Does intent for wrong owner validate a Pesah offering not on 14 Nisan?

Rav Papa – Yes

Rava No

Mishnah

Invalid eaters

Timing of Pesah

Intends at slaughter that uncircumcised should receive atonement during sprinkling?

Rav Hisda – invalid

Rabbah – valid

Proof for Rabbah:

Some uncircumcised??

“This” limits. Already derived from “all” that valid

Therefore, all uncircumcised during sprinkling -valid

Rav Hisda – “This” even some uncircumcised during sprinkling is invalid

Rav Ashi – rejects both