest that had a mystical experience at mass and said their church wouldn’t be receiving on the hand anymore. He took it in a negative direction. 40:17 – How do you help get youth to have a relationship with Jesus? I work specifically with teenagers. 43:08 – How can we be as perfect as Jesus? 45:02 – I’ve been on a journey of “sainthood” and in the midst of 2 years, I feel like I haven’t gone anywhere. I think what I’m missing is that relationship with Jesus. I don’t know how to have one. Can you help me? 48:54 – How important is it to spend some time with Jesus every day to develop a friendship? 51:20 – A good friend said, “Don’t say God, say Jesus”. Is there something I can do to promote that closer friendship to the triune God? Are we supposed to refer to one person more than the others?
…
Questions Covered:
05:10 – How do we talk to people about defending the lives of those on death row? 12:20 – If God is sovereign, why would the fetus be born in the first place if he knows they’re going to hell? 19:18 – How would you respond to someone that says, “A fetus is an innocent aggressor, therefore killing it is justified”? 31:15 – One of the arguments from pro-choice people is the verse in the bible that states that the soul enters the child’s body at some point in the middle of pregnancy. They argue that abortion is ok up until that point. How would you respond to that? 36:04 – How do you respond to someone that says that since the heartbeat starts at 6 weeks, it should be ok to stop it before that point? 43:46 – Do we know if aborted babies go to heaven? 47:55 – With so many self-esteem issues, how do you explain the value of life to someone that doesn’t think they should live? Since they don’t think their life has value, they also don’t see the value of a fetus in the womb. 52:00 – I have a friend who was previously pro-life and then had the potential of becoming pregnant and switched to being pro-choice. I ended up pushing her away with my reaction to her viewpoint. What are some of your thoughts on how to keep your emotions out of conversations on this topic?
…
Questions Covered:
01:26 – In Revelation 12, it talks about how the woman has birth pains when delivering her son. Is there any evidence that this refers to Mary’s pain at the foot of the cross? 12:25 – From scripture, is there a difference between dogma and doctrine? 17:10 – Is there anything that describes if the prophecies of Isaiah have all come true? 20:41 – In Matthew 27:52-53 when all the people rose from the dead when Christ was crucified, why is it not recorded in any gospels other than Matthew? What kind of impact did it have on Jerusalem? 28:44 – In Samuel 4:1-11, the Philistines went and got the Ark of the Lord from Shiloh. What is the ark? Why did the Lord leave Israel to lose to the Philistines? 34:24 – When we pray in accordance with the scriptures, what scriptures are we referring to? 39:32 – What amount of awareness did Mary have during the passion of Christ? 44:58 – The New American Bible has a note that the 2nd story of creation in Genesis is a much older narrative than the 1st. Does this mean that the 2nd story was written before the 1st? 49:37 – In Matthew 24:34, what do you think about the events that must happen before the end of time? What did Jesus mean by “this generation”? 52:24 – When Jesus cursed the fig tree, was it just to teach a lesson or was he truly angry?
…
Questions Covered:
02:54 – Did Jesus put himself in Mary’s womb since he’s God? 04:33 – I don’t think that Jesus was the Messiah. Why do Christians believe this? 12:52 – In 2nd Corinthians 5:18, it talks about the ministry of reconciliation. Is this approved text for the sacrament? If not, what does it mean instead? 20:22 – How can we interpret Romans 13:2 in reference to injustice in the world with the government? For example with the revolutionary war. 24:13 – Since only the Father knows the end of the world, does that mean that Jesus isn’t all knowing? 32:29 – Could you explain the typology of Mary being the Ark of the new covenant? Is it too far to say if someone touched her that they would die? 39:16 – In Mark Ch 3:21, Jesus’ family thought he was “out of his mind”. How does this fit in with the Catholic understanding of the holy family? 45:39 – Jesus said “I’m the way, the truth, and the life”. How do you get someone to understand that there’s a truth higher than their own? 50:06 – What kind of authority does the bible have if the Church is able to make decisions not based on the bible?
…
Questions Covered:
08:12 – Are there any statues honoring Israelites who came from Bethlehem? 14:33 – What’s your view on receiving on the hand vs. on the tongue? 21:20 – What are the Nephilim, and how do we know that we’re completely human and not possibly descended from them? 30:08 – How would you respond to a Protestant who said the Church apostatized in the 200s century is the modern Catholic Church? 35:56 – Does chewing gum break the Eucharistic fast? 41:12 – Is there any possibility Ignatius can reissue St. Gregory’s prayer book in larger print? 43:49 – Catholic Community Radio….Do the Gospels recount things in chronological order? 50:30 – What’s the emphasis of the parable of the talents?
…
Questions Covered:
03:47 – Do you know anything about The Healing of Families by Fr. Yozefu B. Ssemakula and whether it contains harmful falsehoods? 05:11 – Are Protestants who divorce and remarry (while still remaining Protestants) in adulterous relationships? 14:58 – My friend just delivered a premature baby. Her priest says he can’t baptize the baby because he can’t be touched inside the incubator. Is that correct? 19:21 – How do I respond to my Anglican friend who says that the Eucharist is simultaneously the Body and Blood of Christ and the bread and wine? 28:35 – What are the origins of depicting God as an old man and Jesus with long hair in religious art? 37:20 – How did John the Baptist end up living in the wilderness without his parents? 41:30 – My friend is going through a difficult time with his paranoid religious mom and I’m wondering if there’s anything I can share with him from a Catholic perspective that will help him out. 44:46 – How many times can you receive communion in a day? 46:55 – What’s the Bible’s advice about being vulnerable? 50:03 – Why is the priest allowed to dip the consecrated host in the precious blood before receiving, but the laity aren’t?
…
Questions Covered:
19:30 – Should I fear purgatory? 28:40 – Does the apostolic pardon remove all temporal punishment, or is there some other thing you have to do like being completely detached from sin? 33:10 – Did I answer my granddaughter correctly when she asked me “If purgatory is real, why did Jesus die?” 41:00 – If we pray for the souls in purgatory, do they know who prays for them? And is it okay to hear several masses for them, or is one sufficient? 46:50 – It’s a good idea to begin suffering in this life so we don’t rely on purgatory too much. 51:30 – Is it possible to prove that purgatory exists?
…
Questions Covered:
16:45 – How can I reach my son who refuses to talk to me at all? 22:50 – My son just told me he no longer believes in Christ but he wants a Catholic marriage to a girl who’s a devout Catholic. 43:15 – How do you turn off your mind at night when you’re thinking about your kids? 49:50 – How do I talk to my adult son and daughter who are fallen-away Catholics?
…
Questions Covered:
06:10 – Why is Michael the Archangel a saint if he’s an angel? When did the Church first start having saints? 16:15 – What is the origin of birthstones? Are they a pagan item? If so, is it ok for Catholics to have them? 23:19 – Following the resurrection, we’re told God exists outside of time and space. Given this, how would we be with him in the new world? 28:25 – What is the Church’s teaching on marital rape? A friend said it was never seen as rape but just a marital dispute so the law never had any say in it. 31:07 – Have you heard of Wycliffe’s bible? If so, is it ok for Catholics to read from it? 35:10 – As a Catholic, will your book A Daily Defense help me explain our faith to people who may not believe in it? 38:22 – How can I defend and incorporate my faith into conversations with Atheists and Protestants? 44:30 – Is there any connection between the sons of Noah and the 3 languages on the cross?
Resources Mentioned:
The New Testament Documents: Are They Reliable?, by F. F. Bruce The Historical Reliability of the Gospels, by Craig Blomberg Jesus and the Eyewitnesses: The Gospels as Eyewitness Testimony, by Richard Bauckham
…
Questions Covered:
06:19 – In other religions, can there be miracles? What do we do with the stories of other so-called saints from other religions? 14:05 – Can you explain the process of how the church declares something infallible? 16:15 – I’m an immigrant and I’ve lived in the US for 19 years but I don’t have legal status. What advice would you have for someone like me that wants to be a good Catholic and live a good life according to Christ’s teaching? 20:00 – You mentioned the best dating for the birth of Christ being 2-3 BC. Where did you get this conclusion from? Why do you believe that is the best time period as opposed to a different time period? 28:55 – I’m not sure what to do about my husband receiving communion. When I met him, he said he was Catholic but when we did marriage classes, he told the deacon he had only been baptized and didn’t receive his First Communion. I only recently found out about this so what should we do about this as he has been receiving the eucharist for 25 years now? 35:04 – How can I explain to someone that says a fetus is not an alive human? They made the argument that since you check for heart and brain activity to see if someone is dead, that would be the case for a fetus as well. 40:35 – If an orthodox church came back into communion with the church, what would they do about their canon? Would they have to get rid of it? 47:00 – Was dividing animals and walking through them ever part of the marriage covenant? 51:03 – To what extent can you disagree with the Church and the Pope before it goes too far?
Resources Mentioned:
CA Focus episode – What Was the Star of Bethlehem? The Handbook of Biblical Chronology, by Jack Finegan From Abraham to Paul: A Biblical Chronology, by Andrew Steinmann
…
Questions Covered:
05:11 – In Matthew 7:21-23, Jesus talks about being saved and doing the will of his father in heaven. What does the will of the father mean in relation to entering the kingdom of heaven? 13:38 – When Jesus tells the disciples to eat the bread and drink the wine, he’s just talking directly to them. Where in the bible does it say those items are supposed to be distributed to the people? 17:24 – What does God mean when he says we need to pick up our cross? 23:45 – I have a friend who claims she went to hell and while there, she was tormented by demons. What does the Catholic church say about life after death experiences? 35:43 – Will my mom still be saved if she used to be Catholic but she’s now protestant? 46:03 – Is water baptism necessary for salvation? 51:15 – The bible says that when Jesus died on the cross, people were risen into heaven. Were any of the people that died before Jesus taken into heaven?
…
Questions Covered:
08:04 – I have a hard time with the Marian dogmas. Where in scripture is Mary’s perfection written out? 16:37 – I live in a nursing home and they have ecumenical services that have what they call a “eucharistic meal”. I go to the other denominations’ services to build community, but I don’t receive these “meals”. How can I explain to others why I don’t? 23:45 – My girlfriend is Evangelical and looking to convert. She’s having trouble with Matthew 1:25 where it says, “But he did not consummate their marriage until she gave birth to their son”. Why is this said if Mary is a perpetual virgin? 35:07 – What is the proof of Mary’s assumption and incarnation? 44:44 – Why did Jesus have to die for our sins?
…
Questions Covered:
02:06 – My son is manically depressed and suicidal. He doesn’t care or believe in God. I know that in order for God to enter into his life, he has to be willing to let him in. If he is in a state where he’s not thinking clearly, would my prayers be enough to save him? 08:25 – It seems that the Church doesn’t let the public know of how they deal with priests that have violated human rights, particularly those of children. How do they deal with them and why isn’t this information public? 15:55 – Are we allowed to venerate Orthodox saints? 20:05 – Proverbs 17:17 says a friend is always a friend. Does that hold true when your friend is sleeping with your husband? 22:22 – Why is the staff of Aaron involved in the ark of the covenant? Why are the staff and the manna removed from the ark and just the 10 commandments are left? 29:12 – Could you elaborate on how we become true Christians of our craft? 32:25 – What happens to the time of resurrection with cremains? My mom was a devout Catholic and when she passed away, my priest said there was not a problem with separating cremains. Is this true? 37:00 – How do I respond to someone that says I should just talk straight to God instead of praying the rosary? 41:00 – I don’t understand Mark 6:52. Could you please explain it? 42:55 – How do I approach living a “single and suffering” life? 45:08 – Why was Jesus circumcised and why did it used to be mandatory? 47:33 – My husband has not been confirmed but he receives all the sacraments. Is this ok? He uses the argument that he doesn’t feel like he has to stand in front of a bunch of people and do it. 50:34 – If we aren’t supposed to separate cremains, why is it ok that there are relics of saints separated from their bodies?
Resources Mentioned:
The Catholic Guide to Depression, by Aaron Kheriaty
…
Questions Covered:
04:55 – Could you give me some advice on how to improve my prayer life? 12:00 – In the beginning of mass when the priest says “Call to mind your sins,” if he doesn’t say that, are they still forgiven? The priest at our church says “Let’s call to mind God’s forgiveness/mercy” but not the other words. 15:30 – How can one with kids spend time with them in prayer when they’re all under the age of 7? Also, how can one get them more engaged at mass? 19:10 – My mother wants to be cremated and put next to my father. When I recently spoke to the funeral home, I found out the people aren’t actually put under the ground but spread in their rose garden. Should I tell my mother? Both her and I are both devout Catholics. 23:40 – My husband and I have been married for almost 27 years and he started drinking a couple years ago. I have a hard problem with him drinking the harder stuff. How can I communicate with him that I don’t like him drinking that stuff? 33:29 – How should I confess my sins in regards to me talking to a woman who is separating from her husband? At what point is that acceptable or not acceptable? 43:50 – Is generational sin part of or foreign to Catholic thinking? 47:42 – I understand that a process of the canonization of a saint is to exhume the body to see if it’s incorruptible. How would you go about this if the person has been cremated? 51:52 – I find myself being really indecisive. Is there a prayer you can recommend for me to pray to see if God wants me to become a priest?
Resources Mentioned:
Catholic in Recovery
…
Questions Covered:
02:25 – I’ve heard a lot of apologists refer to a 3-tiered system of priests. Could you talk about this in reference to 1st Peter and Exodus 19 in light of the golden calf? 14:30 – I was having a discussion with our associate pastor and he said Mary was not married and I disagreed with him. Was Mary married or not? 20:20 – I recently returned to the Church. I prayed to God asking how to get closer to him and out of nowhere, I heard “give up everything”. What does that mean and what do you have to give up to be a disciple of Christ? 29:30 – If I go to confession and after I confess everything, maybe an hour later I die, will I go directly to heaven? 36:15 – How can I explain to a protestant friend that it was never intended for there to be multiple denominations but only one church? 44:55 – What is the church teaching on the books missing from the bible? Should we be reading them? 49:45 – In Genesis 4:16-17, where did Cain find a wife if there were only 4 people on earth?
…
Questions Covered:
04:30 – In the beginning of your book Pope Peter, you talk about how it’s a deficiency that protestants talk about the visible and invisible church. Why do you view it as a deficiency to have this viewpoint? 13:51 – In scriptures in the Old Testament, how do we know that God actually said what he said? Also, how did God speak to these people and how did they know he was speaking to them? 21:34 – What makes a confession valid? If a priest hears a confession, is it only valid if he’s in communion with Rome? 29:34 – How are patron saints chosen? 35:38 – Where in the bible does Jesus teach that pre-marital sex is a sin? 41:00 – My stepson is 9 but he has psychological disabilities in which he has rage fits where he throws things and says bad things. Does he need confession every week in order to receive the sacraments because of what he says and does? 50:25 – Why does Christmas have one “s” at the end, but when we separate “Christ” and “mass” there are two s’s?
…
Questions Covered:
15:14 – How does one answer a person who says he doesn’t believe that the bible is the inspired and inherent word of God? 20:18 – Could you please give a definition of “Theology”? I’m not really sure what it exactly means. 29:50 – Is there a theological preference based on the study of God’s word as to how he is worshiped in the liturgy? 35:53 – I heard about a teaching of the Church about how celibacy is an objectively superior state to marriage. How does it relate to Adam and Eve’s calling as a couple and does it indicate a shift after the coming of Jesus? 41:55 – I had a non-Catholic friend explain to me that compounding sin from Adam is the cause of our shortened life span. Is it true that the sins of our fathers are the reason we don’t live as long as Adam did? 49:12 – Why is the early church father Origen not a saint? As a catechist, do you recommend any sources for a full-blown catechist program?
…
Questions Covered:
7:30 – How do we interpret the genres of the gospels in light of historical discrepancies? 17:55 – Are there any limitations on solitary confinement that would be unjust? 23:18 – I’m a religion teacher and a student of mine asked, “Where is our soul before conception?” 29:03 – If Jesus was truly born on Dec 25th, what is the timeframe between then and epiphany? Did they really stay at the inn all that time? 35:15 – When Mary passed away, she was assumed, not risen into heaven. What’s the difference between assumption and ascension? 45:25 – Why did God harden Pharaoh’s heart if we have free will? 51:55 – A previous caller talked about how the dating of when Quirinius was governor of Syria wasn’t accurate. I know the answer to that as I’ve written a paper on it.
…
Questions Covered:
05:00 – Knowing that Jesus was a perfect man, did he always know that he was the second person of the Holy Trinity from the first moment of his human conception? 13:15 – Why does the Pope accept the “Communist Cross?” 19:25 – We just had an epiphany blessing at our church and the priest said it cannot be done in any other way than using the Latin Rite because there is not one in the Novus Ordo. I feel excluded when things are only in Latin. Why haven’t more things like this been made available in English? 42:02 – How do you resolve the conflict between Linus and Paul since John was still alive when Linus became pope? 51:11 – Two of the glorious mysteries are the assumption and coronation of Mary. In scripture, you don’t know Mary is crowned and raised into heaven. If the mysteries are based in scripture, how can I explain to Baptists the reason for these being mysteries?
…
Questions Covered:
14:20 – What are the origins of the word Vatican? I’ve heard that it means “divining serpents” so I’m just looking for some clarity on this. 17:05 – If Jesus is God and the Bible is the word of God, would Jesus have had to read the bible to know it? 29:58 – There’s been a lot of controversy over the traditional extraordinary mass being said over the Novus Ordo. Why is it that it will sometimes be allowed for Novus Ordo parishes to celebrate the traditional mass but then it won’t be allowed for parishes that only celebrate the traditional mass? 37:10 – When we go to mass and the priest says the words of consecration, is it ok for us to repeat it in the pews along with him? 42:46 – I’ve seen Christian women use their beauty to reach souls. When women use makeup in this manner, can it then be considered virtuous? Can the use of beauty in this way ever be considered virtuous? 49:35 – When you’re praying the Hail Mary, it says “pray for us now and at the hour of our death”. How does Mary know the hour of our death?
…
Questions Covered:
03:45 – Could you talk about how we as present-day Christians are fulfilling divine protocol and honoring who preceded us in the church? 11:50 – If a couple is married civilly for the sake of the children but plans to get married in the church later on, if one or both of them go to confession, would it be considered valid? 15:30 – Why does the USCCB designate some days as Holy Days and others as Holy Days of obligation? 21:20 – Assuming that there is only one creator in all of existence, can you logically conclude that this creator is omnipotent? 24:30 – I know that Jesus can tell a mountain to move, and it will move, but what does the church say about the authority we have as baptized Christians over creation? 36:20 – When Mary conceived Jesus by the Holy Spirit, does that mean that God adopted us into the family? If so, then why do we have to have baptism? Also, what question do you wish that I asked and what would be the answer to that? 44:10 – How does God experience time compared to how we experience time? Is it possible to pray for something in the past if we don’t know the result of it yet? 51:03 – Is there a typological significance to Moses’ death? If so, what is it?
…
Questions Covered:
06:50 – According to tradition, Peter was a bishop of Antioch, but later went on to find the Church of Rome. The Eastern Orthodox tend to bring it up as a contention against Papal supremacy. How can we argue against this? 13:45 – What would’ve happened if Adam and Eve hadn’t sinned? 17:45 – I’m addicted to watching alien shows/content and it’s had a negative effect on my faith. Can you give me some tips on how to reconcile my interest with my faith? 23:45 – I feel sometimes that even though I have everything, it all feels mundane, and I have a thirst for Heaven. It feels like a prison. Can you tell me how I can deal with this? 35:30 – How can I bring someone to the faith who doesn’t really read the bible? 45:00 – I have a friend who’s a deacon in the Coptic church, and he tells me that when Joseph and Mary left with the baby Jesus to go to Egypt, they were there for 3 years. If that’s true, how was he presented in the temple? 48:50 – I wasn’t a believer growing up in the Catholic Church. In the past 5 years, I’ve come to realize my ways were not good. I’ve been looking into various religious sects, but I’ve come to see that the Catholic Church is the true Church. How do I move forward from here?
…
Questions Covered:
03:30 – How does the 8th day play into the sabbath? 18:40 – How do we respond to the object that we’re just picking and choosing what the church fathers said? 29:45 – Can you articulate the difference between what happened on the cross from a Reformed Christian position and the Catholic position? If you could start at the death of Jesus and go through the resurrection, not leaving out the Reformed Protestant/Calvinist position of feeling the wrath of God. 41:10 – Was it necessary for Christology for Jesus to be virgin-born? 45:20 – I’m not Catholic but at Christmas time I always watch the mass. How far back do the rituals of the mass go? 48:50 – What is the evidence that the Church believed in the Immaculate Conception before it was defined? Were there any early church fathers that believed in it before it was defined?
…
Questions Covered:
06:35 – My mother is Episcopal but I’m Catholic. What can I tell her that will really get her over the hump and want to become Catholic? 15:00 – I have a protestant family member that asked, “Why do Catholics believe that Mary didn’t die and where can we find it in the bible?” 18:40 – There’re certain popes who have told some notoriously bad lies. Given that the pope is supposed to be the vicar of Christ, why is he able to act that way? Wouldn’t the holy spirit lead him away from that? 28:50 – My Protestant roommate has assented to the truth of Catholicism. However, he has such a thriving church community at his Protestant church that he’s hesitant to leave and commit to becoming Catholic. What are some arguments I can use to help him fully cross over into wanting to become Catholic? 45:30 – I feel baptism is not the right thing to do to a baby and that it should be a conscious decision of an adult. Could you give some examples from the bible of where it says babies should be baptized? 52:20 – My wife wants to know why she has to fill out an annulment form if I am the one that wants to join the Catholic Church.
…
Questions Covered:
04:47 – Do you think there’s going to be a future with the Latin Mass or is the Pope trying to get rid of it entirely? 12:24 – According to Protestantism, they repent, their sins are forgiven, and they go to heaven. If we as Catholics don’t confess them to a priest, they are not forgiven, and we cannot go to heaven. Why is it that our terms are different? 21:43 – Paragraph 603 of the Catechism says, “Jesus assumed us in the state of our waywardness of sin”. Could you unpack and clarify this? I understand the son of God became a human being with all of our characteristics other than sin. If this is true, then how did He have “waywardness” Himself? 30:02 – John 3 says you need to be baptized to be saved. Luke 7 says your faith saves you. How did the woman in Luke get saved without Baptism? 36:23 – My daughter is having problems with fertility and her OB GYN is recommending she freeze her eggs. What is the Catholic Church’s view on this and fertility? 45:58 – Simon says to her, “Behold this child is destined for the rise and fall of many, and as a sign that will be contradicted, a sword will pierce so the thoughts of many will be exposed.” What is being contradicted and what is this sword that is piercing? Why is Mary’s heart being pierced taken only mystically and not literally? 50:51 – I was invited to a New Year’s party with friends and I know there is going to be excessive drinking and sexual immorality. What is the church’s stance on scandal and how would it relate to my situation?
…
Questions Covered:
04:20 – Why is it that lay people cannot offer the Eucharist, at least to a limited capacity/ privately? 12:47 – What are some ways or methods to prove Apostolic Succession, going back to the apostles? 18:56 – Is it a contradiction that God is both perfectly merciful and perfectly just? 29:39 – I’m a recovering alcoholic and my kids told me I lashed out and that they prayed over me/ performed an exorcism. I ended up becoming sober a month later, but I have no memory of any of it. Can you tell me if it was valid? 40:30 – When we recite the creed, we say Jesus “will come again to judge the living and the dead”. If Jesus died for our sins, how does judgement come into play later on? 4:17 – Is it ok to take the COVID vaccine if it’s been tested on aborted fetal cells? 50:44 – I have friends who are bible Christians, and they have an aversion to Mary and the rosary. How can I respond to them saying that because it’s not in the bible, it’s not valid?
…
Questions Covered:
05:45 – I feel the Catholic policies on priests being celibate and born-again protestants not being able to receive the Eucharist are wrong. 15:34 – I’m a protestant. Could you give an explanation on baptism being tied to salvation? 20:44 – What does the sacrifice of the mass refer to? Wasn’t Jesus already sacrificed? 29:01 – How can you go from experiencing Christ in the eucharist not just from a theoretical standpoint but a personal one as well? 40:20 – Could you provide some clarification on the Catholic Church’s teaching on the redemption of Christ? How does He redeem our souls with His death? 46:50 – I know that you’re supposed to confess past mortal sins if you remember them, but does this apply to someone with scrupulosity that has trouble discerning whether a sin is mortal or not? 49:53 – Why does the church have a stance of being against in vitro fertilization if God said to “be fruitful and multiply”?
…
Questions Covered:
05:13 – I heard you quote there are less abortions now than before Roe V. Wade. I’ve had a pro-abortion friend tell me the same thing. How do you find a statistic like that? 16:42 – Do you think it’s morally correct to take the vaccine and how do you think it will have an effect on the pro-life movement? 28:46 – Why does the church advocate specifically for vaccines if they know they use aborted fetal cells in their development? 33:42 – My wife had an ectopic pregnancy and miscarried the baby at 6 weeks. Where does the church say the baby goes to? Are they in heaven or limbo? 43:57 – Can you disprove that Jesus was pro-choice? I really feel like Jesus wants us to choose life.
…
Questions Covered:
02:55 – Does the original 1611 King James version of the Bible have the deuterocanonical books in it? I know the Douay-Rheims version does but would that King James version be ok? 07:10 – Is it a sin to listen to music that has swear words? Can you enjoy it even if you don’t agree with what they’re talking about? 13:10 – I was raised a Catholic but have been away and haven’t gone to reconciliation for a number of years. All I remember is going as a child. How does an adult go to reconciliation? 20:15 – How could the Catholic Church have avoided The Great Schism and The Protestant Reformation? 29:54 – I’m doing my best to fast and pray but it almost feels like nothing is coming of it, especially with trying to end abortion and euthanasia. I just don’t know what else I can do. How can I get past this point? 35:32 – Since Mary was born without original sin, didn’t that predispose her to say yes to the angel Gabriel? If it didn’t, then why was she born without original sin? How is it known that she wasn’t born with it and not just purged of it after she said yes. 41:59 – I was reading the Saint Joseph bible and it said after Jesus was born, Joseph and Mary had sexual relations. Why did it say that if Mary was a perpetual virgin? 48:48 – If even though Mary was born without sin and then chose not to sin, wouldn’t the same be true about Jesus himself? 51:59 – Does Jesus break the law of non-contradiction since he is both divine and human at the same time?
…
Questions Covered:
05:10 – We were just informed that our granddaughter is bisexual and has a friend that is becoming transgender. How do we treat this situation? 12:47 – I am recently divorced. I’ve already talked to a priest, and he said we have grounds for annulment. How soon should I go about starting this process? 18:20 – What is the point of elevation during mass? 21:46 – My family friend bought a book for Christmas and the past 5 or 10 years, the author has been implicating the Holy Father in nefarious end time prophecies. Can I trust him and his book regarding these prophecies? 29:41 – I had a friend get a chapel veil for a Christmas present. Could you tell me more about it? When and how did it come about and when is it appropriate to wear one? 32:03 – How are we supposed to deal with someone that is in a same-sex relationship at our church? They’re in a leadership position and actively leading young people astray. It seems like no one else is dealing with it. 40:58 – I haven’t gotten the vaccine yet and I don’t know if it’s right or wrong. If I get it, will I go to hell? 47:00 – My favorite translations of the bible are the King James and the New King James versions. As long as I am reading the deuterocanonical parts in the Catholic Bible, is it wrong to read from these Protestant versions? Is there anything anti-Catholic in these versions? 50:49 – I want to gain a better understanding of priests and the orders they choose. How do they go about choosing one and when? Also, do they have to stay a part of that order the rest of their lives or can they switch?
…
Questions Covered:
01:30 – A friend of mine says historically the transubstantiation was just developed by the authority and the clergy to get people to give more money and to control the church. She also said that priests are celibate because the church didn’t want to pay for wives and children. Are either of these statements true? 11:30 – What do you think of the book “Purgatory” by Father FX Schouppe? 16:15 – How does retirement work with Jesus saying not to store up treasures? 19:25 – Why do we have to wait until children are born for them to be baptized? If there is a surgery done where they must be taken out of the womb and then put back in, could they be baptized during that time? 22:00 – Could you talk about Hebrews 10:29, specifically where it mentions “sanctifying”? When I was having a dialogue with some Calvinists, they said he who is being sanctified is Jesus himself but to me it seems that it’s talking about a person who is falling away from the faith. 34:15 – What are the origins of saints being a patron of a specific cause? 43:20 – Can humility bring about harm to other people if you ask for it for yourself? 47:50 – What is the origin of Christmas as a holiday? I’m a high school student and today in class a student and teacher told me it’s a pagan holiday. Could you give some clarification as to where they may have gotten that from and if it is indeed a pagan holiday?
…
Questions Covered:
03:40 – What do Ch 65 and 66 mean in terms of a new heaven and new earth? Does sabbath rest on Saturday night and Sunday night still apply? 14:00 – If you are getting someone the sacraments in an extraordinary matter and you have doubts if they know of the necessary truths, is it ok to share those truths with that person? How can someone validly receive last rites if they’re not Catholic? 18:25 – Is it possible for humans to communicate with animals telepathically other than just speaking? 28:50 – I’m seriously considering joining the Catholic Church but I have problems with how Catholicism changes what the bible says. For example, where it says “Eat the bread and drink the wine,” however, I have yet to go to a Catholic church that serves the wine. 35:10 – I haven’t gone through confirmation yet but I want to change rites, from the Latin rite to Byzantine rite. How can I go about that? 39:25 – In your opinion, what’s a cool story in the Old Testament to do for a bible study? 43:10 – Is there a difference between dogma and doctrine? 46:30 – I’ve seen a few Catholics that use a red ribbon or red thread kind of like a bracelet to keep away bad spirits. Is this allowed? Could it also be used so that you yourself don’t pass along evil to others? 51:00 – Why do people think that John the Baptist was Jesus?
…
Questions Covered:
05:10 – What is the meaning of Matthew 24:28 because it’s translated differently. One says “where the carcass is the vultures will gather”. Another says “where the body is the eagles will gather”. Is it talking about the church and the saints? If so, why do some translations not seem that way? 15:30 – What is happening in the book of Tobit to Sarah’s previous husband? Is God allowing the demons to kill the husband? Or is it more figurative? 16:52 – My son was saying he doesn’t understand in Job why God is allowing all these things to happen to Job. He thinks it’s unfair and that it’s really then the work of the devil. How can I explain why God is allowing these things to happen? 21:58 – What are some resources I can use to better understand the bible? 24:12 – What is the connection between 1st Thessalonians Ch 4:14 and the assumption of Mary? It’s in my rosary pamphlet so I was wondering if you could offer any other passages connected to the assumption to better meditate on it. 31:52 – How best can you read the bible and fully understand it? Are there any resources to use so that I can be sure not to just take everything literally? 39:00 – Is Joachim’s (Mary’s Earthly Father) name in the Bible? 41:42 – I’m having trouble interpreting the moment where Jesus is with the apostles, and they see someone is spreading the word of Jesus and they don’t want to hear about it but Jesus says they’re an ally. How can we say that the Catholic church is the true church while excusing the fact that people are part of other denominations? 46:16 – The Old Testament mentions some animals that we’re not supposed to eat because they’re “dirty”. Are we fully allowed to consume animals even though this is mentioned? 51:01 – What did Martin Luther do to alter the original bible scriptures to make them his own? 52:44 – For the virgin birth prophecy in Isaiah 7:14, is it a dual prophecy or is it only for the virgin birth?
…
Questions Covered:
4:21 – Did the blessings from the Old Testament from Abraham and the prophets have any supernatural benefits attached to them? 12:04 – In your book “The Bible is a Catholic Book”, you said that after the apostolic age, no new scripture was written. Where can I find more information/evidence on this? 14:50 – Why does the book of Daniel at end of Ch 14 feature a second incident of Daniel being thrown in the lion’s den? 19:32 – Were the guards at the tomb Roman or Jewish? What does church history tell us about them? 22:22 – At the presentation of Jesus at the temple, Simeon says to Mary “a sword will pierce your heart too so that the thoughts of many can be revealed” What does that mean, specifically, “that the thoughts of many can be revealed”? 29:00 – Is there any way to reconcile the Torah, the Christian bibles, and the Koran? 32:52 – What is the historical/ biblical evidence for apostolic succession? I’ve been having a discussion with a protestant about it. 41:21 – I had a priest tell me that biblical history started with Ch 11/12 when God talked to Abraham. He said everything before that was just a story to set things up. Is that true? 46:48 – Could you explain 2nd Kings and the story of Elisha? It seems kind of random and I don’t really understand it. Why did they make fun of him and why was his punishment so severe?
…
Questions Covered:
05:57 – What is the difference between salvation and redemption? Who paid the cost for redemption? 07:56 – I’m a revert and I found out that since my wife and I were married outside the church, it’s not found valid. Can I have some clarification as to how our marriage is seen in the eyes of the church and how to go about this “hiatus” until we get it validated? 13:41 – Is there any reference in the bible to there being a “mother” God or a female figure God? 17:41 – If you’re going to have a religious practice that’s trying to study the heart and mind of reality, why wouldn’t your religion be totally scientifically based, Catholicism seems to always be on the coattails of science. 21:47 – I had a Methodist friend who argued for female ordination and brought up St Paul mentioning Junia, saying she was “honored among the apostles”. Could you talk about this and what it means in terms of females being able to be ordained? 30:55 – At the 2019 Amazon summit that met at the Vatican, what did the Pachamama statue that was presented to the pope symbolize? Was it the Virgin Mary or “mother earth”? 35:56 – How is there one God but then when talking about the trinity, it is said that God is then each of the three parts as well? 44:19 – A Lutheran friend said Christianity is the only religion where works are not required for salvation. Could you please give me a Catholic response to this? 49:00 – I’m a new Catholic. Once a month the priest gives a priestly blessing on new couples married within that month. He raises his hand to give that blessing. The parishioners raise their hands toward the couples as well but I never do it. What is the right way?
…
Questions Covered:
06:20 – How can Jesus be both finite and infinite at the same time? 14:35 – In Hebrews 10:5-10 where it says “but a body you prepared for me,” is the “body” the body of Jesus or the body of the Blessed Mother? 17:05 – Why in Leviticus and Deuteronomy is the penalty for breaking so many laws death? 20:53 – How is the word “brother” used in the bible? Is it always just in the literal sense? In Luke 1:36 I believe it’s used differently. 28:39 – During the great schism, if the bishop of Rome separated from the rest of the patriarchy, why wouldn’t that be considered a judgement on the see of Rome by the united church of the first millennium? 33:21 – After the resurrection of Jesus, he tells Mary Magdalene not to touch him because he hasn’t gone to the father, but Thomas sticks his fingers in the wound prior to him going to the father. Why is that? 36:22 – I’m a confessional Lutheran, could you give me 3 of the most important ways we have it wrong and 3 of the most important ways we have it right? 44:59 – Are we allowed to consume meat from halal butchers? I’m not sure if it is prepared a certain way that would be against Catholic teaching. 50:33 – I want to go into apologetics, specifically for the unbound. How would I go about starting out? 52:00 – If the translations of the bible are from Greek, does it mean that the Greek bible has it all correct?
…
Questions Covered:
07:26 – Where I live, any gathering of more than 50 people requires you to be vaccinated. Some masses are being restricted to vaccinated persons only. What’s the moral procedure in requiring this sort of thing in order to receive the sacraments? 17:30 – Where did the King David star come from? 21:58 – If I have a child out of wedlock, am I able to receive communion after going to confession? 28:53 – I’ve noticed some books have two stamps that go on the front of books that say they’ve been reviewed by the bishop and/or are free from doctrinal error. Why would some books that deal with doctrine choose not to be reviewed and approved in this way? 33:16 – I had a discussion with someone about praying to Mary and I said that Jesus obeyed the commandment to honor his mother and father. How do I respond to him asking if Jesus prayed to Mary? 36:42 – Is it true that when you receive Jesus that you are also receiving a part of Mary? 44:48 – Why would being vegetarian or vegan be against our faith? 48:25 – Why do Catholics pray to St. Michael and call him “thou” rather than “you” as if he is superior to humans?
…
Questions Covered:
24:00 – When we as Catholics say Jesus is the fulfillment of the Old Testament, how do we know that the writers didn’t do that intentionally? 35:05 – Is there a Catholic book that talks about what happened between the Old Testament and the New Testament? 43:55 – How do you find the Immaculate Conception in scripture? 51:46 – I think when Jesus was walking with the two disciples after his resurrection is when he was connecting the dots between the Old and New Testament.
…
Questions Covered:
07:02 – Is holy orders necessary for someone to receive a valid sacrament from them? 17:03 – Did the Catholic Church start novenas? 21:53 – Is it ok for Christians to uphold some stoic thought? Also was Saint Paul influenced by stoicism at all? 25:09 – How did the early Christians interpret the words “the Holy Catholic Church” in the Apostles Creed? 32:45 – I heard that Augustine taught that baptism was done “ex opere operato”, but the fathers before him taught that it was through faith. Why is that? 36:45 – I was reading your book Pope Peter and you had a different interpretation to Galatians Ch 2. How did you come to the conclusion that the James that’s being spoken about is James, son of Zebedee and not James, son of Altheas? 43:00 – If I belong to a church that is in communion with Rome, like Lutheran or Orthodox, then why should I become Catholic? 50:01 – When did the Tabernacle start to become instituted?
…
Questions Covered:
18:53 – How can we be sure that Church Fathers weren’t just handpicked to fit the views of The Church? Why should we listen to their words as opposed to other people of importance? 32:10 – Did the Catholic Church embrace or allow certain pagan practices? For example, the Christmas tree, giving presents, hanging lights, etc. 49:20 – Could you explain how to distinguish between when Jesus and the church fathers are speaking symbolically and literally? Specifically, how to answer Protestants that argue that Jesus was just speaking symbolically about the real presence of the Eucharist.
…
Questions Covered:
00:54 – Why can’t we commune with people that are dead? See them, talk to them, etc. My husband recently passed away. 17:00 – Why was a land flowing with milk and honey attractive to Jews if they’re lactose intolerant? 23:39 – In the garden of Eden, why is the “evil” tree called the tree of knowledge? A lot of atheists attack in this way, saying that God doesn’t want us to have knowledge. 33:14 – When Martin Luther left the Catholic Church, were there other Priests that either left with him or, if they didn’t leave, they agreed with him? 35:28 – How can infants be baptized if they have not repented? In the New Testament, it seems to insinuate that baptism is not possible without repentance and discipleship. 44:39 – In the Old Testament we have tetragrammaton, the unpronounceable name of God. Why are we or aren’t we allowed to say this? 52:30 – If you wanted to understand the mind of God, why wouldn’t your religion want to study what exactly God did? Shouldn’t there be a more scientific approach to religion?
…
Questions Covered:
04:11 – From a Catholic perspective, is there any guidance or are there any rules regarding an age difference in a marriage? 06:48 – Who are the scribes and Pharisees that sit on the seat of Moses in Matthew 23:2? 13:37 – Does the church have any teachings about loved ones coming to visit us in our dreams? Is there anything in the bible that talks about it? 16:50 – Jimmy, you did a joint podcast with a Lutheran named Jordan B Cooper. What do you think it would take for Lutherans to be back in communion with the Catholic Church? 17:02 – What is to be said about the salvation of people of other religions that are very devoted to their practice of it? 29:55 – Lucifer was supposed to be the second most powerful being before he fell from heaven. How is Saint Michael able to defeat him if he’s not as powerful as him? 29:55 – Lucifer was supposed to be the second most powerful being before he fell from heaven. How is Saint Michael able to defeat him if he’s not as powerful as him? 35:50 – Have you ever been invited to or thought to go on an evangelical or Pentecostal panel or show? 43:13 – When Jesus draws the line in the dirt, are there any lessons he wants to teach us in what he’s doing? 49:32 – Why is it that when a bishop bestows a blessing on the congregation, he does the sign of the cross three times, but when a priest does it, it’s just once? 51:23 – I recently started RCIA. This Christmas, all my children are going to be here and I’m going to tell them I’m coming into the church. I know they’re going to bring up scandals within the Catholic Church. Could you give me some advice on how to respond to this, as well as some general advice on how to tell them I’m entering?
…
Questions Covered:
01:13 – If a relative were on their deathbed and you wanted to call a priest to visit them, but their family was opposed to it, is it ok to still do it? What would be the prudent thing to do? 14:34 – I called in a couple weeks ago and you gave me an analogy about God’s forgiveness. Imagine you break your neighbor’s window while playing baseball. Even if the neighbor forgives you, there will still be a legal punishment, and someone still has to pay for it. Could you help me out with some problems I have with it? 20:29 – How should I answer people who say that religion should be a private thing and shouldn’t be shown in public? 28:55 – My wife is a part of a megachurch and says we don’t celebrate Easter correctly and Christmas shouldn’t be in December. How can I answer these disputes? 34:38 – We see people asking for money on the side of the road all the time. I know as Christians we are supposed to be givers. How do you recommend going about this in those kinds of situations? 38:05 – I was listening to the previous question about the man asking what he can do for his dying relative. I wanted to mention the Divine Mercy chaplet and what it promises for people who pray it right before death. FREE 20 ANS PRAYER 39:36 – Did Mary know how special she was? Growing up, did she realize how different she was from everybody? 43:54 – My sister, who’s not Catholic, has expressed to her daughters that she wants to be cremated and scattered in the Gulf of Mexico. I know that we as Catholics are not permitted to do this. I feel it would be scandalous if I attended the scattering ceremony. Is it correct that I am not allowed to attend? 46:12 – In the gospel there’s a story where a man with a withered hand comes to Jesus and he heals it. If it is easier for Jesus to just tell people that they’re forgiven, why did he have to go to the cross? 50:10 – I left the Catholic Church about 45 years ago because I’m gay. I’ve recently thought about coming back to the church. A part of my heart would always be resentful because you can’t be in good standing with the church and be with someone of the same sex.
…
Questions Covered:
07:10 – Why isn’t our holy father doing more to unite the church? It seems like every time I turn around there’s more division rather unity. 13:45 – What do you, Father, think about Revelation 22:11 in relation to talking about how evil people will keep doing evil? 17:47 – I don’t know much about the King James version of the bible. Could you talk about it? Who created the translation? 21:23 – I’m Lutheran but I have a lot of “Latin mass Catholic” friends. I’m seeing a lot of current Catholics that have large followings call Pope Francis the “antichrist”, similar to what Martin Luther did. Why is this tolerated and why aren’t they subject to excommunication like him? 29:43 – In the liturgy of the Eucharist, why is it the “holy and living sacrifice” rather than just the one sacrifice in the cross? 34:21 – I have protestant friend who tells me there’s two baptisms. Could I get clarification on why we only have one baptism? She’s also confused as to how the Catholic church is the only one with the Eucharist, she thinks the holy spirit in protestant churches is the same thing. 41:58 – Why did God not have a birthday? 45:26 – I was recently in Europe and saw an exhibit on the Egyptian sphinx. I have a Catholic friend who says it was justified for Christians to deface these historical artifacts. Is that true? Also, is it wrong to burn books that are perhaps heretical or morally wrong? I don’t agree with it. 52:01 – Could you please share your thoughts on the FSSP? I know they’re diocesan, but they perform the Latin mass.
…
Questions Covered:
24:35 – Can we view the sacraments themselves as miracles? 34:05 – What would be the signs of an incorrupt saint? What’s the science behind that? 41:05 – When Jesus is talking about the prophets, he says he measures them by their fruits. Does this also apply to miracles? 45:31 – How does the blood type found at Lanciano compare to the one found on the Shroud of Turin? 51:10 – You mentioned earlier about not putting your faith in your senses and how the Lanciano miracle has been disproven. Could you tell me where you got this information from?
…
Questions Covered:
06:10 – Why does it matter if Mary was born with or without original sin? How do we know that Mary didn’t have any children after Jesus? 15:18 – I had someone ask me why we baptize infants. Could you tell me if the answer I gave them was ok? 24:00 – Is God limited by sets of conditions or events? 43:45 – How does someone transition from saying Catholicism is true from just an intellectual standpoint and start to feel it emotionally too? 47:53 – Why do you, Trent Horn, never answer questions about faith alone and the bible in your debates? 52:30 – How do you explain why it’s a sin to take the Lord’s name in vain, specifically when saying “Oh my God”.
…
Questions Covered:
00:30 – There’s been a lot of talk at my work about “mercury being in retrograde” and that it makes everything on earth topsy-turvy. Could this really effect things on earth? I thought this was completely unfounded but then I thought about how the moon controls the tides and how people seem to act crazier when there’s a full moon… Would love Jimmy’s opinion on this! 11:36 – If Adam and Eve didn’t commit original sin but some other descendent did, say Cain, would we have a split line of humanity? One line with a fallen nature and one without? 15:55 – To my understanding, animals’ souls lack the necessary ingredient of reason to be eternal, so their souls perish with their bodies when they die. In Numbers 22, the Lord opened the mouth of Balaam’s donkey, so he could speak to his owner. It appears that God raised Balaam’s donkey’s nature for a moment to include the use of reason to speak and convince Balaam of his sin. What would have happened to the donkey if he had died in that state? If he momentarily possessed a rational soul required for eternal life, and he used it to obey God by convincing Balaam of his sin, would the donkey have then had the possibility of eternal life in heaven? 28:59 – What exactly is happening in the book of Tobit when Sarah’s husbands keep dying? Is a demon really killing them? If so, how? Possessing Sarah and causing her to kill them, possessing the husbands and having them kill themselves? Some other way? 34:02 – If God is beyond time (time is not a concept for God), could the Passion of Jesus still be going on and then conceivably my since could make the pain that Jesus endures even more… and then the opposite, if I sin less, Jesus receives less pain? 43:00 – Say there was a global catastrophe that caused much destruction and prevented communication between the Americas and Europe. No one in the Americas knows if anyone still lives in Europe and has no way of finding out. In this scenario, would it be prudent for American cardinals to elect their own pontiff, or should they hope that papal succession is safe in Europe? 49:00 – Did Jesus know how to build an airplane? Is there a way to say that he didn’t without calling in to question his divine omniscience as the 2nd Person of the holy Trinity? 52:45 – What’s the real deal with Ed and Lorraine Warren. I can assume that the movie prelude statement about them being commissioned by the Church is a stretch or even a lie. Though, they do have a bunch of supposed possessed items, one being the Anna Bell doll. My curiosity is intrigued on this, I can’t imagine the Church would enlist lay people to do this type of work. Is it all just a lie?
…
Questions Covered:
05:39 – I love these episodes! I’ve got a question for you – if humanity ever encounters another intelligent species in outer space (or the inner earth or whatnot), would someone from said species be potentially eligible to be elected Pope (assuming they met the other qualifications), or is that office explicitly limited to humans? 10:55 – What are your thoughts on the Omicron Variant? 18:02 – My ten-year-old brother would like to know if it’s possible that Bigfoot could be an alien 24:42 – If you had conjoined male twins, could one get ordained and the other married? Does the extent of conjunction affect the answer? 31:54 – I know that it is fine for Catholics to believe in evolution, and I do. But recently, I have read some academics who argue that human morality is a product of evolution. That is, people who acted in anti-social ways were ostracized by society and more likely to die, and therefore people having our current moral orientation evolved through natural selection. Can this view be reconciled with Catholic understanding, or is it in opposition? 41:11 – What evidence is there for ball lightning? I saw it roughly 20 years ago and was fascinated. But at that time there were no pictures or good theories. 46:22 – IF parents and Godparents can present a newborn child for Baptism…could someone, say a son, ask a priest to forgive the sins of their mother, or father, who are essentially, due to the advanced nature of Alzheimer’s babies?
…
Questions Covered:
17:11 – Have you heard of a “zinc spark” that happens at the moment of conception? 23:45 – How can I make a philosophical defense for the personhood of fetuses? 33:17 – Is it okay to administer morphine to someone at the end of their life? 43:14 – What’s the Catholic position on terminations for medical reasons? 51:00 – How should I respond to someone who recognizes that abortion kills a human but still feels that the weight of responsibility that pregnancy places on a mother is reasonable justification for it? 53:15 – Isn’t it part of Catholic moral teaching that you’re culpable for what you know at the time?
…
Questions Covered:
18:57 – When did Christians actually start calling it “Christ-mass”? 29:33 – Isn’t Christmas originally a pagan holiday for the birth of the Sun? 42:55 – What’s the proper name for the nativity scene? 44:29 – Historically, what has the ranking of the Christmas feast been compared to others like Pentecost and Easter? 47:19 – When the shepherds visited Jesus, did they have all their sheep with them?
…
Questions Covered:
04:40 – When Peter mentions “other scriptures” in 2 Peter 3:16, does that imply that there was a set canon at that time? 10:50 – I’m gathering with my adult children over Christmas, and they’re all at various stages of leaving Catholicism. How can I make the most of those three days together? 19:05 – What does John 12:39-50 mean? It hurts to read because I love the Jewish people. 30:10 – When Jesus went down to hell to preach the gospel, at what point were the souls there saved? 35:35 – Psalm 106 mentions Aaron as one of God’s saints. Is he a saint in the Catholic Church? 39:45 – How does 1 John’s mention of a sin that is “unto death,” that we shouldn’t pray for, fit in with confession? 43:00 – How can I encourage my son and his wife, who are getting married outside the Church, to get their marriage blessed? 47:03 – I’m becoming Catholic but my wife is Jewish. Do we have to consummate our marriage inside the Church? I don’t think she’ll want to do that. 49:20 – Am I supposed to speak in tongues? 50:25 – Why should Catholics believe in the reliability of the first epistle of Peter when modern scholars believe Peter didn’t actually write it?
…
Questions Covered:
07:10 – How did John the Baptist escape Herod’s decree to kill all the children in Israel? 11:40 – If we have free will, then why do we pray? And are we judged twice? 17:00 – How should I understand the miracles attributed to Pope John Paul II when there was no scientific analysis of them beforehand, and in the case of the nun, the fact that the Parkinson’s came back? 20:15 – Is it appropriate to sing the Gloria during Advent? 21:25 – Are we supposed to believe in prophetic messages as Catholics? 29:50 – Was it only John who saw the events recorded in Revelation? If so, how do we know it’s divinely inspired? 35:20 – What does Jesus mean in John 15 when he says “No slave is greater than his master?” 42:10 – What did Jesus mean when he said only the Father is good? 49:10 – Is St. Joseph the spouse of Mary, or is the Holy Spirit? And is St. Joseph our spiritual father?
…
Questions Covered:
03:19 – I come from a Baptist background. Why don’t Catholics carry Bibles everywhere? 05:28 – I’m unvaccinated and my church is saying not to attend unless you’re vaccinated. Should I obey them? 09:20 – I run a business that goes against Google’s wishes but doesn’t technically violate any copyright laws. Is this moral? 16:30 – My friend’s baby just died, and he’s very upset about the Church’s teaching on limbo. How should I explain to him that limbo is not an official teaching of Catholicism? 24:32 – Who is the first Catholic? Is it John the Baptist, or Jesus, or Mary, or the people who found the tomb, or the disciples in the other room, or someone else? 41:58 – Is Gematria allowed in Catholicism? 52:11 – Should we honor my mother-in-law’s wishes to be cremated and scattered?
…
Questions Covered:
13:15 – My Protestant friend thinks that Purgatory takes away from the salvific action of Christ on the cross. 19:52 – I have friends who are outspoken pagans, but I befriend them with the intention of evangelizing without beating them over the head. 22:40 – I’m not a Catholic. Does “heathen” or “pagan” refer to me? 28:50 – How can I answer my Protestant family members who ask whether non-Catholics can go to heaven? 32:51 – How can I have a meaningful dialogue with anti-Catholics? I think a lot of the time people are just making talking points, not listening to each other in discussion. 41:00 – Why do you believe that the Protestant version of God is similar to the Catholic version? 49:55 – My ex-Mormon friend experienced abuse in his background and is against anything religious as a result. How can I bring him around to Catholicism?
…
Questions Covered:
07:11 – Were there any Church fathers who talked about the Assumption of Mary? 13:16 – Why is the Immaculate Conception proclaimed as a dogma? I know why the Church believes it, but why is it at the level of dogma? 20:47 – By what decree or edict am I bound to agree with and follow the pronouncements of the Pope? 29:35 – What did St. Thomas say about there being two purgatories? 33:18 – Why do we believe that Jesus is the Messiah? 43:40 – When you pass away, do you go to purgatory first, or heaven? 50:10 – How does suffering that doesn’t have a direct effect on someone else, like taking a cold shower, become redemptive?
…
Questions Covered:
20:20 – What did the sacraments look like in the early Church, and how were they administered? 32:20 – Was the word of God as we know it today shared in the early Church? 36:22 – What was the early Church’s opinion on baptizing infants? 42:27 – Which one of the Church fathers addressed the denial of Jesus’s divinity? 47:44 – What was the nature of the disagreement between Peter and Paul in Acts? Was it different than the kinds of disagreements that our bishops have today?
…
Questions Covered:
05:29 – What are the origins of the sacrament of baptism? 16:45 – What do the words “As it was in the beginning” in the Glory Be refer to? 20:12 – Is there a way that the Church assesses their priests and holds them accountable to their teaching? 30:50 – Why does the Catholic Church say the Orthodox have valid holy orders but the Anglicans do not? 35:40 – Is the mark of the beast coming soon with new technology? How will we prepare for it? 42:22 – What value is there in forgiveness if it doesn’t remove punishment? 49:10 – Why is missing Mass on Sunday a mortal sin as compared to others like murder and adultery?
…
Questions Covered:
04:46 – What can I say in confession if I can’t remember all my sins? 06:12 – Why do we sometimes not receive communion wine? 10:46 – Jesus says to keep his commandments and his statutes. What are his statutes? 12:42 – Where can I find an explanation of the true nature of the Mass in Scripture? 15:45 – What is the Catholic view of the atonement? 22:38 – Is it correct that the early Church used the complete Old Testament and the complete New Testament, even though the New wasn’t compiled and canonized yet? 29:10 – If heaven is outside of time, doesn’t that mean everyone who has lived and will ever live is already there? 37:35 – How are Orthodox priests and liturgy considered by the Roman Church today? Is it considered a legitimate Eucharist and communion? What are the issues that need to be resolved for full reconciliation? 46:16 – Is there any dogmatic or doctrinal reason why we can’t receive the precious blood in our own personal vessels during the pandemic? 51:26 – My Eastern Orthodox friend believes that the western theological tradition was corrupted. How could the eastern and western traditions contradict each other?
Resources Mentioned:
Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, by Ludwig Ott
…
Questions Covered:
12:00 – How can I explain to my brother that he needs to be married in the Catholic Church for it to be a valid marriage? 18:45 – Why would you have to have apostolic succession to validly consecrate the Eucharist? 31:10 – I heard that Catholicism is more “mystical” than other branches of Christianity because Catholics have things like intercession of the saints and the apocryphal books. Why does that matter? 46:06 – How should I talk to my Protestant parents about my interest in Catholicism?
…
Questions Covered:
04:50 – Is it a more accurate translation to call Mary “full of grace” or “favored one”? 13:35 – How can we clarify the poor side effects that unintentionally came out of Vatican II to those who dislike the council? 19:32 – How can we defend the Real Presence of the Eucharist, especially when there’s so much proof from the early church that people reject? 24:00 – How can God have free will if he’s not capable of sinning? 33:57 – What would you say to someone who says the Church Fathers were too focused on philosophy instead of Scripture? 41:35 – How can I respond to the charge that the Catholic Church killed thousands of Protestant martyrs in England? 47:20 – What’s the best way to start talking to my Hindu friend about Catholicism? 52:16 – When we come to our resurrection, how will humanity all fit on earth? Will there be enough space?
…
Questions Covered:
01:10 – Joshua 10:12-13 doesn’t make any sense, because we know that the sun doesn’t move. 16:22 – Why did Jesus change the names of the apostles? 22:33 – Why don’t Catholics learn the Bible like other denominations do? 29:00 – Why does Jesus call himself the good shepherd? Didn’t a lot of shepherds eventually slaughter their sheep? 38:15 – Since Jesus will come to judge the living and the dead, does that mean some people won’t die before going to heaven? 40:30 – Why wasn’t it a sin for Jesus to stay in the temple for three days? 43:20 – Are angels boys or girls? If neither, why is Michael called a boy? 45:54 – The Bible and Jesus seem to talk about so many different ways we can fall into sin. How does that square with the Catholic teaching that we can only go to heaven if we’re in a state of grace? 49:43 – Was Adam the first man or were there other humans before him?
…
Questions Covered:
04:57 – How can only the Father know, in Mark 13:32, “the day or the hour”? 11:40 – When John the Baptist says to “repent and believe in the gospel,” what is he referring to? I thought the gospel was Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. 17:30 – What point is Jesus making in Luke 11:24-26 when he says that after an unclean spirit leaves a person it comes back with seven more? 21:33 – How do you reply to the objection against Mary’s sinlessness that says other people in the Bible are addressed in the same way as the angel addressed her? 28:37 – Why did women stop wearing veils in Church when the Bible clearly says they should? 33:45 – How do I study Revelation from a Pentecostal background? 36:36 – Where is the idea of Holy Orders found in the Bible? And does the Bible ever address why we can’t receive the sacraments validly apart from Holy Orders? 44:22 – Why did God stop Abraham from sacrificing Isaac but didn’t stop Jephthah from sacrificing his daughter? 48:28 – Where is it said that suffering is an “amoral evil,” as I once heard a priest say?
…
Questions Covered:
05:10 – It seems like there’s an apparent contradiction between the value of women in the book of Sirach and in the rest of the Bible. It talks about daughters being a liability, divorcing your wife, and the wickedness of man being better than the righteousness of women. 14:25 – Since there were bishops from the East who became popes before the East-West schism, isn’t that an argument in favor of the papacy? 18:10 – How should I talk to my friend about the hierarchical structures of the Orthodox and Catholic Churches? He seems to be leaning more Orthodox on this point. 29:00 – In my theology class we were talking about whether a traditional family (only father works + stay-at-home mom) or a non-traditional family lifestyle (mother works, or both parents work) is more beneficial. Is there a definite answer? 33:05 – What is the treasury of merit and how does it play into the theology of indulgences? 40:25 – How do you defend the Church against someone who believes it has pagan beginnings and that the Vatican is shaped like a dragon? 49:00 – I believe that since the second person of the trinity became a man, not a martian, that means there are no aliens. What is Jimmy’s best response to this? 41:40 – Is acupuncture approved by the Church?
…
Questions Covered:
06:05 – Why do Catholics single out abortion as a sin that we’re expected to stop others from doing? There are many many other sins in this world, so why should I be concerned with this one in particular? 13:00 – How will you know when Jesus has come again? 19:45 – If evil thoughts come into someone’s mind, could they be put there by Satan apart from my will? If that’s the case, do I have to confess it? What’s the Church teaching? 24:40 – Can the Catholic stance on the death penalty be backed up with sola scriptura? 35:30 – As a Protestant, where should I begin my research if I’m interested in Catholicism? 43:05 – Are Satan and the demons in hell suffering, or just the people who go there? And are we able to contact the souls in hell, whether from this life or the next? 48:20 – Have you read By Man Shall His Blood Be Shed? What do you think of what it teaches about the death penalty compared to what Pope Francis is teaching now?
…
Questions Covered:
5:19 – I don’t think God’s going to send anyone to hell, because Jesus died for the whole world and God is love. 19:17 – If someone dies and we don’t know whether they believed in God before they died, should we still pray for them? Are they in purgatory? Will the masses said for them be effective? 29:57 – If salvation is a covenant, then isn’t it wrong to speak of it as being lost, rather than as being broken? 33:59 – If someone is baptized and confirmed Catholic, but then leaves the Church later, how does that affect their salvation? 43:26 – Purgatory sounds like a second chance at salvation. 47:33 – I looked up the definition of mortal sin and I’m wondering how it’s different from every other sin. Doesn’t all sin separate us from God?
…
Questions Covered:
12:13 – How can I tell my Protestant father about the Catholic view of salvation? 17:47 – If God’s ultimate plan is for all to be saved, why would he create anyone knowing that they’d be damned? 30:37 – Why is the crucifixion necessary for our salvation? 36:43 – Is salvation eternal or temporary? 42:01 – Why wouldn’t God give the grace of salvation to everyone?
…
Questions Covered:
05:29 – Is my dad culpable for sin for selling his company’s products to a non-Catholic missionary? 13:01 – How is Jesus God? 18:29 – In Sunday’s gospel, what did Jesus mean when he said “heaven and earth will pass away?” And why did he say the Son of Man didn’t know the hour, if the Son of Man is God? 23:47 – If God is all-loving and all-knowing, why wasn’t he teaching Adam about repentance? 37:18 – Is it against the rules for Catholics to be freemasons? 46:40 – If a baby dies but it hasn’t had the chance to sin, would it go to heaven right away or to purgatory? 50:36 – How do we go from the apostles having the authority to bind and loose to the priesthood having the same authority? Why shouldn’t all believers have that authority once they receive the Holy Spirit?
…
Questions Covered:
08:17 – How do we know that Jesus loves us? 15:11 – Why don’t we defend more of our teachings from scripture instead of from tradition? 24:09 – How can the Psalmist say that God is in Sheol if that’s separation from God? 32:38 – Besides purgatory, can our prayers help someone after they’ve died? Can they contribute to that person’s salvation? 40:27 – Why isn’t there a readily available collection of Catholic teachings that are based on tradition? 46:54 – Would it theologically or pastorally make sense to ask the bishops to make a statement forbidding pro-abortion politicians from receiving communion?
…
Questions Covered:
03:48 – Are Cleopas and Clopas the same person? 07:49 – My son and his wife want to baptize their baby in the Episcopal Church because “there’s no difference.” How can I approach this with them? 15:25 – When I pray the Liturgy of the Hours, do I have to use the doxology written there, or can I use the usual one? 17:45 – What’s the Catholic view of what hell is? 21:14 – Does Fr. Sebastian ever give sermons on hell? I don’t think I’ve heard one in 30 years. 30:09 – How can grace be justly withheld, as St. Thomas says in the Summa Theologiae? 34:37 – My mother voluntarily skipped mass for the first time in a while. I know she’s suffering from deep depression, so is that a good reason to skip? Could it be physically debilitating? 41:17 – Is the congregation supposed to raise our hands during the Our Father in mass? 44:08 – What exactly does the sacrament of confession mean, and how does it compare to the Orthodox version? 48:27 – Fr. Sebastian’s book Secrets From Heaven had such a great impact on me. I did have a question about his interpretation of the woman who touched Jesus’s hem as someone showing a lack of faith. Couldn’t she rather be someone in a position of humility? 51:49 – How do we as Catholics show our love to same-sex attracted people while also professing the truth of Catholic teaching to them?
…
Questions Covered:
09:50 – How can I communicate with a non-Catholic who believes in nothing but what’s in the Bible? 18:00 – For a while I thought I was called to evangelize to a leader of a non-Catholic Church, but he hasn’t replied to any of my contacts at all. Should I just give up, or try something else? 22:32 – How can I explain to my brother that Jesus is our brother without taking away from his glory as Son of God? 29:06 – Jesus said to make disciples, but there’s not one set way to do that. What’s the next step after telling people about Jesus? 35:40 – I wear t-shirts with Catholic messages on them and wear a rosary from my belt, and I think that’s an effective way to evangelize without words. 41:45 – I find myself getting defensive a lot. What’s an effective strategy for someone like me with a short temper or who might be too attached to logic when a more pastoral approach would be better? 46:06 – What do you do when a best friend says that you don’t have to know God to get to heaven, you just have to be a good person? 49:50 – How do I evangelize family members? 52:25 – How are we supposed to evangelize, which is a public activity, in accord with Jesus’s condemnation of the hypocrites who make a big show of themselves?
…
Questions Covered:
12:10 – I’ve been to various recovery programs for addictions to gambling, overeating, and alcohol. None of them are working. 29:50 – I’m a recovering sugar addict. Have you encountered this before? For the most part it’s not looked at seriously. 35:40 – My son’s in a detox unit right now and I’m not sure how he won’t go right back into his addiction when he’s out. 44:30 – Does Catholic in Recovery have any place for someone who needs to break his alcohol addiction but not quit it for life? I don’t think quitting for life is a realistic possibility since it’s a disease. 49:50 – Could you give me more information on Catholic in Recovery retreats?
…
Questions Covered:
16:50 – Is there a patron saint for loving relationships? 31:45 – There are some members of my family who don’t get along and it’s driving a wedge in my family. How can we address this? 44:45 – My daughter has cut off communication from me and I’m wondering what’s healthy for me to do in this situation.
…
Questions Covered:
04:20 – Is baptism efficacious if the person receiving it isn’t fully conscious of it, such as someone with dementia? 11:25 – At the final judgement, will non-believers be allowed into heaven if they confess that Jesus is Lord? 20:50 – Is it selfish to think that people who are suffering from terminal illnesses shouldn’t go through with euthanasia? 30:15 – I’m thinking about converting to Catholicism but I don’t think my wife wants me to. If I don’t do it for that reason, will I be damned? Also, does it cost money to get an annulment? 41:20 – Are St. Nicholas and Santa Claus the same person? 49:20 – What’s the Catholic teaching on race?
…
Questions Covered:
07:25 – What’s the difference between pantheism and panentheism? And how does the latter differ from the belief that God is in everything? 16:25 – How do I defend the doctrine of the trinity when people challenge it with 1 Corinthians 15:24? 29:50 – I’ve heard speculation that God showed Lucifer his plan for salvation, and that’s what induced him to revolt. Do you know anything about that? 42:20 – If the devil seeks to divide, but Jesus also said he came not to bring peace but to divide, what degrees of division are acceptable to God? 50:35 – Are we discouraged from burning sage or other types of incense?
…
Questions Covered:
07:15 – I’ve struggled with scruples for most of my life, and I want to mention that it’s a psychiatric condition that can be treated. 17:05 – I have heard that the candles on the altar are 51% bee wax. Do they have to be that way or can they be different? 24:00 – How do I explain the role of the papacy to an Armenian Orthodox and a Seventh-Day Adventist? 33:15 – What books do you recommend for one family member who’s atheist and another who’s “spiritual but not religious?” 45:45 – Why is purgatory a thing if God can do anything in an instant?
…
Questions Covered:
06:30 – Is sexual attraction created by God? If it is, what about same-sex attraction? Is it good? 15:55 – How would you help a scrupulous person distinguish what is and isn’t sin? 31:10 – At what point does the Eucharist become the Real Presence of Christ? 41:30 – How could individual Catholics, in the moment, have known whether there was an antipope? 49:05 – Would Catholics agree that while salvation includes things like obedience, the sole basis by which we become friends with God is through faith?
…
Questions Covered:
06:17 – Are the letters of St. Ignatius of Antioch forgeries? 12:16 – Could Jesus have had a crush? 23:17 – What book should I give to a Muslim or a Buddhist who doesn’t know much of anything about Christianity? 33:33 – Could a loved one bring communion to a family member who’s close to death? 39:31 – What’s a good response to a pro-choice person who says we shouldn’t be forced to keep a person alive? 49:20 – What determines the words of consecration? I’m asking since there’s a discrepancy between the words of the Extraordinary and Ordinary forms, as well as with one of the Eastern rites.
…
Questions Covered
04:51 – Hebrews 9:24 mentions “Christ” and “God” separately. Why does it say that if Christ is God? 14:48 – Why do Eastern Rite Catholics still venerate Orthodox saints? 19:19 – Can you explain why Mark brings up the naked man in 14:51-52? It seems kind of random. 31:28 – Some Jewish scholars claim that the Sanhedrin trial in Matthew isn’t historical. How would you defend its historicity? 45:09 – My sister believes in purgatory but thinks we’re living in it right now.
…
Questions Covered:
15:04 – In a post-pandemic world, what should this balance look like in a parish? 21:43 – I’m wondering about Deacon Harold’s thoughts on the build back better philosophy and want to share mine also. We should be careful because it can be used for good or bad. 29:17 – I’m a Catholic school teacher and a new mother and I’m having trouble finding the balance. What’s your advice? 36:01 – My wife’s family didn’t attend a Catholic wedding ceremony because they’re fallen-away Catholics. Is that the right decision to make on their part, especially if it can possibly damage the relationship? 47:31 – I’m in diaconate formation. How can I balance my studies with family and work?
…
Questions Covered:
05:44 – How would you respond to someone who is consistent on when life begins? For instance, they might say something is only alive if it has consciousness, and if you say “What about someone in a coma?” they say “Yeah, that’s not a human.” 12:12 – Would our arguments be better if there were fewer straight white males making them and more minorities and women? 19:35 – What’s the reasoning process that brought you to your definition of person? 28:20 – Has the teaching of the Church about embryonic stem cell research changed since the late ‘90s when it was not allowed in any circumstances? 37:00 – How do you distinguish between directly killing someone and not electing to save someone? 46:30 – How would I respond to women who say men have no place in the abortion debate? 52:19 – How would you respond to someone who says the government shouldn’t be involved?
…
Questions Covered:
01:13 – Jesus says to the thief, “today you will be with me in paradise.” So he actually went that same day up to heaven? Can you explain? 05:15 – I love the Latin Mass and am very involved at my parish. Many of my friends would describe themselves as “traditional” and often the first question they ask visitors is “what Latin Mass do you attend.” They seem to be missing some key elements. How can I help them? 15:14 – Is Medjugorje an approved apparition? Should a faithful Catholic visit there? 18:52 – How is bilocation not a logical contradiction? 29:10 – How do we Catholics delineate what political stuff we can be involved in and what we shouldn’t be involved in? Separation of church and state? 32:07 – Did Jesus really mean it when he said to turn the other cheek? 41:01 – In prayer, when are we supposed to strike our breasts? 46:47 – Are aerial toll-houses true? I’ve heard about toll-houses from Orthodox Christians and many of them believe it.
…
Questions Covered:
05:26 – I heard that we need to pray for the souls in purgatory because they can’t pray for themselves. If that’s the case, how can they pray for us? 05:26 – I’m wondering if this is a good argument against a neutral, mechanistic universe: life seems to strive towards self-existence, so that’s a decidedly positive direction as opposed to a neutral naturalism. 11:18 – As a Catholic, am I allowed to donate to a deceased person’s memorial fund if it goes towards the formation of Assembly of God ministers? 13:57 – How do I have an answer for the Catholics who don’t believe in the real presence? 18:37 – Some people use the passage in Numbers 5, where the priest gives a woman accused of adultery a concoction that will cause a miscarriage, to say that the Bible supports abortion. What do you make of that? 28:57 – Why is the pope tolerating the patriotic Church in China? 31:53 – What can I say to my wife who left the Church because of bad catechesis and priests who don’t “preach from the heart?” 44:15 – I work for an insurance company that wants to be the broker for a cannabis supplier. Is that moral within church teaching? 49:32 – Why isn’t the blood of Christ reserved in the tabernacle after Mass?
…
Questions Covered:
4:11 – Do the saints who go to heaven bypass purgatory because they’ve become perfectly sanctified or is there another reason like a special grace? 08:19 – Is Jimmy a fan of the Ozark Mountain Daredevils? 14:30 – Is it sinful to watch media that takes the Lord’s name in vain? 18:40 – What would the feeling be if we were in heaven but our loved ones didn’t make it? Would we be sad? 22:50 – What’s the best way to introduce my significant other to Catholicism? 28:25 – How accurate is C.S. Lewis’s space trilogy scientifically? 33:15 – It seems like we don’t have free will because our choices are either caused or uncaused. If they’re uncaused, then they’d be random; but if they’re caused, there’d be a chain of causality going back outside ourselves so they wouldn’t be our choices. What’s the Catholic resolution to this? 45:08 – Where is hell? 48:06 – Should I have a litmus test for a parish before I join? 50:48 – If the priest prays the apostolic prayer over you before you die, do you skip purgatory?
…
Questions Covered:
03:57 – My girlfriend is non-Catholic and doesn’t understand why she and her family can’t have confession and the Eucharist, and also why I need them if it’s possible for non-Catholics to go to heaven without them. 10:05 – I heard a rabbi claim that the Jesus that Christians believe in is a false Jesus. Why don’t the Jewish people believe in Jesus? 15:38 – How does the necessity of baptism square with the idea that those who haven’t heard of Catholicism can be saved? 23:28 – How could an all-loving God allow such horrible suffering like in the Holocaust? 29:11 – If I’m praying for something, but then remember more intentions as I’m praying it, does that make the prayer progressively less powerful for each, like it’s being divided? 31:49 – I was in a major car accident and am in a lot of pain and sometimes can’t make it to mass. My Catholic doctor tells me to offer it up and that I’m saving souls in purgatory. Also my daughter had my granddaughter baptized Lutheran and won’t have anything to do with the Catholic Church. I just really need some guidance. 35:59 – I understand we get a plenary indulgence if we go to mass on All Souls’ Day. What do we have to say or do for it? Also, if we pray at a cemetery, do we get a second indulgence? 41:02 – Have you heard of the book Psychic Wholeness and Healing by Conrad Baars and Anna Terruwe? It’s a Thomistic approach to psychology and I’m wondering if it’s trustworthy. 44:27 – Can you pray for Jesus? 46:00 – How should we make jokes? And how should we react to sinful joking?
…
Questions Covered:
06:25 – I’ve noticed that during consecration some of the faithful will bow when the priest kneels. Is that okay, and if so, should it be encouraged? 12:42 – Was it ever a custom immediately following Vatican II for the Ordinary Form to be celebrated facing east with communion rails? 16:17 – If anyone is in purgatory, we know they’re going to heaven and God’s timing is perfect. So why are we praying for them? 22:58 – How do you actually pray for the dead? What are you supposed to say? 28:46 – I was talking to a Protestant about how the Church is important because we need an interpretive body of God’s word, and she responded that the Holy Spirit interprets for her. How do I answer this? 32:48 – If I’m living in a state of grace, am I in spiritual communion with Jesus? And if that’s the case, what would a prayer for spiritual communion actually do? And what does living in spiritual communion mean on a day-to-day basis? 38:00 – Is it appropriate to not kneel during mass? 43:54 – What happens to a person when they’re in a state of obstinate mortal sin and they receive communion? And is a Catholic politician in a country that legalizes abortion an advocate for mass murder? 48:18 – I heard that if you’re watching a live mass, if you have bread and wine with you, they won’t be consecrated so you can’t have communion if you’re unable to go to Mass. Is that true? Doesn’t it put a limit on God’s power? 51:52 – What is the determining factor in whether a baptized person goes to hell or purgatory after they die?
…
Questions Covered:
05:11 – How is Mary both our Mother and the Church? 10:38 – Where did Moses and Elijah come from during the Transfiguration if the gates of heaven weren’t opened? 13:03 – If a person has been hexed, can they be freed or helped by drinking holy water? I know someone in this situation who’s not even willing to see a priest. 16:29 – Is there something wrong with women wearing veils? Our priest is against it. 21:18 – Sometimes repeated prayers feel so dry. Is it just as good to talk to Jesus one-on-one like a friend? Is this really a prayer? 24:55 – What is a religious exemption from taking the vaccine? How is it applicable to our faith? 34:20 – I’m starting to consider becoming Catholic. How urgently should I be seeking to understand the Catholic Church? Should I be a little more careful about it? 41:20 – What’s the best elevator pitch Catholic explanation of salvation? 44:17 – Can you be consecrated to both Mary and St. Joseph? Does that work? 46:25 – Can we watch certain films that display sinful events and acts? 49:13 – I heard about a meeting between John Paul II and a group of Jesuits 20 years ago. Apparently they asked him if they could start a renewal and he said no because it would cause too much chaos. Do you know anything about this?
…
Questions Covered:
29:30 – Do you think, in this “information age,” we’re actually moving into a dark age? 34:01 – Is part of the reason we’ve arrived at transgenderism due to people mixing up accidents with substance? 36:59 – Are there any arguments for why the state should not pay for transgender surgeries? 45:17 – Is there any danger of using the Septuagint exclusively for Old Testament studies? 48:40 – What are your thoughts on the roots of modern relativism? I think it’s based on freedom of religion as articulated in our Constitution. 51:24 – Is the Pope not with reality? He met Biden with open arms and he supports all this stuff like transgenderism and abortion.
…
Questions Covered:
02:35 – How do I explain to someone that when we pray and bow to God it’s worship, but when we do it to Mary it’s not? And how do I address someone who says that when we pray to saints it’s actually praying to demons? 15:14 – How do we respond to an atheist who says it doesn’t matter how you live because Catholics believe you just have to go to confession and get your sins forgiven? 22:40 – What’s the Catholic definition of apocryphal books? And why do we sometimes refer to the author of a book in the Bible as “the inspired author” when we usually know who they are? 28:40 – If we could convert aliens, could they become priests? 34:10 – Do you know anything about remote neural monitoring and whether that’s how the antichrist plans to take over the world? 42:14 – Why don’t Protestants accept that Peter is the rock that Jesus built his Church on? 45:00 – What’s the actual job of the guardian angels? And what’s the difference between a guardian angel and an archangel? 48:40 – How authoritative is the Didache in the Catholic Church? If it has authority, why don’t we refer to it more often? 50:28 – How can I get a rosary?
…
Questions Covered:
03:35 – Can a Catholic date a non-Catholic who hasn’t had their annulment yet? 10:10 – Is it possible that the good thief, since he was crucified with Jesus, could have received the same effects from that as baptism? 14:30 – When I was young I heard that in the future we’d have backpacks that would allow us to transport through the air. Do you know if anything like that was ever developed? 17:35 – Pope Francis has said that all religions are willed by God. Is that actually a Catholic teaching if the Church has said there’s no salvation outside the Church? 21:20 – How can I talk about Catholicism with someone who doesn’t care about denominations and says it’s just about Jesus? 28:38 – At our final judgement, is it possible that God would let us simply choose heaven or hell? 38:00 – My protestant friend is asking me about the “Chrislam Temple,” which will be an interfaith complex in Abu Dhabi uniting a church, a synagogue and a mosque. She says it’s a sign that we’re heading towards a one world religion and the end times. What do you think? 44:50 – What do you know about St. Bede’s Ecclesiastical History of the English People? What can we get from it and is it worth reading? 48:05 – I’ve heard that if you miss the Gospel reading at Sunday mass, you can’t receive the Eucharist and it doesn’t fulfill your Sunday obligation. Is that true? 51:40 – One time a priest didn’t give me a penance after confession. Was it a valid confession?
…
Questions Covered:
05:00 – I’m not Catholic because I don’t think the Church stands up enough on social issues. 17:27 – Someone told me he “wants nothing to do with the white Jesus.” 22:13 – I believe many Catholic dogmas were not present in the early Church. 34:04 – I’m thinking about leaving the Church because of lukewarm preaching. When I joined it seemed like they were more courageous, but now it seems like it’s gotten bad. 42:57 – What makes Catholicism more true or accurate than other Christian sects?
…
Questions Covered:
11:28 – I was raised Baptist, and I have an issue with the difference between the books in Catholic and Protestant bibles. 20:31 – I’m not Catholic because of the idol worship. 29:53 – I’m a Jehovah’s Witness. Why should I be Catholic? 42:21 – I believe the Catholic Church is a front for false worship. 49:35 – I have a huge issue with how the Church handled all the sexual abuse.
…
Questions Covered:
01:19 – Is St. Thomas More’s “Dialogue of Comfort” consistent with the Catholic Church’s teaching on suffering today? 05:12 – Is everyone in heaven a saint? 07:14 – Is it safe to call St. Peter the Bishop of Pentecost? 12:20 – When the priest mentions “Those who sleep in Christ” during Mass, is that a different state from heaven, hell, and purgatory? 17:10 – I often read that some saints went to confession weekly. I thought you only went to confession when you committed a mortal sin. Does that mean these saints were committing mortal sins all the time, or is it ok to go to confession just for venial sins? 19:59 – Can thoughts be mortally sinful? 22:54 – How should I confront or correct priests who change things in the liturgy or teach things that aren’t correct? 29:01 – What can I do if I want to visit a seminary but they don’t want to allow exemptions for the COVID vaccine? 36:39 – How could anybody get the idea that Mother Teresa was a bad person? 44:23 – My non-Catholic family member was recently hospitalized. If he doesn’t make it, is there hope for him to reach heaven? 52:03 – What’s more important: theology or God?
…
Questions Covered:
02:35 – Is it possible to sin in a dream? 05:47 – We know Jesus didn’t sin, but the Gospels say he matured. What does that mean? 11:39 – I read from Richard Rohr that Hell isn’t a real place, and that it isn’t so much a place as a state of being. What exactly is the difference between those? 18:59 – Why does the woman in Revelation wail aloud in labor pains if she was Mary and therefore born without sin? 22:23 – I’ve been told by Eastern Orthodox that they don’t believe in purgatory because of the treasury of merit. What is your take on that? 34:41 – How will we recognize when Jesus comes back? 37:17 – Are traditional indigenous dances allowed during Mass? 45:04 – Why is the Holy Spirit the third person in particular? 48:19 – Is it wrong to protest Nebraska Medical Center for not allowing EWTN on their televisions? 51:03 – Was Judas a sinner?
…
Questions Covered:
01:33 – Genetics seems to refute Catholic dogma because it shows that Adam never existed. 09:43 – If James says Abraham was justified when he offered Isaac as a sacrifice, but then Paul says he was justified when he believed God, isn’t that a contradiction? How could you still believe in the inerrancy of scripture? 14:37 – Most scholars seem to accept that Mark is the oldest of the Gospels, and also accept that the end isn’t original. They also say that the epistles of Paul are older, but Paul never met Jesus in the flesh. If that’s the case, is the historical reliability of the New Testament in doubt? 21:57 – How do I best spread the faith while maintaining my duties as a public school counselor? 33:28 – How do I begin in the field of apologetics? 41:07 – What do “works” mean in the Catholic Church, and are they what save you? 50:50 – How would you respond to this argument: if it’s morally permissible to remove a clone from your body, then it’s morally permissible to remove a fetus. Therefore abortion is morally permissible.
…
Questions Covered:
05:36 – Sam Harris argues that free will is debunked by our inability to find an origin for our own thoughts. What is Trent’s response? 19:25 – If Jesus, who is God himself, admits that it would be better if Judas had never been born, isn’t he admitting that he made a mistake? How could he be all-good? 23:45 – What’s the best argument you’ve heard against theism? 31:51 – If God is all-powerful, how come so many awful things happen? 38:12 – My uncle is arguing that if humans were special and created by God, they’d all look the same at the beginning of the process and be created at the same time. But since that’s not the case, he says there’s no God. 48:30 – I believe that the universe has a creator, but I think he’s so distant from us that he doesn’t really care for us.
…
Catholic Answers Quiz Show! Elisha vs. Angel
Contestant One 1) Which of the following encyclicals was not written by Pope JPII?
a) Pacem In Terris (Peace on Earth) b) Veritatis Splendor c) Evangelium Vitae
2) Pope John Paul was the first non-Italian pope in:
a) 1237 years b) 871 years c) 455 years
3) Pope John Paul II attended
a) The First Vatican Council. b) The Second Vatican Council. c) Neither because he lived in communist Poland.
Contestant Two 1) Pope John Paul gave his teaching, now called the Theology of the Body:
a) In an encyclical b) At his weekly audiences. c) In a book called Fides Et Ratio.
2) Pope John Paul got lots of criticism because he once kissed:
a)A copy of the Koran. b) Fidel Castro. c) A statue of the Buddha.
3) Pope John Paul II was shot:
a) On the feast of Our Lady of Fatima. b) On the feast of the Divine Mercy. c) On the feast of Sts Peter and Paul.
ROUND TWO Contestant One 1) The souls in Heaven:
a) Are given faith in proportion to how they lived. b) Do not have faith. c) Are given a superabundance of faith.
2) The Apostle Paul was a:
a) Sadducee b) Temple Priest c) Pharisee
3) The title “Theotokos” or God-bearer was used:
a) By only one of the early church fathers. b) By none of the Church fathers. It is a later development. c) By many of the early Church Fathers.
Contestant Two 1) The Communion of Saints refers to:
A) The canonized saints who can be honored at Mass. B) All of the saints in heaven whether they have been canonized or not. C) All of those who have been made children of God by Christ whether in heaven, on earth, or in purgatory.
2) Which of the following is true about St. Paul:
a) He was a powerful healer, so much so that people could heal the sick just using objects that had touched Paul. b) He was a preacher, but unlike the other apostles, he had no healing ministry. c) He taught that only the sacraments could heal.
3) The bishops of the Orthodox Churches are:
a.) Not successors of the Apostles as Catholic bishops are b.) Successors of the Apostles c.) Successors only of St. Paul but not of St. Peter
FINAL JUDGMENT
True or False: The Holy Spirit is not the Father, the Father is not the Son, and the Son is not the Holy Spirit. True or False: The Investiture Controversy involved Greek Patriarchs refusing to allow the Pope to appoint bishops. True or False: During the Roman persecutions, those who caved to Roman pressure were never allowed back into communion. True or False: Jesus chose only Jewish men for his Apostles. True or False: Jesus had the Beatific vision even when he was in Mary’s womb. True or False: Detraction is the sin of lying to hurt the reputation of another. True or False: One is not morally required to always choose the highest good.
…
Questions Covered:
19:15 – A few weeks after my miscarriage I saw JPII in a dream, and he said to me “You have a child.” I was pregnant again in the next week. That’s why he’s the patron of my daughter. 24:20 – Do you think JPII should be declared a Doctor of the Church? 31:25 – JPII’s intercession helped deliver my daughter safely, and also made for a special connection between her and Our Lady. 36:27 – I thought JPII was a great pope, but the religious summit at Assisi was problematic because it led to religious indifferentism. 51:50 – I really appreciated JPII’s theology on marriage and divorce.
…
Questions Covered:
04:30 – What does metanoia mean? 11:00 – Are there any arguments from the early Church Fathers in favor of iconography? 13:00 – I have a question about preterism. Who is the man of lawlessness? Could it be Nero? 17:35 – How would you approach the topic of suicide with someone who hasn’t brought it up but might be showing hints? 23:55 – What are your thoughts on Jesus being able to custom-tailor Mary to be the perfect mother of him and the Church? 31:45 – How is the first chapter of Genesis compatible with science? What’s the general opinion of the Church on how it should be interpreted? 37:40 – How can I explain to a Protestant our understanding of cooperation with God’s grace? 44:20 – What’s the Catholic understanding of faith vs works and how they play into salvation? 46:10 – I spoke with some Protestants who talked about an idea of “Mother God.” They believed in the persons of the Trinity, but also believed that, taken all together, there was one “Mother God.” Has this idea come up before? Did the Church have to address it? 48:25 – Is it okay to play Dungeons & Dragons? 50:30 – Is there any circumstance in which a Catholic married couple, under the guidance of a priest, could use condoms? 52:45 – How should we submit to authority when there’s so many laws we don’t know about?
…
Questions Covered:
04:25 – My spouse has a severe porn addiction. We’ve tried so many ways to break it but it seems like it’ll never stop. How can I raise my children so they won’t be harmed also? 14:41 – What does it mean when people say “Offer it up to God”? 16:30 – Do you believe that we’re coming close to the end times based on what we know from Revelation and what’s happening in the world today? 21:13 – When does Genesis go from being literal history to poetic, symbolic literature? 35:03 – How can I find a good priest in my area? Do you have any recommendations? 43:20 – Why do we believe that the deposit of faith ended with the Apostles? I’m in a discussion with Mormons who are strongly pressing me on this. 48:15 – Since one of the founders of the neocatechumenal way, Carmen Hernandez, is being considered for beatification, would that remove some of the negative perceptions surrounding it? 52:40 – When we say the Our Father, why do we leave off “For thine is the kingdom, the power, and the glory, now and forever”?
…
Questions Covered:
01:13 – Is it alright to not thoroughly understand every single teaching of the Church and simply believe it on authority? 9:50 – What’s the morality of smoking marijuana, specifically when you don’t intend to get high? 17:04 – The Catechism of the Council of Trent seemed to say that Judas is in hell, but in the new Catechism it doesn’t declare that. If the Church is the pillar and bulwark of truth, how does that work? 22:33 – Why doesn’t the Catholic Church recognize Mormons as Christians? How do we get off saying that when other denominations say that about us? 31:33 – When Our Lady of Fatima spoke to the children, she called herself the Lady of the Rosary instead of the Mother of God, and seemed to demand that people pray to her instead of to Jesus. That seems kind of suspicious to me. 42:14 – If God already knows over all time who’s going to be saved in his plan, what’s the purpose of us trying to get to heaven? 49:43 – When Moses struck the rock twice, God said he wouldn’t enter into the land he was giving his ancestors. But in the beginning of the Bible, it says the land was always guarded, so how did others get in? 52:15 – What is the biblical evidence for purgatory?
…
Questions Covered:
06:55 – Do I NEED to ask the help of the Saints and Mary? 14:53 – If the Church has the power and authority to give out indulgences, why is she so stringent about giving them out? 23:52 – Why can’t our parishioners receive the blood from the chalice since COVID started? If it’s truly the blood, and truly incorruptible, shouldn’t they have it? 31:09 – Why did Judas go to hell but the thief on the cross went to purgatory? 37:37 – I’m not sure how to defend the infallibility of the pope to my Protestant and atheist friends. They say that gives him supernatural power. 46:30 – My younger sister wonders why women can’t be priests because there’s plenty of holy women.
…
Questions Covered:
03:17 – Do vaccine mandates contradict the Catechism? 11:48 – I heard a rad-trad argue that the Novus Ordo is spiritually harmful, even though it’s licit, by comparing the two forms of the Mass to the sacrifices of Cain and Abel. How would you respond to that? 19:25 – Where can I find evidence of Jesus in the Old Testament outside of the Psalms? 24:41 – contacted Tim a few years ago and he helped me dig deeper into my faith and I’m so thankful for his help. 29:23 – What’s the Catholic stance on asexuality (not being attracted to either sex)? 36:16 – What does one have to do to devote themselves to the Immaculate Heart of Mary? 43:50 – When the priest is consecrating the sacred elements, because he’s in persona Christi, is it right for us to understand that in that moment he’s actually Christ? If that’s so, is it accurate to understand his body as accidental and his substance as Christ’s, just like the Eucharist? 48:51 – How do we know that forgiveness of sins in John 20 is talking about sacramental confession and not just forgiveness in general?
…
Questions Covered:
17:13 – How did confusion about gender and gender ideology start? 21:03 – How am I to deal with the transition of my relatives when God’s truth tells me not to accept their new names/pronouns? 29:23 – Would you agree that one way to embrace people trapped in gender ideology is to acknowledge their feelings and that they feel extremely out of place? That could disarm the invective around this and reach them better. 32:44 – I’m a nursing student and I’m concerned about how I’m going to have to talk to patients who present themselves as transgender. How should I approach that without endangering my livelihood? 37:12 – My children go to school with a young boy who now thinks he’s a girl. The school and the mom are both supportive but it’s causing problems. Who do I start talking to about this? 43:02 – At what point should a public school teacher, who is being told to teach gender ideology, walk away from the job? 48:08 – I think one thing that would put a stop to this right away is if, when people who transition get older and regret it, they sue their doctors. Is that a path we should pursue and encourage?
Resources Mentioned: A Catechesis on the Human Person and Gender Ideology, by Bishop Michael Burbidge …
Questions Covered:
13:10 – I heard a skeptics’ claim saying that the predictions Jesus made about his death and resurrection were actually made up after the fact in order to make Jesus look more credible. Is there a Catholic response to that? 21:14 – How do Christians resolve the inconsistencies between the four gospels? 44:03 – Why should I believe in Jesus?
…
Questions Covered:
05:24 – Do you think pro-life people are guilty of making red herring arguments? Do we need to change our arguments? 14:15 – Does the Church teach that Adam and Eve did not have any children before the Fall? 18:07 – How do I defend the Catholic Church’s claim that it’s not the schismatic Church in the east/west split? 22:58 – What are the best defenses of Christianity as opposed to some other faith? 30:48 – Someone in a coffee shop told me she wasn’t comfortable with me praying in public because not everyone believes what I believe and we weren’t in a Church. What’s a good Catholic response to that? 37:10 – How do Catholics interpret Romans 9 in the context of debate with Calvinists about the elect and predestination? 43:10 – If I follow God’s will, am I abdicating my free will, which is a great gift from God? 48:34 – How do I explain why non-Catholics should not receive communion?
…
Questions Covered:
45:15 – I’m in the Archdiocese of Cincinnati. The idea of Beacons of Light is to consolidate into families of parishes to better allocate priests and resources to serve the needs of the people.
…
Questions Covered:
00:57 – If Calvin and Luther believe in the perpetual virginity of Mary, why, when, and who put a stop to this belief? Why was the doctrine of the Assumption defined? 04:28 – What is the Catholic justification for adding in the Filioque? 07:20 – Can you explain how Catholics should balance the worship/adoration of God and Mary? 14:17 – Where did the idea/ name for purgatory come from? And why don’t Protestants believe in it? 17:55 – I have a hard time joining together the common apologetics and the early Church history, especially with the letter of 1st Clement. When I read historians, I have a hard time connecting the two because the apologetic realm seems to be heavy and strict while the history realm tends to have a lighter take. 29:22 – I’ve learned that someone has to know that they’re committing a sin for it to be truly considered a sin. If someone was totally incapacitated, would they not be committing a sin if they’re not really aware that they are? 33:08 – Jimmy, what evidence do you have for your different opinion on the source of the Gospels? 40:15 – Could you explain the passage in Revelations that talks about Jesus spitting out those that are lukewarm? What is your opinion on those that are lukewarm in the present day? 46:19 – I’m converting to Catholicism and I learned I’m not supposed to read my old Protestant books. I know sometimes apologists read these to try to come up with ways to rebut what they talk about. Should I get rid of these or what should I do with them? 52:30 – In Matthew 16:18, if Jesus set up a visible, identifiable church, wouldn’t that prove Protestantism wrong because he protected his church from the gates of hell?
…
Questions Covered:
04:23 – I have a theory that when Christ said he emptied himself, he removed all his ability to stop what was going to happen to him because that was the only way for him to truly put himself. Could Jimmy give his opinion on this? 15:49 – I’ve heard that approximately ⅔ of Catholics don’t believe in the real presence. If it’s a dogma, why would the 2/3s who don’t believe still be considered Catholics? 22:48 – I was visiting another parish and the priest distributing the Eucharist said, “The body and blood of Christ” rather than just “The body of Christ”. Is it ok that he said this? And how did the early Church discern that we’re fully under one species? 28:41 – I have a view of purgatory in which the people there are able to pray for people on earth. That they grow closer to God and eventually closer to heaven. Does this go along with Catholic teaching? Could you give me some insight into this? 31:39 – Among Christians I see there’s two views, one where things are Good and God made the world, and the other where the world has fallen and the Devil has reign. What do Catholics believe about this and are we supposed to believe just one or the other? 35:02 – In Genesis 1 when God is talking about making man, Trinitarian Christians say there’s evidence of the trinity because of the Hebrew words used to imply the plural, while others say that those same Hebrew words do not prove that. I want to know how to defend the trinitarian viewpoint. 45:31 – Can the will of the father and of the son ever come into conflict? I’ve heard that in the Father’s perfection, there wouldn’t need to be a coeternal son and that he would be perfect in and of himself. 49:41 – How do you know the difference between when your Guardian Angel does something for you rather than God? 52:39 – What is St. Raphael’s job?
…
Questions Covered:
01:18 – When Jesus tells the 12 apostles to receive the holy spirit, could you tell me how that plays out to the rest of the generations of the world? And how can we actually discern the Spirit? 12:32 – Did the apostle John write the Gospel of John or was it someone else? 22:23 – My 17 yo daughter asked me why the God in the Old Testament seems much more harsh than the one in the New Testament. Why does it seem this way? 28:51 – In Luke 16:9 it says “Make friends with dishonest wealth so that when it fails you, they may receive you into the eternal dwelling.” Could you tell me what it means by this? 33:04 – How does God never have a beginning? 35:50 – In Mark 10:17-18, why did Jesus say “Why do you call me good when only God is good?” 42:30 – What does it mean that Jesus was “perfected” or “sanctified”? 49:50 – In the bible does it say there’s no purgatory for children? And what would it be like for unbaptized children? 51:55 – Is racism a sin? In the bible, both Paul and Jesus expressed racist views. For example, Paul says people from the Island of Crete are all lazy and gluttons. Jesus also said people from Canaan are all dogs.
…
Questions Covered:
03:59 – I’m a Protestant and I’m wondering about regenerative baptism and Acts 10. How does it fit in with the Holy Spirit being upon them before and them being baptized because of it? 11:38 – Last Sunday the gospel was “It is easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than a wealthy person to get to heaven”. What does Jesus truly mean by that? 21:52 – What is the true name of the Messiah? I’ve heard that it’s Jesus but I’ve heard others as well. 28:49 – I read in the New Testament that Jesus had brothers. Is this true? 35:51 – Could you compare the passage Philippians 4:13 “I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me” with Sirach 3:18-19 in terms of humility? 42:05 – In 1 Corinthians chapter 7 when St. Paul tells those who he’s speaking to to be celibate like him, is he speaking to administrators or the congregation of laity? 49:20 – In the bible it says Adam and Eve made original sin, so why is Mary the only one in the entire universe born without original sin? 51:11 – We have a soul and pray, go to confession, etc. to improve it, but did Jesus have a soul like us?
…
Questions Covered:
03:35 – Does Jesus have a created soul from his human soul in reference to “begotten not made” in the Nicene Creed? And what does the “not made” mean in reference to both His human and divine nature, if He has both? 07:17 – How biblical are dreams and how much faith should I put into them? 16:08 – My friend is convinced that Jesus was married. Could you tell me how to get through to her that He wasn’t? 20:36 – I was away from the Church for about 48 years and I’ve recently come back. In a guide book I was reading on St. Peter, it said to refer to Joel 2:28. When I went to my NASV bible, there was no Joel 2:28, but there was when I went to my RSV bible. Why is it in one and not the other? 24:22 – Before my husband and I got married in the Catholic Church, his parents said he was baptized, just not in the Catholic Church. He ended up becoming Catholic after we were married and we learned that he was never baptized at all but just “dedicated”. After knowing this new information, do we have to have our marriage validated in any way? 31:08 – How far back does the tradition go for Catholics to celebrate mass every day of the week? 33:40 – My parents are both deceased and I see them in my dreams every night. Why do they? Also, how do we know if we die? 40:40 – How do we reason with those who are part of the progressive Christian movement today? Particularly on the acceptance of homosexuality. 46:33 – I have part of my dad’s ashes on my dresser. It was not my decision to put them up there, but is this bad? Does this mean that his soul is lost? 49:22 – I’ve been looking for a good Catholic Bible, but in the process of this I was wondering why all of the Protestant denominations reject the books the Catholic Bible has and theirs don’t.
…
Questions Covered:
05:40 – Is the Pope a dictator? 14:10 – Was the perpetual virginity of Mary defined at a council, and who were the other women at the foot of the cross other than John and Mary? 19:05 – Is there no outreach from the Catholic Church compared to others? For example, going door to door or actively trying to convert people in public. 28:48 – Could I get some pointers on how to defend Mary’s perpetual virginity? 39:00 – I have family members that are Pentecostal. They say the saints are sleeping and there’s no way they can intercede for us at this point until the second coming of the Lord. Are they really sleeping or are they 100 percent alive? And where are our family members that have already departed? Can they intercede? 44:55 – I’m looking for a one-stop-shop resource that’s a defense of Catholicism. Could you recommend one? 47:42 – Is the “Oneness” doctrine considered blasphemy?
…
Questions Covered: 13:50 – If someone created a truly artificially intelligent being, would it be a sin to kill it? 18:30 – My husband had a brain aneurysm and I ended up donating some of his organs but I never talked to a priest about it. Would you be able to tell me how to discern this matter? 23:50 – Could you define what the church means by “extraordinary means to support life”? 29:26 – What does the Catholic Church teach about Catholics practicing Yoga? I have heard about how just doing the poses can invite demons. 33:25 – Could you elaborate on the Catholic response towards someone who’s “brain dead”? My stepdad passed away with oxygen to his brain. I wanted to talk about this experience and was wondering if Father could talk about what happened. 43:15 – Could you talk about the pneumonia and shingles vaccines and the use of aborted fetal cells in them? 45:32 – A patient asked me to prescribe Cialis, but I knew he was using it with a mistress. Was it wrong to give it to him? I also had a patient whose parents were going to place her in an institutional setting, and they wanted to put her on birth control so she wouldn’t become pregnant in case she was raped. Was it wrong to give it to her? …
Questions Covered:
07:16 – How could someone be a good “Berean” and know what tradition teaches if it’s not in scripture? If sacred tradition is true, why is so much of it not spoken about in the bible? 16:16 – When a bishop publishes a book, does that count as holy scripture as well? 25:08 – During the Church’s 1054 bipolar split, did sacred tradition prevail against the gates of hell? 29:32 – How do we identify what you call “sacred tradition” in its present form? 41:17 – I’m an Anglican but I agree with the importance of Sacred Tradition.
…
Questions Covered:
22:41 – I’ve always been told that the Kingdom of God is unfolding through time. Is technology a manifestation of that? 38:14 – I think there’s possibilities of extraterrestrial life because Jesus said he has other sheep not of this fold, and because the Bible mentions the word “cloud” a lot. 47:52 – When does technology addiction become a sin?
…
Questions Covered:
07:30 – Why is it better to be Catholic than non-religious? 17:05 – Is God a wrathful god that destroys, or a loving god who saves? What’s the Catholic position? 34:45 – If Jesus says we must eat his flesh and drink his blood to have life, how is that reconciled with the Church teaching that Protestants and atheists and other non-Catholics can possibly be saved? 44:35 – What do Catholics believe about how to get to Heaven? 52:25 – Who is the patron saint of the internet, and why do we need one?
…
Questions Covered:
04:13 – My understanding is that according to Catholic Teaching, you’re not supposed to deprive your spouse. Given that Mary took a vow of perpetual virginity, why did she enter into marriage if she knew that she and Joseph would not create a child? 17:37 – Was Jesus ever married and what language did he speak? 24:13 – Could there be new doctrines formulated in the next 500 years as The Church changes? Specifically ones about St. Joseph (how we honor him, how he could be more important, etc.) 46:24 – In the Apostle’s Creed when it says “He descended into hell and on the third day…”, are those three days Friday, Saturday, and Sunday? 52:14 – Is it ok for me as a Catholic to attend a Protestant bible study? I was invited by a friend.
…
Questions Covered:
04:41 – I know the bible was divinely inspired, but I don’t understand the discrepancies between the gospels. 14:20 – How can I explain original sin without Adam and Eve? 19:53 – Could you explain the part of the Nicene creed where it says “begotten not made, consubstantial with the Father”? 29:00 – I have bought candles from the store and got them blessed. All the candle wax has been used, is the glass blessed as well? If so, is there a certain way I have to dispose of it? 30:33 – Did John the Baptist have a beatific vision about himself when Mary went to visit her cousin and he leapt in the womb? 36:02 – I heard Adam had a helper before Eve named Lillith, is this true? 41:25 – I believe the Holy Spirit is the female side of God because I think there has to be some sort of female part of him to have brought a spouse for Adam. Could you explain why everything about God is male oriented? 50:20 – If the body of Christ happens to drop on the floor, is there a special procedure to go about dealing with it? 52:29 – How would the Greek language have applied to everyday life of the gospel writers and the Septuagint being written in Greek?
Resources Mentioned:
How the Accounts of Jesus’ Childhood Fit Together
…
Questions Covered:
03:50 – In Matthew 12:48 – 50, Jesus asks “who is my brother?” what does he mean by this? And in the Hail Mary, why do we say Mary is the mother of God if she is only the mother of the 2nd person of the trinity? 14:50 – I’m a cradle Catholic but my father was a Presbyterian and we have had discussions about Mary having other children. I accept the dogma, but I’ve never quite had a definitive answer for it. 22:45 – I have a friend who became Protestant, and he was wondering how the saints can hear our prayers. 31:00 – I was a protestant but became Catholic two years ago. I was baptized at 12 years old, and when I went to RCIA they said that was ok. Why do we not have to be baptized again in the Catholic church? 34:40 – The church says Mary and Joseph were virgins, but if they were married, don’t you need to have consummated the marriage to be considered husband and wife? 42:00 – I just became a Catholic 6 months ago. If Mary planned to be a perpetual virgin, then why did she get married? 45:00 – Why don’t Catholics postpone baptism until they’re older to decide for themselves like Protestants? Or, why don’t they have a 2nd baptism?
…
Questions Covered:
07:15 – I’m Catholic but my barber is Jehovah’s Witness, and he says Easter is a pagan holiday. He says one of the problems with Catholicism we celebrate holidays like Easter and Christmas. 13:40 – A Protestant friend of mine was talking about Mary as the “co-redemptrix”. I was trying to explain through her response to the angel Gabriel and that she actually gave God permission through her “yes”. Could you give your comments on his thoughts? 20:30 – I’m Catholic, how can we better defend apostolic succession? 29:45 – I’ve never been to a Catholic church, but why do Catholics and other organized religions all claim that they’re the ones that are better than the others? Where in the bible does it say that we have to be a part of any one? 44:40 – In 2nd Peter, Peter says to his followers if you have questions, you should really follow Paul. Why does he say this?
…
Questions Covered:
01:45 – I called a couple months ago about why I should be Catholic, and I’m now in RCIA. What advice would you give to people that are in RCIA? 07:30 – I heard your previous answer to how we can believe in evolution and still be Catholic. The one thing that trips me up though is how Jesus will sometimes refer to Adam and Eve, so is this Jesus saying himself and confirming that they were the first people? 17:30 – Could you talk about dying in a state of grace? If you die and haven’t been to confession, what happens? 21:30 – As an Anglican converting to Catholicism, indulgences and purgatory are new to me. Could you explain them? 36:40 – Why do people call Mary holy? I’m pretty sure it isn’t stated anywhere in the bible. 45:38 – In scripture or in writings of the church fathers, did Saint Paul acknowledge and submit to Saint Peter’s authority? 51:12 – How do Catholics resolve piety and God illustrated in Socrates and Euthyphro?
…
Questions Covered:
03:20 – How can we apply faith from Hebrews 11 to today’s world? 17:30 – How can you believe in evolution and “The Big Bang” and still be Catholic? 30:17 – What makes certain saints incorruptible? Why them and not others? 37:05 – Why do we have bodies in the new earth/ after the resurrection? 44:57 – What is the process of priests wanting to celebrate the Latin Mass as opposed to the Novus Ordo mass now? I know they have to get special permission but what about establishing it within their parish? 47:35 – What is the Catholic Response to the reformation? I feel like no one has had a definitive answer to it. Could you also recommend some material to look into it more?
…
Questions Covered:
03:18 – Could you talk about the history of the Catholic Faith in Britain in relation to the Anglican church? 14:18 – Angels are supposed to be pure spirits, do they also have souls like humans? 21:26 – What is a sacrament? 28:30 – From a Catholic standpoint, what is the role of the woman in the family? And what should a man look for in a “good”, practicing Catholic woman? 38:17 – Some Muslims don’t believe that Jesus didn’t die, how do you combat this and other arguments Muslims have against Christianity? 44:44 – Could you explain the allegories surrounding the 24th, 25th, and 26th chapters of 1st Clement? 48:45 – The euphemism of natural death is anything but natural and is a pit from the tree of knowledge, but how does Mother Mary succumb to face a natural death? 52:25 – What’s the point of miracles? Do you think they function past church authority?
…
Questions Covered:
05:15 – In the Roman Catholic Church we are told to ask Saints for their intercession. Why are we not encouraged to pray to those of the Old Testament that don’t have the title “Saint”? 10:00 – Why are there so many questions that come into Catholic Answers about the difference/confusion between predestination vs earned salvation? 17:35 – Are Christians who die defending the faith martyrs? 23:00 – Are our Guardian Angels “reassigned” after our deaths? And are the choirs of angels mirrored in hell? 28:48 – How are we to understand the story of Jonah without believing he was actually swallowed by a whale and lived in one for 3 days? 31:47 – Does the church have any reasoning to say whether Adam, the first man, was a modern human or a precursor? 35:05 – If we believe that Mary is without sin, and since Jesus died for our sins because he was without sin, why couldn’t Mary have died on the cross for our sins? 42:40 – Why have the rules changed that a Catholic can be cremated? Do the rules still hold that they should be buried in a Catholic Cemetery? 48:20 – What does the Church teach about good members of non-Christian religions and their ability to enter the kingdom of God? 51:28 – How is the authority that priests are given passed on to lay men to handle the consecrated Eucharist?
…
04:23 – How as Catholics do we understand the Nephilim and Og without sacrificing history and science? 16:14 – Reading different Catholic publications, I come upon saints who don’t have a date on the liturgical calendar, and who are, speaking frankly, obscure. They are honored on All Saints Day. Would asking for their intercession be more efficacious given that the more popular saints are very busy with the prayers directed to them? 18:42 – I read a quote on Twitter attributed to St. Padre Pío, in which he told someone he prayed regularly for the good death of his Uncle, to which the other person replied confused because his uncle had passed away years ago. St. Padre Pío replied that it didn’t matter because God was not bound by time and He would make use of his prayer if that was His wish. Regardless of the veracity of this quote. Is this possible? Can we pray for the good death of someone who died years ago, and can that change something that happened in the past? Based on the theory that the transporter kills the person and then replicates them as clones, here’s a scenario: Captain Kirk goes to confession and then beams down to the wacky planet. While there, he does not get baptized and has unmarried relations with green women and then beams back up. He does something like this numerous times throughout his tour of duty aboard the Enterprise. Does that mean there would be multiple Captain Kirks in heaven, purgatory, and hell? 29:15 – My girlfriend and I have been watching the show “Agents of Shield” and came across an interesting moral dilemma. Spoilers ahead, some listeners might want to skip this one. In the show, an Android is created and is nearly indistinguishable from human. She gets her hands on the Darkhold, a seemingly dark magic book, that can enable the reader to do essentially anything. To escape her Android programming and have “free will”, she uses the Darkhold to create a machine that generates a human body for herself, crafted from matter taken from an alternate dimension, complete with her consciousness/memories/etc. At this point, she considers herself to be human, as she now can choose what she wants to do and is experiencing feelings, not just the simulated responses to stimulation her android self had. My question is: Is she really human? I remember an episode where you spoke about the Star Trek transporters, and how it essentially destroys and creates another human body. In this case, would this human body receive a soul? Would the dark forces at play, or alternate-dimensional matter inhibit this from happening? And how does an AI consciousness play into it all? 00:00 – Here’s a sci-fi question wrapped up with some theology for you… Have you ever seen the anime Neon Genesis Evangelion and how do you think it treats the ideas of gnosticism, kabbalah, and other esoteric themes? 00:00 – Since Jesus touched millions of items throughout his life and over thousands of years the items have broken down, yet matter is never destroyed, would this mean there are atom sized relics? 45:00 – In number 2116 in the Catechism, the Church rejects all forms of divination because they all conceal a desire for power over time, history, and humans. How would time travel into the future for the purpose of seeing the future before God has revealed it not fall under the same condemnation? Isn’t time travel “power over time”? (extra info: even if God allows us to figure it out through natural technological advancement, we couldn’t conclude that he must be fine with it for the same reasons we don’t accept technological advances in contraception, cloning, and other sinful acts.) 50:00 – In the Netflix show Peaky Blinders, a woman confessed to a priest that she’s going to murder someone. Obviously, this isn’t how the sacrament of confession works. However, not only does the priest NOT correct her, but he then goes t…
Questions Covered:
22:54 – All of my children have left the faith and a large part of why we won’t talk to them about it is because we’re afraid, like how Rose mentioned fear dictating our actions. What should I do? 29:29 – I’ve been in a relationship where I’m trying to bring the person to Jesus. Now I think I want to break up and discern the priesthood, but I’m afraid that might lead her down a bad path. 36:46 – How do I honor my father who abandoned me when I was young and has no relationship with me? 42:54 – I ended a relationship in which I felt a bit emotionally unsafe. How can I move on from the things I feel sorry about? 49:14 – I’m a domestic abuse survivor with PTSD and have plans to get euthanasia-assisted suicide because I have no reason to live. If I do that, will I go to hell?
…
Questions Covered:
03:59 – What is purgatory? 13:35 – I want to know about the reach of papal infallibility and the limits to which it binds. Am I duty bound that it’s prudent to dogmatize its truths? Do we have to believe the 3rd and 4th Marian doctrines are all of the truth or can we be good Christians and believe in what Eastern Catholics say about it? 20:46 – What are the sacraments? 29:10 – Why does the Catholic Church find something substantial in Plato’s philosophy? Specifically St. Augustine has referred to it. 45:52 – Does one have to be in a state of grace for God to sincerely hear their requests or what they’re praying for? 49:24 – Have you heard anything about the “one world religion” that the pope is supporting? What are your thoughts on it? 52:16 – What is the definition of Hell?
Resources Mentioned:
Purgation Station
…
Questions Covered:
03:17 – Why is the diocese of Rome not an archdiocese? 06:27 – Are there secular arguments for the existence of human dignity? 11:55 – Did Our Lady ever mention that we should pray for the souls in purgatory, or is it something that the church asks us to do? Is purgatory mentioned in the bible? If there’s no purgatory, where do we go? 16:00 – What is astral projection? What is the difference between bilocation and astral projection? 24:03 – Is it ok for extraordinary ministers to retrieve the eucharist from the tabernacle? Or should only priests do so? 29:29 – If St. Therese died on Sept. 30th, why is her feast day celebrated on October 1st? 32:06 – Is it morally permissible for someone to plan a trip that would take him away from the ability to attend mass? Particularly in the context of explorers and pioneers. 37:13 – Could you talk about general judgement, and why do people with near death experiences never talk about judgement? 44:10 – I’m a convert, former protestant. One of my old professors talked about the God of the Old Testament. He said the Jews were “henotheists” and not monotheists. What is the difference and does the Catholic Church have a stance on it?
…
Questions Covered:
01:15 – What do Catholics believe about acupuncture? 05:55 – Why do Catholics say Catholicism stems directly from Jesus and Protestantism does not? 15:40 – Where did the idea come from that the fruit on the tree of knowledge of good and evil was an apple? 22:40 – Why did Isaac bless Jacob if he lied about it instead of his brother? 29:05 – How is it that we still have free will if God knows what we’re going to do already? 36:00 – Are there any boundaries on alcohol consumption for Catholics? Is there anything in scripture that talks about it? 43:40 – I heard lyrics of a song that said “the wrath of God will satisfy”, but don’t Catholics believe something deeper than that? 50:25 – Why do Catholics hold miraculous medals, the rosary, etc. as significant to our beliefs?
…
Questions Covered:
06:20 – If from the moment God creates us, he knows we’re predestined to heaven or hell, how do we have free choice? 15:20 – Why do Catholics believe in Purgatory? Specifically, the Biblical evidence. 21:19 – Could things like having our temperature taken on our forehead, or carrying our phones around in our hands, be signs of the Mark of the Beast? And would God make it something like that, that we might do without knowing? 23:15 – Why does the Church keep and venerate relics and saints’ bodies? 34:00 – What does the Church teach about organ donation and cremation? 40:15 – Why do Catholics believe they’re not allowed to hold God accountable to his own moral system? 46:25 – Why do Catholics worship Mary and the saints?
…
Questions Covered:
02:25 – What would you say to someone that is interested in joining the church but the idea of having to go to a class to join the church is off-putting to them? 11:05 – I heard a point made from a person that the crumbs of the host of the holy eucharist is somewhat an exaggeration of reverence how it is treated. Back in ancient history when they used real bread, not wafer, when broken and shared, it inevitably made breadcrumbs fall on the ground and they did not treat it with as much prudence as they do now? 15:07 – Can a person with ADHD be at fault for the constant distractions that happen during Mass or prayer? 17:51 – I’ve heard of a Mass celebrated where the Homily was done through a video call, where the priest was in another location, and broadcasted in Mass as the Homily. Is this ok? 20:33 – Are Guitars and Drums allowed in mass? Also, is it good to have them used in liturgical celebrations? 23:02 – Should we as Catholics allow synthetic intelligences full voting rights? 28:58 – What is the best step a person can take to get over scrupulosity? 33:15 – Why do we call priests father? Doesn’t the Bible tell us that we’re not to call anybody father except God the father? 41:49 – How efficacious is mental prayer compared to verbal prayer? Should one ever be specifically used in place of the other? 44:27 – Is there any resource where it gives a Catholic summary or commentary of every chapter of every book in the Bible? Especially reading the Prophetic books, it kind of helps if there’s an explanation for each chapter. 47:07 – Can you explain why, if I’m understanding correctly, a marriage between two baptized protestants would be presumed valid while a marriage between a protestant and lapsed Catholic would not? 50:42 – How does one discern if they have given into a lustful thought?
…
Questions Covered:
19:50 – Based on the Catholic teachings, is it wrong to celebrate the feast days commanded in Lev 23? 23:08 – How could God condemn Adam of Eve of sinning because of eating from the tree of good and evil? They didn’t know the difference before eating from the tree, so how can you count it as sin? 24:39 – Is it okay to not believe in a historical Adam & Eve? 31:14 – Why isn’t St. Constantine on the Roman calendar? In the East we celebrate the feast of St. Constantine and Helen, but the west only celebrates St. Helen…do Latin Catholics reject his sanctity? 34:32 – When certain faith communities refer to a “great apostasy,” what are they talking about? Is there a certain period when the church fell away? 36:25 – How can a person believe something that seems false to them? If you aren’t convinced of a thing, can you really say you believe it? 43:06 – Father, would you explain the icon of Jesus holding an infant in swaddling clothes? Is this Mary? 46:55 – With regards to the book of revelation, is there any reference to a one world government with regards to events to come? 49:38 – What does the church teach regarding suicide? I have heard conflicting answers. 52:37 – Can a priest be sent to minister to someone dying in their final hours who is not a Catholic?
…
Questions Covered:
04:00 – As a protestant, we were focused on present-day miracles from Christ, but Catholics are more focused on miracles through intercession from saints. 16:30 – What is the 54-day rosary novena? 20:00 – Is the phrase “full” in Luke 1:28 when Gabriel says “Hail Mary full of grace” an inaccurate translation? 28:43 – What happens to the soul when somebody goes to communion with mortal sin? 36:12 – Did God the father die when Jesus died? 40:47 – Nancy Pelosi recently made a statement using the term “free will”, I think the Catholic media needs to do a better job at responding to it. How would you define free will? 48:41 – What is your take on the controversial blessed Carlo Acutis stained glass image? Joe Heschmeyer argued against a Catholic Youtuber that said in the stained glass he’s wearing sneakers and jeans and some Catholics took an issue with that. 52:44 – How does the Anglican/Protestant view of the doctrine of justification differ from the Catholic view of it? Could you explain the differences?
…
Questions Covered:
17:00 – What is the best way to find God’s will for your life? 22:37 – How do you “let go and let God” on a situation, but also continue to pray for the situation? 33:26 – I am struggling with the happiness part, could you summarize how to get there? 42:20 – How do you recognize when God answers your prayer? 48:25 – My husband is a worrier and often angry, how can I deal with him?
…
Live from the big stage at the Catholic Answers Conference! Questions Covered:
06:15 – Are you familiar with the portrayal of Our Lord in The Chosen TV series? If so, what do you think about it? 09:22 – I understand the role of Judas, but I struggle with him being predestined to betray Jesus. How should we feel about him? 18:20 – What are ways the Church can encourage young people in their faith in our ever-changing world? 23:30 – What is your perspective on Catholic education today on forming our children? 34:15 – How can we avoid falling into tribalism in the Church without failing to protect Catholic teaching? 49:10 – Why isn’t the Church supporting more classical academies?
…
Live from the big stage at the Catholic Answers Conference! Questions Covered:
2:20 – What would you say are the most important things the we as Catholics can do to share the love of Christ and promote the cause of life in our communities? 05:05 – We know that out of respect for the body, the Church requires the remains or cremains must be interned whole and complete. So why do we spread class 1 relics all over the globe? Doesn’t this violate church teaching? 07:50 – My sister joined a church that rearranges their Creed to read “crucified, descended into hell, died, and was buried.” What are the implications of the Harrowing of Hell on Christology? 13:40 – How can we respond to someone who challenges the Church’s and Christ’s moral teachings out of a sense of empathy? 17:00 – How do you explain to fellow Catholics that Christ is in time but is fully God and God is outside of time? 19:40 – How would you go about the transformation by the renewal of your mind as St. Paul describes in Rom. 12:2? 22:55 – How has the Church portrayed Christ by allowing Cardinal McCarrick and other priests to remain in office even after their sexual abuses became known? 28:55 – Where in scripture does it show that Christ has a sense of humor? 30:50 – Why did Jesus Go to hell to save people? Why didn’t he do it from heaven? 33:55 – We just heard a talk on why Jesus’s manhood is so important. In light of that, shouldn’t we place similar importance on his ethnicity? 37:55 – If I don’t get the COVID vaccine I could lose my job, but it goes against my conscience. What would Jesus do in my situation? 46:50 – Jesus’ last words to the woman caught in adultery were instructions to sin no more. How does one not become discouraged over this seemingly impossible command? 50:38 – I’ve heard it said that transgender people are less likely to commit suicide if we refer to them by their preferred pronouns. How do you respond to that and have a conversation with regards to transgenderism considering the Church’s teachings and the image of God in us?
…
Live from the first day of the Catholic Answers Conference! Questions Covered:
02:50 – How do we reach the younger generation who’s no longer on traditional media and are hearing a lot of falsehoods on the new media? 13:05 – Is it worth arguing against wrong ideas in a college classroom, or is it better to wait? 17:45 – What’s the Church’s teaching on laypeople baptizing a relative? 28:30 – Do you have any suggestions on how to open the minds of children as young as 13 and 14 who have so little interest in even knowing who they are and why they exist? 32:54 – How can I talk to my Seventh-Day Adventist friends who say the Jewish ritual food laws still apply? 38:46 – When does ensoulment occur? 47:45 – How do I answer people who ask why we should follow a Bible in which God commands murder of entire peoples?
…
Live from the first day of the Catholic Answers Conference! Questions Covered:
02:15 – How was the Church able to determine if Hebrews belonged in the Bible if we didn’t know the human author? 06:12 – The two big historical stories from Genesis are Abraham and Joseph—what credibility can we give to the stories outside of the Bible itself? 15:15 – How literally should we take seventy times seven? Not mathematically, but should we really forgive over and over if someone keeps hurting us? 22:14 – Can you offer up your Purgatorial process to help someone reach heaven? 28:30 – Are getting to heaven and the reward in heaven two different things? 37:44 – What did Pope Francis mean by not making the Eucharist a political matter?
…
Questions Covered:
02:30 – If a pitcher intends to deceive a batter with a pitch, is this considered lying? 07:20 – What is the point of having a priest offer a sacrifice at the altar when Jesus is interceding for us before the Father? 14:53 – Lisa…Mounds, OK…EWTN app….Why did John the Baptist send emissaries out to find out who Jesus was? Didn’t he know who he was as his cousin? 18:34 – Is there a theological justification for saying “G—D— it”? Like, I want God to take this bad thing I did and get it as far away from me as possible. 22:10 – Why is the COVID-19 vaccine so controversial when other very common vaccines are made with the same connection to abortion? Why isn’t there as much controversy over those? 28:41 – What should I do about the seeming disconnect between Catholic groups and clergy on the morality of vaccines? How should I interpret the different statements between what Bishops say and what Catholics around me say? 35:27 – When did the celestial battle between the devil and the angels take place? 40:00 – Why doesn’t the Church issue anathemas anymore? 44:05 – What is Jesus’s origin? Was he born in time, or was he from all eternity through the Father? 46:03 – Why did Vatican II change who could touch the host? Before, only the priest could, but now other people can too. 51:20 – How do we know which verses in the Bible we can interpret for ourselves and which ones have a fixed, doctrinally defined meaning?
…
Questions Covered:
03:00 – If the Church is infallible and the Pope upholds infallible doctrines, how is it possible that the Church could have ever needed reform? 07:07 – If contraception is immoral for humans, then is it okay to neuter animals? 12:07 – How are Luke 11:52 and Mt. 23:13 related to the keys that Jesus gave to St. Peter? 16:45 – Why is Mary called “Tower of David,” “Tower of Ivory,” and “House of Gold” in the Litany of the Blessed Virgin? What are the origins of those titles? 20:58 – How can we merit salvation in a state of grace when we’re already saved? 30:10 – What is non-Incarnational Protestantism and how is it different from Catholicism? 33:26 – Why is the nullification process so intimate? It asks very difficult questions about the couple’s intimacy and past. 42:16 – Are the people in heaven aware that there are people in hell? 48:09 – Is it risky to ask the Saints for prayer, since we’re not certain that they’re in heaven?
…
Questions Covered
03:43 – Is the sacrifice of the Mass properly understood as one sacrifice applied to each individual? 15:03 – If you get a divorce, as a Catholic, can you remarry? If you do remarry, is it considered adultery? 18:02 – Should one receive the Eucharist while feeling pregnancy nausea? 22:04 – Is the Eucharist the true body and blood of Jesus, or is it just a symbol? 36:15 – What’s the charism and short history of the Norbertines? 43:34 – How are people who join the armed forces following Jesus’s command to turn the other cheek? 51:58 – If a couple got married in the Church but then divorced, are they allowed to live together as long as they’re not intimate, like roommates?
…
Questions Covered:
2:20 – How powerful is St. Michael the Archangel? Does the devil fear him? 11:22 – Is it okay for me to attend an Eastern Orthodox Divine Liturgy? If it is, do I have to do anything to distinguish myself? 14:52 – Why isn’t the Real Presence mentioned in the Nicene Creed? 22:15 – What is the immediate meaning to Ahaz of the virgin prophecy of Isaiah 7? 31:05 – How is everything is good if, as Augustine says, it was made out of nothing and is mutable? 36:26 – If someone is a civil leader, how do you know if their authority comes from God or not? 43:06 – I woke up today thinking very heavily about an old friend, and then I learned that she’d died by suicide 22 years ago. Is it possible that the Holy Spirit was asking me to pray for her? 49:34 – How would you answer someone who believes in the Catholic Church but they’re having trouble with some of the things Mary said at Fatima?
…
Questions Covered
13:45 – How do you explain to a fellow Catholic that we’ll eventually come through current crises stronger than before? 17:17 – I’m talking to an anti-Catholic who says that anyone who attended the Council of Nicea was forming a church of the devil and was not in the Church of Christ. 22:25 – How are the titles for the clergy like “Your Eminence” or “Your Excellency” proper? Are they a bad holdover from the middle ages? 30:12 – Do you believe that the idea of a Catholic monarchy in the U.S. is a good idea? 34:44 – How much accountability is the Church supposed to take for humanitarian efforts outside of the Church? Should she focus more on worship? 40:12 – What are some actionable things we can do as Catholics or in our parishes to endure certain crises/scandals going on, whether domestic or out of our control? 43:40 – Do you talk about the Crusades in your book? 47:47 – What do you think the causes were for the sex abuse scandals? 50:28 – I think the crisis of the Church is due to communists infiltrating our seminaries decades ago.
…
Questions Covered:
05:10 – I reject the Pope saying it’s okay to take the COVID vaccines, which are based on the murder of children. 15:08 – Is there a difference in the kinds of suffering we have? 20:22 – I disagree with the idea that abortion is wrong even when the mother is too young to take care of a child. 30:00 – Is eternity in hell a just and fair punishment? 42:19 – I’ve heard conflicting things from multiple Catholic leaders about the morality of the death penalty. What is the Church’s official teaching, and why? 47:50 – Do we have an obligation to give priority to vaccines that have no connection to abortion? 50:27 – I think the teaching against masturbation is unrealistic and harmful and leaves people in a state of constant guilt.
…
Questions Covered:
10:25 – Do you lose your free will when you die? 19:55 – I’m reading “Letter to Families” by JPII that talks about this subject. Also, where did you get your quotation from St. Therese? 37:39 – I’m in my eighties and have experienced the suffering that comes with that, and I’ve found great consolation in devotion to the Blessed Mother. 44:49 – If people can get to heaven by invincible ignorance, what’s the point of evangelizing and making people into Christians?
…
Questions Covered:
Can you explain the glory that we “give” God and does God need this glory? The idea of giving God glory is a little confusing. I know we are suppose to glorify God but never questioned what exactly that entailed. 37:45 – What does Joe think about the idea that Christianity boils down to the service of others and the peace that brings? 51:30 – If we’re all united in Christ when we’re in heaven, how will we still be individuals?
…
03:04 – How should one respond to someone says the Neocatechumenal Way is a cult? 12:41 – Why can’t girls be priests? 17:03 – Where do we get all the details of how our churches look and what our priests wear in today’s liturgy? How did we get here from what’s described in the Bible? 21:52 – Is applied kinesiology okay in the Catholic Church? 28:40 – How can we believe the Eucharist is truly Jesus’s body if the body is inherently physical? 34:05 – If someone got married outside the Church, but they want to be married in the Church, can they go to confession and receive the sacraments or do they have to wait until they’re married in the Church? 40:48 – What’s more important: a civil union, or a marriage in the Church? 46:00 – Why did God create the world, and all of us, knowing that there would be pain and suffering? 48:58 – How should I begin reading the Church Fathers? 50:35 – Are the Jews still God’s chosen people?
…
Questions Covered:
18:20 – When the Crystal Cathedral was converted into a Catholic Cathedral, what sacramental changes were made to it? 22:08 – I think that good architecture directs our attention to the fullness of the faith. 29:21 – What’s the significance of artists or architects intentionally including flaws in their work? 32:40 – We have an opportunity to build a new chapel here. What are some tips for making sure we create a good and beautiful building? 37:33 – Are the dimensions of the golden mean still used today in church architecture? And can those dimensions be used in the construction of a guest room? 45:08 – How can I learn more about Duncan’s work? 47:35 – What are your thoughts on the renovations going on at Notre Dame cathedral? 52:50 – How important it is that all the artisans and craftsmen of a Church be believers?
…
Questions Covered:
04:07 – I think the Scriptures show that non-denominational approach is better for me personally to serve Christ. 14:55 – I think people use religion and Catholicism as ways to make sense of the world, but it’s not actually truth. 19:25 – I’m not Catholic (or any denomination) because I think it’s too rule-oriented. We should have more liberty in Christ. 29:30 – I want to become Catholic but I’m not sure how to begin. 34:05 – I grew up Catholic but branched away from it because I feel like there’s not much community in it. 41:10 – I believe that Jesus is the high priest and there’s no need to go to a priest for confession. Also the Catholic expression of worship is different from what we see in the Bible. 52:57 – I’m not Catholic because the Church doesn’t want me, a divorced and remarried man.
…
Questions Covered:
06:07 – I don’t see any good evidence that God exists, and any evidences I hear fall flat. Also, the problem of evil—specifically, that God is evil. 15:55 – I’m in the process of conversion, but my mom doesn’t want to convert because she feels like she’s betraying her Lutheran heritage. 19:38 – I’m Orthodox because I couldn’t find a primacy or infallibility in the early Church, and because I think Orthodoxy has preserved the tradition more faithfully. 40:19 – The Church openly teaches people to accept abusive relationships, both from other humans and from God. 45:50 – I believe the Catholic Church is the false church according to Revelation.
…
Questions Covered:
04:25 – My Protestant friend objects to the TV show “The Chosen” because she thinks it violates the second commandment. What can I say to her? 13:42 – How did the Liturgy of the Hours develop? Do religious orders have their own version? 18:18 – I always understood that we are judged at our death and then go to heaven, hell, or purgatory. But I heard the other day that we’re judged at the end of the world. Are we re-judged? 29:50 – What specific evidence do people usually use to claim that Christianity came from Zoroastrianism? 37:33 – Is it possible for the devil to enter your room during one of your dreams? 44:35 – If John the Baptist’s father was a high priest, why didn’t John serve as a priest? 48:48 – If Jesus blots our sins away, are we still going to be judged for that sin after we ask for forgiveness?
…
Questions Covered:
4:30 – A friend told me it’s more merciful for someone to exist in hell than to not exist at all. Is that true, and if so, why is it? 8:20 – If someone committed a mortal sin, and forgot about it at his next confession but still made a good confession, would he still have to confess it once he remembered it? 16:48 – Do the Church Fathers, in their discussion of the Eucharist, ever use the term metaousious? 20:51 – How could it be just for God to give an eternal punishment for finite sins? 28:30 – I heard a deacon say that they had a cross (not crucifix) in their church because we want to remember Jesus’ resurrection, not his death. Is that a new idea? Should we be wary of it? 31:15 – Can canon law be changed before the next edition? 35:50 – Since the Eucharist is the source and summit of our faith, why isn’t it mentioned in the Apostolic creed? 41:42 – I’ve seen multiple priests, when I go up to receive communion, have one host at the ready but then switch it out for another when I receive. Why would they do that? 45:20 – If Adam and Eve had not sinned, would we be in need of heaven? 50:45 – When the priest’s hands are consecrated, can that consecration be passed down to a layperson?
…
Questions Covered:
08:00 – Was St. Rita unequally yoked to her husband? 17:25 – Why doesn’t the Church or Christian counselors emphasize more the importance of making sure couples are in alignment with their faith? For example, frowning on marrying someone outside the faith. 21:53 – How do I handle a husband who is my same faith, but now seems to view God and my faith as a competitor, like I have another boyfriend or something. 30:32 – My husband and I are in the process of validating our marriage. What advice can you give when my husband doesn’t want to pray with me or participate at Mass? 42:15 – I’ve been married for 21 years but two years ago my husband left the faith and now my children are wanting to leave. I continue to go alone. What can I do besides pray? 48:07 – My friend is in a physically intimate relationship with a girl who is not Christian. He asked me if I thought they should break up. What should I tell him? 51:34 – My husband in Jewish and sometimes I just need his support, for example, to get my kids to come to Mass. What is your advice?
…
Questions Covered
07:00 – What tips do you have for defending the faith against agnostic atheists with Buddhist leanings? 14:11 – What can I say to people who say “God is too big for one religion” and cite people of other religions who do great things? 19:44 – As a college student, what’s the best way I can I engage with people who are already theologically astute, especially of other faiths? 24:20 – How can I answer the Calvinist claim that the union of the Father and Son was broken at the crucifixion, and the Son felt the full wrath of God? 32:35 – How can you defend a faith that worships the most evil and most powerful deity? 40:20 – If Jesus is God, what’s the point of him being sinless? 45:40 – What’s the distinction between killing someone and letting them die, as it relates to abortion, euthanasia, and assisted suicide? 52:24 – How would you explain to someone that the Trinity is something logical and reasonable?
…
Questions Covered:
01:24 – How do Catholics understand Daniel 9:24-27, particularly the part about the messiah being cut off in the middle of the week? 08:30 – The death penalty is all over the Bible, but is it supported by anything Jesus said? 15:33 – Where should I tell my agnostic friends to begin reading the Bible? 20:17 – When Jesus died, did just his human nature die or both his human and divine natures? 24:36 – In Romans 9, is “Those he foreknew he also predestined” the most accurate translation? If not, what’s more accurate? If it is, how is that compatible with free will? 36:12 – Does 1 Corinthians 11:5-6 and 10 require women to wear veils at Mass? 44:03 – Could Mary have said no? 48:28 – Is it wrong to ask the Saints to physically do something for us? 50:43 – Colossians attributes creation to the Son, but the Creed attributes it to the Father. Who created?
…
Questions Covered:
04:47 – What’s the logic behind the objections to the deuterocanonical books? 16:01 – Is the divine simplicity found in the Bible? Can a Catholic hold to a different metaphysical view? 22:46 – Does Heb 11:6 mean that someone who doesn’t believe in God can’t do anything good? 34:00 – Where does the Bible mention the existence of purgatory? 37:45 – I’ve been told that the temple description in Ezekiel is supposed to be a representation of the Church today. If that’s the case, why did Ezekiel go into so much detail about the temple? 46:38 – Isaiah 3:44 says “All the hosts of heaven shall rot away.” How is that possible? 52:34 – What does Paul mean in 1 Tim 1:13 when he says shown mercy because of his ignorance?
…
Questions Covered:
06:35 – Did Jesus have a guardian angel? Could the one who comforted him during his Agony in the Garden have been it? 15:00 – Do sedevacantist priests confer valid sacraments? 17:53 – My priest doesn’t allow us to go to confession anonymously. How can we work around this without doing anything wrong? 22:10 – If you audibly hear a voice telling you a negative message while you’re looking at the crucifix, is it from Jesus or could it be from elsewhere? 30:40 – Will the apostolic pardon keep you out of purgatory? 33:13 – Was Mary only sinless when she was pregnant with Jesus, or was she sinless her whole life? 36:28 – Were the words of the Memorare changed from “in thy clemency hear and answer me” to “in your mercy?” 39:55 – Why isn’t it idolatry to have figurines and shrines of saints? 46:40 – My Pentecostal relative died recently and my family wanted to have the service in a Catholic church. They also wanted a pentecostal preacher to say the service, but the priest said no and they got very upset. How could I have talked to them about it better? 51:00 – I’ve been a Protestant my whole life. I’m thinking about becoming Catholic but I’m having a really hard time getting in contact with the local priest. Is this a sign that God doesn’t want me to become Catholic?
…
Questions Covered:
05:23 – What resources can you recommend on the Great Schism? 07:30 – I have a friend who’s a self-proclaimed naturalist and talks about stuff that sounds kind of like witchcraft. How can I talk to him about ditching the mental/spiritual side and coming towards Catholicism? 15:50 – Why don’t we have any devotions to people from the Old Testament? 20:30 – What does “synodality” mean? What is the upcoming synod on synodality going to be about? 24:45 – How do dispensations work? How can a bishop free us from something we’re morally obligated to do? 37:00 – What’s the Catholic take on Romans 4 saying we’re justified by faith and not works? 45:37 – How do we know that the Catholic Church is the original church founded by Jesus? 50:10 – How can I talk to my 20-year-old fallen-away son about coming back to the faith?
…
Questions Covered
03:20 – In the Olivet discourse, the Apostles asked when the world would end, and Jesus said he didn’t know. How could that be if he’s God? 16:15 – Would it be ethically okay to kill someone if I had no choice in order to save my family? 22:42 – Do we have to stop watching movies or shows where people use God’s name in vain? Are we participating in that sin? 31:20 – Why does the Creed say Jesus rose “again” from the dead? 37:12 – If people can be saved by invincible ignorance (not knowing the Gospel through no fault of their own), does that mean we shouldn’t try to convert them, since there’s a better chance of them being saved if they haven’t heard? 44:18 – Why did Joseph want to divorce Mary? Was it because he believed what she told him and didn’t think he was worthy, or because he didn’t believe her and thought she’d committed adultery? 50:24 – What’s the difference between sinlessness and righteousness? 51:51 – Is there a plenary indulgence with Last Rites, and how does that affect our time in purgatory?
…
Questions Covered
04:38 – How do I answer the Protestant objection to praying to the saints that says they don’t hear us because that would make them sad, and there’s no sadness in heaven? 12:27 – Is it sinful to use recreational marijuana in moderation? 18:13 – If your priest isn’t paying attention during your confession, does your absolution still count? 23:00 – What are some good and not-so-good biblical movies? 32:44 – My girlfriend’s employer is mandating the COVID vaccine and she doesn’t want to get it. How could she bring this up to her employer? 43:52 – Why do we call Mary “Mother of God” if God is eternal and there are three distinct persons of the Trinity? Isn’t that a misleading title? 50:28 – Why do we want to go to heaven if “Heaven and earth shall pass away”?
Resources Mentioned:
Note on the morality of using some anti-Covid-19 vaccines
…
Questions Covered:
02:10 – Is the Catechism “adding to the Bible” in the way that Revelation commands us not to? 08:10 – Why do have to recite the rosary out loud? 11:55 – What’s the Catholic understanding of having a personal relationship with Jesus? 16:30 – Why do we ask the Saints to pray for us? 20:41 – Is it okay for my girlfriend, who is visiting from out of town, to sleep in my apartment (in a separate room) for a night or two? 24:47 – What are plenary indulgences, and what do they accomplish? 33:51 – Is panentheism (Google: “the belief or doctrine that God is greater than the universe and includes and interpenetrates it”) an accurate view of God? Specifically, is it a more accurate representation of him than the traditional white-robed man or the postmodern “all around us” views? 42:43 – Outside of receiving their communion, is it okay for me to regularly attend a Protestant worship service? 48:27 – Why did Jesus often order those he healed miraculously to not tell anyone about it, and why did they so often disobey him? 52:07 – I tried to go to confession before Mass recently and the priest told me he couldn’t hear me at the moment but he could hear me afterward. I said I wanted to confess before because I had a mortal sin and wanted to receive communion, and he said I could receive and then confess after Mass. I’ve never heard that from a priest before. Is it ok?
…
Questions Covered
04:43 – Could Fr. Hugh comment of the state of religious orders and their orthodoxy in the United States? 13:19 – How do I evangelize to my agnostic family and friends who believe in higher power but don’t want to follow organized religion? 19:28 – Is it okay for me to work at a workplace where I can be reasonably sure people will be committing sins? 23:47 – Who is Our Lady of Charity? 32:52 – What are the Church’s teachings on religious liberty? 46:36 – How can I talk to someone in my family who’s convinced the Freemasons have infiltrated the Church?
…
Questions Covered:
02:55 – Is the story about Ananias and Sapphira and their terrible end literally historical? Was it not a bit too harsh? 06:43 – Is it right for a priest to own personal properties, like houses or investments? 17:24 – What are the best sources to learn correct biblical interpretation (by the magisterium) of the sacred scripture? 19:42 – What can I do when I see a kind of new “schism” in our beloved Mystical Body of Christ? 23:54 – Why is it that the Catholic Our Father ends with “deliver us from evil,” and not “for yours is the kingdom, the power and the glory forever and ever”? 28:59 – I’m struggling with sin constantly even though I pray the Rosary every day, and morning and night prayers, and watch the daily online Mass. How can we be like the Apostles when they had the privilege of Jesus’ company and received the Holy Spirit in a very active way compared to now? 33:12 – The second half of Acts and onwards of the New Testament has Paul written all over it. Protestants and Orthodox have used that to prove that Paul is the leader and not Peter. Even some Church Fathers didn’t behave as if there was a single authority. What is the best way to refute that? 36:40 – What is the Catholic view on the relationship between doctrine and history? Particularly, what does the Catholic Church have to say regarding Historical Jesus studies? The field of Historical Jesus studies is dominated by Protestant/Non-Catholic thinkers, so I’m wondering if Catholic teaching has something to uniquely contribute to it that is often forgotten or neglected by scholars outside the Church 43:12 – Is the Church truly given authority by Jesus to remit punishment from sins after death? I thought God alone determines punishment. What are the bases for indulgences in scripture and tradition? 49:12 – Would it be possible to overcome the schism from 1054? 52:03 – How about the coin in the fish’s mouth miracle of Jesus — is it historical or a kind of parable?
…
Questions Covered:
30:48 – In the Gospel, Jesus was told by his brothers to go to the festival to preach, then Jesus said that he won’t go there. However, when evening came, he actually went there secretly then started preaching. Did Jesus lie here? 38:26 – Why did Jesus choose Judas to be part of the twelve apostles knowing that he would betray him later on? 43:49 – What do Church teaching, Scripture, and natural law say about homosexuality? 51:05 – If the devil and demons are being tormented eternally in hell, why do these evil spirits have the ability to roam on Earth?
…
Questions Covered:
04:33 – In Acts 3:13-16, Peter says twice the Jewish people denied the holy and righteous one. Why does he say this about others when he did it himself? 07:10 – Is there any effect the Eucharist has on an unborn child when his mother receives it? 11:21 – Can you still receive the Holy Spirit if you smoke cigarettes? 15:12 – When they took all the animals on Noah’s Ark, did that include the dinosaurs? 17:35 – When Jesus forgave the paralytic’s sins, did Jesus forgive the sins that caused him to become paralyzed, or did he forgive unrelated sins? 28:29 – How do you avoid discouragement when your good deeds aren’t accepted by the world? 35:39 – Does the cloud of witnesses (Heb 12) include those in Purgatory? And are they aware of our life events? 43:21 – What’s the difference between Jesus’s Ascension into heaven and Mary’s Assumption into heaven? 45:58 – How did we transition from worshipping on Saturdays to Sundays when Genesis says God sanctified the seventh day? 53:20 – What does the Bible mean when it says St. Paul was forgiven out of ignorance?
…
Questions Covered:
15:01 – As an alcoholic in recovery, how can you confess mortal sins if you can’t remember everything you did? 19:35 – I’m a recovering alcoholic and there is tons of wisdom in those AA rooms. I owe my recovery to them. 23:56 – I have Scott’s book and it’s great for me. 33:17 – I don’t think my mother is an alcoholic, but she definitely abuses alcohol. How can I talk to her about being more temperate? 36:43 – I love that Scott is bringing a Catholic voice to this when there’s so much Catholic stuff hidden in it already. 47:12 – How is the religious 12-step program different from the traditional 12-step program? 51:50 – If the Bible says alcoholics won’t inherit the kingdom of heaven, why do we have people in recovery say every day “I’m an alcoholic”?
Resources Mentioned: catholicinrecovery.com …
Questions covered:
08:15 – How is it moral or consistent with God’s law for him to command the death penalty for homosexuality in the Old Testament? 21:47 – My friend isn’t Catholic but believes in transubstantiation. He believes he can pray over his food and it’ll become the body of Christ. What can I say to him? 29:00 – Why are there two different versions of the Catholic Catechism? 35:34 – What’s the difference between books with fantasy elements that are condemned, like Harry Potter, and other books with fantasy elements that aren’t? 44:45 – Some Muslim gentlemen showed me in the Q’uran that Joseph wasn’t married to Mary, but just cared for her. How do we know that Joseph was her husband? 51:30 – Am I avoiding lukewarmness?
…
Questions Covered:
03:04 – Are earrings and tattoos sinful because they damage our bodies without benefit? 08:40 – Are Christian conceptions of angels derived from Zoroastrian tradition? 15:50 – Why does the Douay-Rheims Bible list a third and fourth book of Kings? 18:33 – If our only choices are obey God or go to hell, how do we have free will? Sounds like he’s making us an offer we can’t refuse. 20:11 – Does a forgotten mortal sin merit purgatory? 22:20 – Are Catholics required to believe that Mary didn’t suffer labor pains? 28:25 – Is the man speaking to Daniel in Daniel 10:5 considered to be Jesus? Are there any other appearances of Jesus in the Old Testament? 34:25 – Where is the Garden of Eden now? 36:12 – Did the early Christians tamper with the Old Testament? 41:26 – The Catechism says angels are spiritual, non-corporeal beings, but the Bible seems to depict them as having bodies. How should we understand them? 49:15 – What does it mean to increase in the state of righteousness after initial justification? 52:25 – Why does God allow us to have loving relationships with other people if he alone satisfies all our needs and happiness?
…
Questions Covered:
08:43 – Do you know where it was that St. JPII said pro-life ministry is one of the highest ministries in terms of pleasing God? 12:15 – In my third pregnancy, the doctors said the baby had passed away, so I took medication to pass it. Was that an abortion? 13:40 – Does Ivermectin have any connection to aborted cell lines? 21:58 – Is there a pro-life concern with any of the current COVID treatments available? And why do all the vaccines need to be developed off the same one cell line? 29:14 – When Roe v. Wade was passed, what was the conservative/liberal split on the Supreme Court? 31:52 – Why can’t women get an abortion in the case of rape? 36:49 – If we use other animals for medical research, like fetal pigs, why are we now using humans for that kind of research? 47:09 – Do you know who it was that put forth the idea that only certain people deserve medical care if they’re contributing to society? 51:15 – Is it okay for someone living in a lot of suffering, like in solitary confinement, to accept being killed to be put out of their misery?
…
Questions Covered
06:38 – Should a priest use the Church’s form in the words of absolution? What should I do if he doesn’t? 09:00 – Is the Kingdom of God or the Church a society? 12:30 – Why does God give the devil so much power? 14:42 – What would you identify as the most urgent need among Catholic leadership today? 18:00 – What should I make of claims like in “Infiltration” that secret societies are trying to take down the Church from within? 21:34 – Is there any part of scripture to read when fear is prevalent? 24:16 – Why is there so much controversy over the Latin Mass? What should the laity’s position be? 30:40 – Could you expand on the idea of slavery in the Bible and how it’s different from how we understand slavery today? 34:06 – What is the definition of the chosen people as given in the prophets, and how does that carry over to Christianity today? 37:20 – Why would cremation devalue a body, as opposed to burial? 39:25 – How should we approach interpretation of dreams? 42:32 – If someone has a same-sex attraction, does he need to include that detail when confessing sexual sin? 44:40 – What’s the Catholic teaching on tithing? 46:35 – Why are priests who say confusing things like Fr. James Martin not being reprimanded while others are? 49:28 – Why does suffering play such a significant role in God’s plan? 50:40 – How should I pick a confessor? 52:57 – Is it moral for me to receive the COVID vaccine?
…
02:38 – I work at a renaissance fair that has vendors selling pagan merchandise. Am I participating in sin? 06:41 – If you’re good your whole life, but commit a mortal sin right before death and don’t go to confession, do you go to hell or to purgatory? 14:07 – If we eat the Eucharist, which is Jesus, are we cannibals? 17:35 – How can I explain to my son why a boy in my neighborhood is being dressed like a girl by his parents? 28:53 – Does the Church consider cosmetic procedures/surgeries to be vain and a sign of attachment to the world? 40:58 – What is a Norbertine? How are they different from other monastic orders? 46:55 – Is there any basis in the Bible for annulling a first marriage? 52:44 – Is the priest only in persona Christi during the consecration or for the rest of communion?
…
04:51 – Why don’t we observe the Sabbath on Saturday? 12:44 – Can a Catholic assent to the idea that we all have unconscious biases? 21:08 – Why is living a moral life necessary if we can just have a deathbed conversion/baptism/confession? 31:28 – If I bring a non-Catholic to Mass and tell them not to go to communion, but they go anyway, what should I do? 36:20 – I’m dealing with scrupulosity and have a very long exhaustive list of possible mortal sins. If I were to go through and discern if each one was a mortal sin, that would take a really long time. Should I make a shorter list and confess those in order to take communion? 44:55 – Is there a good resource for keeping high school- and college-age adults engaged in the faith? 49:20 – If the male priesthood represents the maleness of Christ, why can men still be laity?
…
Questions Covered:
13:29 – Many speakers say that action or inaction of the parents are the cause of these feelings in their children. Do they ever tell the parents that they are the cause of this and the children are the victims? 13:20 – How do you help loved ones find their identity in Christ when they identify as “they” and have same-sex attraction without shoving it down their throat? 30:05 – Why didn’t you use the term “love” in your comments about parents speaking with their children? 31:57 – My son was dating a girl for many years who broke up with him and later said she is gay. Is there any way he could have known that sooner? And how do we interact with her parents? 37:35 – My 15 year old granddaughter wants to change her gender and says that she can’t keep being Catholic. What does the Church teach? 45:18 – What is a good approach to leading a parent who identifies as gay or bi back to Christ? My parents divorced and my mom “married” another woman. 50:01 – As an Eucharistic minister, am I encouraged or discouraged from giving Communion to someone I know is living an active gay lifestyle? 51:51 – My friend’s two children identify as gay and she assumed because I was Catholic that I would reject her and her children. How do I tell her I still want to be friends without accepting that they are right?
…
Questions Covered:
07:35 – If a woman is pregnant with an unrelated embryo (such as through IVF) and wants to abort it, how can I explain why that’s wrong? 19:47 – What is Trent’s opinion on using graphic abortion images during sidewalk counseling? 23:55 – What’s the Catholic Church’s stance on vaccines that use aborted fetuses in their development? 33:43 – Wouldn’t it be more persuasive for pro-lifers to use a consistent life ethic? 33:43 – Wouldn’t it be more persuasive for pro-lifers to use a consistent life ethic? 43:35 – How do you aid in healing a woman who’s already had an abortion and feels guilty? 48:00 – How do I answer someone who says a baby isn’t a human until it can live outside of the womb, no matter how much support it has outside?
Resources Mentioned: EWTN.com: Morality of Cooperation in Evil …
36:22 – How do we teach kids to desire the virtues? 52:45 – Is it possible to become overly obsessed with living virtuously?
…
20:10 – If I’m divorced, does that mean I am no longer chaste? 28:08 – Could you repeat your definitions of chastity and celibacy and elaborate on celibacy? 31:35 – How do we refrain from having sexual thoughts when we see others? 37:50 – What’s the best way to advise a teenage daughter who wants to begin dating? 44:10 – What is the Church’s stance on transgenderism? 49:50 – Where can I go to look for a good, holy, Catholic man? 52:35 – What’s the most compassionate yet efficient way to talk to non-Catholics who say “If you love that person, it’s alright” to engage in premarital sex?
…
03:25 – What’s the difference between a mystical union, a spiritual union, and a physical union? 08:35 – Was Padre Pio’s stigmata real? If it was, why was it on the palms and not the wrists? 14:32 – Should we expect our government to follow Christian values? 17:55 – Why do people think the Catholic Church withheld crucial books from the Bible? 30:10 – I’ve been an atheist my whole life. I’m now struggling with suicidal thoughts and I’m wondering if faith could do anything for me. 41:25 – What’s the difference between homosexual orientations and actions? 47:06 – Why did Christ descend into hell after the crucifixion? 51:12 – What is meant when the Bible says to fear the Lord?
…
02:32 – How seriously should we take people who claim to receive visions from God of the future? 10:57 – Who are some of the Protestants who claim that the word “imputed” was never mentioned by St. Paul when talking about Abraham’s faith? 16:15 – If you don’t complete your penance after confession, does that nullify your absolution? 19:39 – Do we have to obey our bishop’s vaccine madate? 23:56 – Is infant baptism biblical? 32:15 – Why are people certain that they know God exists or doesn’t exist when there’s not conclusive evidence for either side? 41:32 – How do I reconcile the non-stable, non-eternal nature of forms (like in evolution) with providence? 46:46 – How are both the Church and Mary our mother? 49:40 – Is “selling your soul to the devil” real?
…
2:31 – Who are the “sons of God” in Genesis 6? 06:17 – Isn’t it okay for us to be angry at God? He can handle it. And isn’t it wrong to say Jesus chooses hardship for us? That sounds Calvinist. 16:09 – When we go to heaven, will we have less knowledge of God than the angels, the same, or greater? 21:04 – How did we get from a God who visits punishment on us for four generations (in the Old Testament) to one who says we must forgive seventy times seven times? And how would I answer an atheist who says that makes God cruel? 30:17 – Why in the Church in America is there a tendency to question or criticize the Pope instead of trying to understand what he’s doing? (regarding motu proprio) 35:06 – Is there any evidence from the early Church Fathers of what happened to Nicodemus and Joseph of Arimathea? 40:21 – Do I have to agree with all of Catholic Social Teaching in order to become Catholic? 44:30 – Is the name “Jesus” synonymous with “Joshua”? 46:15 – Is it a sin for me to allow my family members to receive Communion when they shouldn’t? 48:13 – How much credibility should we give to the writings of saints and mystics, especially when talking to non-Catholics?
…
13:59 – What can we do day-to-day to encounter God’s love for us, especially when we’re experiencing difficulties? 20:23 – If we want to invite someone to Church or a Bible study, but they have a very shadowy past, where do we draw the line between being merciful and being cautious? 29:47 – What exactly does it mean to say God is love? Does it mean he doesn’t have a choice but to love us? That sounds kind of impersonal to me. 34:48 – How do I deal with imposter syndrome with Jesus? 41:57 – Did Jesus stop being love when he said “Father, father, why have you forsaken me?” 45:42 – How can I be like Harold (the first caller) and stop being so mad at Jesus for my suffering? 51:08 – I take communion to people in hospitals and nursing homes. How can I get more people to help with this?
…
Questions Covered:
01:02 – I have three arguments for why women should be allowed to be priests. 15:07 – What’s the scriptural and/or traditional basis for saying the fall of the angels took place before the fall of man? 21:46 – What is the connection between Christ’s ongoing intercession and the Eucharist? And if Christ’s intercession is reliant upon his sacrifice, doesn’t that hinder God’s omnipotence? 29:09 – Why would we choose wearing either a scapular or crucifix instead of the other? 35:14 – Do my wife and I have to wait to get our marriage convalidated before we try to conceive? 41:44 – What happens to Protestants who are in mortal sin but don’t have the sacrament of confession available to them? 47:50 – When we pray the Fatima prayer, do we really mean “Lead all souls to heaven” or just the elect? 51:15 – What happens to people who are ill and die without receiving last rites?
Resources Mentioned:
Edward Feser, How to Go to Hell Catholic Answers Focus: Is the Church Hiding the Book of Enoch?
…
04:41 – Why does Peter have such a strong reaction in Acts 10 against eating what is unclean when he heard things like the bread of life discourse? 08:54 – How does free will play into the story of the Fall of man? 16:05 – Is there any subtle mention of the Trinity in the Old Testament? 20:27 – What do these verses from Isaiah and James mean? 24:05 – How do I respond to the claim of limited atonement? 35:20 – Sometimes I feel like God has set us up to sin. We’re predisposed to sin, but God set us up that way. Why would he make us like that? 42:30 – Is it okay for me to attend my half-sister’s wedding after she’s left the faith? 47:36 – Is it okay for me to worship on my own instead of in a particular church? 53:03 – Is it okay to work at a place where you can reasonably suspect people go to commit sin?
…
Questions Covered:
05:00 – I’m an altar server. Should I bow with the priest during the consecration and rise after, or keep bowing? 13:50 – When Mary was made queen, did they actually see the coronation or was it a symbol? 18:05 – Why would God give Adam and Eve the temptation of the tree if he wanted them to go to Heaven? 21:29 – What does the Catechism mean when is says that the Eucharist preserves us from grave sins? 29:00 – Was the devil created by Jews in order to explain evil? 39:30 – Did Mary become more beautiful when she went to Heaven, or was she already as beautiful as she would be since she was without sin? 42:35 – What are some good arguments for Christianity that are not the trilemma or historical evidence? 47:40 – Why do we have to go to Heaven? 50:45 – If I pray the St. Therese novena will she give me a flower? 53:10 – Is it’s okay for girls to be altar servers?
…
Questions Covered:
15:29 – What was Mary called by those around her in her time? And if Mary never sinned, does that mean she always did everything right? 31:55 – Why do Catholics say that Mary is the Immaculate Conception? 42:10 – What is a dogma, and why is the birth of Mary not considered a dogma? 44:44 – Is there any Church tradition or Biblical title that first declared Mary as Undoer of Knots? 49:05 – If Mary was an immaculate conception, were her parents immaculately conceived too? How far back does it go?
…
03:09 – Did the Catholic Church recognize any of Luther’s 95 theses as legitimate, and did any of them actually help reform the Church? 08:20 – When are Catholics born again? 15:03 – Is prayer less efficacious if you’re in a state of mortal sin? 20:55 – Is using profanity a sin? If it is, how should we address the many Catholics who do it? 28:50 – What is the Leviathan in the book of Isaiah? 29:50 – If Christ is real, why have priests molested children? 44:40 – Is it morally okay for a librarian to check out and stock books of an immoral nature?
…
14:28 – The Catholic Encyclopedia says that the different lists of popes we have disagree with each other. Doesn’t that throw some doubt on papal succession? 42:42 – What level of respect do we owe to our bishops?
…
05:35 – How come whenever God addresses someone in the Bible, they always respond with “Here I am!” 11:19 – What is the soul? Do animals have souls? 16:06 – I have a friend who’s converting to Catholicism but he’s also attending meetings with the Freemasons. What should I do? 23:19 – Is it okay for me to wear my rosary around my neck? 29:55 – Why do Catholics say Mary didn’t sin when Romans 3:23 says all have sinned? 34:29 – Why can’t women become priests? 44:05 – What’s the differences between the Catholic Church and the Eastern Orthodox Church?
…
04:15 – If we know saints are in heaven, how do we know that people are in hell like Judas? 12:00 – Is there any reasonable compromise between new-earth belief and old-earth belief based on science? 18:45 – What’s the function of a diocese metropolitan? 21:28 – Does receiving the Eucharist remit venial sins? And what’s the difference between venial and mortal sins? 23:50 – During the Transfiguration, what were Jesus, Moses, and Elijah talking about? 25:02 – Since the Last Supper took place before the sacrifice on Calvary, was that Eucharist exactly the same as the one we receive now? 23:31 – Can you help me understand Judges 11:29-39 and why God seemed to accept the sacrifice of someone’s daughter? 33:42 – If people in hell can manifest themselves to living people like psychics or mystics, can people in heaven do the same? 41:00 – Why was the Mass done in Latin for so long when people didn’t understand Latin? 48:43 – What should we do if we have gone to a medium and followed their instructions?
…
02:12 – Why did Jesus ask “Who touched me” when the woman with the hemorrhage was cured? 07:17 – Are the little scroll in Ezekiel and the little book that John eats in Revelation the same? 16:42 – Does the book of Job show that we’re just pawns being played with by God and the devil? 28:45 – Can the resurrection of the dead mentioned by Matthew after the crucifixion be evidence for Mary’s Assumption? 33:00 – Why are the Jewish armies praying for the dead in 2 Maccabees? 38:58 – If Christ’s human knowledge was limited, how does that apply to his knowledge that the Samaritan woman had five husbands? 43:13 – Why did Jesus use Adam and Eve as an example of monogamous marriage when there’s evidence Adam had multiple wives? 48:20 – Why doesn’t John’s Gospel come first? It starts with “In the beginning,” and Luke would flow right into Acts.
…
07:30 – Are all big “T” Traditions found implicitly somewhere in Scripture? 15:03 – My atheist friend doesn’t think the Moses story is real. What can I say to him? 20:54 – Based on Romans 8, is it possible for someone to be justified and glorified if they’re not predestined? 28:54 – Are the parables of Lazarus and the unforgiving servant about purgatory? And how can I learn more about purgatory? 36:33 – Were Sts. Augustine and/or Jerome at the Council of Carthage? 42:32 – How do I reconcile 1 Jn. 3:8-9 with us being sons of God? 46:16 – In Mk 15:2, did Jesus admit he was King of the Jews? 49:30 – How do I respond to Protestants who say the Catholic Church is the beast in Revelation and the Pope is the antichrist? 51:12 – One of the common explanations for the “brothers” of Jesus is to say there’s no Aramaic word for “cousin.” However, in Luke, we read that Elizabeth is Mary’s cousin. Why do we have the word there but not in reference to Jesus’s brothers?
Resources mentioned: jimmyakin.com: “The Point of Lazarus and the Rich Man” https://jimmyakin.com/2019/11/the-point-of-lazarus-and-the-rich-man.html Jimmy Akin’s Mysterious World: “The Exodus! Did it Happen?” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oh1MAA_t6Ak …
05:16 – What kind of grace can we merit? 11:05 – What if there’s a better alternative to the COVID vaccine? Should we be using that instead? 18:02 – What is the Catholic view of substitutionary atonement? 22:47 – Does the Catholic Church support the decriminalization of drugs? 30:46 – My mother received last rites about six months before she died. How long do the effects of last rites last? Would she still benefit from them at death? 35:20 – Is it morally permissible for a Catholic to attend a non-Catholic wedding? 45:05 – Doesn’t Paul condemn fasting from certain foods in 1 Tim 4:3? 49:59 – Is there a way for me to still access the Eucharist if I reject one of the infallibly defined dogmas of the Catholic Church?
…
10:20 – What circumstances would compel God to give us a sign? What would a sign from God look like? 21:16 – How am I supposed to understand trust in the context of “Trust in the LORD with all your heart and lean not on your own understanding” (Prov. 3:5-6)? 28:59 – Are Seventh-Day Adventists’ baptisms valid? 33:44 – Why is it licit for priests’ retirement funds to be made by investing in morally problematic companies like Google and Amazon? 36:00 – What’s the best translation I should use for memorizing Scripture? 40:46 – In light of Cardinal Burke’s illness, what should we think of the COVID vaccine? Should we be more open to receiving the ones that are less morally problematic? 42:50 – How can I effectively witness to a former priest? Is it possible for him to be reinstated to the priesthood? 49:00 – I’m dealing with scrupulosity. Is it okay for me to make a provisional confession with the intent to confess the rest of my sins later?
…
Questions Covered:
18:22 – Where can I find more documentation on how kids should be baptized? 24:34 – Could the Greek word meaning “baptism” mean something else? 36:08 – I’m a Born-Again Christian. What does Jesus want for us regarding Baptism? 48:00 – Is it us saying “yes” that makes the Baptism valid, or something else?
…
Questions Covered:
05:53 – What is the process of annulment and how do these processes vary between dioceses? 22:22 – In the case where children are involved, should the parents seek the counsel of the priest who married them? 29:52 – If I was married in the Protestant Church, how is this considered valid by the Catholic Church? 36:10 – I am new to the Church, and I’m being told I need an annulment even though I was never married in the church. Why? 42:50 – If one member does not consent to annulment, what is the status of the marriage? 46:39 – My fiancé is trying to annul a marriage with someone who is mentally unstable and is trying not to involve her out of fear. Now, my diocese tells me this is unallowed. What should I do?
…
Questions Covered:
03:50 – How can the Church be pro-life if God commanded the Hebrew army to go on conquest? 16:15 – What is the difference between Mary’s Immaculate Conception and my own conception? 24:00 – What is the Catholic view of immigration? 42:29 – Which came first: the fall of angels or the creation of man? 48:30 – Is it reasonable to say that God created all things in 6 days?
…
Questions Covered:
02:25 – Is there a contradiction between Matthew 5:19 and 5:20? 06:55 – What is the Church’s teaching on tattoos? 14:30 – When Jesus was 12 in the Temple, why didn’t any of the teachers remember him 20 years later when his public ministry started? 17:22 – How does the contingency argument relate to the Big Bang? 22:32 – Can you explain relationships or the lack thereof in Heaven? 29:18 – Are the saints in Heaven aware of our sins? 35:40 – What is the Catholic basis, if any, for religious exemption from the COVID-19 vaccine? 43:53 – Are people in the state of mortal sin allowed to feel happy? 48:11 – Why do I offer up my suffering to God? 50:55 – How did the bishops expand from the 12 apostles?
Resources Mentioned:
CDF: Note on the morality of using some anti-Covid-19 vaccines
…
Questions Covered: 01:45- I suffer from scrupulosity. I tend to view God as a God who will send us to hell at the tiniest little mistake. How do I view God as a more loving and merciful God? Is it possible to go to hell if we are not sure if we committed a mortal sin or not? 07:30 – In a spiritual sense what is our life on earth compared to the spiritual life in Purgatory, Heaven and Hell? What is our role/purpose in living here first on earth? 13:24 – Can you explain the thought that Purgatory is a place to atone for our sins? This is what I was always taught. 20:34 – Can one pray to a deceased loved one without the knowledge that they are in Heaven? 24:49 – How do we know if we are in purgatory or hell if we are being tormented in both? If I am in purgatory and I think I am in hell and I start cursing God’s name for putting me in hell, is there a chance I can actually be cast into hell at this point 34:37 – Will a soul who has not followed the Christian life still have the opportunity to go to purgatory and Heaven? 42:25 – Does God still love the souls in Hell and the demons? 44:25 – Why do we believe that when we die we go to heaven and are not just asleep until Jesus comes again? Jesus says that Lazarus “is asleep” when he is dead so it seems as though we would all just be sleeping until Christ comes again 50:50 – When you go to Purgatory do you see other people in purgatory with you or those in Heaven, Angels, or even Jesus? …
Questions Covered: 16:00 – If the divine grace Christ merited can be “applied” at any point in time, why did the righteous have to wait in Abraham’s bosom? 19:12 – If it is taught that if you reach a certain level of charity, you can immediately go to heaven, but charity is solely to will the good the other, how does this other motive of getting to heaven not undercut what charity truly is? 25:06 – What is Limbo? Why was it removed? When did the doctrine of “universal salvation” emerge? 28:30 – Do we know what the sensation of purgatory is? Is it physically or spiritually painful? Will we be aware that we are in purgatory? 38:30 – My mom just passed away; we miss her. My dad asked that even though we know that she is happy in heaven, does she feel separation from us in the same way we feel separated from her? So, she wouldn’t be sad, but does she feel any lack like we feel without her? 46:43 – I just started reading “Purgatory is for Real” and I’m not clear on why if our sins are forgotten by God, why do we “dwell” on them in a sense, and why need purgatory at all? 2:32 – I suffer from scrupulosity. I tend to view God as a God who will send us to hell at the tiniest little mistake. How do I view God as a more loving and merciful God? Is it possible to go to hell if we are not sure if we committed a mortal sin or not? …
Questions Covered: 02:33 – I am evangelical and I have a question for Mr. Staples about apostolic succession. 15:46 – Ever since the Pope’s letter came out, I have been trying to find the “new” (Novus Ordo) mass in Latin, but I can’t find one. Why isn’t this form of the Mass being promulgated? 26:33 – I have a family member who does not believe in the divinity of Jesus because there is only one God. How do I answer him? 34:35 – I’m getting ready to start RCIA and I wanted to know what the Catholic Church teaches about “binding and loosing”. I also had my kids dedicated. I know it’s not the same as baptism, but does it hold any weight? 44:27 – Does Romans Ch. 7 negate mortal sin and turn it into venial sin? …
Questions Covered: 1:42 – Bishop Barron questions if anyone is in hell and he says there is no church teaching on who is in hell. Are there people in hell and can we know if there are? 11:48 – Can Tim help me formulate an answer to the pro-choice argument that pregnancy is extremely dangerous and so therefore abortion is okay? 23:29 – Why does the Pope come out with the Motu Proprio but not come down strongly on politicians who are pro-choice and still receive communion? 39:44 – Why should I be Catholic? 44:29 – How do I answer the claim that St. Augustine was a Calvinist made by my protestdent friends? 46:20 – I’m an orthodox Christian and I’m discerning marriage with a Roman Catholic girl. I really cherish the tradition we have of infant baptism, confirmation, and communion happening all at the same time. Why doesn’t the Roman Catholic church have this tradition? How can you claim the fullness of the faith without doing this? …
Questions Covered:
14:40 – How would I respond to a friend who keeps sinning and going to confession as a “ticket out” (and not stopping sinning)? 20:40 – What can you do about confession if you’re not yet a Catholic? 32:11 – A few times when I went to confession I forgot my penance. Is my confession valid? 36:35 – Why do we have to confess mortal sin and not venial? 42:00 – When did we start having private confessions? 48:19 – I had not gone to confession in over 40 years and went earlier this year. But then I remembered additional mortal sins after I had gone to confession. What do I need to do?
…
Questions Covered:
07:38 – When the ‘65 Mass and missal were around, did priests have the choice to celebrate 1) either all in Latin or with some vernacular, and 2) either facing East or not? 11:30 – How can parish priests evangelize to fallen-away Catholics? 16:12 – Will the Eucharist be in the New Earth? 19:05 – Is it morally acceptable for me to ask someone their gender if I already have a good idea what it is? 21:02 – I recently learned my marriage isn’t valid. Do I have to refrain from receiving Communion until it’s validated? 24:24 – Is the Catechism infallible? How should we use it as a source if it’s not? What exactly is theological opinion? 32:04 – What’s the latest Canon law thinking on the pope’s motu proprio? 34:10 – Is JPII’s Theology of the Body considered doctrine or just theological opinion? 45:20 – My church doesn’t kneel after the “Holy, holy, holy” in the Eucharistic prayer. We sit instead. Is this okay? 48:03 – How was it decided which specific saints are in the Eucharistic Prayer?
…
Weird Questions Covered:
01:29 – If a human is a rational animal (that’s to say that it has the natural tendency to grow, eat, feel, see, will, and reason) then would the consecrated Eucharist have these innate tendencies as well? Are there any conditions under which the Eucharist can do even one of those things mentioned, let alone all of them? 4:26 – By time traveling are you interfering with God’s plan? Even if we think we are stopping an evil act, God has his reasons. 06:22 – If you were to save someone in the past would that person in the new timeline have a different soul? They lived a longer lifetime and committed other acts either righteous or sinful. To me that would logically mean it’s not the same soul since we are judged by our one life. One version of the person could have gone to hell and other to heaven. 11:12 – Given the speed of light, is it possible that a person, right now, on a planet 2000 light years away and with a telescope so powerful that he could see onto the surface of the earth in great detail, could watch Jesus walking and teaching. 14:00 – Will every curiosity or question that I have in this life have an answer in heaven, or will the experience of sanctification or purgatory simply remove that curious or questioning spirit from me? 15:59 – What is your take on the floating log mat model for the origin of coal beds and biogeography? As both a coal miner and a Catholic, I am interested in the theory that the great flood caused a mass (or masses) of fallen logs to float about the world, but I have a hard time making the leap that this proves a young earth and our previous theories for the formation of coal seams taken millions of years are no longer valid. On a related note, is the story of the great flood required to be taken literally, or could it have been a regional flood that wiped out the human population but maybe did not cover the entire earth? 19:49 – I became Catholic, I enjoyed those shows on Travel Channel like Ghost Adventures, where these paranormal investigators would lock themselves in a “haunted” place and try to capture evidence of the paranormal through EVP [that is, Electronic Voice Phenomena] sessions and whatnot. I don’t necessarily believe it was all real (or all fake for that matter either) and I’m a fairly educated individual and understand the behavioral psychology of “hearing voices” through EVP and, as such, am highly skeptical. HOWEVER, these shows are very entertaining, and I have to admit, I enjoy them, for entertainment. As a Catholic, is it a sin to watch these shows for entertainment? I would never even think of doing it myself or even put any stock in what they do. I know we are forbidden from attempting to contact the dead, but is watching these shows for entertainment, per se, sinful? I can’t find anything definitive about it. 36:24 – Let’s say, in an alternate timeline, the Left Behind fictional series, centered around the end of the world and the 2nd coming of Christ, was authored by faithful Catholics. In order to keep the series in line with Church teaching, what events would need to be included, what events would need to be omitted, and what events may or may not be included as they are subject to theological speculation? 42:21 – Suppose someone became an undead vampire. Yet, they still have a moral conscience and know right from wrong. The Church also teaches that suicide is a mortal sin. Would it be a sin for such a person to commit suicide in order to protect others from becoming a vampire? 51:05 – How would you reconcile Earth’s liturgical calendar with planets that have longer or shorter solar years? Can you have Easter twice in one year? Could you have a year without Christmas?
…
Questions Covered: 06:31 – Is there a specific thank you prayer to say to the Lord when he answers your prayers other than just saying “thank you”? 11:50 – What does Jesus mean in Matt 23:3 by “call no man father”? Don’t we call priests “father”? 10:05 – Is the ancient practice in Leviticus of the priests offering grain to God by raising and waving it high in the air the origin of why the priest lifts the Host during the Consecration? 20:28 – I know that the saint statues in my house are not God, but what led the ancient Israelites to believe that the statues they made (the golden calf for example) were actually God? Why did they worship/believe that their idols were God? 23:35 – I’m a revert to Catholicism and I don’t understand why the Church makes you get married in the Church. The Church will accept baptism from other churches, why don’t they accept marriages from other churches? 35:50 – I don’t understand why God allowed men in the OT to have multiple wives and now is against that. If God is an unchanging God, why did He “change His mind” on this? 47:53 – How does Mary reconcile with Romans 3:23 and doesn’t this contradict the Immaculate Conception? …
Questions Covered:
19:35 – How do we reconcile the perpetual virginity of Mary with Mt. 1:18 and 1:25? 35:15 – Why don’t Catholics believe in sola scriptura? 45:45 – How is it fair that Adam and Eve and Mary were exempt from original sin but no one else is?
…
Questions Covered:
09:30 – Do Jews think the Son of Man in Daniel is also the Messiah? 18:41 – Are we supposed to treat the Eucharist as a spiritual booster shot or as something more? 34:17 – If God’s omnipotence means he can only do things that are logically possible, then which came first: logical truth, or God? 44:11 – How can I respond to the dispensationalist claim that Paul’s letters are only directed to the Gentiles, and everything else is for the Jews? (“Rightly dividing the Word”)
…
05:35 – Why do different translations of certain Old Testament books seem to have larger wholesale differences between them than in the New Testament? 16:00 – What is the Church’s stance on secular democracies and the relationship between Church and state? 22:23 – Why will God come back? 33:13 – What magisterial documents can I read that talk about substance and accidents in the Eucharist? 42:27 – How can I talk to a loved one who has joined the Jehovah’s Witnesses? 48:50 – Can you clarify “Anihu” and “Yahweh”? Are they the same?
…
08:55 – What did the Church Fathers say about perfectionism (the idea that we can be perfect in this life)? 15:20 – My friend is completely against the death penalty and all wars because he says they don’t give someone the chance to repent. But couldn’t God see into the future and see whether someone would repent or convert if given the chance? 30:10 – Is it acceptable to use a Greek Orthodox prayer book? 34:45 – Do we eat the accidents of Christ in the Eucharist? If not, what do we make of Eucharistic miracles? 52:30 – What’s the difference between the free will of 1) Lucifer, Adam and Eve, 2) the Virgin Mary, and 3) everyone else in heaven?
…
06:54 – What was the process of determining the canon of Scripture? 21:00 – What’s the difference between communion in Catholicism and Protestantism? 31:57 – Can you discuss the disagreement between Catholics and Orthodox over the Immaculate Conception? 42:20 – Are organ transplants acceptable in the Catholic Church? 51:55 – What’s the history of the phrase “call upon the name of the Lord?”
…
06:27 – Can you explain Tertullian’s comment that “The soul is naturally Christian”? 10:25 – What’s the biblical basis for the prayer of oblation? 24:20 – Were the children of Sodom considered innocent? Why would God destroy the city if they were? 38:06 – Are the “sons of Heaven” in Gen. 6:2 angels? 50:08 – If I have to receive absolution from a priest, does this mean Jesus didn’t pay the price for sin on the cross?
…
Questions Covered:
05:35 – In the Old Testament why did God kill people? 12:56 – My brother thinks that the bible was changed through the years and so it is not trustworthy. How do I answer his claim? 18:13 – When defending the Faith, how does one answer the accusation that you are “playing with words”? 22:34 – Did the Catholic Church forbid the reading of the bible ever? 29:00 – How to respond to someone who says that the Church is anti-Semitic? 43:23 – What does Trent think about the verse where Jesus tells the apostles to go preach to the cities but that they won’t get to all of them before he returns? 49:23 – How can the Catholic Church truly be Catholic if it is fundamentally Latin?
…
Questions Covered:
05:35 – In the Old Testament why did God kill people? 12:56 – My brother thinks that the bible was changed through the years and so it is not trustworthy. How do I answer his claim? 18:13 – When defending the Faith, how does one answer the accusation that you are “playing with words”? 22:34 – Did the Catholic Church forbid the reading of the bible ever? 29:00 – How to respond to someone who says that the Church is anti-Semitic? 43:23 – What does Trent think about the verse where Jesus tells the apostles to go preach to the cities but that they won’t get to all of them before he returns? 49:23 – How can the Catholic Church truly be Catholic if it is fundamentally latin?
…
01:20 – What does it mean to say that blasphemy against the Holy Spirit is unforgivable? 03:40 – In light of the motu proprio, why is the Latin Mass bad? 06:51 – How do I respond to the charge that the papacy has inherited its powers and office from the Roman emperor? 13:35 – I don’t understand the difference between the extraordinary and ordinary forms of Mass. 17:10 – What is the oldest religion? 22:15 – Do atheists have a guardian angel? 24:07 – What were the true origins of the Protestant Reformation? 32:42 – If angels don’t have free will, how did Lucifer and ⅓ of the angels rebel against God? 41:17 – Is anything linked to the number 666 considered evil, or are there other conditions that have to be met also? 46:53 – How do I talk to a friend who is cohabiting with someone and has a child with them, but doesn’t see the need to get married? 50:10 – Is Mary Magdalene the same Mary who’s the sister of Martha and Lazarus?
…
03:13 – What is the Catholic view on the nature of reality? 10:38 – Sometimes when the Bible speaks about the end times, it describes great disasters and apocalyptic events. However, Jesus also says he’ll come like a thief in the night. How do we reconcile these? 16:53 – If God has no potential, how do we explain Mt. 19:26 and Mk. 14:36? 19:05 – Where were Lazarus’s sisters when he was suffering and dying? Why weren’t they helping him? 29:00 – Can you tell me about the priestly lines of Aaron, David, and Melchizedek, how they are connected with the Priesthoods of Noah and Adam, which was the line(s) of Jesus, which lines are today’s Catholic priests, and if there are any other priestly lines? 36:45 – Since the Last Supper took place during the passover meal, what would it have looked like from a cultural standpoint when Jesus instituted the Eucharist in the middle of the meal? 42:18 – Do Protestants go to purgatory even though they don’t believe in it? 43:45 – Why can’t we repent after death? 48:50 – Why does Jesus say heaven and earth will pass away when heaven is infinite?
…
Questions Covered:
11:00 – What is baptism in the Holy Spirit? Is this different from baptism with water? Is it legitimate? 17:15 – Where is the biblical evidence for baptism for infants? John only baptized adults. 23:00 – Can lay people baptize in an emergency? And if so, can the person who was baptized be re-baptized later on? 31:10 – I have a 9 mo. old grandson and I’m trying to get him baptized and I’m wondering if I can baptize him in a protestant church and still raise him Catholic? 36:36 – I would like the Catholic understanding of original sin vs. the protestant understanding of original sin in relation to baptism. 46:42 – Some of my grand-children are not baptized and I’m very worried and I’m wondering how I can encourage them to get baptized? 52:24 – What is baptism of desire? I had a granddaughter born 2 weeks ago who needed open heart surgery and her parents refused to baptize her.
…
Questions Covered:
02:15 – What is the Church’s position on speaking in tongues? 07:17 – Is the description of the appearance of angels symbolic for their glory? 16:31 – How do I convince my friend of the perpetual virginity of Mary? 28:39 – Would it be prudent to have a wedding reception at a masonic (as in Free Masons) center? 31:55 – Why didn’t we just keep using Latin in the Mass and just teach people Latin so that we really would be one united church, united under one language? 43:39 – I want to give Cy and Tim a compliment. A general question about king David. 48:27 – Can second cousins marry? 50:46 – I am new to Christianity and I am wondering where Judas Iscariot is right now?
…
Questions Covered:
29:08 – What does the Motu Proprio mean by “parochial parish”? 32:15 – A lot of commentaries jump around the issue of the Motu Proprio, that is, that Pope Francis wants to end the Latin Mass. I would like to get the bishop’s response to this. 35:48 – Can the bishop comment on the survey referred to in the Motu Proprio? 37:47 – Does the Motu Proprio reject documents of Vatican 2? It seems like it negates some of what the 2nd Vatican council tried to implement. 37:47 – Does the Motu Proprio reject the documents of Vatican 2? It seems like it negates some of what the 2nd Vatican council tried to implement. 40:36 – I’m 78 years old and I remember the drastic changes of Vatican 2 and I have seen the effect it has had on the church. I’m hoping that they can go back and change some of the decisions made in Vatican 2. I wish more people who were actually around during Vatican 2 would discuss it more! 47:05 – I detest the 2012 English missal translation. Why did they change the 1972-1974 missal?
Resources Mentioned:
Mass Exodus: Catholic Disaffiliation in Britain and America since Vatican II, by Stephen Bullivant
…
Questions Covered:
09:17 – Did God create light millions of years ago? With the speed of light from stars, how do we understand the age of the earth?
16:07 – Is it okay that I believe in flat earth and the firmament if I am currently studying to be a Catholic?
30:32 – I’ve been told that non-Catholics are not allowed to receive the Eucharist. I am also told that Catholics cannot go receive communion in other churches. Is this true?
38:25 – A Protestant told me that the early Church was not Catholic, and that St. Athanasius was a born-again Christian, not baptized. Is that true?
44:50 – Do Catholics believe that Jesus died for our sins and we are saved by grace or do you believe his sacrifice was not enough, so people have to go to purgatory?
Resources Mentioned:
JAMW Ep. 68
A Daily Defense
The Father’s Know Best
The Apostasy That Wasn’t
…
Why do Catholics believe what they do?
Questions Covered:
12:28 – Why did Jesus still have his wounds on his glorified body? Is it like that in heaven?
19:55 – Why do Catholics kneel and stand and sit during the liturgy?
23:24 – Why do we pray for the saints to intercede for us? Wouldn’t that cause sadness for the saints in heaven?
29:09 – Why do we pray for the saints to intercede for us? Wouldn’t that cause sadness for the saints in heaven?
33:40 – What is ordinary time in the liturgical calendar versus the other times of the year?
37:03 – There are books in Catholic bibles that are not in Protestant bibles. Why is that?
46:20 – Why do Catholics believe that you cannot use birth control?
Resources Mentioned:
Why Catholic Bibles Are Bigger by Gary Michuta
Bringing Sanity Back to Sex Part 1 and 2
How Contraception Thwarts Love
…
Questions Covered:
04:19 – Why did God make the devil?
06:03 – Canon 29 forbids on the Sabbath and Judaizing at the Council of Laodicea. What does that mean? Why?
11:06 – How did Hildegard become doctor of the Church?
13:05 – Is the Septuagint older than the Maccabees?
16:50 – Why didn’t the Pharisees believe Jesus after he did all his miraculous signs and why did they hate him?
20:14 – Is there a non-literal way to interpret the story of Abraham sacrificing Isaac in Genesis 22?
30:09 – I have a new Jehovah’s Witness friend. He says the soul dies with the body. How can I respond to this?
35:00 – Why did we go from the word “cup” to “chalice” in the liturgy?
37:43 – What does Jesus mean when he says, “Give to God what is God’s, and give to Caesar what is Caesar’s”?
42:55 – We know that Mary is the only human to have ever lived without sin, but do we have any evidence of St. Joseph sinning? Could he have been sinless as well?
46:00 – I have heard a lot of complaints that the Church is just oppressive and doesn’t allow individual freedom. How can I respond to that?
50:54 – What is God really saying in Revelation 18:4-5?
Resources Mentioned:
A Daily Defense
Hunting the Whore of Babylon by Jimmy Akin
…
Transgenderism is a growing concern for the Church as more and more parents and kids are convinced to take part in gender treatments from a young age. Mary Rice Hasson talks about the danger of accepting gender dysphoria as healthy and provides practical support for how to combat this dysphoria.
Questions Covered:
23:38 – How should Christians respond to the claim that “gender is a social construct”?
35:13 – Why is it such a big deal if someone lives their life as they see fit? Being so anti-LGBTQ is turning people away from Jesus. Why do you have to say you’re right and they’re wrong?
44:04 – My child is 17, almost 18. She has autism and she mirrors behavior. She now believes that she is a male trapped in a female body. She has had hospitalizations and the staff has completely supported her by changing her name in her chart and refusing to refer to her by her name. How can I navigate this? How can I protect my daughter from the medical staff?
Resources Mentioned:
Personandidentity.com
Irreversible Damage by Abigail Shrier
Parents of ROGD Kids
…
What are the differences between Protestant and Catholic belief? Karlo Broussard responds to common Protestant challenges.
Questions Covered:
14:39 – How do you counter when a Protestant says that John 6 is just analogy or metaphor? They say, that sounds like cannibalism, that’s crazy.
22:03 – How can we respond to Protestants about Jesus having “brothers” and Mary being a perpetual virgin? Why do we pray to saints and not go straight to God?
33:25 – On Catholic radio, I have heard a lot about where people go after they die: heaven, hell, Sheol, and purgatory. In Scripture, it seems to me to be more clear cut: heaven or hell. How do you respond to this? And what is the second death?
39:42 – I am married to a Protestant woman. She won’t go to Mass with me because she can’t receive the Eucharist. How can I talk with her about this?
44:20 – My husband says that because Catholics believe that the Eucharist is the body and blood of Christ, we are sacrificing him again and again. How do I respond?
49:25 – If Christ’s atonement was for all people, then why do people still go to hell?
…