The Unusual Suspects
Tara & Josh
We’re just two odd balls trying to suck you into our little orbit of unsavory dinner party topics ☠️🤣 We’re the weirdos your moms warned you about 👻
Podcasts Similar to The Unusual Suspects
Those Who Watches the Night (96.29%)
Those Who Watches the Night
The Eerie Touch (95.75%)
The Eerie Touch
Hellbound (94.75%)
Lara Whitley
Killin Missin Hidden (94.25%)
Brad. Just Brad.
Weeknight Mysteries (94.23%)
Weeknight Mysteries
Serial Sisters (93.83%)
Burns Bureau
Murder, She Cried (93.69%)
Paradeim
Murders, Mysteries, and Mimosas's podcast (93.63%)
Murders, Mysteries, and Mimosas
Willows and the Weird (93.28%)
Jillian Willow / Debra Willow
Murders, Mysteries & Mayhem (93.16%)
Murders, Mysteries & Mayhem
Every Town (92.98%)
Every Town
The Darker Side of Life Podcast (92.63%)
Kristen & Dana
Cults, Conspiracies, and Other Creepies (92.41%)
Jasmine Jones and Haley Meisen
International Unsub (92.38%)
Ethan Cheng-Luong
Mythical True Crime (92.31%)
DJ
Two Drink Mysteries (92.26%)
Mary & Patti
iMurder (92.14%)
Joselyn Martinez
The Pretty Weird Podcast (91.99%)
Tatum Peggy Harris
True Crime + Toni Time (91.95%)
True Crime + Toni Time
Red String Society (91.92%)
Red String Society
Cult Stuff and Chill (91.79%)
Cult Stuff and Chill
Murderology (91.69%)
Rachel Abbott
Southern Grimoire (91.62%)
KD 'Bugsy' Burr
Fineapple Express (91.62%)
lulu moli
Case Files with Kat and Ashley (91.43%)
Case Files with Kat and Ashley
History mysteries (91.43%)
Lily Brown
Castles & Cryptids (91.35%)
Alanna and Kelsey
3 AM Mystery Club (91.32%)
3 AM Mystery Club
Haunted Family Podcast (91.32%)
Holly and Heather
Coffee, Curiosity and Moi with Nands (91.25%)
Moi
The murderandmystery‘s Podcast (91.25%)
Uniquely Twisted Productions
Mesmurder (91.25%)
S.H.
Real Weirdness - Histories, mysteries, humor and haunts... with just a dash of crime. (91.21%)
Miranda, Augie and Pam
Morbid Curiosity: A True Crime Podcast (91.16%)
Nichole
Crimes, Creeps, & Comedy (91.06%)
Conor McIntyre
Dark Vandalia - True Crime, Folklore and Paranormal (91.02%)
darkvandalia
Bitchcraft Podcast (90.96%)
None
FPI UNSOLVED (90.96%)
FPI UNSOLVED
Spotlight on Darkcast (90.94%)
Beyond The Rainbow
Scary Mysteries (90.69%)
Scary Mysteries
Murders in Paradise (90.64%)
Mysteries in Paradise
The Vortex (90.54%)
The Vortex
Unsolved Mysteries (90.52%)
Alissa
Good Nightmare (90.51%)
Sarah
Macabre Ramblings (90.5%)
Rui
Deadly Secrets: The Lawson Family Murder (90.49%)
FOX8 WGHP-TV
Myths, Magic and Murder (90.46%)
Abbie & Katherine
Two Weirdos One Podcast (90.36%)
Megan Taylor / Ashley Kovacic
True Crimes and Weird Times (90.31%)
Ashley & Kim
Murder Mystery (90.27%)
Vitoria
Missing Pieces (90.27%)
Mackenzie Crookes and Natasha Bennett
Truly, Darkly, Creeply (90.27%)
Truly, Darkly, Creeply
The Grimm Mystics (90.25%)
Amber Scribbick & Lesley Gregg
Pajama Crimes (90.17%)
Kristen
the teenage sleuthes (90.13%)
the teenage sleuthes
Clandestine Podcast (89.99%)
Clandestine Podcast
Camp Final Girls (89.97%)
Chelsea Warner, Alicia Padilla
Some Kind of Moment (89.89%)
Athoug, Adwa and Shahla
Far Side Chats (89.8%)
Far Side Chats
Ghost Town: Strange History, True Crime, & the Paranormal (89.61%)
Jason Horton & Rebecca Leib and Studio71
True Crime, NC (89.61%)
FOX8 WGHP-TV
The Spook Cast (89.39%)
Laney & Chris
Evidence of Monsters: True Crime (89.35%)
Evidence of Monsters
Murder Mystery Shack (89.29%)
Murder mystery Shack
Broken Coast Audio Co (89.27%)
Ryan
The Truth Inside (89.16%)
Lauren
The Metaphysician’s Electronic Journal (89.14%)
The Metaphysician
Who Drank The Kool-Aid? (89.14%)
Who Drank The Kool-Aid?
Shoes Boos and Tattoos (89.14%)
Shoes Boos and Tattoos Podcast
Mysterious Occurrences (89.09%)
Melanie
MURDER! MYSTERY! MONDAY ...but it's Sunday (89.09%)
Jonathan Ferreira
I Felt Evil (89.05%)
118th Studios
Washed Away (89.01%)
Cosmic Bigfoot
The Prosecutors (88.98%)
PodcastOne
This One's A Doozy (88.92%)
Funner House Publishing
Creepy Bastard (88.91%)
Creepy Bastard
Murder, Mischief & Moscato (88.91%)
Murder, Mischief & Moscato
Mature Audiences Only (88.9%)
Kimberly Nice
Mysteriously Listed True Crime (88.88%)
Casa Muretito Productions
B’s Corner (88.78%)
b
Out Of Time (88.78%)
Out of Time
The Disappearance of Olivia Perry (88.72%)
Jeffrey Ashkin
Porch Sittin’: A True Crime Podcast (88.66%)
Ashley Brewer
Me, Myself & Mysteries (88.6%)
Hayley Hilleshiem
Darkest Mysteries from Reddit 2022 - Best Reddit Stories Podcast 2022 (88.58%)
Darkest Mysteries from Reddit
Truly Chilling (88.57%)
Jamie Mitchell
Is Anybody Out There? (88.56%)
rsophie865
DRAGONFLY: Brett Cantor Murder Mystery (88.53%)
Death by Misadventure: True Crime Paranormal
The Crimes We’re Into : a true crime podcast (88.53%)
Leslie and Tamara
M: Myths & Monsters (88.53%)
M the Podcast
BcuzImJohn (88.5%)
John
True Crime Podcast 2024 - Police Interrogations, 911 Calls and True Police Stories Podcast (88.49%)
True Crime Podcast 2022
Cold Claws & Crime (88.33%)
The Millennial True Crime Podcast
The Devil's Margarita (88.27%)
Devils Margarita
Corpus Delicti (88.25%)
CDM Productions
Sister Sanatorium (88.22%)
Sister Sanatorium
Southern Woke (88.2%)
Kalan & Marena
Murder Vibes: A True Crime Podcast (88.17%)
MV Podcast
Spooky and the Skeptic (88.16%)
Kalee
Detective Writer (88.14%)
Sally