Tenesha McGuire invites her great-grandmother to join an excursion to London’s Imperial War Museum. Tenesha, a chaperone for some high school students on their senior trip, wants her great-grandmother to tell them the fascinating stories of the London Blitz.
But her great-grandmother won’t accompany her—too many bad memories. Memories that surprise Tenesha. Memories that will help her create a few of her own.
“The Blitz Experience” is free on this website for one week only. The story is also available in the Fantasy Bundle of Bundles Storybundle, in the volume Faerie Justice Bundle: A Storybundle Special Edition, which combines all of the Faerie Justice stories and short novels so far. You will also get with other bundle of bundles from fourteen different authors. Lots and lots of reading there. You’ll get 47 ebooks for about $2 per book. Or, if you’re feeling minimalist, you can get your own standalone copy of the story at any retailer or pick up a copy here. Enjoy!
The Blitz ExperienceKristine Kathryn RuschTenesha McGuire towers over her great-grandmother Littleton. Tenesha’s great-grandmother, whom she has called Grand since childhood, used to be the tall one. In fact, Tenesha can’t quite believe that the short but sturdy woman before her is Grand. They haven’t seen each other since Tenesha graduated from high school—and that is six years now—but still, no one should change quite that much.
They stand awkwardly in the living room of Grand’s house. The living room, at least, hasn’t changed. It’s narrow, with a small fireplace and furniture littered with handmade quilts and pillows. The end tables are the same—square spindly things that her great-grandfather had made as a young man—covered with a sheet of glass so that no one can ruin the surface.
This living room was always a place of excitement for Tenesha. Here, she first imagined World War II—practically seeing how suffering Londoners survived. She heard tales of kings from Henry the Eighth to the Edward the Eighth, who married an American divorcee and stepped down. History came alive here, and Tenesha still loves this living room—small as it now seems—for giving her that gift.
The living room smells of tea, old socks, and some kind of ointment, just like it always has. The only difference now is a flat-screen television in place of the old console model that once stood in front of the picture window.
“Come along,” Grand says. Her voice is the same. Strong and veddy veddy British—not quite the posh, clipped tones of the Queen, but reflecting a strong upper-class education. “Let’s have some tea.”
She meant the mid-afternoon meal that the British insist upon. Tenesha has never understood how the British have managed to keep their figures while eating four meals per day, one of them mostly made up of baked goods and sweets. Americans have gone to fat, all except a diligent few like her, and they don’t have as many scheduled mealtimes.
Even though she lived in London from the ages of six to eight, England seems foreign to her. She isn’t sure why. She also spent summers here until she graduated from high school. But each June when she arrived, she had to reacclimatize herself to all the little differences.
At least this time, she doesn’t have to deal with Grand’s neighbors. They always tut-tut when they see her, as if they can’t believe she and Grand are related. Tenesha looks like a lighter version of her father. She has his brown eyes and curly brown hair, but her skin isn’t conventionally white or black. Grand’s neighbors would often ask Tenesha if she was Greek or Italian. She would answer that she was American, which irritated Grand.
You must never forget who your people are, Grand would say. You come from good British stock.
And good American stock. Her father was born in Chicago, and still lived there, loving its blunt sameness. He rarely came to England with the family, preferring to stay in Chicago.
Grand has papery white skin, so pale that her veins show bluely through it. Her eyes are, even now, a vivid blue, and she has the Kewpie doll lips so in vogue when she was a girl.
Tenesha and Grand look nothing alike, but Grand has always insisted that the only person in the family who takes after her is Tenesha.
No one—not even Tenesha—can see the connection. But it still pleases her whenever Grand says it.
Grand hasn’t said it this visit. Not that they have had much time. Tenesha is on a strict schedule. For the first time, she’s acting as a chaperon. She agreed to help her best friend, Kara Edwards, with a class of high school students on their senior class trip.
Tenesha hadn’t thought it would be so much work. This is the first afternoon Tenesha has to herself. Grand knew she was coming and also knew they wouldn’t have a lot of time together, and Grand says she’s all right with that.
Tenesha isn’t. Money is tight. She expected that. She majored in history, and as her advisor said, no one majors in history and expects to be suitably employed upon graduation—even if they graduated magna cum laude, like she did.
Tenesha did manage to find work as a researcher for a well-known historian, on the very campus that she had just graduated from. But the job barely covers her bills—which includes the minimum payments on the $100,000 in student loans. That kind of money would make Grand gasp.
“Life is all the education I ever needed,” Grand used to say. Then her eyes would twinkle. “But the world was different back then.”
Tenesha slips into the kitchen, with its dowdy cabinets and dull white appliances. Grand is pouring hot water from a kettle that she has used all of Tenesha’s life. The teapot Grand is pouring the water into, however, looks new.
Grand’s hands, gnarled with age and arthritis, don’t shake. Her back is straight—something rare in a ninety-year-old woman. She sets the pot in the middle of the table, then sets biscuits and teacakes on plates nearby. She places a matching plate in front of Tenesha’s seat, the one that’s been hers all her life, and sits across from her, in front of the window overlooking Grand’s backyard.
This is what Tenesha wishes she could show the students. Not the changing of the guard or the Tate Modern. This small house, with its two gardens—the welcoming flower garden out front and the nourishing vegetable garden in the back. The heirloom tea set that Grand hauls out every afternoon, whether she has guests or not, a tea set that, Grand says, miraculously survived the Blitz.
Tenesha has heard the Blitz stories—hiding in shelters, the blackouts, and the god-awful rationing. When Tenesha was young and a plane flew over, Grand always grabbed her arm and looked up, as if she were prepared to drag them both to safety.
“It can’t be fun,” Grand is saying, “shepherding children over hill and dale.”
“High school students, Grand,” Tenesha says. “Teenagers.”
“Oh, dear,” Grand says as she pours. She goes through the entire ritual, offering milk and sugars, then shoves the plate of biscuits forward. Tenesha takes two of her favorites, with a chocolate layer in the center. “You must be having some fun on this trip.”
“I am,” Tenesha says. “I’m seeing things I probably should have seen when I was a kid.”
Grand’s lips purse and Tenesha realizes that Grand took that last comment as a criticism.
“I’m doing all the touristy things,” Tenesha says to cover over the awkwardness. “You know, Buckingham Palace, and the Houses of Parliament and Big Ben, and all that.”
Grand’s smile returns. She clearly remembers Tenesha asking to go to the Tower of London every year, and Grand’s response: No family member of mine is going to the Tower ever again.
“You know,” she says to Grand now, “Maybe you should come with us tomorrow. We’re heading to that war museum in Lambeth. The kids have studied World War II from the British point of view, and they’re actually looking forward to it. They would love to hear from someone who lived through it.”
Grand takes a cookie and sets it on her plate. The movement seems deliberate, polite, as if she’s using it as cover to give her time to think.
“There are volunteers who do that,” she says finally.
“Yes, but they’re not my Grand,” Tenesha says. “The kids’ll see them as some kind of lecturer. You’ll be the real thing, someone who can remember it all.”
Grand taps a biscuit against the plate, a habit that Tenesha has forgotten, but now, as she sees it, seems old as time. Grand is knocking the crumbs aside.
“No one remembers it all,” Grand says.
“You know what I mean, Grand,” Tenesha says. “You’ll tell them things they can’t get from a textbook.”
“I haven’t ever visited the Museum,” Grand says.
Tenesha is about to say, Well then, maybe you should, when Grand continues.
“I lived through that. Musty relics simply can’t tell the tale, not well enough for me, anyway.”
“But the museum isn’t for you,” Tenesha says. “It’s for me and those kids, so we understand what you went through.”
Grand raises her head. Her eyes seem brighter than usual. “You can’t know. Not unless you go through something like that yourself. And I fervently wish each and every day that no one I love will ever experience anything approaching those years. Although one can’t control history, now can one?”
“No,” Tenesha says. Her face heats. “I’m sorry, Grand. I didn’t realize—”
“How could you, child?” Grand says. “It’s my past, not yours. You’re building a new past, all your own. Speaking of which, I have something for you.”
She puts both hands on the table and levers herself upward. That movement is new, and is the only sign besides the loss of height and the wispy hair that Grand has begun her tenth decade on this Earth.
Tenesha stands up, but Grand waves a hand at her.
“Sit, sit. I won’t be but a moment.”
So Tenesha sits back down. She takes a bite of her own biscuit. Biscuits here are sweet—cookies, in American terminology, although no one in the States makes cookies like this. Even the chocolate tastes different. Richer, sweeter, darker. She’s missed these, just like she’s missed Grand.
Grand comes back, her right hand clenched into a fist. She opens it and shakes it ever so slightly, and a tiny gold cross on a matching gold chain hangs between her index and middle fingers.
“I’ve been saving it for you,” Grand says.
Tenesha isn’t sure how to respond. She’s never been religious. No one in the family is. Not even Grand. In fact, Grand only goes to church once a year, on Battle of Britain Sunday.
The cross shines with its own internal light. It has cuts along the center that look like small leaves. They glow redly in the sunlight filtering in from the window.
“It’s lovely,” Tenesha says, cupping the cross in her own hand. And it is. It’s also heavier than she expected, as if it’s made of real gold.
“We chose it when you were very little. Do you remember?”
Tenesha felt a glimmer of a memory. Adults everywhere, peering down at her. Crosses hanging from necklace trees. She pointed to one, but Grand grabbed her hand before she could touch it.
“I think so,” Tenesha says.
“I’m sure you do,” Grand says. “I remember getting mine.”
She pulls a larger, ornate cross from inside her blouse. This cross looks ancient. It’s slightly warped, and reminds Tenesha of nothing more than the Crown Jewels she saw the day before.
“I’ve never seen you wear that,” Tenesha says.
“I never take it off. But I don’t display it either, unless I need to.”
“Why would you need to?” Tenesha asks.
“I hope you never find out, child.” Grand goes behind Tenesha and attaches the thin chain of the small cross around Tenesha’s neck.
Tenesha clasps the cross in her right hand. The metal is warm against her skin. “If we picked this out so long ago, why are you giving it to me now?”
“Because you’ll need it,” Grand says.
“For what?” Tenesha asks.
“Those awkward little life lessons,” Grand says with her puckish grin. “The kind from which the most powerful memories are made.”
Rupert Lowe has always been ambivalent about his job at the museum. He has never seen himself as a museum sort of bloke. And he’s not that fond of the museum itself. Not the displays, but the actual building.
It’s old and large, made of stone, and once served as a hospital for the insane. While it looks very different than it had in its hospital days, it still makes Rupert think of an institution.
He tries not to think of this as he goes to work every day, but he has more difficulty controlling his thoughts on Sundays.
That’s partly due to his Sunday assignments. Rupert was hired as an all-around employee, filling in the gaps, helping where needed. Usually that means taking coats or carrying displays, moving tables, or helping young children find the loo.
That’s his job.
Except on Sundays. On Sundays, he begins the day at the Reception and Enquiries Desk and must respond with professional courtesy as people ask him all manner of silly and repetitive questions. Public interaction is not a personal strength, as his bosses well know, and so they try to use him in other capacities, but in these days of uncertainty, a man simply can’t say that he isn’t suited to the task at hand.
Rupert got his job because his uncle Clyde believed that Rupert needed some toughening up. Uncle Clyde had served in the many military actions that followed the Second World War, including the Iraq mistake that bloody bastard Blair had blundered into.
Uncle Clyde believed in King and Country. He never voted for Blair or the mealy-mouthed Gordon Brown, but he didn’t like Rupert’s opinion on them either. They’re our leaders, lad, Clyde would say. Best you listen up and follow orders.
Rupert was never very good at following orders, but he does attempt it here, even on the Reception and Enquiries desk. He doesn’t smile at the families coming in but he doesn’t tell them they’re daft, either, when they bring their five-year-olds and ask if it’s all right to take them into the Holocaust Exhibition on the second floor.
Instead, he politely informs the families that neither the Holocaust Exhibition nor the Crimes Against Humanity Exhibition are designed for children, and he simply can’t allow anyone under the ages of sixteen to view those exhibits.
By afternoon, he’s exhausted by his stint at Reception and Enquiries (truthfully, by the politeness required of him), and he still has six hours of work to go. No standing allowed on Sundays. He actually patrols, making certain that the children are touching only the things they’re allowed to touch.
At least, that’s how his boss described Sunday afternoon duty. Rupert has found that children generally aren’t the problem. It’s their parents who want a piece of this and a bit of that. The museum is quite friendly—most of the exhibits allow touching or sitting or leaning, but a few are clearly marked with a Do Not Touch sign, and those are always in trouble from a handful of people who believe signs do not apply to them.
Those people seem to come on Sunday. Sunday’s crowd is truly what does him in. Parents with children looking for an educational way to keep the little buggers entertained; ancient blokes who did their time in the service, come to complain that the exhibits don’t accurately represent what happened; and the usual gaggle of tourists, all trying to squeeze the maximum viewing in the minimum amount of time.
This afternoon, a flock of American students have joined the usual suspects. Generally, he likes Americans. They’re open and forthright and blunt in ways he could never be.
But he likes them on weekdays, when the museum isn’t so crowded. On Sundays, the Americans just add to the noise. And their lack of education shows. At Reception and Enquiries, they ask ridiculous questions such as why the Revolutionary War doesn’t have a display.
Our subject, Rupert always says primly, quoting the museum’s mission, is conflicts involving Britain or the Commonwealth since 1914—and some wag always asks what the Commonwealth is. It took him nearly a year to realize that more than half of the Americans actually don’t know.
Now, he sees to his disgust that the Americans are queued up at the Blitz Experience. The Blitz Experience is his favorite place in the entire museum, partly because it was a revelation to him when he went through it.
It’s a reconstruction of an air raid shelter and a bombed-out neighborhood in 1940, complete with sound effects and smells. The little room even shakes as the “bombs” fall from above.
His family has talked of the Blitz for years—Uncle Clyde claims that suffering through it as a tot inspired him to become the man that he is—and Rupert has always tried to imagine the difficulties and the heroism. So when he, as part of his training, was allowed in the Experience, he had the shock of his young life. Not the discomfort of the scratchy walls or the faint whistle as bombs fell outside. The room’s shaking disturbed him and so did the faint smell of smoke, but it was designed to disturb him.
He planned for that, and sat at attention as he imagined his grandparents—his grandmother, pregnant with his mother, and his Uncle Clyde in short pants, his hands clasping his chubby knees, all enduring.
But they probably hadn’t endured. That’s what so surprised Rupert. The Experience showed it all—the good and the bad—the way that the stress made the people in the shelter snap at each other and snipe, bitterly complaining about their lot.
He hadn’t ever imagined that, and later, when the lights came up, and recorded voices spoke of helping the injured and fighting blazes, it wasn’t enough to overcome his shock.
For some reason he had thought it hadn’t been that divisive, that everyone had come together, and clearly they hadn’t—not willingly at least, and not every single night.
He’d stepped out of that experience a changed man. He thought of that every Sunday afternoon, when he spent the last ninety minutes of his day guiding patrons into and out of the Blitz Experience.
This afternoon’s influx of Americans doesn’t really please him. Two groups of Americans went through the Experience earlier, when he wasn’t monitoring the rope, and he was glad of it. Since he started monitoring the Experience this afternoon, he’d watched the remaining Americans filter their way here. Now they stand at the end of the queue. Four boys and three girls, along with three adults, two men and a younger woman.
These people will be the last he can put through before closing time.
He grabs another metal sign and carries it to the end of the queue. As he walks, he counts aloud. He wants them to realize he has a quota. He also wants to remind the Americans to read the plaques on the wall before they enter the Experience. That way, at least, he will have fewer questions when they emerge.
Only as he walks around the rope, with its Do Not Pass, sign, he realizes he doesn’t need to remind the Americans to read the plaques.
Some are already doing so. The rest are listening attentively to an attractive young woman with dark hair and snappy black eyes. She wears a gold cross around her neck that catches the light.
“The London Blitz,” she’s saying, “began in the Docklands on September seventh, nineteen forty, and continued, unabated, well into nineteen forty-one…”
He likes the word “unabated.” It suggests an excellent education. He can’t stop to listen. He’s counting his way down, and no one is even paying attention. Not even the pair of gentlemen standing just behind the young woman.
Rupert made a mistake earlier. The two men aren’t Americans. He recognizes the older of the two. He’s brought family and friends telling them about the war with an air of authority only experience can give.
Even he is listening to the young woman, remarking to his friend as Rupert passes, “She’s quite the thing, for an American.”
Isn’t she though? Rupert thinks.
His mood lifts. He’s nearly done, and the day no longer seems as dismal as it had in the morning. He’s made it through and seen a pretty girl as well. A pretty, educated girl. A pretty, educated American girl, something he finds unusual and attractive at the same time.
Maybe he’ll speak with her when she emerges from the Blitz Experience. Maybe he’ll get Alfie to cover the door so that Rupert can escort her to another part of the museum, get to know her a bit, see if she’s staying in London longer than the usual two weeks.
Then he stumbles slightly, feeling silly. Even if she is, what interest would she have in him? He’s just a day worker with big dreams, none of which he’s pursued yet.
By the time he makes his way back to the rope, he’s decided not to seek out Alfie. If the girl wants to chat, she will. But most likely, she’ll be like the other visitors to the museum, who see him only as a roadblock in their haste to see every part of the building before they’re asked to leave a few minutes before six.
“Blitz,” Tenesha says, “is short for blitzkrieg, a German word meaning lightning war.”
Denver, Hitch, Fox and Gianni are watching the girls while they listen to Tenesha. She has a hunch they’ve come just to be near the girls. Neither Bailey nor Ali or Jada have boyfriends at the moment. They’re not looking at the boys at all.
“The Germans,” Tenesha says, “used the blitzkrieg style of attack to great effect in World War Two. When it came time to turn their attention to England, the Germans decided to send aircraft in great numbers and have them bomb selected targets.”
“Britain,” says the man behind her. “They turned their attention to Britain.”
Tenesha turns toward him. He’s as old as Grand, with a weathered face and tired eyes. He stands with a much younger man, who has the look of someone who is being dragged through an experience he’d rather not have.
“I beg your pardon,” the older man says with delightful courtliness. “I’m a stickler for accuracy about this war.”
She doesn’t mind. The students should know about the Blitz before they go into the so-called Experience. She has no idea what they have and haven’t studied. They seem more informed than most kids their age, but they have big gaps. She doesn’t want this to be one of them.
“They listen to me all the time,” she says with only a slight bit of exaggeration. “If you would like to tell them about the Blitz, go ahead.”
His eyes light up. He glances at his companion who shrugs. Then the older man steps forward as if he’s been asked to give a speech. “I suspect, since your young lady here is so knowledgeable, that you’ve been to the area we call Docklands. But let me tell you what it was like on that September night….”
She listens long enough to realize the man is an excellent storyteller. He takes them from the bombing raids and the British response known here as the Battle of Britain, and into the night raids that followed. His hands move as he talks. Even his companion leans forward, suddenly interested.
Then she looks at the exhibit hall beyond. The museum is much more than she can see in one day. She wishes she had come here earlier. On this trip, she’s discovering a new London, tourist London, and she’s beginning to understand why her American friends like coming here. It’s not gas fireplaces and narrow living rooms, cold shops and mediocre food.
There’s life here that goes back so far she can barely imagine it. The Ancient Romans built walls and roads here. People have lived and died in this place the Romans called Londinium for centuries.
“…they call it the Second Great Fire of London,” the man is saying.
She turns.
“There was a first?” Denver asks before she can stop him. He’s a big kid who’s very smart but also very awkward. She doesn’t want her students asking stupid, ignorant questions. Even though they aren’t her students, and she can’t expect them to know everything.
“In 1666,” the man says with good humor at the question, as if he doesn’t mind at all, “most of London burned. That’s why we have laws now that require buildings within the city limits to be made of stone…”
He handles the questions well. Her students have gathered around him. They’re lost in the story, like she used to be as a child, when Grand told her about London’s past.
The young man who divided them into groups has returned to his place in front of the ropes. His gaze meets hers, as if asking if she’s ready to go inside.
She smiles at him and shrugs, inclining her head at the old man, who has now riveted the group with his story of the destruction of the Square Mile shortly after Christmas 1940. The Square Mile is where London actually began. In 1940, buildings that survived the great Fire of 1666 still stood, as did several famous churches, untouched by flame of three centuries before.
Of course, in the center—then as now—is St. Paul’s Cathedral, beautifully redesigned after 1666 by one of the world’s greatest architects, Christopher Wren. Wren’s Cathedral, considered one of the most beautiful in the world, was the tallest building in London in 1940.
The old man’s story holds the kids in awe as he teases them with the idea that the St. Paul’s they saw only days before might be another rebuild after the fires of December 1940.
Of course, it isn’t. There’s a famous newspaper photograph that Grand has framed in her home of St. Paul’s poking out of wisps of billowing smoke, under the headline: War’s greatest Picture: St. Paul’s Stands Unharmed in the Midst of the Burning City.
Her hand creeps to the cross Grand gave her. It still feels warmer than it should. When she sees Grand again—and with luck, that will be before she leaves London on Friday—she’ll ask what the cross is made of, why it always feels warm.
The old man has moved onto the attacks after the new year, and how Hitler missed his opportunity to destroy Britain by focusing instead on Operation Barbarossa, his disastrous invasion of Russia.
“He was an excellent tactician,” the old man says, “but an impatient one. If he had followed his strategy all the way to the end, we probably wouldn’t be standing here today.”
“Or we’d be speaking German,” says his companion.
“And heil Hitlering each other,” says Denver, clearly trying to curry favor.
“Some of us would never have done that, lad,” the old man says. “No matter who won the war.”
The pretty American looked at him as if she could see through him, and then he blushed. Rupert hates blushing, but he can’t control it. He feels like one of those ridiculous blokes whose every emotion shows on his face.
Rupert wants to close his eyes in shame, but he doesn’t. He can hear the last echo of the voices from inside the Experience, and he knows this round is about to end. He moves to the exit door, waiting to guide the newly educated to the next part of the museum.
They emerge like they always do, heads down, silent. This group has no American school students. It’s a normal Sunday mix of Londoners bringing family and European tourists, who clutch their belongings as if someone is going to steal them. An elderly couple holds each other up.
He waits until the last of this bunch leave, then he closes the exit door. He turns.
The Americans are watching him with expressions of eager expectation on their young faces. Normally Americans are shifting from foot to foot. Generally, by the time they discover the Blitz Experience on the lower ground level, they’ve seen the rest of the museum. They’re here to be entertained or because some completist feels they must experience this too.
Rupert moves the rope aside, then opens the door. A bit of light falls on the faux stone benches. By this time of day, the Experience smells faintly of nervous sweat. Some people—even those who never lived through the Blitz—do find this intense. More than one bloke of his own age clapped him on the back on the way out and said, This is bloody scary, Mate. Not at all what I expected.
Rupert likes the look of disappointment on the faces of the Americans as they file in. The Experience looks so innocuous.
The pretty American waits until her students are inside and then she follows. She nods at Rupert as she passes him, and his skin heats again. It’s as if the Great Fire of London has started inside of him. He pretends it isn’t happening and nods back, feeling like an utter fool.
The elderly gent’s companion steps inside, but the elderly gent stops at the door.
“There’s room,” Rupert says.
The elderly gent shakes his head. No one inside seems to notice that he hasn’t gone in. His companion is shuffling after the Americans, looking for a spot on the bench.
“Are you sure, sir?” Rupert asks.
“Quite sure,” the elderly gent says. He reaches for the door, but Rupert grabs it first. As it swings shut, the elderly gent’s companion looks up, startled, as the door closes in his face.
For a moment, the room is in complete darkness. The utter blackness is breathtaking. Someone on Tenesha’s right takes her hand. She doesn’t pull away. She finds comfort in the warmth. She gropes a moment in the darkness with her left hand, finding the bench, and then someone else’s hand. She touches it tentatively. That person grabs tightly.
She has no idea who she’s sitting beside. At the moment, she doesn’t care.
In the distance, she hears church bells—and she remembers what the old man said: London used church bells to signal the start or end of an invasion. That entire fall, winter, and spring, the bells didn’t call the faithful to services. The bells warned of grave danger.
She supposes the bells now are to indicate an invasion. She expects a siren to follow, but wonders at the accuracy of it all. Could the people in the shelters actually hear a bell?
Then there’s a scratchy sound, like a voice over a public address system. She thinks she hears someone take a breath, and then it stops. Lights come up ever so slightly, and she gasps.
How did they do this?
She’s in a basement with twenty people she doesn’t recognize. Her students sit around her, as does the companion of the old man. But the old man himself isn’t here. The companion looks shocked. He’s glancing about as if unable to believe he’s alone.
The kids are simply going along with the ride, but the hair has risen on the back of her neck. Something has changed. It takes her a moment to realize what that something is.
This basement smells of cigarettes and sweet pipe smoke. Overlaying that is the smell of mold and damp. The bench she’s sitting on isn’t stone after all, but some kind of rusted metal.
Rusted metal slats. When she groped with her left hand, she could swear she felt a solid bench beneath her.
When she stepped inside the Blitz Experience, she got the sense of a narrow space with a low ceiling, not something this big and wide. The museum building is huge, but could it accommodate something of this size?
She isn’t certain.
The people—actors?—inside the basement are staring at her.
“This is not a public shelter,” says a man near the door. The door is a gray metal with a handmade sign on the interior which reads Shelter.
He’s speaking to the elderly man’s companion. She looks at the man. He looks as baffled as she does.
She hasn’t given him much notice until now. He’s slender, with black eyes and an angular face. He has a dimple in the middle of his chin. He’s wearing a shirt over a T-shirt advertising the name of some British sports team. He wears tennis shoes—what the British call trainers—on his feet.
The other man, the one who spoke, is staring at the companion in distaste. The man who spoke is wearing an old-fashioned suit with pleated trousers, a vest, and a matching coat. His white shirt has a starched collar that looks so stiff Tenesha wonders if it’s hurting the skin on his neck.
“I’m terribly sorry,” the man continues, “but this shelter is for no more than fifty persons.”
“There’s only thirty-five of us down here,” Denver says. “We could squeeze in fifteen more if we had to.”
Everyone looks at the boy in shock, including Tenesha. He’s been outspoken throughout this trip, but she didn’t expect him to willingly participate in any role-playing.
“You’re American?” a middle-aged woman asks. She sits on the room’s only chair, her sturdy legs crossed at the ankles. Tenesha can see a black line running up the back of her calves and thinks it odd, until she remembers Grand saying that women painted the black line on their legs to make it look like they were wearing stockings.
“Yeah,” Denver says. “We’re American high school students. We’re here to learn something.”
“Denver,” Tenesha says. “Don’t.”
He looks at her, frowning. Then he looks back at the others in the basement—the ones who were here first. Can’t he feel it? The strange tension, the almost palpable sense of fear?
The entire building shakes. Dust falls from the ceiling on the head of a bald man sitting across from Ali and Jada. The girls giggle as he brushes off his skull.
“Stop,” Tenesha says to them.
“You’re in charge, Miss?” the man who first spoke asks.
“Of this group, yes,” she says. She almost adds, all except for the man at the end, but she doesn’t.
“You cannot stay here. We simply cannot allow it. Should something happen—”
He stops himself, then looks down.
“It’s all right, Mr. Pintner,” another woman says. She’s younger, prettier, than the woman on the chair. She’s wearing a brown dress with sensible shoes, but the arms of a bright red sweater are tied around her neck, giving her a jaunty air. “We all know what might happen.”
“No, we don’t,” Denver says, then he looks at Tenesha.
“Denver,” she says. “That’s enough.”
He flops backwards, but the gesture lacks conviction. He does feel the oddness. Maybe that’s why he’s speaking up.
She glances at the rest of her little troop, all wide-eyed and a bit scared now. If this is a re-enactment, designed to make everyone uncomfortable, it’s working.
Mr. Pintner, the man who seems to be in charge, says, “If something happens to the shelter, and they need to identify…us…somehow, they won’t know how to go about it. They’ll think you work here.”
“They’ll sort it out,” the companion says. He sounds calm enough, but his entire body is rigid. He’s clearly frightened.
“There are public shelters right next door,” Mr. Pintner says. “Perhaps no one explained this to you at your hotel, but just follow the signs. The warehouses—”
The building shakes again, silencing him. More dust falls. The bald man wipes off his head, then moves aside. No one glances at the ceiling except the companion.
“Is that safe?” the companion asks.
Now they all look up. There’s a jagged crack, running from one wall to the other.
“That wasn’t there before,” the middle-aged woman says. She sounds a bit breathless. “Do you think we’ve been hit?”
“If we have, the Watch will come and find us,” Mr. Pintner says.
“Not if it’s an incendiary,” the bald man says.
“What’s an incendiary?” Denver asks, then bites his lower lip.
Everyone looks at him. Then the middle-aged woman turns to Tenesha.
“It’s terribly inappropriate for you to be sightseeing in London. I don’t know who brought you to the city or why, but when this is over, you should return to America post-haste. And to bring children with you….”
She shakes her head.
One of the men pats her hand. “Now, now, Felicia. They’re here. The decision’s been made, hasn’t it. There’s no sense in recrimination.”
“Someone will come if we’re in trouble,” the younger woman says. “That’s what the Watch is for.”
“Besides,” the bald man says, “if it is an incendiary, we’ll know within five minutes.”
Everyone looks up again, as if that crack in the ceiling has changed somehow.
“What’s an incendiary?” Denver whispers.
“A bomb that starts fires, I think,” Fox whispers back. He’s slender and dark, and usually tries to fade in a crowd. It’s a sign of his own discomfort that he’s speaking up.
“Christ, and we’re trapped in a hole?” Gianni asks, a little too loudly. He’s square-shouldered and tall, the only athlete in the group.
“Young man,” the middle-aged woman—Felicia—says. “It may be customary in your country to use foul language in times of crisis, but it’s not here.”
Tenesha hadn’t even noticed Gianni’s slip, not until Felicia spoke up, but now she needs to do something about it. She’s about to ask him to stay silent, when he bows his head.
“I’m sorry, ma’am,” he says. “I didn’t mean to be rude. I’m just surprised we’re here, is all.”
“As are we all,” she says. “I’m not even sure how you got in. Isn’t Mr. Ludgate monitoring the door?”
She asks this last of Mr. Pintner.
“He’s on fire watch,” Mr. Pintner says. “If he had to deal with an emergency, he would have stepped away.”
“Letting these Americans in,” Felicia says.
“I’m not an American,” the companion says. “My name is Edmund Hennel. My people have been in London since William the Conqueror. I most certainly do belong, and I resent the implication that I do not.”
“I’m sorry, Mr. Hennel,” Felicia says. “But you don’t work here. This is a private shelter.”
“You’d send us out there?” he asks. “With bombs falling everywhere? Simply because we don’t work in your facility?”
“I’ve explained it to you,” Mr. Pintner says.
“Yes, you have,” Hennel says. “And it doesn’t suffice, now does it? You’d send us out to die just because we might die in here and muck up the record-keeping?”
The bald man clears his throat. “When you put it that way, it does sound a trifle unreasonable.”
“Yes, considering your man let us in,” Hennel says.
Tenesha leans forward in surprise. Hennel seems completely sure of himself. Does he really think that awkward museum employee works with these people?
Then she realizes that Hennel must be bluffing. Someone is bluffing, since this can’t be real.
Her eyes hurt from the dim light. She feels the beginnings of a headache. Bailey, the girl on her right looks pale.
“Ms. McGuire,” she says softly, “I smell smoke.”
Tenesha sniffs, realizes that smoke is what’s bothering her eyes, not the light. But all the smoke, from the cigarettes to the pipe that an older man, barely visible in the far corner of the basement, holds in his right hand.
“People are smoking,” Tenesha says.
“You’d think a place like this would be designated nonsmoking,” Ali says.
“No, no,” says Bailey. “Wood smoke. Like something’s burning.”
“I smell it too,” says Felicia with a touch of panic in her voice.
“It’s your imagination,” Mr. Pintner says. “We’ve been talking of incendiaries, after all.”
“No,” says a thin young man sitting near a pile of boxes. “I smell it as well.”
“We have to get out,” Felicia says, the panic no longer a touch. “We’ll die in here.”
“If there’s smoke, we’ll die out there,” Mr. Pintner says. “Trust the Watch. They’ll get us if there’s danger.”
“And if they can’t get to us?” Hennel asks.
“Then we’ll burn alive,” Denver says, with just enough tremor in his voice for Tenesha to realize he’s not play-acting. He’s frightened.
“Do something,” Hennel says, and it takes Tenesha a minute to realize he’s talking to her.
“Me?” Tenesha asks. “What can I do?”
“I don’t know,” he says. “You’re the one with the cross.”
Everyone looks at her. She puts her hand on the tiny gold cross. It’s hot, but then everything is hot, including her.
“My Grand gave that to me yesterday,” she says, feeling confused. “It’s hers, not mine.”
“Should we be praying?” Ali asks. “Is that what you mean?”
“No,” Hennel says. He’s still staring at Tenesha. “You know what I mean.”
She shakes her head. She doesn’t know and she’s about to say so when someone pounds on the door.
Bailey emits a tiny shriek. Felicia crosses her arms. “We can’t take anyone else in here. We can’t fit anyone. We already have too many, and most don’t belong.”
Mr. Pintner ignores her. He pulls the door open. An older man—Tenesha can’t even begin to guess his age—stands outside. He’s wearing some kind of uniform with a big black belt and boots, and he has the most ridiculous tin hat on his head that she’s ever seen.
The smell of smoke has grown stronger now, as if it wafted in through the open door.
“Quite so,” the newcomer says. “I thought perhaps someone might be down here. We need to get you out. The buildings are burning on both sides.”
“I told you!” Felicia says, but Tenesha can’t tell who she’s saying it too.
Tenesha’s heart is pounding, hard, and it’s hard to catch her breath, but whether that’s from nervousness or the smoke, she can’t tell.
“Where’re we going?” Mr. Pintner asks.
“We’ll find somewhere,” the newcomer says, but he doesn’t sound reassuring.
Mr. Pintner moves beside the door. “You know how it works. Women and children first.”
“That’s sexist,” Bailey says.
“It’s nineteen forty,” Denver says.
“Still,” Bailey says.
Tenesha shushes them. She guides them out, struggling to get the boys to move.
“We’re not children,” Fox says.
“Just go,” she says.
As she steps out into another basement room, this one white with smoke, Denver grabs her arm.
“Ms. McGuire,” he says. “Something’s wrong.”
Yes. This scenario is too realistic. She doesn’t like it at all. But she doesn’t say that to him. Instead, she says, “What do you mean?”
“There’s only one door in that room,” he says. “And it’s in the right place. We came in that door.”
She turns.
It looks nothing like the door to the Experience. The museum personnel must have designed the room to spin around in the dark. Still, that odd sensation, the one she felt as the darkness lifted, has returned.
“I’m sure they just moved us,” she says with conviction she doesn’t feel.
“I don’t like this.” Denver’s voice trembles again.
She puts her arm around his shoulders. They’re surprisingly thin.
“I don’t either,” she says. “We’ll complain when it’s all over.”
“Yeah,” he says. “But to who?”
The first closing announcement ends on the museum’s public address system. Rupert silently curses himself. He hates it when his timing is off. The poor people inside the Blitz Experience have just had the magic of the moment interrupted with a bit of reality. Go to the gift shop, collect your coats, it’s time to leave.
He glances at his watch. The Experience will complete its run in less than a minute. The elderly gent is still hovering near the door. He looks nervous, although Rupert has no idea why he should.
“So you were there, eh?” Rupert says to him.
The elderly gent nods.
“Seems to me it would have been awful,” Rupert says, “never knowing what’s about to happen next.”
The elderly gent looks directly at him. There’s power in the elderly gent’s gaze and just a hint of contempt.
“We never do know what’s about to happen next, now do we?” the elderly gent says.
Rupert’s poor face heats again. “You know what I mean. That you could die at any moment.” Then he realizes that the elderly gent could say with the same contempt that all of them could die at any moment, so Rupert adds, “At the hands of Jerry, I mean.”
The elderly gent nods. That powerful look has left his face. “It wasn’t pleasant,” he says. “But we survived.”
“Against all odds, they say,” Rupert says.
“Yes,” the elderly gent says. “That’s what they say.”
He stares at the exit door. Rupert glances at his watch. They’re done. He waits a half second—he likes giving the Americans an extra moment of darkness—then pulls the door open.
And feels his breath catch in his throat.
The room is empty.
The smoke is thicker near the stairs. Tenesha’s eyes are watering.
“Come along,” the man in uniform says. Somewhere along the way she has figured out he’s the Watch they mentioned. The comments from earlier finally made sense. Grand had spoken of Watch commanders. They were part of the Home Guard—at least, that’s what Tenesha remembers. She doesn’t ask for clarification, though. She just follows along.
“How do we know we have everyone?” Denver asks.
“Mr. Pintner will make sure everyone’s out of the room,” the Watch says. “Come along. We don’t have much time.”
It’s warmer as they rise, but it’s an odd warmth, like the warmth from a fireplace. Tenesha can feel the pockets of coldness around it, and she sees bit of ash. Her heart is pounding so hard that it might come out of her chest.
This is not a play. No one has created this. Somehow, she has stepped into the London Blitz, and she doesn’t know how she got here.
She reaches the top of the stairs. In front of her is a large room, filled with metal desks and gooseneck lamps, none of which are on. Another man wearing a tin hat—apparently another member of the Watch—stands near one of the desks, holding a lantern that’s tinted red.
Tenesha can barely see the lantern. After a moment, she realizes that’s not because of the smoke. It’s deliberate.
She wonders why they’re all so worried about the light when through the windows, she can see fire burning across the way, lighting the night sky.
Her realization—confirmation, really—that this is actually happening focuses her. She stops at the top of the stairs, even though the man in the tin hat wants her to go forward.
“I’m a teacher,” she says because it’s easier than explaining she’s a chaperone. “I want to make sure my students get out.”
Oddly, he accepts that, rather than asking her why she’s brought students down here.
The smoke is making her dizzy. She rips off the bottom of her shirt and ties it over her mouth and nose. As the students come up the stairs, she instructs them to find something to cover their faces as well.
And she counts: Bailey, Ali, Denver, Fox, Hitch, Gianni, Jada. Her charges. Then the companion, Hennel, who glares at her.
“Do something,” he says.
“Like what?” she asks.
“I don’t know,” he says, “but you’re the one who brought us here.”
The man in the tin hat grabs Hennel’s arm and yanks him away from her.
“Talk later,” the man says. “We have to get out and we don’t have much time.”
Tenesha corrals her students, arms around them, moving them forward. But she stops in the middle of the room. Flames rise around the windows, and it’s warmer the closer she gets.
“Where are we going?” she asks.
The man points to her right. She turns. There’s a darker corridor there, barely illuminated by firelight. She pushes the students forward, but they don’t need much encouragement.
She keeps her eye on all of them, always counting, getting so she can recognize them by their hair or their height. She follows them to two massive steel doors, one of which stands open. Through it, she sees more smoke and ash raining on a cobblestone street. Little fires burn, but they’re caused by flaming bits of wood that have somehow found their way to the cobblestone and are now burning themselves out.
“I don’t want to go out there,” Bailey says.
“We stay in here, we die,” Hitch says, and while Tenesha doesn’t appreciate the harsh assessment, she knows it’s true.
She moves to the front of her students, then she turns and looks behind her. The man in the tin hat is hurrying toward her. She’s suddenly worried he’s going to tell her that she can’t leave that way, that they’re trapped inside.
Her breath catches, and she coughs. Her chest hurts. She’s not getting enough air. The ripped part of her shirt covering her nose and mouth is wet from the dampness of her breath.
“Follow me,” says the man in the tin hat and then he scurries through the door. The thick air doesn’t seem to bother him.
“Let’s go,” she says to the students. They don’t have to be told twice. They follow the man into the streets.
The air is alive with smoke and bits of burning paper raining down on them. The sky—what she can see of it—is a brilliant pink and red, both beautiful and terrible at the same time. The smoke doesn’t smell horrible, like she would expect. It smells like incense, sort of, or some kind of weird tobacco in a pipe. Only the entire street smells of it.
Then she realizes where she is. She’s in the Square Mile.
The firestorm of late December 1940.
“We need to find shelter,” she says.
The Watch turns along another cobblestone street. Fire hoses litter the ground, pumping water from a truck that doesn’t fit on the narrow street. Tenesha squints. The firefighters are one more block over, working a blaze that is so close, it terrifies her.
Above, planes scream by. She can’t tell who they belong to—the Germans or the British. But no one around her ducks. To her left, a building crumbles as if a giant has pushed it.
One of the kids squeals and leaps toward her. The air is nearly too hot to breathe.
They have to get inside, but there seems to be no inside. And Tenesha knows enough about firestorms to know that soon the fires will create their own wind, and then everything in their path will become fuel. No one’s lungs will be able to stand the incredible heat.
She can barely make out the shape of buildings. Nothing looks familiar, but if she’s in the Square Mile, it wouldn’t look familiar. Most of it burned decades before she was born.
Her skin itches from the dry hot air. Her eyes ache. She stumbles forward. The students are still moving as well.
Ahead, barely visible in the smoke and ash, one of the Watchmen—recognizable only from his tin hat, waves at them. He grabs the arm of the man in the lead and pulls him out of her sight. The students follow, disappearing into the miasma.
Her stomach twists. What if there’s nothing beyond? What if this illusion ends there, and they step off the face of the Earth like the old sailors used to believe they could?
They’re all going to die, and somehow, that companion—Hennel—thinks it will be her fault.
“They’re not here,” Rupert says, his voice echoing in the narrow space. “How can they not be here?”
Rupert has gone inside just to make sure the Americans haven’t hid somewhere—not that there’s any place to hide. The Experience is pretty small. People sit on benches, and then as the lights come up, they see a replica of a London street—before the Blitz, during the Blitz, and then afterwards. They ease out through the second door.
Had they gotten out when he wasn’t looking? Why would they do that?
Then again, why do Americans do anything?
“They should be here,” he says stupidly. And they’re not here. They’re not here at all.
He feels a mixture of anger and panic. People don’t just vanish, now do they?
He makes himself take a deep breath.
“Or mayhap they do,” the elderly gent says.
Rupert looks up. The elderly gent is blocking the exit.
“What?” Rupert asks.
“You said, ‘People don’t just vanish, now do they?’ and I said, ‘Mayhap they do.’” The elderly gent clasps his hands behind his back.
Rupert swallows hard. He could have sworn he hadn’t spoken aloud. But he does tend to mumble to himself when things get difficult. Maybe he had been talking.
“After all,” the elderly gent says, “I didn’t see them come out. Did you?”
“No,” Rupert says. “But I wasn’t looking the whole time.”
The elderly gent gives him a disbelieving look. “You think nine people can simply slip by you and you wouldn’t notice?”
Rupert shrugs. “There’s the corridor and then the exhibits….”
His voice trails off. He isn’t even convincing himself.
They haven’t slipped past him and they aren’t in the Experience. Where are they?
“You tell me, lad,” the elderly gent says.
This time, Rupert knows he hasn’t spoken aloud. He supposes his expressions are speaking for him.
“I don’t know. They can’t have gone this way.” He looks at the back of the Experience, the fake storefront, and the broken cobblestone street. There are lighting effects behind it, and maybe a maintenance tunnel or something. He doesn’t rightly know. He’s never been behind the Experience. Only inside of it.
And it would take someone very determined to break through the illusion. Besides, what would be the point?
“Why aren’t you worried?” Rupert snaps. “Your friend was inside.”
“He came to learn.” The elderly gent rocks backwards slightly. “And I’m quite sure that he is.”
There’s a rumbling behind them. Tenesha turns. Stones have fallen across the road, blocking the way that the group has just come.
“Is everyone through?” she asks.
Then she sees Mr. Pintner. “We have an accurate count, Miss,” he says. “Keep moving.”
She has no choice. She scurries forward. She can feel something in the heat—a stirring—as if the breeze is about to start.
Hennel grabs her arm, his grip so tight that it’s painful. “Your students are inside,” he says. “Let’s go.”
They step into some kind of yard. It looks bizarrely normal in the reddish light. A garden, some statues, and a mausoleum, the stone shining redly at them.
The students are ducking inside. She follows, and hurries forward, wiping at her suddenly tearing eyes. Hennel and Mr. Pintner follow.
It’s cooler in here, and that makes all the remaining moisture in her body emerge. There are electric lights, thin, but real. For a moment, she thinks the blackout is over. Then she thinks maybe they’ve all realized it’s pointless. And then she realizes that no, this building has no windows, so no light can escape.
She stops, leans on a pillar, and looks ahead.
Arches. A series of stone arches around a granite casket.
She’s been here before.
Just a few days ago, as a matter of fact. A few days before seventy plus years from now.
“We’re in St. Paul’s,” she says.
“Don’t you Americans know anything?” Hennel says. “This is the Crypt.”
The Crypt is a separate building from the great church, but it’s on the church’s grounds. And she was here, a few days before.
She turns, and grabs Hennel’s arms, shaking him. “We’re in St. Paul’s!”
“No,” he says stubbornly. “We’re—”
“St. Paul’s,” she repeats. “It’s the only thing around here that survives.”
He stares at her for a moment. His mouth opens slightly. “But we’re in the Crypt,” he says.
“And that’s the Duke of Wellington,” she says, pointing to the granite casket. “Hasn’t he been here since 1805? You’ve seen him before, haven’t you? I certainly have.”
Hennel looks like someone has awakened him from a nightmare. “My Lord. So it is. We’re in the Crypt and the Duke has been here since 1805 and St. Paul’s—St. Paul’s was built for eternity.”
It takes her a minute to remember the quote. Their guide had spoken it on the tour of St. Paul’s. Sir Christopher Wren’s boast, “I build for eternity,” turned out to be true. And it doesn’t feel like a boast now, because for the first time since the world turned on its head, Tenesha can catch her breath.
“Let’s not stand here,” says Mr. Pintner. He puts his hand on Tenesha’s back and moves her forward. “I’m told they often have a cuppa and I don’t know about you, but I could do with one.”
Then he walks forward, so staunchly British that Tenesha can’t help herself. She grins.
Hennel smiles with her. “We’re in St. Paul’s,” he says.
“We’re in the Crypt,” she says with an involuntary, relieved giggle. “And somehow it all survives.”
The second closing announcement echoes through the public address system. Rupert runs a hand through his hair. How can he tell his superiors that he lost nine visitors, eight of them American? He can just see the story on CNN International now. Americans raise a fuss whenever anything happens to one of them. Imagine what will happen when they find out that eight of them have disappeared, seven of them school age.
His stomach is twisting.
“I don’t know what to do,” Rupert says. “I’m not even sure if we have procedures for this.”
The elderly gent smiles at him. He’s still leaning inside the Experience door, as if he’s expecting to find all nine on the benches. “Give it a moment, lad. It’ll all work out.”
“What do you know?” Rupert asks. “Has something like this happened to you before?”
“Not to me, lad,” the elderly gent says reprovingly. “And it really hasn’t happened to you either. Haven’t you wondered where they’ve gone?”
“I expect they’ve left somehow,” he says. “They snuck out when I wasn’t looking. Or they broke part of the Experience and went exploring.”
“You don’t really believe that,” the elderly gent says.
Rupert flushes. The truth is, he doesn’t believe it. He’s much more willing to believe they’ve disappeared.
It’s that imagination, boy. He can hear his Uncle Giles’s voice in his head. It’ll get you in trouble every time.
“It makes more sense than them vanishing in thin air,” Rupert says.
“Does it really?” the elderly gent says. “A group of Americans, with their teacher no less, and one very conservative British citizen, decide en masse to ruin a display in a museum. They unite and assault the display within five minutes of meeting each other. Does that make sense as well?”
“Maybe one of the Americans has a gun,” Rupert says. “He forced them.”
“How did he get in then?” the elderly gent says. “In fact, how did he get into England? I presume they flew from the States. Can you imagine a firearm making it through Heathrow?”
Rupert hasn’t flown out of Heathrow. He hasn’t been to the airport since 7/7/07, not that he went often before that either. The train stations are difficult enough for him and ever since those July bombings, he hasn’t been comfortable on a city bus or in the Underground. Every time he travels through King’s Cross he thinks, not of Harry Potter, but the way the entire place shut down that terrifying morning.
“This isn’t terrorists, is it?” he asks the elderly gent.
The elderly gent chuckles. “No. It’s not terrorists or anything else that’s easily explained. Just be patient.”
“Be patient?” Rupert says. “We’re closing.”
“In five minutes,” the elderly gent says. “They’ll solve it before then, I’m sure.”
“Who’ll solve what?” Rupert asks.
“Mr. Hennel and the pretty young American lady. They’ll bring everyone back safely. You’ll see.”
“What exactly’s going on?” Rupert asks.
“A tiny demonstration of power,” the elderly gent says, “and nothing more.”
Someone had put the kettle on. But no one had made tea. Instead, one of the Wardens hands out chipped mugs filled with cocoa to anyone who wants it.
Cocoa, if Tenesha remembers correctly, is hard to get with rationing coupons. It’s a treat. She whispers to the students to be grateful, but she doesn’t have to remind them.
“This is the best hot chocolate I’ve ever tasted,” Ali says after taking a sip. She slips onto a wooden folding chair.
Some people Tenesha hasn’t seen before are playing cards off in the corner. Others have blankets spread out on the floor.
Tenesha shudders a little. The floor isn’t solid at all. Each stone is marked with names and dates. This is a crypt, as she and that strange man Hennel kept saying back and forth to each other, and the names and dates mark where someone’s body rests—usually someone famous to the British, because she hasn’t heard of them.
She takes a cup of cocoa, says polite things, trying to sound as grateful as she feels. Mr. Pintner gets his cup last, and doesn’t complain at all that he has cocoa instead of tea. Someone has brought biscuits, and a few of the students take more than their share.
She doesn’t reprimand them. She’s not having any and neither are many of the adults.
Instead, she carries her cup to the side where Hennel stands. He’s leaning against the wall, watching the group.
“You said I know how to get us out of here,” Tenesha says. “Why would you say that?”
He looks at her in surprise. “Because you brought us here.”
“I did not,” she says. “I’m not even sure where here is.”
“You do know,” he says. “We’ve come to St. Paul’s on December twenty-nine, nineteen forty, in the height of the London Blitz.”
“All the way from Lambeth?” she says. “In science fiction stories, time travel doesn’t work that way. Either you move in time or space. Not both.”
He tilts his head slightly, as if she’s said something cute. “This isn’t science fiction. This is real life.”
She lets out a little laugh. “This isn’t real,” she says. “The smoke smelled like incense. Smoke doesn’t smell like that.”
“Oh, but it did that night, luv,” he says. “Mr. Maplethorpe told me many times that—”
“Mr. Maplethorpe?” Tenesha asks.
“The man I came with. The one who lectured your students.”
She nods. The old man Hennel had arrived with. The old man whom, she just now realizes, never entered the Experience.
“Mr. Maplethorpe told me that on the night the Square Mile burned, the smoke smelled of seasoned oak. Some compared it to perfume or pipe tobacco. And some thought it smelled of incense.”
“Seasoned oak?” she asks.
Hennel says gently, “We walked past buildings that were more than three hundred years old. Burning buildings, some made from trees even older than that. We were smelling the great forests of England as they vanished forever.”
That brings tears to her aching eyes. She’s tired, she decides. Or maybe she’s overwhelmed.
What makes you think I brought us here?” she asks.
He reaches forward and she nearly backs away. But she decides not to. He takes the cross that Grand gave her in his hand.
“This,” he says. “It’s not a regular cross, you know.”
“Is that why it’s hot?”
It’s his turn to look surprised. “I thought it was hot from the fires.”
She shakes her head. “It’s always like that.”
Or at least, it has been as long as she’s owned it, all of twenty-four hours.
“Hmm,” he says, as if that’s a revelation. “I didn’t know these things had a power of their own, but it makes sense.”
“These things?” Tenesha asks. “I thought it was just a cross.”
He shakes his head. “Mr. Maplethorpe explained it to me. Take it off and I’ll show you.”
She reaches behind her head and unclasps the cross, then hands it to him. He stares at it for a moment, as if it’s unfamiliar, then points to the ridges in the middle of the cross itself.
“See how they reflect the light?” he asks. “It’s always in this pattern and the reflection is always red, never yellow or white. But red.”
She takes the cross from him and moves it around. The gold doesn’t reflect at all, and the little cuttings do reflect red no matter where she moves the cross.
“What does it mean?” she asks.
“That the bearer is magical,” he says with the utmost seriousness.
“A cross?” She raises her voice in disbelief. People look at her. The students frown, and Denver makes a gesture which means You okay? She nods and continues the conversation, this time in a lower tone. “Crosses are the opposite of witches. The Church hates magic.”
“That’s why this cross is different,” he says. “To the untrained eye, it looks normal. It was designed as the Church went after pagans. Mr. Maplethorpe says that’s why the poor souls burned at the stake and persecuted during the Inquisition had no magic. They weren’t protected.”
“With a cross?” Tenesha asks.
“Think through, luv,” he says. “If you have magic and you lived around the ancient church, wouldn’t you do what you could to blend in? It’s silly to think that the magical would get captured. They’ve survived for centuries, or so Mr. Maplethorpe says. They wouldn’t have done that if they didn’t have a few brains.”
She laughs. “This is a present from my great-grandmother. She must not have known what it was, because I have no magic.”
“You must,” he says. “This has to have happened to you before.”
“Coming to the Blitz? Not highly likely.”
“Going to some past event,” he says. “You’ve done it before. Everyone’s power manifests young. Yours has to be to travel in time.”
She stares at him. Even as she starts to shake her head, she remembers Grand’s living room, how Grand’s stories always came alive in that room, so alive that Tenesha could actually see them.
“You have, haven’t you?” he says and he sounds excited. “You have done this before.”
Grandmother. The words came out of a very long ago past, her mother talking to her grandmother on the phone. She sent an entire sandbox of children to the bar where I met her father. I’m not even sure how they came back. But I can’t have a four-year-old running about unsupervised through all of human history.
That first trip to Grand—the first that Tenesha can remember—came right after that. But before it, Tenesha had to wear—what? Some kind of hated necklace. Not a cross, but something that made her heavy, that weighed her down.
And then Grand: She’ll only be able to practice here, Liv. In my home. Under my supervision. Send her summers. She won’t even know she’s preparing.
“You remember something,” he says.
“If you know this,” Tenesha snaps, “then you’re magical too.”
He shrugs. “That’s what Mr. Maplethorpe says, but I don’t know what my abilities are. He says I have to believe that magic exists before I can tap my own powers.”
She closes her fingers around the cross. “You believe. You’re trying to convince me.”
“Oh, luv,” he says, “you’re the one who’s convinced me. Now we have to get back home.”
“What do I do? Tap my ruby slippers together three times and say, ‘There’s no place like home.’”
His mouth opens slightly. “That’s it!” he says.
“C’mon,” Tenesha says. “The Wizard of Oz isn’t true. Now I know you’re teasing me.”
“Mr. Maplethorpe hated that movie. He says it revealed too many things. He said they had to add the ruby slippers to the film or everyone would know how to do a location spell.”
“What?” Tenesha is growing more and more confused.
“Just try it, luv,” he says. “What can it hurt?”
She thinks for a moment. What could it hurt? Nothing if it doesn’t work. But if she tries it and it does, she might leave the students behind and she would have no idea how to retrieve them.
“Get the students,” she says to Hennel. “I guess we’re going to give this the good old college try.”
“Tell you what,” the elderly gent says to Rupert. “Let’s pretend this hasn’t happened at all. Come out of there and close the exit door.”
“Why?” Rupert asks.
“Let’s just try it,” the elderly gent says.
The third and penultimate announcement echoes off the public address system.
“What can it hurt?” the elderly gent asks when the announcement is over.
Probably nothing, Rupert thinks. He scrambles out and pushes the door closed, adding a fervent little prayer of his own.
“When do I open the door again?” he asks the elderly gent.
The elderly gent shrugs as if the answer’s obvious. “Why, the moment they return, of course.”
They’ve moved deeper into the Crypt, away from the others. Hennel retrieved the students on the pretext of showing them some famous person’s tomb. Only Bailey protested. She didn’t want to see anything ghostly on an already scary evening.
No one holds hands. They won’t give up their precious cocoa. So Tenesha has them huddle around her, touching shoulders. She makes sure she’s brushing against Hennel, who is brushing against the students.
She taps her heels together, eyes closed. She can’t quite bring herself to speak aloud, and she’s afraid if she is magical and she thinks about home, the entire gang will end up in her parents’ house in Chicago.
So she thinks, I want to go back to the museum. Please send us all back to the museum. We want to return to our time and the museum.
She opens her eyes to complete darkness.
“Damn,” Denver says. “The lights are out again.”
“Do you think the fires burned through the lines?” Bailey asks.
“Fires can’t burn down a stone building, can they?” Ali asks.
Then the lights return. All nine of them—students, Hennel, her—are crammed together on a street corner.
Rubble has fallen in front of a shop. On the shop’s unbroken windows, someone has written Dried Eggs Today. Fresh Cheddar, followed by a price per pound. Through the open door, she can see the empty shelves inside, but nothing lies broken on the floor, even though something should be there. After all, there’s rubble to the left of the shop, the remains of some building not quite as fortunate.
Tenesha’s breath catches. She did it wrong. They’ve arrived somewhere else, somewhere that might be just as bad.
Then she realizes that the faint odor of smoke is coming from her clothing, not from the building. There’s no dust or ash in the air. In fact, someone has glued the rubble together.
The street corner isn’t real. It’s been done up to look real. She lets out a small sigh.
A voice overhead says in a firm brook-no-quarrels British accent that they must leave immediately.
“Now where are we?” Bailey asks.
A door opens and the poor redheaded museum employee looks inside.
“They’re back,” he says with some relief. “They’ve come back.”
Rupert knows that he sounds like an idiot but he doesn’t care. As the first Americans step out, heads bowed, he sighs. He did hallucinate all of this. They’re just fine, leaving the Experience like everyone else does, just a bit subdued.
Then one of the girls looks over at him. Her face is smudged with black and her hair is falling out of its barrette. Her eyes are irritated and red.
He glances at the other Americans. They’re covered in dirt as well, and a few of them have ripped clothing.
A young man grins at him. “That’s the best ride I’ve ever been on, man. I don’t know how you guys did it, but that was cool.”
He lifts a mug to Rupert. The mug is battered and old, and smells faintly of cocoa.
Rupert doesn’t say anything. The American students file out and then their teacher, who doesn’t meet his gaze at all.
The elderly gent’s companion has his hand on her back, leading her away from Rupert to the elderly gent.
“This is Mr. Maplethorpe,” the companion says. “I figured you should meet him.”
The elderly gent bows to the young woman. “I’ve known your great-grandmother for a very long time,” he says. “And you’re just as lovely as she said.”
Rupert frowns. They set something up, to play him for a fool. They all knew each other.
He glances at his watch. The museum is nearly closed.
“I beg your pardon,” he says, struggling to keep his anger at bay. “But the museum will close in less than two minutes….”
“There’s an exit down here into the gardens,” the elderly gent says. “I suggest we go out that way.”
And then he leads them away from the Experience without a fare-thee-well to Rupert. Rupert stands for a moment, feeling hurt, and then he realizes he’d better follow lest they try something again.
He totters after them, staring at those mismatched cocoa mugs, wondering where those came from. The students are laughing and talking, looking happy and unconcerned as they go through the door.
He watches them wander into the garden, then he closes and locks the door after them, leaning on it.
He isn’t sure what to make of his last half hour. He wants to chalk it up to his evil, vivid imagination, just like Uncle Giles would.
But not even his Uncle Giles would have an explanation for those mugs. There were no mugs in the Experience, and the mugs in the cafeteria look nothing like that. He knows the Americans didn’t bring the mugs with them because backpacks and anything larger than a small purse has to be left at the coat check. No one carried anything large enough for the mugs, and no one had a way to make cocoa.
He shakes his head as the final announcement airs on the public address system.
He just wasn’t paying attention, that was all. He had been struck by the beauty of the American teacher, and he hadn’t looked at the students closely enough.
Now he has to go inside the Experience with the lights on full to make certain that no one spilled anything in there.
He’s going to have to report the elderly gent. The elderly gent was part of this whole thing. He probably shouldn’t be allowed near the Experience again.
The gardens are lovely, the air fresh and so very welcome. Tenesha is still holding her mug of cocoa, made seventy years before in another part of London. She’s still holding it, and it’s still warm. That’s got to be some kind of miracle.
Although she’s not feeling very miraculous. She’s sweaty and covered in soot. Her clothes reek, and she feels oddly betrayed.
The students seem happy enough. They think they went on the best ride ever, better than Disney World, better than Universal Studios, something so real they’ll talk about it for the rest of their lives.
Hennel and Mr. Maplethorpe know better. Mr. Maplethorpe walks alongside her. He seems to sense her mood, since he says nothing.
“You and my great-grandmother planned this, didn’t you?” Tenesha asks as they pass beautifully manicured rose bushes.
Mr. Maplethorpe looks straight ahead. “She’s been waiting for you to return to London. It’s put a strain on our magic.”
“Our magic?” Tenesha asks.
He nods. He puts a hand on her arm and stops her. Then he looks around to see if the students are following. They’ve huddled together, comparing notes. Hennel stands a few yards off, looking awkward, as if he wants to join Tenesha and Mr. Maplethorpe, but isn’t sure he’s welcome.
Tenesha’s not sure he’s welcome either. She wants to have this discussion alone.
“We have a group, you see,” Mr. Maplethorpe says. “It’s best if you have a group.”
“Great,” Tenesha says with sarcasm. “You have a group. I just discover that I have the power to travel through time and space, but you have a group, and my abilities strain your magic. I’m sorry.”
“We didn’t want you randomly traveling without understanding what happened,” Mr. Maplethorpe says. “We put a protect spell on you, placed you in your own little bubble so that you’d be safe. But we expected you to come back to England before you entered university. Instead, you did not return for six years. We’ve barely been able to control your magic.”
She almost sips the cocoa, then wonders if she should. Not because she suspects it will poison her, but because it’s oddly precious now, a relic of the past, of the experience that she has just had and doesn’t entirely understand.
“Maybe if you’d been honest with me. Or flown me out yourselves,” she says.
“We’re mostly pensioners—”
“Pensioners,” she says. “With no funds I suppose.”
He nods.
“I thought you were supposed to be magic. Why don’t you conjure up some diamonds or something?”
“It doesn’t work like that,” he says. “Our gifts don’t give us a choice. We’re not like you Americans portray in the movies. Our magicks are usually small, and often inconsequential. Yours, it turns out, is neither. The ability to travel through time is rare and valued. And your ability clearly spans longer than your life, which is the normal limitation on these things. You’ll be quite valuable, should you allow us to press you into service.”
“Service,” she says. “What kind of service? Something that’ll turn me into a pensioner when I’m old?”
He winces. “No, my dear,” he says. “Our guild has existed long before there were guilds. We split into several factions. There are the mercenary types—they run several corporations, including magical ones—and then there are those of us dedicated to service. We also split. We have those who do good works, and those who make certain we remain untouched. We haven’t had a time traveler in our guild in nearly three hundred years. And we could use one.”
He stares at her.
“I have a job,” she says.
He takes the mug from her and sets it on a nearby wooden bench. Then he takes her hands in his own. From a distance it probably looked like he was proposing.
“Whether you return to America or not,” he says, “you’ll need training. We no longer have the resources to keep your abilities under wraps.”
“I’m sure someone there can train me,” Tenesha says.
He sighs. “We have very few members of our guild in America. The corporate groups are much stronger, and they will charge you for lessons. We will not.”
She shrugs. “It’ll be expensive either way. I’d have to move to England.”
“It’s not the expense so much,” he says. “It’s the time it will take for you to find the proper instructors. You’d probably have to move there as well. Time travel is the most difficult to control. That’s part of our problem. It takes only a willingness to slip into someone else’s memories, and then you’re there. So if someone’s telling you an emotional story about the day their first child was born, you might conceivably find yourself at that birthing chamber.”
She doesn’t move, but her heart has started to pound. This sounds familiar. Lately, it has felt as if she’s stepped a little too close to her friends.
“Why do you think you’re a history major, my dear?” he says. “Because you have the ability to imagine history thoroughly? Bosh. You would hear a lecture and partially slide away, because our magic can’t quite hold you any longer. That slippage will get worse.”
“Why didn’t Grand tell me this?” Tenesha asks.
“She planned to when you visited. Then you gave this gift of the museum visit, and even asked her along. She would have come if I hadn’t needed someone to prove to Mr. Hennel that magic exists as well. His talents are smaller than yours, but no less valuable. He can convince people that he’s right when he speaks with conviction.”
Like he had with her when they discussed the Wizard of Oz.
“His powers can be dangerous if left alone. We’re hoping to train him to use them for good.”
Tenesha pulls her hands from Mr. Maplethorpe’s. Then she takes her mug back. It doesn’t even feel like a modern mug. It’s too thin. Nowadays, mugs have substance.
“You talk a good game,” she says. “You use all the right words—service, working for the good, making the right choices. But how do I know that you’re not some kind of opportunist or….”
She let her voice trail off. She almost said a scam artist, but she knows he’s not that. Because she really was in the past. So that much is true: she wouldn’t have believed anything if she hadn’t traveled back to the Blitz.
“Do you believe your great-grandmother would ever work on what you Americans would call the wrong side? She’s no opportunist, is she?”
Tenesha looks at him. Grand is a good woman. If Tenesha believes anything, she believes that.
“I’ll need to talk to her,” Tenesha says.
“Of course you will,” Mr. Maplethorpe says.
“You people are asking me to change my life.”
“Actually no. The moment you realized you have abilities your life changed. You now have the choice of direction. Of course you must proceed with caution. We would expect no less.”
He bows to her, a curious little movement that seems both courtly and dismissive. Then he walks back to Hennel, presumably to deal with that man’s reluctance with whatever scheme Mr. Maplethorpe has proposed to him.
“Hey, Ms. McGuire!” Denver walks toward her with the rest of the group with him. “We were wondering if we can go through the Blitz thing again tomorrow.”
You could, she thinks but doesn’t say, but you wouldn’t like it.
“I’m afraid we won’t be anywhere near the museum tomorrow,” she says, unable to remember their exact itinerary. Not that it matters. She now has an itinerary of her own.
She must see Grand again, and she has to talk about her future. She has to now learn and understand her own abilities. She has to decide who she is going to become.
Although that part isn’t as hard as she made it sound to Mr. Maplethorpe. She decided long ago that she’s not interested in money—no one who majors in history is—and she realized with her first summer job that she’s not suited to the corporate life.
Besides, Grand won’t live much longer, and Tenesha has always wanted to spend more time with her. Tenesha will learn about this guild and the abilities of everyone in it.
They can teach her how to prevent time-traveling to places like the Blitz. She doesn’t want to go through anything like that again—at least, not unexpectedly.
Then, if she doesn’t like what this guild stands for, she can strike out on her own. She is an American after all. A believer in the rights and powers of the individual.
She’ll make her own choices.
But they’ll be informed choices.
She smiles to herself, feeling better than she has in months. She feels like she has a direction now. She’s still not sure where she’s going, but she has time to figure that out.
A lot of time.
All the time in the world.
The Blitz Experience
Copyright © by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
Published by WMG Publishing
Cover and Layout copyright © by WMG Publishing
Cover design by WMG Publishing
Cover art copyright © depositedhar/DepositPhotos
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of !ction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are !ctional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
Any use of this publication to train generative arti!cial intelligence (“AI”) technologies is expressly prohibited. The author and publisher reserve all rights to license uses of this work for generative AI training and development of machine learning language models.
At the Keep, women serve one purpose: pawns for greater power. Power belonging to Micheline’s father. He uses magic to achieve that goal, but that magic serves another purpose, as well. It tests a woman’s purity. And what Micheline learns about this test will change her forever.
“Purity Test” is free on this website for one week only. The story is also available in Fantasies Collide Vol. 4 as a standalone anthology or in the Fantasy Bundle of Bundles Storybundle, in the volume Fantasies: A Colliding Storybundle Special Edition, which pairs the Fantasies Collide volume with volume four of Series Collides. The Fantasies edition will give you an additional 39 stories, along with other bundle of bundles from fourteen different authors. Lots and lots of reading there. You’ll get 47 ebooks for about $2 per book. Or, if you’re feeling minimalist, you can get your own standalone copy of the story at any retailer or pick up a copy here. Enjoy!
Purity TestKristine Kathryn RuschMy feet are scraped and bleeding, my slippers shredded and almost useless. The dress hangs in tatters around me. No longer white, it still bears the pearls along the bodice, and I hope I can keep them close, and sell them in whatever town I find myself in.
Provided I find a town. Provided I ever leave these woods.
I have traveled for two days, surviving on puddle water and berries, hoping that the sounds I hear behind me aren’t my father, Roland, and the dogs.
I was but a child when Sutton came to the Keep. He seemed like an old man even then, with a beard that trailed to his knees and white hair that fell about his shoulders. His fingers were long and fine, but his back was broad, like a laborer’s, and his skin was rough to the touch.
His eyes frightened me. They were a pale blue, so pale that, in a certain light, they seemed clear. When I mentioned them to my mother—she was alive then: alive, vibrant, and beautiful—she laughed.
“Of course, Micheline,” she said in her lilting accent, using—as she always did—her people’s version of my name. “He is magic. It is fitting he has devil’s eyes.”
My father said my mother was a witch, but she had no true magic powers. She knew the gentle arts—herbs for healing, mostly—and she had an enchanting laugh. Men were drawn to her, and women too. She had a personality that overshadowed all others, and dwarfed my father’s.
Apparently my father had once loved her. Perhaps he loved her still in the days surrounding Sutton’s arrival, but he did not trust her. If my brother and I had not had my father’s auburn hair and freckled skin, his green eyes and his hooked nose, he would have disavowed us as another man’s children, as he had done with my younger sister. She had the misfortune to look like our mother: nut brown eyes, features delicate and small, and black hair so thick it hung in waves down her back.
She was just a babe when Sutton arrived, and my father hadn’t yet denied her, but in hindsight, it is clear the poisoned thoughts were already in him, twisting him, marking him, making him a man incapable of warmth.
My mother’s death the following year—giving birth to yet another dark-haired babe, a boy who would not live till dawn—completed my father’s transformation. From that night forward, I never saw him smile nor speak a kind word.
The Keep was my father’s. It had been his father’s, and his father’s father before him. A large, rectangular building with four small towers, it looked more like a castle or a fortress. But we called it the Keep because it had once been part of a larger complex, filled with granaries and great houses and stables.
They had all crumbled before my father was born, but the ghosts of them remained, leaving their stone footprints on the property. A guard tower, which had once been part of an acres-long wall, still stood, empty and dust-covered. My brother and I used to explore it before my father hired a nurse after my mother’s death—a nurse who taught me how to stitch and sit quietly and never ever reveal my innermost thoughts.
The guard tower had four levels, and a winding staircase that made its way around the interior like braids on a maiden’s nape. The top level had an arching ceiling, and a view that extended for miles on all sides. My brother and I often hid up there from our mother, and she would pretend she could not find us, although our footprints littered the dust, and our giggles echoed through the levels below.
My father gave Sutton the guard tower as a home. Suddenly my brother and I were forbidden to go within sight distance of the place. We would sneak to the edge of the woods and watch as laborers brought all manner of strange things inside—tables made of shiny material we had never before seen, boxes of foul-smelling roots, and cloth so thin it seemed as if it weren’t woven at all.
Later, the horses would arrive—and cats and dogs—never to be seen again. Other animals as well, things I didn’t recognize, with horns and snouts and short stubby legs. They would vanish into the first floor of that tower, and sometimes we would hear cries and wails as if the very depths of hell had opened.
But that was after Mother had died. Before, there were no animals, and Sutton would join us at feasts. My mother would tease him—“What miracle have we performed today, Mr. Sutton?”—and he would answer her, telling her of sparkling air or reading stray thoughts. One evening, she made the mistake of laughing at him, and from then on, he would disavow miracles, claiming he did simple magic and nothing more.
My father believed Sutton’s magic was not simple. My father believed Sutton could return our family to its former glory—castles and land and serfs. My father would no longer be a small lord, but a great leader, a warrior-chieftain who might one day unite the other lords, and take on the name of King.
My father never saw that goal—we still have warring lords, arguing tribes, and no unity at all—but he came close.
He came desperately close.
And then I ran away.
But I get ahead of myself.
There were years between my rebellion and my mother’s death, years in which my father grew harsher and colder and more ambitious; years in which the strangeness of Sutton’s Tower grew; years in which entire buildings appeared behind it, all of them emitting horrible yowlings and fetid odors, and sometimes, a river of blood.
My father gave my sister to a convent when she was three. Years later, I asked him about her, and he claimed that while she was my sister, she was not his daughter, and he had no obligation to her. I visited to the convent once, and no one had heard of her.
She is lost. I do not know why or how.
I asked my brother, but he no longer cared. He became a soldier after my mother’s death. At the age of ten, he wielded a sword twice his size. From then on, I saw my brother only at meals.
He was not allowed to speak to me, and soon he refused to meet my eyes. The closeness we had felt vanished. He became a stranger who drank too much, laughed too hard, and fought recklessly.
When my father started thinking of my brother’s marriage, using my brother’s life to establish alliances, I thought little of it. It is the way among lords—the firstborn must make a good match, whatever the cost.
The women paraded before my brother were often not women at all. Some were mere children. The two years that separated my brother and me seemed like a gulf then. While I still spent time with my nurse learning demure ways to defer to my future husband, my brother had already seen our entire corner of the world.
My father would hold feasts to honor the families who brought their daughters to the Keep, seeking an alliance. I attended, but was not allowed to speak unless spoken to, and certainly could not discuss anything with the newcomers.
I did not understand enough of life to fathom my father’s concern with purity. I believed him obsessed with pureness of heart. He did not care about anyone’s heart, having lost his own. He cared only that the woman who married his son was a virgin, and he did not trust doctors and midwives to determine it was so.
So when the young women and their fathers left the feasting hall with my father and Sutton, I thought it a common enough custom. I did not understand the protestations of some lords, the unwillingness of many to even come to our small Keep.
Once I overheard some soldiers speculating about my father’s determination. The soldiers believed that my father investigated the girl’s private parts the way a midwife would, while the girl’s own father looked on.
But the soldiers were as naïve as I was, only in a different way. They did not understand what a midwife later told me—that a girl’s virginity could not always be determined with a look or a touch, that sometimes, a virgin had no proof of it, condemning the innocent girl to charges of promiscuity when, in truth, she had never lain with a man.
The midwife who told me this also confided that she believed this happened to my mother. The wedding night, the midwife said, was a disaster. No blood had spilled on the white sheets, so everyone thought my mother’s maidenhood had not been intact at the time of the wedding.
Yet for her entire marriage, my mother claimed she had never touched a man other than my father.
I am exhausted. This forest seems to run forever. The wind echoes in here, whispering through the branches of the mighty oaks that hid the sun. The ground is rugged. I move slower now; my feet so sore that I limp even though I try not to.
I can no longer run.
I look at the tall trees, at the welcoming thick branches with their wide forks, and remember what it was like to be a child, hiding among the leaves.
I think of hiding now. It would be so easy. I would tie what’s left of my shoes to the shreds of my dress, then wedge my bare feet against the rough bark. I would wrap my hands around an easy-to-reach branch, and climb, pulling myself upward until the leaves hide me from the ground below.
My father wouldn’t find me. Neither would Roland or the others.
But the dogs would. I’d seen them tree a cat many times at the edge of the forest, surrounding the trunk, their paws scraping against the bark, baying and howling and barking until someone came.
I used to laugh at the dogs, but I do not now. I think of my father’s cleverness, his intense determination to get whatever he wants, and I shiver.
I continue to stumble forward. I cannot hear the dogs.
I am gaining a fragile hope. Perhaps they have returned to their pen. Perhaps my father has returned to his Keep.
Perhaps this final humiliation will break him.
But most likely, it makes him stronger. My father thrives in adversity.
He made his greatest mistakes when he believed the world was his for the taking.
She was tall, like my mother, a woman full grown. A few years older than my brother, she was still unwed. Her fiancé—a man of honor, her father said—had died on the battlefield, and she had mourned him which was unusual in an alliance that had been arranged from birth.
Her name was Opal, and I thought her the most beautiful creature I had seen. Her hair was so blond it was almost white, and it accented her chiseled cheekbones and sky blue eyes.
She did not smile. She made it clear she had no desire to come to our little Keep and see our pretend kingdom. She did not want to be the lady of this land.
She would, she told my father, eyes blazing in defiance, mourn her lost love for eternity.
“Fine,” my father said to her, “I do not care how you feel, only that, should the alliance be made, you do your part and produce sons.”
She spat at his feet.
Her own father apologized for her. He believed the union advantageous to both families. We had adjoining property, and weaker lords on either side. We could mount an army, he said, and take even more land. He was too old to lead. He would leave that to my father, so long as both families shared in the spoils.
The bargain was made before my brother ever saw his intended.
Not that it mattered. He was smitten from the moment he first looked at that stunning face. She slapped him when he got too close, and after he recovered from his shock, he slapped her in return.
My father laughed.
“Passion,” he said. “It guarantees sons.”
But there were no sons. There was no marriage. Opal would not submit to my father’s ministrations. Her own father pleaded, saying there could be no alliance without a guarantee, but she refused.
My father came to me for the first and last time in my life.
“Do you know your mother’s potions?” he asked.
“Some,” I said. “I was too young to learn most of them.”
“A sleeping potion is all I need,” he said.
I could do that.
I felt so pleased to help my father. Finally he had turned to me. Finally he had noticed me.
I would do anything he wanted.
I completed the potion in the space of a morning, and tested it on the nurse. She slept deeply, but continued to breathe—always a risk with a sleeping potion. Then I took it to my father.
He thanked me, and said no more.
But I knew he had plans, and I knew they concerned Opal. He had a servant pour the potion in Opal’s wine at that night’s feast. She yawned within minutes, excused herself, and was nearly asleep before she reached the guest quarters.
I excused myself as well, snuck into the guest quarters, and hid across the hall from her room. I wanted to know what my father was up to.
Around midnight, when the feast had dissolved into a drunken party, my father and Sutton came up the servants’ stairs. My father unlocked Opal’s door and went inside. Sutton remained in the hall.
He did not see me, but then Sutton never saw me. His gaze always skimmed past me as if I were a servant, beneath his notice, someone who did not exist.
Still, I did not move. I scarcely breathed.
After a moment, my father exited the room, the sleeping Opal cradled in his arms. He was a strong man, but he had trouble with her weight. Her arms and legs dangled, her hair trailing to the floor. Her feet were bare, her nightdress barely covering her torso.
She slept as soundly as Nurse.
The men tiptoed down the stairs, and I followed as closely as I dared. They wound through the back corridors, past the still hot ovens, toward the yards.
I hated the yards. The stench was abominable—pigs, and cows, and chickens running free. This late, the animals slept, all except one sow who lifted her head from the putrid muck and watched as the men hurried by.
I gave the pigs a wide berth. But the sow put her head down before I passed, and did not watch me at all.
The men went beyond the yards to Sutton’s Tower. My father set Opal on an old stone garden seat and remained with her, while Sutton opened the doors to one of the tower’s new sections. Then Sutton stood aside.
I circled along my old secret path, moving closer so that I could see. I ended up on the edge of the woods, and hid behind an old stump covered with weeds. I made no sound at all. My father did not see me, and Sutton never would.
The fresh scent of evergreen and crushed grass cleared the stench of the yards from my nose. The ground was damp with late-night dew, soaking my slippers within moments. But I didn’t mind; I liked the night and the darkness. I would have enjoyed it more, if it weren’t for the strangeness of my father and Sutton.
They both stared at those open doors. My father leaned against the back of that bench, hands clenched, Opal forgotten behind him. Sutton shifted nervously.
“Perhaps you should move, milord,” he said.
My father nodded, then stepped aside, heading away from me.
At that moment, a light flared inside the new room. The yellow edges of it caught Sutton as if he were a thief. The light came closer and closer, almost blinding in its intensity.
I squinted, and crouched even lower beside the trunk. The light illuminated the dried leaves, the drops of water on the broken blades of grass, the rich brown of the earth near my feet. I wasn’t sure if the light illuminated me as well.
Fortunately, my father did not see me at all. Neither did Sutton. They were staring at a white horse that had emerged from the doors, a white horse with a long horn. From the tip of that horn came the bright light. The horse had blue eyes and a mane the pale colors of the rainbow. The colors shifted with each of the horse’s movements.
Sutton moved to the side, out of the way of the horse. My father placed a hand above his eyes, shielding them.
The horse pranced forward. It paused for a moment. It did not look at the bench.
It looked at me.
I crouched even lower, but I felt the brightness of that light upon me. I raised my head ever so slightly. The horse had not moved, but one of the bright blue eyes held mine.
I shook my head, thinking, No, please, stay away, don’t let them see me.
The horse whinnied, nodded, then turned as if it were guided by unseen hands. It returned to the building, sliding through the doors, and disappeared.
The light slowly faded, but left reflections across my eyes.
“They lied,” my father said. “The unicorn did not go to her. She is not a virgin.”
“It is understandable, given her advanced age—”
“It is not understandable,” my father said. “She has been misrepresented.”
He walked to the doors and pushed them closed. Sutton hadn’t moved.
“Either the virgins are too young,” Sutton said, “or you cannot come to terms with their fathers. Perhaps you should take this one, demand a greater bride price since she is damaged—”
“I will not condemn my son to relive my life!” my father snapped. “I have told you this.”
“Then betroth the boy to a young one. Have him marry her the moment she comes of age.”
“We’ll have to retest her.”
“But the difference is that these fathers know what you’re doing. They won’t allow their daughters to be tainted.”
My father sighed. Then he shook his head, and started back toward the Keep.
“What of the girl?” Sutton asked.
“Leave her,” my father said. “She no longer matters to me.”
I waited until Sutton disappeared into his tower, and the lights went out. Then I roused Opal as best I could. She was much bigger than I was, so I could not carry her even if I had the strength.
Instead, I let her lean on me as if she had had too much ale, and helped her back to her room. With luck, she would remember nothing of the trip when she finally awoke.
But I did. The magical horse with its ability to find pure women, my father’s unwillingness to treat Opal with the least civility, and the vehemence in his voice when he spoke of his own life made me leery.
Soon my brother found himself engaged to a child of ten. The wedding, planned three years hence, predated my own by only a few months. He is wed now, though not happily. His young wife is a shrew, and he sees her only to perform his duties or so he says.
I vowed I would not have such a marriage. I vowed I would have warmth in my life, and laughter, like we had when my mother lived.
Although I made these vows, I was not sure I could keep them.
Then my father introduced me to Roland.
Roland was a tall man with broad shoulders that tapered into a narrow waist. His eyes crinkled in the corners, and his smile softened his face. He too carried the blood of my mother’s people—the black hair and the dark, dark eyes—but he did not have their ways.
His land lay between my father’s and the sea, most of it forest, all of it valuable. If he allied with my father, he would become part of a clan that extended from the shore to the hills—the most land in all the south.
My father wasn’t yet a king, but he was becoming the largest landowner in the entire country, almost large enough to raise an army equal to that of those who called themselves his betters.
With Roland’s help, my father would finally be in position.
The nuptial negotiations went on before I met Roland, but I did not care. I had always known I would marry to serve my father’s dynastic needs. I had no control over that. I merely hoped I could stomach the union my father chose.
When I met Roland, I was pleased to find him handsome and overjoyed at his tenderness when he took my hand, the softness in his voice when he spoke my name.
There would be affection in this marriage, affection and warmth and laughter. I could build a home as my mother had, and stop thinking about the darkness that was growing around the Keep.
By the time I met Roland, I had stopped walking all over my father’s land. I particularly avoided Sutton’s Tower—not because of the strange horse they called a unicorn, but because of the corpses I sometimes found near the wood.
The cat was strange enough. I had discovered it, with its small head and tiny horn, the twisted back and the stunted tail, shortly after my mother’s death. But the dogs, protrusions around their mouths, half formed wings on their backs, disturbed me most. I imagined I saw suffering still in their dead eyes.
The screams and squeals that came from Sutton’s Tower took on a sinister cast for me after that night with Opal, and despite the beauty of the unicorn beast, I realized Sutton was dabbling in something that threatened us all.
For I had no doubt he created these beasts with a particular goal in mind, just as he developed this unicorn to serve my father’s fancy.
I did not think of the virginity then. I thought of it as part of a parcel of a woman’s purity of heart rather than the goal of Sutton’s experiment.
At that point, I also did not think of the quick way in which the unicorn had found me.
I thought, once I met Roland, my life was set.
The morning of my wedding—yesterday morning—I stood in my dressing room as the seamstress stitched me into my gown. The wedding dress had a thousand seed pearls for a thousand years of happiness, and a necklace of full-sized pearls sewn into the collar. They matched the pearls along the veil, as did the pearls on the cuffs of my sleeve.
The hairdresser coiled my thick hair around my face, pinched my cheeks, and showed me my reflection in the looking glass. A woman full grown—a beautiful woman, whose skin was as luminous as the pearls, whose softly glowing cheeks reflected the color of her rich auburn hair, whose eyes shown with the light of a thousand-year future—stared at me from the glass.
I did not know that my drunken father had revealed a secret to my bridegroom the night before.
“When you are my son-in-law,” my father whispered, “I will show you how to become rich. I have a beast that approaches only virginal women and shuns those who are not. I used it to ensure the purity of my son’s bride, and I shall lease it out to other fathers who want to do the same.”
That morning—yesterday morning—I was not thinking of the unicorn or my hungover father. I fantasized about life away from the Keep, about the life I would build with my husband-to-be, about the children we would have—dark-haired girls who looked like my mother, and auburn-haired boys who would remind me of my brother before my father took him away.
I was preparing for happiness, as if it were my due.
As I went down the back stairs to the Great Hall where the guests and the priest waited, my brother found me. His left eye was swollen shut, his cheek speckled with blood, his knuckles raw.
“What happened to you?” I asked.
“I’m sorry,” he said, and swept me into his arms.
I was too surprised to struggle. “What’s going on?”
“Roland,” he said with a touch of bitterness, “insists.”
That was enough for me. I would do what Roland said because he was going to be my husband, because I was beginning to believe I loved him, and because I thought he could do no wrong.
Together my brother and I tucked my veil into my bodice, and twined my train around his hand. Then he carried me through the kitchens and into the yards, careful to keep the foul muck from touching me or my dress.
The pigs were awake. They grunted as we passed. The chickens fled, making a half-hearted attempt to fly, and the cows simply looked over their shoulders, surprised that anyone would try to disturb them.
My heart pounded. My mother’s people had a separate wedding ceremony, one that came first, one that guaranteed the union would not be sullied by its brush with the church.
I hoped Roland wanted that, because the other thing—the unicorn—meant he did not trust me, he did not believe me, he needed proof before our first night together.
I had kept myself pure. I had not touched another man. My father would not allow me to be alone with Roland—“You must watch her,” my father had said. “She is tainted by her mother’s blood.”—so in no way could I be impure.
But my word did not count. Women like Opal had twisted my father further, made him believe even less. But I wouldn’t have expected it of Roland.
The moment my brother carried me out of the yards, however, I saw how wrong I was. Roland’s lovely face had a bruised cheek, and the corner of his mouth carried dried blood.
My brother had defended me, and lost. As his price, he had to fetch me to this hideous place so that a creature not created by God could attest to my virginity.
Sutton stood beside the doors, as he had that awful night with Opal. My father stood beside Roland near the fence.
“What caused this?” I asked my brother.
He told me about the drunken conversation, the creature my father had Sutton create to do his bidding, and the allure it held for Roland.
“Roland merely wants to see it work,” my brother said. “This is his best chance.”
Those words should have soothed me.
They did not.
My brother carried me to the stone bench. “It’s just a formality,” he said in an apologetic tone. “You’ll be all right.”
Perhaps I would have been. Perhaps the moment would have passed swiftly, and I would have forgotten Roland’s betrayal, my father’s willingness to show off his toy, and Sutton’s desire to humiliate all women.
But I remembered my first view of the unicorn. It had been an impressive beast from a distance, and I feared it up close. What did it do to determine virginity?
I knew the woman lived after the test—my brother’s wife was proof of this—but was she changed? Had my brother’s wife been a charming child, only to become a shrew after the touch of that ethereal light?
Had she been burned by a spawn of Satan, created by a man who was in league with the devil?
Had the experience so warped her mind that she never trusted again?
I turned on that stone bench, my dress catching on the rough edges, holding me in place.
Sutton opened the doors, and the light flared, as it had before. Only this time, I could see inside the building, see the stable filled with hay, the white horse—the unicorn—and the perfection of its equine face. The blue eyes seemed natural in the light of day, and the pale rainbow hues of the mane seemed a product of the torch that burned atop that strange horn.
The unicorn pranced toward me, its head lifted, its tail up, as if it were coming toward someone it knew and loved.
And, God help me, I raised my hands to my mouth, as terrified—more terrified—than I had been that night in the woods. I could scarcely breathe.
Please, no, I thought. Don’t come near me. Don’t hurt me. Please.
The unicorn stopped in confusion. It looked over its shoulder at Sutton, then at my father, and finally at me.
A tear traced its way down my cheek. Please …
The unicorn nodded, tilted its head, and I felt a warmth, an understanding. Perhaps—
The word was not mine. I squeezed my eyes tightly shut and cowered, preparing for the touch of that magic light. Instead, I heard a whinny and my father’s cursing, and then Roland—Roland!—screaming, “You liar. You barbaric liar! You promised me a virgin bride, a good girl, and what do we have? A whore. A whore in virgin white.”
I opened my eyes.
My father was staring at me as if he had never seen me before. My brother started walking toward the yards, his back to me, as if I no longer mattered.
Roland grabbed my veil and yanked it off my head. His hand held my hair, pulling it so hard my scalp ached.
He raised his hand to cuff me, and I came alive. I punched him in the stomach, then kicked him in the knee, making his leg crumble. I shoved him away, tugged my hair from his grasp, and ran toward the forest.
“Stop her!” Roland shouted.
“Why would you want to do that?” Sutton asked. “She’s not what you want.”
“I never said I wouldn’t marry her,” Roland snapped. “She just has to be punished for her betrayal, so that it would never happen again.”
My betrayal. Mine? What about his? Who had that loving man been, that hero of my dreams, the husband who would take me from all of this?
A figment of my imagination?
A lie?
I had done nothing, and he had accused me of betrayal.
I kept running, hoping my father would defend me. It was a false test, he would say, created to ferret other men’s lies.
But he said nothing. Finally, Sutton shouted, “Milord, we need her. She must not get away!”
“She is her mother,” my father said, his voice half-hidden beneath my ragged breathing, my panic. “I should have known.”
And then I was in the trees, my dress catching on bark. I ripped the bottom half away and kept running, tears flowing down my cheeks.
“We’ll never catch her now,” Roland shouted. “Get the dogs!”
I hit a clearing and slipped on a patch of dirt. My feet went out from under me, and I landed on my back. The dirt moved. I was sliding downward. I hit a rock at the bottom, tumbled forward, and struggled to catch my breath.
Behind me I heard nothing.
I had a few moments. If they were going to get the dogs, I had only a few moments. But I had to outthink them. If I could stay away from the dogs, I could run through the woods and maybe make it to the shore, and my mother’s people.
Or if I came out near a village, I could sell the pearls, and get enough gold to buy food, new clothing, maybe even a horse. I could live on my own somewhere else, where there was no magic, no family, and no betrayals.
For the first time, I thanked my father for all his fox-hunting conversations at the various feasts. I knew how foxes somehow escaped the dogs. I had tricks that I could at least try.
I ripped my dress, strung some of the shredded pieces down a side path, then backtracked my steps. I held the dress up so that it wouldn’t catch any more and headed forward, crossing a small stream so that the dogs would lose my scent.
Then I hurried deep into the forest, always moving, never stopping, forever listening, for barking, baying, and the sounds of the hunt.
I am near collapse. A few berries, little water, no rest. I doubt I can keep going much longer.
Yet the forest continues forever. Perhaps there is no end to it. Perhaps I’ll die in here, alone, unmourned, spoken of as the humiliation of my family if I’m ever spoken of again.
I keep thinking I hear dogs, but they’re not barking. They crash through the woods, occasionally huff as if something pricks them. I never think of dogs as silent creatures, hunting with determination.
Maybe my father didn’t take Roland’s suggestion. Maybe I’m fleeing for no reason.
Maybe no one is searching for me at all.
That thought makes me stop. I bend over, trying to catch my breath. Little spots dance in front of my eyes. I stand, brace a hand against a tree trunk, and blink, hoping I don’t pass out.
The crashing, ever so faint. I have heard it since yesterday.
The dogs bay when they tree a fox. They bark when they get close, letting their masters know that the fox is within sight.
This part of the forest is too dense for horseback riding. My father, Roland, my brother, they would have to come on foot.
I cannot hear them, either.
The idea that they would not come hurts more than the idea that they’re chasing me. It merely confirms that I have no value. That I am nothing to my father, my brother, and a man I once thought my beloved.
I am nothing.
The huffing gets even closer, and I see something white through the trees. White, yet filled with the colors of the rainbow.
My breath catches. I blink, wondering if I am so exhausted that I’m seeing visions.
Then the unicorn steps into the patch of trees. Its flank is scratched, its mane filled with leaves and burrs. It stares at me, the blue eyes filled with knowledge.
Stop running. Please.
The voice in my head is not my own. I lean against the tree, using it to hold me up.
I am so sorry. I didn’t know turning away would make them abandon you.
“How can you speak?” I whisper.
I don’t speak. I have thoughts. I can share them with women like you. It’s part of the magic.
The unicorn bows its head. The horn—which is not flaring with light—nearly hits a tree branch.
I didn’t want them to hurt you. I thought if they let you go, you would be safe. I didn’t realize until too late you belonged to them.
“Not any more.” My voice is weak, even though I’m no longer trying to whisper.
It’s better this way. You have no idea how cruel they are.
Because I closed my eyes. I did not want to see. They were part of my home.
But I wanted to get away. I wanted a perfect, happy life with Roland.
“How did you escape?”
They didn’t close the door. I followed you. They didn’t even realize I had left.
But they would. My father guards his possessions, at least the ones he values. The ones he doesn’t value get lost.
Like my sister.
“They’ll come for you.”
Yes.
Unlike me. They won’t come for me.
But they won’t catch me if I don’t want them to. We can stay together.
“Why would I stay with you?” I ask, then wince at the cruelty in my speech. Cruelty that hides some truth. Why would I stay with this thing? I don’t even know what it is.
I don’t know what I am either. Except that I do not fit there. Neither do you. We are of a kind, and we are alone. Let us stay together. I will help you travel, and you will help me learn. And somehow, we will stay away from them.
A shiver runs through me. “You read my thoughts.”
When they’re powerful enough.
“Only mine?”
Yes.
The unicorn raises its head. Our gazes meet. Its blue eyes are gentle.
It has never ever been cruel to me. In fact, it is the only one in my life who has ever heard me or done as I asked.
I step forward, hand extended. “May I touch you?”
Yes.
I do. The hair on its nose is rough beneath my fingers, like horsehair. The horn does not flare with light, but looks very solid.
The unicorn watches me, its body trembling.
Except for our breathing, the woods are silent. Not even a bird chirps. And no dogs bark, no humans crash through the bushes.
No one knows where we are.
“Have you ever seen the sea?” I ask.
I do not even know what a sea is. It continues to watch me, its mane shifting from red to pink to white to blue.
“It’s where my mother’s people live.” Where everyone laughs with joy, and doesn’t judge, where they marry not in front of a priest, but by clasping hands and vowing eternal love.
I believe in love, it says.
“So do I.” I smile. That’s enough, at least for a beginning.
I put my hand on its flank.
Together, the unicorn and I walk through the forest, away from my father’s land, across Roland’s, all the way to the sea.
Purity Test
Copyright © by Kristine Kathryn Rusch Published by WMG Publishing
Cover and Layout copyright © by WMG Publishing Cover design by WMG Publishing
Cover art copyright © Tjapa2007/Dreamstime
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
Any use of this publication to train generative artificial intelligence (“AI”) technologies is expressly prohibited. The author and publisher reserve all rights to license uses of this work for generative AI training and development of machine learning language models.
I just curated a Storybundle called The Fantasy Bundle of Bundles. You see, Storybundle is a bundle of ebooks by different writers on a theme. The concept behind this Storybundle is that each writer contribute a bundle of books. My main contribution is the entire Faerie Justice series in a compilation that you will never find anywhere else. My secondary contribution is in collaboration with Dean Wesley Smith. We’ve put together two books from our Collides collection—one is a book of fantasy short stories from our various series, and the other is a collection of otherworldly fantasy tales.
Those are only two of the bundles in this bundle of bundles. You’ll get stories from 12 other writers…or maybe 50 other writers, if you think of all of the contributors to the anthology series you will find here. All of the ebooks are exclusive to this bundle of bundles. You won’t find them anywhere else.
So much reading! Go take a look! Click here to get yours.
All spring we’ve been counseling writers who have come to realize that going wide with ebooks is not bringing in the kind of income that the writers had hoped for. The days off to all the retailers and making a small fortune are gone. Now, writers need to expand their horizons even more, doing other things that aren’t as intuitive as putting books in bookstores.
Finally, Dean Wesley Smith and I asked writers on my social media accounts and Dean’s website if they’d like to see a seminar on expanding income opportunities. Everyone said yes.
Honestly, we need this too. Every few years, indie writers need a refresher course in what’s available. They also need to figure out what they want to do with their limited non-writing time. So, we’re excited to do this seminar. Here’s the information, mostly cribbed from Dean’s website. (The “I” in the piece from here on out is Dean.) Btw, since we compiled this list, we’ve come up with a lot more. As I said, very exciting!
What is this all about? Basically showing writers and indie publishers how to make at least $40,000 per year and even more if you are already making that much. The more we talked about doing this and talked with others, the more we knew it would be fun for us to lay all this out. And help our own business in the process.
So many writers are getting discouraged by not making much money, and yet they don’t even realize how the cash streams are built. In essence, this will be an awareness seminar on all the fifty or seventy or more major and minor ways of helping yourself make a living beyond just putting your work in the major stores around the world. Being wide around the world we will consider a basic starting point.
And don’t worry, we will explain completely what “being wide” entails. Got a hunch most are missing places for cash streams that would be very simple to add in.
This course will be for writers of all levels. From a number of short stories published to fifty or more major books. For early stage writers, much of this will be down the road, but it will be good to learn about and plan for. For more advanced writers, this will be a way to explore things you might not have thought of, or have thought of and are not sure if it would be worth your time to add in.
SPECIAL FEATURE!! And for everyone, since indie publishing is changing so fast, we are adding in one special feature. In one year we will update everything and add new information and videos into the class and do an extra webinar or two. And then we will do it again in two years. And in three years. If you are in the class this first time, there will be no extra charge. You automatically will get all the updates every summer.
We plan to divide up the many, many, many ways to make money with your writing into various levels. And trust me, a lot of these ways will not suit you, but the key is to find ways that fit with your business and your writing.
There is no right way to make a living. But there are hundreds and hundreds of ways to make a living your way.
Here are some samples of what we will discuss and learn how to do on each level…
LEVEL ONE (The major and obvious cash streams…) + — Kickstarter (and Kickstarter imitators) + — Patreon (how to use it for a cash stream) + — Substack (and how to use it for a cash stream) + — Shopify (direct sale… when to set up and so much on how to use it) + — Direct Sales (book fairs, and the like, the problems, the good things, the costs) + — Audio (huge area on costs, how to do it, how to use it, when to bring in AI and how to judge… so much stuff) + — Nonfiction Writing (how to have it help your fiction writing and make money.) + — Translation (changing all the time… markets are growing and AI translations will be discussed as well.) + — Short Fiction (a ton of ways to help make money here, more than you can imagine, actually.)*
And about a dozen others at this major level… As I said, we are way into over seventy possible cash streams and increasing the count all the time as things pop up. These lists are just basic core sample lists.
LEVEL TWO (Not so obvious cash streams.) + — Bundles + — Bookbub (and other smaller ones… how to make money on them) + — YouTube (a ton of things here… wow) + — Social Media platforms (beyond Facebook, a long ways beyond… and not ads) + — Merch (not licensing, just selling your own and how and where… this combines really well with book fairs) + — Newsletters, blogs, and readers clubs (huge area and a lot of ways to do them to build readers)*
And a ton more beyond these as well. So, so much information and so many cash streams that are possible.
It will be a lot of information to talk about in four weeks and that is why we say the minimum of videos will be 5 per day or 100 over the four weeks. (Again, you can do them at your own pace and no assignments.)
THE STRUCTURE OF THE SEMINAR…Five days per week, five or more videos per day. Four weeks long. Questions will be answered either privately or in videos for all to see as extras, depending on the question. Four webinars, one per week to focus on each week’s topics and what has gone before. Webinars will also be recorded.
Webinars will be starting in the second week on Wednesday at 4PM West Coast Time.
In the second, third, and fourth years, (every summer, late July) more videos will be added and more webinars scheduled to talk about the new and changing details. The key in this new industry is to stay informed as things change and this will be a great way of doing that, plus for new writers building a career, every year will be a great check-in point for yourself on progress.
No assignments, no requirements. You can go over the videos at your own pace, but keeping up will help you in the webinars. And, of course, they will be there to go back to at any point.
First day’s videos appear Monday, August 17th and the last videos for the first year will be posted on Friday September 11th, with the last webinar being the following week.
Cost is $500 but we have an early bird discount of $400 until August 1st.
Still room to get into the class so no need to write ahead at this point.
Send the $400 early-bird fee to PayPal to the email address* dean@wmgpublishingstore.com* (dead email only used for PayPal.) I will let you know I got it and put you on the list.
Questions, write me directly.
Hope you can join us in this really fun seminar. This will be amazing in so many ways.
This post is a chapter from my book, The Write Attitude, which is now in a second edition. I’m posting it here to entice you to to pick up a copy. You can buy copies in ebook. Here’s a link to the ebook on the WMG Books site, but you can get the ebook anywhere. The paper will be available soon.
The second edition of The Write Attitude is quite different from the first edition, which originally appeared in 2016. I kept some parts of the original book, but much of the material is newer. The new material comes from my Patreon page. Not every post from my Patreon page shows up here, although several do. If you want to see everything, though, head to Patreon and sign up.
This post is from September of 2025, and is in the first section of the book.
SHORT STORY CRAFTFrom 2025
I’ve been working with a handful of wonderful writers on their craft. I offered a few mentorships last year to keep myself focused on craft while our personal business world was so fraught. I work with scenes and short stories, because I don’t read other people’s novels.
Occasionally, one of the writers I’m working with will comment that they forced the story they were writing into some arbitrary length (3500 words or 7500 words) because they’d been told that short fiction had to be short.
At first, I thought this was a problem that just one writer had, but no. I saw it more than once from writers who should know better.
The story you tell should be the length it takes to tell the story. Period.
If you have to turn in a short story for an anthology deadline or you are doing something crafty (like working with me), and the story you started runs long, either finish that story or set it aside. Then write a new story. Rinse, repeat, until you find a story that hits the proper length.
Do not ever shorten a story because you think someone won’t read it if it is too long. No. Not ever. Just don’t do it.
Especially now with indie publishing. A story is the length it needs to be to tell the tale. And nothing more.
That experience, plus heading back to the University of Las Vegas, Nevada this fall has storytelling in my front brain.
The class I’m taking is Theatre History, from the dawn of the theatre through the Reformation. (Next semester takes us past that.) It’s a survey class, focused on the developments and changes in the theatre from the ancient Greeks (more or less) onward. (Yes, we’re dealing with non-Western traditions as well. But mostly Western stuff, which begins with the Greeks.)
A history of theatre is a history of storytelling. The tools that we’re studying are tools to improve storytelling and make sure it holds the audience’s attention.
After class on Monday, I went to the Union for a late lunch and pulled out a paper edition of The Mysterious Bookshop Presents The Best Mystery Stories of the Year: 2024, edited by Anthony Horowitz. I don’t want to study at lunch and I don’t want to scroll through my phone. So I bring short stories which usually gets me through a half an hour or so.
I read the Jeffrey Deaver short story, “The Lady in My Life.” I’m a fan of his work, buying the latest novel new each time one appears. I like his short fiction as well, with a caveat that I will get to below.
The structure that this particular volume of the Best Mystery Stories uses is this: A bio of the author, the story, followed about an “about the story,” written by the author.
In Deaver’s case, he wrote that “The Lady in My Life” was based on a song, so that he could contribute to an anthology edited by Don Bruns. Deaver said that was all he could tell us about the story because, like the previous 100 stories he wrote, this one has a “big twist” at the end.
Then he went on to say this:
A short story…exists for one reason only.
A breathtaking shock.
They’re like an illusionist’s tricks. Setup, shocking reveal, and the thought: How the hell did the author do that?
No character studies, no important messages.
Just an unexpected blow to the gut.
Anyway, that’s what I strive for.
I sat at the table in the Union, conversations flowing around me, sunlight pouring in the big windows, and thought about that for a few minutes.
I had two simultaneous reactions:
And
Let’s deal with #2 first.
When I read “The Lady in My Life,” I actually stopped in the middle and went back to the opening scene. I knew I was missing something, because that first scene seemed tacked on—too character-focused for a Deaver story. I knew the twist was somewhere in those opening pages.
In other words, I wasn’t lost in that piece of fiction: I was looking for the surprise.
The first time I ever read that way was in my twelfth year. I binge-read Agatha Christie. I was sprawled on my very 1970s brown and orange bedspread in my bedroom in our 1920s farmhouse on a Sunday afternoon. Tattered paperback library books were scattered around me. I was staring at them as if they held a message because I realized in that moment the Christie books had a pattern.
The person whodunnit was the person you least expected.
A few weeks later, I was in the same position on the same ugly bedspread, frowning at Murder on the Orient Express. I thought I had figured out Christie’s pattern, but…
SPOILER ALERT FOR A 91-YEAR-OLD NOVEL
…everyone had a motive. No one was the person you could least expect. Not a single character.
Because, you see, it turns out they all did it. Every last one of the passengers on that train. (Except the mighty Hercule Poirot, detective extraordinaire, of course.)
I actually felt cheated, and a little stupid. These days, when I miss something, I’m excited by it. I got fooled and it’s hard to fool me, at least in fiction. Then I want to know how the author did it.
But my discovery about Christie was so new, so profound (to me), that I couldn’t believe she had played that trick on me. Personally. Because, you know, writers only write for one person. The single reader on her ugly orange-and-brown bedspread in the quiet of her room.
(Cue peals of laughter here.)
Deaver’s short stories feel like Christie’s novels to me. That’s probably half of a compliment. I like them enough to read them, but I don’t get lost in them, and my goal, as a reader and a writer, is to get lost in fiction.
Instead, Deaver’s stories are an intellectual exercise for me. Can I see through them on one reading with no reread?
This surprise I got half of, but that’s all that was available to me. He actually withheld information, which irritates the piss out of me as a reader. Give me the information in such a way that I won’t see it. Don’t hide it from me.
Grump.
I’m not here to tear apart Deaver’s short stories. He’s a master writer. He’s created iconic characters in his novels (Lincoln Rhyme, Kathryn Dance, Colter Shaw), and he’s written some short stories that I think are among the best I’ve ever read.
But the only reason a short story exists is to shock the reader?
No. And God, no.
My reaction to that is profoundly visceral and not just because I can predict what he’s going to do with 90% of his short stories.
It’s the way he denies things that I adore about short fiction.
I love a good character sketch, one that puts me in someone else’s brain for a while, one that reveals rather than tells.
I love a good political rant, even if I disagree with it.
I love a good romance, although I know that the ending will probably be a happily-for-now. (It’s almost impossible to do a happily ever after in a short story, although I have seen it done successfully.)
I love a good historical exploration of a time I will never see.
I love a good adventure—be it in space or in the near future, in a made-up fantasy world, or a world slightly askew from ours. Or heck, in our world in places I will never get to.
His little note dismisses almost everything I love about short stories and boils them down to one thing. One predictable thing.
Because if you always write big twist endings, the readers stop reading for enjoyment. They want to beat you at your game. Sure, it’s fun, but I’d rather not know how the story is going to end going in. Unless, of course, it’s a romance, and even then, I like to be surprised by the journey to get to that happily for now.
That heck-no feeling I had when I read Deaver’s author note was not just from me the reader. It was also from me the author.
I don’t want to be limited to one way and one way only of writing anything, let alone short fiction. I can’t think of anything duller than writing the same story over and over and over again.
To be fair to Deaver, he doesn’t do that in his long-form fiction. He writes something different most of the time, although he does rely on the big reveal or the surprise twist a lot. In this too, he reminds me of Christie. He’s writing in the same genre most of the time (all of the time?), but he researches or experiences new places or new tech to explore in his fiction.
Christie traveled, and wrote about “exotic” locales, at least from the British reading public’s point of view. So many readers read her books to experience vistas they would never normally see, particularly in the Poirot books.
I have too much of a hummingbird brain to focus on just one thing. I like dipping in and out of different genres. I like writing standalone books and short stories. I like exploring different topics.
Yes, that has a downside too. It means I’m slower than most writers in getting to the next book in a series, but it also means that I bring fresh perspective to that series when I return.
I can’t tell you how many writer friends have complained to me about writing in the same series over and over again, and feeling like they can’t write anything else “because their readers don’t want it.”
That last quote is a quote that someone in traditional publishing (an editor, the head of the sales force) told the poor writer. Because traditional publishers and editors told me that about my work too, and I ignored them. I ended up with a lot of pen names instead, knowing that I couldn’t limit myself to one series, one topic, one genre…or one big twist.
I don’t believe in closing the door to any kind of storytelling. The story is what it wants to be. It might not end up as science fiction by the end. It might not be a crime story, even though it started that way. It might not be a romance after all.
There might be a big reveal or a breathtakingly small moment. And yes, there might be a big twist—if that’s what the story dictates.
But stories exist for many reasons.
And always have.
So, writers, write what you want to write, at the length the story itself dictates, and don’t worry about what some cranky writer tells you.
Even if that cranky writer is me.
“Short Story Craft” from The Write Attitude
Copyright © Kristine Kathryn Rusch
Published by WMG Publishing
This ebook is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This ebook, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
Any use of this publication to train generative artificial intelligence (“AI”) technologies is expressly prohibited. The author and publisher reserve all rights to license uses of this work for generative AI training and development of machine learning language models.
This rather short list makes it look like I didn’t read much in June, but I did. I had some misfires (as you can see), and I read quite a few things that I didn’t think were worth recommending. And then there’s Kelley Armstrong…
I binged the Kelley Armstrong Rockton/Haven’s Rock series until I caught up. The next (final?) book will be released in February and is already on preorder. You’ll find a lot of recommendations here, even though she forced me to read a pet-in-jeopardy novel, a child-in-jeopardy novel, and something that I did not expect at all and it upset me and I couldn’t stop reading… I guess Kelley Armstrong has moved into Stephen King territory for me, which means I’ll forgive her almost anything. It also means she is never, ever, ever going to be bedtime reading.
I did pick up the latest novel by an author I’ve read since the beginning of her career. Over time, my reading of her work dropped away from reading everything to reading some things. Her actual series didn’t really work for me—I used it as airplane reading in the 1990s and left the finished paperbacks on the plane for someone else—and then some of her other books stopped being to my taste, mostly when she added fantasy. (The fantasy was usually plebeian and my years at The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction ruined my tolerance for mediocre fantasy.) I’d been struggling with her romantic suspense novels—some worked and some didn’t—and the last four or five were just dull, which I consider to be a sin in a suspense novel. I preordered the newest suspense book, as was my bent, and discovered a protagonist too stupid to live. Seriously. She made very bad choices for unconvincing reasons. I gave up after 44 pages and realized that I’m done with this author. I’d given her more than my usual number of bad (to me) books, and I am (sadly) moving on. Some of her early works really influenced me and I’ll be forever grateful, but I’m done reading her work. It doesn’t speak to me anymore.
I also gave up on a novel by another long-time favorite author of mine, but I was much more forgiving here. He occasionally commits saga, covering decades in a relatively dry (and wry) voice. Sometimes it works for me; sometimes it bores me. I’ve tried to read this book twice and faded out both times—one when the book first appeared four years ago now.
And I finished Ally Carter’s Gallagher Girls series. The final book wrapped up loose ends, but I’m not recommending it, since it was a bit of a slog for me. I only mention it because I’ve recommended every other book in the series and you might see the lack. The series is absolutely worth reading and many of you might think the last book is the best. It might be a matter of personal taste as to whether or not it works for you.
However, you’ll find a few fun things in this particular recommended reading list. And, as I said, a lot of Kelley Armstrong.
June 2026Armstrong, Kelley, The Boy Who Cried Bear, Minotaur Books, 2024. This is the second book in the Haven’s Rock series. I recommend you read the Rockton series and the first book in the new series before picking this one up. I went into it fully committed to the series and knowing that this book was about a missing child. However, the kid was ten and there were sections from his point of view. Of course, me being me, I checked a few things before launching into the book. You may not need to. The other piece of information that you might want is this: I read this book overnight. Sigh. Breaking all my rules… Yes, I loved it.
Armstrong, Kelley, Cold as Hell, Minotaur Books, 2025. This book pissed me off for all the right reasons. It violates one of my biggest reading rules. It involves something that I never read for enjoyment. Yet, there I was in mid-June, turning pages so fast that I could hardly see the words. The scene in question is utterly stupid and completely gripping and I didn’t believe it for a minute, but I absolutely positively had to know what happened next. That is the mark of an amazing writer. And I’m still pissed that I read the scene. And bought the next book. And will continue to buy her books. Just to annoy myself. (This is book three. Do not start here.)
Armstrong, Kelley, The First Sign of Danger, Minotaur Books, 2026. I’m a little peeved. This is the penultimate Haven’s Rock novel, and the only one that’s currently available. (I have the final book on preorder.) There’ve been villains lurking throughout this series, and Armstrong finally deals with them here. I gobbled this book up in less than 24 hours.
Armstrong, Kelley, Murder at Haven’s Rock, Minotaur Books, 2023. This is book one of the “new” series, which is really just a continuation of the old series. But, I suspect, after writing into the dark, Armstrong let someone name the previous series after the town. Or maybe she did. Anyway, that town is gone, for reasons left out to avoid spoilers, and now we have Haven’s Rock, which is being built as this story starts. Because the Yukon is always filled with scary things and scary people and (maybe) serial killers which is (apparently) a joke I was unaware of, there is a murder before the town even gets its first permanent residents. The mystery is good, the book is unputdownable, and I like these characters. So I binged. I suspect you will too.
Feinberg, Scott,“Paul Williams Has Something To Say,” The Hollywood Reporter, April 8, 2026. I thought I knew a lot about Paul Williams, the composer, and it turns out I knew nearly nothing. I had no idea that he had quit music for a number of years, and was lured back into it. And there are a lot of other interesting tidbits in this short interview. Many of you know that I like articles about longevity in the arts, and this is a good example of that.
Rose, Lacey, “The ~~Late~~ Great Stephen Colbert,” The Hollywood Reporter, May 6, 2026. This is Stephen Colbert’s “exit” interview, and it’s fascinating. It looks at his longevity, his willingness to experiment, the political fallout, and a lot more. Really worth the read.
I know many of you don’t go to Dean’s website, which means many of you miss some wonderful online writing tidbits as well as some excellent deals. I mention the tidbits, but today’s email is about the deals.
We’re running a workshop sale in the doldrums of summer. We figure many of you don’t have time to write but you can watch videos on airplanes or in long car trips or at the beach. So here’s the info on the summer sale. It comes from Dean’s website, so the first person here is Dean.
Everything on Teachable Half Off… PLUS!!That’s right, this sale is different. We have never done any sale like this before. We do about two sales per year these days, although that number is going down as well.
So with the code SUMMERSALE, you can get anything on WMG Teachable at half price.
And if you buy anything at half price, you also get a POP-UP of your choice. There are about 70 or 80 Pop-Up classes to pick from on just about any topic or genre, and they are priced at $150.
So get a classic workshop at half price ($75 half price amount) and get a free choice of a Pop-Up worth $150.
And you can get more than one class or workshop at half price and for each one get a free Pop-Up of your choice. Or buy one Pop-Up at half price, get a second one free.
Anything works and as many times as you would like. No limits.
Here is how it works…Find any class or workshop on WMG Teachable and hit purchase.
Then put in the code
SUMMERSALE
And you will have the workshop or class for half price.
Then pick a Pop-Up class you would like and write me with your choice. Or I will write you asking for your choice. Then I will send you a code to get into the Pop-Up of your choice for free.
Again, you can get as many as you like. Teachable does not yet have a shopping cart, so you will need to buy the half price class one at a time. And get a Pop-Up class for each one.
Yes, the challenges do count as a class.
And any of the bundles and such.
And if you get a class with four quarters in it, such as the Bite-Sized Copyright full year, I will give you a free Pop-Up for each quarter. Now that would be a great deal.
ONE MORE SPECIAL THING WITH THIS SALE…If you have been thinking about the Lifetime Everything Subscription (600 plus classes and growing) but it is just too expensive, we are discounting it in this sale a little more. Instead of the half price at $5,000, we are discounting it to $4,000. And if you have already taken a bunch of classes or have another lifetime subscription, write me and I might be able to do even better.
This sale isn’t going to last long, so don’t delay. No telling when we will do another sale and I doubt we will ever do one like this again.
I curated a Storybundle to help us all escape the nightmares of 2026. As I explained in an interview with Jamie Ferguson, one of the other participants in the bundle, sometimes an escape means going to another scary place. But sometimes it means going to a wonderful alternate timeline where things are much better.
This bundle has everything from noir to romance. Great time travel tales and marvelous alternate history. There’s monsters and trains and adventure. There are crimes. There’s happily ever after. And almost everything is exclusive, including the writing workshop if you’d like to learn how to write your own time travel story.
My contribution to the bundle is an exclusive mini-bundle of two of my novels. The exclusive is called What If…Volume 1. (Yes, there will be more.) This particular volume combines two of my novels—Snipers, which is an alternate history and a time travel story filled with romance and adventure, and the first attempt at the same kind of story. The first attempt, Consecrated Ground, isn’t time travel at all. It’s a crime novel, and it’s not available anywhere else at the moment (although it is on preorder). Consecrated Ground is dark; Snipers is not (ultimately). Both are well reviewed and were popular when they were first published.
The cover on the top of this post is the brand-new cover for Snipers. And belowis an image of most of the books in the bundle. You can get all 15 books and the workshop for $30 (and give to World Central Kitchen at the same time).
Now here’s the bad news: The bundle will cease to exist late on Thursday (PDT). So if you want great ebook reading at a discount, go forth quickly and buy your copies. You can get your copies here.
This post is a chapter from my book, The Write Attitude, which is now in a second edition. I’m posting it here to entice you to to pick up a copy. You can preorder copies from all online retailers. Here’s a link to the ebook.
The second edition of The Write Attitude is quite different from the first edition, which originally appeared in 2016. I kept some parts of the original book, but much of the material is newer. The new material comes from my Patreon page. Not every post from my Patreon page shows up here, although several do. If you want to see everything, though, head to Patreon and sign up.
This post is from February of 2025, and is one of the early chapters in the book.
Sticking The LandingOh, wow. Endings. They’re so very important. They make or break an entire novel. Sometimes they make or break a reader’s entire experience with the author.
I’m very aware of this, and sometimes, as a writer, I don’t care. I’m not trying to please my readers. I always write to please myself.
Last week, as I was planning the future of my own writing, I ended up marinating in memories of my traditional publishing days, which brought back all those compromises I had to make. I never compromised on the work. I would walk instead of changing my vision for a story or a novel. And that made me unusual.
However, I would compromise as I was developing the idea, because I needed to sell on proposal. Often, I just ignored the proposal later, but occasionally I didn’t.
There were often dozens of fingers in my work on the proposal stage. People would say: Make it more like this current trend. No one wants to read about that topic. And my favorite, which still reverberates in my head sometimes: Wow, you’re trying to insult everyone all at once.
It’s hard to write when you have a crowd in your office. It’s hard to do a good job. I’m aware of that, and it makes me so happy to be indie these days.
I still read traditionally published writers, though. I have several whose work I love. And I sample books from writers I’ve never read before.
In January, I read a lot of short story anthologies, and in one of them, I read a story by a New York Times bestseller of long-standing. (And no, I will not tell you who she is.) I remember when her career started in the early part of this century. I thought she was a good mystery writer.
But somewhere along the way, she pivoted to the trendy. She became a writer of domestic thrillers—you know, the kind that happen in upper class suburban neighborhoods and gosh, by golly, gee whiz, there’s crime there and domestic violence and OMG, untrustworthy people.
Yeah, as you can tell, not really my genre, although I did sample a number of writers, realized it was me not them, and returned to my mean streets of cities fiction and other things.
I think I sampled this writer’s work then and didn’t like it— remembering that it’s me, not you—so I was a lot surprised by how much I liked that short story. I figured maybe she had moved off the domestic thriller train. It’d been a decade or more, after all.
I ordered her latest, which is set in New York (yay!), and then picked up one more book that sounded interesting as well. I settled into the latest book, and sure enough, the first part was pretty darn good. It kept me reading, anyway, even if there were parts that reminded me of Ira Levin novels from sixty years ago.
That’s okay. I don’t mind homage.
About two-thirds of the way through, though, there was a lot happening and it was getting more and more unbelievable. There were ghosts, but she wanted it both ways—maybe they’re an hallucination, and maybe they’re not—and the ghosts may or may not have an impact on the plot.
Then there was the bombshell about the husband that our protagonist knew but never mentioned, and then a lot of people died off-stage, all of them, and then…
Well, I kept reading, and sure enough, the twist was that it wasn’t the husband, like it usually is in domestic thriller. Okay, fine. The main plot ends, the ghosts are laid to rest, more people die, and we get to “six months later.”
And again, off-stage, we learn that some of the bodies were indeed dropped by the husband. The only person who ever believed in him was the wife, who at this point is (as the romance readers say) To Stupid To Live. She’s the only person in the book who isn’t a bad person, but that’s only because she’s dumber than a box of rocks. Everyone else is venal or a criminal or both. Most of them have murdered someone or accidentally caused a death, and all of them are unlikeable.
I finished that book, took it and the one I hadn’t read, and tossed them into the trade-in pile. I’m never reading her work again. Because really, honestly, that last third of the book was a truly terrible read.
She had a five-page long afterward in which she thanks her first readers, her second readers, her editors (both New York and London), her writer’s workshop, her agent (whom I happen to know and who is all about what she can sell, not about good storytelling),and all of her friends.
In other words, she lists the crowd in her office, and I’m sure, given that six-months-later section, they had a lot of influence on that.
Plus, the math was wrong. That might have irritated me the most. The main killers are eighty years old. It’s 2025. They had an eight-year-old child in 1963. Which meant that the kid was born in 1955. Which meant that the parents were both 10 years old when the kid was born.
Seriously, there were 1,000 early readers on this book and no copy editors? No one caught this but me? I actually went back to see if I had misread, but no, I hadn’t. Everyone listed in that afterward was math-challenged. Or they figured 1963 was so long ago no one would notice.
No one except this 65 year-old-reader who has a sister who turned 80 last year and who was sixteen when I was born in 1960. And no, she didn’t give birth to a kid in 1955 either.
Awful, horrible, irritating.
Because I’ve been looking for another good thriller writer. I don’t mind suspending disbelief and putting up with a high body count. I like to race through a book when it makes sense.
I thought, midway through, that I was really going to like this book. I almost ordered more books from this woman, but I’d learned long ago to see if the writer could stick the landing.
And, as you can tell, she didn’t. For me.
Sometimes sticking the landing is personal. Sometimes I don’t like the reveal that the narrator is the killer, even though I often love unreliable narrator stories. I hate books where the cute kid or puppy dies at the end—so much so that I now look ahead to see if the cute kid or puppy introduced on page five ends up dead at the end. (In paper books, I scan for kid/puppy’s name in the last chapter. It’s a pretty reliable method. I also have a few friends who know that I hate this with a profound passion, and they will let me know if a favorite author veers into dead kid territory.)
Oh, and a disclaimer—sometimes I kill the kid and the puppy in my fiction. As I told one of my students in January, I’m a complete hypocrite. (Or maybe just a true Gemini.) I hate that in my reading, but if the story I’m telling requires it, I will go that far in my writing.
Often, though, mostly, in fact, I will jump through major hoops to prevent the death of cute kid/puppy because I don’t like writing it. It’s devastating.
Anyway, that’s a me thing. And I will break the rule for some writers (I’m looking at you, Stephen King). I trust Stephen King to make sure that the death of the cute kid/puppy is never there solely to tug on my heartstrings. Usually the death is well foreshadowed (thank you) and it’s never there just to get more readers. It’s there because the story demands it.
I’ll abandon any writer who introduces the kid character, and then kills him off for no other reason besides giving the protagonist motivation. And again, that’s a me thing.
But the book I read this past week—which is not going on the monthly Recommended Reading List on my website—reminded me why so many traditional publishing books fail to stick the landing, particularly for authors who can’t stand up for their own vision.
I don’t know this particular author personally, but I will wager that she has made it such a habit to outsource her final draft that after two decades, she can’t conceive of any other way to write. And as a result, the end of the book was a mishmash of icky dumb stuff. (Everyone suspects the husband so make someone else the bad guy! If it’s the neighbors, there will be echoes of Ira Levin! We can use the Ira Levin thing as a pitch to the movies!)
The short story, on the other hand, would not have gone through the hands of the agent or both editors or anyone else associated with them. There’s not enough money in short fiction for those folks to waste their time.
So the short story was written by the unvarnished writer, who doesn’t write out of fear, the one who trusts her own vision.
As we all should.
I know, I know. I’m making a bunch of you very worried about your endings now. You wonder: How do I make sure I stick the landing?
Well, you write clean first drafts, don’t rewrite, and don’t let anyone else in your work. Then, you trust the process. Believe me, your creative voice will set up the proper ending. It won’t do fakey twists. If there’s a twist, it will be a legitimate one.
And then you let the project go. You move to the next.
There will be silly and stubborn readers like me who have ridiculous rules about what they read. (I will not read anything with corn on the cob in it! You can’t make me.) You’ll never get those readers. They will hate your work because you violated some personal rule you (and probably everyone else) had no idea existed.
But if you let an entire committee into what you do, then the writing you do will not be your best. You will stick the landing once in a while. Enough so that some readers will like what you do. But you won’t do it most of the time.
In fact, your books/stories well be good enough. As in mediocre. As in readable and little more. As mostly forgettable.
I don’t know about you, but I don’t want my fiction to be forgettable. I want it to be memorable.
The only way you will get people to read your next book is to have a satisfying ending on the current book…whatever that current book is for your readers. (I just finished a novel that I’ve had on my TBR shelf since 2009. That is the next book for me from that writer.)
So write your vision, and keep your friends, family, first readers, agent (if you’re dumb enough to have one), and editors out of it. You’re the writer. They’re not. How will they know if the storyworks? The story lives in your head.
The manuscript might fail, but that’s just a communication tool.
The story is all yours…and should remain all yours.
If your work is consistent—as in the ending should flow from details that exist in the beginning—then readers will return to you, even if they didn’t particularly like the ending of a book. They will see the authenticity.
The book I just finished reading had no authenticity. It was filled with kitchen-sink items, and that 1963 problem was a tell. The date had to be left over from an earlier draft.
I feel for the author. She’s clearly got it into her head that she needs the assistance of an entire village to make her books work.
And her work is good enough. It will help readers pass the time. But her work certainly won’t make them remember her for a long period of time.
That’s a shame, because the short story shows a writer with great power. Her novels do not.
Ah, well.
I’m sure I won’t remember this book much after this week. Maybe the Ira Levin stuff, and the 1963 things because it’s so egregious. But I will remember that I have not had a good experience with this author in the long form.
And I will not buy another novel from her. Ever.
“Sticking The Landing” from The Write Attitude
Copyright © Kristine Kathryn Rusch
Published by WMG Publishing
This ebook is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This ebook, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
Any use of this publication to train generative artificial intelligence (“AI”) technologies is expressly prohibited. The author and publisher reserve all rights to license uses of this work for generative AI training and development of machine learning language models.
With school over (as of the first week of May), I have more time to read. I occasionally binged a novel. I’ve had some down days as the chronic health issues flared and on one lovely day, I read two entire novels, something I hadn’t done since the damn dental surgeries of 2023. It was fun to read like that again. One of the novels I read that day would not have lent itself to a longer read. It would have been confusing.
Around Memorial Day, I read a novel that had been released the Tuesday before from a favorite Big Name Writer of mine. The novel was good enough to hold my interest, although I found myself scanning. I took an evening off to finish it…and wow, did I get mad. He skipped the validation entirely. Just ended it with Our Hero talking to a reporter, a scenario that would have worked in the 1990s, but in 2026, in the Dumpster Fire Era? No. Fake news abounds, and what would have been a career-ending scandal would be just a day in the office now. So I turned the page…and there was no more book. Extremely irritating, so badly irritating that it took me almost a day to recover. Yeah, sometimes I take the reading personally, especially when I don’t have as much time for it as I used to.
(Note: I wrote a post on the importance of endings on my Patreon page. That post became a chapter in my upcoming book, The Write Attitude.)
But, he’s an Old Reliable, for me anyway, and I’ll pick up the next book. It would take maybe half a dozen misses for me to let him go as a go-to author. This was unusually cursory and incomplete for him, which was weird. Probably something happening in his life that took focus away from the novel. Sigh.
I also binged the Best American Mystery and Suspense stories, but I wrote it up a month later. So I’m only letting you know which stories stuck with me. Let me say this: Titles are important, folks. If the title didn’t remind me, I had to look at the opening—and sometimes that didn’t remind me either. So, writers, make sure your titles fit your stories. I can’t say too much about the stories I liked because that will ruin them—which is actually a compliment.
As for my reading during the rest of the month, I’ve enjoyed what I’m seeing. I’ve shared what I like below.
May 2026Aptaker, Ann, “Neon Women,” The Best American Mystery and Suspense 2025, edited by Don Winslow, Mariner, 2025. Originally written for an anthology of crime stories set in the 1970s, this story captures a lost Times Square and a lost kind of personality. Vivid, startling, and well done.
Armstrong, Kelley, The Deepest of Secrets, Minotaur, 2022. This is the final book in the Rockton series, but not the final book in Kelley Armstrong Casey Duncan Series. Yes, it can be confusing. I wrote a post on my Patreon Page about excellent series, and discussed the courageous stuff that Kelley Armstrong is pulling off even though these books are traditionally published. I’m not going to tell you much about this book because it will spoil the series if I do. Just suffice to say I’m impressed as hell.
Armstrong, Kelley, A Stranger in Town, Minotaur, 2021. I’ve spent May plowing through Kelley Armstrong’s Rockton series. She’s pulling off an amazing reader trick, at least for me. She makes me read books in a setting I would never travel to and I can suspend my disbelief at some of the circumstances so quickly that I’m deep in the story before I even know what’s happening next. This particular tale focuses on the title–a stranger in a place that strangers can’t even find. And of course, there’s a murder and the overall plot is quite dicey and oh, my…if I say more I ruin it. Read this series, and start with City of the Lost.
Balogh, Mary, Remember That Day, Berkeley, 2026. Normally, I would put Mary Balogh’s cover here, but no. Nope. No. Not doing it. We actually made fun of the cover at Writer’s Lunch in February. The cover is so awful that it looks like it was designed by a beginning cover artist. And the “hero”‘s eyes are looking down her low-cut (for Regency) dress. Not kidding. So no cover picture. You can look it up yourself.
The book itself is wonderful and a masterful feat of storytelling. She brings two of her series together here, and her series always have dozens of characters. The romance is good and the story feels original. I wrote a longer piece about this on my Patreon Page. I started a series about writing series, and cited this book as a master work (with some analysis). So check it out!
Carter, Ally, Out of Sight, Out of Time, Little, Brown, 2016 edition of a 2012 book. This is book five of the Gallagher Girls series. It was unputdownable for me, but if you’re new to the series, start with book one. All of the tension here, at least at the beginning, comes from previous books. Then the book itself adds even more tension. Cammie, our heroine, has lost her memory over the summer, and since she is in the middle of a terrible crisis, the memory loss is a bigger deal than usual. Plus, someone important is in a coma, and the school has other problems and maybe we’re going to learn something about Dad and…Yeah. Just start the series and catch up. You’ll be happy you did.
Coates, Craig Francis, “Grendel,” The Best American Mystery and Suspense 2025, edited by Don Winslow, Mariner, 2025. “Grendel” is probably the best story in the volume. You don’t even have to have read Beowulf to understand it, but it helps if you did. The ending made me gasp. The skill level here is high. The story is one I wish I’d thought of myself. Enough said.
Leder, Stephanie, “Not A Dinner Party Person,” The Best American Mystery and Suspense 2025, edited by Don Winslow, Mariner, 2025. Great characterization here, great voice, and a wonderful ending that makes the story.
McElwain, Julie, Echoes in Time, Seshat Books, 2025. I know that Julie McElwain is self-publishing this series now, and I’m really glad she is. The books are hard to put down, the situation totally unbelievable and, as a reader, I don’t care. I’m loving the reading experience.
However, I worry about her (vaguely, since I don’t know her). She’s paying for covers and for someone to design the interior. That someone did not proof their work, and they’re just pouring the book into an online program without knowing how book interiors (for print) should look. I worry that McElwain is being horribly overcharged and that will make recouping her money difficult and at some point, she will stop writing the books for economic reasons. So…read this series. (It starts as a traditionally published series, then moved indie.) Encourage your friends. Let’s keep her sales up so that she can continue writing Kendra Donovan books, because they’re fun.
Pochoda, Ivy, “Jackrabbit Skin,” The Best American Mystery and Suspense 2025, edited by Don Winslow, Mariner, 2025. This novella is set in a part of Nevada/California that scares the ever-loving’-crap out of me. So remote that it makes the Yukon seem populated, this part of the desert is empty and terrifying and filled with people who don’t want to be found. So, what does our LA protagonist do? She moves into one of those places where people go to get away from people. I know this, and I was tense from the first sentence. Pochoda’s writing is strong, the sense of place real, and the crimes believable. Even the ending, which I honestly did not see coming, is believable. One of the best novellas I’ve read in years.
Winslow, Don, The Best American Mystery and Suspense 2025,Mariner, 2025. When I started reading this volume, I worried about recommending it. Heck, I worried about finishing it. Don Winslow likes gritty noir, and much of what’s here is just that. But the great things about gritty noir are the characters, the voice, and the setting. So most of the stories held me, even when I didn’t want them to. It was the most even reading experience I’ve had with a good anthology in years. (Bad ones are even in their mediocrity.) I found myself riveted by almost every story. I’m not sure this is bedtime reading, but it’s good reading nonetheless, and you should pick it up.
Annie Reed and Dave Hendrickson invited me to participate in their summertime romance anthology, Sunkissed Summer. I love writing for anthologies, and as my life is getting less hectic, I have more time to do so. (I had hoped to be in their previous volumes, but time and attention allow that to be possible.)
Sunkissed Summer features stories by wonderful writers from Annie and Dave themselves to Christy FiField, Dayle A. Dermatis, Thea Hutchinson, and so many others. I’m honored to be in such company.
My story happens in summer school, which, in the desert, isn’t as lovely an idea as you would think. And the characters aren’t your average college students…
Get your copy here—and enjoy!
She looks innocent—a bride in a frilly white dress on her way to her wedding. Until she curses out a parking meter, and heads, angrily, into the courthouse. One jaded defense attorney notices her, but only as a curiosity. He saw brides every day in Las Vegas. He has no idea that, in the next few hours, this bride will change his life. Forever.
“The Bride Case” is available for one week on this site. The ebook is available on all retail stores, as well as here.
The Bride CaseBy Kristine Kathryn RuschI first saw her on my way to work, and I thought nothing of it. Well, not nothing. I noticed her, because how can you miss a middle-aged white woman in a frilly wedding dress, cursing at a parking meter?
But I truly thought nothing of it, because I live in Las Vegas, the city with a wedding chapel on every corner, particularly downtown, where the Justice Center is.
The Justice Center, which I must visit weekly, whether I want to or not.
It was one of those rare gray Mondays where the mood of the sky matched the mood of everyone who had to show up in court that day. I lived in a condo in one of the nearby downtown high rises. I bought the place when I was newly single and not thinking, back when I believed I could walk to work, even when the temperature was 115 degrees.
I regret the decision, particularly since my office is a half mile south, in the pretty little neighborhood some wag dubbed Lawyer Row. I can park down there. I can park in my condo building. But I can’t find on-street parking at the Justice Center unless I show up super early, which means—yes, indeed—that I must walk to work.
Past all the people lucky enough to find a parking space, but so stressed that they can’t figure out the touchless parking meters that the City of Las Vegas installed during the height of the pandemic.
What this means is that those of us in our summer suits, sweating as we lug our required briefcases filled with laptops and actual paperwork because Justice doesn’t believe in the paperless office, schlep past the frustrated soon-to-be late folks at the parking meters.
Even if I had been inclined to stop, I wouldn’t have, not for this woman, because she was cursing, and shoving the meter with the flat of her hand. At the time, I didn’t blame her. Apparently, she had opted for an early morning wedding, and she was going to be late.
I did wonder why she was there alone—no bridesmaids, no kids, no friends—but I’ve seen stranger things near the wedding chapels. Actual fights, men pacing and smoking as if their partner wasn’t going to show up, people so drunk that I wasn’t sure they even knew each other.
I wondered about her…and then I walked past, and noted all of the TV live remote vans. Every single local news channel was represented.
The savvy morning crews knew that they had to arrive before seven to get the prime parking spots. Each van had its favorite place, so generally, I only noticed them if they had to park elsewhere. Only one did, not too far from the angry bride.
I didn’t see any reporters though, just camera crew. Which wasn’t that unusual this time of the morning. The reporters often got dropped off about an hour before whatever court appearance they were covering. No sense having the talent wait around.
Although I doubted there’d be much waiting that day. The case they wanted to see was mine, and it was particularly made-for-TV. A five-year-old cold murder case had been supposedly resolved when Metro arrested a former city treasurer.
I’m not even sure this would’ve been news back when Vegas was mobbed up. There was an assumption that everyone was corrupt in those days.
But now the city prided itself on being squeaky clean, and this treasurer—who had been fired for cause three years ago—had already proven himself a bit too shady to fit the city’s new image.
The problem wasn’t that he was shady. The problem was that he wasn’t a criminal, at least as far as I could tell. Granted, I’m a defense attorney, not a mind-reader.
But this guy—Derek Hiess—had no extra money in his bank accounts. He had no extra bank accounts. I work for a large law firm, famous in the area for handling only the biggest and most difficult cases. This means we have in-house detectives and more computer techs than I want to think about and all kinds of associates who have to do the grunt work.
They all grunted through a lot of work and found nothing that implicated Hiess in anything besides being viciously unpleasant. Yeah, sure, he was divorced—aren’t we all?—but he made his child support payments, sometimes by the skin of his teeth. He let the ex and the kids get the house; he lived in a small apartment not too far from me, in the newly revitalized Arts District.
Without the child support, his bills were miniscule. With the child support, they were crushing.
That was the only damning detail.
That and the fact that the murder victim, Maise Krause, had been his lover at the time of her death. And the only reason we know their connection is because a city employee stumbled on some video footage of the Helldorado Parade downtown that showed him kissing her. The police hadn’t had that information before, and like a doofus, he hadn’t told anyone he was the last person who had seen her alive.
Which, by the way, was not a crime.
It just seemed criminal, especially since the police had been trying to solve this murder for years now.
I had a number of problems with this case, the first being I really didn’t like Hiess. Even when he was being nice, he had an air of smarm about him. He clearly thought he was smarter than everyone else, including his lawyer, but fortunately for me, he was scared, so he didn’t contradict everything I did.
He only questioned it.
The senior partners at my law firm wanted this case for the publicity. One of them had already spoken to a Dateline producer behind the scenes, sending footage and talking about how this was truly perfect for their brand of true crime. Even if we lost, the theory went, we’d still make bank with all the new clients who would come through the door to have a famous law firm represent them.
That didn’t mean I had to like it. One of the reasons I caught the case is that I have a made-for-TV face. I’m not a good-looking man in person, but the camera does something to my bone structure that makes me look debonair and Cary Grant-ish on screen. If I hadn’t seen the effect myself, I would have thought that this particular case came to me because someone wanted me to lose.
Of course, I hadn’t told Hiess any of this. I gave him the standard defense lawyer speech—come clean with me because we’re better off ahead of the bad news—you know, all that stuff the client never does.
I’d been thinking about that as I headed into one of the side doors at the courthouse, where the reporters couldn’t go. The only bad thing about that door was it was near the 24-hour Marriage License Bureau, and all of those people who were lined up (already! On a Monday!) reminded me of lost hopes and dreams.
I was sure—hell, I knew—that none of them were thinking about the inevitable end of the relationship, which was either death, estrangement, or divorce.
Yeah, I was in a foul mood, but handling a not-guilty for a guy everyone had already pre-convicted never made me feel good. I could be an in-your-face kinda lawyer and I could be scary when I was doing it, because even though I had a Cary Grant-ish face on camera, in person I still had the muscular beefiness of my football days.
I went through the metal detectors, barely registering the ritual, except to note that on this door, anyway, the line wasn’t too long. At the main entrance, the line sometimes snaked halfway around the block, especially when there was a big jury trial or some high-profile case that allowed a gallery.
Mine wouldn’t have much of a gallery because we were still in preliminary motions. We were of interest, but not enough to attract an incredibly huge crowd…yet.
I wended my way through the hallways. Like most buildings in Las Vegas, this one is full of light, and someone decided that the entry needed some trees. The public areas are some version of the reddish brown that colors the Justice Center’s exterior. Apparently, some designer believed that reddish brown was a lot more cheerful than industrial gray.
Maybe they were right, but something about the design always made me think of a university building rather than a place where half the decisions were about life or death.
The main hallways were filling up with the pre-eight o’clock crowd—the clerks, the bailiffs, the worried-looking new attorneys, and the judges who wanted to get in an early-hour review.
I nodded at the judges, none of whom were robed up yet, so they just looked like ordinary people. I said hi to bailiffs, clerks, and anyone else I ran into weekly, and tried not to grin at the worried-looking new attorneys. I had been them once.
I no longer worried. There was no point. I’d lost cases that were slam-dunks because of some juror who got a bee up their butt, and I’d won cases that no one should have believed because some juror led the charge to convict.
And yeah, that means I think jury trials are iffy propositions.
Like most defense attorneys, I try to avoid them. Like many defense attorneys who are good at oral arguments, I usually end up with a jury anyway.
That’s because, deep down, I’m a performer and the entire legal community probably knows it. Certainly, the partners in my firm do. That’s another reason I end up with assignments like Hiess’s.
Of course, if I wanted to, I could have busted myself down to family law, which meant divorces and child custody and almost no juries. Hell, much of it got settled by arbitration or one-on-one with a judge—if it ever got that far.
The problem I had with family law was simple: Everyone involved believes they’re the good guy. They’re all deserving, and the other side is filled with assholes.
No one thinks about the kids, no one thinks about the truth, no one thinks that hey, if I’m just a tiny bit more reasonable, I might actually walk away from this thing with my ego and my wallet intact.
Of course, for most of these folk, the fight isn’t about the ego or the wallet. It’s about the fight. Which is the flipside of all that good sexual tension. You don’t have to like someone to have sex with them. And when the attraction wears off, you then figure out that you don’t like them, but you had something, and that something was always drama, drama, drama.
I was there for the drama before my own hearing since I had already done my prep. I’d promised I’d check in on Lucinda Elbe, who had become a project of mine. She’d moved from commercial and business law to family law because she wanted to make a difference, and I had been the idiot who told her that if she wanted to make a difference, she should quit law altogether and join some nonprofit somewhere.
To my surprise, she had laughed at me and told me that there was room in every profession for a difference, and that was when I got just a little scared.
Here’s the thing about me: I don’t get scared often, but one thing that will set off my inner white knight is an innocent who is about to have that innocence rudely and predictably stripped away.
Elbe would have hated being described as an innocent. She had been a ferocious champion for her commercial clients, but there was a difference between being an attack dog for some business interest, and watching a kid get stripped away from the only parent who loved them because the other parent saw the kid as a trophy to be won over by constant litigation.
At some point, Elbe would get nailed, and it would most likely destroy her, and I wanted to be there to minimize the damage, however I could.
Something about this morning’s case, the final gavel on a divorce, bothered me. I couldn’t put my finger on it, but I knew, if anything was going to slap Elbe alongside the head, it would be today.
I slipped into the back of Judge Aranza Castillo’s courtroom. It was one of the smaller courtrooms in the very center of the building, which meant it had no windows. Its setup was what I considered backwards, with the jury box on the judge’s right. The courtrooms I trained in always had the jury on the judge’s left. So whenever I walk into these rooms, I feel a little discombobulated.
The bench was directly in front of me, with Nevada’s blue Battle-Born flag on one side of the judge’s chair and the U.S. flag on the other side. Some judges kept a round clock above their chair, but Castillo preferred the state seal.
Her chair was empty, the bench tidy. The attorneys were in place, with Bruce Laymon on the right, and Lucinda on the left. Lucinda sat calmly, back straight. Unlike most female attorneys, she wore a navy suit with a skirt instead of trousers, and paired it with heels. Her black hair was pulled into a perfect knot at the top of her head, her hands folded over the folders in front of her. A laptop rested to one side of her, and at least two yellow legal pads on the other.
Her client, an older man with badly dyed black hair, mirrored her posture, but not as effectively. He couldn’t sit straight, whether that was because of the extra weight he carried or because he never normally sat that way. His folded hands held a pen and rested on top of yet another legal pad.
Everything here told me that those two expected a fight, but with who I had no idea.
Laymon was a good enough divorce attorney, but certainly not the best. He lost as many cases as he won, and some of the ones he lost were the kind that shouldn’t have been lost at all.
He was the one who looked nervous, and maybe he should have, because his client wasn’t beside him. He clutched a phone in his hand, peering at it repeatedly as if he expected something from it. Then he would look at the door to the judge’s chambers, probably worried that she would emerge while his phone was still visible.
The entire courtroom seemed to be holding its breath.
We stayed that way for ten minutes.
I was about to touch Lucinda on the shoulder and tell her to break a leg, when the court reporter came in. She saw Laymon’s phone and gave him a warning side-eye. A bailiff took his spot near the back, nodded at me, and then turned his attention to the front.
If I wanted to talk to Lucinda, now was the time.
And then it was too late. The door to the judge’s chamber opened, and Judge Castillo swept in. She seemed tall, but that was the robe combined with her athletic thinness. She wore heels so high that I couldn’t imagine how she stayed balanced.
She put folders on her desk, sat down, gaveled the court into session, and then said to Laymon, “Counsellor, where is your client?”
“She said she’s here,” he said.
“Clearly she is not,” the judge said. She shoved her papers to one side and asked, “Did you tell her that you can represent her without her appearing?”
That was a strange question, one judges rarely asked unless there was some kind of problem.
“I did, Your Honor.” Laymon’s voice actually shook. I wasn’t sure I’d ever heard him sound nervous, even when he let his nervous tics get the best of him.
“And…?” the judge asked.
“And she insisted she needed to be here.”
“Great,” said Lucinda’s client, and he didn’t mean that it was great at all. He sounded concerned.
Lucinda put a hand on his, probably to shut him up.
“Ms. Elbe, make sure your client knows that you speak for him here,” the judge said, without looking at her.
“Yes, Your Honor,” Lucinda said.
Everyone was on edge. Maybe this was the vibe I had gotten from Lucinda at the office earlier. Not that there was some innocence-shattering event about to happen, but that this divorce hearing had gotten so contentious, even the judge was surly.
If that was the case, I really didn’t need to be here. I could get a lot more done prepping one of my other cases before I went into court with Hiess.
I stood up and eased toward the door, hoping the judge didn’t see me. But of course she did. She raised her eyebrows at me, silently asking why I was here. I shrugged, declining to answer. With luck, she wouldn’t ask me anything out loud.
And that luck held. I made it to the door, pulled it open, and nearly got bowled over by the bride I had seen earlier. She smelled faintly of mothballs mixed with very old Chanel No. 5.
She clutched a bouquet of dried flowers, and stalked down the aisle like a demented bridezilla.
“Douglas!” she called at the top of her voice.
The man beside Lucinda shrank into himself, as if he could make himself disappear. Lucinda sat even straighter, but did not turn around.
“Mr. Laymon, get ahold of your client,” the judge said with great irritation.
That was Laymon’s client? That woman who looked enough like the illustrations of Dickens’ Miss Havisham that I was nervous all over again.
“Get ahold of me?” the bride shrieked. “Get ahold of me? He doesn’t want to hold me, and look! I still fit into the dress.”
One of the bailiffs moved forward, but the judge made a surreptitious move with her left hand, stopping him. He stood, hand poised near his weapon, watching the bride.
“Mrs. Monroe,” the judge said. “Please sit down, and let your attorney speak for you.”
“In other words, get ahold of myself,” the bride said viciously. She flounced, and the ruffles on her dress bounced in unison. “I will not put up with this any longer.”
She walked down the aisle toward the lawyers’ tables, her wide skirt brushing both sides of the ineffectual little barriers that separated the attorney tables from the public seating. For a moment, it seemed like she was going to join Laymon, but then she spun and faced Lucinda’s client—who was most likely Mr. Monroe.
“Look at me,” the bride said, running her hands in front of her gown. It had a beaded bodice that looked stiff and uncomfortable, and it trailed into a point on that full skirt.
The dried flowers rustled as she moved. Dead leaves and petals marked where she had already walked. She wore pearl-drop earrings and a pearl necklace that ended in a sedate cross around her neck.
Everyone in the courtroom was looking at her. None of us could take our eyes off her—except her soon-to-be former husband.
“Look at me,” she repeated, with emphasis.
He brought his head up just a little. The second bailiff had moved slightly in front of the judge, who once again waggled her fingers, indicating that he should move away from her. Clearly, she wanted to see this.
Lucinda still seemed preternaturally calm. I’d never seen her like this. Maybe this was what she looked like when she was terrified.
“I know I’m not as pretty as the new girlfriend,” the bride said to the soon-to-be ex, “but you thought I was pretty once.”
My heart sank. I knew that Lucinda had been going through something with this case, but I thought it was normal divorce stuff, not a stunt like this.
“There is no new girlfriend,” the soon-to-be ex muttered.
The bride didn’t seem to hear him.
“The last time I wore this dress, you and I vowed till death do us part,” she said, and shifted the dried flowers.
I caught a glimpse of something conical, and I felt a half second of confusion even as my brain was playing those last words. Till death…
I launched myself forward like I would have done at the snap in a football game. That half second of movement, which didn’t quite count as a false start but probably should have—I had perfected that.
I didn’t see any other movement, but then, I wasn’t trying. My gaze was on those dried flowers, one part of my brain arguing with the other. Because of those metal detectors, what I thought I saw was impossible, right?
But the flowers had lost most of their petals and the leaves had formed a circle on the floor, and the soon-to-be ex was cringing so badly that he was turning into a gigantic ball of terror.
My forward movement was causing the bailiffs to move toward the bride (or maybe me, I don’t know) and I couldn’t find my voice even though I wanted to scream at Lucinda to get down or move aside or duck or something. Part of me was afraid to mention Lucinda’s name at all, because right now, the bride was focused on the soon-to-be ex and mentioning the attorney invited unwanted attention.
As I got close, the bride raised her head ever so slightly. Her gaze met mine.
I’d seen flat eyes like that before. Half the people I defended had eyes like that—emotionless, empty, and somehow calculating.
She dropped the flowers from her left hand, and in her right was a white pistol. I’d never seen a white pistol before. It matched the damn dress.
I was still a yard or so away, but I leapt across the divide, figuring if I could grab the dress, I could bring her down. The bailiffs were close as well, and Lucinda started to turn sideways, so I figured she hadn’t seen the gun at all.
Something banged as I wrapped my arms around a mountain of pearl-encrusted tulle. My shoulder hit against something hard, and then I landed, unable to catch my breath. A lazy thought The air must’ve been knocked out of me reverberated in my head as I stared at a somewhat dirty white pump, abandoned beside me. A foot in white stockings was being dragged backwards and there was another pump being dragged with the white-stockinged foot, and I was sliding along, and I couldn’t quite grab purchase on anything, plus the tulle was covering my face, making everything seem like I was seeing it through white gauze.
Lucinda was shouting my name, some guy was screaming, and the judge’s gavel was banging, banging, banging, and I was beginning to wonder if I’d swallowed some tulle, because I truly couldn’t breathe and then there were people, yelling, and I closed my eyes and…
…didn’t open them for three days. So much for my high-profile case. Apparently I had just become a lot more high-profile than my case.
The headlines were nuts. The staid version was a variation on Attorney Shot In Las Vegas Courtroom, but the rest treated what happened that morning like a joke: Divorce, American Style; Angry Bride Shoots The Wrong Lawyer; Former Defensive End Turned Defense Attorney Takes Out Crazed Bride, and so much more.
I would’ve stopped looking, but people were sharing with me, somehow thinking it all cheered me up.
Cheering me up wasn’t possible. I was on my back in a private hospital room (thanks to the power of one of the biggest law firms in town), feeling like someone had taken a chainsaw to my chest. I went from being a man dealing with what he thought was a major irritation (a media circus court case) to a man in the midst of a media circus because he’d—apparently—saved some lives.
I guess I ended up being the unintended victim. The bride had turned toward me at the last second, which meant the gun was pointed at me while I was in the air, and the gun’s only bullet hit me damn near point-blank.
Apparently, it was touch and go for the first day, and less touch and more go on the second, and by the third, they figured I’d live, even though I’d lost part of a lung and had shattered ribs. Breathing was no fun, the press was no fun, and I felt this amorphous anger at everything—while my brain kept replaying that slow-motion sprint with a full-on regret voice-over.
Maybe if I had shouted. Maybe if I had grabbed Lucinda instead. Maybe if I’d yelled for the bailiff. Maybe if I’d screamed, “Gun!”
Maybe, maybe, maybe…
If I managed to silence some of the voices with logic, other ones rise up, revamping the scenario all over again. I needed distraction, but wasn’t sure how to get it.
It’s hard to be distracted when you’re doped up in a hospital bed with only the TV and your thoughts for company.
Obviously, the bride was arrested on the spot. The media somehow got images of that perfect-fitting wedding dress, now bloodstained, and had all kinds of commentary I tried hard not to follow.
The divorce, surprisingly enough, was on hold because the no-longer-soon-to-be ex wanted to renegotiate a lot of things, especially the money, so that he wasn’t paying for the defense of a woman intent on killing him. If I had been healthy, I might’ve helped with that. That case sounded interesting to me—the only interesting part of this whole thing.
I wanted to talk to Lucinda about it, but apparently, she didn’t want to talk to me. She hadn’t shown up at the hospital at all. I didn’t even get flowers from her, and my entire room was filled with flowers, now that I was out of the ICU. Get-Well flowers from friends, Thank-You flowers from some of the people I had (in theory) saved, a big spray of Look-At-How-Rich-The-Sender-Is flowers from the law firm, and an even bigger spray of flowers from one of the TV networks.
I hadn’t read that card yet, but if it was anything like the booking shark who had shown up when everyone thought I was going to die, wondering if I would gasp an interview before I croaked, I suspected that the card wasn’t worth reading after all.
By day four, I was feeling sorry for myself, not just because I was in unbelievable pain and the doctors didn’t prescribe enough painkillers. It didn’t matter how many times I tapped the little button on my drug remote, the pain level remained 350,000 on a scale of one to ten, ten being high.
I toggled between wondering who I could threaten with some kind of lawsuit to get me more drugs and wondering why the hell I hadn’t remarried when I had the chance. At least a wife would have been obligated to sit by my bedside and go through this hell with me, right?
You’re not a hero, a little voice in my head kept repeating, borrowing the long nasal vowels of my Midwestern first (and only) wife. If you had stayed out of the way, one of the bailiffs would have tackled her and no one would have gotten hurt.
That vocal little representative of my former life had it wrong. Someone would have gotten hurt. It just wouldn’t have been me.
Everyone in that courtroom thought they were safe because of the metal detectors and, well, because Mrs. Monroe (whose first name was, I learned through the news reports, Ellen) was batshit crazy, which meant no one thought she had the wherewithal to buy a 3D printer and make a ghost gun that could actually work.
Turned out that Mrs. Ellen Monroe was only batshit crazy when it came to Mr. Douglas Monroe. In all other parts of her life, she was quite competent. The more I heard about that tortured relationship, the more I suspected that Mr. Douglas Monroe was terrified that his wife would try something—and that she would pull it off.
Lucinda hadn’t said anything about any of this to me or to anyone else I talked with from the firm. Either she thought the kind of cuckoo allegations that Mrs. Ellen Monroe made against her husband were normal angry about-to-be-divorced spouse allegations or maybe Lucinda didn’t want anyone to know that she had ventured into a violent (and eventually quite bloody) version of the Twilight Zone.
Finally, on day six, after the doctors had decided that I needed to sprint across the hospital, which actually meant that my IV and I needed to be escorted around the nurses station by an actual nurse, I finally saw Lucinda.
She missed the heroic walk around my floor, but not the aftermath, me on the bed, gasping like a dying fish at the bottom of a boat. The gasping was, I’d been told, perfectly normal. If I healed properly and worked on my lung function, I would graduate to a more sedate wheeze.
The door to my room was open, but Lucinda peered around the frame as if she expected someone to deny her entry. Or maybe she was seeing if I was actually there, and not dead, or not there and dead, or maybe just sleeping, so she could leave the card she had brought and claim credit for a long and meaningful visit.
When she heard my fish-gasps, she looked like a startled rabbit. Her gaze met mine, and she asked from her perch at the door frame, “Do you need a nurse?”
“Nn-ah-o,” I managed, wanting to tell Lucinda this was normal right now, but not really sure I should say something like that. After all, it might make her feel guilty.
But then, why shouldn’t she feel guilty? I had taken a bullet for her, after all.
I beckoned for Lucinda to come in, and she did, walking like a person on the way to a firing squad. She looked over her shoulder more than once, maybe hoping that someone in authority would tell her I was too sick to talk to visitors.
I made myself smile at her, and she gave me one of those full lip movements that meant the person was trying to smile and failing miserably. She was dressed in a blousy dress shirt, black yoga pants that ended at her calves, and athletic shoes with enough foam to mean business.
I had been mistaken in my gasping first impression. She wasn’t carrying a card or flowers or a book or any token at all. Her nails were bitten down, her hair was pulled back, and she had circles under her eyes so deep that someone could have stored golf balls in them.
She grabbed one of the side chairs, pulled it over, and sat down on my non-IV side. Then she grabbed the remote and shut off the TV. I hadn’t had the sound on, but the images had been comforting. I hadn’t shut the thing off since I woke up in the room, so her movement left me feeling a tad bereft.
“You okay for a talk?” she asked. “They said you were, but you’re gray, and —”
I waved a hand, silencing her. I didn’t want to talk about whether or not I was up for a talk. I wanted the talk or I wanted my TV. Really, I wanted to get the hell out of here and never ever ever come back.
She bit her lower lip, watching me use the tricks my brand-new physical therapist had taught me just to get my breathing under control. The physical therapist had come to my room two days ago and given me breathing exercises to prepare me for the day when I could actually go to the physical therapy department.
Lucinda plucked at my arm, focusing my attention. “You don’t look well,” she said, and in that statement was buried an excuse to get the hell out of my room.
Well, I would have said if my breathing had been under control and if I could ever relearn how to say more than three words without inserting a gasp between them, I did nearly die a week ago. So I’m doing okay, considering.
Instead I managed to say, “Ah…m…faahnnn.”
That was me post-surgery. Lots of breathiness, lots of consonants. I sounded like someone from the Deep South, even though I’d never made it past the Mason-Dixon line.
“Okay,” Lucinda said, “but, oh God, I didn’t expect you to look this bad. I mean, you were shot and everything, and I knew it was bad, but somehow I thought since it was a ghost gun, it’d have a ghost bullet or something, and—”
She shook her head, looking young and twisted and sad.
“God, I’m an idiot, aren’t I? I mean, I thought how can a ghost bullet nearly kill someone? I should’ve known.”
Yeah, you should’ve, I would’ve said if I could’ve said it. Instead, I nodded somewhat sagely and let her talk.
My gasping had reduced itself to the occasional much-too-big-for-a-normal-person breath.
“I just—I wanted you to be the first to know.” She was twisting her hands together, something I’d never seen an actual person do with such sincerity. It looked like she was trying to wring water out of them.
I eyed her warily, doing my best to keep my gaze off her twisting fingers.
“I’m—um—quitting the law.” She winced as she looked at me. Her left hand was actually turning white where the fingers of her right were digging in.
I wasn’t surprised. I kinda expected this. I’d seen lesser crises force lawyers to jump from the profession.
Here, she’d seen a friend—or at least a colleague—shot right in front of her because her client had a crazy wife. Lucinda was probably second-guessing herself, and maybe my words about family law were reverberating in her head.
They were certainly reverberating in mine. I had been afraid family law would shatter her. I just hadn’t expected this kind of shattering.
Lucinda stared at me, her bottom lip trembling.
I couldn’t tell if she was going to talk more. If she was, I didn’t want to start, because speaking still took way too much effort.
“I’ve disappointed you, haven’t I?” she asked.
It’s not about me, I would’ve said, if I could have spoken quickly. I was trying to figure out how to dance around all of this, without sounding like an idiot with southern-fried marbles in his mouth, when she added more.
“I mean, you warned me that this was nothing like real estate, and Jesus, what I wouldn’t give for a shady bastard skirting the thin edge of the law right now. I thought they were evil assholes, but this—what she did—she could have killed you.”
Lucinda’s voice had grown softer with each sentence, and I had to strain to hear that last part.
So much of this had probably gone over and over and over in her head, and I was just getting to hear the ruminations. I moved my hand—the one without the IV needle jammed just above the wrist—and I took her hand, squeezing tight.
She raised her head, surprised at me. I’d never touched her before, not in all of our conversations. She probably hadn’t known that a part of me had always wanted to touch her, but hadn’t had the courage. Besides, she was a colleague, and the firm frowned on fraternizing.
And if I had been honest with myself, then I would have known that for the excuse it had been. I too had been damaged by family law, but the family the law had pertained to was mine—those families were mine, really, since the first divorce I went through had been my parents, which had destroyed my mother (and taken away any hope she had of making a decent living while caring for us kids), and the second divorce had been my own—the one I had walked away from, leaving my ex with all the money and the furniture and the house, because I wasn’t going to be like my father.
Lucinda was staring at me, and she was probably thinking that I was thinking about her, which I was, but not in the way that she was probably thinking about it.
“And,” she said, looking down at our hands. “If I missed that, what else did I miss? I mean, her husband did say he was scared of her.”
I almost nodded, but nodding would’ve been the wrong thing to do. I wished I had a voice—a real one—so that we could have a conversation, a real one, but it was going to be hard.
“He wants me to keep handling the divorce, but I don’t want to. I don’t want to go in a courtroom again.”
I didn’t blame her. Time to get counseling, I would have said if I could have. But I didn’t, and weirdly, she got me thinking about returning to the courtroom. I hadn’t given it much thought, but it didn’t terrify me. I wasn’t scared of anything right now, except maybe not being able to breathe properly again.
“And you were right about family law,” she said. “It’s heartbreaking. It’s awful. Oh, God, I keep thinking, what if a child had been involved? What then?”
I squeezed her hand, and managed to say, “Loo…sin…dah.”
She stopped talking and looked at me expectantly.
I held up a finger on my IV hand. It was easier than saying Give me a minute.
“Wha…t…hah…pen…d,” I managed. “Nah…ttt…you…rrrr…fah…l…tt.”
“But it was,” she said. “I—”
“No,” I said, and that word came out clearly, as if I actually could get enough air. “No. The law…”
I had to pause and breathe for a moment. But the words were coming easier. Maybe it was like the physical therapist said. Maybe if I didn’t think about it, I could settle into a breathing routine.
I banished that thought right away, hoping it wouldn’t contaminate the lung capacity I had left.
“…tea…ches…us…that…pee…pl…ahrrr…assholes.”
She let out a whoop of laughter and looked at me in surprise. “The only word you can say clearly is ‘asshole’!”
She laughed like a kid who, for the first time, had heard an adult tell a potty joke.
“Nah…tt…trooo…” I managed. “…sah…ddd…law…too.”
She nodded. “You did,” she said. “You did.”
At that point, I gave up trying to talk. It was too hard. Instead I waved my IV hand at the table across from me, and pointed at the laptop my assistant had brought from the office, even though I hadn’t requested it.
“Cah…nnnn….tt…tt…ahl…kkk,” I said as she handed it to me. I opened it and turned the screen toward her. Then I opened the message program and typed:
What happened is 100% on that evil bride. She made the gun, she brought the gun, she used the gun. If her husband had seen that coming, he didn’t tell you, because clients don’t tell us everything.
As for you leaving the law, that’s a personal choice. I never had the sense that you loved the law the way that some…
I almost typed “some of us” but stopped myself. No need to go for the full reveal.
…do, which means this isn’t a calling for you. So, do what you must.
BUT, and this is important, see a counselor. You’re not sleeping (clearly) and you need to talk to someone who can actually talk back. I’m here to listen, though, and maybe type a message or two.
I barely resisted the urge to add an emoji, which made me realize just how doped up I was because I am not an emoji guy.
I sent the much-too-long text because I wanted her to have it on her phone, even though she had watched me type the whole thing.
Her eyes filled with tears.
“You don’t hate me?” she asked.
I could never hate you, I typed. I think you’re an amazing woman.
Her cheeks flushed, and one of the tears fell, and she stood up. She said, “I’ll come see you later,” in a tone that made me believe she never would.
And sure enough, I was right.
I never saw her again—even though she texted me and pretended to worry about me and claimed she wanted to make sure I was okay.
I wasn’t okay, but I lied and said I was. Because what else could I do? I reminded her of the worst day of her life, a day she clearly didn’t want to deal with, and I was too sick to put a lot of effort into taking care of her as well as taking care of me.
By the time I finally got out of the hospital, she had quit the firm.
By the time I was home long enough for the home health care aide who visited twice a day to stop visiting at all, Lucinda had taken a new job.
By the time I had my first hey-that-didn’t-hurt-as-much-as-usual physical therapy appointment, I learned that Lucinda’s new job had taken her all the way across the country.
Apparently, she hadn’t thought that detail was worth telling me.
And that was when I sank onto my much-too-comfortable couch and started to shake. I’d been holding it together until then. But the woman I had been trying to help hadn’t seen it worth her time to even let me know the smallest detail about her, and that made me feel like an idiot.
I don’t like feeling like an idiot.
So I did what any good defense lawyer does when someone in the human race disappoints them. I sucked it up and moved on, adding just a bit more cynicism to the suit of armor I had built out of an entire lifetime of cynicism.
By the time I was ready to return to the world full-time, I was a lot more guarded, a lot more snide, and a lot less compassionate for everyone—including me.
Which made me a hell of a difficult witness at the bride’s homicide trial.
Yeah, good old Mrs. Ellen Monroe had decided that plea deals were for babies. Apparently, she had told her defense attorneys to fill the jury with women who had gone through a messy divorce because Mrs. Ellen Monroe thought they would understand. Apparently, she had dreams of jury nullification or acquittal by cause or some other such nonsense.
I wasn’t supposed to talk with anyone except the prosecutor, and I couldn’t sit in on the trial because I was a witness. I hadn’t been ordered to stay away from the news on the case, which part of me figured was an oversight and another part—the defense attorney part—hoped that the lack of an order was a careless practice endemic to the District Attorney’s Office.
If it was, I would use it in future cases because, at that moment, future cases were all I had to look forward to. I was currently showing up in the office for a few hours of every day, subjecting myself to over solicitation from my legal secretary and frowns of worry from everyone else, biding my time until I got the medical all-clear for a full-on return to work.
That plastic bullet had done a lot more damage than anyone thought possible, and my recovery was taking more time than my insurance company liked. Fortunately, they were scared of my law firm, since we had successfully sued them more than once for failing to uphold the terms of their policies.
Everyone was worried about me testifying in what the media was calling The Bride Case, but no one could prevent it because—whether we liked it or not—I was the victim. I had a narrative to tell, and sympathy to gain, and I knew I had better do it right.
Knowing and practicing are two different things. My brain knew I had to do everything right, but my heart wanted to see how the case was going. Fortunately, the case wasn’t live-streamed anywhere. The judge hadn’t banned cameras from the courtroom, but she had banned gavel-to-gavel coverage, so the news I gathered was mostly tidbits, the kind of juicy stuff that television stations and online rags used to intrigue their paying customers rather than inform the rest of the public.
Which meant I was more than a little surprised by my surroundings when I was called to the witness stand on Day Two of the trial.
Day Two, 9 a.m., shortly after the court started its session, just like Dan Abrimowitz—the prosecutor—had predicted. He’d said one day for opening arguments and stupid, baseless motions, and the actual meaty part of the trial would start on Day Two.
I hadn’t really figured it would happen that way, because I’d never seen a trial that had gone according to plan. But Abrimowitz seemed to have his finger on this one’s pulse.
I knew that when I walked through the double doors, girding my loins for the inevitable PTSD reaction that Lucinda had mentioned, caused by being shot in my place of employment—a reaction, it turned out, that I didn’t have.
The courtroom was bigger than the one I had been shot in. It was one of the largest courtrooms in the Justice Center, even though it looked like the other one, with the Nevada Battle Born flag and the U.S. flag flanking the judge, a seal over her seat, jury on the wrong side, and large desks for the attorneys. The gallery had more seats, and every single one of them was full.
Reporters sat in the back, cameras were to the side, and my heart sank when I saw cameras from the major national TV networks. That meant this case, with its funky opening, would be on at least one true crime show, and I would get to see myself over and over again, giving whatever testimony was necessary.
Hell, there was probably footage of me being carted out of the Justice Center on a stretcher, considering all the media that had been present that day.
My name had been called before the bailiff opened the doors for me, so people had turned in their seats to watch me walk toward the witness stand. I knew better than to smile at anyone. I kept my gaze on the judge—Carol Siddalli, who had graduated from law school one year ahead of me. She looked older now, her hair cropped like a cap around her head. Her features had hardened, and she had learned how to keep her face expressionless.
There was very little of the woman I had known from late nights at the law review, and I had thought she had looked old then.
As I walked, though, I noted that Mrs. Ellen Monroe had not gotten her jury. It was 60% male, and a goodly portion of those men looked like they did manual labor. The women were evenly divided between twenty-somethings and fifty-somethings, and only one of them was white. She wore a brownish suit coat so old that it was pilled, and a pair of matching pants that were too short for her stick-thin legs.
She was probably not the ideal juror that Mrs. Ellen Monroe had had in mind.
I swore an oath to tell the truth so help me God, hand on the Bible, and expression as sincere as I could make it, and then I sat in the witness box and felt like a fraud.
Unlike most of my colleagues, I’d never sat in a witness box—not to test it out, not as a lark, not even at the bidding of one of my professors back in the day. The chair was surprisingly comfortable, the mic a tad too far away, and the perspective just plain odd.
I could see the entire courtroom, just like the judge could, only from a much lower perspective.
The gaze of everyone in the courtroom was on me, from the jurors to the gallery to the defendant herself. She stared at me as if I had surprised her. I know that we didn’t know each other, but she seemed stunned that I even existed.
Abrimowitz had prepped me pretty well. Just enough so that I knew where he was going, but not enough to make me sound rehearsed.
Even so, he startled me with his first question.
“How’s your health?” he asked as he got up from the prosecutor’s table.
I’m the kinda guy who normally lies and says I’m fine even when I’m not, but he wanted a true answer here, not the macho one.
“I’m still having breathing issues,” I said, “and moving sideways often sends a jolt of pain through me. There was a lot of damage.”
I didn’t look at Mrs. Ellen Monroe when I said that, but even I could hear the fury in my voice.
Abrimowitz had me describe each wound in detail, how it felt to deal with those, and then he asked me to establish my baseline now.
The jury seemed fascinated by all of this. I did my best not to squirm in my chair. Had I been running the defense, I would not have allowed such a detailed and thorough description of the health issues.
Any defense I had run would have stipulated to those points, just to keep the descriptions to a minimum. Descriptions of pain and suffering usually inspire juries to side with the injured party, so long as that person doesn’t whine.
I made sure I wasn’t whining, mostly by not looking at the defendant at all.
“All right,” Abrimowitz said. “You weren’t supposed to be in the courtroom that morning, correct?”
“That is correct,” I said, making eye contact with the jury.
This was the meat of the testimony, at least as Abrimowitz saw it. I figured it could play for either side, if we weren’t careful.
Letting the jury see me, letting them know that I saw them, would keep them on our side, I hoped.
“Didn’t you have a big case of your own that morning?” he asked.
“I did,” I said.
“Why weren’t you prepping for that?” Abrimowitz asked.
“I had finished my prep,” I said. “I had an hour or so before court, and I couldn’t be with my client.”
“Still, you could’ve gotten coffee or prepped another case. Instead, you came to watch Mrs. Monroe’s divorce case. Is there a reason for that?” Abrimowitz was covering the bases, trying to make sure he asked the tough questions before the defense did.
“Her lawyer, Lucinda Elbe, worked in our firm. It was one of her first family law cases, and I wanted to let her know that she would do just fine.” I wanted to explain more, but I didn’t. It was essential for a witness to only answer the question asked.
For the first time, though, I was seeing just how hard that could be.
“Do you usually cheer on your colleagues?” Abrimowitz asked.
“In the office, sure,” I said. “But this was the first time I had visited one in court.”
“What made this different?” Abrimowitz asked.
“Ms. Elbe had just made the transition from commercial law to family practice. I was worried about her. Family practice can be emotionally difficult for everyone, even the attorneys involved.”
I tried not to pause in the middle of that, but I couldn’t help shifting my shoulders just a little. Abrimowitz and I had discussed this: We expected a series of objections here.
Had I been Mrs. Monroe’s attorney, I’d’ve objected to me as a witness, objected to everything I said about the courtroom, and definitely objected to the description of the emotions around family law cases.
I might not have won the objections, but I would have screwed up Abrimowitz’s rhythm, and I would have confused the jury. It’s hard to keep track of questions when the opposing counsel constantly interrupts. Sometimes there’s a gap of ten minutes or more between the question and the answer itself.
But there had been no objections, not yet anyway. I resisted the urge to look at Mrs. Monroe’s attorney to see why she wasn’t doing anything at all.
“Please explain emotionally difficult,” Abrimowitz said, all but daring the opposing counsel to object.
He pointedly did not look at the defense table. And it took all of my strength to keep my gaze away too.
So I looked at the jury. Their gazes were firmly on me, as if they couldn’t get enough.
I needed to pretend that I was trying this case—without getting too deep in that pretense, because that might make me screw up as a witness.
Still, I assumed my best talk to the jury voice.
“Family law deals with divorces,” I said. “By the time a couple gets divorced, the arguments are old and the anger is deep. Often, there are children involved and even more often, the situation with the children is dire. The choices that get made in family court can rip your heart out.”
Abrimowitz let that sentence hang. His gaze met mine. He was surprised. He shouldn’t have asked the question in that manner and I certainly shouldn’t have been allowed to opine like that.
“Were there children involved in this case?” he asked.
“I have no idea,” I said. “Ms. Elbe and I didn’t discuss the details. All I knew was that the case was bothering her more than usual, and I figured she needed some moral support.”
“She didn’t tell you about the clients?” Abrimowitz asked.
“No,” I said. “She barely confided in me.”
“Yet you showed up.” He moved slightly, a signal that he wanted me to focus.
“I did show up,” I said. “I was going to tell her I was in the building, and she could find me if she needed advice or support.”
“You’re not a family law attorney, though, are you?”
“I’m not.”
“I still don’t see your interest here.” Abrimowitz was really pushing this. I wasn’t quite sure why.
“I liked Ms. Elbe. I didn’t think she belonged in family law. I thought it would destroy her, and it did. She’s not practicing anymore. She moved out of state.”
“Ms. Raylin?” The judge’s voice startled me. She was looking at the defense attorney. And that’s when I understood what was going on. This was judicial nudging, basically trying to tell opposing counsel to object.
I stopped talking and waited. Most witnesses probably would have proceeded. For that reason, Abrimowitz made a small movement with his hand, cautioning me to remain quiet.
Raylin, the defense attorney, was a mouse of a woman, with brown hair cut too short, a brown suit coat that was too big on her, brown pants that didn’t quite match, and low-slung black heels that clearly didn’t go.
Her trial bag had accordion files and at least two laptops, and at that moment I realized what she was.
Either she was the cheapest lawyer Mrs. Ellen Monroe could find, or, more likely, Raylin was a public defender.
“Yes, Your Honor?” Raylin sounded surprised that she was addressed at all.
“Do you plan to object?” the judge asked. So much for the nudging.
“No, Your Honor. I told you earlier, I have no objections to this witness.”
Mrs. Monroe looked at the judge with wide eyes, then back at Raylin. Raylin’s head was down, her arm over a yellow legal pad. She seemed to be writing something or maybe she was just doodling.
She didn’t seem to care much, that was for certain.
Which, I must say, pissed me off. Not for Mrs. Monroe, who was clearly guilty, but for my entire profession.
Everyone is entitled to a defense. I believe that like a religious precept. There are ways to defend guilty people. There are ways to protect both them and society.
What Raylin was doing was not one of those ways.
Apparently the judge agreed. “Just because you have no objections to the witness doesn’t mean—”
“Your Honor.” Abrimowitz spoke softly but with some force. That took balls. He was, essentially, reprimanding the judge.
I shook my head, just a little, hoping Abrimowitz saw me.
“Yes, counselor?” the judge asked in a tone so frosty that I had to check my arms to see if I had been coated in ice.
“May I continue?” That clearly hadn’t been what he was trying to say.
“No, you may not,” the judge said. “I need to caution you that some of your witness’s answers are not allowed under the rules. I will not strike those answers, but I do want you both to watch yourselves. Both of you should know better.”
I was used to a judge reprimanding me, and so, apparently, was Abrimowitz because he didn’t look fazed at all.
Mrs. Monroe seemed even more startled than she had a moment ago. The jury was squirming just a bit—each and every one of them—and Raylin, well, she had finally looked up from her legal pad, as if she didn’t quite understand what was going on or what her role was in any of this.
Which was probably true.
“Now you may continue,” the judge said to Abrimowitz.
He took a deep breath, probably to cover for the fact that he too had lost his train of thought. I hadn’t. I had just opined that Mrs. Monroe’s actions, however indirectly, had destroyed Lucinda, something I didn’t know as a fact. That was what the judge objected to, and that was the direction that Abrimowitz could no longer take.
“Are you involved with Ms. Elbe?” Abrimowitz asked.
I was expecting that question. He’d asked it in prep too many times. He clearly did not believe my answer which had been the same then as it was now.
“No,” I said.
“Did you want to be?” Abrimowitz asked.
“No,” I said, aware that was a slight lie. She had caught my attention from the start. When I offered her advice, I had been hoping she’d see me as someone she could rely on. But I hadn’t taken it any farther than that.
“Yet you seem interested in her,” Abrimowitz said.
“I take an interest in a number of my colleagues,” I said. “Male and female.”
“Yet you’ve never come to court before,” Abrimowitz said.
“That is true,” I said. “I’ve never come to court before to watch an attorney I was worried about. And I’ve regretted it in a number of cases.”
“So you were turning over a new leaf,” Abrimowitz said with a tight smile.
“I wouldn’t call it that,” I said. “I just had a feeling that something was going deeply wrong with this case, and I worried that someone was going to get hurt.”
“Ms. Raylin?” the judge asked, nudging again.
Raylin lifted her head. “Um, objection?”
“Based on what?” the judge asked, as a prompt.
“Um…his answer?”
Laughter rippled through the courtroom, including the jury box.
“What part of his answer?” the judge prompted.
“Um…all of it?”
The judge sighed softly. She had tried to make her point and failed. If she continued to prompt, she would be risking a bias allegation on the side of the defense. Right now, the transcript did not show her concern, but if she commented anymore, she could be in trouble. And since Raylin hadn’t cited a reason for the objection, the judge’s response was immediate and logical.
“Overruled,” she said with great disgust. “Continue, Mr. Abrimowitz, but do remember my warning from earlier.”
“Yes, your honor,” Abrimowitz said. He looked at me. “Please confine your answers to what you know as a fact.”
“Sorry, yeah, okay,” I said, trying all the answers because that was safer, especially considering my growing irritation at the damn defense attorney.
I loathed Mrs. Monroe, and yet I was half tempted to leap across the courtroom, sit at the defense table, and take over for the incompetent Ms. Raylin.
Remember, I told you. I have white knight tendencies. In this case, the damsel in distress wasn’t Mrs. Monroe, but the law herself and, in particular, my little corner of it.
“What happened after you got to court?” Abrimowitz asked me.
“It was a strange set-up,” I said.
Abrimowitz walked me through the “strangeness,” constantly referring to my experience in courtrooms as a baseline.
Raylin should have objected.
Out of the corner of my eye, I saw Judge Siddalli shift more and more as my testimony continued. Yes, we both knew that I hadn’t just stepped up to the line, but I’d crossed several.
Abrimowitz seemed more and more confident as the questioning went on. Mrs. Monroe sank into her chair. She understood that we were harming her, but her lawyer just kept doodling or making notes or whatever it was that she was doing instead of objecting.
The jury was watching me closely, unaware of the drama going on between the judge and the defense.
“Did you see a gun?” Abrimowitz was asking me.
“Yes,” I said.
“When?” he asked.
“The bouquet of dead flowers was falling apart,” I said, “and I saw the white barrel. Only I’d never seen a white gun before, and it wasn’t until she reminded her husband that they had promised to be together until death that I understood what was going on.”
“Before the bailiffs did,” Abrimowitz said. It should have been a question.
“I was watching from a different angle,” I said. “I launched myself—”
“We’ve shown the video,” Abrimowitz said, cutting me off. “The jury knows what you did, and I’m sure everyone around you was grateful.”
“Mr. Abrimowitz,” the judge said, not even waiting for the defense to screw up an objection.
“Sorry, Your Honor,” Abrimowitz said, and focused on me. “It would seem to me that you and not Ms. Elbe would be the traumatized one from this entire situation. Are you having difficulties?”
I blinked at him. I wasn’t sure what he was driving at since we hadn’t discussed this part.
“Other than my brand-new physical limitations, no,” I said. And then, because I couldn’t help it, because someone really needed to put up a defense, if only for the sake of the law, I added, “But I am left with a question.”
Abrimowitz’s eyes narrowed. He must have heard something in my tone.
“And what is that?” he asked, with a caution in his voice.
“Because I’m considered to be the victim in this case,” I said, “a lot of people have sent me the press coverage of the incident or have talked to me about it.”
The judge had stiffened again. Mrs. Monroe sat very still. Raylin finally lifted her head, frowning at me. I wondered if she was finally forming an objection.
“And I have seen no one ask what I consider to be a salient question,” I said, allowing time for someone to stop me.
Abrimowitz did.
“I’m sure we’ll get to your question eventually,” he said. “Right now, though, I think we’ve covered everything. I have no further questions.”
Then he pivoted and returned to the prosecutor’s table.
“Ms. Raylin, do you have any questions?” The judge asked. Something in her tone led me (and probably half the courtroom) to believe that Raylin was going to decline to cross-examine me.
“Actually, your honor,” she said, “I do.”
Raylin sounded as surprised as I was. But she wasn’t interested enough to stand up. She just leaned forward.
“Mr…um…” She had to look at her notes to find my last name, even though it had been used several times in the past fifteen minutes, and I was the victim. She should have known my name like the back of her hand.
She turned a page, and finally Mrs. Monroe pointed at something on the paper. Raylin nodded, and continued.
“Um… you said you had an unanswered question. What is it?”
I felt a jolt. A defense attorney should never ask a question she didn’t know the answer to. Not ever.
But, in for a penny, in for a pound.
“I’ve been wondering why a woman as obviously competent as Mrs. Monroe would bring a gun to court with the intention of shooting her husband. What had he done to deserve that?”
“Objection!” Abrimowitz yelled so loudly that his voice echoed around the room.
Raylin was waving her hands at me as if she couldn’t believe I had said that.
Judge Siddalli glared at me. “You know quite well that there are no good reasons for killing someone.”
I looked over at her, surprised she had said that. Apparently, her disgust at Raylin had removed half of her judicial filters.
“It would seem, Your Honor, that the State disagrees with you, since many states have kept the death penalty. According to our laws, then, there are many legal reasons for taking someone’s life.”
Her eyes narrowed. I remembered that look from law school. We’d had a lot of late-night law review arguments, she and I. She always quit before I did because she refused to go to the mat on the logical inconsistencies that exist in almost every human-designed system.
“It’s not relevant,” Abrimowitz said. “I want that answer stricken.”
“Um…” a tentative voice said. It took me a moment to realize that voice belonged to Raylin. “I actually…um…think it might be relevant. I mean, if my client had a good reason—”
“It means nothing,” Abrimowitz said. “She shot an innocent man, who for some reason is defending her.”
“Oh, hell,” I said, deciding to undo the damage I had just done. “I’m not defending her. She shot me with an illegal firearm that she brought with the intent to kill her husband. I think I’m within my rights to wonder why she thought the man deserved to die, rather than, say, have all his possessions removed from him in a fairly ugly divorce.”
The jury was staring at all of his. Reporters were checking their phones and notes to make sure they were getting all of this.
And then Mrs. Monroe stood up.
“Because, you imbecile,” she said in that strident voice that still haunts my nightmares, “my husband and I made a vow before God to stay together until death parted us. I didn’t want to be with him anymore than he wanted to be with me, but divorce is a sin. So I figured I’d do God’s bidding—”
At this point, Raylin was shouting incoherently, the judge was pounding her gavel, calling on Raylin to get her client under control, and Abrimowitz was shaking his head as he frowned at me.
I had just guaranteed a conviction for him, taught a young lawyer that she either didn’t belong in this game and/or that she really needed to learn how to advocate for her clients—even the obviously guilty ones.
I shrugged at him, and he glared at me.
The bailiffs swarmed Mrs. Monroe, Raylin finally objected, and the judge loudly informed her that her client could watch from outside the room. Then the courtroom got blissfully quiet, and everyone turned to me, apparently remembering I was still—technically—testifying.
“I want the lawyers in my chambers. Now,” the judge said. “Court is adjourned until nine tomorrow morning.”
Everyone stood and started talking, including the jury, which was a bad sign. I remained in the witness chair as Abrimowitz and Raylin trailed after the judge.
For the first time in a long time, I was happy I wasn’t trying this case. Those two were probably going to be shredded by the judge, and justifiably so.
After the courtroom emptied, I got up, feeling that now-familiar stretching pain in my chest. I managed to get halfway down the aisle when Abrimowitz slammed out of the judge’s chambers.
“That doesn’t look good,” I said.
“Oh, it’s fine,” he said. “We’re going to have a plea, which we should have had from the beginning. And the judge is tearing that baby defense attorney a new asshole. I’d get out of here, though, if I were you, and you better hope you never get into Judge Siddalli’s courtroom again. She’s really mad. At me, at you, and she’s hoping that no one takes this to the judicial review board, because she’s going to look very bad.”
“She should,” I said. “And that defense attorney—”
“—is none of your damn business!” Abrimowitz took a step toward me, right hand closed into a fist. “What the hell were you thinking?”
I opened my mouth to answer but he held up that hand, palm open now.
“No, don’t tell me,” he said, then shook his head. “Because it makes no sense. She shot you, for god’s sake. What the hell?”
I didn’t think he wanted to hear the white knight speech, the I love the law corollary, and the someone had to do it justification. So I shrugged.
“Justice is blind,” I said.
“Not when it lost half a lung and spent six months recovering,” he snapped.
He was breathing hard, and we were staring at each other. His face was red, and I was remarkably calm.
“I’m the one who was shot,” I said.
“And that should piss you off,” he said.
“It did,” I said. “It does.”
His eyes narrowed. “But…?”
“But a bad, lazy defense pisses me off more,” I said.
“You want her to go to jail, don’t you?” he asked.
I paused, then thought about it. As I did, I suddenly became aware of my breath. It didn’t work the way it used to. My lung capacity was down by one quarter, and my ribs would never entirely heal right. Any exercise took more effort than it did before I got shot.
Not to mention the nightmares and the pain—Christ, the pain, especially on those nights alone, when there was no one to distract me.
I read legal history those nights. Stupidly enough, I believe in this system. I think it’s the best one I’ve read about, and for it to work, someone has to defend the Ellen Monroes of the world.
Not doodle on a legal pad and say um too many times, but to actually defend her. To find the best solution for all involved, whether that was a plea or a good attempt at jury nullification or just a straight conviction with the death penalty off the table.
“I don’t care if she goes to jail,” I said, surprising even myself.
“What?” Abrimowitz brought his head back so hard I thought I heard his neck creak.
“It’s not going to change anything for me. She shot me. I nearly died. I have a shit-ton of scars and I’ll never be able to breathe easily again.” I sounded a little breathy as I said this. “Lucinda lost her ability to practice law because she’s terrified of the courtroom. Last I heard, Judge Castillo is on leave. I have no idea what happened to the husband—”
“He moved, after the divorce was final,” Abrimowitz said.
“—so everything is different for him too,” I said. “Those are facts. What happens to Ellen Monroe means nothing to us. It does mean something to the future, though. With luck, she won’t shoot another man again or make another gun. She’ll be off the streets, and with even more luck, she won’t be in a cell with someone who’ll get out and refine her techniques for getting a ghost gun into the courthouse.”
Abrimowitz frowned at me, then slowly shook his head. “You’re a piece of work, you know that?”
I shrugged again. Maybe I was, maybe I wasn’t. But that didn’t matter either.
“Law’s not a job for me,” I said.
“Don’t give me that ‘it’s a calling’ bullshit,” Abrimowitz said.
“All right,” I said. “I won’t.”
Then I turned my back on him and walked out of the courtroom.
Law wasn’t a calling for me. Isn’t a calling for me. It’s a framework, a way of understanding the world. It is logical (for the most part), built on other pieces, and fastidiously guarded by a precious few.
If I had to compare it to anything, I would call it a religion. Not the wave a Bible and thump your chest, filled with emotion and the holy spirit kind of religion.
The studious kind, the kind that tries to figure out the place of humanity in the world, in a vain attempt to make sense of our existence.
I smiled at myself as I hit the main hallway that led to the front doors. To walk this way, I had to pass the courtroom where I got shot.
Lives changed in courtrooms, sometimes dramatically, like mine did, and sometimes in the routine administration of justice.
That is how it should be, in my world anyway.
It puts logic on chaos, a way of making the inexplicable seem important.
But only because it needs to be done right. And this one hadn’t been.
What happened if Ellen Monroe’s husband deserved to die for the things he did? We would never know. And Ellen Monroe wasn’t talking about them, not in ways we understood.
He should’ve been called as a witness. He should’ve been part of her defense—not financing it, not even as moral support, but as a small fact to cast doubt.
What kind of woman dresses up in her wedding dress on the day of her divorce? What leads her to that? And why don’t more women do it? Or more men, for that matter?
What caused Ellen Monroe to snap when hundreds of thousands of others never do?
Those questions fascinate me, and they don’t get answered in the wrong kind of criminal proceeding.
But there’s no one I can tell this to, no one else whom I know who will understand.
My somewhat monastic servitude to the law has become more devoted in the time since the shooting than it was before the shooting—and I think on that servitude often, especially as I look at the courthouse where it all happened.
The constructs we build. The choices we make. The vows we break.
In the grand scheme of things, they mean nothing.
Most of what we do means nothing.
But looking at the grand scheme of things is as futile as retrying Ellen Monroe.
It’s the little things that matter, the tipping points, the moments that might send us all over the edge.
We’re waiting there, in our metaphorical wedding dresses, cursing parking meters, and wondering how we got there—and knowing, deep down, that we got there step by step, building blocks the same way the law builds precedent, one small choice at a time.
I don’t think about Ellen Monroe when I breathe. I think about the law.
I think about the people who die for their religion each and every day. I took a bullet for mine, and I would do so again if the opportunity arises.
I would absolutely do so again.
___________________________________________
“The Bride Case” is available for one week on this site. The ebook is available on all retail stores, as well as here.
The Bride Case
First appeared in Alfred Hitchcock’s Mystery Magazine, September/October 2024
Copyright © 2025 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
Published by WMG Publishing
Cover and layout © copyright 2025 by WMG Publishing
Cover design by WMG Publishing
Cover art © copyright Canva
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
For Amelia’s second marriage, Gram gives her a visit to a wedding counselor. Not a marriage counselor, but someone who will advise how to achieve a perfect marriage through the perfect ceremony.
Superstitious nonsense, Amelia thinks, although she doesn’t want to offend Gram. But as the meeting progresses, Amelia realizes what the perfect wedding means—and why Gram wants her to have one.
“Something Blue” is available for one week on this site. The ebook is available on all retail stores, as well as here.
Something BlueBy Kristine Kathryn Rusch“Gram,” Amelia said for the fifteenth time. She was hunched in the passenger seat of her grandmother’s 1968 Cadillac, elbow catching on the armrest’s silver ashtray. “I don’t need a marriage counselor.”
“Wedding,” Gram said, perching her right wrist on the top of the steering wheel while she pushed up her glasses with her left forefinger. “Wedding counselor. And you do, girl. You didn’t listen to me that last time.”
Amelia sighed. Her grandmother would never let her forget the divorce, not because Gram disapproved—she’d been through three husbands herself—but because Gram said that Amelia had made a fatal mistake.
She had looked behind her as she walked up the aisle.
Gram had said that meant Amelia would regret her wedding day for the rest of her life. And Amelia did regret that day, more than she could ever state to her improper and fun-loving grandmother.
Gram fishtailed around a corner, honked at a ten-year-old boy on the side of the tree-lined country road, and waved. The kid, looking startled, waved back.
“You know him?” Amelia asked.
“Should I?” Gram said.
Amelia shook her head. All her life, she had lived in awe of Gram. When Amelia was a little girl, Gram ironed the curls out of her still-black hair, and wore mini-skirts showing off legs that were better than those of most teenagers. When Amelia was a teenager, Gram wore hip-huggers and floral print shirts, but eschewed granny dresses because she’d already worn them in a previous incarnation. When Amelia got married the first time, Gram had shown up at the wedding with six pierced earring holes in each ear, and new diamond studs in each.
Now Gram wore her gray curls in an above-the-ear bob and was talking about getting her eyebrows pierced. She was dating two different men: a real estate broker twenty years her junior, and a retired pilot ten years her senior. Neither man knew of the other, and Gram had hilarious stories about sending one man out the back door as the other man came in the front. Gram had nothing against extra-marital sex, even in these days of AIDS, but she did take marriage seriously.
Very seriously.
Too seriously.
First she tried to talk Amelia out of this second wedding, but since Amelia couldn’t be talked, Gram was determined to make her do it right.
“Where are we going?” Amelia asked, as she peered out the window. When she had finally agreed to come along with Gram, she hadn’t expected to leave Beaver Dam, let alone find herself in the middle of the Horicon Marsh. She had memories of the Marsh that dated back to when she was a little girl. Gram had been on husband #2 then, and they had lived in Theresa, just north and east of the Marsh. Whenever Amelia’s folks took her there, they always stopped on the side of the road, hoping to see wild birds in the reed-filled water. Sometimes they did. Usually they didn’t.
“You’ll see,” Gram said.
“Gram, if we go much farther, I’m going to insist on driving.”
“And who, I want to know, is missing points from her license?” Gram snapped. “Certainly not the elderly woman driving the car.”
Amelia sighed and sank lower in the front seat. Yes but, she thought and didn’t say, who has twenty-twenty vision? Who’s not wearing bifocals that constantly slip to the edge of her nose? Who drives with both hands on the wheel? Certainly not the elderly woman driving the car.
Maybe that was the problem. Gram said whatever she thought, but Amelia never spoke back to her grandmother. And Amelia was three years away from forty. It was time she spoke up.
Besides, she was beginning to get carsick from the pine-scented air fresher hanging from the rearview mirror.
“Gram,” Amelia said. “If this wedding counselor is so good, how come you didn’t use her?”
“I did,” Gram said. “With Willard.”
Willard. Well, there was no arguing that then. Willard had been Gram’s third and last husband. The love of her life. Willard had been three hundred pounds of extremely nice male who had treated Gram with the respect—and caution—that any wild animal deserved. Willard had stayed with her for five years, then died of heart failure in his sleep one cold November night.
Gram never remarried.
Even though she’d had regular “visitors” from that December on.
“I want you to have what Willard and I had,” Gram said into Amelia’s silence.
“I do,” Amelia said. “Scott’s wonderful. He’s the nicest man I know.”
“He’s the nicest man you know now,” Gram said. “But you used those exact same words about Whatshisname.”
“Ralph,” Amelia said.
“Ralph.” Gram shook her head. “You know, you should pay attention to names. They’re a sign. How could you fall in love with someone named Ralph? The name is slang for—”
“I know,” Amelia said. That joke had ceased being funny in the first month she dated Ralph. “And he was the nicest man I knew. Then. Scotty’s nicer.”
“Ralph was not nice,” Gram said. “Ralph only pretended to be nice.”
“If he only pretended to be nice,” Amelia said, “why’d you let me marry him?”
“Who could stop you? Besides, you knew.”
“I knew what?”
“That it was a mistake. Otherwise, you wouldn’t have looked back.”
Amelia sighed. Gram had a superstitious streak that was a bit surprising given her practical and adventurous nature. When she played gin, she never touched the cards until the last one was dealt, thinking that to peek beforehand would ruin her luck. When one famous person died, she always expected two more in related fields to go because, she said, famous people died in threes. And she never went into New Age stores that carried crystals because, she said, too many crystals in one place affected her psychic energy. Amelia had always thought that meant Gram shouldn’t go into jewelry stores either—and she should stay away from the salt and sugar aisles in the grocery store, but Gram never quite got the connection.
“Gram, I looked back,” Amelia said, “because of you.”
“Don’t go into that again,” Gram said.
“I did,” Amelia said, “because you whispered that my train was wrapped around my heels.”
“I was in front of you at the time. I didn’t expect you to believe me.”
“Gram,” Amelia said. “My train was not wrapped around my heels.”
Gram shrugged, then turned the wheel slightly with her wrist, following the curve of the road. “So my eyesight ain’t what it used to be.”
“Gram, that was fifteen years ago. Is your eyesight worse now?”
“No,” Gram said. “It got better. The miracles of modern science.”
Amelia tilted her head back in the seat. “Gram, I’m beginning to think you did that on purpose.”
“So what if I did?” Gram said. “You shouldn’t’ve married a Ralph.”
“I loved him.”
“You only thought you loved him, dear,” Gram said. “Trust me, I know.”
Amelia closed her eyes and gave up. She loved her grandmother dearly but sometimes there was no arguing with her. Especially when Gram’s mind was made up, as it had been from the first day she met Ralph.
Not good enough for you, Gram had said.
He’s the CEO of a software company, Gram, and that’s a burgeoning industry. We’ll be rich by the time I’m thirty.
Rich isn’t everything, my girl, Gram had said. Besides, you’ve got twice the intelligence he does.
So?
So, you’ll get bored. And I’ll bet he’s not good in bed.
Gram!
Believe me, I can tell which ones are, my girl. He’ll be finished before you’ve started.
Gram!
Think I don’t know about such things? Your grandfather—
I don’t want to know, Gram.
You should listen, honey.
No, Gram. I really don’t want to know.
But Gram had been right. The software company went belly-up, Ralph was a poor conversationalist, and he approached sex like it was a one-minute mile. But how was Amelia supposed to know? He’d looked good on paper, and she’d been good herself. She’d been the only girl she knew who’d been a virgin when she got married.
The first time, anyway. This time, she test-drove the model before she decided to live with it. Scott was six-foot-seven with gentle brown eyes and a smile that softened his already round face. He was not graceful, and during the first hour she knew him, he’d hit his head on the doorway into the restaurant to which they went on a blind date, shattered the crystal chandelier, and accidentally kicked over another diner’s chair—two tables away. After that debacle, they decided that Scott was not meant for fancy restaurants. He was more at home—well, at home—where the doorways were high enough, the light fixtures were made of plastic, and the other diners, when invited, were used to Scott kicking them under the table.
He was not athletic, except in bed, and he was at least as smart as she was. She’d compared their IQs. And he was a successful geneticist at the University of Wisconsin—a good researcher and one of the best teachers in the department.
He was also shy, which she saw as a good point; it had prevented him from asking other women out. She wouldn’t have met him at all if a mutual friend hadn’t forced them to see each other.
A mutual friend.
Not Gram.
Gram was still skeptical. She didn’t see any fireworks, she said. No spark. He was smart, yes, but how was he going to use those smarts? And he lacked people skills. Always a failing, she said.
A serious failing.
But he’s good in bed, Amelia had said.
I don’t want to know, Gram had said with a familiar tone of distaste.
You wanted to know about Ralph.
I wanted to warn you about Ralph, Gram had said. That one was obvious.
Well, Scott should be obvious too.
Gram had shrugged. If the size of his hands are any indication, she said, of course he’s—
Gram, Amelia had said. Don’t go there.
You’re the one who mentioned it, Gram had said.
And Amelia had given up.
Gram pulled into a driveway and stopped.
Amelia had been so caught up in thoughts of Scott that she hadn’t been paying attention. Now she looked at her surroundings. They were still on the highway, but just past the marsh. They hadn’t reached a town yet, or if they had, she couldn’t tell. The driveway Gram had pulled into was more like a gravel yard. It extended three car lengths in the front, and at least two car widths. At the far end of the driveway was a brown ranch house that badly needed paint. Two flower boxes sat outside, with dead flowers wilting over the sides. A rusted tricycle lay on its side beneath the only tree, a weeping willow that looked as if it too were on its last legs.
Gram shut off the car.
“This can’t be it,” Amelia said.
Gram gave her a withering look. Amelia had cringed from that look her whole life. It meant I certainly hope you’re not going to make comments like that when we’re inside.
Amelia ducked her head and mumbled, hoping Gram would take that for an apology. Actually, Amelia felt that Gram owed her an apology for wasting her day and forcing her to go to a place she had no desire to go. She could have stayed home and caught up on her soaps. Her new job in the research area of the Department of Natural Resources gave her bank holidays off, and she felt as if she were only working half as hard as the rest of the population.
She was enjoying that.
Gram opened her car door and got out, her tennis shoes crunching on the gravel. Amelia had worn suede boots, an obvious mistake in this environment. The boots had no real sole and were designed for city walking—pavement, carpeting, with plenty of rests in between.
She felt each stone in the gravel as clearly as if she’d been barefoot.
“No dawdling,” Gram said as she scurried for the front door.
Amelia suppressed a sigh. She wanted to dawdle. She wanted to get back in the car, and head for the marsh. Even that would be more interesting than this place.
She picked her way across the gravel. By the time she reached the stoop, the door was already open. A middle-aged woman with light brown hair was smiling at Gram.
“Mrs. Sparks,” the woman said, and Amelia was surprised to hear, not the flat vowels of the Midwest, but the clipped tones of an upper class British accent. “And I suppose this is your granddaughter.”
“Yes,” Gram said. She held out a hand, as if Amelia’s slow approach to the porch had been intentional. “Amelia, say hello to Sophie Danner.”
Amelia smiled and said hello just as her grandmother had asked. Sophie Danner was not what Amelia had expected. She had thought to see a woman of her grandmother’s age and of the temperament common to most women of that generation—most women but Gram.
Sophie Danner had to be Amelia’s age.
Or younger.
Sophie stood away from the door, and Gram went in, as if she had done so a hundred times. Amelia followed, wincing at the stale smell of boiled cabbage and garlic. Sophie herself smelled faintly of sweat as if she’d been cleaning house or sitting in the sun, and hadn’t had time to shower yet. She wore a faded gold t-shirt with a logo Amelia had never seen before, and blue jeans one size too small. Her feet were bare, and her toenails were painted a vivid green.
“Do make yourself comfortable,” Sophie said. She cleared some papers off the red and black plaid couch, and tossed them on the floor. They covered a gray carpet that was so thin that Amelia could see the wood underneath. Sophie took more papers off the matching easy chair, and sat down.
Amelia sat too.
Gram was thumbing through a pile of pictures scattered on the dining room table. “Your latest project?” Gram asked.
“No, no. It was an unsuccessful. The wife wants me to see what went wrong, to see if the problem was in the ceremony or the man.”
“What do you think?” Gram asked.
“Upside down flowers, no wedding cake, and no rings,” Sophie said. “Of course they weren’t going to last the year.”
Amelia suppressed the urge to groan, and then wondered how she had gotten in the habit of suppressing all her reactions around Gram.
“My granddaughter,” Gram said, “doesn’t believe in this.”
“Wedding counseling?” Sophie looked shocked. “Your grandmother told me about your turning to look at the back of the church at your last wedding. Of course it failed.”
“Of course,” Amelia mumbled.
“It’s good you divorced him. Regret is a terrible thing to stare at day in and day out.”
“I was young,” Amelia said.
Sophie smiled and clapped her hands together. “Of course you were,” she said. “It’s amazing what we learn as we age. It’s rather difficult to admit we don’t control our universe, but once you’ve made that admission, you can slip right over it, and control the things you can control. Right?”
“Right,” Amelia said, not understanding a word Sophie had just said.
“Good.” Sophie leaned forward. “Let’s discuss your plans.”
Gram was holding a picture and peering over its edge at Amelia. In a moment of weakness, Amelia had blabbed all the plans to Gram. Amelia couldn’t well lie about them now.
Not without Gram correcting her.
And Amelia had never been fast on her feet, at lying in any rate.
“I suppose you want to hear the unusual parts first,” she said, looking at Sophie.
Sophie pursed her lips together. “Actually,” she said, “Let’s talk intent. Church wedding or civil ceremony?”
“I hardly see how that’s relevant,” Amelia said.
“You’d be surprised,” Sophie said. “The church often counteracts superstition.”
“So you recommend a civil ceremony?” Amelia asked.
“Of course not,” Sophie snapped. “I prefer church. It makes my job so much easier.”
“Counteracts, Amelia,” Gram said as if that clarified the matter.
“Oh,” Amelia said, sounding as dumb as she felt. “Church. Scott’s parents insisted.”
“His parents are still alive. Good,” Sophie said.
Amelia frowned. She wasn’t that old, was she? Old enough to make the groom’s parents survival suspect?
“Look,” Amelia said, wanting the experience over with, “why don’t you just tell me what you need to know and I’ll tell you what Scott and I decided. How’s that?”
“Charming,” Sophie said. “It’ll work best for all concerned.”
Gram humphed and set the pictures down. She stayed in the dining room, though, as if she expected her presence to be a distraction.
It was.
No one could ignore Gram for long.
“Tell me about your dress,” Sophie said. “I do hope you didn’t chose white. You were married before, and therefore you’re not a virgin, are you?”
“Damn close,” Gram said.
“Gram!” Amelia felt her face flush. “No, I’m not a virgin—” and her flush grew deeper as she wondered how many secrets of her life she was willing to tell this woman “—and my dress is not white, although I’m not sure how that matters.”
“In this country, white is for virgin brides. But if you’re not a virgin, and you wear white, someone will die before the year’s out.” Sophie spoke of the impending event with unearthly calm.
“Someone? Who someone?” Amelia said. “The wife? The husband?”
“Yes,” Sophie said. “Generally the husband. You know that white is the color of mourning in China, don’t you?”
“How is that relevant?” Amelia asked.
“She just told you,” Gram said.
Amelia clasped her hands tightly in her lap. She was doing this for Gram, she reminded herself. It was one short afternoon out of her life. She was doing it for Gram.
“My dress is blue,” Amelia said. “It’s real simple with—”
“Blue?” Sophie said. She shook her head. “That won’t do, young lady.”
Now Amelia was a young lady? This from a woman about her own age. This time she did look at Gram, and let all her annoyance show. Gram shrugged and picked up one of the discarded pictures, feigning interest.
“What’s wrong with blue?” Amelia asked, knowing she was opening a door that should have remained closed.
“Blue,” Sophie said. “It’s a sign that your lover has been untrue.”
“Oh, come on,” Amelia said. “How can that be? What about something borrowed, something blue?”
“Something old and something new.” Sophie leaned back on the couch. “Yes, I can see how you’d perceive that as a conflict. All those things are required for the perfect ceremony, but they’re generally small, you know, like a ribbon of blue through a garter. It’s rather like Jimmy Carter; it gives the husband permission to have lust in his heart, but not anywhere else. An entire dress, however, an entire dress is another matter. Has Scott been unfaithful to you, my dear?”
Scott? Gentle, gawky Scott who couldn’t talk to a woman he was attracted to without accidentally breaking half the objects in the room around him? Scott, who confessed the night he fell into bed with her (literally fell; he got tangled in his pants) that he’d only slept with one other women in all his forty years, and he hoped she wouldn’t think him too inexperienced? That Scott?
“Of course not,” Amelia snapped.
“Fiancées are often the last to know,” Sophie said.
“Why in God’s name would a man get married if he were having an affair when he was engaged?” Amelia asked.
“Peer pressure?” Gram said.
Amelia ignored her.
Sophie just stared at her. “There is no understanding men, is there?”
“No.” Amelia stood. “There’s no understanding you. Why would what color I wear at my wedding affect the rest of my life?”
“Amelia—” Gram said in her sternest voice.
“Don’t lecture me,” Amelia said, rather surprised at her own forcefulness. “I have a right to know. What does it matter?”
“Your wedding day is the most important day of your life,” Sophie said, “and that plays a part in the power of the superstitions attached. They work. You’ll see. I can even point to one in your life—”
“Yes, yes, the infamous looking back down the aisle, as if I believe that,” Amelia said.
“No, although that is a good example,” Sophie said. “I suspect another one influenced you even more. Did they throw rice or bird seed at you and your first husband as you left the ceremony?”
“Rice,” Amelia said, feeling rooted to the spot. Why couldn’t she get away from this place of perverse craziness?
“Long grain, brown, or instant?”
“I don’t know, probably instant knowing our friends,” Amelia said.
“Well then,” Sophie said. “There you have it.”
“Have what?”
“Why you don’t have children.”
“How do you know I don’t have children?”
“Because your guests threw Minute Rice,” Sophie said.
“Probably explains other things as well,” Gram said.
“Gram,” Amelia growled, startled to hear the same tone in her own voice as the one Gram often took with her.
Gram shut up.
“That’s not proof of anything,” Amelia said. “We used birth control. We didn’t have a lot of sex after a while. All of those were factors.”
“All of those were results,” Sophie said.
“Of instant rice?” Amelia asked.
“Of course,” Sophie said. “The tradition is bird seed to promote fertility. Many children which was the point of marriage, at least when the tradition was developed. That got converted to rice, which was less effective, and so many people throw that chemically treated stuff, which is not effective at all.”
“My god,” Amelia said. “Gram, are you paying this woman for this nonsense?”
“That’s none of your business,” Gram said. “This is a present.”
“Some present,” Amelia said, out loud. Then she realized what she had done, and the realization scared her. Apparently the days of stifling her responses to Gram were gone. “Do you actually believe this crap? If I wear white, my husband will die. If I wear blue, he’ll have an affair. If I fail to provide my guests with bird seed, I won’t have children, as if the tubal ligation I had three years ago will have nothing to do with it.”
“Amelia,” Gram said.
“No,” Amelia said, not willing to stop, even though she knew that was what Gram wanted. “I can’t believe you’re perpetrating this—this—this—garbage. Marriage is about choice. It’s about choices made every day, by people with guts. People make mistakes, and they live through them. Not because they wore blue at their wedding, but because they chose to. They decided to work on the marriage, they decided to stay together, they decided to continue loving each other.”
“It is not that simple,” Sophie said, holding up a hand.
“Is what I’m saying simple?” Amelia asked. “It sounds a lot harder than trying to make one day of your life perfect. I’m sorry to insult you ladies, but do you really expect me to believe I have no control over my life? That everything is governed by superstition and the simple things we do to ward off the evil eye?”
“Yes,” Sophie said.
“Are you even married?” Amelia asked her. The sarcasm that came out of Amelia’s mouth was an unfamiliar, at least around Gram. Amelia only used that tone at work, and then she used it with microbes that didn’t belong in people’s water supplies, things that she didn’t expect to appear in her electron microscope.
“I’m divorced,” Sophie said, head down.
“Oh, for godsake,” Amelia said.
“It’s not what you think,” Sophie said.
Amelia looked at Gram who was standing straight as a post, the photographs bending in her hand.
“What do I think?” Amelia asked.
“That these things didn’t work for me,” Sophie said. “But I discovered Wedding Counseling after my divorce.”
“So why didn’t you marry again?”
“Because it’s more likely for a woman my age to be killed by terrorists—”
“I hate that statistic,” Amelia said. “Every single woman over thirty recites it like it’s the damn Bible, and no one remembers that that study was disproved. The methodology was faulty.”
She had yelled the last. Her words echoed in the small living room. The flush she had felt earlier returned to her face.
“I’m sorry about your gift, Gram.” Then she bowed slightly to Sophie. “And I’m sorry if I insulted you. But this just isn’t for me.”
“It should be,” Sophie said. “I haven’t had a failure yet, not in 152 consultations.”
Amelia sighed. The reasons for that could be a hundred fold. It might simply be that Sophie’s group of clients were self-selecting for the desire to make their marriages work. It might be that they were a statistical anomaly.
It might even be that the superstitions and her wardings worked.
Amelia didn’t care. She wasn’t going to follow dumb superstitions, and she wasn’t going to listen to a woman who hadn’t made a good marriage herself.
“I’d like to leave, Gram,” she said, and headed for the door. When she reached it, she turned and saw Gram give Sophie an envelope. Gram was apologizing for Amelia’s rudeness as Amelia left.
Amelia went down the cracked stoop to the gravel drive. Birds flying overhead, going to the Horicon Marsh, cawed. A slight breeze blew over her, and it blew away the stale air from the interior of the house. She had never acted like that around Gram before. In fact, she rarely lost her temper at all. But she didn’t like the pap this woman had been serving, and she couldn’t remain silent about it.
Somehow, the silence made her feel as if she were perpetuating the beliefs.
And she couldn’t. She couldn’t change her plans no matter how much Gram wanted it. This was Amelia’s wedding, the one she was planning with Scott. And it was her marriage, with Scott. And it was up to them to make it work. If they failed, she didn’t want to hire Sophie to scan their wedding pictures. Amelia wanted a real human accounting, a way of knowing where she and Scott had gone wrong.
The door closed behind her. She cringed, then turned. Gram was walking alone down the short sidewalk. She was clutching her purse to her chest. “I’d like you to drive,” she said.
“I’m sorry, Gram,” Amelia said as she started across the gravel.
“Don’t be,” Gram said. “This had the desired effect.”
Amelia stopped. “What do you mean?”
“You won’t talk to me,” Gram said. “You let me blather, and you smile and say, ‘Yes Gram’ as if I’ve already gone senile. Well, I haven’t. And you made a terrible marriage the last time, even though you’re not willing to admit it, and I didn’t want you to make a terrible marriage this time.”
“Sophie’s ideas are not what I need,” Amelia said.
“I know, and thank God for that,” Gram said.
The breeze blew Amelia’s hair in her face. She brushed it back with her left hand. “I thought you believed Sophie.”
“Oh, I think she has a valuable talent. I think she has the ability to make people see their future marriages clearly. I think if I had brought you here when you were going to marry Ralph, you would have decided to call off the wedding.”
“So you don’t buy this blue thing, this bird seed stuff.”
“No,” Gram said. “I wore black when I married Willard, or don’t you remember?”
“I remember,” Amelia said. “But I don’t know what it means.”
“It means,” Gram said, “that you’re sad about the wedding, maybe even that you’re doing it against your will.”
“But you loved Willard.”
“Of course I loved Willard.”
“And you were the happiest I ever saw you that day.”
“Of course I was,” Gram said.
“Then that just proves that Sophie’s wrong.”
“No,” Gram said.
“No?” Amelia asked.
“No,” Gram repeated. “It means that when I came to see Sophie and we discussed the wedding, I realized how much I wanted my marriage to be successful, and how hard I was willing to work to make it go that way. Which, if you’ll recall that little speech you gave us in there, is exactly what you said about Scott.”
Amelia turned slightly so that her hair wouldn’t keep blowing in her face. “You could have just asked me.”
“I did,” Gram said. “You always told me that he was a nice man and I shouldn’t worry, which is exactly what you said about whatshisname.”
“Ralph.”
“Ralph,” Gram said and shook her head. “How you could marry a name like that, I’ll never know.”
“Don’t start, Gram.”
Gram shrugged and walked to the car. Amelia hurried behind her. Gram climbed into the passenger seat and stuck the keys in the ignition. Amelia slid into the driver’s side.
“You mean you went through this whole charade just to learn if I loved Scott and would work on our marriage?”
“Yes,” Gram said.
“Why?”
“You mean besides the fact that I love you and want only the best for you?”
“That goes without saying, Gram,” Amelia said. She pushed the seat back so that her knees weren’t crammed into the steering wheel.
“Well,” Gram said, “it’s because you’re nearly forty. If I had married Willard when I was forty—and I knew him then—we would have had thirty wonderful years together instead of five. Five simply wasn’t enough. Thirty wouldn’t have been either, but it would have been better—”
Her voice broke. Amelia put her arm around Gram’s shoulder and pulled her close. “All I wanted,” Gram said against Amelia’s collarbone, “is to make sure you have a Willard in your life. Every girl deserves at least one.”
“I do, Gram,” Amelia said softly.
“I know that now,” Gram said. She pushed away and dabbed at her eyes with her thumb. “Will you drive? I have bridge club at seven.”
“Sure, Gram,” Amelia said.
She turned the key and the car started, its motor humming. She took a deep breath.
“Gram,” she said. “Thanks. No one has ever given me a gift like this.”
“What gift?” Gram asked.
Amelia turned slightly in her seat. “I thought you said this was a present.”
“The visit was and you didn’t want it.”
“But you gave it to me anyway.”
“You shouldn’t thank me for something you didn’t want.”
Amelia frowned. “But it turned out all right.”
“Well, it did, but that’s no reason to thank me.” Gram pushed a button on the door, and her window came down, letting in that errant breeze.
“Why not?”
“It worked because of you, my girl,” Gram said. She leaned her head back and closed her eyes.
Amelia stared at her for a moment, still uncertain about what to make of her Grandmother, even though they’d been close her entire life.
“I suppose you and Scott will want to visit me,” Gram said, eyes still closed.
“Of course,” Amelia said.
“Regularly,” Gram said.
“Yes,” Amelia said.
Gram sighed. “Then I’ll have to move.”
“Why?”
“Or raise my chandelier. Which will be cheaper, do you think?”
Amelia put the car into reverse. “Raising your chandelier.”
“Good,” Gram said. “I rather like the house.” She opened her eyes. “I think you should let me drive.”
“No, Gram,” Amelia said.
“Then get us out on the highway, my girl,” Gram said. “Time’s wasting. You young people never understand how important these small moments are.”
Amelia grinned. “I think we do, Gram,” she said. “I think we do.”
___________________________________________
“Something Blue” is available for one week on this site. The ebook is available on all retail stores, as well as here.
Something Blue
Copyright © 2018 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Black Cats and Broken Mirrors, edited by Martin H. Greenberg and John Helfers, DAW, June, 1998Published by WMG PublishingCover and layout copyright © 2018 by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © inarik | Depositphotos
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
I’m having a blast working on book trailers when WMG does Kickstarters. I just completed this book trailer for Dean’s Kickstarter, which launched today. I hope you enjoy the video and I hope it inspires you to look at the Kickstarter! Lots of cool stuff there. (Click here for the Kickstarter)
https://kriswrites.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/Mary-Jo-Assassin-Book-Trailer-Low-Res.mp4
I mentioned in January’s list that I had fewer books to recommend in February and March. I read a lot but didn’t finish some of the books, and the ones I did finish, I didn’t really like well enough to recommend. As I tell my writing students, you have to stick the landing. And some of those landings really missed. A few of the others just bored me. I faded out as I went along and realized I didn’t want to read the book anymore. (I do that by grabbing other books, starting those, and realizing that I’d rather be reading them.)
I have stories here from 2 different Best American Mystery & Suspense, but I’m not recommending either volume, since I didn’t read a lot of them. The stories seemed child-cruelty heavy or animal abuse heavy, and I’m not really into either of those things. And there’s some I’m not fond of the kind of noir in either of them. So it’s up to you if you get these two volumes.
So here’s what I liked back in February…
February 2025Bernier, Ashley-Ruth M., “Ripen,” The Best American Mystery and Suspense 2023, edited by Lisa Unger, Mariner Books, 2023. When editors are lazy with the Best Americans and do not put the stories in any kind of reading order, the opening story is a real crapshoot. I’m always braced for something that does not give me any ideas as to the way the volume will go. As a result, I approach the first story with trepidation, and usually that trepidation is justified.
In this volume, though, the first story, “Ripen,” is well written, powerful, and memorable. I was happily surprised by the entire thing. The setting is rich, the characters vivid, and the story itself strong. Read this one.
Cho, Winston, “AI: The Ghost in Hollywood’s Machine,” The Hollywood Reporter, December 13, 2024. (This story online has a different title.) Fascinating piece that could have been written about any emerging technology, really. AI will change how business gets done all over the planet (is changing?), and Hollywood is no different. It will make some things easier to “film” such as massive crowd scenes (already is, in fact) but it might cost a lot of jobs. As in a lot of jobs. And the kind that normally don’t get taken by technological change…as in the jobs of creatives. I think we’ll see a lot of these articles in the future as we try to figure out how to live with this newest thing in our lives.
Cobo, Leila, “Guarding Celia Cruz’s Legacy,” Billboard January 11, 2025. Fascinating interview with Omer Pardillo, who manages the Celia Cruz estate. It’s about how he got the job, how he goes about maintaining the estate, and the heart of the estate. He lists where the revenue comes from. He says it’s mostly from recording royalties and brand partnerships. It’s really fun to see his joy at all of the success the estate’s been having. At one point, he states that it’s not bad for an artist who’s been dead for 21 years.
Cole, Alyssa, “Just a Girl,” The Best American Mystery and Suspense 2024, edited by S.A. Cosby, Mariner Books, 2024. This story, written as a series of online TikTok posts, DMs, texts, emails, and online articles, is devastating and heartbreaking and extremely powerful. Tiana, her first year in college during Covid, starts posting updates on TikTok, and gaining a following. She tries a dating app, encounters a gross guy, and calls his yuckiness out on her TikTok…and then he and his friends start going after her. Everything spirals after that. What’s amazing about this story is that you can see the joy leaching from this young woman as she realizes how terrible the world can be—and how dangerous it is for young beautiful women. Highly recommended.
Freimor, Jacqueline, “Forward,” The Best American Mystery and Suspense 2023, edited by Lisa Unger, Mariner Books, 2023. Normally, I wouldn’t read a story that looked dense and difficult, but the format (and the footnotes) are the point of the story. It’s an amazing work of fiction, with a great reveal. Yes, it takes concentration to read it, but it’s really worthwhile.
McClintock, Pamela, “Ryan Reynolds Multitasks Like a Mofo,” The Hollywood Reporter, December 13, 2024. There’s a lot of fascinating quotes in this interview with Ryan Reynolds, whom The Hollywood Reporter dubbed their Producer of the Year. He does a variety of things besides act, and seems to enjoy all of them. The quote I like the most is at the end:
…it’s all an emotional investment. If you can create emotional investment in anything, any brand, it creates a moat around that brand that really, I think, facilitates the resilience and allows it to weather the storms in the bad times. And yes, that’s the part I love.
I think I love it too, although not as much as actual writing and making things up. Still, lots of good stuff to think about in this interview.
Zeitchik, Steven,“The Other Rebuild,” The Hollywood Reporter, January 17, 2025. 2025 has been such a shitshow already it’s hard to remember that the LA Fires happened only a few months ago. We seem to be moving from tragedy to tragedy, heartbreak to heartbreak, every single day, and we lose track of what others have gone through. A number of my friends went through the fires and fortunately, in this round of the climate change blues, very few of them lost their homes. (I can’t say that about previous California fires.) But everyone’s mental health took a nosedive. Many moved to different digs in the same town while others are leaving their LA homes. It’s an ongoing tragedy, and this is a piece from the early days. Important.
I tend to write a lot of mystery novellas. They’re too long for traditional publishers, which makes them perfect for WMG. We can put the novellas in book form.
Over the last year, a number of you have asked how to get my Derringer-award winning novella, “Catherine The Great,” and while you can get it in last year’s Holiday Spectacular compilation, that’s only available in ebook. Many of you want paper…and I get it. I do too.
So, we decided to put it into paper. And by the time we got to that project, I had also written three other mystery/crime novellas. One is a thriller (Kizzie) and two are more straightforward mysteries. We put all four in a Kickstarter that launches today.
Here’s the video for the Kickstarter. Over the next week, I’ll also share the book trailers with you for the novellas. However, if you’d like to see them now, head to the Kickstarter. They’re all on it, along with a lot of other goodies.
As you can tell, this is one of my favorite things to write. I hope you end up getting the books.
https://kriswrites.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/4-Mystery-Novellas-Low-Res.mp4
You’ve probably noticed that we really upped our design game at WMG Publishing in the past year. Some of that is due to the new designers we’ve brought on board, but some of it is because Stephanie Writt has a lot of design experience using modern tools like Canva.
In combination with Dean, whose done more book covers than anyone I know, they’re working together to come up with really pretty books.
Every Friday, they do a seminar together called Writer Direct, which helps writers go directly to the readers, through indie publishing and marketing. (It’s open to anyone for a monthly fee.) For the past six months, the writers who attend have asked Dean and Steph to do a workshop on covers.
Once they started brainstorming, they realized they could do workshops on covers and interiors and Kickstarter.
These courses are designed to take a writer who has never designed anything and have them making gorgeous books by the end of the class. I’m their guinea pig. (Dyslexic girl. If they can get me to do it, anyone can do it.)
The nice thing about these, though, is that there are design tricks in the new programs that long-time designers don’t know. So there’s an entire section for people who have been making covers and designing books for years.
The classes won’t start for a few weeks, but we’re offering an early bird sale on these, which is buy two and get the third free. (In other words, save $500.) Or just buy one and save $100 off the price. Find out more information here.
When you follow that link, you’ll see another class from me. I’m doing short classes on techniques that I can teach quickly. After finishing the difficult senses—smell and taste (which I taught together)—those who came to the webinar asked for similar classes on the remaining three senses.
So, I’m going from hardest to easiest. The next one is on touch. It starts right after I finish the in-person Gothic workshop next week.
Finally, Dean and I are finishing up the next installment in The Kris & Dean Show Goes To the Movies. We’re doing Ocean’s 11 (the 2001 version). I’m the one who picked that because I’ve been meaning to examine that film very closely.
Turns out it’s even more useful than I thought it would be. This class will teach you all about how to feed information to a reader so that they don’t notice the important stuff until you want them to. It’ll also show you how to establish characters quickly, and how to handle an extremely complicated storyline with verve and clarity.
We’re having a great time doing this one, and it’ll go live next week.
So take a look and see if there’s a class for you.
Like to read? Like to knit? Like socks? Like fantasy?
Then this is the Kickstarter project for you.
Here, in a nutshell, is what it is:
Socks & Sorcery will have four themed collector’s boxes, each delivered three times over the course of a year. Every box contains:
Mix and match any of the four themes—Dragons, Familiars, Witches and Vampires, or Faeries—or get them all for a box delivered each month for a year!
There are lots of great writers contributing books to this project including T. Thorn Coyle, Anthea Sharp, Leslie Claire Walker, and Thomas K. Carpenter. The first book in my Fey series, Sacrifice, is also a part of the project.
This project is a lot of fun, and I’m pleased to take part in it. I hope you join us!
I do most of my business writing on Patreon these days, but roughly once per month, I’ll put a post for free on this website. This post initially went live on my Patreon page on March 30, 2025. If you go to Patreon, you’ll find other posts like this one.
Putting Yourself Out ThereI’m gearing back up to return to the university in the fall. After a heck of a couple of years, I’m resuming my very slow attempt to get a few extra college degrees. Mostly, it’s an excuse to listen to people much younger than myself learn cool stuff, and an excuse to listen to people somewhat younger than myself share their expertise.
I get inspired by all of that.
I’m searching class schedules and realizing that my Spanish has gotten rusty again, so there is probably a summertime online refresher in the complicated tenses on the horizon. Even though, really, using the proper tense is not my problem so much as finding the correct vocabulary word. As in any word that might suit in that circumstance. The vocabulary was the first thing to flee my brain in the hiatus.
The thing that fascinates me the most, though, is watching the theater kids, particularly those who are (at 18, 19, or 20) convinced they’re going to be Actors! (and yes, the exclamation point is there for a reason). Most won’t be, not because they’re not good enough, but because they don’t listen well and they already think they’re God’s gift to the profession.
Mostly, I watch the ones who are insecurely secure in their dreams. These kids know exactly what they want in their lives, but they’re not sure they’re good enough to get there, so they work extra hard to figure out where they should be.
Sometimes it is not where they expect to be. In the theater department in particular, they have to take courses in all aspects of theater, and they sometimes learn that they love a part of theater that they hadn’t expected to like at all.
Surprisingly enough to my younger self, the one who didn’t have the courage to follow her musical abilities into a music degree or to even walk into the theater department at the University of Wisconsin, there are a lot of introverts in theater. Some of those introverts are writers, yes, but many go onstage and perform. Most, in fact, because they like being someone else in front of a group. It’s safer for them.
I get safe. It makes sense. I also get the fear of doing something revealing in front of a crowd. Mostly, that fear is gone for me now. Years of public speaking and talking on panels at sf conventions eased my mind.
Still, I was pretty shocked when I learned that a lot of actors and musicians suffer severe stage fright—people you’ve all heard of. If they have to go onstage, they sit in the dressing room and shake, or, in some cases, puke, because they’re so scared.
Had I known that…well, I doubt I would have done it, because puking is not something I voluntarily do, even for art…but it certainly would have eased my mind about what for me is relatively minor stage fright (in comparison to what these folks have).
Really, though, it’s what they are willing to do for their dreams and their art. They put themselves out there. More importantly, they figure out how to put themselves out there.
Every year, I have a conversation with at least one of my writing students who is terrified for some reason I never probe of putting their work in front of an audience. It always boils down to the fact that they’re afraid of being seen.
Sidebar from a nearly 65-year-old person who has worked in the arts her entire life: You are never seen. Not in your entirety. You may reveal all of your secrets and no one will care. Or they’ll comment on the portrayal of something minor, like the cat, and kvetch about that. It’s disappointing…and freeing.
However, the fear of being seen is a real and crippling fear, stopping a lot of prose writers and poets from following their dreams. Writers, unlike actors and musicians, can hide from the world. You can use a pen name, set up a legal entity that doesn’t use your real name (in an obvious manner), and never let your picture out into the world.
You can hide and publish your work. That’s the great thing about being a writer.
Usually when a writer figures out their own personal workaround, they put their work on the market, whatever it means for them.
I had one of those discussions this past week with a couple of different writers, some in person, one online, and when I photo-bombed the Writers’ Block webinar on Wednesday.
After that moment on the webinar, I spent a few hours thinking about how universal that fear is among writers. I’ve been in this business almost fifty years now, and I’ve seen it every year.
Then Dean and I watched a little bit of The Voice. We often watch something to rest our poor brains, usually at dinner. We’ve moved away from news (since there’s no way that will relax anyone), and gone to documentaries and The Voice.
We usually watch a segment or two and then go back to whatever we were doing. It will take us days to watch an entire 2-hour episode.
So that Wednesday night, we watched two members of Michael Bublé’s team duet on a song he wrote, called “Home.” Most of you know it as a super hit for Blake Shelton, but Bublé wrote the song and released it first.
Before the battle, Bublé talked a bit about writing the song. I can’t find the clip for that (mostly because I’m lazy, but also because it’s not that relevant), but I did find the one that caught my attention.
It got me thinking, and I went up to my office and made a list.
Most people who work in the arts realize that their work has to be put out into the world.
Often they perform their own work, in some kind of concert, and it is that work that ends up catapulting them into whatever level of fame they will reach.
And then, partly because of the vagaries of the (exceedingly complex) music copyright laws, they may hear someone else cover their song. They might be like John Legend, who has said on The Voice that he cannot listen to a cover of one of his songs fairly. Or they might be like Bublé who not only assigned the song, but was honored by the way the singers performed it.
In early drafts of a play, the playwright will have to be nearby to do some kind of work to smooth out that section. Sometimes it’s because the star is a doofus and can’t say a word with more than two syllables, but mostly it’s because that section of the show, when performed in previews, did not work. Neil Simon deals with this a lot in his autobiography Rewrites.
After his early years in Hollywood (when he didn’t have enough clout to have that stupid contract), he rarely sold a screenplay and when he did, it was a charity sale from a friend who would buy the screenplay so that the writer could retain his Writers Guild membership. (And then the charity friend would do a shooting script.)
Even the lowest of the low, graffiti “artists,” the ones who deface buildings, understand that their art needs to be seen. (I’m grumpy about graffiti these days since Vegas has a lot of wall murals all over the city—and the freakin’ graffiti “artists” will deface them. Grrr. I hate people who deface other people’s art.)
Some of it was funny. Much of it was not.
Fiction writers—people who write novels and short stories—are the only artists I know who expect someone else to publish their work. Fiction writers, particularly those who are traditionally published, believe that all they have to do is write it, and everyone will flock to their feet.
That’s an ingrained attitude, and a hard one to fight. Heck, a lot of these writers are worried when they decide to give a copy of their manuscript to an editor at a book publishing house or (worse) an agent.
Writers do not expect to have their work in the public view, and often fear it.
I’m not sure why this is. I think it’s just part of the culture.
There are movies that show writers at work, and someone else dragging that “brilliant” manuscript off the writer’s desk. Or the writer “gets discovered” in an English class (never happened when I was in school). Or someone else mailed off their manuscript.
That myth goes hand in hand with the idea that writing should be hard and writers should suffer while doing it. That myth also goes with the idea that anything written fast is terrible and anything labored over is brilliant. And that myth goes with the idea that being prolific is a sin. (Tell that to Charles Dickens and William Shakespeare.)
Indie writers have a similar problem, but it’s couched in other terms. I don’t want to learn how to publish. That’s going to be hard. It’ll take too much money or I can’t do covers or…or…
Okay, I want to reply, whatever roadblocks you want to set up for your work, go ahead.
But real artists—be they musicians or painters or (yes) writers—need to have their work seen. They need to figure out how to get on that stage despite their stage fright and put their art in front of an audience.
Otherwise the art will be destroyed when they die, tossed out with the trash or deleted off their computers.
Oh…and let’s talk “covers” for a minute. Blake Shelton’s version of “Home” is very different from Bublé’s version, which is different from the duet that aired on The Voice this past week.
If you’re lucky as a writer, and if you put yourself out there, at some point, someone will want to do make another piece of art using yours as inspiration. Maybe a movie, maybe a TV show, maybe a dramatic reading or an audio book.
That’s a “cover” for lack of a better term. (It really is a derivative work, and it does fall in a different place in the copyright law, but go with me on this for a minute.) Instead of being all protective and saying that you must control all things, say yes…if the contract terms are good.
That’s all.
A singer doesn’t have to get permission to cover a song. I can sing “Home” badly in front of an audience if I want to, but if I get paid for it, I need to let the songwriter know that I’m going to be covering the song. The songwriter cannot say no.
It gets complicated after that. (Okay, it’s already complicated.) But implied in all of this is that the music needs to get in front of an audience. The play will be performed. The screenplay will become the basis for a movie. The painting will hang on a gallery wall.
What makes writer-artists any different? Why should we fight so hard to create something and then be afraid to put it in front of an audience. Particularly since we’ll never see that audience. We don’t have to hear from them either, if we keep our email private and don’t go on social media and don’t read reviews.
What makes fiction writers so dang delicate? Every artist has fears. All of us do. If we want to make a living at our art, we learn to overcome the fear.
It may take a dozen workarounds. It might mean the writing equivalent of puking in the bathroom before stepping on the stage. But if you value your own work and your own dreams, you learn how to get past whatever is stopping you.
Just like other performers do.
“Putting Yourself Out There,” copyright © 2025 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Picture of Gavin is there because, despite appearances, he’s terrified of putting himself out there.
I read a lot in January and liked a lot of it as well. Some truly marvelous books (which is not what I could say for February & March. More on that in those lists). I also finished my reading for the in-person space opera workshop I was conducting in the middle of the month. Honestly, I didn’t like much of what I read in the brand-new anthologies I found. The stories had no depth or no ending or both. So I don’t have a lot to recommend from those books. Usually I can at least recommend the introductions, but one stunningly left out all the great female space opera writers of the 1990s and barely mentioned the ones in the 2000s. I realize that bias happens, but that one stung on a bunch of levels. (I guess I expect it from old timers, most of whom are not with us anymore, but not folks who were active in those time periods.)
I haven’t yet finished reading The Best American Sports Writing of the Century, because I needed to take a break. The book has a slant that is very white-male oriented. It’s also filled with some challenging pieces that aren’t holding up to the 26 years since the book was printed. (I swear, New Journalism is soooo self-involved.) But some of it is good and interesting and I’ll come back to it when the mood suits me. I doubt I’ll ever recommend the book, but watch: there will be a time when I recommend more essays from it.
I read one of the best novels I’ve seen in years and some great articles. So January was quite a success…which is why this list is so late. It took a while to chronicle my reading.
January 2025Anders, Charlie Jane, “A Temporary Embarrassment in Space Time,” New Adventures in Space Opera, edited by Jonathan Strahan, Tachyon, 2024. I absolutely love this story. It’s everything a certain kind of space opera should be—fun, preposterous, believable, tense, and adventurous. All wrapped into a neat and well-written package. A wonderful gem of a story.
Crais, Robert, The Big Empty, Putnam, 2024. The best book I’ve read all year, maybe in the past few years. I love Robert Crais’s Elvis Cole and Joe Pike. Pike doesn’t show up until halfway through this book because Bob is so dang good at point of view and the way a story should flow. I don’t have a lot of time for leisure reading, and right now, my lack of time is significantly worse. So I did the readerly thing. I stayed up past my bedtime, and Dean literally had to pull the book from my hands. I still read it in two days. Fantastic. And no, I’m not going to tell you much more than “fantastic” because, as with all of Bob’s books, to say more is to ruin a surprise. (I might have already said too much, in fact.)
Deaver, Jeffery, and Maldonado, Isabella, Fatal Intrusion, Thomas & Mercer, 2024. Yep, I have an Amazon link only for this book, because I just discovered something very unpleasant. This book (and a bunch of Deaver novellas) are only available in ebook on Amazon. Sorry about that! I read the book in paper, which is how I prefer to read, so I had no idea that this had happened until the moment I was putting the book on the list. Sigh. It makes me, as a reader, more than mildly pissed off.
The book is good enough. It’s not as good as most Deaver books, but it’s better than a lot of thrillers. I’ll read the next book in the series, and if I like it, I’ll pick up one of Maldonado’s books. Collaborations are a difficult animal. They can be something better than both writers, especially if the book is something they wouldn’t have written without the collaborator. I suppose Deaver could argue that he wouldn’t have had a character like Carmen Sanchez, but except for a few chapters that I suspect were all Maldonado, she felt very generic. So I don’t think this collaboration enhanced the two writers’ work (I’m saying this without having read hers). But this is a good way to while away a few hours.
Fekadu, Mesfin, “The Loophole That Landed Muni Long a Grammy Nom,” The Hollywood Reporter, November 20, 2024. The online version of this article has the title “Muni Long Explains How She Made It,” and I think that is a better title for the content here. Muni Long has been around for awhile, and she has followed her own path. There are some great quotes in here, but the best was her response to how she got paid for her streaming content:
Sometimes you look at your quarterly statement and you’re like, “Oh wow, $1,000 for 500 million streams. Great. That’s awesome.” The sheer volume that I have to write in order to make an income that makes sense [is insane]. What saved me is that I have quality and quantity, whereas some of these people, all they have is one or two records.
Quantity and quality. She’s right. We’re doing the same. Take a look at this one, even if you’re new to Muni Long.
Harris, Robert,, Vintage Books, 2016. I really like Robert Harris’s writing, although his topics don’t always interest me. I picked up Conclave after seeing a review of the film. A lot of my favorite actors are in it, and since I like Harris, I thought I should give the book an eyeball before watching the film. Glad I did. There’s a nice moment toward the end of the book, something completely unexpected and yet set up. It worked for me, and might not have worked in the film (which I have not yet seen). Of course, that had me looking through more Robert Harris for the books I’ve missed. I mostly didn’t order the ones on the topics that I don’t care about, but I did preorder the next. I love his courage as a writer. He’s always doing something interesting. This is a novella, filled with his great characters and marvelous writing. Oh, and for the interested: I am not Catholic, although I was in and out of Catholic churches as a kid because so many of my friends were Catholic. So I have a passing familiarity with some of the rituals, but no great interest in the church or its habits. I still found this fascinating.
Heinz, W.C., “Brownsville Bum,” The Best American Sports Writing of the Century, edited by David Halberstam with Glenn Stout, HarperCollins, 1999. I had never heard of W.C. Heinz before reading this book. Yet many of the other writers in the front half of the book (at least) mentioned him as the best of the best. Well, this is my favorite piece in the book so far. It’s a 1951 piece about someone named Bummy Davis who was a fighter back in the day when fighters could kill each other in the ring. This one reads like a short story—the life and death of kinda thing. The writing itself is sharp and crisp, the events breathtaking. The murder, at the end, shocking because it happened in a bar, not in the ring. If you find the book, read this one first.
Rose, Lacey, “Selena Gomez is Waiting For Your Call,” The Hollywood Reporter, November 20, 2024. Last fall and early this year, there were a lot of interviews with Selena Gomez as the Oscar and Grammy hype heated up. She has a good team. But she’s also a great interview because, as young as she is, she’s had an amazing career. She knows who she is, and she’s blunt about it. I can’t encapsulate this long piece in any coherent way, except to say all writers (and Selena fans) should read it.
Royko, Mike, “‘A Very Solid Book,'” The Best American Sports Writing of the Century, edited by David Halberstam with Glenn Stout, HarperCollins, 1999. A lot of the work in this book is dated. So dated, in fact, that I had to look up some of the rivalries just to see what was going on. But this piece by Mike Royko from 1987 is familiar. I was 27 at the time, and aware of the Mets/Cubs rivalry.
Some idiot at some NY publishing house asked Royko to review a book about the Mets. And oh, did he. This piece is not dated, once you knew about the rivalry, and it is one one of my favorites. I just read it again, out loud this time to Dean. It’s a very short piece that is, ostensibly, a review of a book by Mets first baseman (at the time) Keith Hernandez. And Smith was a Cubbies fan through and through. The book is solid, you see, because it can survive being thrown against a wall…
Really worth reading
Score, Lucy, Things We Never Got Over, Bloom Books, 2022. Okay, this is annoying. As I set up this post, I discovered that Lucy Score’s ebooks are exclusive to Amazon. Same thing as the Deaver/Maldonado above. Grrrr. You can get the paperbooks anywhere you want, but to get the ebook, you have to go to Amazon. You can’t even go to her own website/store to get the book. Sorry about that. Get the paper. She has some lovely deluxe editions.
However, I did find the book on Amazon. I had just finished something else (what I can’t remember) and the algorithm suggested this book. I did what I often do and read the first chapter. And wowza is it good. Seriously, this first chapter is worth reading even if you don’t pick up the book. The chapter is a masterclass of information flow. The chapter title is Worst. Day. Ever. The first paragraph is a perfect hook:
I wasn’t sure what to expect when I walked into Café Rev, but it sure as hell wasn’t a picture of myself behind the register under the cheery headline “Do Not Serve.” A yellow frowny face magnet held the photo in place.
Each paragraph builds on that. With each page, the situation gets worse and worse and worse. You—well, I—had to go to the next chapter immediately. The book ends up being a tiny bit long, and for a moment verges on “if you two only talk to each other, this would end” but by then I didn’t care. The book is fun, the writing is great, and the characters are a hoot. So pick this one up…or at the very least (writers) read that first paragaph.
Smith, Red, “Next To Godliness,” The Best American Sports Writing of the Century, edited by David Halberstam with Glenn Stout, HarperCollins, 1999. My father, who was born in 1914, used to talk about the great sports writers and announcers from his life. He also talked about great players, so many of their names are familiar to me. Others, not quite as much. But Red Smith was quite familiar. His name was in the air all the time in our family, and also in the various writing classes I had. Red Smith was one of those writers even non-sports fans enjoyed.
Back when my father imprinted on baseball, there was radio, but it was local only. So games played outside of the area weren’t aired. The readers had to rely on the print media.
“Next To Godliness” describes an entire game in maybe 1,000 words. It also describes the reaction to that game from Smith himself. It’s lovely and well done. There’s a reason this man’s work was remembered—at least for another 50 years.
Smith, Thomas, “Dua Lipa Talks 2024,” Billboard, December 14. 2024. I love Dua Lipa’s stuff. I run to it. I also enjoy how she’s running her career, in the same way that I admire the way Taylor Swift is. These women are taking charge in a way that most musicians do not. So read this. She’s interesting and what she’s doing with her business is also great.
Verhoeven, Beatrice, “John M. Chu,” The Hollywood Reporter, November 13, 2024. Fascinating interview with John M. Chu, released just before Wicked came out. (If you haven’t seen Wicked, oh, you must! It’s marvelous.) Lots of great material here, mostly about being courageous. Lots of behind the scenes on his various movies as well. In The Heights, Crazy Rich Asians, and more. Read this one.
Weir, Keziah, “Give And Let Give,” Vanity Fair, October, 2024. I’ve been thinking about this interview ever since I read it, particularly as one particularly nutty billionaire chainsaws his way through American government, another sends his fiance into space, and the rest don’t seem to give a rat’s banana about actual human beings.
Melinda French Gates, former wife of Bill Gates, is also worth billions, and she’s giving it away, systematically, to charity after charity. She says it’s not easy, because she had to have the right organization in place to help funnel the money, and then she has to figure out where she can do the most good. Note the difference: Do The Most Good. Yeah, she’s not the only ex-wife of a billionaire doing this.
It’s fascinating to me that the wealthy women understand their social responsibility and the bulk of the men…do not.
I know, I know. It’s April Fool’s Day. And Dean Wesley Smith decided to launch a Kickstarter anyway. It’s for his Poker Boy series, which is one of my favorites. If you back it, you’ll get four Poker Boy ebooks and whatever stretch goals we hit. And writers, there’s some really great rewards here. So take a look.
And if you’re uncertain, at least watch the video I did. Enjoy! (Oh, and head to the Kickstarter here.)
This is the first time in months that I was able to do a lot of reading for pleasure. Yes, I had other things to read and work on, but my time is starting to ease up. Yay! And more yays…I’m keeping this one up in real time. I will be publishing the lists I missed over the next few months, but I’m going to try to keep up with the current months as I go. I managed in October, which was a real victory. I enjoyed a lot of what I read, as you can see below, but also had to complain about a few books (without author names attached).
I guess I’ll start with the complaints. I read a standalone novel by a writer whose work I usually love. The novel was predictable and deeply unpleasant. I kept waiting for a twist, but none came. And the ending had no validation at all. The story just ended. It was almost offensively awful. I kept reading, thinking that something would pay off. This is what happens when you love an author’s work. You trust them to tell a story you’ll like. However, when they don’t, you usually don’t punish them. I will certainly buy his next. However, if the books continue to offend or displease me, I’ll stop. Fortunately, this one was from 2018, and he’s written a lot of books I like since. So this was a one-off. I also know that there are some topics he writes about that just don’t interest me. I think the problem on this one was marketing. It was marketing like the books I like, even thought it’s nothing like them. Whoops, traditional publisher. You didn’t give me enough information to make an informed choice. That same publisher did something similar on a book that came out last year. I wouldn’t have bought it, if not for a reader review that mentioned something in the book that made it a must-be (and a favorite read) for me. So marketing really does matter. Communicating the right thing to readers really matters.
Then I read a book in a series that I like a great deal, but this one was so mediocre that I was scanning by the end. And then I looked at Amazon to see when the next book was coming out…and it wasn’t. (She’s traditionally published.) That broke my heart a little. If she were indie, she’d have a next book which I would read, thinking this one a blip. (Sigh.)
And a third book that I’m not going to recommend, from yet another favorite writer. I read it…slowly…as my before-bed reading because it wasn’t challenging. Until it was. It became a challenging read because (I realized) there was no story if the heroine wasn’t TSTL (romance terminology for Too Stupid To Live). And if she and the hero had just talked, there would be no book either. Not that the secondary characters were any smarter. I finished it because…because…I didn’t quit. I think if I had been reading it at a different time of day, it would have gone into the trade-in pile much sooner.
Ironically, I’m rereading a book by the first author as I type this, and I’m reading another book by the third writer I mentioned. These duds didn’t scare me away. I couldn’t read another book by the second writer because there were none available. (Waaaaaah)
And now, below, on time! the books and articles that I can recommend from October.
October, 2024Burt, Stephanie, “Swift 101,” Vanity Fair, July/August 2024. Stephanie Burt taught a class in Taylor Swift and her many influences at Harvard. The class isn’t just about music. In fact, it’s in the English Department. The things she learned and taught are fascinating. Makes me wish I could take the class next year…and I’m not a Swiftie (although I like many of her songs).
Colapinto, John, “Jon Bon Jovi’s Long Journey Back,” AARP The Magazine, June/July 2024. As many of you who read these lists a lot know, I’m fascinated by how people manage to have very long careers. Jon Bon Jovi’s career has lasted more than 40 years. And then, despite great self-care, he lost his voice. This is about the ways that “life happens,” as he says. The interview is about survival and art, and is really worth reading.
Connelly, Michael, Desert Star, Little, Brown, 2024. It’s been a long time since I blew through a book as fast I blew through this one. Connelly’s books are uneven for me, but they’re always readable. This one had actual tension that kept me turning pages. Renée Ballard goes for her usual morning surf, and while she’s in the water, someone steals her wallet and badge (hidden on her car). Because she faces discrimination in the office, she doesn’t want to tell her boss that her badge is missing. So much of the early part of the book is about the recovery of her badge, and of course, things get worse. She involves not only Harry Bosch, but his daughter Maddie, and then there’s a twist—and well, I went through this in just a few hours. If you like this series, you will as well.
Dailey, Hannah, “K-Pop Is Everything,” Billboard, August 24, 2o24. Universal Music Publishing Group runs an international songwriting camp. The teaser on this article is that the camp is designed to produce “the next real batch of surefire hits for [K-Pop’s] young stars.” The pressure, the work, the procedures described in the article remind me of the music factory at the Brill Building in New York in the early 1960s, a place that truly was a hit factory. The difference, though, is the writers know that the lyrics will get translated. (Translators get a royalty split.) Fascinating read.
Fell, Nicole, “Finding The Right Palette for Red, White & Royal Blue,” The Hollywood Reporter, August 15, 2024. I loved the book Red, White & Royal Blue, and I’ll be honest: I haven’t seen the Amazon film yet. It’s a romance, and neither male lead looks like the men I’d had in mind while I read. So I’ve been putting off watching it. (Yes, I’m that superficial.) But Casey McQuiston, the author, was interviewed (along with one of the actors) for The Hollywood Reporter, and I did read that avidly. There’s a quote in the middle of this piece about the differences between a novel and a film, from McQuiston’s point of view, and it’s absolutely worth reading. (The book is too.)
Friend, Tom, “Peter Gammons: Diamond Vision,” The Year’s Best Sports Writing 2024, edited by Jane McManus, Triumph Books, 2024. Form follows function. In the middle of this essay, about Peter Gammons and the day he nearly died, Friend mentions that Gammons told his writing instructor back at the beginning of his career that he didn’t want to write bland prose. He wanted to be part of the story. There is nothing bland about this essay. Its structure is unique and appropriate, and allows for the kicker of an ending. It’s very well done.
Havens, Lyndsey, “Spinning Another Year,” Billboard, August 24, 2024. Most of the trick to staying in business is about learning how to survive massive ups and downs. For United Record Pressing—a company that makes vinyl records, the actual product—the secret to their success has been perseverance, and giving up, even when vinyl was at its lowest sales figures (two decades ago). If you want to survive in business, then this is one of those must-read articles.
Herron, Mick, Dophin Junction, Soho Press, 2021. I got sick at the beginning of the month, and I’ve learned that when I’m down, I need to read spectacular wordsmiths who can also tell a story. I’ve read all of Mick Herron’s Slow Horses books, and I’m not that fond of his detective series, so I grabbed this short story collection off my shelf. It does feature stories from his various series, which are good enough, but the standalone stories are the best. I’ve pointed out a few here. Several of the stories contain surprises, but if I point that out in my mini-review of them, that will spoil them. So I’m just going to comment briefly on the ones I like.
I should note that the volume contains one of my very favorite short stories, “The Usual Santas.” I recommend it to writers often so that they can see how a masterful writer handles names and naming. Every character (and there’s a lot of them) is named Santa. Yet you can keep them straight. I usually post about this story in the Holiday Recommended Reading List, which you’ll see the day after Thanksgiving.
Herron, Mick, “Lost Luggage,” Dophin Junction, Soho Press, 2021. “Lost Luggage” focuses on a game that couples often play—looking at a stranger and seeing if they can figure out (without asking) who or what the stranger is. The game is familiar, since Dean and I do it as a writing exercise…and occasionally argue about our opinions. Of course, we never ask. Does anyone?
Herron, Mick, “Remote Control,” Dophin Junction, Soho Press, 2021. Lovely, twisty little story that has the benefit of being beautifully written as well.
Herron, Mick, “What We Do,” Dophin Junction, Soho Press, 2021. Even though above, I mentioned that I don’t like Herron’s regular detective series much, that might be a function of viewpoint. Usually he writes from the point of view of Joe Silvermann who is just incompetent. I don’t find him interesting at all. Zoe, his (sometimes?) wife, on the other hand, is exceedingly competent, as is exemplified in this story. The book ends with it, which is usually the slot for a strong story, and it fits the bill.
Jenkins, Sally, “Bitter Rivals. Beloved Friends. Survivors,” The Year’s Best Sports Writing 2024, edited by Jane McManus, Triumph Books, 2024. I already bought my sister a copy of this book, based on this essay alone. My sister adores tennis, always has, and I knew she would love this essay. It first appeared in The Washington Post in 2023. The essay discusses the relationship between Chris Evert and Martina Navratilova over the decades. They met as teenagers, had a sports rivalry, but came to a deep friendship and understanding. Then they both got cancer a few years back. This essay, about friendships and living long full lives, is worth the price of admission into this volume. Extremely well done.
Land, Barbara, and Land, Myrick, A Short History of Las Vegas, University of Nevada Press, Reno, 1999. Dean had this book in his office and put it in the should we keep this pile for me. We cull our books every now and then, and most of the ones he had in that pile I was happy to let go. I read this one. It’s fascinating. The front part is clearly about the history of the city, and didn’t really date. The latter part was like reading a novel in that I knew what was going to happen to all of the players later on. There was so much rah-rah stuff in the second part, and I knew it would go south for almost everyone mentioned. Still, I found myself quoting some of this stuff at one of our writer meetings. And I also learned why the streets downtown have the names they do. So I liked it. I’ve put up the cover for the second edition. I have no idea if there were many changes, since I read the first edition, and found it fascinating in so many ways.
Lewinsky, Monica, “In Praise of Alternate Endings,” Vanity Fair, July/August 2024. I admire the crap out of Monica Lewinsky. She could have put a metaphorical blanket over her head since the 1990s. Instead, she has taken care of herself, and gotten healthy after the awfulness that was put upon her by so-called friends and the former President of the United States. She writes a lot about how to survive, and wowza, you know she’s survived a lot more than many of us. So I always pay attention to what she writes. This time, she’s talking about never losing hope. It was important in July/August. It’s more important now. Read this.
Marchese, David, “Al Pacino Is Still Going Big,” The New York Times, October 5, 2024. Fascinating interview on a long-time career. I’ve always found Pacino interesting, and that was confirmed in the interview. His attitude toward work, toward being an artist, toward managing money (which really struck me, considering my summer), and on just plain old survival really struck home. It’s worth getting the free subscription at the NYT.
Paiella, Gabriella, “Casual Luke Rides The Big Wave,” The Year’s Best Sports Writing 2024, edited by Jane McManus, Triumph Books, 2024. This essay is about the winner of the original Big Wave competition, in Hawaii. I know a lot about big wave competitions. I used to be able to watch one from my house on the Oregon Coast. When the waves get so large that no one in their right mind would go near them, surfers travel from all over the world to compete and see who can survive them. This particular competition was won by a local, a guy who was working as a lifeguard on the beach at the same time as the competition went on. It’s an amazing story about doing something for the love of it, which I think is at the center of sports.
Rys, Dan, “A Man’s World,” Billboard, August 24, 2024. A creepy and somewhat surreal article about James Brown’s actual estate. Not just the money and the management, but his actual home, frozen in time from the day he was rushed to the emergency room before he died. That part is…strange. But the things the estate must deal with, including Brown’s rather tarnished reputation, is quite fascinating and worth the read.
I’m so thrilled to announce our latest theme anthologies which have arrived just in time for the holiday season. These three anthologies contain stories from last year’s Holiday Spectacular, only these stories are arranged by theme.
So, if you want to read only romance, because you want to have a bit of joy in your life, pick up Winter Sparkles. If you would want some dark crime stories to reinforce the end-of-the-year darkness, buy Hardboiled Holidays. If you like stories about secrets as much as I do, get a copy of Holiday Secrets.
We’ve revamped the designs. The books are as wonderful as the stories. I think you’ll love them!
Of course, you can get the books as part of this year’s Holiday Spectacular Kickstarter. In addition to the reward featuring the books, you’ll get the annual Calendar of Stories (starting on Thanksgiving and running to New Year’s Day). And, because we’ve hit four stretch goals so far, you’ll also get three more stories of mine, a holiday issue of Pulphouse Magazine, and two (yes, two!) online workshops about copyright, worth $500 each.
Yeah, if I were you, I’d head over to the Kickstarter right now. Because it ends on Thursday at 7 p.m. Pacific Time.
Trapped in time on the empty streets of Las Vegas, Christmas Day during the pandemic – a research adventure into the past turns into a nightmare of waiting amongst a empty city full of fear-stricken people.
But a strange poster sticks out among many on a boarded-up window in the Arts District. An invitation that shines a ray of hope on the future. If only the right “Last Thursday” can be located —in time…
“Last Thursday” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Last ThursdayKristine Kathryn RuschPandemic Christmas—his first, his only, everyone’s only, really, because the crisis would be over, at least in the States, by the end of 2021. Rupert stood in front of the closed-up bar; hands jammed in his pockets. No one had told him that the Nevada desert could be cold in the winter, just like no one had told him why he needed to avoid 2020, only that he had to do so.
Like waving a red flag in front of a bull, as they said back in this time. Meaning the obscure warning had been a lure for him, and ultimately, a trap.
Of course, he wouldn’t get sick—his immunity was innate, something sciency, something no one had really explained. The way that vaccination had evolved from shots in the arm to some kind of pill to something that babies got in the womb. Where he came from, everyone was immune to the virus they called COVID-19 and to HIV and to tuberculosis and every other disease the 2020 folks were afraid of.
He hadn’t thought much about his immunity, which meant that even though he had known about COVID-19 for reasons equally obscure to him, he had known he wouldn’t get it, so he had thought that 2020 was worth traveling to.
Boy, was he wrong.
Lonely, surrounded by scared people heading into and out of businesses with masks on, heads down, bodies tense. No one wanted to converse, no one wanted to look at him, and at first everyone thought him weird or some kind of conservative (what kind he didn’t fully understand in the beginning) because he wasn’t wearing a mask.
He eventually masked up. He eventually got used to the reticence. He wasn’t sure he would ever get used to the feeling of being trapped.
And he was trapped. His exit date was January 13, the week after the Capitol breach he had ostensibly wanted to study. That was what his application said, only because that was the one historical event he had known well enough to list.
Everyone knew about January 6. It was a major pivot point, like July 20, 1969, with the moon landing, and August 6, 1945, with the first nuclear bomb.
His theory? There were lots of pivot points, and everyone wanted to study them, so why not jot one down? He’d picked 2021 because it wasn’t that far back. He wouldn’t have to do a lot of life study or figure out how to survive in a world without, say, private bathrooms. Less inconvenience, and more time to explore the past.
Because, really, all he’d wanted to do was to travel in time. He wanted to leave his present and see what the world had been like before he was born. He wanted something new and different, and he had gotten different, and new, too, if truth be told.
But he hated it. He hated all of it, and more than anything, he wanted out.
Which was what made the sign so tantalizing.
He had been walking in the early morning because that was what he had taken to doing. Las Vegas was a surprisingly sleepy city in 2020. Not a lot of nightlife, and what was there had been prescribed. The casinos were mostly empty—those that were open anyway. And tourists were belligerent—those who showed up, that is.
Walking, it seemed, was something people could do without masks, provided no one did more than nod once as they crossed the street to avoid anyone coming at them. Masks seemed primitive to him, but logical. Since vaccines were just starting their roll-out this month, masks were all most people had.
When he did get close to people, he saw a tremendous amount of fear in their eyes. He intellectually understood the fear, even if he did want to tell them all not to worry, since he couldn’t infect anyone.
He didn’t say that, of course. He didn’t say much.
He explored his neighborhood and when that ceased to interest him, he went a few neighborhoods over, to what the locals were calling the Arts District and what his manual had called the Revitalized Downtown.
(So much about his manual was wrong that he had stopped using it. He’d shut off access to it, even though he could reinstate it in the corner of his right eye with a few commands. Whoever had written the thing had done their best to be vague (no spoilers!) while still trying to be accurate. Vagueness had been achieved. Accuracy…hadn’t.)
That morning—Christmas Day—he was walking early on a street he had only just discovered a few days earlier, even though it wasn’t too far from his apartment.
The first day, he had seen the bar, but hadn’t paid a lot of attention. It was recessed into a row of shops in the middle of the block. Called Weston’s Sea Shanty, the bar wasn’t near the sea nor was it owned by anyone named Weston. There were no shanties, which, Rupert learned through a hasty word search, were either some kind of shack that lumberjacks used (no real trees here for lumberjacks to cut) or some kind of song that sailors sang when they were working (no place for sailors to work that was sailor specific, anyway).
The entire bar confused him, just like so many other things. He’d stood in front, next to some tables chained together so that the homeless who had infiltrated this area couldn’t use the chairs for their own purposes, and looked at the barricaded windows next to a clearly locked door.
Plywood covered almost every window in this neighborhood, but this being the Arts District, real artists had covered the plywood with designs—most of them messages of hope or curses against the virus, and all of them interesting.
Except this one. The plywood had been whitewashed and, except for the bar’s name across the top, had been covered with signs. Some of them were useful—the state regulations regarding bars and COVID behaviors, including the fines levied against any business that failed to follow the directive—but some appeared to be someone’s attempt at humor.
Or maybe not.
Rupert was beginning to think he was humor-challenged in 2020 as well.
Because the signs that had vaguely threatening rules for customers, promising that those who did not follow said rules would be tossed out on their asses, didn’t strike him as amusing. Each rule had its own sign, from the order to mask up, another order to remain six feet apart, and a third that mandated no shaking of hands—a custom he had yet to see and clearly did not understand.
The only rules sign that caught his eye, though, was one that made him slightly sad. No hugging, it said. We used to like hugging and maybe we can do it again. But not right now!
In the middle of all those signs there was one more. It was slightly faded and the only one without any color on its surface, just a simple black-and-white note, almost as if it had been printed on a glitchy 2020 printer.
Interested in Time Travel? Meet Here Last Thursday, 7 P.M.
His heart jumped the moment he saw that sign, and once he saw it, he couldn’t stop staring at it. He had walked this way for two days straight and he didn’t remember seeing it before, but that didn’t mean it hadn’t been on the wall.
The sign looked like it had been on the wall for years. But he knew that wasn’t possible because the plywood went up when everything shut down in mid-March of 2020. So the sign hadn’t even been there a full year.
And no matter what they said about the weather in Las Vegas, the weather here was mild. It wouldn’t destroy a sign like that, making it fade and look glitchy. If the sign had been on the wall for months, it would look the same…or, if it had been in full daylight for at least part of the day, it would have turned yellow.
The paper was crisp and white and new-looking. Or maybe that was because he wanted it to be new-looking. He had no idea if it actually was.
And given the other attempts at humor on the plywood, the sign itself was probably a joke.
But what if it wasn’t? What if he could actually meet up with other time travelers and relax, if only for an evening?
Maybe even find an early escape.
Rupert leaned against the chairs, feeling his heart pound. He was so lonely that he was willing to break a few rules.
If he jumped back to his time early, he would be fined and banned from time travel forever. He was also told that he couldn’t jump backward without permission.
He had the ability to do so, though. Every time traveler did. It was only the fines and threats of sanctions and, in a few cases, actual arrest that kept everyone following those regulations.
Besides, last Thursday was just yesterday. It wouldn’t be a big jump at all, not big enough to be noticed, not big enough to matter.
He would travel correctly. He wouldn’t worry about the spatial part of the jump. There was an alley not far from here, an alley that had enough crevices that he could stand in one and activate his handheld time portal. No one would see it.
One day—less, really, because last Thursday at 7 p.m. was only 14 hours ago.
He just needed to go back to the apartment and grab the time portal out of its shielded safe.
He smiled for probably the first time in days. Maybe even weeks.
Time travelers. In a bar. Somehow, that seemed appropriate to him—in a heartwarming way. In a thank God I found my people way. In a maybe a few hours of commiseration will make the next three weeks bearable way.
The walk to the apartment went faster than expected. And by the time he got there, his mood was much better than it had been when he left.
The apartment was something called a short-term rental that the Time Board had found for him. They had paid for it in full, too, which was important, since they hadn’t given him a lot of discretionary 2020 income. He’d had to be frugal which had irritated him almost more than the mask rules.
Located on the first floor of a ten-story building, the apartment was a corner unit without a lot to recommend it. Farther up, the apartments had a view. His was of the bail bonds office across the street and the Justice Center a few blocks down.
The neighborhood had a lot of homeless, a problem he hadn’t even known existed outside of the 1930s. He’d made the mistake of calling them all hobos when he first got here.
Now, he was a little annoyed at them, because they peered into his place if he left the blinds up or they peed on the wall which made the sidewalk smell like fresh urine half the time. He had to step around them and had learned the hard way not to throw money at them, because they usually drank it up. Instead, he’d handed out bags of food until the building superintendent stopped him.
They’ll stay by the building if you do that, the super had said. We don’t want them to. And if you want to stay in the building, you’ll quit now.
This time period was so heartless in so many ways. The casual cruelty took Rupert’s breath away. He couldn’t understand why there was no safety net for people who clearly needed mental health intervention or why no one had started a home for people whose income levels had dipped below the poverty line.
He didn’t ask about it, though, because he had no idea which questions were allowed and which ones weren’t. He had learned to keep his mouth closed so that people didn’t think him weird. He had started listening more, something that was (he was surprised to figure out) relatively new to him.
The apartment had a single bedroom with a very small bed, a tiny closet that barely fit the clothes he’d had to purchase, and a minuscule (and slightly insulting) bathroom with a stand-up shower so narrow he hit his elbows whenever he soaped up.
The living area included what was termed a “galley” kitchen (these sea metaphors bothered him), a dining area, and a couch with a TV plunked against the wall. The TV had taken forever to learn how to operate, but he’d managed. The Time Board had sent him with a “smart” phone which had “internet” technology, a search system so primitive that he felt it was better to ask people rude questions than try to use the blasted thing.
He managed to learn to cook, so he got to know the kitchen and its cabinets, and he found one that had a deeper back than the others. He stored the security safe there. He had to climb on a chair to find it, and then he’d had to switch on the chip in right thumbnail so that he could feel the edges of the safe.
He pulled it out. For a moment, he was terrified he had forgotten the combination, but he hadn’t. He had to twist it right, left, and turn it upside down before sticking his activated thumbnail against the bottom.
The safe opened, and the portal fell out. It was the size of a marble. He barely caught it, and he clung to it like the lifeline it was. It would be so easy to lose. Before he left, he’d actually splurged for the around-the-neck storage unit that looked like a bulky (and badly designed) necklace.
He got that now, put the portal in it, and stuffed it under his shirt.
His heart was pounding hard. He wasn’t supposed to do any of this. He didn’t need the portal for another few weeks. He hoped it didn’t have some kind of monitoring tech he didn’t know about so that the Time Board would know he was messing with it.
But if they knew, they’d stop him immediately—that was one of the benefits of time travel.
So after a few minutes—when nothing happened—he felt better. He managed to use some breathing techniques to slow his heart rate down. He slipped his coat back on, grabbed his 2020 wallet and his stupid, idiotic phone, and left the apartment, barely remembering to lock it.
He wanted to run back to the bar, but he didn’t. He walked with purpose, passing only a handful of people, most of them in cars, all of them looking sad.
When he got to the bar, he was surprised to see it was still closed. The entire neighborhood looked shut down. Even the restaurants where he had gotten take-out in the last few months were shuttered.
Apparently, Christmas was one of those holidays, although no one had told him. Which was the litany of his life at the moment. No one had told him anything.
He made his way to the alley behind the bar. The middle of the alley curved downward as if the ground had cleaved in two and someone had poured concrete over the divide. There was no water in it because there hadn’t been rain in forever (which the locals were complaining about).
The alley stank of rancid beer mixed with urine. He looked around, expecting to see a homeless person or two tucked against the building, but there was no one. Sometimes the authorities did a sweep through the neighborhood rousting the unlucky souls who weren’t supposed to be there.
Maybe that had happened recently—even though the urine stench suggested otherwise.
Rupert was alone, though, as far as he could tell. He had the presence of mind to look up, to see if any windows overlooked the alley and if they did, if someone was standing in them.
No windows, and no one on the flat roof above.
So he slid his weird necklace forward, grabbed the portal and called up the interface, using his left thumbnail. The coordinates for his return were there, but listed as Trip #2. If he deleted the history when he got back from this little adventure, the trip home would be listed as Trip #1. He wondered if that would be a red flag, then decided he didn’t care.
He wanted to see like-minded people. He needed to see like-minded people.
He programmed in Trip #3, which was so much easier than Trips #1 and #2. All he had to do this time was change the date and time, not the location.
Then he hit activate, and felt the weird whirring, with that ever-so-faint (and to him inexplicable) touch of hot air, and suddenly, it was dark.
A single streetlight shone at the end of the alley, and near him was a light above the door that led into the back of the bar. It was also about 20 degrees colder than it had been a few seconds ago and 15 hours from now.
At least, he hoped it was 15 hours. He hoped it all worked right.
He stepped out of the alley to see the street a tad more alive than it had been before he left. Cars drove by with their lights on. The Mexican restaurant across the street had its door open despite the cold.
A man stood on the street corner beside a closed theater, a guitar case open in front of him. He had the guitar strap around his neck, but he wasn’t playing. He was staring at Rupert as if he’d never seen a person before.
Rupert grinned at him, and the man touched the mask across his face. Rupert felt his cheeks heat. That’s why the man was staring at him.
The one thing Rupert had forgotten this time was his goddamn mask.
Fortunately, he carried a spare in his back pocket. He pulled the mask out and put it on, then pivoted and walked toward the bar—
Which looked no different than it had in the morning. The tables were pulled to one side, the chairs chained to them. The door was closed and locked, and the lights were off.
“Really?” he whispered in frustration. “Really?”
Apparently the sign didn’t mean the-night-before Thursday. It meant the Thursday of the previous week.
He hoped.
He decided he wasn’t even going back to his cruddy apartment, and he really didn’t care much about the guitar guy, although he probably should.
That thought alone made Rupert feel a tad guilty. He walked back to the alley and set Trip #4. One week previous. The official “last Thursday.”
And then he activated the portal.
Finally, he arrived somewhere lively—ish. People had spilled out of the bar into the street. They were holding drinks and laughing, but the laughs weren’t real. They were forced, as if everyone was trying to convince themselves that they were having a really good time when they weren’t.
The air was as cold as it had been when he left the…what should he call it? The 2020 present? Because it wasn’t his present. This was all his past.
He wended his way around the people, all of whom had masks, mostly worn around their chins, and started to let himself into the bar. A bouncer stopped him, told him to wait a minute until someone left. They were truly enforcing the state-imposed occupancy limits.
Finally, a woman stumbled out, barely keeping her feet in her heels. She waved at the bouncer, wished him a good night, and staggered off. The bouncer trailed after her, asking her if she wanted an Uber.
And that was when Rupert let himself inside.
The air smelled of beer and fresh chicken wings. It took a moment for his eyes to adjust. There was a bar on his right, with only a handful of bar stools, spaced so far apart that conversation would be impossible. Some people sat there, masks around their chins, drinking alone.
A group had formed in the back, and they looked somber. Rupert checked the clock behind the bar. It was 7:10.
His heart lifted. That had to be his time travel group.
There were only three tables on the main floor, and all three tables were full. No one laughed in here, not like outside, and he found he preferred the semi-silence to the desperate trills of people trying to force themselves into a good time.
Some kind of rock music played overhead, just loud enough, which—in his experience—was rare in a 2020 bar.
He walked past the three tables to that group in the back. Ten people had spaced themselves maybe three feet apart, not the required six. Two were standing close to each other, both men. One was bent over, and Rupert thought maybe that man was sick.
The closer Rupert got, though, the more he realized that the man wasn’t sick. He was sobbing. The man next to him had a hand near his back, as if wanting to touch him in comfort, but was unable to.
On a counter, he saw a large photograph of a woman caught in the middle of a joyous laugh, with lights from this very bar blurred behind her. Candles were lit beside the photo.
Heat filled Rupert’s cheeks again. This wasn’t a time traveler’s meeting. This was some kind of memorial.
He stopped at the edge of the group anyway. A person looked at him—gender impossible to determine—brown hair medium length, a silver ring in their right eyebrow, a tattoo along the right side of their neck. Their mask was a shiny black, and looked expensive.
“This is…?” he asked, keeping his tone respectful.
“Analise’s memorial,” the person said, choking on the word “memorial,” sounding like they expected Rupert had come for that. “How did you know her?”
He could have said he didn’t, but he thought the better of it. Instead, he said, “I got to know her through the bar.”
The person smiled, which he could only tell because their eyes crinkled the way eyes do with a full smile.
“We all met her here. They didn’t have a funeral, because—you know—fuckin’ COVID. She went to that Thanksgiving thing, and then—fuck. She died alone in the hospital, you know? No one should have to die alone.”
Rupert nodded. His heart twisted, just a little. He’d been reading and hearing about the deaths, but he hadn’t known anyone. And technically, he didn’t know this Analise person, but he knew of her now, and it made him sad.
“The toast is going to be in a few minutes,” the person said. “You need to get your drink.”
Rupert walked to the bar and ordered a Heineken, which got him a glare from the bartender. But within seconds, an open bottle slid toward him. He left some money next to a soggy napkin, and walked back to the memorial, checking the rest of the bar as he went.
There were no other groups. Just this one, after 7 P.M. on a Thursday.
The wrong Thursday, apparently.
But that didn’t stop him from sharing a beer with them, listening to stories about Analise and her most spectacular memorable laugh.
Then he thanked everyone for including him and went outside into the cold. He paused for a moment to check the plywood, to see what signs were there.
The time travel sign was in the same place it had been on Christmas morning.
So clearly, he had the wrong “last” Thursday.
He sighed, belched up warm beer, and wandered into the alley, intent on going back.
Once he arrived in his 2020 present, though, only a few seconds had passed. It was still Christmas morning in an empty alley, and he had the entire lonely day ahead of him.
The beer had given him indigestion and a slight headache. Or maybe the time travel had given him the headache.
Or the memorial.
He didn’t want to go back to his hideous little apartment, not after that. And besides, he had just one more “last” Thursday to check out.
He adjusted the dates on his time portal, looked around like he had done before, and saw no one. Then he initiated the travel.
The wind felt a little warmer. The air a little colder. He didn’t remember that Thursday two weeks before being so cold, but he really hadn’t paid attention to the weather much.
He pulled his coat tighter, made sure the portal went back into its little storage necklace, and wandered out of the alley.
Some of the same people were sitting outside the bar, talking loudly. A few were laughing desperately. The same bouncer was near the door, but he didn’t recognize Rupert—of course, since the bouncer hadn’t met Rupert yet.
This time, the bouncer didn’t try to hold him outside. Rupert went in, checked the clock behind the bar, saw that it was 7:03.
But no one else was at the back where the memorial had been. Tables were piled high and chairs were leaning against the counter.
At the bar, two people sat next to each other. One of them was a man from the memorial service. He had his phone to his ear and he gasped.
“Jesus,” he said to the person next to him. “Analise just died.”
“No,” the person said. “Not possible.”
Rupert moved away, wandering around to see if there was some room he had missed.
But there wasn’t.
He wandered around the bar until 7:30, too restless to sit. He bought another beer, but didn’t drink it.
He left it on the bar as he went back outside, and peered at the plywood.
The sign was still there.
He sighed and walked to the alley, feeling discouraged but not discouraged enough to quit.
The previous Thursday was warmer but windier. The indigestion from that very first beer made his entire chest ache.
He hit his rib cage with a fist, belched, and stepped out of the alley. The wind was even stronger here, messing his hair.
This time, he didn’t even go in the bar, not right away. He looked at the plywood, and sure enough, there was the sign.
He wanted to curse at it, but that just seemed silly, even though it seemed to be taunting him.
The bouncer wasn’t there. No one sat outside either, not in this wind. He almost went back to the alley, but he couldn’t quite do that. Instead, he went inside.
Of course, there was no group. Only one person—a woman he had never seen before—inside, flirting with the bartender, who was having none of it.
Rupert smiled at them, waved just a little, and went back out to the alley, wondering how many Thursdays he would have to experience before he found the people he was searching for.
The next Thursday—the previous Thursday, really—was Thanksgiving. He’d suffered through that day once already, alone in his apartment, eating a make-your-own turkey platter from one of the grocery stores.
That experience had been more palatable than this one. A woman sat outside the bar, nursing some kind of amber drink. She looked sad.
She wasn’t sitting very far from the damned sign.
“Hey,” Rupert said to her.
She looked up.
“You ever notice that sign before?” he asked, pointing at the time travel sign.
She glanced at it, rolled her eyes, and shook her head.
“What passes for humor in this town,” she said and took a sip of her drink, dismissing him.
He took that as a no.
He went inside—no bouncer again—saw one full table with people who were obviously related to each other.
This time, he went to the bar. “Who put that sign up about time travel?” he asked the bartender.
The bartender looked at him like he was crazy. “What sign?”
“On the plywood,” he said. “There’s a sign about a time travel meeting…?”
“Christ, I don’t know,” the bartender said. “The owner prints fun crap he gets off the internet, and I stopped keeping track months ago.”
Then he frowned at Rupert.
“You want something?”
Rupert looked at the clock. 7:20.
“Naw,” he said. “I was just wondering about the sign.”
“I’m sure it’s just a dumb joke,” the bartender said. “I can ask him where he found it.”
“It’s okay,” Rupert said. “Thanks.”
And he let himself out.
The woman was gone. There was no one on the street. It was as desolate as it would be on Christmas morning.
Rupert decided at that moment that he hated it here, here being Las Vegas, the most overhyped city in the history of the United States. The vaunted nightlife was non-existent. He would have thought it would continue to exist during the pandemic, and it kinda did, but it wasn’t really any kind of “life.” More like a pretense, which made him more uncomfortable than the emptiness.
It also made him want to go back to his own time period sooner rather than later.
He’d keep collecting Thursdays until he found the right one. There had to be a day before the sign went up.
He just had to keep going back until he found it.
Five Thursdays, with the weather varying. Drippy rain one evening. A lot of tension right after the election but before the result. People huddled kinda together, staring at the overhead TVs, worrying.
By the last Thursday in October, the weather was almost warm, and he remembered how much he had enjoyed that not-too-hot desert air. There hadn’t been much to enjoy in this city, not in 2020, and it had seemed worse rather than better.
The indigestion had faded by then, and he was thirsty. He promised himself a bottle of water, and some wings because he was starting to get hungry.
He crawled onto a bar stool (no bouncer—when was that dude hired?) and ordered. The bartender didn’t like the bottle of water even though he delivered it, but seemed cool with the wings.
Some sporting event was playing on one overhead TV. On another, commentators were talking earnestly, probably about the upcoming election. Rupert wanted to tell them to settle down—they would get through it. The days would pass, the result would become known, the world would eventually move on.
But he didn’t get to say that, not any of it. He had to keep his mouth shut.
A peeling laugh—one of the prettiest things he’d ever heard—came from the front door. He turned in time to see a statuesque woman, long red hair curled around her face, laughing as she entered.
The first person, in all his travels on this strange day to actually possess a real laugh.
He could only see her eyes, but that, the red hair, and the laugh might’ve been enough to identify her, although he didn’t need to because the bartender called, “The usual, Analise?”
“Two,” she said, holding up two fingers for emphasis as she headed toward the back.
Rupert glanced at the clock. 7:45. Not part of the time travel group, then. If the stupid group even existed, which he doubted.
His wings arrived. They were a weird orange color, but they smelled good. He took a tentative bite, found them to be spicier than he had expected, but that didn’t bother him. He practically inhaled them, which meant he had been a lot hungrier than he thought.
Throughout it all, Analise talked and laughed, and actually spread some joy in that sad bar. He could hear her, telling stories, asking for another drink.
Her laugh was infectious and full-throated. People crowded as close to her as they dared in these socially distant times.
“Ah,” she said to a friend as Rupert was finishing his wings, “just live a little.”
“It’s not possible to live a little right now,” the friend said.
“Oh, yes, it is,” Analise said. “Your attitude is a choice. Yeah, it’s sad right now, but we don’t have to be sad every single moment of every single day.”
Rupert couldn’t hear the friend’s response. Instead, he pushed his basket of wings away.
Rupert felt as if Analise had been talking to him. He hadn’t really thought about his attitude.
It was a privilege to time travel. The Time Board, they tested everyone, and only let a rare few go back to work on whatever they chose to work on. Most everyone else got disqualified or told they weren’t time-travel material right from the start.
He hadn’t been told that, and despite his tendency to skate through requirements, he hadn’t been disqualified either.
He was lucky, even if 2020 was challenging. Especially since 2020 was challenging.
He let out a sigh, put some money on the bar, hoping it was enough for a tip. That was a custom he hadn’t figured out entirely yet either. Why didn’t they pay their staff enough? Why was it his duty to add to the salary?
Of course, he hadn’t asked anyone that question, because he didn’t know if it was a question the natives asked or if it would mark him as a true outsider.
He slid off the bar stool. He had a decision to make. He had forgotten to check the sign in his haste to get something to drink. He needed to check to see if the sign was there—or not. Maybe he should abandon this silly quest for other travelers and return to that bleak Christmas, where he could continue to serve out his privileged term.
Analise laughed again, and it made him smile. Such a joyous sound, a sound that had been missing almost his entire time here.
And by his 2020 present, that sound would be silenced.
He clung to the cool leather of the bar stool with his left hand. He had to do something—even though he hadn’t researched it.
That’s what the Time Board pounded into the travelers. Research, research, research. Some lives meant absolutely nothing in the scheme of things. A traveler could mess with them all he wanted and nothing in the future would change.
Other lives—hell, other moments—well, they were drivers of major change.
But, as one of his mentors told him, only around major events. A guy bending over to pick up a dime on the sidewalk might survive a mass shooting because he’d moved out of harm’s way, changing the trajectory of hundreds of lives.
A guy bending over to pick up a dime on the sidewalk on an average day with nothing strange occurring would be a dime richer.
The student travelers had laughed, but that had stuck in Rupert’s head.
And it was stuck there now.
This was a Thursday in a series of Thursdays, in a bar that didn’t seem known for anything except good company and reasonably good wings.
He hadn’t researched, but he didn’t need to.
This was 2020. The major events happened in other cities, not Las Vegas. Here, people tried to go on with their lives, and other people—like Analise—made it easier.
Decision made, Rupert stepped away from the stool and walked over to her. She looked up as he did, and that was when he realized he hadn’t tugged up his mask.
He pulled it off his chin and up, over his mouth and nose. Then he bowed just a bit formally because he couldn’t smile.
“Forgive me for intruding,” he said, “but do you have plans for Thanksgiving?”
The light left her eyes. She frowned at him, as if he was some kind of stalker, which he probably sounded like.
“What do you care?” she asked, an edge in her voice.
You’re the most upbeat person I’ve discovered in 2020. You’re full of light and laughter and affection, and I hate to see that snuffed out needlessly.
“It’ll kill you,” he said. “Going to that Thanksgiving thing. You’ll catch COVID, and you’ll get so sick that you’ll have to go to the hospital, and then you’ll die, alone just before Christmas.”
She laughed, but this time the laugh was brutal. “Good lord, aren’t you the world’s most cheery soul? Are you telling everyone you see to stay away from Thanksgiving celebrations or am I the lucky one?”
“Trust me,” he said, feeling panic. She didn’t believe him. Why didn’t she believed him? “If you go that Thanksgiving gathering—”
“I’ll get COVID and die. I got that. I’ll be careful. I always am.”
But she hadn’t been, not here, and not this evening. Her mask had been around her chin too.
He didn’t know how to say any more, because he knew how it sounded. It sounded like all those warnings on TV. He didn’t know how to make it specific to her, because he’d never heard where she went or how she contracted it or how, even, the person at the memorial had known.
Analise raised her eyebrows at him. She extended her right hand, palm down, and waggled her fingers.
“Begone, weird paranoid little man. Take your death fantasies elsewhere.”
His stomach turned with a sense of desperation he hadn’t felt since he got to this time.
“Please,” he said. “Please, just—”
A hand grabbed his arm, and yanked him back. He looked up, expecting to see the bouncer.
Instead, his advisor’s face was inches from his. The man’s green eyes glittered with fury.
“What do you think you’re doing?” he half-whispered.
“I figured—”
“You figured wrong.”
His advisor almost dragged him out of the bar. They got outside into the growing darkness. A few people pushed past them to get into the bar, but the street was mostly empty.
“How’d you get here?” his advisor asked.
Rupert touched his necklace, and his advisor’s eyes narrowed. The man looked different with one of those blue masks across his mouth and nose. Older, because of the wrinkles around the eyes.
“Location, idiot,” his advisor said, not even trying to hide his contempt.
“Alley,” Rupert said, nodding in the correct direction.
His advisor pulled him that way, but not before Rupert could check the plywood.
There was no sign. No sign at all.
Rupert ended up in time travel hell. Really, it was just a small room at the Time Board, toward the back, where he waited for nearly two hours before someone came to talk to him.
And then, they didn’t debrief him. Instead, they took his portal and his identification and told him he wasn’t welcome at the Time Board ever again.
“You know what you did, right?” the assistant who took his identification asked him.
She was thin with dark hair and even darker eyes. Her narrow chin put him in mind of Analise.
“Yeah,” Rupert said. “I shouldn’t have told her. How badly did I screw up the timeline?”
The assistant snorted. “You didn’t. That’s why we send everyone to 2020 for their final test.”
He felt cold. “No one told me it was a test.”
“That’s right,” the assistant said, “or you would’ve been on your best behavior. We wanted to see you in the field.”
“Why?” he asked. “Surely, after the warnings, most people don’t—”
“Most people do,” she said. “You go to a place, meet people, and they’re not names or statistics anymore. They’re friends, acquaintances, lovers—”
“Laughers,” he said quietly.
She frowned at him, then shook her head, maybe assuming she hadn’t heard him correctly.
“Everyone wants to help. Half forget the training.” She shrugged. “That’s how you flunk out. No redemption. But no other punishments.”
“For changing the timeline?” he asked.
“You didn’t change the timeline,” she said. “You can’t change the timeline in 2020 by warning someone that the virus will kill them. They know that. They think you’re just one of those people, the kind that takes it on themselves to tell strangers how to live their lives.”
Which he had. So he apparently was one of those people.
“There were a lot of 2020 natives doing exactly what you did. That was why she didn’t think you were anything but weird. By the time she got home, she probably forgot about you.”
Rupert sighed. He hadn’t thought about that. But that had been the problem, hadn’t it? He hadn’t thought at all.
And now he knew. The next time, he would do better.
“No redemption?” he asked, hoping he hadn’t heard that right.
“You forfeited your right to travel in time,” she said. “You can’t be trusted. What if you tell JFK not to go to Dallas?”
“Who?” Rupert asked.
She glared at him. “I have no idea how you qualified anyway,” she said and shoved him out the door.
The sun was bright and golden, the air so much fresher than it had been in 2020. The campus was green and lush, the buildings a bit too sharp-edged and metallic for his tastes.
Students walked to class, laughing and talking as if they hadn’t a care in the world.
Just like they would have done in 2019.
He felt a surge of disappointment so great that it shocked him. He finally realized why he had joined up.
He didn’t want to move forward in time. He wanted time to be predictable. Time travel—he had thought—would have given him a measure of security, of comfort, of knowing what was going to come next.
But even in his 2020 present, he had been moving forward, not backward. And the framework he had thought he understood hadn’t been one he had understood at all.
He walked away from the building and found a bench near a flowering plum tree. It must have been spring. He didn’t even ask what date they had brought him back to.
He had no real idea when he was. He supposed he could ask. Questions like that weren’t unusual on a Time Board sponsored campus.
But he didn’t want to ask right now. He didn’t even want to know what day of the week it was.
He hoped it wasn’t Thursday.
He had enough of Thursday to last a lifetime.
Because he’d lived through what was, for him, a lifetime of Thursdays. And had learned a lesson he couldn’t apply to a job he could no longer do.
Yeah, he was changed. But in ways he hadn’t figured out yet, ways he wasn’t sure he wanted to figure out.
He just wanted to sit on that bench and let the world flow around him for a few minutes.
Or maybe forever.
He wasn’t sure which.
____________________________________________
“Last Thursday” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Last ThursdayCopyright © 2024 by Kristine Kathryn RuschPublished by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2024 by WMG PublishingCover design by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Canva
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
Tuesday’s election results in the United States have left a lot of people feeling shocked, dismayed, upset, and angry. Others are pretty happy with that result. And even more people have moved on, thinking, Well, that’s over.
It’s not over, really. Whenever a new administration comes in the White House, changes occur. I suspect that the changes under Donald Trump this time will be even more significant.
However, this is not a political blog. There are thousands of bloggers and podcasters and commentators who are going to analyze and rehash and predict and try to figure out what happened in the past week.
If you want that, toddle on over to your favorite pundit and listen in.
This post is about the future.
Let’s establish something about the present first.
This outcome was one of four that could have occurred. The four outcomes (in November anyway) were:
I even read an article the day before the election listing all of those outcomes and talking about which one was likely. (The writer ended up being wrong on their predictions.)
The polls and trend lines have shown the strong possibility of a Trump victory for almost a year now. The reason that President Biden stepped down wasn’t altruistic. It was because the polling was so bad for him that he either got out of the race or lost big in November. (If you think Harris’s loss was big, Biden’s would have been much bigger. She at least made it into a race.)
People have known and discussed the possibility of a Trump victory for a long time now. It was an emotional shock to the system—maybe for everyone (in good and bad ways)—but it wasn’t a surprise.
And now, here we are, facing a future that is uncertain. We don’t know exactly what Trump’s policies will be, nor do we know how they will be implemented. We don’t know if they will have an uneven impact across the country or if the impact will be the same everywhere.
This has been a U.S. election on steroids. The difference between this one and the last two is pretty simple, though.
Trump won outright. It’s hard to argue with a victory like that.
So the post-election period will not include litigation and rioting in the streets. That’s a good thing.
It means that the next few months will be less chaotic than most thought they would be.
Less chaos leaves room for a lot of planning on the part of smart businesses and government officials.
We writers need to plan as well.
But that begs the question. How do you plan when you have no idea what will happen next?
Well…I hate to say this, but that’s called living, folks. We never know what’s going to happen next. Usually that feeling of not-knowing is just background noise. Every now and then, though, it’s front and center, like it is right now.
I wrote versions of this post in the past. I’m going to reiterate what I said in those.
Here’s how you live and run a business in uncertain times.
Most of these points are self-explanatory. Let me explain a couple, though.
The first one is quite important: figuring out what the possible futures will be. That pre-election article I mentioned above had done that. The analyst looked at what he saw as the various outcomes of the election, outlined them, and considered them.
Once you know the possible outcomes, you plan for each one of them. Yes, some will favor your business. Others will not. It’s up to you to figure out what will happen in each of those scenarios.
Let me remind you that hope is an emotion and not a plan. You might hope things are going to go a particular way, but if they don’t, you need to be prepared.
Right now, we have three months to plan. Three months to implement whatever your business needs. You plan for the worst. You also plan for the best. I’ve written a lot of blogs about the fact that success can hurt a business too. (Too much cash outlay too quickly, for example, or hiring too many people to keep up with demand.)
By the end of those three months, the few months after that might have come into focus. You plan for that focus. You also plan for uncertainty.
There is going to be a lot of uncertainty for the next six months or so. Brace yourselves for that.
I don’t use the word “plan” lightly. You need to consider what’s ahead, and your plans need to be concrete.
If you have posited four scenarios, then you need four concrete plans for those scenarios. If you can, you go with step one and step two and step three.
You will end up modifying those plans a lot as the future shakes out and we get more than an inkling of what’s ahead. You won’t be able to do some things you can do now. You might have other opportunities that you didn’t expect.
That’s how uncertainty plays out.
You need to make the same kind of plans for your family and yourself. Good outcomes, bad outcomes—they’re all in play at the moment. Do the hard work of planning ahead, and you’ll thank yourselves later. You might be surprised by a sudden change in your business, but you’ll be prepared.
What do I mean by “surprised” in that context? I mean that maybe the outcome you had strategized as the least likely is the one that happened. But you had planned for it, so you’re ready.
That’s how all of this works.
I hate to tell you this also, but there is good news for writers in uncertainty and difficult times.
People consume more entertainment. They watch more movies, fight over sports instead of politics, and they take up hobbies as ways to keep themselves distracted.
But most of all, they read. Book sales always go up in uncertain times. Books are cheap entertainment, comparatively speaking. A person can get four or more books for the price of a movie ticket.
People also use libraries more. Once they feel their finances have settled, they will return to buying books by their favorite authors. So even if someone “just” get your books from the library, eventually, they will pick up an actual copy on their own. Or they’ll tell others about it and those people will help you make a sale.
Writing helps you escape as well. Indulge yourself. Write something you don’t think will sell.
The world is changing, and you never know what might hit with people. You certainly can’t base it on what was.
That’s the other thing. As I said above, the world will go on. It always does. Sometimes there’s fundamental change, and sometimes it seems pretty stable.
We’re in a period of change.
And that’s pretty much the only thing we know for certain.
Note: I will be doing quite a few posts in the next few months, as I deal with all kinds of changes. Most of those posts will go on Patreon. If you’re interested, you can find my Patreon page by clicking here.
Also, Dean and I have revived what used to be called the Kris & Dean show, to help writers plan for 2025. We did a video. Take a look before Tuesday, which is when this program starts. Here’s the link.
“Facing The Future in Uncertain Times ,” copyright © 2024 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © 2024 by Kristine K. Rusch
No-nonsense private eye Belinda Sweet, the only person in Los Angeles who wants no part in fame, avoids cases that bring her attention. Until she stumbles on one in a bar, when a barfly asks her to act as his alibi for killing his wife.
When the cops arrest him but then let him go, Sweet needs to know why. She’s lived in LA long enough to recognize an actor when she sees one. And she refuses to stop until she uncovers the real story—even if fame inevitably follows.
“Mr. Alibi” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Mr. AlibiKristine Kathryn Rusch“Will you be my alibi?” asked the man at the end of the bar.
He wasn’t an attractive man and this wasn’t the kind of seedy bar where you’d expect to find someone trolling for an alibi. In the eighties, we would’ve called this a fern bar, by which we meant a yuppie bar, something all woodsy brown and forest green with fake Tiffany lamps over each booth and actual windows which let in actual sunlight.
The guy was exactly the kind of guy you expected to find in a fern bar, a no-neck former high school jock with too much fat around the middle and a face that had settled in on itself. He looked like the guy central casting would’ve have put into the fern bar as wallpaper, and honestly, until he spoke to me, the wallpaper thing worked. I had seen him, but only as the stock character at the end of the bar.
He moved a seat closer to me, leaned across the bar—which was polished so heavily that its surface could act as a mirror—and said, “Miss?” in that tone which meant excuse me, but I asked you a question and I really really really need an answer.
Still, I glanced over my shoulder to see which miss he was referring to. I’m not the kind of woman people would call miss, not even when I was young. Back then, I had one of those faces that I had to “grow into,” and then, everyone promised me, I’d be considered “handsome.”
Like a girl wants to be told that she’s going to be “handsome,” which is a boy word and code for Jesus, she’s ugly now, but maybe she’ll gain a little character as time goes on.
Time went on, and I gained character, but not enough to keep my face from resembling decades-old shoe leather. Don’t suppose I helped it any by living in Southern California and going without sunscreen for my entire life.
“Yes, miss, I meant you,” the guy said, interrupting my train of thought. He smiled to take the edge off his words, because the edge had taken him from excuse me, but I asked a question to Hey, stupid, I’m talkin’ to you.
“What do you want?” I asked, and instantly regretted it. I had a rule: don’t engage in bars. Generally, the rule only applied near last call, when the guys got so drunk, they’d sleep with anything that walked.
The anything-that-walked category included me. It was damn near the only sexual category that included me. I was the woman all your hard-drinking friends referred to as the road kill they had to chew their arm off to escape from on the morning after.
“I was wondering if you would be my alibi,” the guy said. He probably thought it was a cute pick-up line, and he probably thought he’d try it on the ugly broad first. That way, if she poured her drink all over him, then he wouldn’t be out anything and he was free to try another lame-ass question with a slightly prettier woman.
“What the hell do you need an alibi for?” I asked, expecting him to answer Tonight, with a bit of a twinkle in those too-sharp brown eyes.
Instead, he said, “Yesterday afternoon,” and moved one seat closer.
Yesterday afternoon I was on a dirty side street in a dilapidated neighborhood, trying to take down a tweaker who’d accidentally kidnapped the wrong little girl. That little girl was in my car, crouched against the floor mats, covered in a blanket despite the heat.
I told her she could sit on the seat and wait for me, but she was too scared to sit, and frankly I didn’t blame her. I was a little scared myself.
The tweaker was one of those scrawny pus-faced bastards with rotating pinwheels for eyes. His brain had become as mushy as five-week-old bananas, and his hands shook as he trained a gun on me.
The gun looked rusted. It looked old. But there was no way I was going to let him pull the trigger. I had no idea if the damn thing was loaded. I also had no idea if the damn thing would explode if he rattled it too much.
He was shouting at me to back off, bitch, back off and I was backing. I wanted to get the kid the hell out of there, but I also didn’t want to attract this dude’s zombie tweaker buddies.
They had all cocked up this scheme together, the scheme to kidnap the mayor’s daughter, after they had sold all the scrap metal they could find including (but not limited to) the manhole covers from nearby streets, statues from one of the nearby parks, and copper wire from every air-conditioning unit in the county.
Only they hadn’t kidnapped the mayor’s daughter, they kidnapped the mayor’s daughter’s best friend, a little girl with the unlikely name of Karma Maggerty. Once I got her home to the idiots who named her, I was going to tell them to start calling her Kammie before I used my own gun on someone’s kneecap.
But that was all in my future—if I had one.
And you always had to doubt that you had a future when a pie-eyed tweaker shook a gun at you from less than fifty feet.
“I’m just going to leave,” I said, backing up. I had already called 911, begging them to come and arrest these assholes. Of course, the minute I gave the address, the 911 dispatch hung up on me.
She didn’t really hang up, of course. She just went to another line—“oops,” she said in that fake-competent voice they require from 911 operators, “looks like we have another emergency.”
They were going to have another emergency when I got through with them. If I got out of here. If the mayor’s daughter’s best friend survived.
I had to hang up and call again, becoming that other emergency myself, and this time, I told them that I knew where Karma Maggerty was, and they better get their asses over here before she got killed.
This time, the dispatch stayed on the line with me. She was nattering at me from my back pocket, where I had stashed the phone after the tweaker demanded that I put the damn thing down.
I wasn’t about to get rid of my only lifeline so I pretended to set it down as I tucked it into my back pocket. The tweaker pretended to be satisfied, or maybe he didn’t notice.
If he were by himself, I would trust that he didn’t notice a thing, but from inside the house, three other pus-faced tweakers with pinwheels for eyes watched me like I was Triple-X pay-per-view. I didn’t know if any of them had shotguns or semi-automatic weapons or even a simple old-fashioned pistol of the rusted variety now facing me.
“You can’t leave!” the original pus-faced tweaker shouted at me.
“And why not?” I asked in my most reasonable voice (prompting all kinds of alarmed noises from the phone in my pocket).
“Why not?” the pus-faced tweaker asked. “Why not?”
Any reasonable person would then have added the very adult line, because I said you couldn’t, that’s why. But he didn’t. He actually tried to think about it, with that banana-mush brain of his.
As I knew he would.
I backed away, one step at a time.
“I said you can’t leave!” he screamed at me.
I stopped backing.
“Why not?” I asked. Note I did not tell him I’d already asked that question. I’d dealt with enough tweakers to know that their memory was as porous as their skin.
“Why not?” he asked. “Why not?”
Only this time, he turned toward the house, as if he were going to consult with the other pus-faced tweakers, and I chose that moment to get the hell out of there.
I sprinted to the car, pulled open the driver’s door, said, “You there?” to the poorly named kid in the backseat, and as she managed a shaky, “Yes,” I turned the keys in the ignition, thanked Almighty God that the engine roared to life, and floored the damn accelerator, pulling out like Starsky and Hutch in the only stupid scene anyone ever aired of that television show any more.
The car’s tires squealed as we zoomed down the block, and behind me, I heard an explosion. Either the rusted gun had gone off, or the barrel had blown out, or the united brainpower from the pus-faced tweakers ignited their at-home meth lab.
I wasn’t going to turn around to find out.
Besides, I had to swerve some more to avoid the phalanx of cop cars streaming onto the street.
I went up on the grass of a nearby house, the cop cars all stopped around me, and their occupants got out, keeping the doors open and aiming their goddamn not-rusted guns at me.
I had to get out, hands over my head, saying, “I’m the one who called! I’m the one who called!”
It took a while to convince them, but convince them I did. I never did find out what happened to the tweakers—I had to go to the nearest precinct, give my statement, endure the heart-felt gratitude of my clients a.k.a. Karma’s idiot parents (whom I forgot to advise on changing their child’s name)—and then I went back to my lovely apartment in beautiful downtown Burbank, and passed out from exhaustion.
Just a day in the life of Belinda Sweet, down-on-her-luck private eye (whose parents were not at fault for her name, Belinda being a perfectly acceptable moniker in the early 1960s, and Sweet being the name of the idiot she had the misfortune to marry and the good sense to divorce).
A day in the life—and, oh yeah, also yesterday afternoon.
“Yesterday afternoon,” I said to the guy at the bar, “I was entertaining ten cops, four tweakers, and a little girl. So sorry, I can’t alibi you.”
“Damn,” he said, and moved back to his original seat at the end of the bar.
He didn’t seem fazed by my oh-so-eloquent rejection, but the bartender raised his eyebrows at me. Dunno if that was a reaction to my description of my yesterday or if it was just a silent query about the state of my beverage, which was, by the way, one appletini. Not because I happen to like appletinis—I don’t. I don’t like any kind of tini except a martini, and even that’s stretching things a bit—but because the appletini with the three green apple slices decorating the slightly apple green martini glass was my signal to the potential client who suggested this place that yes indeed, the ugly broad at the bar was the person he was supposed to meet.
I’d been here exactly one hour, had exactly one sip to see if the damn drink was as disgusting as it sounded (nope, more disgusting), and no client had shown up. Unless the client was Mr. Alibi.
I wasn’t about to ask him, though. If he wanted my services for yesterday afternoon, he should have hired me yesterday morning.
As if he knew I was thinking about him, he looked over at me. “Do you know anyone who can give me an alibi for yesterday afternoon?”
He was sounding desperate.
“No.” I said.
And then, because I couldn’t resist, I asked, “What do you need an alibi for, anyway?”
“Oh,” he said, with a shrug of his left shoulder. “Nothing really. Except that I kinda sorta killed my wife.”
This was what they called in the trade a confession. I kinda sorta shoulda called the cops right then and there, but I was in a bar, and I had an appletini, and the guy didn’t look exactly sober, and he was asking me for an alibi, and he probably still wasn’t all that serious.
Or maybe he was. The bartender thought he was. The bartender said, “How do you kinda sorta kill your wife?”
“With a shotgun,” the man said, and this time it wasn’t me who called 911, it was the bartender, who wasn’t even really discreet about it.
The cops showed up and hauled the guy away, even though we had no real proof he shot his wife or that the woman was even dead. All we did have proof of—or at least all I had proof of—was that this bar was in a better neighborhood than the tweaker house because the police response time to a hint of an emergency in this part of town was twenty times shorter than their response time to an actual emergency in the tweaker neighborhood.
Me, I waited another half an hour for my client, who never showed, stiffing me for my time and the stupid appletini. And as I sat there, watching the apple slices dissolve into whitish goo, I had the horrible, awful feeling that Mr. Alibi really had been my client, and I had handled the encounter poorly. Maybe the poor bastard hadn’t shot his wife. Or maybe he hadn’t killed her. Or maybe he blamed himself for leaving her alone that afternoon when the boogeyman broke into their upscale apartment and shot her while she was waiting in her negligee for Mr. Alibi.
Yeah. And I was going to win the Miss California pageant next year.
Still, I couldn’t get him off my mind, which was why I was Belinda Sweet, down-on-her-luck private eye, instead of Belinda Sweet, rich-and-famous private eye.
I got obsessed with the strangest, most non-lucrative things. Like Mr. Alibi and his mysteriously shotgunned, possibly dead wife.
First, I tried to fight the obsession. I’d had these things before, and they’re not just bad for me, they’re bad for business, especially after all the great press coverage I was getting from the Karma Maggerty case.
If I really wanted to, I could’ve stayed in my office for the next week and answered the phone. Fifteen reporters called to each possible client, but that meant there were possible clients, which didn’t always happen to me.
Of course, the fifteen reporters weren’t real reporters. They were either tabloid reporters or some junior hack from the local affiliates. A few were from those goofy celeb shows like Extra and Entertainment Tonight, which had to have been hurting for real celebrity news. But this story did have, as one “reporter” explained to me, a connection to the mayor of the nation’s most important city, a kidnapped child, and gravelly voiced PI right out of central casting.
Nancy Grace, he’d informed me, had gotten famous on a lot less than that.
In a valiant attempt to shake off the obsession, I called back every single potential client, realized that a large percentage of them were loons with decades-old cases that other people had tried to solve, and half of the remaining group had the deadly dull I-think-my-spouse-is-cheating-on-me cases that made my work so darn fun.
I sent most of those cases to my better-equipped colleagues (one of whom is a multimillionaire because [hello!] this is Los Angeles and everyone is cheating on everyone else) and kept the three new insurance companies who wanted another fraud investigator as well as one of the Missing Child organizations that wanted me on permanent retainer.
The company clients all wanted an actual meeting along with a rates card, which I did draw up. The meetings were all scheduled for the following week, which left this week with nothing for me to do except preen in front of every single camera in Hollywood—which I certainly would not do.
So I obsessed. And when I couldn’t take it any more, I trudged back to the fern bar.
Well, actually, I drove. It only felt like trudging because driving in LA traffic always feels like trudging.
The same bartender was on duty. At least, I hoped it was the same bartender. He too looked like a guy out of central casting, and the uniform didn’t help. It wasn’t a uniform, per se, just a white shirt with the bar’s name in green over his right breast, but he wore the shirt with the pair of black pants that the owner of the fern bar had clearly mandated.
“You remember me?” I asked the bartender.
“Appletini, right?”
I grimaced. “Not normally.”
“Duh,” he said and grinned. “Whiskey, right?”
“Not today,” I said, a little startled he’d guessed accurately. “Gimme whatever you got that’s on tap.”
He poured me a nice piss-colored name-brand American beer which both of us knew I wasn’t going to drink as I climbed into my place at the bar.
It worried me that I had a place at the bar. At this bar, anyway. In my neighborhood bar, which was properly dim and scarred up, with no windows at all and certainly no plants, I had a regular seat and a standing order, not to mention a running tab.
But not at this bar. With luck, I wouldn’t come into this bar again.
“That alibi guy we called the cops on yesterday,” I said, “you ever see him before?”
“No,” the bartender said.
“Did he, by chance, pay for his drinks before the cops came?”
“Handed me a credit card when he ordered the first drink,” the bartender said. “I closed out his tab as the cop car was pulling away.”
The bartender grinned at me. I looked at the bar’s name on his shirt and realized he didn’t have the standard fern bar metal name badge. Maybe this place had a bit more (less?) class than I expected.
“Ted,” the bartender said.
“Hmm?” I asked.
“You were looking for my name. It’s Ted.”
I grinned. “Belinda.”
He held out one of those sun-wrinkled hands. I took it. It was cold-damp, like he’d just had it in a bucket of ice, which was entirely possible.
“So why are you asking about the tab for a guy who wanted to use you as an alibi, and why were you drinking an appletini yesterday when you so clearly find them disgusting?”
I was thinking that he would be a better private investigator than I was. Which made me flush just a bit.
I took a deep breath and said, “I work as—”
“A private investigator, I know.” He inclined his head toward one of the three televisions angled over the bar. “Your face has been all over the news.”
My flush grew deeper. I wasn’t used to being recognized, and I didn’t much like it. Which decided me then and there. No interviews, not for the Karma case, not for any case. Once some other big thing happened in LA—and it would only be a matter of days (or hours)—my mug would be off the big screen, and people would eventually forget.
“Yesterday, I was waiting for a client who never showed,” I said. “Then I got to thinking that maybe Mr. Alibi was my client, only he didn’t approach me in quite the right way.”
“You want to work for a guy who killed his wife?”
“No,” I said. Which wasn’t exactly true. I didn’t want to work for him, but I did want to find out about him. “I mean, I’m not going to give him an alibi, but I do want to know what he really needed.”
“Someone to take the shotgun away before he turned it on his wife,” the bartender said.
“What he needed yesterday,” I clarified.
“I think we gave him what he needed,” the bartender said, picking up a bar rag and wiping the already highly polished bar with it.
“I do too,” I said, “but still…”
“You’re feeling guilty?”
“No.”
“Angry?”
“No.”
“Then what’s the problem?” he asked.
“I just want to know what the hell he really did.”
There. I’d said it. I wanted to know how nutty Mr. Alibi really was and if he’d shot his wife in a jealous rage or if he’d just cold-bloodedly hauled out the 12-gauge and pointed it after she served him a tough steak.
Because even if he had shot her at point-blank range, it wouldn’t have made the news. Or it wouldn’t have on the kind of news day that yesterday was (and the day before), with Karma’s dramatic interview (that lady, she saved me) and the mayor promising to rid the city of tweakers so no family would ever have to suffer like that again and the dramatic audio of my second 911 call. (Gee, y’think they lost the first one?)
“You want to know what he really did?” the bartender asked, as if I were nuts. “You’re one of those chicks who gets off on blood and brains all over the wall?”
“Nooo,” I said, losing a bit of patience. “I’m one of those ‘chicks’ who sometimes discovers a question that needs an answer before she moves on to something else.”
The corners of his mouth twitched. He was holding back a smile.
Damn if Ted the bartender hadn’t been toying with me.
“You’re asking about credit card receipts,” he said. “That means you want me to either give you his name or his phone number or both.”
“You took his phone number?”
“No,” Ted said, “although I’m supposed to. Especially now when people’s credit cards are being denied left and right.”
“But you don’t,” I said.
“Because most people think I’m hitting on them when I ask.” He shrugged one broad shoulder. “It’s too much of a hassle. I just put a fifty-dollar hold on the card, and that does the trick ever so much better.”
I frowned. The hands told me he’d been bartending forever. The brains told me he should be doing something else.
“This your bar?” I asked.
“You think I’d be wearing this stupid shirt if it was?” he countered.
I acknowledged that logic with a simple move of my head.
“That was your not-so-subtle way of asking what a smart boy like me is doing in a place like this?”
“Yes,” I said.
“Pissing off my mother,” he said, and walked away from me.
For a minute, I thought he wasn’t coming back, but he did. He just went to the back and came out with a slip of paper that had obviously come from a credit card machine.
“Stanley Donen,” he said.
“What?” I said.
“Stanley Donen.” Then he spelled the name just so I’d get it right.
I must’ve had an odd look on my face, because when he looked up at me, he said, “What?”
“You might be smart, bartender boy,” I said, “but you don’t know your Hollywood history. Stanley Donen is a director from the 1950s. He directed Singing in the Rain.”
“I thought that was Gene Kelly.”
“Him too,” I said.
“You don’t think this guy is Donen’s son or something,” Ted said.
“Could be,” I said. “Donen’s last film was in 1984. But Mr. Alibi doesn’t seem like Hollywood royalty, does he?”
Ted looked at me oddly. “You think you can spot Hollywood royalty?”
“There’s generally an air of entitlement.”
“I dunno,” Ted said. “Asking to be alibied seems rather entitling.”
I shrugged. It didn’t seem that way to me, but I wasn’t going to argue it.
“It can’t be a fake name, you know,” Ted said. “He had identification.”
“You asked to see his ID?” I asked, knowing how old Mr. Alibi looked. No one in his right mind thought that man was under 21.
Ted made a face at me. “Not exactly.”
“What does that mean?” I asked.
“I mean you need ID to get a credit card.”
“You do,” I said. “You just don’t need your own.”
Mr. Alibi had given the same fake name at the police station along with a home address where, the arresting office told me with some irritation, a lovely middle-aged woman (emphasis on lovely) had flashed a rock the size of Rhode Island with a matching wedding band on her left hand and claimed to be his wife.
His living wife.
She also claimed her husband had a flair for the dramatic and liked to spend his afternoons shocking people.
So the police had investigated no further, warned him that he was out of line and to never do anything like that again, mentally added the phrase in our jurisdiction because they had a hunch he would do something like that again if he had enough drinks in him, and sent him on his merry little way.
So off I went on my merry little way, trudging to the address the cops gave me, which happened to be a not-so-small house in Beverly Hills, which was probably another reason why the cop hadn’t investigated much further, since whoever bought the house could’ve paid for a dozen cops just like him (and probably had).
The house was on one of those quiet cul-de-sacs that had been all the rage back when Beverly Hills starred as the wealthiest neighborhood in Los Angeles, back when the idea of hillbillies with money was funny and outré and kinda ironic, instead of the unintended result of a reality TV show.
I had a moment of doubt as I pulled up in front of the long curving driveway. The house was a remodeled 1960s mansion that wanted to be a suburban ranch house, but looked like it had swelled out of control. It was painted forest green and white, and because it was in Beverly Hills, the forest green looked appropriate and lovely when compared to the green of the plants and the spectacular green of the lush lawn.
No water crisis in this part of the city, or maybe someone was ignoring the limit on water usage that had been in effect—gosh, since I moved here as a toddler, way back in the dark ages.
Maybe, I said to myself (well, not “said,” exactly, “doubted” is more like it), maybe he actually is Stanley Donen’s kid, and he inherited the house, and he’s the kind of crazy that 99.9% of all Hollywood offspring are, and his lovely middle-aged wife (emphasis on lovely) tolerated it because it included the money to support her in the style that only a failed actress/model could aspire to in middle age.
Then I came to my senses, remembered that even though I was a down-on-my-luck private eye, I was still a private eye, with all kinds of modern tools at my disposal, which meant that I had an iPhone that I didn’t entirely understand, and I leaned back in the driver’s seat, logged onto the Internet Movie Database, and looked up Stanley Donen.
He was still alive, although imdb didn’t tell me where he lived. He had three kids, all boys, two in the Biz, as folks say around here. Not a one of them was named Stanley, although all were about the same age as my fake Stanley. So if he had been Stanley Donen’s kid, he would’ve been listed in imdb. They had plenty of time to scope him out. He was too old to be a grandkid, so he was a fake.
My heart leapt, which is an actual feeling that some down-on-their-luck private eyes have when things go their way. (The first time it happened, I thought it might be a cardiac arrhythmia that was heading toward a heart attack—which tells you just how rare that leapy feeling is.)
Then I went to the LA County website and looked for the deed registration page only to discover that some bastard had taken it down in a fit of civic pride (more likely fear of a lawsuit because of all the personal information stashed on that site). I’d used that registry more times than I wanted to think about, and I felt momentarily irritated that the information wasn’t available to me and then I realized that if I were a true hacker, I could find the information anyway, but I wasn’t a true hacker, not that kind anyway, and besides, it would be easier to drive the county offices and just ask to see the deed because it was, after all, public information.
But first, I had to act like the good, old-fashioned private eye that I was.
I had to boldly go where no private eye had gone before.
I parked the car and walked up the driveway, determined to knock on the house’s beautiful oak door.
The woman who answered the front door was indeed lovely and just barely middle aged (damn that cop) and not at all willing to admit that one Stanley Donen lived in the house—at least, not until I mentioned the cop, and the fact that I would be happy to call him to the house right now to verify that this was the address on Stanley D’s arrest record and that he had, in fact, talked to her.
She didn’t look dumb. She knew that lying to the cop in the middle of an investigation was a very bad thing.
“Okay,” she said with a sigh. “I know him. But his name isn’t Stanley and this isn’t his house.”
I could’ve guessed the “his name isn’t Stanley part,” but I hadn’t been so sure about the house. I had a dozen follow-up questions, but she still had her manicured hand on the door ready to slam it, so I decided to ease into the toughest question.
“Whose house is it?” I asked.
“Mine,” she said.
“Just yours?” I asked.
She raised her eyebrows in mock surprise.
“Yes,” she said with some irritation.
I nodded, not wanting to upset her too much. “And you are?”
“Not willing to suffer an interrogation,” she said and tried to slam the door.
But I’d been prepared for that move, and I caught the door with my hand. I was stronger than she was. She had gym muscles, which looked good. I had real muscles, which didn’t improve my appearance at all.
“I can find out at the county,” I said. “Then I’ll just come back with my trusty cop friend, and we’ll both find out what you know.”
She narrowed her eyes, shook her head slightly, and sighed. “Roxanne Winterbury.”
That name rang a bell, but I wasn’t sure which bell it rang. Could’ve been any bell, really. I wasn’t willing to ask her. Not yet.
“And how, Roxanne, do you know our friend Not-Stanley?”
“We go to the same gym,” she said.
Okay. That surprised me. I’d expected to hear that she’d met him in a bar.
“What gym is that?”
She named an upscale place in one of the upscale strip malls not too far from here. The kind of place that cost you $50 just to walk through the door and ask a question.
“And what’s Not-Stanley’s real name?”
Her lips thinned. She clearly wasn’t supposed to tell me this. “Doug Sirk.”
“Doug…Sirk?” Then I spelled the last name.
“Yes,” she said.
“As in Douglas Sirk?”
“I suppose. Why? Do you know him?”
I knew of him. Douglas Sirk was another director, not as well known as Stanley Donen. Sirk’s career, in movies anyway, only lasted through the 1950s. I didn’t know of anything he’d done after 1959—and I wasn’t sure why. Death, moved to television, retired—I had no idea. I was a movie buff, not a movie obsessive.
“No, I don’t know him,” I said. “Not personally anyway. But I do need to talk to him about what happened yesterday.”
“Oh,” she said. “It was just one of his pranks. It backfired because some bartender called the police.”
I blinked at her, a little too stunned to say much more. Actually, confessing to a crime when you actually hadn’t committed a crime was a misdemeanor, which was only enforced when you actually cost the city some money, which he had.
Only he hadn’t really cost it enough to make things terrible for him—not yet, anyway.
“Prank?” I asked.
She laughed a little nervously, then bit her upper lip and shrugged. “He likes to say outrageous things to upset people. Usually he gets a good story out of it.”
“But yesterday, he got arrested.”
“Well, who would believe that a man like that shot his wife?”
I would, I almost said, but didn’t. Clearly Miss Roxanne Winterbury wouldn’t. Proving, of course, which one of us was gullible and which one was cynical beyond belief.
(And making me wonder why the gullible one had the manicure, the rock the size of Rhode Island, and the mansion in Beverly Hills.)
“The bartender clearly believed him,” I said.
She sighed. “I know. I’ll have to talk to Doug about it the next time I see him.”
So he hadn’t talked to her since she lied for him. I found that fact fascinating all by itself.
“What made you lie for him?”
“It was part of the prank.” She waved that manicured hand, letting go of the door as she did, and nearly knocking me off balance.
“He set it up ahead of time?”
“He does that,” she said. “He goes around asking pretty women to be his alibi, and when they accept, he figures out something for them to alibi him for. It’s his way of picking up girls.”
Then she giggled in a wholly inappropriate way for a woman of recent middle age.
I could dispute the pretty part and I felt slightly vindicated about the pick-up line part, but I still didn’t understand exactly what was going on here. “When did he ask you to alibi him?”
“Oh,” she said and frowned. “Maybe a week ago? At the gym’s juice bar. You know.”
“No,” I said. “I don’t know.”
I almost added that no respectable place calling itself a gym had a juice bar. But again, much as I wanted to alienate this woman, I didn’t dare.
She must have sensed my judgment, because she didn’t say anything. So I did.
“Did he give you his phone number?”
“Oh, no,” she said. “We see each other every day. We’re both there from nine until ten. By then the early morning crowd has cleared out and the staff has had time to clean off the machines.”
I shuddered a little. “Did you see him this morning?”
“No,” she said.
“Was that unusual?”
“I was running late. Sometimes he finishes early.” She said that with a bit of a blush, which made me wonder if that last sentence was a double entendre.
So she kept track of him, but he didn’t wait for her.
“How do you know it was a week ago that he asked about the alibi?”
Her blush grew just a bit more. “We decided to share a post-workout smoothie. We hadn’t done that before. I nearly missed a standing lunch date.”
“What exactly did he ask?”
“He asked me if I would be his alibi.” She smiled at the memory. She really was a pretty woman. Damn her. “And of course, I said yes.”
Of course. Because that was what any sane woman would do.
“So he told me that if anyone showed up asking for Stanley Donen, I should tell them I’m Stanley’s wife and that he wasn’t home at the moment, but that he had been home for the hours they were asking about.”
“Even if they were cops?” I asked.
“He said he knew people on the force. He said it would be harmless fun.”
I nodded, as if I understood. I guess I did understand. This Stanley Donen/Doug Sirk was a nutball.
And so was this woman.
“You didn’t ask why he needed an alibi?” I said.
She laughed. “Of course I did. He told me he was playing pranks on friends. He’d tell them something outrageous and if they were silly enough to check, my response would confuse them more.”
“Did it?”
“Oh, yes,” she said and giggled again. That giggle would really be annoying from a two-year-old. On a woman in her late thirties, it was obnoxious as hell. “Those police officers frowned at me, looked a little angry, and then apologized. I think it was worthwhile just to have a member of the LAPD apologize, don’t you?”
I had a good relationship with the LAPD, despite its press.
“They may not see it that way, ma’am,” I said, sounding a bit like an LAPD officer myself.
The smile fled her face, and she suddenly looked frightened. Maybe she wasn’t as smart as I had originally given her credit for.
“Did I do something wrong?”
“You lied to the police in an ongoing investigation, ma’am,” I said. “They might consider that terribly wrong.”
Then I turned on one foot and marched back to my car, feeling a little less confused and a lot more satisfied. I didn’t hear the door close behind me until I’d reached the street.
So Roxanne Winterbury had watched me leave. Which meant she was thinking.
Wonder if that meant she had lied about her friend Douglas Sirk’s phone number. Wonder if she was reassessing the relationship or wondering how to warn him.
Then I decided it didn’t matter.
Warn him about what? That an ugly private eye was looking for him? That would frighten him how?
I wasn’t sure what I’d do when I found him. Except tell him to stop besmirching the names of beloved directors (even if that was stretching it in the case of Douglas Sirk).
Still, this whole case was getting curiouser and curiouser, to quote Alice in Wonderland. And I really did want to find out what was down that rabbit hole.
The gym felt like it was its own personal rabbit hole.
First of all, it wasn’t a “gym,” but a personal health and fitness club. And it nearly did cost me fifty dollars to get in the door.
No one got inside without paying some kind of deposit, preferably with a valid Black American Express card.
I got in because I had a valid private eye license, not one of those fakey things they sold on late night TV. To the bouncer’s credit (and yes, the place had a bouncer—although they probably called him a security guard), he actually knew the difference between a fake private detective license and the real thing.
He not only let me in with great reluctance, but he shadowed me with even greater distaste. If I hadn’t showered that morning and if I wasn’t wearing the cleanest of clean clothes, I would have thought that my body odor quotient was high—even for a personal health and fitness club.
The front desk put the reception desks at most five-star hotels to shame. It covered half a wall, had more computers than a bank, and a staff that looked so buff the soft lighting reflected off their perfect muscles. Unlike the folks who usually man the desk at a personal health and fitness center, these folks looked like they actually had an IQ as well.
I introduced myself while I held my wallet open, showing the license. Then one of the buffettes looked at me, then looked at another buffette who apparently was nonverbally dispatched to find the head buffette.
Who came out of the back wearing the gym rat equivalent of a suit—khaki pants, a designer golf shirt, and a watch that cost five times the price of my iPhone. He smiled, and I half expected to see that little starlike glimmer on his perfectly even, frighteningly white teeth.
“Ah, Miss Sweet,” he said in that unctuous tone used only by maitre d’s at upscale restaurants, “let me help you with your quest.”
I so badly wanted to correct him. I was Ms. Sweet, not Miss Sweet, and private investigators did not have quests. We had clients.
Only I really didn’t have a client here, now did I? I had a hunch. A hunch that was slowly turning sour.
We went around the lovely desk, past the banks of computers, and off in the distance, I could see high-end treadmills and ellipticals, filled with high-end (and somewhat desperate) people, all of whom looked extremely serious about their treadmilling and ellipticalling.
We slipped into an office twice the size of mine. The head buffette gestured toward one of the chairs in front of his expensive desk, and I sat down, discovering that the damn thing was as comfortable as my couch. I tried not to relax in it.
“Mrs. Wimberly Winterbury called,” he said, and I was so startled that I missed the rest of his sentence.
That’s why Roxanne’s name was familiar. Wimberly Winterbury had died less than a month ago, leaving her his 1.2 billion dollar estate, but his children (all twelve of them, with his six previous wives) were contesting the will. She was living on her generous allowance in the home he had bought for her before they married.
I knew all of this because, in LA, you can’t avoid the high-end gossip, particularly if it involves gold diggers, more than a billion dollars, and angry relatives.
“Miss Sweet?” the head buffette was saying in that unctuous tone. Apparently I had missed something after all, probably some crap about confidentiality, blah, blah, blah.
So I went on the offensive.
“I’m a bit disturbed here, Mr….?”
“Nevins,” he said.
“Mr. Nevins,” I said in my friendliest tone. “I’m investigating some disturbing reports concerning Mr. Sirk. It turns out he’s been using a fake name. Douglas Sirk isn’t his real name at all.”
“Nonsense,” he said. “His identification checked out perfectly.”
Meaning his credit card worked.
“What identification do you require?” I asked.
Nevins pulled up a file on the flatscreen computer next to his desk, discretely turning it away from me so that I couldn’t see the information as it showed up.
Wimberly Winterbury died, and his widow was involved with a con man who needed an alibi shortly thereafter. I was on the news and the next day, the same con man was talking to me.
Was that the link between us? Our trashy TV news coverage? Because it certainly wasn’t the fact that we were both middle-aged, pretty and rich. I was middle-aged, but pretty and rich seemed to have passed me by.
“He showed us his driver’s license, of course, and his credit card,” Nevins said.
Both of which were easy to get, even if they weren’t yours. “How long has he been a member?”
“Six months,” Nevins said.
“And have you been deducting the fees every month?” I asked.
“Heavens, no,” Nevins said, and he made that phrase actually sound convincing. “We charge annually.”
“One big lump payment,” I said.
“Along with an initiation fee in the first year,” he said. Then he looked at me blandly. “It does separate the wheat from the chaff.”
And I was clearly chaff.
“Would you do me a favor?” I asked. “Would you run a small charge on the credit card?”
“We can’t do that, Miss Sweet,” he said in his most disapproving tone. “We don’t give other people money from someone’s credit card.”
“It’s not for me,” I said, and resisted the urge to add, you dumbass. “I want to see if the card is still working. If it is, then you can reverse the charge and apologize if he sees his bill. If it isn’t, then I’d like it if you talked to me about Douglas Sirk and let me know what’s in his file.”
“I’m sure it’s legitimate.”
“You do know that he was arrested yesterday, right?”
Nevins looked at me with alarm.
“For shooting his wife,” I said.
Nevins’ alarm grew. I’d never seen a man’s eyes get that big.
“Roxanne Winterbury alibied him without even knowing why,” I said. “And he didn’t use the name Sirk. He used the name Stanley Donen.”
“The director?” Score one for Nevins.
“And if you go to the Internet Movie Database, you’ll realize that Douglas Sirk is the name of a movie director as well.”
That seemed to convince Nevins more than the credit card idea. Still, he punched several numbers into the computer, paused and said to me, “Do you think $20 will suffice?”
“I think it’ll tell us what we need to know,” I said.
He finished punching in the numbers, then stopped and stared at the screen. Then he punched in more numbers, and more numbers, seeming more frantic with each punch.
“Good Lord,” he said as that unctuous mask dropped away. “I’ll tell you what I can, Ms. Sweet, but I really don’t have much here.”
Damn if he didn’t suddenly become a human being. One who might have helped in a very large theft. But I didn’t tell him that. I figured he was smart enough to figure that one out on his own.
“I’ll take what you have,” I said, unable to resist sounding just a little unctuous myself.
What he had were two bogus credit card numbers, one stolen driver’s license number, an address and a cell phone number. Nevins wanted to call the cell, but I persuaded him not to. I also persuaded him to wait until I was done with my investigation before he called the police.
“We don’t want to tip off Mr. Sirk, now do we?” I asked.
Nevins agreed. Besides, he probably needed some time with his lords and masters to figure out how they handled account fees paid with a credit card issued to a man with fake identification.
That the ID was fake was pretty easy to prove. The California Department of Motor Vehicles couldn’t tell you who a license belonged to, but they could tell you who it didn’t belong to. And a call to the DMV with the license number came back with the information that that particular number and that particular name did not go together.
Which was more than enough for Mr. Nevins, but not quite enough for me.
As I left, I called a buddy at the LAPD to see if he could (quietly) let me know who the number did belong to.
It belonged to one Fred Zinnemann, yet another director, whose last film came out in 1982. But the heyday of his career was—you guessed it—in the 1950s (if you ignore my two favorites, Day of the Jackal and Julia). He was the guy who directed High Noon and I was tempted to whistle the theme song as I trudged through the streets of LA because I was beginning to feel like Gary Cooper, all alone in my quest for justice.
Donen/Sirk/Zinnemann had to have used more fake information to get that driver’s license. The fact that he existed in the DMV’s database meant that he had actually gone through them to get the Zinnemann license. Which meant that the birth certificate he presented had to look real to them. What I couldn’t get my LAPD friend to find out was how long Zinnemann had the license. Cops weren’t supposed to dig in DMV records either (weird California laws) and so he didn’t want to go back to his source.
So I had three fake names, two bogus credit cards, a real driver’s license number, a cell phone number, and two addresses.
And then, I realized, if the driver’s license was real, then the address on that license had to be real too.
And that’s how I found myself driving to Encino at sunset, when I really should have been driving home.
Encino, California, where Michael Jackson died. Encino, California, home of some really bad movie jokes (including a movie-long joke called Encino Man). Encino, California, which had waaaaaay too many houses for my tastes.
Encino has these lovely, big, expensive houses where the stars and their support systems live (although why they’d live in this part of the Valley, I’ll never know). It also has some smaller houses, the kind where real people live—or people as real as people can get living in Los Angeles.
Zinnemann’s house was in one of the real neighborhoods. Each house was maybe 3,000 square feet max, and some were much smaller, maybe 1,500 square feet. Not every house had a second story, but all had lovely landscaping, much of it turning brown.
This was a neighborhood where the people followed the water rationing rules, where they did their best, even though it was never enough to compare to the fancy houses just a few blocks away.
This house had actual trees in front, although what kind I had no idea. I’m a people detective, not a tree detective. A deliberately crooked brick walk led to a nice front door with its own little roof—a 1920s style that belonged in the Midwest, not in Encino.
The house was old enough that it might have been considered upscale in its day. Now it was a bit dowdy, in need of paint, a good pressure washing, and some de-cobwebbing.
Oh, yeah, and someone needed to remove the police tape from the front door.
The tape looked relatively new. It was still bright yellow and it didn’t have the dirt that coated the rest of the house. The yard bore lots of evidence of a police presence: tire tracks on the brown dirt where flowers had died long ago, crushed brown grass that still showed the marks of footprints, and one plastic folded number, the kind that crime scene techs use. They must have been irritated that they forgot it—and wondering just where they left it.
The number reassured me. It meant they had already photographed the scene. If I didn’t disturb the police tape, then I wasn’t truly messing with a crime scene.
I stepped off the brick walk and stepped over the tire tracks, heading to the picture window on the east side of the front door. I looked behind me to check if anyone could see me from the street. They couldn’t; those willowy trees were in the way. I stood on my tiptoes and peered inside the house, cupping my hands around my face.
The living room was a shambles. The couch had been moved, a coffee table was overturned, and something large and glass had shattered on the floor.
But that wasn’t the worst of it. The worst of it was the floor and the built-in bookshelf. The floor was hardwood. It had once been covered with a rug.
I knew that because there was a stain around the floor in a rug-shape. In the center of the non-stain area (where the rug had been) was a brown stain, this one thick and oblong. Ish. Oblong-ish. Something had gone through the rug all the way to the floor.
Judging by the spatter at the edges of the rugless area, that something was blood.
The crap on the bookshelf wasn’t just blood. It was blood and brain matter and bone fragments.
Someone had been shot and that stuff was blowback.
I tried to remember if I had heard about a shooting in Encino recently, but nothing came to mind. That didn’t mean anything. Millions of people lived in the LA Basin, and some of those people belonged to gangs, while others were thieves and murderers—probably at the same proportion that any other community had thieves and murderers.
What I wanted to know was who this house belonged to, who was investigating the shooting, and who the hell died.
I figured that wouldn’t be too hard to find, and I was right.
Once I returned to my car, I pulled out my trusty iPhone with its wonderful Internet connectivity. I used to do my job without an Internet connection at my fingertips, but damn if I remember how I did it.
I plugged in the street name, the word “murder,” (figuring the cops wouldn’t do this much work for a simple shooting; not that anyone could have survived that much bone, brain, and blood loss), and came up with some relatively minor news reports.
Interestingly, most of the reports were on the various evening news shows—the ones that had sent their junior hack reporters to interview me. Those shows loved blood-and-guts news stories, especially those with video footage, just like they loved car chases, because those also had lovely video footage.
This crime was basic evening news fodder. A single woman, murdered in her home in a quiet Encino neighborhood. The news ate this thing up, particularly when it had aerial footage of a coroner’s van parked outside the house, and the crime techs at work in the yard.
And it was one of those scary headline crimes—single woman murdered, no apparent motive. She lived alone and had died alone. The only reason anyone even knew she was shot was that a neighbor peeked through the window and saw the body.
The neighbor was a short-term suspect, particularly when it turned out he had an arrest record a mile long. He was the neighborhood peeping tom—with a conscience, apparently. He didn’t have to call the police, but he did.
The woman, Katalin Voight, had moved to Los Angeles two years before. She was forty, not interested in any Hollywood work at all, and self-employed. She was a freelance bookkeeper who found work on Craigslist.
The Craigslist connection kept LAPD detectives busy for a long time, particularly since the 2009 Craigslist Killer case back east made everyone think of murder in connection to the site. But her records showed no murderous connection to Craigslist, nor did they show any murderous connection to anyone. Her family lived in the Midwest, and all they would say (sadly, of course) was that she wanted a new life.
Her neighbors knew nothing about her, her clients knew very little, and she hadn’t made many friends here, although she had a wide and varying social network on the Internet.
A quiet woman in a quiet house in a quiet neighborhood, loudly shotgunned to death even though no one heard, found by her peeping tom neighbor days after the event.
The news played it up for nearly a week before the coverage faded. That was almost two months ago. The fact that the tire tracks and footprints remained showed just how dry it had been in LA lately. I hadn’t realized how long it had been since we last got rain.
I set the iPhone down and looked at the house. A woman had died here. She had become more famous in death than she had in life—a curiously LA phenomenon. Even that fame was fleeting.
Roxanne Winterbury had become famous for marrying and being widowed by a very wealthy man. Her fame rose a few weeks ago as the court cases involving her inheritance began.
I became famous a few days ago for rescuing a child. My fame would pass within the week, but it did exist.
And while it was happening, I met a man who claimed to be a director. He almost voluntarily went off to jail, but not before orchestrating his own alibi. Which he tipped off when he was talking to me.
I frowned. A man who claimed to be three different directors. He didn’t orchestrate that alibi. He directed it.
I needed to get to a computer with a bigger screen and a lot more firepower.
I went to my crummy apartment which had my incredible high-speed Internet access, my up-to-the-minute computer and my extremely empty refrigerator.
I stopped for pizza on the way there.
Amazing how much of the world is at your fingertips nowadays. Amazing how little the police knew about taking advantage of that.
It took me less than an hour to call up Katalin Voight’s records from Rapid City, South Dakota. She had been a full-fledged CPA there, with actual big-time clients—or as big-time as clients got in Rapid City.
She was Katalin Voight to her clients, but in her personal life, she was Katalin Johnson, wife of Kenneth Johnson, who owned one of those movie palaces that had once been a vaudeville theatre.
The arrival of multiplexes, easy DVD rentals, and affordable big-screen TVs closed the movie palace. The papers soon carried a divorce notice for Katalin and Kenneth Johnson. Then the papers carried a one-paragraph mention of a restraining order. Then they carried an announcement that Katalin Voight’s business was closing its doors after fifteen profitable years while Ms. Voight was going into retirement.
It didn’t say she was retiring in Los Angeles, but she did.
And Kenneth tracked her there.
How do I know that?
Because those same papers ran a photograph of Kenneth when they announced the closing of the movie palace that he had owned and loved forever. The movie palace that closed despite his best efforts. The movie palace that had lost money for nearly a decade, despite his efforts. The movie palace that may have lost money because—he said—of the mismanagement of his CPA, one Katalin Johnson.
That photograph looked just like Stanley Donen/Douglas Sirk/Fred Zinnemann. The man who had briefly enjoyed the limelight as a movie palace owner. Who limelighted again (although somewhat privately) as the LA press discussed his wife’s mysterious murder. Who sought others in the limelight so that they’d help him regain that limelight.
He directed Roxanne Winterbury to give him a bad alibi that any cop should have been able to see through, and he directed me to search for the same bad alibi.
Which I did.
And that led me to his ex-wife’s house, and the detective on his ex-wife’s murder, who was somewhat annoyed at me for finding the ex-husband, whom he had no idea existed.
Kenneth Johnson was staying at one of those anonymous by-the-month business hotels that dotted all of LA County. He’d been there for a month before his ex-wife’s murder, and he stayed there throughout the publicity.
It wasn’t hard to find him, if you only knew where to look.
Kenneth Johnson got his fifteen minutes of fame. In tried-and-true LA tradition, he gave interviews to the press against his attorney’s advice, appeared on all the talk shows, and proclaimed his innocence. That went on too long for my tastes, but how long I have no idea, since I stopped watching after the first two days.
The problem was he extended my fifteen minutes of fame to nearly six months. I became the most famous detective in Los Angeles. Someone even ran a special about me on Court TV, although they didn’t interview me or my friends or most of my clients, and used only stock footage.
I tried to see this as a good thing. New clients, a better office, and enough money to afford a really good secretary who could screen my calls, turn away unwanted visitors, and tell the press to go to hell.
But I gotta say, I resented Kenneth Johnson. I felt like some flat-faced extra who had somehow become an unlikely star of a blockbuster film. I didn’t want the fame he’d directed me into, and I couldn’t seem to get out of it.
But it’s my new reality. Well-known detective Belinda Sweet, the go-to girl for the biggest of the big cases. Those cases do pay well, and I’m smart enough to solve them.
But getting used to this new persona is a bit rough.
I keep reminding myself: New personas and new realities are an LA thing. They’re exactly what Katalin Voight wanted when she moved to the city. A chance to start over. A chance to remake herself.
A chance to be someone else.
I am someone else, and I’d rather be me.
But that’s the LA curse and the LA blessing. At least no one will ask me to alibi them any more—at least, not after the fact.
Although some director’s been chasing me for weeks now, wanting me to host a cable show on alibis.
Which, of course, I will never ever do.
____________________________________________
“Mr. Alibi” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Mr. AlibiCopyright © 2016 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine, September/October, 2010Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2016 by WMG PublishingCover design by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Loke Yek Mang | Dreamstime
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
Right now, every single person I speak to in the United States mentions how stressed they are. We have a lot going on here. It’s a week from the election, two days from Halloween, and it’s been a weird summer (at least here in Las Vegas). At WMG, we’ve been dealing with all sorts of changes, 99% of them really fun.
We moved our main offices to Las Vegas…10 days ago. We’re designing our books, making them more accessible on every platform and in every format. We’re finishing projects previously left undone…
And we are tired.
So when it came time to do the video for the Holiday Spectacular Kickstarter, which launched today, I let my mood inform my work. (I also had assistance from the adorable Angel.)
https://kriswrites.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/Holiday-Spectacular-2024-Kickstarter.mp4We do the Holiday Spectacular every year. It’s a calendar of stories that you can receive from American Thanksgiving to New Year’s Day. Most folks opt to get theirs via email, but we’re looking at other ways to deliver, which we’ll have in place by the time the Kickstarter is over.
The Holiday Spectacular stories, written by some of the best writers in the business, follow three general genres this year: Thriller, Romance, or Fantasy (with a sense of wonder).
If you back the Kickstarter, you can get the calendar (with every reward) as well as anthologies and all kinds of cool merchandise.
So head on over…and spoil yourself (or your loved ones). After the year we’ve all had, you deserve it.
1912—In a world where President Andrew Johnson’s conviction at his impeachment trial guaranteed that Reconstruction not only had teeth but also continued into the 20th century, South Carolina stands out as a leader in change, a pioneer of laws that change the balance of power. This new United States, this new South, sees Blacks and women rise to their rightful places of power alongside Whites.
But that doesn’t stop Lost Causers from trying to return the country to its old ways.
So, when someone tries to stop presidential hopeful Kate Wells from speaking at an event organized by the influential Abigail Lockwood, Abigail knows the Lost Causers want to send her a message.
But her response might prove one they never expected.
“Politicians, Lost Causers, and Abigail Lockwood” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Politicians, Lost Causers, and Abigail LockwoodKristine Kathryn RuschOneFlames spat and snapped beside her, but Abigail’s gaze rose to the sparks, floating lazily toward the moss-covered live oak trees. If one of those caught on fire, the woods would go up. May had been inordinately dry, but April had been wet, and she had to hope that a loving God would cancel those two things out and keep the home she’d been born in—the land she’d been raised on—intact.
She stood barefoot on the dirt path leading to the pavilion. The fire ate the canvas like someone had treated it with alcohol. The ribbons went first, but the ropes and stakes remained, and inside she could still see the shadows of the chairs and tables set up for the rousing evening of speechifying and glad-handing that she’d been working so hard to organize.
She couldn’t think about what they’d do tomorrow, when they had to get through this moment first. Rufus was on her left, passing her buckets, which she passed to Titus, who handed them to the gardeners, running around the pavilion, splashing water on the flames.
The sizzle and pop and steam made it seem like the water was doing something, but the one thing it wasn’t doing was dousing the flames. They were growing worse by the instant.
The pavilion was sandwiched next to the great house, in the wide patch of lawn that she had created not five years before. The gardeners had complained that she was pulling down plants that had been in the earth since Lockwood Hall had been the River’s Bend Plantation.
The gardens weren’t burning yet and neither was the forest of trees planted on three sides of the great house, which led her to believe that the fire had been deliberately started. She hadn’t had that thought, though, when she sent Jeremiah on his horse to roust the firemen. It would take them at least forty-five minutes to get here, and she had to stall that fire somehow.
It was only standing here, half of her so hot that she could feel her skin prickling and the other half slightly chilled from her wet nightdress, that she realized the fire hadn’t been spontaneous.
Someone had snuck onto her property, either through the trees or under the canopy marking the main road, just to set the pavilion on fire. She didn’t want to think about what might have happened if they had come into the house.
Too late to think about that now. Now she had to grab, pass, grab, pass, grab, pass, and hope that the buckets would be enough to stem the tide of the fire until the firemen got here.
At least the pond was still full from the spring rains. And, if they needed it, the river that had once given the old plantation its name was close enough that they could extend the bucket brigade if they had to.
In that split second between buckets, as she swiveled from handing off a bucket to grabbing the next, she wiped the back of her hand over her face. The air tasted of soot and burning fabric.
The night sky glowed orange. They had to see it in town by now, even if Jeremiah hadn’t arrived at the fire station yet.
That was the problem living this far out. The pavilion might be a complete loss by the time the firemen got here. But they would be able to stop the fire from spreading and, God forbid, keep it from the house.
TwoKate Wells stepped onto the observation platform, the door to the train car banging behind her. Despite the gaslights around the terminal, she could only see a few yards of track disappearing into the darkness.
The air smelled faintly of smoke, which surprised her, given the warmth of the June night. But what she considered warm might be cold to someone raised in this hothouse clime.
Muffled conversation rose as the regular passengers made their way off the train. Arriving at three in the morning did make everyone seem a bit muted. Kate didn’t feel muted. Or tired. Just frustrated.
This trip was not working out the way she wanted it to.
Perhaps that was why she was hiding on the observation platform, waiting for everyone to leave before she disembarked. Not that she expected anyone to stop her or to recognize her. The biggest problem she had so far in her campaign for president was getting enough press coverage to become well known.
She placed a fist on the steel railing around the back of the car. Maybe she should have tried a whistle-stop campaign. But she had been afraid that no one would show up at campaign stops.
This election had an inordinate number of candidates, and this was before the conventions. As she told Martin Halston, whom she’d hired to run the campaign, she would do her whistle-stop after she had received the Republican nomination.
The last thing she wanted right now was a reason for the party power brokers, from John Roy Lynch to William Taft, to have an excuse to dismiss her candidacy. They might anyway, if she presented the wrong platform.
Martin wanted her to run on the standard old tropes—it was past time for a woman to become President. After all, women had gotten the vote at the same time as blacks. Women had become governors, senators, and federal judges (although none yet had been appointed to the Supreme Court). Martin felt that reminding her constituents and, in particular, the power brokers, that a woman deserved a chance at the highest office in the land would get Kate through the door.
But everyone from Carrie Chapman Catt to Jane Addams to Alice Paul had made that argument. The argument had gotten them nowhere.
Instead, Kate felt they (she) should address how difficult 1912 was already proving to be. The economy lacked the stability that it needed, particularly after the panic of 1910. Just as things had started to look up, the RMS Titanic had gone down, taking some of the world’s power brokers with it. And, in the two months since, confidence in humanity’s ability to make the world better seemed threatened, too.
Kate was going to try that argument here in South Carolina. She had always liked coming here. She felt at home, had since her first visit at a retreat for the Congressional Women’s Caucus. The land looked very different from her native Illinois, but the gentle outspokenness of the women here appealed to her blunt Midwestern self on a level she had yet to completely understand.
But it was more than that. Ever since the war ended, South Carolina had been a leader in change. It pioneered laws that changed the balance of power, redistributing the land once owned by the treasonous Confederate landowners, allowing blacks—who were in the majority here, even then—to take over the government.
She had been looking forward to coming to South Carolina, but as the train stopped, she felt unsettled, as if she had made a mistake in coming here.
She tapped her fist on that rail. She couldn’t hear voices any longer, which meant that the other passengers were inside the terminal. She went back into the observation car, and picked up her personal bag. Her assistants already had her luggage.
She would head to her hotel and see if she could get some sleep, before the meetings began in the afternoon.
She took her bag to the exit, opened the door, and sneezed. The smell of smoke had grown stronger, blowing in on the wind. Maybe not a hearth fire at all. Perhaps something more serious.
But no one seemed alarmed, and the exhaustion she had been holding at bay threatened to overwhelm her. Her mood would improve after sleep.
It always did.
ThreeAbigail sat on the steps leading to the veranda and watched the sunrise cast red light all over wisping clouds. Usually she loved this view of the lawn and the gardens beyond. She’d stand, a cup of coffee in her left hand, and survey her entire domain.
Maybe God was punishing her for that arrogance. Lord knows, He punished the previous owners of this land something awful.
Someone placed a heavy shirt around her shoulders. She looked up. Titus stood behind her. His skin looked mottled and patched, dark where soot covered it, and light brown around his lips, where he’d clearly wiped off his mouth. Tracks ran through the soot, tears most like, although he would deny it.
Her son was nothing if not stoic.
He sat beside her. The top of the steps creaked under his weight. Her youngest boy now outweighed her by a hundred pounds, all muscle.
“The horse came back,” he said quietly.
It took her a moment to understand him. Her brain was working slowly, which she blamed on the lack of sleep, but was probably the trauma of the night. Her hands ached, her eyes burned, and she stank of smoke. He had probably dropped the shirt over her because her nightgown, thin and soot-covered, revealed more than it covered.
“Jeremiah’s?” she asked, just for confirmation.
Titus nodded.
She had wondered what happened to Jeremiah. The firemen had arrived late, claiming they had seen the red against the sky, and smelled the smoke. She had set that information aside, thinking they had simply passed him on the road.
The fire department had a new mechanized truck, and it went fast. Jeremiah, she had thought, would have moved the horse off the road so that the truck itself wouldn’t spook him.
The pumper automobile still stood at the edge of the lawn, its tanks empty, and the boilers off. The firemen were rolling up the hoses and getting ready to go. She had focused on the fire and the land and the drama of the night, and hadn’t given a second thought to Jeremiah.
“When?” she asked quietly.
“I don’t know.” Titus ran a hand over his mouth, a nervous tick since babyhood whenever he didn’t want to say what he was thinking. “They found it grazing near the main road.”
She nodded. The horse wouldn’t have come closer, not with the fire and the upset.
Jeremiah was a good man. He ran the household for her. She liked to joke that he was the family butler, but in truth, he was the manager, making sure the dozen or so employees she engaged did their jobs.
She hadn’t even questioned his decision to alert the firemen. That kind of thing was what Jeremiah did.
“Do we know where Jeremiah is?” she asked.
“No, Mama,” Titus said.
But they both had an idea.
FourThe body lay crumpled beneath an ancient live oak just off the road leading to Lockwood Hall. Sheriff Dunnet Brewster removed the hat from his bald pate and clutched it to his chest.
Jeremiah Harding had been a good man, and he hadn’t deserved to die.
Dunnet was partly relieved two of his men had found Jeremiah, thinking maybe whoever had started the fire had taken him into the woods near here, and tortured him. There were still enough Lost Causers who felt that ku-kluxing was an exhibit of power, not a pathetic attempt to recover what they had lost.
Dunnet crouched beside the body. It was huddled in a fetal position, originally making him think that Jeremiah had been beaten, and had died protecting his face and torso.
But as Dunnet got close, he saw a bloody mass across Jeremiah’s front. Dunnet grabbed Jeremiah’s shoulder and pulled him slightly forward. The remains of Jeremiah’s shirt gaped, revealing a neat little round hole between his shoulder blades.
He’d been shot in the back by something powerful, or at a close enough range that the bullet (bullets?) did maximum damage, exiting out the front.
The shot would have thrown him from his horse, and he would have sprawled along the road. Whoever killed him had dragged him here, and posed the body.
Which bothered Dunnet. That made no sense. Lost Causers usually liked to show their handiwork, not hide it. It made terror easier.
Dunnet rose slowly, his knees creaking. He had seen a lot of things, but this was new.
Still, it was his job to investigate.
“There should be a blood trail,” he said to his men. “Let’s find it.”
FiveThe knock on her door came at ten a.m. sharp. Kate blinked. She’d been dozing, but that didn’t substitute for good sleep.
“Coming,” she said, as she gathered her robe and slipped her feet into the slippers she carried everywhere.
She pulled open the door to find Martin outside. He wore the same suit he’d worn the night before, only he had his coat over his shoulder, and he had found a different shirt that looked only slightly wrinkled.
He clutched a tray in both hands, with a silver coffee pot, two bone china cups, and a pile of pastries in the middle.
“I had another hour,” she said, letting her irritation through.
“Yep.” He pushed his way into the room, and she closed the door behind him. He set the tray on the table near the window.
She trailed behind him. The coffee smelled good. The pastries smelled better. She hadn’t realized how hungry she was.
“Possible change of plans,” he said, and her heart sank. The speakers were lined up, the event had been advertised for nearly three weeks. She’d had assurances—
“There’s been a fire at Lockwood Hall,” he said.
She blinked, not expecting that. She had expected to hear that some of the local bigwigs had decided not to speak on her behalf after all. Since W.E.B. DuBois entered the race, she had been hearing a lot of discouraging talk about her candidacy. DuBois was brilliant, famous, outspoken, and a heck of an organizer. He knew everyone.
The only hope she had was that he wasn’t always politic. He could antagonize as easily as he could charm.
“A fire?” she asked.
Martin pulled out a chair for her, then crossed to his and sat down. He looked as tired as she felt.
“I don’t know how bad it is, but it was bad enough that the entire fire department worked half the night on it,” he said.
“The smoke,” she said, more to herself than to him. “That’s what I smelled.”
“Most probably,” he said. “I don’t have a lot of information, but we might have to forgo our work here. If you’re going to keep to your schedule, that is. If not, then we can try to reschedule the actual event.”
She looked down at the pastries. They glistened with butter and sugar, decadence that she hadn’t seen much of on this trip.
She’d done the best she could on a limited budget, but she had seen South Carolina as the centerpiece of her travels. Where South Carolina went, so went Mississippi and Georgia and Louisiana and almost every other state of the former Confederacy. She didn’t think she could get the male black vote here, not with DuBois in the ring, but he wasn’t that popular with women of either race.
She had seen an opening, and these meetings here in the next two days were the centerpieces of them. But she was relying on Abigail Lockwood to help introduce her to the local women who ran everything from the mayor’s office to the congressional campaigns. A lot of the funding came because of the recommendation of black women, and Abigail had assured her that she could help.
And now the fire.
Kate wasn’t sure what she should do—for herself, her campaign, or for Abigail.
If Abigail was even all right.
Kate felt her cheeks warm. She hadn’t even asked how Abigail was doing.
“Was anyone hurt?” she asked.
Martin shrugged. He wasn’t even looking at her. He was pouring coffee. “I’ve told you what I know.”
Kate nodded, thought, then decided. If she ever became president, she would have to deal with the good and the bad, the disaster as well as the triumph.
Might as well start now.
“Let’s go to Lockwood Hall,” she said, “and see if Abigail needs help.”
SixThe news Sheriff Dunnet Brewster shared hurt. Abigail stood in her front parlor—the parlor that Jeremiah would have insisted they use—and clasped her hands over her heart. She had known since the horse came back that something had happened to Jeremiah, but her own innate optimism had let her hope that he had been bucked off or knocked unconscious.
Not shot as he rode into town.
Dunnet stood near the door, twisting his hat in his hands. Titus and Rufus stood beside Abigail, while her oldest son, Robert, remained outside, talking to the fire chief. No one sat on the horsehair sofa or tried to squeeze their bulk into the upholstered armchairs, and for once, Abigail didn’t offer it.
“I know you’ve had threats from the Lost Causers,” Dunnet was saying. “Any recently?”
Abigail glanced at her sons. Sometimes they—and Jeremiah, God rest his soul—protected her from the worst of it. Thinking, apparently, that she couldn’t handle tough times. Not remembering that she had taken over this acreage when their daddy died, more than twenty years before. Just as Reconstruction was ending, when the terrors were at their worst.
“A few years ago,” Rufus said, “right after that Supreme Court case, we had constant threats.”
Dunnet frowned slightly. No one had told him, because Abigail and her sons decided to handle it all themselves.
“That case wasn’t even about you,” Dunnet said.
“It was, though,” Titus said. “It would’ve had an impact on any family that got its property after the war. Just because the case was based in Mississippi didn’t mean it wouldn’t hurt us if it went the wrong way.”
Abigail had watched that case with unease. Even though the Congress had mandated that the traitors who fought against the Republic lose their property, there had been talk throughout the last sixty years that the property laws were unconstitutional—that the federal government didn’t have the right to break up plantations of active Confederates and sell them to whomever had the funds or was willing to work off the purchase price.
The property laws had benefited blacks and poor whites alike, shifting the balance of power so dramatically that most of the former landowners had fled West rather than live in poverty in the land they had once ruled.
But that case, like so many others in the past few decades, had tested the strength of the federal government over the states and she had been lucky—they all had been lucky—that the federal government won.
“You never reported anything,” Dunnet said.
Titus ran a hand over his mouth, which gave Rufus time to answer. Rufus was the polite one among her sons.
“You weren’t sheriff yet,” Rufus said.
So much in such a small sentence. The previous sheriff—Joe Davis, a white man whose family could trace its roots back to the Revolutionary War—never prosecuted Lost Causers. Somehow, there was never enough evidence, even when the victims (if they survived) could identify the assailants.
Dunnet nodded. His gaze met Abigail’s. She had worked on his election, reminding everyone in the county that they were best off with people whose families had either come out of slavery or remembered what it was like to be poor, white, and barefoot, people who believe that no one cared about them.
She worked tirelessly to keep her people in office, and sometimes she failed, as evidenced by the election of Sheriff Joe Davis.
“You could’ve told me,” Dunnet said.
“We did just fine,” Rufus said.
Just fine was a matter of opinion. They had survived the anger, the demands, the burning cross at the edge of the road.
“We hired guards,” Abigail said. Dunnet needed to know the measures they had taken. “And in December, when it was so cold, we decided we didn’t need them anymore.”
“Who knew the damned Lost Causers would come slinking back out when the weather warmed up,” Titus said.
She glanced sideways at her son. His eyes were red-rimmed, and his cheeks moved as he clenched and unclenched his teeth. Another nervous habit, one he had learned from his father. One of the few things.
She had no idea how her husband would have handled this all. He used to take a lot of measures into his own hands, something that she urged her sons not to do.
The law helps us, she had said over and over again. And it had until a few Lost Causers managed to win local office. She was now devoting a goodly portion of her annual income to make sure no Lost Causers won any elections.
Dunnet’s frown had grown. “You think Lost Causers did this?” he asked.
“Don’t you?” Titus asked.
Dunnet’s gaze met Abigail’s. That frown bothered her, just like that fire bothered her. And all of it was mixed up in the loss of Jeremiah. She had relied on him since her husband died, and she was having trouble thinking straight.
“You have problems with any particular Lost Causers?” Dunnet asked her.
“We have trouble with all of them,” Titus said.
Abigail placed her hand gently on his arm. “The Adairs,” she said. “They still think this property belongs to them.”
“You don’t think it was them, though,” Dunnet said. “Why not?”
“Of course it was them,” Titus snapped. “Why else kill Jeremiah? He kept kicking them off the property. They’d tried to take him once before—”
Abigail tightened her grip on her son’s arm, stopping him. She hated it when he talked over her.
“The Adairs have threatened all of us,” she said to Dunnet. “But they would never set a fire that could burn the great house. Or the gardens.”
She glanced at Titus whose mouth had become a thin line.
“In fact,” she said, “they threatened to kill everyone who removed plants along the lawn when we redid the gardens ten years ago now. They said we were ruining ‘River Bend’s heritage.’”
She gave a sarcastic emphasis to Lockwood Hall’s old name and history.
“It was them, Mama,” Titus said. “Who else would it be?”
“I don’t know,” she said, feeling more than a little off-balance. “But I don’t think it’s our job to find out.”
SevenSomehow Martin had commandeered an actual automobile. Kate had tied a hat around her head to keep her hair from flying everywhere. The Abbott-Detroit, as the driver called it, had a roof, but there was no glass in the side windows, so the breeze flowing through the carriage was formidable. She had to keep a hand on top of her hat, just to keep it from peeling off the top of her head.
Martin’s hair wisped around his skull, making him look like he had just awakened. She could only see it from the back, since he had opted to sit up front with the driver. She hadn’t caught the driver’s name, which was unusual for her. One of her great skills as a politician was hearing names once and remembering them.
But she had been greatly distracted today, trying to figure out what her next move would be.
She had finally decided to let compassion guide her first, and then she would decide, after she had spoken to Abigail Lockwood.
They had met nearly fifteen years before, after Reconstruction formally ended. The Democrats had started to regain footholds in the South, with some former Confederates heading home from the West, hoping to rebuild. Abigail had started a grassroots organization that funded Republican candidates, those who supported the tenets of Reconstruction—free public education for all, ease of land ownership, and continued punishment for anyone who espoused the treasonous ideas of the former Confederate States.
Kate had come in as a young politician, still on the rise in the Illinois legislature. Even though Abigail hadn’t mandated it, her organization benefitted women the most, primarily because women had been slow at building national coalitions.
Kate had helped her build a branch in Illinois. They had worked on other projects once Kate got into Congress, but Kate had never directly gone to Abigail for help before.
And now, Abigail was the one who needed help.
The trip to Abigail’s home—one of the biggest holdings in the entire state of South Carolina—had taken less than fifteen minutes, even though the former plantation was a good ten or more miles outside of town.
The automobile turned onto a wide lane, sunlight barely filtering through the canopy formed by gigantic limbs of old trees covered in moss. The road was stately and beautiful, but the air here smelled so strongly of smoke that Kate’s eyes watered.
She half feared what she would see as they bumped across ruts to get to the main entrance, even though she had been assured that the great house had not burned down.
The great house was too small a phrase for what greeted her. The columned mansion, with a front portico that looked like it belonged on one of the stately palaces of Europe rather than a home in the middle of the Carolina countryside. Kate had read about such homes, but had never seen one. Built before the war, of course, by white Southern planters with delusions of grandeur, most of these old buildings had been torn down or carved into apartment-style dwellings for multiple owners who had sub-divided the land.
Very few had remained intact, although more in the Carolinas than almost anywhere else. Here, the reclamation laws had started early, and the prices were low enough that former slaves could buy their old masters’ dwellings for a pittance. Most knew how to work the land, make it profitable, and keep the houses running—and apparently, Abigail’s family had counted itself in that number.
The automobile stopped near the stone steps that led to the double doorway made of wood painted white just like the house itself. Only sides of the house were covered in soot, probably from the morning’s fire.
Kate got out of the automobile, and sneezed once at the strong smoke smell. Other vehicles were parked along the side of the road, and a few horses were tied to a rail several yards away. She wasn’t the only visitor.
Martin got out, and accompanied her up the stairs. He grabbed the door knocker, a gigantic L carved out of brass, and tapped it twice.
No one answered. He did so again, the sound echoing in the odd stillness of the morning. Not even birds chirped. She had expected more noise after all of the events that had occurred here, but she had been wrong.
Kate was about to give up and see if she could roust someone from the back of the property when the door opened. A tall broad-shouldered man stood before them. He wore denims and a work shirt covered with soot. He looked exhausted.
He was one of Abigail’s sons, but for the life of her, Kate could not remember which one.
“Miss Wells,” he said. “We weren’t expecting you.”
Sons of the South, always formal.
“I’m sorry to intrude,” she said. “I was hoping to speak to your mother.”
He nodded, and swept her and Martin into the large front parlor with its heavy furniture, and oppressive stench of smoke. Only after he left them alone, did Kate realize she should have commiserated with him about the losses. But she hadn’t. She was out of her depth on something like this.
He returned not five minutes later.
“Come with me,” he said.
As she followed him, Kate saw no opportunity to commiserate. He was all business, leading her and Martin quickly through the hall that went past the public rooms of the house. Kate had a sense of expensive and old furniture, a variety of antiques and heirlooms.
He led them into a stunning wide room with high ceilings and wicker furniture covered with orange and white cushions, matching the white rugs and the sheer white curtains that were pulled away from the eight-foot-tall windows overlooking the back of the house. Through them, Kate could see Abigail talking with a burly man whose bald head glistened in the sun. He was wearing some kind of uniform.
Abigail’s son opened double doors that Kate had initially thought were windows, then stood back.
“She’s out there,” he said.
Kate thanked him as she walked by, Martin trailing her. She expected Abigail’s son to follow, but he didn’t. He pulled the doors closed and remained inside.
That thought made Kate realize she hadn’t seen any staff at all. One of the selling points of holding the rally here, Abigail had said, was because her staff was used to putting on large functions.
Was the staff gone? Had they not shown up this morning?
But the questions fled as Abigail turned toward Kate. Abigail, usually the most beautifully dressed woman Kate had ever seen, wore a muslin gown that was faded and loose. Her eyes were red-rimmed, and she had a black smudge along her neck and arms. Her hair, still in its night braid, was pulled loose along the back and sides.
She looked heartbroken and exhausted.
Kate extended her hands, and Abigail took them, clutched them, really. Then, without thinking about it, Kate pulled her into a hug.
Abigail clung to her, and Kate held her tightly. Over Abigail’s shoulder, Kate could see Martin’s reflection in the window glass. He looked stunned. Kate was not a person who hugged easily. She rarely shook hands with anyone, a habit he wanted her to change.
Then her gaze moved from his reflection to the lawn. The grounds were blackened by fire, and coated with mud. Broken poles stood at odd angles. The remains of chairs tilted sideways, and the stage where she would have spoken that night was charred gray, as if it were a ghost of itself.
Licks of black went down the lawn, and some of the trees in the garden beyond were half-blackened. The air stank of smoke here, but also had a thick wetness, as if the water used to curtail the flames still coated everything.
Finally, Abigail stepped out of the hug, and gave her a half-apologetic smile. “We clearly can’t hold the rally.”
“That’s not why I’m here,” Kate said. “I’m here to provide whatever you need.”
She meant it too, although she wasn’t sure exactly what she could do.
“I was supposed to say that to you.” Abigail grimaced, and Kate realized she was holding back tears. The man she had been talking to looked surprised. Apparently, everyone was used to the Abigail who took care of others, who seemed impervious to anything thrown her way.
“Well, things change,” Kate said, surveying the lawn. They were lucky the fire had not spread.
Then, since no one had bothered to introduce the bald man, she leaned forward and extended a hand.
“Kate Wells,” she said.
“Dunnet Brewster,” he said. “I’m the sheriff here.”
He was watching her as if she were something strange and new. Maybe she was—a Northern white woman who had barged her way into what was clearly a family scene.
“Do you have any idea who could have done this?” she asked, partly because she didn’t like the way he was looking at her.
“Not yet,” he said. Then he looked at Abigail. “I thought you had the pavilion up for a family event.”
“No,” Abigail said. “Kate is on a speaking tour.”
The sheriff frowned, clearly confused. “A lyceum tour?”
Kate bit back a sharp retort. So many had wanted her to go on a lyceum tour instead of a political one. But she didn’t want to see the masses, not yet. She wanted to talk to Republicans and power brokers. A new kind of tour, really, and Abigail had agreed with it, before all of this.
“No,” Abigail said. “She was to speak to local officials and members of the party.”
“The Republican party?” he clarified.
Abigail nodded. “You should have gotten an invitation.”
He shrugged. “I don’t go to political gatherings if I don’t have to.”
And that, Kate would have said had they been having a normal discussion, was why so many local political office holders never rose in the ranks.
But he had turned slightly, his back half toward her, so that he could see the mess on the lawn.
“Speaking tour,” he repeated. “What are you speaking about, Mrs. Wells?”
The assumption of marriage. She had long since stopped correcting anyone who made it, although it still annoyed her. Why did the language designate whether or not a woman was married, but not do so with a man?
Martin spoke before Kate could answer. “Miss Wells has started a presidential bid. I’m surprised you haven’t heard of it. She is the first female who actually has a good shot at becoming the Republican party nominee.”
The sheriff raised his eyebrows. “You believe the power brokers at the convention will choose you?”
Something in his tone made it clear that he thought she had no hope whatsoever. But Kate was used to doubters.
“That’s why I’m on the tour,” she said.
“And she has a good shot?” He directed this question at Abigail, not at Martin or Kate.
“She does.” Abigail sounded tired. “The field is wide open right now, and it will take someone organized, with political savvy and financial resources, to win over the brokers.”
“A good shot,” the sheriff repeated. “How very unusual.”
Kate felt a thread of irritation. She had come here to talk to Abigail, not argue her political prospects with a local sheriff.
Then Kate looked at Abigail. She seemed alive for the first time since Kate had arrived.
“You think this is about Kate,” Abigail said to the sheriff, surprising Kate.
“Don’t you?” he asked.
EightKate looked confused, but Abigail wasn’t. She felt strong for the first time that day.
The idea that the fire was set to stop Kate was the first thing that made any sense. Not the Lost Causers, who truly did not care (at this point) who the presidential nominees were, but others—and Abigail had run into dozens of them—who believed that women did not belong in public office.
Kate was the first with a chance at the brass ring. She probably wouldn’t win the nomination, but if this tour was successful, she would have enough support to become the vice presidential nominee. And she would bring Illinois with her, along with all of its money and influence.
“I’ll have Rufus give you a list of names who have disparaged this meeting,” Abigail said to Dunnet. “And I will find a site for the rally tonight.”
“No,” Kate said. “You have more than enough to do. We will call off the rally—”
“That is what they want,” Abigail said.
“Forgive me, Mrs. Lockwood,” Dunnet said, “but you don’t know that.”
Her gaze narrowed. “Oh, but I do. It explains everything.”
“Even Jeremiah’s death?”
She paused, thought about it for a moment, and then nodded. “Yes, especially that.”
Kate took a step forward. “I hadn’t realized that someone had died. Abigail—”
“It means,” Abigail said, deliberately interrupting Kate, “that whoever did this knew the fire wouldn’t be enough to stop me. So they tried to make certain the fire would harm the property, maybe even the house, and if it didn’t, they figured I would be incapacitated by the loss of Jeremiah.”
And to think she had nearly played into their hands.
“I don’t think finding a new venue is wise,” Dunnet said.
“It’s not your decision,” Abigail said.
He opened his mouth, but she held up a hand, stopping him.
“I can tell you this, however,” she said. “We were wrong. Lost Causers set the fire, and shot Jeremiah. It just wasn’t the Adairs, or anyone close to them. You’ll be looking for someone close to the local Democrats. Not someone who hates me.”
Dunnet glanced at Kate, as if he expected her to step up and stop Abigail from making this decision. Kate just watched politely, as her assistant shifted behind her.
“And,” Abigail added, “one last thing. The person you’re looking for knows me well. They would know that losing the pavilion wouldn’t stop this rally, but losing Jeremiah would.”
“You have someone in mind,” Dunnet said.
“I have several someones,” Abigail said. “I’ll give their names to you tomorrow. That way, we’ll see if your investigation takes you to them naturally.”
Dunnet’s eyes narrowed. “I thought you trusted me, Abigail.”
“Oh, I do,” she said. “I also trust that I can be wrong. So this will be a kind of insurance.”
“If I may,” Kate said, and Abigail braced herself for Kate to back out of the rally after all. “In my experience, people who make these kinds of threats—people who actually act upon them—are not happy with failure. They will try again.”
“Ma’am,” Dunnet said. “My experience—”
“Miss Wells is a lawyer who prosecuted all sorts of criminals in Illinois before embarking on her political career,” her assistant said somewhat primly.
“Not to mention she has a point,” Abigail snapped. “Haven’t you read how many times John Wilkes Booth tried to get close to President Lincoln before succeeding?”
“No, ma’am,” Dunnet said stiffly. “That case is a bit before my time.”
So Abigail had hurt his feelings by questioning his abilities. Too bad. She needed him to do her bidding, not the other way around.
“I will let you know where we will hold the rally,” she said. “I suggest you have some operatives there, in disguise, looking for Lost Causers lurking outside.”
Dunnet stared at her for a moment. He appeared to be wrestling with himself, then he turned to Kate.
“You do realize, ma’am, that if you are correct, your life could be in danger.”
She smiled at him, but her eyes were sad. “Unfortunately, Sheriff, we live in a volatile nation. These days, my life is in danger whenever I step on a stage. And I am not alone. I’m sure Mr. DuBois and Mr. Roosevelt have similar thoughts when they step on a stage as well.”
“You should hire guards, ma’am,” Dunnet said.
Her smile widened. “What makes you think I haven’t?” she asked.
NineThe city’s Lyceum Theater was a larger venue than Kate had planned on. The stage was a proscenium arch that overlooked the patrons, rather than one that would allow her to see their faces. But she couldn’t very well say no to the venue. Abigail had gone to great personal trouble to secure it, on this very difficult day, and Kate would make the best of it.
She had handled the rest—or rather, Milton had. He had notified the other speakers of the change of venue, and had sent a dozen different people to inform ticket holders that the rally would be held downtown rather than at Lockwood Hall.
It had taken some time to make the change—everyone wanted to gossip about the fire—but it looked like the evening might happen after all. Kate needed to change into her speaker’s clothing—she had a trim blue dress light enough to handle a place that would become hot and stuffy despite its size.
She wasn’t sure if she wanted to keep her speech short, or if she wanted to give the speech she had initially intended.
Abigail had done much to guarantee that this would happen, so Kate needed to guarantee that this effort would not be in vain.
That meant she would have to garner press coverage somehow.
She just wasn’t sure how.
TenThe intersection of Democrats, Lost Causers, and Abigail Lockwood was a small one indeed. Even with the lists that Rufus Lockwood had written for him, Dunnet did not have a wealth of suspects. Most were too stupid to execute such a plan or had no interest in politics at all.
If he ruled out the Lost Causers who were related to the Adairs of River’s Bend Plantation, then he had an even smaller list.
It all came down to one name: Joe Davis, the former sheriff.
And somehow, Abigail had known that. And she had known Dunnet wouldn’t have believed her if he hadn’t done some of the legwork himself.
But now, he didn’t know what to do. Because approaching his predecessor was difficult enough without this large an accusation attached.
Dunnet had decided to wait until the speechifying was over before he made any move. Part of him hoped that nothing would happen this night, and he would be able to take his time investigating the fire and the murder.
But part of him knew that it would end here, no matter what.
The Lyceum Theater took up one entire city block. It had a lot of smaller rooms, but somehow Abigail had commandeered the theater itself. It probably helped that she was on the Lyceum committee, and had donated a lot of money for theater renovation.
The ticket holders barely filled the front section of the auditorium. What would have looked like a large gathering on the lawn at Lockwood Hall looked like a tiny meeting here.
Everyone was dressed well, and most seemed unconcerned about the change of location. The Lockwoods had come, but did not stay. Abigail Lockwood had simply thanked everyone for being so flexible. The applause greeting her words had been raucous, proving once again how loved she was in this community, but she hadn’t wanted to hear it. She had smiled (through tears, he thought) and waved at the crowd, before vanishing into the back.
The other speakers sat on stage. Everyone from the current governor to several former governors, all Republican, and the most respected man in respectable South Carolina politics, Robert Smalls.
Smalls, who had held every conceivable office here, was still a United States Senator (and probably would be until he died). Some say his theft of the CSS Planter changed the tide of the war in South Carolina. In one night, he had stolen a Confederate vessel and taken his knowledge of where the mines were planted in Charleston Harbor to the Union, saving thousands of lives.
Yet once Dunnet had heard Davis derisively call Smalls “The Boat Thief,” as if the great man were nothing more than a common criminal.
Smalls had grown round with time and good food, but Dunnet would not want to tangle with him. Smalls sat next to Kate Wells, patting her hand once or twice as they were immersed in deep conversation.
Smalls had once said he would never endorse political candidates, so his appearance here was some kind of coup.
Dunnet used all of the speechifying to pace around the auditorium. He had officers outside, some in disguise, but so far he had heard nothing.
Then, just as Smalls rose to speak, a door opened on the second tier of seats. Joe Davis waited there for just a moment before slipping inside the auditorium.
He was a big man, with the kind of white skin that turned red in the sun. He wore a black suit that looked too heavy for the weather. He didn’t sit down, but instead tugged his coat nervously.
Dunnet felt his heart sink. He hadn’t wanted the conclusions to be right. He hadn’t liked Davis, but Dunnet didn’t want to think that someone who wore the same badge he now wore could go so easily to the wrong side of the law.
Not that men like Davis saw what he was about to do as “the wrong side of the law.” Dunnet had arrested enough Lost Causers to know that the mixture of people on that stage was an affront to all the Lost Causers believed in.
The white men, talking with the black men as the colleagues they were, had to grate as well. Not to mention the entire event being arranged by a black woman to benefit a white woman who easily sat side by side with a man like Robert Smalls.
Dunnet slipped behind the seats, going around the back, keeping his gaze on Davis. Dunnet took his Tower cuffs off his tool belt and held them in his left hand. He didn’t want to pull a gun. Someone might notice. But they wouldn’t notice the handcuffs.
Davis didn’t even look at him. Davis was working his way toward the front, tugging on his coat in a way that Dunnet didn’t like.
Dunnet moved quietly, approaching Davis from the back.
Smalls finished his introduction, and as the applause rose to greet Kate Wells, Dunnet stepped beside Davis.
Dunnet grabbed Davis’s right arm.
“Come with me,” Dunnet said, loudly enough that Davis could hear him. No one else seemed to as the applause continued.
“You need my help, Sheriff?” Davis asked. He clearly didn’t know why Dunnet had grabbed him.
“Outside,” Dunnet said, not quite willing to lie, although it might’ve been easier.
“I’d like to hear the little lady, if you don’t mind,” Davis said.
“I do mind,” Dunnet said.
Davis’s gaze was flat. He looked at the stage, where Kate Wells stood, in front of the podium, not behind it, comfortable in her early thank-yous to all of the dignitaries who had come out to support her.
“Don’t get in the way, Dunnet,” Davis said.
“I’m not going to,” Dunnet said, using a maneuver he had practiced a hundred times. He yanked Davis’s right hand back, grabbing the elbow of the left, pulling it downward. It took a single quick movement to attach the Tower cuffs to Davis’s wrists.
Davis’s eyes narrowed. “I haven’t done anything.”
“Not here you haven’t,” Dunnet said. “Not yet.”
But he had seen Davis’s coat swing open, seen the pistols riding on his hips. Many men carried guns in this town, but most did not carry two at the same time.
“I’d like to know what you’re accusing me of,” Davis said.
Looking backwards, Dunnet wanted to say, but did not. Instead, he said, “You’ll find out soon enough.”
Then he pulled Davis by the arms, leading him to the very door he’d entered from, and out of the building, glad to be free of the speechifying, but sorry too, on one level, because he wanted to hear what a woman like Kate Wells thought she could offer that the men could not.
ElevenKate watched the sheriff arrest a man she had never seen before in the very back of the auditorium. The lights had remained up at her request, not because she was paranoid, but because she had wanted to see how her words would affect the audience before her.
She had been speaking about the murder and fire at Lockwood Hall, about the fund she was establishing for the family of the man who died, as the sheriff led someone out of the auditorium.
She waited until they were gone, before pivoting to her speech. But as she did, she mentally tossed her prepared notes. She was going to speak from the heart, for better or worse.
She said, “In this generation, we all talk about what we are owed. My female colleagues believe women are owed a right to stand legitimately for higher office. My black colleagues believe they are owed a president from their ranks, as do so many of my white Republican colleagues.”
The men behind her shifted on the stage. A few people in the audience looked down.
“But there is a dark side to this feeling of being owed. The families of former Confederates believe they are owed either land or reparations for the loss of their fortunes. They have never recovered from the war.”
The members of the press in the front row sat up, perhaps thinking that she was going to side with the Democrats. That would be true pandering, if she even implied that those who believed in the Lost Cause had a point.
Now that she had everyone’s attention, she leaned against the podium.
“The war ended before I was born,” she said. “Before many of you were born. We lost a president, then tried, impeached, and found the next guilty of high crimes and misdemeanors. We survived decades of turmoil.”
No one moved, except her. She stood upright, raising her voice even more.
“Through courage and strong leadership,” she said, “we have built a new world, one in which all people are not only created equal but have the same equal opportunities under the law. Strangely we do not celebrate this. Nor do we look at each other as equals. We see black and brown and white, male and female, Democrats and Republicans, rather than those with the best vision for the future, the best vision for our multicolored nation.”
Normally, she would have launched into her vision here, but she did not. Not yet.
“The events of last night, against one of the city’s most prominent families, come out of that sense of entitlement the Lost Causers have. Over the years, we have repeatedly suffered at the hands of those Lost Causers. But the Lost Causers do not rule us. Thank heavens.”
A few heads nodded.
She spoke to them.
“Because,” she said, “imagine if they were still in power. Imagine what would have happened if the Lost Causers rose ascendant after the war, as it looked like they would for a moment. Imagine a world in which they continued to rule the South. Imagine where we would be now.”
People looked at each other. A few frowned.
“The Lost Causers have only the power we give them. And we have given them little. We should give them even less. What we should do is celebrate who we are as we move forward in this new century…”
TwelveAbigail Lockwood leaned against a pillar backstage, letting herself feel the exhaustion for the first time that day.
She had no idea if Kate Wells would impress the power brokers here in South Carolina. The speech was decidedly unusual, but so were the events of the day. And they were not Abigail’s concern, not for the next few weeks.
She needed to work with Jeremiah’s family, to plan his funeral and honor his life. She needed to soothe her sons and her staff and rehire those guards.
But she also needed to heed Kate Wells. No one could simply tolerate the presence of the Lost Causers among them anymore. When she was done with the grief and the healing, Abigail needed to work on changing the laws, perhaps reviving some of the Reconstruction-era laws that had caused so much consternation.
The ones that held that reverence for the Confederate cause was, in itself, treason. That meetings in which the Confederate flag was flown were not legal gatherings, but acts of terror.
It wasn’t enough to elect people like Dunnet or to financially support candidates like Kate Wells.
It was time to put the war in the past once and for all. Not to forget it, but to bury it, and all of its harmful aims.
Abigail ran a hand over her face. She was sad and a little terrified, but mostly, she was angry.
And, she had learned throughout her long life, that anger didn’t help anyone any more than feeling entitled did. What she needed to do was channel that anger into action.
The right kind of action.
The kind that built a better future, rather than tried to patch the problems of the past.
Mentally, she tipped her hat toward Kate Wells.
“Thank you, Kate,” Abigail said quietly, as she pushed herself upright.
She was going home, to the land that her family had worked for more than two hundred years, the land her family had owned for forty-three years.
The land had a lot of scars. The fire was just a new one. But the land was the source of her power. And she would use it.
She would use it all.
____________________________________________
“Politicians, Lost Causers, and Abigail Lockwood” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Politicians, Lost Causers, and Abigail LockwoodCopyright © 2021 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
First published in Alternate Peace, edited by Steven H. Silver and Joshua Palmieri, Zombies Need Brains Publishing, 2019
Published by WMG Publishing
Cover and Layout copyright © 2021 by WMG Publishing
Cover design by WMG Publishing
Cover art copyright © sepavone | Depositphotos
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
As many of you know, we lost our wonderful cat Cheeps in March. He was a heck of a personality, and the condo feels smaller without him. But his health had been uneven for years, and we finally had to let him move on.
He’s the first cat I’ve ever had who actually had fans. He had a Facebook following. During the pandemic, I decided to let him and Gavin help me with promotion. I started something I called Promotion Central, and said that the staff was the cats. I’d post pictures and then write something wry, and people liked it.
Mostly, though, they liked Cheeps. He was pretty. He also had kitty charisma. And somehow, his personality got through.
He was loud, he was demanding, and he was impossible to ignore. He also had an impish side and a sense of humor.
My two remaining cats, Gavin and Angel, do not have a sense of humor. Gavin is working very hard at filling Cheepy’s shoes (okay, he didn’t wear shoes, but you know what I mean). Angel is constantly worried about everything. She wants to do things right.
Cheeps couldn’t give a rat’s flying patootie about doing things right. He expected others to do for him. He was in charge. We all danced to his (rather loud) tune.
Shortly after he died, I wrote a short story inspired by the (extremely sad) trip to the crematorium to pick up his cremains. I dedicated the story to Cheeps. And…Dean bought the story for Pulphouse. The story’s in the current issue, which you can get if you click here.
But I also did something else, and it was a bit more subconscious.
I had to curate a Storybundle this summer. We had chosen the names of the bundles back in the spring. This one was a repeat of one we’d done before, only with new writers. It’s called Cattitude.
The title is so very Cheepy. But I swear I wasn’t thinking of Cheeps as I put it together—consciously anyway. I was thinking of him subconsciously.
You see, every Storybundle gives the buyer the opportunity to donate part of the fee to charity. I wanted a cat-related charity for this bundle, so I researched a bunch of them. I kept coming back to Best Friends Animal Society. Best Friends “is dedicated to ending the killing of dogs and cats in America’s shelters. To help Save Them All, Best Friends works with shelters, rescue groups and our members nationwide.”
Cheepy was not a shelter cat. (Gavin and Angel were.) But Cheeps was a rescue. We got him out of a severe hoarding situation. He was clearly abused. He was afraid of feet for years, especially if they were encased in black shoes. It took him forever to warm to us, although he was very affectionate with Gavin. In his last few years, Cheeps allowed cuddling…on his terms. He finally decided to spend time hovering near us, usually on the back of the couch or a chair when one of us sat in it.
When Dean got seriously injured a year ago, Cheeps became his best friend, doing a Cheepy cuddle of staying close. It took a lot of time and a lot of love, but he had gone from being scared of everything and everyone (human, that is) to running the household.
I think every cat should have that chance. (Every dog too.) That’s what was hovering in the back of my mind as I chose the charity.
I ended up writing about the charity in the promotional material for the Storybundle, rather than heavily promoting the authors—which might not have been the best sales tactic, because the writers are wonderful. The bundle includes ebooks from T. Thorn Coyle, Lisa Silverthorne, Christine Pope, and Anne Renwick. Ron Collins and Jeff Collins, Bonnie Elizabeth, Kari Kilgore, and Annie Reed contributed ebooks you can only find in this bundle. My contributions are one of my very favorite Kristine Grayson novels (featuring a kitten superhero—that is, a superhero who saves kittens) and a Year of the Cat volume, featuring stories from across several decades.
All about cats, of course. Great cats. Wonderful cats. Magic cats. Opinionated cats. Cats with moxy. Rescue cats. Shelter cats. Bookstore cats. Lots and lots of cats.
The bundle is time-limited, so it’ll disappear forever this week. You have to head over there now to get all this wonderful reading, which you can get as little as $25. So head on over, and get these wonderful books. I guarantee that you’ll enjoy each and every one of them.
May was when some crap hit the fan at WMG, and I found myself working 18 hours per day and getting very little sleep. Consequently, I didn’t read much in May. What I did read was in bits and pieces, spread out over the entire month. So I don’t have a lot to recommend here…but wait until you see June!
May, 2024Huston, Caitlin, “Fiction Forward,” The Hollywood Reporter, March 6, 2024. When someone tells you something is not possible or that it won’t sell or that no one is interested, think on this story. I can’t tell you how many people have told me over the years that fiction audio, especially podcasts, doesn’t get an audience. Yet the most-nominated podcast in this year’s Ambies was a fiction piece. If I say more, I’ll rival the word count of the piece I’m sending you to. So go take a look.
Macintyre, Ben, Rogue Heroes, Broadway Books, 2016. After reading The Mosquito Bowl, which I recommended in February, I found myself scanning my World War II books to find another interesting volume. I ended up reading Rogue Heroes, which was fascinating and cringeworthy at the same time. Macintyre does not flinch at some of the brutal depictions of his protagonists or of the war itself. I found the entire thing fascinating and deeply uncomfortable.
McQuiston, Casey, I Kissed Shara Wheeler, Wednesday Books, 2022. I think I owe an apology to Casey McQuiston for letting this book sit on my shelf for two years. I had an early edition of the book with a cover that screamed romance. I thought I knew what the book would be about, but wowza was I wrong. That’s how I’ve reacted to all of McQuiston’s books. I literally judge them by their covers and find them wanting. Then I read the books and I fall in love.
Shara Wheeler kisses our protagonist Chloe, her rival for valedictorian at Willowgrove Christian Academy, and then disappears. Just walks out of school and goes somewhere else. The mystery of Shara Wheeler’s disappearance, her behavior before she vanishes, and a few other fascinating pieces that I can’t tell you because Spoilers! is what made me read this book in a month in which I had no time.
Get this one. Share it with your friends.
Tringali, Anthony, and Cox, Stephen, “‘Over the Rainbow’ Under Suspicion,” The Hollywood Reporter, March 6, 2024. If there’s anything I’ve learned in my years of studying copyright, it’s that figuring out of music copyright has been stolen isn’t as easy as it looks. But it does look like Harold Arlen and Yip Harburg might have lifted most of the melody for “Over The Rainbow” from a Scandinavian composer named Signe Lunde. Whether or not the lifting was intentional is up for debate. Whether or not it matters depends on how the information is presented. Signe Lunde was a woman who was well known. She also became an active Nazi sympathizer. Those are just some of the fascinating twists in this article. I suggest you read it, and see what you think.
Weprin, Alex, “The AI Perils Buried in the Fine Print,” The Hollywood Reporter,* March 27, 2024. Fascinating analysis of all the conundrums buried in what we’re all calling AI. People are interested in using it, but aren’t sure how or why. Corporations are having similar dilemmas. Really worth the read. It’ll give you something to think about.
Dean and I just finished outlining the entire Mystery Novella class that we’re co-teaching. It’s based on the writers workshops that I have always wanted to do in person, but I think it would take at least two weeks, several hours per day, to teach one novella class.
Right now, that’s cost prohibitive here in Las Vegas. We’re working on making it affordable, and maybe within two years, we can do that.
But right now, we’re doing the novella classes online.
Novellas are my favorite form, and for me, novellas just happen. Twenty years ago, I used to cringe when my crime stories veered into novella territory. Back then, no publication took mystery novellas and the novels had to be at least 90,000 words. I managed to place a few of the shorter novellas in the digest magazines, but it was always tricky. Thank heavens for anthologies, because that was my only shot at the time.
Now, though, with indie publishing, there are many many many uses for novellas, mystery and otherwise.
I had a mystery novella in this past year’s Holiday Spectacular. “Catherine The Great,” which is about a very gifted defense attorney, won the Derringer Award for Novelette (in a tie with David Dean). You’ll be able to get a copy of that when we release the Holiday Spectacular Omnibus in a week or two. (We redid it, with a new cover and a properly edited interior.) I’ll let you know the moment the new version of the omnibus is available.)
I usually don’t sing my own praises, but I’m good at novellas.
The mystery novella class begins tomorrow, and you still have time to sign up. We’re taking signups through the week.
One other workshop starts tomorrow, and it is the one that I had to convince Dean to do. You see, Dean hates the phrase “writer’s block” because he believes it’s an excuse.
If you actually look at the term, though, it’s one of those umbrella phrases. Writer’s block means something different to each writer at different phases of their lives.
After I convinced Dean we needed to do this class, he asked me if there were enough forms of “writer’s block” to make a week-long workshop. So I had him ask folks on his blog, and the writers we know here in Vegas, and others as well. Within about two hours, we came up with fifty different things that writers had termed “writer’s block.” Each thing has a different solution. Some of those solutions are like the exhaustion one, above: Give it time. Others have easier solutions, like project block: assign it to your subconscious, then go work on something else.
We have the list, and we have the solutions, and wow, are we looking forward to this class. We’re calling it Writers Block Freedom because it provides solutions to the wide variety of symptoms for the problem we all call Writers Block.
And let me be clear here. Some of these so-called symptoms are more challenging than others. The solution isn’t go work on something else. It might be a restructuring of your viewpoint or a way of taking care of your health.
This class also starts tomorrow, and there’s a weekly webinar with the class, one we hope will bring writers together for solutions and pep talks.
Do long-term writers need this? Of course, I was glad we were planning this class, because I felt blocked this month, even though I’m not. I just had real-life priorities that got in the way of the writing, some things that would have forced me to take family leave from my day job if I had one. We all struggle with starting and stopping. That’s part of who we writers are.
Anyway, the link to this class is here. And again, you can sign up all week. In fact, you can sign up at any point, but you will miss several in-person webinars if you do that. So take a look.
By the way, the links I posted above take you directly to the classes, but you might want to poke around the WMG Writer Store all by itself. We’re adding things all the time. And if you went to the Anthology Workshop, you might recognize some of the t-shirt sayings.
I hope to keep you all posted on the various goings on these days, as the fall progresses. Not that it feels like fall here in Vegas. It feels like July. I hope that changes soon…
Laurel helps many people who return from the desert shaken by what they’ve seen—or think they’ve seen. But Mark seems different. He listens to her, and he makes her obsession with finding the strange silver objects—and discovering their secrets—his own.
But that obsession comes with a cost: one neither might want to pay.
“Spaceships In The Desert” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Spaceships In The DesertKristine Kathryn RuschLaurel ran down the steps of the post office, clutching two manila envelopes and half a dozen letters. Darkness had fallen even though it was only a few minutes past five. A light, chill drizzle coated the air. She felt rushed, although she had no reason. No one waited for her to come home except the cat, and the cat usually didn’t care when she got in as long as he was fed on time.
She hurried to the twelve-minute parking zone, unlocked the passenger door on her white Datsun, and put the mail inside. Then she crossed around the front of the car and stopped.
On top of Skinner Butte, a cross blazed against the darkness. She had never seen the cross before. Its blue-white light lit up the trees and cast shadows on the hillside below. Mark would have loved it.
But Mark was dead. She cross-watched alone.
She unlocked the driver’s door, got in, and drove off, never once looking back at the cross that stabbed the hillside with unearthly light.
The afternoon seemed like any afternoon, even later, when she tried to find the differences. Gus, Big Harry and three others sat in a corner booth and pounded on the table when they ran out of coffee. She marveled at the men, the way they could drink steaming liquid and not seem to get hotter. She drank ice water and sweat still tickled her back.
The sound of the jeep pulling into the gravel driveway stopped all conversation. And when the tall young man walked in the door, Laurel could tell he had seen something strange. He was slender, almost reedy. His thighs below his rumpled shorts were badly sunburned, although he hadn’t realized it yet, and so were his arms and face. His angle-cut brown hair was a week’s growth away from losing its style, and his sweat-stained shirt looked new. But it was his eyes that caught her. They had a faraway frightened and entranced expression that she was beginning to recognize.
She set a glass of lukewarm water down on the counter. “Drink it slow,” she said.
He swayed as he picked up the glass. His fingers were long and thin, without calluses. “Needs ice.”
Laurel shook her head. “Just drink it. You can have one with ice in a minute.”
He finished the water in two gulps, then wiped his mouth with the back of his hands. His fingers were already shaking. He had gotten far too much sun. He would be staying there longer than he realized. He put the glass down. “Ice this time.”
She put a small scoop of ice in his glass, then added warm water. The last thing he needed was stomach cramps. “You saw them, didn’t you?”
His eyes got wide and, for a minute, she thought he was going to be sick already.
“Jesus, Laurel,” Gus said. “You gotta ask ’em that every time?”
The young man frowned. His water glass was already empty. “What are they?” he asked.
“Them tall cool silver things sitting in the sage brush?”
The young man nodded, then clutched the counter for support.
“Spaceships,” Gus said reasonably. “Spaceships in the desert.”
Gus said that every time, and the reaction was always the same. The stranger would always turn away, always refuse to talk to her, as if she had been making fun too.
But this young man ignored Gus and turned back to Laurel. “Why did you ask if I saw them?”
“Because,” she said. “You had the look.”
He held out his glass, and his warm arm was shaking badly. She took the glass out of his hand, then scurried around the counter. He tried to stand up, but lost his balance and would have fallen if Big Harry hadn’t grabbed his arms. Harry picked up the young man and carried him into the back room.
“Want me to call the doctor, Ma’am?” he asked.
“No,” she said, opening her medical kit. “I think I know what to do by now.”
She lived at the base of Skinner Butte in a big, rambling house that someone had placed on the register of historic places, but had then neglected to record the history. Her apartment on the second floor had a spectacular view of the city and, off in the distance, the Cascades and the Three Sisters. She had no real use for Oregon’s tree- and snow-covered mountains, although she found them pretty. She was a flatlander, born and bred in the Midwest, who had fallen in love with the deserts of the Southwest. But she had come to accept her life here, with its solitude and quiet, uneventful days.
The cat dozed on the windowsill, occasionally opening an eye to gaze at the mountains. To him, they represented a wild place, a place where, if he had been born five sizes larger, he would live and hunt and be free. She ran her fingers through his black fur and he gave a soft purr.
Then she set the envelopes down, pulled off her coat, and hurried to the bedroom. There, through the window, she could see the cold light of the cross creeping down the hillside, looking for something, looking for her.
Water, salt, lotion and shade. When Laurel treated those people, her back room smelled like calamine. She would hear their secrets, people talking because they were lonely, because, for the first time in years, someone was taking care of them. And then they would heal, and they would realize what they had said. Their smiles would become rigid and they would leave, quickly, as if she had embarrassed them.
This young man was different. His sunburn wasn’t as bad as she had originally thought and he wasn’t as dehydrated. He took the salt tablets she gave him wordlessly, as if he knew what they were, and he put the lotion on himself. Then he slept for nearly forty-eight hours, waking only for meals and to go to the bathroom.
“Finally found yourself one, eh, Laurel?” Gus asked on the middle of the second day.
“He’s still sick, Gus.” She wiped the counter with an old towel. Its sour smell rose up and twisted the inside of her nose.
Big Harry and Gus glanced at each other. “Sure, honey,” Big Harry said. “But if I was you, I’d move that big fancy jeep of his before someone takes it for parts.”
She glanced out the window. His jeep sat there, gathering dust from the driveway and the underused highway. If she walked out there now and tried the door, she would burn her fingers. “I think it’ll be safe enough,” she said.
On the third day, he woke up near dusk, his eyes clear and his expression bright. “I had the strangest dream,” he said. “Tall, cool, silver things in the desert, calling to me.”
“It wasn’t a dream.” Laurel handed him his dinner—a thick cheeseburger on an equally thick bun, homemade fries and milk. He looked at it as if he hadn’t seen food for days.
“You telling me it’s real?” he asked.
Laurel set the tray down and stole a fry for herself. “I don’t know if it’s real or not,” she said. “I just know that it’s there.”
She sat at the dining room table and opened her mail. Pictures fell out, sliding across the polished wood surface, and glaring at her with reproduced accusing eyes. She knew what the letters would say: Find him; Heal me; Please, in the name of Jesus, save her. Wadded bills and checks were taped to the hand-scrawled letters. She set them all aside to return later and opened the final envelope.
Another check, this one from Sylvie, the next installment on the café. No note, no letter. Just the agreed-upon sum. Laurel pocketed that check and sighed.
His name was Mark and he was on his way home to Oregon. He had lived in Southern California for three years “drinking too much,” he said, “to shut off his brain.” She guessed, from his deep tan and muscular body, that he had been some kind of athlete, but he never told and she never asked. He was young, maybe twenty-five, but she could ignore that if she didn’t concentrate on his wrinkle-free skin.
She too said very little about herself. She told him she was forty, a truth she usually told no one. She told him about buying the café, but didn’t tell him why she had chosen a site fifty miles from nowhere, her only customers scared tourists unused to long stretches of barren highway and the regulars who drove truck or lived on tiny, unprofitable ranches on the little dirt roads leading off into the sagebrush.
They had had their conversations in the whipping wind, talking rapidly lest the dust thicken their tongues as they bounced along those same dirt roads in Mark’s jeep. He was determined to find the tall, cool, silver things—Gus’s spaceships—even though she had tried to talk him out of it.
“They don’t appear to people who look for them,” she said that first day. The sun was going down, but the heat still shimmered along the desert.
Mark covered both seats with towels, then got into the jeep. “I don’t care,” he said. “I’m going to find them.”
Laurel threw one last look at the café. She had left Sylvie in charge. Not much had happened at twilight. The regulars went home to their wives and the tourists found a roadside motel to protect them from the eeriness of the desert at night. Sylvie could handle the occasional customer—and the quiet.
Laurel got into the jeep. She could feel the heat radiating from the plastic, through the terry cloth, through the denim of her jeans. “They never appear at night,” she said.
“Don’t worry,” he said. “We’ll find them.”
And he drove. Every night for two weeks, they drove. Laurel saw parts of the desert she had never seen before; hill after hill, scrabbled cactus, and the drifting, inevitable sagebrush. Once they found a skull. Laurel thought it belonged to a coyote, but Mark was certain it had belonged to something different.
Then, one night, he stopped the jeep. The desert stretched for miles around them, offering nothing but sand and scrub dusted by moonlight. It was cold. Mark reached in back and brought out a woven Indian blanket. He wrapped it around them, as if they were sharing a bench at a football game, then reached beside the driver’s seat and pulled out a thermos and two thermal cups. He poured steaming coffee, thick with cream, just as she liked it, and handed her a cup. He poured another cup for himself. She waited, knowing that this was something important.
“Why do you come with me?” He stared straight ahead as he asked the question, almost as if he were speaking to the desert itself.
The stars were deep, bright pinpoints of light against the black sky. Laurel took a sip of her coffee. It burned her tongue. She had been driving all those years ago, just driving to—how could she put it?—escape. Then she decided she couldn’t say anything about that, and simply said, “I saw them. Twice. The first time, it was mid-afternoon and I was driving down from Idaho. And there they were, tall and silver and cool.”
Like a mirage that wasn’t a mirage. She knew that if she walked over to them and touched their sides, her hands would freeze to the metal like they used to when she licked them and touched her slide in the middle of winter. The spaceships sang to her, and the singing lulled her, rocked her gently, until the conscious part of her mind reminded her that she was in a desert, in the sun, in the heat, and somehow the convertible had found its way to the café and coolness.
“The second time, I was looking for them, only I pretended I wasn’t. I saw them out of the corner of my eye, standing like sentinels guarding the entrance to a secret fortress. This time I decided I would touch them. I got out of the car and they disappeared. Shimmered once and then completely disappeared.”
She smiled at the memory, as real as if it had happened that morning. “I would have thought they were a dream-vision if it weren’t for all the other people who have seen them too. Even Gus has seen them, although he won’t admit it.”
Mark nodded, finished his coffee, and capped the thermos. He put his hand on hers as if to thank her. They sat like that for over an hour, listening to an occasional howl from a distant coyote and letting the mystery of the desert envelope them like a hidden lover.
She listened to the news as she cooked dinner. The latest hijacking, the newest scandal, meant no more to her than she meant to the cat. He rubbed on her legs for attention sometimes, but that was only because he wanted food. She rubbed against newsprint, thumbed the radio dial, but that was only because she wanted entertainment, because she wanted company.
She took her meal—Spanish rice, tortilla chips, and refried beans—and sat at the dining room table. The envelopes bearing their hopeful letters reproached her. If she were a different woman she would take the money, touch the pictures, see if she could find the missing, comfort the bereaved. But she was not a different woman. She enjoyed her privacy as she had once enjoyed her powerlessness—only now, she recognized that she had privacy. She never realized that she was powerless until powerlessness was gone.
They had been working their way around in a circle and finally, they had reached the beginning again. Mark took her out that night anyway, on a road they had traveled before. There were no tire tracks, no tall, cool, silver things, nothing to prove they had been this way before, just their memories and the map they had been charting their route on. Twenty miles down the road, Mark stopped the jeep.
“Look,” he said, and pointed to the top of a hillside. A cross, illuminated by tiny floods at its base, beamed its message to an empty landscape. “You ever go cross-watching?”
She shook her head.
“I do,” he said and laughed in the way that people do when they reveal something potentially embarrassing. “Sometimes I think that those crosses are put there by aliens to signal each other. Hiding behind the tenets of a human religion. By placing the crosses a certain way, they send messages to each other and we look at the crosses and wonder who would place them so high and far away, always thinking that the ‘who’ is human.”
“But you don’t believe that,” she said not as a question, because his tone, so matter-of-fact, told her that, indeed, he did not. He was merely saying something preposterous to protect himself against her reaction to his real belief.
“And then I think maybe the people—the humans—who put up crosses and those ‘washed in the blood of the lamb’ signs are the real aliens. Human beings aren’t that fanatic. We’re complex beings with scattered interests, not obsessed with one thing to the exclusion of everything else.”
We’re obsessed, she thought, but said nothing because this time he was open to her, expressing something he truly thought.
“And then I think about the people those cross-bearers follow, the TV-preachers and the tabloid-psychics, people who take the money from their impoverished fellows and tell them to erect crosses on hillsides so that their prayers will be answered. And I wonder what is alien and what is normal.” He ran his hand through his hair, grown out now and almost ill-kempt.
“And that’s why you’re searching.”
“Maybe,” he said.
She took out her yellow legal pad and began answering the letters she had piled on her table. Perhaps, when she had the money, she would buy a computer so that the letter she wrote wouldn’t have to be copied from memory night after night. Dear so-and-so, I’m sorry that I cannot help you. While it is true I have certain powers, I choose not to use them for money . . .
She remembered the first time she had, the only time she had, shortly after the tabloids printed their first article on the Nevada Café Owner’s Amazing Powers, after she had learned how to use the gift she had received when Mark died. She had helped an old woman track her son, a vet lost, supposedly, to the Viet Cong. He was living in the United States, with a Vietnamese wife and two children. He hadn’t contacted his mother because he knew that she would never understand. To her, he believed, it was better that he appear lost or dead than married to an Asian woman. He had been right.
Ink smudges marred the side of her right hand and her fingers cramped. The cat lay in his perch at the window, but didn’t look at the mountains. He was watching the light of the cross creep slowly over the house and down the lawn.
Places had certain resonances, she thought when he stopped the jeep nights later at the same spot they had drank coffee and talked. They had said no more of crosses, but she had begun to notice them, sticking like white spikes in the hillsides, little messages from alien gods.
Mark grabbed the blanket from the back and got out of the jeep. “Come on,” he said. She wondered if he was trying to conjure up the spaceships with a more personal heat than the desert provided.
He spread the blanket on a bare patch of ground beneath a small knoll and extended his hand to her.
“Creatures live in the sand,” she said.
“I’ll make you forget them,” he said. And with his twenty-five-year-old body, he did.
He did.
Sometimes she wished she could go back to being the woman she had been before Mark. She remembered escaping the failed marriage, the failed career, finding the desert, the spaceships and the café like she remembered stories other people had told about their own lives. Somewhere she had lost her connection, her ability to believe. Everything was real. She could imagine nothing any more. Even the cat’s fantasies were more interesting than the workings of her own mind. Cat fantasies, which she could touch because they lived together, without even touching the cat.
The cross worried her.
She hadn’t seen crosses since Mark died. She used to tell herself that was because she wasn’t looking any more. But that was wrong. Maybe it was like searching for the spaceships. Maybe she was looking too hard.
She pushed aside the last letter, grabbed her coat and keys and stepped outside without saying goodbye to the cat. Down the hill, she could see the bustle of shoppers crossing the street, their arms laden with packages.
She wondered what they believed in and then decided that it didn’t matter.
The cross seemed to have grown. It loomed large against the hillside, its white light ending unnaturally, only a few inches from her feet.
Is she stepped from the sidewalk onto the illuminated grass, would she lose her power? Would the light speak to her? Change her? Or would she be the same? A middle-aged woman living out a young man’s half-articulated dream, a dream he had abandoned in her desert nearly five years ago.
She stared up at the cross and it seemed to be staring back, waiting.
It was dawn when they got off the blanket, tired, sand-covered, and tingly. Laurel brushed off her clothes as Mark shook the sand from the weave. He put the blanket in the back of the jeep, then grabbed her arm.
“Stare straight ahead,” he said.
She did. And there they were, off to the left, tall, cool and silver, like rocket ships from 1950s pulps, only blurring somehow, perhaps because she wasn’t looking at them directly, but through the corner of her eye.
“I want to touch them,” he said.
But you just touched me, she wanted to say, although she said nothing. He wasn’t hers to hold.
“Come with me.”
She watched them shimmer as the sun’s rays grew warmer. Whose dream were they? Hers or his? She had discovered them first, but he had searched, methodically, painstakingly, until he found them.
“Laurel?”
She didn’t move. He stood beside her for a moment, but only for a moment, then hurried in the direction of the spaceships, never looking at them, always studying the ground, but she knew he could see them at the edges of his vision. When he seemed halfway there, she turned and watched him, careful not to stare directly at the silver coolness.
Finally he reached them and disappeared between them with a cry not unlike the one he had made as he had entered her. That was when she began to run across the sand, feeling the heat already, seeping into her shoes, her body, and she wondered how long she had been standing in the sun before he disappeared.
She watched the sagebrush, the snakes and the scorpions, always searching for him in the shiny silver towers just ahead. When she was within a few yards, she called him and heard nothing but her own cry reflected in the dry air. Another cry began, a low moan, too deep to be Mark’s, and it so startled her, that she looked up. The spaceships seemed solid, and she realized that they weren’t spaceships at all, but buildings in some kind of city, whether past, present or future, she couldn’t tell. But as she looked at them, they began to waver like heat visions, and she ran harder, her breath coming ragged in her burning lungs, her hands extended before her, her mind screaming for Mark, although she couldn’t waste the air, the effort to use the lips. The buildings grew faint, then strong, then faint, but she managed to reach one, to touch it, before they faded completely, and it was as she had known it would be—frosty cold, so cold that it burned—and her palm stuck to the steel, and as the building faded into nothingness, she saw a tiny handprint—hers—fade with it.
Later, they told her, a helicopter spotted her, and someone picked her up. She stared at her burned hand for days and when she finally asked about Mark, they told her he had disappeared in the desert and was probably dead. But she didn’t cry because she knew different. Whenever she touched things with her injured hand, she could see him in that cold silver city, searching still, whether for something he hadn’t found or for her, she did not know.
She stared at the light inching toward her feet. Cross light. She hadn’t cared about crosses until Mark had mentioned them, just like he hadn’t cared about spaceships until she had asked him if he had seen them. Just as he had chased her obsession, she was chasing his.
She stepped into the blue-white light. It didn’t feel cold or alien as she had expected it to. She didn’t feel different at all. A sadness went through her as the last belief, the belief that Mark’s crosses would give her back her spaceships, ebbed away.
Then she turned and saw her shadow haloed in blue-white light, looking alien, looking different. When Mark had disappeared, she had donned his dreams, thinking she couldn’t follow him, thinking she had to do what he would have done had he stayed.
The cross dared her to the top of the hill.
She sighed, then started up the narrow, winding footpath that eased its way through the trees. The butte was quiet. No parkers, no evening visitors, no one except her, her breathing, and her feet scrabbling along the path. She wasn’t frightened, but the light made her feel as if she walked in a world with hard edges, where trees bit and shadows had sharp corners. Had Mark felt this way as he crossed the desert, as if he were alone and in a strange place? Or had his excitement driven him forward?
Finally, the butte leveled off and she could see the cross. It stood like a guardian at the edge of a precipice. A lone sentinel watching her pilgrimage with a detached cool interest.
She had stared straight on like this at the spaceships—the city—and they had shimmered. But the cross seemed to grow stronger. Her hand tingled and she remembered the feel of the silver burning her before it faded away.
Could the cross heal her? If she reached out and touched it, would it take away the power, the curse her shimmering desert city had given her?
She extended her hand and it shook. On the dirt below, her shadow looked as if the planes of her body were square instead of rounded. A box shadow, drawn by a child and a ruler.
The cross grew stronger, the blue light almost silver in its whiteness. Laurel stepped forward, wishing for the healing; and she walked, the light became a solid thing in her hand. A vision came to her of TV preachers, speaking against blue backdrops, the white light of their image crawling from the television set, flickering silver across the viewers’ faces.
And then she remembered Mark, wandering in that cool, silver city, still searching for something he would never find. He was conducting her search and she had never told him what she was looking for. Just as he had never really told her why he watched crosses. If she touched that cross, she would be trapped forever in a place like this, a place where she didn’t belong.
She put her hand down and the light from the cross seemed to dim. As she watched, the light retreated, sucked into the cross, until the structure itself grew dark and black. The cross winked out as quickly as a heat mirage.
The halo had slipped off her shadow like an overlarge suit. She stood in the darkness, enjoying it, then she reached into her back pocket. Sylvie’s check had been folded into small pieces. Laurel unfolded it, and slowly, methodically, ripped it apart. It was time to leave the trees and the snow-covered mountains. Time to forget the dreams of a man whose presence was only a memory.
She would go back to her world. Her desert. And start looking for spaceships.
Or cities.
Or tall, cool, silver things shimmering in the sand.
____________________________________________
“Spaceships In The Desert” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Spaceships in the Desert
Copyright © 2015 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Starshore, Summer 1990Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2015 by WMG PublishingCover design by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Sarahluna | Dreamstime
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
Here’s something fun. My award-nominated novella, “Maelstrom,” is in a Storybundle with eight other space opera ebooks. It may look like there’s only eight books here, but really, there are entire series bundled into some of these ebooks.
You can get them all with a simple click. But they go away in about 48 hours. So hurry on over.
And, in case you’re on the fence, here’s the blurb for “Maelstrom.”
Nedda Ferguson-Lithe lost her father on the Gabriella’s final mission. The ship’s disappearance remains one of the great mysteries of the sector.
But as Nedda interviews the crew’s survivors, she finds more questions than answers.
No one knows who or what causes the maelstroms that make exploring Nájar Crater on Madreperla so dangerous. But everyone knows that the rumors of the crater’s riches prove far too tempting despite the danger.
Every time a ship ventures into that crater, a maelstrom drives it out. Or destroys it. Nedda hopes to find out which fate met the Gabriella—and her father.
Nominated for the Asimov’s Readers Choice Award for best novella, Maelstrom proves a heart-wrenching standalone addition to Kristine Kathryn Rusch’s award-winning Diving Series.
Gift first saw the lights as a baby. The faerie lights promised him a different life from the one he would know in the castle.
But he couldn’t resist the pull of the mortal world. And that curiosity might change the course of not one, but two, kingdoms forever.
An unforgettable story about magic, choices and love, which inspired part of World Fantasy Award winner Kristine Kathryn Rusch’s international bestselling Fey series. Investigate the series at World of the Fey.
“Changeling” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
ChangelingBy Kristine Kathryn RuschThe colored lights danced over his baptismal crib. He didn’t have words yet—he was only four days old—and the world still blurred before his half-opened eyes. He had been left alone for just a moment. His pagan mother, Queen in more than name, arguing with his Christian father over the necessity for the ceremony. The nurses huddled against the strong oak doors, listening through the cracks as the Queen vented her fears about the holy water about to be dripped on her son’s head.
The baby, whose father wanted to call him Sebastian and whose mother wanted to call him Elric, reached toward the lights, pudgy fingers grasping with the odd strength that only babies had. By accident, he touched a blue light and pulled his hand away with a startled cry. With the smell of sulfur and a bit of smoke, the blue light had become a tiny naked woman, with thin wings shimmering on her back.
“Got him,” she said.
The other lights stopped flickering and floated to her, each popping and becoming little naked people as well. The baby watched them, his fingers stinging with heat, and turning blue at the tips. He whimpered as the little people wove a gossamer net around him, but his nurses, intent on the argument that had just missed—by the width of a poorly aimed goblet—coming to blows, heard nothing. The net was soft and warm around him. As it lifted him in the air, his fingers stopped stinging, and he could almost smell his mother’s milk. The rocking and the milky scent soothed him. As the little people carried him to the window, he felt a calm he had never known before.
He turned his small head in its nest and looked down on his former bed. Another being had already taken his place, fingers curled over the baptismal blanket as if to hold it tight.
“Changeling,” the baby thought, marking not just his first word, but the arrival of his conscious being, born a full adult, thanks to the fairies’ magic touch.
Arianna opened the sash covering the window overlooking the garden. She climbed on the window seat, tucking her bare feet under her long dressing gown. Sunshine warmed her, and the scent of roses filled the room. She leaned back and closed her eyes, not wanting to see the tapestry-covered walls that she had seen every morning of her entire life. The thick featherbed leaning against the wall was rumpled—no one had come in yet to fix it or dress her—and the fire in the grate had burned to ash in the middle of the night.
But it didn’t matter. The morning was warm and beautiful, just as Mother had predicted it would be. Mother had been upset each time she spoke of the coronation: her bejeweled hands clasped as if in protest and her great green eyes filled with tears. She had never liked Elric, always claiming that he was not her child, something Father had laughed at, recalling the Great Baptism Debates and before that, the Awful Royal Birth Screams that had echoed from the chambers above.
Lord, how she missed her father. His calmness had been the perfect foil to their mother’s odd notions. Besides, he had always found time to spend with his children, even when their mother did not.
Mother had managed to stall the coronation for six weeks, but the Lords had finally overruled her. Mother had said nothing of it, but Arianna assumed that the Lords had threatened to overthrow her if she didn’t allow Elric to take the throne.
Not that Elric cared. Elric did whatever anyone told him, which should have pleased Mother, if she had wanted to retain power. All she had to do was order Elric to listen to no one but her.
Something rustled in the garden below. Arianna opened her eyes and leaned out, hoping to see a deer. She had seen one on the morning of her father’s death, and Mother had said that proved she had second sight, had seen the death warning, and failed to heed it. Arianna had said that it proved there was a deer in the garden and nothing else.
The rose bushes were in full flower. Red and white flowers stood out like drops of paint against the rich green leaves. Off to the side were the hedgerows, marking the delineation between the rose garden and the rest of the flowers. A bird burst out of a copse of trees to her left and Arianna started to turn away, thinking that was what she had heard, when she realized she had seen something else.
A shiny black head of hair half hidden among the cluster of white rose bushes in the center of the garden. She made herself turn back slowly, trying to ease the beating of her heart. When she was a child, her mother used to tell stories of tribes of evil woodsmen who beheaded children and used their hair for court wigs. Even though Nurse later explained that those were tales designed to keep the children on the palace grounds, part of Arianna still believed the stories to be true.
The hair moved, just a little, enough so that Arianna was convinced that it was attached to someone. She leaned out the window, careful to grip the cold stone sill. At that moment, the person stood, and she was startled to see Elric, surveying the garden as if he had never seen it before.
She pulled herself back enough to stay out of his view. Elric looked odd. His shoulders seemed wider, and his mouth had a curl to it, almost as if it would ease into a smile or snarl at any moment. His skin looked white in the morning sun and his black hair darker than it usually appeared.
But that wasn’t what surprised her. What surprised her were his eyes. They had a sharpness, an alertness, to them that she had never seen before.
“Elric!” she called. “You’re supposed to be in your rooms!”
He glanced up at her, eyes as wild as the deer she had seen, and then he shimmered and disappeared.
Caught. Seen by a switch of a girl no bigger than his aunt Fay. If they knew back at the Gates, they would laugh him from the Ring, and he would lose his chance to become king of them all at the Midsummer Frolic.
He crouched in the shadows of the trees. The girl still leaned from the window, searching the garden, trying to find him. She had a familiar look to her, a brightness to her eyes, that only those with a touch of Trueblood had. If she looked hard enough, she could probably see him, even now. Truebloods could not hide from each other.
She went back inside and he sighed with relief. He had been a fool coming here so close to the solstice, but he couldn’t stay away. After he became king, he would never return to the mortal world. He would stay in the Ring, protected by magic, until his powers waned and a new king rose to take his place.
A shiver ran down his back. In the shade, the ground was damp. He wasn’t used to being in the mortal world in the daylight. Birds flitted from tree to tree just as they did in the Ring, and the sun had a warmth he had never felt before.
Something about the castle drew him. Something that whispered at the edge of his memory.
Elric.
She had called him Elric.
(“Sebastian!”
(“Elric!”
(“Woman, I’ll have none of your heathen names for my son. He was born into a Christian household and Christian he’ll remain!”)
The People called him Gift. He remembered the naming ceremony around the fire. He had rested in a new cradle made of ferns and twigs and the remains of his net. They had called him Gift and thanked the forest gods that they had been able to save him.
He would receive a new name, should he be crowned in the darkness.
Elric, you’re supposed to be in your room.
He had been in this castle before. Flashes (another being in his place) had haunted him each time he stood in the garden. They would haunt him until he died.
Unless he settled it now.
She had thought him Elric. Elric he would become.
Arianna did not move as Lissa tugged on her hair. Mother had dictated the dress and the hairstyle: several long braids wrapped around her head and decorated in pearls. Arianna loved to have her hair fall free, but Mother said that was unbecoming to a woman without a husband. Mother’s husband had died, but she still wore her hair long and flowing down her back. Arianna wondered if she would ever be able to do the same.
Arianna’s reflection in the rippled glass showed a face white with strain. Lissa held her lower lip between her teeth as she combed. Mother had beat Lissa with a comb once when Arianna’s hair had tumbled down her shoulders during dinner. Lissa had vowed never to let that happen again.
Lissa pulled so hard that Arianna’s head wobbled. She would not cry out. She would say nothing. She wanted out of this room as quickly as possible. She wanted to see Elric.
If she closed her eyes, she could see him there, movements as wild as an animal’s. He had shimmered and disappeared, but as she had crouched down from the window, she had thought she saw him in the trees, staring at her.
Her brother had always been odd, but his oddness had never seemed purposeful before.
“Are you almost done?” she snapped at Lissa.
“I still have half the head, Highness,” Lissa said, “and it must be right for the Queen.”
“The Queen be hanged,” Arianna said, but not loudly enough for Lissa to hear. Arianna feared her mother’s wrath as much as the maid did.
The castle was cold. He thought it odd that mortals would choose to live in a place colder than the outdoors. The air smelled damp and musty, and strangely familiar.
He had never seen so much activity in one place. In the large kitchen, the only warm room he had found, women, wearing kerchiefs over their hair, tended fires in large stone boxes. The room smelled of cooked game and fresh bread. His mouth watered, but mortal food was not what he was after.
In the larger gathering rooms, servants added decorations to the walls. Up the flat stone steps, a woman with the shine of a Trueblood allowed another woman to help her dress. The girl he had seen sat before a mirror while another girl played with her hair. Men in other chambers helped each other dress. But only one chamber drew him, one he remembered being in when he was so tiny he could not speak.
The oak door was closed, but he spoke softly to the dying wood. It answered creakingly in great pain from the metal studs someone had poked in its frame. He brushed his hand along the scarred surface, easing some of the pain, and the door slid open for him, without a sound.
He slipped inside. The cold walls were covered with woven rugs, decorated with great care. Voices echoed from the inner chamber. He walked around the gilt edged chairs and made himself shimmer like light before stepping into the carved open doorway.
His shimmer nearly left him. He froze, cold as the surface of a pond on a winter day. Standing before him, wrapped in heavy woolen robes, was the being he had last seen as a baby. Only now it looked like a waxen image of himself.
Another man bobbed and danced around the image. “…bit warm, Highness,” the man was saying, “But lovely. Yes, impressive. The others will be pleased to see the wealth this kingdom has. You must walk firm, my Lord Elric, as if you own it all, since you do now. You do.”
Elric. You should be in your rooms.
Elric! ’Tis a royal name from my people! You shall not corrupt him by naming him for some misbegotten saint!
His fingers twitched and the sharp blue pain he had felt ever since he could remember returned. Lights. Lights. He had seen lights and touched them and then…
…he was beside the fire and they were calling him Gift. He was no gift. He was one of the many babies brought to faerie because the fey had grown old and corrupt and could no longer bear their own.
His shimmer disappeared and he had to catch the cold stone to keep himself from falling. No wonder Fay had to boost his magic when he confronted the adults. The little bit of Trueblood wouldn’t carry the magic required of a full Trueblood. He was mortal. He was mortal and they never told him.
A rustle behind him made him turn. The girl was there, looking older, the hair piled on top of her head and wrapped in pearls. Her dress clung to her chest, then widened at her hips until he could barely see her tiny slippers peaking out.
“Elric,” she said, her forehead wrinkled in a frown, “why aren’t you dressed?”
He grabbed the shimmer, pulled it back around him and pushed against the wall. Her frown grew. She reached out, and would have put her hand through him if he had not moved away.
“Milady Arianna?” the manservant spoke.
The girl shot a suspicious glance at his hiding spot, then walked into the other room. “Elric,” she said, looking at the waxen image. “Elric? Is that you?”
Because Mother had waited so long, the Lords had decided to hold the coronation in the church. Arianna arrived early, knowing she would catch her mother there.
The church was a miniature version of the castle. Made of stone and mortar, with towers on all four sides, it looked like a child’s play toy instead of a place of worship. Arianna had stepped inside only once—for her father’s funeral—and she had been very uncomfortable.
Inside, the church was colder than the castle’s closed east wing. The back pews were made of stone and were covered, just for today, with thin red cushions embroidered with the family’s crest. The front pews were wooden boxes, designed to hold and protect the gentry from the masses. The King’s box, rarely used, had a small platform leading up to it, so that the King would sit higher than anyone else in the room.
Arianna stood in the door for a moment, getting her bearings. Her mother’s voice echoed from one of the back rooms: high, strident, and forceful. Arianna didn’t know how the bishop could argue with her. No one argued with Mother.
Arianna walked down the stone floor. A rolled up red rug would be laid for her brother, but not until he appeared. The stone sent chills through her thin slippers, and she stifled the urge to sneeze.
Her father had lost the religion battle, just as he had lost most battles with his overbearing wife. Arianna sometimes thought he had died early, just to get away from Mother.
She followed the voices into a group of rooms of the King’s box. The rooms were done in gold and red, with plush chairs and big oak desks. Mother always said the church had money. Here was the proof of it.
The Bishop faced Arianna. He wore his white and gold robes, and clutched a staff so tightly that his knuckles had turned white. His round face held no expression at all except for two red spots on his cheeks. Arianna knew the feeling. Sometimes a club to the head might make Mother talk sense.
Mother towered over the Bishop. She had insisted on wearing her specially built shoes with the three-inch heel, making her taller than anyone in the Kingdom. Her dress, made with real gold thread, and heavier than the King’s coronation crown, shimmered in the candlelight.
“You will not touch him, nor will you douse him in holy water,” Mother said with such force that Arianna knew that she had repeated the sentence at least a dozen times.
“It is part of the ceremony, Highness, and as such, I cannot skip the ritual. The foreign nobles will know.”
“Foreign nobles be hanged!” Mother said. “He is not a Christian. He does not need Christian trappings at his coronation.”
“He will be a Christian king, Highness, ruling a Christian nation.”
Mother waved a hand and the Bishop winced. “If only his father were alive. He would come up with some kind of compromise.”
“If Father were alive,” Arianna said, “we wouldn’t be having the coronation.”
Mother whirled. “Arianna!” Her voice held relief. “Show him what holy water does to my children.”
Arianna swallowed. The burn marks ached. She had dipped her fingers in holy water after a ceremony held in the palace. Nurse had to put out Arianna’s burning skin with her skirt. Father had warned Arianna never to show the Bishop the scars. He said that would be grounds for a complete revolt against the monarchy.
“It makes us nervous, Bishop,” she said, ignoring her mother’s plea-filled gaze. “Perhaps you can wave—” she didn’t know the term for the equipment he used “—that thing over my brother’s head and pretend there is water in it. After all, we’re going to pretend that he’s a Christian king since none of us know the first thing about your religion.”
“Arianna!” Mother hissed.
“Quite right, Arianna, quite right,” the Bishop said. “A compromise worthy of your father. Then the other nations will think we have a Christian king, and I will not have shirked my duties.”
Odd that he didn’t worry about the reaction of his god. Arianna sighed. She didn’t have time to think about that. “Mother, I need to talk with you.”
Her mother glanced at the Bishop, then at Arianna, as if she couldn’t believe the argument had been so easily settled. “What is it?”
“Privately, Mother.”
“All right.” Mother shot another angry look at the Bishop, then left the room and followed Arianna out of the church. As they stepped across the threshold, Mother wiped her shoes to get the stench of holiness off them. “What’s so important?”
“I saw something strange in the garden,” Arianna said. She explained Elric’s odd behavior and the way the new image of him had disappeared twice, both times leaving a shimmer that she could barely touch.
“And you can see that shimmer?” Mother asked.
Arianna nodded. “It doesn’t go away, no matter what I do. If I squint, if I touch it, no matter what, it stays.”
Mother sighed and shook her head. “We need to take you home and get you tested,” she said. “I should have known when that holy water exploded on you—”
“Mother, please.” Arianna had been listening to that speech since the deer in the garden.
Mother smiled absently and patted Arianna’s arm. “If you see that shimmer during the coronation, I want you to point it out to me,” she said. “Then stand back.”
A small crowd of people had disembarked from a carriage near the gate. “What is going on?” Arianna asked.
Mother’s smile grew wider. “I don’t know,” she said, “but I think there’s magic in the air.”
He shimmered against the wall until the manservant left. The waxen image still stood in front of the mirror, unmoving. It appeared to be staring at itself, but he knew that it was waiting for someone to tell it what to do.
Mortals were such fools. They actually believed that lump was a real being? If he had not come back, the waxen image’s reflexes would have slowed to nothing. It needed power from its home source and he knew he was that source.
He was Elric.
The name suited him better than Gift. He wiped the shimmer off his skin and went into the dressing room. The waxen image turned at the sound. Elric approached and touched it, feeling the clammy skin, shivering at the lifeless eyes.
He let the image go. So he had been home here, once. Not long, though. They had taken him young, as they often did.
He had time. He hadn’t expected to find the answers so quickly. He would follow this image and see what its day was like.
Arianna sat on the altar beside her mother, staring at the Bishop as he repeated his admonitions to the new Christian King. Elric hadn’t moved from his spot in the back of the church. He looked normal now—a bit slow, and witless, the kind of man who would always do what he was told. Was that why the Lords wanted to speed up the coronation? So that they would have a malleable king? Did that mean that Mother would have to fight for her very existence?
Arianna sighed. She didn’t like thinking of the future.
The Bishop finished his lecture. One of the churchmen in the back signaled Elric to walk down the aisle. Two young boys walked before him, opening the red carpet. Elric walked as he was told: step, pause, step, pause; never taking his eyes off the front of the church. Mother stood and Arianna stood beside her, feeling a strange fear in the back of her throat.
Elric knelt on the steps leading to the altar. The Bishop walked down two steps to tower over his future king.
Something shimmered on the back of Elric’s coronation robe. Arianna tugged her mother’s overlong sleeve. “There,” she whispered, pointed to Elric’s feet. “There it is.”
Mother frowned.
The Bishop turned and dipped his staff in the holy water. Arianna turned white. He had promised. He had said she had come up with a good compromise. She started across the altar, her mother grabbing at her skirts.
“No, Arianna!”
“…e Spiritu Santu—”
She grabbed the Bishop just as her mother grabbed her, just as the holy water flew from the bulbous end of the staff. The water landed on Elric and splattered the back of his robe, the carpet and the people sitting in the front boxes. A drop landed on Arianna’s hand and a small fire flared, sending sharp pains through her skin.
She slapped it out. Another fire started on Elric’s robe. Elric himself looked up at the Bishop—and smiled, truly smiled for the first time in his life. Then he vanished, leaving only bits of clay and earth on the collapsing robe.
The nobles in front screamed. The church smelled of smoke. Mother had pushed the Bishop aside and was struggling down the steps in her too-tall shoes. The fire on the back of the robe had grown until it was the shape of a man.
Elric. It was Elric. Not the one who had disappeared, but the one she had seen that morning, with his lively blue eyes and strong quick-moving fingers.
The Bishop picked up the bowl of holy water and made to throw it on Elric, but Arianna grabbed his arm. “No,” she said, wincing as more water spilled on her. “It won’t put out the fire.”
Another flame sprouted on her arm, and she had to use the Bishop’s sleeve to put it out. He looked at her with such repulsion that she thought he was going to hit her.
Elric’s fire was out and he was cradled in his mother’s arms. She picked up the robe and wrapped it around him, murmuring, “My son! My son.”
One of the Lords stood. “I demand to know what has happened.”
“There is an enchantment—” The Bishop began.
“—which the Bishop broke,” Arianna replied. “That was why my brother was always so slow. The tears of Christ have made my brother himself again.”
A rustle of voices ran through the crowd. Elric staggered forward, held in place by Mother. She wasn’t going to let him go. He shot a glance at Arianna, a look filled with such panic that she felt her heart go to him. “What was that?” he whispered. His speech had an odd accent, a lilting, almost musical tone.
“Christian Holy Water,” she whispered.
“Christian?” He let out air, almost like a sigh, then began to struggle.
“Don’t move, you fool,” Mother hissed in her best command voice. “You can’t go back now. You can only stay with us. Best make what you can of it.”
“This is a Christian place?” His voice, mercifully, remained low. “I can’t stay here.”
“You have to,” Arianna said. “You’re being crowned King.”
“King?” He glanced at the door, then at the ceiling, then surveyed the burn marks on his skin. He looked at his fingers as if he expected something on them, but couldn’t find it. “I am mortal then.”
The Bishop yanked his sleeve from Arianna’s grasp. He looked at the crowd, then at Elric. Arianna could see the Bishop make a decision before he spoke. “Of course you’re not mortal, boy,” he said as quietly as his booming voice would allow. “You’re King—above man, above all except God.”
He waved the staff over Elric and spoke more Latin. The noble sat down, and Mother relaxed her grip. The coronation was done.
But Arianna watched that lively, intelligent male face. Her true brother. The coronation may have been over, but the fun was just beginning.
Elric had fallen asleep beside the fire, listening to the coo of his newborn son. He had been awake for nearly three days now, listening, waiting. The window open, the baptismal crib decorated just as he remembered it. He had banished the nurses and guarded the child himself.
Colored lights flew in the window. The baby’s coos grew louder as he saw the pretty colors. He reached for them, giggling as he did, accidentally touching one. A pop and the smell of sulfur filled the room, jarring Elric awake.
The fairy stopped her ministrations over the baby. She stood in midair and bowed to Elric.
“Human King,” she said in a mocking tone.
He reached for her, his fingers still heartbreakingly normal. The blue had been gone for years. “Take me back,” he whispered.
She shook her head. “You’ve been tainted,” she said. “I’ll take your son.”
He watched as the fairies wove a skein of light and wrapped it around his child. He wished he could speak to the boy, tell him that the world of magic was a better world than this, that there was hope there and—
The door burst open behind them. The fairies disappeared in a halo of light. Elric had to run forward and catch his son before the baby dropped back into the crib.
“They were here,” his mother said. “I smelled them.”
She reached into the air, touched a remaining light beam and winced as it popped. One fairy shook a fist at his mother and flew away. She turned on Elric. “You were going to let them take him.”
He stared up at her. She was Trueblood and powerful, but she had never scared him. She had chosen to give up her life for a life with humans. He clutched the baby to his chest.
“Yes,” he said. “I was going to let them take him.”
“Why? Don’t you remember? Don’t you know fairies can never love?”
He didn’t care about love. He was too fairy to know what it meant. But he remembered. He remembered the free flowing magic, the warm nights, the wonderful spectacle of lights. They hadn’t loved him, but they had given him laughter, which no one seemed to understand here.
He looked at her, and felt a sadness burn into his soul. “They’ll never come back now.”
“I know,” she said. “And now we are finally free.”
She took the baby from him and left the room. He went to the window and stared out, seeing lights flickering in the garden. He would call them back if he could, but he was mortal bound and ugly in their sight.
They would die off soon. Their line was too weak. He would never see them again.
“We’re not free,” he whispered to the uncaring wind. The lights around him winked out—one by one. “We’re all prisoners of our destiny.”
____________________________________________
Changeling
Copyright © 2015 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in The Book of Kings, edited by Richard Gilliam and Martin H. Greenberg, Roc, July 1995Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2015 by WMG PublishingCover design by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Steve51 | Dreamstime
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
Still playing catch-up from our incredibly weird year. I’m not sure it was a bad year, because we got rid of a huge ugly problem in our lives, one we didn’t even know we had until January, and our business is thriving. Dean is healing, and we’ve made some good changes. So the year will end up being a positive one…even if I’m incredibly tired and behind on things like Recommended Reading because of it.
Well, I did the reading. You all know that. I just didn’t write up my likes. And to be completely honest, I put up the March list after leaving out one publication because I had so many recommendations from it. I wanted the March list up, so I moved everything from that magazine to April. That’s On Wisconsin for Winter of 2023. I needed to complete something, so I sacrificed accuracy for completion. Ultimately, I didn’t include everything, because some are UW specific and went into my library. But you’ll find a lot from that issue down below.
I’m slowly catching up on writing about the reading. For context, I did this reading in April, but wasn’t able to write much about it until July, August, and September. There’s a lot of great stuff here, though, and most of the articles are free. Take a look.
April 2024Benson, Harry, “Ticket To Ride,” Vanity Fair, February 2024. I seem to be collecting a ton of articles about the Beatles first visit to the U.S. in 1964. Because it was sixty years ago, everyone is writing and sharing pictures. Harry Benson, though, was traveling with them, and saw the change from famous band to pop icons. Of all the articles I’ve seen, this is the best.
Cartwright, Lachlan, “Take The Cash or Fight? Media Moguls Split on AI Deals,” The Hollywood Reporter, February 14, 2024. I’m pointing out this article to show you (especially you creatives) that the AI fight is complicated. So many people are trying to figure out what the generative AI future will be, and some people are hedging their bets. Some of it is because of the money, but some of it reflects the uses of AI. So read this and keep it in mind as we see more and more articles on generative AI.
Coates, Ta-Nehisi, We Were Eight Years in Power, One World, 2018. Ta-Nehisi Coates’s We Were Eight Years in Power is one of the most banned books in the United States. I’d been meaning to read it for years, and finally decided, heck, I’m going to do so. My copy is now dog-eared and underlined, with lots of yellow sticky notes. It’s an important book. It’s a meditation on writing, from a man who reread the essays he wrote while Barack Obama was in office after he knew that Trump had been elected. Some of the essays—particularly the first, about Bill Cosby—were dated even then. Some have become dated by now. But so much in here is still important, still worth reading. A lot of it is uncomfortable to read as well, in a challenging and good way. And much of it is filled with truths, including one that’s important in 2024, now that we have another cadidate of color.
Like this:
For most of American history, our political system was premised on two conflicting facts—one, an oft-stated love of democracy; the other, an undemocratic white supremacy inscribed at every level of government.
Or this:
Racism is not merely a simplistic hatred. It is, more often, broad sympathy toward some and broader skepticism toward others. Black America ever lives under the skeptical eye. Hence the old admonishment to be “twice as good.” Hence the need for a special “talk” administered to black boys about how to be extra careful when relating to the police.
I found lines and paragraphs and entire pages like this, all worth underlining, all still (sadly) true. This is an amazing book, one you might want to read and discuss with friends.
Gardner, Chris, “‘I’m Bloody Tired of Hiding,'” The Hollywood Reporter, February 28, 2024. Fascinating interview with Lynda Obst, the megaproducer, who has been in the business forever. Apparently, getting older and having a cancer diagnosis has made her a lot more forthcoming. A blunt and fascinating “no-whining” interview with a woman who has succeeded in the business longer than many of us have been alive. The attitude that gets her through everything when something goes wrong? They won. We lost. Next. You know, that’s kinda my attitude too. It works.
Glicksman, Josh, “A League of Their Own,” Billboard, February 10, 2024. A fascinating roundtable, timed before the Super Bowl featuring professionals who have, over the past few years, combined music and sport to create a whole new market. I’ve circled and underlined this to death. Pay attention to the discussion of rights here, and the possibilities presented by a whole new market. Then open your mind to changes in writing and marketing. You might not see what I’ve seen here, but you might get a picture of some of it.
McManus, Karen M., One of Us is Lying, Delacorte Press, 2017. I think, considering the spring I had, this book appealed to me just from the title. Only in the book, the liar is a mystery and unfortunately, in our lives this spring, the liar was not a mystery. Still, this is a fun, fascinating mystery novel which is pretty much the Breakfast Club as a locked room mystery. (Someone dies in detention.) Good characters, good writing. I enjoyed it enough to buy the sequel.
McManus, Karen M., One of Us is Next, Delacorte Press, 2020. I really didn’t think that McManus could pull off a sequel to One of Us is Lying, but she did. The ending was a bit abrupt, but that was okay. (It wasn’t okay when I finished the next book, which just…ended.) This was a lovely way to spend an afternoon.
Mitchell, Gail “Superstar: Usher,” Billboard, February 10, 2024. Fantastic article on what it means to be an artist with a long career. I circled and underlined a lot in here. Usher discusses creativity, staying relevant, whether it’s important to stay relevant, and remaining inspired. He also discusses how to keep all you’ve done before out of your head, as well as what the expectations of you are.
The article ends with this quote:
We’re as powerful as we choose to be. That’s what got me here. I just believed and didn’t pay attention to what anybody else had to say.
If you plan to have or already have a long career, read this.
Prince, Daisy, “Barbarians at the Glades,” Vanity Fair, February 2024. Fascinating and creepy article about Palm Beach and West Palm Beach, the changes that have occurred to both communities since the arrival of MAGA has upended the old order, and a bit about generational wealth. I’m sharing because this is a time to share the unease.
Provost, Megan, “What It Means To Succeed,” On Wisconsin, Winter 2023. The interview with the University of Wisconsin-Madison’s new provost is mostly about AI and his ideas about the way that AI will alter academia and the way that research gets done. I’m collecting all this AI information; I find it fascinating. I hope you do as well.
Schmitt, Preston, “Creating The Badger Brand,” On Wisconsin, Winter 2023. Wow. This is an amazing article. The UW was one of the last major universities to license its logo. It also had some issues figuring out what the logo was. (In fact, in a future issue, a man wrote in contesting some of the information in the article. After you read it, you’ll see why.) If you want to see the complexities of trademark and licensing, check this out.
Steinhoff, Jessica, “Surprising Stories From the UW Archives,” On Wisconsin, Winter 2023. This article made me want to travel home again, if only I could. I’m not surprised at some of the stories, like the material from the Sterling Hall bombing in 1970, but others did surprise me. I didn’t know, for example, that the 602 Club was an unofficial gay bar. And I certainly didn’t know about the mandolins from 1893. Take a look, just for the cool history.
As many of you know, Dean and I had a heck of a year. I had more dental surgeries
than I want to think about. Dean fell during a 5K and shattered his shoulder, having
major surgery and PT. We had (and still have) a major business issue to deal with.
Of course all of those things had an impact on our writing. We slowed down or
stopped altogether. If we didn’t know better, we would have said we were blocked.
But we weren’t. Life got in the way. It does that sometimes. And sometimes, we as
writers get in our own way.
Dean and I made a list of over 50 things writers call “writer’s block.” The solution for
these things is not one-size-fits all.
We decided, based on our year and our hard-fought wisdom over decades, to help
writers through whatever they’re calling writer’s block.
We’ve designed two courses over 18 weeks, including 16 webinars and lots of
homework, to help writers overcome whatever is stopping them or slowing them
down.
We want to help writers return to the joy of writing.
These classes are new. They start on October 1. And until Monday, you can get
them at a discounted price.
Take a look at the website and the video Dean made explaining what we’re doing.
See if it’s for you.
Questions? See if Dean answered them on his website. Click here.
Join us in breaking free from writer’s block.
Thank you, thank you, thank you, everyone for backing the Fey Kickstarter! I’m so thrilled that you like the books enough to support them early. Wait until you see how lovely they are. WMG has really started stepping up its game.
You should be getting surveys soon. Fill them out so that we can send everyone their books!
Thanks again!
We have hit the last day of the Kickstarter for the newest Fey book, Incident at Serebro Academy. The book is a standalone adventure in the Fey saga—the perfect place to start. You can get the ebook with every reward, and that includes a discounted price on all of the Fey novels. We’ve hit stretch goals as well, so there’s lots of fantasy reading here, as well as some cool writing workshops.
Here’s the book’s blurb:
THE FEY ATTACK
A grisly ambush at Serebro Academy starts a race to uncover secrets that might save the Academy or destroy it entirely.
Magical maps, Fey spies, treachery and dangerous secrets. A stunning fantasy—impossible to put down.
This thrilling page-turner continues Rusch’s masterful melding of epic fantasy and steampunk while demonstrating once again her place as one of the greatest storytellers of our time.
The book was fun to write, and it’s beautifully designed. Each chapter has art, which shows where on the map the action takes place.
So click on over to the Kickstarter and explore. You might find something just for you.
-5Days-1010 Hours-25Minutes-9Seconds
Written as a prequel to Kristine Kathryn Rusch’s popular Fey saga, “Destiny” follows the Shapeshifter Solanda on Nye. The Black King wants her to use her special abilities on a job that will change the Fey forever. But Solanda wants to change the life of one child. Can she do both? Or should she do nothing at all?
“Destiny” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here. If you want more Fey, visit our website, World of the Fey. And remember to go to the Fey Kickstarter that runs through Thursday, September 19.
DestinyKristine Kathryn RuschSOLANDA WALKED the cobblestone streets of Nir, the capitol city of Nye, her tail up. She had a meeting with Rugar, the son of the Black King. He had sent a Wisp to find her, and it had taken the little creature nearly a day to do so.
Solanda was in her cat form, as she had been since the Fey captured this repressed country—and thus very difficult to find. The Nyeians had many faults—they were prissy, overdressed, and pasty faced, not to mention abominably poor soldiers—but they did treat their animals well. She had found a family who fed her to excess, allowed her to roam outside, and pampered her as no cat should be pampered.
How appalled they would be if they ever discovered the golden cat their daughter had adopted was really a Fey Shapeshifter.
Solanda’s tail twitched once in amusement. Every day she imagined eating her lovely tuna dinner in the glass plate that the family gave her, and then Shifting into her Fey form just to say thank you.
She didn’t know what would appall the Nyeians the most: the fact that she was Fey, or the fact that she would be naked. She doubted any of them had seen a naked woman before: the wife managed to change her clothing one piece at a time, without ever taking it all off at once, and the husband didn’t seem to think this unusual. He would probably be more shocked than his wife at the appearance of a naked Fey woman in his house. He would probably fall over in a dead faint.
Only the daughter, a girl of five, was redeemable. Esmerelda was a good child. She had to be. She was raised Nyeian. Her mother trussed her in layers upon frothy layers of clothing, making movement nearly impossible, and then yelled at the poor child whenever she did something natural, like running.
Sometimes Solanda thought she went back to that household at night because she felt sorry for the child. But in truth, she stayed there because they gave her fish properly deboned and they brushed her, and they put a warm cedar bed in Esmerelda’s room. Esmerelda, good child that she was, never confessed to her parents that she often picked up the cat and carried her to bed, cuddling with her long into the night.
And Solanda would never tell anyone—Fey or Nyeian—that sometimes she purred when she slept, pressed against the little girl’s back.
Shifters were supposed to be the coldest of the Fey, the most fickle members of a warrior people, incapable of real emotion, flighty, restless and completely self-absorbed. They also were supposed to take on the characteristics of the animal they had chosen to Shift into, so Solanda’s fickleness—theoretically—was doubly compounded by the fact that she had chosen the cat as her alternate Shape.
Of course, it didn’t matter how many times she had proven herself trustworthy. In the war against Nye, such as it was, she had done intelligence for the Black King. She had worn her cat form and slinked into Nyeian villages, soldiers’ camps, and mess halls, keeping her ears open, and learning more than she should have.
Most countries that the Fey had fought had banned strange animals from military compounds. Solanda had heard that the Co had gone so far as to slaughter any strays, thinking they might be Fey reconnaissance. But the Nyeians had a fondness for cats, and while they kept stray dogs out of their camps, they fed cats on the side.
Solanda had spent most of the war the pampered resident of a Nyeian general’s tent. He used to feed her bits of meat off his own plate while telling his staff his battle plans for the next day.
And then when he fell into his snoring sleep, she would go to the nearest Shadowlands and inform the Fey general of all she had heard. Toward the end of the war, she reported directly to the Black King, who shook his head at the stupidity of the Nyeians.
Conquering Nye was the first step toward world dominion. The Black King didn’t say that, but Solanda knew that was his goal. The Fey were a great warrior people, but they only owned half the world right now. The Black King—and the Black Throne—wanted all of it.
Solanda entered the merchant sector of Nir, and silently cursed to herself. The merchants often shooed cats out of this area. Her presence here was suddenly noticeable, and she didn’t dare Shift. She’d shock an entire community of Nyeians—which would probably be good for them.
Scents from the nearby vendor stalls caught her nose. Fried beef, more fish, some sort of vegetable something which turned her feline stomach. The fish was enticing. It almost made her forget that she was here because she had been summoned by the Black King’s son.
Rugar had been her commander for part of the Nye campaign. He was an able warrior, frustrated under his father’s tight leash. The problem with Rugar was that he believed himself to be the equal of his father, and he was not.
Solanda would rather work with the Black King, ruthless as he was, than with his less-talented son.
The tall stone buildings prevented the sun from getting to the cobblestone. The stone was wet beneath her paws from the morning rain. The air was thick and muggy, making the six layers of clothes the Nyeians wore look even more uncomfortable.
The handful of Fey who were on the street wore their traditional uniform—a leather jerkin and pants. The Fey were so much taller than the Nyeians that even if they didn’t dress differently, they would be noticeable.
She ducked under some clothing stalls, past the buildings that housed the year-round indoor merchants, and turned on the street that led to the Bank of Nye. The Black King had taken over the building. It was four stories of gray stone, towering over the buildings around it—as close to a palace as there was in Nye.
She sighed heavily and crossed the street, climbing up the stone steps and staring at the large stone door. She’d have to Shift just to get into the place.
Then she saw a nearby window ledge. The window was open. She leaped onto the ledge and jumped to the stone floor inside. She thought this building unusually cold for a Nyeian structure. The house where she was pampered was made of wood, and had thick rugs on its floors. Every surface was soft, and the air perfumed.
Here the air smelled like chalk and the stone was chilly despite the heat. There were no guards in this room, although there should have been. It looked like it was someone’s office—a desk in the center, chairs on the side for supplicants.
The door was open and led into a cavernous hallway. She heard voices and followed them. Several Fey guards huddled in an alcove. They were Infantry and young, tall even though they hadn’t come into their magic yet. Their dark skin and black hair was a welcome sight. She’d gotten tired of looking at the pasty-faced Nyeians, and hadn’t realized how much she missed her own kind.
“…fool’s errand, don’t you think?” One of the young men said.
“If it’s so important, why doesn’t the Black King go?” another asked.
“Blue Isle is important,” said a young woman. “It’s the only stop between here and Leut.”
Leut was the continent on the other side of the Infrin Sea. The Black King wanted to go there more than anything. He wanted to conquer as much of the world as he could before he died.
“If we are going to conquer the world,” the girl was saying, “we have to go through Blue Isle first.”
“Then it doesn’t make sense,” the first man said. “Why send Rugar? He’s not as good a commander as his father.”
“Maybe,” Solanda said in her most authoritative voice, “the best commander in the world has a plan that’s too sophisticated for you to understand.”
They all turned. They had similar upswept features, narrow faces, and pointed ears. Solanda had often thought that her people looked like foxes—most of them, anyway. Shifters, like her, often took some of the characteristics of their animals. Her hair and skin were more golden than dark, and she had the Shifter’s mark on her chin—a birthmark that established who and what she was when she was in her Fey form.
But they couldn’t tell now. All they could do was tell that a cat had spoken to them.
“Well,” she said, sitting on her haunches and wrapping her tail around her paws. “Where do I start? Do I reprimand you for gossiping in the middle of the day? Do I tell you that I got into the building through a window that some careless fool left open and, if I had been some young Nyeian bent on assassination, I could have walked right past you and you wouldn’t have noticed? Or do I ask that one of you poor, magickless fools get me a robe so that I can have my meeting with Rugar?”
They didn’t answer her. She raised her chin slightly. Amazing how she could intimidate them, even though she was so very small.
“By the Powers,” she snapped. “Get me a robe. And put a guard on the window.”
She nodded over her head toward the room she had just come out of.
Two of the young men ran off toward the room. The third young man hurried off, presumably to get her a robe. That left the young woman.
“I really should report this,” Solanda said. “Technically, you put the Black King’s life in danger.”
“From the Nyeians?” the young woman snorted. “You snarl at them and they run. They couldn’t fight us in the war, and once they found out that they’d remain in charge of their businesses, they really didn’t care that we took them over. Why would one of them try to get in here?”
“Revenge?” Solanda said. “We did, after all, slaughter half their army. Those young men were related to someone.”
“Then that should take away half the threat, shouldn’t it?” the young woman said. “After all, the Nyeians believe that only men are capable of fighting.”
Solanda felt amused. “I have a hunch that belief has changed since they were defeated by us. What’s your name?”
“Licia,” the girl said.
“You haven’t come into your magic yet, have you?”
The girl straightened her shoulder. Magic was always a touchy subject with Infantry. They were tall enough to show that they would get magic, but chances were if they neared adulthood and still hadn’t come into their magic, their abilities would be slight.
“No,” she said.
“You showed a tactician’s mind. Why do you waste it gossiping with people who aren’t worthy of you?”
The girl straightened her shoulders. “I don’t normally guard. I am usually in the field.”
“But there’s no field at the moment, is there?” Solanda said. “What are you doing here?”
“Rugar asked me to come. He says his daughter needs more swordfighting training.”
Solanda narrowed her eyes. Jewel, Rugar’s middle child, was the most promising of all his raggedy offspring. She hadn’t come into her magic yet either, but her height and her heritage suggested when her magic came it would be powerful. She was a good swordswoman now—Solanda had seen her fight in the last of the Nye campaign.
“Why would she need more training?”
Licia shrugged. “I suspect it has something to do with the fight Rugar had with his father this morning.”
Solanda tilted her head to show her interest.
“They just left that room you came through. They were screaming at each other all morning long.”
“About what?” Solanda asked, realizing that she was now gossiping. But she didn’t want to go into a meeting with Rugar with less knowledge than he had.
“About going to Blue Isle. Rugar says he won’t go without his daughter.”
“Not his other children?”
“He didn’t mention them.” Then Licia smiled. “At least not at the top of his voice.”
Solanda suppressed a sigh. The Black King favored Jewel. He felt that her brothers were idiots—and he was right. Their magic was slight, like their mother’s had been. Rugar’s entire life had been about defying his father. Rugar should have married a woman who had great magic. Instead, he had chosen someone he could control.
The young man returned with a flowing golden robe that was clearly of Nyeian origin. Solanda didn’t ask where he had gotten it. She didn’t thank him. Instead, she said, “Place it over me.”
He did, blotting out the light. The robe smelled faintly of perfume and perspiration, but it clearly hadn’t been worn in some time. The fabric was heavy satin—too heavy for a humid day like this—but she wasn’t in the position to be choosy. If Rugar was planning something stupid, she wanted to meet him Fey to Fey. Psychologically, it gave her an advantage.
She Shifted, feeling her body slide into its familiar Fey form. Her body stretched and grew. Her tail and whiskers slid into her skin, her hair flowed down her back, her front paws became hands. She ended up in a sitting position, her knees drawn to her chest, the robe draped over her like a tent. Inwardly she sighed, and wished that there were a more dignified way of Shifting into clothes.
Then she slid her arms through the sleeves, and her head through the neck hole, letting the stiff fabric flow around her. It was a woman’s garment, although she had no idea why someone would store one in a bank—or perhaps she did, and didn’t want to think about illicit affairs among Nyeian bankers.
She lifted her long hair out of the garment’s neck, and let it fall down her back. Licia bit her lower lip, and the other Fey looked down. They hadn’t realized they were talking to the best Shifter in the Black King’s army—at least, not until now.
Fools. Shifters were rare. How many of them would come into the Black King’s dwelling and order Infantry around?
“Licia,” she said, “announce me to Rugar.”
The girl’s skin colored slightly, but she moved in front of Solanda and led her down the hall. It got stuffier the farther in they went. Solanda was grateful that her feet were bare. The cool stone was going to keep her from melting in this robe.
Licia led her up a flight of stairs into a rabbit’s warren of what had once been offices. Solanda smiled. Rugar was hidden here, in an obviously less desirable area of the building. The Black King had a thousand ways of showing his displeasure with everyone around him.
Licia knocked on a door at the end of the hall. Solanda stood far enough back that she wasn’t visible from inside. She heard Rugar’s gruff voice, and then Licia’s response, announcing Solanda.
The door opened, and Licia stepped aside.
“I guess that means you’re supposed to go in,” she said.
Solanda stopped and put a hand on the girl’s shoulder. She spoke softly so that Rugar couldn’t hear. “If Rugar and his father are fighting,” she said, “side with the old man. Rugar is not the future of this race. You’re better off remaining in Nye with the Black King than going to Blue Isle with Rugar.”
Licia nodded, then glanced over her shoulder as if she were afraid of Rugar. Solanda walked past her and through the open door.
Rugar stood in the center of the small room. He was medium height for a Fey, and his features had a predatory, hawk-like look to them. His almond-shaped eyes were the deep black that Solanda associated with the Black Family. It was as if the Throne echoed in their very essence. He had thin cruel lips, and an expression of permanent unhappiness.
For man in his fifties with grown children, he looked startlingly like a petulant child.
“You sent for me,” she said, not disguising her lack of respect for him.
He clasped his hands behind his back, his father’s favorite stance. “I’m taking an army to Blue Isle. You will be part of it.”
She snorted. “I serve your father, not you.”
Rugar glared at her. “He gave me permission to choose whomever I wanted from the standing armies in Nye.”
“You have no need for a Shifter,” she said. “Blue Isle is a tiny place, filled with religious fanatics who have never seen war. You’ll sail in with your troops, wave a few swords, and be able to claim victory over an entire country in the space of a day. I’ll be useless to you.”
He shook his head. “I’m taking you, and a lot of Spies and Doppelgängers. I am to be military governor of Blue Isle. My father will launch an attack from there onto Leut.”
Solanda narrowed her eyes and was glad she wasn’t in cat form. She probably would have found an excuse to scratch Rugar, and that wouldn’t have been good for either of them.
“Spies, Doppelgängers, and a Shifter,” she said. “It sounds like an intelligence force. You won’t need it if you conquer the country as quickly as you believe you will.”
His gaze went flat. “I will need it.”
She stared at him for a moment. He knew something and he wasn’t going to share it with her. Spies made sense, even in an easily conquered country. They would find the pockets of resistance. But Doppelgängers had no place there. They killed their hosts and then took over the body, including the memories. Except for the gold flecks in the eyes, no one could tell them from their victims. Doppelgängers had a sophisticated magic—one that the best commanders used sparingly. And certainly didn’t waste them on an already conquered country.
“You have no need for me,” she repeated. “I stay with the Black King.”
“You’ll come with me.”
“Your father said so?”
“No, but he will.”
“Because he already acquiesced on Jewel?”
Rugar started. He hadn’t expected her to know that.
Solanda raised her eyebrows and allowed herself a small smile. “I am good at gathering intelligence.”
“And,” he said, “as you pointed out, there’s no need for intelligence gathering in a conquered country.”
She nodded. “I’ll go to Leut with your father, when he’s ready. Until then, I’ll relax here.”
“Solanda—“
“Rugar,” she said, holding up a hand. “You and I have no great liking for each other. I have a hunch your father is sending you to Blue Isle to get you out of his sight. I’d rather not be associated with you in any way. Right now, I hold your father’s respect. I’d rather not change that.”
Rugar took a step toward her. She could feel the violence shimmering in him.
She grabbed the doorknob. “Touch me,” she said, “and I’ll scratch out your eyes.”
“You can’t touch me. I’m a member of the Black Family.”
She smiled. “I’m a Shifter. Unpredictable, irresponsible, flighty—remember? I’m sure the Powers would let this slide.”
“But my father would not,” Rugar said.
“Oh,” Solanda said softly, “but I think he would.”
She tried to see the Black King before she left the building, but he was nowhere to be found. His personal guards were gone as well. She decided she would find him in the morning, and went back to her life as a pampered Nyeian cat.
The home that she had chosen was a large one on the outskirts of Nir. It had two stories filled with more clutter than any home she had ever seen. Books of poetry, musical instruments, incredibly ugly paintings, and furniture everywhere. The only saving grace was that the furniture was comfortable and the kitchen had a cat door that she could escape through when the wife decided it was time for music.
Solanda slipped through the cat door, past the kitchen hearth. One of the three Nyeian servants was cleaning the pots from the evening meal. The air smelled faintly of roast beef, and Solanda’s stomach rumbled.
Still, she didn’t beg from the servant. She knew better. The idiot had kicked her “accidentally” once, and had the scars to prove it. But Solanda knew if she attacked anyone in the house too many times, she would be thrown out, and she wasn’t willing to lose her rich dinners and soft bed just yet.
She blended into the hideous yellow wallpaper as she hurried up the stairs to Esmerelda’s room.
Esmerelda sat on the edge of the bed, fingering a rip in her dress. She had a forlorn expression on her small face. Her brown hair hung limply around her cheeks, and a streak of dirt covered the pantaloons beneath the skirt.
Solanda had never seen Esmerelda look dirty before, nor had she seen the girl’s hair loose at any time except bedtime.
“Oh, Goldie!” Esmerelda raised her voice in relief. She was speaking Nye, which was a language that Solanda hadn’t known well when she moved into this house. Here her Nye had improved greatly, but she wanted to be fluent in it by the time she left.
The little girl launched herself off the bed and grabbed Solanda before Solanda could jump out of the way. Esmerelda wrapped her arms around Solanda and held tightly. Esmerelda had never done that before. If she had been a grabby little girl, Solanda would have been gone a long time ago.
So this meant, quite simply, that something was wrong.
Solanda let herself be held for a moment, then she turned her head toward the door and flattened her ears. Esmerelda, smart child that she was, understood both signals. She pushed the door closed, and then let Solanda go.
Solanda jumped on the windowsill. Esmerelda followed her, but didn’t open the window like she usually did.
The room was hot and sticky. Solanda wouldn’t be able to stay here too long if that window wasn’t opened.
“I don’t dare,” Esmerelda said softly. “Mommy’s really mad at me. She didn’t even let me have dinner.”
Now Solanda was interested, but she didn’t want the story, not yet. She bumped her head against the window’s bubbled glass.
Esmerelda bit her lower lip and shook her head.
Solanda placed a paw on the glass and meowed softly.
“Okay,” Esmerelda whispered. “But if anyone comes, I’ll have to close it.”
Solanda almost nodded, then caught herself. When Esmerelda came close, Solanda bumped her affectionately with her head, and then watched as the little girl pulled the window open.
A cool breeze made its way inside. That was the other nice thing about this house. Esmerelda’s room opened onto a large undeveloped area, so the smells of the outdoors came in strong. Breezes were unencumbered. Esmerelda’s mother hated this, and often wished for close neighbors, but Solanda saw it for the blessing it was.
Esmerelda knelt down beside the window and put her elbows on the sill. She didn’t touch Solanda, but she was still a bit too close. Her body heat was ruining the breeze.
“I been so bad,” she said, “I won’t get to go outside ever again.”
Solanda watched her. The little girl had never been able to resist a cat’s gaze. Solanda had never seen a child who was so very lonely. Esmerelda wasn’t allowed to play—except with dolls whose clothing was frilly as the stuff she was trussed in—nor was she allowed to associate with the neighboring children who were, in her parents’ mind, beneath her. She had lessons in poetry and music, art and dancing, but she liked none of it. What she really wanted to do was run as far as she could, and climb trees and learn how to swim.
She’d probably never get to achieve those goals.
“I was running this afternoon,” Esmerelda said. Her face was wistful. She leaned her forehead against the glass. “Mommy was looking at fruit and I thought I could just go around the block, but she saw me. I guess she followed me.”
Esmerelda had done this before, and it hadn’t gotten her sent to bed with no supper. Solanda suspected the problem had something to do with the rip in the dress. Clothing was sacred, at least to this family. Solanda wanted to tear every piece so that this little girl could be free.
“She saw me fall.” Esmerelda said, fingering her skirt. “She saw me hit a Fey.”
Solanda stiffened. She almost asked who, and caught herself. Two near lapses in one conversation. She was getting much too relaxed with this child.
Esmerelda ran a soft hand over Solanda’s head. Her touch was gentle again, as it had always been before.
“She said she was the Black King’s granddaughter, and she yelled at Mommy for dressing me the way she did. And Mom yelled back. The lady said yelling at her was like yelling at all the Fey all at once.”
Only one Fey woman could make that claim. Jewel. No wonder Esmerelda’s mother was upset.
“And then Mommy told Daddy and he said that the Fey might hurt us. Because I ran.” A tear coursed down Esmerelda’s cheek.
And those fools were blaming the child for being a child. Solanda pushed against the girl’s hand, and Esmerelda sniffled.
“I didn’t mean to run. I just can’t stay still sometimes.”
Solanda understood that. She could never stay still. It was a curse of being a Shifter. It was the reason Fey wisdom said that Shifters were the most heartless of the Fey. Most Shifters did not have children, and most rarely stayed anywhere long enough to form a real relationship.
Esmerelda sighed. “I wish I was like you. I do what I want. Or like that Fey lady. She was nice to me. She didn’t like Mommy though.”
Neither did Solanda.
“She said children shouldn’t be dressed like me. She said I ran into her because my clothing didn’t let me run properly.”
Probably true, Solanda thought.
“And that made Mommy really mad.”
Esmerelda let her hand slide off Solanda’s neck. She bunched her hands into fists and rested her chin on them, looking fierce and strong. Solanda felt her whiskers twitch in amusement. One day, Esmerelda’s parents would no longer be able to control this child. If she was this strong, articulate, and intelligent at five, she would be impossible to control at fifteen.
Especially with all of the Fey influence around her.
“I wish I had magic,” the little girl said. “Just a little bit. Then I could run and no one would know. I’d make myself invisible and no one would see me.”
Solanda looked out the window, knowing her expression was too sympathetic for a cat. There was a ring of oaks at the edge of the lawn. They were blowing in the breeze. Maybe there would be another storm. Maybe this storm would finally cool the place off, although she doubted it. Nye’s hot season was the worst she had encountered in any country she had ever been in.
“Esmerelda!” her mother’s voice echoed from the hallway. “Why is your door closed?”
Esmerelda gasped and pulled down the window so quickly she almost caught Solanda’s tail in it. Then she leaped onto the bed, stretching out. Solanda jumped beside her and curled up at her feet just as Esmerelda’s mother opened the door.
The woman’s face was flushed. She looked like a tomato about to burst. She was so tightly corseted that her body looked flat, and Solanda wondered how the woman could even breathe. She wore an evening dress of white satin that accented the redness of her face. The sides were lined with sweat.
“What are you doing?” she asked. Then she frowned. “How did that mangy cat get in here?”
Solanda growled softly in the back of her throat. She was not mangy. And the woman had never called her that before.
“I told you that you were supposed to be in here by yourself to think about what you did today. Things could have been much worse. Fortunately, she was in good mood. You know what those people can do? Why it’s said they can cut the skin off a person with the flick of—”
Solanda yowled, and the woman stepped back, a hand over her heart. Esmerelda sat up, worry on her small face.
“Are you okay, Goldie?”
Solanda licked her right paw as if she had twisted it. She was not going to let that woman tell this little girl about Fey atrocities—even if they were true.
“Come on, Goldie,” Esmerelda’s mother said. “There’s some beef for you in the kitchen.”
Usually that would have gotten Solanda off the bed. But she could sneak down after everyone was asleep and take what she needed. Right now, she wanted to stay beside Esmerelda.
“Goldie,” the woman said.
Esmerelda, good child that she was, bit her lower lip and said nothing. She didn’t beg for the company that she obviously wanted.
“Goldie!” her mother sounded exasperated now. Then she shook her head. “Why do we put up with this animal?”
Neither Solanda nor Esmerelda answered.
Finally Esmerelda’s mother sighed. “All right, she can stay. But I do expect you to sleep in that dress tonight and to think about how you could have hurt us all. That rip should be a reminder of the danger your misbehavior put us in. Nye isn’t the place it used to be, child. Do something wrong, and those Fey will harm all of us.”
Then she pulled the door closed, and Solanda heard the boards creak as she made her way down the stairs.
Esmerelda’s fingers played with the rip. Solanda looked at it, then crossed the bed, took the skirt in her teeth and pulled. The rip grew. Esmerelda giggled, then covered her mouth. Solanda pulled harder. If the little girl had to sleep in these clothes, she might as well be comfortable.
Esmerelda ripped the pantaloons too, along the dirt line, giggling as she did so. “Mommy will think I did it when I was running,” she said. “You’re so smart, Goldie.”
Of course she was. Solanda preened and allowed herself to be petted one more time.
Then Esmerelda looked at the door, her smile fading. “Sometimes I think Mommy doesn’t want me. She wants somebody else. Somebody perfect.”
Too bad she didn’t realize that the child she had was better than perfect. Solanda sighed softly. Some people had more than they deserved.
The idea came to her in the middle of the night, in that hot and stuffy room. She could take Esmerelda away, and Esmerelda’s parents wouldn’t even know it had happened. But it would take the cooperation of the Fey Domestics.
Fey magic was divided into two parts: warrior and domestic. Warrior magic was designed for warfare. Some Fey magic turned its practitioner into a weapon, like the Foot Soldiers who had fingernails that could slice better than a blade. Domestic magic could not be used to fight any war. Domestics lost their magic if they killed. Their magics were healing magics or home-bound magics, such as spells that made chairs more inviting or fires warmer.
The next morning, after making certain that Esmerelda got breakfast, Solanda slipped out the cat door. She went to the Domicile that the Fey Domestics had set up just outside of town. The Domicile had been built especially for the Domestics, and covered with various protection and healing spells. It was a traditional U-shaped building—with hearth and home magics in one length of the U, the healing wards in the other, and the middle section as a meeting place in between.
Solanda usually didn’t seek out the Domestics. They always wanted to experiment with her—have her try on a new cloak covered with some sort of rain protection or have her taste a new food to see if it had an effect on her Shifting. The last time she had been in a Domicile had been when she had broken a paw jumping from a tree in one of the last Nye battles. The Domestics had mended the bone, and had given her a smelly ointment she had to apply in cat form. She had thought the stench alone would kill her.
As she mounted the steps to the center part of the building, she shook off her paws. Here she would not Shift to Fey form. The Domestics weren’t as obsessed with power as Rugar was, so she didn’t have to use her height as a reminder of the strength of her magic.
She pushed open the door and stepped inside.
The air was cool and welcoming. It smelled of a sea breeze. Bits of magic floated in the air. Spinner’s magic. They were working on their looms. She could hear the hum just down the corridor.
A Baker entered, his fingers dusted with flour. They glowed. And she knew he had spelled the bread he’d been baking to remain fresh for as long as possible. It was a traveling spell, one most often used when troops were heading off to battle. She wondered if someone had requested it.
“I’m here to see Chadn.”
The Baker nodded, then slipped through a door that led to the Healing part of the Domicile. Solanda hopped onto a chair. Her mood rose and she cursed, jumping down. She didn’t need to be spelled, to wait, happy and contented, on a chair dusted with Domestic magic. Instead she paced the cool floor and wondered why she couldn’t smell the baking bread.
Finally Chadn entered the room. She was a young Shaman, although the toll of her power had already turned her hair white. Her face was wizened, her mouth a small oval amid wrinkles. Only her eyes were bright—sparkling black circles of light in a ruined face.
She had been assigned to stay with Rugar during the war and she was happy to be free of him. Shaman were the most independent Fey: their Vision as strong as those of the Leaders, but their magic Domestic so they could not rule a warrior people. They were the wise ones, the advisors, supposedly the strength behind the Black Throne. The Black King required a Shaman of his son, but did not use one himself. He had dismissed his own, years ago, for disobeying him. It was one of many areas where the Black King broke with tradition.
“Solanda,” Chadn said. “I had hoped to see you.”
Solanda jumped on an end table and was relieved that her mood did not change. She sat on her haunches and looked into Chadn’s face.
“I have a request,” she said. “It’s for a Nyeian child.”
“A child?” Chadn sounded surprised. “Not a Fey child?”
Solanda shook her head.
“I had Seen you with a Fey child.”
The Shaman’s Visions—and the Vision that leaders like the Black King had—allowed them glimpses into the future. Some said that the glimpses allowed the Visionary to change the future. Others believed that the glimpses led the Visionary to that future.
Solanda’s eyes narrowed. “I have not been with a Fey child.”
Chadn nodded. “It was on Blue Isle. The child was a Shifter, and you kept her from death.”
Solanda’s whiskers twitched. “I told Rugar I would not go to Blue Isle with him.”
“The future of our people lies with you, Solanda.”
“And a child?” Solanda raised her chin. “Are you sure it was a Fey child?”
“Not entirely,” Chadn said. “The child had blue eyes.”
Solanda gave a soft grunt of surprise. She had heard of blue-eyed people, but she had never seen one. “The child couldn’t be Nyeian?”
“She was Fey, and newborn. She had a birthmark on her chin. Only her eyes were strange, and perhaps that was because of the Shifting. I Saw you put your hands on her lips, and swear to protect her, raise her, and make her strong. Then I Saw her full grown, saying you had been the closest thing she had to a mother.”
Solanda laughed, although inside she felt cold. A Shifter only swore to protect a child who held the future of the Empire. A blue-eyed child that Shifted? The center of the Empire?
“Visions can be altered,” Solanda said. “I am not leaving Nye.”
“You may have no choice.”
“I’ll always have a choice,” Solanda said.
Chadn inclined her head toward Solanda as if giving in on that point. “What does the Nyeian child need?”
Solanda took a deep breath. “She is different from any other Nyeian I’ve seen. Strong, independent. She met Jewel yesterday and is being punished for it. I would like to remove the child from her family and bring her here, to be raised among us. She will be useful when she’s grown. She will be part of the second-generation, the Nyeians that rule Nye for the Fey.”
Chadn stared at her for a moment. “So take her. Shifters steal children.”
“This one’s mother will raise a fuss if she’s gone.”
“What mother wouldn’t?”
“She’ll come to us.”
“And you can’t prove to the Black King that we must keep the child.”
“Not yet, anyway,” Solanda said.
Chadn folded her hands over her stomach. “You want a Changeling.”
“Yes,” Solanda said.
“How old is the child?”
“Five.”
Chadn sighed. “Have you asked the child if she’s willing to leave?”
“Not yet. I wanted to know if I have help first.”
“You will keep the child at your side?”
Solanda frowned. That wasn’t a normal request. Shifters rarely kept children. They usually brought them to Domestics to raise. “Must I?”
“At five, it will be you she trusts.”
Solanda shrugged. “Then she shall stay with me.”
“And you will stay away from Blue Isle.” Chadn said that not as a question, but as a statement.
“Rugar will not let a Nyeian child in his war party.”
“So the child serves two purposes.” Chadn’s eyes narrowed. “Has she magic?”
“Of course not.” Solanda laughed. “There is not magic outside the Fey.”
Chadn frowned. “I am no longer certain of that.”
“Because you Saw a blue-eyed Shifter?”
“Because I Saw a great war, coming when we least expect it.”
“War is part of Fey life.” Solanda jumped off the table and headed for the door. “I’ll bring you news of the child tomorrow.”
“I’ll have Changeling stone ready,” Chadn said. “But realize before you act, that this is for life.”
“I already know that,” Solanda said. “I have chosen well.”
“I hope so,” Chadn said.
Solanda went to the docks and sat on a fence. She loved it here. The Infrin Sea formed the most natural harbor on Galinas, and there was always some sort of activity. Toward the north end of the harbor, the Nyeian builders made the great ships. Those ships traveled all over the known world, and now Fey Domestics helped unload cargo that would go all over the Empire.
Ships from Blue Isle had stopped coming to Nye when news reached them of the Fey takeover. She would never see an Islander, never learn more about them than she already had.
And that would be all right.
For there were some things she couldn’t discuss with Rugar’s Shaman. Like the prophecies that had been made by another Shaman at Solanda’s birth, prophecies that claimed her legacy would be in the children she saved.
Children—not child, like Chadn had seen. Solanda would influence the life of more than one.
The breeze was cooler here, carrying with it the smell of salt and a tinge of dead fish. That smell made her stomach rumble. She tried not to think of the things she ate in her cat form, things she would find disgusting when she was in Fey form. Right now, raw dead fish sounded extremely appetizing.
But she didn’t go in search of the source of the smell. She had some thinking to do. Prophecies and Visions made her nervous. She had no idea what to do with the information Chadn had given her. Because, at various points in her life, Solanda had been told by Visionaries that her future held contradictory things.
One Shaman had told her she had to avoid the Black Family for she would kill a Black Heir. Another Shaman had told her she would raise a Black Heir. And now Chadn had Seen her swear to protect a blue-eyed Shifter, a newborn who couldn’t survive on her own.
Solanda bowed her head. The prophecy she never mentioned, the one her parents had kept silent, had come the day of her birth and she had never forgotten it. The prophecy was a cold one: she would die before her time, far from home, for a crime she did not regret.
The Fey did not believe in crime. They were constantly at war, so the crimes that plagued other races—murder, theft—were absorbed into the wars themselves. The Fey only punished two crimes: treason and failure. Both of those crimes were considered crimes against the Empire. Failure was a large crime, encompassing the failure to follow an order, or the failure to defeat an enemy in a prolonged battle.
Treason was any crime against the Black Family and was such a heresy, that it wasn’t even discussed among rational Fey.
Both crimes bore the penalty of death.
It seemed to her that she would never commit crimes like that, that the prophecies had come because she was a Shifter, not because of her character. She wasn’t as flighty or as difficult as anyone said she was.
And besides, she had to take care of Esmerelda.
She wished she could be there the morning that Esmerelda’s parents discovered the Changeling. It would look like Esmerelda, even act like her—if stone could act like a living breathing creature. But it would only last a few days, and then it would cease to exist. They would think Esmerelda dead, when, in actuality, she was only gone.
Then, perhaps, that wretch of a mother would regret how she treated her daughter.
Esmerelda would live a life she couldn’t even imagine now. She wouldn’t have to wear six layers of clothes on the hottest day of the year, and she would learn how to live life to its fullest instead of remaining indoors and studying all the time.
Esmerelda would be the closest thing to Fey that a Nyeian could be—and for the first time in her young life, she would be happy. Solanda would see to that.
They would both be very happy.
Solanda returned to the house after dinner. Ultimately, she found she couldn’t resist the dead fish that were piled near one of the docks. She had eaten herself sick, and then had to clean every inch of her fur before she even attempted the walk home.
Not that the house was home. In some ways, Esmerelda was.
Solanda used the cat door. Esmerelda’s parents were talking softly in the parlor.
“Perhaps boarding school,” the mother was saying. “If she is this incorrigible now, imagine what she’ll be like when she gets older.”
“Give it time, darling,” the husband said. “She’s still a child. She will learn, as we all did.”
“It’s just I despair of ever teaching her manners. You didn’t see her with that Fey….”
Solanda had heard enough. She hurried up the stairs. She would talk to Esmerelda tonight. Tomorrow the Wisps would come, carrying a bit of stone in their tiny fingers. They’d fly in the open window, leave the stone on the bed and it would mold itself into a replica of Esmerelda while Solanda was leading the real Esmerelda out of the house.
Quick, neat, and completely perfect. The parents wouldn’t have to worry about manners or boarding school. Esmerelda would get her heart’s desire. And Solanda would have her reason for staying in Nye.
The door to Esmerelda’s room was open. Esmerelda sat beneath a lamp, a long skirt over her lap. The air was stuffier than usual, and Solanda saw that the window was closed.
It had probably been closed all day. Sunlight had poured in, and the poor child had had to sit in the heat, working on some task her mother assigned her.
When Solanda got close, she saw what it was. The child was attempting to mend her own ripped dress.
The stitches were uneven, and Esmerelda had stitched the bottom layer of fabric onto the top. That would make her mother even angrier. Esmerelda’s eyelashes were stuck together, her nose was red, and there were tearstains along her cheeks.
“Goldie!” she said, and let the dress topple to the floor. She was wearing another dress, equally inappropriate to the hot weather. She reached for Solanda, but Solanda jumped onto the windowsill.
She was not going to be hugged by a hot sweaty child—not, at least, until the window was open and the fresh air came inside.
Esmerelda glanced toward the door. She put a finger to her lips, as if she thought Solanda were going to give her away, and then called, “Mommy! Can I go to sleep now?”
Solanda froze in her spot. She didn’t want to be seen in here, not tonight. She wanted to have her conversation with Esmerelda in private.
“Are you done with your dress, darling?”
“Yes.”
Solanda looked at it. The dress was ruined. The poor girl would have an even more difficult day than usual tomorrow.
“Then blow out the lamp. Good night.”
“Good night.” Esmerelda pushed the door closed. Then she went over to the window and opened it.
A strong breeze came in, and on it, Solanda smelled rain. Maybe, after she spoke to Esmerelda, she would go outside. By then it would be raining, and she would be able to cool down.
Esmerelda put her hand over the lamp’s chimney and blew. The flame inside the glass went out. Solanda blinked in the darkness, letting her eyes adjust. It only took a moment. There were clouds over the moon this night, and it was very dark.
Esmerelda went back to her chair. “I wish you knew how to sew, Goldie.”
“I don’t,” Solanda said. “But I know someone who does.”
Esmerelda let out a small yelp, and put her hands over her mouth. She peered around the room as if looking for the source of the voice.
Solanda had to go slowly with this. The child wasn’t used to magic, not like Fey children were.
“I could take the dress to her tonight,” Solanda said, “and by morning, you wouldn’t even know there had been a rip in it.”
Esmerelda’s eyes were wide. She finally turned in Solanda’s direction. “You can talk, Goldie?”
“As well as I can listen.” Solanda jumped from the windowsill to the bed. The room had cooled down. The fresh air felt marvelous. “What would you think, Esmerelda, if I took you to a place where you could wear comfortable clothes, play with children your own age, run and jump and swim to your heart’s content? What if I told you that you would never have to sew another stitch, have another music lesson, or sit in a corner when you’ve done something that your mother didn’t like.”
Esmerelda looked for her, but clearly didn’t see her. Cat’s eyes were far superior in the dark. Solanda watched the child lick her lips, rub her hand over her knees, and then sigh.
“How long would I stay?” Esmerelda asked.
“Forever,” Solanda said.
“Would I have to be a cat?”
Solanda laughed. For all her verbal sophistication, Esmerelda was still a child at heart. “No,” Solanda said. “You’ll stay just as you are.”
“Would Mommy come?”
“No.”
“Daddy?”
“No.”
Esmerelda’s shoulders stiffened. Her little body looked rigid. “Who would love me then?”
Solanda started. She hadn’t expected that question. “I would be with you,” she said.
Esmerelda was silent, as if she were thinking this over. “Where would you take me?”
“To my people,” Solanda said.
“I’d live with cats?”
“No,” she said gently. “With the Fey.”
Esmerelda gasped. She held onto her chair as if she expected to be dragged from it.
Solanda wondered if she should have said that, but she had never taken a child before. Certainly she knew of no one who had ever taken a child of this age.
But Chadn had said she had had to speak with the child, and the choice to come had to be the child’s. There was sense in that. Esmerelda, at age five, would always have a memory of living with her parents. She needed a memory of her choice to leave them.
“Esmerelda,” Solanda said. “I—”
“No!” Esmerelda screamed. “No!”
She launched herself out of her chair as if her voice had given the ability to move again.
“Help! Mommy! Help!”
Solanda’s ears went back. She hadn’t expected this from Esmerelda, not her sane, different child.
“Esmerelda, I only want to give you a better life—”
“Mommy! Daddy! Help!”
Finally Esmerelda pulled the door open and blundered into the hallway. Solanda followed, tail between her legs, ears still back. The little girl’s screams echoed down the stairs. Her parents had reached her, and they both put their arms around her. Esmerelda was too terrified to be coherent.
Then the mother looked up the stairs. She saw Solanda, her gaze flat.
And Solanda realized she had no choice.
She Shifted, her body lengthening, her tail disappearing, her fur becoming skin.
Then she walked, naked, to the floor below.
Esmerelda’s mother gathered her child in her arms and backed away. The father placed himself in front of his small family, arms out.
“You came from the Black King, didn’t you?” the woman said. “To punish us by stealing our child.”
“It’s not about you,” Solanda said.
Esmerelda peeked around her father, eyes wide. Solanda had never, in her entire life, been so conscious of her nakedness.
“Wh-what do you want?” the father asked. He was trying to sound brave. Like most Nyeians, he was failing.
“I had hoped to take your daughter, but it seems that she prefers this place, even though you treat her as less than house pet. It seems, for reasons I cannot understand, that she loves you.”
“Of course she does,” the woman said. “We’re her parents.”
“As if that’s a divine right.” Solanda stopped on the middle stair.
The family cringed below her as if they expected her to strike them with a lightning bolt. She didn’t have that kind of magic. They had seen the extent of her powers, but apparently they didn’t know that.
“She is a child,” Solanda said. “She is to run and play. She is to have friends of her own age. She is to have comfortable clothing so that she can move without tripping. She is supposed to get dirty, to rip her skirts, and fall on her behind. She is to have some joy in her life. Do you understand?”
“I thought you Fey were supposed to leave us alone,” the mother said. “I thought—”
“Be quiet,” the father said.
Esmerelda clung to her father, her curiosity moving her closer.
“You will give her those things,” Solanda said, “or I will take her from you. Do you understand?”
“Yes,” the father said.
“You can’t do this,” the mother said. “You can’t change our customs. The Black King promised you wouldn’t.”
“A promise made to a conquered people is worth nothing,” Solanda snapped. “You will do what I say, or the child is mine.”
“Mommy.” Esmerelda reached for her mother. Solanda’s eyes narrowed. Couldn’t she see that her mother saw her only as a thing to be trained, to be forced into the right and proper life?
Probably not. It was too sophisticated a concept for her. The same innocence that allowed Esmerelda to accept a cat’s speech, allowed her to believe that she was loved.
“Do I take her now?” Solanda asked.
“No,” the father said. “We’ll do as you say.”
“But our friends—”
“Shut up,” the father snapped. “Do you want to lose her?”
For a moment, the mother’s gaze met Solanda’s and in it, Solanda saw something she recognized, a coolness perhaps, a calculation. How would that woman have answered if she had been asked who would love me then? Would she have dodged the answer like Solanda had? Or would she have heard it at all?
“She will stay with us,” the woman said. She sounded resigned.
Solanda felt a hope she hadn’t even known she had die inside her. “Then I’ll watch. You will treat that child as if she is more precious than gold. And if you fail, even once, she’s mine. Is that clear?”
“Yes,” the father said.
But Solanda did not take her gaze from the mother.
“Yes,” the woman said.
Esmerelda had stepped to her father’s side. She was still holding his leg. “Are you Goldie?” she asked.
Solanda gave her a small, private smile. “Only for you.”
The little girl slipped behind her father again. Her answer was clear, too. She would stay, no matter what. And Solanda had done all she could.
So she Shifted back to her cat form. For a moment, she watched them all, tail twitching, then she ran up the stairs and into Esmerelda’s room. She stopped for only a moment, knowing she would never return.
She leapt onto the windowsill, and sighed. She had just lost her excuse for staying on Nye. She was bound to the Black Family. She had to do as they wished.
Rugar wanted her to go to Blue Isle.
Where a Shifter awaited her care. A newborn child, with blue eyes. A child who would think her the closest thing she’d ever had to a mother.
Solanda looked over her shoulder. She heard Esmerelda’s voice, high, piping, excited; the soft answers of her parents. Solanda had lied to them. She would not be able to watch.
She hoped they would take good care of her little girl.
Then she jumped out the window, and climbed along a tree branch. Maybe her future had been preordained. Maybe she had no choice. She would raise a Black Heir, maybe kill one, and influence children.
How different would tonight have been if she had told the child that she would love her?
She would never know. Perhaps that was the moment in which everything could have changed. Maybe she had just missed her only chance to save herself.
____________________________________________
DestinyCopyright © 2012 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in French as “Destin” in Faeries: Toutes Les Fantasy, Hiver 2000-2001 First published in English in Creature Fantastic, edited by Denise Little, Daw Books, 2001Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2012 by WMG PublishingCover and layout design by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © 2012 by Dirk Berger
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
We just launched a Kickstarter for The Incident at Serebro Academy. It is the next Fey novel after Barkson’s Journey. However, you don’t have to read Barkson’s Journey to enjoy this one.
You see, most of the books in the Qavnerian Protectorate series (which is a side series off the main Fey) happen at the same time. So, you can read these next three books in any order you want. (I prefer my order, but hey, I’m just the writer.)
Here’s the blurb for The Incident at Serebro Academy:
THE FEY ATTACK
A grisly ambush at Serebro Academy starts a race to uncover secrets that might save the Academy or destroy it entirely.
Magical maps, Fey spies, treachery and dangerous secrets. A stunning fantasy—impossible to put down.
This thrilling page-turner continues Rusch’s masterful melding of epic fantasy and steampunk while demonstrating once again her place as one of the greatest storytellers of our time.
The Kickstarter contains all of these books and a lot more, like the map and mugs and even more books. So head on over and get a copy of The Incident at Serebro Academy before anyone else.
Don’t Like Kickstarter?
And for those of you who aren’t Kickstarter fans, but want to order the book, it’s up for preorder on your favorite stores. My favorite is World of the Fey, which also has a lot of the goodies that are in the Kickstarter. So here’s the link to the store. After you’ve ordered The Incident at Serebro Academy, poke around. You’ll find all kinds of fun stuff.
Lots to enjoy here! I hope you will.
When a notorious local developer claims to own the home of the late Olivia, her neighbors band together to stop him. But as they each work to thwart the developer, secrets pile on secrets until everyone finds themselves with something to hide.
“Olivia’s House” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Olivia’s Houseby Kristine Kathryn RuschOlivia died on Thursday. By Monday, the vultures had swooped in.
To be fair, though, the vultures had already settled in this desirable little corner of Las Vegas real estate.
Arlie wiped a hand over her forehead and stood in front of her open garage door, watching the parade of Mercedes, BMW SUVs, and shiny new oversized trucks ostensibly used for construction. These men—and they all seemed to be men—never really did any construction, not like Arlie and her wife, Babette, did. Arlie and Babette worked alongside any contractor they hired, climbing on the roof, inspecting the attic, and frowning at the termite damage near the patio doors.
The pest services people had left days ago, their bill on the as-of-yet-un-remodeled kitchen counter, next to the gigantic bill for the asbestos remediation in the bedrooms, living room, and formal dining room.
The house, which had looked so perfect a year ago, had all kinds of secrets hidden in its walls, and not the kind that inspired Arlie to daydream about who might have visited here, who might have performed on that baby grand piano that the previous owners sold with the house, or who might have lounged around the (at the moment empty and in desperate need of remodeling) kidney-shaped pool.
She still loved the house, but she was in the middle of a major remodel, and the middle of a remodel always brought up a twinge of buyer’s remorse.
Sweat ran down her back. Her thin, long-sleeved shirt clung to her arms like the sawdust from 2x6s she was trimming on the back porch. She had come to the garage to grab a broom and the wet vac when she saw all the vehicles pull in across the street.
The houses in this ancient (by Vegas standards) subdivision sat back from the winding road that circled each little sub-neighborhood. Arlie’s house sat at the end of a cul-de-sac, with Olivia’s house on one side and an even older ranch-style home on the other side.
All the original trees, expensive grass, and tall fences ensured that she hadn’t even heard the vehicles pull up. She used to joke with Babette that if Olivia wanted to hold one of those exclusive 1960s Vegas parties this little corner of the subdivision had been known for, Arlie and Babette wouldn’t have heard a thing.
But Olivia hadn’t held a party in decades. There probably hadn’t been that many vehicles in front of Olivia’s house since the 90s.
Arlie wiped her sawdust-covered hands on the back of her khaki work pants. She was standing in just enough shade to keep the vicious Vegas sun off her face. But it was still hot out here.
The huge black truck parked directly across from the opening in the beautiful (old) adobe fence started rocking. Then the driver’s door opened, and Leighton Taylor swung out.
Her heart sank.
Leighton owned the nightmare monstrosity at the curve leading into this particular cul-de-sac. Not only did Leighton’s contractors fail to water down their dirt when they dug or worked, getting grit all over this part of the neighborhood, but they also worked at all hours, making the monstrosity worse, not better. At the moment, it was probably at its best (which wasn’t saying much), a partially built 8,000-square-foot series of cubes the architect Leighton hired called a house.
And worst of all, its eastern end butted up against Olivia’s property. At least the construction was on the opposite side of the house from her beautiful bedroom, so she hadn’t heard most of the construction noise, although she had complained (softly) that the beep-beep-beep of vehicles in reverse awakened her most mornings.
Leighton’s building didn’t fit in the subdivision, but it wasn’t the only building that looked different. Sahara Circle, built in the 1950s, was one of the first subdivisions in the entire Vegas Valley.
In its heyday, Sahara Circle was the place for the rich and famous. It was not too far off the growing Strip and yet secluded, where the kids of the rich and famous could grow up in what they claimed to be an idyllic 1960s world.
Idyllic for straight white people, anyway. Arlie was painfully aware that she and Babette wouldn’t have been able to live here when the subdivision was built. She had seen their inclusion in this still-idyllic part of Old Vegas as a win for modernity—even though, Babette had pointed out, that they were both white and back in the day, they would have been considered eccentric spinsters who combined their resources to live “economically” in the manner to which they had become accustomed.
Leighton didn’t look like a mid-century mogul, either. He was long and rangy but lacked the sun-weathered skin that marked him as someone who actually did physical labor. Up close, his face was fleshy, and his eyes were generally puffy from either too little sleep or too much drink.
Arlie and Leighton had clashed from the moment they met because she had made the mistake of asking him what he thought of the “piece of crap” down the street. He had given her a dismissive smile that the wealthy seemed to learn at birth.
“That piece of crap is mine,” he replied.
She had flushed, but she hadn’t apologized. The neighborhood was historic, even if Vegas hadn’t yet designated it that way, and the houses were all built in a 1950s, 60s, or 70s style. Even the more architecturally daring homes had that mid-century vibe.
But Sahara Circle was built before subdivisions realized they needed HOAs that everyone had to sign onto, a limited range of designs, and even approved colors and landscaping.
Arlie and Babette hadn’t known about the lack of regulation when they bought their home, nor had they known that rich assholes like Leighton could buy in and then bulldoze the original homes. Initially, Arlie had thought Leighton was building on one of the few empty lots left in the city. It was only later, while talking to Olivia, Arlie learned that a sister home to hers had existed just a few houses away.
Olivia. When Arlie and Babette bought their house a year ago, Olivia had been a spry 85-year-old. Then she had a fall, which occasioned an MRI and some X-rays that showed something cancerous—Arlie never caught the details—and about the time the asbestos company had finished their remediation, Olivia was confined to her bed.
Arlie visited, of course. She learned all the good current gossip, all the even better ancient gossip, and all the scary gossip as well, learned who had affairs, and who drank too much, who turned a large fortune into a small fortune, and who had mob ties back in the day. Arlie learned who had passed through the neighborhood, which celebrities lived where once upon a time, and whose kids sold off too cheap.
Olivia never said anything about her own kids, and they never visited, not once, not after Olivia’s diagnosis, not during her treatments, and certainly not in her last weeks. Arlie had offered to call, and Olivia had shaken her head with a sad smile.
“What’s done is done,” she had said, “and no maudlin deathbed conversations will repair it.”
For all the gossip, Arlie had never learned what “it” was, although she had hoped to get a glimmer of it at the funeral. But no. The kids hadn’t shown up for that either, although the entire neighborhood had, as well as the members of half the charity and arts boards in the city.
Arlie let out a breath as another bead of sweat ran down her back. The early afternoon didn’t provide a lot of shade, and the Las Vegas summer sun had a bite to it, a literal bite. Still, she walked down her cracked driveway to see if she could figure out what Leighton and his minions were doing.
Although she had a hunch. She had an awful, horrible hunch.
Leighton’s gaze met hers as if he expected to see her there. Maybe he did. Maybe one of his minions had told him she was there, watching him.
“Don’t worry.” His tone had that edge it always had when he was talking to her. “We won’t block your view.”
She blinked and frowned. There really was no view to block. Her house was a one-story ranch behind a high fence with old palm trees and lots of planted vegetation. She couldn’t see Olivia’s house except when the gate was open, the way it was now.
Then the realization dawned, but she played ignorant because she knew that with people like Leighton, playing ignorant was often the best way to get information.
“Your place can’t block my view,” she said, “no matter how high you go up.”
His smile was cruel. “I meant here. Across the street. We own this now.”
“Oh, good,” she said, even though she didn’t feel it. “Someone with money who already has a finger in the neighborhood. The house just needs a little TLC to be brought back to its former glory.”
“There was no former glory,” Leighton said. “It’s a goddamn ranch house. Tacky and old. It’s goin’ down. Not sure what I’ll do with the lot yet, but I like having the room for expansion.”
Even though she had expected him to say that, her stomach twisted. She hoped the loathing she felt for him didn’t reach her face.
“You bought Olivia’s house,” Arlie said, confirming what she had just heard. She was doing her best to keep her tone neutral so that he wouldn’t see just how much the idea of it rocked her.
“Yeah. I bought the house,” he said in a low, confidential tone, “pretty much before the old lady died. The kids didn’t want the place, so I had an offer in months ago. Made it possible to finalize once the estate paperwork is done.”
Months ago. While Arlie and Babette were talking about what they would do if the house came up for sale. If their finances could handle another payment, another expensive remodel. They loved the neighborhood, and Arlie had loved the house. It was a treasure, with lots of little nooks and crannies and expensive one-of-a-kind details.
“The kids are so sure they’re going to inherit?” Arlie asked. Because she wasn’t.
“Yep.” Leighton smirked. “She has no other heirs.”
“But the will hasn’t gone through probate yet,” Arlie said. Not that she would know. It was a guess.
“Minor details,” Leighton said. His smirk grew. “But I promise. We won’t mess with the view.”
“Is that supposed to have some hidden meaning?” she asked.
His smirk turned into a half-smile of contempt. “It means that’s all I can promise. Except that the piece of crap house is coming down as soon as the legal work is finished.”
She didn’t nod. She could barely move. He had used the words “piece of crap” just to goad her.
“If the estate isn’t settled, how did you get a key?” she asked.
He shrugged a single shoulder. “Don’t have one. Just walking the outside.”
He winked at her, then pivoted and headed back to his abomination of a truck. She watched from the driveway, arms crossed, as the men gathered outside and talked, as they paced the ground, as they messed up the landscaping with their footsteps, as they forced a fence so they could get through, as they screwed everything up.
She watched until they were gone.
And then she went inside to talk to Babette.
Arlie was proud of herself: She didn’t burst into tears as she stepped into the cool darkness of the caterer’s kitchen, and she didn’t put her fist through a wall. In the past, she might have done either. Or both.
Babette was seated at a folding table they had set up in lieu of a kitchen table. She had peeled off her canvas work gloves and placed them in the pile of gloves that ran the gamut from yellow plastic cleaning gloves to leather ones so thick they could have been used as catcher’s mitts.
Babette was looking through bills and the original architectural rendering, which they had found in one of the built-in drawers in the super-sized laundry room.
Babette was tiny, with a buzz cut that usually showed off whatever flamboyant color she had dyed her hair. She had done rainbow hues for Pride Month but washed those out on the first of July. In past years, she had blended into the red, white, and blue, but she was mad at the direction of the country at the moment, so she let her hair return to its usual black.
“I told you it’s too hot to work out there,” she said without looking up.
Then she looked up and must have seen something on Arlie’s face because her next question was, “Now who died?”
Arlie took a moment before she answered the question because it poked at something. Who died? Olivia, but they knew that. Who else died? What else died was the better question. What else was the dream she had had of living in an idyllic 1960s suburb with her wife and her accepting neighbors, having barbeques in the summer and progressive dinners during the holidays, waving at each other over the fences, and knowing (and accepting) all the gossip as they retreated into their mid-century enclave at night, redesigning the entire place to a modern sensibility, not the one she and Babette had grown up in, the one that hadn’t accepted them at all.
This, Arlie realized, was a lot more personal than she had originally thought.
She poured herself a large glass of homemade lemonade before sitting down at the table. Then she told Babette what she had seen.
Babette’s pretty little mouth formed a moue in irritation, which grew into a raspberry and an expletive when Arlie told Babette what Leighton had actually said.
“There’s no way,” Babette said. “Legally, they can’t sell property they don’t own.”
The “they” in that sentence had to refer to the kids, who, it was becoming clear from the expressions on Babette’s face, were at fault for this entire mess.
If Olivia had been analyzing the mess, she would probably have blamed herself and that mysterious event or thing that had come between her and her children. But Arlie kept quiet about that. It was easier to blame the kids, and since they were still alive, it was logical as well.
A phone call wouldn’t stop them from selling the property to Leighton, and Arlie and Babette didn’t have enough money to compete with Leighton in some kind of bidding war. Arlie and Babette weren’t hurting; they had flipped enough houses all over Las Vegas to have a good reserve fund, and they got good money on the places they kept—good enough, anyway, to give them a healthy monthly income.
But a healthy monthly income couldn’t buy out an asshole like Leighton. That would take real money. And while Arlie and Babette knew a lot of Las Vegans with real money—folks who bought the ten million dollar homes in Summerlin and folks who made more money in a week than Leighton was spending on that monstrosity of a house—those folks wouldn’t help with this, partly because Arlie wasn’t going to ask.
No home inside Sahara Circle had been designated as historic. Vegas didn’t give out that distinction very often and had, thus far, avoided some of the early subdivisions. Besides, this place was technically in Clark County, not in Las Vegas proper. The differences between the two told a tale of annexations gone awry, lax laws in one area and tougher restrictions in another, and competing jurisdictions on everything from land management to wastewater restrictions, all of which drove Arlie quietly insane, particularly when she had to figure out which jurisdiction handled what issue.
But still, she had been looking forward to spending the rest of her life in this cul-de-sac, looking at the rehabilitated mid-century moderns around her, enjoying her fantasy subdivision, and dying, as Olivia had, in her own bedroom overlooking her lovely garden.
“I guess it’s time,” Babette said, setting the bills aside.
She spoke with such calm, such deliberation. Whenever Babette used that tone with Arlie, Arlie got nervous. But this wasn’t about Arlie. This was about the house—both houses, really. Theirs and Olivia’s.
After all, they weren’t trapped here. They could flip this house. They’d lose money because they were putting in finishes that didn’t belong in a flip, and they were paying a little too much attention to historical accuracy, but it was better to take a loss than be miserable forever.
However, losing the house—this house—might just break Arlie’s heart. And would that make her miserable forever? She wasn’t sure.
“Time for what?” she asked.
“Well,” Babette said, picking up the glass of lemonade that Arlie hadn’t yet touched, “we’ve been talking about the lack of a homeowners association since we got here. I guess it’s finally time to start one.”
Arlie half-smiled. “Sounds like a great solution except for one thing.”
“What’s that?” Babette asked, then sipped the lemonade.
“Leighton would be part of the association,” Arlie said.
“Well,” Babette said, shoving the glass toward Arlie with a bit of a grimace. Apparently, the lemonade was too tart for Babette. “Not technically.”
Arlie frowned at her. Usually, Arlie knew what Babette was thinking, but she couldn’t follow the logic.
“He doesn’t have a home here, now, does he?” Babette said. “That thing he’s building, it’s not finished. And it certainly doesn’t look like a home to me.”
Arlie grinned. Sometimes, Babette’s deviousness bordered on brilliant.
Then Arlie’s grin faded. She had always opposed homeowners’ associations. They got in the way of flips half the time, particularly when they had silly regulations, like what types of vehicles could be parked on the street when, even in the middle of construction.
“How on Earth would we start one?” she asked.
“Well,” Babette said, “it seems that we should call a meeting first and figure out the procedure second.”
“We can’t do it here in our house,” Arlie said. “Nothing’s finished.”
“I don’t see why not,” Babette said. “We have folding chairs. And air-conditioning. What else do we need?”
Apparently, they needed couches, end tables, and armchairs, as well as air conditioning. The meeting ended up at Derrick Houghton’s place down the street, and even though he insisted his living room was fine, everyone migrated to the massive kitchen. Ten neighbors—barely a quorum, under Roberts Rules of Order—sat around the breakfast bar, nursed beers and iced tea, and noshed on a vegetable tray with two kinds of sauces or charcuteries which had more choice than an appetizer at a restaurant.
Derrick was the single father of three teenage kids who were with their mother for the summer and “escaping the Vegas heat,” he said.
He was a slightly pudgy man who wore black socks with his sandals. That wasn’t his only fashion faux pas: he also seemed to prefer lime green shorts paired with lemon-colored shirts that he seemed to buy in bulk.
Arlie had yet to learn what he did for a living, although she had an idea that he lived off family money. Babette refused to speculate about the neighbors, which, in Arlie’s opinion, took all the fun out of living in a neighborhood.
In addition to Arlie and Babette, the Garcias from three buildings down had come. They were new to the subdivision as well and looked a little uncomfortable at the gathering. Rosalinda Garcia leaned against the kitchen island as if she needed it to hold her up, and her husband, Hernán, stood near the refrigerator as if he wanted to bolt out the back door.
Their closest neighbors, the Nguyens, stood across the kitchen from the Garcias. The Nguyens had lived here since the devastating real estate crash of 2009, which had destroyed much of the value of Las Vegas real estate.
Even though the Nguyens lived on a two-acre parcel near the gate, they owned four different houses here. The Nguyens upgraded all of them and rented them to high-end clients, usually celebrities who had residencies at Strip casinos.
Thao Nguyen looked like he had just come from his office. He didn’t specialize in real estate—that was his wife—but he had some kind of high-end job that required thousand-dollar suits, even in the summer heat. He didn’t look hot, even though he still wore the jacket over a pale orange shirt that shouldn’t have worked but did.
His wife Cam wore a sundress of the same orange. Arlie wondered if they coordinated. She also wore pale orange sandals with wide high heels that looked like they were made in the 1970s. Her hair was piled on top of her head, held in place with a bamboo barrette that matched the bangles on her arms and a ring on the middle finger of her right hand.
She was drumming her long fake nails on the countertop until Madison DeRoot caught the fingers in her own. Cam gave her a startled look, and Madison smiled apologetically, moving her hand away.
“Long day,” Madison said. “My nerves are frayed.”
Madison ran one of the largest financial services corporations in Nevada. Arlie had no idea if Madison owned it and couldn’t think of a good way to ask. Madison had clearly changed clothes after she got home from work. She wore a caftan and flat sandals that didn’t match. Her hair, which she wore up when she went to work, fell past her shoulders in unnatural blond waves.
“This may not help your nerves, then,” Babette said. The others would hear Babette’s comment as a concern. Only Arlie knew that tone from Babette meant that Babette was verging on irritation.
“I gotta hear what you propose,” Madison said. “Don’t wanna change the neighborhood too much.”
“Too late for that,” muttered Nancy Givens. She looked every day of her fifty-some years, although Arlie could still see a trace of the little girl whose picture had been used in a profile of the neighborhood done by Life Magazine back in the day.
Nancy had inherited her house from her parents and saw herself as the unofficial historian of the subdivision. The Nguyens told Arlie that initially, Nancy had led a fight to keep the neighborhood covenants in place—the ones that didn’t allow coloreds in the subdivision at all except as maids and gardeners.
When Arlie asked her about it, Nancy shrugged it off.
All of the developments re-examined their covenants about that time, she said. Remember? The press made a big deal about President Reagan’s homes having protective covenants about that point.
Arlie wasn’t buying homes when Reagan was president, but she had seen a lot of “protective” covenants, which only protected whites and were still on the books even now. She wanted to argue that Nancy had fought to get rid of the covenants, but language always gave people away. When Nancy had referred to the covenants as “protective,” Arlie knew that the gossip she had heard was correct.
Nancy was one of those people she imagined frowning on Arlie’s perfect subdivision, the one filled with more people like her and Babette and the Nguyens and the Garcias, and not with people like Nancy and Derrick—and Old Man Buckles, who sat on one of the kitchen chairs near the door.
Old Man Buckles—Jerry, doll, he’d said when she had introduced herself almost a year ago—had the shoe-leather skin that Leighton never would. Old Man Buckles didn’t look old, at least not physically. He had broad shoulders and a barrel chest, strong legs, and hands that were wide enough to hold dinner plates.
But his clothes were looser than they should have been, and the hems on his pants brushed the floor, suggesting that he had lost inches, as people did when they got older.
His blue eyes were bright, though, and if it weren’t for his shock of white hair and his yellowing teeth, she would have thought him in his fifties.
Olivia had called him a contemporary, so he had to be in his eighties.
He owned what had been the largest house in the subdivision until Leighton started building that nightmare. Old Man Buckles’s place had two wings off a center structure; each wing could have been a ranch house by itself. The center structure, like so many midcentury moderns, was focused on the driveway, the circular turnaround, and the four-car garage.
As far as Arlie could tell, he lived there alone. There was no fifth Mrs. Buckles. According to Olivia, the previous four wives had gotten away with half his fortune. The kids visited regularly—always, Olivia had said, hoping they would cozy up to him enough to get the full inheritance. It wasn’t hard to identify his kids either since the sons and, unfortunately, the daughters looked like out-of-shape versions of their dad.
Babette was handing out one sheet of paper with the proposal’s bullet points highlighted. After she had given everyone the highlight page, she added the proposed HOA terms. She had talked to their real estate lawyer about what it would take to set up a retroactive homeowners association, and it sounded like a lot of work.
Arlie was hoping they could accomplish some of this without a formal legal agreement—which would, no matter how thinly they sliced it, have to go to Leighton as well.
Old Man Buckles was the first to finish reading. He rolled the papers into a club and slapped it against the open palm of his left hand.
“So, what’s this about, really?” he asked, looking directly at Arlie.
Something in his gaze made her want to squirm.
“Leighton,” she said. “He claims he bought Olivia’s house.”
“Oh, bull—” He cut the word off mid-swear, glanced around the group, and finished with “—pucky. I doubt Liv’s lawyers even reviewed the will, let alone figured out how to execute it.”
“He should have,” Thao said primly. “She’s been gone—what? —a week now?”
“Since Friday,” Arlie said.
“Any good lawyer worth his salt would already know what’s in the will,” Madison said.
“Her,” Old Man Buckles said. “We share a lawyer. It’s a her.”
“Worth her salt then.” Madison’s cheeks had flushed.
“She’s a good one, but she takes her time,” Old Man Buckles said. “I kinda like that. It allows for changes.”
“There can’t be changes now,” Nancy said loudly as if Old Man Buckles was both dumb and hard of hearing. “She’s dead.”
Already, the group had gone down some kind of rabbit hole. “Leighton says he negotiated with the kids ahead of time,” Arlie said. “He says they have an agreement in principle, and once the will’s complete, he’ll own the place.”
Old Man Buckles, half-smiled, leaned his chair back on two legs and rested the crown of his head against the wall between the two windows.
“Could work, I guess,” he said.
“Do we know the kids are going to inherit it?” Derrick asked.
“That’s usually how it works,” Nancy said, sounding defensive.
Old Man Buckles crossed his arms. Arlie watched him out of the corner of her eye. She couldn’t quite tell what he was thinking, and she wanted to know.
“Jerry,” she said, “do you have anything to add?”
“Not at the moment,” he said, then rolled his eyes.
“Look,” she said. “If what Leighton says is true, he’s within his legal rights to build anything on Olivia’s patch of ground. He can tear down her lovely house and put up another monstrosity as long as it stays within the building codes.”
“Which are for shi…zzle here,” Hernán muttered.
“Yeah,” Nancy said. “They built this development outside the city for a reason.”
“The codes aren’t that different here,” Arlie said. She’d investigated them. “Maybe they had been back in the day, but they’re not now.”
“Well, that’s something, anyway,” Old Man Buckles said.
“Not really,” Arlie said. “Leighton knows the code, and he’s adhering to it.”
“So, I don’t see what we can do here,” Madison said. “He owns the land, he’ll build something ugly on it, and we’re stuck unless we move.”
“Worse,” Derrick said. “He’ll tear down Olivia’s house and change the tenor of the neighborhood.”
“Maybe…” Old Man Buckles said.
“No maybes,” Nancy snapped at him. “He’s already building the ugliest thing I’ve ever seen, and it sounds like he hates Arlie here.”
Arlie’s cheeks heated. The fact that Leighton might build another ugly house wasn’t her fault. She started to say something, but Babette put a hand on her arm.
“No matter what we do,” Thao said, “we will not be able to put legal restrictions in place in time to stop whatever Leighton Taylor is planning.”
“We’re screwed then,” Rosalinda Garcia said, meeting her husband’s gaze. He raised his eyebrows.
Arlie recognized the look. It was married-couple for we leaving yet?
“Well,” Babette said, “we could file some kind of restraining order until we put the legal requirements in place.”
“Going to court isn’t going to stop Mr. Taylor,” Thao said as if he had experience with Leighton. “He has more attorneys than all of you do.”
Arlie noticed that he kept himself out of that list.
“Then maybe we buy him out,” Derrick said. “I’m sure if we pay a bit more than he will pay—”
“Men like Taylor, they don’t care about money.” Old Man Buckles rocked his chair.
Derrick frowned at him as if that movement was going to cause problems.
“Then we have no hope,” Nancy said. “Because Leighton’s way ahead of anything we want to do.”
“I did not say he couldn’t be coerced.” Old Man Buckles smiled. “Anyone can be convinced to do anything. You just have to find the right incentive.”
His smile set a little chill through Arlie.
“What does that mean?” Madison asked.
“I mean,” Old Man Buckles said, “we want something, he wants something. We want him to leave. We really want him to stop building that monstrosity, and we certainly don’t want him to expand into Olivia’s property.”
“We can’t do anything about that.” Nancy waved her hands at him the way people did when they were panicked.
“It’s pretty simple, really,” Old Man Buckles said. “We make it unpleasant for him to stay.”
Arlie swallowed hard. Both Nancy and Old Man Buckles were old Vegas. This development was old Vegas. There were aspects of old Vegas that should remain in the past.
But she wasn’t sure how to say that without saying her assumption out loud.
“I don’t think Leighton notices unpleasant,” she said, a little too loudly.
“Everyone notices the right kind of unpleasant,” Old Man Buckles said. He lowered his chair hard. The two legs banged on the tile floor.
“Well,” Thao said, “I don’t think there’s anything we can do.”
He took his wife’s hand, then looked at Arlie.
“I would support the start of a homeowners’ association, should it not be focused on one homeowner. I think we need restrictions so we don’t lose any more of the old designs to people like Mr. Taylor.” Thao gave her a pained smile. “But that is all I would support.”
Madison looked from him to Arlie to Old Man Buckles.
“I seem to be missing something here,” she said.
“You’re not missing anything,” Hernán said. “In fact, I’m not even sure we had this meeting.”
He said that last with a lot of emphasis, his gaze on Old Man Buckles.
“Yeah, well,” Derrick said, pushing off the edge of the counter so that he could stand upright. “I guess we talk to some lawyers then about drafting something. Should we pool resources for legal fees?”
“Draft a homeowners association?” Cam Nguyen asked. “If that’s what you’re suggesting, I’m for it.”
“I don’t want fees to get out of hand,” Nancy said.
“How about we get a quote,” Babette said, “and then we’ll talk again.”
“Sounds fair,” Derrick said.
“Lawyers get involved,” Old Man Buckles said, “lawyers make money. No one else does.”
“This isn’t a divorce, Jerry,” Nancy snapped at him. “Sometimes lawyers are helpful.”
“Yeah,” he said, slapping the rolled papers against his palm again. “I suppose. When you need them for cover.”
Arlie wished she hadn’t invited him.
“We do need them for cover,” she said, trying to turn the conversation around. “We need them to make sure we do this right.”
Old Man Buckles smiled and said nothing at all.
In the middle of the night, Arlie woke out of a dream. Olivia had been talking to her from the bedroom, something about Don’t ask Jerry about the history of this place, dear. It’s better if you don’t know.
Arlie couldn’t remember if the conversation had taken place or not. The dream seemed vivid and real, and somehow, that confused her more: Was it a memory? Or was it something her brain made up?
She eased quietly over the side of the bed, careful not to wake Babette. Arlie grabbed her robe and slipped her feet into the shoes she’d taken to wearing instead of slippers. The house was a construction site, after all, and they were living in the middle of it, which she believed stupid, but Babette had wanted to establish themselves in the neighborhood.
Arlie usually didn’t regret it, except in the middle of the night. She hated turning on lights more, but she was also afraid of stepping on a loose nail or a shredding bit of wood.
She tied her robe over her middle, shivering in the air-conditioned cold, and walked to the kitchen. There, she reached for the light switch and stopped herself. She had the odd feeling that the house was being watched.
Which was silly, because someone would have had to get through the adobe fence, not trigger the security lights, and be standing in their wide backyard to see into the kitchen.
Still, her skin crawled. She decided against opening the refrigerator door.
Instead, she went into the laundry room and opened the exit, which led to a corner in the patio that had seemed like wasted space to her when she first saw it. Now, she was grateful for it because it meant she could step onto the patio silently.
The air was slightly humid and smelled of rain and dust. A storm had come through so recently that the nearby grass was wet. Vegas had a monsoon season in the summer, resulting in thunderstorms that were powerful and dramatic and could cause flooding, but they rarely made the news because they were so localized.
The one that had just gone through was probably what had awakened her, and the electricity in the air probably had given her skin that crawly feeling.
The idea didn’t make her feel better, though, possibly because of the remnants of the dream.
One afternoon, about two months before the end, Arlie had arrived just as Olivia was watching the evening news. A before-the-weather segment showed a video of a house for sale near Paradise Park.
“Tony’s house,” Olivia had muttered. She’d already taken her nightly meds and was a tad more loose-lipped than usual.
Tony turned out to be Tony Spilotro, who was a known enforcer for the Chicago mob. He’d been in charge of the mob’s interests in Las Vegas in the 1970s and 1980s, at least according to the news story.
Olivia waved her hand and said, “They all seem so surprised he had a normal house. Everybody had a normal house. What do these people think? That—”
And then she focused on Arlie as if seeing her for the first time.
“You buy other houses here,” Olivia said, “you be careful when you open the walls. And when you dig. Tony lived near Paradise, but those Paradise Park people had nothing on Sahara Circle.”
And then she laughed. She patted Arlie’s hand, then stared outside for a while before falling asleep.
Arlie never got her to say anything after that.
But she did know what Olivia meant because one of Arlie’s first flips had been a Paradise Park ranch. Paradise Park was right near the Las Vegas National Golf Course, in the middle of what was then all there was to the Strip. And Arlie had found a series of secret rooms in that ranch, although not a one of them had any buried money or a body or anything else.
She wandered to the empty pool. Two of the lawn chairs had blown over—there had been a storm—and she set them upright, then sat in one, feeling the damp seep through her robe.
That next flip was the tough one—the escrow house, she called it, because she never really did end up owning it. Estate troubles from the beginning. The owner had died without a will, or so the family said, which meant everything went to them. But the owner’s live-in girlfriend found a document in his handwriting, witnessed by two old friends, that served as a holographic will, showing his intent.
Then his business partner found another will, a later one, both on the computer and printed up, with the owner’s signature and a note in his handwriting saying that will would supersede everything.
That was when the lawsuits started. Nevada was an intent state—that’s how Arlie’s regular lawyer put it. Whatever the deceased wanted, whatever he intended—that was what the state wanted to do.
And the question was, which of those wills showed his intent? Usually, it was the most recent will, but the unusual nature of it—for him—typed and only partially handwritten meant the heirs would spend months, maybe years in court over this. Because there was a lot of estate to dispose of.
“Run from this one,” her lawyer had said. “Run fast.”
She had taken the advice and, after twelve months, was grateful for it. The last time she had driven by the place, it was still shuttered, with overgrown weeds and a dead lawn, leading her to believe the court cases continued.
Court cases. Wills. Intent.
And a computer.
She didn’t like what she was thinking. She didn’t like it at all.
Arlie spent the evening digging in her old file boxes in the garage, looking, she told Babette, for a bill she thought she hadn’t paid. Babette didn’t care. Her attitude was always that Arlie did what Arlie did.
But Arlie was feeling guilty in advance, and she overexplained when she was feeling guilty, which was not good, considering she hadn’t done anything wrong yet.
It took her nearly an hour to find the old paper file she had kept for the house in Paradise Park. She’d kept the emails and documents on her computer as well, but she shared that with Babette, and she didn’t want anything to come up in the browser history.
Sure enough, in the middle of all the legal papers were photocopies of the various wills and a copy of the half-typed, half-handwritten will. Arlie scanned it. It really didn’t apply as well as she had hoped, so she scanned the handwritten will as well. That was closer to what she was looking for.
She made copies of both documents using one of the older printers in the garage, folded the new copies, and shoved them in her back pocket. She then replaced the files where she had found them, made sure to shut off the printer, and meandered her way into the bedroom.
Babette was in the kitchen, arguing with someone about water usage, which wasn’t an issue with this house, considering they were on a well. So, Babette was working on one of the other properties, handling the regulatory stuff that cropped up all the time.
Arlie was grateful for that because she often lost her temper when she had to deal with bureaucrats. Long ago, she and Babette agreed that Arlie got to use the hammers as often as she wanted, mostly to work out frustrations that would have been worked out with her fists in the past, and Babette got to talk someone to death, which was her preferred method of dealing with difficult people.
In the bedroom, Arlie went deep into the closet, where she kept her clothes in boxes, waiting for construction to get finished. She opened a box of jeans, pulled out her blackest pair, and stuck the papers in the back pocket. Then she found a black long-sleeve t-shirt and tossed it on top of the jeans. She placed one of her black baseball caps on the pile for good measure.
She pulled the door closed on her closet and went back through the house. Babette hadn’t even noticed that she had walked through.
Arlie stepped outside into the growing heat of the day. She hit the ancient button near the garage that opened the gate. The beautifully wrought metal doors swung open, groaning as they went.
Then she looked at Olivia’s house.
If no one had told Arlie any differently, she would have thought Olivia was still inside, gazing at her beautiful backyard. The hum of cicadas had started, signaling that the day would be hot, so Olivia wouldn’t turn on the backyard fountains until late evening. The fairy lights on the grounds would add to the magic. There was a lot of found art around trees, and near bushes, all of it sculpture and most of it made by very famous artists.
Arlie had no idea what would happen to all of that if Leighton got the place. She might have to beg him to let her remove the one-of-a-kind pieces. Or maybe she would have Babette do that. Or some other neighbor (Thao?) whom Leighton objected to less than he objected to her.
Arlie wanted to be specific, but she didn’t dare. What she was doing was bad enough; she didn’t want to make it completely obvious.
Because that would be worse.
It seemed to take forever for night to fall and even longer for Babette to fall asleep. The good thing was, though, that once Babette fell asleep, she slept so hard that Arlie usually had to shake her awake if she needed her.
Arlie was counting on that oblivion right now. She slipped out of bed half an hour after Babette started making her tiny little snoring sounds and climbed into the closet, closing the door tightly. Instead of the overhead light, while she dressed, she used the flashlight on her phone, grabbing black Nikes rather than her boots because the boots were probably a lot more distinctive. After dressing, she stuck her hair under the baseball cap, patted her back pocket to make sure the papers were in it and then eased the closet door open.
The house was treacherous in the dark, as all houses were in the middle of a remodel. Nothing stayed in the same place for longer than a few days, so Arlie had to pick her way carefully across the darkened living room and into the kitchen. She placed her phone in its cradle, and she wasn’t going to wear her smartwatch either. She didn’t want to be tracked, and she didn’t want to shut them off.
The only thing she was going to carry with her was a thin flashlight, some thin plastic gloves, and her lock-picking tools. She had learned how to pick locks nearly fifteen years ago, after yet again paying a locksmith to open relatively easy (he said) locks in houses she had bought. She was spending hundreds per year on locksmiths, and she realized if she knew how to pick a lock, she would save a good portion of that.
The toughest part was going to be getting from her house to Olivia’s. There was only one way to do so directly—through the gate and across the street.
Arlie wasn’t going to walk that way. Instead, she was going to take advantage of the darkness, scale her own fence, and walk along the neighbor’s paths. She had to approach Olivia’s house from the back, away from her own property and away from Leighton’s.
Arlie and Babette had security cameras everywhere, and Arlie had decided that shutting them off would seem too suspicious. She knew where the blank spots were on her property, so she would stick to those.
She had no idea if there were blank spots in Leighton’s. She wasn’t even sure Leighton had cameras or a security system. If she were building his monstrosity of a house, she would have insisted on some kind of security, even with all the security in the subdivision. The tools and materials his builder was using were expensive, and losing them to a thief would be costly.
Scaling the fence was easy from the inside of the property. There were stumps of old palm trees that she hadn’t yet removed. She stood on one of those, put her hands on top of the adobe, and pulled herself up, knowing she was protected by the fronds of the remaining palms from any other nearby cameras.
She jumped down and landed in some scratchy dead brush, which crinkled under her feet. She paused, waiting to see if anyone heard or if anything moved.
This half-acre of her neighbor’s property was undeveloped, and they were never here. The home was an inheritance that they planned to fix up and hadn’t gotten around to yet.
She walked along the fence line, between the ancient palm trees and around the dead brush, until she reached the side of the road. From there, she crossed the cul-de-sac on one of the vacant lots, headed behind Old Man Buckle’s property, across a cracked and ancient driveway, and through a hedge into Olivia’s backyard.
Olivia had a 1970s security system but had let the contract lapse because she didn’t want security from Sahara Circle to run to her house every time someone from home health care forgot the code and pushed the door open anyway.
Arlie expected the system to remain off. In fact, she was gambling on it.
She walked around to the front of the house, staying in the shadows. Olivia had let the security lighting go, and the fairy lights in the back that she had so loved were either burned out or turned off. Still, some security camera from a neighbor’s (heck, from Arlie’s own place) might catch her silhouette moving across the yard. Worse, some camera might actually catch her face.
She figured her face was shielded enough with that ball cap, so long as she kept her head down. But in contrast to her t-shirt and jeans, her skin was light enough to be noticeable on a camera.
So she kept her face turned toward the house as she made her way to the front door. She slipped on the gloves, crouched in front of the main door, and picked the lock so quickly and efficiently that she startled herself.
The door opened without making a sound. That was why she had picked this door. The patio doors grated on their metal tracks, the back door stuck, and the entrance into the garage squealed so loudly that Arlie had been able to hear it across the street whenever she was outside.
Arlie slipped inside and gently pushed the front door until the latch clicked shut. Then she pushed in the handle lock and turned the deadbolt that had been so easy to open.
Her heart was pounding hard. The scent of Olivia’s favorite vanilla candles mixed with the leftover smell of her Chanel perfume hit Arlie, followed by other smells. The musty scent of a closed-up house (already!), and the faint stench of urine and illness, coming from down the hall. She had half-expected the odor of rotting food, but the hospice people must have cleaned that up as they left. Their equipment was gone from the entry as well.
She turned the flashlight toward the floor, then flicked the light on, and scanned the living room. It looked the same as it always had: expensive couches and chairs, all bought at the height of the 1960s mod era. Small sculptures on the table, books lining the built-in book cases, no television to be seen.
The garden faced her through the wide windows across the living room, but she really couldn’t see much more than the overgrown hedges along the patio.
She flicked the flashlight off, then silently made her way to the long, narrow hallway. The first door on the left was a study/library with more books. It had been done in red velvet and dark wood.
This room was stunningly dark. She flicked on the flashlight again, hoping that the curtains were closed like she remembered.
They were. She turned on the overhead light.
It was dim—the old bulb barely up to the task of banishing the gloom. She reached across the desk to the desk lamp, letting its orange-yellow light warm up the place.
She stood for a moment, feeling the frustration of her conversation with Leighton. This room alone had thousands of dollars of custom-built paneling, probably imported from Africa in the 1960s before the exotic wood bans. The desk was hand-carved from the same wood, and the chair, which wasn’t as comfortable as it looked, had a pad that matched the red carpet and drapes.
The newest thing in the room was the computer, and it dated from the early 1990s. It was hooked up to a dot-matrix printer that was almost the size of Arlie’s bandsaw.
But Arlie knew the computer worked because Olivia used it to write letters. She would be printing and mailing them if Arlie arrived in the early afternoon.
Arlie made sure the computer was plugged in, and the printer was attached. The paper was threaded through the platen.
She turned both machines on, the computer beeping happily at her as if it had missed being active and the printer moaning as much as the doors did. Then, the printer’s gears flopped into place, and everything was ready.
Arlie dug into the computer files just to see if there was a letter here or any kind of will. She found a few letters to Olivia’s lawyer, Anita Reiff, mostly about small things. Nothing about a will or anything to do with Olivia’s children. And nothing to the children either.
Arlie opened the desk to see if there were letters from the children and found nothing. The computer was too old for email, and Olivia had resolutely refused to update her technology. So there had been no obvious contact with the kids in decades.
Arlie reached into her back pocket and pulled out the photocopies. She would have to use some of the language from here, then print out the will and somehow get it to Reiff.
Arlie opened a file marked Miscellaneous, and there she found a single file marked Musings.
She opened it and saw that it was a bullet-point list of things that needed to go in an updated will. These musings were from 2008 and did not mention the kids. Instead, the heirs were half the charities in town.
“Good,” Arlie whispered, and the sound of her own voice startled her. This was the perfect place to start.
She copied the file, then stopped, her heart pounding. The stupid file had the current date.
She had forgotten the most important thing. She had to change the computer’s clock.
Fortunately, she owned computers like this in the 1990s, and she knew how to use them. So, she did. She had the computer default to its original settings, and the date was left blank. Then she tossed the copied file into the trash, made sure the trash was empty and started again.
This time, the new file showed the date as –/–/–, which was what she wanted. She would go back in after she was done and change some of the more recent letters as well, just so that this wasn’t the only file touched.
She didn’t have to add much. Just one single bullet point recommending that Arlie either inherit the house or be hired to restore it. In either case, the house was not to be sold or altered in any way.
Arlie didn’t know the legal language for that, but she didn’t have to. She also didn’t have to steal any of the language from those old wills. She felt a twinge of unease, but she wasn’t going to let that stop her.
Instead, she hit print.
The dot-matrix made eee-eee-eee noises as it printed, and she was convinced the entire neighborhood could hear them. She pulled the document out of the printer. It was barely legible. There wasn’t much ink in the printer. Did the document need a signature to be valid? It wasn’t really a will. It was just intent.
And for that, it would need a date.
Or would it? Because Arlie had only known Olivia for a year, that automatically dated the document.
She leaned her head against the bulky computer screen and sighed. Her stomach was twisting. She felt ill. Her heart was pounding.
She would have to somehow show this to Babette and explain it, even before taking it to the lawyer. And then, she’d have to tell the lawyer how she came into possession of it and—
She couldn’t do it. She couldn’t come up with a plausible way of handling any of it.
But if she didn’t do it, she wouldn’t be able to stop Leighton. If she did, she would be committing some kind of felony. Theft, embezzlement, or something.
Yes, she loved this house. She loved this subdivision, and she loved the image she had of it, restoring it to its former glory, only with all people welcome.
But she couldn’t commit a crime to do it.
And maybe, just maybe, the document she had altered showed Olivia’s actual will. Now, Arlie wished she had talked with Olivia about her plans for the future.
But Arlie hadn’t.
Her mouth was dry. She was already breaking the law. She was trespassing. But it was the kind of trespassing she had done in the past to examine an empty house she wanted to flip. She was doing no harm—if she didn’t take anything. And if she didn’t use this altered document.
She stared at it for a moment. She could tear it up and throw it out, but if someone pieced it back together…
Better to take it home and light a match to it. Better that no one ever knew what she had done.
She folded the printout and stuck it in the left back pocket of her jeans. She stuffed the other documents back in the right back pocket where they had been when she arrived.
Then she closed the file she added, closed the folder, and shut down the program on the computer before shutting the computer itself off. Her hands were sweating inside those plastic gloves. She checked the desk and made sure she hadn’t left anything.
She shut off the desk lamp and saw, in the weird flat light of the overhead, that the printer’s orange light blinked. She shut the printer off, letting out a small breath as she did so. She almost forgot that.
She just wasn’t cut out for any of this.
Somehow, she would have to live with Leighton’s ugly house and his vindictive teardown of this place. And if she couldn’t live with it, well, then she knew how to sell a flip, and she also had the skills to rent it.
Still, her eyes teared up as she let herself out of the library for probably the last time. She turned, looked at it, absorbed what a lovely, comfortable room it was, and vowed to keep it in her memory. Then she shut off the overhead light, opened the door, and stopped in the hallway, tempted to do one last walk-through.
But she had taken enough risks.
She locked the front door from the inside. She was going to risk letting herself out through the garage and into the backyard.
The door stuck, just like she remembered, but it didn’t have a deadbolt. All she had to do was lock the handle and pull it closed. She managed to get the door open without it making too much noise.
She had to turn on her flashlight, keeping the beam low so that it wasn’t visible through the dust-covered garage door windows.
Then she walked past the Cadillac that Olivia had kept after her husband died, past the pile of equipment that seemed to date from the 1970s—everything from fertilizer to lawn spray that had probably been banned before Arlie was born.
The garage smelled faintly of dust and chemicals, mostly old gasoline. Leighton would have to clean this up first thing because it was probably a safety hazard.
Arlie shut off the flashlight before pushing on the other garage door, the one that led into the backyard, and it didn’t stick as much as she remembered. Maybe it swelled in the heat. Or maybe Leighton had let himself into the place since the door wasn’t closed as tightly as it should have been.
She tiptoed across the yard, stifling a sneeze as she did so. That chemical odor had gotten into her nose. She went through the opening in the trees, backtracking, pausing for only a moment when she thought she smelled cigarette smoke.
She waited, trying to see if the smell was coming from a nearby yard or someone walking down the road.
She took a tentative sniff, hoping it wouldn’t inspire the sneeze, and no longer smelled the cigarette smoke—if she ever had. She might have smelled something from that garage.
Almost as if on command, she sneezed. It was explosive and loud, and she froze, hoping she hadn’t awakened half the neighborhood.
But no one moved. She didn’t see anything in the faint light from the corner street light more than a block away. She didn’t hear footsteps either.
Her heart was pounding because she felt guilty. She needed to get home, get rid of the document, and go to bed. Maybe take a shower first, just in case some of that garage smell had gotten on her clothing.
The walk home was uneventful. She let herself into the house, half expecting Babette to confront her. But Arlie was alone.
Thank heavens.
She would never tell anyone what she had done.
As far as she was concerned, this night had never happened.
It had never happened at all.
Two nights after she broke into Olivia’s house, Arlie woke up to the loudest bang she had ever heard.
“Thunder,” Babette murmured and rolled over.
But Arlie frowned. She hadn’t ever heard thunder that loud, not even in monsoon season.
Then there was another bang, and another, and another. The sounds were too sharp to be thunder. Thunder rumbled. It didn’t sound concussive unless it was right overhead.
She had no idea what it was, but she grabbed Babette around the waist and rolled them both off the bed.
“What the—?” Babette asked, struggling.
“Get under the bed,” Arlie said, shoving her.
“What’s going on?” Babette asked, not moving.
If Babette had one flaw that Arlie wanted to change, it was the fact that she woke up so damn slowly.
Another bang, and this time the ground shook. Something hard—several somethings hard—hit the side of the house, and as the shaking eased, another bang, farther away this time, followed by breaking glass.
“Someone’s getting in,” Babette said.
“I don’t think so,” Arlie said and shoved Babette with all her strength. Babette finally got the message and crawled under the bed.
Another far-away bang and more breaking glass. Then, loud, scared voices and the smell of smoke—real, heavy, chemical smoke.
“Shit,” Arlie said, wishing she had grabbed her phone as she grabbed Babette.
Arlie had no idea what this was, but she worried that it was a gas main explosion. And if it was, then she and Babette would die in here.
Arlie groped for her slippers, found Babette’s, and thrust them at her. “Put these on,” she said.
“We can’t go out there,” Babette said. “Someone is shooting at us.”
“Explosions,” Arlie said. “Probably gas leaks.”
Babette cursed. She seemed awake now.
Arlie slapped her hands against the floor, found her own slippers, and pulled them on. She also found her robe and clung to it. Then she grabbed Babette’s hand.
“We’re going outside,” she said. “Head down, shoes on.”
“Robe?” Babette asked.
She slept in a skimpy little shift. Arlie wore a t-shirt and shorts, mostly because she woke up fast enough to answer a door or handle an emergency.
Like she was doing now.
She gave Babette the robe and dragged her into the bedroom. Arlie grabbed her phone off the nightstand and saw no alerts on it as she turned on the flashlight function.
The banging had stopped, but the voices had grown louder. Then, in the distance, sirens.
Arlie led Babette through the living room, noting broken glass from at least two windows. The stench of smoke had grown stronger, and her eyes were watering.
She pushed open the front door and stepped onto the path leading to the driveway.
She recognized a few of the outside voices now—Nancy, Madison, Derrick—mixed with others that sounded unfamiliar. Overhead, clouds of smoke plumed, and someone was yelling something about hoses.
The sirens were growing closer with each passing moment.
She pushed open the small gate door and stepped through it ahead of Babette in case there were problems on the street in front of them.
And good thing she did.
Because there were burning bits of something on the street, in Olivia’s yard, and in her yard.
Burning. In the summer. In Las Vegas.
“We have to get our hoses,” she said to Babette.
Babette didn’t say anything. Instead, she pointed. Reluctantly, Arlie followed Babette’s finger.
Flames rose out of the center of Leighton’s monstrosity. Except for the middle cube, which was burning, the rest of the cubes were in pieces. That was what was all over the yards, the properties.
Leighton’s monstrosity had exploded.
Arlie let out a sigh. It couldn’t be a gas explosion then since the building wasn’t done. The walls weren’t up, so the gas hadn’t been attached to the house.
The relief she felt lasted only a second because she needed to check her own yard, as well as the interior of the house. Flying pieces of shrapnel burned everywhere.
Babette—who simply could not handle an emergency ever— had not moved.
Arlie swore at her, something she almost never did. “Get the damned hose. Put out the fires.”
If she could, Arlie would have done that herself, but she had to check the house first, and if she sent Babette, Arlie had no idea if Babette would stomp out a fire she saw, come to get Arlie, or, worse, do nothing at all.
“The damn hoses!” Arlie repeated, then pushed Babette, which seemed to make her come alive.
That, and the fact that most of the neighbors were running toward their own homes, either to get hoses, make sure everything was all right, or get out of the way.
The sirens sounded really close, but Arlie couldn’t count on them. The entire subdivision could go up if this kind of fire got out of hand.
She would take care of her house first, then the yard, then Olivia’s.
Arlie went to the house after making sure Babette grabbed the nearest hose. As Arlie opened the door, she saw Babette turn on the water on the side of the building.
Screw that. Arlie went into the laundry area, where the sprinkler controls were, overrode them, and turned them on. Babette would still get enough water for the hose, but the sprinklers would take care of any embers that they couldn’t see yet.
Then she turned on the lights, and she went back to the living room. That was where she heard glass breaking on this side of the house. Bits of Leighton’s property had to hit with a lot of force to clear the fence and blast their way into the house.
She found a long piece of rebar on the carpet with a scorch mark, but no fire. She touched the rebar. It was still warm, but not hot. Still, she picked it up and tossed it onto the ancient tile in the un-remodeled kitchen.
Then she continued, walking around the street side of the house as the sirens pulled close and stopped mid-thrum. There were more voices, shouting, and the sound of water running all over the house.
More shrapnel had broken one of the patio doors near the garage and another window in the half bath. Nothing hot, nothing burning. However, she had to tell by touch (and she kept picking up the pieces of Leighton’s house) because the chemical stench of the smoke was making her eyes water and her throat hurt.
She went out back. The yard was soaked, which was good, and she didn’t see anything that had cleared the fence here.
But she took several steps back, getting her slippers and nightclothes wet as she looked at the roof.
Some shrapnel up there, bits of the house, but it didn’t seem like they were burning or had started anything. The damn roof was made of asbestos, and the asbestos remediation team told her to replace the roof all at once, especially if she was going to change any part of the house’s footprint.
She had planned to, but not right away. So, the asbestos had probably snuffed out any problem. However, she’d have to call the team back out as soon as possible because any damage to asbestos would cause it to flake, and she and Babette might inhale it.
Minor problem right now. Minor.
Arlie could hear the firefighters yelling, someone saying the police needed to be called, and someone else asking if there was anyone living in the structure.
She continued to walk around her home, making sure the wet ground didn’t contain burning shrapnel and that nothing burned on the roof.
Bits of Leighton’s house stuck in her siding, and one more piece of rebar looked like an axe thrown at a tree, but the damage was all from flying debris and not from fire.
She made her way around the house, saw the firefighters dealing with the fire in the middle of Leighton’s monstrosity, saw two other firefighters walking around Olivia’s place, and saw one more heading toward the other side of the street to make sure the houses over there were all right.
In the light of the flames, she could see the faces of Derrick and Nancy and Madison, frowning at the destruction. They were standing with their arms crossed, and then, as a group, they looked at her.
Arlie’s cheeks flushed. She didn’t have anything to do with this. How could they think that? And what had they already told the firefighters? That she hated Leighton and the thing he was building on his own property?
She was a builder, not a destroyer. She wouldn’t have blown up his house, even if she had thought of it (which she hadn’t).
Some other neighbors stood to the side, a few in long robes, some in t-shirts and shorts like she was, and a few others looking like they had thrown on whatever was nearby.
It took her a moment to recognize Thao. He wasn’t in one of his fancy suits, but instead, something that looked like a bright orange-brown jogging outfit from the 1970s. The security guards from the front gate were talking to the police. She hadn’t even realized that Metro was part of the group that had shown up, but there were their police cars and an ambulance, too.
The hose was curled along the driveway, water dribbling out its end. Babette walked toward Arlie, looking as sodden as she felt.
“I think I got everything out over at Olivia’s. I figured we were okay when you turned on the sprinklers.”
Babette should never think during an emergency, but Arlie didn’t say that. Instead, she put her arm around Babette and pulled her close, glad she was all right, glad everyone seemed to be all right, hoping that the stench wouldn’t cause other problems, hoping that this turned out to be a disgruntled employee and not a failure of the security up front or something more sinister, something that her neighbors suspected her of.
Babette rested her head against Arlie’s shoulder and snaked her arm around Arlie’s back.
Whatever caused this, they would deal with it. They would figure out what it meant for them.
The arson investigator showed up while the ashes were still cooling. It was barely dawn, and a few firefighters remained to monitor the embers. Arlie was leaning against her fence, the adobe digging into the back of her t-shirt. She hadn’t changed yet, and she probably looked a mess. But she had managed to make coffee.
Babette had taken a shower and then went back to bed, but not before asking Arlie how long the air would stink of smoke.
Arlie had no idea, so she made something up.
Now, she was studying Olivia’s house, which also took some damage from the explosions—more than her own house had. Fortunately, she’d been planning to replace the broken windows, so she really had no cost for this.
She would follow the lead of the others in the subdivision, though, when it came to collecting insurance money. If these explosions happened because Leighton had done something stupid, then she was all for suing the ever-living hell out of him.
The arson investigator was a short man with bow legs that she usually associated with a hardcore rancher. His brown face had some red, probably from the heat, and she would have described the tight gray curls on his head as ash if she somehow didn’t feel that inappropriate.
He carried a gas mask—or some kind of mask—in one hand and a fire helmet in the other. His blackish-gray uniform had a yellow band across the middle, identifying him as part of the fire investigative team. All kinds of equipment—some of which she recognized as heat monitors—danged from hooks around that middle belt.
His boots left dust marks on the road. He walked toward her, stopping only to set down the hat and mask. Then he pulled a clipboard from the large pocket on one side.
“You see this happen?” he asked her as he reached her.
“Heard it,” she said.
“You wanna tell me about it?” he asked.
What an easy way to get someone talking. Everyone liked to talk about their adventures with a fire and explosion.
He wasn’t writing on the clipboard, not yet, so she figured she could tell him a bit.
So, she did—the explosions, thinking it was something else, turning on the sprinklers— “Smart,” he said—and told him that Babette had put out small fires too.
“We had damage,” Arlie said. “I can show you.”
He nodded. “We’ll need to photograph it. My team’ll be here shortly. They’re working on the other properties right now.”
That caught her. “Other properties? Did something else get hit in the subdivision?”
He gave her a tired smile. “No, not here. Other properties owned by Mr. Taylor. Do you know him?”
“Kinda hard to miss him,” she said, thinking about the words “other properties.”
Something rustled behind her. Babette approached, looking cool and comfortable in gray shorts and a matching gray top. She carried her coffee, and anyone else would have thought she had just gotten up.
But Arlie recognized the brightness in those eyes. Babette had seen her talking and come out to save Arlie from herself.
“You don’t like him?” the investigator asked.
“I don’t really know him,” Arlie said. “But let’s just say he and I are oil and water.”
“Good morning!” Babette said, smiling at the investigator. Then she let her smile fade. “Or should I leave off the ‘good’?”
He shrugged and gave her his tired smile. “I’ve ceased judging mornings. I understand you had a rough night.”
“That is an understatement,” Babette said. “I’m sure my wife told you all about it.”
There was judgment in that sentence.
“She told me what she did. Smart stuff, keeping any ground fires from starting. There were a few down the block that we had to put out.” He watched Babette, but she didn’t relax as he clearly wanted her to.
“I take it you’re investigating,” she said. “Do you have a card?”
“I do.” He lifted the clip on his clipboard and handed her a card. “You’re an attorney?”
“No,” Babette said and didn’t say anything else. Babette was good at being silent when silence was necessary.
Arlie didn’t care about silence, not at the moment anyway. “You said there were other explosions at Mr. Taylor’s properties?”
“Three,” the investigator said. “All over the city. Same kind of explosive used.”
“You know it was an explosive device?” Arlie asked.
“I’m sure we’ll find out more soon enough,” Babette said hastily, trying to get Arlie to stop talking. Babette worried too much. This investigator did not have an “I’m being friendly because I’m investigating you” vibe. Arlie had been investigated enough as a kid with anger-management issues to know the difference.
The investigator ignored Babette. In fact, he turned slightly so that he could face Arlie directly.
“Yes,” he said, “we know that these were explosive devices. Old ones. Unstable as hell. It was lucky whoever planted them didn’t blow himself to smithereens just transporting them.”
“So, no one was killed, then,” Arlie said.
“Not that we’ve found so far. Mr. Taylor was in his condo when everything happened, so he’s all right. And this property was the only one in a subdivision. The others are office complexes.” The inspector tucked the clipboard under his arm. “You ever hear any rumors about Mr. Taylor? Did he have ties to this subdivision?”
“You mean besides owning property here?” Arlie asked.
The inspector nodded.
“We don’t know anything about him,” Babette said, tucking her arm in Arlie’s. She wanted Arlie to walk away.
But Arlie wasn’t ready to leave. She couldn’t quite understand the source of the inspector’s question.
“I—I don’t think Leighton has ties to the neighborhood. I know he bought that property he was building on. It was for sale for almost a year before he picked it up. Why do you ask?”
“Because the devices have a unique signature,” the inspector said. “One we haven’t seen for nearly forty years.”
Arlie felt a cool shock run through her, Old Man Buckles’ voice strong in her head: Everyone notices the right kind of unpleasant.
The inspector was staring at her. Had he seen that chill travel down her spine?
“So, you think there’s more in the neighborhood?” Babette asked. Arlie couldn’t tell if the fear in her voice was real or staged for the inspector.
“I don’t know,” he said. “We’ll do a thorough search. As far as we can tell, Mr. Taylor only owns one property; is that correct?”
Arlie swallowed. Her throat was scratchy from the smoke. “He told me last week he was going to buy Olivia’s house once it went through probate.”
“Olivia…?” the inspector asked.
Arlie pointed. “Olivia’s house. The property butts up against his. He wanted to expand.”
“All right.” The inspector nodded. “You see anything suspicious, anything at all. You call 911. Don’t even call me. Get a team out here. Those devices are nothing to mess around with.”
“Will do,” Arlie said.
He nodded, then walked across the street to Olivia’s. He peered at it for a moment, then hauled a cell phone out of his gear and spoke quietly into it.
“I thought he was asking for statements,” Babette asked.
Arlie put her hand over Babette’s. Babette’s skin was cool.
“He’s already ruled us out,” Arlie said. “He recognized the devices.”
Babette looked up at her, understanding finally crossing her face. “You think Old—”
Arlie squeezed Babette’s hand, shutting her down. “I haven’t seen him, have you?”
Babette shook her head. “Should we go over there?”
Probably. It was probably a great idea to tell the inspector about Old Man Buckles. The other neighbors had told the firefighters about Arlie’s verbal wrangles with Leighton.
“No,” Arlie said. “It’s none of our business.”
Even though it probably was.
Gossip spread through the subdivision faster than the flames had the night before. Almost everyone, it seemed, stood outside and watched the inspectors, offered opinions, had ideas.
But, as far as Arlie could tell, no one mentioned Old Man Buckles. Maybe no one else had heard his comments the night of the homeowners meeting as threats. Except Nancy. Nancy had tried to shut him down.
And Nancy wasn’t gossiping at all. Like Arlie, she was just listening.
More inspectors arrived. They poked and prodded and collected. They photographed the outside of Olivia’s house, the damage to Arlie and Babette’s house, and all of the places where the shrapnel ended up.
They formally interviewed security but didn’t formally interview anyone else. A few of the neighbors were upset that the inspectors didn’t talk to them at all.
The night of the explosion, Arlie deliberately watched the evening news. She recorded all four local newscasts and watched them back to back. Only one managed to catch up with Leighton.
He looked haunted and terrified, and his “no comments” were bracketed with an “I have no idea what happened.”
The local reporters all spoke to different people who knew Leighton, including some from the neighborhoods where the other bombs had gone off.
“You don’t wish this on anyone,” said one woman, “but if it had to happen to someone, well, then…”
Another said, “Good luck to the cops. Everyone hated this guy. Everyone.”
There were overhead images of the damage in Sahara Circle, but the subdivision’s security refused to let reporters inside. That was why Sahara Circle had security in the first place; once someone developed the first star map in the 1970s, the subdivision owners didn’t want tour buses to come through there.
Apparently, the system still worked when it had to.
One newscast—the last one of the evening—had a tidbit.
“Sources say that the bombs used in these explosions had been used in several similar hits on businesses back in the 1970s. The bomber was never found, but police at the time believed the hits were retaliation for the business owner’s refusal to pay protection money to the mob.”
A chill ran through Arlie again. She kept her head down so that Babette didn’t see her face, not that Babette had to.
Arlie couldn’t take it anymore.
She stood.
“I gotta see if Old Man Buckles is okay,” she said.
Babette lifted her head. “You think that’s a good idea?”
Arlie shrugged. “Checking up on the neighbors is usually a positive. He’s the only one I haven’t seen all day.”
Babette’s face fell. “What if he’s…?”
“Either he’s there, or he’s not,” Arlie said and pretended that she would be fine either way. But she wouldn’t be fine until she knew he was all right. And if he wasn’t there…
She squelched that thought before it had time to become full-blown.
Then she let herself out of the house.
The sky was a burnt amber. Smoke still wafted from the explosion site. The smell clung to the air like the stench of burned rubber at a tire factory.
She took the long way toward Old Man Buckles’s house near the gate rather than walking past what was left of Leighton’s. Her heart was pounding, and she felt slightly ill, although she blamed that on the stench.
When she reached his house, she stared at the four-car garage in the center, which made it difficult to figure out where the front door was.
Finally, she went to the door that actually looked like someone used it and rang the bell. Static crackled as an intercom she hadn’t even noticed blinked on.
“It’s open, doll.” Old Man Buckles’ voice.
She felt relief and irritation at the same time. Part of her didn’t want to see him. She wanted to avoid this conversation. But she did want to know if he was all right.
The door pushed open outward, which wasn’t the way doors usually worked. But it was a safety feature if you expected threats to walk through that door as often as friends.
She stepped into the cool darkness, noting the smell of Vicks mixed with the fresh odor of cigarettes. Amazingly, she could smell anything, given the stink of the outdoors.
She pulled the door closed and faced three different corridors.
“Living room, doll.” The voice seemed to come from in front of her. She used her knowledge of these old ranch homes and followed the corridor that led toward the back rather than the ones going to her right and left.
The corridor wound past the ugliest fireplace she had ever seen—an open fireplace that looked like it was part of the corridor. Built of brown and tan stone, the fireplace struck her as a hazard rather than a desired feature of the home.
But the fireplace told her she was heading in the right direction. She rounded it and found herself in a great room the size of two living rooms. It had windows to a back garden that looked like it belonged in a wet, humid climate instead of Las Vegas—weeping willows, live oaks, roses of a dozen varieties, and more than she could identify from a distance. Mostly, what she saw was red and pink flowers and greenery. None of which belonged in a desert.
The living room was low to the ground and had uncomfortable, matching 1960s furniture, the kind of design she called Frank Lloyd Wright light.
Old Man Buckles sat near an indoor planter that ran the length of the garden windows. The indoor planter was made of the same stone as the fireplace but didn’t have any plants growing in it at all.
To her surprise, Old Man Buckles was sitting in a wheelchair. He had oxygen tubes running up his nose and a tank on the back of the chair.
“Forgive me if I don’t stand up,” he said. His voice sounded as strong as ever, and his face was a healthy pink color.
“What happened?” she asked, looking at the chair.
“Doll,” he said, “don’t ask me questions today.”
“Okay.” She didn’t sit down. “I just wanted to see if you’re okay.”
“Didn’t get any sleep for two nights, three if you count me following you.”
Her gaze met his. His eyes were blue and sharp, not the eyes of a sick old man at all.
She didn’t say anything. He shook his head.
“You know, you damn near ruined everything. What’d I tell you about lawyers?”
“They’re good for cover,” she said.
“Before that. You bring in lawyers, lawyers make money. No one else does.”
Her cheeks heated. He had seen the will.
“You didn’t delete the file properly,” he said. “I did. Don’t want anyone investigating that will to find it. Olivia wanted her money to go to charity.”
Arlie’s mouth was dry. Her heart had started beating hard.
“I woulda told them to sell you the house,” he said. “I’m still gonna tell them that if you promise me one thing.”
“What’s that?” she asked, wondering why he was going to tell anyone what to do.
“You make sure you be careful when you touch anything. Particularly in the garage.” He coughed. Then the cough led to another and another, each deeper than the first.
“What’s in the garage?” she asked when he stopped.
“Five fewer things than there were yesterday,” he said. His voice was raspy now.
She frowned.
He rolled his eyes.
“Jesus, doll, use that brain of yours. Liv and I, we knew each other from work. I planted things, she made them. She was an artist, that Liv. Then, her kids found what she was building. They was in college then, thank God. She’d kept everything off-site when they were growing up. Still, one of them lost a finger.”
Arlie blinked, trying to follow. Maybe she was following.
“Olivia built bombs?”
“Oh, honey, they were more elegant than that. Designed for the space, you know. Like these chairs. That’s what artists do. Form follows function.”
“Olivia would never—”
“What?” he snapped. “Did you think she was some harmless old biddy? Olivia was a great lady. She just…”
He coughed again, then wiped the back of his mouth.
“The smell is getting to me, you know?” he said.
Arlie didn’t respond.
His shoulders went down. “She just never got over it, hurting her kid like that. The other people who got hurt on site, she always knew, you know, they deserved it on one level or another, but her kid? He didn’t.”
That’s why Arlie wasn’t supposed to call them, why Olivia knew her children would never come to see her.
And Olivia had understood.
“She thought she could atone, you know. That’s why the will.” He pressed the tubes deeper into his nose.
“The kids already sold the house to Leighton,” she said.
“The kids don’t inherit nothin’,” Old Man Buckles said. “I seen the will. I been talking to Anita—that’s the lawyer—and I’m executor. Lucky me. It’s straightforward, and all that money, it goes to the right places—kid’s charities, homeless shelters, all those places Olivia donated her time to. I couldn’t let you mess that up.”
“So, you blew up Leighton’s house?” Arlie finally found her voice.
“It became pretty clear to me you weren’t gonna quit. So, I had to do something. I figured, you know, incentive. It’s not like it hasn’t been done before. Guys like him, they threaten violence, but they can’t handle it.” Old Man Buckles smiled, his hand still covering half his mouth, holding the tubes in his nose. “You’ll see. He’ll sell everything and leave town in less than a year. You don’t gotta worry about him. He might even sell you that lot if you want it.”
“I’m not made of money,” Arlie said, sounding annoyed. She wasn’t annoyed. She was nauseous. She had caused this. Her hatred of Leighton. The homeowners association. The stupid will.
Old Man Buckles was watching her closely.
“I wasn’t going to do it,” she said. “I burned that document I printed. I wasn’t going to do anything.”
He sighed. “Lawyers. What’d I tell you about lawyers?”
She had no idea how that was relevant. She was about to ask when he waved his free hand.
“Leighton would’ve hired one, forced the kids to do the same. Then some stupid investigator would’ve gone through the computer and found the damn document you altered. Just like I did. And then everything would’ve been questioned. Everything.” He pointed a finger at her. “You damn near ruined it all.”
She understood that. She wasn’t sure how she felt about it. About any of it. But especially about Olivia.
“They already tied the bombs to the 1970s bombings,” she said. “You’re not worried about that?”
“Why should I worry?” he asked. “I’m an old man. Nobody looks twice at old people.”
“And if I tell them you did it?” she asked.
“Go ahead,” he said. “I’m not a contractor. I’m not a person who can carry boards on her shoulders and climb roofs. I’m not someone who can get in and out of houses without being picked up by security cameras.”
He was threatening her. But she wasn’t afraid of him.
He must have seen that, because he added, “You keep your trap shut, Liv gets what she wants. People benefit. You talk, lawyers make money. That what you want?”
Arlie felt dizzy. “I don’t know what I want,” she said.
“It’s up to you,” he said. “That’s what you gotta remember. It’s all up to you.”
She walked back in the growing twilight. By the time she reached her house, the porch light was on.
Arlie went inside. Babette was sitting at the kitchen table, going over the bills as if the last 24 hours hadn’t happened.
“I take it he’s all right, and his house was spared,” Babette said.
Arlie sank into one of the folding chairs. It creaked under her weight. This was her moment. She could say, He planted those bombs. And Olivia built them. Which would mean that Babette would call the police, and they would interview Arlie. Everyone would mention how she hated Leighton, that she was always in and out of Olivia’s house, and that she could not have known about Olivia’s kids.
Nancy would have known. Maybe that was why Nancy didn’t say anything. Nancy had been brought up not saying anything. Because that was the kind of neighborhood this was.
Not an all-white, all-straight perfect neighborhood with a few shady characters. But a veneer over a lot of ugly things. A veneer of ranch houses and roses and live oak and trees that didn’t belong in the desert.
Arlie had been working off a fantasy, trying to turn it into a modern fantasy.
And if she didn’t say anything, it would be the same kind of subdivision, filled with good people and bad, famous people and not-so-famous people. Criminals, and—
“Is he all right?” Babette had lifted her head from the bills. She looked concerned.
Arlie nodded. “He’s having trouble with the stench. Has to be on oxygen.”
“Yeah,” Babette said. “I wouldn’t mind some of that myself.”
Then she turned her attention back to the bills before her, to their life together—hers and Arlie’s. Here, in their dream home, if they ever remodeled it. The home that once had a sister home where the bomb went off. The home that stood directly across the street from the beautiful house once owned by a serial bomber.
“You okay?” Babette asked. She didn’t look up this time.
“Yeah,” Arlie said. She stood.
Maybe she wouldn’t buy Olivia’s house after all. Maybe she wouldn’t restore it. Maybe she’d even talk Leighton into keeping it.
But as that thought crossed her mind, she realized she still didn’t want Leighton on this block. And she had liked Olivia—at least the Olivia she had known. The one who worked on half the charity boards in the city and knew all the gossip in the neighborhood. The one who had died looking at her garden.
Right now, all Arlie had was Old Man Buckles’ word for what Olivia had done. That’s all anyone had. And he was a mean piece of work. Maybe he was lying.
She liked to think he was lying.
Really, it was easier to think he was lying.
Yeah. He was lying.
Because that was what people like him did.
She oughta know. She ran into them enough on the job here in Las Vegas. She could deal with them.
As long as she kept everything in perspective and went about her business.
As long as she lived her life without thinking about theirs at all.
____________________________________________
Olivia’s HouseCopyright © 2024 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
Published by WMG Publishing
Cover and layout © copyright 2024 by WMG Publishing
Cover design by WMG Publishing
Cover art © copyright fergregory | Depositphotos
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
September 1920, New York City: Phillipa D’Arco makes a living investigating the past for the United States Government. Bloodless, they call her, making her one of the best operatives. So, when Phillipa fails to return back to 2057 to report her findings, Assistant Attorney General Preston Lane needs to make a decision: send in yet another investigator or lose a valuable asset.
Whatever Lane decides, he knows he’ll face consequences. But the truth behind Phillipa’s disappearance will cause ripples in time Lane can’t begin to imagine.
“September At Wall And Broad” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
September At Wall And Broadby Kristine Kathryn RuschMANHATTAN
SEPTEMBER 16, 1920
SHE DIDN’T WANT to go to work this morning. Normally, Philippa couldn’t wait to leave the tiny two-room walkup she shared with five other women. The place smelled of grease and dirt so old that no amount of bleach would get it out. She had tried to clean the flat when she realized she would have to live like everyone else in this godforsaken century. She scrubbed the place until her hands were raw, and made no difference whatsoever.
Ambition was cold comfort when you shared a mattress with two other women—girls in 1920 parlance—neither of whom had bathed in the last week. The flat had two windows, both of which overlooked the brick building next door. No breezes, no sunlight.
Not that it mattered. She stayed out of the flat as much as she could, coming back to sleep and change clothes. She probably smelled no better than her companions. The bathroom was down the hall, the bathtub foul, and the toilet an atrocity.
She’d been counting the days to September 16, not because that was the day she’d been waiting for, but because she’d be able to go home, real home, bathe, sleep in a bed with Egyptian cotton sheets, and turn on the air conditioning, even if she didn’t need it.
For the first time in her entire career, she missed the middle of the 21st century. She missed it with a mad passion, realizing that with all the rising sea levels, the incredible population growth, the poverty that no one could quite wipe out, the life she led there was one of privilege, even though she associated more with the upper class here than she ever had there.
Still, she stood at the door of her apartment building, and looked up at the azure sky. A perfect blue, the temperature in the low sixties, promising to be one of those spectacular New York days, the kind that made you wonder why you lived anywhere else. The city, about to enter its ascendancy in American life, glowed under the September sun.
People were walking outside and gazing upward, some even smiling, probably planning a series of errands that would get them out of the office. Folks who worked outside had smirks of superiority; they got paid to be outside.
A few people were probably thinking ahead to lunch, planning to splurge at one of the food carts, and maybe even sit on one of the benches lined up along the streets or head to one of the city’s parks, if only for a few minutes. A few snatched minutes that no one would ever get.
She shuddered. She’d been in Manhattan before on a perfect September day. On one of her first jobs, in fact. She’d stood not far from here and gazed upward at a building that wasn’t even a glimmer in someone’s eye this morning, and watched, at 8:46 am, as American Flight 11 crashed into the World Trade Center’s north tower.
The same sort of sunshine. Same kind of optimism in the air.
Only then that crisis had been more deadly, using weapons not yet dreamed of, hitting a building impossible to build in this time period, while an entire nation watched on a machine that Philo Farnsworth wouldn’t even imagine for another year.
That day had been hard, but she had been prepared. She had watched the footage, read the accounts, talked to others who had also visited September 11th. And that day had been the final test in her training: could she maintain her composure as people jumped to their deaths to escape flames, as buildings pancaked around her, as first responders who wouldn’t live out the day ran past her to save as many lives as possible?
She had been, in the words of her instructor, “positively bloodless.” He had meant that as a compliment, and she had taken it that way. “Positively bloodless,” meant she kept her composure, did her job, and got out with a minimum of notification and a minimum of fuss.
Yes, she had nightmares. Everyone did; it was part of the job. But they weren’t debilitating, and she was able to work through the worst of them with the therapist the department had assigned her.
She was, in other words, a stellar candidate, the best of her class. A woman who had since completed dozens of difficult assignments.
A woman who did not want to walk to the corner of Wall and Broad on this beautiful September morning. A woman who did not want to enter the House of Morgan to take her lowly secretary’s desk with its fancy expensive Underwood typewriter, something she had been instructed to be very, very careful with because it was delicate. It wasn’t delicate. The damn thing was a tank and it would take a sledgehammer to destroy it.
She would wager, if she had anyone to wager with, that the Underwood would survive today’s bombing with nary a scratch.
She sighed, and stepped into the sea of humanity. Only four hours left, and she needed to make the most of them.
WASHINGTON, D.C.
MARCH 23, 2057 (SUPPOSEDLY)
ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL Preston Lane needed a moment to process the information the four people behind him had just presented.
He pivoted and faced the floor-to-ceiling window of his office in the Time Department’s building. The building was known as the Bubble for a variety of reasons. The first was obvious: its round glass shape looked like a bubble. But the second was because it was protected by time bubble after time bubble after time bubble. “Time bubbles” were the nickname for “time-guards.” In some ways, time bubble was more accurate, in that the bubble froze a time period into place.
He worked here instead of the Robert F. Kennedy Department of Justice building (which was a nice, but old building) because the Time Division of the Justice Department, like all time-related government departments, had offices here. The Bubble protected all who served.
The yard outside was in full spring bloom. Cherry trees lined the wall, their blossoms in full pink flower. The green grass, the emerging foliage, all spoke of a fantastic DC spring.
Which hadn’t quite arrived in DC yet.
The permanent staff blew smoke up his ass about the yard. It’s enclosed, so it follows its own schedule, the head gardener told him when he’d asked. Think of it like a greenhouse.
A greenhouse with a manipulated timer. He’d gone into the archives shortly after receiving his assignment and looked. This year’s cherry blossoms mimicked last year’s weather. Last year, the trees had reached full bloom by the end of March, just like they had for the past thirty years. This year, the trees outside the Bubble had returned to their April schedule, the one that had made this city and its cherry trees justly famous.
Plants didn’t cooperate inside a time bubble. If you wanted plants to bloom and grow, they actually needed care, just like they would in a greenhouse. If you wanted to pretend that they followed the same schedule as the outside world, you didn’t speed up the timeline or import different plants from different time periods. You set the yard’s chronometer to its own schedule, and prayed that it worked like the rest of the world.
Which it did not. The world was/is/will always be a messy place. For the plants inside the yard, the world had an unbreakable schedule, and theoretically, the entire staff enjoyed that.
It made his skin crawl. All of this did. The deeper he got into his assignment, the more unhappy he became.
Especially with the Wall Street case.
Before he got appointed to the Time Division, someone on staff had noticed that Manhattan’s financial district had been time-guarded from mid-August to mid-September 1920. Time-guards in the United States needed approval from the Time Department. The Secretary of Time had claimed she knew nothing of this, and indeed, there were no records of who or what had installed that bubble.
Plus, the bubble did not conform to government regulations.
Government-formed time bubbles existed throughout the United State’s history, and they also existed now. The White House had its own time bubble, as did Congress, the Supreme Court, and the Pentagon. All of the buildings housing the Cabinet had them as well. Not every place could be protected—if someone could easily get to a United States Representative, for example, because the country did not have enough money to protect district offices. The money instead went to time-guarding polling places on each and every election day in the country, no matter how small the election.
Lane did not have the ability to reset time. Officially, no one did. But he suspected someone held that power unofficially, and that someone or those someones existed in the very government he served.
But the answer to that question was above his pay grade.
What happened to Philippa D’Arco, however, was not.
Lane took a deep breath. He’d go out into the yard and walk among the cherry blossoms if he weren’t allergic to the damn things. Because he needed to move.
But he couldn’t, because he had to finish this meeting. He turned his back on the windows. Wilhelmina Rutger and her three assistants still stood behind him, ignoring the comfortable chairs and the hollow tables that allowed for some selected time viewing.
His wife would be furious. He was supposed to accompany her on some important dinner for her hedge-fund business. She had probably given up on him anyway. She didn’t understand the government’s mandate: anyone who worked in the Bubble had to take a second oath, vowing to never ever use time travel for personal gain. Even if that gain was keeping peace in a marriage already on the rocks.
He forced his attention back to the problem at hand—not his problem, but the division’s problem. They were related, after all.
“Okay, let me see if I get this straight.” He had started so many conversations like this in the six months since his appointment. Time travel’s complexities made his brain hurt. “D’Arco had ten windows for return and missed all of them, which is, apparently, unlike her. She’s also the first investigator we’ve sent to the September 16th bombing who failed to return.”
“Yes.” Wilhelmina was petite and blond, with a friendly face completely at odds with her take-no-prisoners personality. “Philippa’s body didn’t return either, which is our failsafe.”
Wilhelmina peered at him, as if she were testing whether or not he actually knew that. He wasn’t sure he did. He tried not to look even more creeped out. He hated the way that people just vanished when they stepped into the time chamber, even if the vanishing was only for a moment or two. He didn’t want to think about how he’d feel if they came back a few seconds later as a corpse.
“In other words this is extremely unusual.” Lane sighed again, and swept his hand at the chairs. “Let’s sit.”
They did. He frowned at the assistants, having no idea who they were. Wilhelmina always seemed to bring a different set of assistants to every meeting. Lane wasn’t sure if that was because she couldn’t keep assistants or if her assistants swapped out due to those time complexities.
“Philippa is the first woman we’ve sent to the Wall Street bombing,” Wilhelmina said. “Our previous investigators were all men. The first one arrived just after the time bubble burst, 12:01 pm on September 16, 1920, one minute after the bomb went off. He couldn’t even get into the bomb site at Wall and Broad. We tried to have our second investigator arrive at 12:02 pm, and he couldn’t do that. He could travel outside the time bubble around the financial district, but he couldn’t time-travel inside it within hours of that explosion. We sent our third investigator to Manhattan one month before the explosion with the idea that he would get a job that would allow him to investigate the entire area, and see if the historical record is missing something that we should know.”
Lane remembered now. “That last guy is the reason we ended up sending Philippa.”
“Yes.” Wilhelmina smiled, even though the smile did not go to her eyes. The smile said, We’ve had this conversation and you should remember it. All of it. I hate repeating myself. Sir.
He did remember the conversation now. He had asked her, Why weren’t we aware of the rigid class structure in New York at that time?
It’s not class structure that we’re running into per se, sir, Wilhelmina had told him. It’s nepotism. To get hired in the House of Morgan, you need to have some kind of relationship with someone who does work there. And in 1920, we’re at the height of the corruption that became known as the Teapot Dome Scandal. Everyone inside the New York Police Department who could hire our man won’t now, because he has no ties to Tammany Hall. We—
He’d cut her off. He had no idea what Teapot Dome was, and didn’t want to find out. The same with Tammany Hall. He had some historical expertise, but it wasn’t New York in the 1920s. When he accepted the President’s appointment as Head of the Time Division in the Attorney General’s Office, Lane had hoped to use this job to deal with interesting things, like people traveling back in time to murder someone else’s grandmother who just happened to be a federal judge or something.
Instead, he was dealing with protected time periods that hadn’t been protected by the proper authorities, and hints and allegations of alleged time abuse. Half his staff was somewhen else at the moment, investigating, prodding, poking, seeing there was a case. Or, as his boss, the Attorney General, liked to say when he brought potential cases to her, the staff was seeing if this was something that would “benefit us in the next election, or is it something that we can leave on the scrapheap of history for the next administration?”
Maybe he should quit, before the cynicism took him out of the game entirely.
“Sir?” Wilhelmina asked.
He’d checked out again. He wondered if he could pretend it was because he didn’t understand the time paradoxes.
“No one looked at young women in that period,” Wilhelmina said through gritted teeth. She was clearly repeating herself. “If they had jobs, they were clearly from the wrong class and being women, they were considered stupid.”
He had no idea how anyone could find women stupid. There had to have been women like Wilhelmina in that day and age. How had anyone believed they were inferior?
“Philippa is one of our best operatives,” Wilhelmina said. “She studied the bombing for three months before we sent her back. She’s spent a month In Time.”
Lane hated that phrase. It came from In Country, military slang for foreign territory, particularly a war zone. But its use here often confused him, because the rest of the world always wanted him to do things “in time” as well, and it meant something completely different. Like “just in the nick of time,” which was the only way he’d make that dinner date now.
“Philippa couldn’t have been killed in the bombing. She knew where she should stand, what she should do, where the most victims were, the greatest danger. She knew it all. She also knew she could return to us at 12:01, and give us her information. She would have come back, sir. I know it.”
Wilhelmina’s voice shook as she said that last, not with anger, but with sorrow. Or was it fear? Either way, he’d never heard those two emotions in her voice. Now she had his full attention.
“So what do you want to do?” he asked.
Wilhelmina was authorized to do a lot on her own. The fact that she had come here, with a request that she hadn’t yet articulated, meant something was very different.
“I want to send in an investigator, sir,” Wilhelmina said.
He frowned. “We already sent in three, not counting Philippa. At a certain point, we have to decide that we have done what we can on this investigation. We only have so many resources.”
“We don’t leave people in the field,” one of the men snapped. Everyone looked at him. He paled. “Sir. Sorry, sir. I mean, after all. She could be in trouble.”
Could have been in trouble, Lane mentally corrected. But he didn’t say it. He continued to address his questions to Wilhelmina. “Do we have information on her after September 16?”
“In a cursory search of the historical record, her alias, which is Philippa Darcy, does not show up. But it doesn’t mean anything. Thirty-eight people died that day, and 143 were seriously wounded. But that was according to the statistics released long after the fact. No one put up flyers or tracked everyone who had been on the street that day. Even if they had the resources, they didn’t have the will. The newspaper reports, for godssake, only listed names and address of the lower-class victims, and that was only if they got identified. The authorities didn’t even know for certain if the body parts they found matched up to the—”
“I’m aware of the vagaries of the pre-technological age of investigation,” Lane said. “I’m asking if Philippa Darcy married or showed up in the public records. Maybe she had done her best to leave a message…?”
The investigators were supposed to send their recall device back if, for some odd reason, they decided to stay in the past. Only a handful of people had ever stayed, and all of those had traveled back just a few years, not more than a century.
“No message, sir,” Wilhelmina said. “We checked. But Philippa is in the payroll roster in the House of Morgan for the week before. There is no payroll roster for the week of the 16th, and she isn’t on it the following week.”
Lane placed his hands on his knees and slid back. “Clearly there’s a problem with the time-guard around that time period. What we’ve been doing hasn’t been working, so I don’t think sending another investigator into that time-guarded period is the best answer. I think you’ll need to come up with a new plan to figure out how this bubble got placed, and who placed it.”
One of her assistants slumped, but Wilhelmina’s back straightened.
“I’m not asking for someone new to investigate the bombing or that time-guard, sir,” she said in a how-dumb-are-you voice. “I’m asking to send an investigator to locate Philippa. I have to believe that she knows something, that she discovered something, and that someone is preventing her return. None of our failsafes have worked, and at least one of them should have. We should have some knowledge of what happened to her, and we have none.”
“You automatically leap from this mission didn’t go right to someone has harmed her?” It was Lane’s turn to use the how-dumb-are-you voice. “For all we know, she could have been standing too close to the bomb when it went off, and she got vaporized. She, her device, the failsafes, everything. After all, as you just pointed out, our information from that time period isn’t exactly trustworthy. And I seem to recall that they never did figure out with any certainty what happened that day.”
The third assistant grimaced. “There’s a lot of evidence to suggest—”
Wilhelmina held up a hand, silencing him. “We do an out-and-back,” she said. “A short mission, looking only on that day. We send in someone new. We give him the right credentials. After all, William J. Flynn took a train in from DC the moment he heard about the bombing. We can have our man take jurisdiction for just a few hours.”
Lane had no idea who this William J. Flynn was, although he supposed Wilhelmina had once briefed him on that as well. So many cases, so much to remember. Maybe he would resign at the end of the year. Clearly all of these time paradoxes were taking a toll.
“I thought we already did that,” Lane said. “Wasn’t that our second investigator?”
She glanced at her assistants. “We had the wrong credentials.”
“What?” Lane asked. He knew he hadn’t heard this.
“We had legitimate New York police department credentials, but we had given our man a position too high up in the department. They figured out fairly quickly that he was a fraud. Only they figured he worked for former Commissioner Arthur Woods, not that he had come from the future.”
Arthur Woods. Another name Lane probably should have remembered. He sighed. He would have to read up on this entire investigation just to refresh his memory. He could either do that, or trust the woman who sat before him.
“How much will this cost the department?” Lane asked.
“It depends,” she said flatly. “You can calculate the loss of a human life and the loss of the training we invested into the investigator, or you can figure the price of one more trip into time.”
“Possibly losing another investigator,” he said.
“Possibly,” she said.
“If we do, we both lose our jobs,” he said.
“That’s what’s worrying you?” she asked.
“No,” he said. “It isn’t. What worries me is that we’re doing something we don’t entirely understand. We’re throwing more resources at it rather than investigating the best methods and then taking them. There is no hurry, Ms. Rutger, as you’ve often told me. If we send in someone today or next week, it won’t matter. They’ll still go back to the same time period.”
She raised her chin ever so slightly. He had gotten through.
“You’re right, of course,” she said. “In my concern, I had forgotten that. We will conduct a more thorough investigation, and then I will consult with you again.”
“Thank you,” he said.
Wilhelmina and her assistants left, but he remained seated. Something about this disturbed him greatly. Not Wilhelmina’s hurry or even the assistants’ passion. In fact, he understood the assistants’ passion. They could have been the ones on the front lines. But for the luck of the draw, this conversation could have been about any one of them.
No, something else bothered Lane.
New York’s financial district. Three major attacks that he knew of: this one in 1920, the 1993 bombing of the World Trade Center, and the 2001 destruction of the World Trade Center. Plus at least two thwarted attacks, one in 2012 against the Federal Reserve in lower Manhattan, and another in 2025 against the New York Stock Exchange.
Were they all time-guarded events? If so, were they time-guarded by Homeland or Justice or the Time Department? Or by someone else? Something else? A multinational? A foreign government?
Lane stood up slowly. He had to make a choice here. He could remain the ignorant figurehead, disappointed in the job that they had given him, or he could step into his role as the chief investigator of time irregularities for the Federal Government.
He hated those dinners his wife planned. He used to love investigative work. He’d simply been overwhelmed by his learning curve and, if he were honest, by the fact that he walked through several time bubbles every morning when he came to work. He hated the Bubble, but everywhere he’d worked in DC had a time-guard of one type or another. The problem wasn’t the job; the problem was his attitude.
He’d allowed others to dictate policy during his first six months here. Time to change that, no pun intended. Or maybe he did intend to pun. Because it was past time. And he couldn’t use the amazing resources at his disposal to start again. So maybe he could use them to solve something huge.
Or, if this wasn’t huge, just to make the right decision in the Philippa D’Arcy case.
Whatever that decision might be.
MANHATTAN
SEPTEMBER 16, 1920
PHILIPPA GLANCED AT the clock hanging on the far wall. The incredible clack of typewriters had its own rhythm, a rat-a-tat-tat-tat-tat-tat-tat bing! that had become familiar to her. At the desk next to her, the new hire sang “Over There” faintly under her breath, a reprieve from the Tin Pan Alley tunes she had started the morning with. The last few hours of Philippa’s last day. She looked at all the girls around her, intent on their typing or fixing their shorthand or stacking already-completed letters in manila folders, and wondered how they would fare.
They might be all right. The large room had no windows, the grillwork making it seem like a prison. All of the girls who worked there wore white shirtwaists and long skirts, their hair in a neat bun. They seemed interchangeable and probably were, to the men who ran the House of Morgan.
Philippa straightened her desk, rolled a sheet of House of Morgan letterhead in the platen of her Underwood, and stood up.
Mrs. Fontaine looked up from her desk. It faced the rows and rows of desks.
“You do not have permission to stand,” she said. She was twice the age of the girls and twice their weight. She ran a tight office, but a fair one. She pretended to be an ogre, but the girls loved her, because she understood what it was to be young and employed and a little bit terrified.
“I’m sorry,” Philippa said. “I’m afraid I need a personal moment.”
Technically, the girls weren’t to leave their desks until their thirty minute unpaid lunch break. But Mrs. Fontaine understood that women couldn’t always sit that long, particularly at certain times of the month. She claimed she got her girls to do five times the work the girls in other financial houses did, because she allowed them “personal moments.”
Mrs. Fontaine nodded. “Make it quick.”
Philippa wouldn’t make it quick. Not that it mattered. After noon today, she would no longer be employed at the House of Morgan.
She would make one more tour around the building, and try to see if there was something unusual. Then she would return to her desk and prevent some of the girls whom she’d befriended from taking their usual lunch. They would be safe inside their windowless room, but on that street, near the Curb Market, the Sub-Treasury, the New York Stock Exchange annex, and all of the other buildings, people would die, lose limbs, have their lives forever changed.
Technically, she wasn’t supposed to prevent that. Technically, she was supposed to go about her business. But there was no way of knowing what the girls would have done without her, so trying to play that game didn’t work. She had to live with herself, and even though, in her real life, in her real time, these women were long dead, they were alive now, she’d been their friend, and she owed them.
She slipped a steno pad into the pocket of her long skirt, and stepped away from her desk. She smiled a thank you to Mrs. Fontaine, then headed in the direction of the women’s necessary. The one great thing about the House of Morgan was that it had bathrooms and they were clean. Not that she needed to use one.
She waited until she was out of Mrs. Fontaine’s sight, then pulled the steno pad from the pocket of her skirt. She hugged the pad against her chest and then wandered, making certain she looked lost.
It had worked every time she had done this in the past. Some man would ask her where she needed to go, she would give an answer, and he would point her in the right direction. The younger men would ask her name, and give her a bright smile. The older men would sometimes put their arm around her and guide her to the correct floor.
She didn’t want either to happen today. She needed to do her last tour unescorted. Then, if she didn’t find anything, she would slip onto the street and run to the Sub-Treasury building.
She couldn’t get their mission off her mind either. Right now, as she patrolled the inside of the House of Morgan, workers at the Sub-Treasury building were transferring a billion dollars in gold coins and bullion to the federal assay office across the street.
She had no real idea how they were doing this; her reading told her that the workers were using a wooden chute, and after the bombing, a U.S. Army battalion would arrive to protect the gold.
Initially the Time Crimes Division believed someone was trying to steal the gold. After the first investigator discovered that no gold got stolen, someone suggested that the time-guard had been put into place to prevent the gold from getting stolen, and had been successful.
But that didn’t make sense either, because the gold would be a lot easier to steal after the bombing than before. Hell, she could figure out how to do it: she could time travel into the Sub-Treasury or next to the chute in the assay office at 12:01 in the chaos. With the right kind of manpower and weaponry, the gold would disappear.
But it didn’t; it wouldn’t; it never would. It would remain.
The fact that she was even thinking of heading to the Sub-Treasury building showed just how desperate she was to get some information, any information, before she left 1920 at 12:02 pm. She had already been to Sub-Treasury courtesy of a nice young guard, who had thought her harmless. A different nice young guard had shown her what he could in the assay office, and there, she found nothing out of the ordinary.
Not that she knew what she was looking for. Something. Something had to be here, besides this bombing.
Something had to be so important that changing it threatened The Way Things Were.
She walked up a marble staircase to the private meetings floor. She’d been called into a few of these conference rooms. She’d sat on a wooden chair in the back and taken notes.
Today, if someone asked where she was going, she had a half-plausible lie based on that previous experience. She knew that Junius Spencer Morgan the younger, the heir to the throne, was having a meeting in one of the rooms facing Wall Street. She’d seen photographs of the aftermath, although she wasn’t sure which room he was in. If someone stopped her, she would tell them she was going to relieve the secretary handling that meeting.
But no one stopped her. She went up staircase after staircase to floor after floor and she was about to give up, when she noticed one of the doors to the maintenance area stood open.
She’d tried that door in the past, and it had been locked. This time, she slipped inside.
Four men were leaning together, gesturing and whispering. They appeared to be arguing. They didn’t notice her.
They didn’t look like maintenance men. They were too clean for one thing. People who did physical labor in this decade had a layer of grime on their clothes and skin that just couldn’t come off in a weekly bath. Their clothes were off too. A little too shiny, a bit too new. And one man wore shoes that had a metal ridge she had never seen before. Or, rather, that she hadn’t seen in a very long time. Or, rather, that no one would see for many many years.
The men all looked at her at the same time. One man flushed red.
“Can we help you?” asked the man wearing the odd shoes. He had dark eyes and skin that wasn’t quite white. She wouldn’t have noticed that a month ago, but after living here, in a world where everything was defined by skin color, last name, education, and accent, she noticed.
Her heart started pounding. Her planned lie about Mr. Morgan seemed wrong, somehow.
“I saw the open door…” she said.
“Christ,” hissed the man who flushed. “She saw us. No one was supposed to see us.”
His teeth were white. Even. Perfect. So were the teeth of the first man who spoke. So were her teeth. People here remarked on that.
These men didn’t belong here any more than she did. And, she would wager, no one in the Time Division knew about them.
She backed out of the room, slammed the door closed, and ran for the stairs. With one hand, she lifted her skirt enough so that her own boots didn’t catch, and with the other, she put the steno pad in her pocket. Then she reached for the railing. The steps were slick, and she had to slow down some.
She heard footsteps behind her. She sped up just as someone grabbed her. He smelled of cologne. Not Bay Rum. Cologne. Nothing from this time period. It was too subtle, too complex. And the hand that covered her mouth had had a manicure.
She bit his palm. He cursed, but didn’t let her go. Instead, he dragged her up the stairs. She struggled, but couldn’t free herself. Her feet banged on every step, jarring her all the way up her spine.
Surely, someone on the lower levels heard that. Surely, someone would come investigate. Surely, someone would do something.
She elbowed the man, then tried to hit his face with her fists. When he pulled her onto the upper floor, she levered herself up on his arm and kicked him on his shins. He didn’t even flinch. He continued to drag her. One of the other men joined him, and they flung her into that room.
She slid along the floor on her skirt, and nearly slammed into the wall. The men peered down at her.
“What do we do with her?” asked the man who had flushed.
The man who had dragged her reached down, and pulled her lips back so that he could look at her teeth like she was a horse. She tried to bite him again.
“Feisty bit of business,” one of the other men said.
“Who are you, really?” the man who dragged her asked.
“Philippa Darcy,” she snapped, using the name she used in this period. “I’m expected in Mr. Morgan’s office.”
“It’s eleven-thirty,” one of the men said to the others.
The man who dragged her grinned. “Then I’ll wager that Mr. Morgan won’t mind if you don’t show up. He probably won’t even notice.”
“He will,” she said, keeping to the game. “He’ll notice. He’ll send someone searching for me.”
“Nice try, honey,” said the man who dragged her. “But you girls aren’t that important to anyone in the House of Morgan. No one except your boss even knows your name.”
“What do we do with her?” the man who flushed asked again.
“We can’t send her home for another 31 minutes,” said the man with the shoes.
Her heart rate increased. They knew. They knew about the bomb; they probably knew that she didn’t belong here.
“What’s really going on?” she asked.
“Ah, honey,” said the man who dragged her. “That’s above your pay grade. It’s strictly need-to-know.”
She struggled to her feet. Damn the skirt. Her legs caught in its folds.
“I think I need to know,” she said, with more bravado than she felt.
“And you will know,” the man who dragged her said. Then he grinned. “All in good time.”
And all of the men laughed, as if he had told a particularly witty joke.
WASHINGTON, D.C.
MARCH 23, 2057 (SUPPOSEDLY)
LANE WAS DEEP in his research when his assistant peeked her head in the door. He nearly snapped at her, but thought the better of it. Her lips were in a thin line, her hair slightly out of place. She looked frazzled, and one reason he had hired her was because she was the most unflappable person he had ever met.
“The Attorney General just called a meeting downstairs,” she said. “He says it’s urgent.”
“I thought nothing was urgent in the Time Division,” Lane said.
“Apparently,” she said, “this is.”
MANHATTAN
SEPTEMBER 16, 1920
AT 11:55 AM, Charles Gage took his seat at the back of Fred Eberlin’s New Street restaurant. The place smelled of frying meat and spilled beer. The table was sticky, and even in the middle of the day, the electric lights were on. They weren’t very powerful, and they barely cut the gloom.
The waiter who had greeted him didn’t want him to sit so far back.
“Wouldn’t you rather have a seat up front by the window, sir?” he asked as Gage strode toward the back of the restaurant. “You can watch all of New York go by without moving a muscle.”
“Not today,” Gage said. Today, if he sat by that plate glass window, or any plate glass window within six blocks of Wall Street, he ran the risk of serious injury, maybe even death.
Even sitting this far back was a risk. But he wanted to be inside the time-guard. Within the hour, the police would block off sections of Wall Street, and he wouldn’t be able to get in unless his paperwork was perfect.
He didn’t want to rely on perfect paperwork. He wanted to rely on outsmarting whatever it was that had set up the time bubble in the first place.
The waiter sighed loudly. “The specials are on the board up front, sir, but I suppose I can recite them for you.”
“I’d rather have a sarsaparilla,” Gage said. He’d acquired a taste for the damn things on another job, ten years ago his time, but only a year before this one. He had a hunch that whatever the Coca-Cola company used to make the drink was bad for him, but he didn’t care. It was a taste he couldn’t get anywhen else. If, of course, he had time to drink it.
He pulled out his pocket watch. He’d set it to New York time the moment he arrived. He couldn’t get to Washington D.C. on September 16, so he’d had to settle for Philadelphia which, for some reason, wasn’t time-guarded at all. He took a train to Manhattan, and arrived at Penn Station at nine a.m. Then he’d walked down the island, and stopped near the Equitable Life Insurance Building, which, at 38 stories, was currently the tallest building in the city, if not the world.
He’d loitered outside for as long as he could, watching the cutthroat operatives of the outdoor Curb Market trade the junk stocks and bonds that the regular markets sneered at. Part of him was fascinated to see history in action. The Curb Market’s annex was nearly finished, and these traders would move inside within the year. But for the moment, they acted like street vendors, waving their tickets and shouting to be heard.
But he couldn’t simply observe them. He needed to keep an eye on the street. He was watching for a touring car with a New Jersey license plate. He was also looking for some sort of old wooden wagon being pulled by an elderly horse. The horse would end up in pieces all over Wall Street, as would the wagon. The touring car would end up on its side.
Smart money believed that the car rear-ended the wagon, which had probably come from the DuPont Powder Works with a load of dynamite. Manhattan had banned the transport of explosives on its streets during the daylight hours, but that didn’t mean that companies followed the rules.
He saw the touring car, recognizing its plate—NJ24246—and realized that the man who claimed to be the chauffer in the news reports looked nothing like the man driving. Then Gage saw a brand new wagon being pulled by an elderly horse. He wished he could take video, but he didn’t dare. He was already attracting enough attention by standing outside the Equitable Building.
He’d slipped through the crowds and made his way to the restaurant where he sat now, wondering if the things he had seen had any meaning whatsoever.
Not that he was here for the bombing. He wasn’t. He was here to find Philippa D’Arco, or Darcy as they called her. Her image was stamped—literally—inside his mind. One of those chips that the investigators for the Justice Department used on occasion. He knew what she looked like when she walked, talked, laughed, as if he had known her well. He wouldn’t be able to miss her any more than a lover or her own family would have.
If Gage saw her. If he found her.
He wasn’t entirely sure she was still here. He had telephoned the House of Morgan that morning, and asked if she was working. He’d been told that secretaries did not receive personal calls while at work, and then someone had asked his name.
“I’m her father,” he had lied. “Her mother’s gravely ill. I would like to speak to her.”
“You may do so during her regular luncheon,” the young man who had answered the phone told him. “All female secretaries take luncheon beginning at noon.”
“But she is in the office?” Gage pressed.
“She signed in at 7:45 am, sir. Good day.” And the young man had hung up.
So Gage had three pieces of information to take back with him. Philippa D’Arcy had shown up to work. The chauffer on the touring car did not look like his photograph in the papers from the hearings. And the wagon that might or might not have been carrying the dynamite was brand new.
The waiter set down a tall glass with the greenish brown liquid foaming inside. Gage picked it up, hoping for one sip before all hell broke loose—
And then the world went white. A sound, louder than anything he’d ever heard, shook the building. The air turned fire hot, then evaporated, and his lungs ached. He dove under the table. Too late. Already shards of glass had slid their way here.
Everything went deadly quiet. Nothing. Not a single sound. Almost as if all of New York held its breath at the same moment.
And then someone moaned.
The waiter was crouched against the back wall. The two customers who had been sitting near the window were sprawled on the floor. Another waiter leaned against the counter, still clutching a plate of food.
Gage stood, ran his hands over his suit, checking to see if he was uninjured. He was. He knocked some glass shards out of his hair, picked up his hat, and shook it off as well.
The screams were beginning, as were the cries for help.
He took a deep breath, tasting smoke, blood, and something acrid, but at least there was oxygen again. He steeled his shoulders, and stepped into what he knew would be the hardest few minutes of his life.
He had to step over the injured, pass the dumbstruck, avoid the helpless, and head for the door. It had been blown open by the force of the explosion. A young man sprawled on the steps, bleeding from a gash in the head. His trembling right hand reached for a spiked rail that had ripped through the shoulder of his suit.
That had to be George Lacina, who worked at Equitable Life Assurance, the man whose comment to The New York World had set off all sorts of alarms in 2057. Lacina said that he later noticed that all the buttons on his coat had come off, and his watch was ten minutes slow.
Almost as if time had stopped. Or gone backward. Or rippled.
All signs of a time-guard.
Gage glanced at his pocket watch. It appeared to have stopped. But as he looked at it, the second hand moved. He needed to do the same.
It was easier said than done. Hundreds of people poured out of buildings, hurried down stairs, and ran away from the financial district. Some of them bleeding, many of them covered in glass or plaster, all of them looking terrified.
He had to go upstream, pushing through them all, careful not to fall or he would be trampled to death. All the while his feet slipped on blood or severed limbs or body parts he couldn’t identify.
A woman on fire screamed as she ran past him. A man tackled her from the side, wrapping her in a coat.
Gage pretended he didn’t see, reminded himself it was history. When that didn’t work, he lied to himself that it was a virtual simulation—and he’d been through hundreds of those. Thousands. He couldn’t help these people. They were more than a century dead, and for most, this was the worst day of their lives. But he couldn’t reach out, couldn’t do anything.
He had to find Philippa.
He reached the House of Morgan, pushed his way up the narrow steps toward the open doors. People still poured out, but he didn’t see her among them. He caught some of the women who looked unhurt.
“Philippa,” he said. “Where’s Philippa?”
Mostly they shook their heads, then shook him off. One heavyset older woman frowned at him, said, “She went … necessary. But … an hour ago.”
Only she was gone before he could parse out what that meant. Or what he hoped it had meant. Philippa had gone to the ladies room an hour before and had never come back.
If she was a smart little time traveler, she would have vanished by now, safe back in 2057, inside the Bubble, making her report. But he was here because she hadn’t done that. Her body hadn’t shown up, her chip hadn’t activated, her failsafe device hadn’t returned.
He knew his chip would survive a blast—he’d been through half a dozen of them, not to mention the fact that everything was tested for all kinds of conditions—so he doubted her equipment had failed.
He kept grabbing people, asking, “Philippa?” and getting no response.
Except from a red-haired young man, wearing shirtsleeves, and ripped pants.
“Thought I saw her upstairs,” he said, voice trembling. “Lordy, I hope she’s all right.”
Gage nodded, kept moving, found the stairs, tried to ignore what he saw. Couldn’t ignore all of it. The young man held into place by something large—a bit of wall, maybe?—pinning his skull to his teller cage. The man with the broken leg trying to help another man bleeding from the face. The woman ripping pieces of her skirt and using them to tie off oozing wounds.
Above the trading floor, the glass dome that marked this part of the House of Morgan creaked. People screamed and dove for the walls. He didn’t. He knew it wouldn’t collapse.
Junius Morgan, carrying a wounded man toward the door. His face was scorched, his clothing blood-covered, but he seemed determined.
All of these people were heroes. Gage wasn’t. He couldn’t be. He had to keep searching for Philippa.
He explored several floors, saw more wounded, but no more dead, avoided some of the dazed victims, and kept searching. He didn’t see her and no one seemed to know where she was.
He spent nearly two hours inside the House of Morgan, exploring each room, seeing all the damage—which was much more considerable than the papers ever made it out to be—and he found no trace of her.
It was as if she had followed instructions and vanished. Only she hadn’t.
Finally, when he walked out of the bank, exhausted and covered in dirt and blood, he braced himself. Time to assume his identity as a Pinkerton, pretending he’d been hired by the Equitable Company, since the House of Morgan was unofficially using William J. Burns’s International Detective Agency.
He would find Philippa, or the parts of her, or what became of her, if he had to stay here for the next year to do so.
WASHINGTON, D.C.
MARCH 23, 2057 (SUPPOSEDLY)
THE CONFERENCE ROOM, bunkered under the building, was an unassuming little space, modeled on the White House’s Situation Room. Bunkered, time-guarded with all the latest gadgetry, but so shielded that no one could travel in even from inside the Bubble itself.
Lane hated the little room. It looked like something out of time itself. Rectangular, with blond wood paneling, matching table, and the most uncomfortable blue chairs in the world, the room was always stuffy and tension-filled.
He was the last person to arrive, and as he pulled the door open, he had only seconds to prepare. No one had warned him that he faced not only the Attorney General, but Cabinet Secretaries from Treasury and Time as well. And, off in a corner, as if he were monitoring the meeting instead of participating in it, Brandon Carnelius, the Chairman of the Federal Reserve.
Lane had barely gotten the door closed when the Attorney General said, “You need to recall Charles Gage from 1920.”
Kayla Huntingdon was not known for her diplomatic skills, something that had gotten her into trouble with Congress more than once. Sometimes Lane wondered how she ever made it through her confirmation.
“We lost an operative,” Lane said. “And we’ve found some anomalies.”
“We know,” said Noah Singh. He ran Treasury. He was known for his diplomacy, not that it showed at the moment. “Recall him anyway.”
Lane knew better than to remind Singh that he did not work for Treasury. Annabelle Tsu, the Time Secretary, nodded. “We have decided. We’re going to leave the time-guard in place.”
“We didn’t create it,” Lane said. “I’ve researched. It didn’t come from the government.”
“Not technically,” Singh said. “But you needn’t worry about it.”
Lane looked at Huntingdon. He realized from the set of her full mouth that she was furious. She had not been informed about something. Tsu’s long red fingernails tapped on the tabletop. Apparently she hadn’t been informed either.
“You want to tell me what’s going on?” Lane asked. He’d directed the question at his boss, Huntingdon, but he didn’t care who answered.
“Technically, you don’t have the security clearance,” Singh said. “We’ve decided to bring you into this, since you might run into an anomaly, as you call it, again, and we need you to be prepared.”
Huntingdon looked down, her blond hair covering her face. Lane had seen her do that before. It was a deliberate move so that no one could see her expression. Yep, she was pissed. And he had a hunch he was about to be.
“I’m not sure that you’re aware of the fact that the Federal Reserve System was founded in 1913,” Singh said.
“I know my history,” Lane said.
“Let him speak,” Tsu said quietly.
“And worked with other central bankers in other nations during the various wars. The Fed’s powers expanded after the Great Depression, the Great Recession, and of course, the recent Currency Crisis,” Singh said. He sounded like every bad professor Lane had ever had.
“Let me cut through the bullshit for you,” Huntingdon said. “Somewhere along the way, these so-called financial geniuses figured the only way to control monetary policy was to change it. By going backwards.”
“What?” Lane blinked. No one was supposed to alter major historical events just because they hadn’t worked properly. Or what this generation thought of as properly. “They can’t do that. It’s not legal.”
“We started our policy before it was illegal,” Carnelius intoned from his corner. As if that made it right. There were laws in place to cover such things. Otherwise someone could go back in time and do something that wasn’t a crime then, but was now, and be completely immune from prosecution.
Lane started to say that, but Tsu shook her head. Tsu, who looked as angry as Huntingdon.
“Forgive me, sir,” Lane said to the Fed Chair, knowing he was out of turn. “But we’re all forbidden from messing with Time.”
“Yes, we are” Singh said, taking the focus off Carnelius. “The Fed knows that now. But they started before the rest of us. Interestingly enough, they had time travel devices long before anyone else did. And they did things that they’ve been trying to clean up ever since. You’re probably most familiar with the Flash Crash of 2010? That was an error on the part of the time travelers from the International Monetary Fund, who are tied into this as well.”
“I don’t understand,” Lane said.
“Someone,” Huntingdon said, “and no one will say who…” and with that she looked at Carnelius, “tried to use a time device in 1920. And then tried to cover it up. Which is why all the original detectives from the Bureau of Investigation to the New York Police Department to the private detectives had no real idea what happened, because all of their theories were true.”
Lane got cold. A messy cover-up led to conflicting time stories, which led to bad investigations, which lead to chaos that often cost lives. Like it had in this instance.
“We cannot investigate the so-called bombing without making matters worse,” Huntingdon said. “So call off your people. And when you hit a similar time-guarded moment related to something financial, check before you send investigators into the past.”
“Wouldn’t it be easier if we knew what periods to avoid?” Lane asked Huntingdon.
Her lower jaw moved slightly before she responded. “It would. And yet, apparently, the Fed is not in the business of making our lives easier.”
Carnelius shook his head slightly, as if no one understood him.
Lane filtered several responses before he said the one thing he felt he had the right to say, “We’ve been working on the Wall Street Bombing for nearly a year of our time. We’ve used a lot of resources. Why has this just come up now?”
“Because,” Carnelius said, “one of your operatives stumbled on some of ours.”
“Who?” Lane asked. “And when?”
“In 1920. Miss Philippa—Darcy? D’Arco? She stumbled on my people. The moment they found out who she was, they sent word to us.”
Time didn’t work that way, but the language didn’t keep up. They’d found out in 1920, but when had they discovered it in 2057? Or had they? How had word gotten back? Lane didn’t know, and he had a hunch everyone would say he didn’t have the right to ask.
“When can we get her back?” he asked. That at least, would be a victory. He wouldn’t have lost an investigator to this ridiculous operation.
“They won’t give her back,” Huntingdon said, the frustration clear in her voice.
“See here, Kayla. It’s not quite like that,” Singh said.
“She can’t come back,” Tsu said. “She knows too much.”
“She’s ours now,” Carnelius said. “You don’t need to worry about her. We’ll take good care of her.”
“Like you took good care of Wall Street in 1920?” Lane snapped.
“Prescott,” Singh said. “Some respect.”
“Yes, respect would’ve been nice, wouldn’t it?” Lane said as he got up. “Thirty-eight dead, hundreds more injured, in what history considers the worst act of terrorism on American soil until a bombing in Oklahoma City in 1995? All caused by some idiots mishandling time travel for the Federal Reserve.”
“Technically, it wasn’t us,” Carnelius said. “We’re not the only Central Bank with time travel capabilities.”
“Oh, that makes it so much better.” Lane spread his hands on the tabletop and looked at Huntingdon. “I’m going to tender my resignation.”
“And I’ll have to refuse it,” she said. “With this kind of secret, you have just become a lifer in the Time Division.”
Lane’s breath caught. He felt a moment of terror that he then suppressed. “You can’t do that. I serve at the whim of the President.”
“And at whose whim does the President serve?” Tsu muttered.
“Enough,” Singh said. “This meeting is over. And it never happened.”
“Of course not.” Lane felt dizzy. “Just like I never lost an investigator.”
“You didn’t lose her,” Carnelius said. “You simply transferred her to a better paying job.”
“I did nothing of the sort,” Lane said. “I want that on the record.”
“What record?” Huntingdon asked. “This meeting never happened.”
Lane tilted his head back. His brain hurt. And this wasn’t even a time paradox. It was a political one, with real repercussions on real people’s lives.
“When will you return her to us?” he asked.
“We won’t,” Carnelius said. “She’s ours now. Forever.”
That would have sounded ominous outside of the Bubble. Inside it, it was damn near terrifying.
“I suppose you won’t tell me what that means,” Lane said.
“It means she’s elsewhen.” Carnelius stood. “And that’s all I’m going to say.”
MANHATTAN
SEPTEMBER 1, 2088 (SUPPOSEDLY)
“YOU’VE GOT TO be kidding,” Philippa said. She sat on what looked like air, a clear chair that was more comfortable than anything she felt in weeks. “I have to stay here?”
“Not here, exactly,” said the man who had dragged her. His name was Roland Karinki, and he worked for the Time Unit in the Federal Reserve. At the moment, they were in the Manhattan Fed, in a room that literally vanished in the clouds. “You’re free to leave this job, to do whatever you want.”
“But I can’t go home,” she said.
“If by that you mean 2057, no, you cannot. It’s forbidden to you now. But we can use your services here or in the distant past. We have a lot to do.”
She tried not to look panicked. She tried not to be panicked. Her training had warned her that she might get stuck out of her time. It wasn’t supposed to bother her. She was positively bloodless, after all.
But she didn’t feel bloodless.
“I liked 2057,” she said. “No, I loved 2057.”
“I believe you,” Karinki said. “At least you’re not trying to lie to me by saying that you’re leaving behind friends and family. I know Time Division forbids both of those.”
“Not friends,” she said, although if she were being truthful, she had not been encouraged to have good friends.
Which made her wonder about all those girls she’d worked with in the House of Morgan. Had they made it out safely? Were they badly wounded? Would she ever know?
“You’ll like it better here,” Karinki said. “I promise.”
“Promises from a man who grabbed me and tossed me into a room, then took me out of my life. Great. How do I know I can trust you?”
“Because,” he said. “I have orders from your boss. Do you recall Prescott Lane? He left a file for you, which you can view at your leisure.”
She narrowed her gaze. “I know nothing about 2088. You could have faked it.”
“I could have,” Karinki said. “But I didn’t. We didn’t. And we will help you adjust.”
She leaned her head back, and thought for a moment. She was somewhen else. That was what she wanted when she woke up this morning in that wretched two-room flat, with two smelly girls beside her on a flea-ridden mattress. And she had a hunch the food would be better than it had been in 1920. The attitudes would be better as well. And then there was the matter of comfort.
Maybe she was positively bloodless. Because she could feel herself transitioning to the new when.
“I need a hot shower,” she said. “Some new clothes. And a bed in a place that has climate control.”
“That’s easy,” Karinki said. “How about dinner?”
“Sure,” she said. “Alone. In my new apartment. With all kinds of information at my fingertips about the last thirty-one years. I won’t make a decision until I know what my options are.”
“Fair enough,” he said, and then extended his hand. “Welcome to the future.”
She looked at his palm. It was clean, but it had bite marks on the fleshy part that he hadn’t yet cleaned up.
“It sure as hell better be nicer than the past,” she said.
“Time periods are never one thing,” he said. “You should know that.”
She did know it. Maybe better than he did.
Maybe better than anyone.
She looked out that window at Lower Manhattan. Sunlight reflected off the Equitable Building struggling to survive between skyscrapers she couldn’t identify. Through the buildings’ canyons, she saw the Upper Bay, Battery Park, and a clean Statue of Liberty. Saw New Jersey in the distance.
“What month is it?” she asked.
He grinned. “September.”
She looked outside again, but not down this time. Up, like people on the sidewalks in 1920. She saw a clear blue September sky. The kind that promised one of those spectacular New York days, the kind that made you wonder why you lived anywhere else.
“I’m staying in Manhattan,” she said. “I don’t care when. But I do care where.”
He studied her for a moment, then nodded. “We can arrange that.”
“Good,” she said. “Because I wouldn’t work for you any other way.”
____________________________________________
September at Wall and BroadCopyright © 2014 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Fiction River: Time Streams, edited by Dean Wesley Smith, WMG Publishing, August 2013Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2014 by WMG PublishingCover design by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Rolffimages | Dreamstime
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
The kids at school call Wilhelmina “Cry-Baby Witch.” Kinda true. At least about the witch part. But they don’t know that, and Willi still struggles to control her magic.
So, when she gets caught using her magic to help one of the animals in Mrs. Anderson’s room, Willi fears the worst. Because creepy Craig Maddson now knows Willi’s secret. She knows he plans to tell on her. But she has no idea how to stop him.
“Chameleon” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Chameleonby Kristine Kathryn RuschWilhelmina crept inside Mrs. Anderson’s room, and sat there, with the lights off. Outside the windows, snow fell in big white flakes, faster and faster, so fast that Willi couldn’t see the teacher’s parking lot just across the sidewalk. The chameleon paced in its little cage. The mama gerbil had her back to the cold, and the papa gerbil, in his own glass world, watched the snow as Willi did. The snake cage was open — the boa constrictor was still missing — and the mice were crowding their own cage in its absence. The rabbit sat on a table up front, nibbling on a carrot and staring at Willi with beady eyes.
Willi didn’t mind. She felt safe here, in the humidity, with the smell of too many furry bodies. Even with the boa constrictor on the loose, popping out of the ductwork, and scaring the principal as it had done the day before.
Everyone else was waiting out the storm in the auditorium. Willi hated the auditorium. She would rather wait here, with the animals.
The snow had started that morning, after gym. The principal made an announcement, saying it was too dangerous to drive. The radios had already announced that the parents should not try to pick up their kids. Everyone would spend the night at school, if they had to, and Mrs. Bates, the cook, would make them something extra special. Lucky she did at lunch, because the electricity went out just before math. The clock behind Willi’s head still read 1:15.
Willi wasn’t scared. She knew her mom would come anyway. A storm would never stop her mother.
The animals didn’t seem frightened either. They liked the quiet, just like Willi did. She was glad to get away from stinky old Craig Maddson, and weird Dougy Spencer. The kids hadn’t stopped picking on her since she had come to school two months ago, just after Thanksgiving. They made fun of her clothes, and when she went into the bathroom and zapped herself into new ones, the kids stopped laughing and no longer even looked at her. Sometimes they called her a witch, and she couldn’t even tell them to stop because that was what she was.
She brought her knees up against her chest. When she had told her mom about it all, her mom had said that Willi shouldn’t want to be like the other kids. Willi didn’t agree until a week later, when the teacher took them to the natural history museum, in the history of science building attached to the grade school. (Her mom had enrolled her in a university lab school, thinking that smart kids would be kinder than the dumb ones Willi had studied with in Kentucky.) The kids laughed and pointed at all the dead animals, stuffed and frozen in their glass cages. The bobcat had moth holes in its fur, and just beneath the surface, Willi could hear a faint whisper of memory, begging to go free. She wasn’t powerful enough to free the bobcat, so she sat in front of the cage and cried.
And had been called Cry-Baby Witch ever since.
Outside the wind howled, and a bit of cold seeped in through the windowpanes. The rabbit’s fur ruffled. Willi whispered a protect spell and blew it at all the animals. They looked up at her, as if in gratitude, and she blew them a kiss.
She wished she knew where the boa constrictor was. It had always been her favorite. She liked its long slimy length, the power in its straight body, the alien coldness in its black eyes. Maybe, if she used dust magic, she could find it.
She whipped the dust into little particles, and sent them searching, but the snake wasn’t in Mrs. Anderson’s room. Willi slipped out into the hall. Maybe the snake did travel the ductwork like the principal said, and she would find it in someone else’s classroom.
The hallway was dark, darker than she had ever seen it. The lockers stood like soldiers at the Air Force base where she had lived with her daddy just before he died and her mother decided to stay for good. The window displays beside each classroom’s door had lights glowing on the contents. The hearts Willi had painstakingly cut with scissors because her mom told her not to show her powers glowed redly. Something moved in the fifth grade’s display case, and as she walked by, she saw the boa constrictor, its body flaking and dry, wrapped around a Peek-a-Boo doll.
It hadn’t been eating school mice as Mrs. Anderson had said. It had gotten itself trapped. And it was dying.
Willi glanced up and down the hall. She didn’t see anyone. In the distance, she could hear singing coming from the auditorium. They had been singing all afternoon in the fake generator lights, away from the storm. Willi thought that everyone would be hoarse by now. She saw someone cross the hall and disappear into the boys’ room. She was as alone as she could be.
She ran back into Mrs. Anderson’s room and got two mice, begging their forgiveness. She wasn’t too fond of mice — they ate their babies, just like the papa gerbil did — and that made her mad, but she wasn’t sure she wanted to kill them. But, as her mom would say, creatures ate each other. That was the way of the world.
Willi hurried back into the hall with the mice trapped in her pockets. She sat on the floor and raised her fingers, making a small turning motion. The thin silver lock guarding the display case clicked and the door swung open. The snake nearly fell out. Willi flattened her hands like a bed, and let the air carry the snake to her. She eased the snake down and put the mice in front of it. She made an invisible barrier so that the mice couldn’t run away. The snake looked up at her, its cold cold eyes actually seeing her for the first time, and then it snapped a mouse between its oversized jaws.
Willi stood. She couldn’t watch this.
Craig Maddson stood behind her, his face white as the bunny’s fur. “You are a witch,” he whispered. “And I’m going to tell everybody that you stole the snake and you’re killing mice.”
“I did not!” she said. “It was dying!”
But he had already taken off running down the hall, his Nikes slapping against the tile floor. She couldn’t let him tell. She couldn’t. The kids hated her bad enough. But if the teachers thought she messed with the snake, she would never go into Mrs. Anderson’s room again.
Never see the rabbit again, never hold the chameleon and watch its personal magic. Never be safe.
Without thinking, she raised her hand and bid the air to tie Craig’s feet. He tripped and skidded along the tile, finally landing outside the auditorium. He sat up and flopped his legs like a fish. Then he started screaming.
The principal burst out of the auditorium door, his short rotund frame crouching over Craig. Willi put a hand over her mouth. She had made it worse.
The snake had swallowed the second mouse and was slithering against the wall, trying to hide. Willi glanced around. The principal would see her. Anywhere she went, he would see her, and she had already used her magic quota for the day. She was trapped.
She turned and ran down the hall, past the doors to the gym, past the music room and into the narrow hallway where the grad students had their tiny offices. All the doors were shut and locked. They must have gone home before the snow hit.
The end of the hallway smelled of paint and formaldehyde. Willi burst through the double doors leading to the Natural Sciences building. She spun around the corner, and found herself face to face with a stuffed bear. She stifled a scream. The bear was so old, its fur had no whisperings at all. She ran past it and all the other dead animals, until she found the hall of the dinosaurs.
Her teacher, Mr. Hayes, hadn’t taken them in there. He had pointed at the dinosaurs and laughed. “Those models,” he had said, “were made in the 1950s, before I was born. They’re out of date and wrong.” But they had looked great to her, tall majestic beasts, with green skin and eyes as cold as the snake’s.
She didn’t hear anyone behind her. Her heart was pounding in her chest, and her breathing was coming hard. She hurried into the dinosaur room, and snuck around the big green dinosaur in the middle. The dinosaur had a long neck and a tiny head that was staring at the door. She touched its flank. The dinosaur was made of plaster of Paris. It was cold and hard.
She sank on her knees and leaned against the dinosaur’s leg, waiting for the principal to find her.
She didn’t know how long she sat there, in the dust and the dry-smelling heat. No one had walked on this side of the dinosaur in a long time. Her tennis shoes had left patterned footprints on the floor. Her jeans were covered with a white and green powder. It took a moment before she realized that the dinosaur’s legs were peeling.
Willi touched it, and more dust dropped onto her hand. She couldn’t imagine being so old and out of date that no one even tended her. Poor dinosaur. She leaned her head on the plaster of Paris, and listened, but heard no whisperings, no hope, no feeling of being trapped like she had gotten from the bobcat.
The dinosaur wasn’t dead. It had never been alive.
Somehow that made her very sad. She brought her knees up to her chest and tucked her chin against them. Ice pelted the side of the building, sounding like rocks thrown against a concrete wall. No one had come after her yet. Maybe they hadn’t seen where she had gone. She was used to her mother, whom no one could ever hide from.
Willi got up and dusted off her jeans. She wandered to the back of the dinosaur room. Other dinosaurs stood against the wall. A rounded one, with a big head and an armor-plated back, had lost all its covering on one side, revealing a mesh frame. The pterodactyl (her favorite and the only kind she had heard of) was missing one wing. Maybe Mr. Hayes hadn’t brought them here because the dinosaurs were in such bad condition, not because they weren’t up to date.
Maybe she would stay here forever. The dinosaurs didn’t care who she was. They were different from all the dead animals, just like she was different from all the other children. Her mom said she had to blend in, learn how to get along with humans. But Willi didn’t want to blend in. She wanted to save a snake without Craig Maddson telling on her, and she wanted to talk to the rabbit without people thinking her crazy. She wanted to free what little life she had found in the bobcat, if she could only find a way.
Her mom made it look so easy. Everyone thought her mom was normal. They didn’t know that she made dinner by pulling out the groceries they had bought for appearance sake, snapping her fingers and setting out serving trays. They didn’t know that she changed her hair color without going to a beautician. They didn’t know that she didn’t work for a living because she had all the money she had earned on horse races since gambling became a craze in Atlantic City.
No one could put anything past her mom, but her mom could put stuff past them. That, her mother had said, was what Willi had to learn.
What Willi had failed this afternoon.
She sighed, and coughed as dust got into her lungs. No one would come for her. She would rot in this back room with all the non-dead dinosaurs. Half of her wanted to get found. Half of her wanted the principal to kick her out.
The other half wondered who would take care of the animals if he did.
She wandered back to her hiding spot and touched the side of the dinosaur. This time she did hear whisperings, but like nothing she had ever heard before. Voices. Voices were trapped inside the dinosaur.
…is too. They get really big and they stomp all over everything and eat people…
…I’m going to get on its back and it’ll take me away, like Danny and the Dinosaur…
…If only I was as big as you. Then they wouldn’t hit me any more.…
The voices were small, light. Children’s voices.
…It is too real. You just can’t see it. It comes out at night and watches us while we sleep.…
…and it was really hot, and all they got to do was eat and sleep, and hunt…
…I don’t know why I like ‘em. I just think dinosaurs are cool…
Willi moved her hand away. The dinosaur’s head had turned just a little. It seemed to be smiling at her. What lived inside it were fantasies, beliefs, fears, and it held them dear. She leaned her head against its side.
“I’m sorry that you’re flaking,” she whispered. “If they let me come back tomorrow, I’ll have enough magic to fix you.”
The dinosaur’s smile grew, and the voices swirled around her, almost too fast to catch. It took a few minutes for her to realize that some of the voices she was hearing were coming from the hall.
She let go of the dinosaur. The children’s voices disappeared. Only two adult voices remained.
“…saw her in the middle of the hallway, feeding the snake. We don’t tolerate theft in this school, Mrs. Ramsey.” The principal’s nasal voice echoed. Willi ducked against the dinosaur’s leg.
“Of course she fed it.” The voice was her mother’s. The tone was exasperation at a stupid human being. “The snake was dying. It must have been a hard choice for her. My daughter loves animals. She had to sacrifice mice to keep the snake alive.”
“We don’t know that the snake was dying, any more than we know that your daughter ran this far. This area is forbidden to children —”
“Mr. Caldwell, I have just about had enough of your prattle,” her mother said. “I know my daughter’s mind. If she’s going to hide, she’s going to hide well. And what I said about the snake is pure logic. You said it’s been loose for a long time — a fact I find appalling — and I assume there are no mice or rats in this building, except for the ones in cages. Now, I don’t know how long a boa constrictor can go without a meal, but it stands to reason that the thing would not be in good health.”
They stopped outside the door. Willi saw their feet swirl the dust. Her mother was wearing her black cowboy boots with their four-inch heels. The principal had on his good leather shoes, the ones without the scuffs.
“I must be frank with you, Mrs. Ramsey. Ever since Willi came here, she has not fit in. She spooks the other children and she does strange things like she did this afternoon. I don’t know what she said to Craig Maddson, but he was so frightened that he couldn’t move his legs for the longest time —”
“Mr. Caldwell, my daughter is brilliant and talented and unusual. I thought an experimental school like this one would be a haven for her, but you’re like the other teachers in this country. You only care about making her normal. Well, she’s not normal and she never will be. Perhaps you should concentrate on making the children better individuals instead of better clones.” Her mother took a step into the room. “Willi?”
The yell was for show. Willi’s mother knew where Willi was, and Willi knew better than to stay hidden. She snuck out around the side of the dinosaur, wishing it could protect her. But it could only listen and absorb her hopes and fears.
Her mother’s hair frizzed in all directions, and her leather coat hadn’t a speck of snow on it. The principal looked rumpled in his black suit.
Her mother said. “Willi, are you all right?”
Willi’s hands were clenched in small fists. “I didn’t mean to do anything wrong. The snake was just trapped, and I was trying to help it, and Craig Maddson is so mean!”
“It’s all right, honey. You’re not coming back here.” Her mother held out a leather-gloved hand. “Let’s go.”
“I must protest,” the principal said. “There’s a blizzard out there. You may have made it here safely, Mrs. Ramsey, but you’ll never make it home, not with the child.”
“Try me,” Willi’s mother said. They started down the hall, Willi’s hand tightly wrapped in her mother’s. “By the way, you might want to catch that snake. It’s stalking Willi’s favorite rabbit.”
“How —?”
“No!” Willi shouted. She broke free. “Stop it, Mom. You’ve got to stop it.” She ran down the hall, around the corners, past the bear, past the offices, past the rooms, until she reached Mrs. Anderson’s. The snake had made its way under the desks to the table in the front. The rabbit was washing its face, all unaware. Willi scooped it up and hugged it to her chest, burying her face in its warm, musky fur.
“It won’t get you,” she whispered. “It won’t.”
She whirled and climbed on the table, leaning against the windows, against the swirl of depthless white. The rabbit trembled in her arms.
Her mother and the principal appeared at the door. The principal saw the snake, turned and hurried down the hall. “Willi,” her mother said. “You’re being silly.”
“No, I’m not,” she said. “This rabbit’s just like me. Nobody likes it and nobody protects it.”
“You protect it,” her mother said as she came in the room, gingerly stepping over the snake. She stopped by the window and tapped the chameleon’s cage. “You would do a better job if you became like this little fellow. Blending into your environment, but never losing track of who you are.”
“That’s what you yelled at him about.”
“Mr. Caldwell?” Her mother smiled, making her entire face look no older than Willi’s. “No, honey. He wants all children to goose-step in place, to be the same creature. In the real world, snakes, rabbits and mice all share the same plot of ground, but they have to be careful of each other.” Her mother glanced around. “You’re right. This is a very safe room. No wonder you like it here.”
Willi leaned against the window. The glass was like ice against her back.
“Here, let’s put that snake back so your rabbit is safe.” Her mother clapped her fingers and the snake floated across the air. The lid on the snake cage came open, and the snake lowered into it, gently. Then the lid went back on.
Slowly Willi set the rabbit down. The rabbit scampered a few feet away, then huddled, as if it still wasn’t over its fright.
“Let’s go home, honey.”
“No,” Willi said. “They’ll wonder how we did it.”
“It’s all right. You’re not coming back.”
This would be the fourth school she left in the past year, and the only one with animals. Willi glanced at her rabbit, at the chameleon, at the snake. The dinosaur in the next room needed her help, and the animals needed her protection. She didn’t want to leave them, no matter how mean Craig Maddson was.
When the snake had run away, it had nearly died.
“No,” Willi said. “I want to stay.”
“I thought you didn’t like it here.”
“I like some things,” Willi said. She liked Mrs. Anderson and the animals. She even liked that back room, filled with dust and dinosaurs. She especially wanted to see the dinosaur again. “Maybe I been too much like the rabbit. Maybe it’s time to see what the chameleon can do.”
Her mother smiled and hugged her. “Fitting in isn’t what matters. Being true to yourself is. You’re not a rabbit, honey.”
She knew that. But she wasn’t a chameleon either. She was a big green dinosaur, the kind that didn’t exist by human standards, made of strange materials, and filled with fantasies, beliefs and fears.
She put her arm around her mother, and they headed to the auditorium. They would stay. They would suffer through the singing and the cold food, and maybe Willi wouldn’t fit in, maybe she wouldn’t be normal, but maybe for a short time, in the dark, in the storm, the other kids would think she was one of them.
____________________________________________
ChameleonCopyright © 2012 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Dinosaur Fantastic, edited by Martin H. Greenberg, Daw Books, 1993.Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2012 by WMG PublishingCover design by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Arnaud Weisser | Dreamstime
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved.This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental.This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
I know you’re all looking for a great read to get you through the last two weeks of summer—unofficial summer, that is. In the States, summer ends with Labor Day, even though the official end is September 23. But life and work and all those supposedly non-summery things will start getting in the way of those beach reads. Or in the case of Las Vegas, the sitting-inside-and-basking-in-the-AC reads.
Well, I have the answer for you. It is the Big Time Bundle 2024, which I curated. It has great fiction from Lisa Silverthorne, Ron Collins with Jeff Collins, Kathryn Kaleigh, Robert Jeschonek, Douglas Smith, Dean Wesley Smith, Michael Stackpole, Kevin J. Anderson, with Doug Beason, and WMG Publishing, Inc.‘s Holiday Spectacular Time Travel anthology.
My own contribution is one of my most favorite. The Gallery of His Dreams was nominated (or won) every award that existed in sf at the time. I wrote the story during a rough time, and it was a great escape for me. I hope it will be for you.
The bundle will exist for two more weeks before fading away. So you’ll run out of…time! Yes, time! So get yours now.
Here’s the link. https://storybundle.com/time
War correspondents and soldiers possess one thing in common: They only see pieces of the war—even a magical war.
Everything rests on a single magical weapon, dispatched by Pixie Air, which the soldiers believe will solve everything.
One war correspondent questions how. But for the first time, she finds herself on the battlefront, hoping that her people succeed in this last attempt at saving their corner of the world.
“Dispatches from the Front: Number Sixty-One” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Dispatches from the Front: Number Sixty-OneKristine Kathryn RuschWinter, Year FiveNear the Cascann Mountains
The shelter is little more than a snow-covered hut. The centaur who brought me up here cannot fit inside. We cover him with blankets to warm him up, give him hot mead and the last of some richly scented stew, and send him back to his troops.
All the way up, he complained about letting a human ride his back, even though he is the media liaison for this part of the war. He doesn’t like answering to a woman, particularly a woman once known as a unicorn tamer, a woman whose only real magical skill—besides her learned ability to put pen to paper—is to get equine creatures to do her bidding.
He made me swear I was not charming him. I swore. He did not believe me.
The journey up the foothills was treacherous, and one I was glad I did not have to make alone. He remained silent through most of the trip—afraid, he told me when it looked like we wouldn’t reach our destination—that I would report every word he said.
I reminded him that we had censors. Before any parchment gets tied to the feet of the carrier pigeons, it is copied by the monks attached to each unit, and dispatched to headquarters. The monks remove things, the officials remove more.
So I try to be vague while being descriptive. I’m told by my editor that the censors don’t mind harsh talk, just specific talk, talk that will give away positions to the enemy or allow him to divine battle plans.
I’ve heard that the Scralle have lost their diviners and are now relying on general wizardry, but like all rumors, there is no way to confirm.
What I told my centaur—what I tell all of the media liaisons—is that being a battlefield correspondent is like being a soldier. I only see pieces of the war, not the whole. I leave the analysis for the historians of whichever side survives.
Those historians will not know what to make of this—the entire magical world at war with itself.
The hut has only one room. Pixie Air has divided it into two using a gossamer blanket that is sturdier than it looks. The main area, with the large fireplace, is filled with pixies. Those back from the latest mission have the closest pallets to the heat. The rest must rely on blankets so small that they wouldn’t cover my feet.
The second room is for the lumbering non-magical humans—mostly young women or boys who have not reached their full growth. They wear furs and lined boots against the cold. While they wait, they play card games that I have never seen before or ask me and the unit scribe to write letters to their loved ones back home.
I was told, back at base, that I could go on the next mission, but the Pixies object. I am twice as tall as the tallest human here and three times as heavy. I am the only adult over the age of twenty-five.
It doesn’t matter that I have kept my so-called innocence so that I can retain my small magic. What matters out here are height and weight restrictions. If I get into one of the crafts they call pixie boats, there will be no room for the bomber and that will compromise the mission.
The centaur will not return for me for three days. During that time, I will eat the meager rations of food, probably taking something from someone who has an actual purpose in this raid, and try to be useful.
The pixies sit in the farthest corner of their section of the room. The leaders—none of them above a colonel (and I get the sense these ranks may be honorary or self-chosen)—do not know what to do with me. They want to comply with headquarters, but they are frightened and tired and not used to making decisions.
They’re also not used to the cold.
This pixie troop comes from the tropics. They volunteered as a unit—straight out of flight school, one of the older men told me—and fought their original missions in the jungles near their homes.
But after the destruction of the Pegasus Fleet, most of the winged fairies defected. Only a few remained, and those who did had greater uses as attack planners rather than raid commanders.
The pixies continued to move north, until someone discovered—quite by accident—that pixies flying against a gray sky over a snow-covered landscape were nearly invisible.
The air troops got sent here, along with the pixie boats—painted by artist mages to resemble clouds—and sent on their first raid.
Headquarters say Pixie Air has changed the course of the war. They believe that the pixies, with their delicate wings and quiet voices, are the ultimate in stealth weaponry. The Scralle do not know how to find them, let alone bring them down.
Rumors say that dragons have been sent against pixie fleets and have failed. Even if the dragons open their mouths and spew fire against what seems like—to them—an empty sky, they cannot defeat the pixies. They generally fire away from the fleet—dragons being the blindest of all flying creatures.
I mention this late my first night to the commander. She is a delicate woman, who has been in the war from the beginning. She volunteered before her country ever got involved, and she initially attached herself to the First Eighty-second Flight Unit, back when they took multiple ethnicities.
For a short time, she was paired with a pegasus—a good team, she said, because he could fly her into enemy territory and she could invade the headquarters, as unnoticed as an insect, operating as a short-range spy.
When I asked her about the destruction of the Pegasus Fleet, she turned away. Later, her second, a man who has known her since childhood, says she blames herself for the poison. She smelled the mash as the brownies heated it, and it nearly made her pass out.
I say, there is no way she could have known what it would do, and even if she did, she wouldn’t have been able to stop it. Four thousand pegasus on the western front died as vampire troops, posing as humans in the late-night hours, replaced the good mash with foul.
Her second nods. “I know,” he says, “but that does not alleviate her guilt. There are always some friends we cannot bear to lose.”
I say nothing. Each unit I embed with thinks I am new to the war. I am not. I too have lost my share of friends, and some of those deaths will haunt me forever.
But I spoke to her second after I spoke to the pixie commander. She listened to my talk of dragon fire and invisible pixie boats, and looked at me as if I were crazed. Then she held out her right hand.
The fingers are blackened and swollen. The tops of her wings are bandaged, the tip of her nose gone. Even though the pixies wear the warmest clothes they can find, even though the wool they receive from the weavers is spelled against the chill, it is not enough.
These small bodies are used to temperatures one hundred degrees warmer than the warmest days in these foothills. Add elevation, and the temperature drops even more.
The commander must send double, sometimes triple, the number of pixies it takes to keep the boats aloft in case part of her troops lose consciousness or worse.
She figures they have only five more raids up here before the enemy finds our hut. She implied, in our shortened conversation, that my presence might have threatened even those. The centaur and I were visible against the snow. Even though we wore white—also spelled to take away lines, and ease visibility—his hooves left prints, and our scents carried on the chill breeze to the orcs on the other side of the mountain.
She will not approve me for a raid over the next target. I cannot say I blame her. I am getting in the way. My understanding of the way the pixie boats worked may have been right for the first few years of the war, but it is not right now.
So I go to the far corner of the room—the half for the humans. Outside, the wind howls. It has gotten dark. Lanterns hang from the wall, but it is cold back here. The gossamer curtain blocks more than sound; it also blocks heat.
In the far back corner lie the wounded. They will get evacuated as soon as the raids are over. An oxen-drawn transport will leave tracks in the thick snow. Eagle runners can only carry a stretcher between them, and are also quite visible, particularly as they struggle with something that weighs as much as a young human.
Fortunately, most of these injuries are physical. Cursed or charmed injured must go to the barn, as far from the others as possible. We all know that anyone who is taken to the barn will die—it is not warm enough to live there for more than a few days—and while we have compassion for them, we cannot risk being contaminated by them.
Curses seep. They invade dreams, travel in body fluids, or shared utensils. Sometimes they are airborne, although the air here is too cold to keep most curses alive.
Only the house medical mage treats the injured who have been moved to the barn. Before she can re-enter the hut, she gets scrubbed with lye (her skin is so raw, I have no idea how she bears it) and rubbed with herbs that supposedly protect against a curse’s spread. The other mage—brought to create the weapons—says some kind of charm over her coming and going, and everyone hopes that is enough.
I have brought my quill, ink, and precious paper. I sit in the far corner with the gravest of the ill, and take dictation. After a few moments, we realize that I must clutch the inkwell between my legs so that the liquid remains warm enough to use. As the ill talk, I can see their breath.
Only it is not fair to call them “the ill.” They are so much more. There’s Tanre, a boy of thirteen years who has been fighting for the past three. He has just started to hit his growth spurt. The first sprouts of beard form on his chin.
They embarrass him. He wants to remain young forever, so that he can stay with the pixies. But his hands are gone—lost when the last alcana opened as he dropped it through the trap door. His flying partner managed to tie off his wrists and do a rudimentary spell to keep him from bleeding to death. The pixies had already turned around, and the mage who invented the alcana happened to be near the hut.
No one could save Tanre’s hands, but they were able to save his life. He believes the witches in his village will be able to make new hands for him, but no one has the heart to tell him that our side does not use that kind of magic. That kind of magic—which revives dead body parts and uses bits of the darkness in all of us—is what started this war in the first place.
Instead, we leave him with the hope that he will get well, he will live a useful life, and he will fight again.
He sends a letter to his mother, and it is an adult’s letter, filled with nothing but the beauty of the countryside, the courage of the various peoples he’s met, and the strangeness of a woman who can write.
People like Tanre, from countries so remote they are only sites on poorly drawn maps, have born the brunt of this fight. My people stay in the cities, plan the attacks, make changes as the forces grow or diminish. But Tanre and his kind are on the edges of the crisis, seeing the destruction first hand, and believing they make a difference.
His letter is lovely—he is articulate for a boy his age—and it says nothing. The next letter I write, for a young woman named Quay, is not articulate at all, but it is filled with anguish. She has lost fingers, and her face—once beautiful—is black with frost. There are poultices that can help her, healers from the cold communities who know how to treat such damage, but I do not tell her this. I don’t know if she will reach them in time.
Instead, I let her dictate a blunt letter to her fiancé, freeing him of his obligation to her, and letting him marry the woman he has always loved. Tears fall across her dead skin as she says this: she has been promised to him since they were infants. She is letting go of a dream.
I ask her why she does not wait, why she will not let him make the choice after he sees her. She turns away from me, and for a moment, I think she will not answer. Then she says, “It is not fair to hold him to a promise his parents made. The world differs from the one we were born into.”
The world differs.
She says this with simple understatement. The world she was born into, maybe fifteen years before, was in the last days of the Interim. I have lived twenty years longer than she. I was born in the last days of the last war, and saw the veterans return home. I was old enough to go to the flaring conflicts—the firestorms, the politicians called them—that could so easily be put out with arrogance and a bit of so-called diplomacy.
I thought war was that: simple conflagrations among peoples not meant to live together—elves moved from their small woods to houses in the city; sea nymphs forced to work in rivers; the were-creatures, brought to so-called zoos so that they could be studied and tamed.
Whenever a non-native population rebelled, it was seen as an isolated incident. We were raised to believe that all beings could get along. But the hatreds between the dwarves and the trolls; the natural enmity between vampires and humans; the unwillingness of ghosts to leave their traditional haunts, were more than flare-ups. They were the result of too much tampering. Politicians thought diplomacy could solve all—that we would learn to get along, that we could deny our natures—not realizing that this strange idealism created even stranger bedfellows. Believers in dark magic affiliated with practitioners of even blacker magics, and bribed the greedy, like the dragons who normally affiliated with no one.
When the actual war came, it caught us all by surprise and yet shocked no one. It was a logical extension of all that had come before.
But I say nothing of this to her. The world does differ for her. Because she had those early years of calm, when it seemed like all the bloodshed would remain in the past—or at least in distant places with names none of us could pronounce.
In those days, she would not have been able to envision herself here, on this cot, her beauty gone, her dreams shattered, her future the only gift she could give to the man she loved.
In the other room, the pixies plan the next raid, their voices rising in agitation. We cannot make the words out in here—they are lost to the gauze and to the high-pitched tones that the human ear can acknowledge but not truly hear.
I take the letters I have finished, unrolled and drying, to the company clerk. It is better for the letters to go through official channels. If they go back with me, they’re subject to all the censorship that my dispatches must face. The letters might not arrive home before the wounded do.
Then I push past the gauze curtain and step carefully into the pixie area. The pixies are so small that I could easily hurt one if I’m not careful. Their wounded lie on pallets nailed into the wall like shelves. I have not talked to them. I have not tried. Most are in comas induced by too much effort, a loss of magic, and the deep, destroying cold.
“Humans are not welcome,” the commander says to me. “and you cannot report on our conversations.”
I nod. But I know what they’re discussing. It has been the subject of everyone here—the high casualties, the impossibility of maintaining these raids much longer, the future missions. We all hope for five, but the medical mage in the back told me in confidence there are barely enough for one more.
“I have a suggestion,” I say. “Since you’re planning strategy, I thought you might want to consider it.”
The commander puts her hands on her hips. Her wings flutter in the heat waves from the fireplace.
“Speak,” she says. Even in her tiny voice, the word sounds like the command that it is.
“Let me release an alcana,” I say a bit too eagerly. “Then you won’t need anyone else in the boat with me.”
“You’re not to serve,” she says. “We have had strict instruction about that.”
From the centaur? Or from his unit commander? Or have the orders come from even farther up? I do not know and I do not ask. I’ve found that it’s better for me to take action on the front than it is to go through channels. Channels are starting to disintegrate anyway.
(It is amazing to me to write a sentence like that, knowing it will be cut. Why do I write it anyway? Because I have to? Because I’m daring them—you, poor censor, who must read these words? Or because I hope that these reports, all of them, of which this is the sixty-first, will be published some day, some day in an Interim, where a young girl can grow up and think a lack of conflict is normal, where she does not face the loss of her beauty at twenty or the loss of her hands at fourteen.)
“Nothing is strict any more,” I say to the pixie commander.
She studies me, damaged hands still on her hips. I wonder what else she has damaged, what I can’t see, what she can’t see yet. And I wonder if she will survive long enough to take stock, to know what faces her in the years ahead.
I wonder that about all of us, in my most despairing moments. I wonder if any of us will survive long enough to understand what we have seen.
“You have magic,” she says after a moment.
I nod.
“You might lose it. The alcana can destroy magic around it.”
Which is why the pixies cannot touch it, why the boats are reinforced with some kind of metal, made in the mountains a thousand miles from here and flown, at great risk, to these isolated places.
“My magic is small,” I say.
She shrugs. “It is magic. I cannot destroy that.”
“I have the power to charm equines,” I say. “It is supposed to vanish with my innocence. I haven’t tested it since the war began.”
She leaps onto a human-sized stool, left in here as a table. Her wings flutter as she leans toward me. I wonder if that flutter is a form of palsy, the beginnings of a pixie’s loss of control of her various limbs.
“You rode a centaur here,” she says.
“He is the media liaison. He is under orders.”
She sighs. “Innocence is an old-fashioned term for virginity. Have you lost yours?”
“In all the ways that matter,” I say.
She laughs. The sound tinkles, like water across rocks, gentle and beautiful and terribly out of place here. If she were my size, she’d clap me on the back. Instead, she reaches out her small hand and takes my littlest finger, shaking it as if we have just become comrades.
She thinks I am being coy. She thinks I have been with a man. But I am not being coy. I believe there are all forms of virginity, and they can all be lost. Does it matter whether I have made love when I have seen mermaids sliced from waist to tailfin? Or children, orphaned, homeless, and starving, destroyed by the breath of a single brown-eyed dragon? Or men, leaping to their deaths, because they believe their own lives are worth less than the world they are fighting for?
I did not charm the centaur to get him to come up here. I did not even try.
I believe my innocence to be lost long ago, the day I first trudged into the Rhines, volunteering for duty with my papers, my pens and my bottles of ink.
“We leave before dawn,” the pixie commander says, her smile fading as suddenly as it arrived. “Someone will make sure you’re awake.”
She floats off the stool on a current of hot air from the fire. That small movement seems like it takes a lot from her. When she lands on the floor, she puts a hand to her back, hunches for a moment, then, thinking she’s unwatched, winces. Finally she stands upright and walks among her troops, a proud woman ready to face another day.
I report to the weapons mage. He is not the inventor of this alcana, although the inventor once lived in this hut. The alcana is a newer weapon, one developed for the cold regions, designed to work at lower temperatures than most evil charms.
We have had a dilemma from the moment we started using magical weapons against our opponents. Too much darkness in the weapon itself, and we become like our enemies. Our violence, our bleakness, our lack of compassion will only be a matter of degree—and we will no longer be fighting for all that is good and true, but that which isn’t quite as bad and not quite as false.
There are rumors, unsubstantiated of course, that the weapons makers must return to the labs for a debriefing. One maker, on his way out of a camp south of here, told me he feared that he would be put to death upon his return.
“How else can they control us?” he whispered. “There’s no way to test for incipient darkness.”
The alcana inventor has trained his apprentice and left three days before I arrived. Weapons inventors are privy to a kind of invisibility so that they might pass from one region to the next; the centaur and I might have passed him on the trails and never have known.
The weapons mage has long black hair, tangled from the harsh winds, and a beard badly cropped below his chin. His eyes have a desperation to them. He seems more afraid of the weapon than I am, perhaps because he knows what it does.
We are inside what must have been a chicken coop before the winter storms came, before the war found its way up here. The air still smells of dung and chicken feathers. It has a dryness that makes me want to sneeze.
The mage does not let me touch my alcana. That is what he calls it: mine. While I stand there, he charms it to obey only me.
It is smaller than I expect, although twice the size of an adult pixie, and it is shaped like a giant robin’s egg, although it is not blue. It is an iridescent white, a color I have never seen in nature.
It will fall from my hands, silently against the gray sky, landing with a little poof in a pile of snow. Then it will burrow to the frozen ground, and the magic will leach from it, absorbing other magics, turning them and changing them ever so slightly—just enough so that their users can no longer summon them. Unsummoned, the magics will wither, and eventually die.
The only thing we do not know is the range of the alcana. We do not know if magics ten miles away will wither as well or if only the magics in the near vicinity will wither.
“We are protected in any case,” he tells me. “The alcana only steals the dark magics.”
“Then why warn me away? Why warn me that I might lose my magic?”
His smile is slight, bitter. He mutters, “I wish she had not told you that.”
I wait, in silence, and he finally adds, “Because we do not know how many of our magics have their origins in darkness. They have turned light. But light has various shades, and one of them is the gray of twilight. Which side does gray belong to? Both? Neither?”
He wears gloves while he handles the alcana, and hands me a pair just before I leave. He gives me specific instructions which I cannot repeat here—not because I know you’ll delete them, my friendly censor (you will, of course; I would), but because I do not want to trust them to the page even as far as headquarters. If I did, this would be the dispatch stolen, this would be the turning point of the war: the enemy would learn the basis of our weapons technology, and would, then, know how to spell against it.
I cannot give them this gift, even in theory.
Suffice to say my duty is easy enough. Little more than dropping the alcana from the pixie boat. Painfully little, but just enough to cost me my hands should I do it wrong.
And because I will be in the boat alone, no one will be able to tie my wrists. I will bleed to death, trapped in a boat painted like clouds, held up by a fleet of pixies, flying courageously toward their doom.
It is disingenuous to say I am awakened before dawn, just as it is disingenuous to write this in present tense when it is clear by the act of writing that I have survived enough to tell this story to someone. It is just there are few words to describe the moment when someone tapped my shoulder. I was not asleep, but I was not exactly awake either. I had been lying on a filthy cot, thinking of the day ahead, cold and trembling, and then I am awake, following a young man I have not met yet into the boat barn.
The pixie boats are misnamed. They are boxes large enough to hold a platoon of pixies but so small I wonder if I can actually fit inside. The outsides are painted like clouds, or were, but are now so scratched and damaged from use that they look like bits of unusable cotton.
My advisor—I don’t know what else to call him; he never gave me a name—shows me where to lie, how to hold the alcana until I need to release it. My breathing is shallow; I regret begging for this assignment now.
I will be trapped inside that box—alone—until a pixie crawls through one of knotholes in the side and shouts the heads-up at me. Then I release a lever, open the trapdoor beneath me—with nothing to hold me inside the box except my legs braced against the walls—and hold the alcana over the emptiness. Then I activate it, and let it go.
I’m not even supposed to watch it drop. I let it go, pray it hits silently in the snow, and then close the trapdoor. The sound of the closing door will notify the pixies that I’m done. Then they’ll turn around and head for home.
It almost works like that. I do fit inside the box—although how two humans fit inside at the same time, I’ll never know. I have to lay in a fetal position on my left side so that my right arm can reach the lever. The mage has given me a holder—like a little stand—for the alcana so that I do not have to hug it to me. He worries that I might get some permanent damage if I do that.
I’m worried I’ll get permanent damage no matter what. Within a few moments—or so it seems—my entire left side falls asleep. I wish I could follow it—the time in the box is excruciatingly long. Before we even take off, I’m chilled through. By the time we’re done, they’ll have to check me for frostbite, if I don’t fall asleep and die first.
I have no idea how the pixies fly in this—their wings so thin I could shove a fingernail through them. They hold gossamer strings attached to the box. The commander assured me before we left that the strings have the power of a spider’s web, which does not reassure me. I have broken through spiders’ webs many times.
It is surprisingly light inside. The wood is thin and the box poorly constructed; light comes through all sorts of cracks. That’s good; I’d been afraid I’d be flying in darkness.
Liftoff seems surprisingly easy; it’s the mid-air part of the flight that’s hard. The box rocks—partly with wind currents but partly, I later learn, as the pixies drop away, one by one, victims of the cold.
By the time we reach the drop zone, only half the squad remains.
I do not know this inside, blissfully. I am cramped in the small space, unable to do much more than raise my head. I want to move a little, but I’m afraid the pixies won’t be able to handle any great shifts in weight. So I move my fingers on my nerve-deadened arm, and pray that the sleep won’t kill it. I waggle my toes, and count, and, under my breath, recite every poem I learned as a child.
The interior of the box warms a little, due to my body heat and the air I breathe out. But I am still frozen through and through. I cannot believe that some of the human team have ridden on eight or more missions. I do not know how they endure this.
Finally, a pixie squeezes herself through the knothole near my head. Her features are strained, which I attribute to the difficulty she has getting inside, but which I later learn is due to the team attrition. At this point, she doubts we will ever make it back.
“It’s warm in here,” she says in her tiny voice.
“Only in comparison,” I say.
She smiles, but the smile is distracted. “It’s time.”
I nod, and she squeezes out—all going the way the instructors have told me it would. I pull the lever with my good arm and for a moment, I fear that the trap door is frozen shut. Then it squeals open, letting in air so cold that I think I will flash-freeze like a drop of water on a crisp mid-winter day.
With a shaking right hand, I reach for the alcana. I do not trust my left. I remember the boy with no hands, wonder if he had a malfunctioning limb, wonder if he tried to activate the alcana with only partial control of his dominant side.
I scooch against the wall, feeling the rough wood send splinters into my back. I use my knees to hold the alcana, having been warned not to activate it in the holder (in case I can’t remove it, I think).
Then I lean over the trapdoor. Beneath me, I see sundazzled snow, and tops of trees and chimneys belching smoke. All seems peaceful, like the valley I came up with the centaur.
Do they know what’s coming? Do they realize the threat?
Do they care or are they as sick of this war as we are?
I shove the activated alcana through the hole, and reach for the lever, promising myself I will not watch.
I almost make it. I see the puff of snow as the alcana slips beneath the surface, between several buildings and near a tramped down bit of land. The door closes slowly enough that I see someone—human-shaped, although I cannot be sure the person below is human—emerge from one of the buildings and walk the opposite direction from my little missive.
Then the trapdoor closes, shaking the entire box. For a moment, it slips toward the front, sending me sliding toward the lever. More splinters go into my cheek—and probably into the numb left side, although I cannot tell for sure.
I think I hear chatter—screaming, maybe?—although I might be making that up.
Finally the box rights itself. I feel the turn as we head back, and I believe I do doze, in the silence, in the frozen air that suddenly feels hot, in the strange interior light.
When I wake—and this time, I do wake from a real sleep—it is as the box thuds to the ground, back at the hut. The lid comes off, other humans bundle me out and carry me to the human room where the injured lay. Someone rubs my limbs, puts an ammonia-scented ointment on my skin, and whispers soothingly at me.
I go back to sleep, asking no questions, which is so unlike me.
It is not until the following day that I learn only twenty of the pixies made it back from that trip. The other eighty died, falling away like the alcana, too small to even make puffs in the snow.
When the centaur returns, I go to him carrying only my parchment for this dispatch. I have given my pens and ink to the scribe, my envelopes to the clerk. The papers are mostly gone, used to write letters home for the humans remaining in that hut.
There are barely enough pixies for one more raid. The commander tells the centaur that, and he nods gravely.
Then he gets on his knees, camel-like, to let me climb on his back. He does not grouse this time, nor does he mention my abilities.
“I hear you released a weapon,” he says.
“Yes.” I do not want to talk about it. Even now, my skin tingles with the cold and I have no feeling in my left foot.
“Did it go off?”
How should I know? I want to snap at him. He knows better. He is a soldier. We only see pieces of the war, never the entire part. Each action we make might be futile; each life lost, lost for nothing.
Then again, we might have made the decisive blow that changes everything.
Only the historians will know.
“Did the weapon work?” he asks with a little more emphasis, as if I had not heard him the first time.
“I hope so,” I say. For the sake of eighty tiny people I never really met, for everyone in that hut, for all the people scattered along our side of this mountain, I truly hope it worked.
____________________________________________
Dispatches from the Front: Number Sixty-One
Copyright © 2021 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Army of the Fantastic, edited by John Marco and John Helfers, Daw Books, 2007Published by WMG PublishingCover and layout copyright © 2021 by WMG PublishingCover design by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Michele Cornelius | Dreamstime
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
Funeral directors deal with many unexpected things at a funeral, but only a select few know how to handle an influx of flower fairies. Flower fairies often prove unpredictable…except when they get angry. And then they become terrifying.
So, when a flower fairy child shows up alone with a bouquet for someone who requested no ceremony, the funeral director knows to address her carefully. Because if the other flower fairies fear harm might come to one of their children, the humans around them could face the greatest threat of all.
“Flower Fairies” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Flower FairiesKristine Kathryn RuschShe stands behind the bouquet of flowers, her little face barely visible through the green fronds. Her skin is the color of loam, her eyes the faded green of underwater seaweed, and her lips the dusky rose of the tulips that hide her.
My heart pounds. I see her among all the bouquets set on the long white table, but my colleagues don’t. They’re moving flowers, checking tags, figuring out which bouquet goes into what memorial chapel.
We have four funerals this afternoon and two viewings tonight. The funeral home is large, modern, with several exits and entrances, so none of the groups will see each other. Their music shouldn’t even overlap.
On days like today—a Saturday, shortly after the winter holidays—I employ nearly a dozen people, some of whom just stand by the doors and make sure the right family goes to the right memorial chapel.
It’s all very delicate and very sad, and I try very hard to make sure that my employees seem sympathetic. After hundreds of funerals, however, many people lose sympathy. They recognize the patterns and realize some people are loved, some are hated, and some are simply forgotten.
And then there are the very old, whose friends and family have died long ago.
The very old touch me. I can easily see myself as part of their ranks, alone and forgotten. I want someone to honor me when I die, just as I’m sure they wanted someone to honor them.
So I do. For their funerals, I put on my best dress, and sit in the chapels myself. The ceremony is often elaborate, planned for friends and family who are now gone. When that happens, it’s clear the person never expected to live so long. Often she (and it usually is a she) planned her ceremony with my father or my grandfather.
We keep amazing records. My family has planned funerals for this town for more than a century. If a historian comes into our little parlor and asks to see the records from a burial sixty years before, I can find it. I can tell who presided and who attended.
I can also tell what kind of floral arrangements decorated the memorial chapel.
Flowers have always been my specialty.
Perhaps that’s why I notice the flower fairies long before anyone else does.
This little girl looks no more than three, but looks can be deceptive, particularly among flower fairies. Three is a problem. Three means I might have to return her to her family.
When she realizes that I see her, she smiles. Her eyes brighten to emerald and actually twinkle.
She touches the flowers in front of her. Ferns accent a mix of dusty rose and purplish blue tulips, with a single well placed lily in the center.
“I made this,” she says in a decidedly childlike voice.
Everyone in the room turns. The silence, which was already heavy, turns oppressive.
She doesn’t seem to notice. She’s smiling at me. She is as young as I feared.
“Isn’t it pretty?” she asks.
I turn to my assistant Diane. Diane’s skin is normally the color of chalk, but it’s gone even paler now.
“Call Roderick,” I say.
Roderick is the only one of the flower fairies who uses modern technology. He burns through cell phones like smokers burn through matches. Fortunately, he’s smart enough to keep the same number with each phone change.
Diane slips out of the room. Technology usually doesn’t work well in the presence of the magical.
I smile at the little girl. “Your flowers are lovely.”
“Thank you,” she says primly. Then she waits. She wants me to ask what it is she’s doing here or, worse, what she wants.
I never ask the flower fairies what they want. That’s the wrong question. It’s a question—particularly with a magical child—that could get the questioner in decades of trouble.
“Is this your first bouquet?” I ask, not really wanting to hear the answer.
She nods. “Can I stay?”
I don’t dare say no to her. Saying no to an infant flower fairy is much more dangerous than saying no to an adult.
“You can stay,” I say and try not to cringe.
I was little more than a babe myself when I first met the flower fairies. My parents owned a summer cabin near one of the mountain lakes. It was the only place I’d lived that didn’t smell faintly of formaldehyde.
Instead, it smelled of the cool, clear lake water—and flowers.
Flowers. Flowers everywhere. My father believed that the cabin’s previous owners had planted thousands of perennials, not listening to my mother when she would remark that many of the flowers that covered our property every year were annuals. Not only that, but they often bloomed at the same time—peonies and geraniums, roses and lilacs, asters and snowdrops. Seasons seemed to mean nothing on our land, something I didn’t appreciate until much later.
I must have been six when I stumbled onto the clearing. In those days, children—even young children—were allowed to wander so long as they came back in time for supper. I wore a watch with large hands. I’d learned to tell time two years before, and I adhered to the schedule rigidly.
The schedule gave me freedom, which I desperately needed. When you grew up above a funeral home, you knew more about sadness, mourning, and death than you should have. The entire house had an oppressive air—one I accepted as normal until I grew old enough to visit my friends.
Sunlight filtered through the trees, burning off the last of the early morning fog. That fog made everything seem opaque—the trees, tall and strong with their green leaves; the shadows, deep and dark and somehow welcoming; and the flowers, which covered the meadow like grass.
The colors would have been overwhelming but for the fog: Blues and reds and pinks and so very much white that it looked less like an accent color and more like a deliberate shade.
I stepped from my path in the trees, expecting to walk on a carpet of flowers, because that was what they looked like, a carpet that led to another part of the woods.
But I sank into them. The ground where the flowers grew was lower than the ground in the forest. I walked in a sea of blooms, shoulder-high, and I felt like I had found heaven.
My watch stopped and I was late for lunch, forbidden to go off on my own again for a week. By the time I returned, the flowers were taller, and I didn’t like walking inside of their stalks. The darkness with its intermittent rays of sunlight frightened me—and even then, I knew there was something wrong here, something not completely normal.
But I visited the clearing every summer. I learned to remove my watch before I stepped inside, because it stopped every single time I went into the clearing.
But I was never late to lunch again—the fairies saw to that. For such capricious little creatures, they have oddly tender hearts.
We have six memorial chapels—two large, three medium, and one small, so that the family doesn’t notice that the deceased has few friends. This afternoon’s funerals will take place in both large chapels as well as two of the medium chapels.
We’ll have crowds.
But the little girl’s flowers aren’t going to any of those chapels. They’re going to the small chapel, on the far side of the building.
At six tonight, we’re holding a viewing.
I don’t expect anyone to come.
The deceased is Helena Spenser, one of the very old. The obituary that ran in the paper this morning said she was one hundred and five, but the age was just an estimate. Like so many of her generation, she was born at home and no one ever issued a birth certificate.
And like so many women before her, Helena Spenser often lied about her age.
I met Helena a decade ago, when she made her funeral plans. She was formidable, a woman who still had vestiges of unusual height. She carried herself like a dancer, back straight, moving with fluid grace.
I even remember the outfit she wore—a black dress trimmed with red, and decorated with a single rose in the dress’s lapel. Her hat, a cloche which matched the dress in design and trim, tilted rakishly on her thick silver hair.
My office was small then; I hadn’t yet built the new Memorial Center. We sat in what had once been the servant’s quarters in my family’s oversized Victorian and, heads bowed, decided how Helena Spenser’s friends and family would celebrate her long life upon this Earth.
Only this morning’s obituary warned me that Helena Spenser’s family had died sixty years before in a devastating fire. Her close friends—a group of widowed women who had raised hell and money for our little town—died nearly two decades ago.
She had acquaintances, but not the kind that most older folk had. She had never left the home she built after her husband and sons died, so she had no retirement center bridge partners, no orderlies who cajoled her to eat, no nursing home directors who felt it their duty to attend the funeral of one of the “members.” She never went to church, so no minister would feel obligated to say a few words about her passing.
While she’d been spectacular in life—an actress who became a playwright, a self-made woman who had somehow survived the loss of everyone who mattered to her when she was still in her forties, the center of society into her seventies, and a philanthropist until the day she died—she kept to herself.
There was to be no ceremony. I remembered that much without even checking her file.
Such nonsense, she’d said when I broached the topic all those years ago. Show the world I’m dead and then burn what’s left.
I hadn’t known about the fire then. I hadn’t known about it until this morning when I read about her.
I’d known the obituary was coming; I’d called the paper myself to make sure I didn’t have to fund a notice of the viewing from Helena Spenser’s account. But I hadn’t expected the obituary to be so detailed and rich, nor had I expected Helena Spenser’s life to be so fascinating.
Although I probably should have.
I had only met her the once, and she’d made quite an impression on me.
We have no other flowers for Helena Spenser’s viewing, and that angers me. This woman gave millions in charity, and no organization that benefited from her benevolence thought to send a single memorial.
Granted, most people send flowers to funerals and Helena is only having a viewing. And in the middle of this morning’s obituary, the paper had highlighted a box of memorials where money could be sent in lieu of flowers.
I understand charitable donations. I usually encourage them. But someone should remember this woman as she leaves this life to go to the next. Someone should decorate her chapel, just for a little while.
Looks like that someone will have to be me.
Each funeral has excess flowers. The family takes the cards and the bouquets that they want—if any—and then one of my employees discreetly asks if the family minds donating the remaining flowers to lonely nursing home and hospital patients.
Of course the family doesn’t mind. The family doesn’t want to think about the flowers because that’s just one more thing to worry about.
Besides, flowers die too—and that’s an often too visual reminder of the fact that their loved one has just left the world.
So I will take some leftover flowers and decorate Helena’s chapel.
It became Helena’s chapel this morning, when we moved her body from the embalming chamber to the casket and then moved the casket to the front of the room. The casket is polished lavender—not quite the model she picked out (that one has been discontinued) but close enough.
She looks lovely inside of it, nestled on satin that matches her hair. We didn’t have to put much make-up on her. She doesn’t look that much different from the woman who visited me in my office all those years ago.
She’s wearing a black suit with purple piping. The black sets off her hair, the purple accents the casket itself. It’s too bad no one will see this. Rarely has our staff made a corpse look so good.
I check on her before the first funeral. I put the guest book near the entrance, so people can sign in and leave if they want to. I place the placard announcing the visiting hours just outside the door.
Right now, Helena looks lonely in her small chapel, without flowers and without notes. The piped-in music, all 1920s jazz, sounds a little too jaunty for the occasion. But I didn’t pick it. She did.
She had planned everything down to the last detail.
Except, of course, the effects of age and time.
By late afternoon, Roderick still hasn’t arrived. I’ve had Diane page him three more times. I even sent one of the lowliest assistants to the edge of the clearing not far from the old Victorian. This assistant will stand near the old growth tree stumps that dot the back of my property, and call for Roderick.
Roderick never comes when he’s paged like that. Instead, he finds me, wherever I am, and reminds me he’s not a dog.
Of course, this time, the verbal page isn’t working either.
I can’t wait. I have to ready the chapel just in case someone shows up for Helena’s viewing.
Gingerly, I carry the little girl’s bouquet into the chapel. The vase is made of obsidian. I’ve never seen anything so beautifully carved.
The flower fairy sits on the edge of the vase, her feet dangling off the side. Her little fingers caress the ferns. Her emerald eyes twinkle.
“Will everyone like the flowers?” she asks.
I can’t answer that question. If I say yes and no one does, then I have lied to a flower fairy, which puts me at their mercy. If I hedge and say, I hope so, then I am insulting the little being who created this arrangement, because I’m telling her in a sideways fashion that the flowers aren’t good enough. If I say I don’t know, I lose standing with the flower fairies.
Instead, I stop outside the chapel doors. I look down the private hallway and make sure we’re alone.
“Are you sure you want to remain with the bouquet?” I ask.
She nods. She’s tiny and delicate and amazingly beautiful. She looks like a flower herself.
“These flowers are for grieving,” I say.
“I know,” she says. “That’s why there’s a lily.”
The funeral flower, apparently, for flower fairies as well as for humans.
“All right,” I say, and with one hand, pull open the heavy oak door leading into the chapel.
No matter how gently we perfume the air, the scents of death and formaldehyde linger. The body in the coffin never looks real. I am always amazed at how many people say that the deceased looks so happy or so alive or so beautiful.
Helena does look beautiful—for a wax doll—but the vibrant demanding woman I met the day we planned this event was much more beautiful. Animation, personality, that spark of life—it can’t be faked, not with make-up and reconstruction and excellent posing.
It can only be mimicked.
I expect the flower fairy to gasp or be shocked. But she rides on her vase like a soldier going to battle. She does look up front as we walk. A small frown crosses her little face.
“Pretty,” she says, and points.
At first, I think she’s pointing at Helena. Then I realize she’s pointing at the coffin.
“I want the flowers there,” she says, still pointing.
I follow the point as best I can. I swallow, trying to think of a tactful way to tell her the arrangement is too small for such a large empty space.
“Usually,” I say, “something as pretty as your arrangement goes on the shelf just behind the coffin.”
I indicate the shelf near the podium. Usually three of the loveliest arrangements go there. But a single arrangement, particularly one this beautiful, would look spectacular there as well.
“No,” she says and moves her finger up and down imperiously. “There.”
She means the closed half of the coffin. I suppress a sigh and silently wish for Roderick.
Of course, he doesn’t come.
“The viewing doesn’t start until six,” I say. “It’s four now.”
I’m not sure she understands. I’m trying to tell her, in a roundabout way, that she’ll be alone. I don’t dare say that bluntly because I’m afraid she’ll use her budding magic to force me to stay or to bring in my assistants.
Or worse, to bring in everyone from one of the nearby services.
“It’s all right,” she says.
And I hope it is.
“I have some errands,” I say. “I’ll be back before the viewing starts.”
“I know,” she says and settles behind the fronds.
For the next hour, I try not to think of her alone in there. She’s young and if young fairies are anything like young humans, then she must be bored.
If she’s bored, she’ll either sleep or she’ll cause trouble.
I’m hoping for sleep, but part of me expects the worst.
After I leave her, I text Roderick. A plume of smoke rises from my Blackberry, so I know the text has gone through. I set it on vibrate and put it in my pocket.
Then I go to the largest chapel, where the final funeral is just ending.
The funeral is for the mayor’s mother-in-law. She was a difficult woman, who never had a kind word to say about anyone, her son-in-law in particular.
The large crowd isn’t here for her. They’re here to see and be seen. It’s funeral as political event. The mayor will be running for governor next fall, and, unless something goes wrong, he’ll win. Everyone wants to be his friend, in whatever way they can accomplish that.
His wife is the only one crying. She’s not sobbing. Instead, her eyes are leaking. She keeps wiping the tears away as if they anger her.
They probably do. No one should cry for the woman in the casket. Even in death, she looks mean. Her mouth is pinched from smoking, her fleshy cheeks forming jowls that we couldn’t erase with make-up. She died of a massive heart attack while berating the head of the town council and the joke around town (spoken quietly and away from the mayor’s hearing) that she had done the impossible: having a heart attack without having a heart.
The mayor is saying a few words. They’re deft—he is truly a politician—and then he’ll invite everyone forward to pay their last respects.
He has promised me all of the flowers—his wife wants none of them. I slip away, leaving the remainder of the ceremony to my able assistants, who can better stomach hypocrisy than I can.
Instead, I head back to my office, checking my Blackberry as I go.
It’s not like the flower fairies to leave one of their children alone for so long. It’s not like Roderick to ignore my pleas for assistance.
We’ve known each other since my days in the woods, back when I was a child. Roderick took care of me and his price (fairies always have a price) was to learn how to use modern technology.
Roderick wanted to cross between his world and ours. Mostly he manages it. People do notice him, but they think it’s because they find him attractive. Somehow they miss the glamour that slides off him like glitter.
I’m about to text him again, when Diane catches my arm. I didn’t even see her approach.
“You need to come with me,” she says.
She was assigned to our other large funeral of the day, but that ended hours ago. I expect her to lead me to the big chapel. Instead, she takes me to the smallest chapel and carefully pulls open the door.
“Look,” she says.
I’m afraid to. A magical child left alone in a place of the dead. I thought I was making a mistake. Now I will see exactly what that mistake is.
I peer inside, carefully, so that the girl can’t see me.
My breath catches.
Flowers cascade off the closed casket. Lavender and bluebells mix with a carpet of greenery. The greenery outlines the aisle that flows all the way to the main door.
I remain in the hall and let the door close.
The child was bored, and she found a way to amuse herself. My heart catches.
“You didn’t hear from Roderick, did you?” I ask Diane.
Diane shakes her head.
“I didn’t notice,” I say. “The flowers aren’t covering Helena, are they?”
“I didn’t notice either,” Diane whispers.
We should check. One of us should go inside and make sure the girl didn’t cover our corpse with a carpet of roses.
But I can’t bring myself to send Diane in there, and I’m not going to go myself. I don’t know how to tell a magical child—a flower fairy—to stop doing something.
I’ve been chastised by the flower fairies before.
I brought my father to their clearing, hoping he would ask them to do the flowers for his funeral home. They humored him, then made him forget.
And they punished me for sharing our relationship.
They made me promise that I would display any flowers they gave me, even when I became director of the family funeral parlor.
I agreed. I thought I had outsmarted them because I never planned to work with my family.
I was twelve.
I didn’t understand the ways of the world.
I still honor that agreement, even though the contract has expired.
I have seen what happens when someone crosses them.
I adjust the placard on its board. Then I text Roderick again.
Urgent, I type. Please. Help.
The smoke rises, acrid and dark. He’s getting my messages.
He’s just not answering.
And I don’t know why.
At quarter to six, I slip into the private bath behind my office and change into my best dress. This dress is new; I bought it the day I heard of Helena’s death. The dress is black with red trim—not as glamorous as hers was, but I can never do glamorous.
I don’t wear a hat because hats indoors, particularly at a funeral, are often considered bad luck. But I pile my hair on top of my head and secure it. Then I slip one of the hothouse roses—also red—into the makeshift bun.
I can never be as dramatically beautiful as Helena, but I can at least honor her by looking my best.
I slip on a pair of black pumps and grab a glittery black clutch purse.
Then I head for the smallest chapel.
Diane stands outside the door to usher in anyone who shows up. It’s a little after six. So far she’s ushered in no one. We’ve received no calls, no condolences, and no questions about where to send cards.
Roderick hasn’t come either.
I twist my fingers together. The little flower fairy won’t know that anything is amiss at the viewing, but what do I do with her afterwards? I’m not sure she should stay with the bouquet.
Diane grimaces at me as I approach. I recognize the look; she hates these lonely viewings as much as I do. We’ve done too many of them over the years.
“Want me to go in with you?” she asks.
I shake my head. “Send Roderick in, though, if he ever shows up.”
She nods.
I grab the oak handle on the door and pull it open.
This time, my gasp is audible. Diane crowds beside me and gasps as well.
The chapel is covered in greenery. The pews are covered in a carpet of wildflowers, the floor itself looks like it’s made of moss, and trees grow in the corners. Flowers bloom on the shelves—more roses than I’ve ever seen, carnations, and lilies in stunning displays.
But the bouquet on the casket remains, and so does the open part of the casket itself. Helena Spenser looks like she’s resting on a bier made of flowers.
“My God,” Diane breathes. Then she touches my arm. “If anyone shows, should I send them in?”
“Yeah,” I say. I have no idea how I’ll explain this, although I’ve had a few fairy-sponsored magical moments before, and I’ve found that simple works best. “If they ask, just tell them she loved flowers.”
“Okay.” Diane seems reluctant to move.
I know I am. But I’ve come to pay my respects, and I’m going to do that. Then I’m going to sit as if I’m family and watch over her until viewing hours end.
I step inside. The aisle is so soft that my heels pierce it. I wobble. I’ll do damage as I walk, so I pull off the shoes and set them by the door. They’re instantly covered with grass and purple crocuses. I wonder if I’ll ever get them back.
I walk on the moss. It feels warm as sunlit ground. It’s comfortable and soothing, like going barefoot in the glade.
Still, I step carefully. I’m not sure where the child is. I don’t want to hurt her.
I walk up to the coffin. Helena’s eyes are closed, her lashes brushing her heavily made up cheeks. She looks content, even though I’m not sure how. Corpses don’t show emotion.
I glance at the bouquet, wondering how that infant fairy managed so much work in such a short period of time.
But I don’t see her.
I tell myself this isn’t unusual; to create this magical wonderland, she probably has to move around a lot.
But my heart is pounding.
What happens if I lost her?
What happens if she gets hurt?
I don’t even know what to call her. Fairies guard their names jealously and they don’t like pet names.
I decide to cajole her. “This room has never looked lovelier.”
“Good.” The voice behind me is male and it makes me jump.
I turn. The man behind me is taller than I am. He is so thin that my hand could probably encompass his waist. He wears leaves over his hips and down his legs, but his chest is bare.
His skin is green, his hair brown. Instead of looking strange, he looks gorgeous.
Such is the way of flower fairies.
“We have worked hard this afternoon,” he says.
As he speaks, more fairies come out of the greenery. They’re all heights, and thin. Some have green skin, some have loam-colored skin like the little fairy. Some have skin the color of ivory. Their hair often matches the flowers they carry. They are all barefoot. The men wear leaves like this man does, and the women wear skimpy dresses made of petals.
Since fairies wear nothing in the wild, they are covering themselves according to human custom.
“This is stunning,” I say. “And quite unexpected.”
The door in the back opens, and Roderick slips in. He’s wearing a suit and it looks stranger than anything the other fairies wear. Normally, Roderick wears tight black jeans, a t-shirt with some Goth band I don’t recognize, and heavy boots.
The suit looks like an Armani, perfectly tailored to his slender frame. The white shirt beneath accents the darkness of his skin. His normally spiky hair has been combed back, and his piercings are empty.
He looks like a teenage boy told to clean up for his grandmother’s funeral.
“There you are,” I say with so much relief it even surprises me.
He smiles. I thread my way through the throng of fairies and stop beside him.
“I tried to contact you,” I say. “I was worried.”
“It’s a small price to pay,” he says, then sweeps his hand toward the chapel.
As he does, I see the glamour fall from his arm. The scents of moss and sunlight and a hundred flowers follow that glamour
“If I had warned you,” he says, “this would not have happened.”
“Why not?” I ask.
“Because this is your domain.” He bows his head slightly. “We have invaded. We beg pardon.”
He thinks they’ve done something wrong.
“Pardon granted,” I say, because you never cross fairies, no matter how well you think you know them. “I appreciate the respect for my domain. But you do need to know that I would have allowed this.”
He looks at me in surprise. So do some of the others.
“This is a non-denominational chapel,” I say. “What that means is the family and friends can design the service they want for the deceased. Just as you have here.”
The little girl climbs into his arm. She puts her thumb in her mouth and rests her head on his shoulder. She’s watching me with those emerald eyes.
The fairies had sent her ahead because they knew I wouldn’t object to her. They had tried to outthink me.
He cradles her close. “You would have allowed this?”
I nod. “It’s lovely. I’m sure Helena would have appreciated it.”
He says, “We wanted to honor her.”
“She meant a lot to you,” I say, falling into my role as funeral director.
“To all of us.” He smoothes the little girl’s hair. “We honor her, because she honored us.”
I’m surprised. I thought my staff and I were the only ones who knew about the flower fairies.
“She saw you then,” I say.
“Not at first.” He rests his head on the little girl’s for just a brief instant. “But every day for the last sixty years, she stopped and admired our flowers.”
Sixty years. Since her family died.
“Then she would murmur how lovely they were. Gradually we revealed ourselves. She visited our flowers. She played with our children. She was a bright, warm spot in the middle of our day.”
I thought of that for a moment. A woman who had lost her husband and children. A woman who was looking for a way to go on. She had found it in flowers each and every day.
Then she learned the secret behind the flowers and instead of being afraid, she embraced it.
She embraced them.
As I have never dared to do.
“Do you mind if I sit?” I ask.
“Is that what you planned to do?” he asks.
I nod.
“Do you do that at all such occasions?”
“No,” I say. “Only the special ones.”
And this one is very, very special.
“Let’s all sit,” he says. He leads me to the front pew, then joins me. The little girl has fallen asleep in his arms. She has his look around the eyes and lips. I wonder if she’s his.
I know so little about him—about any of them—and I am afraid to ask.
One by one, they approach the open casket, and one by one, they drop a flower inside. The flower varies—sometimes it’s a daffodil, sometimes an orchid. But it’s always lovely and it always fits.
When they’re done, they sit in the pews. Vines cover them. Honeysuckle grows along the walls. Wisteria covers the doors.
We bow our heads in silence to this great woman. We mourn her passing and we celebrate her life.
Then, when the viewing hours are over, they all stand—and vanish.
Except for Roderick. He remains beside me.
“We’ll clean this up,” he says.
“Leave it,” I say. “We won’t use the chapel for another two days.”
He smiles and touches my face. “Come see us in the glade,” he says. “We miss you.”
Then he too vanishes.
I stare at the motes of glamour, still floating where he had been. Before, I would have heard a threat in his words.
I would have been frightened.
Fairies can be terrifying.
But it took Helena to remind me that they are also extremely special.
They honored me today by respecting my chapel while honoring her.
If I treat them kindly, perhaps one day, they will decorate my chapel and sit in silent vigil after I am gone.
I hope so. Because from now on, I will remember that while flower fairies are capricious, they have oddly tender hearts.
____________________________________________
Flower Fairies
Copyright © 2016 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Realms of Fantasy, October, 2009Published by WMG PublishingCover and layout copyright © 2016 by WMG PublishingCover design by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Mega11/Dreamstime
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
I am finishing this up very late. I saved the articles and books in piles, meaning to finish my recommended reading list as I read. But the events of the spring and early summer prevented me from doing much more than my writing and the work I needed to do to keep my business alive. I managed to get bits of the Recommended Reading List done as I read, but only bits. One of those bits is in this introduction. The others are scattered throughout this particular piece.
I wrote the following paragraph right after I finished the essay I’m referring to. I was shaking as I did so, because I was so very angry—and not in a good way.
Wow. I don’t get angry at the essays I read very often, but I lost my temper at one of the essays in The Best American Essays 2023. Normally, I don’t reveal much about an author or an essay I don’t like, but I’m going to mention this one here: “Revelation at the Food Bank” by Merrill Joan Gerber. I’m outing her because she infuriated me with her ignorance and her narcissism. Get this: during Covid, her cleaning lady told her to stop shopping at the grocery store and go to the food bank instead because they didn’t make you get out of your car. So this Gerber woman did. I figured the revelation would be “gosh, look at how many people are struggling.” Instead, this idiot of a woman, a retired professor with a ton of accolades as a writer, a woman who can afford a cleaning lady, for godssake, continued to go to the food bank because she made a connection with “the food bank lady.” No thought to the fact that Gerber can actually afford to buy her own food. No thought to something like grocery delivery. No thought to how many people needed the food she was taking because they couldn’t afford it and had a family to feed. As you can tell, I’m so furious at this woman that I could just…I don’t know. And I’m angry at the editor who bought the piece in the first place and the editor of this volume, who decided that this essay was one of the year’s best. (It goes on and on and on revealing this woman’s total self-involvement. No thought to others here at all.) Man. I do everything I can to support our various food banks and the services for the struggling folks in this city, and then there are people like the two editors and this idiot woman who don’t understand their freakin’ privilege at all. Wow.
Yes, I wrote the above in the moment, and I’m glad I did, because I’m writing the rest of this now after our difficult spring. The above paragraph reminded me how thoroughly pissed off that essay made me (and still makes me) and how it made me wonder if I should even recommend the volume. After a few months, I thought…ah, heck, I can recommend individual essays from the volume. After all, it’s not the fault of the other writers that they’re lumped in with this awful woman. But…as I sat down with the book…I found that I just couldn’t. I can’t honor this editor, nor can I give Robert Atwan, the overall editor, even tacit approval for the terrible decision to include this essay.
You can call this cancel culture if you want. But this is my list, and my website, and I am not going to give any credit to something I find so deeply, deeply, deeply offensive.
Anyway…I did return to the Alexander Chee Best American Essays volume after abandoning it shortly after the pandemic because I couldn’t handle tough subjects at the time. I’m glad I did return to it. I read a lot more than I expected in March. Looking back on it all, I’m a bit astonished by that. Most of it is nonfiction, essays, and articles. Only one novel here, which makes sense considering all that I was doing. I think everyone will find something to enjoy here.
March, 2024Abramovitch, Seth, “Looks Like He Made It: Manilow At 80,” The Hollywood Reporter, January 4, 2024. Because of my age, I know too many Barry Manilow songs. Because of my age, I’m rather uninterested in the man. (It was exceedingly uncool to be a Manilow fan when I was a teenager.) So, as a result, I trained myself to be resistant to all things Manilow. And it took me a while to read this article. I’m so glad I did. It’s about perseverance in the arts at the highest level. If you’re working in the arts, you need to read this.
Biskind, Peter, “We Give Social Media Something to Fight About (That Isn’t Politics),” The Hollywood Reporter, January 26, 2024. A fun article about the things people love about Hollywood. You might agree with some, and might hate others, but this is fun.
Chae, Jung Hae, “The Gye, the No-Name Hair Salon, the Coup d’Etat, and the Small Dreamers,” The Best American Essays 2022, edited by Alexander Chee, Mariner, 2022. I love this essay. It combines the difficulties of dealing with a parent as their own person. It also reflects the way that different cultures impact our lives. And it looks, honestly, at our relationships to dreams and money. Read this one.
Chee, Alexander, The Best American Essays 2022, Mariner, 2022. Unlike the Best American Essays 2023, I can highly recommend this volume. Every essay caught me and made me think. The ones I list here are only there because they had something extra for me. This is an extra special volume. Pick it up.
Crosley, Sloane, “After Barbie, Greta Gerwig Has No Plans To Rest,” Vanity Fair, December/January 2024. Greta Gerwig has more courage than I do. She works in Hollywood and she’s willing to buck every single naysayer she meets. There’s so much quotable stuff here. One of my favorites? “At some point, the terror of never making anything becomes much bigger than the terror of making something bad.” Read this, and try to apply Greta-courage to your next work.
Galuppo, Mia, “From A Child’s ‘Insightful’ Eye,” The Hollywood Reporter, February 16, 2024. An interview with the director of The ABCs of Book Banning, a documentary on how banning books negatively impacts children. Read this, then watch the documentary.
Galuppo, Mia, “It Can Be A Very Lonely Profession,” The Hollywood Reporter, January 8, 2024. Producers are extremely important to making movies, to making certain that creative things happen in Hollywood. It’s really hard to organize a lot of money, the people needed to make the film work, and to keep your enthusiasm for the work. This is a very frank interview among a group of producers. Lots of great quotes, especially from Christine Vachon, who has been in the producing trenches for decades. I love this one from her, which came for me at the right time.
A crisis is only when someone gets hurt. Everything else is just a pain in the ass, a challenge, a problem. But “crisis”—there’s only one reason to ever use that word.
Gimpelevich, Calvin, “Among Men,” The Best American Essays 2022, edited by Alexander Chee, Mariner, 2022. The great hook on this essay caught me at the very start. Calvin was both transitioning and working construction. He ran into a lot of prejudice and had to deal with some problems that every slight male encounters. Only he hadn’t been in the world of men at that point as a man and saw parts of the culture he had never seen before. I’m not going to summarize any more because you need to read this to get the full insight and impact.
Keegan, Rebecca, “‘It Was One Big Train Wreck In My Head,” The Hollywood Reporter, January 18, 2024. This interview convinced me to watch the documentary, The Greatest Night In Pop, which I highly recommend. The interview is with Lionel Richie who pulled off an amazing feat. He had very big and very crazy night. He was hosting The American Music Awards. He was winning awards that night…and he was coordinating the single-night only recording of superstars who got together to sing “We Are The World.” He and Quincy Jones pulled off an incredible balancing act. From writing the music, to getting super famous people (and great musicians) to agree to managing personalities for nearly 24 hours, he did what in hindsight looks impossible. Read this…and watch the documentary, particularly if you’re an artist yourself. It’s astounding.
McClintock, Pamela, “Will Packer Mints Money With Black Movies,” The Hollywood Reporter, January 4, 2024. Like Greta Gerwig (see below), Will Packer has spent decades in Hollywood proving the suits wrong. He has made films that no one believed in because they featured Black performers or were about Black topics. I love reading articles about people like this, because they keep going despite the headwinds. And that is what Packer seems to do best. Take a look.
Mounzer, Lina, “The Gamble,” The Best American Essays 2022, edited by Alexander Chee, Mariner, 2022. A fantastic essay on living with a gambler and about magical thinking. I think there’s a bit of optimistic magical thinking in all writers, so this resonated for me. Unexpectedly, though, in the middle of the essay is a wonderful (very long) paragraph about the way that people give condolences in the various dialects of Arabic (which is fascinating in and of itself). The paragraph ends like this:
Death is the greatest of obstacles, the strictest and most unchangeable of fates. It is the single certainty, written from the start. In its face, this truth must be acknowledged by all. When it comes to death, a surrender to fatalism is a great comfort. Otherwise the if onlys might themselves to your feet, tripping you back into the past every time you try to move forward.
Breathtaking. And quite wise. And well done. There are more gems in the essay. Go see for yourself.
Simpson, Erika J., “If You Ever Find Yourself,” The Best American Essays 2022, edited by Alexander Chee, Mariner, 2022. Boy, I saw a lot of myself in this essay. The rest of the title is “…piss poor and struggling to survive.” I was, after my divorce. Maybe a bit before as well. I had no money and no one to ask for it. (My folks, upon hearing I was getting a divorce, said, “What did you do?” and did not offer to help in any way.) I barely made my bills. I wrote a lot of nonfiction and some places did not pay me. Others did, but never when I needed it. Fortunately, I had that skill, though, so I could augment my income. Still, I did most of the things that Simpson outlines in this essay. I sure wish I had had it back then.
So, Anthony Veasna, “Baby Yeah,” The Best American Essays 2022, edited by Alexander Chee, Mariner, 2022. This is a beautiful essay, very poignant. It’s about hope and despair and suicide. So lost a close friend to suicide, and the essay is, in part, a tribute to the friend. While that’s poignant, it’s made even more so by the fact that So himself died the year after this essay was written. Worth reading, but sad that he will not be around to contribute more.
Spitznagel, Eric, “Take My Joke, Please!” The Hollywood Reporter, January 10, 2024. A really good article on jokes, theft, and copyright. Even though most of us who write aren’t writing for ourselves to perform onstage, we are going out into the world and doing things. So this is worth looking at.
St. James, Simone, Murder Road, Berkeley, 2024. Creepy and marvelous book about a very scary stretch of road and a couple who encounters dark things along it. St. James has written a number of Gothic-adjacent books that I like. This one isn’t Gothic. It’s more contemporary dark fantasy. (I don’t want to say horror, because it’s not quite there either.) I devoured this in two nights, which for me is like reading in a single sitting. It’s not my favorite of hers, but it’ll tide me over until the next book of hers arrives.
Stevens, Angelique, “Ghost Bread,” The Best American Essays 2022, edited by Alexander Chee, Mariner, 2022. I’m sensing a theme in some of the essays I liked. They’re about the difficult relationships between parents and children. This one is about Stevens biological father and her own somewhat difficult life. Memorable and difficult.
Sun, Rebecca, “Blame The Gatekeepers, Not The Filmmakers,” The Hollywood Reporter, January 18, 2024. Very important essay about the reasons why movies about white people’s responses to horrible events in the native community, like “Killers of Flower Moon,” are the chosen narrative voice. Sun’s thesis is that the white gatekeepers can’t see past their own noses. Having seen that reaction to one of my projects which has been under option for nearly ten years now, and has had the “why don’t you focus on the white people” question or worse, the question that comes at me (why did you chose to write about these things? as if as a white person I shouldn’t have violated some code), I think her thesis has merit. If nothing else, it will start discussions.
Andersonville. The name strikes horror in the memory even now. But before Lieutenant Nathaniel Garrison lost two years of his life to that place, he fell in love with a beautiful Confederate—and married her at the exact wrong moment.
Even fifty years later, he hears her voice.
Then, on the Titanic’s sister ship, the Olympic, he sees something he shouldn’t, something that brings back everything: the war, the loss. The woman herself.
“The Dead Line” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
The Dead LineKristine Kathryn RuschJUNE 17, 1911NATHANIEL GARRISON GRIPPED the silver handle on his walking stick and cursed the unsteadiness of his legs. After three days, he should have had his sea legs. The Olympic was the largest ship ever built and, as a result, was steadier in the water than most. He had spent a fair number of years on ships—both before and after the war—and he had never had so much trouble walking on a deck.
Of course, in those days, he hadn’t been recovering from a bout of pleurisy that had nearly taken his life. He hadn’t been this thin since those horrible years in Andersonville, years he was still amazed he had survived.
The afternoon’s weather was balmy and he couldn’t stay confined to his stateroom. He was supposed to remain indoors—all that outdoor air was supposed to be bad for him, not that he cared. He had not made it seventy-four years by believing everything other people told him. His body craved light and air and exercise. By gum, he’d have both.
The Boat Deck was filled with people. Many were sitting in lounge chairs, blankets at their feet, staring across the railing at the surprisingly calm Atlantic. Others were gathered at tables, having animated conversations. Rich people, of which he was one. Captains of industry, their wives, children, and mistresses. People he did not socialize with unless necessity forced him into it.
He supposed he would find a great deal of entertainment among the luminaries on this ship. It was the Olympic’s maiden voyage and, as a result, he found himself in a floating party, complete with reporters hired by the White Star Line to capture the grandeur, and allowed access to all the first-class berths, so long as they did not bother the passengers.
Sometimes he wondered how difficult that was. In addition to him—a man who never gave interviews because he despised the influence of the scandal sheets—there were several other well-known men, including J. P. Morgan who was here, of course, to monitor his investment. Several members of the British peerage were on board as well, many on vacation and some, like Lord Reginald Seton, to do business in New York.
If Garrison had been a reporter, he would have interviewed them all. What would the crew have done, after all? Thrown him off for violating his agreement? He suspected a number of journalists were taking notes, and the very thought of it kept him away from the public areas most of the time.
He rested his arms on the deck’s wooden railing and stared at the gray Atlantic which stretched as far as the eye could see. The sky above it was bluer than the ocean but they still blurred at the horizon. Out in the middle of nowhere, going somewhere fast.
He looked down. Even though he’d been on the Olympic for three days, he still couldn’t believe the size of her. Here, on the Boat Deck—A Deck as the brochures called it—he was as high as he could get. Seemingly miles above the frothing water, as if he were watching from the balcony of one of London’s tall buildings overlooking the Thames instead of from the deck of a ship. A floating palace, the ads had called it, and that was probably true.
A floating palace filled with the usual sycophantic and self-absorbed courtiers, all of whom thought they were more important than they were.
Behind him, a woman laughed. The laugh was fluted, trilling up and down the vocal register like a diva’s playful attempt at a scale. The hair rose on the back of his neck.
He hadn’t heard that laugh in nearly fifty years.
Surely he was mistaken. He was short of breath and just getting over being ill. He had spent too much time alone, and whenever he did that, he thought of the war.
He thought too much of the war.
Then he heard the laugh again, closed his eyes, and saw her, just as he had that first night.
She had taken his breath away then.
Much as she was doing now.
JUNE 17, 1861LIEUTENANT NATHANIEL GARRISON placed his cap under his arm and nodded crisply to the Negro butler who opened the massive oak door. The man before him had to be at least eighty; his dark skin lined with wrinkles, his curly hair a pure white. The man took his hat and his card and ushered him inside.
Garrison had an odd feeling that he had suddenly stepped across the Mason-Dixon line. But he knew that wasn’t so. It wasn’t legal to own slaves up here. The butler had to be a free man.
But it still made Garrison uncomfortable. Despite Lincoln’s denials that this was a war fought over slavery, slavery was the issue that had caused the South to secede. Even the appearance of it here, in the nation’s capitol, made him more uncomfortable than he dared say.
The air was cool inside, despite the awful heat. The entry was large and mostly made of oak. A wide staircase led to the upper stories. On the banister, an iron gas lamp, carved in the shape of Cupid, rose.
Garrison had never been inside the Cunliffe house before, and had no real idea how to act. It was his first society party and he was here only because he was on General Scott’s staff, not because he was important in and of his own right.
His summer dress uniform was still too hot for the heat and humidity of official Washington. A trickle of sweat ran down his back despite the coolness of the entry.
The butler had hung his cap somewhere and was opening the pocket doors that led into the main part of the house. “This way, sir,” he said, bowing before Garrison.
Now Garrison could hear voices and the soft music of a string quartet, playing Mozart. The sound wafted in from the verandah, but there were people in the drawing room as well, holding glasses filled with champagne and plates covered with hors d’oeuvres.
He caught snatches of conversation as he moved into the room.
“…when Tennessee seceded…”
“…President Lincoln isn’t acting as if we’re in a war…”
“…General Scott isn’t just old. He’s senile. We’re—”
That last conversation stopped as the speaker, a young man who wore a cream summer suit, saw Garrison. Garrison took a flute of champagne from a tray offered him by a Negro waiter, and walked toward the verandah.
President Lincoln wasn’t the only one who wasn’t acting as if there were a war. Half of Washington’s military was here, eating finger foods and discussing secession as if it were a parlor game.
Garrison didn’t want to be here himself. He had a lot of work ahead of him drilling the 90-day militia units and trying to form the new three-year volunteer units into a coherent army. None of them had had any real training. Many were simply young men who wanted to fight. And even though Washington was now ringed by military camps, organized units and fancy uniforms did not make an effective fighting force.
Lieutenant General Winfield Scott, who was general in chief, had planned to spend the first year of the war preparing. Even if the plan hadn’t leaked, Garrison thought it wouldn’t have worked. The cries that started with the firing on Fort Sumter had risen in May when Richmond had been chosen as the capital of the Confederacy, and were now hitting a fever pitch.
Richmond wasn’t that far from Washington, after all, and most people thought the war would be over quickly if only the United States quashed the Rebels in their capital.
Garrison was worried that the Rebels might try to do the same to Washington—a fear he shared with General Scott.
Either way, the war would escalate from small skirmishes to a large battle soon enough. The only question was when.
The champagne flute was made of crystal and he had to hold it delicately as he made his way to the verandah. Here, even more people stood. The air smelled of the small smoke fires burning in bowls at the rim of the property to keep the mosquitoes away. Several more servants, holding large fans, waved them up and down so that the thick air moved.
It wasn’t yet twilight, though that hour wasn’t far away. The longest day of the year was fast approaching and sometimes it seemed to Garrison that the days would never be long enough.
Across the yard, he finally saw his hostess, Mrs. Evangeline Cunliffe. Mrs. Cunliffe was a widow whose husband had died of a fever several summers ago. She was known for holding the most important society functions in all of official Washington.
When General Scott heard Garrison complain about the invitation, Scott pushed him to go. Old Fuss and Feathers was never one to turn down an important social function. His political nature was too honed—perhaps from the days when he was the Whig candidate for President, days he rarely talked about since he had lost so badly to Franklin Pierce.
Garrison was not a social man. He would thank his hostess, mingle for a few moments after that, and then disappear into the house. Without making his apologies, he would be on the road back to camp within the hour.
Behind him, a woman laughed. The laugh was fluted, trilling up and down the vocal register like a dance hall girl’s playful attempt at a scale. In the days before his father forced him to go to West Point, Garrison had fancied himself a musician. His father had sent him away precisely to destroy that ambition and had succeeded, for the most part.
Except when something caught his ear, as this laugh did now. He turned, looking for the source of it. Women in wide hooped skirts stood on the lawn, their shoulders bared, revealing cleavage, and their hair in ringlets that seemed too girlish for most of them.
The laugh came again, and he turned again, finally catching the last note of it. The woman who made the sound was wearing pink, but on her the color seemed natural. She had black hair and eyes equally as dark, against skin the color of alabaster. The pink dress had no ornamentation—no lace, no frothy ruffles designed to enhance the bosom. Even though the woman was petite, her features small and foxlike, she filled out the dress nicely, naturally, as if the style had been created just for her.
She wore diamonds around her neck—or what appeared to be diamonds—small ones that caught the light. They added radiance to her face, but he was already captivated. He had never seen such delicate beauty before, delicate beauty that added to, and did not try to hide, strength.
The cloying scent of perfume overwhelmed him, and he suppressed the urge to sneeze. A hand slid through his bent arm and gripped it tightly.
“Lieutenant Garrison.”
He looked down at Mrs. Cunliffe. Her long black hair had been pulled to the back of her head and held in a snood. She still wore black, even though her husband had been dead for years, but the dress whispered as she moved. Silk, and from the look of it, expensive silk at that.
“Mrs. Cunliffe. I was just coming to pay my regards.” His voice sounded foreign to him, stiff, formal, and unnatural, in a way it usually never was.
Her smile brightened her face. She lacked the beauty of the woman he had been watching, but she made up for it in personality. Even he could understand why so many men in Washington discussed her with such open admiration—and he was at least fifteen years younger than she.
“Come now, Lieutenant.” Her voice had a soft Virginia accent that somehow made her seem even more feminine. “We both know you were not looking at me.”
To his surprise, he felt a flush rising in his neck. He was not a man who blushed—but then, he was not a man who usually got caught unawares.
“If I had been looking at you, Ma’am,” he said, “I would have been more welcoming as you approached.”
She laughed, deep-throated and rich, a woman who no longer had need of feminine games. “You are as charming as they say, Lieutenant.”
“Who says?” he asked.
She shrugged and gestured with her free hand. “All of Washington. You’re one of the city’s most eligible bachelors, you know. Rumor has it that you’re going to whip old Fuss and Feathers’ troops into shape long before he realizes there’s a war going on.”
To hear Scott’s nickname come from a civilian startled him almost more than her disrespect had. “General Scott is aware of the war,” Garrison said quietly. “He simply believes we must prepare for it.”
“Admirable,” she said, “if we were going to fight a prolonged war.”
He wasn’t going to get into a political discussion with his hostess. He’d been raised in the country, but even in the hinterlands, he’d learned enough about decorum to know that politics and parties did not mix.
She took his champagne flute and set it on the flat top of the wooden railing. Then she led him off the verandah and down the stairs to the lawn. “What, Lieutenant? No opinion? Or would you rather seem loyal to your commander by keeping your silence?”
He smiled. She was good. “I’m merely a lieutenant, ma’am,” he said. “My opinions do not matter.”
“I suspect that as a lieutenant who is out in the field every day—”
“If you call the perimeter of the city a field, ma’am.”
“—your opinions are probably more accurate than those of General Scott. I hear he’s not as sharp as he used to be. Is that true?”
He was sharp enough to order me to this damn thing, Garrison thought, but did not say. “General Scott has a long history of military leadership in our country. That he is old and that the press has ridiculed his preparations does not mean that he has diminished capacity.”
Even though Garrison had seen evidence of it. The shaking hands, the sometimes befuddled look in Scott’s blue eyes. Occasionally the man forgot he had given an order, or forgot which day of the week it was. Other times he was so quick that Garrison felt he could never outthink the old man. It varied from day to day, and in degree and measure.
“You’re one of the few to deny it,” Mrs. Cunliffe said, her tone musing. “Of course, your carefully chosen words were not an exact denial, were they? More of a way of avoiding the question.”
That flush still warmed his neck. The woman was smarter than he expected, and not nearly as retiring as most women of his acquaintance. Of course, most women of his acquaintance were matrons who were concerned with their broods or girls who had just reached their majority and were interested in becoming an officer’s wife.
“Such a shy man,” Mrs. Cunliffe said. “Who would have thought such a big strong strapping fellow like you would be shy?”
He wasn’t shy, just focused. But he would let her take his actions any way she wanted. It was easier that way.
She led him across the yard directly toward the beauty he had been admiring moments ago.
“Shoo,” Mrs. Cunliffe said as they got close, waving her arm at the men who were surrounding the younger woman. “I have an introduction to make.”
To Garrison’s surprise, the men left, several with backwards glances at the beauty as if they had expected her to defend them. She said nothing, merely watched Mrs. Cunliffe with a polite and curious smile on her fox-like face.
“Serena,” Mrs. Cunliffe said, “I would like you to meet one of Washington’s most eligible bachelors. That we even have him here is a rare treat. Lieutenant Nathaniel Garrison, Serena Freneau.”
Miss Freneau offered her hand, small, delicate, and white, and he took it by the fingers, then bent over it, not quite kissing it. Her fingers were warm and smooth in his own.
“A pleasure, miss,” he said.
This time, her smile was all for him. “The pleasure’s mine.”
“I’ll leave you both,” Mrs. Cunliffe said. “And remember, Lieutenant. This is a party. No need to be so very serious.”
He looked after her, watching her black skirts sway as she walked away from him. A party, and he was too serious. Of course he was serious. There was a war going on, a war no one seemed to understand except him.
“Perhaps the city’s most eligible bachelor is interested in the city’s most famous widow.” Serena Freneau’s voice was soft and teasing, with a bit of a bite to it.
He looked back at her, unable to believe his lack of manners. He hadn’t let go of her fingers yet, and didn’t dare now. It would make him look even ruder than if he continued to hold them.
“I’m sorry,” he said. “It was just that was our first conversation. I had no idea she even knew who I was.”
Miss Freneau’s eyes were a shade of brown that matched her hair. They twinkled at him. “You’re at her party, aren’t you? Of course she knows who you are.”
That flush—why was he cursed with it on this night?—rose again. A trickle of sweat followed the drying path along his back, tickling as it traced his spine. “I meant—”
“I know what you meant.” Slowly she looked down at his hand, still holding hers. “Aunt Evangeline always surprises people with her knowledge. Perhaps it is because men think knowledge is unusual in females.”
He almost felt trapped by those fingers in his, the way that she wasn’t protesting what was becoming almost a faux paus. “I don’t find knowledge unusual in females,” he said. “I’m just surprised that as important a personage as Mrs. Cunliffe would know who I am.”
“A member of General Scott’s staff? The only one, it’s said, who knows that a short war is what the country needs? Of course she knows who you are.”
And apparently Miss Freneau did as well. “I didn’t realize that Mrs. Cunliffe was your aunt.”
Miss Freneau smiled at him. This one was soft and rather indulgent. How many different versions of a smile did this woman have?
“You don’t have time to keep track of social conventions.” Her fingers squeezed his in acknowledgement of their touch, and then she broke the contact. “It’s simply nice to know our fair city is being kept safe by men such as you.”
“Our fair city is under no immediate danger.”
“That’s not what they say.” Miss Freneau leaned toward him. “I’ve heard that the Rebels want nothing more than to destroy the Capitol. What sort of disgrace is that?”
“It’s war, miss,” he said, and wished he hadn’t. When had he gotten so prim around women?
“Are you saying we should take their capital as well?”
“As your aunt just reminded me,” he said gently, “this is a party. There’s no need to be so serious.”
Miss Freneau’s eyes widened and then she laughed—that same musical sound he had heard before. It was entrancing, almost seductive, and he felt a small thrill of pride that he had caused it.
“Of course,” she said, taking his arm just as her aunt had. “I’m the one being rude. I’m asking you to discuss work and this gathering is supposed to make you forget about work, relax, and enjoy yourself.”
He placed a hand over hers, noting the looks he got from the men who had been gathered around her before. He remembered how she hadn’t touched any of them, but she had touched him. Again, that small pride ran through him.
“Would you like some punch, Miss Freneau?”
“I thought you would never ask,” she said, leading him to the outdoor table covered with punch and various cakes.
Her skirts brushed his legs. She wore a light perfume, so unique that it took him a moment to realize it was lilac water mixed with her own scent.
When they reached the table, he slipped out of her grasp and took the cut-glass punch cup an elderly female servant offered him, then handed it to Miss Freneau. He took another glass for himself. He was going to ask if she wanted cakes, when she leaned forward.
“There will be dancing later, Lieutenant,” she said. “My aunt has given permission for at least two waltzes. We’re being informal—no dance cards—but I would hope you save one waltz for me.”
This time he smiled. The waltz was a brazen dance not often allowed at social functions, especially social functions of this caliber. “Have you ever waltzed before, Miss Freneau?”
“Only with my dance instructor,” she said, “and only because I forced him to teach me.”
Garrison could see that. The woman had a strength about her that could not be denied. “To dance it might compromise your reputation.”
Her eyes twinkled and this time, her smile was wide. “Reputation? Lieutenant, we’re at war. In six months time, who will care about reputations?”
“If we do this right,” he said, “you won’t even notice the war.”
She tossed her ringlets back and sighed. “And here I was hoping for a measure of freedom.”
“That seems to be,” he said, “what everyone is hoping for these days.”
JUNE 17, 1911GARRISON TURNED, the remembered scent of lilac water still in his nose. That waltz had been the highlight of his life until that point, Serena Freneau’s small body moving with his in a sweeping motion, her skirts flaring behind her, his hand pressed against the small of her back, her bright eyes holding his as if there were no one else in the room—indeed, no one else in the world.
It had been the beginning of something, although not quite the something he had thought.
The laugh again, musical, warm. He scanned the deck chairs, saw no one laughing. Most of the passengers there were reading or talking softly, enjoying the maiden voyage of a ship he couldn’t even have imagined fifty years before.
The world had changed, so much that at times he barely recognized it.
He scanned until he saw a grouping around one of the iron tables placed on the deck by the crew before dawn. An umbrella shaded the table itself. The women who sat there were not the young creatures he had thought, but elderly, most of them wearing tasteful black gowns. Not the black silk that Mrs. Cunliffe had worn fifty years before, with reams of material over hoops, but long skirts that covered sensible shoes, black lace around the neck, and in the case of one woman, a long strand of pearls that added a bit of brightness.
He was about to turn away when he heard the laugh a third time. It came from the woman wearing the pearls. She had silver hair rolled into a bun at the back of her head, rather like that of an aging Gibson Girl. Softly curling tendrils fell along the sides of her narrow face.
The chin wasn’t as sharp as it had been and the skin look papery, like some women’s skin got when they aged, but the brown eyes were still sharp, maybe more sharp now that they no longer matched her hair.
He leaned against the rail, feeling sea spray mist him like tears. His breath was in his throat again, his heart racing like a boy’s.
It wasn’t possible. It couldn’t be possible. She had died, drowned as she tried to escape a U.S. naval blockade runner. The rough seas had pulled her under when the lifeboat she’d stolen capsized.
He’d seen the obituary, visited her grave. Clenched his fist on top of the stone and pounded until his skin rubbed away, and his blood stained the rounded edge.
If that were her, if she really lived, it meant she had told yet another lie, and another lie might be more than he could bear.
MAY 20, 1864HEAT, ALREADY, even though it was barely noon. Flies, on his face, his arms. Too tired to brush them off. Thinner than he’d ever been. The dysentery was bad. Not as bad as some, dying in the middle of the camp, no one noticing until they’d become so covered with flies that they looked like a strange hive. And the stench…
A man never got used to the stench.
Garrison sat, arms around his legs. Uniform was all rags, which was good in this heat. It’d been cold when he was captured, over a year ago now. Over a year and he hadn’t changed clothes since. Hadn’t really bathed except early on, when he didn’t know that he shouldn’t use his drinking water for washing.
He sat near the edge of the log stockade. Other men around him, though he barely noticed. He was too weak to notice much. His brain simply hummed as he tried not to think, tried not to think about any of it, from the first awful days.
Ahead of him, the line drawn in the cracked red Georgia clay, harsh now, deeper than it had been last summer—the days of the miserable heat. He’d tried to bury the dead then, had some strength, but when he’d collapsed, no one had picked him up. No one had helped. He just kept thinking of the bodies and the disease. Less than 16 acres this camp was, and, some said, more than twenty thousand men here—living men. Who knew how many dead?
And who cared anymore?
Still, he stared at the line. The dead line, they called it. One foot across it and a guard would shoot him, not care if they only wounded, let him rot in the wretched Georgia sun. Sometimes men cried from out there, whimpered, moaned in pain, and no one dared go help them. No one dared try. Not if he still valued his life.
Garrison sometimes wondered why he did. It would all end so easily. One foot across, maybe two. The perimeter wasn’t as well guarded here. There weren’t enough guards for all these men. That’s why, he guessed, the lack of food, the horrible conditions. Keep the men weak and they couldn’t run. They wouldn’t even try.
But he stared at the line. The dead line. Like he did every day. So easy to end it all. And so hard.
One shot, or maybe, escape. But to what?
The thoughts were too much and he willed his mind back to hum. It wasn’t going there, rarely did when he contemplated the dead line. For there was nothing left for him. Nothing at all.
No way he could face her. Anyone. No way he could face anyone from his past at all.
A hand on his back, then a crust of bread thrust at him. He looked over, saw Major Tom Winthrop of the New York Zouaves, his gaudy uniform now tatters, the colors faded and no longer joyful.
Winthrop thrust the bread at him again, and this time Garrison took it. The crust was so dry it crumbled in his hands. He knew how it would feel in his mouth, impossible to swallow without water—and he wouldn’t get his ration until that night, if he was lucky enough to survive that long.
Lucky enough. The thought almost made him chuckle.
Still he took a bite, forced himself to chew, swallow, nearly choking on the scratchy stale crust going down. He uttered a weak cough, wiped his mouth with the back of his hand, and then checked it for blood.
None yet. But it was only a matter of time. Only a matter of time.
“New recruits today,” Winthrop said, using the term that had once been a joke and wasn’t any longer. More prisoners in the already overcrowded space. Raw and green and unable to know what horrors faced them, thinking at that point that they were better off than their fellows, at least they were alive. “There’s one you should see.”
It took Winthrop a while to make the whole sentence, but it took Garrison a while to follow it as well. They were well matched, like old men who had said everything they needed to long ago.
“Why?” Garrison asked.
“News. About that woman.”
Winthrop knew everything. Down to the ugliest detail, like a father confessor. There had been nothing else to do in here, but talk. Even then, Garrison hadn’t said much. Only to Winthrop whose unit had left him for dead, thinking he had betrayed them, when—in truth—he hadn’t. He knew who did, he had said, not that it mattered now. That man was free or dead or in some other camp. Winthrop was concerned with survival here.
“Don’t need news,” Garrison said.
“This you do.” Then Winthrop turned, slowly, like a man underwater, and waved his fingers at someone, beckoning him forward.
Garrison heard the footsteps, the intake of breath, saw a droplet of sweat hit the dry red clay. The man still had enough water in him to waste it in sweat. Some day, he would think that a luxury.
“My God in Heaven, are you all dying?”
Garrison looked up, saw a young man’s face, red whiskers sprouting in patches with the growth of a week, hair messy and covered with grime. New recruit, captured nearby. Not a long journey. Not a lot of suffering. Yet.
“Tell Lieutenant Garrison what you told me,” Winthrop said.
The boy waited for Winthrop to finish, impatiently, Garrison thought, obviously not used to the pace of life here. The conservation of life, the way energy had to be stored, held, a commodity as precious as water, twice as precious as bread.
“Lieutenant Garrison?” the boy asked. “Not Nathaniel Garrison?”
“Yes,” Winthrop said.
Garrison stared at the boy, the green eyes sliding back and forth, the beginnings of a panic that Garrison didn’t yet understand.
“I’m sorry, sir.” The boy bit his lower lip. “She said you were dead.”
“Who?” Garrison’s voice was little more than a whisper. The voice a man not yet dead. But close. Too damn close.
“Your wife.”
Garrison’s hand snaked out before he could stop it, all bone and sinew, and it caught the boy’s wrist, still fat with flesh. The boy looked down, startled, tried to wrench away and couldn’t.
“How do you know my wife?” Garrison asked.
“A party, last summer. She held a charity function for the widows and orphans campaign.” The boy’s voice was trembling. “Please, sir, you’re hurting me.”
“Did you sleep with her?”
“Sir, I—”
“Did you?”
The boy swallowed, his Adam’s Apple bobbing. Garrison envied him the saliva that made such a movement so simple, so involuntary.
“She said you were dead, sir.”
Garrison flung the boy away from him. How many lives this time, then? How many?
“And I suppose you told her everything you knew, figuring it wouldn’t hurt.”
The boy was rubbing his wrist. He studied Garrison for a moment, then an awful understanding filled his face, an understanding quickly denied. “Sir, I thought she was a loyal officer’s widow.”
“She was a loyal officer’s wife.” The words caught in Garrison’s throat like the crust had, and he coughed again, wiping, checking for blood, seeing none. Not yet. “But she was not loyal. Not loyal at all.”
APRIL 25, 1863IN HIS OWN BEDROOM, the window open, the spring air carrying the faint scents of cherry blossoms on the breeze, Garrison could almost see the future. His wife beside him, naked, her warm body pressed against his, both of them still sticky from love-making, the softness of the cotton ticking in the well-stuffed mattress lulling him toward sleep, it wasn’t hard to imagine years from now, the war over, how he would lie here, holding her, trying to make no noise so that the children wouldn’t hear.
Perhaps it was a fantasy. There were no children yet, neither of them wanting to bring a child into this horror, this world that was so far from the one he had known. Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation, only four months old, guaranteed that if the North won—when the North won—the world would be a different place from the one Garrison grew up in.
Serena had just been complaining about how difficult it was to keep help any more. She had grown up in Evangeline Cunliffe’s house where the servants had once been slaves who had stayed with the family after receiving their freedom—or so the Cunliffes had told Garrison. He doubted even that was true when, after the war began in earnest, the servants vanished one by one, like thieves in the night, stealing their freedom the way that their counterparts had for decades down South.
Serena sighed next to him and he wondered if she were drifting into sleep. They had promised to stay awake together—he only had twenty-four hours until he had to return to hell—but they had not always managed to keep that promise before.
“Where will you be?” she asked him, her voice sleepy. He felt her breath on his chest, and the softness of her hair beneath his hand.
“I don’t know for sure,” he said, hating to lie to her. The lie spoiled the beauty of the night. The war came back now in all its bloody terror, the stench of mud, the cold, the smell of gunpowder and smoke filling the air.
She raised up on one elbow and looked down at him. Her beauty was greater without the clothes, the way her neck rose out of her shoulders and collarbone, the way her torso tapered into a waist so small he could wrap his hand around it.
“I swear I don’t know why General Hooker trusts you as his attaché,” she said, that faint teasing look on her face, the one that had entranced him two years before. “Best hope you never have to lie for him, Nathaniel Garrison.”
“You know I’m not supposed to tell you,” he said, drawing her down.
But she put her other arm on his chest, keeping her face above his. His eyes had adjusted to the dark. He could almost see her expression, could imagine it even though it wasn’t completely clear.
“Who am I gonna tell?” she asked. “Evangeline? She disappeared a month ago. The other wives? They’re fearing a summer siege on Washington and have gone farther north. There’s no one, Nate, no one I’d trust to tell, not and risk your life.”
He pulled her down, kissed her, wished he could stay even one more night. “You don’t need to know.”
“Sure I do. If you die, how’ll I know? Silence for months and then a casualty list? At least—”
“You can watch the battle, see the number of dead, and worry that I’m in it?”
She pushed herself up again. “I do that anyway, only now I do that with all of them. Maybe if there was only one—”
“We’re trying for Richmond again,” he said. She could always get him to tell her, and she said it eased her mind. And knowing that she knew eased his. “And this time, I think we’ll take it.”
“You have a plan.”
“I don’t,” he said. “General Hooker does.”
“Is he as good as they say?”
“Better.” Garrison liked working with Hooker. So different from the other generals who had led the Army of the Potomac. The men were fed properly and had decent camps. Hooker had worked with the Calvary until Garrison believed they could take on Jeb Stuart, and he knew how to use the abundance of men. “He’s given us our confidence back.”
“Good.” She lay her head on him, her hair falling across his face. “Where will you be?”
“Chancellorsville, most likely,” he said, “although there’s a chance I might be in Fredericksburg.”
“You don’t know?”
“It’s part of the same maneuver,” he said. “It just depends on where Hooker puts me. He usually likes me to be in the thick of the action, so that means Chancellorsville.”
“You’re splitting the Army?”
“And hoping Lee heads the wrong way.”
She let out a small sigh, and said nothing for the longest time. He stroked her hair, memorizing it, knowing he would keep this memory with him through the worst of the battle—the waiting.
“Why can’t you stay here? You delivered your dispatch to the President. They don’t need you.”
But they did. There were men who relied on him. They listened to him, much to his surprise.
“If I did that, love,” he said, “I’d be hunted for a deserter.”
“We could live in Michigan, or maybe Canada. Far from all this. Maybe go West. No one would care.”
“Except me.”
She was silent for a moment, then she said, “It’s like a game to you all, isn’t it? Diverting Lee, trying to cross into Richmond, getting the capital, like the king in a game of chess.”
He hadn’t expected the outburst, although he should have. She had done it before. “Chess doesn’t cost lives,” he said.
He hadn’t meant to. He tried to keep most of the reality of the war from her.
He put his arm around her and pulled her back close. “Let’s not fight. I have to leave in the morning.”
She held the rigid posture for another moment, then collapsed against him. And he held her like he always did, as if it were going to be the last time.
MAY 6, 1863HE WASN’T EVEN SURE where he was. Somewhere in Virginia, but nowhere he recognized. His head ached. He had a lump on his forehead the size of a walnut, according to the man he was chained to. They were tied together like plowhorses, expected to eat and move and shit together like animals. He didn’t exactly know how he’d been captured, only that it had happened.
His last memories were of his rifle, hot in his hands, the bayonet bloody from the man he’d just stabbed, the morning sun rising, sending light and heat on the battlefield somewhere outside Chancellorsville.
Lee hadn’t retreated like Hooker thought he would. Faced with an army of superior size, Lee had charged forward, with strength and courage and fury. Hooker had expected Lee to turn tail and for some reason, Garrison had thought that would happen too, even though now, three days after the worst of it, three days after he’d been captured, he had no idea why. Lee was no coward, although some were saying Hooker was. Inept, cowardly, stupid. His plan had backfired. Somehow Lee had seen through the ruse at Fredericksburg, dodged the trap laid over the Rappahanock, and had come to Chancellorsville ready to fight.
And fight he had.
Garrison had lost his horse in the middle of it, the beast screaming and falling beneath him, throwing him clear. He hadn’t had time to see if the horse was dead—the momentum of the battle had carried him forward and he’d stabbed and shot and fought hand to hand with more men than he could remember, most of them younger than he was, most of them bloody and thin and filled with a fighting frenzy that seemed almost crazy.
He’d been fighting with his own frenzy, thinking how angry Serena would be if he died, how she would check the casualty lists and see his name, and that had driven him forward, over bodies, dead men, dead horses, and blood slicker than water on the ground. Forward until he heard—felt—a crack so loud that it shook the entire world, and then he had wakened, a day later, chained to other men, men who said they were sure he was going to die or never wake up because of the lump on his head.
They fed him, shared water with him, happy that he was awake and they wouldn’t have to drag his dead weight to whereever it was their guards were taking them.
Right now they sat in the woods, near the thin underbrush and the copse of trees, and waited, as they had done before. Their guards were scouting the path ahead, leaving a handful behind to watch the prisoners.
Garrison thought this might be an opportunity, but he wasn’t sure what kind of opportunity it was, a wise one, a foolish one. He was chained by the legs and arms to men he didn’t know, and he saw no way of escaping without dragging them all with him. That wouldn’t work for even the first mile, and even in his most hopeful state, he knew it.
One of the guards, a man nearer to forty than thirty, had been watching Garrison for the last day, a smirk on his face every time he caught Garrison’s eye. He was one of the ones left behind, and when he saw Garrison staring at him, he smiled.
“I can get you special favors if you like,” the guard said, strolling toward him as if they were at a lawn party instead of in the woods.
Garrison frowned, felt the tug against the bump on his forehead. “Me?”
“You’re Nathaniel Garrison, ain’t you?” The guard smiled, revealing a gold tooth. He had bars on his gray uniform, gold bars, and tassels too. He was someone, then.
“What’s it to you?”
“Ain’t had a chance to thank you.”
The men stirred around him. The ones chained to him moved away as if he were tainted. “For what?”
“Our greatest victory. Heard you made it possible, letting General Lee know he was facing a trap.”
“Wha—?” the man next to him started, but Garrison raised his right hand, stopping him.
“I haven’t spoken to Lee.”
“I know that.” The guard’s smile grew. “You didn’t speak to anyone except your wife. She says you was one of the toughest. Most men, they take a bit of tail now and then, but you was all proper, almost like a Southern gentleman, insisting on courtship and love and marriage. And she was willing, seeing what a prize a man like you was. Right hand man in the Army of Potomac not to one but to all of its generals. They liked you, didn’t they, Lieutenant?”
He rose, felt the chains hold him, but he stumbled forward anyway, and fell.
“Didn’t know that about your wife, now did you? Little Serena Freneau, one of the P. G. T. Beauregard’s special ladies, doing the work of Rose Greenhow, but doing it better. So much better, landing a prize like you. Do you think she done it so that she could be with Beau after the war? Or do you think it was the glory all along, like she said? The glory and the cause of it—”
Garrison lurched forward, dragging the others with him, reaching for the guard’s boots, but the guard stepped out of the way and laughed.
“Don’t like the way the lady took you by your testicles and—”
“That’s my wife you’re lying about.”
“Lying?” The guard crouched, just outside of arm’s reach. “Lying? Her aunt run to Richmond before they could put her in the Old Capital Prison, didn’t you hear? Mrs. Cunliffe’s in London now, making sure the English know we need them at our side.”
“Don’t listen,” one of the other prisoners said. “He’s just trying to make you do something stupid so that he can shoot you.”
But the guard was watching Garrison like he was enjoying the reaction. He didn’t look like a man bent on shooting anyone.
“You couldn’t know this,” Garrison said.
“I’m on Beau’s staff,” the man said. “I got the report direct from your wife’s contact, like I got the others. Then they told me you was here, and I was to come take care of you. Make you an offer, Lieutenant Garrison. You can join our side and stay with your wife, or you can become a prisoner of war like the rest. We could use someone like you, with the knowledge of the Yank force from the inside out.”
Garrison stared at him, at the gold tooth that caught the sunlight, dazzling the rest of the man’s mouth and making his tobacco-stained teeth seem even dingier by comparison.
“Think on it, Lieutenant. These men here know your traitorous bent. They’ll make sure you pay when you get to whatever camp they’re sending you to. You can die there or you can come to Richmond, see your wife, spend the rest of your life in relative luxury.”
“By becoming an agent for the Confederacy.”
The guard nodded. “Now you’re thinking.”
And he was thinking of it, for just a brief moment. An agent for the Confederacy, getting information and somehow sending it back to Washington. But he needed a network for that, and if the United States government knew about Serena, they would never trust his information.
Serena. Her face rose in his mind, the fox-like intensity, the way Evangeline Cunliffe introduced them, the way Serena had smiled at him when she hadn’t given time to any of the other men. A set-up, even then?
All this time, the warm words, the loving, all a diversion to get information?
Where will you be? She would ask, her voice sleepy, and he would tell her, things he had sworn to tell no one, thinking her an extension of himself, his wife, loyal to him and to all he was loyal to, believing as he did. Living as he did.
His wife.
“No,” he said. “I’ll never help your cause.”
Only the words came out thick and angry, and he wasn’t sure if he was talking about the Confederacy or Serena—her cause, not his, taken at the price of his trust.
Why was he believing a greasy guard with a single gold tooth over the gestures of his wife, the woman he’d pledged to before God?
Because the man knew too much, too many things, and it put all the questions in perspective.
Where will you be?
“Surely, Lieutenant, your life is worth more than that,” the guard said.
And Garrison stared at him, out of reach, the anger cold in his stomach. A killing anger that would have rampaged through this small section of woods if he were only free.
Here I was hoping for a measure of freedom, she had said on that first evening.
And he had replied, so blithely, almost flirting, That seems to be what everyone is hoping for these days.
“Lieutenant? Are you reconsidering?” the guard asked.
“I gave you my answer,” Garrison said.
The guard frowned. “She thought you would do it for her.”
Garrison looked up, that last more appalling than anything that had come before. Appalling perhaps because it held some truth. If he hadn’t known of the betrayal, he might have joined her in Richmond, might have found a way to continue his marriage without sacrificing too much of his soul.
The thought rocked him to his very essence.
“It seems,” he said slowly, “that my wife doesn’t know me as well as she thought she did.”
It was an affliction they both had suffered from although it looked, from his new vantage, as if he would suffer more for it.
If he lived.
MAY 20, 1864“I’M SORRY, SIR,” the boy was saying. “I didn’t know.”
Of course not. Garrison hadn’t known either. She had been so good at playing parts, not thinking of the consequences.
At least his discussion with the guard so long ago had done one thing. It had saved him from the wrath of the other prisoners. They had seen his face; they had known his betrayal of his own troops had been involuntary.
But he learned in the year that had gone on, through rumor and discussion and the general torment of the guards who had learned who he was, the cost of his midnight confession. Seventeen thousand lives lost, and just on his side. Seventeen thousand in a battle they should have won.
How many other lives, from Shiloh to Fredericksburg, could be laid directly on his love for his wife? How many?
He would never know.
“I didn’t bring him here to have him tell you that.” Winthrop had his hand on Garrison’s arm. He could feel the bones of Winthrop’s fingers, the unnatural scaliness of his skin. Winthrop was dying. They were all dying, slowly, and of more diseases than Garrison had thought imaginable. Disease exacerbated by starvation, heat, and the god-awful stench.
Garrison looked away. “He’s not the first to tell me he’s had her.”
It explained why she was so practiced, when he had been so inexperienced that he thought her skill normal for a woman of eighteen years. It explained so much.
All those nights he had thought of it, of her, going over the words they exchanged, the secrets, the way she had wheedled things out of him, even while he was discussing with first Scott, then Burnside, then Hooker, how to stop the flow of intelligence from the North to the South, how to deal with the disloyal women like Rose O’Neal Greenhow, a society woman just like Evangeline Cunliffe, who had created such a stir by being imprisoned early in the war.
“Why then?” he asked the boy. “Why are you here?”
The boy looked at the log stockade, the men sitting outside it, the dead line. He apparently thought Garrison wanted to know why he had come to Andersonville.
Garrison clarified. “What do you know about my wife?”
The boy winced at the word, but answered. He had more courage than Garrison wanted to acknowledge—or wanted to see. In a place like this, courage could get a man killed.
“Only that she’s dead, sir.”
That caught him. He saw, for a brief moment, her vivid brown eyes, remembered how, when he had looked in them on his wedding night, he knew she would outlive him. Nothing, he had thought then, could extinguish a flame like hers.
“How?”
“Drowned, sir. Trying to get back into the Confederacy. She’d been in England, and their ship was being pursued near the Carolina shoreline.”
“How do you know this?”
The boy looked down, his red whiskers standing out like bristles against the pasty skin. “I saw her, sir.”
Garrison frowned, trying to make sense of this. “You’re Navy?” They usually didn’t house Navy here.
The boy shook his head. “I was called to identify her.” He studied his hands. “It was known that I…”
Garrison studied his own hands. It would take little for them to wrap around the boy’s throat, and throttle him. It would actually be merciful, more merciful than living here, or slowly dying here as they all were.
Instead, he clenched his fists, placed them at his side in the baked clay, and asked, “Did the ship go down?”
“There was a storm, sir. She took a lifeboat, afraid their ship would run aground. If they caught her on it, apparently, she was to be hanged.”
Winthrop looked at Garrison. Garrison said nothing. Someone had found her out then, long before the boy. And the boy, then, had been under suspicion, to see if he sent secrets to the enemy. Perhaps he had. Perhaps he was here because he had betrayed the wrong person.
Garrison didn’t care.
He got up, staggered away from the dead line, trying to avoid the men sprawled like corpses in the dirt.
She was dead, then. The light in those eyes gone forever. That dry humor, the softness of her pressed against him in the night. Gone. He wouldn’t have to face her, wouldn’t have to face that moment which he had been certain would come, the one in which he would have to choose between his loyalty for his country and that passion, whatever it was, he had felt for her.
It had been so easy in the woods. He had just found out. She hadn’t been before him. He could still feel the hurt like an open wound.
But what if she had told him? What if she had leaned against him in the night, after their loving, and told him, then said, as she had that last night, We could live in Michigan, or maybe Canada. Far from all this. Maybe go West. No one would care.
Except him, he had said.
Except him.
JUNE 17, 1911HE HAD A CHOICE, he knew. He could walk away, chalk it up to coincidence, his illness, the dazed feeling men sometimes got while at sea.
But he remembered her eyes, their vividness, the way they had held him when she said her vows, his certainty that she had more life force than he.
Nothing, not time, not infirmity, not wishful thinking, could keep him away from that table.
He put his walking stick down forcefully, tried not to lean on it too hard, and made his way toward her.
The conversation stopped as he approached, the women staring up at him as if he were a curiosity. He could only see her. Eyes usually faded, got watery, lost their color and intensity with age and time, but hers had not. They still had a fire in them, a life force so intense he could feel it.
“Good afternoon, ladies,” he said, bowing as he had the first time he had seen her. He smiled as he stood, knowing he still had some of the old charm. “Forgive my interruption, but I would like to speak with Serena alone.”
She could have denied it, he supposed, and would have tried if she had been alone. But the other women turned toward her, looking surprised, as if they should have known all of her friends.
Her skin seemed paler than it had a moment ago, and up close, he could see the fine wrinkles, like flaws in parchment. “It’s all right,” she said. There was still a trace of Maryland in her voice. Like home, he used to think. Like home.
The women got up, gave him another glance, and then walked away. The stoutest of them, an imposing matron with the kind of power women of a certain age gained, patted a gloved hand on hers.
“If you need us, my dear, we’ll be on the deck chairs.” Then the woman looked at him as if warning him of all sorts of dire problems should he assault their friend.
He slipped into the chair the woman had just vacated, and after a moment, she left them alone. He hung his walking stick on the arm, using the movement to think about what he would say, what he would do.
He wondered if he could get the captain to place her under house arrest, if the United States government would pursue a 48 year-old case. War crimes, perhaps, treason of the highest order. Could he actually prove she had caused all those deaths, done all those things? Most of the witnesses were dead now, but he was still alive. He and a handful of others.
She was looking at him as if she couldn’t quite place him. He hoped it wasn’t an act. He had thought of her daily for the last fifty years. The first two with love so fierce he thought he would die from it, and the last with a hopelessness that seared him to his very soul.
He had never loved like that again, never trusted anyone again. He had held several women, almost brought two to wife, but could not bear the thought of letting them in his home, in his bed for an entire night. In the end, he had channeled his energies into his businesses, except for the time he made for his nieces and nephews, treating them as if they were his own. She had taken so much from him, more than the war ever could.
“You wished to speak to me?” she said, so impersonal, so formal, as if they had just met.
“Serena Freneau Garrison,” he said softly, “I saw your name on a grave in Washington, D.C.”
She stared at him for a long time, her eyes running over his face as if she were searching her memory, looking at portraits. Then tears came to her eyes. “Nathaniel.”
She said his name as she had when he loved her, half a whisper, filled with promises. His heart lurched again.
“They told me you died at Chancellorsville.”
“They told me you betrayed us two days before.”
Her eyes widened.
“I know it all,” he said. “The way you pulled information from me. The way you sent it all to Beauregard, who then used it to slaughter our men. Tell me, Serena, who died for you that day in 1864? A servant? A life you considered less valuable than your own?”
“It was all a mistake,” she said. “And the rumors were so terrible, I decided to let Serena Garrison go. I thought it better—”
He put a finger over her lips and she closed her eyes, the movement of a lover. She tilted her head into his touch ever so slightly, and he remembered how she let him hold her fingers so improperly that day on Mrs. Cunliffe’s lawn fifty years before.
“No more lies, Serena,” he said, and let his finger drop.
She opened her eyes. The tears were still in them. “It was a long time ago,” she said. “I was young and stupid—“
“Serena. No lies. I spent two years in Andersonville before I got exchanged out. You owe me the truth.”
She let out a small breath of air, glanced at the deck chairs where her friends sat. “I asked you to go away with me. I fell in love with you, Nathaniel. I mourned when they told me you were dead.”
“By your hand.”
She raised her chin slightly. So familiar. The gestures, the movements. He had remembered them perfectly. “We were at war.”
“You and I? Funny, I thought we were in love.”
A tear fell, glistening like a diamond as it hovered, caught on her cheek. He saw her more clearly now, how she had acted for him as if she were playing a part on the stage. But the young man inside him, the man who had hoped and believed her to be a part of him, he still wanted to believe her.
And the rest of him wanted to carry her to the rail and toss her over, let her drown for real.
This time, he was the one who glanced at her friends. The stout woman was glaring at him, her eyes accusing.
Serena followed his gaze.
“They’re making me uncomfortable,” he said. “Walk with me.”
She rose quicker than he did. He grabbed his walking stick, used it to lever himself up, then switched it to the other hand so that he could offer her his arm. She took it, her hand light and delicate against his coat. He felt absurdly like asking her if she wanted punch or perhaps to waltz.
They walked to the railing. He led her behind one of the lifeboats, roped in and covered at the edge of the deck. He had stopped shaking. He felt stronger than he had in weeks.
This would be his only chance, here, out of the sight of those women. He would still have to lift her, but only a little. And then a toss that might wrench his back and she would be falling, a scream floating up at him before she hit the froth below.
She was studying him, those dark fox-like eyes, probably seeing all the emotions on his face.
“There are people who will miss me,” she said. “Are you still such a terrible liar, Nathaniel?”
“No,” he said.
A small shudder went through her then. She hadn’t expected that, although she had seen on his face what he meant to do. He would be able to toss her over and lie about what he had done. Another of her legacies.
Garrison looked over the railing at the gray Atlantic. The vast ocean of nothingness, the place that was supposed to have claimed her, when in fact it hadn’t.
“I’m sorry, Nathaniel—” she started, but he didn’t let her finish.
He dropped his walking stick, grabbed her waist—not as small as it had once been—and hoisted her up. She didn’t scream, but she grabbed the railing and hung on, her body tense.
It wouldn’t be easy. Nothing with her was ever easy.
“My husband is a rich man,” she said. “We can pay you, Nathaniel. You could be rich.”
His hands tightened on her waist. “Who’s your husband?” he asked softly, as if he were intrigued by the notion of another man’s money.
“Lord Reginald Seton. Please, Nathaniel. Let me down.”
He let go so quickly that she nearly fell overboard anyway. Her body collapsed against the rail, her heels kicking against the side. She eased herself down and for a brief moment, he saw fear in her eyes.
“Does he know of your past life?” Garrison asked.
She raised that sharp chin. “I met him in London. During the war.”
One of the collaborators. One of the men who had hoped to fund the South.
“And how long have you been married?” Garrison asked.
She stepped away from him, the movement small but noticeable. “I thought you were dead.”
Forty-seven years. They had married while Garrison was starving in a camp she had sent him to. The camp she had condemned him to.
She had spent forty-seven years in London society under a different name, and no one had been the wiser. Forty-seven years in a marriage that had obviously worked, with a man who had a reputation to protect. A man, by the very nature of the peerage to which he belonged, could suffer no hint of impropriety.
“Where is he now?” Garrison asked.
“The smoking room, I believe,” she said.
“This early in the day?”
“He enjoys cards,” she said. And cards offended many of the women. The smoking room had become a replacement for some of the men’s clubs.
“Let’s go there.”
“I can’t.”
“But I can.” He took her arm, dragged her forward, then slipped her hand in his elbow again. “Walk normally,” he said softly, “and smile.”
She did. They were halfway across the deck when he realized he’d left his walking stick behind. He was functioning on something purer than energy now, something deeper. He would go through with this if it killed him.
Fortunately, they weren’t far from the smoking room. He pushed open the doors and saw, as he had hoped, the reporters that the White Star Line had hired to glorify the Olympic’s first trip.
“Gentlemen,” he said, as he dragged Serena forward. “Come with me.”
They did, of course. No one said no to Nathaniel Garrison. How ironic that he needed them, them and their scandal sheets, to get the only revenge possible now.
He would destroy her place in society. Once he revealed her identity, everyone would know who she was, who she had been. His story was familiar enough.
It was time to make that story hers as well.
He would ruin her life as she had once ruined his.
Garrison walked across the checked carpet, past rows of empty tables flanked by green leather chairs, to the center of the room.
There Lord Seton was already standing, his cards turned down in his large arthritic hands. He was a big man who did not stoop with age, with a large white mustache that seemed to have stolen all the hair from his head. His eyes were faded, so faded it took Garrison a moment to see the color.
“Serena,” Seton said. “What is the meaning of this?”
Garrison glanced at his side, made certain the reporters were there, saw Serena, her eyes wide, the fear evident now.
“Lord Seton,” Garrison said, letting Serena’s hand drop and placing his own on the small of her back. “My name is Nathaniel Garrison. I’ve been so looking forward to meeting you. Please allow me to introduce you to my wife.”
He paused for half a moment and saw the horror plain on Seton’s face. The reporters had gasped. Serena looked as if she were about to faint.
Garrison stared at her one last time, saw how years of good living had softened her, and knew the publicity, the scandal, the trial would be her Andersonville.
He nodded to her once, an acknowledgement that finally the table had turned. There was nowhere for her to go, no escape possible. She couldn’t even handle the lifeboats by herself.
Then he turned and left her there, surrounded by reporters, and a scandalized man who had only thought he was her husband for forty-seven years. Garrison, her real husband, left her to face her future alone—her bleak future—as she had once left him.
Fifty years to the day it began, the war was finally over.
____________________________________________
The Dead Line
Copyright © 2013 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in The Blue and the Gray Undercover, edited by Ed Gorman, Forge Books, November 2001Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2013 by WMG PublishingCover design by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Christophe Boisson/Dreamstime
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
Homer Ziff wanted to know how his outdoor cats spent their days, so he attached a tiny digital camera to their collars—and discovered a mystery in his own backyard.
Winner of the Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine Readers Choice Award for 2008, this Anthony-nominated story was one of the most talked about stories of the year.
“Hitchhiking Across an Ancient Sea” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
The Secret Lives of CatsKristine Kathryn RuschHomer Ziff didn’t believe in old adages, but after his long and eventful spring, he couldn’t help but think that whoever put the words “curiosity,” “cat,” and “kill” in the same sentence had to be onto something.
It all began about his own curiosity—about his cats. Homer Ziff lived alone with two indoor cats and six outdoor cats. Well, six he could pet and hold; there were others—the friends, neighbors and hangers-on, he called them—who visited at meal time or for a rest on the back forty in the mid-afternoon sun.
Not that he had a real back forty. But his back yard was an impressive three acres, complete with woods and stream. One of the reasons he bought the house was that it had the best of both worlds: in the front, he had a small lawn that led to a quiet residential street; in the back, he had the acres of property that covered a protected wetland. No one would ever build behind him, the lots next to him were full, and the houses across the street had reached their maximum size according to code.
He knew his neighbors by sight (rather like he knew their cats) and he would nod at them whenever he saw them, but didn’t engage in conversation. He couldn’t bring himself to talk to them, not after his first attempt, when he’d stuttered at a man several doors down, and the man had rolled his eyes and walked away.
Homer would liked to have blamed his surly neighbor for his own lack of congeniality, but that wouldn’t be fair or accurate. Homer didn’t engage most people in conversation. He had a stutter that got worse when he was nervous.
Over the years, he’d learned to prefer his own company. He liked being alone with his thoughts and his cats and his property.
And it was his thoughts that made being alone possible. Not that his thoughts were original—sadly, they weren’t—but they were organized, and that had given him an edge. Once upon a time, he had been a professor of physics at Oregon State University. A rising star when he was hired, he’d become a stalled star by mid-career—a man for whom the great things expected never materialized.
Which would have been well and good except that stalled stars had to be stellar teachers and he was not. He was pathologically shy, and his stutter got worse in front of large groups. He was better one on one, but stalled stars weren’t allowed to teach the smaller classes. He had to teach some large sections as well, and he dreaded them like he dreaded a visit to the dentist.
But he did have one valuable skill. He could explain things clearly. His gift of clarity had gotten him through graduate school and into an important teaching position, but that gift also stalled him. And it made him into something of a rebel.
Because of his gift, he threw out the suggested text for 101 Physics (a more confusing book he’d never seen) and wrote a series of notes that sold in the campus bookstore—not just to his students, but to students from other physics classes. The bookstore owner called him one day to ask whether students at the nearby University of Oregon could purchase the notes. Then students from some of the private colleges made the drive from McMinnville and Portland to get his notes, and finally, the chairman of his department said, “Y’know, Ziff, you could make a fortune on those notes if you just turned them into a book.”
So he did. It became the number one 101 physics text in the country, which led his publisher to ask if he would write a simple physics book for the masses, which he did, and another for children, which he did, and suddenly Homer Ziff no longer needed to worry about being a stalled star. He had become a rising star again—or maybe even an established one—and could have his pick of the courseload within his department.
Only the books had given him another gift. Financial independence. He no longer had to teach. And since standing in front of students made him so nervous that he sometimes spent the hour before class in the restroom, he decided that the prudent move would be to quit.
He bought his marvelous house, made sure his finances were in order, and then retired to write a half dozen more popular science books, with more under contract.
Some days, the cats were his only companions. He didn’t mind, really. He never stuttered when he spoke to cats, and they didn’t care that he lacked original thought.
They were happy that he provided food and shelter and a bit of companionship.
He was happy to have them purr.
Because of them, he had become a little cat-obsessed.
He had been surfing the net one night when he discovered a website designed by a man in Germany. The man sounded like a kindred spirit. He lived with a cat to whom he devoted an inordinate amount of time. That cat was an indoor-outdoor cat, and the German man wondered how his cat spent his time outside the house.
So the man, who appeared to be some kind of engineer, modified a digital camera, put it around his cat’s neck, set it up to take pictures every minute and a half, and sent the cat on its way. The resulting photographs were charming and inspiring.
Homer found himself staring at his outdoor friends, wondering how their days went. One cat’s routine illuminated the life of one cat. Six cats’ routines might actually be the beginning of some kind of scientific study.
At least, that was what he told himself as he used the instructions on the German man’s website to build six catcams. After some struggle, Homer managed to attach them to five of his outdoor favorites (he gave up on the wily old tom—who not only drew blood, but managed to slice him up badly enough to require fifteen stitches on his left hand).
Then he sent the five on their mission, hoping to discover the secret lives of cats.
And he did. He discovered all sorts of marvelous things.
He saw the same feline faces in his yard, in his neighbor’s yard, at the century-old schoolhouse down the street. He realized that each cat had not only its own routine, but shared a neighborhood routine as well.
Mornings began at his house, with a treat of kibble and soft food, followed by a trek to the dumpster behind the local Burger King, then to a long rest under the bleachers at the old school.
The ground beneath his neighbors’ cars and his own Ford pick-up served as sites for daily conferences. A house three blocks away provided an afternoon snack, usually followed by a dumpster diving at a local fish market and the nearby Diary Queen.
On warm days, the cats tromped down to the wetlands for drinks from the springs that prevented anyone from building behind Homer’s property.
He would have blessed those springs, if he hadn’t seen something curious.
On the earliest photos the springs looked like a primeval swampland. Cats, due to their low-to-the-ground perspective, took the most amazing photographs. Apparently the wetlands at dawn (or was it dusk?) had ground fog, which made everything opaque and surreal.
The swamp (he didn’t know what else to call it) had tree limbs and branches and sticks rising from the muck, all hidden by the ghost-like grayness of the fog. To his surprise, the cats didn’t drink from the water here. They sat in front of it—all five of them—as if they were watching something.
Subsequent photos on different days showed something that resembled an elephant’s graveyard. What he’d initially thought were tree branches were bones sticking out of the mud. Some of the bones were covered in moss. Others had ivy growing around them like large green cobwebs.
The ivy gave him some perspective, but not enough. He couldn’t tell what kind of bones these were. Cats are small creatures and the cameras took photographs from that small perspective. Bones which seemed huge in some photographs seemed tiny in others.
Those others, he soon realized, were taken from some kind of height. Either that particular feline photographer had climbed a tree or it sat on a bank or it watched from a stump.
Homer found it curious that the cats never got close to the elephant’s graveyard. They always sat back. But as the weeks went on and the photographs accumulated, Homer realized that the graveyard was a spring haunt, just like the school had been in the winter.
The cats weren’t interested in food; they were observing something.
And that intrigued him.
Because cats, like humans, had a scientific turn of mind.
He had noticed that scientific frame of mind from the day he brought home his first kitten. Cats not only studied things, but they made a study of things. One of his cats decided to probe the mysteries of ice cubes—how they turned into water, whether they could be carried, why they sometimes shattered. Another spent an entire week learning how the front door knob turned. Eventually that cat learned how to turn the knob herself; fortunately she never did figure out the necessity of pulling the door open.
Or maybe opening the door didn’t interest her. The front door was the only one with a cut glass door knob. It refracted light. Maybe the cat had been more interested in the prisms inside the knob than in using that knob to go outside.
Homer never mentioned these thoughts to anyone else. He often felt as if he put too much time into his cats. And then he discovered that German man’s website, and realized he was not alone in his obsession with cat thought.
But, Homer would have wagered, the German man did not have an entire second computer devoted to the photographs that the cats created. Nor, Homer suspected, did the German man spend as much time trying to figure out what his cats were thinking as they stared—not just at the elephant graveyard, but also from underneath cars or beside Dumpsters.
The cats seemed involved in a part of life that Homer had somehow missed.
As the spring went on, he realized the cats were studying the elephant graveyard the same way that his indoor cat had studied that doorknob. They just hadn’t gotten to the touching stage yet.
He would know when they did. Daily, he got a series of photos of the back of pink tongues, lapping water from a puddle or a stream or a bowl that someone had placed outside. He would get photographs of near-dead prey wriggling out of a mouth.
But he saw nothing like that near the bones.
Only cats, watching the swampy water as if it held the secret of the universe.
Then, one Sunday afternoon, everything changed.
A little white female he called Mata Hari because of her attractiveness to the males (even after she was fixed) and her tendency to wander off on dangerous and secretive missions of her own brought home a defining photograph.
Every day, she sat in the same spot near the swamp. The little camera around her neck took a variation of the same photograph—a bone fragment sticking out of the primordial ooze. Sometimes the fragment was brown with mud and sometimes it looked almost white. But, over time, he realized it was the same fragment, which meant she sat in the same spot daily, studying something that she felt was important.
Only that Sunday, the fragment was covered by a human hand.
The hand loomed in the photograph, the fingers dominating the scene. They rose upward toward the sky, the ridges of the knuckles visible against the blackness of the muck. Dried cuts marred the flesh along the back, and the fingernails—clipped short—had dirt embedded all the way down to the skin.
Mata Hari had brought home ten pictures of the hand, which meant she spent fifteen minutes contemplating it, twice as long as she usually spent at that spot. The cat had managed to get several different angles, and oddly, each was farther away than the previous one.
The hand put the other bones in perspective. He returned to his photo files, opened the relevant pictures next to the photo of the hand and compared.
His breath caught. What had seemed like animal bones—small and fragile, old, abandoned, like elephants in their graveyard—were not. They were too large. He had been more accurate with the foggy photos when he’d thought of the bones as branches and logs.
These bones were large. No domesticated animal, except maybe a Husky or a Rotweiller, would have bones like that. Nor would most of the wild animals around here. This area was too populated for bears, even with the wetlands below. Maybe a deer or two had died down there, but certainly not a bunch of them. The coyotes were the size of raccoons, and barely larger than the cats, and there were no wolves here.
Which left only one other creature that could have provided the bones.
Humans.
And the latest victim had just arrived.
He needed to know if any of the other cats had photographs of the hand.
He got up and peered out his window. Two of the other cats had returned. He stepped outside and removed the memory card from both cameras, careful to put in a new card before he shut the cameras off. He’d tried night photos before, but the flash had scared the cat so badly that it had run in circles, screaming.
He hadn’t known cats could scream.
He gave each cat some pets and a small treat, then went back inside and downloaded the photographs.
In every bunch, a handful were duds—blurs, unrecognizable objects, a paw in front of the lens. These two batches were no different. But he set aside the blurs and unrecognizable objects this time, deciding they might be useful.
Then he scanned the images until he got to the swamp.
These cats had come to the graveyard as well, and at about the same time as Mata Hari. In fact, one of the unrecognizable objects might have been her haunch as the other cat sniffed her in greeting.
These cats stayed even farther away. He got found photographs of an entire arm, covered in bruises, and a bit of shoulder. His hands were shaking as he magnified the images.
The arm and hand had clearly come from the same place. He could see the bone fragment, the moss-covered bones, the ivy-covered bones and the brackish water. Now he knew why the cats didn’t drink here.
He wasn’t even sure why they came—they were well fed, so they didn’t need to eat decaying flesh. Were they watching something decompose? Or were they hunting the rats or some other creature that frequented the wetlands?
For the first time since he started this experiment, he felt frustrated that he couldn’t ask.
And then he found the money shot.
Or what would have been a money shot had he been a photographer along the lines of Weegee—the man who photographed corpses at crime scenes.
This shot was worthy of Weegee as well: a naked woman, her back arched, arms and legs splayed over what he had once thought were branches, her face turned toward the camera.
His shaking grew worse as he magnified this image. Her face had no real expression. The mouth was open, battered and bloody, the nose flattened, the cheeks covered in either blood or dirt.
But the eyes got to him. The eyes didn’t look human. They looked like something out of a bad horror movie—filmed over with white, unfocused, and empty. It wasn’t even fair to say that they were staring, because they weren’t. There was no intelligence behind them, no thought, no anything. No staring happened because there was no intelligence inside those eyes to stare.
He leaned away from the computer and frowned. Something about the image was familiar. At first he thought it was simply the way the woman had fallen, and then he realized what it was.
She had come to his door. Four days ago. She’d parked her SUV against the curb, the windows open, her daughter—who was ten, maybe eleven—crying inside.
The woman had knocked, and he almost didn’t answer because she looked so angry. But when he pulled the door open, she smiled at him.
“My daughter is selling candy so that her band can go to the regional tournaments.” She opened the box. “Would you like to buy something?”
He didn’t look at the candy. He looked at the crying girl in the SUV, wondering what her story was. He could probably guess. She didn’t want to sell the candy, but her mother tried to force her. And when that hadn’t worked, the mother decided to do it herself.
“She’s shy,” her mother said, as if confirming his thoughts.
He couldn’t condone this kind of behavior, not from an adult. He hated bullying in all its forms, having been a victim of it when he was young and skinny and too nerdy for his own good.
But the woman made him nervous, and he couldn’t say what he wanted to, which was, Let your daughter be herself. Not everyone is a good salesperson. Or good with people. Or even good one-on-one.
Instead, he struggled with, “N-N-No th-th-thanks.”
And shut the door.
The woman remained on the porch for a moment, as if she couldn’t believe he’d been that rude, and then she’d walked back to the SUV. She’d tossed the box of candy at her poor daughter before getting inside, and driving away.
If she was here, in this swamp, somewhere in the neighborhood, where was the little girl?
He was reaching for the phone before he even realized what he was doing, and dialed 911. When the operator answered, he said, “I think there’s a dead body in my neighborhood.”
And that brought the detectives to his door.
They were in plain clothes, but they showed him badges. He recognized both detectives from the local paper. They had been working on some kind of task force, and they had their pictures in the Metro section often enough that he could almost remember their names.
Fortunately for him, he didn’t need to. They introduced themselves.
The man with the silver hair trimmed so close to his neck that it looked like whiskers was Detective DeCarovich. His partner, a woman who looked like she could bench-press Homer without any effort, was Detective Ortiz.
They came inside Homer’s house without invitation, and wanted to know where he had seen the body. He brought them the photograph which he’d printed out on his laser printer, and they asked again where he had seen her.
So he had to explain—slowly because his stutter acted up—about the cat cameras and the experiment. The detectives stared at him as if he were crazy, so he finally waved them over to the computer and showed them the German man’s home page, complete with instructions on how to build the camera.
Ortiz was the one who finally realized that Homer was serious. She turned to him, her dark eyes wide and stunned. “You did this with your own cats?”
Then she turned toward Princess, his pampered white Persian who looked like she had starred in the Fancy Feast commercials. Princess was lying on top of the red satin pillow he had placed on his couch as a joke, and she looked about as indolent as a cat could get.
“Not her,” he said. “The outdoor cats. The more or less feral ones.”
DeCarovich crossed his arms. He clearly didn’t believe Homer and might even think Homer had something to do with the woman’s disappearance.
Homer crooked a finger. “Come with me,” he said. “But quietly.”
He led them into the kitchen which overlooked the back forty. Fortunately, Mata Hari was in her afternoon spot, on top of a rock near an overgrown rhododendron, stretched out and sound asleep.
“See that box around her neck?” he said. “It has her camera. There are four other cats with cameras as well.”
“For godsake,” DeCarovich said and shook his head. He clearly wasn’t impressed. He acted more like a man who had thought he’d seen it all, only to be surprised by something this weird. “Why would you do that?”
“Curiosity,” Homer said. “I wondered what they do all day.”
“Eat and sleep,” Ortiz said.
“Actually, no,” Homer said. “They’re quite active…”
And then he let his voice trail off. The detectives weren’t interested in his cats. They were interested in the photographs. DeCarovich was looking at the dead woman again.
“You really don’t know where this is,” DeCarovich said.
“No,” Homer said. “And I’m not even sure it’s on my property. It could be anywhere in the neighborhood.”
“Or farther,” Ortiz said. “Cats can have a territory of twenty acres or more.”
DeCarovich turned toward her as if she had suddenly gone as crazy as Homer.
She shrugged. “I grew up around cats.”
DeCarovich let out a small laugh, the kind a person used when he discovered he was among people he thought beneath him. Homer had heard that laugh a lot as a kid, and he didn’t miss it.
His face heated, and his throat tightened. The stutter would get even worse. He knew the symptoms. He had to struggle just to start his next sentence, but he knew the tricks: don’t get stuck on one word. Instead, recast your sentence into something else.
“M-M-Maybe I can reconstruct where they go,” he said. He led the detectives back into his study so that he could open the computer photo files. “I have d-d-days worth of photos. Maybe th-th-there are l-l-landmarks.”
He called up the files and started with the swamp and elephant graveyard photos, working backwards through each cat’s imagery file. He wished now he hadn’t thrown out most of the blurred and unfocused photos. They might tell him something.
Ortiz was leaning over his shoulder as he worked. DeCarovich walked through the room, studying Homer’s books and his framed awards.
“You wrote these?” he asked after a moment.
“Y-Y-Yes,” Homer said.
“Science guy, huh?”
He wanted to go for a self-deprecating “kinda” but the “k” would give him trouble. He had to settle for another stammered “yes.”
“I guess guys like you would do stuff like this. Experiments, huh?”
But Homer was careful not to answer that vague a question. He still had the sense DeCarovich believed he was involved in that woman’s death.
“Th-Th-The p-p-pictures?”
“Yeah.” DeCarovich looked at him.
Homer nodded. His throat had tightened so badly he knew he wouldn’t be able to easily get out another sentence.
“Damn,” Ortiz said beside him. “These cats go underneath everything.”
They did too. Under leaves, between bushes, under rocks. There was no clear trail, nothing recognizable, at least to human eyes.
“You actually think this guy’s onto something?” DeCarovich asked, no longer trying to hide his contempt.
“I think we finally found the bone yard,” Ortiz said, and Homer was the one who shuddered.
He remembered the articles now. These detectives had just formed a task force to investigate a series of missing persons cases, all of women in their thirties who disappeared in broad daylight.
“Except we didn’t find it, not yet,” Ortiz was saying. “These cats can’t tell us where it is and if we try to follow them, we’ll make sure they never go there again.”
“We’ll have to do a grid search,” DeCarovich said.
“And destroy a lot of physical evidence along the way.” Ortiz sighed. “At least now we know what happened to Ann Kemmel.”
“Th-Th-That’s the woman?” Homer asked.
Ortiz nodded.
“Wh-Wh-What about her daughter?”
Both detectives stared at him as if he had just confessed. He swallowed and forced himself to tell them about the incident with the candy bars and the SUV.
“F-F-Four days ago,” he said.
“That’s when she disappeared,” DeCarovich said. “Only her kid wasn’t with her. Her kid was at home the whole time.”
Homer shook his head. “I saw her. She was in th-th-the c-c-car.”
“How would you know?” DeCarovich asked.
“She was c-c-crying real hard.” He felt his face get even redder. “I th-th-thought her mother was b-b-being mean.”
DeCarovich’s eyes narrowed, but Ortiz didn’t seem to notice. She turned toward him.
He raised his eyebrows. “I thought we were too easy on her.”
“I can’t believe she was lying,” Ortiz said. “She must have seen something. I’ll bet she was scared.”
DeCarovich shook his head. “She was just another—.”
He waved his hand at Homer, and Homer wondered what word DeCarovich left out.
“She st-st-st…” Homer couldn’t say the word. He never could under stress. “She has a speech d-d-defect?”
“Like you,” DeCarovich said.
Homer nodded. He had been right then. The mother had been treating her like his mother had treated him, believing that he could overcome his problems with just a little more hard work.
“She wasn’t in the car,” Ortiz said. “She was lying.”
“Lying,” Homer said slowly so that he wouldn’t stutter any more, “makes a speech problem worse. Any stress, even small stress, will make the problem worse.”
He got it out without a single mistake. His cheeks grew even hotter. DeCarovich frowned at him, but it was no longer the frown of the impatient. It was a frown of consideration.
“You think the kid saw something?” he asked Homer, and Homer got that sense again that DeCarovich still suspected him.
Homer’s throat tightened, so he shrugged.
“I’ll bet she did,” Ortiz said. “We need to reinterview.”
“With the photographic evidence.” DeCarovich picked up the print-out. “Can we keep that?”
Homer nodded.
“She’s going to be just as afraid of us as she was the last time.” Ortiz sighed.
Homer knew what she was imagining. Trying to interview a child whose mouth continually betrayed her would be difficult at best.
Ortiz took the photograph from DeCarovich. “Too bad you can’t put a video camera on those cats. Then we could just find the body and the evidence. There’s bound to be some if he’s been using that spot for the past five years.”
Five years. Homer started. They were investigating five years worth of disappearances. Five years of dumping dead women into a primeval swamp.
“It c-c-can’t be t-t-too cl-cl-close,” Homer said. “We’d smell it. Me and the neighbors. Bodies…”
He didn’t have to finish his sentence. Ortiz was nodding.
“You’re right,” she said. “We need a topo map.”
“You want wind charts too?” DeCarovich was being sarcastic.
“I’m serious,” Ortiz said. “If we can find the body without talking to that kid—”
“We have to talk to her,” DeCarovich said. “We have to know why she lied.”
Homer knew DeCarovich was right. But the two thoughts—the video camera and that little girl—gave him an idea.
“D-D-Don’t show her the photograph,” he said. “She won’t be able t-t-to t-t-talk after th-th-that.”
“Listen, buddy,” DeCarovich said, but Ortiz put a hand on his arm.
Homer made himself take a deep breath. “What I meant was I might b-b-be able t-t-to modify the c-c-cameras. Instead of every 90 seconds, I might be able t-t-to have images every five.”
“Which just show us more leaves and trees and rocks,” DeCarovich said. “Nice try, but that’s going to give us more of the same.”
“No,” Ortiz said. “It won’t. It might show us where the cats go into the woods. Can you set up a time stamp too?”
“Yes,” Homer said. “If we know where they go in, the angle of the sun might tell us what direction they’re going.”
He realized after he spoke that he was no longer nervous. He liked the female detective. She didn’t intimidate him.
“These cats aren’t looking up,” DeCarovich said. “We can’t see sunlight.”
“Through the leaves, on the ground, we’ll get some stuff. C’mon, Rick,” Ortiz said. “You’ve done similar things with shadow.”
“I still think we do a grid.”
“Let’s give Mr. Ziff a chance,” Ortiz said. “His cats might help us.”
DeCarovich snorted. “Like they can do that.”
“They already have,” Ortiz said. “They gave us Ann Kemmel, and a reason to reinterview her daughter.”
DeCarovich glared at Homer. “You get one day for this nonsense. One day. After that, we do a grid.”
As if Homer had a stake in not having a grid search. He just wanted them to find this poor woman’s body. And figure out what else was down in that swamp.
Near his house.
Someone had been dumping bodies near his house. Near the safest place he knew.
He shuddered.
“Would you like a c-c-copy of th-th-the photo files?” he asked Ortiz.
“Yeah,” she said. “We have some computer whizzes who might find some answers here. And give me the URL for that German website, so they know this is legit.”
He nodded, made copies onto a CD, and wrote down the web address for her.
She tapped him on the arm as a thank you. “This is kinda cool,” she said, holding up the CD in the jewel case he’d given her. “Who knew that cats did such interesting things?”
“Yeah,” DeCarovich said as he led her out the door. “Like staring at dead bodies. Who knew?”
Homer couldn’t let DeCarovich’s sarcasm and attitude get to him, even though it brought back not only Homer’s high school days, but his teaching days as well. More than once, he’d caught his students in the hall, making fun of his stutter. Often they were the students from his 101 Physics class, and it was right after the unit on particles.
He had no trouble discussing electrons and protons or baryons and mesons. But quarks. Quarks caught him every time. That “ka” sound tripped him up and it got worse the longer he taught. The closer he got to the discussion of elementary particles, the more difficulty he would have.
Just like that little girl. He wished he could interview her. His stutter would put her at ease. She would be able to tell him what she saw or didn’t see. She would be able to tell him how she survived when her mother hadn’t.
He sighed and turned to the project at hand. He was glad he still had that sixth camera, the one the old tom had fought off. Homer was able to experiment with it. He couldn’t set the timer for five seconds—it simply didn’t work—but it could go off every ten seconds.
The problem was that it used a lot of energy when it took that many pictures. He found some larger memory cards, but he didn’t have adequate batteries, and it was too late to buy any new ones.
So he would have to pick his times, hoping he got the right part of the day.
Then he checked his cupboards. He had a lot of canned salmon and tuna. He would need it. He would have to catch each of his feral photographers, remove their cameras, modify them, and reattach them. Then he’d have to catch the group again tomorrow and remove the memory card.
Twenty-four hours really wasn’t enough.
But it was all he had.
By dawn, he had replaced the cameras on all of the cats.
Mata Hari was the first to return. She brought him a lovely series of photographs of the undercarriage of every car on the street. Just as the memory of the camera filled, she had crawled under a fence near the school.
He wondered if that was where she would go to get to the swamp, but he had no way of knowing.
He removed the camera, reset its automatic timer to beginning shooting later the following day, but knew it would do no good.
DeCarovich would hold to the twenty-four hour rule. The man probably still suspected Homer. Homer knew that by now, his fingerprints would have been removed from the jewel case to see if he had a criminal record (he did not) and the computer crimes unit would make sure that he hadn’t dummied up the German website. They would find that he hadn’t faked the website and that his cats had been taking pictures now for more than a month.
DeCarovich would also check Homer’s work history, his phone usage (which was almost nil) and his bank records, which would probably surprise the detective. Popular science books made money—even if men like DeCarovich weren’t interested.
Although Homer didn’t know how someone like DeCarovich couldn’t be interested. His job was all about science. Just on this case alone, they’d be using topographic maps and sunlight angles; they’d be removing fingerprints and studying computer records; they’d probably be using DNA to identify what was left of the other bodies.
Just by that quick reckoning, Homer figured their work would touch on geography, physics, computer science, biology, and chemistry. And all of it—even the deductive reasoning that DeCarovich was probably using to continue to blame Homer—required a meticulousness that only the best scientists could achieve.
So Homer had to hope that the other cats would bring him something, something recognizable.
Something good.
The answers he sought came, surprisingly, from Einstein—a small shy male with a shock of white hair over his tiny furrowed brow. Einstein had been difficult to conquer: it had taken weeks to catch him to neuter him, and weeks after that to regain his trust. That he wore a camera at all was amazing; that he actually showed Homer the trail to the body was a shock.
Homer thought Einstein was one of the few cats who didn’t make a daily pilgrimage to the swamp. Apparently he did go, just didn’t stay as long as the others, and so sometimes he didn’t get a good photograph. Also, Einstein was the cat whose photos were most likely to blur because he ran almost everywhere.
But on this morning, he meandered toward the swamp—through the hole in the fence that Mata Hari had found, around a stone with the year 1908 carved into the top, and then down an embankment into a copse of trees.
Einstein actually followed a tiny trail. Homer hadn’t noticed it on the previous shots because it looked like a bare line in the earth, nothing spectacular. But on the ten-second shots, it was clear that the bare line was connected to other bare lines—a rabbit path that wound from the 1908 rock and into the trees.
There he saw a moss-covered old growth stump, some ancient logging, and several late-blooming irises in front of a ruined log that Einstein crawled on top of to peer into the swamp.
The body looked worse today; less like the woman Homer had met and more like a corpse. Einstein had gotten several good pictures of it, and Homer didn’t study any of them.
Instead, he copied the entire memory card onto a CD, printed the files, and called Ortiz.
She wasn’t at the station. The dispatch patched him into her cell. She answered on the fourth ring, sounding annoyed.
Homer identified himself, then said, “I think I know where the path is.”
“Thank God,” she said. “We’ll be right there.”
And they were. Within fifteen minutes, they had parked in front of his house. DeCarovich looked less dyspeptic today, but Ortiz seemed frustrated.
They had been talking to the little Kemmel girl when Homer called, although “talking,” DeCarovich said, “isn’t really the word for it.”
Homer didn’t ask about it. He figured they’d tell him if they wanted to. It wasn’t his investigation after all. He was just helping with one small part.
He put the printed photographs in a line, with little gaps between them. Next to them, he put a map of this section of the neighborhood.
“See this?” he said, pointing to the fence. “That’s part of this house.”
He pointed to a house not far from the school.
“And this rock?” he said. “It’s behind the school. They christened it last year as part of a rededication. It’s been there since the school was built.”
He had highlighted what he believed to be the path leading into the trees.
“I figure you can use the landmarks—the irises, the old-growth stump, the log—to find her.”
“You didn’t look?” DeCarovich asked.
Homer frowned at him. No one in his right mind would investigate this one on his own, not when he understood the science of trace and the importance of keeping a crime scene uncontaminated.
“No,” Homer said. “I figure th-th-that’s your job.”
The stutter surprised him. He thought he was confident enough in his map not to tighten up. But that hint of a threat in DeCarovich’s voice had been enough to bring back the stutter.
“We need to go down there,” DeCarovich said.
“Let’s send a team,” Ortiz said studying the photos.
“Let’s not waste taxpayer dollars until we know we’re in the right place.”
For once, Homer agreed with DeCarovich. They didn’t say much more to him. They took the printed photographs, the map, and the CD, and then they left.
He felt at loose ends. Despite his sensible thoughts about the crime scene, he did want to investigate it himself. He wished he were more involved.
After all, his cats had been the one to discover what Ortiz had called the body dump. If only they were trained cats. He could send them down the path to the swamp with cameras around their neck and watch as the detectives officially found Ann Kemmel’s body.
But he couldn’t assign the cats anything, and he could only view what they wanted to look at. Mostly, all they cared about was the undercarriage of cars.
Then he frowned and headed toward his computer. The cats loved the undercarriage of SUVs more than actual cars. SUVs had big tires and a wider frame, but a lower undercarriage than a truck. That gave the cat a lot of places to hide and even more places to visit with little feline friends, all in the comfort of a shady spot on the street.
But one photo had come to mind. A photo taken by yet another cat—Galileo—somewhere around the time of the candy selling incident. It had been a blur photo, and Homer had tossed it, but he hadn’t yet cleared off the memory card.
He grabbed all the cards that needed clearing and started cycling through them one by one. He didn’t find any more images of the path to the swamp—he knew he wouldn’t—but he did find several of a parked SUV with unfamiliar tires.
And then he found the photograph he was looking for. Two photographs, actually. One of a skinny leg with a single pink girl’s tennis shoe about to touch the pavement—and another of a pink-and-blue blur disappearing behind a bench across the street.
He closed his eyes, trying to remember what that crying girl had been wearing that afternoon. He just remembered her face, splotchy and humiliated, her eyes swollen from all the tears she’d shed. He could also remember the SUV, with its blue and silver metallic sides.
Silver, like the side where the pants leg brushed.
He opened his eyes and studied the next two frames. He didn’t see any more pink and blue blurs, but he did know where that bench was. It was several doors down from his, right across the street from his surly neighbor, the man who had rolled his eyes when he’d heard the ferocity of Homer’s stutter.
Homer went cold.
He wondered if he should call Ortiz. He didn’t want to bother her, not when she was looking at the crime scene.
Instead, he opened a file on his computer, looked at the neighborhood map he’d downloaded earlier and studied the wetlands.
They not only ran behind his house, they ran the entire length of this side of the street, ending (or beginning depending on your point of view) at the century-old school house.
Anyone who wanted to could carry a body from their own personal back forty into the wetlands and walk through the overgrown wooded area to the swamp without being seen.
No wonder DeCarovich had suspected Homer. Homer fit all kinds of profiles. He was reclusive. He lived alone. He had access to the so-called body dump. He even inserted himself in the investigation.
His hands were shaking again. He wasn’t sure if he had important information or not. The two detectives were still having trouble talking to the daughter. But Homer had evidence she left the SUV on her own and ran away.
Before or after her mother had disappeared?
He logged onto the internet and looked up what he could find on the disappearance of Ann Kemmel. She only ranked a few paragraphs in the paper on the day after her disappearance. But those few paragraphs were enough.
She and the SUV were missing.
She was last seen here on his quiet block in the middle of the afternoon on the day she disappeared, selling band candy for her daughter.
Just like he’d said.
He sank deeper into his chair. His mouth was dry. He was innocent. Ortiz knew that or she would have confiscated his computer. They would have come into his house with a warrant.
Or maybe they were waiting to find the body.
Maybe they needed just a little more for probable cause.
A knock on the door snapped him out of his reverie. His heart was pounding and his face was already flushed. He knew he looked guilty. For all his caution, he had done so much wrong.
It would only be a matter of time before someone would come to arrest him.
He managed to leave his study, walk across his living room and peer through the glass in the door.
Ortiz stood there, arms folded behind her back. There was no sign of DeCarovich.
When she saw Homer, she nodded. She didn’t smile.
Here it was: fair warning. She had come to ask if she could search his house. He would tell her to get a warrant. He would use his small fortune to hire the best criminal defense attorney in the state. He might even get his publisher’s publicist to get him some interviews on his good Samaritan deed gone wrong.
He pulled open the door.
“We found her.” Ortiz sounded tired. “And the others, most likely. I just wanted you to know. Your cats were right.”
He waited for her to say the next part, the part about searching his house or getting a warrant. But she didn’t.
She seemed to be done.
“Wow,” he said. “The photos worked?”
“There was a cat path,” she said. “The lab techs are down there now. It’s a mess. But no one would have smelled it. Too far from houses. Too far from that school.”
“The cats had to know.”
“The cats must have smelled something decaying, but it didn’t interest them. None of them are starving.”
He smiled in spite of himself. Her comment had echoed his thoughts.
And besides, she’d seen his outdoor cats. They clearly weren’t starving.
“Um,” he said. “I was wondering one other thing. Th-th-that girl? Did she run away from her mother?”
Ortiz frowned at him. “How did you know?”
“I th-th-think I found some more pictures.”
She came inside without asking, but she did take off her shoes. They had a swampy smell—or maybe she did—the beginnings of decay.
Princess and his other indoor cat, King, came out of the bedroom, sniffing the air. So that smell did attract them.
“I think I found pictures of the SUV,” he said, and told her about the underbellies of cars, how cats socialized there, and how much they seemed to like a shady spot on the road.
“We were talking to her when you called,” Ortiz said. “Poor kid. She’s going to need therapy for the rest of her life.”
He looked at the detective. She was already peering at the photographs on his computer.
“Why?”
“She says her mother went inside a house to sell band candy, and she ran away. She went to her grandmother’s, but her grandmother brought her home.”
“And no one saw the mother again.”
“That’s right,” Ortiz said. “Missing Persons wasn’t even that interested since the SUV was gone too. They figured the mother had run off.”
He pointed out the skinny leg, the pink shoes, the blur of blue-and-pink across the street.
“And you know where this is, don’t you?” Ortiz said.
He nodded.
She grinned at him. “Too bad we can’t put those cats of yours on payroll.”
“You wouldn’t like them as employees,” he said. “They go their own way.”
And it wasn’t until after she left, with more printed photographs and more files on CD, that he realized he had had an entire conversation with a woman he liked and hadn’t stammered.
At least, not much.
He thought of it as a victory.
He didn’t realize it was also the beginning of an odyssey.
Ortiz and DeCarovich got a search warrant for the surly neighbor’s house and found blood in the basement, and all sorts of other grisly things. The man had done exactly what Homer had hypothesized: killed the women (after abusing them sexually), then waited until dark and carried their bodies through the wetlands to the wider swampy area, dumping them there. Sometimes he would move their cars before he killed them, sometimes afterwards.
DeCarovich believed that there was a car dump like there was a body dump, but so far, no one had found it.
Ortiz kept Homer apprised of all of it. She even visited him a few times, always asking about his cats. Finally she told him she wanted to go to dinner with him, but she couldn’t, not until the trial was over.
The trial. He hadn’t thought of it. The grand jury, the testimony. The cross-examination.
He could already see what was coming:
He was a central part of the case—actually, his cats were—and he would feel like a failing professor all over again. Stammering his way through his stories, wishing that he could find a way to mitigate the talking part, and still explain—meticulously—his role in the arrest.
He decided to write out his testimony, to plan it, detail by detail. And as he did, he threaded the photographs through the text.
It only took him a week to figure out what he had.
A true crime book.
An unusual true crime book.
No one else had ever written anything like it.
He summoned up his courage and showed it to his agent. She loved it. She proposed a few other books as well—one just a book of photography by his cats. She showed him some curious coffee-table book from several years before of cats painting (actually just sweeping their paint-covered paws over walls and floors) and told him it had been a bestseller.
He agreed to do it all, but prosecutors wanted him to wait until his testimony was finished so that he wouldn’t be accused of helping the police for money.
He wondered how anyone would think he had rigged his cameras to his feral cats for money, but he knew that people could believe anything.
So he waited. And he testified. And he did feel humiliated.
Until Detective Ortiz—her first name was Susan—took him out for a celebratory steak dinner. She had praised him, called him brilliant, and even said he was interesting.
He didn’t feel interesting.
But he liked her attention.
He liked her.
He was so glad that the case had wrapped up quickly. He had been a star witness—not the star witness, though. That proved to be the little girl, with her father at her side, pointing out the man she’d last seen with her mother.
The surly neighbor, who no longer rolled his eyes at people who stuttered.
They had convicted him, two of the people he held in contempt. They had ended his life on the outside.
Two stammerers—two momentary stars—and five wandering cats, reluctantly sharing their secret lives bit by tiny bit.
____________________________________________
The Secret Lives of Cats
Copyright © 2016 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Ellery Queen’s Mystery Magazine, July, 2008Published by WMG PublishingCover and layout copyright © 2016 by WMG PublishingCover design by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © IleanaolaruDreamstime
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
Thank you, backers of the Pulphouse Subscription Drive Kickstarter! We hit all our goals and did much better than expected. We greatly appreciate all of your support!
And if you missed the craziness or just don’t want to go through Kickstarter, check out our website. You can subscribe there and get all kinds of other cool stuff.
Thanks again, everyone!!
Denny and Nikki share a similar history. Or so it seems to Denny when Nikki shows up, bruised and withdrawn, in the quiet Oregon Coast town he now calls home.
But history creates a powerful pull on the psyche. Sometimes in good ways. Sometimes in bad. And sometimes, the end of a journey actually marks a new beginning.
“Hitchhiking Across an Ancient Sea” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Hitchhiking Across an Ancient SeaKristine Kathryn RuschThe prairie grass, rich and tall and fine, tickles my chest as I walk. A child could get lost here. I’m six-eight, and I feel dwarfed by the endless vista of grasses, undulating in the breeze. The air smells fresh, like a sea breeze, and I wonder what Karen will think as she stands at the edge of the prairie, land stretching far as the eye can see.
The rain slanted sideways the day Nikki arrived, hard, pelting rain without chill, the kind of storm unique to the Pacific coast. I had just pulled my boat in—the day’s catch not quite what I expected—when she stopped in front of McIver’s Store.
She was driving a brand new Volvo, dark blue, obviously a tourist car because the paint-job wouldn’t have survived in the salt-laden air more than a month. Her legs were long, her hair dark and red, her eyes covered with sunglasses despite the darkness of the day. But it wasn’t so much her body I was looking at. It was the air of silence she carried around her, like a piece of fragile glass separating her from the world. Sylvia Plath called that glass a bell jar, and I hadn’t seen one since my mother’s shattered twenty-five years before.
I left the boat and the catch to Bill, my assistant, and I hurried up the sand-covered path, not caring that I still wore my rain gear and smelled of fish. I pushed open the screen door, and let it slam back with a bang. McIver’s smelled of coffee, day-old donuts, and wood smoke. She stood in front of the cash register, sunglasses still on, hands shaking as she counted out fifteen dollars for her groceries.
Long tapered nails, painted red. Two nails on the right hand broken below the skin line. Polish chipped on the other three. A bruise growing purple between her thumb and her forefinger. I couldn’t turn away, not even then.
“Help you, Denny?” Old Man McIver asked, caution in his voice. He had seen the glasses, seen the bruise, put it all together. And he knew me. Remembered when I arrived, just as bruised, just as silent.
I grabbed the coffeepot, and poured the old brew into the remaining Styrofoam cup. “Cold one,” I said. “Damn rain kept up all day.”
“Surprised you go out in it,” McIver said. “Most of the other boys spend their days in Ike’s, drinking and waiting for the clouds to clear.”
“Most of the other boys make a half-assed living off the sea.” The cup warmed my hands.
She didn’t look up as she took the packages from McIver. “There’s a sign in your window about cottages.”
He glanced at her, then at me, both looks measuring and tough. “Yup. You interested by the week or the month?”
“Month,” she said.
He stared at me, pale blue eyes going watery in the store’s dim light. I grabbed my cup and went outside, the message clear. He wasn’t going to say a thing until I left. He saw my interest, knew that common wounds bind deep. He wanted me to leave her alone.
I leaned against a post for a minute, watching the rain slant in front of me like someone sketched it in the air. Then I wandered back down to the boat.
She and I would have time enough for talking later.
Took three nights driving to get here. Karen woke up once in Montana, looked at a daybreak sky full of clouds from the fires in Yellowstone, and said, “It’s pretty, Dad.”
“Yes,” I said. “It is.” And thought briefly about stopping. Who came to Montana, after all? It was long and rugged and cold. There was fishing in clear mountain streams. Not a living, maybe, but a way of life.
Then I looked over at her little four-year-old face pressed into the pillow, almost blocking the view from the passenger window, the Volvo’s plastic cracked from too much wear, and knew Montana was too harsh for us. We belong in Kansas, in prairie grasses that extend forever, willows that bow over a patch of land like islands rising out of the sea. The land is old, and has seen more bloodshed than the rest of the West combined.
So much death that a little more only enriches the soil, enriches the land.
Bloody Kansas.
We’ve come home.
When I first arrived in Emmett’s Cove, I wore a three-piece suit and shoes that shined so clearly I could see my own reflection. My only experience out of doors had been a two-day camping trip in Yosemite, where I’d spent most of my time staring at Sequoias and wondering if trees that tall were filled with wisdom. Height and wisdom once had a correlation for me: I had gotten into Northwestern on a basketball scholarship—basketball being the only escape from Chicago’s South Side, at least for boys like me. I blew out my knee second term and pulled a week’s worth of all-nighters in the hospital, studying so that I could stay even if I never walked again. I walked, but not on the court, and by the time I graduated, I had a straight-A average, and enough recommendations to get me into Harvard Law.
I graduated summa cum laude, turned down jobs with prestige firms in New York and L.A., and returned to the South Side, thinking that even though I was in private practice, I could be the Clarence Darrow of my generation. Five Cook County detectives mistaking me for a five-nine robber in a ski mask (“Why else you in the neighborhood, boy?”—a nightstick across the mouth preventing me from saying my office was half a block away), and a six-week stay in Sacred Heart Hospital changed my mind on that. Somehow I had thought that the law degree would protect me from the ignorance and violence I had grown up with. But nothing could protect me—I couldn’t even protect myself against five armed men. Perhaps it was that knowledge, more than the beating, that made me leave.
So ten years later, I knew how Nikki felt when she arrived in that Volvo: wanting space and silence in a place where no one knew her name; wishing she could hide her face, and the story it told; hoping no one would ask one small question, a tiny show of concern.
Places like Emmett’s Cove, though, the concern came in glances, in questions not asked, in answers not given and in one-hundred dollars rent for a furnished cabin that would command over five-hundred dollars in the height of the season. There was also warmth, if you knew how to find it and loneliness, everywhere you looked.
The motel room smells musty. Thin chenille bedspreads cover rubbery old blankets. Karen balks at sleeping in daylight, but I can see the exhaustion in the shadows that hollow out her eyes.
I stand at the window until her breathing evens, staring at a grouping of cottonwood trees that breaks my view of the prairie. The motel is old, used as little as the highway now that the interstate sweeps cars by this forgotten expanse of land. People here are as taciturn as people on the coast, but they’re different, rooted. It’s as if the land has reached up and wrapped itself around their ankles, drawing them inward like a slow quicksand no one wants to fight.
My daughter sighs in her sleep. She is the best of both of us: skin a fine milk chocolate, hair a deep brown with red highlights—not quite auburn, not quite black. Wrapped in the chenille, she looks small and desperate, her tiny hands clutching a stuffed dog that somehow survived the fiery house.
We need roots, Karen and I. Not a past to chase us like an angry demon across a burning landscape, but roots to hold us, so we can turn and face that past with the strength of generations.
I hope we’ll find that strength here, in the prairie, on land that once stood beneath the waters of an ancient sea.
I found the cottage easily enough. Nikki made no attempt to hide the Volvo, which spoke to two possibilities: she had been planning her escape for a long time and the Volvo was new or no one remained to look for her. Her lack of caution suggested no one remained.
Every evening, she walked on the beach, arms wrapped around her despite the oversized cable sweater she wore. I began bringing my boat back early, sometimes abandoning a sweet run, much to Bill’s chagrin. He worked with me because I worked, one of the few in this town who refused to let the sea beat me. I learned fishing from Old Man McIver during two tough years when I was always cold, always aching. I figured that if the sea beat me, I would have nothing left, having let the urban jungle close its door behind me.
A week into my changed routine, Bill abandoned a line to see me standing at the prow. His gaze followed mine, rooted on Nikki standing near Cutter’s Rock, looking thin and forlorn. He stared with me for a moment, then grunted. “That explains it,” he said, and went back to his work.
But it didn’t, not really. I had lived in Emmett’s Cove for a decade. Lived alone, had few friends, and never dated. My house had become my refuge, filled with hundreds of books, recordings, and videos. Sometimes I drove inland, sold my fish to a handful of stores beyond my regulars, or attended a class in Portland or Salem, but rarely did I spend time with anyone else.
And I was not the only one with this solitary routine. Emmett’s Cove stood at the mouth of an isolated stretch of beach. Highway 101 went through, but most drivers never made it that far. They turned on one of the highways leading to civilization. Emmett’s Cove would have died decades before if it weren’t for the great fishing just off the inlet. Tourists drove through in the summer, but most drove on, searching for towns with artsy-crafty shops and twenty-four hour grocery stores. Part-time fishermen took the summer cabins, and everyone else belonged.
Or was a refugee like me, running from an unsettled score, a violent past. Living in a kind of stasis, waiting for the world to catch up.
That night I got off the boat, removed my gear, and washed up in the small shed at the edge of the dock. Bill took care of the line and the catch, shaking his head all the while. I walked down the beach to Cutter’s Rock, keeping my pace friendly, splashing at the wave’s edges to make my presence known.
Still, Nikki jumped when I said hello.
She wasn’t wearing her sunglasses. Her right eye was purplish yellow and swollen almost shut. Four fading bruises ran like fingerprints down one cheek, with a matching thumbprint near her jaw. She didn’t smile at me. In fact, she took half a step back.
I held out my hands to show I meant no harm. My height, my very presence on an Oregon beach was enough to unnerve most people. “I come in peace,” I said, only half humorously.
She nodded once, gaze skittering away from me like a stone atop of waves. I stood beside her. From the land, the ocean looked like a picture postcard, dressed up with salt and sea tang, an unreal vista. On the boat, I felt like a beetle on the back of a lion. One false move and I would fall to my death.
“It’s like standing on the edge of the world,” I said.
Maybe that was what it was. We had run so far we couldn’t run any farther. The coastal mountains rose behind us like giants guarding a fairyland.
“Sometimes I pretend that the rest of the world has gone away,” I said. “There’s only us, here. Now.”
I got the smile then. It lit her entire face, made the bruises fade, gave her a beauty I only suspected she possessed. “I wish,” she said, the words plaintive and full of such longing that I felt to continue the conversation would diminish us both.
We stood, side by side, until the ocean swallowed the sun, and night surrounded us.
At daybreak, Karen and I walk down the dusty back highway that will lead us to the creek. I have filled my backpack with two vacuum bottles filled with water, prepackaged sandwiches from the grocery store, and a bunch of bananas. Karen carries her stuffed dog, not quite understanding this pilgrimage, but willing to go along with it.
As the road plunges into the prairie, she stops and holds up her hands, a wordless request that I carry her. I pick her up and we stare at the grass. Waves rippled through it as the breeze touches it. Karen watches with a solemnity she once had for the ocean. The stuffed dog lies between us, a soft barrier. Dust whirls around us. The day will be hot.
At the base of the hollow stand three oak trees. A half-dry creek runs between them, and on one side is a half-collapsed barn. A few yards away, a fireplace stands like a lone sentry.
A hundred and thirty-five years ago, my great-grandmother hid under the hay in this barn, listening as white men circled outside, their dogs baying. She had seen her father attacked by dogs—barely enough of him left to lynch, she once said—and she knew if she got found the dogs wouldn’t get her first. For three hours, she didn’t move, scarcely breathed, felt hay tickle her nose, her chin, her very being.
Finally they left. At dawn, her contact, a big, eastern white man named Sam came, wrapped her in a blanket and stuck her in the back of his car like a slab of sausage. He went through three picket points, telling guards in a joking tone that he had runaway slaves in the back of his cart. The guards all laughed, never checked, and she made it to Chicago, where she lived long enough to tell a little boy that if she had it to do over again, she would have gone back to Kansas, because that was where freedom began.
“Is this it?” Karen asks, clearly disappointed.
“This is it,” I say, wishing that it felt more like home.
Somehow I expected the earth to reach up here and grab me, small vines that would circle my ankles and pull me inward. But my daughter and I sit in the shade, feeling the humidity grow as the sun shortens the shadows. I feel the history seeping out of the land. If I close my eyes, I can almost see my great-grandmother’s childish face, drawn tight with terror. And before her, the generation of nomadic peoples who fished the prairie as if the sea waters never retreated. The land was old, and I was only a heartbeat in its history.
“Ready to go?” I ask.
Karen nods.
I take her hand, and we make our way back up the dusty trail, the heat fierce against our backs. We have nowhere left to go. Our search for home is like the Christian search for the grail. It rises like a beacon before us, but we can never touch it. We will remain, forever, hitchhikers crossing an ancient sea.
The first time was as natural as breathing. One moment we were in Nikki’s living room, the next between the sheets, my dark hand covering her white. She tasted of rainwater and summer sunshine. And I was gentle, especially after I saw the scars tracing her skin like war wounds.
She never told me. I never asked. But over the years I pieced it together.
He had been a colleague, a bit older, more confident. The attraction was rich and fine, fraught with danger that blossomed under stress or after too many drinks. And she, somehow, grew to believe she deserved it, grew to think his fists were part of his love. Until the night in the grocery store parking lot, where a fight erupted into a beating, the beating into a brawl. She lost the baby; he lost his life; and at the hospital, the detective told her they would file no charges, since it was clearly self-defense.
To the detective perhaps. To Nikki the incident spoke of the possibilities of love. She wore the bell jar as protection, guarding a side I would never touch, no matter how gentle my finger, how soft my tone. After Karen, the bell jar became more fragile—perhaps a baby’s cries were more threatening than my masculine needs—and when it shattered, the shards fell over all of us.
Another man resides in the hotel. Fortyish, he fancies himself a Midwestern Christo. He is working on a masterpiece in the prairie. He will unveil it in two days.
We sit on rusted metal lawn furniture and drink beer in late summer twilight, just after I put Karen to bed. His hands are gnarled, his face sea-weathered. I wonder if he has lived on the coast.
I tell him about my search. He laughs, voice booming across the expanse of land.
“People like you,” he says, “do not know how to live. You encounter tragedy and flee as if it were the enemy, instead of embracing it and all of its possibilities. And because you run, you do not feel, and because you do not feel, you do not live.”
I stand then, unwilling to let a man I hardly know make pronouncements about my life.
“See?” he says. “You run, even now.”
I go inside. The day’s heat is trapped in here. Karen’s legs poke out of the sheets, her hair sprawled across the pillow. I close the windows, turn on the ancient air conditioner, figuring its rattle is preferable to the heat. Karen sighs once and turns. I cover her, then sit in the darkness and watch her sleep.
I knew even before the sirens began. Out on the boat, just beyond the inlet, I made Bill turn back. “Squall?” he asked.
“Not exactly,” I said.
Perhaps I saw unconscious cues. Perhaps I saw the smoke. Or perhaps I had a premonition. It didn’t matter. What mattered was that as soon as the boat scraped the dock I was off and running toward the house.
Smoke billowed around the point, black and ugly. The sirens started when I was two blocks away. I arrived to find Karen on the front lawn, arms wrapped around her stuffed dog, rocking back and forth. The house was engulfed—not even the volunteer firefighters would go inside.
There had been small signs, sure. An unexplained fire on top of the stove. A space heater catching a towel. Somehow I always found a reason that had nothing to do with Nikki. Karen didn’t understand that towels on heaters caused fires. Karen splattered grease on the stove. Never noticing, of course, that each time, Karen had been outside, safe and protected, her stuffed dog for company.
Hard to believe that a woman I loved was unstable. Harder still to believe that all the things we never talked about, all the hints, the imagined stories, might not have linked us after all.
I didn’t want to think that I had not been enough, that the shattered place inside Nikki finally engulfed her like fire engulfed the wooden house.
All Karen and I had left was the Volvo. The insurance man tracked us down, didn’t meet my gaze when he apologized for the death of my wife, as if it were his fault, as if his insurance didn’t provide the proper magic. His check bought us clothes and the ability to travel. I rented the boat to Bill, and we left.
Running again from the scene of a crime.
The day of the unveiling is cool and spring-like, odd for Kansas in July. We wander down a gravel road, a group of pilgrims united only in our quest to see what an artist has created in the prairie heat.
Karen walks beside me, stuffed dog tucked under her arm. He has not left her side since the fire, her own magic against all future tragedies. She holds me too, as if her grip ensures that I will never leave her.
We haven’t talked about the fire, have said little to each other since we left the coast. The shadows under her eyes have grown deeper, and I wonder if perhaps I was wrong. Perhaps we should have stayed and faced the burned-down ruin, discussed the scars that tragedy left.
I pick Karen up and squeeze her. She squawks in protest. I put her down, and we walk together, a part of a Kansas crowd going to see a Kansas event.
The artist is there, sitting on top of his pickup truck, as immobile as a statue. He doesn’t acknowledge me, even when I wave. He watches the people pass by, listens as the gasps rise.
I am taller, so I can see it from the rise. Three sails rising out of prairie grass, looking forever like a ship sailing the inland sea. The grass undulates around it, waves battering its sides. An emptiness flows through me, a longing deeper than any I had ever felt before.
Karen tugs my arm. “Daddy,” she says, and I realize she cannot see. I pick her up, feeling her four-year-old weight. Someday she will be too big to hold. Someday, she will be all grown up, with passions of her own.
I point and her gaze follows, then she gasps and squirms again. I cannot hold her. She slips through my arms and into the grass, only the ripples showing her passage.
“Karen!” I follow, half embarrassed by her outburst, but unable to prevent her passage. The artist stands on his truck, watching. The crowd is silent. I trace the ripples as I would the wake of a boat, and reach the sails a moment after Karen.
They are three tall masts pounded into the earth, the grass hollowed out around them to simulate a ship. She walks around and around, looking lost. The she kicks a sail. The shiver runs along the mast, makes the fabric slap in a non-existent breeze.
“It’s not real,” she says.
I grab her, pull her into my arms. She fights against me for a moment, then collapses against my shoulder, deep wracking sobs flowing from her chest. The passion missing from me and my wife has found a home in our child. The roots I’m searching for Karen already has. They’re on a coast half a continent away, near a burned-out house overlooking the sea.
“I’m sorry,” I say, and the words have more power than I ever thought they could. I stand and carry my sobbing daughter out of the waving grass.
She is right. The sea is not here. It receded eons ago to a world filled with sharp edges, with cliffs and rocks and slanting rain. Odd to have found a beacon and be blinded by its light. I never knew what I had because I never let myself see.
I emerge covered with dirt and straw. Like my great-grandmother, a hundred and thirty-five years before, I feel free. She was right. Freedom begins in Kansas, but she was wrong too. It is something we can take home with us. And I learned it, not from an old woman near death, but from a young girl near birth.
The artist smiles at us as we walk past. Karen shifts in my arms, body calm after her bout of tears. I nod once, glad to be embracing life.
____________________________________________
Hitchhiking Across an Ancient Sea
Copyright © 2021 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Grails, Quests, Visitations And Other Occurrences, edited by Martin H. Greenberg, Richard Gilliam and Ed Kramer, Unnamable Press, 1992Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2021 by WMG PublishingCover design by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Jill Battaglia/Dreamstime
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
I put together a fun video for Pulphouse Magazine just in time for the annual subscription renewal Kickstarter, which began Tuesday. I had initially set this post to go up automatically on Tuesday, but it didn’t for some reason. Sigh.
So I’m letting you know now. We’ve hit four stretch goals so far, and we’re trying to hit another over the weekend. (120 backers by Sunday.) This means that if you back the Kickstarter, you’ll get your six issue subscription with really great fiction inside and four anthologies. Writers will get several opportunities to send stories to Pulphouse which is truly special because the magazine is closed to submissions most of the time.
I also put together the Kickstarter video, which is fun, but not as much fun as this one. Yep, I’m playing with iMovie only because I haven’t had the time (literally) to relearn a much more sophisticated program. I’m getting there. I’m hoping my time frees up soon.
In the meantime, I need two things from you. The second thing first: check out the Kickstarter. Lots of great rewards and even more wonderful fiction. First thing second: watch the video below. Enjoy!
Pamela Jackson’s secrets forced her to change her identity and move to the Oregon Coast.
When Pamela finds herself called to jury duty—and worse, selected for the jury on a murder trial—she fears she must see it through to keep up appearances as an upstanding citizen.
But Pamela might know a little too much about murder to pull it off.
“Jury Duty,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Jury DutyKristine Kathryn RuschPamela sat in the center of the courtroom, not too close to the front because she didn’t want to call attention to herself, and not in the back because she didn’t want people to think she was hiding. She had done everything she could to blend in: she wore no make-up, and her clothes were Northwest business casual—a pair of brown slacks with an off-white sweater. With her left hand, she fingered her juror number—267—thoughtfully provided on a little wooden keychain so that she wouldn’t lose it.
The court clerk pulled numbers out of a box and handed them to the judge. He was balding, and the top of his head shone in the fluorescent lights. His nasal voice boomed through the courtroom without the aid of a microphone, “Five-hundred-and-eighty-one. Five, eight, one.”
As the unlucky man rose from his seat on the left side of the courtroom, the remaining members of the jury pool swiveled to watch him walk toward the jury box. Six people sat there already, hands folded, heads down, waiting.
The judge had said they would pick twenty-seven, enough for two juries and three extras. Both juries would listen to the case, although one jury would be designated as “alternate.” The remaining three people were alternates also, added protection for a death penalty case that could last over a month.
Pamela had been called up two weeks ago, along with 1,000 others out of this county of 50,000, and she had stood in her kitchen, clutching the letter, feeling an uncomfortable sense of irony.
When she had come to Rickets Rock, a town so small that it seldom showed up on any map, she had decided that she would live as quietly as she could. She didn’t want to draw attention to herself, good or bad. That meant getting a driver’s license, registering to vote, being a good citizen. It meant concocting a history, and trying to smile at the locals. It meant lying, each and every day.
The jury summons had caught her in the lie: she couldn’t back out because she had used a false name on her voter registration form. She had to go along with the fiction that she was Pamela Jackson, and hope that something about Pamela would keep her off the largest and most notorious jury the county had seen in decades.
“Juror thirty-four,” the judge said. “Three-four.”
A woman two seats from Pamela stood, and nearly tripped as she tried to get out of the row. Pamela kept turning her number over and over, the hard wood edges catching on her fingertips.
She had decided, when she had gone to orientation and received the outrageously long questionnaire, that she wouldn’t lie if at all possible: she knew that trying to remember too many lies had tripped up more than one person.
So she had placed her personal views on the pages, thinking that they would disqualify her. Particularly the carefully worded questions on pages 10 through 13, the ones about law, the death penalty, and murder.
Question 33: Do you believe that some acts are so heinous that they can only be punished by death?
To which she had replied: Yes.
Question 50: Have you known or are you related to anyone who was murdered?
To which she had replied: Yes.
And Question 117: Do you believe Raymond Northrup is guilty of the crimes of which he has been accused?
To which she had replied: I could care less.
She had felt certain that the defense attorney, going through the questionnaires, would demand she be taken out of the jury pool, especially when she had had to explain her answer to question 50 on a later questionnaire. (How was the deceased related to you? Husband; Explain the circumstances of the death: He was a jackass. Of course, she didn’t write that. Instead, she made up a lie about a beloved uncle who died in a convenience store robbery.)
“Two-sixty-seven,” the judge said. “Two, six, seven.”
Pamela’s hand clenched around the number. She touched her round juror button, pinned to her sweater, and cursed silently. Her luck had abandoned her.
Now her goal was to be dismissed in the voir dire.
She grabbed her book—Patricia Cornwell’s treatise on forensics and Jack the Ripper—and slung her purse over her shoulder.
Then Pamela eased out of the row, past the loggers and the truck drivers and the waitresses, and walked, head down, shoulders slumped forward, to the jury box.
Her heart was pounding. She had often pictured herself in a courtroom, but not here, not among the jury.
Instead, she expected to be at the tables, an attorney beside her, defending what was left of her miserable little life.
Another half hour went by before the rest of the twenty-seven victims were chosen. Then the questioning began, starting with the first juror picked, a dapper man who was the only person in the room, besides the attorneys, to wear a suit. Fifteen minutes into his voir dire, he was dismissed for claiming he did not have a strong stomach.
As he stepped down, the clerk drew a new number from the box, and another prospective juror took the first juror’s place.
Pamela noted the excuse, and apparently so had the second juror. He made the same claim, which caused the judge to issue a gusty sigh.
“If we dismiss everyone with a weak stomach, we’ll have no one left.” He faced the defense attorney, who had posed the question. “If you believe these crimes are too graphic, we’ll make sure there’ll be no crime scene photos after lunch and we’ll provide sickness bags, just like the airlines. Now, move on.”
Pamela was the first up after the luncheon break. She returned to the courtroom loggy from the personal pan she’d had at the nearby Pizza Hut, and exhausted by a morning of listening to other people’s lives.
During lunch she had toyed with changing her strategy, possibly saying that she did not approve of the death penalty or that she did not believe a person was innocent until proven guilty. But all of those answers would have contradicted her juror’s questionnaire, a questionnaire that had informed her on the top of every page that her answers had the force of answers given under oath.
A new answer would call attention to her. If she was lucky, she would escape without much attention being paid to her at all.
Finally, the attorneys reached her. She had to repeat her name and her address.
“You own a bookstore, Ms. Jackson?” The prosecutor, Daphne Sullivan, stood in front of the jury box. She was a middle-aged woman who wore a stylish black suit that seemed out of place in this small county.
“Yes.” Main Street Books, the new-and-used bookstore she had opened in what passed for Rickets Rock’s downtown. When she had first received her jury letter, she had hoped that being a small business owner would disqualify her, but the clerk of courts had quizzed her, found out that she had a part-time assistant, and that the store sometimes closed when Pamela planned a day off, and decided that the store could afford to lose Pamela for a few weeks with little or no hardship.
“Do you enjoy reading?” Sullivan asked.
“Yes.”
“Do you often read books like that one?” Sullivan nodded at the Cornwell.
“Yes.” That was a deliberate lie, one concocted to get Pamela off the jury.
“Would you hold the book up so that everyone can see it?”
Pamela did. Her copy, a hardcover with a shiny dust, looked black and official.
“We won’t have to worry about a weak stomach with this one,” the judge muttered, even his soft words echoing throughout the courtroom.
“Do you watch CSI?” Sullivan asked.
“Sometimes,” Pamela said.
“Cold Case Files? The forensics programs on The Learning Channel?”
“Sometimes,” Pamela said.
“So you feel you have a grasp on the forensic side of police procedure?” Sullivan asked.
Pamela shrugged.
The judge said, “We’ll need a verbal response for the record, Ms. Jackson.”
“When you say ‘a grasp,’ I don’t know what that means,” Pamela said.
“Do you understand it?” Sullivan said.
“It’s just science,” Pamela said.
“And you understand science?”
Of course, you fool. I have more advanced degrees in biology and chemistry than you can dream up.
Pamela had to bite back the response. She wasn’t a scientist now. She owned a bookstore. She was a mousy woman with mousy clothes who tried to disappear when people looked at her.
“I try to understand it,” she said, which was as close to the truth as she could come.
“I have no problem with this juror,” the prosecutor said, and turned toward the defense attorney, Jake Chivara.
He was too slick for this part of Oregon. His suit had the shine of silk, and his hands were manicured. His black hair had a layered cut that cost more than Pamela’s entire outfit, but his eyes shone with an intelligence that she recognized as a match for her own.
He adjusted his suit coat as he walked toward the rail. “Do you consider murder your hobby?”
Her fingers clutched the book, its hard edges biting into her palm. “My hobby?”
He nodded toward the book she held. “You read about it. You watch television programs about it. You obviously think about it a lot.”
True enough. She didn’t like how perceptive he was. “I watch television programs about politics and biography and history, too, but I don’t consider them my hobbies. I live alone. I run a bookstore. I read almost everything that comes through the door.”
“But you brought that book for a reason, didn’t you?” Chivara asked.
“To read while I waited,” she said.
“You could have brought a romance novel,” he said.
She shrugged. “I would have finished it in the time allowed. I wanted something that would last me all day.”
“Be honest, Ms. Jackson. You brought that book so that we’d assume you know police procedure. You wanted to force us to kick you off the jury.”
She looked at him in surprise and knew, at that moment, she had been caught. She had never been caught before, at least, not in her manipulations. It was a strange sensation.
Chivara smiled at her. “I don’t like being manipulated, Ms. Jackson.”
Pamela’s hands slid on the book’s cover. She was sweating.
“Your questionnaire says you believe that some crimes should be punished by death,” Chivara said.
“Yes.” She swallowed hard. This was the first time, in all of the questioning, that someone had mentioned the questionnaire.
“Does that mean you believe in the death penalty?” he asked.
“I haven’t given it any thought.” At least not in that way. The law was the law and she had nothing do with it. She didn’t plan it nor could she change it. Human laws weren’t immutable like scientific ones, but they existed and nowadays she did her best to live within them.
“Do you have a problem sending a man to his death?” he asked.
“Not in the right circumstances.” Her answer had too much of an edge to it. She wished she could take the words back the moment she uttered them.
Chivara smiled again. “What sorts of circumstances, Ms. Jackson?”
Her mouth was dry. “I thought we were talking about the death penalty.”
“We are. What circumstances? These circumstances?”
“If he did it,” she said.
“Do you think he did it?” Chivara asked.
“I could care less,” she said, repeating her answer from the questionnaire.
“Really? You don’t care one way or another?”
She didn’t like this attorney. He was irritating her. “Unless you put me on this jury, this crime has no impact on my life. I don’t really care what that man did. I don’t really care what the President does either, and he has a lot larger impact on my life than some petty murderer.”
“Petty murderer,” Chivara repeated softly. “You’re quite interesting, Ms. Jackson. You know science and read about the law, but you say this case doesn’t concern you. If we put you on the jury, would you care then?”
“Not really,” she said. “I’d just be doing this because you’re making me.”
Chivara’s smile became broad. “At least you’re honest.”
He walked back to his table, examined his notes, and then leaned over the railing, clearly speaking to his jury consultant.
Pamela’s heart pounded hard. She tried to keep an impassive expression on her face, but she found it difficult. For the first time since she’d shown up in this courtroom, she was frightened.
After a moment, Chivara looked up.
“Ms. Jackson, do you know my client?” Chivara swept his arm toward the defendant. Until this moment, Pamela had refrained from looking at him.
She had seen his photograph on the county newspapers and once on the front page of the Oregonian, but she hadn’t really looked at him. Nor had she looked at him the one or two times he waited on her.
“We’ve never formally met,” she said.
“But you have met,” the attorney said.
“He waited on me once at the Sneaker Wave,” she said. “And at the Italian Noodle.”
“Did you have a conversation?”
She shrugged, then added for the record, “Probably not.”
“Probably not?” Chivara repeated.
“I go out alone with a book,” she said. “I usually don’t have conversations.”
Truthful again.
Chivara’s eyes narrowed, and she had the sense that he thought she was holding something back.
Chivara turned away, and she hoped he would dismiss her for cause. Instead, he said, “I have no problems with this juror.”
The judge turned to her. “Is there any reason you believe you should not sit on this jury?”
Dozens. She had dozens of reasons, but none she could admit to. Neither attorney had given her a way out.
“I don’t know if I can be impartial,” she said, “given that I’ve met him.”
The judge let out another of his gusty sighs. “The interactions you’ve had with the defendant are no different than sitting across a courtroom from him day in and day out. So give it a try, Ms. Jackson.”
“Your honor,” Chivara said, “this is why we wanted the trial moved.”
“You made that motion and I dismissed it,” the judge said. “If you want to try this case for the court of appeals and not for the jury, go ahead, Mr. Chivara. Otherwise, get over the loss and move on.”
Pamela’s cheeks were warm. Her ploy hadn’t worked, might even have backfired.
“Juror two-six-seven,” the judge said, “you’ll be sitting on this case.”
Since it was the off-season, the cut-rate hotel that the court used to sequester juries was happy to have them. The jurors even got to have their own rooms, a luxury for which Pamela was grateful. She didn’t like company in the best of circumstances, and this certainly was not the best of circumstances.
That first two days in the courtroom were difficult, especially for the other jurors. The prosecution laid out its case, and the defense gave its own theory of the crime. Most of the jurors were already familiar with the crime, but the details made them squeamish.
Pamela didn’t mind the details, but she had trouble wrapping her mind around the crime at all.
Apparently, the defendant, Raymond Northrup, arrived home one afternoon in a rage. He shot his wife, his two daughters, and his infant son, supposedly planning to kill himself as well. In the end, he chickened out (or “came to his senses,” as Prosecutor Sullivan said), and called 9-1-1 instead. The paramedics arrived to find a house filled with blood, and Ray Northrup sitting on the couch, watching reruns of The Simpsons as if nothing was wrong.
The prosecution promised pictures and the tape of the 9-1-1 call; the defense promised experts showing how the police botched the investigation, figuring that they already had the killer when, of course, the defense claimed, they had not.
Pamela listened with—she thought—clinical detachment, picturing both versions of the crime: a man pushed to his limits by bills, sick children and a nagging wife, hauling the shotgun out of the front closet and turning it on all of them; and the same man pushed to his limits, who arrived home after a hard day’s work as a waiter (he could get nothing else in this small town) to find his entire family slaughtered.
But the clinical detachment didn’t take, or perhaps it was a façade, designed to fool even herself. For that night, and two nights thereafter, Pamela had the nightmare, the one she had fled when she had come to Oregon.
The images were jumbled: Jason stumbling backwards, his hand up; Jason on the floor, his face gone; Jason’s blood staining the wall beside their stove. She started to grab things—her ring, his watch, their checkbook, and then she set them down.
She knew better—even her dreamself knew better—and instead, she took the cash from the drawer, and the bike leaning against the old Billingsly house next door.
More images from before: the water from the shower draining pink; her clothing in the wash machine, the smell of bleach in the air; the half-eaten ham sandwich that had started it all.
She had been clutching it, trying to force it down, when he had walked in. You can’t do anything right, she had said to him. I wanted hot mustard, not sweet. Don’t you ever listen?
His voice, meek and soft, infuriated her, and at that moment, she woke up, covered in sweat, shaking, uncertain where she was, figuring at first it was some anonymous hotel on the trip west, then remembering how she had gotten herself into this new predicament years after the fact.
The hotel looked the same as the others: a double-bed barely bigger than the single she’d had in her first apartment; end-tables so cheap that if she leaned on them, they’d crack; a television set bolted to the dresser, and a double-size window with a single pane of glass so thin that it could shatter with the pressure of a determined fist.
Pamela got up and paced, her feet cold against the worn carpet. She was glad she was alone—who knew what she had cried out, what she had actually said?
That first night, she didn’t go back to the bed, sleeping instead on the scratchy sofa, an equally scratchy blanket pulled over her scrunched-up form. She didn’t sleep much and when she did, she dreamed of being uncomfortable, not of the past.
And she returned to that couch after every day of difficult testimony, after every photograph and replaying of the 9-1-1 call, until the clinical detachment she thought she had achieved that first day became an actual reality.
She could listen, store facts, theories, and opinions in one side of her brain, and kept them separate from the other side.
The emotion side.
The side that had always given her too much trouble.
Three-plus weeks of testimony, arguments, breaks and confusion. Three-plus weeks of “retiring” to the jury room to wait while the lawyers and the judge worked something out. Three-plus weeks of small talk with people who probably never would have entered her store, people who probably hadn’t voluntarily picked up a book in their lives, people who—with the exception of the transplanted Californian—had never lived anywhere but here.
Small minds with nothing but television and the trial to occupy them. Talk of the trial was off-limits until the testimony was over, so the Small Minds discussed the previous night’s Frasier or the Buffy rerun or the late-night movie they were given on tape so they wouldn’t watch the local news and talk shows.
She didn’t watch any of it. She didn’t discuss any of it either, preferring to read. The guards—at least they felt like guards—let her assistant deliver books, sometimes four and five a day, and Pamela read rather than socialized. So long as her mind was busy, her body remained calm.
The guards would paw through the bags, of course, verifying that everything Pamela’s assistant brought were books, verifying that her assistant hadn’t hid a newspaper article about the trial as a bookmark, verifying that there was no note advising her how to vote at the end of the trial.
But no one looked at the titles either. She finished the Cornwell, moved onto a history of the fingerprint, then followed that with a history of the corpse. A few tomes on forensics, a study of ballistics, and of course, dozens and dozens of novels—all shapes and sizes.
She read and thought and listened, and wished she had known all of this years ago, before she had come west. She would have done things oh so very differently. How easy it would have been to make it seem like he had gotten angry over the sandwich, he had hit her repeatedly, he had grabbed the gun.
But she hadn’t known any of it. She had done the best she could with the little bits of knowledge she had, and she had managed to escape.
She lived here now, a new life she mostly enjoyed, and saw no use re-evaluating every second of the past.
Then, finally, the moment arrived. The closing arguments ended, the jury instructions were repeated ad nauseum, the defendant staring at jurors as if he were trying to fathom what each and every one of them were thinking.
This time, when they went into the jury room, there was a palpable sense of relief. The restrictions were off: they could discuss anything now, and the Small Minds all started to talk at once, offering opinions, offering advice, discussing what an ordeal they’d been through, how they couldn’t stand the pictures.
Pamela couldn’t stand the voices. Middle-class, grating, most of them with that slightly dulled speech she’d learned to recognize from locals. She sat in one of the upholstered chairs nearest the door, and wondered how she would get through this.
The jury room itself was small with two exits—one leading back into the courtroom, the other into the hallway. The room had no windows. Whoever had designed this room had certainly visited and obviously enjoyed the ambiance of hell’s anteroom, because even the temperature was correct: hot enough to make the already small space seem unbearably stuffy.
“Right, Ms. Jackson?”
She heard her name and looked up. The transplanted Californian was looking at her. He was a wiry blond with a scraggly mustache whose rope-thin body and denim shirt made him look like a man who belonged outdoors, not trapped in a room furnished with modular office chairs and a cheap fake-wood conference table.
“I’m sorry,” she said, peering at his name badge. Z. Wilson. She should have learned his name in the past few weeks. She should have learned all of their names, but of course, she hadn’t.
“I said, I think we should get around to electing a foreman first, then talk about the case. What do you think?” His blue eyes studied her with an openness she didn’t like. Obviously he expected her to be on his side.
“Looks like you’re already doing a fine job,” she said. “We don’t need a vote.”
“We’ll vote.” His voice had that irritated edge Jason used to get when she didn’t give him the answer he liked.
She leaned back in her chair, deciding to give Z. Wilson some distance.
The woman who wore the giant silver cross on the front of her blouse each and every day reached to the center of the table and took twelve little pieces of paper from a notepad. Then she grabbed pencils and handed them out as if she were a school teacher.
She gave Pamela her paper and pencil last, smiling at her. Pamela did not smile back.
“Perhaps,” said the Silver Cross, “perhaps we should say a small prayer so that God will guide our work.”
“A small prayer?” Pamela asked, unable to keep silent in the face of this new irritation. “What kind of guidance do you want? Dearest God, please let us know if you want this killer to go free or if you want the state to fry him. Amen.”
“Ms. Jackson,” said the Californian. “That’s enough.”
She shrugged and pressed her lips together, but she had made her point. Two of the Small Minds who hadn’t said anything yet—the first man chosen, and one of the other women—glared at Pamela as if she had killed the three children and the namby-pamby wife.
The wife, quite frankly, sounded like she deserved it, but the kids, well, Pamela didn’t believe in killing kids. Kids couldn’t be blamed for the situations they found themselves in. Only the parents were responsible for that.
“Write down the name of the person you think most suited for jury foreman,” the Californian said. “Then put your paper in this little bowl next to the notepad. Don’t sign your name.”
“Why don’t we just have a real election?” Pamela asked, clutching her pencil. “You and whoever else is enough of a control freak to want this idiot job?”
“You mean you?” another Small Mind asked.
“I don’t want it,” Pamela said.
“Vote for whomever you’d like,” the Californian said.
Pamela sighed and shook her head. Then she wrote down Z. Wilson: Because I believe in validating power grabs, folded the paper into tiny squares and set it in the bowl.
Hers was the sixth. One Small Mind—a twenty-something man who was already going bald—chewed his pencil and looked from person to person before writing on his paper. He was the eleventh to put his vote in the bowl. The Silver Cross lady was the last, and she looked spooked.
“Mr. Acenan,” the Californian said to yet another Small Mind, “would you mind reading the results? Mrs. Dunbar will tally them.”
The Dunbar woman took another sheet of paper from the stack and held her pencil poised. The man dug inside the bowl, removed a piece of paper and read the results aloud.
Pamela wished she could take the book out of her purse. Who would’ve thought that average citizens would take this job so very seriously?
The Small Mind reading the papers had finally gotten to Pamela’s. He glanced at her, his face flushed, and only read the name, not the commentary.
“You know,” Pamela said mildly, “censorship is against the law.”
“And you’re a disgrace,” the Small Mind said, still clutching her paper. “Can’t you be serious about this?”
She thought of answering him honestly, but she knew the word “no” would piss him off. So she said, “I just want to get down to business. I’ve already lost a month of my life to this mess. I don’t want to lose another one because you people dither.”
“An election isn’t dithering, Ms. Jackson,” the Californian said.
“You’ve already taken over,” Pamela said. “Why do we have to bother with the election?”
“Because,” the Californian said, “it’s part of the instructions. See? Item four. Elect a jury foreperson.”
“You said foreman before. Can I change my vote?” Pamela asked. “I didn’t consider any women.”
Someone made a sound of disgust. Mrs. Dunbar said loudly, “We already have a majority for Mr. Wilson. So he is our foreperson, unless there’s an objection.”
Pamela almost objected, just out of spite. She had to entertain herself somehow. But she was beginning to realize that her own antics might prolong this already painful situation, so she said nothing.
She crossed her arms and listened to Mr. California-Wilson read the jury instructions that the judge had already read to them, then ask if there were any questions that needed discussion or clarification before they got down to the “nitty-gritty.”
Everyone said no, except Pamela, of course, who really didn’t like the grade-school way this deliberation session was turning out. But she had decided to be quiet, and so she would be. She listened, or pretended to, while the jury discussed the rules, then reviewed the rules, and then discussed them even more.
Finally, at four o’clock, Mr. California-Wilson suggested that they take a preliminary vote—gosh! Just like the instructions suggested!—to see how far apart they all were. The vote would be anonymous, of course, and all the little pieces of paper would go into that damn bowl again.
She put her little piece of paper on top of her book, a novel called A Certain Justice which Pamela had chosen more out of irony than interest, and then paused.
She really hadn’t given the fate of Mr. Raymond Northrup much thought, although she had done her part. She had listened, without prejudice and with that hard-won clinical detachment, to days and days of repetitive testimony, to argumentative lawyers and bad judicial rulings, to witnesses who hadn’t known a damn thing and to witnesses who believed they had.
She had listened, she had absorbed, and she had come to no conclusion.
Yet they were asking her for one now. And if she was going to be the good citizen she was pretending to be, she had to give a real opinion. She supposed finding him guilty would get her out of here the quickest. After all, that was what the Small Minds seemed to believe, if their post-trial conversation was any indication.
But she couldn’t write guilty on her piece of paper. Her hand froze over the page every single time. She was stunned to discover that the decision really did matter to her.
After all, she could have been the person sitting next to Chivara. She could have been pacing some jail cell right now, wondering if 12 disparate people would sentence her to a lifetime of imprisonment. She owed Northrup as much consideration as she had, mostly because she hoped someone would give her the same consideration if (when?) her time came.
She bit her lower lip, then glanced up at the bowl. It looked full. A number of the Small Minds were staring at her again.
Her hand shook over the paper. She gripped the pencil tightly and wrote Not, leaving off the guilty. She didn’t want Mr. California-Wilson to misconstrue her intent.
She folded her piece of paper in half this time, just like everyone else had, and then she shoved it into the bowl. The Silver Cross woman grabbed it and handed it to California-Wilson as if he weren’t capable of grabbing it himself.
He nodded toward the Dunbar woman and she got out yet another piece of paper so that she could tally the results.
Pamela expected more than one not-guilty vote. After all, it was pretty obvious that Northrup didn’t have the balls to kill his entire family, no matter how angry and frustrated he got.
But she was the only not-guilty. California-Wilson tried not to ask for names, but she knew they’d find out, so she admitted it.
And that was when the clerk of the courts arrived, and told them to break for the night.
The next morning, the Small Minds had game plan ready. They were going to review the evidence to convince her.
“Don’t you want to know why I think he didn’t do it?” Pamela asked.
“It doesn’t matter what you think,” Silver Cross said. “You obviously didn’t care enough to listen.”
“I listened,” Pamela said. “I even made notes every evening. Did you people bother doing that?”
No one answered her. No one even looked at her.
“Look,” she said. “I could change my vote so that we could get the hell out of here. Lord knows, I don’t ever want to see you people again. But I don’t think this guy did it, and I’m not going to send him to jail just because I want to sleep in my own bed tonight.”
She was rather proud of herself. She sounded like a Real Citizen, like someone who cared about her fellow man.
“So,” Mr. California-Wilson said with a notable lack of interest, “why do you think he didn’t do it?”
“Because,” Pamela said, careful to keep her tone respectful and polite, “he didn’t run.”
“Most people know better than to run,” Wilson said.
“Most people know better than to kill their families,” one of the Small Minds muttered.
“What?” Mrs. Dunbar asked.
The man shrugged. “I’m just saying if you’re going to apply that kind of logic, then the whole case all falls apart.”
The Small Minds argued among themselves for a long time, apparently forgetting that Pamela was the one they had to convince to change her mind. For a while, she thought she had convinced a few of them, but no.
They simply liked arguing.
And another day went by without any progress at all.
The week blurred into a series of questions and answers, followed by arguments.
“Ms. Jackson,” someone asked at one point, “how can you think he didn’t do it? He was covered in blood.”
“So was the house,” she said. “Didn’t you look at the pictures? He sat on the couch, by his own admission. It was soaked in blood. Maybe he even hugged one of the kids like the defense attorney said. What would you do if you came home to your entire family dead?”
Of course, during the ensuing argument, she didn’t say that she wouldn’t have hugged a dead kid. But the arguments were never really about her, anyway.
“Ms. Jackson,” one of the Small Minds said long about day three, “he told everybody at work that he was on edge, that he felt like he was going to explode. It’s pretty clear that he did.”
“Hell,” she snapped. “I’m on edge. Does that mean I’m going to go on a rampage and kill you all to calm myself?”
It sounded tempting, but she knew better. She hadn’t hurt anyone—deliberately—since she washed her husband’s blood off her skin five years ago.
“Ms. Jackson,” the Silver Cross idiot said to her on day five, “who else could have killed that family? Nothing was stolen and no one else even knew them, so no one else had a reason to kill them.”
“You mean someone has a reason to kill an infant?” Pamela snapped. She ignored the wife. The wife bothered her. Pamela would have killed the wife given half a chance. Just because the woman hadn’t been happy with her reproductive choices and her husband’s inability to earn a living didn’t give her the right to whine all the damn time.
Like these people were doing. The room really had to be bigger, much bigger, so that Pamela could pace.
She was alone and remained alone on this not-guilty thing. Even when she convinced the entire jury to go back into the courtroom and listen to the read-back of some testimony about the way that Northrup was found. His voice on the 9-1-1 tape, filled with emotion (she knew from personal experience that after killing someone, the emotion drained away), and the way he sat on that couch—as one cop put it—like he had nothing left to live for.
Ten days. Ten days they argued and fought and screamed at each other. (She didn’t scream. She hated raised voices.) And they couldn’t make her change her mind.
Ten days and 3 hours. The lunch break was when Mr. California-Wilson, whom she’d taken to calling the remaining Beach Boy to his face because he irritated her, knocked on the court-side door, and told the clerk that the jury was hung.
Fascinating word, hung. Past tense of “hang,” an active but unhappy word which meant to suspend or to die by hanging or to deadlock. All of those meanings had a little murder in them.
Just a little.
She had committed a killing after all.
And like the one she had committed before, she hadn’t given it much thought until she actually completed the act. By then, the deed was done and she had to deal with it. It simply felt wrong to change her mind, as if she had lost a principle or something.
So when the judge polled the jurors—all of them, including her—and asked if there was any way to resolve the deadlock, she had spoken a forceful no.
The judge had no choice but to release the jury from its duty. The case was over, and the prosecutor had lost by one vote. The defense didn’t cheer, although Northrup had looked for someone—anyone—to hug and got no volunteers.
Pamela filed back into the jury room with the Small Minds, happy she would never see them again, collected her things, and left the courthouse.
She had to go to the hotel to pack, and then she would be able to go home. Packing took longer than she expected—she had lived in this dive for nearly two months—and when it was over, she found that she would actually miss the place.
She’d learned to sleep in the bed, finally feeling like the ghost of Jason and his hideous death were behind her. The nightmare, completely gone.
It was almost as if she had been on trial and had forgiven herself.
The drive from the hotel to Rickets Rock took her past the courthouse. The cameras and crowds were gone. The place looked almost deserted. She was nearly past it when she realized that she had left her book inside.
She almost thought of donating it, then changed her mind.
She had donated enough to this stupid cause already.
She parked in the lot, just like she had on that very first day, and went inside by the front door. The anteroom was empty except for one of the court employees, sitting behind a counter.
The employee looked up, and clearly didn’t recognize her. Pamela had taken off her juror button the moment they had been excused.
“May I help you?”
“I was on the Northrup jury,” Pamela said, “and I left a book in the jury room.”
The employee swiveled her chair, looked behind her, and reached down, lifting A Certain Justice. “This it?”
It was. Pamela had never summoned enough energy to read it. She thanked the woman, took the book, and turned.
“Ms. Jackson?”
The familiar voice sent a shiver through her. She looked over her shoulder. “Mr. Chivara. I thought you’d be off celebrating with your client.”
Chivara smiled. It wasn’t that predatory smile he used in court, but a rather wistful one. “I had a few things to get out of the courtroom. I see you did too.”
She nodded, tucked the book under her arm, and started to leave. He kept pace with her.
“I understand you’re the one who hung my jury,” he said.
“So?” she asked.
“So,” he said as he pushed open the door leading outside, “it surprised me.”
“I’m sure it didn’t, counselor,” she said. “You picked me for some reason and it wasn’t my good looks.”
He laughed. The sound echoed across the empty street. “That’s true. I thought you’d help my client, but not in this part of the case.”
She stopped. “What does that mean?”
“It means, Ms. Jackson, we found that you lied on your jury questionnaire.”
She felt cold. She knew better than to say anything. If she confirmed or denied, she would play right into his little game, whatever it was.
“And since we found that out, we figured we could use you as the basis for our appeal.”
“You planned an appeal?” she asked.
“Every good defense attorney keeps one eye on the current case, and one eye on appeal. You were my ace-in-the-hole.”
“I was your ace-in-the-hole when you picked me?”
“Now that wouldn’t be quite right, now would it?” This time he gave her the predatory smile. “Of course, no one can prove when we learned that you didn’t have a murdered uncle. Nor can they prove when we discovered that Pamela Jackson isn’t your real name.”
Her chill increased.
“Lying on a jury questionnaire is perjury, Ms. Jackson,” Chivara said, “and I’m an officer of the court. Technically, I can’t let you get away with that.”
She forced herself to breathe. Then she turned around. “I can’t say anything to you. You’re accusing me and doing it in a do-you-beat-your-wife fashion.”
“Am I?” he asked, his arms crossed.
“Besides,” she said because she had to, because she couldn’t keep silent, “if I did lie, and you discovered it, are you going to serve your client by reporting it? After all, I did hang your jury.”
Chivara studied her for a long moment. “If I were still prosecuting, I’d already have you for identity fraud, and perjury. If I keep digging, what else would I find?”
A trail of temper, which had ceased. She had found her own kind of peace here in Seavy County.
“I like fiction, Mr. Chivara,” she said. “We established that on the day of jury selection.”
“You like crime dramas, Ms. Jackson,” he said. “We never established that you liked only fiction.”
She remembered the feeling she’d had that first day in the courtroom—that he was the only worthy adversary she had ever found. He was as smart as she was, which was a problem.
“We never established what lengths you’ll go to in order to win a case,” she said softly. “Looks like we’ll learn that one today.”
Then she turned around and headed down the steps to her car, feeling his gaze on her back. She half-expected to hear his footsteps following her, to feel his hand grab her arm, to pull her back and take her into that courtroom.
She’d be the one going to jail, and then she’d be the one going to trial, defended by someone like Chivara. Just like she’d imagined.
Just like she’d feared for the past five years.
But Chivara didn’t follow her down the stairs. In fact, when she got into her car, and looked out the window, he was still watching her.
He had to choose between letting the client he had clearly thought guilty (after all, why else scheme for the appeal?) go free or letting a woman who had changed her identity and committed at least two small crimes that he knew of go free.
Poor Mr. Chivara. Such choices he had.
Such choices she had. Did she stay and pretend like nothing happened, trust the bastard to do what was in his best interest? Or did she run, again, losing all the money she’d put into her store and her home?
She clutched the key to her car. People who ran were guilty: she had argued that in the jury room, and her argument would come back to him. He’d know she’d done something.
But if she stayed, he’d have only his own conscious to wrestle with.
As a good defense attorney, he did that each and every day.
She put the key in the ignition and started the car. Chivara was still watching her.
She waved at him as she drove out of the parking lot.
Away from the courtroom and juries and the law.
Screw Chivara and his suspicions. She was going back to her store, her home and her life, her solitary life as a model citizen, a woman who did her duty and nothing more, just like everybody else.
____________________________________________
Jury Duty
Copyright © 2021 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Crimewave 8, 2005.Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2021 by WMG PublishingCover design by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Aleksandar Radovanovic/Dreamstime
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
All of our writing workshops on Teachable.com are 50% off for a little over 24 hours. Yep! You can get whatever workshop you want (out of hundreds) for half price. That includes items like bundles, which are already discounted.
If you want more information, click here. If you already know what you want to purchase, click here to go directly to Teachable where you can use the code GREATBUNDLE at checkout.
I hope you find something you really want.
Enjoy!
For a long time, we’ve been trying to figure out how to bring new writers into our online writing workshops. Over the years, we’ve put together almost a thousand workshops. Many (most) are geared toward already established writers who want to improve their craft. But a lot of them are good for beginners as well.
Finally Dean Wesley Smith got the bright idea to put them into bundles by topic. There are so many…and they’re all 50% off right now. I’m going to copy one of his posts here:
Any bundle is 50% off on Teachable. And we are still adding in new bundles to focus on certain topics We have six now with more coming soon.
To get a bundle at half price, simply go to WMG Teachable, find the bundle or bundles you want, and hit purchase. Then put in the code…
GREATBUNDLE
And hit apply and you will have it for 50% off. And most bundles are really good deals to start with.
We are doing this because we are launching the FOCUS BUNDLE series.
But first let me list the large bundles, the ones we call Lifetime Subscriptions (yes, they are all 50% off as well.)
We have a lot of other great bundles that are on sale… They include…
There are also some other bundles on sale, but the genre bundles for mystery, science fiction, and fantasy are not all recorded yet and are delayed into the summer. But you can grab them on sale if you don’t mind waiting.
NEW FOCUS BUNDLESWe have six of them up with seven classes per bundle on focused topics.
Topics to Include… + Depth (How to open a story… all the different courses) AVAILABLE + Learn Beyond Basic Depth AVAILABLE + Productivity… AVAILABLE + Basic Writing Business… AVAILABLE + Writing Science Fiction… AVAILABLE + Focus on Characterization… AVAILABLE + Writing Mystery + Writing Fantasy + Licensing + Writing Attitude + General Writing Techniques + Writing Short Fiction + Promotion the Right Way*
Anyone else have suggestions for bundles combining different classes, pop-ups, and lectures, let me know by email or in the comments. Again, no bundles will be in these FOCUS BUNDLES and they will not be in any LIFETIME SUBSCRIPTIONS… Why? Because if you have the Everything Lifetime, you have these already and can use the bundle for a guide. All of them will be a mix of regular classes, workshops, pop-ups, and lectures.
Sale will last until I get all these FOCUS BUNDLES up, so don’t want too long.
To get a bundle at half price, simply go to WMG Teachable, find the bundle or bundles you want, and hit purchase. Then put in the code…
GREATBUNDLE
And hit apply and you will have it for 50% off. And most bundles are really good deals to start with.
Write Dean directly at Dean dot wmgworkshops at gmail for more information.
…you know what I mean. (That Reese’s ad has a lot to answer for. Just sayin’)
Anyway. I curated a Storybundle that features Fantasy and Steampunk together, for the second time. (We did one last year.) It’s in honor of my Qavnerian Protectorate series, which is a side series of the Fey. I have an exclusive book in this bundle: The ebook for Barkson’s Journey, which is in the series, but does standalone. (You can start here, in other words.)
This is a great way to get the book early, because you’ll get it with nine other ebooks. And those ebooks will really augment your summer reading list. You’ll find steampunk from favorites like Gail Carriger, Colleen Gleason, and Christine Pope, as well as books from new favorites like Kari Kilgore and Michael Warren Lucas. There are also short stories, in three different volumes. A collection from J. Daniel Sawyer, and two different anthologies. The first from Patricia Bray and Joshua Palmatier takes steampunk to a whole new level (adding aliens!) and then our own Fiction River steampunk volume with more of your favorite authors.
We are also giving you the opportunity to support one of my favorite charities, Girls on the Run. It helps young girls all over the country gain confidence in their bodies. Girls on the Run trains girls from grades three to eight to run, yes, but also to believe in themselves. I like to think that it teaches girls how to be like the heroines in their favorite books. If you want to see what they do, click here.
And if you want the Storybundle (and I hope you do!) please click here. You have a little over a week to get this great deal.
Before the pandemic, we did an Anthology Workshop in person every year. The last one was in February of 2020. Yeah, you all know what that means.
We decided to return to the Anthology Workshop this year. They take a lot of work to set up and get underway. This year’s will happen in August, and it is…sadly…closed. The next one will be in two years, because the workshops are harder to organize in Las Vegas than they were on the Oregon Coast (we miss you, Kip!) and we want to make sure all of the anthologies are published before we do the next one. We have six anthologies this year, and they will all be part of the rebrand of Fiction River. (Yes, it’s coming back!)
This year, we added a feature called “Prepare Ahead,” which is for the writers who are attending. They get a workshop for free that explains the genre and has an interview with the editor or editors about what they want to see from the writers. (And what they don’t want to see.)
We decided to open the Prepare Ahead classes to anyone who wanted to take them (and maybe submit a story). Initially, we sold them as a bundle, but we only have two classes left. One of them starts tonight. (Yes, I’m late, as usual.) And it’s my second anthology, the Science Fiction Mystery anthology. I’m so excited about this. I love science fiction mystery. I can’t wait to read the stories. I suspect my excitement translated into my video…and will translate into the class.
Anyway, if you’re at all interested, here’s a link to the class. I think you’ll have a lot of fun with it!
But hurry! The class starts tonight!
When Detective Webster Coninck arrives at the murder scene outside Tups Tavern, he quickly identifies the body: Tom Johanssen. Former classmate, full of charisma, and a man with enough enemies to line up interviews into next week.
Webb finds himself off the case because of his personal history with Johanssen, but Webb believes his local knowledge holds the key to solving the case. But only if he can face his own painful history.
Chosen as one of the best American mystery stories of 2011.
“Local Knowledge,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Local KnowledgeBy Kristine Kathryn RuschThe call came in at 11:54 a.m., December 15, 1995. Body found at Tups Tavern, 35 East 35th street. Webb thought the call routine until he arrived.
Tups, frequented by sailors and longshoremen, was on the lakefront. Superior glistened, never freezing over, never covered with snow. But not pretty either, not in this part of town. In this part of town, the massive lake was dark and dirty, not sky blue like it was everywhere else.
Drug deals went down nearby and the local hookers worked dockside. Knifings were common. But this victim hadn’t been knifed.
He’d been shot.
Patrols had followed procedure. Two squads, parked at an angle on the broken concrete parking lot, colored the tavern’s gray walls red, blue, red, blue. Barflies stood near the open gunmetal doors, drinks in hand, coats draped over their shoulders to protect them against the cold.
They watched Webb as if he were one of them.
Which, in a way, he was.
He slipped between the dented bumpers, thankful he still fit in small places. Fifty crunches, one-armed push-ups, a half-hour run around the football field, all required before he allowed himself to hug a bar stool and drink until his tongue was numb. He always said the exercise let his body perform his job, and the booze kept his mind from dwelling on it.
But he wondered sometimes, especially when he saw himself reflected in those shabby tattered people whose drinks were more important to them than the life drained on the concrete.
He didn’t acknowledge them. Instead, he stopped beside the squads and memorized the scene.
Body belonged to a tall middle-aged man, lambswool coat—too rich for this part of town—exit wound a bloody mess in his back. Shoes shiny Italian leather, almost no scuff marks on the soles, dirt caking the right toe and the left heel. Right hand outstretched, slightly sun-wrinkled, white, with a gold ring, large ruby in the center. Salt-and-pepper hair, neatly trimmed, no strands out of place. Face pressed against the ice- and sand-covered concrete, features not visible from above.
Daylight was thin under a thick layer of clouds. Coroner would have to work in artificial light. Webb slipped on a pair of surgical gloves, crouched, and touched the back of the outstretched wrist.
Still warm. Webb glanced up, saw bloodstained holes in the pile of ice-covered snow plowed to the edge of parking lot.
“Anyone know him?” he asked, as he crouched lower, and peered at the man’s face. Then he realized he didn’t need to ask.
He knew the man. Tom Johanssen, returning home, after thirty-three years.
Tom Johanssen. The first time Webb had seen him, they’d been in high school. Webb was the gangly new kid from Louisiana—a whole country and half a culture away from Northern Wisconsin. Tom was all black hair and smiles, broad shoulders, chiseled features, and smarter than anyone else. Only he didn’t flaunt it, just like he didn’t flaunt the girls. Boys liked him too, wanted to be in his shadow, and that was the first time, maybe the only time, Webb had ever experienced—had ever fallen under the spell of—true charisma.
Then Tom shattered it all, the entire brilliant future, the golden dreams, by getting Jenna Hastings pregnant. Two days after graduation, they married, and Webb saw Tom only occasionally: buying groceries at the Red Owl; or riding home from work in the big yellow electric company truck. Webb went to college and Tom stayed behind, and it wasn’t until five years later that Tom surfaced again, playing lead in a local country band.
Webb had gone to see the band just after he graduated from Mankato State and just before he entered the police academy. Tom stood center stage, black hair curling over his forehead, guitar slung across his shoulder. Girls crowded him as if he were Elvis, and Jenna was nowhere to be seen. Webb had watched mesmerized, and had wondered then if Tom was divorced.
But the divorce came after the scandal, leaving Jenna with four boys and Tom with another mistake on his record. He joined the service, and went to Germany. Married again, became successful, and sent his folks piles of money. Year after year, he promised to come home, the prodigal son, now back in favor.
He never did come home. Not for his grandmother’s funeral or his grandfather’s. His sister’s wedding or his son’s.
He never came home.
Until now.
“I’m taking you off the case.” Bernard was hunched over his desk, beefy arms covering two separate piles of papers. He was staring at the file in front of him as if his next words were written on it.
Webb leaned against the door, arms crossed. Despite the stuffy heat of Bernard’s office, Webb still felt a chill, as if the cold from the death scene had got deep into his bones. “I can be objective.”
“Like hell.” Bernard caught a thin strand of hair and twirled it over his bald spot. “You went to high school with him. Florence—”
“I went to high school with him, Ethan went to high school with him, and Mike Conner is Jenna’s brother-in-law. Stanton’s kid married Tom’s kids’ half sister—and Pete flew Tom out of town in sixty-two. Everybody in this town is connected to Tom somehow. You lived next door to him for six years.” Webb’s hands, hidden beneath his arms, were clenched into fists. He didn’t know why he was fighting for this one so hard.
“I know,” Bernard said. “That’s why I want to give this one to Darcy.”
“Darcy?” Webb tilted his head back so his crown hit the wood. Bernard was watching him, tiny blue eyes lost in his florid face.
Webb had trouble arguing this one. He’d fought for Darcy Danvers. No one had wanted to hire a woman cop, let alone a woman cop from out of town. She’d come in with more ribbons than anyone, more experience with real crime. She was athletic and tough, smartest woman he’d ever met—hell, smartest anyone he’d ever met—and a real street fighter.
“She doesn’t know this town,” he said, trying not to wince. That had been Bernard’s argument against hiring her, the city’s argument against keeping her, and the basis of Webb’s defense of her five years back.
“She knows it good enough,” Bernard said. “She’ll follow through where the rest of us won’t.”
“I’d follow through,” Webb said.
“Even on Flo?”
Webb closed his eyes, his sister’s face rising before him, not as it was now, but as it had been that night long ago, puffy, tear-streaked, miserable.
“Even on Flo,” he said.
But he didn’t get a chance. Bernard took him off the case anyway. Webb staggered out of the office, short of breath and dizzy. Too many emotional shocks. First Johanssen, dead, then losing the case. It should have been his. It had to be his, to make up for thirty-three years.
Darcy was standing at her desk, a file of ancient clippings open in her hands. At forty, she was teenager-skinny, her arms long corded muscle, her breasts nearly flat against a trim torso. Her brown hair was cut short, above her ears, and the lines on her face were only visible up close. From a distance, she looked like a fifteen-year-old boy.
“I want to help you,” he said.
“No dice.” Her voice was cigarette-gravel. Two packs a day, filterless. Cigarettes for her, booze for him. Somehow they made it through the long, cold winters. “Bernard took you off this case.”
“You’ll need a local guide.”
“I can find one.”
“Maybe,” he said. “You don’t know what Johanssen did.”
She closed the file. “Dumped his wife and four kids for a sixteen-year-old groupie who claimed she was nineteen. Took her to Germany, married her without getting a divorce. Second marriage still might not be legal.”
“Surface stuff.” He took the file from her, glanced down.
It was from another case, a knifing at the same bar, in sixty-two. He tossed the file on the desk.
“There’s always knifings at Tups,” he said.
“When Tom Johanssen’s band was playing?”
“Nobody plays at Tups. Tom Johanssen’s band was drinking. Johanssen and Cindy Waters were already on an airplane for Minneapolis.”
“How’d you know?”
“Local knowledge,” he said. “Still think you don’t need me?”
Darcy studied him. Her left eye was gray, her right eye green, a fact that had always intrigued him.
“So,” she said slowly. “Where were you when Johanssen got shot?”
“Got a TOD yet?”
“About ten-thirty, give or take. Coroner’s not in yet.”
Webb shrugged. “In my car. Listening to the scanner and thinking about lunch.”
“Alone?”
“In this town, detectives don’t have to partner.”
She frowned at him. He once told her she was the only partner he wanted. “Can anyone give you an alibi?”
“Does anyone need to?”
The room had gone silent around them. Maybe he’d raised his voice. He didn’t know.
“It might help,” she said, picking up the file he’d tossed. “Word has it Johanssen screwed your sister.”
“Got that wrong,” Webb said. “He didn’t just screw my sister. He destroyed her.”
Webb’s sister Florence wasn’t pretty. She’d never been pretty, not even as a little girl, but she’d been close. The wrong kind of close. Her features, taken separately, were perfect: oval eyes, long narrow nose with just a hint of an upturn, high cheekbones, and bow-shaped lips. Put together, they looked like she’d been colored by a child with a crayon too fat for the child’s hand.
But what made it worse was that she wanted to be pretty. More than she wanted anything else.
She almost achieved it with Johanssen. She’d been twenty-one then, trim, with hair so black it shone blue in the sunlight. Her smiles had come from her heart and she walked with a lightness she would never have again.
Webb used to think she had finally grown into her body until he stumbled on Johanssen, shoeless and shirtless in Flo’s bedroom on the middle of a Thursday afternoon. Flo had been in the bathroom. Webb could hear the water running.
Johanssen had grinned, hair tousled, cheeks still flushed, the sheets smelling of sex. Your sister’s one hell of a woman, he’d said.
Webb had squeezed his fists tight, held them against his sides, not sure he wanted to fight in his parents’ home. You’ve got one hell of a woman at your place.
Not for much longer, Johanssen’d said as he slipped on his shirt.
That what you’re telling Flo?
Yep.
It’d better be true, Webb had said, or I’ll be coming after you.
I’m sure you will. Then Johanssen had grabbed his shoes, and slipped out the window, as if he’d done it a thousand times before. And he probably had.
The conversation had echoed in Webb’s mind for years afterwards. The beauty of it was that Johanssen had never lied. He’d never promised that he’d take Flo with him when he left. At least not to Webb. And probably not to Flo.
But Johanssen’s strange honesty couldn’t excuse what he finally did do. He’d chosen Flo because she was needy, and she’d fallen for him so deep that she’d never love anyone again. That would have been enough for Webb, enough to keep Webb searching for Johanssen all those years, but there was more.
Johanssen’d chosen Flo because of her college money. She’d won two science prizes her last year of high school, the only girl in the state to do so at that time, and she’d gotten three grand in awards. That, plus a thousand inheritance from a dead aunt, and savings from four years of full-time work while living at home, brought Flo’s savings account to well over $5,000.
In 1962, with that much money, a man could buy a house.
Or go a long way toward disappearing forever.
On the afternoon he left, Johanssen slept with Flo for the last time. Then he’d convinced her to go to the bank, take out all her money and give it to him. He’d buy plane tickets with it, he said, start a new life far away from here, with a new wife. He just never said who that new wife would be. And while Johanssen’s band was getting drunk at Tups Tavern, Flo had sat in her parents’ living room, in her very best dress, looking as pretty as she would ever get, waiting for a knock that never came.
She’d refused to press charges, said it was her fault, and didn’t change her mind no matter how much her family pushed. She kept her job, never tried college, never moved out of the house, and never fell in love again. And whatever chance she had at pretty died that night, along with her heart.
Sometimes Webb thought it was all his fault. He should have beaten up Johanssen in Flo’s bedroom and chased the bastard out of her life.
But he hadn’t. And that was something thirty years of police work could never change.
One missed moment, one bad call, had ruined his sister’s life.
Forever.
Flo still lived in their parents’ house. It was a three-bedroom starter home, built post-war, and had a little over 1,000 square feet counting the basement. Their parents had been dead ten years and Flo had yet to buy her own furniture. She still slept in the same room that she’d had all her life.
Webb walked in without knocking. He shut off the television, like he always did, and crossed the empty living room into the kitchen. His sister sat at the wobbly metal table, slapping cards on the faded yellow surface, a cup of cold coffee at her side.
“You’ve heard,” he said.
“Every asshole in town’s called me,” she said, without looking up. “Thinking I’d be pleased.”
“Are you?”
“I don’t know yet.” Her hands were shaking. He didn’t know if that was from the caffeine, the news, or both. He always suspected that she’d harbored a hope about Tom Johanssen, a hope that Johanssen would come back for her, that he’d made a mistake.
Webb went to the counter, grabbed the pot off her Mr. Coffee, and poured the remaining coffee into the sink. Then he tossed out the grounds. The garbage below the sink was overflowing. He’d have to take it out before he left.
He made a new pot of coffee, grabbed a chocolate from the basket on the sideboard, and took his normal seat at the table. Behind him, the Mr. Coffee wheezed. It was at least fifteen years old.
Flo set her cards down and studied her hands. They were so thin that he could see the bones. Her skin was a sallow yellow—she never got any sun—and he doubted that she ate more than enough to keep herself alive.
“What was he doing here?” she asked.
“I don’t know.”
“How long had he been here?”
“I don’t know that either.”
“Don’t know or won’t say, Webster?” Her voice cracked as she spoke, taking some of the force from it. The force, but not the pain.
“Don’t know.” He ran a hand through his thinning hair. He’d been so worried about her that he hadn’t learned the basic facts. A mistake he had never made before. Maybe Bernard had been right.
Maybe Webb didn’t belong on the case.
“You always know.” She got up, poured the coffee out of her cup, and then stuck her cup between the dripping coffee and the pot.
“They don’t want me on this case.” His voice was low.
She spilled, cursed, and ripped off a paper towel. Then she paused, leaning over the sink. “Because of me?”
He debated not telling her, but that wasn’t fair. Then she’d think he was lying about what he knew.
“Yeah,” he said, staring at her cards. Frayed edges, chocolate stains on the back. She played solitaire a lot. “Because of you.”
She didn’t move. “It shouldn’t make a difference, should it, Webster? Thirty-three years ago? That shouldn’t affect now, should it?”
“I don’t know,” he said, pushing away from his mother’s kitchen table. “You tell me.”
Options. Choices. The facts Webb knew about Tom Johanssen ended about 1970. He’d left a half second before the scandal broke, joined the army, flew Cindy Waters to West Germany, and married her there. After he got out of the military, he’d moved to some wide-open western state, Montana, Idaho, Wyoming, or Utah, and worked for some computer firm. There were rumors of continued scandalous behavior, from affairs to drug abuse to corporate raiding. He made a fortune. Enough for two houses of his own. He paid off his parents’ and his grandparents’ mortgages, had two more children, flew his older children to Montana-Idaho-Wyoming-Utah once every few years for skiing and the obligatory parental visit.
And not once did he return.
Not once.
Until now.
That was where Webb’s investigation had to start. At Johanssen’s decision to return to the land of his sins. Never mind that Webb was off the case. Darcy’d still be digging up graves by the time he had answers to the more pressing question.
The secret wasn’t in who Johanssen had hurt. Webb suspected that the list probably extended well beyond Midwesterners. The secret lay in what had made him change enough to come home.
If Webb found that, he’d find the killer.
He knew that much as well as he knew his own sister’s name.
He had to work fast. Once Bernard caught him, he was out of time, probably with a suspension, badge and gun turned in for good measure. So he laid the attack like a well-planned military maneuver. People first, machines second.
Johanssen’s parents still lived on the corner of Maple and Pine in a red-and-white clapboard house that had seemed bigger when Webb was a kid. He had only been to the house a few times, the most memorable a class picnic at the end of his junior year. The house had seemed wrong, even then. Johanssen was too glamorous, too intelligent to come from a house that had no books on the walls, and which had yellow and brown slipcovers all over the furniture. His parents, Gladys and Phil, were so firmly working class that Webb had trouble associating them with their son. As the picnic wore on that bright sunny afternoon, it soon became clear that Johanssen had done the planning, the cooking, and the cleaning to make it all happen. Webb had felt a stab of pity. His own parents would have helped even if they didn’t believe in a project, but it was obvious that Johanssen’s wouldn’t.
Webb grabbed his badge before he got out of the car. He didn’t like rooting this deep into his own past. He didn’t like the memories and the way they made him feel, as if he were smaller than he really was. In life Johanssen had made him feel that way; he seemed to do the same in death.
The sidewalk leading to the front door was cracked and broken. The concrete steps showed the signs of harsh winter. A fake grass welcome mat that dated from the sixties sat soggily near the stoop. Webb was careful not to step on it as he knocked.
The yellow curtain covering the window nearest the door moved slightly. Then voices echoed, and finally the door opened. The hunched old man staring through the screen was barely recognizable as Phil Johanssen.
“Mr. Johanssen,” Webb said, holding up his badge. “I’m Detective Webster Coninck. I’ve come to talk to you about your son.”
“No need to be formal, Webb,” Phil Johanssen said, as he pushed open the screen. “I remember you just fine. Sorry to hear about your folks. Gladys always sent a card.”
“I know,” Webb said. “Flo and I appreciated it.”
Flo had gasped each time she saw the word “Johanssen” on the envelope. She had hoped that the cards had come from Tom.
Webb slipped inside. The house smelled of mothballs, liniment, and fried foods. Phil Johanssen still wore his slippers. His blue pants hung on him, and his red-and-black plaid shirt dated from the late seventies.
Gladys stood in the door to the kitchen. She looked much the same, only faded, as if she had been in the sun too long and it had leached the color from her. Her hair, once the exact shade as Tom’s, was now laced with gray, and the wrinkles on her face had the effect of dulling it.
“Webster,” she said, and her strong alto took him back to his teenage years quicker than anything else ever could. “I was hoping you’d come.”
“Mrs. Johanssen,” he said. “I’m so sorry about Tom.”
She made a small snort and took his hand. Her grip was surprisingly firm. “Come into the kitchen. I haven’t had a boy at my table in too long.”
The kitchen had been remodeled. It had a window over the sink, and oak cabinets that still gave off a faintly new scent. The countertops were a shiny ceramic, and the stove, refrigerator, and dishwasher were matching white. The table, covered with a vinyl tablecloth, sat against a bay window opening into the backyard. Plants littered the large sill. On the walls around them, Gladys’s spoon collection alternated with Phil’s pipe collection.
That was the smell Webb missed, the faint odor of pipe smoke clinging to everything.
“He gave smoking up for his health,” Gladys said, following Webb’s gaze. “But he couldn’t give up the pipes.”
She sat down beneath the spoon collection. Phil sat in front of the bay window. Webb sat across from her. The chair was covered with a crocheted cushion that didn’t fit his body.
“Has anyone else spoken to you?” he asked, careful to keep his voice gentle.
“Just the boys who came to tell us the news,” Phil said.
“Like on the TV,” Gladys added. Her hands rested on the vinyl cloth, fingers laced together. Her knuckles were white from the tightness of her grip.
So Darcy hadn’t been there yet. She would arrive soon.
“So,” Webb said, “when did Tom tell you he’d be coming home?”
“Didn’t know until them cops showed up,” Phil said. “You’d think the boy would call if he was coming home after thirty-three years.”
“So you had no idea he was coming?”
“I did.” Gladys had her head down, her hands pressed so tight that they were turning red. “He called two days ago. Said he’d be here tonight. I didn’t say nothing because I thought he wouldn’t come. Like all them other times.”
“Dammit, woman.” Phil shoved his chair back. “You could have said something.”
“The disappointment—”
“Wouldn’ta killed me.” He got up, bowed in an odd, formal way to Webb, then left the room.
Gladys’s lower lip trembled. She brought her head up. Webb was sorry for thinking that they hadn’t cared about Tom’s death. They had been trying to put a good face on it.
For company.
“It would have hurt him something awful, Webb. The last time Tom didn’t show, Phil went to bed for a week. Didn’t want to do that to him this time.”
“Have there been other times when Tom said he’d be here and then never shown?”
She nodded, grabbed a tissue from her sleeve and dabbed at her nose. “Every three years like clockwork. He never made it. Not once. And he always felt so bad after that he’d pay to take us out there. But it ain’t the same as coming home.”
“No, Ma’am, it isn’t.”
“I don’t know why he hated it so bad. It was like the town burned him and he couldn’t face it again. I kept telling him that folks’d forgiven him, but he didn’t seem to hear. He was a good boy, Webb. You know that.”
“He made quite an impression on me,” Webb said.
Gladys studied her hands. Her thumbs worked against each other as if she were rubbing pain out of them. “I’m sorry about Florence,” she said, her voice a whisper.
He opened his mouth, closed it, unsure what to say. He almost said that it didn’t matter, but it did matter. Tom had ruined his sister’s life.
“You tell her that money’s still here. I got it in an account for her. Remind her.”
Webb went rigid. The room spun and he realized he hadn’t taken a breath. Gladys looked up, the lines in her face deeper somehow, and he made himself breathe. He couldn’t hide his surprise.
“You—?”
But Gladys didn’t answer. She pushed her chair away from the table, stood, and walked to the sink. She grabbed a glass from the sideboard and filled it with water. Her reflection in the window was wavy and indistinct.
“He was a good boy, my Tom,” she said. “He just forgot sometimes that things have consequences. Like never coming home. His kids would’ve liked him here, you know? At a game maybe or that play Donnie was in. It’d meant a lot.” She took a sip. “Guess it don’t matter now.”
“Who killed him, Mrs. Johanssen?”
“That’s the question isn’t it?” She set her glass down, but she didn’t turn around. “Not sure I want to find out the answer.”
Neither was he. But fear had wrapped itself around his heart, and he had learned long ago to face that fear, to stand it down as if it were a charging dog or rampaging drunk.
He was on this path. Nothing, not even his own fear, would make him leave.
The Johanssens had offered to repay Flo her $5,000, and she had never taken them up on it. They had it in an account in her name, had since 1971.
When Tom sent them the money to pay off their own mortgage.
Webb didn’t want to think about how much money was there, what kind of life Flo could have had if she’d only tried.
He drove away from the Johanssens’ sick and shaking and wishing for a drink.
Instead he turned onto Hill, drove past the high school, past the duplexes owned by John Johanssen, and stopped at a crudely constructed A-frame on what looked like a vacant lot bordering John Johanssen’s property.
Three brothers. Tom, John, and Scott. Scott Johanssen was the youngest, Vietnam vet, five children and no job.
The yard was a mixture of snow and dirt. Toys, half buried in the muck, were colorful reflections in the glare of a powerful porch light. Webb got out of the car, and trudged on the unshoveled path. It was icy and awkward with tramped footprints. Voices echoed from inside the house. Sharp voices, male and female, that cut off abruptly when he knocked.
There was no screen. When the unpainted door eased open, the scents of dirty diapers and dryer lint floated to him on a bed of warm air. A woman stood behind the door, her body thick with the aftermath of a pregnancy, her blouse stained with milk. The toddler in her arms was kicking her in a vain attempt to get down.
“Scott Johanssen, please,” Webb said.
“You a cop?” she asked.
He nodded, reaching for his badge. But she didn’t wait. She stood aside and yelled, “Dad, another one!” as she let Webb inside.
He stepped into a kitchen filled with old dishes and an overflowing diaper pail. In the center of the room, a weather-scarred picnic table stood, covered with crumbs and an overturned child’s juice glass.
“Through there,” she said, waving a hand at the A-shaped doorway.
He followed the trail of baby clothes and toys until he reached shag carpeting that might have been brown and might have been orange. This room smelled no better than the other. The furniture was old and brown, the upholstery torn. A TV was crammed against the unfinished wall, a red “mute” across Dan Rather’s face.
Scott Johanssen was crammed into a Barcalounger that sagged under his weight. The footrest tilted, obviously broken. Scott was balding but still baby-faced, his round features a fatter, younger version of Phil’s.
“Webster Coninck. Why the hell they got you on the case?”
“Dad,” the woman said from the doorway.
Scott shrugged, and slapped the remote on a cup-strewn metal table. “Fair question when you remember that Webster here vowed undying hate on my brother thirty-some years ago.”
“I came to offer condolences, Scott.”
“Yeah, and monkeys’ll fly out of my ass.”
“Dad,” the woman said. “The children….”
“It’s my house, Cheri,” Scott said. “You don’t like how I talk, you and them kids can go back to that asshole husband of yours.”
“I’m sorry,” she said to Webb, and then disappeared into the kitchen.
Scott peered up at him. “Condolences my ass,” he said. “You want to know if I killed him.”
“Did you?”
“Should have, for all the times he left Mom and Dad hanging. And them kids. They worship him, you know, and he didn’t even have the time of day for ’em. Not even when he flew ’em to Utah. He’d let that slut of his take ’em places, and then he’d show up maybe for supper, maybe for one day of skiing, and that’s all they’d talk about. Me and John, we were always there for ’em, but we were never enough. I was a fat bum, and John was too slick. Their dad was perfect because he was mostly a figment of their imaginations. That’s what Tom was good at. Making up lies about himself that other people’d believe.”
“What kind of lies?” Webb asked, figuring he’d let Scott talk if that was what Scott wanted.
Scott snorted, slid one finger forward and shut off the TV. A whine that Webb hadn’t been consciously aware of disappeared. “Lies? You mean like that corporate job that made so damn much money? I called him at work lotsa times, always got him direct. Then I lost the number, called information, and got the receptionist. She said she’d never heard of him. I got—” he grinned “—well, lessay I can be a mean s.o.b. when I wanna, and she put me through to personnel. Said they had a Tom Johanssen in their records. He’d been there and left years ago. That was in 1979, and when I’d ask him about it, Tom’d just laugh and say, ‘Scott, there’s business and then there’s business.’ As if I didn’t know that. Every grunt ever lived knows that. Just didn’t want to hear my brother saying it, you know?”
Webb wasn’t sure he did know. He shifted. His feet had left a fresh snow-mud trail on the flattened carpet. “You ever see him on those trips back here?”
Scott narrowed his eyes. “How’d you know about them?”
Webb shrugged. “Amazing what you hear when you’re listening.”
Scott pushed back on the arms of the chair. The back of the Barcalounger hit the wall.
“I was still drinking,” he said. “So it had to be ’88, ’89, down to Tups. I had just come from Ma’s and she was in a fine fix because she thought Tom was coming home. But he never showed. He was good at that too. So I wander into Tups and take my usual spot when who do I see through that stupid glass bead curtain Tup used to have but my brother in one of his fancy suits, talking to some fat asshole I’ve never seen before or since.”
“What happened?” Webb asked.
“I was drinking.” Scott picked up the remote, tapped its end against the metal, making a sound like a brush on a snare drum. “So I wasn’t thinking, you know? I shouted his name and stumbled back there and by then him and his buddies are gone.”
“You sure it was Tom?”
“I was drinking,” Scott said. “I wasn’t drunk. Besides, he sent me cash money to apologize for being a jerk and asked me not to tell Ma. Told Dad, though. Big mistake. He tried to find Tom, and when he couldn’t, he spent near a year in Tups, hoping he’d come back. He never did. Then Tom flew ’em all out on one of them Utah ski trips, and when Dad come home, he didn’t want to talk about it any more.”
“You know what Tom was doing here?”
“Nope, and I’m sure Dad don’t neither. Like I said, Tom was good at making you think one thing when he was doing another.”
Webb knew that. He knew that very well. “So what do you think happened to Tom?”
“I think somebody finally got tired of all the lies and used a bullet to shut him up.”
“Any idea who that somebody was?”
“Nope.” Scott stopped tapping the remote, and pushed a button. The TV flicked on, so loud that Webb jumped. “I’m sure you’re not hurting for suspects though.”
The winter darkness that Webb hated had settled by the time he left. The sky was black—no stars, only clouds—and the streetlights made the snow seem white. Black and white with no gray. Not even the world had room for nuance any more.
John Johanssen lived out near Jenna Hastings Johanssen Conner. John’s house was a 3,500-square-foot mock Tudor. It stood on a hill with a view of the river valley, the rolling land, the copper water tracing its way to Taconite County. John owned fifteen acres here, and half the town besides. His rents were sky-high and his reputation nasty. But his buildings were never empty, and if Tom hadn’t become such a legend, John would have gotten credit for being the rich Johanssen brother.
John’s wide, winding driveway had a square snow blower-built wall on each side. The snow was still picture-perfect, icy pure and fresh fallen white. The garage door was down. Webb parked on the far side, careful to leave room for a second car to park beside him. He got out, slammed his car door, and the sound echoed in the winter air. He followed the snow-blown trail to the immaculately shoveled front porch.
He grabbed the carved brass knocker with his bare right hand. The shock of cold ran through his skin and up his arm. He banged once, then waited, scouting for a doorbell.
He didn’t need it. John’s wife Evvie pulled the door open, and braced the frame with her right hand. She was too-rich thin and wore fresh makeup despite the late hour. “He’s not here, Webster,” she said.
“I wanted to talk to both of you,” Webb said.
Her smile was tired. “You know I can’t do that without John.”
John had never liked it, not from the day they got married. Any independence Evvie showed somehow reflected on him. Evvie couldn’t talk to another man alone. Webb had been on some of the calls as a beat patrolman. John never hit his wife, but the yelling had terrified the neighbors more than once. Webb suspected that was one of the reasons the couple had moved so far out in the country.
Webb didn’t argue. He could talk to them together if he needed to. “Where is he?”
“Funeral home. Someone has to make the arrangements.” She brushed a strand of unnaturally dark hair from her face. “I’ve been trying to call the folks in Utah. The numbers don’t work, except the home number, and Cindy won’t pick up.”
“Someone at the station probably notified her.”
“Hope so. We shouldn’t have to take care of him. He never did his part for this family.” Then she shrugged. “Shouldn’t have said that, should I? Speaking unkindly of the dead.”
“It’s not a sin,” Webb said.
“At least, not in the world of Tom Johanssen.” She sighed. “I’ll have John call. I know he wants to talk. This has him shook.”
“And you?”
“I’m surprised it didn’t happen years ago.” She took her hand off the doorframe. “Thanks for understanding, Webb.”
“Always have,” he said.
She nodded and eased the door closed. It snicked shut, and he stood for a moment, his hand still aching with cold. He’d always liked Evvie. She and John were high school sweethearts, and seemed to have an understanding. But Webb’d always thought John never treated her well enough, despite the house, despite the trips, despite the money. She had no life away from him, and she should have.
At least Webb thought so. But he wasn’t sure if that thought came from his own desire to see Evvie alone and have a real conversation, just once, without the guilt.
He sighed, walked off the steps, and back to his car. When he got inside, the porch light switched off.
The home Jenna Hastings made with her second husband, Steve Conner, was one mile and an entire income district away from John Johanssen’s. Jenna lived in a small three-bedroom ranch in at the base of one of the rolling hills. Her nearest neighbor on the left had a front yard littered with dead appliances and car parts. Her nearest neighbor on the right lost his home in a winter fire fifteen years ago and replaced it with an Airstream because he hadn’t been insured. Jenna had tried to make her home nice, with flower boxes outside the window and a fresh coat of paint every year. But the little house still looked like what it was—a starter home for a family that had never moved on.
Webb used to drive out to Jenna’s a lot when Steve was still on the force. They’d have barbecues and parties for the department, and Webb’d watch her four Johanssen boys take care of her two Conner girls. Handsome children, all, with the same restless intelligence he’d once seen in Jenna’s eyes.
He turned onto the highway leading to the Conner place and was startled to see the road filled with cars. Black-and-whites parked haphazard, their blue and red lights bright splashes against the snow. His mouth was dry, his stomach suddenly queasy. He had purposely had his scanner off, and now he flicked it on, the buzz and crackle of voices uncomfortably loud.
Steve Conner was standing under the outdoor light, coatless, arms wrapped around his torso. He was yelling at one of the patrolmen who stood, head bowed, blocking Steve from the house. Other officers were walking in and out of the open front door. Even from this distance, Webb could see the damp footprints on Jenna’s red-and-black rug.
He got out of his car slowly, like a man in a nightmare. The air, frosty cold, didn’t touch him. His feet squeaked on the snow and some of it fell over the edge of his shoe, and instantly melted on top of his sock. He scanned each squad until he saw what he was looking for, Jenna’s too-white face pressed against the rolled up window, watching as her husband continued to argue with the officer in charge.
All beat officers, no detectives. That made him shaky. He grabbed one of the patrolmen—a woman, actually, Kelly Endicott, who had gone to school with one of Jenna’s kids.
“Who ordered this?” he said.
“Headquarters.” She shook his arm off.
“Who?”
She shrugged. “No one wanted a name attached.”
“What’s the charge?” he asked, hoping that he’d stumbled on something else, that this was a mistake that had gotten out of hand.
“Murder, Webb.” Endicott’s voice was soft. “They found the gun.”
He put a hand to his head. It didn’t make sense. They had to do firing tests and match-ups and hours of lab work, and even then they couldn’t be certain that the gun they had was the one used in the murder. The idea of ballistics, as used on TV detective shows, was as much a fiction as the locked room mystery.
“What’d they find?” he asked.
“Conner’s old service revolver, under one of the cars at Tups. It’d been fired. Conner says the gun was stolen one night when he was at Tups.”
Webb nodded. “He’d reported it in years ago.”
Conner, a gun nut, had made a special petition to keep his weapons. Webb had kidded Conner about losing his revolver. Hated the force so much you’ve gone and lost the one thing to remind you of it.
Webb rubbed his hand over his face. His skin was getting chapped from all the exposure to the frosty air. “How come Jenna and not him?”
“No motive,” Endicott said. “He’d never met Johanssen. She had cause, so they say.”
“She’s had cause for thirty-three years,” Webb said. “Didn’t mean she’d do it now.”
“I don’t like it any more than you do, Webb. Seems to me someone just decided how this would fall, and didn’t do the backup work.” She tugged on her cap. “But what do I know? I’m still considered a rookie.”
She walked away from him, back to Conner and the officer he was yelling at. Webb glanced at Jenna. She had gained weight since high school. She had a matronly fullness, the kind of motherly warmth once drawn in ads for Campbell’s Chicken Noodle soup. When she saw Webb, she shook her head, and held up her hand as if he shouldn’t come near. He shrugged, and she shrugged in return. Then he retraced his steps to the car, got in, and went back to the station to see who’d caused this travesty.
During the winter, after five, the station had a different feel, a dark, gloomy feel, as if no hope could return to the world. Most of the desks were empty, but cops milled around, finishing business, leaning on counters, talking on the phone. Webb hated night activity. In this town, night activity was always sad activity: drug arrests, drinking violations, domestic violence disputes. Later, after midnight, the bar fights and the knifings would happen, but now, the station’s business was usually about kids in trouble with nowhere to turn.
The cops couldn’t help them either. The best the kids could hope for was to return to the parents who had neglected them in the first place. The worst was juvie, the petty criminal training ground.
Webb slipped inside. The station smelled of chalk dust and old coffee grounds. The concrete walls muted voices, made them sound as distant and less important than the voices on the police scanner.
Darcy sat behind her desk, hands in her short-cropped hair, a cigarette burning to ashes in a tray below the bright glare of the desk lamp. She was staring at the notes in her phone log, cheeks red with a stain Webb had learned to identify as anger.
“What’s the idea not showing up at your own collar?” he asked.
She didn’t look up. “Wasn’t mine. It was Bernard’s.”
“The gun’s not going to hold up.”
“You’re telling me.” She kicked her chair back. Her eyes were full of red. “Serial numbers were scratched off years ago. Bernard claims the notches in the handle make it Steve’s. His brother confirms it. But the gun’s wiped clean, no prints, and only one shot fired. Johanssen was killed point blank, so the killer has to have powder burns. I’ll betcha Jenna Conner doesn’t.”
“Why her? Why not Steve?”
“Former cop with a brother still on the force?” Darcy snorted. “You tell me, smartass.”
“Shouldn’t have arrested her at all, then.”
“No, they shouldn’t have, but they want it wrapped.” She pulled a file from beneath her log. “Makes this all worthless.”
Webb pulled up a chair. “What is it?”
“Johanssen’s arrest record. Longer than my arm, some drug related, all smuggling. No convictions, not even any overnight stays in jail. Big lawyers, big money.”
“And you think they bought someone here?”
She shook her head. “I think this town’s too wrapped up in its past to know what’s going on in its present.”
Webb nodded. The analysis made sense. Tom Johanssen betrayed his wife, so she murdered him, first chance she got. What did it matter that she had to wait thirty-three years to do so?
The problem was, the same logic applied to Flo.
He swallowed, not liking the options. “You know about the trips, then.”
“Every three years like clockwork,” she said. “Supervising international barges with some ‘special’ loads. A real hands-on kinda guy.”
“Drugs?”
She shook her head. “At first, I think. Then contraband. Going in and out. The Utah company was a front for chip smuggling. Disbanded last year just before the Feds caught up to it.”
“So you think this was a related hit?”
“I’m sure of it,” she said. “He screwed up, let some investigator get too close. That’s why the Utah office closed. His friends didn’t like it, and they killed him.”
“That’s not evidence, Darce.”
“Evidence.” She waved a hand. “Look at the evidence. The hit’s professional. There’re no prints, no witnesses, no gun ID, and a weapon left at the scene. Someone wanted him, and they knew if they got him here there’d be plenty of other suspects.”
“And a police department unused to these kind of cases.”
Her smile was tired. She picked up the cigarette, flicked the long trail of ash into the tray, and took a drag. “I didn’t say that.”
He smiled back. “But you could have.”
“I could have.”
He sat down in the metal chair beside her desk. The green upholstery had a rip in it that whistled under his weight. “Let me see the file.”
She tossed it at him. “This bothers you?”
“The whole thing bothers me. Tom was a bright guy. Why come here to meet a shipment if he knew his people blamed him for the raid last year?”
“Money?”
Webb frowned, remembering Flo’s face on the last beautiful day of her life. “He had other ways of getting that.”
He opened the file. Many of the sheets inside were old. Arrest records originally done on typewriters and recopied so many times that the dirt dots outnumbered the keystrokes. As usual on the old ones, the photos were missing, removed to put in a mug book or on another, more successful arrest sheet. The fingerprints were dark whorls of unreadable lines.
He flipped. The later arrest records were on a computer printout. Information, but no original arrest sheets. There was reference to an FBI file, and notes from Darcy’s conversation with the head of the FBI’s case. A reference sheet in the very back also had a DEA file number.
“There’s a lot of stuff here, but not a lot of paper,” he said.
She nodded. “They’ve been trying for him for a long time. He knew computers. He could make details disappear.”
Webb closed the file and handed it back to her. Just like Tom. Slippery to the end. Never appearing to be the person he actually was.
Webb pulled his gloves out of his coat—and paused, not liking the hunch that had just grabbed him and wouldn’t let him go. “Who did the autopsy?”
“Cerino. There wasn’t a lot to do since it was an obvious gunshot wound, so she did a prelim to establish time of death. She’ll do the rest tomorrow.”
“DNA, fluids, fingerprints?”
Darcy was frowning at him. “Why? We have a positive ID”
“Mine?” Webb asked.
“Yours, and his brother’s.”
“Scott’s?”
“John’s.”
Webb felt oddly lightheaded. Of course. No one wanted to bother his parents. No one ever wanted to bother Tom Johanssen’s parents. And everyone knew that his brother Scott wouldn’t give him the time of day. Even in death.
“Get someone to fingerprint the corpse and check it against the federal database.”
“I doubt he’s in the base. I said he disappeared things—God.” She stamped out the cigarette. “You don’t think he disappeared himself, do you?”
“Why not?” Webb asked. “He did it before. He’s the only one who would have known there would be other suspects here. I don’t care how good a professional hit man is, he doesn’t research those kinds of details.”
“But the ID—you ID’d him.”
“I haven’t seen him since 1962.”
“But his brother,” Darcy started.
Webb held up a finger, then picked up the phone. He listened to the dial tone as he thumbed through Darcy’s battered phone book until he found the number he was looking for. He wedged the phone between his shoulder and ear, and dialed.
“Evvie,” he said when she picked up the phone. “Webb again. Sorry to bother you. Is John there?”
“No.” She sounded small, hesitant. “He’s at his folks. You can reach him there.”
“I will,” Webb said, “but tell me one thing. When was the last time John saw Tom? Did he go on any of those Utah trips?”
“Heavens, no,” she said. “John’s too proud to let anyone pay his way anywhere. The last time we saw Tom had to be the last time we went West which was in—I don’t know—seventy-nine? eighty?—at least fifteen years ago.”
“Fifteen years,” Webb said. “Thanks.”
He set the receiver down. Darcy was staring at him. “No one’s that devious,” she said.
“You don’t know Tom,” Webb said.
“But his parents could have identified him,” Darcy said.
“He knew they wouldn’t,” Webb said.
Darcy shook her head. “He couldn’t have relied on that.”
“Sure he could,” Webb said. “He knew how it worked around here. He knew the department. He knew we would call John for the ID. John takes care of the family. And the entire town bends over backwards to protect Tom’s parents.”
“But his other brother—”
“Hates his guts. Everyone knows that. You want a reliable identification, you call John.”
Darcy was frowning. “So how did Tom get the gun?”
“It was stolen from Tup’s right? If you look, you’ll probably find that Tom was in town at the same time the gun went missing.”
“You think he’s been planning this that long?”
Webb gave her a bitter smile. “Tom always has a backup plan.”
She shook her head once, as if it were all too much for her. “I’ll get right on it,” she said.
FBI and DEA involvement somehow circumvented the usual state-to-state rigmarole. Darcy had impressed on them the need for immediate action. The fingerprint ID was fast, made even faster because the dead man was from California, a state that fingerprints all its citizens who get driver’s licenses. The body belonged to Anthony McGregor, a computer consultant who had left home three days ago. He had told his wife that he was on a buying trip to the Midwest with a new client, a man with a lot of cash and a lot of connections, a man whom McGregor met through a mutual friend, a friend who had once commented on McGregor’s vague resemblance to the client. McGregor had hoped the trip would provide an upward shift in the family’s fortunes.
Three hours after his death, Anthony McGregor tried to get a direct flight from Minneapolis to Miami. Since he didn’t book in advance, he wasn’t able to fly direct. He had a layover in New York City, a layover that extended from one hour to four because of ice problems at Kennedy. Two FBI agents and two DEA agents met Anthony McGregor when he disembarked at Dade County Airport. Strangely, Anthony McGregor was two inches taller and fifty pounds heavier than noted on his driver’s license. He’d also lost his need for corrective lenses.
“We get him when the FBI’s through with him,” Darcy said. “The murder’s in our jurisdiction.”
Webb rubbed his eyes and took a sip of his cold coffee. He’d been up all night. “You get him, Darce.”
“He’s ours, Webb.”
Webb shook his head. “I’m not going to taint this one. You got a clean case.”
“You don’t taint it,” she said. “You solved it.”
He smiled at her, liking that loyalty, knowing that sometimes this was where friendship hid—in the purposeful forgetting of important details. “I added local knowledge.”
“Crucial local knowledge.”
“Nothing more than some interviews would have provided.”
“But not within the right amount of time. We solved this while he was still in transit—”
Webb held up his hand, stopped her. “Darce, he screwed my sister, remember?”
“Oh,” Darcy sighed. “A jury’d love that.”
“Wouldn’t they though?”
She took out a pack of cigarettes, tamped it, then reached inside. It was empty. She crumpled it and threw it at the wastebasket, missing as usual. “How bad do you want him?”
“Bad enough,” Webb said, “to get out of the way.”
“He sure ruined a lot of lives.”
“He did that,” Webb said. “And some of the lives ruined themselves.”
Thirty years of police work. Thirty years, and he finally caught the man he’d been after all along. Webb stepped outside the station into a pale peach-and-orange dawn. The snow reflected the sun, making the whole city and the lake beyond look rosy.
But he couldn’t claim credit, and he wasn’t sure he wanted to. He wasn’t sure he’d be a hero in his sister’s eyes.
He sighed, ran his hand through his hair, and felt the stress of the last twenty-four hours in the oily strands. A shower, breakfast at a diner, and then he’d see Flo. He’d have to work on her now. She couldn’t live in silent hope any more. She couldn’t play the victim any longer. If he were prosecuting, he’d call her as a character witness, and he’d make sure to have her talk about the double-cross, the first double-cross on Tom Johanssen’s record.
She’d have to do it with Johanssen sitting across from her, older now, but still handsome, and rich enough to have real smart attorneys at his side. She’d finally have to stop taking responsibility for Tom Johanssen’s actions. She’d have to see him as he was.
Just as Webb had had to do.
He’d felt that little stab of betrayal in the police station, when his hunch rose to the forefront of his mind. He’d identified the body. He’d put himself on the line for Tom Johanssen once again. Believing the hype, believing the image, and almost letting the bastard go.
Again.
Webb had lied to Darcy. It wasn’t because of the future court case that he’d stepped aside. That was a good superficial reason, but not the true one.
The true one was that he didn’t want to see the fallout from Tom Johanssen’s latest double-cross. Before the victims had been his wife and kids, and Flo. This time, Johanssen’d set up his whole family, his folks, his brothers, his ex-wife’s new husband, and an entire town. He’d used the animus he’d created thirty-three years ago as a smokescreen to cover his flight to a new life.
At the expense of his ex-wife, his children, and one reasonably successful California computer consultant who had the misfortune to resemble Tom Johanssen enough to fool people who hadn’t seen him in years.
Local knowledge.
It worked both ways.
Webb got into his car. He felt as if a burden had lifted, as if the dark cloud he’d been living under had finally passed by. He could move on now, maybe even escape the black-and-white winters, find a place with a bit of nuance, a bit of gray.
He turned the car around and headed east, into the light.
Into the warmth.
____________________________________________
Local Knowledge
Copyright © 2013 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine, November, 2011Reprinted in The Best American Mystery Stories, edited by Robert Crais, Mariner, 2012Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2013 by WMG PublishingCover design by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Andreus/Dreamstime
Oh, my goodness, I’ve had fun with videos this spring. Once again, I’m the one doing the videos for WMG Publishing, Inc., a fact that makes me very happy. Our videos lacked voice for the past several years. (I’ll share an example of that later in the week.) I did the video for the Ghost of a Chance Kickstarter, which you can see if you click here. I also did this fun little rebranding video, which shows writers (and the rest of you) how important branding is to book buying.
The point of the Ghost of a Chance Kickstarter was to put the proper branding (covers etc) on the Ghost of a Chance books. We had gone through several branding attempts, and none of them worked. (Watch the video.) Now we’re all happy with the new look. These are Dean’s novels, and they’re fantasy romance or, as the new subgenre is called, romantasy. If you like romance with your fantasy or fantasy with your romance (or peanut butter with your chocolate…wait! Wrong ad!) click here.
One of the Kickstarter rewards is a class on finding your perfect reader, which is what the above video is about. That’s just one illustration on how to find a reader for your work. That online class will only be available in the Kickstarter. And… with every reward, you’ll get the five Ghost of a Chance novels, which are a lot of fun and well worth reading.
So…that’s one bit of learning. Here’s another.
As many of you know, we’re doing Prepare Ahead classes to accompany our in-person Anthology workshop in August. We’re going for some major subgenres this year, which can be hard to write for if you don’t understand them. We just finished up Military SF, and now we’re moving to a favorite of mine, Fantasy Regency.
Anthea Sharp will be editing this volume and she has a lot of insights on how to write fantasy Regency. Yes, there are rules. But those rules aren’t as strict as they’d be if you were trying to write the Regency that fits into the romance genre.
We’ve opened up the Prepare Ahead classes to everyone. If you want to learn this subgenre, and actually write for Anthea, then join this workshop. If you join today, you get a full week to learn this material. If you join later in the week, well, then…you only have until next Sunday.
I’m writing a story for this one too. It’s not my usual writing genre, but it is one that I read a lot. So I’ll be learning alongside you. Click here to join the online class.
And finally, our next Art of the Novella class is about to start. This one is also fantasy. You will learn how to write a fantasy novella which is, believe me, a heck of a trick. You have to keep readers engaged at the longer length, but you can’t commit 100K novel or even a novel series. And if your novella is in a series, well then, there’s a trick to that too.
Join us to learn all the tricks and to have fun doing it. At the end of the class, you’ll be writing a novella which I will read and comment on.
Here’s the link for that.
So…lots of learning this week (plus a fun video and some good reading).
Oh, and PS, if you want some insight into the above video, head over to my Patreon page. I have a couple of posts on the differences between this video and the actual Kickstarter video…and why those differences exist.
We are slowly getting through what was a very difficult eight months. In addition to Dean’s injury and the shooting at UNLV, we had issues of our own at WMG. A long-time employee turned out to be someone other than who we thought she was. The mess she left behind after her dismissal has been staggering, and we’re repairing all of it. It meant a lot of hard work, but we’re coming through it.
We were just discovering the issues in February as I started this post. I did most of my reading for the Holiday Spectacular then, before I ended up doing clean-up and schedules and talking to lawyers and law enforcement. As I write this, in late June, we’re finally getting back on track, and this website will become what it was—lots of interesting things and fun postings as well as notifications of all I’m doing.
Here’s February’s list. I was finally able to type up all of my copious notes. You’ll find lots of nonfiction and some really good articles.
Enjoy!
February 2024Bissinger, Buzz, The Mosquito Bowl: A Game of Life and Death in World War II, Harper, 2022. I had a weird experience reading this book. I started to read it in February of 2023, got very ill, and set it aside. Then I picked it back up later in the spring, but only read it while I was waiting for food at the restaurant downstairs. The book is compelling, and by the end, I was reading quickly, but I didn’t finish it until this February. Some of the details are just too grim to linger with long, and some are very sad. Other parts of the book just show how strange war is, particularly how strange and far-reaching World War II was.
The book examines what happened to the college football stars of 1941, when they got called up and scattered into the various units of war. These young (white) men had a lot of promise, but got derailed by a world war. They ended up playing in a “bowl” game in Guadalcanal in 1944, the only time these young men got to play football against each other.
I like books like this because they bring massive events, like WWII, down to the human level. Lots of lost hopes and dreams here, and life-changing moments. The amazing thing to me in this particular case is that I never forgot a detail about this book, even though I was reading it over such a long stretch of time.
Cole, Teju, “After Caravaggio,” Black Paper: Writing In A Dark Time, University of Chicago Press, 2021. The first essay in the book deals with Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio, who was, in Cole’s words, “the quintessential uncontrollable artist.” Yeah. A brawler who eventually became a murderer, Caravaggio was at times feted and at other times homeless. His work endures, partly because of the viciousness and clarity of his subject matter. Cole explores this and the difficulties of life in the various places—even now—where Caravaggio had once lived. There’s an undercurrent in this essay that grapples with the appreciation of the work of a difficult human being, which is something I have grappled with myself over the years. Enjoying the work of a criminal of any stripe feels dirty. This essay didn’t clarify anything for me, but it is nice to see someone else grappling with the same issues.
Cole, Teju, Black Paper: Writing In A Dark Time, University of Chicago Press, 2021. I’ve picked a lot of essays to highlight out of this book, but I could easily have picked several more. Or several instead. The entire book was wonderful, and my reaction to finishing it was to wish I had something else just like it to read. Of course there is nothing else just like it, but I consider that reaction to be one of the highest compliments I can give a book. I don’t want to give up the experience of reading it for the first time. So, in that way, I envy you. You’ll get to experience it anew. I’ll be rereading, of course, but that’s not entirely the same. Get this one, and enjoy!
Cole, Teju, “The Blackness of the Panther,” Black Paper: Writing In A Dark Time, University of Chicago Press, 2021. This entire essay was difficult for me to read. Not because it’s about racism, but because I hate zoos. And he deals with zoos here (panthers), as well as does something with a house cat that made me really uncomfortable. But the heart of the essay is excellent. It makes me see the world anew. Especially the line that caught me in my Americanism: I grew up with Black presidents, Black generals, Black kings, Black heroes, both invented and real. Black thieves too, Black fools. It was Nigeria, the biggest Black nation on earth.
We have a large Black population here in the U.S. (not the largest by a loooong way) but we’re always, always, always dealing with the history of slavery and Jim Crow, so that we pride ourselves on the first Black senator from such n so state or the first Black president, as if we invented it. And we did not by a long stretch. I’m so deep in my own culture, though, that I forget how different from ours that other cultures can be.
I will probably be rereading this essay a number of times despite the mistreatment of actual cats. There’s so much here…
Cole, Teju, “Experience,” Black Paper: Writing In A Dark Time, University of Chicago Press, 2021. If you want to learn how to write the five senses, read this essay. If you want to experience the five senses, read this essay. More than once.
Cole, Teju, “A Letter to John Berger,” Black Paper: Writing In A Dark Time, University of Chicago Press, 2021. Beautiful little short piece that I had to read twice because I found it so lovely. If I say more, I’ll ruin it for you.
Cole, Teju, “Mama’s Shroud,” Black Paper: Writing In A Dark Time, University of Chicago Press, 2021. A really beautiful essay on the reality of death and love. That sounds pretentious, but this is not pretentious. It’s heartfelt. And in the middle is a lovely quote: Death makes us protest the fact of death. It makes us wish for the impossible. Read this, especially if you’re struggling with loss.
Cole, Teju, “On Carrying And Being Carried,” Black Paper: Writing In A Dark Time, University of Chicago Press, 2021. A thoughtful consideration of what art and literature really mean, and how we all stand on the shoulders of those who came before. In some ways, for me, this essay matches “The Blackness of the Panther,” because the realizations in that essay (the ones that existed therein and the ones that I had personally) would not have crossed my mind without the experience of reading that essay. It was the perfect piece to end with, which is what Cole did here.
Cole, Teju, “Passages North,” Black Paper: Writing In A Dark Time, University of Chicago Press, 2021. I think I underlined almost everything in this essay. It works as a piece, though, so I wanted to recommend it. Ostensibly, it’s about the shooting in Oslo years ago now, but it’s about more than that. It’s about processing pain and figuring out how to move forward. Really, the entire book is about that, which is why I haven’t highlighted all of the essays that I loved here, but this one hit me particularly hard.
Cole, Teju, “A Quartet for Edward Said,” Black Paper: Writing In A Dark Time, University of Chicago Press, 2021. An examination of music, and art, and memory, and the way all of them impact us in different ways. This piece also looks at inspiration and the closeness we feel with our favorite artists, even if they don’t know that we love their work.
Fienberg, Daniel, “Norman Lear Was TV’s Lodestar,” The Hollywood Reporter, December 7, 2023. When I read this tribute to Normal Lear, I was having some trouble in my own life. I knew I’d be turning 64 this year, and I was feeling it, particularly since Dean had been injured and I had been taking care of him. I had to take a leave of absence from school because I knew that the work I had been doing in the fall wasn’t sustainable. (Little did I know that it would get harder, not easier, as we discovered the horrid betrayal of a long-time employee. Not going to school was a good decision.) After I read this, I realized that my grandmother had lived longer than Lear had and she had been in her right mind all the way to the end. She had energy throughout her nineties. I have at least another 30 good years ahead of me, if I do this right.
Most importantly, though, was this quote, which I circled and underlined:
And finally, when he died, Norman Lear was 101. But “101” is just a number, and it can mean different things for different people. Norman Lear could have spent the last 40 years in retirement — either in tropical seclusion or on the aforementioned national tour with civic documents — and his status as one of the most important and best writer-producers in the history of the medium would have already been set in stone.
Instead, he kept developing shows and producing shows. He kept finding voices to nurture and kept using the clout associated with both his name and his talent to keep the spirit of his classic shows alive, rather than merely keeping their syndicated bottom line intact.
Lear kept learning and growing, which is what it’s all about. He also cemented his legacy and influenced hundreds of people in-person, thousands by contact, and millions through his actions. Wow. That’s a heck of a life, and one to emulate.
Keegan, Rebecca, “Final Cut is a State of Mind,” The Hollywood Reporter, December 15, 2023. The Hollywood Reporter does a series of round tables in anticipation of the Oscars and award season, guessing who will be on ballots. This round table is an interview with six directors, all of whom were together for it. There’s a lot of wisdom here and a lot of great conversation about creativity. My favorite quote, though, comes from then 80-year-old Michael Mann. When asked how he felt, knowing the impact the choices he made had on other people (directors), he said, “It’s a surprise. I pretty much occupy a present, looking to the next thing I want to do. Go forward.”
That’s how I live too, and for a while, being in my sixties really messed that up. I kept seeing “forward” as “on the way to dead.” But it’s just a shift in attitude, along with the fact that I need to plan for the future of my work, now more than ever, after the implosion of one of my plans. Time to be thoughtful, not casual, about the future. So I love this quote.
Marshall-Chalmers, Anne, “The Track That Louisville Built,” Runners World, Winter, 2023. Ever wonder how things change? Sometimes someone gets an idea that everyone else thinks is impossible, and yet, that person manages it…somehow. That’s what Sadiqa Reynolds did when she decided to transform a run-down part of Louisville into a state of the art track facility. Spoiler alert: she pulled it off. But it took so much work and effort that most people would have given up. She didn’t. I love reading about amazing people, and she is one of them.
Miller, Shannon, “New Power Generation,” Las Vegas Weekly, 12/7/23. Ever since I moved to Las Vegas, I’ve been stunned at this community’s commitment to renewable energy. It’s staggering. When I tell people about it, they doubt me because they only know the party city, not the serious city behind the tourist façade. So I put this here, just to prove, yet again, that Las Vegas has vision and it’s fascinating to be a part of.
Penzler, Otto, Bibliomysteries, Pegasus Crime, 2017. I started reading this book in 2019 and quit for an unknown reason. I recommended two stories from the volume (which I still remember reading) and didn’t mention others. I do find that weird. I reread some stories in the volume and read all the others that I had missed. This is one of those consistently good anthologies in which very little stands out (except the two I mentioned years ago). I recommend the book as a whole. It led me to reading its sequel in March, which I will discuss then.
Rankin, Seija, “Making of Barbie,” The Hollywood Reporter, December 12, 2023. No, I still have not seen Barbie. I doubt I ever will. Barbie and I have had a troubled relationship all our lives. You’ll find that most women my age loathe her, although our daughters love her and so do their daughters. That’s because women of my generation remade her into a feminist. Before that she was a bimbo with a dream house. (Yeah, I have opinions. No, I will not see the movie. You can’t make me.)
However, I love reading articles about the making of this surprising hit film. Surprising to the men in suits who have never understood that women get their families to entertainments, not the men in their lives, no matter how many studies show this. (Sigh. Another fight that can wait for another day.) Anyway, this article about the making of is filled with all kinds of history and understanding and actual love for the doll from the filmmaker (thank heavens, because if she had hated it, the movie wouldn’t have worked at all.) Some great quotes here too. This one in particular about filmmaking—about art really—from the end of the article:
[Margo] Robbie’s proudest moment of dialogue isn’t a speech, but the six words that end the film: “I’m here to see my gynecologist.” She picked more than a few battles in her role as producer, occasionally fielding discomfort or nerves from the studio and corporations involved in Barbie. “But the last line of the movie was the hill I was ready to die on,” she says. Robbie received feedback, though she won’t say from whom, that there was concern the line might spur young viewers to ask too many questions. “I said, ‘If that’s the only thing this movie accomplishes, then I will be so proud, because that might save that little girl’s life one day,’?” says Robbie. “I think it’s extremely important that girls know, and if this movie makes them ask, then it will all have been worthwhile.”
Reginato, James, “Estate of Play,” Vanity Fair, October 2023. Fascinating, fascinating article on the Downton Abbey-ish British estates, how they’re managing to survive in this very different world, and how they’re handling their own history. There’s a rather uncomfortable photograph in the middle of the article showing actor David Harewood sitting in the Harewood estate with the current owner…whose ancestors enslaved Harewood’s. Yeah. History is messy and not dead at all. Really worth the read.
Runner’s World Staff, “Everyday Champions,” Runners World, Winter, 2023. Initially, as I read this article, I was going to point out the series of names that inspired me the most, but honestly, everyone in this group of runners inspired me. They run despite the other challenges in their lives, sometimes because of the other challenges. Read this. It will remind you why you do hard things. (It certainly did me.)
As many of you know, we’ve been talking for years about taking WMG Publishing Inc into the media world. There’s all kinds of corporate decisions to be made, and now that we have a staff in place that actually supports the changes, we’re moving forward at lightspeed. For a while, I’ll do the videos and the audio, but some of that will get handed off to someone else. Or maybe just the posting on social media part.
Right now, though, I have a Kickstarter video to share with you. I did this for Dean Wesley Smith’s brand-new Kickstarter. The Kickstarter is for Dean’s Ghost of a Chance series, which we’ve rebranded. It needed the rebranding. The series was romantasy before anyone knew what that was. (Wait until you see my later video—the one that shows the rebranding. That’s coming soon.)
It’s been seven years since I’ve done videos, handing them off because of illness to someone else. That someone else had no voice whatsoever so our videos went from fun to bland. We’re back to fun. I still can’t do much of what I want on these videos, because I need to relearn the programs, so I simply did this inside of iMovie as practice.
I’m happy with the result.
Those of you who like fantasy and ghosts and romance will love these books. They’re a good quick read. You can get all five books in the series as ebooks with any reward in the Kickstarter. There are a lot of great other rewards as well, so scroll on through and see what appeals to you.
I suspect you’ll find something that you really really want.
Take a peek.
1946: Betty Nerenhauser works with the famous screenwriter Jackson Holden Carter in hopes of learning enough from him to earn her big break. But her break comes when she least expects it—the day strange little men show up at Jackson’s office asking for his help.
Soon, Betty finds out just why Jackson mentored her—and how high the cost if it turns out he was wrong.
“Hollywood Endings,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Hollywood Ending: A Faerie Justice StoryBy Kristine Kathryn RuschHere, in Hollywood, they test everything. They test wannabe actors to see how they’ll look on the silver screen. They test sets, props, lighting, and sound for the best possible effect.
And they test endings. They test and retest and test again. They want the perfect ending.
But no one knows what the perfect ending is. Everyone thinks it’s a happy couple, walking arm and arm into the sunset. But sometimes, that happy couple walking off into the sunset violates the sense of the movie.
Sometimes, the Hollywood ending feels tacked on.
And sometimes, the Hollywood ending is just plain wrong.
In my memory, the sunlight is too bright. And it’s cold. 1946, the coldest winter on record. That was what the radio told us, and back then, we thought the radio was always right.
Or maybe I did.
I was nineteen, young, and stupid. I got my job because I had great legs and even better breasts, but I thought I got it because I could type 140 words per minute without a miss and hoped I’d keep the job because I could write.
Not that I got much of a chance to write. I was apprenticed to Jackson Holden Carter, the greatest screenwriter who ever lived, and he was the only person who took me seriously, even though he didn’t have to.
Jackson had an office on the studio back lot in one of those little bungalows. You already know what the studio back lot looks like; you’ve seen it in hundreds of films, maybe more. You’ve certainly seen it in the films of the 1940s because location shoots didn’t become common until the 1950s, unless the location was the desert (cue in the Mojave for the Sahara); the mountains (cue in the San Gabriels for the Alps); or the ocean (cue in the Pacific for the Mediterranean).
His office was one of those bungalows better suited to the tropics, with the wide open windows, ceiling fan, and rattan furniture that looked appropriate but was truly uncomfortable. Jackson’s office had two desks, one for him, and one for his flunky—which was, for that brief year, me.
Every morning, I came in with our coffees and donuts from the commissary, put everything on my desk, alongside the only working typewriter in the place, and prepared myself for Jackson’s onslaught.
He always got to work before me. By the time I arrived, he had taken off his suit jacket and slung it on the back of his chair, rolled up his sleeves, and had his straw hat resting haphazardly on the papers piled across his desk. He had a list of that day’s chores—sometimes a scenario (a few-page sketch of a screenplay he hoped to write), sometimes entire scenes for a screenplay, and once the entire screenplay itself.
I spent my days typing and fetching food. He spent his talking out the stories, weaving them like a storyteller of old.
Not quite perfect for me—I would’ve preferred to be the weaver. But it was close.
And it changed, one afternoon in January, when the little old men came to find us. Little old men weren’t common on the studio lots unless they were management. Even in those days, everyone worshipped at the fountain of youth, only they weren’t quite as blatant about it.
I was in my chair typing away on a scenario for a weepy that Jackson really didn’t want to write. It was our fourth version of the scenario in two days, none of which had gone to the director who had requested it. Jackson was self-editing, something I’d rarely seen him do, partly because he hated weepies.
Then Jackson stopped talking, which wasn’t all that unusual, particularly when he was spitballing something off the top of his head. I had learned not to look up, because the silence would be followed by a literal gush of words.
Only the gush never came.
And the light had changed.
So I finally did look up to see the little old men crowding our door.
They looked like they’d walked out of a fairy tale. They were astonishingly little and unbelievably old, the kind of old you rarely see any more, the wizened wrinkled shrunken old that made them all look like peeled apples left too long in the sun.
The little men wore perfectly tailored black suits with white shirts so starched that they hadn’t wrinkled at all even though it was mid-afternoon. They all wore hats, not quite bowlers, not quite fedoras. They had big noses and long chins and old-fashioned wire-rim glasses that either hid or magnified their eyes, depending on the angle.
“Why don’t you take a break, Betty?” Jackson said. My name is Elizabeth. He was the first to call me Betty.
I glanced at him. He’d never told me to take a break before. If anything, I had to plead for them—interrupting all that free-flowing creativity to make sure I had time to go to the ladies or get lunch or sneak a cigarette.
He looked back at me, then nodded, just once, reinforcing his words. A break, Betty. He didn’t say it, but I heard it, and knew it for the command that it was.
I would’ve gladly taken a break if I could’ve gotten past those little men, which was a mighty big if. Still, I stood and moved away from the typewriter, which might’ve been all he meant. I had vacated a much-needed chair and retreated to the corner, as far out of the light as possible.
Jackson stood too, rolled down his sleeves and put on his jacket, the first time I’d ever seen him do that in the office. Usually he walked out of the office with his jacket slung over his arm. The jacket would drape over his shoulders as he got into the car the studio provided and by the time he got to whatever restaurant he was eating at that night, the jacket would be on properly. But he never wore the jacket on the studio grounds, not even the few times that the head of the studio had shown up to give him what for.
“Gentlemen,” Jackson said as he shrugged to adjust the jacket sleeves into place.
I expected him to follow that with his usual sly To what do I owe this honor, but he didn’t. He just looked at them like a boy who expected to be chastised for a sin he didn’t know he had committed.
The shortest of the little men came inside the room. The others followed. There were four of them, which surprised me. I would have guessed that there were at least a dozen the way they crowded that door.
“There’s been a kidnapping,” the shortest little man said. He spoke with a thick Middle European accent, the kind that told me he’d learned English as a fourth or fifth language, probably as recently as ten years before.
It took a moment for his words to penetrate, but when they did, I looked at Jackson, expecting I don’t know what. Panic, maybe.
“When?” Jackson asked, his voice flat, his accent completely gone.
“This morning,” said the shortest little man.
“And you’re just coming to me now?”
“It took a while to find you,” the shortest little man said.
That surprised me. Jackson was visible, one of the most visible of all the writers on the lot. He was a celebrity in the Hollywood community, the man who could write anything on command, the man who knew every historical period, the man who made more quips—quips repeated by the entire town (bon mots, I can almost hear him chastising me even now; the right word, Bets. The story’s always better when you have the right word).
“You ever think I didn’t want to be found?” Jackson asked. Then he looked at me.
They all looked at me, like I had walked into some private club that I didn’t belong to, the kind that would never allow me to qualify for membership.
“Thought I told you to scram,” he said, sounding more like the Jackson I knew.
I started to stammer something about not being able to get to the door, then realized no one cared. So I grabbed my purse and wound my way around the little men.
They smelled of cigars and unwashed wool. Those suits weren’t made for Los Angeles, not even in the winter.
No one watched me go. But when I reached the door, Jackson said, “Hey, Bets, do that scenario for me, wouldja?”
It wasn’t a request. It was another command, and I knew it. Much as I wanted to know what was going on there, I couldn’t ask. Much as I wanted to write in our cozy little bungalow, I couldn’t do that either.
So I stepped into the winter chill (had to’ve been all of 70 degrees), and walked rather angrily to the nearest empty typewriter. I found one in the secretarial pool, which didn’t please me at all, and I set to work, figuring this was my chance to prove to Jackson that 1) I couldn’t be dismissed so easily and 2) he was squandering my writing talent by letting me type instead of write alongside him.
I had a bit of trouble starting up. I wanted to know about the kidnapping. Why would someone come to Jackson about a kidnapping? And how come he didn’t ask who was kidnapped?
I ran my hand over the cover to the typewriter, tempted to give it all up, and head back to the bungalow. But I’d only seen Jackson angry once, the time I forgot to tell him that Mae Wren had come to see him.
In my defense, famous actresses came to see him all the time, wanting him to expand their parts. Famous actors did too. It wasn’t that I was blasé—particularly about Mae Wren, who’d been my idol since I was a girl—it was just that I had to finish some of Jackson’s pages, ones he’d dictated, before I forgot them.
I have a prodigious memory, but it works best when I recall things in order, and that day, I hadn’t gotten to the Mae Wren part before Jackson heard that she’d arrived.
And I couldn’t explain that to him either.
He’d already commented on my memory, saying I remembered better than anyone he’d ever met, saying it was a skill that had a touch of magic to it. He told anyone who’d listen how much he treasured that skill, and how he’d never let me out of his sight.
I’ll need her someday, he’d say, as if he hadn’t already been keeping me busy, and then he’d grin at me, like we shared a secret.
It was the memory of that grin that made me sit down. Jackson would tell me when the time was right. But at the moment, he needed this scenario, and whatever I wrote would give him a jumping-off point.
I’d written down some ideas before, but never as a screen story, five pages long, as if we were going to turn my pages into Morley Stanhope, who wanted this particular weepy. As I wrote I had vague hopes that my words would become the basis of the screenplay, so I put my heart and soul into the whole thing.
I’d like to say my scenario was a cross between Dark Victory and Lost Weekend, but it wasn’t. It would’ve been a modern version of Little Women if Marmee had been a drunk. Or an American version of the Little Matchgirl, with a gutsy girl who wanted to be a writer only to be derailed when her little sister died of neglect.
Not too original, but original wasn’t the point, not in Hollywood then, not in Hollywood now.
I worked harder than I’d ever worked in my life, but half the time, my mind was on Jackson Holden Carter. Jackson Holden Carter and the little men, which sounded a lot more like a screen story than the dreck I was writing.
I wondered how I’d find him when I got back—weeping at the loss of a friend? Conferring with a private detective? Pacing the floor, worrying about a loved one?
I didn’t see any of that when I got back to the bungalow, clutching my precious little scenario.
Instead, I walked in to find Jackson bent over his desk, clutching his head in his hands, his hair mussed. His jacket was slung carelessly over my chair, and his trousers were riding up, showing socks that had crumpled into his shoes.
I’d never seen him look so sloppy—or so upset.
“Jackson?” I asked softly.
He looked up, and for a moment, I didn’t think he recognized me. Then he took a deep breath, gathered himself, and extended a hand.
“You got it?”
I handed him the scenario and he scanned it. It took him only a moment, then he said, “It ain’t art, kid, but it’ll do. Go hand it in.”
He gave it back to me.
I moved his jacket, pulled out my chair, and sat down. Then I grabbed some paper and rolled it into the typewriter.
“What’re you doing?” he asked.
“Putting your byline on it,” I said.
“Betty, this’s your work. You don’t let anybody put their name on your work, you got that?”
My cheeks heated. Back then, I thought he was ashamed of what I’d done. I didn’t realize he gave me the best advice a screenwriter could ever have—don’t let anyone steal your work, and for godssake, don’t give it away for nothing.
I swallowed, then typed the first page over again, this time with my name—Betty Nerenhauser—under the title. It only took a minute, and he watched me the whole time.
When I finished, he pulled the paper from the platen, and looked to see if I’d followed instructions. When he saw that I had, he gathered the rest of the scenario, handed it to me, and told me to deliver it. I thought he was gonna pat me on the head too, but he didn’t.
Instead, he escorted me to the door, like an old-fashioned country gentlemen.
I almost let him usher me out. Almost. I stopped at the door.
“Those men,” I said. “They said someone was kidnapped.”
He nodded, his expression guarded.
“Someone you know?” I asked.
The look that crossed his face was odd, as if he finally understood my concern and wondered at it.
“Yeah,” he said.
I nodded. “The cops on the case?”
He shrugged, an unexpected movement, given how upset he’d been. “They can’t do anything.”
“How do you know?” I asked. “A kidnapping—”
“Is all about getting there in time,” Jackson said. “Time’s up.”
“Oh,” I said. His friend was dead, and he was sitting here.
I put a hand on his arm. The scenario could wait.
“Lemme buy you a drink,” I said.
He shook his head. “There’s someone I gotta see,” he said, and walked me to the door. I hovered there for a moment.
Finally, he gave me a slight push forward. “I’ll be all right.”
And I stepped outside only because he wanted me to, even though we both knew that he was lying.
The next morning, I was summoned to the director’s office the moment I came onto the lot. Morley Stanhope was a bald-headed weasely man known for his groping hands and his casting couch. He sat behind his desk, a stogie in his mouth, tie loosened, and demanded to know why I had turned in a scenario when he’d specifically requested Jackson.
I clutched my purse in front of me. I hadn’t had time to go to Jackson’s office to drop off my stuff, and a good thing too, since that purse had become a shield. It would become a cudgel if Stanhope tried any casting-couch garbage with me.
“Mr. Carter was having trouble writing a weepy,” I said.
Stanhope glared at me. That was when I realized he thought I had put one over on Jackson.
As if anyone could do that.
“He asked me to try it,” I said.
Stanhope’s glare got worse. “And he liked what you wrote?”
“He told me to give it to you,” I said, which was true.
“You got any idea why he wanted you to write this?”
Somehow I felt that answering honestly wasn’t in my best interest, maybe wasn’t even in Jackson’s best interest. Stanhope seemed too suspicious, as if he was checking up on Jackson as well as me.
So I decided to lie. “Well, honestly,” I said, “he said that weepies were women’s pictures, and a woman would understand them better than any man ever could. So why not have a woman write one?”
I lowered my voice as if I was confiding in Stanhope. “I figure he was testing me, sir. I’m sure that your judgment will be the final deciding factor.”
I was implying that I would lose my job if the director didn’t like the work, which wasn’t entirely fair to Jackson. And I wasn’t sure Mr. Casting Couch would actually care.
Stanhope sat up, slapping my five-page manuscript against his palm. “Well, Ms. Nerenhausen, this is one brilliant scenario. Almost made me cry just reading it.”
My cheeks heated. I was pleased, even though I knew I shouldn’t be. I had just graduated from flunkie to flunkie who had allowed an evil ghoulish director to take some kind of corporate revenge on Jackson.
“So,” Stanhope said, “you should write me the entire screenplay. Think you can do that?”
My golden opportunity and I wanted to turn it down out of loyalty to Jackson. But he had warned me this would happen one day. He had said, Kid, they’re going to use you to get to me. If you don’t play along, you’ll lose every chance you’ve ever had. So play along. Someday I won’t be here. Someday, you’ll need the skills.
I forced myself to answer. “I-um-I…when do you want it, sir?”
“You got ten days.” Stanhope steepled his fingers as if he was trying to look serious. “I need quality, brilliance. The best anyone’s ever done. If Jackson’s right and women write the best weepies, then you’ll give me a blockbuster picture that’ll bring me every kudo in the book.”
No expectations there. The heat in my cheeks turned into a flame.
“Sir,” I said, “in the spirit of full disclosure, this will be my first screenplay.”
“Even better,” Stanhope said. “Anita Loos’s first screenplay was The Women. And it was damn brilliant.”
Claire Booth Luce wrote The Women. It was a successful stage play. Anita Loos just added some tidbits for the screen. And The Women wasn’t her first screenplay. She wrote title cards for the silents long before she wrote The Women. But I didn’t correct him. If he wanted to inject me with false confidence, he could try.
I’d write the best screenplay I could, then let Jackson look it over. I had to trust that he wouldn’t let me embarrass myself.
“Thank you, sir,” I said, bobbing my head like an idiot. “I’ll have something for you in ten days.”
“Not something, honey,” he said. “Our next film. Something that’ll make the women of America sit up and notice.”
I didn’t want to remind him that women would sit up and notice a stinker as easily as they’d notice a quality picture. I backed out of the office, my heart racing, my mouth dry, and every single writerly thought gone from my head. I’d just gotten my biggest wish, and hadn’t even had to climb on a casting couch to do it.
Now that wish was mine to screw up.
If I hadn’t screwed it up already.
I ran across the studio, dodging the little golf carts that everyone used to get around, passing women in harem costumes, men dressed like cowboys, and at least one gigantic matte painting destined for god knew where.
When I got to Jackson’s office, I yanked the door open, startled to find Jackson inside. He was rifling his own desk like a thief in the night. He looked as surprised to see me as I was to see him.
“I’m sorry,” I said. “It wasn’t my fault.”
He stood up, his desk drawers still open. His suit was wrinkled too. It looked like the same suit he wore the day before, but that couldn’t be possible, because Jackson Holden Carter had more suits than the studio wardrobe, and he never wore the same color two days in a row, let alone the same suit.
“What wasn’t?” He was suddenly giving me his full attention.
“He gave me the script, Jackson. I’m supposed to write it in ten days.”
Jackson frowned. “What script?”
“The weepy. You know. You had me write the scenario for it.”
“Oh,” he said and sank into a nearby chair. “I expected that.”
“You did?”
“You did the work, Bets. You get the credit.”
“You’ll help me, won’t you? I’ve never written a full script.”
“Yes, you have,” he said. “I’ve seen a few. More than one has fallen out of your purse. I put them back, just like you expected me to. And I read them too, just like you expected me to.”
That heat flooded back into my cheeks. “You never said anything.”
“You never asked.” He gave me a lazy grin. “If you had, I’d’ve said yes. You’re good, doll. You got more talent in your little finger than half the palookas in this place.”
“Thanks,” I said.
Then his grin faded. “But you gotta remember that talent ain’t everything. Talent ain’t nothing without good hard work. Talent is probably the most confusing thing on God’s green earth, truth be told. And when your latent talent flares up, you gotta learn to control it.”
I frowned, not sure I’d ever heard this speech from him before, not sure I entirely understood it.
He studied my face, clearly seeing my confusion. “I’ll teach you everything I know about control, which isn’t as much as I used to think, and we’ll get you through this.”
Then he glanced at his watch.
“But not today. Today, I’ve got other things to do.”
“Your friend?” I asked.
He looked at me, as if he were startled that I remembered. “Yeah,” he said. “That.”
“Is there anything I can do?” I asked.
“Not yet,” he said.
I waited for him to tell me all about it. I waited—and he just stared at me, sadly, as if he had lost more than a friend.
As if he had lost everything.
Then he took a deep breath. “You get to work on that screenplay.”
I grinned. I couldn’t help it.
“I got ten days,” I said. “I got time.”
He froze, then nodded, as if he had to force himself to move. His mouth moved like he planned to smile ruefully but forgot how.
“Time,” he repeated. “We always think we got time.”
I thought he was referring to his friend, losing his life in that strange way. Kidnapping. Death. Early death made everyone reflect on time.
At least, that was what I thought.
But Jackson was talking about something else.
Even though I wouldn’t know it until much later.
I was working on the weepy when they sent for me. I was sitting alone in Jackson’s office, pounding on the typewriter, three pencils stuck in my hair and another between my teeth. Every few paragraphs, I’d stop, make a correction, and keep going.
At that rate, I’d have my preliminary draft done in three days.
Of course, I didn’t have anyone to tell. Jackson hadn’t even shown up at all that morning, which wasn’t like him. And I’d brought him a coffee and some crullers from the commissary. I had my own coffee—long gone now—and my own crullers, also gone, and I was ready to break into Jackson’s stash when someone knocked on the door.
I glanced over. One of the studio security guards leaned in the door. I’d seen him before—young guy, barely older than me, with such a square jaw and bright blue eyes that he could’ve come from central casting (serve up one security guard, pronto. And make him easy on the eyes.).
“Miss Nerenhausen?” he said. “You’re to come with me.”
I sighed and set down the soggy pencil I’d been using. No one summoned me. Hardly anyone knew I was here.
Except Stanhope. He probably wanted to tell me the weepy was now a male adventure flick, and I was out of the picture—no pun intended.
The guard waved a hand around his hat and it took me a minute to realize he was trying to help me. I pulled the pencils out of my hair, then grabbed my purse, opened my compact and checked the mirror. I looked like an insane writer, hair sticking up in tufts, pencil lead all around my mouth, even some sugar frosting from those crullers earlier.
What a lovely introduction to a security guard from central casting. He probably thought I was a ditz.
I used a tissue to wipe off my face, smoothed my hair with my hand, and reapplied my lipstick. Then I slung my purse over my shoulder and nodded at him.
The last thing I wanted to do was defend myself to some idiot director, especially when I didn’t have a leg to stand on. Jackson could give the occasional director what for. In fact, Jackson would remind the idiot why he’d wanted a woman writing a weepy in the first place. But me? I’d just have to nod and watch my opportunity slip away.
It mattered to me more than I wanted it to, especially now that Jackson wasn’t here. That peeved me too. Jackson usually let me know his whereabouts. I thought we’d become buddies, but now that I had real work, I had to assume we weren’t buddies at all.
The security guard led me outside, past the bungalows, and stopped at a limo. He opened the back door for me.
I looked at him sideways.
“This’s all they had on such short notice, miss.”
I sighed and got in, pretending a nonchalance I didn’t have. I’d never sat in the back of a limo before. I’d helped Jackson into more than his fair share, and I’d even peeked around the interior once or twice, but I’d never actually crawled in.
Nor had I had someone to close the door for me or to get into the driver’s seat like I was someone important.
Remember, Bets, Jackson’s voice echoed in my memory. They treat you nice when they need something from you, and forget you exist when you’ve completed your mission.
I tried not to let it go to my head. But there was water on ice in the back, and some real pastries—not just crullers—and coffee in one of those expensive steel thermoses. No champagne, but I didn’t expect it, not this early in the day.
I carefully poured myself some coffee—the cup provided was real bone china—and watched the scenery go by. We twisted up to Bel Air just like I would have expected: See The Famous Director At Home!
The driveway was nearly two miles long, twisting up a well-manicured lawn that actually had winter flowers growing in oblong beds. Those flowers looked like transplants, not like they were happy there, and I would have wagered my entire salary that some poor gardener took plants in and out of those beds each and every month, to answer Stanhope’s whim.
The driveway circled around a fountain in front of a Los Angeles colonial, bigger than my entire apartment building. A few other cars were parked here—Studebakers, Olds, nothing I would’ve thought of as classy enough for this neighborhood.
The studio guard—limo driver?—got out of the front and opened my door. I half expected him to say, “Mr. Stanhope will see you now,” but he didn’t.
He didn’t say anything.
Instead, he looked grim.
He took my arm and led me along a brick-lined path around the house. I could smell the pool before I saw it; chlorine bathing the air like raindrops.
I thought of Stanhope’s arrogance—summoning writers poolside even in the depths of winter, just because he could.
I was so focused on the upcoming slight that I wasn’t prepared for the scene before me.
The four little men stood around the pool, bent over it as if they’d never seen water before. The poolside furniture had been moved off the patio and was pushed up against the house, covered in a tarp. A woman hovered just inside the glass doors, her hands clasped together—and she wasn’t what I expected either.
Mae Wren, star of stage and screen (as the gossip rags called her), deserved her made-up name. Up close, she was tiny and birdlike, her classic Lillian-Gish-for-a-new-generation features making her seem almost surreal.
The little men weren’t looking at the beautiful famous woman only a few feet from them. They acted like she didn’t even exist. But the guard kept glancing her way, a bit too awestruck for someone who spent his working days around faces as or more famous than hers.
“What’s this all about?” I asked the guard.
He glanced at me, his fingers tightening on my elbow as if he expected me to bolt.
“They want you to identify someone,” he said.
“Who?” I asked.
He nodded toward the little men.
My stomach clenched. “I don’t take orders from them.” Or you, I thought, but didn’t add.
“Before we call anyone else,” he said, “they wanted you here. They asked me to bring you.”
I yanked my arm out of his grasp. “I thought you worked for the studio.”
“Sometimes,” he said, and took a step back.
The little men were watching us. I had lumped them together when they were in Jackson’s office, but they had very distinctive features. The shortest man, the one who had been the spokesman back there, looked older than the rest, the lines on his face so deep that they seemed almost carved.
I walked toward them, my mouth inexplicably dry. As I got closer, I could finally see the pool. The water was bright blue. Steam rose off of it. Ms. Wren was one of the new Hollywood—the kind that spent oodles of dollars just to keep her pool heated through L.A.’s “cold” winters.
The little men moved aside as I neared, as if they didn’t want to touch me. Two of them looked meaningfully at the pool.
I followed their gaze.
And saw that suit. Day three of that suit. Jackson never wore a suit that long, not that he’d ever wear this one again.
It was turning green from the chemicals in the pool. Air was trapped in the jacket, making it look bloated. It took me a moment to realize that someone was inside that suit.
“No,” I whispered.
“We must retrieve him from the pool,” the shortest little man said.
“Then do it,” I snapped.
“We cannot touch him,” the shortest little man said.
I looked at the guard. He stayed back as well.
“You brought me here to drag someone out of a swimming pool?” I said. “You can call the cops for that.”
The shortest little man shook his head. “You must do it, Ms. Nerenhauser.”
“I’m not in the body retrieval business,” I said. “You can get someone else.”
“We cannot,” the shortest little man said.
“Then I’ll call the police. What’re you people, incompetent?” I started to turn but the nearest little man grabbed my sleeve. He missed my flesh entirely.
“Please,” he said, his voice more accented than that of the spokesman. “He chose you.”
That knot in my stomach got tighter. We were all dancing around the identity of that corpse. It was Jackson’s suit, and someone was wearing it, and the guard said they needed me to identify it. But they seemed to know who it was, just like I might’ve known who it was, if I let myself think about it.
“No one chooses the person who pulls his body out of a swimming pool,” I said.
“Ah,” said the shortest little man, “but he does if he knows he is going to die.”
I looked at the hand still clasping my sleeve. The fingers were callused and tobacco-stained.
“If he knew he was going to die,” I said, my voice shaking, “he would’ve told me.”
“Would you have believed him?” the shortest little man asked.
No. Of course not. I’m not a fool. No one knows when they’re going to die. No one can predict that, especially when they’re as vibrant as Jackson.
The little man who had ahold of my sleeve tugged me backwards, toward the pool. The guard got one of those skimmer-things that people used to clean leaves out of the water, and handed it to me.
The metal was cool against my palm. I looked at the suit, floating there. This was a joke. It had to be. It was one of those prove-yourself-you-chump practical jokes that so many on the lot liked to play on each other.
I’d finally become a victim of it because I had taken over Jackson’s weepy. He wanted me to prove myself.
I swallowed, crouched, and used the skimmer-thing to pull the suit toward me. Definitely something inside. Definitely something body-shaped, with dark hair floating around the skull, bloated ringless fingers pointing toward the bottom.
Studios could make anything. Studios could make wax dummies of the most famous people or the humblest of extras. Studios had pretend corpses lying around just for an occasion like this. Maybe someone was filming this. I’d heard about those kinds of films, the kind that made everything seem real but it wasn’t, the kind that got raw emotion on screen because—some believed—it was better than anything an actor could produce.
The body bumped against the side of the pool. I looked up. The little men had gathered around me. The guard stood behind me. Across the steaming water, I saw Mae Wren, her hands still clasped together, her features shiny from the clear glass she looked through.
“Someone’s going to help me now, right?” I asked.
They shook their heads. I closed my eyes for a moment—it was a prank, it had to be—and reached into the water.
I expected it to be cold, even though I knew it was heated. I wanted to feel the shock against my fingertips, the chill running up through my skin. Instead, the water was as warm as a sun-kissed lake in the summer.
My fingers closed on a sleeved wrist, cufflinks biting into my flesh, the feel of wet linen familiar and strange at the same time.
Wet linen, with the starch gone. Wrinkled and sodden, exactly how Jackson would not want to look.
I pulled, but it didn’t work, and I almost fell in. My fingers slipped, hit flesh and—
he was standing right there, just for a moment, and in that moment, we were in the office, and he was in front of his desk, and I realized it was yesterday, when I last saw him, yesterday, and there was more of the conversation that I remembered, or maybe my brain had just taken me to that location because he was there, and he looked at me with a sadness I’d never seen on his face before, and he said, “Bets, I didn’t mean for this. I’m so sorry.” And then he vanished, leaving me alone in that room, in the dark, a stack of paper beside my typewriter, and his suit jacket over the back of his chair. I wanted to call out to him, but I couldn’t, instead I—
squealed and let go. I would’ve toppled into the pool if the guard hadn’t caught my shoulders.
“Okay,” he said to the little men. “That’s enough.”
He wrapped a towel around my hand, which tingled, and looked across the pool.
“I called the cops,” he said to no one in particular. I had no idea when he could’ve done it. When I was reaching into the water? Was there a phone out here?
I looked at the folded up furniture and saw the phone hanging from the exterior wall, the cord swinging as if there were a breeze.
Then I glanced at the double glass doors. Mae Wren was gone.
Then he bundled me back to the limo. The little men followed. They got into their various cars—the ones I’d seen parked around the circle, and we left, turning out of that long driveway just as two police cars turned onto the leafy private street. They didn’t seem to notice our small parade, driving right by as if we had done nothing wrong.
My hand ached as if the water had been as icy as I feared. The ache went all the way up my arm, into my shoulder, along my jaw and into my skull. My eyes burned. Every time I closed them, I saw Jackson, standing there, looking apologetic.
I’d never seen Jackson apologetic.
We stopped at the bottom of a hill, at a small house on the corner. The limo was almost as big as the driveway. Curtains twitched in the house across the street. Apparently people here weren’t used to seeing a limo parked at this address.
The guard got out and opened the curbside door for me.
“What’s this place?” I asked. My head ached. I wanted quiet. I wanted to go back to the office.
I wanted Jackson there, so I can tell him about the strangeness of the morning.
“Just go inside,” the guard said.
“Who are you?” I asked.
“My name is Mike,” he said, and I thought, Of course it is. Guys like him—security guards out of central casting—they were either Mike or Joe. And they were always there to fill a slot, to give a few lines of dialogue, to move something forward.
Apparently, he had to move me forward. He put his arm around me, pulling me toward the house. I thought of dragging my feet, but it seemed like too much effort.
“You don’t work for the studio, do you?” I asked.
“I do,” he said, sounding a bit defensive. “But I moonlight for Jackson.”
His voice broke just a little. He could’ve done the ID same as me. Only he didn’t.
They wanted me to touch Jackson.
The thought made me shiver.
Mike looked down at me, that square jaw making him seem as unreal, as much like a character from a fairy tale as the little men. I was going to ask him why he hadn’t identified the body, when he opened the door to the house and pushed me inside.
The interior was dark and smelled faintly of roasted meat and freshly baked bread. Mike directed me to a chair. My eyes slowly adjusted. The furniture in the living room was too heavy for the hot Los Angeles summers. Matching upholstered couch and chairs with claw feet. I rubbed my hands over the fabric, guessing it was rolled wool. An expensive Turkish carpet covered the polished hardwood floor, and a Seth Thomas clock ticked on the mantel above a useless fireplace.
The door opened and the little men came in. They looked at home here, among the heavy furniture and thick area rugs. The little men took off their hats and hung them on a coat rack I hadn’t even seen. Mike stood behind me, as if he was going to hold me in place.
The little men sat around me, leaning forward.
“What do you know?” asked the shortest little man.
“Not a hell of a lot,” I said, which proved just how upset I was. I never swore around my elders. I never swore period. “For instance, I have no idea who you are.”
They all looked at each other, then back at me.
“You do not know what Jackson knew?” the shortest little man asked.
“How could I know what he knew?” I asked. “He dictated screenplays to me. That’s all.”
Again, they looked at each other. Mike behind me moved slightly as if he were uncomfortable.
“He told us that his knowledge would transfer to you,” the shortest little man said. “He said we were to call you in the event of his death.”
I leaned into the chair, going farther than I expected. The springs in the back were gone.
“That was him,” I said, more to myself than to them.
“Yes, child,” said the shortest little man. “Death finally caught up with him.”
“He drowned?” I asked. “Fully clothed?”
Again, they looked at each other.
“No, child,” the shortest little man said. “He was shot.”
“By whom?” I asked.
“How should we know?” said one of the other little men. “It happened so long ago.”
“It happened this morning,” I said. “That’s not long ago.”
“No, child,” the shortest little man said. “He was shot long ago. Death caught up with him last night.”
I shook my head. “What?”
“Oh, dear,” one of the other little men said. “He was wrong.”
“He said her talent was latent,” Mike said. “It’s not fully developed. Maybe it takes time.”
I glanced up at him. The guard’s cap was gone, revealing a shock of auburn hair. Unlike most redheaded men, his hair accented his blue eyes and his golden skin. He was much more handsome without the cap than he had been with it.
“Okay,” I said, my heart pounding. “Here’s what I know. I know I’m supposed to be writing a screenplay. Jackson expected me to do it. I have nine days to finish—eight and a half if you count the time you guys have just wasted for me.”
The shortest little man started to speak.
I held up my hand to silence him. Part of me watched, appalled at myself. I never treated other people like this. I was too young, too shy, too female to behave as if I were the one in charge.
“I know that you all came to the studio yesterday and told Jackson a friend of his had been kidnapped. Why didn’t you just say dead? A friend of his was dead.”
They looked startled.
“And now Jackson is. What’re you playing at? How come you didn’t stay for the police? What’s Mae Wren got to do with it all?”
“You should know,” one of the little men said.
“I don’t know,” I said.
The shortest little man popped out of his seat. He walked toward me, then past me, and stopped beside Mike.
“He lied to us. He said she had power.”
Mike sighed. “He thought she did.”
“Isn’t anyone going to tell me what’s going on?” I asked, sounding a lot more like my out-of-control, useless self.
“Your friend, Jackson Holden Carter, is dead,” the shortest little man said. “He will not return. He will not write your script. He is gone. And we are sorry.”
My lower lip trembled. I stood up.
No one stopped me.
“Do I have to drive myself back to the studio?” I asked Mike. “Or are you taking me?”
He pulled the keys from his pocket, grabbed his cap off a nearby end table, and walked to the door. As he pulled it open, dust motes floated on the rays of sunshine that came in from outdoors.
I stepped into that sunshine. The air was still Los Angeles cool, but it felt better than the inside of that stuffy house.
“What was that all about?” I asked as he let me into the limo.
“It was a mistake,” he said.
“But Jackson’s dead,” I said.
He nodded and blinked, as if he were repressing tears. “Looks like we all are.”
He let me off at the gate. I’d like to say I never saw him again, but that wouldn’t be true.
Or maybe it would.
It’s hard to explain.
I gave my name to the guard, who let me through the side door. Then I walked back to the bungalow. The sunshine had focused down to a point, and the normal studio sounds—conversations, laughter, the occasional music rising from a closed set—seemed like background noise.
Out of the corner of my eye, I thought I saw Jackson, dressed in a pirate’s costume, looking like Errol Flynn in Captain Blood. But as I turned, I saw only an extra in a blousy shirt and black pants, with a red sash across his waist. He smiled and tipped an imaginary hat at me.
I couldn’t smile back.
I kept walking, the sunlight fierce. The afternoon had gotten warm—in the seventies warm—and I normally would have welcomed it. But I felt too hot, sweat trickling down my back.
As I rounded a corner, I saw Jackson again, wearing a toga, his face unlined and terrified. I closed my eyes, but the image grew, so I opened my eyes, turned, and saw an old half-torn poster for Ben Hur, one I had never seen before, with Ramon Novarro looking sad and majestic all at the same time.
I tripped, caught myself, and continued, finally stopping outside the bungalow. Inside, the ceiling fan would be slowly turning, moving the air, maybe moving some papers around.
I pushed the door open, half expecting to see him, disappointed that I didn’t. I stared at his chair, pushed back, turned. All it needed was a suit jacket. A hat on a nearby desk. The crullers I brought in that morning still waited for him. Like the now-cold coffee.
I sank into my chair. I looked at the words on the platen of my typewriter, and remembered where I wanted to go, but not how to get there.
Jackson was dead. A friend of his had been kidnapped.
Mike the security guard from central casting had called the police.
The little men thought I knew all about it.
The little men with strange accents, who looked like they had emerged from a fairy tale.
I looked at my script and wondered what the hell had just happened. I touched the paper, my hand shaking.
There was a pile of paper beside my desk, just like there had been in that vision I’d had beside the pool.
I didn’t remember leaving the paper there.
You’re not going to remember everything, Bets. But you’ll remember most of it.
Jackson’s voice.
I turned, but he wasn’t behind me. Then I glanced at his desk. His jacket hung over the back of the chair.
The same jacket I had seen in the pool.
The jacket was green from chlorine. Water had formed a puddle on the floor.
“J-Jackson?” I asked, trying to swallow the hitch in my throat.
He faded in, just like he would have done in a movie. I knew the screen trick. First you film the empty chair. Then you put the actor in that chair and film again. Then, in the editing room, you merge the images, beginning with the empty chair, then slowly adding the actor, and finally you ended with the actor in the chair, looking solid.
Looking real.
“Sorry, kiddo,” he said. “Didn’t mean to scare you.”
But he was scaring me. His shirt was plastered to his too-thin chest. His wet hair fell across his forehead like paste. His skin was grayish white, and his lips were blue.
“What’s going on?” I asked, fervently wishing he would tell me this was a practical joke.
He shrugged a shoulder. “Ah, Bets, it’s a mess,” he said.
I looked at the water, puddling on the floor. The entire office smelled of chlorine.
“No kidding,” I said.
He wiped a hand over his face, then shook off the water. Still, water beaded on his cheeks. “I promised you I’d train you, and I’m not going to be able to.”
“You already said I could write scripts,” I said.
He smiled. “Different kind of magic, kid, and in you, that talent isn’t latent. You just need to get to Carnegie Hall.”
And by that he meant practice, practice, practice. He loved that joke. I’d tired of it the second time I’d heard it, back when I started.
“Then what?” I asked.
“You can see and remember,” he said. “I shoulda told you when I first met you, but I knew the seeing hadn’t arrived yet.”
“Seeing?”
He waved a hand. Water dripped from his wrist. “You’ve always had the remembering. Everything sticks in your brain. I knew that the first day, when you typed my dictation. You know how many pages I was into it before you even sat down at the typewriter?”
“Three,” I said, because I did remember that, at least.
“You know how many other people can perform that trick?”
It was my turn to shrug.
“None,” he said. “At least not living. We got one memory per generation, and our generations are long-lived.”
I frowned.
“You getting the picture? You’re not normal, kid,” he said.
I swallowed hard. I had a vision of Jackson appear before me to tell me I wasn’t normal? Seriously? Wouldn’t that be redundant, since just seeing him sitting there (and talking to him) made me automatically not-normal?
“Seeing, though, seeing comes with age.” He leaned back in his chair. The chair squealed, just like it always did. Or was I “remembering” that too?
He was watching me closely. But I hadn’t moved.
“I didn’t want to trigger the seeing,” he said. “but I guess I just did.”
I sank into my chair.
“I’m going to give you four pieces, kid,” he said, “and when I’m done, you have to act fast. Right now, they don’t know you’re here.”
“They?”
He waved that hand again. Water sprayed the desk.
“Four pieces,” he repeated. “You get to put them together. I’ll try to leave a few traces. But time is of the essence—and be forewarned. They seem to have a better grasp of time than we do, which is startling if you think about it.”
I didn’t find it startling. I didn’t know why I should. Right now, this vision of Jackson was just speaking gibberish, and I wasn’t sure how to make him stop.
“So here we go,” he said. “You ready?”
And before I could answer, he reached up and—
we were in a field, smoke-covered, filled with men, screaming, or was it the horses screaming? Lots of screaming, high-pitched, pain-filled, horrible—my skin crawled and I wanted out.
Jackson stood in the center, but not my Jackson, a different version of Jackson, face barely recognizable beneath his thick mustache, his hat hiding his forehead. Only his eyes were the same, dark and unfathomable, but they weren’t looking at me.
Instead, they were peering through the gloom as if he expected something. Then the noise faded, all except three gunshots, booming. The bullets cut through the air, through the smoke, as if they were in a separate reality.
They headed for Jackson, moving so slowly that he should’ve been able to step out of the way, but he didn’t. He stood there, watching them, and then they slammed into him, thudding with an awful meaty thwack, thwack, thwack.
He started to fall back from the impact, except he reached up and pushed the air around him, pushing and pushing and pushing until those bullets were yards away from him, hovering, blood-covered, as if they were watching him.
He dusted off his uniform—one I sort-of recognized—Prussian. From the last war. The Franco-Prussian war. Or maybe the Boer War. One of those wars. Not our war—and then stepped aside. He picked up a man beside him, carrying that man across the smoke-covered field, heading toward a tent way in the back, the bullets following at a respectable distance as if they were cameras spying on him, instead of hot pellets of metal trying to kill him.
Then the smoke covered everything, like a thick blanket of fog and—
Jackson peered at me, as if he wasn’t sure I understood. He looked less substantial in that chair, and the puddle of water had grown to a small trickle, flowing toward the door. He—
stood inside a Nickelodeon and watched herky-jerky images on the screen. A smoke-filled field, horses falling, men reaching bony hands toward him. An organist played in the back, the music sweeping and big. Beside the organ, three bullets poised, their tips pointing toward Jackson, following him at a safe distance as he walked toward the shining silent images in front of him.
A child, thin and gaunt, sat in the closest chair, and when he saw her, he picked her up. She looked over his shoulder, frightened, her eyes familiar, her face a glimmer of the future: Lillian Gish in miniature, starving, tearstreaked.
Only there could be no Lillian Gish yet. It was years before her dramatic poses, her coyly batting eyes. It was—
Jackson, watching me, growing thinner, as if the unseen editor had evened out the film of the man and the film of the empty chair. Evened it out, only somewhere, someone was making a mistake, because the smell of chlorine was overpowering, the water running from the drenched jacket all the way to the door.
My shoes were wet. My shoes and my feet—
and Jackson stood at the edge of the pool, the wind playing with his hair. Mae Wren stood beside the glass doors—on the outside—and she was gesturing. I could hear the wind, but not her voice.
Jackson was staring at her, staring as the bullets crept closer, moving an inch at a time. I wanted to shout to him, but I didn’t because I knew I wasn’t there, although it felt like I was there, in the morning coolness, the world smelling of chlorine.
The bullets were speeding up, faster, and faster, and faster, until they reached velocity and slammed into Jackson, just as they had done on that field, thwack, thwack, thwack, only this time, he couldn’t move his hand, this time blood sprayed around him, and he toppled into the pool, going under, coming up facedown, and Mae Wren did nothing. She didn’t even scream. She slid inside her house and vanished, like she had done when Mike said I called the police and they arrived and—
Jackson was almost gone. A ghostly image on his chair. He spoke, but I couldn’t hear him, but I sensed this last was important, something he truly needed to tell me, something I had to understand. He reached up—
and there were children. The skeletal girl with the Lillian Gish face, the handsome boy with big eyes, urchins they would be, urchins, crawling from their hiding place and flattening themselves on the screen, growing into familiar faces, famous faces, hiding in plain sight.
Jackson watched them disappear. Then he left the theater—the screening theater, not far from our bungalow—and walked back to the office, a screenplay in his hand. He came inside, sat down, and wrote another, and another, and another and—
—they rustled beside me, a stack of yellowing manuscripts beside my typewriter.
Jackson was gone. So was his jacket.
But the room still smelled of chlorine. A puddle remained beneath the chair, although the trickle to the door was drying.
“Jackson?” I said, but he didn’t answer.
I walked to the chair, careful not to step on the drying trickle or into the puddle. Water beaded on the wooden seat, and on the crullers, and on the coffee cup.
You can see and remember, he said.
I had seen and I did remember, but what did it mean, if anything. What did it all mean?
I don’t know how long I stood there, feeling out of time. The puddle was drying, the beads of water had soaked into the crullers, and the smell of chlorine was fading.
I turned, saw the yellowing papers, and took the top one.
A screenplay.
Not even a screenplay, really, not by modern standards. A photoplay—little more than a paragraph, describing an entire silent film—the way it was done back in the teens:
A boy—we’ll call him “John”—newly orphaned, sobs on the street, gets found by a modern-day Fagin, becomes our Oliver Twist. Steals food to save the life of a starving girl, but Fagin gets angry, wants John to steal money, goods. He spirits the girl away…
And the photoplay cuts off, midsentence.
They all cut off midsentence—photoplays, scenarios, screenplays, growing more and more modern, from silent era title cards to outlines of movies to actual screenplays for talkies. The early ones had “John” and urchins and a too-thin girl, but the later ones—
The later ones were all Mae Wren movies.
I’d seen all of her movies.
I remembered them.
And in each, she flirted with death.
And in each, she did not die.
But Jackson did.
Jackson, who went to see her.
Jackson, whose death finally caught up with him.
Last night.
I ran for Mike the guard, the handsome red-haired guard out of central casting. I scanned the lot for him, tried to ask about him, but no one remembered seeing him, not even the guard at the gate, who did remember me getting into a limo, but did not remember who drove it.
So I hoofed it to my car—a battered Ford that had seen better days, and I drove the way we’d come with the limo, from that small house that smelled of roasting meat and baking bread.
When I parked on the street, no curtains twitched. Apparently, battered cars belonged here when limos did not. I got out, walked to the door, and hesitated.
The nice me, the normal me, she would have knocked.
But I was afraid knocking would send the little men scurrying away.
So, with a trembling hand, I grabbed the knob, turned, and pushed the door open.
They had been sitting. They stood—all four of them. A chair scraped against the hardwood, sounding like a squeal. Like one of the injured horses.
I tried to block the image.
“Who was kidnapped?” I asked.
“We sent you away,” the shortest little man said.
“Who was kidnapped?” I asked again.
He glanced at the others. One of them shrugged. A third gave me a rueful look. The fourth walked to the mantel and grabbed a photograph that had been shoved behind the Seth Thomas clock.
The photograph was large and old, the details painted to add a bit of color, like they used to do fifty years before.
In the previous century.
A young man peered out at me, his jaw narrow, his nose a bit too large. He wore the same uniform as Jackson had in the smoke-filled field, and this young man looked proud.
I had seen him too.
Jackson had bent down, picked him up, and carried him toward a tent, only to vanish in a haze of smoke.
Thin, so young he could seem like an urchin.
We’ll call him “John.”
Only he was too old to be John. By the time John appeared in the first silents—the little ten-minute shorts—this young man would be in his thirties.
But he wasn’t.
He’d grown older slowly.
Like Mae Wren. The other urchin.
Mae Wren, who should be in her fifties now, but looked a perfect twenty-five.
“Who took him?” I asked.
The little men looked at me. Then at each other.
“You won’t believe us,” the shortest little man said.
“I think I will now,” I said, and sat on the arm of one of those heavy chairs.
Initially, there had been a dozen of them. A dozen little men with clockmaker’s magic. They could—for a few seconds—harness time.
“Time,” said the shortest little man, “has a power all its own.”
And they could capture it, hold it in an instant, but they could not reverse it.
But Jackson could. Only for a heartbeat, but sometimes a heartbeat was all it took.
A wave of the hand to send bullets backwards, and then a bit of clockmaker’s magic to make them keep their distance.
A touch of future vision so that he knew who to find, who to save, and who to protect.
A little girl who looked like the first movie star, before the first movie star became famous. A man on a battlefield. An urchin everyone called “John” because no one knew his name.
And others. Many others.
The children in the silents.
He couldn’t protect them all. The little men couldn’t protect them either. The clockmaker’s magic only lasted so long. Film preserved as long as someone saw it, but people stopped watching silents nearly two decades ago.
Only Mae Wren continued, growing a little older so that she could take advantage of that Lillian-Gish-for-the-modern-era face. And “John,” lurking in the background, the perfect extra, written into scenes by Jackson, who protected them all.
Or tried to.
It became harder to get a scenario produced, harder to influence casting. As his power as a screenwriter grew, his real power diminished.
It was, they all knew, only a matter—of time.
“What’s so important about all of this?” I asked. “What does it matter if these people you chose live or die?”
The shortest little man stared at me. “Because,” he said, “they kept the darkness at bay.”
“The darkness?” I asked.
And the shortest little man shook his head. “You’ll know soon enough,” he said. “We couldn’t stop it. So we need you to remember.”
Remember how it could’ve been. How it was, for a short time.
With clockmaker’s magic, using a handful of people to hold back time—some with their bodies (Mae Wren, John), and some with their skills (Jackson)—they kept history at bay.
And someone—the little men didn’t have time to tell me who (how ironic is that? They ran out of time)—figured out what Jackson was doing. That someone or someones—Jackson had said “they”—destroyed the extras, stole John and killed him.
Then the bullets caught Jackson unaware.
And Mae Wren, realizing that I could not recover Jackson’s magic, vanished.
Or maybe she had vanished before, leaving only a reflection in the glass.
The little men were telling me all of it, the history of magic, the way time and history intertwined, and how holding back time briefly changed history. Changed the Twentieth Century from the bloodiest so far to our own little ideal.
Which ended in the middle of that conversation as a new reality slammed into me, and carried me back to the studio, to the day I met Jackson for the very first time.
It started on the studio back lot. You already know what the studio back lot looks like; you’ve seen it in hundreds of films, maybe more. You’ve certainly seen it in the films of the 1940s because location shoots didn’t become common until the 1950s, unless the location was the desert (cue in the Mojave for the Sahara); the mountains (cue in the San Gabriels for the Alps); or the ocean (cue in the Pacific for Mediterranean).
When I think of the studio back lot, I think of hot summer afternoons when the sun blazed golden on the flat white buildings, palm trees swaying in a slight breeze, heat waving off the pavement. We were coming out of a war, so only the big shots got air conditioning—and big shots certainly didn’t mean the writers.
Our windows were open, but shaded with white blinds to reflect that sun back on the eucalyptus plants. Fans swirled the air but didn’t cool it. A lucky few had ceiling fans that twirled lazily above, giving the illusion of chill shade.
Picture Casablanca without Sydney Greenstreet. We had the corrupt government (Warner Brothers), the desperate yet-once prosperous refugees (unemployed writers and actors begging for work), and the cynical former idealists who ran places like Rick’s Café American (the writers and actors who “made” it, at the price of their souls).
I showed up to work every day in a sundress and sandals, ready to make my name with my words. Mostly I typed other people’s words and tried to pretend I wasn’t a glorified secretary. And maybe I wasn’t a glorified secretary because I met some interesting people like William Faulkner (a drunk), Raymond Chandler (an even worse drunk) and, of course, Jackson Holden Carter (who wasn’t a drunk at all).
I still see him the way I met him, half in shadow in the back of the writers’ bungalow. He wore a white suit, a summer suit, but had the jacket on the back of his chair. He’d pushed up the sleeves of his thin shirt and his straw hat rested haphazardly on the papers piled across his desk. He wore suspenders and no tie—at least not one I could see. He was thin and tanned and strong, like the young William Francis Beedle Jr, not the older alcoholic one who staggered his way through The Towering Inferno, but the young virile one who swaggered his way through The Bridge on the River Kwai, the one who could save us from anything, even if he didn’t quite believe it himself.
“Jeez,” Jackson said when he first saw me. “A dame.”
I later thought if I’d been writing the script—me, the woman who eventually wrote 40 produced and 200 unproduced screenplays—I’d’ve snapped a witty comeback and flashed a bit of gam, you know, something unoriginal but expected like “That’s ‘Quite a Dame’ to you, Buster,” something that would let the audience know no one toyed with this broad.
But in those days, people did toy with Elizabeth Nerenhausen, who clutched the sheaf of papers from the studio flunky who’d hired her (as he thought: Poor kid, she believes she’s a writer. Let’s not tell her she’s a secretary) and stammered, “Yes, sir. I mean, no, sir. I mean—”
“Which is it?” Jackson said with some amusement. “Yes, sir, you are a dame, or no, sir, you’re not a dame.”
“I’m not old enough to be a dame, sir,” I blurted. “I’m a writer, that’s all.”
“You’re not old enough to be one of them either,” he said. “But you got something you don’t even know you have because you’re too goddamn young. Tell me, what was the flunky thinking when he sent you over here?”
“I don’t know, sir. I’m not privy to other people’s thoughts.”
He raised his eyebrows. “Not privy? Who the hell are you, the Queen of England?”
I opened my mouth, and he waved a hand at me.
“Don’t answer that,” he said. “You’re too young to be the Queen of England. And you don’t have an accent either.”
He did. Just a bit of one. There was something wrong with his vowels, a curtness to his consonants. He had mostly masked it, but I was good with accents. I could figure out where a man was from, down to the region, if his accent was pure.
Which Jackson’s wasn’t.
“They sent me here, sir,” I said. “Do you need another writer?”
“Clearly the studio thinks I do,” he said without a smile. He rested the legs of his chair on the floor, then grabbed a glass off his desk. It was full of a light brown liquid, which I immediately took for whiskey. Everyone knew how hard writers drank and how important alcohol was to their creative process.
It was only later that I realized Jackson kept his glass filled with unsweetened lukewarm tea, mostly, I thought back then, so that he would fit in.
Of course, I was wrong. Jackson never did anything to fit in, although he did a lot so that he wouldn’t be noticed.
“You type?” he asked.
“Yes, sir,” I said.
He sighed. “First thing, kiddo. I’m not Sir, just like you’re not the Queen of England. Whenever someone stood over me with a sword, they wanted to lop my head off, not rub it on my shoulder for some honorary knighthood. You got that?”
“Yes, s—Yes,” I said.
“Second thing, stop acting like I’m going to slap you silly. They don’t do that on the Warner lot. I heard if you want slapping, you have to go over to MGM and piss off the lion. We clear?”
“I guess,” I said, even though I was more confused than ever.
“And last thing, don’t lie to me, not even when you’re confused, like you are now. Got that?”
I nodded.
“Good. Now hand me that useless paperwork, pick a desk, and type this….” He launched into full dictation as if I had already picked the desk, put some paper in the platen, and started to type.
I tossed the papers the flunkie had given me, pulled out a chair, found more paper, and somehow managed to type everything that Jackson had dictated without asking him to repeat himself.
I rolled in the second piece of paper and paused, but he had stopped talking. I turned in my chair to see him watching me.
“That’s some gift you got there, girl,” he said.
“I took first in my typing class,” I said. “One-hundred-forty words per minute.”
“Faster if your fingers were longer, I bet,” he said, and he wasn’t cracking a joke. He was impressed, although at the time I wasn’t sure why.
“What’s your name?” he asked.
I said, “Elizabeth Nerenhausen,” and he cracked up.
“Well, first thing we all do in Hollywood is make up new names for ourselves, and since your name is so damn German and so damn funny, we’re going to call you something else, okay?”
“It’s my name, sir,” I said.
“And sir isn’t mine,” he said, “but I’ll let that slide. We’ll give it a week to find something you’re comfortable with. That’s how long it’ll take you to decide if you’re cut out for this work anyway.”
I didn’t have to decide. I already knew I was cut out for it. But I didn’t blurt that. I just waited for the next instruction, hoping that by the end of the day I could show this man how brilliant I was.
I didn’t, of course. I didn’t write anything, not for weeks. I typed what he said, and ran pages to actors or directors or whoever was clamoring for his special brand of adventure.
What Jackson didn’t tell me, what it took me half my life to figure out, was that he was giving me the best kind of apprenticeship. I got to sit at the feet of the master and watch him work.
I got to learn.
All over again.
I could still see it and feel it and be part of it all. The little men, out of a fairy tale. Jackson—the other Jackson, so serious, so thin.
The Jackson I had left behind.
This is the world they were trying to save us from. This is the world they had foreseen, the one they tried to prevent.
This world was filled with darkness. It had a new Jackson, and it had world wars and scary little men with mustaches who screamed about supremacy in German. (Had I seen him in the old world? Lurking on the lot? Had he helped Time catch up with Jackson? Or had it been, as Jackson said that last day—the day of his death—we always think we got time, meaning, I thought, that we’d live longer than we thought. But he meant that he thought he had captured time, and he hadn’t. He had just frozen it for a moment or two, until it rebounded—like a rubber band pulled taut and then released. Time had rebounded, and had taken him—my Jackson—with it.)
I never saw the little men again. I did see Mike the guard from central casting. He was a doorman in a fancy New York hotel. He didn’t recognize me, but why would he?
I’m the only one who can remember that world.
This world has better movies, richer culture, a cynicism that didn’t exist in mine. The world I think of as mine, that is. I can remember a world without Sergeant York or All Quiet on the Western Front, a world without Wings or F. Scott Fitzgerald or Ernest Hemingway.
I can remember it all, because I saw it all.
And sometimes I think it’s all a dream.
Except when it leaks into our world.
This world.
Like William Francis Beedle Jr. who looked just like Jackson Holden Carter. William Francis Beedle Jr., who, in his earliest starring role, died in a movie star’s swimming pool. Not of drowning, but because he’d been shot three times.
That film had other echoes—from the movie star trapped in her lost world to the fact that Beedle—who renamed himself William Holden—played a screenwriter.
But a screenwriter who lacked success, unlike Jackson. A screenwriter of B movies, movies that weren’t quite memorable, movies that never really made the cut.
Movies whose Hollywood ending seemed fake, wrong, just a bit off.
I didn’t write Sunset Boulevard. I never write the films that carry echoes of the past that never was—from Snow White and the Seven Dwarves (my world did not have a Walt Disney) to It’s a Wonderful Life, from Harold Lloyd hanging from the clock in Safety Last to Christopher Lloyd hanging from the same kind of clock in Back to the Future, both calling on a clockmaker’s magic that, so far as I can tell, no longer exists.
Now we call it the magic of the movies, not realizing that in a slightly different world, a world as out of phase as the Bedford Falls of Jimmy Stewart’s vision, the movies really had magic.
Enough magic to hold back the trenches and the Holocaust and the purges, Vietnam and Iraq and Afghanistan.
I’m not sure if I find this world more vibrant because I live in it now, or because it has more suffering.
Or if the other one has faded, like my old screenplays have faded, because my mind is no longer sharp.
I wrote down as many of the memories as I could. Most of them are unproduced, lying in some studio’s warehouse somewhere, as lost as the ark in Raiders of the Lost Ark. Only a few have gotten out, and they’re not remembered either.
I’m the screenwriter of B movies, not the next Anita Loos, not Leigh Brackett, not anyone really.
Just the woman who remembers.
And soon I’ll be gone.
Like all those urchins in the silents, unremarked, unremembered, holding onto a world no one cares about any more.
A world that no one in this world even knows about.
A world everyone sees as fiction.
Except me.
____________________________________________
Hollywood Ending
Copyright © 2015 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
First published in Jim Baen’s Universe, April, 2010Published by WMG Publishing
Cover and Layout copyright © 2018 by WMG Publishing
Cover design by WMG Publishing
Cover art copyright © Mikhail Laptev/Dreamstime
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
We are offering a series of Prepare Ahead classes for the writers who are attending our in-person Anthology workshop in August. That workshop is closed, but you all can learn about the craft of writing to a particular subgenre without attending. The Prepare Ahead classes are open to anyone.
On Sunday, the latest class, Military Science Fiction, starts up. Take a look here…and join us!
I’ve been so busy that I almost missed telling you writers (and wannabe writers) about this sale that we’re running on WMG Teachable. We’ve bundled many of our online workshops together, and are offering the bundles at half off. Dean is adding more bundles every day on his website.
To get the bundles, go to our Teachable site, and use the coupon GREATBUNDLE at checkout.
The sale will end early next week, so take a look now.
FOCUS BUNDLE TO LEARN BEYOND SIMPLE DEPTH…The order to take the classes inside the bundle is…
Here are the other four FOCUS BUNDLES so far.
FOCUS BUNDLE TO LEARN DEPTH…The order to take the classes inside the bundle is…
FOCUS BUNDLE TO LEARN PRODUCTIVITY…The order to take the classes inside the bundle is…
FOCUS BUNDLE TO LEARN BASIC WRITING BUSINESSThe order to take the classes inside the bundle is…
1… Magic Bakery
2… Heinlein’s Rules
3… Basic Business of Publishing
4… Flexibility
5… Making More Than Coffee Money
6…Writing Business Structure
7…Kickstarter
FOCUS BUNDLE TO LEARN WRITING SCIENCE FICTIONThe order to take the classes inside the bundle is…
1… Writing Science Fiction
2… Science Fiction World Building
3… Cultures in Space Opera
4… Writing Time Travel
5… Writing Believable Aliens
6…Writing Science Fiction Invasions
7…Science Fiction Craft Study Along
Turn in no homework on any of these and ignore all dates on the classes themselves.All five Focus Bundles have a value over $900. Regular cost is $500. Sale price for the Great Bundle sale is $250.00. So even if you already have a few of these, worth the price in the sale.
John Lundgren loves the challenge of defending his clients. As a public defender in the great city of Chicago, he defends them all: the guilty, the not-so-guilty, and the bug-eyed crazy.
But when he gets assigned Richard Palmer, a highly intelligent man accused of an impossible arson and horrific mass murder, he soon discovers this case will challenge him like no other—just not in any way he ever expected.
“The Best Defense,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
The Best DefenseKristine Kathryn RuschThey tell me time has no meaning here. I sit cross-legged in a glade, surrounded by willow trees and strong oak and all sorts of green plants I don’t recognize. Flowers bloom out of season—roses next to tulips next to mums. The air is warm, the breeze is fresh, and I have never felt more trapped in my life.
Except when I was in law school.
Third year, sitting in my carrel in the law library, various teas stacked around the top, hiding me from the other students. I’d spend a few hours digging through some musty old tomes to find one little nugget of information that might help my hypothetical client or, failing that, impress some stupid professor, all the while wondering if I should just drop out.
Escape.
Pretend the past three years of Aristotelian logic and Socratic debate had never happened at all.
Now I have tea at my fingertips—all I have to do is snap them and some scantily clad nymph pours me a cup—and all the food I want (oh, yeah: that’s the thing they don’t tell you: never eat the food), and it doesn’t matter.
I’m still digging through tomes, trying to find something to get my client off. He’s not so hypothetical any more. Although I am going to have to impress a few people.
People I don’t really want to impress.
People who may not be people at all.
I only caught the case because I didn’t escape quickly enough from Judge Lewandowski’s courtroom. I’d been there to argue against remand for a repeater, even though I knew all of Chicagoland would be better off if he went to prison for life.
That’s what I do. I defend the defenseless. At least, that’s what I tell the newspapers when they ask, or that schmo at a cocktail party who thinks he’ll get the better of a seasoned public defender.
Mostly I do it because I like to argue and I like to win against impossible odds. I’m not one of the liberal-hippie types who gravitates to the PD’s office to save the planet; I’m not even sure I believe everyone is entitled to a fair trial.
What I do believe is that everyone is entitled to the best defense I can provide—given that I have hundreds of other active cases, only twenty-four hours in my day, and no real budget to hire a legal assistant.
Which was actually what I was thinking about as I slipped into the bench two rows back from the defense table to repack my briefcase before heading down to the hot dog carts on California Avenue.
“John Lundgren.”
Hearing my name intoned by the judge after my case has already been gaveled closed was not a good sign. I looked up so fast my notes almost slipped off my lap. I caught them, but lost the briefcase. It thudded against the gray tile floor.
“Yes, Judge,” I said, standing up, even though my entire day’s work was laying in a mess around me.
The judge was peering at me through her half-glasses. She looked tired and disgusted all at the same time. “You’ll represent Mr. Palmer.”
I glanced around, trying to figure out what I’d missed. The courtroom was filled with attorneys waiting for their cases to be called, a few witnesses and even fewer victims, and a couple of defendants who had probably made a previous case’s bail.
“Now,” the judge said.
The one place I hadn’t looked was the defense table. A scruffy man with long black hair stood behind it, his shoulders hunched forward. He wore a trench coat covered with soot, burn marks, and not a few holes.
I slid out of my bench, leaving my briefcase on the floor and grabbing only a yellow legal pad, knowing that no one else would pick up my mess. Unlike TV lawyers, real lawyers are so overwhelmed they don’t dig through each other’s briefcases, hoping for the one nugget of information that will make or break the trial of the century.
Not that I’d ever handled a client involved in the trial of the century. Or even one involved in the trial of the year.
“You must be Mr. Palmer,” I said as I dropped my legal pad on the defense table.
Palmer didn’t even look at me. His face was covered in soot and a three-day-old beard. He smelled like gasoline and smoke.
I didn’t even have to guess what he was charged with. It was as obvious as the stench of his clothes.
The prosecutor—some new twit who looked like he was wearing his father’s suit—rustled his papers together. “Mr. Richard Palmer is charged with arson in the first degree, attempted arson in the second degree, and sixteen counts of murder in the first degree.”
“Mr. Lundgren, how does your client plead?”
I looked at my client, but he didn’t look at me. The smell was so overwhelming, my eyes were watering.
“Mr. Lundgren?”
“Mr. Palmer?” I said softly. “What do you want to plead?”
Palmer kept his head down.
“Mr. Lundgren,” the judge said, “I asked you a question.”
Well, Palmer wasn’t talking. I wasn’t even sure he was present and accounted for. But if he was like 99.9% of my clients, his plea would be simple, no matter what the evidence against him.
“Not guilty, Your Honor,” I said.
“See?” she muttered. “That wasn’t hard, now was it? Bail, counselor?”
She was looking at the young prosecutor. His hands were shaking.
“Since Mr. Palmer is accused of burning down one of the largest mansions on the Gold Coast, your honor, and killing all sixteen people inside, we’re asking for remand.”
He made it sound like they’d ask for more if they could get it.
I opened my mouth, but the judge brought down her gavel so hard it sounded like a gunshot.
“Remand,” she said. “Next case.”
And with that, I became responsible for Richard Mark Harrison Palmer the Third.
Or at least, for his legal defense.
Every last bit of it.
It took hours before I could get to the Cook County Jail to see my brand-new client. By then, he was in prison blues. Someone had washed his face, and surprisingly there were no burns beneath all that soot.
I’d represented arsonists before, many of whom smelled just like Palmer had when he was brought to court, and they were always covered with burns or shiny puckered burn scars.
They were also bug-eyed crazy. Something about staring at fire made their eyes revolve in their skulls—rather like the eyes of someone who’d taken too much LSD over too long a period of time.
But this guy didn’t look crazy. He didn’t give off the crazy vibe either, the one that always made me stand near the door so that I could pound it for a guard and then get the hell out of the way if I needed to.
Palmer sat at the scratched table, his head down, his hands folded before him. His hair was wet and he smelled faintly of industrial soap.
“Mr. Palmer.” I sat down across from him, set my briefcase on the table, and snapped the top open so that it stood like a shield between us. “I don’t know if you remember me. I’m John Lundgren, your court-appointed public defender.”
“I don’t need you.” His voice was deep, his accent so purely Chicago that the sentence sounded more like a mushy version of I doon need yoo.
“I’m afraid you do, Mr. Palmer. You’re charged with some serious capital crimes, and it was pretty clear that Judge Lewandowski doesn’t believe you can handle it on your own. So she assigned me—”
“And I’m unassigning you. Go away.” He looked up as he said that and I was stunned to see intelligence in his blood-shot brown eyes.
I sighed. I always hated clients who argued with me, clients who believed they knew more about the legal system than I did.
Or worse, clients who somehow believed they could go up against Chicago’s finest prosecutors all by themselves.
“I’m not charging you, Mr. Palmer,” I said. “The county pays my salary to represent people who can’t afford their own attorney.”
“I don’t want an attorney,” he said.
I sighed again. It was always a nightmare to go before the judge—any judge—and say that my indigent client wants me off the case in favor of his own counsel. Usually I’d have to sit in anyway, advise the stupid client on matters of the law (or, as I’d privately say, matters on which he was screwing up royally).
“It’s better to have one,” I said, “especially when you’re facing sixteen counts of premeditated murder. You want to tell me what happened?”
Usually that ploy worked. The client forgot his belligerence and wanted to brag. Or to defend himself. Or make excuses.
A lot of my colleagues never wanted to know what the client believed he did, but I always figured the more information I had, the better. That way, I wouldn’t get blindsided by my own client’s idiocy in the middle of trial.
“No, I don’t want to tell you what happened,” Palmer said. “I think it would be better if you leave.”
I closed my briefcase. “You’re not going to be rid of me that easily. I will remain your attorney until we can go to court to sever the relationship, and then the judge is going to want to know all kinds of things, like what kind of preparation you have to represent yourself. And frankly, Mr. Palmer, I’d be remiss if I didn’t—”
“Tell me how stupid I’m being for taking this on alone, I know.” He gave me half a smile. It was condescending. I’d never met an arsonist capable of being condescending before. “But you’re the one who pleaded me not guilty.”
“You weren’t exactly talking,” I said. “I even gave you a moment to give me some kind of response, and you didn’t say a word. So I gave my standard answer. Not guilty. We can always modify the plea later. Do you have medical records that would show mental health treatments—”
“I wasn’t going to plead out to a mental defect,” he said.
My hand froze on top of the briefcase. “You were going to plead guilty? Why in the hell would you do that, Mr. Palmer?”
He shrugged. “It seemed like the only thing to do.”
“Look, I don’t know the details of your case, Mr. Palmer. The file hasn’t come up to our offices yet. So I don’t know what they have on you. But let me tell you, I’ve seen some supposedly tight police cases unravel in court. It might look hopeless now, but I can assure you that with good counsel we should be able to fight this. So let me—”
“I’m not suicidal or stupid,” he said. “I have no defense.”
I’d heard that before too, usually from guilty clients who felt remorse.
“I’ll decide that,” I said, and flicked the locks on the briefcase so the top popped open again. I pulled out the legal pad that had Palmer’s name on it and indictment scrawled almost illegibly in my handwriting. “Just tell me your side of the events.”
“The events, Mr. Lundgren?” He raised his eyebrows at me. I had a sense that I have only rarely, that I was sitting across from someone with an intellect more formidable than mine.
“Where were you? What happened? What exactly are they accusing you of? That kind of thing.”
“You heard what they’re accusing me of. They think I burned down the Brickstone mansion and killed everyone inside.”
I hadn’t known it was the Brickstone mansion. When I was an undergrad at Northwestern, my buddies and I used to climb over the ivy-and-moss covered stone fence onto the three-block expanse of yard owned by the Brickstones. We’d walk to the edge of Lake Michigan, plop behind a group of giant rocks that blocked that section of the shore from the mansion proper, and proceed to get very drunk. We’d see who could drink the most and still be awake for sunrise.
Usually that would be me.
“The Brickstone mansion,” I repeated, trying to put this together. “They say you burned it down?”
I expected him to tell me that was a figure of speech. In fact, so convinced was I that that was going to be his next sentence that I almost missed his actual one:
“To the ground.” His tone was dry. “Nothing left but charred remains.”
I frowned at him. That made no sense. The Brickstone mansion was in Chicago’s city limits—and any building in the city limits had to be made of stone. The famous Chicago Fire left its legacy: no building could be made of combustible materials.
And I’d seen the Brickstone mansion. It was well named. It was made of a kind of white stone you didn’t find outside of the Midwest, but the wealthy in Chicago seemed to adore it. Each “brick” was the size of an armchair, and when I looked at them one drunken dawn, those giant stones gleamed whitely in the light of the rising sun.
“Did you see it?” I asked. “What was left?”
“Of course I saw it,” he said. That look was making me uncomfortable. I was beginning to feel as if I truly was dumber than he was.
“And was it burned to the ground?”
“Nothing left except rubble,” he said.
“You smelled of gasoline when I met you, Mr. Palmer,” I said.
He shrugged.
“Gasoline fires burn hot.”
He looked down.
“But they can’t melt stone. You want to tell me what’s going on?”
He lifted his head. His mouth was open slightly, as if he hadn’t expected real thought from me. “I burned down the Brickstone mansion,” he said. “Killing everyone inside.”
I no longer believed him. “How?”
“What do you want me to do? Say I waved my magic wand, brought down lightning from the heavens into a puddle of magicked up gasoline, and caused the building to explode?”
It was my turn to shrug. “That’s about the only thing that would reduce that white brick mansion to rubble.”
“Well, then,” he said, crossing his arms. “That’s exactly what I did.”
We left it at that. I couldn’t get him to tell me anything else, and I didn’t really try because he seemed to have dumped the idea of firing me. He didn’t exactly say I could stay, but he nodded when I said I’d be back after I had a chance to review the file.
I took that as a change of heart. We were now attorney and client, whether either of us liked it or not.
So I went back to the office in hopes of finding the file. It was on my desk along with six other brand-new case files, eight old case files, and the seven cases I’d been trying desperately to plead out. My office was a graveyard of active files. They trailed off my desk to boxes on the floor, accordion files on my chair, and half-opened file cabinet drawers beneath my window.
I wasn’t exactly overworked. Overworked would mean that I had some free time to look forward to. My workload was impossible, which made it exactly like everyone else’s workload inside the Public Defender’s office.
Which should have meant that the minute I saw all those piles of paper, I should have forgotten about Palmer. But I didn’t. In fact, I grabbed his file first.
It was incomplete. A lot of the paperwork had little typed notations TK which, oddly enough, meant “to come” (I always thought, shouldn’t that be TC? Probably too close to TLC, something the police department did not believe in). A few sticky notes explained that the documentation was being copied, and one handwritten note said that the arson squad planned to finish its investigation tomorrow and would have a detailed report by the end of the week.
And pigs would fly out of my butt.
But I made do with what I had. I often got incomplete files, especially on cases as new as this one. Sometimes the police department felt they’d done enough, and would “forget” to update me. So every morning, I made a list of cases that needed additional material, and I’d talk to a clerk who’d talk to a squad leader who’d talk to a detective who would sigh and fill out the necessary paperwork.
The more times I had to do that, the more the detective got irritated at me, so that by the time we went to court, I was usually as big a bad guy in the detective’s eyes as the person he arrested. Fortunately for me, detectives, while smart, aren’t all that articulate, and I can—if I choose—slice one of them into tiny little pieces on the stand.
I don’t always choose. Because if I do, that detective and his buddies’ll be gunning for me on the next case. So I reserve such treatment for special cases.
I had a hunch this was one those.
Special. How I hated that word.
But I stopped feeling sorry for myself and started to make notes about all I could glean from the file.
At 12:13 a.m., neighbors near the Brickstone Mansion (and you’d have to be stretching it to call them neighbors, considering the three-block lawn, the half-mile driveway, and the large stone fence blocking the view) called 911 to report flames shooting into the sky “so high that it looked like the entire North side is on fire.” A few boats on Lake Michigan called in a massive fire as well.
The fire seemed localized around the Brickstone Mansion. Fire crews were called in. When they arrived, they realized the doors were all bolted shut on the outside. The building was “fully engaged.” When they attempted to put out the fire, the entire place exploded.
Debris fell all over that massive yard, but somehow managed to miss outbuildings, vehicles, and people. Fortunately, the flaming debris did not ignite secondary fires anywhere on the property or on nearby properties.
But the mansion itself was a total loss.
By six a.m., it was clear to fire investigators that at least sixteen people had died inside that building—all of them unidentified. An accurate body count was, according to the report, TK.
Investigators found my client hiding between the shrubs and the stone wall—on the inside of the Brickstone property. He smelled of gasoline, had soot marks on his hands, and “couldn’t give a coherent account of where he had been or what had happened to him.”
Finally, when pushed, he said, “I had to do it,” and then clammed up.
The fire department called in the police, who arrested my client, and brought him to the station.
I searched the file and found no mention of hospitals or trauma centers or counselors. I made a note of that too—because it was good for us.
Then I continued to read. At the police station, my client was offered breakfast including coffee (they always make that sound like a service when, in fact, I think it part of the torture), which he declined. He was interrogated, but refused to say much more than what he said to me, which was that no one would believe what actually happened.
Finally, the exasperated detectives figured they had enough to charge him, and brought him into Judge Lewandowski, where the lucky defendant got introduced to me.
Which was going to make Mr. Palmer’s day—or rather, his tomorrow. Because I was filing a motion first thing to have his case immediately thrown out for lack of evidence. And for severe mistreatment on the part of the police and fire departments. The man was covered in soot and gasoline. He needed to go to a hospital. He was probably disoriented when they found him.
There was no proof that he wasn’t in that house when it exploded, and had somehow miraculously survived.
I was going to argue all of that in front of whatever sympathetic judge I could find (adding, of course, as much legal mumbo jumbo as I could assemble by nine a.m.)
I was pretty good at putting together case dismissal arguments, so good I wouldn’t need to do too much research on the case law. And I think my client’s appearance (I’d put him back in his street clothes for court), his non-confession, and one or two well-timed coughs on his part, would be enough to get him off.
I was in a great mood as I outlined the argument on my trusty laptop—until I got the hair-brained idea to look up Palmer himself.
Palmer is an old and venerable name in Chicago. During the last half of the nineteenth century, Potter Palmer and his wife Bertha remade Chicago into the city it is today. In addition to building the Palmer House Hotel, they donated their private art collection to the Art Institute (those Monets? Bertha’s), redesigned downtown Chicago into the configuration it has today, and built the very first mansion on Chicago’s Gold Coast.
In fact, it was their decision to move north (or rather, Bertha’s) that segregated the rich from the rest of the plebs in Chi-town. If there hadn’t been Palmers in Chicago, there wouldn’t have been a Brickstone mansion to burn down, over a century later.
Richard Mark Harrison Palmer the Third was related to those Palmers but not on the right side of the sheets. From what I could gather, the first Richard Mark Harrison Palmer was really Richard Mark Harrison until he got someone to admit something and prove that there was Palmer blood in the Harrison bloodline.
That didn’t get Richard the First any money or any of the Palmer property (of which there is still a lot, at least according to city rumors), but it did give him some status among people who care about that kind of thing.
Which led to his son and his grandson getting the family name (and, apparently, the family snobbery), as well as inheriting the family business.
When Richard the First ran it, it was some kind of ghostly empire where a number of “real” mediums brought back the dead, if only for an evening and a bit of conversation. By the time Richard the Third inherited it, it had become a school for the psychic and those with magical abilities.
I didn’t make a note of that or any of the rest of this, particularly the files I found all over the internet about Richard the Third being some kind of magical hero—a man with strong abilities who wasn’t afraid to use them to fight the Forces of Darkness.
Stories like this—even though they came from places like the Star and the National Enquirer—would be enough to torpedo my case, if I couldn’t get the damn thing dismissed. At the moment, it wouldn’t negate my client’s mistreatment at the hands of the authorities, although it would explain that mistreatment.
No one likes a nutcase. Particularly a nutcase with delusions of grandeur.
And sure enough, the following morning, the prosecution brought it all up while we stood in front of the judge, arguing for dismissal. Palmer stood on the other side of me, reeking in his gasoline- and smoke-damaged clothing.
When we met just before court, I told him to look as pathetic as he could which really wasn’t hard for him, considering the ill treatment he’d gotten in jail the night before. I’d also asked him to give me at least two deep tuberculoid coughs, one at the beginning of the hearing and the other somewhere in the middle.
His first cough, just after Judge Galica entered, was a tour-de-force of shudders and phlegm. It was so convincing that the Judge himself asked Palmer if he needed water or a lozenge or—heaven forbid—a break. But Palmer managed to shake his head, and the prosecutor used that moment to shoot me an accusatory glare as if I’d been the one to do the coughing.
This time, the prosecutor wasn’t a baby. It was Rita Varona, one of the office’s very best. Normally she made me nervous.
This morning, she didn’t. They’d sent her because of the judge we’d been assigned.
Judge Joseph Galica had gone from law school to the Fair Housing Council and later became an advocate for the homeless before getting appointed to the bench. He was as liberal as possible, someone who knew the excesses of the Chicago police (some say because he was in the middle of the 1968 riots and got teargassed), and who actually believed that all defendants should be treated with respect.
Yes, I milked Galica’s attitude. But I did focus on the legal argument as well. I was brilliant, and was about to make my most important point when Palmer interrupted me with another prolonged coughing spell—this one requiring a glass of water from the bailiff.
That spell got Varona to butt in, saying what a fake Palmer was, both in his life and his profession, that he had a hatred of the Brickstones, and he’d told a number of people that the house on the coast was “evil” and had to be destroyed.
I carefully did not look at my client while these arguments got made. Varona talked a lot about my client’s beliefs, and finally made the slip I was hoping for.
“He claims he’s a magician, Judge,” she said. “Once the arson squad’s reports come back, we’ll be able to show that he used the wonders of science—chemistry and physics—to explode that house as if he’d performed a spell on it.”
“Why would he do that?” I asked in my best snide manner.
Varona gave me a sideways glance. She’d hoped for that question. “To cement his claim that he’s the best wizard in the city of Chicago. To get rid of a family that he considered to be his enemy and to increase his business traffic and visibility at the same time.”
Then she launched into his family’s history of quackery as if that were proof of his murderous tendencies.
I let her talk, even though the judge kept glancing at me, clearly wanting me to object.
Finally, the judge himself said in a blatant hint-hint, nudge-nudge kinda way, “Mr. Lundgren, what do you have to say about Ms. Varona’s claims?”
I made sure I didn’t grin. This was the moment I’d been waiting for.
“Simply this, Your Honor. If my client really were Chicagoland’s best wizard, then he should have been able to get himself out of jail. In fact, he would have cast some kind of spell on the responding officers to leave him alone or on the fire investigators so that they wouldn’t find him. Instead, he spent the night in lockup and has the bruises to prove it.”
“Your Honor,” Varona said. “I never claimed he was a wizard. Just that he advertised himself to be one.”
“And if he’s not a wizard,” I said over her, “then all you have to do is look at the family history that Ms. Varona outlined to see that there’s a solid record of mental instability here. And the Chicago PD knows it. That’s why they didn’t take him to the hospital. That’s why they conducted such a shoddy interrogation. And that’s why the fire investigator’s report doesn’t record what my client actually said when they found him. Just that he—and I quote—’couldn’t give a coherent account of where he had been or what had happened to him.’”
“He’s clearly guilty, your honor,” Varona said. “He was on the scene. He’s wearing the same clothes he wore yesterday and I’m sure you can tell from there that they stink of smoke and gasoline. He—”
“Gasoline?” I said, trying not to overplay my incredulousness. “Your Honor, Brickstone mansion was built of stone. Gasoline couldn’t burn that place down. Nor could it cause an explosion of the magnitude described in the other reports. I got assigned this case while Mr. Palmer was standing alone in front of Judge Lewandowski. I didn’t get the file until late last night. That’s why we’re here. If I’d had any of this information, I would have asked for dismissal then.”
Varona rolled her eyes. “Your Honor, Mr. Palmer is a very dangerous man—”
“If that’s true,” the judge said, “you should have waited until you had a real case before charging him. I’m going to drop all the charges against this poor man, and I’m going to instruct his attorney to get him to the hospital immediately.”
And the gavel came down.
Palmer turned to me. His mouth was open, and his eyes were wide. I’d never seen a man look so astonished.
“That,” he said, “was pure magic. You’re amazing.”
I shrugged. It was less egotistical than agreeing. Then I touched his arm. “You heard the judge. I have to make sure you get medical treatment.”
Palmer nodded. We walked out of the courtroom together, and I surreptitiously checked my watch. Another two hours before I had to be back. I actually could take the guy to get medical care.
Besides, the judge would probably check, so I wanted to be able to prove I’d followed instructions.
“You know,” I said as we walked down the stairs, “you might want to pull every favor you have and hire a good attorney. Because the prosecutor’s office will come after you again.”
“I’m not worried,” he said.
“Yesterday, you were ready to chuck it all.”
He smiled. “Yesterday I had no idea what a good defense lawyer can do.”
I permitted myself one small smile of satisfaction.
We walked in silence through the hallways that connected the courthouse with the Public Defender’s office. Because Palmer reeked so bad, I stopped at a desk and asked for an official car to take us to the hospital. I didn’t want Palmer in my used Lexus.
As we waited, Palmer turned to me. “You seem to love what you do.”
“Yeah,” I said.
“Because you appreciate the challenge.” That sense I’d had of his intelligence came back. He’d seen through me faster than most did.
“Yes,” I said.
“Would you consider continuing to defend me?”
“If they charge you again, you can come to me,” I said, hoping it wouldn’t come to that. Then I realized I already had a strategy in place. I’d work the evidence, and if that turned against us, then I’d get a few shrinks to examine the family history and Palmer himself and declare him mentally incompetent. He’d probably get time in a mental hospital or some outpatient counseling, but that wouldn’t necessarily be bad—if all those articles on his past had even a smidgeon of truth.
“Good,” he said. “Then you won’t mind handling the most difficult part of the case.”
And Lord help me, I thought he was still talking about the criminal case. Because egotistical me, I said, “The difficult part of any case is my favorite part.”
Which is how I ended up here in this glade, surrounded by willow trees and strong oak and all sorts of green plants I don’t recognize. A place where the breeze is warm and smells of roses, and the little creatures who bring me food and drink have human faces and multicolored wings.
You see, the most difficult part of the case is arguing to get Palmer’s magic back. Apparently, the magical world has laws and rules and regulations just like ours. And while there isn’t jail per se, there are worse punishments, like taking away someone’s magical abilities.
Palmer is Chicagoland’s greatest wizard. He can wave a wand and bring down lightning from the sky to ignite a puddle of magically enhanced gasoline to destroy a mansion made of stone. (And yes, I checked just before I got whisked here. There was a lightning storm that night.)
It seems no one here cares that Palmer destroyed the house. They’re not even that upset that he managed to kill the beings inside which were—if the files I have scattered across the grass are to be believed—dragons that could assume human form.
Seems the dragons had a plan to steal every treasure in the City of Chicago, starting with the contents of the Art Institute first, but ending with every human treasure, like the Chicago Bears—the actual team members, not the team ownership. When dragons steal a city’s treasure, they don’t move it. They just take over the city. Chicago would have been a haven for evil—that’s what Palmer says—and after seeing the folks who run the magical justice system, I’m inclined to believe him.
Not that I have to. I just have to defend him. I have to make the case that even though he used his magic injudiciously and caused sixteen deaths and—worse, under magic laws—called attention to himself in the non-magical world, he was justified in doing so.
Palmer’s right; this is the most difficult part of the case. Not to make the argument—I’m great at argument. But to understand the stupid magical laws. I have to know the system before I can beat it.
Which is why his magical friends dumped me here, in this glade which is run by faeries. And what I didn’t know at first was these faeries are the kind Rip Van Winkle ran into on his famous night of bowling and carousing. These folks control time. They make it go slow or they speed it up.
Palmer promises me I’ll have all the time in the world to do my research. I won’t lose a day of my life. I’ll be here, I’ll make my arguments, I’ll win my case (I’d better, considering what these people can do), and then I’ll go home as if nothing’s happened.
Of course, I’ll be a little older, a little grayer, a little paunchier. They can’t completely negate the effects of time on a human being.
But, as Palmer says, now at least I’ll know how people seem to age overnight.
As if that’s supposed to cheer me up while I sit here in sunshine-filled hell, eating the best food and drinking tea by the gallon, reading parchment and watching tiny replays of arguments made through the ages.
And I do mean ages.
Magic has existed a long, long time. Longer than the United States. Longer than the Magna Carta. Longer than England or the Roman Empire or Ancient Greece.
Our laws aren’t based on Greek conventions or English common law. They’re a modification—an improvement (believe me)—of magical law.
Which just makes it all the more confusing.
And I’m told, defense attorneys aren’t required here. So no one goes into that side of the magical legal system.
After reviewing one-one-thousandth of the documentation before me, I can see why. It’s hard to defend these people against anything. And not just because of the convoluted law, but because of all the things they’ve done.
Fortunately for Palmer, I’m not one of those liberal-hippie types who gets appalled when his client is actually guilty. I’m not in this to provide a fair trial. I’m in this to provide the best defense I possibly can.
Because I like to argue and I like to win against impossible odds.
And that’s exactly what I’m going to do.
____________________________________________
The Best Defense
Copyright © 2018 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Crime Spells, edited by Martin H. Greenberg and Loren L. Coleman, Daw Books, February 2009Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2018 by WMG PublishingCover design by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Christianm/Dreamstime
As some of you know, WMG suffered quite the business crisis this spring. Suffice to say that it was startling and angry-making. The upshot, though, is that the company is healthier than ever before…and I need to be the one in charge for a while.
That would get in the way of my writing, if I wasn’t the most stubborn writer on the planet. However, the way that I’m guaranteeing that I write is running a challenge with other writers to see if they can write as much as I do this summer. This focuses me and gets me to write first no matter what else is going on.
If you’re a writer…or know one...here’s a link to the challenge, with explanations. Read all the way through. Chances are, this summer, you’ll be able to beat my numbers. But let’s try together, shall we?
As you prepare to embark on your yearlong space cruise, this excerpt from Amelia Pillar’s popular Etiquette for the Space Traveler will provide you with the skills you need to make your trip enjoyable for you and your fellow travelers. With tips such as making the most of the zero-G experience, interacting with new species, and properly utilizing your steward, this guide will help you channel your inner adventurer and negotiate your vacation without fear of misstep.
“Amelia Pillar’s Etiquette for the Space Traveler,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here or in Colliding Worlds, Vol 4.
Amelia Pillar’s Etiquette for the Space Traveler Kristine Kathryn RuschThe Interstellar Travel Company provides this short complimentary manual for each passenger on its ships. Travelers desiring more information should buy the entire updated version of Amelia Pillar’s Etiquette for the Space Traveler in the gift shop.
I. IntroductionFor most travelers, a trip on an interstellar cruise ship is a once-in-a-lifetime experience. Few can afford the minimum three-month trip to the outer regions of the solar system. Even fewer can afford the yearlong adventure to the five nearby star systems which you are about to embark upon.
Should this trip go according to plan (and rest assured, most do), you will see native creatures in the wild, see aliens on their homeworlds, and see natural wonders beyond human imagination.
This short guide shall prepare you for all of those things.
But first, you must survive the trip itself. And for many first-time travelers, the trip is the most difficult aspect of the journey.
II. The ShipThe Suite:By now, you have arrived in your suite and you are a bit startled at its size. Even though the designers have done all they can to make the two- or three-room cabin that will be your home for the next twelve months seem large, you feel momentarily claustrophobic.
This is caused, in part, by the low ceiling and the large furniture. The large furniture accommodates all of our human guests, including those of expansive girth. If you and your traveling companion do not consider yourselves expansive, summon your steward and request normal-size furniture.
Once your steward reprograms your couch and easy chairs to smaller proportions, your living area will seem quite large. However, do not request a smaller bed. Although such a request seems quite practical now on the first day of your voyage, it will not as the trip progresses.
Have your steward show you where the blinds are. While the floor-to-ceiling windows with views of space and its environs seem quite lovely at the moment, there will be times on this voyage when you do not want to be reminded that you are in a tube floating through a hostile environment, with only a thin membrane between you and the vacuum of space.
For the most part, such realities will not impede upon your journey. But there will be moments, particularly after the first round of survival drills, when you will think that you have made a terrible mistake by leaving the safety of Earth.
At that time, remind yourself that you are an adventurer!
Adventurers explore the great beyond. You are part of a grand tradition of travelers who venture into hostile environs. The ship’s library carries adventure journals going as far back as the Victorian era. Consider yourself an English gentleman riding his first elephant. Or a well-heeled 19th century woman venturing down the Amazon with only a parasol and native guides to protect her.
In that spirit of adventure, you will learn how to use the lifepods. You will become an expert at locking yourself in your room and establishing its own internal environmental system. You will excel at putting on your own environmental suit and sending messages through its comm links to the nearest interstellar vessels.
Look at such drills as tests of the imagination. Remember that in the century of interstellar cruising, we have only lost ten thousand ships—and more than half of those were in the difficult early years.
When you finish your first drill, you will feel a bit shaken. It is only natural. Close the blinds, pour yourself one of the nice cabernets from your ensuite wine cabinet, dim the lights, and watch the living room holounit—preferably a scene from one of the places you are about to visit.
This is not the time to regret your decision! You must remember that you are an adventurer and up to each task that faces you!
The Public Areas:Depending on the size of your ship and the number of guests, the public areas will seem either unbelievably large or amazingly cramped.
In each case, remember that you shall be traveling with the same group of people for the next 365 days. It is best not to antagonize them. Loud noises and strong odors cause the most clashes on cruise ships.
Unfortunately, both loud noises and strong odors emanate from children. Should your ship allow children in the adult common areas, make certain you go into those areas accompanied by your most tolerant attitudes.
Should you have children of your own, sniff them before you take them from your suite. If they have eaten something offensive (onions come to mind) or are in need of changing, take care of those problems before venturing into the corridor. School your children in the art of silence. Although our ancestors’ adage “Children should be seen and not heard” is outdated on Earth, it should be the mantra of the cruising parent.
Even ships that allow children in the adult areas have child-only sections. We suggest that you and your children spend all of your time in those sections. You and your fellow passengers will be happy—and you will avoid the sniffing, silencing rituals that other, more insensitive parents must go through.
Environmental Systems:The environmental systems on all Interstellar Travel Company’s ships are state-of-the-art. However, on certain stretches of the trip (particularly those trips with long distances between stops), the Earth-level gravity must be shut off so that the system can go through its weekly routine maintenance.
Some travelers get ill in zero-G. If you are one, inform your steward. You may receive permission to activate your ensuite environmental system, preserving your Earth gravity.
However, true adventurers overcome their space sickness to learn the joys of traveling in zero-G.
Zero-G makes even the most jaded traveler feel like a child again. Floating is the closest we humans get to flying. On the first zero-G section of the trip, you will see even the stodgiest passenger giggling hysterically as he cartwheels weightlessly through the corridors.
Most of these zero-G adventures will only last a few hours, but one, in the very center of the yearlong trip, will last two days.
This creates certain challenges. It is usually best to forgo water showers during this extended period. Instead, take a sponge bath following the specific instructions posted on the wall of your bathroom.
Rest assured that each bathroom on the ship has straps on the toilet, plus a special seat cover that prevents your waste from floating out of the room with you. (If traveling with children, one must insist that each member of the family use the seat cover or your suite will become uninhabitable in short order.)
Dining presents its own challenges. The ship offers courses called “Dining in Zero-G.” Only those who have taken the courses will be allowed extensive meals. Everyone else will be given food cubes for the duration of the gravity outage.
Your bed comes with an attachable pouch, so that you can sleep during the long gravity outage. Have your steward assemble the pouch for you days before the outage begins. After the outage begins, he will be dealing with emergencies (usually caused by those travelers who do not believe in following instructions) and will have no time for the niceties of setting up sleeping pouches.
III. ExcursionsMost excursions will take you to approved human areas of various alien worlds. While many of you will tell the staff you are fully capable of behaving well unsupervised, do not leave the designated areas and follow the guidelines for each trip.
The aliens you meet in these designated areas will be accustomed to human contact. They will abide by our customs, provided you do not accidentally grab the wrong appendage when you are shaking “hands.”
Aliens outside of these areas will follow their own customs. And while there are stories of passengers carried away by angry aliens, such tales simply are not true. These stories come from the land of the Buhgeye, tall green aliens with an appreciation of human beauty. Those passengers carried off, screaming, in a single tentacle, return much later, mollified and holding a flattering self-portrait.
IV: Returning HomeOnce you have embarked on your adventure, you will not be able to return home until the designated date. Since you have signed documentation to such effect, no amount of begging or pleading or bribery will allow you to disembark at the nearest space station and make a return trip.
The ship has the finest doctors, so health issues will be resolved on board. Medications and therapies will help those passengers who suffer from advanced space sickness, claustrophobia, and homesickness. Those passengers unable to withstand the rigors of space travel will spend the entire trip in our virtual reality unit, reliving stress-free moments from their past or adventures from stories provided by resident psychiatrists.
As the end of the journey nears, most passengers find themselves unwilling to leave the familiarity of their (now-comfortable) suite. Unfortunately, you must disembark upon arrival at our Earth port. We do provide a reacclimitization service that helps our passengers regain their “land legs” again.
To help reintegrate yourself into society, do not brag about your trip to your friends. Show them a few select highlights, but let them ask the questions.
Passengers who brag and worse, those who embellish the details of their adventure are the ones who become the source of the rumors you have heard about the discomforts of space travel. Spare future passengers the hyperbole, particularly if they plan to travel on an Interstellar Travel Company cruise ship in the future.
V: Further InformationPassengers who desire more information on various aspects of space travel should visit the gift shop. In addition to Amelia Pillar’s Etiquette for the Space Traveler, passengers will find other illuminating titles, such as Space Viruses and How to Avoid Them, Zero-G for Dummies, and the ever-popular Aliens: The Good, the Bad, and the Edible.
Amelia Pillar’s Etiquette for the Space TravelerCopyright © 2016 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Asimov’s SF Magazine, July, 2010Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2016 by WMG PublishingCover design by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Victor Habbick/Dreamstime
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
Asimov’s Science Fiction has just published my story, “Last Thursday.” Honestly, I love this story. It was fun and cathartic to write.
I’m also with great company in the volume. From a novella by Michèle Laframboise to poetry by Bruce Boston, the writers in this issue are stellar (pun intended).
So pick up your copy today by clicking here.
We’re doing a number of fun things this summer. One of those things begins this weekend.
We’ve revived our Anthology Workshop, which is an in-person workshop. It’s very advanced, and it takes a lot of work and fortitude for a writer to be accepted into it. This year’s Anthology Workshop is closed. But we’ve been trying to figure out how to bring in new writers, slowly and with some training.
With that in mind, we’ve opened the Prepare Ahead class (designed for the writers who are coming) to writers who are not going to attend. You’ll get to learn about the various subgenres, and write to the guidelines. The first class starts on Sunday at midnight.
Here’s the promotion material:
Welcome to the Prepare Ahead class in conjunction with the 2024 Anthology Workshop being held in Las Vegas, Nevada the first week of August.
As each of the six anthologies for this year come up, the writers attending the Anthology Workshop in person will get these classes for free to help them understand better what the editor is looking for.
This year, for the first time, we are opening up these to anyone interested in writing for the anthologies.
The classes will include a short Zoom interview with each editor about what they are looking for and not looking for in their anthology. Then there will be 10 or more videos about the genre and the subject and how to write for it.
The stories must be written in the same timeframe as those who are attending with the exact same deadline and word counts. The editors of each anthology will give you comments by email after the workshop, or possibly buy your story for their book.
These will all be WMG books. Details will be posted.
There are six anthologies, one story per week. As those in the in-person class, you can try to write for all six or just pick and choose. But those in class will be attempting to write all six.
We hope you join us. It will be great fun, even if you can’t make it to Vegas for the Anthology Workshop.
Here’s the link: https://wmgwriterstore.com/collections/anthology-2024-prepare-ahead-classes
If you want to sign up for all of them, then you need to do so in the next two days, because the first anthology goes live on Sunday night.
If you only want to sign up for one or two, you can do so in the next few weeks. Realize, though, that you might miss the genre that you’re interested in.
Again, here’s the link: https://wmgwriterstore.com/collections/anthology-2024-prepare-ahead-classes
This is going to be a lot of fun. We’re looking forward to it. I hope you join us!
As a long-time embedded reporter, Khalil thinks he’s seen it all. But during his latest assignment—against an enemy he doesn’t understand and in a conflict he understands less—Khalil finds himself in the middle of the action, but not in the way he expected. And he quickly realizes that what lies beneath the surface on this ice-covered planet will change his life, and the lives of many others, forever.
USA Today bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch draws on her background as a professional journalist to pen this transformative tale that superbly captures the friction between the press and the military and demonstrates that valor can be found in the least expected places.
“Embedded,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here or included in Colliding Worlds, Vol. 5.
EmbeddedKristine Kathryn RuschWe cover from a distance:
Embedded in the unit, not part of the unit. Observers who occasionally get an arm slammed across their chest like a three-year-old about to run into traffic. We see all, understand little, and report next to nothing.
Welcome to the life of the embedded reporter.
I thought it’d be so glamorous. Sixteen tours later, five wars, thirty war zones, I’ve seen nothing glamorous. I’ve seen a lot of dirt, dust, blood. Too many severed limbs and even more severed lives. Lost lots of friends; lots of personal enemies, too.
Got pelted with shrapnel, nearly lost my own arm, held a colleague while she died screaming in pain. Then left that war zone to go to a bloodless conflict fought by computers and robots, and thought I’d go mad from boredom. Games are more exciting: even though they’re pretend, they at least have virtual blood.
I realized I wanted to see blood. Real blood. Then I worried that I had gone blood mad.
And then, ironically, I arrived here.
I’d heard about LaDucci in a sideways kinda way. Men were taken out of Basic and sent to LaDucci training. Not too terribly unusual: soldiers were taken out of Basic all the time and rerouted to more specialized training. Not even the gender specificity was unusual: some conflict zones suited some genders better than others.
Women take down the Enfelz with almost no effort, but men get no traction at all. Something to do with the biological makeup of both species. Men were part of the attack force heading to Enfelz, but only in support positions.
Just like men and women were in support positions for the Hanen, where the gender neutrals who preferred to remain in that twilight between the gender they were born with and the gender they should’ve been born with, fought with a ferocity (and a success rate) not equaled in any other field of battle.
Men got the LaDucci, and the rumor was that it was because men partnered better, but I’d never seen that. Humans were humans—some partnered with other humans just fine and some sucked at working with another.
I sucked at working with someone else, which is why I usually embedded and usually went into the unit alone. With that system, I got the backup of a military unit without the pain in the ass of dealing with another reporter. I even did my own filming and uploading, learned how to use all the equipment from driving trucks to flying low-to-ground vehicles to piloting my own orbit-to-ground ship. Heck, I can even pilot a small spaceship if necessary, although I do mean small. I’ve trained on two-person ships, but I’ve flown ten-person ships—badly, but I’ve done it.
I took LaDucci like I’ve taken every assignment for the past eight years—vowing it would be my last. Each was a step down in the war zone ladder. I went from the wars that the folks back home cared about to the wars they didn’t care about but had to focus on to the wars they’d never heard of but might care about to wars they’d never care about no matter what happened.
Technically, LaDucci was my first non-war—a conflict that someone else was fighting but with our help. In the as-yet-unwritten histories, LaDucci will get mentioned only if we have severe casualties in some unplanned military action that goes wildly out of control.
Otherwise, LaDucci will remain one of those and we sent support troops conflicts, the kind that gets a half-sentence mention in any history of modern warfare until some enterprising historian decides to focus her entire thesis on the conflict, publishes the account, and gets fêted for finding lost stories of war. That’s at least a hundred years out, and thank whatever god I’ll never live to see it.
Maybe my imaginary future historian will find this little document. I wonder what she’ll make of it.
Wish I could accompany it into the future, and assure her that it’s all true.
Because there are times when I have trouble believing it myself.
LaDucci had devolved into a ground war over some frozen tundra on the northernmost continent of a backwater planet in the Scrarart System. The war—excuse me, conflict—had started when the Milwans wanted to depose some genocidal dictator who was screwing up their trade plans in the region.
We got involved because the Milwans had a treaty with the Keylen Alliance who got their military backup from the Mars Union who always partnered with troops from Northern Earth.
Hell, our people were knee-deep in weird grayish-green snow before our leaders even knew we’d become involved in LaDucci. And by then, it was too late. Too much money, too many lower-level promises, too many alliances at risk to pull out.
The politicians had been assured this was mostly a clean war—fought with computers and tech (other groups’ tech)—and in the beginning it had been. But about the time those assurances happened, the first troops hit the snow, and by the time someone wanted out, entire training units had developed for troops to send to LaDucci, because it took a specialized kind of human fighter, and once the politicians learned that, they hemmed and hawed and decided that we needed to learn to fight alternative wars, and they labeled LaDucci one of those, and once I saw that memo float past my daily feed, of course, I had to get involved.
I mean, what the heck is an alternative war?
I embedded in the next unit heading to LaDucci, thinking I would get to see a snow-conflict firsthand.
Instead, I got weird-ass shit right from the very beginning.
The embeds get decided up top. I’m not sure how far up top, but farther away than some Podunk war in some backwater system. So when I arrived at SC3RT15, the main base for the LaDucci Action (as it’s officially called), I got sent to the Corps Commander, which never happens. Usually I arrive, head to the press office, get assigned a unit, get a dressing down from Whoever Runs The Thing—all of it involving stupid rules that (in recent cases) I knew before Whoever was born. Heck, some of those rules were put into place after I did something that convinced the military that they needed a new rule to prevent anyone from doing that something again.
This time, I didn’t go to the press office. I was sent directly to the Corps Commander.
I’d never encountered her before, but I knew her reputation. I also knew that this posting was a demotion for her, particularly since the rules of engagement stated that no women should fight on LaDucci for “species interaction” reasons. In other words, she could be in charge of the whole fight—from space, far away from the action.
She’d been pretty once, although she’d probably kick my ass for saying that. The pretty had disappeared into a tight-lipped expression that raised lines around her narrow mouth and suspicious eyes.
“Can’t have you here, Khalil,” she said. “You’re male.”
I rolled my eyes. Of all the reasons she could have chosen, she chose the one I knew was false.
“C’mon, Commander,” I said. “The guidelines say men only in LaDucci.”
“Only men can serve in the LaDucci campaign,” she said. “Reporters and support staff need to be female.”
I couldn’t resist. “You’re support staff?”
She gave me a preoccupied smile. “Nice try, Khalil. You can’t sidetrack me here.”
“Honestly, I’m not trying to. They sent me, I’m officially embedded, I get to go where my unit goes.”
She studied me. She knew I was right. Once a reporter’s name was attached to a unit already involved in a conflict, the reporter owned that story.
“If you stay, you’re going to regret this one, Khalil.”
My turn to flash the preoccupied smile. “Commander,” I said, “I regret each and every one of them.”
When the conflict doesn’t matter to you, war zones differ only by environment. Hot, cold, one sun, five suns—it doesn’t matter. What changes is how you dress and how you deal. Sometimes you wear full environmental gear so the entire experience of combat is accompanied by the amplified sound of your own hollow breathing, and sometimes you wear partial gear to combat the actual elements—the sand, the heat, the wind, the bugs.
That’s what I hate the most about warm places. Doesn’t matter where they are, doesn’t matter what planet they’re on, doesn’t matter how different the topography: all warm places have hideous bugs. It’s as if that old Earth Goddess, Mother Nature, became Mother Universe and declared that heat and insects went hand-in-tentacle.
Cold is actually easier to combat. Some cold places are so desolate they needed full environmental gear, including helmet and hollow breathing. But some are not considered hazardous (unless the soldier got careless) and you can go out wearing a thermal jacket and pants, along with skin coverings over your hands and face.
After a while, most of the troops on LaDucci went without the coverings altogether. The bracing air had a higher oxygen content than Earth Standard, and that elevated mood. The cold made you feel alive—or it made me feel alive, anyway—and it reminded me that I was someplace real instead of that constant parade of battleship, orbit-to-ground vessel, base, suited maneuvers, base, ground-to-orbit vessel, battleship, new posting.
The weapons were different here too. Laser rifles had to be used sparingly: they melted the ice-coverings over the tundra, and sometimes released avalanches so severe that we’d taken out some of our own equipment before we realized what we’d done.
Yeah, I say “we.” Language isn’t as precise when you’re embedded. It’s us against them, me versus the enemy, the good guys fighting the bad guys. Your brain gets hardwired that way, which is why embedding is a bad idea and why no real reporter should ever do it, and yet we do it all the time.
If we didn’t, we’d have no access to war zones at all.
The only hope that we have is that after we’re done with our active years, we compose some kind of memoir that tells the “real” facts. Only most of us don’t survive to the memoir—and those of us who do have lost interest in the overall conflicts long ago.
Cynical doesn’t begin to cut it. Cynical is where we start. We end up somewhere long past bitter, beyond hopeless, in a place as bleak as LaDucci on a cold winter night.
What I’m writing here doesn’t count as memoir. I’m not organized enough for memoir.
This is just a document. Because someone has to write this shit down.
And that someone may as well be me.
I have to admit: I liked the LaDucci posting.
I liked the quiet.
At first, I thought I was just tired and in need of rest. You can’t spend your life traveling from place to place, with no real home, and not have some low-level exhaustion dogging you all the damn time.
I didn’t sleep much—I never sleep much—but I didn’t feel that underlying layer of panic each and every moment of each and every day.
Our post was at the edge of an ice field, about one hundred klicks from any fighting, nearly five hundred klicks from the major fighting. We had to follow the action the way the ships in orbit did: using our computers, filtered through whatever layers the military had set up.
It felt odd to be on land, using in-space information gathering tools. Usually when I was on solid ground, I saw things with my own eyes, learned whether those information-gathering tools were accurate, and tried, as best I could, to report honestly on what was really happening.
I always add “as best I could” because so much of what I would want to report was forbidden: even the stuff from my very first posting, decades ago, remains classified.
The post, which we knew only by its service number, LD69A2, was bigger than I’d been led to believe. Not too long before, someone had built two barracks, a separate mess, and an officer’s quarters, none of which were in full use.
Clearly the military or the government (ours or Mars Union or maybe even the Keylen) had plans for this area after they conquered it. Because I had little else to do, I started researching what could make this part of LaDucci so very valuable.
It wasn’t the water or the minerals. For a while, I toyed with the idea that it was the location itself.
But I didn’t have enough information to know what made the location valuable—from a military standpoint or a governmental standpoint. And so far, no one was talking.
Still, it was a strange bit of land to be fighting over.
The tundra, the ice fields, the snow glazes were all so fragile that sending probes from vehicles in orbit would often trigger avalanches and destroy the probes. The first troops that came here were considered support, and they were researching the area, to see what kind of tech we could use to fight with.
Then they learned that the land itself was a factor in the fighting—that avalanche thing could be used to our advantage.
It took some kind of scientific knowledge of stresses and ice flows and the way pressure applied from above (or below) could predictably send an avalanche cascading toward the enemy. Or make the ice flow shatter at a point where the enemy could not retreat and save itself. Or make the tundra crumble, sending fumes toxic to the LaDucci into the environment.
It took a diabolical mindset, a combination of science, engineering, and a gleeful childishness that reveled in finding the most creative way to crush an enemy force.
Not that any enemy force ever made it all the way to LD69A2, or as the troops here sometimes called it, “Laid 69. Ate, too.” And then they’d chuckle as if they’d made up a particularly witty and original joke.
I’d laughed the first time, groaned the second, and pretty much ignored it from that moment forward. That joke, and its constant reiteration, actually made me think of the Corps Commander’s prediction that I’d regret coming here.
Decades in war zones left me wired for battle. I didn’t mind the boredom that any posting held, because it was always punctuated with moments (sometimes days) of sheer terror, followed by joy that I was alive—and pressure to complete some kind of story that would make it past the censors, be interesting, and be informative.
But here, I’d reported all I could on the young men who got here, the naïve hopeless dreams, the long days, and the even longer nights. I couldn’t mention the cadre of engineers gleefully making models of the snow fields to blow it up, and I couldn’t talk much about the occasional suicide squads that would show up at the very edges of our post, supposedly to make us all a little more on edge and a little more afraid.
Reports from those tiny conflicts would come back, and they were always a bit mysterious: the squads would die long before they arrived at their planned targets. Their vests would malfunction or they’d fall through some ice (without the help of our engineers) or they’d get poisoned by the gas released from the crumbling tundra.
I could and did report on that first gas release, because it surprised all of us, but I couldn’t do the follow-up on the way the engineers glommed gleefully onto that detail to plan even more diabolical strategies to be used closer to the actual conflict.
Because that’s pretty much all this base did: after it finished modeling various scenarios, it would send a group of engineers to another unit, and they would set traps for the enemy—or try to. It was hard to get enough purchase in an active fighting zone to lay under-ice charges that would ripple through the battlefield.
Those charges generally had to be set ahead of time.
Honestly, it was sheer boredom that got me to accompany one of the engineering teams as they went out to get some readings on the edges of the ice flow.
And it was sheer stupidity that allowed me to see that there was more to the LaDucci conflict than it seemed.
When you embed, you travel with the troops. You go where they go, do what they do, hang back when they tell you, and run like hell when they scream, “Get outta here!”
I’m used to that.
I wasn’t used to a squad of engineers, who giggle like schoolboys and talk in numbers and acronyms I truly did not understand. I knew they were going to measure the length and depth of the ice flow. I hadn’t realized they were also going to measure its thickness and maybe see if some tundra lurked below.
They might, they said with twinkling eyes, set off a small avalanche, just to see if they could do it.
They never said stay close. They never said don’t wander. They never said stick to the trucks.
Not that these were regular trucks: we had hovercraft here, low-level trucks in grayish white, so that they seemed invisible over the snow and the somewhat filthy ice. Hovercraft always made me a bit seasick, so I never remained on board if I didn’t have to.
The engineers did tell me I could watch if I wanted to, but after a few minutes, all I saw were holographic renderings of ice layers floating above the probe’s entry point, the light of the holograph slightly dimmed so it was impossible to see from a distance.
There was more talk about numbers and temperature differentials and stability and all sorts of things that floated by me like ice chips on the increasing cold breeze.
I wandered away, although I didn’t wander far. In fact, in my defense, I followed a set of footprints to the place where the footprints stopped, overlooking a ridge that rippled into a valley that connected this part of the ice flow to the closest fighting, a hundred klicks away.
I stared at the valley, wishing I could walk it and get away from all this, craving some kind of action, some kind of change, when I realized I wasn’t alone.
He sat on a snow mound, curved up from the ridge by a no-longer existent wind. One leg touched the ice shelf, the other bent and resting on the snow mound, one arm wrapped around his knee. He looked like he was posing for the Iconic Image of LaDucci: soldier, in shadow, staring at the distant war, freezing his ass off.
I didn’t recognize him, but that didn’t entirely surprise me. So many soldiers processed through LD69A2 that I sometimes barely noticed them before they got sent elsewhere.
But as I looked, I realized I should have noticed him as he traveled with us.
The footprints I had followed out here were his.
And all of the men—the engineers—I’d come with were behind me, playing with their stupid gadgets.
My heart started pounding, and I thought of the suicide bombers I’d encountered in one of our dirtier little wars. Well, I didn’t entirely encounter them. I had seen the aftermath of their destruction, including a half-caved-in starbase. I’d arrived in time to see body parts still floating among the wreckage.
I certainly didn’t want to become wreckage. Or a big red blob on the grayish-green snow.
That snow crunched beneath my feet, and he turned. He moved his head back once, a half-nod in acknowledgement.
“Hey,” he said.
“Hey,” I said, hoping my voice didn’t reveal my nerves.
“Kinda far from your unit, aren’t you?” he asked.
So, not one of us. Every muscle in my body tensed.
“Not that far,” I said. “Looks like you’re kinda far from yours.”
He grunted and put his leg down. If he made a move toward me, I’d run. He’d probably get too close—he looked to be in much better shape than I was—but I didn’t care.
I’d give it all I had.
“From this distance,” he said, “you can see some of the lights, flashing quietly. Like a message from beyond.”
He was staring down that ridge into the valley. In spite of myself, I looked too. You could see the lights appearing and disappearing like winking stars. Almost pretty, if they weren’t guaranteeing someone’s instant death.
“Your friends are looking for you,” he said.
I glanced over my shoulder, saw a couple of the engineers trudging my way. Their body language spoke of martyrdom and disgust. I could predict the conversation:
—You didn’t tell us where you were going.
—We’re responsible for you. If something happens…
—You know how much time we wasted searching? We brought you out here as a favor…
Their voices rumbled, and the squeak of their shoes was uncommonly loud.
I peeked to see how the soldier on the snow mound reacted to their arrival.
He was gone.
I hadn’t heard him leave—and I should have. Given the noise the engineers were making, and the noise my own shoes had made, any move the soldier made should’ve been audible.
But it hadn’t been.
The engineers reached me before I had time to process that thought.
“There was a guy here,” I said. “On that snow mound.”
I pointed, but the engineers didn’t look in that direction. Instead, they shared a couple glances, and I felt the instant conspiracy.
“What aren’t you telling me?” I asked.
“Nothing,” said one of them. I mentally called them Brainiacs One, Two and Three, because I didn’t need to clutter my brain with their names. I would never be able to do a comprehensive piece on these guys, so I didn’t bother with the details.
“It doesn’t sound like nothing,” I said.
Brainiac Two gave his friends conspiratorial glances again, then said, “Why don’t you check out the snow mound?”
“And let him shoot me?” I asked.
“Was he humanoid?” Brainiac Three asked.
My cheeks were heating up. Dumb. Dumb, dumb, dumb. The LaDucci weren’t humanoid. They looked like a cross between a dolphin and an alligator, the short squat legs and long snout with the round bodies and gray-green coating that made them almost impossible to see in the snow.
“Yeah,” I said, feeling stupid.
“Then you should be safe,” Brainiac One said, contempt dripping from his voice.
I trudged toward the snow mound, stunned to be slogging through deeper snow than I’d encountered anywhere else on LaDucci. No tracks either—not leading up to the snow mound, not behind the mound, not on its other side.
And creepily, not on the mound itself, even where the soldier had placed his foot.
“You’re telling me I’m seeing ghosts?” I asked.
“We’re not telling you anything,” Brainiac Three said with such emphasis that I realized he wasn’t speaking to me; he was speaking to his friends.
“We’ll let the commander talk to you,” Brainiac One said. “And you won’t like it.”
But the unit commander wouldn’t talk to me. Not for three days, anyway.
He was dealing with a troop swap, an inspection, and some engineer’s hare-brained idea that had nearly caused one of the barracks to implode on itself.
His adjunct told me that the commander would talk to me when he had time, and I knew the tone. The tone meant I’d be lucky if the commander ever talked to me, and I shouldn’t hold my breath.
Not that I was holding my breath. The Brainiacs had set up the meet; I certainly hadn’t wanted it. I would ask for a meet with the unit commander when I needed him to confirm or deny something officially about some military action. I really didn’t want to see him for any other reason.
Especially one that painted me in such a stupid light. I researched my experience out there, and discovered it was something that happened on the ice fields. Along with snow blindness (on really bright days), nights often brought what were called ice hallucinations—visions of something or someone that had no real basis in fact.
The more I dug, the more I learned that any frozen expanse brought those kinds of visions, although usually they happened after some kind of deprivation, not to some idiot trudging across snow because he no longer felt like watching engineers enthuse over ice-field depth.
The engineers knew I had seen an ice vision. They probably wanted me to talk to the commander so that I’d get transferred out of here. I wasn’t ready to leave yet; I hadn’t found the definitive story, so I didn’t push the meet either.
I just needed to remember to eat right and wear the proper equipment the next time I headed into an ice field. I probably should have gotten more sleep, but I wasn’t about to kid myself. I couldn’t will myself to sleep more, no matter how hard I tried.
I was just getting past the incident when the vision showed up again. I had dozed in my own little corner of the barracks. I didn’t quite have a room, but I had a private bed (no bunk), a desk, and some blankets I could pull across the only open area so that I could work more or less undisturbed.
I usually spent most of my time in my chair, working, documenting bits and pieces of things that I could compile when I left. I’d been working to understand snow fields, ice flows, and tundras for the previous twenty-four hours, and had focused so hard that I’d forgotten to sleep. The sleep caught up with me in the afternoon, and I hadn’t managed to stagger to my bed. Instead, I’d cratered in my chair, my head back, mouth open.
The pain in my neck woke me up. My mouth was dry, and my throat ached, which told me I’d been snoring. I looked around to see if any of the men had snuck in to my ignominious position, only to see someone sitting on my unmade bed.
Unmade beds offend soldiers. They either force me to make the bed, or frown at it mightily. They never sit on it. So the fact he was sitting caught my attention right away, a half second before I realized he had one foot on the floor and the other up against his chest.
His face was in shadow, even though the room was well lit.
“Oh, for god’s sake,” I said, “not again.”
I ran my hand over my face, removed some of the drool from my chin, and felt the sleep along my eyelids. I’d really been out—and now I was hallucinating in the barracks instead of the ice field.
“They’re an hour away from the ridge where we met,” he said. “You have a team out there, measuring. Bring them back.”
I frowned. A team? They? What?
“I can’t stay here,” he said. “It’s too far away.”
And then he vanished, like the good little hallucination I wanted him to be.
I rubbed the aching muscles in the back of my neck, took a sip of very cold coffee, and staggered to the latrine to wash off my face. That wasn’t enough to wake me, so I decided to go for the full-shower-and-some-kind-of-meal method of getting rid of the grogs.
I was covered in soap when someone burst into the shower area. “Get out, suit up, we’re going into lockdown,” he said, as the door slammed. When I asked what was going on, my voice echoed.
He had already left.
I rinsed the soap off, passed a towel over my body, and yanked clothes over my still-damp skin. I didn’t have an environmental suit in the showers, so I sprinted to the barracks as everyone else sprinted out, weapons in hand.
“What’s going on?” I asked.
“Suicide squad,” one of the men said as he jogged past. “Took out the surveying team at the edge of the ice flow.”
I felt cold—and not because of the weather. I looked at the time as I grabbed my suit from the barracks. Less than an hour after my vision.
Son of a bitch.
We lost five men, and would’ve lost the entire barracks if it weren’t for the rest of the engineers. The ice flow had cracked where the surveying team was working, and the crack was working its way to us. It would have either collapsed the barracks or destroyed the tundra if the engineers hadn’t planned ahead for just this kind of contingency.
I have no idea what they did—something about depth charges, frozen barriers, and recreation of original conditions—but whatever they did, it worked and saved thousands of lives.
Just not the team. Five lives lost, in a way that could’ve been prevented, if I had just spoken up.
And said what? That a vision told me the suicide squad was coming? Besides, the bastard had been vague.
And that thought—about the vision’s lack of specificity—made me realize I was being childish and short-sighted.
I’d been to enough war zones in enough strange places to understand that sometimes not all is as it seems. You can’t accept Earth Normal in a place where Earth isn’t even visible with advanced space-viewing equipment.
So I went to the unit commander, just like the Brainiacs had wanted me to.
The commander looked older than he had when I arrived. He probably looked older than he had twelve hours before.
He was standing near some holographic projections, scrolling through them as if they dissatisfied him. I knew he could see me through them, but he didn’t acknowledge me for nearly a minute, probably hoping I would go away.
“Make it quick,” he said. “I have families to contact, and planning to do.”
My speech on the strange things I’d seen in war zones went out the window.
“I had warning about this,” I said.
He stopped, collapsed the holo images, and turned toward me. His blue eyes were flinty, his chin set.
“Tell me,” he said.
So I did.
He didn’t quiz me. He didn’t recommend a trip to the base psychiatrist. He didn’t ask for a full medical work-up.
Instead, he asked, “Where’d you see him the first time? Show me on the map.”
He called up a holographic map of the area, and I pointed out exactly where that vision appeared.
“Took him a lot of energy to hightail it here,” the commander said to me, “and you ignored him.”
I frowned. My stomach clenched.
“You mean he’s real?”
The commander peered at me, as if he couldn’t understand what I had just said. Then he clenched one hand into a fist, and slowly released that fist, one finger at a time.
“You’re a damn reporter,” he said, mostly to himself, voice a lot calmer than his expression. “No one briefed you. Of course no one briefed you.”
“Briefed me about what?” I asked.
“The imaginary friends,” he said.
The imaginary friends was the nickname the first troops to arrive in this place gave the Eldanten, which was what the creature that I had seen was. They first became visible to male soldiers who’d had imaginary friends as children. It never happened to women or to other species. It seemed that something in the human male physiology made the Eldanten visible, and the Eldanten took the form of the man’s childhood imaginary friend.
I had winced at that description. I was so far from my child-self that I hadn’t recognized my own imaginary friend. I’d had one too, and he’d helped me through some truly ugly years from ages five to twelve. Puberty gave me height and weight and that gave me confidence to claim the smart mouth I’d developed for my imaginary friend as my own.
And I’d never thought of him again.
Until now.
The commander punctuated his description of all of this with asides, reminders for his superiors, things like we need to fuckin’ brief the reporters and how come no one psych evaled you? as if someone could have. I’m not military, I’ve never been military, and when I’m not an officially assigned embed and not on some battlefield, I don’t have to follow orders. I’d’ve run from a psych eval faster than a washed-out cadet ran from Basic.
“We’re allied with the Eldanten,” the commander told me, “although it wasn’t a willing alliance at first. They took our men and made them fight the Eldantens’ war—a different war than we’d been supporting with the LaDucci. Now, we help each other.”
Gre-at, good, wonderful. Names I didn’t recognize, conflicts I’d never heard of. Normally, I would have been ecstatic to learn of a story no other reporter had. But at the moment, I wasn’t a reporter.
I was a man who had somehow gotten roped into something I had no connection to.
“The Eldanten taught us about the poison in the tundra,” the commander was saying, “and they helped us minimize damage from the suicide squads.”
Then he peered at me. “At least until today.”
“I didn’t know,” I said.
The commander raised his hands in a gesture of surrender, although his eyes still glimmered with fury.
“I know, I know. That’s on us. But now we’ve got to train you and bring you into the team.”
“What?” I said. “I’m not a soldier.”
“You are now,” he said.
“Oh, no,” I said. “I’m not here to fight. I haven’t had training, and I don’t want it. Your little wars aren’t mine.”
“The war’s not little,” he said, “and it’s yours now.”
I shook my head. “Partner him with someone else.”
“Can’t,” the commander said. “Once they choose they’re bonded. It takes some massive kind of energy flow for them to pick a partner. They can’t re-partner again. You’re stuck here, Khalil. And we’re stuck with you.”
I don’t do stuck well. I don’t do orders well. I don’t do military drills and proper behavior well.
“No,” I said.
“And,” the commander was saying as if I hadn’t spoken at all, “his territory is the ridgeline. We need intel from there. We’ve been sending new men to that area from the beginning, hoping someone would be able to communicate with an Eldanten.”
“Keep sending people,” I said, “because I’m not staying here. You can’t compel me to do so.”
“Oh,” the commander said with a dark glimmer in his eye, “I most certainly can.”
I’d been through similar things with commanders before. They seemed to believe they controlled every human they ever came across. And, honestly, because I was embedded, I had to follow some of his rules—as long as I stayed.
But he didn’t control the length of my stay, and since I was a freelancer, he couldn’t threaten me with job loss or talk to my boss. All I had to do was get out of LaDucci.
I’d done this before: I’d snuck out of some commander’s clutches. It took a ground-to-orbit vehicle, enough money to bribe a few guards, and the short-term theft of a small ship.
The two times I’d done this before, I’d programmed the ship to return to its parent vehicle, leaving me “stranded” somewhere, usually a place with a large criminal element. That way, I could get my own ship (without registration), fly to some other place without being tracked, and then move to a whole new sector.
The universe was vast, and the parts we controlled big. It took official information a lot longer to arrive than it did for me to do so. I could even continue embedding, because most commanders never checked a freelance reporter’s history. There was always an assumption of shadiness, and a willingness to look the other way, if the reporter promised to follow the rules inside the base itself upon penalty of expulsion.
Anyone who ran a unit knew that reporters like me feared expulsion much more than they feared losing work or some military court-martial that was never going to happen.
I was annoyed that I’d have to go on the run again—third time in fifteen years—but I knew how to do it.
I had already picked out the vessel I was going to commandeer. In fact, I had picked it out when I arrived (old habits die hard) because it was queued up for repair, and not on the usual heavily guarded landing strip. The repairs weren’t happening because the techs were busy with the ice field, so the ship remained there, minimally damaged and ripe for the taking.
I would have taken it too, if I hadn’t had to go back and get my gear.
He swirled in like a miniature blizzard, face still in shadow. I truly could not remember what my imaginary friend looked like, and that had an impact on my vision of the Eldanten.
“I thought your job was to report,” he snapped. He sounded furious.
“It is,” I said.
“You didn’t tell them. I told you to tell them. You failed at your job.”
I let out a small puff of air. We were standing just behind the barracks. No one was around, at least that I could see. Just the two of us, a lanky young man without a face and me, grizzled and tired and out of his depth.
“I didn’t fail at my job,” I said. “You misunderstood my job.”
“You’re supposed to report,” he said.
“To the people back home. I’m supposed to compose stories about what happens here, and tell them about it. I have nothing to do with the military,” I said.
His body froze for a half second. At that moment, I wished I could see his face—or what passed for his face—because I wanted to know what he was feeling.
Oh, hell, who am I kidding? I knew what he was feeling. He was pissed as hell at me.
“I risked everything to come to you,” he said. “My entire family is dead.”
I frowned. I thought, somehow, that the Eldanten were beings of light or some kind of ghosts or something. I hadn’t realized that they actually existed.
They exist—I later found out—but they are in some kind of zone that we can’t see, hear or smell. Our senses are incredibly limited, and the Eldanten exist in a place our senses cannot perceive.
“Your family?” I asked.
“And my friends, and my entire village. You lost five people. We lost two thousand. Because you didn’t report.”
He launched himself at me, and I felt a chill run through me, like a sharp wind had suddenly blown up. Then he reformed behind me, and sank to the ground in a crouch, arms wrapped around his head, moaning.
At first I thought I had hurt him.
I hadn’t. Not physically, at least.
But oh, emotionally. Mentally. I had devastated him.
And all he believed in.
That realization came to me quickly—almost as fast as the guilt.
And I can’t shake the guilt.
No matter how hard I try.
We’re stuck with each other, he and I. Him, because he had bonded with the wrong man, and me, because I can’t leave him now. I call him Nevas, which isn’t his name. I can’t pronounce his name. I don’t know if he can pronounce mine. He’s never tried.
He’s younger than I thought—the equivalent of a teenage boy in our world—and he has no more chances to bond and help his people. I’m his only hope.
Not that he wants to help his people. His people are gone. But he can help the remaining Eldanten that live along what we see only as tundra and ice flows and snow fields.
Hundreds of thousands of them in large cities, teeming with life that we can’t see. Our barracks exist on the edge of the smallest of those cities. The inhabitants tolerate us because our weapons work better against the LaDucci than the Eldantens’ do.
I’d love to say that I’m a changed man, but I’m not really. I’m still an asshole. If I could figure out how to flee this place without adding to my nightmares, I would.
But I can’t.
I have waking nightmares, the way I used to have waking visions of my imaginary friend, back in the days of my horrid childhood, when I thought things could not get any worse than they were.
Of course, they could get worse.
You could be bound to a creature who blamed you for the destruction of everything—and everyone—he ever loved.
A destruction he had sacrificed his entire being to prevent. He can’t return to his people, not in the same form. He’s as stuck with me as I am with him.
And he showed that kind of unwavering courage we celebrate in story and song. But he was too young to understand that some people aren’t worthy of loyalty, and sometimes a person who is in the position to do something won’t do it at all.
He gets that now.
Whenever he tells me something, something the base or the unit or the commander need to know, he adds, “You’ll report this, right, reporter?”
I assure him that I will.
And then I do.
What he doesn’t understand is that I’m not a reporter any longer. I’m part of this unit now. I’m in training to be some kind of soldier. A half-assed one, I guess, but something the unit can claim.
He keeps asking me, my Eldanten imaginary friend, what the point of my old job was, if not to save lives and protect the ones we love. What’s the point of reporting, he asked, if you’re not allowed to say much, and when you do, no one pays attention?
I had no answer for him the first time he asked that question, and I have no answer now.
I’ve saved more lives with him at my side than I ever had as a reporter. Or rather, he’s saved more lives.
And he’s not even human.
Late at night, in that bitter, bitter place beyond cynicism, that place where people like me most comfortably dwell, I sometimes think the fact that he’s not human is why he’s saved so many lives.
But that’s not fair to all our men here. Our boys here. Because they save lives each and every day. Human lives. Eldanten lives. Hell, sometimes even LaDucci lives.
Our boys are trying to find a way to win this thing so we can all go home.
Not that home exists for most of us.
But our boys don’t know that, any more than my Eldanten imaginary friend does.
Like them, he’s young. He’s strong.
Unlike assholes like me, he cares.
And unlike me, he can actually make some kind of difference.
EmbeddedCopyright © 2016 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Fiction River: Valor, edited by Lee Allred, WMG Publishing, July 2015Published by WMG PublishingCover and layout copyright © 2016 by WMG PublishingCover design by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Innovari/Dreamstime
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission
Shanika never wanted to pursue a career in magic. Her mother dreamed that up for her.So, when she makes it to the finals of the American Magic reality show, she figures she’ll do it for her mother—and the money.But her talent might just garner her unwanted attention, and a choice she never expected.
“Salem Week,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Salem WeekKristine Kathryn RuschShanika noticed him at the United Center auditions. Six thousand hopefuls, and somehow her eye caught the creepiest one. He had just a bit of a glow, and the glow was…off. A muddy gray-green-black color surrounding him, not in sparkles, but in sharp ragged lines, almost as if he had exploded and someone magical had frozen the moment of detonation before the energy could expand outward and kill anyone else.
Then he disappeared into one of the doors leading out of the stadium, and she didn’t see him anymore.
She didn’t give him anymore thought either—not during those long three days of callbacks, and especially not after that moment of triumph, where the celebrity judges called her “winning” and “original.” Her mother had cried and clung to her, and the TV cameras had leaned in a bit too close.
Shanika didn’t like the way her face reflected in the lenses and she willed herself not to cry. The American Magic producers had already teased a sob story out of her (not that she had cried while telling it but, she later found out, her mother had retold the same story, and had sobbed so hard that she had ruined her makeup—which meant the producers had crying and the story and Shanika).
Shanika also knew that the American Magic producers wouldn’t use the second part of her interview unless she made it to Salem Week and flamed out spectacularly. Then that interview would show (prove) what a jerk she really was—at least from an American Magic perspective.
Because, honestly (and they had asked her to be honest), she didn’t want to be here. Winning American Magic was her mother’s dream, not Shanika’s. Her mother had watched each of the fifteen seasons of the show and had always speculated loudly about whether or not she would have won if she had only been two years younger when the show started up.
The first auditions for the very first season had come to Chicago (just like they had for Season 15), and her mom had huddled outside, thinking about lying to get in, believing that the producers actually double-checked identification.
The American Magic producers didn’t hire a private investigative firm to vet identification until Season 2. And Shanika’s mom would tell anyone who listened that if she had had enough guts to lie about her age, she would have won, because the talent wasn’t quite as fierce in that first year as it would get later.
Finally, while they watched an episode of Season 12, Shanika’s grandmother told her mother to stop denigrating her own talent. Shanika’s grandmother had said to Shanika’s mom, Baby Girl, there’s only one mage I’ve ever seen with more sparkly inviting performance magic than you, and that’s our Shanika.
And from that moment on, Shanika’s mom turned all that ambition, all those failed dreams, on her third child. Shanika, who didn’t care about magic. Shanika, who never had attention before. Shanika, who (even at age twelve) had been on her way to a career as a concert pianist, not as a performer who prostituted her magic for the sake of the Almighty Dollar.
Shanika had hoped that her mother would forget the American Magic dream after Season 12. After all, Shanika wouldn’t qualify until Season 15. Unlike her mom, Shanika was too young to be part of a reality TV show even if she had wanted to be part of it.
Shanika figured the only way to shut her mother up was to audition. And because Shanika was Shanika, she couldn’t mess up the audition just because she was following her mother’s dream instead of her own. Shanika gave it her all during that final audition in front of the three celebrity judges, and they rewarded her with a golden ticket to every contestant’s dream—Salem Week.
Six thousand in Chicago, 10,000 in San Francisco, 12,000 in Dallas, 4,000 in Las Vegas, and 3,000 in Seattle—all boiled down to 250 scared, sweaty contestants who flew into Boston and boy were their brooms tired as more than one wag said, thinking he was being original.
Nothing about the 250 stood out from the 250 in each previous year. They were all young and green and insecure and full of themselves. There was the backbiting and the untamed egos, the “types” as her mother called them—the Entitled Teenage Girl, the Tortured Male Artist, the Misunderstood Depressive. They just wore different clothes from season to season.
Her mother gaped through the entire experience, from the plane ride to the thirty-minute bus ride to the cheering at the Gothic sign proclaiming You Are Now Entering Salem, Massachusetts. The contestants—at least the ones on Shanika’s bus—were both tired and excited, and they all talked about the fame and fortune ahead of them.
Shanika didn’t care about fame and fortune. If she did, she wouldn’t have aspired to become a concert pianist. A musician could be famous in the genre, but no one went into classical music to become a multimillionaire and have legions of fans. A musician went into classical music because she loved the music itself.
No one here seemed to love the magic. At least, no one she had talked to. And Shanika was just as bad as the other contestants on that point: She wasn’t here for love of the craft either.
She was looking at the promised $1,000 for every episode that used her face, $5,000 for every episode she spoke on, and $10,000 for every episode that gave her more than five minutes of airtime. If she made it to the Top 24, she would receive $20,000 per episode, plus 50% of her appearance fees, endorsements, and all the other things that went with being on American Magic.
If she won, she’d receive half a million dollars outright in addition to the earnings from a standard contract with ImpsWitch Productions. She’d done her research and learned that the contestants who made it to the top five made even more money than the winner, because they weren’t bound by ImpsWitch’s contract terms.
So yes, if anyone asked, she would say she was doing this for the money. Not because she was greedy, but because she was tired of living in her grandmother’s house, sleeping on the hide-a-bed with her sisters, and trying to remember (even when she was tired) to augment her mother’s protect spell so that no stray bullets would come through the wall.
Shanika tried not to think about any of that. She really didn’t like how it was all going to play on TV. She knew the producers would cut up her interview to make her sound all whiney, when, in fact, they had to drag information out of her.
Yes, she lived in gang territory. Yes, it was dangerous to get to school. Yes, she was uncomfortable at home, but she loved her family, and yes, things had been hard since her father had died, but they were all making do, and someday, things would be better, particularly if she made some really good money on American Magic.
But she’d seen those sob stories: it seemed every contestant from every year had one, and now she would too, and no matter when she went home, people would look at her with pity, and think, Poor thing. She lives such a horrid life—when her life wasn’t really horrid at all.
(It wasn’t all rose petals and kittens either, but she figured the hard stuff was her business and no one else’s.)
She was trying to disappear into the background as the bus pulled into the U-shaped parking area in front of the Hotel of the Seven Gables. Her mother was sucking all the air from the bus, telling everyone about the history of American Magic and how the statistics broke down, and how fortunate they all were to be in the top point-seven percent of everyone who had auditioned for Season 15.
Some people gravitated toward Shanika’s mom, wanting the optimism and the comfort. Others sighed heavily, crossed their arms, and glared out the windows. The camera operator at the front actually had to tell Mom to shut up twice so that he could focus on contestants’ worries and fears, not parental worries and fears.
Initially Shanika had been excited to have Mom along—it was Mom’s dream after all—but one full day into the experience, and Shanika wanted nothing more than to be here on her own, having an adventure, and seeing a corner of the world she’d never seen before.
After all, everyone had heard of Salem, Massachusetts, the place where witches stood up and stopped the witch hunts and made The World Safe For Magic. Salem was hallowed ground for the magical, and the producers used that to their advantage. They promoted the city and the city promoted American Magic in return.
Even Shanika, who really had tried to avoid all things American Magic, had fallen for the every-mage-needs-to-visit-Salem patter.
She wasn’t impressed so far. She wouldn’t have noticed the bus’s arrival into Salem if one of the producers hadn’t mentioned it, sparking everyone to applaud so that the camera operator could get images of their happy, expectant (terrified) faces. Salem looked just like Boston had to Shanika. The producers kept pointing out all the historical sites, but Shanika wanted to see the Thirteen Colonies Theater more. It had been built specially for American Magic after the series took off.
The theater was easy to spot once they passed it. Unlike most of the buildings in Salem, the theater was big and modern, with lots of steel and angles. Right on cue, Shanika’s mother had started into how the initial building permits were nearly denied and how the builders had to move to the outskirts of Salem, away from the historic downtown and…that was when Shanika tuned her out.
She kinda wished she had paid attention now that they were in front of the Hotel of the Seven Gables. She had expected it to look like that famous house everyone had read about in Nathaniel Hawthorne’s book.
Instead, the hotel looked like the hotels near Chicago’s O’Hare Airport, big and rectangular with lots of windows, going up more stories than she could count. She sighed softly to herself: she had wanted a more magical experience (pun intended) because she figured she was leaving soon. Still, this was going to be the first time she ever stayed in a really nice hotel, and she was going to make the best of it.
She waited until half the contestants were off the bus before she even stood. Her mother had bounced off first, as if all of this were for her. Shanika saw her mother’s round shape supervising the movement of their meager bags.
Shanika grabbed her purse and the battered paperback she’d brought (mostly for comfort) and walked to the front.
As she descended the steps, she saw that kid again—the one from the United Center auditions. He was standing by a podium labeled Valet, but she knew he wasn’t one of the parking attendants.
She saw him more clearly this time. He had stringy black hair and pale skin covered with what her grandmother called a wish-beard (Don’t be like them other boys, her grandmother said to Shanika’s oldest brother. They try too early, ending up with a wish-beard, not a real beard. You wait until you got real man hair.)
The kid’s eyes were black and almost empty, and his mouth a straight line. He had a piercing just below his bottom lip—a red jewel that almost got lost in the wish-beard. He wore a Poison T-shirt with the sleeves ripped out, revealing faded tattoos that made his skinny arms look almost green.
If it weren’t for the expensive leather duffel leaning against his ripped jeans, Shanika would’ve thought he was as poor as she was. But something about him was off—staged, almost, as if he wanted everyone to think he had come from nothing.
She nearly missed the bottom step and staggered onto the curb. Some nice kid from Minneapolis who’d been trying to chat her up through the whole ride caught her arm and steadied her.
“Okay?” he asked.
She nodded. Her mom hadn’t even noticed.
But the kid near the valet stand had. His gaze met hers and she shivered. The red jewel under his lip actually glowed.
Then he smiled slightly, whirled, and headed inside the hotel. As he stepped through the door, the air around him turned gray, green, and black. More like smoke this time than a glow, but just as startling. And then, just as she was trying to figure out exactly what he was, those sharp edges reappeared and she got that sense of a contained detonation all over again.
Then she couldn’t see him anymore as he stepped deeper into the hotel’s gloom.
Her heart was racing. There was something really off with that kid. What she was seeing wasn’t an aura. She knew (thanks, Mom!) that American Magic had hired aura readers during Season 2 and that actually enabled the show to get rid of half of the troublesome contestants before they even hit their second round of pre-camera auditions.
No, this kid had something else.
Shanika looked around for one of the producers. She saw Carly, the producer who had interviewed her back in Chicago.
Shanika sidled up beside her.
“I’m sorry to bother you,” Shanika said.
Carly looked tired, her dark hair frizzing in the humidity. But to her credit, she smiled when she realized who was beside her.
“Hey, Shanika,” she said. “What can I help you with?”
“Did you see that kid near the valet stand?” Shanika asked. “There’s something scary about him.”
Carly didn’t make light of Shanika’s comment, like Shanika expected. Instead, Carly glanced at the valet stand, then looked around. “Guess I missed him. What’s the problem? Has he done something to you?”
“No,” Shanika said. “But there’s something off about him.”
She tried to explain the gray-green-black stuff threaded with red, and how that was a warning. She could tell from the expression on Carly’s face that Carly thought Shanika was just magically overwrought.
“I’ll look into it,” Carly said.
“You don’t even know what he looks like.” Shanika clenched her fist, sent a tiny bit of image-magic to it, and then opened her hand. A tiny three-dimensional image of the kid and the valet stand sat on her palm for a moment before rising to Carly’s eye level.
“You’re not supposed to do magic outside of the practice rooms,” Carly said, but the words sounded automatic, almost like she had to say them because it was some rule or something.
But she wasn’t even looking at Shanika as she spoke. Instead, Carly was looking at the tiny image of the weird kid. She held up her phone and snapped a picture of the image.
“Now, get rid of that,” Carly said.
Shanika snapped her fingers and the image disappeared.
“You’re going to do something, right?” Shanika asked.
“I’m pretty sure he’s already on our radar, but I’ll make certain,” Carly said. Then she looked at Shanika and smiled. “Stop worrying, hon. Go have a good time. This is a strange experience, but the folks who have fun are the ones who do the best.”
Shanika made herself smile. Carly was right: Shanika needed to focus on herself and on doing her best, if only to make it to the real money. But that kid had creeped her out, and she couldn’t help herself. She worried.
She knew, though, if she told her mother about this, her mother would say it wasn’t Shanika’s problem. Let the experts handle it, her mother would say.
But in Shanika’s world, the “experts” (which was Mom’s code word for “adults”) usually needed Shanika’s help.
Still, she slipped past Carly, found her mother, and helped her wheel their luggage into the huge hotel atrium. Pictures of famous witches hung everywhere, and in the lobby’s center, there was a bronze statue of the Witch Trials—that moment when the Puritan Judge Magistrates learned they weren’t the most powerful people in Salem. The statue was almost life-size, and took up the center of the room. A lot of contestants were staring at the figures, and at the magic, portrayed as rays of sunlight streaming out of the townspeople’s hands.
Organizers stood near the lobby desk, handing out keycards and explaining the rules. They also gave out slips of paper with the rules printed on them.
Shanika took hers before her mother could grab them. Shanika scanned the hotel assignments, saw that she and her mother were sharing a room, and sighed quietly. She’d been hoping to share with someone else, just so that she could meet someone for the few days they were in Salem, but that wasn’t going to happen.
Shanika grabbed her luggage and followed the stream of contestants to the elevators, her mother scurrying behind.
The competition didn’t officially start until the next morning, but American Magic provided a buffet dinner and magic coaches for anyone who felt their routine needed a touch-up. Also, performers had to sign one last waiver, promising (yet again) that they would avoid dark magic. If they were doing original spells, they had to have those spells approved through a committee, who searched for any hint of darkness.
Shanika watched the steady stream of contestants go into a banquet room with a sign taped to the double-doors that read Original Spells. She half-expected to see that kid go in there, but she didn’t.
She didn’t see him at all that night. If Carly hadn’t told her that he was being watched, Shanika would’ve thought that he was just a figment of her overactive imagination.
She barely slept that night, and learned at the banquet breakfast that half of the contestants didn’t sleep either. No one looked well rested, and some people looked like they were on the edge of some kind of breakdown. Hands shook, voices raised, and the occasional spell sizzled.
Anyone who accidentally used magic that morning got one warning. If they used it again—like one girl did, to change her breakfast to something she really wanted—they were automatically sent home. That girl burst into tears, crying, “But I always do that at home!”
No one cared. Most contestants didn’t even look.
Shanika thought about all the times she had quietly used magic at home. Her mother and grandmother frowned on “wasted” spells. They claimed that a person’s magical reservoir was not infinite, and if someone made too much frivolous magic, then their powers would eventually diminish.
Shanika had seen that theory repeated on the Internet and in some books on magical child-raising, but she had never seen evidence that that theory had basis in fact. Still, good parents made their kids use magic wisely—never to advance themselves without effort, never to punish someone else, never to alter another person’s form without that person’s permission.
The rules that most mage parents used for child-raising were, in fact, the Good Conduct Rules hammered out here in Salem after the carnage of the Witch Trials, when it became clear that the magical could wipe out the religious with a blink of an eye.
The magical didn’t want to do that. They wanted to continue to live in harmony with the rest of the community, like they had done for centuries.
And the only way to repair the damage done by the deaths and accusations on both sides was to come up with a set of rules—most of which had been coded into law around the country.
That was why so much of magic had moved from basics like protection and augmentation to performance. Performances were safe, and legal, and often fun. Performance magic had a joyful component that most utilitarian magic did not.
Shanika wasn’t a big performance magic fan. She would rather listen to a good symphony. Music was magic to her, which was why she tried to ditch her mom when they arrived at the Thirteen Colonies Theater. Shanika had seen the band standing outside the stage door. The other contestants didn’t recognize the band, but Shanika did.
She had watched them more than she had watched the performances when American Magic played on TV at home.
“Can I watch you guys practice?” she asked.
“You a contestant?” One of the musicians asked. She recognized him. He was the band leader, Melvin Moody.
She knew that answering correctly would get her sent to the other door, but she wasn’t sure lying was the best policy either.
“I am,” she said, “but I’m more interested in music. I’d love to see what you do—”
“So you can see how the other contestants prepare.” Moody rolled his eyes. “No cheating, girlie.”
“I’m not cheating,” she said, her voice going up. “I—I don’t want to be a performing mage. I want to be a concert pianist. My mother made me audition. She’s over there.”
Shanika nodded toward her mother who was standing near the main door that the contestants were filing through. Her mother glared, and waggled her fingers in a get your butt over here now movement.
“Yeah,” Moody said. “Sure. Right.”
“Seriously,” Shanika said. “I loved how you used Flight of the Bumblebee last year to accompany the failure montage. I loved that you had someone blat it on a tuba when that one guy toppled over his entire table, sending toads everywhere.”
The musicians looked at each other, then at her. She might not have convinced them, but she at least had their attention.
“Tell you what,” Moody said. “You make it through to the next round, and tonight we’ll show you the dailies, so you can see what we did from our perspective.”
“You’ll lose practice time if you do that,” one of the other musicians said, in a tone that implied it was a really bad idea.
She didn’t care. “Oh, thank you,” she said. “Where will I find you?”
“The Sarah Good Ballroom,” Moody said. “We’ll be there about eight.”
Shanika clasped her hands together, and grinned with joy. “Thank you!” she said again as she scurried toward her mother.
“What are you getting into?” her mother asked.
Shanika didn’t answer. Instead, she hurried to her place in line. She found her name on the call sheet and her number.
“Oh, dear,” her mother said. “Afternoon. Everyone knows the morning sessions are more lenient.”
Shanika didn’t care. She took her name badge and headed to the practice area. She had a reason to stay for the evening besides the money. She got to see real professional musicians at work. She couldn’t wait for that.
That alone might make the entire trip worthwhile, even if she got no airtime (or money) at all.
Her spell was simple enough, and it used her musical talents. She would conjure an entire jazz band, one instrument at a time, and have each instrument play something simple. Then she was going to—without magic—scat over the band, making her voice an instrument too.
She had done a fashion spell in her United Center audition, taking the clothes that one of the camera operators was wearing (with his permission) and making them as fashionable as the clothes celebrity superstar judge Vivian Singh was wearing. But Shanika had made the alteration without fundamentally changing the clothes the camera operator wore. She just dusted the clothes up a bit, and gave them a bit of sparkle.
This spell, the one Shanika planned to do here, was a lot more complicated. Her mother wanted her to save it for one of the later rounds, but Shanika wasn’t sure she’d make it that far.
Besides, she really wanted to see what the musicians did, so she had to make sure she would stick around. And—a side benefit—the spell would prove to them that she was a musician too.
So she practiced during the morning session before finding her mother in the balcony just before the lunch break.
“I’ve been counting,” her mother said, staring at the stage. “They want 125 to move to the next round, and so far, they’ve picked 56. The afternoon will get progressively tougher.”
Shanika forced those words to wash over her. She wasn’t going to listen to her mother’s panic. Instead, Shanika was going to focus on making it to the evening.
She looked around the auditorium. She had gotten used to being in near-empty auditoriums for the music competitions she’d participated in—alone—in Chicago. There, the competitors would often watch in sullen silence, refusing to clap or cheer a good performance.
Here, the smattering of parents and friends who had come along managed to make the place sound a lot more lively than it actually was.
Shanika leaned over the reinforced metal railing at the seats below. Maybe fifty of the contestants were watching. Some had probably already been chosen to go on; others were simply waiting for their turns.
No parents were allowed to sit down there, but some of the producers sat near the doors. Up front, a sparkly shield covered everything from the first row of seats back.
Most contestants didn’t have enough magic to see the shield. Shanika knew that because the producers had mentioned it repeatedly. Only a small handful had enough magic or the right magic to see it.
The magical shield had existed since the start of the competition so no parents could augment their kids’ talents and no competitors could shoot out some magical bomb to spoil someone else’s performance.
It also protected the audience from any spell that went seriously awry. The judges used to sit behind the shield, but this latest group of judges, which featured some of the most powerful mages in magical performance, felt they couldn’t properly view spells through a shield.
They figured they could handle the risk of a badly executed spell. So far, they’d put out several fires, stopped a misfired perfume smell that would have turned everything into a powerful foul stink that could’ve lasted for days, and barely dodged an out-of-control chocolate rain.
Shanika wouldn’t have wanted their job for anything, but apparently the judges saw this sort of thing all the time.
She leaned back even more and realized that from this position she could see the contestants waiting in the wings. Everyone had to go backstage thirty minutes before their group’s assigned time. Then, one by one, they’d be called by name, to do a minimum of a thirty-second performance to a maximum two-minute performance.
At any point, the judges could interrupt or stop the proceedings. Contestants knew that. Rules stated that any contestant who performed an uninterruptable spell would be automatically disqualified.
Which didn’t stop contestants from trying it anyway.
The contestant on the stage, an already balding white man with the stage name Wizardo! in a 1970s blue tux, was going for humor. He had already conjured a top hat out of thin air; next (she knew) he would pull a real live rabbit out of it.
It would’ve been a cute little spell—funny even—if Shanika hadn’t seen fifteen versions of it from fifteen other contestants at the United Center a few months ago. Wizardo! still might have pulled it off if he’d made some kind of fun about the cultural stereotypes he was playing with. Maybe if he had a riff about the way the unwashed masses used to believe magic wasn’t real or the fact that anyone can (and often did) pull a rabbit out of a hat. But he didn’t. He was using ancient patter, probably from a history book.
Shanika leaned slightly sideways so that she could see the contestants in the wings. They were scrunching forward, as if they couldn’t wait to get on stage. It certainly wasn’t the guy’s patter that was drawing them.
Then something else caught her eye: the kid from the United Center and the valet parking podium was standing farther upstage than he should have been. What caught Shanika’s eye was the stage manager, who was speaking into a microphone attached to her headset as she snapped her fingers at the kid, then pointed deeper in the wings, obviously giving him a command to move.
The kid ignored her.
Shanika’s stomach lurched. He was turning a slight gray-green. The stage manager had walked away, gesturing at someone else, and the other contestants were watching the stage.
Driscoll Johnson, the cutest of the celebrity judges, had stopped the current contestant and was grilling him about the bunny—where did it come from? How did the contestant plan to return the freaked-out bunny to its point of origin? Did the contestant think about the fate of magicked bunnies or did he just use them and toss them away like they weren’t even living creatures?
Everyone was laughing except Wizardo!, Shanika, and the kid in the back. Those spikes were starting to show, streaked with red—and she knew, she knew that this time, the explosion wouldn’t be contained.
The kid was standing in the perfect spot to destroy every contestant on the stage and to literally bring down the roof. The power from the blast—if she could judge from what he was building—would hit the judges, the stage managers, the camera operators, and maybe even dent the shield.
“Mom,” she said, tugging her mom’s sleeve. Her mother was laughing just like everyone else. “Mom.”
Her mother frowned at her. “What?”
“Go get help.”
“What?” her mother asked.
The kid’s cloud or aura or whatever it was had gained black streaks along with the red. The spikes looked armed and dangerous.
“Just get security!” Shanika cried and launched herself forward.
She zoomed toward the stage, pointing her body like a bullet, and broke through the sparkles in the shield. People started screaming, and the celebrity judges were on their feet. The rabbit escaped from Wizardo!’s hand, and the stage manager was yelling at Shanika.
She didn’t care.
She grabbed all the gray goo around the kid, and shoved it at the spikes, then wrapped him up in as much fabric as she could find.
The stage manager was still yelling at her, and Shanika said, “Help me, for heaven sake. He’s using black magic!”
The kid was struggling in her arms, and she was running out of strength. She couldn’t keep pulling fabric from thin air, and the gray goo she had appropriated from him was reforming as blast spikes.
Another girl jumped on Shanika, and reinforced her fabric spell with some kind of plastic spell.
“Don’t cover his face,” Shanika said. “It’ll kill him.”
“But he’s conjuring out loud,” the girl said. It took both of them to hold him down.
She was right: the kid was speaking his spell.
Shanika used the last of her magic to wrap a gag around his mouth. The gag was pink and it sparkled, and his eyes narrowed. He spat, but he couldn’t get the fabric out of his mouth.
More people piled on, and then security came, and someone pulled Shanika off the kid. They shoved clear protection shields around the kid, and that’s when Shanika noticed that she had wrapped him up fashionably, in an outfit that made the tux Wizardo! had been wearing actually look like something a celebrity would wear on the red carpet. The kid even had on a top hat, only his head had been shoved through it, and the top hat—a super-large one—covered his shoulders and arms, holding them in place.
Shanika’s legs wobbled, and she suddenly felt very dizzy. Someone caught her and eased her to the ground. She looked up. It was Driscoll Johnson.
“Get her some water, Gatorade, something,” he said. “She’s having a reaction.”
This was not how she imagined being close to Driscoll Johnson. She couldn’t even smile weakly at him.
“She got through the shield?” Vivian Singh asked, crouching beside Shanika.
“Like it was tissue,” Seth Lee, the other celebrity judge said. “She shouldn’t have been able to do that.”
He sounded scared.
“We’ll worry about it later,” Driscoll Johnson said. “She saved us all.”
“Does that mean she won?” Shanika’s mother asked. Shanika hadn’t even seen her arrive. Shanika closed her eyes and wished she were somewhere else. Anywhere else.
But she didn’t have any magical reserves to make that wish come true.
“We all won,” Driscoll Johnson said. “Thanks to your daughter, today, we all won.”
In the end, they disqualified her. She had broken two major rules—she had broken the shield between the contestants and the audience, and she had interrupted another contestant’s routine.
It didn’t matter that if she hadn’t, everyone would have died. It didn’t matter that if she hadn’t, American Magic would have gone off the air in a spectacular way.
It didn’t matter how much her mother argued for her, the lawyers and the suits and the network all decided Shanika couldn’t continue to participate.
Which Shanika didn’t mind, even though her mother was heartbroken. Shanika wanted to go home. She didn’t want the attention that the incident was foisting on her.
There was talk, led by Driscoll Johnson, of giving her some kind of monetary award for saving the day, particularly after her sob-story interview got played over and over again on national television (along with photos of her grandmother’s tiny house). The analysts all noted that Shanika had learned how to do powerful protect spells because she lived in a gang neighborhood.
She never bothered to tell anyone she’d actually learned the spells by augmenting the spells her mother and grandmother had already performed to protect the house. Shanika never got the chance to define her own narrative, as the producers would have said. She was the little poor girl who had to defend her house and ended up defending everyone at American Magic too.
Three different clothing companies wanted to buy her spells for protective gear, and the Defense Department wanted to consult with her for military applications, and somehow, the organizers of American Magic claimed they had the rights to negotiate for her, and her mother stepped in (thank heavens) because Shanika was underage.
All Shanika wanted was to hang out with the band. She never got the chance to see the dailies, and by the time she thought to ask (a few days later), she was told the band never showed dailies to anyone. It didn’t matter how much she said she was invited, she couldn’t get through that door.
Typical. Because no one was listening to her, like they’d failed to listen to her before. She’d known that kid was trouble from the beginning. Apparently, he was part of a coven that had been trying to sabotage American Magic for ten seasons. The coven hated American Magic for trivializing magic.
The kid claimed that he would have set off the explosion spell, and then others from his coven would have swooped in and repaired everything before anyone got hurt.
But no others from his coven had been anywhere near the Thirteen Colonies theater that day. It soon became clear that someone had sent the poor kid into the situation alone to die in the explosion, and take the full blame, so the coven could continue its campaigns against performance magic unmolested.
The coven was being rounded up, the kid was talking to the authorities, and everyone connected with American Magic was giving interviews about how scared they had been.
The interviews finally ended, and the negotiations continued (who knew that Mother was good at that stuff?) and Driscoll Johnson made it clear to the producers and the network that if they didn’t find a way to financially reward Shanika, he would denounce them publically.
But everything was in limbo. Mostly, she wandered the hotel, where the contestants continued to strive to be the next Magical American. She had an honored seat for the performances if she wanted to see them, but she didn’t.
Instead, she played the piano in one of the banquet rooms, and wished she had never gone to the United Center auditions in the first place.
She was playing her favorite Chopin sonata when a shadow loomed over her. She stopped and sent up a protection shield before she realized she had even taken her fingers off the keys.
“Hey! I’m not trying to hurt you!”
She turned. The band leader Melvin Moody stood behind her. He looked as tired as she felt.
“When you talked to us that day,” he said, “I had no idea you were so talented.”
“Me, either,” she said, sliding into her interview response. “I had no idea I could go through that shield—”
“I know,” he said. “I heard. But I’m not talking about the magic. I’m talking about the music.”
She relaxed for the first time since she got here. The protection shield vanished as if it had never been.
“I want to be a concert pianist,” she said.
“That’s what you said.” He slipped onto the piano bench beside her, keeping a careful distance between them. “I had forgotten that until I heard someone playing. I haven’t heard Chopin played with such passion—maybe ever.”
She flushed.
“Forgive me for asking,” he said. “Just consider it a fault of my job, but do you use performance magic to augment your play?”
It was a point of pride among professional musicians: no magic allowed. Music was its own magic. She loved that, always had.
“No,” she said, trying not to sound offended.
He nodded, looked at the music stand, and then at her, as if he were thinking about something.
“You have to be here awhile, don’t you?” he asked.
“Until my mom gets back from today’s negotiations,” Shanika said.
“No, I mean in Salem. There’s the court case and the negotiations and—”
“Oh, so much,” she said. “They say it’s better if I don’t go home.”
She sort of agreed. She needed to go back to school, but everyone would want to talk about this—and she was done talking.
Moody ran a finger along the keys. “How would you…like to play with us?” he asked, slowly, as if he had come to a decision in the middle of his question.
“Tonight? Jam?” she asked.
He smiled. “No,” he said. “Play with us until the end of the show.”
“What?” She wasn’t sure she had heard him right.
He shrugged. “Our pianist just quit. One of the contestants tried to make an entire platoon of Gummy Bears dance on top of the piano and melted them into the strings instead, and that was the last straw for the pianist. He quit.”
Shanika sighed. “So you want me for my protection abilities.”
“No.” Moody looked down at his fingers, then played a soft C chord. “You’re a hundred times more talented than he is.”
“Yeah, magic—”
“At the piano,” Moody said. “The pianist who just quit? He couldn’t play Chopin. Not like you just did.”
This felt unreal. Shanika stared at Moody and said the first thing that came to mind. “I’m only fifteen.”
“I know,” he said.
“I’m supposed to be in school,” she said.
“We have teachers here for the underage contestants,” he said. “They can help you too.”
Her cheeks flushed. Playing music. On a big stage.
It wasn’t classical music, but it was music. Playing concerts. Learning how to be professional. A professional musician.
Her dream come true.
Shanika grinned at Moody. “Yes, I’d like to play with the band,” she said.
He shook her hand, and said something about rehearsals and a contract. She’d let her mom worry about the contract. Shanika would worry about the rehearsals.
Her heart was pounding, and she felt better than she ever had in her life.
The auditions at the United Center hadn’t worked the way she wanted. They hadn’t worked the way her mother wanted either.
But they had worked—better than Shanika had ever expected.
Salem WeekCopyright © 2016 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Fiction River: Sparks, edited by Rebecca Moesta, WMG Publishing, March 2016Published by WMG PublishingCover and layout copyright © 2016 by WMG PublishingCover design by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Fergregory/Dreamstime
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
After a decade of trying to get a statue of Mercury for her museum’s antiquities department, Harper finally succeeds. But then the statue arrives—broken—and a spectacular forgery. Her boss—impressed—calls the statue the ultimate forgery. Harper wonders if she, too, should appreciate the forgery—until the statue starts talking.
“Clay Feet,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Clay FeetKristine Kathryn Rusch“It’s broken,” Harper said. She still held the metal pry bar in her right hand. It took all of her discipline to keep from swinging the thing at the museum staff.
The crate’s top lay on the storage room floor, straw and packing materials scattered everywhere.
But Harper wasn’t looking at the packing materials or the crate itself. She was looking at the statue inside. Mercury’s winged helmet tilted jauntily on his stone curls, looking more like Robin Hood’s cap than the armor for the Messenger of the Gods.
“His helmet isn’t supposed to be like that,” she said, “and his feet! Look at his feet!”
The rest of the antiquities staff looked. Mercury’s feet, which should have been stuffed in winged shoes, had melted onto the crate’s bottom.
Harper dropped the pry bar onto the stone floor. The clatter did not make her feel better.
This ancient statue of Mercury was supposed to be the heart of their new antiquities collection. Harper had negotiated for it for the last decade. She’d even flown to Rome to meet with Italian authorities. Like so many other countries now, Italy wanted its precious antiquities inside its own borders.
Lately cries of theft had reverberated all over the world—whether it was old thefts of Egyptian tombs (which benefitted places like the British Museum) or Nazi thefts of Jewish art, which then got sold (without enough provenance) to newer museums throughout Europe and the United States.
Technically, Harper had gotten the Mercury on loan, but the loan was permanent, so long as the museum made annual lease payments that amounted to more than her entire salary.
The hat Harper could repair, but the feet—how was she going to explain the feet to the Italian government? How was she going to explain the feet to anyone? Marble didn’t melt. Marble lasted centuries—millennia—buried underground, near rivers and streams.
“Have you ever seen anything like this?” she asked, more to herself than anyone else. She hadn’t. Not with something that had such great bona fides. The provenance on the Mercury sculpture was the best she’d ever seen.
“Actually,” said Malcolm Endicott, the senior curator, “I have seen something exactly like it.”
She turned.
Endicott was an old man. He was old when she was hired out of college fifteen years before, and he was older now. His skin had mottled and loosened; his hair had thinned so much that it looked like a ripped shirt covering his skull.
He wore bespoke suits to work every day, and at all times of year, he covered his wattled neck with a cravat instead of a tie.
His wife had died a few years before, and that seemed to give him permission to spend all of his time here.
Harper didn’t mind. The old man had a wealth of knowledge that she hadn’t sufficiently tapped yet, even though they’d worked side by side for most of her tenure.
“You’ve seen melting marble?” she asked him.
He smiled gently. He was sitting on a stool near one of the temporary walls. His back was straight, his expensively shod feet curled around the stool’s rungs. If he fell, he’d break not only bones in his torso, but the bones in his legs as well.
“Darling,” he said in a tone only he could use with her. “Marble doesn’t melt.”
His thoughts echoed hers, but she didn’t say that. Instead, she swept her hand toward the statue and its ruined feet.
“Then what is this?”
His smile grew. “An elaborate forgery.”
“You can tell that from over there?”
He nodded.
“The forgery fooled experts all over the world,” she said.
“Then the forgery itself might be worth some money,” he said.
“Only historical forgeries are worth money,” she said.
Sometimes forgeries had a provenance too. Either they were completed by an artist who later made a reputation for himself, or they belonged to a moment in time, one that could be traced and reproduced just like the original.
For decades, the replications of the Venus de Milo was all that the art world had of that masterpiece. Many art historians believed a lot of the replications were forgeries.
Then the original Venus was discovered, and the others lost value, but not as much as they would have without the provenance.
“I would wager,” Endicott said, “this is a premier historical forgery.”
“Wagering doesn’t help us.” Usually she wasn’t that curt with the old man. But usually she wasn’t faced with a forged treasure she had fought nearly a decade to receive.
“Did I ever tell you how I served after the war?” he asked.
“No,” she said, trying to hide her impatience. She didn’t have time for a story. Besides, she already knew about Endicott’s past.
He had joined up late and served the last two years of World War II in combat. He then resigned for a tour to rebuild Europe. Occasional stories that leaked out from him or his late wife put him in Paris after liberation, Berlin after Hitler’s death, and the Italian Alps after Mussolini’s fall.
“I was on recovery duty.” He put a hand on that false wall to brace himself as he untangled his feet from the stool. One of the younger staff members rushed to his side, but he waved the woman aside. The wall wobbled as he stood, but it didn’t tumble like Harper feared it would.
“Recovery duty,” she repeated. She knew better than to ask a question. She didn’t want to encourage the memory.
Endicott nodded as he walked toward her. His polished shoes slid on the straw and she reached out in case he fell. He ignored her. Instead he crouched and stared at the ruined feet.
“Plaster,” he said softly. “Experts couldn’t have been fooled by plaster.”
She crouched beside him. Cautiously she reached inside the crate. The statue felt like marble on the surface, the way that fake marble countertops felt like marble. But fake marble countertops did not have the weight of marble.
This statue had the correct weight. Their normal deliverymen would have noticed something lighter. She would have too as she helped them struggle the crate into the receiving part of the storage area.
Her finger brushed against the melted feet. The weight of this statue came not from the surface materials but from the materials used on the interior.
Endicott was right; it was plaster mixed with some kind of rock for heft.
“You’ve seen this before?” she asked.
He nodded. “At Carinhall, in a corner of the garden. My heart nearly stopped when we arrived to find Nike of Samothrace melting in the rain.”
He left it there, waiting for her to ask questions.
But she didn’t. She didn’t have time.
Instead, she directed the staff members to take photographs and document the crate’s arrival.
She had to check her own documentation which she kept in her office.
But she couldn’t stop thinking about Nike of Samothrace. It was one of the Louvre’s most famous sculptures. Better known as Winged Victory of Samothrace, the sculpture anchored the wing between the Galerie d’Apollon and the Salon Carré with the new rooms built parallel to the Grande Galerie.
On her very first visit to the Louvre, Harper had run up the flight of stairs leading to Winged Victory, wanting to see both her and the Mona Lisa before her visit ended.
But Harper had spent most of her time gazing at Winged Victory. The huge statue, taller than most men, had been found in pieces on the island of Samothrace in 1863. It was reassembled into an imposing figure of a woman—Nike, the Greek Goddess of Victory—her wings extended behind her, body in motion, as she stood on the prow of a ship. The sculpture probably stood on a promontory overlooking the sea. The archeologists searched but never found the most important piece—her head—and yet the sculpture was impressive without it.
As Harper sat below it, she could almost hear the sea wind blow, and Nike’s garments flapping in the breeze. No sculpture had taken her breath like that before; few had done so since.
Although the sculpture of Mercury, which the scholars believed to be as old as Nike of Samothrace, had taken her breath too when she saw it in a private collection near Rome. That was the day she decided to purchase it.
That was the day that started her on the long journey which brought her here.
Here, to her office, where she stared at the pile of documentation beside her. Provenance, insurance documents, down payments, and guarantees. Now she would face lawyers and legal challenges and headaches beyond imagining.
She needed to be back in the storage room, photographing the Mercury statue and the condition it arrived in. Her entire career rested on this sculpture now. Not dealing with the fraud directly would be disastrous, both to her and to the museum.
Still, she couldn’t bring herself to go back downstairs. She had come up to her office to get all of the materials and to start downloading new copies of the e-mail files from the past two months. She was supposed to print up the e-mails whenever they came in, but she was usually too busy.
Now she might pay for that as well. If any emails pertaining to the Mercury sculpture were lost, the trail might grow cold.
So she had electronically stored the files and now she was printing them, the printer queue backed up some 55 emails strong.
She should have looked through the documentation while she printed. Instead, she went to Google and typed in “Karenhall.” She got some strange responses, most of which seemed to have nothing to do with Endicott or sculpture.
So she typed in “Karenhall” and “World War II” and got this message: Did you mean Carinhall? She hit that link, and discovered what Endicott meant.
Carinhall was Hermann Goering’s country house, located fifty miles outside of Berlin. Goering had been a member of Hitler’s inner circle. He had filled Carinhall with valuable artworks from all over Europe, then taken eleven traincars full of those artworks from the house just ahead of the Russian Army’s arrival in early 1945.
Americans were not allowed on the site until the Russians had left in the fall of 1945, and then the only Americans who went there were part of an international group formed to return priceless artifacts to the countries the Nazis had stolen them from.
Harper found no mention of Endicott’s name in connection to Carinhall, but she did finally understand why he had been in Paris and Berlin and in the Italian Alps. Anywhere the Germans stored priceless art, stolen from conquered nations, Endicott had been there, cataloguing, discovering, saving.
She had no idea she was working with such a man. She wondered if anyone else in the museum did either.
She grabbed the stack of documentation for the Mercury sculpture, checked to make sure she had enough paper in her printer for the remaining e-mails, and then went back to the storage area.
Of course, Endicott was no longer there.
She found him in his office, a cloistered room in the very center of the museum. The room was hidden behind secret panels in the library wing. To get in, one had to know which panel hid the combination lock, and what the combination was.
Staff members had told Endicott for years that the room was no longer safe for him to spend so much time in (if, indeed, it ever had been), but he didn’t care.
If I die in there, he would respond, his faded blue eyes twinkling, then eventually you’ll smell me and you’ll know what happened.
She hadn’t liked that idea at all, and checked on him twice a day—when she first arrived and just before she left.
She did understand why he spent so much time in his office, though. It was homey, in a cluttered Victorian kind of way.
Reproductions of bronzes and small Etruscan vases stood on various surfaces. Larger reproductions of some of the world’s most treasured antiquities covered his floor.
Harper particularly liked the statue of Diana, which was a reproduction of another famous Louvre sculpture. One Christmas, Endicott had placed a wreath of mistletoe around Diana’s head. The mistletoe remained all year. The next Christmas, he’d added a Santa cap to the stag that leapt beside her.
Even now, in June, the Christmas decorations looked appropriately festive.
His whimsy was apparent everywhere—in the lovely jacket he had placed over the reproduction of the Venus de Milo (the jacket had Anne Boleyn sleeves and did not button in the front, leaving Venus’s greatest assets visible to the room), as well as in the placement of the screaming Harpies in front of a worried-looking statue of Zeus.
Most of the small jokes were beyond the newer curators and staff members, but Harper spent a lot of time noticing the details, and the details in Endicott’s cluttered office all had meaning, most of it wry.
He was sitting behind his desk, another reproduction, this one of the desk Jack Kennedy used to use in the Oval Office. The statue of a small boy peered out of the opening near the feet, echoing the famous photograph of Kennedy’s son, John, playing there when he was still a toddler.
“I thought I’d see you sooner,” Endicott said. “Still worried about losing your job?”
“My job or any job,” she said. “This is a drastic mistake. I’m not sure how I could have made it.”
Endicott’s smile was sad. “You didn’t, my dear. Someone else did, either before the statue got crated or along the way. That’s for insurance people and detectives to find out. You’ll be vindicated. Somewhere there is a real statue.”
“Like there was for Nike of Samothrace?” she asked.
“Ah, you looked it up,” he said.
“Yes,” she said. “There’s even a documentary about the effort it took to take Nike from the Louvre shortly after the Germans invaded Poland. France didn’t want its treasures stolen or destroyed.”
“So,” Endicott said, touching his fingertips together, “you think I lied about seeing Winged Victory in the gardens at Carinhall?”
“I’m assuming it was a reproduction,” she said. “But I couldn’t find confirmation in my very short search.”
“It was,” he said. “And not as good as the one you have in the storage area. The entire statue was made of plaster, not coated with some other substance like the one below. I have no idea what Goering was thinking when he placed it in the garden. He had to know it would melt.”
She frowned at Endicott. “I didn’t realize he reproduced a lot of art. I thought he confiscated it. The website I found says he took everything from Jewish homes and museums and placed it in his various homes.”
“He did.” Endicott wasn’t smiling any longer. “And he wasn’t alone. It seemed half the German army was stealing art. And then the Allies stole art as well. It’s a crime that we’ll never recover from.”
“So the reproductions?” she asked.
“Placeholders,” Endicott said. “He commissioned them to fit into his designs until he found where the originals were hiding.”
“Fortunately, he never found Nike,” Harper said.
Endicott tapped his fingertips together. Then he slid his wheeled chair back and grabbed a large, thick book. It was covered in dust. He used a cloth to remove the dust, then he opened the book.
It was filled with yellowed clippings, photographs, and notations. He paged through it until he found some grainy pictures.
“I think he did find her,” Endicott said. “I think he replaced her with the reproduction, leaving the reproduction in Valençay.”
“Tallyrand’s estate?” she asked. “I thought Venus was there too.”
She was an instant expert from her Internet reading.
“And the French crown jewels, which I believe he left, expecting to come back for them.”
“You have proof of this?” she asked.
He tapped the pictures. Harper leaned forward. She was wrong; they weren’t grainy pictures. They were black-and-white pictures of the Carinhall garden in full flower, with sculptures everywhere. The reason the pictures seemed grainy was because whoever had taken them had done so in a downpour.
Nike of Samothrace stood in the center of the garden, water dripping off her majestic shoulders. Around her, water pooled, but the prow of the ship which was the sculpture’s base looked like it was intact. She saw no melting, no blurring of the sculpture’s clean lines, which she should have seen with plaster in that kind of downpour.
“But the Nike in the Louvre is real,” she said. “I’ve seen it.”
“As has all of the art world for the past sixty years,” he said.
“How did the sculptures get switched?”
“Ah, that’s the question,” he said. “It took special movers to get that statue to Valençey in the Loire Valley. Yet the Germans, with all of their very careful documentation, have no record of the work it would have taken to remove Nike from her storage spot at Valençay and take her to Carinhall—close to Berlin, no less.”
“And then take her back,” Harper said.
“Before the Russians arrived,” Endicott said, “since she was majestically melting when I found her.”
He grabbed another notebook. This one wasn’t as dusty. He opened it to the middle, revealing photographs of the same garden, littered with rubble from the destroyed house. At the center of six shots stood the plaster Nike of Samothrace. The prow of the ship looked like a sunken bathtub, the grass covered with a whitish paste. The sculpture itself looked like a nude. The lines of the garment, which were designed to look like a Greek gown blowing backwards in the wind, were gone, leaving only the sculpture’s legs and torso. The magnificent wings dripped giant drops of plaster onto the plants behind them.
“My God,” Harper said. “Who took the original photographs?”
Endicott shrugged. “We found these photographs in the house. I assume one of Goering’s staff took the pictures, or perhaps his second wife, Emmy. It is one of those mysteries. We don’t even know when they were taken, although we know it was before 1945, when the family fled the property.”
Harper took a closer look at the original photographs. Then she grabbed one of the magnifying glasses that Endicott kept on his desk.
Behind a shrub, she saw the edge of a winged hat. Peeking through the leaves, she thought she saw winged shoes.
“Look at that,” she said, pushing the photographs back to Endicott. He took a different magnifying glass.
“I don’t think that’s your Mercury,” he said. “The body’s position is different.”
She stood, so that she could see it better. She wasn’t sure. The body position might be accurate for her Mercury. It was hard to tell, now that the sculpture she had in the storage area was a reproduction. She had to trust her memory for forms.
She’d seen the original (and it had to be the original; she couldn’t have been fooled by a fake) nearly a decade before. Her memory, while good, wasn’t that good.
She scanned the other photographs. Their angle kept the statue hidden. They almost made Mercury seem like he was hiding in the garden.
“I think it’s just brilliant placement,” she said. “Whoever designed this garden probably knew all of Mercury’s identities.”
“Perhaps,” Endicott said, but he didn’t sound convinced.
Harper set the magnifying glass down. “How much do you think a forgery with this kind of provenance would bring?”
“One of Goering’s forgeries?” Endicott shrugged. “Hard to tell now. Maybe not so much in the art market, but in the historical markets, among collectors, quite a bit.”
“Between that and the insurance, then, we might be able to make some of our investment back.”
“Might,” Endicott said, but he sounded dismissive, as if he didn’t care about the insurance.
She did. She cared about the financial bath the museum would take because of her mistake.
“I’m not sure,” Endicott said, “you’re seeing what I see when I look at the original photographs.”
“I’m sure I’m not,” she said. “You were there. You know how they fit in context.”
He shook his head. Obviously, he hadn’t meant that either.
“What do you see when you look at the photographs?” she asked.
“Miracles,” he said. “A garden full of miracles.”
Usually Harper appreciated Endicott’s whimsy, but on this day, it irritated her. She felt like she had lost precious time talking with him. He could have told her about the Mercury sculpture in the garden, the fakes that Goering collected, and the possibility that one of them had found its way into her museum.
Instead, Endicott had played games, making her stare at old photographs until her eyes hurt, and talking of miracles.
Those photographs had no date on them. For all she knew, the Nike of Samothrace could have been the plaster reproduction, coated with something that held off the rain for a year or two.
She tried not to let her irritation blossom into anger because she knew she wasn’t really angry with Endicott—he had provided her with a bit of salvation, after all—but with the so-called experts she’d hired to guide her Mercury statue on its journey from Rome to her storage room.
Someone had failed, and even if she didn’t lose her job over it, she would lose time and honor and her spotless reputation.
Endicott wouldn’t explain his “miracle” comment. He seemed almost hurt when she asked him to. Instead, he’d shrugged and mumbled something about the ramblings of an old man.
That was when she knew she had lost him. He had meant to explain something to her and she had somehow offended him.
At the moment, she didn’t care. He would get over his fit of pique. But she might not get over this blow to her reputation. She had to act now, with her own photographs and documentation. She needed to write up her own history of the purchase and call a lawyer, so that she was not only prepared when the time came to defend herself, but well represented.
She hurried out of Endicott’s office, and down the stairs. She hated taking the elevators after hours. The sound of the mechanisms in the empty museum always made her think of monster movies—something about to attack in the darkness.
Not that the museum was ever completely dark. Some of the collections had covers, protecting them from the lights, but each room had dim lighting. The museum had a single security guard, but mostly he monitored the security cameras. He only did a room-to-room visit once an hour, and even then, what he did was a walk-through, not a thorough examination.
The main lights were off in the storage room. The staff had clearly finished up while she was talking to Endicott. Prints of digital photographs sat on one of the metal tables. The photos were good, but, as she feared, not good enough.
She looked around for the digital camera, thinking maybe someone had left it on the table. But she didn’t see it. She would have to go back to her office to get her own camera, which made sense, because from now on, everything she did would be on her own.
As she turned, she saw a man sitting on the stool, his features hidden in shadow.
“For god’s sake, Malcolm,” she said to Endicott, “you’re going to break every single bone in your body sitting on that thing.”
He laughed. Only the laugh didn’t sound like Endicott’s. It was rich and warm and deep, almost as if it had its own built-in reverberation chamber.
“I’ve never broken a bone in my life,” he said.
He was quite clearly not Endicott or anyone else she knew. She should have hit the lights when she came in, but she hadn’t, and now they were by the door, which seemed very far away from her.
Because of a blackout years ago in which a security guard walked through a Vermeer canvas on loan from another museum, the directors insisted on flashlights at every corner. Since the storage room didn’t have corners, it had flashlights on every table.
She moved slowly, so that she didn’t seem like a woman panicked.
The flashlight leaned against a receipt book. She grabbed the light, flicked it on, and shone it at the man’s face.
He didn’t raise his hands to block the light. He didn’t even squint. Instead, he looked vaguely amused. He had a stunningly handsome face—high cheekbones accenting a Roman nose. His eyes were so dark they looked black in the light. His hair curled around his forehead and down the side of his face like a small cap.
“Do I pass inspection?” he asked.
She didn’t answer. His face looked oddly familiar, but the familiarity became something else as he moved. It was almost as if she’d seen one of the statues come alive.
And then she realized who he looked like.
She looked over her shoulder at the open crate. The assistants had moved it closer to the lights, which meant she could still see the features in the thin emergency lighting as well.
“Oh, by Zeus’s throne,” the man said. “Go turn on the overhead lights. I’ll go stand by the stupid sculpture so that you can see definitively that I am the subject of the sculptor’s vision. Then we can move on to other, more important things.”
She almost didn’t walk to the light switch, just because she didn’t want to take orders from this strange man. But she did. And she also hit the silent alarm, so that the security guard would know there had been some kind of breach.
When she turned, she saw the man standing next to the sculpture. He was thin, but heavily muscled—like a professional distance runner would be—and he looked exactly like the fake Mercury, except that he wasn’t wearing a winged helmet, at a rakish angle or any other way.
“You made the forgery,” she said.
“My dear,” he said, “if I had made the forgery, it would have been a lot better than this one. I stole the forgery and had it sent to you.”
“Excuse me?” she said. Did he just admit he was behind this whole mess? If so, why?
“You have no right to the statue,” he said.
“I paid for it,” she snapped.
“Ah, yes. American greed and arrogance. You’re like so many other arrogant cultures. They all die, you know.”
He was as irritating as he was pretty.
“The sculpture belongs to the museum,” she said. “What did you do with it?”
“The original sculpture,” he said, “belongs in a temple, where it can be properly worshiped.”
“Worshipped?” She wanted to look at the door, to see if the security guard was anywhere close, but she didn’t want to clue the crazy man that someone was coming.
“Worshipped,” the man said. “All of these statues that you’ve pilfered are religious icons, you know.”
“No one knows what this is,” she said. “It was found in Greece nearly a century ago. There was no temple nearby, no clue as to why Mercury stood alone.”
“Hermes,” the man said.
“Excuse me?” she asked.
“The proper name is Hermes, although you’ve pilfered that name as well. And for a scarf. You have no idea how offended one God can feel.”
The flashlight slipped in her hand. Her palms were sweating. This man was scaring her.
“Yes, yes,” she said. “I know the Greek name for Mercury is Hermes. But—”
“But nothing,” he said. “This is a Greek sculpture from a temple originally built to honor Hermes. It does not belong to you. Nor does it belong to Rome. It belongs on its island, away from avid eyes that do no understand that Gods were meant to be worshipped, not gawked at.”
Hadn’t the guard gotten her message? She was convinced she had sent it. So far this strange man didn’t seem like a physical threat to her, although he might hurt the forgery. And that might be just as bad as losing the original in the first place.
She had to stall. Maybe the security guard, who wasn’t the most courageous man, was waiting for backup.
“No one worships the Greek Gods anymore,” she said. “There are no active temples.”
“And that,” the crazy man said, “is a crime. But it is one we live with. Still, this image was stolen from its homeland. It must return there, to its proper place.”
She swallowed. “Why?”
“Why?” he said. “To rebuild. We’ve let pale imitations of ourselves be studied for too long. We need to restore the temples, and take our places as proper gods.”
“Our places?” she asked, feeling even more confused than she had when the conversation started. “Yours and mine?”
He gave her a condescending smile. “I’m sorry, my dear. You are a minion, not a god.”
She straightened. Of all the things people had called her throughout her life, minion was the absolute worst.
“Just because you look like a damn statue doesn’t make you a god either,” she snapped.
To her surprise, he smiled. “What came first, eh? The statue or the god?”
“The concept,” she said, as if he were asking a really intelligent question instead of a facetious one. “And everyone knows that sculptors from Bernini to Michangelo used real life models to represent made-up characters.”
“Hermes is made up?” he asked.
“All gods are,” she said.
His eyebrows rose. “A cynic.”
“A realist.”
“This sculpture,” he said, “was not made by one of your late-model Italians. It dates from the era you call Before Christ.”
“That statue,” she said, “probably dates from last week.”
“I am talking about the real sculpture,” he said. “This one comes from sixty years ago. Your friend Endicott should have recognized it. His friend Goering had it made.”
“Malcolm Endicott would not call Hermann Goering a friend,” she snapped.
The crazy man held up his hands as if he were trying to calm her. “No, no, you’re right,” he said. “I simply meant—”
“That this is one of Goering’s fakes,” she said. “I already figured that out. Give me the original.”
“I am the original,” the man said.
“You are Hermes, Messenger of the Gods?” She couldn’t keep the sarcasm from her voice.
He nodded slowly. “I have come to tell you and others like you that you may not keep our statues. It is long past time. We have put up with this long enough. We would like our temples rebuilt, our statues returned to their homelands and replaced.”
He spoke as if he had been making a pronouncement.
She glanced at the door.
“Why?” she asked, mostly to keep the crazy man talking.
“Why?” he said. “Because it is the right thing to do.”
“All of you believe that?” she asked.
He nodded.
“That’s the message?”
He nodded again.
She decided to humor his delusion. She wished the damn security guard would get here.
“You,” she said, “the God of Commerce, are telling us to hurt our museum business and send one of our major draws away at no charge. That doesn’t sound good to me. Does it sound good to you?”
His lovely eyes narrowed. “What do you mean?”
“This museum is a business. If you are Mercury or Hermes, as you seem to prefer, then you protect merchants and all commerce. They call you the God of Commerce. Are you going to deny the title?”
“I am also the Divine Herald,” he said. “I lead people on their final journey, death. Are you asking me to respond in that capacity as well?”
She couldn’t hide her shiver. But she straightened nonetheless. She wasn’t going to let him know how much he intimidated her.
“Don’t threaten me,” she said.
“I’m not,” he said. “I’m just amazed you’re pulling out my résumé to make me feel guilty. I am the messenger of the gods, and the message I bring is to let these statues return to their rightful place.”
“Which would ruin my business.”
“In the United States, a museum is not a business. It has protected status. That status is called a non-profit, which makes it a charity.” His eyes twinkled. “I am not the god of charities.”
Whoever he was, he had a point. A museum was not a business. It got grants to supplement its income. It survived even if it didn’t make a dime.
“You’ve done this before,” she said. “You took Nike of Samothrace and returned her to the Louvre.”
She expected him to deny it, or to be surprised by the question, not understanding it at all.
Instead, he smiled again. “You are smarter than you look. But I did not return her to the Louvre. I sent her to a protected place in the Loire Valley, while I searched for the remains of her temple. I have not yet found it.”
“You sent her to Valençay. And now she is in the Louvre, where she started out.”
“She will be returned to her homeland,” he said, “when a place is prepared.”
“Do you have a place prepared for my statue?” Harper waved her hand at the dissolving reproduction.
“No,” the crazy man said softly. “I am just tired of my image being set up on a pedestal to be gawked at by ignorant tourists.”
“You would rather have your image in hiding?” she asked.
“I would rather be worshipped,” he said.
Of course he would. What man wouldn’t?
“Would you rather be worshipped as the God of Commerce and the messenger for the others? Doesn’t that make you an errand boy instead of a god?”
“I am not that,” he snapped.
“That’s how you’re acting,” she said.
“I am not,” he said, straightening.
“Then tell me,” she said, trying to keep the smile off her face, “why the God of Thieves is angry that someone has stolen a statue made from his image.”
The crazy man’s chin rose. His eyes narrowed, and for the first time, he looked formidable.
He might come at her. The only way she could prevent it was to keep talking—and maybe find that metal pry bar.
“You’re right,” she said, her throat suddenly dry. “Museums are not a business. And many museums, many famous museums, have stolen artifacts inside our walls. Some have paid hefty fines to keep precious artifacts. Others have had to return those artifacts to their home country.”
“So?” the crazy man asked. She had his attention now.
“So,” she said. “If you are who you say you are, you claim you want your image in a place of worship. What better place to worship the God of Thieves than in the antiquities section of a well known museum?”
It was her last gambit. She had probably offended him so deeply that he would lunge at her, hurt her, maybe even do damage down here.
She clutched the flashlight like a club, ready to use it if she had to.
But he didn’t look like a man about to lunge. Instead, he was frowning slightly, as if he were thinking.
“Thievery and commerce both,” he said slowly. “For museums make people pay to see the things you’ve stolen.”
“Yes,” she said, her heart pounding.
“And often, these things you’ve stolen have been stolen from the dead, whom I have led to their final resting places.”
She nodded, afraid to interrupt his reverie.
“And yet, people come here. They look in awe at the treasures you’ve assembled. The treasures you’ve stolen.”
“Well, someone has stolen them,” she said. She wasn’t going to admit to theft. So far as she knew, she hadn’t committed any.
So far as she knew.
He nodded. Then he bowed slightly.
“I have misrepresented you,” he said. “You are not a minion. You are a high priestess. The high priestess of the museum.”
Her cheeks flushed. “Thank you,” she said. “I think.”
He touched the crate. “I cannot speak for the others. I am their messenger, not the one who makes decisions for all of Olympus. But I can speak for myself. I am sorry to have misjudged you and your kind. And I am sorry that I disturbed you.”
“You didn’t….” she said, and then she let her voice trail off.
Because he had disappeared.
Literally vanished, right in front of her.
One moment, he had been standing there. The next, he was gone.
She walked toward the crate, and waved a hand where he had been. Nothing. No one stood there.
Then her gaze went to the statue. It looked different.
The winged helmet was on straight—and the winged boots were back on the feet. She touched the legs. Marble. They hadn’t melted at all.
Had she dreamed all of this?
She went back to the table.
No. The pictures were still there, with the missing shoes, the melting plaster, everything.
The doors burst open. The guard and Endicott hurried into the storage room.
“Something wrong?” the guard asked.
“Yeah,” Harper said. “I pressed the alarm at least a half an hour ago. What took you so long?”
“Three minutes, ma’am,” the guard said. “It’s only been three minutes. I have it all in my log.”
“I heard it too,” Endicott said, “and I came running.”
Three minutes? How was that possible? That was the longest three minutes of her life.
“What’s wrong?” the guard asked.
“Someone was here,” she said. “Do you have video in this room?”
“Only of the doors, ma’am,” he said.
“Check it,” she said. “But first, make sure we’re alone.”
“Yes, ma’am.” He put a hand on his gun, and walked around the edges of the storeroom.
Endicott peered at her. “What’s going on?”
She waved her hand toward the crate, without looking at it. “Tell me what you see.”
He put his hands behind his back and walked to the crate. Then he peered at it for the longest time.
She didn’t look at him. She watched the guard shine his own flashlight in the corners, making sure nothing lurked there.
He wouldn’t find anything. She knew that now.
“My God,” Endicott whispered.
“The statue is real now, isn’t it?” she asked.
He did exactly as she had. He went for the photographs.
“It’s been replaced,” he said.
She nodded.
“How?” he asked.
She took the photographs from him. “That,” she said, “is a very long story.”
“I have time,” Endicott said.
He did. So did she. And she had to tell someone.
She looped her arm in his, still clutching the photographs, and walked him toward the door. They would have dinner. Then they would come back and reassess.
“The story,” he urged.
She smiled. “You know the photograph of Mercury in the garden at Carinhall?”
“Yes,” he said.
“You were right. That wasn’t my statue back hiding behind the plants.”
“What was it?” Endicott asked.
“A miracle,” Harper said. “An annoying little miracle.”
Clay FeetCopyright © 2012 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in The Trouble With Heroes, edited by Denise Little, Daw Books, 2009.
Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2012 by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Andrey Lavrenov/Source
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved.This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional,and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental.This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
I don’t think I’ve let you all know that all of our online workshops on the WMG Teachable site are 50% off right now. That sale will last until late Wednesday night.
If you go to WMG’s Teachable page, you’ll find all kinds of workshops and opportunities. Add FeySale at checkout, and you’ll get each workshop for 50% off.
Don’t know what to take? Dean did an entire series of posts about the kinds of classes available. Click here, and then scroll through his website to find all the different posts.
Also, the opportunity that I’m the most excited about is this: You can attend (virtually) the Licensing Expo later in this month with me and Dean. We will be taking videos of our tour of licensing, our discussions and things we learn. The videos will go up in real time during the event. Learn more here. And yes, this is also 50% until Wednesday night.
The reason we’re having the sale is the same reason we usually do. We’ve opened a lovely new online store, this one for the Fey. Take a look. This store is going to grow exponentially this year, so join us on the ground floor…
Lots more news soon!
Lt. Kenyon serves his country and the war effort by censoring the crew’s letters home, even if his shipmates hate him for it. But when the crew begin writing about a ghostly vision—a vision impossible to believe but inadvisable to ignore—he must address the danger facing the ship. And he must make a difficult choice that will affect every last man on board.
“Tribute,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
TributeKristine Kathryn RuschWe were on the Pacific, a long stretch of nowhere, gray upon gray, going on forever.
This was early in the war, our backsides still blistering from the pounding the Japs were giving us. I was a newly minted lieutenant with a job I hated: I was the one who read all the outgoing mail and censored it even before it left the battleship.
I’m sure our boys knew someone read the mail. I’m sure all of them knew it was me. But we didn’t discuss jobs much. I was just one of a handful of ranking paper pushers on a vessel where most guys got their hands dirty. I like to think I was more uncomfortable than they were; after all, I knew more about any of them than they would rightly tell me.
…Judy, hon: dreamed about you three nights running. Finally Sanders, my bunkmate, told me to think purer thoughts—guess I was moaning suggestively in my sleep…
…Martha, remember that night down on Wisconsin Point? Sometimes I think I still got sand in my drawers…
…And, Ma, don’t say nothing to Carl about when I’m coming home. No sense in disappointing the kid. I just have a hunch things ain’t gonna go the way we planned…
Hopes, dreams, and fears, all hand-scrawled, all personal. Sure, the guys knew someone would read them, but even on this, their first mission—maybe especially on this, their first mission—they were scared and homesick, that rush of emotion that led ’em to join up forgotten back at the first day of camp.
I was a more grizzled vet. I joined up in ’39 for a variety of reasons. My folks were gone, my sweetheart married another. I’d left Connecticut angry and lost. There was a war brewing; we all knew it, and I thought if I joined early, I had a better chance of surviving.
Hard to convey how naïve we were. Fresh out of Seattle with a stop in Hawaii. We looked at those charred ships still decorating Pearl Harbor, saw some of the survivors moaning in the remaining hospitals, and felt patriotic all over again.
But out in the middle of a gray ocean, nothing around us but water and sky, it was easy to forget how badly we wanted revenge. Nights spent listening to the engines chug along—the only thing between us and a watery grave—and we knew we were heading into the unknown. It didn’t matter how right our mission was. Our lives had changed, and we still weren’t used to it.
We weren’t part of any fleet. We thought we were supposed to join one at Pearl, but those orders got changed. Of course, we didn’t learn about the change until after we stopped, refueled, and steamed ahead on our own.
We felt as if the battles were being fought ahead of us, as if we were struggling to catch up. Some of the ensigns sat watch on deck, worrying about Jap suicide missions. Those worries got into the letters too—and I’d cut them out, using thick black ink on both sides of the paper, so that no one could read what the boys were saying. Sometimes I literally cut the pages and taped the remains together. That way the folks at home wouldn’t know if little Johnny was fighting in the Pacific or the Atlantic, and they wouldn’t know how frightened he was.
But I did. The fears stuck with me, haunting me in different voices when I lay down on my bunk. I ranked a cabin—smaller than the head, but private just the same—because of the secret nature of my job. I guess the brass was afraid I’d confide in my bunkmate or talk in my sleep, so they censored me in the only way they could—by letting me have my privacy.
In my privacy, there wasn’t a lot to think about except what I read. How Hastings hoped his newborn daughter was doing well, Carmichael worrying about his wife, who’d never lived alone; and all those investments LeMeu was making from abroad. Still, when the strangeness started, I didn’t think much of it. I was concentrating on the gossip, wondering how scrawny guys like Daemer managed to get a date at all, let alone five different women whom he claimed undying love for.
Muriak, I think, was the first one to mention the ship. Like a pirate ship—he’d written in his sprawling prose—lots of masts and riggings. Only there had to be an engine, too, because she kept up with us. Always dogging us in our wake.
I cut the reference without much thought—except to note the superstitious way he talked about her. I even remember thinking of warning him—a man wasn’t allowed to talk about anything that referred to the war (no wonder so many of those letters ended up pornographic: they didn’t have anything else they could write about)—but I changed my mind soon enough. If I warned every guy who crossed the line, I’d have no job to do. Or worse, they would all remember that I was the man who read their mail, and knew exactly what they wanted to do to their sweethearts (often in painfully graphic detail) when they got home.
I’d been too visible already on this trip. I’d done my duty, and while it had been the right thing, it had bothered everyone—including me. Still, I paid attention. I had to.
Muriak had first watch most nights, and it seemed that sitting alone in the dark got to his head. At least that was what I thought. If there was a ship dogging us, like he wrote about, he would have reported it to the captain—that was part of his duty. I checked, discretely, and he never had.
The second reference came in DeBeyr’s daily letter to an old friend of his in Princeton, a guy who was an unhappy 4-F. Seems Blackbeard is tailing us, he wrote. Wonder what we should do if he boards.
I cut that too. Even though it was fanciful, it read like code—and that wouldn’t be a good thing to fall into enemy hands.
Then the very next letter, Briscoe’s, had this: A lot of guys have seen a ghost ship. I think it’s the effect of staring at nothing all day. You can’t know how depressing it is, staring at sea and sky with nothing to show you the horizon. When there’s emptiness all around you, you start making stuff up to fill it.
The black pen inked out that section too, wise as it was. My stomach clenched, though. Not because I was censoring—believe it or not, I got used to that pretty quick—but because of his tone and the idea that some of the recruits were going slowly, steadily mad.
I read Briscoe’s letter just before lunch. I finished it (he wrote to his sister every day even though, before he shipped out, they weren’t close. Just need someone sympathetic to talk to, I guess, his first letter had said. I had cut that sentence too) and put it in the packet for the letters to be dropped next port—where some other censor would check my work before shipping the letters on home—and let myself out of my cubby.
My office was private too, and cubby was a good description of it. Small, boxlike, and filled with papers, there was barely enough room for a chair and a desk. I worked in silence, reading other people’s mail, and making decisions about it. The room was windowless and charmless and in my time on that ship, I never decorated it. I guess part of me wanted it to feel dirty and secret like the job I was doing.
When I left the office, as I did after I read Briscoe’s letter, I had to hide everything on the desk, then lock the door and pocket the key. I always tested the knob, just to make sure I didn’t make a mistake. It was more for my protection than the letters’. The boys knew they were being censored; they just didn’t have to see how much.
I searched out the captain and found him in the officer’s mess, getting ready for lunch.
“You’re early, Kenyon,” he said as he took a cup of coffee to a nearby table. He was a burly man with a perpetually red face. His short blond hair made the top of his skull perfectly flat, as if someone had cropped it with a machete.
“Yes, sir,” I said. “I have something to discuss with you.”
He grunted and gestured, looking very uncomfortable. The last time we’d had this type of discussion, I’d shown him four letters from Ensign Zuklor in which he mentioned committing suicide before we reached the front.
Zuklor was sent to the ship’s doctor, and dry-docked in Hawaii, considered too unstable to handle work in the pressure cooker of a battleship.
I decided to plunge right into it. “Have you heard any talk about a ghost ship?”
The captain’s smile was faint. “On every trip, someone mentions a ghost ship. You’ll have to learn to live with the lore of the sea, Kenyon.”
I almost defended myself, but held back. I learned long ago that the captain didn’t like to be contradicted—about anything.
“I’ve seen a specific ship mentioned in three letters now, sir,” I said.
The captain raised his head and looked at me. His eyes were bloodshot and lined with fatigue. I wondered if he ever got more than four hours a night.
“If it’s a real ship, someone’s being derelict.” His tone was ominous, and I struggled to maintain my composure. There was no love lost between us, and things had gotten worse since Zuklor.
“I don’t think it’s real, sir. One of the boys said it looked like a pirate ship, with masts and everything. Another wrote home, saying we were being dogged by Blackbeard’s ship.”
At that moment, the cook came out and set a plate before him. Roast pork sandwich complete with gravy. By this point, the men in the regular mess were eating chipped beef with everything. Only the officers got real meat any more.
My stomach growled. The cook looked at me as if I had invaded his kitchen. “You want him to have some?” he asked the captain.
“Won’t hurt,” the captain said, although he sounded a little reluctant. Apparently he had wanted a semi-private meal. In fact, until that moment, I hadn’t thought about how often he came in early. He was usually just finishing when the rest of us got our meals.
The cook disappeared.
“You ever sailed these waters before, Kenyon?” he asked me.
“No, sir.”
He grunted and sliced his sandwich. He had no qualms about eating before me. “There’s always talk of something here. Doesn’t surprise me that the men are seeing a ghost ship. There are just parts of the sea that have haunted places, echoes, whatever you want to call them. You get used to them.”
“Briscoe also mentioned it in his letter home,” I said. “He thinks the crew is going crazy.”
The captain smiled faintly. “I’ll have someone check on it,” he said in a tone that told me he wouldn’t.
“Sir, I felt strongly enough to come to you—”
“And I appreciate that, sailor. I told you I would take care of it.” He ate a slice of pork, and then looked at me, as if measuring me. “You got anything else?”
“No, sir,” I said.
He slid his fork in the gravy, sighed, and glanced around the mess. So far, we were the only people in it. “I gotta tell you, Kenyon, you’re here on suffrage. The Navy insists in a war that we have a man like you, and I follow orders. But your job is to make sure that nothing leaks in those letters to the folks back home. Not to report every little problem to me.”
“Sir, according to my training, I am supposed to report oddities to you.”
“Oddities.” He leaned forward. “I think men have a right to privacy, Lieutenant. The fact that you violate it every day as part of your job is something I have to live with. But mostly, I don’t want to hear about it. The men need a place to let off steam, and they do it in their letters home. That’s better than doing it on each other, or making this ship hell.”
The cook stood in the door, my roast pork sandwich steaming in his hand. The captain beckoned him forward. The cook scurried over, set my sandwich down, and vanished again—as if he wanted to stay as far from this conversation as he could.
My stomach growled. The food smelled heavenly. Hard to believe a man could work up an appetite reading other people’s letters.
“Yes, sir,” I said, picking up my fork.
“But you don’t agree.” He must have caught something in my tone. I didn’t agree. And now he had opened the door.
“No, sir. Forgive me, sir, but if it weren’t for me doing my job, Ensign Zuklor might be dead now.”
“Half these boys might be dead in another month. Hell, in another week, if the Japs mined areas we don’t know about.” The captain sounded unconcerned, but the lines around his eyes deepened. He was letting me hear one of his constant worries.
“But Zuklor was unstable.”
“You say.” The captain sopped up the rest of the gravy with the last of his bread. “I wonder how many other men just don’t write down their fears. Maybe we punished Zuklor for being honest, for confiding in someone who would listen. Maybe he let off steam and he would have been a good sailor after that. Have you thought of that, Kenyon?”
Actually, I hadn’t.
“What’s private should stay private,” the captain said.
“And if Zuklor had killed himself while we were on the seas, unable to dock anywhere? What would that have done then? You just said sailors are superstitious. Would that have made this a doomed ship?”
The captain stared at me for a moment. His blue eyes were hard and cold, and I thought I saw hatred in them. “People live and die on ships. Some of us spend our whole lives on them happily, and hope for a burial at sea.”
His intensity disturbed me. I made myself eat some more of the sandwich. The pork was heavily salted and a bit old.
“So Zuklor’s suicide wouldn’t have caused a problem?”
“If he would have committed suicide,” the captain said. “I think it was just talk.”
“Yet you sent him to the ship’s doctor.”
“Who asked him if he wrote the letters, and made his recommendation based on that.” The captain put his hands against the table and shoved his chair back. “This is a tense ship. Has been ever since we left Pearl.”
“And you blame me.”
The captain stood. “Don’t you?”
I hadn’t until that moment. “Sir, it’s part of my training to report anything suspicious to you.”
“Suspicious,” he said. “I don’t think sightings of ghost ships, and a man’s personal doubts are suspicious. Unless you got evidence of murder or collaboration with the enemy, I don’t want to hear about it. Do you understand?”
It was my turn to stare. The training had been so clear—so blunt. The letters were a window into the ship, into the morale, and the ideals (or lack thereof) of the crew. Yes, I was supposed to guard against information leaving the ship, but I was also supposed to use the information I gathered for the good of the ship, and now the captain did not want to do that.
“Do you understand, Lieutenant?”
“I guess so, sir.”
“No guessing, Kenyon. You’re on my ship. Whatever those moles who trained you told you is their business. But here, you do as I say. If you have problems with that, I’ll let you off at the next base, and my recommendations won’t be charitable. Is that clear?”
“Yes, sir.”
“From now on, your lunchtime in this mess is 1300 hours. If I see you here one moment sooner, you will be written up. Good day, Kenyon.”
He was gone before I could answer him, slamming the door of the mess behind him. I made myself eat some more lunch. My hand shook as it brought the food to my mouth. I had been warned, when I entered intelligence, that we were hated among the old guard. I guess I hadn’t realized how much until that moment.
No one joined me for the last half of my meal. No one even came in the mess. It was as if they all knew I would be there, and they all decided to avoid me.
I went back to my cubby, and continued to read in silence.
From Steig’s letter to his wife: Remember how we used to compare dreams, Irene? I had the strangest last night. A big old pirate ship, flying the skull and crossbones, stopped our ship, and demanded we pay tribute. I was on watch. I said, We’re the United States. We don’t pay tribute to no one. And the pirate, a grizzled guy like you see in the movies only dirtier, said, I don’t mean honor, stupid. We need a toll or you can’t get through.
Well, I says. I’m not authorized to make that decision. You gotta see the captain. Get him, the pirate said. But I woke up before I did.
From McNamee’s letter to his best friend: So I go looking for the captain, and of course, he’s nowhere. I come back to the bow and I shout: We’re a battleship. We don’t carry money. But we could blast you outta the water. And the men on the pirate ship laugh…
From Porter’s letter to his mother: For three nights, I search for the captain. I finally find him, and he says he’ll take care of it. I hear him using the bullhorn, saying that because the schooner’s not real, they can’t collect tribute.
Strangest thing was, Ma, the next day, I saw the captain and when his gaze met mine, it felt like he knew, like we had the same dream. That ain’t possible, is it, Ma? You ever hear of anything like that in this day and age?
The letters were full of odd things: dreams, ghost ships, bright lights to sea. And fog. We seemed plagued by fog.
I was beginning to wonder if the letters were revenge for Zuklor. Someone, some wag from below, thought maybe they’d see if I’d break. Maybe the captain put them up to it so that I’d make the early report, and I’d then be stuck with this knowledge, that the entire crew was having an experience that I wasn’t, an experience that just wasn’t possible.
I thought of challenging him again, but that would only upset him farther. And I couldn’t, under my orders, discuss the letters with anyone but another intelligence officer or my captain. I decided to save the bunch until I had someone to consult.
But that didn’t stop me from being curious. I had a fairly lively imagination. It was one of the reasons I got this job in the first place; I could imagine all sorts of gloom and doom scenarios from a single sentence. I knew, intellectually, that this had to be a trick, but emotionally, I found myself wishing that the ghost ship existed.
I found evidence that it did in the most unlikely places. Men who didn’t normally speak to each other were writing about similar dreams, similar experiences. I wanted to believe that they wouldn’t talk to each other, that they wouldn’t hate me so very much that they would combine their efforts. Yet I knew that was probably what was happening.
I had been warned during my training that my job would make me a pariah. I had thought I was a loner, thought I wouldn’t mind. But I did mind.
I just hated to admit it to myself.
For the next two nights, I couldn’t sleep. Finally, at 0100 hours on the second night, I got off my tiny little mattress, wiped the sweat from my face, slipped on my uniform, and went onto the deck.
The cold air woke me up further, but managed to clear the cobwebs from my mind. A fog had rolled in, as it had every night for the last week. A thin fog, almost like a ground fog—the kind you’d see over marshes and rivers on fall nights back home. But this wasn’t fall, and we weren’t anywhere near ground.
Young Ashburton was on watch. He saw me, saluted, and then turned away, as if I weren’t worth his time. Odd. If the war hadn’t happened, I would have thought him not worth mine. We came from such different backgrounds—him from the slums of Columbus, Ohio, me from one of the wealthier families in Connecticut. It was his letters that made me realize that he was a guy I could like. He was surprisingly articulate and well-read, with a great deal more ambition than I would ever have. He loved his high school sweetheart with a passion foreign to me, and it seemed, from my lofty, lonely perch, that Ashburton had learned more about living in his eighteen years than I had in my twenty-five.
So it cut when he turned away—and he probably didn’t even know it. There was no way he could know as much about me as I did about him. No way at all.
The deck was slick with fog-soaked damp. I walked to the railing and stared down at the froth we were churning up. The moon was nearly full, sending its bright light onto the strange fog hovering over the water’s surface. Usually fog trapped sound, but on this night, the sound seemed to dissipate. Instead of hearing the constant thrum of the engines, I could only feel it through the bottoms of my regulation shoes.
The water itself seemed unusually silent. Usually the splash caused by our movement was a constant, reassuring sound. I couldn’t hear it either—at least not regularly. It was as if I could see and feel the world, but not hear it, almost as if I were in a dream.
Then Ashburton whimpered, like a dog startled out of a good night’s sleep. I turned, but couldn’t see him. My heart was pounding. My head told me that this was part of the trick—alarm Kenyon when he came on deck—but I had to check it out. I’d be derelict if I didn’t.
I walked toward Ashburton’s perch. He was huddled there, staring forward, and I knew he didn’t see me at all. He wasn’t even thinking of me. He was staring at the ocean as if he had never seen it before.
I stared too, but I would be lying if I said I saw the ship. What I saw was white, like the fog, and it vaguely resembled a ship, the way that clouds sometimes resemble recognizable shapes. The air had gained even more of a chill, and I wrapped my arms around myself for warmth.
Part of me wanted to run belowdecks, but the rest of me was curious. I walked forward, wondering if my eyes were deceiving me, wondering if I saw what I wanted to see. My footsteps echoed on the deck. As I got closer, Ashburton whirled, startled. His wide eyes met mine and then he flushed, as if I had caught him doing something illegal.
“Everything all right?” I asked in my calmest voice.
He nodded, a short, rabbitty movement that belied his answer.
“See anything?”
“No,” he said, but somehow couldn’t resist a look over his shoulder at the sea. The fog was still there, rising above the waves like a live thing. If I squinted, I thought I could see three masts and a hull, all white and opaque.
“Is that a ship?” I pointed at the masts.
“N-No,” Ashburton said. “It’s the fog.”
I nodded, squinted, and couldn’t really tell if he was right or not. It looked like fog. It looked like a ship. It looked like anything I wanted it to.
I was getting very cold. I shivered, and water droplets fell from my hair onto my face. They felt like ice.
Ashburton was covered with water drops too. The fog had risen to the deck level and the wetness in the air was making us damp.
“Ever seen anything like that?” I asked.
“Fog is fog,” Ashburton said.
I remained unconvinced. I stood there for a moment longer, hoping to see the Blackbeard of the letters, but I saw nothing. Even the so-called ship seemed to lose its form. I shivered once, then went below, got out of my wet things, and slipped back into bed.
But I didn’t sleep.
Exhaustion can do strange things to a man. It makes him desperate if there’s no underlying cause. Insomnia had never plagued me before, but it plagued me now. Two more nights passed without any real sleep. I did not go back to the deck. I didn’t want to see that fog, or the specter of a ship that really wasn’t there. Instead I spent the frustrating nights tossing and turning in my bunk, trying to get other people’s words out of my mind. Trying to think on anything but the mystery of the ship.
Finally, I took an afternoon and paced the deck, getting as much exercise as I could so that sleep would be inevitable. I asked cook to give me some warm milk before bedtime, and he obliged, adding a dab of honey and lemon—a concoction my dead mother used to make when I was ill.
Either the milk or the exercise did the trick. I fell into my bed, and was asleep long before I had a chance to toss or turn. I didn’t even dream. The cycle of worry, or whatever it was, had ended.
The next day, I felt refreshed. Ashburton’s refusal to meet my gaze when we saw each other at 1200 didn’t bother me, nor did the three more letters I read that discussed the ghost ship. Rumors were flying on our own ship that we would see action soon, although I thought them the talk of a restless crew. Attention seemed to be turning elsewhere.
I went to bed that night with no thought of walking the deck in the fog or of hot milk and insomnia. Instead, I closed my eyes, and fell into a sound sleep like I had done most of my life.
Only this time, I dreamed.
Fog slid under the door like a wraith, curling and rolling forward, its whiteness so bright that it illuminated the room. The fog beckoned me outward, like a lure. I got up, then walked forward, opening my door to see what had gone wrong.
Fog poured down the steps and into the narrow corridor. Ground fog, thin and rippling, the fog of my youth, the fog of bogs and swamps and rivers. The fog of land, not the fog of the sea.
I missed land. I hadn’t admitted that to myself until then.
I followed the fog up the stairs and to the deck. The deck was empty, the engines silent for the first time since we’d left port. Fog enshrouded everything, making it look as if we were encased in ice.
Directly in our wake, however, was a pirate ship. It had three masts and a wooden hull. It looked old and well-used. It didn’t have a Jolly Roger, though. It had no flag at all. I had no idea how I knew it belonged to the pirates. I simply knew that it did.
“So,” a voice said behind me.
I whirled. A man, dark and grizzled, stood behind me, his feet lost in the fog. He wore three layers of clothing, most of it tattered, and in his left hand he held a pistol. Not a modern pistol, but a muzzleloader with a long barrel and a flint.
“Your people are refusing tribute.” His eyes were black and they glittered in the strange light. “They do not believe we’re a threat.”
“You’re not a threat,” I said. “You’re a dream.”
His smile was thin. “Perhaps. But if we’re not, every life on this ship is forfeit.”
I glanced at his ship, with its cannons on the side, ragged men staring at me across the expanse of fog-covered sea. “If you’re real, you have no hope against us. We could sink your ship in a matter of minutes.”
He laughed, then nodded. “That’s the first sensible remark I’ve heard.”
“If you were real pirates,” I said, emboldened, “you wouldn’t give us so many chances.”
He raised his chin slightly, as if I had challenged him The water, from the humidity in the air, was beading on me, but not on him.
“If you are real,” I said, “and you can somehow invade our dreams, you don’t need to talk to us to plunder our ship.”
“We no longer seek gold,” he said. “We have no use for it.”
“Then what do you want?”
“Tribute.”
“Recognition? Is that why you visit our dreams?”
“No.” He suddenly seemed impatient with me. “We charge a price to anyone who sails these waters. If you do not pay us tribute, you and your ship and your crewmates will not survive the year.”
“And if we do pay?”
“You’re protected from harm. Forever.”
My gaze met his. “How can any man guarantee such a thing?”
“A man does not,” he said. “But we both know I am no longer a man.”
I woke up in my bed, with no recollection of walking back down the stairs. One moment I was on the deck, the next I was in bed.
I sat up. The dream had been very real, frighteningly real. If that was what the men had seen, then no wonder they were writing of it in their letters home. It had startled me too.
I shivered. The room had a chill. I rubbed my hands on my arms and realized that my sleeves were wet. I touched my hair. It was wet too.
I opened the door to my cabin. There was no fog in the hallway, and the engines thrummed as they always did.
It had been a dream, I thought. It had been a dream. It could have been nothing else.
From Redgen’s letter to his best friend: He said he was doomed to sail the seas for a thousand years, haunting the places where he had sunk other ships, stolen men, hidden treasure. Penance, he said, was hard, because he and he alone had that sentence, and he could not handle his ship without help. He was a strange man. It didn’t sound like a curse, at least not to him. Sounded like he wasn’t willing to give up the sea, like death wasn’t going to stop him. He wanted me to believe he could give us a gift in return, but pirates don’t give gifts. Not even dead ones.
From Glassman’s letter to a colleague: So I’m wondering if my subconscious hasn’t made him up. Part Blackbeard—who never sailed in this area—and part Barbary pirate, part legend and part myth. I’m thinking perhaps that he’s a lord of the sea. All sea-faring cultures had stories about creatures that wanted something valuable in exchange for a magical gift. Would you look him up for me? I think these long days at sea are bringing back memories of stories I studied years ago, and I would like to know which one is haunting me now….
From Minter’s letter to his sister: I offered to help him, but I couldn’t do nothing. I didn’t know what he wanted. Kinda strange, now that I’m awake. I wonder if I was doing the right thing. But the men are so scared. The captain don’t know that, how scared we all are, and if we could get through without a scratch, a miracle ship surviving years of war, then that’d be worth some raggedy dream pirate tribute, don’t you think?
Don’t you think?
I stared at the words before I inked them out. Before I inked out the entire section. Men are always so superstitious. Worried about the past, worried about the future. Worried about figures that appear to us in dreams.
Mass dreams. Mass hysteria. An image we were all seeing. Was it the suggestibility brought on by such close quarters? A half-remembered story started in the crew’s mess? Or was it as simple as discomfort brought on by the fog?
I sighed and opened another page of Minter’s letter, in which he discussed more mundane things, like the quality of the food, and a Christmas memory that seemed incomplete.
I found my mind wandering, playing over the words I’d read. What if everyone had approached the old pirate wrong? They all seemed willing to believe he was real. But what if he was just a dream—or, more accurately, a nightmare? And what if the only way to exorcise him from the mind was to give him what he wanted?
I set down Minter’s letter and stared at the pile of letters, waiting to go out. I knew the crew’s secret thoughts; they didn’t know mine. If I told them what I was thinking, I’d have to speak the idea aloud. They got to write the ideas down, to trusted people, beloved people. These men would never have spoken about these things to each other—at least, not if they didn’t know each other well.
And while I knew them all well, they didn’t know me at all.
That night the fog seeped into my dreams, perhaps because I was expecting it, because my mind was ready for it. Because I had been thinking about it all day, and planning for it. I let myself sink into the dream and its logic quicker than I had before.
The fog on the deck was white and waist-deep. The air was moist, as it had been before, and so cold that I thought I’d never get warm. I carried my blanket with me this time, and wrapped it around me as if I were an old woman.
He didn’t have his pistol. Instead, he stood, legs parted and disappearing into the sea of white. The fog looked almost solid, as if it were ice, and I could walk across it to the pirate ship beyond.
I glanced at the ship. Other letters had mentioned the skull and crossbones flag, but I didn’t see it. The ship looked like one I had seen in Boston harbor when I was a boy; small and snug and somehow safe, despite the power of the sea.
“Beautiful, ain’t she?” he asked. His voice was growly, with a bit of a British accent. I didn’t remember it from before. Was it there because I expected it?
“I’ve never seen anything like her.”
“Nor will you again.” He clasped his hands behind his back. “So, are you ready to pay tribute?”
“If I do, no harm comes to us. Any of us?” I was thinking that even in the dream world, this was a bargain.
“No harm comes to any man on this vessel.”
I stared at him a moment. I was thinking that even in the dream world, this was a bargain. There’d be no more nightmares, no more ghost ship, no more watchmen whimpering in the fog.
“What do you want?” I asked
His smile was feral and my heart started pounding hard. I wondered if it would wake me up.
“I need a crewman, a man with salt in his veins and the sea in his heart.”
“Not larceny?” I asked.
He laughed. “That too.”
“Why? Shouldn’t your men travel with you for eternity?”
“That’s my sentence, not theirs. They live their natural life, and then they retire. And when they do, I need a replacement.”
“Pirates retire?”
His smile again, wolfish, a bit too bright. “They’re not pirates. They’re just my crew.”
“You feed them? Clothe them?”
“Laddie, you’ve eyes. They live in a place where they don’t want for anything.”
I stared at the ship, simple in its old-fashioned beauty. It looked like a palace made out of fog. “One man?”
“One man, with no wife to pine for him, no family to miss him, no friends to see him off.” His eyes narrowed. “Know a man like that?”
My mind scanned through a thousand letters. Every letter I’d ever read, every face I’d ever seen. A man who lived for the sea. A man who had nothing to go home to.
A man who wanted a burial at sea.
“Just our captain,” I said.
The pirate raised his eyebrows. I clearly hadn’t said what he expected. “You’d leave this ship in the hands of the First Officer?”
“He must be competent or he wouldn’t hold the position.”
“That’s one way of looking at it,” the pirate said. “Are you sure?”
“As sure as I can be.”
He nodded, then reached out a grimy hand. After a moment I took it. We shook, and I wondered what kind of honor this cursed thief thought he had.
“Tribute’s paid,” he said, and vanished.
I woke in my bed, cold, the sheets so wet I worried that I had a fever. I was shaking and shivering and wondering how dreams could be so very real.
I fell into a restless sleep, broken before 0600 by the sound of booted feet, running past my door. More feet on the deck above, and then voices, low and panicked. In my fogged state I wondered if the pirates had boarded after all, if they had taken the ship, and then someone pounded on my door, startling me.
The first officer stood, there, back straight. Only his flushed cheeks showed that something was wrong. He came in without waiting for my permission, and closed the door behind him.
“Have you seen the captain in the last six hours?” he asked.
“No.” I rubbed my eyes, trying to force myself into full wakefulness. “Is something wrong?”
“Did he put anything in his letters, something that might have—” his voice broke.
“Might have?”
“Shown his mental state?”
“I’m not permitted to discuss letters with anyone but an intelligence officer or the captain.”
“Or the captain’s representative,” the first officer said.
I stood slowly, my mouth dry. The sheets fell away, but landed in a clouded heap. They were still clammy, and my boots shone with a wetness they hadn’t had when I first went to bed.
“What’s happened?”
“He’s not on the ship.”
“But that’s impossible.”
“He’s gone. It appears he was dragged from his bed.” The first officer ran a hand over his face. “Some of the crew are reporting dreams of pirates pulling him off the ship, screaming.”
“To cover up their own actions?”
“You think this was a rebellion?”
“Do you?”
We stared at each other. And then, almost at the same time, looked away. He cleared his throat.
“Letters?” he asked again.
“Nothing,” I said. “He never wrote to anyone. He had no one to write to.”
The first officer looked at me, nodded, and left the cabin without another comment.
I sank back down onto the bed. No one could have known about my choice—my dream choice. I had been in my cabin all night. Alone.
I put my head in my hands and wondered what sort of creature I had bargained with the night before. Then I looked at my hand, the one I had used to shake his.
It was covered with dirt.
After we searched exhaustively for the captain, we were ordered to return to Hawaii. Another ship met us within a day, and its crew became our guards. The U.S. Navy believed we had mutinied and murdered our captain, but they never did find enough evidence to charge us.
We were all given stateside assignments, far from each other, in places where we could not influence the war effort, where we could serve out our terms without distinguishing ourselves in any way.
Safe from harm.
I bounced from post to post, reviewing the mail—only this time it had already been inked, so the reading was less interesting—with no one to talk to and nothing to do with my time except think.
And it wasn’t until the last year of the war, that I finally understood the expression on the old pirate’s face. He had been surprised because he had chosen me for his crew. I had no wife to pine for me, no family to miss me, no friends to see me off. The old pirate hadn’t known my job, hadn’t realized that I would know everything about everyone on the ship.
He had simply figured that I would volunteer.
And I hadn’t.
I had volunteered another man’s life, a man who hadn’t liked me, a man I hadn’t liked.
Perhaps I hadn’t been so altruistic after all. Perhaps my imagination and my powerful mind had formed a denial so great that I hadn’t been able to see my own actions, my own selfishness.
We had come to no harm. In fact, nearly sixty years later, we’re still alive. All of us, every member of that crew. Everyone who had been on the ship that morning when I woke up.
After the captain vanished.
We’re all healthy, vigorous, never been sick a day since we turned back.
Was sentencing one man to a living hell worth all that?
Sometimes I like to think so.
Sometimes I like to think I did no harm.
Guess my denial’s as strong as ever. And my lack of will just as bad. I can’t go back to that long stretch of nowhere on the Pacific. I tell myself I don’t know where it was.
And I wish I could believe the lie.
Tribute
Copyright © 2024 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
“Tribute” by Kristine Kathryn Rusch was first published in
Oceans of Magic, edited by Brian M. Thomsen and Martin H. Greenberg. Daw Books February 2001
Published by WMG Publishing
Cover and layout copyright © 2016 by WMG Publishing
Cover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG Publishing
Cover art copyright © Eti Swinford/Dreamstime
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
The picture above is of my cat Angel, who, when she challenges us to play, sometimes looks vaguely nuts. That’s how I’m feeling right now. It’s been a heck of a few months, and I realized on Sunday that I simply did not have the focus to spend long sessions writing and thinking about story.
I know how to fix that. Spend time writing and thinking about story.
But I’ve had some other challenges these past (seven) months, and trained myself to focus outward. Now I need to retrain and focus inward. I would like some help doing so.
In late December and January, two challenges made me concentrate on something that used to be as natural as breathing—putting writing first. February was easy. March…um…and April…OMG! April…
Now I’m ready to focus again, and it would be grand if I had an outside reason to negate the other outside reasons to do other things.
Hence the challenge.
I’m going to repost Dean’s blog on this from a few nights ago, when I suggested it to him. The challenge starts tomorrow, but you have until Friday to sign up…if you want to join me. (I hope you do!)
Spring Restart Writing Challenge with KrisThe challenge is to write as many consumable words from Wednesday, May 1st through Friday, May 31st 2024 as Kris writes. The goal is to get writing and focused on the writing for the month of May no matter what has happened in the previous months of the year.
The challenge is on WMGTeachable.
What are “consumable” words?
— Any fiction of any type (no requirement to publish during the challenge time)
— Any nonfiction that others will consume such as blogs, introductions to collections things like that.
You can NOT count emails and comments on Facebook and other social media or comments on blogs. They do NOT count.
No genre limitations.
Rules
1… Every day Kris will send a letter through the class email system to just those in the challenge talking about the words she wrote the previous day and her experience. There will be a running count on the class of Kris’s total words every few days. At times Dean will do a video updating everyone as well, but it is the daily letters from Kris that are the best parts.
She will not talk about the content of what she is writing. And neither should you.
2… The cost is $300. You must sign up by Friday, May 3rd.
(No credit from anything, I am afraid. Can’t buy in with credit to get more credit. But the half-price sale is going on right now.)
3… If you do NOT write as many words as she does in the two weeks, you get $300 credit toward any online teaching, such as Pop-Up series or lectures or classics or lifetime workshops.
So in essence, you are buying at least $300 credit and getting the chance to watch Kris and see how you stack up against her writing output.
4… If you beat Kris’s word count at the end of the month, you get $600 in credit for anything on Teachable to be used at any point for anything in the future (except other challenges.)
Again, Kris will report each day about her previous day’s writing through the email program in the Teachable class, but only to those in the challenge.
5… On June 1st you will report to Dean your word count in May to get your credit.
Kris is excited to do this. She had a bumpy last few months and really needs the focus to get back on her writing.
This is a win/win/win challenge. Jump in, should be fun and get your writing fired up for the spring! And you get an up-close look at how Kris writes on a daily basis, including how she deals with scheduled events like the Licensing Expo later in May.
Lifetime Everything Subscribers, if you would like to jump into the challenge to follow along, write Dean and he will send you a code.
Homicide Detective Ned Zaleski resents the chief’s decision to enlist Sherlock Holmes’ help in Zaleski’s latest murder investigation. Zaleski fails to see how Holmes, newly transported to the 1990s from his own time by the Santa Cruz Time Wizards, can shed any light on a modern-day serial killer. But Zaleski soon learns Holmes’ earned his reputation for insight honestly. And that insight might lead Zaleski down a path he cannot bear to go.
First published in Sherlock Holmes in Orbit, an anthology authorized by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s estate, “Second Fiddle” offers an intricate series of unexpected twists and surprising turns that only Kristine Kathryn Rusch can deliver.
“Second Fiddle,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here. It’s also available in ebook, trade paperback, and hardcover in Crimes Collide, Vol. 1, here.
Second FiddleKristine Kathryn RuschWEDNESDAY, 5:36 A.M.
HOLMES LOOKED OUT OF PLACE as he crouched on the pavement, staring at the streak of blood. I had already put Vicks on my nose and lit a cigarette. The stench on the side of the road had nearly gagged me—a ten-year veteran of homicide and fifteen on the force. The area smelled as if someone had run over a herd of deer three days ago, then left them in the sun. Holmes had merely wrapped a scarf around his face before examining the blood streak as if it contained the secret of the ages.
I had already followed that blood streak. It led down an embankment to a mutilated female body lying in the drainage ditch against the chain wire fence. The killer had been daring this time, dumping the body next to one of the busiest interstates in the area, only yards away from Cabot Hill, Santa Lucia’s newest—and ugliest—housing development.
But the location didn’t seem to catch Holmes’s attention, and neither did the rusted-out 1970 Oldsmobile abandoned on the roadside, with blood on its fender. A member of the forensics unit was scraping off the blood into a plastic bag. The photographer was straddling the drainage ditch, snapping pictures of the body. Three men from the unit were scouring the car, and two other detectives were scanning the roadside looking for other clues.
I was standing beside the squad car listening as Rae Ann, the only woman on the team, hunched over the radio, requesting a few more hours at the crime scene. It would play hell with the morning commute, but Holmes had requested it. And since the department had paid over a quarter of the budget to get the only privately run time travel company to bring the Great Detective to Santa Lucia, it had to honor his requests.
I had been watching him since they brought him into the force twenty-four hours ago. He was thin, of average height, with a hawk nose. I had expected a taller man, and perhaps by Victorian standards he had been. His suitcoat was a bit more tailored than I had expected, but he did wear a deerstalker cap, and he carried a curved pipe which he put away when he discovered that a person who owned something made of elephant ivory was subject to verbal abuse in California.
I had protested Holmes’s arrival, but the chief insisted. Our small department had had a running rivalry with the FBI for years, and since there was no actual proof that the murderer was kidnapping his victims and running them across state borders, the chief was doing all he could to prevent FBI involvement. Holmes was merely the ace-in-the-hole, a last-ditch effort to prove to the feds that the homeboys could solve one of their own.
From the moment Holmes arrived, he listened a lot, asked few questions, and asked for information on the era, on California, and on Santa Lucia in particular. I had snorted when they told me that. He may have been the greatest detective that ever lived—although I would wager greater detectives had existed in relative anonymity—but his information was one hundred years out of date. How could a man who had made his reputation by observing the small details discover a twist none of us—good detectives all—had failed to see?
And believe me, we had looked. I had had four hours of sleep a night since the task force was formed a month ago. That’s when we realized that Santa Lucia was as much a victim as the mutilated bodies we found. The killer was preying on the rich and famous—two young movie stars, a former child television star, a Princeton football player who was this year’s number one draft choice, and the wife of one of the state’s most famous senators—a well known sculptor in her own right. Each of his victims was famous enough to make the evening news across the country, and all of the bodies had been found here, in Santa Lucia, even though most of them had disappeared—alive—from somewhere else.
Holmes followed the bloodstain to the crusted grass on the embankment before putting a hand over his nose. Then I nodded. He seemed to have a diminished sense of smell, probably from snuff, or his pipe smoking.
“What the hell you think you’re doing, Ned? You too good to scour the crime scene?”
I glanced over my shoulder. Birmar was standing there, his tiny eyes running and his round face pale and greenish. He was a different kind of detective than I was. Holmes had been his idol as a boy and Birmar had been the brains behind calling the Santa Cruz Time Wizards for help in this case.
“I’m working,” I said in a tone that brooked no disagreement.
“Looks like you’re watching Holmes,” Birmar said, but he walked away, his overcoat clinging to his frame like wet sandpaper.
I had been watching Holmes, but I had already surveyed the crime scene. I had been the first member of the team to arrive. My house was a block away. That galled me. I was the spokesman on this case. If the killer was following the press coverage, he knew about me. And even though my address and phone number were unlisted, it wouldn’t take a lot of effort for a guy this smart to figure out where I lived.
“Officer Zaleski.” Holmes was looking up the embankment at me. “Would you join me for a moment, please?”
I sighed, leaned over, and stamped out the cigarette in the squad’s ashtray. Then I approached the embankment, careful to avoid the blood streak. A low irritation was building in my stomach. Whenever this guy wanted a consult, he chose me, not Birmar. And I had better things to do than babysit someone who was wasting more of the department’s money than the chief was.
“Do we know whom this unfortunate woman is yet?” he asked. Even with the Vicks and the cigarette, the smell was nauseating. A body, decaying normally, shouldn’t smell that strong. “No,” I said. “Well,” he said. “This one may be exactly what we have been looking for. She does not have much in common with the others.” I looked down, reluctantly, holding up all my training as a shield. The body was not a person; it was the king in a chess game, the reason for the fight and no more. But the killer had left her face intact, and the look of horror in her wide blue eyes would haunt me if I let it.
I made myself examine her for the clues Holmes was talking about. Her teeth were uneven and discolored—certainly not the product of million-dollar attention. The remains of the dress she wore showed a store-bought label. Holmes reached down and held out a piece of fabric to me. The cuff of a sleeve. One button was missing. The other had been sewn on rather ineptly.
“Jesus,” I said. “Copycat.”
Holmes leaned on his haunches and peered up at me from beneath the brim of his cap. “Copycat?” He clearly didn’t understand.
I pulled myself out of the embankment. “We got two of these nuts on the loose. One of them is killing for weird personal reasons and the other is reading the press coverage and imitating.”
Holmes clambered up beside me, remarkably at ease with his body although he looked as if he never exercised. “Nonsense,” he said. “Such a thing is preposterous. The odds of having two killers with the same—”
“It happens all the time,” I said. I walked to the squad. Rae Ann’s cheeks were flushed. She was fighting with dispatch. “They’re already rerouting because of a multicar pileup on 1-5,” she said.
“Let me talk to them.”
“There is no need.” Holmes was standing behind me. “As long as your photographers are finished, we may return to the station. You and I must discuss the way these copycats work.”
WEDNESDAY, 11:53 A.M.
THE LAST THING I wanted to do was sit at my desk and talk basic criminal theory with a man who had died three decades before I was born. But he absolutely refused to work with Birmar (“I am afraid, my dear sir, that the man does not understand nuance.”), and the chief told me my job was on the line if I ignored Holmes. Wonderful. It seemed that the Great Detective needed a foil, and he had chosen me as this century’s Watson.
The chief was using his office to brief a new team that would handle a double murder reported to the Gato Apartments. No privacy anywhere. So I took Holmes to my favorite dive, a bar just off Fifth that had been passed over by ferns, gold piping, and neon lights. The place hadn’t seen daylight since 1955, and the windows were painted shut. The interior smelled of cigarette smoke layered so deep that the walls were half an inch thicker. The floor was littered with popcorn and sticky with spilled beer. Someone had to be bribing the city health authorities because logically the place should have been closed in its first year.
To my surprise, Holmes said nothing as we walked in. He followed me to a booth and slid in as if we were both regulars. I ordered a light beer and he ordered an iced tea “heavy on the sugar and cream,” then smiled at me. “I have grown quite fond of that in the last few days,” he said.
I was in no mood for idle conversation. “So you want me to explain copycats.”
He shook his head, a slight smile on his narrow lips. “I think I grasp the concept. However, I thought I should let you know that I believe you are wrong.”
I felt a heated flush rise in my cheeks. The man knew how to get to me. I had been decorated three times by the State of California for my work, recognized as one of the best detectives in the nation by The New York Times, and had been portrayed in a TV movie based on one of my cases.
“Look,” I said. “I’ve investigated more homicides than I care to think about, and I’ve been on teams that have captured six different serial killers. Someone who doesn’t follow the pattern is inevitably a copycat.”
“But the pattern was followed,” Holmes said. “All the way up to and including the directions of the knife wounds, as well as the advanced odor of decay. Some of the flesh was not hers, and beneath her were the bits and pieces of another corpse. An animal, as in the other instances. In the past the killer has used this technique so that a hidden body will be discovered, and has done so this time. I do not believe you have put these details in the press, have you?”
The cocktail waitress set down my beer, sloshing some of the foam onto the scarred wooden table. Then she put down a glass of iced tea for Holmes, followed by a pitcher of milk and a bowl of sugar. With a sarcastic flourish, she produced a spoon and handed it to him, scooped my five dollar bill off the table, and left.
“No,” I said reluctantly. “We haven’t.”
“In addition, there was a small print from an—athletic shoe—and it had come from the opposite direction away from the car. I think you will find that the killer splashed the blood on the bumper as a way to lead us astray. The blood streak was a similar ploy, for it is too even and straight to have been caused by a body dragged to the edge of the embankment. The killer walked through the embankment in the pre-dawn hours, walked from one of the side streets, carrying the body with him. Since the incline from the road is so steep, I would doubt that anyone saw him.”
I took a sip of the beer. My hand was shaking. I had noticed those things, but had not put them together. Holmes was right. I guess some details didn’t change over the span of centuries.
“I believe,” Holmes said, “that if we discover who this woman is, we will have found our killer.”
WEDNESDAY, 2:33 P.M.
WE SENT THE VICTIM’S FINGERPRINTS and photograph to crime labs nationwide. We gave her picture to the press, who published it nationwide, then we hired a temp to monitor the phone calls.
Holmes was amazed by some things: the amount of data we had at our fingertips; the way that information could travel across country in a matter of seconds. Of course, he expressed that amazement with calm, letting us know that such changes were logical extensions of the era in which he had lived. He also told me privately that he believed such intellectual ease had made us lazy.
Birmar thought the remark funny. I didn’t. Holmes wasn’t making any points with me at all.
By this point in the investigation, we had eight different psychological profiles on the killer. The profiles assumed the killer was male and strong (which seemed obvious, given the football player), deficient in social skills and with a deep-seated hatred of famous people. Holmes disagreed with all of the experts on all of the points but two. He conceded that the killer had a hatred of the famous, and that the killer was strong.
We had returned from the bar after a lunch of burgers, heavy on the grease. I had had the one beer and Holmes had downed four cups of tea, making him jittery. When we returned, we were summoned to the chief’s office, along with Birmar, for an analysis of the case.
The office smelled of reconstituted air and old gym socks. The chief kept his workout clothes in his filing cabinet—“that way no one will snoop,” he would say slyly—and never opened his windows. His desk was littered with papers, and a computer hummed continually on the edge of a nearby table. The chief sat in an overstuffed chair behind the desk. Holmes and Birmar had taken the only remaining seats. I leaned against the closed door, arms crossed in front of my chest.
The chief had gone over the newest psychological profile—which said nothing different from the others—and then asked for our opinions.
“I would disagree with your experts,” Holmes said. “It would seem to me that our killer is quite socially adept. After all, he managed to get close to people who are continually surrounded by others—and in the case of the—stars—are heavily guarded. No, this is a person who has enough resources to be able to travel great distances quickly and unseen, a person with the ability to get close to the unapproachable, and a person with ties to Santa Lucia.”
The chief and Birmar were watching Holmes as if he were god. I was beginning to resent the sound of that resonant accented voice. I had already figured out the Santa Lucia part—that seemed obvious—and I had told the chief about my theory that the killer had a job that attached him to the famous. I had missed Holmes’s third point, and I shouldn’t have. Maybe Holmes was right: maybe my access to technology was making me intellectually lazy.
“It’s got to be a private plane,” I said. “He brought three of the victims in from the East Coast in less than two days.”
“I’ll call the airport,” Birmar said.
The chief shook his head. “Our killer would be too smart to land in Santa Lucia. We need to check the airports that handle small planes. Get some help on this, Birmar. Get the logs from all the airports within a day’s drive from here.”
Birmar blanched. “Sir, I don’t believe he would drive all the way here from, say, Utah.”
“One must never let one’s own preconceptions interfere with an investigation,” Holmes said.
I stared at him. He looked perfectly at ease, sitting in a plastic chair, his feet outstretched, the chief’s computer humming from the table beside him. No wonder Holmes was not ruffled by being leaped into the future. When he was involved in an investigation, he checked his expectations of the world at the door.
Holmes looked at me. “What type of job would a man need to get close to the famous?”
I shrugged. “Journalists get passes. Police, security guards, hairdressers, drivers, caterers—there’s a whole list of support personnel that could get inside any citadel as long as they know how to open the door.”
“Yes,” Holmes said, steepling his fingers, “but that door must be the same for each of these unfortunates.”
“We already have a team investigating the links between our victims.”
Holmes smiled. “We will find nothing yet. Until we know the name of our final victim, our killer has us at a disadvantage.”
I deliberately uncrossed my arms, and let them drop to my side. “What makes you say that?”
“We have all assumed the killer is male,” Holmes said. “It wasn’t until this very moment that I realized we are looking for a woman.”
WEDNESDAY, 3:15 P.M.
I WAS VERY GLAD that Rae Ann wasn’t in the office with us—or any of the other women in the department for that matter—since Holmes spent the next half hour explaining that the “fair sex” can be quite brilliant. He relayed his experiences with one Irene Adler and, while he implied that she was an exception to most females, he assumed that each century must produce at least one similar mind. Only this mind, the one we were seeking, was diabolically fiendish.
The thing which convinced him that our killer was a woman was the shoeprint. Holmes claimed he had been turning the pattern over and over in his mind while we talked. Forensics had confirmed that the shoe was a bargain brand, bought at a discount shoe store, and that it was a male size four. Holmes said he had watched footwear for the next day and noted that many of the female officers preferred men’s tennis shoes to women’s. No men wore a size four, but a number of the women did.
“That’s not proof!” the chief snapped. “That’s supposition. Besides, serial killers are always men.”
Holmes sighed. “I understand that you have a lot of data on these killers. But there is nothing to prevent a woman from using these techniques for her own gain. There are several other things that point to a female hand. The victims were clothed, not naked, as seems to be common in these cases. And, while she seems to have done a lot of lifting— which I believe possible for the women I have seen since I have come here—the method of murder, the knife attack, relies more on surprise and a victim’s abhorrence of knives than any need to physically overpower someone. The knife, by the way, is an angry weapon, often chosen by people who have kept a great deal of fury buried inside for a long time. A woman’s weapon, if you will, since women are trained not to express their feelings.” Then Holmes smiled. “That much, at least, has not changed between our time periods.”
Holmes leaned back in his chair and pressed his steepled fingers against his lips. He spoke softly, as if he were speaking to himself. “In fact, I would suppose that a number of the unsolved serial killings you have in this nation are unsolved simply because you are unwilling to admit that the fair sex is as capable of atrocity as we are.”
At that comment, I turned my back on the discussion and left the office. Holmes’s contempt for our methods sent an anger through me that was counterproductive. He had worked on a handful of cases in Victorian London, a city with a population half that of Santa Lucia, Santa Cruz, and San Jose combined. Murder was a parlor game then, and the only serial killer, the infamous Jack the Ripper, had never been caught. If I had remained in the room, I would have said all of those things.
Instead, I went to my desk, took deep breaths, and thought. The precinct was nearly empty, with most of the department working on various cases, and another group handling the Gato Apartment murders. In the background, a phone rang incessantly. Behind bubble glass at reception, a uniformed officer argued with a woman about wasting the department’s time searching for a lost cat. One of the dispatchers, a slender woman with black hair, wandered out of the radio room, and poured herself a cup of coffee.
I wished there was more noise. I thought better when I had to screen out distractions.
I hated to acknowledge that Holmes had a clarity of vision which I lacked. That our killer was a woman made sense. It would explain the two anomalies to our statistical analysis: the football player and the senator’s wife. A young man in his early twenties could be lured anywhere by an attractive woman—and not feel threatened by her. The senator’s wife with feminist leanings simply needed her sense of sisterhood invoked.
That made our search easier. We weren’t looking for hairdressers or caterers or even journalists, which had been my initial bet. We were looking for someone who fit more into the profile of a person who owned a private plane. Someone who would have contact with all of these people and yet remain anonymous. A driver. For short promotion tours, a lot of studios and publicists relied on a handful of people who were screened to drive the famous about. Most preferred women because women were perceived as nonthreatening. A driver with a private plane could be on call in several communities, under several aliases.
I went over to the departmental computer, mounted and chained onto a desk in the middle of the room (someday maybe the department would spring for individual computers for all of us—a more cost-effective solution than hiring the Santa Clara Time Wizards) and pulled up the victim files. They didn’t go into the kind of depth I wanted, so I went into the newspaper logs instead, looking for any recent mention (before the murders, of course) of the victims’ names.
The door to the chief’s office opened and closed. I heard footsteps behind me and knew who they belonged to. I wasn’t surprised when Holmes pulled up a chair and sat next to me. He watched as article after article scrolled by on the screen.
“Are you finding anything?” he asked.
I nodded. The football player had been to three different cities so that he could meet the owners of the team that had picked him and get wined and dined separately by each. Both movie stars had been on promotional tours for films they had just completed, and the senator’s wife had been accompanying her husband on a junket around his home state.
“Finding the driver who handled all of these shouldn’t be hard,” I said. “The companies should have résumés on file complete with photographs. But it is not illegal for someone to use an alias—as long as they’re using the correct social security number.” I grinned at Holmes’s look of confusion. I wished I could see that look more often. “But,” I said, “even if we show the link, we still don’t have enough to hold up in court.”
Holmes leaned back in his chair. “I do not understand the fear with which you all seem to view your legal process,” he said. He had heard enough about it—I had heard the chief warn Holmes twice not to mess with evidence or interfere with forensic procedure—but I thought he had been ignoring the warnings until now. “But I do agree that we need more information. A case is not closed until we understand the motivation for our killer’s actions.”
I had had enough. Too little sleep, too much coffee, and too many lectures. My patience snapped. “First of all, this is not ‘our’ killer. Secondly, I have worked on cases in which the killer’s only motive is a hatred of the color yellow. Thirdly, real life is not a murder mystery. Here, in the 1990s, we rarely tie up all the loose ends.”
“Loose ends,” Holmes said softly, “are a luxury a stable society cannot afford to have.”
Rae Ann’s arrival saved me from replying to that. She held out a fax, the cheap paper curling into a small roll. “We found her,” Rae Ann said. “Our latest victim. Kimberly Marie Caldicott. A housewife from Bakersfield, California.”
“Bakersfield?” I said. I frowned. Bakersfield. Holmes had to be wrong. A housewife didn’t fit into this scenario.
“Does she have any ties to Santa Lucia?” Holmes asked.
Rae Ann nodded. “Born and raised here. Graduated from Santa Lucia High in 1970. Homecoming queen, valedictorian, and voted most likely to succeed. Teenagers aren’t good at predicting that sort of thing though. Who’d’ve thought she’d’ve ended up a divorced secretary, mother of two?”
“She doesn’t fit the profile, Holmes,” I said. “I think we really have to entertain the idea of a copycat and look for information leaks in the department.”
Holmes shook his head. “You are overlooking the obvious, my friend. Before we assume two killers with the same strategy, we must investigate this as a related death. My dear—” he looked at Rae Ann—“answer a question for me. I assume the items you mentioned in reference to Kimberly were honors.”
Rae Ann nodded. “That’s the top of the heap in high school.”
Holmes smiled. “Then we need to find out who got stepped on in Kimberly’s rise to the top. We need to find the young lady who came in second.”
FRIDAY, 4:10 P.M.
THE SANTA LUCIA HIGH SCHOOL ANNUAL had only one picture of the salutatorian from 1970: her official graduation photo. Lorena Haas was a pie-faced girl with coke-bottle glasses and a mid-sixties bouf-do, the kind of bookish intellectual girl who sat quietly in the back of a room and remained unnoticed even after twelve years with the same classmates. A few of them remembered her, and used words like quiet, shy, and moody. Only one classmate kept in touch, and she claimed Lorena lived back east, and drove a taxi for a living.
“Lorena may have hated Kimberly,” the classmate said, “but there’s no way she woulda killed her.” Holmes had smiled at that. “Jealousy,” he had said to me, “is, perhaps, the most destructive of human emotions.”
Whatever the motive, the evidence against Lorena Haas was mounting. Within a day of looking at the annual, we had found Haas’s pilot’s license, matched her voice prints to airline logs, and through that tracked her various aliases. We even had enough evidence to tie her to each victim— she had chauffeured all of them in company limousines.
The discovery put the remains of the investigation in the FBI’s purview, although the Santa Lucia Police Department Special Homicide Unit would always receive credit for solving the case. The FBI found Lorena in a D.C. suburb, living under the alias Kim Meree. They brought her to San Francisco on Friday morning, for an interview, before they officially charged her with the crime.
Holmes insisted upon seeing her. The chief had had to negotiate for that. Finally, Holmes’s fame had prevailed. Holmes was going to be able to speak with Haas alone.
Holmes insisted that I accompany him. I was tired of being his Watson. Ever since Holmes arrived, I had played second fiddle. I really didn’t care why Lorena Haas had murdered a bunch of celebrities and her high school rival. I had already been assigned to a murder/suicide that had been called in this morning—easily solved, of course—but the kind of case that generated a pile of paperwork. I was still protesting as we climbed the steps of the FBI building in San Francisco, where they were holding her for questioning.
“We’ve got enough to make a case, Holmes,” I said. “There’s no reason to talk to this nut.”
I had been making the same argument all day. Holmes had brushed it off before, but this time he stopped at the top of the stairs and looked down at me. On this afternoon, he appeared taller, and I suddenly realized what a striking presence he really made—in any century.
“My dear sir,” he said, “one must always discover if one’s suppositions are correct.”
“And if they aren’t?” I asked.
Holmes looked at me gravely for a moment. “Then we solved the case by luck and happenstance, not by intellect.”
I sighed to myself. “She’s not going to confess anything, Holmes. She’s too smart for that.”
“I don’t need a confession,” Holmes said. “Merely a confirmation.”
He pulled open the door and went in. I followed him. I would be so glad when he was gone. That patronizing tone, as if he and he alone saw the details of the universe, grated on me so badly that I tensed each time he opened his mouth.
The inside of the building had a dry metallic dustless scent. Our footsteps echoed on the tile floor, and the people we saw—all wearing suits—did not meet our gaze as we passed. We passed door after door after door, all closed as if hiding secrets we could never be privy to.
When we reached the designated room, Holmes took the lead, and had the agent show us directly to the interrogation area. Before we went in, we were instructed that our entire conversation would be taped.
A guard stood outside the interrogation room. The guard nodded at us as we went in, as if memorizing our faces. The room itself was white, except for the one-way glass on the back wall. Even the table and chairs were white. Lorena Haas stood in front of the glass, peering at it, as if by doing so she could see the people hidden behind. She turned as the door closed behind us.
Although I had seen recent photos, I was unprepared for her physical presence. She had come far from her coke-bottle glasses days. Contact lenses had made her eyes a vivid blue. She had shoulder-length blonde hair, high cheekbones, and a small upturned nose. She moved with a litheness of an athlete. She could easily have carried those bodies. If I hadn’t known, I would have matched the 1970 Kimberly Caldicott graduation photo with the 1990s version of Lorena Haas.
“I’m not talking to anyone without a lawyer,” Haas said. She had the flat nonaccent most Californians specialized in. She leaned against her chair instead of sitting in it, and she kept gazing at Holmes as if he were familiar.
“I merely wanted to meet you,” Holmes said, and stuck out his hand. “I am Sherlock Holmes. I am sure you read about my involvement in the case.”
She didn’t take the offered hand. “Oh, yeah,” she said. “The world’s greatest detective. I suppose I should be honored. Well, I’m not. People like you, they make their way by focusing on the inadequacies of others.”
Then her gaze met mine. Those intense blue eyes sent a shudder through me that I couldn’t hide.
“You must be Ned Zaleski. The newspapers mentioned you, too. You were the one who led the investigation until Mr. Holmes came and took it all away from you.” Her words had an accuracy that hurt. I had never mentioned my displacement to Holmes as a problem, but I had resented it. More than I ever expressed.
She smiled, slowly, as if we shared a secret, and I remembered that morning, so long ago it seemed, when Holmes took his first action on the case. The last body had been discovered near my home. And until that point, I had been the focus of the investigation, the cop made famous by Lorena’s work.
She knew. She saw. And worse, she understood. Jealousy, Holmes had said, is, perhaps, the most destructive of human emotions.
Lorena Haas had allowed jealousy to destroy her. Who would know what remark one of her famous passengers made that set her violent emotion free. But once freed, it led her back to Santa Lucia, to her home, the place where coming in second had destroyed her life. It didn’t matter that Kimberly Marie Caldicott had not succeeded. What mattered was that in high school, Kimberly Marie had become a symbol of everything Lorena could not have.
A symbol she killed over and over again with the weapon of anger. A knife. Holmes had been right again. Without asking her a single question, he had managed to confirm both her guilt and her motivation.
He was right, and I despised him for it.
Lorena’s smile grew and I had to look away.
Holmes half-bowed to her, ever the English gentleman. “I thank you for your time,” he said, and knocked on the door. A guard let us out of the room.
I said nothing to Holmes as we walked back to the car. My skin was crawling and I was deeply thankful that he was scheduled to leave with the Santa Cruz Time Wizards the following morning.
When he returned to his home, he would not remember me. But, like Lorena with Kimberly, I would always remember him.
FRIDAY, 6:05 P.M.
IT SHOULD HAVE ENDED THERE, but it didn’t. As I dropped him off at the chief’s house for a celebratory dinner that I was not planning to attend, a voice pierced through the static on my police radio, announcing a body had washed ashore from the Santa Lucia River. The body was that of a young girl, missing for two days, and she had obviously been strangled.
As the dispatch fed the information, I imagined the scene: the bloated, black-faced body, tongue protruding, the neck a mass of welts and bruises washed clean of evidence by the river herself. A homicide unrelated to any other that would probably go down in the books as unsolved.
Holmes was watching me. “Loose ends happen,” he said, “only when we permit them to exist.” My mouth worked, but I said nothing. Who had appointed him my teacher, anyway? I was just as good as he was.
He took his pipe out of his pocket and then pulled out a pouch of tobacco. “What Miss Haas failed to realize,” he said, “is that such jealousies prevent us from seeing ourselves clearly. She already had the perfect revenge: a good income, several jobs that put her in touch with something your society values. She had an interesting life, but instead, she constantly compared herself to an imaginary figure from the past.”
My jaw was clenched. After this evening, I would never see the man again. Yelling at him would do me no good.
He filled his pipe, and put it in his mouth, then shoved the tobacco in his pocket. Then he reached out a hand. I shook it, more out of a desire to get rid of him than courtesy.
“I am quite sorry,” he said, “that I will not be able to take my memories of you back to Baker Street. You have one of the keenest minds I have ever encountered.”
Then he let himself out of the car, and walked up the sidewalk to the chief’s house. The face of Lorena Haas rose in my mind. History would never record what the young Kimberly Marie Caldicott had thought of her. Perhaps Kimberly looked at her with respect and admiration, or perhaps she had noted, once too often, a talent that went unused.
I could follow Lorena’s path, and make Holmes a hated icon on which I could blame all my inadequacies. Or I could move forward.
I glanced out the car window. Holmes stood on the steps, his pipe in his mouth, his cap pulled low over his forehead. I nodded once to him. He nodded back.
Then I wheeled the car onto the road, picking up my mike and reciting my badge number. I would go to the river, with no preconceptions, and forget about technology. I would look for details, and I would open myself to nuance.
I never wanted to see Holmes again, and there was only one way I could make sure that happened.
I had to stop relying on suppositions, experts, and computers. I had to sharpen my own mind, and think for myself.
Second Fiddle
Copyright © 2024 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
“Second Fiddle” by Kristine Kathryn Rusch was first published in
Sherlock Holmes in Orbit, authorized by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s estate,
edited by Mike Resnick and Martin H. Greenberg, DAW, 1995.
Published by WMG Publishing
Cover and Layout copyright © 2024 by WMG Publishing
Cover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG Publishing
Cover art copyright © Squidmediaro/Dreamstime
This book is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. All rights reserved. This is a work of fiction. All characters and events portrayed in this book are fictional, and any resemblance to real people or incidents is purely coincidental. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form without permission.
Backers of the Barkson’s Journey Kickstarter! Thank you! You have made the beginning of Barkson’s publishing journey a special one.
I appreciate it!
For everyone else, you can preorder the book at your favorite stores…or at the new Fey store, which goes live later today.
Again, backers! Thank you so much!
About 28 hours remain on the Kickstarter for Barkson’s Journey. The book is a brand-new Fey novel in the Qavnerian Protectorate side series. I really think you’ll love this book. I had so much fun writing it, and Barkson—well, she surprised even me.
We’ve hit four stretch goals…
Which means that for as little as $5, you’ll get:
All of this will disappear tomorrow (Wednesday) at 7 pm, so act quickly!
For two centuries, Injustice Collecting allowed for balance in a system populated by many sentient species. Everyone understood the system and its necessity. Until the humans arrived. They want justice for what happened to their children. But the humans don’t understand the proceedings. And misunderstandings might prove the catalyst to the greatest threat the system will ever face.
“The Injustice Collector,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here. It’s also available in ebook, trade paperback, and hardcover in Colliding Worlds, Vol. 2, here.
The Injustice CollectorKristine Kathryn RuschRecord of Proceeding
Incident at Gray’s BrookInjustice Collector 0080 Presiding
Testimony of Requesting Party
They trusted us with their children.
Later, they claimed they trusted us because we resembled animals from their world. Canines. I have seen representations of such things, and the resemblance is superficial.
We are thinner, taller, and we do not stand on all fours. (Many of my people were insulted by this implication—that we could not walk upright—but I was more insulted by the look of the beasts: shaggy, unkempt, and that appendage at the base of the spine—the tail—looked vaguely ominous to me, as if the creatures were slapped together by a careless scientist.)
It is true that we do not have bald skin as the humans do; ours is dusted attractively with fine hairs, making each of us distinctive. Our noses are larger and our mouths open beneath them—perhaps the most canine of our features—but we, as a people, have come to resent the word “snout.”
As for the rest, we do not see ourselves as too different from the humans. We use our arms in much the same way, we have hands, we wear clothing. It is true that we do not wear shoes, but the bottoms of our feet are tough and hair-covered. We do not injure as easily as the humans do.
Which, I suppose, is the heart of the problem.
They came half a season ago. Their ships were shiny and silver, made of materials we had not seen before. Their leaders offered to teach us how to create such materials, but the lessons never happened—one of many such incidences. Among my tribe, the humans have become known as the People of Broken Promises.
The humans created a settlement on the ice plain, not realizing, of course, that we were in summer, and the plain was at its best. Trees flowered, insects buzzed, and a thousand varieties of summer vegetation grew across the expanse. The air, thick with humidity, was nearly unbearable to us; to them, it spoke of comfort—the “tropics,” “paradise,” and other words that we did not then know.
We did know that soon the fall would come with its rains, destroying all but the hardiest of plants. Those would die in the cold, buried beneath the sheet of ice that gave the plain its name.
We doubted the humans would survive the fall, let alone the cold. We did not tell them of the cycle, believing that such warning would reward ignorance.
That is why we did not contact the Injustice Collector at the theft of land.
We believed justice had taken care of itself.
Interruption in the Proceeding
Two Cycles into the Requesting Party’s Testimony, A Breach of Protocol:
Breach of Protocol by the creatures known as human require in-depth reporting methods not employed in two centuries of Injustice Collecting. The humans, it seems, are unfamiliar with the concept of Justice/Injustice. They believe such decisions might be rendered on the small scale, and as a result, have appealed to me in unorthodox ways, which under rules 7765 and 11,235, I am obligated to report.
As a result, my presence will intrude on the record of these proceedings. I beg the Review Board’s indulgence.
—Injustice Collector 0080
Explanatory Note:
This meeting is taking place, as is customary in cases of cultural disputes, in the Great Hall of the Collecting Ship. Four members of the Requesting Party, both male and female, stand to the left. Twenty members of the Non-Requesting Party stand to the right.
Both sides have been instructed in the rules of the proceedings, although for the two days of rules’ instructions, only two of the humans attended.
Since the number of humans has grown significantly, I can only assume the added 18 were not briefed by their colleagues.
[An Aside: Working conditions are barely tolerable. The Great Hall barely accommodates all of these bodies. As is mentioned in the opening testimony, these human creatures are as large as the MugwL. The crowd presses against my Decision Desk. The temperature in the Great Hall has risen significantly. The Collecting Ship’s systems are not designed to accommodate so many heat-giving sources in such a small area.
[To complicate matters, both the MugwL and the humans have distinctive—and competing—odors. The MugwL’s fur stinks of rone spice—a sharp peppery scent that invades the nostrils—and the humans, beneath the coating odor of soap, give off a musk that burns the eyes. When I inquired, I was told that such an odor is called a “nervous sweat” and it cannot be controlled. Human suggestions to control the temperature were ignored as untenable. My suggestion that some of the human party leave was met with severe protests. However, if the stench worsens, I will be forced to cut the human presence in half.]
The Non-Requesting Party is inattentive and disrespectful. They speak without tone—in something called a “whisper”—and believe they cannot be heard.
They have obviously not met an Injustice Collector before. They seem to believe that because I am small and do not have features they can readily identify, I am somehow less than they are.
Already, I can see why the MugwL find them so intolerable.
The Breach of Protocol began when the MugwL Representative stated, “That is why we did not contact the Injustice Collector at the theft of land.”
The “whispering” rose to an intolerable level, and one human, not one of the original two (I believe, since it is hard to tell—the bald skin is, as the MugwL implied, offensive), cried out,
“We didn’t steal! We asked permission to settle there!”
The MugwL Representative continued over the disturbance, adding his phrase, “We believed justice had taken care of itself.”
At which another of the humans, one of the tallest, turned toward the MugwL so quickly that I feared violence.
“You fucking bastard,” the human said—and judging by its tone, the words “fucking bastard” are an insult. “First you kill our children, now you tell us it’s our fault! Judge, this is all wrong. You gotta hear our case—”
I clapped two of my hands for silence, and to my surprise, the human complied. Perhaps it was the spray of red light that flew from my fingertips. That seems to impress the lesser species.
As I clapped with two hands, I used the other three to set the collection bag beneath the Decision Desk. It became clear to me in that moment that the humans do not understand the proceedings.
I do not sit in Judgment, therefore I am not a Judge. I merely listen to the reports and determine to whom the Injustice has occurred. Then I collect it.
Or rather, the bag does. Most of my efforts go toward corralling the bag.
I try to explain this to the humans again (more confirmation that the initial human representatives did not report back to their colleagues), but the humans did not seem to understand.
More “whispering” occurred, and a common sentence wound its way through the Non-Requesting Party: It’s obvious that we have suffered the injustice. Our children are dead.
If matters of Justice/Injustice were so easily determined, there would be no need for the Decision Desk. Again, I explain, but the humans seem confused.
They seem to believe that the decision is a judgment which I would therefore make. They do not seem to understand the distinctions required by the customs of the Alliance.
I call for a recess, insist that both Parties leave the Ship, and order scrubbers into the Great Hall to attempt to alleviate the stench.
Then I transmit my request for assistance to the Board of Governors.
I tell them I am concerned that I might commit an Injustice myself.
Excerpts from the 500-page Gubernatorial Response to Inquiry Presented by Injustice Collector 0080 in regard to Non-Requesting Party Involved in the Incident at Gray’s Brook
[Requesting Party Reference: MugwL Case 3345678221]:
The self-named Humans are an unknown, unstudied species. A careful search of the records reveals that they have never been a Requesting, Non-Requesting, Peripherally Involved, or Bystanding Party in any Justice/Injustice proceeding…
Cases involving unknown, unstudied species must proceed as if the species is sentient, according to Justice/Injustice standards…
…and so, to satisfy your request, we had to return to the earliest records of Justice/Injustice proceedings, in which species now known to us [but which were, at the time of the proceedings, unknown] established Justice/Injustice Precedent…
…what the early Injustice Collectors learned was that the bags did not accept as an Injustice cases presided over by an Injustice Collector in which a Party of Unknown Sentience did not understand the intricacies of the proceeding…
Therefore, certification continues in the Incident at Gray’s Brook, also known as Requesting Party Reference: MugwL Case 3345678221.
Record of Proceeding
Incident at Gray’s BrookInjustice Collector 0080 Presiding
Testimony of Requesting Party
[continued]
Human children are curious creatures. They share some traits with the adults of the species, but no one would intuitively understand that such a small creature, less than a meter in length at first appearance, would eventually become the towering figures now standing to my left.
In fact, we had no idea at the time of the incident that the creatures called “children” were also a type of “human.” We believed them to be a related Earth species, rather like the Canine we had referred to in our previous remarks.
It is counter-intuitive to believe these creatures would grow at such an astounding rate. It is also counter-intuitive to believe that a group traveling the great distances that the humans traveled would bring the young of the species, carrying with it the very future of the species itself.
We therefore request that the surviving children join this proceeding as the Bystanding Party—
Interruption in the Proceeding
Eight Cycles into the Requesting Party’s Testimony, A Breach of Protocol:
This protocol breach [and, I am certain, all others] are caused by the factors listed in the Second Cycle breach described above. I see no reason to repeat that finding here. In future breaches, I shall simply describe the breach, and continue with the Report of the Proceeding.
If any member of the Review Board has an objection, I refer him to the Board of Governors’ Response to the Official Inquiry on the Humans [attached above].
—Injustice Collector 0080
“Your Honor,” said the human who, before this morning’s proceedings, introduced himself [they assure me that this creature is a male] as the one in charge. At my request, he wears a large red badge which lists his designation: John Graf. I do not know what these words stand for; I know only that I am to use them whenever I refer to the human with the red badge. “You can’t let them do this.”
The “them” in that sentence refers to the Requesting Party. The “this” refers to the introduction of the “children” as the Bystanding Party.
I cite regulations, as I have done for days now. The “humans” apparently have a short attention span. We discussed the rights of the Requesting Party in regards to the Bystanding Party on the first day of the explanatory proceedings.
“No, sir,” the John Graf human said, “I’m afraid you don’t understand. By our laws and customs, the only people who speak for our children are their parents.”
I do not know this word “parents” and I tell the John Graf so.
His bald skin turns an alarming shade of red, nearly the color of his badge, and I am concerned that my words have harmed him physically. The “whispering” begins again, and I beg for silence.
Then I tell the John Graf that he may recess for medical treatment if he so desires.
His tiny features press together, as if he is trying to make them into a MugwL face. “I’m in perfect health, Your Honor.”
He sounds—and I am merely guessing—offended. I look down at the bag which I have stored under the Decision Desk to see if it detects an Injustice that I may have inadvertently caused, but it hasn’t even twitched.
“I just find it appalling that you don’t know what parents are,” the John Graf says. His voice has risen to an intolerable level. “I’m opposed to a legal proceeding when our cultures are so different that we have to explain something as basic as parenthood.”
I hold up my middle hand. “We are discussing ‘parents,’ not ‘parenthood.’ Please do not confuse the issue.”
He makes a blatting sound, like the wind through a malfunctioning weezer engine.
“I am not confusing any issue,” he says. “You people are. We can’t continue with this charade any longer.”
Another concept I do not know. But I do not ask him to explain it, since I am beginning to agree with the MugwL’s characterization of the humans as People of Broken Promises. I ask the John Graf to explain “parents” and instead, he confuses the issue by adding two more unknown words into the proceedings.
No explanation of “parents” appears to be forthcoming.
“We’re leaving,” the John Graf says.
The nineteen other humans nod in agreement. They all turn toward the Great Hall doors, but I do not open them.
“You cannot leave when the Proceedings are underway,” I tell them. “The doors will only open in case of Recess or Final Determination.”
[An Aside: I wish for nothing more than the opening of doors and the disappearance of the humans. The stench seems worse this day. My eyes have been burning since the presentation began.]
“We refuse to participate any longer,” the John Graf says. “This is a joke!”
Joke. Another new word. I choose not to focus on it, but on the preceding sentence.
“You cannot refuse to participate,” I remind him. “The time for that is past. You had from the moment the Request for a Justice/Injustice review was made to the Board of Governors to the moment the Collecting Ship arrived to demand a cancellation. You did not make such a demand. So the proceeding must continue.”
“Another stupid law no one bothered to tell us about,” the John Graf says, waving his arm downward, as if he is compacting a pile of snow.
“We should’ve just killed the fuckers,” one of the other humans says, rather loudly. This is not a “whisper.” I believe it was meant to be heard. “Blasted them all to hell and back for what they did to the kids.”
Murmurs of agreement thread through the human crowd. The MugwLs look at me as if they expect me to stop it.
They should know better. If the humans take action, I can only observe. If the MugwLs or their survivors then believe that the human action was wrong, they can make yet another request for an Injustice Collector. I will become a Peripherally Involved Party, and will not sit on the Decision Desk.
[An Aside: I confess that such a change would please me. I find this case taxing, and would like as much as the humans for it to end.]
“It could’ve been an accident,” says the John Graf. “It’s pretty clear we don’t understand these aliens any more than they understand us. I’m not going to be in charge of a genocide, even when—”
“Even when they kill our kids?” the other human asks.
The John Graf expels air, and shakes his head from side to side. He is clearly in charge, but the others do not agree with him. I fear trouble of a type I am not equipped to deal with.
I glance down. The bag has turned a light lavender. It is getting greedy. I slam its top closed with two of my hands, using the other two to twist the top into a knot. The bag fades, but I worry that this is just an act.
The John Graf is leaning close to his compatriots. “We’ve been here for fifty years,” he says, as if this is important.
It sounds strange to me. The MugwL claimed in his opening testimony that the humans had only been here half a season, and I see no evidence to the contrary.
But the other humans do not disagree with that characterization. In fact, many of them nod which, as their representatives informed me on the first day, is a sign of assent.
“This is our home. Our children were born here,” the John Graf is saying.
I am leaning toward the conversation, even though I hear it more clearly than the “whispering.” The MugwL watch me as if they expect me to do something about this exchange.
At least the MugwL are smart enough to know that I will not interfere.
“Leaving is not an option,” the John Graf says. “We must peacefully co-exist.”
“Even if they kill our kids,” the vocal human states. Although the words sound like a question, they are not.
“That’s what we’re here to determine,” the John Graf says. “Whether it was intentional or not. Right?”
At this last, he turns to me. He seems to be expecting a Judgment again, but I do not give it to him.
Instead, I do as I have done before. I recite the law and the history. “The MugwL have requested our presence because they believe an injustice may have occurred.”
“Hell, yes, an injustice occurred,” says the vocal human. “They murdered our children. That’s an injustice.”
“But you did not request the proceeding,” I say. “They did.”
The vocal human starts to answer, but the John Graf steps in front of it. [Him? The genders are difficult to determine. I shall cease trying until I am told with certainty which of the six known genders I am dealing with.]
“Because of us,” the John Graf says. He looks over his shoulder at the MugwL.
The two of them stand, hands together, heads bowed, as is proper procedure. Emotion does not cross their faces. Only the slight change in their peppery odor tells me that they are reacting to this at all.
“We went to them,” the John Graf is saying to me, “right after the deaths. My people wanted an arrest, some kind of charges, sanctions—a few, like Victor here, wanted to take matters into their own hands. But we want to peacefully co-exist. So I want to handle this by the book. I go to MegrP, their leader, and I say just that, we need to handle this properly so that we stay allies. He listens, then asks if I think an injustice has occurred. And I say hell, yes. Our kids are dead. He nods, and says he will contact you.”
I let him speak, even though the history of the request is not relevant. That too was explained in the first two days, and apparently not conveyed to all of the humans.
“Nonetheless,” I say when it becomes clear that the John Graf is done speaking. “They are the Requesting Party, and it is by their aegis that I am here.”
“So?” the John Graf asks.
“So you must let the proceeding continue.”
“What, so they can tell you their side of the story without us saying ours? How fair is that?” His voice has risen to nearly intolerable levels. “It’s our kids that’re dead, us that’ve suffered here, and it sounds like we’ll suffer some more when Fall—however you people define your seasons—eventually shows up and washes our homes away. That’s Injustice, Mr. Collector. We haven’t done anything wrong.”
“This is not a Judgment,” I say yet again. “This is a Justice/Injustice proceeding.”
“Yeah,” the John Graf says, “and I thought that meant a finding of fact. You know, the truth will out and all that. Some impartial person would investigate, maybe even go to the crime scene, interview some MugwLs and the surviving kids and find out what happened. But if I understand your rules right, you’re just going to let this guy talk—and he wasn’t even there. Then you’ll make some kind of judgment, and we’re done. That’s not Justice, Mr. Collector. That’s just plain wrong.”
The bag is a darker shade of purple. I use my middle arm to check the knot. The knot is tight. The bag will not get loose.
“This Proceeding was Requested,” I say. “It must continue. When it is finished, you may seek this ‘investigation’ and ‘judgment,’ perhaps from your own people. This Proceeding is what it is, and I cannot make it anything else.”
[An Aside: although, in some ways, the Proceeding has become something else. It resembles the Proceedings of the early Alliance rather than modern Proceedings, partly because of these protocol breaches.]
“We have spent more than Eight Cycles here,” I say. “If we continue at the pace, we will be here until Fall. The Requesting Party must complete his testimony. If there are no further objections, I shall send my staff for the Bystanding Party, and we shall—”
“But there are objections,” the John Graf says. “The very objection that started me. Children can’t be here without their parents’ permission. And no parent is going to allow a child to take place in this farce.”
Again with the unexplained words. I chose to ignore them.
“What your people want now does not matter,” I say. “All that matters now is the Proceeding itself. These ‘children’ are, at the request of the Requesting Party, the Bystanding Party, and by our regulations, required to be here. You cannot change centuries of law simply because you do not agree to it.”
“What’ll happen to the children?” the John Graf asks.
I am at the end of my patience. “We discussed Bystanding Parties on the first day. Consult with your representatives. We shall indulge you no longer.”
The John Graf clenches his hands into fists and does not step away from the Decision Desk. The vocal human moves its head from side to side.
“Told you we should’ve blasted them,” it “whispers.” Its gaze is on mine as it speaks, and I know the comment is somehow directed toward me.
“Proceed,” I say to the MugwL representative, and he does, with obvious relief.
Record of Proceeding
Incident at Gray’s BrookInjustice Collector 0080 Presiding
Testimony of Requesting Party
[continued]
As I said more than Eight Cycles ago now, the humans trusted us with their children. This was not a trust we asked for or even understood. We had no desire to interact with the humans, but their intrusiveness forced us into relations.
They asked questions; they tried our food (and complained when it made them ill); they even came into the village during Privacy Cycles, demanding attention. All of that, we accommodated. We listened, we spoke, we spent time with them at their request.
We did not ask them questions, knowing that our lack of interest would show them they were not wanted. Yet they seemed to ignore that message.
Part of the problem, we assumed, was that they always sent new representation. The early Elders vanished, replaced by other Elders, and now we are being introduced to yet a new set of Elders. Even though the shiny silver ships the humans arrived in seemed small, they carried a multitude of beings, so many that we often found ourselves confused.
We did not even note the presence of “children” until late in the days of the first set of Elders. Then the Elders brought small creatures to us, and showed us the “children” proudly. We believed they had been sent in another mission, that the humans, in their folly, thought they could add their native creatures to our environment.
We did not know that these creatures were the young or that they were somehow created without waterbaths and the freezings of six winters. We did not know that the young could be created off the world the humans call Earth.
Interruption in the Proceeding
Nine Cycles into the Requesting Party’s Testimony, The Arrival of the Bystanding Party.
This interruption is one I had requested when I insisted the Requesting Party continue with its Testimony without all Requested members present. The “children”—some thirty of them of various sizes and shapes—have been brought in by two Collectors-in-Training and five robotic helpers.
Like the other humans, the “children” do not seem to understand the proceedings. Since explanation did not work with the older humans, I do not believe it will work with the younger, and chose not to take the two days to reiterate the rules and regulations.
If any member of the Review Board has an objection, I refer him to the Board of Governors’ Response to the Official Inquiry on the Humans [attached above].
—Injustice Collector 0080
In the midst of the arrival of the Bystanding Party, the humans committed yet another protocol breach. I note this here, but do not place it into the record as a secondary interruption since this is an interruption of an interruption.
Nonetheless, I report it here:
“I object,” says the John Graf. “These children have no legal rights here. Their parents must be present.”
[An Aside: there are now fifty humans, two MugwL, two Collectors-in-Training, five robotic helpers, and the bag in the Great Hall. Even if I complied with the John Graf’s demands, the additional humans [if, indeed that’s what these “parents” are] would not fit into the room. I do not mention this. I have ceased arguing with the humans.]
“The ‘children’ are the Bystanding Party,” I say. “If the Bystanding Party does not understand its function here, I suggest it choose one representative member, and set the rest free. The representative member will listen to the testimony, will spend time with the Collectors-in-Training to gain an understanding of the rules session which was missed, and will, if need be, relay the Justice/Injustice to the remaining members of the Party.”
“Your Honor,” one of the “children” says. It has a high voice with many overtones, “our parents don’t want us here.”
Again, I ignore this. “We shall recess for One Cycle while the Bystanding Party picks its representative.”
And so we do.
[An Aside: After the Great Hall empties, and the Scrubbers enter, attempting to clean the vile stench from the air, I look down at the bag. It is a faint lavender.
[It senses my attention, and sends me this message: There have been too many protocol breaches all ready. This proceeding will fail its Review. Let me take the Perceived Injustices now in the interest of time, and it will save us all more Cycles of this.
[I note the communication here in an aside, since it is within the bag’s rights to make such a communication. Each case I have administered has included such a communication.
[Only this time, I actually contemplate the bag’s request. This procedure is unusual and will receive great attention from the Review Board. I am tempted to save all of us the trouble and allow the bag this one indulgence.
[Apparently it senses my hesitation and turns a violent purple. The color change and the shimmering hatred that rises from the bag’s porous exterior remind me that, no matter how logical a bag’s argument, the bag is always concerned with its own power. Too many Injustices, even Perceived Ones, might overload the safety protocols, and the bag would be freed.
[There are fifty bags within traveling distance of this sector. One free bag could free the others—that’s how the Attwne System dissolved.
[I reject the bag’s request, but note my hesitation here, in case the Review Board would like to bring me up on charges for even considering it.
[By the time the Representatives return—two MugwL, two human [as I note with relief], and two “children” of the larger variety—the bag is again pale lavender, and I have made certain the knot and the imprisoning devices are fixed securely.]
Record of Proceeding
Incident at Gray’s BrookInjustice Collector 0080 Presiding
Testimony of Requesting Party
[continued]
By the time of the Incident at Gray’s Brook, we had already been to the human settlement six times with the express purpose of seeing the “children.” The “children” gather every other Cycle in a building called the “school.” There they sit while a full-sized human passes knowledge to them via three different means—vocal communication, printed communication, and written communication.
The system seems inefficient to us, and is part of what led us to believe the “children” were another species. We now believe that the human young are not born with the knowledge of the community implanted in the brain. The knowledge must be transferred by these inefficient means.
Since we use these means only with inferior creatures, ones that we hope to domesticate, we place this assumption of ours before the Decision Desk as a simple Misunderstanding, not an Injustice.
Interruption in the Proceeding
Eleven Cycles into the Requesting Party’s Testimony, A Breach of Protocol: Cause of breach is, as noted above, human ignorance.
—Injustice Collector 0080
“I don’t suppose anyone wants to explain that distinction,” says the John Graf. I believe he is referring to the distinction between the “Misunderstanding” and the “Injustice.”
We have explained this, taking days—not cycles—to do so. But I weary of reminding him of that, so say nothing.
After a moment of silence, the John Graf says, “I thought not. Why do I even try?”
Record of Proceeding
Incident at Gray’s BrookInjustice Collector 0080 Presiding
Testimony of Requesting Party
[continued]
Just before the Incident at Gray’s Brook, one of the human Elders came to our Village Council and requested a “field trip” in which their “children” would see how we tend our own young. This “field trip” as best we could understand it was an educational venture designed to exemplify the distinctions between our two species.
It took the humans several visits to explain the need for such an event to us. Even so, we are uncertain as to whether we sufficiently understand it, and believe on this point that the Non-Requesting Party might like a voice.
[An Aside: I offer the opportunity to the John Graf. He raises and lowers his shoulders.
[“This isn’t a proceeding, it’s a joke, and we’re here under protest,” he says by way of explanation.
[The MugwL seem to find this response as unsatisfactory as I do. But that does not stop their testimony. Their representative continues.]
To understand what transpired next, we must explain a distinction that we have learned over this half-season of dealing with the humans. In their language, “day” means “cycle.” Their concept of time is different from ours in significant ways, ways we do not yet completely understand.
We have come to realize that even though we speak the same accepted Alliance tongue, our understandings break down at even this most basic level. Some of our scientists postulate that the humans have a summer’s lifespan, although others believe this to be impossible based on the humans’ ability to learn Alliance languages and travel in space.
This digression stems from our attempt to understand the humans’ extreme reaction to the Incident at Gray’s Brook and our culpability, if any, in it.
Interruption in the Proceeding
Eleven Cycles into the Requesting Party’s Testimony, A Breach of Protocol: Cause of breach is, as noted above, human ignorance.
—Injustice Collector 0080
“Culpability, hell,” says the other human representative quite loudly. “We’ll show them culpability.”
Record of Proceeding
Incident at Gray’s BrookInjustice Collector 0080 Presiding
Testimony of Requesting Party
[continued]
At the time of the incident, our young were in the waterbath. The waters are at their lowest this time in the season, and the fetal pods are clearly visible.
The waters are also quite warm and, in the words of one of the “children,” “inviting” although, it must be noted for the record, the MugwL heard no such invitation.
The “children” asked if it was permissible to touch the pods. We apparently did not understand the nature of their question. We told them that, indeed, it is always permissible to touch the pods.
We did not, however, expand the answer, expecting more questions. Apparently, however, the “children” are unlike the humans in more ways than knowledge and size.
The “children” did ask one other question. They asked if the water was harmful.
The question was, on its surface, unnecessary. If the water was harmful, would we have put our fetal pods into it? Of course not. We answered the question we believed was asked. We answered according to our biology and our customs. We did not realize that the “children” could not frame their questions correctly.
Again, we plead Misunderstanding, not Injustice.
Interruption in the Proceeding
Eleven Cycles into the Requesting Party’s Testimony, A Breach of Protocol: Cause of breach is, as noted above, human ignorance.
—Injustice Collector 0080
“Lying manipulative bastards,” says the other human representative.
The John Graf puts his hand on the other representative’s arm. The other representative moves away.
Record of Proceeding
Incident at Gray’s BrookInjustice Collector 0080 Presiding
Testimony of Requesting Party
[continued]
The devastation was stunning and terrifying. The people who witnessed the deaths are not the same. They cannot go near the human settlement; they are appalled at the very mention of humans. This emotion grew worse when it became clear to all concerned that the “children” are also human young.
[An Aside: for the first time, the MugwL representative is having trouble controlling his voice. It breaks. This is the first obvious sign of emotion from the MugwL and it is quite moving.
[I do not look at the bag, waiting at my feet, below.]
The “children” shed their clothing with a rapidity that startled us. Then they plunged headfirst into the water. A few jumped feet first.
We had never seen anyone but registered tenders step into water, and even then, they followed distinct and important protocols.
These “children” followed no protocols at all. They drenched themselves and arose, laughing—a sound that is the same among both of our species (something we did not know and did not want to learn in this context).
Then the laughter turned to shrill, high pitched sounds that the humans later identified as sounds of extreme fright. The “children” had rested their feet on the pods—a few “children” had gone underwater and touched the pods with their hands—and the pods—the pods—
The pods absorb food through the exterior shell. It supplies the fetal material and maintains the growth necessary for development. Anything that touches the pod becomes food, unless certain protocols are followed.
Even the tenders do not touch the pods without wearing special equipment, equipment that we did not bring on our “field trip” with the “children.”
We managed to save five of the children, but ten of them—ten of them—
We learned, to our dismay, that human blood is red. When combined with water and flailing limbs, bubbles are created, making a pinkish foam.
Many of us still see this foam in our dreams.
Record of Proceeding
Incident at Gray’s BrookInjustice Collector 0080 Presiding
Citing of the Injustice[s]
According to custom, I place the bag on the Decision Desk. The bag maintains its composure above the desk; the bag’s porous outer layer is now a creamy white.
Then I state the interrogatory: What do you believe are the Injustices in this Incident?
The Non-Requesting Party attempts to respond, but is silenced. The Bystanding Party simply shifts from foot-to-foot as if the proceedings do not concern either representative. The Requesting Party look at the bag with great fear before replying:
“The Injustices are, as we see them, as follows: One Injustice occurring against the Requesting Party, and one Injustice occurring against the Bystanding Party.”
Interruption in the Proceeding
Eleven Cycles into the Requesting Party’s Testimony, A Breach of Protocol: Cause of breach is, as noted above, human ignorance.
—Injustice Collector 0080
The John Graf steps forward. “What the—?”
He does not finish his own sentence.
Record of Proceeding
Incident at Gray’s BrookInjustice Collector 0080 Presiding
Citing of the Injustice[s]
[continued]
“The Injustice against the Requesting Party is this: The humans should have explained to us the nature and vulnerability of their young. In this, they should have explained the purpose of “children” and the caring of them. We should not have been responsible for beings we know nothing about.
Interruption in the Proceeding
Eleven Cycles into the Requesting Party’s Testimony, A Breach of Protocol: Cause of breach is, as noted above, human ignorance.
—Injustice Collector 0080
“Right,” the other human representative says, surprising me with his agreement. “Go ahead. Blame the victim.”
Record of Proceeding
Incident at Gray’s BrookInjustice Collector 0080 Presiding
Citing of the Injustice[s]
[continued]
“The Injustice against the Bystanding Party is more severe. It is this: Although these human young, these “children,” are adaptable enough to survive their youth away from their home world, they are not strong enough to face challenges inherent in space exploration. It took less than a season to wipe out ten of these youth. One can only surmise how many more will die before the Fall comes and the floods—”
Interruption in the Proceeding
Eleven Cycles into the Requesting Party’s Testimony, A Breach of Protocol: Cause of breach is, as noted above, human ignorance.
—Injustice Collector 0080
“For Crissake,” the John Graf says, using yet another unknown phrase. “We did not bring the children here. We gave birth to them here. We’re colonists for God’s sake. We’re building a life here. Can’t you people understand that? My father explained it all when the ships landed. He told you what we were doing, and you agreed to let us have the land. You agreed to let us live here. And all our studies said it was safe. There’s no injustice in that. Don’t you get it? We’re just living—”
Record of Proceeding
Incident at Gray’s BrookInjustice Collector 0080 Presiding
Citing of the Injustice[s]
[continued]
According to custom, I place another hand on the bag, and ask: Does the Bystanding Party accept the Injustice claimed in its behalf?
The representative of the Bystanding Party has to be prodded by the John Graf. The representative of the Bystanding Party appears startled, then says, “I dunno.”
Again, faced with the ignorance of the humans, I cite the Gubernatorial Decision, accepting that response as an affirmative, and continue with the procedure.
“In this case,” I intone, “as in all cases of this nature, the final decision on the Injustices will be made by the Wiwendian.” I add for the humans, “the Wiwendian is what you have casually heard us refer to as ‘the bag.’ It is, instead, the true Injustice Collector, in that it feeds on such violations, needing them to survive. We feed the Collector, so that it and its people will not create new Injustices, simply for the sake of devouring them. In stating this old truth, I remind us all of the oaths we have taken to maintain Justice in our universe.”
I place my remaining hands on the bag, and undo the knot I tied in its opening. “Do you accept these Injustices?”
There is a whooshing, and the bag turns a light lavender. The Injustices white and blue, swirl away from the Requesting Party and the Bystanding Party. For a moment, I believe I see something red near the Non-Requesting Party, but the redness vanishes.
The bag accepts the Injustices and then fades to its normal color. I place the bag beneath the Decision Desk once more, and declare the proceedings complete.
But the proceedings do not exactly end. I add these events as an addendum to my report:
“That’s it?” the John Graf asks. “You ask a silly question of a bag and then it changes color and we get to go? That’s all that happens? We spent months of our lives here for that?”
The time reference confirms yet again the MugwL’s impression of time differences between the humans and our various species. More study will be needed to ascertain if this is, indeed a fact.
“Yes,” I tell the human. “The Proceeding has ended.”
“But nothing has changed,” the John Graf says.
“On the contrary. The Wiwendian—we—have taken the known Injustices from this world. The slate is clean. You may begin again.”
“Begin what?” the other human asks. “Our children are gone. We’ve gotten no satisfaction here. You let those people—those murderers get away with feeding our kids to their pod thingies.”
I signal my Collectors-in-Training. “I have done my work according to the laws and customs of our Alliance. I have responded to the Requesting Party, brought the Wiwendian, and collected injustices. If you perceive any violations, you may bring them up with the Review Board.”
I have, of course, added this for the humans’ benefit. It is more explanation than I usually offer after a decision has been rendered.
I feel the humans’ displeasure and empathize with it, but even they must realize that nothing brings back lost lives.
That, perhaps, is the ultimate Injustice, but one so common that the bag usually rejects it.
“My assistants will explain how to file your petitions with the Review Board,” I say as I open the doors to the Great Hall. The rush of cool air is marvelous. “But not in here.”
The Collectors-in-Training usher the humans out, but they are not the ones that stop at the doors. The MugwL do, and as they do, they let out their own sounds of fear and displeasure.
I rise, peering over their heads.
In the distance, smoke rises from the MugwL village. Too much smoke, accompanied by leaping flames.
The John Graf looks upset. He puts his arms around the “children” and leads them outside.
But the other human, the vocal one, stops, turns and looks at me, not the MugwL. I do not know human expressions, but this one seems, in some way frightening—the raised eyebrows, the half-contained amusement.
“On my world,” he says, “when systems break down, only one kind of justice remains. We call it street justice.”
And then he leaves.
The MugwL cry and wail, claiming their village is gone. My Collectors-in-Training still usher them out, and finally close the door.
I am alone, except for the bag. The bag that wants to collect these Injustices, in a Preliminary fashion, to save us a trip.
If my bag is any indication, the Wiwendians are becoming dissatisfied with our agreement to feed and house them in exchange for controlling their somewhat destructive talents. But that is an aside.
I would have refused its request on principle—one finished Proceeding is enough for any Collector—but principle is not my real reason for saying no.
I say no because I do not want to preside over another Proceeding involving humans. Too messy, too many chances for mistakes.
The red floating above them as the bag collected the Injustices disturbs me. Red is usually the color of violation. The Injustices from the MugwL and the “children” were not red.
The humans have a rawer, more passionate sense of Injustice than we do.
There is already so much Injustice in the Alliance that we barely maintain our hold on the Wiwendians. My Wiwendian already finds the human sense of Injustice attractive. Other Wiwendians will as well.
The humans will give the Wiwendians too much power.
Together, they will destroy everything.
And I fear that, after this Proceeding, they have already started.
The Injustice Collector
Copyright © 2024 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
First published in I, Alien, edited by Mike Resnick, Daw Books, April 2005
Published by WMG Publishing
Cover and Layout copyright © 2024 by WMG Publishing
Cover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG Publishing
Cover art copyright © Bcon Management Inc./Dreamstime
The author-preferred edition of The Wedding Ring has just appeared in paperback. Both editions of the story—the one that appeared in Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine and the one I wrote first that is…um…racier?…(and edited with the digests in mind)—are in the volume, along with an essay explaining the story’s trajectory. This volume is good for both readers and writers.
You can pick up an ebook copy here or a print copy wherever books are sold.
I’m so pleased to announce that the second collection featuring my popular characters Spade and Paladin has just hit print!
The collection features a brand-new, never-before-seen novella about Spade and Paladin, called “The Case of the Purloined Pages.”
If you’ve never read a Spade story before, you have a chance by reading this week’s Free Fiction Monday story, “The Case of the Stolen Memories,” which is also in the book.
Here’s the blurb for the collection:
Explore the world of science fiction fandom as Secret Master of Fandom and private detective Spade solves crime after crime in this latest collection of stories.
Featuring two of masterful author Kristine Kathryn Rusch’s most popular characters: Spade and Paladin (Spade’s enigmatic sidekick and infamous detective for hire), these delightful stories include “The Really Big Ka-Boom,” “At Witt’s End,” “Unity Con,” “The Case of the Stolen Memories,” and the never-before-published “The Case of the Purloined Pages.”
Find out why Mystery Scene Magazine says: “I hope to read many more stories about Spade and Paladin.”
You can get the print book anywhere books are sold. The ebook is also available on all ebook sites, including our own, which is here.
We have so much going on right now at WMG that I’ve forgotten to remind you all about the Write Stuff Storybundle. Nine ebooks on writing, craft, business, and success, as well as a pop-up writing workshop which is worth $150 all by itself. You can get everything for as little as $25 and toss in a few bucks to support the Able Gamers charity.
The writers I share the bundle with are Anthea L. Sharp, Mark Leslie Lefebvre, Douglas Smith, Dean Wesley Smith, J. Daniel Sawyer, B.A. Paul, Dayle A. Dermatis, and Tracey Cooper-Posey. Dean, Doug, and Mark all provided books that you can only get in the bundle.
So what are you waiting for? The bundle will continue for about one more week…and then it’s gone forever. Get yours now.
On the new Fey Kickstarter…in less than an hour!
Thank you, backers!
(If you want to see what’s going on, click here.)
The Kickstarter for the latest Fey novel, Barkson’s Journey, has just gone live. Please head over and see the cool art and the maps and the merchandise. If you’ve never read the Fey series, you can get the first seven books as part of the rewards, as well as the first book in the new series (The Kirilli Matter) and the novella that the fans helped bring to live (The Reflection on Mount Vitaki).
Lots to read, lots to see. Head on over!
I’ll write more soon about how thrilled this makes me, and share some tidbits…
I have wonderful news to share. My story, “Catherine The Great,” is a finalist for the Derringer Award. The Derringers, for those of you who don’t know, are a prestigious mystery award given to the best short fiction of the year, as determined by The Short Mystery Fiction Society. “Catherine the Great” is in the novelette category, along with stories by James R. Benn, David Dean, Jacqueline Freimor, and Nick Kolakowski.
I’m really excited by this honor for a couple of reasons. The stories are blind-judged, so name value means nothing. Just story quality. That’s point one. Point two is that “Catherine The Great” came from our Holiday Spectacular (and will be reprinted in the big overall volume this summer, so you all can read it). And the third point is that the story was just so much fun to write. I had no idea where I was going when it started, but I’m happy with the way it ended.
If you want to see the entire list of nominees, please click here. Winners will be announced on May 1.
I’m so excited about this. WMG is finally going to publish the next book in the Qavnerian Protectorate Saga, which is a sub-series of the Fey. We waited two years to publish this book, Barkson’s Journey, because we needed maps. We tested so many different ways of doing the maps, and none of them worked. But we finally have one, and it’ll go into the book, which is going to be lovely.
We’re launching the book with a Kickstarter, which is what we do these days. So those of you who love the Fey can get the book early. (Actual release will be in the late summer.) If you click here right now, you will be reminded when the Kickstarter goes live…which is on Tuesday.
I have completed two other books in the series and am nearly done with yet another. I think there’s one more after that, but since this started with a novella, I can’t even trust myself on how many books it’ll take to complete this saga. I’m having a lot of fun writing it and learning about the continent of Dorovich, which the Fey tried to capture once centuries ago, and failed.
Now I know why.
Barkson won’t tell you why, but the later books will. Barkson is a literal race against time. I had fun writing it. I suspect you’ll have fun reading it.
Or, at least, I hope you will!
If you would like a free audio version of this post, please click here. I ended up with an issue after last week’s post on the controversy surrounding The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction. It was not the issue I expected. I even sent an email to a friend about that original issue, which did not materialize. What I said to them was, “I’m […]
Vaadum: the kind of place where vacationers go by accident. When a spaceship arrives at a Vaadum Resort and Casino on fire, with some passengers already dead, the survivors seek refuge. But when someone starts picking them off, too, the crew must catch the killer before no survivors remain. Chosen as one of the best novellas of the year by the readers of Asimov’s Science […]
If you would like an audio version of this post, click here. I did not want to write this post. In fact, I would have skipped the topic altogether if maybe a dozen different people hadn’t asked me to weigh in. I also felt that I was one of only a handful of people who could explain some of what editor Sheree Renée Thomas went […]
We are having a heck of a good first day on the Kickstarter for the brand new Diving novel, The Ivory Trees, and it’s all because of you. You folks are grand! We hit our goal in an hour and we are well on our way to the first stretch goal. Then we got a “Project We Love” from Kickstarter itself, which is quite an honor. And, best of all for me, 140 people as of this writing have backed the Kickstarter. In 6.5 hours. Thank you, thank you, thank you! I’m so honored!
Here’s the link for all of you and I’m attaching a video ad that the folks at WMG put together. They did a bang-up job on this, as did Dean who designed it all.
Thank you!
The next Diving novel takes us back a little bit in time, because I needed to learn a bit about the various cultures I was writing about. So Ivory Trees looks at some shenanigans in the Empire as well as explains some things that were deliberately left blank in the regular Diving novels.
Before you Diving fans ask, yes, I’m getting to Boss & Coop. I had to write this first. (And a few other things.)
For those of you who aren’t Diving fans, this novel is a great place to start. Parts of Ivory Trees have appeared in Asimov’s, including “The Break-In” in the current issue. You can read an excerpt here. Then I’d suggest picking up the magazine because this issue contains a lot of great fiction by really wonderful writers.
Every person who backs the Kickstarter will get an early ebook copy of Ivory Trees. Then you can pick and choose from the rewards, including some really cool sf merchandise (like pillows, blankets, and mugs) to online writing workshops as well as the entire series, should you want all your books in one place.
So head on over. The Kickstarter begins today. Join us!
When an African-American woman arrives whipped and tortured at the Club on Lake Superior, she interrupts a meeting of powerbrokers setting up the 1924 senate election. Russell hoped to use the meeting to garner support for his candidate, Joe Stanislawski. But the interruption disrupts Russell’s plans.
When Joe rushes to the woods where the woman says the men who beat her are still beating her husband, Russell follows. But what Joe does next surprises everyone involved.
“Fighting Bob,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Fighting BobKristine Kathryn RuschThe club hid behind a grove of trees on the southern shore of Lake Superior. The driveway was a thin, winding unpaved path that seemed to lead nowhere. At night, sailors on the lake barges could see the lights reflected in the windows, but the building gave the illusion of a large, secluded home. The monthly dinners had been going on there since Fighting Bob ran for President the first time. I figured it was the best place for Joe to announce his candidacy and get some statewide support.
He was going for Robert La Follette’s old seat, the one Robert Jr. took when his dad got elected President. Joe was taking on Wisconsin’s biggest family in its home base. He wanted to be a Senator, figuring that the Congress had more power than any other governmental body, especially since the Stalemate of ’25.
I drove my roadster up the windy drive, hearing tree branches scrape the windshield. My knuckles were white, and my throat dry. I was one of the youngest members of the club, thanks to family ties and a successful law career, but I had never before taken advantage of my exclusive connections. But I knew Joe, with his humble beginnings, needed the approval of the state’s powerful to pull down Bob Jr. and break the La Follette deadlock on the state.
Joe stared straight ahead, eyes focused on a point in the center of the windshield. His borrowed suit fit well and his hair curled over the back of his starched collar. His right coat pocket bulged slightly with the derringer that he had kept with him ever since his labor union days. He didn’t seem nervous, but I knew he was. He had been talking about this meeting for days.
A number of cars already lined the parking lot. As I gave my keys to the valet, I noted a car pull up behind mine. Fola La Follette peered at me over the dash, her small gloved hands clutching the wheel. Belle, her mother, sat at Fola’s side; only the white strands mixed with dark gave any evidence to Belle’s advancing age. If the La Follette women were arriving alone, that meant the men were already inside. All spouseless, serious, and prepared for battle.
Someone had warned them Joe was coming.
And I had asked that the La Follettes not be notified of this month’s meeting. My stomach clenched. The evening would not go as smoothly as I had thought.
The building stood dark against the pine trees, the red brick seeming almost black in the twilight. The door was open to catch the breeze blowing through the trees. I waited on the stone path, although Joe shifted impatiently beside me. I knew that Belle and Fola had seen me. It was better to face them now than to avoid them.
The valet helped Belle out of the car. She looked old-fashioned despite her laced shoes, and the skirt that fell to mid-calf. She came over to me, hand extended, and I got a very faint whiff of her lavender perfume. “Russell,” she said, “if your father knew what you were doing, he would question the wisdom of letting you inherit.”
I took her hand and bent over it perfunctorily. As I stood, I smiled. “My father always allowed me an open mind.”
But she had already turned her attention to Joe. “You must be Mr. Stanislawski,” she said.
Joe’s posture was stiff, but his expression was friendly. A lock of black hair had fallen across his forehead. “Yes, Ma’am.”
“I believe I met your family in ’24,” Belle said. “They were trying to stop that railroad strike in Milwaukee.”
“Yes, Ma’am.”
“They thought it so odd for a woman to come and negotiate, even if she was the wife of the president-elect.”
“Yes, Ma’am.”
I stiffened. Belle smiled. Fola moved closer to the conversation. Joe ignored her.
“You wouldn’t have trouble with a woman in that kind of situation, would you, Mr. Stanislawski?” Belle asked, her tone the same as it had been for all the other questions.
“Not at all, Ma’am,” Joe said. “I believe in the same rights your husband believed in. I believe in equality under the law.”
Fola snorted. “Until you’re elected.”
Belle pursed her lips. “Fola. Allow the young man his ideals. Sometimes I think that’s more than my son has.”
“Robert is following Daddy’s plan.”
“Precisely. He needs a plan of his own.” Belle touched Joe’s hand lightly. “Best of luck to you, young man. They’ll probably be vicious inside.”
She turned then, and made her way slowly up the stairs. Fola took her mother’s elbow to steady her as they disappeared into the darkness behind the door.
Joe took a deep breath. “She’s good.”
“Sixty years at her husband’s side,” I said. “They always claimed she was his strength.”
“And probably his brains too.”
I glanced at him. “If you’re going to malign Fightin’ Bob La Follette, I’m going to put you back in the car and take you out of here. You can’t take this state’s only president and shred him among the people who financed his election.”
“Nearly ten years ago.”
“Ten years isn’t very long here. They still talk about the ways La Follette put away the bosses in aught-two.”
Joe nodded. He tilted his head back, looking more like the fine young candidate I had pledged to support than he had a moment earlier. “Let’s go inside,” he said.
We walked up the red brick path. Slightly overgrown shrubbery brushed at my pants legs. It was moments like this, as I was about to risk my reputation and connections, that made me wonder about my own motives.
The butler nodded as we passed inside the door. The narrow hallway was dark, the newly installed electric lighting doing little to dispel the gloom caused by the paneled walls, thick red carpet and low ceiling. The smell of tobacco permeated the air. Conversation filtered in from the main room. We rounded the corner, and I stopped, as I always did, in awe at the wall of floor-to-ceiling windows overlooking the lake. About fifty people filled the room, holding drinks and standing in small groups. None of them seemed to notice our presence except Ira Knudsen who smiled at me. Ira’s wife, Ruby, and I had grown up together. When La Follette and his Progressives supported the suffragettes in bill after bill, Ruby took advantage of her new rights and became one of the shrewdest business people in the state. She and her husband had joined the club together.
I led Joe to the bar tucked in the corner near the windows. I ordered a brandy and braced myself to defend Joe’s beer order. But he shook his head. He didn’t want anything, preferring, I supposed, to keep his mind clear.
A hand clapped me on the shoulder. “So this is the young man who is going to wrest the power away from the La Follettes.”
I didn’t have to look to know whom the booming voice belonged to. “Joe,” I said. “This is Timothy Van Hise, president of the University of Wisconsin system.”
Van Hise’s large hand swallowed Joe’s. Joe looked like a rag doll next to the larger man. “So why should I vote for you when the La Follettes know Washington and have made this state the great place that it is?”
The conversation in the room hissed to a stop. Van Hise’s words echoed in the silence. Joe glanced at me, once, and I didn’t move. We had discussed this. I had explained that he needed these people. He needed their support, their encouragement and their money to defeat Bob Jr. Joe’s I’m-a-working-man-just-like-you-tactics wouldn’t work in this room.
“Because, sir, I’m young, I’m fresh and I have my own ideas.” Joe’s voice sounded a bit shaky.
“We all have our own ideas, young man. But most of us stay out of politics. And most of us know better than to challenge an experienced politician who has established himself within one of the most powerful bodies in the world.”
I took a sip of my brandy to cover a sudden attack of nerves. Van Hise had been chosen spokesman. Joe’s trial had begun. Joe glanced at me again, and I knew then that he wasn’t going to follow my advice.
“Forgive me, sir,” Joe said, “but the Senate gained its power in the Stalemate of 1925, a stalemate caused by the Senate’s disagreements with President La Follette himself. That his son has gained a measure of respect in that body is, perhaps, a tribute to the La Follette charisma and nothing more. Wisconsin is not represented on the more powerful committees and in the past five years, we have voted along with the business dollars that President La Follette died fighting.”
Someone gasped. Fola, standing off near the double oak doors, clutched her purse as if it were a naughty child. Belle sat in an overstuffed chair, legs crossed and eyes closed.
“If we’re not careful,” Joe said, “this drought of the past two years could become an agricultural depression which will lead to a major, national economic downturn.”
“And you can solve these problems?”
“One man can’t solve them, but I can work at solving them better than a man who carries the La Follette name, but not the La Follette spirit.”
I turned away then, and walked toward the window. I set down my brandy glass, afraid that it would shatter between my clenched fingers. My father had lost most of his fortune when La Follette circumvented the Congress and tightened the reins on domestic money speculation. And when the Progressives turned their back on Wilson’s post-war foreign policy, my father financed the fight that eventually denuded the executive branch of much of its power and caused (or so said the press) Robert Marion La Follette to die of a heart attack a month later. By that time, my father had become a bitter man, financially ruined and despised in the state of his birth. I rebuilt his fortune, penny by penny, cautiously planning for the time when I could finish the job of defeating the La Follettes.
Joe had never told me how he felt about the La Follettes. I assumed we shared the same opinions. His family had fought the La Follettes on every railroad regulation that came down to strangle the state since the early 1920s.
“What do you know of the La Follette spirit?” Fola asked. The window reflected the entire scene against the darkness of the lake. Fola’s brother Bob stood behind her, hand on her shoulder. Philip La Follette lounged in the corner, seemingly as uninvolved as his mother.
“I am a working man,” Joe said. His voice had a ring to it and a power, and I knew the intense, driven expression on his face, even though I couldn’t see it. “I grew up reading La Follette’s Magazine, believing the dream that everyone—male or female—had a chance in this country. I watched your father fight the great trusts and battle for the poor people, the underprivileged. My father died in a railroad accident that wouldn’t have happened if the Stalemate of ’25 hadn’t prevented your father’s Railroad Regulations Act from passing—”
A pounding on the window stopped him. The glass in front of me shook and shimmered. A woman leaned against it on the outside. She used the glass to brace herself as she propelled herself toward the light. Her hands left bloody prints as she moved.
Van Hise stepped past Joe and pushed open the balcony doors. The woman came inside. Her clothes hung in shreds around her body and she didn’t even try to cover herself up. Her eyes were wide and glazed. Blood from cuts all over her black skin dripped on the red carpet below her.
“Please,” she said, “they’re going to kill me.”
“Who?” Van Hise asked. We all hovered around her, afraid to get too close.
“My husband.” She pointed toward the direction she came. “Please…”
Ira Knudsen glanced at me from across the circle. I could see the disapproval on his face. I knew that mine reflected the same emotion.
“Don’t stand there.” Belle was on her feet. “Someone call a doctor and help this child.” No one moved. She snapped her fingers at the butler. “See to it that she gets cleaned up and covered up.”
The butler pulled off his jacket, pushed his way past us, and wrapped it around the woman. She collapsed against him. A few of the men, Joe and Van Hise among them, were already outside. I went with them, followed by the La Follettes. Through the window, I saw Ira pick up his glass and settle into a chair as if nothing had happened at all.
The air was cold this close to the lake. Blood spattered the grass. The woman had left a trail going into the trees. We didn’t need to follow it. The snaps of a whip crackled the air, followed by the whinny of a horse and men’s laughter.
I walked toward the edge of the trail, careful not to step in the blood and stain my shoes. We all knew what we would find. Not everyone in the country believed in the equalities that La Follette espoused—and some used white sheets and violence to prove it.
We rounded the corner into a small clearing. Five men wearing the white robes of the Klan watched as a sixth whipped the already shredded back of a black man tied to a pine tree. The man leaned face down against the tree, seemingly unconscious, only the way he was tied keeping him from slumping against the ground altogether. Several horses waited at the edge of the clearing. A noose hung from an oak tree branch not far above us.
“Enough of this!” Van Hise shouted.
Joe slipped into the trees. I moved to follow him, but couldn’t see where he had gone. He probably went back to the club to get extra help—and to stay uninvolved. A fight with the Klan this early in his career would only hurt him. I had to hold myself as rigidly as I could to keep myself from shouting like Van Hise was.
The Klansmen turned. Their robes were spattered with blood. The taller man toward the side stepped forward. “Senator,” he said. I started when I heard his voice, then felt my flush of anger grow. He ignored me and directed his remarks to Bob. “Didja come to help us tame the nigra?”
Bob stood straighter. “You’re breaking the law,” he said in his best stentorian voice.
“Nigger lover.” The fat man in the middle walked toward us. “We wouldn’t have ta take care of this if you and your father hadn’t—”
A gunshot made us all turn. The horses screamed and bolted, leaving Joe standing across the clearing, unprotected except for the derringer in his hand. The fat man grabbed Bob and placed a gun against his head. I felt a moment of wild hope. This more than anything would end the La Follette hold on the state.
“We’re all gentlemen here,” said the taller man. He looked at me. “In fact, many of us have the same goals. Let us go and there’ll be no further violence.”
“Let him go, Fritz,” Joe said. “You’re not solving anything.”
Belle came up beside me, the only signs of worry on her face a slight pursing of her lips. “And if you kill him, I’ll be forced to press charges.”
“If you have a grievance about the way things are being run, then you go to Bob or you come to me,” Joe said. He stepped into the clearing, the derringer leveled on Fritz. “Let him go. Or this will get very unpleasant.”
No one moved. I swallowed. The evening hadn’t gone at all like I had planned. Everything was out of control. No one had listened to me. The La Follettes had shown up, and the Klansmen had decided to take their weekly action in the woods.
And the last thing we needed was for my candidate to shoot the brother of one of the most prominent bankers in the state while he held a United States Senator hostage.
“Let him go,” I said. Belle glanced at me, understanding my calm, disgusted tone, understanding more than I wanted her to.
Fritz dropped his hold on Bob. Bob stumbled forward as the Klansmen turned and ran into the woods. Van Hise and two of the other men untied the black man from the tree. He fell forward and they caught him. Philip La Follette took a few running steps forward, but Belle grabbed his arm.
“You’re letting them go,” Philip said, his voice rising in pitch.
“Of course.” Belle hit him once, lightly, with her fan. She put her hand on her other son’s arm. “Are you all right?”
Bob nodded, wiping the sweat from his forehead.
Fola stood in the center of the clearing, her legs and shoes spattered with mud. “You knew them,” she said to Joe.
He slipped his derringer back into his pocket. “I’m sure we all did.”
“And yet you let them go.”
“There are other ways to take care of them,” Joe said.
“Yes.” Fola drew herself to her full height, looking like a younger version of Belle. “You can do nothing and let them continue.”
“Or we can bring political and economic pressure to bear,” Belle said. She wasn’t looking at her daughter. She was looking at me. “These are lawyers, doctors and bankers we’re dealing with, not working class men. We can stop them in other ways, can’t we, Russell?”
I didn’t say a word. A flush rose hot against my chest. I hadn’t known they were going to be out tonight. If I had, I would have stopped them. Power comes through many avenues, not just political ones. I needed Joe, but I needed other methods as well.
“Joe,” Belle said, “my husband used to say that there are two kinds of people in this state: thugs and honest men. And he was always afraid that the thugs would take over the government once again, giving us witch hunts and terror that we haven’t seen here since aught-two. If I asked you for the names of those men, would you give them to me?”
“Yes, Ma’am.” Joe didn’t even hesitate.
“Then perhaps you, Bob Jr., and I need to discuss strategy. It might be better to have two good men in office, even if one of them has to be in the House, than none at all, wouldn’t you agree?”
“Well, Ma’am, we need to talk about a definition of good.”
“Indeed we do.”
The tension had grown so thick that I walked away. The ground squished beneath my feet. I was protected. They could do nothing to me, tie nothing to me. I had lived a quiet life and only taken one political action—Joe’s sponsorship. And, as far as I was concerned, it had failed.
Behind me, the black man groaned with pain. His wife waited in the club, bleeding her tainted blood all over the expensive floor. First women allowed, and now nigras. Soon all the distinctions would disappear, and La Follette’s vision would fill the state, the nation.
I understood why my father had become so bitter.
The battle was more difficult than either one of us had thought.
Fighting Bob
Copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
First published in Alternate Presidents, edited by Mike Resnick, TOR, 1992
Published by WMG Publishing
Cover and Layout copyright © 2015 by WMG Publishing
Cover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG Publishing
Cover art copyright © Ibangpots/Dreamstime
If you would like a free audio version of this post, click here. A series of articles have appeared over the summer about the ways that the pandemic affected us as human beings. One of the most obvious is that people have forgotten how to behave in public. Vox did a long article on this, citing various examples, including many that featured concert goers throwing […]
Coney Island in 1907, known for its freaks and spectacles. But for Rose, Coney Island becomes a place of wonder, a place that makes memories. A place that saves lives… A moving story that offers a glimpse at the Coney Island of old through an unexpected lens. “Rose in Dreamland,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s […]
July was strange. I had a lot of dental and other medical appointments which ate up a lot of time. Some of the stuff that happened forced me to rest afterwards or deal with migraines. I’ve had migraines my whole life, so I can judge how “bad” they are. These were bad enough that I couldn’t really think, but I could read. So the last […]
Two opportunities have cropped up this week to sample my very popular Diving Universe. The first opportunity comes from a Storybundle curated by Robert T. Jeschonek. Bob has put together a Space Opera Sisterhood Storybundle, featuring great female characters and a number of wonderful female writers. The bundle includes my Diving novella, “Becalmed.” So if you’ve never read anything in the Diving universe, start here. […]
To get a free audio version of this post, click here. I’m obsessed with all things Barbie right now. Not because I loved the movie. I haven’t seen it, and am not sure I will. My relationship with the doll is fraught due to some bad childhood moments, and I’m not sure I want to open that memory box all the way in the blues […]
Stealth tech: a lost science everyone wants to reclaim. The woman who helped Boss dive the Dignity Vessel, known then as Squishy, claims a long and storied history with stealth tech. Her research into the lost science caused deaths before, and she failed to prevent them during that fateful dive. Now, she vows to find a way to destroy the technology once and for all. […]
For an audio version of this blog, click here. Because of various health issues, I’m behind on the Niche Marketing blogs. I am better, but struggling to catch up. I’ll be back on Niche Marketing next week. Until then, here’s a blog I wrote in July just in case the health issues got in the way. Enjoy! I had a great June. I finished four […]
Kincaid always shows up at a crime scene before the crime happens. Except at the Burger Joint. He got stuck in Los Angeles traffic and arrived just after the shooting ended. Now he must deal with carnage, carnage he couldn’t prevent—carnage he has never been able to prevent. The carnage takes him to the end of his singular talent, and as he tries to flee, […]
For an audio version of this post, please click here. I had nearly a dozen conversations in July with writers who told me why they did not use Shopify for their online store. Instead, these writers used dated products that were the Big Thing in 2015 or freebies from the web (which is scary, when dealing with money) or some Shopify knockoff that has one-tenth […]
Rena lost everything when her husband and son died in a fiery car accident. Now she has only her daily swim at the rec center, where she hopes no one pays attention to her horrible burn scars. But someone noticed—the same someone who murders a lifeguard while Rena does her laps. Only Rena can identify the killer, but the identification might prove more difficult than […]
I’ve been offline this past week after some minor surgery. I’m fine, but the offline part got in the way of me saying thank you to all the backers for the great support of the Pulphouse Kickstarter. We hit our goal, then hit five stretch goals and two special goals, thanks to all the wonderful backers. Thank you, thank you, thank you. If the rest […]
To download a free audio version of this post, click here. I had this post all planned. I was going to use a novella I was writing in my Santa Series, under my Grayson name. I started the novella at the end of June, and planned to finish it within a week, so that we could add it to the Holiday Spectacular Kickstarter as an […]
Suze loves her music. She hides in it when her parents fight. But when the fights end in divorce, the divorce brings an end to the music—obtained illegally by Suze’s mother. Now Nils, Suze’s father, must quickly find a way to save his daughter’s music—and her sanity—without breaking the law. “Watching the Music Dance,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one […]
As some of you know, we’re running a subscription drive Kickstarter for Pulphouse magazine. We’ve got all kinds of rewards, starting at $25 for a six-issue subscription. In fact, the six-issue subscription comes with every reward. As I mentioned in some of my posts, we also have merchandise in the Kickstarter. The merch is priced low, but has the six-issue sub added in, so you’ll […]
For a free audio version of this post, click here. My plan all along for this series was to take a few projects of mine and use them as examples of ways to apply niche marketing thinking to books. It took me a while to get here. If you want to see some real world examples, take a look at the previous post. If you’re […]
When Greta arrives at Grayson Place with her ballet company, her memories haunt her. Karl Grayson died there twenty years earlier, but she returns to the mansion for the company’s fiftieth-anniversary gala anyway, just as he wished. Karl’s death freed her once. Or did it? “Waltzing on a Dancer’s Grave,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s […]
A lot of reading in June, but mostly for various editing projects. One of them, the Holiday Spectacular, will have a Kickstarter that goes live in October. Before that, though, you can sample our Christmas in July promotion of the Spectacular with the compilation of last year’s stories. What I did read outside of that project I liked, but not enough to recommend. I read […]
To get a free audio version of this post, click here. This little niche marketing series continues, and what we need are examples. Fortunately, I have them. Note: if you’re new to this series, please go back and start with the first post. In the second part of this series, I listed the various books I have published and which are currently still on the […]
I’m going to start with the thing that’s not as much fun as everything else. That’d be the little bit of advice. I have a new book out, which is called How Writers Fail: Analysis and Solutions. The topic is dark, but the book is uplifting, especially if you have some of the issues I’m dealing with here. If you know or if you are […]
The four musketeers plus one they call themselves: Johnny, Craig, Dale, Rennie and Carren. They want to make something of themselves, do great things after high school. So, they devise an experiment to guarantee their lives will amount to something. And that experiment changes their futures—but not in the ways any of them expects. A Nebula Award-nominated story about dreaming of a future and looking […]
I’m still behind on posting these, but I’m catching up, despite emergency vet visits and five dentist visits for me so far. (That’s so fun. Not.) I’m getting there, though. May was a hectic month as well, with the end of school, the end of a cold, another workshop, and lots of visitors. I still managed to read for enjoyment quite a bit. Have to […]
For A Free Audio Version of This Blog, Click Here. At the risk of overwhelming you all, I’m going to discuss strategies for niche marketing before I get specific. Please note that this is the fourth post in a series on niche marketing. Please look at the previous three posts so that you know where I’m coming from, particularly last week’s post. And remember, that […]
Beautiful longhaired tom Wall T runs a tight household. But when the other cats in his pride begin reporting a mouse incursion, he launches an investigation. What he uncovers might change everything he thought he knew about crime and leadership. This delightful detective tale by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch offers a fascinating feline perspective on the nature of a crime. “An […]
For an audio version of this blog, click here. I dithered a lot before starting this post. I wanted to show you how to pare that long list of mine that I featured in the previous blog down into something manageable, to show how niche marketing is done in an effective manner. But I couldn’t get myself started. Granted, I had a very sick cat […]
Kessa possesses only small magic. But her skills allow her to help those who wield bigger magic. Her latest job takes her deep into the bowels of New York City’s subway system, hunting for bits of history long since forgotten. And what she finds deep down in the dark will both threaten her life and change it forever. “Track 61,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is […]
I ended up being in two Storybundles in the month of June, both with new books exclusive to the bundles. Bundle The First The first, the Epic Elves Storybundle, appeared just this week, and wow, am I excited about it. Curated by one of my favorite writers, Anthea Sharp, the bundle is filled with ten writers, a few new to me whose work I can’t […]
For an audio version of this blog, click here. This summer, we have finally decided to revamp a number of things about our business. Dean and I started WMG Publishing over 13 years ago, and based it on the traditional publishing model. Back then, we didn’t see that traditional publishing would make itself mostly irrelevant. We figured traditional publishing and self-publishing would exist side-by-side. That’s […]
Triwell doesn’t adopt strays. He feels like a stray himself, a man who has lost everything even though he has a house and an antiquarian bookstore in Seavy Village on the Oregon Coast. But the cat adopted him. And she proves a mystery. A mystery who lives with him. A mystery he will solve one summer in a surprising—and deadly—way. “Cat Nap,” by international bestselling author Kristine […]
Wow, am I late on this. No, I have not dropped the Recommended Reading list, but it was the one thing that could go by the wayside during one of my busiest springs ever. So I have two months of reading list to get to. I hope to finish this by the end of June…before June’s list is due in July. Fingers crossed! I’m amazed […]
For an audio version of this blog, click here. Niche marketing has existed since the beginning of marketing. Back in the day, though, companies didn’t call it “niche” marketing. These places marketed to their category or their type. The idea that something could be marketed to everyone was a mid-20th century idea, bolstered by television. When programs went out to 120 million viewers or more […]
At times, many seek ways to change their existence. Some take classes. Our Opera Singer shows up in a voiceover class. A decision everyone in the class might come to regret. Perhaps most of all, her. “Our Opera Singer” perfectly captures Kristine Kathryn Rusch’s mastery of crime fiction. “Our Opera Singer,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The […]
I know, I know. The title is a terrible pun. But it’s also appropriate. I curated the 2023 Write Stuff Storybundle. It’s full of career-enhancing advice…and there’s a free workshop too. (Okay, free if you pay $20 for the bundle. But that’s a savings of $130, plus you’ll get twelve ebooks.) I’m going to put my introduction to the bundle here now, so that I […]
For an audio version of this blog, click here. I opened a can of worms in my own head when I wrote last week’s blog which I titled “Stars.” The post deals with the fact that there are no big names in entertainment any longer, except for legacy names, like Harrison Ford in movies and Stephen King in fiction. A source I quoted from The […]
Leta’s death leaves her husband Mac with his memories and one famous holorecording. On June 16, 2001, Leta ate at a restaurant called Anna’s, and a time travel recording made of that day later became a sensation. Leta collected all of the versions of that recording, but Mac has never seen it. Until now. Called “hauntingly sad” by the Sacramento Book Review, and chosen as […]
This week, WMG Publishing officially published The Court-Martial of the Renegat Renegades. And…this week…Asimov’s announced the winners of its Readers Choice Awards. The Court-Martial won in the Best Novel/Novella category! This novel stands alone, so it’s a great entry point into the sprawling series, but there are a lot of Easter eggs for Diving fans. Get your copy today from your favorite bookseller or buy the ebook direct […]
To Get a Free AI Audio Version of this blog, click here. Me and the Google (as a friend of mine calls it) spent what I almost termed a “dispiriting” hour as I searched for the 21st century’s superstars in a variety of fields. I say “almost termed” because, when I think of it, “dispiriting” is the wrong word. Adult me, who loves this modern […]
Roz trusts her husband, Jack. So when she catches him in her photography studio with a naked young woman, she knows the situation offers more than meets the eye. Turns out the young woman wants to pose for “artistic photographs”—the euphemism given to naked daguerreotypes sold to soldiers on the western frontier.
But the young woman does not fit the usual naked-photograph type. Roz vows to discover what the young woman really wants…and what she wants with Jack.
“Artistic Photographs,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, writing as Kristine Grayson, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
Artistic PhotographsKristine Grayson“She looks like trouble,” Roz Donnelly whispered as she dragged the heavy box of glass photographic plates across the floor of her studio, narrowly avoiding the overstuffed sofa she had placed near the fringed lamp.
Her husband Jack peeked through the red velvet curtains. “So?”
Roz slapped his fingers and he dropped the curtain, turning to face her. He was tall, his muscles rope hard, and his body lean from too many years on the back of a horse. His brown hair brushed against his collar—new and perfectly starched for the first time since she’d known him—and his brown eyes held a trace of humor in them.
“Jealous?” he asked, leaning into her.
“Of that baby?”
He shushed her. “That baby might hear you and leave.”
Roz shook her head. “That baby has a plan, Jack, believe me. And we’re probably its victims.”
“What are you afraid of, Roz, my darling? Afraid I’ll trade you in for a younger model?”
He was so close, she could smell the tobacco on his clothing. It mixed with the scent of her own specially made soap, and something undeniably Jack. Ever since she had met him, she had been under his spell.
“If she’s the model, you wouldn’t last a day,” Roz said. “She may be ten years younger than I am, but she’s older in spirit.”
He ran his thumb along her jaw, sending a shiver through her. “My cynic.”
She knew he felt the shiver; his eyes crinkled as he held back a smile. But she didn’t want him to feel as if he had an advantage. “That cynicism has saved you a hundred times in the last ten years. You should respect it.”
“Oh, I do,” he said, this time letting the smile out. “But I wonder why it appears now.”
“This city has decency laws, doesn’t it?” she asked.
He shrugged. “The law is not something I specialize in, darling.”
“You should.” She bent down and tugged at the box of glass plates. It weighed as much as she did, and she could use his help, but she wasn’t going to ask for it.
She glanced up. He was peeking through the curtain again.
“Well?” she asked. “Will she be artistic enough?”
He ignored her sarcasm. “I don’t think the decency laws matter anyway. No one has applied them to photography.”
“It’s only a matter of time, thanks to you,” Roz muttered, but she did so with a smile. Her husband’s schemes had allowed her to own this photography studio for two years—the longest they’d been in one place since they got married.
He hadn’t said a word about moving on. But Roz was starting to feel restless. He disappeared for weeks at a time, following one scheme or another, but she had to stay to take portraits of people she didn’t even like.
Somehow she had a hunch there was more to photography than spending her days in a musty studio, even if it did have a secret and shady side.
A side the young woman in the other room had somehow figured out.
Roz had a feeling about this girl, a feeling she didn’t like. Jack had a feeling too, and he liked his. Roz couldn’t tell what part of his anatomy he was thinking with. She knew her husband well enough to know that, while he never touched any other woman, he didn’t mind a long healthy look.
“We’ve got to hurry,” he said, letting the curtain drop one final time. “The girl’s getting cold.”
“I suppose you know that for sure,” Roz said, pushing the box all the way into the corner.
“As a matter of fact, I do.” He grinned at her. “So let’s move it, Rosalind.”
“Then pick up the damn box,” she said. “I can’t move it any farther.”
He bent down and lifted it as if it weighed nothing. “I thought you would never ask.”
He kicked the curtain open with his foot and stepped into the small theater they had built in the back of the photography studio. The theater did not hold an audience—there was no room for seats or aisles. Instead, there was floor space wide enough for several cameras, all set up at strategic angles.
The stage itself was narrow, and even though there were curtains behind it, the curtains opened onto a wall. The theater had no windows, and the front curtains were the only way into this area.
Roz had insisted on double curtains with openings in different parts so that no one would stumble onto this back area. The curtains themselves were part of a formal furniture grouping in the main part of the studio and to date, one year since they’d added in the theater, no one had discovered it.
Roz waited a moment before going in. She had to be in the right frame of mind to confront her artistic subjects. Usually when she took photographs, she asked questions, drew people out. When she took her art photographs, she never even learned the subject’s name.
It was easier to deny that she had done anything if she had no idea who she was photographing.
Finally, Roz pulled the curtains apart. She let the curtains swish closed behind her before she looked at the girl. The girl was clearly an adult, although she was no more than twenty-one. She was full-breasted and wide-hipped with enough heft to suggest wealth. Her eyes were big and brown, her mouth curved in a slight smile. She hadn’t put on the drape that Roz had left for her, and Jack had been right—the girl was clearly cold.
“Cover yourself up,” Roz said, nodding at the drape.
“I thought the point was to take nude photos,” the girl said.
“The point is to take artistic photos,” Roz said through gritted teeth. That some people found the artistic photos erotic was not her problem.
The girl did not move toward the drape. She stood there in all her goose-pimpled glory, staring at Jack, almost daring him. He, bless him, was ignoring her and not because Roz was in the room. He didn’t like contrary females.
Then Roz frowned. That wasn’t entirely accurate—he did like Roz—but he claimed he hated her contrary nature, even though it had gotten them out of a thousand scrapes.
Roz checked out the first camera. Jack continued to hold the box of plates, waiting for her to tell him what to do with them. She could have let him continue to hold them until he complained, but she wasn’t in the mood to torture him, even if he had brought her the girl.
“Set them next to this camera,” she said, “and then get me the other box of plates beneath the developing counter.”
“Roz, this is enough plates—”
She turned toward him, nearly knocking the camera. “We’re taking three kinds of photographs—daguerreotypes, portraits and Talbotypes. They require different plates.”
And different papers and different cameras and different skills, but she wasn’t going to tell him that.
“Why so many?” the girl asked.
“Some for us and some for you. It was part of our deal.” Then Roz squinted at Jack. “You told her about the deal, right?”
He nodded and looked at the girl for confirmation. She nodded too, even though Roz had a hunch the girl had heard nothing about the different types of portraits before now.
The girl walked to the edge of the stage. She hung her toes over the lip. Her toenails had turned blue. She didn’t look seductive or even comfortable, although she was trying.
Jack gave her an uncomfortable glance and hurried out of the theater.
Roz stuck her head through the first camera’s curtain. The girl looked even more provocative when framed by the lens.
Time to talk to the girl and make sure Jack had followed the rules. Even though Roz was taking artistic photographs, she wasn’t one of society’s predators. She never took destitute women and photographed them—at least not on purpose. Jack had brought one or two in early on, but Roz had figured out early what he was about. Most of those women were malnourished and therefore too skinny for art photography.
Men didn’t like to fantasize about women so skinny their breasts had sunken into their chests. Men liked women who were big in front and in back, women whose flesh jiggled as they moved. Roz never fit in that category either—her life (mostly on the run) had left her slender and muscled—the antithesis of modern beauty.
“So,” Roz said, “Jack didn’t make any agreement with you.”
“He said we’d settle it later.”
Roz clenched her right hand, but kept it hidden behind her thick black skirt. What he had meant was that Roz would settle it later—and apparently he had been right.
“Are you paying us?” Roz asked.
“No,” the girl said. “He said that would take care of itself.”
And that, ladies and gentlemen of the jury, was what Jack called an agreement. Roz shook her head.
“All right. Before we go any further….” She paused. She really couldn’t take it any longer. “Put on the damn drape. You’re not here to seduce me.”
The girl’s lower lip jutted out. “So? He’s going to take the photographs.”
“I’m going to take the photographs,” Roz said. “I’m the photographer. He’s just the front and the money man.”
How she hated calling him that. He really was the money-slipping-through-the-fingers-like-water man.
“Oh,” the girl said and backed away from the edge of the stage. She picked up the sheer drape and wrapped it around herself, then shivered. “It doesn’t cover up much.”
“It’s not supposed to. There’s a robe behind the curtain over there.” Roz gestured toward the curtain at the side of the stage.
The girl followed her direction, grabbed the robe, and slipped it on. “How come it’s so cold in here?”
“It makes better art,” Roz said sarcastically.
The girl sat on the edge of the stage and tucked her feet under herself.
“Here’s the deal,” Roz said. “For the next two hours, we will take as many photographs of you as possible.”
“I thought you were only doing a few portraits.”
“There are different kinds of photography,” Roz said, not willing to go into too much detail.
The last thing the girl needed to know was that she had treated a ream of paper with salt and silver nitrate so that they could reprint the Talbotypes as many times as they liked—or to put it more accurately—as many times as they could afford to do.
“This is an artistic session,” Roz said. “I’ll put you in different poses and take as many portraits as possible. You will get half the portraits—” Technically, she would get half of the number that Roz told her were portraits, which in the past had been less than a fourth—”and a quarter of the daguerreotypes—” actually, only about one sixteenth because artistic daguerreotypes brought a large sum from soldiers heading out to the frontier. “I hope that’s acceptable.”
The girl was picking at her robe. Roz wasn’t even sure she was listening.
“In exchange for that, we will keep the rest and sell them to cover our expenses.”
“Sell them to whom?” the girl asked.
The “whom” threw Roz. She hadn’t expected good grammar from a girl who wanted to pose nude.
“Anyone we please,” Roz said. She wasn’t going to negotiate with this girl. It would be Roz’s way or no way at all.
The girl smiled. “All right.”
Roz felt a shimmer of unease. She had been right; this girl was planning something.
“What if I tell you I only want one portrait and you can keep the daguerreotypes?”
“I would tell you not to change the deal,” Roz said.
“Hell, hon, let her change the deal if she wants.” Jack was coming through the curtains, the second box of plates in his arms.
“No,” Roz said.
“I made my initial agreement with him,” the girl said, not looking at Roz. She was smiling at Jack instead. Jack, the bastard, was smiling back.
“Fine,” Roz said, uncertain whether she was more irritated at the girl or at her husband. “He can take your portraits then.”
“Roz.” Jack set the plates down hard. They clanked together and Roz prayed that none of them were broken.
“All right,” the girl said. “I’d rather be photographed by a real photographer anyway.”
“Doll.” Jack took a step toward the girl. “If you want a real photographer—”
“Then Jack’s your man.” Roz smiled sweetly at him. “You remember how to work the camera, don’t you, dear? The one you’re used to is the one in the middle. Don’t touch the two on the sides. The process is different for those. And the one near me is a camera obscura. It is nothing like anything you’ve ever used before.”
“Can’t you control her?” the girl snapped at Jack. She looked so fierce that Jack took a step backwards.
“Um.” Apparently Jack didn’t have a good lie ready. “No, doll.”
“Pity.” The girl pulled her robe tighter. “Well, I’m here, I’m naked, and the price is right. Let’s do this thing.”
Roz didn’t move. “Why do you want your photograph taken like this?”
The girl stood, shook her head like a horse about to run free, and let the robe fall away from her shoulders. “I appreciate art,” she said.
The session took two hours. The girl was a natural. She even managed to get the drape to hang as if the wind were blowing around her—and she sustained that pose for a good five minutes.
Roz went through every one of her plates.
Jack, whose attention wandered mid-way through, took care of the three customers who came to the main studio. His voice would filter in, and Roz felt a stab of envy. She didn’t want to be alone with this girl. She would rather be taking sedate portraits of matrons who believed it was time to step in front of yet another infernal machine.
Roz had asked him to put out the closed sign, but of course he hadn’t. Jack had a penchant for risks, particularly unnecessary ones. They made his heart beat faster. Risks also excited other parts of him, which Roz didn’t mind.
She almost wished the girl had held his attention, instead of being such a flinty manipulative little shrew. The girl had questioned each one of Roz’s orders, but performed with a smile whenever Jack spoke to her.
Jack tired of this first and left. Roz had to endure it for the entire session.
“Get dressed,” Roz said.
“Are we done?” The girl seemed almost disappointed.
Roz nodded. “If I wait much longer, some of this work will be lost. I have to process these plates quickly. They can’t sit.”
“I thought they’ve come up with a new process, one that allows the plates to be shipped without being developed.” The girl had grabbed the robe.
Roz frowned. The feeling that she was being used rose again. Most people knew nothing about the current state of photography. The dry plate system intrigued her, but she hadn’t seen it yet.
“The process has made its way to New York City,” Roz said. “It won’t come to these parts for months, maybe years.”
And she didn’t even want to discuss the cost. The new process would require a new camera, new and different plates, and time to learn how to use them. All things she did not have.
The girl slipped off the stage, leaving her clothes behind. She held the robe closed with one hand. “I don’t suppose you have a chamber pot down here.”
The only chamber pot in the entire building was upstairs, in Roz and Jack’s bedroom. She wasn’t going to let that little minx in there.
“You’ll have to go out back,” Roz said. “I suggest you put on your clothes first.”
“There isn’t time,” the girl said and slipped through the curtains.
Roz cursed under her breath. From now on, she was going to pick the subjects for the art photography. Jack might claim he had a better eye—and he probably did for the female form—but Roz could spot a fellow con artist a lot quicker than Jack could.
She set the last plate in the box, wondering how long it would take before she had to rescue her husband from the girl’s unwanted attention. Maybe she would let Jack get himself out of it. After all, he had found the girl attractive at first.
But not in the end. In the end, he had been as disgusted with the girl as a man could be.
Roz took pity on him. He was no match for that girl, and Roz didn’t to spend the remainder of the afternoon in the theater.
She was reaching for the curtain, when a female voice cried out, “What is the meaning of this?”
That voice did not belong to the girl. Roz parted the curtain ever so slightly, careful not to let the ripple make itself noticed inside the studio.
A stout, middle-aged woman in black bombazine was standing on the woolen rug. She had both hands on her ample hips and she was staring at Jack.
Roz stared at Jack too, and suppressed a grin. He looked terrified.
But the girl on his lap—the naked girl on his lap—arched her back, shoving those glorious breasts in his face. Only she wasn’t looking at him. She was smiling at the woman.
“Hello, Mama,” the girl said. “Care to join us?”
“Emmeline!” the woman in black bombazine said, unwittingly giving Roz information she didn’t want. “Put on some clothing.”
“But Mama,” Emmeline said in a voice that purred. “I can’t have fun with my clothing on.”
The woman’s face turned red, then purple. Roz had seen people have apoplexy before. Some had even died of it. She resisted the urge to race out from behind the curtain and calm everyone down.
“Ma’am.” Jack sounded panicked. “This isn’t what it looks like.”
“That’s right, Mama,” Emmeline said. “We only just got started.”
“No!” Jack started to stand.
Emmeline rolled sideways, and Jack reached for her, but if he grabbed her, his hands would have landed on those massive breasts. He must have realized that because he jerked back as if he had been burned. Somehow Emmeline managed to catch herself and remain on his lap all at the same time.
“Ma’am,” he said, trying desperately not to touch Emmeline, “I’m a happily married man. Right, Roz?”
Roz didn’t answer. She couldn’t rescue him this time. They’d lose a lot of money in plates and equipment if she did. He would have to come up with something on his own.
The girl on his lap stroked Jack’s chin.
“Roz?” Jack looked toward the curtains.
Roz cursed under her breath.
“His wife doesn’t seem to mind sharing,” Emmeline said.
Roz cursed again. The girl was even more manipulative than Roz had originally thought.
The woman in black bombazine had turned an alarming shade of puce. She started forward. She had an umbrella in her right hand. Roz hadn’t seen it before because it had been hidden behind the wide and unfashionably hoop skirt. The woman was brandishing the umbrella as a weapon.
“Roz?” Jack’s voice trailed off. He seemed to realize that she wasn’t coming to his aid.
He glanced around the room. Emmeline snuggled closer to him and that seemed to decide him.
Jack stood.
This time Emmeline fell to the floor, banging her elbow against the wood and letting out a string of epithets that made Roz blush.
“Ma’am,” Jack said, holding up his hands to ward off any umbrella blows. “Your daughter made advances to me, just a moment ago. You see, initially, she had come in here to have her portrait taken.”
“You make innocent girls take off their clothing for portraits?” The woman brandished the umbrella over her head. But Emmeline froze. Roz stared at the girl. Something was changing here.
“Um, no,” Jack said, and to Roz’s surprise, he was blushing. She had never seen him con anyone with a blush. She was the one who could do that. Jack’s blush had to be real.
Or maybe it was simple panic. She’d never seen him panic while standing still before. Usually his full-blown panics happened on the run.
“Actually, ma’am,” Jack was saying, “she came in here asking me to take an artistic portrait.”
The woman paused, holding her umbrella over her head like a scythe. “An artistic portrait?”
“Yes, ma’am. You know. The kind that French portraitists paint.”
“Naked portraits? You create naked portraits?”
“For married women only, ma’am. Often they take such portraits for their husbands to enjoy. In private.” Jack was finally getting into the spirit of this.
Roz glanced over her shoulder at the plates. She was running out of time. She had fifty wet plates of a naked manipulative girl drying in a box behind her, wet plates that had to be developed soon or they’d be ruined forever. Thank heavens Jack had already taken another box-load of them into the development room to start the process.
“What kind of man would take naked photographs of his wife?” the woman asked.
Every man who could get away with it, Roz thought. As if that old biddy didn’t know.
“Soldiers, generally, ma’am. Men who are heading out on the frontier. They need something to remember home by so…so…” Jack was casting about for a reason. His gaze darted toward the curtain. He still wanted Roz to rescue him. “So that he won’t go astray.”
Roz rolled her eyes, but the woman eased her umbrella down. She looked at Emmeline, who was now cringing on the floor. Roz had no idea why the truth—or the partial truth—would cause Emmeline to be frightened, but there it was.
“Is this true?” the woman asked Emmeline.
Emmeline grabbed the robe, then held it in front of her. Jack could still get a good look at her backside, although he wasn’t even trying. That proved to Roz that he found the girl unappealing.
“Well?” the woman asked.
Emmeline swallowed. “I thought maybe this time Father would notice me.”
Roz gasped. Jack looked stunned. The woman swooped down and grabbed Emmeline by the arm. Instead of finishing the sentence, the girl let out a loud yell as her mother pulled her upright.
“I have had enough of you,” the woman said in a low tone. “You will get your clothing and get dressed. I will take care of you at home. As for you, young man—”
And as she turned to Jack, her voice rose. She still hadn’t let go of her daughter’s arm.
“—you will take me to your so-called art portraits and we shall destroy them. Together.”
Jack’s mouth dropped open. This time, he looked directly at Roz who slipped even farther behind the curtain. Her fists were clenched. All that money, gone.
“Um, ma’am,” Jack said, his voice trembling. “I’m out time and money—”
“I will pay your expenses plus a handsome sum more so long as you never refer to this incident again.”
Roz leaned toward the crack in the curtain. A handsome sum more?
“How much is handsome?” Jack asked.
“Five hundred dollars. In gold.”
Roz clasped her hands together. They were rich!
“Over my expenses.”
“Yes,” The woman sounded angry. Roz prayed Jack wouldn’t anger the woman further. He had a talent for ruining a good thing.
“All right.” Jack almost—almost—smiled. He caught himself just in time. Roz started to step away from the curtain so that he could bring the woman into the theater, but he didn’t. Instead, he went into the development room.
The man was smarter than she gave him credit for.
Roz sprinted back toward the cameras. She took the drape and tossed it over the box of wet plates (please let them last a few moments longer!), and then grabbed Emmeline’s clothes. They were made of silk. Roz should have noticed that before, but she’d been concentrating on the girl’s face—on that look of triumph and manipulation.
Roz hurried out of the curtains, then caught them with her free hand so that they wouldn’t wave and draw attention to themselves. Emmeline was still sitting in the middle of the floor, clutching her robe. She looked like she was about to burst into tears.
Roz tossed her clothes at her. Emmeline opened her mouth and Roz put a finger over her own lips. Then she ran to the main door, opened it, and slammed it as if she had just come in.
“What’s this?” she asked as loudly as she could.
“Um, n-n-nothing.” Apparently, Emmeline didn’t have to pretend to sound frightened.
“I come home to find a naked woman in my studio,” Roz said, and then caught herself. All of her nouns and pronouns were wrong. Home was upstairs and as far as the city was concerned the studio belonged to Jack.
“Mrs. Donnelly, I’m really sorry,” Emmeline said.
“Get dressed.”
“Yes, ma’am.”
The sound of breaking glass stopped both of them from play-acting. Anger shot through Roz. She’d spent two hours getting those portraits. The old biddy had no right to destroy them.
Emmeline bit her lower lip. Roz took a step closer to her and whispered, “Don’t say anything about that theater.”
Emmeline’s eyes widened. “Really?”
“Really.”
To Roz’s surprise, Emmeline hugged her. “Thank you.”
“Thank—?”
The door to the developing room opened and Emmeline dropped out of the hug as if it had never been. She grabbed her clothes and was halfway into her shift before her mother came out of the room.
The scent of chemicals followed her, and the anger threaded through Roz again. Who was this woman that she felt she could just destroy anything that got in her way?
“You are this man’s wife?” the woman asked in that preemptory tone.
Roz wanted to retort with You’re this creature’s mother? but somehow didn’t think it appropriate.
“Yes,” she said.
“Do you know that he takes nudie photographs in this studio?”
Roz faked a blush. She felt the heat rush through her face and she whirled on Jack who was standing directly behind the old biddy and grinning.
“You what?!?” Roz made herself sound as indignant as possible.
“Honey bunch,” Jack said in his best fake hen-pecked husband voice. “It was an accident…”
He continued to make up his false excuses as Roz walked toward him. Emmeline’s mother grabbed her daughter, flung the dress over Emmeline’s head, and then dragged her from the studio. Emmeline’s shoes and stockings were on the ground where Roz had dropped them.
“…so I hope you’ll forgive me, darling,” Jack said with the biggest grin Roz had ever seen. He held out both hands. They were filled with gold coins.
Roz bent over to touch them. She had dreamed of holding wealth like this, but the dream had never come true.
The door opened back up and Emmeline walked in. Her dress was on backwards and her face was tear-streaked. Her mother stood in the doorway.
“You promised,” she mouthed to Roz, then she bent down, grabbed her shoes and stockings and hurried out of the studio.
“Promised what?” Jack asked as the door closed.
“That I’d develop the rest of the photographs,” Roz said.
Jack leaned forward and kissed her. “Roz, sweetie,” he said when he was finished, “you really are the brilliant one in this relationship.”
Yet that comment didn’t make her feel brilliant. Jack was still up to something, and she didn’t know what that something was.
When she finally got to their upstairs apartment, tired, aching and stinking of chemical washes, Jack was waiting for her in the living room.
Naked.
“Jack, I’m tired, I’m hungry, and I’m a bit annoyed at you. This is not the time—”
“Baby, I had a naked girl on my lap, breasts shoved in my face, and you were watching the entire time. Besides, that old biddy could have shut us down and instead, she made us rich. Any of those things would have excited me, but all three together….” He pulled her close. “This, my love, is an opportunity you do not want to pass up.”
He kissed her, and she leaned into him, as she always did. He was right; the afternoon had been oddly erotic. She had just forgotten about it in her haste to develop those photographs.
It had always been this way with them—from the moment she saw him, she had wanted him, even though she had not understood the feelings at the time. She had eloped with him, and learned that instead of growing weaker, that pull had grown stronger.
Afterwards, they lay on the quilt on top of their bed, spent and exhausted. Roz had no idea how they’d made it to the bed, only that they had ended up there.
Jack had been right. This had been an opportunity she would have regretted missing.
“Who would have thought,” Jack said, his head tilted back, eyes closed, “that Norma Trager would have had five hundred dollars in gold on her person?”
Roz blinked.
“I don’t think I’ve ever met anyone who carried that much money with them. Do you think she knew what Emmeline was about and planned to pay us off? Maybe she had more money. Maybe I settled too soon.”
“Norma Trager?” Roz asked.
“Oh, yes. She probably has more than she needs. After all—”
“Norma Trager?” Roz’s voice rose. “You knew her name?”
Jack propped himself on one elbow. “Didn’t you recognize her? You’re the one who specializes in the gossip columns.”
He was lying. She could always tell when he was lying. His voice smoothed out and he got a slick little smile that didn’t quite reach his eyes.
“No,” Roz said. “I didn’t recognize her, and neither did you. You knew who Emmeline was before she came into the studio. In fact, you planned this little scam, didn’t you?”
“Roz, I would never plan anything without you.”
Another lie, as they both knew. “This time you were scamming me, weren’t you?”
He sat up. “Roz, it’s not like that.”
“Oh?” she said. “Then why didn’t you tell me in advance?”
He slipped off the bed, moving out of her reach.
Roz pulled the quilt around her and took a deep breath. “All right,” she said. “Tell me everything, so I know just how much trouble we’re in.”
“We’re not in trouble,” Jack said as he put his clothes back on. He wasn’t looking at Roz, and she knew which part of the sentence he had left out.
They weren’t in trouble yet. But they would be. Roz wasn’t sure how, but she knew they would be.
He didn’t say anything.
Roz sighed. “Damn,” she said. “Now I’m going to have to destroy a whole day’s work. You could’ve told me before I saved the plates.”
“Don’t destroy them,” Jack said.
Emmeline had asked her not to destroy all of the wet plates either. Finally Roz was getting to the heart of the matter.
“Why not?” Roz asked. “We can’t sell them. Norma Trager bought your silence for five hundred pieces of gold.”
“She didn’t say we couldn’t sell them.” He looked innocent. “She just said we couldn’t talk about them.”
That was true. Norma Trager had said that, thinking all of the portraits of her daughter were destroyed.
“What’s the scam, Jack? Tell me now or I swear, I’ll find that little con artist and have her tell me herself.”
“No.” He looked even more panicked at that thought. “Roz, believe me, this is a good thing.”
She stood and went into the living room in search of her dress. This was not a conversation to have naked.
“I do not believe,” she said as she picked up her shift, “that anything you call a good thing is, indeed, a good thing.”
“Please, Roz.”
She slipped on the shift and dropped the quilt, then grabbed her dress. It was fine, although the buttons from the waist down had fallen off. She was lucky she hadn’t stepped on any of them.
“Roz.” He had come into the living room. His pants were buttoned, but he still hadn’t put on a shirt. His flat and muscular chest, lightly dusted with hair, made her want to touch him again.
She turned her back on him and fingered the ruined dress.
“All right,” he said. “I met Emmeline a few days ago—”
“Oh?”
“Don’t start, Roz. You know I don’t do that sort of thing.”
She brought the dress up to her face to hide her smile. It was hard to be mad with him when he was being sincere.
“Anyway,” he said, “she knew I was a photographer. She waited for me outside. She asked me if I took artistic photographs.”
The girl had studied her subject. Roz picked up her stockings and her shoes, which had toppled together like drunken sailors.
“I told her I did. Then she asked me if I knew of Robert Millard. Well, who hasn’t heard of Robert Millard, I said. She gave me a strange little smile and said that he was her father.”
Roz set her shoes, stockings and ruined dress on the sofa, and walked past Jack into the bedroom. She made sure she didn’t brush against him. If she had, she would have had to touch him, and at this moment, that would have been wrong. He had to think she was mad at him.
Jack turned and watched her, arms crossed, his muscles standing out in sharp relief against his naked skin. “I laughed. I said everybody knows that Millard has five sons and no daughters.”
Roz raised her eyebrows. If Jack knew it, then indeed, everyone knew it. Jack was right; usually she was the one who read the gossip rags. He ignored them.
Although, she supposed, he knew about Robert Millard because of his wealth. Jack always knew who the richest and most influential people were in any town.
“She nodded. She said that her mother had been his mistress and when she got older, he cast her off like an old shoe. They still got money from him, but she wanted love.”
“Love?” Roz grabbed her dove gray day dress out of the closet. “She expects love from her father because she poses in the nude? This is one sick family, Jack.”
“She gave up on love a long time ago,” Jack said. “She really just wanted him to acknowledge that she was his daughter. She figured that if she forced the issue, he’d have to acknowledge her.”
“She was going to blackmail him?” Roz asked.
“I think so. Acknowledge me or I’ll tell everyone who I am.” He waved a hand. “Or maybe she’s just going to ask him for money. I don’t know.”
Roz shook her head. People did not know how to run a proper scam any more. “She’s impulsive and dumb. This plan is guaranteed to get him to ignore her. Why would he acknowledge a daughter who acts like that?”
“That’s why she wants me to sell the remaining photographs. I’m her leverage,” Jack said. “You did make one more portrait, right?”
“Yes.” Roz slipped the dress over her head, then mentally cursed the choice. It buttoned in back.
Jack came over to help her. His deft fingers brushed her shift.
“Well, I’m supposed to make sure he gets a photograph and knows who it is.”
Roz slapped his hand away. “You won’t do any such thing.”
She turned. He was frowning at her.
“Some day you’re going to have to acknowledge that I’m the brains of this operation,” she said. “If you go in there with that portrait, he’ll have you arrested on some kind of charge. Pandering or something. Forcing women into prostitution. You can’t do her dirty work.”
“Well, she can’t,” he said. “He won’t even let her near his bank. She’s tried. He’s thrown her out before.”
In spite of herself, Roz was thinking about this. Dammit, Jack always did this to her. He gave her a puzzle and, if she caught him in time, she got to solve it in ways that benefited both of them.
“Jack,” she said, turning her back on him again so that he could finish buttoning her. “How do you feel about the City of Kansas?”
“It’s a nice city.” He’d been saying that from the beginning. But he never sounded thrilled. Jack was a rover. He had only settled because of her and her studio.
“Would you be broken-hearted if we left?”
“I always want to be with you, Roz.” He patted her back, his signal that he was done buttoning her up.
“I mean it.” She turned again, and found herself trapped between his arms. “What if we left Missouri altogether?”
“And go where?”
She shrugged. “I don’t know. New Orleans, maybe. We have a lot of artistic photographs that we haven’t sold. And if we pack up our equipment, we might be able to start anew somewhere else.”
His eyes lit up. “But you like it here.”
“Not really,” she said. “The locals aren’t that interesting. Everyone else is just passing through. Besides, I’m getting tired of taking portraits of matrons and their broods. I’m not cut out for the working life.”
“I could have told you that, babe,” he said, brushing her lips with his.
“I had to learn it for myself,” she said.
“I trust you have a new plan?”
“No,” she said, “but I’ll have one soon.”
Roz wasn’t a crusader, and she really hadn’t liked Norma Trager. The woman pretended at morality when in reality she had been some man’s mistress and borne him a child out of wedlock. Of course, Roz might have misjudged her. A woman usually didn’t want her daughter to make the same mistakes she did—and Emmeline Trager was on the road to making if not the same mistakes, then some that were even worse.
But there was one thing that Roz really liked in a man and it was the one thing that Jack had. Loyalty. He loved her, he respected her, and even though his eye wandered, his heart didn’t. She was the center of his life.
As it should be.
Obviously, Richard Millard had no center to his life. Casting off a mistress was one thing (and not really one that Roz approved of), but casting off a child was another thing altogether.
If Roz could get him to acknowledge his daughter, then her work was done. If she made a small profit in the bargain, she wouldn’t complain.
So that was how she found herself outside the First Pioneer Bank of Missouri, wearing a new gray morning dress and a hated corset beneath it. Her hair was in a bun at the back of her skull, and that bun was hidden beneath a black lace net. She wore gray gloves on her hands and gray boots on her feet.
She looked as prim and proper as she could, considering that inside the thick embroidered bag she carried was a portrait of Emmeline Trager in the nude—a portrait that Roz had carefully constructed to be as…artistic as possible.
She took a deep breath, knowing that anyone watching would think her nervous. What she was trying to do was work herself into a state and time her blush so that she looked angrier and more grief stricken than she was.
Since the third man in a row held the large oak door open for her, Roz decided it was time to go inside. She nodded at the man, thanked him in a tone that perfectly imitated Norma Trager’s sounds of indignation, as she stalked through the door.
Men seemed to have a finely tuned sense of when to avoid a woman. The bank’s customers moved out of her way as if she were Moses and they were the Red Sea. The town’s newspaper editor watched her from his position near the polished table. Two cattle ranchers hurried out the door. A third settled into a chair near the back as if getting ready to watch a show.
She clutched the embroidered bag to her chest and approached one of the gilded cages. The teller leaned backwards as if he could avoid her
“I would like to see Robert Millard,” she said.
“I’m sorry, ma’am,” the teller said. “Mr. Millard sees people only by appointment.”
Behind the teller, another man—this one rotund and officious—watched with ill-disguised interest.
“He’ll see me,” Roz said.
“Ma’am—”
“Tell him it’s about his daughter.” She said that last loud enough for the entire bank to hear it.
The teller frowned at her and was about to tell her what everyone knew: that Mr. Millard didn’t have a daughter. But the officious man in the back understood a problem when he saw it.
“Come with me, ma’am,” he said as he let himself out of the cage.
He led her through a carpeted hallway, past oak doorways with names emblazoned in gold letters. She had to work to keep the smile off her face; the buzz of conversation behind her convinced her that the first part of her ploy worked. The bank’s customers hadn’t been aware that Millard had a daughter, but they were now. Even if they thought the daughter was hers.
The man stopped at the last door, held up a finger, then disappeared inside the room. She heard a faint shout, a word that most men would have considered imprudent when spoken around a lady (fortunately for Millard, she was no lady) and then the officious man appeared again.
“He’ll see you now.”
No announcing of her name, no asking of her name. Just a simple invitation inside. The officious man held the door for her, then left the room so quickly that she wouldn’t have been surprised to see a foot on his nether regions, propelling him forward.
The man behind the desk was standing. He was tall and imposing, with a shock of gray hair and bushy gray eyebrows. He glowered at her and she resisted the urge to grin at him. But she had a role to play.
“Mr. Millard?” Again, she used the tone she had learned from his former mistress. Deep, formidable, and disapproving.
“What is this about?”
“Mr. Millard,” she said, “my name is Rosalind Donnelly. My husband owns the photography studio on A Street.”
“I have never been to that studio,” Millard said, making it very clear what he thought of photography and her Irish last name.
“No, sir, you haven’t, but your daughter has.”
“I don’t have a daughter.”
There it was. The hypocrisy she had been hoping to avoid. She felt the outrage she had been pretending only a moment before. Roz reached into her bag, grabbed the portrait, which she had had the forethought to frame and slammed it on his desk.
“My husband tells me this is your daughter. Is that true?”
Millard looked down and his face flamed red. “Where did you get this?”
“I found my husband developing it.” She crossed her arms. “Mr. Millard, we both understand that men will be men, particularly when provoked. I want you to keep your daughter away from my husband. If you do not, I’m sure I can find other portraits of her. My husband said she was quite eager to be photographed—as he puts it—artistically.”
Millard grew redder as she spoke. Sweat ran down the side of his face. He continued to stare at the portrait as if he couldn’t believe it existed.
“My husband is a God-fearing man, Mr. Millard. He has sworn off this practice before. It is the reason we moved to the City of Kansas which, we were assured, was a moral and decent place to make our home. Instead, we discover that young women prefer to be photographed in a state of undress.”
Millard’s mouth worked, but he said nothing.
“I have it on good authority that your daughter approached my husband. He did not approach her. She has led him back down a path of sin, which is between him and his God. But between you and me, Mr. Millard, is this young woman yours? Because if she is—”
“What do you want?” He forced the words out as he reached for the portrait and turned it over.
“Only your assurance that this girl will not venture near our studio again.” Roz took a step forward, looming close to him, as his former mistress had done to Jack. “You do have control of your daughter, do you not?”
“She, um. She…” He reached into his breast pocket, removed a carefully folded linen handkerchief, and dabbed at his forehead. “She lives with her mother.”
Roz froze as if she were in shock. “You and your wife no longer share a home?”
“My wife and I are quite happily—blast, woman! You’ve put me in a delicate position.”
Roz’s chin went up. Her entire body straightened and she forced the flush into her own face. “Are you telling me, sir, that your daughter is illegitimate?”
Maybe Roz had pushed that statement too far. But she couldn’t take it back. Besides, all the morally righteous women she’d ever met were given to melodramatic turns of phrase.
“Ma’am, it was a youthful indiscretion and she—”
“Are you telling me you have had no hand in raising that child?”
“My wife knows nothing of her,” he said and she could actually hear pleading in his voice.
“Well, I can assure you, Mr. Millard, that will change.” Roz grabbed the portrait. She made her hand shake. “This girl is a menace to decent society. Someone must control her before she does even more damage.”
She shoved the portrait into the bag and headed toward the door. He wasn’t stopping her.
Dammit. He was supposed to stop her. Now what was she going to do? She couldn’t very well go back to the studio. Jack had sold it just that morning.
“What do you expect me to do?” Millard’s voice was soft. She almost didn’t hear it.
She stopped. “Apparently nothing, Mr. Millard. Don’t worry. I shall take care of this.”
“I am worried, Mrs. Donnelly. A man of my reputation—”
“Should think things through before he makes a mess of them.” Now she turned, slowly, hoping he would take the glee in her eyes for anger. “After all, we both know men will be men.”
His gaze met hers. He seemed to be appraising her. “Yes,” he said, “I guess we do.”
They stared at each other for a long moment. Finally, his gaze returned to the desk, where the portrait had been.
“What, exactly, can I do, Mrs. Donnelly, to prevent you from talking with my wife?”
Roz straightened. “You should control your daughter.”
“Yes, ma’am.”
“But of course you will not. So this will happen again. And my husband seems to be the person she has chosen to lead down the path of inequity.”
Too thick. She was going to have to stop frequenting vaudeville.
She touched her hair with a shaking hand. “My husband and I have relocated because of this problem before. I’m afraid we’ll simply have to do so one more time.”
She turned, hoping—praying—Millard would stop her again.
“Ma’am,” he said. “I’ll pay you for the portrait.”
“What?” She put that frosty tone back in her voice. “My husband and I have agreed not to sell these evil things any more. If he discovers that I have done so—”
“I can’t expect you to give it to me to keep it out of the wrong hands. I’ll buy it from you. Call it a loan. So that you can restart your business in—”
“The West,” she said. “We will be taking the next train out.”
“Yes, ma’am.”
“I do not take bribes, Mr. Millard.”
“It’s not a bribe, Mrs. Donnelly. I would like the portrait, and I am certain that you will need funds to make your fresh start.”
She bowed her head. “I did not come here for this.”
“I know that, ma’am.”
Roz had a hunch he had done this before, paid money to keep talk of his former mistress and daughter quiet. He would do it again if he could.
“I will take your loan,” she said, walking back toward him, still clutching the bag. She wouldn’t relinquish that until he gave her the money. “But I will repay it as soon as I can.”
“I’ll draw up a note, then, ma’am,” he said.
It took all Roz could do not to look at him in surprise. Apparently, he had believed her.
“So we have to pay him back?” Jack sounded indignant. He was leaning on the railing, staring down at the water of the Missouri. The paddlewheeler had left port an hour ago, with all of Roz’s camera equipment, some new clothes, and a lot of money in gold coins sewn into her shift and Jack’s vest.
“No, silly,” Roz said. “He thinks we’re heading west. I even told him what train we’d be on.”
“We need new names again, just in case,” Jack said.
“We need them anyway,” Roz said. “I trust you’ve been selling the daguerreotypes.”
“Not yet,” Jack said. “Someone might know her. She doesn’t need that stigma.”
As if Jack were worried about Emmeline. “Still afraid of her mother, huh?”
“For a former sexpot, she wields a mighty umbrella.”
“Well,” Roz said. “She won’t come after you. She’ll come after me.”
Jack turned toward her. “What did you do?”
Roz shrugged. “On the way out, I saw the editor of the local paper. I gave him one of the daguerreotypes and told him that the portrait was of Mr. Millard’s daughter, that she had it taken so that the entire town would be scandalized and he would have to pay attention to her.”
Jack seemed shocked. Roz had never seen Jack look shocked before. It gave her a heady sense of power.
“Why would you do that?” he asked.
“It’s what Emmeline wanted,” she said.
“Roz, you hated Emmeline.”
Roz moved away from the railing. No sense standing so close to the water when she was weighted down with gold coins, coins she hadn’t—technically—stolen.
“Of course I hated Emmeline,” she said with just a hint of a smile. “But she’s an adult. And she did want her father’s attention. Now she has it.”
Jack shook his head. “Be careful what you wish for because Roz might give it to you.”
She took his hand. “I’ll give you what you wish for, big boy.”
“All I want, my darling Roz,” he said with a rakish grin, “is a little bit of your attention.”
“A little bit?” she asked.
“Forget what I just said.” He bundled her in his arms and lead her to their stateroom. “I don’t want a little of your attention. I want all of it.”
“Mmm,” she said, opening the stateroom door. “What a demanding husband.”
“Be happy,” he said. “I could be like Millard.”
“No, you couldn’t,” she said, pushing the door closed and grinning at her husband. “Not if you want to live.”
Artistic Photographs
Copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn RuschPublished by WMG PublishingCover and layout copyright © 2023 by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © alanpoulson/Depositphotos
To Get a Free AI Audio Version of this blog, click here.
The initial title of this post was “Fighting The Future.” It came from a quote that I spent about a half an hour searching for. I had hastily scrawled the quote on a piece of paper while doing a dozen other things the past two weeks, but I didn’t cite the source. All I know is that the quote came from something I was reading, but what, exactly, appears to be lost to the wind.
I suspect the quote came from a book called Oscar Wars: A History of Hollywood in Gold, Sweat, and Tears by Michael Schulman. The book is a dishy, but well-researched history of various parts of the Academy Awards. A lot of the book deals with the history of organizations from the Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences to the Writers Guild and beyond.
Many of these organizations came about in times of great technological change, because the creatives whose careers were going to be impacted by these changes wanted protection. In other cases, the creatives whose careers were impacted by the changes wanted to carve out the future, in a way that would help them dramatically.
It’s not always young creatives who are creating the future. It’s established creatives as well. Sometimes those of us who’ve been in the business for a while can see the future more clearly than those who are just stretching their artistic wings.
We’ve been through some of these wars before.
It’s also possible I had seen the quote in some of the coverage of the current Hollywood writers strike. All I know is that when I read the quote, I felt not only inspired, but I also felt the speaker’s sense of frustration.
The quote went something like this: No matter how hard you try, you can’t fight the future.
It’s a negative quote—You can’t—and I really didn’t want to go with that.
It’s true, though. You can’t fight the future. It will come for you, and it will come in unexpected ways.
Those of us who have lived through the past eight years know that very clearly. Things started to go off the rails for many of us in the United States in 2015. Other countries were off the rails before that, and some seemed to be chugging along just fine until 2020.
Then the future clobbered us. Hard. Thought things would go your way? The future asked in its best villain voice. Try adding a pandemic to your calculus.
Some of us eventually did add the pandemic to our calculus. The past always holds the key to the future, but not in ways that people expect.
People expect a road map from the past. A kind of if you do things this way, then that will happen. And oddly, in publishing, it remained like that for about forty years. That period of stability, in publishing in particular, was greatly unusual.
Stability isn’t the human condition. As the pithy little saying on this morning’s cereal box reminded me, the only thing we can count on is change.
Sadly, the way that the past holds the key to the future is by giving us imperfect examples of what had come before.
I remember vividly telling damn near everyone I knew that if we follow the road map set by the flu epidemic from 100 years ago, we wouldn’t see the end of the pandemic phase of Covid-19 for three years.
And I was right, almost to the day. What I didn’t say, though, was that protected communities—those that completely quarantined—got struck by later stages of the pandemic. Other places had built up immunity, but these isolated communities hadn’t, so they went through their own pandemic hell, some as late as seven years after the first case of the flu showed up in North America.
As I said, imperfect, and just a guideline. But still, something to look toward.
This week, The Washington Post had an article titled “The WGA strike is part of a recurring pattern when technology changes.” The article explored everything from the arrival of kinescope to television to streaming, and showed how, when technology changes, the industry had to change with it, whether the industry or the creatives who worked inside it like the changes or not.
Ironically, this article landed on the same weekend as a huge variety of scare headlines about AI. “AI is as big a threat as nuclear war!” screamed one. “AI’s creators are afraid of it!” screamed another.
And a dear clear-eyed friend on Facebook talked about ChatGPT and noted that we’re watching the world change. He also noted that we will see a lot of denial about it. Farther down the thread, he noted that we can’t stop the change, but we can figure out how we’re going to use it.
That’s the point of the scare headlines, by the way. They’re not wrong. In the wrong hands, AI will destroy everything we know and love, maybe even destroy the planet, if our science fiction colleagues from decades past are to be believed.
But that’s because these things—from AI to virtual reality—are tools. Tools are apolitical things. A hammer can assist with building a wall or it can tear down the same wall, depending on which part of the hammer you chose to use. But it can also kill someone, quite quickly and easily, with either side of the hammer.
In the wrong hands, quite literally, a hammer becomes a murder weapon.
I learned this lesson early, with words. My family was all about words. Words can create worlds. They can make a child feel loved. Words can also humiliate someone or even destroy them. Words are a tool, and that tool can be as destructive as a hammer to the head.
At Clarion, thanks to another clear-minded friend, I learned that I had learned the weaponization of words all too well. I had to learn how to speak kindly. I almost wrote all over again but that would have been wrong. I had to learn how to use words kindly in spoken speech for the very first time.
It is a learning curve, and it’s one I work on every day. (I also occasionally feel the urge to destroy with words—and I do, if confronted by a bigot (and my brain catches up to the situation quickly enough). I now use the weapon when a weapon is needed, and not in every day conversation.)
Commenters on my first friend’s Facebook post pointed out that the AI genie is out of the bottle, and our job now is to use these tools wisely and regulate them properly.
Yes, that will not stop the determined person who wants to misuse the tools, but it gives us resources to solve the problem.
Better folks than I am working on ways to control this part of the future. As I mentioned in “Lessons from the WGA Writers Strike” a month ago, the WGA is trying its best to prevent AI from destroying lives and livelihoods.
The sad thing is that it will not be 100% effective. It will get the best deal possible and negotiate a few points away that will cost someone a job somewhere. That’s one of the sad things about technological advancement. It will create jobs, sure, but at the cost of others.
This weekend as well, Neil Clarke issued the first draft of a position paper for the publishing industry, particularly the genre industry, to use. He’s frustrated that the publishing industry (particularly the genre organizations) have been slow to respond to this changing dynamic, so he is starting the ball rolling.
He’s asking for helpful comments. If you go there to pick a fight, you will be sent away.
We’re at one of the early stages of this particular change. It’s not the only change we’re going through. The pandemic caused a lot of unanticipated change. Climate change is also going to force many of us to change the way we live—not just how we live, but where and what we consider to be important in our futures.
There are a lot of other changes like that, some local, some regional, and some international. (The pandemic was unique in that it was completely global. Not even last century’s world wars were 100% global.) I suspect the world of 2035 will be completely unrecognizable from the world of 2015.
The future is inevitable. We need to face that.
Or, in the words of the now-lost speaker in the lost article, We can’t fight the future. We can’t, because we’ll lose.
I’ve been thinking about that as well, as I read all of Dean’s posts on being a new writer coming in. He spoke at two writers conferences this year, and each time, he realized that the new writers are getting conflicting and often bad advice from both the traditional and indie publishing industries.
He has written ten posts (so far) on the conflicting information. Start with this one, and then search for the others. They’re not always well marked.
Writer Ron Collins took on Dean’s posts in a post of his own. (Oddly, I agree with both Dean and Ron.) Ron has taken to labeling traditional publishing “Dependent publishing” and independent publishing as …well, independent publishing. It’s Ron’s phrase “dependent publishing” that really caught me, though, because that’s what it is.
Writers in the past were forced to rely on traditional publishers to get product out. The writers who are struggling the most with all of the changes are the ones who liked being dependent, the ones who liked having someone else take care of that messy business stuff. It really didn’t seem to matter to those writers that the people taking care of the messy business stuff often took advantage of that writer, never fulfilling any promises, skimming money off the top (which still goes on), or actively embezzling.
Nor did it seem to bother those writers that their career of “being taken care of” would have a short lifespan. Most “dependently published” writers, to use Ron’s phrase, back in the day had a career that lasted at most ten years.
Those writers never could figure out how to stop the inevitable decline of their fortunes. Only a handful of writers—and I do mean a handful; I can count them on one hand—who wanted to be taken care of had a career that lasted twenty or thirty years. That was a happy accident, usually caused by a lottery-style windfall that made all kinds of traditional publishers want a piece of that pie.
Thousands of other dependently published writers never went beyond the third book of their careers, although some of those writers still sell the occasional short story.
Still, though, there are hundreds of writers who want to get into that dependent publishing game. I no longer have pity for them, because the information on how to actually have a career as a writer has existed for a decade or more now.
Many of these writers stick their heads in the sand and will not listen to anyone tell them that their dream is not possible in 2023. Maybe if they’d started in 1990, they might have had a chance. Even then, they wouldn’t have lasted through the purge at the end of the previous century; most dependently published writers, especially those without business savvy, did not.
The writers with their heads in the sand aren’t really fighting the future. They’re fighting the present. Confront them with the possibilities—both good and bad—that the future holds, and they will bury their heads deeper. They’ll deny it all.
And honestly, they’re lost. They can’t be recovered. In some ways, they’re volunteering to be the ones whose livelihoods disappear (if they’re making a meager living at traditional publishing right now) or they’re volunteering to have their dreams destroyed.
It’s the writers who face the future who will survive. That’s why I chose this title. Because we might not understand what is coming at us. We might not even predict it all accurately.
But we are standing with our feet firmly planted in the present, aware of the way that the publishing industry (both dependent and independent) works now and we’re keeping a weather eye on all of those developments lurking in our future.
Yes, we’re guessing at what’s going to come. Many of us, like the Writers Guild, like Neil Clarke, are working to shape that future. Many others are figuring out where we will fit in what’s heading our way.
We can’t fight the future as much as we want to. History teaches us that. Those who deny that the world is changing or pretend the changes won’t have an impact on us will probably lose everything.
Those of us who understand that change is inevitable will survive. Those of us who are figuring out how to make that change work for us will do better.
Ron notes:
The chief development skill of an Independently Published writer, then, is listening. By that, I mean, taking in the thousand streams of information that seem to flow over them, and sifting out the wheat from the chaff.
He makes it sound so easy. It is for him. That was his training in his pre-writing career and it’s just his nature.
So many writers aren’t geared for listening to anyone. Others aren’t able to take “streams of information” and sift them. To many writers—heck, many people—sifting through information is impossible. It’s a learned skill, one that I discovered years ago when I hired really smart people who hadn’t gone to college.
I had not realized until then that the main skill college teaches isn’t some career path or how to take an exam. The main skill college teaches is the one Ron describes above: how to listen and then separate the wheat from the chaff.
People who have not had that experience or who rebelled against it and refused to learn it are not suited to an independent freelance career. Nor are they suited to any kind of career that lacks a set path with definable goals.
Writing used to have a set path with definable goals. Those goals weren’t easy to achieve, but they were understandable. Now it’s a choose your own adventure, which suits people like me. I like living that way, and I like trying to anticipate the future.
Most people don’t, though. Most people find this way of living very stressful.
I’ve come to the conclusion over the decades that some writers just need to be taken care of more than they need a writing career.
The rest of us, though, need to plant our feet in the present, turn our back on a past that never treated us very well in the first place, and face the future, whatever it might bring.
For a long time, Dean and I have tried to teach writers how to face the future. It isn’t just standing and staring at it. There is some active planning involved, even if that planning turns out to be somewhat wrong.
We’ve finally put that planning into an online class called “The Decade Ahead.” You can investigate it if you follow this link.
In the meantime, let me remind you that this weekly blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynruschr4e to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: Facing the Future,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © Can Stock Photo / Gajus
Shelton believes flowers save people, so Ruth-Anne Grant’s demands that he remove her name from his floral delivery list appall him. Because it turns out the roses he spent his morning crafting came from her stalker.
Shelton, embarrassed and frightened for her, gives her the stalker’s name, thinking his involvement will end there. Only it doesn’t.
The police show up at his flower shop two days later, and they don’t care about a stalker. They want to catch a murderer. And they need Shelton’s help.
“Thorns,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
ThornsKristine Kathryn RuschIt started on an unseasonably hot May afternoon. The air was as thick as a Midtown July. I’d already brought the exotics inside—much as I hated to since exotics lured the casual buyer, the out-of-towner, the newly arrived, soon-to-be-jaded Manhattanite. Exotics were what they expected from the city. Something unusual, something strange, everything they wanted available for a price.
The shop’s interior was as cool as it could be with the front door open. In the summer, I kept the air at frigid, but I didn’t have the budget for that in May. So I had the air at luke-cool and kept the misters running. The plants would survive a day or two of this, and if the weather stayed the same, I’d have to spring for the extra electricity.
I was rearranging everything when she came inside. I saw her in the big round shoplifter’s mirror I’d installed long about 1985: before then, I thought that my mirrored cases protecting the most fragile blossoms would give me enough reflection to prevent the occasional theft.
Then, I was naïve enough to wonder who would steal plants. After all, resale was hard. But four teenagers with their eyes rolling inside their sockets from some drug I couldn’t identify, waving semi-automatics and shouting, Mister, hey, Mister, open the goddamn cash register, changed my focus on security forever.
She peered through the fronds of an apartment fern, bumped a bucket of past-their-prime rosebuds, and somehow managed to knock over—and catch—some pansy starts I saved for the locals who liked to put them in their window boxes.
I watched her work her way to the counter, not liking the long white box she carried under one arm. She slammed the box on the counter and looked around, hoping to find someone who would answer questions or take a complaint. I sighed as softly as I could, left the calla lilies I’d been shearing for a funeral in the Village, and headed toward her, trying not to let my reluctance show on my face.
She was slender and almost pretty, with honey brown hair that marked her as a non-native New Yorker. Her lower lip was chapped—either she bit it too much or no one had taught her about Chapstick—and her skin was that blotchy pale most white New Yorkers managed to sustain year-round.
She shoved the box at me. It was long, and dented, with a dirt stain on the side, as if it’d been thrown or dropped onto the street. A gold sticker with the shop’s name in italic script held the box closed.
I touched the edge, felt the familiar ridged cardboard, wondered if I’d find the roses I customarily put inside or something else, something worse.
“What can I do for you?” I asked, pretending I hadn’t noticed anything out of the ordinary.
“Don’t send me any more of those.” She shoved the box again. Her hand was shaking. I got the sense that her anger covered a deeper emotion, one I couldn’t yet identify.
I slipped my finger between the box’s lid and its interior, felt the softness of tissue paper, just like I would have expected from our store. With a single movement, I flicked the box open.
A dozen white roses, an expensive item at this time of year. They were wrapped in red tissue, just a smattering of baby’s breath behind them, and some green fronds to give it all color.
A beautiful package. I’d worked on it myself. I had tied the white silk ribbon around the stems just that morning.
“You don’t care for roses?” I asked.
“I don’t care for him.” She shoved the box a third time. It slid halfway off the counter, and I had to catch it before the flowers spilled onto the floor.
“Ma’am, this is probably something you should take up with the gentleman—”
“I would if I could,” she snapped, “but I don’t know who he is. He’s stalking me.”
I felt the fine hairs on the back of my neck rise. I fumbled inside the tissue for the card I remembered placing there.
I found it. One of the simpler ones with green leaves running along the side.
My heart is true, it said in my handwriting.
“You’ve seen him. You tell him to leave me alone.” Her trembling had moved from her hands to her face. Her eyes filled with tears and she blinked angrily. Her lashes got wet, but the tears didn’t fall.
“I’m sorry,” I said. “I didn’t see him. This was a phone order.”
I knew that much from the fact that I had written the card.
“Taken with a credit card?” she asked.
“Probably,” I said. “I would have to check.”
“Well, don’t take any more, especially not for me.” She whirled, stumbled into one of my taller orchids, and grabbed the pot as if it were a lifeline.
I came around the desk, balanced the orchid and put a hand on her back. Her muscles were rigid. She pulled away from me, glaring at me as she did.
“I’ll do what I can,” I said. “I’ll need your name and address just to make sure.”
She nodded, wiped a hand over her face, then mumbled, “Ruth-Anne Grant.”
“Miss Grant, I’ll make sure he doesn’t send you any more flowers from here. Would you like me to give his information to the police?”
She blinked. I saw her expression clear as the idea reached her mind. I knew what she was going to ask before she asked it.
“Can you give the information to me?”
“Not his credit card information,” I said. “I do have a name, though. Would you like that?”
“And a phone number?”
I wasn’t sure of the ethics of that. “For that, I’d have to talk to the police.”
She nodded, expression tight. “The name then. The name’s a start.”
I moved the orchid away from her, then went back to my desk. The desk was in the back, near the workstation I used for more elaborate orders. The easy orders I prepared out front so that customers and passersby could watch if they so wished.
There was a large glass window that opened into the store, so that I could see the customers, and above that, the images from several security cameras that I bought last year.
Ruth-Anne Grant wandered through my orchids, touching the fragile blooms despite the signs that warned her not to, and looking at the other plants that covered every available space in the store. Outside, a young couple holding hands examined one of the apartment-size palm trees that stood just under the awning.
If this were a normal afternoon, I would have gone out and asked them if they were interested in a plant to liven up their home. But it wasn’t a normal afternoon. Ruth-Anne Grant’s revelation had made certain of that.
Twenty years ago, I gave up my law practice to open a flower shop. I had discovered that I wasn’t tough enough for the law, but I loved plants. I thought of flowers as a way of delivering joy or comfort. I spent extra time on bouquets for lovers, and when I designed funeral arrangements, I tried to give them a special touch, so that the bereaved would see the sympathy I had for them.
I never thought my gift would be used to terrorize someone.
My fingers were shaking as I sat behind the desk. My computer slept, the dark screen running the shop’s logo against a backdrop of lilies.
I used the mouse to wake up the machine, then I went into the day’s order files. I searched by recipient. My software was so well designed (thanks to a former lover) that I found Ruth-Anne’s order quickly, even though I’d had a very busy morning.
The information rose in front of me like a rap sheet. The flowers were ordered by a Dwight Rhodes, and he paid with a platinum American Express card. He lived in Soho. I recognized the address as one of the newer coops that had sprung up in recent years.
There was nothing in his information that would have made me suspicious. I didn’t even wonder why he came to my shop, which was nowhere near his home. A lot of people walked past here on their way to work; I would simply have figured if I had even thought about it at all that he was one of them.
As a double-measure, I checked Ruth-Anne Grant’s address. She lived in the Village, one of those twisty neighborhoods with funky apartments and a lot of local color. I wondered how Rhodes had first seen her—whether they worked near each other, or had stumbled into each other at some restaurant.
I checked the in-store window. Ruth-Anne was waiting by the counter now, leaning away from the roses as if they might poison her.
I scrawled his name down, then shut down the program before heading out front.
“Here,” I said, handing her the paper, not wanting to speak his name aloud. “This is the man who ordered your flowers.”
She stared at the paper for a long time. She had stopped shaking. In fact, she seemed calmer now than she had when she had entered the shop.
Outside, the couple shook their heads and walked on. A woman wearing black fondled the wisteria I had wrapped around a clay statue. A man leaned against a lamppost, drinking bottled water, and watched her examine the plant.
“Could you tell me anything else?” Ruth-Anne had looked up from the paper. The blotchiness had left her skin. Now it was just pale. I could see exhaustion in her features, exhaustion so deep I wondered how she could function from day to day.
“I just don’t feel right giving you anything else,” I said. “I’m not even sure I should have given you his name.”
“Just tell me this,” she said. “Does he live in Manhattan?”
I nodded.
“Near me?”
I figured I could give her that much. I shook my head no.
“Is he Uptown or —”
“I can’t,” I said. “Really. I’ll talk to the police. I’ll give them everything they need. Just send them in here, and they’ll take care of it.”
Her mouth closed, her lips tight over her teeth, almost as if she were physically holding the words back. She took a deep breath, obviously gathering herself, and then she extended her hand.
“You’ve been a lot of help. I’m sorry I was so upset when I came in.”
I took her hand. She was so thin that I could feel the bones beneath her skin. “Anyone would be under the circumstances.”
She nodded, then slipped her hand out of mine. She headed toward the front of the store.
I scurried around the counter, and said, “Wait.”
She turned.
I grabbed a small pot of pansy starts. “Here,” I said. “Take this.”
Ruth-Anne frowned. “What for?”
“I just—don’t want you think of flowers as bad things. These’ll grow in your kitchen window or on your balcony. If you let them, they’ll take care of you all summer.”
She studied them for a moment, just like she had studied the paper. Then she took them from me.
“Thank you,” she said and she smiled. The smile gave her a bit of life, made me see what she had been like before this entire ordeal started. “I had forgotten how kind people can be.”
And then she left.
I stood among the pansy starts for another ten minutes, just staring outside my shop. The misters came on once, caught me in their spray, and eased some of the heat. People wandered by on the sidewalk, sometimes touching, always admiring the plants.
The man, leaning against the lamppost, finished his bottle of water, and went inside the deli next door. A teenager skateboarded by, leaping off the curb so that he avoided my display.
I went back to my arrangement, but my heart wasn’t in it. Instead, I grabbed the roses from the box, removed the damaged ones, and put them in a bucket of water.
I grabbed a sign from my desk drawer—Free. Take one—and taped it to the bucket. Then I put the bucket outside.
As I did, a woman who looked wilted from the heat stopped in front of me.
“Free?” she said. “Really?”
“Really.”
She picked up the most perfect rose and rubbed it against her cheek, her eyes half closed.
“Thank you,” she said. “Thank you.”
And then she walked away.
I smiled, feeling better. Then I went back inside, feeling refreshed enough to give everything I had to finishing the funeral arrangement before my delivery guy showed up.
The police arrived two days later.
Rain had broken the heat, and spring had returned to the city. My shop door was open, like it had been during the heat wave, but now cool breezes blew through, albeit cool breezes smelling of auto exhaust and garlic-ginger from the Asian-synth restaurant on the corner.
I knew from the moment the two men entered the store that they weren’t customers. My customers browse. They touch leaves, sniff flowers, run hands lovingly on clay pots. These men strode in, coats flaring behind them. Plants trembled in their wake.
I watched from the counter, my finger hovering above the panic alarm I had installed after the teenager incident. If the men tried anything, I’d press the button and a siren would blare. I would use that moment to duck and run to the back, hoping I could make it out of the store before the men realized where I had gone.
They were both white with black hair and chiseled faces that would have been attractive if they hadn’t had such hard lines. Broad shoulders, muscular arms, and beneath the coats, the bulge of shoulder holsters that hid guns.
The taller one reached me first. He had a flare of gray at his temples that softened the hard edge. If I had met him in a bar, I might have bought him a drink, hoping for some conversation before we had a dance or two. But I could tell from his posture that he was the kind of man who would never dance with another man. The only way he would enter the bars I frequented would be by accident.
“Mr. Shelton?” His voice was deep, authoritative. I jumped in spite of myself.
My hand trembled over that button, even though I knew at that point that this man was not going to rob me. “Yes?”
He flashed a badge at me. I struggled to see it clearly. My finger remained near the button.
“I’m Detective Whittig. This is Detective Barret.” Whittig indicated the shorter man who had stopped behind him. They both stared at me.
My hand had moved away from the button.
“May I see your badge again?” I asked, glad that my voice sounded calmer than I felt.
Whittig opened the badge wallet and I peered inside. It looked official enough.
“What can I do for you?” I asked.
“Two days ago, you ran a stolen credit card to pay for some flowers.”
I probably did that more often than I realized, but no cops had ever visited me because of it.
“No credit card company has contacted me,” I said.
“They wouldn’t.” The second detective, Barret, had one of those dry voices that sounded sarcastic even when he wasn’t trying to be.
“It’s common procedure to have a stolen card denied,” I said, “or to be contacted by the credit card company if the transaction is unusual. Two days is a long time. I would have heard.”
“Maybe normally,” Whittig said, “but this isn’t normal.”
“Perhaps you’d better fill me in, then,” I said. “Why wouldn’t I have heard?”
“Because the cardholder is dead,” Barret said. “He couldn’t report it missing.”
I frowned. “Even so, the credit card companies monitor transactions. They should have noticed something unusual.”
“There’s nothing unusual about buying flowers from a neighborhood vendor,” Whittig said. “I’m sure someone would’ve noticed the card was missing, if it’d been used more than the once. But it wasn’t. It hasn’t been used at all since two days ago.”
“So how do you think I can help you?” I asked. “Would you like me to look up the record? If the card was stolen, I probably won’t have much you can go on.”
Barret looked pointedly at my mirrors and the single camera hidden behind an extremely well-tended spider plant. “Maybe you got video of the person who used the card?”
“Two days ago?” I nodded. “I keep the tapes for months.”
“Holy Christ,” Whittig said to Barret. “Someone who actually follows the security company’s directions.”
“I’ve had a few bad experiences,” I said. “I do everything I can to make sure I don’t have any more. If you give me a name, I can look up the transaction, see what time it occurred, and give you the pertinent video.”
Whittig nodded. “Let’s do that.”
He glanced at his partner. Barret didn’t seem to have an objection.
“His name was Dwight Rhodes,” Barret said.
I froze for perhaps a half second, maybe less. It felt like an eternity, like I had guilt written all over my face. Guilt and fear and something else—something I hadn’t experienced in a long, long time.
Horror. I felt horror.
“Rhodes,” I said, somehow managing to keep my voice even. “Dwight.”
“Yes.” Whittig was watching me. “Do you know him?”
“If he shopped here, he was an acquaintance.” I retreated to primness. “The name doesn’t ring any bells.”
I hoped they couldn’t see the lie.
“That’s R-O-A-D-S?” I asked.
“No.” Barret used that dry voice again. “R-H-O-D-E-S, like rhododendron.”
“All right.” I sounded just a little too hardy now. They had to know something was up. “I’ll check that for you. The main order computer is in the back.”
“Mind if we come with you?” Whittig asked.
“Actually,” I started to say that I did, then I stopped myself. Much as I wanted to look this information up alone, I didn’t want two police officers in the front of my store discouraging business. “I don’t mind at all.”
I led them into the back. It smelled of greenery, of the lilac shipment that had just come in as well as the last of the Easter lilies. Bouquets, some half finished, littered my worktable, and two orders still waited for customer pick-up in their white floral boxes.
I tapped the computer, hoping I was wrong about the name, that it wasn’t the one I had given Ruth-Anne Grant. The detectives leaned over me, crowding me. I could hear their breathing, raspy and out of sync.
I found the records from two days before, and of course, there it was, the name, Dwight Rhodes, big as life. His Soho address was there, along with his phone number and the stolen credit card.
“That’s it,” Barret said unnecessarily.
I opened the file, revealing the order, the time it had come in, and when I had processed it.
Whittig swore. “Phone order.”
I sat there, unable to move. My mouth was dry. I had given this man’s name to Ruth-Anne Grant. She had been in bad shape.
She had thought he was her stalker.
And now he was dead, with detectives here, following up.
“Can we have a printout of that anyway?” Barret asked.
The printout would lead them to Ruth-Anne Grant. She was the one who got the flowers; she was the one who returned them. Even if she hadn’t done anything, she would still tell them about her visit here.
About what I had done.
I used the key controls to hit print, and heard my printer snap to life a few yards away. The detectives had turned their attention to it; I was no longer of any use to them.
“I take it,” I said, wishing that I could banish the primness from my voice forever, “this Rhodes was murdered.”
Both detectives turned back to me, identical movements, bringing them closer and adding to that claustrophobic feeling.
“Didn’t we say that?” Barret asked. “I thought we said that.”
“We might have said he was just dead.” Whittig’s tone told me that he knew full well what they had said, that it had been deliberate.
“So he was,” I said. “Murdered. In the last two days. Right?”
I was still staring at the screen. Both men were reflected in it. They looked at each other over my head.
“What’s it to you?” Whittig asked.
“Because,” I said, the primness finally gone, my voice shaking. “I might have made a big mistake.”
“You knew him?” Barret asked.
“I don’t know,” I said. “I don’t know if I ever met him. But I gave his name away.”
“His name?” Whittig sounded confused. “To who?”
The printer beeped. The paper had run out. I stood, grabbed some paper from the storage shelf, and put it in the paper tray. Then I manually restarted the printer. The order spit out, quickly and cleanly.
I handed it to Barret, and pointed to the sentiment on the card.
“I gave his name to Ruth-Anne Grant,” I said, wishing I didn’t have to say anything, wishing this had never happened. “She thought he was stalking her.”
It felt like I had passed a death sentence on someone, like I had been the person who had stood up in a large theater, pointed at a woman I’d only met once, and shouted, “Unclean!”
I could tell just from the looks on their faces that the cops thought they had their killer. Hell, I believed it too. The coincidence was too much. I’d learned a lot about investigations and coincidence and the ways crimes were committed in my old job, and I knew the odds favored Ruth-Anne Grant over everyone else.
They were going to talk to Ruth-Anne, and they would push her and poke at her, and make her say things she may not mean. And she would no longer be the victim of a stalking. She’d be the perpetrator of a crime.
I stood and went back to my computer, feeling like I hadn’t had any sleep. Detached, tired, empty. I shuffled across the floor, and brushed against tables, nearly knocking over a globe filled with late-season forced narcissus.
I caught it, held it, feeling the bubble glass in my hands. It would be so easy to crush the globe, feel the bulbs and squeeze them to death as well.
Life was so hard to cultivate, so easy to destroy.
I set the globe on the rough-hewn antique table I used for my more fragile vases.
The door opened and I whirled, careful to miss the tables this time, although I brushed part of a palm and broke off a branch. For half a moment, I feared the cops were back.
They weren’t. Stan, my delivery driver, stood in the doorway, looking at me with great annoyance. He was young, early thirties, and had visions of being a Broadway star.
He had the beauty for it, but not the chops. I’d seen him off-off-off-Broadway, and he was so wooden that I was embarrassed. Still, one couldn’t fault a man for his dreams. And with the money he earned from this, and his two other jobs, he paid for lessons at one of the acting academies on the upper west side.
“I knocked in back. Pounded in fact, and you didn’t even bother. I’m half an hour behind now. I couldn’t leave the truck back there and you know how hard it is finding parking up front.”
“I’m sorry,” I said. “The cops were here.”
He flushed as if he were the one they were after. “Cops? You okay?”
“I don’t know,” I said, surprised that I made the admission. I never talked much with Stan. He was too attractive, too young, and frankly, a bit too dumb for me. I didn’t want to get involved in anything more than the employer-employee friendship we seemed to already have.
“Nobody broke in, did they?” He had been driving for me when those kids came in with the shotguns. In fact, he was the one who helped me clean up the store.
I shook my head. “One of my customers was murdered.”
I guess I could call Dwight Rhodes that, even though I knew he had never really been a customer. At least, not voluntarily.
“Damn, boss, I’m sorry.”
I nodded, and decided that I had to move.
“I only have three deliveries this afternoon,” I said, and hoped it was true. I couldn’t remember any of the orders I’d taken. Everything left my brain when the police came through that door. “But if you finish early, check with me one last time. I’m a bit frazzled.”
“No kidding.” He pushed his way past the line of herb starts I kept for the locals. “I’d be too.”
I knew I could trust him to check back if he had the chance. Stan was good that way. He’d been one of the best employees I ever had, even though he wasn’t technically just mine. When I realized that I didn’t have enough business to pay for all his delivery runs, I got together with a few other smaller shops. We shared Stan as our delivery driver. It covered his vehicle costs, and it took the burden off our small businesses. None of us counted him as an employee. We all paid him under the table, and he took care of his own costs.
Of course, the only price we paid on that was a future one: If Stan ever got that Broadway job he dreamed of, we’d lose him in the space of an afternoon.
I followed him into the back. He grabbed the largest arrangement, a clichéd spray of carnations and greenery for a funeral, and carried it to the truck. I followed with the daisy basket I’d made for an upscale boutique and the delicate vase filled with the palest pink roses I had.
We loaded up the truck and he left, after checking to make sure I was all right.
I said I was, and even I believed the lie. Until I found myself in the back, staring at the damn computer. I wasn’t looking at the missed deliveries, even though I had promised myself I would.
I was doing something I should have done that very first day, when Ruth-Anne Grant crossed my threshold.
I should have run a search on her name, seen how many other deliveries she got from me, and who had sent them.
The computer found five, spaced over five months. They came at the same time on the same day of the month, as if the guy had a ritual.
And of course, each name who sent the flowers was different from the last. The bouquets were different too, and so were the prices, almost as if this mook knew how much was on that credit card he’d stolen and how much he could spend without getting caught.
Roses in May, hyacinths in April, tulips in March, a mixed bouquet in February, and an expensive bonsai—one I had nurtured for nearly a decade—in January. That one broke my heart as if this stalker had attacked me personally.
If Ruth-Anne Grant knew the bonsai was from the stalker, she had probably thrown it out.
All that work, all that love, lost.
Just like Dwight Rhodes was lost.
I did another search, this time for the names on the credit cards, to see if the stalker had used them more than once. He hadn’t, and they had never shopped here.
Then I printed out the Ruth-Anne Grant order files. As they chugged out of my too-slow ink jet printer, I studied them. Phone orders each one, each with a romantic message, each sent anonymously.
And those dates…
They weren’t really enough to let a woman know she had anything more than a secret admirer. What made a woman think she had a stalker? Frequent, persistent attention. Phone calls. Letters. Gifts.
Many, many gifts.
And clearly this guy wasn’t one who liked face-to-face contact. He ordered with false names and left no fake name on his deliveries.
The only other things I could tell about him were obvious: he had opportunity to get other people’s credit cards without them reporting the theft to the credit card companies, and he knew his flowers. He bought what was in season.
Frequent, persistent gifts. Once a month wasn’t frequent enough, and Ruth-Anne Grant’s anger made me think the flowers were a theme.
Persistent. That much was clear. But smart enough to cover his tracks over and over again. With the credit cards, with the names, with the anonymous messages.
I gripped the papers, still hot from my printer, and sank into a nearby chair. Ruth-Anne Grant hadn’t been lying about the stalker.
I whirled in my chair, grabbed the phone, and dialed Flowers by the Book, a boutique book and flower shop nearby. We shared Stan, and I liked to talk to the owner, Odele Page, an opinionated woman in her mid-fifties.
I explained the situation, leaving the murder and the police out of it, by saying that I thought maybe a client of mine had a stalker, and would she look up the client’s name, see if she had anything on file with anonymous cards, and fax me the information?
She offered to do it then and there, on the phone. I cradled the receiver between my ear and my shoulder as I moved around the back, too stressed to stay still. I checked the mirrors and the door, making certain I was alone.
All the while, I listened to her computer system beep and ping, her fingers tapping lightly on the keys. She would sigh and then sigh again, and finally she gasped.
“Ruth-Anne Grant,” Odele said, and recited the address.
I stopped between the blue vases and the white ceramics I bought from a local artist. “That’s the one.”
“I’ve sent her something the first week of every month since December.”
“On an exact date?” I asked.
She paused for a moment, and I heard the sounds of keys again. “Looks like as close to the third as possible.”
Mine were around the twelfth.
“Can you fax me the information?” I asked.
“I don’t know,” she said. “It seems private.”
“The only private thing on there is Ruth-Anne Grant’s address, and I already have that,” I said. “The rest has got to be stolen credit cards and false personal information.”
Still, Odele hesitated.
“Look, Odele, all I’m going to do is give this information to the police. I hope that they’ll go after this guy, whoever he is. Can I at least tell them to contact you?”
“I’ll fax you,” she said, and hung up. I smiled. I had figured she might respond like that. Odele was, after all, a typical former hippie, aversion to the police and all.
Odele wasn’t my only phone call. I contacted all the other florists who shared Stan. A few of them hadn’t heard of Ruth-Anne Grant, but a few others had, all of them near my neighborhood, all of them boutique shops like mine.
Each shop had its particular day, and they were close enough that I began to get a sense of what Ruth-Anne Grant had gone through. She was getting flowers every day of the week, anonymously, for five months—the December offering from Odele being the first.
It was also the most unique: a holiday package of greens, mistletoe, and holly around a large poinsettia. Along with the plants came a bag of Christmas cookies from a nearby bakery, and various teas from all over the world.
But the centerpiece was Odele’s specialty, a large-sized, stunning gift book that she had first bought for the previous Valentine’s Day: Elizabeth Barret Browning’s Sonnets from the Portuguese, with illustrations by well-known New York gallery artists.
Love poems, and love art, along with flowers, sweets, and tea. Anyone would have been happy to receive a present like that. And the first offering would have seemed marvelous—a gift from a mysterious admirer, perhaps even someone Ruth-Anne Grant thought she knew (and secretly hoped cared for her as much as she cared for him).
Over time, though, as the gifts became routine, as she started asking her friends and colleagues who sent them, Ruth-Anne Grant must have realized that the presents which had given her so much pleasure had a sinister undertone to them.
A bell tinkled in the main part of the shop. A young man, no more than twenty-five, stood between the orchids and the eucalyptus, looking lost. He wore a black suit—a Ralph Lauren knock-off by the way it gathered at the seams—and a pale pink shirt. His tie combined both colors in just the way a sales clerk might think was attractive.
He didn’t have a lot of money, then, but he had a job that required others to think he had.
I sighed and set down the faxes from the various shops. Normally, I would have bounded into the front room. I loved helping customers.
One of my simple pleasures, which might now be gone. Because as I stood in the back, my fingers stained with the ink from my cheap fax, I found myself wondering who this man, this new customer, wanted to hurt.
I helped him anyway. I made myself smile as I walked out of the backroom, and I questioned him like I would any other new customer. We talked about his sister, the one with MS, and how much she loved flowers. We talked about his critically ill mother, who was worried about his sister’s care after she was gone, and we talked about his budget, which, as I expected, was tight.
Normally the conversation would have been enough for me, but my mood was so odd, my discomfort so great, I flirted with him—not obviously, but just enough to let him feel the personal interest.
He finally pulled out his wallet and showed me his sister’s latest picture. She was younger than he was—high school, still—and cute in that fresh-faced way most teenagers had.
As I studied her, as I saw that spark of intelligence in her eyes, mixed with a touch of sadness, I realized I had seen a lot of family photos over the years. I was nosy and intrusive and garrulous, and while most of my customers liked that, a few never came back because they didn’t want the conversation.
I handed the wallet back to the young man, undercharged him for two arrangements of spring flowers—one for Mom and one for the sister—and sent him on his way.
Then I stood near my cash register, trying to identify what I was feeling. It was the edge of an idea, a memory, a thought that I had nearly captured just a moment before.
When I was looking at the photograph. When I was realizing how I interviewed all of my new clients.
I would never have sold that bonsai over the phone. I always made it a policy to hand-sell special items, to make certain the customer saw them, and approved of them.
I had talked to him.
He had told me whatever story he had made up–or had he made it up? Had he convinced me of his delusion, that there was some special woman out there for him, some woman he was trying to impress, some woman that he loved?
What would I have told him? Bonsais needed nurturing, a tough hand but a gentle one. Bonsai’s weren’t for everyone, but the person who appreciated them had a botanist’s heart.
I wished I had found out more about Ruth-Anne Grant. Something about her, or this sick creep’s fantasy of her, convinced him to send her flowers. Convinced him—convinced me—that she deserved a plant that required a commitment.
I shut down the register, and hurried to the back, stopping in front of my stack of videotapes.
I had January.
All five weeks of it.
My hand shook as I looked for the date, and when I found it, written across the label in magic marker, my heart nearly stopped.
“Gotcha,” I said as I pulled the tape out of the pile. “You son of a bitch, I’ve got you now.”
And the hell of it was, I remembered him.
As I watched the tape, images grainy and unfocused, not professional at all, I went back to that afternoon.
It was dark at 3. A storm had threatened all day, and finally hit, mixing rain, snow and sleet. I had stood near the window for a long time, moving plants, wishing the old building that housed the store had a better heating system and better insulation.
He had come in, black hair dusted with snow, a traditionally handsome man wearing a silk suit that looked, to my inexpert eye, like Armani. He had the body for the suit, broad-shouldered, narrow-hipped—legitimately GQ.
I’d let him browse a bit—sometimes the high-end types stumbled into the wrong store to kill a moment before a meeting—but after a while I realized he was actually shopping, and I went to help him.
He had flirted with me—it was visible on the tape, his hand on my sleeve ever so casual, the way he tilted his head so that he could look into my eyes, the slight smile.
I remembered him, not just because he fit my idea of gorgeous or because we had flirted, but because I had led him to the bonsais. I had talked him into it—for his lover. The lover he had described.
A man.
My hands shook as I searched for that original order form in my stack of faxes. Mine were at the bottom, of course. I should have looked for them there. And sure enough, the evidence was before me.
I hadn’t sent that first plant to Ruth-Anne Grant. No, it had gone to R.A. Grant at Ruth-Anne’s address. R.A. A deliberate lie.
None of the others were lies. Over the phone, he had ordered flowers for a woman. In person, just that once, he’d told me, convinced me, he was ordering for a man.
I sank into my chair. I no longer try to hide who I am. I learned that lesson long ago the hard way, when I was an upscale defense attorney with an infatuation for the civil litigator down the hall.
He had outed me, vindictively, one afternoon in a staff meeting. I had flirted without realizing what I was doing, hoping that no one saw my infatuation, hoping that no one understood.
And his outing was cruel, in an Upstate old-boys club, which, in the mid-eighties, wasn’t half as liberal as it thought it was. I wasn’t fired; I was shunned, given cases so obviously tailored to forcing me out of the firm that I should have fled in panic.
Instead, I decided to retaliate. I invited the litigator’s wife to lunch and, instead of eating with her, I gave her flowers. I still remember how her eyes lit up, the way she had smiled at me. It was clear litigator boy hadn’t given her flowers in a long time, and she found them special.
And at that moment, I realized I didn’t have it—the balls, the stomach, the cutthroat attitude that made the best attorneys. I couldn’t even avenge myself on a man who had made my job hell.
I couldn’t take that light from that woman’s eyes.
Instead, I decided that I couldn’t be miserable for the rest of my life trying to be someone I wasn’t and I gave it all up. I sold my house, my wardrobe and my life, and came to Manhattan and bought, on a whim, a flower shop, which I made my own.
Flowers saved people; flowers shouldn’t destroy them.
And somehow he—this stalker, this GQ man who was obsessed with another person without regard to that person—somehow he had known who I was, what I believed in, and he subverted it.
He used it, to play his little games.
Sometimes, with the memory of my past, I get a kind of clarity. Not an understanding of who or what I am—I know that deeply now—but a way of seeing the world, the patterns I had learned in law school, the ways that I was supposed to view the world in the adversarial system I had found myself in.
The pattern here, the one that I chose to focus on, was a simple one: In the beginning, this jerk ordered in person. I confirmed by looking at the various faxes I collected, and it was clear.
Like my bonsai, like Odele’s specially book-bound package, each of those first orders had been difficult, the kind of order that was almost impossible to make over the phone.
And because he wasn’t thinking like a criminal then, Ruth-Anne’s stalker had to have gone into shops he was familiar with. Maybe he had seen me around or talked to me before. I certainly would have flirted with him.
Odele’s store wasn’t far away, and neither were the others he had used. He lived near here, and he shopped near here, and eventually he gained a system, a system that involved stealing credit cards and using them to place the orders.
He had to have started that before he saw me, though, because the average Armani owner had no need to steal funds, and probably could think of a thousand other ways to cover his tracks. Like cash, for instance. Cash required no names, and wasn’t even remarkable. A lot of people paid cash for a bouquet, only to decide at the last minute to have that bouquet delivered.
And there were certainly enough flower shops in the Five Boroughs to keep a cash-paying stalker in plants for decades.
No, either he had stolen that outfit or—
I paused, frowned, and went back to my video. The graininess worked against me. I had been so concerned with this guy’s face and his expensive clothes that I hadn’t looked at his shoes.
Shoes were always the tip-off. Expensive shoes were much more comfortable than cheap ones, so even if a rich guy had no pretensions, he wore good shoes.
To my disgust, the stalker stayed behind tables and large plants. I couldn’t get a good image of the shoes—until the last few frames.
When he came over to pay for the bonsai, his shoes appeared briefly in the center of the image.
They were black. But I couldn’t tell if they had been polished or not—the tape was too dark. However, these shoes, these so-called expensive man’s shoes, had an interesting feature.
They had thick soles, nearly tennis shoe thickness, which implied rubber.
Only one group of people wore shoes like that with clothes like his. Waiters. Bartenders. Guys who were on their feet all day. Retail employees generally didn’t have to dress up. If they did, they got the shoes too because it was all part of the package.
Only in restaurants did guys have to wear the clothes without the matching shoes. Restaurants often ordered outfits for their staff, sometimes one or two, expecting them to wear the clothing on the job and near the building. But they never bought shoes. The waiters bought the shoes themselves, and of course, they couldn’t afford the expensive ones. They went to Jersey, shopped in Payless or Wal-Mart or Target, and bought shoes they could afford. Shoes with thick rubber soles so that their feet wouldn’t ache quite so bad at the end of the day.
And what else did waiters do? They whisked away credit cards in little leather receipt books, discreetly running the cards behind the bar or in a back room so that the restaurant patrons didn’t have hear the constant chugging of the computerized credit card machine, vomiting out receipt after receipt, authorizing dollars and deducting the amount from a pile of plastic.
An old client of mine used to substitute one credit card for another, giving him a few days of use before the cardholder realized that the platinum Visa in his wallet didn’t have his name on it. Ruth-Anne’s stalker could have done that, or he could have done something even simpler.
If he was a waiter, standing in the back of a restaurant, he could have copied the card number, the expiration date, and the name onto his order pad. Then he could have used those card numbers for phone orders with places like florists. We ran the cards, but we never checked that the person on the phone was the actual owner of the card.
We never checked because who, in their right mind, would steal a credit card and order flowers with it?
At least, that was the assumption. And like all assumptions, it was wrong.
I had a full presentation for Detectives Whittig and Barret when they returned: a print-up of the video image, right down to the shoes, faxes of invoices—all made out to Ruth-Anne Grant, a list of restaurants nearby that required its staff to wear silk suits, and a suggested theory as to what had actually happened.
I actually had her stalker’s name, but I didn’t tell them because I still knew a few things about the law. Any good defense attorney would make it impossible for the prosecutor to use evidence gathered by a citizen like me.
I had made a print of the best video image and showed it around. It only took me a few days to find Ruth-Anne Grant’s stalker. His name was Glenn Haines, and he worked at an upscale restaurant between my place and Odele’s. It was called Chez Nouveau.
Maybe I kept the name for security. Maybe I did it so that I could make certain that Whittig and Barret got the right guy. Or maybe I did it because I had an inclination to take care of the matter myself.
Even though I never did. That had been Ruth-Anne Grant’s mistake. They indicted her on first-degree murder charges the day before I handed over the stalker information. Whittig and Barret seemed so uninterested in catching the stalker that I thought at first they weren’t going to follow up.
But they did—not to find the stalker—but to solidify their case against Ruth-Anne Grant. While I’d been thinking like a defense attorney who would use the information to get a jury to acquit, Whittig and Barret were building a case.
If they could prove that Ruth-Anne Grant had a stalker, they had motive for first-degree murder.
Of course, Whittig and Barret never told me that. They just thanked me for the information, did the additional research, and arrested Haines. Then the District Attorney’s office, always smarter than I wanted to give them credit for, got an earlier trial date for him.
If he pleaded to the charge or got found guilty, they’d have a paper record for Ruth-Anne Grant’s motive.
And I couldn’t argue because I got Haines off the street. The only good thing in all of this was that Haines wouldn’t hassle anyone else. His stalking days would end—at least until he got out of prison.
But it hasn’t ended for me.
I dream about Ruth-Anne Grant sometimes. She never speaks. All she does is slam that box of roses down on my counter, and looks at me, as if I’m the one who stalked her, hurt her, and ultimately destroyed her life.
When I wake up, I try to tell myself that she made the choice. She was the one who didn’t do her research to see if Dwight Rhodes had sent her all those flowers. Instead, she had taken her gun and waited for him in the hallway, shooting him before he could even get close.
Her choice, not mine.
But those thoughts never comfort me. Because I remember how harassment feels, how it makes you so very helpless, and how stopping it seems impossible.
And I know how terror feels—not for weeks and months and years, like she went through but just for a brief instant, when those teenagers, waving those semi-automatics, came into my store and shouted, Mister, hey, Mister, open the goddamn cash register.
I haven’t been the same since. I still tense when a kid under twenty comes in, and I look over my shoulder when I lock up at night, and I keep my security tapes, long past the dates the security company says is necessary.
I know what terror feels like, and it makes me wonder what I would do to those kids if they kept coming into my store, never hurting me, always threatening me.
I’d never feel safe again.
And if I ran into them on the street—or, God forbid, some idiot told me their names, I couldn’t guarantee, even now, that I wouldn’t seek them out and give them a taste, just a taste, of what they gave me.
I used to believe in the law, until I realized that the people behind it—me and that civil litigator—were just as flawed as the people before it.
I used to believe in myself until I gave an innocent man’s name to a woman who wanted to kill him.
And I used to believe in the healing power of flowers until one unseasonably hot May afternoon, when I learned that even the most fragile blossom can be as potent a weapon as a locked and loaded gun.
Thorns
Copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
First published in Alfred Hitchcock’s Mystery Magazine, January/February 2004
Published by WMG Publishing
Cover and layout copyright © 2019 by WMG Publishing
Cover art copyright © Kamil Hajek/Dreamstime, Freud/Dreamstime
To Get a Free AI Audio Version of this blog, click here.
I’m not even sure I can describe the last few weeks of April and the first few weeks of May without using my calendar for help. I had a series of writing, publishing, and work deadlines. Everything in my Spanish class was geared toward the last month, from a presentation (yes, in Spanish, about a topic that I could give a flying rat’s behind about), to a paper (with a collaborator, see above about the flying rat’s behind), to a final (once again, flying rat’s behind [this class was not what I had hoped for]).
I also had some fun things planned—a couple of end-of-the-season runs and a musical (or two), as well as time with friends. Then I caught a “mild” cold which also hit in the middle of the worst allergy season that Vegas has seen in years because we actually had rain this winter. The cold left; the cough and some allergy symptoms remain…to this day.
(I Googled how long a cold’s cough can last and various medical sources tell me that a “lingering” cough post-cold can last from three to six freakin’ weeks. Oh, and try not to “force” the cough, because y’know, that’ll make it worse. And oh, yeah, those cough suppressants? They don’t work either? And…grrr. Just grrrr. And FYI, ragweed season is often 10 weeks long. Sometimes Google is not your friend.)
Oh, and then last week, I taught an in-person workshop on romantic suspense which was, I must say, an absolute blast. The students were fun and they laughed a lot and they challenged me and they wrote good stories, but I had to talk and that meant the occasional coughing fit (and no, Harvard Medical School, I did not “force” that cough; it was inevitable) which actually showed up in a few stories, so even though I fled the room, it must have been rather startling.
I took time off from my usual exercise during the workshop, except for my 12,000 step streak. I planned to resume my usual schedule after the workshop was over (which meant that Friday was off, and Saturday was on), and I figured that was enough.
But the Saturday run was too physically hard, so I stopped short of where I planned. Sunday, I decided to forgo the usual exercise, and I am reassessing the entire recovery plan.
I’m also near the end of a large book project and I have some things that were due a week or two ago that I really need to get to, so I’ve been busy that way, and when I’m not running, it takes much longer to get the 12,000 steps, but at least I get to catch up on my favorite podcasts.
I had to get this blog post done by today to fit into other people’s schedules, but I wasn’t willing to give up my fiction words so close to the end of this book. I have a list of blog post topics that I’m really excited about writing. So, I planned to write one of those.
I wrote my fiction words and would have written more, but I have these other deadlines to finish. Then I had some errands to complete. I got home and needed a dang nap, which worried me. Has the cold returned? Are the allergies attacking? What’s going on?
I got up, did a few laps around the building for my steps, and my little voice whispered, Y’know, you took one day of rest after the craziness that was this spring. One whole day. That’s not what athletes do.
And then the little brat added, Maybe you should write about rest for your blog post.
Okay, subconscious. Message received.
I know about athletic rest. I really do. I even know that it’s divided into two categories. They are short term or active rest and long-term recovery.
They’re not as self-explanatory as they sound. Active rest is the kind of exercise someone can do after intense exercise. So, say, you have a long run or do some incredibly hard training program. The next day, a short easy run or a walk might be in order or maybe swimming (but goofing around swimming, not hardcore swimming). Anything to move muscles but not continue the micro-tearing that heavy exercise can cause.
Long-term recovery is what it sounds like. But it’s not defined. It’s one of those wiggly things, as noted in an article on UCHealth (which is out of the University of Colorado Health Newsletter):
The duration of a recovery period depends on factors such as your age, sport, and training regimen.
Well, yeah. Duh. Okay. My age is older than most athletes they’re talking to. My main exercise is running, but I upped it this year to return to Pilates and train for a teeny tiny triathlon (seriously, it was a micro-tri. That’s what they called it). And then April, and May, and…yeah, okay. I’m doing a lot.
So, I got grumpy at the UCHealth article, and looked up recovery periods for runners. Not that these stupid things talk about runners in their sixties, mind you. They’re happy to tell middle-aged people that they’re past their running prime, but they can still enjoy it. And to inspire us with 90-year-olds who still run marathons. But the sixty, seventy, and eighty year olds? We’re invisible on these sites.
Anyway…
Runners World published an article in 2022 titled, Six Reasons Why Rest Days Actually Boost Your Running, and it actually contained this lovely annoying paragraph:
In other words, rest right, and you’ll run faster and be healthier. Skip it, and you might be forced to take time off due to an injury. Here’s exactly why you need to take a break sometimes to build a stronger—more rested—you.
And then, to add to my annoyance, Self had an article that listed six signs that your run day should be a rest day. What is with the number six? And enough already! I’m getting the dang message.
I went through the six signs and did an assessment. Those six signs are:
Okay. Okay. I’m getting the message. I need some rest.
But I applied these six things to the writing and the deadlines and found they only apply this way. I need more sleep. I’m not feeling stressed about finishing the book. I want to. I’m not even stressed about the other deadlines.
Plus…naps are possible during writing times.
So, yes. I need rest. I need to consume some storytelling in the form of novels and shows and movies. I am (obviously) no good at doing nothing.
But I am good at naps, and my cat Gavin is a great assistant on that part.
Plus, I have nothing scheduled for the next two weeks. (That’s totally weird.) I can go to Pilates if I want to. I can skip it if I need to. Hmmm.
And I need to get rid of this dang cough, which can’t be done actively (according to WebMD and its online friends). It must be done passively.
Okay, then, subconscious and blogs and articles and “experts.” Message received.
It’s time to rest and do things that recharge me.
And to realize that I had a heck of a busy spring. I suspect those “experts” would have told me that one day was not enough recovery time.
Dang it.
I really do prefer to be superhuman.
Even though I’m not.
“Business Musings: Rest,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © 2023 by Kristine K. Rusch.
He calls himself Ben…sometimes. Mostly he avoids thinking of his name so other people won’t remember him.
He kills people for a living, but he has standards. He uses astrology to help him follow the right path.
But when someone targets him, Ben realizes his methods might just get the astrologers who have been helping him killed.
“Ghosts,” by international bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here.
GhostsKristine Kathryn RuschIt goes like this:
Fifteen layers between him and the client. His people mostly, from the front that gets the order to the hacker who checks it out. Not everyone who wants to hire a hit man should be able to find him. That’s why there’s redundancy upon redundancy—for every hacker, there’s another who double- and triple-checks. After all, he’s not going to risk his life, his freedom, on the word of some nobody with a computer, a nobody he’s never met.
The order comes through the system—or systems if he wants to be more accurate—and if all the information matches, he considers the job. The timetable is necessarily flexible: anyone who wants a quickie goes somewhere else. Quickies get a man in trouble. Check the evening news. Any time a pro gets caught, it’s someone who specializes in quickies. Sure, they get top dollar, but they also take maximum risk.
He tries to eliminate risk. He’s Aries with Virgo Rising, Moon in Libra. Born for his job, at least according to his chart. Perceived as detail-oriented, almost fussy, a pain-staking perfectionist, he is at heart a warrior, brave, impetuous and independent. His true self, his emotional self, is a judge, coldly calculating, always striving for balance.
He has a superstitious side as well, and isn’t sure where it comes from. In the past, he tried to bury it, but he finally gave in ten years ago and his business improved.
That was when he discovered Glenna. She had a New Age bookstore in Sedona, Arizona, and an uncanny knack of seeing his future. The first time he entered her store, intrigued by a book in the window, she’d said from her table in the back, “Should I be afraid for myself, old friend?”
The question had both startled and intrigued him, and when he answered no, she smiled and said, “My chart was uncertain. It told me that today would introduce me to Death.”
He hadn’t heard of a chart, knew nothing about astrology except for the goofy write-ups in the newspapers, write-ups which never seemed to be about him. But she had encouraged him to have his chart done and after careful consideration, he’d given her his birth date, time, and location. She promised to have a reading for him in three days.
It was that reading which changed his life, and added one more layer between him and a job.
Now he compares his client’s chart, the chart of his intended victim, and his own chart, searching for the optimum day, the appropriate venue, and of course, any hint of failure. If he’s not compatible with a client, he passes the work to someone else. If his read of the victim’s chart makes the victim seem personally powerful, dominant over him, or just plain lucky, he passes on that job as well.
He has learned, through trial and error, that he is not right for every job, nor is every job right for him. His perfectionism serves him well, and protects him from his impetuous nature.
He has achieved balance which, for him, makes everything right with the world.
The balance starts to crumble on the fourth of May. He is in Los Angeles, using the name Carlisle because it intrigues him. He uses it as a first name because he has learned that people cannot remember an unusual first name. They remember what it sounds like—”I think it was Carl.” “No, honey. He called himself Lyle.”—not what it is. By the time the police are talking to them, he’s long gone, vanished like smoke in a strong wind.
He has his network of astrologers, mostly because he believes in back-ups, but he never has the network handle all three things—the client’s chart, his chart, and the victim’s chart. Only Glenna gets all three. She is his double-check, partly because she is so very accurate, and partly because he trusts her as much as he can trust anyone.
She has never worried about who he is or what he does. When she realized what he did for a living, she did not call the police as some would have nor did she suddenly fear him. Her manner toward him did not seem to change.
The afternoon he came for his reading, she greeted him with a smile. “My chart had been right,” she said. “I did meet Death yesterday, just not in the way I thought.”
It had been his first lesson about horoscopes and charts. When they were done by a true professional, like Glenna, they were incredibly accurate, although, at times, useless. Sometimes the language was too cryptic, too given to misinterpretation.
He learned, through trial and error, to plan his jobs based solely on things he understood—good days, bad days, luck, and the possibility of a future.
The victim’s charts were always the easiest to read. If they did not predict a major calamity within a year of the reading, then he did not take the job. He usually appeared in a person’s chart as a defining event or a crisis or as Glenna would say, “A possible ending.”
The first time she saw one of those in a victim’s chart, she made him swear he would not tell the victim.
“I can’t promise that,” he had said. “But I can promise that I will not give that person false hope.”
She had shaken her head at him, but had said nothing. That was when he had asked her why his work didn’t bother her.
“I never said that.” She folded her hands gravely over the victim’s chart. “I vowed, when I went into this business, that I would not judge.”
He did not tell her—indeed, he has never told her—that she made his work easier. He feels that is too much information. She probably knows it anyway, since she seems to know everything. But he does not want to take the risk of losing her. She is one of the few sure things in his life.
But he has never been long on trust, which is why he finds himself in a shop that smells of hairspray and plastic, just off Hollywood Boulevard, in the low-rent section of town. The shop has a giant hand in the window—the place is best known for its palm reader who is, in his opinion, a charlatan.
He comes for the astrologer, a pot-smoking eighteen-year-old who calls herself Elli May. She does a weekly or monthly chart for him whenever he comes to Los Angeles. The first time she saw his natal chart, she asked him if he was a cop or a private detective. She clearly lacked the life experience that Glenna had.
“I do work in enforcement,” he had said, and left it at that. From that point on, Elli May never questioned him. She also stopped offering him joints.
Her charts are deceptively simple. She uses a computer program which her younger sister designed. She has not customized a chart for him because he hasn’t asked her to. He wants to seem as normal as possible, given that he’s a hit man visiting a teenage astrologer to find out the best date for his next job.
The shop’s hairspray and plastic smell comes from the room deodorizer she uses to cover up the sickly sweet stench of pot. She hasn’t yet learned the value of incense. The palm reader should know—she’s old enough to be the girl’s grandmother—but she doesn’t seem to care. Or maybe she recognizes what the girl does not: that the only law he follows is the one he makes up himself.
“Hey ya,” Elli May says when she sees him. She pops a stick of Juicy Fruit and chomps, mouth open. “Didn’t think I’d see you today.”
Instantly his guard is up. She knew she would see him today. They have an appointment.
“Why’s that?” he asks, heading toward her tiny velvet covered table in the back.
Elli May shrugs. She’s not a very good liar either. “I’m not really ready for you today, Mr. Carlson.”
Here he’s Carlson, on the street he’s Carlisle. An easy mistake, he’ll tell someone if they ever ask. The names sound alike and he’s never bothered to correct her—no sense letting the girl know she’s wrong.
He slips into the chair, stretching his long legs and resting his hands on his stomach, pretending at an ease he no longer feels. “I think you’re ready. I think the chart shows something you don’t want to mention.”
She flushes a blotchy red. “I don’t—”
“You may as well tell me,” he says. “You gotta get used to telling clients good news as well as bad.”
The palm reader harrumphs behind him, then gets up and grabs her purse. “Want some coffee or something?” she asks Elli May.
“No,” Elli May says, her eyes big and pleading. He can read them, probably better than the palm reader can read palms: Stay. Please stay. He’s a scary man and I have bad news.
“Be back soon,” the palm reader says, and heads out. The door bangs behind her.
Elli May looks at him, and swallows, then coughs. He’d bet all the money in his wallet that she has just swallowed her gum.
“It can’t be that bad, kid,” he says, mostly because he wants out of here, but not without knowing what she knows. “Let’s get it over with and you can get back to your smoke.”
She squints at him, measuring him in an entirely different way. This is their last time together and she has just begun to understand that he knows it too.
As she slides around the table, she slips a hand in the pocket of her jeans and pulls out another piece of gum. She doesn’t offer him any. She takes the stick from the foil, and shoves the gum in her mouth.
Then she sits down, pulls open a drawer, and his chart comes out. It looks like all the others—a wheel with meaningless notations in the outer rim, more symbols between the spokes, and numbers in the inner rim. The numbers are attached by lines that all seem to bunch up in one area. Glenna once told him that this part of his natal chart shows all his strengths. He supposes it also shows his weaknesses.
Elle May sets the chart in front of him.
“Doll,” he says because he knows it’ll annoy her, “you’ve already read my natal chart. I asked you for this week.”
She wears rings on all of her fingers, including her thumbs, big cheap rings that hid her skin. She toys with one of them now, as if considering what to do next, then she reaches in the drawer and pulls out another chart.
Elli May calls this an action table, and in it are little boxes for inane things like “The Best Time to Take a Vacation” and “The Best Time to Obtain a Loan.”
He slides his hand under the new sheet and grabs the natal chart. He sets it on top of the action table and taps it. “Look at all that focus on the Eighth House. What is that again?”
“Finances,” she mutters.
“And secrets, mysteries, power, death, and transformation, right?”
She nods.
“Don’t fuck with me,” he says in a very flat voice. “You give me what I asked for and I’ll remember you’re just a kid who’s learning her job.”
Her eyes widen. She folds those ringed hands together. “I, um, threw it away.”
“I’m sure you did,” he says. “But you remember it.”
She bites her chapped lower lip. “Mr. Carlson, please, my aunt—” Apparently that was the palm reader “—she says not to tell everything. It’s not smart.”
“Usually it’s not,” he says. “But I’m not your average customer. Did you know that President Reagan, he had an astrologer?”
The girl swallows again, but as she does, she pushes the gum into her cheek where it becomes a bulging, unattractive lump. She’s too young to remember Reagan. She was born during his second term. He’s just a name from a dusty textbook to her.
“I’ll bet that astrologer told him he was gonna get elected the first time. But you think the astrologer tells him that something cataclysmic is gonna happen on March 30, 1981? Probably not. Afraid, you know, that he’ll get upset at the reading. So he don’t know he’s in any danger, any more than usual. That day, he gets out of his car, and wham! shot through the lung by a kid barely outta college. Lives, no thanks to his astrologer. And I’m sure that chart disappeared like nobody’s business, and the astrologer says ‘No one can anticipate such random events, Mr. President.’”
The girl’s blotchy flush gets deeper. He knows he’s got her. He had her with the word “cataclysmic,” but he went on because she was young and needed to hear the point. Not for him. He’s not coming here again—he doesn’t like working this hard, not with one of his people—but maybe for someone else.
Occasionally, he can be altruistic, although it always surprises him. He thinks it may come from his Rising Sign. Virgos are known to be helpful at times.
She reaches into the drawer a third time, and pulls out a computer-generated sheet filled with squiggles and symbols he does not understand. The week’s dates are running along the side, May 4-11. That’s the only part he recognizes.
He hides his surprise; he was so convinced she had destroyed this that he almost doesn’t believe it’s before him.
“Okay,” he says, leaning forward. “Explain it to me.”
“It’s called a termination event.” Her voice is shaking. “But it doesn’t necessarily mean you’re going to die. It means that something significant in your life will end, change, terminate, you know.”
“Significant how?” he asks. He knows these charts can pick out various aspects—relationships, home life, business. He needs specifics.
“It threads through everything,” she says. “Work, relationships, finances. I’ve never seen anything like it.”
Of course not. She’s a baby. She’s never seen anything like anything.
“It started this morning, or maybe even a couple of days ago. You didn’t have me run that, so I don’t know.”
And wasn’t bright enough to check. He’s glad he’s not one of the careless types, the kind who uses his power easily. He can just imagine pulling his gun from its shoulder holster beneath his suit jacket, ending this session with a bullet. But he won’t, no matter how annoyed he is. He’s more of a planner than that.
Besides, he has a hunch this isn’t the kind of termination event she’s talking about.
“It builds until the sixth, when everything comes to a head, and then, I don’t know. The chart flips, and to be honest with you, sir, I haven’t seen anything like this.”
“Like what?”
“Nothing.”
At first he thinks she’s being evasive, then he realizes that she means literally nothing.
“How can that be?” he asks.
She shrugs. “I tried calling the guy who trained me, but he’s at some retreat in Michigan until the 15th.”
He sighs, slaps a fifty on the table, and takes all three charts, even though they’re not worth that much.
“Anything else?” he asks as he stands.
“Yeah,” she says, standing too, and pointing at the top sheet. “Right now, your energy is at odds with itself. A lot of things will be revealed, secrets will be uncovered. There’s so much darkness here that it scares me.”
“I suppose it would,” he says.
“No.” She straightens her shoulders, apparently thinking it makes her look stronger and taller. It actually makes her look scared. “You don’t understand. All these things, they’re very bad. I’ve never seen such a horrible chart. If I were you, I’d go to bed and not leave for a week.”
“I suppose you would,” he says.
Her lips narrow and anger flashes through her eyes. “I’m trying to warn you.”
“Of what?” he asks, hoping this time she’ll be specific.
“This week,” she says, “you may lose everything.”
He studies her for a moment. She seems so sincere, so worried about him, even though she doesn’t really know him.
“It wouldn’t be the first time,” he says, and walks out the door.
The first time had been twenty years ago. He’d been working as a bouncer at a major New York nightclub, and he’d gotten friendly with the owner, a balding man who wore too much jewelry and liked a little too much blow. He supplied it to his friends, too, and used Ben, as he’d been known then, to deliver it.
Young Ben proved his honesty—he always returned the money, every dime of it, to the club’s owner—and his street smarts. He’d thwarted more than one robbery attempt, and he’d beaten a handful of men much larger than himself to a bloody pulp.
After one incident, which Ben won but which left him with a broken rib, split knuckles and two black eyes, the owner gave him a gun and paid for time at a range so that he could learn how to use it.
Ben had an affinity for guns. Great aim, which improved with practice, an eye that seemed perfect even if the scope was off. He knew the damage a gun could do—saw it up close and personal one night—and vowed never to use one except in self-defense.
Of course, self-defense isn’t always what the cops make it out to be.
Ben had been on a delivery when the owner’s supplier went to the club and took it down. Ben may have been passing on the funds, but the owner hadn’t been. The club burned with only employees inside, the result, the cops said, of free-basing, matches and too much alcohol. Everyone died. The warning was sent—and the only person left to get it was Ben.
As he saw it, he had three choices: run for the rest of his life, beg for the supplier’s (nonexistent) mercy, or defend himself. He defended himself with a coldness he hadn’t realized he had. He planned the attack as calmly as he planned anything, knowing that he could simply be firing the first volley in a war that would never end.
But warnings could be sent both ways, and he wanted the community to know that no one fucked with him. He cashed everything out, moved out of his apartment, and became a ghost.
Six months of work, tracking connections, finding people who specialized in being lost, and then taking care of them, quickly, efficiently, and with a minimum of fuss.
He was nearly done when they caught him. Lost five guys taking him down, wounding him badly enough that he could no longer defend himself.
That was when he learned he hadn’t prepared enough. The club owner had been a small fish, the supplier another small fish, the people he took out more small fish. The man who talked to him was probably a medium fish, one who claimed to represent a larger fish.
He offered Ben training for a job, a high-paying one that he’d have to work only a few times a year.
“You have an affinity for it,” the medium fish said. “Shame to let such talent go to waste.”
He never wasted it. Somewhere, he lost Ben, the boy bouncer, and became the ghost, the man who could go from place to place and never be recognized, the man who had fifteen layers between himself and the world.
Years later, when Glenna saw that incident in his chart, she said, “You lost everything and it stripped you down to your warrior nature. Since then, you’ve never looked back.”
He sees no point in looking back. He learns his lesson and moves forward, in the world and not a part of it.
Losing everything means only one thing now: losing himself.
The afternoon sun is pale through the smog. Cars honk, tourists gawk at the poverty that is Hollywood Boulevard, and he remembers why he hates Los Angeles.
He didn’t expect such news. He has been careless in recent months—having his own chart done only when he had a job. May was, literally, uncharted territory.
Until now.
He pulls the cell phone out of its pouch on his belt. This phone is one he cloned in Detroit a week ago. He hasn’t used it yet, so it’s as clean as the phone in his rental and the five he stashed at the airport.
As he walks, he dials. Glenna will be able to explain this chart. She’ll run it herself and tell him what the darkness is, what the nothing is. She isn’t afraid of him, and she has the experience to understand every nuance a chart can make.
He listens to the rings as he passes a diner filled with transvestites, hookers, and wannabe stars. His rental is parked halfway up the next road, around a curve, up a hill, impossible to see from the main thoroughfare.
Even when he hasn’t agreed to a job, he’s cautious.
“Cosmos,” says an unfamiliar male voice, loud through the earpiece.
No “May I Help You?,” no “Leading the Way in Harmony,” which is the store’s tagline, something Glenna always insists her employees say. In fact, this man’s voice is so flat he sounds disinterested, like a cop who is answering the phone to see who is on the other end.
Still, he decides to play it, just to see. “Glenna, please.”
“Who’s calling?”
“I need a name, sir,” and he knows his hunch is right. Glenna has never screened her calls. Not in the ten years he’s known her.
A person has to take what comes, she says, however it comes.
She is, if he remembers right, some combination of Pisces, Cancer and Aquarius, all intuition and emotion, sensitive, psychic and unique. Certainly not someone who would respond well to a voice as cold as this one.
He decides to push one last time. “Glenna has never asked for my name before. Just put her on.”
“No can do, sir,” the voice says. “I need a name.”
He hangs up, then shuts off the phone, slipping it into his pocket. He’ll toss it when he gets onto the freeway, somewhere near a bridge or an off-ramp near gang territory. After he wipes it down, of course.
It isn’t until he gets to his rental that he realizes he’s shaken. It’s such an unfamiliar emotion, he’s forgotten how it feels—the chill down the back, the twisting in the stomach, the unsteady nerves in the hand.
For he was wrong when he thought the only thing he had left was himself. He has Glenna, his seer, his touchstone, and the only person he’s trusted since he started down this road twenty years before.
The Web is an anonymous man’s the best friend. On it, he has found sites that have told him how to pick hotel keycard locks, how to buy illegal and untraceable weapons, how to steal identities.
Now, in the privacy of his touristy hotel near Universal Studios, he uses the Web to learn something he does not want to know.
Glenna is dead.
Not just dead. Murdered. Two days before, in what the Flagstaff newspaper is calling a gangland style hit. In other words, a professional job.
He gets more information from the local radio news sites and a Phoenix newspaper that feels an obligation to cover the entire state. The details are familiar. He recognizes the method. The job was a quickie, gun left on the scene registered to a New Orleans police detective who had it stolen (or in New Orleans, with its corrupt department, who sold it) at a take-down five years ago. Hit happened late at night, in a private corner near a vegan restaurant she frequented. One shot, taken no more than three feet away, and not heard by the locals. Silencer, probably, or pillow or purse to muffle the sound.
There were probably other details the cops were keeping to themselves, things like a stranger seen near the store that day or that night, an abandoned rental car, wiped clean, or evidence pointing to a local, evidence that didn’t pan out.
The thing that disturbs him the most is that the local police don’t handle it themselves. They don’t even call Phoenix for help. They assume it is a hit, which means the gunman has organized connections, and they call in the FBI.
He’s glad now that the cloned phone is gone. He needs to be gone too. No time to delay. There’s probably someone tracking his steps in Hollywood as he’s closing his laptop.
Check out is easy. Tourist hotels, gotta love ’em. The staff doesn’t care why he’s leaving early. They figure they know. Too much fun in the sun. Too many rides. Too much alcohol, not enough money.
He slips out as quietly as he slipped in, drops the rental at LAX, and hops the next Southwest flight to Vegas.
For the first time in years, he needs real help, and there’s only one place he can get it.
He flies Southwest because they let customers pick their own seats. If you don’t like who you sit next to, you can move, no questions asked. He takes a window toward the back, grabs an airsick bag, and makes himself look queasy.
No one sits next to him.
The short flight is uneventful, but his mind is racing. Glenna may have mob connections, but he doubts it. She may have an ex-husband with access, but he doesn’t believe that. Hell, she may be the mother of a high school cheerleader whose jealous rival hires a hit man, but he never believed that story in the first place. He certainly doesn’t believe it now.
He has a hunch he’s her only connection to the dark world he lives in.
Should I be afraid for myself, old friend? My chart was uncertain. It told me that today would introduce me to Death.
He leans against the tiny window, staring at the tops of clouds. She had told him at that first reading that charts weren’t easily predictable. She’d looked at his and thought that he was a stand-in for Death because of his job.
I did meet Death yesterday, just not in the way I thought.
She had been wrong twice. Her chart had said that day would introduce her to Death. Without him, Death would never have found her, at least not in this way.
He doesn’t need actual proof. He has more important things to worry about.
He needs to figure out if she’s a warning or if she’s a tool. Or both. The shooter had to know the cops would find her long before he did. If the shooter were after him and knew about Glenna, all the shooter had to do was wait.
So he’s not an obvious target. He’s something else, but what he doesn’t know.
She had his charts for the next job. His chart, the client’s chart, and the victim’s chart. No names, only reference numbers. Numbers she promised—and he checked (late one night, easily breaking into that silly little store)—that never had names attached to them.
She never had his real name anyway or his address. He always contacted her, and she didn’t seem to mind.
All she had was birthdates, times, and locations.
That was plenty.
His right hand crumples the airsick bag. He is still shaken, and beneath that feeling is something else, something even more unsettling.
He does not want to examine what that feeling is.
Angel Bridges has an astrology palace near one of the Elvis chapels on the strip. The astrology palace is as garish as anything else in Vegas: six stories high with turrets and neon astrological symbols that flash on and off depending on the time of year and the fluctuations in the cosmos.
Angel makes her money telling gamblers how to bet based on the stars, but she runs a side business for true believers. She makes no money on that one—she does it strictly for love. And she never asks questions because she values her life and her position in a town where people do anything to guarantee luck.
It’s five o’clock when he walks in, the beginning of her evening rush. One of the little waifs who works as an assistant approaches him, but he ignores it. The waif bleats, but he continues to walk toward Angel, cutting ahead of a long and patient line.
She sits on a thick couch, a caftan spread around her ample frame. Diamonds glitter on her ears and fingers—she can’t lead other people to wealth if it doesn’t look like she has some of her own.
She sees him, smiles at her current customer, and excuses herself, as if she’s going to get more research material. She disappears behind a gold leaf door. He takes a side hallway that seems to go in the opposite direction, but doesn’t.
They end up in her office, an ergonomically correct room with no windows and a skylight that, at night, sends patterns of neon across the darkened floor. He learned that at one a.m. on a Christmas Eve as he checked her files, making sure her connections were clean ones.
As she closes the metal door, he hands her the natal chart. She’s never seen it before. She’s only done client charts for him. She has no idea it’s his.
“I need two months,” he says, “starting with April 20th of this year. And I’m going to wait for it.”
He’s never done that before. He’s always come back. She peers at him, then adjusts her red wig. He doesn’t like it. She looks better with her natural black.
“It’s gonna cost,” she says. “I’ll lose about a quarter of the suckers out there.”
“I’ll pay,” he says.
She nods, presses a button, and tells an assistant to inform the clients she’s received news of a change in the stars. Then she focuses on the chart and punches up something on her computer.
He takes an upholstered chair designed for a frame shorter and heavier than his. It’s the most uncomfortable chair he’s ever sat in. But he doesn’t move. Instead, he ponders.
A hit like that always draws the FBI, later rather than sooner in small towns, although he probably should expect sophistication in a strange little town like Sedona. What will the FBI learn from his files?
Too much, actually, if they plug the dates, place names, and birth times into their unsolved database. One half of the birth information will tie to hits all over the country. It won’t take a rocket scientist to figure out that the other half belong to the folks who paid good money to get the first half out of the way.
And then there’s his, of course, and its repeated monthly or weekly charts. Not that it’ll do the Feds much good. Ben disappeared twenty years ago. A ghost took his place, a ghost no one has been able to trace for a very long time.
They will get his patterns though and, if they put someone smart on the case, a pretty good analysis of his MO, damn his perfectionist Virgo side. They’ll also get an excellent description of him from neighboring shopkeepers and former employees because they’ll know what questions to ask.
And from the client list, they’ll probably track down a few of his hackers or maybe the fronts who took the order. His carefully formed fifteen will crumble to six or seven or four.
One piece of information and his operation shatters. Was that the goal? Or is he being neutralized because the big fish is finally gone or because someone has finally caught up with him?
They’d caught up with him before, but always failed in hand-to-hand. It took some planning to make him ineffective. Some planning and some unwitting compliance from himself and his superstitions.
He’d gotten complacent, a bad thing in his business.
“This is a piece of shit chart,” Angel says.
“Inaccurate?” he asks.
“No, just incomplete, like they were using one of those computer downloads done by someone who only gives half a crap.” She runs a bejeweled hand over her eyes. What is it about these astrologers that makes them wear too much jewelry on their fingers?
“So whatever this person told me is incomplete?”
“Dunno,” Angel says. “What’d you get told?”
He slips the other chart to her, the one with the week ahead.
Angel frowns at it. “Why’re you going to a crap artist when you got me?”
“You’re not always with me, babe,” he says, folding his hands together and leaning back.
She shakes her head, then she pushes the weekly sheet to him. “Look at this. It doesn’t tie. It’s as if this astrologer’s forgotten the natal chart. We got a birthdate in Eastern Standard Time, and we got an analysis done for someone born in Western Daylight. Doesn’t work. This is so basic.”
“So it’s wrong,” he says.
“This weekly thing is a piece of garbage.” She tosses it into the nearby wastebasket with a flourish. “But this natal chart, I gotta tell you, is the nastiest thing I’ve ever seen.”
“Because of how it’s done?”
“Because of what it means.” She frowns at him, shoves the wig back so far he can see the pink of her scalp. “This is another client?”
He nods, not trusting himself to answer.
“This is one mean s.o.b. Dangerous. He thinks he’s clean, but he’s not. He kills for a living, and even though charts can be figurative, I don’t think this one is. He sees himself as a warrior, but he’s an assassin, plain and simple. Not the kind of person nice folks should hang with.”
He hasn’t moved, his hands still across his stomach, his feet stretched out, his body trapped in the world’s most uncomfortable chair. But his muscles have all gone tense. He can feel the gun beneath his suit coat. He hopes his expression hasn’t changed, then he wonders if it should have changed. After all, she’s just told him one of his clients is a killer.
“What’re you supposed to do for this guy?” she asks, and he mentally curses her, wishing that she would remember she’s not supposed to ask questions. “A job, like the others?”
He nods.
“I hope it’s a legal job. You don’t want to mess with this guy in any real way.”
“What else does the natal chart tell you?” he asks. Somehow his voice remains calm.
“That he’s got more secrets than God. That he’s unpredictable and charming and could turn on you in a second. I won’t do anything for him, no matter how much he paid me.”
She’s trying to be nice to him. She doesn’t know. His muscles are freezing up. He’s holding back the truth, that she has worked for him for five years, thinks he’s a friend, thinks he’s someone she can trust.
“Well,” he says, “let’s see what the two-month chart says.”
“You don’t seem shocked by this.”
“I thought he was shady. You’re not surprising me.”
She nods, focuses on the computer screen. For a long time, all he hears is the tap-tap of keys. He resists the urge to stand and pace.
They had to have already found some of his people. The only way to get to Glenna was to find out about the blind box in Flagstaff. In the past, he used to go there, pick up the stuff and drive it down. Three years ago, he decided she could open the box on occasion. He brought her a key, and sometimes he would call, asking her to pick up the various charts. She would.
A few of his hackers and a couple of his fronts have that address. Others have a blind box in Vegas and another in L.A. If the cops triangulated that cell phone call, they know he was in L.A. Or maybe someone else knows.
He gets up so abruptly the chair bangs against the floor. Angel starts. “You okay?”
“Need to make a private call,” he says. “I’ll be right back.”
“Take your time,” she says. “This is one confusing mass of planets.”
He doesn’t like that sound either. He heads to the door, takes the corridor outside and goes in the Elvis chapel. There’s a line here too, mostly of drunks. He congratulates one of the champagne drinking men, lifts his cell as he pats him on the side, and then goes onto the strip.
It’s changed over the years. Big buildings loom over him, pretending to be something they aren’t—the Eiffel Tower, the Empire State Building, a complete European City State. The neon lights make it as bright as day. Cars pass, people stumble by, many of them holding buckets with tokens in them or nickels. A few have newspapers and others clutch cash as if it isn’t real.
He dials the store in L.A., hoping it’s open late. On the fifth ring, a woman answers. He recognizes the voice. The palm reader.
“You get Elli May out of there,” he says.
“So it’s you.” The reader curses him in some romance language—probably Italian. “You could have warned her.”
“I had no idea.”
“She comes here looking for adventure, not a gun in the face.”
A gun in the face? He hadn’t expected that. He expected something a few days away, maybe an FBI visit or a discreet contact. Not a direct attack. “Is she all right?”
“Scared. She gave him all her charts. He didn’t want money. A good thing, eh? So now she can go back to those parents of hers, the ones who didn’t even care that she was gone.” The reader curses him again.
He lets her. “Who put the gun in her face?”
“I don’t know his name.”
“Have you seen him before?”
“No,” she says.
“What can you tell me about him?”
“Why should I tell you anything?”
“Because I may be able to prevent him from coming back.”
She pauses. He can feel her brain whirling. He wonders if he’s making a mistake, calling her, if the attacker is still there. Then he decides it doesn’t matter. Most folks can’t track a cell phone call. Even if she has Caller I.D., all she can find out is what the cell phone number is, not where the call originates.
“He came in about three hours ago,” she says. “He was young, white, has money—or at least thinks he does. Hand-tailored suit, but dirty shoes, like he’s been traveling or forgets to shine them.”
He listens, body tense.
“He points the gun at me first, and I shrug. I’ve seen guns before, but not eyes like his. Big and brown and spinning, almost. Crazy. He thinks he’s smart, but he’s only smart like a fox. This kind does not survive long.”
Is she talking to the attacker now? Or is this the kind of way she always speaks? He wishes he had paid more attention to her, instead of dismissing her out of hand.
“He wants the charts. He gets angry when he finds out they’re all the same birthdate. He wants the other ones, the client charts. She says she has no idea what he means, but she gives him everything. He slaps the gun across her face and she falls. I’ve got my own gun and I pull it out. He turns, laughs at me, says, ‘Grandma, you’re no match for me,’ and then he leaves, as if the fact we seen him don’t matter, as if his visit is normal.”
“Then what?” he asks.
“A call to the police, of course. No one’s come yet. This part of town, who cares? But you care. You know this man.”
“No,” he says. “I don’t.”
“He knows you. He says you’re getting old and tired and you don’t even realize it. A relic, he calls you. A superstitious relic.” She pauses. “You will not come back here.”
“That’s right.”
“I am telling you, you will not come back here. My niece, she thinks he will murder you. She thinks it is her fault.”
“Tell her that her chart is off. She forgot to adjust for time zones.” And he hangs up.
He wipes the phone off and then tosses it on the sidewalk outside the Elvis chapel. The drunk will think it has fallen from its perch in his pocket. It won’t be until he gets his bill that he realizes something has gone wrong.
He goes back into the astrology palace. The line is shorter. The person who was having his chart done still waiting near the couch, only now he is checking his watch.
He slips into the back, goes to the office. She has swiveled her chair so that she’s working on a back desk, using protractors and paper charts and colored pencils. It takes him a moment to realize she’s redoing her work by hand.
“What’s the problem?” he asks.
“It comes out the same,” she says and she sounds complete surprised. “Even with the proper adjustments, this weekly chart comes out exactly the same. Something started a week ago, something very serious, which led to a great loss a few days ago, one which had an impact today.”
At that, she looks up at him, as if he can give her the information she seeks. He can, of course, but he won’t.
When it becomes clear that he’ll say nothing, she continues. “It builds and then there is nothing.”
“Nothing?” he asks, beginning to hate that word. “What the hell is nothing?”
She shrugs. “I’ve never seen anything like it. There is no more chart.”
“So it means death.”
She shakes her head. “I’ve seen death in charts before, often charts you give me, sometimes in the gamblers’ charts. But it usually appears as a transformation. A person’s life continues even if he does not.”
“What the hell does that mean?”
She smiles. This is clearly a conversation she’s familiar with. “Let’s say you die tomorrow. Your financial affairs will continue. Your relationships will continue, at least for a little while. You may still have an impact on the world, long after you’re gone. I suppose eventually the chart will come to nothing, but I have never seen one do that. Usually the person who dies does not come back for another reading.”
That last she says wryly, as if humor might help her unease. It doesn’t help his.
If he stops, if he ends, nothing will continue. He has no relationships, not like she is talking about. He has no friends and family (well, he has a family, but they are not people he has thought of in decades. He left them when he stopped being Ben, maybe even before, when he went to work in the City), and his finance affairs will become untended accounts that banks all over the world will have to deal with some day.
He has no will, no legacy, no real life. When he goes, he will leave nothing behind. He will evaporate, like a spirit in the wind.
“I don’t understand,” he says.
“Neither do I,” she says and frowns. “All we have is a cataclysmic event and then nothing. Perhaps I should run my own chart. Perhaps the world is going to end.”
She does not say this with humor. He stares at her, then he flings five times her usual payment on the desk. “Thanks.”
“Come back tomorrow,” she says. “I’ll research this, see if anyone else knows what it means.”
“I think you might just want to let this go,” he says. “I am.”
“I can’t let it go. It may have great meaning.”
“I doubt it,” he says, and lets himself out the door.
The line is even shorter. The man waiting for his reading is talking angrily to one of the waifs.
He goes outside, looks at the fake towns, the people pretending they’re having a good time. The cell phone is gone from the sidewalk in front of the Elvis chapel. He wonders if the drunk found it or if someone else picked it up.
It is time to disappear. To become a true ghost, never thought or heard of again. Over the years, he has made a hundred escape plans, and he has liked none of them. Nothing sounds duller than sitting on a tropical beach sipping Mai Tais for the rest of his life.
No matter what Angel said, or how much contempt she said it with, he is a warrior. And he wants to die a warrior’s death. If he cannot work, he cannot enjoy his life.
Maybe he should cut all his ties with the past, the fifteen layers (some of which are gone, some of which have betrayed him), move to a different country, and set up again. Someday, perhaps, he can come back here as an independent and start again.
But he is too old to start again. He only has ten more good years, twenty if he keeps himself in perfect condition and chooses targets as old or older than he is.
Perhaps the nothing on his chart reflects his ghost status. Perhaps it means that he will choose a new identity, with a new birthdate, and start again.
Perhaps. But he does not believe it. He has reached the end, and he is not sure what that means.
But he knows what he will do.
He will wait.
What he figures is this:
The young man is after him for his client list, which means he has not found the fronts, only the hackers. In fact, he may have only found one hacker—any one with Flagstaff PO Box would do.
What disturbs him is the connection to astrology. The guy knew about the superstition somehow—and he thinks he knows how. Sometimes hit men become legends in their own business, especially if they’ve been around a while, like he has. They get monikers, usually based on something unusual.
He hasn’t been tied into the network in years—too much risk, risk he doesn’t like. But the network is still tied to him, clearly, or to his reputation. They can’t call him the Zodiac Killer—that had been taken by some psycho who wouldn’t know a pro hit if he were instructed in how to do one—so they probably gave him a different name: the Horoscope Man, the Astrology Hits, something. And from there, this guy searched until he found something unusual.
What doesn’t fit, what bothers him, is that the guy’s research makes him seem cautious, but his encounters—both with Glenna and Elli May—make him seem like a quickie.
The guy’s also arrogant, so he doesn’t cover his tracks. The fact that he has the charts is both exhilarating and disturbing. Disturbing because the guy’s going to get caught and he’s going to give up what he knows. Exhilarating, because the FBI, even though they’re involved, don’t have the charts and can’t tie Glenna’s clients to anything.
If the guy is as smart as he seems, he’s going to find out about Vegas. Once he finds Vegas, he’ll find Angel. Once he finds Angel, his spree will end, one way or another.
There’s even a timetable, according to the weekly chart. By the sixth of May, the guy’ll be in Vegas—and there’ll be a confrontation. Better to know that in advance. No surprises.
No surprises, the better the chance of winning.
If there is something to win.
What he doesn’t admit to himself as he waits is how disturbed he is. Deep down. He’s never been anyone’s focus, never been the source of anyone’s search—not him, not his ghostly self. Sure, he’s probably in a bunch of police and FBI databases, but for his various crimes.
Right now, he’s being tailed for who he is, targeted for what he knows, and the people he’s surrounded himself with are being punished.
He hates that.
He hasn’t realized how much he hates that until he sits in Angel’s office for the second night in a row, trying to find a comfortable chair. The lights are out, but the skylight lets in so much neon ambiance that everything is well lit.
The computer is off, but he has helped himself to her files, realizes she has some connections that make him nervous. He wonders if they know who he is, if they know about his previous break-in, and if they care.
Probably not. If they cared, they’d take care of him. They’re probably watching now, just to see what he’s doing, just to find out what he knows.
What he knows is that he’s having a hard time staying calm. And that’s not like him. But he keeps thinking of Glenna, her easy manner, her smile when she saw him after a long absence, the way she believed whatever she did was for the best.
He led the guy right to her, and she had died, violently, because of him.
Strangely enough, that disturbs him. When he gets paid to take a life, that’s different. It isn’t about him. It’s what he does. It’s not personal.
This is. This loss had a direct connection to him, more direct than pulling the trigger.
This loss pisses him off. And the fact that it pisses him off pisses him off even more. He isn’t supposed to have attachments. He’s outgrown them. They’re useless in his business. He needs to be a complete loner, and somehow he’s failed to do that.
Part of him worried about Angel until he saw who she was dealing with. If the guy offs her, he’ll have an entire family of people to answer to. She’ll be protected.
It’s his remaining astrologers who are in trouble. Them, and his hackers—the ones who haven’t encountered the guy—and the fronts, and all the others associated with this little operation. He’s struggled to keep them as clean as possible. He doesn’t want anything to happen to them because of him.
At least, that’s what he’s telling himself as he sits in the shadows, watching the blue neon Scorpio signal—an M with a pointed tail—flash on and off against the cherry colored carpet. He’s also thinking he may have overestimated this guy when he hears the security lock click open.
Finally.
He pulls out the semi he got at a militia convention outside of Denver and aims it at the door. He has to wait until he’s sure because he doesn’t want to nail Angel by mistake.
Someone slips inside, as thin as one of the waifs. The neon is off for the moment, dammit, and the room is darker than usual. Then the gold Taurus ignites—a circle with horns—and he sees the leather jacket, the slicked-back hair, the cruel curve to the mouth.
“You could’ve just asked for my client list,” he says.
The guy swivels, surprised. But he covers well. “I had to find you first.”
His answer is a spray of bullets that rip the guy up and make him dance before slumping against the wall, lifeless and empty.
Now he’s got to move quick. He suspects the palace has walls thick enough to hide the noise, but suspecting is not the same as knowing. He approaches the body, gaping and bloody where the torso should be, and stares at the face.
Unfamiliar, not that he should know who the guy was. And young, arrogant. A quickie, just like he thought. He slips on his gloves and pats the pockets, finding a Hilton room key and a receipt with the room number, and a wallet with I.D. poorly faked, from some computer site.
Not even a quickie then. An amateur, a wannabe. No wonder he needed the client list. He didn’t have connections to get jobs on his own. Glenna had been practice, proof that he could do it.
And maybe he couldn’t. A real pro would’ve shot Elli May and the palm reader. A real pro wouldn’t’ve left such an obvious trail.
A tiny red light is blinking on the back of the computer. He looks for the source—thinking maybe someone has a laser scope on him. How can that be? There’s no way to focus the scope on him from that angle. There should be shadows from the skylight above. He’s been checking. The astrological signs are sending the proper light to the carpet.
Some kind of warning light. Some kind of security trigger. He pockets the room key, but destroys the receipt. Then he peals off his gloves, and folds them over his shoes like a cheap pair of rubbers. There’ll be bloody footprints. He can’t help that. But that’s the only clue they’ll have, and with Angel’s unsavory connections, the cops’ll probably look somewhere else.
He reaches for the door, turns the knob, hears a second click. Not a security lock this time. Something flat and ominous, something he should have expected, but didn’t because this, for him, was a quickie too.
He pulls on the door, but it doesn’t open. Programmed to lock after violence like that. He’s seen security like this before. He’s not going to be able to shoot through the metal door, at least not in time.
“Damn,” he says as he turns, hoping he has time to get up to the skylight, to break through it. The red light on the computer is blinking so fast that it seems almost constant.
He stands on one of the uncomfortable chairs, the semi pointed at the skylight. He’s pulling the trigger when the computer explodes.
He has time to analyze it.
It’s not really a white light. It’s more like sunlight, broad and glistening, incorporating many colors, but so brightly that all he can see is white.
He’s afraid to look at it, afraid he’ll see that no one is waiting for him, or that the folks who are waiting are really, really, really pissed off.
He hides his eyes, but the light comes through the lids, just like it would do if he were really there. He doesn’t look at it, pretends he can’t feel its warm glow, and gradually, it fades away as if it never existed.
As if he never existed.
Which, he supposes, he hasn’t, not for a very long time.
“Ben?”
He opens his eyes. The old lady standing over him has thin gray hair and a broad face. Her features are familiar.
“Ben?” She sounds like she’s witnessing a miracle. Behind her head, a TV screen blares the news. A woman is reading headlines, and below her is a sports ticker. It gives the score of the All-Star game.
He frowns. The old lady is calling for nurses, and he realizes that he’s in a bed, immobile, and very, very tired.
“You’re back, Ben. Thank God. I’ve been here everyday.”
Finally he recognizes the voice. The old lady is Angel. He was wrong. Her hair’s natural color isn’t black. The tips are, but she’s stopped dying it. A scarf lays on an end table, along with a book about destiny. She’s been waiting for him, and reading.
“You saved my life. That serial killer—”
She doesn’t get a chance to finish. His room is invaded by scores of health care professionals in white coats. They surround him, stick him with things, ask him questions he doesn’t know the answer to, tell him he’s lucky, lucky, lucky to be alive.
He has lost more than two months. It’s mid-July. He has been immobile in a Vegas hospital bed for two months—not alive, not dead.
Living in limbo. Existing. He was, he realizes, during that span, nothing at all.
They take Angel out, afraid she’ll tire him, but she promises to come back.
He has to cope with many realizations—that his rehabilitation will take months, maybe years. He may not walk again. His left arm has been destroyed. He’s afraid to look at his face.
They found out his real identity from his fingerprints, sent for his family, and found out he has none left. His fingerprints are on file, he remembers, because of a drug bust twenty years ago, one the club owner paid their way out of. He had forgotten that. He has forgotten more than he knows.
What he does learn from Angel over the next few days is that, in her eyes, he’s a hero. Somehow, she thinks, he got the guy’s chart. They’re calling the guy—Dante Evans—a serial killer who specialized in astrologers.
Evans wasn’t as careful as he thought. He left clues at the scene of Glenna’s murder and Elli May was able to I.D. him from a photo as the guy who beat her the afternoon of May fourth.
Angel believes that “Ben” knew something was wrong, and when he figured it out, guarded her. She has no clue who he really is, and if she has no clue, then neither do her contacts—the ones who booby-trapped her office.
She is embarrassed as she explains this. “They made me promise that I’d keep their information secure,” she says. “They set up this trap. At first it was supposed to go off if there was unofficial activity in the room, but I was afraid for my assistants, so they set it up to go off if there was other factors. I never asked what those factors were. They promised it would never happen.”
He knows. It could have been any number of things: a response to the cordite, to the sound of gunfire, to the spray of warm liquid—like blood. Or merely a remote device, set off by someone who kept an eye on the place, whenever he believed there was trouble.
Gunfire counted as trouble.
But he says nothing to her, and he also says nothing when she offers to pay for his room. His tracks are covered, so deep that he knows he’s facing an opportunity.
Angel sits beside his bed. She’s still apologizing to him, feeling guilty for misreading the chart. She doesn’t understand that it’s not Evans’ chart, that it’s his chart, but he won’t tell her that.
“I still have trouble believing death registers as nothing. But they can’t find anything about him. We’re the only ones affected,” she says.
He listens. He doesn’t tell her what he believes. Can’t. He’s afraid she’ll run his chart or the serial killer’s chart, which is what she believes it is. If she runs it past May 11, she’ll find the nothing ended on the day he woke up. The nothing was the coma.
Even though it wasn’t really nothing, not like the chart said. After all, Angel’s here and she thinks he’s a hero. He has had some impact on her life.
Maybe the nothing was a misinterpretation—or a non-interpretation. Maybe everything was in such flux that no one could predict what would happen.
“Angel,” he says, when she finally pauses for breath, “do you believe in second chances?”
“Of course, honey,” she says and pats his good hand. “The religions, they all deal with that. It’s even in a person’s chart, in the nodes. Past lives always have an impact on present ones.”
“No, no,” he says. “I’m talking about this life. What if there’s a clear line, a break between what you were before and now. Can you be something else?”
She studies him for a moment. He wonders how clearly she’s seeing him. Does she think he’s talking about his old drug arrest, his wandering lifestyle? Or does she think something deeper is going on, maybe even suspect the darkness he let take over his soul?
“I think a person gets a second chance like that for a reason,” she says, “and only a fool would pass it by.”
He nods. He’s been thinking that too.
“You want me to do your chart, so we can see what path you should walk?”
“No,” he says. He’s done with that. Charts are too accurate. He’s not going to plan his life like that any more. Besides, he wants to forget that he’s a warrior with a judge’s soul. He wants to think he’s been reborn in July. A Cancer. Sensitive, nurturing, protective. Someone else entirely.
“How come you never told me who you really are, Ben?” she asks, looking down. This question matters to her.
He gives it due consideration. “I guess,” he says, “because I never knew myself.”
Protected by fifteen layers, a soldier in a war he didn’t believe in or understand, searching for meaning where there was none, meaning that got the wrong people killed.
He’s not a hero, not even close. Doubts he ever can be. He’s still superstitious, maybe more so than he was before. He’s hanging up his weapons and finding a new path—one that might make him worthy of the light.
Maybe, the next time it surrounds him, he can look at it and through it, to the world beyond. Maybe the next time, he’ll have enough courage to go there, and face himself, what he’s been and what he’s done.
The thought disturbs him and he closes his eyes, for the first time in his own memory not trying to repress feeling, but to acknowledge it.
To feel something where there was once nothing.
To be a person instead of a ghost.
GhostsCopyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Death By Horoscope, edited by Anne Perry, Carroll and Graf, August 2001Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2023 by WMG PublishingCover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Agsandrew/Dreamstime
To Get a Free AI Audio Version of this blog, click here.
Every time I complain about being too busy to get all of my work done, I toy with the idea of quitting school. I’m taking classes every spring and fall semester at UNLV. Dean tells me I don’t have to work hard at them because I already have a job, but you know, the ancient training dies hard.
I was raised to be as good a student as I can be. (Sometimes it’s hard; I’m dyslexic and certain subjects are detail focused. I am not great at them.) I put a lot of effort into learning, but I also get a lot out of it.
Still, I hear his point. I watch the other people I’m in school with and I realize that I’m lucky. I’m studying for the reasons I have always studied—to learn something. The middle-aged students around me are trying to get an advanced degree to move careers or advance in the ones they have. The younger students—the ones straight out of high school—are trying to find themselves and figure out what they want to do with their lives.
They all feel tremendous pressure, and the idea of getting even a mediocre grade makes them (the younger ones in particular) believe that they’ve ruined their entire futures.
I am not in that precarious state. I’m doing this for me. I’m finishing the Spanish degree that I couldn’t finish forty years ago. Back then, the University of Wisconsin required language students to travel abroad for an entire semester to immerse themselves in the language. I couldn’t afford to do that, and there were no scholarships available. Besides, I would have had to leave my then-husband which, looking back on it, might not have been a bad thing.
Still, the experience left me functionally illiterate in Spanish which irritated the heck out of me. I tried studying on my own, but it’s not the same. The classes challenge me, as I’ve written before, and taught me several things, particularly about the damaging effect of getting stuck in the words rather than the conversation.
So quitting is not a good idea for me, even though it comes up almost weekly. I really am overscheduled. I love it and I hate it and I want to write more and I want to do more.
Only…I learned a lesson about my own process a long, long time ago. If I’m left to my own devices, if I schedule time to write and do nothing else, I’m creative for a few days, maybe a few weeks, and then I dry up. The words don’t flow easily. I can’t remember what I wanted to write or why I wanted to write it.
I need to be challenged.
The first time I experienced this was in 1985 at the Clarion Writers Workshop. Six weeks long, spent with other writers in an almost hermetically sealed Michigan State University. We were in a closed dorm (not the graduate dorms that most years of Clarion students had) and we rarely saw anyone else. In fact, our walk to class took us through an underground tunnel where there were always the remains of hastily eaten breakfasts, but no sign of people. One of my classmates, Robert J. Howe, labeled that little passage The Marie Celeste and it stuck.
I had thought that six weeks with writers, talking writing and reading, was my idea of heaven. By week three, I was bored out of my mind. Yes, I had a lot of work to do. Yes, I learned a lot. And jeez, I wanted to think of something else, have a conversation about something—anything—else.
I realized then that I needed outside input, and a lot of it.
I had to relearn that lesson a couple times as a young professional. I would take a week or two off of my day job and stay home to write. Which I did. And then, I simply couldn’t take it anymore. I didn’t just need the time away. I needed something else to occupy my brain.
School does that for me. I’m studying stuff I wouldn’t normally study. If I’m reading, I’m reading someone else’s reading list. I’m learning things in disciplines I’ve never really explored in depth. I’m stepping outside of my comfort zone all the time.
I’m doing that living in Las Vegas as well. I see entertainment I wouldn’t have given a second thought to in the other places I’ve lived. I explore casinos, and neighborhoods that my younger self might have considered sketchy.
I don’t know if I’ll ever use the input, but it might crop up in ways that I might not recognize. Sometimes I do know what I’m learning and sometimes I wonder where the heck I got that idea.
Over a year ago, I saw an interview with a neurologist, who mentioned that one of the most important things a person can do is cross-train the brain. The article went on to talk with creatives and a different expert mentioned that those who indulged in “creative cross-training” did better on everything, from the happiness and wellness scale to actual creativity.
Of course, I didn’t save the article in my Pocket Reader app. Or if I did, I can’t locate the damn thing. I can’t remember when exactly I read the article, and I know it wasn’t called “Creative Cross Training.” I just Googled the title and found a series of posts on the topic. The most interesting one is the one, of course, that everyone quotes. It’s from Adobe’s 99U site. The article makes this point, that drawing teaches a writer to see, and music teaches a writer to hear.
But I think creative cross-training should be more than just experimenting in other art forms. Maybe other disciplines might be better. I learned a lot when I was teaching myself how to be a runner. I’m learning a lot about the human body as I learn Pilates. (It also helps my back).
Learning another language isn’t just teaching me how to communicate. It’s teaching me how to see the world in an entirely different manner. Some of that will help with my science fiction and fantasy writing, but some of it simply gets me to consider topics and concerns that never usually enter my consciousness.
Not only that, the creative cross-training does what real cross-training does: it gives the primary muscles a rest while activating the secondary muscles. It took me years to realize that I couldn’t run/walk all the time. I have terrible balance (always have) and I needed to work on core strength. Finally, I found Pilates.
I’m really bad at Pilates. There are certain moves this old and many-times-injured body can no longer do (if I could have ever done them). I try, though, and that’s what counts. I have better balance than I had, and strengthening my core muscles has really helped my running form.
I know that cross training is essential. But I get so tied up in the day to day on my writing work that I forget to put in the other stuff. Having an outside schedule can be annoying. I know I’ll lose hours every week traveling to school, sitting in class, and doing my damndest to finish homework that—as Dean says—I really don’t need to excel at.
But I am giving it as much effort as I can, and in hindsight, I’m seeing the payoff.
Much of the time, though, I find myself thinking about Nancy Kress’s award-winning novella (which later became a book series) titled “Beggars in Spain.” We published the novella as a standalone hardcover in the original Pulphouse Publishing’s Axolotl line. The story is about people who have done away with the need to sleep.
That causes other problems, of course.
But I still think…what would happen if I could sleep less and do more? It’s not possible, especially for me with my health. If I cut down on sleep, I manage a day or two before I actually fall asleep while doing other things.
That temptation is there. Think of all I could accomplish with an extra eight hours in my day. Think how crazy I would really be.
Creative cross training has been essential to my process from long before I even had a term for it. I needed to think about something other than writing and publishing and fiction and editing. I needed to focus in a completely different direction, meet people who never think about storytelling for a living, and talk with folks who have different concerns from me.
It keeps my brain fresh, but more importantly, it keeps my writing fresh.
And that makes it all worthwhile.
And speaking of creative cross-training, I’m teaching an in-person class this week in romantic suspense. I’m inspiring myself, and getting that popcorn kitten feeling. School’s out for the summer (for me), so I really should be resting. But the workshop came up…and then rest. I hope.A reminder: this weekly blog is reader supported.If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynrusch to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: Creative Cross Training,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © Can Stock Photo / MilanMarkovic.
After covering too many war zones, Joshua returns to his grandparents’ place to find the house neglected and the patio filled with cats.
He wants a refuge from the death he witnessed, but the cat yowls remind him of the cries of the wounded. No matter how hard he tries, the cats keep appearing.
So, he finally calls for help, help that proves a little weird, a little strange, but maybe just right.
“Still Life, With Cats,” by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook here and is included in the collection The Year of the Cat: A Cat of Space and Time, which is available in ebook and trade paperback here.
Still Life, With CatsKristine Kathryn RuschThe feral cats in the courtyard were having sex again. Joshua pulled his pillow over his head, and tried to go back to sleep. No matter how many times he got animal control out here, he never seemed to win.
A thousand cats had to live in the trees behind the old stone mansion. A thousand cats, and a thousand more being made every single day.
No one had warned him about the cats when he moved in.
Or the raccoons. They made even worse sounds during sex than the cats. Cats were bad enough; they sounded like panicked children or terrified women, bringing back old memories from his years in Beirut, Bosnia, and Iraq.
But raccoons sounded like vicious lions ripping up a corpse. On his first night in the mansion, he grabbed his largest flashlight and ventured outside to see what was causing the noise—his curse, always to run toward danger instead of away from it—and expected to see a bear mauling some skanky kid who’d been smoking meth near the back of the property.
Instead, he startled two raccoons having a private (well, not really private, more like intimate) moment. One screeched and scurried toward him, while the other fell over backwards.
He ran all the way back to the mansion, laughing harder than he had in years. Fortunately, the raccoon didn’t give pursuit.
Outside his window, the sex continued. One particularly throaty yowl sounded like Stuben’s cameraman right after the roadside bomb sliced off his left leg.
The image—blood spurting, Stuben covered with shrapnel crawling toward his injured friend, the truck burning behind them—already flashed in front of Joshua’s eyes.
He wouldn’t get any more sleep, maybe not for a few days.
He rolled over and looked at the clock alarm he didn’t need. Six a.m. A long day of nothing ahead. But if he stayed in bed, he would either haul out his gun and shoot the damn cats—which was illegal, since he was just inside the city limits—or he would try to sleep and would suffer the nightmares for the rest of the morning.
More yowling. His skin had become gooseflesh. He rubbed his right arm, the only unscarred patch of his upper torso, and watched the gooseflesh disappear. Then he got up, and made the bed, just as if he were still in the field.
Actually, it felt like he was in the field. This old mansion reminded him of some of the places in Bosnia—built long ago, abandoned by the people who had loved it, and left to decay. Yet vestiges of luxury remained.
This room was one of those vestiges. The gold marble floor caught the morning light, and the sand-colored walls reflected it. The bed stood on a large raised platform made of marble as well, and his friend Roxy had placed silk hangings around the king-sized mattress, so that it felt as if he slept under expensive mosquito netting—not that he needed any in this part of Oregon.
The bed itself, one of those pillow-top jobbies with a machine that adjusted the mattress hardness, bordered on ridiculous. So did the silk sheets, the thick down comforter he hadn’t needed since it was spring, and the extra soft pillows. The occasional tables matched the marble floor, and the vanity in the walk-in closet seemed like just that, a vanity.
But he’d only given Roxy a week to prepare the place for his arrival. That included furnishing, cleaning, and repair. From what he had heard (and seen) the cleaning had taken most of the week. The furnishing was a one-day affair, and the repair, unless it was an emergency, hadn’t gotten done at all.
His own fault, really. From the time he left the hospital in Wiesbaden to the day he had arrived in the town his passport claimed as home, he’d had nearly six weeks. Of course some of that included evaluations at Bethesda, and a psych work-up in some private D.C. clinic that operated on government grants.
But he still could have guessed his arrival here with more than a week’s accuracy.
Here, not home. He couldn’t call this place home. It wasn’t. It never had been. He’d come here as a child to visit his grandparents, and he’d spent summers in a now-unusable room down the hall. From those visits, he remembered his grandmother’s kitchen (warm and inviting, always smelling of coffee and cake), the books in the library (mostly untouchable in languages he couldn’t then read), and the hot sunlight (clear and crisp without the haze of humidity he had come to accept from his parents’ sojourn in the South).
He used to think he loved it here. But he had discovered he didn’t love it anywhere. Not that one place was better than the next. No. He couldn’t stay in any place long enough to get to know it.
That was one of the many reasons he’d become a war correspondent. One of the many reasons he’d traveled for ninety percent of his adult life.
One of the many reasons he felt like he was going slowly insane locked in this place, on the outskirts of a town he didn’t remember.
The cats screeched and then something clattered. He peered out the window in time to see a black-and-white tabby fleeing across the yard. A clay pot, still filled with dirt, had fallen over. A gray cat with eyes that looked like abalone, stared at him from below.
The evil eye, his great-grandmother would have said. She had lived in this room until he was eight. That summer, she had died during her afternoon nap and his grandmother made him say good-bye.
That was the first time he had seen death. The small, shrunken old woman with claw-like hands was completely motionless. She smelled faintly of pee and mothballs. Her skin was a color of gray that he knew unnatural, even then.
His grandmother had cried that afternoon, but all he had felt was relief. Relief that the old woman wouldn’t caw questions at him, spraying him with her musty breath; relieved that those hands would clutch at him any longer; relieved that he no longer had to pretend to enjoy the sticky candies she had forced on him every morning when he went to see her before being allowed outside.
Outside, into the courtyard, where fountains had once sprayed and flowers had bloomed. The same courtyard where cats had sex and broke his grandmother’s pots and stared at him as if he was the one who was out of place.
He saved the international papers for the real afternoon, when he was done with the American entertainment nonsense and ready for unabashed journalism.
But he had a gap to fill between ten and one, and on this day, he decided to fill it by solving the cat problem once and for all.
He got the same dispatch that he always got, a lackluster woman with a voice to match, who seemed to believe that people’s animal problems were none of her business. This time, he asked for her supervisor.
He knew it would take some argument, and it did, but he got transferred to a kind, caring woman who knew his property and empathized with his problem. But, she told him, all animal control could do was put down the rabid cats and the terribly sick ones. The county would fix the animals at taxpayer expense, and then return them to the place they were found.
Which explained why his feline population hadn’t gone down no matter how many cats he live-trapped for animal control. He felt an uncharacteristic surge of anger and frustration. How was he supposed to live here if the place was overrun with felines?
And that was the problem: he was living here. He couldn’t just move to another dilapidated mansion or a quiet ranch house. The only way he’d gotten out of the hospitals was to promise he would stay in one place for a year. One place didn’t mean one town. It meant one building, one location, no moving—not even once.
Of course he had to check in with the local psychiatrist who sent reports back to Bethesda. Joshua wouldn’t be approved for military access—no embedding—without finishing his year in the States. He could, he supposed, report the old-fashioned way—sneaking around, doing the work on the side—but modern news organizations required their reporters—even the stringers—to have military access. He’d have to work for Pacifica, who paid next to nothing, or Al Jazeera, which would make him suspect in his home country, or any host of other not-quite-mainstream news organizations.
He thought of all this while the supervisor explained her problems—the lack of funding, the lack of state regulations, and the lack of interest by anyone who didn’t have an animal problem—and midway through her discourse, he realized she had recognized his name and was hoping for a local story of some kind, one that might help her fund her tiny government fiefdom.
“I empathize,” he said when she took a breath. “There isn’t enough money anywhere. But aren’t there regulations about the number of cats that one person can own?”
“You own these?” she asked.
“Didn’t you just tell me that they’re my problem? Didn’t you say they have to stay on my property?”
“Hmmm,” she said. “I see what you mean. But then the cats would all have to be put down.”
“I thought that’s what you did anyway,” he said.
“Oh, no,” and then she started into another endless monologue about feral cats. Because he wanted her on his side, he didn’t interrupt. Instead, he thumbed through the want ads in the Oregonian.
When she finally finished, he said, “I need to get them off the property.”
She was silent for a long moment, and he could feel the disappointment echo through the line. He wasn’t sure why he cared. Normally he bulldozed past other people’s emotions. But this time, he recognized his own hesitation, and wondered if he was being gentler than usual because he was fragile himself.
“Before we invoke that state law, which might get you fined and maybe even arrested—” she suddenly sounded like arresting him was a good choice “—let me put you in contact with a local woman who is starting a no-kill shelter. Maybe she can help you.”
He couldn’t imagine these wild creatures being sheltered, but he figured he would go through the hoops. What else did he have to do? And if he got arrested for having too many cats, so be it. It would give him a few days to examine the local jail, and pretend he had moved somewhere else.
“Fine,” he said. “What’s this woman’s name?”
“I’ll call her,” the supervisor said. “She’s skittish with people. If she wants to come, she’ll come. If not, you’ll see an officer in a day or two.”
A day or two. The wheels of government worked slowly no matter where he was. He tried not to sigh, thanked the supervisor for her time, and hung up, disappointed that his great foray into the bastion that was animal control had only taken an hour of his time.
Maybe he would start the afternoon papers early, and go through all of his languages. He’d have to struggle with Arabic—it was his newest language and his poorest—and he hadn’t tried reading Serbian in almost a decade, so he’d see if his skills had atrophied.
But it would be good to revisit old ties. He was supposed to be writing a memoir after all; that was his official, non-medical excuse for hibernating.
He hadn’t started. But now, after two weeks of his own company, without deadlines or explosions to run toward or meetings to set up with the general staff, he needed something to occupy his mind.
Something besides cats and exploding cameramen and shrapnel, raining like hot flame all around him.
He hadn’t come home for that funeral. His grandparents had had the misfortune to get hit by a tanker truck on the same day as the Beirut barracks bombing that killed all those marines. He hadn’t even been in his quarters for his parents’ frantic intercontinental phone calls. When he heard the news, nearly a week after it happened, he flashed on his grandparents’ bodies burned beyond recognition like the men he’d seen around the compound, and didn’t even feel guilt.
People died. The living went on. That was the way of things.
He felt guilt now. He had loved his grandparents and he had loved this library. Maybe he would spend the year refilling it with books. Or maybe a half year, so that he could enjoy them.
He finally decided to go into town—his first foray since he had discovered that these days all a man needed was an internet account and a credit card to make grocery stores deliver.
Feeling decadent and a little rich (he never really spent his pay in all the years he’d gone from country to country), he bought himself two computers—a desktop model, which he hadn’t had since laptops were introduced, and a brand new lightweight laptop which made the battered ones that had gotten him through two separate war zones feel like anvils.
He was just driving back when he saw her standing in his driveway, her arms stretched out as if she were giving a benediction to the dozens of cats that surrounded her.
When the cats realized his vehicle was coming through the gate, they scattered. She whirled—and he got a momentary impression of an angry goddess, creating her own tempest. Then her arms dropped, and she tilted her head, looking like an ordinary and somewhat plain American woman.
He got out of the gas hog that Roxy had leased for him, and felt a bit of embarrassment. He had planned to get something that didn’t guzzle as much fuel—after all, he’d seen what the greed for oil could do—but he hadn’t gotten around to that either.
And he hadn’t thought of it, not in all the times he’d driven the thing, until this woman, whom he’d never met, stared at him like she owned the property.
“I take it you’re Joshua Clemon?” She had a bit of an accent that he couldn’t quite place, which was odd for him, since accents were his specialty. More than his specialty: they were necessary in his trade.
“And you’re the woman with the no-kill shelter,” he said.
She laughed, a sound like the bells from a French cathedral. “I am the woman who dreams of a no-kill shelter. Right now, I have a 20-acre ranch just outside of town where I pretend that the animals I take in are safe.”
“So you can’t help me.” He opened the back of the gas hog and removed both computers, marveling that he could carry the boxes as if they were briefcases.
“I didn’t say that.” She watched him, hands on her hips. She probably saw him as a rich, uncaring American. A man who bought expensive toys and had a dilapidated mansion to fix up because he had nothing better to do with his time.
“Come on in,” he said, nodding toward the front door.
She glanced at the gate, then at the woods beyond where the cats had disappeared. He sensed a reluctance.
“We can talk out here if that makes you more comfortable.”
“No,” she said, as if she just remembered how to be polite. “It is better if we go inside.”
Better for whom, he didn’t know, and if he had been on a story, he would have asked. But this woman was not in some war-torn country. Each remark she made did not have to be pursued and examined as if it were a puzzle to be solved.
He pushed open the door he had forgotten to lock and stepped into the hallway. His grandmother used to keep the wood floors shining, the occasional table beside the door spotless, and the entire place smelling of lemon polish. Now the floors were scuffed and covered with dirt, there were no occasional tables, and the entire place smelled faintly of cat.
He almost led the woman to the formal living room, where his grandmother presided over her home, but the living room hadn’t worn its formal dress for twenty years. Old habits, he was amused to note, died hard.
Instead, he went to the library. It at least had been cleaned.
“I still have some work here,” he said.
“It’s nice to see someone rebuilding the place,” she said. “It used to be so loved.”
“You knew my grandparents?” he asked.
“No, but I have seen photographs.” She extended her hand. “I am Galiana, by the way.”
He took it. It was work-hardened, the first he’d encountered in this country.
“Galiana with no last name?” he asked.
She smiled. “It’s all consonants. People here just call me Galiana.”
He nodded, not satisfied. But he would find out in his own way, in his own time. He set the computers beside his new desk, grabbed a wooden chair and slid it toward her. Then he sat on a step of his work ladder.
“You’ve seen my problem,” he said. “What do you think?”
“That the cats aren’t a problem.” She sat with her back straight, hands folded in her lap.
“What do you mean, not a problem? There’s a thousand of them.”
“Maybe a hundred, tops,” she said, “and this is their home. They’ve lived here for generations. To them, you’re the interloper.”
She clearly didn’t understand the scope of the problem. He’d met a lot of these well-meaning do-gooders in his travels. They were naïve and energetic and they had a vision, which often didn’t correspond with reality.
“They haven’t been here for generations,” he said. “There were no feral cats on the property when my grandparents were alive.”
She blinked, a surprised look. It was appealing. Different, maybe, from anything he’d seen before. She wasn’t conventionally pretty. Her features were pleasant, her face one that dozens of women had at her age—pale skin, blue eyes, rounded cheeks made rounder by the unflattering cut of her brown hair.
Yet there was something about her…
“I meant cat generations,” she said after a moment. “How long has this place been empty? Twenty years, right? For feral cats, that can be twenty generations. Think in terms of a hundred of your years. That’s a long time.”
“So you’re saying I should just let them live here?” He rolled his eyes. “Is this that politically correct thing I’ve been hearing about from overseas? Because if it is, it’s gone to ridiculous lengths. They’re just cats. If we were in Southeast Asia, I’d be perfectly justified if I killed one every day and ate it.”
Spots of color appeared on her face.
“I thought you wanted to save them,” she said in a small voice.
“I want them off the property. The supervisor at Animal Control wanted to save them.”
“Oh.” She studied her folded hands for a moment. Then she stood. “I misunderstood.”
He was sorry he had offended her. He had no social skills any more, not for real people. Only for people he was using to get a story or people he was interrogating for information. People he’d encounter a few times and then abandon, like he abandoned cities.
“Can you get them off the property?” he asked.
“I was hoping that they could stay,” she said. “The woods are large. I was thinking maybe we could find a way to keep them safe, feed them, and let them live their natural lives.”
So she wanted to use his property as her no-kill sanctuary. Not a shelter at all, but some kind of farm or ranch or something. “And have kittens every year? I’m already overrun.”
“We’d fix them, of course,” she said.
“And then what? They’d invite all their little friends, and suddenly I’m living in cat heaven. This is my grandparents’ home. I’ve already neglected it too long. I need to fix it up, not make it a palace for strays.”
She smoothed her hands along her jeans. He’d seen women who wore skirts do that, but he’d always thought it was to smooth wrinkles. Jeans didn’t wrinkle.
“I can guarantee that they won’t bother you. You’ll never see them,” she said.
“Or smell them? Or deal with their poop and their destructiveness? They’ve broken almost everything in the courtyard.”
“I think I can broker some kind of truce, yes,” she said.
Truce? Is that what he wanted? A truce? How many truces had he seen over the years? Every single one of them had failed.
“You make it sound like I’m at war with the cats,” he said.
“Aren’t you?” she asked.
“No,” he said. “All I want is for them to leave my land.”
“It’s their ancestral homeland,” she said.
“Oh for heaven’s sake,” he said. “It’s mine too.”
She shrugged and extended her hands. “See? Truce is the only answer.”
“They’re cats,” he snapped. “Cats can’t own property. They are property, and I want them gone.”
“What if I can make them disappear?” she said.
“Then do it,” he said, sorry he’d ever thought she was attractive. Sorry he still thought she was attractive, even now.
“Are you hiring me?” she asked.
“If you can guarantee that none of those creatures will ever bother me again,” he said.
“I can do that,” she said softly, although her tone seemed a bit doubtful. “I’m sure I can do that.”
Roxy was one of his oldest friends. They went to summer Bible school together as children, and then when they were old enough to realize that coloring cardboard cut-outs of Jesus wasn’t fun, they ditched Bible school together.
He thought he loved her when he was twelve. When he was thirteen, he realized she was too much woman for him. When he went to college, her letters kept him steady. When he went overseas, he realized just how provincial her world was.
She married twice, both local men, both terrible conversationalists. She visited him in Paris once—not as a sexual thing (after puberty, there was nothing sexual between them, not even a thread of attraction)—but because she wanted to escape her humdrum life.
Everything frightened her, from the double-decker tourist buses (giving guided tours in English, German, and French) to the Louvre (It’s so big, she said. How can you see it all? That’s the point, he said, You can’t.) to the restaurants with their deliberately slow service and complicated French cuisine (what is a cassoulet? She asked. A casserole sort of, he said. But what’s in it? She asked. Whatever the chef wants to put in it, he said.).
She left, deciding that foreign countries were for adventurous people like him, and he went to Somalia because Paris had been too civilized. It had always been too civilized, just like Oregon was too provincial. Whenever something happened in these places, it was too structured. Even the chaos had order—and what fun was that?
“I heard you met Galiana,” Roxy said, pushing her chair away from the table. They were in a local Italian place that had surprisingly good cuisine. The chef had studied in Rome, and it showed in the lightness of the sauces and the delicacy of the spices.
The restaurant itself wasn’t light or delicate. It was dark, paneled, and discreet. He liked it for that. He didn’t feel as exposed as he usually did in American restaurants.
“How did you hear that?” he asked.
“Because I’ve known her since your mother died. She was a nurse in the ICU. Don’t you remember?”
He remembered almost nothing of his mother’s death and funeral. He had flown in from Kuwait, eyes still stinging from the burning oil fields, and sat in the fluorescent lights staring at a woman who looked just like his great-grandmother. Nothing of his mother remained.
He had been too late, and part of him had spent those last few days wondering if it had been on purpose.
“I don’t recall,” he said, but he had a sudden flash of a memory: the doctor introducing a “healer” who could ease his mother’s pain.
“Just as well,” Roxy said. “Galiana wasn’t at her best in those days.”
And she was at her best now? Psychically in tune with stray cats? He was glad he hadn’t met her then. Although he should have remembered a woman with such an appealing presence. He usually did.
“Well,” he said, “she’s pretty strange.”
Roxy laughed. “And you’re not?”
Not among his peers, he wasn’t. He was just like they were, tough and broken and relentless. Sometimes he forgot that the whole world wasn’t that way.
“I figure you two had a lot in common.” Roxy grabbed a toothpick and shoved it between her teeth as a substitute cigarette. “That’s why I kept trying to set you up.”
It all clicked into place now. The dinners that Roxy staged during his first week home, the ones he was too busy to attend, weren’t just because she worried that he wasn’t going to eat well. They were also designed to take some of the pressure off their friendship.
“So she knows all about me,” he said.
“Not all.” Roxy waved a hand for the waitress, then pointed at her coffee cup. “But she knows you can be a prick.”
“Can be,” he repeated. “Hell, I was a total ass this afternoon.”
“She mentioned that too,” Roxy said, “and wondered why I even thought you two would be suited.”
“Why did you?” he asked.
She shrugged a single shoulder. “You both have the same look,” she said. “Like you want to be somewhere else.”
He had fixed the floodlights outside, but the light didn’t stop them. Instead, they copulated as if they were the floorshow at some expensive Italian villa.
Didn’t mating season end eventually? Was there a period when kittens got born and kittens got raised and the adults became serious and quiet?
At one a.m., he gave up on sleep for a second night, and went to his newly set up computer. The vast and mysterious Internet informed him that female cats went in and out of heat often, especially if the cats were well fed or in a warm climate. They also could go into heat shortly after giving birth to kittens. Males prowled for a sexually willing female their entire lives, copulated with her, and then got their faces slapped for the effort.
By three-thirty, the yowling died down, and he finally dozed off only to wake up at seven as the orgy chorus started all over again.
He refused to get earplugs. He hadn’t needed them during the bombings in all the various war zones he visited. He wasn’t about to get them now.
But in all those war zones, he’d slept when he was exhausted, not when he was supposed to. He used to say that a man could sleep through anything.
Obviously, the cats were proving him wrong.
Galiana entered, looking vaguely medieval in a long purple coat that nearly hid her jeans. Her hair brushed her shoulders and she wore no make-up, but her eyes glittered in the morning light.
“I’d’ve called,” she said, “but I figured you’d want this done right away.”
“I do,” he said.
The clothing suited her. She looked striking. He wondered how he had ever thought her plain.
She glanced at the woods. Of course, the cats were hiding there. They never gave the floorshow when guests were on the property.
“I need you to do a few things before I start,” she said. “You have to shut off the electronics in the house, just in case, and—”
“In case of what?” he asked.
She still hadn’t looked at him. “In case my equipment causes a power surge.”
He didn’t see any equipment. “What are you going to do?”
She folded her hands, and turned toward him, serene and glittery at the same time. “I’m going to convince them to give up this part of their home.”
That woo-woo language irritated him. Odd that the language would bother him here, in Oregon, but not anywhere else in the world. In other places, he would see it as part of the local custom. Here, he found it pretentious.
“How do you plan to do that?” he asked.
“Essentially, I’ll use a field that will convince them to go elsewhere.”
“An electrical field?” he asked. “Like those collars that keep dogs in their yard?”
She shrugged, but it was a European shrug, which made it a voiceless version of I suppose so.
“I thought those things were inhumane.” He’d gotten that from his middle-of-the-night reading, astonished that there were so many animal issues that people in this country got excited about.
“You were willing to kill them,” she said.
And he was. He still was. That screeching the night before still echoed in his ears.
“I just thought you weren’t the kind of person who would harm animals.”
She tucked a strand of hair behind her right ear. “You have no idea what kind of person I am.”
That was true too.
“You said a couple of things,” he said, changing the subject. “What else?”
“After you unplug your valuable electronics, you either have to shut down the house—all the curtains, all the blinds, and stay inside—or leave for a few hours. I recommend leaving. It’s safer.”
“Safer? How much power do you plan to use?” He felt a reluctance to let her even start. He had nothing of real value in the house, but the house itself mattered to him—which surprised him. He hadn’t thought anything mattered.
“Your house will be safe,” she said, as if she had heard his thoughts.
“But I won’t?” he asked.
“You are flesh and blood, just like the cats.”
“So are you,” he said, feeling a little odd now. “Can’t you get hurt?”
She shook her head.
She seemed very clinical in her approach to this. He would have thought someone who empathized that much with animals would be passionate about her work. But he recognized the detachment. It was the removal of the personality—the emotions—so that the job could get done.
How many times had he done that?
Only for his entire career.
“Can I watch?” he asked. “If I promise to stay outside your power range?”
“No,” she said. “I would actually prefer it if you left.”
But there was no chance he would leave. None at all.
On the second floor, he had installed blinds in most rooms and shades in his bedroom, not that they had done any good. She helped him secure all of those.
The first floor had only curtains, and as they swooshed closed, clouds of dust rose.
She told him to wait on the second floor and not peek out, no matter what he heard.
“What if you get hurt?” he asked.
“I won’t,” she said, and seemed to believe it. He was beginning to have his doubts.
She left him in the second floor hallway where there were no windows at all. She recommended that he bring a flashlight and a book—”always better to leave the electric lights off while I do this,” she said—and he pretended to take her advice.
When he heard the front door close, he went into his emergency travel bag, which old habit forced him to keep under the bed, and removed a cell phone, a notepad and pen (because he felt naked without them), and his binoculars.
He snuck downstairs into the library, pulled a chair into the hall, and used the binoculars to find a gap in the thick red curtains.
Then he camped in the chair, and waited.
The cats swirled around her. Even though the binoculars gave him a clear view of the courtyard, he couldn’t distinguish individual cats. They seemed to blend and blur, and they seemed content—although he wasn’t sure how he knew that.
Finally, she looked down, as if she were surprised at the number of cats around her, then glanced at the woods. More cats loped forward, leaping over the stone wall and landing near their compatriots.
More cats than he could have imagined. She was right: generations of them, at 10 to 20 kittens per year per female. Most didn’t live long—ferals had an average lifespan of three years—but that was enough to create twenty more cats per to fill the empty acres around his house.
A tiny black and white got stuck on the wall, then tumbled into the mess. Several females carried kittens in their mouths, other kittens following like ducklings. This alone was worth the price of admission, and he wished he’d taken out his video camera, but he had heeded her advice about electronics and had decided to keep it safe.
She was nodding at the stragglers, as if approving of their arrival. Then she raised her arms again—
—and the entire world exploded.
Dozens of other memories flooded him, mixing and mingling into one large mess of an aftermath, filled with dust clouds and a pale pink haze of blood. He brushed himself off, then realized he wasn’t covered with dirt. Nothing had changed, except that he had fallen off his chair.
There had been light and a flash-bang—and then the world had gone white.
He picked up the binoculars. They were fine. But his hands were shaking. His entire body was shaking.
He made himself go toward the window, terrified for Galiana—what had she done? What kind of mistake had she made?—and pulled back the curtain, feeling the dust cloud around him as if it were sand disturbed by a landmine.
She stood in the middle of an empty courtyard, smiling.
The cats were gone. There was only Italian tile, broken pottery and the remains of the fountains his grandmother had so loved.
No cat carcasses, no blood. Nothing to show there had been an explosion anywhere in the vicinity.
Had he imagined it? The damn psychiatrists had said that post-traumatic stress did that sometimes—took a trigger and made it replay an event.
But this had replayed hundreds of events for him all at once, and he hadn’t imagined it. He couldn’t imagine it, not like that. His flashbacks—which he’d been unwilling to call flashbacks until now—were just ghosts standing beside him: Stuben’s cameraman as his leg flew off; that child in Beslan who sobbed uncontrollably because he hadn’t been in the school the day of the terrorist attack; the fleeing and burning passengers in King’s Cross that horrible summer he decided to take a vacation in London.
All of them haunted him, all of them came back by sound not by sight, and the light came first here, not the sound. By the time of the flash-bang, he thought the world had already ended.
He pulled open the front door before he even knew he was running, heading hell-bent for the courtyard and Galiana. Running toward danger, like he had every moment of his benighted life.
Only this time, he wasn’t carrying a camera or a microphone or even his notebook (had he dropped it? He didn’t remember). He was running toward her, determined to save her, the first heroic act in his decidedly unheroic life.
And she watched him come, that smile fading from her face. The sunlight was behind her now—it was twilight? He thought it was noon—and it haloed her.
He was asking her if she was all right before he even skidded to a stop beside her, but he knew the answer.
She was fine. She was clearly fine. She had done this before and it didn’t seem to bother her.
Whatever “this” was. Whatever “it” was.
“You watched,” she said, and that took the heroic impulse out of him.
“For godsake,” he said, “that’s what I do. I watch. I report what I see. Did you think I wouldn’t?”
She shrugged, an American movement this time: I really don’t care.
He felt silly, like a schoolboy being reprimanded. “What happened to the cats?”
“You wouldn’t believe me if I told you.”
“You’d be surprised what I can believe,” he said—and it was true: he could believe that people who lived side by side would murder each other over a brown patch of land; he could believe that men could slaughter babies because they might be raised in a particularly hated religion; he believed that humans had an infinite capacity for evil and no one seemed shocked by this, no one except maybe him.
“I sent them to another dimension,” she said.
Whatever he had expected, it wasn’t that. “What?”
“See? I told you that you wouldn’t believe.”
“Believe?” he said. “I’m not sure I even understand.”
“The world,” she said. “It splits into various realities at each moment of decision. Or each important one. Parallel universes, your scientists call it.”
Her accent was even more pronounced now, and even more unrecognizable. Your scientists. Why weren’t they hers?
“In several of those universes, you never reclaimed this house. I sent the cats to one of those.”
“How?”
“The only way,” she said, clearly amused. “Magic.”
“Magic,” he repeated.
She shrugged—European again. Believe what you want or don’t.
“How can you do magic?” he asked.
She looked annoyed. “How can you write?”
“It’s not magic,” he said.
“Really?” she asked.
Her eyes still glittered. He finally recognized the appeal. A fanaticism, one that always drew him. He liked interviewing the believers, the ones who carried out the missions, no matter what side they were on. They seemed so certain. He was never certain, not even now.
He was still shaking, though, and his heart still raced. He wondered if the psychiatrists would think him cured because he had tried to save someone. He doubted it. The key was not to lose his composure, not to race toward the danger, but to make sensible decisions.
He doubted he’d ever be sensible.
“How much do I owe you?” he asked.
“Two hundred dollars,” she said. “This was less work than I thought.”
He wondered how much it would cost if it had been more work than she had thought. He grabbed his wallet out of his back pocket—relieved to find the wallet still there, after his fall—and handed her two hundred dollar bills.
She stared at them for a moment, then looked at the now-silent woods.
“They really weren’t harming you,” she said, and he knew she meant the cats, not the woods.
But they were harming him. They were reviving memories, interrupting his sleep, taunting him with relationships he’d never really had—even as wild and casual as the feline relationships were, they still led to families, to futures, to a world he’d long since abandoned.
He thought of the attraction he had felt toward her, and wondered if he had felt it because of that fanaticism or because she was the only interesting person he’d met since he’d come home.
Maybe it was a combination of both, but whatever it was, he no longer felt it. He wanted her gone.
“Roxy thinks we’re suited,” Galiana said.
“Roxy thinks a lot of things,” he said.
Galiana’s glitter faded. Her smile became rueful and she nodded, understanding.
“It is hard to stay in one place, isn’t it?” she said softly.
He looked at the now-empty woods, and sighed.
“Actually,” he said, “I think I’ve been in the same place for more than twenty years.”
And, he realized now, that it was time to change. To move. To be somewhere else. Which meant he had to become someone else. And wasn’t that why he was here? To become a man other than the one who watched and reported and pretended nothing affected him?
“Good luck to you then,” she said, extending her hand.
He took it, expecting some of the attraction to return. But it didn’t.
He smiled at her. “You helped me in ways you’ll never know.”
Her eyes glittered for a moment, then she slipped her hand away. He had the sense she did know. Just like he had a hunch she had known he was sitting in that hallway, watching her. Had she sent other things away besides the cats? A part of him, maybe?
She turned her back and walked to the gate, heading to her car.
He sat in the empty courtyard, silent for the first time since he had arrived, and knew he would get used to this place. He would make it something real, something important, bring back the beauty and warmth it used to have
He could do that. He was sure he could do that.
Now he understood. She hadn’t taken anything from him. She had given him something—she had given him a place away from the wars.
And, for the first time, it felt as if he’d come home.
Still Life, With CatsCopyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
First published in Something Magic This Way Comes, edited by Martin H. Greenberg and Sarah A. Hoyt, Daw Books, March, 2008.
Published by WMG Publishing
Cover and Layout copyright © 2023 by WMG Publishing
Cover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG Publishing
Cover art copyright © Ivan Piven/Dreamstime
To Get a Free AI Audio Version of this blog, click here.
For most of you, the main issue in this year’s Writers Guild of America writers strike is whether or not your favorite TV programs will be affected. Already, some of the streaming shows, such as Stranger Things and Cobra Kai have shut down due to strike issues. The broadcast shows haven’t started next fall’s season (except maybe premiere episodes) and won’t until the strike is over.
Some shows, like late night talk shows and Saturday Night Live! have already gone dark. Others may soon follow, depending on what happens with different unions, acting in solidarity with the writers.
For some of us, this strike has already had an impact. I know that my deals, which were humming along just fine thank you, are now going to take a hit that I can’t predict. Will there be more opportunity after the strike ends? Less? How involved are my deal partners in the WGA? (One is in Spain. Will that matter?)
I’m not the only person licensing derivative work who is wondering these things. I know of half a dozen book writers who just had projects paused or set aside for now. None of us know what will happen next.
And that goes double for my screenwriter friends. Those in L.A. have their picket line schedule. The others in various places, like Portland, are doing their bit on social media. They’re taking a risk, but they understand why this strike is happening.
In April, nearly 98% of the WGA membership authorized a strike if both sides couldn’t come to terms. The negotiations went late into the deadline night, May 1, with the strike being called when talks broke down.
For those of you who aren’t really following this, here’s the one paragraph shorthand. Every three years, the Writers Guild of America, which represents thousands of movie and TV writers, negotiates the terms of a Minimum Basic Agreement with the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers. This is a collective bargaining agreement, which all members of the WGA and AMPTP must adhere to. A lot of work goes into the agreement, and it really does protect the writers as best as possible.
If you want to understand how this all works, take a look at the FAQ the WGA provided on this particular campaign.
I’m not going to rehash the details of the campaign, the strike or even the potential impact. Instead, I’m going to focus on the thinking behind this particular impasse (and the 2007-2008 one as well).
For years now, I have written post after post about contract negotiations and understanding your rights as writers. This is important for traditional writers with book publishers, yes indeed, but also for indies. Indies, if they are successful, need to understand the Terms of Service they’re agreeing to, as well as the contracts that they might sign if they license derivative works (like audio or merchandising or (ahem) movies) for their book (or, more accurately, their intellectual property).
Contracts (which is what terms of service are) dictate everything about our intellectual property once we put it out into the world. Signing the wrong contract, even missing a word, can cause problems.
Let me give you a really clear example that a writer linked to in one of my blog comments last week. Mark Sumner wrote on Mastodon that in 1999, a series he worked on went from NBC to the SyFy Channel. His income for that series went from $240,000 to zero. “Because,” he writes, “my contract paid ‘per broadcast episode’ instead of just ‘per episode.’”
One tiny word. Broadcast. That’s what the contract said, and that’s how payments were triggered.
I’m sure that when the contract was negotiated, it was not common practice to move an active show from broadcast to cable. In other words, the contract language in Sumner’s contract was probably standard, and the change was unexpected.
It is the job of lawyers on both sides to anticipate problems. It’s also the job of lawyers that work for big corporations to find loopholes in contracts and exploit them so that the corporation can reduce costs.
I have no idea how many writers, actors, and other creatives got slammed with that one little contractual word in 1999, but I’ll wager it was quite a few. If you look at the history of residual payments from the late 1960s, you’ll see a similar pattern of behavior.
(For those of you who don’t know, residuals are financial compensation paid to creatives in the film/tv industry “for the use of a theatrical motion picture or television program beyond the use covered by initial compensation.”)
Early on, there were no residuals for TV. Then residual payments were capped at six rerun performances. It took years for residuals to be uncapped and to apply to things like DVDs and foreign markets.
It’s not just writers who must fight the industry to get proper compensation. Other guilds (like the Directors Guild of America and the Screen Actors Guild) have done the same.
Sometimes the Minimum Basic Agreement for all of these guilds strives to right past wrongs. As Patric Verrone, the president of the WGA West during the previous strike, told The Los Angeles Times in April:
We know from other work areas — like in reality television — that if you don’t get jurisdiction from the jump, you’re never going to get it. It becomes a really high hill to climb.
Jurisdiction. He’s speaking legally. The WGA tried to retroactively organize reality TV writers, with limited success. Reality TV became the go-to medium for the networks in previous strikes, because those writers were not even affiliated with the WGA at that point.
Gradually, the WGA has chipped away at the disparity, but it is a chipping away process, not an actual victory.
Because of that, and because of other issues that were not foreseen until they bit writers (and other creatives) in the butt, the WGA has spent this century trying to harness the future for years. The big win in 2007-2008 received a lot of criticism at the time. It was over “new media” which was barely defined.
At the time, everyone knew that the internet was going to be a major part of film and television viewing, but it was assumed that only a small number of people would want to watch their favorite shows on a computer screen. Streaming as we know it didn’t really exist. Netflix was a DVD-by-mail company.
Everyone thought that streaming would be an ad-supported business rather than getting consumers to pay directly for the service.
And yet…the WGA, the DGA and other groups held out for residuals from new media. At that point, the offer on the table from the AMPTP was zero. No money paid at all to writers if anyone watched a show streamed over the internet.
Getting the right to negotiate over a writer’s contribution to “new media” as well as an outline for residuals was a huge victory in the 2007-2008 strike. At the time, though, no one knew how big that victory would be. In fact, I remember a lot of grousing from my screenwriter friends (because another issue, which had to do with DVDs, did not get settled).
Now, though, everyone understands how big that victory was. Meredith Stiehm, the current president of WGA West, told The Washington Post,
If we hadn’t won that — 50 percent of our work right now is on streaming services and platforms. We wouldn’t have been covered for that.
It was a near miss. And studios are still mucking with the details. That’s one reason why the controversies include the difference between a “mini room” and a writers room as it has existed for years in broadcast and cable. There is also a problem that we book writers have to deal with in some of the platforms we use—a lack of transparency.
Broadcast media has to show the audience numbers so that it can attract advertisers. Netflix and other streamers can claim something is a hit without backing it up.
Because of that, writers are missing a major payment: the bonus for a successful show. As Vox explains in its very good rundown of what’s at stake in this strike,
In general, the biggest problem is that residuals on streaming are lower than in broadcast TV. If you write on a broadcast show, and it’s a huge success, then you get extra payment, in part because your show is bringing more eyeballs to advertisements or cable subscriptions.
But if you write, say, Stranger Things, and it’s a massive hit for Netflix, bringing in thousands of subscribers and revenue, you don’t share at all in the profit even though you’re a main reason the platform is succeeding. That, the WGA argues, needs to change. In negotiations prior to the strike, the AMPTP refused.
I know, I know. This is deeply in the weeds for many of you. You think it doesn’t apply to you—and if you’re not a WGA member or if you don’t have anything under development in movies or TV right now, you’re right: there is no immediate impact on you.
There might be, since there is an AI component to the strike, which I am not going to discuss here at all. Look it up. I’m not going to discuss it, because many of you will panic and jump to the wrong conclusions. Read about it, think on it, and watch how the AI component of the strike develops. That component might have an impact on the definition of “writer” going forward, among other things.
What I actually want you all to look at in this strike and in the 2007-2008 strike (as well as the three contract negotiations in between) is the attitude of both the WGA and the AMPTP.
They are both leveraging their power to secure their future. They don’t think of themselves as pawns of corporations (the WGA) nor do they look at financial and compensation issues in the same way (the AMPTP, in particular).
Both are struggling to survive and to get the best deal possible for the people they answer to.
As individual writers, you answer to yourselves. Whenever you are making decisions for your business, you should be acting like the WGA and trying to harness the future. You need to make educated guesses about which rights to protect and which ones to sacrifice. You need to assume that you will have a future. For your intellectual property, that future will last for your life plus 70 years.
That’s a long time. You need to defend it for yourself and your heirs. (Don’t have heirs? Designate a charity—a large one, because small ones can’t manage something like a writer’s lifetime of work.)
But you also need to read contracts and terms of service the way that the lawyers for AMPTP do. You need to make sure you leverage the language in the contracts to benefit your business and maximize your profits.
I would hope that you wouldn’t do it on the backs of other creatives who work with you. I would hope that you treat them with respect and as equals. But you might have to walk away from a deal or working with an artist you love because the terms of that partnership don’t gel with your business.
Is it hard to learn all of this? Of course. Most writers think it’s deadly dull and exceptionally dry, and it can be if you just read tomes about intellectual property law.
But watch the law in action. See how negotiations work. Take a look at the impact of small words like “broadcast.” Watch writers fight for their positions in real time.
This strike provides an opportunity for study. Do so. There’s a lot of available information about this strike. Read about it, read about the negotiations, and think about what each side wants and what they need.
Guaranteed neither side will get what they’re asking for. They will have to compromise. It might take months. Let’s hope it only takes a few weeks.
But the future is at stake here, and negotiators on both sides know it.
This weekly blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynruschr4e to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: Lessons From The WGA Writers Strike,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Images in this blog provided by the WGA.
As I write this, you have a little under 2 days to get your paws on the Cattitude Storybundle. I curated this, and it features wonderful writers and 3 exclusive books! Click here to get yours.
And, just to entice you, let me add the introduction I wrote for the entire thing:
Cattitude!My cats have gotten out of control. During the lockdown, I promoted a series of projects using my co-workers as a hook. The only co-workers I had at the time were the the cats who boss me around: The Mighty Cheeps, and his buddy Gavin, a.k.a The Boys.
I’d post a picture of them on Facebook, write a funny or wry bit about their terrible office behavior, and end with a bit of promotion.
Little did I realize that the demand for the antics of the staff at Promotion Central would become the highlight of my Facebook page. I’ve learned if I don’t include a photo of the Boys, or our new(ish) third cat, Angel, no one reads the posts. Those cats are more popular than I am.
It shouldn’t surprise me. Cats and the internet go together like chocolate and peanut butter. You can live with either one, but once someone combined them, well, there’s no separating them. Ever.
Of course, we’re going to take advantage of that. Cats and the internet becomes cats in ebooks. Since cats in books have always gone hand in glove (have you ever met a bookstore dog?), it seems only natural to put cat books into a Storybundle.
The best thing about cat books? It’s easy to find good ones because all of the best writers live with cats. Writers and cats are similar creatures. We’re loners who like company. We really don’t leave the house much. We have active imaginations. And, most importantly, we like to imagine that we’re the center of the universe.
In this bundle, we have cats who very well might be the center of the universe. From Stefon Mears’ The Captain’s Cat to the Collins’ brothers, The Interegalactic Veternarian of the Year, we have an abundance of space-traveling cats. We also have cats of mystery in books by Sue Ann Jaffarian, Robert Jeschonek, and Annie Reed.
Then there are the familiars—the cats with witches, the witches with cats, and the mage with very little magic who has an actual familiar named Ruby. That last describes my collection of short stories. Mindy Klasky’s Single Witch has her own troublesome familiar and romantic issues as well. Bonnie Elizabeth’s frost witch figures out how to get magical cats to actually help her. (Is that because cats with magic are nicer than cats without?)
And finally there’s the cat in the bookstore, Rhiannon, who runs the bookstore in Sea Shell Cove, along with her person. They’re dealing with all manner of things from ghosts to centaurs, with a murder to solve before it’s too late.
Yep, we’ve mixed genres here, even in the anthology, A Cat of A Different Color, which I co-edited. Because, you see, as far as I’m concerned, cat stories are a genre unto themselves. You need a cat of strong personality and a story to tell involving the cat. Since there’s a cat in the story, then the story involves the cat—
Oh, you’ll see.
You’re in for a delightful reading experience. If I could harness the magic of the cat staff at Promotion Central, I’d have them tell you to get the bundle now, because it’ll disappear in a few weeks. You’ll lose the chance to buy these books for a low price…and get three exclusives. Yep, three books you can’t get anywhere else.
All the books in this bundle are wonderful. All of the cats are memorable. All of the stories will hook you from the first line. You’ll be getting quite the reading experience for your money.
Oh, and before you go, do consider adding some money for our charity, Able Gamers. Able Gamers enables folks who are housebound to experience a life outside of their homes without leaving the safety of their place. (I suspect indoor cats would approve.) Able Gamers tailors gaming consoles and other equipment to individuals so that they can participate, make friends, and spend time with others, without leaving their homes.
Three exclusives, lots of cats, and a chance to help others. What a great way to start your summer. Click here for your bundle.
When tragedy took everything from Violet, she left home and never looked back. Until now. Her mother’s funeral.
Violet hopes she can settle her mother’s affairs and quietly return to the life she built after that day. Until she sees him. Skeeter Johnson. The boy who shot her in the face.
In a moment, her past returns to haunt her. A past she thought she left behind. A past, she comes to discover, full of her mother’s secrets.
“Her Mother’s Secrets,” by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story is also available in ebook through various online retailers here.
Her Mother’s SecretsKristine Kathryn RuschViolet had one year of pretty in her life—1976—and at the time she had been too concerned about her weight to notice. She remembered, vividly, obsessing about her fat thighs. She was so obsessed, in fact, that she never wore shorts or miniskirts, even though she weighed 115 pounds, and had, at that point, thighs six inches in diameter.
She discovered her year of pretty twenty-one years later when she was going through old photographs in her mother’s house, preparing it for sale. Her mother had died of pneumonia two days before, and left Violet the task of dealing with everything, the estate, the house, and the daily phone calls from her mother’s friends, asking for a memorial service. Her mother had expressly asked for a conventional funeral, and Violet had had to explain that wish again and again.
The pictures were a revelation. She sat on the middle of her mother’s floor, boxes strewn around the orange shag carpet, her grandmother’s rocking chair a hand’s reach from her side. The television was off, unusual for that time of day in that house, and she had changed the radio station from her mother’s soft jazz station to the town’s only oldies station. The music somehow added to the memories, made them jar against the images in front of her.
She remembered that time so well, feeling gangly and dumpy and flawed. She remembered using Noxzema at night and Stridex in the morning, remembered hours in front of the beveled mirror in the bathroom playing with her hair, remembered shunning makeup because she was too terrified she’d put it on wrong.
The photographs said she hadn’t needed makeup. The girl that looked back at her was not the one she remembered. This girl was slender, with dark brown hair in a stylish cut, clear gray eyes and a skin that appeared flawless.
Not like she remembered.
None of it was as she remembered.
None of it at all.
She had grown used to her face, but most people were startled by it. By, her husband once said, its appearance of normality far away, and its strangeness up close.
He had liked the strangeness, even at first. It was one of the things she loved about him. That, and his unusual calm. His great warmth. His strength and his protectiveness.
Her mother used to say, It’s amazing what gifts tragedy brings us.
“What a pile of crap,” Violet muttered, just as if her mother were still alive and listening. “What an absolute pile of crap.”
She wasn’t going to show him, she resolved then. She didn’t want him to know what he had missed.
But he wanted to know what disturbed her so, thinking it was her mother, assuming it was her mother, and Violet had said—no, yes, no. Ah hell, and pulled the pictures from the box.
They were different sizes—the school photo was large, and the rest were snapshots from various cameras, made at a time when that determined the size of the print. He gave each photo due consideration, studying it as if it were a window into another world. Then, when he finished, he gave each photo to her.
Her first prom, when she stood beside Skeeter, her robin’s egg blue dress revealing a trim delicate form that matched her delicate features. A laughing girl, sitting in a tree, the delicacy buried in bell-bottom jeans, sweatshirt jacket, and wide crinkly smile. The same girl, same tree, different jeans, different mood, brow furrowed as she concentrated on a book.
With each photo, her hand shook. Tom’s familiar face, with its sun-wrinkles and age-softened skin, seemed unfamiliar as he looked through the pile. Then he stopped at her graduation photo, taken only weeks before the shooting.
Her auburn hair was in a pageboy without bangs, the ends turned under her ears. She wore no makeup—she didn’t need any, not with her naturally rosy cheeks, her pink bow-shaped mouth, and her perfect skin. The green dress with its soft collar made her wide eyes look green as well.
Beautiful. She had been beautiful, not pretty. Tom would finally get to see what he had lost.
He wrapped an arm around her as if he had heard the thought. Then he set the photo down, and pulled her close, kissing the top of her head. He put a finger beneath her chin, lifted her face to his and pressed his lips against the smooth skin near the glass eye, the place where she had no feeling at all.
Yet she felt that kiss through every inch of her body, all the way to her soul.
She had spent most of the afternoon finishing preparations for the visitation: viewing the body, making certain that her mother looked as normal as possible—whatever that meant—setting up the guest book, and making sure the flowers were arranged properly. The funeral home had been built in the 1960s and still reflected its origins. None of the decorations looked proper against the blue wallpaper and the blonde wood.
Not that her mother would have cared. Her mother always understood the importance of making do. She had been a single mother long before such a thing was fashionable, working two jobs and trying to raise a daughter in a somewhat normal environment. Violet had hated it all, her mother’s haste, the slap-dash meals, the hard-fought home. More often than not, her mother dropped her at school while still wearing her robe and curlers. Violet always asked to be let out a block away so that no one saw.
Someday you’re going to regret always thinking about how things look, Violet Marie, her mother had said a week before the shooting. Two months after, she had apologized, as if the injuries were her fault.
Even though Violet was early, there were still half a dozen cars in the funeral home parking lot. Her mother had been well known and well liked in this small Wisconsin town near the Minnesota border. She had been the first woman CPA, the first woman to head an accounting firm, the first woman president of the Chamber of Commerce. The last illness had happened not because her mother was elderly, but because she hadn’t been paying attention to her health. She had been too busy on a new project—helping the church buy a building big enough to house the town’s first homeless shelter.
At least Tom was at the funeral home. He had brought his suit coat with him, so that he wouldn’t have to go to the house and change. He had thought people would arrive early, and they had.
He had been a saint through all of this, something she wouldn’t have expected. He had once told her that he hated funerals, hated the ritualized grief. Then his father had died, and he had learned why the rituals existed. Tom thought of things she wouldn’t have considered, because he had experienced a parent’s death already.
She let herself in the double doors, shocked at the darkness of the entry. The artificial lights were on, but they did not compare to the fading summer light outside. Piped-in piano music played hymns that Violet thought might be appropriate—her mother had only liked big bands, jazz, and swing tunes, and Violet couldn’t play those here, not in this somber place. The air smelled of lilies and death.
The guest book stood beside the door to the small chapel, and inside, her mother’s open coffin was bathed in a yellow light. Three people stood before it, their gray heads bent over the open end as if they were praying. Tom sat in a pew, watching them.
She glanced at the guest book, saw seven names besides hers and Tom’s, and didn’t recognize any of them. That didn’t surprise her; she had spent her youth here, but had been gone for twenty years—except for short visits in which she saw only her mother. Her mother had tried to keep her up on the news, but it soon became clear that Violet didn’t care about any of it. Gradually, her mother only told Violet about the changes, and Violet had listened with half an ear.
She slipped into the pew beside Tom. He put his hand over hers, and together they watched as most of the town came to pay their respects to her mother. They heard stories about her mother’s good works, about her sharp words, and about the battles she had fought and won. Only one person was tactless enough to mention the unwanted pregnancy and the mystery of Violet’s father, and the kind way the event came up didn’t bother Violet at all.
Toward the end of the visitation, she found herself in the foyer, surrounded by grieving people she only dimly remembered, and nodding to their words of comfort. She hadn’t cried yet. She doubted she would, not in this place and probably not in the church during the following day’s funeral. Instead, she planned to mourn her mother when she returned home, to the safety of her own house, and the comfort of the things she found most dear.
Tom was talking to the funeral home director, double-checking the arrangements for the body to be transferred to the church the following morning. She could hear their voices faintly beneath the conversational hum around her.
Then the door opened to reveal some final guests. Violet had been watching Tom; she hadn’t seen who had arrived, but the growing silence caught her attention.
The man standing on the threshold was tall and well-formed with a short professional cut to his dark hair. He wore an obviously expensive charcoal gray suit with hints of black, and his diamond cufflinks caught the artificial light. He looked as adult as a thirty-eight-year-old man could, and yet she didn’t see him that way. She saw him as he had been, a reed-thin boy, so thin that he had looked as if a single blow to the stomach would break him in half. His hair had been long and scraggly, the home cut overgrown already, a scuffed and cracked leather jacket around his shoulders, and his jeans dirt-caked and full of holes.
Skeeter Jackson. The boy who shot her.
Violet didn’t move. It felt as if every muscle had frozen. She was facing the chapel so she could see him, and the people she had been talking to had turned slightly so that they could see him as well. Tom was across the room, frowning, looking worried. He would be at her side in a minute. He would be at her side and she would be safe.
Skeeter—surely no one called him that anymore; they probably used his real name, such a tame name: Stephen—stopped in front of the coffin and bowed his head. He stood there for a long time, undisturbed, the posture clearly that of a man who mourned. Skeeter had never been one who could hide his emotions. She remembered him, fiery and quick-tempered, just as quick to smile.
She remembered the gun in his left hand.
He took something from his suit coat, and her muscles locked tighter. But all that emerged was a flower wrapped in cellophane. She squinted. It was a lilac branch. Lilacs were her mother’s favorite flower. Where had he gotten that? There were no lilacs in Wisconsin in August. It must have cost him a small fortune.
He removed the cellophane, stuffed it in the right front pants pocket on his perfect suit, and then carefully, gently, set the branch in her mother’s coffin.
No one spoke, but someone gasped. Tom was frowning at her. She had gasped. Tom excused himself from the funeral director and made his way to her side.
Skeeter’s hand lingered in the coffin for a moment, almost as if he had caressed her mother’s still face, and then he turned. His dark eyes met Violet’s and held them. Tom came up behind her. She could feel his warmth through the thin material of her dress. He put a hand on her shoulder, claiming her.
Skeeter didn’t seem to notice. He walked up the aisle, his gaze remaining on her. People parted so that they wouldn’t have to get near him, or perhaps so that they could better see the coming interaction. Her throat locked, and the tears that had threatened since her mother’s death suddenly seemed quite close.
It seemed to take him forever to come up that aisle. Finally he stepped into the foyer and stopped in front of her. His clothes were different, but his posture was the same: feet spread slightly in fighter stance, arms down, palms open, as if he were ready for anything that came at him. He smelled faintly of lilacs, and she realized that the branch he had placed in her mother’s coffin hadn’t been hothouse grown. It had been fresh.
“Violet,” he said, and his deep, rich warm voice—a musician’s voice with all the timbre and lyricism that implied—made her shiver. Tom’s grip tightened, and she knew what his face looked like without even seeing it: guarded, protective, warning.
Skeeter paused just a half moment—or had it merely seemed like that to her? Then he said, “I’m sorry.”
She opened her mouth, but nothing came out. She wasn’t even sure what she would say, what she wanted to say. The moment stretched into an eternity, her gaze on Skeeter’s just like it would have been so long ago.
“Thank you,” Tom said finally.
Skeeter looked up at him as if seeing him for the very first time. Then he slipped around the people who had gathered, and went out the main doors.
“Who was that?” Tom asked softly in Violet’s ear. But she couldn’t answer him, not here.
The funeral home director turned to her, the fake compassion on his angular face unable to mask the interest in his eyes. “Would you like me to remove the flower, Mrs. Davies?” he asked.
The room remained silent. Everyone was still watching her, waiting, hoping to see—what? A breakdown?
“Mrs. Davies?” he asked again, as if she couldn’t hear him even though he was only a few feet away. “Would you like—?”
“No,” she said. Then she too slipped through the crowd and headed into the hot August night.
“I haven’t held one of these in seventeen years,” he said. “What is it about you, Violet, that makes me want a smoke?”
He hadn’t looked up, yet he had known she was the one standing before him, the uncanny connection between them unbroken by time. The cigarette flowed from index finger to middle finger to ring finger and back again.
“I stayed in touch with your mother,” he said. He raised his head. In the strange light, he looked even more like a boy. “There’s a few things you should know. She—”
“No,” Violet said. “I didn’t come out here to talk to you.”
He looked surprised by that, by her vehemence, by the bitterness that filled every word.
“Then why did you come?” he asked at last.
“To get away from them.” She glanced back at the funeral home. It seemed as if she had been running from other people’s gazes ever since she was seventeen years old.
“And your husband?”
“What about him?”
“Were you getting away from him too?”
How could she explain life with Tom, the safety and security he gave her, the feeling of being completely and utterly loved? How could she explain the difference between that and the heady excitement, the razor’s edge of danger that she had once felt with Skeeter?
She had been very young. Foolish, even.
She took the cigarette from his hand, brushing his warm skin. He glanced up at her, obviously surprised at even this casual touch. She dropped the cigarette and then ground it beneath the thin sole of her shoe.
“Don’t ruin your life for me, Stephen,” she said.
He stared at her for a moment, then smiled, that crooked sideways smile that even now made her heart lurch. “Don’t worry, Violet Marie,” he said. “Once was bad enough.”
She went into the guest room and removed her dress, hanging it on a padded hanger that dated from the forties. Her hands were shaking. She had spoken to Skeeter Jackson. Finally, after all these years, she had found enough courage in herself to speak to him, to exchange words, to touch him. She felt sixteen again, and giddy with fear and excitement. How did he inspire that in her even now? She taught high school English to students she called “kids,” who were so young that she considered them unworldly and naive. They called her “Mrs. Davies,” and considered her so old she once heard an eleventh grader ask another when she had died.
When had she died?
She grabbed a T-shirt from her suitcase, and slipped on a pair of jeans. She left her feet bare. When she was sixteen, she had spent all her free time with Skeeter Jackson and thought herself daring. She had learned how to hot-wire cars and siphon gas and hold a gun. She had learned how to spot a cop car from the position of its taillights, and she had learned how to pass for a woman ten years older so that she could get in bars. All the while, she had remained the model student and the perfect daughter. Her mother was too busy to notice who Violet spent her evenings with, and Violet was too involved to mention it. Her mother hadn’t even met Skeeter until two months before the shooting when he came by during a small family reunion picnic wearing a blue nylon muscle shirt with small holes all the way through it, revealing his as-yet-unmuscled chest. He smelled of cigarettes and beer with the faint hint of pot, unfamiliar odors at her house, and her mother had invited him to share some fried chicken and to meet the relatives.
He had. He had been personable and charming, and he had eaten as though he had never had a homemade meal before. Then he had left on his older brother’s motorcycle, and her mother had watched him disappear.
“Looks like Vi has her own James Dean,” her uncle Robert had said.
“Every girl needs one,” her mother had said slowly, and then turned away. Everyone grew quiet, and Violet had known, from long practice, that her mother had just made a rare mention of her father.
She smoothed her hair back, felt the sweat on her scalp. She pulled open windows in the study, and gazed out of them at the funeral home where there were still cars.
Skeeter’s was gone.
Who would have thought that he would drive a Jag, that he would wear a suit that cost more than her monthly salary? He had come from one of the poorest neighborhoods. His sister had died two years after the incident, beaten to death by the local pimp. His brother ended up doing twenty to life for a series of burglaries, the last involving a gun and a motorcycle dealership. She had always assumed that Skeeter would end up the same way.
Skeeter. She would have to get him out of her mind. He no longer had a place in her life—he hadn’t since the shooting. She was here to honor her mother, and to clean up the home her mother had lived in for forty years. Not to dwell on Skeeter Jackson.
She touched the smooth scar beside her eye, felt the reconstructed bone, wished she could remember more about the incident than she did. It was forever gone from her mind, just a tantalizing hint of the night—the new drug Skeeter’s friend Jake brought, the buzzing, elliptical feeling that it gave her, the way the entire room seemed both larger and smaller. The sadness, the deep welling sadness, and the beauty of the gun in Skeeter’s hand. And then there was nothing except pain, the incredible throbbing in her head that didn’t leave for months, maybe, if she were honest, maybe even years. The hospital bed against her back, the pillow beneath her head, and the nurse’s voice, Anita’s voice, asking her if she wanted flowers from Skeeter, and the way she had screamed then, remembering the gun and the pain and—
She shook it away. That was why she never thought of Skeeter. That was why she never saw anyone from this town, why she visited only her mother, and only then for short periods of time. Being trapped here for the week before her mother’s death, and now for at least a week afterward was like being in hell, and she had just had a vision of the devil himself.
The house was finally getting cooler. The streetlights had kicked on, and given the room an odd sort of gray light. She flipped the green desk lamp that she had purchased for her mother on one of her last visits.
Her mother had kept her important papers in a box beside the narrow table she used as a desk. Beside the lamp were expensive pens—one of her mother’s few indulgences—including a quill pen complete with inkwell. The makeshift desk had a blotter, unsoiled by doodles, and it also had account ledgers nearby, all of them neatly labeled by year.
Violet grabbed that year’s ledger, and opened it to the place marked by the ribbon. Her mother’s handwriting, still the perfect cursive she had learned in grammar school six decades before, recorded each bill paid whether for utilities or a credit card, and each check received from the Social Security stipend to her retirement. Her mother’s bills had been up to date as of two weeks before. Despite her illness, she had sat at this desk and filled out that week’s bills, making certain that she remained a responsible citizen all the way to the end.
The bills were small and inconsequential. The house payment was gone long ago. Violet thumbed through the ledger, looking for the tax payment to make sure the property taxes had been paid, and also to see what the county considered a fifty-year-old suburban ranch house to be worth. The farther back she went, the sturdier her mother’s handwriting became. Cable, telephone, groceries, heat—fluctuating with the weather—electricity, insurance, gifts. The property tax payment might have been in the fall of the previous year. Her mother had enough money set aside; she had probably paid the bill the moment it was incurred. That had been how her mother had done things.
Violet removed the previous year’s book, and opened it to the ribbon marker. The only notation on that page was in red: underlined and followed by an exclamation mark. Paid in full! She turned to the previous page, and froze.
The notation was simple: 12/31 Stephen White Jackson (Loan: cf. 8/14/80) $42,125.14. It was a payment to her mother of forty-two thousand dollars. The repayment of a loan her mother made to Skeeter, three years after the shooting.
The shaking had returned. Violet left the ledger open and rummaged until she found the 1980 volume. She found August easily and turned pages until she reached August 14. The notation was in the middle of a pile of mundane bills, including one for Violet’s medical expenses.
8/14 Stephen White Jackson—interest free loan $10,000.
Interest free. Given to Skeeter when Violet was attending college downstate, and the other students were looking away from the angry redness that marred the right side of her face.
Why?
A door banged in the front of the house. Violet jumped, heart pounding.
“Violet?”
The voice was Tom’s. She took a deep breath and put a hand over her stomach. She hadn’t realized how tense she was until that moment.
“Violet?” he said again, and this time his voice was closer.
“In the study,” she said.
He came in, blocking the door with his large build, and flicked on the overhead light. “How come the house is so dark?”
She blinked at the brightness. “I was looking through Mom’s financial records.”
“You didn’t have to do that tonight.”
“I couldn’t do anything else,” she said. Her voice sounded strained and strange to her own ears.
He hadn’t moved, as if her strangeness had put a wall between them. How hard this had to be on him. He had known her mother for fourteen years and had respected her. He had to have some feelings about her death as well, but he never spoke of them, instead taking care of Violet, letting her needs come first.
He was a caring man. He had always been. That was part of the attraction for her. He was the only man she had met since the shooting who made her feel as if she were the most important woman on earth.
“I found something,” she said softly, unable, as usual, to keep something from him.
He came in the room almost too quickly as if he had been waiting for an invitation. He put a hand on her shoulder. “What did you find?”
“Mom loaned Stephen Jackson $10,000 in 1980.” Her voice was shaky and brittle, rather like she felt.
“Stephen Jackson? The man at the funeral home?” Tom was pretending ignorance, but she could tell that someone had already told him who Skeeter was.
“Yes,” she said. “He paid her back in full and with interest last year. I don’t know how long he’d been paying her before that.”
“Why is that important?” Tom’s question wasn’t about the payments. It was about the loan.
“Stephen is the one who shot me,” she said, marveling that she couldn’t keep anything from Tom now, but that she had never told him that detail before.
His hand tightened on her shoulder. “Then why did you let him in the funeral home?”
“I didn’t have a choice. It’s a public place.”
“No,” Tom said. “It’s not.”
“Mom lent him $10,000 interest-free. That had to be some of the money she inherited from Grammy. And she did it three years after the shooting, about the time Skeeter—Stephen—would have been released from jail.”
“Why would she do that?” Tom asked.
Violet ran a finger across the old notation, feeling the impressions left by her mother’s pen so long ago. “I don’t know.”
“And your mother never said anything?”
Violet shook her head. Then she frowned. “But Skeeter did. He said tonight that he had stayed in touch with Mother, that there were a few things I should know.”
“You spoke to him?” Tom sounded alarmed.
Violet turned slightly in the chair. The desk lamp illuminated Tom’s face, made it seem even paler than it really was. “He was in the parking lot.”
“Waiting for you.”
She hadn’t thought of it that way, but he probably had been. “I don’t know,” she said.
“And you spoke to him?”
“I told him I didn’t want to. I left him there. He didn’t have a chance to tell me whatever it was he started to say.”
“He’ll tell me,” Tom said. He was starting to bluster, his grip on her shoulder too tight, his body growing tense.
“No,” Violet said.
“He will.” Tom seemed to grow taller. He knew how to use his build to advantage.
“He might,” Violet said, “but it doesn’t matter anymore, don’t you see? Whatever was between them was finished last year. The loan was marked paid in full.” She smiled ruefully. “And emphasized with an exclamation point.”
“But it’s got you upset,” Tom said.
“Mother’s got me upset,” Violet said. “Skeeter Jackson is simply part of my past.”
Tom had gotten up before her. He had cleaned out the car, and taken it to a nearby gas station for a wash so that everything looked good for the funeral procession. He had pressed his own suit, something he hadn’t done since they were married, and then made her breakfast. He had even put the ledgers away.
It felt odd to be in her mother’s house, eating from her mother’s dishes, drinking her mother’s coffee, without her mother standing near the sink or reading the newspaper in her chair by the window. The house was quiet and there seemed to be a waiting in the stillness, as if her mother would come through the door at any moment, and flick on the television.
Violet hadn’t slept much, and she had gotten up twice so that her tossing and turning wouldn’t wake up Tom. They were crammed together in the sleeper/sofa, neither of them willing to take over the queen-sized bed her mother had slept in. As dawn had arrived, Violet had stood before the living room window, staring at the street. She could remember it in a million incarnations—with snow blocking the view, with a line of blooming roses between their house and the neighbor’s, with children skating on a thick yellow plane of ice. She had walked down that street with every boyfriend she had ever had—except Tom—and she had held various hands, kissed her first kiss beneath a long-gone maple, ran back from the seventh-grade Christmas Dance excited because Scotty Turine had danced with her.
Her sixteenth year, the boy who kissed her beneath the maple had been Skeeter. He had also been the first to touch her breasts, the first to see her naked, the first to discover the small mole above her heart. He had been very tender, and had shown remarkable restraint for a boy his age: he had been afraid of getting her pregnant, of having them turn out like his parents had turned out: married at sixteen, parents at seventeen, divorced by twenty. She had seen him as her savior and protector then, much as she saw Tom now, only with Skeeter it had ended horribly, shattered in a night she could barely remember.
And then she hadn’t seen him again, until the night before her mother’s funeral.
I stayed in touch with your mother.
And her mother had never said a word. She had loaned him what to them was a small fortune—which he had repaid at more than four times the original amount—and she had never mentioned that either. With that one single notation, her mother had become as strange to Violet as the road. Familiar only in memory, the details now tainted by a slightly different light.
Finally Violet had taken an aspirin, her mother’s old remedy for sleeplessness, and had fallen into a deep, dreamless sleep. She hadn’t felt Tom leave to do his errands, waking only when the delicious odors of bacon and coffee tantalized her nose.
Somehow she made it through the hours before the funeral, arriving at the church to find a group of elderly women in the basement cutting sheet cakes and making more coffee. She had waved hello to Anita, a Ladies Auxiliary member who had also been the nurse who had cared for her during those awful weeks in the hospital. Anita had smiled back, wiped her hands on a towel, and seemed about to come over, when Violet was called upstairs to greet some of the first arrivals.
The funeral itself was short; her mother had insisted on a standard religious ceremony. From the phone calls Violet had received in the days since her mother’s death, it seemed that her mother’s friends would have preferred the memorial service. They all wanted to stand up and give testimonials to her place in their lives. She had had to turn them all down, and give the remembrance of her mother to a minister that Violet had never met.
He acquitted himself well. He spoke of her mother’s life and her friendships and her generous nature; he only spoke of God a few times, and then in the proper context. The prayer was one that Violet herself had offered up every day since her mother’s death but had not acknowledged, a prayer that her mother would be as well received in the afterlife as she had been in this one. The music was beautiful, the service mercifully short, and Violet had only used one purse-sized box of Kleenex: a victory, she thought. Her Midwestern roots showed in that; she wanted to do her crying in the privacy of her own home.
She didn’t notice how full the church was until the ceremony was over. Every pew was filled, and part of the balcony as well. Most of the mourners went to the basement, while a select few attended the graveside service. Violet watched as her mother’s casket was lowered into a dark hole beside her grandparents’ graves, beneath a cottonwood tree that was shedding tiny white seedlings. It looked as if God had decided to create snow in August, just to honor her mother and her love of winter.
That thought, more than anything else, made Violet cry.
By the time she returned to the church, her eye and nose were swollen, and a new coat of makeup couldn’t hide the redness in her skin. But she put on what Tom called her company face and went to greet all the people who had come to acknowledge her mother and see her safely home.
As Violet started down the stairs, she heard the rumble of conversation. There was little laughter, but there was warmth. The air smelled of coffee, and she found that soothing. She rounded the corner, and saw the dining room was full. The long blonde tables were covered with paper tablecloths. On them, the Ladies Auxiliary had placed silver bowls filled with mint candies and peanuts, platters with tiny cake squares, and the china coffee cups that were designated only for special occasions. Each table had one Auxiliary member stationed in the middle: it was her job to pour and to make certain the food supplies remained.
Most of the mourners stood in small clusters. A handful sat at tables, mostly the older ones, and all around her, she heard her mother’s name mentioned with affection. People were telling stories, and she wished she could simply flit from group to group to hear those stories without tainting them by her presence.
She took a cup of coffee and a piece of chocolate sheet cake with whipped cream frosting just before she saw him, standing in the back. He was wearing the same suit as he had worn the night before, but he wore a black shirt and matching black tie that somehow made him look even more expensive. A few people were talking to him, but he wasn’t listening.
He was staring at her.
Warmth flooded her face. Tom took her arm. He followed her gaze. “I’ll make him go.”
She shook her head. “They clearly knew each other. He has as much right to be here as anyone.”
“He bothers you. I don’t think your mother would have wanted that.”
Obviously not. Her mother had kept her entire relationship with Skeeter secret, and she had probably done that so that she wouldn’t upset Violet. It was too late now; Violet was upset. There was nothing anyone could do to change that.
“Let him be,” she said wearily. “We won’t see him after today.”
Tom harrumphed as he always did when he disagreed with her, then he went to a nearby table to get his own coffee and snack. She would have to keep an eye on him; when they disagreed this badly he often took matters into his own hands. Whatever her mother would have wanted, it wouldn’t have been a scene at the reception following her own funeral.
Several women came up to Violet and told her how wonderful her mother had been and how much they’d miss her. She smiled and nodded and spoke to them softly, unable to remember their names. Others came to her as well, and the hour passed quickly. People had their coffee and their memories and their moment to tell Violet what they would have said at the memorial service, and then they left to go on with their lives.
She would have to reconstruct hers. But she had done that before. She was an expert at picking up the pieces.
“Violet?”
She started, even though she was prepared to hear his voice, even though she knew it would come. She heard his voice in her dreams sometimes, its warmth, its tenderness. Its fear.
She turned. He was standing so close to her that it took her breath away. How could a man’s face remain essentially unchanged after twenty years of living? His eyes had the same vulnerability, his lips the same self-conscious quirk, his skin the same lucent quality that it had always had.
“I don’t think this is a good idea.” Tom had come up beside her. He put his arm around her, pulling her close.
Skeeter didn’t look at him. “Violet, please. I’ve respected your wishes not to see me for the last seventeen years. At least let me talk to you now.”
“I don’t think what you have to say matters,” Violet said. “We won’t see each other again.”
“It matters to me.”
“She doesn’t want to listen to you,” Tom said. “And I don’t think she has to listen to the guy who shot her, not on the day of her mother’s funeral. Not ever.”
Skeeter’s beautiful eyes widened. He looked at her, then at him, then at her again. “Is that what you told him? That I shot you?”
“You did,” she whispered.
His lower lip trembled. For a moment she thought he wasn’t going to be able to speak. Then he said: “Violet, what purpose does lying serve? Especially now?”
“Don’t call her a liar,” Tom said.
Violet put her arm around him, in part to hold him in place, and in part to maintain her own balance.
“He didn’t shoot you, Violet Marie.” A quavering voice spoke behind her, and for half a moment, Violet thought that it belonged to her mother. She glanced over her shoulder and saw Anita, the head nurse of the children’s wing of Sacred Heart. She had spent as much time in Violet’s hospital room as her mother and grandparents, holding her hand, and telling her that there was more to life than a pretty face.
Once Violet had awakened to see Anita holding Violet’s sobbing mother. I don’t know how she’ll live like that, her mother had whispered. I don’t know how to give her a future anymore.
Just be thankful she’s alive, honey, Anita had said. A quarter-inch to the left and you wouldn’t have to worry about nothing ’cept how to bury her.
“You never got your memory back,” Anita said, “did you, honey?”
Violet felt the flush in her face grow deeper. “No.” Then she looked at Skeeter. “But I remember you holding the gun.”
“I took it away from you twice,” he said softly.
“But you went to jail.”
“Juvie,” he said. “For the drugs.”
The drugs. They had been such a part of that night. They had been such a part of that year. Her mother hadn’t known, not until the accident, and even then she hadn’t wanted to believe.
“He pushed the gun away from you,” Anita said. “You kept staring down the barrel.”
“How do you know?” Tom’s voice was so low as to be menacing. Violet tightened her grip on him. His presence was good for her, his voice echoing her thoughts. How would Anita know? How would anyone know except Violet and Skeeter.
“There was a witness,” Anita said.
Jake. Jake who had brought the drugs. Jake who had been laughing when she took out the gun the first time. “Where’s he?” Violet asked Skeeter.
“Joliet,” Skeeter said. “Trafficking charge.”
“He lied for you,” Tom said.
“He wouldn’t lie for anyone,” Skeeter said. “I barely knew him. Don’t you think they investigated? A good girl like her, a boy like me. It was his gun, and she had the powder burns on her arm.”
“Skeeter,” Violet said.
“Stephen,” he corrected. “Stephen now.”
“You didn’t try to see me.”
“I was arrested,” he said. “I had my brother get you flowers with money I should have used for the lawyer, but they got sent back.”
“They made you scream,” Anita said to Violet, and she remembered those, like she remembered the gun. And Skeeter’s name, along with the pain.
She closed her eyes. Tom tightened his grip.
“Then when I got out,” Skeeter said, “your mother said you were gone. And she wouldn’t help me find you. She said you refused to talk about what happened, that you’d scream or cry or leave the room whenever someone mentioned my name.”
“But she gave you money,” Tom said. “To stay away.”
Violet opened her eyes. So that was why. To keep her safe. The explanation felt good.
But it also felt wrong.
Skeeter—Stephen—shook his head. “She gave me money,” he said, “to go to college.”
Violet leaned into Tom. She felt her breath stop in her throat, her body so tense that she seemed frozen in place once more.
Stephen misunderstood her silence. “She was a good woman, your mother,” he said. His nose was turning red. “She told me that I had a choice. She said I could be like my brother or my sister or my friends, and end up in prison for the rest of my life, or I could make something out of myself. She said no one would take me as a risk now, that I wouldn’t be able to get aid or help or maybe even a job, not yet. So she loaned me the money. She put in it an account and paid my tuition and my room and board and my books, and she told me that it was an interest-free loan, and she said I didn’t have to pay it back if I made something out of myself. And I did. I own a chain of restaurants in Minneapolis, and they’re well known, reviewed in all the best magazines. I paid her back. All of it, a little at first, then the full amount last December. I paid her back with interest, and she didn’t want the money, but I had to, Violet Marie. I had to. Don’t you see? She gave me my life back. The only thing she couldn’t give me was you.”
He reached out to touch the right side of her face, the ruined side, and Tom caught his hand.
“No,” Violet said, bringing her own hand up to grab theirs. Stephen’s fingers were cold, Tom’s were warm, and the single fist they made was too big for her small hand. “Tom, let me talk to Stephen.”
“Violet—”
“Please,” she said.
He let Stephen’s hand go, then pulled her against him. She could feel his heart pounding, saw in his face his desire to stay. But this wasn’t about him. It hadn’t been about him from the start.
Finally he let her go and then he went into the hall. Anita smiled at Violet, then followed, picking up Tom’s coffee cup as she went.
“Protective,” Stephen said.
Violet nodded. Tom had always been protective. She had liked that. It had made her feel safe. Safe, she used to think, from the Skeeters of the world. But Skeeter had protected her too. She simply hadn’t remembered, that’s all. How strange her memory was, how fickle, and how her mother had never contradicted her, had simply let her go on, just as she was supposed to.
“What happened?” she whispered.
Stephen stuck his hands in his pocket, ruining the lines of his suit. “Jake brought the LSD, and it was a better grade than we were used to. You went first, and it was clear right off the trip would be messy. You got Jake’s gun. You thought it was so beautiful. You kept staring down the barrel, and Jake kept saying, ‘Take it away from her, man.’ So I did. Twice. And you kept reaching for it, like a baby seeing something pretty. Finally something else caught you and I thought it was safe. I was about to get high myself when I saw you had the gun. Your finger was on the trigger. I shoved it away—”
He stopped, swallowed, shook his head. She felt as if she were encased in glass.
“I’ll never know,” he whispered, “if I’m the one who made the gun go off.”
She turned away from him. She had to find a chair. Her legs wouldn’t hold her any longer. There were still some folding chairs out, metal, sturdy. The Auxiliary was cleaning up the cake. She and Skeeter—Stephen—were the only mourners left in the room.
“Mother knew,” she said.
“Everyone knew,” he said. “Jake ran, but it didn’t take the cops long to find him. I went to the hospital with you. I thought you were dead.”
She tried to see it from his perspective, the only one still sober in the room, the blood, the fear. But she couldn’t. She still remembered the gun, and how pretty it looked. That memory had never gone away.
“I don’t even drink anymore,” she said.
He smiled. It was a sad smile. “I don’t either.”
“Mother forgave you.”
He grabbed another chair, pulled it close, sat on it backwards so that he could rest his arms on its top. “She said it was all our faults. Her for not watching you more closely, me for buying drugs, and you for being stupid enough to try them.”
Violet swallowed. Her mother had never spoken that candidly to her. Had she?
“I still think it was me, Violet. You wouldn’t have done it without me. Without my contacts. Without Jake and his gun.”
He had lived with this as long as she had, and it had scarred him just as it had her. Only he hadn’t found someone like Tom, someone who had told him that the scars were a part of him, and beautiful for that reason alone.
“I’m sorry, Violet Marie,” Skeeter said. “I’ve been wanting to say that for twenty years. I’m so very sorry.”
She had her hands clasped in her lap. She unthreaded her fingers, extended her right arm, and took his left hand. Then she placed it against her ruined cheekbone. He touched the scar gingerly, as if it still hurt her. She put her hand on top of his, and pressed it against her skin.
“We were young,” she said. “Stupid. We’ve lived with this every day. Mother did her best to make sure there was no damage.”
“There’s always damage,” he said.
“But it heals,” she said.
He bowed his head. “I wanted to say thank you to her. I wanted there to be a memorial service so that I could let everyone know just what she did.”
Violet swallowed hard, the lump in her throat so large she almost couldn’t move it. “I don’t think she wanted anyone to know what she did. I think that’s why she wanted the ceremony she had. She always kept secrets. Your loan. My father. God knows how many others there were.”
He didn’t speak for a long moment. Dishes clattered in the kitchen, and a woman sang, softly, one of the hymns from the service.
Then he raised his head. “I loved you, Violet.”
She stared at him for a moment. There were lines on his skin, visible in the fluorescent light of the church basement, sorrow lines around his eyes, worry lines around his mouth. The boy was there, but hidden in the man’s face.
“I loved you too, Skeeter,” she said. Then she kissed his wrist, let go of his hand, and stood. She ran her fingers through his still thick dark hair, wondering what would have happened without the drugs, the gun, the shooting. Wondering if he would have a chain of restaurants, and she would be content with teaching children how to enjoy their lives.
She doubted it. She wondered if this was what her mother had spoken of, whenever she mentioned the gifts that tragedy could bring. How strange to think of it in a different context. Violet had always thought her mother had been referring to Violet’s birth.
Stephen smiled at her, nodded, as if he knew that the conversation was at an end. There was nothing more that they could say to each other. They would never exchange addresses or phone numbers or pleasantries. There was too much between them for that.
She left him, sitting alone in that large room, empty chairs around him.
As she stepped outside, the heat of the day wrapped itself around her like a hug. The sun had lost some of its brilliance and had gained a mid-afternoon diffuseness. Tom stood at the edge of the parking lot, beneath an oak tree whose roots were pushing through the concrete. He was rocking on the fissure like a boy.
She walked up to him and put her arms around him. He held her for a long time, his face in her hair, and she could feel him shaking. What had he been afraid of? That Skeeter would hurt her? That she would leave without him, chasing a shattered dream?
Finally Tom let her go. “What happened?” he asked.
She slipped her hand through his, and led him to the car. “I’ll tell you,” she said, “when we get home.”
Her mother’s home, where there were pictures of a pretty girl that Tom hadn’t known, where there were ledgers filled with secrets that Violet wasn’t sure she wanted to find.
But she would find them. They were all there, waiting for her, and she didn’t need to fear them anymore.
The first one taught her that.
Her Mother’s SecretsCopyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine, March, 1999Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2023 by WMG PublishingCover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Nikitu/Dreamstime
To Get a Free AI Audio Version of this blog, click here.
I’m writing this on the last day of April. I’ve been planning this post for months now, as the drumbeat of bad news out of Amazon escalated from rumors to asset sales to major layoffs. The reason I’m posting the date in this blog is because by the time you read this, there might be even more news that has somehow affected writers.
I’ve been worrying about this year since at least 2011. Maybe longer. I knew at some point, the world’s largest retailer would mess with their ebook program(s). Amazon is not a book retailer. They’re no longer a bookstore, and haven’t been one since the last century.
They’re an online retailer, currently the largest in the world by most measures, but they might not be number one by the end of 2023. Others are rapidly climbing the list, and aren’t suffering from the same kind of missteps that Amazon made during the past few years.
When big companies have bad earnings reports, the people running the big company must make changes—even if changes aren’t warranted. The CEO answers to the stockholders, not to the customers, and stockholders generally demand some kind of change…or the CEO gets fired.
In the past two years, Amazon has had bad earnings reports. 2022 was terrible. The company lost all of the gains it made during the pandemic. CNBC reported this on December 19, 2022:
Shares of Amazon have tumbled 49% in 2022 and are on pace for their worst year since the dot-com crash of 2000, when the company lost 80% of its value. Among the highest-valued tech companies, Meta has had the worst year, down 66%, followed by Tesla at 57% and then Amazon.
Keeping an eye on earnings reports, both expected and actual, are important for writers to do with any business they’re tied up in, because then the writer isn’t blindsided by changes that come from above.
The losses started in mid-2021, but they were small. Year over year, though, which is how most publicly traded companies now look at earnings, were devastating in 2021. After all, 2020 was filled with phenomenal growth. A year later, the growth was slowing, and by 2022, reversing.
Amazon made a lot of money during the pandemic and, like many tech companies, seemed to think that the gravy train would continue. Apparently no one in the company thought it through: what we were going through was a true Black Swan event. It happened worldwide at the same time, and no one alive had gone through anything remotely similar.
Rather than seeing the event as something unique, with its own set of rules, the people in charge of the tech companies decided the future had arrived. We would all be shopping online forever now, talking to friends and family on Zoom, and never leaving our homes. Apparently, these starry-eyed CEOs and prognosticators weren’t listening to their own friends and family, who were probably chomping at the bit as much as everyone else, waiting for the day when they could burst out of their little bubble and return to “living” again.
When living returned, the tech companies saw quarter to quarter losses, and many of those losses were major. Some companies are doing just fine because they didn’t expand during the pandemic. But others are doing poorly.
Like Amazon.
Amazon spent the newfound wealth like it was a growing start-up again. They bought or rented warehouse space all over the country, and added a huge number of employees.
And now, with the financial losses, Amazon is reversing a lot of those decisions.
Most writers wonder why that’s important. After all, big companies are just big companies, right? They have money. They’ll continue.
But they don’t always continue. Take a look at Bed, Bath, And Beyond. In fact, take a look at this article in Business Insider, which is illustrated with large bold subheads. It gives a quick overview of how a company can go from a juggernaut 20 years ago to bankruptcy and possible closure today.
For more than a decade now, I have fought with writers old and new about relying solely upon Amazon. I’ve written blog after blog recommending that writers go wide, and yet many writers never listen.
Most of them give me the same song and dance: Amazon is the biggest retailer in the world. It’ll never go away.
I have not gone back in my blogs to see when I started writing about going wide. I do know that I actually used the picture of eggs in a basket several years ago to encourage writers to go wide. And if you look at any of those old blogs, particularly from 2011 or 2012, you’ll see the kinds of statements I mentioned above littering my comment field.
I kept saying that someday Amazon will change, and that change will hurt writers, particularly those who tie their entire writing career to Amazon. The writers who have gone exclusive through Amazon via Select are really going to be in trouble.
And the trouble has already started.
Some of that trouble was built in from the start. What actually got me taking notes for this blog post was a Facebook post from one of the best-known Kindle Unlimited writers who claimed that writers never have a passive income off their work. Writers must constantly write and release to be successful.
Um…what? Really? News to me and most writers who have gone wide. One of the best things about writing is the passive income. If Dean and I quit tomorrow, we will continue earning for years to come. Sure, some of the revenue will go down a bit if we don’t put out new product, but mostly, the income will plateau.
Apparently, goosing payment through new releases is one of the few ways that K.U. writers survive. And if they don’t do it, they don’t get paid as much or as well. Or maybe not at all, given what he (and all of the people in the comments) said.
But that’s built-in trouble. Add to that some significant changes in the way Amazon is doing business.
In March, writers who are in Kindle Unlimited reported that their earnings went down. Lindsay Buroker posted this on her Twitter feed to warn her fans that her books would soon be leaving Unlimited.
The amount Amazon is paying authors for Kindle Unlimited page reads is on a pretty noticeable downtrend this year. I’m going to take my Star Kingdom and Dragon Gate series out of the program in a few weeks.
— Lindsay Buroker (@GoblinWriter) April 14, 2023
Smart move. And very smart to warn her KU readers ahead that the books will no longer be available through the program.
The financial loss for writers was significant. And it’s worse if you look at a historic timeline for the KU payments.
First, though, let’s go over what Kindle Unlimited is, and, more importantly, where the money comes from.
Writers who have their books in Kindle Unlimited must be exclusive to Amazon through a program called Kindle Select. Those writers get paid in two ways: they get paid for “page reads” in Kindle Unlimited itself—the program of all-you-can-eat books that goes to subscribers. The writers also get what the rest of us get: a percentage of the sales price if their ebook gets purchased.
None of these writers can go wide. Their fortunes are tied 100% to Amazon itself.
The payment for their “page reads” comes out of something called The Kindle Select Global Fund. The fund is based on the subscription fees paid by Kindle Unlimited Subscribers.
And here’s how writers get their share of the fund, according to Amazon itself.
The share of fund allocated to each country varies based on a number of factors, such as exchange rates, customer reading behavior, and local subscription pricing. Author earnings are then determined by their share of total pages read. They are able to earn a maximum of 3,000 Kindle Edition Normalized Pages(KENPC) read per title per customer.
First, I’m not going to attempt to explain the Kindle Edition Normalized Pages. Look that up yourself. But do look at that whole sentence. Writers can only earn a maximum of 3,000 page reads per title per customer. Which means if one of the writers’ books really, really, really takes off in KU, the writer’s earnings are capped.
And that terrible feature has been part of the program from the beginning.
The point of Kindle Unlimited is to bring readers into Amazon’s ecosystem, where they will then shop for other things. In other words, Kindle Unlimited is an advertising program, a loss leader if you will, to get people to spend money elsewhere on the platform.
The Global Fund’s payouts to individual writers have gone down dramatically in the past ten years. While the total amount paid by the fund has grown (because more and more authors/books are in it), the amount per title has decreased.
In 2015, the fund paid nearly 6 cents per every 100 pages read (which, to me, is a ridiculously small amount, on par with traditional publishing). By 2022, the fund was paying about 4.6 cents per 100 pages.
In March, the amount dropped to roughly 4 cents per 100 pages.
You can find the numbers on Written Word Media. If you want to see a chart, head to this chart that Daniel J. Tortora maintains.
The scary thing about the Global Fund—about KU in particular—is that it can be whatever Amazon wants it to be. They’ve already changed the terms of KU to exclude things that were once included, like magazines.
This a program that is Amazon-controlled. That’s important on the small scale—such as excluding things like magazines or dropping the rates—but it’s also important on the large scale.
Amazon can shut down Kindle Unlimited if it outlasts its usefulness or if it doesn’t earn to expectations. I’m not even sure what earning to expectations means. Maybe it’s not money. It might be a set number of subscribers.
Either way, Kindle Unlimited/Kindle Select exists at the whim of Amazon, which, in this fraught economic moment, is quite a risk for writers.
Amazon can and does shut down author accounts all the time for perceived and actual problems. Perceived? A writer friend of mine, award-winning and bestselling in both traditional and indie, had her account shut down for a reason that I can’t even remember right now. The reason was that minor. And terribly frustrating, because she hadn’t done anything wrong. But it took nearly a week of back and forths to get the account reinstated—and that wasn’t even in Kindle Unlimited. That was a straight Amazon account.
The problem is even worse for Kindle Unlimited authors who have pledged exclusivity to Amazon. As TorrentFreak reported in February, writers in Select have had their books pulled because the books were “freely available all over the web.” In other words, the books had been pirated.
Writers had their accounts suspended. If they could prove that their books were “freely available on the web” due to piracy, the accounts got reinstated. After a loss of revenue, however.
Amazon can remove books for any violation of their terms of service. It can be difficult for the writer to find a human to handle the complaint. It takes time.
Everything about Select smells of traditional publishing to me. The historically low payments, the take-it-or-leave it terms. The fact that a career can disappear virtually overnight.
This is why I repeatedly urge writers to go wide.
But it’s not the only reason. Amazon is clearly reevaluating their business model on all levels, and that includes books.
When Jeff Bezos was CEO, books and the book division were untouchable. Bezos started the company as a bookstore, and had a firm love for books. The new CEO does not have that love of books. He came from Amazon web services, and is proudly stating that he’s not going to run the business “the Bezos way.”
I’m not exactly sure what that means. Does that mean he won’t make the business as innovative? As profitable? (If so, he’s succeeding.) Or is that simply a matter of style?
Whatever the difference is, it is clear that the new CEO’s priorities are very different. In November of last year, Amazon announced that it would cut employees in its books and devices divisions. Shock resounded through the book world. Everyone thought books and Amazon were synonymous. Even if Amazon was having financial trouble, it wouldn’t touch the books.
Whoops. That’s no longer true.
Then the cost-cutting continued into 2023, and in every single department. 18,000 jobs in January, 9,000 in April.
All of these cuts have had an impact on customer service. The complaints about Amazon have only grown in the past six months, from both consumers and from writers. Nothing moves quickly at Amazon anymore and if there’s a problem, a robot deals with it first. I’ve heard more customer complaints about Amazon in the past year than I ever have.
I also don’t think it’s a coincidence that some vendors noted a glitch in the late April/early May payments. About the time that writers were fretting that they couldn’t get anyone to answer their complaints, an Amazon employee had uploaded a video of her firing on TikTok. She’d been chronicling her day, and happened to open her email account in front of a live video feed.
There, in her email, was notice that she had been fired. Her reaction went viral.
Employees aren’t the only part of the business being cut. In April, Amazon announced that it was closing Book Depository. Book Depository delivered paper books worldwide, using warehouses in strategic places all over the globe. The company was a boon to readers who preferred paper editions.
The fact that Book Depository disappeared was just further proof that Amazon is no longer giving special privileges to its book division. Readers no longer get special consideration. (Writers are only an appendage of readers, in Amazon’s view.)
What that means is that the book division now gets lumped into everything else. From the vantage of the people who run the company, the folks who answer only to profits and stockholders, everything at Amazon can be cut, altered and changed.
The new CEO came in and began cutting and retooling the company into his own image. He presided over the massive losses, which, to be fair, weren’t entirely his fault, and responded the way an average CEO would respond, with cuts that reduced pretty much everything that makes Amazon special.
The cuts did what they were supposed to do. The first quarter of 2023 actually was better than experts had predicted. But as Gizmodo noted in its April article about Amazon’s continued cost-cutting,
In the long-term layoffs are a time-tested bad strategy for a company’s sustainability. But in the short-term: big number go up, overhead go down.
Layoffs and cost-cutting also change the internal company dynamics. Amazon employees are claiming that the company’s culture has changed from a Day One company to a Day Two company. As Modern Retail explains the difference in an article titled “‘Day 2’: How cracks began to emerge in Amazon’s e-commerce empire in 2022”
The Day One mentality meant that, despite being 28 years old, Amazon still approached each day as if it were the first day of their brand-new startup. And Bezos often said that day two is death for companies.
Whether or not Amazon’s Day Two status will mean the demise of the company is far in the future. What it does mean is that Amazon’s position as an innovator and a company that prided itself on the customer experience is part of the past.
Amazon is a different company now, one that does not prioritize books over shoes. Both are widgets that the company sells. And if the book division is not making as much profit as expected, Amazon will retool it.
Retooling it might mean getting rid of Kindle Unlimited.
Writers who are exclusive to Amazon need to follow Lindsay Buroker’s lead. These writers need to let their readers know that they’re moving out of Kindle Unlimited. Then the writers need to go wide. The writers can and should stay on Amazon, but not exclusively.
Yes, it will take months, maybe years to replace the Kindle Select income, but that Select income has become unreliable at best. It will remain so. Or, it might disappear altogether.
Writers who are already wide still need to keep a weather eye on Amazon. They need to know what changes are coming to the company. Amazon is a behemoth, and even writers who are wide make a lot of their income in Amazon’s ecosystem.
Those writers need a plan for what they will do if Amazon changes its publishing program and cost-cuts at the expense of programs writers rely on.
I learned over many years that having a single client for your company is bad for business, even if client is a billionaire or, say, the biggest retailer in the world. Your business is inextricably tied to someone else’s business. If their business tanks through mismanagement or some unexpected surprise, yours will too.
The best way to run a business is to make sure your income comes from a variety of sources. At minimum, for writers, that means going wide. (There are other sources too, like Kickstarter.) This exclusivity thing? It only benefits Amazon. It doesn’t benefit the writers at all.
If writers stay exclusive with Amazon after the changes this past year, then those writers will get no sympathy from me when their businesses disappear one day, through no fault of their own. I’m really not all that sympathetic now. But I do understand that many writers are lazy opportunists. They put their books up exclusively on one site, did a handful of things that Amazon told them to do, and didn’t really learn business at all.
Because if people who are exclusive to Select understood business, they would understand the problems of exclusivity. They would understand that they were relying on a company that had no fellow feeling for them to make their living. They would understand that their writing careers were precarious and subject to the whim of an international conglomerate that can change its policies at will.
That’s not running a business. That’s covering your eyes and hoping for the best.
I too hope for the best for these writers. I hate watching careers get destroyed. For decades, I’ve watched traditional publishing shatter writers’ dreams. I have a hunch the next few years will be about watching writers’ dreams shatter as collateral damage in Amazon’s changes to its business model.
For those of you who can listen, please do. Go wide. Do it now.
Because you’re really and truly running out of time.
This weekly blog is part of my business model. I write these posts and put them on Patreon first. Then I put them on my website. I don’t control Patreon—I’m relying on their ecosystem for part of my income. But only part of my income.
I do control this website. (If I have hosting issues, I find a new host.) Whenever new tools show up, I evaluate them to see if they will help me build a stronger and more solid writing business. And if they do, I figure out a way to incorporate them.
So…as a reminder, this weekly blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynruschr4e to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: Go Wide or Run Away or Amazon Fail,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © Can Stock Photo / studiostoks.
I read a lot in March, and planned to write it all up quickly. But I had February to write up, and then some other projects hit, including a really annoying Spanish paper, and I ended up not doing much more than making lists. I loved almost everything I read, and what I didn’t love, I liked. That makes for an unusual month, but a good one. I also managed to read a lot because (and don’t tell my prof) I stopped reading the homework. She just recapped it in class anyway, and the reading itself was dry as dust. So I used that time to read other things, many of them fun. Since I liked so much of it, though, I got slowly overwhelmed by the writing/reporting task ahead. I kept putting it off. (And I’m getting a lot of writing done, so there’s that as well.)
I do want you to note how many books in my list come from my TBR shelf. Remember, writers, discoverability doesn’t happen immediately. It can happen years later. I’m just discovering some of these Val McDermid books even though I’ve been familiar with her and her work for years.
I’ve got a lot to recommend. Enjoy!
March, 2023Abramovitch, Seth, “The Flood of ’38 Sunk Houses, Roads, and Hollywood,” The Hollywood Reporter, January 18, 2023. This is a short little piece about a bit of Hollywood history I did not know. I was reading it during the record rainfall we had in Vegas this year, and it put a few things in perspective.
Coates, Tyler, “We Didn’t Make This To Be A Guidebook,” The Hollywood Reporter, January 10, 2023. This article is about the women who put together a documentary on the Jane Collective, which existed in Chicago pre-Roe. (I wrote about them peripherally in my Kris Nelscott book, Stone Cribs). The interview talks about the making of the documentary, and Jane’s lasting legacy, plus what we can learn from them. It’s extremely sad to me that we are now in a world where Janes might spring up again. I hate that. I think the women who made this documentary do too.
Cole, Teju, Known And Strange Things: Essays, Random House, 2016. This is an amazing book of essays. I highlighted some of my favorites last month and highlighted even more of my favorites below. (I read this book in the last week of February and the first week of March, which is why they’re separated out.) I’ll be honest: I loved the first 3/4 of the book much more than the last third. I wanted more discussion of art than I did about politics. But the whole book is amazing and made me do a lot of thinking. There are a million (well, maybe not a million but a lot) of sticky notes in my copy as well as a ton of highlighted sentences, paragraphs, and pages, filled with stars and exclamation points. Many story ideas for me, many revelations. I have another book of his essays, but I need to digest this one before I get to the next. I’m still processing, and oh, I’m so glad I found this book.
Cole, Teju, “A Piece of the Wall,” Known And Strange Things: Essays, Random House, 2016. Not, as some of you might think, the Berlin wall. But the wall between Mexico & the U.S. Yes, there was one before Trump. Cole is examining that area, and the politics of it from ten years ago. Made me remember when I was a news director, and we sent a correspondent to Nogales to talk to migrants coming across the border. Depressingly similar, as if nothing changes. I hope it does at some point.
Cole, Teju, “Shadows in São Paulo,” Known And Strange Things: Essays, Random House, 2016. I keep turning this essay over and over and over in my mind. Cole got inspired by a 1960 black-and-white photograph of men on rooftop. He decided he needed to know where the photo was taken. He went on a quest to find the exact location where the photographer stood. Sounds easy, right? But cities change in 60+ years and he was having a lot of trouble figuring it out. I’m not going to spoil the moment of discovery for you, but it makes for a memorable piece from a memorable photograph.
Cole, Teju, “Touching Strangers,” Known And Strange Things: Essays, Random House, 2016. This book is filled with pictures, many of which Cole took himself. The ones he did not take are the subject of some of the essays herein. I look at the pictures before I read a book because–hey–I’m human, okay. And there was one photo that really disturbed me. It was of white cop in full uniform with his arm around the neck of a young girl wearing a flag t-shirt and cutoffs. Both of the cop and the girl look uncomfortable. When I saw the photo, I thought maybe they were a couple in a horrid relationship. I couldn’t quite parse it out.
Turns out that they were part of a project by photographer Richard Reynaldi called “Touching Strangers.” The project is exactly what you think. Reynaldi would ask strangers if they would pose together for a photo, and if they would allow him to pose them. That’s what this photo is: two people who had never previously met who were posed into this disturbing shot. Cole uses this essay to explore a lot of different things. He starts by discussing how photographs are nothing but surface…except in the hands of a truly skilled photographer. This essay–and that photo–are worth the price of admission.
Cole, Teju, “The White Savior Industrial Complex,” Known And Strange Things: Essays, Random House, 2016. Heartbreaking, pointed essay on exactly what the title says. I read this essay twice, underlined a lot of it, and thought even more about it. What saddens me about it (and oh, there’s so much that saddens me) is that the essay was written maybe 10 years ago, and it feels like nothing has changed. Quite sad.
Feinberg, Scott, “Expectation is a Dangerous Thing,” The Hollywood Reporter, January 11, 2023. This is a roundtable with the possible Best Actor contenders for the Oscar, before they won, of course. It’s a good read. I love these round tables. But I really like this quote from Jeremy Pope:
“Audiences are unreliable, but you are not.” When you do the work and investigate and excavate and find out your why, the sky can be the limit. They will always be unreliable, but when you do those things, you are not.
In other words, trust yourself and your process. That works in all of the arts.
Keegan, Rebecca, “I’ve Grown Into Myself,” The Hollywood Reporter, January 27, 2023. A wonderful interview with Jane Fonda, filled with a lot of tidbits, including this one:
I’m not scared of dying. I think I’m telling the truth when I say that,” Fonda says. “But I am really scared of getting to the end with a lot of regrets when it’s too late to do anything. And when you figure that out, it instructs the way you live between now and the end.
As I’m getting older, I’m looking to others for wisdom on seeing the final third of my life. I like that quote. It focused me at a time I needed the focus. The entire interview is like that. Worth reading.
Kilkenny, Katie & Cho, Winston, “Attack of the AI Bots: Screenwriter Friend or Foe?” The Hollywood Reporter, January 11, 2023. If you read my blog, you’ll find a reference to this article. There’s a sidebar in which an actual screenwriter critiques some pitches written by ChatGPT. But there’s more here, with some analysis, and it’s all worth reading.
McDermid, Val, Broken Ground, Grove Atlantic 2019. After reading the Distant Echo in February, I looked up the Karen Pirie series and tried to decide if I wanted to read more. A few of the write-ups led me to believe that those particular books weren’t for me. So I skipped them. I missed some big events in Pirie’s life, a romance, a death, and a promotion, but honestly, I didn’t care. I caught up well enough. I wasn’t about to read about dead kids to get through the entire series. Weirdly, the books are titled such that you’re seeing my opinions in reverse reading order. This is the most recent one I read, from 2019, after I had read the other two listed below.
Karin Pirie investigates cold cases in Scotland, and this one involves a body found in a peat bog, pretty well preserved. The body’s underneath motorcycles, which were also buried. Lots of questions here, and some real twists. I did not figure the book out until McDermid wanted me to, which is a heck of a recommendation from me.
Each book in this series builds on the last, so if you are going to read the series, do so in order.
McDermid, Val, Out of Bounds, Sphere, 2017. I love how this book opens and what it leads to. Some kids go joyriding, and it ends badly. Investigators get called in, only to discover that the surviving driver’s DNA is a familial match for DNA in the system for a rape in the 1990s. The kid is a teenager, so obviously not him. Probably his father. But finding that father isn’t as straightforward as you’d think. And then the case gets really twisty, along with other cases that tie in. The only part of these books that I don’t like is the trope that every competent investigator must fight the brass, and the brass is stupid. I’m soooo tired of that.
Otherwise, the book is my favorite of the three I mention here.
McDermid, Val, The Skeleton Road, Sphere, 2015. I wasn’t sure I was going to like this book. I had very much liked Distant Echo, but the write-up of this one online made it sound like it was all about the Balkans. I really wasn’t that interested. But, I figured, I’d give it a try. I’m glad I did.
Climbers find a skeleton on a rooftop in Edinburgh. It leads to a mess, including a woman who believes she’s been abandoned by her charismatic lover. Lots of betrayal and secrets, lots of sad and aching people, including our heroine, who has lost someone she cares about very much. Well written and interesting with good characters, this book convinced me to read the others (except the dead children books).
Olson, Kayla, The Reunion, Atria, 2023. This is Kris Popcorn. I read about the book in a magazine and thought, Yep, sounds like my kind of book, and I ordered it. Then I had one of those pull-a-blanket-over-your head days, and thought I needed popcorn. So I read this. The book is about a former child star who tried to fix her life after a bunch of issues. The network has set up a reunion special and she’s going to reunite with her love interest on the show who is (not coincidentally) also the guy who broke her heart.
The writing is snappy, if thin on setting, and the characters are grand. The book is deliberately frothy. Kayla Olson write it during the worst of the pandemic when she needed an escape. What she ended up doing was providing a romantic escape for everyone else. This was a great deal of fun.
Paterson, Lesley, “Writing Is All About The Long Game,” The Hollywood Reporter, January 10, 2023. This wonderful essay is in the middle of some of the coverage for the Oscars. Every year, during awards season, The Hollywood Reporter puts out many, many, many extra issues, and it takes me forever to read through them. I’m glad I did.
Lesley Paterson is the screenwriter/producer for the remake of All Quiet on The Western Front. She’s also a world champion triathlete. She equates writing and being a triathlete. She also writes about her 263rd race as a triathlete in 105 degree heat, after she had crashed her bike. She had a broken shoulder and she needed to do the swim. She knew she could run, but swim? She needed to win this race so that she had enough money to option the book for her movie. I kid you not. Read this thing. It’s amazing.
Provost, Megan, “Mendota Remembers,” On Wisconsin, Fall, 2022. An unbelievably cool article about a discovery on Lake Mendota in Madison, Wisconsin. An archeologist was diving for a completely recreational reason when she saw what looked like a canoe. It was. An ancient one, from 800 C.E. by ancestors of the Ho Chunk Nation. In a lake that people dive all the time. A lake that’s constantly filled with activity.
The article is about the discovery, the recovery of this delicate canoe, and all of the work it took to confirm the find. Read this. It’s soooo cool.
Riedel, Michael, “How Hollywood Director Cameron Crowe Rebooted Almost Famous For Broadway,” Vanity Fair, October, 2022. I love articles on derivative works. I really love articles on how they get conceived and made. Cameron Crowe made a movie about his youth, featuring his mother, and that movie became something bigger than he was. Decades later, the opportunity to make it into something for Broadway arose as his mother was dying. (Prepandemic.) This is a sad and triumphant little piece about life and art and some other things in between.
Shelton, Ron, The Church of Baseball: The Making of Bull Durham: Home Runs, Bad Calls, Crazy Fights, Big Swings, And A Hit, Alfred A. Knopf, 2022. I loved this book, but it made me sad too. I’ll get to the sad part in a minute. The book itself is a lot of fun. I loved Bull Durham and the book helped me remember much about it. It also reminded me (before the Writer’s strike) just how much of TV/movie-making is serendipity and/or having the right people in the right place at the right time.
So…what made me sad? Agents. What else. Shelton writes this in his final chapter:
White Men Can’t Jump, which I wrote, directed, and coproduced four years after Bull Durham and was a bigger commercial success, is being remade by a writer-producer I don’t know. I called my agents to protest. They confessed that not only was it true, but they had packaged the remake idea and represented the filmmaker. Welcome to the movie business. It may be a betrayal, but it’s a betrayal within industry standards.
Me, I’d’ve fired those assholes. Apparently, Shelton shrugged and moved on. That’s why he can stomach working in Hollywood and I can’t.
There’s lot of other tidbits in here, baseball, writing, and otherwise. I think you’ll like it as much as I did.
I read a lot in March, and planned to write it all up quickly. But I had February to write up, and then some other projects hit, including a really annoying Spanish paper, and I ended up not doing much more than making lists. I loved almost everything I read, and what I didn’t love, I liked. That makes for an unusual month, but a good one. I also managed to read a lot because (and don’t tell my prof) I stopped reading the homework. She just recapped it in class anyway, and the reading itself was dry as dust. So I used that time to read other things, many of them fun. Since I liked so much of it, though, I got slowly overwhelmed by the writing/reporting task ahead. I kept putting it off. (And I’m getting a lot of writing done, so there’s that as well.)
I’ve got a lot to recommend. Enjoy!
March, 2023Cole, Teju, Known And Strange Things: Essays, Random House, 2016. This is an amazing book of essays. I highlighted some of my favorites last month and highlighted even more of my favorites below. (I read this book in the last week of February and the first week of March, which is why they’re separated out.) I’ll be honest: I loved the first 3/4 of the book much more than the last third. I wanted more discussion of art than I did about politics. But the whole book is amazing and made me do a lot of thinking. There are a million (well, maybe not a million but a lot) of sticky notes in my copy as well as a ton of highlighted sentences, paragraphs, and pages, filled with stars and exclamation points. Many story ideas for me, many revelations. I have another book of his essays, but I need to digest this one before I get to the next. I’m still processing, and oh, I’m so glad I found this book.
Cole, Teju, “A Piece of the Wall,” Known And Strange Things: Essays, Random House, 2016. Not, as some of you might think, the Berlin wall. But the wall between Mexico & the U.S. Yes, there was one before Trump. Cole is examining that area, and the politics of it from ten years ago. Made me remember when I was a news director, and we sent a correspondent to Nogales to talk to migrants coming across the border. Depressingly similar, as if nothing changes. I hope it does at some point.
Cole, Teju, “Shadows in São Paulo,” Known And Strange Things: Essays, Random House, 2016. I keep turning this essay over and over and over in my mind. Cole got inspired by a 1960 black-and-white photograph of men on rooftop. He decided he needed to know where the photo was taken. He went on a quest to find the exact location where the photographer stood. Sounds easy, right? But cities change in 60+ years and he was having a lot of trouble figuring it out. I’m not going to spoil the moment of discovery for you, but it makes for a memorable piece from a memorable photograph.
Cole, Teju, “Touching Strangers,” Known And Strange Things: Essays, Random House, 2016. This book is filled with pictures, many of which Cole took himself. The ones he did not take are the subject of some of the essays herein. I look at the pictures before I read a book because–hey–I’m human, okay. And there was one photo that really disturbed me. It was of white cop in full uniform with his arm around the neck of a young girl wearing a flag t-shirt and cutoffs. Both of the cop and the girl look uncomfortable. When I saw the photo, I thought maybe they were a couple in a horrid relationship. I couldn’t quite parse it out.
Turns out that they were part of a project by photographer Richard Reynaldi called “Touching Strangers.” The project is exactly what you think. Reynaldi would ask strangers if they would pose together for a photo, and if they would allow him to pose them. That’s what this photo is: two people who had never previously met who were posed into this disturbing shot. Cole uses this essay to explore a lot of different things. He starts by discussing how photographs are nothing but surface…except in the hands of a truly skilled photographer. This essay–and that photo–are worth the price of admission.
Cole, Teju, “The White Savior Industrial Complex,” Known And Strange Things: Essays, Random House, 2016. Heartbreaking, pointed essay on exactly what the title says. I read this essay twice, underlined a lot of it, and thought even more about it. What saddens me about it (and oh, there’s so much that saddens me) is that the essay was written maybe 10 years ago, and it feels like nothing has changed. Quite sad.
Olson, Kayla, The Reunion, Atria, 2023. This is Kris Popcorn. I read about the book in a magazine and thought, Yep, sounds like my kind of book, and I ordered it. Then I had one of those pull-a-blanket-over-your head days, and thought I needed popcorn. So I read this. The book is about a former child star who tried to fix her life after a bunch of issues. The network has set up a reunion special and she’s going to reunite with her love interest on the show who is (not coincidentally) also the guy who broke her heart.
The writing is snappy, if thin on setting, and the characters are grand. The book is deliberately frothy. Kayla Olson write it during the worst of the pandemic when she needed an escape. What she ended up doing was providing a romantic escape for everyone else. This was a great deal of fun.
Roz knows that men distrust women in any profession. But when the men from Wells Fargo need a photograph of the man who tried to rob their stage coach, Roz becomes their only choice.
She agrees to photograph the prisoner, but only on her terms—and her terms prove unique, indeed.
“Knowing Jack” by bestselling author Kristine Grayson is free on this website for one week only. The story is also available in ebook here and is included in the collection Geek Romance, which is available in ebook and trade paperback here.
Knowing JackA Roz & Jack StoryKristine GraysonRoz tugged the darkroom door shut and locked it, slipping the key into the pocket of her long black skirt. The stench dissipated a little, although the studio smelled strongly of chemicals, a scent that never entirely vanished.
She leaned against the door and listened, hearing nothing. Good solid oak blocked the smells and the sound. Fortunately no one had entered the studio while she had been in the dark room. She wasn’t quite ready to handle customers.
The studio was large, given the size of Lattville. The town had decided to rename itself just recently. Most of its signs still read Lateville, so named because many of the miners who had arrived here before the war thought they had missed all the gold.
They hadn’t. The actual name of the town should have been Earlyville, since most of those miners were long gone by the time gold had actually been discovered. Lattville grew, thanks to the discovery and the fact that it was a stop on the main stagecoach route that covered Northern California.
Even so, despite Lattville’s size, a fair number of people had found their way into this studio. Portraits of the latest governor hung on the wall, alongside one of California’s senators, and the former presidential candidate John C. Fremont.
More portraits cluttered the floor behind the main desk, where visitors signed in and paid their bills. A brocade divan sat at one end of the room, a conventional sofa and rocking chair grouping at the other.
The studio was utterly silent and hot. The windows didn’t open, making the place oppressive. She made her way through the clutter to the business desk, stopping to look at the family portrait prominently displayed on the wall behind her.
The portrait had been taken outside and the girls had lined up in age order, getting their pretty white dresses stained with grass. Roz ran her fingers across the white painted date, unable to believe that the portrait was ten years old. The vivid expressions on the faces made it seem newer somehow.
Roz glanced at the full-length mirror nearby. The studio provided it so that clients could check their appearance before getting a portrait taken. She almost didn’t recognize herself. Age had changed her face, making it narrower, lining it. The carefree look she’d had as a girl was gone now.
Too many years of struggle. Too much hardship.
She tucked a loose strand of brown hair behind her ear. The white blouse already showed the wear of the day and the black skirt had flakes of dirt or dust or something on it. She brushed at the skirt and then straightened, putting a hand behind her back. She hated corsets. They always left her short of breath.
But today she had to look presentable.
At that moment, the studio door opened. She turned.
The men standing in the doorway had clearly not come for a portrait. The tall man had piercing blue eyes and a strength to his face. His boots were muddy and left a trail on the runner just inside the door. The second man was shorter, older, and balding. He looked both official and apologetic.
“Mrs. Driscoll?” he asked, then stepped forward, hands out. “I almost didn’t recognize you, my dear. What has it been? Eight years?”
Roz had no idea. She didn’t recognize him at all. “At least that.”
He took her hands and smiled at her. “How is your husband?”
“He’s been busy of late.”
The balding man nodded. Behind him, the tall man cleared his throat.
“I’m afraid this isn’t a social call, m’dear,” the balding man said. “I’m looking for your father.”
Roz was prepared for this. She squeezed the balding man’s hands. “I’m minding the store today.”
“I can see that, but—”
“Let me, sheriff,” the tall man said. “This is a matter of some urgency. Where is Mr. Cooper?”
“Dealing with family matters,” Roz said. “Can I help you?”
“This isn’t a job for a woman,” the tall man said.
Roz gave him a small smile. “I’ve been around photography and portraiture for most of my life. I’m a skilled photographer. If you came here for a portrait, then I can help you.”
The sheriff let go of her hands. Color fused his round cheeks. “This really isn’t a job for a woman, ma’am. We don’t want a portrait of us. We need something else photographed.”
“Oh?” She let her voice grow cold. “I’ve photographed dozens of people. I’ve even photographed corpses, felons, and miners.”
“I never took Peter Driscoll to be a man who would allow his wife to do such things.” The sheriff was frowning, as if he wanted to take her husband to task.
“He can’t prevent something he doesn’t know about,” Roz said, and was pleased to see that both men were shocked.
“When will your father return?” the tall man asked.
“I don’t know,” she said. “Not today, certainly.”
“We need a photographer this afternoon,” the tall man said.
“Harold,” the sheriff said. “Perhaps we can skip it this one time.”
Harold. Could she be so lucky? There was only one Harold who insisted on photographs. Roz had never met Harold Adams, but she had heard of him. She hadn’t realized that Harold Adams himself would be the security on that coach. If she had known, she would have had more faith in her plan.
Roz threaded her fingers together, pressing them so hard that her knuckles were turning white.
“You’ve never worked with Wells Fargo before, have you? We need a photographer. A real one.” Harold nodded to her. “I’m sorry to have bothered you, ma’am.”
“Please,” she said. “Let me do the work.”
Harold shook his head. “No matter what your husband thinks, this job is not appropriate for a woman.”
The sheriff gave her an apologetic—if confused—glance and started out. She took a step after them.
“If you need photographs today,” she said, her voice shaking, “I’m all you have.”
Harold stopped just outside the door, blocking the light. He glared at the sheriff, who shrugged.
“This is true, then?” Harold asked.
“Look around,” the sheriff said. “Did you see another portrait studio?”
“Surely someone else takes photographs here.”
“Nope.” The sheriff looked apologetic. “But I don’t think it matters. They can photograph him in Sacramento—”
“We’ve waited before,” Harold said. “The photograph never gets taken, or they take a photograph of a corpse wearing a white cloth over his face to respect the dead. That does not satisfy my boss.”
The sheriff sighed. “You’d think your boss would be satisfied that we caught the bastard.”
Harold glanced at Roz, apparently trying to see if the language had offended her. “Ma’am, we have in Lattville’s little jail, the man who tried to rob the Wells Fargo stage coach this morning.”
Roz’s cheeks flushed. She willed the reaction to vanish. She hoped the men would think that she was nervous, not that she already knew about the robbery. Of course, the entire town probably knew about the robbery by now.
“We need him photographed,” Harold was saying. “The Wells Fargo Bank in San Francisco keeps photographs of all the robbers who have been foiled trying to rob Wells Fargo trains and stage coaches. It’s quite a collection, and it is to the point that if we miss even one of these bandits, we—those of us who work security for the company—could get fired.”
Roz was breathing shallowly.
“It should be enough that we caught the son of a bitch.” The sheriff shook his head slightly as if he thought this was all foolishness. Then he realized what he said and in front of whom, and tipped an imaginary hat to her. “No offense meant, ma’am.”
“None taken,” she said, even though she was even more uncomfortable than she’d been when they walked in. She had to show them she was up to this task.
“Are you still willing to take the job, ma’am?” the tall man asked. “Wells Fargo pays handsomely for its portraits.”
She made herself swallow, a difficult task against her dry throat. “Then by all means,” she said, trying to sound nonchalant. “Let’s go.”
The entire town would probably think she was crazy to take the wagon three blocks, but she needed it.
The mule wasn’t used to her, and tried to kick her as she hooked it up to the wagon. She managed, somehow, leaving her skirt muddy and her white blouse heavy with sweat. Damned corset cut into her ribs and she would have given anything for a deep, sweet breath of air.
Then she had to make the drive, which was harder than she had expected. Twice in three blocks, she nearly got stuck in the mud. No one in his right mind would try to rob a stagecoach with the roads as foul as these. Anything carrying weight would get stuck and, the stagecoach driver, knowing that, would probably have extra security or take additional precautions of some sort.
Harold Adams was waiting outside the jail for her when she arrived. He offered to take her equipment in for her, but she stopped him.
“I’d like to see what I’ll be photographing first,” she said.
“All right.” He held open the door for her and she stepped inside.
The main room was small and crowded. The low ceiling made it seem even smaller and the pot-bellied stove in the far corner took up much of the room. A rickety desk stood nearby along with two chairs.
The sheriff sat on one of them, holding a ring of keys. In place of the wall directly behind him were rows of iron bars. It took her eyes a moment to adjust to the dim interior before she saw a slight door framed in the metal.
Sweat ran down her spine, pooling at the bottom of her corset, making it stick to her.
“Nervous, Mrs. Driscoll?” Harold asked. “I thought you’d said you’d done this before.”
“Not here,” she said. “I’m only visiting Lattville. The jails I’ve been in have all been larger.”
Harold frowned, but said nothing. The sheriff stood. “Where’s your equipment?”
“Outside,” she said. “I want to see what I’m photographing first.”
“Your father will have my hide,” he said as he unlocked the main door.
“He just might,” she said following the sheriff into the small hallway that opened onto the two tiny cells, “but by then, the deed’ll be done.”
The first cell was empty. In the second, a man sat on the cot, his handcuffed hands hanging between his knees. Roz’s breath caught.
“Ma’am?” the sheriff asked.
“Does he have to be trussed up like that inside his cell?”
“He’s a dangerous criminal, ma’am. Wanted in five states. Thought we should take some precautions.”
She nodded. She had known that about the prisoner. In fact, she knew more about him than the men beside her did. Her gaze met his and a familiar flash of longing shot through her. Despite the mud streaking his too-thin face, the mats in his long brown hair, and the anger that flashed through his dark brown eyes, her husband was still the handsomest man she had ever seen.
“You want me to photograph him in here?” she asked.
“Where else would you do it?” the sheriff asked.
“Well, you see,” she said, “we have a problem. There’re no windows back here and the light is faint. We will not get a good photograph in these conditions.”
Harold stood in the iron doorway. “What do you suggest?”
“We could put a half dozen lanterns in the cell and hope for the best.”
“This jail’s made of wood,” Harold said. “That would be highly impractical.”
She turned toward him. He shrugged.
“One kick,” he said, “and the prisoner might start a fire and escape in the confusion.”
Fires were useful in wooden jails. Roz knew that from experience. She tried not to smile at the memory. It was important that she stay in character.
“You’re the one who wanted the photograph,” she said. “How have you done this in the past?”
He sighed. “Usually we have a window or a better light source. Or a brick jail.”
The sheriff glared at Harold.
“So what do you suggest?” she asked.
“You go set up on the sidewalk. We’ll bring him outside for just one moment.”
She nodded, then looked at Jack who hadn’t moved off the cot. His face was red with fury.
“You say he robbed a stagecoach?” she asked.
“I say he attempted to.” Harold sounded satisfied.
“But he’s wanted in—what? four states?”
“Five,” the sheriff said.
“We finally caught him,” Harold said.
“You’ve been waiting for him?” Her voice rose ever so slightly.
Harold nodded. “We knew he’d slip up once. We just didn’t expect the slip-up to be literal.”
“Literal?” she asked.
“He fell as he tried to unhook the strongbox.”
She couldn’t resist. She looked at the cell. Jack’s nostrils were flaring, his hands clenched with the effort he made to keep silent.
“Honestly, ma’am, I don’t think we’d’ve caught him otherwise. He snuck up on us quiet as a cat and had the guards knocked down and the box nearly off before we even knew what happened.”
“My arrest had nothing to do with you people,” Jack said. Roz willed him to keep silent. “I’d’ve been long gone if the coach hadn’t got stuck at that moment, and threw me off balance.”
“See?” Harold said. “He even admits it.”
“Well, do you expect him to do otherwise?” Roz asked. “You caught him red-handed.”
She directed that last toward Jack, with just enough of an I-told-you-so in her voice so that he—and he alone—could catch it.
He looked away.
“Let’s get this done before the light fades outside.” Harold was showing his familiarity with photography. Having him here had been a stroke of luck. He’d overseen the photographing of nearly a dozen criminals for the San Francisco bank since the war ended.
“All right.” She swished her way toward the iron doors, praying that Jack would help her work this scam. He was angry enough at her that he might not participate. They had fought about this robbery and he had done it against her advice.
It had taken all her strength to plan his rescue. She’d started before he’d even gotten caught. In fact, she had told him that was what she would do.
The fact that she had been right made him furious. She could tell. But fury or no, he had to cooperate with her or he might get sent away. They certainly had enough evidence against him this time.
“She’s going to take my photograph?” Jack asked, and Roz had to use all her acting skills not to sigh with relief. “This is even stupider than it sounded when you first mentioned it.”
“You don’t get an opinion,” the sheriff said.
Roz stepped through the iron doors, nodded at Harold, and paused when she reached the main door. “You think the sidewalk just out front will work or should I set up in the street? I’m muddy enough that it doesn’t matter.”
Harold walked to the door with her and peered at the sky. The thin winter sun was halfway down the horizon. He had been right; the light would be gone soon. Her struggle with the mule had taken longer than she thought.
“Guess we’d better use the street.”
She nodded and walked to the wagon. She climbed in, grabbed her pistols out of one of the boxes she had put in there that morning, and slipped them into the pockets of her skirt. One of them clanged against the key.
She had forgotten about it. She certainly didn’t need it any longer. She fished it out of her pocket and tossed it outside the wagon, hearing the key plunk into the mud.
Now watch the sheriff try to get old man Cooper and his two pruney daughters out of that dark room. Someone would have to knock the door down—once they realized the three of them were inside.
It had been Roz’s second stroke of luck that the oldest daughter had come home for the first time in years—and an even greater stroke of luck that the real Mrs. Driscoll was a shrew. The moment she’d seen Roz’s gun, she’d started screaming at her father about this backwater town and how she’d hated it and that this was precisely why she had stayed away for so long and never brought her children here. Her father had merely looked at Roz as if wishing she would shoot him then and there.
From the back, Roz unloaded the oldest camera she had found and set it on its tripod in the middle of the street. If her luck continued, she might be able to keep some of the photographic equipment. She hadn’t lied about her abilities there. She was a very good photographer, when she got the chance to practice her trade.
As she was adjusting the curtain on the back of the camera, she watched the lens as Harold brought Jack out of the jail. The sheriff followed, carrying a shotgun, but with the muzzle pointed toward the street.
Harold hadn’t put Jack in leg irons—maybe the sheriff didn’t have any—but Harold did have a Colt pointed at the center of Jack’s back.
“Make it fast, Mrs. Driscoll,” he said.
“All right.” She stood and walked over to them. “Let me position you so that the camera doesn’t see you at all.”
Harold nodded, clearly having been through this before. She moved him so that his body was as far from Jack’s as possible. Harold kept the gun trained on Jack. She pulled Harold a little to the left.
“Hmm,” she said. “Maybe this’ll work after all.”
Then she reached into her pocket and removed both pistols, shoving one against Harold’s chin and pointing the other at the sheriff.
They both looked stunned.
“Try something,” she said to them, “and Harold won’t have a face.”
“Tell them to drop the guns, Roz,” Jack said.
“I was getting to that,” she said, annoyed.
“Roz?” the sheriff asked. “I thought you were Abby Driscoll.”
“Your mistake,” Roz said, pushing the gun even harder against Harold’s chin. “And do drop your weapons. You know how unstable we women are.”
Harold dropped his gun. Out of the corner of her eye, Roz saw it fall. Jack crouched, grabbing for it, at the very moment the sheriff fired. The mule brayed nervously, but didn’t move. The bullet missed Jack—the third great stroke of luck.
She didn’t want to think about it. She’d lose her nerve.
“Now, what did you go and do that for?” Roz cocked the hammer on the gun under Harold’s chin. Sweat dripped off his face. “I’m so sorry, Harold, but your friend the sheriff here wants you dead.”
“Put the rifle down,” Harold said.
Jack was holding Harold’s gun in his handcuffed hands. He pointed it at the sheriff.
“Rifle down,” Jack said. “I’m not a delicate flower like my wife. I will shoot you.”
Lies. Jack had never hurt anyone. He stole, scammed, and charmed, but he never killed.
“And if you kill my husband,” Roz said, “this delicate flower will blow Harold’s brains all over main street.”
The sheriff’s rifle clattered onto the wooden sidewalk.
“Now what?” Jack asked softly.
“The wagon, darling,” Roz said.
“It’s attached to a mule,” he said.
“So am I,” she said, not looking at him. “Sometimes the arrangement works.”
He cursed and sloshed toward the wagon.
“I don’t suppose you have keys to his handcuffs,” she said to Harold.
“No.”
“Well, then,” she said, “I’ll simply have to shoot them off later.”
“Roz!” Jack sounded angry.
She grabbed Harold by the front of his shirt and pulled him toward the wagon. When she reached the wagon, she braced one hand against it.
Jack was sitting on the wagon, reins in one hand and the gun, still pointed at the sheriff, in the other. He was twisted awkwardly because his hands were still bound together at the wrists. “Roz, hurry.”
She wasn’t about to hurry. If she did this wrong, they were as good as dead.
“I will shoot you, Harold,” she said, “but I don’t want to today.”
With that, she shoved him backwards at the same time she hooked one foot behind his knee and pulled his leg out from under him. The mud, which had given her and Jack trouble all day, finally worked in her favor. Harold landed with a splash.
Roz swung herself onto the board and clucked at the mule—
—who didn’t move.
“Told you,” Jack said. “There’s got to be some good horses nearby.”
The sheriff was reaching for his rifle and Roz shot the wall above his head.
The second gunshot scared the mule and it leapt forward with surprising speed. The wagon, balanced better with Jack up front and the camera gone, managed to move with the mule. If they didn’t get stuck, they would be home free.
“We don’t need the damn wagon,” Jack said.
Roz was peering behind them, ready to shoot anyone that followed. “We need to get something out of this godforsaken town.”
“They’ll find us fast with this thing.”
“No, they won’t,” she said. “I have a plan.”
People were pouring into the main street, which was disappearing behind them. Harold was standing and calling for his horse.
“You always have a plan,” Jack said.
She couldn’t tell if he was making fun of her or not. “If I hadn’t had one today, you’d still be in that damn jail. I’m the one that saw that photo gallery in the stupid bank and I’m the one who figured out how to use it. It was easier than I thought. I thought I was going to have to pretend to be a traveling photographer, but thanks to the damn daughter—”
“Roz,” Jack said. “I’m grateful.”
No one was following them, yet, but the road was getting treacherous. Roz glanced over at him, saw the fondness on his face which was getting even muddier thanks to the gobs of goo being kicked up by the mule.
“Really?” she asked.
“Really,” he said. “But we do need to dump the wagon.”
She sighed. “I want the equipment.”
“Photography equipment is too bulky. I tell you that in every town. It’ll mark us—”
“I know,” she said. “At the next crossroads, we jump.”
“What?” he asked. “That’s your plan? Jumping off a moving wagon?”
She nodded, debating whether or not she should tell him about the fresh horses and buckboard she had actually paid for with the last of their money and had hidden that morning before she had come to rescue him.
Then she decided against telling him. He’d have to trust her.
“I don’t like your plan,” he said.
“You didn’t like my plan yesterday either, so you didn’t listen and look where it got us.”
He was silent for a moment. Then he said, “I owe you, Roz.”
“I know.” She leaned over and kissed him. He tasted good.
“Roz,” he said against her. “I’m driving.”
The crossroads was just ahead. She recognized it. She looked behind them. Still no one. But Harold and that sheriff would be coming soon.
“Ready?” she asked.
“I always am,” he said.
“Good,” she said, “because we’re getting off here.”
She shoved him toward the edge of the wagon. He dropped the reins and she didn’t pick them up. The mule was doing fine on his own—he didn’t need to be whipped in the butt for encouragement.
“Jump!” she said to Jack.
He did, and she followed. The mud was harder than it looked, knocking what little wind she had right out of her.
Jack, as usual, seemed just fine.
“Damn corset,” she said when she could.
“I’ll help you out of it,” he said, reaching for her blouse.
“Not here,” she said. “There’s a stream just down this road. We clean up there, and then get out of here.”
“Think they’ll come this way?”
“Not for a while,” she said. “They’ve got a photographer to free and a photographer’s wagon to follow. Besides, we’re not heading that way. We’re going east.”
“East?” He peered at her.
She gave him her best smile, even though she was muddy and tired and out of breath. “I want my photography studio, and to do that, Jack, you gotta go where the people are.”
“Who ever heard of migrating east?” he asked, but she could tell he wasn’t averse to the idea like he would have been just the day before.
She brought her hands up and thoroughly kissed his dear, muddy face. When she was through, she said, “We’ve been doing things your way long enough.”
“And it’s worked out fine,” he said.
“If you think fine is broke and homeless.”
“But a photography studio,” he said. “Who would go to a female photographer?”
“Harold Adams.”
“You just proved my point.” Jack raised his hands slightly, and stared at the handcuffs. He sighed. “I don’t want to go straight.”
“Who said anything about going straight?” she said and got to her feet. “Now let’s get out of here.”
“You’ll have to tell me the plan,” he said as he stood.
“Why?” she asked. “It always works out better if you don’t know.”
“I’m not that bad,” he said.
“That’s a matter of opinion, Jack,” she said as she led him down the road toward their fresh horses and new wagon. In the distance, she could hear the mule braying. She smiled at hers, happy to have him back.
They’d go straight. But she wouldn’t tell him that yet. One thing at a time.
After all, planning ahead was the key to knowing Jack.
“Knowing Jack”Copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn RuschPublished by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2023 by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Alanpoulson/Dreamstime
Yes, yes, yes, I know. I haven’t posted March’s. I read a lot during March, and then put off doing the list for other work (including finishing a Fey novel…which I’m still finishing). The list for March will go up this week, and I hope to have April’s after that.
Sorry for the delay!
To Get a Free AI Audio Version of this blog, click here.
Three things happened in quick succession recently, that forced me to write this blog now, not, say, months from now.
First, a writer friend astonished me by saying they have finally gone indie, after being urged to do so for more than a decade. They’ve been unable to sell a book traditionally for that entire decade, but they’ve kept writing.
Only…they’re not really ready to go indie, because they want to pay someone to design the book’s interior for both ebook and for paper. They want to pay someone else to design their cover, and they want to pay yet a third person for marketing.
I’m afraid my hair was on fire as I answered them…as gently as I could…informing them that they could do most if not all of these things on their own. They were looking at a cash outlay per book of a minimum of $5,000—and they wanted to publish a book per month.
I have no idea if this friend is wealthy. I do know that as a start-up, with zero track record outside of nonfiction and short fiction, this person would not earn back the full $60,000 they spend on this plan for years and years. I warned them about scammers, I gave my writer friend links, and I know that I overwhelmed them. But Good-freakin’-God, this person and I had the same conversation in 2012, when doing everything they discussed was a lot harder.
Then I sent them to a service…that went out of business, like every other service. (Except this service did not steal the writer’s IP in the process, like so many others had.)
I know other writer friends are trying to triage with this poor person, but I’m thinking, just let this writer spend the money. They’re actively refusing to learn modern publishing and have actively avoided it for 12 years. It’s not going to matter how much most of us yell; that person will not take the leap into indie.
Then, at lunch, I mentioned an older writer friend of ours, a writer in his eighties who declared fifteen years ago that he was retiring from writing because he was about to hit seventy. He crept into indie publishing with some unpublished backlist titles, then published all of his out-of-print titles and finally, about eight years ago, published a brand-new newly written book.
Yeah, this writer has help, because he’d run a business in the past, so he built a new business (after he retired) that resembles WMG. Someone else handles most of the publishing details, and he has social media folks because he can afford them. (He is wealthy, having had movies made from his work and because he’s a good money manager.)
Lo and behold, this guy, who fifteen years ago said that the words have dried up, has published at least 10 newly written books since that first one eight years ago.
I got a newsletter from him on the same day as I had gotten that other email about the writer who wants to be taken care of. Dean got the same newsletter and we discussed it at lunch.
I mentioned how this eighty-something writer had secretly unretired, and Dean said, “If he had stayed in traditional publishing, he wouldn’t be writing anymore. It’s indie that brought him back to life.”
Completely true. Not only has indie brought his fiction back to life, but he’s doing all kinds of creative marketing things, like limited editions and special editions and fan-favorite editions. He’s participating in bundles and is talking about a Kickstarter, but worries that he lacks the time, because he doesn’t want to take time from his latest novel.
Lately, I’ve been having issues with creeping into my sixties, so I was looking at my eighty-something friend and marveling at his production. Also he’s more than twenty years older than me, so if I keep writing at my normal pace for twenty-five more years, imagine…
Well, age was my focus in thinking about my friend, not indie/traditional. But Dean is exactly right. This writer friend was being destroyed by traditional publishing and he found a way out. He loved indie so much and loved the freedom it gave him even more, so all those stories in his head returned.
The other writer? They just want someone to take care of them, the way they imagine traditional publishers will.
I understand the “taking care of” attitude. That was how we were all brought up in our careers back when traditional was the only thing we could do. We were told that these people would take care of us…only none of them ever did. Not even with the bestsellers.
But I had a different revelation earlier in the summer. (I actually wrote a more general column about it for The Grantville Gazette.)
As regular readers know, I got very sick in June. Unable-to-get-off-the-couch sick. Unable-to-read-or-write sick. Unable to do anything challenging, including watching something that required brain power.
So after wending my way through the three most recent Star Trek movies (which I was seeing for the umpteenth time), I channel surfed, and found myself on an old episode of Magnum P.I.
The episode aired in 1987, and because it was 1980s TV (and Magnum), the technology in the episode was current, if not a little ahead of what was available.
I was having enough trouble with the ancient cars and the fact that everything looked out of date. Then T.C.’s daughter gets kidnapped and the team jumps into action. They come up with a plan to catch the kidnapper using money that Higgins gave them from Robin Master’s account (and, it feels weird to tell you all this without saying SPOILER, but if you’re that interested in a TV episode from 1987…well, not my issue).
The money is in the ubiquitous bag, of course. They’re going to put a tracker in the bag, and Rick will use a computer to monitor the tracker. The computer is the size of my desktop screen, but is clearly a brand-new late 1980s laptop. The tracker is the size of a dinner plate.
How anyone could miss that thing in a bundle of money is beyond me.
The team promises to stay in touch…on their walkie-talkies. (Those things were hard to ignore too.) Magnum is the one who receives the instructions from the kidnappers (why him? I don’t remember. Because his name is on the show?). He goes into a hotel room, finds a cued-up video tape showing T.C.’s daughter and that day’s newspaper…and of course, enough details to give the good guys a clue as to where she was being held.
Then the instructions come across the landline in the hotel room. And everything gets put into action…as the commercial break hits and the daytime commercials (hemorrhoid cream, Medicare Advantage, dentures ack!) roll.
I sat there stunned—not at the commercials (okay, the commercials), but also at the technology.
I was a full adult in 1987, divorced and on my own, working very hard at breaking into what was then known as publishing because there was no traditional to add to it. I learned every nook and cranny of that profession upside down, backwards, and forwards. I learned as much as I could as in-depth as I could, and then proceeded forward.
Over the years, I learned other things about that profession and I kept learning and growing. I found ways around the things that no one told you about until you experienced them (like what to do when your excellent career tanks through no fault of your own), and I still continued forward.
I started writing this blog—409 posts so far—to convince myself that indie publishing was viable, and then when I realized it was, I continued the blog as a way to keep learning and growing and moving forward in my writing career.
I can see myself, publishing in whatever way is viable twenty-five years from now, just like my eighty-something friend.
But my other writer friend? They got started later, but all of the teaching they absorbed was from the 1980s or earlier.
In fact, everything all of you have learned about traditional publishing from traditional publishing is still rooted in the 1980s.
The days of walkie-talkies and landlines and trackers the size of dinner plates.
That writer friend who wants to be taken care of? They believe that books were beautifully designed back in those days and yes, some were. Usually specialty press books done with an eye to the interior beauty.
But regular books?
Those of you with a 1980s hardcover on your shelf, go pick up the book. Turn to a random page. Take a look at the typeface. Then look to see if the lines on the page are actually lined up.
I read a lot of older books and what catches my eye every single time is that the interior design is much harder to read than the designs in modern computer-generated interiors. Books set on a linotype and hand-pasted were as good as the person doing the pasting. Then they were printed on machines that sometimes failed, and ripped off parts of the page.
Those books are not beautiful on the interior. They can hurt the eye.
Books designed in the early days of computer book design had the usual early days of any computer anything problem. Some of those books have missing chapters or repeated chapters or a failure of spellchecking. (You know what I mean: someone accidentally put the wrong word into the spellchecker so the spellchecker inserts the wrong word instead of the right one.)
Everything this writer friend who wants to be taken care of believes about publishing is as out of date as the radio in Magnum’s borrowed Ferrari.
The thing is…we all get comfortable with what we learned from the days we learned it.
For a long time, I kept all of my books from college, including the texts from my baby science classes like my Physics for Poets class (yes, that was what it was called). Until I dropped the book in one move or another, and actually read the page before me. Everything on that page, and I do mean everything wasn’t just out of date. It was wrong.
Science had moved on. Kris’s library hadn’t.
Everything that writers believe traditional publishing will do for them, from beautiful covers (have you looked at some covers lately?) to good copy editing (have you read trad pubbed books lately? I have and the copy editing is atrocious) to marketing (what marketing? Seriously? What marketing?) comes from the 1980s or older.
If those things were being done well then (and marketing was, for bestsellers), those things are not being done well now. If they were done poorly then, they’re worse now.
But more than that. You all know how I feel about traditional publishing, so let’s put this in the indie context.
Most indie writers base their expectations on the traditional publishing model that I mentioned above. The indie writers learned the same 1980s or earlier model, so these indies are doing what they can to goose initial sales, to increase velocity so that a new book will go out at thousands of copies (even if they’re given away).
Then the indie writer forgets about their older books, thinking the backlist is worthless. A lot of indies don’t update their covers after a few years, and certainly don’t go through their inventory when a new subgenre becomes popular. Or when a topic becomes trendy and they have an “old” book that is on-topic.
There are no old books now, folks. There are newly published books and new-to-the-reader books.
New and old is a traditional publishing concept based on physical shelf space, which was limited. The virtual shelf space is unlimited, so readers can find an old title just as easily as a brand-new one.
You can do marketing yourself (better than trads ever did) and market a title that’s six years old right next to the novel you just finished.
To use traditional publishing expectations, methods, and nomenclature is as silly as running to find a payphone to call 911 when you have a perfectly good cell phone in your hands.
We’ll never be able to convince that first writer I mentioned to do indie publishing right. We (the friends) will watch them publish that first book, spend thousands, and then watch it sell maybe 100 copies in the first month (if they’re lucky).
I’m braced for the inevitable this doesn’t work conversation.
Because if you’re thinking the old-fashioned traditional publishing way, 100 copies will be a stunning failure.
If you understand modern publishing, though, those 100 copies might be 150 by mid-year, which might be 200 a few months after that, and maybe more later. Over time—and there is time (unlike traditional) that book will sell more copies than it ever would have in a traditional publishing house…and the book will still be in print.
Win, win, win.
I’ll be honest, though. I’m still thinking about that Magnum episode, wondering what attitudes of mine are stuck in 1987. When I think about 1987 as 1987, I’m aware that it’s 36 years ago.
When I think about some of the things I did, I can feel how long ago that was.
When I think about what I’m writing now, what I hope to write, and what I did write back then, 1987 feels stunningly close to yesterday.
I’m sure I’m stuck in certain years and attitudes. I’m trying to shake them off—or at least evaluate them and see if they’re worth keeping.
I know it’s a long process. If you dig back on this website into the original blogs from, say 2011 or 2012, you’ll see a lot of different attitudes from me than I have now. It took me a long time to convince myself that indie publishing would work.
Very few people were making a living at it ten years ago. Hundreds—thousands?—of writers are doing so now. It should be easier for writers to understand that this is a viable path.
But, if they don’t realize that their training is out of date, then they’re going to have a much tougher time of it than the writer who understands that the world of 36 years ago is long gone.
Everything has changed, and continues to change.
Long about this point in the year, I find myself needing to delve into this year’s new technology to see if it is right for our business at this moment in time. Delving into new tech always feels like a pain, but it’s not. It’s what keeps our publishing business alive.
Writing is writing is writing. We’re storytellers and we’ll tell stories.
But getting our stories to the readers in the best possible way? That changes all the time.
Keeping up is hard, but it’s necessary. Not just for technology’s sake, but for our writing.
My eighty-something friend proves that. He had given up on writing when he thought he’d have to deal with the horrors of traditional publishing for his remaining years.
When he realized that he could control his writing and his publishing, his creativity roared back.
I’m inspired by his longevity and his willingness to change. I think his long career as a writer comes from that willingness to change.
Writers who don’t look to the future, or at least see the present, are never going to have careers that last forty, fifty, or sixty years. Maybe ten years, if those writers are lucky. Maybe. Or maybe only four or five.
It’s sad, really.
But this profession is for optimists, and those willing to learn, willing to try, and willing to grow. Everyone else will have a little luck, a little success, and a long decline.
I’ve learned that the hard way.
I admire writers like my eighty-something friend, and feel sorry for my other writer friend. But I learned long ago that you can’t rescue someone from their own assumptions. People have to find the way out of the blocks in their own brains on their own.
That’s a tough lesson to implement, but those of us who have careers that span decades have seen a lot of people come and go. We’ve learned to stand back and let other people make their own mistakes.
Some people surprise us and climb forward. Most do not.
It’s sad, but it’s their problem. And that’s the hardest lesson of all.
We just started a new Kickstarter for my Fey novels. There are workshops and other writerly things offered in the Kickstarter, as well as some rebranding for the Fey. Please check out the Kickstarter. LINK!!!**
This weekly blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynrusch to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: Living in the Past,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © Can Stock Photo / Knowlesgallery.
Nell’s determination drives her throughout her life. It allowed her to play baseball when only “tomboys” played. It allowed her to walk again when doctors said she never would. And now, even in old age, it will allow her to find answers to questions plaguing her for her entire life.
But the answers she seeks solve one mystery and pose another.
Chosen as one of the best short stories of the 20th century, “The Young Shall See Visions and the Old Dream Dreams” was featured in A Moment on the Edge: 100 years of Crime Stories by Women, edited by Elizabeth George.
“The Young Shall See Visions and the Old Dream Dreams,” by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story is also available in ebook through various online retailers here and is included in the collection Crimes Collide, Vol. 3, which is available in ebook, trade paperback, and hardcover here.
The Young Shall See Visions and the Old Dream DreamsKristine Kathryn RuschNell rubs a hand on her knickers and grips the bat tightly. Her topknot is coming loose. She can see strands of hair hanging in front of the wire frames of her glasses.
“What’s the matter, four-eyes? You nervous?”
She concentrates on the ball Pete holds in his right hand instead of the boys scattered across the dusty back lot. Any minute now, he’ll pitch, and if she thinks about the ball instead of the names, she’ll hit it.
“You hold that bat like a girl,” T.J. says from first base.
Nell keeps staring at the ball. She can see the stitches running along its face, the dirty surface disappearing into Pete’s fist. “That’s because I am a girl,” she says. It doesn’t matter if T.J. hears her. All that matters is that she spoke.
“Pitch already!” Chucky yells from the grassy sideline.
Pete spits and Nell grimaces. She hates it when he spits. With a sharp snap of the wrist, he releases the ball. It curves toward her. She jumps out of its way and swings at the same time. The ball hits the skinny part of the bat, close to her fingers, and bounces forward.
“Ruuun!” Chucky screams.
She drops the bat and takes off, the air caught in her throat. She’s not good at running; someone always tags her before she gets to base. But the sweater-wrapped rock that is first base is getting closer and still she can’t hear anyone running behind her. She leaps the last few inches and lands in the middle of the rock, leaving a large footprint in the wool. A few seconds later, the ball slams into T.J.’s palm.
“You didn’t have to move,” T.J. says. “The ball was gonna hit you anyway.”
“Pete always does that so that I can’t swing.” Nell tugs on her ripped, high-buttoned blouse. “He knows I hit better than any of you guys, so he cheats. And besides, the last time he did that I was bruised for a week. Papa wasn’t gonna let me play anymore.”
T.J. shrugs, his attention already on the next batter.
“Nell?”
She looks up. Edmund is standing behind third base. His three-piece suit is dusty and he looks tired. “Jeez,” she says under her breath.
“What?” T.J. asks.
“Nothing,” she says. “I gotta go.”
“Why? The game’s not over.”
“I know.” She pushes a strand of hair out of her face. “But I gotta go anyway.”
She walks across the field in front of the pitcher’s mound. Pete spits and barely misses her shoe. She stops and slowly looks up at him in a conscious imitation of her father’s most frightening look.
“Whatcha think you’re doing?” he asks.
“Leaving.” Her glasses have slid to the edge of her nose, but she doesn’t push them back. Touching them would remind him that she can’t see very well.
“Can’t. You’re on first.”
“Chucky can take my place.”
“Can’t neither. He’s gotta bat soon.”
She glances at Chucky. He’s too far away to hear anything. “I can’t do anything about it, Pete. I gotta go.”
Pete tugs his cap over his eyes and squints at her. “Then you can’t play with us no more. It was dumb to let a girl play in the first place.”
“It is not dumb! And you’ve gone home in the middle of a game before.” She hates Pete. Someday she’ll show him that a girl can be just as good as a boy, even at baseball.
“Nell.” Edmund sounds weary. “Let’s go.”
“He’s not your pa,” Pete says. “How come you gotta go with him?”
“He’s my sister’s boyfriend.” She pushes her glasses up with her knuckle and trudges the rest of the way across the yard. When she reaches Edmund, he takes her arm and they start walking.
“Why do you play with them?” he asks softly. “Baseball isn’t a game for young ladies.”
He always asks her that, and once he yelled at her for wearing the knickers that Karl had given her. “I don’t like playing dollies with Louisa.”
“I don’t suppose I’d like that much either,” he says. When they get far enough away from the field, he stops and turns her to him. There are deep shadows under his eyes and his face looks pinched. “I’m not going to take you all the way home. I just came because I promised I would.”
“You’re not gonna see Bess?”
He shakes his head, then reaches into his pocket and pulls out the slender ring that cost him three months’ wages. The diamond glitters in the sunlight. “Karl’s back,” he says.
***Nell traced the nameplate. Karl Krupp. She hadn’t imagined it; the name didn’t disappear under her touch like so many other things did. Her fingers, with their swollen knuckles and fragile bones, looked defenseless beside that name. Slowly she let her hand fall back onto the cold metal rim of her walker. He would be how old now? When she had been ten, he had been twenty-five—a fifteen-year difference that would now make him…ninety-five. She glanced at the door to his room. It hadn’t been open since he arrived, and that frustrated her. She wanted to see how badly age had changed him.
She supposed it hadn’t changed him much, since he was in Household 5. The other residents were reasonably intelligent and ambulatory—except for Sophronia. But the nurses had removed her as soon as her senility became evident. Nell’s own memory lapses and growing tendency to daydream worried her. She wasn’t sure how much provocation the nurses needed before they moved her to a more restrictive household.
Nell lifted her walker and moved away from the door. She didn’t want Karl to catch her snooping. Her name was different and she certainly didn’t look like the scrawny tomboy he had known, but she didn’t want him to know that she was watching him until she knew exactly what she was going to do.
***Karl slouches indolently in the settee. His long legs stretch out before him and cross at the ankles, his left arm is draped across the armrest, and his finely chiseled head rests against the upholstered back. He should not be comfortable, but he clearly is.
Bess sits in the armchair across from him, leaning forward. Wisps of hair frame her flushed face, her eyes sparkle, and her hands—looking naked without Edmund’s ring—nervously toy with her best skirt.
Nell lets the door swing shut. Karl doesn’t turn at the click, but instead says in his deep, rich baritone, “Is that my Nell?”
She freezes, not expecting the well of emotion that voice raises in her. She imagines herself running to him and burying her face in his neck, then pulling back and slapping him with all her strength.
“Nelly, it’s Karl.” Bess can’t quite keep the happiness from her voice.
“I know,” she says, flicking dried mud off her thumb. She is covered with sweat, her glasses are dirty, and her topknot is coming loose. She probably doesn’t even look like a little girl.
“Nelly…”
She hates the nickname almost as much as she hates Bess’s tone. “I’m gonna go wash up.”
“Go around front so you don’t get mud on the floor.”
Nell suppresses a sigh and turns around to let herself out. Just then her father opens the door, bringing with him the scents of tobacco and hair tonic. He ignores his youngest daughter’s appearance and starts to go into the parlor.
“Who owns the fancy Model-T? Is it yours, Edm—?”
He stops just inside the parlor and Nell takes a step forward so that she can see everything. Karl rises quickly and extends his hand. Bess is biting her lower lip, and Papa has flushed a deep scarlet.
“I told you,” he says in his lowest, angriest voice, “never to cross my threshold again.”
“Mr. Richter, things have changed.”
“I don’t care if you’ve become the richest man in the world. You are not welcome here.” Papa’s voice grows even softer. “Now get out.”
“Sir, please—”
“Get. Out. Or must I escort you?”
With one swift, graceful movement, Karl sweeps his hat off the table and places it jauntily on his head. He nods at Bess, steps around Papa, and musses Nell’s hair as he goes out the door.
Papa doesn’t move until he hears the automobile crank up. Then he says tightly to Bess, “You know he’s not allowed to be here.”
“But he’s different. He’s got a new job in Milwaukee, and he’s got prospects, Papa.”
“Fine. Let him find another girl.”
Nell leans back against the door. They have forgotten that she’s there.
“Papa.” Bess rises out of the armchair. In her high-buttoned shoes, she is almost as tall as her father. “Things are better. He promised.”
“Oh? Did he promise he would never hit you again, or did he just talk about money?”
Bess whirls away and looks out the window. “Papa, that’s not fair.”
“No, it’s not fair.” Papa pulls his watch from his pocket, opens it, and then closes it without looking at the face. “But I don’t want him back. After he hit you, I heard Nelly crying herself to sleep every single night.”
Nell’s face grows warm. She thought no one knew.
Papa stuffs his watch back into his pocket and adjusts his waistcoat. “Now, I would like some dinner.”
Nell slips out the front door and heads around the house to the pump. Her body is shaking. She remembers Bess’s swollen and bruised face, but she also remembers the fun they had laughing on the front porch with Karl. Her tears those nights hadn’t been just for Bess. They had also been for those summer afternoons filled with laughter, lemonade, and Karl mussing her hair!
***Even though it was difficult, Nell liked to walk. She felt that each slow step added a minute to her life. Without her walker, she would have to use a wheelchair—and the wheelchair was a sign of weakness. Lifting the walker and then taking a step gave her the same sure feel that she used to have after hitting a home run the way Karl had taught her to.
Sometimes she spent the entire day walking up and down the hallways. She got to go outside on those rare occasions when her family visited. They took her out so that they could avoid talking.
Each household was painted a different color. The walls in Household 5 were robin’s egg blue and covered with artwork done by the residents. Shortly after Karl arrived, a painting of a multicolored spiral had gone up beside his door.
Nell found her gaze drawn to the painting. She pushed her glasses up so that she could study it. The spiral had rungs, like a ladder. At the bottom, instead of a signature, was a notation that tugged at a memory she couldn’t reach: deoxyribonucleic acid. She read the phrase twice, then saw with a start that Karl’s door was open. Strains of a Chopin etude slipped into the hallway. Intrigued, she leaned closer.
The residents were encouraged to fill their rooms with their personal effects. Most rooms had a television set, a stuffed armchair covered with a quilt, and a cross on prominent display. But Karl’s room was lined with bookcases, and the bookcases were full. Karl stood near the door, holding a book in his hand.
“It’s the pretty woman from across the hall.” His voice hadn’t changed. It was still rich and full, and it still sent shivers down her back. His black hair had become silver and his skin was covered with delicately etched lines. Age hadn’t bent him. He extended his hand. His movements were as graceful as ever. “Would you care to come and visit for a moment?”
Nell found herself staring at his hand. The last time she had seen it, it had been covered with blood. “No, thank you,” she said. “I’m taking my walk.”
“Surely you have just a moment—?” He inclined his head toward her, waiting for her to give him her name.
“Eleanor,” she said.
“Eleanor?” He took a step back so that she could pass him. She hesitated, then smiled a little bit at herself, realizing that this was the man who had given her a taste for charm.
“A moment.” She turned her walker and started toward him, feeling awkward for the first time in years.
He watched her shuffling movements. “Arthritis?”
She shook her head. “I broke both hips pinch-hitting for some Little Leaguers in 1975. The doctors said I’d never walk again.”
“Did you win?”
She looked up at him, startled to find herself only a foot away. “I’m walking, aren’t I?”
He chuckled. “No, no. The game.”
“Oh.” She pushed the walker through the doorway. Bookcases made the entrance narrow. His room smelled like ink and old books. “We lost by three runs.”
“It’s a shame,” he said quietly. “You should always win your last game.”
She stopped near the window. He had a view of the back parking lot. “Who says it was my last game?”
She turned and looked at his room, then. It was filled with books. A desk covered with papers stood in the center of the floor and a stereo, like the one her granddaughter was so proud of, took up a shelf of one of the bookcases. The bed in the far corner was neatly made and covered with a manufactured spread.
“Would you like to sit?” He pulled a chair back for her. Nell shook her head.
“Tea then?” He reached behind him and plugged in a coffee machine. Cups, canisters, and vials filled with liquid rested beside the machine.
“What are you doing here?” Nell’s question slipped out. He turned sharply to look at her. Nell felt herself blush. “I mean, you don’t look as if you need to be here.”
He smiled and the lines cascaded into wrinkles. “My grandnephew runs this place. He figures I’m getting too old to live alone.”
“But there are other places to stay if you’re in good health. You don’t seem to need medical care.”
“I don’t yet.” He hooked his thumb in his front pockets and leaned against the door frame. Nell wondered if he’d stop her if she tried to leave. “I’m helping him with some research.”
Nell glanced again at the desk. Some of the papers lying there were covered with the same spiral that was near the door.
“We’re trying to find a way to slow down the aging process,” he said. “You’ve heard of Leonard Hayflick?”
“No.”
“Hayflick is a biologist who found that cells have a clearly defined life span. He figured that the life span was determined by the number of cell divisions instead of chronological age. But some cells deteriorate before they reach their maximum divisions. And that, some believe, causes aging. Follow me?”
Nell realized she had been staring at him blankly. “Sorry.”
“Let me put it simply,” he said. “Everyone can live to a certain maximum age, but not everyone reaches that age because of physical deterioration. What we’re trying to do is prevent that physical deterioration so that people can live out their entire lives.”
“What is this maximum age?” Nell asked.
Karl shrugged. “We don’t know. But some people have claimed that they were well over a hundred. And I just read about a woman recently whose baptismal records prove she is a hundred and twenty.”
“Why are you telling me?”
“You asked, Nelly.”
Nell’s entire body went cold. She gripped her walker tightly and tried to think of a way she could get out of the room.
He took a step toward her, and she cringed.
“I’m sorry,” he said softly. “I should have let you know right away that I knew who you were. My family stayed in Wisconsin, Nell. They let me know what was going on in your life. I knew you were here well before I came.”
“What are you going to do?” Her voice trembled.
He took another cautious step toward her. “Well, first, Nelly, I’d like to explain about Bess.”
“No,” she said and her fear was as real as it had been that sunlit July morning when he had clamped his bloody hand against her mouth. “If you don’t let me out of here, I’m going to scream.”
“Nelly—”
“I mean it, Karl, I’m going to scream.”
He opened his hands wide. “You’re free to go, Nell. If I wanted to hurt you, I could have done it a long time ago.”
She pushed the walker before her like a shield. Her hands were slipping on the metal. As she passed Karl, she didn’t look at him.
The walls seemed narrower and the distance to her room much too short. When she got inside, she closed the door, wishing that it would lock. But she knew that part of her fear was irrational. There wasn’t much a ninety-five-year-old man could do to her here, not in this home filled with bright lights and young nurses. All she had to do was scream and someone would come to her. They didn’t ignore screams in Household 5.
***Nell tugs at her knickers. No matter how tightly she ties them, they always stay uncomfortably loose about the waist. She has been reluctant to slide into a base like Chucky tells her to because she’s afraid that if she does her knickers will come off.
She takes the path that goes through Kirschman’s apple orchard. Mr. Kirschman hates it when the kids take the shortcut through his orchard, but they do anyway.
As she turns the corner to the center of the orchard, someone clamps a hand over her mouth and drags her back against the tree. The hand is tight and slippery. It smells like iron.
“Nelly, promise not to scream if I let you go?”
The voice is Karl’s. She nods. Slowly he releases her.
“What were you trying to do?”
He raises a grimy finger to his lips. His dark hair stands out in sharp relief to his pale skin. “I don’t want you to go any farther, okay? I want you to go back and get your father right away. Promise?”
Nell nods again. She’s staring at his stained white shirt and she realizes that it is covered with blood. She wipes at her mouth and her hand comes away bloody.
“Nell—”
She turns and starts to run, not realizing until she’s rounded the corner that she’s disobeyed Karl. There, lying across the orchard path, is her sister. Bess’s hair is strewn about her, and her blouse is covered with blood.
“Nell,” it’ll be okay, just—”
Nell screams. Karl is standing behind her. She pushes him out of her way and runs down the orchard path toward home. This time running seems easy although the air still catches in her throat. She can’t hear Karl behind her, and as she nears the house, she knows she’s safe. Karl won’t hurt her, Karl would never hurt her. The only one Karl hurts is Bess, and that is Bess’s fault because she doesn’t listen to Papa and now it’s too late, it’s all too late because Nell has left her there, bleeding and helpless, with Karl, the man who hurts her, the man whose hands are covered with blood.
***“Did I ever tell you that my sister was murdered?”
Anna smoothed her already neat skirt and sighed. “Yes, Mother.” Her tone said, A thousand times, Mother. Do I have to hear it again?
Nell clutched her hands in her lap, trying to decide if she should continue. Anna would never believe her. Even though she was fifty-five, Anna rarely thought about anything more serious than clothing and makeup. And, of course, she had never known her Aunt Bess.
“I saw the man who killed her.”
Anna suddenly became stiff, and her eyes focused on something beyond Nell’s shoulder.
Nell’s heart was pounding. Her oldest, Elizabeth, would have listened. But Bess had been dead for six years. “I think I told you this once,” Nell said. “But the man who killed her—his name was Karl—also killed her fiancé, Edmund. And they never caught him. And it used to frighten me, thinking that someday he’d come back for me.”
“That was a long time ago, Mother.” Anna’s voice had an edge to it.
“I know.” Nell’s fingers had grown cold. “But I wouldn’t be telling you now if it weren’t important.”
Anna looked at her mother full in the face, a deep, piercing look. “Why is it important now?”
“Because he’s here,” Nell whispered. The words sounded too melodramatic, but she couldn’t take them back. “He’s across the hall.”
Anna took a deep breath. “Mother, even if he were here, there’s nothing he could do. He probably doesn’t even remember you.”
“He remembers,” Nell said. “I talked to him.”
“Even so.” Anna reached out and took Nell’s hand. Her palm was warm and moist. “He’s an elderly man. He probably won’t live long. If we called the police and they verified what you said, he probably wouldn’t even make it to trial. I mean, who else knows about the murder, besides you?”
“My father knew and—”
“Anyone living?”
“No.” Tears were building in Nell’s eyes. She blinked rapidly.
“Then it would be your word against his, and frankly, Mother, I don’t think it’s worth it. I mean, what can you gain now? He’ll die soon and then you won’t have to worry.”
“No.” A tear traced its way down Nell’s cheek and stopped on her lips. She licked it away quickly, hoping Anna didn’t see. “He won’t die soon.”
Anna frowned. “Why not?”
“He’s working on an experiment to prolong his life.”
“Oh, for God’s sake, Mother.” Anna pulled her hand away. “How many other people have you told this piece of nonsense to?”
“I haven’t—”
A nurse knocked on the door and walked in. She set a tray next to Nell’s armchair. “I have your medication, Nell.”
Nell reached over and took the Dixie cup. The liquid inside was brown. “This doesn’t look like my medication.”
She looked up in time to see Anna shaking her head at the nurse. “Just drink it, Nell,” the nurse said in her fakely sweet voice, “and it’ll be all right.”
Nell took a sniff of the cup. The contents smelled bitter. “I really don’t want it.”
“Mother,” Anna snapped. Then in a confidential tone to the nurse, she said, “Mother is having a bad day.”
“The past few days have been difficult,” the nurse said. “She hasn’t gone to meals and she won’t leave her room at all.”
“Is that true, Mother?”
Nell swirled the liquid in her cup. Sediment floated around the bottom. Suddenly she realized that it didn’t matter. No one would care if Karl poisoned her. She put the cup to her lips and drank before she could change her mind.
The liquid bit at her tongue like homemade whiskey. She coughed once and then set the cup down. “I don’t see why you want to know,” she said.
Anna pursed her lips. “Mother, really.”
Nell rubbed her tongue against the roof of her mouth, but she couldn’t make the taste go away. She grabbed the side of her chair and got to her feet. Her hips cracked slightly when she stood. The nurse handed her the walker.
“Where are you going, Nell?”
Nell didn’t reply. She moved the walker toward the sink, and got herself a drink of water.
“I’m afraid my mother may not be well,” Anna said softly. “She was just telling me that the man across the hall murdered her sister, and she’s afraid that he’s after her.”
“Mr. Krupp? I wouldn’t think so. He’s been bedridden since he came here.”
“Maybe you should say something.” Anna stopped speaking as Nell turned around. Nell made her way back to the armchair. The nurse took her arm as she sat down.
“Nell, I understand the man across the hall frightens you.”
Nell looked up at the nurse’s round face, trying to remember her name without glancing at the nametag. “No. Whatever gave you that idea?”
“Your daughter was saying that he made you nervous.”
The nametag said DANA, L.P.N. “I haven’t even seen him and he’s very quiet. Why would that make me nervous?”
The nurse smiled and picked up the tray. “I was just checking, Nell.”
Anna waited until the nurse left before speaking. “Why did you lie to her, Mother?”
“I don’t know why you come visit me,” Nell said.
Anna slid her chair back and stood up. “I don’t know either sometimes. But I’m sure I’ll be back.” She picked up her coat and slung it around her shoulder. “And, Mother, it’s better for you to socialize, you know, than to stay locked up in your room. Talking to other people will give you something to think about, so that your mind won’t wander.”
She walked out. Nell waited until she could no longer hear the click of Anna’s high heels on the tile floor. “My mind doesn’t wander,” she murmured. But the nurse had said that Karl was bedridden, and he had looked so healthy to her. Nell sighed and then frowned. What would he be doing in Household 5 if he couldn’t get out of bed?
***Nell picks up the bat and takes a practice swing. Her dress sways with her, but she won’t wear the knickers Karl gave her. Bess has been dead for a week, and Nell is lonely.
“What are you doing here?” Chucky asks. They are alone. The other boys haven’t arrived yet.
“Wanna play,” she says.
He frowns. “In a dress? Where are your knickers?”
“Threw them out.” She hits the bat against the dirt like she’s seen Pete do.
“You can’t run in a dress.”
“I can try.” Her anger is sharp and quick. She hasn’t been able to control her moods since Bess died. “I’m sorry.”
Chucky ducks his head and looks away. “It’s okay.”
“I’m sorry,” she says again, and looks at the playing field. The grass has been ruined near the bases. Sometimes she thinks baseball is the only dream she has left. Now, with Bess dead and Karl gone, even that seems impossible. “I’ll just go home.”
“No,” Chucky says. “I mean, you can play.”
She smiles a little and shakes her head. “Not in a dress. You were right.”
“Wait.” He touches her arm and then runs to his house, letting the porch door slam behind him. She goes to home base and swings the bat again, pretending that she has hit a home run. It is a good feeling, to send the ball whistling across the creek. She loves nothing more. If only she were a little boy, she could play baseball forever. Karl once told her that she could turn into a boy when she kissed her elbow. She tried for weeks before she realized that kissing her own elbow was impossible. She will never be a boy, but she will be good at baseball.
Chucky comes back. He thrusts some cloth into her hand. “Here,” he says.
She unfolds it. He’s given her a pair of frayed and poorly mended knickers. “Chucky?”
“They don’t fit me no more. Maybe they’ll fit you.”
“But isn’t your brother supposed to get them?”
“Nah,” he says, but doesn’t meet her eyes.
“I don’t want to take them if it’ll get you in trouble.”
“It won’t.” He studies her, sees that she’s unconvinced. “Look, you’re the best hitter on the team. I don’t want to lose you.”
She smiles, a real smile this time, one that she feels. “Thanks, Chucky.”
***Nell resumed her walks again, making sure that she took them around medication time.
Karl’s door remained closed for days, but she finally caught him in the hallway, switching Dixie cups on the trays.
“You’re switching my medication,” she said. She stood straight, leaning on her walker, knowing that he couldn’t touch her in the halls.
“Yes, I am,” he replied.
She swallowed heavily. She hadn’t expected him to admit it.
“Why?”
“I guess I kinda feel like I owe you, Nell.”
“For killing Bess?”
He set the cup down on the tray marked with her room number. His hand was trembling. “I didn’t kill Bess,” he said quietly. “I killed Edmund.”
“You’re lying.”
He shook his head. “I was going to meet Bess that morning in the orchard. We were going to run away together. Edmund got there first, and he killed her. So I went and I killed him.”
Nell could feel the power of that morning, the sunlight against her skin, his bloody fingers across her lips. “Why—didn’t you tell somebody?”
“I still committed a murder, Nelly.”
That’s why he had told her to get her father. That’s why he had never come back to kill her, too. “Why—” She shook her head in an attempt to clear it. “Why did you come back here?”
“Wisconsin is my home, Nell.” He was leaning on the cart for support. “I wanted to die at home.”
“But your experiment?”
He smiled. “I’ve outlived most of my siblings for a good twenty years. And the formula wasn’t quite right for me at first. We’ve changed it, so yours is better from the start.”
“Mine?”
“Nelly.” He bowed his head slightly and ran his fingers through his thick, silver hair. The gesture made her think of the old Karl, the one who had taught her how to laugh and how to hit home runs. “What did you think? That I was poisoning you?”
She nodded.
“I’m not. I’m trying the drug on you. I know I should have asked, but you didn’t trust me, and it was just easier to do it this way.”
“Why me?” she asked.
“Lots of reasons.” The cart slid forward slightly and he had to catch himself to keep from falling. “I don’t know many people who still play baseball when they’re seventy years old. Or learn to walk again when the doctors say they can’t. You’re strong, Nelly. The power of your mind is amazing.”
“But what if I don’t want to live any longer?”
“You do or you wouldn’t be out here, trying to catch me.”
“I have caught you.” The hallway was empty. Usually it was full of people walking back and forth.
“I know,” Karl said. “What are you going to do? Call a nurse, tell them to arrest me? There’s no statute of limitations on murder, you know.”
Nell studied him for a moment. He was thin and his skin was pale. He was ninety-five. How much longer could he live?
“I don’t want any more of your medication,” she said.
He stood motionlessly, waiting for her to say something else.
She moved her walker forward, on the other side of the cart. “And I don’t want to talk anymore.”
She didn’t let herself look back as she slowly made her way down the hall. Imagine if she could walk without a walker, without pain. Imagine if she could live longer than her father, who had died when he was ninety-eight. She wasn’t ready to give up living yet. Some days she felt as if she had only just started.
When she reached her own door, she stopped and looked back at Karl’s. Once she had believed in Karl and his miracles. She did no longer.
***The world has reduced itself to the ball clutched in Pete’s hand. “Throw it straight,” Chucky yells.
Pete spits. Nell barely notices. She watches that ball, knowing that when he throws it she will hit it with all her strength. Time seems to slow down as the ball whizzes toward her. She knows how the ball will fly, where it will end up, and she swings the bat down to meet it. There is a satisfying crack as they hit and time speeds up again.
“Holy cow!” Chucky cries, but Nell ignores him as she drops the bat. Out of the corner of her eye, she sees the ball sail over the creek. She runs as fast as she can. Her right foot hits first base, and she keeps going, flying, like the ball. It disappears into the weeds behind the creek as her left foot hits second. Her glasses bounce off her nose between second and third, and she is navigating according to color. Her lungs are burning as her left foot hits the rock that is third base.
“Go, Nelly! Go!”
She runs toward the blurred shapes behind home. There is a stitch in her side and her entire body aches, but she keeps moving. She leaps on home base and her team cheers, but she can’t stop. She has run too hard to stop right away, and she crashes into Chucky, who hugs her.
“Great!” he says. “That was great!”
She stands there, savoring the moment. Karl would have been proud of her. But Karl would never know. She wipes the sweat off her forehead and says, “I lost my glasses.”
As Chucky trudges out to retrieve them, she realizes she can get no higher than this; her tiny girl’s body, for all its batting accuracy, will prevent her from going on. But she doesn’t care. If she can’t play on a real team, she will hit home runs until she is a hundred, long after these boys are dead.
“That was great, Nelly,” Chucky says as he hands her her glasses. “Really great.”
She checks the lenses, which haven’t cracked, and then bends the frame back into shape. “Not bad for a girl,” she says with a glance at T.J. Then she goes over to the grass and sits at the end of the line, hoping that she’ll get another chance at bat.
***The sound of running feet woke Nell up. She had heard that sound before. Someone had died or was dying and they wanted to get him out before the other residents knew.
She grabbed her glasses and got out of bed, carefully making her way to the door. They were gathered in front of Karl’s room. Two men wheeled a stretcher out. The body was strapped in and the face was covered. Quickly they pushed him out of sight.
She crossed the empty hallway. The tile beneath her feet felt cold and gritty. They had left Karl’s door open, and she stopped just outside it, catching the smell of death under the scent of ink and books.
“Nell?” One of the nurses started down the hall toward her.
“Is he dead?” she asked.
“Mr. Krupp? I’m afraid so. I’m sorry if it disturbed you.”
“No, not really,” Nell said. She drew her nightgown closely about her chest. She was getting cold.
“He probably shouldn’t have been in this household,” the nurse said. “He was much too sick, but his family wanted him to have a private room.”
Nell wondered how the nurse expected her to believe that. One glance inside Karl’s room made it obvious that he hadn’t been bedridden. Nell surveyed the room once more. The desktop was bare and the vials were gone, but otherwise it looked the same.
The nurse finally reached her side. Nell recognized her as the round-faced one who usually gave her her medicine, Dana, LPN.
“How did you get out here?” Dana LPN asked.
“Walked,” Nell said.
Dana LPN shot her a perplexed look. “Well, let’s get you back to bed, shall we?”
She put her arm around Nell’s waist and helped her back to the room. The support wasn’t necessary until they reached the door. When Nell saw her walker in its usual place beside the bed, her knees buckled.
“Nell?”
Nell straightened herself and pushed out of the nurse’s grasp. She made her way to the side of the bed and lightly touched her walker. “I’m fine,” she said.
She climbed into the bed and lay there until she heard the nurse’s footsteps echo down the hall. Then she got up and walked slowly around her room.
You’re strong, Nelly, he had said. The power of your mind is amazing.
She walked to the door and stared at Karl’s empty room across the hall. The drawing was still there, its spirals twisting like a malformed ladder. Beneath the stunned joy that she was feeling, frustration beat at her stomach. She would never know if it was her own determination or Karl’s bitter medicine that made her legs work again, just as she would never know if he had actually killed her sister or if he had been lying. She wanted to believe that it was the power of her own mind, but her mind’s healing took time. She had started to walk within days of receiving the medication.
Nell went back to the bed and sat down, wondering what Anna would say when she learned that her mother could walk again. Then Nell decided that it didn’t matter. What mattered was that her feet which had run bases, chased two children, and carried her through decades of living worked again. Once she had vowed to hit home runs until she was a hundred. And maybe, just maybe, she would.
The Young Shall See Visions and the Old Dream DreamsCopyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Alfred Hitchcock’s Mystery Magazine, July 1989Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2023 by WMG PublishingCover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Sciccone/Dreamstime
To Get a Free AI Audio Version of this blog, click here.
I suspect spring in Las Vegas will always have reminders for me. In those first dark days of the pandemic, when we were wiping off our groceries and viewing our neighbors with great suspicion, when we were wearing cloth masks that were makeshift at best, and running out of toilet paper as well as hand sanitizer, I ran outdoors.
Very early in the morning, taking the stairs from our condo down to the street, actually crossing the street if I saw anyone at all. There was a group of us who were out at that time of day—a redheaded runner who lived on Fremont Street (and ran the same route, only going the opposite direction), a middle-aged woman who walked and was usually on the phone, and a man from my building who walked his three bulldogs every day at the same time.
We didn’t talk. We waved from a proper distance. All of us carried masks, but weren’t masked. We’d hastily put the mask on if someone came close. I actually wore a neck gaiter that I could pull up like a bandit.
This morning, I was sorting my clothes for the upcoming summer and found some cloth masks. I’d already noted last fall that I was unwilling to throw my cloth masks away, even though I haven’t worn any since late 2020. I’ve been wearing K95 when I need to wear masks.
I did stash the cloth masks, though. They’re in a bag I got from the musical Hadestown. I think that’s appropriate.
There are many things that remind me of that spring. Not people—I haven’t seen the first two from my early morning group since 2021. I see the neighbor often. I also see the spring changes.
Back then, I would run, and later in the day, Dean and I would walk, around the neighborhood. We looked at little round cacti that got their spring growth (and sometimes bloomed). At the pollen that littered the street three blocks down. At the spring flowers that had a moment just before the summer heat crushed them.
The neighborhood is different now—there’s been a lot of building and remodeling and growth—but some of those pockets remain. And at this time of year, the sight of those things immediately sends me back to those fearful days.
I like to think I got through them pretty well. I was as realistic about the pandemic as I could be. My history background both informed me and worried me. Dean stopped asking me when I thought the pandemic part would end because my answer was always, Give it three years. That’s when the pandemic started waning in the 1920s.
Here we are, three years later. Yes, I know, dear readers, COVID-19 is still with us. Friends have had it all through the fall and winter. A friend just had a bout last week. If I log onto Facebook, I see even more friends who are suffering with the virus, even if they’re vaccinated. That disease is pernicious and it wants to infect us all.
I suspect that by the end of this decade, it will have infected us all. It will then become one of those rounds of viruses that we deal with each and every year. It’s moving into that category.
But guessing the timeline accurately didn’t make it any easier to go through those years. All that death. I still don’t want to total up the losses in my life. I’m sure everyone who is reading this blog has had similar experiences.
It will take a long time for all of the data to be absorbed and analyzed. It’s just starting now.
For example, Markus Brauer, a psychology professor at the University of Wisconsin-Madison teamed up with professors from the School of Journalism and Communication on a study conducted in the early days of the pandemic. The results were published recently.
It found that “higher media consumption—seeking out the news—was associated with more emotional distress.” I read an article about it in the University of Wisconsin alumni magazine, On Wisconsin, and had a visceral reaction:
I wasn’t extremely emotionally distressed.
Denial much?
I even had trouble getting through the article. Then I found this paragraph:
The study doesn’t allow for causal conclusions. While it is likely that seeking out news updates about the pandemic led to emotional distress, according to Brauer, it is also possible that people who are distressed try to manage their emotions by checking the news more often.
The second half of that paragraph describes me and my coping mechanism. When I’m upset, I seek information. The more information I have, the calmer I become.
Although I doubt I was calm after March of 2020. I doubt I was calm for years.
I put my head down and launched right back into what Dean and I call “Lincoln City Think.” I had been so sick and trapped up in Oregon, barely able to leave the house most of the time, that I had figured out coping mechanisms to get through the day. (You can find some of those in my book Writing With Chronic Illness.)
I knew how to survive minute to minute, hour to hour. I also knew how to calm myself in moments of political stress (which we had an abundance of in the U.S. that year). I had been a reporter for a reason. When something goes haywire, I seek information. I look for causes and solutions. I gather data. I check the data to see if it changed overnight.
I am very aware of these habits and actively sought them out.
What I didn’t realize was the impact this all had on my fiction writing and reading. I noted a few things. Such as…I couldn’t read romance novels at all. A part of me no longer believed anyone would ever get a happily ever after. I didn’t want to read certain types of mysteries either, because they were distressing.
Science fiction and fantasy provided a lot of escape, but I have a problem with those genres. My years as an editor made me highly critical of them, so I needed to approach them sideways—trying not to look too hard at what the author was doing.
I defaulted in my reading to a lot of favorite authors because I knew I’d get a reliable read. That was helpful, but my reading declined and as it did, so did my writing.
Or so I thought.
What really changed was this: I had become what I call outer-directed. When I’m threatened or in crisis, I focus on what’s around me, not on what’s inside me. I can’t get lost in a made-up world, because that’s just too dangerous. I don’t dare go through this world with blinders on. Something even worse might happen.
I struggled and wrote and read what I could. I found other things to focus on, though. Writing and reading didn’t give me an escape, but learning Spanish did. It took concentration and felt like I was feeding that outer-directed part of myself.
That lead me to taking school (which was online at that point) too seriously, something I had to work my way out of last fall. I am not a young student with a bright future ahead of her. I really don’t need these classes. They’re for me. So I don’t need to be anal about it, and I don’t need straight As. I’m taking classes for myself, not to get a career or figure out my future. I’m there to learn, and, sometimes, to have fun.
During lockdown, I had to start running in the mornings, which took my best writing time, because the gyms were closed. Those morning runs became a lifeline. I met a lot of (properly distanced) Las Vegans on those mornings—everyone from the security guards at a parking garage (imagine that job) to the street vendors who slowly returned to Fremont. There are a lot of people who glue Las Vegas together in the hours before 7 a.m, people you don’t see later in the day.
I was out there with them, earlier and earlier, because it gets so damn hot here, and no way in hell was I going to the gym and trying to exercise masked among people who felt they didn’t need to follow the rules. (Yes, it was that bad, even into late 2021.)
There were highlights. The people, as I mentioned. I actually could get to the local donut shop that closed every morning around 10 because they were sold out. They even reserved donuts for me every week, because they knew I’d come in.
I ignored the impact on my writing. I figured I was slow because I didn’t have enough time or because of school or because I was exhausting myself with exercise (another way to cope).
I didn’t realize just how much of myself I had shut down until the pieces started resurfacing. I started reading mystery again—difficult mysteries about difficult topics—last fall. I stopped doom-scrolling in early 2022, and now check notifications only when I’m on a break. I’ve even gotten rid of a lot of notifications because I don’t need to be that vigilant.
I walked into a crowd a few weeks ago and didn’t feel like I had done something wrong. It actually helped to get sick with a cold/flu thing last fall because I had to get through all those oh-crap-what-did-I-do-wrong? emotions that were somehow tied to wiping off my groceries and wearing gloves everywhere.
I’m swimming again, and I didn’t even worry about getting in the pool until much later when I realized what post-pandemic me had done.
And lately—really, three years almost to the day after the pandemic shutdown—I finally started getting lost for hours in my writing, instead of for short bursts.
Emotional distress? You betcha, sweetie. I was not a happy camper. Was any one of us? We all coped in our own ways, and many of us are still coping.
I’m not at all angry at myself for the lost time and the lost days and the worry that came from all of it. I learned long ago about the truth in that saying misattributed to Winston Churchill: If you’re going through hell, keep going.
I’ve done that many times in my life. Head down, body hunched, moving forward because going back won’t get me out. Nothing will except the march of days.
I’ve reclaimed a lot of things, and I’m slowly putting things in perspective. I’m slowly getting rid of pandemic habits.
At Dean’s suggestion, I stopped running in the morning. It took weeks for that to ease out of my life: I felt like I was doing something wrong.
I’m a morning writer, though, so getting my mornings back was heavenly and enabled me to triple my output.
I felt—still feel, sometimes—like I’m no longer getting enough exercise, even though I did my first (micro-mini) triathlon in March. Yep, I’m exercising still, but it’s not a focus.
The fiction writing is.
I’m getting slow again on email (a feature of fiction writing). I’m solidly unavailable until I get my words done, and I’m back defending that vigorously. A little part of myself stood to one side and watched with amusement as a podcaster tried to convince me to do an interview with his millions of listeners…before noon my time.
Nope, no, not doing it. And I was forceful about it too. Thank heavens the exchange was in email because I was really pushing back hard. I might’ve insulted the guy in person—not because he was pushy (although he was) but because I had finally found my space again and I was going to defend it no matter what.
I’ve relaxed my stance on school so much that I skipped a class for the first time in more than 40 years because I really didn’t want to do what was scheduled that day. I would never have done that in the height of the (Zoom) pandemic. I even “attended” class the day after I got my first Covid vaccine…and fell asleep in front of my computer.
Best of all, though?
Ideas are coming in a way that I can easily access them. I wrote a lot during the pandemic, but it was in fits and bursts and it often felt like I was sneaking time away from valuable survival practices.
Now I’m getting deep into what I’m doing. Multiple files are open all the time. Sticky notes grace my desk in a constructive way, not in a don’t forget to do this kinda way.
It feels good.
I’m not all the way back, though. I’ve spent a goodly part of 2023 figuring out what the pandemic habits I’ve adopted are, and whether or not they’re worth keeping.
I’ve been changing most of them, but some of them remain in my closet with the masks, stored in a Hadestown bag in case some other emergency arises.
I know those masks are useless and ridiculous. I just can’t part with them yet. I suspect they’re a metaphor for other habits I have yet to discover or acknowledge.
I’ll get there.
We are now in that new world I knew was coming after the crisis hit in 2020. I knew (and blogged about) the fact that we could never go back to the world we had in 2019.
We still can’t, although we can reclaim a lot of we lost.
A lot of what we have is new, though. Being in class with kids who lost at least a year of in-person schooling has been an eye-opener. It took me a while when in-person classes resumed in the Fall of 2021 to realize that my fellow Spanish students weren’t weird; they just weren’t used to being out in the world. They had lost a lot of social skills or never really had the opportunity to learn them.
Their generation will carry these scars into a future the rest of us can’t fathom yet.
We’re seeing an impact of that pandemic hole in our lives in a myriad of ways. I’ll be blogging about some of it in future pieces because the pandemic hastened some long-overdue changes in entertainment.
Some of us are farther along the recovery path than others. I watched with something like surprise as we’ve greeted visitors to Vegas, friends who admitted they had barely left the house in three years.
I was out of our place every day, walking and waving and seeing people (from a distance). It’s hard to avoid others when you live in a building with 300+ units and four elevators. So when another friend admitted they hadn’t been on an elevator in three years and was terrified to be that close to people, I had to reassess my assumptions. Some people are just now moving forward, and others haven’t even left their neighborhood yet.
We’re all assessing our pandemic damage. We not only have to figure out what it is, but how much effort we’re going to put into fixing it. We changed not just habits during the pandemic, but our entire lifestyles. In some ways, we changed. Period.
The question we all have is whether or not we want to rebuild or if we want to build anew.
And I don’t think that’s a global question. It’s a habit-by-habit, detail-by-detail question.
Yeah, I’ll bet most of us have stopped wiping off our groceries. But I suspect each one of us has a stupid pandemic habit that we’re not willing to part with yet…if ever.
Because it comforts us.
Like those masks in the closet.
Maybe they’re not being saved for a rainy day. Maybe they’re there as a reminder of what we’ve—what I’ve — been through. A reminder that I might not need after a few more springs.
Maybe, one day, the blooming cacti will be reminder enough.
Maybe, one day, I will go through a spring without remembering 2020 at all.
I’m hoping so.
Because I’m not just ready to move forward. I am moving, discarding one no-longer-necessary pandemic coping mechanism at a time.
To support the business blog:
Join me on Patreon
or
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynruschr4e to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: Assessing Pandemic Damage,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © 2023 by Kristine K. Rusch
Centuries ago, a tsunami hit the Oregon Coast, destroying miles of coastline. When beach erosion reveals the stumps of a dead forest from that disaster, Anne and Louisa cut school to see the trees. But they freak Louisa out. She sees faces trapped inside the wood—and she believes she has the magic to free them.
“Forest for the Trees,” by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story is also available in ebook through various online retailers here.
Forest for the TreesKristine Kathryn RuschOn Wednesday, there were three cop cars in front of Louisa’s house. On Thursday, she didn’t come to school. On Friday, when she joined the smokers in the parking lot, I grinned at her as if nothing was wrong.
“Wanna cut class?” I asked.
She bummed a smoke and sucked on it like she’d been smoking all her life. Actually, when I met her a year ago, she’d never had a smoke or a drink. She’d never done anything except follow the rules, which, I gotta admit, I thought was pretty boring.
“We could see the forest,” I said.
She looked at me sideways, and I could see she was tempted. We’d been planning to go to the forest, but no one wanted to do it on the weekend when it would be full of tourists.
Dodging tourists was part of living in Seavy Village—just like the traffic and the foggy mornings and the pounding surf in the middle of the night. People said we were lucky to grow up here, but what did they know? The town was only interesting when you came to visit. Staying was something else altogether.
“The forest, Anne?” Louisa asked, stubbing out her cigarette on the school’s brick wall. “How would we get there?”
I shrugged. “Walk?”
It wasn’t as strange a suggestion as it sounded. Seavy Village was only seven miles long. The high school was at the south end. The forest, as everyone was calling it, was most visible in Seaview Beach, which was a mile south of Seavy Village. In fact, most tourists thought the town of Seaview Beach was still a part of Seavy Village. But we locals knew different.
“Why the hell not?” Louisa said. She still hadn’t looked at me directly. “Let me get my gym shoes from my locker.”
She walked to the main door and disappeared inside the school. I smoked another cigarette and watched the buses pull up. Kids from all over the county came to Taft High. Some of them had bus rides of an hour or more. I used to think living in town was bad until I dated a guy who lived out. There was nothing to do at his place. He didn’t even have neighbors for a mile in either direction.
I didn’t have a lot of neighbors either—most of the folks who owned houses near us were weekenders—but there was the comfort of being in a neighborhood. And when Louisa moved in down the hill, I actually had the chance to make a friend.
She came out without her book bag. It was strange to see her without it. We were good students. We studied and everything. But class got pretty redundant, so we stayed away as much as we could.
Her Reeboks looked out of place with her dark brown pants and matching top. Louisa was one of those color-coordinated girls. You know the kind, the ones who always understood which earrings went with what shirt and who learned to carry a different purse with each outfit when they were, oh, maybe five.
I tried living like that for a week once in the ninth grade and decided it was way too much work. Sometimes I thought I wasn’t meant to be a girl. I couldn’t put on makeup to save my life; I usually wore jeans and a sweatshirt; and I didn’t even care what my mom’s best friend—who also happened to be our stylist—did to my hair.
The thing I liked best about Louisa was that she didn’t try to make me just like her and she didn’t hang out with me because my lack of style made her look good. She hung out with me because we could talk, and because, it seemed, she thought I was smart, which most people didn’t get right away.
“You ready?” she asked, shooting a nervous look at the buses. The drivers had to report truants and tardies if they saw them. But right at that moment, they were busy making sure everyone got off the bus. They wouldn’t notice us if we hurried.
“Yeah,” I said, and headed out.
We took the path that led around the school. The first few blocks would be the hardest. Once we got to the beach, we’d be okay.
I’d cut class a lot of times before, and I never got caught so long as I stayed on the beach.
I didn’t know what Louisa was thinking. She had her hands in her pocket and her head down. She didn’t even notice the equipment moving dirt as we walked up the footpath to High School Drive.
They were breaking ground for a new movie theater—a six-plex, according to my mom, who was a real estate agent—but I’d believe it when I saw it. Nothing good ever came to this town. At least, that was what it felt like.
We didn’t even get the stuff most kids considered normal—CD stores, bookstores, good clothing stores. The six-plex wouldn’t open until after we graduated, so we were stuck with the Bijou, which had the same movies all the time.
I took up smoking just to have something to do. It added a little thrill, a sense of adventure, a hint of bad. If I got caught, it would be a change of pace.
We crossed Highway 101 and headed down 40th to the beach access. The steps were steep and the railing had washed away in a December storm.
The wind was cold down here and the fog was so thick that the sand and the sky melded into one gray nightmare.
“I don’t think we can walk down there,” Louisa said, and she had a point. Whiteout conditions were dangerous. You couldn’t even see the line of the surf, and you’d have no idea of a big wave or a log or something was rolling right at you. Plus you could get lost.
I squinted at the fog, as if that made things better. “Let’s take back roads, then.”
Back roads were almost as good as the beach, especially on foggy days. No one would be able to tell who we were or how old we were. Even a cop car passing would be concentrating on avoiding the pedestrians, not seeing if they were delinquent kids.
We were halfway up Brown’s hill when I finally had the nerve to bring up Wednesday.
“You wanna talk about it?” I asked. I didn’t have to clarify. Louisa knew what I meant.
She shoved her hands deeper in her pockets and walked a little ahead of me, the fog swirling around her. Our footsteps rang on the pavement, but that was the only sound except for the ocean pounding below us. Louisa wasn’t going to tell me. She never did.
Still, Wednesday had been pretty bad. Three cop cars, like I said, and her mom across the street, sitting beneath our mailbox, wrapped in a sweater and crying. I stood in our living room window and watched, holding my breath most of the time.
I could see two cops inside, just their legs through the doorway, and Louisa’s dad’s legs too, his feet shuffling as if he were trying to get past someone and do something else. I never saw Louisa that day, and I was too scared to call.
When the third cop car showed up (and for one scary moment I thought it was an ambulance), Louisa’s mom had the cops escort her back inside. She came out nearly ten minutes later, carrying a suitcase and a pillow, looking stressed, her head down as if she couldn’t face the neighborhood.
That was enough for me. I got my mom and asked her if we should go down there, maybe tell the cops that Louisa had to be inside, and that she shouldn’t be left alone with her dad. But my mom said getting involved would only make her dad madder if, indeed, that was the problem (Her mother is crazy, you know, my mom added as if that made it all better), and maybe I should think about finding a new friend.
“You think the forest is still there?” Louisa asked.
Her voice sounded rusty. We were on the downhill side of Brown’s Hill, walking past the stucco mansion that kept falling apart in the rain.
“Yeah,” I said. “They don’t think it’s going to go away until May.”
We were wet by the time we crossed the bridge over the Dee River, the divider between Seavy Village and Seaview Beach. The Dee was a tidal river that flooded real bad in a freak storm a couple of years ago. I always went over it with caution now, afraid that I’d be on the bridge when the next freak storm hit.
The forest was another one of those freak things that made this part of Oregon a little stranger than most. It wasn’t really a forest, not any more. It was the remains of a forest, hundreds of years old. The tree stumps were petrified and then buried by sand.
They reappeared every fifty years or so and only on a winter beach. Mr. Johnson said that was because there was less sand on a winter beach—the sand got washed out to sea or something in the fall, only to get put back in the summer. And some years, the years the forest came back, the sand got sucked down to some prehistoric level or something.
Not that the forest is prehistoric. It’s about four hundred years old. You see, in the early 1700s there was this massive earthquake along this coast, so big that Japan got hit by a tsunami. Since Japan had a society then that recorded time and tragedies and stuff, we know the exact time the wave hit (and wiped out some villages, I guess). If you calculate backwards, and do all sorts of math like wave speed and force and stuff like that, you can figure out to the minute when the earthquake hit the Oregon coast.
A whole chunk of coast fell into the ocean during that earthquake. There was a tsunami here too, and it knocked down the entire forest. The trees snapped like twigs, and the logs washed away, probably to get thrown up on some other beach, or travel inland along the rivers.
But the stumps of those trees petrified somehow. And every so often, they get uncovered, just like they were this winter. The first time in my lifetime.
When we reached Seaview Beach, most of the fog was gone. We ducked down a side road, through a housing development and practically ran to the beach. All our caution seemed to be for nothing. Most of the houses were empty, and they shouldn’t have been. This housing development was new and affordable, according to my mom. The kind of place that locals bought, even if it was on the west side of 101.
We’d nearly reached the beach access when Louisa stopped. She turned to me, her face dotted with drops from the fog, and her cheeks red from the cold.
“Maybe we shouldn’t do this,” she said.
“Why not?” I asked. “We’re here.”
“Just a feeling.”
“You think someone’s gonna see us?”
She peered at me as if trying to understand my question, then shook her head. “Not cops or grownups.”
“Who then?”
She shrugged and turned away. “No one, I guess.”
She started down the road that led to the beach access. I followed. There were no cars parked nearby, and no one in the surrounding houses.
Here, the fog bank held off to sea, a big thick cloud that could come inland at any point. If we were going to see the forest, we had to do so quickly or it might get hidden in whiteout conditions, just like we’d found on the beach farther north.
Louisa stood above the stairs that led down to the beach, her arms crossed. I passed her and took the steps two at a time—a stupid thing to do, considering they were wet and covered with sand. But I was committed, so I continued all the way to the beach itself.
“Come on,” I said.
She glanced over her shoulder once, as if she wanted someone to stop us, and then she climbed down.
I had never been to this beach access and it took me a moment to see the forest. At first, I thought the sand was littered with an unusual number of rocks. As I got closer, I realized they were stumps, flattened and molded by the sea.
The tide was out, and the water’s edge seemed very far away. Overhead, a gull cried, its sound plaintive and mournful in the still air.
Louisa stood directly behind me, so close I could feel the heat of her body.
“Oh, my god,” she said. “Do you see it?”
“See what?” I asked. “The trees? They’re kinda cool. I was thinking maybe we should get close to them, see what they feel like. I mean, they look like stone, but maybe they feel like wet wood—”
“No.” Louisa grabbed my arm, keeping me back. “Stay here.”
“Why?”
“Can’t you see it?”
She was beginning to get to me. “Of course I can see it,” I said. “They’re right in front of me.”
“Not the trees,” she said. “The faces.”
I squinted. Try as I might, I couldn’t see any faces anywhere. “What are you talking about?”
“In the wood.” She pointed with her other hand, the one that wasn’t clutching my arm and cutting off the circulation. “See? On top of that one, and the side of that one….”
Her voice was shaking. She actually saw faces, and it was freaking her out.
“Yeah,” I said. “It’s like seeing monsters in fluffy white clouds. Get over it.”
But she didn’t move and she wasn’t letting go of me. I shook her off and walked down the sand. It was hard-packed, like a path, and the water didn’t come up this far—at least, it hadn’t in the last week or so. I could see all the footprints of the people who’d come before to look at the weird trees.
“Anne, please,” Louisa said. “Don’t go any farther.”
But I was feeling tough that day. I walked deeper into the trees and finally crouched by a big flat one. I looked at its side, its sheered top, molded round by the water, and the side half-hidden by sand. I didn’t see a face at all.
“It looks safe to me,” I said.
“It can’t be.” Her voice was soft. “They’re dead.”
“They’ve been dead a long time.” I didn’t even try to hide my exasperation. “Any souls they have have long since gone to heaven.”
“Don’t mock,” she said, holding up her hands in a gesture I’d never seen before. “Please come back.”
And because she was so freaked, I did. I peered at her, trying to see my friend in that panicked face, those staring eyes. “What’s wrong with you?”
She looked away. “Can we go now?”
“We just got here.”
“I don’t want to stay. I want to go to school.”
“Okay,” I said. “But this might be our only chance to be down here alone.”
“I hope so,” she said. “I really do.”
***I didn’t see her for the whole weekend. There weren’t any cop cars in front of her house, though, and her mom was back, laughing with her dad as if nothing had happened. My mom sniffed and said something about the cycle of abuse and how I should learn from it and maybe she could find me some reading material on it, and I stopped listening at that point because it sounded too much like homework.
There was a new movie at the Bijou, but Louisa didn’t want to go. By Sunday, I’d seen it three times, and decided it wasn’t really worth the repeat viewings. I walked down to the beach a couple of times to sneak a cigarette, and I did my homework, and when my dad wanted to see the forest late Sunday afternoon, I decided to go with him.
My dad’s a strange guy. Lanky and so young-looking that sometimes people ask me if he’s my brother. He’s like this computer whiz and he’s worked at home as long as I can remember. Important people call him on the phone or e-mail him and ask him to do these impossible projects and he just does, like it’s nothing.
But because he works at home, he gets these bugs up his butt for no apparent reason. Once he took me to Cascade Head in the middle of the week because the hiking trail had opened and he’d heard that a rare wildflower was blooming up there. We never did find it, but later he told my mom that we’d done a lot of daughter/father bonding.
I thought we’d done a lot of daughter/complaining, father/placating, but I never said that to him. He had fun, and I guess that was enough for me.
I’ve always a little protective of my dad. He never does really seem like part of the world. Which goes a long way to explain why when he asked me to see the forest with him, I didn’t roll my eyes and tell him I’d already been, thanks. I just went.
It was creepier the second time, even though the sun was shining and the ocean glistened a pretty blue. The stumps still looked like rocks. I finally touched one and it felt like anything you found on the beach, slimy in some places, dry in others, and covered with so much sand that it just kind of clung to you.
But that uneasy feeling Louisa had sparked in me stayed, and I found myself walking through the broken forest, looking for faces.
“You seem intense,” my dad said.
“You think people lived in these trees?” I asked him. “You think maybe they all died when the wave hit?”
“There’s no way to know, hon,” he said. “I’m sure there were some people here. A lot of Native Americans camped here in the summer.”
“But the quake was in the winter.”
He gave me a lopsided smile, my dad’s apology smile, the one he used when he had only half a piece of information and knew it. “Well, then,” he said. “Your guess is as good as mine.”
I was just trying to figure out what set Louisa off, and I couldn’t. Maybe it didn’t have anything to do with the trees. Maybe it was about the cop cars and the stuff she wouldn’t talk about, the stuff that my mom said made her bad friend material.
Because my mom didn’t approve of Louisa, I didn’t feel like I could talk to my dad about her either. My parents shared stuff with each other, mostly everything, from what I could tell, and sometimes it made me feel like the odd person out. I didn’t have anyone to share everything with, and if I told one of them, they’d tell the other, even if they weren’t supposed to.
Still, I tried one more time. “You think a lot of people died on this beach, Dad?”
He frowned at me—his concerned look. “What’s this with you and death? Are you depressed? Do we need to talk about something? Is there something you’re not telling me?”
I rolled my eyes and shook my head. “Da-ad.”
“Listen, Anne, you know how precious you are to us. You know….”
I knew and I stopped listening, just like I always did. Since the high school shootings started, and all the articles about stuff like that being one way kids dealt with depression (the other, apparently, being suicide), my dad would occasionally freak like this.
He was always convinced he’d missed something. I suppose that was because he usually did. He went through life missing stuff. I guess it was only reasonable to suppose he’d miss important stuff with me too. Not that I cared. If I really needed his help, I asked. Maybe I wasn’t normal that way.
I’d asked this time, he’d misunderstood, and I decided not to say any more. It was okay. The way things’ve gone, I’m kinda glad we never talked about it. I guess there are just some things in life you don’t want your dad to know.
***On Monday morning I was in my usual spot, sneaking a smoke from T. Walker, when Louisa ran over. Her hair was a mess and her shirt had an old grease stain running across the front. She’d never come to school looking like that, and it scared me.
“Anne,” she said, grabbing my arm and pulling me away from the wall. “I figured it out.”
“Figured what out?” I leaned backwards so I could hand the cigarette back to T. Walker. He raised his eyebrows like he was as shocked at Louisa as I was, even though he probably couldn’t care less. T. Walker didn’t care about much except his smokes and his guitar. That was probably why I liked him.
“How we can save them.”
“Save who?”
“The faces.”
Okay. That was it. She wasn’t acting like Louisa at all. Maybe something happened at home, and maybe she wanted to talk about it. But this seemed like a strange way to do it.
I walked farther into the parking lot, crossing the small grass divider and going into the forbidden section where the teachers parked their cars. We could get in trouble for standing there, but guaranteed no other kids were going to join us.
“Louisa, there aren’t any faces. I went with my dad this weekend. I didn’t see—”
“You what?” She sounded like I’d committed mass murder.
“I went with my dad. He wanted to see them.”
“It’s not safe there, Anne. Jeez.” She ran a hand through her hair. I finally realized how it got so mussed. “Didn’t I tell you that?”
“It’s the beach, Louisa. Of course it’s not safe.”
She looked at me as if I was the crazy one. “It’s not the beach. It’s the spirits.”
“Huh?”
“The tree spirits. I’m not sure what kind they are.”
“What are you talking about?”
She sighed. “Come to my house. I’ll show you.”
God, the first invitation and it had to come like this. Right after my mom went through one of her big rants about abuse. Less than a week after the cop cars show up for the umpteenth time.
“We got class,” I said.
“Like that’s important to you.”
“It is,” I said.
“Mr. Carlson’s the only one who grades on attendance, and you don’t have him until sixth period.”
“We cut on Friday.”
“So?”
“So—I don’t know. You’re being weird, Louisa.”
Her entire expression changed. One minute she was my friend, and the next it was like a mask fell over her face. She nodded, then gave me the fakiest smile. “You’re right. I was being weird. It’s not like me. I’m sorry.”
I’d never seen her do that before. The change, I mean. I’d seen the fakey smile before, usually when she was talking to some kid she didn’t like, some kid who harassed her. She’d never given me that look before.
It scared me. “I didn’t mean anything.”
“No,” she said. “You’re right and I’m wrong. Every once in a while, I forget….”
She let her voice trail off as she turned away from me. The smokers on the side of the building were all watching us. Had one of us raised our voice? I didn’t think so, but I couldn’t remember.
“Forget what?” I asked.
She shook her head. “Let’s go inside. It’s almost time for first period.”
“I’m sorry if I said something wrong.”
She gave me that fakey smile again. “Of course you didn’t.”
Then she started across the parking lot. I had to run to keep up. When I reached her side, I said, “You know, Louisa, maybe we should go to your house anyway. You need to change shirts.”
“I’ll take care of it.” She kept walking, going even faster as if she were trying to get away from me. She got to the building before me and by the time I got inside, she was gone. I searched for her, looking in all the usual places—near her locker, in the bathroom, outside the cafeteria—and she wasn’t in any of them.
She didn’t show for first period either or for third. By then I was getting a little freaked myself. When I got into the hall in the crush between classes, I leaned against a bank of lockers and hit the speed dial on my phone.
No answer. I had dialed Louisa’s cell which made it even weirder. She usually answered her cell.
I used my address book and tried her home number. I’d put it in on a lark. I’d never had to use it before, because Louisa kept her cell with her at all times. Once I’d even called her in the middle of the night, and she’d answered. She’d been asleep, but her cell had been right there beside her, just like usual.
The phone at her house rang and rang too.
“Problem, Miss Moore?” Ms. Silvani was watching me from the door to her room. She was our English teacher. Pretty young, according to my mother, and really woo-woo, according to my dad. What it meant to me was that she knew a lot of New Age stuff and didn’t bore us with all that Christian crap, although she could explain it when she needed to.
I hung up the phone and stuffed it in my purse. “Do you know anything about tree spirits?” I asked.
She gave me a little smile. “Tree spirits?”
I nodded.
“Is this for a class?”
I couldn’t lie and say it was for English because she would know. So as I nodded, I thought it through. “Extra credit in social studies.”
“Extra credit? What do you need that for, Anne? Have you been skipping again?”
All the teachers, it seemed, knew I skipped whenever I felt like it. Most of them never mentioned it, the way you don’t mention that someone’s got really bad b.o. or toilet paper stuck to their shoes.
I shrugged. “Do you?”
“What would tree spirits have to do with social studies?” Ms. Silvani asked.
“You know that forest that just washed up?”
“Yes,” she said.
“We’ve been talking about it, and I thought I’d do a paper on beliefs, you know. What would the Native Americans’ve thought. They believed in tree spirits, right?”
Ms. Silvani took a deep breath, like I’d asked her the secret of the universe. “The tribes here on the coast had their own culture and much of it has been lost.”
“Okay, but—”
“The belief in tree spirits is specific to particular regions.”
I frowned. “What do you mean?”
“Well, I don’t know much about Native American belief systems, I’m sorry to say, and I know even less about the local tribes. But I do know that European myths deal with tree spirits. That’s why we knock on wood, to awaken the spirit in the tree so that it hears our wish.”
“Oh,” I said. This wasn’t what I wanted to hear. I had to work hard at trying not to look at my watch. I knew Ms. Silvani. She could go on for hours. My mistake for asking her.
“A lot of cultures believe that if a tree dies, its spirit dies too. The Greeks said the Dryad, their version of a tree spirit, was tied into the life of her tree. If her tree got ill, so did she. Some cultures thought that destroying a tree would bring the wrath of the spirit upon them and others had no thought that trees were anything but—well, trees.”
“Um, thanks,” I said, hugging my books close. “I guess I should go look up the Greek stuff huh?”
“I’d look up the local myths, if you can. There are some people in Portland who might know about the local tribes. I’d recommend that you go to the casino, but the Natives there really don’t specialize in traditions. They might be able to send you to someone who does—”
“No offense, Ms. Silvani,” I said, “but that sounds like too much work for a two-page paper.”
She smiled. “I thought work was something you liked.”
Usually. But not at the moment, not when I was trying to figure out what to do about Louisa. I’d hoped that Ms. Silvani would have given me a clue to what Louisa was talking about and—
She had. I must have looked like a light bulb went off behind my face.
“What is it?” Ms. Silvani asked.
“I, um, just figured out how to do the paper,” I said.
She smiled.
“Thanks!” I waved at her and headed down the hall, as if I were going to class. The second bell rang and I waited a few minutes before going back to my locker.
The hall cleared the minute the bell rang. It went from being too crowded to being empty. I dialed Louisa’s cell phone again and got no answer. I swore, my voice echoing in the empty hallway. Then I went back to my locker and got my coat.
Louisa had seen dead faces in the trees. Now she was talking about tree spirits. I didn’t know what she’d been watching on TV, maybe too much Buffy, but I had a hunch she was about to do something strange.
And, I guessed, she told me about it so that I would stop her.
***It took me longer than I thought to get home. I had to duck twice because some school buses arrived late—apparently there’d been a blockage on 101 and they couldn’t get by. I didn’t want anyone to report seeing me on the road.
When I got to our street, I saw that Louisa’s parents’ cars were gone. The house looked pretty empty. So did ours, up on the hill. The windows were open, but the lights were off inside. Dad must have forgot to turn them on again.
I pulled my coat tighter and went to Louisa’s front door. Up close the place looked kinda small. The paint was peeling on the garage side of the door, and the screen door was covered with coastal rust.
I never thought of Louisa’s parents as being poor. I kinda thought they might have money. She always looked so great and had the trendiest stuff, which I never got unless I bought it myself. My mom said it made me appreciate it more. Yeah, right.
I knocked, then took my hand back as if I could take the knock back. This probably wasn’t a good idea. What if her dad was here by himself? Would he get mad at me? I had no idea how this abuse thing worked except what I saw on TV, and I knew that wasn’t real.
I had just started to walk away when the door opened.
“Hey,” Louisa said.
I jumped.
She was standing behind the screen, looking messier than she had before. Like she was baking or something.
“I thought you were going to stay in school.” At least she didn’t have that fakey smile any more. But she was watching me like she didn’t know me.
“I got worried about you.”
She shrugged. “Now you know. I’m fine.”
“I’m sorry about what I said—”
“I don’t care. I’m busy. Is that all you wanted?” She’d never been that cold to me before.
“No,” I said. “Whatever you wanted me to do, I’m willing.”
She studied me for a moment. I thought she was going to tell me to go away, and then she said, “Okay. Come on in.”
She pushed open the screen door. It squealed from the rust and the lack of WD40, something my dad would have done at the first hint of a squeal.
I stepped inside.
The house wasn’t as dingy as it seemed outside. In fact, it was full of bright light, even though the sky was gray. I looked up. The entire ceiling was a skylight, coated with some kind of yellow that seemed to make it even brighter in there. I thought it might be unbearable on a sunny summer day.
Plants grew everywhere, climbing the wall, creeping over iron chairs, lining the window that overlooked the interior of the garage. I recognized the design of the house. There were others in the neighborhood just like it. Mom said it was a 1940s development—kind of a ranch. Only someone had covered over the walkway that led to the entrance and made it into a room.
It was cozy and it smelled green. I liked it.
“Cool,” I said.
She grinned. It was the first real look she’d given me since I called her weird. “I was in the kitchen when you knocked,” she said.
She led me past the plants and up one concrete step into what used to be the front door. This opened into the living room, which was L-shaped. A big picture window with a view of the ocean dominated the room. An old-fashioned brick fireplace sat in one corner, and the faint smell of wood smoke made it clear it was used a lot.
The kitchen was to my right. There was a pass-through window, made of wood, and then the kitchen itself, small and boxy. I thought of the big modern kitchen my dad had put into our house three years ago and wondered how anyone could cook in this thing.
It was clear someone was cooking though. A pot of water boiled on the stove, making the room humid, and three books were open on the tiny counter.
Above the sink was another window with an ocean view. Those windows kept the place from feeling too tiny. Still, I had no idea how three people could live in such a small area.
“Okay,” Louisa said, leaning up against the counter. “I’m going to tell you what I’m doing. If you don’t like it, don’t say anything. Just go back to school. I don’t want to hear that I’m weird. I know that I am.”
I nodded. Until that day, I’d never thought of Louisa as weird. She seemed pretty defensive about it, so I didn’t say anything.
Louisa ran a hand through her hair. “You never asked about the cop cars.”
“Yes, I did,” I said, surprised at the change of subject. Did she think she was weird because her dad hit them? If my mom was right, that wasn’t weird. It happened to lots of kids.
“No, you didn’t. You just wanted to know if I wanted to talk about it and if I didn’t, that was okay. Most other places, everyone would want to know. Why were there cop cars? What was going on? And then someone would call the social workers and they’d start the whole processing thing until they’d realize it wasn’t what they thought. Although in some places, they thought it was worse.”
I had no idea what she was talking about.
“My mom,” she said, very carefully, “is a witch.”
I shrugged. “Mine can be too.”
“No,” she said. “I mean it. She’s a real witch.”
“Like on Charmed?”
She rolled her eyes. “That’s made up stuff. My mom follows the Old Gods.”
“Oh,” I said, not knowing there were old gods.
“And sometimes she does stuff that—I don’t know.” Louisa shook her head. “Never mind.”
“No, it’s okay.” I really didn’t care why her dad beat her mom up, but if she needed to talk about it, I was willing to listen.
“People call the cops,” Louisa said, her voice low. “And it’s none of their business. She does rituals. Like when she planted the garden. On Wednesday. Our yard is fenced, you know.”
“I know,” I said, hoping I didn’t sound as confused as I felt.
“So she thought she had the right to—” Louisa blushed.
“To?”
“It’s a fertility ritual. You have to be naked.” She said the words all in a rush.
“That’s why the cops were here?”
Louisa nodded. “They took her away because they wanted her to see some counselor. She came right back. The counselor yelled at the cops, and told them they needed training in alternate religions.”
“But your dad—”
“Is used to it. He doesn’t fight it any more. He just waits.”
I was really surprised. This town was so small someone usually gossiped about this kind of stuff. I had no idea why I hadn’t heard anything this time.
Or maybe they all believed like my mother did.
“So,” Louisa said when it was pretty clear I wasn’t going to ask questions. “I looked up the trees in my mom’s books.”
“The trees? Oh! The trees.” I had forgotten for a minute. My head was spinning with the thought of Louisa’s naked mom outside (it was cold that day. What was she thinking?) and her dad just waiting his way through all this stuff, and the whole town thinking they hated each other when they probably didn’t at all.
“Yeah. I looked them up,” Louisa said, “and there’s this ritual that if you do it right might set the spirits free.”
“You don’t have to be naked, do you?” I wouldn’t do that. Not on the beach in the spring. It was always chilly on the beach.
Louisa laughed. “No. We just have to make this potion and sprinkle it on the trees and then say this stuff.”
“Does it work if you don’t have magic?”
“See, that’s where you watch too much TV.” She grabbed a wooden spoon and turned toward one of the bowls. “It’s not about powers you’re born with. It’s something you learn. That’s why it’s called witch craft.”
“So there’s no good witches and bad witches?”
“Sure there is, but my mom doesn’t know any of the bad witches. She doesn’t have that kind of stuff around the house.”
“You’ve done this before?” I asked.
Louisa shook her head. “Mom wanted me to, but Dad says that religion is a choice and I don’t have to make any choice at all if I don’t want to.”
“Is he a witch too?”
“Not hardly. He’s Episcopalian.”
“Oh,” I said again. We didn’t go to church enough for me to really know the difference between Episcopalians and the Methodists or the Baptists. All I knew was that the Catholics had Mass and a ton of rules that we Protestants didn’t have.
“Do you want to help?” She didn’t sound as guarded as she had before.
“I asked Ms. Silvani about tree spirits, and what would happen to them if they’d been in the forest when the earthquake hit,” I said. “She said they’d be dead.”
“Ms. Silvani isn’t a witch.”
“But she knows—”
“She dabbles, my mom says,” Louisa sounded like an authority. “She doesn’t really practice anything.”
“You said they were dead that day.”
“They looked dead. You saw it.”
“No,” I said. “I’ve looked twice. I don’t see anything.”
“Because you’re not trained. If you were trained, you’d see it.” She was stirring whatever was in the bowl. There were lots of ingredients on the tiny counter, all of them in plastic bags marked with purple marker.
“How can you tell the difference between dead and not dead?” I asked.
“I can’t,” she said, and she seemed really unconcerned. I was getting uncomfortable. No wonder she was feeling strange about being called weird. Maybe if she told other kids in other towns that she knew all this stuff, they called her weird and left and made fun of her later. That’s what people do.
I wouldn’t. But I’ve seen it happen a lot.
Still, I wasn’t sure I wanted to be standing there.
“Okay, but you said if they’re dead, then we shouldn’t do this, so I’m thinking that maybe we should wait until your mom gets home and tell her.”
“I did,” Louisa said. “She said it was four hundred years ago, and not my business.”
“Maybe you should listen.”
“To my mom? You don’t listen to yours.”
Okay. She had me there. But my mom didn’t dance outside in the nude for a gardening ritual and specialize in magic.
“I still don’t see why you think they’re not dead,” I said, thinking that might be the way to talk her out of this.
She poured the contents of the bowl into the pot of boiling water, and instantly a smell like flowers and freshly mown grass filled the room.
It made me sneeze.
She handed me a Kleenex, and then set the timer. The water boiled and looked very green.
“The books say that if a person kills a tree, he kills a spirit, depending on the kind of spirit.”
“Yeah,” I said. “Ms. Silvani said that too.”
“But mostly, the spirits are immortal. They move from place to place, tree to tree, when the time comes. They act as guardians for the forests.”
“They don’t do a very good job,” I said, thinking of all the logging that went on around here. The original forests in this part of the state were long gone.
“Well, I don’t think they can do their job,” she said. “They’ve been imprisoned since the earthquake.”
“You think a person did that?”
She shook her head. “One of my mom’s books says that sudden acts of God—a hurricane, a flood—can trap these spirits in the dead tree stumps. Can you imagine being stuck in the same place for four hundred years?”
A shiver ran through me. I was having trouble imagining staying in Seavy Village for another six months. I didn’t want to think about being trapped inside a tree stump for 800 times that long.
“Now do you want to help?” she asked.
I wasn’t sure. Louisa was throwing too much at me too fast.
“It’s okay if you don’t,” she said into my silence. “I mean, I know it’s weird.”
“It’s not weird,” I lied. I didn’t want to hurt her, not again.
She gave me a half smile, like she knew I was lying, but she approved anyway. “You don’t have to come.”
“I know,” I said. “But I will.”
We finished the potion, which was like making some stupid soup no one ever heard of, and then we walked to the forest. Part of me was glad my folks didn’t know what was going on and part of me was really worried. I kept thinking about all the magic stuff I’d read, from Harry Potter to The Wizard of Oz*, and I knew messing with this stuff could only get you in trouble.
I had to admit I was kinda surprised nothing blew up when we put the last of the ingredients into the potion. I thought it should have smelled really bad or something, but it didn’t. It kinda jelled into this liquidy gooey stuff, but that was it. I’d seen worse in the home ec class my folks made me take sophomore year.
Middle of a school day, middle of a work day, and no one was on the beach anywhere. It was drizzly too, which was probably one reason, and cold, so we were pretty bundled up.
The tree stumps were lost to the mist, and you couldn’t see the ocean just beyond them. It was like we were in the remains of a ruined forest somewhere inland, and it made me wonder if these tree spirits that Louisa was so worried about had known we were coming.
What if they did something to us? What if they traded our bodies for theirs? What if we got stuck in the trees?
On the way there, I started to talk to Louisa about all of this, but she shushed me. She said thinking about problems was the worst thing you could do around magic. That was why so many spells went wrong.
So I tried to clear my mind and that didn’t work. It was like trying not to think of pink elephants—suddenly they popped up everywhere. I didn’t tell Louisa my fears any more, but I think she knew.
She seemed pretty quiet herself.
She was standing next to me at the beach access, her hooded raincoat hiding her face, and she would’ve looked like some medieval witch if the coat wasn’t neon blue. She was carrying one bucket of potion. I had the other one, and it was heavy. I wished more than once on the walk here that we’d thought of a different way to carry the stuff.
She took two serving spoons out of her pocket and handed one to me. “I think we should get right in the middle of the trees, and each work in a different direction.”
I thought we should go home, but I didn’t say it. I guess her friendship was more important to me than I knew until that minute. I really didn’t want her to get mad at me again.
I clutched my spoon in my fist like club and followed her through the sand-covered stumps. We got to what she thought was the middle (I thought we were a little too close to the ocean for that) and stopped. She set down the bucket of potion.
At that moment, a wave broke against the shore—a big wave, what we call sneaker waves in Oregon—and it splashed us, grabbing at her potion and trying to take it out to sea. Louisa dived for it, but I’m the one who caught it with my foot.
She got up, soaking wet and gave me a grin. “Thanks.”
I nodded, too cold and scared to talk. She slipped her hood back and pulled open the Tupperware top on the bucket. A wisp of smoke came out and curled into the mist. I told myself it was steam, that the potion was still hot, but I had no idea how it could be after that long walk from the middle of town.
“You go north,” she said. “I’ll go south. But wait until I give you the signal.”
“Wh-what signal?” I managed to ask.
“I’ll pause and then nod at you.”
“Okay.” I was still gripping the spoon like a club.
Louisa dipped into her bucket and I dipped into mine. We started flinging gelatinous bubbles of potion in all directions while she recited nonsense words—at least they sounded like nonsense to me. It also sounded like she had practiced them, because she didn’t slip up and when she repeated herself the words sounded the same.
The bubbles of potion landed on the stumps and stayed, or on the sand and disappeared into it. The mist backed off as if it were afraid of us, and even the ocean quieted down. I thought I smelled something old and decaying, but that might have been coming from the waves. Sometimes the ocean had a rotting scent all its own.
Louisa and I kept backing away from each other, and eventually, the only way I could tell she was still around was the sound of her voice, saying those goofy words. I was glad to hear it, so that I didn’t feel like I was flinging potion all on my own.
Slowly the bucket emptied, my spoon got clotted, and the bubbles didn’t fling as far. The stumps disappeared into the sand, and I had reached the edge of the forest.
I was about to ask Louisa what was next when I realized I didn’t hear her any more.
I didn’t hear anything any more, which really freaked me out. The coast is rarely quiet, and the beach even less so. There’s always wind or traffic or the sound of the ocean pushing against the beach.
But there was nothing. It was as if someone had dropped a glass cage around me. I couldn’t even feel a breeze, which just wasn’t natural. There was always a breeze on this beach. Always.
My damp hair hung beside my face. The mist was still here, the drops holding their place in the air as if they’d been painted there.
Then I heard a sound. It was a creak, like a floorboard in an old house. The creak was followed by another, and another, and suddenly an entire series of creaks. Then the creaks became snaps, the snaps became bangs and I was surrounded by faces—clear, floating faces, all of them with that surprised look that people get when they’d just been awakened from a really deep sleep.
The faces swirled around me, coming at me, peering at me, and I backed up, tripping on the sand and falling against a rock. I may have screamed, or it might have been Louisa. Or maybe we both did. I don’t know.
All I could think about was all those TV shows and movies where spirits floated in and out of people like light, taking them over and becoming them. What would a tree spirit do with me? Kill me for setting it free? Even accidentally?
They swirled closer and closer, hovering over me, peering into my eyes as if they could see what got me to free them. Then they rose up and banded together, like a water funnel in a windstorm. They rose higher and higher, more of them pulling out of the stumps, until they were toweringly high, so high, I couldn’t see the top.
I didn’t move from my place in the cold damp sand. The faces didn’t come near me now. They just kept rising and rising until there were no more coming out of the stumps.
Then they flattened themselves against the skyline, like a giant cloud that had come in too close and was going to pelt us with rain. They hovered for a moment, and a thousand eyes, maybe more, looked down at me.
I never felt so tiny and insignificant in my entire life. I cringed, still hanging onto the spoon.
Finally the faces turned away from me. The cloud swirled for a moment, then headed inland, so fast that a moment later, the sky was clear.
Even the mist was gone.
The tree stumps looked cracked and empty, blacker than they’d been, as if they weren’t going to last through the winter, as if a big wind would take what was left of them and send them out to sea.
It took me a minute to find my voice. “Louisa?”
She didn’t answer. Maybe they took her. Ms. Silvani said in class that some of the minor deities required sacrifices. Did the spirits look at me and decide I wasn’t worthy? Was that why they stared, then flew away?
Or had they flown away because they looked at Louisa and knew she was the one they wanted?
I managed to get up and stagger through the decaying stumps. The sand seemed thicker than it had been, and it was hard to slog through. I finally reached the south side and saw the neon blue coat, crumpled against a rock.
It took me a minute to realize I was looking at Louisa. She was huddled there, her hands over her head, her bucket beside her, the spoon half buried in the sand.
“Louisa?” I asked.
She huddled even more.
“Louisa?” I put my hand on her back.
She looked up, startled. “Are they gone?”
I nodded. “Didn’t you see? They went inland.”
“Oh.” She moved like an old woman, as if each muscle hurt. “I hid when the first face came at me. Did they come at you?”
“Yes.”
She stared at me for a minute. I decided not to tell her the rest. About how the faces inspected me and then stared at me before swirling into a cloud and heading east.
“The forest feels different now, doesn’t it?” she asked.
I nodded.
“Do you think we did the right thing?”
I sat down in the sand beside her, more tired than I cared to think about. I didn’t know the answer. Maybe I was scared of the answer, just like I’d been scared of magic all along.
“You said it before.” I brought my knees up and wrapped my arms around them, hoping to stay warm. “How would you like to be trapped in one place for four hundred years?”
She nodded once, then smiled at me. “Thanks for coming with me,” she said.
“Wouldn’t have missed it for the world.” And, at the time, I was telling the truth.
***So it’s spring now and graduation’s only two weeks away. Things here still pretty much look the same. There were cop cars at Louisa’s house last week—some springtime fertility ritual gone wrong, Louisa says—and her parents are talking about moving again. Mine are wondering if they’re doing the right thing, letting me hang out with a girl whose parents are so abusive they get reported to the cops every month.
The winter beach is going away. The sand’s coming in with the spring tides and the trees are nearly gone. The local newspaper’s full of articles about disappointed tourists and the fact that the trees might not be uncovered for another fifty years.
The paper’s been full of some other things too. Stuff about “eco-terrorists” burning logging trucks, and sabotaging logging equipment and put up blockades that made logging roads impassable.
The strange thing was that no eco-terrorist organization is taking credit. They all say things like, “We think what happened is great. Wish we’d done it.”
Louisa and I are the only ones who believe them. But we don’t talk about it.
We got enough to talk about. We both got accepted to four different colleges, all of them out East, and we’re trying to decide where to go. We’ve decided we’ll go together, so there’ll be at least one familiar face, but we’ve also decided wherever we go, it’ll be far away.
After all, who wants to stay in the same place forever?
Forest for the TreesCopyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Asimov’s SF Magazine in July 2004Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2023 by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © by Mniebuhr/Dreamstime, Hypermania37/Dreamstime
To get an audio version of this blog, click here.
When I was at Clarion years ago, one of my classmates (and now lifelong friend) had a verbal altercation with a waitress. Something was not cooked to his liking, and he had to send the food back. The second attempt didn’t work well either, and he decided to order something else. He took his time. The waitress, annoyed at a long day already, snapped, “What do you want?”
He looked up at her and said calmly, “I want to be rich and never have to work again.”
We laughed, she got angrier, and that sentence became one of our Clarion catchphrases. (We had a lot of Clarion catchphrases. Most of them came from him.)
The sentence is one I think of often, especially when someone asks me what I want in a tone that means they’re not going to give it to me if they can at all help it. The assumption in that sentence is pretty astonishing. I want to be rich and never have to work again.
Rich people do work. Many of them work at managing their money or their investments, but just as many of them work at the job that made them rich, mostly because they love what they do.
I didn’t know that at the time, though, and neither did my classmates. We believed that rich people were idle people who had it made.
That’s a terrible assumption, because we all have a different definition of rich. Some writers will only achieve “rich” when they make several million dollars. Others will achieve “rich” when they make half a million. Still others will achieve “rich” when they make three times their salary…in one lump sum.
It’s the windfall that hurts a lot of writers. That’s winning the lottery to many of them, and as the statistics show, 70% of big lottery winners go broke within three to five years. Among the myriad reasons for that are bad financial decision-making, including failing to calculate how their increased spending will deplete their windfall.
Writers will often think that the windfalls will continue. Not even the major bestsellers have a steady income. Their income streams vary year to year, making the kind of financial planning that people with day jobs do impossible. There’s a different kind of financial planning—one that Dean and I do, one that many business owners do—that looks at the possible earnings from several angles, such as what happens if the money comes in later than expected or not at all. Or, sometimes worse (for tax reasons) what happens if it’s more than expected.
Financial success often stops writers cold, particularly those who write hoping for money. They don’t see a need to continue writing because they have “enough money.” That there is no such thing as enough money (all levels of money can be squandered) doesn’t factor in for them.
And if they’re young and don’t know how to invest, that million dollars they received won’t last ten years ($100,000 per year plus new bigger bills).
I know a lot of writers who won the writer equivalent of the lottery: they got several hundred thousand or maybe a million from a movie or TV deal, but didn’t ask for proper credit. If the writer is good at managing money, as one of my friends was, they buy their home outright and pay cash for a decent car or two so they have transportation. They put a lot of money in savings or safe investments, and keep writing.
But even then, at the most conservative, those writer-lottery payments fizzle out. Do the math. Half a million dollars lasts ten years if the writer spends $50,000 a year, five years if they spend $100,000. Money is finite and writers often forget that.
I’ve talked about this kind of success hurting writers in the past. But that’s not the way that success kills writers and a writer’s career. When most of these writer-lottery winners spend all of their money, they find themselves on comfortable footing again. They know how to earn from a position of not having enough money. They put their head down and write, write, write.
Success, though, can destroy that desire to write.
The first way is really subtle, and it comes from my friend’s statement: I want to be rich and never have to work again*. If the writer has that idea of wealth, then they’ll stop writing altogether as long as they’re rich* (in their own mind, anyway).
It’s tough to ferret that one out, because the writer feels like they’ll get to the writing at some point. But they never do. They don’t see the reason.
Achieving a goal often kills the desire to create, especially if the creative person used that goal as a carrot to get ahead. It’s tough to figure that out, even tougher to solve it, because the writer is goal-oriented. Now the writer needs a bigger goal, and damn, that goal better be close to impossible so the writer might have a chance of continuing forward for a long time.
Another way that success destroys a writer is something Dean, former professional golfer that he is, calls “protecting the lead.” When an athlete in a solo sport (golf, tennis) has the lead, that athlete will often change their style of play mid-game to make sure they don’t lose. If they were playing wildly, they tame down. Or they get in their head.
The problem is, when the athlete protects their lead, they’re actually hurting it. Because they become conservative and toss away whatever it was that got them the lead in the first place. Athletes who protect their lead usually lose by the end of the game.
Same with writers. Their first standalone novel sells a bajillion copies, so they figure that book has “the formula” and they replicate that formula over and over again.
Readers are complicit in this one, because readers say they want the writer to write the same thing that they wrote before. But readers hate it when a writer does that too much, thinking the writer is a one-trick pony. Eventually the readers get bored and move on to other writers…who bring a sense of freshness and surprise to everything they write.
You see, readers do want the same thing from the writer. They want to be surprised. They want to be highly entertained. They want a reading experience that they’ve never had before.
What brings them back to the writer is trust. Trust that the writer will tell a good story. Trust that the writer knows how to entertain. Trust that the writer will surprise them, both from a plot perspective and from an emotional perspective.
Protecting the lead—for the writer—is the worst thing because that destroys the trust with the reader. A reader will give a writer two or three or four books before giving up on that writer. Readers understand that writers go through bad patches, just like other artists. Readers trust the good writer will eventually return.
But if the writer continues to write to formula, the reader eventually thinks the writer had only one good book in them. The readers fade away slowly, so the writer’s books sell fewer and fewer copies until the writer’s success is far in the past. The writer has no idea what happened, because the writer believed they were doing the right thing.
It’s tough to be creative and original when everyone is clamoring for the same-old same-old, but the writer needs to be creative and original all the time.
Another way that success kills a writer? Success ignites the critical voice. Suddenly, the writer is no longer alone in their office making shit up. That writer feels the crowd of millions of readers, all clamoring for this plot twist or that character to survive. This happens a lot to writers who work in series. Later books get harder and harder to finish because of the weight of all that has come before.
The worst thing writers can do is read reviews of any kind, from reader reviews to critical reviews. A friend of mine once had a huge Twitter following (probably still does), but had to go offline 95% of the time because his followers had daily opinions about what he should write next, how he should write that book, and what he did wrong with a previous book.
When I published the nonfiction book Women of Futures Past about the history of women in sf, I started to get a lot of hateful comments on Twitter—from young women sf writers, who claimed that I was lying about women being part of sf from the beginning. The personal attacks were hard and offensive and painful, coming as they did from people I thought would be allies. Instead, these women were angry at me because I had threatened what they believed (without evidence) to be true. It shook me.
I liked Twitter. I enjoyed the interactions, I used to get a lot of news links from it (because I follow major journalists and old journalist friends). I decided not to leave Twitter as my bestselling friend did. Instead, I blocked the haters, even though (at the time) conventional wisdom was that a follower is a follower is a follower, someone who had value to me for my career.
Um, nope. I’ll sacrifice a follower to save my own sanity, thank you.
Now, if you want to follow me somewhere other than Facebook, please go to Spoutible. I’m there as Kristine Rusch.
At millions of copies sold, though, as it is for some writers, it’s hard to block all those negative voices. And the positive ones are even harder. After every Diving book of mine gets released, I get great letters from readers, many of whom are guessing where I’m going to go next. Some of those readers demand that I write about this character or that character in the upcoming book.
Fortunately for me, I don’t work that way. I’m a major contrarian so of someone demands that I do X, I’ll most likely do R. I’ve been that way since childhood. (Imagine living with stubborn little me.) I ceased being a people pleaser long ago.
But most writers are people pleasers and when they have millions of people (readers) to please, those writers freeze. They simply can’t muster up the will to write more, because they know, deep down, that some of their readers will be angry.
It’s easier not to write at all than it is to face the wrath of thousands of readers.
Writers have to figure out for themselves what success is, and what will happen to them when they achieve that success. Writers have to plan for everything from losing their goals to protecting their offices from the cacophony of a million reader voices.
That protection starts before the massive success—or should start before, if possible. Because then the writer will survive. Figuring out how to manage money that arrives in large, intermittent waves will help as well.
And so will a reality check.
Just because you’ve written something big and successful doesn’t make you the greatest writer in the world. It doesn’t make you any better than anyone else.
You’ve become successful. Congratulations. Now, figure out how to stay humble and hungry while dealing with your success. Because humble will stop you from becoming one of those rich assholes that no one can talk to. Hungry will help you continue with your first love, writing.
You can’t always know how you will respond to success before you have it. So the best thing you can do is study other successful people. See what they do right and what they do wrong.
And remember, that sometimes “right” and “wrong” are value judgements, not actual facts. You might not like how Mega Bestseller writes or handles his fans, but you can learn something from him. Watch everything from money management (that you can see) to writing behavior to publishing behavior.
I personally prefer writers who keep writing in the face of incredible success. That’s harder than it looks. It’s easier to be a one-hit wonder and dine out on that one success than it is to keep writing and risking never achieving that “peak” again.
Remember one last thing: sometimes what you consider to be a success is not what the writer considers to be a success. Frederick Faust wanted to be a poet, and managed to publish a few terrible poems in his lifetime.
To support his poetry habit, he wrote what he considered to be pulp fiction…and published an estimated thirty million words under many pen names including Max Brand. Brand was a familiar name for decades for the Westerns he wrote, many of them becoming films, but he also created iconic characters like Dr. Kildare.
Only Faust didn’t really value his fiction writing. He wanted to be a poet. He called his Westerns “old melodramatic junk.”
Three hundred novels and thirty million words looks like success to me. It didn’t look like success to him.
So sometimes writers can be tripped up by achieving what they consider to be success even though others can’t see it.
Be careful. No one teaches you that success can be deadly, but it can.
Does that mean you shouldn’t try to be successful? Hell, no. Strive. Do the best you can. Watch what comes out of your mouth. It can be more revealing than you know.
Do you want to be rich and never have to work again? Do you have some assumptions like that? They’ll bite you down the road if you do.
Realize that you will have some difficulties when you achieve success. Prepare for them. Plan for them.
You’ll be better off if you do.
This weekly blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynrusch to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: How Writers Fail Part 12: Success Kills Them,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © Can Stock Photo / akarnaushenko
A handsome man walks into a bar…and can’t pick up women. Sounds like a joke. Or a bar bet. Or maybe, just maybe, a bit of magic follows him everywhere. A short, somewhat malicious bit of magic, with a fondness for Piña Coladas.
“Say Hello to My Little Friend,” by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story is also available in ebook through various online retailers here and will be included in the collection Fantasies Collide, Vol. 1, which is available for preorder in ebook here.
Say Hello to my Little FriendKristine Kathryn RuschHe was strange from the start, yet oddly compelling.
I can explain the strange. The compelling is harder.
He’d come into my bar about 3:30 Friday afternoons, thirty minutes before the official start of Happy Hour. He’d take a seat as far from the door as he could get. He’d order two drinks—one, a piña colada, the other, light beer on tap.
Then he’d wait.
He was stunningly handsome. That’s the thing you’d see first off. The square jaw, the black-black hair, the laughing blue eyes all accented his broad shoulders and perfect male model physique. Only he dressed like a regular guy: nice suit with a jacket he’d remove when he sat down, white shirt, and shoes that could use some attention. Before the drinks arrived, he’d loosen his tie and roll up his sleeves, revealing muscular arms.
And then he’d nurse the beer.
Any red-blooded woman would look at him, as well as a handful of closeted males. So of course I looked at him. I’m as red-blooded as the next woman—even if it is my bar.
I’m red-blooded, but not pretty. I’m perfectly cast in my role as bar owner. I’m muscular and broad-shouldered too. My father used to say I looked like Bette Davis—and he didn’t mean the young beauty of her early roles. He meant the battle-axe from “Whatever Happened to Baby Jane?” with the crumpled skin and the bugged out eyes and the voice that sounded like she’d smoked a thousand cigarettes too many.
A few men like this look. They figure I’m easy (I’m not) because I’m lonely (I’m not that either), and they try to woo me with lies. The occasional guy who enjoys my friendship takes it a stage farther, but we usually agree to go back to platonic after a few months.
Men who look like this guy never give me a second glance. And if one of them had slept with me by accident (and none of them had), it would have been an invitation that came at last call, and the night would end with him chewing his arm off in the morning.
I know that. So when I started talking to Mr. Weird But Beautiful, I did it not because I wanted him (even though I did). I did it because he looked like he needed some advice.
To understand why he needed some advice, you need to know what my bar looks like. It’s not a fern bar or a sports bar. There are no big screens scattered around, all turned to ESPN. There are no giant booths with huge backs because I don’t want couples making out in my place and getting us slapped with violating the decency laws.
There are round tables of various sizes scattered across the floor, and they get pushed aside on Saturdays, when my favorite DJ comes in to spin the tunes—usually oldies, because I don’t tolerate that hip-hop crap in my bar.
The rest of the time, it’s the juke that’s been here since I bought the place. A pool table against the back wall gives the regulars a reason to return besides my lovely presence.
The bar’s the first thing you see when you come in the door. The back bar is large and mirrored, so it looks like we have even more booze than we do. I put the expensive stuff back there because the business travelers who’ve just had a meeting in the big conglomerate across the street make it worth my while.
The bar is a classic U and made of expensive wood with a polyurethane top, so that I can wipe the thing off every night. Everyone vies for the twenty bar stools that surround the outside of the U, and during Friday Happy Hour, the line for those stools can be five deep.
Although it’s not fair to call them stools. They’re actually tall chairs with rounded backs that hug the backside of whoever’s sitting there. I bought the things from a bar going out of business about five years ago, and they’re the best purchase I ever made. They keep the hard drinkers—the guys who pass out with predictable regularity—in their chairs. These guys don’t fall four feet to the floor, hitting their head on the bar rails on the way down and thinking lawsuit when they finally wake up.
Guys who drink like that—and every neighborhood bar has them—keep our local taxi service in business, especially weekend nights. I don’t even have to call any more. At closing, half a dozen cabs show up here like they’ve been summoned. I confiscate keys, pour the hard drinkers into the cabs, and sign the tab. Then when the drinkers come back for their cars, I won’t hand over the keys until I get reimbursed.
It works for all of us, and rarely does the hard drinker get mad.
I take care of my people. That’s what I’m known for.
Which is why no one was surprised when I started talking to Mr. Weird But Beautiful.
He started coming in long about February, with that uncomfortable look most first timers in a bar often have. He wore a shiny silk suit and a matching silver tie, and he looked good enough to eat.
When he sat at the bar, I was surprised. When he ordered his light beer and piña colada, I waited for the pretty business associate to show up for their meeting.
Only she never came. The beer got nursed and the piña colada disappeared, although I never saw him take a sip.
And as the bar filled up, a bottle blonde stopped beside the empty chair, leaned against the bar, and displayed her assets prettily for him. After she ordered, she turned to him, and he smiled one of those Tom Cruise mighty megawatt smiles, the kind that makes you hot just thinking about it.
She smiled back and I could tell she was feeling like I was feeling—the right word and she was his.
He had one of those deep Barry White voices which carried even though he probably didn’t intend it to.
Her eyes danced and she leaned in, just a bit, as he said, “Please say hello to my little friend.”
Then he looked down.
She flushed, grabbed her drink, and left the bar.
And he leaned back, looking very confused.
Now most guys, when they have a pick-up line that fails, try another one. And any guy who looks like him doesn’t need a line at all.
It was a testament to his attractiveness that no woman ever dumped a drink on his lap or slapped him or called him names. Every woman he approached—and by April, he was approaching the desperate ones as well as the pretty ones—gave him that what-the-hell-did-you-just-say? look and fled.
But he never varied his line, he never altered his routine, and he never ever got anyone to say hello to his little friend.
Until, of course, me.
With Mr. Weird But Beautiful, I found myself feeling oddly responsible. I wanted to sit next to him and say, “What? Your mother never taught you manners?”
But I knew that wasn’t the way to approach him.
Instead, I pulled a bar stool over to his other side, the side away from the empty stool he hogged every Friday, and said, “Your little friend routine doesn’t work.”
He looked at me like he didn’t know I could speak English. Maybe he thought the only sentences in my repertoire were “Light on tap and piña colada, right?” and “That’ll be six-sixty-five.”
It seemed to take him a minute to process this new sentence, and then he said, “It’s gotta work.”
“Nonsense,” I said. “You need a new line, that’s all. Half the women in this place would go home with you if you asked them right.”
“I don’t want them to go home with me. I want them to go home with Marty.”
That’s when I sighed. I couldn’t help it. “Look,” I said, “to get them home with Marty, you need to charm them first.”
“No,” he said. “That’s not fair. Marty needs to charm them.”
“Marty can work his magic in the privacy of your own bedroom,” I said. “You—.”
But by that time, Mr. Weird But Beautiful was giving me the what-the-hell-did-you-just-say? look. He flushed and he was starting to get out of his chair when I grabbed his wrist.
His muscular oh-so-strong wrist.
“I’m trying to help you here,” I said. “It’s been nearly three months, and you can’t get a girl to spend thirty seconds with you. You’re going about it wrong.”
He pulled his wrist from my grasp. “First, I don’t want her to spend time with me. I’m trying to fix up Marty. Second, Marty and I do not share a bed or even a house. Third, what the hell even makes this your business?”
“Nothing, I guess,” I started, but by the time I finished the third word, he was gone.
Without paying for his beer or his piña. And, as usual, the beer was barely touched, but the piña was gone.
It really bugged me that I never saw him drink it.
Especially this time. When I was sitting beside him from the moment I set the drinks down.
These were the closeted guys, one of whom got very drunk on a Friday in March, sidled up to Mr. Weird But Beautiful, and said, “I’ll say hello to your little friend” in a suggestive voice, and nearly got tossed across the room.
Mr. Weird But Beautiful left after that too, although that time he paid, hands shaking. He did come back, though, the following week, and when his closeted stalker came up to him a second time, Mr. Weird But Beautiful held up his hand.
“Look,” he said in a polite voice, the same voice he used for his pick-up line. “I vote Democrat. I believe in equal rights. I know we should be flattered because you’re probably a very nice man. But believe me when I say that my friend and I are not your type.”
The closeted stalker nodded once, then went back to his chair, probably trying to maintain some dignity. He never approached Mr. Weird But Beautiful again, but he did watch from time to time, maybe hoping Mr. WBB might change his mind.
Although I could have told him that he wouldn’t. A guy who doesn’t change his pick-up line is not going to change his orientation, no matter how much the other party hopes he will.
Believe me, I know. Because most guys are oriented toward beautiful—or at least pretty—and no matter how friendly they are, no matter how much they talk to me or flirt with me, they’re not going home with me, and they’re certainly not going to invite me to spend time with their little friend.
At least, not when they’re sober. And I’ve been a bartender long enough to know, they’re not worth a damn when they’re drunk. After a while, you look for meaning, you know? Just a kind word, a phrase, a bit of understanding.
I try a little kindness once a night, just to keep my hand in the game, which was why I talked to Mr. Weird But Beautiful in the first place.
Sometimes kindness pans out. Sometimes it doesn’t.
And sometimes it leads you places you never thought you’d go.
He didn’t sit at the bar. Instead, he took a table in the middle of the room.
And since none of the cocktail waitresses would go near him, I had to wait on him. From the bar, I said tiredly, “Beer and piña, right?”
He looked at me, those blue eyes flat, his expression reserved, his tone one you’d use with a six-year-old. “Just the beer.”
So I brought him the light, still foaming over the stein, and onto the tray. Man, was I out of practice.
I set down the napkin, then the beer, and started to leave, when he said, “I’ve been thinking about our conversation.”
“Good,” I said, and returned the tray, wiping it down before I set it near the server’s station.
“And I’d like to ask you a few questions,” he said just a little louder.
Jodi, the cocktail waitress, raised a single eyebrow. It was her who-does-this-asshole-think-he-is? look.
But there was no one else in the place. So I told her to man the bar, and I walked back to him.
He kicked out the chair beside him. I sat. This wasn’t going to be an easy conversation.
“So why doesn’t it work?” he asked. “That line, as you call it.”
My turn to give him the incredulous look, and I almost hauled out one of the sentences I’d been thinking since he first came in—“What? You were raised by wolves?”—but if I did, he’d bolt, and spend the rest of his life trying this stupid gambit at bars all over town, until he finally gave up and stayed home—alone—for the rest of his life.
I couldn’t decide if that outcome was a crime against nature or just the way things should be.
For a minute, I toyed with answering the question delicately. But I’d tiptoed around delicate the day before, and it hadn’t worked. This guy had spent all night wondering why “Say hello to my little friend,” repelled women. He wasn’t going to get delicate.
He might not even get blunt.
“Look,” I said in my best I’ve-been-around-the-block voice, “we all know that most men name their penis, okay? We know you have a close relationship—a friendship—with that part. We just don’t need to know it from the moment—”
“You think Marty is my penis? Are you nuts?” He stood up, bumped the table, and knocked over the stein. I slid my chair back so I wouldn’t get doused in light beer.
Jodi tossed me the bar rag, but she wasn’t getting anywhere near good ole WBB.
“Who else would he be?” I asked as I set the rag on the table and went for some bar napkins.
“My friend,” WBB said. “You know, the guy who comes in here with me. The guy who drinks the piña coladas.”
“I hate to tell you this, pal,” I said as I tossed half the napkins on the table and the other half on the stain spreading across the floor. “But you come in here alone.”
I expected an argument. I expected him to tell me all about this Marty, who accompanied him. I expected to hear every detail about the delusion.
Instead, WBB said, “That fucking son of a bitch,” handed me a twenty, and walked out of the bar.
“This. This is my little friend. Marty the fucking bastard. Say hello, Marty.”
“Hello,” the little man said in a nasal tone. He was dripping blood over the floors I had just cleaned the beer off of.
“Hello,” I said. “Do you want to press charges? I can call the police.”
The little man shook his head. Blood dripped everywhere.
“Show the nice lady what you can do, Marty,” WBB said. “She’s been kind to me. She deserves to know.”
I flushed at the word “kind.” No one had noticed before.
Marty closed his eyes. His nose was still dripping.
WBB shook him. “Show her.”
And Marty disappeared. But the blood kept dripping on my floor. Ping, ping, ping.
Jodi and I exchanged glances. I’d seen a lot of strange things in my bar, but that was the first legitimate disappearing man.
“Now,” WBB said. “Explain what was going on.”
He shook his fists. Only Jodi and I knew that there was a little guy between them.
Either that or WBB was David Fucking Copperfield.
“Tell them,” WBB said.
“We had a bet,” the little guy said, and reappeared as he spoke. He was dangling between WBB’s hands and looking as forlorn as a human being could. “We bet that no matter how good-looking he is, he couldn’t get me a date.”
“The rest of it,” WBB said.
The little guy sighed.
WBB shook him again.
“We handicapped him,” the little guy said, “by making him say, ‘Say hello to my little friend.’ You know, like in golf. Figuring the good player needed a level playing field with the ugly player. Me.”
“Ugly.” WBB said. “Damn straight.”
I didn’t say anything. I’d seen bar bets before. But judging from WBB’s face the day he first came in—all stunned at the way the bar looked and smelled—he didn’t. He had no idea that cheating was part of the process.
“How much was the bet for?” I asked.
“The year-end bonus,” WBB said. “Five grand.”
“He doesn’t need his,” the little guy said. “People give him stuff because he’s so pretty.”
I stared at WBB. His beautiful blue eyes flashed. He was furious.
He shook the little guy one more time for good measure. “Tell her the rest of it. I’d say, ‘Say hello to my little friend.’ And then you what?”
The little guy cleared his throat. “I disappeared.”
He vanished then quickly reappeared.
“To everyone except me,” WBB said. “I could see the little bastard.”
“I hate to tell you this,” I said, “but he disappeared long before you came into the bar. If he really was with you.”
“He was,” WBB said. “Tell her.”
The little guy shrugged one imprisoned shoulder. The movement looked like it hurt. “It’s my only talent. It’s all I can do. I trained it. Because people always looked at me with pity. I’m short and I’m ugly and you wouldn’t believe the jokes.”
“So you turned the table on your friend?” I asked. “A man who was going to help you? You played a trick on him?”
“He promised he wouldn’t,” WBB said. “He promised he’d stay visible.”
“I did!” The little guy said.
“To me,” WBB said. “And only me. The man who believed in him. I figured once someone talked to him, she’d want to go out with him. I used to think he was clever.”
The little guy tried to wipe his nose but WBB held him fast.
“I believed in him,” WBB said, and dropped him.
The little guy bounced in the pool of his own blood.
“Fucking bastard,” WBB said, and left.
And of course, I never saw him again.
Like “betcha I can’t appear and reappear.” Like “I can make a piña colada vanish without even touching it.” Like “I bet a handsome man like you can’t get a woman to give me a second glance.”
I let him stay. He’s a curiosity. Now that they’re used to him, the regulars place bets right alongside his. The entire place is getting rich.
Except me.
Because there’s a part of me that still wants the fairy tale. You know, you help the gorgeous guy, and even though you’re a plain Cinder Ella, he sees through the grime and makes you his princess.
But WBB hasn’t come back. I haven’t even gotten enough courage to ask his little friend for WBB’s real name.
I know real life is not a fairy tale.
But I also know that tiny men who look like Rumpelstiltskin can’t disappear at will.
And yet this one does.
Somehow that’s not quite enough to overcome my belief in the way the world really works.
You see, I own a bar. I know that people never change their orientation. And WBB, for all his willingness to help his little friend, was oriented toward beautiful—or at least pretty.
And no matter how nice I was, and how much I was willing to help him, and how much his pride made him come back to talk to me, to explain he really wasn’t crazy, I knew he wasn’t going home with me.
I knew he was never going to invite me to spend time with his little friend.
Say Hello To My Little FriendCopyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Imaginary Friends, edited by John Marco and Martin H. Greenberg, Daw Books, 2008.Published by WMG PublishingCover and layout copyright © 2023 by WMG PublishingCover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Alphababy/Dreamstime
To Get a Free AI Audio Version of this blog, click here.
Here we are—the mess of the mess of the mess. Right now, we’re in one of those technological befuddling moments, where the technology is ahead of the law.
What that means, exactly, is this: We’re not sure what the technology can do, so we don’t know if what it’s doing is legal, in a whole variety of ways.
The law is both a scalpel and a cudgel. If we use the law one way, it becomes a cudgel that smashes behavior and does its best to prevent the behavior from ever occurring again. Look at the laws against homicide in your state. Those laws are not scalpels. Those laws are cudgels, deliberately. As civilized humans, we don’t want other humans to commit murder for any reason. End of story.
(Please don’t write to me about exceptions. I know. I write entire novels about them.)
There are many times, however, that we need the law to be a scalpel. We need it to delicately carve good behavior from bad. We also don’t want it to accidentally smash something good to smithereens.
Just today, Dean and I were walking home in a wind tunnel created by the buildings near ours. The wind was bad anyway, but in that little area, it was extreme, like usual. Dean mentioned that there are entire computer programs that could explain why.
Those programs are often used now to examine how the wind works around bridges and tall buildings in relation to other tall buildings. In the past, those calculations were done by engineers and often by hand. One mathematical error and even brand-new bridges and buildings collapse.
If you don’t believe me, look at the footage of the Tacoma-Narrows Bridge before its famous collapse in November of 1940. Technology, math, and engineering of the time simply didn’t allow for prevention in that case. Like so many engineering problems of the mid-20th century, the problems were discovered after the emergency and were added as cautionary tales for designers going forward.
Now, though, tech allows us to prevent all kinds of wide-ranging disasters because of computer modeling.
In some ways, generative artificial intelligence in art, audio, and writing is nothing more than computer modeling. The artificial intelligence isn’t intelligence at all, at least as we know it. It’s an algorithm trained to respond in a particular way to a variety of inputs.
The inputs make the AI program reactive, not creative. My post last week titled “AI And Mediocre Work” dealt with a lot of this, but a comment by Matt Weber capsulized it with a quote from Oliver Sacks, in his book, An Anthropologist on Mars:
Creativity, as usually understood, entails not only a “what,” a talent, but a “who” — strong personal characteristics, a strong identity, personal sensibility, a personal style, which flow into the talent, interfuse it, give it personal body and form. Creativity in this sense involves the power to originate, to break away from the existing way of looking at things, to move freely in the realm of the imagination, to create and recreate worlds fully in one’s mind — while supervising all this with a critical inner eye.
These generative AI programs are useful for a variety of things, some of them mentioned in the comments on the last post, others mentioned in analysis about the programs that you can find most anywhere. What they are not is creative.
Let’s set that aside, though. We will all end up using these programs for one task or another.
What started this little miniseries of blogs was, in fact, my desire to start using AI audio. It had gotten to a level that I feel comfortable putting not only the blog posts into audio, but some of the nonfiction books as well. If you want to find out what I’m thinking about the various audio opportunities for my own work, please look at this post.
Up until that point, a lot of my readers thought I was opposed to using generative AI. I’m not. I have already used several different programs for minor things, and I’m going to use others for relatively major things.
I’m just as interested in the AI art programs as I am in the AI audio programs. I’ve used some mapping programs to help artists visualize the layout of my various worlds. I’m using the free programs, so the tools are often wrong in a variety of ways. I have to use words and bad maps to get my point across. But that’s okay.
I like some of the art I’m seeing from the various programs, and that art would be good enough to use on, say, short story ebook covers, where we don’t want to spend a lot of money. (If any.)
We’re not doing that yet, though, and there’s a really good reason.
Copyright.
The copyright issues on much of the AI usage are a complete mess and that, in my opinion, makes them dangerous to use in any commercial manner.
I don’t use the word “dangerous” lightly. Copyright issues could mean something as simple as removing the item from sale to hundreds of thousand paid in statutory damages.
The problem is that we don’t know what’s happening yet, and because we don’t know, we have to be really careful.
Some of the copyright issues can be resolved with a contract. The Terms of Service on these sites are contracts that you agree to, either by affirmatively clicking I accept or by using the site or by paying money for the service.
The problem with Terms of Service is that they can change on a whim. In its paper on artificial intelligence and copyright published in February, the Congressional Research Service made the passing comment about OpenAI, the developer of ChatGPT and DALL-E.
OpenAI’s current Terms of Use, for example, appear to assign any copyright to the user: “OpenAI hereby assigns to you all its right, title and interest in and to Output.” A previous version of these terms, by contrast, purported to give OpenAI such rights.
As I said, these terms can change drastically. It’s up to the user to check the terms constantly.
Contracts can supercede copyright if done properly, but doing the contracts properly means understanding the law.
And the law is just plain unclear. The article that I quoted above, from the Congressional Research Service, has a good overview of where the law stands right now in the U.S., and provides links.
The law is different in different countries—and is changing so fast that four hours after I finished this post, CNBC put up an article titled “Italy has banned ChatGPT. Here’s What Other Countries Are Doing.” Not all other countries, mind you, but some of the big ones. Please read this.
In a very good overview article, the World Intellectual Property Organization examines the different ways countries have already addressed some aspects of copyright and A.I. It notes that many countries “are not amenable to non-human copyright.” It cites the United States, which we will look at in a moment, and also Australia, saying,
…[in] a recent Australian case (Acohs Pty Ltd v Ucorp Pty Ltd), a court declared that a work generated with the intervention of a computer could not be protected by copyright because it was not produced by a human.
The result is a little less clear in Europe. The Court of Justice of the European Union stated in several cases that
…copyright only applies to original works, and that originality must reflect the “author’s own intellectual creation.” This is usually understood as meaning that an original work must reflect the author’s personality, which clearly means that a human author is necessary for a copyright work to exist.
But other countries, including New Zealand, Hong Kong, Ireland, India, and the United Kingdom, seem to give the copyright in the programmer.
Neither of these instances give the copyright to the person who used the AI program to generate the artwork. In the U.S., for example, that work will have no copyright protection and will be in the public domain. In the United Kingdom, the programmer who created the program the author used to create that cover might actually own the copyright in that art.
The cases get complicated, though, when the thing that the computer program spews out is altered by a human being. If you have a chatbot plot your novel and then you use that plot as the basis for the work, taking bits of that result but not all of it—have you created a new work? A derivative work? Is it something created by a human being or is it something that is strictly speaking computer generated?
(Please don’t try to answer this in the comments. Please.)
So…let’s say you don’t care who owns the copyright of the piece of art you generated through an AI program. Let’s say that if the art’s in the public domain, that’s okay with you.
But these matters are unsettled and as they work their way through the courts, so does a ticking timebomb.
The timebomb is the matter of copyright infringement by generative AI.
The programs were created by scraping the internet, searching for imagery (in the case of the art programs) and writing (in the case of the chatbots). The scrapes are exhaustive. Even if something has copyright protection, it probably got scraped.
For example, last fall, I wrote a Spanish paper that touched, ever so briefly, on Picasso’s Guernica. While researching, I got sidetracked by looking at who owned the copyrights for Picasso’s paintings, and found a complaint by a teacher. She couldn’t get “good” quality slides of any of his work because the Picasso Foundation and various museums vigorously defend the copyright. But poor quality images of all of his work exist all over the web. I can guarantee that they were scraped by AI art programs, along with the work of Rembrandt, which is clearly in the public domain.
Copyright here is a mess, because the scrapings also include artists who are still alive, still producing, and still hoping for commissions. You can generate a piece of art on any one of the sites by asking for an image in the style of your favorite artist.
In most cases, you’ll get a fair (if mediocre) approximation. In many cases, you’ll get an almost exact reproduction of a piece of artwork that is under copyright.
Right now, the programmers are declaring that scraping is fair use. The artists say the scrapings are copyright violations. In the United States, a finding of copyright infringement is a statutory one, meaning that the damages are by statute. And that can mean that the person who infringed can be charged anywhere from $750 to $30,000 per infraction. Meaning that if I got a cover similar to a Picasso and it was an infringement, and sixteen of my friends also got infringing Picasso knock-offs, the copyright owner of that new piece of art (the programmer? The person who requested it?) could be charged nearly a half million dollars in damages.
If that infringement was deemed intentional (and how could it not be, if you asked for something “in the style of”), then the amount per infraction goes up to as much as $150,000. In our make-believe case, that’s 2.4 million dollars. As the online legal site Justia says in its article on copyright infringement,
When a case involves many incidents of infringement, statutory damages can become immense.
The real risk is not having to take your cover down. The real risk is being party to a copyright infringement lawsuit that could bankrupt you and take away your own originally created copyrights.
In examining who would be liable for copyright infringement in the above case in the U.S., the Congressional Research Service says this:
Under current doctrines, both the AI user and the AI company could potentially be liable. For instance, even if a user were directly liable for infringement, the AI company could potentially face liability under the doctrine of “vicarious infringement,” which applies to defendants who have “the right and ability to supervise the infringing activity” and “a direct financial interest in such activities.”
Right now, a large number of cases are wending their way through the courts here in the U.S. I don’t know if the same thing is happening in other countries, but I suspect there are a large number of cases there as well.
It will take a good five years minimum for this to shake out in the U.S., maybe more if Supreme Court gets involved. In fact, I’ve been quoting an article from the Congressional Research Service, which exists “at the behest of and under the direction of Congress” to look closely at various issues that might require a legislative solution. The conclusion of February’s analysis from the CRS is this:
Given how little opportunity the courts and Copyright Office have had to address these issues, Congress may wish to adopt a wait-and-see approach. As the courts gain experience handling cases involving generative AI, they may be able to provide greater guidance and predictability in this area through judicial opinions.
Writers need to adopt a wait-and-see approach as well, particularly if they (misguidedly) include anything from a chatbot in their own writings.
As for using other AI services like art, be exceptionally careful. Do not use the generated art for commercial purposes, which is, essentially, in an enterprise designed to make a profit. If you’re unclear about what that means for your project, then someone else will be too.
When you’re unclear and it could lead to a violation of the law, then don’t do it. Period. If you feel that you could defend your actions in court, let me point something out:
You’d have to go to court to defend that action.
There would be legal fees and other consequences, especially if you’re wrong and you lose.
It’s better to wait until this all shakes out.
So how does it all square with me using AI audio right now? Well, I’m being very careful. I look at the terms of service. I’ve rejected several organizations based on the lack of clarity in their terms of service. The lack of clarity might be about ownership of copyright (and in one case it was) and some of it might be a badly designed TOS. One TOS gave me permission to use the audio file for commercial purposes in the copyright section and then repeatedly stated that the audio file can only be used for non- commercial purposes throughout the rest of the TOS.
Most likely, some minion forgot to clean up the language in the TOS and only changed the copyright section. But do I know that for sure? Or was I looking at a typo in the copyright section where the organization left off the word “non”?
There’s no way to know, and I’m not going to court to find out, so I’m not doing business with them.
I’m also using only the generated AI voices. I’m not using voices in the style of Jennifer Lopez or Denzel Washington. I don’t want to risk using a cloned voice of someone famous for the work I’m doing.
And right now, I’m not letting them clone my voice either. Not that my voice is worth a lot of money, but it might be someday. Who knows?
It’s all unsettled—and I don’t like uncertainty when it comes to my copyrights.
Neither, by the way, do other entities. For example, Neil Clarke at Clarkesworld is very clear about this. When he reopened Clarkesworld for submissions in March, he wrote,
There’s also the matter of rights, specifically a lack of clear ownership of these works. I simply can’t sign a contract without those.
So even if you did do something cool and creative somehow with a chatbot as your basis, you can’t license it to anyone who understands copyright, because there’s no way to know who owns the work you’re trying to license.
As I said in the beginning, this is a mess of a mess of a mess. It won’t be settled for some time.
So don’t be in a hurry. Use the tools that you can safely use for commercial purposes (if you understand Terms of Service). Use the other tools for non-commercial purposes if you use them at all.
I would suggest that when it comes to copyright, you learn to cultivate a very low risk tolerance. You could lose everything if you guess wrong.
And really, is a shortcut worth losing everything?
It isn’t to me. I hope it isn’t to you as well.
Most writers don’t understand copyright, figuring they can always learn it later. I write a lot of blog posts on copyright, and you can search for those on this website. Or you can take the Bite-Size Copyright class that we offer through WMG Workshops. The second quarter’s classes are starting now.
I highly recommend it. You’ll spend a little bit of time each week learning a different aspect of copyright. We are not lawyers, so don’t expect this to be a class giving legal advice. The class does make you aware of the issues that creatives need to know under copyright law, and gives you places to find out more.
If you prefer books, Nolo Press’s book on copyright is invaluable. You’ll get a short overview of copyright and other contractual matters in my book, Closing The Deal On Your Terms.
Do yourself a favor and learn this stuff. It’s best to do so in small doses, which is why we set up the Bite-Size Copyright course.
In the meantime, here’s a reminder:
This weekly blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynruschr4e to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: AI, Copyright, and Writers,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © Can Stock Photo / studiostoks.
When Roderigo and Izzy form a group to stop the Angel of Death from taking more innocent lives, they realize they need help. One by one, Roderigo recruits people who see the Angel, who know its evil magic, who suffer from the damage the Angel wreaks.
When Roderigo enlists the newest recruit—a war-damaged sniper—he achieves the formula for the group’s ultimate success. But he might have just doomed the group to the ultimate failure.
“Killing the Angel of Death,” by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story is also available in ebook through various online retailers here and will be included in the collection Fantasies Collide, Vol. 5, which is available for preorder in ebook here.
Killing the Angel of DeathKristine Kathryn RuschOnei“I got another one.” Rodrigo Jimenez sauntered through the uneven door into the tiny office.
Most people had to duck when they stepped inside. Rodrigo did not, and that always surprised Isadora. He looked like a much larger man—perfectly proportioned, almost square, with more muscles than she had ever seen on a human being before.
He stood just inside the canted doorway, his thumbs hooked on his back pockets and scanned the room as if seeing it for the first time.
She wished he wouldn’t do that, because then she would see the room clearly too. Wax-coated paper coffee cups from the giant 1980s hot beverage machine in the shared hallway toppled out of the plastic garbage container near the door. The recycling bin was mostly empty, just a few circulars and advertising flyers that Rodrigo would toss in there whenever he came into the office first.
The pilled beige industrial carpet needed vacuuming (needed replacing, really), and an inch of dust covered the windowsill in front of the half-open window.
The dust wasn’t Izzy’s fault. The office was in a strip mall on a very busy road, and if the window was open, the entire place filled with road grit within fifteen minutes.
Still, the place was a sty. He knew it, and she knew it. He wanted it to be shipshape at all times; she didn’t care. She figured the person who cared the most should be the person to do the work; he figured everyone should be cleanly.
That was only one of their many differences.
“We have enough people,” she said, not moving from behind the faux wood oversized desk they had found at a warehouse that specialized in cleaning out old offices. At least she had a modern chair—her back didn’t accommodate the green-and-steel concoction from the 1960s that Rodrigo had picked up at the same warehouse.
“We don’t and you know it.” Rodrigo flopped on the ratty brown couch—her furniture contribution—and folded his hands behind his head. “We need a sniper.”
“I don’t like guns,” Izzy said for the five-thousandth time.
“Then leave the damn project,” Rodrigo responded, as he had each time. It had become a ritual. They had to get through the I don’t like guns routine before they could have a real discussion.
“You can shoot,” she said.
“I’m not accurate at long distances.” He tilted his head slightly. “That’s a special skill.”
She supposed she knew that. She supposed she knew lots of things. But most of that knowledge came from television. With Rodrigo, most of his knowledge came from life.
“You’re stalling,” he said. “You just don’t want to go the Meeting.”
She rolled her eyes. “God, the fucking Meeting.” She hated the Meeting. Everyone there had eyeballed her weird the day she had given her “testimony,” and the “facilitator” had had the balls to tell her that maybe she needed to find a meeting outside the city, in a place where people would understand her grief.
She had never even gotten to her grief. She had started wrong, started with the trigger—Bongo’s death. She’d told them how losing her only friend had started a downward spiral, how she had actually stood in front of her medicine cabinet and stared at the contents inside, how the fact that he hadn’t wound his furry feline way around her legs in that moment of crisis made the moment of crisis even worse.
She’d come back, though, because Rodrigo—whom she hadn’t known at the time—had touched her arm.
“These people,” he said, “they don’t get it. Some of us do.”
And then he’d left. And because of that moment of compassion, she’d returned one more time, and had to endure some scrawny kid shaking his head and whispering loudly to the dumpy middle-aged man beside him, “Oh, God. The cat lady returns.”
Rodrigo had saved her. He had shut the kid down with one steely look, then brought Izzy a coffee from the burned mess in the scratched gray urn at the back of the room.
She clutched the cup he’d brought her and listened to tales of grief clearly more harrowing than hers. The dumpy guy, watching his wife die by inches after she was burned in a fire; the scrawny kid, losing his best friend in a freak accident at a water theme park.
Most people didn’t speak, though. They listened, picked at their clothing, watched the clock on the wall, and drank too much terrible coffee. The “facilitator,” a thin nervous woman who seemed to prefer faded print dresses three sizes too big, mouthed the platitudes Izzy had expected: Grief is a process. We all experience it differently. It’s different with every death. Ride the waves and understand that this, too, will pass.
If Izzy wanted platitudes, she would have gone to church. She had figured that something that billed itself as a Grief Support Group, held in a half-forgotten side room of City Memorial Hospital, would actually be run by someone with credentials, someone who understood grieving, someone who actually cared.
It seemed like the only person who had cared had been Rodrigo, and except for talking to her that first day, and bringing her the coffee on the second, he hadn’t said a word. He just sat near the back wall, wooden chair tilted back, massive arms crossed, and watched the proceeding as if he were the body guard, not someone whose life had been upended by death.
She later discovered that upended wasn’t even the right term. The last ten years of Rodrigo’s life had been all about death, and he was trying to find a way to deal with it.
Or he had, before the shooting.
“It’s not even the same Meeting,” he said, as if to placate her.
“It’s always the same Meeting,” she said and made a face.
iiThe new Meeting was more of an offshoot, and could more accurately be described as a Survivors’ Club. Yeah, they welcomed new members, but usually those people left when they realized the group was that group.
That group was the one that had—according to the media—failed so badly at providing support that one of the members hauled out an automatic rifle and slaughtered everyone in the room.
The truth was different, of course. No one had been in the room when Dugan had entered from a side door. The Meeting had ended. Half the group was standing on the sidewalk in front of the door. A few had already left, and two or three more were in the parking lot, on the way to their cars.
Rodrigo was close to the door, smoking a cigarette—illegally, since state law proclaimed that he had to be at least ten feet away. He saw Dugan barge out, swinging the rifle wildly, and Rodrigo said (not that anyone would listen) that Dugan wasn’t in his eyes.
Rodrigo had seen PTSD, hell, Rodrigo had PTSD, and he knew when someone was flashing back, and he was convinced (not that he had any proof) that Dugan was back in whatever war zone his trauma had come from. Dugan had only described the events once—something about a group of guys arriving on a truck in a dusty village, swinging rifles, picking off everyone around them, and he had been sharing a meal with a friend, and he couldn’t get his weapon out or didn’t have the right weapon or something.
Anyway, Dugan walked with a limp, had a scar that ran up his entire left side, and more guilt than any man should have.
He had come out of the side door and picked off six people on the sidewalk before heading toward the parking lot, tripping on the curb, falling on his hands and knees, the rifle skittering away. He ran his fingers along the concrete, said something like, “Oh, Jesus, no,” and that was when the first cop arriving on the scene had shot him.
Rodrigo hadn’t had a weapon, or he’d have shot Dugan too, but not a shoot-to-kill. Something that would’ve let the man live long enough to explain himself, maybe long enough to feel regret.
Rodrigo had tried to stop Dugan. Rodrigo had been halfway to the parking lot when the cop wheeled up and fired out of the driver’s side window. That was when Rodrigo—whose skin was darker than Dugan’s—hit the deck.
Izzy knew this part of the story, because Rodrigo had told her. She had given up on the Meeting by then, given up on being called The Cat Lady, given up on the “facilitator,” who had been shot in the shoulder and wrist, but who had survived. That “facilitator,” whom Izzy couldn’t stop thinking of as a job with air quotes, had never come back.
The hospital’s insurance company paid for everyone’s medical care, but refused to let any more grief meetings take place onsite without a trained psychiatrist running them. The hospital didn’t have any trained psychiatrists it could “waste” on people who were “merely” grieving, so the Meeting moved to its current location, and the survivors acted as facilitators, rather like an Alcoholics Anonymous group.
Not optimal, but at least honest. And much as Izzy hated the Meeting, she still showed up sometimes and stood in the back, just because she kept hoping something would fill the hole inside her.
Or maybe she just wanted to see how everyone was faring. Grief piled on grief piled on grief led to breakdowns. She had no idea how much the trauma of a shooting added to the stress, but she figured it couldn’t be considered minor.
She hadn’t even been there, and she thought about it every single time she passed the old meeting site. She wouldn’t even park in that wide-open parking lot, because there was a stain near the curb. Rodrigo said it was an oil stain, but she didn’t think so. Three people had bled out there, and somehow that blood got absorbed into the cheap asphalt.
She firmly believed that places got haunted by the violent dead, and the hauntings always took a form that was recognizable by the survivors.
She counted herself a survivor, even though she hadn’t liked most of the people who had died.
Now the Meeting was held about a half mile from the office, not near any hospital at all. The space was in the basement of an ancient Y. The Meeting shared the large room with AA, Adult Children of Alcoholics, Narcotics Anonymous, and Gamblers Anonymous. The weekly meeting schedule was posted in different colors for the different groups, plus there were flyers, and some poor kid who volunteered at the Y maintained the meeting schedule on the Y’s creaky old website.
It was all too complicated for Izzy or, at least, that was what she told Rodrigo. He never missed a Meeting. He was more facilitator than the old “facilitator” had been, and he actually seemed to care about the others.
Which made his cooperation with Izzy all the more surprising.
He walked to the Meeting. She drove, because she wanted to be able to escape without waiting for him.
Her car was an ancient Mustang which had once been a new Mustang, her husband’s pride and joy. Her husband was long gone—everywhere except in her guarded heart. His presence wasn’t even part of this Mustang any longer.
He would have hated the way the leather bucket seats had tiny tears along the base, the garbage piled up behind the front passenger seat, and the fact that the Bose Sound System he’d lovingly put in by hand now couldn’t play a cassette tape if she even owned one to play. The black exterior hadn’t been washed in more than a year—the last time the day some kid had scrawled Wash Your Fucking Car, Bitch, Or Lose It in the dirt on the rear window.
She parked, like she always did, five rows down, where the parking lot had buckled and weeds as old as the Mustang had grown out of the cracks.
She had passed Rodrigo about three blocks away, charging forward because the man never walked slowly. She meandered across the parking lot in the mid-afternoon heat, wondering why she stayed in the city when the summers were torture and the winters were worse.
Then she stopped two doors down from the side entry to the Y, and watched people enter, trying to guess which one of them was the one that Rodrigo wanted her to see.
“You won’t see her until you get inside.”
As usual, Rodrigo had snuck up on Izzy. No matter how hard the man charged, he still moved like the Seal he had been a lifetime ago.
She didn’t start, though, when he spoke to her, although her heart had sped up just a little. She had been prepared for him to come up behind her, and she had still been surprised when he spoke.
“A woman,” Izzy said, glad she sounded calm. “I didn’t expect that.”
“You think women can’t be snipers?” he asked, but didn’t wait for her answer. Instead he walked to the door and pulled it open.
It was one of those heavy metal doors with a barred grill just above eye level—at least for her. The scents of sweat, chlorine, and fifty-year-old coffee wafted out at her.
The Meeting had been held here long enough now that she had begun to associate those smells with despair.
She stepped inside, blinking in the sudden darkness. It took a moment for her eyes to adjust.
This door opened into the old lobby. The new lobby was two floors up, and actually looked inviting. This one still had the Formica desk sticking out of the wall, the cubbyholes in the back that used to house mail and keys for the residents who lived upstairs, and a few chairs, crowded around the scratched window that opened over the pool.
The pool was also in the basement, but on a different side from the meeting rooms. The window didn’t keep a lot of the sound out. Kids screamed and laughed. Something boomed and splashed, and a lifeguard yelled.
The pool was uncomfortably close to the meeting rooms in the basement. They were all damp and smelled of both mildew and chlorine. There were no windows at all in any of the basement meeting rooms, single exits grandfathered in by virtue of the fact this building had stood in the same place since the 1930s.
The pool had been revamped in the 1970s, and at that point, someone had slapped cheap paneling all over the basement, but the paneling only made the rooms darker and the smell of mildew stronger.
She followed Rodrigo down the curving staircase behind the old desk, feet slapping against the metal stairs. The railing had rusted years ago, and hadn’t been replaced. She always wondered if the damn thing would hold her up if she needed to catch it in a fall.
She doubted it.
But she doubted a lot of things.
At the base of the stairs, a confusing catchall area was the only place she ever saw anyone who swam. They’d come out of the locker room, hair wet, some kind of duffel over their shoulders, and gaze at her with bleary red eyes, wonder why an overweight woman with silver lining her hair was even anywhere near an athletic facility.
They never looked at Rodrigo that way. They looked at him like they expected him to order them back into the pool, then make them swim fifty laps before they thought of leaving again.
Doors veered off in five different directions, something she’d found very confusing the first few times she had come here. Now she knew they had to take Door Number Three (not marked that way—it wasn’t marked at all. It was just the third door from the base of the stairs).
Above her, the florescent light buzzed and blinked, making her feel slightly dizzy. Stay in this area too long, her brain warned like it always did, and we’re going to give you the worst headache of your life.
Rodrigo pushed Door Number Three open, and headed into the narrow hallway that contained three rather tiny bathrooms (of the male, female, and handicapped variety) and two different doors on opposite sides that led into the same damn meeting room.
It was the smallest room in the basement, and Izzy was convinced it had once been some kind of storeroom. Three florescent lights hid inside plastic panels on the ceiling, panels that lied and claimed there should have been six lights.
The ubiquitous back table held three of the Y’s black beverage urns—one for coffee, one for hot water and one, weirdly, for hot cocoa, even in the summer. Donuts from one of the morning meetings hardened on a platter near the cocoa urn. Clearly the morning meeting hadn’t been Narcotics Anonymous because those folks always cleared out the sugar, even if it was crap sugar like those donuts.
Someone had put out the folding chairs in five rows of seven with an aisle in between, and a podium up front, causing Rodrigo to swear. Half the group, including the scrawny kid, were gathered near the coffee urn. Of course none of them could bother to set up the room properly.
Rodrigo slung the chairs into a circle like they’d been made of putty. It wasn’t until Izzy start to help him that she realized one chair was occupied. A woman sat in the back corner, farthest from the door, out of view of the podium, and nowhere near the snacks table. She blended into the darkness as if she was made of it.
Izzy knew without Rodrigo saying a word that this was the woman he’d brought. Not because the woman had wrapped herself in darkness, not because she was good at remaining in the shadows, not even because she exuded an air of fuck with me at your peril.
It was because she was angry.
So furious in fact that the air around her felt like it had been charged with violence.
The last thing this group needed was another violent angry person who couldn’t deal with whatever had happened to her. The group ostracized folks this obviously angry—had since Dugan decided his anger was more important than their lives.
Most angry grievers, they’d leave after the first meeting or two, but it was clear this woman had been here before. She didn’t seem alarmed by Rodrigo, knew who to hide from, and actually had a question in her eyes when she saw Izzy.
The woman had been here enough to know that Izzy wasn’t a regular. No five times per week whether she needed it or not for Izzy. More like once every five weeks whether Rodrigo could drag her here or not.
“Need the chair,” Izzy said.
The woman didn’t move. “Looks like you got more than enough.”
That was true. Thirty-five chairs and only ten people near the coffee urn, twelve if you counted Izzy and Rodrigo. Thirty-five was the hopeful number they’d promised the Y when they took the space; thirty-five was the fiction they maintained even though the Meeting hadn’t hosted more than twenty since the massacre.
“Still,” Izzy said, “you shouldn’t sit in the back.”
“And you shouldn’t come once in a blue moon and think that entitles you to giving people orders,” the woman said.
“Iz,” Rodrigo said. “Sit.”
As if she were a misbehaving puppy. As if she would respond to orders at all.
To prove her independence or her contrariness or her orneriness, Izzy went to the other table, the one with stick-on name tags and blue magic markers, scrawled Isadora on one that cheerfully proclaimed Hi! I’m _____________!
She was half-tempted to add a smiley face with sharp pointy teeth after the second exclamation point, but figured that would only show her age, not help anyone understand her attitude.
She slapped the nametag on her shirt, hoping she would remember to remove the damn thing before someone on the outside grinned and pointed and said, Isadora, huh? That’s an unusual name.
She didn’t even get coffee because she wasn’t going to stay long enough. She had a hunch she’d bolt in the middle of the first story. She was feeling itchy already.
But she sat in the chair Rodrigo had indicated, which was—not coincidentally—directly across from Hidey Woman. Izzy couldn’t even see the woman’s face in the shadows, just her scuffed Nikes and her bare ankles peeking out from a pair of pristine blue jeans.
From the pool area, the life guard’s whistle cut through the low murmur of conversation. Last warning or clear the pool or Ready Set Go. Izzy never knew which it was, but she always found it amusing that this version of the Meeting started with a prompt from a lifeguard.
The world was full of ironies and this was one of them.
The group took their chairs, balancing coffee, some cookies she hadn’t seen, and next week’s schedule, clutched in nervous fingers. She recognized all the faces—the dumpy guy, who’d lost half his body weight after the surgery to remove a bullet from his spleen; the fat lady, mother of five full-term stillborn babies, who, like Izzy, hadn’t been at the Meeting that day of the shooting; and the scrawny kid, who gave Izzy the evil eye, as if everything bad that happened in the world was somehow her fault.
Rodrigo didn’t start the meeting. He rarely did. That afternoon, the honor fell on Clarabell, a wizened seventy-something who claimed she’d been named for a stupid clown on a stupid kid’s TV show.
That’s how my childhood played out, she’d said bitterly one afternoon before the shooting. Imagine what that was like, particularly when it was clear to everyone but me that the obnoxious clown was male.
Back then, she’d gotten sympathy from the Meeting—before the scrawny kid and the dumpy guy and their judgmental attitudes had shown up. Now, she never mentioned it and, Izzy noted, she no longer wrote Clarabell on her nametag. Now it simply said Clara, as if that made everything better.
“It’s been five months,” Clarabell said. “How’s everyone holding up?”
No hellos, no let’s introduce ourselves, no discussion of where and what the meeting was. Not even a mention of what she was referring to. If there were any newcomers here—and Izzy didn’t think there were except maybe Hidey Woman—they were on their own when it came to understanding just what the hell was going on here.
“Just a reminder,” said a bearded man near the door. “The hospital’s insurance only pays for six months. If you want to continue therapy after that, you’ll need a referral.”
“And insurance of your own,” the dumpy guy murmured.
“Fat fucking chance of that,” the scrawny kid said.
“We’ve got each other, anyway,” Clarabell said, but she didn’t sound too sure of that. What did they have, really? A shared room in the dank basement of an old Y, an experience that bound them together in group tragedy, after they’d come together for comfort from personal tragedy.
That was about all Izzy could take. She bounded out of her chair, only to have Rodrigo grab her right arm and pull her down again.
He leaned over to her. “You’re listening this time,” he whispered.
Her stomach knotted. “She talk at all?” Izzy asked, nodding at the woman.
“Not yet,” he whispered. “Maybe not ever.”
“Then I’m leaving.” Izzy shook off his hand, and stood again, saw the scrawny kid glaring at her, and knew what he would say if he felt like he could—like he used to before the shoot.
What happened, Cat Lady? Need to get home to kitty-kitty-kitty?
Fuck you, she sent him, as if telepathy were real. Fuck you and your superior fucking attitude.
Yeah, she still had anger issues. One year in, and she was beginning to believe that the wheel of grief wasn’t a wheel at all, but a gauge with her needle stuck at Fuck You Forever You Fucking Asshole.
Or as Rodrigo liked to delicately call it, The anger phase.
Izzy pushed her way out, back to the narrow hallway, the strange little room of doors, the buzzing florescent, and the scuffed staircase. The smell of chlorine made her sneeze.
She was really tired, the kind of tired you got when every day was a burden, and every hour seemed to last longer than the one before it.
She glanced up the stairs like they were her enemy. Rodrigo had said the woman wouldn’t enter by conventional means, which meant she wouldn’t leave by conventional means either, and Rodrigo wanted Izzy to meet her.
Izzy could go back to the office, and wait, only to have Rodrigo bawl her out, and then drag her to yet another Meeting on yet another too-hot afternoon.
Or she could sit on the stairs and brood until the Meeting ended. One hour, if the schedule was to be believed. Because a half hour after this meeting ended, the Wednesday AA group would saunter in for their discussions of twelve steps, compulsions, and higher powers.
No one ever talked about higher powers in the grief groups that Izzy had attended. Higher powers were there to help with addiction, not with loss.
All she knew was that any time someone murmured It was God’s will at the Meeting before the shooting, someone else would snap something rude about God.
It was Rodrigo’s response that Izzy had never been able to get out of her head.
If that was God’s will, he’d said, referring to something he had never really told the Meeting in detail, then God is a goddamn motherfucking son of a whore sadist, and I hope to Christ I never meet the motherfucker face to face.
Rodrigo’s outburst had silenced the room. No one had seen him lose it like that before, and maybe not since.
Izzy had, but Izzy talked to him outside of the Meeting. Izzy knew that her anger was nothing compared to his and there were days when he felt a kinship with Dugan. Sometimes, Rodrigo said more than once, it’d be a lot easier to blame someone for the whole mess.
Why? she’d asked only once.
Because then I’d take the motherfucker out, he said, his voice so cold and chill and flat that she had no doubt he’d do it.
No doubt he’d find a way.
And she had held onto that for the six months before the shooting and four months beyond. The month of the shooting, she’d half blamed Rodrigo. If he’d been that close to everything, how come he couldn’t stop Dugan? Dugan had taken out the one person that Izzy had liked at the Meeting, a sixteen-year-old girl whose baby sister had died of leukemia.
What had those parents done to deserve that response from God? They lost both their children—one to a disease that had a 90% survival rate for most kids, and the other to something stupid and random that had happened because she’d been trying to take care of herself, trying to move forward with a life that should have extended eighty or more years ahead of her.
Izzy tried not to think of Alyssa because it only pissed her off. Alyssa—no tats, one piercing in each ear, and only a slight hint of pink over her dark brown hair, straight As, and the ability to cry without moving her face.
She was the only one of the group who haunted Izzy, maybe because she had been the only one who had ever touched Izzy’s heart.
The door banged open, and conversation filled the hallway beyond Door Number Three. Izzy stood, brushed off the back of her jeans, and leaned against the rusted railing, trying to look cool rather than distraught—not that anyone would notice.
Just her luck that scrawny kid would come out first. His skin was clearing up. He’d also gotten taller in the past few months, but his eyes were still sad.
She leaned toward something like compassion for him when he reached her.
“You know,” he said, “the Meeting actually works better when you sit through it.”
He didn’t wait for her response. He bounded up the stairs two at a time, and disappeared before anyone else came through the door.
Apparently, the Meeting had bothered him too.
Izzy moved away from the stairs after that, taking refuge near the door to the women’s locker room. No one else noticed her. She counted bodies as they left…seven…eight…nine with scrawny kid. Which meant that Rodrigo was still inside the room with Clarabell.
He could handle himself, but sometimes it was polite to rescue a friend, even if that friend had dragged you unwillingly to a meeting you really never wanted to attend.
Izzy sighed and pushed off the wall, heading into Door Number Three, listening for conversation as she went. Nothing. Which meant that either the door was still closed or they weren’t talking or something else was going on.
Her stomach clenched, because it always clenched when something out of the ordinary happened around the Meeting. But she made herself ignore the feeling.
She opened the door, and as she did, the snap and slam of metal folding chairs being flattened grated her. Rodrigo was gathering the chairs, closing them with one hand and then adding them to the pile he managed to carry with the other.
At first glance, he seemed to be alone in the room. No Clarabell, no stragglers hanging out by the coffee.
Then Izzy saw the Hidey Woman stacking another set of chairs in the corner. That surprised Izzy. She figured Hidey Woman for someone who dwelt in the darkness and never helped anyone in the light.
“Isadora,” Rodrigo said, as he added one more chair to his impossible arm pile. “Thought we’d lost you.”
She wasn’t sure if she should let Hidey Woman know just how vulnerable Izzy really was.
“Waited outside,” she said. “Meeting go okay?”
“The Meeting never goes ‘okay.’” Rodrigo was very good at spoken air quotes. “But we got through it.”
That, she wanted to say to him, was not a recommendation. But she bit the words back because she also didn’t want to discourage Hidey Woman from attending.
Izzy believed that if someone found the Meeting valuable, they should not be discouraged from attending.
Rodrigo took his impossible pile of chairs over to the Hidey Woman. Apparently his strong arms had reached their limit. He handed her the chairs as if they’d been at this routine for a while.
“We’ve got about ten minutes, Iz,” Rodrigo said.
It wasn’t so much a statement as a command. Get your ass over here. If we’re going to talk to her, we’re doing it now.
Izzy nodded, then walked across the room, almost stopping for coffee just so she would have something to do with her hands.
She reached Rodrigo and the Hidey Woman as they put the last two chairs into the pile. The room looked so much bigger when it was empty.
“Isadora, meet Lana.” Rodrigo said.
Lana. The name didn’t quite fit her. Too mundane, too short, too bland. The Hidey Woman—Lana—didn’t move, seeming to wait to see what Izzy would do.
Izzy held out her hand. “Izzy. I prefer Izzy. Rodrigo likes the formal name.”
Lana didn’t nod. For a brief second, Izzy thought Lana wasn’t even going to extend her hand for a shake, and then she did, slowly and languidly, resulting in one of those rich lady handshakes: I’m too wealthy and pampered to bother to squeeze her hand. In another life, I would have hand you courtesy and kiss my ring.
The attitude, the thought, and the shake that inspired it surprised Izzy. She’d expected a firm, masculine grip, something tough as tough could be. Rodrigo had said sniper, after all.
But Lana was tiny, and didn’t seem to be any kind of sniper at all. She barely came up to Izzy’s shoulder, but stood with the perfect posture that spoke of early (and intense) ballerina training. There was a set to her head, the way her feet seemed to prefer a modified version of second position, the precision in her movements.
Her hair was long and pulled into a bun, her dark eyes dominating her small face, and her chin was narrow, giving her face a startled foxlike appearance.
Not threatening at all.
But, then, people thought that about Izzy too.
“I thought we could talk to Lana about what we do,” Rodrigo said.
Izzy looked at him. His chocolate brown eyes peered down at her with the full expectation that she would talk to Lana about what they were planning to do, since as of yet, they hadn’t done anything.
There was no good way to start this conversation. Start with an apology, and Izzy would be at a disadvantage. Start with a question, and she gave Lana a chance to back out. Start in the middle of it, and Izzy would sound like a crazy person.
She chose a fourth option.
“You ever hear of the Angel of Death?” she asked. “We’re going to take him out.”
iiiThe reactions were always predictable. Some people backed away. Others laughed nervously. A couple said, Wouldn’t that be nice. And one or two—the ones that stuck—didn’t say a word.
They simply waited for more information.
Lana’s gaze never left Izzy’s. Waiting. Withholding judgment until the very end.
“We’re building a team,” Izzy said. “Rodrigo believes you could be part of it.”
Izzy deliberately left herself out of that statement. She didn’t know enough about this woman, didn’t know enough about what this woman could do. Wasn’t even sure Lana was as billed.
Until Izzy remembered that air of violence, the one that had accompanied Lana in those shadows, making her seem bigger than she actually was.
“The Angel of Death,” Lana said quietly. “You believe that is a real being?”
There it was: the loss of control of the conversation. And to make things worse, she answered a question with a question.
Izzy gave Rodrigo a sideways glance. He nodded, almost imperceptibly.
“You know there is,” Izzy said, deciding to be somewhat aggressive. “If you didn’t, Rodrigo wouldn’t have brought me here.”
Lana looked at him, as if seeing him for the first time. Then she brought that measuring gaze to Izzy.
“If there were such a creature,” Lana said, “then it would be immortal and untouchable. Going after it would be a fool’s errand. Even if you could kill it, something would replace it, and death would simply continue.”
“You don’t use death to stop death,” Izzy said. “You use death to get revenge.”
“‘Vengeance is mine, saith the Lord,’” Lana said.
“If that were true,” Rodrigo said, “all of human history would be very, very different.”
Lana’s eyes narrowed, and she smiled, tilting her head to the right as if conceding a point.
Her entire body relaxed just enough to be noticeable.
“You want to send a message,” she said.
“I do,” Rodrigo said. “I absolutely fucking do.”
TwoiThey didn’t ask her if she believed in the Angel of Death. She had asked them. Lana had done her best not to seem incredulous. She had tested them with the Biblical quote, because religious nuts often went off the deep end about the angel of death or the destroying angel or whatever Christianity called it.
Every religion had a personification of death, maybe to make it real. And each personification was different.
Just like each experience with the so-called Angel of Death was different. She firmly believed in those beings in the light people who had been brought back from the dead had seen. They hadn’t been benign actors, beloved people from a former life. They had been death angels, deciding which fish to keep and which ones to throw back.
The death angels never really had a plan, she thought. More like a desire to see what would happen this time if they screwed with a particular person.
“I’m in,” Lana said quietly. “I’m definitely in.”
iiThe first time she had seen what they were calling the Angel of Death, she’d been six. She had been eating dinner at the kitchen table with her sisters, her parents, and her baby brother, still in his high chair. The room smelled of mushy peas and beef gravy, a radio played Madonna’s “Vogue” in the background, and the grownups were talking about something Lana didn’t understand. Then, the light in the room dimmed.
She looked up, saw a person, indistinct and shadowy, with his fingers wrapped around her father’s throat.
Therapists later asked why she thought the person was male. She couldn’t articulate it then; she could now. Male hands looked different from female hands. Just slightly: a little broader. A little flatter.
Or maybe, she sometimes thought, the hands had been familiar. Hands she had seen a lot as a young child, hands of a person she no longer remembered.
But she remembered that moment. Those hands, squeezing her father’s throat. He continued talking, as if nothing was wrong, as if the knuckles on those hands around his throat weren’t turning white with effort, as if the life wasn’t being choked out of him, bit by bit.
“Mommy,” she had said, terrified. “Someone’s hurting Daddy.”
Her mother had looked sideways, her own face indistinct in the memory, as if Lana had no words, no reference for the expression on her mother’s face.
“I’m fine, honey,” her father had said to her, his voice as calm as ever. “I’m just fine.”
And then he had stood, put his fingers on the kitchen table for balance, and toppled sideways—someone—and she never knew who—catching him and easing him to the ground.
Of course, at that moment, he had already been dead.
Family lore said that Lana claimed someone had hurt her father after he had already fallen. But her mother always watched her with a bit of speculation, as if worried that Lana might tell her that someone was hurting her, and then her mother would die.
Her mother hadn’t died yet, at least that Lana knew about. She hadn’t seen or spoken with her mother in more than a decade.
There simply was no point.
They had nothing in common. The Bible that Lana could quote with ease was her mother’s beloved book, not hers. Lana didn’t have a religion. She wasn’t an atheist. She believed there were things in the world that she did not understand.
But she also believed that they were unknowable, and that religions simply guessed, trying to make people feel better about their miserable little lives.
She had never thought of her life as miserable or little, not until recently. She couldn’t shake the images, the fear, the guilt.
The anger.
And she had come to believe that people didn’t die of old age; they died of an accumulation of death—dead parents, dead children, dead friends. At some point the accumulation defeated them, and they succumbed.
She could feel her accumulation pressing on her. Some people—they had low death tolerance. Others had a higher one, like a high pain tolerance. They could handle so much more than most people could
She was one of those, she had thought. But lately, she hadn’t been.
It was the accumulation. Friends, colleagues, enemies. Victims, too, since she had killed her share, always at the direction of her government, for something she had once believed in, something she was beginning to think had been perverted, if it had ever truly existed at all.
iiiThey took her to a dumpy office in a dying strip mall. Rodrigo and Izzy seemed at home here, with the 1970s wood paneling, the beige carpet that probably hadn’t been cleaned since 1990, the couch that looked older than Lana.
She had expected something sparkly, something that spoke of magic, not something that looked as defeated as she felt.
They promised her pizza while they waited for the rest of the team. The pizza arrived first, which was probably good, considering that the team was much larger than she expected. The ham and pineapple pizza was mostly demolished when the first of more than a dozen people came through the hollow-core fake wood door.
She missed most of the names, mostly because the people pouring in weren’t what she expected.
She expected more soldiers like her and Rodrigo. Or police. Or mercenaries. People with skills she knew and understood.
And there were maybe some of those—maybe seven, if she could judge by posture alone. But those weren’t the folks who caught her eye. They passed by her as if they were partially invisible.
She was watching the gorgeous drag queen in a flowing pink pantsuit and glittery heels who had clearly dressed down for the afternoon. Then Lana noticed the young person who wore black jeans, a black shirt, had dyed his (her?) hair shoe-polish black like Joan Jett used to wear hers, wore black lipstick and black eyeliner, and had painted her (his?) fingernails black.
He (She?) was followed by another person whose gender was deliberately ambiguous, a slouchy thin person who wore a knitted hat despite the heat, a hoodie with a picture of kittens and chainsaws across the front, and jeans that had more holes than material.
Two twenty-somethings came in next. The twenty-somethings looked like teens, until Lana saw their faces full on. Prematurely lined, even though neither young man had reached his full growth. Their dark faces had the texture of hard leather, the kind of faces people who suffered from too much sun exposure usually got in their forties.
They barely acknowledged her as they flopped on the filthy carpet.
Behind them came a rotund woman who looked like she should have fronted a cable baking program from the 1980s, a scrawny elderly man with hollow eyes, and an ethereal girl who appeared to be no more than twelve.
The girl’s eyes were dark, and, at this distance appeared to be without pupils. When Lana turned away, movement caught Lana’s eye again, and for a half second, she thought she saw wings.
But when she looked at the girl directly once again, the girl looked like a normal twelve-year-old, long-limbs and flat torso, with the promise of beauty to come.
Not everyone came from the Meeting, as Rodrigo called it. Some Izzy had found; the others Rodrigo brought. The drag queen invited herself, after her gender-neutral friends had found the place—by accident, they claimed, although Lana was beginning to think there were no accidents here. The drag queen, in turn, had invited two thin, sad-faced men who sat in the back with their arms wrapped around each other, almost for protection.
There appeared to be more men than women which surprised Lana, and the women were less athletic than she would have expected. Three of them looked like teachers or librarians or some other cliché of middle age.
Several African-Americans, and one Asian-American woman who looked tougher than everyone else put together. Everyone younger than thirty appeared to be mixed race, although with the makeup on the kid wearing all black, she couldn’t really tell.
Lana took a can of Diet Pepsi, and retreated to a corner, leaning against the wall, the handgun she had a concealed carry permit for pressing against the small of her back. She always wore loose shirts to cover it, not that anyone ever noticed the gun or her. Although here, everyone saw her anyway, which was a brand-new experience for her.
She had spent so many years practicing the art of invisibility that she had no idea what to do when she was actually being seen.
“They’re here to vet you,” Rodrigo said, but didn’t explain how they would accomplish that.
People found their places on the floor, leaning against the walls, and sitting on the handful of chairs. Some folks had brought coffee, others drank bottles of water they had brought with them. The two twenty-somethings each took a piece of pizza, then waved them at the others, as if asking permission to eat.
No one complained, not even Lana whose appetite had left her.
Izzy sat behind the desk, half hidden behind a slender PC that appeared to be the newest thing in the place. Rodrigo rested one thigh on the desk, bracing himself with his other foot.
Just like he was at the Meeting, he was the leader here without saying a word. He waited until everyone settled, and silence grew—except for the rattling of an air conditioner that had been old when this place was built.
Rodrigo studied the faces around him, then glanced at Lana.
“I think we might’ve found our sniper,” he said.
She started. She had never told him what she had done. She had left it all behind, the shootings, the kill orders, even the rifles. She hadn’t held a weapon in three years.
Correction: she hadn’t actually held a real weapon in three years. Every time she fell asleep, she woke up to find her left hand braced underneath her rifle, her eyes pressed against the scope, her trigger finger at the ready.
That there was no rifle didn’t really matter. There had been one. And, apparently, it would always be with her.
And, apparently, it would always be visible to sensitive folks.
Or folks who had done a boatload of research.
Although she wasn’t sure how he could have researched her. Lana wasn’t the name she had been given by her religious mother. Lana was the name she had chosen, picking that name only because it was easy to spell, easy to remember, and unusual enough in this day and age to make it feel like hers.
Rodrigo was watching her watch everyone else, which made her nervous. After the group had settled, she did an actual count.
Fifteen, not counting herself, Izzy, and Rodrigo.
Fifteen people who had somehow, for some reason, decided they needed to take out the Angel of Death.
Lana let out a small snort at the thought, felt a half-smile start, and made it stop before it became a full smile.
No one besides Rodrigo was looking at her now, and then she realized that wasn’t true. One of the semi-invisible librarian women was staring at her, and so was the drag queen.
The drag queen, clearly over six feet tall, made taller by the heels in her glittery sandals, walked over to Lana, extended a manicured hand, and said, “Starina.”
Lana raised her eyebrows, and said, “Really? You took on the name that Nathan Lane’s Albert used for his drag queen in The Birdcage? Really?”
The drag queen let her hand fall. “Sarcastic and all-seeing. What did you find for us, Rodrigo?”
“Snipers are great observers,” he said quietly. “And we don’t need names. This is not the Meeting.”
“I’d say welcome, honey,” the drag queen said, emphasizing honey, “but I’m not sure about you yet.”
Lana wasn’t sure about any of them. She sipped her Diet Pepsi, trying not to wince at the fake-sugar aftertaste, and then watched them watch her.
“If we’re going to stare silently at each other,” Izzy said from behind the computer, “I’m going to go insane. So, one word or one sentence, name your last straw. We’ll end with you.”
She didn’t say Lana’s name, just glanced at her so that Lana knew who you meant.
“I’ll start,” Izzy said. “Cat.”
She said it defiantly, as if challenging anyone to laugh at her. Lana wasn’t sure she understood what Izzy was even asking for, given the cryptic nature of the one word and the command.
“Nephew,” said one of the women sitting on the floor.
“Roadside bomb,” said the military man next to her.
“Traffic stop,” said the man beside him.
“Judy’s,” said the thin man with his arm around the other man. The other man nodded, and said, “Judy’s.”
That, at least, Lana recognized. Judy’s nightclub shooting, October of 2016, in the middle of the presidential campaign from hell, everyone thinking that maybe the rhetoric from the Republican nominee (and the local candidates) inspired three shooters to kill twenty people and wound sixteen more, just one town over.
Lana had loved Judy’s. Big-hearted, with a beautiful painting of Judy Garland in all of her incarnations adorning the wall that the police eventually shattered with big rescue vehicles they’d gotten because of 9/11 funding.
She expected the gender-neutral kid in all black to say Judy’s too, but he (she?) said, “Faghole,” and a teenage girl near him nodded. Lana knew the insult too. Instead of “asshole,” “faghole” was something mean homophobic kids had started shouting at kids whom they found different. But she didn’t know it was a place or a thing or something that would cause a vision of the Angel of Death.
The rounds continued.
“Best friend.”
“Fucking cancer.”
“Emergency room,” said one of the librarian women. “Night after goddamn night.”
So not a librarian. A nurse.
“Judy’s.”
“Fifteen-car pile-up.”
“Traffic stop.” Again. She didn’t quite see who had spoken.
“The neighborhood, man,” said one of the men on the other side of the room. “Just the freakin’ neighborhood.”
“Judy’s.”
The ethereal girl shook her head, waving her hand, as if she still couldn’t speak about whatever it had been.
“Hot truck abandoned in the desert,” said one of the leathery young men. The man next to him nodded.
The nearest desert was two thousand miles. But deserts, Lana got deserts. Deserts. They were deadly.
“My son,” said one of the muscular men, whom Lana had pegged as a cop.
“Portage Elementary,” said the man next to him.
The school shooting—the worst kind of school shooting (as if there were any good ones)—two states over. First-graders. Who the fuck killed first-graders?
At least two assholes in the United States had done so.
Two.
Spurred on by the Angel of Death.
Lana set down her Diet Pepsi, brought her knees to her chest, and hugged them.
The voices around her were dry, matter-of-fact, listing more family members, more friends, more circumstances.
The litany got to the drag queen, and Lana braced herself for another Judy’s. Instead, the drag queen said, “Pepperbeans,” and the beefy man next to her patted her hand, and gave her a sympathetic smile before he said, “The best grandmother in the entire world.”
It took less than five minutes for the litany to reach Lana. She glanced at Rodrigo, who was staring at her. He hadn’t said anything, just like the ethereal girl and one of the librarian women.
But no one mentioned that. No one urged them on.
Yet everyone stared at Lana as if she could give them her entire life story in one word. Last straw. They thought there was a last straw.
“You assume there’s just one,” she said quietly. Her voice wasn’t as flat as she wanted it to be. She wanted to sound as matter-of-fact as they all had, and she couldn’t.
She just couldn’t.
She didn’t belong here.
She pushed against the wall, then made herself stand. They all watched her.
“It’s silly anyway, right?” she asked, “talking about death as if it’s something we can attack, something we can stop.”
The woman who hadn’t spoken, the one who hadn’t given a reason for being there, stepped in front of two of the other librarian-looking women. This woman was about fifty pounds overweight, but she carried it well. Her face had been sharp and angular once, but now there was extra flesh under her chin, a slight puffiness to her eyes.
Her hair was iron-lady gray, and she didn’t wear any makeup at all. But she was wearing a dress, and not a sundress either. Something that pretended to be businesslike—or would have been forty years ago, when they didn’t make suits for women.
“You were hoping for something magical,” the woman said, her voice soft. She had a slight Southern accent, but from what state, Lana couldn’t tell.
Lana wanted to deny the accusation, but she remembered her disappointment when she had seen the office, how she had wanted something sparkly, something that didn’t look defeated.
But everything seemed defeated here—and she knew, they all had to know—there was no magic in defeat.
“Something…Disney,” the woman continued. “Something…over the top.”
Tears pricked at Lana’s eyes. So what if she wanted that? So what if she had hoped for a little magic in her life? So what if she had thought maybe she would find it here?
“You make the mistake everyone makes when they think of magic,” the woman said. “You think it’s easy. It’s not. We don’t do easy here.”
“What do you do?” Lana let the defensiveness out. “Sit around and plan revenge on something that doesn’t even exist?”
The woman looked at Rodrigo, who shrugged one shoulder.
“You deny that death exists?” the woman asked Lana.
Lana let out a bitter laugh. “If only.”
“Then stay. Listen. Assess when we’re done.”
“Let her go,” one of the men said. He was one of the men she had taken for a cop, although his last straw had been something like the death of a parent or something. “We got enough shooters.”
“Not long-range precision shooters,” Rodrigo said. Then he looked at Lana, as if he was disappointed in her.
She stood even straighter, and measured the distance between her spot on the far wall, and the door.
“Snipers,” he said, “usually don’t join something like this.”
“We’re not joiners,” she said.
“No,” he said. “That’s not it. Snipers usually think of themselves as the Angel of Death. They don’t need someone to remind them that there is another mechanism in place, something that can kill without a scope and ammunition.”
Her cheeks heated. “I’m not that arrogant.”
“Oh, but you are,” he said. “Or you would not have taken the job of sniper.”
“I tested into it,” she said. “Best shot in Basic. Best shot in every single unit I joined. They finally recruited me.”
“And you let yourself be recruited,” Rodrigo said.
The blood left her cheeks, taking the heat with it. “I don’t ‘let’ myself do anything,” she said. “I took the job.”
“Why?” he asked.
They were all staring at her. Had she taken it because she was arrogant? Because she liked killing?
“Because there was no one better,” she said, her fingers clenching into fists. “Because, there was no one better.”
ThreeiJubilee had had enough. She watched the sniper woman step into the center of the room, small and powerful, her body in perfect shape, each motion made with great confidence. Jubilee had not been that confident at that age. In fact, she had only become confident when she had become her true self, a process that had taken forever.
Half the people in the room caught Jubilee’s movement, and waited quietly. Her friends from Judy’s, they knew that Jubilee could be tough when she needed to.
But she hadn’t needed to in this group. She had let Rodrigo run everything, let Izzy handle all the details, figuring they were the organizing type.
Jubilee had other things to do, other things to think about.
But she didn’t feel that way now. This group was much more important to her than she realized.
For one of the few times in her recent life, she wished she had worn something less dramatic, something less pink. She had seen that little sniper woman dismiss her, simply because she was wearing clothes that made her comfortable, clothes that made her feel stronger, and for some reason, she wanted the little sniper woman to respect her.
Jubilee would never learn.
That very thought had gone through her head when she introduced herself to the sniper woman as Starina. Jubilee had been poking, figuring a military woman with a tough background wouldn’t respect her from the start.
Jubilee had been surprised that the sniper woman had known the reference, and had been even more surprised when the sniper woman had called her out about it.
Jubilee had just been developing a little trust in the sniper woman when she went all This is a bunch of hooey on them.
Jubilee stood. Tru clutched at Jubilee’s arm, trying to stop her. Tru and their good friend Mica usually had a finger on the temperature of the room. But Jubilee didn’t want a temperature. Jubilee wanted to make a point.
“Let her go,” Jubilee said, nodding at the sniper woman. “She’s made it clear that she doesn’t want to participate. We don’t need to convince anyone to be part of our group. People need to convince us that they belong.”
She raised her chin ever so slightly, her voice shaking more than she expected. She hadn’t thought she would be so passionate about who was on the team.
But she was.
Because this was important.
No matter what the sniper woman thought.
iiIt had taken Jubilee years to find someone who had seen the same things she had. Not in the world—God knew anyone who was grew up queer or different experienced the same hatreds, the same prejudices.
It was those little fleeting glimpses of something else, something on the edges. Not just when someone died. But when someone hated. When someone harmed. When someone lied.
The first time she’d seen it, she hadn’t even known Jubilee was inside her. Then she’d been Dennis, the kid who hunched over and hid most of the time. Dennis had been too tall, too “effeminate” in the words of her gym teacher, who had literally tried to knock “some sense” into her three weeks into the fall semester.
High school in Wyoming, where men were men, and Matthew Shepard had been beaten, tied to a fencepost, and left to die like a tiny 5’2” human scarecrow only two years before. Jubilee had met a lot of great people, compassionate people, in Wyoming, but none of them had understood the cost of growing up different in a small Western town unless they had experienced the same things.
Coach had tried to make Jubilee a basketball star. Anyone that tall needed to be playing basketball, that was Coach’s thinking—ignoring Jubilee’s lack of interest as well as a lack of physical coordination that came from a 10-inch growth spurt that had happened over the space of one short summer.
The tauntings, the beatings, the way some of the boys tried to catch her alone, to show her exactly what was waiting for her if she didn’t toughen up, a reality all of her life, until she’d discovered some like-minded folk in (ironically) Laramie, who actually showed her how to deflect, how to avoid, how to protect herself.
Still didn’t stop her from getting stomped that night in March, beaten within an inch of her life. She had been laying on the slushy concrete, her right cheek half-frozen against the ice, hot blood dripping down her face from her shattered nose, eyes half open, staring at Andrew as he died just across the parking lot from her—Andrew, the only person who had ever been kind to her. Andrew, who was not gay, was not trans, was not anything except the nicest human being in the entire world, killed because he had dared—dared—to befriend the wrong person.
That night, something had flashed underneath the streetlight, just before Andrew had died. Wings, maybe. A face, rather like Oz’s big see-through head floating above the flames in the movie The Wizard of Oz. (Maybe that was one reason Jubilee idolized Judy. That moment when she faced down the Wizard. It was not just everything Judy had done, everything she stood for—but her courage, her desire to defend everyone, including a scarecrow who was smarter than anyone and more vulnerable than everyone knew.)
That night, on the ice, bleeding out, Jubilee (Dennis then) had stared at the wings under the street light. The wings got smaller, the face faded, and then there was the smell of vanilla, almost overpowering, and a touch of snow. She had the sense that the creature had just come from Andrew, that it had been (feeding?) on Andrew, and now that Andrew was no more—eyes empty, body unmoving—the thing had flown to her.
She hadn’t been sure that was bad, not at that moment, with her whole life ahead of her filled with, as far as she could tell (as far as Dennis could tell) more beatings, more hatred, more loss.
Then something caressed Jubilee’s face, feathers—or so it seemed—soft and soothing. And the smell of vanilla had grown a lot stronger. At least she liked vanilla. Vanilla suggested warmth to her, maybe even love.
Then, suddenly, she heard voices across the parking lot, voices that made her shiver or maybe just made her realize how helpless she was, broken against the pavement. She waggled her fingers, tried to move her feet—why, she’d never know, because she had no idea if those voices belonged to the boys who had beaten her and killed Andrew, or if the voices belonged to someone who might consider rescuing her.
One of the voices said, There’s another one, and came closer, and she cringed. The smell of vanilla had disappeared, the feeling of warmth, the feathers on her face, replaced only by the crusty edges of blood around her nose, the throbbing in her shattered left cheek, her left eye, slowly swelling shut.
The voices belonged to people who had no idea who she was (what she was), thought she was just some boy who’d gotten beat up, and then they found Andrew too, and they thought mugging gone wrong, so they called the police, called an ambulance, and somehow, some way, Dennis survived.
Andrew was dead, but Dennis hung on for a few more years. Hung on to what Jubilee never knew, because the depression after that, the waves of despair, they grew and grew and grew.
And Dennis almost faded away.
Somehow she got out of Wyoming. Scholarships—at least education saved her, more or less. When you hid and studied you actually got somewhere.
For her, somewhere was NYU, New York, with all its variety, and she found like-minded people, she found people who saw her, not Dennis, and brought out her, brought Jubilee into the world, and showed her how to be herself. She entered a community that meant so much more to her than any other community ever had, graduated from college with a degree and a real job, where people didn’t care who she was as long as she met the unisex dress code (she could do that), and for a moment—just a moment—she thought the world would treat her well.
Then she watched, watched, watched as friend after friend died. Some old timers, finally succumbing to the opportunistic diseases that took advantage of someone HIV-positive, others dying the same way Andrew had—from fists and bigotry and too fucking much hate.
By the time Jubilee had transferred here for work, she was strong. She was Jubilee. She was numb.
She knew the back passages of Judy’s, and she knew how to recognize the Angel of Death. The Angel didn’t have wings this time—sometimes the Angel had wings and sometimes it didn’t. Sometimes it looked like a man, and sometimes it looked like a woman—rather like Jubilee at one point in her life. Sometimes it looked human and sometimes it looked like a clichéd demon. And sometimes, sometimes, it took the form of a lover or a loved one or souls who had passed and—she thought (they all thought)—would never return.
Only once had the Angel tried to impersonate Andrew. Only once. He had come toward her in the midst of her despair—one of those dark nights of the soul that not everyone climbed out of. She’d been beaten—again—in a parking lot—again—by assholes—again. But she’d learned those details much much later.
What she remembered, what had been real to her, was that feeling, that Why the fuck am I bothering? Nothing ever changes. She was twenty-five, out of college, still in New York, but in the wrong part of the city for a concert, and she’d dressed like Jubilee. Her mistake, even though they said that the victim should never consider their clothing a mistake, but she did, she had, and she felt—oh, God, she felt like what was the goddamn point?
The Fake-Andrew-Angel had reached for her just as she had thought Maybe I’ll let go this time, and the Fake-Andrew-Angel had smiled at her. It extended its hands—which looked like Andrew’s hands—and for a moment, she was fooled, thinking maybe it was Andrew, maybe there were good people where she was going, a different kind of life there, one that wasn’t so painful.
Then the Angel’s fingers brushed her face, like feathers, and it said, Jubilee, Jubilee, it’s been too long. Love, I’ve missed you—and the words were so wrong, the sentiment so far off, that she knew, she knew, this wasn’t Andrew. Not her Andrew, not the only person who had gotten her through that hellish high school. Not the person who had died defending her.
Had died defending Dennis.
So as the Angel put its Fake-Andrew fingers on her face, Jubilee slapped them away. Then she had punched it in the jaw.
The thing was, she had never punched anyone before. Not once, in her entire battered life. She’d been the punched. She’d never been the puncher. She usually curled into a fetal ball. She had stopped begging that night in high school, in that frozen parking lot where Andrew had died, because she’d learned then that begging only made things worse.
Her punch, though. Her punch had been involuntary, filled with a rage she had never before acknowledged that she had. Fake-Andrew-Angel had staggered backwards, surprised, hand on its cheek, its eyes black and all pupil for just a moment, wings flaring around it as if it planned to fly off.
Then it dropped its hands, and said in Andrew’s plaintive voice, I thought we were friends.
Andrew and I were friends, Jubilee had said. You pollute his memory. Get away from me.
And the Angel left. Just left, as if it had been a vampire in a movie and she had thrown holy water on it.
Everything around her cleared. She wasn’t in some magical realm. She wasn’t even somewhere warm. She was in another parking lot, one she had not ever seen before.
Her torso underneath a dumpster that stank even though it was nearly zero degrees outside. Her knees and toes were numb—exposed to the cold because she was wearing the open-toed shoes she preferred at her favorite club—and her entire body ached.
The dumpster—it was a sign. Someone (smaller, not as strong) had tried to toss her in it. That someone had failed.
She never remembered the fight—not that it was a fight. It wasn’t fair to call a beat-down a fight, and she never knew who attacked her, although she could guess why.
She couldn’t remember anything from the evening leading up to the dumpster. The only thing she could remember was Andrew-Fake-Andrew the not-so-fake angel, and knew, at that moment, that she had tangled with something bigger than herself.
The ambulance that had arrived just as she had woken up out of that trance (was that why she had awakened? Because an ambulance had arrived? Because someone had tried to save her?) managed to get her on a gurney before she even knew what was happening. And then one of the attendants said that phrase that she had heard only once before in her life: Wow, one of the attendants said, you’d think someone who had been through all that would be dead.
Then he saw her looking at him through a rapidly swelling eye, and he winked at her. Not a sexy wink, but the wink of someone who knew and understood.
You’re lucky, honey. You made it out this time, he had said. And that honey had been a gift, not an insult. Just a bit of understanding on a horrid horrid night, a night that should have ended everything.
The next morning, every part of her ached, except the bruised and battered knuckles on her right hand. Those bruises, the doctor said, looked more like electrical burns, but they didn’t act like burns. They were clearly bruises that resembled the kind of burns Jubilee would have gotten if she had stuck her hand in an electrical socket and the socket had exploded.
That was how she had known the punch had been real, the surprise had been real, the Fake-Andrew-Angel had been real.
A therapist told her, later, that she had seen things, but they hadn’t been real. They had simply been the electrical impulses of an oxygen-starved brain.
Science, the therapist had intoned, has shown that most of these near-death visions are simply synapses firing in unusual ways because of the stresses on the body.
But the knuckles? The bruising? The black streaks, which had remained for the better part of a year?
No one had answers for that. No one except Jubilee who, at that moment, decided to believe.
She’d even asked the therapist, taunted the therapist really, in the last hour they ever spent together, the last hour Jubilee ever paid for.
What caused these marks, then? Jubilee had asked.
The therapist shrugged. The person who was supposed to have all the answers shrugged, and said, Your body simply chose to express the trauma in that way. Bodies do that.
Jubilee hadn’t believed that at all, although she found it curious that the therapist, who was part of the community, had seen marks like that before, had thought those marks somehow normal. Now, Jubilee would want to ask the therapist about it, but then Jubilee had simply felt rage.
The therapist had gotten a concerned look, folded her hands together, and intoned to Jubilee: Respect the trauma, and you will eventually heal from it.
Respect the trauma. Jubilee actually heard that part. Respect the trauma. Realize that something had happened to you. Something big, something profound. Something difficult.
Respect the trauma had become her mantra. And it got her through.
It got her through breakups and the deaths of friends. It got her through the loss of her soul-mother, the woman who made it possible for her to become Jubilee in the first place.
It got her through that night at Judy’s.
She had been in her dressing room, getting ready to go onstage. She’d been performing at Judy’s three nights per week. She’d been bartending on three other nights. The job that had brought her here was long gone.
That night, she’d heard gunfire, and it sounded close. She never know why she had grabbed three feather boas, and some extra-large panty hose at that moment, but she had. She burst out of her dressing room, pointed at the scared young stagehand, and told him in her most commanding voice to call 911. Which he did as she went to the doors that separated backstage from the gunfire, and she had locked them, tying the feather boas in place for added strength, protecting her backstage crew while they tried to escape out the exit doors.
At that point no one—not the shooters, not Jubilee—had thought about the stage as a way to get backstage. All she had done was think about the doors, barricading the doors.
There’d been three shooters that night, not one. The media couldn’t decide if the deaths at Judy’s had been an act of terrorism, an act of hatred, or an act of some local deranged minds, rather like the attack on Jubilee and Andrew all those years ago.
Jubilee knew it had been all three—she hated that term domestic terrorism—but that’s what it was. Bigotry mixed with deranged minds, mixed with easy availability to weapons, and some sick reason to attack people who were only out to have a good time.
She’d gotten twenty people out, before one of the shooters broke through the doors she had locked. She kicked off her heels—not sure why she hadn’t kicked them off before, but adrenalin, panic, had caused her to make some strange choices—and then she had climbed the catwalk as quietly as a 6’2” person could. Fortunately, she hadn’t put on her costume. She was wearing her bra and Spanks, her real hair which she kept short so she wouldn’t get too hot under her wigs, and her feet were bare now. Bare, making climbing easier, if painful.
She’d reached the top of the catwalk, and she’d dumped one of the lights downward, narrowly missing another one of the shooters, the one standing on stage, firing into the audience huddled on the floor. Later, she found out, he had been hit with shards of broken metal and glass. At least she had caused the motherfucker some pain.
He whirled, pointed his rifle upward, and shot God knows how many repeating rounds. Missing her as if she were Tom Cruise in every single movie he’d been in. The shooter ran as he shot, shouting at his compatriots that she was here, there was someone above them, someone else who had to die.
She’d seen the wings again that night, but not the Fake-Andrew-Angel. Instead, he had come to her—it had come to her—as her beloved soul-mother, sitting on the edge of the catwalk.
You know it would be less painful if you fell, her fake soul-mother had said, so far off target again, that Jubilee’s breath caught. Whoever this so-called angel was, it was bad at its job. Or maybe it hadn’t done its research or maybe it was simply supposed to confuse.
Instead, it had goaded her, just like it had the first time. Only this time, Jubilee jostled the catwalk, then kicked out with her bare feet, catching the fake soul-mother angel-asshole off guard, and it toppled headfirst toward the stage.
Its wings unfurled at the last second, but not soon enough to do anything except ease the fall. It landed with an ungainly thud and a cry of pain that everyone in the club seemed to hear, including the cops, who were, at that moment, shooting their way in.
Adding to the casualties of course. Because police in minority communities always added to casualties.
That was something she’d tried to impress on the four police officers on the team Rodrigo had put together, but those police officers still didn’t understand it, not even the African-American one. They talked about triage and the need to save some if you couldn’t save all, and she always argued that you had to save all, until she realized that arguing was futile. There were simply some things even reasonable people, even reasonable people with something in common, simply could not agree on.
No one shot her that night at Judy’s. Somehow, she got out. She managed to find friends, reunite lovers, get phones to those who needed to call family right now. Someone gave her a coat, and someone found her some shoes, and still she worked, tirelessly, calmly, making sure everyone in her community was A-Okay.
The local papers started calling her the Angel of Judy’s until she made them stop. Because she’d seen the angel at Judy’s and it hadn’t been one she wanted to emulate.
She’d been fine after that—no need for therapy, not her, not this time. She had finally (she thought) found her calling, the ability to hold friends, friend-family, and acquaintances together, to keep a damaged and grieving community alive. To be the rock in the center of chaos, the one everyone went to when they needed a shoulder, when they needed a hug or a good meal or just someone to sit quietly in the same room, listening to each other breathe.
And then Pepperbeans died.
Pepperbeans, her little long-haired white mutt of a dog. Pepperbeans hadn’t been at the club that night, although Pepperbeans usually went everywhere with her.
But Jubilee had received a few death threats, ones she believed (she didn’t always believe the threats), and when she believed a threat, she knew it was better to leave Pepperbeans at home, because sickos who targeted the LGBTQ community targeted animals too. Bigots always saw dogs as easy prey and Jubilee hadn’t wanted to lose hers because Pepperbeans had had the misfortune to be at the wrong place at the wrong time.
Pepperbeans, fourteen years old, getting a little creaky, but not anything else. The dog loved her treats. She loved playing with Jubilee, and she loved cuddling at night—a warm little snuggle that had become reassurance after all the darkness.
Until the snuggle ceased to be warm.
Pepperbeans had died three weeks after Judy’s. Perfect death, really. The kind that Jubilee would want if she got a vote in how she passed away. In her sleep, at home, snuggled against her favorite person in the whole wide world.
The vet said it had been quick and it had been natural causes, and no, Pepperbeans hadn’t suffered at all. If you have to pick a way to go, the vet said, echoing Jubilee’s thoughts, then this is absolutely the best way.
Not that it helped Jubilee. She beat herself up internally worse than any of the beatings she had gotten for being different. What had she missed? How could she have saved her dog? Why couldn’t she save her dog?
And why—oh, God, why—did Pepperbeans have to leave now?
The despair threatened to eat her alive. Jubilee knew the despair wasn’t all Pepperbeans. It wasn’t even close to Pepperbeans. Izzy’s words “the last straw” were accurate, if a bit minimizing. Pepperbeans simply stood for all the loses, all the deaths, the one last factor that nearly tipped Jubilee over the edge.
Until she remembered that she had punched one version of the Angel of Death, and shoved another version off a catwalk. What would she have done if she had seen the one that had come for Pepperbeans?
Would Jubilee have recognized it? Was there a dog version of the Angel of Death? Was it something she could have stopped?
And those thoughts brought the recriminations back all over again.
She clung to the recriminations even as she tried to find a way to make them stop. She played with them in her mind, over and over and over again, as she rebuilt Judy’s, as she held friends, as she still provided comfort.
She even looked at other dogs, but couldn’t—just couldn’t face loving another one, loving something good and small and innocent. Not when she was surrounded by so much death.
And it had been that thought, that very thought, which had come to her in, of all places, a no-kill shelter, that she was surrounded by death, even in places like this, which had banned it.
She could see the Angel of Death. And if she could see that motherfucker, she could hurt it. She could hurt it bad.
Once she did that, once she scared it like she had scared that one near the dumpster, she could demand that it change its ways. It could still do its job. People who got horribly ill, with no hope of recovery ever, just misery forever, they needed some kind of respite. And, if she were honest with herself, she didn’t mind if the angel killed a few homophobes, a couple of terrorists, and a mass murderer or two.
But Pepperbeans, who had simply loved her? Andrew, the best person in the whole world? Her soul-mother, who taught Jubilee that we all had someone special inside us; we simply had to find her?
The Angel of Death shouldn’t get to take the good ones. No one should take the good ones. No one at all.
Stalking sounded easier than it was. Jubilee probably could’ve staked out nursing homes or the ICU at the hospital, maybe followed some hospice nurse on her daily rounds, but that didn’t just seem fair. That seemed wrong.
If she went to visit the dying, she should actually give them her time and her full attention, not scout around to see if some stupid “angel” approached on little death wings.
She had been sitting in a park—a dog park, honestly, because she missed having a dog. She watched other people’s dogs frolic on the somewhat matted and stinky grass, and thought about stalking (and fucking destroying) the Angel of Death.
Only she didn’t know how to go about it.
Then Rodrigo sat down beside her.
iiiShe hadn’t known him then, hadn’t known he was a good and kind person, hadn’t known he gave as much (if not more) of himself than she gave of herself. All she saw was a squat muscular man glancing at her from the corner of his eye.
She was taller than he was, but obviously not tougher. She knew a man like him could take her down with two quick moves—had taken her down like that more than once.
Her heart started beating rapidly, and she gathered her purse, her book bag, and her coat.
“Stay,” he’d said.
She gave him one of those dismissive smiles, the kind she’d learned from the woman who’d been her soul-mother. So many deflecting things Jubilee had learned, the way women blew off men without ever really confronting them.
She nearly dropped her purse, that was what kept her on that bench a half-second longer, grabbing the purse strap, mentally cursing, thinking about everything she could have done but wasn’t doing and—to be honest—wondering why the hell she couldn’t even get a moment of peace, when he spoke again.
“I want to kill him too.”
She looked at Rodrigo in complete horror. He wasn’t looking at her. Instead, he was staring at a little brown shih tzu that stood in front of him, tail wagging happily, and for a moment, Jubilee thought he had been talking about the dog.
“You see him,” Rodrigo said. “I know you do.”
She froze in place. Surely, he wasn’t there. Surely, he wasn’t talking to her. She had been leaning forward just a bit to gather her things, and she leaned just a bit more and, in a not-as-surreptitious-as-she-would-like kinda way—she looked to see if he was on his cell, if he was talking to someone else.
Of course he wasn’t. He was talking to her.
He had meant it all for her.
Then he looked at her head-on. His eyes were brown, and they seemed kind. She hated it when the people who attacked her initially seemed kind. Things like that made her already-fragile belief in humanity become even thinner.
“Every time,” Rodrigo said, “I see a man. He looks like a soldier out of uniform. Straight back, khakis, sleeves rolled up to reveal powerful arms. His face is wrong, though—not quite human, an approximation of human—or maybe we’re all that kind of approximation when we’re killing.”
That phrase, that sentence, it made her shiver. Was he threatening her? She pulled her purse up by its strap, hugged it to her. The shih tzu barked playfully, and leapt back and forth, trying to get Rodrigo’s attention again. Instead, another dog showed up, a bigger dog—some kind of mutt—and they ran off together, playing and barking with great joy, exactly the way the park should work.
Rodrigo must have seen her expression (how could he miss it, after all?) and he smiled ever so faintly. “I didn’t mean to alarm you.”
Talk of killing, talk of death, with a stranger, and he hadn’t meant to alarm her?
Her coat was caught between her left thigh and the rusted metal armrest. She couldn’t quite get free.
“Five tours,” he said. “I kept reupping. I don’t know why. Guess I thought I could make it better.”
She froze again, heart still pounding, but somehow willing to listen. How did he continue to find that sweet spot, the one that kept her just barely in place, unwillingly hanging on his every word?
“You see him,” Rodrigo said again. “I know you see him.”
And this time, he sounded just a little desperate, as if he didn’t want to believe he had made a mistake sitting next to her, a mistake engaging in conversation with her, a mistake revealing so much about himself.
Revealing what, though? That he was just a little crazy? Or maybe not a little crazy. Maybe a lotta crazy.
She’d learned long ago not to engage with crazy. She managed to free her coat. She slung her purse over her arm, and stood up in one single movement.
But she couldn’t help herself. She had to say something. She was going to say that she didn’t think he should talk like that to strangers.
Instead, she told him something she’d learned in the community damn near her very first week in New York.
“Pronouns are important,” she said. “It’s not a ‘him.’ It’s an ‘it,’ no matter how it presents itself. It’s an it.”
He rocked backwards as if she had pushed him against the bench. Then he tilted his head just a little, nodded, and smiled, as if her words had clarified something for him.
“What do you see?” he asked quietly.
“People I knew,” she said bitterly. “Misappropriated images of people I knew. And wings. And it smells like vanilla. Put me off ice cream and vanilla lattes for the rest of my life, let me tell you.”
He gave her a second smile, but it looked perfunctory, as if he knew her comment required one.
Then he patted the bench.
“Sit back down,” he said. “Let’s talk.”
She didn’t sit. She was never going to sit because some muscular man told her to.
He glanced at the bench, then shrugged just a little, as if to say that it didn’t matter if she sat. It would be her loss to continue standing.
“There are people like you,” he said, “like me. People who see him—it. Who see it.”
In spite of herself, she appreciated the correction. He was trying. She wasn’t sure she wanted him to try, but he was.
“It…” he seemed to be searching for the word. “It changes us.”
“Death changes us,” she said, shifting her purse on her shoulder. Dogs barked behind her, and a tall Doberman entered the park as if he and his person owned it.
Rodrigo inclined his head, giving her that point. Then he said, “I mean, when we see him…it. When we see it, we become different. We think of it as something…”
Again, he seemed to cast about for the word. But this time, he couldn’t seem to find it.
“Something we can fight,” she said.
His gaze flattened for a moment, as if that hadn’t been the word he had been searching for. Then he sighed, and shook his head once.
“I was going to say we want to fight it, but that is wrong,” he said. “Except for the deeply ill and those who die in an instant, we always fight death.”
“And suicides,” she said softly.
“Deeply ill,” he repeated, and she bristled. She did not believe suicide was an illness. Sometimes, it was a choice in the face of great physical pain. Or in the face of a world gone mad.
Or maybe she simply felt insulted by the comment, considering all the times she had considered suicide, and then (mentally) walked away from it.
“Then,” he said, apparently not seeing evidence of her own internal dialogue, “I was going to say we want to defeat it, but that is not right either. Because much of our science, our medicine, our psychotherapy and religion, it is all about defeating death.”
“I suppose,” Jubilee said, suddenly tiring of the conversation. He was getting philosophical with her, and she didn’t enjoy that. Apparently, he was borderline crazy after all.
He sensed it. He could sense her mood changes. Perhaps they showed on her face.
“I finally realized,” he said quietly, “that the word I want is stop. We want to stop death. Entirely.”
“I don’t,” she said coldly, shifting her coat to her other arm. “There are some people who deserve to die.”
And then she walked away from him, threading her way through the dogs, her heart getting heavier and heavier each time one planted itself in front of her, with a doggy smile on its face, tongue lolling, tail wagging.
She nearly made it to the edge of the park, when she had to go back.
He was still sitting on the bench, staring at the dogs as if they held all the answers.
“Why did you talk to me?” she asked as she approached. “What made you say all that stuff to me?”
He peered at her, almost as if he had forgotten her. Then his brow furrowed, and he took a deep breath—a man who was unwilling to speak, after talking so very much.
“Because I can see it,” he said quietly. “On your right hand. You touched one.”
Then he ran his fingers along the back of his own right hand, exactly in the place the black marks had been on her hand.
It unnerved her, but this time, she didn’t want to step away.
“I didn’t touch one,” she said. “I punched one.”
Hard. Hard enough to startle it. Hard enough to make it have second thoughts even as it tried again.
“Punched it,” he said quietly, and then he chuckled. “Punched it.”
He shook his head, and his smile grew with each shake. He was incredulous and yet somehow joyful, and the look transformed his face, from something broad and tough to something almost handsome.
“Punched it,” he repeated.
She felt a smile building inside her. It did sound ridiculous, Jubilee, punching the Angel of Death.
“And I kicked one,” she said. “Hard enough to make it fall.”
He raised his head, his gaze meeting hers, and his smile, which was already broad, grew into a gigantic grin.
“You’ve fought the Angel of Death twice,” he said.
“If only I’d won,” she said.
“Oh, you did,” he said. “You’re still here.”
“For the moment,” she said, not willing to promise anything more than that. “I’m here, for the moment.”
ivSomehow, he convinced her to have coffee. Then coffee became lunch, and lunch became dinner, and the conversations went on into the night. The people they’d known, the people they’d lost.
She shared more than he did, but she always shared more than anyone else, so she didn’t think it unusual until much later, after she had joined the group and watched him with others.
They all talked about their last straws and their broken hearts and the day when everything changed for them, but he rarely said a word. He watched instead.
She had no idea what his magic was, but she knew he did have magic. It was subtle and hard to see, but it showed up, like it had when he spotted her, like it had when he ran his fingers along the back of his right hand in the same pattern as her black marks.
When he “saw” something, she learned to pay attention, although she didn’t always approve.
And she didn’t approve right now, of this woman, this sniper that Rodrigo seemed to think they needed.
They hadn’t even decided on weapons yet. Jubilee wasn’t even certain that weapons would work. They didn’t even have a true game plan, just a series of ideas, wishful thinking all of it, nothing concrete. She wasn’t sure they would ever have anything concrete. She wasn’t even sure concrete was possible.
And yet she was offended when the sniper woman—incongruously called Lana—stood up and declared their mission silly. Even though part of Jubilee agreed. Part of her knew that death had always been a part of life. So many ancient cultures believed—taught—told everyone—that without death, life had no meaning.
Jubilee wasn’t sure she believed that. She wasn’t sure she wanted to believe it. She wanted to think that life could be as precious, as fleetingly perfect, without the ever-present threat of an ending looming in the distance.
The sniper woman was staring at her. Jubilee couldn’t tell if she saw disgust in the sniper woman’s eyes or if the sniper woman always looked at everyone with great contempt.
Perhaps it was the sniper woman’s defense mechanism. Or perhaps the sniper woman was truly as arrogant as she had sounded just a moment before, when she declared herself the best shot in her unit, the best shot in any unit she had ever belonged in, implying that she was also the best shot in any unit she might find herself belonging to.
“Let her go,” Jubilee repeated. “We don’t need attitude like that.”
Usually, when Jubilee spoke here, in this office, everyone listened and agreed. This afternoon, they listened, but no one nodded. They seemed uncertain, as if they were at a crossroads none of them completely understood.
“She stays,” Rodrigo said, without looking at Jubilee.
“If she wants to,” Izzy added softly, her gaze on the sniper woman.
The sniper woman turned her gaze from Izzy to Rodrigo, and then back to Jubilee.
“What are you people going to do if I try to leave?” the sniper woman asked. “Kill me?”
Tru let out a guffaw. Jubilee looked over at Tru.
“Dude,” Tru said, as only they could do, putting the emphasis on dude in such a way as to make even that word seem slightly ironic. “We’re here to stop death. Dude. I mean really. We would kill you because you won’t help us stop death? How dumb is that?”
The sniper woman leaned back ever so slightly, her cheeks turning a slight shade of pink. Apparently, she hadn’t been put in her place in a while.
“What do you need a sniper for?” the sniper woman asked, without the edge of her earlier comments. “I mean, if there is an Angel of Death, and it is a magical creature, surely a bullet wouldn’t stop it.”
“Here we go again,” said one of the cops from behind Jubilee. “Here we go again.”
FouriHe wasn’t the kind of man to believe in magic crap. Hell, he was barely the kind of man who believed in God, motherhood, and apple pie. Lou DeMartino crossed his meaty forearms over his chest and wished he had an excuse to get the hell out of here.
Too many people, and he didn’t like half of them. Okay, maybe more than half, since he hadn’t even bothered to retain their names. He’d really been good at that shit once—introduce him to a roomful of people and he could cough back their names even out of order, making them all feel important.
These days, he didn’t feel like making anyone feel important.
He didn’t even feel important himself.
He leaned against the stupid wood paneling—if you could call that seventies crap wood—and wished he’d fixed the air conditioner last week when he’d been here, chatting up Izzy. He liked Izzy. She was no-nonsense, just as damaged as he was, and had some kind of darkness hiding behind her eyes.
Plus, she didn’t judge. She knew he’d seen more than most, rejected more than most too, and had done his share of damage.
She didn’t care. She would lightly touch his arm when she talked to him, smile at him without reservation (unlike the way she smiled at everyone else) and let him take his own sweet time to tell her why and how he’d found his own way here.
Everyone else assumed he’d seen something on the job, or it was some kind of accumulation of work and shootings and he let them think that. When Izzy asked her last-straw question, he’d never really answered it honestly, sometimes saying something facetious like traffic stop, which two of the African-Americans said, and they always looked at him or Frankie or Jose, the other cops, as if all three of them were responsible for whatever the hell other cops did all around America.
Only the African-Americans who said traffic stop, they never ever looked at the African-American cop, William something or other, because they never ever thought he’d be trigger happy, not at a traffic stop, not understanding that traffic stops were one of the most fraught things a cop could do.
You pull over a car, you don’t know if it’s a good citizen inside who will have their license and registration at the ready, who’ll say yes, officer, and no, officer, and maybe, once everyone relaxed at little, might joke about having to pee or asking (sideways, maybe flirting) if they could get off with a warning this time.
You don’t know if you got a good citizen or someone on the run from something, someone with a gun on the passenger seat, someone who thinks the end is near and just fucking starts shooting, like they did to Lou’s friend Ron five years ago. Ron survived, but he was on disability, real disability, not the psychiatric crap that Lou was on.
Not that Lou disagreed with his disability. It just wasn’t the kind of thing a guy like him should have agreed to, something that a guy like him should’ve needed. He should’ve toughed it out, just like he was toughing these damn sessions out, with all the people pressed around him, the rattling air conditioner that dripped more water than it put into the air, the crap-ass carpet that didn’t provide any protection for his thin ass against that solid (probably concrete) floor underneath.
If he’d known that the woman they’d come to vet, Lana something or other, would ask all the same stupid questions, express all the same stupid doubts, go through the same stupid discussion about magic and bullets and could they really have power over death—not that Biblical power over death crap, in which Jesus steps out of the tomb after three days and everyone prematurely declares death defeated, not that stuff—but a very real ability to fight Death or its minions or its angels or whatever the fuck you wanted to call it, on its own terms.
He didn’t have time to listen to those questions again. Or rather, he did have time, he had all the time in the world, because he doubted he was ever going to get cleared, considering how jumpy he was, how much he hated being around other human beings, how just leaning against this wall, his butt pressed against the floor, Jubilee’s mighty ass half a turn away from his face, how much all of that just made him want to crawl out of his skin.
But he didn’t, not yet, although he might, if someone—anyone—doubted that magic existed one more time.
Jubilee turned just a little toward him, put one manicured finger to her beautifully painted lips, and nodded toward Rodrigo, who was listening to everything intently, as if she was saying, Let Rodrigo handle it.
If Rodrigo was going to handle it, he should’ve handled it before summoning everyone from their houses, from their all-important afternoon channel-surfing, watching the country implode because the president was a moron and, depending on which cable news channel Lou stopped on for which length of time, either the Democrats were at fault or the Republicans, and someone was going to get impeached or go to jail or should be left alone to do his goddamn job or maybe, maybe it was all broken, and they all needed to take a pill and lie down and hope that this too would pass.
Lou let out a long breath, and apparently, it had been really audible because half the room turned and looked at him.
“You got something to add, Lou?” Carter asked from across the room. Carter was one of the professors, someone who was used to asking snotty condescending questions, particularly at those whom he perceived as less educated and therefore less intelligent than he was.
“Yeah,” Lou said, half-grunting the word as he stood up, so that he could tower over the sniper (although he would never tower over Jubilee, who was tall to begin with and always wore heels that made her at least six inches taller than she needed to be).
Lou pushed his way to the front of his little section of the group, looked at the sniper and thought, yep. She had sniper training all right. Probably not as good as she thought she was, but good enough for their purposes.
“Let me put it to you in really simple terms,” he said to her, “so the rest of us don’t have to listen to this shit for the umptiumpth millionth time. Magic exists. But it ain’t really unusual, and that’s where we all make the mistake. We justify off the magic stuff as every day—the way sunshine sparkles on water or the fact that a full moon brings out all the crazies worldwide—and we normalize much too much. Like death. We just figure, shit, yeah, it happens to all of us. Death and taxes, yadda yadda yadda.”
The sniper—younger than he would’ve thought, eyes that weren’t quite dead, not yet, but were heading there. She’d seen too much and she didn’t want to believe in nothing. Jesus, he could understand that. He’d been in the same boat when he got here, right after Miriam died.
“We got it worked out,” he said. “To answer your questions, maybe before you ask all of them, we’re not gonna use regular bullets or silver bullets or bullets dipped in holy water. We ain’t really using bullets at all. We got surprise on our side, and a whole hell of a lot of rage, and what you’d be shooting, from a distance and accurately—what a lot of us might be shooting, just not from that distance—are dummy bullets, maybe rubber, maybe non-lethal crowd control. We’re going for shock and awe. You don’t fight magic with magic when you’re a bunch of lugs like us. You fight magic with sheer determination, a whole lotta righteousness, and the courage of our fucking convictions.”
“And you think that’ll work?” she asked.
Apparently, he’d missed that question in his little rant. He’d thought the answer was implied. Apparently not.
“Here’s the thing you should understand, Miss Windspeed, Calculus, and Impossible Angles, you don’t know if anything’ll work until you give it a try. And conditions on the ground might make a great attempt fail. Or they might strengthen the weakest attempt ever designed. You know, luck. It can be a factor in anything we do.”
“I thought you were going to tell me that luck is magic,” she said.
He didn’t know how she did it—found the one thing that would shut him down—but she did. Maybe that was magic.
He felt older than he had five minutes ago, just from the words she’d uttered. Stabbed him, right through the heart. Although there was an open track to that heart, and he knew it.
“I’m beginning to think luck is the antithesis of magic,” he muttered, and shuffled back to his spot. Jubilee watched him. Damn, that woman saw everything. He used to too.
She gave him a compassionate look, half-hidden by her fake eyelashes, but there all the same, and turned back toward the sniper and her stupid questions.
Luck. Lou shook his head. Once upon a time, he’d thought of himself as the luckiest man alive. Whenever he introduced Miriam, he’d say, She agreed to marry me. I think that makes me the luckiest man in the whole entire world.
And then…Jesus… and then her cancer and all the magical medical crap in the world didn’t save her. And she made him promise. Him, promise, that he would be the one, if she couldn’t have a good life after the surgeries, if she was going to decline and become one-quarter of a person, if her life wasn’t going to be worth living—she made him promise that he would have the docs pull the plug.
I trust you, she’d said. You’re the strongest man I know.
But he wasn’t strong. It came to that moment, when the doctors said they couldn’t make her better, they weren’t even sure she would wake up from the last anesthetic, and if she did, they knew she wouldn’t be herself because the freakin’ cancer had eaten her beautiful brain.
He’d known that was coming, he’d known it when she looked at him—just the once, two weeks before—and for a half-second, she wondered who he was. She hadn’t said that, thank God, because if she had, he might’ve wondered (ah, hell, he was still wondering) if he’d killed her because she didn’t know him anymore.
But the docs talked to him, and then a whole other set of docs talked to him, and then yet another set of docs talked to him, and they all agreed that for all intents and purposes, for the purpose of the Do-Not-Resuscitate that she had signed, for the purpose of figuring out all the life and death stuff, she was already gone.
Already gone.
So he said, his voice choked with emotion, his voice barely there—the strongest man alive—he’d said, Yeah. Do it. Pull the plug.
And they did. They took her off life support. They let God do what God was going to do, as one of the docs said, and Lou damn near jumped down his throat.
Miriam didn’t believe in God. She believed in logic and science and maybe some kind of something that humans hadn’t discovered yet. She wasn’t even sure there was life after death, which meant when she had told him that she wanted to die rather than live a marginal life, she had been the strongest person alive, because she believed that dying would probably wipe her out of existence entirely.
And she thought that was okay.
He didn’t. He still didn’t.
So he went from thinking he was the luckiest man alive to knowing that he was the unluckiest, because he had found the best person in the world, and then he had killed her.
Jubilee put her hand on his arm. Damn that woman, knowing and trying to alleviate other people’s pain. Damn her for her compassion.
He wanted to move away.
Instead, he sniffled, and silently cursed himself, and if Jubilee hadn’t been holding him down, he would’ve fled. He would’ve been done with this group.
No one looked at him, though. No one looked at sniveling former tough guys. No one, not even in this group, wanted to acknowledge that tears were possible and events in the world, in your goddamn life, could turn you into a weeping pile of worthlessness.
No one looked at him except Jubilee, and if she put one of her long arms around him, he silently swore he push her away. Hard. Noticeably hard.
He sniveled again, and wiped his nose with the back of his hand, and wished he could stop being such a goddamn baby.
Then he made himself concentrate, realizing he had lost the thread of the conversation.
“So you’re saying we’re going to be the Polish cavalry in World War II,” the sniper was saying to the group.
Lou frowned, not knowing the reference. Jesus, his ignorance upset even him sometimes. Maybe instead of sitting on his ass and feeling sorry for himself every day, he should read a book once in a while.
“That’s a myth,” Carter said in his condescending tone. “The Polish did not attack German panzers with lances and swords. The Germans created myth as propaganda, and there you are, spouting it—”
Pauline, one of the few people Lou liked in the room, a teacher who had somehow survived Portage Elementary with the ability to smile and be nice even now, stepped in front of Carter just enough to shut him up.
“Yes,” she said to the sniper woman. “That’s exactly what we’re saying. Sixteen times, the Polish cavalry faced stronger German forces, and in almost every one of those battles, the cavalry committed itself well. They succeeded at their missions. Yes, a lot of people died, but they died well and bravely, which is, I think, all we can hope for.”
“Bullshit,” the sniper said. She was shaking. “Bull-fucking-shit. That well and bravely thing is something someone who has never been to war says because they believe that a hero’s death is actually possible.”
Oh, God, Lou thought. Here it comes. The bile that no one in this place needs right now.
And as if she had heard his thoughts, the sniper clenched her small fists.
“Well and bravely?” she asked. “You want a sniper. You know what a sniper sees through her scope? Someone living their life—maybe talking to a friend, maybe shooting at an enemy, maybe just crossing a road. We watch, we see, we put them in the crosshairs, and when the moment is right—when we determine that the moment is right—we shoot them.”
The room was silent. Lou closed his eyes, wishing he could close his ears.
“They explode backwards as if propelled or maybe sideways or maybe into the person they were talking to, and they don’t get back up. They don’t even try, if we’re good, and those of us who do the job in war, we’re good.”
He sighed just a little and opened his eyes. He could shut his ears better with his eyes open. He stared at the open-toed shoes that Jubilee wore, her feet not pretty at all—very masculine, maybe the only masculine part about her. Except for the glitter toenail polish with the little stars in the very center, polish that matched her flowing pink outfit.
“They’re not heroic. They’re not brave. They were simply there one minute and gone the next. And everyone else? Yeah, maybe they have a moment where they grab a comrade and pull him aside or run in to carry out the wounded, but that doesn’t negate what they did the day before, with their own rifle—”
“Enough,” Rodrigo said quietly, the first words he had spoken in over an hour. “We know.”
“You don’t know,” the sniper said. “You go on and on about being happy that you have a sniper, and you don’t even know what we are—”
“We know,” Lou said, before he could stop himself. “Jesus, woman, we know.”
He didn’t stand up this time. He sat there, the crown of his head leaning against the wall, his arms still crossed, his legs outstretched.
“You’re the one who doesn’t know,” he said, as he pushed himself away from the wall. “You have no idea who we are or what we’ve been through. The person you’re so rudely shouting down about heroism? That’s Pauline, a school teacher—she’s still a school teacher, although I don’t know how, because I wouldn’t be a school teacher after what she went through.”
After all, he couldn’t be a cop any more after what he had gone through. At least not until they cleared him, not until he cleared himself.
“She saved the lives of fifteen six-year-olds, did you know that?”
“Lou,” Pauline said, waving a hand, trying to make him stop.
“She took three bullets getting her first-grade class away from that crazy with an automatic weapon. You remember, the one who gunned down children because he wasn’t properly potty-trained or whatever—”
“Lou,” Pauline said, just a little louder.
“She’s a hero. She made sure her kids were safe, then went back into the school and dragged out her colleagues. You see her. She makes you look like you’re Arnold Schwarzenegger. If she had died that day, she would have died bravely and well—”
“Lou!” This time it wasn’t Pauline. It was Izzy, and he realized what he had said. If she had died that day. God, where did these sentences come from?
He nodded, and would’ve shut up, if the sniper hadn’t taken that moment to frown at him.
“You don’t know us,” he said. “You have no idea what we’ve been through, what we’ve seen, or why we’re here.”
“So why don’t you tell me?” the sniper asked.
“Because, honey,” he said, “people like you don’t deserve to know.”
FiveiAnd with that final insult, Lou DeMartino voted with his legs. He shot one last nasty look at Lana, then pushed his way past the people in front of him, and walked out the office door.
One by one, the others followed him. A number of them gave Rodrigo perplexed looks, as if they didn’t know why he had brought them to the office in the middle of such a hot afternoon.
And he wasn’t sure either, truth be told. He had seen her, saw the ghost of the rifle still in her hand, knew that she had been one of the best of the best, just by the aura around her, her eyes, and the way she still held that invisible gun.
But he couldn’t see her soul. He couldn’t see any of their souls. He could only guess and, as usual when he tried to lead, he guessed wrong.
He tried not to let despair take him. Self-pity was a waste of time. He firmly believed that, and yet, there he was, tottering on the edge of it.
Lana stood very still as the exodus began. She didn’t move as it continued, even as people around her left. Sometimes they brushed against her. Sometimes they bumped her so hard that she had to struggle to keep her footing.
Even when Rodrigo had brought in outspoken people like Lou DeMartino, the group had never reacted like this. They almost seemed to hate her.
Maybe they did hate her.
And that surprised him.
But she was the closest thing to a pure killer that he had tried to recruit for the team. There was clearly very little humanity left inside her.
And maybe that was good.
Only a handful of people were left. Izzy still sat at her desk. Jubilee stood near the wall, Tru beside her like they always were. Two of the police officers—William and Jose—and that professor, Carter, who grated on Rodrigo’s nerves, even though Rodrigo knew the man’s story. His entire extended family lost the day after he left for college, in a house fire that would have taken him too, had he been home. Day two of the family reunion. The day before he left for college, he’d had fifteen family members. Two days later, he had none.
He could’ve given up. Instead, he’d bottled up, and used his mind to move ahead, getting two Ph.D.’s and doing some post-doc work before getting snatched up by the university here. He was thirty-five before it all caught up to him, and even then, he hadn’t understood it.
A friend had brought him to the grief group, and Rodrigo, seeing the anger underneath, had brought him here.
Lana’s gaze met Rodrigo’s as if to ask, What now?
He had no idea. The group had clearly rejected her, the first time that had ever happened. Usually they accepted anyone he brought in.
Maybe they knew that with the arrival of a sniper, the plan would actually happen. Maybe that frightened them.
It was one thing to talk about killing the Angel of Death. It was another thing to actually try it.
He pushed away from the desk, feeling slightly chilled. The air conditioner failed when the room had been full, but now, its half-hearted wheeze managed to put out enough cold air to make him uncomfortable.
Or maybe, the fact that they had been close to executing his plan made him uncomfortable.
Because he had lied to all of them. He had never actually seen the Angel of Death.
He had felt the angel, over and over again. The beat of wings, the looming presence, that moment when the person, bleeding out in his arms, seemed to rally, only to smile, focus on something in the distance, and fade away.
Five tours. He hadn’t lied about that. Five tours and lots of death, and that feeling just before someone left, that feeling he didn’t know how to describe. When he’d been in the Arizona desert as a boy, crossing from Mexico with a group of people his mother had paid dearly for him to travel with, he could tell when someone wasn’t going to make it.
Not because they gave any overt signs of illness or because they seemed to be on their last legs, but because the sun got very bright, and the air gained a chill it hadn’t had before, and then the sound of flapping wings, not that he had known what that was the first time.
The first time, he had thought he heard sheets on a clothesline, flapping in the breeze, before he realized there was no breeze, no clothes line, no clean clothes.
And then the sun became so bright it hurt his eyes, and he shivered, and the next thing he knew, the slender man beside him, the one who had shared his water, the one who had egged him on, had fallen face first in the sand.
No matter what Rodrigo did—no matter what they all did—the slender man did not get up. He would never get up again.
The first of so many deaths. On that trip, another six succumbed. And then there were the people at the nursing home where he had gotten his first job. At that home, there was no sunlight. Just fluorescents that flared as if they were about to go out at the oddest hours. Only they didn’t burn out. They stayed on, and didn’t flare again, not until a few minutes before someone else died.
And then there were his tours. He didn’t like to think about his tours. In fact, he couldn’t think about them or the brilliant sunshine that seemed to coat everything. It couldn’t get stronger there because it was already at full strength, something that sometimes made him wonder if he had actually served in a real place or if he had been doing his tours in a small corner of hell.
He wasn’t sure; he had never been sure.
All he had done when he got home was try to find respite, try to figure out how to live with all he’d seen.
Which led him to the Meeting, and then the shooting, there.
He knew Izzy blamed him for some of the deaths, particularly young Alyssa. Because Izzy thought—maybe rightly—that he could have stopped it.
If he had seen it. If he hadn’t been looking up, noting the chill on the breeze and the fact that the sun was brighter than he had seen it in years. And that surge of fear that had run through him—that had happened before the first gunshot, before Dugan had come out of the door, chasing everyone.
If Rodrigo had just looked down, he would have seen the movement in the glass panels beside the door, he would have known, he would have grabbed the rifle, saved lives.
He would have, he would have—if he had known, he wouldn’t have taken the water from the man whose name he had never known. Rodrigo was younger, stronger, he could have made it through that desert on his own. And in the tours, he would have…
The air conditioner rattled, almost like the sound of flapping clothes on a line. He frowned, glanced at Izzy, who was staring in horror at Lana.
Lana, who had a handgun in her hand, her nearly dead eyes unfocused and unseeing.
Just like Dugan. Dear God, just like Dugan.
Rodrigo launched himself toward her as she raised that handgun slowly, aiming it—at him? He didn’t have time to consider—and then the report echoed in the close quarters.
Out of the corner of his eye, he saw Jubilee grab Tru’s neck and fling them to the ground as she went down. The police officers ran toward Lana, just like Rodrigo was doing, but Carter was staring toward the air conditioner itself.
The rattle had stopped, and the air inside the office had grown stifling.
Rodrigo reached Lana first. He tackled her, knocking her backwards, but she kept a grip on the handgun.
“Let me go, you fool,” she said. “You want it dead, right? Let me make sure it’s dead.”
But he didn’t let her go. He wasn’t going to let anyone go. He had enough people die on his watch.
She was struggling beneath him.
“Let her go,” Izzy said. “Rodrigo, let her go.”
Jubilee was standing slowly. Tru stayed down, their head covered with their arms. The police officers were standing beneath the air conditioner, looking at the floor.
The air conditioner itself had changed color. A blackness covered it, almost an ichor—if that was the right word; it certainly wasn’t one he had ever used before. The water from the broken condenser dripped down the wall, also black.
Izzy had stood, making her way around the desk.
“Let her go,” Izzy repeated. “Before it vanishes. Let her go.”
It. It. He didn’t know what “it” was. He didn’t see an it. But Jubilee was on her feet now, and Tru had let their hands slide from their skull.
He let Lana go, and she walked over to the desk, moving just beyond it, and poking with her toe.
Poking at nothing.
“Don’t you see it?” Izzy asked.
“See what?” he asked.
“That shape over there,” Carter said.
“The wings,” said Jose.
“It’s so small,” William said.
“Andrew,” Jubilee said.
“Alyssa,” Izzy said.
“Alyssa?” It took Rodrigo a moment. The teenage girl, the one that Izzy had taken under her wing.
The one who had died at Dugan’s hand.
Lana was still poking with her toe. “I didn’t think a real bullet would kill it,” she said.
Then she raised her head, her gaze meeting Rodrigo’s. “You didn’t see it?”
“I don’t see anything,” he said. He never saw anything. He should have told them that from the start. He never saw anything at all.
“The girl. Maybe twelve. She was—it was—” Lana shuddered. “It couldn’t hide the wings. Or those eyes. All black, all pupil. No whites.”
She looked at Izzy. “How long had she been coming here?”
Izzy was staring at the floor, in the space that Lana kept poking with her toe.
“I don’t see a twelve-year-old,” Izzy said. “It’s Alyssa. Or it was, until…”
Jubilee walked toward them. “I should’ve known they could be hurt. The way that one ran from me after I punched it.”
Rodrigo joined them. They were standing around something, only he couldn’t see it. Nor could he see a bullet hole in the wall.
Just the ichor on the air conditioner, and a scent—something like rancid vanilla.
“What do we do with it?” Carter asked him, as if Rodrigo had all the answers. Although he probably deserved that. Because he always acted like he’d had answers.
“We can kill them?” he asked, astonished that it actually worked. Even though they hadn’t tried.
“Yeah,” Tru had joined the group. “Not that it matters. You all saw the other one, right?”
“No,” Lana said. “I would have shot it too.”
“You can’t,” Tru said. “They take lives at the right time. So if one is supposed to die…”
“Another shows up to make sure it does.” Carter put a hand over his face, then staggered backwards just a little.
“It doesn’t matter,” William said. He normally didn’t say much at all. “We sent a message. We let them know we’re serious.”
Lana looked at him sideways, as if to say, You believe that? Then she glanced at Rodrigo.
“It was here all along,” she said. “Why didn’t you just kill it?”
“I never saw it,” he said, almost whispering. “I never saw any of them.”
“Then why did you bring us here?” Izzy snapped, clearly furious. “Why did you promise us we could kill them? Why did you organize us? Why did you rent this office? Why did you—”
“Because,” he said. “Some of us need more than talk. Some of us need to take action.”
“Even if it’s futile?” Izzy asked.
He had never seen her that angry.
“Especially if it is,” he said.
He hadn’t expected them to succeed. Expected one of them to succeed. Although he had known Lana was something special with her invisible rifle and her very real handgun, the one he hadn’t realized she was carrying all along.
His gaze met hers, and there was something in her eyes, something livelier than there had been earlier in the day.
“It was feeding off you,” she said. “Your pain. I was watching it. I saw the wings twice. And then, as everyone left—”
“The wings unfurled,” Jubilee said. “I caught a glimpse of them.”
“Was it coming for one of us?” Carter asked.
The bright light in the office. The chill. The sound of wings. Had that been for them? Or for the Angel of Death itself?
“How would we ever know?” Tru asked. “How would we ever know?”
iiNo one wanted to leave. No one except Rodrigo.
They just kept staring at the dead creature that he couldn’t see.
So finally, he walked out of the door, and sat on the cracked sidewalk, his feet extended in the ruined parking lot.
It was twilight. No more sunlight flaring. No bright day. No chill in the air. No wind. It was hotter than shit out here. Midwestern heat, filled with so much humidity that the air felt like a blanket, pressing down on him. Drowning him, with each breath.
But he kept breathing. Thinking.
He went to every Meeting. He came to this office every day. He talked about killing the Angel of Death, and then when it happened, when someone actually pulled it off, he felt as numb as he had in Afghanistan, when that last bomb exploded fifteen yards and two buildings away from where he was.
Triage was easy when you were numb. You didn’t think about the tattooed limbs as part of a man you’d spoken to not thirty minutes before. They were simply parts to be gathered, a job to be done.
That was what this had been for him.
A job.
A way to get through.
He crossed his arms over his knees and rested his forehead against his wrists. Magic had happened and he missed it. The event he had been planning for occurred. Ironically, the person he had brought in to do the job had done it, quickly, efficiently.
And, as he suspected, it had made no difference. Because there had been a second angel, there to take out the first.
Voices echoed behind him. Then laughter.
Laughter. When was the last time he heard laughter? Real joyous laughter?
He raised his head, saw Tru and Jubilee, smiling at each other as they came out of the building.
Jubilee crouched beside him. “It vanished on its own,” she said. “Kinda like the witch in the Wizard of Oz.”
“‘Surrender, Dorothy!’” Tru quoted. “Guess threats like that never work.”
“Judy’s revenge,” Jubilee said, and Tru laughed.
Tru started across the parking lot, but Jubilee stayed for a moment longer, crouching beside Rodrigo.
“What can I do for you?” she asked him.
He shook his head. He had no idea.
“It’s nice to hear you laugh,” he said. “Keep doing it.”
She squeezed his shoulder, then stood. “You know where to find me.”
“Yeah,” he said, watching Tru shift from foot to foot in the parking lot. “Thanks.”
Jubilee stood and headed to a car that Rodrigo hadn’t seen before. More voices surrounded him. William, Jose, Carter, talking about what they had seen. They didn’t acknowledge him, too intent on their conversation, perhaps, or maybe they hadn’t seen him at all.
Then Lana. She sat down beside him, extended her legs and crossed them at the ankles.
“I suppose you want to hunt them,” she said.
He let out a breath. Did he? Spend his entire life pursuing creatures he couldn’t see? Being present at the worst moments, trying to figure out why the sun was brighter that day or the air had a chill? Did he really want to do any of that?
“No,” he said. “You can, if you want.”
“And be what?” she asked. “The Angel of Death for the Angel of Death? No thanks.”
She wiped her hands on her thighs, as if her fingers had gotten dirty just from firing the gun.
“Your club is weird,” she said. “I don’t like it.”
And he, he just realized, didn’t like her. He let out a silent sigh, then got to his feet. He wondered if he should thank her.
But she made it easy. She just walked away from him, as if they hadn’t spoken at all.
That just left Izzy. Izzy who was still inside the office. Izzy, who practically lived there.
He went inside and found her, sitting at her desk, staring at the apparently empty spot on the floor.
“What do we do now?” she asked, not looking at him. “What do we do now?”
He crouched in front of her, then leaned forward and drew her into a hug. He’d known her nearly a year and he had never hugged her before.
She leaned against him, body stiff, and then, muscle by muscle, it relaxed.
It wasn’t until his shoulder felt warm that he realized she was crying. He leaned his head against hers.
“Fucking wheel,” she said after a few moments.
“Wheel?” he asked.
“Grief wheel,” she said. “It’s not a wheel. It’s a gauge.”
“A gauge?” He wasn’t sure he understood what she was saying.
“Yeah,” she said into his shirt. “Denial, anger, bargaining, depression, acceptance. It’s not a wheel.”
Bargaining. Jesus. The entire group had been built on bargaining. They had been negotiating how to kill the Angel of Death. Bargaining with the way the world worked, as if they could actually change it.
“I’d been stuck on anger,” Izzy was saying.
And he had been bargaining. He’d brought them all into it.
“You’re not stuck anymore?” he asked.
“I don’t think I am.” She brought her head up. Her cheeks were wet, and her eyes should have been red, but they weren’t.
He wasn’t stuck anymore either. But he felt a little lost, like he sometimes did when he finished a mission. Not that he had finished this one.
Or had he? He had finally found the right person, the catalyst, who changed everything.
What had Lou said? Their mistake… We justify off the magic stuff as every day…we normalize much too much. Death and taxes.
Death and taxes.
And Izzy, in his arms, warm and lighter than she had been since he met her.
She was watching him. He smoothed her hair away from her face. Then he kissed her. And she kissed him back.
Not hearts and flowers. Not even Disney-fied.
But nice. And different.
There was a reason he had relied on her, a reason he had trusted her.
They understood each other. They had needed each other. Right from moment one.
He helped her out of the chair.
“There’s going to be a full moon tonight,” he said, the king of non sequiturs.
“You saying we all went crazy because of it?” she asked.
He hadn’t been. But he wouldn’t put it past them. Any of them.
“Just thought maybe you’d want to see it,” he said.
“I’ve already seen full moons,” she said.
“But not this one,” he said.
She stared at him for a moment. Then she smiled, nodded, almost laughed.
“You’re right,” she said. “Not this one. Chance of a lifetime.”
It was. It was one of those moments—like every moment, really—that would never come again.
But he didn’t say it.
Instead, he led her outside, to the ruined parking lot on a crappy street in a dying strip mall. A big orange moon was rising over the dilapidated buildings a few blocks away.
Orange meant there was a lot of sunlight reflecting off it. Big meant it was low on the horizon. And yet, it felt unusual. Magic. More magic than the actual magic that had occurred in their rundown office.
He put his arm around her, and she leaned into him. And they said nothing as the light hit them, brighter and brighter.
But the air stayed warm, and nothing flapped in the nonexistent breeze.
They were alone
They were together.
And, for that moment at least, they were alive.
Killing the Angel of Death
Copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
All rights reserved
Published 2023 by WMG Publishing
Cover and layout copyright © 2023 by WMG Publishing
Cover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG Publishing
Cover art copyright © sarah5/Depositphotos
Chronic illness flared—well, actually announced its presence quite dramatically—so I was sick for a week, which put me behind on almost everything. I got a lot of reading done, including some that I was supposed to do, but did not write up the Recommended Reading List at all. Then I did other things to cope with being behind, and this was the one thing I could put off, and put it off I did. I am just getting to it, in the middle of March, which makes this little opening a long apology for posting this near the end of the month.
I hope to have March’s up earlier in April, but I’m not holding my breath. And, because I’m hurrying this, books2read is acting up and taking its sweet time giving me links. Sometimes it only gives me the one I provided. (And made me switch services to find it.) So, sorry, you might have to go directly to your favorite store without benefit of a link. Sigh.
I am highlighting some of Teju Cole’s essays from his book, but I hadn’t finished the book when I wrote these. The full recommendation (positive) will be in March.
Anyway, here’s all the good stuff from February.
February, 2023Cole, Teju, “Always Returning,” Known And Strange Things: Essays, Random House, 2016. A beautiful essay about writing and writing heroes and time passing and things unseen. Cole visits W.G. Sebald’s grave to honor that writer. (There’s an earlier essay on Sebald, which is wonderful, but I’m not sure it’s an easy read for those unfamiliar with his work.) This essay touches on a variety of things, from the cultural differences between the U.K. and the U.S, to the kindness of strangers, to the lenses through which we view every day.
Cole, Teju, “Gueorgui Pinkhassov,” Known And Strange Things: Essays, Random House, 2016. I have been thinking about this essay ever since I read it. I even mentioned it in a Business Musings blog post. It’s about artistry, Pinkhassov’s in particular. What caught me about the essay is his constantly changing use of the new tools in his toolbox. The essay was written at the time when the camera on the phone became ubiquitous and people started talking about the death of photography. Instead, some photographers took the camera phone as a challenge, and came up with ways to make this new tech work for them. There’s more to this essay, but that point resonanted with me, given what’s going on with AI right now. I’m still thinking about this, and probably will for some time.
Cole, Teju, “A True Picture of Black Skin,” Known And Strange Things: Essays, Random House, 2016. This book has an entire section on photography, and many of the photographs are inside the book. One photo is of a Black woman from 1963, done in black and white. The photo is titled Mississippi Freedom Marcher, Washington, D.C. 1963, and is by Roy DeCarava. I won’t go into Cole’s analysis here, except to agree with him: this photo is breathtaking. One thing the essay does, though, is discuss the difficulties of photographing Black skin, with tools designed to handle pale and reddish skin tones. White folks designed the cameras for white folks, which I suspect I knew, but hadn’t seen analyzed as well here as Cole does. Read this, and please, look at the photo.
Cole, Teju, “Unnamed Lake,” Known And Strange Things: Essays, Random House, 2016. In the middle of this essay, Cole gets to the point of the title–that there is an unnamed lake “underneath all reality” and “there are places where the ground, insufficiently firm, can suddenly plunge one through into the subterranean truth of things.” The essay explores this feeling in a very realistic way, but looks at the dark side of it. The nightmares. The dark visions that become a part of history. Cole wrote this essay long before the U.S. plunged into the darkness that Trump started feeding and which still echoes now. But this essay could have been written last year.
Feinberg, Scott, “When ‘You Have A Spark Toward A Story,'” The Hollywood Reporter, November 21, 2022. There’s so much wisdom in this round table that I can’t summarize it. It’s the possible nominees for best screenplay in awards season, featuring Tony Kushner, Jordan Peele, Martin McDonagh, Chinonye Chukwu, Rian Johnson, and Daniel Kwan, all talking about the craft of writing. Some, like Kwan, are new(ish). Others, like Kushner, have been writing a top level for decades now. The interaction and the discussions are so worth your time that I think you need to hurry over and read it right now.
McDermid, Val, The Distant Echo, HarperCollinsPublishers (UK), 2018 edition of a 2003 book. I’d been reading a lot of books about college students and murder, some good and some bad, throughout the year. Maybe it’s because I’m in school right now, although I’m not feeling very murdery. I’m just feeling behind. Anyway, the students in this book stumble on a dying woman in the snow in Fife at midnight. They try to save her, but fail. For their troubles, they become the main suspects in what becomes a horrific and famous murder….which goes unsolved, partly due to another death. So, the book skips ahead 25 years. Two of the no-longer young men die in mysterious circumstances, which makes the cold case hot again. The denouement is a bit overly dramatic, and I’m sorry to say, a baby is in jeopardy. But in my defense, I read about the dang jeopardy baby because it was born during the second investigation. (I’ll be honest: I angrily scanned the baby-jeopardy sections…after I checked the end to see if the kid lived.) I hated the baby-jeopardy part. It seems that McDermid went through a child-in-jeopardy phase, which I will address below.
The book is very good. I couldn’t put it down, even with the evil baby sections, which is why I’m recommending it with a warning for other tender souls like me. The book’s cover says “Introducing Karen Pirie,” which meant nothing to me, but apparently, there’s an entire TV series about her. She does get introduced here, very near the end, and never is a viewpoint character. Then, when I looked to see more about her and the series, I found that the first book after this one had…you guessed it…another damn kid in danger. Even though Pirie is a cold-case detective. So I skipped that one, but I bought the next few. More about that in next month’s Recommended Reading. Anyway, this is worth reading, if I haven’t spoiled too much of it for you.
Moody, Nekesa Mumbi, “‘How Do You Put This Beautiful Story into This One Tune?'”, The Hollywood Reporter, December 7, 2022. This is the songwriter round table from The Hollywood Reporter, as it guessed which songwriters would get tapped during awards season. The songwriters in the room were Diane Warren, Joe Jonas, David Byrne, Finneas, and Ruth B. Lots of expertise in the room, and lots of insights, not just about songwriting, but about storytelling. Read this one carefully.
Robinson, Lisa, “Everything’s Coming Up Lizzo, and It’s About Damn Time,” Vanity Fair, November 2022. I’m not sure I read a recent interview with Lizzo that actually takes the time to explain her history and her dedication to positivity. I do know that her song, “It’s About Damn Time,” got me through the summer of 2022 (on repeat, no less). That song won a much-deserved Grammy. I love her attitude, I love her work. I’d known a lot about her history, but not all of it, and that just makes her dedication to positive vibes even better.
If you want to see how artists survive and thrive, then read this. Lizzo is a great modern example of perseverance and turning that perseverance into art.
Steinem, Gloria, “A Call to Hope,” Vanity Fair, November, 2022. Like most feminists of my generation, I have mixed feelings about Gloria Steinem. She’s twenty years older than me, and some of her attitudes come from that earlier era. I remember the great things she’s done and the cringe-worthy missteps. So when I saw this essay that she wrote in Vanity Fair, I braced myself. I wasn’t sure which Gloria would be here. It was the inspiring Gloria, the one who has fought more battles than I can imagine, the woman who lived in a pre-Roe world, then the world of victory, only to see the Supreme Court try to force women back into the box that Gloria worked so hard at breaking us out of. I expected some vitriol here. Instead, the essay is filled with necessary hope. Please read this one.
To Get a Free AI Audio Version of this blog, click here.
I write better in Spanish than I speak. Much better. Some of that is because I have read Spanish with varying degrees of competency since I was eight. Many of my problems speaking the language come from either a lack of vocabulary or, in the past year, an inability to access that vocabulary in the moment.
However, much of the reason that I write better in Spanish than I speak is because of AI. And because of an acceptance among the professors at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, that the students will use the website tools available to them—in English and in Spanish.
I am a dyslexic. I have never been able to spell well. In fact, I spell better in Spanish than in English because Spanish makes sense. (The sounds of the language appear in the spelling for the most part, unlike English.) I still transpose letters in Spanish, but I will look at them later and think, Whoops. That would sound weird.
I never do that in English.
When I write a paper in Spanish, I use a Spanish spell check and grammar check. Two years ago, when my classes started requiring essays, I would write in Spanish until I couldn’t find the words or the proper structure. Then I would put an English phrase in brackets and continue.
I’d go through the essay, pull out the brackets, and put that phrase in three different translate programs. I wouldn’t go with the most common translation, because some of the programs are quite literal. I would go with the one that looked like something I would write—right or wrong.
Nowadays, I dumb down my essays a bit. If I can’t figure out how to use the English phrase, I figure out a different way to say the same thing in Spanish. I still look up the odd word. (My favorite from last semester? Parachute, which is paracaídas, or, in English, “for falls.”)
If I’m feeling really insecure about a paragraph, I will put it into a translate program, translate it back into English to see if it says what I think it does, then translate that English into Spanish and see if I even get close.
Mostly, I’m doing okay. Sometimes I’m still way off. The correct version, however, goes into the paper.
The distance between my spoken Spanish and my written Spanish is vast. Vast enough that I, were I some professor faced with a student like me, might think that I let someone else (or AI) write my papers for me.
However, every professor I’ve had has required us to do some free writing in class and turn that writing in. Sometimes that writing is in an exam and, last semester, it was almost daily about something we read.
My vocabulary in the free writing sessions is better than my spoken vocabulary, but it is not great. And I occasionally forget an accent mark or I transpose letters, and don’t catch it. But my written Spanish remains consistent. It’s clear that the woman who writes the papers using the AI tools I mentioned above is the woman who has done the free writing in class.
When ChatGPT filled the news, we were starting a new semester. My Spanish prof had just handed out an assignment to write a major research paper as 50% of our grade. She mentioned the AI program and added, Just let me know if you use it.
She made no judgement about it at all. Just acknowledging that the tool was there, and she wasn’t going to fight it.
I spoke to my research paper partner, who is taking something like six classes this semester, and asked him what his other profs said about ChatGPT. He said that, with one exception, they all said the same thing.
Just let me know if you use it.
It sounds like the university itself has already moved to an acceptance that the tech is changing and it will have an impact on what students do.
The tech is changing in all different creative venues, from AI art, which we will discuss next time to AI audio, which I’ve been focused on in these past few weeks, to AI writing.
These tools will be available from now until the internet breaks (if it ever does). I’m sure that as spell checkers became available and as grammar checkers started being the default in most word programs, professors worried. How would they know if their students can write well?
I’m sure the profs of language programs were quite worried.
I would have been. In fact, early on in my renewed Spanish career, I tried to operate without the spell check or grammar check, and then decided that I was the only one who cared about that.
To be completely honest, I learn more by going back and forth between my words and the computer program’s offerings. I can see now which programs are literal translations and which ones actually offer nuance. I also see how easy it is for those translation programs to misunderstand something in basic Spanish and create an amazing word salad in English.
These are tools, tools that I will probably use for the rest of my academic career.
I could write an entire paper in English, hit translate on the most reliable program, and have some rather cruddy Spanish translation of what I have done. It would confuse words and gender, and sometimes just give up and use the English word when I would want a Spanish one.
Editing that is much too much work for me. Even if I took the time to correct it, I’m sure I would miss something.
Google Translate has existed since 2006. It’s been augmented many times and now uses a different basis than the early programs, but it’s okay for basic stuff. As I searched for the date when Google Translate was launched, I discovered a few companies that offer professional translation services that are machine-based.
Those are services that let the machine translate the document, and then human beings edit the documents to, as one service said, make sure that there are no dangerous translations.
(Their example was in the medical field. A mistranslation could cost a life.)
These services claim they are cheaper and faster than a standard human translation service. I don’t know. I haven’t priced them. But they do seem like a compromise that businesses who want some document translated into a dozen languages might use.
These are AI programs which have been around for 17 years. Add smart phones into the equation, and things change even more. Las Vegas is a multilingual city. I’ve watched people speak into a translation program on their smart phone and have the phone spit out a translation into English so that the person near them can understand them.
Sometimes that translation is word salad. Sometimes it’s close to what was said. Often it’s just what the two people trying to communicate need.
In other words, tools have their uses. We just have to figure out what they are.
The new AI programs in art, writing, and audio are tools. Nothing more and nothing less. Before I go farther, let’s acknowledge that they will create all kinds of problems.
A podcast interview I read this morning (probably thanks to an AI transcription program) between Shamitu Basu, host of Apple News In Conversation, and Nilay Patel, editor in chief of the Verge discussed some of those problems in a way I hadn’t seen it before.
Patel noted that when Microsoft marketed Excel for the first time, “entire floors of accountants at major companies around the world” disappeared. Their jobs went away.
Patel predicts this for copywriters in ad agencies who are producing “midlevel copy” for things they don’t care about. He notes that people in the bullseye of the change experience something frightening. They know their jobs are going to disappear. That’s a horrifying feeling, which is happening all over right now.
But he points out something else, which truly caught my attention. He said,
The way I’ve been thinking about it is that it reduces the cost of making mediocre work to almost zero — and that’s how we need to think about it. ChatGPT does not produce the best text on the internet. It produces acceptable text at a high rate. Midjourney and DALL-E and whatever else do not produce the best art that has ever been made. It produces acceptable art at a high rate for low cost.
The interview talks a lot about “mediocre work.” He expands on it, by talking about some of the changes that will have to happen in the culture as a result of these programs.
But I want to pause at the words “mediocre work” because it really gets at what I’ve been thinking about.
As a Spanish student who has spoken English her entire life, I do not expect my Spanish writing to come anywhere close to my writing in English. I’m trying to get through classes and write good-enough essays to get a grade.
I’m not trying to be a worldclass Spanish writer. I’m doing deliberately mediocre work…partly because that’s all I can do.
However, when it comes to audio, I can do excellent work. In 2021, I took a voiceover class at a studio here in town, partly to get my chops back and partly to learn what I had missed in the past decade or two. (I had missed a lot. I still need (and want) their editing classes.)
After we did our first cold read, the instructor asked me if I had had professional experience, because it showed. Yes, I was out of practice. Yes, I hadn’t used that particular tool (my speaking voice) in a very long time. But I still had (and have) the ability to do high quality voiceover work with the right kind of practice.
Yet, I’m now using AI voices to put out an audio version of this blog. There will be AI versions of some of my books in the near future. I explained a lot of my thinking on this in the first research post on AI Audio, which went live at the beginning of this month.
I’m fully aware that these audio blogs are not up to my professional standards for voiceover. I would change a lot if I were trying to make these better than adequate.
As I said in previous pieces, I just wanted the work out there so that people who want or need a quick way to listen to the blog have something besides the AI voice on their computer or smart speaker to help them listen to this weekly blog.
The responses I got when I put out the first audio blog based on the weekly blog surprised me. I realized that my own experiences as a radio announcer, engineer, and voiceover artist got in the way of my expectations.
Not expectations of the way that audio works, but my expectations of the way that people listen.
A number of people told me they would never listen to AI voices, which I knew going in. Even more had an opinion even though they told me they don’t like podcasts or audiobooks. Sigh. Okay, then.
But some folks truly surprised me. They only listened for less than a minute. Some didn’t even get past the introductory voice and wondered why I had chosen a male voice as my voice. My radio training came in there. I love introductory voices and added one for clarity.
I’m going to be doing a number of audio things in this little blog for clarity’s sake. That’s part of my training. A straight audio version is often confusing. In fact, if you compare the text across, you’ll find some minor tweaks that I made to the audio version because the words as I initially had them worked better on the page.
Then there were the comments that really surprised me. The ones that objected to the pronunciations, and blamed it on the AI. Some of that is the AI voice and its limitations, but some of it is just what you get with audio.
For example, I constantly correct voiceover artists, much to Dean’s annoyance. Someone either mispronounces a word on a commercial or the writing itself is terrible, and there I am making some slight adjustment or commenting on the mispronunciation. It annoys me, particularly when it can be so easily avoided now. (Back in the day, the pronunciation of some words were mysteries; you didn’t have the internet to give you the various pronunciations.)
Then there is the tone of the voice. Or the rhythm of the performance. Those all existed as benefits and problems before AI audio. There’s a voiceover artist on one of my audiobooks whose work I actually loathe, but they have a massive following on Audible, so I’ve sucked it up, even though they mispronounce common names from other cultures and their tone is nasal and grating (to me).
A lot of the problems that people complain about with ChatGPT, for example, are problems that existed before ChatGPT. For a few weeks, every writer I know had ChatGPT write a bio of them, and each bio had things wrong. Some of the things were spectacularly wrong, such as telling one writer that she had died years ago. That’s very science fictional…
However, most of what ChatGPT did were tiny annoying errors. Giving a writer an award they hadn’t been nominated for. Assigning them a book title that had nothing to do with them. Getting their age wrong or the number of books they had published or…or…or…
Everyone complained and pointed to how bad ChatGPT was. But that very week, the local paper had run an article on my neighbor who runs a variety of businesses here in Las Vegas. There was a paragraph in the middle that claimed he ran several businesses that, in reality he was an investor in, not the person who came up with the vision or who manned the desk. That paragraph also claimed a business he’s currently seeking funding for actually existed.
These problems creep up in journalism all the time and always have. Especially if the piece is an interview, which isn’t based on research. The reporter has to have heard the interviewee correctly—and then the reporter needed enough background to understand what the interviewee was telling them.
Reporters do their best to avoid these errors, but everyone is on a deadline, and budgets have been slashed. Most papers no longer have factcheckers, so these problems have multiplied over the years.
Those multiplying errors become truths. I’ve seen articles about me, written before ChatGPT, that have given me awards I’ve never earned and claimed I had written books I had never heard of. A lot of writers, especially in the early post-F&SF years, accepted my successor’s attempt to wipe out my history at the magazine. My Hugo-award winning work there is often left out of any biography about me, partly because of that partially successful attempt to pretend I had not existed.
We’ve seen yet another example of what I’m talking about with the Wired hit piece on Brandon Sanderson, which I will not link to. That piece is filled with misinformation, including a hint that Brandon might suffer from a psychological disease because he writes so much. If the idiot who wrote the hit piece had even bothered to look up said disorder, he would have realized that there was no way that Brandon, a successful New York Times bestselling author, had it. People who have it aren’t writing things that make sense.
Sigh. Grrr.
That hitman writer didn’t do mediocre work. He did terrible work. A chatbot would have done a better job.
But let’s get back to mediocre work, shall we? AI audio, AI writing, AI art are all delivering mediocre work, work that still needs a bit of human intervention to even bring it up to the standards of adequate. I spend 20 minutes or so on the audio getting it to a level that satisfies me.
There are places, though, where mediocre work doesn’t belong. The best way I can illustrate this for you is using an article from The Hollywood Reporter.
At the end of an article published in January, at the height of the ChatGPT terror, The Hollywood Reporter assigned ChatGPT to write some pitches, using a standard trope. X movie meets Y movie. (Die Hard meets 80 For Brady, for example.)
The magazine then printed the pitches and had Big Fish writer, John August, analyze them. It’s worth reading all of the pitches and his comments.
His final analysis is truly telling. He wrote,
These read like the summaries on the top sheet of script coverage. That’s not a knock; I used to be a reader at TriStar, and they’re not always easy to write. As far as the ideas themselves, they’re all taking ‘X meets Y’ far too literally. Screenwriters don’t start with this shorthand; they find their way to it to explain their take.
In other words, these little paragraphs are mediocre. Script coverage might be hard, but it’s not something that anyone tries to do in an artistic way—especially if they want to keep their jobs.
The key sentence is the last one. Screenwriters don’t start with this shorthand. They use the shorthand to explain what they have already done.
What I find amusing about all of this AI terror, particularly in the writing community, are the writers who use ChatGPT to give them ideas. Or to use as a basis for their next project. Or to help them plot.
One writer got very angry at some newbies who decided that ChatGPT would save them time. She wrote that she doesn’t want to save time when she writes. She wants to enjoy what she’s doing.
Of course she does. She’s an award-winning writer with a hell of a following. She entertains herself and thereby entertains others. That’s how it’s done.
This other crap? Those poor writers are using a tool that can barely achieve mediocre to help them be creative.
What she missed—what a lot of the writers who are worrying about their fellow writers are missing—is that these ChatGPT-shorthand writers have no hope for long careers in the first place. These folks are focused externals, like getting help plotting, rather than learning how to do it organically. They want some computer program to help them write, which is like me expecting to sell my Spanish essays to some major literary outlet in Latin America.
It’s that ridiculous.
Why start with something guaranteed to be mediocre? Are you saying your skills aren’t even good enough to be considered adequate? And you’d rather use some kind of shorthand than learn?
Yep, that’s exactly what these folks are saying.
What I’m finding fascinating about the AI audio as I delve deeper into it is that there are some built-in tools that I want to play with, as a creative and an audio engineer.
They’re still not going to make my audio blog rise to the level of art, but they do provide me with opportunities that would either cost me a small fortune to do properly or opportunities that I can’t access without a lot of time and effort.
Multiple voices, for example, are expensive when they’re real people. So the fact that I can use them here without much effort makes me happy.
But doing other things? Like an actual audio play of any quality? That’s not really possible.
And there are many things in the audio world that I don’t want to do with AI. This tool does exactly what I need, what Patel called reducing “the cost of making mediocre work to almost zero.”
My problem with audio is that I would have done work too high quality for a quick and dirty blog post, and wasted hours, if not days, on a fifteen-minute segment. That’s not worth my time.
But what is worth my time is making sure that the audio fans out there get a good-enough product to make it to next week’s blog.
That’s the proper use of a new tool.
Yes, there are still a lot of problems. And I will deal with a few in next week’s blog that creatives need to know about and think about.
But if this post does nothing else, I hope it convinces you to think of these advances in technology as tools to bring work to the level of mediocre. If you want to be better than that, don’t use the tool.
Either do the work yourself or hire it out to someone great.
We will get used to these new tools, just like we got used to Excel spreadsheets and language translation programs. They will become part of our lives.
Right now, we’re in the messy beginning, sorting out all the details. And that might take quite a bit of time.
Speaking of learning how to improve your writing, WMG Publishing is running a Kickstarter which has a lot of great online writing workshops. The Kickstarter is for a starter kit that will introduce you to the first books in ten of Dean Wesley Smith’s series. You’ll get the starter kit with each reward. The kit is also a writing revelation. If you want to learn how to hook people into a great book series, take a look at what Dean is doing.
The Kickstarter ends about 24 hours after this blog goes live on the website, so hurry.
This weekly blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynruschr4e to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: AI And Mediocre Work,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © Can Stock Photo / Amaviael.
When a dead body turns up at the first ever Dinocon, Secret Master of Fandom and Private Detective Spade knows just who might be behind it all: Lucinda Danielle Stanhope who calls herself the Martha Stewart of Science Fiction. Now he just has to prove it.
“Stomping Mad,” by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook through various online retailers here and is included in the collection The Early Conundrums, which is available in ebook and trade paperback here.
Stomping MadA Spade ConundrumKristine Kathryn RuschShe called herself the Martha Stewart of Science Fiction, and she looked the part: Homecoming-queen pretty with a touch of maliciousness behind the eyes, a fakely tolerant acceptance of everyone fannish, and an ability to throw the best room party at any given Worldcon in any given year.
So when a body was found in her party suite, the case came to me. Folks in fandom call me the Sam Spade of Science Fiction, but I’m actually more like the Nero Wolfe: a man who prefers good food and good conversation, a man who is huge, both in his appetite and in his education. I don’t go out much, except to science fiction conventions (a world in and of themselves) and to dinner with the rare comrade. I surround myself with books, computers, and televisions. I do not have orchids or an Archie Goodwin, but I do possess a sharp eye for detail and a critical understanding of the dark side of human nature.
I have, in the past, solved over a dozen cases, ranging from finding the source of a doomsday virus that threatened to shut down the world’s largest fan database to discovering who had stolen the Best Artist Hugo two hours before the award ceremony. My reputation had grown during the last British Fantasy Convention when I—an American—worked with Scotland Yard to recover a diamond worth £1,000,000 that a Big Name Fan had forgotten to put in the hotel’s safe.
But I had never faced a more convoluted criminal mind until that Friday afternoon at the First Annual Jurassic Parkathon, a media convention held in Anaheim.
***The convention was officially called Dinocon I because Crichton’s people, or Spielberg’s people, or some studio’s people wouldn’t give permission to use the Jurassic Park name with a non-sanctioned project. I normally don’t get involved with a media con, especially one held in Anaheim, but this one had a million dollar budget and a state-of-the-art computer system, and I simply couldn’t resist the challenge.
So I was in Ops with most of the folks running the con when the call came through. Ops, for those of you who’ve never seen one, is a hotel function room with most of the furniture removed, replaced with tables covered with computer equipment, too many chairs, and tons of print out paper. Most of the people working Ops look haggard and stressed by the time the convention starts, and many of them are ready to collapse by the time it’s over. So we really didn’t need to hear some security person, young by the sound of him, on the two-way radio:
“Hey, ah, we got a, um, Situation X, here.”
Everyone in Ops snapped to attention. The actual term was a File X—always a pun, everything a pun—and it was only supposed to be used for an extreme emergency.
“Copy that,” Doris, a muscular woman the size of Stallone, said. She headed security, and had at every major con I’d ever worked on. Security is important at sf conventions, perhaps the most important thing, because these cons, as most of you know, aren’t your simple suit-tie-and-briefcase affairs. The big conventions have three levels: the fans, most of whom dress in costume (some medieval barbarians, some Captain Kirk, some space aliens); the pros, most of whom write, act, or somehow work in the science fiction field; the dealers, most of whom sell sf paraphernalia—books, videos, posters, and the ubiquitous Bajoran earrings. Media cons had more earrings, videos, and actors; fewer books, writers, and intellectual discussions. Behind it all is the con-com, the army of people who run the entire shebang, and put out any and all fires along the way. Security deals with most of those: from regular hotel guests who are scared by the werewolf in the elevator to the teenagers who’ve stayed up all night playing the card game Magic, and who suddenly think it fun to pull the fire alarm on the second floor.
Never, in my twenty years of fandom, have we gotten a call for this kind emergency, and never have I heard a security person sound so scared.
“It’s in room 4708. Can someone come here?” The security kid’s voice cracked, confirming my suspicion: he was a volunteer, and he was eighteen at most.
“What’s the nature of the emergency?” Doris asked.
“I don’t think you want me to describe it on an open channel,” the kid said.
“All right, be right there,” Doris said, and left.
We mused about the “Situation” X for a moment. “Maybe,” Ruth, the con chair, said, “he saw a fur bikini for the first time.”
“It’s the masquerade tonight,” John said behind her, and we all laughed. He probably saw a costume, got scared, and decided to call it in. We’d all had that happen before.
“Or maybe it’s pea soup,” said Ben, and I, being most senior on the staff, groaned. I remembered that one, which had now eased into fannish legend. Just after The Exorcist came out, some fans in Baltimore held a room party and served pea soup along with the usual potato chips, cheese, and beer. After midnight, when the crowd got really drunk, someone had the brilliant idea of imitating Linda Blair in the famous vomit sequence. Of course, everyone had to do it, and by the time security arrived, a sea of pea soup was running down the corridor like the Blob without the assistance of the special effects people.
“Please, ghod, anything but that,” I said.
At that moment, the phone rang. Ruth answered, and handed it to me, her tired face filled with confusion and surprise. “It’s Doris,” she said. “For you.”
I slid my chair back and grabbed the phone, feeling as confused as Ruth looked. Doris could have radioed me. That would have been procedure. Maybe something was really up in 4708.
“Yeah?” I said.
“Spade,” she said—my fannish friends had called me Spade since I solved the first case almost twelve years before—“you’ve gotta come up here. Now.”
“What’s going on?” I asked.
“An absolute disaster,” she said, and hung up.
“Why didn’t she use the radio?” Ruth asked.
I shrugged. “I guess she didn’t want anyone else wandering up to the room.” I eased myself out of my special chair, the one that I insist a con-com bring to every convention if they want my services, and with a push of a button, shut down the financial files on Dinocon’s main computer. Then I made my way slowly—because I never hurry—to the fourth floor of the main convention hotel.
Dinocon had 8,000 registered attendees, and it was only Friday afternoon. The convention was scheduled to go through Sunday, and another 2,000 people were expected at the door on Saturday. Most of these folks were already crowding the halls, having conversations with friends they hadn’t seen for a while and trying to discover where that night’s parties would be held. I squeezed my way through—negotiating packed hallways was never easy for a man of my bulk—and made it to the elevator in time to nab the last spot. No one complained, though, as I squooshed people toward the back. Part of that was my con-com badge—regular con attendees knew better than to harass a person in a con-com badge—and part of it was my reputation.
“Hey, Spade!” someone yelled from the back. “You get a piece of that diamond?”
“I don’t charge for my services,” I said, in a gently chiding voice. I made my money years ago as an early employee of Microsoft. I took all my bonuses in stock, and then retired at the age of 31, not as rich as Bill Gates, but rich enough.
“He’s a gentleman detective,” someone else said from the back, and the entire elevator chuckled.
“Imagine,” I said as the doors opened on four, “a gentleman—and a scholar.”
I got off, but not before I heard more giggling as the doors closed. Fannish humor was not the stuff of stand-up routines, but it was usually full of sweet, if not always socially adept, affection.
The room 4708 was on what had been designated by the hotel as a party floor. On these floors, it was okay to have loud conversation all night, to serve beer in rooms, and to talk in the hallways. Other floors, the non-party floors, were for people who actually wanted to sleep during the con, something I hadn’t done in the last thirteen conventions I had attended.
Photocopied 8”x11” signs were taped onto the wallpaper, most of them announcing bid parties for other conventions. The signs on 4708 looked professionally done on slick glossy paper. They announced the first annual Literature Con to be held in an ancient Hilton an hour outside of Manhattan. I stared at the signs for a moment, frowning. Anyone with half a brain knew that most of Dinocon’s attendees weren’t likely to attend a literature con, especially one held all the way across the country. But the posters had another draw besides their slick appearance.
Food.
Come to our bid party, the sign read, and dine at your heart’s content. Award-winning chocolates, Lucinda’s World Famous Chili, and gourmet dishes from the farthest reaches of the Solar System. Come to the party of the convention. You’ll talk about it for the next three lifetimes.
Curiouser and curiouser. Lucinda was Lucinda Danielle Stanhope, also known as the Martha Stewart of Science Fiction. Lucinda hated media cons, thinking that they ruined “pure” science fiction. Pure science fiction, to her, was anything beautifully written with long treatises on science. She thought plot-driven fiction an abomination, and sf on movies and television beneath her notice.
Although she might have changed that opinion, since her current boyfriend, who had started as Science Fiction’s answer to James Joyce, had gotten a job as a story consultant for a major studio. (“A guy has to make a buck,” he said to me at the last Worldcon. “Besides, since Independence Day, everyone is hot for sf properties.”)
She might have changed her opinion, but I doubted it.
I had known Lucinda for a long time. She and I had had a run-in at Con Diego (called Con Digeo by its attendees because of all the typos in the program book) several years back and I had tried, unsuccessfully, to avoid her ever since. Our conversations from that day on had consisted of only two words, uttered in passing.
Asshole, she say.
Bitch, I’d respond.
I sighed, squared my shoulders, and braced myself for the verbal onslaught as I knocked on the door.
Doris answered. She looked grim and shaky. She motioned me inside and closed the door.
The suite smelled of fresh bread, chili, and something foul, something I had never smelled before and wasn’t sure I wanted to smell again. We stood in an entry that led to the bathroom on the left, a main room just before me, and a bedroom on the right. The security kid so skinny he was skeletal and a shade of green I’d never seen outside of a blacklight poster, leaned against a faux Louis the Fourteenth table. He had a hand over his mouth and was taking deep breaths, as if to calm his stomach.
“What is it?” I asked.
Doris pointed toward the main room. I lumbered in, cautiously, not sure what to expect. A chocolate pterodactyl hung from the ceiling and flower arrangements that looked vaguely prehistoric stood on every end-table, along with cute little origami triceratops heads. A human-sized tyrannosaurus rex made entirely out of cheese stood on a circular mirror stand in the center of the room. Crock pots filled with chili bubbled on a table leaning against the wall dividing the main room from the bathroom.
“What —?” I started to ask again, and then I saw her.
She was sprawled on the floor, her left hand resting on the glass double doors leading out to the patio. The doors were closed. I cautiously made my way around the cheese dinosaur and the main table, still in the middle of preparations for the night’s party, and stopped near her apron-clad torso.
There was no doubt it was Lucinda. She wore a linen pantsuit beneath that apron, and in her right hand she held an apple partially julienned into a stegosaurus. It was her head that was the problem.
It had been stomped flat, crushed into unrecognizability. More gray matter than I would have expected spattered the teal carpet, mixed with more blood than I had ever seen in my life. I swallowed twice, hard, not wanting to repeat the pea soup episode and contaminate the crime scene. Then I cautiously made my way back into the foyer.
“You call the cops?” I asked.
“No!” Doris said. “They’d shut us down.”
“Damn straight they’d shut us down,” I said. “We have a murderer on the loose here.”
The kid moaned and headed toward the bathroom.
I grabbed his arm. “Uh-uh,” I said. “Puke in the public restroom. You don’t want to contaminate a crime scene.”
“Too late,” he mumbled, yanked free, and stumbled into the bathroom, kicking the door closed behind him.
“Poor kid,” Doris said. “I’m amazed he has any stomach left.”
“Listen, Doris, we gotta call the cops.” I covered my hand with my sleeve and reached for the black rotary dial on the faux Louis the Fourteenth.
Doris put her hand on mine, forcing the receiver down. “It’s Friday afternoon,” she said. “Think about what that means.”
Eight thousand attendees, all of whom would demand refunds. The hotel, which would sue for breach of contract. The reputation, which would shut down all Los Angeles area conventions for the foreseeable future, not to mention all media cons, not to mention all conventions held in this hotel chain forever.
Millions of dollars, all because Lucinda made someone stomping mad.
“Can’t we at least wait until tomorrow?” Doris asked.
Retching sounds echoed from the bathroom. My stomach rolled in sympathy.
“Tomorrow?” I asked. “Don’t you remember the party signs that are up all over this convention. For tonight? In this room?”
“Can’t we change them to tomorrow night?” she asked. “Then we won’t have to refund, and we won’t be in breach of contract.”
But we would still have the reputation problem, along with another one. “Tampering with a crime scene is illegal, Doris,” I said softly.
“Can’t you solve this?” she asked. “Can’t you solve this before the cops get here?”
“I’ve never done a murder investigation before, Doris,” I said.
“Please,” she asked. “If we can give them a suspect, they won’t shut us down, and Ruth and I can handle the PR problem, at least long enough to save the con.”
“You don’t care that a woman has been trampled in her own hotel room?”
Doris crossed her muscular arms. “You really need to ask me that, Spade? I wouldn’t be so rude as to ask you.”
She could have, though. Because I was upset. Lucinda had her points. She made a mean chocolate soufflé, and she knew more about fannish foods than anyone I had ever met. She also had her moments: the charity auction she ran for literacy at Orycon in the early ‘90s brought in $5,000 more than usual because she browbeat the attendees into spending more money. And she got them to do it by having them buy signed books.
Sometimes I found myself in complete agreement with Lucinda’s arguments.
And that terrified me.
I stared at Doris.
“Will you help us?” she asked.
I sighed. “I won’t tamper with the crime scene, and I will meet with the police when they arrive. You will call them from this room and you will make sure that no one else enters here. You’ll also keep the kid from talking to anyone but me. If I happen to solve this thing before the police arrive, fine. But I won’t go any farther than that. I’m not going to let some murderer run loose because you want to hold a media con honoring one of the lamest movies of all time.”
“The special effects were cool.” The kid had opened the door to the bathroom. He was now a chalk white.
“But the plot sucked,” I said. Then I nodded at Doris. “Call. I’m going to snoop a bit. And don’t leave until I tell you to. Got that?”
She nodded and reached for the phone. I stopped her. “Cover your hands with your sleeves. And don’t touch anything besides that receiver.”
She glared at me, but followed my instructions. I prowled into the bedroom, deciding to talk to the kid after his breath cleared up.
Lucinda, not surprisingly, was a neat freak. She had arrived and unpacked, her clothing hanging on her hangers in the walk-in closet. Each item was separated by tissue paper, and her hats were in boxes on the shelf above. Her shoes were lined up below in neat little rows beneath the matching clothes. She had two wigs on the dressing table, one studded with little plastic dinosaurs—the clear brightly colored kind that bartenders used to put in drinks in the mid-sixties. A silver lamé dress hung from the plant hook in the ceiling. Lucinda had planned to go all out on this party, and it surprised me. She had to be doing a favor for someone. Media cons were beneath her—and while she enjoyed fannish cooking, she hated fannish clothing.
I got back into the foyer as Doris hung up the phone. “I didn’t tell them it was a murder,” she said.
I mentally shook my head. That would be her problem when the cops arrived. It would be better for all of us if I had some idea what had happened.
“Okay, kid,” I said to the security boy, “come into my office and talk to me. And don’t touch anything.”
The kid’s color still hadn’t returned. He followed me into Lucinda’s bedroom and started to close the door.
“Don’t touch,” I said. We went deep into the bowels of the room, and stopped near the bed. I knew that Doris would have trouble hearing us from this spot because I had had trouble hearing her on the phone.
“What’s your name?” I asked.
“Chad,” he said. I raised a single eyebrow, Spocklike. I had never met a kid who worked con security named Chad. Or at least, a kid who worked con security who would admit to being named Chad.
“Okay,” I said, “I need to know: what made you come to this room in the first place?”
He wiped his mouth with the back of his hand. That stomach of his was amazingly weak. “I was by the flyer table—that was my post—when these fans came down the stairs and told me they’d heard a huge pounding on the fourth floor. They took me to their room on three and I heard it too, like something really heavy was going to crash through the floor. Then I came up here. The door was open, and I let myself in. It was really quiet. I called out to see if anyone was here, and then I saw the food. I went in to grab a snack and —”
He burped, then covered his mouth, swallowing hard. “Sorry,” he said.
“It’s all right,” I said. “Do you know who these fans were?”
“Not by name,” he said. “But they have the room below this one.”
And were probably preparing for another party since the room below also had to be a suite. I rubbed my chin in proper detective fashion. I had a conundrum. I need to talk to those fans, but I didn’t want to leave Doris alone in the room. Nor did I want anyone else to know what had happened to Lucinda.
Then I realized it didn’t matter. Doris had been in the room without me already. I had investigated, and I knew how things looked. I had seen everything but the bathroom, and that could be remedied.
I took the kid back to the foyer. “Wait here,” I said, and peered into the bathroom. The kid had already contaminated the crime scene—several times—but there didn’t seem to be much to see. The bathtub was still maid-spotless and the counter had Lucinda’s make-up and nothing else. The toilet seat was up, one of the towels was askew, and otherwise everything looked fine. It didn’t even smell as bad as I thought it would.
“Okay,” I said as I emerged. “Let’s find those fans. You wait here, Doris, and don’t touch anything.”
“Don’t worry,” she said, looking faintly annoyed at the suggestion.
The kid and I slipped into the hallway. The con was filling up. Two women wearing belly dancer skirts and midriff tops, conversed about the proper navel jewel. Five teenage boys compared tattoos. Three grown men, in Klingon boots and armor, adjusted each other’s forehead ridges.
The kid and I took the stairs.
The third floor was filled with people in dinosaur costumes. Some were cheap Halloween masks, while others were full-bore papier-mâché or plastic. The costumes looked heavy, they looked hot, and they smelled of glue. I stared at them, mostly at the feet, wondering what kind of pressure a person would need to drive those hard plastic soles through a skull and crush it.
Then we were in front of 3708. The kid knocked on the door. His hand was shaking.
It was opened by a slender woman whose black hair formed perfect Louisa May Alcott ringlets around her face. She wore a lavender satin shirt with purple satin pants, and the outfit somehow looked perfect on her. Her convention badge was clipped to a tiny piece of cardboard inside her shirt’s high pocket, so as not to ruin the satin.
“Hi,” she said, looking a bit confused.
“Security,” the kid said, glancing at me. “Remember? You asked about the big stomping?”
“Oh, yeah.” She was staring at me. Her eyes were lavender, like the shirt. I’d never seen eyes like that in person before. Only in photographs of Elizabeth Taylor. “Who’re you?”
“I’m from Ops,” I said. “Mind if we come in?”
“Why?” She was asking the kid.
“Because when I went upstairs,” he said, “I found —”
I kicked him. He shut up.
“He found that he had a few more questions to ask you,” I said. “Mind if we come in.”
“No,” she said. “I guess not.”
She got out of our way, and we stepped into the foyer. It exactly matched the suite above, only here the carpet was brown. Two men sat in the suite’s living room. They looked vaguely familiar. They stood as they saw us come in.
“Something wrong?” the first one asked.
He was tall and muscular—those fakey kind of muscles that come from too much health club, and too much low-fat food. His shirt was unbuttoned below the navel, revealing a washboard stomach, and his bare feet looked manicured. His companion wore ripped jeans and a Star Trek t-shirt, but unless I missed my guess, his hair had been permed.
Interesting look, for fans. It looked a little too Hollywood, a little too put together, for my tastes. Maybe these folks were slumming.
“You guys with the convention?” I asked.
“What’s this all about?” T-Shirt asked. He had his hands on his hips. Same fakey muscles, and he didn’t look as if he had ever cracked a book. But, I reminded myself, this was a media con. Folks here didn’t have to crack books, even though most of them did.
“Of course we’re with the convention,” the woman said, and tugged gently on her badge as if to prove it.
“What’s your interest?” I asked. “Filking?”
“Excuse me,” Manicured asked. His face flamed and he looked insulted.
“Fill-king,” the kid said, “not fucking.”
Interesting comment, I thought, but I didn’t look at him. “Pipe down, Chad,” I said. “What are you guys doing at the con?”
“Anyone can come,” the woman said, apparently realizing that my questions had more importance than the guys were giving them credit for. “Right?”
“Of course,” I said, “but usually people have special reasons for attending. What are yours?”
“We like dinosaurs,” T-Shirt said.
“Fascinating,” I said in my best Spock voice. No one laughed, even though most fans usually did. My best Spock voice was pretty damn good. “So what’s your favorite dinosaur? A plugosaurus or a brontodacdyl?”
“All of ‘em,” T-Shirt said.
“Hmmm,” I said. “Hear you had some noise problems.”
“Yeah, man, sounded like weird pounding upstairs,” Manicured said. “Like someone was trying to punch a hole in the floor.”
“Sounds serious,” I said. “Will someone move that chair over here?” I pointed to a square wooden chair that seemed to be the sturdiest thing in the room. T-Shirt moved the chair to the place I pointed to, right next to the balcony doors.
“Spot me, Chad, will you?” I asked as I climbed up.
“Ah, um, ah, you might want me to do that,” he said.
“No need,” I said, even though the chair was groaning under my weight. I reached up and removed the ceiling panel. Gobs of dust and dirt rained on me, and I had to clear a spider web, but after that I had a pretty good glimpse of the space between the ceiling and the floor above.
“Looks normal,” I said, and to my surprise, it did. I put the tile back. “You guys are safe.”
“That’s it?” the woman asked. “That’s all? It sounded wretched up there.”
“It was,” Chad said. I braced myself on his shoulder and squeezed as I got down. It shut him up again.
“That’s it,” I said cheerfully. “I hope you have a good con.”
“Ah, thanks,” T-Shirt said. He was frowning at me.
The kid and I left. The dino costumes flooded the hall. The newer ones looked even more realistic than the earlier ones. Especially the Spielbergian velociraptors. All terrifyingly icky except for the guy wearing blue jeans and a tie-dye brontosaurus head. And the inevitable tot dressed as Barney.
One glance at the elevator told me we weren’t going back to the fourth floor that way. Too crowded. It also meant the cops wouldn’t come up very quickly when they arrived.
“Where to now?” the kid asked.
I didn’t answer. I was feeling pretty annoyed with him. Pretty annoyed with the whole thing, really. I wanted to get back to my Ops computer with its lovely numbers and forget I had ever gotten involved with this detecting business.
Even if I was good at it.
We took the stairs and I was puffing by the time we reached the fourth floor. I hadn’t had this much exercise in weeks. And I was moving faster than I liked.
Most of the dino costumes were on the third floor. Regular con-goers littered the fourth. None of them looked like the three ringers downstairs.
I shave-and-a-haircut knocked on 4708. Doris answered immediately. “What took you so long?”
I didn’t answer. As I came in, I asked, “Did Lucinda know I was coming to Dinocon?”
“How should I know?” Doris asked.
I glared at her.
She sighed, exasperated. “Probably. If she was looking. You would have been hard to miss since your name was in the con-com listing in all the progress reports. Why?”
I had my suspicions. I made my way back into the suite’s main room.
“Hey!” the kid said. “What’re you doing?”
His voice had gotten increasingly shrill. I ignored him. I made my way to the body, and, just as I remembered, the floor didn’t sag under my considerable weight.
I knelt beside the body. The gray matter and blood were drying in a perfect arch.
“Hey!” the kid yelled. “You said no tampering.”
“Grab him, Doris,” I said through my teeth. He was getting on my nerves. This whole thing was.
I grabbed the right wrist, dislodging the julienned stegosaurus, and felt—plastic. Soft, lifelike, fake plastic.
“Bitch,” I mumbled. I half expected the crushed dummy to mumble “asshole” in return. Then, louder, I said, “Doris, did you call 911?”
She didn’t answer. I turned. She was frowning at me.
“Doris?”
She flushed. “No,” she said. “I called the regular line. I wanted to give you as much time as possible.”
Her caution had worked to our advantage. “Call and cancel,” I said. “Then break that kid’s arm if he doesn’t tell you where Lucinda is.”
“Lucinda —!”
“Just do it.” First time I’d ever understood the sense of a Nike ad.
She twisted the kid’s arm up behind his back. Within seconds, he was screaming, “Executive Suite! Executive Suite!”
I got up and walked over to him. “Key,” I said.
He handed me a specially marked executive floor key. “Come on, Doris,” I said. “Keep a good grip on this kid and commandeer us an elevator.”
She did exactly as she was told.
***On the way up, I explained the whole thing, and the kid wisely said nothing, confirming all my suspicions. I was trying to contain my anger, because this thing had just become personal.
And to think I would have mourned the bitch if that had truly been her on the floor below.
You see, the plan was simple: the execution was hard. Lucky for Lucinda that her boyfriend had his new job in Hollywood and even luckier for her that most special effects guys are also sf nerds. Ironic that she needed media people to tamper with a media con. But Lucinda had always been a bit dim when it came to irony.
And, apparently, detail, at least non-food related detail.
First there was the fannish clothing. No matter what kind of theme party Lucinda gave, she never, ever dressed in fannish clothes. No wigs decorated with little plastic dinosaurs, no silver lamé dress. She might have consented to work a media con, but she would never have given up her stylishly proper clothing. She planned the perfect media party, all right, down to the clothes, forgetting that she would never, ever wear those clothes because, of course, she didn’t plan to.
But that wasn’t the only detail that bothered me. The three “fans” on the floor below had been extras in a straight-to-video sf release that I’d been watching at home a few nights before the con. I would have made them as non-skiffy folk anyway. All science fiction fans—media and lit alike—know the difference between a real dinosaur and a made-up one.
And then there was Chad, clearly another actor for hire. Except he overdid the vomit bit, and the bathroom smelled as if the maid had just left. Lucinda probably hadn’t counted on the strength of my sniffer.
But she had counted on me. In fact, I had been the center of her plan. Without me, it wouldn’t have worked. She knew that I knew better than to tamper with a crime scene, no matter how great the temptation. She knew that I had a healthy respect for the authorities and that I would insist on cops being present.
And she knew that the cops would see this for the hoax it was. She would appear at the right moment, blame the convention for overreacting to her little party, piss off the cops just enough to get the whole con shut down. The hotel chain would have been angry, the attendees would have demanded refunds, and the whole cascade effect that Doris had foreseen when she first saw that body would have occurred. Media cons, not just in LA, but all over the country would have suffered, and possibly died.
Lucinda’s little stunt would have caused more damage than the murder. It was sabotage, served cold.
***When we reached the executive suite, Doris made the kid open the door. Lucinda saw him, stood up, and cooed. She was dressed for her act in a white sheath that accented her lightly tanned skin and golden hair.
When she saw us, her eyes widened.
“You bitch,” Doris said, blowing my line and letting go of the kid. He started to back away, but I shoved him forward and closed the door behind us.
“Back off, Doris,” I said. “She’s mine. There won’t be any cops, Lucinda. You won’t ruin this convention.”
“I’m going to see that you’re banned from cons forever. I’m going to make sure that your name is taken out of the Fannish Directory. I’m going to —”
“For what? For a little party I planned to throw for some friends?” Lucinda asked. “Don’t you think it rather cute? I do.”
“You —”
Doris lunged for her, and I caught her, staggering a bit under her power. The kid bee-lined for the bathroom, fear making his intentions real this time.
“Go to Ops,” I said to Doris. “Tell them everything is fine. I can take it from here.”
“I’m going to get you,” Doris said, but she listened to me. She knew as well as I did that strange things happened at sf conventions, and that there was no proving malicious intent here.
Knowing about it was something else.
“Misunderstandings are so tragic, Doris,” Lucinda said, blinking her blue eyes guilelessly.
Doris growled and disappeared out the door. I stood in front of Lucinda. “Media cons aren’t your style.”
She smiled. It was sweet as rhubarb pie. “They’re not yours either.”
“I don’t see anything wrong with people having fun. I’m a bit more open-minded than you, Lucinda. I believe people can enjoy reading and watching movies. I believe there’s room in fandom for both.”
“You’re so naive,” she said. “These cons are so anti-literature. They appeal only to the ignorant. People who don’t understand real science, or real science fiction.”
“I think people who think they guard pure science fiction may not understand real science or real science fiction either,” I said pointedly.
“Good god,” she said, “a philosophical discussion when I have a party to finish.”
“It seems strange to me that you’d put on a party here, Lucinda.”
She shrugged. “I thought I’d give these people the opportunity to come to a lit-con and see what they were missing.”
“So kind of you,” I said.
She smoothed her dress. “We all do what we can in the circumstances provided.”
At that moment, I almost told her what tripped her up. I almost told her that it was her lack of scientific knowledge, her lack of understanding of forensic science that had destroyed her. First, the splatter had been too pretty, too uniform. Second, and more importantly, the type of force it took to stomp out someone’s brains would have caused damage to the plywood floor. Damage someone of my weight would have felt in loose boards or groaning wood.
But I didn’t. Why give her the ammunition? She might try again someday.
“Am I excused?” she asked brightly.
“There is no excuse for you, Lucinda,” I said in my best fannish manner, and moved out of her way.
***The bane of the non-licensed investigator is that we have no real authority. We can’t arrest. Worse yet, people with authority often look down their noses at us.
So we are forced to take some matters into our own hands.
Lucinda, misguided as she was, was clever. Who could prove that the panic the kid, Doris, and I felt was anything more than a product of our own imaginations? She would say that she had planned a perfect party, and we had nearly ruined it.
In fact, that night, she did carry off the party with full aplomb. She did change the victim from her clone to that of a lawyer, in keeping with Jurassic Park (the movie) tradition, and she did pour ice in the bathtub, but those were the only changes she made. The party was the hit of the convention, and became the talk of sf—both media- and literature-oriented—for years to come. It was, in its own way, the Woodstock of science fiction. Eventually everyone who was anyone claimed they had been there, even if they had been clear across the country at the time.
Everyone who was anyone except me.
You see, I was in Ops, checking the computer records. We had an unexplained power failure just as I was transferring Lucinda’s credit card information from her con file into an active file so that we could bill her account. Unfortunately, the accident caused blips in her credit record that cascaded down the system and destroyed her credit rating for the next year. She had to defend and deny and repair, all of which took time away from cons and con parties, and fandom.
And somehow she got it in her pretty little head that this would happen again if she ever attempted to sabotage—even accidentally—a major convention again.
Misunderstandings are so tragic.
But we all do what we can in the circumstances provided.
Stomping Mad: A Spade ConundrumCopyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Return of the Dinosaurs edited by Mike Resnick and Martin H. Greenberg, Daw Books, 1997Published by WMG PublishingCover and layout copyright © 2023 by WMG PublishingCover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Milosluz/Dreamstime, Cornelius20/Dreamstime
WMG has put together a starter kit for Dean’s fiction. You can get the first story/book in ten of his series through the Kickstarter at every award level. I love these books, particularly the Cold Poker Gang series (which is WMG’s bestselling series) for mystery fans and The Earth Protection League for sf fans.
If you already love some of the series, you can find the reward that allows you to buy every novel in that series.
Or, if you’re a writer, take a peek at the workshop rewards. They’re amazing and only available through this Kickstarter.
But hurry! You only have a few days left to get the starter kit. Click here to get yours.
To get a free A.I. audio version of this blog, click here.
I did not expect to spend the past two days working on Patreon.
I mean, I planned on updating my Patreon page sometime in the future. As I wrote in the Year in Review post about advertising, much of what I had been doing had grown stale. I knew that, with the changes in the social media environment, I was going to have to up my game.
I planned on revamping this website and my Patreon page, and on doing more with my newsletter.
Any day now.
Okay, that’s not fair. Because I am trying to figure out how best to configure the website. It’s becoming a priority, because I really hate this style, which dates from 2015.
I plan to do most of the site myself, because the last time I hired someone else, the things I liked about the website diminished and the things I hate about it increased. Not to mention that we used some program over and above Word Press which turned out to be unwieldy and to this day, we’re still finding bits of code from that redesign.
I’m not doing that again.
So I’ve been niggling at it. Maybe I’m a bit gunshy. I feel gunshy. And I’m time limited.
But I’m excited about the AI audio and I’m having fun with the program. On Thursday of last week, when the previous blog went live, I experimented with other features of the Murf.ai system. I planned to write a post about all I’ve learned, and some realizations that occurred when my first audio blog went live.
First, though, I figured I’d better add a tier on my Patreon page for audio. I was still undecided about what or if I would charge people for getting early access to the audio blog. Then I realized I have a tier for early access to the text blog, so I need something similar for the audio blog.
However, I figured, there will be less content with the audio blog, because I probably won’t do any of the Patreon exclusives or the short notes in audio. So I’d charge less. (It also gets me off the hook if I simply don’t have time to do an early access audio blog during one week.)
I dug into the back of my Patreon page for the first time since I set it up. And wow, did I learn things.
First, I hadn’t realized (or maybe hadn’t remembered) that Patreon had grandfathered in my price structure because I was a founding member of Patreon.
Yes, my account is that old. And I haven’t updated it since I set it up.
I have found that annoying for years now, but I had always had the revamp on the backburner. What I didn’t realize was just how old some of the materials were.
What annoyed me most was the lovely picture I had used as a header. It was of a cat who had died a year after that photo in horrible circumstances, so every time I saw her, I felt sad.
Then I had an introductory video that I had worked on at least eight years ago, with another cat in the center of it. Sir Galahad of Kitten left us in 2017, which tells you how long ago that was as well.
I put up a new header and deleted the video. To add a new video, I would have to leave the grandfathered-in pricing structure and since I don’t plan to do a lot of videos, I decided against a new video.
But I had to rewrite the section on why I’m doing Patreon. And that’s where the learning came in.
When I had set up my Patreon account, this kind of crowdfunding was new. Yes, indeedy do, I was an early adapter here, and I had felt hugely uncomfortable about it.
I was asking for money in a way I had never done so before. I do ask at the bottom of each post, but that felt like public-radio fundraising to me. (It still does.) I’m used to that. I worked for a listener-sponsored radio station for almost a decade, and then I did fundraising for the local NPR station in Eugene until I simply couldn’t handle their internal politics (and their rinky-dink approach [at the time anyway] to fundraising).
I can do on-air fundraising in my sleep. Writing up a little fundraising pitch at the end of a blog post was and is not hard.
Writing up why someone should support my blog on a subscription basis was hard for me when I first did it. I was a little too apologetic. I also had no idea what I was doing.
I set up some things that really fit with what I was writing at the time. Eight or so years ago, I was still blogging about both traditional and indie publishing. I did a lot of investigative work about royalty payments from traditional publishers. I did a lot of other behind-the-scenes traditional publishing investigation as well.
That was costly and time-consuming. I had a large readership of traditionally published writers whom I was scaring to death. But I was also giving them tools to get out of their traditional publishers with copyrights intact and tools that would help them fire their agents and tools that helped them hire accounting firms.
More than one traditionally published writer sent me a very big donation because I had saved them tens of thousands of dollars.
I figured that might continue, so I had upper level tiers on my Patreon page of $50, $100, and $500. Folks didn’t take the $100 or $500 level. Instead, they continued to give me big donations through PayPal.
I hadn’t learned how to do this kind of crowd-funding yet…and then, it changed.
A lot.
Over the years, not only did my content shift, but so did the culture. People got used to donating small amounts to creators in return for some kind of steady reward.
I knew that, but I didn’t really think much about it. I had my backers, and I fulfilled my part. I had fun with Patreon, but mostly on the content level.
I hadn’t realized how much the tier level had dated.
Until I started upgrading.
Then I learned something about myself and about crowdfunding.
Back when I set all of this up, the tools for Patreon and for what I wanted to do were very different. Patreon required that we offer something for each tier. Most of my colleagues were offering a short story per month or a personal phone call or something I’m simply not set up to do.
I hate phone calls. I hate doing Zoom meetings or webcasting. I avoid those things in real life, even among friends and family, so I really didn’t want to offer that as a reward on my Patreon page.
I don’t want anyone in my fiction. I can’t release things early because of my writing method. I write fiction out of order. I’m currently working on a Fey novel that I had initially thought was the first in a subseries. What it turned out to be was part of a sketch for several books. The section I’m writing now is the third book.
So offering early access was hard. I still write short fiction for traditional publishers, and my contracts want the stories to be original, so I can’t offer early access to those either.
Those things haven’t changed in eight years.
My decision back then was to offer early access to the blog. I also set up an advisory board. I was envisioning it as a group of traditionally published writers who would help me by telling me their experiences in the increasingly complex world of traditional publishing.
I also, at the upper tiers, offered early access to the nonfiction books that I wrote because of the blog. My phrasing was revelatory—at least to me. Books published by WMG Publishing only. Any books published by a different publisher would not qualify.
Nowadays, I don’t submit books to any traditional publisher. Traditional publishers don’t offer anything I can’t do myself through WMG. And the traditional contracts are so awful that I would never consider signing one. (Yes, I would try to negotiate, but most of the terms these days—even for bestsellers—are non-negotiable.)
At the upper tiers, I had to be really vague. An extra digital surprise. Or some gifts. I ended up giving a lot of Storybundle codes to the upper-tier people, because that was all I had to give.
Everything has changed, from my attitudes to the things that are available.
Attitude first. As I mentioned above, crowdfunding has changed. Readers often give small amounts on a regular basis to the creators they love in exchange for some kind of benefit. It has become part of the culture.
I do it as well.
As a result, I am no longer uncomfortable with it. It’s part of who we creators are now. We have options and opportunities, and we need to take advantage of them.
Because I no longer help traditionally published writers with any of the things I used to do, I no longer get those one-time large donations to the blog. Instead, if I try to help a traditional writer these days, I get attacked on social media for being “old” or “out of touch” or “unwilling to understand the real world.”
Okay, then.
Honestly, I figure if someone still wants a traditional book publishing credit, they either work in academia and need that credential for their real job which is teaching, or they are unwilling to learn business and will never understand why their desire for a traditionally published book will probably tank the writing career they’ve dreamed of.
These are not my people, not my readers, and not the writers I want to talk to.
I like business-minded writers who want to learn as much as they can about the ever-changing indie publishing business.
So, with that in mind, I deleted most of the language that had to do with traditional publishing. I deleted the advisory board. I deleted the upper level tiers.
I added benefits that I couldn’t have provided eight years ago. Those benefits include: one-time discounts on our direct-sales store, wmgbooks.com, for most tiers; a continuing discount on the store for the highest tier; and for two tiers, a discount on our online workshops through Teachable.com.
Neither the direct store nor Teachable existed when I started my Patreon page. We did do online workshops back then, but we had cobbled together our own website, and offering discounts was a heck of a burden.
It’s not now.
Also, A.I. audio did not exist, so offering audio wasn’t a choice either, unless I recorded it. I didn’t have time.
The only things that remain the same are the early access to the blog itself, and the books that come out of the blog. Oh, and the exclusive content, which I’m having a lot more fun with.
Patreon got easier to use as well. Setup is a click of a button here, a choice there. Eight years ago, Patreon was little more than a website with some design and some financial features. Now there’s a lot to learn, and a lot that made my life easier.
I redesigned the page in less time than it took to build it. That was a plus.
Patreon always asked for goals, and I had no real idea how I wanted to do them. I had some listed, but they felt forced.
Now I have a single goal—300 backers on Patreon—and when I hit that, I’ll offer another cool discount to all the backers. If I need another goal, then I’ll come up with another idea. Depending on how long it takes to hit this first goal (if I ever do), then I might have even more tools to build with on Patreon.
So…here I am, writing a blog about redesigning my Patreon page instead of writing another A.I. audio blog. That initial blog that sent me down this path is half done and will probably be the next one, unless something truly strange happens.
I did not expect the redesign to be a blog topic, but the differences in tech and attitude between the year I set up the page and the year I redesigned it are amazing. I feel like I’ve moved from a Model T to a 1960s Corvette. It’s still not the computerized tech we have in modern cars, but I have a hunch that’s coming.
I have to admit, I also feel really good that I moved something major off my list. That doesn’t happen very often.
I still have the website to rebuild, but that’s next week’s problem. Or the week after that.
Right now, I’m going to bask in the personal victory, and reflect a bit more on just how far we’ve all come.
Rather than do the usual push on a relevant online workshop as well as a nonfiction book, let me just urge you to take a look at the new Patreon page.
Then, if you feel like joining others who have supported the blog there, feel free.
Otherwise, if you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynruschr4e to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: Patreon Changes And Me,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch.
To cope with his wife’s death, Petras must come to terms with the reality of it. He needs to see her body, visit the place where she died…understand why she died.
But the closer Petras gets to the place Hedie died, the more questions he faces—questions that might destabilize everything Petras thinks he knows.
“The City’s Edge” by Hugo Award-winning author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook through various online retailers here and is included in the collection Colliding Worlds, Vol. 1, which is available in ebook, trade paperback, and hardcover here.
The City’s EdgeKristine Kathryn RuschiPetras Kiyune stood on the platform his wife had built years ago, and looked out over the destruction. Beside him, Ahmed Quinde breathed audibly, even though he had seen this mess before.
Petras hadn’t, not outside of vids and holo-reports—media coverage so inadequate that he couldn’t quite grasp that the reporters had been talking about this as if it were a minor setback.
It was the loss of everything.
The landscape reminded Petras Kiyune of a child’s drawing of a desert—brown dirt against a purplish sky. The dirt extended forever, sometimes in mounds, sometimes choppy, always looking disturbed. No sign of life anywhere—not little plants scrabbling to hold on against a harsh environment, not trails left by creatures he couldn’t quite remember.
He’d been to a dozen different deserts on three different planets, all in the company of Hedie, as she scouted locations that only she could see in that magnificent mind’s eye of hers. Those deserts had an orderly look, as if the winds that blew across their sands had a map to follow, one that told the breezes where each grain of sand belonged.
Even the plants had looked like they belonged to that order—the sagebrush of a white sand high desert on Tanbul, the blue spiky cacti of the low flat desert on Milbztr, and the alabaster rock weed that gave the dunes of Vunplydo’s desert their unique texture.
Those deserts looked like they’d been created as part of the plan of a god or an almighty engineer, like Hedie herself.
This looked like the disaster it was.
The ground was uneven, torn up. The dirt was multicolored—not sand at all—but different hues, from different levels. He’d seen the strata years ago, as Hedie had bent over and scraped at the side of a hill with her pocket knife, revealing light brown dirt on top, whitish dirt in the middle, and almost black dirt beneath.
Now, the white dirt scattered on top of the black dirt, which gathered in clumps on parts of the brown dirt. At least, when he looked directly forward. When he looked to his left, the pattern was reversed, and when he looked to his right, the dirt didn’t look like dirt at all. It looked like gigantic mudballs, rolled by a giant.
He rubbed a hand over his face, the imagery that his brain clung to striking him for the first time: a child’s drawing. A giant. The twins’ bedrooms flashed through his mind—Cordilla’s, with her geometric sketches affixed to the screen wall, and Rodrigo’s, with the giants looming like friendly aliens from his screen wall.
Petras closed his eyes for a moment, refusing to think about the last two weeks in those rooms, wishing his children got along well enough that he could convince them to sleep in his room, where he could hold them close, just for one night.
He needed it more than they did.
“You okay?” Ahmed, who was now the chief engineer of this nonexistent project, looked at Petras with concern. Ahmed had made it clear that he had brought Petras here under duress.
Petras almost never used his connections as the Permanent Prime Minister’s son to benefit himself. Most people didn’t even realize that PPM Shayla Kiyune and Akida University Professor Petras Kiyune were related. There were more than enough unrelated Kiyunes in Akida to make the last name unremarkable.
Petras glanced at Ahmed. He was a slight man, bent by the events of the past two weeks, his skin grayish now, the shadows beneath his eyes a purple that matched the sky. Petras didn’t need to add to the man’s burden. Petras knew firsthand the kind of anguish that Ahmed was going through. Hedie had been going through the same anguish when he met her, shortly after the first project she had apprenticed on, the Nbrediss Island Chain bridges, collapsed overnight.
Petras was going through his own anguish right now, but it was different—old as time, and new and raw and almost unbearable.
“You don’t have to see it, you know,” Ahmed said. “In fact, I would advise against it. There’s almost nothing there. It won’t help you—”
“It’ll help me,” Petras said. But he had a realization. Maybe Ahmed was telling him to walk away because Ahmed wanted to walk away.
The landscape was nearly unbearable to look at, especially considering what it had been just a month ago. Clear sky bridges over matching roads beneath, the skeletons of buildings rising around all of it, water splashing through as both decoration and lifeblood. Hedie had been particularly proud of the waterfalls. She had designed them to stop if someone touched them—the water literally froze in place with so much as a brush against a living being, animal or human, clothed or unclothed—only to start with the exact same motion the moment the touch was removed.
The lights beneath the waterfalls turned them whatever color the city leaders wanted. She kept the water a permanent light blue, with just a bit of yellowish light dancing on the surface, like those images of Earth lakes on brilliant sunny days. She had seen Earth lakes; Petras had not.
He’d spent his entire life before he knew her inside the Caado System, watching as his mother groomed and maneuvered herself into the Permanent Prime Minister position, realizing that he could follow the same track and maybe have more than a 65% chance of becoming PPM when she died, and then rejecting it all for—as his mother called it—a mundane life, filled with trivial things.
He thought of it as a good and comfortable life, filled with family and friends and the best luck possible.
Until Hedie died. Until the unfinished city vanished.
Until everything he knew turned inside out, upside down, and threatened to never right itself again.
iiPetras had slept through the disappearance. All of Akida had, or so it seemed. And he thought that odd.
The domed city—the project Hedie was in charge of—hadn’t even been close to finished. The most unusual part, the fact that it could pull itself away from the planet and travel elsewhere if needed, had been assembled but not activated (except in pre-completion tryouts).
At least, that was what Hedie had told him.
When he woke up, in the chair beside Rodrigo’s bed after reading to the boy, Petras had staggered to bed, noted that Hedie hadn’t come back yet, and thought it strange.
But nothing unusual that night had awakened Petras except the crick in his neck from sitting improperly. And when he went back over the in-apartment security vids, he saw nothing.
He, of course, had been looking to see if Hedie had come home, and maybe ended up somewhere else in the building. He hadn’t seen her.
Only later, only when the media reports kept repeating how no one had realized that the domed city had taken off on its own, did he find the silence around the city’s disappearance odd.
It should have been loud—the city, ripped from its moorings, the engines starting up, the peal of metal against metal.
Hedie couldn’t have been wrong, could she? Had the domed city been hooked up, its flight capability on full?
He had wondered, until he heard others wonder the same thing. And then the rumors—that no one was seeing the city in orbit. Or in space. Or anywhere nearby.
That had to be impossible.
But the person he would have asked, the person who should have known, the person who had designed the entire mechanism, was dead. About the point he would have gone to her, asking what was going on, was the point he bundled the children off to his mother’s because he had nowhere else to take them while he went deep into Akida to identify his wife’s body.
iii“I need to see where they found her,” Petras said quietly. “I understand, though, if you can’t bear it.”
He clasped his hands behind his back. Even though he and Ahmed stood on the platform several meters above the destruction, there was no wind. When Petras and Hedie had looked at the site, years ago now, the wind had seemed constant.
Petras stared at the devastation, not entirely understanding it, and not willing to look away.
“No, no, I’m not—I will take you there.” Ahmed’s tone was gracious, as if they were at a dinner party. His body remained bent, though, his gaze not on Petras, but on the vast dirt-filled emptiness in front of them. “I need to walk every centimeter of this place.”
That, Petras knew, was an exaggeration. The domed city his wife had designed and had been overseeing was going to cover more than 1,000 square kilometers of land. It would have provided so much more room than that, though, existing on several levels, each with its own tiny dome.
Petras did not have the kind of imagination that Hedie had. He had initially envisioned the city as if it were like the ancient nesting dolls his mother had received from an Earth envoy when Petras was a boy—dolls inside of dolls inside of dolls, until the smallest was too tiny to hold yet another doll.
But Hedie had laughed when he described that image to her. More like half-domes, she had said, one resting on top of the other. But with the illusion of a full dome.
He hadn’t understood it until the first two segments were built. She had taken him into the ground-level dome and made him look up. He had seen a rounded sky, that showed the slightly purple light of Akida midday to great advantage. Then she had taken him to the next level—above the ground-level dome—and the sidewalk he stood on was flat. The dome above looked rounded, though—another rounded sky with the same purple light of midday.
An illusion more or less. She had explained the science and technology behind it; he had understood none of it.
Just like he had understood little of the government’s need for detachable cities on Akida. The entire Caado System was stabilized, and nothing threatened it from the outside. Even the aliens that lived throughout the sector were peaceful. So why worry about attacks from space?
His mother had eventually explained it in a way he could understand, even if he didn’t entirely like it.
The worry that had led to funding such a large project on such a massive scale wasn’t an attack from space. The worry was an attack from within. And when Petras had pooh-poohed that, pointing out that there had been no real attacks in any of the major cities in the entire Caado System, his mother had talked about attacks thwarted and ambitions curtailed, and things he didn’t even want to consider.
His mother had told him (not his wife, not the planner and builder, but his mother, the PPM) that the domed city’s divisions—its inner half-domes—would provide their own filters. Groups had already applied for permits to have entire levels to themselves. They would set costs and they would set the rules, and they would ensure that no other group from the outside would ever take up permanent residence on their level.
He had found it creepy. His mother had tried again, reminding him that the building he and his family lived in had its own code. Only professors with Akida University could even apply for residence there, and only tenured professors could buy their own apartments.
He had thought nothing of that at the time. Other parts of Akida had the same restrictions—covenants in neighborhoods, building codes—all of it designed to keep some families out while letting others in.
He had known, though, that such things created unrest. The idea that the segments would exist on a land space of 1,000 square kilometers had bothered him, particularly with domes stacked on top of domes inside a larger dome until Hedie had taken him on a tour of the partially finished city itself.
Don’t worry, she had told him. No one will feel left out. And there will be few differences to notice.
He hadn’t believed that either, until he had walked through the first two half-domes. They were the same. You couldn’t even tell that one was raised higher than the other.
Each level seemed like a different version of the same city—a purer, fresher, more beautiful version of Akida itself.
And Akida would empty into Hedie’s city once Hedie’s city was done.
Or would have emptied into Hedie’s city, had Hedie’s city not disappeared.
His mind couldn’t comprehend that the domed city had been here one moment, and in flight the next. He couldn’t comprehend how 1000 square kilometers had become dirt overnight.
He couldn’t comprehend life without Hedie.
“There’s no need for you to walk this part of the city with me, Ahmed,” Petras said, instantly regretting the use of the word city. “I’m sure you’ve seen it before. Just send me in the right direction.”
“I can’t,” Ahmed said, his voice a little strangled. “You have to be accompanied.”
“Watch me from here,” Petras said. “I’m sure that will fulfill your requirements.”
He nearly said, Hedie bent the rules all the time, but managed to stop himself. That probably wasn’t something any of them wanted to think about right now, particularly Ahmed. The poor man had to keep functioning, despite the deaths and destruction.
Just like Petras did.
Petras could have avoided this moment as well. He could have stayed home with his grieving children, cocooned them in their still-comfortable life, dealt with the death benefits and the funerals and the media, the sideways looks and the sadness from friends, but he didn’t want to.
He couldn’t, really. He had to be out here.
Other people didn’t understand, and he couldn’t really explain it, not to them, not to himself. The best he could do was this: Hedie traveled so much and was away from home so often that he had to see her remains or he would forever believe she would return to him. She had made him promise that he would do that, years and years ago, just after they married.
She had known about his powerful imagination, so different from hers. His was filled with fables and histories and lore; hers was filled with structures and right angles and big creations that rose from nothing.
That their twins had come out the same way had not surprised him, although it had startled her. Their daughter, who built forts with her dollies, and their son, who pretended those same dollies were magic creatures—those children weren’t replicas of Hedie and Petras, exactly, but they had the best pieces.
And Hedie had known, as she had known so many real world things, that if Petras accepted the fact of her death, he would be able to raise their children properly. If he chose to live in a fairytale world, then he would not.
So he had kept his promise to her: He had gone to Akida’s morgue, filled to the brim with victims of the domed city’s strange flight, and he had waited, silently, with all the sobbing families. He couldn’t sob, not until he saw her. And he couldn’t bring himself to shove ahead in line against all the other people who had come.
Especially since they, for the most part, weren’t people of privilege. Their spouses or children or grandchildren had had precious jobs, yes, but in a domed city that might not have welcomed them if they hadn’t been working on it.
Because the one thing Hedie had insisted upon, the one thing she had claimed made the project work, was that she wanted a level for the workers, the people who would not be able to pony up the funds for the entry deposit, especially since it had become clear as the domed city plans were finalized that the entry deposits would have to be higher than initially thought.
He had stood in that morgue and watched people lose not just loved ones, but opportunities and futures, and he tried to convince himself that their losses were worse than his.
But his had been Hedie. And there would never be anyone like her.
If Hedie were here, she wouldn’t be standing, broken, beside him, afraid to crawl onto the dirt. She would already be there, looking for evidence of what had gone wrong. She wouldn’t be at loose ends—not because she was mourning (she would have been) but because she wouldn’t have allowed a setback like this to derail her.
She had been strong, stronger than all of them, and he—even now—couldn’t believe she was dead.
But she had been right: He knew she wasn’t coming back to him. When his turn finally came, he had gone into the morgue room—not looking imagery on a screen or a 3D projection. He had asked for—and gotten—permission to see her, to touch her, even though he hadn’t touched her at first.
Because part of him, the sensitive, imaginative, terrified part of him, believed, deep down, that touching her would hurt her, and he would leave touching her to the doctors.
Even knowing she was dead.
And there was no doubt of that after seeing her beloved frame, damaged and destroyed. The face had resembled hers, but the rest of it—oh, the rest of it—looked like a broken bowl inside a pillow case. For a moment, you could imagine the bowl was still there, but if you touched any part of it, you could feel the shards.
He knew she was dead, but that wasn’t enough.
He had to know what killed her.
And he couldn’t quite admit that to anyone, not in a clear way. Instead, he had bullied his way to this platform, and he was now forcing Ahmed to face the loss of an entire project, and the death of nearly 600 workers, all of whom who had ended up just like Hedie—crumpled in the dirt where the city used to be.
At least, that was how Petras imagined it.
But his wife always told him that imagining wasn’t enough. Seeing helped. Touching helped more. Using all five senses would bring an understanding that mere thought could not.
Such a hard lesson for a man who lived inside his mind rather than in his body.
Ahmed was watching Petras, waiting for Petras to say something else, do something else. Ahmed’s mouth pointed downward and his dark eyes had lines along the sides that they hadn’t had last month. His temples were flecked with silver that hadn’t been there two weeks before.
He was living with Hedie’s legacy as well. With all of their legacies.
“Let’s go,” Petras said, clapping Ahmed on the back. “The sooner we get started, the sooner we will be done.”
As if they could ever be done. As if this place or this moment would leave them behind.
Petras knew it wouldn’t; he had a hunch Ahmed knew it as well.
ivHedie had built the platform first, and in typical Hedie fashion, she had built it herself. She loved getting her hands dirty, constructing things, not just in her imagination, but the old-old-fashioned way, with her fingers.
She had actually fired some engineers from her projects for suggesting that they use molds and printers and automated machines to build parts of her projects, the easy parts, she called them, like a platform that covered a bit of ground, a platform that existed to survey—as she would say with just a bit of humor—her entire kingdom.
She built the first platform for Petras. Because he didn’t like walking in nature. And there had been a lot of nature. Spindly trees and dry underbrush, vegetation that grew on bark and boulders that had toppled down faraway hills in even more faraway times.
It looked both impassable and impossible to him, an unconquerable land that should be left to rot, just like the Akida government had done since humans first colonized this planet five hundred years ago.
Hedie had seen possibilities. Use the trees for wood and supplies, grind up the underbrush for mulch for the city’s gardens, figure out what exactly the vegetation was on that bark, and then level everything—including the ground.
She had done that and so much more, taking the boulders and putting them inside her domed city as decoration, removing stone and selling it to home builders inside Akida for people who would never qualify to live in the dome itself.
But back then, when she had first taken Petras to the platform and surveyed her kingdom, she had laughed at his unease. His dislike of the fact that the platform had no railings, that one misstep would send him tumbling to the ground ten meters below. She had climbed down the side, something he hadn’t been willing to do, and she had shown him—that day—with her little pocket knife, the way that the strata varied, and told him about ground stability and fuel sources and the perfect sites for cities that could survive on their own.
He had seen none of it, but he had tried to—catching her imagination and holding it against his.
He saw fairytale cities made of clouds, giant cities made of ivory, paintings in two dimensions transposed against the ugly ground before him.
She had seen an actual city, one she could build, one she thought would be better than any city either of them had been to.
And she had it three quarters finished when it killed her. Somehow. Quietly. During the night.
vPetras and Ahmed had gone to the destruction the way that everyone used to go to the half-finished city: They took a skimmer off the platform onto the uneven ground.
As they stood in the skimmer’s hollow surface, a slight wind pulling at their clothing, the automated system issued a series of warnings. The newly revealed land was untested, the area was restricted, the preponderance of dead bodies discovered at the site might lead to disease…
Petras tuned it out after the third warning. If he died here, so be it. His mother would make sure the children had enough money to make it through the rest of their lives; Hedie’s parents would provide the love and nurturing.
He’d already made plans with both sets of parents, not because he expected to die any time soon, but he was keenly aware after the events of the past two weeks that he could die just as suddenly as Hedie had, and the children would have nothing.
It seemed his comfortable lifestyle had prevented that realization until now; he was ashamed that he had fought with Hedie on every step involving a future without the two of them. The estate planning, the care of the children, an outline of a world in which neither he nor Hedie existed.
It had seemed unimaginable one month ago; it was halfway to a reality now.
The skimmer was not allowed to cross over the site where the city project had been. The investigators had yet to finish their report. They were as much in the dark as everyone else. The city had been there, unfinished, in progress, at midnight local time; by 1 am, it was gone.
The investigators were reviewing the security footage now, trying to see if someone had hooked it up unbeknownst to the engineers. Unbeknownst to Hedie.
The skimmer landed on the last bit of shaved ground before the devastation. The ground had been primed for some kind of working sidewalk, something that the teams would use as they entered and left the city itself.
Petras could even see the mark in the dirt, the footprint—as Hedie would have called it—of the city’s edge.
The city’s missing edge.
He stepped off the skimmer onto the smooth pale brown surface. Ahmed did not follow, but instead, seemed to be waiting for Petras to come to some kind of realization.
Petras wasn’t going to ask what Ahmed wanted him to see, but Petras could guess.
The ground didn’t look benign down here. It was laden not only with dirt from below, but with bits and pieces of the city itself. Some blue shards of clear material, chunks of piping, unidentifiable metal pieces that looked sharp enough to be knives, even though they clearly were not.
Ahmed had warned Petras to wear protective shoes—and he had—but he had the dizzying sense that if he fell, he would be sliced to ribbons. He had the sense that he should have been wearing some kind of gear, but what kind, he did not know.
He half-expected the air to be warmer down here—that desert imagery again, even though Akida was not situated on a desert.
He could almost see Hedie, standing not too far from here, grinning at the vegetation, knife in hand.
It couldn’t be more perfect, she had said, as if she had discovered paradise.
He wondered what would happen if he had been able to go back in time and warn her that she would die here, crushed by the very city she had wanted to develop.
Would she have given all this up? Or would she have grinned again, and said that she would be happy to go out with her boots on?
Sometimes he thought she would be happy to give it all up, and sometimes he thought she would have been happy with this death. And mostly, he realized how little he knew about her inner life, despite how much she had understood his.
The smell of rotting vegetation and mold was long gone. The air wasn’t damp either. All the water had been removed from the property long ago, diverted to wells that would provide water to the city.
Ahmed stood on the skimmer a moment longer than Petras had. If anything, Ahmed looked even more bent and broken than he had up on the platform, as if this ruined ground itself was destroying him.
As brilliant as Ahmed was, he wasn’t Hedie. The city hadn’t been his vision. It had been Hedie’s. She used to tell Petras how hard it was to be the second-in-command on a project like this, not just because of all the stress and the work and the obligations, but because the vision for the project was never quite focused. Yes, the plans helped, and yes, the models made it clearer, and yes, even the partial completion helped realize the vision.
But the actual idea—the thing from which it sprang—the energy for the project, its heart and life’s blood—that was impossible for anyone else to grasp except the person who designed it and brought it to completion.
Hedie’s ability to make her projects live was the reason she got hired all over the Caado System, the reason she was always in demand, and the reason she argued for a project here, in Akida, so she could help raise her children.
The domed city had been close enough to completion, though, that her restless mind was looking for a new project, new sites, new inspirations.
She had been thinking of leaving him again, and the hell of it was, he had understood.
Petras had to forget that Ahmed was behind him. Ahmed made it harder to focus on Hedie, on the remains of her final, failed project. Petras had come here to say a final good-bye to his wife, not to take care of a man who was tasked with dealing with the remains of her vision.
Petras took a step forward, his boot sinking into the dirt. He frowned at the ground around him, something bothering his fuzzy brain. He tried to dismiss the sensation, blaming it on the fact that the ground was not all that firm beneath his feet.
“Where was she found?” he asked, half turning, trying to focus on the task before him.
Ahmed pointed. “Just over that rise,” he said. “They all were.”
Petras stopped. That disquieting sensation filled him. It felt like an outside force, not an internal one.
“I thought six-hundred people died here,” he said.
“That’s right.” Ahmed’s lips puckered, as if he tasted something sour. He didn’t look at Petras. Ahmed looked forward, at the dirt ahead of them, as if he didn’t really see it, as if he saw the domed city that had been here before.
“All of them ended up in the same place?” Petras asked. His hands were shaking. His stomach had become queasy.
Something was wrong here—many somethings were wrong here. The city, gone. Six hundred people, gone. Hedie, gone.
“Yeah,” Ahmed said.
“That’s unusual, right?” Petras asked. He would think so, but he wasn’t an engineer.
Ahmed shrugged one shoulder. Even that seemed like an effort for him. “All of this is unusual.”
“What, were they working in the same building?” Petras asked.
“We don’t know,” Ahmed said. “We lost the security cameras with the domed city itself.”
“Except the stuff from the platforms,” Petras said.
Ahmed nodded.
Petras turned away from him, trudged up a mound of dirt, felt it slide beneath his boots. There was nothing firm here, no foundation for the entire city, nothing.
Petras had lived with an engineer long enough to know the fundamentals. Besides, Hedie had shown him how the city would be laid out.
Level the ground. Then place a foundation over it. Then build the flight specs. Then add the infrastructure—the water and power and sewage. All of that infrastructure would leave if the city left. The city would be built on top of the infrastructure, and then parts of the city would layer on other parts.
The dirt—the dirt was the very bottom. The foundation should have stayed, though. Hedie had said that the foundation would remain. If the domed city had to take flight, it would have to land on another foundation somewhere else.
That was, she had told Petras, the only flaw in the flying domed city plan.
Petras finally made it to the top of the nearest mound. The ground was still made up of mixed materials—the white, dark, and brown dirt all scattered across the top, as if disturbed by a great wind.
There was a slight wind here, and a smell that he didn’t recognize. Not that living decay he had smelled when the scraggly forest was here, but a faintly rotten scent overlaid with a bit of burned metal, ozone—something snappy and crisp and metallic and smoke-filled.
He peered down, expected a crater. Instead, he saw a flattened portion of ground. Only on the ground were strange prints, things he did not understand.
“Don’t walk any farther.” Ahmed had caught up to him.
“Where was she found?” Petras asked.
Ahmed pointed at the nearest print at the top of the rise.
Despite Ahmed’s warning, Petras took a few steps forward, and looked.
Not a print, really. An indentation. In the shape of a human form, curled in a fetal position.
Petras crouched. The stench grew suddenly worse. The dark part of the dirt here wasn’t black dirt. It was stained—and he suddenly understood what it was stained with.
Blood.
His wife’s blood.
The city had left, and then she had landed here, every bone in her body crushed.
He frowned, trying to imagine it. Because that dome was airtight, several layers thick, and there were layers and layers of foundation and infrastructure and—
That unsettled feeling became worse. It was impossible. What he was seeing. Impossible.
“I’m sorry,” he said as he turned slightly. “I’m not clear on something. How did the bodies get here?”
Ahmed ran his fingers across his forehead, as if he were trying to smooth out the new wrinkles.
“We don’t know,” he said. “We really don’t know.”
vi“Engineers and governments are the same on only one point,” Hedie said, two days before the wedding. “They both prefer certainty to uncertainty. Uncertainty can drive them crazy.”
She hadn’t been looking at Petras as she said that. She had her back to him, her entire body hunched. She was looking at a wall-sized 2D image of the Nbrediss Island Chain, the ocean a bright cheery blue, the islands themselves strange brown shapes that resembled—from this distance—rocks strewn across a pond.
“It wasn’t your project,” he had said, his stomach twisted in knots. They stood in his kitchen. It was the middle of the night. He had awakened to find the bed empty, and then emerged to discover her here, looking at the Island Chain again, as if she could solve the mystery of the collapsed bridges.
“It was my project,” she said. “I’m just lucky.”
“Lucky.” He didn’t think of her as lucky. The loss of the bridges haunted her so much that he worried about what he was getting into, what kind of person he was marrying. “I don’t understand how you can consider yourself lucky because you were with this project.”
“That’s just it,” she said, still staring at the image. He realized as he looked that she studied the image without the bridges, never the image with the bridges. “I wasn’t in charge of this project. I’ll be able to work again. Everyone who signed off—they might never ever be able to build anything again.”
The bridges remained a mystery that Petras did not like. Every new revelation sent Hedie into a frenzy of examination.
The ocean was too deep to find the bits of the bridges. The bridge pieces never washed ashore. Divers didn’t find foundations to the bridges.
But the bodies of the workers—they had floated to the surface almost immediately.
And they hadn’t drowned.
That had been the first important clue. They hadn’t drowned. They had no water in their lungs, but their bones were shattered, as if they had fallen from a great height.
“Everyone thinks they fell off the bridges,” she had said slowly that night, as if Petras hadn’t spoken at all. “But they couldn’t have….”
“What do you mean?” he had asked.
She shut off the image then, and turned to him, enveloping him in her arms.
“We’re getting married in two days,” she said.
“I know,” he said, wondering what he was getting into.
“It’s time to focus on the future,” she said.
“I know,” he said.
“So let’s,” she had said, and kissed him. And he had forgotten about missing bridges and damaged bodies, thinking only of family and a life with her, instead of one without.
She had only spoken of those bridges one more time.
viiPetras touched the ground where his wife’s body had ended up. The dirt was caked, thicker because it was laced with blood.
“Did you ever hear of the Nbrediss Island Chain bridge disaster?” he asked.
“Every engineer has heard of it.” Ahmed sounded very far away, even though he was only a few meters from Petras. “Seventy-five bridges with the same flaw, collapsing due to the same storm—and not a severe one at that.”
“That’s one theory.” Petras rolled one little clump of dirt into a tiny ball. He couldn’t let go of it. Not yet.
“That’s the only logical theory,” Ahmed snapped.
“So you know the other one,” Petras said.
“That aliens stole the bridges? Teleported them elsewhere?” Ahmed’s tone had grown derisive. “Any culture that can teleport structures of that size can build bridges like those linking the Nbrediss Islands.”
“Unless the teleportation device was also stolen,” Petras said. Hedie had believed that, in the end. Because she had seen some security footage from a dock near one of the bridges.
The bridge had disappeared.
Then, fifteen minutes later, bodies rained from the sky, landing in the ocean as if dropped from a great height.
They were rejected, she had said. Because whoever stole the bridges didn’t want people. They wanted intact structures.
She had looked ashen after seeing the footage, and it had taken him days to get her to tell him why.
The people who had fallen—the workers—they had been sent back alive.
He swallowed against a dry throat, then looked up at the purplish sky. Where had they appeared, his wife and the 599 others? Just inside the atmosphere? At the top of the dome?
Those last five seconds—
Those people must have been in hell, she had said, imagining it. He had closed his eyes against the image, back then, not wanting to pollute his mind.
Now, though, now—
He thought of her falling. Five seconds was a very long time. Long enough to recognize where she was and what would happen. Long enough to reach toward the existing city of Akida, toward her family asleep in their comfortable apartment.
Long enough to feel—what? Love? Regret? Fear? All of those things?
“You don’t believe that, do you?” Ahmed asked.
Petras realized Ahmed had taken a long time to speak, and when he had, his tone was different. More curious than sarcastic.
“Hedie did,” Petras said.
He stared at the bloody ground for a long moment, realizing that the sensation of disquiet had left him. Had it come from outside? From her?
Then he shook his head, the lore and folktales warring with the logic. Probably not from her ghost. But from the memory of her, the things she would have wanted Ahmed—and those running the project—to know had she lived.
Had she not been at the project when someone had transported it elsewhere.
“Hedie?” Ahmed said. “What would she know about it?”
Then Petras realized that Ahmed hadn’t known. Hedie had been right. No one had known of her involvement in the first project. It hadn’t been part of her résumé because she hadn’t been a major player.
Petras stood, and wiped his fingers on his pants.
“Look it up,” he said. “You’ll see.”
And if Ahmed were smart, he would see the similarities. Maybe Ahmed would tell the others.
Or maybe Petras would remind his mother of both disasters. The PPM could investigate them as a unit, and do what needed to be done.
Petras turned. He could see the lights of Akida from here. Where his children were. Where Hedie’s parents were. Where his mother was. The entire world, for him.
He would move forward in it, taking care of his small life.
It wasn’t up to him to solve this. To find those who stole gigantic pieces of technology with other kinds of technology.
He would leave that to governments and engineers, people who needed certainty.
He had his certainty.
Hedie was gone, and she had left a legacy different from the one she had expected to leave.
She had expected to leave giant monuments, a tribute to her engineering vision, examples of her prodigious and unbelievably creative mind.
Instead, she left two imaginative children and a man who loved her—a small impact, but an impact all the same.
Petras would honor her the way she had wanted him to honor her—by recognizing her death, and raising their children to be the best of both of them.
Little pieces of the future, that he would protect, the only way he knew how.
“The City’s Edge”Copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Bridging Infinity, edited by Jonathan Strahan, Solaris, October 2016Published by WMG PublishingCover and layout copyright © 2023 by WMG PublishingCover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG PublishingCover art copyright © maninblack/Depositphotos
To get a free AI -generated audio version of this blog, click here.
Dean has a phrase that he uses often, especially when he’s teaching. He says writers have to give themselves time to turn the ship. By this, he usually means that writers need to change their thinking, and that takes time.
He also uses it for businesses. If you have a small boat, a canoe or a kayak, turning the ship is easy (ish. It’s never entirely easy.) If you have a cigarette boat, the kind that’s built for speed and mobility, then turning the ship is normal.
But if you have a cruise ship or an aircraft carrier, something that can handle thousands of passengers, turning that ship takes time.
The reason I mention this is because I made a mention in last week’s post on my AI audio research about WMG Publishing. In reference to redoing work we had already done, I wrote, “[W]e have 1,000 books. That’s a lot of time [to redo them], even if each book only takes fifteen minutes.”
I know a lot of readers just glossed over this, but I didn’t even as I wrote it. We run up against the 1,000 books problem over and over again.
We run into it when Amazon changes some important algorithms or Ingram decides that cover specs should be different. We run into it when some of the distribution systems change their pricing page, adding or subtracting foreign taxes or mandating a minimum price per word count.
We’ve had the 1,000 books problem almost from the beginning. When indie started, over twelve years ago now, Dean wanted all of our books and stories available online. That was our focus when we started WMG Publishing, and became an even tighter focus when we hired Allyson Longueira. Her original mandate was to publish everything on our bibliographies. It took time and several employees, but we managed to do it.
Keeping up is the problem now. So when a new program enters the independent publishing sphere, we have to choose what products to put into that program—if we try the program at all.
At times, because of our size, we have moved from the earliest of early adapters to the folks who bring up the caboose. We do so partly because of the 1,000 books, partly because of time, and partly because we’ve seen so many good ideas die a few years in because of poor execution—or because consumers did not pick up the idea, no matter how good it was.
When we do decide to move to a new platform or try something new that has come into the business, we have to triage. Those of you who are following our leap into our online store can see that triage in action.
We can’t upload everything all at once. We don’t have the time. Our employees have 120 hours per week to get things done. To get everything we have to do done. When we add something new, something else gets set aside.
Dean and I also have a lot to do, but we’re not focusing on the day-to-day minutia of the business. That’s for the staff. We have a staff because we wanted to keep writing. Because publishing has changed so much and because there is now a seemingly infinite number of things a publisher can do to promote one book, let alone 1,000 books, that 120 hours per week is a drop in the bucket.
Dean and I can literally stay ahead of the team with the books (and shorts) that we finish, because the team has so much to do.
That’s why I’ve been handling the AI audio. I won’t be doing all of it—the books will be through WMG—but I did the research, and I’ll continue to do my blog, plus other pet projects.
Dean has pet projects as well.
Sometimes we do things that logically should go to WMG simply because we don’t want to overburden anyone.
So, we triage. We have email chains and discussions about which projects should get the attention first. We talk about how many person-hours it will take to adopt a new program, and is that program worth removing person-hours from another program.
Sure, we could hire someone else, but those of you in corporate or those of you who have run businesses know the problem with that: Training also takes time, and that time often has no real return, particularly if the employee does not work out.
We do use freelancers on occasion, but even that sometimes requires training. Everything is a juggling act.
Let me be really clear here: What we have is a good problem to have. We have too much material rather than too little. I’m not sure we’ll ever get it entirely under control, but we’re trying. And sometimes we forget how hard what we’re doing is.
A case in point: one way that we got most of my inventory into ebooks was to post a new Free Fiction Monday story every week. For more than four years, we put up a new, never-before-posted story on the site. Now, we repeat stories, but I try to make sure that the stories haven’t been seen in years. And every year, we’re still posting about 10 new ones (sometimes more).
When we hit that final story, when the inventory was up, did we stop to celebrate? We didn’t. Because it wasn’t a focus any longer. We should have celebrated. That was a monumental task. But we were on to other things. New mountains to climb and much more to do.
The difference between what we do at WMG and what traditional publishers do is vast. But the biggest difference is this: We keep our inventory fresh. We know what we have. We actively churn it, discuss it, and figure out what would be best to use when and where.
For example, WMG runs a really cool promotion called Every Day’s A Holiday At WMG. For a tiny subscription fee ($5 per month), subscribers get a free weekly story, and discounts on books and online workshops, and whatever else they feel like sharing.
That moves the inventory, and it also brings new readers into fiction that might have disappeared years ago.
Nothing fades when we work this way. Books get new promotions when something else in the culture makes them relevant. Covers get updated. And then, as I mentioned above, we figure out how to move them to new platforms, when there are new platforms to move to.
That’s what we’re doing with audio right now—and with the store. With the store, we’re trying to put all of our series books there first. Then we’ll move to short stories and novellas and standalone books.
With audio, we’re going for nonfiction first, so that we can experiment. Then we’ll follow with the most popular series or the ones readers have asked for.
What that means is that a different set of books will appear on audio first as opposed to the books that are appearing first in the store.
Each change requires thought and discussion. Every decision is based on what we know right now. Some of those decisions will have to stand for years (because we might not have time to revisit the decision) and some are only temporary—we hope.
It’s a problem that many writers don’t have yet, so they don’t understand why it seems like I’m dithering on adapting something new. I might not be dithering. I might be investigating…and I might end up deciding that something isn’t for us.
Or maybe I’ll decide that it is, but we don’t have time.
Or maybe we’ll dive right in, because we can’t leave money on the table any more.
It’s a strange place to be, but it’s fun too. I’d rather have too many choices than not enough.
And the cool thing about the world we’re in now is that choice seems to be everywhere. We can do all the things…if we can only find the time.
What I described above is just one way that a publisher has to look at the world as opposed to the way that writers of one or two books look at the world. If learning more about this way of thinking interests you, try this classic workshop that WMG offers: Think Like A Publisher. You can find more about it and other workshops in our searchable workshop website.
If you want help with time management in general, I have a Freelancer’s Guide Short Book on the topic called, appropriately, Time Management. (You’ll note that, as one of the older titles, this book has not yet moved to our online store. All that triage!)
And the regular reminder:
This weekly blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynruschr4e to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: The Importance of Ship Size,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © Can Stock Photo / Goodday.
First, some really exciting news! The Courtmartial of the Renegat Renegades is a finalist for the Asimov’s Readers Choice Awards in the novella category, and “Rocket Girls,” is up for best novelette! I’m really thrilled. (And super thrilled about Rocket Girls, since it’s a personal favorite). The other writers in my category are amazing, from Rick Wilber, Sean Monaghan, and Nick Wolven in the novella category, and Suzanne Palmer, Eleanor Arnason, Will McIntosh, Greg Egan, and Alastair Reynolds in the novelette category. The short story category has some wonderful writers as well, including my Clarion Writers Workshop classmate, Geoffrey A. Landis. (Not to mention one of my Clarion instructors, Joe Haldeman, is up for best poem.) If you click on this link, you can see all of the finalists, and (bonus!) read all of the stories. Congrats all! I’m honored to be in your company!
Those are 2022 stories. I have two stories out already in the digests in 2023. I wrote “Drinking in the Afternoon” in February 0f 2021 after the vaccines became available, but before I could even get one. “Drinking” is one of the few stories I vividly remember writing, because I simply had to get it out of my system. It’s a sly mystery, with crimes that sneak up on you, which is why it’s in the March/April edition of Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine. I share the table of contents with incredible writers, from Joyce Carol Oates and Doug Allyn to Brendan DuBois and K.L. Abrahamson. I haven’t read their stories yet, but believe me, I will, since all four writers are personal favorites. Order a copy here.
I also have a story in the March/April edition of Asimovs. “The Nameless Dead” is not part of any series. The story actually came to me in a (very dark) dream, with the opening lines being spoken angrily in my head. I had to get up and write them down. Our point of view character is not a nice woman and she knows it. But she’s useful, and that can sometimes be the entire point. You can order your copy here.
And, finally, here’s something absolutely beautiful. The cover of Robot issue 96. It has my story “The Retrieval Artist” in Italian. I’m not sure how many of you read Italian, but for those of you who do, here’s the link to get your copy
Caro, once considered the most beautiful woman in the world, had a daughter with a relatively ugly magician. Caro’s daughter, unfortunately, inherited her father’s looks—and his magic. She uses that magic to help protect her beautiful mother, and famous women like her, from the snarkmeisters on red carpets everywhere.
But the snarkmeisters pale in comparison to the darker magic driving them—a magic that thrives on human failings. A magic that might prove too great to overcome.
“Fashion and the Snarkmeisters,” by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story is also available in ebook through various online retailers here.
Fashion and the SnarkmeistersKristine Kathryn RuschYou saw it, everyone did—1 billion people if the Nielsens are right (and they so rarely are)—that moment when the statue of a gigantic, naked, golden man toppled onto a scrum of snarky, microphone-wielding “reporters.”
Oh, the dithering. Oh, the slow-motion replays. Oh, the terrified faces—right out of a Hollywood disaster movie.
No one was injured, at least not in the Hollywood-disaster-movie way. Expensive clothing was wrinkled and stained beyond repair. Reputations were ruined with little more than a few high-pitched squeals. And way too many people celebrated on social media.
I admit, had I been sitting at home watching the so-called debacle, I might have Tweeted something inappropriate and regretted it enough to delete my Twitter feed the next day.
But I wasn’t at home. I was standing about fifty feet to the left, behind the emergency curtain at the edge of the red carpet, some special safety pins clamped in my teeth, a stronger-than-surgical-steel needle in my right hand, and a spool of special glittery metallic thread in my left.
I might have growled a cheer, but I knew better than to open my mouth and take a deep breath before shouting my huzzahs. After all, if I had swallowed those pins and lost my concentration…
Well, I get ahead of myself.
*The Real Beginning
I have no idea if the snark started on May 16, 1929, in the Blossom Room at the Hollywood Roosevelt Hotel (make that May 17, the day after the Big Event) or if it started back at dawn of time when clothing stopped being optional.
What I do know is this: The word “award” came into common use in the Middle Ages, and if you look at mainstream dictionaries (the ones that don’t accept magic), you’ll see that award meant “decision after careful observation.” Okay, fine. That sounds right—especially considering how much time we all spend watching the nominated films every year.
For the magical, though, the word “award” holds a deeper meaning. The word has the word “ward” in it, and wards, as we magical know, mean “to protect, guard.”
You think you know where I’m going—especially since that gigantic golden man fell on those snarky faux-celebrities—but hang on. You have no real idea.
Because once upon a time, awards carried no bling. The bling that you were awarded, back in the day (Ancient Greece, Ancient Rome, Medieval Europe) came in the form of trophies.
And the word “trophy” comes from the French trophée which means “a spoil or prize of war.”
Once trophies got associated with awards—and when all of that moved to Hollywood—the war metaphor becomes apt. Epic battles, gauntlets, victories, and defeats occur throughout award season. Someone’s always on top, someone’s always losing, someone doesn’t fight hard enough, and someone always does something memorable, although not necessarily in a heroic way.
My earliest experiences with awards season came courtesy of my mother, whom you all know as Caro—so famous that all you need is the nickname.
Yeah, that Caro, whose real name had become unwieldy over the decades: Carolyn Sarah Brown Lodge Young Blondell Reynolds Taylor Mellon Torres.
As most of you probably know, Mother was the most nominated actress in the history of film awards—until Meryl Streep took the title a few years ago.
Mother: Beautiful, powerful, award-nominated, always at the top of her game—at least in public. And a mess in private.
The husbands saw that and fled, leaving me alone with her. Me, the only daughter of the most beautiful woman in the world.
I had three reactions to awards season.
I was ten when I realized those things could be melded together.
*The Bad Guys…
…are not the snarkmeisters who got crushed. Honestly, really, as much as we all love to hate them, these so-called “fashion experts” and/or “fashion bloggers” and/or “fashion critics” are really human beings with no real talent themselves (except wit, which, we can argue, is a talent which can be used for good or for harm).
Somehow these slimeballs manage to fill airtime in a way that draws viewers. People like Mother, who have only glamor (actually “glamour”—they’re dusted with fairy magic that makes them shine even more than the rest of us), can’t see the actual magic that fuels this stuff.
A crack between worlds opened when fashion became important (and much as I love it, I’m not giving you that history), and then the crack widened with each incursion of critics. The International Best Dressed List? Started in 1940, not coincidentally as the world marched to war.
The rise of television, the march of fashion magazines, the plummeting self-esteem of young girls—all a plot that came from the deepest, darkest magics.
Women hold the most innate power, as you all know (or maybe you don’t), which is why forces always emerge to hold us down. As each victory occurs, another battle springs up elsewhere.
How do I know all this stuff? Because I inherited almost everything from my father. And no, you have no idea who my father is. In fact, in our house, he’s called He Who Shall Remain Nameless, mostly because the press has not yet figured out that he exists. He was a one-night stand between the first Mellon marriage and the second Mellon marriage (Caro and Rafe Mellon divorced, then realized they couldn’t live without each other—until they did).
Sadly, I look just like my father—short, squat, big ears, pointy chin. The press, the fashion bloggers, hell everyone on social media mentions this all the time—how sad it is that the daughter of the most beautiful woman in the world (okay, now they call her “one of” the most beautiful women in the world, but still) is an ugly duckling who never turned into a swan.
And no one, not even my mother, thinks that odd.
But I know why I’m here. Because He Who Shall Remain Nameless gifted me with magic—the one that makes things happen. (You don’t think it was an accident that a guy as ugly as him slept with the most beautiful woman in the world, do you?)
Part of that magic I inherited is the ability to see other magic. Imagine my fear one night as I watched the clips of Events coverage and saw black shapes glowing behind the snarkmeisters. This was early 1990s, when the awards shows were still in their fashion infancy. In fact, most of the attendees chose their own clothes and the phrase “Red Carpet Fashion” didn’t even exist.
The arrivals got shown in a clip montage as the Big Event started—and that’s when I saw those shapes, hovering.
I was at home, where every good ten-year-old should be, eating popcorn with my nanny. Events nights were scary nights in the house, because they devastated Mother.
She always had the best I’m so pleased you won instead of me face, but after the cameras shut off, she didn’t go to the after-parties. She came home and sobbed. By the next day—at least back then—she was all right, ready to return to whatever soundstage they had pried her out of to attend the Event, but the night of the ceremony, my mother was a hurt little girl, who couldn’t understand why no one liked her, really really liked her.
The snarkmeisters had little power then. Usually they wrote for newspapers or fashion magazines, weeks after the Event, and their words had little impact. They didn’t even hold microphones in those ancient days. Yet the black shadows stood behind them, sparkling with orange glimmers of evil intent.
And I couldn’t help myself. I screamed.
Popcorn everywhere, a panicked nanny, a terrified child. Lots and lots of tears, which had to be quelled before Mother came home to indulge in hers.
I wasn’t crying because I was sad, but because I was frightened.
That night marked the first time I voluntarily called He Who Shall Remain Nameless.
He chuckled, a raspy unpleasant sound that always reminds me of fingernails on a blackboard, and said, “Kid, the world’s rich right now. So the darkness comes to feed. It’ll get worse before it gets better. You can do two things. You can let it consume those delicate flowers like your mother, or you can figure out how to protect her.”
And then he hung up.
By then, I had stopped crying and started thinking.
I couldn’t convince Mother to drag me to the Events. She said They Weren’t Appropriate For Children (while thinking that Children Weren’t Appropriate For Events).
It took a confluence of things to lead me to my calling.
*Thing The First
I turned thirteen. In Hollywood terms, there’s nothing worse than hitting puberty as the ugly daughter of the most beautiful woman in the world. (In real world terms, there’s a lot worse, but let’s go with my reality, shall we?)
I mean, puberty is tough enough for girls. Parts bud, other parts spontaneously bleed, zits appear, and lifelong friends (going through the same hormonal nightmares) sometimes turn into mean girls.
Mother actually helped.
She said, “My darling, you look the way you look. None of us can take credit for our genetics. However, you can control the way that you present yourself. Think of your clothing as your armor. Every day is a battle to be beautiful, and if your face can’t achieve it for you, then you make absolutely certain that your clothing will.”
She taught me hair, makeup, asset management (not the financial kind) and how to make the most of the best parts and minimize the bad parts.
I surpassed her knowledge within a year, and was actually helping her dress—and about that point I discovered—
*Thing The Second
—my talent for creation. If I made clothing, sewed my own dresses, embroidered my own jeans, I added the kind of glamour that my mother had. A wisp of fairy dust that made the clothes just that much more beautiful.
It would take years of study, both magical and nonmagical, to actually learn true fashion—but I get ahead of myself.
Because I hadn’t realized that I wanted to become one of the best fashion designers in the world until I discovered—
*Thing The Third
—photos of a short, not-beautiful woman who died the year I was born. She had everything my mother never had—including eight Academy Awards (and more nominations than anyone except Walt Disney). She was a woman named Edith Head, the best costume designer the movies have ever known.
Not fair. She didn’t design costumes. She created fashion. The kind that defined eras. Era after era after era.
If she could dress everyone from Mae West to Audrey Hepburn, finding the perfect clothes for those completely different bodies, then she truly was a magician—and one I aspired to be.
And that, my friends, was the true beginning of Warrior Woman Design.
*At First…I just wanted the rest of us—y’know, those of us with few assets to manage—to have equal footing in the workplace. Study after study after study has shown that beautiful people get higher pay, better jobs, and more press coverage than folks whose faces (and bodies) aren’t symmetrical.
A little glamour on a business dress, and suddenly a plain woman becomes powerful. Or maybe she just thinks she does. Or maybe her inner beauty shines out.
Back then, I had no idea what made it work, but now I know. You feel beautiful, then you are beautiful. It’s that simple, that profound.
I learned design at several fashion institutes and donated the clothes to needy women who didn’t have the right outfit for a job interview. (We still have a branch that does that.)
And as I grew more confident, the world kept changing. Fashion became relevant. Places like E! Entertainment Television began four-hour shows live from the red carpet of every damn award ceremony ever held, and the snarkmeisters gained power. Or, in truth, the shadows that had started to fill the snarkmeisters’ eyes and govern their dumpy, jealous, non-creative little bodies gained power.
The last year my mother dressed herself for the award-show gauntlet was the first year I got to accompany her on the red carpet, and now it’s time to dump the cutesy little half-screenplay way I’ve been writing this thing.
Because that night was hell.
***Through the magic of television, the red carpet looks big and beautiful and in our collective imaginations, everything around it is big and beautiful too.
But really—No.
Most neighborhoods in Los Angeles are not beautiful, sorry to say. They’re flat retail markets with scuzzy 1960s or 1980s or 1990s buildings that look dated in that magic sunlight. The sidewalks are wide, the traffic backs up even on a good day, and the tourists gawk everywhere, expecting a star.
The red carpet is protected space—covered in awnings, guarded by security, usually for days before an Event. Most Events have risers set up on either side of the carpet for “fans” who aren’t really fans, more like paparazzi who staked out the turf. (Every Event tries to weed out the paparazzi, but can’t, now that everyone wears baggy, low-slung, ripped jeans and some rude T-shirt.)
TV trucks park as close as allowed. A wall covered with the Event’s logo goes up beside the red carpet so that the Truly Famous can be photographed properly for the fashionistas and post-game (I mean—Event) shows, and the week-long orgy that is post-Event entertainment television.
We little people, and by that I mean those of us who are not nominated Actors or presenter Actors, get shoved aside by the array of camera-toting assholes who shout, “Caro! Show that fine tush of yours!” “Caro, let’s see some leg!” “Caro, lean in for a cleavage shot!”
At that Event, it took me ten minutes to catch up to Mother after the photo gauntlet swept her in and pushed her out, straight into the clown-like mask-face of one of the most famous snarkmeisters, a woman who should have known better, having suffered a lot of snark herself back in the day.
She was, I believe, the first one to ask a question that came from the shadows, a question that in English makes no sense, even though these days it has become common:
“Who are you wearing?”
Never good live and scriptless, Mother blinked in surprise, thinking she had misheard the question. She frowned, and through a camera (as we saw through hundreds of playbacks, usually accompanied by Mother’s sobs), she suddenly looked old and befuddled.
Then the tide swept her away. Her moment in the sun—as a presenter that year—wasn’t to her advantage either. She had chosen a dress from her closet that dated from before I was born. Yes, it still fit, and without the lights, it looked gorgeous, but someone (a shadowy someone in makeup, perhaps?) hadn’t extended the makeup from her face to her neck and onto her bosom.
She looked like an elderly woman wearing a Caro mask whose color didn’t match her sun-wrinkled skin tone.
At the time, Mother was forty years old. Everyone said she looked eighty.
Show after show after show, recap after recap after recap, there was Mother, front and center: Red Carpet Fashion Victim, worthy of the jibes that our culture gives women no longer in their prime.
Men have it easy when it comes to clothing—even on the Red Carpet. They get props for wearing a white tuxedo jacket with black pants or for wearing a scarf instead of a bowtie. Every now and then, some idiot wears shorts or scuffed jeans and gets dinged for being too casual for “the biggest night of the year” (or what passes for a big night that week), but mostly, the men have little choice, so they can do little wrong.
But for women, it’s a nightmare.
Wrong color, wrong shape, wrong hair, wrong jewelry, wrong posture, too much leg, not enough leg, too much cleavage, too see-through, not see-through enough, too daring, too bold, too reserved, too refined, too short, too long, too wide, too narrow, too—
Oh, you get it.
And with each little snarky phrase, the shadows grow. They get bigger and blacker and even more powerful. They absorb glamour like an alcoholic sucks down beer, and they prey on women—in our culture at least (I have no idea what happens in those cultures where the women are robed and covered all day)—because in our culture, women have the plumage, the glory, the most glamour and the most instinctual magic.
He Who Shall Remain Nameless sent me books on shadows and darkness and creeping bad things. I learned that the creeping, shadowy, bad things always, always arrive twenty years before the world turns on itself, and the way they accomplish that turn is to eat all of the world’s innocent beauty.
And bury it under snark.
After that devastating fashion-victim Event, I thought Mother would never leave the house again. So, I slowly rescued her.
First I made her a pair of 1930s movie pajamas—the kind of exquisite silk top and bottom numbers that Ginger Rogers made famous before the Second World War. They were the first project I made for Mother in which I added a little magic—comfort magic, to calm her, and remind her that she was more than a pretty (well, beautiful) face.
The pajamas worked—and they gave me an idea.
Next year, when the shadows asked that stupid question—Who Are You Wearing—she would answer—vaguely, because shadows must always be answered vaguely (there’s too much magic in names) that she was wearing an original—designed by her daughter, the ugly duckling.
Me.
***The following year, Mother was nominated for her 13th Oscar, and of course, she didn’t win. I had hoped she wouldn’t—thirteen is one of those numbers you should live through, not call attention to.
She wore a flowing, pale lavender gown with piping that made it look vaguely Egyptian, placed in a pattern that warded away bad magic and amplified protective thoughts.
I accompanied her that year, not as her “date” because, by then, she had a new man, but as her dresser.
I followed along, adjusting her train. I primped, I plucked, I made sure no makeup artist screwed up the lovely glow we gave her. (And sure enough, I saw a tiny harassed blonde who, when I viewed her with magical vision, looked like she had been swallowed by a black, shadowy Category 3 tornado.)
I got Mother to her seat, and then hovered at the edges, so I could touch her up if need be.
All went well, through the too-long dance numbers and the lame jokes, (although I did have to touch up her eye makeup after the Dead-Roll, because she had some friends on it). But I wasn’t prepared for the moment Mother’s category got announced.
Mother’s dress flared as it tried to keep her tension down (I put some comfort magic in the thread as well), and then—
She lost.
No surprise there.
But that was the category where the winner—a twenty-something with a plum indie role (right before her big debut as the Heroine Of A Saga) tripped going up the stairs to get her award. And remained sprawled for the longest time.
I couldn’t run to the winner; I didn’t dare. Because I hoped no one else magical was watching. The energy above her, the lavender energy that tripped her—well, that had come from my mother.
Mother had been jealous of the winner throughout the entire awards season. And honestly, I understood it even if I hadn’t encouraged it. A twenty-something, beautiful, witty woman actually making more money per picture than Mother made in her entire career—and already stamped with a trademarked series of award wins.
Well, Little Miss Award-Winner-Above-The-Title managed to pick herself up and go on, giving a good speech if not a great one, and the show continued.
But I had some revamping to do.
The dresses couldn’t just send out magical “protect” energy. The energy had to be addressed at the shadows—the true magical threat, not a talented young woman who just happened snag the role of the season.
I didn’t yell at Mother. After all, she had put on her marvelous best I’m so pleased you won instead of me face, and had outwardly done the right things. Never once has she expressed the mean-girl jealousy that appeared via the dress that night.
And believe you me, I did some serious magical cleaning to make sure that the dress hadn’t been infected with shadow energy.
Nope. The dress had done its job. It had protected my fragile mother from the crushing disappointment that accompanied her every loss.
At least, this time, she wasn’t excoriated on the fashion shows. And every single night thereafter, she was listed as one of the best-dressed with only one snarkmeister mentioning that Mother was a Woman Of A Certain Age.
I would have thought victory was mine, if it weren’t for the humiliation the poor twenty-something had inadvertently suffered at my hands on her big night.
I had to make sure that sort of thing would never happen again.
***I refined the dresses, gave them away for free, test-ran them at minor awards venues such as the Pawtucket Film Festival, and then offered them to starlets for bigger festivals like Sundance. No one fell, no jealous energy attacked another winner, and if the snarkmeisters didn’t mention the dress positively, then they didn’t mention it at all.
Mother married (happily) in one of my dresses, divorced (happily) in one of my dresses, and lost every award she was nominated for in the next five awards seasons, without ever attracting any more snark. Plus, her appearances got her ranked in the top five at least once a season—and she was becoming known for wearing Warrior Woman Designs, which had rehabilitated her.
Snarkmeister 1: Everyone should be so lucky as to have a daughter like Caro’s. The girl never had the looks, so she studied how to make fashion accessible even for the not-so-beautiful. When you apply that fashion to the unbelievably beautiful—well, [my only-for-today-friend Snarkmeister 2], you can see the results.
Snarkmeister 2: You certainly can [Snarkmeister 1, my current-and-future rival, whom I’m only talking to because we’re getting paid a few thousand and we get to wear free clothes]. Who knew that ugly ducklings knew how to swan along a red carpet?
The positive press grew, and soon everyone wanted to wear Warrior Woman. I only have so much staff, however, and only have so much magic, so I had to choose who needed my help.
The women I dressed were too old by Hollywood standards (meaning barely over thirty), too fat by Hollywood standards (at least a size six), or too ugly by Hollywood standards (think Streisand, who [even now] gets referred to as a success despite her lack of looks).
The dresses didn’t make these women younger or thinner or prettier. The dresses made them feel protected, and warded off the snarkmeisters and their increasingly more powerful shadow puppet masters. My women were untouchable and, over time, the dresses let them relax enough that they saw what was going on with their own friends (and rivals).
I like to think the dresses let them see an echo of those shadows that haunted me.
The women talked to me about making dresses for everyone.
I couldn’t do that, but I started developing a plan.
I couldn’t get rid of the snarkmeisters and their all-powerful shadows. Complaining about them only made them stronger.
But I could send the shadows back where they came from—if I could only get my hands on some undelivered little golden men.
***Here’s something no one tells you about awards shows until it’s too late. The awards themselves are protected better than the gold at Fort Knox. (Is there still gold at Fort Knox? Oh, you get the idea.)
Seriously, I don’t think the president is guarded as well as those little trophies.
So, I had some setbacks. All I wanted to do was ward the trophies—have them repel the snarkmeisters and band together to send the shadows back through that crack in the world from which they slimed forth.
I tried everything. I worked backstage. I even volunteered to be on the trophy committee (which has a different name at each ceremony). Nada.
Finally, I decided to pay for inclusion in the goodie bag. Eighty thousand dollars worth of swag compiled just to give free stuff to already rich people. I gave a little gold man to everyone, with a coupon for a free post-Oscar collectible T-shirt wrapped around his tiny little tush.
Those shirts, which I worked on for months, sent a little bit of positive energy into the world.
But more than that, they allowed me into the dress rehearsals, partly because I extended some of that swag to the hard-working artists who put on the show.
I didn’t get to see any gold trophies, but I did see something rather horrifying.
Where the red carpet met the marble floor inside one of the most famous theaters in the world, a slight crack had formed. Not one that a structural engineer with no magic would see. A crack in the fabric of reality, the kind shadows slip out of.
And there were shadows slipping upward, like smoke from an underground fire.
I backed away, and then I called He Who Shall Remain Nameless, not because I needed his more powerful magic, but because he knew who the magical were among the electricians, contractors, and set designers in our industry.
Together, my father and I found a group with more than glamour, and who were willing to work on short notice.
I needed them to add a layer of glittery, clear paint to the gigantic gold statues that stood near the front door—and I needed them to do it legitimately.
And they did.
***Now, realize that none of the magical truly knows how magic will work. And none of us truly understands the mechanism that makes magic do what it does. We can predict, but we’re like TV weather anchors. We can get it wrong.
I expected that magical glamour, added to the statues, to suck up the shadowy forms and hold them prisoner inside those gigantic trophy replicas.
Instead, the glittery coating reflected the protective magic from the dresses worn by the actresses who had just completed the red carpet gauntlet and who were feeling a bit—cranky? Weary? Terrified?
Terrified. Because the moment they walked away from the snarkmeisters’ microphones, those women knew the snarkmeisters—under the influence of their dark shadows—would find something to snark about, ruining a night that was supposed to be about the honor of being nominated and making it into a night about whose dress fit best.
I stood just behind the emergency curtain at the edge of the red carpet, armed for a magical emergency. I had some special safety pins clamped in my teeth, a stronger-than-surgical-steel needle in my right hand, and a spool of special glittery metallic thread in my left.
I was going to repair a few dresses, reinforce the magic, and coordinate the removal of the shadows after the glare of the cameras moved inside. Instead, the glowing dresses and their lovely stars queued up, air-kissing before they mounted the stairs for a drink and a little relaxation before an usher found them and settled them in their seats.
I could feel the magic of the dresses—my magic—thrumming. Those dresses were working overtime, like all armor does in battle, protecting those fragile human bodies hidden deep inside.
I just didn’t expect the armor to link up, like protestors facing the police—using magical arms threaded at the metaphorical elbows—to hold off a darkness that was growing increasingly worse.
These women had no magic besides the kind my mother had. Just a little something extra to make them glow before the cameras. Yet, to a person, these women looked toward the snarkmeisters, lined up for a final “interview” as if the shadows had become visible.
Maybe they had.
They had certainly become powerful.
And that coating on the golden statues was doing absolutely nothing.
So I spit the pins into my left hand, took the needle, and was about to lob my magical gold thread at the shadows when the crack in the ground widened.
The statues opened their eyes, and looked—truly looked—at the shadows.
And the shadows blinked.
They started to flee, but one of the statues toppled sideways so fast that no one could move out of its way. It hit the snarkmeisters—yes—but if you look at all those replays, which you see over and over again, you’ll see that it landed on top of the place where the red carpet met the tile.
It blocked the crack into the other world.
The shadows floated around the statue in terror, and that was when the second statue seemed to absorb them. But what I saw wasn’t the absorption. It was the dozens of gold, manicured fingers, which came from the dress magic, that shoved the shadows into that statue, inside the ward that the trophy truly was.
I crouched at the toppled statue’s base, and grabbed my thread, using it and the needle to stitch the edges of the crack closed.
Then I used the last of my magic to spell that thread. It would continue sewing itself after the teamsters got the statue upright again.
The crack would—and did—close.
And our little part of the world was safe again.
***I wish I could say that snark died that day. Or that the snarkmeisters vanished.
That group did, actually. They were humiliated and/or terrified, some of them coming to their senses.
New snarkmeisters immediately rose in their wake. But honestly, I didn’t see any shadows around them.
Now, I see shadows around cell phones—in the hands of ordinary people who somehow think themselves snarkmeisters. They blog, they post, they Tweet. They have absorbed the culture of critics, and they initiate online battles as harmful as any that go over the airwaves.
I would organize an anti-snark campaign, but I have no ground to stand on, really, as you can tell from my tone.
Snark happens when you don’t respect someone, when you want to control and ridicule them to show your own superiority.
I think I might have absorbed some of the shadows on my own.
Mother tells me I need the shadows for battle. Weapons make us stronger, she says. It simply depends on how they’re used.
But I don’t like the shadows within, and I’m vowing to purge them.
After I watch that instant replay of our miraculous victory—one last time.
Fashion and The SnarkmeistersCopyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Chicks and Balances, edited by Esther Friesner and John Helfers, Baen Books, 2015Published by WMG PublishingCover and layout copyright © 2023 by WMG PublishingCover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Subbotina/Depositphotos
Full disclaimer here: I wrote longer pieces on my Patreon page and combined them together for this post. There’s a lot of learning and dithering there, as well as a fairly mediocre audio sample that you can hear if you want to join up.
I wrote those pieces in the moment, so I’m reprinting them here without changing that “in the moment” feel. I have edited for content, though, because some is no longer relevant, and some only belongs on Patreon.
So…here goes:
Sunday, March 5, 2023
I just spent a half fun few hours and a half pain in the patootie few hours. As I mentioned in the previous post, I’ve been working on AI audio. I decided I’d make a decision on the preliminary service this week.
I figured I’d do a lot of audio versions of the test blog, each from a different site. But the terms of service on some sites scared me off. On others, it was the pricing. Not the introductory pricing, but the pricing that WMG needed.
The Enterprise Tier of many of those services, which is the tier WMG would need, are often eye-crossingly expensive. Many of them include services that we don’t need…at least at the moment.
A number of the services sounded great, until I looked at how many hours of audio I would get for the price. A few of the services, in beta, were really expensive. I’d rather pay a voice actor than pay for these services.
So I ended up trying only one service, Murf. It has a good TOS (at the moment, anyway). It gave me ten free completed minutes of audio. I only used 1:17 minutes.
The free service did not let me clone my voice (not that I would have at this juncture), although I could have tried a simulation. Instead, I had the choice of two middle-aged female voices or half a dozen female young adult voices. I could also have at least two middle-aged male voices, and a bunch of middle aged young adult voices.
I chose the least objectionable middle-aged female voice, and played.
I had to work with pronunciation on some expected things, like my last name, and some unexpected things, like PayPal. The voice, at a neutral speed, sounded robotic, so I sped her up.
As I noted in the text, I had to change a number of things for clarity. I will have to do some of the audio blogs differently than I do the text blogs, which really isn’t a problem.
All in all, it took me 30 minutes to learn the system and create the 1:17 minutes of audio. I could have done the same on one of my audio programs, using my own voice, in half that time.
But I don’t expect the audio version of the blog to take longer than 30 minutes to set up. Most of that 30 minutes was me learning the program. Not a big deal, actually, and it wasn’t that hard.
I was surprised, actually. I thought it would be more difficult. Instead, I had fun.
Tuesday, March 7, 2023
In my AI Audio research, I found a lot of really good programs. Almost all of them wanted me to email them or contact them by phone to do voice cloning. Which means that voice cloning is expensive.
At the moment, I’m not into expensive. I’m going to pay a little for some of these services because I want to do the blog and a few other things, but I am not going to pay a lot.
I’m going to wait on voice cloning.
I liked what I saw from Murf.ai, and I had fun playing with their system. It didn’t take long, as I mentioned above, and the sound was good enough. (I didn’t spend extra time tweaking it, since I wasn’t sure if I was going to use the program.)
I liked the Pro Plan, but I liked the Enterprise Plan better. According to the pricing page, there was only $33 between them, so why not go with the Enterprise Plan?
Well…I didn’t click through enough.
Let’s backtrack a bit. When I initially researched the AI Audio services, I read a lot of reviews. Some services clearly curated their reviews, which means (for the handful of you who aren’t aware of this), they interact with people who had a negative experience, and then ask that the negative review get removed.
The really expensive services are more sophisticated about that. They leave the complaint, and their reply, and then get the reviewer to put up another review—a we’re all good now—review.
A few companies actually scrub the negative reviews. I’m not sure how they do that (or how much it costs) but it has always irritated me. I don’t like the way they pretend that nothing is ever wrong. Things do go wrong, but usually those things can be fixed.
Which brings us to Murf.ai. Murf does not curate their reviews on any of the sites. There is a lot of satisfaction with their audio services, enough to hearten me.
All of the complaints I found had to do with billing. Much of what I found was the kind of review I’d seen on sites for gyms that have memberships.
It’s impossible to cancel the service and get a refund
Or…
I ended up paying much more than I wanted to.
I made a mental note of that. Be careful; watch pricing. And then I forgot about it.
After doing some of the research, I decided to sign up for the Enterprise Plan. It says “$59 per user per month.” I spoke to Allyson Longueira at WMG, figuring we’d sign me up through the company since, after my exploration was done, the company would handle everything. We’d add users as needed.
Well…no.
The pricing is $59 per user per month, but with the Enterprise Plan you need to have a minimum of five users. You can’t just have one user at $59.
Then there’s this per month crap. You can’t pay monthly. You have to pay for the entire year.
Up front.
Which I was not willing to do. No way were we going to spend $3540 to experiment with a service of any kind. Especially since I wasn’t sure we’d like it.
These pricing shenanigans are all over the web. They are annoying as hell. And, according to those bad reviews, some people actually paid without looking—and were then startled that when they expected to be billed $26, say, for the Pro Plan, and instead were billed $312, they immediately wanted their money back.
They tried to get it back through Murf. I’d’ve just gone to my credit card company, but hey, not everyone knows to do that.
Anyway…
Those pricing fun and games irritated me. They always do when I run across that thing.
So I set Murf aside and investigated other companies again. Most AI Audio services want you to call them for quotes on their Enterprise Plans…and oh, yeah, you need ten or more people on the plan.
Nope. At most, we’d have five. At most. Probably two.
Some services required the customer to be a corporation. That’s not a problem for us, but that meant corporate pricing. Which is always Ye-ou-ch.
On my Patreon post, some folks mentioned they’re already using their built-in text to speech functions (in the accessibility settings) for ai assisted reading. Some people already use a text-to-speech function so they can hear the daily paper or read a website. So, these folks warned me, there might be no reason to do the blog.
Ah, maybe it’s just vanity. Maybe I’m playing. I don’t know.
But their points made me rethink a few things…and search for a text-to-speech function that I could use in the programs I already had.
I have a subscription to Adobe Audition. It has a text-to-speech function, but it’s not really designed for multiple voices. However, it does have a really nice AI Audio feature that will clean up a bad sound environment, which intrigued the heck out of me. Maybe I can record at home after all.
That would make my life easier.
But…not the blog. Because life is too short, and I get really anal about recording. And editing. And working on sound.
So if I recorded the blog myself through Audition, I’d lose two to four hours per week. Doing it with an AI voice? Maybe thirty minutes. Once the controls are set up, it might even be less.
Audition was a sidebar.
There are other sidebars, most of which I’m not going to discuss here, since they have to do with some internal company decisions. Let’s just say that the investigations continued.
I ended up cycling back to Google Play Books.
There’s a lot I don’t like in the Google AI Audio program. First, everything that is converted into audio has to be a book. Second, the audiobook is required to be on Google Play. Third, Google can change its terms of service tomorrow if it wants to, and I have no recourse. (Neither will you.)
There are, however, a few things to like.
Google Play’s interface is currently free. Or as it says on their information page:
For a limited time, there’s no charge to create, publish, and download these audiobooks.
Uh-oh. That means that at some point in the future, there will be a charge.
But right now, the service is free. Free is a good price.
The second thing to like? Right now, anyone who creates an audiobook using Google’s tech can download that audiobook (for free) and sell it on other retail platforms…as long as it’s on Google’s platform as well.
Okay, then. It costs nothing to produce an audiobook. Nothing except time, and even that will be limited.
As I dug into this, and got to thinking about it, I put my negotiator’s brain on it.
Yes, the program is free now, but it won’t always be. However, Google tests its programs for years sometimes, so the free might last a while.
But what happens if Google changes its TOS so that the books can no longer be downloaded and sold elsewhere? Suddenly those books would have to be exclusive to Google. Maybe the TOS would try to make that exclusivity retroactive. (I haven’t read closely enough to know that if the service changes, the TOS might state that those changes would have an impact on previous recordings. )
I don’t like any of that. I mentioned it to one person who said, “Well they can’t do that. What would they do? Take away all the downloads?”
Oh, probably not. But maybe. Or maybe they’d ask for a retroactive fee. Even if the (imagined) change in the TOS was legally indefensible, a certain percentage of people might pay anyway. If they did, Google would make a boatload of money.
There are a lot of what-ifs like that, and most of them are not good.
Except that there’s a recourse to most of the changes I imagined.
The recourse would be this: We could leave our audiobooks produced by Google up on Google Play and then redo the books for a different platform.
Before I made any decisions about anything with the audio, I needed to talk with Allyson at WMG. Because my imagined problems and my solutions would require a duplication of work. In other words, the books produced in 2023 might have to be redone in 2025.
Sure, the tech might be better in 2025. We might want to redo the books anyway. But we have 1,000 books. That’s a lot of time, even if each book only takes fifteen minutes.
I’m not worried about that, and neither was Allyson. Who knows what will change in the next few years. It’s a risk worth taking.
So here’s what we decided.
WMG would do the low-level audiobooks through Google’s system. (Tier 3 for those of you who read the first research blog)
I would play with all kinds of experimental audio on both Murf (for the blog) and on Adobe Audition. WMG would use Google Play to create audiobooks at Tier 3 (the good-enough tier) while we figure out how we’re going to add Tiers 2 and 1.
Here’s the problem: there’s only so much time. We have employees, but they work 40 hours per week. I work more than that on so many different projects. Dean works harder than all of us combined.
We don’t have a lot of time.
Right now, AI audio costs little in time. It will enable consumers to get an audiobook of something they don’t have time to read (or have trouble reading, due to health issues). It’s a win on that level, and is worth the effort, minimal as it is.
I’ll be putting my blogs up as audio files. They’ll go up early on Patreon, and later on this website. I need to figure out exactly how I want to do all of this, so I won’t start this week.
I’ll figure it out though, and probably blog about it. Or not. I have a few other things to work on. The world is changing so fast it’s hard to keep up. Which techno me actually finds fun.
Okay, then. I guess I’ve figured out the next few weeks.
I’ll keep you informed about what I’m doing, and how it’s all going. I’m sure there’s another post or two in the future.
We’ll just have to see.
This weekly blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynruschr4e to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: The Research (Part Two) AI Audio,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © Can Stock Photo / solarseven.
To pay off her law school debts, Kerrie works in the public defender’s office at the Interspecies Court. Her workload includes more clients than she can defend, most of them from cultures she does not understand.
The public defender’s office loses almost all of its cases, but sometimes it gets a win. Kerrie thinks she has a winner. But does she? Or will winning the case mean she loses at everything else?
“The Impossibles,” by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook from WMG Publishing here. To read more books in the Retrieval Artist series, click here.
The Impossibles:A Retrieval Artist Short StoryKristine Kathryn RuschAlarm, six a.m. Earth time—the whole damn starbase ran on Earth time. Barely a moment to rub the sleep from her eyes, roll out of her bed, and bang her knees against the wall, just like she had every morning since she graduated from law school. Not quite the top of her class. Okay, twenty-fifth. Not the middle either, not last. Near the top, close to the top. Not in the top ten or even the top twenty—not in the area where she could’ve gotten recruited by some firm, somewhere.
Didn’t matter that she went to Alliance Law, best school in the Earth Alliance, harder to get into than any school on the Moon or on Earth, harder than Harvard or Oxford or Armstrong Legal Academy. Only two hundred students qualified for Alliance Law every year, and only one hundred graduated three years later.
Those statistics meant nothing. All that mattered, apparently, was the top twenty. And Kerrie had been just five spots away from a guaranteed recruitment.
That was what she thought about every morning when her knees smacked into that wall. Then she would debate with herself: was it the 90 on her second-year contracts exam? Or the essay she had to redo five times for her Earth Alliance Agreements class? Or the party she went to that last week of first year that caused her to get up late for her Torts final, making Old Man Scott dock her two points for tardiness?
Or had she failed some indefinable thing—not volunteering for Fair Housing duty or failing to participate in Moot Court every single semester?
She didn’t know—and she cared. She had had such high expectations for herself, and she hadn’t achieved them.
Her family was happy—she was a lawyer in the prestigious Multicultural Tribunal system. But it wasn’t as glamorous as all that. It wasn’t glamorous at all—not that people outside the base, this single base dedicated almost entirely to InterSpecies Court for the First District, knew about the ugliness of the place. She had been shocked when she arrived nearly two years ago.
All newly minted lawyers arriving here for the first time were shocked. And all of them wondered what exactly led them here. Something they had done? Or something they hadn’t?
It wasn’t just the student loans. It couldn’t just be the loans, with their lovely little check-off option: Loan will be paid in full if student volunteers for public service internship post-graduation.
Everyone checked that box, and the law firms that recruited, they paid off the loan so the student didn’t have to.
Only she didn’t get recruited. No one told her that only twenty students from every class get recruited when she applied to Alliance Law. They implied—as they handed her the damn loan forms—that all students of Alliance Law got recruited.
And she supposed that was probably true if looked at in a purely legalistic sense.
She would most likely be recruited when her stint was up, two months from now. After two years here, she had more experience in InterSpecies Law than half the professors who taught the courses at law schools all over the sector.
Horrible, awful experience, but experience nonetheless.
She rubbed her knee as she grabbed the outfit she chose for today—black skirt, black suit jacket, black blouse. No need to stand out, no need to dress well. She was as interchangeable as the shuttles constantly moving between here and Helena base.
She downloaded the morning’s files through her links as she grabbed coffee from the tiny communal kitchen. The base provided almost everything: food, housing, clothing if necessary. Food and caffeine were the most important because otherwise (the base had learned) too many of the baby lawyers passed out in court. They were so busy they forgot to eat, something else Kerrie didn’t believe until she got here.
Too much work, not enough time to eat let alone think. She thought law school was bad. Law school—the best law school in the Earth Alliance—was a cakewalk compared to Earth Alliance InterSpecies Court for the First District. The Court also known as The Impossibles.
Here everything was impossible from the case load to the odds of winning. No one won, not really. The reality of the system was uglier than anyone ever imagined.
From the counter, she took a banana, which was a little longer and a little more orange than she liked. 15,000 varieties of bananas alone were grown in the base’s hydroponic gardens. The gardens stretched all along one tier of the base, providing fresh fruits and vegetables for the residents and the guests, if they could afford it. Guests who couldn’t afford fresh got the same indefinable food served to the prisoners—all of whom were on their way somewhere else, all of whom were scared, confused and, in their minds, completely innocent.
As she hurried out the door, she nearly rammed into one of the night court lawyers coming in (What was his name? Sam? She couldn’t remember and she should have, since they shared a lease). He grunted at her, so exhausted he could hardly move, and she nodded back, a little refreshed after a real night’s sleep.
Refreshed but preoccupied. As she scurried to the elevator, she sorted the twenty-five cases she had to deal with today into four categories—morning, afternoon, evening, and Please-God-Never. The Please-God-Nevers she hoped to pass up the food chain to the lifers who knew how the system worked. The lifers, who had arrived as loan-lawyers like she did, and stayed because they claimed they liked it here. The lifers, who looked five times older than they were, and who—somehow—still had just a whisper of idealism in their voices.
The idealism left her Day Three, when she had to send a toddler to the Wygnin for a crime his father committed six months before the kid was born. She couldn’t stop it. Hell, she didn’t even have time to review the file. She just had to plead and take the best deal—and in Earth Alliance InterSpecies Court there was no best deal, only a less egregious one.
The elevator took her to the main hallway for Courthouse Number One, which housed most of the InterSpecies courtrooms. There was no court “house” of course—that was just a linguistic formality from Earth. There were a lot of linguistic formalities because this place had no buildings, just floors and sections, more floors and sections than she thought possible. Floors and sections and rings—how could she forget rings? Especially when she might have to go to the jail ring later in the day, although she hoped not.
The only thing she’d scored on since she arrived here was the apartment. Hers was close to work. Some of her colleagues rode on the tram from the outer rings of the starbase, losing two hours of sleep per day because they didn’t dare doze for fear of missing their stop.
She didn’t go down the main hallway. Instead, she took a short half flight of stairs because it was easier than waiting for another elevator. The half-flight took her to the public defenders office, which had been her home away from home since she got out of law school.
After twenty-two months of actual survival—of not saying fuck it and letting Daddy or a rich cousin pay off her loan, of not prostituting herself, or telling the loan agency to stick it and take it out of her pay for the rest of her life—she actually rated a desk in the defenders office. Granted, it was in the back of the bullpen and barely as wide as the chair she got with it, but it was still a desk. Some days she saw it as a medal of honor.
Today she saw it as one stop too many in a day already overcrowded with too many stops.
She tossed the banana peel in the recycler near the door, a bit surprised she’d managed to eat at all. She had no memory of consuming that banana—and she should have. She didn’t like the long orange variety; she thought they were too bitter and citrusy to be a real banana.
Apparently she was so hungry she didn’t even notice, and besides, she was still shuffling case files in her head—trying to find the best order, one that sent her from courtroom to courtroom in a logical fashion and gave her the most possible time with clients.
She’d learned through hard experience that nothing mattered more than the schedule. Not reading the file, not figuring out which judge she faced. Finding time to meet the client, who often had a wish or an idea or a scintilla of information that might get the sentence reduced or lightened or—in a perfect universe—tossed out, although that had never happened to her or one of her clients or even to a client of anyone she had worked with.
She had heard rumors, of course. Gayle Giolotti had saved the lives of three kids on a technicality, and Sheri Hampstead actually got an acquittal by proving that the government bringing the case (Wygnin? Disty? Kerrie couldn’t remember) didn’t have the proper DNA identification of the accused.
She’d always planned to check on those rumors, but of course she didn’t have time, and now her stint was nearly up, and once she left this godforsaken place, she would have no reason to look, no reason to check, no reason to think about it ever again.
A steaming mug of coffee sat on her desk along with a pair of shoes she thought she’d lost. Her boss, Maise Blum, rested one hip on the desk’s corner, as if she planned to be there all day.
Maise was tall and thin. Forty, maybe fifty, maybe sixty, she was one of the lifers, and it showed in the frown lines etched alongside her mouth. Her long black hair, which she wore up, had a sprinkling of silver, but Kerrie couldn’t tell if that was vanity, an attempt at gravitas, or an actual hereditary detail.
“Got a case for you,” Maise said.
“Sorry,” Kerrie said. “I’m here to check in and then I’m off to Judge Weiss’s court to begin today’s sprint.”
“One case in exchange for ten of yours. I don’t even care if it’s ten of the toughies.”
That caught Kerrie’s attention. In her first month, she would have agreed without looking up. In her first year, she would have agreed without questions.
But she’d been here too long to trust a sweet deal.
“What the hell’s wrong with it?” she asked.
“It’s work,” Maise said.
“They’re all work,” Kerrie said, taking the shoes and locking them into the bottom desk drawer. She’d actually written them off more than a year ago. She had forgotten that she had loaned them to Maise for some ritzy Bar Association dinner.
“Work you should do,” Maise said. “This is your acquittal.”
Kerrie froze, mid-lock. She stood up slowly and even—for a half second—stopped multitasking her schedule. She shut down all but her emergency links, leaving only the appointment clock running along the bottom of the vision in her right eye.
“How come you don’t want it?” Kerrie asked. “You’ve never had an acquittal.”
“How do you know?” Maise asked, without a smile. Her dark eyes were so serious that Kerrie tilted her head.
“You have?”
“Not all of us talk about our successes.” Maise’s tone held bitterness, and Kerrie understood. Successes here weren’t always one-hundred-percent positive. Most of them were bittersweet.
“So why not have another one?” Kerrie asked.
“I told you. It’s work. Real work. Research work.”
Kerrie hadn’t done research work since she got here. She hadn’t had time.
“They’re all research work and none of it gets done,” she said, realizing as she spoke she sounded like a lifer. “What makes this one different?”
“The client is pregnant.”
Kerrie closed her eyes. She hated pregnancy cases. She had one a month, maybe more, and they were all heartbreaking and sad and horrible. One client asked if she should abort the fetus rather than lose the court case; another wanted to find out if Kerrie would adopt the baby herself so that the child wouldn’t be considered a firstborn.
“No,” Kerrie said. “No pregnancy cases.”
“And the client says she’s a member of the Black Fleet.”
That sent a wave of interest through Kerrie, so intense it felt like a live thing. She hadn’t had a feeling like that since law school. “She’s willing to admit that she’s part of a criminal organization to get out of an InterSpecies case?”
“Yep,” Maise said. “You want it?”
“I still don’t know why you’re not taking it.”
Maise crossed her arms. “She has her own lawyer. Peyti.”
She spit the word. The Peyti had the best legal minds in the Earth Alliance, but they could be difficult to work with. It wasn’t just their appearance, which was sticklike and gray. Their breathing masks made conversation difficult, and their insistence on following procedure to the letter usually offended the judges in the InterSpecies Courts.
The judges here had to get through as many cases as possible on a single day or backlog would overwhelm everything. And preventing backlog was as important—maybe more important—than delivering justice.
There was only so much room in the starbase’s jails and prisons, and there were only so many courts, and there was only so much time. Everyone in the First District who ran afoul with the laws of another culture brought the cases here to the special courts set up to reconcile one species’ law with another.
Technically, the cases were supposed to go through the offended culture’s courts, but everyone waived that part of the procedure so that the case could be tried in the InterSpecies courts. It wasn’t an appeals court—that was on a different starbase in a different part of the First District—but it might as well have been, given the nature of the arguments here. They were always based on procedure and technicalities, not on the facts of the case or the finer points of the law.
There was no way Kerrie could learn the case law from twenty-five different cultures for her twenty-five different cases that she had today alone. She had to wing it, and the judges knew she was winging it, and the prosecutors knew she was winging it. The formalities helped, and the commonalities helped as well. And she did try to bone up. Most of the cases involved familiar cultures—Disty, Wygnin, Rev—although occasionally she got something weird like the Gyonnese or the Ssachuss.
“Now the truth will out,” Kerrie said. “Your Peyti prejudice could get you in trouble, you know.”
“It’s not a prejudice. I just don’t have the patience to deal with them,” Maise said.
Which was as good an excuse as any, Kerrie thought but did not say. “When’s it on the docket?” Kerrie asked.
“Noon.”
“Noon?” Kerrie’s eyebrows went up. “Whose court?”
“Judge Langer.”
Kerrie rolled her eyes. “Not the easiest judge in the universe.”
“But one who will listen.”
Kerrie knew that to be true. “I take this, you take all of my cases for today.”
“No can do,” Maise said. “I have seven I can’t rearrange.”
“All right, twenty cases, my choosing.”
“I said ten.”
“I was going to say no. I still can,” Kerrie said.
“You’re intrigued.”
“Not enough to handle a tough case at noon and keep everything on my docket. Twenty cases, my choosing.”
“Fifteen,” Maise said.
“Done,” Kerrie said, and proceeded to shuffle through files. Four this morning that she hadn’t even looked at, keeping one. Three in the afternoon, and all of her evening docket—which was five. Plus three Please-God-Nevers that no one had been willing to take off her desk in more than two months.
She removed her own name as defense counsel and added Maise’s before she sent the files to Maise, just so that there was no screw-up in the court listings.
Maise sent one file so fat through Kerrie’s links that she actually got an overload warning. She had to switch the file to a different node, something she hadn’t had to do since law school.
“You didn’t tell me she was a convicted felon,” Kerrie said.
“I did too,” Maise said. “Black Fleet, remember? It’ll work out.”
“It better,” Kerrie said, but Maise had already left.
***Kerrie had to mentally shuffle files and rearrange her entire schedule. It now seemed deceptively simple: one case at 9 a.m. in Courtroom 61, and another at noon in Courtroom 495. Never mind that Courtroom 495 was about as far from the public defender’s office as possible. Never mind that Courtroom 61 was close.
Kerrie had to review the new file—she couldn’t scan this one nor could she trust the Peyti lawyer who might have more years of experience, but who had probably never ever appeared in InterSpecies Court.
And that was always a recipe for disaster.
Not to mention the client. A pregnant felon, willing to move to criminal court rather than face whatever the hell she did somewhere inside the Earth Alliance.
But Kerrie was intrigued. She wasn’t sure if that was good or bad.
Intrigued meant she’d pay attention, but intrigued also meant she could get emotionally involved.
And emotionally involved here meant heartbreak of the worst kind.
She set the thick file on AutoLearn, which would send the information directly to her brain. She hated AutoLearn, but she used it almost every day. AutoLearn didn’t give her any real understanding of the file. It didn’t even give her a good grasp of the facts. What it did was give her a sense of the file, a cursory knowledge of all of the details, which she would be able to find if she needed them during court.
The biggest problem with AutoLearn, however, was that the learning was actually time-stamped, and it would expire in two weeks if not reinforced. She usually didn’t reinforce what she AutoLearned with real learning—the cases vanished that fast—but she had a hunch she might have to do so here.
While that program fed information to her brain, she headed to holding for a moment with her other client. She let his file run in front of her left eye: Fabian Fiske, which had to be some kind of made-up name. If she had time, she’d search the file to see if he legally changed his name somewhere along the way. But she didn’t have time.
She barely had time to glance at the facts:
Fabian Fiske worked for Efierno Corporation as a construction day worker. That fact alone made her cringe. Most of the defendants she got here were construction day workers. They signed up because they needed the work and waived the right to company protection should anything go wrong.
Since construction workers usually went into strange areas before the bulk of the business itself, construction workers were more likely to break intercultural laws. And the least likely to have a good lawyer to defend them or have access to the corporation’s Disappearance services.
Here was the problem, the fact of Kerrie’s everyday life since she graduated from law school and ended up in this godforsaken place: Everyone believed that someone accused of breaking the law of another culture ended up in front of one of thirty Multicultural Tribunals—and technically that was true. Technically, Earth Alliance InterSpecies Court was a branch of the Multicultural Tribunal for the First District. In practice, there was nothing multicultural about the courts Kerrie stood before. No panel of judges from different cultures heard these cases. It wasn’t practical.
Instead, a single judge from a rotating group of judges from different Earth Alliance cultures handled cases like Fiske’s, usually with two or three questions and a pound of the gavel. If a judge didn’t act quickly, the court system would get jammed, because contrary to popular belief, people got accused of breaking other culture’s laws all the time.
That wouldn’t be a problem if the cultures weren’t so vastly different. Over its history, the Earth Alliance made treaties with a wide variety of alien cultures. Those treaties facilitated trade within the sector, making the Earth Alliance the most powerful governing body in the known universe.
But the price of those treaties was steep—at least from the human perspective. The treaties all stated that the violator of a law got punished by the culture whose law was broken. It sounded straightforward, but the differences in cultures made for punishments humans—and many aliens—did not like.
The most famous early case, and one every law school student studied, was of a man who accidentally stepped on a flower—a crime in the community where he was temporarily assigned for work—and he was sentenced to death.
That sentence was carried out.
As were thousands—millions—of others. Humans didn’t like that, and refused over time to work for the large corporations. So the corporations developed a way of skirting the law, first by hiring the best lawyers for their people, and when that didn’t work, by setting up Disappearance services, allowing the employees accused of the most egregious crimes to get a new identity, leave their lives, and slip away.
Of course, those employees either paid for the service themselves or they were high up enough in the corporate structure to qualify for a free Disappearance.
Independent Disappearance services also existed, but they were so expensive that someone who worked as a construction day worker couldn’t afford the consultation fee, let alone the price of a full Disappearance.
On her way to the holding section of the courthouse, Kerrie had to go through security—a small machine that scanned her entire body. Then she had to go through another scan as she walked through the double doors.
The scans disrupted her file review, and she had to scan backwards, missing—of course—the most important part: what, exactly, Fiske was accused of.
She didn’t have trouble finding him. He was older than the image in his file by at least two decades, but he looked like a dried out version of the man pictured. His hair was gray, his face lined, and his hands gnarled. The poorest of the poor. He couldn’t even get his hands enhanced so that he could do his job properly.
“Fabian?” she asked.
He stood, politely, and nodded at her. A man who followed rules. He wore a rumpled blue work shirt, and muddy pants that he brushed off as she walked toward him.
A trickle of compassion washed through her and she tamped it down. She couldn’t afford it, any more than he could afford to have a real defense.
“Do you have a suit?” she asked.
“No, miss,” he said, inadvertently accenting their age difference and the fact that he had no idea who she was.
“I’m sorry,” she said. “My name is Kerrie Steinmetz. I’m your lawyer. In court, you have to call me Ms. Steinmetz.”
If she let him speak at all, which she doubted she would.
“All right,” he said softly, bowing his head.
She sent a message across her links to Miguel, one of the paralegals. Need a suit from the closet, size—
She glanced at him, unable to measure, visually. She wasn’t used to seeing men with such broad torsos and such slender legs. “What size do you wear?”
“What?” Fiske blinked at her.
“Suit. And shoes. What size do you wear?”
He shrugged. He had never owned a suit.
“Clothes, then,” she said. “Shirt, pants, shoes.”
She repeated the shoes in case he was overwhelmed, and softly, he answered her, color rising in his cheeks. The kind of man who didn’t like revealing personal information. The kind of man who tried hard not to be noticed.
What the hell had he done?
She sent the information to the paralegal, then led Fiske to the chairs.
“I need you to go over this with me,” she said. “Who is accusing you again?”
“The Baharn,” he said.
She actually felt a second of hope, and tamped that down. Unlike many of the cultures she dealt with, the Baharn accepted financial fines in lieu of an actual sentence.
“And you…?” She let her voice trail off.
“Got drunk.” Fiske’s voice wobbled. “I don’t even remember it.”
“But there’s a visual, right?” she asked, not because she knew, but because that was how these things worked.
“I just passed out,” he said. “They said I touched one of their—I don’t know what they’re called. The kid of someone important.”
“Kid?” Kerrie asked before going farther. There were no fines when someone tampered with a Baharn child, no matter what caste the child belonged to.
“Teenager. Adult really, by our standards. Twenty-something. Full grown.”
She nodded, feeling a bit of relief.
“I brushed him when I passed out. What was some religious kid doing in a human bar?” His voice went up. “No one will tell me that.”
The kid had been trolling for trouble. Or a percentage of a fine. But she wasn’t going to tell Fiske that either.
“Did someone ask your companions for money to make it all go away?” she asked.
“They ran,” he said. “They left me.”
Smart people. And he had passed out.
The paralegal came in with a suit on a hanger, shoes dangling off it. “I need you to put this on for court,” Kerrie said to Fiske.
He looked at it.
“You have to dress properly for court or they won’t listen to you.”
He took the clothes. “Where do I—?”
There were no private areas. She nodded toward a back corner. “Over there,” she said. “We won’t look.”
She thanked the paralegal and told him to wait for a second, then turned her back as Fiske changed, using that moment to review the visual. It went down exactly as he said, except that the “kid”—a long horned tentacled creature so wide that he didn’t fit into a human chair—had hovered near the bar, clearly trolling.
She couldn’t use that as an argument—that was an appeals argument or something that actually would have to go in front of a real Multicultural Tribunal with an expensive defense attorney arguing the case. Fiske didn’t have the money for that and she didn’t have the time.
Then she looked at the fine, and frowned.
Fiske came back, shuffling in the shoes. They didn’t quite fit him. He looked lost. He was lost, although not as lost as he had been before.
“You need to pay the fine,” she said to him.
He shook his head. “I can’t afford it.”
She didn’t insult him by telling him it was a small fine. To her, it was a small fine. To him, it probably was a fortune.
“You can’t afford not to,” she said. “If you go in front of the judge and you don’t pay the fine, he’ll send you to Baharn lock-up. Then someone will brush against you and the fine will go up. By the time you leave that place, you will have accidentally touched half a dozen Baharn, and each time, you’ll receive a brand new fine.”
“They can’t do that,” he said.
“Of course they can. You’re already considered guilty of the crime. You’ve just compounded it. You get five years for every unpaid fine. After two weeks, you’ll probably have forty years to serve. And after a month….” She shook her head, then softened her voice. “It’s a death sentence, Fabian. You have to pay the fine.”
“I can’t,” he said. “I don’t have work. I don’t have the money. My family will be destitute.”
“What will happen to them if you are in prison for the rest of your life?” she asked.
He lowered his head.
In a gentler tone, she said, “The court will put you on a payment plan. You can pay as little as you like, and you can stretch the payments out for the rest of your life, but that’ll keep you out of a Baharn prison.”
He raised his head, his eyes wide. “I thought you could get me out of this. I was drunk. Can’t we go to the judge and say it was an accident?”
“We can,” she said. “He won’t listen. And honestly, can you prove it?”
“What?” Fiske asked, clearly shocked.
“Can you prove that you didn’t brush against that Baharn on purpose?”
“I was drunk,” he said. “I passed out.”
“Can you prove that?” she asked. “Were tests conducted at the scene?”
“I don’t know,” he said. “But my friends—”
“Ran. And they’re not on this starbase, and you don’t have the money to send for them. It’ll cost more to bring them here than the entire fine with penalties and interest. Pay the fine, Fabian.”
He swallowed.
“Or spend the rest of your life in a Baharn prison. Those are your choices.”
He shook his head.
“Decide now, Fabian,” she said, glad he had an unusual name, because she could remember it. She used to give her clients time to make a decision, but then she realized it wasn’t worth it. That took time away from other clients. “This is your last chance.”
“If you were me,” he started, “what would you—”
“I’d pay the fine,” she said. Then she put a hand on his back and shoved him toward the paralegal. “Miguel will take you to the court. I’m sending the filing ahead. You’ll have to sign and set the payment schedule.”
Then she sent the filing before Fiske had a chance to say anything else.
Her gaze met the paralegal’s. “He’s due in Judge Weiss’s court at 9 a.m. Take him to the clerk, fill out the last few details, and for godsake, make sure he’s off the docket. If you fail to take him off the docket, I’ll fire you myself, is that clear?”
The paralegal nodded, looking scared. She’d made that same threat last week to a different paralegal who was now no longer employed with the Public Defenders office. Unlike some of the other attorneys, she carried out her threats. There was no room for error here—and she had learned that the hard way.
She extended her hand. Fiske took it hesitantly.
“Stay on Earth or the Moon from now on, Fabian,” she said. “Don’t go near unfamiliar cultures, and I promise. Things will get better from here.”
Then she let go, gave him a half smile, and left holding, feeling jubilant. She didn’t let Fiske see her face because he wouldn’t understand. The paralegal probably didn’t either, but this was what passed for a win in Earth Alliance InterSpecies Court—and she had learned early to celebrate these wins, because they were all she had.
Of course, if she were the superstitious type, she would have wondered if this win boded ill for the morning’s other big case.
But she wasn’t superstitious. She wasn’t going to let one tiny victory color the rest of her day.
***Since she didn’t have to go to court at 9 a.m., she was free to see her new client. Prisoners didn’t get transferred to the holding area until an hour before trial, so she had to go to the jail. As she left, she sent a message down her links to have her client moved to the interview room.
Two tram rides, jam-packed with lawyers and paralegals and law clerks, all heading to the jail to do something at the last minute before someone’s court appearance. Had she taken two more trams, heading to the prison part of the base, she would have also encountered family, friends and hangers-on, but fortunately she wasn’t going there. She didn’t need to see any of that anyway.
The trams went through tunnels drilled deep in the base, far away from the outer rings. Transportation on the outer rings belonged to the shuttles to Helena Base. From Helena, people could go anywhere in the sector.
But security learned early on that running the shuttles and the trams on similar tracks facilitated jail breaks. So the tram system got moved to the deepest part of the base.
Since there was nothing to look at, Kerrie reviewed the case as best she could. But she had barely looked at any of the files by the time she reached the jail. She used the lawyer’s entrance, pressing her hand against the door all the way in. Her identification opened those doors, but didn’t stop the full-body scans, searching her for a weapon.
She’d learned to ignore that, even when the scans got invasive. Instead, she simply went deep inside her own mind, studying the cases, preparing for the next court session.
She stepped into the interview area, walled off from the rest of the jail by thick walls and soundproof barriers. A guard met her, called her by name, and took her down a corridor she had never seen before.
She expected to be in the large communal interview room, where privacy shields lowered over the table where she would sit with her client. She would have been able to see all the other lawyers talking to their clients, but not hear them.
Instead, the guard led her to a tiny room, made of the same clear material as the privacy shield. But a long table was bolted to the floor here, along with four chairs and a very visible panic button, in case she needed out. The door to the prisoner’s wing was reinforced with shields and warnings, and the door on her side had some kind of prod attached that would zap the prisoner if he even tried to get out.
As she let herself in, she saw that the Peyti lawyer had already arrived, even though she hadn’t asked for him. Her only indication of the Peyti’s gender was his clothing, suit, tie, pants, even though Peyti culture didn’t require those things at all. It showed the Peyti was sensitive to human conventions, and thought it important that humans know that about him.
He was stick-like, so thin that he looked like he was about to break. His breathing mask covered the lower half of his face, and the three long thin fingers on his right hand tapped the tabletop rhythmically.
He had no patience, which was unusual in a Peyti. And he was not as tall as the average Peyti.
She felt her heart sink. He was young—hence the clothing, the worries about what someone else would think, and the impatience.
She opened the door.
“I’m Kerrie Steinmetz,” she said. “I’m the public defender your client requested.”
He stood and extended his right hand.
“Uzvik,” he said, voice so soft she could barely hear him. She understood why Maise hated working with the Peyti. They were hard to hear, for one thing, and for another, their names were confusing. Most Peyti she’d met had “Uz” in their names somewhere. She would have to be careful not to use the wrong suffix when she spoke to him.
She took the fingers gently in her own. They felt like bendable chopsticks. She had learned not to shake them or even grip them too hard. She didn’t want to cause him pain.
She held the fingers for the requisite fifteen seconds, then let go. “I’m a bit confused, Uzvik. Public defenders get assigned for clients who can’t pay. Yet you’re here.”
He tilted his head, a sign of sadness among the Peyti. “I am not being paid. It is a courtesy.”
“For whom?” she asked.
“My client,” he said.
“If you are not being paid, how is she your client?” Kerrie asked.
“Someone must stand by her,” he said softly.
Crap. A loyal companion. She hated those. “Do you belong to the Multicultural Tribunal Bar?”
“No,” he said so softly she could barely hear him.
“What’s your specialty, then?”
“Criminal law,” he said.
“With a specialty in what?” she asked.
“Piracy,” he said, and if he had been human, his tone of voice would have made her think he was embarrassed by that.
“Then you’re completely out of your jurisdiction and your presence here compromises my attorney-client confidentiality. You’re going to have to leave.”
He nodded and stood. “She is not guilty of this.”
Kerrie would be rich if she got paid for every time someone said that to her. “You know as well as I do that it doesn’t matter here.”
He tilted his head, his big eyes sad. “I thought it does matter. There are stories—”
“From the Multicultural Tribunal,” she said. “Not from Earth Alliance InterSpecies Court. Here you’re guilty unless there’s a technicality.”
“She is not a citizen of the Earth Alliance,” he said.
“I know that,” Kerrie said. “I thought that was a point in her favor until I saw her sheet. She’s a convicted criminal.”
“Ah,” he said, his eyes narrowing in a Peyti equivalent of a smile. “But she is not.”
“Not what?”
“Convicted. You have not looked closely at the file, have you?”
“I just got it this morning,” Kerrie said.
His brow wrinkled. “She has been here for two weeks. We put in the request before the prison ship brought her here.”
Kerrie shrugged. She’d heard that complaint before too. “The wheels of justice turn slowly.”
He looked alarmed. He extended those strange fingers just as the announcement came through her links. She had to sit down, hands on the table, because her client was coming into the room.
“I need you out of here,” Kerrie said.
“I can be of assistance. Co-counsel.”
“You’re not certified to practice in this court,” she said. “And because I know you’re not certified, that won’t invalidate her pleadings. So no more tricks. Get the hell out.”
He didn’t wait for her to repeat herself. He scurried past her and pulled open the main door.
“And don’t stand in the corridor where she can see you,” Kerrie said. “I’ll file a complaint with the authorities of the jail and you’ll lose all visiting privileges.”
He bowed his head, then let himself out. She turned slightly so that she could see him disappear down the hall.
Then the warning echoed through her links again. She sat straight, regulation position, as the door opened and her client entered.
She was smaller than Kerrie expected, heartbreakingly thin in the manner of those raised in zero gravity. She moved slowly, clearly unused to and uncomfortable in Earth-normal gravity.
The pregnancy didn’t help. She was in her third trimester, but how far along was hard to determine given her thinness. Her belly would look huge at six months let alone nine.
“Where’s Uzvik?” she asked.
“He can’t be here,” Kerrie said. “He’s not certified for this court.”
The girl sat down heavily, one hand on her belly. She looked disappointed.
“If that was a strategy, it was a stupid one,” Kerrie said. “I could be disbarred for letting him second chair.”
“You could pretend you didn’t know.”
Kerrie wondered how many times this girl had asked someone to “pretend” they didn’t know something for a court case.
“Is that how he’s gotten you acquitted in all those other cases?”
The girl shrugged, unwilling to answer. Smart. Because Kerrie would have to file amended petitions, stating she had knowledge of actions contrary to the legal ethics.
“I don’t know how things work in the Frontier,” Kerrie said, referring to the part of the section where the Black Fleet had almost free range. “But here, following the rules matters.”
It was all they had, really, even though she felt like a hypocrite saying so. The rules didn’t work for almost everyone coming through the system—particularly when cases like Fiske’s had to be considered victories.
“I’m not exactly sure what you thought you’d gain by bringing him along,” Kerrie said in a tone harsher than she would usually use with a client so early in their discussion. “Your problem is with the Ziyit. They punish theft pretty simply. All you’ll lose is a hand, one I’m sure your people in the Black Fleet can afford to replace. Your baby isn’t at threat, and you’re probably not going to go to prison. The Ziyit don’t believe in incarceration.”
“I can’t afford replacement,” she said. “I can’t afford medical treatment at all.”
Kerrie sighed and leaned back. She hated clients who lied to her. “The Black Fleet can afford anything it wants. It also has—from everything I’ve heard—some of the best medical facilities in the known universe. You can get the hand replaced. It’ll be so perfect, your kid won’t know what happened.”
The girl shook her head. “I can’t. Don’t you know how this works? The Ziyit will cut off my hand, and then they won’t tend to me. They won’t even let me bring in a doctor to treat. Then they’ll send me away for treatment. The blood loss alone could kill me. It’ll probably kill my baby.”
“So use an AutoBandage and make sure someone from the Fleet is nearby. One ship won’t matter,” Kerrie said. “The Ziyit don’t care. They want the hand as a trophy. They’ll display it as a deterrent. As interspecies punishments go, it’s a relatively light one. They don’t even care if your ship waits for you. They won’t do anything to stop you from going there to get medical treatment. They’ll just deny you treatment in their facilities which, I have to tell you, is a good thing.”
“You don’t understand,” the girl said, rubbing her belly. “I can’t go to the Fleet. They’ve tossed me out.”
Kerrie stared at her, and resisted the urge to shake her head. That changed everything. It explained why the Peyti lawyer wasn’t getting paid. It explained the strange tactic as well.
Because the girl was in legal limbo. She wasn’t a member of the Earth Alliance, so she had no access to Earth Alliance medical facilities unless she could pay for them. And her presence here meant that she couldn’t pay for them.
She was right; even with AutoBandages, she’d bleed out before she got to a site that would allow someone impoverished access. That might take days, maybe weeks. Shipboard methods might keep her alive, but they wouldn’t keep both her and the baby alive.
“I suppose you’re guilty,” Kerrie said.
The girl shrugged again, and Kerrie mentally cursed Maise. An acquittal. Yeah, that was going to happen. Instead, Maise had used her known prejudice against Peyti to pass off a nightmare case, one that would haunt Kerrie’s dreams for the rest of her life. She’d lose, not just the girl, but the baby too.
“Why did the Fleet abandon you?” Kerrie asked.
The girl looked down. “Because I got caught,” she said.
***The story went like this:
The girl—whose name was Donnatella Waltarie—got a job working as human consultant to a Ziyit family that would be traveling into the Earth Alliance in a diplomatic role. The female head of the household (there were multiple females with multiple roles in Ziyit families) had received an appointment as the Ziyit ambassador to Messner at the far end of the sector.
It was a political appointment, given as patronage, not because the Ziyit female had any particular knowledge of the Earth Alliance or human culture. Donnatella was to tutor the younger females in human customs—and she did, for nearly two months.
Two months gave her time to find the Blueglass Stone, a famous piece of Ziyit jewelry that had an outsized value on the black market because of its rarity. Donnatella didn’t say, but implied, that the Fleet had a buyer for the Stone.
On her last day with the Ziyit family—as they packed for their trip—she slipped the Stone into one of her pockets. She received her pay from the Ziyit family, took a shuttle to an outlying space station, and then rejoined the Fleet. The Stone left with her.
“But you said you got caught,” Kerrie said.
The girl’s lips twisted, as if she didn’t want to discuss that moment. Kerrie would have to push her. Instead, she mentally scanned the file she had absorbed and got her answer.
The theft—caught on surveillance equipment—happened four years before the arrest.
Add to that the abandonment by the Black Fleet, and Kerrie had an inkling as to what was going on behind the scenes.
“Whose baby are you carrying?” Kerrie asked.
“It’s not important,” the girl said.
“I think it is. It’s the reason all of this is happening to you. The Black Fleet abandoned you because its leaders had to choose sides—and you lost.”
The girl shrugged. “That won’t get me out of this mess. Even I know enough about the legal system here to know that.”
“Won’t the baby’s father send a ship to help you with the medical part of your sentence?” Kerrie asked.
The girl’s lips thinned. “No.”
“And your parents—?”
“Dead,” she said.
Kerrie frowned. “The Ziyit have images of you stealing the Stone. Then you got dumped so that you would be arrested here.”
The girl nodded.
“If the punishment is carried out properly, you’ll die or the baby will.”
The girl leaned back, pretending calm, although she wasn’t calm.
“Which will solve someone’s problem with you in the Black Fleet, is that correct?”
The girl nodded once, as if she didn’t want to.
Kerrie didn’t want her to. She didn’t want to know any of this because this girl, Donnatella, was right. It made no difference to Kerrie’s job or the case before her.
The loss of a hand was a light sentence in InterSpecies Court because hands could be replaced. It was more traumatic to humans than it was to Ziyits who had twenty-six different appendages that could be considered hands. But humans—generally—survived the loss.
If Kerrie argued the case properly, she might get some consideration for Donnatella’s condition—extra bandages, the presence of the Peyti when the sentence was carried out.
But that didn’t solve the underlying problem. The girl had no money, and no way to get medical treatment inside the Alliance. She would get none on Ziyita, where the sentence would get carried out. And she couldn’t afford transportation off the planet. The Alliance couldn’t provide the transportation.
Donnatella—and her baby—would die there.
“You don’t deny that you stole the Stone,” Kerrie said.
The girl shrugged. “I am a thief for the Black Fleet. Or I was. I am good at what I do.”
So was the Peyti, because he got her acquitted time and time again.
“You were born on one of the Black Fleet’s ships,” Kerrie said. “Outside of the Earth Alliance.”
“On the ship, yes,” the girl said. “Where I don’t know. The ships never keep track of where the children are born.”
So she truly was not a member of the Earth Alliance, although Kerrie couldn’t prove that. The Black Fleet also didn’t issue birth certificates.
Kerrie leaned back, frowning, wondering if that lack of proof would help her get Donnatella to a medical facility.
Probably not. Because judges in InterSpecies Court always wanted proof, particularly when an attorney tried something original.
Which Kerrie would be doing here.
She had no proof—none—of Donnatella’s citizenship. Or did she? She had files to check.
She stood. “You need to be in court at noon. Clean up. Dress well, and say nothing.”
“You’re going to send me to the Ziyit, aren’t you?” the girl asked.
For the first time, she seemed scared.
Kerrie knew better than to soothe her. Anything could happen in court, no matter how much an attorney planned. And when the deck was stacked against her, the way it was in InterSpecies Court, only a fool made promises.
“I won’t send you to them,” Kerrie said. “The judge will.”
And then she left.
***She had cleared her schedule of court appearances but not of cases. She was still buried, just not as momentarily busy. Still, there was always more to do.
Before she took the tram back, she saw two more of her clients stuck in jail. Normally, she wouldn’t have had a chance to see them before they arrived in holding. This time, however, she was able to take their measure—not just of their appearances, but their willingness to plead. Of course, they both thought she could get them off and when she told them she couldn’t, they asked if she could find a Disappearance service for them.
Technically, she said piously, because she always had to say this piously, Disappearance services for people in your situation break the law. I can’t break the law or I would lose my law license.
As she rode back, she wondered if losing her license would be a bad thing. What was she doing, after all? Just processing people for various governments, sending them away. Getting them through the system so that they could receive punishment for crimes many of them didn’t even understand.
She forced herself to review Donnatella’s files instead of think. She searched and as she searched, she found what she was looking for. Her stomach knotted.
In nearly two years, she had never tried anything like this. But it was, as Maise said, her one chance at an acquittal.
She had to try.
***Courtroom 495 was Kerrie’s least favorite courtroom in the entire InterSpecies Court system. Despite its number, it was one of the older courtrooms, small and cramped, with a low ceiling, dark faux wood walls, and benches that hadn’t been upgraded since the courtroom was built. A small dock separated the prosecution and defense table from the benches and from the jury box.
But there hadn’t been a jury seated in this courtroom in decades. Jury trials were so rare here they had become a spectator sport and as such had moved to the larger courtrooms in the center of the so-called courthouse.
No one sat in those seats, however, making the courtroom oddly packed in all areas except one. The chairs even looked new there, which Kerrie always thought somewhat sad. She found it a commentary on the system eating everyone alive.
She arrived ten minutes early. Ten minutes early and she had even managed lunch. Lunch on the tram—cold sandwiches made of mystery food—but still more than she got on many afternoons.
As the court clerk called her case, Kerrie moved to the defense table. The bailiff went to holding to get Donnatella Waltarie. The Peyti, Uzvik, had a seat in the front row. He must have been there since Kerrie made him leave the jail.
The bailiff brought Donnatella into the courtroom. She looked well-scrubbed, but tired. Her face was pale, with deep shadows under her eyes. Kerrie wondered if she had been crying.
She stopped at the defense table, but didn’t sit down, hands clasped protectively over her belly. She had been to court before. She knew this wouldn’t take long enough to make it worth her time to struggle into a chair, and then struggle out of it again.
Judge Langer glowered from the bench. She was fifty something, with hopes of moving up to real Multicultural Tribunal cases, not these quick gavel-pounders. Kerrie had stood before her twice before, and learned that Langer tolerated no delays, no nonsense. But she did treat the lawyers equally, which was something most judges didn’t do. Most judges favored the prosecution, because the law did.
The prosecutor, Peir Hroth, had graduated from law school at the same time as Kerrie. He too had loans to pay off. He too was doing his time here. He had opted for prosecution because he hoped to become a judge one day—and defense attorneys rarely (never) made it into important judgeships.
He had lost weight since he got here, and he looked even more tired than he had on the shuttle from Helena Base.
He glanced at Kerrie and nodded, one of the few prosecutors she had known before coming to InterSpecies Court who still remained cordial to her.
The court clerk called out the case number, and read the charges. Then the judge asked Kerrie, “Do you dispute?”
“We do, Your Honor,” Kerrie said, stepping forward. “We ask that the charges get dropped.”
A dispute never caught anyone’s attention. Attorneys disputed the nature of the charges all the time, trying to lower the punishment. But when Kerrie asked that the charges get dropped, the murmur of conversation behind her—something she was so used to that she hadn’t noticed it—ceased.
Everyone was staring at her, from Peir to the bailiff to her client.
And the judge, of course.
“Did I hear you correctly, counselor?” the judge asked.
“Yes, Your Honor.”
The judge leaned forward, her eyes glazed like people’s often were when they reviewed something through their links. Kerrie knew the judge was scanning the file.
“I see nothing to dispute here, counselor. The prosecution has a video of the crime.”
Peir stepped forward, probably to argue that they had overwhelming evidence against Donnatella. But Kerrie didn’t want him to get a word in.
“Yes, Your Honor,” Kerrie said. “We do not dispute that the crime happened.”
She heard a squeak of protest to her left. Donnatella didn’t like that argument. But Kerrie didn’t consult with her. Kerrie didn’t have to, not on this.
“We dispute that the charges apply,” Kerrie said.
“It’s a theft, Your Honor,” Peir said. “Of course they apply.”
The judge waved her hand at him, silencing him. She looked intrigued, which relieved Kerrie—until she heard the judge’s next words. “I hope you have a good reason to use the court’s time on this, counselor.”
“I do, Your Honor,” Kerrie said. “Donnatella Waltarie is not a member of the Earth Alliance. Our treaties with the Ziyit do not apply to her. We cannot send her into their justice system because we have no right to do so.”
“She’s a member of the Black Fleet,” Peir said, giving Kerrie a sideways glance filled with disbelief. “Just because she’s part of the Black Fleet doesn’t mean she’s not a member of the Earth Alliance. She could have joined them at any point in her life. Besides, Your Honor, her undisputed affiliation with the Black Fleet proves that she is a criminal and that she is willing to lie to achieve her own ends. Defense counsel is a nice person; she has probably decided this is the best way to help a pregnant client avoid a criminal prosecution.”
Kerrie’s eyebrows went up. Did he just call her a nice person? In front of the judge? The argument diminished Kerrie’s standing as an attorney by questioning her judgment. Her cheeks flushed. The comment made her angry, as it was probably designed to do.
Instead of lashing back at Peir, she said, “I am honored that the prosecutor believes I am a nice person. I hope the court clerk will keep that in the record—”
Chuckles rose behind her. Others had caught the slight.
“—because it is court records that we are relying upon here,” she said. “My client has been accused of many crimes. She has faced a judge or a jury on twelve separate occasions, and in each case, she has been acquitted.”
“That’s lovely for her, Your Honor,” Peir said, “but those cases have no relevance—”
“If you would let me finish, counselor,” Kerrie said. She paused so the judge could weigh in. Peir’s behavior was unorthodox in open court, but so was hers. The judge had probably forgotten what it was like to have an argument placed before her, with its rules and structures. All of her other cases on this day, in this week—hell, in this year— would be pro forma gavel-down cases: Two speeches, one by each attorney, a ruling, followed by a curt next. Nothing this elaborate had happened in this court in a long time.
The judge did not speak up. She was watching Kerrie closely, clearly waiting.
“In all twelve of those cases, Your Honor,” Kerrie said, “my client stated that she was not a member of the Earth Alliance, that she had been born on a ship of the Black Fleet outside Earth Alliance territory. All twelve cases have been adjudicated in Earth Alliance courts. All twelve have court records, and judgments were made based upon the facts presented in those cases. In short, Your Honor, we have twelve different courts, scattered throughout the sector and the Earth Alliance itself, that have ruled that my client is not a subject of the Earth Alliance.”
The courtroom was quiet now. Everyone stared at Kerrie, including Peir. He had a look of panic in his eyes. He had no idea how to argue this, or what to even say.
“Those twelve cases were human-on-human crime cases, Your Honor, which fall under Earth Alliance jurisdiction no matter whether the accused is part of the Alliance or not,” Kerrie said. “This is the first case in which my client has been accused of theft against a nonhuman member of the Earth Alliance. Different laws apply. These laws are based on treaties between the Earth Alliance and the Ziyit. My client is not subject to those treaties since she belongs to neither culture. I can cite case law, Your Honor, if you would like. Jurisdictional issues were argued in the first years of the Multicultural Tribunals and they found—”
“I’m familiar with the law, counselor.” The judge looked bemused. “I have looked at the court cases, and you are right. Your client is not a member of the Earth Alliance. We have no choice but to drop the charges against Donnatella Waltarie You are—”
“Your Honor!” Peir took an extra step forward, his voice filled with panic. “We ask that Ms. Waltarie be detained, so that we can ship her to the Ziyit so that they may prosecute her for these crimes.”
“Have the Ziyit made an extradition request?” the judge asked.
“Um, no, Your Honor. But once they hear of this, they will—”
“I cannot rule on what someone will do, Counselor. I can only rule upon the cases in front of me. That’s covered in the first week of law school. Are you in need of a refresher course?”
“No, Your Honor.” Peir stepped back. “I’m sorry, Your Honor. But—”
“If you can figure out a reason to hold her, do so, counselor,” the judge said. “But I won’t rule on it. This case is dismissed.”
She brought her gavel down and the courtroom erupted. People began talking, laughing, shouting. Even the bailiff looked bemused.
Kerrie turned to Donnatella. “We have to get you out of here before they have a chance to contact someone on Ziyit.”
Donnatella blinked at her, looking confused. “I’m free?”
“You are, unless they can get an extradition order. So let’s go.”
“How do I get out off the base?” Donnatella asked. “They brought me by shuttle.”
“The shuttles are free and run every hour.” Kerrie took Donnatella’s arm and shepherded her toward the aisle. People were grabbing at them, asking questions and trying to talk. No one had had an acquittal this year—and technically, this wasn’t one either. It was a dismissal. But the result was the same.
Donnatella wouldn’t be punished for her crime.
“The shuttle will take me where?” Donnatella asked.
“Helena base,” Kerrie said. “It’s the nearest stop and large enough for you to get lost in. Come on.”
She looked for the Peyti, but didn’t see him. He would probably meet them at the shuttle station. She hurried Donnatella out of the courtroom and to the lawyers’ elevator. As she got in, Kerrie ordered the doors closed so no one could follow them.
She didn’t stop at the usual courthouse shuttle station stop. Instead, she went down to the public defender level, crossed the hall, and took another elevator. Donnatella had to struggle to keep up.
“Where are we going?” she asked.
“Somewhere they won’t look for you.” Kerrie took one flight of stairs down and walked through two doors. The second door opened to a small shuttle station. The red numbers above the door said the next shuttle was due to arrive in five minutes.
Donnatella stopped beside her, red-faced and breathing hard, her hand protectively over that stomach. She didn’t say anything, though, about troubles, so Kerrie didn’t ask.
She needed to get Donnatella on that shuttle.
“You will talk to no one once you board,” Kerrie said. “If someone asks your name, you pretend not to hear the question. Move away. Do not identify yourself. There are no conductors or bots to take tickets. Don’t let anyone trick you. If you don’t identify yourself, they can’t serve you with an extradition order. You don’t need to identify yourself at the other end either. When you get there, just mingle with the crowd. Do you understand?”
“Yes.” Donnatella’s expression had lightened. She was almost smiling.
“Do you have money?” Kerrie asked, silently cursing herself for even thinking of the question.
“I can get it,” Donnatella said.
“That’s what I’m afraid of.” The last thing Kerrie needed was for Donnatella to steal money on Helena base and get caught. Then she’d be served that extradition order. Kerrie needed Donnatella to get as far away from here, as quickly and easily as possible. “Do you have access to your own money?”
Donnatella smiled. “I don’t have any money of my own.”
Kerrie extended a hand. Donnatella looked down.
“Take my hand,” Kerrie said.
Donnatella did. Kerrie pressed the unlinked money chip in her thumb. The unlinked account had no personal information on Kerrie at all. Just funds. It transferred its entire reserve into Donnatella’s account. The entire reserve sounded like a lot, but Kerrie only used that account for incidentals. It had maybe one hundred credits.
“Now you have your own money,” Kerrie said, letting go of Donnatella’s hand.
“That was yours?” Donnatella asked.
“Yes,” Kerrie said. The red numbers on the wall were counting down. The shuttle was only one station away. “Now it’s yours.”
“But you didn’t have to do that.” Donnatella’s smile had faded. She looked shocked.
“Yes, I did,” Kerrie said. The shuttle pulled up, doors slid open. The nearest car only had two passengers, both of whom looked exhausted. Family members of people on trial, probably.
“But—”
“Stop arguing and board,” Kerrie said. “Remember what I told you.”
“I owe you,” Donnatella said as she climbed through the doors, using one hand to brace herself.
“No, you don’t,” Kerrie said.
“I do,” Donnatella said with great emphasis. “And my people always repay our debts.”
The doors swished closed. Donnatella stood by the window. She waved as the shuttle pulled out.
Kerrie watched it disappear. It had one more stop before it detached from the base and flew the short hop to Helena base. One hundred credits wouldn’t get Donnatella far on Helena. It had two segments—the rich resort side and the cheap side that connected to the InterSpecies Court starbase. Donnatella couldn’t afford an upscale hotel room there, but she could get herself a meal and maybe a low-rent place to stay. There were also good medical facilities on Helena that wouldn’t turn away a woman about to give birth.
Kerrie let out a small sigh, then put a hand to her forehead.
She hadn’t ever sent a client back on a shuttle. Just sobbing family members and disappointed friends.
She staggered back up the stairs, feeling lightheaded. She had won the morning, but she still had the afternoon and the evening to suffer the usual defeats.
As she walked to the public defenders office, she sorted the afternoon and evening cases, surprised at how light her workload was. She had forgotten that she had traded most of it for Donnatella’s case.
Kerrie actually had time to get some real coffee before her next client meeting.
Maise stopped her before she reached her desk. Maise was smiling. “Come with me. You know the rules, right?”
Of course Kerrie knew the rules. Her job was about the rules. But she couldn’t think about what applied at the moment.
Maise led her into the main conference room. It was stacked with empty coffee cups and discarded clothes that needed cleaning. The room smelled faintly of sweat and old food.
Maise closed the door.
“When you win a case,” Maise said, “your debt is forgiven. You’re free to go if you want, Kerrie.”
Kerrie frowned. She had forgotten that rule, or maybe she never really believed it. Or she thought it wouldn’t apply, because no one ever won.
“But I would stay at least another week if I were you,” Maise said. “You’re about to be recruited like no one gets recruited. Not even the number one graduate of Alliance Law gets pursued like you’re about to. Someone is first in their class every year, but almost no one wins on the defense side in InterSpecies Court unless they’re already a lifer. You’ve hit the jackpot, Kerrie.”
Kerrie sat down. She had just sent a pregnant girl with no prospects to a resort she couldn’t pay for, and that was a win? Kerrie made herself breathe.
“I’m going to be the first to recruit you,” Maise said. “We need people like you to stay here, to fight the good fight. Most of the good attorneys go on to private practice, but the people who need us cycle through every day. And if you win a case—”
“You said I would win,” Kerrie said. “That’s why you gave me that case.”
“I hoped,” Maise said. “We get cases like that every now and then. But not everyone pulls out the win. You did.”
Kerrie looked at her. A lifer? Here? Always behind, always scrambling, watching people who really didn’t deserve their punishments shuffle away, never to be seen again.
“Thanks for the offer,” Kerrie said. “I’ll consider it.”
She lied, of course. She couldn’t do it. But she didn’t want to say any more, not when Maise had orchestrated this.
“I can move someone to your afternoon cases,” Maise said. “You can take the rest of the day off.”
Kerrie shook her head. “You said I could leave if I wanted to.”
“You can,” Maise said. “But as I said, if you stay one week—”
“I will,” Kerrie said. “I’ll stay that week.”
Because it was easier to stay and think than it was to flee just like Donnatella did.
Besides, Kerrie hadn’t given life after this job much thought. She hadn’t had time, for one thing, and for another, she had had no idea who would recruit her, and if they didn’t, what she wanted to do. Apparently, she was going to get recruited now. And that alone made her a little shaky.
“I’ll take my cases for the day,” Kerrie said. “But ease me out of the rest of the week.”
“Done,” Maise said.
Kerrie nodded, stood, and stopped. “Thanks,” she said.
“Don’t thank me,” Maise said, and somehow that didn’t sound like a perfunctory statement. Maise really didn’t want credit. Probably because of her bigotry against the Peyti. Or maybe because she hadn’t known exactly how to approach the case herself.
Kerrie let herself out of the room. She’d buy herself a coffee somewhere else. She had time for once.
She murmured thanks to her colleagues as they congratulated her, a number of them touching her arm as if her good luck could rub off on them.
As she stepped outside of the office, a movement beside the door caught her eye.
The Peyti, Uzvik, straightened. He had been sitting there, and apparently he had been waiting for her.
“I already put Donnatella on the shuttle,” Kerrie said. “She’s probably in Helena now. I’m sure you can find her there.”
“I did not come to see her,” he said in his soft voice. It sounded hollow because of the breathing mask. “I came to see you.”
Kerrie frowned. “Me?”
Uzvik nodded. “I have come to offer you work.”
She stopped in the middle of the hallway. “Work?”
“The Black Fleet needs lawyers,” Uzvik said.
“I’m sure they do,” Kerrie said. “But I know nothing of Black Fleet law. I’m not even sure there is any.”
“For their interactions with the Earth Alliance,” Uzvik said.
She tilted her head, uncertain what he was saying. “You’re recruiting me to work for the Black Fleet?”
“We pay our lawyers more than any other group. You cannot even make this much in private practice. You wouldn’t even work that hard.”
“I don’t understand,” Kerrie said. “What do you want with me?”
“You have proven yourself to be creative and flexible, two things the Black Fleet needs in its attorneys. Most lawyers cannot find the loophole that you discovered in this case. You are gifted, counselor.”
Gifted. Most lawyers. It took her a moment to process what he was saying.
“You were never here for Donnatella, were you?” Kerrie asked. “This was some kind of test, wasn’t it?”
“Yes,” Uzvik said.
“And if I failed, what then?” Kerrie asked. “Would Donnatella have gone to the Ziyit?”
“Yes,” Uzvik said.
“You were willing to sacrifice her for a test?” Kerrie asked, her voice rising. “Did she know that?”
“Her case was legitimate,” Uzvik said.
“So she didn’t know,” Kerrie said. “Would you have told me if I had let you second chair?”
“That would have defeated the test,” Uzvik said.
“She could have died,” Kerrie said.
“But she did not.”
“Did you get her kicked out of the Black Fleet, then?” Kerrie asked. “Did you turn her in to the Earth Alliance?”
“No,” Uzvik said. “The circumstances were of her own making.”
“They were simply there for you to exploit,” Kerrie said.
“Just so.” Uzvik folded his long thin fingers.
“And you think that I would work for you after this?”
“It is easy work,” he said. “You would make money and you would have maybe two cases per year.”
“All I would have to do is sell my soul,” Kerrie said.
“The matter of the human ‘soul’ has never been proven,” Uzvik said.
Kerrie stared at him. He was Peyti, literal, difficult, brilliant.
“The Peyti are known for their ethics,” she said.
“We are known for rigorously defending our clients to the fullest extent of Earth Alliance law,” he said.
He was right; she had simply taken that as ethics.
“Get away from me,” she said.
“I am authorized to make a generous offer—”
“No,” she snapped. “Get the hell away from me.”
“You would be perfect—”
“No.” She walked toward the coffee nook, so fast she was nearly running. Just when she thought she had seen everything, every kind of permutation of Earth Alliance law, every type of victim, someone came up with something even more venal.
A test, one that would have sacrificed Donnatella for no reason at all.
“The result would have been the same.” The Peyti had kept up with her. She could hear his labored breathing as he struggled to remain beside her. “She would have gone to Ziyit without my interference.”
“But you could have prevented it.” Kerrie said. Then she stopped again. The Peyti nearly walked into her. “Did Maise know about this?”
“We asked that the best be assigned this case,” Uzvik said.
She did. She knew. And she had manipulated Kerrie into taking the case.
Kerrie’s stomach turned. “I told you to get away from me,” she said. “And I mean it. I’ll call base security if I have to.”
She turned around and headed back to the public defenders office. Uzvik remained where he was, looking small.
She went through the doors. Maise was talking to one of the associates. Kerrie was so angry, she almost couldn’t speak.
She wondered if Maise’s prejudice against Peyti was a ruse, one she used whenever she was working with the Black Fleet.
“Do you get a cut?” Kerrie asked.
Maise looked up.
“A recruitment cut?” Kerrie asked. “From the Black Fleet? Do they pay you to bring them the best and brightest?”
“Let’s go to the conference room,” Maise said.
“Let’s not,” Kerrie said. “Everyone can hear this. I quit. I’m done. And you guys, if Maise offers you a case, watch out. It might be poisoned.”
“You should stay,” Maise said. “The recruiters—”
“I know,” Kerrie said. “I don’t really care. I’m going to find a job. And it won’t be one that requires a high-end recruiter. Because I’m done here. Right now.”
Then she slammed her way out of the office. Messages ran along her links from the various lawyers in the PD’s office. Some messages were automated, telling her how to wrap up her career with the InterSpecies Court. Others were filled with questions, questions she wasn’t going to answer.
She went back to her apartment. Except for the night court lawyer who was asleep, the apartment was empty.
She went to her room and gathered her belongings. She would head to Helena. And there, she would figure out what to do.
At the moment, she saw only two options: she could contact independent Disappearance Services. They needed lawyers too. Of course, she would be crossing all kinds of lines, legal and ethical.
Although she would be doing it for a good cause.
Or she could ally herself with some of the legal groups that took big cases, cases that got appealed to the Multicultural Tribunals, cases that might lead to overturning treaties, and modifying laws.
All she knew was that she couldn’t stay here. And she knew she couldn’t work for an organization like the Black Fleet. An organization willing to sacrifice its own people as a test.
The Earth Alliance sacrificed its people to satisfy treaties, to facilitate trade.
She had been a blind participant to it all.
But she was blind no longer.
And she knew how she felt.
She hated all of it.
And she would never be part of it again.
The ImpossiblesCopyright © 2023 Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published Analog SF Magazine, December, 2011Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2023 WMG PublishingCover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Keremgo/Dreamstime, Sscreations/Dreamstime
Thank you, everyone, for supporting the Kickstarter for The Court-Martial of the Renegat Renegades. Thanks to all the backers and to everyone who shared information about the Kickstarter. I’m so pleased that so many of you helped out!
I hauled out the staff at Promotion Central to say thanks as well. They usually do their promotions on Facebook, but I figured they could move over here for half a day.
Thanks again!!! It means a lot to me.
I have finally found the time to research AI audio. Or rather, I’m finally making the time.
I have ventured to this precipice before, and backed off. Now, though, I feel the need to move forward. We (me, Dean, WMG Publishing) are leaving a lot of money on the table. I haven’t been able to get moving on my own voiceover, which would require me to either record out of the condo or to rearrange our place to make it soundproof. (Not something I’m really willing to do, even though we do have one spot I can use.)
I have investigated hiring voice actors. The ones who are already on my various series are too expensive, even at the marvelous discounts they offered me as the author.
I have done a quick examination of the math. The numbers I used were for the existing series as they sold on Audible. Regular Audible, over time, not ACX Audible.
Using those numbers, it would take two to five years to break even on the professional voice actor performances. I’d love to use those folks, since voice actors bring their own audiences to audio. If I go with a different voice on a series, for example, I will lose the voice actor’s fanbase.
It really is in my best interest to keep the original actor…if I could afford them. Which I can’t. The numbers don’t justify it.
However, I’m receiving at least a letter per week from someone asking for audio versions of my books. Some of these folks are longtime fans who now have reading issues. Others are folks who listened to earlier books in a series while making a commute.
Working in the office is back, baby, and that means that commuting is back, which means that listening to audiobooks in the car is back. People are extremely disappointed to learn that they can’t get the next book in a series or even two or three books (considering they haven’t been buying for a couple of years).
I understand. Which is why I’ve been noodling at audio for years now. Ten years or so ago, we opened our own audio studio at WMG, but hired someone who didn’t do as asked. I wanted us to use our resources to produce books. The employee instead defaulted to ACX, which was new at the time.
I was getting sicker and sicker, and that was a fight I couldn’t handle. Finally, we shut down our studio and moved on. I regret this more than I can say. Ten years on, the audio distribution systems are good enough to handle what we would have produced. We are transferring what few audio products that came out of our studio onto our bookstore. The other products are, frankly, a mess, and we need to resolve that.
Then I entered the local voiceover community here in Las Vegas. I did so for two reasons. My main reason was to listen to the other voicers and see if any of them could handle one of my series. As I looked at the pricing, though, I realized I couldn’t afford them…and they didn’t need to practice on my book.
The professional voicer community is like WMG’s professional writer community. Those voicers are being trained to charge for their work, and to do so properly. I wasn’t going to mess with that.
The other reason I went was to improve my own rusty skills. I’m going to keep doing that, with a return planned for this summer. I will eventually narrate some of my own projects. Those will be fiction projects and I’m looking forward to it.
I had thought about hiring nascent talent from the University of Las Vegas-Nevada. I now know how to do that, and I can probably do it for free. I might do that with some radio plays. I’d work with the drama department for the proper permissions.
All of those ideas are firmly based in what I’ve known about audio from my career in radio and from my years working with it on the side. That knowledge is anywhere from 20 to 40 years old. Those systems still work in the modern era, but they aren’t the totality of the picture.
The actual voices in my head come from readers/listeners who want the next book. Listening to audiobooks has changed in the intervening decade.
Once upon a time, the people who listened to audiobooks fell into a niche category. Generally, the people who spent money on audiobooks were people who had money. Audiobooks weren’t cheap. Most commercial audiobook companies abridged the books, which sometimes made them hard to understand. For example, I listened to the abridged audio for the Star Wars book that I wrote, The New Rebellion…and I couldn’t understand what was happening.
Expensive and confusing—not worth the time. There were a few companies, like Blackstone Audio and Books on Tape that provided the entire book, unabridged. Books on Tape had a rental program that sent you maybe a dozen cassettes, as well as postage to return them.
It was a commitment to listen to an audiobook, and there was no fastforwarding through the dull stuff or just to get a sense of the content.
Once audiobooks became digitized, the game changed. You could skip ahead. You can listen at 2x speed and not miss a word. If you’re the kind of listener who doesn’t care about the performance, then you can speed through audiobooks quickly.
And, I’ll be honest, there are some audiobook narrators who truly grate on me. Listening to the book with that voice is annoying. I’ll listen to those narrators—who are performing to the best of their abilities—at 2x speed. I listen to most podcasts that way as well.
My old voicer self is appalled at that. Because so many books are a performance. I would never listen to an audiobook done with multiple voices that way—or at least, I haven’t yet.
I am not alone in this. People savor some audiobooks and they speed through others. Some people are so busy that they can only listen on a commute. Others have vision impairments that make reading hard, so they save the reading experience for special books.
There is no “average” consumer of audiobooks. Each consumer has different levels for different books, and there’s no predicting how each individual will respond. The process is too individual.
Years ago, as AI audio started, I made a mental note of how I wanted to use it: I decided that I’d have at least three tiers of audiobooks on some projects.
Tier 1 would be a true audiobook with a professional voice actor, someone who knew what they were doing. Or maybe even Tier 1 would have a name actor, someone who brings a big audience with them. For this, I would charge premium prices—whatever that meant at the time.
So, for the sake of argument, let’s call a Tier 1 price $25 for 15 hours of listening. It takes prep to make this book, and it would take a long time for it to earn out. But it would be the high-end version, for the people who care about those things.
Tier 2 would also be a true audiobook with a not-as-proper narrator, either someone new or maybe me. I know, I know. Some people think the author’s voice is worth more, and that might be true of an actor or Prince Harry or maybe even Stephen King, but for most people, the author is almost a negative. Not many authors have training to read their own books, so there would be a lot of cringe-worthy moments. I probably wouldn’t be my usual audio perfectionist self here, so I would charge less, maybe $15 for 15 hours.
Tier 3 would be the AI book, using one of the services and a standard voice. The book wouldn’t take long to put together and the reading would be pedestrian. So the price would be anywhere from $5-10 for the fifteen hours. Maybe less, depending on what it took to put the book together.
I suspect most audio consumers would get the Tier 3 book, not just for the price, but also the convenience. The consumer wouldn’t care about how “good” the audiobook was. That consumer would just want to consume the content, maybe at 2x speed.
As I write this, I realize there are a few other tiers I would add over time. There would be a tier between 2 and 3, that would probably be my voice, cloned. So AI audio, yes, me, yes, but not really me. You’d learn nothing about the “author’s” narration, like where I would actually put the pauses.
The other tier that I can foresee at the moment would be an audio play version of a book—either with multiple voices or revised so that the book was truly a performed version of the book, with music and sound effects.
The voicer in me really wants to do that. The writer in me is a bit appalled at the time involved.
The time involved factors into my decision making in many ways. For example, reading the nonfiction books bores the crap out of me. I’ll never do it. So I have many nonfiction books that wouldn’t get produced—or would need someone else’s voice. Those books are never going to earn as much as the fiction books, so I need a fairly cheap way to produce them.
Back when we had an audio employee, I had hoped that they would read the product, but of course, they didn’t. Sigh. And in my farming out days when I thought maybe I could bring in a practice voice from, say, UNLV, I considered using nonfiction.
But those were just noodles.
The moment I heard about AI audio, the nonfiction books were the first products I thought of.
Anyway…
That has been my vision for years now with audiobooks. But as I started to research this, I realized I had one more vision: The blog.
I’d love to have this weekly blog in audio form as well as online. I’ve wanted to do that for years now, since we had the audio room at WMG. I was just too sick to do it weekly, and I didn’t see any financial reason at the time to pay our staff person to record it.
At that point, there was no Patreon or anything like that. We would have had to sell the audio version of the blog on WMG’s website, or on mine, and I didn’t see any financial gain there.
Now, though? I definitely see it. The audioblog would be a Patreon level, along with maybe a subscription.
So…as I started doing my research into the AI audio, I did what you all should do. I read the terms of service first.
I was looking for a handful of things.
First, I had to make sure that I controlled the content. I didn’t want some AI site to gain ownership of any kind in my copyright because I had decided to make an audiobook of something.
Second, I needed a license for commercial use, since I would be selling the audio version of whatever I did.
Third, I didn’t want exclusivity. I’ve been exclusive with Audible for years now and I loathe it. As I always warn you all when you make exclusive deals, imagine what would happen when the lovely service you’re using turns on you.
That’s what Audible did to me. I got thousands and thousands of dollars up front ten to twelve years ago, along with bonus payments, because Audible was trying to establish itself.
The editor I worked with was tremendous. He was a reader. He liked the people he was working with, and he loved the books. He wanted more of everything. He responded quickly. The contracts were good.
Then things started to go south. Audible became a wholly owned subsidiary of Amazon. Which was not a problem at first, and became one about five or six years in. Because Amazon started flexing its muscles.
Still, Audible was pretty much the only place to go for audio at that point. Other places were too small and/or they had to distribute through Audible anyway. So it was a shrug.
But all the bonuses? They went away. And Amazon started playing screwy games with payment, so the payment amounts went way down. I started chaffing at the exclusivity.
Then Findaway Voices came in. They were too expensive for people like me to have something produced. (Again, I did the math; again, it didn’t work out.)
By the time I wanted to leave, we no longer had an audio room and I was too sick to do much. So I figured audio could wait.
Unfortunately, the wonderful editor left, replaced by a guy who was such a screw-up that he spent most of his time planning his social life (on the phone…asking me and the other authors for advice (!)) and not editing, not getting things done, not sending out contracts.
By the time he was fired, my Audible products had stalled and there was nothing new to goose sales. The person who replaced him wouldn’t even return my calls—and I have dozens of items paid for by Audible on Audible.
That’s how exclusivity bites you in the ass.
I’m not taking the books down yet, but it’s a bucket list for my future.
So…any service that requires exclusivity is no longer any place that I want to go.
Still, I looked at various programs and, as I said, started reading terms of service. Places like Apple want exclusivity. You’re creating the book through Apple, so they want to make sure the book is only available there.
That’s a hard no for me.
Google, on the other hand, allows you to export the content and sell it somewhere else, providing a not-half-bad commercial license…except…it’s for a book and you have to guarantee that the audiobook will be available on GooglePlus.
If I was doing books only, maybe. Maybe not, because as with most terms of service, the terms can change on the company’s whim.
So another hard no.
What I need, and what I’m digging into, are places that produce books and then release them. I control where the content is sold. (Commercial license.) In some, I have to make sure I credit publically and clearly where the AI audio was produced. In others, I don’t have to.
One site has a “no profanity” clause. Which would require me to have a clean version of whatever product I’m doing. That’s not a problem for, say, the blog, because I can clean up my language here.
But it is a problem if I’m working on a Smokey Dalton novel, which has some extremely period-appropriate horrifying words in the books, or if I’m writing a rather spicy romance.
Makes me wonder, in fact, if the site could even be used for the spicier kinds of romance.
Last week, I posted what I was going to do, and a lot of people weighed in, some on Patreon, some on the website, and some via email. No one understood what I was trying to do, maybe because I hadn’t explained it. (Well, duh.)
A few people complained about the robotic voices. WMG had been invited to beta test a new product a month or so ago, and our non-audio person in charge of this thought both voices were fine. The female voice was human enough, but the male voice did have a robotic edge.
I don’t mind—if I’m going to look at the product on a Tier 3 level. The key is to get the sound file out into the world.
With all of that in mind, I now have reached the test stage. I have some other needs that you folks don’t have.
If I end up with an AI service of the kind I’m describing here, I need a higher level plan, one that would allow several people to access the account. That automatically puts us into an expensive payment structure—either the “Pro” level or the “Executive” level…which on most sites means I have to contact them directly to find out the price. And, as they say, if you have to ask, you can’t afford it.
What I’ll be doing is testing the sites as an individual first, and then moving to a higher payment level if I like what I’m hearing.
I’m also doing a lot of reading on the various rating sites. A few of these companies have a major complaint—which is that it’s almost impossible to cancel the service.
I can’t tell if that’s from someone who is spending at the lowest level or one of the Executive plans.
That requires more research. But, given what I want to do, it is a potential red flag.
That’s as far as I’ve gotten in this very busy week, filled with the Rock ’N’ Roll races here in Vegas, lots of visitors, too much homework for my one class, and a fiction project due, as well as the last days of a Kickstarter, which has me doing more promotion than usual.
Oh! And my latest Fey novel, The Kirilli Matter, appeared last Tuesday, so I did some promotion on that as well.
I hope to have more audio news for you soon. I’m finding this fun, which is a good sign. It means I’ll be working on it much harder than I probably should, given everything else I’m doing.
I promised you all that I would add some sales material down here, with things that are relevant to the current post. So…
If you want to understand how to read terms of service with the proper jaundiced eye, you can take our Bite-Size Copyright course or you can pick up my book Closing The Deal On Your Terms.
And here’s one other reminder: This weekly blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynruschr4e to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: The Research Part 1 (AI Audio),” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © Can Stock Photo / aroas.
If not, here’s your chance. The Court-Martial of the Renegat Renegades is a standalone book in my Diving universe. For $5 you can get the ebook, and every stretch goal we’ve hit in the Kickstarter that we’re currently doing. Right now, backers will get four anthologies and the Diving Notebook about this book. (Think the extras on a director’s cut, with commentary.) Backers also get 4 really fun sf writing workshops that they can keep for themselves or give to writer friends.
The Kickstarter will end in a little over 2 days, so hurry on over and get all kinds of goodies. Oh, and if you haven’t read the Diving books yet, you can get all of them in the rewards…at a discount.
Take a look.
Because he lost his arm in the war against Napoleon, Nicholas cannot return to Society. The ton will reject him.
Now, he lives in solitude in his estate, claiming he prefers it.
Then a child arrives. A young boy who reminds him of his past. A boy who threatens his present. A boy who must be dealt with to ensure Nicholas’ own future.
“Controlling the Sword,” by World Fantasy Award-winning author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story is also available in ebook through various online retailers here.
Controlling the SwordKristine Kathryn RuschHe preferred the bayonet. A musket shot poorly at best and was likely to blow up in a man’s face. A knife could be knocked free. But a bayonet garroted the enemy well, surprising a man at arm’s length and not giving him time to recover.
But weapons debates were moot now. Nicholas spent his days in the family estates near Kent, hiding from the ton with its missish debutantes searching for a husband and randy widows expecting satisfaction. To them he was a hero. They looked at the poorly healed scar on his cheek, and saw not the edge of a blood-spattered knife that came too close to the eye, but the romantic mark of an untamed rake. They touched his empty right sleeve, pinned to his shoulder, with admiration, wanting the story. But he could not tell a green girl about the heat in Salamanca, the blood lust in the eyes of the Frenchman who slit him from shoulder to wrist, and the awful infection that made his arm swell and ache until the bone surgeons decided to hack it off.
After three nights of witty repartee, he could take no more. He had been in hiding ever since.
He spent his evenings alone in the library, a fire in the hearth, a glass of port clutched in his left fist. He had not realized what a luxury it had been to sit before a fire, a glass of port in one hand, a good cigar in the other—an enjoyment in which he would never again partake. The books around him had been his father’s, Romances and Grand Adventures, monographs from the Colonies, and Histories of everything from the house and family to the Far and Mysterious East. Once he might have read, but these days he did not. He stared into the orange flames burning black against the stone face of the hearth or the two swords crossed beneath his father’s portrait, their red tassels dangling on the dust-covered marble mantle.
The swords frightened him.
At night he would dream that he would hear them clatter against the flagstone before the hearth. Once he had run down the stairs, expecting to see them lying on the floor, dripping with blood, but the library had been as he left it, his empty glass beside the chair and the cherry red embers still giving off a bit of warmth.
*The carriage that pulled into the yard was black with a dray horse, obviously hired. Nicholas watched from the large windows in the hall as the young boy opened the door, then hesitated before stepping down alone.
The boy was slight, his hair dark. As he turned, Nicholas gasped. No doubt. This was his brother’s child.
Not that there had been a doubt before. The letter from the solicitor had arrived almost a month earlier, carrying copies of the boy’s birth records. Richard Adam Lucien Worth, heir apparent to the family fortune. Nicholas would act as guardian until the lad reached his majority.
Nicholas sighed. He went to the door, which Simms the butler had already opened, and stood behind it, sinister lord of the manor. Simms was warmer: he hurried down the stairs to help the boy. The cabbie merely waited until the baggage had been removed from the back, then clucked to the horse and drove away, leaving the boy standing in the dust. The bags were two, patched and poor, certainly not befitting a lord’s son.
A lord’s son. Until a month before, Nicholas had thought he had inherited the family estate.
The boy stared at the house, his thin mouth open. He had Randolph’s face—not the face of the man known throughout London for his way with the ladies, but the older brother Nicholas remembered, the one who hesitated before he acted, lest he incur their father’s wrath.
The house, with its wide turrets and branching wings, probably did look imposing to a boy raised on the Scottish moors. His mother had fled to her family upon discovering Randolph’s indiscretions. But her parents had died some years back, and she had followed them with an ague. Neighbors contacted Randolph’s solicitors when they found the boy living alone.
Nicholas hadn’t even known Randolph was married.
Simms reached the boy and immediately picked up his cases. The wind caught most of the conversation, but Nicholas could catch the deferential tone in Simms’ voice, the way he gently said, “Young Master.” Nicholas nodded. Good. The boy would need someone gentle. Nicholas certainly wouldn’t be it.
As they walked up the stairs, the boy kept glancing back at Simms, as if he expected the older man to drop the cases. The boy’s breeches were torn and his hair needed trimming. The wind brought with it the scent of little boy sweat—he needed a scrubbing, had probably not had one since his mother died, if then. When the boy saw Nicholas, he stopped, his eyes growing darker, just as Randolph’s would have.
“Me lord uncle.” The boy’s voice had a touch of the Scottish burr.
The title and the deference rankled. Nicholas didn’t want the boy here. He wanted to be left alone, with his meager fires, his one arm and his port. “You’re to call me Nick,” he said, “after the very devil himself.”
Then he spun on one booted foot and stalked to the library, slamming the door behind him.
*Simms and Pratt, the housekeeper, had managed to keep the boy away from him for three whole days. On the fourth, Nicholas trotted down the stairs just after noon, his head thick and achy with the drink he had imbibed the night before. He had planned to go to the stables, to work Midnight, but the idea of sitting astride the big black stallion, reins caught in only one hand was ridiculous. An entire bottle of port had not drowned the image.
Still, he wore his riding boots and coat, and carried his short whip. Perhaps after a bit of nuncheon he would have the courage to mount a horse—any horse—one-handed.
As he passed the library, he saw the boy, standing before the cold hearth, staring up at the crossed swords. The boy didn’t hear Nicholas approach. This time the lad looked not like Randolph, but like Nicholas himself a lifetime ago, when he thought the swords a symbol of his future as a warrior.
“’Tis said your great-great-great—ah, I don’t know how many greats—grandfather used those swords against Cromwell.”
The boy jumped at the sound of Nicholas’s voice, and turned, his body snapping to attention.
Nicholas put his left hand behind his back. He wasn’t sure what had possessed him to speak to the boy. “The old man was named Richard, which is, I believe, your given name.”
“Me mother called me Dickie,” the boy said.
“Here in England,” Nicholas said, “we shall call you Richard.”
The boy licked his lips. “’Taint a boy’s name,” he said, his voice small.
The desire behind the protest was not lost on Nicholas. “Perhaps you’re right. ’Tis too formal for a boy. But Dickie has no dignity. When we sup tonight, you shall tell me which of your given names you prefer to use.”
The boy’s tongue appeared again, over the tops of his lips. They were chapped. “You want ter sup together?”
“Tonight,” Nicholas said, and bowed once, a slight acknowledgment of his rudeness. The boy looked horribly lonely. And why wouldn’t he be? In a strange country, in a strange home, with a man who in a fit of pique had compared himself to the devil?
“Them swords,” the boy said. “Ya ever use them?”
Nicholas permitted himself a wry smile. “Once,” he said. “When I was a boy.”
“Could ya learn me ter use them?” The boy was stiffly formal, his hands clasped behind his back in an unconscious imitation of Nicholas.
“I was right-handed,” Nicholas said. “I doubt I could show you anything.” He slapped his whip against his boots. “Dinner. Seven sharp.”
Then he went to the stables to see if he could mount Midnight.
*He had been little older than the boy the afternoon he had tried the sword. He had moved one of the stools close to the hearth, and stood on the top. The mantel—kept highly polished in those days—stabbed him in the chest. He had to stand on his toes to reach the hilt of the top sword. He yanked it up and back from its perch. The sword weighed twice as much as he expected. It nearly dislodged his father’s portrait. He swung it down to save the art, and lost his balance in the process.
The fall seemed interminable. His right arm, his sword arm, led the way, and the sword hit first, its clang echoing through the great room. He landed on his back, knocking the air out of him. The hilt jabbed into the soft skin beside his spine. Pain shot up and through him, making him gasp.
Footsteps echoed in the outer hall, but he couldn’t pick himself up, couldn’t force himself to stand and hide his misdeed. Collins, his father’s man, arrived first, and stopped at the door, his wig askew, his heavy features flushed with exertion.
“Lord, young man,” he said. “You done it now. You damned yourself, ’tis what you’ve done.”
“Don’t fill his head with such nonsense.” His father pushed past Collins. His blouse was loose and his graying hair untied and flowing over his shoulders. His breeches were newly cleaned and in one hand he held a matching great coat. He had been about to go out. “What have you done, boy?”
Nicholas was still gasping for air. No words emerged. He rolled off the hilt and onto his side. Each movement brought him agony. Collins stooped beside him, and pried the hilt from his right hand. “’Tis doomed you are,” he said. “You’ll be a cripple for the rest of your days.”
The pain was enough that Nicholas believed him. He might never stand again.
“’Tis a silly superstition,” his father said, “and I’ll not have you speak to him of it.” He took the sword from Collins and rehung it beneath the portrait without benefit of the stool. “I told you not to touch anything in this room, lad.”
“Aye.” Nicholas’s voice wheezed out of him. Slowly the air was coming back. Cool air touched his bare skin as Collins lifted up his shirt.
“He has a nasty bruise, milord. I think we should send for the doctor.”
Nicholas hated the doctor, a man with dirty fingers and a stained coat. “No,” he said, sitting up. “I’ll be all right.”
“Leave us,” his father said to Collins.
“As you wish, sir.” Collins stood and bowed. He left the room.
His father put a hand behind Nicholas and helped him to his feet. The movement was painful, but not unbearably so, now that his wind was returning.
“What did he mean, crippled?”
His father gave him an odd look, as if for the first time, he were seeing his son as a man. “A wive’s tale,” he finally said. “’Tis scratched into the hilt in Latin: he who cannot control the sword is forever at its mercy. My father couldn’t wield it properly, and later lost his leg in fighting the insurrection in the colonies. There was an uncle who played with the swords and lost a finger. The stories go like that. The superstitious always look for ways to explain misfortune.”
Nicholas nodded. The pain in his back ran up and down his spine. He longed for a chair and a cold compress over his eyes. “Are you going to punish me, sir?” he asked, wanting this meeting to end.
“I think your accident was punishment enough,” his father said. “Just remember: this room is not a place for little boys.”
*He had wrestled with the horse and lost. When he came down the stairs for supper, every inch of his body ached. His man had had to clean straw from his hair, and scrub blood from his chin from the time he had bitten his lower lip. He wanted nothing more than a long quiet evening with a lot of port to drown the humiliation from memory.
The boy was already at the table, in what had once been Randolph’s spot, to the left of the master of the house. Head bent, hands clasped in his lap, the boy appeared smaller than he was.
“Heads up, lad,” Nicholas snapped. “This is a meal, not a church.”
“Sorry, sir.” The boy brought his head up, his longish hair falling into his eyes. He brushed it away with one hand.
Nicholas leaned on his left hand as he eased himself into the chair. Each movement made him ache. He was like a child, unused to the saddle. He would be limping for days.
A door banged in the kitchen, then Simms emerged, carrying a silver tureen. Apparently he and Mrs. Pratt had decided to go all out for this meal. Simms set the tureen down and began ladling out the soup. The broth had a savory odor, and Nicholas’s stomach rumbled.
The boy gulped, and bobbed his head, once. “I’ve made up me mind, sir,” he said.
“Yes?” Nicholas watched as Simms set the soup bowl in front of him. Beef, potatoes and carrots floated in the thin brown broth. He didn’t care what the boy had decided. He merely wanted to end the meal and get on with the evening.
“Adam, sir. Do ya think they’ll find it manly enough here in England?”
Simms set broth in front of the boy. Nicholas blinked at him for a moment, confused. Then he remembered the conversation from the afternoon. The boy was choosing his name. He nearly said that anything was better than Dickie, but the boy’s hopeful look stopped him. “I daresay they’ll think it first-rate.”
The boy—Adam now—flushed with pleasure. He dug into his soup, clutching his spoon in his fist and shoveling food in his face like a boy in an orphan’s home.
“Adam, did your mother teach you to eat like that?”
Adam froze. “Nay, sir. She said a lad should eat slow ter enjoy the meal.”
Nicholas nodded. He wished he could dig through the food as Adam had done. “Do as she taught you,” he said. Then he rubbed his remaining hand on his breeches and picked up his own spoon. Eating left-handed still felt awkward to him, and he had never before done it in front of another. His hand shook as he brought it to his lips.
“Did ya kill him?”
Nicholas swallowed the rich soup, and frowned. He set his spoon down. “Kill whom?”
“The man what done it ter ya. Took yer arm.”
Nicholas felt the heat rise in his cheeks. No one had ever asked him a direct question about his injury. Not even the girls of the ton. They had hinted, but never once asked. “Aye.” Nicholas said. It was difficult to get the words past his lips. “I stuck him with my bayonet.”
And the man had screamed before he fell, one more body on top of a pile of bodies in all that smoky heat. Nicholas’s last act with his right arm. He had fainted himself, moments after that.
“Good,” the lad said. “Then yer a hero, like they say.”
Nicholas’s appetite had fled. He swallowed, somehow feeling it important to speak. “No, lad. Killing another man does not make me a hero.”
“But ya made it through one of the bloodiest battles of the war.”
Nicholas picked up his spoon. He had to eat. He made himself dip the spoon in the broth. “Aye,” he said. “And sometimes I wish I hadn’t.”
*That night, he dreamed an old dream, one he first had in Spain. He was feverish, lying on a cot in the heat, men screaming around him. Flies buzzed around his face, and the tent smelled of rotting flesh. His arm hurt so badly that each touch sent him into agony.
The bone surgeon stood over him, his uniform covered with blood. “We have to take the arm.”
“No.” Nicholas’s throat was parched and the words were little more than a whisper.
Then Collins came up behind the surgeon, the sword in his work-roughened hands. “’Tis because of the accident, young man,” Collins said. “If you’d not taken the sword, you’d keep the arm.”
“Superstition!” His father’s voice boomed over the screaming men. “My son cannot control the weapon. He deserves to die.”
“Take the arm,” Collins said. “’Tis the boy’s fate. He’ll live, leastways.”
Nicholas made himself sit up. The darkness was oppressive. He could still feel the heat from the dream. The stench of rotting flesh and too many bodies packed too close together remained in his nostrils. But he felt the bed linens beneath him, and saw the familiar shapes of his armoire, fireplace and chair outlined in the thin moonlight streaming through the window.
With the back of his hand, he wiped the sweat off his brow, then put his head on his knees.
“Marriage is easy in Scotland, you know.”
The muscles in Nicholas’s back tensed. He had heard Randolph’s voice. But that was impossible. He brought his head up. The moonlight outlined his brother, sitting in the chair that had been empty a moment before. Randolph was relaxed, an elbow leaning on the chair back, and his left ankle resting on his right knee. Typical Randolph, all fluidity and ease.
“The girl was pretty, and Father wanted an heir.” Randolph grinned, as if they were having a conversation over dinner. “When she told me she was pregnant, I wed her and brought her back here. All seemed fine, until her eighth month, when she caught me with Lady Alexander in flagrante dilecto. The girl fled, against the doctor’s advice, and since we never heard, we assumed the child had died.”
It was a dream. It had to be. Randolph was dead. Nicholas sat cross-legged. “You lost your soul somewhere, Dolph. ’Twas not the way to treat your wife and child.”
Randolph shrugged. “We never said the banns. She wasn’t landed. Father said we could get it annulled, if it ever really existed.”
Nicholas rubbed his hand over his eyes. The movement made him feel wide awake. “Strange thing to come back from the grave to tell me, Dolph. I care less about your sham of a marriage than you did.”
“I think not, brother,” Randolph said. “There is no marriage on record. You could cut the boy if you like.”
A chill ran down Nicholas’s spine, as if Randolph had run his dead fingers along Nicholas’s skin. “I have no intention of denying the boy his inheritance.”
Randolph stood. As he turned, the moonlight reflected off his white shirt, revealing a small, bloody hole near his heart. “Don’t lie to me, Nicky. ’Tis why you try to drown yourself in drink, to hide the anger you feel at losing the title yet again. This time to a boy.”
“’Tis not why I’m angry!” The words exploded from Nicholas with a force that he hadn’t known he had. “I am angry at you, Dolph. You died while I was gutting Frenchmen for Wellington. You died in a duel you didn’t have to fight, protecting some woman’s non-existent honor—”
“Actually,” Randolph said, leaning against the wall, arms crossed over the hole in his chest, “I died protecting my own non-existent honor.”
Nicholas was shaking. He had lied to himself so effectively he hadn’t realized there was anger beneath the drink. “I came home half a man to find I had nothing to come home to. No family, no one who cared so much as a whit that I survived.”
Randolph shrugged. “You came home to all this. Without the boy, you could be lord here.”
“I have none of your ambitions,” Nicholas said. “I have my own income and no need for the estate.”
Randolph bowed, slightly, in mockery. “Then I had no need to come here. Forgive me, dear brother. As usual, I have misunderstood you.”
Nicholas placed his hand behind him to brace himself on the bed. His outburst had left him shaken. “’Twas a senseless way to die,” he said.
“’Twas a senseless way to live.” Randolph’s voice had an unusual seriousness. He ran a hand through his hair, and then grinned. “You needn’t worry, Nicky. This will be my only trip. No sense in the neighbors thinking the manse is haunted.”
“They wouldn’t think of ghosts, Dolph,” Nicholas said. “They would merely use it as confirmation of my growing insanity.”
But by the time he finished the sentence, the moonlight illuminated a bare patch of wall and an empty chair. Nicholas took in a deep breath. He was still shaking, and he hadn’t moved, but Randolph was gone.
The dreams were over. Nicholas was awake for the rest of the night.
*The next morning, he left his chamber early and went to the stables. He took out the gentlest horse, a mare his father had purchased for guests, and dismissed the grooms. Then he worked at mounting, concentrating each time on retaining his balance. Over the year of his illness and recovery, he had lost much strength. The problem was not really the loss of his arm, but the loss of strength in his body. What had once been effortless now took a great deal of concentration and energy. He mounted on the second try, and controlled the reins with his left, letting the mare set the pace while he relearned how to ride.
He returned to the house at noon, planning to change before nuncheon. As he passed the library, he noted Adam, staring at the swords. The boy stood in the same position he had used the day before: hands clasped behind his back, head up, shoulders back, and brow furrowed as if in concentration.
Nicholas tucked the quirt in his boot, and went into the library. “’Tis truly not a room for boys,” he said, hearing his father’s voice speak through his own.
Adam looked around sharply, as if he hadn’t realized that Nicholas was there. “I’m sorry, sir,” he said.
Nicholas glanced at the swords. They gleamed. Mrs. Pratt kept them cleaned, just like she kept the portrait free of dust. Only the mantel seemed to escape her careful attention. “The swords fascinated me as a boy,” he said.
“And me da?”
Something in the boy’s tone made Nicholas turn. The boy had bit his lower lip in anticipation of Nicholas’s response.
Nicholas chose his words carefully. “Swords were not your father’s weapons.”
“But I thought ya took one each. Ter Spain.” The boy’s face reddened as he spoke. His small body was rigid as a soldier’s before a general.
“To Spain?” Nicholas frowned. The boy thought his father had fought with Wellington. Yer a hero, then. The boy knew nothing of Randolph, nor of his death. “Nay. The blades we use now tip the ends of rifles. I daresay your father was good with a gun.”
But not good enough. Or quick enough.
You could cut the boy if you like.
“A gun?” the boy asked, as if guns lacked romance.
“Aye,” Nicholas said. The air felt fragile between them. The wrong word would shatter the moment.
Adam returned his gaze to the swords. “Me ma did na talk about him, ’cept ter say I got the look of him.”
“In your face,” Nicholas said. “You have the look of him as a boy in your face.”
Adam’s body tensed. “He were a good man, right sir? I asked Father John, and he said he did na know.”
Your father drank too much and cared nothing for you. He made no provisions for you, and probably would have turned you away had he lived. Nicholas licked his lips. One couldn’t say such things to a child. It was hard enough growing up with a real father—a taciturn man who only noticed when a boy did something wrong. Growing up alone in a strange home had to be twenty times more difficult.
“Your father,” Nicholas said slowly, “was the best man he knew how to be.”
The boy whirled, beaming. “I knew it. The old missus next door, she said ’twere a crime the way he treated his family. But she did na know him. Ya knew him.”
“Once,” Nicholas said. A lump had risen in his throat. He had to swallow hard to make it go away. He had been fifteen when he left the house, and already Randolph was lost to him. His big brother had become a man more interested in the gay festivities of the ton than in the political realities of England. Perhaps the ghostly Randolph had been right; perhaps Nicholas had been angry. But it had been the anger of a second son who thought the eldest was squandering the family name. Since Nicholas had made his own name, and had learned that such things were rarely important.
“‘Once?’” the boy repeated. “Then she was right?”
The joy had fled from the boy’s expression. Randolph had never had a face that mobile. Nicholas felt the loss. He hadn’t realized how much he had basked in the warmth of the boy’s emotion. “Ah, lad,” he said. “Men are not saints, no matter how much you want them to be.”
And because he could no longer stand to field the boy’s questions, Nicholas turned and quickly climbed the stairs.
*That night, long after the rest of the house fell asleep, Nicholas sat in the library and stared into the flames. He held a glass of port in his left hand—the same glass that he had poured when he arrived. The port no longer eased the ache or prevented the dreams, and he was tired of waking with a muzzy head and a sour taste in his mouth.
He stared at the swords. Superstition. Yet here he was, crippled for the rest of his life, just as Collins had said. Perhaps if he took the swords down successfully…
He shook his head. The thought was silly. Even if he removed the swords, he would still miss an arm. He would always and forever retain a physical memory of that field in Salamanca.
You could cut the boy.
Rich, landed, and powerful. And still unable to hold a glass of port in one hand and a cigar in the other. He had his commission and his income from his mother’s home near London. More than enough for a man who lived as he did.
A man who for another ten years had to raise a boy not his own.
And me da?
Lad, your da was no better than the rest of us. Nicholas stood, leaving the port on the table, and headed up to bed. As he passed the swords, he touched the tassels lightly with his good hand. A shiver ran up his back.
He who cannot control the sword is forever at its mercy.
Aye. There be truth in that.
*The next morning, Nicholas was up at dawn. He took Midnight on a canter through the property, noting that the servants had kept it up despite his neglect. He would go over the books in the afternoon, making certain all were well paid. He and the stallion returned lathered. The groomsmen offered to take the horse from him, but Nicholas did the work instead. He needed to stretch his muscles, and he needed to learn to take care of himself with a single hand.
He finished mid-morning, and paused outside the stables to take a deep lungful of air. He hadn’t seen this time of day in weeks, perhaps months. The sunlight cast everything in gold, and gave the grounds a freshness they lacked by midday. He stood for a moment, basking in it, then went inside.
As he passed the library, a movement caught his eye. He went to the door, his soldiering instincts making him move quietly. Adam had pulled a stool over to the mantel—the same stool Nicholas had used years before—only Adam had his back to the door. He leaned across, the edge of the mantel pressing against his chest, as he reached for the hilt of the nearest sword.
Nicholas tried to speak, but the words stopped in his throat. If the boy did not try this time, he would try later. Nicholas remembered that much of his childhood. Instead, he positioned himself only a few feet away from the boy, close enough to use his body to break the boy’s fall.
Adam grabbed the hilt and eased the sword off its perch. Its weight unbalanced him and he swayed. Nicholas took a step inward. His heart knocked against his chest. A remembered pain ran up his back, but still he waited.
Adam gripped the top of the mantel with his left hand and steadied himself, the sword pointing downward.
It was nearly as long as the boy. Adam held his place and swung the sword at an imaginary enemy. The sword made a whoosh in the air. He stopped quickly, the back of his clothes suddenly drenched in sweat.
Nicholas swallowed. He had been holding his breath. Something inside him felt envy at the boy’s prowess. Perhaps if he had had such strength, perhaps then, he would not be standing here, like this.
Adam took his other hand off the mantel and swayed precariously. He braced his right wrist with his left hand and tried to return the sword to its place. But its weight was too much for him to lift above his head, and he started to tilt to the side.
Immediately, Nicholas was beside him. He put his arm around Adam’s waist, holding the boy in place. The boy was warm and too thin. Nicholas could feel the knobs of the boy’s spine through his shirt.
“Lor, sir,” the boy said. His voice was breathless. “Ya scared me.”
Then they were even. Nicholas steadied the boy, then took the sword from the boy’s grasp. The sword was lighter than he remembered, with a more elegant feel than a bayonet. With a simple movement, he returned the sword to its place above the mantel. Then he helped the boy down.
The boy’s face was crimson. He kept his head bowed, hunching his shoulders forward as if he expected to get hit. Nicholas returned the stool to its place.
“’Tis sorry I am, sir,” Adam said. “I should na have touched it.”
What have you done? I told you not to touch anything in this room, lad.
Nicholas’s father’s words nearly escaped his lips. But Nicholas stopped them. He had wanted his father to hold him, to reassure him about the bruise that would plague him for nearly two weeks. His father had said nothing more.
The accident is punishment enough.
“You may do as you wish,” Nicholas said. He swallowed the fear and anger that was threatening to overtake him. “You are lord of this place, after all.”
The boy’s eyes widened. He had clearly never thought in such terms.
“But,” Nicholas said. “I am your guardian, and I think it might be wise if you listen to me.”
The boy bit his chapped lips. “I will na touch them again, sir.”
Nicholas crouched in front of the boy, seeing for the first time the fatigue lines beneath the boy’s eyes, the hollows in the boy’s cheeks, the sores on the inside edge of the boy’s lips. Although the boy now lived in rich circumstances, he still had no one to care for him. “The swords fascinate you, don’t they, boy?”
Adam nodded. His wide eyes stared at Nicholas’s face.
“England has no use for swordsmen,” Nicholas said.
“I do na wish ter be a soldier, sir,” the boy said, his flush growing even deeper. “Beg pardon.”
Adam beneath bodies on the fields of Salamanca: flies swarming overhead, the sun beating down with an intensity foreign to England. The boy flailed with his right hand, trying to get someone’s attention, but he did not call for help.
Nicholas swallowed. “No offense taken,” he said.
The boy took a deep, slow breath, as if he were trying to calm himself.
“If I can find someone to teach you, would you like to learn the sword?”
The boy exhaled. His eyes watered. He blinked rapidly, and averted his gaze. “Do ya think I could?”
“Aye,” Nicholas said. “As long as you take other lessons. We’ll teach you to speak the King’s English and find you a tutor so that you can attend Cambridge when the time comes.”
Adam nodded, willing to agree to anything, it seemed, as long as he could touch the sword.
“Go now, and tell Simms we need an early nuncheon. I’m hungry, aren’t you?”
“Aye, sir.” The boy fled as if the hounds of hell pursued him. Nicholas stood and surveyed the swords. Clean, and polished, shining in the daylight, they still had a menace to them.
The boy would learn to control them. And he would learn the history of their use. Weapons did not cripple. Men did.
Perhaps, in time, Adam would understand that.
Perhaps, in time, others would understand as well.
Perhaps a man would no longer need a favorite weapon, and the bloody fields would become a distant memory.
Nicholas stared at the swords, as he had when he was a boy.
One could only dream.
Controlling the SwordCopyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published Excalibur, edited by Richard Gilliam, and Martin H. Greenberg, and Edward E. Kramer, Warner Aspect, May 1995Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2023 by WMG PublishingCover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Fernando Gregory/Dreamstime
…or so, to help the Kickstarter for the new standalone Diving novel hit a new goal. We want 350 backers by Sunday night, so tell your friends. If we hit that goal, backers will get a book about the writing of the novel, filled with outtakes…and an online writing workshop. So tell your friends!
Click here to see the Kickstarter.
I’m writing this on Monday late which, here in the States, is Presidents Day, a federal holiday. I had planned to have two blog posts done by now, but I hadn’t even had a chance to start this one until a few minutes ago.
Events conspired to prevent my best-laid plans.
I had a severe allergic reaction to something I ate last weekend (SuperBowl weekend) and was sick for the front part of the week. When you lose more than 5% of your body weight, it takes a while to rebuild stamina. (Still working on that.) Which has an effect on mental clarity, as well as the time it takes to finish something.
So rather than try to write anything, I finished assembling a nonfiction book that will appear in June. That was easy enough. I also did some promotion on the Kickstarter we’re doing for my latest Diving novel, The Court-Martial of the Renegat Renegades.
I also realized I had better start promotion for my newest Fey novel, The Kirilli Matter, which came out on Tuesday. So I did some preliminary stuff there.
I had planned to research AI Audio and work on the website last week, and I did neither. I’ve learned that when I’m working at half or quarter speed, I’d better not try anything new. I’ll either break it or decide it’s stupid or think it’s beyond me.
So today was the first day I had to investigate a few things audio-related.
My plan had been this: I was going to research as much as I could on AI audio, and then put a blog into one of the text to speech programs. I want to provide audio versions of each week’s blog. I’ll do that through Patreon, and also as a subscription on my website and on the Shopify store.
I had hoped to have much of the preliminary research done as blog #1 and then present the first attempt as blog #2. Which meant I hadn’t written anything up this week.
But that’s too much work to cram into an already busy Monday. I’m hoping to have part of that done next week.
The reason I’m calling this post half a process blog is because I am describing what I’ve been doing, but I also have been watching the events unfold at Clarkesworld.
I am thanking my lucky stars that I no longer edit a magazine with a slush pile. Until Neil Clarke blogged about what’s going on at Clarkesworld, I hadn’t given the whole AI writing thing any real thought at all.
Why hadn’t I given it any thought lately? I’d already written a post about AI for the year in review, and saw that the changes are fast and furious. It’s hard to stay ahead and blog about anything, when change is that rapid.
I’ve done enough research to know that the chatbots are a new tool. They’ll be used in different ways, by different writers. The problems will get resolved, or things will change, and we will become accustomed to the changes.
What I find a bit ironic is that as all of the news about AI writing was hitting, I was reading a book of essays by Teju Cole called Known And Strange Things. All of the essays were written before 2016, but I can’t tell you exactly when or where because his traditional publisher screwed the hell up on the copyright page. (Previous publications are vague if they exist at all.)
Anyway, in an essay titled “Gueorgui Pinkhossov,” Cole writes about photography as it existed in 2012 or whenever that particular piece was written. (He mentions 2012.) Back then, there had been a debate about the value of photography now that everyone has a camera phone. I remember that debate. Everyone thought the world was ending. But, over time, we learned how to discern the difference between professional photographers and the rest of us.
In the middle of the essay, Cole writes this:
But the problem with the new social photography isn’t merely the postprocessing: after all, photographers have always manipulated their images in the darkroom…[T]he rise of social photography means we are now seeing images all the time, millions of them, billions, many of which are manipulated with the same easy algorithms, the same tiresome vignetting, the same green wash…In other words, the photographic function, which should properly be the domain of the eye and the mind, is being outsourced to the camera and to an algorithm.
Sound familiar? Change the words from photography to writing and writers, and you get the idea.
Fascinatingly to me, Cole goes on to discuss the work of Pinkhossov after Pinkhossov started using his camera phone. (At that point, Pinkhossov had been a professional photographer for 60 or so years, with his first famous shot appearing in 1952.) A photograph taken with the iPhone is in the book, and it is nothing like the photos I take of the cats or the races or my dinner. It is clearly a work of unique eye, something I never would have considered shooting with my own phone.
An example of art, after all, using a new tool.
That’s how I’ve been thinking about the AI writing algorithms. I’ve also been shaking my head at the dumbass writers who continually say they like the AI writing tool to help them plot. Those writers simply do not understand how fiction writing works. Plot comes from depth, by going deep into characters as individuals (real living people…who just happen to be fictional). If you approach plot as an exercise, something separate from the story creation done by your own fingers at your own computer, then you haven’t learned your craft yet, and no AI writing tool is going to help you.
I had only given the writing side of things thought. I hadn’t considered slush piles at all. I’m relieved not to be in charge of a slush pile, even though I haven’t had one since 1997. I’m still scarred. I only work with professionals, and then only trusted folk.
But editors like Neil Clarke are in the thick of things. Slush piles are good things, at their heart. They enable new writer discovery. They make it easy for writers outside the genre to find their way into the genre, without requesting a meeting.
That, however, might change.
In his post from the 15th, Neil writes that spam submissions—which is what he calls AI-generated fiction (in any capacity)—grew to 38% halfway through the month. Now it’s more. In fact, Neil had to close submissions because of the junk he’s been receiving.
And he’s worried. Not just about his magazine or his eyes or his ability to figure out what is spam and what isn’t. (Believe me, I know what he’s seeing and really, it’s not hard. It’s the difference between a nice photo of my cats and a spectacular photograph that makes us see a cat anew.)
He writes:
It’s clear that business as usual won’t be sustainable and I worry that this path will lead to an increased number of barriers for new and international authors. Short fiction needs these people.
Then he adds:
No, it’s not the death of short fiction (please just stop that nonsense), but it is going to complicate things.
It is already complicating things. And it’s a problem for magazines and other publications with open slush piles. It’ll be a problem across the board on anything writing that has open submissions, from contests to agents to Hollywood pitch sessions.
It’s a gigantic change, and one that will cause all kinds of ups and downs before it settles.
The one thing Neil isn’t addressing—hell, no one is—is how many indie books will suddenly sound bland and boring because their lazy-ass authors are using some kind of chatbot tool to “write” faster. There will be an accumulation of junk that’s going to increase.
It’ll take a while for this to shake out.
And yet here I am, working on figuring out ways to use AI audio for my own work. Me, a woman who has a lot of professional voice training. A woman who knows how hard it is to do clean audio files when you’re actually reading them.
Yet I also write a lot of material and have written even more. I couldn’t read my blog every week without sacrificing other writing, which I have been unwilling to do. I thought of podcasting almost a decade ago and, again, decided not to because of the writing.
I’ve taken part in the local voiceover community here because I want to learn some of the new tech, before I do some audiobooks on my own. I initially joined the community to meet some of the upcoming voices, and maybe hire them for audio work.
I’ll still do some of that, but even that is a drop in the bucket of what I need. So AI audio it is. At what extent I don’t know yet—because the decision tree was supposed to start last week and has, instead, started today.
I want to use AI audio as a tool. Would I ever use a chatbot to write for me? No. At the moment (2023) I see absolutely no benefit in that tool for fiction writers.
Could there be a benefit by 2033? Hell if I know. If you’d asked me (and some did) in 2012 if I’d ever use AI audio, I would have said no. Because robotic doesn’t begin to describe the level the tech was at during that time.
So…do I have answers? On AI writing? Sure. Stay the hell away from it if you’re a professional writer. Neil Clarke (and I’m sure others) will ban you from their publications if they know you’re using that crap. (Not that your work would be of sufficient quality to be bought anyway, if you think that an AI can improve your writing.)
Readers will probably turn away from you as well if you’re using that crap to speed up your “writing.” If you have readers…
Do I have answers on AI audio? For me, I do. I’m going to use it as a tool on a variety of projects, and I have thoughts about how to use it and regular human performance in the future. I’m excited to get to it. But that’s for me.
And, before you ask, AI art is a do-not-touch until the copyright issues get resolved.
I suspect I’m going to get a kabillionzillion comments here, many of which I probably won’t want to see. If it gets out of hand, I’m going to shut the comments down. If you spam me (and you know who you are), you’ll lose your commenting privileges forever.
Yep, I’m going hardcore. But this is a blog post that’s mostly about noodling because that’s all I’ve had time for these past two weeks.
I’ll have more to report in a few days…I hope.
This weekly blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynruschr4e to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: Random Thoughts,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © 2023 by Kristine K. Rusch.
I’m so excited that you’ll all get to read The Kirilli Matter: The First Book of The Qavnarian Protectorate. What is the Protectorate? Well, it’s in the Fey world, on Dorovich, and I’m not going to tell you much more than that…except to say that yes, this book has Fey in it, and yes, you’ll understand more when you read. If you’ve never read any books in the series, you can start here, because this series does stand alone. (It’s richer if you know about the Fey. A lot richer. But that’s the only difference.)
So pick up your copy. You can get the ebook direct from WMG Publishing. Or you can go to your favorite vendors. You’ll have to go to them for the paper editions right now, but at some point in the not-too-distant future, you’ll be able to get those direct too. I’m assuming, however, that you want your Kirilli Matter right now, so click on the links.
And, if you want more Fey, pick up the prequel novella in the series, The Reflection on Mount Vitaki, which you can get, along with 9 other ebooks, at a great price on Storybundle. But that deal will only last for another two days or so. After that, you’ll have to order it at a much more expensive rate on the usual sites.
Since we’re talking about new books, I can’t let you forget that we’re holding a Kickstarter for the newest Diving novel, The Court-Martial of the Renegat Renegades. We’ve already hit two stretch goals, so if you back at $5 or above, you’ll get all kinds of goodies, not the least of which is the new novel…which you’ll get early.
Finally, I’m going to leave you with something fun. Here’s the book trailer for The Kirilli Matter. If that doesn’t interest you in the book, nothing will. Enjoy!
Julia serves process in Corvallis, Oregon. One of the lawyers in her office warns her of the dangers her job poses, but she just needs two more years of interning to qualify for law school.
But her last subpoena of the day offers more than she bargains for—and holds more lives than just hers in the balance.
With its heart wrenching twists, “Serving Process” proves Kristine Kathryn Rusch’s mastery of crime fiction.
“Serving Process,” by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook through various online retailers here.
Serving ProcessKristine Kathryn RuschThe house looked abandoned.
Julia sat in the molded seat of her six-year-old beater, the windshield wipers making their familiar quick-paced thud-scrape-thud, but still unable to keep up with the pouring rain.
The entire neighborhood was winter gray. It didn’t help that the sky was gray at what should have been the lightest part of the afternoon, and the rain was falling so heavily that she had trouble seeing the road half a block away.
The bare trees were black against the dark sky, dead leaves piled on overgrown grass, the nearby sidewalk cracked so badly that it looked more like concrete chunks than an actual path that led to the house.
The house itself was maybe a hundred years old, with a pitched roof that might’ve been red at one point, gutters that clearly didn’t work, and windows that seemed like they led into blackness.
The stairs leading into the half porch were as ruined as the sidewalk, and the wood on the railing was so crumbled, she could see it from the driver’s side window. The front door itself, which might have been white at one point, looked ragged and flimsy.
She leaned over her half-full Starbucks cup, and grabbed the loose papers on top of the sealed manila envelope that she had placed in a plastic sleeve. She pulled the papers over and took the pen out of the unused second cupholder where she used to store her phone. Now she had one of those nifty phone holders that looked better in the store than it did attached to the dash of her car.
She checked off the names on the first page, which she should have done the moment she served them. But she was an efficient process server, and her boss, whose small Corvallis law firm had only three real attorneys, didn’t care if she followed procedures one hundred percent to the letter. She batched her reports, filling them all out when she returned to the office, and then going to the firm’s legal secretary who was also the firm’s notary to make sure that everything was as clean as it could be for court.
Julia could follow those procedures because Ethelina, the firm’s legal secretary, hated to go home at night. She often ate dinner at her desk, and finished up whatever tasks she could find, finishing up around eight. Ethelina put in twelve-hour days, as if she were a young attorney on the make, which she most decidedly was not.
She was a widow who hated her quiet house and loved the people she worked with. If Julia was a slightly different person, she’d convince Ethelina to sell the house and buy something closer to the office. But Julia had stopped messing in other people’s lives two years ago—at least in a personal fashion.
Now she messed in those lives in an impersonal way, serving process while she interned at Constantin-Azar, Taylor & Taylor. She was two years from her bachelors in poli sci, which her boss, Adolphus Constantin, swore would be good enough to count as pre-law for the University of Oregon Law School.
She had saved this address for the last stop of the day. Halfway out of town, just off Highway 20 on the way to the Oregon Coast, the drive was by far the farthest she had to go, and the most difficult. Usually she went for difficult early, but the heavy rain had defeated her.
Maybe she just thought that her mood would lift as the day progressed. And that particular hope had been in vain.
She sighed, brushed her overgrown black curls off her face, and looked at the final name.
Reggie Nielsen
The address matched the address of this decaying house on this dead-end street. Nielsen was getting a subpoena as some kind of witness. That type of subpoena shouldn’t have been a problem.
All the problems Julia had experienced in the past year of serving papers had come from the divorce and child custody cases. The men, in particular, took those moments to scream at her, as if she were the one filing for divorce or trying to limit their time with their children.
The women looked at Julia like she had betrayed them, but rarely did they make her heart rate increase, and make her wish she had taken up Gruff Taylor’s offer to take her to the gun range every weekend.
Gruff Taylor was the one lawyer in the office she stayed clear of, mostly, not because she was afraid of him, but because their politics and worldview were so different that, even now, she was afraid of offending him and losing her job.
Julia zipped up her GORE-TEX jacket, pulled up the hood, and snapped it in place. Then she grabbed the manila envelope with Reggie Nielsen’s name on it, as well as the docket number and the law firm contact information on the top.
The plastic sleeve felt cool in her hand.
At least she had worn her duck boots. They went up to her mid-calf and looked terrible, but they were perfect for days like this—and sidewalks like the one that faced her.
She got out of the car. The air was cold and damp, and smelled of rain and mud and something pee-ish, although she had learned that there was a “decorative” plant in some of the yards in older neighborhoods that reeked of pee. She didn’t see one of those plants but that didn’t mean it wasn’t somewhere around, its stink blowing in the wind that threatened to make the rain horizontal.
The faster she got out of here, the better.
She locked her car with the remote, and put the fob in her pocket, zipping the pocket closed (another hard-learned lesson). Only once she was out did she realize she had left her phone in the car.
Not that it mattered. Her watch was paired with her phone. She could call for help if she needed to.
She had only had to do that once, but once had been more than enough.
The sidewalk was even trickier than it looked. The concrete poked up at odd angles, and the holes it left made for giant, boot-sucking puddles. After three steps, she went around the sidewalk onto the saturated, leaf-covered lawn.
She was leaving boot-sized prints that instantly filled with water. Clearly no one else had walked along this path today.
Halfway to the house, she stopped, trying to see if there was a different entrance. The sidewalk continued to the right, leading to a garage that was falling in on itself. No one would dare park a vehicle inside for fear of having the garage collapse on the vehicle itself.
To the left, the house was mostly strangled by overgrown bushes and grass. Going that way didn’t even look possible.
If there was a doorway near the garage, she didn’t see it. If no one answered at the front, she would try again on a drier day. She had five days to serve this particular envelope. Maybe she would see if she could find this Reggie Nielsen online or ask to see if Gruff Taylor (whose paperwork it was) knew whether Reggie Nielsen had a job somewhere.
She sloshed her way to those steps. They were made of concrete, not wood—which was a good thing. She wasn’t certain she would have trusted the wood, given that the railing was even more rotted than it had looked from the car.
The door really was flimsy. She could probably put her hand through one of the scrapes along the front.
She climbed up gingerly, put a booted foot on the half porch, and was happy to feel concrete strong enough to hold her weight.
She looked for a doorbell and finally found it, next to the door frame, covered in spiderwebs and dirt. The door was also covered with the kind of dirt that came from years of neglect and, she would wager, if she looked up, she would see even more spiderwebs, now probably wet and ropy in the rain.
She wasn’t going to look up.
She wrapped her sleeve around her left hand, then used it to press the doorbell. To her surprise, a wheezy bing-bong reverberated in the gloom.
Beneath her, several somethings peeped in panic, the sound alarming them almost as much as it alarmed her.
No lights came on, nothing moved inside the house. It had a neglected dirty odor, the kind the came from empty places. She leaned over and peered through the dirty picture window.
There was an old greenish-gold shag carpet, brighter and springier in places where furniture had been. The walls had squares that showed where pictures had once been. There were curtains on the floor leading to the dining area, and some old steps that curved toward the second floor.
But she was right: this place had been empty for a while.
And that pee-ish smell might have come from a squatter or two who had left the place before (or when?) she showed up.
She leaned back, wondering if it was worth her while to go around the house, and see what she could learn about Reggie Nielsen. That’s what she would have done, if it weren’t pouring. But the rain was defeating her.
And the peeping sound was beginning to annoy her.
She turned around, and saw something white, balanced on the side of the stair. It took a moment to realize the white squirmy thing was coming out from underneath the stair.
She suppressed a scream before she realized that whatever it was, it wasn’t a rodent. It didn’t have the right kind of tail. The tail was small and fur-covered and went out straight.
Her heart knew what she was seeing before her head realized it.
A kitten, so young that its eyes were barely open. It was peeping the way that kittens did when they were pinging for their mother.
“Oh, crap,” Julia muttered.
She had half a heartless second where she thought maybe she should pretend that she hadn’t seen the creature at all. But she would be back here tomorrow or the next day, and if she saw a dead kitten on the lawn, she would know that it was her fault.
She sighed, and scooped up the kitten with her right hand. Then she climbed gingerly down the steps and peered underneath the half porch.
It took a moment for her eyes to adjust to the gloom under the steps. Then she saw them. Two more white kittens, on a ledge underneath the house, near a gigantic puddle. There was no mama cat, no evidence that there had been a mama cat except for the kittens themselves and, she had to admit, the one in her hand was mighty thin.
How long had they been here? They probably had been all right for a day or so while Mama foraged, but she wouldn’t have been able to return to them with this puddle here. And she probably rescued what kittens she could, leaving the rest.
Mama cats were heartless that way—or practical—or non-sentimental, depending on your point of view.
Julia looked around behind her, saw nothing and no one except the rain and the growing dark. This one was on her.
Of course it was.
She took the first kitten back to her car. The kitten was silent now, and only its rapid heartbeat under her fingers let her know it was still alive. She struggled to free the remote from her pocket with one hand, and then unlocked the car.
She opened the back driver’s door, and tossed the paperwork into the front seat. She had a blanket in the back and several empty boxes she meant to take to recycling. She pulled out one of the boxes, put the blanket in it, and then put the kitten on the blanket. Then she closed the box, folding its ends in place, and hoping the kitten would stay while she rescued the other two kittens.
She closed the door gingerly, so that she didn’t startle the kitten any more than she already had, and returned to that horrible porch with the pinging kittens beneath it.
This was going to throw off her entire day. So much for returning to the office and filling out her paperwork so that Ethelina could notarize it all. Now Julia was going to have to deal with an emergency someone else had left her—or some pragmatic mother cat, who thought the space beneath the steps of an abandoned house was a good place to have babies, only to discover otherwise.
The water in the yard looked deeper. And it seemed a lot darker than it had a moment ago. The rain was heavier.
Julia sighed and stuffed the remote back in her pocket, zipping it closed again. She should really have grabbed her phone just for the flashlight feature.
Nice time to think of that.
She reached the stairs, her feet cold enough to make her wonder if her well-made rain boots were leaking. It wouldn’t surprise her, given how much wet she was sloshing through.
She crouched again, and peered underneath, waiting those few seconds for her eyes to adjust again.
The kittens had stopped peeping. If she hadn’t known they were there, she wouldn’t have seen them, huddled back against the wood of the house, bundled together for warmth.
She grabbed the bundle, separating the kittens. One squealed in protest, but the other, whose eyes were still closed, just huffed really hard as if it was too scared to fully catch its breath.
She carried them back to the car and stared through the back window for a moment. The box she had folded closed seemed the same. The last thing she needed was to open the car door and have the first kitten leap out.
The protesting kitten squirmed in her hand, but the kitten was tiny enough that she could hold it and pull the door open. She climbed inside with the kittens and pulled the door closed. That way, they couldn’t escape while she was trying to put them in the box.
She set the weak kitten on her thigh and used that hand to open the box. She peered inside. The first kitten hissed at her from the bottom. It was shivering, whether with fear or cold she didn’t know.
She put the kitten she still held in with its sibling, and then slid her hand around the third kitten. It was clinging to her jeans. She had to pry its tiny sharp claws off her leg.
The two kittens in the box were leaning on each other, as if relieved to be reunited.
She set the third kitten inside and quickly closed the box. Then she placed one of her textbooks on top of it, as well as a somewhat musty towel that she had stuffed in a corner and nearly forgotten about. She hoped that would hold the kittens until she got them somewhere.
But first, she had to satisfy herself that she had rescued all of the kittens. She reached across the seatback into the front seat, and grabbed her phone.
Then she double-checked the box, hoping that she hadn’t missed anything, and let herself out of the car again.
The rain had thickened into large drops that sounded like hail as they landed on her GORE-TEX. The lawn had become an ocean. If the mother cat was trying to get back here, there was no way she would be able to now.
Julia made it to the half porch and crouched. Her thighs complained about the unfamiliar movement for the third time in less than an hour. She turned on the phone’s flashlight feature, and wished she hadn’t.
She understood now what happened to the mother cat. The cat’s body was barely visible under the murky water. She swore quietly, and looked at that ledge to see if there were any more kittens.
She saw one more, squeezed so far in the back that she would have missed it without the flashlight. She reached in and grabbed the tiny fragile body. It was warm—barely—and as she pulled it out, the kitten turned, too weak to mew or even bite her.
She scanned the area one more time, knowing she would have nightmares for the rest of her life about the cat, the kittens, and the area under the porch. She glanced at the mother cat one last time, wondering how she had drowned. Had she hit her head? Gotten stuck?
It would be impossible to know without a real examination, and Julia didn’t have time for that, even if she had had the inclination, which she didn’t. She backed away from the area under the porch, noting as she did that the water had made its way to the lip of the ledge.
She had found those kittens in the nick of time.
Now she had to figure out what to do with them.
She carried the last kitten back to the car, followed the same procedure she had used with the first three. None of the first three had any desire to leave that box, and they barely noticed their sibling as she put it next to them.
That kitten hobbled over to them and leaned against them, contributing to the growing, shivering pile of kitten flesh.
She closed the box, got out one last time, and then let herself in the front of the car. She locked the doors, started the car, and turned the heat on as high as it would go, then set the blowers so that as much heat as possible would head into the backseat.
She had grown up with cats. She loved them, but hadn’t had any since she left her ex, five years ago. She had left two cats with him. They were his cats anyway. He had gotten them before her, and kept them afterwards—the kind of one-person cats who looked at anyone new in a relationship as the bad guy, not as an extra friend.
Her uncle had owned a farm, and she had spent a lot of time around barn cats. Her parents had had four cats, and she’d seen more kittens than she wanted to think about.
None of them had ever been as uncurious as this bunch. And listless. She had a hunch she didn’t have a lot of time to get them to a vet.
Time or money, really, but she’d worry about the money later. She hoped she still had some room on her credit card.
The car was turning into a small oven. She poked on her phone’s navigation app, searching for a vet nearby.
The closest was a fifteen-minute drive. She almost called ahead, and then stopped herself. She didn’t want them to say no, she couldn’t come in.
Instead, she drove down rain-slicked streets, probably not as cautiously as she should have driven, given the amount of water coming from the sky.
But she got to the vet’s office in ten minutes, was lucky enough to arrive just as another car pulled away from the front door, so she got the prime parking spot.
She was going to have to move fast. She put her phone in her pocket along with her wallet and the key to the car. Then she got out, grabbed the box from the back, and hurried to the front door.
For a second, she thought it wasn’t going to open. Then someone pushed it open from the inside. Julia and her box swept in, dripping all over a mat.
The interior was warm and smelled of wet dog mixed with antiseptic. The person who had let her in was a woman with brown hair, dressed in scrubs. Ahead of Julia was a long reception desk, with three different spots and two receptionists, both of whom were working on computers, and didn’t look up as she entered.
So Julia turned to the woman in scrubs.
“Hi,” Julia said, “I don’t have an appointment, but I just found these four kittens underneath a porch at an abandoned house. Their mother died, and I’m not sure they’re going to survive. Please….”
She didn’t finish that sentence because she didn’t know how. Besides, the woman didn’t wait for the answer. She took the box and said, “Come with me,” to Julia, and added, “I’m taking them to six,” to the receptionists.
One of them—a young man with silver studs gracing his eyebrows—looked up. “She needs to check in,” he said.
“This first,” the woman said, and hurried down a corridor to the right that Julia hadn’t even seen when she first entered.
The woman opened a door, and let her into an appointment room that was nicer than the last appointment room Julia had been in when she saw her own doctor. There was an exam table that came up to her chest, a sink over some cabinets near another door, and two comfortable looking chairs.
The woman handed the towel from the top of the box to Julia, and then pulled back the flaps. Both women peered inside, and Julia let out a small sigh of relief. All four kittens were still huddled together.
Part of her had been terrified that they had gotten loose in the car.
The woman stuck her hand, and felt the kittens, pulling on their fur. “They’ve been alone for hours. We need to get them some liquid. I’m going to take them to the back and start a drip for each one. Is it okay if you don’t watch the exam?”
“Yeah,” Julia said, uncertain what the procedure was. She had never brought cats to the vet. Her parents had brought their cats, and her ex had brought his.
“I’ll be back,” the woman said, and lifted the box. She leaned against the other door—which did not have a handle—and opened it. She paused right there and said, “I’m Dr. Garvey, by the way.”
“Julia Endicott,” Julia said.
“This’ll take a little while,” Dr. Garvey said. “Why don’t you give your information at the desk, and then come on back here when you’re done.”
“Okay,” Julia said, but the vet was gone before Julia had hit the second syllable.
For one brief second—one brief heart-stopping second—she thought about leaving. They wouldn’t be able to trace her, and then the kittens would be their problem.
But she didn’t know the procedure at this—or any vet—and what if they would just put down creatures that needed medicine but had no owners? She hadn’t saved them to lose them all over again. Not that she would have known if she snuck out.
She sighed, silently cursing herself. This was going to cost her more than she could afford in both time and money.
She let herself out of the room and ended up back in the reception area, which was now full of Great Danes. Two of them, near the far reception spot. The second receptionist, a woman with her glossy black hair pulled into a bun at the nape of her neck, was taking a credit card from the Great Danes’ owner, an elderly man who was dwarfed by the dogs.
One of the Great Danes had a cast on his left hind leg, but it didn’t seem to bother him. The other Great Dane looked just fine. The elderly man was talking about the aftereffects of some kind of shot, in a tone that suggested he was happy that the dogs got care, not that he had to pay for it.
If only Julia could feel that way.
She stopped in front of the male receptionist. He was a little beefier than he had seemed, with tattoos on his lower arms, near his wrists. He held up one finger as he finished typing something on his computer, then swiveled his chair toward her.
“So it was kittens?” he asked in a voice that was kinder than she expected.
“Four of them,” she said. “It was awful. They were under this porch and if one of them hadn’t crawled out, pinging, I wouldn’t have found them at all. They would have drowned.”
She glanced at one of the windows behind her, saw that the intense rain was continuing, and let out a breath.
“I mean,” she said, “it’s probably underwater now. They’d be gone now.”
Her voice wobbled even though she hadn’t intended it. The entire experience had affected her more than she realized.
“So they’re not your kittens?” he asked.
“No, I found them. I was at the house…” She wasn’t sure if she should say she served process. In fact, she decided at that moment she wasn’t going to.
The elderly man finished paying, sticking a gold AmEx back in his wallet. He grinned at the woman behind the desk, then led the dogs to the door.
“I was there—I work for a lawyer,” she said. “I was supposed to find the homeowner, but no one lives there, and then I saw the kitten.”
She told the story, and both receptionists listened, nodding and looking concerned.
“I suppose you need a credit card for all of this,” she said at the end of it all.
“Let’s get your name and your information,” the male receptionist said, “but we won’t deal with payment or anything until we know if those kittens are going to make it.”
Her eyes teared up. She hadn’t done all of this to have the kittens die at the vet.
“Kittens are hardy,” he said in that kind voice. “I’m sure they’ll make it.”
But she remembered her uncle’s farm. Kittens weren’t hardy, not like puppies. Kittens were fragile little creatures that survived—her uncle once said—only by the grace of God.
He used to laugh that cats survived in spite of their metabolism, not because of it.
When God decided he needed a fragile delicate carnivore, her uncle used to say, He invented the cat.
And the receptionist probably knew that, which was probably why he was going to wait for the verdict before taking a credit card from her.
Still, she gave her name and address and described the kittens to him as best she could, before heading back to that exam room.
There she sat on one of the chairs, and pulled her phone out of her pocket. Water dripped on her hand. Her GORE-TEX was still beaded with rain. She pulled off the coat, so she wouldn’t get wet on everything else, and hung the coat on the back of one of the chairs.
Then she called the office.
“I’m having a weird day,” Julia said after Ethelina answered. “Are you going to be around until eight or so? I’m not getting back until late.”
“Yeah, sure, I can stay,” Ethelina said, as if her presence after hours was unusual. “Why?”
So Julia told the full story for the second time, and when she finished, Ethelina said, “I can definitely stay. And I’m buying you dinner when you get here. Nothing fancy. Just Chinese takeout, but you need it.”
Julia laughed. She didn’t need takeout but she would take the kindness.
“Thank you,” she said. “Now, is Gruff still there? This is his case, and he needs to know what’s going on.”
“He’s here,” Ethelina said, and without saying anything else, transferred Julia to Gruff’s line.
“Yeah?” he said as he picked up, his tone dismissive. “You serve my subpoena?”
She decided, in that moment, she wasn’t going to tell him about the kittens. Not yet, anyway.
“No,” she said. “No one lives there. The house is abandoned.”
She realized, as she said that, she hadn’t done the normal things, like check the door to see if it was unlocked. The very idea made her shudder. That place was creepy.
But she also hadn’t checked to see if there was another livable structure in the back.
“Do you have a secondary address for this Reggie Nielsen?” she asked.
“No, that’s the only one I have in the file. I’ll see what I can turn up. You coming back here?” Gruff didn’t sound as upset as she had expected.
“I have to finish up something, then yes, I’m coming back,” she said.
“All right,” Gruff said. “I’ll see you when you get back.”
And then he hung up.
She let out a small breath. The man was infuriating, but he had been that kind of infuriating since she’d met him. She would have thought that she would be used to it by now, but she wasn’t.
She stuck the phone back in the pocket of her GORE-TEX and leaned forward, feeling more stressed than she expected.
The kittens had taken a lot out of her, or maybe it had been the day or the rain or the fact she had been surprised by the house itself.
The door to the back opened, and Dr. Garvey came back in.
“You brought them here just in time,” she said. “They were dehydrated. I could guess which one found you, because only one of them is as lively as a kitten should be.”
Julia nodded. “I’m amazed it found a way out of that space,” she said.
“Yeah.” Dr. Garvey gave her a small smile. “I’m glad I was still here. Even happier that I was out front, talking to reception. Sometimes they don’t move fast enough, and with those kittens, time was of the essence.”
“Was?” Julia asked.
“Two of them for sure will make it. The other two are touch and go,” Dr. Garvey said. “We’ll do the best we can, though. They’re dry now and in a warm cage together. They’re getting fed intravenously because I’m not sure they’re even weaned yet. Any idea what happened to their mother?”
“She drowned,” Julia said. “I saw her when I grabbed the last kitten.”
“Drowned. That’s weird,” Dr. Garvey said. “You’d think she’d be the one to survive.”
“I’m thinking maybe she got stuck or something,” Julia said. “There was a lot of water.”
She shuddered.
“Any explanation for the blood?” Dr. Garvey asked.
“What?” Julia suddenly felt cold. “What blood?”
“One of the kittens was covered in blood. You didn’t notice?”
“Is it okay?” Julia asked, then realized the question was stupid. Dr. Garvey had just told her the condition of the kittens.
“The kitten had no visible wounds, so the blood didn’t belong to it, or the other kittens. You didn’t notice?”
“I just grabbed them and put them in that box,” Julia said. “All of them were wet and cold. I just figured it was water.”
“No,” Dr. Garvey said. “It was blood. At least on one of them.”
“The first kitten, the one who found me, it didn’t have any blood,” Julia said. She frowned. She wasn’t sure about the last one, though, the one that was crammed far back into the wall.
“Hmm,” Dr. Garvey said. “I still have the cloth we used the clean the kitten off. Maybe I’ll type the blood and see what we have.”
Julia wasn’t sure if that sentence was a test, to see if the very idea alarmed Julia. It didn’t, although she found it curious.
“What would you hope to find?” Julia asked.
“I don’t know,” Dr. Garvey said. “I would have thought this relatively routine—kittens get abandoned all the time—until that blood. You say the house is empty?”
“Yeah,” Julia said. “It looked that way.”
“But you don’t know,” Dr. Garvey said.
“I can’t imagine anyone living there,” Julia said. “There wasn’t even furniture.”
Dr. Garvey nodded. “Those kittens are lucky you found them,” she said. “They wouldn’t have made it through the night.”
***The kittens were lucky, but Julia wasn’t. The bill was probably going to be astronomical. She gave the male receptionist her only credit card and prayed that she wasn’t already over her limit. He took down the number and told her they’d let her know what the charges were going to be when they figured out what, exactly, the kittens needed.
She nodded, left, and called the office, making sure Ethelina was still there. She was, and asked for an update, which Julia gave by rote. Then she drove back to the office, feeling a little numb.
The rain hadn’t let up. It was coming down so hard now that her heavy-duty windshield wipers couldn’t keep up. She had to go slower than she wanted to.
And the streetlights didn’t really penetrate the gloom. The sky was a weird brownish-gray color, almost as if the sun and the storm were having a fight just before sunset, and the sun was losing.
The office was in a neighborhood not too far from Oregon State University, but close enough to the Benton County Courthouse to hear the courthouse’s carillon play the Oregon State Beaver Fight Song twice a day. She bumped her way along the street, which was curved on both sides so that the water would run down to the drainage on days like today.
There was still a fine film of water on the pavement, though, which sprayed upward any time someone went by going too fast. That muddy spray added to the fight her windshield wipers were struggling with, and blinded her every single time.
When she finally reached the office, she pulled into the driveway very carefully. There was enough room for six cars in the parking area, but Adolphus always drove like a bat out of hell, and if he were trying to leave, he wouldn’t have seen her at all.
No one had left, or so it seemed, because there was only one spot left, as far from the back door as possible.
She put her phone in her pocket, slipped the paperwork under her GORE-TEX and got out of the car, splashing her way to the back door.
It was on a half porch just like the half porch at the abandoned house, only this particular half porch was well-maintained. There was no opening for a cat to crawl underneath. The stairs were clean, and the railing was made of some kind of treated metal that didn’t rust in Oregon’s impressive rains.
She pulled open the screen door, shoved the main door with her shoulder, and stepped into the office kitchen.
It smelled of coffee and sweet pipe tobacco, which meant that Gruff was breaking the rules again and smoking inside. He often did that on rainy days, which meant that throughout the winter one of the foremost attorneys in the State of Oregon flaunted the law that prohibited smoking in any indoor public space or place of employment.
She pulled the paperwork out of her GORE-TEX, and hung the coat on the coat rack in the narrow little hallway that led to the half-bath. Then she finger-combed her hair—not that it would do any good—and took the paperwork into what she called the hole-in-the-wall office for non-entities.
She and a rotating set of interns and junior associates had desks in what had once been this bungalow’s dining room. The side of her desk was pushed up against the corner. When she had time to sit there, her back was against the wall. She could see both doors and had half a view out the dining room window—half because half of the window was blocked by some kind of shrubbery with the ugliest rubbery leaves she had ever seen.
She set the paperwork on her desk, then walked through the other door into Ethelina’s Kingdom, aka reception. Ethelina was at her desk, leaning her head sideways as she cradled the phone between her ear and her shoulder. She was typing on the computer and had three paper calendars pulled close.
Julia waggled her fingers, and then pivoted so that she could return to her desk and write up her reports on her successful deliveries.
“Not so fast, Missy.” Gruff.
She closed her eyes for a brief moment. Of course, Gruff had seen her, and apparently he needed to talk with her. Then she opened her eyes and turned around again, not quite able to smile, but at least she had wiped the irritation off her face.
Gruff Taylor was six-two barefoot, but he insisted on wearing tooled cowboy boots that added another three inches to his height. At forty-five, he still had all of his hair, a mane of silver and gold that added another half-inch at least, except when he covered it all in a cowboy hat.
He was in his shirt sleeves and wore a pair of Levi’s tucked into those boots. He was the kind of thin most men got when they worked a ranch, but as far as Julia knew, he hadn’t done physical labor in his life.
He carried the sweet smell of pipe tobacco with him, stronger than usual, which just confirmed her suspicion that he had been smoking in his office.
“What’s this about kittens?” he asked.
Her shoulders slumped. She didn’t need this, particularly since they would end up busting her budget.
“I found four of them,” she said. “I took them to a nearby vet. At least two are going to live. Their mother drowned under the porch of that house you sent me to.”
He didn’t seem surprised, so Ethelina must have told him everything she knew.
“The vet also said she found blood on one of the kittens. She’s testing it,” Julia said. She didn’t want to have this conversation. “You find another address for Reggie Nielsen or do I need to do some digging?”
“Had Abbets do some,” Gruff said. Abbets was a recent hire who had a talent for finding odd information, and would probably end up as the permanent investigator for CT&T. “That’s Nielsen’s last known. He was fired from every single job he’d ever worked, so that’s getting us nowhere. And this time, he didn’t file for unemployment, which means there’s no help there.”
“What do you need him for?” Julia asked. It was a sign of just how tired she was that she even asked. Usually she just delivered the paperwork; she never asked why.
“Only eyewitness to a rape-murder,” Gruff said.
She made a tiny sound of disgust.
“How can you be an eyewitness to something like that?” Ethelina asked. Somewhere in the middle of this conversation, she had hung up the phone. “What kind of man fails to dive in and save the victim?”
“A man who was in the office building across the street,” Gruff said. He didn’t sound defensive or even strident. Just stating the facts, ma’am. “He saw the attack underway and called the police. By the time they arrived, the woman was dead and the killer was long gone.”
“You’re defending the killer?” Julia asked, unable to modulate her tone.
“I’m defending the alleged killer,” Gruff said. “Who was across town at the time, in the presence of five other people.”
“Sounds open and shut to me,” Ethelina said. She didn’t approve of Gruff’s return to his old defense practice. He had taken a side journey into corporate law after he had lost a particularly high-profile case, but corporate law was about staying out of the courtroom.
Gruff’s defense practice had been all about going into a courtroom.
“It would have been, if Nielsen hadn’t been so adamant about his identification,” Gruff said. “Apparently he worked for my client, and said he knew him, and recognized him in an instant. The police and the D.A. believe Nielsen. I want to talk to him, and I don’t like that he’s missing.”
“I didn’t say he was missing,” Julia said. “I said the house is abandoned. I wasn’t able to go to the back because of the kittens. I’ll go back tomorrow.”
“We’re going first thing,” Gruff said.
“We?” Julia asked. “I said I’d go. I’ll be fine.”
She hoped. The rain was supposed to end by morning. Maybe the house wouldn’t look as creepy in the thin winter sunlight.
“I’m coming with you,” Gruff said. “I don’t like how this is shaping out.”
“Why don’t you just deliver the subpoena, then?” Ethelina asked, because she knew Julia didn’t have the guts to make the same request.
“Because we like to follow procedure here, my dear Ethelina,” Gruff said. “Our procedure is that we have Julia serve process so that we lawyers have some distance.”
“You’ll be there,” Ethelina said drily. “There won’t be any distance.”
“Nor will there be any Reggie Nielsen, unless I miss my guess,” Gruff said. “But if he is there, then I’ll stay in the car, and Julia can give him the paperwork.”
It was a thin dodge. Ethelina’s gaze met Julia’s and Ethelina rolled her eyes. She was sitting behind Gruff’s back, so he didn’t notice.
“We’ll drive separately,” Gruff said. “Will that satisfy you, Ethelina? I felt that eye roll, you know.”
If Julia hadn’t been so tired and discouraged, she might have smiled. But she didn’t. “I’ve got reports,” she said, and headed back to her desk.
“Nine a.m. tomorrow, no matter what the weather,” he called, louder than he needed to.
“Yeah,” she said. “I’ll see you there.” Then she sat at her desk and resisted the urge to put her head in her hands.
Four kittens, a morning with Gruff, six reports, and a long night ahead. The only upside was that Ethelina was buying dinner.
Outside, the rain continued to pound against the roof and the windows, sounding like it would never ever end.
***But the weatherpeople were right: the rain stopped in the middle of the night, and the next morning dawned—if not sunny and warm, then at least lighter and not as cold. The air was still damp though and had a biting chill caused by all the humidity.
The ground was covered in puddles and the streets had what the weatherpeople sometimes called ponding, which wasn’t that normal in Oregon, because usually the drainage systems were up to the task of clearing out the water.
This time there had been so much water that it might take a few dry days before anything looked at all normal.
So, once again, Julia was driving slowly toward Reggie Nielsen’s last known address. In the thin sunlight, the neighborhood didn’t look quite as seedy. Some of the houses were well-kept, with actual yards that weren’t overgrown, and pruned trees and houses that didn’t need a new roof or a coat of paint.
Everything was older here, though—a neighborhood that was down on its luck, but, in some places, pushing valiantly on.
Just not at what had been the Nielsen house. She pulled over out front, and parked, not far from where she had been the day before.
If anything, the house looked seedier in the sunlight. It was the neighborhood haunted house, the place that everyone wondered why no one had torn it down already. All of the shrubs were overgrown, the grass taller than it had been the day before when it had been battered by the rain. The sidewalk really was a ruin of concrete chunks and that half porch looked even shakier than it had when she had been standing on it in the downpour.
She didn’t get out of the car. If Gruff wanted to join her, then he needed to join her. She had the paperwork on the passenger seat, just like she had the day before, and the phone in its little cradle. He hadn’t called her.
At that moment, Gruff’s black Ford F-150 pulled in behind her. At least it didn’t look like a lawyer’s vehicle. In fact, it was so old, it looked like it belonged in the neighborhood.
He got out and, to her surprise, was wearing some kind of rain boots instead of his cowboy boots. His jeans were faded and he wore a hooded sweatshirt underneath a light jacket she had never seen before. No hat this time either.
“Kittens under there, huh?” he asked, without saying hello. He nodded at the half porch.
“Yeah,” she said, her stomach knotting up. She didn’t want to look underneath. She’d thought about it all night, the mother cat, the possibility of more kittens.
It didn’t help that the vet had awakened her this morning. Julia had hesitated before answering, not wanting the bad news.
But it wasn’t bad news, not really. All four kittens were going to make it. They were still fragile and needed to be dewormed and defleaed as soon as they were strong enough to handle chemicals, but for the moment, they were sleeping on a blanket covering a bunch of cedar chips. That would keep the fleas from getting worse.
Julia could visit them later in the day, and probably would, once she untied the knots in her stomach. She didn’t really want to go to the vet’s for a variety of reasons, all of which were on her: She had no idea what to do with the kittens once they got healthy, and she really didn’t want to know what the final bill would be. She’d checked her finances sometime in the middle of the night, and even $100 was going to bust her budget, knock her over her credit card limit and give her no breathing room at all should something else happen.
But that problem wasn’t one she would solve before she had to meet Gruff, so she had set the problem aside, and had driven here.
A breeze added to the morning’s chill. The air smelled brackish, almost rotten, and that slightly foul odor was probably from mama cat’s body.
Gruff didn’t seem to notice. He was standing with his back to her, a toothpick in his mouth. He was studying the house.
“Maybe he knew this place was empty,” Gruff said, almost to himself.
“Huh?” Julia stood next to him. The sweet scent of pipe tobacco remained on him, but not strongly, almost like a light aftershave.
“Sometimes people who don’t want to be found give a fake address,” he said.
She knew that. She’d encountered it a lot when she had to serve someone. But they usually could be found anyway, through their social media or their job or a tip from a friend.
“Usually, the fake address is really fake,” she said. If he was going to mansplain, then she would too.
“Yeah.” Gruff looked at her. “Exactly. This one isn’t. That’s what bothers me. And the smell. You notice it? Something died.”
“The mama cat,” Julia said.
He shook his head. “Maybe,” he said. “Under the porch, right?”
He walked that way, avoiding the sidewalk altogether—either proving he was more practical right from the start, or that it was easier to see hazards in actual non-rainy daylight.
“Yeah,” she said. “I’m not going with you.”
“Didn’t ask you to,” he said. He reached the half porch in only a few strides. He didn’t go up the steps. Instead, he stopped below the picture window and looked through the glass, hands in his back pockets.
He nodded once, as if he had seen something he expected, and then he crouched, much like she had. He leaned in, and leaned back, a grimace on his face.
Then he stood up and walked back to her, rubbing his nose with the sleeve of his coat, as if he could get rid of the smell.
“She’s alone, right?” Julia asked, because she couldn’t hold it in any longer. She didn’t want to know the answer if it was no, but she had to know the answer, just so she could stop speculating.
“You got all the kittens out,” he said. “I’m sure she was happy with you.”
Julia blinked at him, trying to understand what he meant. And then she did. He meant that the mama cat was happy with her. The dead cat.
She hadn’t expected any kind of flight of fancy from Gruff Taylor.
“Wh-What makes you say that?” she asked, feeling a little surprised.
“A hunch,” he said. “Come with me.”
“I don’t want to see her—”
“You won’t have to,” he said. “I’ll take care of her or bring someone here to do it. Let’s go around the building, though. Bring your phone.”
“It’s in my pocket,” she said.
“Good,” he said, and strode across the lawn. She had to scurry to keep up. The ground was saturated, but the thick grass made it not quite as muddy as it could have been.
They reached the driveway and the nearly ruined garage. The smell got stronger here, not less. Gruff made a face, then glanced at her.
“You have a strong stomach, I trust,” he said, and it wasn’t a question. It was almost a command.
She nodded. She did have one, fortunately or unfortunately.
He glanced at the garage, then passed it as if it meant nothing.
Behind the house was a rusted Impala that made her car look like a Lamborghini. The car probably ran, though, judging by the tires and the fact that it was parked a little sideways, like people did when they parked in a hurry.
Gruff glanced inside the Impala as well, then moved past it.
The back of the house had two stone steps leading to a back door. The screen door was sitting beside the house in a pile of weeds.
The smell was stronger here.
“We should call the police,” she said.
“Not yet.” He climbed up the stairs, and peered through the window in the door. Then he pushed the door with his booted foot.
The door creaked open, revealing a door stop that had moved aside, just a little, as if it had been battered in the wind.
Julia took another step forward. The smell increased even more, but that didn’t stop her. She saw something on the linoleum ahead of her.
A blood trail from one of the cabinets to the threshold.
The blood was an actual drag trail, about an inch wide, and there were paw prints in the blood. They vanished at the stoop, probably because of yesterday’s incredible rain.
Her stomach knotted, and she couldn’t entirely blame that on the smell. She leaned a little farther forward, saw two shoes splayed outward, clearly attached to legs.
She couldn’t see the entire body, but Gruff could. He tilted his head back, as if he wasn’t quite sure what to think. Or maybe he wasn’t surprised.
“You can call the police now,” he said.
She didn’t though. “Is that Reggie Nielsen?”
“That’s my guess,” Gruff said. “A pretty educated guess really.”
“What happened?” she asked.
Gruff came back down the stairs. The door eased closed on its own.
“He was shot.” Gruff ran a hand over his face, then shook his head. “His gun’s still there. There was some kind of firefight.”
“He was living there?” she asked.
“Just in that room,” Gruff said. “Or maybe he was using the kitchen and living somewhere else on the property. Doesn’t matter. He’s dead now.”
Gruff’s eyes were sad. Julia wrapped her arms around herself, and looked at the scene around her.
Someone had tracked this man, who was living rough, and then shot him. Why? She only knew of one reason, but then, she didn’t know Nielsen.
Still, the reason was compelling enough that the police would figure it out as well.
“You need to go,” she said. “I’ll call the police after you leave.”
Gruff shook his head. Maybe he wasn’t thinking clearly.
“Seriously,” she said. “This will have an impact on your defense.”
He gave her a sad smile. “I can’t ask you to lie.”
“I wouldn’t,” she said. “I just wouldn’t mention you.”
“Which is a lie of omission,” he said. “I’m an officer of the court. I can’t cover something up.”
So he had thought of it.
“What kind of person are you defending?” she asked ever so quietly. “The kind of person who would do this?”
He glanced over his shoulder, then sighed. “You know,” he said. “Innocent until proven guilty is a hard standard to maintain.”
She didn’t know that—or maybe hadn’t—until this morning, until he said that.
“I love the courtroom,” he said. “Just love it. I’m good at it too. But very few things take you into the courtroom. I’m not cut out to be a prosecutor. The government overworks you and pays you too little. But this…”
He shook his head. “Call.”
She started to object again, but he held up his hand.
“I’m not cut out to be a defense attorney,” he said. “I learned that lesson once before, but I’m older. I thought I’d get past it. There is no ‘past it.’”
“And now you’re stuck,” she said, “defending someone who might have done this to silence a witness.”
He gave her a half smile. It made him look younger and actually vulnerable.
“I can’t defend him,” Gruff said. “I’m a witness. It’s a conflict.”
He sounded…relieved? Resigned? She couldn’t quite tell. It was her turn to sigh. She took out her phone and dialed 911, as she walked away from the smell. The dispatch answered, and Julia reported the body, the address, and was honest about why she was there: she was serving process.
She didn’t give Gruff’s name, though. If he was going to implode this part of his career again, he had to do it on his own.
The Impala was filled with clothes, and papers, and pillows. On top of one of the pillows was a brand-new package of cat toys. It made her heart twist.
Had Nielsen gotten those toys for mama cat? Was she his cat? Or had he thought maybe he could tame her with the toys?
The dispatch said that units were on their way.
Julia hung up, turned around, saw Gruff watching her. She went to the door, but he caught her arm.
“You don’t need to,” he said.
“Is there cat food inside?” she asked.
He blinked at her, then looked, which was so much easier for him, because he was taller.
“Yeah,” he said. “A bowl of kibble.”
Something in his tone caught her.
“And more blood, right?” she asked.
He nodded. “Your mama cat got shot too,” he said.
“The drag marks,” she said. “Mama got her babies out of the house, to somewhere safe, she thought.”
“Yeah,” he said. “I didn’t want to tell you that she had a wound on her side. She probably didn’t drown.”
“Do you think there are more kittens inside?” Julia asked.
“We’ll look,” he said gently. “But I doubt it. Your mama cat was pretty heroic.”
And his statement that mama cat had been happy with Julia. It was less sentimental than fact. In her dying hours, that cat had used all of her strength to rescue her kittens, only to place them in even more danger.
If one of the kittens hadn’t climbed up that stoop, they would have died anyway.
There were sirens in the distance.
Gruff didn’t seem to notice.
“I’m going to pay for those kittens, by the way,” he said.
She shook her head. “I’m the one who decided to take them in.”
“It’s my case,” he said. “My responsibility.”
Then he glanced at the door, which was all the way closed now. Either that diminished the smell a bit or Julia was getting used to it.
“And I’ll take two of them,” he said.
“What?” It took her a moment to follow his logic. “Two kittens?”
He nodded. “I’m going to need a reminder that I’m not cut out for parts of this job.”
“Kittens are more than a reminder,” Julia said. “They’re work.”
“I know,” he said quietly. “I’ve had cats before.”
The sirens were closer. A slight breeze, cool and damp, brushed against Julia’s face. Maybe that was why the smell was dissipating a little.
“You’ll let me pay,” he said.
Odd that she had control. But she did. And she wasn’t going to decide against her own interest.
“Yeah,” she said.
He gave her a thin smile. Then it faded.
“I gotta tell you one more thing,” he said, glancing at the Impala. She wasn’t sure he even saw it, not really. He just seemed to need a place to look that wasn’t her face. “I wasn’t being creepy when I told you I’d take you to the gun range.”
She stiffened. She didn’t want to have that conversation, not as the sirens seemed only a few blocks away.
“Process serving isn’t safe,” he said. “I worry about sending you out. I argued with Adolphus about it.”
“I’m okay,” she said, although she wasn’t sure. “Besides, having a gun doesn’t solve everything. It didn’t help Mr. Nielsen.”
Gruff stared at her for a moment. “You’re tougher than you look,” he said.
And you’re a lot more sensitive than you seem, she almost said. But she didn’t. Because he was being kind and sad, and not the man she saw at the office at all.
The sirens got quite close and then shut off. She thought she heard car doors slam.
This would take most of the day, most likely. Interviews, discussions, the case. She’d tell the police about mama cat, or maybe Gruff would, so that someone would remove that body too. And Julia would ask someone to look for kittens inside, but she agreed with Gruff: she doubted there were any. Mama had been with the four when she died. If she had bled out while dragging kittens to the hiding place, she would have been somewhere between the back door and the front stoop.
Julia would never have found her, and Gruff wouldn’t have figured out what happened to her.
Or figured out what happened to Nielsen, who apparently had been trying to do the right thing by reporting what he had seen the day of the rape and murder.
Then she shook her head slightly. Maybe he had been that man. Or maybe she had made up his motive because he was trying to take care of mama cat.
She would probably never know, because Gruff was going to be off the case real soon now. Seconds from now, once the police arrived at the back of the house.
In that instant, Gruff would go from defense attorney to witness, and she would go from process server to witness too.
Almost as if he could hear her thoughts, Gruff said, “This isn’t going to be fun.”
“It’s already not fun,” she said, as two uniformed officers entered the backyard.
But it was necessary.
Just like serving process.
And rescuing kittens in the pouring rain.
Serving Process
Copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
First published in Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine, July/August 2022
Published by WMG Publishing
Cover and Layout copyright © 2023 by WMG Publishing
Cover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG Publishing
Cover art copyright © eric1513/Depositphotos
I know, I know. The title is harsh. Because the topic is harsh.
Remember, I have decades worth of experience watching and trying to help writers. And I have learned, to my chagrin, that some writers are beyond help.
Or rather, the help those writers need is beyond anything I or any other writer/mentor can provide.
The writers who are beyond help often ask for help, especially early on. They take classes. They try a few things. They talk a great game. They might know everything that there is to know about writing/publishing/agents or whatever holds their interest.
But when you actually look at what they do, the one thing they do not do is write.
Let me amend that.
They do not write for publication, whatever publication might mean.
There are a handful of these writers who actually write a lot and put it all in a drawer. This has been the behavior of some writers since the dawn of time. Ever hear of Emily Dickinson’s sister? Her niece? Well, they’re the ones who got her work published after she died. (Even that is a long sad story, filled with anger and lawsuits and tampering with the poetry.)
In her lifetime, ten of Emily Dickinson’s poems were published, and some speculate that she had nothing to do with the publications. She wrote the poems, handbound them, and sent them in little booklets to friends and family. Speculation is that some friend or family member had the poems published—anonymously, mind you—because someone believed that Dickinson’s voice should not have been silenced. When asked if her work could be put into a charity anthology or even an anthology of anonymous work, she dithered and ultimately, through dithering, let the opportunity pass.
Does that sound familiar to any of you? That dithering is often the subconscious, worrying about what might happen if something is published.
Whatever fears the writer has—a fear of failure, a fear of success, a fear of being “revealed” for who they really are—mount. The writer simply can’t overcome them, and so, rather than publish, the writer dithers or fails to mail things or indie publish things.
The writer often guarantees their own failure.
I’ve watched so many writers do this. If you don’t try, then you can’t fail on a large level. If you don’t put your work out there, then you won’t have to see that the world won’t fall at your feet just because you published something. If you don’t put your work in print, then you won’t have to see what readers or critics or your friends will say about it.
These fears are paralyzing for many writers (heck, for many creatives in all disciplines). I still run from singing, mostly because singing in public brings memories of my mother. The last time I sang with a group, when I was around 40, we participated in a competition at Portland’s Arlene Schnitzer Concert Hall.
We performed on a riser, and I was toward the back. After I climbed to my position and turned around, I could see the front rows of the audience. And there, for a moment, was my mother. She sat in one of the chairs to the side, a frown on her face. I figured I was seeing a woman who looked like my mother.
We started singing, and the woman who looked like my mother started shaking her head. Then she sighed and rolled her eyes, just like my mother would have.
I made myself look away.
When I looked back, the seat was empty. I doubt anyone had been sitting there. Or maybe I had been right; a woman who looked like my mother sat there briefly.
It didn’t matter. My throat closed up, my voice failed me, and I couldn’t wait to get off that stage.
I haven’t sung in public since.
What would it take to get me to sing in public? I’m not sure. I’ll probably find out in the next few years. I’m hoping to muscle my way past it. But if I can’t, then I know what I would need to do.
Therapy. Talk therapy, focused on exorcising that woman from my brain so that I can enjoy an art form I’ve loved since I was little.
What happened to me on that stage (and on most stages where I had to sing) happens to writers too. Something terrifies them on a deep level about either writing or publishing.
So those writers do what they can to guarantee the failure.
The problem that we creatives have when they have this kind of paralyzing fear is that the fear encompasses success as well as failure. Success—singing on stage in a competition that we were winning—is just as hard if not harder than bombing.
I always expect to bomb when I sing. When I realize that I’m not bombing…well, then the throat seizes up and the voice quits.
It’s not conscious.
Nor is it conscious for a writer who needs to fail to protect themselves. They don’t get to the writing. Or they don’t publish their work. Or they don’t mail it (if they want to be traditionally published).
Logic doesn’t work here. If you ask that person what they’re afraid of, they might tell you or they might dance around it. How would I have answered about my singing? That I was terrified that the ghost of my long-dead mother would disapprove?
It’s not about logic. It’s about emotion, and that emotion is almost always fear.
If you see yourself in this, and you really, really, really want to be a published writer, then you need to get professional help. That professional help is not another writer. Which is why I say that as a writing teacher, I can’t help a writer like this.
The powers that stifle that writer’s voice are beyond the powers that I have, the recommendations and the exercises. Some of these writers take a lot of courses from WMG. Some of these writers do well at them. These writers often do well one on one, but not at the larger picture.
The larger picture is that something is twisted up in their psyche that creates a fear so big that the writer can’t overcome it with practice or logic or effort. The writer needs to untangle the something—whatever it is. And with storytelling (as with singing) that something probably came out of childhood.
I know mine did. I worked enough on myself with the help of a therapist that I can see where my mother’s own fears triggered my own. She was a spectacular singer. (I have great memories of her singing descants and harmonies on hymns in church…while she stood in the pews. Her voice would soar.)
As a young woman, she was offered an opportunity to study with one of the great opera singers of the time and turned it down. Or it did not happen for another reason.. I have no idea why. Was she afraid? It would make sense. She had been orphaned young, sent to live with a bunch of siblings, endured a lot of abuse, and probably did not have the confidence to declare that she wanted the opportunity. Or maybe it was as simple as money. It was the 1930s. Depending on who she was living with at the time, there might not have been enough money for her to take advantage of the opportunity.
Whatever it was, it morphed into her being extremely critical of anyone who sang—even professionals that she saw on television or on the radio. She directed church choir for decades, but not a choir I was ever in. Still, that didn’t save me from her savage reviews of anything I sang.
That’s all in there for me. And if I’m going to sing, I need to remove that influence.
Right now, removing that influence is not worth the time for me. Maybe someday it will be.
But it will take time and effort—a lot of effort.
And that’s what writers who let themselves fail on this level also face. Solving the problem will take courage to face their own stuff. It’ll take money to get professional help. And it will take time.
There is no magic bullet or an easy solution. There’s the solution that will help the writer along, but that solution is unique to that writer. There is no one-size fits all.
As I mentioned at the start, I’ve seen a lot of writers with this issue. Most of them are like me with singing. They try occasionally, but don’t really put in the effort. They coast on who they were or on the praise from a teacher long ago or on that one contest that they won or the single short story sale that they made decades before.
Every now and then, though, writers surprise me. I privately dismissed them, thinking they had too many issues to ever continue with the writing. After a year or two of excuses, I usually help the writers only when it can’t be avoided. There are so many other writers who actually take advice or who are striving, even if it is not in ways that I would recommend.
I admire effort, and if I see no effort, I’m not going to put in the time either.
The writers who surprise me, though, are the ones who actually do find help. Real help. They do the work to get past their issues. Sometimes it takes years. But these writers all figure out a way around the fear.
The metaphor I think of is another one to do with actual performance. Years after I was out of school, I learned that some performers have stage fright so badly that they throw up before every performance.
Those performers go on stage anyway. They deal with the fear their way, and then perform their art, whatever it is.
I had no idea that such a thing was possible. I figured that fear would win every time—at least when it came to singing on a stage. I had no idea there were workarounds.
However, if you asked young me for a workaround of any obstacle I discovered in my writing career, I would find that workaround. Sometimes it took years. Sometimes it took working outside the box.
And sometimes it took sucking up the bad stuff and setting it aside so that I could continue doing what I love—which is writing and publishing.
In fact, this past summer, I did a series of videos about the Fey. They accompany my book, Lessons From the Writing of the Fey. That book was hard to write, and the videos were even harder to do.
I had had a series of career-killing problems with those books, and I had managed to survive, through the support of Dean and my friends, but also by setting each indignity aside. I kept working and I mostly ignored all the bad shit.
Yes, therapists who are reading this. I know. Denial is a bad thing. But it helped me through the abusive world of traditional publishing, and it helped me work on the Fey back in the day.
It only became a problem when I decided I’d write the next book in the series. Then I had to face those problems and exorcise them. I had to talk about them. I had to figure out if I could overcome them.
It took work. I had to overcome some major project blocks to get there. I finally had to go to the readers of the series and ask them to give me a deadline through Kickstarter.
I don’t miss deadlines. Not when someone important to me expects the work to be done by that deadline.
I knew the deadline would work.
But, ironically, I had to do so much work on myself and getting past all the blocks I had set up so that I wouldn’t fail with the Fey again, that I did miss the deadline we had set. We had the option of refunding the Kickstarter money…and every time someone suggested that I got mad.
I would finish the novella we had promised. I knew I would.
And I did.
Doing so released me and got me to write three more books so far. The project lives again.
I suspect getting through all of that was my equivalent of throwing up (repeatedly) before going on stage. It took work, it took determination, and it took years to figure out how to work around the blocks that my experiences—and my self-protection mechanism gave me.
Let me tell you from experience: It’s easier to stay off stage than it is to deal with one’s personal bullshit. But staying off stage is a lot less satisfying than overcoming the blocks—whatever they are—to achieving your dreams and goals.
Sometimes failure is a mask for a deeper issue.
If you really want something, you find a workaround.
And you do it on your own time.
It might take you years.
And that’s okay.
As long as you try.
This weekly blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynrusch to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: How Writers Fail Part 11: They Want To,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © Can Stock Photo / benzoix
First, a thank you! We hit our ask on the Kickstarter for The Court-Martial of the Renegat Renegades within the first hour! And our first stretch goal a few hours later. Couldn’t have done it without you all!
WMG Publishing is doing all kinds of fun ads and such for the Kickstarter. Figured you’d want to see this one.
A standalone Diving book! Yep, if you haven’t read the series, you’ll be able to read this novel. It’s a legal thriller space opera, and wow, did I have fun writing it. The book won’t officially appear until June, but you can get an early copy of either the ebook or the paper edition if you back the Kickstarter.
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/403649867/the-new-diving-novel
I’ll have more news on the Kickstarter and all that’s happening with it in a few days.
When Keisha married Ruben, she planned the perfect wedding—and the perfect wedding cake. But when an uninvited guest ruins the reception, it unravels not only Keisha and Ruben’s perfect day, but everything about their relationship.
Keisha’s mother always said Keisha led a cursed life, but she never believed in magic. So, when an unexpected event brings Keisha and Ruben back together again, Keisha must make a choice: hold on to her beliefs or place her trust in Ruben once and for all.
“After the Wedding,” by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook through various online retailers here.
After the WeddingKristine Kathryn RuschIt all went sour one hour after Keisha and Ruben finished their vows. Triumphant photographs taken, family organized in a tight groups, candles placed nearby for mood lighting, even the good Reverend Fisher smiling as if he had done something right.
Maybe he had. The day was beautiful. The sky so blue it looked like a painting, the sun warm but not too bright. Drops of rain remained on the newly bloomed pink heritage roses in the church’s two-acre garden. The caterer didn’t even think they needed the white tent that Keisha had reserved, although when she saw it wasn’t there, she had her mother request it be put up anyway.
And that was when they all heard the scream.
Keisha gathered her organza gown over her knees, kicked off her ridiculously tall, thin, and expensive heels, and ran barefoot across the newly mowed grass—once a cop, always a cop, she reflected later—butting guests aside to get to the woman in distress.
The screams were high and piercing, terrified and out of control. As she got closer, she saw some of the guests (groom’s side, sharing his dark brown skin and his square shoulders) standing, with hands clapped over their mouths.
She plowed through them as well, hands grabbing at her, trying to stop her from going any farther. But there was no stopping her, so the crowd parted, revealing the cake.
The cake. The one thing she had truly splurged on. Keisha believed that weddings were the point of the event, not the reception afterward, although she wanted to show her friends her appreciation. She believed in vows and marriage and happily ever after.
Not some drunken asshole, crushing her six-foot-tall chocolate, white, strawberry, and caramel layer cake, perfectly divided up so that friends could have a piece with just one flavor or with all the flavors mixed in.
She had spent weeks contemplating that cake, and now a man in a cheap suit sprawled on top of it, compacting all six feet down to two feet, the little bride and groom, sculpted by one of Ruben’s friends into perfect replicas of Ruben and Keisha, in pieces on the wooden platform the caterer had placed over the uneven ground.
Keisha stomped around the table, covered with ruined bits of cake. That asshole, whoever he was, owed her $2,000 for the cake. Maybe he owed her $4,000 if she added in pain and suffering. Maybe he owed her $8,000 if she counted the loss of one of her childhood dreams. When she’d been a starry-eyed little girl, she’d never imagined the reception after the wedding. She’d imagined walking down the aisle in the world’s most beautiful dress (check) to meet the world’s most handsome man (check) for the world’s most beautiful ceremony (check). Afterwards, she’d serve her friends the most marvelous cake ever.
Ever.
Dammit.
She reached the man’s side, about to grab him, pull him backwards and slap him so hard that he would both wake up and know she meant business, when she saw the knife hilt sticking out of his back. She knew from the location and the size of the hilt that this man was really and truly dead.
Not to mention the fact that he had face-planted into the cake and had been there long enough for her to run across the church yard, which meant that he might have suffocated in chocolate, white, and caramel frosting.
“Well, that didn’t work,” Ruben said from beside her. His bass voice, with hints of Georgia mixed with just a bit of the Paris of his school years, usually sent shivers through her. At this moment, it just made her mad.
She waved her hand at the woman who made the cake, a woman who eschewed the word “baker” for the name “cake artist.”
“Have you called 911?” Keisha asked in her take-no-prisoners cop tone.
The cake artist burst into tears. Keisha’s eyes narrowed. Shouldn’t she be the one sobbing right now? She was the bride, and this was her dream wedding, and she had planned for this idiot day for over a year.
But she didn’t sob. She looked past the cake artist, and found her friend Joseph, his eyes wide.
“Call 911,” she said.
He nodded, and with shaking hands, pulled out his cell phone.
Was she the only calm person here?
“No one leaves,” she said. “Make sure your friends and neighbors stay.”
She looked at one of the pimply faced ushers—some cousin of Ruben’s.
“You,” she said, “go to the valets and tell them no cars are allowed to leave. Don’t tell them why.”
The kid nodded.
She would secure the crime scene as best she could. The reception, clearly, was ruined.
Now, she gave Ruben the glare she’d been holding back. He still looked magnificent in his tux. It accented his dark dark skin. She loved that skin, its shine and its smoothness. She loved his high cheekbones and almost-black eyes.
Except right now.
“What do you mean, that didn’t work?” she asked, keeping her voice low.
He clearly heard the anger in it, because he raised his eyebrows. “The church,” he said. “Your mother had insisted on the church. Nothing goes wrong in a church, she said.”
Keisha raised her chin slightly.
They weren’t in the church. They were in the church yard.
His idea. He wanted the reception outside, weather permitting.
I can’t ask my momma to celebrate her only boy’s wedding in a dingy church basement, babe.
It was a compromise. One she had made for him. One she hadn’t thought through.
She turned away from him, saw her best friend Mattie, looking radiant in the mauve maid of honor dress she had picked out herself.
“Know any cake places that deliver?” she asked Mattie, because if anyone knew, Mattie would. She liked eating in more than she liked dining out.
Mattie tilted her head slightly sideways. “You want cake?”
“Everyone’s going to be here a few hours longer than expected,” Keisha said. “We might as well feed them.”
“The show must go on,” Ruben said quietly. But his deep voice was loud enough for the people closest to the table to hear.
She wished she still had her spiky heels. She’d stomp one on his ridiculously expensive Italian leather shoes.
“It’s not a show,” she snapped. “It’s a crime scene.”
In more ways than one.
***It wasn’t that she didn’t care about the dead guy. She’d seen enough bodies in her career that she immediately snapped into professional mode.
Apparently, she should have sobbed and fallen into her new husband’s arms. Because, when everything settled down, Ruben called her cold, businesslike, unfeeling. She called him insensitive and unsympathetic. He called her an ice princess. She called him a horn dog. He called her frigid. She called him a sex addict.
They stopped speaking. They stopped frequenting their favorite restaurants.
They got a divorce, before they even had a marriage.
He got the condo they were going to live in together. She got the apartment they had lived in. He got the old bedroom set. She got the new one, untouched and pristine, waiting for the wedding night that never happened.
The marriage receded so far into the past that most of her friends had no idea she’d been married. They tried to hook her up with gorgeous men, or nice men, or men who happened to be both. She turned down all offers. She hadn’t gone on a date since her first date with Ruben years before.
If anyone asked why, she said she was unlucky in love.
But if her close friends commented on it, she snapped at them.
I’m cursed, she’d say. Let’s leave it at that.
***The dead guy was one Maximo Severinus Cosima. She’d never met him. No one that she knew had ever met him, at least while he was alive. Ruben’s family seemed to have no ties to him either. The caterer hadn’t seen him before. The cake artist—who left the business after all of this—had never heard of him.
Apparently, he had wandered into the church yard, saw the gigantic cake, and died—added, of course, by the knife in the back.
There was no security footage, no one had recorded any video on their phones. The wedding photographers and videographers were inside the church, the caterer in the kitchen, the guests waiting in the lovely sunshine.
Maximo Severinus Cosima had simply stumbled in from nowhere, his last act on Earth ruining the happiest day of a couple’s life.
And yes, Keisha knew she was blaming the victim. She really didn’t care. She couldn’t blame the victim in most of the cases she handled. Victims were generally victims, often of random crimes or their own bad taste in lovers.
But this guy seemed to attract haters from every walk of life, and as the ranking detective on the case said, it was a miracle that someone hadn’t murdered Maximo Severinus Cosima before that particular day.
Keisha waved off most discussions of Cosima. She didn’t want to think about him. The man had crushed a cake as he died, and revealed all the fractures in a relationship that she had thought perfect. Stupid fractures in hindsight. Fractures that shouldn’t have caused a divorce.
She didn’t like reminders that she had done something wrong.
So she didn’t think about Ruben or Cosima or cake for ten years.
Not until the death of Jolene DuPrix.
***Jolene DuPrix, all around gadfly and major pain in the ass. She’d been difficult in high school, always complaining in that nasal voice of hers that she had been wronged somehow. Her Bs in pre-Calculus came because Mr. Gyleen didn’t like her. Her failure to make the varsity cheerleading squad sophomore year was because she wasn’t allowed to be the top of the cheer pyramid.
She whined and bitched and bullied her way through everything, damn near getting voted homecoming queen just because everyone was afraid of hearing her bitch if she lost. (She still lost; she bitched.)
Keisha wasn’t her only friend because Keisha didn’t consider herself a friend. But Keisha, at least, talked to her. And continued to talk to her whenever Jolene called.
Jolene stayed in their small hometown when Keisha moved north for college. Jolene got a job at the old Andrew Carnegie library when Keisha got a masters in criminal justice. Jolene never became head librarian because she never got a degree. Keisha became one of the most educated new officers in the expanded Danica, Illinois, police department—big city police, because they were just south of Chicago.
Diversity hire, Jolene had sneered on Keisha’s Facebook post announcing her new job. Keisha hadn’t unfriended her, not after that, but she had asked not to see any of Jolene’s posts any longer.
And that, Keisha thought, was that.
Until Jolene died alone in her book-filled two-bedroom house, not even a cat to keep her company.
Jolene, who left everything to her “best friend,” Keisha Summers.
***Keisha could have refused the inheritance. She knew how. She’d heard some of her lawyer friends complain about the vagaries of estates in the past.
But Jolene’s lawyer sweetened the pie with talk of collectibles and hundreds of thousands of dollars in the bank.
Keisha didn’t care about the money or the stuff. She was going to turn the proceeds over to one of the police department charities after all. She had planned on giving it to Jolene’s library, but it had closed two years before due to state budget cuts.
She wasn’t exactly sure why she had accepted the inheritance, except that it felt wrong to turn the inheritance down. Keisha joked that the people who had known Jolene knew that the only reason she had accepted the estate was because Keisha was afraid Jolene would haunt her, whining for all eternity. But in reality, Jolene DuPrix had had a strange and lonely life, and the last thing Keisha wanted to do was reject the poor woman one final time in death.
Keisha hired an auction firm to clean out Jolene’s house for a percentage of the sales. She hadn’t expected to hear from the company until the auction was over.
But the company’s owner called her one rainy afternoon, asking her if she could come to town for just one day. He had found some strange things he felt she needed to see.
She went, and it changed her life forever.
*The room looked like something out of one of those creepy (and usually wrong) serial killer TV shows. Blocked-off windows, photographs glued to butcher paper on the wall, bits of yarn between the images. All of the images revolved around Keisha, and had from childhood. There was even a photograph of a wedding cake, with Keisha’s little girl handwriting on it: Imagine this at your wedding!
The images were too much to take in all at once, but she saw pictures of Ruben, pictures of Ruben and Keisha back when they were happy, even pictures of Cosima, when he had been alive.
She photographed it all with her smart phone, then called the Danica police department, asking for one of the detectives who had been on the wedding case. Of course, he was retired. It took three different transfers and a conversation with the chief of police before she discovered that the Cosima murder had gone so cold as to be forgotten.
Only one of the detectives was still on the case. She sent him a copy of the photographs, told him the estate was moving apace, and he needed to get down here immediately. He texted he’d get to it eventually, so she called the chief back, and magically, she got another text. The detective and his new team would be there in two days.
She wasn’t going to wait around. She couldn’t be involved, since the death had happened at the wedding she wanted to forget. And now there were other ties, ties that if she were the investigating detective, she would be looking at closely.
The auctioneer wanted to know what to do. She told him that he had to leave everything in place and postpone the auction for one month. She paid him a little extra for the inconvenience, cursing the fact that she was dealing with yet another personal crime scene.
Then she went home, and called Ruben.
***They hadn’t spoken since the day the divorce was finalized. Ten years and change. She expected his phone number to be different. She expected to use the police department database to track him down. She expected a woman to answer the landline when she finally figured out where he was.
Instead, she got Ruben: that bass voice still had hints of Georgia mixed with just a bit of the Paris of his school years, and it made her shiver. She even knew what the tone meant, just from his hello. He was confused.
“Ruben,” she said, surprised her own voice sounded so calm. “I didn’t mean to surprise you, but I thought you needed to know. They finally found a link between us and Maximo Severinus Cosima.”
She half expected Ruben to ask who Cosima was. It had been ten years. The name had haunted her, but it probably hadn’t haunted Ruben.
She expected him to ask what the link was. Instead, he asked, “You have time to tell me in person?” and her stomach clenched.
She hadn’t thought of that. The phone contact didn’t bother her, but in person? She hadn’t planned for it. And except for events that occurred while she was on the job, she planned for everything.
“Sure,” she said, surprised once again that her voice could sound so calm. “Where do you want to meet?”
“The usual spot?” he asked.
The usual spot had been a trattoria and bakery a block from the condo they eventually bought together.
“It’s still open?” she asked.
He chuckled, a deep rich sound that she had missed on a visceral level. “Open and growing. You won’t recognize it, Keesh.”
No one else had ever called her Keesh. When he had first done it, she had said that she wasn’t a food item. But he persisted, and she had found it endearing.
Until it hadn’t been.
That memory sent a chill through her. She didn’t want to be that woman, the one who visited with her ex, remembered what she loved about him and forgot what she had hated.
She almost said no, let’s talk on the phone. But it would be easier to show him the photographs than it would be to either text them or to describe them.
And, she had to admit, she was curious about his life. She had purposely refrained from searching for him on the web or seeing if he had a Facebook account or using her department resources to track him.
She hadn’t wanted to be that woman either.
“Tomorrow?” she asked. “Maybe six o’clock.”
“I’ll be there with bells on,” he said, and laughed.
***He actually did wear bells, on the end of a little striped fool’s cap. It was red and white, probably a Christmas elf cap, and it did give his face an elfin look—even though he was over six feet and nothing about him was tiny.
That thought made heat rise in her cheeks.
The trattoria had grown. It had wings, where the owners had bought out nearby businesses. The bakery now had a separate entrance.
She had entered that way, and ended up—as she often did—averting her eyes from the large and decorative cakes. Even the cookies looked soft and doughy, with frosting covering them—all of it cakelike, except the actual Italian desserts lining one wall. Even the cannoli were pretty.
Her stomach growled as she found her way into the restaurant, worried that she wouldn’t be able to recognize Ruben after all this time.
And then there he was, fool’s cap, bells, and goofy grin. The man she had fallen in love with when she was twenty-five years old.
He stood when he saw her, and his movements weren’t quite as fluid as they had been back in the day. He was just a little heavier. The weight didn’t gather in any one place. It had thickened him slightly, as if someone had taken his skin and put an extra layer of fabric under every part of it.
She didn’t look the same either. Her hair was short now with a silver layer like glitter thread. Usually she liked the effect, along with the lines that had formed around her mouth and eyes. They made her older, more serious, not the kind of woman that anyone would ever mistake for a girl.
Now, though, she felt self-conscious about it. She drew her coat tighter, and stepped into the restaurant, glad that this section opted for dark wood paneling and somewhat dim lighting, except for the little lamps on every table.
Ruben stood, jingling the bell, and grinning, then he peeled off the cap revealing a perfectly shaped, perfectly bald skull. Her breath caught. His hair had been tight and curly, but thin, even ten years ago, but she had never expected this.
Part of her—the older, more realistic part—loved it. The young woman who still had the world’s most handsome man in her mind was just a little appalled.
She smiled at him as she came closer. He stepped to the other side of the table and pulled her chair back, still the perfect gentleman, the one who used to annoy her and charm her at the same time.
I’m a cop, Ruben, she used to say. I can handle my own chairs.
She didn’t say that now. Instead, she nodded, and was about to slip into the chair when she felt his hands beside her.
“Coat?” he asked.
She would have given him crap about that too, back in the day. Now, she unbuttoned it, letting him ease it from her shoulders and down her arms. He hung it on the back of her chair, then went back to his side of the table.
She almost said, Nice to see nothing’s changed, but everything had.
“You look good,” she said.
“You look even more beautiful than I remember,” he said.
Her cheeks grew even warmer. She hoped he couldn’t see the flush in the dim light.
A waiter stopped beside them and handed out menus, explaining a few specials. Ruben listened attentively, but didn’t open his menu. Keisha opened hers as her stomach growled.
She hadn’t expected to be this hungry. She had actually envisioned ordering a cup of coffee and fleeing before everything became unbearable.
That was probably the more sensible plan, but she was tired of being sensible.
She ordered a Caprese salad and some calamari. He ordered linguini with clam sauce. She had forgotten that was one of his favorite meals.
“All right,” Ruben said after the waiter took the menus. “Let’s do the dance. Married?”
“No,” she said. “You?”
“Only the once,” he said. “Boyfriend?”
“No,” she said. “You?”
A smile touched his lips. “I don’t swing that way.”
“You know what I mean,” she said.
“Yeah.” His voice had softened. “And no, no girlfriend, not for a long time.”
“You still live in the condo,” she said.
He nodded.
“I moved out of the apartment,” she said. She had a condo of her own now, not as pretty as the one they had bought, but functional.
“Still on the job?” he asked.
“Yeah,” she said. “I work major crimes now, hand-in-glove with the prosecutor’s office.”
Because she had a master’s in criminal justice and an interest in the law. And a closure rate five times higher than anyone else in the department.
“You?” she asked.
He shook his head. “Went back, got another degree. I teach now.”
“What?” she asked. “Business education?”
“First-graders,” he said, and gazed at her for her reaction. Which, considering his growing smile, must have been to his satisfaction.
She hadn’t expected that. Nor had she expected the ease of the conversation, as if they had just seen each other that morning.
The very thought made her uncomfortable. The waiter brought her salad—if a large slab of mozzarella, beautiful sliced tomatoes and fresh basil could be considered a real salad.
She put it in the center of the table and indicated that Ruben should share it.
“You okay if we talk about Cosima now?” she asked.
His smile faded. “I would love to pretend that Cosima never existed. They ever figure out why that bastard ruined our wedding?”
“No,” she said, “but at least they have a connection now.”
And then she explained it. She had to tell him about Jolene, although nothing could quite convey that the grating annoyance everyone felt around her. Then Keisha told him about the inheritance and stopped him from asking questions about it. She still didn’t want to examine her entire motivation, not yet.
Finally, she got to that strange room, and all of the photographs.
She showed him the pictures she had taken on her cell phone, but they didn’t convey the creep factor quite the way she wanted them to.
Even so, he had gone gray.
“She stalked you,” he said.
“I don’t think that’s possible,” Keisha said. “She never left our hometown.”
“Not all of these look like they came from online,” he said. “Particularly the photos of us. I’ve never seen some of them.”
“Well, you are looking at a photo of photos,” Keisha said, trying to keep her tone light.
But he was having none of it. He shook his head. “These are candid shots, babe,” he said. “Someone was following us. Whether it was her or she paid them, I don’t know. But there’s no way—”
“She’s dead now, Ruben,” Keisha said. “It doesn’t really matter.”
He set Keisha’s phone down.
“It does matter,” he said. “That woman ruined our lives.”
That was the feeling Keisha had been trying to suppress. An anger at the woman who had tied them, somehow, to Maximo Severinus Cosima. And probably instigated something that led to his death at their wedding.
“That’s a little melodramatic, don’t you think?” Keisha asked, mostly because she didn’t like how she was feeling.
“No,” he said quietly. “Maybe she didn’t ruin your life. But that day, that beautiful horrible day, I’ve never recovered from it, Keesh. So maybe I was wrong. Maybe your life is just fine. But mine, mine will never be the same.”
Keisha nodded, not trusting her voice. Then she swallowed hard. “It’s in the past now, Ruben,” she said.
“Maybe for you,” he said. “Maybe for you.”
*They didn’t talk much more during the meal. She didn’t know how to respond to Ruben’s declaration. It was in the past, and it was tragic—not just a man’s death, but their reaction to it. They had been young, and they hadn’t handled a weird occurrence on their day well at all.
It had split them apart. There was no reason something like that should have ended their marriage, and yet it had.
Ruben finished his clam linguini before she finished her calamari. He pushed the plate aside. She expected him to make apologies, get up, and leave.
Instead, he folded his large hands together and leaned forward. “Did your detectives ever investigate the church?”
“They’re not my detectives,” she said and immediately wished she could take back. She sounded just like the surly girl who had appeared at the ruined reception. “I mean, I could never work with those detectives. I was involved in the case. They actually had to clear me.”
He nodded. “I remember, babe,” he said. “I’m sorry. I phrased that badly. Did anyone ever look into the church?”
“Why?” she asked.
He shrugged, but she knew that gesture. It was a pretend-casual gesture, when in reality he wasn’t being casual at all.
“I just thought about it occasionally over the years. It wasn’t our church. We didn’t know anyone involved until we chose it. Your mom didn’t know anyone either, right?”
Keisha’s mother had given them a list of churches. She had starred that one because it was one of the oldest in the city. It had been cleared repeatedly by her mother’s friends.
Keisha shook her head. “She didn’t know anyone.”
There was a lot of weight behind her words—and they both knew it. Her mother had been extremely superstitious. She had always believed Keisha was cursed, something Keisha loathed.
The wedding, her mother used to say, proved her point. Things like that only happened to cursed people. The divorce, her mother used to say, was no surprise—not because Keisha and Ruben didn’t love each other, but because cursed people could never be happy.
Keisha had stopped speaking to her mother after the wedding debacle. Her mother died a few years after that, and Keisha hadn’t even gone to the funeral.
And yet now, there was evidence that Keisha had had a stalker, and had had one her entire life. In her mother’s old-fashioned world—then Keisha shook her head. She might as well be honest about it. In her mother’s world, where witchcraft was real, the actions of a stalker could easily be seen as a curse.
“What?” Ruben asked. Apparently he could still read her expressions as well.
Keisha lightly tapped the side of her phone, careful not to turn it back on.
She said angrily, “It fucking looks like Mom was right.”
***Keisha had resolutely not believed in curses. Or magic. She had repeatedly told her mother that she only believed in human agents causing human mayhem.
Her mother always countered with the fact that witches were human, and they sometimes used the magic for human mayhem.
As she got older, Keisha would claim she had never seen a magical spell that would be provable in court.
Her mother claimed there was more than one kind of court.
And then there was the blow-up fight, not long after she split with Ruben.
You say I’m cursed, Mother, Keisha had shouted, because you don’t like me. You never have. You never saw my successes, only my failures. And those you blamed on an outside agency rather than helping me through them. I’m not cursed. Maybe you consider yourself cursed because you had me.
Keisha hadn’t waited for the answer to that. She hadn’t wanted to hear it.
And those words were the last she had ever spoken to her mother—at least face to face.
“The church,” Ruben said into the long silence, “was supposed to protect us, like holy water against vampires or something.”
Keisha nodded. “Mom said we screwed up by being outside. We should have stayed in the basement. The reception was in the open, a place where magic could sneak in, and did.”
“Magic,” he said softly. “Do you believe that?”
“I believe Mom believed it,” Keisha said. “And I had a stalker, clearly I did. Mom told me in the only way she knew how, and I couldn’t hear her.”
“So you didn’t answer my question,” Ruben said. “Did anyone investigate the church?”
“In what way?” Keisha asked.
“Cosima’s connection to it, for one thing,” Ruben said. “He’s kind of the lost detail here. I never really got a sense of him.”
Keisha frowned. “Neither did I.”
***Somehow they ended up in her condo. The excuse was that she had her department laptop there, and she had set up her Internet connection with several layers of encryption (with the help of the department techs) so she could sometimes work at home.
But, as they took a cab from the trattoria, she wondered if that had been some kind of excuse. Maybe they should have gone to the department, talking to the one cop still on the case, and given him the details of their suspicions.
While she set up her laptop on the kitchen table, Ruben walked around the condo’s living area. It was L-shaped, flowing from the small living room to the dining area (right next to the windows with a real city view) to the kitchen.
Fortunately, she had left it somewhat clean. She never used the living room, so there was space to sit on the soft couch, and very little clutter on the end tables. The dining room table was another matter. Stacked with everything from mail to books she meant to read, there was only one small area where she sat down to eat.
The gigantic TV, which pivoted so it could be viewed from the living room to the dining room to the kitchen spoke of a single woman who spent most of her time alone.
She hadn’t really realized how small the condo was until Ruben entered it. He looked like a giant in a hobbit village, moving cautiously around the tiny things. He would bump a shelf, then catch something that started to fall with his fingers, his movements elegant.
Maybe she had rented this place because she had known, subconsciously, that it was too small to contain him. Maybe it had been too small to handle her memories of him as well.
She didn’t like that thought, so she looked at the computer instead. She entered her badge number and logged into the system. The old case file was new enough to be computerized. It had photos of the body on the crushed cake, which made her stomach turn.
She looked at the access log and saw that no one had looked at the file since her call the day before. That didn’t mean anything: Most detective divisions still kept a paper murder book for each homicide, so the detectives could have looked at that. But the online file was better: It was actually searchable, even old ones like this, and most of the younger detectives preferred that.
If the remaining detective had assigned a new team to this, more likely it was that they would log on to read the murder book, rather than read the paper version.
She sighed and made a mental note to call the auctioneer. She would have him check on the house, to make sure the detectives actually showed up to the detect like they had promised.
They would complain that she looked at the file, especially since hers was the only access the file had had in ten years. She didn’t like that either: this case—this event— (God, she almost thought, had ruined her life. Did she believe that or had Ruben put that thought into her head?) had changed her life, and no one considered it worth their time to investigate? That broke her heart.
She glanced up at Ruben. He looked at her at the same time, as if there was some kind of rule that their gazes had to meet. Her heart leapt as she looked at him, and she wanted to slap it down. Traitor. She shouldn’t feel like a giddy young girl just being around him again. She wasn’t a giddy young girl. Besides, they didn’t know each other at all any more. They had grown apart, if they had ever been together.
Still, she gave him an awkward little smile, and went back to digging.
The detectives had done a cursory job on Cosima. He had been a neighborhood regular. He was considered crazy, the kind of man who walked around, shouting his own name and banging himself on the chest as he did so, as if reaffirming his own identity.
They assumed he was homeless at the time of his death (because he usually was homeless) and that he had been drawn to the wedding reception because of the food. The butcher knife belonged to the caterer, so the detectives assumed that someone had seen him too close to the food, gotten in an altercation with him, and stabbed him, probably because they felt threatened.
All of the catering staff and the cake artist herself had been examined closely by the detectives and the forensic team, even checked with ultraviolet light to see if they had washed off any recent blood. Some of them had old blood on their clothing, particularly the head caterer, because she worked with knives a lot.
But nothing had tied them, or anyone else at the wedding, to Cosima.
“They never checked,” she muttered.
“What?” Ruben had been staring at the books on her living room shelves, clasped behind his back so that he didn’t knock anything loose.
“The detectives. They didn’t really delve into Cosima’s life, and they never examined whether or not he had a connection to the church.” She scrolled through the files. “And they didn’t interview the good Reverend Fisher either.”
Ruben shuddered visibly. “I didn’t like that man.”
“So you said at the time.” She kept her gaze on the laptop. Ruben’s strong dislike of Reverend Fisher had been one of the few points of contention before the wedding.
Shouldn’t we be married by someone we like? he asked more than once.
When did liking an official become a prerequisite for marriage? Keisha had said in response.
“Is he still at the church?” Ruben asked.
“I don’t know,” she said. She opened a new window on her browser and Googled the church name. It showed up as an active listing in three other communities, but not this one. So she refined the search to this city only and tried again.
She got several hits, all of them from the media, some of them concerning the death at her wedding. One of the listings at the bottom of the first page was from website about abandoned, forgotten, and decommissioned church buildings.
She swore softly.
“What?” Ruben asked again. This time, he pushed his way over to her spot at the table, and managed to squeeze himself in the small space behind her.
She clicked on that website. It was garish, with scary jagged font, and as she read the first page, explaining that she was about to go where no human should go, the words started dripping fake blood.
“Nice,” Ruben said sarcastically. “Why are we on this site?”
She didn’t answer him. Instead, she typed the name of the church in the website search function. The site gave her a sub link, which she clicked on, and she found herself staring at a photograph of the church.
Its stained glass windows were boarded up and there was a lock on the door. Even though the photograph had been taken on a bright sunny day, the church itself had been in shadow.
“That photograph is twenty years old,” Ruben said.
Keisha leaned toward the image. He was right. The church looked ready for teardown ten years before they used it.
She clicked through the write-up about the church.
Decommissioned in 1880, the church has been the focus of several strange incidents in the past two centuries. Most of the incidents are the standard moving lights in a boarded-up building, although some witnesses have claimed to see the church at its height, a congregation inside, worshipping and singing hymns.
Some of the incidents come from the church’s reputation, including rituals gone awry. And some come from the fact that the authorities can’t keep the homeless out of the church, particularly on cold winter nights.
The church has been slated for demolition dozens of times since its decommissioning, but something has always prevented the teardown. Several owners have bought and sold the place over the years, the most recent a paranormal activities company (see sidebar) that hired the church for ceremonies.
The company came under scrutiny after a man died at a pagan wedding—
“Look at the date.” Ruben’s fingertip touched the very part of the window Keisha had just been reading. “That’s our wedding. It wasn’t a pagan ceremony.”
She let out a small breath and slid the chair back. “Well,” she said. “It kind of was.”
“Oh, no,” he said. “Your mother.”
Keisha put her hand on the lid of the laptop, closed it without logging off, and kicked the chair opposite her out, to indicate that Ruben should sit down.
He did, his jaw clenched.
“My mother wanted us in a church to protect us from evil spirits,” Keisha said. “I told her I wasn’t religious—”
“I remember,” Ruben said.
“—and she said not to worry, she would handle it. That’s when she gave us—”
“The list,” Ruben said. “And we drove by. But the church we saw looked nothing like the photographs online here.”
Keisha nodded, not liking the floaty feeling in her head. She’d had a similar feeling in Jolene’s house, looking at the strange room.
“And it was nice inside,” Ruben said, but his voice rose slightly.
“It was,” Keisha said, “but remember how everyone said they were surprised by the interior?”
“Yeah.” He barely moved his lips as he said that word. He was coming to the same conclusion she was.
Or was he? He hadn’t grown up with a mother who claimed she was a witch.
“Maybe we didn’t see the exterior as it was,” Keisha said. “Maybe…”
“That’s not possible,” Ruben said forcefully. Then he took a deep breath. “Is it?”
Keisha squared her shoulders and opened the laptop.
“Time to find out,” she said.
***Most of the police photographs of the crime scene were of the cake and the catering area. As Keisha looked at them, she remembered the caterers complaining about the primitive kitchen, the horrid facility, the lack of cleanliness. That was why they insisted on having the food outside if possible. That way, they could use their own equipment, the equipment they brought to outside weddings away from any regular kitchen.
Keisha had thought nothing of it, just as she had thought nothing of the cake artist’s comment that she couldn’t handle the gloom. Keisha thought anyone who called herself a “cake artist” was by definition a flake, even if she created the best cakes Keisha had ever tasted.
Only one of the crime scene photos was an exterior shot and it was of the back. The windows that Keisha remembered as plain, leading into the kitchen, were boarded up.
She frowned.
“Do you remember this?” she asked, tapping that photo.
He shook his head. “Those windows were open. Because of the heat in the kitchen. Remember?”
She nodded.
Then she opened another new browser window and did something she had never done before: she Googled the media coverage from her wedding day.
Article after article appeared. She clicked on the first listing, saw the photograph, and put her hand over her eyes. The church looked just like the church on the website, windows boarded up, door hung crookedly.
And sure enough, the headline was excruciating.
Man Dies at Pagan Wedding
No wonder the police weren’t investigating this the way they would investigate a random death at a wedding. They were looking at it as if a ritual had gone wrong.
And when they found nothing, they were ready to move onto something else.
Ruben’s hand covered hers. His skin was warm, dry, and slightly callused.
When she didn’t move, he scooted his chair across the wooden floor, and put his arms around her. She rested her head on his shoulder. She had missed that. She had missed being held. She had missed being held by him.
“My mother was right,” Keisha said into his shirt. “Our wedding was cursed.”
“By her, maybe,” Ruben said.
Keisha shook her head slightly. Finally something made sense. Her mother hated organized religion. The fact that she had insisted on a church wedding had made no sense to Keisha.
But a wedding in a decommissioned church would allow some of the religious protections mixed with pagan ones. Pagan and Christian rituals often intermingled. Keisha’s mother had explained that a thousand times.
She must have thought that the intermingling would guarantee strength—and maybe it had.
For Jolene.
“Keesh, look.” Ruben stroked her hair, then moved slightly. She raised her head, and looked at the screen.
He touched part of the article.
…murder of Gerald Rossi, a homeless man who went by the name Maximo Severinus Cosima. Despite neighborhood attempts to roust him, Rossi saw the church as his home and would fight with anyone who came inside. No one reported seeing him at the wedding ceremony, however, although neighbors wondered how everyone managed to avoid him…
There it was in black and white. Cosima’s connection to the church. The wedding party had invaded his home.
“Someone didn’t want us to get married,” Ruben said. “Your mother?”
Keisha shook her head. “If Mom didn’t want us to be married, she could have stopped it a lot of other ways. This wasn’t about us failing to get married. This was about ruining the marriage.”
Ruining her life. And his.
She leaned against him, and he put his arm around her.
All of her life, she had denied the existence of magic. She had believed in reality, a dry, harsh reality with no magic at all.
But if she had been honest with herself, the first time she ever saw magic had been when she met Ruben. Not because he had any. But because of the way they felt together.
He reached around her and clicked the back button on the computer. It took them to Google again, and he clicked on another article. There the Reverend Fisher’s picture showed up, not as a reverend at all, but as the man who owned the church.
Head of the Society of Paranormal Properties, Reginald Fisher, said he had no idea that the wedding—which he officiated—would end so badly…
Keisha let out a small sigh. “It was all here. I just hadn’t wanted to look. I cut off my mother because she said I was cursed—”
“From birth,” Ruben said. “She was a nasty woman, Keesh. I never wanted to tell you that, but she was. That’s why I thought she had cursed us.”
Keisha shook her head again. “Jolene did. You never knew her. But her mother was part of a coven my mother refused to acknowledge. My mother said they used their magic for the wrong things.”
“Your mother used hers to make sure we thought we were in a real church,” Ruben said.
Keisha looked up at the side of his face. He was still staring at the screen, clicking through.
“I didn’t think you believed in magic,” she said.
“Your mother talked to me about it,” he said. “She showed me a few things. After a while, I believed her. I tried to tell you, but you wouldn’t listen.”
“I didn’t want her infecting you,” Keisha said.
“She didn’t,” Ruben said. “I’m glad she told me. I understand this now. You don’t have to convince me.”
“But I have to convince me,” Keisha said. “We have to look at everything, detail by detail.”
And so they did.
***She took the first leave of absence from her job that she had ever taken. She claimed bereavement leave, because of inheriting Jolene’s estate. The chief questioned her, asking if she had cared for Jolene.
“No,” Keisha said. “I just have to process what she was doing, and why she left everything to me.”
Even though that was a lie. She knew why Jolene had left her everything. It was the ultimate fuck-you. Keisha hadn’t figured out that Jolene and her mother had wormed their way into the Society of Paranormal Properties. Keisha hadn’t seen any of the dark magic spells that Jolene had done, the curses large and small, starting from the moment they were in kindergarten together.
Jolene’s mother had picked Keisha for Jolene to practice her spells on, and Jolene had done so with a vengeance. Which explained some of the whining. Keisha often succeeded despite the curses. She liked to think she had done that on her own, but her mother might have had some involvement.
Or maybe not.
It was too late to know what changes in Keisha’s life were because of curses or because of counter spells. She wasn’t sure she wanted to know.
She mentioned that to Ruben one afternoon as they finished going through yet another pile of documents found in Jolene’s home. Spell after spell, curses from a variety of magical cultures, some of them in the form of dolls and some of them in the form of spices.
“I hate thinking that we could have stayed together if I had just listened to my mother about being cursed,” Keisha had said.
They were sitting at her dining room table again. They did their research in her condo, but they had started spending their nights in his.
Ruben put his hand on the papers. “Your mom said the same thing to me, Keesh. And I thought about it a lot over the years. And I think the curse is just one small part of what happened at that wedding.”
She put her hand on top of his, then threaded her fingers through his.
“I think,” he said, “the curses only go so far.”
“What do you mean?” she asked.
“Aren’t you afraid of starting this relationship again?” he asked. It was the first time either of them had mentioned the fact that they had slipped into old patterns. Blissfully slipped into them. And they were as good now as they had been in the beginning, before the wedding.
“No,” she said.
“You’re not afraid the curse will start up again?” he asked.
“She’s dead,” Keisha said.
“Curses don’t always die with the person who cast the spell,” he said.
Keisha shrugged one shoulder.
“Then we don’t have to try to marry again,” she said, startling herself. She was amazed that part of her had been thinking about trying again.
“We can just live together?” he asked, with a half-smile.
“It worked before,” she said.
“And that’s my point,” he said. “Jolene had been watching us, even then. We’d had some hard times. Other relationships of yours had ended in the hard times, but ours hadn’t.”
“Until the wedding,” Keisha said.
“Until the wedding,” he agreed. “And what happened afterwards.”
“The curse,” she said.
He shook his head. “I don’t think so.”
She looked at him. His dark eyes were so sincere. “What do you mean?”
“Those harsh words? Those were us,” he said. “We were stupid. We broke up for the dumbest of reasons.”
Her cheeks warmed. “Ruben—”
“Think about it, Keesh. You’ve been cursed your whole life. Yet you managed to graduate from high school with straight As. You got into the college of your choice, got into the MBA program, became one of the fastest rising detectives in the police department. You designed your own job, for heaven’s sake, despite setbacks. You did that. The curses were just another bump in the road.”
She swallowed hard. “Everyone has bumps.”
“Yes,” he said. “And they defeat most people. You told me that Jolene whined every time she had a setback.”
“Maybe her curses weren’t that powerful,” Keisha said.
“Maybe not,” Ruben said. “Or maybe you did have some protections.”
“Thanks to my mother?” Keisha asked.
He shrugged. “Or maybe your own innate strength,” he said.
She played with his fingers for a moment, looking at the documents beneath them. They were digging into an old incident, one that had torn them apart. One they had let tear them apart.
“Does this mean you want to try again?” she asked quietly. She had mentioned it a moment ago, but he hadn’t responded directly.
“Yes,” he said.
“I don’t know how many curses she put on me,” Keisha said. “I don’t know what might go wrong.”
“None of us ever do,” he said.
He wasn’t understanding her.
“I can’t promise a happily ever after,” she said.
“I don’t expect one,” he said.
She frowned at him.
“No one is happy forever, Keesh,” he said. “That’s why the vows say for better or for worse.”
“I thought you don’t want vows,” she said.
“I didn’t say that,” he said. “I’m not sure we’re ready for them, though.”
“The relationship—”
“Not the relationship,” he said. “The fact of a ceremony. Maybe we should just jump a broom or something.”
She giggled. “That’s still a ceremony,” she said.
“Well, then,” he said. “We’ll do it without a ceremony. If you’re willing.”
“I am,” she said, and kissed him. “Oh, believe me. I am.”
After the WeddingCopyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn RuschPublished by WMG PublishingFirst published in the Uncollected Anthology Happily Ever Afters, February 2016Cover and layout copyright © 2023 by WMG PublishingCover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG PublishingCover art copyright © kloromanam | Depositphotos
I taught a workshop, and spent a lot of January reading stories in manuscript. (I still have a lot to go because of a stupidly busy February.) I ended up reading a novel that was awful. The writing was good; the situation implausible; the characters all dumber than rocks. But I couldn’t figure out how this traditionally published author got to his ending. So I kept going…and found out that the book had no ending. No climax, no validation, just characters doing something they should have done in Chapter 3. If I had a fireplace, this novel would have gone in it. Unfortunately, because I was reading so many (good) manuscripts, I didn’t realize that stupid novel had sucked the air out of my leisure reading for half of the month.
Fortunately for me, I picked up the novel listed below, and even though I had other things I needed to read (plus some truly dense Spanish by that point), I found as many hours as I could to enjoy it. I also read a few magazines and two nonfiction books, even though I only list one. I looked at the marked articles and found that they no longer inspire me, except for two from Vanity Fair. So not the best leisure reading start to the year, but a good start nonetheless. I think you’ll enjoy what I listed here.
January, 2023Clark, P. Djèlí, A Master of Djinn, Tor, 2021. First, a complaint. I’m not finding the next book in this series for sale anywhere. I don’t know if that’s because of the way that Tor mishandles series books (they rarely publish all the books they’ve contracted for) or if it’s because Clark hasn’t finished the next book or, if he has, then maybe it’s inp process…? Anyway, it would be nice to know, because I’m ready for the next book right now.
As you can probably tell from my complaint, A Master of Djinn is a wonderful book. I’d read the novella published in this world, and that’s probably what got me to buy the novel. The world is steampunk and magic, Victorian (well, Edwardian) era…Egypt. Because magic has been unleashed into the world, Egypt has become the major power, not Great Britain. (Although there’s influences…) The characters are spectacular, the worldbuilding is breathtaking, the story is compelling, and it all feels original, because Clark uses the setting so very well.
One of my favorite books in a very, very long time. I want more. If only I can figure out how to get more…
French, Christine Madrid, “The Angle of Suspense,” Vanity Fair, October 2022. I read this article while I was prepping for an in-person writing class in which I knew the writers would have trouble with setting. I hoped this piece would help them. I have no idea if it did or not. It focuses on the way that Hitchcock changed the language of villainy using architecture. Fascinating stuff.
Norman, Tony, “Kindred Spirits,” Vanity Fair, October 2022. When you click on the link, you’ll see that the web version of this piece has a different name. I have no idea why Vanity Fair does this, but it does. The piece is about August Wilson’s The Piano Lesson. Samuel L. Jackson originated the role that John David Washington now plays. Both men are in the show (directed by LaTanya Richardson Jackson, who now becomes the first black woman to direct a play on Broadway). Of course, this piece focuses on the men, not on her, because…you know. Sigh. Anyway, this is a great article about being an artist for decades. Read it.
Richardson, Heather Cox, How The South Won The Civil War, Oxford University Press, 2020. This is probably the most important book I’ve read in a decade. Americans, you need to read this. I know American history. I majored in it, write about it, read it for fun. Heather Cox Richardson puts pieces together that I hadn’t considered at all. Or maybe that I didn’t know.
When Trump first lumbered onto the national political scene in 2015, my friends would tell me that he couldn’t win, and I would say, Given the history of our country, he has an extremely good chance of winning. He’s tapping into the things we pretend don’t exist. I hate that I was right. (I also told anyone who would listen, including friends running the Democratic party at the time, that Hillary should not be the candidate. She was badly damaged after two decades of being the subject of far right hatred. I hate being right about that too.)
This book isn’t about Hillary. It’s about the parts of America we as a nation have never dealt with. The reckoning might start with surviving the Trump era, but I’m not so sure. The stuff Cox Richardson writes about is baked into our national DNA. When we as a country failed to punish the Confederates, and let them set up the Lost Cause Myth, we continued the problems set up by our slave-owning founders. Barack Obama’s presidency did not make this a colorblind nation (sorry, Mr. Chief Justice. That’s not how it works).
Please read this book. I waited almost 3 years to read it, until my heart had healed enough to handle it. Then I devoured it and gave it to friends. (I’m still giving it to friends.) If you want to understand the past ten years (Hell, the past 250+), read this.
I have a lot of big plans for 2023. I have to revamp the business side of my writing career. That requires a lot of work from me.
I’m making this blog a process blog because it’s taking me longer than I want to get the pieces in place. But, I’m finding, that’s the way of things for me. I can imagine it, so of course, I figure I can finish it quickly.
It seems like nothing in my life is quick right now—at least that kind of quick. When I look at what I actually do, such as the latest novel I finished (Diving, not a Boss book), I realize I wrote 150,000 words in three months (about 30,000 of which I have set aside, because they don’t fit into the book. That’s 50,000 words per month or roughly 12,500 words per week during the holidays, while I was sick, while I was in school, and while I wrote this weekly blog, a month other things.
In other words, by most measures, 150,000 words in three months is fast. But it’s not as fast as I wanted it to be.
I am writing this on Monday afternoon at UNLV, just before my Spanish class (the homework for which took me 6 hours this weekend, about double what I had planned). I had spent my “free” time this weekend figuring out one new aspect of my social media and the rest looking at new themes for this website.
Why? Because my first order of business is to revamp my advertising.
Now, before I go too far here, let me clear up something. I do own a publishing company. WMG Publishing publishes all of my work. (Eventually, anyway. I do publish some things in anthologies and other venues, sometimes first.) The team there does a huge amount of advertising, usually on a budget, and always effectively. They’re refocusing their efforts because we have a new Shopify store. They’re slowly getting our 1,000 titles on the site.
Once they have a preponderance of the titles up, WMG will be taking advantage of the various tools Shopify offers to promote things.
They also do things like Book Bub ads, Facebook ads, and other in-house projects, such as their newsletter, “Every Day is A Holiday,” which offers great weekly promotions. To be frank, I’m not sure of everything they do, because they do so much.
But they need me to promote as well, and I’ve gotten lazy about it. I mean, really lazy. My newsletters are not regular. I forget to promote a new book or a new project. I haven’t changed the widgets on this site in a long time.
Some of my laziness is a habit. I was great at promotion until I wasn’t. That started in 2016 or so, as I got sicker and sicker up in Lincoln City. My ability to do anything became less and less, and so I gave up a lot of things.
What I couldn’t give up, I did by rote. That included most of my Twitter feed, and what I post here. I would try to get a newsletter out, but that only happened when I had the time to give up a writing session or two.
I had a whole bunch of things that I needed to do “real soon now.” I mentioned some of them in my year in review articles. They’re everything from investigating A.I. Audio in depth to fixing my Patreon page design to figuring out some of the new tech that will save me time once I learn it.
All of those fit into the Real Soon Now category. Add in the Vegas move, and a chance to get healthy and live a life, the pandemic, the lockdowns, the massive societal changes…and Real Soon Now kept getting moved back.
A number of things changed for me. They include a change in my writing schedule and the ability to focus again on something other than the outside world; last year’s in-depth analysis of the changes in publishing (all publishing); and the loss of Twitter. In fact, losing Twitter was the last straw, because I had to think about marketing differently than I had.
Then, on top of everything else, advertising broke. Or rather, as I said in the year in review blog about this, it felt like it broke. Because of changes in laws, changes in social media, changes in our cultural perspective, advertising didn’t work the way it used to.
And here I was, advertising—marketing—using hacks I had set up as I got sicker and sicker six years before.
I wasn’t the only one doing things by rote. Most marketers were and are. I read The Hollywood Reporter somewhat religiously, and several other media trade journals less religiously, but every single one of them had spent 2022 trying to figure out how to make advertising work in a changing world.
None of us knew or know what the next best thing is. I’m beginning to believe that it’s what I’ve always preached—building your own community, somewhat slowly. Not that our culture does anything slow anymore.
In fact, the idea that I’m doing the same thing I did six years ago makes me feel like I’ve been doing the same thing since…oh…1950 or something. Really, what I have been doing is that out of date.
To use one of terms I used in my year-end blog, my marketing had become stale. And as I wrote at the time,
Staleness in marketing is the best way to make sure no one hears the message. Yeah, yeah, you always say that is the subconscious thought. Then your product gets dismissed and the consumer moves on.
So…I’ve got a rebuild list, and then I have a “figure out new” list. I’ve started in the rebuild list.
This past weekend, I finally joined my own Twitter alternative. Spoutible started this year. It’s very similar to Twitter. I’m on there as @KristineRusch (at spoutible.com). At the time of this writing, I have 19 followers, down a little from the thousands I had on Twitter.
I have a couple of other social media sites, and one somewhat dormant account that I’ll bring up a bit. I do a lot on Facebook, but most of that uses my cats in a fictional advertising agency called Promotion Central. People like watching the cats battle their way to some semblance of an ad campaign, so I’ll keep doing that.
But it’s not new or different, and it doesn’t really address the promotion problems I’m having. I doubt Spoutible will either, or the other social media platforms.
Which brings me to the website. I’m currently looking at themes and working with WMG on choosing one that will be (much) easier to read than my current site. I’m also looking for a design that will allow me to do all kinds of promotion easily.
So it’s taking time. I’m using a friend’s method: I’m only putting in a half an hour per day on it on non-school days. If that’s research, so be it. Or shopping for themes, so be it. But that will give me a lot of time that I haven’t been spending in years past on setting up proper promotion—and repairing everything that has fallen apart or gotten old and stale.
Maybe by then, I’ll have some other ways to market my books (and other products) to readers. One criteria I have is that the promotion must be something I enjoy.
I find writing the little reports from Promotion Central to be a great deal of fun. I’m always snapping photos of the cats now, with an eye to “how can I use this”?
I want the design of the website to be quick and intuitive as well as visually interesting, so that will probably take longer than I planned.
And I need to explore some other options, which I will report on as soon as I get the chance.
I had hoped that this little post would have more meat to it, telling you all to do this or do that. But right now, I’m feeling around in the dark. I suspect you are as well.
I’ll do some updates, but you’ll also see changes here, especially as the weeks go on. I’ll also be posting about my research, particularly if I find anything interesting.
Feel free to add thoughts in the comments, since we’re all fishing around in the dark right now.
Since a month or so ago, I promised I would do some blog-related promotion at the end of each blog, I’m going to add a book here. I wrote Writing With Chronic Illness when I was in Lincoln City. The book includes tips for working through such things as brain fog, learning how to be kind to yourself when you can’t do anything, and much more.
And here’s the weekly reminder:
This blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynrusch to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: I,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image or Promotion Central the top of the blog copyright © 2023 by Kristine K. Rusch.
So many mysteries in the past. So many opportunities, as well. While Portals, Inc. uses historians to test its time travel devices, historians use Portals to test their theories.
Neyla believes the 17th century discovery of the dead Princes near the Bloody Tower will tell her who murdered the boys centuries before.
Thomas Ayliffe believes he can pull off the crime of the century—any century.
All three agendas collide in a story about crimes and criminals, past, present, and future.
“The Tower,” by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook through various online retailers here and is included in the collection Colliding Worlds, Vol. 3, which is available in ebook, trade paperback, and hardcover here.
The TowerKristine Kathryn RuschHe had gotten a message.
Sent by old-fashioned tradecraft dating from the days of the Secret Intelligence Service, long before the advent of MI6. A simple flowerpot on a balcony in Kensington, a tiny red flag next to the ugliest flower Thomas had ever seen.
The flower didn’t matter. The flag did.
It meant: Be at the designated spot, midnight. Be prepared.
So Thomas stood on London Bridge, his back to the traffic, his arms resting on the railing. To his left, the lights of Southwark Cathedral. To his right, the Monument designed by Sir Christopher Wren to remind everyone of the Great Fire of London in 1666.
Thomas pretended to contemplate the lights of London reflected on the water. A bit of a wind brushed his cheeks, bringing the slightly bitter scent of the Thames.
Behind him, cars hummed as they glided by. Someone would notice him sooner or later. A man standing on London Bridge at midnight, his arms resting on the edge, looking down at the water, spoke of melancholy at the very least, a potential suicide at the very worst.
His hair ruffled as the breeze grew stronger.
Then he felt someone at his shoulder and he braced himself so that he couldn’t be tossed over. His heart was pounding.
Paranoia, that’s all it was. He was here to do a job, not to be killed.
Still, he stepped slightly to his left, just enough to take him out of harm’s way.
“Lovely night.” The voice was husky, unfamiliar—and surprisingly—female.
Thomas looked at her out of the corner of his eye. She was slight, hair cropped short, rounded cheeks reddened from the chill breeze. Maybe thirty, maybe younger.
“I’ve seen better.” He spoke the coded response, half expecting her to go off script. After all, it was a lovely night, and strangers occasionally said such things to each other, even at midnight on London Bridge.
“I saw better on New Year’s,” she said. “The way the fireworks seemed to float through the Eye.”
She was his contact then. Somehow he had always imagined the insider was a man. Middle-aged, disgruntled. Willing to be bought off. Thomas had been watching all of them—those that he could, anyway—wondering who would meet him when the time came.
Odd that he missed a woman. Maybe that’s why he had. She seemed shadowy, inconspicuous, perfect for this kind of corporate espionage.
“These days,” he said, “fireworks remind me of Guy Fawkes Day when I was a boy.”
“Shame they can’t blow up Parliament today.” She turned toward him and grinned.
He didn’t grin back, but he did check, out of the corner of his eye, to see if anyone approached. Aside from the cars humming behind them, the Bridge was empty.
“So?” he asked. “You have a date certain?”
“Two, actually,” she said. “The first is Wednesday at five p.m. West Wall, White Tower. The second is July, 1674.”
“1674?” he asked. “I don’t want that year.”
“It’s your only hope,” she said. “They don’t like doing remotes. You’re lucky. The researcher is highly regarded, but female. She doesn’t dare walk across the Thames. She has to be on location.”
He shook his head. “I want 1650, early September 1666, or 9 May 1671. 1674 is too late.”
“You’ve also made your impatience known,” she said. “If you want to finish your job in the next year, you’ll take 1674. It’s the only remote planned.”
“They’re not doing other remotes?” He certainly wouldn’t hear of them. He did work at Portals, just like this woman did, but he had never been assigned to the technical areas. The managers had actually given tests to all applicants, and he had failed the mathematical portions. But he had aced the history sections. So he’d spent the past two years in research, finding out tiny things for major historians, and growing more and more impatient.
“They’re afraid of remotes. They’ve only done one, and it was controlled. This is the first uncontrolled remote, and some think it too dangerous.”
“Uncontrolled?” he asked.
“Into a site where they don’t know each and every detail. They don’t even have the government’s permission.” She was staring at the Thames.
He did too, watching the lights ripple on the inky black water. He could get caught on this end, then, not by Portales, but by the British government. But there were no laws against time travel. Not yet.
“You have to be careful,” she said as if reading his thoughts. “This is the first such major experiment. Try not to cock it up.”
Cock it up. As if he were part of the corporate team. He didn’t care if they never had another remote, so long as he got his treasure.
But he wasn’t sure how he would go about it, even with this remote. “What happened in July of 1674?”
The woman didn’t answer. Instead, she stared at the Thames for a moment. Then she said, “You’re the fake historian. You figure it out. And, by the way, your portal is Neyla Kendrick. Good luck.”
His portal. A pun. He hated puns, and was about to tell her when he realized she was walking away from him. The breeze carried her vanilla perfume long after her footsteps faded.
He had been told his contact would arrange the right time period, and make sure he could do his job with a minimum of fuss. Everything would be timed to the second.
He needed it timed. He needed it just so.
He could call it off, he supposed. His client would hire someone else, someone with less caution, someone with a few more balls.
Not that he lacked balls. He’d carried out some of the greatest thefts in living memory.
But this one would be the pinnacle of his career—not just in money, but in audacity.
The Crown Jewels.
Not all of them of course. The most famous ones as well as the ones still in use had to remain. But the minor ones, the ones he’d researched, the ones no one had done much more than stare at under glass for hundreds of years, he could take any one of those, and would.
If he decided to do this.
1674—July.
He thought he’d covered all the possible opportunities to steal the jewels in the 17th century.
What had he missed?
“That’s too tight,” she said to McTavish, who was trying to dress her.
The Closet was cold. Rows of clothing, all on racks, all from different time periods, ran off into the distance.
She felt like she was in one of the old warehouses that used to line this part of Southwark after the Second World War. She had to remind herself that beyond the double doors was a modern well-lit hallway.
McTavish tugged at the tape one more time.
“That hurts,” she said.
He let go and the tape unraveled. She took a deep breath for the first time since he had wrapped the stuff around her. She looked down. Red welts covered the fleshy part of her upper breasts.
“Just get the reduction,” McTavish said. “You can have them inflated when you get back.”
As if her breasts were balloons. She glared at him.
McTavish had been a dresser, a costumer, and finally a designer for the London Stage. Portals, Inc. had hired him away with an obscene salary, mostly for his knowledge of historical fashion. Not just because he knew how to make someone look like they were from, say, the Middle Ages, but because he could actually pinpoint a year. He could find or make materials that fit so accurately, no native of the time period would think anything was wrong.
McTavish wasn’t that careful with his own clothing. He wore the standard long frock coat—this season’s current design for the fashionable man—but his was velvet, and too hot. He always smelled faintly of sweat.
“I’m not going to get my breasts reduced,” Neyla said. “I’m leaving Wednesday morning.”
“It’s cosmetic,” he said. “It’ll be done in less than an hour. You’ll have no pain at all. And when you get back—”
“They have to put some substance inside my breasts. It won’t be me any more. I like having the original equipment.”
He raised his eyebrows at her. “You also want to do your research, right? With those honkers, no one’s going to mistake you for a boy, not unless I wrap all of your torso.”
“I won’t be bathing,” she said, still shuddering at the very idea. She was going back to the land of unwashed flesh, fleas, and bedbugs. That was what she feared the most. The bugs, the dirt, the way she would have to live it all.
“It’ll be July,” McTavish said. “Hottest month of the year in any century. You’ll already be wearing more clothing than you’re accustomed to. The last thing I want is for you to get heatstroke. Another reason not to bind these puppies. Get them reduced.”
“No,” she said. “You’re going to flatten them and you’re going to make it look natural.”
Then she grabbed her pink cotton shirt and pulled it on, leaving her bra on the nearby rack as if she had forgotten it. She wasn’t going to wear anything over “those puppies.” She was going back to work.
“It’s not going to look natural,” he said.
“Neither are my teeth,” she said, “but I’m not having those pulled for verisimilitude either.”
Then she stalked out of the Closet.
She was getting angry at McTavish and that wasn’t right. He was just a perfectionist, trying to make her the best 17th century male she could possibly be. He was trying to protect her.
She appreciated the attempt at protection. But she wasn’t going to give up her breasts. She had given up enough for her work. Just moving to London was enough of a sacrifice.
She was a San Francisco girl, born and raised. She loved the cool air, the fog, the modern buildings and the lack of history. She had gotten all of her degrees at UC-Berkeley, as well as two post-docs, one assistant professorship, followed by a full professorship with summers off and tons of university support to go all over the world to investigate old bones.
She had been about to accept a tenured position when Portals, Inc. contacted her, asking her to submit a proposal for their top-secret project.
Time travel. Controlled, examined. Portals wanted to investigate all kinds of historical avenues before taking its product public. It was a giant form of beta testing. If something went wrong for the historians investigating old myths, virologists investigating ancient diseases, and biologists trying to get DNA from long-vanished species, then Portals would do more testing on its travel system.
Neyla’s proposal was simple: It was a redraft of her undergraduate honors thesis, which she had written in conjunction with the History, English, and Anthropology departments. Her thesis was an analysis of the importance of the Princes in the Tower, as told by their bones. Not that she had seen their bones, of course. No one alive had. The bones had been examined only once, in 1933. What then passed for modern science concluded that the bones belonged to two young boys who were the right age to be the princes, and therefore probably were.
That conclusion was enough for the British government. Since then, they hadn’t allowed anyone to examine the bones.
She hadn’t expected Portals to care about the ancient mystery of the Princes in the Tower, but apparently they had received so many requests from historians and amateur crime buffs, all of whom wanted to solve the mystery themselves (and wanted to spend a year in 1483 and 1484 doing so), that the Portals CEO, Damien Wilder, figured this could be the signature project.
He had been looking for someone who knew how to solve the mystery of the Princes’ deaths in a short visit to the past. Neyla’s proposal was the shortest—a return to July of 1674, when the skeletons were discovered on the south side of the White Tower. Unfortunately, no one had a date certain, so anyone hoping to find the bodies might have to spend the entire month in 1674—which was a prospect she was now facing.
She stepped inside her office, her heart pounding. She was still angry over McTavish’s comment. Not because he had any power to make her go through even minor physical changes for this project, but because he had tapped into her fears about this trip.
So many risks. She had to somehow pose as one of the workers or someone who belonged at the Tower during July of 1674. She and her team would be traveling with only the minimum of supplies, a second set of clothing, and the miniaturized scientific equipment.
She slipped behind her desk. Beyond the large glass windows, London sprawled. The skyscape looked nothing like the skyscape in 1674. Then the Tower housed some of the largest buildings in the city. Now century-old buildings dwarfed it. Even the creaky London Eye made the Tower look like a hunk of the past stuck in the middle of the present.
She pulled out the box holding the equipment she would take with her. The box was long and thin as if it contained a necklace from Tiffany’s. Inside were small items designed to look like things from 1674, a quill pen, a pin, a ring. They all housed something important from her computer (complete with camera and voice recorder) to the many backups she needed.
Everything was solar powered, which helped. Her traveling companions would have redundant equipment, so if someone lost theirs, they wouldn’t lose the information.
The entire trip could be summed up in this small box. If she didn’t get the right information at the right time in the right way, the trip and all its dangers would be for nothing.
She couldn’t quite get over her own audacity.
To travel into one of the world’s most heavily guarded places, to a place still more famous for its prisoners and executions than for its grandeur and its coronations, took a degree of chutzpah she would never have guessed that she had.
Finally she stood and walked to the window. The Thames glittered in the sunlight. Cars flowed over the bridges and through the city, like blood through veins. She was too high to see people walking. From this vantage, though, she could see the entire Tower complex from Traitor’s Gate up front to the Jewel House toward the back and the White Tower in the very middle.
Dark and old, foreboding and entrancing, the Tower at this moment was filled with tourists and schoolchildren, people who had paid to “experience” the past.
In two days, she would join them, pretending to be that peculiar kind of tourist who dressed up in period dress to enjoy an historical monument.
In two days, she would stand by the White Tower, and become someone else.
Thomas wanted to get in and get out, quick and dirty. He’d been willing to spend a few days in September of 1666, the Great Fire, just to get the right opportunity. But even his vaguer instructions for the Cromwellian era took into account the fact that the Jewels weren’t very important in the Interregnum. Most got sold or lost or stolen.
Thomas had just planned to do a bit of the stealing, in a very short period of time.
Now he had to spend a month with a woman interested in the bones of children. He wasn’t even sure what the fuss was about. The Princes had died hundreds of years ago, at a time when England routinely killed its monarchs. It wasn’t even accurate to call the boys princes. Technically, one—Edward—was the King of England.
The son of Edward IV, Edward V’s only crime was being underage and sickly. His brother Richard was the spare to the heir.
They had come to the Tower voluntarily, to prepare for Edward’s reign. His uncle Richard was supposed to be the kid’s Protector, the person who managed the Kingdom until the boy came of age. But something happened—historical crap no one really cared about any more—and Richard (the uncle not the spare) decided to take the Kingship for himself.
The boys lived for a while after Richard took the throne. And eventually they died—either from sickness or murder most foul. Richard became the infamous Richard the Third, known more for murdering his nephews than for his deeds as King.
Had the boys been allowed to rule, the entire history of the English monarchy might have changed.
But they hadn’t been allowed to rule, and there were more than enough murders after them. Henry VIII murdered wives, for heaven’s sake. His eldest daughter became known as Bloody Mary for her actions as Queen of England and his youngest daughter, Elizabeth, had been no shrinking violet.
Every English monarch of the period killed “pretenders” to the throne, some of whom had more claim to that throne than the person sitting in it.
And each death, if prevented, could have changed the course of English history.
So…two little boys? Really, who cared?
The biggest problem Thomas had wasn’t with Neyla Kendrick or with the long-lost Princes. It was with his own knowledge base. He was going to replace one of Kendrick’s assistants.
Thomas knew everything there was to know about the Tower during the Great Fire. He also knew everything he could possibly learn about Thomas Blood, whose attempt to steal the Crown Jewels on 9 May 1671 was one of the more famous thefts in English history.
Thomas even knew which Jewels were lost forever in the Interregnum.
He just didn’t know what had joined the collection by 1674, what would be missed, and what wouldn’t.
With only less than two days to find out, he didn’t have time to study. This job was becoming a great deal of aggravation.
But, he had to remind himself, no amount of aggravation would make him quit.
There was no better target than this one, no better test of his skills.
To commit the crime of a lifetime took an amazing thief.
To commit the crime of several lifetimes took one of the best thieves ever.
He wanted that title for his own.
The flunky half bowed as Neyla spoke. He was scrawny, with bad teeth, and thinning hair. And he was young, twenty-two if he was a day. She had never seen him before, but then she hadn’t seen half the people who worked for Portals before. Because he was afraid to give her bad news himself, the head of Travel had sent this poor soul to her. Apparently, the head of Travel had figured out she’d be pissed off.
“Beg pardon, ma’am,” the flunky said timidly, “but Dr. Wilson’s got pneumonia. He nearly died. One of his lungs collapsed. They’ve reinflated it and given him some kind of treatment, but he won’t be well by tomorrow at five—at least not well enough to trust him alone without medical help in such a primitive time. Ma’am.”
“You’d think in this day and age,” she said, “no one would ever get that sick.”
“Beg pardon, Ma’am,” the flunky said, “but people still do get ill on occasion.”
“But pneumonia? None of us should’ve gotten that. It’s one of those things that can be prevented.” She ran a hand through her hair. “This makes no sense. Pete Wilson is our biologist, our food specialist. He’s the one who is supposed to prevent us from getting sick. He can’t get sick himself, not before we go.”
The flunky wisely remained silent.
“I suppose we have to call this off now.” She stood, turned her back on the flunky, and went to the window. The Tower looked foreboding in the sunlight.
She half expected to feel relief, but she felt none. She wanted to go, and she wanted to go tomorrow.
“I’ve been told, Ma’am, that no one wants to cancel. They’ve assigned you someone else.”
She frowned. “They’ve assigned…?”
She had handpicked Pete, just like she had picked the rest of her team. But her contract did give Portals the right to assign people to her team. She had argued about that, and she had lost. Portals wanted the right to send troubleshooters and others on trips to take care of potential problems.
“His name is Thomas Ayliffe,” the flunky said, “and—”
“Bullshit.” She turned. “They’re not sending someone named Thomas Ayliffe to the Tower of London in 1674. They can’t be serious.”
The flunky’s cheeks had turned red. “I’m not in charge—I mean, what’s wrong with Thomas Ayliffe?”
“You’re clearly not up on your 17th century London history,” she snapped. “Who assigned this idiot to my team?”
“Mr. Wycroft, at least he’s the one who told me—”
She didn’t need any more. She pushed past the flunky and stormed to Wycroft’s lair.
Wycroft had half of the entire twentieth floor. He had assistants everywhere. He was nominally Neyla’s boss, although she really answered to Darien Wilder.
Wycroft’s receptionist was an old battle-ax who had been hired away from one of Britain’s stuffiest banks. She had been hired for her prim and proper attitude, and her withering looks.
But Neyla could out-wither anyone. She took one look at the battle-ax, and the woman leaned back, ceding the field. Neyla hurried past her, only to be joined by Wycroft’s chief assistant, Flynn Martin.
He was short and stocky with a friendly face and dark hair just starting to go gray. People mistook him for an easy-going person, but Neyla knew better. Flynn Martin was the steel inside Wycroft’s velvet glove.
“I know you’re upset,” Flynn said. “But, Neyla, we need this trip to go off tomorrow—”
“I’m not taking any old person along with me because you have a schedule.” Neyla kept moving, past desks and fake plants and tasteful copies of sculptures from London’s most famous monuments.
“We need to test the remote devices,” Flynn said. “We’ve put a lot of planning into this—”
“So have I,” Neyla said, “and I’m not going to let some idiot get in my way and blow my cover on the very first afternoon.”
“Neyla, let’s talk like adults—”
“Yes, let’s,” she said. “And since my problem is with Harrison Wycroft, I’ll speak to him, not to you.”
She slammed both hands against the double doors leading into Wycroft’s office. The doors banged open.
Wycroft sat behind his desk, with his back to the floor-to-ceiling windows. The cityscape extended beyond him, almost as if it were a decoration in his office, the London Eye turning lazily to his right.
“Neyla,” Wycroft said without saying hello, “he’s the only person we have available with at least a passing knowledge of the 17th Century.”
Wycroft was an obese man whose size seemed appropriate, partly because he favored three-piece black bespoke suits, bowler hats, and the ubiquitous black umbrella.
“So postpone the trip until Pete is well,” Neyla said.
Wycroft sighed and waved a hand at Flynn. Flynn pulled the doors closed as he stepped back outside.
“Pete, it seems, isn’t as cautious as we thought. He was dealing with bacteria from another trip, this one to the 15th century, and comparing various disease vectors, somehow infecting himself with a particularly virulent strain of Pneumocystis carinii. The problem is that he’s ill and in isolation, and we’re not going to get him back for weeks, maybe months. Even then he might not be cleared to travel.”
She crossed her arms. “How long has he been ill?”
“He’s had a cough for a week. It got worse over the weekend.”
“And no one thought to warn me?”
“We hoped it wouldn’t be serious.”
She shook her head. She understood why Pete wasn’t going. She even understood the need for haste with this trip. Portals had its various patents to protect, experiments to foster, research and development to promote. She was only one small cog in a very big wheel.
What she didn’t understand was how no one seemed to understand that a man named Thomas Ayliffe would be a problem.
“This Thomas Ayliffe is pulling your chain,” she said.
“What’s wrong with Ayliffe?” Wycroft asked. “Have you had difficulty with him before?”
“What’s wrong with him?” she snapped, stepping toward Wycroft. “What’s wrong with him? You say he’s an expert on 17th century London.”
“The closest that we have on such short notice, yes,” Wycroft said.
“If he’s an expert,” she said, “he’s giving you a message. Have you done an identity check on this man?”
Wycroft slid out a drawer. He pressed something—probably one of his private networked computer links—and examined the answer.
“Yes, of course. He went through the same rather difficult vetting system that you did.”
“His name is legitimate?” she asked.
“Yes.” The answer came from behind her.
Neyla turned. A man stood there. He was tall, broad-shouldered, and as well dressed as Wycroft, only in a suit that wasn’t half as conservative. The man had black hair, blue eyes, and ruggedly handsome features.
“I don’t believe we’ve been introduced.” His British accent was so posh that he sounded like he belonged at Buckingham Palace. “I’m Thomas Ayliffe.”
“And I’m Nellie Bly,” she said.
He stared at her with that same withering look that the battle-ax outside had perfected. “You can check my birth records.”
“We have,” Wycroft said. “Neyla, what’s your objection to the man’s name?”
“Apparently Ms. Kendrick believes I’m going to use the name when we go to 1674. And that would be unwise.” Ayliffe walked into the room, stopping beside her. He smelled of soap, as if he had just stepped out of the shower.
She looked at him sideways. He was significantly taller than she was, which was also a problem. Brits in the 17th century, especially working class Brits, were notably short due to poor nutrition and unhealthy environmental conditions.
“You see,” Ayliffe said, “Thomas Ayliffe was one of the many names used by the infamous Thomas Blood.”
“Why is that a familiar name?” Wycroft asked.
“For god’s sake,” Neyla said. “Thomas Blood is the most famous person ever to steal the Crown Jewels.”
Wycroft stared at her.
“In 1671. He failed, but spectacularly,” she said. “He became a folk hero, depending on your political persuasion at the time. Remember, Cromwell was only a few years before, and not everyone believed in the restoration of the monarchy.”
Wycroft raised his eyebrows.
“I can’t help my family name,” Ayliffe said, “but I promise not to use it when we travel. It’s not like you need a passport anyway. No one checks your identification.”
Neyla glared at him. He didn’t even look at her. He directed all of his comments to Wycroft, which she also found irritating.
But she could do the same thing. “He’s too tall,” she said.
“Both Henry Tudors were over six feet,” Ayliffe said.
“Henry the Seventh and his son, Henry the Eighth, were both royalty raised in the best of conditions. Besides, by 1674, they were long dead. No one would remember that they were tall. They would simply remember that Henry VIII was supremely fat.”
She bit her lip, wishing she hadn’t said that in front of Wycroft. She made herself continue, partly to cover her gaffe. She now turned toward Ayliffe.
“Even if they did remember how tall the Henries were,” she said, “you’re going to be posing as some ditch digger who probably never had real meat or fresh vegetables in his entire life. You’ll stand out.”
“And you won’t?” He finally turned to her, then he let his gaze run up and down her entire figure.
To her own disgust, she blushed. She wasn’t going to defend her appearance.
“According to his file,” Wycroft said, “Mr. Ayliffe here used to participate in the Society for Creative Anachronism, so he’s not averse to costuming. He works in our history department, specializing in the Elizabethan era, which isn’t that much different from the era you’ll be traveling in—”
“It’s different enough,” Neyla snapped.
“But the clothing and customs are close,” Wycroft said.
“Close isn’t good enough,” she said. “We’ve been working on this for two years. We have a team.”
“Pete’s not going no matter how you argue it,” Wycroft said. “And waiting won’t help. We’re just going to have to muddle through.”
“Let’s muddle through without the tall guy,” she said. “The rest of us are ready. I don’t know what he’ll add.”
“I do know something about food,” Ayliffe said. “I spent a few years at Stratford before I realized that acting wasn’t for me, so 17th century English isn’t that foreign to me. I will probably be able to understand the natives better than you will.”
He had a point, although she wasn’t going to concede it. Everyone who studied with the Royal Shakespeare Company spent quite a bit of time learning how to speak Elizabethan English, which was still what they were speaking in the 1670s. Her American accent was going to be a handicap. She had planned to speak to the locals as little as possible.
“You will need a translator, right?” Ayliffe asked. “And I didn’t see one on your list. I think that might be a lot more valuable than a biologist.”
“Pete isn’t just a biologist,” she said. “He was in charge of food safety.”
“If you want safe food, stay here,” Ayliffe said. “Back there, you’re going to eat things that horrify you because you have no other choice. You’ll just have to trust that all those medical precautions they took here at Portals will protect you.”
“Nothing will protect against food poisoning,” she said.
“Expect a mild case or two,” he said. “I’ve had it. It’s not pleasant, but you’ll survive.”
“In the modern era,” she said. “Four hundred years ago, it could kill you.”
“But we’ll have the remotes,” he said. “We’ll be able to come back if someone gets deathly ill. Right?”
He directed that last question to Wycroft.
Wycroft’s mouth pursed. His eyes shifted to Neyla, then back to Ayliffe. Wycroft looked very uncomfortable.
So no one had briefed Ayliffe on all of the details. Just some of them.
Ayliffe looked from Wycroft to Neyla. “What don’t I know?”
“We can return any time in the first three days,” she said. “Then we have another window thirty days later. That’s it.”
“What do you mean, that’s it?”
She shrugged. “If we miss the windows, there’s a very good chance we’ll get stuck back there.”
She tried to sound calm about it, but she wasn’t calm. She was going to monitor those windows like nothing else, and she was going to return in one of them, no matter what.
“Why?” Ayliffe asked. “You can come back any time. Time travel is time travel is time travel. It doesn’t correlate. Even if you leave the past on 30 July 1674, you’ll be able to arrive back here one second after you left. What’s the problem?”
“It’s a design flaw in the remotes,” Wycroft said. “Something we haven’t been able to solve yet.”
“Whatever the remotes do,” Neyla said, being as vague as she could be since she never really bothered to understand the science, “they work on the initial energy burst for the first three days. Then the system will go dark for a while, recharging, for lack of a better phrase. Our first opportunity to return will be in thirty days.”
“Our first,” Ayliffe said. “So you won’t get stuck.”
“We don’t know that,” she said. “What we do know is that only people who have used the three-day and thirty-day windows have returned. No one else has. I would assume they’ve tried every thirty days after that. I don’t know for certain.”
He frowned, then looked at Wycroft. “How do you know this? I thought this is the first major remote trip.”
“You think we didn’t test the remotes?” Wycroft asked. “We’ve been testing them for a decade.”
“And you’re willing to go with this design flaw?” Ayliffe sounded shocked. That pleased Neyla. Maybe he’d back out.
“It’s no more dangerous than sending someone back to the 17th century,” Wycroft said in that tone he used when he was spouting corporate cover-your-assisms. Neyla had heard these arguments before. In fact, she had made some of them.
“So those people who got lost,” Ayliffe said, “you haven’t sent teams after them?”
“Where would we look?” Wycroft asked. “And what if the problem isn’t the remotes? What if they got arrested or something else happened?”
“You don’t leave people behind,” Ayliffe said.
“They knew the risks,” Wycroft said. “So do we. There’s a chance that they wanted to stay, you know. Maybe they found true love.”
He couldn’t hide the sarcasm from his voice. Since Portals went public, the number of movies and novels about people finding love back in time had quadrupled.
“Most likely they died,” Neyla said.
Ayliffe looked at her, obviously alarmed.
Neyla added, “If you come with us—and I think you shouldn’t—you’re not going to go on some sanctioned SCA field trip or some little practice holiday for Elizabethan scholars. You’ll be entering a dark, dirty world more dangerous than any third world country. The longer we stay, the less chance we have of surviving.”
“So let’s get in and out fast,” Ayliffe said.
“We can’t,” she said. “I don’t know what day in July they discovered the bodies of the Princes. Even if I did know, I’m not sure how fast I’ll be able to gain access to them.”
“This is,” Wycroft said, “our first experiment in a deliberately long trip. We’ve had accidentally long trips in the past, but not something like this.”
Ayliffe visibly swallowed. He looked nervous for the first time since she had met him.
“And,” Neyla said, mostly to make him more nervous, “most of those accidentally long trips happened in the time travel booth here in Portals itself. Remotes aren’t the only problem with time travel.”
Ayliffe studied her. Then he squared his shoulders, and looked at Wycroft.
“I suppose I have to sign waivers,” Ayliffe said.
Wycroft looked relieved. For some reason, he seemed to want Ayliffe on this trip. “You’ll also have to go to medical and make certain you’re both healthy enough for the trip and you have the right protections.”
Ayliffe nodded, then he tipped an imaginary hat to Neyla. “Nice meeting you,” he said. “Looks like we’ll be spending some time together.”
“Not if I can help it,” she said.
He hadn’t known his allies in the company would deliberately make one of the original team ill, but it made sense. He also hadn’t expected anyone to know what his name meant. But then, he had initially planned on traveling back in time alone. He had been opening the door to Wycroft’s office when Neyla Kendrick had said If he’s an expert, he’s giving you a message, and he damn near turned around and left.
He’d always used names like Thomas Ayliffe on jobs. A bit of an inside joke, which meant nothing to anyone but him.
But she had seen through it—and accurately. He had sent a small message, one that he hadn’t expected to be received until after he left, if he had accomplished his task.
She made him nervous.
She was also too pretty to masquerade as a boy. Too pretty and too buxom. He had no idea how the costumers were going to hide those curves, but they had quite a job ahead of them.
Which reminded him. He needed clothes for the journey.
He had a lot to do before five o’clock tomorrow. He hoped he could finish everything in time.
Neyla’s breasts had finally been tamed, and the wrapping didn’t even hurt. McTavish, working with some of the scientists, found a nice mixture of spandex and nanotechnology to squish her breasts. Then McTavish wound some regular cloth around her belly, so that she looked like a man who had a barrel chest, rather than a pretty boy with man-boobs.
When she looked at herself in the mirror, with her short hair, barrel chest, and spindly legs, she seemed like something out of Hogarth—one of the wide-eyed commoners crowding around the subject of the drawing on crammed streets of London.
The rest of her team looked authentic too—at least to her. Jeff Renolet, who didn’t need wrapping to create his own barrel chest, stood beside her. He was in his forties, balding, with a ruddy face. He normally wore crowns on his front teeth, but Portals’ dentist had removed them for this trip. Jeff looked like an old fat man who had been repeatedly punched in the mouth.
Next to Jeff, Benedict Ivance scratched underneath one arm. He had chosen loose-weave linen, which held dirt in every single wrinkle. Modern linen had been treated so that it was soft, but linen without treatment was rough. If he was scratching already, he would be raw by the time this trip was over.
Compared to the others, Dan Sheldon looked like a half-grown boy. He was whip-thin thanks to his daily six-mile runs and his love of urban free climbing. His eyes were clear, his blond hair cut in a bowl-shape. He had the kind of innocent face that often showed up in religious paintings of the era. Instead of his filthy clothes, he should have been wearing priest’s robes.
Thomas Ayliffe towered over all of them. His clothing was a bit upscale for a member of the working class, but McTavish had taken care of that by ripping it, mending it, and then ripping it again. Ayliffe looked like an elegant man who had come upon hard times.
Besides, Neyla was beginning to think the man would look good in anything.
She hated that she found him attractive. He was annoying and in the way, and he was noticeable. He was going to scotch this mission just by being part of it. She knew it, and she resented it.
She had done everything she could to get rid of him. She had spent fifteen minutes after Ayliffe left Wycroft’s office, trying to convince him to take Ayliffe off the team. When that didn’t work, she had gone all the way to Damien Wilder’s office, only to be told that Wilder was in Japan, making some kind of presentation.
She was stuck with elegant, good-looking Ayliffe and with his ripped upscale clothes.
Her party’s cover story was simple. They had joined up on a trip to London to find work. They’d been in the city only a few months and had found just enough to keep them alive.
Theoretically, the story explained their extra clothing, their bundles of supplies and the fact that none of them looked like the other. Friends and colleagues, not relatives.
They’d had the story drummed into them, practicing it and everything else at odd moments. Neyla, the only one without a British accent, had vowed not to speak much, at least around natives. But the others had to be careful as well. Jeff had studied 17th century speech and Ayliffe knew Elizabethan English, but neither of them had heard it spoken correctly.
They double-checked their equipment one last time. Everyone had their own remote, as well as their own tiny computers. Some had specialized equipment. Ayliffe got custody of Pete’s food safety devices, with a short instruction on how to use them. Because Pete wasn’t coming along, Neyla insisted on double the amount of water purification tablets even if that meant a little extra bulk in their kits.
When they were done, she looked at the entire group.
“Last chance to back out,” she said.
They stared at her. Jeff’s right eye had developed a nervous tick. Benedict bit his lower lip, as if he were trying not to say anything, and Dan took a deep breath, clearly trying to calm himself.
Only Ayliffe looked like a man about to go on an adventure. His eyes were bright, his cheeks slightly flushed.
“All right, then,” she said. “Off we go.”
Now it all felt real to her.
She followed her little troop through the arches, past the buskers and the tradesmen offering everything from a printout of that day’s news to Tower trinkets supposedly for less than they were being sold for inside.
Almost no one walked in with her group. What tourists they saw were leaving. The Tower closed to visitors at six, and most people had spent all day here.
The modern gift shop looked garish in front of the Middle Tower. Neyla walked past it to the matching ticket booths. They seemed as out of place as the gift shop, but at least they didn’t block the old entrance to one of the towers.
She hurried up to the window, the other members of her team following her.
“Five tickets,” she said, broadening her American accent and filling her voice with excitement.
The ticket taker, an elderly woman with a kind face, leaned toward the plastic separating her from Neyla. “Ah, luv, I’ve got to charge you full price, and you’ll only get an hour in there. Come back tomorrow noon latest, and you’ll be able to enjoy the whole place.”
“I’m flying home tomorrow,” Neyla lied, sounding as disappointed as she could.
The ticket taker sighed, as if this were her problem, not Neyla’s. “Then you’re better off, luv, walking the outside for free, taking pictures and looking at the ravens. It’s a lot of money for just an hour, and I don’t feel right selling you a ticket.”
Just sell me a damn ticket, Neyla wanted to snap. I’m sure your bosses would appreciate the revenue.
But she smiled instead. “You’re so kind. But my friends here want to see the Crown Jewels, and I want to see where Anne Boleyn got her head cut off.”
The ticket taker winced at Neyla’s crudeness, but it worked. Playing the demanding American got her exactly what she wanted.
She bought five tickets, then led her little group back to the Middle Tower. The Middle Tower had been an entrance into the entire complex since the beginning of the 14th century. It had to have been impressive then, so tall and formidable and new.
Neyla knew the history of each and every building. She knew who built it and why, its various uses, and when it was remodeled, moved, or, in a few cases, destroyed. She carried multiple maps of the entire complex in her head, just in case the remotes worked improperly. The last thing she wanted was to overshoot their historical timeslot and end up inside the wall of a building that had later been torn down—or a moat that had been filled in.
Her group had quite a trek from the Middle Tower down Lanthorn Lane to the Bloody Tower, which would take them to the Inner Ward. Tourists had gone on a prescribed walk ever since the Tower was opened to the public, centuries ago.
She knew there were other ways inside the Tower’s defenses, she just wasn’t allowed to take those ways as a member of the public.
As her team walked, they gawked at their surroundings like proper tourists. The real tourists gawked at them, dressed in their period costume. They received several stares and more than a few people pointed at them.
Neyla tried to ignore them all. She kept her eye on the Bloody Tower, as she had since the first time she had come here. It got its name from the Princes. The Bloody Tower was the last place they’d been seen alive, looking out the windows in 1483. Over time, no one saw them any more, and Tudor historians claimed Richard III had murdered them there.
Of course, no one knew exactly what happened to the Princes, if indeed they were murdered there or anywhere else. Even if they had died there and the 1933 examination of the bodies was correct, then someone had taken the corpses and carried them across the grounds to the Innermost Ward, where they were buried in the foundation of a spiral staircase.
The bodies had been found in 1674, when workers getting rid of a forebuilding attached to the White Tower dug into the foundation of that staircase. The workers hadn’t been surprised.
It wasn’t unusual for bodies to be buried all over the Tower’s grounds. After all, the place had served as a prison from its very beginnings over 1,000 years ago. Many times, unidentified skeletons were discovered throughout the complex; more than once, dozens of bodies were discovered at the same time.
Generally no one cared who the skeletons belonged to. The Princes were one of the few exceptions.
The team reached the Bloody Tower, but didn’t stop. Neyla didn’t look at the windows like she usually did and wonder which ones had provided Edward V’s last view of the world.
Now the team had entered the Inner Ward, where the Tower’s most famous history occurred. Here, on these grounds, Henry VIII had conducted the beheadings of his rivals and wives. Here Elizabeth the First, when she was imprisoned in the Bell Tower by her sister Mary, walked every day with an escort, probably trying not to look at the spot where her mother had died.
“We’re nuts,” Jeff whispered.
“You want to back out?” she asked him, feeling a surge of disappointment.
He shook his head slowly, as if he were warring with himself. “Just didn’t expect it to feel so real, you know?”
She did know. They stopped on the west side of the White Tower, the oldest building in the entire complex. William the Conqueror had built it in 1097 out of gleaming white Caen stone. It had stood alone on the banks of the Thames, a large Norman keep, the tallest building in all of England, twenty-seven meters high.
Neyla looked up all those meters. The Caen stone had held up well. It no longer gleamed, but it still looked white, partly because of the cleanings that it routinely suffered now that preservationists had decided that the filth in the air would eventually cause the stone to decay.
One of the Yeoman Warders, in his regulation Elizabethan black and red garb (tourists called the Warders Beefeaters, which made her think of gin), approached their group. He turned to Ayliffe, as if Ayliffe were their leader.
“You only have about a half hour, lad, if you’re going to see anything important. We shut down promptly at six.”
“Thanks,” Ayliffe said. “We’re nearly done.”
The Warder nodded, then wandered away, probably to give his warning to the other remaining tourists.
“We’d better act fast,” Dan said.
“We’re going to take our time,” Neyla said. Going too fast might cause mistakes. The first—and most important—thing they had to do was find the right spot on the ground outside the White Tower.
The grass had been cordoned off—too many feet would cause the stuff to stop growing—but the grass not too far from the northwest corner of the White Tower was exactly where they wanted to stand. They couldn’t get anywhere near that demolished forebuilding, since no one knew exactly how big it had been.
Benedict watched the Warders. He would give the team the all clear when they could run for the grass. The rest of the team pulled out their remotes.
The remotes were thin disks that looked like badly crafted circles that hung from a chain. Only right now, no one in the group wore theirs. They were instead squeezing the disk’s sides to turn it on.
The technical team already programmed the date and time in. No one on Neyla’s team knew how to program these things, even though she begged for the chance to learn back when this trip got scheduled.
She wanted to control when she returned. But she was told that the remotes were so delicate that one mistake could send her into a different time period, and strand her there forever.
She wasn’t sure she believed it. Portals was a corporation after all, and divisions in corporations did their very best to hoard knowledge so that they could hoard power. But she hadn’t won this argument either.
When she finished turning her device on, she took Benedict’s and started it. Then she and the team waited while he watched.
Finally, he nodded. The group hurried to their spot on the grass, and when Neyla gave the signal, pressed the center of the disks, activating the travel mechanism.
She clutched her disk so hard, she was afraid she was going to break it. At first, nothing happened. She glanced over at the Bloody Tower, saw a Warder running toward them, and then he simply faded away.
Everything went completely black. A wind buffeted her, changing direction constantly. Thunder clapped—or maybe she was hearing sonic booms—and the air grew hotter, then colder, then hotter again.
For a moment, she felt like she was falling, and then she realized she really was falling. She landed in a heap on the hard ground, the wind gone, the air warm and fetid.
She blinked hard, realized the darkness wasn’t quite absolute. A moon shone above her and the stars surrounded it.
She’d never been able to see the stars in London before.
“Anyone else here?” she asked quietly.
She sat up, stretched her limbs, and realized that while she didn’t have any broken bones, she would be badly bruised.
Her heart was pounding.
“I’m here,” Dan said, his voice as soft as hers. “Hit my head pretty hard.”
Her eyes were adjusting. She could see the outlines of the White Tower now, and thought she might see a dim light through one of the windows. A dim, flickering light. A lantern, perhaps, or a candle.
“You all right?” she asked.
“I think so,” he said.
She moved toward his voice. She craved real light—a flashlight, a small phone/computer display, something. She hadn’t planned on the darkness.
It felt like a live thing. A close, smelly live thing. Her eyes burned. The air was filled with smoke.
She hadn’t expected that either.
“Anyone else here?” she asked as she groped for Dan. Finally her hand found wool.
“Ouch,” he said and pulled away. “I banged myself something awful.”
“Me, too,” she said.
“God. They said we’d fall. They didn’t say it would be so far.” That voice belonged to Benedict. “You’d think they could calculate how much dirt and fill and stuff accumulated over the centuries.”
Neyla sighed in relief at hearing his voice.
“Are you all right?” she asked Benedict.
“Banged up, just like Dan, but nothing serious.”
“They said we’d fall only a few decimeters. Did that seem like a few decimeters to anyone? Seemed like at least a meter to me,” Dan said.
Neyla had no idea. The fall was expected but hard. She was beginning to worry that Jeff and Ayliffe were too badly injured to speak.
“Experts don’t know everything.” That was Jeff. He half mumbled it. “I don’t think they considered the tiny details. After all, they weren’t the ones traveling in time.”
Neyla was relieved to hear his voice. “Any broken bones, Jeff?”
“Twisted my ankle, but I can put weight on it. I’ll be all right.”
All the voices were close to her. She let out a sigh. “What about you, Thomas? You okay?”
Silence. She heard her own breath, a little ragged as it went in and out. Beside her, fabric rustled. Then someone’s joint made a cracking noise.
“Thomas?” Why would Ayliffe pretend to be hurt? Why wouldn’t he answer? “Feel around for him, guys. Maybe he got knocked unconscious.”
She kept her voice down as she spoke. She didn’t know if guards patrolled the grounds.
Clearly, her team had arrived at night. Which was good on one level—she would be able to see how far the work progressed, maybe even find the bodies herself—and bad on another. She would have to figure out what to do with her team before dawn, whether or not they would leave the complex or find a place to sleep somewhere nearby, somewhere that they wouldn’t get caught.
“I’m not finding him,” Jeff said.
“Me, either,” Benedict said.
“Hey, Thomas!” Dan raised his voice slightly.
Neyla’s eyes were adjusting to the darkness. She made out the shapes around her. The three men, Benedict slightly prone, Dan sitting up, and Jeff, on his hands and knees groping for Ayliffe. The White Tower in front of her. An amazing expanse of ground behind her.
The Grand Storehouse hadn’t been built yet nor converted to the Waterloo Barracks. She could see what had been, in Henry III’s time, the outer wall, extending all around her. As she turned, she thought she saw movement.
She squinted.
Someone was running silently across the grounds.
Away from her.
“Crap,” she said and stood up. “Is that Thomas?”
She pointed toward the shadowy figure.
“It’s got to be a guard,” Dan said, sounding slightly panicked.
“He’s not running toward us,” Jeff said.
“Maybe he’s getting help,” Benedict said.
“No, he’s not.” Neyla stood and wobbled just a little. Her muscles felt like they’d been stretched and turned inside out. “It’s Thomas.”
“Why would he run?” Jeff asked.
“He’s probably disoriented,” Dan said.
“He’s not that either,” she said.
She should have trusted her instincts.
Thomas Ayliffe aka Thomas Blood.
The damned idiot had been sending a message.
And she was finally, finally receiving it.
He had expected the air to stink, but not something this foul. It was as if he had landed inside a dumpster filled with raw meat on a hot summer evening.
While he tried to catch his breath, he willed his eyes to adjust to the darkness.
The darkness was great luck. He could get to Martin Tower, where the Jewels were kept in the 17th century, with a minimum of fuss, so long as he stayed away from any guards. Then he could take the Jewels, come back somewhere near here, and press his damn remote, all within his three day window.
Hell, if he did it fast enough, he would be inside a three-hour window.
Provided he could stand.
The fall had hurt. He had probably landed on some of the things he’d squirreled inside his linen shirt. He’d brought a paste copy of one of the rings he wanted, as well as some keys and a few small weapons. Tools of the trade, which had probably added to his bruises.
Neyla’s voice, sounding musical, American and out of place, asked if everyone was all right. Thomas got onto his hands and knees, stifling a moan as he bent his back.
He crawled along the grass, his fingers finding mud—or something worse. He didn’t want to look up. He had no idea how the sewer system worked in the Tower. Did people have privies here? Where did they dump the chamber pots?
He shuddered so deeply that he almost moaned again, but the thought was enough to get him to his feet.
Once on his feet, he could see the outline of the wall built in 13th century. Martin Tower stood on the upper northeast corner, and he could see it vaguely.
He felt disoriented. Knowing that buildings wouldn’t be here—the museum for one, the Jewel House for another, Waterloo Barracks for a third—wasn’t the same as seeing the grounds without them.
It looked like a completely different place.
It was a completely different place.
He brushed his hands on his knee breeches, grabbed his small bundle of supplies, and started to run as silently as he could.
He headed up the path toward the Martin Tower, ignoring the pain that ran up his spine. His whole body hurt, but he was trying to convince himself that it was the kind of hurt a man got when he had the wind knocked out of him, not when he was seriously injured.
He had to remember the plan.
There would be guards. He had read somewhere, in one of the contemporaneous accounts, that the guards around the Jewels had doubled after Thomas Blood’s failed attempt in 1671.
Which was just three years ago now.
Weird.
He had to take out the guards. Break into the Jewel cupboard, and take his items.
If he was really lucky, he would get away completely. Neyla would think he somehow never made it to 1674, and she would go on with her mission without him.
He would complete his theft and be on his way.
With things more precious than gold.
She wasn’t going to let that arrogant bastard ruin her trip.
She heard one of the men behind her call her name and another shush him. Then she heard footsteps, also from behind her, and hoped it was her team running with her.
She sprinted after Ayliffe. He had too much of a lead for her to catch him, but that didn’t matter. Once he reached Martin Tower, he wouldn’t be able to get in.
It was locked, and the guards had been doubled in the past three years. He probably didn’t know that.
Her breath was coming in small gasps. Her throat tickled. The foul air made her want to cough.
So far, no guards, but that would change. Didn’t they hear the commotion in the yard? Weren’t they trained to come running?
But she hadn’t been able to find out how many guards were on duty in July 1674. Even if she had, it wouldn’t have mattered. Corruption was so deep in the Tower that just because someone was supposed to work, it didn’t mean that he actually showed up.
She couldn’t see Ayliffe any longer. He had to have reached Martin Tower.
Her breath came hard and suddenly she couldn’t catch it at all. She wheezed and doubled over, coughing so hard that it hurt. Something was getting to her.
Lack of oxygen. The odors. The smoke.
Something.
Her eyes watered, but she made herself stagger forward.
She had to catch him, before he doomed them all.
He made himself take deep breaths of the thick air. He needed to slow down his heart rate and remain calm.
Then he reached inside his jacket, lifted the edges of his linen shirt, and felt until he found the two tools he would need right now.
The skeleton key, which he had been told was universal, and a teeny tiny stun gun, one that didn’t shoot its barbs over a distance. Instead, its business end sent an up-close-and-personal charge through the victims that they wouldn’t soon forget.
His hands were shaking. He willed himself to settle down.
He could hear footsteps along the path, then wheezing and loud coughing. He couldn’t tell if the cougher was male or female.
Someone wasn’t taking well to the 17th century air.
He gripped the skeleton key tightly in his right hand, willed himself to do this right, and stepped in front of the door.
Then he shoved the key into the lock, and turned.
For a moment, he thought it wasn’t going to work.
Then he heard an audible click.
“There is a God,” he whispered. Or at least, a spirit of some kind, watching over him, helping him succeed.
What if they weren’t?
Dan and Jeff had joined her. She looked over her shoulder. Benedict was only a few yards behind them. He appeared to be running backwards, keeping an eye out behind them to protect them from potential trouble.
She reached the exterior of Martin Tower just as the door creaked closed. Something clicked.
She grabbed the handle and pulled. The door was shut tight.
Locked.
The bastard had shut them out.
Dan caught up to her. He was breathing as hard as she had been.
He tugged on the door, just like she had, and he couldn’t get it open either.
“Now what the hell do we do?” she asked.
He grinned at her, then he looked at the windows on the second story.
“We climb,” he said.
Thomas started. The guard was wearing the red-and-black Beefeater uniform. Only his was dirty and rumpled.
Thomas made himself take a deep, calming breath. Of course the man wore a Beefeater’s uniform. The uniform had been designed in the Tudor era.
The guard spoke. For a moment, it sounded like gibberish. Then Thomas concentrated, like he used to do at the beginning of any Shakespeare play, and the words filtered through his brain.
The man had cursed. His accent was thicker than Thomas had expected, the emphasis on different parts of the words than Thomas had learned.
But they were familiar enough.
The guard stood. He was half a foot shorter than Thomas, and had gone to fat.
He smelled of grease and onions and unwashed flesh.
Thomas’s eyes watered. He wondered if he would ever get used to the stinks around here.
“March away,” the guard snapped. “Your place is not here.”
“Oh, I belong here,” Thomas said and pressed his stun gun against the guard’s side.
The man burbled, then convulsed, falling backwards to the ground, his head hitting the stone floor repeatedly, sounding like some kind of drum.
Thomas watched for just a moment, making sure the man wasn’t having some kind of seizure. The last thing Thomas wanted to do was kill someone.
The guard’s face was red, but he seemed okay. He moaned and stopped convulsing. But he wasn’t getting up.
He was breathing, though.
Thomas couldn’t wait any longer. He grabbed the lantern off its peg, and hurried down the corridor to the left, hoping against hope that the Jewels were where they were supposed to be.
Benedict caught up to them. “We going in?”
“I am.” Dan took a few more steps back, and surveyed the side of the building. “I should be able to let you in shortly after I get inside.”
“If you don’t get caught,” Benedict said.
“O, ye of little faith,” Dan said. He gripped the side of the building, then found footholds. “This thing isn’t smooth. It shouldn’t take me long.”
Neyla was glad he didn’t ask her to come along. He had asked her to urban free climb back when they were training. She had taken one look at the building that he had chosen in Canary Wharf and immediately declined to go any farther. She realized that afternoon that she had a very mild fear of heights.
He scaled the side of the building like Spider-man dressed for a Shakespeare play and reached the window in no time at all.
Neyla hadn’t even realized she was holding her breath.
He braced himself, then reached into his jacket and removed the knife he had brought with him.
For a moment, Neyla thought he was going to pry the window open. Instead, he used the hilt to smash the glass.
Shards rained down on them. Jeff cursed. Benedict bent over.
Neyla was standing far enough away that she didn’t get hit.
“You could’ve warned us,” Jeff said.
She shushed him. They were already making too much noise. She turned and looked at the Inner Ward.
She wasn’t sure what she was expecting—exterior security lights to go on? If someone lit a candle a few buildings away, she wouldn’t be able to see it.
She turned back toward the building. Dan had disappeared inside.
Now all they had to do was wait.
The stairs appeared so swiftly that he almost tripped down the first. The stone walls saved him. The walls around the stairs were so narrow that they caught him even as he pitched slightly forward.
His breathing was ragged. He put one hand on the stone wall, wincing at the stone’s dampness, and went down.
He would only get one shot at this, especially now that Neyla knew he had no reason to participate in their little bone expedition.
He was glad he wouldn’t have to stay here long. He hadn’t expected the past to be so creepy.
He followed the twisting staircase down and relaxed slightly when he saw that it opened into a large arched room.
The cupboard was in just such a room—he’d seen someone’s portrait of that. He hoped that the ancient art was accurate.
Funny, he had thought it would be easier to break into the Tower without the high level security, the cameras, the motion sensors, the laser traps.
But he had never been so terrified on a job in his entire life.
He walked forward into the darkness, holding the lantern in front of him, and wishing it gave off more light.
He held a torch in one hand, but he didn’t appear to be looking for anything. It took Neyla a few minutes to realize what he was doing.
He was patrolling the grounds.
She pressed what remained of her little team against the door, and pointed. They nodded. They huddled together as the man walked within a few yards of them, not noticing the broken glass or the three people a stone’s throw away.
She hoped he would be gone by the time Dan got the door open.
If Dan got the door open.
She didn’t know what would happen if he didn’t.
Thomas held up the lantern, hoping he wasn’t hopelessly lost. Then something glinted in front of him.
His breath caught.
He was here.
Finally.
Then the door creaked open and a thin ray of light trickled out.
“Come on.” Dan’s shadowy head peered around the door.
Jeff slid in first, followed by Benedict. Neyla entered last, pulling the heavy door closed behind her.
They were in a small antechamber of some kind. Dan had found an old-fashioned lantern, made of iron and glass, designed to protect candles from gusts of wind. The smoke from the candle wisped out of the top, near the metal ring that Dan was holding.
He nodded toward the center of the room. A guard lay flat on his back, his eyes partly open.
“Is he dead?” Jeff asked.
“Dunno,” Dan said. “Thought I’d let you in first.”
Neyla clenched her fist, then made herself release it, finger by finger. Dammit, dammit, dammit.
Benedict hurried over to the guard and felt his carotid artery for a pulse. After a moment, he said, “He’s all right.”
That was some consolation, at least. But now, no matter what, they would have to leave. They couldn’t show up on the grounds the day a guard was attacked in Martin Tower.
The last thing she wanted was to get caught. Not here. In the 17th century, prisons were foul places, filled with wretched people, particularly the people who weren’t wealthy and couldn’t pay for their own upkeep.
“What did Thomas do to him?” Jeff asked Benedict.
“Can’t tell,” he said. “Doesn’t look like he was stabbed. Probably hit him over the head.”
“Doesn’t matter,” Neyla said. “We have to find Thomas and get the hell out of here.”
“Out of Martin Tower?” Dan asked.
“Out of 1674,” she said. “You want to be arrested here?”
“Jesus,” he said. “No.”
“Where are the Jewels?” Benedict asked.
She had to stop and think. She never studied much about Martin Tower. She knew the history, of course. The Jewels were locked in a ground floor cupboard, beneath the apartments of the Deputy Keeper of the Jewel House.
She had seen drawings of Blood’s incredible heist, the one he had nearly gotten away with, and they always portrayed the cupboard as a large space, somewhere nearby.
But to get there directly? She had no idea.
“Was there an apartment upstairs?” she asked Dan.
“There were doors,” he said. “I came in a corridor. The lantern was hanging near them. I had to use one of my matches to light it. I hope that’s okay.”
She didn’t care that he had brought illegal matches or that he had lit the lantern. But the fact that it hung near a door not too far from the window meant that the apartments were on the west side of the building.
“We go this way,” she said and headed to her left.
This had to be it.
His heart was pounding so hard that for a moment, he thought someone was coming after him.
He made himself take a deep breath. He would worry about that if it happened. Right now, he needed some jewelry.
He studied the cupboard. The handles, locked shut with the padlock. But the cupboard doors themselves were hinged.
He hadn’t brought a metal file, but he did have a few other tools. He could get the tiny nails out of the hinges and pull them off the door. Then the door would open from the side.
It wouldn’t take long at all.
He looked around for a place to hang the lantern, found one not two feet away. He stopped, set down his bundle, then removed the candle and used it to light the other three. He replaced them and hung the lantern.
He stepped toward the cupboard and reached for the closest hinge. His hands were shaking.
He had never been so nervous on a job.
He had never done a job as complicated as this.
Thomas forced himself to relax, and slowly, carefully, pried the tiny handcrafted nails out of their hinge.
Neyla was beginning to doubt herself. She usually double-checked things in her research materials or with her computer, but she didn’t have fingertip access any more.
She missed it.
She would have missed the stairs too, except that the corridor led right to them. The branch to the right, going away from the stairs, almost seemed like an afterthought.
Dan started going down the branch, but she grabbed his arm and shook her head.
Her memory said the Jewels were on the ground floor, but she wasn’t sure how they defined ground floor here. Had her team come in on the ground floor or was there one level down, accessible from another part of the building?
It made more sense for the Jewel cupboard to be as far beneath ground as possible. That way it would be easier to defend.
She started down the stairs.
“I don’t think so,” Dan whispered. “I think they’re on this floor.”
“You take Benedict and look,” she said. “But first, give us each a candle.”
“They’re not in holders,” he said. “The wax’ll burn your fingers.”
“I don’t care,” she said. “I don’t see well in the dark.”
They stopped. He fumbled with the lantern, handing her a candle and handing Jeff one. Then he closed the glass door and picked up the lantern.
Benedict watched the whole thing as if it were a waste of time.
“If you don’t find anything,” Neyla said, “come back here. We’ll be waiting.”
At least, she hoped they would be waiting. She wasn’t sure what they would find below. If they did find Thomas, she was going to have to find a way to subdue him. After all, he had almost murdered someone.
She and Jeff went down the stairs slowly.
The stone walls along the side were narrow, cramping her. The walls were damp and the air had a mildewy odor that mixed with the ripeness of stagnant water.
She resisted the urge to sneeze. Something in this time period really bothered her. She hadn’t realized she had allergies until she came here.
Still, she made herself move down the stairs as quietly as she could.
When she reached the bottom she saw a series of arches that she recognized from the old paintings.
She was on the right path. She wished she could yell for Dan and Benedict, but she didn’t dare.
Instead, she put a finger to her lips. Jeff nodded. Together they walked through the arches, going slowly, hoping against hope that Thomas wasn’t planning to ambush them.
Thomas took out his knife and started digging into the wood itself. Screw the nails. The wood was the softest part of this damn cupboard. And he was going to get in no matter what.
He was making a god-awful noise. He hoped no one heard it from the apartments above. He knew from the Thomas Blood stories that one of the men in charge of the Jewels—the Keeper of the Jewel House? His deputy?—housed his entire family in Martin Tower.
It had been that family that caught Thomas Blood. The son had inopportunely returned from his military service after years away, and caught Thomas Blood’s gang in the act of theft. The gang managed to escape, but the son raised an alarm and the guards caught Blood’s gang in the streets just outside the Tower.
Thomas had vowed to himself that he wouldn’t get caught.
So far, he seemed to be doing well.
Even if he had to gouge the damn hinges free.
Neyla glanced at Jeff, then pointed toward the sound. Two arches away, she could see a soft yellow glow.
Jeff nodded. Then he reached up and pinched his candle out.
Neyla did the same.
They pressed against each other, walking toward the noise.
It had to be Thomas.
She hoped.
To his surprise, the Jewels weren’t sitting on rests or in small holders. They were crammed haphazardly on shelves, looking like nothing more than some very wealthy person’s high-end jewelry closet.
He stared for a moment.
He’d seen such riches before. After all, he had seen the Crown Jewels—these Crown Jewels—in their modern display, under reinforced glass with sensors all around, cameras on each jewel, special lighting, and an appropriate setting for each, showing off its sparkling magnificence.
There was no sparkling here, not even when the light caught the diamonds and sapphires and rubies. These things hadn’t been cleaned in a generation.
The orb sat to one side. St. Edward’s crown, restored after Thomas Blood had crushed it to get it out of the Tower, sat near the back. Thomas couldn’t see the Scepter, not that it mattered.
But he didn’t want them. He wanted Edward the Confessor’s sapphire ring.
He had an exquisite paste copy tied under his shirt. Or at least, what he and the forger thought was a copy. No one knew exactly what the sapphire ring looked like. It had been melted down, the sapphire placed in the Imperial Crown in 1837 for the coronation of Queen Victoria.
All they had to go on were paintings from the National Portrait Gallery and some of those lacked so much in detail that he had been praying he had it right.
Now he realized it didn’t matter. The ring was probably as filthy as the rest of the jewelry, and no one knew if there was filigree work or any engravings or anything that made the ring unique.
He should have thought of that. People didn’t clean themselves in this century. Why would they clean their jewelry?
He went through the cupboard as quickly as he could, searching for the ring.
Each time he found a small piece he could pocket, he moved it to one side. He would take a lot of lesser jewels out of here, things thought sold off to fund wars or lost to the sands of time.
Maybe lost to a traveler in time.
He grinned to himself.
Then he found Edward the Confessor’s ring. Thick and well made and surprisingly heavy.
Thomas reached into his own shirt and untied the fake ring. It gleamed compared to the actual treasures.
He tied the real ring inside his shirt, put the fake with the Scepter, and then he looked at the others, trying to figure out how to carry them. He had found five pieces small enough to carry without causing too much trouble.
Counting the ring—which his sponsor saw as the real prize—Thomas would have six pieces. Five for his sponsor (in exchange for Thomas’s fee) and one for himself, a keepsake of an extraordinary moment.
But he wasn’t done yet.
He would put the other five pieces inside the bundle. He crouched, untied it, and spread it on the floor.
Something rustled near him. A rat? A guard?
He looked up—
And saw Neyla.
Her gaze met his. He smiled.
“I figure no one will miss these,” he said.
“They’d miss the guard,” she said.
He raised his eyebrows. “I just stunned him.”
“Lucky for you he’s not dead,” she said.
“I don’t think that’s lucky. He can identify me. I’m finishing up and getting out of here.”
Her mouth opened, then closed, then opened again. Didn’t he understand the implications of all of this? Didn’t he realize that he had just ruined her trip? That he might get them all killed? Or maybe worse—imprisoned here, in the 17th century?
She shook with fury. “Put those things back.”
He smiled again. “And do all this for nothing?”
He tried to duck, but he couldn’t, since she had already found him in a half crouch.
She hit him like a linebacker, and knocked him on his already injured tailbone. Pain swept through him, harsh and unrelenting. He couldn’t catch his breath.
She grabbed him by the jaw, fingers behind his ears, and slammed his head against the hard stone floor. Once. Twice. Three times.
He twisted, pain searing through him from his back, then his head, then his back. He wrapped his hands around her wrists and tried to pull her off.
He should buck, but he couldn’t get his legs underneath him. They were bent at an angle and he couldn’t get purchase.
She was going to kill him. This attractive, monomaniacal bone researcher was so mad she was going to slam him to death.
He tried to gasp out an apology, but he couldn’t think clearly enough to put the words together.
He wasn’t sure how to stop her.
He wasn’t sure if he could.
“You’re going to kill him.”
Jeff had yanked her back. He was holding her.
Sweat ran down her face. She was coughing slightly. She had been gripping Thomas’s jaw, her fingers digging so hard into his skin that her hands hurt.
Thomas was still on the ground, looking dazed.
If she said she hadn’t meant to hurt him, she’d be lying. She had never been so angry in her life. He had hurt an innocent man, ruined years of her work, and threatened all of their lives here in a dangerous past, and he had joked about it.
Joked.
Like it was all one big lark.
She was breathing hard. Then she moved toward him again, but Jeff grabbed her.
“No,” he said.
“I’m not going to kill him,” she said.
Instead, she dumped out the bundle, then ripped the linen in half.
Thomas had raised one hand to his forehead, and he was moaning. Either she had injured him badly or he figured she wasn’t going to attack him any longer.
She handed the ripped cloth to Jeff. Then she grabbed Thomas’s hands and pulled them together.
“Tie him as tightly as you can,” she said.
Jeff blinked at her.
“Do it!” she snapped. She wasn’t sure how long she could hold Thomas.
Jeff tied the linen around Thomas’s wrists so tightly that she could see the fabric digging into his skin.
“Now what do we do with him?” Jeff asked.
“Give me a minute,” she said, “and I’ll figure it out.”
When the guards or whoever found him and untied him, he would twist away, grab his little remote and vanish.
He would be gambling that this room would still be in Martin Tower in the future, but it was a small gamble. They usually didn’t change the configuration of an existing Tower.
Besides, anything would be better than staying here.
Neyla picked up the Jewels and put them back. Then she stood up, putting one hand on her own spine.
In the other hand, she held his knife.
She wasn’t going to kill him. She wasn’t that kind of woman. She wasn’t even going to damage his handsome mocking face, although she was still tempted.
He had no idea how much work he was going to cause her. Somehow she had to drag him out of here. And then they were going to have to deal with him in the future.
She had no idea what would come of that.
But first, she had to make everything right.
She handed the knife to Jeff. Then she untied her own bundle, added Thomas’s things to it as she looked for the unauthorized tools he had brought along. Something had gotten him into this building, and he had used something to hurt that guard.
She didn’t see anything that would fit those descriptions in his bundle.
Which meant they were on him.
Smart. He might have had to leave the bundle behind. He clearly planned ahead.
She opened his jacket then ripped open his shirt.
The disk rested against his chest. But that wasn’t what caught her attention.
What caught her attention was everything he had smuggled in. Skeleton key, extra knife, stun gun, and a dark, dingy ring.
She grabbed the ring.
It was heavy, ugly, and old. She rubbed her finger across it, removing layers of dirt. A gigantic sapphire gleamed up at her.
Edward the Confessor’s ring.
But she had seen it in the cupboard.
Gleaming prettily.
Because it came from the 21st century, polished, and shiny. Not because it belonged here.
Because it was paste.
“You son of a bitch,” she said. She turned to the cupboard, grabbed the fake ring, and put the original back.
Then she bent over and grabbed the remote, holding it in her hand.
Thomas looked frightened for the first time. “Don’t,” he said.
“You think I’m going to leave you here?” she asked.
“You can’t,” Jeff said. “He doesn’t fit.”
“Don’t take that,” Thomas said. He wasn’t quite begging. She wasn’t sure if she wanted him to beg. She didn’t want to see him lose all of his dignity.
“Give me one good reason why I shouldn’t,” she said.
His eyes moved back and forth, as he clearly thought of several options and discarded them. Finally, he said, “You’d be sentencing me to death. You’re not that kind of woman.”
“Sentencing you to death,” she mused. “Here, in the Tower of London.”
His cheeks flushed a dark red. She could feel the fear coming off him in waves. He actually believed she might leave him here.
Instead, she let the remote fall back onto his chest.
“Come here, Jeff,” she said. “We’re going to have to carry him out.”
“I can walk,” Thomas said.
“So get up,” she said.
He rocked, moaned, and was about to work his way up when Jeff grabbed an arm, yanking him to his feet.
“We’re not going to let you go anywhere unescorted,” Jeff said.
Neyla took the paste ring and all of the tools, putting them in her bundle. Then she left the remains of Thomas’s bundle. There was no way to hide the fact that he had broken into the cupboard.
But nothing was missing. So if the guard was smart, he could take credit for chasing the robber away.
Lots of ifs.
She took Thomas’s other arm. Then she and Jeff dragged him out of the cupboard room, and back to the stairs.
He wasn’t sure he blamed her. He had destroyed her life’s work.
Damn. He should have escaped. If she had only taken a few minutes longer to reach the cupboard, he probably would have escaped.
If she had been a different kind of woman, he would have asked her to join him. Who could tell if the Confessor’s ring was different? He would have wagered no one had tested that sapphire in hundreds of years. Besides, modern paste sapphires weren’t made of plastic. They were crystals too, just not quite as valuable as the real thing.
But he knew better than to argue. Besides, what could they do to him? When they got back to the 21st century, it would be their word against his. And even if they convinced the folks at Portals that he had tried to steal the Jewels, it didn’t matter. The crime occurred hundreds of years in the past.
No one could prosecute him.
No one would dare.
Or so he told himself as he let them drag him up the stairs, back to the door, and—he hoped—the future.
The others were waiting at the top of the staircase. Benedict looked terrified. Dan just seemed nervous. He kept turning his head, as if expecting someone to attack them at any moment.
But if no one had come when the guard was attacked, then no one was going to come at all. One thing about thick stone walls. They were mostly soundproof.
Dan took Thomas from her. Neither he nor Benedict seemed surprised that they had captured Thomas or that he looked a little roughed up.
They led him through the corridor as if this had been the plan all along. The guard was still prone. But he had raised one hand to his head and he was moaning.
They had to hurry.
Neyla pushed open the doors. The air outside was cooler but smellier.
It was still dark. Somehow she had expected the sun to be coming up. It seemed like she had been in Martin Tower for hours, and it had probably been less than thirty minutes.
She made Jeff extinguish his candle, then the five of them hurried across the grounds. She kept an eye out for the guard who had made his rounds earlier, but she didn’t see him.
When she reached the spot where the team had arrived, she almost told them to get their remotes.
Then she realized that they were feet lower than they had been. They might materialize inside the ground.
For a moment, she felt at a complete loss. The plan had been to find a safe place, figure out the guard schedule, and get out at the right time.
She didn’t have time. She had no idea what the right place was now.
The others stared at her.
Then she realized what she had to do.
She opened the bundle and pulled out the skeleton key she had taken from Thomas.
“We’re going inside,” she said.
They didn’t disagree. Because they knew they had no choice.
It was up several floors, but she had no trouble getting there. The team ran into no guards, no locked doors. The White Tower’s interior looked pretty much the same now as it would centuries in the future.
The others followed her without question, dragging Thomas with them. For once, he had nothing to say. No quips, no barbs, no suggestions. He just let them take him back to the future.
She wasn’t sure she liked this subdued Thomas any more than she liked the arrogant man she had first met. But she wasn’t going to worry about him at the moment.
She led the group up stairs and through dingy corridors to the Chapel of St. John. Under the impressive Norman arches, candles burned on the altar. Votive candles, in memory of someone. The Church of England had picked up a lot of habits from the Catholic Church and continued to practice them, for which she was very grateful.
Because the altar itself looked unchanged to her.
She looked at her group. They were filthy from running through dirty corridors. Thomas’s jaw had marks from her fingertips. Jeff actually had some blood on his face, but whether that was from her or from Thomas, she didn’t know.
“Ready to go home?” she asked.
They nodded.
She would have to untie Thomas so that he could use his remote.
She leaned toward him. “Try anything, and one of us will take that remote and leave you here.”
He looked up at her. “Have a little compassion,” he said. “You’re in a church.”
She grabbed his remote. “I mean it,” she said.
He sighed. “I’ll be a good boy.”
She nodded. Then she untied his hands.
They all grabbed their remotes. As she nodded, they pressed the activation switches.
And everything went dark.
The wind came up, but it didn’t blow hot and cold this time. It blew softly, marking her movement. The smell barely changed either, but maybe she couldn’t smell anything after having been in that stinky place.
Then she stopped moving and stumbled against the altar. Jeff stumbled against her. Dan staggered forward, and Benedict fell onto a chair.
Thomas landed in a heap on the floor beside her. His face had turned white. He really was in terrible shape.
No candles burned. Pews extended in front of her and beyond them, one of the Yeoman Warders peered inside.
Her heart jumped.
Had they been caught? Were they going to be arrested?
Then she realized it didn’t matter.
The worst thing they had done would be to have stayed past closing time. If the remotes had worked properly, they would have arrived here only a second or two later than they left.
In an entirely different part of the Tower.
“We’re closing up,” the Yeoman Warder said in very understandable modern British English. “That includes the gift shop. If you want to buy something for home, I’d suggest leaving now. You’ve got a bit of a walk ahead of you.”
“Thank you,” Neyla said. Her voice sounded wheezy. She was still lightheaded.
The Warder went back into the corridor, his message delivered.
Jeff grabbed Thomas’s arms. Neyla retied his wrists, then leaned against him. “Try anything, and I’ll have you arrested.”
“For what?” he asked.
“Whatever I can think of,” she said, not conceding that he had a good point. What could they do to him? His crime was in the past. Unless he had completed a major identity theft.
Thomas Ayliffe couldn’t be his real name.
They secured him. Then they grouped around him—Jeff and Benedict on each side, Dan behind, using his body to hide Thomas’s tied hands. Neyla stayed a few yards ahead, just in case something came at them.
They didn’t say anything as they trooped down the aisle, out of the chapel, and into the Inner Ward, heading back to the gate.
Heading home.
He wasn’t to talk to anyone outside of the company.
He wasn’t sure if that was ever or just for the duration.
All he did know was that the hospital wanted him here for observation since, they believed, he’d had quite a fall when he was urban free climbing with Dan.
As if Thomas would ever do anything that stupid.
He wasn’t supposed to close his eyes, but he was tired. Tired and disappointed. So close. He’d actually held the Jewels in his hand. How many modern thieves could say that they had touched the Crown Jewels?
Although touching wasn’t nearly enough.
And he wasn’t going to be able to go back to his sponsor and make another attempt.
He had failed. His first big failure.
And he doubted Portals would ever let anyone get that close again.
At least he wasn’t going to jail. Wycroft had told him that much during his short visit here. Thomas wasn’t going to jail because they couldn’t prove identity theft and everything else would be “too incredible for any local magistrate to adjudicate.”
Thank heavens.
So Thomas, once he healed, would be escorted out of the hospital, out of London, and away from any Portals site forever.
Although he had seen enough of their systems to know that forever might not be that long. Since his sponsor still had people inside, and Thomas did know the system.
He wouldn’t get near the Crown Jewels again. At least, not in 1674. And he wasn’t going near Neyla.
But if he remembered right, Henry VIII had sold some of the Jewels to pay for his various wars. Maybe, if Thomas figured out the right way to approach things, he could try again.
Years from now.
If he wanted to put in the work.
Which he really wasn’t sure he did.
She would be going back, after she had a ton of allergy shots, once she figured out when would be a good time. She couldn’t go anywhere near the first of July, thanks to Thomas. That assault on the guard hadn’t made it into the history books and, so far as she could tell, had no impact on history itself. But it would harm her little band if they returned at the wrong moment.
Now, at least, she could wait until Pete was well. She’d have her original team back.
Thank heavens. She wouldn’t have to worry about another Thomas Ayliffe.
She had tried to visit him in the hospital, but Wycroft had cordoned him off. Ayliffe was leaving London as soon as he was able, which angered her.
He would be a free man.
Because they couldn’t prove identity theft. His identification was rock-solid, no matter how much she believed he had made up the name. They couldn’t charge him with corporate espionage, not without divulging a few too many corporate secrets, and they couldn’t charge him with any other crime.
In fact, Wycroft pointed out to Neyla, she was the one who faced legal charges. She had assaulted Ayliffe in front of a witness.
In 1674. Because he had made her completely and utterly furious.
She had expected to learn things while in the past. She just hadn’t expected to learn she was capable of such violence.
It disturbed her less than it probably should have. She should have been appalled. But she had always known that humans had a base nature. She figured people in the past were closer to it than people of her generation.
But she had proven her own assumptions wrong.
Without that base nature, the Tower wouldn’t exist. And she wouldn’t have the bones of Princes to investigate.
Maybe she should thank Ayliffe. He had taught her that the past could be dangerous and unexpected—and so could she.
The TowerCopyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Asimov’s SF Magazine, March, 2010Published by WMG PublishingCover and layout copyright © 2023 by WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Tomas Marek/Dreamstime
The first time I ever heard the saying, “The problems in your writing are the problems in your life,” I was having a conversation with Harlan Ellison about editing. Back when I was editing Pulphouse: The Hardback Magazine, I was feeling my way around editing fiction.
I had run a newsroom and put out a nightly half-hour newscast. Producing a newscast is editing. You assign the stories, gather everything, organize it, and hope to hell it all makes sense. That’s Monday. On Tuesday, you do it all over again.
While 20-something me was very confident and comfortable with telling experienced journalists what to do, I was not comfortable telling fiction writers the same thing. My instincts were good. Ah, hell. My instincts were great. I knew how to edit. I knew what made a good story, from my own writing, but mostly from learning how to verbally tell a story and keep an audience interested.
A radio piece has to catch the ear, not with great writing, but with great storytelling. The tools are different—you use multiple voices (quotes) and sound effects, instead of a lot of narration—but the upshot is the same. You hook the listener and then get them to listen all the way to the end.
Harlan adopted me as an editor pretty early on. He talked to me about editing, usually initiating the discussion with his questions to me, most of the time on the phone.
On that particular day, he called me and at some point asked me what I was working on. I had bought a story from a mutual friend of ours, and I had asked that friend to revise the story to make it shorter.
The revision came in. The friend had cut the story and left the dull parts.
I later learned as an editor to tell people what I thought needed trimming—not by doing the work myself, but by being incredibly specific. I could only trust a writer so far. And then there were the baby writers who would take my suggestions, “fix” the story, and turn that story in to their workshop. The workshop would shred the story, and then the baby writer would send me an unrecognizable draft.
In those cases, I wrote a really pointed letter. I would take the original story (which I kept) and I would do the revisions myself, and send them to the writer, and ask them for their approval.
It usually worked. One or two baby writers withdrew their stories (this, when I was at The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction) because the writer believed their workshop draft was better.
Nope. The workshop draft invariably sucked.
But back to the friend. I had just read the revised manuscript that day, so when Harlan asked me some pointed questions about the editing, I mentioned that our mutual friend had cut the story and left the dull explanation parts.
“Have you ever listened to him talk?” Harlan asked. “It takes him forever to get to the point, only after he has gone through all the shit you don’t want to hear.”
Sidebar: Harlan was a difficult man. He was a hard person to befriend for a variety of reasons. He didn’t suffer fools and he would call you out on your bullshit. He only respected people who called him out on his, but only after arguing with them endlessly about their opinions.
He would also get angry at the littlest things, and his anger was epic. It didn’t scare me, partly because his anger was verbal (at least with women), and I could handle verbal anger. I grew up with it. I have had to learn how to temper my tongue so that I don’t offend people.
Harlan was also very good at seeing through people’s façades. He could find the vulnerable spot, and if he was in a mood, he could press on that spot until it became a painful open wound. He would do that with regularity to people he disliked. He would do it accidentally to people he cared about.
(He often used these powers for good. He could and did help a lot of people because he could clearly see what they needed. People don’t talk about that as much as the painful stuff, because the help was less dramatic and often quite personal.)
Anyway.
When he made that observation about our mutual friend, I paused and thought. The statement was true. Our friend took forever to get to the point. If you spent time with him, you often tuned out the prelude and listened to the meat as it arrived later.
Harlan and I discussed how to fix the story one more time, and then he told me, “Be gentle, though. Remember. The problems in your writing are the problems in your life.”
I had never heard anyone say that so succinctly. Nor had I heard it in context with the work of a very good writer.
I knew it to be true in my own life. I had gone to a writers’ workshop in Taos, New Mexico in 1986. That’s where I met Dean. The workshop was taught by Algis Budrys, Jack Williamson, Gene Wolfe, and Fred Pohl. Those men did not mince words.
They went over a story of mine and got to the heart of what I was trying to say. They also found what blocked that heart. Then one of them—and I’m thinking it was Fred, because he had no filters, he was the most successful of the four of them, and he had more editing experience than all of them combined—told me that I would probably need therapy to solve this particular problem in my writing. (Why don’t I remember who exactly? Because I was shocked down to my core by that conversation.) (After reading this, Dean just confirmed that it was Fred.)
Certainly, Fred said, you’ll need to change how you’re living your life.
The problem? Well, all four of the men put it like this:
I could keep doing what I was doing, and be a mediocre writer who would have some success before my career fell apart. Or I could dig deep, challenge myself, write the stories that meant something to me, and be one of the best writers in the field.
I was (and am) nothing if not ambitious. It angered me to hear the word “mediocre” to describe my work. If there was anything I could do, anything, that would take my writing to the next level, I was going to do it.
That was May. I went home, blew up the life in Wisconsin that I had been slowly dismantling over two years, ran off with Dean to the West Coast, and by August, I was in group therapy in Eugene.
I started with group because I was skeptical about this therapy thing. I even said to my counselor on the first day of individual counseling that I didn’t want to break my writing by all this therapy nonsense. She said that therapy would, if anything, make my art stronger.
She was right.
It was not a quick fix for me as a human being. It was a quicker fix for my writing. I got practiced at going deep into emotions. I learned.
And yes, the problems in my life are reflected in my fiction. Every now and then, someone comments on something I’ve done and makes an observation that actually stings. It stings not because the person is being hurtful, but because I hadn’t realized that 1) I had that particular issue and 2) that the issue showed up repeatedly in my writing.
One more personal example, and then I’ll move on.
Many of you know that I write out of order. I do so for a variety of story reasons—I write better when I am as ignorant as the character about certain events. So I have to write about some characters before they experience the big reveal.
But I don’t think that the writing out of order started because of that. That might be a happy accident.
You see, I’m dyslexic. And I wasn’t diagnosed as a dyslexic until I was nearly thirty. I don’t think about things the way that other people do. My brain literally does not conform to the normal ways of doing things.
Just tonight, I was showing Dean how I had stumbled all over myself at this morning’s Pilates class. I was laughing about it because my instructor wanted to combine a simple box step with some arm movements. I can do a box step, with a lot of concentration. But add the arm movements? And expect me to do these things in coordination?
Nope. It would take me weeks to learn that, and if you put pressure on me after I had learned it (like making me do it in front of a crowd), I would screw up all over again.
Simple, straightforward movements. Simple and straightforward always, always become complex when filtered through my brain. (Yes, psychology students. My dyslexia shows up most strongly in spatial relations, followed by numbers.)
The problems in your writing are the problems in your life.
How does that translate into failure? In a myriad of different ways. Some of those ways are craft, like they were with the friend that Harlan and I had. Our friend’s verbosity often masked his excellent storytelling.
Or as with me early on, choosing the easy way out of any story situation because I was unwilling to dig deep into my characters.
Some of the ways are little more complex. Some writers quit publishing their fiction for fear that people will reject them. It’s easier to self-reject by not publishing anything at all.
Then there are the business aspects. Have trouble with money in real life? Can’t make it from paycheck to paycheck even if you earn hundreds of thousands per year? You won’t be able to handle money management in your writing business either—even if you understand the principles.
Sometimes money is not money. Sometimes money is emotion. Or security. Or something that you do not deserve.
Then there are those of us who were raised in abusive households. We tend to tolerate the abuses of the traditional publishing industry a lot better than someone who was raised in a healthy home. Someone who was raised in a healthy home won’t put up with the kind of microaggressions and lies that are sadly common in the traditional publishing industry. But someone raised by an abusive parent or two, someone who hasn’t had therapy to deal with it, will not even see the traditional publishing industry’s abuse.
Toward the end of my traditional publishing career, I had one editor launch into me with foul language, personal insults, and lacerating comments about my writing. She told me I couldn’t write a simple sentence. She told me how awful I was at both genres I was attempting.
By then, I was an international bestseller and I had won awards in the genres she said I couldn’t write. I’d also had a decade of therapy, and I knew what she was saying was abusive.
I also knew how to handle it.
I hung up while she was still ranting. Then I documented the horrid discussion, and immediately wrote to her boss, withdrawing my work from the company. I sent the letter by email and registered mail.
Within a week, I was no longer published by that company and she—well, she was not fired. She still works there. There’s a Facebook group for writers who are with her at that company, where the writers compare notes and tell each other how to buck up under her abuse.
I know of at least a dozen writers she has driven from the business.
It’s so easy to say that the problems in your writing are the problems in your life. It’s easy for someone else to see the issues.
It’s really, really hard to deal with those problems, because you have to deal with you. The essence of who you are. You have to make a decision: Is it worth changing this aspect of my life to improve my writing?
If the answer is yes, then you have to figure out how to change that aspect of your life. Usually, you can’t do it alone. Usually, you will need professional help.
Here’s the thing about therapy, folks. You have to commit to the work. The work is not easy.
I’m not talking about getting medicated either. When I discuss therapy, I’m discussing talk therapy. Working with someone else to have an outside perspective on you and your issues, and then figuring out a way to either resolve those issues…or, just as important, accept those issues.
Some things you might not want to change. And if that’s the case, and they’re getting in the way of your writing or your business, you have to figure out a way around them.
Or you take a step back. Writing might not be a career for you. Owning a business might not be something you can do, given the issue that you have.
For therapy to work, you have to be willing to take a fearless personal inventory. You have to be willing to admit that you have flaws and that some of those flaws get in the way of what you want to do with your life.
You have to commit to making changes.
It’s hard and it’s slow and it’s not for everyone.
Harlan, who first codified that saying for me, knew it. I was at his house one afternoon when he received a letter from some asshole who was deliberately goading him.
It was well known in the sf field that if you poked Harlan just right, he would launch into a rant and try to verbally destroy you. It was as if there was a button on the side of his head that, when pushed, would send him into an uncontrollable rage.
Harlan read the letter, and turned bright red. Then he picked up the phone. I put my hand on his arm.
“You know,” I said, “that’s what he wants. It’s a badge of honor to some of this dweebles to have you yell at them. He might even record it.”
Harlan looked at me. “I know,” he said.
“Then don’t do it,” I said. “If you don’t give in, people will stop goading you.”
“I know that too,” he said.
“So why do it?” I asked.
“Because,” he said, “if I don’t do it, I’ll obsess about it for weeks.”
I backed off after that. I might have the courage to tell you folks to get therapy in an impersonal blog, but saying that to someone’s face is a bridge too far for me. I’ve said that to a few people in the past, none of whom took it very well.
Now, I just back away or, if the conversation goes that way, I make a very gentle suggestion: Have you considered therapy?
Usually that suggestion gets ignored. Often the response is rage. And really, it’s none of my business.
Just like it’s not my business whether or not you succeed as a writer, or as a business person.
Ultimately, your future is in your hands. We all choose how we want to live our lives. Some people don’t approve of how we live.
And really, who cares what they think? Who cares what I might think about your life? My opinion is mine, but your life is yours to live in a way that’s best for you.
Over the years, A lot of people had tried to talk me out of staying in the life and the relationship that I would blow up after the New Mexico workshop. From one of my high school teachers to one of my sisters to my very best friend in the entire world, person after person tried to tell me that I was making a mistake when I chose (and stayed with) my first husband.
Which only made me double-down on the mistake.
I was ready to hear Fred’s advice at Taos. Maybe I heard it because I was ready, or maybe I heard it because he tied it to my writing. Or maybe I heard it because Jack Williamson, that sweet, gentle man, reinforced the comment later.
They made the comment. I’m sure they made similar comments to other writers over the years. I have no idea what happened to those other writers. I do know that I took that comment and ran with it. Literally ran to another state and a new life—and launched into a journey to improve my writing and mental health.
I know how tough this one is. I also know that each and every writer struggles with it. And I know that we all have things we refuse to change, even if it would improve our lives tremendously.
Because it’s our choice. And our life.
Some of these choices will equal failure for our writing dreams. I think whether or not we make changes will depend on the real importance of those writing dreams.
For me, those dreams were everything.
For others that I know, the dreams are secondary to whatever it is they’re hanging onto.
To them, pursuing the dream is not worth the effort of a life change. And believe me, it is an effort.
But I’m in a much better, much happier place than I would have been if I hadn’t embarked on this journey.
And…oh. I have a writing career. And even more writing dreams.
I took a risk. But the risk paid off.
Tremendously.
This weekly blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynrusch to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: The Problems In Your Writing Are The Problems In Your Life,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © Can Stock Photo / 4774344sean
Fifteen dragons dead in less than a century.
Rumaad, a different kind of dragon, collects information about the killings the way some dragons collect jewels. Perfectly suited to see the differences in the latest crime scene, he investigates the murder of a dragon he knows all too well.
What he sees convinces him something changed in his world—and not for the best.
“Dragon Slayer,” by World Fantasy Award-winning author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story is also available in ebook through various online retailers here.
Dragon SlayerKristine Kathryn RuschFifteen dead in less than a century, and not one of them by natural causes. The corpses were always found in some stage of mistreatment, headless being the most common. Occasionally, though, fangs would disappear, and sometimes the right foreleg. Or a wing. And once, just once, the tail.
I collected information on the killings just like I collected sapphires. One corner of my lair was strewn with various death relics—a broadsword, a gauntlet, even a lock of hair found between a victim’s back claws.
Something had changed among the humans, something which now made them deadly to dragons.
Fifteen dead in one hundred years was some kind of record. If the killings continued at that rate, we would be extinct within a millennium. Unlike most animals, we didn’t breed whenever we glanced at each other. We had rituals, timing, and our own natural infertility working against us.
The infertility concerned the Lair Fathers the most, but it didn’t bother me much. It seems logical, if you examine it. Impregnation takes time—and there’s often a year between that event and the laying of the egg.
The lairs themselves are the other problem. We’re not social creatures; we don’t like to live too close together. Only a few caves are large enough to accommodate one of us. If we wanted to dwell in the same area, we’d have to suffer through rock outcroppings or move into abandoned human dwellings—the large stone kind with towers, poorly built because they crumble after a century or two of neglect.
Still, despite our distance and our solitude, we have our communities, rituals, and ceremonies. Every twenty years, the Lair Fathers hold the governing council. Mostly it is an excuse for everyone in the Five Regions to assemble, catch up on the news, maybe do a little bargaining. But sometimes we have serious business, like the time Vascan’s youngest took to looting to increase his hoard.
The youngling was banished to the hinterlands, but apparently didn’t survive the trek. The Lair Fathers were called in to look at that corpse, but it was too decayed to determine cause of death. The child could have died of exposure, and been torn apart by animals. Or he could have been murdered and mutilated, like the others.
There was no real way to tell, not without a bit of hair between the claws or a broadsword broken off in the hide.
Failure to determine cause of death didn’t make the situation any less of a tragedy, though. The Lair Fathers had to reconsider the punishments they’d established throughout the regions.
The theory being, of course, that punishment didn’t teach our people things if no one survived the lessons.
***We were heading into Nae The Loch’s Centennial Trade Show and Swap Meet when news of the sixteenth victim hit. Most of us were already in flight—too late to cancel plans even if we’d wanted to.
I didn’t want to. I was verging on my first half-millennium, and I was heading to Nae The Loch with more than bargaining on my mind. For the past decade or more, I’d been thinking of adding an egg or two to my stash, and I finally had a large enough hoard to impress a mate.
Females are particular about the places they stash their eggs, a fact I’ve never understood. Females are never involved with the raising of the hatchlings, preferring to move off to new venues long before the little ones appear. Apparently there is some biological imperative, however, something that makes these flighty creatures particular about egg storage.
Females rarely pick a young male with a small hoard. They seem to prefer males with some experience behind them, and a stash the size of a small mountain.
My father used to say it was because the eggs had to cool under the hoard before hatching—and the bigger the hoard, the safer the egg. But I was never sure of that.
After all, females left eggs all over the countryside. In their fecund period—which can last as long as two millennia—healthy females can drop as many as one hundred eggs, always leaving them in pairs. Rarely do both eggs hatch, and sometimes neither do, but that doesn’t negate the sheer irresponsibility of it all.
If females had to feather their nests with food as well as gold, they might not be so quick to abandon their communities.
But to be honest, there isn’t a male among us who doesn’t envy the female her freedom. All of us wish we could spend our lives exploring the world; we just don’t have the wingspan or the stamina to do so.
Besides, we are the only ones who can breathe fire. Until they develop wings of their own, hatchlings require cooked food. It isn’t until adolescence that a dragon acquires the ability to eat raw meat without causing serious illness or death.
Most males never acquire a taste for raw food. We prefer to cook our own. Females haven’t the time or patience for it. A few of my friends, in their early courting years, tried to seduce a female with a carefully prepared meal of cooked meat, only to have the female turn away in disgust.
I wasn’t planning to make that mistake at Nae The Loch. I hoped for a quick courtship, a few months of passion, and then solitude. I wasn’t even going to follow the serial seduction plan used by most males so that they would have an egg hoard the size of their jewel hoard. I wanted to take time with my children, and bring one set to adolescence before I risked having another.
Nae The Loch was a good three days flight from my home in Montagneux. Despite the long and difficult flight, I enjoyed Nae The Loch as much as the rest of my people did.
The site was the most protected in the Five Regions. The lake existed inside the highest mountain peak known to dragon. The peak had once been pointed, but several millennia back, steam and pressure broke the peak open, sending boiling lava down the mountainside.
The lava cooled, reinforcing the strength of the exterior mountain, but the inside became something else. Gradually, a lake formed inside the crater. Cool, and deep, and blue—deeper than any lake we had ever encountered—the lake became a courtship destination long before the local males decided to hold the Centennial Swap Meet.
Even though Nae The Loch had a lot of flat land deep within the crater (all of it surrounding the lake), no males could live there. The caves ringing the lake were too small for a proper hoard, but they provided good accommodation for a summer’s long trading festival.
Females often stayed in Nae The Loch on their way to other destinations. Rather than drive the females from the area, the Swap Meet brought them. It made meeting males easier, and often prevented difficult encounters on the male’s home territory. Too many males fell in love with their mates, and tried to coerce them into staying.
Some females were known to stay for as many as five years. But all were gone long before the eggs began to crack, leaving some males broken-hearted and incapable of proper hatchling care.
As usual, my arrival at Nae The Loch left me breathless, and not just because I rarely flew to such heights. My body could not take more than three days’ flight. My wings always ached during the first week of the Swap Meet.
Still, I enjoyed the view as I dove into the crater. Nae The Loch stretched before me as far as I could see. In the center, the lake, a perfect reflection of the pale blue sky. Around it, the black land, covered with flat-top rocks brought centuries ago to serve as tables.
Even from my height, I could see the glitter of gold, the flash of diamonds as the sun struck them. Bits of hoards, no longer wanted, brought for upgrading. I had a few rubies stuck in my pouch. Not a lot, because I couldn’t afford much.
At the farthest end of the Swap Meet was the area that interested me. The non-glittery collectibles—a few hand lettered books (I particularly fancied those done in gold leaf); portraits of humans, often framed in gold; and instruments—lutes, pipes, and horns. I fancied a harp one day. At a Swap Meet in La Mer some fifty years before, I had seen one whose frame had been made of gold leaf and whose strings were done in a material strong enough to withstand a small dragon’s claws.
Dragons circled the flat area on the longest side of the lake, waiting for their turn to land. All flew at low altitudes so that they couldn’t be seen over the mountain peaks.
I joined the throng, bobbing and weaving on the air currents, and trying not to be overwhelmed by the sheer number of my fellows. It sometimes took me as long as a week to be able to handle the crowds, but once I became used to them, I was able to stay for months at a time.
Fortunately, my stash was well hidden, my cave guarded by traps as well as some spells purchased centuries ago from wandering unicorns. I’d allowed nearby vegetation to overgrow the entrance. No one could see the cave but me.
The air up here was thinner, and I had been breathless when I had arrived. I was wheezing after several turns, and I wasn’t the only one. The older, heavier males also seemed to have trouble keeping themselves aloft.
One, a grizzled male whose scales had gone from youth’s green-gold to age’s burnished copper, kept swerving across my flight path. I had to veer sideways twice to avoid hitting him. Finally, his right front claw hooked onto my tail. He didn’t pierce the skin, but I lost my balance and would have toppled if two other older males hadn’t caught my forearms and held me steady.
“Rumaad?” one of the males said.
I looked up, stunned. I had never been recognized at one of these things before. Most of my friends stayed away, tending their eggs. I was the last of among my peers to think of finding his first mate.
“Yes?” I said, trying not to let my surprise show. Still, I couldn’t control the nervous plume of flame that emerged from my left nostril. “Can I be of service?”
“Actually, you can.” The dragon who had caught my tail had managed to stop in front of me. He managed a perfect mid-air hover, something few males could accomplish. What had originally seemed like out of control flying must have been his attempts to catch my attention.
I couldn’t hover. The males beside me kept me suspended, so that I wouldn’t fall to the ground.
“I’m Avagas,” the old male said. “I hear you have a stash from the murders.”
Avagas. One of the Lair Fathers, a former leader of the Regional Council, and leader of the Rebellion that —three millennia ago— had made the Five Regions the most powerful nation on the Four Continents.
I was embarrassed that he’d heard of my unorthodox collection. I held my breath, trying to hide my shame, but tendrils of smoke slipped between my back teeth anyway.
“I’m not going to chastise you, boy.” Avagas sounded faintly amused. “I think your knowledge might be useful.”
I took a small breath. His words surprised me. “How?”
“You’ve heard of the sixteenth victim?”
I had heard at my usual daytime rest stop in the Reed Marsh. The Reed Marsh was deep enough to allow a dragon to submerge himself in mud as protection from the sun, and wide enough to keep his presence a secret from the smaller mammals who would carry the news to the humans.
Four other dragons had chosen the Marsh as their rest stop that day and, as twilight fell and we grew restless, one of the travelers had mentioned the newest death.
“The murder occurred near here. We would like to take you to the body, see what you think of this latest death.”
I glanced at the ground below me. I wanted nothing more than to land, lumber into the cave I had reserved at the previous Nae The Loch and nest for a day or two.
But one did not say no to the Lair Fathers, especially one as famous as Avagas.
“I do not know how I can help you,” I said.
“You have seen the other bodies, have you not?”
I had no idea how he learned of that. I had visited the other corpses long after the Lair Fathers finished their investigations. The other corpses had been left, according to Five Regions custom, until scavengers had picked the bones clean and a young male, too young to have known the victim, took over the lair.
The hoard would have been scavenged too, but only by family and close friends. By the time I had seen most of the corpses, the only things remaining in their stashes were the imprints the items left in the ground.
“I’ve seen most of the bodies,” I said, because I knew better than to lie. “The early ones were already scattered when I developed my interest.”
I didn’t tell him though that it was at the early sites where I found the most interesting items—a rusted scabbard picked clean of jewels; rings of metal which I later learned were part of something the humans called chain mail; and a long thin needle coated in ichor.
“Good,” Avagas said. “You will come, then?”
“May I rest first?” The shame that had receded rose again. I was tired and this gray eminence, who had lived six times as long as I had, showed no exhaustion at all.
“We shall rest near the corpse,” he said. “Come along.”
He spun, leaving his place in the landing line, and flew up the cliff face. His companions let go of me, and I bobbled for a moment, before my wings caught the breeze.
It was easier to move forward than it was to try to hover. I managed to keep up with the trio only because one of them would wait for me at each turn.
We went through three passes, all of them part of the peaks that formed Nae The Loch. The passes were narrow and snow-filled, but the chill air felt good to my burning lungs. The flames, which I never controlled well when I was exhausted, shot out unexpectedly twice, once melting snow on the ground below, and once causing a tiny avalanche that tumbled all the way down the mountainside.
From this height, the corpse was easy to spot. It sprawled at tree line, forelegs spread, and tail pointed downhill. The head tilted backwards at an unnatural angle, the unmistakable sign of a broken neck.
As we got closer to the victim, I realized the corpse was unusually large for a male. Then we circled above, and the chill air cooled all the flames in my throat.
The corpse wasn’t male at all. It had the silver and black scales of a female in her prime.
Avagas circled and landed on a flat rock far from the corpse. His companions landed beside him, leaving no room for me.
I wasn’t going to land beside the corpse. The body rested on snow, and the ground beneath sloped steeply downward. As tired as I was, I might topple, scale over tail, to the forest below.
Instead, I found a second flat rock, some distance from Avagas. I landed harder than I expected, my wings giving out on the descent. I was very out of shape and much too tired. I extended my tongue, stuck the fork into the nearby snow, and shoveled a pile into my mouth.
Cool, refreshing, and much needed. I shoveled another mouthful inside, and felt some of my energy return.
The chill of the mountainside felt good against my scales. I had been overheating as well as exhausting myself. I clambered across the snow, glad that it wasn’t that deep here. Otherwise, I would have had to use my wings to keep my weight off the snow, and I didn’t think they were up to the task.
I folded them against my back and lumbered toward the corpse.
It looked even bigger up close. Females still scared me—their sheer size was imposing—almost twice the size of males. At first, I stayed back, studying the scene.
Avagas and his companions approached, using their wings to keep themselves slightly above the snow, probably so that the cold wetness wouldn’t seep between their claws.
“I told you to look,” he called to me while they were still a distance away.
“I am looking,” I said. “Stay behind me.”
“I do not understand. Why—?”
“Do you want me to find out what happened?”
“We want you to find out how the human reached this height, how close it came to Nae The Loch, and whether or not our most secret place is in danger,” Avagas said. “How much time could that take?”
His demands did not surprise me, although he had not stated them before. We had all had the unspoken fear that the humans had found Nae The Loch. It had even been part of the discussion at the Reed Marsh.
“It could take a great deal of time,” I said, even though I had never done anything like this before. I had a hunch, though, that the best way to understand what had happened was to study the details.
“What would you have us do?” Avagas asked.
I swiveled my head, trying not to show my surprise. I did not expect him to ask me for instructions.
If I had been with my birth-year companions, I would have given a different answer—a more strident one, which did not take their feelings into account. But, for all his interest, Avagas was a Lair Father. I could not order him about like an equal.
“Perhaps,” I said, “it would be best if your companions brought us the evening meal. I have been flying all day, and I’m sure this crisis has occupied you. We shall be here for some time. Nourishment would be advised.”
Avagas waved a claw, not even bothering to repeat my words. The other two males flew off.
“And me?” Avagas asked.
“Observe,” I said. “Between the two of us, we might decipher what happened here.”
The snow around the corpse was littered with small holes. The corpse had hit hard, sending ice chunks and debris into the air. They landed in a splatter pattern around the body.
“Your caution amazes me,” Avagas said. “I would simply like to find the human source of our troubles and slay him before he makes our situation worse.”
His words startled me away from my examination. Did he know nothing of humans? “It is not one human who has been killing our people. Humans live six or seven decades at most. Toward the end, they are frail creatures, not even worthy of a hatchling snack.”
His head tilted, revealing the tender underside of his jaw line. “Then what is this killing? I cannot believe it accidental.”
“It is not. I believe the humans have a ritual, which requires proof of dragon slaying,” I said. “Perhaps the Lair Fathers should capture a young human and quiz him about their customs.”
“We cannot speak to those beasts,” Avagas said. “They do not know the holy tongue.”
“But they have their own tongue. It is fine and rich. I’m sure one of us speaks it.”
“Besides you?” Avagas swiveled his head back so that he stared at the corpse.
“I do not speak it,” I said, trying not to let him hear the regret in my voice. I often wished I had spoken it, so that I would understand the texts I’d found, the songs I’d heard. “But there are traders at the Swap Meet who do.”
Avagas sighed, as if speaking the human tongue were a thing beneath dragons. He did not say another word, and I flattered myself that he was considering the suggestion.
I examined each hole in the snow, realizing in short order that my first assumption about them had been right. I waddled closer to the corpse until I stood over it.
Because the death had been a recent one, and because the temperature on this mountainside was chill, the corpse had been preserved as if in life. Her eyes were closed and if one ignored the angle of her head, it would appear as if she had just fallen asleep in the snow.
She had been a magnificent creature. She had a long, narrow snout, and sharp teeth that rose above her upper lip. Her talons were scraped to fine points, and the ridges along her spine nearly hid a band of well-developed muscle that ran along her ribcage.
Her wings were still partly extended. They were thin as flower petals and probably were that soft to the touch. The silver-black of her scales had a touch of green, making them seem almost iridescent. Her tail was thick and powerful, the barb on the end intact and free of blood.
She had not attacked anyone.
I stepped closer, careful where I put my hind feet. I knew that my tail would obliterate any marks in the snow, and I made certain I examined them before I destroyed them.
So far the marks had told me little.
Avagas watched me, as if I were the curiosity, not the dead female. When I reached the weapons embedded in her side, he finally sighed, a bit of flame leaking through his nose.
Apparently I had finally reached the part of the body he had wanted me to see.
Three projectile weapons lodged in her back flank. The weapons were short and stubby, feathered on the ends. I had seen their like before, often littered around lairs. Humans who hunted dragons with these weapons—which they called arrows—often became lunch.
There were longer versions of the arrow, more effective versions—some as tall as the human who wielded them. These weapons, called spears, could slip beneath scales, go between ribs, and find a dragon’s heart.
The arrows, small as they were, rarely pierced skin.
The tips of these arrows had gotten caught between the larger scales of the female’s back. I doubted she even felt them. The feathers were wind-torn and had been sheered off one of the weapons.
She’d been carrying the arrows for some time. No one had bothered to tell her of them or help her remove them. Someone probably would have noticed at Nae The Loch, and helped her there.
It might have been the beginning of a beautiful courtship.
“Human weapons,” Avagas said. “They are more destructive than we thought.”
“These weapons could not have disturbed her flight,” I said. “She took them on the ground. Notice the angle of entry. Whoever shot them hit her from above, not below.”
Avagas crept beside me. I glanced at the snow in his path, and saw nothing that would be disturbed by his presence.
“I had not thought of that,” he muttered. “Yet she has clearly fallen from the sky.”
“Something brought her down,” I said. “I have a theory, but I am unwilling to discuss it until I examine her more closely.”
I walked around the corpse. Mine were the only footprints near the body. The tiny holes from the dirt and ice surrounded the corpse, adding to my theory that she had dropped mid-flight.
Then I realized why that disturbed me. A dragon whose flight was broken did not drop like a stone from the air. A dragon, particularly one with a wingspan as magnificent as this female’s, would glide until she saw a proper spot, and land on it.
Even if she were forced to land in a place like this, she would have brought herself in, hind feet first, scraping to slow her approach if she had to, tail as ballast, until she came to a stop.
Instead, she had landed on her belly like a flopping fish.
I walked around her other side. Finally, I saw fresh damage. Many of her scales had been ripped off. Slashes cut deep into her flesh, and blood stained the remaining scales, covering their lovely silver-green finish.
I followed the twisted neck to the head and peered at it again. She had a white patch of scales between her ear bumps. I’d seen a patch like that once before, a hundred years ago.
She’d been at Nae The Loch both times I’d been here, each time prowling for a mate. Her name was Paeche. The last time I’d seen her, she’d bent her head toward me, butted me in the side, and said, I like a male whose neck still bears a touch of red. Have you mated yet, youngling? Would you like to learn the ways of dragons?
Her approach had terrified me, and I had moved away from her, to the amusement of the traders at their tables. One of the traders later confided in me that Paeche liked her males young and biddable, and it was best that I had not become involved with her, because I would expect an attachment, and she often left the pairing without laying a single egg.
It had been that moment with her that had put me off my quest for a mate at the last Nae The Loch, convincing me that I still had much to learn about females. That did not stop my friends from becoming her conquests. Two of my birth-year companions had heeded her invitation, only to become locked in a struggle over mating rights.
She left both of them for a male I had not met, a son of one of the table traders, who abandoned the Swap Meet altogether and took her to his lair.
“What do you see?” Avagas asked. Apparently my analysis of the human weapons had impressed him. He seemed to have more patience than he’d had earlier.
I did not tell him I recognized the female. I made myself look away from the white patch. More scrapes ran along the side and back of her skull. The scrapes were deep, and at the edges, puncture marks.
Four of them, as I had expected.
Avagas’ companions flew overhead, their wings whistling in the wind. In their foreclaws, they each carried an iron container. The meal that I had requested.
They flew past, and Avagas headed toward them. He probably expected me to follow, but I was unwilling.
The light was dimming, and I wanted to see one last thing before the sun set over the mountain peaks. I peered closely at the scales running along the right side of Paeche’s face.
Scorch marks ran down the center of her shapely snout. I didn’t have to sniff them to know they would smell faintly of sulfur.
I sat down in the snow, feeling even more tired than I had when I’d arrived.
Humans did not slay this dragon. Instead, she had been murdered by one of our own.
***Avagas insisted on a full explanation of my theory. We sat around the fire we’d started with the wood the companions had gathered, and snacked from the iron containers. Raw meat—mostly animal flesh—had been piled inside. We each speared a piece with our claws, charred it with our own breath, and ate long into the night.
The corpse had given up details so clear that I could almost imagine the murder.
Whoever had attacked Paeche had known her flight path and had waited for her on a nearby peak. I knew that if we flew the surrounding peaks at dawn, we’d find the imprint of a small dragon’s tail and hindquarters in the otherwise pristine snow.
Paeche’s killer had waited for her, and when he saw her, he crouched until she passed. Then he flew after her.
He was small enough to slip between her wings, but the strategy didn’t work as well as he thought. She must have caught him, making him tumble away from her. As he spun in the air, his back claws dug into her side, ripping it open, and angering her.
She turned on him, but he surprised her with a blast of fire across the snout.
As she pawed at her eyes, perhaps trying to protect them from the flames, he flew above her, and grabbed her skull with his forelegs, puncturing through the scales and skin with his claws.
Either she turned or he yanked or both. Ultimately, it did not matter. The movement—its suddenness and ferocity—killed her.
She dropped like a stone from the sky, and he fled—whether in fear or triumph, I could not tell.
After my fifth retelling in which I explained how her impact had caused the snow to rain around her corpse all at the same time, after I had again detailed the difference between fresh wounds and older ones, after I had explained how arrows (as opposed to their larger cousins, spears) could not kill a female dragon, Avagas was finally satisfied with my interpretation.
We both knew he would investigate for himself come dawn, but that did not disturb me. In his place, I would have done the same.
What disturbed me, and what I did not say, was that we had no punishments for dragon-upon-dragon slayings. Such things were unheard of. Because we were solitary creatures who rarely interacted, we did not solve our differences through killings.
Certainly, we neglected our eggs at times, but eggs were not hatchlings. Once a hatchling took its first breath, it became a dragon, subject to all the respect accorded to one of our kind.
Respect Paeche had not.
***I woke before dawn to find Avagas stoking the fire with more wood, then blasting it into a bonfire with a single breath of flame. His eyes were red-rimmed, his scales even grayer than they had seemed in the daylight.
He had not slept at all. It was clear this matter disturbed him as much as it disturbed me.
His companions snored, curled around the iron containers as if they were a stash instead of boxes that had to be returned to some trading table.
Sleeping in the snow left me sluggish. Cold had never agreed with me. I did not appreciate the slower heart rate, and the feeling that, if I stayed but a day or two longer, I would become a block of ice.
I sat up, and Avagas handed me a piece of meat so charred that it crunched as I ate it. I washed it down with some melted snow.
When he finally spoke, it was with weary resignation. “Nothing in your details gives us any hint as to who did this. All we know is that our culprit is male.”
I licked the last of the burned meat off my claws, considering my response. If I told him what I had dreamed of, we would move from the realm of certainty to the realm of conjecture. I was not certain that conjecture was appropriate.
He sent another blast of flame at the fire, although it did not need stoking.
“I almost wish it had been a human after all,” he said softly. “At least then, I would know what to do.”
He was right. Our options in that case were plentiful. We could defend Nae The Loch with young males or abandon the site altogether. If neither of those plans satisfied the Lair Fathers and the rest of the Five Regions, we might terrorize the humans, setting fire to nearby cities and driving them from the area.
Driving humans away did not last, but the humans who would return to a settlement decades later did not seem to be related to the group who had fled there. Such an action would have a good chance of preserving Nae The Loch.
“What of the other Lair Fathers?” I asked. “Perhaps they—?”
“No.” Avagas’ tone was pained. “I am one of the few who remembers the Rebellion. It is the last time that dragon turned on dragon.”
“That we know of.”
He swiveled his head toward me. “What do you mean?”
I could not look at him as I spoke. “For the most part, we live alone and die alone. Often our corpses are not discovered for decades. Who is to say that a dragon was murdered? It cannot be proven after so long a time. We were fortunate to find this female so quickly after her death—and even more fortunate that we investigated. If we had not, we might have thought that she had landed wrong, breaking her neck, or—if enough time had passed—we might have found only the tips of the human weapons, and concluded that a human had killed her after all.”
Smoke curled from his nostrils. Avagas looked as if he wanted to blast the fire again, but he could not. There wasn’t enough wood left to take the brunt of the flames. He would risk burning his sleeping friends.
“So the fifteen—”
“May have died at human hands,” I said.
“May.” A small puff of smoke followed the word out of his mouth.
“I have often thought it curious that creatures who wear armor that clanks and carry weapons that can rarely slice through our scales have managed to slay fifteen of us,” I said.
Avagas bowed his head.
He did not seem to want to hear what I had to say, but now that I had started, I had to continue. “I do know that at least one of the fifteen died from a human-inflicted wound. I once found a needle covered in ichor.”
Ichor was only found in a dragon’s eye. An eye without ichor was concave, and the dragon blind.
“I believe a human found his victim napping, crept on top of the victim’s head and pierced his eye before the victim even realized he was under attack. A dragon in such pain would thrash, but not be able to harm something so small, clinging to his skull.”
Avagas wrapped his tail around his hindquarters, head still down, obviously listening.
“It would take little to blind the other eye, and then the dragon would be helpless. A human in such a position could find the tender spot beneath the jaw, shove a sword into it, severing the fire pipes and the lungs. It would take time, but in that circumstance, any one of us would die.”
“But what of the others? The mutilations? We had always thought they were caused by humans.” Avagas spoke so softly I could barely hear him above the snores.
“So they were.” The cold had gotten worse. I leaned closer to the fire. “But there is no way to know when these mutilations occurred. Perhaps they occurred long after death, and the human returned to his tribe, regaling them with his exploits when in truth all he had done was slice a part from a corpse.”
“Your theories make sense.” Avagas shuddered. “I do not like them.”
This, then, was my chance to discuss the last one. Still, I hesitated, knowing if I did, all that we understood about dragon custom would change.
“Then let me give you one more,” I said.
He closed his eyes, as if he did not want to hear. Then he sighed, and opened them. “Speak.”
“This is not a common path to Nae The Loch. I doubt many males travel this distance. There is little food in the snow and there are no obvious resting areas. Females may go this route, but in this case, we must not concern ourselves with females.”
The snoring stopped, and so did I. Then the nearest companion huddled closer to his iron chest, and let out a whistling breath. The other companion grunted. Their snores rose in harmony once again.
I lowered my voice. “If the male who first reported seeing her corpse is also a male who has mated with her, then you will probably have your killer.”
“Why?” Avagas asked.
“He would know her flight path, and he would—”
“I meant,” Avagas said, “what would cause anyone to attack a female? Let us forget that she is larger and more powerful. Females are not a permanent part of our lives. There is no reason to destroy them.”
“Males get irrational about their mates,” I said. “And Paeche was known for consummating but rarely completing the cycle. This killer had the advantage. He had surprise on his side. Yet he chose to burn her face instead diving beneath her and going for the tender spot.”
“And this has given you a theory?”
I poked the fire with one claw. “I believe that our killer was trying to get her to return to his lair, to finish something they had begun a century ago. He did not mean to kill her. Instead, he meant to use flame to force her to fly away with him.”
“For that to work,” Avagas said, “he would have to have a lair near here.”
“And not many do,” I said. “It would seem that you have but to look through Nae The Loch. The killer should not be hard to find.”
***And indeed, he was not. As I suspected, the killer was the trader’s son who had lured Paeche to his lair at the last Swap Meet. She left while he slept one night, without a word. There were no eggs, nothing to remember her by, except the humiliation of an improperly completed mating.
He had a century to plan how to get her to return.
When confronted, he confessed to the murder. It had happened as I had imagined it—an accident in the midst of a badly made plan.
The Lair Fathers are debating his punishment now. Some want to reinstate banishment. Others disagree, believing it is not harsh enough. A few have suggested leaving him to the females.
Throughout this all, he has been imprisoned in a shallow cave at the mouth of Nae The Loch, guarded by males with more fire power than the rest of us combined.
What becomes of him does not concern me. I am not a Lair Father, and probably not destined to be one.
My concerns are new, things I had never considered before. And because of them, I find myself in a strange position.
My collection of relics from the fifteen deaths, once considered esoteric and slightly odd, has made me famous in the Five Regions. There is talk that I should investigate all new deaths as soon as we learn of them.
I do not like this idea. It requires travel, and I know of no way it will help me improve my own stash. And I need to concentrate on my hoard since I did not find a mate at Nae The Loch.
Indeed, the females abandoned the place when they learned of the murders. There is talk that the females will not return to the Swap Meet. Instead, they will flock to other festivals, ones in less remote locations.
Because of one male’s actions, females now view all of us with suspicion.
Still, I think back to that moment on the snow-covered mountainside, as I realized the corpse left me a message about her death.
All males collect. Our hoards are what separate us from each other. Anyone can find sapphires or diamonds. Most of us have, at one point or another, raided human dwellings for gold.
But I am the only dragon in recorded history—male or female—who has collected information and, more to the point, the only one who has found value in it.
I like that distinction. But the distinction also disturbs me. Because, for my collection to maintain its value, the information must remain useful.
I am not certain I want to read corpses. I do not think I will like what they tell me.
I have reviewed my collection, looked over the items found at the fifteen death sites. Only the needle contains a substance from a dragon’s body.
The other items carry human blood or bones too tiny to be dragon. It seems to me that the humans died at the whims of a dragon, as they always have, and only once was it the other way around.
Which means that fourteen male dragons died before their time.
We are large creatures, with no natural predators. We should all die of ill health or old age. Yet fourteen of us were murdered—in the space of a very short time.
Something has changed in the past century. Initially, we thought it was the humans.
Now we know it is not.
What frightens me the most about this is that the details show me one other thing, something I have confided in no one else.
It is true that the fourteen died at another dragon’s hand. However, I do not believe that a single dragon committed the killings.
I believe we as a species have changed. And it is clear that change could doom us all.
Dragon SlayerCopyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in German as “Ein Fall für Rumaad,” Feueratem: Das Grosse Drachen-Lesebuch, edited by Michael Nagula, Knaur, 2003Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2023 by WMG PublishingCover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Ulrich Willmünder/Dreamstime
In some ways, 2020 and 2021 were straightforward years. 2020 was a long scream of a year, one in which we all were trying to survive against a tiny unseen foe. We got vaccines in 2021, and while that eased some of the worry, it didn’t make the worry go away. We were still a group of humans, trying to figure out how to move forward.
But, by 2022, we were all moving in different directions, just like we had in 2019 and almost every other year of our lifetimes. Those long screams of a year—we hadn’t really experienced them, although my parents (your grandparents, probably), had. World War II was truly a world war, something that impacted the entire globe.
Everyone had their individual stories, but they also had the same crisis looming over them. We just left one of those.
And before someone (again) informs me that the pandemic isn’t over, let me say this. The pandemic phase is over, at least in the West. China is going through absolute hell right now. I know that hundreds of people in the U.S. are dying each week, all of them loved and cherished by someone.
But the era of lockdowns and moving in lockstep is over. Covid will be part of our lives forever, and it’s time we figure out how to live with it. A group of us just dealt with it these past few months. Vegas friends got Covid (at different times, and yes, they were fully vaccinated—but this new variant is a wily thing). Our most recent in-person workshop at the beginning of January had six people cancel in the ten days before, all due to Covid.
We ask that everyone who comes to the in-person workshops have their full complement of vaccines. At that workshop, which had two immunocompromised individuals, we also masked up.
Masking up…it’s feeling normal now. I still remember watching a Chinese student at UNLV make her way through the cafeteria in late January of 2020. She was wearing a mask and I wondered why she was so paranoid. Jeez, was I stupid…and was I about to learn how things can change in an instant.
2022 was not about instant change. It was, in some ways, about gradual recovery. It was filled with lurches and starts and stops. I got sick twice. The first was a severe flare-up of my chronic illness. I got the sense that it was laughing at me: Forgot about me? Well, here I am! Most of June, lost.
Then I contracted a virulent cold at 20Books or around 20Books or the week of 20Books. Another two weeks down.
The first illness was extremely discouraging. It felt like I had failed somehow, and in some ways, I had. I had tried a new supplement on the advice of my doc, knowing deep down, that I can’t take such things, even if it seems like the inactive ingredients are fine.
They’re never fine. And so I was sick for weeks, and blaming myself for all of it. (You should see my online running log. It fell off a cliff. Literally.)
The cold, strangely enough, was annoying, but reassuring. Yes, I probably had not taken enough precautions, but at the same time…I got con crud. Which I’d had from previous conventions over many years. Con crud, not Covid.
It was a reminder of past years, a way to remind me that, yes indeed, the world went on.
And it was going on, with severe problems in our household and among friends. School was stupidly hard, and the writing pretty much fell off the same cliff that the running had.
I needed to revamp.
I had triaged a lot during the pandemic. In 2021, I even set a very low word quota for my fiction, something I hadn’t done for decades. While it got me to the computer every day, it proved to me (again) that I’m not good with those kinds of rules. I did the minimum. And that was it. Because I had easily achieved my goal.
I dumped that goal in 2022, but didn’t replace it. And still struggled with my writing. Focus was a real problem. Crisis after crisis had trained me to look outward, expecting the next disaster.
I can’t write when I look outward. Or rather, I can’t write a lot. So my output declined dramatically. Which was odd, because I thought I had solved the problems that I had earlier.
One problem? I hated my office in our first Vegas condo. I never used that office. I wrote on the couch, which meant that I got interrupted all the time, and never did concentrate very well. That worked for some projects, but those big projects that require my full attention?
They didn’t happen.
Then we moved in 2021 to a place that has a more-or-less private office. It’s made of glass and windows on all but one wall, so I have to pull shades and close (a rather ineffective) door to get full privacy. To get full privacy without sound requires headphones.
But I can do that, and the desire to work on the tough projects returned. But not the ability. Something was still off.
Then Dean, bless him, took his life into his own hands and ventured a comment on my writing process. I don’t let anyone into my process ever, at least not without permission and a lot of NDAs. Even then, it’s usually a disaster.
But he mentioned—oh, so casually—that I’m a morning writer, and I haven’t been writing in the morning for years.
Well, yes, of course, yes, I haven’t because I live here and it gets stupidly hot and I need to run for my health which means that non-morning person me would get up at 5 a.m. in the height of the summer to run before the sun came up, just to get my miles in, and I needed to do that and…
Whoops.
That was a pandemic shift. When the gyms were closed. The gym that I used all summer in 2018 and 2019. The gym, which was a default if I couldn’t get outside in the daylight in the fall/winter. The gym…
…was open. And I was fully vaccinated. And the air movement in the gyms we go to has always been stellar, and not many people run on the running track; for some dumb reason, they prefer the treadmill, and, and, and…oh, yeah.
Pandemic habits. Things I had started during lockdown to survive aren’t necessary now. I had gone back to the gym in 2021 after my vaccines, using masks, but I hadn’t changed my mindset at all.
I found that in a variety of places. The gym was just one.
Another? My news consumption. I was obsessively watching each development, both in the pandemic news and in the political news here in the U.S. We had (still have, in some ways) an existential crisis, and monitoring it worked for me…then.
In late 2021, I had finally gotten rid of my Covid news feed through Twitter, including a guy who also got stuck in his pandemic habits. He saw nightmares in each piece of data. He’d been accurate in 2020, not so much in 2021, and for all I know, he’s still screaming into the wind.
I am not criticizing him. He was watching everything from death rates to treatments, seeing each number as a human being. His mental health took a beating. I suspect all of ours did, in ways we are only just starting to discover.
Getting rid of the pandemic panic helped. In 2022, after the mid-term elections here in the States, I stopped obsessively watching political news. I would delete notifications. I left Twitter—not because of my mental health, but because of Elon Musk, the jerk—and found that I really don’t want to replace it.
It’s a luxury for me not to follow the current crisis. My training comes from an abusive family, so knowing what the stressors are means that I can (kinda sorta) see what’s ahead. Including tragedy, meltdowns, nightmares.
Add to that all the journalism training, and I can be real good at reading tea leaves in some kind of crisis.
But when I choose to step away from the crisis (and there always are a million of them), I do so because I personally no longer feel threatened. Or I don’t feel an immediate threat to my friends and family. I can take my time responding to problems. I can throw money at them. I can decide if I want to do more than that.
The key, though, is that I can take the time to contemplate it all.
That’s a true luxury.
So: Full disclosure. I hate running every morning. Running every morning is better than not running at all. But getting up, going out into whatever weather is there, and then coming back for breakfast, feeling behind even before I started (and sometimes feeling too hot or too cold or too tired) was just not fun.
It was necessary.
I made the switch away from morning runs in 2022. And promptly got that cold. Which meant I wasn’t running at all in November, which I then blamed on the switch, not the cold.
Then I looked at my steps and realized that I had screwed up one of my streaks. When I got sick in June, I stopped doing 100K steps per week, which I had done for 3 years up to that point. Non-stop. Three years.
I built back up in the summer, then November—and I could barely manage my 12K per day streak. During the worst of the cold, I would stagger a thousand steps (in a place where I wouldn’t contaminate anyone), and then go lie down. That was fun.
So I thought about returning to the 100K (which you can’t do if you’re only doing 12K per day), and decided not to. I was tired. And part of me just didn’t care anymore. Not about that stuff.
What I did find, as I looked at my numbers, was that my daily word count had reached the highest level it had reached maybe since we moved to Las Vegas. (That part I haven’t checked.) And I was getting a bit vicious about my morning hours. No one dared disturb me, not even cats.
I even decided (not consciously) that I wouldn’t take a morning class in the spring semester. I whittled my classes down to one, because…well, that’s too complicated to discuss, but let’s simply say that I’m not capable of writing, running a business, dealing with health issues, enjoying visiting friends and Las Vegas itself, and going to school in a standard part-time way.
I’m not giving up school—I’m learning too much and getting to see how the younger generations (which is pretty much everyone but me) are living these days. But I can do that with one (stupidly hard) class per semester.
The words, though. Let me be clear. For me, writing is about new words, not rewriting or fixing or even assembling (which is necessary considering how much I write out of order). New words do not include nonfiction (like this blog) or anything I write on my website or emails or promotion or anything like that. New words is new words of fiction, which my lovely fingers just mistyped as “new worlds of fiction,” which is more or less accurate.
Allowing myself the morning time—again, finally—also means the idea machine is up and running. Ideas get sparked by random suggestions, which hadn’t happened at all in the pandemic. I have little sticky notes everywhere. Again. Yay!
One other major changed happened in the last part of 2022, and it is pandemic/life related. We have lost a lot of friends and family in the past three years, more than I’m willing to admit. So many, in fact, that there are times that I forget that someone I care about is dead. (Yes, I know that’s a feature of grief, but it’s also a feature of not seeing people as much as I would like, so I can half-pretend that they were still on the planet.)
If I focus on the loss, I will collapse into a trembling mass of helplessness. Because the losses are severe.
Some of that is my age. And the relative lack of health of people who got involved in professional science fiction in my formative years. The platitudes—no one gets out of this world alive—really don’t help.
What helps is a memory: My grandmother, talking to me and my cousin Vicki. Vic and I were young adults at that point, standing in the dining room of my grandmother’s home.
For some reason lost to memory, Grandma had told us that inside, she still felt sixteen, which was shocking enough to me, considering that at the time, she was in her nineties.
But the part of the conversation that’s been surfacing these past few years is this: She also told us that of her friends, she was the only one left. The only one. Vic said something like, “But you have us, Grandma,” and my grandmother paused.
She did not say that it was different or it wasn’t enough or that we didn’t matter, things that could have been an easy blurt.
I think she was trying to teach us something, because what she said went something like this:
The people that know what I know are gone. The ones that had the same experiences, that remember the same things. They’re gone.
I don’t remember what we said after that. What could you say, from the perspective of twenty-something? And I don’t know if she expounded on that even more.
But now, at sixty-two, I’m having the same experience. I realized—more than once in 2022—that I’m the only survivor of this event or that occurance. I’m the only one who knows what happened, or who lived through it, or who can discuss it.
And that experience has grown over the years.
Add to it the things I discussed in this year in review, particularly the posts about traditional publishing. What I knew of traditional publishing is gone. The hopes and dreams forged in those years, impossible. In particular, read the post on bestsellers. Having a book hit a bestseller list and having that mean something was an easy default goal, even into my fifties.
It isn’t now.
In addition to restoring old habits, I needed reasons to continue pushing forward on the business side.
The old goals and habits weren’t there. They had disappeared in the past twelve years or had become utterly meaningless. I didn’t want to be that old lady, the one who said, Well, in my day, bestsellers were in the millions, not the hundred thousands, and everybody read those books or at least knew of them.
“In my day” is a deadly phrase, guaranteed to destroy any forward movement.
But I needed new goals, a new reason to push forward.
Sadly, strangely, the loss of my friends, two in particular in 2022, gave me the framework. Both had great careers. Neither will be remembered much. Their estates are in ruin, mostly because they had no estate planning when they died.
I’d been writing a series on estate planning before we moved to Vegas, and quit because of a variety of things. I’ve discussed estate planning a lot with you, because of copyright.
But there are estates that thrive and estates that fail, and sometimes the difference between them is so miniscule that no one notices.
What that difference is, mostly, is a long view. Life plus 70, here in the States.
That means my copyrights will still be enforceable seventy years after I die. And, like the rest of you, I have no idea when that seventy-year clock will begin.
It’s not an automatic. Someone has to tend to the copyrights like they’re a garden. And that garden has to exist before the writer dies. As in not just a plot of land with seeds scattered on some hard dirt. But a thriving, growing, beautiful garden that needs to have some kind of order. (So that it doesn’t look like a thicket.)
That’s not something that I can will into being (pun intended). Sure, I can leave my copyrights to someone, but can they maintain them? Can they make the system work without it overtaking their life?
Setting up the estate so that it thrives after I’m gone is a new and difficult goal. It will take time and planning and a lot of vision. It will also need some tending that I once balked at.
I need to leave a plan for all of my series, so that in that seventy-year period whoever has taken over the estate has a road map for continuing the popular stories. I don’t want someone to guess at what I meant. I need to have some kind of outline.
Yeah. There we go. Lots of work that needs to be organized, which really isn’t my strongest suit.
Anyway. 2022 is the year I started looking forward again, instead of hunkering down in my home trying to avoid swirling crises. In the latter part of the year anyway.
Does that mean I know exactly what I’m doing in 2023? Not yet. I’m still doing planning by the seat of my pants…kinda. I will focus down on what’s next once I finish two projects that have been hanging over me.
Using the pandemic methods, those two projects plus short fiction, would have taken the entire year. Now I’m thinking maybe the first quarter. Yep, I’ve increased my word count that much.
And I have to admit, I still look at the temperature every morning. I miss seeing some of the locals that I saw on those morning runs, folks whose jobs send them home by 2 or 3 in the afternoon.
But I don’t miss them enough to get up before the sun rises. I don’t miss them enough to struggle through a 20-mile-per-hour wind. I don’t miss them enough to willingly run in 90+ degrees, even if it is dark.
I’ll do it again if I have to. But let’s hope none of us will have to go through that pandemic lockdown weirdness again in our lifetimes.
I knew that crawling out of the pandemic (phase) was going to be hard and slow. I just hadn’t realized how many habits I had developed to get through—and how necessary it is to change many of them.
One thing I did learn from 2020: I have no idea what 2023 will bring, and I’m not arrogantly going to declare that I do.
But I do have a plan to move forward.
And that’s more than enough.
Speaking of in-person workshops (scroll up, you’ll see what I mean), we have until Friday to get more signups for the Romantic Suspense workshop here in Vegas in May. If we don’t, we’ll only have the study along. So, give it some thought…
And a reminder: This weekly blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynrusch to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: Year in Review 2022: The Final Post (A Process Blog),” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image of my grandmother Rusch and my niece at the top of the blog copyright © Donovan L. Hofsommer.
Maya knows her job as mining supervisor, and she knows it well. But do the higher-ups listen to her? Of course not.
But when the biggest ice storm yet hits Xeunite, Maya finds her incompetent bosses the least of her worries. As the storm rages, Maya faces life-and-death decisions—ones she might not survive.
With “Ice Breakers,” Kristine Kathryn Rusch offers up an unexpected heroine of the highest order.
“Ice Breakers” by Hugo Award-winning author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook through various online retailers here.
Ice BreakersKristine Kathryn RuschPerfect time for the equipment to break. Maya lashed the handle of the Ice Breaker against the pole, fighting the wind with every movement. Her environmental suit—a little too old and a little too tight—blocked the cold, but nothing blocked the wind.
She cursed the higher-ups with each breath. Money-grubbing assholes. She’d been telling them for the past five years that the equipment was on its last legs, that it would break at the exact wrong possible moment, and then they’d lose millions.
But did anyone listen? Of course not. And now, the equipment had broken down at the worst possible moment.
She wrapped an arm around the pole, and braced herself. Most of the equipment was deep in the ice, sturdy enough to handle the high winds that came with Xeunite’s storms.
But this storm, this was a motherfucker, the biggest they’d seen since they started mining Xeunite’s northernmost ice-covered continent. The ice coated everything, but beneath it was a cornucopia of minerals that formed the basis of almost every piece of equipment on every ship and settlement from here to Megnacia.
ClaaLorus Systems had guessed the minerals would be here, spent a small fortune to secure not just the rights but the land, and had been digging in the ice ever since.
Maya had been head of operations for the past five years, and she’d never seen a storm warning like this one. Sustained winds of a hundred and fifty miles per hour and snow mixed with ice. The temperatures, always lethally low here, would go to unimaginable levels considering the wind speed.
Her environmental suit was up to the challenge, but her body wasn’t. There wasn’t a lot to protect her out here. Early this year, she had ordered her team to move the equipment to an ice plain that had once been a gigantic freshwater lake. Ice and snow-covered mountains ringed it on three sides, protecting the area from some storms, but not this one.
This one was coming from the east, directly into the gap between the mountain ranges, and, if her computer simulations were accurate, would form some kind of weather vortex that could sweep up everything in its path.
Normally, she would have sent a crew to make sure every piece of equipment was lashed into place, but she didn’t trust the timing of the predictions. The computer simulation was working off models created nearly a century ago by the first colonizers, and their predictions had been off in the past.
If anyone was going to get caught out here, it would be her. Not because she was the most experienced, but because she would be able to sleep better at night, knowing that she hadn’t sent three team members into this kind of danger.
The wind had picked up just in the past hour. She didn’t have a lot to do outside—and normally, she wouldn’t have had to do anything. But the top of the equipment—four separate poles exposed to the elements—had broken down first.
They didn’t recede into the ground the way they were supposed to. And the poles were mostly hollow. They had caps, but the caps had been built for the shape the poles had been originally. After years of debris and wind and rocks and dents, the caps didn’t hold as tightly.
She had to lower the poles manually, and the one she held was the last one she had to work on.
If a team member had been out here, she’d have told him to leave it. She’d deal with the damage. But she was only five minutes from finishing, and she was a completist. The winds were still weak enough that she could walk through them, although that latest gust had nearly peeled her from the pole.
She opened the exterior control panel, hating the design (just like she had every time). Someone had thought overrides should be accessible from the top, not the tiny interior cabin in the very center of each machine. She managed to hit the right sequence of commands with her gloved fingers, then leaned back.
The pole shuddered and jerked a little. She hadn’t recessed the poles in more than a month because she had been afraid they’d get stuck and she would have to send a repair team out. Now, it seemed, her deliberate negligence was going to cause more of a problem.
Then the pole shuddered one last time and, with a squeal, started downward. She wiped her hands on her thighs, even though she didn’t have to. The environmental suit was self-cleaning. But that pole seemed dirty and rusty and she didn’t want to transfer anything from it to her rover.
The rover. Now that the poles were underneath the ice, it looked like the only thing on the plain. One black utility rover, with big wheels for groundwork, grapplers for orbital assistance, and some carved vents for releasing everything from atmosphere to unrecyclable garbage.
She had landed the rover only ten yards away, but it looked like ten miles. The expanse of ice had that effect. It also tired the eyes.
She debated whether or not to run or to program her boots to adhere to the ice. If she adhered to the ice, she’d move slower than she wanted to. She glanced at the opening in the mountain ring.
The clouds had lowered. They were white and gray and very puffy-fat, except along one side, where it looked like someone had rubbed a finger over them, smearing them.
She had never seen clouds look like that, even though she had worked in bad weather before.
Run, not adhere. If she needed the extra stickiness, she would access it as she moved.
She sprinted across the ice, and reached the rover’s side, just as another gust of wind hit her. It slammed her against the rover, knocking the breath out of her.
Her entire body hurt, and multicolored lights rose in front of her eyes. It took her a moment to realize that the lights were internal.
The wind held her against the rover for what seemed like forever but was probably little more than a few seconds.
Then it eased, and she staggered backwards.
She sent the open command along with her personal code to the rover, and the door rose upward, nearly hitting her in the chin. She had been standing too close.
That blow had knocked more than the air out of her. It had momentarily robbed her of good sense.
She slipped inside, and let the door seal behind her. The rover informed her that its severe weather shields were now in place.
She let out a small breath, and leaned on the door.
Her heart was racing. She hadn’t realized quite how panicked she had been.
Her suit beeped, notifying her that it was adjusting to the rover’s environment. Seventy degrees, the proper mix of oxygen—she could peel off the suit if she wanted to, and she used to do that. But one bad experience (one bad loss) had taught her not to.
The environmental suit remained on in bad weather, even if the rover was just fine.
The suit was doing its nerdy thing, the thing she had set it up for one fine afternoon, giving her facts and figures she normally liked to receive. The temperature differential between inside and out was a hundred degrees, not counting wind chill. At the current wind speed, the windchill was eighty-six below.
Nothing would survive out there for very long.
The rover had originally been divided into four separate spaces—a storage/supply area for whatever mission the rover was going on; a sleep chamber/personal area in case the mission was a long one; a kitchen/relaxation area that could be converted into more seating if a crew was on the rover; and a cockpit, which covered the entire front of the vehicle.
Maya had modified this rover so that the sleep chamber was little more than a closet. She kept the kitchen equipment intact, but had removed everything from the relaxation part of the room. The extra seating could rise out of the floor with a simple command; she didn’t have to move anything else at all.
She had taken some of that extra space for supplies, which filled the back. She had brought extra food and backup equipment for everything from the Ice Breaker to the rover itself. She had known when she left base that morning that she had a good chance of riding out the storm right here, on this stupid ice plain.
She was prepared for that, down to the extra entertainment units to distract her from the whistling wind.
The wind really wasn’t whistling inside the rover. It was too tight for that. And the stabilizers held it in place, so that it wasn’t rocking in the wind either.
Given the predictions, though, she was going to have to sink the grapplers into the ice, because the vehicle itself didn’t have enough weight to withstand wind speeds that high.
Very little did.
If she was trapped here. Right now, she had a go-window of about two hours before the impossible winds hit and she couldn’t fly out of here. She could try to drive for an extra hour after that, but she would only do that if the vortex wasn’t as bad as predicted.
The beeping of her environmental suit, sending information through the hood, was beginning to annoy her. It would only take a few seconds to replace that hood on her head, a few seconds more for the environment to reassert itself throughout the system.
She could gamble on that.
She pulled the hood off, leaving it dangling over the back of the suit, then sat in the pilot’s chair. The rover had already protected itself by sealing up the windows that ran along the front.
The windows weren’t essential. Many of the team who piloted the rover kept the seals over the windows at all times. But she loved having them open. The natural light was lovely, especially when it reflected off the ice field. Some found that blinding; she found it refreshing, and breathtakingly beautiful.
But safer to keep the windows closed. So she swiped a hand across the top of the navigation board, commanding it to use the windows as a screen for the imagery that the front of the rover was recording. It wasn’t quite the same as the view through the windows, but it was close enough.
Although it didn’t light up the interior of the rover the way that the actual view did. Not that there would have been much light once the storm hit full force.
She plotted her trip back to base, looking at the position of the storm versus the power of the storm. The rover did have orbital capacity, so she could zoom straight up and circle Xeunite a few times, waiting for the storm to die.
That would probably be the safest maneuver since, by the time she got to the base, the base would be suffering from the severe weather as well.
The base was on a regular plain, snow-covered, not ice-covered, and wasn’t ringed by mountains the way the mining surface was. Even though the base was mostly underground, the top—which opened for ship arrivals—was exposed to the weather.
It was that moment—the one where she would have to lower the rover into the base in hurricane force winds—that she wanted to avoid. Even driving the rover into the base from the side could cause damage to the base’s interior.
She ran a hand over her face, and prepped the rover for the diciest part of her trip—going straight upward through the edge of the storm—to get to orbit.
She had the rover do some calculations, and she did a few on the non-networked tablet she carried with her on every trip. Sometimes she found that the equipment provided by ClaaLorus Systems had an overly optimistic view of the stresses the equipment could tolerate, and what, exactly, the human body could tolerate.
The overly optimistic view wasn’t enough for her to file a complaint with the various government boards and agencies that provided oversight to this part of the sector, but it was enough for her to redo the mathematics.
And…if she were actually being honest with herself…she was accumulating evidence, so that she would actually be able to be paid by those government agencies once she became a whistleblower. Otherwise, she would need a job somewhere, and this industry was notorious for failing to hire anyone who had complained about anything anywhere.
The routes did not look promising. The force of the wind would strain the rover’s engines. She might have missed her window for the best way to travel.
The storm’s conditions could and would change at any moment.
And that was when something on the feed caught her eye.
She looked up, scanned the imagery playing on the windows. Black and gray clouds, mostly smeared, in the eastern entrance to the ice field. The tallest mountain peaks in the ring around her had vanished in the clouds.
The storm system was actually covering the entire valley like a gigantic blanket which had not been predicted at all.
But that wasn’t what had caught her attention. Something black and gold had pierced the cloud cover to the north. She watched as the thing—which looked like some kind of meteorite—sped toward the center of the valley, leaving a trail of flame and smoke behind it.
The ice’s surface was three miles deep, but she had no idea what would happen exactly if something that hot moving that fast hit the surface.
She didn’t have any weaponry on the rover that could shoot the thing and break it up. So with two swift commands, she added two layers of shields, one for deep space and one to protect against any kind of attack.
Then the thing hit the ice with such force that she could actually hear the bang. Although bang was too small a word for the sound, muffled as it was by the shield layers and the rover’s natural protections. The rover itself shuddered once from the impact, and then rocked as an aftershock hit.
She gripped the navigation panel and stared at the images the rover was sending her. The thing hit, then skidded through the ice, breaking a path, feet deep, sending steam—or ice fog—or maybe even ice itself into the air. She couldn’t quite tell, and the wind didn’t help. It grabbed whatever that plume was and broke it apart, flattening it, and sending it in a thousand different directions.
The thing finally stopped maybe a hundred yards from her, to the east, directly in front of the storm.
But it all looked wrong to her. At that speed, shouldn’t the thing have gone deeper into the ice? Should it have skidded at all? And if it had been a meteorite, shouldn’t it have broken up on impact?
Cracks started forming along the top of the ice. The cracks ran along the length of the entire grove in the ice.
She started two separate scans—the first to see if the cracks off the path the thing created in the ice went vertically as well as horizontally, and the second to see what kind of damage the damn thing was doing where it ended up. Did it still give off heat? Was it burning through the ice? What was it exactly?
She got the answer to the last question first: it was some kind of ship. And her scan showed her two life signs inside.
“Great,” she muttered. Two life signs inside a flaming ball that had landed at that speed. Her gut told her she was looking at some kind of escape pod or debris from some broken-up ship.
Part of her wished there were no life signs. No life signs meant she could deal with the other problem at hand.
The damn thing had carved its way across a fissure that ran deep in the ice. The fissure was something she’d been monitoring, because it had grown during their ice mining.
There was bedrock beneath the ice but that wouldn’t stop the ice from splintering. She had seen it on other jobs, decades ago. That carelessness, though, was caused by the company she worked for at the time, not that they had suffered any consequences. Sixteen people had died, falling into a crevasse that had formed almost instantaneously as the fissure split.
Sixteen people, no consequences.
This time, it would just be her, and there would definitely be no consequences.
But she couldn’t leave those two life signs, whatever and whoever they were, to this growing crisis.
They hadn’t activated a distress beacon, which seemed odd, but then, she had no idea if they were conscious. She also had no idea what—if anything—had been destroyed in their crash landing.
She had the rover try to contact them, saying she was in position to rescue them. She sent the message in every language used in this sector and a few other common ones besides, but she received no indication that the owners of those two life signs had even heard the message, let alone could respond to it.
The storm was growing. The large system swirled on the terrain map along her nav board. The winds were picking up, but the system itself seemed trapped in its own circular pattern. Which was good and bad. It wasn’t moving fast, but it was becoming organized and also gathering a great deal of debris.
She had to make a decision about those life signs, and she had to make it fast.
No one would blame her for leaving them. The circumstances certainly allowed for it. They didn’t work for her, and they clearly had no business being here.
But they registered as human life signs, and she’d been criticizing the lack of consideration for human life in the companies she’d worked for over the past thirty-five years. Weirdly, she didn’t want to save these people because she knew them or because it was the right thing to do.
She felt she had to save them to spare herself from becoming a hypocrite.
She wouldn’t be able to live with herself if she left them behind. She would always wonder how they died, if they suffocated under the ice when their environment ran out or if they had emerged and eventually died in the storm or if they hadn’t had the gear and had frozen to death.
She was certain she could come up with even more horrible death scenarios as time and her guilt worsened.
“Son of a bitch,” she muttered to herself, and put some queries into the nav board. Could the cracks in the ice handle the weight of the rover? Could they handle the tires moving across the surface, the rumble and the vibration? If not, could the rover fly at a low enough level to skate the surface in this wind?
She ran the same questions in her tablet, and got two different sets of answers. The nav board called the thing an unidentified object, and claimed that the risk wasn’t worthwhile.
Her tablet used the same inputs and declared the thing a government-issue escape pod manufactured twenty-five years ago. And yes, if she acted quickly, the rover could both cross the ice directly or skate above it with the winds.
The tablet recommended skating above it all, but she wasn’t going to. She wanted the ability to punch the rover straight up into the atmosphere, as the storm worsened.
She could only do that from the ground.
“Son of a bitch,” she repeated. Then checked to make sure the grapplers worked properly and she could still section off the storage section of the rover.
When she got a yes to both, she put the rover in gear, and headed forward along the edge of the path carved by the escape pod.
The fissure beneath ran perpendicular to the path the pod carved. But the cracks were working their way down, as the wind was winding up. She stopped looking at the sustained wind number, and pretended she didn’t see the “1” before the numbers for the occasional gusts.
That storm was going to arrive whether she wanted it to or not.
“Hey, Maya!” A voice crackled into the rover’s comm. Risa, contacting her from base. “That storm’s getting worse.”
Maya considered not answering at all, but if she did that, the team might send someone for her, against her explicit instructions.
“Yeah, I know. I’m coming back,” Maya said.
“Looks like you’re going in the wrong direction,” Risa said. “Unless everything is off from that explosion. That had nothing to do with us, right?”
Not you, not the company. Us, as if she had expected something to blow on the Ice Breaker. Which simply showed what bad shape it was truly in.
“No,” Maya said. “Nothing to do with us.”
“Well, that’s the wrong direction. I’ll stay on—”
“I got it,” Maya said, and signed off. She let out a small breath. She didn’t want the distraction from Risa, nor, for some reason, did Maya want Risa to know exactly what was going on.
It didn’t surprise Maya that Risa had no idea something had crash-landed. She hadn’t been monitoring the area (or she shouldn’t have been!) and even if she had, that escape pod might have looked like some kind of debris mingling with the storm cells.
Maya didn’t entirely want to examine her motivation for failing to tell Risa about the life signs. Was Maya protecting herself, in case she couldn’t rescue those people? In case she didn’t try?
The rover had reached the edge of the well that the pod had created when it stopped moving. Normally, she would have sent a small arm off the side of the rover to examine the well. But the arm would break off in the wind.
So she sent out a probe with its own internal engine, strong enough to handle these wind speeds. The probe jettisoned from one of the side vents and flew as close to the ground as it could, then descended into the well, sending telemetry and pictures back the entire time.
The pictures showed a round pod with scorch marks on its side. The fire was out, but only because the pod was embedded in ice. The flames had been so hot that the ice had melted significantly, and there was a pool of water below. That water had to be sloughing off around or beneath that pod right now, because the air was so cold the water should freeze the moment it touched air.
It didn’t matter how hot the pod was, as long as it wasn’t actively burning. The rover’s grapplers could handle extreme temperatures of all types.
But Maya wasn’t sure how well the grapplers could handle the wind. If she was going to do anything, she had to do it now.
She raised the hood of her environmental suit, figuring that Risa knew where she was if something went seriously wrong in the next few minutes. Then Maya released the large grappler, guiding it out of its container on the side of the rover.
A gust of wind nearly pulled the grappler off its coupling. That gust had been bigger, but it wasn’t as big as the winds would be in the next hour.
She had to move fast, but she also had to be precise.
The grappler could handle equipment twenty times the size of the rover. Maya had no specifics on the escape pod; she had only eyeballed it. But it seemed to be at the outer limits of the grappler’s capabilities.
She would find out soon enough.
The grappler bent at its top elbow joint and curved downward into the well. It found holds on the outside of the pod, probably for it to remain in place in whatever kind of ship it had come from. The grappler’s gigantic claws slid into those holds as if they were made for it.
Then the grappler tugged.
The pod didn’t move.
The grappler tugged again, and the pod still didn’t move. Either it was too heavy or it had already frozen in place.
Maya’s mouth had gone dry. If she couldn’t get the pod out of that well, she would have to leave those two life signs behind. She personally wasn’t strong enough or fit enough to battle the wind, climb down into that well, and try to open the pod’s doors from the outside. And even if she did, she wouldn’t be able to haul anyone out of there.
The best she could do was mark the spot, hope the incoming blizzard didn’t bury the pod too deep, so that her team could come back when everything was over and try a rescue then.
Even that might not work, because the cold and the wind would create a layer of ice so deep that it might take a week to carve a hole in the ice. She wasn’t sure those life signs would survive that long. She wasn’t sure they would survive long enough for her to rescue them now.
“Come on, come on, come on,” she muttered, not sure if she was talking to the equipment or the pod itself. Because if the life signs could do something, anything, it might help.
Then the grappler tugged the pod loose. In fact, the grappler pulled with such force that it had to overcompensate in the other direction, and the entire rover rocked.
The wind wasn’t helping. It continued to push at the rover. The gusts were actually starting to overcome the stabilizers.
The pod was lighter than she expected, which was another reason the grappler overcompensated. She initiated the commands for the grappler to attach the pod to the back of the rover and, at the same time, she made sure the back of the rover was shielded from the cockpit.
The pod attached with a clang. The airlock computers spun the pod until its airlock matched the rover’s airlock.
The nav board started flaring red. The pod wasn’t adhering properly to the rover. The airlocks weren’t working.
She wouldn’t be able to travel back to base with the pod attached to the rover and the grappler partially extended. She couldn’t fly out of here either, and she couldn’t just sit here. The wind would peel off the grappler as well as the pod.
She needed to get the life signs inside the rover.
She grabbed her laser pistol, regretting every single decision she had made since the day began. She should have let the Ice Breaker break, and let ClaaLorus Systems fire her. She’d been fired from jobs before.
But not after this many years. And not when she was this old.
Too late now, anyway. She was committed.
But she promised herself that if she couldn’t open the pod, she would tag it and drop it close to the Ice Breaker, so that her team could find it. It would get covered with snow and ice, but not like it had been in that well. And maybe those life signs would have a chance to survive.
She left the cockpit, and closed the cockpit door, something she hadn’t done in years. She locked it, coded not just to her warm handprint and active eye scan, but also physically, with a seventeen-figure numerical that had an image in the middle, something she used on her personal stuff, something not in any computer anywhere.
No one could guess that, not without time and the right equipment, and she doubted the owners of those life signs had that.
Then she made her way to the storage area, pulling up her environmental suit’s hood as she went. The environment formed around her almost immediately and, oddly, gave her comfort.
She pulled open the storage area door, stunned to see ice forming on everything inside.
That leak between the pod and the storage area wasn’t a leak. It was an actual opening.
She turned her boots to the ice setting, hoping she would adhere enough to make it to the pod door.
She could see it, intermittently, as the wind whistled between the two vehicles, bringing pointed ice pellets with it. They were scratching the pod, and probably not doing any good for her rover either.
And she didn’t want to think about the grappler, which she hadn’t yet unhooked.
She couldn’t hear much over the howl of the wind, but as she got closer to the open doors, she thought she heard pounding.
Then the pounding stopped.
Oh, God, if those life signs snuffed out while she was this close, she would…she had no idea what. She didn’t want to imagine it.
She went to the wall, and managed to open the tools locker. Thank every god she could think of that the locker had been designed to work in extreme conditions.
She removed a laser cutter, and put a few other tools on her environmental suit’s belt. Then she stuffed the laser pistol in there as well, because she would need both hands.
She could see the outline of the door on the pod, but that outline was getting coated in ice. She couldn’t strap into the opening near the rover because if she did, she couldn’t reach the pod’s door. So she did the next best thing. She hooked two tethers to her belt.
The wind buffeted her as she worked. She only had one chance at unsealing that pod’s door. If this didn’t work, she couldn’t do anymore, because she would get blown into the ice field.
She braced one hand on the pod. The ice was lumpy beneath her gloves, and thicker than she thought.
She started up the laser cutter, working fast, peeling ice away as she cut pieces loose. The pounding continued inside, getting stronger as the ice moved away.
She had no idea if the people inside could hear her work: she doubted it. But they had to know they had been moved.
Finally, she got to the door itself. She was about to yank it open, when it slid sideways, and she found herself face to face with a man who had been beaten bloody.
His face was black-and-blue. His lower lip was split, his nose broken. His eyes were barely visible under the swelling in his face.
He shoved her backwards, and she nearly fell through the gap between the pod and the rover. She caught herself with her arms, hanging onto the rover on one side and the pod on the other.
The man climbed over her as he got out.
As she struggled to regain her footing, she glanced inside the pod. Another person huddled in there in a fetal position, eyes closed, face battered. He seemed to be unconscious.
Her heart rate spiked. What had she gotten in the middle of?
She pulled herself into the rover, barely able to stand due to the wind swirling around her. She caught a strap near the door, and eased herself inside—
Only to find herself face to face with a laser pistol. It was olive. Government issue.
“Close the damn door,” he said.
“Your friend,” she said, looking at the pod.
“He’s not my friend,” the man said. “Close the damn door or get the hell out.”
The wind swirled again, and he slid just a little. His boots couldn’t find purchase on the ice.
“This is my vehicle,” she said.
“Not anymore,” he said. “This thing is some kind of space-to-land vehicle, right?”
“It’s a rover,” she said, trying to keep herself calm. The wind was getting stronger.
He was shaking. He wasn’t wearing any kind of environmental suit.
“I can handle a rover,” he said, more to himself than to her. “Get out.”
“No,” she said.
He fired. His shaking hands made the shot miss her and ping off the side of the escape pod. He swore, tried to regroup, and ended up losing his footing entirely.
He landed on his back with a whomp! and spun along the ice-covered floor toward her. She blocked his slide by moving a booted foot in front of him, and pulled her own laser pistol from the back of her belt.
“Get your friend out of that pod, and I’ll make sure you get out of here,” she said.
“He’s not my friend.” The battered man’s teeth were chattering. He probably had frostbite already.
“What is he?”
The man grabbed her leg and tried to pull her sideways, to make her lose her balance. But she remained steady because her boots adhered to the ice.
Instead, he managed to slip farther, hanging off the edge of the rover. The wind battered his head against the side of the pod.
“You’re going to die if you don’t do what I said.” She sounded tougher than she felt. Her heart was pounding.
He pointed his laser pistol at her, hands still shaking. “I don’t need you,” he said, and fired again.
She kicked the pistol as he fired, the shot going wild. The force of her kick made him slide the rest of the way out of the rover, falling headfirst between the rover and the pod.
She ran to the edge, to see if she could reach him, but he had fallen deep into the snow.
She had no idea why she wanted to save him. He had tried to shoot her twice, and he had clearly done something to the man inside the pod.
The pod.
The wind had grown so strong now that she could barely hold her own position. And she couldn’t keep the pod attached to the rover.
She grabbed one of the tethers and pulled it across the distance between the pod and the rover, stepping with it, turning on the gravity in her boots as well, hoping that would keep her as stable as possible.
The inside of the pod was trashed. The two men had fought in here, and the man on the floor lost. He was wearing some kind of uniform. The logo on his closest sleeve belonged to a prison transport ship. She looked up, saw that the pod was marked Official Use Only.
Somehow, the guy who had fallen into the snow had commandeered this pod, maybe by forcing the guard to open it all for him, then beating the man within an inch of his life.
She grabbed the man and wrapped the tether around him, before attaching it to his belt. Then she yanked him up, knees buckling under his weight.
She could barely shove him toward the door. Only a few yards to cross to get into the rover. Only a few yards.
The gap between the rover and the pod was the hard part. She wasn’t sure how she felt about the other man, dying on the ice below her (relieved?), but she didn’t want to lose this one. Not that she was certain he was a good man—she had no way of knowing that—but he hadn’t actively tried to harm her, and she had come this far.
She kept her arms wrapped around his torso, and leveraged herself across that gap, yanking him along, feeling the effort in her back and her thighs. Sharp pains were shooting through her knees. She couldn’t hold this position long.
Then the wind came up again, screeching—actually screeching—and for once it worked with her, shoving her into the rover. She fell on top of the man, feeling him slide on the ice beneath her.
She stuck one foot between his thighs to stop him from sliding out of the rover just like his companion had. Then she commanded the rover to close the airlock door.
For a moment, the door didn’t move. The wind shoved in, and she wondered if that was causing the door to stick open. Then bits of ice rained off the door’s side. It slid—too slowly for her tastes—all the way closed.
“Restore environment,” she said, but she really meant temperature. Then she grabbed the man and dragged him toward the door into the rover proper.
She managed to get that door open, not sure what she would do with this guy if he became conscious. Would he be as vicious as his compatriot?
She untethered herself, grabbed some extra cords, and pulled the man out of the storage area. She was dragging him by his collar now, because her back wouldn’t let her do anything else.
And her knees. She had never felt such pain in her knees.
But she wasn’t going to let herself limp. She dragged him to the only bed, and somehow managed to lever him onto it. Then she strapped him into place, just in case.
She didn’t know much field medicine. She knew how to deal with frostbite and ice, but that was it. She wrapped him in the special blankets every rover on the base had, and she let the blankets deal with the man’s extreme cold.
She’d worry about his other injuries later.
She checked the straps, then made her way to the cockpit, opening the door, and stepping inside. Her environmental suit’s hood remained up this time, and it was beeping at her. The wind speeds had reached ridiculous levels.
She unhooked the pod from the back of the rover, and did her best to secure the grappler. If it broke, that was no longer her issue. She had a hunch, given the pain in her back and knees, she’d be on some kind of disability leave anyway. She wasn’t sure she could do the work, not given how she felt at the moment.
Then she ran the simulations. The wind was too strong for her to drive through it, and too gusty for her to jettison into orbit. But the ice was still cracking, and the fissure beneath was growing.
She couldn’t drive out. The rover didn’t have the ability to plow through the snow-ice mix. And the wind wouldn’t let her skim over the surface.
She had to standing-start jump into orbit. A one-time shot.
For a half-second she thought about staying here, gambling that the cracks wouldn’t become something more serious.
But the same things that factored into her decision to pull the pod out factored into the decision here. If the rover slipped below the surface and got covered in snow-ice, which then froze over…
It would be a hellish death, along with the guy she didn’t know. What if he ended up as mean as the other guy?
Hellish, with company.
She smiled grimly.
She had one thing to do then, and one thing only.
She strapped herself in, and forced herself to make the preparations, going slowly and stating each action out loud, just so she wouldn’t miss any. She had the rover’s computer on, but it wasn’t as sophisticated as some other equipment she had used, equipment that could advise her when she was making a misstep.
She didn’t think she was, even though it had been a long time since she tried anything like this.
Worst case, she’d be stuck here.
At least, she tried.
Her muscles were trembling from the exertion and the adrenalin. She had no choice, and somehow that was all freeing. She started the command sequence, and let it run, feeling the rover shudder as the power built in its engines.
She hadn’t checked the vents. She had no idea if the snow and ice blocked them. Too late to send some kind of clearing heat through the vents or a bit of garbage or anything. Too late—
The rover groaned—a sound she had never heard before—then vibrated. For a moment she worried that it might explode. She hadn’t considered that.
Then she leaned back in the pilot’s chair. If the rover exploded, she died, and she wouldn’t have to worry about any of this anymore.
Somehow that thought gave her comfort. As she calmed down, the rover lurched and then moved sideways.
At that moment, she realized the rover was already jettisoning upward, through the gusts and the storm, buffeting in the gigantic winds. She simply couldn’t see anything, because she hadn’t set up the nav panel that way.
And now there was no point. She would know if they had made it out when the rover stopped vibrating, when everything felt smooth.
She gripped the arms of her chair, hoping—maybe even praying—and then…the vibration stopped.
She tapped the nav panel, saw that the rover was above the storm now, and heading out of the atmosphere.
She had to orbit the planet until the storm abated, but she could now.
She was going to make it.
Maya leaned her head back and sighed. The shakes began, as they always did for her once a crisis ended.
Only the crisis wasn’t quite over. She didn’t know what she had brought on board.
She leaned forward, accessed the ClaaLorus Systems’ news net, and typed in the name of the prison transport.
And then she saw the notice.
She had been right: the man she had not saved had used a guard to get into an escape pod and somehow, even though there had been no emergency on the transport, managed to get the pod away from the ship. Everyone thought the guard was dead.
But he wasn’t. She had him.
And the prisoner—one Maximus Connera, a man who had left a string of bodies all over this sector—he was dead, down in the ice with his pod, his attempt foiled.
By her.
She ran a hand over her face, and let out a small half-laugh of wonder. Would she have even tried to rescue the pod if she had known what it was? Would she have pulled the guard free?
She had no idea.
She was glad she hadn’t known, glad she had made the decision based on the life signs alone.
Because she was no judge or jury. She didn’t have to make decisions like that.
She had been in the ice because she hadn’t wanted her own people to risk their lives for a piece of broken-down equipment. She hadn’t wanted any other lives on her conscience.
She wasn’t sure if she’d have one. Maximus. Such a name. She could barely remember what he looked like—that battered face—but his voice would haunt her. The way that it dripped menace. The way that it half-floated away in the wind.
He hadn’t asked for her help. She was glad of that. She had no idea what she would have done if he begged her to help him.
She leaned back in the pilot’s chair and closed her eyes, just for a moment.
Base medical would have to deal with the man she rescued. They would have to work with her as well.
Once she got back, she wouldn’t have to worry about any of this. She wouldn’t have to worry about the equipment or storms or anything.
She was applying for a medical leave. She needed the rest. And she would take it, maybe even put in for a transfer to somewhere warm.
She’d have to learn all new equipment, but that was okay. She was ready to.
Because this was extreme. And she was tired of extreme.
She needed easy from now on.
Although she doubted she would get it.
Ice Breakers
Copyright© 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
First published in Mission Critical, edited by Jonathan Strahan, Solaris 2019.
Cover and Layout copyright © 2022 by WMG Publishing
Cover design by Allyson Longueira
Cover art copyright © novelo/Depositphotos
I read a lot in December because I switched my schedule around, and prioritized a few other things. (I’ll probably blog about that at some point.) Having effective glasses also helped, more than I expected.
I don’t have hardly any holiday stories to recommend because we set our deadlines for next year’s Holiday Spectacular in December. I’ve been reading a lot of great holiday stories, just not ones you’ll see for a while. If you want to see previous versions, pick up the individual anthologies or the big annual anthology (2022’s will appear in July).
I was still a sensitive soul when it came to other reading. Never did pick The Best American Essays back up. I found a lot of comfort in Annalee Newitz’s book (below) on lost cities, because it confirmed that humanity just continues. I guess I needed that. Tried to start a John Baxter book, but it felt familiar (not his fault) so clearly that wasn’t what I wanted to read.
There’s a lot of fiction here, and fun things to recommend. I hope you enjoy all of it.
December, 2022Cantrell, Rebecca, “Twinkle (A Joe Tesla Christmas), Yultide Thrills: A Christmas Anthology, 2023. I had a moment as I read this story. I love Rebecca Cantrell’s work, but she often violates my reader rules. I decided life’s too short to read about children or pets in jeopardy (and yes, I know. I’m a hypocrite. I put children and pets in jeopardy in my work). But for relaxation, I try to avoid those things. Rebecca has no qualms about threatening every living creature in one of her books, and sometimes she carries through with those threats. Writers, that adds to stakes.
So I started her collection of Christmas stories. I can relate to the introduction, but in it, she says the stories get progressively darker. Now realize I have not yet read her Joe Tesla novels. So I had no idea how those stories work. And what should happen right off the bat? A little girl appears with a kitten in her pocket. Now, if this were the Hannah Vogel series, I’d be super worried. Okay, I was super worried anyway. So I peeked at the ending, saw that I could tolerate it, and went back and read the entire heartwarming and remarkable tale. I loved it.
It was the only holiday story I read this year. The season, as I said above, got away from me. I didn’t even get to finish the collection. But I will. It’s on my next-year holiday pile. And I may even sneak it in earlier.
Clavería López, Raquel, “Valor social de la fotografia de guerra: Robert Capa en la Guerra civil española,” Documentacion del las Ciencias de la Informacion (Vol. 38), 2015. You knew this was going to happen, right? With all of the Spanish reading I did this past semester, you knew I had to recommend something. We did a paper in which we chose three articles or essays about a favorite topic. For me (author of “Gallery of His Dreams,”) that topic is war photography. The work of Robert Capa in the Spanish Civil War has always haunted me. I saw a display of his work in New York about twenty years ago, and read a short bio.
Still, I managed to miss at least half of the images presented in this essay. Special bonus here is the analysis, some of which I didn’t know. Even if you don’t read Spanish, you might want to click on the link and look at some of the most startling photojournalism of the 20th Century.
Connelly, Michael, Desert Star, Little, Brown and Company, 2022. I can’t tell you what Connelly did in this book that is so very gutsy, but trust me, if you’ve read any Harry Bosch books, you’ll be stunned by this one. I certainly was. The book itself is compelling, the characterization and cases sterling as (almost) always. The book would have been strong even if Connelly hadn’t done the gutsy thing. Since he did, though, I really can’t tell you too much about the book. You’ll just have to read it. Only…don’t make it your first Bosch book. Read one of the others, then get to this one. You’ll be glad you did.
Hibberd, James, “Sylvester Stallone Gets Candid About Career, Regrets, Feuds: I Thought I Knew Everything,” The Hollywood Reporter, November 9, 2022. I have mixed feelings about Sylvester Stallone. Depending on when you talked to me in my life, I would tell you that I hated his work or reluctantly liked it or that some of it was a guilty pleasure. I veered from thinking he was admirable to thinking he was an asshole to landing somewhere in between.
But I can’t deny that he’s had a hell of a career. He does talk about it candidly in this article. There’s some news made here too, in his discussion of his Rocky contracts which sound absolutely hideous. So, no matter how you feel about Stallone, read the article and see how to have a very long career. That, at least, is something he has managed that many, many, many other artists in a variety of fields have not. There’s always something to learn from someone who has been around for decades. And you can find some of that here.
Mateos, Evelyn, “Mural Mission,” Las Vegas Weekly, October 6-12, 2022. I figured I would share something lovely. I know not all of you can travel to Las Vegas, but one of the coolest thing about the city in the past five years or so is the rise of street art. Murals are everywhere, mostly thanks to the Life is Beautiful festival in September. The rise of the murals has led to quite a following for some artists. Las Vegas Weekly profiled self-taught artist Juan Ochoa who has done some of my favorite murals in the city. The article is free. Take a look at his work, and read about how he taught himself. It’s fascinating.
McDermid, Val, 1989, Atlantic Monthly Press, 2022. In some ways, knowing the events that Val McDermid is writing about both enhanced and diminished the story. I knew who she was talking about and what his death was actually like (even though she used a different name and different death). I also know how it feels to cover horrible stories, like the Lockerbie bombing. Everything rings true in this novel, even though it’s not much of a mystery. More an exploration of an era. As such, it’s brilliant and somewhat heartbreaking. At times, I found it slow going because I was not quite ready to go back to those years. Still, I can’t wait for the next book in the series.
Methos, Victor, The Hallows, Thomas & Mercer, 2019. I have no idea what made me buy this book. It was on my TBR pile for four years. I finally picked it up because I was in the mood for a legal thriller.
It’s my kind of book. Lawyer, down on his luck, ends up at the hometown he fled and gets embroiled in a case that involves his past and everything else. The town, in Utah, is only an hour or so from Las Vegas (can you say St. George? I bet you can. No, wait! River Falls!), which made for some interesting reading, since Methos is familiar with both places. I know what dive bar he’s talking about in part of the book, on which street, as well as a few of the other shady places.
I loved the character and the book and the story, and wanted to buy more, but it looks like a one-off. Everything else appears to be kid-in-jeopardy or woman-dies-horribly standard thriller which is just not to my taste. Oh, and he’s published by Thomas & Mercer, which means that I can only give you the Amazon ebook link. I put the B&N paper link behind the cover art. But really, if you’re going to be traditionally published, go with someone who can get you out wide, not in only a handful of places. Finding the book info to share was highly annoying.
Newitz, Annalee, Four Lost Cities: A Secret History of the Urban Age, Norton, 2021. I loved this book. I have marked several pages for ideas and just great insights. Annalee Newitz examines four cities that morphed into something else, although the Victorians liked to call them “lost.” The book is quite personal, discussing times that Newitz themself went to dig sites or talked with experts. But the information here is wonderful as well. I learned quite a few things about Pompeii that I hadn’t known, and finally had a chance to read about the culture in the American Midwest that built mounds in St. Louis (and all along the Mississippi). I went to Beloit College my first year, and it was built on some ancient mounds. That always bothered me; I felt like (in those dark days) the college did not respect those mounds. I haven’t been back in more than 40 years, so I have no idea if that has changed.
I found this book uplifting and fascinating and, as a popular history, quite easy to read. Even though this isn’t my usual area of nonfiction, I never felt talked down to or felt like Newitz overexplained. I highly recommend this book. It’s fascinating.
Quick, Amanda, When She Dreams, Berkeley, 2022. I’ll be honest: I didn’t like this book as much as I’ve liked others in the series. But this is comparing Amanda Quick to Amanda Quick, and in all cases with this series, I’ve read the books rapidly and enjoyed them a lot. This one is about mistaken identities (always a favorite of mine) and murder in a 1930s movie kinda way. I think that’s what I like the most about this series. Quick captures the feel of the old 1930s movies and does it perfectly.
A great diversion for a winter night.
I used to train radio news announcers. I trained them how to read live and on air, a skill I learned myself while still in college. In 2021, I took a voiceover class from an impressive-as-hell studio here in Las Vegas, with the full intention that I would somehow get my books into audio. I had hoped to hire a voice actor or two, or perhaps go back and do the work myself.
Life got in the way. I must say, though, that my instructors were positive about what I was doing (I hadn’t lost my chops), although I knew I had a lot to learn.
I fully intend to return to the studio, probably this summer. Getting my books into audio has been a goal since I broke up with Audible a few years back. (That’s a long story, filled with terrible editors [who were later fired], including one who disrespected me so badly that I canceled my Audible subscription in a fit of pique.) I know I have readers who prefer audio for a variety of reasons, and I’m not helping them at all by delaying my return to the format.
Years ago, in an argument with a friend, I identified myself as an audio snob, which isn’t entirely true. I do love hearing a book read well. My problem is that I trained people, so I listen with a critical ear. I correct news announcers all the time—on TV, on the radio, in a podcast, on advertisements. There are words we all learn first as readers that we mispronounce in the moment because we learned them wrong. (This is a major problem in English.) I correct them out loud when I hear that mispronunciation.
But, over the years, I realized I’m not really an audio snob, not like I used to be. I listen to a lot of podcasts—in 2x speed which isn’t how the speaker intended. I listen to some Spanish podcasts at normal speed or at half speed just so I can get the words. And yes, I’ve listened to audiobooks like that too, particularly if I think they’re “badly” read.
Why? Because I want the content. I’m not there for the performance. I’m there for the material. Which is why, when I can, I listen to the author read their own work, even if they’re terrible at it. I want to know where they emphasize a sentence, what meaning they give to certain parts of the story, what they chose to highlight.
It’s a way that I learn.
As I dithered about audio, everything changed. Joanna Penn first notified me about that almost a decade ago now, at one of our Business Master Classes. She talked about AI audio, reminded me that some sight-impaired readers used the (then) flat voice provided by online services to read the work if the work wasn’t in audio.
She challenged me. Don’t you want your readers to have that choice? I did, and I didn’t. I wanted a certain quality back then, a quality that I don’t even value myself right now.
Of course, at that point, AI audio was only a few steps above that flat reader voice. Maybe at the flat-reader voice stage. A voice robotically reading something. Readers could chose a male voice, a female voice, a particular accent, and that was about it.
Oh, baby, has AI audio advanced since then. Enough so that in 2020, I thought about using the low level of AI audio for this weekly blog, but never got around to it.
Now, though, AI audio has reached the level that I had both hoped and feared. According to an article this month in ArsTecnica, Microsoft has created a program called VALL-E…
that can closely simulate a person’s voice when given a three-second audio sample. Once it learns a specific voice, VALL-E can synthesize audio of that person saying anything—and do it in a way that attempts to preserve the speaker’s emotional tone.
There are so many ways to misuse this technology that it’s terrifying. And yet, I could make people say things they never intended back in the early 1980s. It just took a little longer. (It also took a recording on tape, a grease pencil, a razor blade and some audio adhesive tape.) What’s old is new—or at least, a lot more convenient.
Also, it’s in the hands of everyone who wants it now.
When I first came up with this year’s list for the year in review, I was going to give AI audio, and audio in general, its own special section. It really needs one. Brandon Sanderson discussed his choices for audiobooks in his yearly update. He’s leaving Audible because he calls the way they treat authors (particularly indie) “unconscionable.” He’s delivering his audiobooks through other sites. I suggest you take a look at what he’s doing, because it’s one way to handle audio.
Joanna Penn has another way entirely. She has narrated her own audiobooks for years, and she also uses AI-generated audiobooks. She marks her digital audio products in a very specific way. She makes sure that the buyer knows whether they’re getting a human voice or an AI-generated voice. She lets the buyer decide.
In May, Joanna did a long episode on her podcast that explored AI-audio in all its messy glory. She looks at the ethical issues, the ways writers can develop their own audio, and the ways they can market it.
In this year in review series, I can’t do any better than she has already done. Frankly, I’m at the beginning of my AI-audio career and she’s deep into it. So take a look at her advice.
Because I have one foot in the voiceover world (okay, maybe a toe), I’ve been following the issues with AI audio quite closely. Actors have had real problems with it for a long time now, afraid that their voices would be taken without their permission. I’ve been following SAG-AFTRA’s work on this for years. (SAG-AFTRA is the Screen Actors Guild–American Federation of Television and Radio Artists.) SAG-AFTRA is truly at the forefront of defending the rights of artists in the face of AI.
AI audio has had a seat at the audiobooks table for several years now, but the story of 2022 was AI-generated art. Platforms like Midjourney use text descriptions to produce art. The art is sometimes so good that it wins awards, when the person who ordered it up puts it in contests designed for human artists.
The problems with AI-generated art are so vast that I really can’t deal with them here. Since many of you will ask me if I use any on my book covers, I don’t. Right now, the copyright issues are not settled. Just this month, a trio of artists filed a class action lawsuit against Stability AI and Midjourney, creators of AI art generators Stable Diffusion and Midjourney, and artist portfolio platform DeviantArt, which recently created its own AI art generator, DreamUp. According to an article in The Verge
The artists — Sarah Andersen, Kelly McKernan, and Karla Ortiz — allege that these organizations have infringed the rights of “millions of artists” by training their AI tools on five billion images scraped from the web “without the consent of the original artists.”
The problem they’ve pointed out here isn’t just a problem with art. It exists with many AI-generated programs, from the ones who develop code to art to music. It’s a problem that needs to be settled before I can comfortably use any AI-generated art on book covers, for example.
The cases are appearing so fast that I can’t keep track of all of them. For example, an AI-generated comic book got copyright protection earlier in the year, but in December the U.S. Copyright Office opened a case to revoke the comic book’s copyright. As I said above, this will take quite a while to settle out.
In November, OpenAI released ChatGPT, which can create all kinds of text (among other things). It’s not the first AI text program, nor will it be the last. But the release created a panic among writers. It also caused a huge stir in academia, causing The Atlantic to declare that the college essay was dead and no one would learn critical thinking ever again.
Clearly Stephen Marche, the author of that essay, is an honest sort. I had a friend in college who made a living writing essays for desperate college students. They missed the exercise in critical thinking as well.
Yeah, ChatGPT would have put my friend out of business back in the day (and is probably putting other people out of business now), but cheaters cheat.
Will readers want AI-generated text? I have no idea. I’m not sure how to feel about this, though. “Creating text” is not all fiction writers do. We don’t just create text. We create stories, from our own perspectives with our own voices.
Still, there’s a worry that artificially created text will overtake regular text by creatives. Already, two months into the program, a programmer has developed a way to figure out whether a human or ChatGPT created an essay. He’s marketing a program that colleges and universities can use the way they use online plagiarism finder programs to see if a student uses their own words.
Technology battling technology. It’s truly the Wild West out there right now on all of this AI-generated stuff.
I’m waiting for it to shake out. Right now, all AI-generated programs that cross into the arts also tread on intellectual property rights as well as the livelihoods of creators. There are ethical issues for all of these programs as well as questions about the future of certain kinds of artistic expression.
What will probably happen—be it a few years from now or a decade or two—is that these AI generation programs will become new tools for creatives. Right now, a lot of creatives are using the audio programs to their advantage. I can see some of the writing programs and art programs being the same.
As I write this, I’ve also been noodling with a fantasy map generator. It’s not an AI program, but something designed to help people who are playing games. I am a terrible artist. I can’t draw worth spit. And I need a map for the Fey books.
The map of the world and its various continents exist in my head. There’s a chicken-scratched version on various sheets of paper scattered around my office. It makes no sense to anyone but me.
So I used a free fantasy map generator to communicate those chicken scratchings into something that a real artist can then use to make a beautiful piece of art.
In other words, my map is a communication tool. Most of the details on it are wrong. (I had to correct that part in an accompanying letter.) But it gets the message across.
I’m not yet sure how we professional writers could use the text tool. I see how non-professional writers can use it to get ideas across, just like I used that fantasy map generator.
I also am fully onboard with AI-generated audio products, so long as we identify them as such, as Joanna Penn is doing.
What I’m seeing, from this vantage of early 2023, is the beginning of a revolution. Where it’ll take us, I have no idea.
But the changes wrought by computers has come to a head in the past year or two. We can publish and distribute our own books. We can make a solid living at writing, if we use the tools (like crowd-funding) available to us. We can do our own audiobooks and distribute those. We don’t have to use the big e-retailers if we don’t want to.
So much has changed that it’s almost overwhelming. Scratch that. It is overwhelming.
I’m going to be spending 2023 learning the audio tool and doing some other work on things I mentioned in the previous posts. I’ll elaborate on what I’m doing on Patreon as well as in this blog—when I feel like I can safely share. Or when I feel confident enough in what I’m doing to teach.
Right now, I’m as new to the AI platforms as most of you are. I’m monitoring the copyright battles very closely, and I’m watching what the savvy artists representatives at SAG-AFTRA are doing to defend the work of actors (and others) as these programs grow.
I’m not sure where all this is going to lead. I have ideas, but they’re partially based on ignorance. I’m not informed enough yet to trust my own opinions.
What I do know is this: 2023 will be very interesting—on all kinds of fronts. And we’ll investigate it all together.
As I mentioned in a previous blog, I’ve started recommending classes that we teach in this part of the post. I started this in part due to the changes in social media. But also because WMG just set up a searchable website for all of our online classes. (Before all we had was Teachable, which is not easily searchable.)
Since I don’t have anything on AI, yet, let me recommend once again Bite-Size Copyright. Understanding copyright is the best way to protect yourself, even in this new world we’re entering into.
And…as I say every week, this blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynrusch to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: AI The Year in Review Part 9,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © Can Stock Photo / studiostoks
It has been a very busy start to the year. I just finished teaching an in-person workshop, which we held at Resorts World. It’s a lovely venue (unlike the Golden Nugget), and we had a great time. I’m hoping the students enjoyed it as much as I did. I’m teaching two more workshops there this year—one in May and one in July—which you can find out about here.
Speaking of workshops, WMG Publishing has a newsletter called “Every Day’s A Holiday.” If you subscribe, you get a weekly discount on a workshop as well as a free story. Every week.
And one more thing to do with workshops…we have two special workshops in the current Fantasies Collide Kickstarter. One is called Found Fantasy and the other is Fantasy From Your Life. They’re only available in the Kickstarter, which will vanish in two days. Not to mention that backers at $30 and above will receive six fantasy popup workshops as part of the stretch rewards we have already hit. So head over. Here’s the link again: http://kck.st/3i8W81M I really love this Kickstarter. The basis is five books with twenty short stories, ten from me and ten from Dean. These are all fantasy stories, grouped together by theme. Take a look at the covers that Allyson Longueira designed. They’re wonderful.And, in addition to the popups (which you readers can give to writer friends if you want), you’ll get the five books and seven extra fantasy books so far. Those are the stretch rewards. Since we have two days left, we might hit another reward or two.So much is happening. I’m also in a Storybundle with nine other wonderful writers, including Thomas K. Carpenter, Katie Cross, and Emily Martha Sorenson. The bundle is called the Magic Schoolbus, so if you’re like me, and you like stories about magic schools, then this is the bundle for you. Even though there are ten writers, there are fourteen books, including three of my Kristine Grayson books. Those of you who haven’t read the Daughters of Zeus trilogy can do so now, if you get the Storybundle. It’ll cost you $20 for all of these books, which is a heckuva deal.I know I have more to tell you, but my tired brain can’t remember it all. Expect more update posts in the next week or two. And I’ll eventually get to the Recommended Reading List. I’m nearly there, but I have other deadlines first. (Including doing a weird map for the next Fey book.) Life is fun, but strange right now. Which is kinda cool…
When a disturbing postcard arrives at his Atlanta office, Emerson knows he must report it to the NAACP. The postcard, sent by the mysterious Lurleen from Abbotts Creek, Arkansas, depicts yet another lynching. Emerson agrees to travel to Abbotts Creek to investigate, but he knows doing so poses great risk. Emerson only passes as white, and this Lurleen knows his face.
Emerson knows one day his luck will run out. And when he arrives in Abbotts Creek, he soon discovers that day might have come at last.
“The Monster in Our Midst,” by Edgar Award-nominee Kris Nelscott is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook through various online retailers here. You can also find the story in Fiction River: Past Crime, available in ebook and trade paper here.
The Monster in Our MidstKris Nelscott“I ask not only black Americans but white Americans, are you not ashamed of lynching? …The nation today is striving to lead the moral forces of the world in support of the weak against the strong. Well, I’ll tell you it can’t do it until it conquers and crushes this monster in its own midst.”
—James Weldon Johnson
NAACP Field Secretary
The National Conference on Lynching
May 10, 1919
She found the postcard next to the cash register at a general store in a small town in Arkansas. The hand-tinted photograph caught her attention. She picked it up and nearly dropped it in surprise, then glanced at the stout man who owned the place.
He had been measuring a pound of dried beans for her onto a white scale mounted on a solid oak counter. The entire store smelled of spices and coffee, with an undercurrent of Virginia pipe tobacco.
The stout man had dark mistrustful eyes and a fat, petulant mouth. He wore a heavy apron over his white shirt, and his black pants had worn gray at the knees.
He was measuring her as surely as he was measuring those beans.
“My,” she said. “Is this what I think it is?”
“I dunno, miss,” the stout man said. “What do you think it is?”
“Is this that nigra what gave you all the trouble last fall?” she asked. “I heard about these dealings the first time I came through here—what was it, September? Everyone was talking about how safe they was feeling, now that it’d all ended.”
Apparently, she sounded sympathetic enough. The stout man smiled at her, although the smile didn’t reach his eyes.
“That’d be the one,” he said.
He scraped some of the beans off the top of the pile, then tied the white bag he’d put them in.
He paused, then asked pointedly, “Who’re your people?”
She’d run into that question before, and knew how to reply, no matter what name she was answering to.
“My people are in Atlanta now,” she said, “but I was raised due south of here. I’m Lureen Taylor.”
“Thomas Mosby,” he said, almost begrudgingly.
“My husband’s passed,” she said as if she were a lonely woman, unable to stop sharing, “and I don’t like Atlanta. So I’m looking for a good community with solid values where I can live out my days in relative quiet.”
She wasn’t that old, but old enough to make the story believable. It usually softened men like Thomas Mosby, although it didn’t seem to soften this one, maybe because he had seen her surprise when she picked up the postcard.
She still held it between her thumb and forefinger. If she wanted to stay in this little community for even a few days, she needed to alleviate his suspicions.
“I heard about such cards,” she said, waving it slightly. “I have never seen one made from a real event. Usually I seen the photographs of buildings or the paintings from history, never one from a real moment.”
She still couldn’t bring herself to look at it closely.
“We been recording important doings here since before the war,” he said. “We commemorate the things we’re proud of.”
The test comment. She smiled. She was committed now.
“Like you should,” she said, and ran her gloved hand over the postcard’s surface as if it pleased her. “Add this to my purchases, please.”
“I can post it for you,” he said.
“Can you?” She looked pleasantly surprised, even as she felt dismayed. She didn’t have people in Atlanta. She only knew one person there, and only because she’d been told to watch for him. Their paths had crossed on a dark and rainy afternoon three months ago in West Texas. He hadn’t seen her, hadn’t realized who she was, and probably wouldn’t recognize her now.
But she kept track of him there, knowing the danger he’d been in perhaps better than he had.
The kind of danger she was in now.
Thomas Mosby stared at her.
“Do you have a pen?” she asked. “I’ll just put a little note on it, and we can send it. That way, my people will know I’ll be all right here.”
“I most surely do, Mrs. Taylor,” he said, wiping his hands on a towel. He came over to her, handed her a pen and inkwell, and watched as she wrote:
Since you worried I would end up in a community of strangers, I thought I should let you know how safe this little town makes me feel.
She signed it Love, Lureen, and then addressed the card, hoping against hope that nothing else would rouse Thomas Mosby’s suspicions.
As soon as the ink was dry, he took the postcard from her and put it in a mailbag, but not before looking at the photograph. He nodded at it, as if he approved.
She forced herself to look down at the rest of the pile, since she couldn’t buy another. Mosby would ask why she wasn’t mailing that one, and they both knew a genteel woman wouldn’t keep the postcard as a souvenir.
The body hanging from the streetlamp was mercifully blurry. But the body was clearly male with skin darker than the skin of every person in the crowd. Some were looking up happily, others holding pistols. One young man near the post held a Bowie knife as if he planned to use it.
She wasn’t going to ask if they’d cut and dried some actual souvenirs. She didn’t want to hear the answer, suspecting it would be in the affirmative.
“It was not two blocks from here,” Mosby said. “Right outside the courthouse. The new sheriff, he thought that he could send that boy to Little Rock. And, truthfully, that boy might be in Little Rock, if Little Rock is your version of hellfire.”
Then Mosby laughed, a loud braying sound that hurt almost as much as his words.
The hair rose on the back of her head, but she smiled anyway, as if she thought him the most amusing creature she’d ever seen.
She took her coin purse out of her bag. She couldn’t stay in the store much longer before she started shivering.
“How much do I owe you, Mr. Mosby?” she asked.
He told her. After she handed him the money, he held the small cloth sack he’d prepared for her.
“Welcome to Abbotts Creek, Mrs. Taylor,” he said.
“Thank you, Mr. Mosby,” she said. “Words fail when I try to tell you how happy I am to be here.”
***The postcard arrived on Emerson West’s desk on a bright May morning, in a stack of mail bundled and tied with a harsh brown string. The warm yellow sunlight streamed across his oak desk, which he’d had made special back when he opened his detecting agency a decade ago.
He liked the early mornings; the office was brighter than it would be for the rest of the day, giving him a sense of possibility. He hadn’t lost his optimism in the face of everything he’d investigated, or the frustrations he encountered. But sometimes he needed something as simple as sunlight to remind him of the good in the world.
Fortunately, most of the jobs he had done since he returned to Atlanta had been small ones such as accompanying clients who couldn’t read or write to the courthouse to fill out paperwork, thereby ensuring that the white government clerk didn’t misspell or simply fail to file the pertinent form. Some jobs were a little larger, mostly occasioned by America’s entrance into the war a year ago April. So many young men had joined up without telling their families, and finding the documentation or getting someone to reveal the military records was harder than it should have been.
Now, with 1918 not quite half done, rumors had started that the war would end within six months, but Emerson had no idea how. The newspapers proudly proclaimed that thousands of men per day were sailing overseas to get involved in Europe’s conflict, which meant that thousands of men would die there.
Emerson was privately glad that he was too old to consider going to war. Twenty years ago, he would have proudly joined up, although back then, he would have had to make a choice between enrolling under a lie to become a respected soldier or telling the truth and serving in a segregated unit.
His light brown hair, pale skin, and blue eyes made it easy for him to pass for white. He had studiously avoided passing because it meant disavowing his family. His mother had skin the color of coffee with cream. His father was darker, but was at least one-quarter white. Emerson’s paternal grandfather had been the man who owned his grandmother. Emerson’s mother never said where her white blood had originated.
Emerson had never pressed her, and now the time had passed. His parents both died ten years on now, just after he married. His wife was gone too—childbirth had taken her and the baby—and Emerson saw no point in making new ties.
These days, he passed more often than he had in all of his youth. However, he only did so when he needed information for his detecting business.
The detecting agency had started as a lark, but it had become his life. And because he was now free of family and obligation, he could go places, and do things he would never have considered as a much younger man.
The postcard slid out before he even had a chance to untie the string. He saw the back first, his name written above the words “Atlanta, Georgia,” which were the only things that served as any kind of address.
The postmark had been made four days before in Abbotts Creek, Arkansas. He did not know anyone there. He had never heard of Abbotts Creek before this moment.
The same confident hand that had addressed the card to him had also written:
Since you worried I would end up in a community of strangers, I thought I should let you know
how safe this little town makes me feel.
Love, Lureen
He didn’t know anyone named Lureen. But he had seen this handwriting three times before. Before he looked through his files to make certain his memory was accurate, he turned the postcard over—and dropped it, wiping his hand on his black pants almost without thinking.
He let out a breath, reminded himself that he had seen worse, and picked up the postcard. It was a photograph showing a man hanging from a street lamp, with dozens of whites around him, most of them looking like they had achieved something great.
The dead man was blurry, probably in his death throes, and if he had been touched up, he had only had his skin darkened. But other spots of color were added throughout the postcard—red neckties and handkerchiefs, some light pink added to women’s cheeks and lips, and a bit of silvery paint along parts of the lamppost.
In thick white ink along the bottom, someone had written September 19, 1917.
Emerson turned the postcard back over. He couldn’t look at the dead man any longer, nor could he stomach those jubilant white faces.
He had spent nearly two years investigating lynchings for the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People. Walter White, who had started the Atlanta branch, had hired Emerson to accompany him on several trips into rural Georgia to investigate reports of lynchings.
White, like Emerson, could—and often did—pass.
Once Emerson was trained, White engaged his services using NAACP money to send him all over the South to gather information. Emerson had gone to Louisiana, Alabama, and Mississippi, and things had mostly gone smoothly. The only time he felt truly unmasked was in West Texas, not because he got caught or even challenged, but because he couldn’t pass for a Texan. His accent was wrong, and the attitudes he’d learned to mimic, so common in the rest of the rural South, seemed dangerously liberal in the tiny Texas towns to which he’d been assigned.
Emerson sat in his office chair and looked at that postcard. He had heard from Walter White just last week, and White had said nothing about a new case. The NAACP was turning its findings into a report they would publish to help support Congressman Leonidas Dyer’s anti-lynching bill.
With the war, the excellent performance of the colored troops on the field of battle, and the horrible race riots last year in Dyer’s home state of Missouri, the NAACP felt the time was right.
With all that Emerson had seen, he had no idea if there was a good time for that sort of bill, even with strong white Republican support. But his was not to question. His was to gather facts, so that the report to the NAACP was accurate, not filled with hate-talk and rumor.
He’d been paid well to venture into communities his father could never have walked through. And Emerson tried, always, to keep in mind the victims, especially the ones who were murdered and buried without so much as a by-your-leave. He suspected that some of the young men he’d searched for these past two months had not joined up to fight Over There, as the song said, but instead, had died horribly in some dark Georgia backwater, where no one would talk to outsiders, not even outsiders with the right accent and skin color.
But his beliefs didn’t matter. He kept doing the work, knowing someone had to report the truth. He knew that very few people could even attempt it.
Generally, the request for information came from the Atlanta or New York NAACP offices, not directly like this. But if the handwriting here was from the person who had sent the previous postcards, then perhaps he owed her enough to figure out why she had sent the card directly to him.
He stood and went to the matching wooden filing cabinet and unlocked the bottom drawer. That was where he kept his lynching files. He was afraid—even now—that he could get in trouble for the work he had done, so he kept them hidden. If someone wanted the files badly enough, they could break in, but he knew the lock would discourage the most casual searcher.
Emerson pulled out three, all of which had come from Walter White. Two had been handed to Emerson in the Atlanta offices; the most recent one had been mailed from the New York office. He opened the files, one on top of the other, and pulled out trifolded envelopes that White had included in the larger envelopes he sent.
The Atlanta trifolded envelopes had been addressed to Walter White at his former home address in the city. The New York trifold was addressed to Walter White care of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, New York, NY, the same sort of vague address that had shown up on this postcard.
Inside those envelopes were postcards decorated with equally grim photographs, and a single page from what clearly had been a much longer letter, detailing what little the correspondent knew about the depicted scenes.
One postcard was an actual illustration, with a hand-drawn caricature of a young colored man dancing across flames as he tried to flee white-hooded members of the Ku Klux Klan. The illustration looked like something from a minstrel show, and disturbed Emerson almost as much as did the two photographic postcards.
Their subject matter was the same as the one on Emerson’s desk. He did not look at the photographs again; he did not need to. They were indelibly embedded in his mind, graphic depictions of murder, something the photographer (and those who sent the postcard) believed to be a celebration.
None of those postcards had any writing on them. The letter writer had found them and sent them, along with whatever the correspondent had discovered, to Walter White for investigation.
But the one Emerson had just received was different. It had writing on it. It was addressed to Emerson directly.
And it was signed Lureen.
He had always suspected the handwriting belonged to a woman, although he could not say why. Now, he had confirmation of it.
Emerson ran his fingers along the postcard.
He needed to speak to White before he went to Arkansas all alone. And Emerson needed to discover if White knew more about this mysterious Lureen than he had told Emerson in the past.
***The Atlanta Branch could not afford the expense of a telephone, not even one with a party line. But the office did have use of a telephone at the Atlanta University, and that telephone was expensive and private.
Emerson had graduated from Atlanta University eighteen years ago now with a teaching degree he had used for only a decade. Still, he was proud to say he was part of the oldest Negro university in the United States—not that anyone asked any longer.
The telephone was located in the office of the president, and could only be used with advance permission or on NAACP business. Emerson had placed the postcard in an envelope, planning to use it with the secretary if she refused to let him call the New York office.
She did not refuse. Apparently, she understood the look on his face.
The president’s office was book-lined and smelled of cigars. Papers strewn about the desk did not concern Emerson, but the secretary covered them with a blotter, apparently worried that he would snoop.
He stood at the front of the desk, and picked up the black candlestick telephone. He placed the cone-shaped receiver against his right ear and spoke into the mouthpiece, asking the operator to call the New York office of the NAACP. He hoped she would not remain on the line after the call connected, but he couldn’t guarantee it.
He also couldn’t ask her to sign off, because that would alert her to the private nature of the call, and would probably make her more likely to listen in.
A young man answered, and Emerson asked for Walter White. The young man set the receiver down and went in search. Feeling nervous, Emerson glanced at the clock on a nearby bookshelf. The local branch would be angry if this call went on too long. He hadn’t approved it through them, and telephone calls were expensive.
White answered within a few minutes.
Emerson quickly told him about the postcard, and concluded with, “I want you to decide what I should do with this. I can forward it to you. However, if you would like me to investigate, all I need is the promise of an authorization and payment. I still have half your fee from the last job in my bank accounts and can fund this trip myself.”
White did not answer immediately, which made Emerson’s heart pound. He knew that the connection had not been severed because he could hear the hum of the wires.
Finally, White said, “I am disturbed by the method in which the postcard reached you. It is not our agreed-upon method.”
Emerson knew that, which was why he was calling. He was about to say so, when White continued.
“The woman who calls herself Lureen here is to contact me with evidence she finds of lynchings that she believes I am unaware of. I am then to dispatch an investigator, or to go myself in some cases.”
Emerson closed his mouth, and silently cursed the infernal machine he was using. He couldn’t see White, which interfered with the communication. He knew that White spoke deliberately, a habit that had served him well, and often his voice remained calm while his blue eyes blazed with fury.
Emerson wondered if that were true now.
“You can reach Arkansas faster than I can,” White said. “I would like you to investigate. Your normal fee will be awaiting you when you return.”
“Let me clarify,” Emerson said. “You want me to do what I usually do. You want me to gather facts on the lynching from last September.”
“Yes,” White said.
“I am not going to search for Lureen,” Emerson said, deliberately not making that a question.
“Good heavens, no,” White said. “I would hope that she has left the vicinity already.”
“Hope is one thing,” Emerson said, thinking of the missing young men he had been unable to track down. “But it is not certainty.”
“Indeed,” White said. “However, my agreement with this woman we are calling Lureen does not include running to her rescue. She does know that we have a legal budget should she get in trouble with the law.”
Emerson’s heart was pounding hard. “Does a legal budget matter? Isn’t she in danger of dying the same way the man in the postcard did?”
“Generally, no,” White said, his tone so curt that Emerson knew he wasn’t to ask more about the woman.
Still, he couldn’t resist one last question. “What is your agreement with her?”
“She found us,” White said. “She does this of her own accord, for reasons she has not explained. Every time I have offered to pay her or asked her to have an assistant, she has not only refused, but she has gone silent. However, I did ask her one favor three months ago. I asked her to keep an eye on you, and if you got into trouble to contact one of our branches—and me—immediately.”
“West Texas,” Emerson murmured.
“Yes,” White said. “We lost our normal investigator there. We have not found him to this day. I was afraid the same might happen to you. I wanted her to let me know the moment trouble began.”
“And that’s how she knew my name,” Emerson said.
“Yes,” White said. “It was quite a risk, since, to my knowledge she and I have never met. But I believed she would give you no trouble in Atlanta.”
“She hasn’t,” Emerson said, although he wondered what the post office thought of his receipt of such a postcard.
“I could send a different investigator if you are worried,” White said.
“Are you?” Emerson asked.
“It is unusual,” White said, “and she knows what you look like. There is more risk than you would normally face.”
Emerson clutched the center of the candlestick phone. He already knew these jobs were dangerous ones. And as White said, Emerson was closer than someone from New York or Boston. Emerson was a trusted investigator. So many others lacked the finesse to work in the rural areas where the bulk of these murders occurred.
“I understand the risk,” Emerson said. “I accept it. You will get the usual report from me in a week or two.”
After he hung up the receiver, he sat for a moment in the unfamiliar office, breathing in the lingering cigar smoke.
He had just volunteered to go back into the fight, one that had already exhausted him and taken most of his sleep, as surely as it had stolen a lot of his good nature.
But the images he had seen, the stories he had been told, would not leave his mind. He would get little rest here or in Abbotts Creek.
He set the telephone down and stood up.
He was going to go, even if it was the last thing he ever did.
***Abbotts Creek was in Phillips County, slap dab in the middle of the Arkansas Delta. For such a small place, the town itself seemed prosperous enough. Emerson’s train had veered past what was clearly the main street that had several red brick buildings that seemed new—no more than fifteen years old.
The train station itself looked to support a much larger town. It had two levels and a large arrivals area, with solid wood benches and marble floors. The entire interior smelled new.
As Emerson and four others emerged from the train, the ticket agent behind the big arrivals and departures window, looked up, smiled and nodded, then returned to whatever it was he’d been doing.
Emerson let out a small breath. He would most likely be fine. He had a card identifying him as a reporter with the Atlanta Journal, only the name on it was Earl S. West, since he’d learned that the name Emerson wasn’t sufficiently Southern for some whites. In fact, it suggested a Northern man of liberal education, something his father aspired to, but which had become a handicap for Emerson in communities where he was unknown.
Usually, there were signs posted about the nearest boarding house. He couldn’t see any, so he walked over to the ticket agent. The ticket agent was a small man, with freshly cut red hair, and thin mustache. He looked to be about Emerson’s age, and just as tired.
The ticket agent had changed the sign behind him mentioning the next day’s train, and seemed about to close up.
“Beg pardon,” Emerson said. “I’d be much obliged if you could point me to a boarding house.”
The ticket agent looked up, frowned at him, that friendly smile gone as if it never had been. Had the ticket agent been looking at someone else when he smiled a few moments ago?
“Miss Dottie usually takes new arrivals,” the ticket agent said. “But they usually write ahead. Who did you say you were?”
“I didn’t say.” Emerson smiled as he spoke. “My name is Earl West, and I’m afraid I’m horribly unfamiliar with the local customs. I ask your forgiveness for that.”
“You should ask for Miss Dottie’s. It’s her you’ll be inconveniencing.” The ticket agent made a show of stamping some documents. The slap of the stamp echoed in the large space. “What business brings you here?”
Emerson reached into the pocket of his waistcoat, and pulled out his credentials. “I’m a reporter with the Atlanta Journal. We’re doing a series of articles on the recent sharecropping troubles, and we’d heard that most communities in the Delta had had some difficulties.”
The ticket agent’s face shuttered even more. “You a union man?”
The question surprised Emerson, and he decided to let the emotion show. “No,” he said with emphasis. “Who’d be wanting to unionize?”
“Some carpetbaggers been talking to the nigras around here, stirring them up, saying payments is off. Trouble started last fall, been spreading all over the Delta. Surprised you hadn’t heard.”
Especially given the story that Emerson was telling.
“I’d heard about the troubles and the discrepancies. There’s talk like that from here to Mississippi,” Emerson said. “I didn’t realize there was actual union men stirring up the nigras. That’s unusual, don’t you think?”
“I do,” said the ticket agent. “I always think there’s something wrong when one of our own decides that he don’t like us much no more, and decides to spend his time agitating the darkies.”
Emerson suspected that some of the ticket agent’s word choices were designed to irritate any white outsider who was visiting these parts.
“I just came to report on the trouble,” Emerson said. “We haven’t seen much of it yet in Georgia, but my editor doesn’t want anyone to be getting ideas.”
“Those what had ideas are gone now, praise the Lord,” The ticket agent said, and pounded that stamp one more time.
Emerson nodded, knowing better than to push harder. “If I could trouble you for directions…?”
The ticket agent looked up. “Miss Dottie’s is two blocks south on Elm. Go outside, turn left and walk straight. Can’t miss it.”
“I thank you,” Emerson said, and then walked out of the train station, the heels of his shoes clicking on the marble floor. He felt alone and uncomfortable, just like he had every other time he had done these investigations.
He stepped out of the cool station in the warm sunlight, blinking at its brightness. Wood sidewalks and a well-flattened dirt road ran through the center of town. He saw no automobiles, but several fancy horse-drawn carriages. Lots of men and women on foot, almost all unconcerned with the handful of new arrivals at the train station.
Except for a group of white men across the street. They sat outside a building with a fancy restaurant inside, chawin’ and spitting into the nearby spittoons, and watching him like they’d been told to.
The train station was on Cherry Street. Second Street took him past the men and onto what was most likely Elm.
Emerson walked with purpose, as if he had come to Abbotts Creek dozens of times.
The men, all wearing white shirts tucked into black pants held up with suspenders, watched him. He watched them out of the corner of his eye, careful not to appear as if he were actually staring at them.
He crossed into the street, felt the softness of the dirt, which suggested there’d been rains here recently, and then stepped onto the wooden sidewalk.
As far as he could tell, none of the men followed him. He took that as a good sign. He’d been followed too many times in too many other towns just as small as this one in the past.
The next street up was Elm and sure enough, the boarding house was in the middle of the next block—a white clapboard house with gingerbread trim and a well-kept fence. A sign outside said:
Boarding HouseInquire Inside
He squared his shoulders and walked the half block, feeling as if every eye in the town was on him. He opened the gate, and walked across a beautiful path ringed with red and pink flowering plants that he couldn’t name.
The porch had wear on its main steps, and a large brass knocker covered the main part of the solid wood door.
He knocked twice, then waited.
The door eased open part way.
“I’m enquiring about a room,” he said to the dark crack between the door’s edge and its jamb.
“Two dollars per day, ten dollars per week,” said a strong female voice. “Includes breakfast and supper, both at seven sharp. If you don’t arrive for the meal, you don’t get fed.”
A strict boarding house then. He’d stayed in some that were lax. “I presume payment is up front?”
“Yes, sir, and I do not refund.” The door still hadn’t opened all the way.
“If you have room,” he said, “I would like to pay for two nights.”
He hoped that would be all he needed. He always felt as if he was on some kind of good-luck clock when he did this work.
The door opened the rest of the way. Emerson stepped inside. The interior smelled of roasting beef mixed with heavy perfume. The door closed behind him before his eyes adjusted enough to see the heavy-set woman in front of him. She wore her steel-gray hair in a bun. An apron covered a long blue dress that had seen better days.
“I have a register,” she said. “Come with me.”
She led him into the front parlor. There, someone had set up a counter with some fresh flowers in a vase on one side, and an open register on the other.
She handed him a pen and an inkwell, along with a printed card that he had to fill out with his name, his home address, and the length of his stay.
He did all of that, using the address for Atlanta University as his own, and marked down two nights.
He took four dollars from his wallet, and handed them to her along with the card. She took the money and set it with the card, but did not put either away. Apparently she did not want him to know where the money was kept.
Then she shoved the register at him. He paused before signing his name.
The register went back two weeks. On the page across from the empty line where his name would go was the name Lureen Taylor with the city and state left off.
He paused for a moment too long.
“I require my guests to fill out the register,” the woman said.
He did, not apologizing for the extra time it took him to do so. He signed his alias, and added that he was from Atlanta. He decided not to ask about Lureen Taylor. He would find out soon enough if she remained at the boarding house.
The woman nodded, then said, “I’m Dottie and this here’s my house. You will treat it like a home and not some way station, are we clear?”
“Yes, ma’am,” he said.
“Your room is six stairs up. It is the only room on the landing. It’s a mite small but you’re not staying long. If you decide to stay for a week or more, we’ll find you something more comfortable.”
“Thank you, ma’am,” he said.
She almost smiled. It looked like that was as friendly as she got. “Stairs are back in the entry.”
Apparently, she wasn’t going to take him up there.
“Much obliged.” He turned around, taking in the horsehair furniture that looked like no one had sat in it in this century, the occasional tables covered with expensive glassware and shelves with all sorts of little figurines. He did not pause to examine them.
Instead he returned to the entry, and saw the stairs off to his right. He took them, saw the landing, and a door to his left.
The room was more of a walk-in closet than an actual room. He had to duck once inside, because the bulk of the room was under the stairs. A narrow bed with a handmade quilt pushed against the only long wall. A chamber pot peeked out from under the bed. A short table stood beside the bed, with a washbasin and matching pitcher on top. A kerosene lamp had left black stains on the underside of one of the stairs.
A tiny round window, the size of a portal, had been drilled into the wall behind the bed. The window opened, but just barely.
There was no closet, no bureau, and no place to store his things. No wonder she had said that if he decided to stay longer he would get a nicer room. No one could live comfortably in this one for a week.
He set his satchel underneath the table, as far from the chamber pot as he could. He would have thought that a nice house like this would have indoor plumbing. Perhaps it did on the main floor, but he had not been informed of it. He would have to ask somehow, without offending anyone’s sensibilities.
He pulled out his pocket watch. He had two hours until dinner, which meant many of the businesses were closing. He sometimes had to think what an average traveling man would do, and he supposed someone like him would not wander the streets, looking for someone to speak with.
So he removed his shoes and spread out on top of the covers, hoping to get some rest.
The next thing he knew, a gong had sounded below.
He assumed that sound invited all of the boarders to supper.
***The large oak table in the dining room was set for eight. When he arrived, two men were standing near the sideboard, looking at a decanter and glasses. Emerson could only assume they had hoped for some kind of alcohol, but he doubted they would find any. Arkansas, like Georgia, prohibited the sale and manufacture of liquor, and genteel homes like this one did not serve any of it, even if the owner indulged.
The entire first floor smelled heavily of that roast beef, and his stomach growled. Emerson introduced himself to the men as Earl, but he did not mention his profession or give any reason for being in Abbotts Creek.
“You’re in luck,” one of the men said. “Dottie makes the best roast beef in the entire Delta.”
The other man nodded in agreement, then added, “Pay attention to her hints. If she mentions that she’s low on potatoes or needs coffee, then volunteer to pick some up from Abbotts Mercantile. We’ve learned that if we buy some of the supplies, she rewards us with good down-home cooking.”
Emerson smiled and said he would remember that. They exchanged small talk for a while—both men lived in the house and had since their wives died, claiming living here gave them the opportunity to talk with people they wouldn’t normally encounter.
They were inviting him to tell them about himself. Instead, he said, “I see that Miss Dottie also takes female boarders.”
“Yes,” said the first man. “When there are women in the house, we men are confined to the outhouse out back. Fortunately, the last woman left here near to a week ago.”
So much for Lureen. He tried not to look disappointed. As the other boarders showed up, Miss Dottie banged the gong a second time.
This close, it sounded as if the entire house would shake.
The men sat down in what seemed like their usual places, and then Miss Dottie entered, without any food at all, which surprised Emerson. His surprise only lasted a moment though, because a young colored girl, wearing a maid’s uniform, staggered in under the weight of an uncarved roast.
Emerson had to catch himself from helping her. In this town, among the white folk, this girl was an invisible servant, not a lady deserving of assistance. He studiously avoided looking at her, so that he wouldn’t acknowledge her, even as she brought out the rest of the meal.
One of the men carved the roast, then Miss Dottie said grace. She sat at the head of the table, and presided over the conversation like a queen instructing her court.
Emerson didn’t dare bring up any troubles or the sharecropping information he had received. He definitely couldn’t discuss lynching in mixed company, nor could he comfortably mention race issues.
Finally, he managed to turn the conversation to other guests, asking Miss Dottie who the most interesting boarders she had ever had were. She demurred, saying it wasn’t her place to discuss her “people.”
“Miss Dottie always has a fascinating mix,” one of the men said. “Every time I stay here, I meet someone new.”
“I was saying earlier that I was surprised to see a female name on the register,” Emerson said, hoping he sounded prim.
Miss Dottie’s gaze met his, and he felt her measure him. She finally understood why he paused.
“I’ve been to very few boarding houses that mixed male and female,” he added, disapprovingly.
“We have no women here now,” said one of the other men.
“I like them,” said the first man who’d come into the room. “They always liven up the conversation.”
“Except that last woman, what was her name?” asked a different man. “Mrs.—?”
“Taylor,” Miss Dottie said. “She left.”
“Left town?” Emerson asked.
“She didn’t say.” The man who spoke sounded disappointed.
“We suspect that Dan here scared her off,” said one of the other men. “He was too interested and she wasn’t comfortable.”
Emerson looked at the man they had called Dan. He was one of the men who lived here. He was short and balding, with a round belly. Certainly not the most appealing fellow in the room.
Then Emerson caught Miss Dottie’s eye. She was still staring at him. Something had set her off. Maybe she hadn’t liked Lureen Taylor.
He would have to tread carefully. He wanted to ask more questions, but didn’t dare.
“I saw no reason for her to leave,” said one of the other regulars, maybe in defense of the man named Dan.
“She didn’t belong here,” Miss Dottie said tightly, and the conversation died as if it hadn’t existed at all. Everyone turned their attention to the meal before them.
Emerson looked up after a few minutes to find Miss Dottie still watching him, her gaze flat and cold.
He made himself smile, and vowed to keep quiet for the rest of his stay in this place.
***His vow lasted for less than an hour.
He needed to stretch his legs, and he didn’t feel safe enough to walk in downtown Abbotts Creek. So he took the pipe he rarely smoked and stepped onto the porch.
One thing he did like about nights in faraway places—the soft perfume of spring flowers, the rich sweet cut of pipe smoke, and the comfort of a good wrap-around porch. Miss Dottie’s had a swing and well cushioned wicker chairs.
But he didn’t sit. Instead, he stood near the railing and looked out over the quiet street.
After a moment, the man named Dan joined him. Emerson waited, not certain if the man wanted to defend his actions with Lureen Taylor or if he was just here for a companionable evening.
The man reintroduced himself.
“Dan McCall,” he said, extending his hand.
“Earl West,” Emerson said, and took a puff off his pipe.
“You didn’t say what brings you to these parts,” McCall said.
“It’s not for discussing around ladies,” Emerson said.
McCall looked at him sideways.
“I’m a reporter with the Atlanta Journal. We’re doing a series of investigative reports about the agitators who are stirring up the sharecroppers in the Delta and beyond. My editor’s worried our own boys might get Ideas, and he wants to use other places as a cautionary tale.”
Emerson hoped he hadn’t over-explained. He had done that before, and it had been something which made people suspicious.
“Don’t believe what they tell you,” McCall said. “It ain’t northern agitators coming down here. There’s some white lawyers from Little Rock who seem to believe that how we do business here ain’t proper.”
“Don’t you do business how you’ve always done business?” Emerson asked. He wished he’d had time to study up on this. Ironically, he was going with what he had learned from the papers.
McCall shook his head sadly. “There’s money now. The war, and all. Cotton prices are good, and them nigras, they see a dime and want a dollar. The white lawyers say we gotta write out receipts and payments, pay everyone equal for the same labor. They’re even researching cotton prices, see what white landowners are really getting paid, and making sure they give the right amount to the sharecroppers.”
Emerson took another puff of his pipe to hide his feelings. He hated the sharecropping system. It was little better than slavery—with all the rents and food taken out of the payments, and often nothing left for the sharecroppers to save or use to move elsewhere.
He hadn’t realized that cotton prices were up because of the war, but it made sense as did McCall’s interpretation. Money did bring in agitators, and for good reason. When money flowed, people thought about cheating.
“I’m surprised that you’re talking white Southern agitators,” Emerson said. “I’d thought Northern boys’d come down and stirred up things. I’d heard about how you’d dealt with that boy last September. I’d been hoping to use that as the focus of my article, how Abbotts Creek dealt with those who believed the bunkum those Bolsheviks peddled.”
McCall scratched a match on the wooden post beside him. The match flared with a stink of sulfur. He used it to light his pipe.
“That boy? Moses Ross.” McCall stretched out the name, making fun of it with his tone. “He wasn’t sharecropping. He just got too big for himself. Heading off to some school in the North or maybe Atlanta.”
Then he glanced sideways at Emerson, trying to gage a reaction. Emerson kept his expression neutral, that of a man hearing a tale which did not concern him, instead of the story about the horrifying end to someone else’s life.
“One dark night just before Moses left, someone knifed Willis Bowden to death, left his wife bloody and terrified, and we all know who done it.”
“That boy,” Emerson said softly. He’d heard these stories before. “The wife said so.”
“Oh, no,” McCall said. “She was so out of her head, she said she done it. We told her to hush up, and she did. She ain’t never said it again. Not that she has need to. Willis didn’t treat her the way a Southern lady should be treated, but he did leave her money.”
And gave the town an excuse to make an example of an uppity Negro, Emerson thought, but didn’t say.
“The sheriff arrested Moses Ross. We all knowd he liked Mrs. Bowden. But that boy, he kept saying he didn’t do nothing. His family was gonna use his school money to fight what everyone knew to be true. Took about ten days before everyone was ready, but the sheriff—who had all those misguided reform thoughts—finally saw things our way.”
So, the sheriff wanted actual law and order. Emerson nodded, but not in agreement with McCall. Just in understanding.
Which chilled him.
He had to change the subject. He didn’t want to seem too concerned with Moses Ross’s death. Nor did Emerson want to hear any more details. Not at the moment.
“What about those white lawyers?” he asked. “How’re you going to stop them from agitating?”
“We catch them,” McCall said. He spoke with such calm deliberation, it sounded as if he were talking about a picnic. “We don’t touch them, though. We just make them watch what happens to them they’re trying to convince.”
Emerson had seen something similar in Alabama. Northern labor unionists got hauled to a lynching, and were expected to cheer. If they didn’t, they were afraid they’d die. They didn’t die. They left and reported the incident to the New York Times.
“Does it work?” Emerson asked, keeping his tone calm and barely interested.
“Don’t know for sure,” McCall said. “But we ain’t seen none of them Little Rock folks for months now. And they better hope we never see them again.”
He said that last with great force, as if he were trying to convince Emerson, as if he thought Emerson was one of the lawyers.
Emerson wasn’t quite sure how to convince McCall that he wasn’t.
“Anyone else I should talk to about the ways Abbotts Creek is protecting its own?” he asked.
McCall puffed on his pipe for a moment. The smoke had a touch of vanilla, making it even sweeter than the usual blends.
“We got a meeting coming up five days from now,” he said after a moment. “But we usually don’t take outsiders to it. Maybe a few of us’ll talk to you. Don’t mind hoods, do you?”
The Klan.
Emerson’s heart beat harder. He wasn’t sure if he had just been threatened or if he’d just been approved for membership. He wasn’t sure he would know unless he let the men talk to him.
“No,” he said, “I don’t mind hoods. But I’d best extend my stay. I’d only planned to be here two days.”
“Do that,” McCall said, and something in his tone made the shivers run down Emerson’s spine again.
He had no idea if he was hearing things that weren’t there. His fears and imagination often put him in as great a risk as his actual identity did.
But he thanked McCall, and then stood in what he hoped was companionable silence until the house lights went out.
***Emerson slept with his satchel open and his pistol near to hand. “Slept” was too powerful a word for the half-awake state he kept himself in all night. Clearly he didn’t feel safe, even here.
He kept playing McCall’s words over and over in his head. Emerson slowly realized that he had what he needed. What the NAACP wanted for its reports weren’t so much the gory details as why a lynching had been committed. Not the official story, the one told to outsiders, but the real story, the one the community knew.
Such as protecting a woman whose husband beat her so severely that she took a knife to him in the middle of the night. Clearly, the locals hadn’t wanted to prosecute her, but felt someone had to pay. And reminding the colored community that rising above their station was a bad idea was simply an added bonus.
Emerson knew he couldn’t stay here until the meeting. He wasn’t sure he should stay any much longer. He took his satchel down to breakfast, figuring if anyone asked, he could say he had his papers in it.
He wasn’t sure how much more information he would gather, but he did want to answer one more question for himself. He wanted to know what happened to Lureen Taylor.
Breakfast provided no answers at all. It was served at the long table in the kitchen. Miss Dottie was there, and she wasn’t willing to talk to him. Instead, over the fine biscuits and gravy, she said, “Mr. McCall says you’ll be needing a room for three additional nights.”
Then she looked pointedly at the satchel, and added, “But I see that he’s mistaken.”
Emerson shook his head. “He’s correct. I simply carry my satchel with me because it has my research.”
Her lips thinned, as if she didn’t believe him.
“Well,” she said. “I’m not sure if I’ll have a room. I will know this afternoon. I will tell you when you return.”
Then she stepped over to the counter and opened one of the bins.
“Lord a’mercy,” she said. “We’re in need of flour. I have no idea how I could have let us get so short of something so important.”
Then she closed the bin, crossed her arms, and looked at him. He would have understood even without the stare. If he brought the flour, he could stay.
He smiled, and nodded, not quite willing to verbally commit to her blackmail. After finishing his meal, he set his plate near the others by the sink, then thanked Miss Dottie for her hospitality.
He had put her in an awkward situation. Either she had to ask him if he planned to return with the flour or she had to trust him.
He rather liked her look of dismay.
He went out the back way, using the porch to reach the front. The town seemed quiet, even for a weekday morning. Although it was coming on nine, most folks had probably been working since sun-up.
He walked to Abbotts Creek Mercantile. He’d best take care of his purchase first. Besides, a general store in the morning was always a great place to get information.
The mercantile was only a few blocks from Miss Dottie’s. Two wagons were tied up outside. As Emerson approached, two women came out of the mercantile. One had her hair covered with a scarf, the other wore hers in a knot on top of her head. The shorter war fashions hadn’t really hit this community; both women wore dresses that brushed the wooden sidewalk.
Both nodded at him in greeting. He nodded back. Then he held the door for an elderly woman, who wore a black dress with a bustle and a hat that partly obscured her face. The dress shushed at him; expensive silk, mostly likely widow’s weeds, probably passed down from an even earlier generation. Mourning was nothing if not ubiquitous.
He followed her inside. Every general store between here and West Texas smelled the same—a hint of coffee, the faint scent of tobacco, and a dry edge from all the goods in barrels on the floor.
The elderly woman picked up a basket and wandered toward the sewing goods. The owner stood by a counter, his meaty arms crossed, his fleshy face florid.
He stared at Emerson, much the way that Miss Dottie had the night before.
“Help you?” the man asked.
“I hope so,” Emerson said. “I’m here for some flour for Miss Dottie.”
The man smiled. “Be needin’ a few more nights at the boarding house, eh?”
“I’d ask how you knew, but apparently she does this often.” Emerson did his best to sound amused at her petty blackmail.
“Keeps one of our best boarding houses in business,” the man said as he headed to one of the barrels.
He took a white sack and a scoop. He opened the barrel and started carefully scooping flour into the sack.
“What brings you to Abbotts Creek?” he asked.
“I’m with the Atlanta Journal,” Emerson said. “We’re doing a story on sharecropping—”
“What’d you say your name was?” the man asked.
“I hadn’t,” Emerson said. “My name is Earl West.”
The man tied the bag, then weighed it on the large scale behind him. One pound exactly.
“You from Atlanta?” he asked.
The question seemed to have more import than a casual enquiry.
“I am,” Emerson said, refraining from saying that all the reporters from the newspaper lived in Atlanta. Instead, he added, “We’re starting to have similar troubles in Georgia—”
“Do you know a gentleman named Emerson West?” The man set the pound of flour next to the cash register.
Emerson was so surprised to hear his own name that he wasn’t quite sure what to say. He approached the counter, and saw the pile of postcards beneath it. Then he saw the sign propped against the cash register listing this building as a post office.
He felt cold.
“There are a lot of Wests in Atlanta,” he said, hoping that would stop the man’s questions.
“There are Mosbys in Phillips County,” the man said, “and we’re mostly kin.”
Even the colored Mosbys? Emerson wanted to ask, but didn’t.
“Atlanta’s a big city,” he said, hoping he didn’t sound too argumentative.
“I been,” Mosby said. “It’s not that big.”
Emerson frowned. He could let it pass, or he could say something. He opted for bluntness. “Are you implying something, Mr. Mosby?”
“Lady come in here not one week ago, bought one of them postcards you’re near, and sent it to an Emerson West in Atlanta. Now you’re here. And I’ve been hearing of government men, investigating our justice here, trying to change our laws because they saw things they like better in France. Just making sure you’re not one of them.”
Emerson pulled out his credentials, happy that his hands didn’t shake. “I’m not with the government.”
“You wouldn’t be from one of them new-fangled nigger associations, would you?”
“Do I look like I am?” Emerson asked, hoping he sounded offended instead of frightened.
Mosby let out a small unamused laugh. “For all I know, you’re high yella.”
Emerson’s breath caught in his throat.
Mosby’s beady eyes bored right into him. “I been hearing tell of high yella niggers from some advancement association mixing with good folks, trying to stop some of our organizations from doing right. I even heard one of them high yella niggers is named White. Might think another would be named North, but West’ll do.”
Emerson’s mouth had gone dry. His cheeks were warm. He had actually flushed. He obviously couldn’t hide his reaction, so he had to give it lie.
“I have covered stories all over Dixie,” he said with as much indignation as he could muster. “And never once have I been called a nigger before.”
Mosby reached over the counter and grabbed a handful of postcards. He spread them next to the flour. The first postcard was the same as the one Emerson had received. The next two pictured men hanging from trees, one surrounded by a crowd, the other by four men in white shirts and hats. One of the men looked like Mosby.
The last postcard showed a body being burned—or worse, a man being burned alive.
Emerson made himself look at them. Then he thought about his pistol in the satchel. He’d always feared he would come across a moment like this, when he was directly confronted, and he often wondered what he’d do.
If he shot this man, Emerson would guarantee his own ugly death.
He worked alone.
What he had to do was survive to the next day.
“You trying to scare me?” Emerson asked, voice flat. “Because I came to Abbotts Creek to understand your justice, and perhaps bring a taste of it to Georgia, not to have it threatened against me.”
“I heard that this nigger association collects information on nigger killings,” Mosby said. “I got me a cousin in L’siana who met this White feller, didn’t stop him before he left. Heard tell this White was drummed out of the South, had to go to New York City to escape.”
Emerson had no idea how to deal with this kind of bluntness. He’d heard of it, but never encountered it. And didn’t know how a true white man would respond.
He decided to stick with indignation. “How much do I owe you for the flour?”
Mosby stared at him. Emerson stared back.
Finally, Mosby looked down. “This ain’t a town for niggers.”
“That’s fairly obvious,” Emerson said. “Do you think if I was one I’d be here?”
“I don’t think nothing,” Mosby said. “We’ve had lots of agitators.”
“I’m not one of them,” Emerson said. “But I assume you don’t want to sell me the flour.”
“I don’t need your money,” Mosby said. “And you don’t need to talk to Miss Dottie no more.”
Emerson didn’t know how to argue with that. He needed to leave Abbotts Creek before he really did meet with the Klan. But now, he had to find out what happened to Lureen. He had a hunch he knew, and he didn’t like what he was thinking.
“You said a lady sent one of these postcards to a man named West,” Emerson said, “and somehow that made you think I was colored. I do not understand how a lady’s postcard would make you think that.”
“Miss Dottie didn’t like her,” Mosby said.
Emerson’s stomach twisted. “I gathered that. I also had the sense Miss Dottie doesn’t like everyone.”
“Miss Dottie knows people.” Mosby looked down at the postcards, almost wistfully.
Emerson felt cold. His heart was pounding so hard it was probably audible.
“So,” he said, “will I be seeing a postcard of this lady next time I’m here?”
“No.” Mosby’s tone was flat. “But not for lack of trying.”
Emerson’s gaze met Mosby’s again.
“Because you couldn’t get a good photograph?” Emerson asked, afraid of the answer.
“Because there was nothing to photograph.” Mosby gathered up the four postcards and put them back on the pile. “Now you get. I’ll tell Miss Dottie you have no need of her hospitality any longer.”
“Then she has no need of that flour,” Emerson said, hoping the emotion in his voice sounded like rage. “Of course, she already has my money, so she can afford her own. Do tell her that her boarding house will not get a good review in the Atlanta Journal.”
“We’ll be watching for it,” Mosby said.
Emerson glared at him a final time, then gripped the handle of the satchel and left the store. He paused, his back to the wall, looking to see if anyone was waiting for him.
Cherry Street was empty.
The door banged behind him and he jumped.
The elderly woman peered at him from beneath her hat. She carried a sack in one hand. The other was hidden in the pocket of her silk dress.
He hoped to God she wasn’t carrying a lady’s pistol.
He looked at her, trying not to seem afraid.
She stopped beside him, and also looked at the street, not at him.
“Miss Taylor took the train to Little Rock seven days ago,” the woman said softly. “Before she did, she asked me to give you these.”
She pulled the four postcards out of her pocket, and slid them to his nearby hand.
Then she backed away from him and spit on the wooden sidewalk. “Now, you git!” she said. “We don’t need no agitators here.”
She crossed the street, shaking her head as if his very presence offended her.
He was trembling. He watched her go. He hoped no one had heard any of that. She would get in trouble for helping him, and she could get him in trouble for threatening her.
In the distance, a train whistle sounded. It was later than he thought.
It was always later than he thought.
He stuffed the postcards in his satchel, next to the pistol. Then he walked the block to the station, just in time to board the train.
The Monster in Our MidstCopyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn RuschFirst published in Fiction River: Past Crime, edited by Kristine Kathryn Rusch, WMG Publishing, November 2014Published by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2023 by WMG PublishingCover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Vlntn/Dreamstime
On January 6, 2023, Michael W. Lucas made a rather important announcement on his blog. He wrote, in all caps:
AMAZON IS NO LONGER MY BIGGEST INCOME SOURCE.
It’s not that he added a consulting business to his writing income, or started doing in-person speaking gigs. He didn’t get a day job. Instead, he’s been, in his words, disintermediating.
He’s been consciously moving his readers away from Amazon (and other sources of revenue) and moved those readers to his website. He posted his 2022 sales, in percentages, and noted that, for the first time, revenue that came through his website outpaced revenue that came through Amazon.
Full disclosure: He also announced that his income was down, but that he had expected that, after the online pandemic buying frenzies of 2020 and 2021.
What, exactly, did he filter through his website?
Here’s his breakdown (along with percentages).
Direct sales, 18.57%. Direct Patronizers, 6.34%. Sponsorships, 5.33%, and direct preorders, 2.38%. Taken all together, 32.62% of my income coming from sales through my web site.
Amazon provides 31.35%.
Yes, that is, as he says, a slim percentage difference. (The remaining 36% comes from places like IngramSpark, Kobo, and his old books still mired in traditional publishing.) It’s worth noting that over 10% of his income came from Kickstarter, which he does not count as website sales (appropriately because it takes a percentage and the people you bring to that site grows that site.). However, Kickstarter is a one-time fundraising platform, which provides another way to sell direct to the consumer, without a percentage taken from each book. As such, that means that more than 42% of Michael’s income has come from direct reader engagement.
He’s not the only writer who has made note of this. I’ve talked with several who are taking more and more control of their own product and sales. Dean and I had a dinner with two other couples at 20Books in which we discussed a Shopify store. We’d been doing WooCommerce and weren’t that happy with it. Because we’re early adapters, we’d had our initial WooCommerce store in (jeez, I think) 2013 or 2014. Long ago, when everything was clunky and hard.
Now it’s not.
A few weeks ago, I wrote a post on this site that scared the crap out of most of you. It was about Amazon’s year, and the fact that Amazon is rethinking much of the way that its website and sales platform works. Amazon’s innovation enabled writers to self-publish and make a solid living (if not more), but that was more than a decade ago. Since then, Amazon has been changing the algorithms. It has new management, and it’s just not that interested in books. It will, at some point, maybe in the near future, cease being the biggest beast in the American bookselling sphere. (If you want to argue with me, do me a favor and read the other post first, then argue there.)
A number of writers responded in the comments and also to me personally, some denying that anything was happening (and of course, they thought I was making this all up). Other writers responded with some great and useful comments.
After a decade of dealing with delusional self-published writers (after two decades of dealing with delusional traditionally published writers), I’ve learned to shut those poor deniers out. You can’t convince people who stick their fingers in their ears, close their eyes, and sing every time you show them evidence.
But others? People who want to continue as writers and get the largest audience they can? Those folks are well worth my time. Many of them were panicked and wondering what was next.
I knew how I was setting up the year-end blogs, and I knew that I would be talking about going direct after I did the traditional stuff, the Amazon post, and two other important posts.
The next important post was last week’s. The demise of Twitter and the changing landscape of social media convinced me (and thousands of others) to look at how we promote our work. More than that, it reminded us that something we have built over a decade or more can go away in the space of a month. (Yes, I know, I could have downloaded my Twitter followers onto a spreadsheet and uploaded them elsewhere, then invited them…and that presupposes a lot of things such as the fact that I have developed an elsewhere and that I have that kind of time.)
Michael’s discussion of disintermediation is the key here. The more that we control, the better we are as writers. I have known this for decades, but in the pre-Kindle world, what I could control was pretty limited or very hard. (Dean and I did direct sales with Pulphouse Publishing in the late 1980s and early 1990s and that required a ton of work convincing distributors to take our products and selling on our own at conventions and doing mail order. Yikes!)
The more we writers control our own work—and that means owning our own intellectual property, which most traditionally published writers these days do not—and the more we are in control of our own income, the better off we will all be. Twitter’s slow implosion reminded me of that.
The final important post? The bestseller post. Unfortunately, bestsellers have become so 20th century. They’re a relic of a world we no longer live in. You can’t measure sales any longer, particularly with so many books being sold on so many platforms. Bestsellers were a handy way of keeping track of the books that were the most successful in a very limited marketplace. That marketplace had only a handful of books compared to now.
Of course, readers liked bestsellers as a handy way to buy books. I don’t know about you, though, but for me, I used to read a number of bestsellers because they were good enough to keep me entertained until my favorite author published something new. Now that I can find all the books, I stopped reading those “good enough” books. They were my airplane reading before the Kindle, the books I knew would get me through a three-hour flight without going stark raving mad from boredom. Once I had my Kindle, though, I read whatever I wanted when I wanted it. I didn’t have to carry big bulky books onto a plane.
The Kindle was a game-changer, and I think we hit a similar kind of game-changer in 2022. That was the year that writers discovered ways outside of the standard e-retailers to make a living at writing.
And by living, remember, I always mean a good living, which is middle class at minimum.
Three ways rose to the fore in 2022. Realize all three ways existed before 2022, but they’ve moved into a whole new realm after this past year.
The first way is crowd-funding. I wrote a number of blogs about Kickstarter in 2022, because Brandon Sanderson’s Kickstarter made a whole group of writers realize they can get a traditional publishing advance for their work by going through Kickstarter properly.
What do I mean by traditional publishing advance? Well, most midlist writers these days get about $5,000. Remove 15% for the useless agent, and the writer will then get $4250 spread over at least three payments at least two years apart.
If that same writer got $5000 on Kickstarter, they would lose Kickstarter’s fee of 5% and the credit card fee of 3% (so, 8%). That means they’d get $4600 when the Kickstarter ends. Which makes this better than a traditional advance.
Writers with a larger platform might get more than $5,000, and some writers, like Brandon, will get millions. I did two specific examinations of Brandon’s Kickstarter, the first in the middle of its run, and the second when the run ended. Then I did another Kickstarter specific post titled “How We Use Kickstarter” in September.
The crowd-funding sites all have benefits and drawbacks. I’ve seen writers use a variety of them in a variety of ways. Once the writer learns how to do so, that writer can add quite a bit of money to their annual income.
We offer a free Kickstarter Best Practices course on Teachable, and one of the best things about that course is the opportunity to interact with other writers doing Kickstarters. These writers are sharing tricks and mistakes, figuring out how to use the platform to their benefit.
The best part about that course, though, is watching dozens (maybe more) writers succeed with their Kickstarters. The Kickstarters have brought in, for first-timers, anywhere from $500 to $15,000.
Because of Brandon and all of these other writers, Kickstarter has realized that publishing is a huge category. Kickstarter sent representatives to 20Books for the first time in 2022 and is working hard at making sure writers succeed.
Now, realize, Kickstarter is not all sunshine and flowers. It’s tough to do a good crowd-funding campaign. Kickstarter says that only four out of ten projects on Kickstarter will be successful. And the category with the third highest rate of failed projects on Kickstarter? Publishing.
That’s because writers ask for how much they “deserve” rather than do the research to get the project off the ground properly. That’s why we offer the course.
If Dean and I were to move to another crowdfunding platform, we’d have to learn how to use that platform before launching something there. Each platform is different.
But the point here is that in 2022, a lot of writers have learned how to get that all important advance. In my year in review piece on traditional publishing, I mentioned how Michael Pietsch, CEO of the Hachette Group, said under oath that he did not believe that self-publishing was a threat to traditional publishing because “…[s]elf-published authors can’t pay themselves an advance against royalties.” (Still makes me giggle, that stupid quote.)
Well, through crowd-funding, writers can pay themselves an advance by going direct to their readers. And it’s not against royalties either—the royalties being the hope of future earnings. It’s an advance that’s given for an existing product, which the writer can then send to backers.
And sometimes crowd-funding can encourage writers to create something that they wouldn’t normally do. Dean and I started the Make 100 which occurs every January on Kickstarter because it sounded like a fun project. Make 100 of something and put it up and see what the backers think. We’re on our third Make 100 collection series right now, with a series of fantasy collections. (Five books, 100 stories, 50 from me and 50 from Dean. Check it out.)
So…Kickstarter and other crowd-funding platforms help writers make a good living at writing, providing the writers do their campaigns correctly.
The second thing that became big in 2022 was direct sales. Indie writers have sold direct for decades. (See Pulphouse, above.) But selling direct became easier toward the turn of the century with ebooks, but the interface was clunky and difficult for readers. Once the Kindle came along, though, and Amazon needed content to fill it, readers got used to reading ebooks.
And that meant that enterprising writers could sell ebooks direct to readers.
The problem was that, until 2020, most readers didn’t want to buy anything from smaller websites. 2020 changed that. The attitude switched from I only buy from Amazon (or Barnes & Noble) to I would rather give my money direct to the manufacturer/artist/writer. It’s a huge shift in consumer thinking, one that will not disappear, and one, I think, that has caused problems for Amazon across the board.
What hurts Amazon actually helps indie writers who have their own stores. I had seen this coming last year, and actually said this in one of my year-end posts:
If you haven’t tried any of the online store programs for the past five years or so, then you’ll be surprised at how easy it all is for writer and consumer alike. I personally think this will be one of the major growth areas of 2022.
Some business circumstances prevented us from acting on improving our store until December. Now, our direct store is a priority for the business. I’m quite excited about the tools and possibilities.
I will write a longer post about Shopify and our store later, after we’ve done some experimenting and work with it. Two things are relevant to this year-end review.
The first is this: Going direct to the consumer is not about discoverability. A new reader is probably not going to discover you on your website. That reader will need to pick up your book in a major retailer like Kobo or Barnes & Noble or Amazon. In the back of that book, you promote your own store. So the reader needs to find out about the writer somewhere else, and then come to the writer’s ecosystem.
That ecosystem includes email marketing. For about five years, email marketing had become passé. A necessity, sure, but not the main focus that social media was.
Yet with the social media implosions that I discussed a previous post, email has become a lot more important. And not in the I need to cram my list sense. But for a second part of discoverability. Each new book needs to be promoted through email, so that readers will know that the new book is out and will buy it directly from the author.
That’s all possible now. From what I understand, it’s simple, and I will be testing that more as the year progresses. But scratch a driven indie writer and you will find someone with some kind of direct sales on their site.
I know this intimidates a lot of writers. Joanna Penn has been doing a wonderful series of interviews (one with Katie Cross and one with Morgana Best) as she sets up her Shopify store to sell directly to her customers.
Joanna has sold a lot of her product directly for years, but like us, she did so through a group of sites. Then she moved to Shopify in the summer. Because she’s so great at gathering and sharing information, she has written about her struggles, but also her joy at what she’s doing.
She writes a lot about the pros and cons of having a store on your website. If you’re interested in this aspect of publishing in 2023, check out her very good posts.
Finally, there’s one last category that grew in 2022, and will grow more, I think, in 2023.
That category is just basic fan support. It comes in a variety of ways. Michael Lucas listed it in his sales percentages above. He has a category marked “Patronizer,” which he calls a Patreon-like program on his website. Instead of people paying Patreon to show him support, they pay him. (He also has a Patreon.) That cuts out the Patreon fees. His Patronizer is 6.34% of his income, and Patreon itself is 4.53% of his income, so they’re similar but not the same.
Other creatives are doing things that I suspect will slide into the writerly realm. The one that caught my eye was in The Hollywood Reporter in October. Bucket List Studios, a small company, wanted produce an animated series based on the family’s trips and adventures. They got a $10 million offer from Netflix:
But after discussing the deal — which would entail losing ownership over intellectual property — with [his wife] Jessica, Gee said the two decided to take a risk and walk away from the offer. Instead, they would embark on something more daring: launching a full entertainment studio to create content, products and experiences that embody the ethos of the Bucket List Family, which encourages others to travel and explore the world together.
To do that, they asked their fans to invest in the company, instead of finding some venture capital. Read the article to see how they set up this idea, but here’s the upshot:
In total, Bucket List Studios received $7 million from 34 investors who have put in funding in the $100,000 to $3 million range — and $3 million from around 30,000 investors at the $100 level, according to Gee. The company’s authorized share capital includes 20 million shares of common stock and 10 million shares of preferred stock, with roughly 2.5 million being designated as series seed preferred stock, according to financial documents reviewed by THR. Gee holds about 5.1 million shares of common stock, representing about a 50.4 percent stake in the company.
They also have some investments from venture capitalists, but not as much as they would have needed before.
I’m seeing this sort of thing happening more and more with large projects that require a major investment. The key to all of this is buried in that first quote.
They turned down the Netflix offer, because they would have lost their intellectual property. To hang onto their IP, they went to their fans and the fans are helping them realize this dream.
It’s not a quick or easy solution. It takes technical expertise to do something on the level of the Bucket List Family. But there are writers who are taking sponsorships—having one time patrons on major projects, for example, patrons who might pay expenses for a short time without getting ownership but who are getting something. (A private book, a dedication…I’m not sure yet. It will require more work.)
Another old/new idea. Writers, artists, musicians, sculptors often had major patrons in the past, enabling them to produce work unfettered. It looks like that might be an idea whose time has come…again.
That seems like a bit much for most writers. Most indie writers will probably be content with a few Kickstarters and an online store. Done right, those two alone can cobble together a solid income for one person. Add in the other forms of sales—from Amazon to D2D and IngramSpark—and a writer would be in good stead.
2022 has already brought a sea change in attitudes about Kickstarter and selling direct to the consumer. I expect this trend to continue in 2023, and maybe even grow.
It takes a bit of an open mind and it also takes a recalibration of mindset.
Think of it this way: if writers throw out the dream of “bestsellers” and think about getting their books to as many readers as possible, while making a good living at writing, then 2022 showed them the way.
I realize it’s not for everyone. But for the entrepreneurial writer, the world keeps opening up with more and more opportunities.
And that pleases me more than I can say.
As I mentioned in the post, one of the keys to doing direct sales and Kickstarters and working with fan support is to make sure you control your intellectual property. Writers who sell to traditional publishing do not control their IP. Sometimes writers who option their work for film and TV lose their IP as well. These losses come because the writer does not understand what intellectual property is on a deep level, and does not know how to make it work for them.
This has bothered me and Dean for years. We’ve been trying to teach writers copyright since we started teaching. But writers steadfastly refuse to take the offered courses. So this year, we came up with a course called Bite-Size Copyright. It’s copyright in small doses, one per week for 52 weeks. You can find out more about the class here.
And then there’s this: This weekly blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynrusch to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: Direct: The Year in Review Part 8,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © Can Stock Photo / blueperfume.
Every frequent flyer shares a nightmare—trapped inside a plane in trouble. The key? Don’t think about it. Until you sit next to the wrong woman on the wrong flight on the wrong day…
“Turbulence,” by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook through various online retailers here.
TurbulenceKristine Kathryn RuschFifteenth flight of the month and it was only the fourteenth day. Got on the 747, wasn’t sure if he was leaving or arriving in Chicago. Had a momentary panic before he remembered he was going to Denver. Three meetings, a pitch he had been working on in more airports than he cared to count, and he still wasn’t done. He had to figure out what he truly believed about the product, what it was he could sell. Can’t sell anything if you can’t convince yourself first.
But he was so tired. Couldn’t remember when he last called the wife. Had she complained this trip or the one before? We never talk any more. Hell, he never talked to anyone any more.
First class was full and he couldn’t upgrade. What good was 100K in frequent flier miles when people actually paid for first-class tickets? He begged for an exit row over the wing, got it, and decided screw the pitch. What he really needed was sleep.
He had closed his eyes long before the gate attendant started boarding by rows. He was already dozing when someone tapped his shoulder. He opened one eye, expecting a stewardess—dammit, he’d never get that right, no matter how many miles—a flight attendant. Instead, a large woman (a fat woman) smiled apologetically at him. She couldn’t fit into the row with his knees in the way.
He unbuckled, got out, wondered how in the hell she’d fit in the seat—he barely fit in the seat. She waggled in, then pulled up the armrest, settled against the window, and fought with the seat belt.
He didn’t watch. He got back in, slid down, extended his legs in the measly “extra” leg room the exit row offered, and prepared to drop off when she spoke.
So close to sleep that he wasn’t thinking. He said, “Hmm?” like he would with the wife, a sound which told her, in that infinitely private language of marriage, that he was nodding off, and she shouldn’t press. But he wasn’t married to the fat woman, and she repeated what she had said a moment ago.
He opened his eyes, blinked at her, trying not to look annoyed. That was his second mistake. He should have looked annoyed. She smiled at him, the Safety Information Card in her left hand, and said, “I’m not sure I can operate the door. Do you think they’ll make me move?”
“Dunno,” he said. “Better ask.”
So she did. The stewardess—dammit, the flight attendant—oozed sympathy. “You’ll have more room in this seat, honey, and I’m sure this nice gentleman will help you should anything go wrong.”
This nice gentleman squinched his eyes, and pressed his lips together, wishing that the stewardess, damn political correctness, had followed the rules. He wasn’t sure he’d be able to reach over his seatmate to get to the emergency door should he need to, nor did he think he could shove her through it.
But he smiled politely, folded his hands across his chest, and prepared to close his eyes, when the woman said, “I’ve never had a safe flight.”
“Hmm?” he asked, then damned himself.
She leaned toward him. “Every time, something’s gone wrong. The last time, something under the plane was making an awful knocking sound, and we had to make an unscheduled landing in Des Moines. The time before that, the fog in Chicago was so bad that they overshot the landing and we bounced—have you ever been on a big plane when it bounces?—and I swear you could hear everyone sucking in their breath—”
“His breath,” he murmured.
“What?”
“Nothing.” He made himself look at her. She still clutched the Safety Information Card. She looked scared. His empathy, which had been noticeably missing a few moments ago, was back. Everyone was scared these days, and he understood it. Although he couldn’t remember how long had it been since he’d been scared—not counting those five days he’d been stranded in Canada, mid-September 2001, wondering if his world was going to end.
But scared, really scared of plane flight, he couldn’t remember that. It had to be that first trip, 800K ago, sitting on the runway in San Francisco, praying that he wouldn’t die.
“Sounds like you fly a lot,” he said.
“No,” she said. “It’s bad luck to have me on a plane. I try not to.”
He’d heard this before. He’d heard everything before. “Why’re you flying this time?”
“My sister is having an operation. I’m the only family. Someone has to take care of her son.”
“Family emergencies.” He nodded, trying to sound more sympathetic, but he had a momentary panic that he would spend the next three hours hearing the family’s tale of woe. “Always hard.”
“Yes,” she said. “When my grandmother died….”
He had a gift for tuning out even though he looked as if he were paying close attention. He would nod now and then, make eye contact, mmm-hmm softly. No one ever knew, she didn’t know, he was thinking about the pitch, then remembering all the hundreds of bad flights he’d had: the time the oxygen masks had descended in Portland; panicked stewardi running from the cockpit to their seats as a warning buzzer sounded just before that landing in Cleveland; the ice-slide at LaGuardia the day before that jetliner went into the ocean. There but for the grace of God, he had thought then. There but for the grace of God.
Yet he still retained the skill to put those moments out of his mind, knew that they were simply that. Moments.
She paid religious attention to the safety protocol at the beginning of the flight, interrupting her monologue for it. After they were airborne, she managed to talk non-stop. All near-disasters, frightening misses. The woman ahead of them turned once and shushed her, saying she was worrying the little old lady in the next seat, and that worked for five minutes.
But the monologue seemed to soothe the fat woman and he found himself wondering, as he stared into eyes that could have been green or gold or a weird shade of gray, whether anyone else had ever pretended to listen to her that long.
“You sure are nice,” she said more than once, and he would smile reassuringly, wishing he knew of a graceful way to get himself out of the conversation. But he didn’t, so he mm-hmmed and nodded, and almost didn’t notice when she paused for breath, somewhere over Nebraska.
She frowned, held out a hand, and watched the flesh jiggle. He did too, mesmerized. “There,” she said with authority. “It’s coming. Better buckle up.”
The seatbelt light came on then, and he was about to tell her he was always strapped in when the plane dropped, just dropped, like a kid would drop a marble, then it leveled as if it had hit the floor. People screamed, drinks flew, and the woman in the row in front of them slammed her head against the compartment above her. The smack was so loud that he felt a sympathy ache in his own head, and his breath caught in his throat.
The plane tilted dangerously left, and then righted itself, leaving passengers moaning and shaken, a spatter of blood on the compartment before him, the smell of urine, vomit, and gin in the air. Someone was sobbing. He was clutching the armrest on the aisle side, staring at the emergency exit, wondering if he could turn and pull and shove with the woman in the way.
She laughed shakily, gave him an apologetic smile, and said, “It’s okay now.”
He believed her. He didn’t know why, but he did. A few minutes later, the seat-belt sign went off, and the stewardi came down the rows, checking, soothing, offering bandages and blankets. The woman who had shushed them had a cut on her skull, but insisted they didn’t need to make an emergency landing for her. A doctor a few rows back was allowed to come up and concur. Some other passengers helped with the cleanup, and the plane was filled with nervous voices, voices he had heard in the sky only once before, voices most people saved for elevators that had momentarily stuck or just after a particularly close car wreck.
He was awake now, all of him, and it wasn’t the sudden drop which had done it. The fat woman had awakened him with her monologue, her certainty, her uncanny and accurate knowledge that something had been about to go wrong.
She had reawakened the insidious voice he had put to sleep in San Francisco 800K ago, only its tune had changed ever so slightly.
How many times, it asked, does this happen? How many times do planes malfunction, people get hurt, near misses become real catastrophes like it has for the woman one seat ahead of you? If you hadn’t been wearing your belt, that could have been you. There but for the Grace of God—
“Go I,” he whispered.
“Hmm?” the woman next to him asked.
He shook his head. She closed her eyes, rested her hands on her ample stomach and dozed off. He watched her for the next hour, sleeping the sleep of the innocent, as if she and she alone knew that nothing more would happen to them. He knew that he should sleep too, now that the vomit and the urine and the gin smells had mingled with some kind of deodorizer, and the frightened voices had ceased.
But sleep eluded him, and when the plane bumped its way through the expected turbulence at Denver International, his fingers were digging holes in the armrests again. The plane eased to a stop—a perfect landing, he would have said if he had been calm—and he stood the moment the seat-belt light went off.
The woman woke then, and looked up at him.
“Sorry,” she said.
She knew. She knew she had done what terrorists and bad landings and strange engine noise had not. She knew she had reawakened that insidious internal voice which even now was telling him that flight was not natural, that his life was not natural, that someday, somewhere, he would die.
He felt a surge of anger, knew it was useless, and forced himself to smile his most polite smile—his business smile, the one he’d worn for 800K, the one, perhaps, he might never wear again.
“It’s all right,” he said to her, and for the first time, the lie didn’t sound convincing.
For the first time, he could no longer convince himself.
TurbulenceCopyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
First published in Asimov’s SF Magazine, August 2009
Published by WMG Publishing
Cover and layout copyright © 2023 by WMG Publishing
Cover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG Publishing
Cover art copyright © Albert Lozano/Dreamstime
I’ve been dreading this post, but not for the reason that you think. Somewhere, probably back in November, I had gotten the bright idea that I would do this post and find a social media site to replace Twitter for my promotion and news needs.
(As a former journalist, I found Twitter very useful. I followed journalists in real time, as well as old journalist friends, who would post nuggets, and I knew how to parse those nuggets. The unfiltered nuggets (in tiny bursts) is what I miss about Twitter, not the promotion, not the “social” aspect, not the “community” which I never found very welcoming in the first place. Anyway.)
In other words, I had put a lot of pressure on this post. I was sure that with a week or so worth of research, I’d have a new social media home.
I didn’t expect two things. The first is that nothing has really shaken out as the Twitter replacement. (And Musk hasn’t quit nor has he finished eviscerating the site, even after he promised he’d step down if people told him to…and people told him to.) The second thing is…I’m not sure I want a Twitter replacement. Yes, I miss the news (see above), but I don’t miss the hordes of judgement that would come with any kind of infraction or perceived infraction.
No one ever checked to see if the infraction actually did happen, as was the case with me getting banned by a lot of sf people because they believed that I had never done anything to help women in the field. Never bought stories from women when I was editing The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction (an easy thing to disprove) and never wrote about women’s issues anywhere (also easy to disprove). And yeah, that was the first attack that really bothered me, mostly because I ended up blocking a whole bunch of people whose work I like and whose politics I generally agree with.
It bothered me for days, before I put on my sf convention armor and remembered that social media is like a large party, and I needed my game face on at all times.
I’m not fond of my game face. It goes against my rather blunt grain.
So I’m not going to use this post to find the next Twitter or the place where all the literary folk have gathered. I’m probably going to need to find a few places to land, but that’s separate research unrelated to this piece. In this piece, I’ll look at the changes in the social media landscape and what that means for the future.
In November, The Atlantic published an article by game designer Ian Bogost titled “The Age of Social Media Is Ending.” The subhead is “It Should Never Have Begun.”
Let’s leave off the subhead for a moment and contemplate the headline. The Age of Social Media Is Ending.
Yeah. The title is onto something. The article has a point of view, which I mostly disagree with, although I appreciate his history of the past thirty years as seen through the lens of social media sites.
I think his view of the future as a place where people accept that social media is as evil as cigarette smoking is wrong in the extreme. I think that he, like so many others, forget that social media is a tech development that has some benefits. (Where smoking, as far as I can see, has none.)
He grudgingly touches on that with this paragraph, toward the end:
Something may yet survive the fire that would burn it down: social networks, the services’ overlooked, molten core. It was never a terrible idea, at least, to use computers to connect to one another on occasion, for justified reasons, and in moderation (although the risk of instrumentalizing one another was present from the outset). The problem came from doing so all the time, as a lifestyle, an aspiration, an obsession. The offer was always too good to be true, but it’s taken us two decades to realize the Faustian nature of the bargain.
All of that is true. Twitter famous isn’t the same as TV famous which nowadays isn’t the same as it was 50 years ago. And there is a Faustian bargain here, one in which many people lost their souls to the machine, quite literally.
Think about January 6 Capitol Riot of 2021 here in the U.S. for a minute, and realize that as of this writing, 964 people have been charged with a crime related to that event and 465 have pleaded guilty. None of this would have happened without an egregious misuse of social media by the former president and his minions. Now, realize, that all media, from the dawn of media has been misused by people with malicious intent. Hitler played well on film, which was a new medium at the time. The French Revolution was fueled, in part, by pamphleteers, using what was then a new form of communicating with the masses.
I am not forgiving or excusing social media, but what I am saying here is that it is part of a human evolutionary trend. We get enthusiastic about new things—often new ways of communicating with each other. We use them to distraction, and then we abuse them, and eventually we regulate them or lose interest.
For example, pamphlets still exist. I have one on my table downstairs, which is encouraging me to vote for The Glass Onion in all the upcoming awards ballots. Someone might call it a tiny little magazine or a book-like item, but it’s a pamphlet.
And we all know that news on film still exists, and a lot of wannabe despots make videos of themselves or their ideas or their terrifying public utterances too much of the time.
What caught me about the article was the phrase: The Age of Social Media. Where social media dominated.
I truly don’t think social media is going to go away, any more than the telephone went away. Yes, the landline is mostly toast. So is the party line, thank God. According to a study that Pew Research conducted in 2021, 97% of people in the U.S. have a cellphone, and 85% use a smartphone for their cell connection. So, yeah, Alexander Graham Bell wouldn’t recognize the instrument he created in these handheld computers, but he is the official father of this kind of communication.
I think the Atlantic writer is right: social media’s dominance in our society has been broken. It was already fracturing before Musk bought Twitter. From the beginning of social media sites, the audience split, often by generation.
Facebook was for “old” people, and for a while, Twitter was for the young’uns. Influencers dominated Instagram until the pandemic, and then the idea of going out and influencing was so 2019. Not to mention the fact that Instagram, like Facebook, kept changing its algorithms to favor ads and controversy instead of connection.
As I was researching this piece, I came across social media sites that are now being listed by people in the know (what know, I don’t know) as being passé. And I’m so old I never heard of them.
Among book people, though, two sites caused all of the controversy this year. Twitter and TikTok. Twitter because—you know—dumpster fire, and TikTok because of BookTok. The U.K. Publishers Association conducted a survey of 2000 people 16-25 (Gen Z) and discovered that 59% of them say that BookTok or book influencers have given them a passion for reading.
BookTok has dominated the conversation all year and has helped a lot of backlist titles to sell, particularly in young adult. There’ve been some amazing success stories in romance too, as well as sf and fantasy.
What’s even more interesting to me is the way that brick and mortar booksellers jumped on the BookTok bandwagon. If a title got a lot of love on BookTok, then booksellers would note that on their shelves, sometimes making entire displays for BookTok books. This summer, Barnes & Noble partnered with TikTok to create a reading challenge—encouraging people to post about the books they read and thereby get those books more readers.
With the demise of Literary Twitter, TikTok looked like the hottest social media platform around. And then…well, the regulation started. I’m not delving deep into the controversy because the deeper I go, the more confused I get, which leads me to believe there’s a lot of disinformation here.
Let’s simply note that an internal investigation by ByteDance, TikTok’s parent company, discovered that four of its employees in China “scooped up data” from the accounts of two U.S. journalists, which is a big no-no, made worse by all the international implications.
The current upshot is that many states are banning the TikTok app on government issued cell phones. The U.S. government has done the same thing. Other countries are trying to regulate TikTok as well.
A lot of people have removed it from their phones. But does that mean TikTok and as a result, BookTok, will go away? Probably not. What’s being discussed now is TikTok’s American arm might get sold off, to protect the data, and to get the Chinese connection out of this country.
All of this is neither here nor there for most of us. I think we’ve come to expect a certain level of data-mining and bad behavior by all of these social media companies. We all draw the line at different places. For example, I won’t even consider Counter Social as a platform because its owner, who calls himself the Joker, identifies as a gray hat hacker who is out to fix social media. Associating with this guy is as far out of line for me as associating with Elon Musk.
And yet, I remain on Facebook, even though I think Mark Zuckerberg is even more horrid than those two. It’s just…I’ve been on Facebook for a long time. While I can’t justify it in logical terms, I’m not leaving just yet.
By this time next year, the social media landscape will probably have settled out. It’ll probably continue to divide depending on the community someone wants to attract. That’s how it was in the past, and that’s probably how it will be in the future.
But we’ve ended up with a big problem with the sudden unraveling of Twitter. Thousands of us (maybe more) deactivated accounts which we have had for more than ten years. We’ve let the work of accumulating thousands of followers go in the space of weeks.
I didn’t ever try to curate my followers. Sure, as I said above, I blocked some, but I didn’t go to all those lengths that some writers did to acquire followers. I let my followers grow organically. Still, I left behind a platform that I could use to inform people of something important to me—and a platform where I could do promotion that actually moved the needle on any project—without setting up a replacement.
Uncanny Magazine’s editor, Lynne Thomas, put it best in a piece in Locus Magazine. Thomas was discussing changes Amazon made to its Kindle platform, changes that will hurt Uncanny, and added this,
This could not have come at a worse time for SFF periodicals, since so many of us are also weathering the storms of reduced advertising revenue and the possible death of Twitter, which is vital for crowdfunding projects.
I dealt with reduced advertising revenue in last week’s post. The changing promotions landscape is a reality for all of us right now. We’ve lost several different areas of promotion, especially on the social media side.
Things are not working the way that they did just a year ago. The loss of thousands of followers before I could choose another site to go to made me realize something that a lot of others have said for a while.
It’s better to have your own organically controlled list than it is to use someone else’s platform to do it.
That bit of advice might just be the reason I can’t bring myself to join Mastodon, which is where, it seems, the book world is settling. I can’t do a lot of the research to find another platform. I have this website (which needs an upgrade), my Patreon account (which needs tending), my newsletter (which is still growing), and my Facebook profiles, which I mostly use to discuss my runs, my cats, and some promotions.
With the loss of Twitter, though, I realized something else. I realized that I had gotten into a habit of hitting the Twitter icon on something I wanted to promote, saying a brief something or other about it, and then moving on.
In the post about advertising, I had mentioned that one of the problems with advertising in 2022 was that it had grown stale. Then I realized that my own advertising for my own works had grown stale.
In some ways, as Lynne Thomas said, this change couldn’t come at a worse time. But, of course, there’s no good time.
What I plan to do is slowly figure out what platforms suit me, and then let people know about them. It will require a lot of personal work for me. I’ll be piggybacking off other work done by friends, but mostly, I need to dive in and see what’s next.
As I worked on this piece, I kept discovering new sites. Some look really cool to me, and some look like massive time sinks, and none of them will replace what I like about Twitter. However, moving to any of them would get me out of my rut.
Or maybe the changes this fall have already done that. I got to re-examine what I’m doing on social media. I know I’m not the only one.
Ultimately, I’m not sure that’s a bad thing. There will always be the flavor of the month social media platform. Maybe those of us who got swept up in the Twitter drama will be a bit more cautious about joining that platform, researching it completely and then figuring out whether it’s right for us.
The problem here is time. We only have so much in each day. If we keep remembering that we’re writers, then we need most of that time to actually write something, not to promote other things.
Promotion can’t be by rote, but it can’t be horribly time-consuming either. It needs to be something we can do after we’re done writing.
Also, as writers, we love drama, be it fictional or not. Some platforms encourage drama. Others do not. The ones that do make it hard to look away or to log off. Back to the addiction that Bogost discussed. Some of that addiction is an addiction to stories, akin to binge watching.
That’s actually a good cycle to break out of.
I was a bit discombobulated in November when I left Twitter. But over the weeks, I started seeing the upside. Yep, it’ll take work to create new followings in other places. And it will take time to do so as well.
It also means I have to stop being lazy on this platform. I need to share more about what I’m doing, even in this blog.
For example, Dean and I have a Kickstarter that went live this week. It’s for five fantasy collections, which we’re doing as part of Kickstarter’s Make 100. We’re excited about that. As of this writing, we’ve already moved into the stretch goals, so readers will get a lot of extras if they back the Kickstarter. Check it out.
WMG has a new Shopify store (which I will discuss in depth in a later year-in-review post) which we’re just getting up and running. We also put together an easily searchable website for our workshops. Not to mention all the writing that I’m doing.
So we need—I need—to change my behavior, and the ways I promote things.
It’ll be a steep learning curve for all of us as we learn our new social media platforms and figure out how we fit. It’ll also be a learning curve to change our behavior, because, as one article I read tonight mentioned, we’ve all been doing the same thing with social media since about 2010.
Time for a change.
We just had to be forced into it.
And I suspect, it was long past time to do so.
Last week, I mentioned that in these little end notes, I would point you to a workshop or something else related to the current post. Well, since the changes in social media are so new, there’s nothing related.
So I’ll tell you about two weekly classes that we’ve started in 2023. The one I’m happiest about is Bite-Sized Copyright. We’ve been trying to do a copyright class for years that writers would actually take, and we finally hit on the way to do it. Short little lessons every week for a year.
It’s the best and most painless way to figure out all the details of licensing a copyright.
The other class is the Decade Ahead. Yeah, we started that in 2020, and then got derailed by the pandemic. But we’re back, with a lot of ideas about where we’re going in the future. So take a look at that one as well.
Or take a peek at the Advanced Craft classes. Or all the other things we offer.
I’m sure there’s more I could share with you, but that’s more than enough for now. Except the weekly reminder: This blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynrusch to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: Social Media The Year in Review Part 7,” copyright © 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © Can Stock Photo / curvabezier.
I’m actually a little excited (and terrified that I’m excited) for 2023. All of us involved with WMG Publishing are starting the year at a full run. We’ve made a lot of changes and progress in December, and we have great plans for this new year.
First, let me tell you Diving fans that I’m nearly done with a surprise Diving novel. I decided to write a side Diving novella for two reasons: the first is that Sheila Williams at Asimov’s asked me for something longer. The second is that next week, I’m teaching an in-person class all about combining the caper subgenre with fantasy. Yes, I know. Diving isn’t fantasy, but I figured I’d practice in a world suited to a caper (Diving) and then I’d write a fantasy caper before the class. Realize I made this decision in October, and figured I could get it all done. Instead, I ended up writing a surprise Diving novel, with some side stories. And I haven’t even gotten to the caper yet! I’ll keep you posted on news of that novel, as well as some other fiction I’m working on. (If you want to study fantasy capers, it’s too late to join the in-person class, but you can take the study-along…if you want to do a lot of prep work this week.)
Speaking of workshops…well, let me talk to the readers before I get to the rest of the workshop news. That’ll be at the bottom of this post, not because it’s unimportant, but because some of you won’t get that far.
Today, we launched our Shopify store. You can order ebooks directly from us. I’ll have more to say on that as time goes on, because we’re still uploading books. (We have a thousand books now through WMG. Isn’t that a stunner?) Right now, we have gone live with four of our major series. Diving, The Fey, and Dean’s Cold Poker Gang in fiction, and in nonfiction, all of our writing guides. With more—much more!—to come. The staff at WMG Publishing has done an amazing amount of work to get this together, and I hope you’ll be able to use it for our stuff.
And, as you can probably tell from the header, we’ve started a new Kickstarter. Every year in January, Kickstarter hosts projects under the banner “Make 100.” If you make 100 of anything and run a Kickstarter on it, Kickstarter will promote it. We tried that a few years ago with Year of the Cat (which we were planning to do anyway). It worked out well enough that we decided to do collections.
We’ve done two large collections so far. Five collections with 20 stories each—ten from Dean and ten from me. Since we did sf and mystery the past two years, we decided to do fantasy this year. As you can see from the header, Allyson Longueira at WMG designed some truly lovely books. With every backer reward, you will get the five books in ebook.
The rewards give you all kinds of things, from discounts on the previous collections (in case you missed them) to signed hardcovers to a variety of fantasy novels by me and Dean to workshops. This is a great deal of fun, and a lovely grouping of stories.
Oh, and the book topics run from Weird to Urban Fantasy to Dark Fantasy (with two other fun categories). Watch the video below to learn more. And writers…scroll down for workshop information promised above.
So…the workshops. First, we have a new website that’s easily searchable. If you want to learn anything about writing or business or craft, then put in the topic. I have a hunch you’ll find a workshop to suit your needs.
The workshops that I’m most excited about are these:
Bite-Sized Copyright: Writers license copyright. They don’t sell stories. And licensing includes games and toys and movies and all kinds of other things. While Dean and I aren’t lawyers or accountants, we have licensed our copyrights for decades. We know how to talk to writers about this. We’ve tried to hold this class in different formats for years and no one takes the class. Now, we’ve come up with a new format. One little nugget of copyright knowledge per week for the entire year. Yep, you read that right. 52 short explorations of the ways writers can use their copyrights to increase their income. The class is really worth taking, folks.
The Decade Ahead: Yeah, we tried that in 2020 and guess what? We got derailed by…well…2020. Now, we’re back with a focus on making it through and planning, even when the world throws a surprise at you. Like Bite-Size Copyright, this is a weekly class, filled with all kinds of information.
Advanced Craft Classes: We have a lot of classes. Some are for beginners. Some are for writers with a lot of experience under their belts. But these classes go to the next level. They will take writers into techniques only a handful of writers know and use. Classes cover everything from Pacing to Voice to Viewpoint, and more. You can buy all of the classes together (and get a slight discount), or sign up for them one at a time.
So, as I said above, we’ve started the year at full speed. I hope you will join us on one or all of these projects.
And I wish you the very best in 2023!
Angie achieved fame as a spacer. But when some fresh-faced interviewer asks Angie to tell the origin story of the Space Bimbos, the interviewer gets more than she bargained for.
Instead, Angie tells the tale of a group of ambitious and talented girls who, inspired by an old pulp magazine called Rocket Girls, cobbled together a rocket and tried to blast off into space—and then, made history.
With “Rocket Girls,” Kristine Kathryn Rusch puts her own genius female-empowered twist on the build-a-spaceship-in-your-backyard trope from the pulps.
“Rocket Girls” by Hugo Award-winning author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook through various online retailers here.
Rocket GirlsKristine Kathryn RuschSerious spacers don’t parade around their starships half dressed. Or wearing tight clothing and heels so high they could puncture a floor. Serious spacers wear no makeup, don’t dress their hair, and never ever ever wear jewelry. Serious spacers hate girl things because girl things make them seem unserious and seeming unserious prevents them from getting work.
Serious spacers are thin, tough, and weathered.
Serious spacers say “Please,” and “Thank you” and hope to hell someone’ll give them a commission.
Serious spacers—aren’t me.
The attitude—the attitude started in school. Okay, never mind. I just lied. I lie a lot, but mostly that’s for my job. We’ll get to that. I’ll try to be truthful here. It’s a history, after all. A her-story, really, but that’s beside the point. I’m putting down a record, because without records, there wouldn’t be Rocket Girls, and without Rocket Girls, there would be no Space Bimbos.
But I get ahead of myself.
The attitude—my attitude—my screw-you attitude—well, I was probably born with it. I most likely came out of the womb (yes, vaginal birth, very old-fashioned) thinking Who are you people and what do you want with me? Maybe wondering What is this place? Maybe asking What fresh hell is this?
As for that whole expected crying thing, which I know I did not do because Mom told that story a million times, I have an explanation for that too. First, Mom’s version:
Born, didn’t cry, didn’t fuss, took us awhile to realize she wasn’t breathing. But the midwife figured it out, cleared her little throat with a pinky finger, and voila! my Angie, she entered the world.
My explanation? The entry into a new environment was surprising and unapproved. No one told me I was leaving somewhere warm and liquid, getting squeezed through a tube, and entering a place filled with air. I’m a scientist—okay, not really, another lie, but I have a scientist’s mind—okay, yet another lie. I have a scientist’s curiosity, and I’m sure I wasn’t done exploring the old environment before I got to the new.
And, let’s be honest here (and really, since I’m the only one talking, I’ll be honest here): I’m a control freak. I have been known to not-cooperate with authority, especially authority that has an agenda. And I gotta tell you, those people in that room (birthing suite, whatever) had an agenda.
Typical me, I was more interested in control than survival. Although survival did win out in the end. Of course I took a first breath at some point. Which is why I’m talking to you now.
About attitude.
It only got worse as time went on. For some reason, the Parents sent me to an all-girls school. (I never did get the entire reasoning behind that one.) On Earth. (That part was totally, totally cool. When the administrators let us out of the school walls, of course.) And I got straight As. God’s truth.
(I’m holding up my hand here for those of you who can’t see the holo image or the 2-D version, and are listening to it on some audio channel, or [worse], reading the transcript. [Sorry, you actual readers. I digress a lot. That’s gotta be a minefield to wade through. At least they’re cutting out the “um”s. Or, at least, that’s what they said they’d do.] Anyway, holding up my hand is swearing to a statement, something else I learned on Earth. I learned a lot on Earth. That’s not what this history is about. You’ll have to ask me later about those things, and Earth, and my entire history, and how cool my life has been. You just asked about Space Bimbos, which leads directly to Rocket Girls, which is all I’m going to tell you. God knows, it’s more than enough for one day.)
But behind the As was the attitude. The straight As made the authorities look the other way whenever anything went wrong, and, more importantly, kept the Parents funneling cash at the place, so that I could stay with my pals. We grew up together and we thought we were going to conquer the world. The world being, at that point, Earth, because none of us wanted to go back to the starbases or the Moon or Io or the places we took long, long, long journeys from to arrive at that bastion of education and history.
We hadn’t yet discovered the Rocket Girls.
Ah, the Rocket Girls. I don’t even know how to tell you about them because they are so fantastical, even now. I’d show them to you, except I lost my single copy—yes, copy—in a firefight off Starbase 867 decades ago. I’d love to show you the digital version I had, only my ship, Rocket Girl Won, blew up just outside Earth’s solar system, back when we were fighting the Cascade Wars. I never backed up my computer system or my records. I didn’t trust the web or the cloud or the net or whatever jargon you now use for that floating information data sphere, easily searchable, easily spyable, and easily stealable.
I’m sure, though, you could find an issue of Rocket Girls in that floating information sphere somewhere, but you’d have to check with me as to whether or not it was our issue. Because there were, like, fourteen of them still in existence when I was a girl, over a century ago.
Not fourteen of the issue. Fourteen existing copies of the Rocket Girls magazine or stories or whatever they called them back in the Paper Era. So much data got lost then. We studied it all in school. Paper was fragile. It actually decayed and then vanished. By the end of what most of Earth called the 20th century, someone tried to digitize as much of the paper crap as possible, but they kept only the “important” stuff, and pulp paper fiction magazines filled with lurid art weren’t considered important. Nor were the paperback books that so much of this stuff later got put into.
Designed to be disposable. That saying, “wraps the fish”? It comes from that era because all the news reports were on paper, and lasted only a day or so, before someone used the old paper to wrap cooked fish. Or something like that.
I looked it all up once. Studied the history of paper, of paper creations, even saw some actual ones in museums—not hands-on museums, but behind-the-glass museums that recreated a virtual experience for you. You could look at a paper copy of something, even hold it in your hand, turn the pages, sit in a 20th-century chair in a 20th-century house drinking 20th-century coffee listening to 20th-century music while you did so. Of course, it would all vanish at the end of the paid-viewing cycle, and you be stuck in a blank room with blank walls and a moldable chair, but it would feel real while you were doing it.
I understand some of you are watching me that way now, as if I’m sitting across from you.
I’m trying not to let that creep me out.
But for the record, I’m sitting in an actual room-room, with all kinds of equipment and a fresh-faced girl sitting across from me who professes to want to know everything Space Bimbo, as if I’m a relic (I’m not) and I don’t have another two centuries ahead of me (I like to believe my life is only a third over, even though I know not everyone makes it to 300). I’m still active and fighting and surviving, even if the Space Bimbos are gone—or at least the first generation of us. We’ve disbanded and moved on with our lives, and apparently, according to yon Fresh-Faced Sweetie across from me, the second generation of Space Bimbos is arising.
I’d rather they were Rocket Girls.
I warned you about these digressions, didn’t I? Because initially, I’d been talking about Rocket Girls, the paper story that we passed around at school. We didn’t know it was collectible or valuable or a bit of history that we were smearing our dirty fingers over and giggling at the arcane language and shocking attitudes.
Ruby’s father bought a whole pile of what he called pulps from a museum that was closing. The museum, owned by a long-forgotten city, was selling off its “treasures” to anyone willing to fork out the cash. The true treasures went to museums all over the galaxy.
The stuff that wasn’t important (we discussed “important” above) got sold locally or tossed out. Apparently, Ruby’s father had a thing for old fiction of the era so he bought a lot. Or maybe he just took it out of the garbage. I don’t know, I don’t care, except to tell you this:
There were twelve of us, best friends all. Ruby brought one Rocket Girls to school and we passed it around like it was something forbidden. Maybe it was, I don’t know. No one ever took it from us, nor did anyone yell at us for reading it. Although they should’ve yelled at us for ruining it, because paper—especially old paper—just crumbles in your hands.
She had thirteen of them; we managed to ruin one. I’ll tell you about the others in a minute.
First, let me describe this thing with a bit of history. Back in that 20th century, astronauts—that’s the name they gave spacers back then, back when it was all beginning—actually flew out of Earth’s atmosphere in a ship mounted on a rocket. A rocket that had explosives in it. It was dangerous and stupid and scary and God, it sounds like fun.
The rockets, like so many things of that era, were shaped like giant penises, and fire came out the bottom (don’t go there with the metaphor; just don’t). The power of the rocket got the ships out of Earth’s atmosphere and usually put the ships into orbit. The early ships didn’t have any propellant as we understand it, so the orbit would eventually decay and they’d fall back to Earth.
Later, things got more sophisticated but, from my understanding of all this history, when Rocket Girls came out, these mighty weird ships existed only in some writer/artist’s imagination. I’m pretty sure the things were penis-shaped to get young boys, believed to be the audience for this prurient fiction, to buy the books/magazines/paper products because—and here’s the kicker—often the Rocket Girls covers had some scantily clad big busted beautiful woman clinging to the rocket (legs wrapped around it) without wearing any protective gear at all.
Sexual? Of course. But back in those days, you couldn’t be overtly sexual. Just covertly. In other words, a drawing couldn’t show a woman with a penis in her hand, but it could show a tiny woman hugging one.
Yeah, I don’t understand it either.
And let’s just say that twelve girls at an all-girls boarding school knew less about penises despite all the information at our fingertips than we did about beautiful art.
And that art was beautiful.
The girls were beautiful.
And we were at that impressionable girl-age when you wanted to be pretty as much as you wanted to be successful.
What could be more successful than a beautiful woman heading alone to the stars?
That’s what we saw. All the penises, the analysis, the unreality of it, that came later, when we were older.
You can’t help what you imprint on as a kid. It’s whatever floats in front of you, whatever grabs your imagination and won’t let you go.
These Rocket Girls magazines, they grabbed us. They held us. They spoke to our adventurous souls and our secret desire to be spacers. But they also spoke to our inner rebel.
The Rocket Girls of the magazine fame headed out alone, but did get rescued by men. We missed the subtext. We missed a lot of subtext. We saw the adventure. The heading out alone. The strong women in a strong profession where no one told them what to do.
It was the Wild West out there in Rocket Girls land, and we loved that.
Oh, crap. From the frown Fresh Face is giving me right now, I guess that means you don’t even know what the Wild West is. Look it up: it’s an Earth reference from United States history. Even now, I keep forgetting how far we are from Earth and how little everyone else knows about the place.
Yet it is not just the birthplace of our race. It’s also where Rocket Girls—and the Space Bimbos—got their start.
I know the myths, I know the legends. The marauding band of women, little more than pirates, stepping outside the rules, unable to be called spacers because we didn’t act like spacers. We used old ships, decommissioned ships, traveled on discontinued routes, went to forbidden areas of the sector.
You wouldn’t have heard of us at all if we hadn’t gotten rid of the Manzanita Fleet in the Battle of Cascade Heavy, the tipping point of the Cascade Wars. And that, my friends, was less about Space Bimbos than it was about luck.
We just got tired of being good girls. Straight As, following rules, meeting regulations. We stole the first ship—but I get ahead of myself.
Or not. Fresh Face wants me to get to it, so I will:
School, inspiration, drawing our own Rocket Girls images, spacer training, even though our parents disapproved. But the Parents lived far away, and the school they sent us to was supposed to encourage ambition—any kind of ambition—even if it was as mundane as spacing.
The Rocket Girls magazine was written before humans went into space. Imagined outer space—usually wrong—impossible missions, great clothing, fantastic art, and lots and lots of inspiration. We talked about Rocket Girls. We wanted to be Rocket Girls.
Didn’t matter that we didn’t look like them. I mean, no woman looks quite like them—breasts the size of rockets all by themselves, waists so thin that they barely could contain a raspberry let alone stomach and organs and blood vessels and all the other parts.
Don’t know raspberries? Oh, jeez. Missing one of nature’s most glorious creations. And seriously, Fresh Face, who runs the hydroponics around here? There should be fresh fruits and veggies of all kinds, not just some regionally prescribed crap.
Then there was the Rocket Girl hair, and the eyes, so big that they took up half the face, and skin that was an unnatural white—which, we learned in our Earth history classes was a thing. Skin color, that is. Important for reasons that make absolutely no sense to me now. Yeah, I didn’t do well with it in school either.
Since we didn’t understand it, we ignored it.
So…like all other teenagers on a mission, we started with the clothing—when we weren’t in spacer training, of course. Honestly, you can’t show up in thigh-high boots, form-fitting cutaway teddies, and whip bands around your wrists and expect to be taken seriously at spacer camp.
Kids always start at spacer camp, even now. At least on Earth. Where you can sit out under the stars and imagine great things. My research tells me that spacer camp comes from that 20th century stuff, astronaut camp turned into physics camp, turned into computer camp, if you can believe it, and then split off where all the little round-headed brainiacs went to one camp and the athletic muscle went to the other.
We were round-headed brainiacs who wanted to do athletic muscle jobs the way they were done Way Back When.
That’s why we stole the ship.
That’s how we all got in trouble.
And that’s why we ran away.
Spacer camp. Sounds cool, but is totally stupid.
Starts in Florida, goes into space.
How do I describe Florida to those of you who’ve never been to Earth? If I compare Florida to some other galaxy hot spot, then I only reach those of you who’ve been to that place. And some of you might disagree. So, let me set the scene as best I can.
Florida—a narrow peninsula between two oceans. It used to be wider and flatter, or so the histories show, but Earth went through a dark period of rising seas and massive storms. Parts of Florida broke off or vanished underwater. A massive financial campaign started to save what was left, although for the love of God, I have no idea why.
We were on the “space coast,” all of its treasures surviving the great cataclysm due to a confluence of out-of-work engineers (from when a government-operated space program ended) and a sense of history that seems to strike Earthers every generation or two.
The twelve of us went on a tour of the actual place where rockets launched, hundreds of years ago. We even saw some of the rockets, which just looked old and rusty and rickety.
We got history of humankind’s space exploration, designed to impart respect, and we got instruction in mundane things, like how to start a standard engine, how to stop an energy leak, and how to evaluate a spaceship’s quality.
That’s the thing about going to spacer camp on the Space Coast. There are lots of old spaceships lying about—or at least there were back then. Can’t tell you what’s going on now, since it’s been decades since I’ve been back.
But then, the idea was that the old ships would inspire. We could sit in the cockpit or on the bridge and imagine ourselves lifting off, imagine ourselves wrapped around those rockets and riding that metal penis into space.
We talked about it a lot, that second summer of spacer camp—after we saw the Rocket Girls magazine. And we decided we couldn’t really understand anything until we tried it.
So our spacer camp was different from everyone else’s spacer camp.
Very different.
Don’t believe everything you’ve heard. We didn’t steal a derelict ship, not really. We rebuilt a derelict ship, or as I later told the authorities, we built a derelict ship.
You see, the derelicts all over the Space Coast were in various states of repair. It was kind of like a junkyard for spaceships.
Oh, jeez (yes, jeez. Yes, I know I said it twice now. It’s a word I picked up from Rocket Girls. Deal with it). Those of you who can see me can see me shaking my head. Junk. Stuff no longer needed. Yard—well, that’s a bit of ground used for various purposes. If you’re going to ask me to define every word you do not know, Fresh Face, then we’re all screwed here. So just listen, and look this crap up later. You only have me for a limited time, you know.
But to be clear, since you’re not getting it, there were a lot of broken ships and ship parts all over that part of the Space Coast. Some of them were there because of that great cataclysm. Seems big trauma like that gets in the way of people cleaning stuff up.
So here we are, twelve girls itching for adventure, lying on our backs in the humid night, looking at the moon over the Atlantic Ocean. The moon reflects off that ocean, the light beautiful and rich. It’s hard to believe anyone lives on the Moon or that the Moon is considered (in space terms) not very far away.
Particularly when you’re trapped on Earth in Florida, of all places, imagining yourself going on adventures even though you’ve never had one. Not even the trip to Earth was an adventure in the Rocket-Girls sense of the word.
All of us (except Ruby) had gotten on long-haul passenger ships from our various homes and had cushy berths because all of us were trust-fund babies. We had more money than we should have, because our parents worried about us being so very far away without direct access to funds.
Fast forward to us, lying on the beach, looking at the Moon eleven of us had passed on our way to Florida, the Moon that twelve of us hadn’t thought much of, which looked so tiny and so far away and so inaccessible. Its reflection shimmered on the water like an illusion, and I like to think that’s when we decided to become actual Rocket Girls.
But I’m sure it wasn’t that quick. I’m sure it happened slowly, as we were all kvetching (seriously? Kvetching. Jeez, Fresh Face. Time to start looking things up). We would sneak out of our dorms and sit on the beach. We didn’t drink—not yet—because that part of Florida was “dry” (and I’ll give you that one, since I didn’t know it either when I first arrived. It meant that there was no easy access to alcohol or other drugs that were legal in most places).
I’m pretty sure that’s when we divided ourselves up into the type of adventurers we wanted to be. We did it by skill set. A third of us had only one skill—shopping. So they were in charge of the thigh-high boots, form-fitting cutaway teddies, and whip bands, as well as some other clothing that would be considered a tad more practical.
The fashionistas had to travel out of the region to get that stuff. Turns out that an area which is “dry” is also “repressed,” and wasn’t interested in clothing that accentuated the female form.
A third of us learned weaponry, which was allowed in that part of Florida—which apparently had a long history of allowing weapons but disallowing anything fun like sex and drinking.
We figured we would need weapons because Rocket Girls had shown us the perils of the universe. Monsters with gigantic bug eyes that would turn those bug eyes on human women and try to capture said women with tiny hands covered in too many fingers and lots of claws; men who had been “enchanted” by some alien overlord and who would try to capture women using blasters and ropes and hooks and other scary-looking items; and faceless creatures on impossible spaceships that would try to drag women across the vastness of space as if we could survive out in the open with nothing around us but a tiny bit of fabric over the “forbidden” parts.
(I see you, Fresh Face. “Forbidden” varies from culture to culture. Rocket Girls came out during a particularly repressed time. Look up the cultural norms, because I’m not doing it for you.)
And then there was the remaining third of us, which included me. The engineers. We were a lot more interested in the way the ships worked than in the way the weapons worked. We weren’t as adventurous as our weapons women, but we weren’t as interested in shopping as our fashionistas either.
In fact, we were probably the least interested in the fashion. We gave no fashion advice at all to our shopping compatriots. The weapons women asked the fashionistas to make sure there was some kind of holster for the blaster, which was what we called all of our weapons from laser guns to the five guns that shot actual bullets (and which we engineers locked up as soon as we saw them. It was a tad embarrassing to have to explain to our weapons-loving sisters what kind of danger bullets presented in a pressurized environment. I mean, really, they should have listened in class).
So the four of us who liked engineering and building stuff, well, we were the ones who found all the pieces of the spaceships. We found a hulk that loomed in the sand not far from our private plotting dune, and we pronounced that hulk space-worthy the first day we saw it.
We were wrong, of course. We had a lot of work to do, and by the time we finished the hulk looked like a ruined spaceship with all kinds of crap grafted to it.
We really didn’t know what we were doing. We knew the ship needed propulsion. We knew we had to control it from the cockpit. We knew that the ship had to have an air-tight seal and we figured it needed some kind of artificial gravity.
We forgot about the kitchen, so we had to cobble something together the night before our launch. We did remember chairs, though, and thought it would be better to have them attached to the floor than rolling around. But we figured we could Velcro our sleeping bags to that same floor, which was a decision we would come to regret.
Some of the team ended up regretting lots of things. I don’t. I don’t regret it at all, because the entire adventure set me on the right path…for me. And that’s all that matters—the right path for you.
Spacer camp ended on September 15, on the Earth calendar, with the 24-hour days that mark Earth time. We planned our first (and only) flight for the night of September 1.
What we really wanted to do was fly out of Earth’s atmosphere on a real rocket. A few of us hoped to cling to the outside of it, just like in the illustrations on Rocket Girls. But we engineers explained what would happen to the human body if that was actually something we could have arranged (and I suppose we could have, with some kind of glued handhold or something—until the person burned to a crisp or fell off due to the velocity or passed out from lack of air—God knows what would have happened first).
The description so grossed out the others, particularly since we described everything as if the person clinging to the rocket was wearing thigh-high boots, form-fitting cutaway teddies, and exposing lots and lots and lots of bare skin.
A couple of the girls burst into tears and told me personally that they never could forgive me for that description.
I figured never being forgiven for a description was a lot better than watching your friend die in the most horrible manner possible, particularly when you were one of the people who enabled it.
We missed our September 1 deadline by two days, mostly because someone had forgotten that we needed food on the flight. We had no idea how to make a kitchen. Heck, most of us had no idea how to make food at all.
And yet, there we were, thinking we might make it to orbit, and actually orbit for a while, maybe even a day or two or three. And if that was the case, we needed to eat something.
I left it to the shoppers, after telling them that the food had to be some kind of ready to eat something, and it couldn’t have a lot of fiddly little bits, particularly since I wasn’t too sure that the artificial gravity we were putting into the spaceship would actually work.
I was fifteen, and even though I called myself an engineer, I wasn’t. I didn’t know, for example, that engineers theorized, then tested, then retested, then fixed, then had someone else test, then theorized some more, and tested, and retested, and maybe spent years perfecting everything, because real engineers believed in safety first.
Me, back then? I believed in making it work first, and everything else would resolve itself.
Ooooops.
Luckily, none of us died.
That night, we found the ancient launch pad that had sent some of the very first spacers—um, astronauts—into space. We weren’t calling ourselves spacers then. We had imprinted hard on Rocket Girls, like I said, and so we were calling ourselves astronauts, even in regular conversation.
Our teachers at spacer camp thought it was cute. They thought we were honoring the history of the place. They thought we were really getting into the details of everything they taught.
We did the homework, such as it was, and saw all the relics, such as they were, and did all the camp things that every other camp on the shores of the warm Atlantic did, like swim in the mornings and learn how to play baseball (because organized sport, I guess, taught team building, which was, I guess, necessary for space flight). We did some truly lame experiments that were called chemistry and a few less lame experiments that were called physics and some really cool observations in a nearby planetarium which also set our work back a few nights and almost lost us Chantel.
Chantel really liked the astronomy stuff, and was willing to forgo our little experiment to spend more time gazing at the heavens. We reminded her that we would be in the heavens soon enough, and I actually had to clarify because Chantel looked terrified at that moment. I hadn’t known that she was an old-fashioned Christian and old-fashioned Christianity taught that dead people (who were “good,” whatever that meant) went to actual heaven.
It took Lupe to remind Chantel, using Spanish, which they were both fluent in as well, that words sometimes shared meanings, like cielo and heaven. And sometimes metaphor is good. Chantel, back in them thar days, was a bit too literal for our own good. She got better, albeit not by much.
Anyway, we got her back in the fold with that promise, and then we went to work. We weren’t getting much sleep, especially since reveille was at 6 a.m. sharp followed by the Polar Bear Swim at 6:15. But we were getting lots done.
We had our rebuilt relic ready by September 3, and our planned lift-off under the full moon on September 4. Of course, we didn’t check the weather report, and that could’ve been dicier than it was (we had twilight clouds, but they cleared by midnight).
It took two hours longer than we planned to get the relic onto the ancient launchpad. And we only managed to achieve that because we found an ancient winch attached to an ancient vehicle that Delilah figured out how to operate in the very nick of time.
The only reason our camp counselors, teachers and chaperones did not figure out what we were doing was because of the vast distances.
Spacer camp was as far inland as possible on the Space Coast, and the launch pad was on rebuilt marshland that constantly went underwater in really bad storms. Like I said, Florida was not what it had been in the 20th century, and the Space Coast was only surviving because of some really good funding for important historic sites.
The promised rain at twilight didn’t happen (although we hadn’t known that those clouds were supposed to be rain clouds) so we were in the clear in more ways than one.
Before we got on the relic, we stood back and admired our handiwork. That’s one of my best memories ever. Eleven of my closest friends and me, standing on ancient asphalt in our thigh-high boots and form-fitting cutaway teddies, feeling the sweat drip down our backs from the incredible humidity, listening to the night bugs chirrup and threaten, and looking at the moon providing light over the ocean that was almost as bright as day.
In front of that ocean and that moon, on the ancient launchpad, was the relic. It wasn’t quite a rocket ship—where would we have gotten a rocket? Even though ships were lying around discarded (for teaching purposes), rockets from the bygone rocket era were not. They were dangerous, after all.
There weren’t any weapons either. The weapons crew had to buy some, usually with Mommy and Daddy’s money.
But, because we were sticklers for what we considered to be accuracy, we chose the spaceship shell that was as close to penis-shaped as we could find.
One of us (Claudia?) suggested we paste some kind of statue on the side, dressed as we were that night, clinging to the ship and riding it into the stars (or at least, low orbit). We couldn’t, of course. I didn’t want to explain physics and balance and all kinds of other things, not counting what would happen to that statue if it wasn’t made of the right materials (just like humans weren’t made of the right materials).
I thought, briefly, of painting a woman on the side—and yes, Fresh Face, I did that on almost every other ship I ever had, which is why you know about it—but we didn’t have time or an artist in our midst who could actually paint and not do something computer generated.
Still, I can’t tell you how magnificent that ship was, looming darkly against that brightly light night sky. To this day, I’m amazed the councilors, instructors, and chaperones didn’t notice the ship, but they didn’t. It wasn’t so much that they trusted the kids at spacer camp as that they expected some kind of hijinks.
They just didn’t expect our kind of hijinks.
We did a few things that the experts would have said were wrong (well, we did a lot wrong, actually), but we had no choice. We didn’t have what the Rocket Girls magazine called “Mission Control.” We didn’t have anyone on the ground who was going to monitor us.
Nor did we clamp the ship into the launch pad. We just balanced the ship on the pad and prayed for the best.
Looking back now, it’s kind of a miracle that the ship didn’t tumble one way or another. We didn’t have the shell anchored properly, we had too much weight in the middle, and then we were climbing (yes, climbing) on board on the rickety internal ladder system that I had deemed good enough.
At least I remembered to put lighting inside that came on automatically.
Half of us changed our shoes on the launch pad, but half of us didn’t. All of us put our suits on over our form-fitting cutaway teddies and the too-short shorts that we wore with the boots.
The suits weren’t old. They were state-of-the-art, stolen (the camp later said) from its wardrobe, borrowed (we said) because we couldn’t find anything else. I left my boots in a heap at the base of the launch pad. Those things looked great, but they hurt, particularly where they cut into my—shall we say “generous”?—thighs.
I let us into the ship, and climbed up that ladder, followed by the rest of the engineers. Sadie peeled off to work in the bowels of the ship where we had placed a sort of secondary control area and Joanie and I climbed to the cockpit, much quicker than anyone else because our shoes were practical and our legs weren’t being strangled by fashion.
A couple of the weapons women followed us, going to the third area of the ship that we had prepared—the lounge was what Sadie called it; the passenger area was what I called it, not wanting to hurt anyone’s feelings.
It was maybe the most cramped area of the ship, and it didn’t have any portals. The “passengers” got to watch the launch on a screen, rather than experience it through wide-open clear portals that covered a goodly portion of the cockpit.
They were lucky. They never believed me about that, but they were.
The problem wasn’t so much liftoff as—
Well, I get ahead of myself.
We thought we had all the safety protocols in place. We had straps to hold us into our seats. We had redundant systems. We had a plan and a way to execute it.
We had even done practice flights—on simulators, of course, because we didn’t want the spacer camp folks to catch a single clue—but we figured that was all enough.
We got into our places, and no one even suggested backing out.
Tells you how young we were.
I ended up at the controls, by default. All four of the engineers knew how to fly this thing, in theory, and all of us had had actual flight training long before we ever came to spacer camp, but let me tell you, most flying vehicles on Earth are simple things—and were then too.
Yeah, you had to test and qualify, but essentially, those things drove themselves. I flew some more complicated things—my obsession with old started long before spacer camp and Rocket Girls—but old meant actual planes from thirty years before which (you guessed it) essentially flew themselves.
Our first ship, which we stupidly did not name (not knowing about that superstition), did not essentially fly itself. You had to actively engage with the control panel.
I thought I was ready. I was the one at the helm because I was the one who never had to dunk the ship in the water in simulation or watch helplessly as it tumbled through the air before it ever reached the atmosphere.
My simulated flights were fine. They went well, and we all figured that was enough.
Here’s what I didn’t expect: the helm actually vibrated in my hands. Hell, the ship vibrated around us. It felt like it was going to shake apart.
As I said, none of us discussed aborting the so-called mission, because we were young and dumb and we didn’t know better.
I have never felt a ship shake like that before or since.
The shaking was so violent that Joanie bit through her lower lip, accidentally. I thought my head was going to wobble off. One of the badly assembled chairs actually came loose. Lupe was in it, and apparently, she climbed out of it, and somehow managed to hang on while reattaching it.
I missed that. It had happened in the lounge, not the cockpit.
That cockpit. I still see it in my dreams.
It was small, so tight that the two of us inside were shoulder to shoulder. There was clear something or other all the way around us so we could see. I say something or other because it wasn’t glass and it wasn’t plastic as we know it. Just some kind of material that we hoped—I hoped—was properly reinforced to withstand whatever was going to be thrown at us.
Every single discarded ship had an area like that. This particular relic had used the area as a cockpit before. Every bit of equipment that remained in the relic was either rusted or frozen in place. So we removed it, and replaced it with newer equipment from another relic.
That replacement was what took all the time. We had a state-of-the-art control panel…from fifty years before…which was the newest we could find. It had touchscreens, which were/are notoriously unreliable, but we didn’t care. Anything was better than the rusted frozen thing we had replaced.
Of course, replacing the panel meant replacing all the leads and connections all the way down to what we were calling the engineering room, which was really the engine room, which was really just an unused area—at least when we found it.
We managed to rejigger everything, and install some seats that were more comfortable than the broken ones in the cockpit, but they were a little too big.
We turned everything on before flying the ship, but we never did try to see if everything worked together properly.
Whoops.
Still, I was so proud of that cockpit and control board. It was probably the only thing on the entire ship that was sparklingly clean. It was set up to my specifications, everything spaced properly for my grip, my hands, my sightlines. I have not had anything since that was set up so perfectly, just for me.
We all strapped in. We settled back. Those of us in the cockpit could see the moon illuminating the ocean—and the side of the ship. The girls below, well, I guess they could see the walls and little else, even though they were watching the ship itself on the screens we’d rigged up.
Only Ruby was watching everything from her seat in the lounge. She was the one who saw the vehicles driving through the gates of the old Space Center, moving faster than land vehicles ever should have. Someone had figured out what we were doing, and the vehicles were coming quickly. But they were on land, because they weren’t sure what was going to happen with the ship. (I learned that later.)
Ruby reported their presence in a breathless voice over our comm system. That set the adrenaline going even more than it had been going earlier.
I went through the launch sequence faster than I had planned to. We had a checkpoint sequence, and we sped through it, me and the other engineers.
The ship’s shaking grew steadily worse, and a part of my brain wondered if we would ever get off the ground. We did have our own escape gear built into our space suits. If the ship disintegrated—a distinct possibility—we had parachutes for the lower elevations.
That was pretty much it.
We hadn’t even gotten to the part of spacer camp where we learned that escape pods existed for a reason. There was no way to transform a true spacesuit into an escape pod that would last for anything longer than an hour or two.
But we were the Rocket Girls, at least in our heads. We were willing to risk it.
The engines fired, the touchscreen winked out for a half second, and I brought it back by muttering an expletive and slamming my fist against the screen, in true Rocket Girl fashion.
The ship vibrated sideways, and Ruby worried (out loud) that we would slide right off the launch pad. Instead, the ship lifted, just like it was designed to do, and then it headed into space.
From that moment, we were just along for the ride.
I had programmed the route into the automatic pilot. I was a dummy but I wasn’t completely stupid. I knew I couldn’t handle the actual piloting and neither could the rest of us.
I just figured that automatic pilot was the sort of thing that was better than a human pilot, and maybe it was with Earth ships of that era, but our ship was a hybrid from previous eras, when automatic pilot (I later learned) required a very human backup to deal with all of the problems.
Which showed up almost immediately.
Our trajectory was straight up, which I had not programmed. And the stupid ship was going faster than I wanted. As in four times as fast.
If everything continued the way it was going, we would exit the atmosphere half an hour before we were supposed to and overshoot the proposed orbit—the one that would keep us away from most space debris and existing ships.
There was an override. I remembered seeing it as I installed the touchscreen. As I searched, the touchscreen went out again.
And then the ship vibrated into big meaty pieces.
Apparently the lounge area separated first, and then the engines just fell through the exterior, pulling on the control panel, which took out part of one of our walls.
The suits did what they were supposed to, because they were state-of-the-art. The hoods came up and secured themselves around our faces. The entire suit sealed in less than five seconds, startling me, and getting in the way of my hands trying to work the very dead touchscreen.
The cockpit fell away around us. We were still in the middle of the night sky. We hadn’t left the atmosphere yet.
My friends in the lounge were plummeting away from us. I hoped they were smart enough to get out. The engineering section had disintegrated as thoroughly as our section and I could already see the gigantic parachutes, open and catching the wind.
Which was when my parachute deployed, jerking me upward with such force that my neck felt like it was going to snap off.
The moon was setting on the other side of the peninsula, but I could see it. I like to think I could also see high-heeled boots kicking their way out of the lounge, but I didn’t see any of that. The lounge was too heavy and they were heading down too fast for me to see anything.
Plus, it was getting darker.
I swayed and searched for my friends. My stomach was in knots, and I was terrified.
Below me, the ocean glittered darkly, and I finally understood why the Space Coast was on the coast.
I hadn’t set up any emergency beacons. I hadn’t figured that we would need to contact the spacer camp or any authorities.
As I drifted downward, I thought I was going to float in the cool ocean for hours until I finally drowned.
The other Rocket Girls had similar thoughts, except those in the lounge. They really were kicking out the wall with booted feet—although a couple of those feet did not have high heels on. I suspect those were the ones that broke through.
They got out at the right altitude to deploy their chutes, just barely, they said.
We all landed in that choppy water in completely different places. I tucked as I hit, so I went deeper underwater than I had thought. The parachute helped me up and the suit’s buoyancy bobbed me to the surface fast.
Above me, clouds and no other parachutes that I could see. Around me, only ocean.
I have no idea how long I floated there. Long enough to do some math on how long a human body could survive without drinking water. Long enough to figure out how to wrap my parachute to make it a kind of life raft.
Long enough to think that maybe the maxim safety first had a reason for existing.
You know the rest. They found us. They rounded us up as well as the debris of the ship we had designed.
They tried to expel us all from spacer camp, but saw no point since there was only a few days left. We were suspended though. And those fancy-schmantsy schools we all attended—well, they were notified, but they chose to ignore it all.
Except for the mandatory counseling. We were told to tone down our arrogance, and maybe learn how to do things in the proper order.
We were told to conform.
You see how well that worked out.
Because we had extremely rich parents, we didn’t have to pay for anything. We had very few consequences, and yet it was so terrifying, and we all thought we were going to die, and we were all smart enough to know we had made mistakes, that we became determined to do things right.
Which was why we didn’t follow most of the Spacer’s Dictums, and why we learned how to be better than they were and why we figured out how to live life our way, without sticking around for the consequences.
Those of you who are actually reading the transcript (and I’m so sorry. I’m beginning to think watching was a lot better choice), you won’t be able to see that the last bit was followed by an extremely long pause.
Almost none of you will note that Fresh Face here ended up with a sour expression. In fact, she’s said damn near nothing since I finished, probably because I am finished, and I didn’t tell the story she wanted me to tell, right, Fresh Face?
This wasn’t the myth or legend you heard. You heard, what exactly? That we had taken the rocket—an actual penis-shaped bomb-powered rocket—into actual space, and it blew up there, jettisoning us like bits of confetti at a wedding?
We, of course, were so brilliant that we managed to jury-rig the bits of the spaceship into some kind of device that kept us alive—and oh, yeah, we managed to contact the nearby Moon Base, who sent men to save us.
Those men arrived, and we stole their ship.
Is that the one you heard?
Or was it the one where the ship blew up on the launch pad and everyone died, and we weren’t really the original Rocket Girls. They were our friends and siblings, and we stole their identities and built our ship as a tribute and managed to fly it all the way to the Moon, where we were then arrested, but no one cared because we were so ingenious, building the ship and all.
Ah, esteemed viewers—listeners—readers—whatever the hell you are, you’ll note (or not) that our hostess, Fresh Face here, is nodding. That’s the story she heard. She wanted everyone dead on the launch pad, lots of girl heroics, and improbable flight to the Moon and kudos from everyone in charge.
Well, then, Fresh Face, I gift you that story. Sure, yes, it’s true. Because we all need to believe the myths and legends that form us, right? We can’t help what we imprint on, even if it’s not true.
I try not to tell the truth, because really, who wants to hear it? Who wants to hear that spacer camp was actually inspiring and that we all bonded while we were there, and we really did find the Rocket Girls magazines, but we read them and were a bit appalled and thought we could do better.
So we learned, and attended more spacer camps, and then we transferred to some of the best physics and engineering schools in the world for our undergraduate—all together, even though (I will admit) some of us were better at shopping than engineering—and we got our doctorates and did a lot of practical work and most of us even interned on some really rough scows just to learn the spacer craft, which we all ended up hating.
But, because our parents had money—and you’ll see, this is a theme throughout—we were able to buy our first vessel, which, contrary to lies and myths and legends, we took years learning how to fly, and even more years getting commissions, and even more years developing a reputation, and yes, in those days, everyone called us Rocket Girls, because the ship really was Rocket Girl Won, which really did blow up just outside Earth’s solar system, back when we were fighting the Cascade Wars, because like so many in our profession, wars made our names.
Sometimes it was just enough to survive the wars.
But we lost some of our number—Ruby and Lupe and Chantel and Claudia and Sadie and Joanie—in the wars, and we never really could replace them and we didn’t want to, but we didn’t feel like Rocket Girls without them, so we got drunk one night and figured only the bimbos were left, which was one-third true, because most of the women who died—daredevils all—were our engineers. Hell, I wasn’t even one of the engineers, not at first.
We figured we were the dumb subset of the Rocket Girls, so we called ourselves the Space Bimbos and the new ship was going to be called Space Bimbos Lost, but we figured that would be a bad omen, so we called it Space Bimbos instead, and this time, we painted bimbos all over the ship, in thigh-high boots and short shorts and bustiers, because we were older, and all of those women, who looked like Joanie and Sadie and Claudia and Chantel and Lupe and Ruby, were gorgeous, just like we wanted to be, and the art could handle the extremes of space, and people noticed, and they wanted the story, and frankly, Fresh Face, the story is too damn painful to tell, so you get whatever story I feel like telling today.
Yeah, yeah, you don’t like it much, and yeah, you guessed right when you figured out that I don’t really care what you think of my storytelling.
Because some of what I told you is true, and most of it isn’t, and the real story of the Rocket Girls and the Space Bimbos won’t get told in a setting like this.
It’ll be told in late-night campfires at spacer camps all over the system, from girls who got inspired by bits and pieces of the history—or really, her-story—that someone told.
The inspiration is what matters, Fresh Face, not the accuracy.
Accuracy is for the survivors and we won’t be around a hell of a lot longer. When we’re gone there will be no one to correct the record, and then you too can make it up as you go.
Until then, don’t get too wrapped up in your heroes. We all have clay feet.
Some of us just choose to stuff them in thigh-high boots.
Rocket Girls
Copyright© 2023 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
First published in Asimov’s Science Fiction, May/June 2022
Cover and layout copyright © 2023 by WMG Publishing
Cover design by Allyson Longueira
Cover art copyright © studiostoks/Depositphotos
2022: The year that advertising stopped working.
That’s not true, but it feels true. Conversations at the 20Booksto50K conference were all about the broken ad revenues, and the inability to goose algorithms.
BookBub ads don’t seem as effective. Newsletter campaigns aren’t working. And what happened to all the book bloggers? Nothing seemed to get a book traction…except…BookTok, maybe. Social media sites at the beginning of the year. Traditional marketing categories seemed to work…until they didn’t.
I will deal with social media in a separate post. We find ourselves at a crossroads there. As for the rest, I wrote about this a bit, with some suggestions for things to do, back in October. In many ways, that post did not go far enough. But it’s worth taking a look at.
That post really didn’t examine the year, though. And that’s what I’m doing here.
I believe that what we have in advertising is a confluence of many events.
Those events are, in no particular order:
Let’s take a look at all of this and figure out if we’re in a crisis or if we have just arrived at a turning point…or neither.
First, let’s talk about the concrete stuff. Privacy legislation worldwide has changed how the internet works in our corner of the globe.
In democracies or democratic-leaning countries, the concern is data privacy, particularly as it relates to personally identifiable information. (Where a company can figure out that the information came from you.) In other parts of the world, particularly those with repressive or totalitarian governments, the concern is keeping a containment on data, particularly data that might let citizens of those countries have a broader view of what’s happening in the world or in that country.
Such privacy concerns on both sides have led to a lot of privacy legislation in places like India, Indonesia, Canada, and the European Union. Some of those changes had little impact on the large tech companies. Others had a major impact. Here’s an analysis of many of the changes (and upcoming changes).
In the United States, the federal government (read Congress) tried and did not yet succeed in passing a national data privacy act. There was a lot of debate and analysis at the beginning of the year, but with the press of other concerns, that act got set aside. There was a valiant attempt at reviving it after the Supreme Court eviscerated abortion protections and gave the go-ahead to neighbors spying on neighbors (and medical providers and all kinds of other icky things). But, again, there was no time and no real will on the right to make sure that anything was done to protect the privacy of individuals.
With the failure on the national level, states stepped up. In 2023, new privacy laws will go into effect in California, Connecticut, Utah, Colorado, and Virginia. (I have a feeling I’m missing a few.) In the United States, when state regulations involve big players, like California, that means that national and multinational companies play according to California’s rules, so that the companies don’t get slapped with fines or worse, get disallowed from playing within a state’s borders (creating all kinds of headaches).
Add to that a change in the way that third-party cookies work. For years, marketers (including writers) have used third-party cookies to track and target possible consumers. Entire businesses have been based on this.
Early on, consumers were unaware of the impact of third-party cookies, but now, most consumers set their privacy settings to block third-party cookies. Web browsers like Chrome, Firefox, and Safari have all announced (or implemented) plans to do away with third-party cookies.
What does all of this mean for writers trying to act like the big boys and do target marketing or surveillance advertising? It means that any tricks a writer used based on that kind of marketing will get harder and harder, if not impossible, in the next few years.
That kind of marketing has already gotten hard, which is why data-driven writers online and at conferences like 20Books are in a quiet (or not so quiet) panic. The entire basis of their livelihood had completely disappeared. They now have to build slowly, which is hard, particularly when you got the instant gratification that tweaked algorithms could provide.
Writers aren’t the only ones having trouble figuring out advertising. I think every single issue of The Hollywood Reporter this year had an article on the changes in advertising. Some of it was rather gleeful, especially in regards to Netflix adding an advertising tier to its subscriber base—which means that journalists might actually see Netflix’s viewing numbers now—but a lot of it was filled with fear, especially during the summer.
What happened in the summer? Two things. But let’s start with Economic Uncertainty. As I’m sure you all recall, inflation returned with something of a vengeance in 2022, scaring everyone under 50 who had never lived in a world with rapidly rising costs.
To my surprise and the surprise of several economists, consumer spending didn’t drop the way that it had during the last difficult inflationary period forty years ago. Consumer spending dropped, but not as rapidly or as deeply as predicted.
Still, consumers reacted to inflation and the talk of a recession (which, as if this writing, still hasn’t hit yet) by focusing on essentials, although those essentials had changed since the 1970s and 1980s. Now, the essentials weren’t universal. Yes, everyone needed groceries and many people needed gas, but after that, people chose their own essentials.
From gaming platforms to scaling back on streaming services (but not cutting them out completely), consumers continued to purchase the things that mattered to them the most. They simply didn’t try new things.
And one of the main points of advertising is to get people to try something new. Readers, for example, were less likely to try to read books by writers they had never heard of and were, instead, revisiting old favorites or buying books only by people they had already read.
That wasn’t uniform, and that was the problem. None of this was uniform, making it defy easy prediction. Some writers, for example, had no impact on their sales. Others, particularly writers with a strong backlist, experienced growth. Writers who had never worked on building a reader base (just an algorithm base) watched the bottom drop out of their business completely.
Data-driven writers need to find new ways to tweak data or change their business model altogether.
Writers who have a reader base need to focus on discoverability. Just last week, a reader who had read the first book in my Diving series years ago and loved it just realized that I had many more books in the series—so many she was overwhelmed by the idea of buying them all.
Had I failed on discoverability? For her, yes. But we can’t be everywhere. However, we can focus on more than just the latest book. We can find and educate readers, and bring them into the fold in other ways.
It means a different way of marketing and a different way of looking at advertising, which also means a different way of thinking.
And then, starting in the spring, Distraction took over. For the first time in two years, most people emerged from their self-imposed exile from socializing. In fact, people did so with a vengeance.
They traveled, they visited friends and family, they went to concerts, they ate out. They partied and partied some more and spent time socializing, not scouring the internet for the latest deals or paying attention to emails reminding them to buy the latest books.
The distractions haven’t really let up. Unfortunately for folks in the United States, we had the largest travel season on record—right in time for a once-in-a-generation storm that hit over half of the states in the lower 48, if not more. It was so big that it overwhelmed news outlets which were tracking it. I seriously can’t find how many states were impacted by this thing, but I do know that only the Desert Southwest had no watches or alerts in the days leading up to Christmas. That’s a lot of people who experienced something from a deep chill to feet of snow to disrupted travel plans.
What I found most interesting about that storm was how many people stubbornly refused to give up their travel plans, despite warnings. It was clear that things were going to be bad, but people were willing to brave it. They were tired of being trapped at home, even if it meant they were going to be trapped at an airport instead.
These people are not going to care that you had a flash sale on your latest book. They’re not going to read your newsletter. They’re barely on social media at the moment—and if they are, they’re complaining about the travel nightmare.
They’re distracted.
We all are. Try to remember what happened in the news in the past year. What were the big stories? As I researched this article (and as I’ve been researching the year in review), it kept striking me how many things happened in 2022 that felt like they had happened years ago. This year went by quickly, the first year to do that since 2019. That meant that we all missed announcements and news stories and books and personal changes that our friends underwent and…and…and…
We were distracted and it had an impact on the effectiveness of marketing our work.
But there was another thing that had an impact on the effectiveness of advertising.
It has grown stale.
So many of us were doing the same old same old. We had a routine. We’d publish a book, and announce it on various social media sites. We’d announce to our newsletters or maybe invest a few dollars in targeted advertising.
We weren’t thinking about how we marketed our work anymore. It had become rote.
And that actually worked in the pandemic because people were hungry for distract, any distraction. But it doesn’t work anymore, for any of us. In fact, many of the advertising companies are new discussing “experiential” advertising, which is advertising built into an experience.
We just had a large such event here in Las Vegas. The brand new Resorts World casino partnered with Hallmark to create a light show, maze, and an overall experience. Called Enchant, the entire thing took up a large section of real estate on the Strip. We considered going until we realized that the entire thing cost about $40 per person. There are cheaper and just as pretty things to do here in Vegas including the free Bellagio Conservatory and Gardens (which does, by the way, get you into the Bellagio to eat or wander the casino floor or spend money on a variety of things).
I know the cross-marketing brought a lot of people into the casino. Hallmark has a brand that people love, particularly at the holidays. I’m not sure what Hallmark got out of it, except some additional advertising, and that might be enough. These kinds of things are worth watching, though, and might be replicable on a very small scale.
Advertising companies are also touting Digital Out Of Home Marketing (DOOH), which encompasses everything from VR sampling to ads that show up on menu screens at restaurants and other places. VR marketing might be something that writers can do. Again, we’ll have to watch and see how this all works.
In other words, most companies don’t know what the next best thing is, although there is something buried in the numbers.
Apparently, marketing geared at in-person purchases was effective. In fact, in-person holiday sales in the U.S. grew 6.8%. (Digital grew 10.6%, which isn’t as quick as previous years.)
As Steve Sadove, an advisor for MasterCard (who was looking at MasterCard date), told Time:
…consumers diversified their holiday spending to accommodate rising prices and an appetite for experiences and festive gatherings post-pandemic.
Experience and festive gatherings. We don’t have a captive audience anymore. Nor do we have an audience that is looking at ebooks or reading online as the newest thing (which was happening up until 2015 or so).
Book advertising methods are still based on the pandemic and 2009-2015 experiences, which doesn’t work at all.
In fact, staleness in marketing is the best way to make sure no one hears the message. Yeah, yeah, you always say that is the subconscious thought. Then your product gets dismissed and the consumer moves on.
I don’t know what the next advertising trend is in book publishing. No one does. Just like no one expected social media to change as dramatically as it has. I’ll be looking at that in the following post.
Remember, though, social media isn’t the only way to advertise (although for many, it became the only way). Writers need to get creative in reaching readers.
That’ll be a subtheme in the next few posts, but I won’t do anything solid on discoverability for a month or two, as I gather my own thoughts.
This is a challenging time. We knew that life would be different coming out of the pandemic, but I don’t think we—or I, anyway—expected everything to be different. Maybe because that change would be too vast to comprehend. We’re experiencing it now, and it is too vast. But we’ll get through it, and then be surprised at the way that things had changed.
How we advertise our books is just one thing that’s changing. There are so many more.
So back to my initial question up front: Are we in a crisis or is this just a turning point? I’d say turning point. Because advertising will do what it has always done. It will work for some, particularly the innovative, and it won’t work for most.
That is always the way.
What are the innovations? That remains to be seen. I couldn’t ferret out any trends yet, but that doesn’t mean they aren’t happening. It just takes a while for trends to become clear.
We’ll see what 2023 brings for advertising. Right now, I’m not making any predictions.
Because of my voluntary abandonment of my Twitter account, I have lost one of my best promotion tools. Which means I’m going to have to step up my game here.
I’m going to at least one workshop per blog post that will augment some of the things in the post. If there’s a relevant non-fiction book that I wrote, then I’ll mention that too.
For today, I have two classes. They’re about two of the best forms of advertising no matter what else is happening in the culture. The first class will help with your book covers. The second will help you write good sales copy.
If you want to understand the theories of getting your work in front of readers, then pick up my book Discoverability. Some of the techniques are dated (I tried not to use things that would date, but it was inevitable), but the theories remain relevant.
And as always, a reminder: This weekly blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynrusch to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: Advertising: Year in Review Part 6,” copyright © 2022 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © Can Stock Photo / studiostoks
Rachel knows the law better than most judges, and the clients she defends pay her accordingly. Especially boneheaded clients, whom she charges a stupidity fee.
But as New Year’s Eve approaches, someone from her past needs her help. A sexy someone. Someone she doesn’t want to represent.
Someone who might just cause more trouble that Rachel imagines.
“Other People’s Stupidity,” by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook through various online retailers here. “Other People’s Stupidity” was first published as part of the WMG Holiday Spectacular 2019. To learn more about this year’s project, click here.
Other People’s StupidityKristine Kathryn RuschHere’s what they don’t let you say to new clients at most law firms. They don’t let you say, Really? You realize what you did was stupid, right? Criminally stupid. Fatally stupid. Horribly stupid. And now you expect me to clean up after you? Had you given any thought to what you did? Of course not. Now I have to think about it. Lucky, lucky me.
That’s why I don’t work at most law firms. I used to, and my tongue still has bite marks from all the times I wanted to lash out at the clients. (Note I didn’t say the stupid clients, because almost everyone we dealt with was stupid, and I dislike being redundant.)
I worked hard, saved my money, realized I didn’t know a hell of a lot about anything but the law. I tried retirement—didn’t like it. Nothing to do. No one to badger. Couldn’t imagine spending my life doing good works.
Looked at other professions, realized most of them were based around other people’s stupidity as well, only in those professions the stupidity was usually worse and gross.
I only confront people’s stupidity as their lawyer. The law’s what I know, after all. And because I’m my own man—well, woman, actually, but idiomatic English is sexist—my billing practices have changed. I bill by the hour, sure, but at a rate so low that it looks like I’m the cheapest experienced lawyer in the state.
I’m not. Because I add what I first called a stupidity tax (which the state—and the state bar—objected to. Apparently, the state believes it’s the only entity that can even use the word tax. I did not remind the paper-pushing government employee who got his knickers in a twist that there’s something called the Federal Government, and they too like the word tax. And I was using it more colloquially—but I digress).
The stupidity tax became the stupidity surcharge, but surcharge is too big a word for most of the idiots who come to my office. So now, my rates include the stupidity fee, which runs on a three-part sliding scale.
Part The First: The Standard Scale.
If you drive drunk and get arrested, or if you (say) mouth off to a cop who is trying to arrest you, or do any one of a million things that stupid idiot humans have done since time immemorial, things that are both predictable and banal and will take very little think-time by me or the current associate, then your fee runs up and down this scale based on the amount of time we’ll waste because you did something with easily foreseen consequences.
Part The Second: The What Were You Thinking, Dude Scale
This one’s for the dweebles who like to pile up their idiocies into one big clusterfuck. So, you drove drunk, got pulled over, mouthed off to the cop, punched the cop when he tried to arrest you, threatened his dog, his mother, his wife, told the judge at your arraignment to go fuck himself, and grabbed your crotch as you left the courtroom, making a lewd gesture with your junk while staring at some pretty young associate from a high-toned law firm, who then got offended and reported your behavior (or squealed) to the already-offended judge.
Yeah, you. Believe it or not, one of my recent clients will recognize himself in this little description. You’ll get taxed—I mean, fee-ed—at three times the rate the banal client will. Because, Idiot, it’ll take me the better part of a year to untangle your clusterfuck. If I can untangle your clusterfuck. What makes me want to untangle your clusterfuck is a shit-ton of cash—that you can afford to pay. If you’re an indigent client, then lucky you, you get to go to the public defender’s office, because I don’t handle poor and stupid.
See above.
Part The Third: The Creativity Scale
Believe it or not, this scale can work in reverse. The more creative you are, the less I’m likely to charge you. Maybe. If I like you. If you give me an intellectual challenge. If you’re the right kind of asshole.
Yeah, your case might take up all of my think-time for the next year or two, but buddy, if you can pull that off, then hey, more power to you. I don’t really need the funds. I like a challenge—and I hope whoever is reading this doesn’t think of that fact as a challenge, because I’m not encouraging anyone to sin.
Those of you who have sinned, you now know that I favor the creative over the banal. Consider yourself warned.
The other thing this fee does is give me the non-exclusive right to call you on your bullshit. If I think you’re too smart to have done something that stupid, well then, guess what? I’m going to tell you. And if you’re clearly too stupid to have come up with something that smart except through the grace of luck and fate and whatever other crap rose to the surface that day, well then, guess what? I’m going to tell you.
Because telling people to their face that they are the biggest idiots on the planet is one of the perks of the job, my friend.
And I am all into perks.
*Here’s something else you need to know about me. I’m little, cute, and not young. A friend once called me pocket-sized. Granted, she’s six-six, but I’m barely five-two. I’m also dark-haired, Korean American (adopted outta Korea in the 1960s by good white Midwestern stock), with a wicked Yooper accent. (Raised on the U.P., back in the day, yes I was, you betcha, honeybunch, doncha know.) I can out-Fargo the fake Fargo types because they don’t understand that there are variations in accents in the Upper Midwest, and I got blessed with the deepest dumbest accent of all.
Which I use to my advantage all the damn time, doncha know.
(And yes, law school trained the accent out of me. Hell, television trained the accent out of me when I learned that most of America think anyone who talks in dees and does is a dumb fuck. So I go back and forth, using the Yooper accent to my advantage, sounding like the most educated person in the room when I need to impress someone with my scintillating wit and intellect—or just to convince them that, yes, even though I look like I just got off the boat, I actually do speaka de English, usually better than they do.)
Imagine this: My looks, which makes everyone (including other Korean Americans) treat me like an Other. Which I am not.
(What I know about Korea is the same as any basic white kid with a mediocre Midwestern public school education: there was a war long ago and far away, and it’s not quite over, and there are still Americans stationed in South Korea, and the North is nuts, and I really don’t give a good goddamn. Because, here’s the thing: no one there wanted me. They put me in an orphanage for fuck’s sake, and my parents brought me to the Midwest because they wanted me, and while I don’t look like the average Midwesterner of the white persuasion, I am one, for all intents and upbringing—except when I want to use my heritage (and my femaleness) to my advantage. Which I do, because I’m not above using anything to solve a case or aggravate opposing council. Doncha know.)
The second thing you need to know about me is that my office is impressive as hell. I’m not telling you which city my office is in. I’m not even going to tell you which state I’m in, because to do so would reveal a whole bunch of things I’m not going to reveal. And if you think you can figure it all out from my (formerly) Yooper accent and my Midwestern parents, you would be thinking wrong.
I still take some parts of client confidentiality seriously. So factor in that the names have been changed to protect the guilty, the innocent, and the rest of us. Although, I suppose, if you’re determined enough, you’ll figure out who or what happened here. If I don’t delete this document after I finish it. Which I just might do.
Doncha know.
My office is in one of those horseshit neighborhoods that scared the piss out of everyone in the late 1990s when I bought the building for a song. I’m singing a goddamn aria now, because that building in that neighborhood is worth a hundred times what I paid for it.
Downtown revitalization, baby. Amazing what a city can do when it begs businesses to come and invest. Amazing what a city can do for a lawyer who bought at fire-sale prices, hoping to get a raft of idiots for her stupidity business, and ended up in one of the primo real estate markets in a growing city.
Sometimes, as I say to the idiots I call clients, you just get lucky.
I got lucky.
The building is one of those Queen Annes rezoned commercial. I put a one-bedroom apartment in the tower, and use it myself most of the time, even though I have a swanky home in one of the gated communities on the edge of the city. I can walk the three blocks to municipal buildings and often do, except when the wind chill can kill me, which is too damn often, in my opinion.
My office-office covers the entire second floor and has a view of the neighborhood that’s stunning. The inner sanctum, where my desk and nap couch live, has reclaimed wood floors, dark wood trim, and heavy Victorian furniture redesigned for pocket-sized people.
Always surprises my clients when they go for the small chairs first—because the redesign makes those small chairs look like they’re normal-sized—and then those same clients discover that their fat American asses don’t fit.
I tend to hire pocket-sized legal secretaries because they amuse me (and they can easily use the furniture), and super-sized receptionists because they sometimes have to boot clients/idiots/assholes out of the building.
I have two associates—one who has been with me from the beginning and the other the current resident of the revolving door because only a handful of very special people can tolerate my mouth each and every week.
They have offices on the first floor, behind reception. I also have a legal researcher, whom I keep in the basement, although not chained there, as the rumors have it. He remains down there to avoid me. He can handle the changing computer tech and he loves the smell of dusty old books. If he ever dies, I’m screwed.
Of course, this tale I’m going to tell you of stupidity and mouthery and possible screwery doesn’t happen at any of those locations. Naw, this whole thing started one afternoon in the lovely Hall of Justice which, I gotta say, isn’t the ugliest building in the entire city—not even in the top one hundred—but it has to be one of the most dispiriting.
It’s got one of those reactive late 1960s early 1970s designs guaranteed to counteract all of the bombings that were going on around the country at the time. Tiny windows, or no windows, lots of concrete, and absolutely no reason to be there.
The neighborhood is revitalizing, but it still has that mid-twentieth century stench of decay—the narrow main streets, the weird traffic patterns, the old winter-weathered buildings that have seen better days.
There’s a primary parking area, but small-firm lawyers like me can’t use them, so I use the cheerfully named People Mover (which is really just a light rail line) when the weather prevents me from walking.
Yeah, you’re getting the sense that I hike everywhere. That would be correct. Walking everywhere keeps me thin, and it keeps me from punching people. Sometimes I think I walk so I can punch people. I want someone to mug me, so I can show off those defensive moves I’ve learned in my various karate classes—the ones I took in my ill-advised retirement.
That day, I’d showed up at the Hall of Justice, which shall henceforth (in this narrative at least) be called the goddamn criminal courthouse or rather, the courthouse with both the “goddamn” and “criminal” implied.
The entire place always smelled of chalk and flop sweat, not to mention the stale odor of cigarettes that somehow got embedded into the concrete before the state changed the smoking regulations about thirty years too late.
I use wheeled carry-on luggage instead of pouches or oversized purses or anything else that hangs off the human body. Primarily I do so for convenience, but also—hello! Pocket-sized—because all of that stuff hangs weird on me and fucks up my back.
I was bundled up like a toddler on a ski vacation—puffy coat that fell to my knees (designed for most people’s thighs, but I digress), knee-high boots just a tad too big (made for my jeans, but I wasn’t wearing any that day), puffy hood that could be compressed to a single circle—rather like a the lens on a periscope—and mittens that I actually attach to the little built-in hooks on my coat’s sleeves because I’ve lost too many mittens and it annoys me something fierce.
I was struggling out of the coat. I had stashed the mittens under my pits while I untied the hood, and fought with the coat’s zipper. After I got through security, I would head to the lady’s room where I would stash the boots and puffy coat in my second carry-on, put on my sensible flat shoes, comb my hair and reapply lipstick. Yes, I wear lipstick. It’s medicated. Otherwise, my lips would get chapped.
It was December 28, a freakin’ Monday, in one of those horrible holiday years where Christmas was on a Friday, which meant New Year’s was on a Friday, which meant that the courts would be open from Monday to Thursday (not even a damn half-day on New Year’s Eve) because everyone wanted to close out their docket before year’s end.
I was on my way to defend that day’s prize idiot—a soon-to-be former drunk (thanks to his upcoming incarceration) who decided that a knife fight was a better way to settle a disagreement with a bouncer than simply leaving the bar was.
I had all kinds of felony charges to bat down, and I was confident I could do so with the proper plea. I wasn’t even in a bad mood about it because this yahoo came from an old wealthy family and was maxing out the charges on the What Were You Thinking, Dude fee scale.
I was going to get paid a hefty chunk for my time that day, and I was pleased about it. The nice thing about being single and unattached—no family (lovely white Midwestern parents long gone), no kids, no spouse of any gender—is that I don’t have to do the obligatory family holiday crap. I make a ton of money at the end of every year because I’m one of the few attorneys available to work.
Of course, as I gathered up my puffy coat and checked for the mittens, then grabbed my purse as it came out of the x-ray machine, I was thinking about money. I didn’t even care that the doughy security guard I didn’t like was pawing through my files again. I usually kept an eye on that asshole, because I was beginning to think he had a camera attached to his buttonhole, or something equally nefarious.
Behind me, lawyers running late, clients looking confused, and potential jurors at the wrong door. Ahead of me, people who had already made it through this airline-like madness scurried past, heading (probably belatedly) to their courts or appointments or their phony-baloney jobs.
“Rachel?” The voice, deep and warm like good whiskey, caught me, and made me shiver.
Yeah, I’m Rachel. Yeah, the parents blessed me with that name, although, to their credit, they weren’t psychic and didn’t know Friends would hit about twenty years later. Of course, people told me, You don’t look like a Rachel long before Rachel equaled pretty and (much bigger than me) Jennifer Aniston.
“Rach?” The voice was familiar, and male, and belonged to the one guy I never wanted to see again. All straight women have that one guy, y’know, the one who made you do bad things in the middle of the night, and think about them in the middle of the day.
The one who knew he was that guy, and used it to his advantage, each and every time.
Shit. I thought he had left the city. I thought he had left the state. I hoped he had left the country, and at that moment, I was kinda hoping he would leave the planet.
“Rach, you can’t ignore me.”
I was keeping my head down, but he was right: I couldn’t ignore him. Not just because he had planted himself to the right of the security line, and I was heading in that direction. But also because, Christ, who wanted to ignore such a beautiful man?
I grabbed my file luggage from the doughy security guard, closed the latches, and hoped like hell the doughy security guard hadn’t messed with anything because I hadn’t been paying attention. The puffy coat dangled off my arm, a sleeve brushing against the floor. My purse slipped off my shoulder and whacked me on the hip, and in that moment, I felt friggin’ seventeen again, the prodigy in freshman year in college who always got the question, Honey, are you sure you should be here? Are your parents nearby?
I shoved the puffy coat under my arm, wrestled the purse back onto my shoulder, elongated the handles on my rolling luggage, and shoved my way past the legal assistant blocking the end of the line. My great mood had vanished, my plans for an easy day had been ruined, and it wasn’t even nine a.m. yet.
He was leaning against the dirty white wall now, looking stunning as always. Devon Colfax Schneider, Cole to his friends, Colfax to everyone else, and Leave me the fuck alone, asshole to me.
Only I didn’t say it. Instead, I got lost in the broad shoulders, the perfectly faded jeans that showed off the muscles in his thighs, the area above his thighs—and I forced myself to look away, half expecting him to use the female line, Hey, my eyes are up here.
Instead, when my gaze met his, his was extremely amused. His eyes were blue. Vibrant, sky-on-a-spring-afternoon blue. The kind of blue that you could get lost in if you weren’t careful, and I hadn’t been careful way too much in my life.
He looked a little older—a few more lines around those eyes, a bit of silver in the stubble gracing his firm jaw—but that only made him sexier. He needed a haircut too, his blond hair just touching the edge of his fur-lined brown leather jacket, but that made him even sexier.
“What do you want?” I asked because Leave me the fuck alone, asshole would’ve been rude, even for me.
Strike that. Leave me the fuck alone, asshole wouldn’t have told me what I needed to know, which was why the hell was he standing here looking like he had just won the lottery?
“I know you’re heading to court,” he said, which meant he’d looked me up, which meant he had been waiting for me and not someone else, which meant he didn’t want to have this discussion in my office, which meant this was probably business, and not the good kind.
“Then you know I have no time at all.” The nice thing about being pocket-sized was that you didn’t have to touch anyone when you went by them. You could squeeze through the tightest situation, which I did.
It wasn’t my fault that the luggage wheels rolled over his snazzy handmade cowboy boots.
He didn’t complain, even though I would have, and pushed off the wall, like we did this every single day.
We hadn’t done this every single day for at least fifteen years, but Jesus, it still felt natural.
“That’s why I want to have lunch with you,” he said.
“No time for lunch,” I lied.
“You always make time for lunch,” he said.
He was right: I did.
“I don’t have time for lunch with another person,” I said. If he wanted me to drill down in my objections, I would. I would add that I didn’t have time to have lunch with him.
But unlike my clients, Cole was one smart son of a bitch. He already knew what I hadn’t said.
“I’m buying,” he said.
“I’m impressed,” I said. “Must be someone else’s money.”
I trundled forward. I was on the clock. I had only fifteen minutes to change, stash my coat, and apply that lipstick. I didn’t have time to screw around with Cole. In any sense of the word.
“Lunch, Rach, please.”
“Nope,” I said firmly. I was proud of the firmly. Because if anyone could make me sound unsure of myself, it was Cole.
“Rach—”
I stopped in front of the ladies room door. Not quite directly in front, because too many women were going in and out before their court appearances, but close enough that he got the hint.
“You need something from me, you come to my office,” I said.
“The last time I came to your office, I didn’t leave the tower apartment for two days,” he said.
I remembered those two days. Maybe every minute of them. And every inch of him. Younger him, I reminded myself. Without the laugh lines. And before I told him to go to hell—and he did.
“You should be so lucky,” I said. “My office or nothing.”
And then I escaped into the ladies room to make myself presentable—for court, not for Cole.
I was never going to make myself presentable for Cole again.
***He wasn’t there when I got out of the bathroom—coat stuffed, black power suit straightened, bright red lipstick and just a touch of mascara. All of that plus my perfect wedge haircut made me look like a tiny badass, because I had just reached that stage in my body’s development where I actually looked like an adult. That was the nice thing about my unknown family back in Korea—they had given me great genes. I used to resent how young I looked, and now I used it. Even though that young look I had now made me look fortyish, not fiftyish.
Part of me was disappointed that Cole hadn’t waited—the girly part, the part who still occasionally mourned the fact that those never-leave-the-apartment days would probably mark the highlight of my sexual life. No other man had ever measured up, and no other man probably would, and I had stopped trying to find a non-battery operated substitute five years earlier. My fiftieth birthday present to myself was—well, never mind.
Cole’s surprise appearance distracted me all the way through the prize idiot’s hearing where I had actually planned on kicking ass and taking no prisoners. I still kicked ass and took no prisoners, but I didn’t revel in it the way I usually did. My enjoyment factor was down about fifty percent.
Still, I got the prize idiot to plead to lesser charges and the judge to agree that one year at the state’s most expensive rehab center would be the same for the prize idiot as jail time.
I felt passingly victorious as I left the courtroom, just not ebullient, as I had planned. I was thinking of lunch at one of the spendiest old boys clubs in town, because I had had a banner year, and the prize idiot’s father had promised me a bonus that would make the year a double-banner year if I got the prize idiot into rehab, which I had just done.
A nice stiff drink and a steak for lunch, then back to the salt mines, because I had three more cases to wrap before the new year, and if I presented my arguments as tersely (and as brilliantly) as I planned, I would triumph in all three of them.
Best laid plans. Cole was waiting outside the courtroom.
“You’ve gotten better,” he said. “I didn’t think that was possible.”
I cursed silently. He had been in the courtroom, and I hadn’t seen him. Of course, I hadn’t turned around, but back in the day, I would have felt his presence like a live thing, his gaze following me around the room.
Guess I was out of practice, or maybe we weren’t on the same wavelength anymore.
And then I remembered:
We never had been.
“Save the flattery for someone younger and dumber,” I said. And, I almost added, someone you haven’t betrayed.
I pushed past him and headed down the corridor with the flow of lawyers, witnesses, family members, and court groupies trying to get to the exit and the best restaurants in the area before they filled for lunch.
He kept up. “Mussio’s?” he asked. “A bourbon and steak with the Old Boys Network, to show them that you have bigger cojones than they do?”
I hated being nagged, and I really hated being played. Now, it was becoming apparent that I was also predictable, and had been for at least a decade.
He had just officially spoiled my lunch.
I stopped. The stream of lawyers, witnesses, family members, and court groupies flowed around me, and around Cole who stood in my wake.
“What the hell do you want?” I snapped, and silently cursed myself. What he had wanted was easy to figure out. He had wanted me to ask that question. Because now that I’d asked it twice, I was officially hooked, and he knew it.
“I want to hire you, babe,” he said.
I hated the babe, and he knew that too. He also knew that lawyers couldn’t be hired the way that private detectives were. He knew that because he was a private detective who also happened to have a law degree, a fact he only brought out when he was trying to impress or when he was feeling just a tad stupider than everyone else in the room.
“I’m not for sale,” I said, and stomped back into the stream. I hoped he would remain rooted, like a rock in a river, but of course he didn’t. Because when I got to the elevator, he was right beside me.
“You’re not even going to ask what kind of case it is?” he asked, sounding just a little surprised.
I stubbornly stared at the old arrow above the closed elevator doors, pointing at the floors the elevator passed, like something out of a 1940s movie. I have no idea why they decided to use arrows on the elevators in a building like this, but I approved. I used to love that old arrow. Right now, it was annoying me, just like the man standing close enough that I could feel his body heat.
“The silent treatment doesn’t work, Rach,” he said. “I thought you would have remembered that. I can talk until it annoys you.”
It already annoyed me, but I wasn’t having this conversation with him on the elevator.
I sighed. I knew this mood of his. It was part of a dance we’d been doing ever since we met, and I had no idea how, exactly, to get out of it. I’d never been able to figure that part out.
The elevator doors opened. Three people stood inside. Two I didn’t recognize, but I knew the woman toward the back. Angelina Thackery. She clerked for Judge Segerson. She and I had one of those business friendships, which included the occasional table-sharing in the cafeteria downstairs, along with promises to have coffee “someday.”
I muscled my way onto the elevator, and Cole followed, stepping cautiously around my luggage. Angelina raised her eyebrows at me, as if asking what the hell I was doing.
“You want to hire me?” I said to Cole as the doors closed. “You come to my office and tell me about the case. Otherwise, we’re done here.”
Cole’s cheeks pinked. Apparently, he recognized Angelina too. And he also knew I had just made this official, which—I was guessing—was something he didn’t really want to do.
“Fine,” he said as the elevator door opened two floors down for one of the people in the back. He leaned against the door as the person left. “What time?”
I pulled out my phone and checked the calendar only for form’s sake. I knew that I had no appointments this afternoon. I had planned on a long lunch and lots of paperwork in prep for the last two hearings of the week.
“Three-thirty,” I said. “Don’t be late.”
“I’m never late,” he said, and stepped out of the elevator. The doors closed, and the elevator lurched down.
I felt a bit of surprise. I had expected him to get back on after he realized he had gotten off on the wrong floor.
But I had figured wrong. Apparently I had angered him as much as he angered me.
I had won that battle, maybe the first of those little tiffs that I had actually won. I should have felt better about it.
But I didn’t.
***The steak had been sublime, the bourbon perfect. I’d eaten garlic mashed potatoes instead of my favorite au gratin, because I wanted to keep Cole as far away from me as possible.
Even though he hadn’t shown up at Mussio’s, he still ruined the lunch because I thought about him (witness the garlic-mashed), and I kept looking for him out of the corner of my eye like a high school girl looked for her crush in the school cafeteria.
I didn’t go for the chocolate mousse like I normally would have either. I left as soon as I finished the steak and the cheese-covered broccoli. Even the garlic-mashed was a disappointment.
My office in the middle of the afternoon was a sanctum sanctorum. One of the reasons I bought the house was the afternoon light, filtering in through the original stained glass in the inner sanctum. The red and blue and gold light changed as the sun moved—if there was sun, which by three o’clock on a December afternoon, there was not.
But there was a fireplace. It had been converted to gas when I remodeled the place, but it still gave off a lovely glow and even nicer heat. The inner sanctum was usually calming, but on this afternoon, it wasn’t. I was beginning to doubt anything could be.
I was alone with all of the research that my researcher had pulled for me. He had marked the pertinent parts with color-coded sticky notes—and yes, that meant we were working on paper. Because when it came to research, I understood it clearly when I read it on paper. Yes, I’m that old. Deal.
One of my assistants had brought Starbucks for everyone, so I had a double-double something or other with more caffeine than any liquid should have sitting by my left elbow. I was trying not to watch the clock and failing miserably.
Cole showed up at 3:20—ten minutes early, which was not the old Cole at all. I sat at my desk, elbows on the research, and debated whether or not to let him stew for ten minutes.
That meant I would have to stew as well, and I was already on edge. Still, I took my time getting to him. I washed up in the inner sanctum’s bathroom, made sure my hair was slicked back just enough, and decided against lipstick, because Cole would notice and think it was just for him (which, of course, it would have been).
I had Adi (aka The Best Legal Secretary on the Planet) show him into the outer sanctum—after she made sure the fireplace there was on, the lights were just high enough to show off all the art, and there was no revealing material on the desk.
I grabbed the cup of double-double something and carried it into the outer sanctum with me, along with a legal pad that already had Cole’s name written in blue on the front page.
He was sitting on the edge of the only straight-backed chair in the room, hands folded in front of him, hair half-obscuring his face. He seemed pensive, or maybe even a bit frightened, although I’d never seen anything frighten Cole before. When he heard me, he looked up and smiled—that wide grin that made everyone, and I do mean everyone, smile back.
Only this time, the smile didn’t reach his baby blues. They still seemed as pensive as his entire body had a moment ago.
He stood, nearly toppling the chair over. He caught it, steadied it, and gave it a vile look, as if the chair had caused all of his problems. I expected him to launch into a funny and somewhat vicious tirade about the furniture, but he didn’t.
Instead, he grabbed the wallet out of the back pocket of his too-tight jeans. He opened the wallet as I set my double-double something on the coaster in the center of the desk, placing the legal pad beside it, and taking a blue pen from the pen holder.
From the wallet, he removed ten bills, smoothed them between his fingertips, and then set the bills on the desk, keeping his palm over them.
I could see the denomination through his fingers. Ten one hundred dollar bills.
“I’m hoping this will cover the stupidity tax,” he said.
“It’s not a tax,” I muttered, mostly as reflex.
“Fee, then,” he said.
“Fee,” I agreed as I sank into my chair. The leather seat was surprisingly cool, given the temperature in the room. Or maybe the heat I was feeling had nothing to do with temperature at all.
He pushed the bills toward me. “And,” he said, “I hope you’ll consider this a creativity tax, not something on the standard scale.”
“Fee,” I muttered again, unable to take my gaze off those bills. Creativity fee. He had done something stupid, and he needed me.
Usually I loved a challenge, but Cole was challenging in and of himself. He didn’t need to arrive with a ready-made nightmare from which I had to rescue him.
“What did you do?” I asked, keeping my voice flat.
“You got any real chairs?” he asked. “Because this is going to take a while.”
“The best I can do is a folding chair,” I said, like I said to all of my clients who weren’t pocket-sized. Let them stew in a chair that was deeply uncomfortable, since the entire rest of the world was made for them.
Cole let out a breath of air, then grabbed the straight-backed chair, turned it around, and straddled it. He rested his arms on the back of the chair, and rested his chin on his wrists. The posture put those delicious baby blues directly across from my wary browns.
I looked pointedly at the money. “Just so we’re clear,” I said before he had a chance to say anything else. “This is your consultation hour. I will consider what you tell me in this hour privileged, but I have not decided to take your case, and I may not decide to take your case.”
I probably won’t take your case, I wanted to add, but didn’t. I don’t ever want a case from you, and I certainly don’t need one that contains a thousand dollar stupidity fee.
“I know.” He actually sounded humble.
“I want the nut of the case in three sentences or less,” I said. That was self-defense. Cole could convince me that anything was reasonable, and often had in the past. I didn’t want the charming version. I wanted the impossible-to-sugarcoat version.
His baby blues met my wary browns.
“I rigged an election,” he said.
Whatever I had expected him to say, it hadn’t been that. I knew—well, maybe I guessed—that Cole had done things that weren’t on the up-and-up. That was one reason he didn’t advertise the law degree too much. Fortunately (for him) the state in which he got his degree didn’t make law school graduates automatic members of the bar. He wasn’t really a lawyer. He was just trained like one.
Which was why I wouldn’t have expected him to do something like rig an election. It had repercussions up and down the entire ethics spectrum. On some level, though, I found it amusing that I would think he could beat a client to a bloody pulp or maybe even strong arm impoverished losers into paying their gambling debts, but I would consider him above rigging an election.
“Successfully, I assume,” I said.
He nodded once. Barely a move of the head.
“What do you want me to do about it?” I asked, and wished I hadn’t. Rigging elections, man. That was a whole different level of difficult. Judges were elected in this state, which meant that they were super sensitive about any suggestions of impropriety. They didn’t even like to handle election law cases, because that might make them seem less impartial.
“I need you to stand beside me,” Cole said.
Yeah, I almost said, that’s what lawyers do. They stand beside their clients. But I didn’t. Because he knew that, and he clearly wasn’t talking about that. He meant something else entirely.
“Okay,” I said. “The Reader’s Digest Condensed Version isn’t working. Tell me the whole thing.”
A slight frown appeared between those baby blues. He must have heard something in my tone. Complete judgmental disapproval, maybe? Because that was what I was feeling.
So I leaned forward and tapped the ten hundreds on my desk.
“After you add to the kitty,” I said.
“How much?” he asked.
I wanted to say, Every damn dime you own. I wanted to say, There isn’t enough money in the world that would make me listen to this shit. I wanted to say, Get the hell out of my office.
But I didn’t say any of it. Instead, I said, “Another bill will do.”
“I thought you charge less for creativity,” he said.
“I’m not charging yet,” I said. “This is a listening fee.”
“You mean there will be more?” he asked.
“If I take you on,” I said. “And the Reader’s Digest Condensed Version puts that in doubt. Serious doubt.”
“You’re not going to take my case,” he said.
“I don’t even know what your case is yet,” I said. “But know this: what I know about election law can fill a thimble.”
“Yeah,” he said, looking down. “I used to say the same thing.”
“What the fuck did you do, Cole?” That was the third time. The asshole knew how to bait a hook.
Only I didn’t see any triumph in his eyes.
“It’s not what I did,” he said quietly. “It’s what I’m going to do.”
“And what’s that?” I asked.
“I’m going to turn myself in,” he said.
***I’m not going to give you the torturous blow-by-blow, because it went on for a while and included a lot of “you’ve got to be shitting me’s” and “you actually chose to do that?’s”. There was a lot of discussion about cash and payoffs and bribes and some serious smoke-filled room crap, and some actual depravity that shocked even me.
Through most of it, Cole looked down, like a kid being shamed in the front of a principal.
I got the sense—although he didn’t say—that he had done this before. Maybe many times before.
I’m not some green kid myself. I’ve been in this state long enough—hell, I’ve been in this country long enough—to know that cheating on elections is American as apple pie. Some of that cheating is legal, and some of it isn’t, and most of it upsets the losing party a whole hell of a lot, not to mention the handful of the electorate that actually gets out and votes, and other than that, most people are as cynical about it as me.
Except that deep down, I’m not cynical at all.
Those already-committed funds I mentioned? The ones I didn’t divert to pay for my real estate ventures? Many of those funds go to charities for homeless veterans or abused spouses. I support a lot of women’s causes, quietly, because I don’t want to seem partisan, but it eases my conscience, particularly on the days when my brilliance enables some douchebag to go free on a technicality.
I just didn’t expect Cole to be one of those douchebags. I knew he bent rules. I knew he could be tough. I just didn’t think he could do systemic harm.
Which he had.
And for that reason, I didn’t want to stand beside him in court. That, and a whole bunch of other reasons as well. Particularly since we were once the golden couple—well, not golden, per se, since “gold” isn’t a word people associate with me, and even then everyone knew he was a bit tarnished. Not that I have much of a leg to stand on, since I’m a defense attorney, and no one thinks highly of us, not even when they need us.
But the point is, people still ask me about him, pointedly ask me about him, as if I should keep track of my ex, my particularly gorgeous ex, who was now asking me to represent him on some case having to do with election fraud.
Successful election fraud.
Finally, I couldn’t take any more of the confessional. So I interrupted him.
“What’s coming?” I asked.
He lifted his head. His baby blues focused, maybe for the first time in an hour. “Huh?”
“You’re here, not because of what you’ve done, but because of what’s coming,” I said. “So what’s coming?”
He let out a small sigh, then wiped his right hand over his face. His shit, I don’t want to get into this tell. Which was ironic, since he was the one who taught me about tells in the first place. I never told him he had that one, and I’m not even sure he knew he did.
“A new year,” he said quietly.
I rolled my eyes. He was being deliberately vague.
“I told you,” I said. “I’m not up on election law. You have to talk to me as if I’m a five-year-old.”
“I do that, and you’ll chew my head off,” he said.
Sometimes being exes was a real disadvantage.
“You don’t do that, and I’ll chew your head off,” I said, in the same tone I used before.
“State law,” he said. “The Secretary of State has until the end of the year to question the results of an election. After that, charges can still be brought, but the winner of the election remains in office.”
I peered at him. In all of that discussion, all of those details about absentee ballots this, and paying voters to do that, he never once said which election he manipulated.
But this rule, which I was vaguely familiar with after all, meant the election happened in the fall, which meant that we were most likely dealing with one of the midterm results, not a primary result because those had (if I remembered right) a ninety-day ticking clock, due to the fact that the winner of the primary had to run in the general.
I picked up my double-double something, leaned back in my comfy office chair, and sipped. The rich caffeinated crap tasted damn near the same cold as it had hot.
I was running through all the races in my head, at least the ones I knew about or cared about. The state went Democratic despite some nasty Republican gerrymandering in the last few cycles, and damn near everyone elected was female. There were some gimmes, though, for the Republicans, but there always were for the party in power.
I squinted, and blinked at him. He was watching me with that level gaze, one that made me remember that as well as I thought I knew him, I never really had known him well at all.
“You want to get me to help you overturn an election result,” I said. At least my voice didn’t shake.
“Well,” he said, “it’s not a legitimate result.”
“Says you.”
“Says the evidence,” he said.
“Which I don’t really have time to review,” I said.
I stood up before I even realized I was going to. Damn, I hated being manipulated by anyone, but I particularly hated being manipulated by Cole. He’d done it one too many times already.
“Get out of my office,” I said.
He didn’t move.
“Get out, or I’ll throw you out.”
“You’ll have one of your tiny minions toss me out?” he asked, trying to sound amused, and failing.
“Cole—”
“Rach,” he said, his expression as flat as it had been before. “I come clean on this, I destroy my life and my career. I’ll go to jail. You think I’d do that to overthrow the results of an election.”
“If I understand you, Cole, you have been doing that already. So yeah, I think you’d risk it all to overthrow the results of an election.”
He shook his head. I couldn’t tell if the movement was condescending or not, and I actually cared, which pissed me off.
“Yeah, Rach, I was risking things before. I was convinced I wouldn’t get caught, and I didn’t. So the risk was pretty minor.”
I waited, staring at those baby blues. The lines around them had gotten deeper. He looked older than I expected, used up, tired.
“If I do this,” he said. “If I speak out about this publicly, then the losses become real. I’ll never be able to do my job again, Rach. I’ll go to jail, no matter how much information I give to the courts. No matter how good you are.”
Part of me bristled at that. I’m damn good, and he knew it, and he knew that if anyone could keep him out of jail it would be me, and I almost said that to him, but I didn’t, because if I had, I would have been giving in, and I wasn’t quite ready to give in.
“It’s not a risk, Rach.” He was watching my face. I had a poker face, a damn good one, one that let me win in court time and time again. But it hadn’t ever quite worked with Cole, mostly because he knew my tells. Mostly because he had never told me my tells, just like I had never told him his. “It’s a goddamn sure thing. My life as I know it will be over.”
He sounded so calm, so reasonable.
“Then why do it?” I asked. I had to know the answer to that one, even if I didn’t take his case.
“Because I was an idiot,” he said, “and I can’t live with the result.”
***The result was Harold Conner O’Laughlin, an ancient offensive good old boy who hung around the fringes of politics for years. Reports tied him to all sorts of nefarious dealings, from money laundering to bank fraud, but no one could pin anything on him. He had family money, which he had somehow made grow in ways that public disclosure forms never asked the right questions to resolve.
It didn’t seem that odd that he would win an election—or it hadn’t seemed odd, until the women. Girls, really. He had a predilection for underage girls who had recently gone through puberty, but hadn’t reached their full growth yet. Old enough to marry in some Southern states back when he was born, but not old enough to consent in most of the lower forty-eight now.
When O’Laughlin first ran for office in 1974, the press looked the other way. Or maybe they didn’t look at all. Or maybe they shared the same interests. I have no real idea, and I don’t really care.
The point was that O’Laughlin was a scumbag of the first order, and I couldn’t believe that Cole helped him get elected.
Oh, hell. Not helped. Rigged an election for him.
“You knew what he was,” I said when the fury eased enough that I could actually speak.
“Well, no,” Cole said, in that easy manner of his. “I’m not from around here, remember?”
“Don’t give me that bullshit, Cole,” I said. “You knew what he was because it was in the press during the run-up to the election. You should have quit right there.”
“You don’t quit on the people who hired me,” Cole said quietly.
“But you rat them out?” I shook my head. I’d dealt with mob cases when I was a very young, very green attorney, and fortunately, at that point, I had worked for a white-shoe law firm who knew how to protect us, and how to avoid cases that would get us all killed.
“Why do you think I waited?” Cole asked. “If we do this right, I’ll be under the court’s protection before these guys even know what’s going on.”
I frowned at him. It wasn’t like him to be naïve.
“If this is as big as you say it is,” I said, “then we have no idea who will protect you and who won’t. You’re not giving me enough time to find out, either.”
He ran a hand over his mouth. “You’ll let the state live with that creature in the legislature?”
“The state is already working on getting used to him,” I said. “Let’s trust the press to get him out.”
“‘Let’s trust the press…?’ Who are you and what have you done with Rachel?” Cole almost sounded offended.
I let out a sigh. “I can’t guarantee that you’ll live through this,” I said. “And I certainly can’t guarantee that I’ll do a good job. This is too big to take on right now.”
“And if we don’t take it on right now, we lose the chance,” Cole said.
“There could be a recall,” I said.
“And that worked in Wisconsin, didn’t it?” he asked, referring to the recall attempt on the governor in 2012. That governor proved as hard to get rid of as poop on the bottom of a pair of Nikes.
I shrugged, and took another sip of my double-double something, pretending at nonchalance.
“Rach,” Cole said in that tone, the one that could work its way into my brain and make me question my own sanity. “You realize if you refuse to do this, you’ll be partially responsible for everything O’Laughlin does in office.”
I glared at Cole. “That’s not a winning argument. There are other attorneys you can bamboozle.”
“Not at the end of the year,” he said, “and not whom I trust enough to handle this.”
Those words should have guilted me. Hell, they did guilt me, but just enough to make me angry. I’d already told him to get out, and he hadn’t listened.
So I went for the big guns. I stood up, and said in the softest voice I could manage, “You might trust me, but I don’t trust you. Not anymore.”
He swallowed hard. He knew when I spoke softly, I was as angry as I could get.
Then he nodded.
“Tell you what,” he said. “You have my stupidity fee. Let’s add a few hours of consultation on top of it. You give me the names of a few attorneys you would trust to handle this, and I’ll give you my evidence. You look through it, and let me know by nine tomorrow if you’ve changed your mind. Then—”
“That makes your window even shorter,” I said.
He shrugged. “I want you, Rach.”
And damned if that sentence didn’t send a shiver through me, just like it always had.
***People don’t want to hear about romances gone wrong. They want to hear about the meet-cute (bar, after hours, near the courthouse), the sexual details (you’ve already gotten what you’re going to get out of me), or that moment where it all went wrong, if that moment is dramatic enough.
There were no dramatic moments between me and Cole. Just tiny things—and not lipstick on the collar things, unless the lipstick was mine. Stories that I’d tell him in confidence that would end up relayed back to me by someone who shouldn’t know that thing. Incidents that seemed off and impossible to explain away. Moments where even the smiles rang false.
Great sex blinds. It really does. And I should have figured out long before the sexual bloom fell off the rose that Cole wasn’t the man I thought he was. People warned me, after all. They’d make portentous comments—a few colleagues even saying things like Do you know what you’ve gotten yourself into? and me uttering the blithe happy response of the sexually sated, Of course I do.
Of course, I didn’t. And by the time I realized that Cole had read some of my case files and relayed information from them to opposing counsel, he had already moved on to a younger, prettier trial attorney who would get disbarred for improprieties two years later.
She never blamed Cole outright, but scuttlebutt around the courthouse was that he had something to do with it.
I never blamed Cole either, at least out loud. First, I couldn’t prove that opposing counsel had gotten their information from Cole. Second, given the very public nature of our breakup (which involved yelling [by him] and water-throwing in the deli near the courthouse [by me]), any attempt to blame Cole would seem like sour grapes. Finally, if Cole had gotten into my files (and I’m 88% sure he had), the fault lay with me for not protecting them better. I was handling a pretty notorious case at the time, and everyone wanted the details. Everyone.
That someone got the details and fed them to opposing counsel made my job harder, but not impossible. I still won, even though it took some fancy mouth-work on my part.
And I didn’t get in trouble with the court or the bar, maybe (probably) because everyone had been relieved that I broke up with Cole or maybe that grumpy me had gotten laid in the first place.
I never proved his malfeasance. I never tried to. I had already felt hurt and betrayed by him. For one of the few times in my life, I didn’t want to dig deeper to see if he had compounded the hurt and betrayal by getting involved with me not because he was attracted, but because he needed something from me.
Just like he did right now.
***Maybe it was some kind of weird tit-for-tat that made me take his evidence files. Maybe he really did have a strange hold over me, and I couldn’t say no.
Although I did say no to the goodbye buss, which would have led to a good-bye kiss, which would have become a let’s-see-if-the-sex-is-as-good-as-I-remember encounter in the apartment upstairs.
Anyway, the files he gave me were detailed. There were photos, and emails, and copies of texts. He had this all planned out.
I ordered in Italian primarily for the tiramisu (since I didn’t get my chocolate mousse at lunch) and scrolled through everything, reading much more than I wanted to.
It wasn’t until I was halfway through the tiramisu, which was better than I remembered (and damn near as good as sex) that I realized Cole’s name wasn’t on anything here. There were texts. There were other people’s names. There was email with handles like GTR3345@somepublicdomain.com, but there were no names at all. And to prove dirt like this, planning like this, we needed names attached.
I set aside the tiramisu. Okay, no. I didn’t. I leaned back in my office chair and shoveled that food into my mouth like I hadn’t eaten since the Stone Age. Then I set aside the plastic dish, wiped my mouth off, and stood, unable to sit with any of this.
I paced just like I would have in a courtroom.
Here are the facts, Your Honor.
(Let’s sit with that a moment—or rather, pace with it. He sees me as a mark, and nothing more. He sees me as a mark, and that angers the piss out of me. He sees me as a mark, someone he can use. He sees me as a mark, and I want to kill him for it. He sees me as a mark…)
Okay, I have to get off #5 or I’ll be stuck there for the rest of my life.
Oh, and…
When in doubt, one of the most vicious law school professors in the history of the universe snarled at me in front of my fellow first-years when I couldn’t answer a key question, go back to the statute. You’ll be surprised at what you find.
Make sure you know that law. That’s Lawyering 101, and that’s where most lawyers fail.
Cole went to law school too. He had the same kind of vicious law professors. He knew how to read a statute.
And he also knew about egos. He liked to prey on them, which I found amusing until I didn’t.
I continued to pace. I imagined myself laying out the case for one of my associates.
Here’s what we know:
He also got flustered when I didn’t want to take the case. He flattered me, played to my ego, and tried to bring back the good parts of our relationship.
He gave me a thousand dollars and admitted he was being stupid. Which automatically put him in a one-down position.
Or did it?
It made me expect stupidity. Creative stupidity, but stupidity nonetheless.
I didn’t like the way the Italian food sat in my stomach, heavy and aching. All of me was heavy and aching. I wished I could rewind to this morning, when I thought I would end the year with three wins and a lot more money than I expected.
I looked at my watch. Long past the time for my researcher to be in the basement. But he was supposed to be on call during rough patches, and year-end was a rough patch.
I nearly called him, then I realized that first, I needed to do this myself.
I went to my desk, and opened the non-networked laptop, the one I used for super confidential research. I opened my personal FindLaw account, not the one the office used, and called up the various statutes on election law in this state.
Complicated wasn’t the word for it. But I dug and read some of the commentary, and dug some more, and finally found the prevailing statute.
Should there be allegations of election fraud or “problems” with the way an election was administered in a particular region, the county clerk needed to be notified. If the clerk saw irregularities, she was supposed to contact the secretary of state and request time to examine the evidence. No one on the ballot in question would be allowed to take office until the matter was resolved.
The list for resolution was nearly as long as the possible offenses. The list contained everything from fines to a special election. Once the secretary of state’s office determined fraud had occurred, resolution had to happen. There was no just living with the fraudulent result.
I stared at that, my hands jittery from too much caffeine and sugar.
There was no just living with the result. Once the fraud was proven.
But there was no way to prove fraud in a few days.
So I dug back into the relevant statutes and found some case law. And that was when I exhaled mightily.
Because the courts had ruled—like, a hundred years ago, really, over one hundred years—that once the fraud allegation got made, the election results hit pause. The elected officials from the previous election remained in office until this situation could be resolved. There was the usual legal language for “get this done fast”—all due haste was in there, along with language specific to special elections—which I did not look up.
Instead I wrote down two phrases that I deemed important.
The previous officials remained in office, and the entire slate on the ballot in question could not take office.
The entire slate. Meaning whoever was on the ballot that also contained O’Laughlin’s name also couldn’t get into office until this matter was resolved.
Like so many states in 2018, ours changed from red to blue, on many, many, many local levels. And Cole had been working for Republicans.
I started digging in earnest now, seeing who had been on the tainted ballots and who would remain in office.
I sucked in air as I finished.
O’Laughlin was in one of those ridiculously gerrymandered districts, the kind that snaked around entire neighborhoods. He had been elected, but even in that district, the Democrats took several local offices that had previously been held by Republicans.
And not just “previously” held, but held for nearly two decades.
Anger surged through me—damn Cole—and then I made myself breathe. Before I accused him—again—of manipulating the election, I needed to see something else.
I needed to see how election fraud allegations had been handled in the past.
So I spent the next forty-five minutes reading old newspapers and watching a few video clips.
And I knew.
***The next morning, I called Cole at seven a.m.
“I need to meet with you to discuss all of this evidence,” I said. “But my first opening is at three. Can you come to my office then?”
“We’re on a ticking clock, Rach,” he said. “Can’t your other appointments wait?”
“They’re court dates, Cole,” I said very gently, as if I were talking to a child. “They’ve been waiting, and the judges will have my head if I moved for a delay now. With me, it’s three or nothing. Of course, you’re free to hire someone else, if you would like. I know a few specialists in election law who might still be in town.”
I couldn’t resist that last. It was a jab, but he didn’t know it, because he didn’t know what I had figured out.
“I guess three is all right,” he said. “But we’re going to have to move fast. We have a deadline.”
“I know,” I said. “And I promise you. This will go very fast.”
If I could pull it off. If I didn’t think about the fact that Cole was the one I’d be dealing with.
I wasn’t lying to him. My first court case was a hearing at nine a.m., with another hearing at eleven. I called a meeting of my staff—such as it was—for eight, and told them I would need them to handle Cole. I did not let them know exactly what handling Cole would mean.
They’d learn quickly enough.
The first hearing went better than expected. My client, who had been a no-show at three previous hearings, showed this time, along with his girlfriend and their baby. She had apparently convinced him to own up to his mistakes before the first of the year.
Seemed everyone used year-end as a marker.
That, and the baby, whom my client clearly adored, had made some kind of impact. I couldn’t argue for leniency because judges got pissed when people missed hearings, but I did manage to convince the judge to sentence my client to a minimum security facility near his family.
I was outta there within a half an hour.
Cole didn’t need to know that. He wasn’t hanging around the courthouse this time.
But I had to. I didn’t want to run into him elsewhere. There were small rooms in the courthouse, up on the fifth floor, that lawyers could use for meetings with clients. I took one of the rooms—not because I was going to meet anyone, but because I didn’t want to run into Cole.
The rooms were all small, just a table, a few chairs, and, if you were lucky, one of those rectangular windows that barely let in light on a summer day. In the winter, the light was so thin that it couldn’t really be called “light” at all. The room had fluorescents that washed out everything, including me.
And damn Cole, for making me think about my appearance, even though I had decided (once again) that he was a son of a bitch. I wore my best gray suit, the one that matched my practical (but dressy) gray ankle boots, and I’d spent too much time on my hair. The only thing I couldn’t fix was my eyes. They were sunken deep into my face from lack of sleep, which only made me look like a defense attorney on a big case, which I was—with luck—not going to be at all.
Half the courthouse walked by my open door. I tried not to look up, tried to make sure I remained deep in the files for my last case of the year, if you didn’t count Cole, which I was trying not to.
I got used to the sound of footsteps, but when some stopped outside my room, I looked up, both worried and annoyed, afraid that Cole might’ve found me after all.
Instead, Angelina Thackery, Judge Segerson’s clerk, peered into the room. She held the door with one hand, as if she was debating whether or not to close it.
“It’s officially lunchtime,” she said. Which reminded me that I was going to have to lock up before getting takeout from the not-half-bad cafeteria in the basement.
I worried that she was going to ask me to join her in said cafeteria.
Instead, she said, “And since we’re on personal time, I’d like to make a comment.”
We weren’t on personal time. Self-employed lawyers didn’t have personal time. But I didn’t tell her that.
“Comment away,” I said.
She stepped inside the room and pulled the door closed. “I know you have a history with Colfax Schneider, but lately, there’ve been some really terrible rumors about him.”
“What kind of rumors?” I asked.
Her lips thinned, and she shook her head a little. Confidentiality rules made it difficult for all of us to have real conversations, even if we wanted to.
“You know that Judge Segerson heads the Judicial Ethics Panel, right?” she asked.
I nodded. Her boss was one of the good guys. He actually had ethics, which I had discovered over the years were in very short supply around the courthouse.
“You’ve heard that they’ve empaneled a grand jury in the O’Laughlin case, right?” she asked.
I hated these kinds of conversation. They were like jigsaw puzzles with half the pieces missing.
“I hadn’t heard that,” I said, quite truthfully. “Which case with O’Laughlin? The election violations or the underage girls?”
“The material that was in the press sparked the district attorney to launch an investigation last fall,” she said primly, her gaze meeting me.
She didn’t say “What election violations?” which she would have if she hadn’t heard about them.
“Underage girls, then,” I said, because to my knowledge, nothing about election law violations had hit the press at all. “That should have nothing to do with Cole. I know for a sorry fact that he prefers adult women.”
She gave me such a sad smile that it made me wonder if he had worked his charm on her as well.
“Judge Segerson often takes election law cases, doesn’t he?” I asked.
She nodded, looking wary.
“Are you going to be in the office tomorrow?” I asked.
“Tomorrow is too l—”
“New Year’s Eve, I know,” I said, cutting her off. She was treading too close on the confidentiality stuff, for my tastes anyway. “Will you?”
“Yes,” she said. “But it won’t—”
“Good,” I said. “I may call you for an appointment.”
“You’d have to meet with the judge.” She sounded a bit sad.
“I know,” I said.
She bit her lower lip. “I know you have a past with Cole,” she said, “and that probably makes you want to trust him. But don’t, Rachel. You’re one of my favorites around here. I would hate to see you get tangled up in something ugly.”
My turn for a sad—and bitter—smile. “Oh, I already tangled up with something ugly years ago, and I’ve regretted it ever since. I know better than to take Cole at his word.”
She was biting her lower lip so hard I thought she was going to bite it off and swallow it.
“I hope so,” she said quietly. Then she nodded. “If I don’t talk to you, have a happy New Year.”
“You too,” I said.
She nodded again, then let herself out of the room, leaving the door open.
I stared into the now-empty hallway, my appetite gone. If Cole really was my client, then I was under an obligation to inform him that someone in the government had their eye on him.
Or was I? Because Angelina was deliberately, and I would have once said, frustratingly vague. I didn’t know what they were investigating Cole for, let alone if they were investigating him. All she had mentioned was rumors, which I didn’t have to report at all.
But she did confirm to me, in that sideways conversation, that Judge Segerson was the man to go to with any election law questions. And he would be ethical enough to handle them properly.
My stomach twisted. Then it growled. Apparently that loss of appetite was brief, and perhaps mistaken for some kind of stress.
I had my plan. But I was also dealing with Cole. Damn Angelina for reminding me of that. He was smarter than most people, more manipulative than the average human being, and pretty damn successful at everything he put his hand to—or on.
Including me.
***The second court case went as smoothly as the first. I got pleasantly reminded every year how quickly year-end cases went, mostly because everyone wanted to get out of the courthouse and on to the festivities.
I could have made it back to my office by three, but I didn’t. This time, I trusted Cole’s nervousness, and while he cooled his heels in my office, I warmed mine in the nearest Starbucks, indulging in a festive holiday peppermint mocha while I bought coffee for the staff.
They would be dealing with an increasingly panicked Cole. I didn’t even need the five texts he had sent since three to tell me that. All five were getting increasingly shrill.
I planned my return carefully. I brought the drinks into the office, handed them out personally, even going to the basement to give my researcher his super strong shot of caffeine. He grunted his thank-you, which was more than I had ever gotten from him before.
Then I climbed the stairs to my office—without any beverages at all. I figured Cole didn’t need anything. My staff should have been giving him house coffee, which probably didn’t help his mood much at all.
He stood at the bay windows in the outer sanctum, staring down at the empty neighboring Victorian. I had bought that building and hadn’t yet figured out what I would use it for. I had to be careful, since it was so close to my office; wouldn’t want to rent to the wrong tenants or put some kind of disruptive business next to mine.
“You’re late,” he snapped without turning around. “I told you that we’re on the clock.”
“If you want,” I said, ignoring his tone, “I can get us an appointment tomorrow morning with Judge Segerson. He’s the go-to judge on elections. His clerk says he’ll be in.”
Cole turned around, his face half shadowed in the artificial light. He didn’t look quite as pretty this afternoon. Maybe because he was angry. I wasn’t sure I’d ever seen him this kind of angry before.
“You’ve decided to take my case?” he asked.
“If you do what I tell you.” I hung my puffy coat on the coatrack near the door. The mittens dangled, so I tucked them in the pockets. I smoothed my hands over my hair, which I had already done downstairs, and so I cursed the movement silently because it betrayed that I was still—still, goddammit!—attracted to this man.
“And what are you going to tell me to do,” he said.
“We don’t have to go to the press,” I said. “What we have to do is convince a judge that there are discrepancies. And the evidence you gave me last night more than proves that. He puts the election on hold for ten days—that’s the first threshold—while he looks into the allegations. After the first, I’ll do a media blitz, representing my unnamed client. If we do this right, you’ll get whistleblower status and won’t have to worry about jail time.”
His eyes narrowed. Could he hear my heart trying to pound its way out of my chest? Did I look nervous? I’d been using my authoritative courtroom voice, the one that let me bullshit with the best of them, but Cole knew me really well. Maybe he could hear the nerves behind it all.
“You think I can get whistleblower status?” He sounded incredulous.
“You don’t get what you don’t ask for,” I said, and he smiled. It took a minute for me to understand that smile. He had said that sentence to me early in our relationship, mostly in a sexual context, but also just as a general rule of thumb.
I couldn’t believe he remembered that. I couldn’t believe I remembered that.
“You have thought this out.” He sounded surprised.
“I told you I had a plan,” I said.
“I would feel better if we spoke to the judge tonight,” Cole said.
“I know you would,” I said. “But you know what it’s like at year’s end. Everyone is booked to the max. I think we’re lucky we can talk with him tomorrow.”
“What about some of the other judges? Or maybe we should talk to the press…?”
I smiled. “You mean I should talk to the press.”
“Well, yeah,” Cole said.
I shook my head. “It’s the night before New Year’s Eve. Most places are planning their new year’s coverage, and the real reporters are on vacation. If you do things my way, you’ll get the big names covering this. I might even be able to book us time on the national cable networks. I’ve managed that in the past on big cases. You want that kind of attention. Then the state can’t look away.”
His eyes narrowed further. I wasn’t sure I liked that movement, but I didn’t mention it. I didn’t want to call attention to it.
“What aren’t you telling me?” he asked.
In the past, I would have stiffened, and it would have been a tell. But I had trained that one out of my system. I had to, because clients asked that damn question all the time.
“Nothing that you don’t already know,” I said, deciding to stroke his ego. “There is a chance this won’t work. You left it to the last minute, and that limits our opportunities. If you’d come to me after the election, I could have—”
“I didn’t realize how bad O’Laughlin would be,” Cole said.
“You keep telling me that,” I said, “but I don’t know what’s different. We knew he was a pig before he got elected. What’s changed?”
Cole shook his head. “Stuff I can’t tell you. Stuff I hadn’t known until the after-party. Stuff—it’s disgusting, Rach.”
“Yeah, I know,” I said. “It was disgusting when you went to work for him. Maybe you weren’t paying attention.”
Maybe you were just thinking about the money.
That sentence hung between us, unspoken. Because I didn’t dare say something like that. We’d start fighting and then, eventually, he would break through my lawyerly façade.
He stared at me for a long moment. “Maybe I wasn’t paying attention,” he said quietly. “But what’s done is done.”
“And what’s done put us up against this deadline,” I said. “You want me to call Judge Segerson’s clerk?”
“Yeah,” Cole said, clipping the word. “Do it.”
***I went into my inner sanctum and called Angelina. I kept the call on the up and up in case Cole planted some listening devices in here. I wouldn’t put it past him. I had the place swept professionally monthly, and I had a small wand of my own, which I would use in a day or so.
But I didn’t want to tip him off to the fact that these days, I planned to be bugged. Just like I had the staff hide all of our paperwork from him, and make sure that the computers left out had old, insignificant files on them, just in case he snooped like he had in the past.
The inner sanctum was cold. The staff hadn’t turned on my gas fireplace. I did that now, as I listened to my cell ring.
“Angelina, hi,” I said as she answered. “Looks like I’ll need an appointment with the judge tomorrow after all.”
“Ooo-kay,” she said, sounding skeptical. “He has a hearing at nine, but nothing after eleven-thirty. He’ll probably want to get out of here by noon, just like the rest of us.”
“Eleven-thirty sounds—”
I was about to say fine when the door to my office opened.
“I overheard,” Cole said. “I don’t know what you’re thinking, but the earlier the better. I can meet before nine.”
I sighed and resisted the urge to roll my eyes. “Did you hear that?” I asked Angelina.
“Yeah, and I’m going to assume I’m on speaker, so I won’t say what I said earlier.”
I smiled. She made her point without saying a word. “Can we meet before the judge’s hearing starts?”
“I’ll book you in at eight,” she said. “Expect him to be viciously annoyed.”
I had encountered Judge Segerson first thing in the morning. Viciously annoyed was an accurate description of him at that time of day.
“I will,” I said, and hung up.
“I don’t know why you keep pushing this back,” Cole said.
“Because,” I said calmly, “the judge is the only one we need to convince. He just has to have time to file the paperwork before close of business at the end of the year. I looked. It’s a pretty simple form.”
Cole sighed, then nodded. “I was going to ask you to dinner, but you’re going to say no, aren’t you?”
“If you want me to be prepared for an eight a.m. meeting, I don’t have time for dinner,” I said. Then I smiled at him. “But I don’t have plans for New Year’s Eve.”
“Let’s see if we have something to celebrate first,” he said, and stomped out the door.
I was still standing in the middle of the inner sanctum, holding my phone tightly in my right hand, when one of my associates peered in.
“You okay?” she asked. “He was pretty charged.”
“I’m okay,” I said, and thumbed the phone on. It was 5:05 p.m. Time to send everyone home.
I smiled.
“I really am okay,” I said.
***Judge Segerson was a whippet-thin ferret of a man who looked like he had swallowed a bowling ball and it had lodged against his spine, forcing him to stoop. He wasn’t wearing his robes when we entered his chamber. Just a white button-down shirt and a reddish-brown cardigan that had seen better days. His black pants hung low and had pilled along the side, despite the crease he insisted on.
His wife had died a few years back, and that was when he went from looking natty every single day to looking like a man who remembered only half the rules of proper dressing.
His thin hair stood up in the back, probably from the stocking cap he had worn into work.
I had dressed down. I wore a glittery white dress-up sweater and black pants. I had put on my best suit, then had taken it off. Cole knew me well enough to know that I overdressed when I was nervous—figuring that dressing up negated a lot of sin—and it would have been a tell to wear the suit. Then I put on a different suit, and realized that would have been a tell as well.
So I opted for the sweater, matching boots, and my signature red lipstick.
Cole actually wore a tailored black suit coat over black jeans with silver trim. He also had on a pair of black cowboy boots that somehow looked polished despite the dirty slushy snow we had to wade through to get through the front door of the courthouse.
Judge Segerson bade us to sit. He wasn’t viciously annoyed, not yet anyway, but he did seem preoccupied. He sat behind his desk and looked at me, not Cole.
“What’s so urgent, Rachel?” the judge asked.
I dug into the wheeled carry-on that held my files, grabbed the printouts I had made of much of Cole’s evidence, and slid the entire accordion file toward the judge. Then I placed a brand new flash drive on top.
“My client has evidence of tampering in the O’Laughlin election.” I named the district. “I’ve reviewed it, and I think that election fraud took place.”
The judge put his hand on the accordion file, and wrapped his forefinger around the thumb drive. He looked at Cole.
“Why didn’t you come forward earlier?” the judge said.
Cole looked at me, and for the first time that morning, he looked nervous. “I’d rather have my attorney speak for me,” he said.
The judge turned his attention back to me. “Rachel, what do you expect me to do with this?”
“Well,” I said, choosing my words carefully. “It’s pretty clear that a crime has been committed, and we’re going to need to deal with that. The—”
“Oh, God.” So much for Cole’s decision to let me speak. He was the one who sounded viciously annoyed now. “Your Honor, we need you to review this material quickly, so that you can put the election on hold before O’Laughlin takes office.”
The judge didn’t even look at Cole. The judge’s watery brown eyes were focused on me.
“You’re usually better than this, Rachel,” the judge said.
My cheeks heated. I had expected some turmoil, but I hadn’t expected it to be personal.
“You’re one of the attorneys I count on to be fully prepared,” the judge said.
“Judge, Mr. Schneider approached me on Monday. I haven’t had a lot of time with the material, but what I’ve seen—”
“I didn’t mean on the material,” the judge said. “The statutes. Good God, woman, you usually know them better than I do.”
Cole whipped his head toward me. I concentrated hard on ignoring him, and looking only at the judge.
“What the hell?” Cole said, but he said it to me.
I didn’t answer him.
So the judge folded his hands over all of that evidence and looked at Cole.
“Mr. Schneider, if you wanted me to prevent someone from taking elected office, you needed to come to me yesterday.”
Cole looked at me, then at the judge. “The statute says by the end of the year,” Cole snapped, preventing me from saying the sentence I’d been dreading.
“Yes,” the judge said, “and if you look at the definitions in that section of the code, you’ll see that year’s end and month’s end are clearly mandated. Year’s end, if it happens on a weekend, means the Friday before. The statute also excludes holidays.”
“This isn’t a holiday,” Cole said. “You have court today.”
“Many of us have court today, but we chose to, and we only conduct hearings. Technically, December 31 is a holiday according to the code. We just have a custom that allows us to sneak in an extra court day if we need it.”
Cole’s mouth opened. He looked at me, and at the judge. Fortunately, my face was beet red. I had humiliated myself in front of a judge I respected.
“I can’t do anything,” the judge said. “If you have evidence of a crime, and it looks like you do, I suggest you speak to the district attorney. Or, if you like, I can review this over the holiday break, and I will make the referral.”
“I think that’s probably a good idea,” I said, my voice sounding strangled. “I told Mr. Schneider that I’m not expert in election law, and this morning proves that. So what I see as fraud, you might see differently.”
Cole was shaking his head. He started to say something—probably to tell the judge to forget it—but I put my hand on his (oh-so-muscular) thigh and stopped the torrent of words from escaping Cole’s mouth.
“I will,” the judge said. “I can’t believe you missed this, Rachel.”
I nodded, then stood slowly. “Thank you for your time, Your Honor.”
I ushered Cole out of the judge’s chambers, but didn’t shut the door behind us. Cole was shaking visibly.
Angelina looked up from her desk and was about to say something when Cole snapped, “You fucked me, Rachel.”
“Not for ten years,” I said drily.
“You know what I mean,” he said. “How could you have missed the statute?”
“How could you?” I asked, pretense gone. “You went to law school. You’re the one who pointed me to the code.”
He leaned back as if he had been slapped.
“Oh, that’s right,” I said, “you were a C student, and for obvious reasons. I had a 4.0, even in law school. Law review, the whole nine yards. I got a lot of those grades because I read the law in its entirety.”
“You did this on purpose,” he said, voice shaking.
I shrugged. If I answered that honestly, I might have to talk to the bar. Because I hadn’t served my client’s interest. I had served a greater one. I didn’t want that entire election to be overturned.
“I told you,” I said as calmly as I could. “I don’t know election law. I offered to send you to lawyers who did. You didn’t listen. If you had, you could have had this entire ballot overturned, just like you wanted.”
Cole’s face went pale.
At that moment, the judge yelled from his desk, “Take your fight elsewhere. I have a hearing in a half an hour and I’d like some think time.”
I turned, caught the judge’s eye, and I swear it twinkled. He now understood what I wanted him to understand; I hadn’t misread the statute at all. I had manipulated Cole, just like he was trying to manipulate me.
Only this time, I was the one who succeeded in the manipulation.
Angelina got up and pulled the door closed.
“I’d wish you a happy New Year,” she said to me, “but it looks like—”
“Oh, I will,” I said. “Trust me. Let’s go, Cole.”
I put my hand on his arm, to steer him out of the room, but he shook me off.
“You deliberately screwed me,” he said.
“Many times,” I said. “But that’s in the past. We’re heading to a brand new year. Are you going to want me to set up another appointment with the judge or the DA? I’m sure you’ll end up with whistleblower status.”
I wasn’t sure of that at all, but I was a bit giddy from my success.
Cole ignored my question. We stepped into the hallway outside of the judge’s offices, and this time, I made sure the door was closed.
“You failed yourself,” he said. “O’Laughlin is going to stay in power, and he’s going to hurt this state, and you’ll only have yourself to blame.”
I shrugged one shoulder. “The law has other ways of dealing with Mr. O’Laughlin.”
I didn’t tell Cole about the grand jury, for fear that Cole would go running to O’Laughlin. I now firmly knew where Cole’s allegiances were, and they were with the Republicans, who wanted that entire ballot tossed out.
“You know,” I said, adding a bit of a lilt to my voice. “Maybe you should get a different lawyer. We have too much history. I have a hunch that the past really got in the way of me doing my job.”
“The past?” Cole said. “We had a fine time in the past.”
“Until you used me,” I said, the lilt gone. “Just like you were trying to use me now.”
His eyes narrowed. All of the good looks were gone now. So this was what Cole’s real face looked like, without all the made-up good humor and charm.
“Tell you what,” I said. “Let’s let bygones be bygones. That’s what people do at year’s end, right? I’ll forgive you for trying to manipulate me again, and you can forgive me for my election-law lapse.”
“Fat fucking chance,” he said. He pivoted and stomped away from me.
I watched him go, enjoying that last glimpse of his backside—for two reasons: it was one pretty backside, and it was also nice to see the back of him. He would never come near me again.
I let out a small sigh. Bullet dodged. And by the end, the judge knew what I had done. He knew that I had delayed on purpose, and if he hadn’t figured that out, Angelina would fill him in on all the details, including the gossipy ones.
I wouldn’t go down in the judge’s estimation after all.
Which was, it turns out, the only thing that mattered to me. I didn’t want the judge to think I was stupid. Even though I had been around Cole in the past.
I got better. I learned from my mistakes.
And I probably ensured that Cole and his merry band of fraudsters would do some prison time. We’d have to see how that would play out.
No matter how it would, though, Cole had already paid for his stupidity. I got to shame him, which was no small feat. But the one he was probably regretting right now was the stupidity fee. I was almost tempted to refund it.
He did get the Creativity of the Year award. He was gambling on other people’s stupidity (mine and the judge’s) to thwart the will of the voters.
He had failed.
Because if you wait long enough, stupidity loses. It always does. Often in spectacular and memorable ways.
I shook my head. I was grinning. I didn’t have a New Year’s Eve date, but then, I never did. But all in all, I had a pretty spectacular year’s end. Better than I had expected.
And I had expected it to be pretty damn good.
Other People’s Stupidity
Copyright© 2022 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
First published as part of the WMG Holiday Spectacular 2019 project
Published by WMG Publishing
Cover and Layout copyright © 2022 by WMG Publishing
Cover design by Allyson Longueira
Cover art copyright © AntonMatyukha/Depositphotos
I sat down to add something to this list, and realized I hadn’t started it. I had just set my books aside. Whoops. I thought I’d been keeping up all month. Such a surprise.
What I sat down to add was a bit about The Best American Essays 2022. I love these volumes, as you know, but I had to set this year’s aside. It’s very dark, and I have just come through a rough month, with an added bonus of virulent outrageously bad head cold! Viruses, I had not missed you. Anyway, I have two recommendations so far from this year’s volume, but I quit reading after the Gwartney, listed below. Beautifully done, but it hit me in all of my fears. (I was reading while Dean & I were both sick.) So I swapped out for a book about lost cities, which I’m hoping to like, and then I’ll follow that with some holiday reading, and then…in 2023, I’ll come back to the essays. I know they’re going to be great.
Then school got in the way of posting this. A massive final project that took 35+ hours of my time (but gave me a story idea) over one weekend, and then studying for my Spanish final, as well as hitting writing deadlines pushed this project back and back and back. I’m finally finishing it now. Yes, yes, yes, yes, I’m very late in posting this. I’m hoping to be on top of the December list.
I have lots to recommend here…
November 2022Adande, J.A., editor, The Year’s Best Sports Writing 2022, Triumph Books, 2022. I truly love this series, and I was happy when Triumph Books saved it from the chopping block after Mariner let it go. The past two years, dealing with sports stories from the pandemic and the awfulness that was 2020 and 2021, have made the volume even stronger, as opposed to The Best American Essays series which was just sad and depressing and nearly impossible to stomach at times. These sports stories might not be filled with triumph and happiness, but at least they’re about people trying to do something, even in the face of horrible or impossible odds.
J.A. Adande picked wonderful essays and articles. While I’ve singled out several this month and last, pretty much every essay in the book is worth reading. I think I skipped one because it was breaking my heart too much. And that means it was well written. Others might find it to be one of the better pieces in the volume. If you feel like reading great essays, this is the volume to pick up.
Chee, Alexander, “Introduction,” The Best American Essays 2022, edited by Alexander Chee, Mariner Books, 2022. Sometimes the introduction to these volumes are absolutely brilliant and sometimes they’re perfunctory. This one falls into the brilliant category. Chee examines how the past few years have had an impact on his writing and his writing choices. He makes a lot of marvelous points about the differences between outside expectations and the importance of following your heart. He also discusses how difficult it can be to write from that heart. Every writer should read this one.
Collins, Ron, On Writing (And Reading!) Short: A Science Fiction Writer’s Quest for Stories That Matter, Skyfox Publishing, 2022. I got this lovely little book because I backed Ron’s Kickstarter. As I type this, the book is available for preorder. All writers and readers should pick it up. I glanced at the book when it came into the condo, as I do with every new book that arrives here, and found myself reading. There’s a lot of good writerly advice, but more than that, the book is a shared conversation on the act of reading. Lots of good insights here and lots of good recommendations.
Conochan, Kelaine, “Badwater Ultramarathon: What I Lost and Found During The 135 Miles of The World’s Most Impossible Run,” The Year’s Best Sports Writing 2022, edited by J.A. Adande, Triumph Books, 2022. I find myself thinking of this essay over and over again. Kelaine Conochan had signed up for Badwater only to have it canceled in 2020, so she ran it in 2021. The work it took to train, the things she went through, the fact that she made it…well, much of that was her team. But I live not far from the site of this run, and I do not run outside in the summer. (Okay, I ran outside for 2+ years at 5 a.m. due to the pandemic, but I’ve since stopped. Because no fun. And yeah. No fun. I like to think I was a machine in that period, but not like this.) This is an honest examination of an extreme sport by a participant. I’m impressed and stunned and…no way would I do that. Wow.
Crais, Robert, Racing The Light, G.P. Putnam, 2022. I have been waiting years for this book. I love Robert Crais’s work, and it had been too long since the last book. But Bob had health issues and other things, plus there was this pandemic, you see, and the book got delayed. So when it arrived, on publication day, I read the first page, then the first chapter…and dang if I wasn’t done by the following day. Which means I need another book, Bob.
I was going to write “But seriously,” only I think I’m partially serious. This volume is the 19th in the Elvis Cole/Joe Pike series. It features a missing podcaster and the dark underbelly of the city. There’s so much tension here that I wasn’t sure anyone would make it through. A bit of levity comes from The Cat, who is a real cat, who refuses to be named, and who quietly steals the show in this (and several other) books.
Great writing, great storytelling, great characters. If you haven’t read Crais before, you need to start. He’s one of our best.
Emmert, Mark, “How A Gymnast Who Lost A Friend in The Parkland Mass School Shooting Came To Iowa And Found Ways To Heal,” The Year’s Best Sports Writing 2022, edited by J.A. Adande, Triumph Books, 2022. This is a story of resilience. Alex Greenwald had gotten an athletic scholarship to the University of Iowa before the mass shooting in February of 2018. She had been a different person when she agreed to go to Iowa than she was when she got there. Her coach realized it. The team realized it, and they helped her learn how to compete, how to deal with the adrenaline from athletics instead of fear, and helped her grieve. Sad and eye-opening. Worth the read.
Gwartney, Debra, “Fire and Ice,” The Best American Essays 2022, edited by Alexander Chee, Mariner Books, 2022. This essay is beautiful and painful and so very 2020. Debra Gwartney is the widow of writer Barry Lopez. A writer in her own right (damn near typed “write”), she went through a hell of a terrible 2020. Her mother died, and then a massive fire threatened her home with Lopez. They had to evacuate, while he was exceptionally ill with cancer. More happened, which I’m not going to tell you here. But the essay brings it all into focus, wonderfully and heartbreakingly. Worth the price of the entire anthology, for the reflection on this journey of life all by itself.
Jenkins, Sally, “Beneath 9/11’s Terrible Smoke, A Flash of Gold,” The Year’s Best Sports Writing 2022, edited by J.A. Adande, Triumph Books, 2022. Since I started at the university a few years ago, I came to the stunning realization that everyone in my classes, everyone except maybe a few grad students in my law class, does not remember 9/11. Some weren’t even born yet. Others can barely remember it. It’s hard to believe it was over 21 years ago.
This article by Sally Jenkins brought it all back for me. Sally Jenkins was based in New York but she wrote for The Washington Post. Her husband was a photographer for The New York Times. They were driving into the city that horrible day and saw everything. (She believes they would have been in the middle of it if they hadn’t had an argument that delayed them.) They immediately got to work, trying to cover the story. And she found that she needed some way to get home, so she bought a Schwinn bike. She rode it through those dusty streets, through the horror. She describes it, and the attachment she still feels to the bike. Beautifully written, this is a piece I would share with all those students…if I had a reason to.
Mallory, Michael, “The Three Faces of Laura,” Mystery Scene, Fall 2022. My sister, a big mystery fan, once told me that her favorite movie is Laura. I had never seen it before, and so I watched it. Good movie, not my favorite, but I understand how it could be hers. I did not know that the movie I saw, the one she loves, is only the first of three different versions. Fascinating examination of all three, and the times in which they were made.
O’Connell, Mikey, “Making Bank Without The Boys,” The Hollywood Reporter, September 28, 2022. This article has a different title online, but it’s the same article. It’s a fascinating article about Reese Witherspoon and Lauren Neustadter, who started a company called Hello Sunshine. They believed there weren’t enough good parts for women without those women being attached to some man. Witherspoon and Neustadter ended up creating a lot of programming and movies that are award-winning and popular, like Big Little Lies and Little Fires Everywhere. They ultimately sold the company for $900 million, and kept positions on the board as well as managed to maintain creative control. This interview with them is fascinating.
Samman, Shaker, “‘Things Are Going To Be Different Now,'” The Year’s Best Sports Writing 2022, edited by J.A. Adande, Triumph Books, 2022. Because this book is beautifully edited, with a vision and a voice, the Samman article followed the Jenkins article. Samman was little when the planes hit the towers, and discusses how it felt and what he remembers. The title comes from what his mother said on that day, since his family is Muslim. The article itself follows three Muslims who are trying to keep their faith while participating in sports. That includes wearing a hijab while participating in a mostly white Christian community. The entire essay is heartfelt and heartbreaking. Worth the price of the volume.
Sisterson, Craig, “Native Cultures, New Voices,” Mystery Scene, Fall 2022. An excellent look at the indigenous authors who are finally getting a place at the table. Sisterson writes about the mysteries/crime fiction being written now, and the difficulties the writers had getting published. I now have several more books on my TBR pile…
Ware, Ruth, The It Girl, Scout Press, 2022. I find Ruth Ware’s books to be hit or miss for me. And even when I like them, I don’t love them. The It Girl hits my reader cookies—some past secret, a group of students living with a crime from college, and such. The Oxford setting is a bonus. I did not see the twist, and the book held me. It’s one of the better Ware novels. If I’m sounding lukewarm, it’s because I promptly forgot the book a few weeks after I read it. I didn’t write my post here about the book until the work/school deadlines passed, so I had a pile of November Recommended books. I picked this one up and thought, “What’s that about again?” Part of the problem is the title. It’s not indicative of the book at all. But, since this is a traditionally published book, I’m sure the title was workshopped to death in the office. The other part is…it was a nice way to pass the time, but not a lot more. If you like her work, you’ll probably like this. If you’ve wanted to try her work, then this is the one to start with.
I used to be quite dismissive of the usefulness of the 20Booksto50K conference. Pre-pandemic, 20Books was all about Amazon, Kindle, Kindle Select, and making money on page reads. Great money, for a few folks who learned to manipulate Amazon’s algorithms. Good money, for some who went exclusive to Amazon and manipulated the algorithms. Okay money, for many who did what they could when they were in Select, but who did not have the time or inclination to do the technical shenanigans to boost their books up Amazon’s vaunted bestseller lists.
A lot of people were making more money on Amazon than I was at that point, but I knew—because I’m older than dirt and I’ve seen this a million times—that any castles built on Amazon were being built on sand. I’d ask, What if Amazon goes away? No one could imagine that. Or What if they changed their algorithms? No one could imagine that either, until it happened.
I had a thousand what-ifs like that, and these Amazon-only folks had a thousand answers, which didn’t sound like answers to me.
So, I went to 20Books because it was in my hometown, and Dean and I could be lone voices in the wilderness, begging people to go wide.
Then—you know, pandemic. Changes. 20Books happened in 2021, but Dean and I had to cancel since the evil Covid was spreading like wildfire and even though we were vaccinated, the masking/Covid policies at the venue were awful (they’d been cited several times) and the conference relied on the hotel’s policy as their policy.
We decided that a couple of free talks weren’t worth the risk of getting the dread disease.
Fast forward to this year. To my surprise, we were invited back. We decided to attend, figuring it would be like it was pre-pandemic.
Nope. Things had changed dramatically.
20Books had become the indie conference. It tried to cover everything, not just Amazon and the algorithms. I asked a few folks if the conference was like that in 2021, and they said no. But I’m not sure my sources were the best, since their focus was other things.
It wouldn’t have surprised me, though. The Amazon changes were starting last year, but they hadn’t had an impact on most sellers. Or at least, a noticeable impact.
2022, on the other hand, proved to be a different story.
Talk throughout the conference was all about the problems with Amazon. Tricks that had worked in the past no longer worked. Even the folks who weren’t focusing on algorithms and ads were having trouble. Rules were changing, and income was down.
In some cases, income was waaaaay down.
The programming itself was very different. Many of the presenters were from Amazon’s competitors. Others had methods of making money outside of Amazon. And the talk of bestsellers and manipulating algorithms and making choices to write what the Kindle Select readers seemed to buy was mostly gone.
Yes, there was algorithm talk, but it wasn’t the focus. There was a lot more craft, and even more on audio and crowdfunding and new technologies that were not Amazon focused.
All of this made the conference the best it’s ever been. If it keeps going on this path, it will be the do-not-miss conference of the year. Dean and I learned a bunch, came home and changed a few things in our publishing plan for next year, things I will discuss in future posts.
But let’s start, as we did back in the beginning of indie, with Amazon.
During the pandemic, Amazon and other tech companies hit record high profit levels. We were all at home, after all, except folks whose jobs were considered essential, so we used our devices for entertainment. Then, in early 2022, the pandemic gravy train ended with a thud.
Most tech companies saw a decline in profits. In July, Amazon’s growth rate slowed to the lowest point in nearly two decades.
If you dig deep into the New York Times article about the losses, you’ll see that while subscription revenue grew 14% to over 8 billion dollars. Much of that was due to an increase in Prime fees. The retail portion of the business lost 2.4 billion dollars. This is for the second quarter of 2022. The third quarter numbers were better, but, Amazon cautioned, its growth could fall to levels not seen since 2001.
Judging by the company’s behavior, they’re planning for quite a bit of revenue loss. They’ve cut back on expansion, and cut tens of thousands of jobs, while announcing even more layoffs. They’ve been quietly closing parts of the business that aren’t performing to expectations.
The reason, at least according to the New York Times?
The company faced high costs from decisions to overinvest and rapidly expand, while changes in shopping habits and high inflation dented sales.
Some of the cuts Amazon has made have been in their Devices and Books businesses. Amazon’s Books business “spans all of the e-tailer’s operations that deal with books, from its online stores to its Kindle operations.” This comes after the company announced in the summer that it would cut its book orders from publishers (trad, I’m assuming) because of the overflow of inventory it had acquired during the pandemic.
While Amazon is saying that it is still committed to its book business, that commitment will be tested strongly in the next few years. As long as Jeff Bezos was in charge, books were always considered a major portion of the business.
Now, though, Amazon’s spokespeople are offering that corporate word salad that should strike fear into the hearts of all people who are involved in Amazon publishing. They’re saying,
We remain as committed as ever to the book business and to working closely with authors, publishers, and sellers around the world to offer the best experience for readers.
I can’t tell you how many times over the decades I’ve seen that kind of corporate BS just before the ax falls. I’m not saying it will fall, but I think there’s a greater likelihood now than there was a few years ago.
Some of the quiet cuts have already had an impact on some publishing businesses. Just a few days ago, Publishers Weekly noted that Amazon will shutter its textbook rental program sometime in 2023. The digital textbook rental program will remain, and Amazon will continue to sell textbooks, but this particular program is going to be history probably by summer.
Amazon has also decided to shut down their Kindle Publishing for Periodicals Program. That will disappear in September of 2023. Some publications were offered the opportunity to remain in Kindle Unlimited Magazines, but not all.
This would operate just like any other Kindle Unlimited subscription. The payment will come out of the Kindle Select Global fund which I will get to in a minute.
Neil Clarke wrote about this on his blog:
Earnings from Amazon subscriptions provide a varying and sometimes significant portion of the revenue that these publications require to stay in business. If you don’t already know, genre magazines are subscription-driven, meaning that subscriptions make up the bulk of their income. Some people think advertising is a major source, but it actually represents a tiny fraction for us. (Advertising tends to be a leading source of revenue for glossy magazines, so it’s easy to see where they could get that impression.)
None of these magazines are entirely reliant on Amazon, but as the largest ebook retailer in the field, the cancelation of this program will hurt and in some cases, hurt badly. Badly enough to shutter a magazine? Maybe. It’s too soon to tell and there are a lot of variables, including you.
He then made a pitch for subscribers to support their favorite magazines directly.
Uncanny Magazine editor Lynne Thomas told Locus that Uncanny was not offered the opportunity to join Kindle Unlimited. The loss of the subscription program will have a huge impact on that magazine.
This is devastating and frustrating news for Uncanny Magazine, as well as our peer magazines in the Kindle Periodicals Program. While we maintain multiple revenue streams, especially Kickstarter and Patreon, this is a significant loss for us. We’re still in the process of talking to Amazon to encourage them to reverse this decision, or to provide us with tools to help our Amazon subscribers transition to other platforms. This could not have come at a worse time for SFF periodicals, since so many of us are also weathering the storms of reduced advertising revenue and the possible death of Twitter, which is vital for crowdfunding projects.
These are the canaries in the coal mine, Kindle Unlimited writers. As everyone was discussing at 20Books, the time to go wide is now. (Heck, the time to go wide was when you started publishing…or ten years ago, whichever came first.)
Mark Williams of New Publishing Standard offered a scenario in early November that should scare anyone who is relying solely on Amazon for revenue. He examined Amazon’s decision to add 98 million music titles, including ad-free podcasts, to its Prime membership, and noted that Amazon had probably not negotiated with the individual rights holders.
He asks this:
If Amazon will throw its music catalogue into Prime simply because it can, how long before audiobooks or ebooks are added too?
What will the publishers do then? Pull their titles? And then sell them where? For most publishers, the rival ebook and audiobook players in the US cannot begin to make up for the loss of the Amazon platform. Publishers long since handed Amazon the keys to the ebook gateway. The stubborn refusal of certain corporate giants to entertain all subscription options just makes Amazon all the stronger.
He’s talking about traditional publishers here, but the traditional publishers actually have more clout with Amazon than the indie folk. Amazon here is still acting like the behemoth it was, even though it’s desperate. Note from the New York Times stats above that Amazon’s subscription revenue grew due to an increase in Prime fees, when other revenue did not.
Amazon is throwing things into the Prime pie, while cutting programs that don’t make a boatload of revenue.
Writers need to pay attention to this, particularly writers who are Amazon only. Kindle Unlimited payments do not come from sales of books. They come from the Kindle Select Global Fund. From Daniel J. Tortora, who describes the system better than anyone I’ve seen:
The fund is based on the subscription fees paid by the total number of Kindle Unlimited members. As KU members join or drop off, the Global Fund changes.
I want you to look at that last sentence. The Fund changes. And if, in its annual cost-cutting assessment, KU no longer earns what Amazon thinks it should earn, the program will go on the chopping block.
That’s what’s happening with other Amazon programs above, including some high profile ones announced just a year or two ago.
Amazon was kind to the people in the Periodicals Program. They have some months to work their way out of the program and find other sources of revenue.
Most corporations announce cuts and implement them within a week or two. Amazon is currently giving six months or more on various programs.
Whether that will extend to other programs remains to be seen. If Amazon finds itself in more financial hot water, then they’ll revert to standard corporate behavior.
Right now, they’re cutting tens of thousands of jobs. They’re closing programs left and right. They’re not making any real promises to anyone.
This is a company dedicated to cutting what it considers to be things that do not add to the corporate bottom line.
Books rarely have the profit margins or the following that, say, TV shows have. Books don’t make a retailer a lot of money, especially at 30% of cover. Amazon would need a lot of volume to make money on books, and they might get that volume if they behave toward writers the way they just treated musicians.
Let me be clear here. I’m not saying it’s time to leave Amazon. I’m saying it’s time to go wide. To make Amazon part of your publishing portfolio, not all of your publishing portfolio.
As writer businesspeople, you need to ask yourself how you would do if your Amazon revenue vanished. What kind of changes would you have to make?
This is no longer theoretical for many magazine publishers. It might not be theoretical for book publishers in the future either.
Be prepared. In 2023, go wide. Expand your revenue base. We’ll talk about some of the good ways to do that in the next few posts.
Dean and I are finally getting to the point where we can look ahead. We started a Decade Ahead online class in January of 2020, and gosh, for some reason, our crystal ball broke.
Now, three years later, we are cautiously wandering into the breach. We’ve started the Decade Ahead class, and are offering 30% off on it for the next few days. Here’s the link. To get your 30% off, put this coupon code in when you’re checking out: Flash30.
Speaking of changes we’re making, we finally have a good, searchable website for all of our classes. Check that out here.
We’re making a lot of changes in 2023, but one thing that won’t change is this weekly blog. It remains reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynrusch to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: Amazon Year in Review Part 5,” copyright © 2022 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © Can Stock Photo / artursz.
Eleven-year-old Christopher always spends Christmas alone. This year, he plans to change that. This year, he’ll find a way to make his parents stay home. Everyone tells him he’ll ruin Christmas, but he doesn’t care. He wants a good Christmas, and he’ll do anything to get it.
A classic Christmas story that first appeared in Boys’ Life Magazine.
“Christopher’s Crummy Christmas,” by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook through various online retailers here.
Christopher’s Crummy ChristmasKristine Kathryn RuschChristopher swung off the snowmobile, stepping onto hard-packed snow. Mrs. Svenson looked down at him. Snow dusted her eyebrows. Blonde hair curled out from under her cap.
“Sure you don’t want me to talk to your folks? she asked.
Christopher shook his head. She asked every year, and every year he said no. When he was little, he used to cry. Now the 11-year-old told himself he was too old for that.
Mrs. Svenson smiled. “Then I’ll see you tomorrow.”
He nodded. She always had students over to her house on Christmas morning. The parents liked it because they could sleep late after months of hard work.
She drove off. He was glad she didn’t say “Merry Christmas!” It always seemed wasted on him.
Taking a deep lungful of cold Christmas Eve air, he stared at his home.
Snow rested on its shingles like icing on a gingerbread house. Tiny flickering lights decorated the windows. Ornaments hung from the evergreen trees. Statues of Rudolph and the reindeer gang stood on the lawn. Along with the snow, all this stayed year-round.
The house was dark inside. Christopher’s father worked all night every Christmas Eve. When he finally returned to the North Pole the next day, he was tired, and slept for 24 hours.
His family opened their Christmas presents a day late, and it was just not the same. His dad’s heart never seemed in it.
A shiver ran down Christopher’s back. He had promised himself that if his parents did not pick him up at school today, he would do something.
They never came, of course. Mrs. Svenson had dropped him off on her way home. So it was decided—he would break the sleigh.
He had good reason, he thought. All the other kids enjoyed Christmas on time. His dad flew around the world in that stupid magic sleigh, making every boy and girl smile on Christmas morning.
But Christopher spent every Christmas morning at his teacher’s house with elfin children. Some of the elves teased him because he was bigger than them.
Christopher turned his back to the house and walked the few yards to the compound.
Elves dutifully packed toys in sacks labeled for towns and cities on his dad’s worldwide route.
The reindeer rested nearby, soaking up the excitement. Vixen saw Christopher and jingled her bridle bells.
Born on the same day, she was the closest thing to a friend he had. They played until his father said Vixen was old enough to ride with the rest of the reindeer. She had found it an honor. But Christopher never felt more alone. Now they rarely talked.
“Merry Christmas,” Vixen called before he could turn away.
Head elf Sven Oxenjerna stopped stuffing gift-wrapped toys into a sack marked Eugene, Oregon, and waved. Christopher pretended not to see.
He went to the garage. The sleigh was inside, its white sides glistening, its silver runners shining. No one worried about the sleigh after November. It had to be ready by then, because toy-making took top priority.
When Sven had painted and polished the sleigh, Christopher had watched—and asked questions.
The sleigh, Sven told him, flew for three reasons: his father’s great want to give, the powerful will of the reindeer to travel, and the sleigh’s ability to use the unwavering belief of children from around the world. All were picked up by the sleigh’s Belief Receptor.
Christopher had known that. But he had never seen the receptor. Sven showed him the square metal box on the underbelly.
Now Christopher grabbed a screwdriver off the worktable and crawled under the sleigh. As he reached for the receptor, he thought he heard jingling bells.
“Christopher?”
Vixen! Christopher instantly slid back out and stood up.
The reindeer stood in the doorway, snow covering her back and antlers. “What are you doing?”
Christopher didn’t answer. He knew she knew from the look in her large brown eyes.
“It’s not fair to the children,” Vixen said softly.
“Don’t talk to me about fair. They get Christmas every year. I never do.”
“But you have Christmas all the time. For some kids it’s the only special time they have.”
“You don’t understand,” he huffed, and slid under the sleigh.
Bells jingled as she left.
If Vixen didn’t understand, Christopher thought, no one would.
He removed three of the Belief Receptor’s four screws—and felt magic slip through his fingers and caress his face. It made him remember his father telling of kids who dreamed of Christmas Day and smiled at the thought of presents under the tree.
Christopher had seen pictures of kids living in crumbling buildings. Kids who never got toys. Kids whose parents were gone every day instead of once a year.
He put down the screwdriver and swallowed hard.
Vixen was right. His life was so special he felt cheated when he had one bad day—instead of celebrating his 364 good days. So he would spend another Christmas alone. That was better than disappointing all the kids.
“Did I ever tell you why I deliver gifts?”
His father’s voice boomed in the garage. Christopher jumped. He slid out slowly, expecting to be punished.
His dad sat on the workbench, his long white beard tangled and his hair standing up in tufts. He looked sleepy, not angry.
“No.” Christopher’s hands trembled.
“Because I once received a Christmas present. Just one present. And it made me want to give something back.”
“What…what’re you going to do to me?”
“Nothing.” His father seemed almost happy. “I’ve actually been waiting for this day. If you’re going to follow in my footsteps, you need to know what giving means.”
“I know what giving means.”
His father shook his head. “Not quite. When you stopped removing the screws, you took a step toward understanding.”
Christopher tilted his head. How had his father known what he had felt? Did his father have magic too?
“Suppose I want to do something else?” Christopher asked.
“Come with me tonight, then make up your mind.”
Christopher’s heart felt like it filled his throat. His father had never invited him, and he had stopped begging years ago.
“What if I don’t want to?”
“Then I overestimated you.” His father smoothed his hair. “I’ve got work to do. Be here on time if you want to ride along.”
He left and suddenly the room felt empty. His father always dominated any space he was in.
Christopher looked at the sleigh. Ride along. Why not? It would at least make Christmas different—he would be with his father.
He took the screwdriver and slid back under the sleigh. As he carefully replaced the screws, a smile creased his face.
Christopher’s Crummy Christmas
Copyright © 2022 Kristine Kathryn Rusch
First published in Boy’s Life Magazine, December, 1989
Published by WMG Publishing
Cover and Layout copyright © 2022 by WMG Publishing
Cover art copyright © Disigner/Dreamstime
…Especially on the Recommended Reading List. I’m going to get there, but the last 2 weeks have consisted of literally cramming to get too many projects done in too little time. (Including a Diving novella for Asimov’s!) Big final project for Spanish, which included some reading that really inspired me on a few things, so more writing there. And then…well, I face-planted. You’d think after 50+ of learning about myself, I’d realize that I face-plant after one big project. But this time, three at once. Yikes! I’m just climbing out of some serious exhaustion.
Yes, I am taking care of myself, which is why I didn’t push my way through it all.
It’s also why I’ve been lax in telling you about the 30% off sale on online writing workshops that will help you with the start of the year. There are four challenge workshops you can sign up for. They keep you accountable by emailing Dean each week. If you miss on your challenge, then you get a credit for a different workshop. It’s a great deal. And you do get a reward if you succeed.
The other workshops that are on sale are collections workshops. You do a lot of writing on a particular topic, and at the end, you put together a collection of those stories and publish them. Lots of learning here.To find out more and how to use the code, go to Dean’s website. Click here. The picture of Angel above shows you her holiday mood. Her mode this holiday season is fierce. She loathes Santa Hats. She has decided they must die a horrid death. She climbed the tree yesterday, first time ever (and we had a tree last year). She’s making up for lost time, I guess. I, on the other hand, am enjoying the season, even with all the work. My Santa mug and I have so far avoided the Angel terror, and we’re getting back to work (oh, and celebrating too. I have a lot of holiday plans this week, in addition to everything else. And they must all be completed by December 24, because that’s when the tourists arrive for Vegas’s big New Year’s Eve celebration. This town celebrates the season early, because everyone goes back to work on December 24 and works hard during the next ten days. Dean and I will have groceries at the ready so we don’t have to leave. Angel is already gearing up to attack any fireworks that flare across her windows. Maybe the Santa Hats are just practice…
I started this year’s Year in Review blogs with traditional publishing partly because that Department of Justice anti-trust case produced such juicy tidbits that I couldn’t ignore them, and partly because I have always started with traditional publishing. Back in the day, I saw all of us (writers, readers, and publishers) as creatures that emerged from traditional publishing.
Now, I see a lot of writers who didn’t start in traditional and have no desire to go there. I’ve met a lot of young readers who really don’t care what the newest hottest book is. Heck, I’ve met a lot of young people who have no sense of the latest music (something that was a big deal when I was young) because they have access to all music. They can easily find their niche, and go back to Patsy Cline if that niche is country or maybe find a song by Maren Morris and have them on the same playlist.
Reading the opinion in the attempted merger of Simon & Schuster and Penguin Random House, a merger that the courts ultimately blocked, giving a big (if twenty years too late) win to the Department of Justice, made me realize just how different the various areas of publishing are now.
It also gave me a glimpse into the future, with more clarity than I think I’ve had on the entire industry maybe ever.
Last year I wrote a post in the Year in Review called “The Split.” I finally had numbers that showed just how different the traditional publishing industry was from what most places call the self-publishing industry. Self-publishing is no longer accurate, as we’ll see below, and I’m not sure it’s ever been accurate. It’s more of an indie publishing industry. Some writers do publish their own work, but others have created large businesses that publish the work of many writers.
I wrote a second Year in Review post in 2021 about the splits in indie publishing, and I still stand by that analysis. In that post, I identified five different areas of the part of publishing I’m calling indie. (I still haven’t found a good name for it all. Neither, it seems, has anyone else.)
While I separated them into five areas last year, I’m only going to explore four areas this year. They are:
Last year, this analysis of the publishing industry seemed pretty thorough to me, although I knew I was missing something. Then, throughout the year, I looked at writer after writer after writer who refused to believe the information coming out at the S&S/PRH/DOJ trial, and continued to move forward into traditional publishing, no matter what. I couldn’t see what drove the writers there, except for old-fashioned beliefs.
I think those old-fashioned and engrained beliefs are there. But those writers were seeing something that I had missed.
They were seeing the “top-selling books” market. I analyzed that a bit in the previous year-in-review post, the one about bestsellers. The DOJ, in making its case against the merger, isolated this market for me, and made me understand that it will always be with us.
Writers, particularly writers without any business acumen or future vision, will always try to get into this market. I hate calling it “top-selling books” because that’s not accurate at all. (See that bestseller post.) I’m not even sure there’s a good label for this category.
Books That Get A Big Traditional Advance? Books That Get Special Traditional Treatment? Books Traditional Publishing Has High Hopes For?
Let’s skip the label, since it’s so hard to make an accurate one, and go with the definition from the opinion in the S&S/PRH/DOJ case.
These are books that get advances of $250,000 and above. From pages 34-35, those books “are expected to sell well, are more likely to include favorable terms like higher royalty rates, higher levels of marketing support, ‘glam’ packages (e.g., for hair, makeup, and wardrobe services), and airfare for authors.” Further:
Publishers print more of the books they think will do well; circulate more advance copies of such books to reviewers or influencers to create excitement; push for interviews with more media outlets; and schedule book-tour appearances in more locations….Anticipated top-selling books get more attention from marketing and sales teams.
All of this I knew, of course. I’d seen it. I’d benefitted from some of it (although not a glam package, thank heavens). I also know how worthless most of this is in 2022. The “top-selling” market isn’t top-selling anymore. The numbers have gone way down.
But if a writer consumes a lot of traditional media and looks at the traditional promotions in brick-and-mortar bookstores as well as those rotating ads on the online book retailers, then they’ll see certain books get promoted time and time again.
I always assumed that those writers didn’t know that there were other better ways to get their books to readers. I thought those writers were ignorant. I still think many writers who go into traditional publishing are ignorant, willfully so.
But there’s another category of writer that I was having trouble accepting. I missed the writers who have different goals than I do. The DOJ defines these writers as “distinct sellers.” There are three points to that definition and two are more or less irrelevant to our examination here. (Those points are based on the idea that self-publishing is ineffective because writers can’t pay themselves an advance or market their books properly. Not kidding. See this post.)
I had missed that these writers have different goals than I do. The goal that caught me was the one described on page 33 of the opinion.
…authors of anticipated top-selling books…(1) care more about their publishers’ reputation and services, which ensure wider distribution of their books…
To which we can add “in the old-fashioned traditional media and marketplace.”
If it’s really important for a writer to get the full 1970s star author treatment, however reduced it is in 2022, then that writer will always go to traditional publishing, or more specifically here in the U.S., to the Big 5.
Think of it this way: The Big 5 have become network television. Once upon a time in the U.S., we had three TV networks. In the 1970s, top shows on one of those three networks could get an average of 20 million households watching every single week. (A household was generally considered to be four people, which meant that the viewership was around 80 million people at a time when the U.S. population was around 203 million people.)
Now, almost no TV show on the networks gets anywhere close to that number. Only Sunday Night Football (American football, you non-U.S. residents) gets around 20 million viewers on a weekly basis, and that’s because sporting events aren’t that much fun to watch after the fact. Twenty million viewers at a time when the population of the U.S. is officially 329 million. So, if you go by percentage of potential audience, viewership of a highly successful network TV show has gone from capturing 39% of the population to capturing 6% of the population.
If you look at how the numbers for TV viewership changed in the 1970s, you can see a parallel with book publishing. In 1970, only 4.5 million people had any access at all to cable TV. By the end of the decade, 15.5 million people had access to cable TV. The programming was nascent and not all that great. My parents subscribed to HBO in its early years, and it consisted mostly of a handful of movies, some relatively new, on a repeat schedule throughout the month. In fact, my folks let the subscription go because the price was too high for the content.
These days, network television still has a bit of prestige. It’s still advertising driven and it’s always looking for market share. But almost no one has a TV that’s set up on network only. Most people have streaming services. The number of people with cable is down, because they have to buy packages that includes channels they don’t want, so a lot of folks are cord-cutting.
As far as content is concerned, TV is in a new golden age. There’s a lot of great programming out there, and not all of what’s airing here in the U.S. and on streaming services is U.S. based. (Think Squid Game and Money Heist, among others.)
But there is more content now than anyone can watch, even if they watch in some form of triple speed 24 hours per day, seven days per week. This is a good thing, in my not-so-humble opinion. Very different from the world I grew up in.
(For my sins the other day, I was trying to remember [without looking anything up] the lyrics to the theme song for Green Acres. I hated that show with a burning hot passion, but my mother loved it, so the family TV was always tuned to CBS on Tuesday nights, which meant no one could watch anything else for that half hour or more.)
Network television still has some cachet, but not as much as it had even ten years ago. Lately, snide sideways comments have crept into the mainstream. Network TV is for “old people” or for people who are “out of touch.” The age thing is true: most of the viewers of network TV are older, just like most cable subscribers are older. From a pretty fascinating article on this year’s upfronts (the sales pitches to advertisers for next year’s shows) comes this nugget:
Tubi, Fox Corp.’s free, ad-supported streamer, promises advertisers a median age of 39 years, while viewers watching CBS programming on Paramount+ are 18 years younger than viewers on linear TV on average, per CBS CEO and president George Cheeks.
I’m pretty sure that cachet for network will disappear in the next few years, as all of the network channels now promote their in-house streaming service, and those services are attracting younger viewers. Surveys that I’m not going to take the time to find (but you can, especially if you look at The Hollywood Reporter online) show that younger viewers don’t care what service they stream from, so long as they’re not putting out a lot of money for a variety of streaming services.
My comparison to TV isn’t random. The Big 3 market share has been disrupted for fifty years. The Big 3 channels are still there, a shadow of their former selves, but they continue to play the same game. They market to advertisers, play in the traditional media, and even have some of the same programming they had in 1970. (The Today Show, anyone?)
As recently as ten years ago, I had producers contact me to option my work and assure me that they would make sure that they would approach the Big 3 networks first. I’m sure no one makes that claim any more, since those networks now get only 25% of monthly TV viewing hours (which is how viewership is measured now).
If you make the corollary between the Big 3 TV networks and the Big 5 publishers, you’ll see the future trajectory of “top-selling books.” These books will continue to travel on the same path that they did ten, twenty, and thirty years ago. The market share will get smaller and smaller, but for a while, it’ll seem like those books are the only “major” books there are.
We’re going to have the same problem that all of those TV shows are currently having—how to break through the noise and capture the attention of the reading populace. But that’s a discussion for an upcoming year in review blog post.
Discoverability is changing, just like it does every year. And some of that is trendy and some of it isn’t.
What I see for the future of the publishing industry is this: traditional will continue its not-so-slow decline. It will eventually become a tiny “top-selling” only part of the market.
Innovation will come from the indie side of the equation. Sometimes that innovation will be in the form of a blockbuster, attention-getting novel or series that breaks out of the pack and becomes a national (or international) phenomenon.
Sometimes the innovation might be a new platform or a new way to combine the actual book form with some derivative right (be that an audiobook or a homemade video or a condensed version read in 30 seconds by the author on TikTok). We’ve seen a lot of innovation in 2022, and I’ll be getting to that in the next few posts.
I’m moving off of traditional now. I actually wonder if I’ll even give traditional publishing more than a single post in 2023’s year in review. Traditional is losing its clout and knows it. What’s replacing it feels chaotic, unless you look at the history of television.
Then you know where this is all going. A lot of content, a lot of innovation, and some truly great storytelling—very little of which will be published by the Big 5. They’ll be the old-fashioned comfort food of book buying. Their writers will get the recognition they want through the old-fashioned media they admire, and little else.
The writers certainly won’t get money and they won’t retain their copyrights. But if recognition in the old system is what they want, then they might trade away everything of value to get their story to the world in the only way that those writers care about.
If the S&S/PRH/DOJ case convinced me of anything, it’s that those writers will never be this blog’s audience. I can argue with them about contract clauses and making better money and getting more readers until I’m blue in the face, and they’ll never listen, because they place more value on getting on Good Morning America to talk about their book.
Good Morning America, a show that’s been on one of the Big 3 networks (ABC) since 1975. Old media, without a lot of clout anymore.
But if that writer’s dream is to conquer the media of their childhood, then the only way to do so will be through the Big 5. If the writer can get a contract. If they’re a desirable author for those companies. And if they’re willing to sign one of those awful contracts.
Those writers will always exist. And they’ll keep the Big 5 in new books for at least ten more years. They’ll be part of the publishing industry, just like the networks are still part of the TV industry.
Those writers just won’t have the influence that they want or desire. Nor will they have the name recognition that bestselling writers had, say, in the 1980s.
Things change. Publishing has changed a lot. Traditional publishing is about to get very small, even the Big 5. They’re already fighting for every last dollar, as evidenced by all the contract terms cited in the court case, terms that claim more and more of a writer’s copyright in exchange for lower and lower advances.
But some writers won’t care about that. And they’ll jump into that market.
The rest of us will innovate and move with the new trends.
And now, this year in review will as well.
Thanks for indulging my look at the future in the year in review. My busy life schedule has just eased, so I will have time to go in-depth in a few trends that I’ve been wanting to examine closely. Those will come up in the next few blog posts.
I think the changes in the industry are really exciting, and I’ll be sharing those in the weeks ahead. But here’s my reminder:
This weekly blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynrusch to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: Tea Leaves: The Year in Review Part 4,” copyright © 2022 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog copyright © Can Stock Photo / creatista.
I’m lucky to have books and stories in the latest Storybundle. This one is on time travel. The ten books in the bundle represent many different forms of time travel, from time travel sf to time travel fantasy to time travel mystery to time travel romance. If you scan to the bottom of this post, you can learn more about each book. You have about two weeks to get the bundle. $25 for all of these, which will keep you reading through the New Year. Click here and get yours.
Speaking of time travel, one of the three topics writers could choose from in this year’s Holiday Spectacular was time travel. There are 11 holiday-themed time travel stories scattered throughout the Spectacular. It’s not too late to subscribe. You’ll get all the previous stories (in a lump) and then all the new ones, one per day. Click here to see more.
Thinking about time travel in a whole different way? Wishing you could time travel to the end of the year and not think about 2022 anymore? Well, we can help you plan for that. If you’re a writer and you want to challenge yourself in 2023, we have four formal challenges that you can sign up for. They are:
THE GREAT CHALLENGE is to write and send Dean a short story every week for 52 weeks.
NOVELLA CHALLENGE is to write and send Dean a novella every month for 12 months.
NOVEL CHALLENGE is to write and send Dean a novel every two months, and then publish the book in a paperback and send that to Dean at some point down the road.
PUBLISHING CHALLENGE is to publish one new major book every month. Major books are collections, novels, and novellas.
The cost is $600, but if you miss along the way, you get that much in workshop credit, so basically the challenge is free.
If you hit the challenge, you get your choice of any of the WMG Publishing lifetime subscriptions. That’s a great carrot to keep you going, but more than anything, what you will learn about your own writing and ability to get things out will be very valuable. Plus over the year you will have a lot of new stories and books.
We have a new searchable website so that you can find all of our workshops easily. Here’s the link to the challenge section. And here’s the link to the whole really cool site, so you can shop workshops all on your own: https://wmgworkshops.com/
And now, the promised bundle descriptions….
Here’s an excerpt from Dean’s blog. It describes all the books you’ll get:
So this bundle contains both novel length stories, but also an abundance of short stories and novella length works. There may be ten books in this StoryBundle, but there is over forty different stories. Amazing amounts of great time travel reading.
And one collection, A Speculation of Time, by bestselling writer T. Thorn Coyle that is only available in this bundle. Thorn is a master of the short form and I think you will love the stories included here. I sure do, and I am pretty picky about my time travel stories. To find out more about Thorn’s diverse work, head to www.thorncoyle.com
One of the current masters of the short form, bestselling writer Annie Reed chips in with another collection called Unexpected Aliens. Not every story is time travel, but they are all fantastic. Check out her bio for all of her awards and you can find more information about her amazing stories at https://anniereed.wordpress.com/
Bestseller Kris Austen Radcliffe included the complete Witch of the Midnight Blade series in one book for the bundle. Wow, some fantastic reading. Only someone of Kris’s skill could pull off timeline-jumping super soldiers combined with fantasy elements like the Fates. If you want a lot more about this incredible author, go to http://www.sixtalonsign.com/
Acclaimed writer Leslie Claire Walker offered and I jumped at the chance for a new collection called A Memory of Time. Very different and fascinating looks at time travel as only Leslie can do. For a lot more information about Leslie’s work, go to http://www.leslieclairewalker.com
One more addition to the large amount of stories before I get to the novels. New York Times bestselling writer Kristine Kathryn Rusch and I did a large and very fun collection of 100 of our science fiction stories. Each book had ten of her stories and ten of mine. In Colliding Worlds Volume #3, we focused the twenty on stories that included time. And I thought that would be great fun to include here as well. You can find the other volumes of the Colliding Worlds collection at www.wmgpublishinginc.com
Turning to time travel novels, Jason Koenig offered up something very powerful and different in Backtracker. You might not recognize Jason’s name because it is an open pen name of the USA Today bestselling writer Robert Jeschonek. Robert can take any topic and make you why you hadn’t thought of that. For a lot more of his work go to www.bobscribe.com
Then one of the best writers of time travel romance working today, Kathryn Kaleigh, offered this bundle a fantastic time travel novel from her Becquerel Series, Dragon’s Blood. Once you get started on Kathryn’s novels, you won’t be able to stop. Find out more about her work at www.kathrynkaleigh.com
And then in the same vein of romance and time travel, acclaimed writer Debbie Mumford offered up a short novel with a Scottish twist in Her Highland Laird. This general area of time travel is massive in scope and popularity, as Diana Gabaldon has proven. I think you will love Debbie’s short novel and can find more of her work at https://debbiemumford.com/
As both Kathryn’s and Debbie’s books do, my novel Tombstone Canyon blends romantic elements into historical places, but my book drifts away from the romance to focus more on the historical aspects of the Old West and the use of time travel. To find all the books and stories in the Thunder Mountain series, plus more of my novels and stories go to www.wmgpublishinginc.com
Finally, for yet another completely different take on time travel, New York Times bestselling writer Kristine Kathryn Rusch included her most recent Diving novel, The Chase. This tense can’t-put-down novel deals with societies in space leaving things behind in time, and the results of those decisions over sectors of space.
Frank’s Corner Bar boasts a long history. And traditions. Especially Christmas traditions.
But this year, Christmas might just hold a few surprises for everyone.
“Frank’s Corner Bar,” by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook through various online retailers here. It was first published as part of the WMG Holiday Spectacular 2020. To learn more about this year’s project, click here. “Frank’s Corner Bar” is also part of the collection Stories for the Cold of Winter, available in ebook and trade paperback here.
Frank’s Corner BarKristine Kathryn RuschThere aren’t many left—those dive bars that were staple of every neighborhood, back when men had jobs that lasted until retirement and most women of a certain class stayed home. Segregated by income, designed for locals only, with an exterior that discouraged outsiders, those bars looked as friendly to the regulars as their own living rooms.
By the time I started tending bar in the mid-eighties, the neighborhoods had become mixed and the jobs were fewer. They also didn’t last until retirement, although everyone hoped they would.
People forget the Reagan recessions now, but I remember them, because the conversations at the bar were always about job losses here and lack of money there. Those conversations always began with, “I thought I’d work there my whole life….”
Back when I had a real job that required me to look as feminine as possible, and that meant wearing a suit with a skirt, a blouse with a bowtie collar, heels and freakin’ nylons, I spent two nights a week volunteering at a suicide hotline.
The conversations there also always started with “I thought I’d work there my whole life,” and usually required me to mouth some platitude. We had a three-ring binder with possible responses, as well as battered pages covered with 800-numbers for psychiatric care, and medical care, and battered women’s shelters, and anything else that the organizers could think of, and it never felt like enough for me.
Then I lost my job in one of those company-wide hail Mary reorganizations done just before some Gordon Gekko clone swooped in and sold the whole damn thing for parts. Even before the Wall Street wannabe scooped up the company, I wasn’t sure I’d work at that job my whole life for two reasons: 1) I was a woman and I was doing a man’s job, meaning I wasn’t in the secretarial pool, but actually handling client accounts, and 2) my work was probably for-shit considering my attitude was. I was already casting about for something else to do, something that didn’t put me in black polyester all day, with a sateen bow tickling the underside of my chin.
I’d actually signed up for bartender school, a night class that met once a week, in between my suicide hotline gigs, and I’d signed up before I lost the job.
If you’d asked me why I’d signed up for the class, I’d’ve said something vague about maybe going back to college, getting another degree, and needing some kind of work to tide me over, but mostly, I was tired of pushing paper all day, tired of making the same jokes with the same people, tired of that half-assed sense I had that everything I did was pointless.
Hence the suicide hotline because, I’d thought at the time, that would be easier than volunteering at a soup kitchen (where you’d see the despair face-to-face) or doing intake at the battered women’s shelter (again, face-to-face, with the added “benefit” of wanting to punch every motherfucking asshole who’d used their fists on the women they supposedly loved). The suicide hotline was just as soul-sucking and tiring, anonymous because in those days, you couldn’t see the number that called, and we all worked our shifts alone, so there was no one to share the latest heartbreaker.
So I spent my days dealing with people I didn’t like in a setting I loathed, my nights dealing with people who spent their days with people they didn’t like in a setting they loathed, and even though I didn’t want to give up the hotline, I knew I needed something else. The bartending class was supposed to be an exploration, maybe even a hobby.
But it never got that far: I got laid off a week before the class ended, and the guy teaching it—a scrawny professorial type named Robert—knew a guy who knew a guy who wasn’t averse to hiring a female bartender instead of a cocktail waitress.
Which was how I ended up at Frank’s Corner Bar. A single story of whitewashed brick with glass brick alongside the heavy oak door. There were no windows, and maybe never had been, so it was perpetually night inside, even at eleven a.m. when the city allowed us to open. We didn’t have food, except goldfish crackers mixed with tiny pretzels and bar nuts, but when I started, we were right next door to Frank’s Italian Restaurant, and a lot of the regulars carried their drinks across the two yards of sidewalk between our front doors and settled at one of the round tables for a meatball sandwich lunch.
But now, thirty-five years later, Frank’s Corner Bar is no longer on a corner, and Frank isn’t even a distant memory. I’d never met the guy: he’d died twenty years before I started. The Italian restaurant became a mismanaged burger joint, then a mismanaged pizza joint, and finally became a defeated-looking empty lot, surrounded by a half-caved-in mesh fence.
Eighteenth Street remains as the frontage road for the new freeway, which isn’t new since they built it fifteen years ago, but all of us here at Frank’s call it new, because that’s how we roll. The side street, Mannan Avenue, got paved over and then became a built-up barrier to prevent the freeway traffic from bumping over to the frontage road from the off-ramp.
We’re a little island of past glory, a paid-for fuck-you to eminent domain that had stopped at our very doorstep.
The guy who owned the bar then, Frank’s godson Darryl, knew someone who knew someone who knew someone in City Planning who liked to have his pocket greased, and all of them believed it was a great plan to keep Frank’s Corner Bar on the no-longer-existent corner, serving a neighborhood that had gotten sliced up and sold for parts.
That we still had customers was more of a tribute to the off-ramp than it was to the no-longer-existent neighborhood. There were still enough people out there who didn’t want to go home at the end of a long workday, but also didn’t want to hang out in some Millennial bar playing trivia contests or staring at their phones in the company of other people staring at their phones.
No one who came to Frank’s had friends enough or family enough or a job important enough to require phone staring. And most everyone at Frank’s had never gotten into the habit of using the phones for anything but calls.
Frank’s itself didn’t have a dozen large-screen TVs scattered around the interior, because one was enough to get the regulars to at least talk to each other about which channel we should have on mute—and no, it never was one of the cable-TV talk-news channels, because those damn things were the only things that made the regulars fight.
Most of the regulars actually do have homes, with a spouse or a partner or someone who ostensibly waited on dinner for them. But there are a dozen or more who only have a place with their own TV and a bed to rest after a weary night of drinking.
I had a combination of both—an actual house miles from here, but no someone inside. Not even a cat.
I own Frank’s now. I got the place when Darryl veered off the new freeway overpass and didn’t survive the landing. The cops called it an accident, and maybe it was, but me, the woman who’d tended bar for more than thirty years and who had once worked at a suicide hotline, I wasn’t so sure that the veering was accidental, given Darryl’s state of mind during the six months before.
He didn’t like Frank’s Corner Bar anymore, especially since there was no neighborhood and no corner, and he told me, in one of those after-hour drinking sessions that all bartenders are prone to, that the world never did pretty itself up for him. He never got the wife or the dream job or even out of the damn neighborhood.
The neighborhood left him, which he thought was just plain unnatural.
I tried to tell him it wasn’t. My college degree—lo all those decades ago—was in Urban Planning, and the so-called post-college dream job was in a firm that specialized in neighborhood improvement (but really ended up being in the pocket of large real estate firms). Anyway, I learned, back in the day, that neighborhoods had a pattern—a few decades of growth, followed by a few stable decades, leading to decades of decline. If the neighborhood was lucky, it got rediscovered and then the cycle started again, but sometimes, the neighborhood got unlucky, like ours, and “progress” in the guise of a freeway, for example, meant the neighborhood would never come back.
And it certainly wouldn’t come back in a form any of us recognized, even if it did return.
We all get maybe twenty years of being in the catbird seat, I said to him, not just in our careers or even in our relationships, but in the areas we lived in too.
He squinched at me like he didn’t like hearing any of that, but he made no real comment.
Except maybe that veer off the overpass. Because even though that conversation wasn’t the last conversation we ever had, it was the last real conversation we ever had. And when I got the deed for Frank’s from Darryl’s will, along with his worldly possessions and his not-inconsiderable savings, I also got a letter that said sometimes being able to see patterns wasn’t really a gift; it was a curse.
The lawyer—the son of one of the regulars—thought that statement was some kind of Zen koan, but I knew it for what it was: Darryl’s response to that conversation. I think he had hoped, up until the moment of our discussion, that the neighborhood would magically return, and something I said, with all my vaunted logic, made him realize that even if the neighborhood did magically return, it wouldn’t be a neighborhood that liked or recognized Frank’s Corner Bar.
The thing is, Frank’s wasn’t dying. It wasn’t making anyone rich, but it was earning enough to keep a single owner comfortable. The nearly forgotten Frank had bought the land and paid off the building before he died, and Darryl left the entire place unencumbered, even after the big remodel of 1987 when he tried (mistakenly) to remake the interior into a fern bar before the regulars staged a revolt.
Even with the disappearance of the neighborhood and those folks who stopped for a cold one on the way home to the family from their guaranteed (but dull) job, even though we didn’t cater to trends, and we really didn’t have anything by way of specials, we still had regulars.
Some loved the throwback quiet of the place. Others had been coming longer than I’d been tending bar. And a small handful staked out their territory like Frank’s was their actual home.
Maybe it was.
It sure as hell was mine, more than that empty house.
But Darryl’s demise had made me restless, only not in a way I recognized. Mostly, I did fine as day turned into night, weeks into months, months into years.
It was the holidays that got me, every damn time.
We actually changed the interior of the bar during the holidays. We strung some colored lights around the back bar, even framed the TV with little white blinkers that made Marge (whose favorite perch was one seat over) a little more crazy than usual.
We put a wreath on the door. I bought the wreath every year, usually from some civic organization, a tradition I started my first year tending bar, back when I was still nervously trying to follow the recipes I’d learned in bartender school rather than listen to Darryl about the fact that late-at-night drinkers (the actual drunks) wouldn’t notice if their booze had a tad more water than alcohol just before closing.
I learned about the God of Pour Counts in those years, but I was still young enough and naïve enough to think that maybe folks wanted just a bit of holiday spirit in the place. We never got a tree, although Stenny, another of the regulars, argued for it for a while. But we had the lights, and an eggnog drink special that (to me) tasted like curdled piss.
On Christmas Eve, the bartenders wore Santa hats and the cocktail waitresses wore pointed ears that matched the point of their V-neck winter dresses (only in the opposite direction, of course). One year, Darryl flirted with the idea of having them wear mistletoe, but that lasted two whole days before we all decided the experiment was a grim failure.
It was enough to remind me that yet another year was passing. The holiday season was the only time that actual time showed up at Frank’s Corner Bar. Usually, the dark and the sameness made each day just like the day before.
And then there was Darryl.
I tried not to think about Darryl, although I heard his voice every holiday season. Maybe we get rid of the lights this year, finally, he’d say in my head like he used to say in real life. Maybe we don’t pretend we’re cheery or even charitable. Maybe we don’t buy a wreath.
But I kinda liked the traditions, even if they made me feel the passage of time. My mirror was telling me every day that I wasn’t that perky damn-near-thirty-something, freshly graduated from the school of hard knocks. I looked like someone had glued my father’s tough-guy features onto my mother’s narrow face. My short-cropped hair had some salt with its pepper now, and the salt had even moved to my eyebrows, making part of them disappear.
But when I wasn’t looking in that mirror, I could still imagine myself as that thirty-something searching for something new. And if I could close my eyes, I could damn near touch her, and feel the edges of the hope that drove her to enter this place, still clutching the worthless certificate from that bartending class and thinking maybe, just maybe, she could earn a few dollars here while finding something better in the world beyond.
She never searched the world beyond. And she made more than a few dollars. The conversations were different in those days, and the rhythm of the days suited her.
Gradually, she got subsumed by me, and I’m not even sure how it happened.
But every Christmas, as I strung up the lights at 10:30 am in the goddamn morning on December 1st, just like I’d done every year for the previous twenty-eight (we did something different during that ill-advised fern bar phase), I mentally marked the changes. I looked backwards. I saw the opportunities that had zipped by. I remembered the discussions about eminent domain, what we’d all do when Frank’s vanished, how we’d feed our customers when Frank’s Italian Restaurant closed, then when the burger joint closed, and then when the pizza place closed.
I remembered when Darryl taught me how to make the eggnog pisswater, and me saying, People drink this shit? And his grin and shrug when he said, People love this shit.
They did. They do. They love that shit. And the lights, and the wreath, especially if it’s different from the year before.
They love every last bit of the holiday here at Frank’s because it’s less of a holiday and more of a decoration.
I’m the only one who gets grouchier as the season progresses. Some of the regulars, they just ignore the whole thing. The lights are as invisible to them as the booze on the back wall.
Some of the other regulars, they get maudlin, telling anyone who’ll listen some sad holiday tale. Everyone else—they tend to get quieter during the season, or scarcer—because they have family obligations most like, or because they have to go to the office Christmas party, and do a dozen other year-end things.
Two years after Darryl designed his own personal off-ramp, I found myself daydreaming about shutting down Frank’s. I really couldn’t sell it. We’d had it appraised for the will, and the land, with nothing around it, was worth a fraction of what Frank had paid for it fifty years before.
An island on a frontage road, surrounded by empty lots, was worth nearly nothing. The building itself had some value, which surprised me, and the business even more, only because it was a stable concern, but even if I managed to find some sucker to take it off my hands, I wouldn’t have enough to live on, or enough to invest, not for the rest of my days.
I’d have to go back to tending bar and do it for someone else.
When you’re sliding into your sixties, no matter how strong you are or how tough you look, you’re thinking about the end of the road. Not creating your own end, like Darryl, but maybe wondering how it’ll all pan out.
For me, the only family I got is here, among a bunch of regulars whom I only know in the brownish-yellow light from the fake stained-glass shades that still top the booths—the only real remnant of that fern bar phase.
I worked Thanksgiving Day, Christmas Eve, and Christmas Day, in exchange for my two backup bartenders having to staff the place on the two Amateur Nights in the holiday season: New Year’s Eve and St. Patrick’s Day—the only celebrations that resulted in more puke than a homemade pie-eating contest outdoors in 100-degree heat.
Christmas Eve had its own rhythm, one I recognized after decades. Most of the regulars crammed in earlier than their usual time, had a cup of good cheer—usually the eggnog pisswater—wished me a happy holiday, and vanished to whatever celebration (or non-celebration) awaited them.
One or two brought me something, some kind of token. The occasional ever-hopeful guy would bring me winter flowers, red and white carnations, usually, like we were going to a winter dance. Some of the older men would bring me gifts too, just because (I think) they needed to give something to someone female to keep up a habit started with a long-gone spouse or lover.
By eight, most of the regulars had cleared out, leaving only the ones with nowhere to go. At midnight, I would serve a hot toddy, made with some special imported (expensive) rum I bought for the occasion every year. A handful of the regulars waved off the rum, and one or two always wanted an Irish coffee or something that would wake them up enough for the drive home.
I’d clear them out an hour before normal closing, saying Santa needed her beauty sleep, and then I’d lock up.
That year, I’d locked the doors, and turned down all the lights in the front, before going to the back. Most of the back was taken up by a large cooler—apparently someone once thought we’d be a restaurant too—and an even larger storage room that Darryl had added. The storage room bugged me because he built half of it over a wall safe and the electrical panel, which I had to pay to move.
We also had three microwaves back here (and one out front), as well as a narrow stove that looked like someone had dragged it from a studio apartment more than fifty years ago. At least the sink was big, and the dishwasher bigger, and there was an ice machine that was larger than both of them combined.
I avoided all of that and opened the tiny closet I occasionally used as a bedroom when I didn’t trust my Subaru to get me home. The closet had a good overhead light, a single bed with a pile of blankets, and an end table that always had whatever book I needed for distraction. That afternoon, I had brought two changes of clothes because I knew I’d be camping at Frank’s instead of going home.
The weather gods had given us rain for Christmas, which wasn’t that unusual, but what was unusual was an arctic cold front with killer temperatures that was supposed to arrive at four a.m. or so. The weather gods’ minions told us to expect a slick crossover between rain and the deep freeze, and to plan for the worst kind of black ice.
In fact, one of the minions said, the entire city would become a skating rink.
I’d been of two minds when I first heard that forecast. Part of me thought maybe I’d close Frank’s early on Christmas Eve, send everyone home, and stay shut until the storm passed.
But I kept envisioning those four or five regulars with nowhere else to go, the ones who risked their lives just to sit in a place that gave them a modicum of comfort on a holiday that for them exacerbated their loneliness, showing up and finding a locked door, something that had never happened on Christmas as long as I’d been working here.
I had no idea what those regulars would do. Would they camp out, hoping I’d show up? Would they get back in their cars and brave the black ice to find another port in the storm?
Would they accidentally—or not-so-accidentally—create their own off-ramp on one of the roads between here and their homes?
I’d feel responsible if something like that happened.
So I was the one who camped out. I bought myself the usual holiday turkey dinner from the local grocery store, and stored the dinner in the cooler. I’d microwave my festive food about an hour before opening, and then have snacks for the rest of the day.
I even grabbed some crudités, baked goods, and bags of chips for that day, figuring the weather would be too bad for someone—anyone—to sneak out and try to find food somewhere in this non-existent neighborhood.
The generators were primed and ready to back us up if ice froze the lines. I had enough piss-nog to last the day before I threw that crap out until next year.
I was ready.
I got to sleep around three, woke up at eight as ice pellets slammed into the empty-lot side of the whitewashed brick. It sounded like a herd of kids continually throwing gravel at the side of the building, and then the rat-a-tat-tat escalated into what I imagined continual gunfire would sound like.
I sat up, checked the lights, happy to see they had their brown-yellow glow. If the generators had come on, the lights would’ve been more brown than yellow.
The only good thing about this so-called neighborhood was that we weren’t far from what was becoming the medical district, and a few years ago the city council made sure we were a high priority zip code for outage replacement.
Before that, we’d been one of the neighborhoods that maybe came back on days after the storm responsible had traveled the length of the country and headed out to sea.
I got off the cot, folded the blankets, cleaned up, slipped into real clothes, and finger-combed my hair. The only problem with sleeping here was the lack of shower. City regs did not allow me to put one in, not even for me or my team. I’d also brought towels and washcloths for sponge bathing, and it was good enough to get me through the next few days, but by December 27, I’d be feeling pretty self-conscious if I wasn’t able to get back home.
The weather minions said the storm would be long gone by then, but I wasn’t sure I believed them. So I wrapped myself in my ancient puffy coat, which smelled terrifyingly of old beer and sweat, and peered into the alley.
The sky wasn’t gray. It was gray-green-black, the kind of coloring I usually associated with severe thunderstorms in the summer, not with ice storms in the winter.
The air had a biting chill that was painful almost immediately, and I knew without looking at some dumb weather app that the cold snap wasn’t cold by the usual definition. The cold snap was are you fucking kidding me cold, the kind that we rarely got in these parts.
I pulled the metal door closed and locked it, then hung the puffy coat back on its peg. I microwaved my turkey dinner for breakfast, and didn’t like the itch I felt as I ate it.
The let’s shut down Frank’s thoughts were legion that morning. More than they’d been all season, as if from the moment I put up the lights to the moment I microwaved my festive food, I’d been storing up momentum.
If I sold Frank’s or just shut its doors, I had no idea what I’d do next. I was too young to sit on my ass for the rest of my life. If I even tried that, I’d end up like my regulars, hanging out at a bar, nursing a drink, and wondering why I’d made the choices I had.
I had no real interest in school or another career, and that damn suicide hotline (which ultimately merged with some texting service) had cured me of volunteerism forever.
I was stuck with Frank’s and it was stuck with me, and I was fine with that eleven months of the year. Maybe next year, I just wouldn’t hang the colored lights and I’d get rid of the piss-nog, and blow up what passed for tradition in all that remained of Frank and Darryl’s neighborhood.
By 10:30, the remaining turkey was sliced and in the cooler, cooling. The potatoes were covered, the bread was on one of the side counters waiting for me to snack on it, the stuffing was already in the garbage where that crap belonged, and the orange-cranberry concoction was in my hand, where I kept shifting it over the sideboard to the garbage in my indecisiveness. On the one hand, the concoction was sweet. On the other, it was sour. And I wasn’t sure I liked it.
Finally, I decided to decide later, which meant the sideboard, next to the pile of cookies I’d bought just for me to get me through the day.
I’d already put on coffee behind the bar, and the entire front room smelled like morning to me—a faint hint of cigarettes we could never get out of the place no matter how hard we tried, a bit of alcohol, the never-ending overlay of stale beer all mixed with freshly brewed coffee. The coffee part of the smell would fade by midafternoon most days, but not today.
I figured anyone who managed to find Frank’s in this storm would want coffee first thing. And maybe as the only thing.
I flicked on the lights—not that it made a difference outside the building because you couldn’t see them—and unlocked the front door, opening it for good measure in case some poor soul had arrived early.
No one had, but the sidewalk that used to run to Frank’s Italian glistened in an ominous way. The freeway to my left was nearly empty. The cars that passed by weren’t speeding. They were picking their way along the road like an old guy trying to negotiate steep stairs.
I stood for a moment in the unguarded cold, not yet shivering, realizing there was a good chance I’d spend the entire day alone in an empty bar, because no one could get here.
I was okay with that—at least at that moment. I wasn’t sure how I would feel after hours by myself, with only Christmas movies on the TV and a long empty bar staring at me accusingly.
I tried to shut the door, which was easier to say than it was to do. A wind had come up, a vicious one, with an actual kick. The door didn’t like wind now that we were all alone on our nonexistent corner, but that was usually a problem for the summer, not for the winter.
Still, I had to put my back into it just to get the door closed, and I knew that would be a problem if one of the older regulars managed to find their way here.
And it turned out it was a problem, because the first person inside the bar that dark and dreary morning was Stella. I always figured she’d been a looker in her day, but her style was stuck in her high school years which, if her beehive was any indication, ended somewhere around 1966.
That morning, the beehive was more like a crow’s nest, glistening with ice chunks. Not even the mountains of hairspray she poured on that thing had held the strands in place. Her mascara was running too, which was a shame, because it looked like the mascara was bleeding onto some red, green, and gold stars she’d put on her cheeks just for the holiday.
She waved at me as she came in and fled to the ladies room to see if she could repair the damage, leaving me to wrestle with the wind and the door.
I’d just about gotten it closed when Diamond Jim yelled, “Hey!” from half a block away.
Diamond Jim was half the man he used to be. I knew that because I remembered meeting him in the 1980s, when he was an absolute mountain. Tall, barrel-chested, flamboyant. His hats were legion, and so large that I always knew any hat left behind was his, not because of the style (which varied) but because of the size.
He picked his way across the sidewalk from the parking lot, barely able to stay stable in the wind. He braced one bare hand on the brick wall to keep himself from falling, but I was still holding my breath as I watched him walk.
I held the door, and resisted the urge to extend a hand to him. I didn’t want to unbalance him. He reached the door, grabbed its edge, and then worked his way around me.
His thinning gray hair was windblown, revealing just a bit of pink scalp. That was when I realized he wasn’t wearing a hat, something I’d never seen.
“You lose your hat?” I asked, not relishing the idea of scurrying out into the wind and sleet to find it.
“Didn’t wear one,” he said. “Don’t have one of them stocking things.”
He made it sound like stocking caps were something evil. He staggered the rest of the way inside, and then sank into a nearby chair. He gripped his right wrist with his left hand.
His upraised fingertips looked white on the edges and red all around the little white circles.
I pulled the door closed, then went to the bar and grabbed a bowl. I filled it with warm water, slung a clean bar rag over my arm, and walked over to Diamond Jim.
“You stick your fingers in that,” I said, and set the bar rag down beside him. I’d known Diamond Jim long enough to know that he would have complained about the water and having nothing to clean up with.
The man was precise and fastidious and still was the most stylish dresser I’d ever seen. Even dressed down for today, he wore thick wool pants with a perfectly pressed crease down the center, black shoes that had probably been perfectly polished when he put them on, and a bone white-sweater that looked like it had come out of a men’s fashion magazine.
He slid up the right sleeve, gave me a look, probably saw that I wasn’t going to change my mind, then plunged his fingers into the water. He loudly sucked in a breath.
“Frostbite happens fast,” I said, and went back to the bar. I poured him a cup of coffee, found the creamer that I kept in the little bar fridge just for him, and brought them both to the table as well.
He didn’t say anything more, but his cheeks were bright red. Whether that was from pain or cold, I couldn’t tell.
Then a door banged. Stella had found her way out of the lady’s room, mascara repaired and the multicolored stars looking festive. Her beehive was perfect again. The scent of hairspray wafted over to me, and my eyes watered. I had no idea what the ladies room smelled like, but I hoped no one would light a match in there. I had a hunch the entire thing would erupt into flames.
She looked at both of us for a moment, as if she couldn’t decide what to do. Normally, she would have gone to the far edge of the bar, where she could see the TV best, and she could watch the door. Stella had two modes: she was either garrulous or she was so quiet no one noticed her, except me of course.
Apparently, that day, she was between modes. She didn’t say anything as she approached us. Then she pulled out the chair near Diamond Jim, and sat down. She took his right wrist and slowly pulled his fingers out of the water.
“What the hell did you do?” she asked.
He looked at me, eyebrows up in surprise. Both of us had known Stella for decades and neither of us had seen her act like this before.
“He was using the side of the building for balance,” I said to her.
“No gloves,” she said to him. “Really? On a day like this?”
I hadn’t seen her pulling off gloves either, but she might have done it as she stepped inside. My gaze had gone to the ruined beehive.
“You want something?” I asked.
“The usual,” she said. She put Diamond Jim’s hand flat on her palm and was investigating the fingertips. After a minute, she said with surprise, “You’re gonna be okay.”
“What’re you now, some kinda nurse?” he asked gruffly.
Attention from women made him uncomfortable. Diamond Jim never married. Darryl told me, decades ago, that Diamond Jim had asked the prettiest girl in the city to marry him, and she had turned him down. He’d dedicated his life to making her regret the decision, acquiring the money and prestige he’d lacked when she turned him down, and then she died, and all of his forward momentum stopped, as if he had nothing left to live for, nothing more to power him.
He’d become the man I met, who still dressed stylishly, but always seemed to have a deep well of sorrow at his heart.
I got Stella her first white wine spritzer of the day—she liked to believe she wasn’t a drinker and the white wine spritzer proved it, but I’d never seen anyone pack as many of those away daily as she did.
The door rattled, and I realized that the rattle wasn’t from the wind. I opened the door without even seeing who was behind it, and a bent-over person stumbled in, wrapped in a plaid cloth coat pulled over their head.
I didn’t recognize the coat, and when the person wearing it pulled the coat down around their shoulders, I didn’t recognize the person either.
She was young, maybe thirty, and she had a bruise that ran from her left ear to her jaw. The bruise was just beginning to swell.
I’d learned never to ask about bruises if I didn’t want to know the answer. I also learned not to guess about them either.
“Thank God you’re open,” she said.
She pulled off a pair of gloves and set them on the table beside her. Then she ran her fingers through her short brown hair, and ice pellets dropped off it onto her coat.
“Jesus,” she said, “you’re a dreary lot.”
Diamond Jim sat up straight, grabbing the bar rag to wipe of his hand. “It’s 11:30 on Christmas morning, and you’re in a bar. What the hell did you expect?”
I didn’t think I’d ever heard such bite from him. Diamond Jim was usually polite and charming, even when he was unhappy.
The woman tilted her head just a little. “Point taken. I’d forgotten it was the holiday. That explains a lot.”
There was a moment of silence. I debated asking what it explained, but decided I didn’t care. Diamond Jim wiped his hand again with the bar rag. He seemed more on edge than I was used to.
Finally, Stella spoke. “Explains what?” she asked.
“Everything’s closed,” the woman said. “Here I was thinking it was the storm.”
There was no everything around here. Just us, and the medical district a mile away, and the freeway, humming with traffic—on a good day anyway.
She looked over at me. There were crow’s feet around her eyes, which surprised me. I had to revise her age upward about a decade.
“What do you got to drink around here?” she asked.
“It’s a damn bar,” Diamond Jim said, looking at his hand. “Just order something.”
I’d never seen anyone rub him the wrong way before, but this woman clearly did.
“I’ll just take a water,” she said.
“I’ll pay for it if that’s the problem,” Diamond Jim said.
She tilted her head again, measuring him. Then she half-stood out of the chair and reached into the pocket of her ugly plaid coat. It was blue and green with yellow stripes, colors I hadn’t seen together since my childhood.
I expected her to pull out a single or two. Instead, she had a wad of cash, held together by a rubber band.
Stella’s gaze met mine, and Stella’s eyebrows went up, which was a sight to behold since, unlike me or Diamond Jim, Stella outlined her brows with black pencil.
“You break a hundred?” the woman asked.
“Sure,” I said. “What do you really want?”
“I really want a bottle of water,” the woman said. “I’m not sure about tap quality in an area like this.”
Diamond Jim’s lips thinned, but she actually had a point. I wouldn’t drink water from the tap either, unless it had been disinfected with some kind of alcohol.
I took one of the hundreds from her roll, the bill crisp and suspiciously new. I opened the small bar fridge and removed one of the Aquafina bottles the Coke rep kept foisting on me.
I handed her the bottle, said, “I’ll get your change,” and hauled the bill to the back.
I held the bill up to one of the under-the-counter lights, checked the hologram of the face, saw Ben Franklin in the lined-up images, but I checked the watermark anyway, because I’d seen some good counterfeit bills in my day. The watermark was on both sides of the bill. If someone had gone to the trouble of stealing currency paper, then fuck ’em. They deserved the ninety-plus dollars I was about to give her in change.
I brought her change back and set it on the table next to her gloves. She was sipping from the bottle as if it were a wine glass as dainty as the one Stella was holding.
Stella, who hadn’t yet asked me for another drink. Unusual in and of itself.
The woman’s energy added something uneasy and strange to the day. Or maybe it was the storm outside. Or Diamond Jim’s mood.
I had been hoping for something passingly festive, an acknowledgement of the holiday, maybe a drunken carol or two around dinner, maybe a really good, really long off-color joke that made us all guffaw.
But none of that seemed possible.
Diamond Jim picked up the bowl of water and brought it to the bar, along with the bar rag. He sat down in his usual spot and ordered a Coors Light—the only cheap thing about him.
“TV’s off,” he said to me.
“You really want to watch A Christmas Story for the thousandth time?” I asked.
He grinned, but the grin didn’t go to his eyes. “Why the hell not?”
I sure as hell didn’t. So I turned on the TV, but found a regular season NBA game featuring two teams I didn’t give a rat’s ass about. Still, moving bodies gliding across a court in front of fans wearing Christmas tree lights around their necks was a lot better than pretending little Ralphie Parker’s quest for a BB gun from Santa was something normal and not All-American weird.
Diamond Jim settled into the game, his left hand around can of Coors, the actual beer glass I’d poured the beer in only a few inches from his right. Stella had made her way to her usual spot at the bar, and I put another spritzer in front of her, with just a drop of red food coloring so the entire thing was a slightly festive pink.
The new woman hadn’t moved. She just sat in her chair, pushing her gloves around, nursing the water bottle as if it were the best drink she’d ever had.
Long about one, the wind whipped up so bad that the entire building moaned. The moan usually happened during summer thunderstorms, and a handful of the regulars claimed to like the sound, but none of those regulars were here.
When the wind kicked up to that level—and that had to be thirty to forty miles an hour sustained—I figured this group was it. No one else was going to venture out.
But just as I had that thought, two more people blew in through the door—literally blew in. Jefferson McKnight—whom we called the Professor because he had at least three PhDs (and wasn’t afraid to brag about them) and his wife, Denisha.
Regulars usually didn’t come in couples, but these two hadn’t started as a team. They’d actually met here. Jefferson liked to joke that they had to pair up because they were the only regulars of color, a joke that always made Denisha uncomfortable, and I was never sure why. Maybe because it was accurate.
The old neighborhood—Frank and Darryl’s neighborhood—the no-longer-existent neighborhood—wasn’t that friendly to outsiders, particularly those who didn’t fit into a particularly 1950s white view of the world.
Back in the beginning, even my tending bar had been controversial. Now, no one remembered how controversial it had been. And I liked to think that no one wanted to remember back when the neighborhood actually tried to push out people like the Professor and Denisha.
The Professor tossed his wool coat across one of the booths, and Denisha set hers on the seat on the other side. I didn’t have to ask for their order: in weather like this, they wanted some peppermint schnapps mixed with hot chocolate.
They took seats in the center of the bar, but the Professor kept looking over his shoulder at the woman. Finally, he ran a hand over his perfectly shaped bald pate and mouthed, Who the hell’s that?
I shrugged, and Denisha widened her eyes, as if she couldn’t believe a stranger would show up here, today of all days.
I set their drinks in front of them. I’d added just a touch of whipped cream and two small candy canes I’d gotten with my festive dinner. They both waved the canes at me, and Denisha said, “You be careful. You’ll have the holiday spirit yet.”
“Just trying to foist the sweets off on you,” I said, and they both laughed.
I poured myself some coffee, went into the back for a minute to snag a cookie, and stopped. The air was colder here than it should have been, and that air smelled fresh, the kind of fresh that came with frigid winter storms no matter what the neighborhood.
A shiver ran through me. The back door leading into what had been the alley, and now just looked like the back entrance, was hard to open. And, through long force of habit, I kept both deadbolts locked. But I had been having trouble with the bottom deadbolt, and sometimes it didn’t catch properly.
However, if the top bolt was latched, that door would not blow open.
I sighed slightly, regretting that I didn’t have any backup today. Usually one of the regulars could act as the bouncer—not that we had needed one in oh, maybe five years.
We probably didn’t need one now. The wind was very strong and this building was very old, and maybe something broke loose—or the wind had found its own way in.
I wiped the cookie crumbs off my hands and walked around the counters to the back door. It was closed and locked tight—both deadbolts. It wasn’t even rattling in the wind. But I could still feel the chill, still smell that fresh air.
I followed my nose toward the bathroom—a single toilet and an ancient sink I needed to replace. I kept some cleaning supplies beneath it—a couple of buckets, a mop almost as old as the sink. There was a round frosted glass window above the toilet—or there had been. The glass had shattered inward, and the wind poured in along with the ice pellets.
I shouldn’t have been surprised. That window was original to the building, and flimsy as hell. I never worried about it, though, because it was high off the ground and too small for anyone to fit through.
Still, its shattering unnerved me more than I wanted to think about.
The bathroom door opened into the bathroom itself, so I just pulled the door closed. It rattled, and I could still feel a breeze against my ankles. I’d have to fix this one.
We didn’t have any plywood, but we had several hammers and an entire bucket of nails from various odd jobs. We also had a shit-ton of cardboard, much of it thick, from the boxes the liquor showed up in. I had broken a bunch of those boxes down, but I hadn’t taken the time to haul them to the recycling center. I half-grinned at the mess now. Couldn’t have been better if I’d planned for it.
I grabbed my favorite hammer from storage and a bag of large nails from inside that bucket. Then I set them on the counter, and went back out front in search of assistance.
The Professor stood behind the bar, big arms crossed. Denisha fluttered beside him, going back and forth between the bar flap and the cocktail waitress station.
It took me a moment to realize the Professor was standing in front of the cash register, blocking it from all the other customers.
Stella stood against the wall near her usual stool, fingers clenched into fists. Diamond Jim had spun his stool around so that his elbows rested on the bar top. I would have thought him relaxed, if it weren’t for the vein pulsing in his neck.
The strange woman had her right hand against her bruised cheek. She was staring, eyes wide, at a big, beefy white guy with florid skin. The pistol in his right hand was pointed down at the floor, but it was pretty clear that he wouldn’t hesitate to use it.
Denisha’s left hand was below the counter. Her gaze flickered toward me, and then she waved her fingers at me in a go away motion.
I didn’t have to be told twice. The beefy guy hadn’t seen me, so I slipped into the back, easing the door closed quietly, and punched 911 with my thumb.
For a moment, I thought the cell wasn’t going to work, then it caught, and Lordy, there were miracles, because someone picked up.
I’d called 911 so many times I wondered if they recognized my number, but usually it was for medical services—heart attacks, falls, the occasional punch in the face (that never got reported as an assault). This time was different, but I kept my voice calm as I gave our location, said, “There’s a scary man in the bar holding a gun on my customers.”
The dispatch wanted me to do something or other. I’ll never know because I hung up, slipped the phone in my pocket, and rooted around for something to disarm the asshole with.
For the first time in almost a decade, I regretted getting rid of Darryl’s under-the-bar shotgun. I never knew if he knew how to use that thing, but I’d seen him haul it out on occasion, usually when he was outnumbered after a bar fight started.
I have no idea how to use a gun—shotgun, rifle, pistol, you name it—so I got rid of the thing damn near five minutes after Darryl died.
I was pretty sure that shotgun was the reason the Professor had gone behind the bar because surely a man with that many PhDs knew better than to die for some cash in the register.
Weapons. Most of the good ones that we could use were out there, behind the bar, near the guy with the gun. Knives, soda water, hot coffee.
Hammer, nails, broken glass. That’s all I had back here. Not even a damn nail gun. Not that I would trust myself to use it. I could imagine pointing the damn nail gun at the beefy guy, wobbling a little or just plain missing, and hitting one of the regulars. (Stella, in the eye. Jesus.)
I was about to head out front again when I remembered something Darryl had told me when I started.
He had this trick. He could get a guy halfway over the bar, and then he’d grab the back of the guy’s head and shove it into the bar, holding it in place with one hand.
He’d proudly showed me that trick, saying it would work because people were not balanced when they came over the bar. We practiced and practiced, and I couldn’t do it. I didn’t have the reach to keep a guy from grabbing me in that position, and I didn’t have the arm strength to hold him in place.
So he handed me a bottle of Grand Marnier Orange Liqueur and said, You get the guy halfway across the bar, grab his neck, hold him down for a half second and hit him hard with this damn thing.
I wasn’t sure I could hit anyone with that, not then. But that was when I was new and fresh out of bartender school and I never thought of weapons in a bar or the problems an out-of-control patron caused, but since then, I’d spent years in this place and I had seen it all. I kept a bottle of Grand Marnier in the back, and I occasionally hefted it, thinking about Darryl and all of his advice.
I went back and grabbed the bottle now. It wasn’t as heavy as I remembered, even though I had just picked it up last week. I lifted it, remembered something else that Darryl had said.
Trust adrenaline. Adrenaline makes you stronger.
And dumber. That’s what I’d seen in the hundred-plus bar fights that I’d witnessed in my career. Although Darryl would’ve probably argued that the dumber came from the alcohol, not the adrenaline.
I made sure I had a tight grip on the bottle’s neck, although the damn thing felt slippery to me. My palms were sweating, even though I was slightly chilled from that air pouring in under the bathroom door.
I pushed the door between the back and the bar open just a little. Beefy guy hadn’t moved. He was screaming at the woman, who was crouching protectively in her chair, her right hand elevated, with that roll of hundreds clenched in her fist.
“You fuckin’ should’ve told me the restaurant was gone,” he said. “You should’ve fucking called.”
“I thought this was it,” she said, her arm shaking. “I didn’t know.”
He snatched the money from her hand and said, “I have to do every fucking little fucking thing myself.”
I slid out of the door and crouched behind the bar. Denisha stopped fluttering and looked down at me in surprise. I put a finger to my lips.
I wanted to tell her to settle down. I wanted to tell her that the police would be here soon, although I doubted they would. There wasn’t any “soon” right now. Even driving fast meant tiptoeing across the ice.
Denisha probably knew that. The Professor probably did too. His head hadn’t moved when I got behind the bar, although his eyes had for just a moment. He tilted his chin up ever so slightly, in the faintest acknowledgement possible.
I lifted the bottle just a little, and he tilted his head. He didn’t know what I was going to do. That was clear from his posture.
I needed the beefy guy to turn around. I needed his back to me. I needed to go under the bar flap, appear behind him, and whack him on the head hard enough to stop him in his tracks.
“Hey, asshole,” Diamond Jim said. He stood up, and I could see the back of his head from my crouch. His hair was thinning right around the crown, and it made him look vulnerable.
I had no idea if he had seen me at all, but if he had, he was doing the exact wrong thing. I didn’t need the beefy guy to be looking at the bar. I needed him to look away from the bar.
“Shut the fuck up, Gramps,” the beefy guy said. “This ain’t about you.”
“Gramps?” Diamond Jim asked. “You’re at least as old as I am, asshole.”
“I’m not arguing age with you, Gramps,” the beefy guy said.
“Well, you should.” Diamond Jim moved out of my range of vision. “Because if you remember Frank’s Italian restaurant, you’re at least as old as me.”
Which wasn’t true, of course. I remembered Frank’s Italian Restaurant, and I was younger than Diamond Jim by at least fifteen years.
I crab-walked to the bar flap, and Denisha shot me a panicked look. She had every right to panic, but I had to see.
“I don’t care about your age, old man,” the beefy guy said.
“Well, you should,” Diamond Jim said, using the same tone he’d used the last time he’d used those words. “Because I was here when they tore Frank’s Italian down.”
Only it hadn’t been Frank’s Italian then. I had no idea what Diamond Jim was playing at.
I peered around the edge of the bar. Diamond Jim had walked toward the woman, and I suddenly had a very bad feeling about this.
Diamond Jim was bullshitting the guy so that he could get the woman out of harm’s way.
“Yeah?” the beefy guy said. “Why should I care?”
“Because,” Diamond Jim said as he stopped beside the woman. “I took the wall safe home.”
Whatever I’d expected him to say, it wasn’t that.
But it did get the beefy guy’s attention. He raised his chin just a little, his right arm twitched a little, and I prayed that the stupid gun wouldn’t go off accidentally.
“So, what,” he said, his voice suddenly bland. That was, ladies and gentlemen (as Darryl would’ve said) a tell. “You’re going to tell me to take you home so that you become a hero and save your friends here?”
Diamond Jim laughed. The laugh was cold, a laugh I’d never heard from him before.
“Hell, no,” he said. “I don’t care about these people and neither do you.”
The beefy guy tilted his head ever so slightly. Apparently, Diamond Jim had his attention now.
“So what do you want, old man?” the beefy guy said.
“It’s not what I want, is it?” Diamond Jim said. “It’s what you want. You figured Christmas Day would be perfect to break into the closed restaurant and crack open the safe. You sent your piece here to clear the way for you, just in case the restaurant was open.”
“I’m not a piece,” the woman muttered, but she still crouched.
The beefy guy was still faced ever so slightly toward me. He wasn’t looking down. He was actually looking at Diamond Jim. There was a chance the beefy guy wouldn’t see me move, but there was a chance he would.
No one else was moving. My presence made Denisha stop her pacing, which I would have seen as suspicious, but the beefy guy didn’t seem to care.
“She said it was closed,” he said accusingly, inclining his head at the woman.
“I said it looked closed,” she snapped with some of the attitude she’d brought here earlier. “Then I texted you and said it was closed enough.”
“Whatever the hell that means,” the beefy guy said. “There’s fucking people here, so it’s not fucking closed, you dumb—”
“There wasn’t anything in that safe,” Diamond Jim said, a little too loudly. “I’d heard the same rumors you had. That’s why I took it. I had to hire a guy to open it, but he did, and we didn’t find a damn thing.”
The beefy guy barked out a laugh. “Nice try.”
“Believe me, don’t believe me,” Diamond Jim said. “It doesn’t matter. The wall safe is gone, and you’re holding a gun on people for no reason whatsoever.”
My heart was pounding. Diamond Jim was making this guy mad, which was the last thing we needed.
“I’m not holding a gun on anyone,” the beefy guy said, and he sounded surly, which surprised me.
He was also telling the truth. The gun was at his side, and had been the entire time.
My thighs were aching. I was used to being on my feet for hours, but I wasn’t used to crouching like this. Standing up would be harder than I thought.
“Well,” Diamond Jim said in that same cold tone he’d used earlier, “it doesn’t really matter what you’re doing, exactly. You’re holding a gun and we are unarmed. That’s a threat.”
“I’m not threatening you,” the beefy guy said.
“So I can leave?” Diamond Jim asked.
The beefy guy hesitated. Apparently the question was too hard for him.
“Because I really don’t want to leave,” Diamond Jim said. “I’d like you to leave.”
“So you can call the cops?” the beefy guy asked.
“Maybe,” Diamond Jim said. “It doesn’t matter. By the time they get here, you should be long gone. I don’t know your name. And I doubt anyone here does.”
Except the woman. But somehow this had stopped being about her. She had an ability to vanish that I envied at this moment.
“How about I escort you to the door,” Diamond Jim said, “and you go back to whatever you were doing before you thought of visiting Frank’s Italian.”
Diamond Jim started walking to the door. The guy pivoted, his back finally to me, but I thought it didn’t matter, because Diamond Jim was going to get him to leave.
And then the guy stopped.
“You think you’re so damned smart,” the guy said.
And beside me, I heard Denisha inhale a shaky breath. Apparently, she had thought that Diamond Jim was going to talk him out of the bar too.
“It wasn’t never the Italian place, was it?” the guy said. “This place’s Frank’s too, and I’ll wager it has a wall safe.”
It did. We’d never been able to open it, or rather, Darryl hadn’t. That was when he decided to build the storage room wall right over it.
Right next to the bathroom, with the busted window.
Maybe that hadn’t been a coincidence.
Not that it mattered. I put my free palm on the floor. It was sticky, and I had a random unimportant thought that I didn’t keep this place as clean as I believed I did.
I slowly rose out of my crouch.
Diamond Jim’s gaze flickered, just once. He saw me, and that calm look on his face, the one that had apparently kept the guy under control, faded for a moment.
I froze, but the guy didn’t turn around.
“You take me to the back, near that round window,” the guy said, raising the gun. He wasn’t pointing it, though. He was gesturing with it. “That’s where the safe is.”
Shit. At least I didn’t breathe the word out loud, but I sure as hell felt it. I only had a moment here.
I had no idea how he knew that. I had no idea why he wanted the safe. He had a wad of money—or rather, the woman did. So it wasn’t about money.
It was about something else.
I pushed myself up the rest of the way, willing my ancient knees not to crack—and for once, they didn’t. Then I tightened my grip on the heavy bottle and started across the floor, slowly and silently.
“That’s where the safe was in the Italian place, not here,” Diamond Jim said with hearty confidence. “The walls are brick here. There’s no place for a safe.”
I snuck across the floor. I knew where every creak and groove was. I knew the interior of this bar like the back of my hand, and still I was afraid I’d trip or call attention to myself.
“You fucking liar,” the beefy guy said. “C’mon. You’re coming with me.”
He reached out with his left hand, not his right, which I found curious. But I didn’t have time to think about it as I swung the bottle back, up and over, just like Darryl had taught me.
The weight of the damn thing, and the movement of the liqueur inside nearly made me lose my balance. But I managed to catch myself, swing the bottle forward with some force, and slam the beefy guy on the back of the head so hard that the crack! seemed to echo in the nearly empty bar.
He crumpled without making a sound, and as he went down, the gun went off.
The bullet hit the floor, ricocheted right into Diamond Jim. He screamed, grabbed his thigh, and collapsed at the same time. Blood was instantly everywhere.
An artery. Son of a bitch.
I put the still-intact bottle on the table and hurried over to Diamond Jim. His face was already growing pale. He was propped against a table leg, both hands over his right thigh. Blood was pooling around him.
“Call 911,” I yelled.
No one moved.
I was going to have to give full directions here. “Stella, honey,” I said, not yelling anymore. “Call 911.”
She nodded, pulled her phone out, and stared at it. Somehow Denisha ended up beside her, pulling the phone away from her, and using it.
Diamond Jim was growing paler by the instant.
“I need a belt,” I said, hoping the men still wore belts, although the Professor didn’t look like a man who would.
But it wasn’t the Professor who handed me a belt. It was the woman. She gave me the wool belt from her ugly plaid coat.
“I was going to use it to tie him up,” she said softly to me.
I assumed the him was the beefy guy, not Diamond Jim. I slid the belt underneath Diamond Jim’s upper thigh, my hands already slick with blood. He moaned at the movement, but didn’t fight me, thank god.
I tied the belt as tight as I could, but the wound still oozed. All those First Aid training classes we had every fucking year for liquor board compliance said the bleeding had to stop when you tied something off, so I tried again, pulling even tighter.
Diamond Jim moaned again, but I ignored him this time. I managed to squeeze the skin of his upper thigh so tight that the area around the belt looked as thin as his ankle—and this time, the bleeding did stop.
Diamond Jim’s eyes were fluttering.
“Don’t you fucking pass out on me,” I said to him. “Jim, you stay awake, you hear me?”
He nodded.
Stella tiptoed over, moving around the beefy man who was still out cold, her phone in her right hand.
“They want to know how he is,” she said.
“He’s got a bullet in his thigh, and he’s lost a lot of blood, that’s how he fucking is,” I said. “They need to get someone here now.”
Stella nodded, as if I’d pissed in the punch at her dinner party and she was afraid someone was going to blame her for that. But she brought the phone to her ear.
“Did you hear that?” she asked.
I waved a bloody hand at the beefy guy. “Someone get some rope or another belt and tie him up. And find the gun.”
Stella moved away, careful to keep her shoes out of the blood and far from the unconscious beefy guy. Denisha pulled a belt off her coat—also wool and much prettier than the stranger’s plaid—and brought it over.
“I’m not doing it,” I said. “You tie him up good.”
I got up, even though I didn’t want to. I didn’t want to leave Diamond Jim alone, but I didn’t know the stranger, and I didn’t know what she’d do with the gun if she got it.
For a moment, I thought she had gotten it, and then I saw it, under the table, the blood oozing its way toward the grip.
I picked up the gun by that grip, kept it pointed down (fat lot of good that had done a few minutes ago), and then I carried it to the bar. I had no idea how to eject the bullets or take one out of the chamber or engage the safety—if there even was a safety on that thing.
I put the gun under the bar, near the lemons and limes I had cut that morning, and made my way back to Diamond Jim. Stella was standing near him, answering the occasional question from the dispatch. She was talking to him too, and getting him to answer her.
They didn’t need me.
The stranger—the woman—was standing near the beefy guy, just far enough away that he couldn’t kick her if he woke up. Denisha had tied his wrists so tight that his hands were slightly purple, and I really didn’t care. I didn’t care if he lost the use of his fingers or his hands.
He’d come into my bar and threatened everyone, and shot up Diamond Jim who had become the unexpected hero in all of this.
“What’s this all about?” I asked the woman.
She shook her head, indicated the beefy guy with one hand, and shook her head again.
“Don’t pretend you don’t know,” I said. “You came here first. You’re in on this.”
She was still shaking her head. “I was just supposed to let him know if the restaurant was open. Then I could go home. I’m sorry. I thought this was the restaurant. I texted him, told him there were people here, but he asked me how many and I told him the truth. I should’ve lied. If I’d said dozens, he wouldn’t’ve come.”
I didn’t want to think about that, because that meant he would’ve found another time to show up here, maybe as I was closing, by myself, some dark cold night.
“What’s this all about, anyway?” I asked.
“His dad said there was a second safe behind the main one in Frank’s Italian Restaurant,” she said. “And the second safe had lots of money from some bank robbery, that no one was supposed to touch for years. And then everyone forgot about it.”
“The Hisinger Robbery?” I asked.
“I don’t know,” she said. “Something like that.”
If it was the Hisinger Robbery, then no one had forgotten about it. A small cadre of press and fortune hunters had shown up when they finally tore the building housing Frank’s Italian down, hoping to find the backup safe that apparently didn’t exist.
It was—Diamond Jim said at the time—Al Capone’s Vault all over again.
I glanced at him. He was still mumbling a response whenever Stella spoke to him. His color was bad and his leg was swelling up, but he wasn’t bleeding anymore.
“Why did he think he could get the money now?” I asked the woman.
“I dunno,” the woman said. “He’s kinda out of options. Moneywise. And he knows how to crack a safe.”
She said that as if that was a good thing.
“How come you’re helping him?” I asked. I half-expected some sob story. Out-of-work family, last-ditch attempt, a felon trying to make good and his battered but loyal wife.
Instead, her gaze met mine, and the expression was flat. All the empathy I might’ve felt—and I wasn’t sure it was much—fled at the chill in her gaze.
“He didn’t give me much choice,” she said.
Except that she had been alone with all of us on Christmas Day for more than an hour. She could’ve warned us. She could’ve called the cops. She could’ve told the beefy guy there was no point.
She could’ve gotten away.
“You said everything was closed,” I said. “You said—”
“It doesn’t matter.” She sounded tired. She grabbed her crummy coat, and folded it over her arm, then walked away from the beefy guy. “It went wrong. It always goes wrong when he’s involved.”
“Did he break my window?” I asked.
“Huh?” She frowned at me.
“In the back, the round window. Did he break it?”
“How the hell should I know?” she asked in a tone that said, And why should I care?
I shook my head and glanced at Stella, who was clinging to her phone. She held it just so, and I realized she hadn’t been saying a word. Every bit of my conversation with the strange woman had been probably been recorded by the 911 dispatch.
“Where’s the ambulance?” Denisha asked into the quiet.
“Coming,” Stella said, and as she did, the door opened, blowing in ice and wind and just a hint of snow. It was dark outside, not the dark of night, but the dark of a stormy winter day that made everything seem later than it was.
Four cops came inside, hands on weapons. The biggest one—tall, not fat—looked around, saw the man tied up, and Diamond Jim leaning on the table leg, looking like death warmed over. Blood had stopped flowing, but it still formed a big pool on my not-so-polished floor.
“What the hell?” the cop asked.
“That guy,” I said, pointing at the beefy guy, “shot him.”
“Accidentally,” the strange woman said.
“And she’s in on it,” I said.
“And you are?” the cop asked.
“I own this place.” Such as it is, I almost said, but didn’t, because being glib was not called for at the moment. “We got the gun. It’s behind the bar.”
The cops filed in and as they did, there were sirens. The ambulance, finally. Either the cops had rolled in without their sirens or we couldn’t hear them through the storm and the drama.
Everything sorted out. Stella gave them her phone with the call to the dispatch, the ambulance took Diamond Jim, and another ambulance came for the beefy guy, who was non-responsive (or so the attendants said). The cops took the strange woman, and our statements, finally leaving us long about four in the afternoon.
The door closed, leaving us with a blood pool and jittery nerves.
“Let’s clean up,” the Professor said, making it sound like an order. Denisha went in back and found my ancient mop, not the good one, and the four of us—her, me, Stella, and the Professor—managed to get the blood off the floor.
It took longer to clean up my hands, but I managed. Then I made drinks for everyone. And not some foo-foo holiday shit either. Real stiff drinks for getting through this day.
We combined the drinks with cookies, which probably wasn’t the best idea. And then Denisha said, “You think Diamond Jim was lying about that safe? That he got it?”
I did think he was lying at first, but now I wasn’t so sure. The man who led the beefy guy to the door was a different man than the one I had seen for years here in the bar. And he had lied with such ease that it unnerved me.
I didn’t answer Denisha, not out loud, anyway, and neither did anyone else. We just swirled our drinks and neglected the cookies, and stared at the bar napkins.
“I suppose we could check the safe here,” the Professor said. “See what’s inside.”
“We’d have to move a wall,” I said, and then remembered the broken window. “And I have a window to block.”
“I did already,” Denisha said. “The wind broke it. There was nothing in the bathroom to suggest otherwise.”
I looked at her. She’d heard my conversation with the stranger-woman then. Maybe they all had.
I wasn’t sure it mattered.
“If there’s money inside, it belongs to the bar, legally,” Stella said, and I wondered how she knew that.
Then I squinted at her.
She knew little legal things, and she’d come up with letting 911 dispatch record that conversation.
She’d been a looker, once upon a time.
She caught me staring at her. “What?”
“You were a cocktail waitress,” I said. “At Frank’s Italian. Back in the day.”
She half-smiled at me. “Right outta high school,” she said. “I told you that.”
But she hadn’t.
“You remember the Hisinger Robbery,” I said.
She nodded. “Happened a few years after I started. Was a topic of conversation until I quit.”
Back in the day, it took a perfect touch and a delicate hand to crack a safe. A lot of study, and hours of opportunity. But those hours didn’t have to be all at once. You could open a safe a little bit at a time, if you remembered what part of the process you were in, especially with one of those old-fashioned combination locks.
The safe in Frank’s Italian had been broken in the demolition. And had been empty. Which surprised a lot of people.
“You think there was a lot of money left over from that robbery?” I asked.
“Oh, yeah,” she said. “I’m sure of it.”
All of us stared at her. She shrugged, smiled and picked up the expensive bourbon I’d poured her. The bourbon she drank quickly and easily the first time, even though she had always told me she didn’t drink hard liquor.
I glanced at the Professor and Denisha. She had her head on her arms, resting on the bar top, and he was rubbing her back.
“Long day,” he said to me. “You think the storm is done?”
“I wouldn’t drive yet,” I said.
But he ignored me, got up, and went to the door. I looked at Stella. She leaned forward just a little
Denisha said, head still inside her arms, “Let’s not do this ever again.”
“I don’t think there’s anything left to do again,” I said, still watching Stella.
“Oh,” Stella said, “there’s a little left.”
Then she glanced at the door to the back. Then her gaze came back to mine.
“But I’m not in any hurry,” she said. “Are you?”
“I’m not taking down a wall,” I said.
Denisha raised her head, looking confused. But Stella smiled.
“No point,” she said, and swigged the last of her drink. “I’m off to see how Jim is doing.”
“In this weather?” Denisha asked.
“It’s cleared up enough to drive,” the Professor said. “Although I don’t want to.”
Stella waggled her fingers at me, then headed out the front door, as if this were a normal evening.
The door closed behind her, and the bar felt very quiet.
“What was that about?” Denisha asked. “The bit about the wall?”
“I’m not sure,” I said. But I was sure. Stella had known about the robbery. Stella had taken some money from Frank’s Italian, probably after Frank died. After all, she’d been the only one who could stomach the food from that terrible burger joint. She went every single day.
Just like she came here, every single day. Only Darryl always kept an eye on the back, and then he built the storage area.
Maybe he lied about not opening the safe. I just knew I had never done it.
And I wasn’t about to do so now.
“Memorable Christmas,” the Professor said.
“Too memorable,” Denisha said. “I don’t like memorable holidays.”
“We’re certainly not going to make it a tradition,” I said.
The Professor smiled. “Good thing,” he said as he bundled his wife out the door.
They had left me alone in a blood-stained bar on the strangest Christmas I’d ever spent. They hadn’t even finished off my peppermint schnapps like they usually did.
I locked the door behind them, then leaned on the bar.
Did I think there was money in the safe here? For a half-second I flirted with the thought. Then I decided that I was doing fine without it. Maybe, if I ever took the storage wall down, I’d look.
But one strange thing was for certain. I no longer wanted to move away from Frank’s Corner Bar.
It had personality. It had character. And now I wasn’t borrowing the personality or character from Darryl or Frank or anyone else.
I’d been through this one on my own. It was my story, my badge, my strange life experience.
I grabbed someone’s uneaten cookie, tapped it on the bar, and then grinned. Guess I needed something different to liven up the place. Guess I needed just a hint of drama to make it through this holiday.
I got drama and then some.
In the morning, I’d call the hospital, find out how Diamond Jim was doing. Then I’d wait to see if Stella returned. I rather doubted she would. I wasn’t even sure the Professor and Denisha would be back.
And that was okay.
It was time to move forward, time to make Frank’s Corner Bar something other than a relic. Maybe change the name. Maybe redesign the interior.
And then I laughed, the sound echoing in the emptiness.
Who was I kidding?
This place was what it was.
And I liked it just that way.
Frank’s Corner BarCopyright© 2022 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch
First published as part of the WMG Holiday Spectacular 2020 project
Published by WMG Publishing
Cover and Layout copyright © 2022 by WMG Publishing
Cover design by Allyson Longueira
Cover art copyright © Pablesku/Depositphotos
In my Pocket Reader app, I stored a September article from BBC News as much for the article’s title as its content. That title? “When Is A Bestseller Not Necessarily A Bestseller?”
I think that’s been the burning question in publishing for the past ten years. Bestsellers haven’t entirely lost their meaning, but they’re not relevant the way that they were twenty years ago. Back in the day when traditional publishing controlled 99% of the books that we saw on shelves (before ebooks), a bestseller was the book that sold the best out of the myriad of bookstores.
Even then, those bestseller lists were rigged. I can’t tell you how many times I had colleagues who gamed The New York Times list (the easiest one to buy your way onto, if you had the list of “acceptable” bookstores). It was a relief to have USA Today base its list on actual reported sales across all stores, including the chains. Even those numbers were flawed, though, because they were self-reported by most of the publishers.
Data has never been traditional publishing’s strong suit.
Last week, I examined traditional publishing and the mess that it has become, a mess that has led at least one industry expert to conclude that the services traditional publishers provide are essentially meaningless.
The anecdotal evidence has existed for years. I know several Big Name romance writers who can no longer live off their royalties like they did twenty years ago. Fortunately, a lot of them were good at money management, so they have cash stashed away and their homes are paid for.
Last year, Kat Martin, at 20Booksto50K here in Las Vegas, stated,
I think [the backlist is] a real negative for traditional publishing. Once you sell them your book, they have your book and they own it for years. And they do pay you a nice fat fee up front, so it’s kind of a trade off, but it’s not a long-term, it’s not a retirement thing, because they’re making money off the backlist. You don’t. They give you a percentage, but…the big money, I think, for long term is probably in self-publishing.
(If you want to see this yourself, go to the video. It’s about 38 minutes in.)
Because everyone comes to Vegas at one point or another, Dean and I had a lot of opportunities to talk with writer friends who are (or were) traditionally published bestsellers. Dean had lunch with a person whose work would be considered a major (mega) bestseller. That person expressed shock that the backlist, which once earned a tidy income, earned little more than a trickle now.
That person could no longer sell their books to the Big Five, despite the continuing good numbers on the backlist. The small publisher the person went with is going belly-up, and the author was looking at other ways to publish.
I can’t tell you how many conversations we have with writers in a similar position.
Not to mention the writers we’ve lost over the years. After their deaths, some of the writers’ finances get revealed, particularly when there is no money left and the families have to hold Go-Fund-Me campaigns or seek out help from writerly friends to manage the estates. Now, granted, some of the issues here come from the United States’ ridiculous health care system that requires people with long-term illnesses to go into serious debt, even if they have “good” insurance, but a lot of the problem with writers’ earnings come from the way that traditional publishing is managed these days.
The Big 5, for example, are maximizing their profits at the expense of writers. The Big 5 are colluding, according to the Department of Justice’s case which fought the merger of Penguin Random House and Simon & Schuster (and won). The judge, in her opinion, points out several cases of collusion, especially on rights and contract terms, and in one case says that the behavior would be considered illegal in most industries.
I will deal with a few of these issues in upcoming posts, as I look at growing subsections of the indie publishing industry.
The DOJ defined what a bestseller is for its case. The case the DOJ ultimately proved was that the Big 5 had created a monopsony, which the opinion describes as “a market condition where a buyer with too much market power can lower prices or otherwise harm sellers.”
The DOJ narrowly defined the sellers as the authors of “top-selling” books (aka bestsellers). The DOJ called this a submarket inside of publishing. Page 24 of the decision included this definition of the submarket:
Anticipated top-selling books are those that are expected to yield significant sales, and for which authors therefore receive higher advances….The government contends that such books have distinctive characteristics, including the need for extra marketing, publicity, and sales support to allow them to reach broader audiences.
That part of the definition both parties could more or less agree upon. Heck, all of us who “grew up” in traditional publishing understand that.
The part that became controversial, at least for the duration of the trial, was the “distinct pricing,” which the government used to identify the potential top-selling books. Without going into all the arguments (which the traditional publishers eventually lost), what the government chose as its price point for its monopsony argument was a $250,000 advance and above. From pages 27 and 28 of the opinion:
…the government’s use of high advances as a proxy for anticipated book sales is logical and supported by market realities. In publishing, advances are correlated with expected sales because books that are expected to sell well receive higher advances….In fact, advance levels are set by using P&L’s, and the defining feature of a P&L is the sales estimate….Moreover, industry practices indicate that $250,000 is a reasonable place to draw the line: S&S and two of the three PRH adult divisions require approval from senior publishers or executives for advance offers of $250,000 or more; and Publishers Marketplace, a major industry publication, categorizes deals for $250,000 or more as “significant.”
Writers and non-writers alike recognize this definition. That’s what everyone thinks of when they think of bestselling books. The definition hasn’t changed much since the 1960s when a $250,000 advance would be the equivalent of a $2.4 million dollar advance today. Not many writers are receiving $2.4 million dollar advances now, but in the 1960s, a significant number of books hit that $250,000 threshold.
These days, according to page 26 of my favorite court case:
Books that meet the $250,000 advance threshold comprise only 2 percent of all book acquisitions, but they account for 70 percent of all advance spending, amounting to $1 billion annually.
Looking at it this way, the DOJ case makes sense. They’re defending a small subset of sellers in a small (and declining) subset of the publishing industry. I will deal with this part of the case in a future year-in-review post, because I ended up with a heck of a realization. (And yes, fiction writers, I’m now withholding information to create suspense. Bad me.)
I do need to note there that traditional publishers still try to sell books into the “trade channels” which means the brick and mortar bookstores. According to Mike Shatzkin,
Bookstores have shrunk in number and in size so that perhaps as little as 20-25 percent (or perhaps as much as 30-35 percent, but no more…) of print book sales are made at actual retail stores.
In other words, these bestsellers that the DOJ defended may have 70 percent of advance spending, but they’re competing for an increasingly small market—that of the physical bookstore, which no longer dominates the industry at all.
(This is why advances for “top-selling books” have gone down in the past fifteen years.)
But let’s go back to the BBC’s question: What is a bestseller? The poor author of that piece was disappointed to learn that the books that places like Waterstones in England place on their endcaps and in other prominent positions, books usually listed as “New/Bestselling” aren’t anything other than new, and certainly aren’t bestsellers.
Those slots are for sale, so that publishers, who have spent, say, $250,000 on an advance, can promote the book inside the bookstore ecosystem. It’s a practice that has gone on for decades, but was apparently new to the BBC writer. Ah, disillusionment. It comes in many forms.
So do bestsellers. How do we define them? It’s possible to hit the New York Times list in off periods these days with as few as 5,000 book sales. Yet the writers whose books hit the list can be considered bestsellers. Their books won’t earn out (if they received a $250,000 advance) and they certainly won’t get retirement money, but they will have bragging rights.
Are the Amazon lists bestseller lists? Because they too can be gamed. The original idea behind the group 20Booksto50K was to teach writers how to manipulate Amazon’s algorithms to create sales and eventually hit the Amazon lists.
(Amazon hates this, by the way, and now changes up its algorithm so often that it’s truly hard to game. That was a discussion repeatedly at this year’s 20Books, along with a recommendation that was once an anathema to the group: Go wide.)
Are the free bestseller lists on any of the ebook retailer sites an actually bestseller list? Because the books weren’t sold. Technically, they were given away at high discount. They were what’s called in any retail industry a “loss leader.” From Shopify’s blog:
Loss leader pricing is a marketing strategy that prices products lower than the cost to produce them in order to attract new customers or to sell additional products to customers. Companies typically use loss leader pricing when they are entering new markets or attempting to increase market share.
Doesn’t sound like that would count as bestselling to me, then. And how do we define bestselling? Do we use traditional publishing’s old definition, which was the number of books sold within the first week of publication? That always screwed successful writers like Andre Norton, whose books sold consistently and at higher numbers than the Writer Flavor of The Month, but Norton’s books never hit a “bestseller” threshold in the first week of release, so she couldn’t be considered a bestseller. (Seriously.)
Do we use the DOJ’s distinct pricing number of a $250,000 advance? If we look at the advance for what it is, a loan against royalties (that appear once a book goes on sale), we should probably ask how that differs from a successful Kickstarter campaign.
In theory, Kickstarters kick start projects. Most publishing Kickstarters work the way that traditional publishing works, in that the book is finished once it goes up for “sale.” In the court-case definition, that sale is from the writer to a traditional publisher. In the Kickstarter instance, that sale is from the writer to a select group of readers who back the Kickstarter.
If we use the $250,000 figure, then Brandon Sanderson’s mega Kickstarter from March, for which he received nearly $42 million, is clearly a bestseller. Even the numbers of backers, while low compared to what his traditional publisher reports as his sales (note my hedging here; I don’t trust their numbers any more than the United States District Court For The District of Columbia does) are in the modern bestseller range. That particular Kickstarter had 185,341 backers.
Let’s take Brandon out of the equation though, and consider his Kickstarter as the outlier it is. Let’s go with the $250,000 threshold.
A quick and not thorough glance at Kickstarter on December 6 brought up projects like Will Wight’s three-book fantasy series, which funded at $760,000, and a children’s adventure book earned $384,000. A book on Japanese folklore brought in $510,000 and another turning Dracula into an interactive experience finished at $378,000.
I doubt any of those books would have received similar advances from traditional publishing. Nor would the books on regenerative agriculture (about $400,000) and collecting the art of G.I. Joe ($393,000).
If you count each backer as one book sold, the number of backers hasn’t risen to the number of sales in the old-fashioned bestselling categories. (That might not be the case, but go with it.) For Will Wight, the three books had 6,021 backers. Augie and the Green Knight, the children’s adventure book, had 9,044 backers.
G.I. Joe had 2,797 backers (which is about what a coffee table book would sell for a small publisher). Regenerative Agriculture had 3,088 backers which, if I were doing a P&L for a traditional regional publisher, would have been right in the ballpark, spread out over a year. The Japanese folklore encyclopedia had 5,735 backers which, given the short time frame of a Kickstarter, might have gotten that book on the New York Times nonfiction bestseller list.
But here’s the thing about the Kickstarted books. With the exception of the limited editions (of which there are a few here), the other books are just at the beginning of their sales life. A number of them hadn’t even been posted on retailers’ sites when the Kickstarter ended.
These are just the opening sales, not the largest sales of the book’s life (as are early sales in traditional publishing). These books will go on to have a lot more sales and a long life. They will earn money for years, if the writers keep them up for sale, and the numbers of sales and readers will continue to grow.
How do we count that? We can’t.
Nor can we count auxiliary sales, like audio or foreign rights sales. Those are in flux in traditional right now, and they’re a bit dicey in indie, although getting easier. (Yes, I will discuss this in future posts.)
That $250,000 threshold is a low bar when it comes to indie. As I wrote to a lawyer friend when the court case came out, I know a lot of self-published/indie writers who make that amount in a year on their books. Sometimes that’s on one book and sometimes it’s on several. But unlike traditional publishing, which divides that $250,000 into at least four payments of $50,000 each spread over two years (minus an agent’s commission), that $250,000 comes in monthly installments.
Kickstarters and other rights sales are bonuses.
The question of what is a bestseller is impossible to answer in the modern publishing world. It’s also probably irrelevant. To use Mike Schatzki’s definition of traditional publishing from the 1990s as a moat that protected the castle (publishing) from the great unwashed with all of their (stupidly creative books on agriculture and Japanese folklore) from getting into the bookstores, the moat has dried up. The castle has been overrun. And no one—not the DOJ, not a judge, not traditional publishing, heck—not publishing itself (if it were a real entity) can define what “bestselling” means anymore.
It’s an old term from an out-of-date business model, and one we need to replace.
But that’s about book discoverability, and that’s a blog for another day.
This weekly blog is reader supported.
If you feel like supporting the blog on an on-going basis, then please head to my Patreon page.
If you liked this post, and want to show your one-time appreciation, the place to do that is PayPal. If you go that route, please include your email address in the notes section, so I can say thank you.
Which I am going to say right now. Thank you!
Click paypal.me/kristinekathrynrusch to go to PayPal.
“Business Musings: The Year in Review Part 3: Bestsellers,” copyright © 2022 by Kristine Kathryn Rusch. Image at the top of the blog © Can Stock Photo / studiostoks.
When Susan gave birth to her son on Christmas Day, she named him Harold, after her late father. All his life, Harold wanted to sing. And all his life, Harold met with disappointment.
So, when his own son arrives on December 25 as well, Harold faces a difficult choice: continue the legacy or spare his son the same hardships.
“Harold Angel,” by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook through various online retailers here. For lots more holiday reading, check out the WMG Holiday Spectacular 2022 here.
Harold AngelKristine Kathryn RuschSusan felt sorry for him from the time she heard his due date—December 25th—and hoped he would arrive late. He didn’t; from the moment he was born, he was punctual, meticulous, precise. She had expected that—the strange dream she had the night of his birth somehow influenced the way she raised him, she thought, or perhaps it was, in some ways, prescient.
She named him Harold, after her father. Her husband had died before Harold’s presence was even known, and her friends had nothing to say about the boy’s name, although a few of them did, telling her that Harold was out of date, that she should choose Jason or Jeremy or some other silly J name. But she believed that names created connections, and since Harold would have no man in his life, he at least deserved a connection to a good one, even if that man were dead.
Susan bowed to her friends’ concerns, though, and gave him Jay as a middle name. But she couldn’t bring herself to call him that; Harold she had named him and Harold he was.
When Harold was three, Susan’s newest boyfriend (soon to be her husband) started calling him “The Little Accountant,” and the designation seemed apt. Harold had a fondness for numbers, logic, and precision. He also loved classical music, especially those musicians like Bach in whom he could hear that precision. When he was five, he told Susan he wanted to be an opera star. She winced, not at the idea (she was secretly fond of opera) but at the reality.
Harold was completely and utterly tone deaf.
Most children sang in an enthusiastic and out of tune approximation of any song they heard. Harold sang in the same hideous monotone, and then smiled, as if he had achieved perfection. The leader of the church children’s choir finally asked Susan to remove him from the group, and she had done so reluctantly, by getting him piano lessons at the very same time.
He liked the piano, but didn’t love it, and often forgot to practice. But he hoped to sing, and every year in school, he joined the choir, and every year, until auditions started, he was asked to leave.
In middle school he auditioned regularly and never made the cut. In high school, he stopped trying. By college, he no longer listened to music, and after he graduated, he became that accountant Susan’s husband had once predicted. For the rest of his life, Harold would turn off music whenever he came into a room, and only his mother knew why.
The day she died, she apologized to him. “I had a choice, baby,” she said, “and I didn’t believe it. If I could do it all over again, I would have named you Frank.”
He had thought the comment delusional and rather odd. There had been no one in the family named Frank, and it was a stuffier, stodgier name than Harold. In fact, he had rather liked being named for his grandfather. When Harold was a boy, he used to make up stories about the old man, stories in which both Harolds were heroes.
So, when his wife became pregnant after years of trying, he told her if the child was a boy, he wanted to name the child Harold. She agreed.
Ironically, this child was due on December 25th and just like his father before him, he was punctual—if just barely. Born at 11:59, Harold called his son the best Christmas present he had ever received.
Later that night, he had a dream: An angel with white soft wings and a sharp-featured face sat on the edge of his wife’s hospital bed. Harold sat in the chair across from it. The angel reached out its beautiful hand and touched his face. He felt a slight jolt.
“Strange factors these,” the angel said. “December 25th and a multitude of Harolds. You’ll populate the heavenly hosts all by yourself.”
He frowned, not understanding.
“Time for us is fluid, and for you it’s rigid. Your son will have ninety years on Earth, and like you, all he will want is to sing. Sing beautifully, sing precisely, sing well. And like you, he will sing like the angels, in a voice that can only be heard by God.”
Harold considered that the biggest curse of his life, the thing that determined his fate more than anything else. “I don’t want him to live like that,” he said. “What can I do?”
“Change his name,” the angel said.
“Why does that matter?” Harold asked. “What’s so important about his name?”
“Only Harolds born on December 25th have this curse,” the angel said.
“Curse?” Harold asked.
“We call it that,” the angel said. “Time is fluid for us. One day, you will join us and sing the most important song ever sung in the history of humankind. But to do so, you must know what it is like to fail at the very thing you love. Save him from this, and call him something else.”
“But you said he’ll sing the most important song ever sung.”
“As will you,” the angel said. “After you die.”
And then he awoke. His wife stirred in her sleep, then opened her eyes.
“I never realized it,” she mumbled, clearly not completely awake. “You’re a Harold angel.”
Then she rolled over. He stared at her for a moment, and thought of the curse mentioned in his dream. When is a curse not a curse? he thought. When it becomes the fulfillment of a dream.
His mother shouldn’t have apologized. He preferred Harold to Frank. And so, it seemed, did his son—another tone-deaf accountant who would someday sing (or perhaps, in rigid human time, had already sung) the most important song in the history of the Earth.
Harold AngelCopyright © 2022 by Kristine Kathryn RuschPublished by WMG PublishingCover and Layout copyright © 2022 by WMG PublishingCover design by Allyson Longueira/WMG PublishingCover art copyright © Ysign1/Dreamstime
Today’s story in the 2022 Holiday Spectacular is a brand-new Kristine Grayson novelette. “Dog House” continues the adventures of Imperia Encanto as she figures out how to live in our world. And, um, there might be dogs. It’s not too late to subscribe to the Spectacular. You’ll get all 39 stories, including three of mine. I had so much fun writing this story. I hope […]
In the course of this insane year, in which the news cycle was on overdrive in every single industry, and the Western world (which is what I mostly follow) spent all of its time splitting into factions and screaming at each other. In a year that had a moment of holy crap, are we really going to slide into World War III? followed by the […]
When Rhonda holds a vigil for World Aids Day in the tiny Oregon Coast town of Rickets Rock, she hopes to find someone, anyone, to mourn with her. But she just might wind up saving someone instead. This powerful story about compassion and acceptance demonstrates Kristine Kathryn Rusch’s mastery of short fiction. “Vigil,” by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch is free on this website […]
I started the Holiday Recommended Reading List when I realized that I point out all the great holiday stories in January, after the season has passed. I am always a month behind in reporting what I read. So I wanted you to find the great stories that I’ve enjoyed over the years. I love holiday stories of all kinds. I save up the stories to […]
As I’ve told you many times in the past, I love American Thanksgiving. It might be my favorite holiday. My celebration will be truncated this year, because I caught some kind of cold at 20Books last week. So I had to prioritize. That early morning Thanksgiving run—by which point, I should be pretty much clear of these symptoms and not contagious? Or spending all of […]
Winston’s familiar Ruby, a small black cat, avoids dogs whenever possible. So when Winston sees her talking quietly with a toy poodle-Chihuahua mix, he wants to know why. Ruby, usually so vocal, says nothing. Her silence, that dog, and a storm in the Oregon Coast community of Seavy Village all combine into one of the most memorable days of Winston’s life. “Un-familiar,” by New York Times bestselling […]
This year has been ridiculous. I have no idea why I expected it to be otherwise. I guess there’s a part of me that expected the world to return to normal, even though I’m one of the people who has said since March of 2020 that there would be no normal, at least not what we thought of as normal in 2019. Every industry is […]
The acclaimed short story that inspired the award-winning novel, The Enemy Within. February, 1964: Two men die in a squalid alley in a bad neighborhood. New York Homicide Detective Seamus O’Reilly receives the shock of his life when he looks at the men’s identification: J. Edgar Hoover, the famous, tyrannical director of the FBI, and his number one assistant, Clyde Tolson. O’Reilly teams up with […]
I spent most of the morning trying to start this post. It’s not like me to have trouble writing, particularly a nonfiction post, but I simply couldn’t do what I had planned. What I had planned was simple: Because of all of the news recently and the timing, I had planned to start the Year In Review blog posts early. I’ve always hated that they […]
Just a quick note to let you know that the full novel of The Court Martial of the Renegat Renegades has appeared in Asimov’s. The second half dropped this week in the November/December issue, which you can get now. The novel started as a piece that I had to leave out of The Renegat. I wondered what happened to the crew that returned to the […]
Devi follows orders, even if she hates them. Like her orders for this mission: pilot a single ship—The Matilda—on a fact-finding mission in the middle of a war zone. Despite Matilda’s apparent fondness for Devi, Devi feels the opposite about working with the sentient ship. But as pilot and ship approach their target—a large CeaWayLaV warship—the pair discovers their inability to function as a bonded […]
Even more Spanish academic article reading this month, some of which were fascinating, particularly one on proposed changes in the methodology of anthropology. But never fear, I’m not going to recommend any of it. I also (for my sins) had to read The Cherry Orchard by Chekhov for the 100th time. God, I loathe that play. So not all of my reading was pleasant. Then […]
The Holiday Spectacular Kickstarter has ended. I’m so pleased with the response. Thank you, thank you, thank you, backers! I think you’ll love this year’s stories. I know that I do. https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/403649867/wmg-holiday-spectacular-2022
I don’t know about the rest of you, but I’m tired. Bone-weary, in fact. The last six years or so have been a terrible rollercoaster, filled with disaster upon disaster. There have been some lovely moments, and a few victories for those of us who still believe in the power of the human spirit, but lately, it seems like the bigots and the haters are […]
Nic hunts rats. The kind of rats no one else can find. But while hunting his latest target, he finds more than he bargains for. And these rats might prove the sneakiest vermin Nic has hunted yet. This engrossing detective tale by New York Times bestselling author Kristine Kathryn Rusch offers a rats-eye view of New York City’s unique pest problem. “Rats,” by New York […]
Writers are curious creatures. We’re a mix of insecurity and ego. The ego is there whether we admit it or not. Why else would we write stories and put them out into the world? Deep down, we believe that other people want to read these stories. For some of us (all of us?), we believe that our stories will be read by millions of people […]
Every time I turn around, someone is talking about advertising. It seems like every news story mentions it. Many of the magazines I subscribe to mention it. When I go on social media someone is discussing it. Right now, every business article that revolves around Hollywood or movies or TV mentions advertising, because it’s changing. Streaming services that once had one tier, paid for with […]
As a homicide detective, Frank deals with violent death every day. And his reaction to those deaths kills him by inches. Until his most recent case forces him to take a long, hard look at his emotional state. The murder scene’s only survivor might hold the clues Frank needs to solve the case. It might even hold the key to Frank’s very salvation. “Little Miracles,” […]
Every year, we buy the Pearls Before Swine daily calendar. When we started into 2022’s daily calendar, I hesitated. Stephen Pastis had written all of the comics in 2020, and he was commenting on the then-current events. I told Dean that I did not want to relive 2020. Dean told me I didn’t have to read the comic strips, but he wanted to. So they’re […]
When Detective Mick Hanrahan finds himself subpoenaed back to Seavy County, Oregon, for a homicide case involving his former job, he dreads every minute of it. But Mick quickly discovers the case, which he thought a slam-dunk, involves angles he never expected. In a small county with understaffed legal and law enforcement departments, Mick might hold the key to preventing any further injustice. “Overworked,” by New […]
A few weeks ago, I posted a blog titled “Searching For A Sense of Urgency.” As usual, I uploaded that post to my Patreon page early, and received quite a few comments on it. Two were posted to Patreon for the other supporters to see, and one of those comments got me thinking. The long post, “Searching For a Sense of Urgency,” focuses on the […]
The Fleet designed the new SC-Class ships with an impenetrable bridge. The most protected spot on the ship. Right in the center. So, when Lieutenant Balázs Jicha realizes the bridge of the Izlovchi now opens to space, he fights to remember what happened. And what to do next. Jicha always follows his hunches. Now, he must rely on those hunches to help him save his […]
Thank you to all of the backers and supporters of the Fey Kickstarter. I’m so honored and grateful for your support and interest in the new book. The new book will go out as soon as possible, after all of the backer surveys are completed and we know what’s what. I hope you enjoy the read. Thank you again!!!!
In last week’s post, I talked about the sense of urgency in publishing. I suggest you read the post, because it’s important for all of us. We need to understand how, in the world of entertainment, the producers of content have lost control of the sense of urgency, and how that sense of urgency has moved to the consumers of content. Read the post, please, […]
You have about two days to get your copy of the new Fey novel, The Kirilli Matter, early. For as little as $5, you can get an ebook of the novel, and several other stories, as well as some motivational videos for yourself or a writer friend. I’m writing this on Sunday because the week is going to be crazy, so I wanted to remember […]
Oscar cleans portable toilets for a living. He loves the job—it takes him to beautiful isolated places, like the Lonely Rocks Wayside on the Oregon Coast. Nothing really grosses him out either—until he discovers the body, slashed to death, with a knife still in the chest. When he also sees a break in the guardrail above the ocean, a second car, and a ruined bicycle, […]
Full disclosure: I hate seeing myself on video. Always have, probably always will. But this particular video, assembled by Gwyneth Gibby from the various videos for Lessons From The Writing of The Fey works. Take a look. You can get all of the videos and the book by backing the Fey Kickstarter. Warning, though, the Kickstarter will end in four days. This particular reward is […]
I finished a book by an author I love at the start of the month, then spent two weeks trying to decide if I want to recommend it. The book doesn’t really work. She left out depth entirely, so all we had were these great characters (related to other great characters of hers). She had experimented with something difficult and didn’t quite pull it off. […]
For as long as she can remember, she has had two cousins named Ruby. Her so-called cousin, who lives in this world and whom she can’t stand, and the cousin she meets in her dreams—her Real Cousin Ruby. Her siblings all dream about Real Cousin Ruby, too. But why? In “My Real Cousin Ruby,” World Fantasy Award winner Kristine Kathryn Rusch challenges the border between […]
I recently read a novel by a traditionally published writer who’s been a favorite of mine for forty years. The novel was good—her work is always good—but it lacked dramatic tension. At one point, Dean asked me what genre the book was, because the cover didn’t communicate a genre clearly. I was about 100 pages from the end. I paused, frowned, and said, “I have […]
Paula finds herself living a memory. Transported back in time, she straddles then and now. She must choose: Relive the past or accept the present. But what if Paula wants a third option—one no one thought she’d ever choose. “Killing Time” by Hugo Award-winning author Kristine Kathryn Rusch, is free on this website for one week only. The story’s also available as an ebook through various online retailers here. […]
Yes, I know, I’m letting you know this late in the day. But it was the first moment I have. We have a lot of new classes available for the first time in the sale, including me talking about Lessons From The Writing of The Fey. Yeah, you get to hear some details and maybe get some advice about what you can do. If you […]
Artists: I want you to pay attention here because this post is for you. The rest of you, those who love business, please read because you might find some inspiration here. But I’m talking to the folks who seem to believe that practicing art is something that is divorced from business and must remain so. Those who practice art in this way believe that once […]
We announced last month that we were going to do regular sales of the online writing workshops, so that you folks had time to organize your finances if you wanted to order tons of workshops. Or something like that. ? Anyway, here’s your reminder: The August Workshop Sale is underway. Go to Teachable, pick what you want, and then put in the code AugustRegularSale. Dean […]
You know that famous mystery writer? The one whom death stalks wherever she goes? Turns out bad luck doesn’t cause death to follow her. She provokes it all—for a reason. And this time, someone will stop her. A student at a writing workshop has a secret agenda. Yes, she wants to become a bestseller. But first she must deal with the competition—in a wholly unexpected […]
This is another one of those deceptive titles, like “Money.” Because when most writers read “Competition” as the sub header here, they think, Yep, there’s just too much competition out there. A handful of writers win, but the rest of us lose. Um…no. Readers are a fascinating bunch. They’re terribly unpredictable. Just because something is marked “bestselling” doesn’t mean that everyone wants to read it. […]
For the second time in my career, I’m honored to have a full novel in Asimov’s SF Magazine. This novel, The Court Martial of the Renegat Renegades, won’t be published as a standalone until June of 2023. However, you can read it in Asimov’s in two parts. The first part has just appeared, and you can read an excerpt here. I’m so excited about this […]
When Dylan’s wife, Geneva, dies, Dylan refuses to believe it. Not because he believes in ghosts, but because he believes in science. Geneva, a physicist, believed humans could overcome the perception of linear time. If her theories hold true, Dylan could change his perceptions and Geneva will live again. With nothing to lose and Geneva to gain, Dylan resolves to try. “Without End” by Hugo […]