Pumpkin Smiles
Charlie Day
If scary mysteries and short strange stories are for you, then this podcast is the one you want. A compilation of ghost stories, folktales, myths, legends, and other strange tales from the dark backroads of the internet. These classic campfire tales and unique short stories are real gems sure to leave you both spooked and nostalgic.
Podcasts Similar to Pumpkin Smiles
Stranger Than Fiction (90.99%)
Channeling Spirits
The Marbles (89.76%)
Creepies
Too Weird Didn't Watch (89.1%)
Albert Berg
Anything Spooky Goes (88.0%)
Anything Spooky Goes
Pleasing Terrors (85.99%)
Mike Brown
Evil and Eerie Podcast (85.87%)
Evil and Eerie Podcast
Morbid Academy: A Podcast (85.79%)
Taylor Golub
Dark Reality (85.78%)
John Ringo Jackson
R.L. Stine's Story Club (85.68%)
GoKidGo
One Bizarre Podcast (85.63%)
One Bizarre Podcast
Deviant Little Darlings (85.38%)
Kate & O
Frightday (85.28%)
Audio Wool
Wag Kang Lilingon (85.02%)
Wag Kang Lilingon | Bunk Collective
The Cryptid Keeper (84.98%)
The Cryptid Keeper
Into The Portal (84.89%)
Into The Portal
The Monsters of History (84.75%)
Christian Anthony Gonzalez
The Haunting Stories (84.73%)
Carol Hobbs
His and Hers Podcast (84.61%)
His and Hers Movie Podcast
This Strange World (84.6%)
High Tops Media & Gavin Berger, Leah Ettinger, and Chris Ashe
Destination Terror (84.52%)
Eeriecast Network
The Hit The Lights Podcast (84.44%)
Top5s
Family Plot (84.37%)
Family Plot Podcast
Unnatural Podcast (84.35%)
Ben & Steve
Strange Origins (84.32%)
Fascinating Productions
Para Sisters (84.27%)
Para Sisters
Ominous Origins (84.22%)
Casey Chaplin
We Doing Filmographies (84.2%)
Jason & Julian
Spooky Sistas (84.15%)
Deep State Media
StoryLink Radio (84.12%)
Shandon Loring: Professional Storyteller / Seanchaí
This One's A Doozy (84.04%)
Funner House Publishing
True Myths, One Lie with Culter35 (84.01%)
Anthony Mennella & Studio71
Grandma Tell Me A Scary Story (83.96%)
Rachel Sheehy
The Monster Club.Com Podcast (83.9%)
http://www.themonsterclub.com
Going Dark Theatre (83.86%)
goingdarktheatre
The Ghosts on This Road (83.8%)
Linda Wojtowick
October State of Mind (83.72%)
Ricky A Schroeder
Midnight Society Cast (83.7%)
midnightsocietycleo cleopatra
Nightmares & Daydreams Podcast (83.66%)
Nightmares and Daydreams
Classic Ghost Stories (83.49%)
Tony Walker
Spooky Spouses (83.46%)
Spooky Spouses
Just A Story: Urban Legend Podcast (83.43%)
Just A Story Urban Legend Podcast
Insidious Inspirations (83.39%)
Bloody Disgusting Podcast Network
Knowing My Nightmares (83.39%)
Knowing My Nightmares
Escaping Purgatory - a Supernatural podcast (83.37%)
Escaping Purgatory
Hunting Legends (83.36%)
Lauren Garcia
Are You Afraid of the Podcast? (83.29%)
The Front Row Network
A Dark Memory: Legends, Haunted Places, and Supernatural Mysteries (83.28%)
Scary Stories
Nightshaded Podcast (83.27%)
Nightshaded Podcast
Cracking Cryptids and Curios (83.26%)
Cracking Cryptids & Curios - An "I Am Actually Traveling Back Into Time" Production
An Anomalous Aberration (83.2%)
Jennifer Welch
Bizarre Tales (83.1%)
Bizarre Tales
Jezebel Scary Stories Read Aloud (82.97%)
Kimberley Barker
Scary Stories - BINGE IT! (82.96%)
Sol Good Network
Lore from 210 (82.89%)
Elisabeth Alkier
Real fear podcast (82.84%)
Real fear podcast
Something Scary (82.81%)
Studio71
Just Might Exist (82.8%)
Lindsey Anna and Erica Knorr
Daily Short Stories - Scary Stories (82.77%)
Sol Good Network
Messer Brothers Presents (82.75%)
Messer Brothers
Classic Ghost Stories Podcast (82.74%)
Tony Walker
Wide Atlantic Weird (82.69%)
Cian
The Creep Dive (82.67%)
Tall Tales
Ding Dong Darkness Time (82.66%)
Allison Dickson
The Strange and Unusual Podcast (82.58%)
Alyson Horrocks | Morbid Network
Horrifying History (82.55%)
Horrifying History
Bone Patrol Podcast (82.53%)
Bone Patrol
Grimm and Glitter Podcast (82.47%)
Grimm & Glitter Podcast
Tabi-Tabi Podcast (82.44%)
Ethan
Occultor (82.39%)
MK Miller
Movie Freaks Reviews (82.35%)
kelly kassia
Scary Stories (82.3%)
Sol Good Network
Oddity (82.27%)
Oddity
Straight-Up Enigmas (82.27%)
Jaden McKell
Stories - Scary (82.27%)
Sol Good Network
Supernaturally Me (82.26%)
Briella Romero
Marley's Ghosts (82.25%)
Deb Marley
Podcast in A minor (82.25%)
Amy Zoellers
Weird Mysteries! Shocking Suspense! Classic Terror! (82.21%)
Henrique Couto
Fort Fritz: Campfire Tales (82.18%)
Real Radio 104.1 (WTKS-FM)
Be. Scared (82.18%)
Studio71
Cabinet Of Curiosities Podcast (82.17%)
Sarah Troop
Within The Mist (82.14%)
Gary & GoldieAnn
The Supernatural Virgin (82.13%)
Darren & Vasco
The Friends Of Folklore (82.12%)
The Friends of Folklore
Not Alone (82.11%)
Not Alone
Campfire Adventures (82.08%)
Dylan
Lights Out With Sylvia Shults (82.07%)
Sylvia Shults
Hallowed Histories (82.06%)
Richard Sheppard
The Normal, Strange and Amazing (82.02%)
Blake "Magic Hat" Draut
Scary Stories - Daily Short Stories (82.0%)
Sol Good Network
Creepify (81.99%)
Creepify
Loremen Podcast (81.99%)
Loremen Podcast
Allah nam je dovoljan (81.97%)
Cryptic Chronicles
The Never Relevant Podcast (81.91%)
neverrelevant
The United States of Horror (81.84%)
The United States of Horror
WHAT ABOUT BIGFOOT? (81.83%)
Bigfoot
The Sleepaway Podcast (81.83%)
Ben Ford and Joe Gibbs
The Odd Topic Podcast (81.72%)
The Odd Topic Podcast
Legend Has It... (81.7%)
Morgan Mitchell & Maddy Klever