Mystery Murder & Mayhem
Andrea Lea
True Crime has always been a fascinating subject for me and here I share those stories.
Originally named Mystery Murder & Magick.
Topics include but not limited to: -True Crime -Missing Persons -Serial Killers -The Unexplained -Cryptids -Paranormal -Current Events
Podcasts Similar to Mystery Murder & Mayhem
Murder Bucket (91.6%)
Hannah Palmer
The Sinister Story Hour (90.26%)
Stephanie Lynne
Just Another Murder (89.15%)
Ariana Harrington & Anna Haberman
Drinking with Ghoulfriends (89.12%)
drinkingwithghoulfriends
The Sleepaway Podcast (88.84%)
Ben Ford and Joe Gibbs
Between The Cracks (88.19%)
Gayle Force Productions
Frightful (87.1%)
Peter Laws
SpookyBarberBabes (86.13%)
Spooky Barber Babes
A Scary State (85.51%)
A Scary State
Creeps In The Crypt (85.36%)
Creeps in the Crypt
The Darker Side of Life Podcast (85.25%)
Kristen & Dana
Serial Sisters (85.22%)
Burns Bureau
Ghost Town: Strange History, True Crime, & the Paranormal (84.88%)
Jason Horton & Rebecca Leib and Studio71
On a Grassy Knoll (84.78%)
On a Grassy Knoll
Dead Souls Social Club (84.73%)
Dead Souls Network
Haunted Family Podcast (84.69%)
Holly and Heather
Appalachian Monsters & Mysteries (84.68%)
Appalachian Monsters & Mysteries
Something Sick (84.62%)
Katy and Sydney
Awkward and Afraid Podcast (84.46%)
Awkward and Afraid Podcast
Unsolved Mysteries (84.42%)
Cosgrove Meurer Productions, Inc. + Cadence13
Seven: True Crime Murder (84.35%)
K-Town
A Million Murders (84.31%)
A Million Murders
True Crime Podcast 2024 - Police Interrogations, 911 Calls and True Police Stories Podcast (83.97%)
True Crime Podcast 2022
Mountain Mysteries: Tales from Appalachia (83.95%)
Hailey and Holly
It's a Strange World After All (83.87%)
Brit & Dee
Oy with the Terror Already (83.64%)
Oy with the Terror Already
Morbid Instinct (83.49%)
Elaine Willey
This One's A Doozy (83.47%)
Funner House Publishing
Curiously Morbid (83.44%)
Danielle Waldron
The Marcabe (83.4%)
Marc Hoover
Victims Speak Out (83.39%)
mary501
Myths, Magic and Murder (83.36%)
Abbie & Katherine
Camp Final Girls (83.34%)
Chelsea Warner, Alicia Padilla
13th Gate (83.29%)
The Gate Keepers
Where The Dark Corners Are (83.24%)
Vina Jimenez
Truly, Darkly, Creeply (83.24%)
Truly, Darkly, Creeply
grim. (83.23%)
Grim Podcast
Mystery Still Unsolved (83.2%)
mysterystillunsolved
The Brothers Grim (82.99%)
The Brothers Grim
Darkest Mysteries from Reddit 2022 - Best Reddit Stories Podcast 2022 (82.86%)
Darkest Mysteries from Reddit
Weird Distractions (82.83%)
Weird Distractions Podcast
Far Side Chats (82.81%)
Far Side Chats
All Things Dark Podcast (82.68%)
Crystal Reavis
Is Anybody Out There? (82.68%)
rsophie865
Unsolved Mysteries Rewind (82.67%)
Unsolved Mysteries Rewind
GraveYard Tales (82.64%)
Adam Ballinger & Matt Rudolph
The Creep Dive (82.57%)
Tall Tales
Uncanny America (82.53%)
Renee and Jen Starling
Two Weirdos One Podcast (82.5%)
Megan Taylor / Ashley Kovacic
Weird Distractions Podcast (82.5%)
Weird Distractions Podcast
Straight-Up Enigmas (82.5%)
Jaden McKell
The Conspirators Podcast (82.35%)
The Conspirators Podcast
Coffee and Cases Podcast (82.23%)
Allison Williams, Maggie Damron
Law Ghost Stories (82.05%)
By: Brenna Bizzell & Danielle Shedd Reed
Dawn of Mantis (82.02%)
Dawn of Mantis Podcast
Insane Investigations (81.82%)
Insane Investigations
Tales Of Ghouls And Gangsters (81.71%)
Emily McCray
Let's Talk About The Facts (81.68%)
Elizabeth Furrey
Terror Teller Raido's show (81.67%)
Terror Teller Raido
Killin Missin Hidden (81.58%)
Brad. Just Brad.
New England Gothic (81.56%)
Jessica Voloudakis
The Rock Star & The Nanny (81.56%)
Pacific Podcast Network
Dying to be Found (81.55%)
Deborah Norman
Mythical True Crime (81.55%)
DJ
Cousins on Crime (81.54%)
Cousins on Crime
Evidence Locker True Crime (81.48%)
Evidence Locker True Crime
Gimme the Creeps (81.38%)
Abigail & Daniela
FPI UNSOLVED (81.38%)
FPI UNSOLVED
My Old Kentucky Homicide (81.38%)
Buddy Forbes, Christa Layne, Tyler Layne, and Breanna Pruitt
Strange & Sinister (81.27%)
Strange & Sinister
I Love Old Time Radio (81.17%)
Virtual Vinny
The Metaphysician’s Electronic Journal (81.1%)
The Metaphysician
Nevada Lore (81.07%)
Kelsey Penrose
Macabre at Midnight (81.06%)
Felicia Huffman
The Shadow | Old Time Radio (81.06%)
VOKROX
Cryptique (81.05%)
JN
Into The Strange (81.04%)
Strange Network
Fort Fritz: Campfire Tales (80.98%)
Real Radio 104.1 (WTKS-FM)
Walk in the Dark (80.81%)
Catherine Kruta, Hannah Blosser, Bethany Wagner
Deeply Unsettling (80.8%)
Rachael Concepcion & Erin Artsiukhouski
Best True Crime Stories Podcast 2022 Police Interrogations, 911 Calls and True Crime Investigations (80.76%)
Gawid Entertainment Podcasts
TGICrimeday (80.75%)
TGICRIMEDAY
The Insomnia Report (80.7%)
The Insomnia Report Podcast
Future is Bright? (80.63%)
Future is Bright?
Haunted house Hour (80.63%)
Emma
Dolls and Doom The Podcast (80.57%)
dollsanddoom
Crime Bistro (80.42%)
Anna DiNino
The Mass Hysteria Podcast (80.4%)
The Mass Hysteria Podcast
Dose of Deception (80.37%)
Emilie Hryszko and Shannon Jones
Barrie Craig, Confidential Investigator (80.35%)
Entertainment Radio
Shared Madness (80.33%)
Madison
True Enough (80.3%)
Catherine Duval and Brandon McKown
Morbid Curiosity: A True Crime Podcast (80.29%)
Nichole
Southern Gothic (80.27%)
Southern Gothic Media
This Story is Nuts (80.2%)
Melissa Reece
MURDER! MYSTERY! MONDAY ...but it's Sunday (80.18%)
Jonathan Ferreira
Murders in Paradise (80.16%)
Mysteries in Paradise
Adventures Of The Thin Man (80.15%)
Entertainment Radio
Blood and Guts (80.14%)
Blood and Guts
Murderology (80.11%)
Rachel Abbott